Página 1
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular Council Meeting was held on October 11, 2010 at 7:30 p.m. with Council President
Hogan presiding. Council members present were Mr. Bonar, Mrs. Russell, Mr. McGlumphy,
Mr. Leary, Mr. McGiffin, Mrs. Williams, Mr. Salters, and Mr. Ruane.
Council staff members present were Police Chief Hosfelt, Ms. Russell, Mrs. Mitchell,
Mrs. Townshend, Mr. DePrima, City Solicitor Rodriguez, and Mrs. McDowell. Mayor Carey was
also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 7:15 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting.
Council President Hogan declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that
Council is not in official session and cannot take formal action.
Mrs. Sophia Russell (Councilwoman), 208 N. New Street, advised members that a citizen had
brought to her attention a safety concern regarding youth crossing Saulsbury and Walker Roads. She
also suggested that a traffic light be installed at North Dover Elementary School on State College
and McKee Road and requested police patrol, noting that there is often speeding traffic along this
section of the roadway.
The invocation was given by Chaplain Dixon, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
Mr. Bonar moved for the deletion of Item #9 - Tentative Labor Contract with IUE-CWA 88315
(to be scheduled for the next meeting), seconded by Mr. Leary and unanimously carried.
Mr. Bonar moved for approval of the agenda, as amended, seconded by Mr. Leary and
unanimously carried.
Mr. Ruane requested that Item #7C - Prioritization of Transportation Projects, be removed from the
consent agenda for the purpose of discussion.
Mr. Leary moved for approval of the consent agenda as amended, seconded by Mr. Salters and
carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010
By consent agenda, the Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of September 27, 2010 were
unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Leary, seconded by Mr. Salters and bore the written
approval of Mayor Carey.
CERTIFICATE OF CONGRATULATIONS - DR. HARRY WILLIAMS, PRESIDENT OF
DELAWARE STATE UNIVERSITY
On behalf of the Mayor and Council, Mayor Carey presented Dr. Harry Williams with a Certificate
of Congratulations on his inauguration as the 10th President of Delaware State University.
Página 2
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 2
Dr. Williams thanked the City of Dover for the recognition and introduced his wife,
Dr. Robin Williams, and his sons, Gavin (a 5th grade student at William Henry Middle School) and
Austin (a 9th grade student at Dover High School). He stated that all family members have
successfully made the transition to the City of Dover and that he looked forward to being a part of
this wonderful community.
PRESENTATION - MAYOR’S ARTS AWARDS
Mayor Carey presented a Mayor’s Arts Award (trophy) to Ms. Jordan Beard. Mayor Carey advised
members that Ms. Beard has performed the National Anthem at opening ceremonies for basketball
clinics in the area, enjoys drawing and sketching classes at the Dover Art League, has participated
in “Poetry In Motion” at the Biggs Museum of American Art, and has sung Christmas carols for
visitors at the Delaware Agricultural Museum. He noted that Ms. Beard looks forward to pursuing
music and the arts in college in the future.
Mayor Carey presented a Mayor’s Arts Award (trophy) to Mr. Jeffrey Heilman. Mayor Carey
advised members that Mr. Heilman is a Senior at Dover High School, where he plays the trumpet
in the marching band, wind ensemble, jazz band, and pep band. Mr. Heilman has been accepted in
the Delaware All-State Concert Band and the Kent County Honors Band, and is a member of the
Smyrna Fire Company Band. Mayor Carey also commended Mr. Heilman’s membership in Bugles
Across America, an organization that is committed to providing live performances of “Taps” at
funeral services for veterans, and noted that Mr. Heilman and his family have traveled to four (4)
different states to support this cause.
Mr. Heilman thanked all of his previous and current music directors, including Mr. Lenny Knight,
Mr. Reggie Daniel, and Mr. Gene Moore, as well as his family, for their support.
Mayor Carey presented a Mayor’s Arts Award (trophy) to Mr. Ronald Rider, Jr. Mayor Carey
advised members that Mr. Rider is an established accordion player who entertains audiences with
music spanning modern, holiday, classical, and ethnic folk genres, including songs from Italian,
Polish, Slavic, German, Russian, Hungarian, and Spanish traditions. In addition, Mayor Carey stated
that Mr. Rider also participates in choir at his school and has continuously shared his music through
community service opportunities, including his most memorable performance before the residents
of a local nursing home.
Mr. Rider thanked his teacher and the City for the recognition.
PROCLAMATION - HALLOWEEN TRICK-OR-TREAT
The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:
WHEREAS, the children of the City of Dover enjoy the fun and festivities associated with the
observance of the Halloween Trick-or-Treat custom of traveling with friends and family going from
door to door in their neighborhood, displaying their costumes, and gathering treats; and
WHEREAS, parents are urged to join in the festivities by accompanying their children throughout
their journeys in celebrating Halloween Trick-or-Treat; and
Página 3
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 3
WHEREAS, residents are requested to indicate their willingness to welcome children by keeping
their porch or exterior lights on and that youngsters call only on homes so lighted; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor of the City of Dover has deemed it advisable to observe the celebration
of Halloween Trick-or-Treat on Saturday, October 30, 2010 between the hours of 6:00 p.m.
and 8:00 p.m.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, Carleton E. Carey, Sr. MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
do hereby proclaim that the Halloween Trick-or-Treat observance be held on the 30th day of
October 2010, between the hours of 6:00 P.M. and 8:00 P.M. in the City of Dover and urge all
residents, both young and old, to make this a happy and safe occasion for our children.
PROCLAMATION - BREAST CANCER AWARENESS MONTH
The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:
WHEREAS, breast cancer forms in tissues of the breast, usually the ducts and lobules. It occurs in
both men and women, although male breast cancer is rare; and
WHEREAS, breast cancer is the most common cancer in women in the Unites States, aside from
skin cancer. It is the second leading cause of death in women; and
WHEREAS, it is estimated that more than 190,000 new cases of invasive breast cancer are expected
to be diagnosed among women and more than 40,000 women will die from this disease in the United
States this year; and
WHEREAS, the basic treatment choices for breast cancer are surgery, radiation, chemotherapy, and
hormonal therapy; and
WHEREAS, a patient and their physician will choose the treatment that is right for him/her based
on the location and extent of the cancer; patient's age and preferences, and the risks and benefits of
each treatment; and
WHEREAS, some of the most common risk factors are: sex, age, personal history, family history,
the breast cancer gene, first pregnancy after age 25 or 35, having no children, the use of Hormone
Replacement Therapy (HRT), and Oral Contraceptives; and
WHEREAS, Mammography screening remains the best available method to detect breast cancer
early; and
NOW, THEREFORE, I, Carleton E. Carey, Sr., MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER,
DELAWARE, do hereby proclaim October 2010 as BREAST CANCER AWARENESS MONTH
throughout the City of Dover and encourage all citizens to join in activities that will help the
community understand what they can do to prevent and control breast cancer.
Página 4
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 4
Mayor Carey presented the Proclamation to Mrs. Melany Sammons, Director of the Statewide
Mobile Mammography Facility. Mayor Carey introduced Mrs. Jean Peters, a Stage 3 breast cancer
survivor of 20 years, and stressed the importance of proper testing and treatment.
Mayor Carey noted that during the month of October, in the evening, the City of Dover flagpoles at
various buildings are lit in “pink” to bring about awareness of breast cancer.
There being no objections, Council President Hogan declared a brief recess to allow for
photographs for the Mayor’s Arts Awards.
Meeting Recessed at 7:47 P.M. and Reconvened at 7:58 P.M. (Mr. Salters arrived at 8:03 p.m. and
Mayor Carey arrived at 8:08 p.m.).
UTILITY COMMITTEE REPORT - SEPTEMBER 27, 2010
The Utility Committee met on September 27, 2010 with Chairman Ruane presiding.
Delaware State University (DSU) Force Main Reroute
Mr. Ron Lunt, Public Utilities Director, advised members that the FY 2011 Operating Budget for
the Public Utilities Wastewater Management Division includes a capital project to install a new force
main from the west end of West Rustic Lane to the existing Delaware State University (DSU) force
main along the Delaware Civic Center property. He explained that this project will consist of
installing approximately 1,000 feet of 16-inch diameter ductile iron pipe. Mr. Lunt noted that the
existing DSU force main currently flows to the Delaware Technical and Community College
(DTCC) pump station, and the proposed force main rerouting will also provide for the reversal of
flow from the DTCC pump station through valve installation and utilizing the remaining portion of
the existing DSU force main. He advised members that flows from both pump stations will no
longer discharge into Kent County Station #2 but will instead discharge into the new US Route 13
West Sanitary Sewer Interceptor (Rt. 13 Interceptor). Mr. Lunt noted that the DSU force main
rerouting construction drawings were submitted to Eastern States Construction Services, Inc., who
is currently constructing the Rt. 13 Interceptor. He stated that City staff and KCI Technologies, Inc.,
(KCI) the City’s Project Manager on the Rt. 13 Interceptor, reviewed the Eastern States Construction
Services, Inc. bid proposal and found it free of math errors and/or discrepancies. KCI also conducted
an independent cost analysis of the proposed project and found the Eastern States proposal to be
reasonable and acceptable when compared to current construction costs.
Mr. Lunt noted that the source of the funds for this project will be the Delaware Water Pollution
Control Revolving Loan Fund Program, using the excess funds from the Rt. 13 Interceptor project,
which was anticipated during the budget process. The Rt. 13 Interceptor project was budgeted at
$3,201,480, the actual construction bid was $2,308,800, and the current estimated completion cost
is approximately $2.6M. He stated that KCI and City staff are confident that the Rt. 13 Interceptor
project cost will remain below this estimate; therefore, the City will have approximately $600,000
in excess loan funds to support the completion of the DSU/DTCC Force Main Rerouting project.
Mr. Lunt stated that since this is the final stage of the Rt. 13 Interceptor, the DSU/DTCC Force Main
Página 5
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 5
Rerouting project will be submitted to DNREC as part of an approved change order to the ongoing
Rt. 13 Interceptor project. He noted that City staff has received assurance from DNREC staff that
this is an acceptable change order to the loan program due to this interconnectivity.
Staff recommended approval of the proposal submitted by Eastern States Construction Services, Inc.
in the amount of $240,300 for the construction of the DSU/DTCC Force Main Rerouting and that
the Finance Department be authorized to include the additional expenditure as a change order and
a part of the existing loan agreement between the City of Dover and the Delaware Water Pollution
Control Revolving Loan Fund Program.
Responding to Mr. Bonar, Mr. Lunt assured members that the 16-inch pipe is substantially larger
than what is currently needed and will accommodate future expansion when necessary. He advised
members that Kent County performed some of the engineering work on this project to assure it
would be adequate for the County’s rerouting/bypassing project for the current interceptor, which
saved the City approximately $26,000 that was budgeted for engineering work.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, assured members that City Council
was made aware of the appropriation for this project.
The Committee recommended approval of the proposal submitted by Eastern States Construction
Services, Inc., in the amount of $240,300, for the construction of the DSU/DTCC Force Main
Rerouting and that the Finance Department be authorized to include the additional expenditure as
a change order and a part of the existing loan agreement between the City of Dover and the Delaware
Water Pollution Control Revolving Loan Fund Program, as recommended by staff.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Commercial Recycling Fee
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, advised members that, during
the changeover of vendors for the curbside recycling program, the Delaware Solid Waste Authority
(DSWA) informed the City of its intent to discontinue recycling collection service to 17 Dover
businesses that do not have City trash services. These 17 businesses use a private trash collection
service due to their individual business needs. These customers were receiving direct service from
the DSWA for a fee of $6.00 per month, per container; however, as of September 1, 2010, the
DSWA no longer provides service to these customers. Staff requested authorization to create a
special billing code and implement a fee of $6.00 per month per container for commercial curbside
recycling for customers who do not have City of Dover trash collection services.
Responding to Mr. Snaman, Mr. Koenig stated that the six (6) customers who are listed outside of
the City limits are located in “in-fill” areas along Governors Avenue and are existing DSWA
customers. He noted that staff did not recommend extending recycling services outside of the City
limits at this time.
The Committee recommended approval of staff’s recommendation.
Página 6
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 6
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation
authorizing staff to create a special billing code and implement a fee of $6.00 per month per
container for commercial curbside recycling for customers who do not have City of Dover
trash collection services. The motion was seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous
roll call vote.
Request for Alley Abandonment (paper) - 18 Elm Terrace - Valerie Satterfield
A request was received from Ms. Valerie Satterfield for the abandonment of an unimproved alley
running east-west on property located at 18 Elm Terrace. Members were provided with a map of the
area. Since the alley is unimproved and is considered to be a “paper” alley, it does not require
review by the Development Advisory Committee (DAC) or Planning Commission.
Ms. Satterfield, 18 Elm Terrace, advised members that she wishes to erect a shed on the property
behind her garage and that, prior to requesting a building permit, she assumed it would be necessary
to own the property. Since the alley has not been used for several years, if ever, she requested that
the alley be abandoned.
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Ms. Satterfield stated that, if approved, she would be willing to pay for
any costs involved with the preparation of the necessary deed. She relayed no objection to the utility
easement that will be retained by the City.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that the homes that front on the south side
of Elm Terrace have a paper alley that transects their property. In essence, he stated that these
property owners own two (2) lots; one (1) on both sides of an alley that was not developed or
dedicated to the City, but still appears on official tax maps. The situation has existed since this area
was developed in the first half of the 1920s or 1930s. The owners of these properties have enjoyed
the full benefit of this land without finding a need to abandon the alley.
Mr. DePrima assured members that he reviewed the proposal with various City departments and that
there was no objection to the abandonment. He noted there is a sewer line that transects the alley;
therefore, staff recommended that the City retain a utility easement on the property. Any legal
expenses related to the processing of the deeds or annexing the property to adjacent lots is to be paid
for by the property owner.
Although the sewer lines were depicted on the map provided, Mr. Snaman suggested that staff
provide details as to the location of all utilities for future requests. Responding, Mr. DePrima
relayed no objection to such a request.
For the record, Major Kosior noted that his property is located immediately to the west of
Ms. Satterfield’s and relayed no objection to the request.
The Committee recommended approval of the alley abandonment at 18 Elm Terrace, reserving a
utility easement on the property. (City Clerk’s Note: In accordance with the City’s Procedure for
Alley Abandonments, Resolution No. 2010-11 setting the Public Hearing, will be presented to
Council for consideration for adoption.)
Página 7
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 7
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mr. Salters and by a unanimous roll call vote, Council adopted Resolution
No. 2010-11, as follows:
A RESOLUTION PROPOSING THE VACATING AND ABANDONMENT OF CERTAIN
ALLEYS SITUATED IN THE CITY OF DOVER.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN
COUNCIL MET:
Section 1. The Council of the City of Dover favors the vacating and abandoning of the following
alley:
All that certain piece or parcel of land situated in the City of Dover, Kent County,
State of Delaware, a 12 foot wide paper alley running west to east approximately
67.00 feet from the southwest property corner of Parcel No. 1: Tax Parcel #ED-05-
077.09-05-65.00 to the southeast property corner of said parcel, then running in a
southerly direction 12 feet to the northeast property corner of Parcel No. 2 - Tax
Parcel #ED-05-077.09-05-65.00, then running east to west approximately 68.27 feet
to the northeast corner of Parcel No. 2 - Tax Parcel #ED-05-077.09-05-65.00, then
running in a northerly direction 12 feet to back to the southwest property corner of
Parcel No. 1: Tax Parcel #ED-05-077.09-05-65.00, comprising 811.62 square feet,
more or less.
Section 2. The Council of the City of Dover will sit on Monday, October 25, 2010, at 7:30 p.m., in
the Council Chambers at City Hall, Dover, Delaware, to hear the objections of such residents of the
City or owners of the property affected as shall attend, in accordance with the provisions of Section
27 of the Charter of the City of Dover (Chapter 158, Volume 36, Laws of Delaware).
Section 3. The Clerk of Council is hereby directed to post copies of this Resolution in five or more
public places in the City of Dover.
ADOPTED: OCTOBER 11, 2010
Request for Alley Abandonment (paper) - Girl Scout Lane - Traci McDowell
A request was received from Mrs. Traci McDowell for the abandonment of an unimproved portion
of Girl Scout Lane, which runs behind her properties located at 80 and 100 Nixon Lane. Members
were provided a map of the area. The roadway is unimproved and is considered to be a “paper” road;
therefore, it does not require review by the DAC or Planning Commission.
Mrs. McDowell, 115 Nixon Lane, advised members that Girl Scout Lane is an unimproved, paper
road, which she has been maintaining for several years. If the abandonment is approved, she stated
that it would provide enough property to allow her to subdivide and build another house at some time
in the future.
Página 8
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 8
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. McDowell assured members of her understanding that, if approved,
she would be responsible for any costs involved with the preparation of the necessary deed. She
relayed no objection to the utility easement that will be retained by the City.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that Girl Scout Lane is an unimproved (dirt)
lane/alley that was annexed into the City of Dover and never paved. Only one (1) house fronts
on the alley. He stated that the properties on the west side of Nixon Lane have access to the rear of
their lots and that Mrs. McDowell owns two (2) properties on the east side of the lane on the
north end. The west side of the Lane is owned by the City and is associated with Dover Park. There
are two (2) lots on the west side of the Lane that are owned by David and Mary Miller. Only the
one (1) lot is impacted by this abandonment.
Mr. DePrima reminded members that when abandoning roadways with owners on both sides of the
property, the City will offer one half to each owner. In this instance, he stated that the City has no
interest in the half that runs along Dover Park, noting that the area is outside of the fence and has not
been maintained by the City. He stated that no City departments objected to the abandonment and
that there are no utilities in the proposed abandonment area. Mr. DePrima indicated that any legal
expenses related to the processing of the deeds or annexing the property to adjacent lots would be
paid for by the property owner.
In response to Mrs. McDowell, Mr. DePrima confirmed that the map provided to members did not
depict the correct abandonment. He advised members that the abandonment would include property
from Nixon Lane back to and including Girl Scout Lane. Mr. Ruane requested that the correct map
be provided to City Council when this matter is presented for their consideration.
Responding to Mr. Snaman, Mr. DePrima stated that Mr. and Mrs. Miller may or may not exercise
their right to take ownership of their half of the alley. If they do not, the area would remain a part
of the alley.
The committee recommended approval of the abandonment of the unimproved lane adjacent to
80 and 100 Girl Scout Lane, reserving a utility easement for existing utilities, as requested by
Mrs. McDowell. (City Clerk’s Note: In accordance with the City’s Procedure for Alley
Abandonments, Resolution No. 2010-12 setting the Public Hearing, will be presented to Council for
consideration for adoption.)
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mr. Salters and by a unanimous roll call vote, Council adopted Resolution
No. 2010-12, as follows:
A RESOLUTION PROPOSING THE VACATING AND ABANDONMENT OF CERTAIN
ALLEYS SITUATED IN THE CITY OF DOVER.
Página 9
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 9
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN
COUNCIL MET:
Section 1. The Council of the City of Dover favors the vacating and abandoning of the following
alley:
All that certain piece or parcel of land situated in the City of Dover, Kent County,
State of Delaware, beginning at the northeasterly corner of Tax Parcel #ED-05-
068.19-01-32.00 and running west a distance of 175.00 feet to a set yellow capped
pin at the northwesterly corner of said parcel, then running in a southerly direction
a distance of 200.00 feet to a set yellow capped pin at the southwesterly corner of
said parcel, then running in a southerly direction a distance of 250.00 feet along the
western property line of Tax Parcel #ED-05-068.19-01-42.00 to a set pipe in the East
line of Girl Scout Lane (unopened), then running in a westerly direction 27.5 feet
along the same bearing as the southern property line of Tax Parcel #ED-05-068.19-
01-42.00 to the West line of Girl Scout Lane (unopened), then running is a northerly
direction a distance of 477.50 feet to a set corner of Tax Parcel #ED05-068.19-01-
28.00, then running easterly a distance of 202.50 feet to the intersection of the west
line of Nixon Lane and the north line of Girl Scout Lane, then running south a
distance of 27.5 feet to the northeasterly corner of Tax Parcel #ED-05-068.19-01-
32.00, comprising 17,943.75 square feet, more or less.
Section 2. The Council of the City of Dover will sit on Monday, October 25, 2010, at 7:30 p.m., in
the Council Chambers at City Hall, Dover, Delaware, to hear the objections of such residents of the
City or owners of the property affected as shall attend, in accordance with the provisions of Section
27 of the Charter of the City of Dover (Chapter 158, Volume 36, Laws of Delaware).
Section 3. The Clerk of Council is hereby directed to post copies of this Resolution in five or more
public places in the City of Dover.
ADOPTED: OCTOBER 11, 2010
Dedication of Rights-of-Way and Infrastructure - Susan Place
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, submitted a request for
all public infrastructure improvements associated with the construction of Susan Place, located
within the Persimmon Park Place Subdivision, to be dedicated to the City of Dover for permanent
ownership and maintenance. Members were provided a list (noted as Attachment A to the Committee
Action Form) that identified the public improvements associated with the proposed dedication,
as well as a map (noted as Attachment B to the Committee Action Form) that showed the general
location and configuration of the subject right-of-way. Mr. Koenig advised members that
Separe, Inc., constructed most of the improvements in accordance with City standards and
specifications and that, last fall, the developer paid the City to complete the final construction of the
street. He stated that, as of this date, all work related to the public infrastructure has been completed.
Página 10
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 10
Staff recommended acceptance of the dedication of rights-of-way and public infrastructure for
Susan Place and that the dedication include all of the referenced public improvements.
The Committee recommended acceptance of the dedication of rights-of-way and public infrastructure
for Susan Place and that the dedication include all of the referenced public improvements.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation to
accept the dedication of rights-of-way and public infrastructure for Susan Place and that the
dedication include all of the referenced public improvements (Exhibit #1 and Exhibit #2). The
motion was seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Update - Green Energy Funding and Programming
Members were provided a Green Energy Funding and Programming Update - Stimulus Funding.
Mr. Ron Lunt, Public Utilities Director, reviewed the information provided to members, stating that
there had been a slight change in the funding and programming. He reminded members that the
State Energy Office has allocated $2M of the federal American Recovery and Reinvestment Act
stimulus money received by the State towards reducing the existing backlog of approved residential
green energy grants that have delayed grant payments due to insufficient funds in the respective grant
program. He stated that the $2M has been put into one (1) fund that is available to the City of Dover,
other Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) participants, Delmarva Power, and
Delaware Electric Cooperative customers.
Mr. Lunt stated that the City has one (1) customer in the delayed grant program who would have paid
once the grant funds were available; however, the establishment of the new fund would provide the
opportunity to receive these monies in advance (or earlier). He explained that the customer could
apply directly to the State Energy Office for funds. A home energy audit of the residence in question
would be required, with a rebate of up to $250 (50%) available to cover this cost. The customer
would be required to complete improvements totaling a minimum of $500 to the residence based on
the audit, and this cost could also be rebated.
The Committee recommended acceptance of the Update on the Green Energy Funding and
Programming.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Review of Utility Related CIP’s (Electric and Water/Wastewater) (June)
Members were provided a Project Tracking Report, as of June 30, 2010, for the Utility (Electric and
Water/Wastewater) Related Capital Investment Plan (CIP).
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, indicated that the Cooling Towers
Repair/Renovation Project is a FY2011 Project and was not included in the CIP Report provided.
He stated that the condensation problem has been resolved and that, to his knowledge, there have
been no complaints filed regarding “soot” damages to the vehicles of nearby residents.
Página 11
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 11
With regards to Mr. Ruane’s questions regarding the Bayard Avenue Project, Mr. Ron Lunt stated
that the east side of North State Street, and Bayard Avenue Projects are being completed by the
internal construction crew. He noted that currently, Phase A of North State Street, which includes
Hazel and Rodney Roads, is underway. Mr. Lunt explained that once construction is completed
there, the crew will move to Bayard Avenue to begin construction. Following completion of this
project, the crew plans to return to North State Street to begin Phase B. He stated that the Route 13
Program has been delayed due to Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT) requirements
involving an extensive traffic management plan that has been submitted for approval. Once
approved, bids will be solicited, since this project will be contracted. In addition, Mr. DePrima
reminded members that these three (3) projects were part of the State Revolving Loan, which caused
a substantial delay. Concurring, Mr. Lunt indicated that the City was not provided the funds until
after the first of the fiscal year and that the engineering work had to be accomplished.
Responding to Mr. Bonar, Mr. Lunt stated that the last paperwork submitted to DelDOT by the City
regarding this matter was in August. Mr. Bonar suggested that staff contact DelDOT to expedite the
required approval and if there is a delay, he felt that it may be necessary for City Council to become
involved.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mr. DePrima stated that the Review of the CIP is scheduled to be
presented to members each month. He reminded members that there is always a delay in submitting
the June report since it is the end of the fiscal year. Mr. Ruane suggested that a “prepared date” be
included on the report.
The Committee recommended acceptance of the Utility Related CIP’s Report.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
PACE/NAES Monthly Report (June and July)
Due to time constraints, Mr. Ruane suggested that the PACE/NAES Monthly Report be considered
by members during their next meeting. He noted that he had concerns regarding the Reports and
requested that staff provide an update on the condition of the plants.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Utility Committee Report,
seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE REPORT -
SEPTEMBER 27, 2010
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met on September 27, 2010 with
Chairman Leary presiding.
Review and Recommendation - Filling of Critical Positions
During their meeting of February 23, 2009, members recommended approval of the Hiring Freeze
for Fiscal Year 2008-2009, but to allow the hiring of critical positions through the review and
approval of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee and City Council. It was
Página 12
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 12
suggested that there be a “standing” agenda item to consider the filling of critical positions and, if
there are no positions to consider, the item could be removed.
Mr. Leary noted that there were no critical positions to be considered; therefore, no further action
was required.
Minority Procurement Program Policy
Members were advised that the City does not have a tracking or control mechanism for seeking
minority/women vendors for purchases in the mid-range of $5,000.00 - $24,999.99. As a result, staff
submitted a proposed amendment to Section 3.4 of the Purchasing Policy, along with the addition
of Appendix E, to provide a mechanism to ensure minority/women vendors are approached for
purchases within this range and a mechanism for tracking by the Procurement Manager.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, reminded members that this matter was previously discussed
and that Mr. Clay Hammond, Chairman of the Delmarva Black Chamber of Commerce and Vice
President of Business Development, Global Diversity Group, has reviewed the proposed
amendments and has indicated his concurrence.
Mr. Pete Gregg, Contract and Procurement Manager, reviewed the proposed amendment and form
(Appendix E), which will be utilized by departments.
In response to Mr. Salters, Mr. Gregg explained that when the 3% minority vendor preference is
applied, staff considers the amount of a minority bid at 3% less than submitted. This allows the City
to select a minority vendor who may not have been the lowest bidder (as long as it is within 3% of
the lowest bid); however, the City pays for the services at the full bid amount.
Mr. Jay Burks, Director of the State Office of Minority and Business Women Enterprises, stated that
the database utilized consists of those businesses that are certified as 51% owned/managed by
minorities and/or women. He advised members that the database contains over 1,800 certified
vendors and is available for public access.
Mr. Salters requested specifics regarding the percentage of minority-owned businesses and those that
are located in Kent County. Responding, Mr. Burks stated that the information would be provided
to Mr. Gregg for distribution to members.
The Committee recommended approval of the proposed amendment to Section 3.4 of the Purchasing
Policy for purchases in the mid-range of $5,000.00 - $24,999.99 and Appendix E of the Purchasing
Policy.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation for
approval of the proposed amendment to Section 3.4 of the Purchasing Policy for purchases in
the mid-range of $5,000.00 - $24,999.99 and Appendix E of the Purchasing Policy (Exhibit #3
and Exhibit #4), seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Página 13
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 13
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Legislative, Finance, and
Administration Committee Report, seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll
call vote.
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE REPORT -
SEPTEMBER 29, 2010
The Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee met on September 29, 2010 with
Chairwoman Williams presiding.
Discussion - Manchester Square Safety Concerns
Ms. Ami Sebastian-Hauer, Executive Director of the Dover Housing Authority (DHA), reviewed a
Presentation from the DHA (attachment to Committee minutes). She noted that on August 24, 2010,
at 5:00 p.m., a major shooting occurred at Manchester Square involving 15 people. Ms. Sebastian-
Hauer stated that the Dover Police Department responded immediately and that the majority of the
individuals involved were apprehended. She stated that all of the individuals, with the exception
of one (1), have since made bail. Since this incident, there has been an alarming increase in the
number of reports of shots being fired and/or weapons displayed at several DHA properties.
Ms. Sebastian-Hauer advised members of improvements being made by the DHA with regards to
safety and security. She requested that the City of Dover consider increasing the number of police
officers in the community policing division. She explained the vital importance of the visibility of
police officers, as well as the development of relationships between the police and residents.
Ms. Sebastian-Hauer introduced Mr. Dave Sweeney, of Advantech, Inc., the contractor who
performed the upgrades and additions to the security systems for the DHA.
Responding to Mrs. Williams, Police Chief Hosfelt indicated that in 2006, five (5) City police
officers were assigned to community policing and four (4) officers to quality of life (nuisance
crimes), for a total of nine (9) officers. He stated that the Police Department currently has only
six (6) officers serving in these areas, and the community policing and quality of life teams have
been combined due to the necessity to reallocate officers to address other problems in the City, such
as sex offenders. He reminded members that, due to budget constraints, he agreed to maintain the
police force at 91 for FY 10, rather than returning the authorized strength of the force to 93 officers.
In response to Mr. Clay Hammond, 505 Troon Road, Chief Hosfelt stated that the City is no longer
eligible for the Weed and Seed Grant, explaining that there is a five (5) year window before a new
application can be made. He stated he had made an inquiry to the Attorney General’s Office
regarding the City’s status in this matter.
With regards to the incident on August 24, 2010, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer reiterated that none of the
individuals involved were legal tenants of the DHA, although some were unauthorized guests or
family members of three (3) tenants. She assured members that the DHA has taken appropriate
action regarding those three (3) tenants in enforcing their “zero tolerance” approach.
Responding to Mrs. Williams, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer stated that there is a problem with gang activity
at Manchester Square that is continuing to worsen.
Página 14
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 14
Ms. Joybeth Guy, 745-B Bacon Avenue, advised members that she has resided in Manchester Square
for three (3) years and problems have been in existence there for several years. It was her feeling
that the DHA is not managing the property in a manner that would prevent the situations that are
occurring. She felt the situation there has become out of control.
Mr. Bobby Wilson, 1561 Nathaniel Mitchell Road, questioned how long security cameras in the area
have been “out of service.” Responding, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer stated that only one (1) camera was
out of operation and that the security camera system was recently updated. Mr. Wilson noted that
a shooting incident occurred on June 26, 2010, and questioned the delay in responding to the
problems that have been occurring. He advised members that this shooting involved the front
window of one of the residents and that the window has not been repaired to date. It was his
understanding that no one from the DHA has spoken with this resident, who felt like a prisoner in
her own home. Mr. Wilson stated that, due to fear, she does not “live” in the first floor of her home,
where the window is located. He suggested that the DHA improve their relationship with their
residents.
In response to Mr. Wilson’s concerns, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer indicated that there are two (2) residents
at the home where the window was shot and that it is a one (1) story home. These residents have
been offered transfers as part of the DHA’s relocation program and have been provided choice
vouchers to move from the development. Ms. Sebastian-Hauer assured members that information
regarding this incident was provided to the Dover Police Department and that there are investigations
pending. She advised members that when the DHA has requested increased police presence, there
have been complaints from the tenants. Ms. Sebastian-Hauer explained that, while the DHA
enforces the “one strike” policy and lease provisions, they must also respect the civil rights and
privacy of the tenants.
Mr. Hammond advised members of his previous involvement with public housing and felt that a
more effective strategy in dealing with these concerns is to focus on prevention rather than
monitoring undesirable activity. It was his feeling that resources must be provided to address the
needs of families in the community, explaining that children do not want to sell drugs but they must
be given alternatives. He suggested involving tenants and getting them to take ownership.
In response to Mrs. Williams, Chief Hosfelt stated that when the Dover Police Department had
substations located at Senate View and Manchester Square there was much less crime in these areas.
Regarding the incident that occurred on August 24, 2010, Chief Hosfelt stated that warrants have
been obtained for eight (8) individuals, six (6) of whom have been arrested and two (2) of whom
remain at-large. He explained that there were two (2) groups of subjects involved whose ages ranged
from 10 to 20, and several shots were fired across the Manchester Square Development. Information
obtained from witnesses indicated that there were 20 to 30 gunshots fired. Chief Hosfelt stated that
the City was very fortunate that no one was injured or lost their life as a result of this incident;
however, there was damage to three (3) vehicles and houses in the area. He advised members that
a subsequent search warrant for a follow-up investigation resulted in the recovery of a 45-caliber,
semi-automatic pistol, as well as an SKS assault rifle with a caliber of 223, which is the same caliber
that the U.S. military carries in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Página 15
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 15
Chief Hosfelt advised members that, since 2008, there have been 15 gang-related shootings in Dover,
three (3) gang-related stabbings, and five (5) gang-related homicides in or around subsidized housing
(not just DHA projects). He stated that, since 2005, the Police Department has been educating the
public regarding gang problems that were occurring and/or were anticipated in the City. He stated
that the gangs in the Dover area consists of the “Bloods” and “Crips,” which are active in the
neighborhoods of Capital Park, Capital Green, Liberty Court, Downtown Dover, and Whatcoat. He
noted that there are other gangs, such as “Three Block,” which is a sect of the “Bloods” located in
the downtown area.
Chief Hosfelt stated that when he began on the police force 22 years ago, it was a rare occurrence
to hear a “shots fired” announcement over the radio; however, it is now common to hear this at any
time of day. He stated that from January 1, 2010 through the beginning of September, 91 calls of
“shots fired” were received by the Police Department.
Chief Hosfelt recommended increasing the number of authorized officers. He advised members that
hiring and training a new officer is an 11-month process that includes a background check, 20 weeks
of training at the Police Academy, and a 12-week training period with Dover officers. He stated that
manpower surveys and workload assessments indicate that 34 additional police officers are needed
for the City of Dover, which he understood was unrealistic. Chief Hosfelt stated that he would like
Dover to have four (4), 12-man shifts, which would require an additional six (6) officers in order to
put two (2) officers back into community policing.
Responding to Mrs. Russell, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer explained that if an individual commits a crime
on property owned by the DHA, they are placed on a “banned list.” Once banned from public
housing, an individual is banned for life unless a request for removal is submitted. She stated that
the banned list is provided to all residents, who are advised to contact the Police Department if
anyone on the list is observed on the property since the individual would be trespassing.
Mr. Bonar stated that, although he supports the “right to bear arms,” it was his opinion that handguns
and automatic weapons have no place in the City of Dover except in the hands of police officers in
the line of duty. He felt that the City should send a message to those coming into the City carrying
a handgun that they are not welcome and that this message should be sent to the “Bloods” and
“Crips.” He felt that the City should provide the Police Department with all the ammunition and
resources required to do their job and ensure that the citizens of the public housing areas are safe.
Referring to the City’s Vision Statement in regards to the City of Dover being “a place where people
want to live,” Mr. McGlumphy stated that this refers to “all” people, regardless of where they reside.
He stated that public housing residents should be provided the opportunity to live in peace and
without fear. He requested that the DHA continue their efforts and strongly recommended that the
City heed the information that was provided to members. He noted that the City has an additional
$2M, which was presented during the discussion of Proposed Ordinance #2010-26, Budget
Amendments, which was presented for a First Reading before City Council on September 27, 2010,
and he felt that this matter should be the number one (1) priority for the City.
Página 16
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 16
In response to Mr. Harmon, Chief Hosfelt indicated that there are no requirements for owning a
handgun in the City of Dover. He explained that when a handgun is purchased, the gun must be
registered; however, if the purchaser then sells the gun, there is no requirement to update gun
registration.
Mr. Hammond suggested the possibility of creating a non–profit organization to address quality of
life issues. It was his feeling that this would bring the churches, public sector, masonic community,
and fraternity/sorority communities together and would provide additional funding resources. As
an example, he stated that churches could offer positive alternatives, such as “movie nights” for
children.
Referring to the maintenance of DHA property, Mr. Wilson noted that lack of proper maintenance
can draw undesirable elements into a community. He questioned which department is responsible
for inspecting the DHA properties. Responding, Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning
and Community Development, stated that the City’s Inspection Department is responsible for
conducting inspections. She stated that more than 3,000 rental permits have been issued in the City
and that the Department’s manpower has also been reduced; therefore, only 600 units were inspected
last year. Mrs. Townshend explained that the Department is currently operating in a complaint-
driven mode and that recently, due to the large number of foreclosures and vacant properties, many
demands have been placed upon staff.
Mrs. Williams suggested that the maintenance issue be considered by members during an upcoming
meeting and invited Mr. Wilson to participate in further discussion at that time.
The Committee recommended that the manpower for the City of Dover Police Department be
increased to 100 and to explore the necessary means of raising the revenues to see this accomplished.
Mrs. Williams moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Bonar.
In reviewing the Committee’s deliberations, Mr. Leary noted that Chief Hosfelt had requested an
additional six (6) officers and that the motion would actually add nine (9). He questioned the
rationale for recommending more officers than requested by staff. Responding, Mr. Bonar explained
that the decision to add nine (9) additional officers was to accommodate times when officers are not
available due to vacations, illness, or other reasons. He noted that Chief Hosfelt stated this need
during the Committee Meeting. Mr. Bonar felt that the gravity of the situation demands that the
Police Department be manned at a level sufficient to handle these issues and that hiring additional
officers would “send a message” to the citizens of Dover that Council wants to assure that there are
enough officers to respond when necessary. He reminded members of an incident that occurred
approximately two (2) months ago at the corner of State and Loockerman Streets which involved
over 300 individuals who were fighting in the middle of the street. Mr. Bonar stated that other police
departments from as far away as Smyrna and Milford were contacted for assistance with this
disturbance, which occurred after the closing of a bar. He felt that the culture of violence developing
among young people, the lack of respect for law enforcement and the law in general, and gang-
related shootings were unacceptable. It was his opinion that by understaffing the Police Department,
the City was failing to provide the citizens with the service they deserve.
Página 17
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 17
Mrs. Williams advised members that Chief Hosfelt had reported the success of community
policing in the past. In addition, she noted that officers had been removed from the Community
Policing and Quality of life Programs to work on the Sex Offender Program, and that crime had
increased as a result. For clarification, Chief Hosfelt stated that two (2) officers were transferred
from the Community Policing Unit to the Sex Offender Unit. He noted that, due to the budget
shortfall, the Police Department agreed to reduce the number of officers from 93 to 91 in the FY
2010 budget and these two (2) positions remain vacant, which has created a void in the Community
Policing Unit. (City Clerk’s Office Note: Information received from Chief Hosfelt subsequent to this
meeting indicates that the Sex Offender Unit was created in September 2008 after Council approved
two (2) additional officers in the FY 2007/08 Budget and added them to the force. The newly
established Sex Offender Unit continued and expanded upon the existing functions of the Community
Policing Unit.)
Mrs. Russell stated that, although she agrees that there is a need for additional officers, she did not
agree with the number of additional officers recommended due to the lack of funding, explaining her
feeling that the City’s budget cannot accommodate the recommended additional officers.
Mr. Ruane relayed concerns regarding the procedure for considering this matter. Although he
understood the gravity of the situation, it was his feeling that the request was taken out of context.
He stated that the steps being taken by the DHA to deal with the situation were appropriate and he
was reluctant to dedicate police officers to a particular area. Mr. Ruane noted that a request to
increase staff would normally be presented as a detailed recommendation, including budget
information. He advised members that, according to staff, the cost for one (1) police officer would
be $82,724 and the cost for each additional vehicle (if necessary) would be $22,300, which equates
to a total of $105,000 per officer for the first year, explaining that this cost would escalate due to step
and grade increases as provided in the police employment contract. Mr. Ruane felt that a more
detailed analysis should be provided and presented to members during the mid-year budget review.
He felt it would be premature to act without determining funding or studying the issue to determine
if additional police officers would be an appropriate solution. He suggested that the matter be
referred to the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee for further analysis.
Mr. Salters questioned whether the DHA had taken all necessary steps to assure that unwanted
persons are prevented from accessing public housing properties. He suggested that it was the
responsibility of the DHA to provide security for their residents and felt it would be more cost
effective to erect fencing and security that would allow access only to residents and guests. He
questioned if additional officers would actually resolve the issues and suggested that the creation of
a “gated community” might prove to be more beneficial.
Responding, Mrs. Williams advised members that off-duty officers are currently utilized to provide
additional security during the evenings in public housing areas, in addition to high-level security
cameras. She reminded members that the DHA, like any other landlord, must comply with the
Landlord Tenant Act. Unless there is just cause and due process, she stated that a resident cannot
be evicted or denied occupancy based on their associations. With regards to available funding,
Mrs. Williams reminded members that $2M had been identified by the Controller/Treasurer in the
budget carry forward and, although this has not yet been audited, she suggested that some of these
Página 18
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 18
funds be utilized for this purpose. She explained that the urgency to act is due to the reality that
children are victims of these acts of violence. It was her feeling that it would be unconscionable for
the City to know that children are in jeopardy and not take any action in this regard.
Understanding the concerns of several members, Mr. Bonar advised members that there is an 11 to
12 month preparation process before new police officers are equipped to “take to the streets;”
therefore, unless the recommended action is taken immediately, the additional police officers would
not be fully deployed until approximately a year after the next budget is adopted. He noted that the
Downtown Dover Partnership has allocated $26,000 for extra duty officers to police the City’s
downtown business community and he felt that this was an indication that the City has not properly
funded the Police Department. Mr. Bonar stated that the Police Department, along with the Fire
Department, is a fundamental part of the City.
Although he supported the Police Department and was sympathetic to their needs, Mr. McGiffin
relayed concern with making “piecemeal” budgetary decisions that would have a large impact on the
City’s budget. He felt that this decision should be made in the context of all other budget
considerations and reminded members that the Police Chief is authorized to assign officers and
address priorities as they present themselves. It was his opinion that the current level of police
officers was a substantial number for the City of Dover.
Responding to Mr. Leary, Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, stated that the mid-year budget
review is typically scheduled for the first week in March.
Mr. Ruane reminded members of the City’s budget situation and questioned the ability of members
to vote on an issue without first identifying revenue sources. He noted that the recommendation
would possibly require a property tax increase and, previously, several members adamantly rejected
an increase in property taxes.
In response to the suggestion to erect fencing and/or create a “gated community,” Mr. Bonar
reminded members that during a recent shooting incident, individuals were shooting at people from
a City-owned park through a fence that surrounds a community development. In order to prevent
this from occurring, he noted that there would be a need to install a solid, eight (8) foot wall. He
explained that the Committee recommended providing the police force the manpower needed to
protect the citizens of Dover. Mr. Bonar indicated that, based on figures provided earlier, the City
was considering an increase of ½ of 1% to fund a $186,000 bond issue for the library; therefore, if
it is necessary to raise taxes to fund this recommendation, he stated that it may require a 1½% to 2%
tax increase to fund the Police Department at a level that would give them the manpower to handle
situations and re-establish various programs.
Mr. Salters felt that the City was being presumptuous in thinking that the Police Department can stop
the situations that are occurring in public housing communities. He reiterated the need to conduct
a comprehensive study, noting that additional action by the DHA was needed.
Página 19
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 19
Mr. McGlumphy reminded members of the City’s Vision and Mission Statement and expressed his
concern about the magnitude of violence in the City of Dover. He stated that there are times when
a staffing “surge” is required and that this may not necessarily reflect what is required in the future.
He explained that this is a safety issue that is critical at this time and that members should not delay
taking the necessary action to help resolve these matters. He felt that the City would be negligent
if action was not taken at this time.
Mr. Leary moved to amend the motion by requesting that the Council President refer this item to the
appropriate committee or committees for a proper and full exploration of the problems from the
standpoint of law enforcement, for an examination into the operation and role of the Dover Housing
Authority, and to study the budgetary impact, including funding sources. The motion was seconded
by Mrs. Russell.
Mrs. Russell noted that Mrs. Williams sits on the Board for the DHA and suggested that she recuse
herself from this matter.
On the call for the question by Mr. Bonar, the amendment to the motion was carried by a roll
call vote of eight (8) yes and one (1) no (Mr. McGlumphy).
The motion to approve the Committee’s recommendation that the manpower for the City of
Dover Police Department be increased to 100 and to explore the necessary means of raising the
revenues to see this accomplished, and that the Council President refer this item to the
appropriate committee or committees for a proper and full exploration of the problems from
the stand point of law enforcement, for an examination into the operation and role of the
Dover Housing Authority, and to study the budgetary impact, including funding sources, was
carried by a roll call vote of five (5) yes and four (4) no (Mrs. Russell, Mr. McGlumphy,
Mr. Salters, and Mr. Ruane).
Waiver Request for Length of Dead-end Street (Cul-de-Sac) in Wynsome Oaks Subdivision
on White Oak Road
Members considered a waiver request which would allow the length of a dead-end street in the
Wynsome Oaks Subdivision to exceed 400 feet. The Conceptual Subdivision Plan proposes to
create 17 parcels from an existing parcel totaling 12.78+/- acres. The property is located on the south
side of White Oak Road, southwest of Mourning Dove Lane. The owner of record is TFLD
Management, LLC (Tax Parcel: LC-05-068.00-01-18.00-000).
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, advised members
that the Subdivision Plan for this project proposes 17 parcels with residual land, and the entrance
street leading into the site is off White Oak Road. The Subdivision Ordinance limits a dead end
street to a maximum length of 400 feet. The proposed development proposes a dead end street of
900+/- feet. The street layout in the subdivision proposes one (1) main street (Bella Boulevard) and
a stub street (Emerson Drive) to connect to the property to the west. The portion of Bella Boulevard,
south of the intersection with Emerson Drive, that will end in a cul-de-sac is 400 feet in length and
would be permitted. However, until the road connection to the west is established, the entirety of
Bella Boulevard will be a dead end street exceeding 400 feet in length.
Página 20
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 20
Mrs. Townshend advised members that the Planning Commission recommended approval of the
waiver to allow the length of the dead end street to exceed 400 feet.
The Committee recommended approval of the requested waiver, as recommended by the Planning
Commission.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Prioritization of Transportation Projects
During their meeting of August 25, 2010, members were advised that in the upcoming months,
the Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT), the Dover/Kent County Metropolitan
Planning Organization (MPO), the Wilmington Area Planning Council (WILMAPCO), and Sussex
County will be holding public hearings on the State’s Capital Transportation Program for the
next fiscal year. These hearings will begin the process of preparing a capital program that will
ultimately be approved as part of the Bond Bill in June 2011. Members recommended that the
Mayor and Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, finalize
the list of City Capital Transportation Program priorities that will be ranked by members during their
September meeting, provide this list to Mr. Ralph Reeb and other appropriate DelDOT officials and,
following the November State elections, meet with legislators to obtain their support for these
projects. (This recommendation was approved by City Council on September 13, 2010.)
Mrs. Townshend reminded members that each year City Council ranks transportation projects in the
City of Dover in order to share the City’s priorities with DelDOT. (The last ranking of priorities
took place at the Safety Advisory and Transportation Meeting of September 30, 2009, and was
approved by City Council on October 12, 2009.) Mrs. Townshend reviewed the previous year’s
priority listing that was provided to members as well as staff’s comments, which were noted in red.
With reference to the Delaware Route 8 Study, Mrs. Townshend advised members that there have
been intense discussions with the Capital School District regarding the construction of the new
Dover High School. She stated that two (2) stub streets were constructed in the Village of Westover
and Village of Cannon Mill with the intent that these streets would connect to the property to the
north (now the site of the proposed Dover High School) when it was developed. Mrs. Townshend
noted that the Capital School District has been very resistant to interconnection. Staff has agreed
that if the school district provides a bicycle/pedestrian connection at the stub street in the Village of
Westover, this would be sufficient; however, with approximately 1,000 units in the Villages of
Westover and Cannon Mill, she stressed that it is unacceptable to have individuals drive to Artis
Drive or Mifflin Road, which are already overly congested intersections; and therefore, there is a
need to connect to the stub street in the Village of Cannon Mills. She noted that the new high school
is planned to open in 2014 and she provided a map depicting the road connection (Forrest Avenue
and Hazlettville Road) that will ultimately be required (attachment to Committee minutes).
In discussions with DelDOT regarding this matter, Mrs. Townshend explained the necessity for both
the City and the School Board to give this road connection high priority in order for this project to
come to fruition and for funding to be in place when the high school opens.
Página 21
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 21
In addition, members discussed the possibility of a crossover bridge for pedestrians at the school.
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, explained the high costs that
would be associated due to the need to meet requirements under the Americans with Disabilities Act.
After much discussion, staff recommended that Priority #1 - Intermodal Transportation Terminal
(Dover Transit Hub) be removed, #8 - Delaware Route 8 Study become either #1 or #2, #4 - West
Dover Connector become either #1 or #2, and that the remaining priorities remain the same.
The Committee recommended the establishment of new priorities for Transportation Projects as
recommended by staff, with Priority #8 becoming #1 and Priority #4 becoming #2.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. Townshend stated that during the Committee meeting, members were
advised that the site improvements for the Dover Transit Center are underway and that State Capital
Funding would not be granted for a building. Although the Department of Transportation will work
with a public/private partnership on the project, she stated that the building will be built by the
private sector and the publicly funded portion of the Transit Center will be completed this year.
Mr. Ruane indicated his understanding that the Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT)
is interested in the building and would be issuing a Request for Proposals (RFP) to obtain a private
developer for the project. He relayed concern that if the project were not included on the list, it
would be misconstrued that the Transit Center is no longer a priority for the City of Dover. He
suggested that this project be included on the list.
Mr. Ruane also relayed concern with the North/South Road between Route 8 and Hazlettville Road
on the west side of the Capital School District Property and the Village of Cannon Mills (Project
from Delaware Route 8 Study) being listed as a priority before the longstanding priority of the City
and the Chamber of Commerce for the West Dover Connector.
At the request of Mrs. Williams, Mrs. Townshend reiterated her significant concerns regarding traffic
on Artis Drive and Mifflin Road and the overly congested intersections in that area. She reminded
members that DelDOT has indicated that if the City and School District state that this project is a
priority, DelDOT would possibly take the necessary action to expedite it. She noted that a DelDOT
project can sometimes take decades to complete and, with the school proposed for completion in
2014, she felt that it was necessary to indicate its priority. Mrs. Townshend assured members that
listing this project as the top priority did not indicate it is more important than the West Dover
Connector; however, if the high school opens and the only ingress and egress is via Route 8, a
“regional transportation nightmare” will be created.
Mr. Ruane advised members that the West Dover Connector project is finally being considered a
priority with DelDOT and he feared that if the West Dover Connector does not remain as Priority
#1 with the City of Dover, the perception will be that funding can be taken from this project to fund
the Route 8 project. In addition, he noted that the top project for the Chamber of Commerce and the
economic development community is the Garrison Oak Connector Road. He advised members that
Página 22
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 22
DelDOT has already bought the right-of-way for the connector road and that there are tenants
preparing to move into the area, and many others who would potentially be interested, provided there
was a service road.
Mr. Ruane moved that the West Dover Connector remain listed as Priority #1; the Garrison Oak
Connector Road be listed as Priority #2; the North/South Road between Route 8 and Hazlettville
Road on the West Side of the Capital School District Property and the Village of Cannon Mills
(Project from Delaware Route 8 Study) be listed as Priority #3; the Dover Transit Center be listed
as Priority #4; and the remaining projects follow in the order previously listed. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Leary.
In response to Mr. Leary, Mrs. Townshend explained that, although the City’s ranking has some
influence, DelDOT considers the eminent needs of the area and that the City’s priorities are only one
(1) factor of many that DelDOT takes into consideration.
On a call for the question by Mrs. Williams, the motion that the West Dover Connector remain
listed as Priority #1; the Garrison Oak Connector Road be listed as Priority #2; the
North/South Road between Route 8 and Hazlettville Road on the West Side of the Capital
School District Property and the Village of Cannon Mills (Project from Delaware Route 8
Study) be listed as Priority #3; the Dover Transit Center be listed as Priority #4; and the
remaining projects follow in the order previously listed (Exhibit #5), was carried by a roll call
vote of five (5) yes and four (4) no (Mr. Bonar, Mrs. Russell, Mr. McGlumphy, and
Mrs. Williams).
Briefing on Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT) Projects - Gary Laing
Mr. Gary Laing, Community Relations Officer for the Delaware Department of Transportation
(DelDOT) and Public Relations Liaison, briefed members on DelDOT Projects, as follows:
West Dover Connector
Mr. Laing stated that a workshop was held by DelDOT on September 28, 2010, regarding the West
Dover Connector and that approximately 200 people were in attendance. During the workshop,
DelDOT presented the preferred alternative and stated that changes will be made to this alternative
as a result of comments received.
Mr. Laing stated that money is available in the draft Capital Transportation Program (CTP) which
will allow DelDOT to move forward with project engineering for the design of the road in FY11 and
FY12, right-of-way acquisition in FY12 and F13, and construction in FY14, FY15, and FY16. He
stated that the total expenditure is estimated at $22M, that the process began in 2004, and that it will
be 12 more years before the roadway is completed.
Página 23
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 23
South Governors Avenue Improvements
Mr. Laing reported that, according to contract, paving of South Governors Avenue from Wyoming
Avenue to just south of Water Street will begin next week. Additional work is required at the Water
Street intersection; therefore paving of this intersection cannot be completed at this point.
Responding to Mrs. Williams, Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works,
stated that the Governors Avenue Improvement Project will not solve the water problem at
the intersection of Water Street. He explained that, in order to reduce the flooding at Water Street,
it will be necessary to upgrade the piping system from the intersection to the St. Jones or past
Elm Terrace and Kerbin Street, where the pipe comes to daylight. This upgrade would cost
approximately $3M-$4M.
Responding to Mr. Bonar, Mr. Laing indicated that, according to the project contract, all Governors
Avenue road work is to be completed by the end of the year.
Water Street Railroad Crossover
Mr. Laing advised members that there is no new information to report on the Water Street railroad
crossover, explaining that this project is a long way from being realized. He reminded members that
any at-grade railroad crossing requires approval of the railroad.
Mr. Bonar relayed concern that this project will not be necessary once the Transit Center is complete.
He stated his feeling that a railroad crossing would not be desired next to the Transit Center.
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, advised members
that there has been much discussion regarding the railroad crossover being key to pulling the
downtown and Eden Hill areas together.
Wyoming Mill Road Project
Mr. Laing advised members that he spoke with the manager of the Wyoming Mill Road Project who
estimated that the project will be let out to bid in approximately one (1) month. He explained that
there are two (2) properties that must be acquired and funds must be shifted internally. Mr. Laing
stated that the project is planned to go to construction in the Spring of 2011.
Briefing on Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) Projects -
Juanita Wieczoreck
Due to the absence of a representative from the Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning
Organization, there was no briefing provided to members.
Mrs. Williams moved for acceptance of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee
Report, seconded by Mr. Salters and unanimously carried.
Página 24
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 24
MONTHLY REPORTS - AUGUST 2010
By motion of Mr. Leary, seconded by Mr. Salters, the following monthly reports were accepted
by consent agenda:
Budget Report
Chief of Police Report
City Assessor’s Report
City Manager's Report
City Planner’s Report
Dover Fire Department Report
PERMANENT EASEMENT AGREEMENT WITH DELDOT FOR ACCESS AND
MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT OF LANDS LOCATED WEST OF GARRISON FARM
PROPERTY PARCEL (LC-05-068.00-01.01)
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that agreements between the City of Dover
and LS Power for the Development of the Dover Sun Park required the City of Dover to secure
access and maintenance easements to 24.39 acres of DelDOT-owned lands west of the Sun Park.
He explained that the purpose of the easement is to remove trees that will cast a shadow on the Solar
Panels and assured members that LS Power has agreed to reimburse the City for the easement and
associated costs, including $25,000 for the easement and $2,250 for the appraisal of the property.
Mr. DePrima stated that once the easement is secure, the City will develop an agreement with
LS Power to complete the initial work to provide for maintenance.
Staff recommended that the Mayor be authorized to execute the Permanent Easement Agreement
with DelDOT.
Mr. Ruane moved for approval of staff’s recommendation that the Mayor be authorized to
execute the Permanent Easement Agreement with DelDOT (Exhibit #6), seconded by
Mr. Salters and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
AUTHORIZATION TO PURCHASE CITY OF DOVER DEFINING AND INFORMATION
PAGES IN THE KENT COUNTY DELAWARE 2011 PROFILE
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that Independent Newspapers, Inc.,
publishes an annual Kent County Delaware Profile, which is designed to help with the economic
growth of the County and will be used by the Economic Development Office, the Chambers of
Commerce, local businesses, realtors, colleges and universities, hospitals and medical groups, etc.,
to attract new businesses and industries to the area, and to recruit professionals and executives for
employment. There will be 10,000 copies of this booklet printed and distributed throughout the year.
Mr. DePrima reminded members that last year, this expense was paid for out of Council’s budget
and requested that the $1,200 cost for the information page be paid from Council’s budget again.
Staff recommended authorization to place a City of Dover Information Page in the Kent County
Delaware 2011 Profile and that staff be authorized to include this cost in the budget for future years.
Página 25
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 25
Mr. Ruane questioned why this expense would not be the responsibility of the Economic
Development Office. Responding, Mr. DePrima stated that the request for the item to be paid for
from the Council’s budget was based on the previous year’s action.
Mr. Bonar moved for approval of staff’s recommendation authorizing staff to place a City of
Dover Information Page in the Kent County Delaware 2011 Profile at a cost of $1,200, to be
paid for from Council’s budget, and that this expense be included in the Economic
Development Budget in future years. The motion was seconded by Mr. Leary and carried by
a roll call vote of five (5) yes and four (4) no (Mrs. Russell, Mr. McGlumphy, Mrs. Williams,
and Mr. Ruane).
EVALUATION OF BIDS - PAYROLL, TIMEKEEPING, AND HUMAN RESOURCES
SERVICES CONTRACT
Members were provided information regarding a Request for Proposal (RFP) for Outsourcing
Payroll Services - Integrated Human Resources and Payroll Services. Mrs. Donna Mitchell,
Controller/Treasurer, reminded members that a cost/benefit analysis to compare outsourcing versus
hiring additional payroll staff was previously shared with the City Manager, Human Resources
Director, and City Council. Prior to issuing an RFP, in March 2010 department heads and
representatives from City Departments reviewed a demonstration of the Automatic Data Processing
system to assist in analyzing the payroll outsourcing option. The response was favorable and it was
determined that this system would improve efficiency City-wide, particularly for the largest
departments, Police and Public Utilities.
Members were provided details regarding the cost/benefit analysis as well as the cost of outsourcing.
Mrs. Mitchell stated that, based on the analysis, the manual system used today costs the City
$414,685 compared to a projected cost of $114,209 with the Integrated Human Resources, Time
Keeping, and Payroll services. She estimated a potential savings of $300,476, taking “human error”
into consideration.
Mrs. Mitchell advised members that three (3) proposals were received in response to the RFP, all
of which met the criteria including functionality, qualifications, and project understanding. She
stated that the RFP requested all vendors to price the service on an annual basis for 410 active
employees (including seasonal help) and 236 retirees. A summary of the proposal review, including
fees, was provided to members for their review.
Responding to Mrs. Williams, Mrs. Mitchell stated that services provided by the City’s Human
Resources Department include maintaining the Employee Handbook, performance evaluation,
orientation and processing of new employees, recruitment, City activities (e.g., Munch Lunch),
employee awards, etc. In reviewing the concept of outsourcing, she stated that it was discovered that
the City never utilized the Human Resources module of the HTE system. This resulted in the Payroll
Department handling the Human Resources function as it relates to status forms and other personnel
paperwork in order to complete payroll. Mrs. Mitchell stated that the proposal will allow for a fully
integrated system that is not in existence today with the HTE system. Although she was not aware
of any direct cost savings related to the Human Resources Department personnel, she noted that there
Página 26
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 26
are four (4) employees authorized for the Human Resources Department and that there are currently
only three (3) active employees. She suggested the possibility of the fourth employee not being
necessary as a result of the outsourcing.
Mrs. Williams requested that the City Manager provide Council with a brief bullet list of the
functions provided by the Human Resources Department.
Mrs. Mitchell also advised members that staff included in their review the potential for the City’s
Pension Trust Custodian, Wells Fargo, to handle the issuance of pension payments and benefit
changes for retirees. Staff requested payroll vendors to provide separate pricing for retiree payments
for this purpose. It was determined that Wells Fargo was a little less costly than the payroll vendor
and that it would improve efficiency in the Finance Department, since all transactions would go
directly to the Pension accounts without passing through the payroll account. Mrs. Mitchell stated
that if Council agrees with the recommendations, staff would notify all active and retired employees
of the change by October 31, 2010, to take effect on January 1, 2011.
Staff recommended authorization to award a three (3) year contract, to begin January 1, 2011 and
end December 31, 2013, to ADP for Human Resource, Payroll, and Time and Attendance services
totaling $95,335.10 per year, plus equipment leases in the amount of $5,160.00; and authorization
to award a contract to Wells Fargo for retiree payments at an annual cost of $5,664.
Mr. McGiffin moved for approval of staff’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Bonar and
carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
FINAL READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2010-26
The First Reading of the following proposed ordinance was accomplished during the Council
Meeting of September 27, 2010.
FY 2011 Budget Amendment - Project Budgets
Mrs. Williams moved that the Final Reading of the proposed ordinance be acknowledged by
title only, seconded by Mr. Salters and unanimously carried.
Mr. Salters moved for adoption of Ordinance #2010-26 (Exhibit #7), seconded by Mr. Leary
and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
COUNCIL MEMBERS ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. McGiffin reminded members to mark their calendar for June 25, 2011 for the next African
American Festival.
Mrs. Williams moved for adjournment, seconded by Mr. Bonar and unanimously carried.
Página 27
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 11, 2010 PAGE 27
Meeting Adjourned at 9:26 P.M.
TRACI A. McDOWELL
CITY CLERK
All orders, ordinances, and resolutions adopted by City Council during their Regular Meeting of
October 11, 2010, are hereby approved.
CARLETON E. CAREY, SR.
MAYOR
/TM/jg
S:\AGENDAS-MINUTES-PACKETS-PRESENTATIONS-ATT&EXH\Council-Minutes\2001-2010\2010\10-11-2010 Council.wpd
Exhibits
Exhibit #1 - List of Dedication of Rights-of-way and Public Infrastructure Susan Place (Attached to Original
Minutes and File Copy)
Exhibit #2 - Map of Dedication of Rights-of-way and Public Infrastructure Susan Place (Attached to Original
Minutes and File Copy)
Exhibit #3 - Proposed Amendment to Section 3.4 of the Purchasing Policy (Attached to Original Minutes and File
Copy)
Exhibit #4 - Appendix E of the Purchasing Policy (Attached to Original Minutes and File Copy)
Exhibit #5 - Revised 2010 City of Dover Transportation Projects Prioritization List
Exhibit #6 - Permanent Easement Agreement with DelDOT (Attached to Original Minutes and File Copy)
Exhibit #7 - Ordinance #2010-26 - FY2011 Budget Amendment - Project Budgets (Attached to Original Minutes
and File Copy)
Página 28
EXHIBIT #1
Regular Council Meeting of 10/11/2010
DEDICATION OF RIGHTS-OF-WAY AND PUBLIC INFRASTURCTURE
SUSAN PLACE – PERSIMMON PARK PLACE
ATTACHMENT A
The following is a list of all public improvements which are to be accepted by the City of Dover:
Sewer Utility Infrastructure (Construction Value = $56,250):
8” SDR-35 PVC Sanitary Sewer Main - 1,125 l.f.
6” PVC Sanitary Sewer Laterals - 460 l.f. (23 laterals)
4' Diameter Sanitary Sewer Manholes - 5 ea. (25.50 v.f.)
Water Utility Infrastructure (Construction Value = $45,500):
8” C900 PVC Water Main - 1,300 l.f.
6” C900 PVC Water Main - 481 l.f.
1” Polyethylene Water Service Lines - 460 l.f. (23 services)
8” Gate Valve - 1 ea.
6” Hydrant Valve - 2 ea.
Fire Hydrants - 2 ea.
Storm Water Infrastructure (Construction Value = $20,000):
Catch Basins - 6 ea.
15” Type III Reinforced Concrete Pipe - 78 l.f.
Street Infrastructure (0.23 miles) (Construction Value = $100,000):
Susan Place - From Station 00+00 to Station 12+25 1,225 l.f.
Página 29
Attachment B
EXHIBIT #2
Regular Council Meeting of 10/11/2010
Susan Place-Persimmon Park Place
Right of Way to be Dedicated to the City of Dover
a
Sus
nP
lac e
0 75 150 300 Feet
¯
Legend
Date Printed: September 16, 2010
Date Created: September 16, 2010 Right of Way to be Dedicated
File: m:\gis_data\projects\st_dedication_map
Department: Public Services GIS Dover Parcels
City of Dover, Delaware
Página 30
EXHIBIT #3
Regular Council Meeting of 10/11/2010
3.4 PURCHASING THRESHOLD TABLE
PURCHASING THRESHOLDS
Less than $5,000 $5,000 to $24,999 $25,000 & Over
Open market; Department Head Department Head solicit no less than Formal Invitation to Bid (ITB) or Request for
discretion to obtain quotes; three (3) written quotations; If fewer Proposal (RFP/RFQ); No less than three (3)
than three (3) quotations, justification potential vendors supplied to Central Services;
must be included;
Purchases will be made by Quotations and support Pre Solicitation Meeting required of the
designated personnel; documentation to be maintained in respective Department & Procurement
Central Services files as public record; Manager to discuss appropriate procedures and
To include name of vendor, date of specifications;
submission, and amount; Use the
quotation worksheet in Appendix E.
Approved invoices sent to Requires requisition and purchase Public sealed bid or sealed proposal procedures
Accounts Payable for payment. order through the financial system; as outlined in Appendix A;
Purchases under existing City All purchases will be made by Central Public Advertising at least once a week for two
contracts shall be made in Services or the Police Department (2) consecutive weeks in publication with
accordance with the terms of such Purchase Coordinator by Purchase circulation in each county of the State;
contract. Order or Contract, Additional advertising discretionary;
Supplies available from City stock Award shall be made to the lowest Lowest and/or most responsive bid will be
should not be procured from third and the best quotation; Vendor accepted; Vendor references may be checked
party vendors. references may be checked; to verify ability to meet contract requirements;
Item numbers, quantities, unit Item numbers, quantities, unit cost, Public Bid/Proposal Opening; Time and date
cost, and extension must be and extension must be completed on of public bid opening shall be stated in the
completed on every purchase every purchase order for materials or notice for bids; Delivered to Central Services,
order for materials or paying for paying for contracted labor at hourly 710 William Street, Dover, DE 19904
contracted labor at hourly rates; rates;
Approval - Department Head Fax and email quotations are Bid Bond or certified check in the amount
Level acceptable; equivalent to ten percent (10%) of the bid
amount for items/contracts over $25,000; Can
be waived by Purchasing Agent and
Department Head;
Electronic Approval - City Manager Performance Bond required for construction
& Treasurer work;
Purchase Order to include: Faxed bid are not acceptable for this category;
Unit Cost $; Account number; project Sealed bids may be emailed to
number if applicable; Brief description bids@dover.de.us or as agreed to with the
of item or service when not identifiable; Department Head;
Quotes from each vendor in comments;
Purchases exceeding $25,000 shall require
NOTE – Changes to Purchase Orders Council approval for sole source procurement,
are to be completed through the greater than budget and not low bidder;
financial systems. Purchase Orders Committee/Council Action Forms to include:
received with manual changes to Budget $, P. O. $ or Unit Cost $; Account
amounts/unit cost will not be number; project number; page number in budget;
processed by the Finance Department. Bid/RFP number if applicable. If unit cost bid
include cost comparison. If blanket bid or
proposal is for recurring services, provide
average annual cost for past three years for the
service. Description and recommended action.
Página 31
EXHIBIT #4
Regular Council Meeting of 10/11/2010
APPENDIX E
CITY OF DOVER QUOTATION WORKSHEET
(To be used for purchases between $5,000.00 and $24,999.99)
Department: ___________________________ Division: _________________________
Department Contact (Name & number): _______________________________________
Item/Service: ____________________________________________________________
Estimated Dollar Value: ___________________________________________________
Account Code: _________________________________ Project Code: ______________
Vendors (At least three vendors must be used. Include at least one minority or women owned
vendor, if available. Use of more than one minority or women owned vendor is encouraged):
1. Go to http://gss.omb.delaware.gov/omwbe/index.shtml.
2. Select Minority and/or Women Business Enterprise Directory
3. Search by keyword i.e. Electrician, Construction, Furniture
List keyword(s) used: ______________________________________________
4. Each company displayed will have its assigned NAICS code listed.
List NAICS Code(s) used: __________________________________________
5. Refine search by NAICS Code if necessary.
6. Were Vendors Found: YES NO If so, how many:__________________
Vendor 1: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 2: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 3: _______________________________________________________Minority
If more than three vendors are used, list them on the reverse of this form.
Date sent out for quotes: __________________________
Date due back: _________________________
Date of award: _____________________
Vendor receiving the award: ________________________________________________
Was the 3% minority vendor preference applied in the evaluation? YES NO
Was this a minority vendor? YES NO
Total dollar amount of purchase or estimated total contract value: $_________________
Purchase Order produced: YES NO PO Number: ________________________
Send completed form to the Procurement Office in Central Services.
Página 32
Additional vendors used for this purchase
Vendor 4: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 5: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 6: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 7: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 8: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 9: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 10: ______________________________________________________Minority
Send completed form to the Procurement Office in Central Services.
Página 33
EXHIBIT #5
Regular Council Meeting of 10/11/2010
CITY OF DOVER
2010 TRANSPORTATION PRIORITIZATION LIST
For the purpose of aiding in the prioritization of projects for the coming year, updates have been added to
projects that City Council prioritized in 2009. The Delaware Department of Transportation is in the
process of developing the FY 2012 - FY2017 Capital Transportation Program (CTP). This sets out the
State’s transportation funding priorities over the next six years. Ultimately, the CTP will tie in with the
FY2012 Bond Bill approved by the General Assembly in June 2011. The City’s identified transportation
priorities, once approved by City Council, will be shared with the Delaware Department of Transportation,
and City staff and the Mayor will advocate for these projects, as discussed previously by the Safety
Advisory and Transportation Committee.
1. West Dover Connector
With the completion of SR 1 around Dover, the east-west corridors in and out of the City have
seen increases in traffic. The City of Dover Comprehensive Plan Update in 2003 and the
Dover/Kent County MPO Long Range Transportation Plan recommended studying the extension
of Saulsbury Road due to persistent and fast-paced growth that contributes to existing and future
traffic congestion in the area. The West Dover Connector project is studying the feasibility of
extending Saulsbury Road across the Eden Hill Farm and adjacent agricultural parcels making
connections to New Burton Road and possibly to US Route 13. Because much of the land needed
for such a roadway is undeveloped, the opportunity still exists to make improvements that best
accommodate the area's multi-modal transportation needs. Alternative routes and concepts have
been developed with the input and guidance of the West Dover Connector Working Group that
began in 2004. This group is working in conjunction with DelDOT and with neighborhood and
community officials, schools, local government leaders, concerned citizens, federal and state
environmental and cultural resource agencies, and others to develop options that meet the diverse
needs of the community.
Through a series of workshops, the group developed five alternative options to improve mobility
across the Norfolk Southern Railroad for all modes of travel to and from the west side of Dover,
to reduce congestion at key intersections in the study area, and to improve the connecting
roadway network for local travel.
City Council, in December 2005, adopted a resolution to endorse Alternative Option 5C as the
best possible alternative alignment for the West Dover Connector. The key features of 5C are as
follows:
• Extends Saulsbury Road over Puncheon Run and the railroad spur on a bridge;
• Parallels New Burton Road on the west side of the railroad corridor;
• Provides a new connector road across the Kesselring Farm (west of New Burton Road);
• Connects to New Burton Road with a ramp;
• Connects to US Route 13 using Charles Polk Road corridor; and
• Potential connection to Wyoming Mill Road
The Resolution stated that Alternative Option 5C has little or no impact on the existing homes,
churches, and schools on nearby adjoining streets and would reduce cut-through traffic and
1
Página 34
traffic volume along Camden-Wyoming Avenue, as well as provide a direct connector to US
Route 13. Alternative Option 5C provides for interconnectivity and offers protection of City
utilities without impacting the Mayfair Electric Substation. This option would establish a
defined southern boundary for the City. This option was one of two concepts recommended by
both the Working Group and the Project Team. Alternative Option 5C has been identified in the
Dover City Council's Transportation Projects Prioritization as a key aspect of the West Dover
Connector project.
On September 28, 2010, the Department of Transportation held a workshop and unveiled the
preferred alternative, which is a modified 5C.
a. West Street/North Street Intersection
The intersection of West Street and North Street has been identified as a potentially
problematic portion of the road network. Difficulties for northbound traffic on West
Street attempting to make left turns are compounded by line of sight issues down North
Street. There have not been simple solutions to this issue to date as the road network in
the surrounding area is compact enough where even small adjustments to one intersection
can have dramatic impacts on other intersections. Increased traffic generation from Eden
Hill Farm TND has begun to contribute to congestion in the area and is expected to be
more significant with the addition of Eden Hill’s commercial portions.
2. Garrison Oak Connector Road
Garrison Oak is a 385-acre tract zoned as IPM2 (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone-Technology
Center) and is the only site in the City to be zoned as such. It has been identified by the City as an
ideal location for large technological/green industry firms that require large lot sizes of over
twenty acres.
DelDOT has acquired the necessary right-of way to build a road extending south to Route 8 to tie
in with the interchange. As development plans for Garrison Oak are well underway, the design
and construction of this road is a priority for marketing Garrison Oak. The Dover Sun Park is
expected to break ground in late 2010, and the City is in negotiations with Macquarie Energy for
a gas power plant on another lot in the park. Dover City Council has prioritized this project and
recommended that it be identified in the State's six-year CTP.
3. North/South Road between Route 8 and Hazlettville Road on the West Side of the Capital School
District Property and the Village of Cannon Mills (Project from Delaware Route 8 Study)
The Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization conducted a study in 2007 of the
State Route 8 corridor from the railroad tracks, west to Artis Drive. The study identifies a
number of service roads and alternative roadways to help disperse the traffic pattern and reduce
congestion on Route 8.
The Capital School District is moving forward with plans for a new Dover High School, and the
construction of a north/south road between Artis Drive and Mifflin road, along the west edge of
the Capital School District property and immediately west of the Village of Cannon Mills, is
important in relieving potential stress on Hazlettville Road, Route 8, Artis Drive, and Mifflin
2
Página 35
Road associated with traffic related to the new school. While the Capital School District will
fund and construct a portion of this road from Route 8 into the Dover High School campus, the
Delaware Department of Transportation will need to construct the majority of the road, as more
than half of the distance between Route 8 and Hazlettville Road is south of the property owned
by the Capital School District. Additionally, sidewalk installation where sidewalk gaps are
present might be a priority for implementation to ensure safe pedestrian access to the new Dover
High School.
4. Dover Transit Hub (Intermodal Transportation Center)
The Dover Transit Hub has outgrown the existing Water Street Transfer Hub in Dover, and
DelDOT has purchased the former George & Lynch property at Water and Queen Streets to
support the new transit hub. The site improvements involved to construct the bus transfer hub
are underway at this site, with the support of federal stimulus dollars. The concept for the site
also includes an indoor waiting area, ticket sales, restrooms, and service for local DART,
Paratransit and inter-county lines as well as commercial bus service and taxis and office space
for lease. The building plans and construction are not part of the improvements underway. More
recent discussions including DelDOT, the City of Dover, and the Downtown Dover Partnership
would have DelDOT proceed with an RFP to solicit private sector developers to enter into a
public private partnership to develop the building on the site. Dover City Council has prioritized
this project and recommends that, even if additional State funding is not necessary to pursue the
public private partnership to construct a building on the site, the Department continue with efforts to
construct the transit center building in a cooperative effort with the private sector.
5. Loockerman Street/Forest Street Improvements
This project includes a series of improvements throughout Dover that will encourage economic
development and alternative modes of transportation. These improvements include a roundabout
adjacent to the Dover Train Station building, new curbing, and new sidewalks. Additionally, this
project will enhance Downtown Dover development.
This project remains an important component to the western gateway to the downtown. It also
ties in with the Clarence Street extension project, which will extend Clarence Street north from
North Street to Forest Street. Additionally, a new office building proposal by Bob Duncan on
what is referred to as the “triangle site” across from the Duncan Center also makes this a timely
project. Dover City Council has prioritized this project and recommended that it be identified in
the State's 6-year CTP.
6. US Route 13 Service Road Corridor
In adherence to the State’s Corridor Capacity Preservation Program, the addition of service roads
from Scarborough Road, east and west of Route 13, from the toll plaza through to Dover Downs,
behind the Dover Mall and Wilmington University, would decrease traffic on US 13 in an
attempt to get local traffic off Route 13. Dover City Council has prioritized this project and
recommended that it be identified in the State's 6-year CTP.
3
Página 36
The purpose of the US Route 13/113 corridor through the City has changed. This roadway once
served the dual purposes of a high speed through travel route and as a local access road to service
the many commercial businesses that were constructed along it. With SR 1 serving the needs of
through travelers, the US Route 13/113 corridor is becoming a destination for commerce and
community activities, as well as a significant employment center for the growing service sector.
In order to address the changing character of this roadway, a workshop was conducted by the
Dover/Kent County MPO. The purpose of the workshop was to generate new ideas for
improving the appearance and operation of the corridor. The organization prepared a report
entitled “Concept Plan for US Routes 13 and 113 in Dover – Phase I, Technical Memorandum II:
Final Recommendations.” This was adopted by the MPO in November 1, 2000. The final
recommendations of the study were:
• Create a corridor overlay zone;
• Service roads for local traffic;
• Assist voluntary development of rear access to business;
• Construction of sidewalks and bike paths;
• Median landscaping;
• Add bus pullovers where needed;
• Installation of attractive lights that serve both motorists and pedestrians;
• Bury utilities;
• Install pedestrian buttons at signals and strip crosswalks heavily; and
• Develop a system of appropriate signage.
7. US Route 13 Sidewalk Construction
As part of an ongoing effort along the corridor, this project will complete the sidewalk network
on both sides of US Route 13. The scope of the project includes addressing accessibility and
ADA compliance. Field surveys and preliminary design have been conducted and this project is
in the design phase. Dover City Council has prioritized this project and recommended that it be
identified in the State's 6-year CTP.
8. Kenton Road Corridor Upgrades
The proposal is to upgrade the Kenton Road corridor from Route 8 to Denneys Road to an urban
road standard. Improvements to the corridor focus on new pavement sections, sidewalks,
shoulders, curbing, enclosed drainage systems, bicycle lanes, lighting and intersection
reconfiguration. DelDOT has entered into a contract with Whitman, Requardt & Associates and
this project is in the study phase.
The study is a large study and, in terms of prioritization, the installation of sidewalks along
Kenton Road between Route 8 and College Road would be a first phase priority implementation
project from this study that should be added to the CTP. Dover City Council has prioritized this
project and recommended that it be identified in the State's six-year CTP.
4
Página 37
9. College Road Corridor Upgrades
Another road improvement project is to upgrade the College Road corridor from Kenton Road to
Saulsbury Road to an urban road standard. Improvements in this project include new pavement
sections, sidewalks, shoulders, closed drainage system, bicycle lane, lighting and other
improvements. Once completed, this road will be similar to Walker Road. Dover City Council
has prioritized this project and recommended that it be identified in the State's 6-year CTP.
10. Crawford Carroll Avenue Extension
This project will continue the improved right-of-way of Crawford Carroll Avenue from West
Rustic Lane in a southerly direction to the site with Circuit City and PetSmart and connect to US
Route 13 via a signalized intersection. Crawford Carroll Avenue is a limited access service
roadway designed to alleviate traffic congestion on Route 13 and provide local motorists with
alternate routes to access the commercial areas of Route 13 in north Dover. This project is
currently in Phase III of implementation.
Policy/Program Prioritization List
1. Weekend Bus Service
2. Airport Studies and Improvements to Accommodate Passenger and Aircraft Related Industries
3. Red Light Photo Enforcement Program
4. Bike Path Connectivity
5. Continued Exploration of Options for Relocating the Storage and Marshalling of Chemical Cars
at the Norfolk Southern Yard on New Burton Road
6. Additional Studies of Next Phase to Implement Commuter Passenger Rail Service between
Wilmington and Dover.
5
Página 38
EXHIBIT #6
Regular Council Meeting of 10/11/2010
Página 42
EXHIBIT #7
Regular Council Meeting of 10/11/2010
Page 1 of 3 FINAL READING
CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE #2010-26
1 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
2 The amounts hereinafter named in various City funds are changed from the currently approved revenues/receipts
3 and appropriations to the revised revenues/receipts and revised appropriations for use by the various departments
4 of the Municipal Government for:
5 City of Dove r
6 Gove rnm e nta l Ca pita l Proje cts Fund
7 Propose d Budge t Am e ndm e nt - Fisca l Ye a r 2011
2010/11
2010/11 BUDGET REVISED
8 BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS BUDGET
9 BEGINNING BALANCE & RECEIPTS:
10 BEGINNING BALANCE - PROJEC TS $ 65,479 $ 162,113 $ 227,592
11 BEGINNING BALANCE - LIBRARY - 34,583 34,583
12 STATE GRAN TS 3,343,520 888,828 4,232,348
13 INTEREST EARN INGS 10,900 - 10,900
14 POLICE GRAN TS 18,000 - 18,000
15 LIBR ARY BOND ISSUE/CONTRIBUTIONS 1,000,000 - 1,000,000
16 TRANSFER FROM GEN ERAL FUND FOR PROJECTS 1,307,839 - 1,307,839
17 TRANSFER FROM PARKLAND RESERVE (JWP ADDTN) - 36,872 36,872
18 TRANSFER FROM LIBRARY RESERVE 2,343,519 20,213 2,363,732
19 TRANSFER FROM CAPITAL ASSET R ESER VE 140,000 (140,000) -
20 TOTAL BUDGET $ 8,229,257 $ 1,002,609 $ 9,231,866
21 DEPARTMENT EXPENDITURES:
22 FIRE $ 288,210 $ (64,510) $ 223,700
23 GROUNDS MAINTENANC E 63,675 - 63,675
24 LIBR ARY 6,687,039 943,624 7,630,663
25 RECREATION 45,000 36,872 81,872
26 POLICE 282,380 53,500 335,880
27 STREETS 481,055 - 481,055
28 SANITATION 246,075 - 246,075
29 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 12,000 - 12,000
30 MAYOR 31,500 - 31,500
31 TOTAL EXPENDITURES $ 8,136,934 $ 969,486 $ 9,106,420
32 CUR RENT YEAR BALAN CE - PROJECTS 92,323 33,123 125,446
33 TOTAL BUDGET $ 8,229,257 $ 1,002,609 $ 9,231,866
Página 43
2 of 3
34 City of Dove r
35 W a te r/W a ste rw a te r Im prove m e nt & Ex te nsion Fund
36 Propose d Budge t Am e ndm e nt - Fisca l Ye a r 2011
2010/11
2010/11 BUDGET REVISED
37 BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS BUDGET
38 BEGINNING BALANCE & RECEIPTS:
39 PRIOR YEAR BALANC E - WATER $ 743,431 $ 847,443 $ 1,590,874
40 PRIOR YEAR BALANC E - WASTEWATER 543,668 (589,333) (45,665)
41 BOND PROCEEDS - WASTEWATER 3,016,200 - 3,016,200
42 STATE LOAN FUND - WATER - 2,404,017 2,404,017
43 STATE LOAN FUND - WASTEWATER - 5,597,956 5,597,956
44 TRANS FR WATER/WASTEWATER FOR WATER 500,000 - 500,000
45 TRANS FR WATER/WASTEWATER FOR WASTEWATER 500,000 - 500,000
46 TRANSFER FROM IMPACT FEE RESER VE 242,040 516,781 758,821
47 FEDERAL/STATE GRANTS (WASTEWATER ) - 45,248 45,248
48 TOTAL BUDGET $ 5,545,339 $ 8,822,112 $ 14,367,451
49 DEPARTMENT EXPENSES:
50 WATER 620,000 2,985,055 3,605,055
51 WASTEWATER 1,560,700 5,515,294 7,075,994
52 TOTAL EXPENSES $ 2,180,700 $ 8,500,349 $ 10,681,049
53 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WASTEWATER BOND 2,153,140 - 2,153,140
54 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WATER 623,431 266,405 889,836
55 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WASTEWATER 588,068 55,358 643,426
56 TOTAL BUDGET CURRENT YEAR BALANCES $ 3,364,639 $ 321,763 $ 3,686,402
57 TOTAL BUDGET $ 5,545,339 $ 8,822,112 $ 14,367,451
Página 44
3 of 3
58 City of Dover
59 Electric Improvement & Extension Fund
60 Proposed Budget Amendment - Fiscal Year 2011
2010/11
2010/11 BUDGET REVISED
61 BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS BUDGET
62 BEGINNING BALANCE & REVENUES:
63 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE $ 1,688,861 $ 1,688,307 $ 3,377,168
64 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE BOND - 415,585 415,585
65 INTEREST EARNINGS 40,700 - 40,700
66 STATE REIMBURSEMENT FOR GOVS AVE - 254,757 254,757
67 FEDERAL GRANTS (DOE) - 135,152 135,152
68 TRANSFER FROM ELECTRIC 3,500,000 - 3,500,000
69 TOTAL BUDGET $ 5,229,561 $ 2,493,801 $ 7,723,362
70 DEPARTMENT EXPENSES:
71 ELECTRIC GENERATION $ 1,480,068 $ 471,672 $ 1,951,740
72 TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION 739,000 - 739,000
73 ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING 1,390,429 379,064 1,769,493
74 TRANSFER TO DEPRECIATION RESERVE - 1,000,000 1,000,000
75 TOTAL EXPENSES $ 3,609,497 $ 1,850,736 $ 5,460,233
76 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 1,620,064 643,065 2,263,129
77 TOTAL BUDGET $ 5,229,561 $ 2,493,801 $ 7,723,362
ADOPTED: OCTOBER 11, 2010
Actions History
October 11, 2010 - Proposed Final Reading – Council
September 27, 2010 - First Reading – Council
September 13, 2010 - Considered by Legislative, Finance & Administration Committee