Página 1
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Monday, January 23, 2023 at 6:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware
AGENDA
VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE
This meeting will be held in the City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx.
Public participation information is as follows:
Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://rb.gy/yoyh20
Event number: 2530 690 0748
Event password: DOVER (if needed)
If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.
The meeting can also be viewed on Comcast Channel 14, Verizon Channel 20, and on the City's
Streaming Player located at www.cityofdover.com under "Quick Links".
OPEN FORUM - 15 Minutes Prior to Official Meeting (6:15 p.m.)
The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share their
questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing on the
agenda as a public hearing is prohibited during the Open Forum as an opportunity will be provided during
consideration of that item. Citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is prohibited from
taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule such items as regular
agenda items and act upon them in the future.
INVOCATION - Elder Ellis B. Louden
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Councilman Boggerty
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single
roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of
Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered
a separate item.
Page 1
Página 2
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - January 23, 2023 PAGE 2
PROCLAMATIONS
1. Black History Month
2. Human Trafficking Awareness Month
PRESENTATIONS
3. Certificate of Recognition Pizza Delight by Giacomo
CONSENT AGENDA
ADOPTION OF MINUTES
4. Economic Development Committee Meeting of October 11, 2022
5. Economic Development Committee Meeting of November 15, 2022
6. Regular City Council Meeting of January 9, 2023
COMMITTEE REPORTS
7. Council Committee of the Whole Report of January 10, 2023
Utility Committee
8. Evaluation of Bids – FY 2023 Street and Alley Program (Jason Lyon, Director of
Water and Wastewater)
(Committee recommendation: Award the contract to Sam's Construction, LLC for the
City of Dover FY 2023 Street and Alley Program Bid #23-0005PW, for the amount of
$1,037,595.25)
9. Evaluation of Bids - Williams Park Storm Pipe Replacement (Jason Lyon, Director of
Water and Wastewater)
(Committee recommendation: Award contract to Gateway Construction, Inc. for the
Williams Park Storm Pipe Replacement, ITB #23-0004PW, for $148,000)
10. Annual Review and Approval of Governing Policy for Energy Commodity Risk
Management (Lori Peddicord, Controller/Treasurer)
(Committee recommendation: Approve the proposed amendments to the Governing
Policy for Energy Commodity for Risk Management)
Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee
11. Dover Roundabout Analysis for Governors Boulevard, Ross Street and Bradford
Street (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager)
Page 2
Página 3
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - January 23, 2023 PAGE 3
(Committee recommendation: For Council to receive public input regarding the
options presented and to allow for additional research into low-impact traffic calming
options)
Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
12. Draft Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) (Lori Peddicord,
Controller/Treasurer)
(Committee recommendation: Acceptance of the draft Annual Comprehensive
Financial Report (AFCR)
13. Library Rebranding Presentation (Bryan Sylvester, Library Director)
(Committee Action Not Required)
APPOINTMENTS/REAPPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY MAYOR CHRISTIANSEN
14. Dover Public Library Advisory Commission - Five-Year Term to Expire June 2028
A. Theresa L. Whalen
ITEMS NOT ON THE CONSENT AGENDA
15. Community Reinvestment Funds – Project Allocation
(Staff Recommendation: Accept the $3M from the Community Reinvestment Fund and
approve the project allocation plan.)
16. Well #9 Change Order
(Staff Recommendation: Approve change order request from AECOM, Inc. in the amount
of $19,500, in accordance with the City of Dover Purchasing Policy & Procedures.)
FIRST READING REFERRAL - The First Reading is offered on the Proposed Ordinance. It is
recommended for referral to the Planning Commission for a public hearing on FEBRUARY 21,
2023 and that a Public Hearing before City Council be set for MARCH 13, 2023 at 6:30 p.m., at which
time the Final Reading and Council action will take place. The ordinance is available at the entrance of
the Council Chambers, on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by
contacting the City Clerk's Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us.
17. First Reading-Proposed Ordinance #2023-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023:
Annexation Areas Amendments to 2019 Comprehensive Plan as amended.
The First Reading is offered on the Proposed Ordinance. Amendments to the Comprehensive
Plan require a Public Hearing, and it is recommended that a public hearing be scheduled before
the Planning Commission on Tuesday, February 21, 2023 and that the hearing before City
Council be set for Monday, March 13, 2023 at 6:30 p.m., at which time the Final Reading and
Council action will take place. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council
Chambers, on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by
contacting the City Clerk's Office at 736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us.
Page 3
Página 4
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - January 23, 2023 PAGE 4
Review of a series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as amended. The
Amendments include consideration of the following as associated with Annexation Application
AX-23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road: requests for
amendment of Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the Annexation Plan category of
two properties and requests for amendment of Map 13-2: Potential Land Uses for Annexation
Areas to identify the Land Use Classification of two properties. (Planning Reference: Mi-23-
01)
A. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan
Map - Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of
Bayside Drive to revise the Annexation Plan category from Area of Concern and
unidentified area to Category 2: Priority Annexation Area on Map 13-1: Potential
Annexation Areas Plan Map.
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White
Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
49.00-000.
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road.
Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
B. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation
Areas Map - Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and
west of Bayside Drive to identify the Land Use Classification as Public & Private Utilities
on Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map.
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White
Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-
49.00-000.
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road.
Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
CITY MANAGER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
MAYOR'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ANNOUNCEMENTS
ADJOURNMENT
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO
29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION
OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE
TIME OF THE MEETING
Page 4
Página 5
Item #1.
PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS in 1915, Carter G. Woodson founded the Association for the Study of Negro
Life and History, now known as the Associationfor the Study of African American Life and
History. He believed that historical truth would diminish lies and usher in a new era of
equality, opportunity, and racial democracy; and
WHEREAS, the Association for the Study of African American Life and History has
selected "Black Resistance" as the 2023 National Black History Month theme which
recognizes from American's earliest days, how African Americans have foug ht repression,
oppression, discrimination, and prejudice. From escaping the plantation, to the rise out of
poverty and the strugglefor equal housing and education to the strugglefor voting rights,
the resistance lives on into the 21st century; and
WHEREAS, the important contributions of black faith organizations, cultural centers,
black medical professionals, black athletes, and black musicians who have all challenged
injustice and have worked tirelessly to achieve equality, advocacy, and change; and
WHEREAS, currently, the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement carries on the long
and deep legacy of African American resistance that is ongoing.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF
DOVER, DELAWARE do hereby proclaim February 2023 as
BLACK HISTORY MONTH
in the City of Dover and urge all citizens to recognize the essential role of African
Americans in shaping our nation's history and commit to working together to build a
society that lives up to its dynamic of liberty and justice for all.
Mayor
Page 5
Página 6
Item #2.
PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS, according to the National Human Trqfficking Hotline, "human trafficking is a form of modern-day
slavery in which traffickers useforce, fraud or coercion to control victims for the purpose of engaging in commercial
sex acts or labor services against his or her will affecting every community across age, gender, ethnicity and socio-
economic backgrounds"; and
WHEREAS, human trafficking generates over $150 billion in profits worldwide every year. The 2021 International
Labour Organization report projected approximately 50 million adults and children were victims of modern slavery
globally. An estimated 2 7.6 million were in forced labor including 17.3 million exploited in the private sector, 6.3
million inforced commercial sexual exploitation and 3.9 million inforced labor imposed by state. Traffickers ofien
take advantage of instability caused by natural disasters, conflict, or a pandemic to exploit others; and
WHEREAS, since 2007, the Human Trafficking Hotline for Delaware has received close to 680 signals, such as
phone calls, texts, emails and online tips, and identified over 500 victims included in 212 cases of human trafficking;
and
WHEREAS, in 2009, Trafficking Victims Protection Act passed by Congress establishing methods for prosecuting
traffickers, preventing human trafficking and protecting victims and survivors of trafficking. Recognizing potential
red flags and A-nowing the indicators of human trafficking is a key step in identifYing more victims and helping them
.find assistance. Delaware leaders, social organizations and Delaware Healthcare Association all are devoting
efforts to raise awareness and help stop the epidemic.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE do
hereby proclaim January 2023 as
HUMAN TRAFFICKING A WARENESS MONTH
in the City of Dover and urge all residents to take action by being informed, !!Jpreadawareness and A-nOWthe signs
for it could save someone 's life
Mayor
Page 6
Página 7
Certificate of Recognition
WHEREAS, after moving to the United States from Italy in 1959, Giacomo D 'Ambrosi
opened Pizza Delight by Giacomo in 1972 offering the first fresh dough pizza in Dover at
the Blue Hen Mall; and
WHEREAS, in 1983 they opened acrossfrom the Dover Air Force Basefor a few years
and then moved in 1988 to the Route 8 Greentree Shopping Center. In 1998 they opened
a second location in the Route 10 Gateway South Shopping Center; and
WHEREAS, Pizza Delight by Giacomo has been a trusted and dependable business in
the Dover community for over 50 years. The D 'Ambrosi 's commitment to provide fresh,
quality food to the citizens of Dover has made Pizza Delight by Giacomo a landmark in
our community; and,
WHEREAS, it is deemed an honor and a privilege to present this Certificate of
Recognition to
Giacomo "Jack" D~Ambrosi & Vicki D'Ambrosi
Owners of Pizza Delight by Giacomo
We thank you for serving exceptional homemade food with love, for providing outstanding
service and for being a vital part of the Dover community. The City of Dover extends best
wishes on all your future endeavors.
Mayor
Página 8
Item #4.
Economic Development Committee
Meeting Minutes
October 11, 2022 – 4:00pm
The Economic Development Committee Meeting was held in person and by video conference on
October 11, 2022 at 4:00 p.m. with Mayor Robin R. Christiansen presiding. Committee Members
present in person or via video were Councilman Ralph Taylor, Councilman David Anderson,
Kim Adams, City Manager Dave Hugg, and City Planner Mary Ellen Gray. Clayton E.
Hammond II and Designee of Downtown Dover Partnership Diane Laird were not present.
Guests present were Councilman Fred Neil, Dr. Vilicia Cade with Capital School District, and
Pete Bradley with Kent County Tourism. Public present were Dr. Tony DePrima with Capital
School District Board, and Bobby Wilson.
WELCOME
At 4:00pm Mayor Robin R. Christiansen called the Economic Development Meeting to order.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mayor Christiansen called for a motion to adopt the Agenda. Councilman Fred Neil moved for
adoption of agenda, seconded by Councilman Taylor, unanimously carried. (Clayton E.
Hammond II and Diane Laird absent).
ADOPTION OF MINUTES
Mayor Christiansen called for a motion to adopt the October 12, 2021 minutes. Councilman Fred
Neil moved for adoption of minutes, seconded by Councilman Anderson, unanimously carried.
(Clayton E. Hammond II and Diane Laird absent).
Mayor Christiansen called for a motion to adopt the September 13, 2022 minutes. Councilman
Fred Neil moved for adoption of minutes, seconded by Councilman Anderson, unanimously
carried. (Clayton E. Hammond II and Diane Laird absent).
CAPITAL SCHOOL DISTRICT – DR. VILICIA CADE, SUPERINTENDENT
Dr. Vilicia Cade representing Capital School District. Dr. Cade states good afternoon to the city
council and all honorable people here, to my vice president of my board that is present with me
today, and my board member Mrs. Duggins. I appreciate this conversation on Economic
Development because I believe very firmly that K12 education institutions play a vital role in
Economic Development. Here in the City of Dover we have so much synergy, so much
movement, so much enthusiasm and momentum that is growing around this topic. I am hopeful
Page 8
Página 9
Item #4.
Economic Development Meeting of October 11, 2022 PAGE 2
that my brief presentation will help us spark a conversation and provide some insight on my
vision on how to support Economic Development in our city.
Dr. Vilicia Cade reviewed the presentation entitled “Capital School District Presentation”
Attachment #1.
Mayor Christiansen asked are there any questions for Dr. Cade. Councilman Fred Neil stated not
so much a question but the loudest applaud that I could possibly give to you. Councilman Fred
Neil stated there is no question the irony of that video. The irony is we have people who do not
want to work and an industry that states we don’t need you. And yet the very foundation of
everything we do depends upon on the continuous of humans being able to work and do the job.
I offer my bravos, great keep it up, do what you have, and we will try to support what you have.
There is no question in my mind this is something that has to happen, and you are doing the right
thing at the right time for these kids to grow up. If you had grew up in a household where you
had a second language you would learn that second language. The second language today deals
with dots and dashes, it deals with coding, it deals with all of that. I did not grow up with that.
The kids today would have to teach me. What do I want to do with my cell phone if I want to do
more than call home? What you are doing is on the right track, and all I can say is bravo, bravo,
and bravo.
Councilman Taylor asked about the Parent Leadership Program. Councilman Taylor ask has
Capital School District started working with free adult education either onsite or in the
community? Dr. Cade responded we have a very vital partnership with POLYTECH who has the
adult education contract for Kent County. So, within the Department of Education there is an
adult education branch that is typical. We just had a literacy night and adult education kick off
last Monday, which we worked with our ESL parents. As a part of our parent leadership
program, you will see more partnerships between us and other districts because what I am very
firm on is intentional and receptacle partnerships where we commingle our funds, minimize
duplication of efforts, increase capacity, so we can increase impact by working collaboratively.
Councilman Ralph Taylor had a second question about assisting seniors. As we know seniors are
not capable of some of the technology out here today of basic things. Have you ever considered
an alternative or different type of version of Adopt a Grandparent? Which means you would deal
directly with the seniors. You would teach them how to use these devices, so they can get the
information in real time. I think that would be truly an asset to the community. The long-term
things are necessary, but the right now fixes are inundating us and leaving our seniors behind
each and every day. Dr. Cade responded. Yes, in my previous position in Ohio, I started an
intergenerational partnership with the NAACP, and our school district. I think it is very
important that our young people work with our seniors, and elderly in our community to close
those generational gaps, and to help them advance their use of technology. So, I think there is
great merit in that, I am going into year two, so I haven’t been able to tackle all our issues in the
community. I absolutely see this as an opportunity to work with our senior citizens, and to allow
our young people to take some leadership. But again, going into my year two and the processes
of reconfiguring our entire district I am still building. So, I would take that under advisement.
Councilman Ralph Taylor stated great job, we are well pleased with your efforts. We can see
your fingerprint on things. I was on Capital School Board for about 4 years; absolutely loved it.
Page 9
Página 10
Item #4.
Economic Development Meeting of October 11, 2022 PAGE 3
Being there and seeing things firsthand and you coming in and handling things. Once again, well
pleased with your efforts. Thank you
Mayor Robin R. Christiansen stated I want to thank Dr. Cade personally for being a part of our
workforce development committee, she met in my office with some other folks, and we are gone
to have some great things happen. Thank you again Dr. Cade, and the school board members for
being here.
KENT COUNTY TOURISM UPDATE – PETE BRADLEY, PRESIDENT
Pete Bradley stated thank you for having me. I have a PowerPoint presentation, but feel free to
ask me any questions. We have a small staff; I am the President. We have a Marketing &
Communications Manager, Cathrine Jenkins; Rachel Rohm is our Business Service Manager;
and Debbie Eashum part-time Group Sales Manager. I am very blessed for our great staff.
Pete Bradley reviewed the presentation “Kent County Tourism Presentation” Attachment #2.
Councilman Taylor asks, how do you depict Dover when you start doing your county wide
advertisement? I’ve been seeking for a couple years now a sustained advertising program that
was showing Dover as safe, clean, welcoming, and exclusive. It must be something that it is
sustainable. It cannot be a one-time deal for that will not stick. If you just give a few advertising
spots on the television. It must be sustainable. If you can start advertising that to Bally’s, and to
all that may come on board, that may give us more traction of what we currently do not have. So,
you if you gone to depict us as anything it will be safe, clean, welcoming, and exclusive. We
will take care of the rest as time comes. Pete Bradley responded anytime in advertising
promotion you must have a constant and relentless message when it starts traction. That is why I
am really excited about the master plan. Nothing happens overnight. Councilman Taylor agreed
the master plan is a great thing to talk about. However, people are not going to come to an area
that isn’t safe. We need to tell them that Dover is not a shooting gallery. Dover is not one of
these places, but a beautiful city, and we just don’t get the good out as much as the bad goes out.
So, we need to control the narrative. I think we can control it through this means right here.
Councilman Neil states news is bad news, and good news is a feature. I think the perception is
because you’re seeing it here in our newspaper, you’re hearing the criticism that is not getting
out to the public beyond these walls. In truth in 2015 the metamorphosis that took place from the
tourism when I was first appointed to the board. Which basically the volunteers did not have the
professionalisms that has been brought into the organization. As soon as we brought in the
professionals from the outside suddenly, we had on one of the major sites for hotels “come to
Dover for a weekend” it was special because of everything that is here. It was a big deal at the
time in 2015. Since that time, we have moved on to a different Executive Director. I felt like he
brought in a period where he is a native. Having someone who knew Dover basically added
another dimension to that. So, sometimes we see the perception because were looking in the
mirror, and we say Oh my God I got that blemish. The fact is that blemish is not going beyond
that mirror. So, in term of getting the word out for these activities. Which is why Pete, the Mayor
and I and Councilman Anderson feels the same way with the DDB coming up. With the river
walk coming up, with all these things coming up. When you have the restaurants that are
Page 10
Página 11
Item #4.
Economic Development Meeting of October 11, 2022 PAGE 4
downtown as well as the developments downtown along with the new lighting system downtown
coming in. So sometimes it is hard to ignore what you see in the mirror. What they see is
NASCAR; what they see is FireFly. And if you’re not having problems with FireFly getting the
word out to the music world, or NASCAR having a problem with crime here in the sports world,
and now with the Gifts of Light; I think that’s marvelous. I think that you have to understand by
looking down more globally on it, how does this affect us. We want more. Because you
understand what that local problem has been. People out there really don’t understand that they
don’t even see it. So, understanding that as we work to correct the problems here locally is
extremely important.
Councilman Anderson had a couple questions. How will certain things affect marketing? Like if
Dover gets a river walk, when we open our state-of-the-art skate park, and dog park. I am not
saying people will come, some will come for a skate park, but how would it affect for people to
come for other events to have those particular amenities. Will that have a positive affect
extending their stay? How will that help or not help? Pete Bradley responded it will help. Some
of the things you mention are for local residents. But like you mention when you have a River
Walk and some of things you mention will benefit the tourist and get that cross pollination. Very
important anything new or unique can be marketed. I always talk about the AMC because that is
unique. How are you different from the guy down the block? Or the other region? AMC is just a
concrete example. Other regions do not have a phenomenal air museum. But again, they play an
important role. I am really excited. I am confident we will have those additional wins. Nothing
happens overnight, yet it does build that momentum, and other developers come in see what’s
going on.
Councilman Anderson questioned if you could have one relative unexpensive easy to achieve
things that we are not doing that would help tourism, what would that be? What would you
recommend? Pete Bradley’s response was to put yourself in the eyes of the tourist of someone
coming into the city for the first time. One of thing is that welcoming, and that first impression is
huge. You have different avenues to come into the city, but that is very important. Again, they
have a great team. If you are coming into the city for the first time it can be confusing with
parking. Where do I park? Especially if there is an event going on. That will be addressed.
People want something simple and easy. I know it has been asked of a parking garage. I can tell
you it’s not similar, but an analogy is my daughter went to Notre Dame and at first, I did not
want to go downtown but my daughter said there is a parking garage. They built this garage and
around the garage are these restaurants and shops. So easy to park and would not have to
navigate to find a parking spot on the street. I saw firsthand that entire section of economic
development was crazy.
Councilman Anderson final question is how do you see the new role of Kent County Tourism at
Dover Days because we do miss you all? Pete Bradley responded when I first started, the first
week we ran Dover Days for the last time. And then the next year we were part of the committee
and I told John Doerfler, who was the marketing manager, that I don’t want the impression we
are abandoning it. We play an extremely important role, and we have to be very active on the
committee and be participates. Unfortunately, it has been cancelled. The committees are starting
again. Rachel will be our key player. She lives downtown, right off The Green. She is from the
park system, and she loves Dover. Tourism is in her DNA. We play an extremely important role
Page 11
Página 12
Item #4.
Economic Development Meeting of October 11, 2022 PAGE 5
with that. It’s a huge event. I was blown away and I only was here for 5 days when I started at
Kent County Tourism. The organization did a great job with it. It is a huge event, and we have to
play an important role.
HEALTH OF MINORITY BUSINESS IN DOVER
Councilman Anderson stated we have a couple of subject matter experts on the committee here.
This item was actually requested to me by another committee member. Councilman Taylor and I
have made some interesting trips. Councilman Anderson asked Councilman Taylor, would you
like to start with some things that have happened over the last couple months? Or protentional
out reaches? Councilman Taylor stated you start, and I will piggyback right from where you are
coming from. Councilman Anderson stated there has been of course with all the businesses in the
county there has been impacts recovering from Covid. There are concerns that have been raised
in the entire businesses community including the minority business community. And some
people have wondered if there is an east / west divide. There have been some recommendations
that have come out of the DDP public safety committee for enhancing more west of Governors
Avenue when it comes to amenities. Making sure that there are simple things such as adequate
trash cans. Sidewalks that are walkable instead of being serious tripping hazards and things of
that nature. There have been safety concerns which are, while they are improving thankfully and
thank God for that. We are definitely grateful for our police force and definitely has been
approvement but now we are moving more from the violent crime type issues to the quality of
life. We can actually breathe enough to get to the quality-of-life issues, and in the townhall we
referred a number of those concerns now. For people that have raised quality of life concerns
that are affecting their businesses. Would you like to take it from there Councilman Taylor?
Councilman Taylor stated just listening to the business owners talk about the divide. A night and
day difference. I don’t know everything of how to fix it, but I just know we can do a little better.
Trash cans the simplicity of things like trash cans. When we cross from east and west side of
Governors; the east side was clean, the west side was immediately trashed with needles, drug
paraphernalia and all different kinds of things. So, when you have business owners who are
relying on foot traffic. Between the tripping hazard, the blight and the nastiness, how can we
really say we are trying to do the best thing when we allow that to happen again and again? I am
not challenging you Mr. Mayor. Just simply saying now that we know better, we can do better.
We need to focus and be very conscious of these things and start fixing them. I know Mosaic is
on its way, but Mosaic is not here and there is a lot of life to be lived between now and then. We
just have to do a whole lot better. Our business community is very concerned. Donnell came to
the DDP safety meeting, and he grew up right here right downtown. He knows a lot of these
people, but he is trying to avoid having to go hands on to move people who are addicted, who are
under the influence and passing out. He is trying to remove these people who are urinating and
defecating in the doorways but that should not be his responsibility as a business owner. He
should be able to stand in front of his business and welcome people in but right now that is just
not happening on a consistent basis. Where do we go from here? I think it is going to take a little
more dialogue, but it is time for us to start moving. It is not a time just to advertise of what we
can do. It is time to do what we do best. For me it is law enforcement. I try to stay in my lane
with the Police Department and make sure that everyone is making good decisions. I try to flood
Page 12
Página 13
Item #4.
Economic Development Meeting of October 11, 2022 PAGE 6
them and you with great ideas to make sure that we can move forward. But again, we have to do
something. We got to act, and we got to act now.
Mayor Christiansen stated he would have to concur on the fact that there is a certain organization
that we will remain nameless at this point in time that has for quite a while has ignored the
minority businesses that seem to flourish on the west side of Governors Avenue. I would like to
remind everybody that one of things I did after I became Mayor was, and I still do, to walk and I
touch base with a lot of the businesspeople there and the people that live in those residents. One
of the things I noticed was Christmas stopped at Bayard Pharmacy. So, I took it upon myself and
went out and bought $3,500 dollars’ worth of Christmas decorations that match the ones that was
on the main part of Loockerman Street. I had them put up and bought a $300 Christmas tree and
planted where I thought city property was. Turned out to be Bob Duncan’s property. He wasn’t
really happy about it but we got a nice tree out of it. The merchants on that end of the street
appreciated that Christmas went from State Street to the railroad. I concur with you that we need
to do to a better job. We have an organization we put in place that is funded very well and have
received a lot more funds. That maybe they should pay more attention to the people that are
trying to develop businesses and properties west of Loockerman St. I am not pointing fingers at
anyone. However, it is kind of obvious to me that we have dropped the ball. We have people that
go down there every morning. The young man that picks up trash all along Loockerman and all
the way to Simaron. So, we do make an effort. It is not an easy job Councilman Taylor as you
have already acknowledged. The one thing with the new ordinances we may be able to do
something more rather than what were able to do now and moving people along that are
undesirable and causing certain properties to be diminished. But let us remember that when we
squeeze the toothpaste there, it will go somewhere. So, Mr. Anderson do you have anything else
on the subject or Councilman Taylor?
Councilman Anderson stated he would like to thank Mr. Hugg for his cooperation and when it
comes to making sure that we are more inclusive with our contracting. Councilman Taylor and I
went to a conference on our own dime just in case someone wanted to know that and it gave us
some excellent information which we are sharing with staff. We hope to have some more
positive things come out of that within the next few months when it comes to increasing of
supply and diversity. Bringing in more businesses and jobs in the city and building the
businesses that we have. We need to make sure that when it comes to supply; number one the
taxpayers get their best bang for the buck in the free market. That’s the most important thing.
Not a social agenda. Part of that bang for the buck is keeping some of their money local. Making
sure that local businesses, including minority businesses, have the opportunity to get city
business will have a very positive economic impact. When you look at dollars that remain in the
community you look at that a contract is worth about $8 dollars for every dollar you keep in the
community. It is actually worth $8 in economic activity. That is an important factor. Local
businesses in general and try to make sure minority own businesses and women own businesses
are included in a better outreach is vital.
Councilman Neil questioned if the gentleman or the businesspeople that you have contacted or
work with, are they involved in the activities of the DDP? Because I think this is where the
pressure comes from, that we make sure that when we sit in on the executive board meetings that
we understand and can bring forth some of the things you are talking about. Because I know
Page 13
Página 14
Item #4.
Economic Development Meeting of October 11, 2022 PAGE 7
there is a good relationship between Public Works and DDP. If there is a problem, then I think
our people are out there, if they are not already, to assure to make the cleanup gets done and
faster. I would like to make sure they have a voice within that organization.
Kim Adams, a business owner on both side of Governors Avenue, stated she is on DDP as you
know and a lot of other boards that are here as well. Yes, I own properties on Bradford and
Loockerman. One of my issues is the trip hazards. I witnessed a mother and 2 children fall into
the street one weekend when I was there. I witnessed two elderly people and a special needs
grandson fall into the street in the same area. So, I made a call, and the second time something
was done that day in front of the building. But a lot of the problems comes from the same people
doing the same things day in and day out. There is no change. There is this one guy, I do not
know his name, but he has backpack, some black pants hanging off, a burgundy jacket and he is
high on the street in front of my store. People are not going to come if they see that type of stuff.
He is defecating in my doorways. In the alley they are sleeping in between the buildings. I have
cameras up and at 2:00 or 3:00 in the morning they are doing drug deals behind the building.
These things continue to happen. It is not a secret. I just don’t understand why there isn’t a
change. I am investing a lot downtown. It just has to change. There are four new houses on New
Street getting ready to come up. Nobody wants to spend that type of money to continue to have
these same problems. So, I do not know how it gets solved or what happens. It is the same
people.
Mayor Christiansen stated that I will credit council with making a continuous effort to enforce
the laws that we have on the books. To make sure they are constitutionally vetted. We are
believers in the constitution. Just 2 blocks from here we ratified that very living document that
we all live and try to run our country by. However, it will be vetted so that it is a constitutional
law and will give the police officers a little bit more of power to their punch to take folks off the
street. A lot of it is not necessary law enforcement, it is mental health issues and we do have a
mental health person with our patrol people on the street. So, between the good efforts and good
intent of everyone gathered in this room, and the people that aren’t in this room will try to do
better and make downtown and our entire city a better place to live, work, and play.
Councilman Anderson requested Bobby Wilson, a minority business owner, to speak. Where to
we stand on minority participation on contracts? I know we have talked about revisiting this
issue. Mayor Christiansen responded that the City Manager, after being instructed by City
Council, was to review our bid awarding process, advertisement process and to piggyback on the
State’s list of contractors that are available to do the specific work that we are interested in
having done. So, we have made every effort via our Council President and members of Council
and unanimously instructed the city staff to do so.
Councilman Taylor added that one of the other things we are doing. Right after we awarded the
contract to A-Del, I contacted them, and I asked them exactly; how does this work when it comes
to minority participation for example of a building being torn down? And A-Del said that they
were totally inclusive, they did everything. I then said to them that I don’t understand how that is
going to help the minority businesses if you do everything and you do no subcontracting.
Because typically the minority businesses are unable to do the whole scope of work, so they have
to be subcontracted in. So now that is one of the target areas that we are doing. We are really
Page 14
Página 15
Item #4.
Economic Development Meeting of October 11, 2022 PAGE 8
starting to look at that now. How do we break that job down so that we can make sure that the
minority businesses that are included on the list already, or maybe even coming in, still get some
of the opportunities for that business? It was several minority businesspersons from Maryland
that were telling me how to do this and again, I’m trying to take their good works and bring them
here. It’s going to take a little time, but we are heading in the right direction. Mr. Wilson
commented that he thinks it is taking too much time. This is something that is long overdue,
and we are not concentrating on it wholeheartedly to make this happen. A-Del doesn’t deserve a
contract if they are bringing everyone from New Castle. They should be required to break it
down in some shape, form or fashion and the citizens and businesses of Dover should have an
opportunity on the project. There are opportunities to learn about this. Why don’t we have a
class about this with all of your procurement officers? So, they can get an educated
understanding of how this works. That way everybody can be inclusive. If we need to have a
study, we can bring professionals in to sit down from Maryland to help us in this situation. Mrs.
Adams commented about the Family Court project. For that project, was there a small business
plan to use small businesses? I agree with his question; I’m a small business here in Dover. I can
do a lot of that work as well, but I wasn’t given the opportunity to even bid on it. I deal with A-
Del and a lot of other businesses, larger businesses, that are around here. With DelDOT, they
don’t participate with us either. I do more contracts federally than I do right here locally. My
money stays here because I hire people here, my jobs are here, I spend the money here, and I
employ people here. But a lot of those other companies, there’s such a thing called a small
business plan. How are you using the small businesses here? Where’s your percentage of
minority, women and veteran service disabled? Where is that plan? There is something that
someone can do. I don’t know how much that project is. I know it is over 100 million. Mayor
Christiansen responded that the city had nothing to do with awarding of any of the contracts.
That is specifically a State of Delaware project and I think that you might want to speak to the
local Representative and the local State Senator and also the Governor’s Office as well because
that project came down from higher up. The basic involvement we had is where we wanted it
put so that it would be the southern anchor for our downtown revitalization. Mr. Wilson
commented in reference to the courthouse we are speaking to the Legislatures. We need a
supply diversity goal within our legislation, and I urge everyone here to get with your State
Legislature representative and ask him to formulate a bid bill for supply diversity with goal
setting. Mayor Christiansen stated that it is Council’s policy to seek out qualified minority
contractors to do work for the City of Dover.
MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
NEXT MEETING DATE
November 15, 2022 at 4:00 PM
ADJOURNMANT
Mayor Robin R. Christiansen called the meeting adjourned at 5:30PM.
Exhibits
Exhibit #1 – Capital School District Presentation
Exhibit #2 – Kent County Tourism Presentation
Page 15
Página 16
Attachment #1
Item #4.
Dr. Vilicia Cade
CEO & Superintendent
Capital School District
Taking a Two-pronged Approach
to Supporting Economic Development…
Page 16
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 17
Attachment #1
Item #4.
“A Dynamic Economy Begins
with a Good Education.”
Dr. Bob Taff
Center for Educational Excellence,
University of Dayton
Page 17
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 18
Attachment #1
Item #4.
The Role of K-12 in Economic Development
• Unique responsibility of preparing the future workforce
“Educational Excellence today for a Changing Tomorrow”
• Businesses want to place their companies in community with
thriving schools
• The forgotten “Captive Audience”
Page 18
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 19
Attachment #1
Item #4.
Will Our Children Be Prepared
As you watch the video I ask that you envision a
child that you care about and ask yourself what
aspirations and dreams you have for this child?
Page 19
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 20
Attachment #1
Item #4.
Show the Video of The Future of Work:
Will Our Children Be Prepared?
https://youtu.be/59d3UZTUFQ0
Page 20
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 21
Attachment #1
Item #4.
Dover Middle School Campus
School of Excellence School of Innovation
Page 21
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 22
K-12 Schools have the Unavoidable Attachment #1
Item #4.
Responsibility….
Schools must change and create new paradigms to align to the
changing needs of our evolving technological world…..
Schools must be responsive the wholistic needs to advance the
quality of life to support a health economic growth
Page 22
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 23
Attachment #1
Item #4.
Launching an Era of Excellence through Innovation
Students:
• Focus on work-based learning and career exploration earlier
• Support pivotal partnerships with central Delaware business to create
pipelines and pathways to living wage earning opportunities
• Service learning and connecting students to our legislators deepen sense
of community, belongingness and Senator Pride
• STEAM integration and intentionality
Parents:
• Parent leadership programs that provide opportunities to upskill and
connect to employment opportunities to raise the quality of life
Page 23
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 24
Attachment #1
Economic Development is everyone’s responsibility Item #4.
K-12 is at the foundation of this effort…….
“Technological innovation is indeed important to economic
growth and the enhancement of human possibilities.”
Dr. Leon Richard Kass, University of Chicago
Page 24
Spurring the Audacity of Hope to Achieve Excellence through Innovation
Página 25
Attachment #2
Item #4.
TOURISM IN
KENT COUNTY
PETE BRADLEY
PRESIDENT
KENT COUNTY TOURISM CORPORATION
Page 25
Página 26
Attachment #2
YOUR Kent County Tourism Team: Item #4.
Pete Bradley
President
pbradley@visitdelawarevillages.com
Catherine Jenkins
Marketing & Communications Manager
cjenkins@visitdelawarevillages.com
Rachel Rohm
Visitor Services Manager
rrohm@visitdelawarevillages.com
Debra Eashum
Part-time Group Sales Manager
deashum@visitdelawarevillages.com
Page 26
Página 27
Attachment #2
WHO IS KENT COUNTY TOURISM CORPORATION? Item #4.
Mission Statement
Kent County Tourism Corporation (dba Delaware’s Quaint Villages)
is the official destination marketing organization for the county and its jurisdictions,
whose mission is to generate incremental economic impact for the community through
the attraction of visitors, especially overnight visitors.
It is a self-governing private not-for-profit 501(C)6 corporation with a Board of Directors established in 1990
Page 27
Página 28
Attachment #2
IMPORTANCE OF TOURISM Item #4.
“It All Starts with a Visit”
Tourism is
Everybody’s Business
Visit, Live, Work –
All are interconnected
Page 28
Página 29
Attachment #2
Item #4.
VALUE OF TOURISM IN DELAWARE
• In 2019, there were 10.4 million visitors to the State of Delaware.
• The Delaware tourism industry is the 4th largest private employer in the
state, employing 45,500 people.
• The tourism industry generated $568 million in state and local government
taxes/fees in Fiscal Year 2019.
• Without tourism, each Delaware household would pay an additional $1,564
in taxes.
• The average visitor spent $315 per trip in 2019
Sources: D.K.Shifflet
& Rockport Analytics
2019
Page 29
Página 30
Attachment #2
HOW ARE WE FUNDED? PUBLIC ACCOMODATION TAX (PAT) Item #4.
Current Public Accommodation Tax Allocation
HOW IT’S ALLOCATED:
General Fund – 5%
Beach Replenishment – 1%
Delaware Tourism Office – 1%
Local County CVBs – 1%
TOTAL COLLECTED BY STATE – 8%
12.5%
allocated by the State to the Local County CVB’s from the PAT Tax
goes to Kent County Tourism Corporation to promote Kent County to tourists.
$413,000 in FY22
Note: FY 21 PAT Revenue was $324,000 Page 30
Pre-Covid FY 19 PAT Revenue was $461,000
Página 31
Attachment #2
PUBLIC ACCOMODATION TAX (PAT) COVID IMPACT Item #4.
Month 2019-2020 2020-2021 Inc (Dec) % Inc. (Dec)
April $ 33,496 $ 19,062 $ (14,434) -43.09%
May $ 35,661 $ 11,026 $ (24,635) -69.08%
June $ 47,907 $ 12,043 $ (35,864) -74.86%
July $ 60,615 $ 22,673 $ (37,942) -62.60%
August $ 52,712 $ 33,855 $ (18,857) -35.77%
September $ 42,992 $ 38,954 $ (4,038) -9.39%
October $ 36,793 $ 25,755 $ (11,038) -30.00%
November $ 44,427 $ 21,193 $ (23,234) -52.30%
December $ 34,110 $ 20,041 $ (14,069) -41.25%
January $ 30,352 $ 26,247 $ (4,105) -13.52%
February $ 20,939 $ 16,305 $ (4,634) -22.13%
March $ 24,167 $ 21,370 $ (2,797) -11.57%
Total $ 464,171 $ 268,524 $ (195,647) -42.15%
Page 31
Página 32
Attachment #2
KENT COUNTY TOURISM- PARTNER SUPPORT Item #4.
• Kent County Levy Court ARPA Grant Programs
• Kent County Tourism and the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce played a key role in developing the grant
program specs/logistics to gain approval from Kent County Levy Court
• Hospitality Grant Program
• Eligible organizations- Hoteliers and Banquet Meeting Facilities
• 23 organizations awarded a total of $995,000 in grants
• Small Business Grant
• For profit small businesses with 100 or less full-time equivalent employees
• 140 small businesses awarded approximately 2.2 million in grants
• Fiscal 23- Kent County Tourism expanded sponsorship plan
• Dover Days Event
• Dover Air Show
• Delaware State Fair
• New proposed County Major events Page 32
Página 33
Attachment #2
WHAT WE DO
Item #4.
We lead the Kent County Tourism Industry to
work together to generate visitor spending by
developing and implementing comprehensive
destination marketing programs.
► Marketing/Communications inspires visitation
to benefit the local tourism economy
► Group Sales attracts the memorable
experiences that motivate group travelers and
provides fuel for our marketing machine
► Visitors Services ensures Visitors get the most
out of their stay, spend more, enjoy themselves,
tell others & come back soon (CTA)
► Industry Relations lifts the industry and acts as
the conduit between Kent County Tourism and our
tourism partners
Page 33
Página 34
Attachment #2
WHAT TOURISTS LIKE ABOUT KENT COUNTY Item #4.
History and Heritage
Outdoor Recreation
Breweries, Wineries, and Distilleries
Page 34
Página 35
Attachment #2
OUR WEBSITE Item #4.
240,000+
Visitors Per Year
❑ Responsive Design
❑ Vivid Photos & Video
❑ All Tourism related businesses have listings
❑ Community Event Calendar
❑ Itinerary and Tour Suggestions
w w w .Vis it D e law are Vil lag e s.co m
Page 35
Página 36
Attachment #2
Item #4.
Page 36
Página 37
KENT COUNTY TOURISM
“THE VILLAGER” Attachment #2
Item #4.
Sponsored by
Chesapeake Utilities
Ford Transit 250
Van runs on
Natural Gas & Gasoline!
• Kent County Tourism in partnership with Chesapeake Utilities
created the Mobile Visitor center “The Villager”.
• The center is a 250 Ford-Transit that has been converted and is
equipped to run on Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) with gasoline as
back up.
• The Villager attends festivals, fairs, and events that appeal to
visitors to help pro-actively engage with them along with locals on
what to do in Kent County.
Page 37
Página 38
Attachment #2
Item #4.
Page 38
Página 39
Attachment #2
FISCAL 23 MARKETING PLANS/CHALLENGES Item #4.
Marketing Plans Concerns
• Increased Advertising Spend
• Staffing Challenges- Hospitality Partners
• SEO, PPC, Social Media Advertising Focus
• Group Market Slow to Recover
• Instagram and Youtube advertising
• Connect TV advertising
• Explore Tiktok advertising
• Continue conversion focus- visitor guide, email sign-ups
• Fall Photoshoot
• On-going website enhancements
• Potential new website
• Expanded visitor guide distribution sites
• Downtown Dover Focus- Master Plan
Page 39
Página 40
Item #5.
Economic Development Committee
Meeting Minutes
November 15, 2022 – 4:00pm
The Economic Development Committee Meeting was held in person and by video conference on
November 15, 2022, at 4:00 p.m. with Councilman Ralph Taylor presiding.
Committee Members present in person or via video were City Planner Mary Ellen Gray and
Designee of Downtown Dover Partnership Diane Laird. Committee Members that arrived late
were Mayor Robin R. Christiansen, Councilman David Anderson, Kim Adams, Clayton
Hammond, and City Manager Dave Hugg. Clayton E. Hammond II was not present. Guests
present were Councilwoman Trisha Arndt, Susan Love and Jessica Quinn with DNREC and Dr.
Dina Vendetti with the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce.
WELCOME
The meeting will not be called to order at this time due to lack of quorum. There are no action
items that require a vote; proceed to presentations.
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL
(DNREC) – DELAWARE CLIMATE ACTIVE PLAN – SUSAN LOVE,
ADMINISTRATOR
Susan Love representing DNREC stated, thank you very much for the opportunity to come speak
to you tonight. Hello, I am Susan Love, Administrator of the Climate and Substantiality Program
in the Division of Climate Coastal and Energy in the Department of Natural Resources and
Environmental Control. Thank you very much for inviting me here tonight. I appreciate the
opportunity to come talk to you about climate change in Delaware and opportunities for the City
of Dover to lead in climate change activities. I brought with me tonight, Jessica Quinn, who is
my principal planner on the climate section, she is also available for follow ups. If there is
additional information that any of you would like, Jessica would help me get that information to
you or help remind me that you asked for that information so I can get it to you. You have
invited me for a reason, and I hope and think that reason is because you see the opportunity to
lead by example in the City of Dover and to be a champion for climate change and substantiality
initiatives. Also, to reap some economic and employment opportunities from the transition that
we are hoping to make here in the State of Delaware to prepare for the future climate and reduce
our emissions. I have worked in Dover for a very long time. I have played in Dover, you guys are
an incredible town with a vibrant work force, and incredible tree canopy. Which in DNREC we
really appreciate and like. Employment opportunities and some of the best festivals in the state.
There is always something going on down here in Dover. So, we can build on that, and you can
add substantiality to that list.
Page 40
Página 41
Item #5.
Economic Development Meeting of November 15, 2022 PAGE 2
Susan Love reviewed the presentation entitled “Delaware Climate Active Plan Presentation”
Attachment #1.
Councilman Taylor requested for Ms. Love to speak more of preparedness for climate change.
Councilman Taylor stated if were dealing with temperatures extending 100 degrees and were
having more and more of these days. What are you referring to when you say preparedness?
Ms. Love stated there are a lot of different approaches for preparedness for heat impact. They go
from some of the emergency response preparedness making sure you have cooling centers for
people without air conditioning or you’re doing fan give aways or you have programs where you
can check up on elderly neighbors. You guys probably have a pretty good handle on where the
housing quality may not be very good, so you might know where people do not have access to
air conditioning. There are other things that you can do to prepare that are not incident related.
Putting in place things that will help reduce the vulnerability of your population to those impacts.
Things like making sure you have a good tree canopy that is shady and identifying areas that
don’t have a tree canopy. It can be 10 degrees cooler under a tree than it is outside in a paved
area. If you every walked across Walmart parking lot in the middle of summer, you know what I
mean. It is hot. Making sure your building codes are up to date. Because when you build new
buildings to a higher standard those buildings retain heat and cool better than they would
otherwise. So, those are some primary examples of the way we can prepare for that heat.
Knowing it’s coming and thinking about the activities we are doing today to prepare for those
changing conditions is really important. So, one of the things I do in my job is making sure that
people are considering these changing conditions in everything they do. Whether you are a
farmer, an emergency manager, water resource engineer, architect, or a bridge designer; that you
are thinking about what life will be like next week, in a decade, or in two decades because when
we build something and we create things we create them to last for a very long time. When
DELDOT builds a new bridge, they have an eighty-year life span.
Councilman Taylor asked a question regarding prevention portion. Have you guys examined
working with the municipalities on the impervious service coverages. There are a lot of places
where there is just concrete or asphalt; there is nothing there and nothing has been there for a
while. Nothing is planned. Do you guys have some kind of program that would come in and
assist us or at least with the cost of removing some of that concrete? I believe that would also be
a huge help when it comes to water being absorbed into the earth versus running into a drainage
ditch that is already strained from the very beginning. Do you have a program like that already in
place? Susan Love responded with yes and no. Often times there are funding mechanisms, and
because of recent federal activities through the bi-partisan info structure bill and the inflation
reduction act, there are billions and billions of federal dollars seeking a home to do things just
like that. DNREC worked with the town of Bowers Beach recently. If you have been to Bowers
Beach, they have a ridiculous large parking area that used to be full on weekends when there was
more recreational fishing happening at Bowers Beach. That sort of dried up. Now, they just have
a huge impervious parking lot not being utilized by anyone, and flooding concerns. They
worked with DNREC and got money through DNREC to take out some of that pavement and
turned that into a park. So, we can do things like that, but what we need municipalities to do is
identify where they want to work. And we can help with resiliency planning and sustainability
planning to help you identify where those opportunities are. Once you identify where those
Page 41
Página 42
Item #5.
Economic Development Meeting of November 15, 2022 PAGE 3
opportunities are and where you want to work, we can also help identify funding mechanisms for
those things, so that opportunities out there for sure. As your having ideas there is definitely
people and programs, we can hook you up with for that. I can certainly think of some large
parking lots in Dover that are not utilized for cars very much.
Councilman Ralph Taylor asked about the Energize Delaware Empowerment Program Grants.
We talk about solar. Does that tie right into with the solar program you currently have, or do we
have to apply as a city to be able to be a part of this fund? Susan Love responded that one of the
benefits of going through the Energize Delaware Empowerment Grant Program is that they will
help identify all the pots of money for you that are available to do these things. So, if you wanted
to add solar to your roof here that would be through the Energize Delaware Program if they have
money for that. If you wanted to help set up a community solar program, I don’t think we have
one in the state yet. That is a brand-new emerging opportunity. If you wanted to do
improvements on this building here, the entry point is Energized Delaware and they will send out
energy auditors to access the building for opportunities and once they have that assessment done,
they will help fund those opportunities. They might say you have a bunch of leaky windows, and
we will help you pay to seal those windows up. Or you don’t have adequate insulation in the
attic area, and we will help insulate that and that will save the municipality money. I can help
hook you up with that program.
Councilman Ralph Taylor asked City Manager David Hugg, with a program like this would we
be able to connect with it directly through the city either through services or a special
organization? Would a program like this be allowed to fit into utilities? Would it be allowed to
be a part of our electric bill? Dave Hugg responded; I think so. We are already pursuing the
electric vehicle side of this pot of money. We have two small solar installations that are on city
property one at the electric plant. My understanding is we are eligible for and can take
advantage of all these program opportunities. Councilman Ralph Tayler asked if we need to go to
Leg & Fin first or have we already started the process? Dave Hugg responded a little bit of both.
On the electric vehicle side, we already have a committee working on in it. In fact, we will be
meeting with City Council by the end of the year with a proposal. Part of our energy plan we are
updating, the Integrated Resource Plan, which is the national plan for you will for energy service
for the city. Which is the nation’s plan for energy service for the city. Solar is a major component
of that mix of utility resource. I expect we will see some opportunity to actually invest in solar
other than being just a purchaser. Councilman Ralph Taylor stated that is what I am looking at.
Where there is a 25 or 27 percent increase in cost of the electricity utility, we can have a city-
wide program put in place. Perhaps we can tie homeowners, that are already stressed, into the
program and they move into it organically after we are able to get it going. I think it would be a
fantastic idea and it will be the vehicle portion of it is needed, but if I am looking at the biggest
need right now it is some kind of decrease in our cost of energy. I believe this would be a great
segue into it if we were able to do that. City Manager, David Hugg, responded that right now the
cost of solar is not that much more of an advantage to us then what we are able to buy in the
open market. Susan Love stated that she would like to mention there are a lot of programs
specifically for residents or homeowners that they can access directly. And Mary Ellen, Planning
Director, has been talking to the DNREC weatherization assistance team. The weatherization
program provides free weatherization to low-income residents who qualify. All homeowners or
renters can also, through Energized Delaware, have an energy audit of their own home. And have
Page 42
Página 43
Item #5.
Economic Development Meeting of November 15, 2022 PAGE 4
some measures taken in their own home where they can save money. We can certainly help with
getting information, education, and outreach materials to city residents for those programs.
Councilman Ralph Taylor responded, I am trying to share my vision and I am trying my best to
tell you as best as I can. I am just not looking at something for low or moderate income; I
believe there is a lot of people out here that can use this relief. Whether or not they are deemed
low or moderate income. They work every day, they have bills, the bills that come to their home
have their name on them. So, if we can do our part to assist and that’s what I am after. Even if
Mrs. Love I need for you to come to another committee meeting, if need be, where I give you
plenty of time in front of all our colleagues where you are going to be bombarded with questions,
and we will go from there. Dave Hugg, City Manager, stated we have a number of programs that
we have been looking at for various ways to increase the availability of nontraditional energy to
the city. We have been looking at electric vehicles in part because one of our huge costs in
providing services to the city is the cost of fuel for these vehicles and in at least in one of the
programs there is an opportunity to get the vehicles themselves for free. So, we need to get some
charging stations that would not only serve our fleet but that could be available as an Economic
Development incentive. Wouldn’t it be nice to have a couple chargers out back here where
people that are coming downtown could take advantage? What I was going to call to your
attention is that you all are probably familiar with Del Tech Terry Campus, and they have that
large solar array over their parking lot. There are a number of municipalities that have done the
same thing. There is an opportunity there for us that we never really ever explored but I think
there is funding available to do that kind of project if I remember correctly. Susan Love
responded that I think we can figure that out. We are looking at all our programs. We are looking
for funds that are available from the federal government and trying to figure out where there are
gaps and where we can go after funds as a state. Capacity is always an issue as it always is at a
local level. If there is something you want to do; let’s talk about it. I have a lot of information but
a lot of the programs I have mentioned here are not run by my shop. Tony DePrima who I
understand used to have a role in Dover government. So, I am sure he has a special place in his
heart for helping Dover. Rob Underwood who runs our energy office; and several others I think
would be useful to have us all together. I know just enough about some of those programs to be
dangerous, and I’ll try not to get out any misinformation about them.
Councilman Ralph Taylor stated that cost and the need are there, but availability is not. For
example, our lighting project that we have, the lights are not available. It is a great program, and
it is a needed program. The cost is right, but the availability of product. So, if guys are going to
make us a promise; please, please, please have the supplies and everything available to us so we
can hit the ground running. Susan Love responded that there are definitely supply chains
shortages happening all over, from charging stations to transformers to electric vehicles to
electric school buses. So, there are some wait times. I haven’t heard about lighting; I did not
know there were any supply chain issues on lights, but that very much could be. Getting in line is
important so you can get them ordered and to deploy them when they finally come in, and that is
what we are doing for a lot of things. Councilman Ralph Taylor stated is there anything else you
would like to leave us with? Susan Love responded with, thank you, and I appreciate the
opportunity and I expect we will have some ongoing conversations and I welcome them.
Page 43
Página 44
Item #5.
Economic Development Meeting of November 15, 2022 PAGE 5
CENTRAL DELAWARE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE (CDCC) UPDATE – DINA
VENDETTI, PRESIDENT
Dina Vendetti stated good afternoon everybody. Thank you so much for this opportunity to be
here with you and talk about all things Chamber. I feel like I am preaching to the choir here. You
could tell the story as well as I could tell the story. Because looking around at all the people that
are already involved with the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce. But I always appreciate
the idea to come and talk a little bit. The mayor asked that I come talk about our partnerships and
I am happy to do that. The agenda says give an update and I am happy to do that because there
are always things to give an update about. But before I do any of that I’d like to give you some
high spots in case these are the chamber trivia topics that maybe you don’t know. The Central
Delaware Chamber of Commerce was established in 1919. We look pretty good for over a 100.
We were established as the Greater Dover Chamber of Commerce. The office was right over
here in Treadway Towers. That was long before I was around, or in Dover. Eventually, we were
incorporated in 1959 as a nonprofit. We are a 501(c)(6) not a 501(c)(3) because we lobby. The
vision of the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce is to be the essential resource for the
development of businesses in central Delaware. That is a pretty bold statement, don’t you think?
To be the essential resource. So, for our members we are a member’s organization right now we
have about 780 business members. For our members we want to be top of mind. Whether they
are going through something that’s wonderful or whether they are going through something that
is challenging, we want them to be in touch with us. And when something comes up, we want
them to think of us. Not because we have all the answers, we don’t. We have a lot of the
answers. But for the things we don’t have the answer for, we know the people that do. So, the job
of the chambers is to connect businesses. We connect business in 4 big areas; education, so we
connect businesspeople with ways to learn and opportunities for learning. It might be learning
about a new business strategy. It might be learning about a new trend that is coming along, it
might be a learning a new situation in their area. The premiere educational experience of the
chamber is the Leadership Central Delaware program. Where we connect people with ways to
develop their leadership skills and talents and give them a look behind the curtain to see what
makes Kent County tick. In that program they have the opportunity to meet the people who are
the movers and shakers here in Central Delaware and learn from them how they do leadership,
what their strategies are, and the skills that are needed to do the things that they do. So, that is
education. We connect people with legislators and with legislation. In terms of legislation, we
are honored to be the voice of the business community here in Central Delaware. Our job as that
voice is to monitor what goes on at the general assembly to make sure that the legislation that is
passed is friendly to our business owners. In terms of are we getting ready to pass something that
will cost an inordinate amount of money from the businesses, or is it gone to take an inordinate
amount of time they don’t have or are there things that are happening that will require more
workforce than what they can get their hands on. If that is the case, we get in the middle of it and
we do some education, and some influencing, and a lot of negotiation to try to create something,
that not necessary to take those pieces of legislation and those ideas and throw them out but
instead be of help in making them something that is gone to be useful and helpful to our business
community. Because we know that small business is the backbone of the economy here in
Central Delaware. That is really important stuff. We have two lobbyist that are a part of the
Chamber, and their services are used every day that the general assembly is in session. The third
area is marketing. We connect people with ways to tell their stories, and that is something we
Page 44
Página 45
Item #5.
Economic Development Meeting of November 15, 2022 PAGE 6
love, love, love to do. So, the more we know about our members the more we can talk about our
members. The more we can let people know what they are doing. The more we can put them in
front of people so they can share on what it is they are doing that is helping the community at
large. The last area is probably the most fun and that is connecting people with each other which
we call that networking in the business world. So, we do all kinds of events and activities.
Actually, we do 75 or 76 events and activities every single year. And so that is kind of the skinny
on what the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce is all about. I would be amidst if I didn’t
remind you, we are a credited chamber. In fact, we are the only accredited chamber in the State
of Delaware. And what that means for us is not just a pat on the back and a nice certificate on the
wall, but it means is that our members can be assured that what they are getting is something of
high quality. We are credited by the United States Chambers of Commerce. They come in every
five years and do what we call a “look under the hood”, to make sure we are doing things that
Chambers are supposed to be doing. But more than that, are we doing what we say we do? That
is very important because you can say you do anything. We are doing what we say we are doing.
And according to the United States Chambers of Commerce, indeed we are. More than that we
are a second time five-star credited chamber. What that means is that the United Chamber of
Commerce when they come in and examine what we are doing, they compare us to the very best
chambers all across the country. And there is a rating system, and they score us compared to the
very best chambers across the country. And if we rate high enough then we can become what
they call a five-star accredited chamber. And all that is very cool, but what is cooler than that is
that when somebody else in the country wants to become a five-credit chamber, guess who they
compare them to? That’s pretty cool, right? And so again that is not design just to give us all
these wonderful bragging rights. To tell you how good we are and how the United Chamber of
Commerce thinks we are great, but it provides credibility for us in terms of what we are doing
and also provides a much-needed accountability. We are held accountable to a higher standard.
And what that does for us allows our members to understand that what they are getting from
their membership with the Chamber is something of the highest quality in our country. In terms
of our partnerships, we believe firmly that we can do far more together than any of us can do on
our own. That is something we go back to again, again, and again. So, we don’t pretend to be the
essential resource for the development of businesses in Central Delaware all by ourselves.
Because that is not something we could accomplish. But together we can all be the essential
resource for businesses in Central Delaware. So, we are honored to partner with the City of
Dover on a variety of projects and activities. We are honored to partner with the Downtown
Dover Partnership; I attend their board meetings. And when I can make it happen, I go to the
merchant meetings because they are so much fun. And it is really cool to see the new businesses
starting up in downtown Dover. We are a part of the board for Kent Economic Partnership. We
partner with them in terms of bringing business into the county. Once they get here, what do we
do to get them established and get them known? And that is part of the job that we do. So, we are
involved in all those different entities and more. The Greater Kent Committee, you know all of
that. So, we can work together to make things happen. In terms of updates, I am happy to tell
you something that probably you didn’t realize was going on with the Chamber; as of last week,
after an eight month wait, we are fully staffed. And that is marvelous. In this era of workforce
issues, we felt it too. Now we are back up to full staff and we are excited about that because that
enables us to do the things we need to do. We’ve just gone through a big technology update,
that’s the good news. The bad news is that we just went through a big technology update, and I
think you all what that means. One of our biggest accomplishments in the last year was to be
Page 45
Página 46
Item #5.
Economic Development Meeting of November 15, 2022 PAGE 7
able to be a part of the Kent County Small Business Grant. We worked with the County in
disturbing ARPA funds through a grant program to our small businesses. And we worked with
Kent County Tourism. They took the hospitality side; we took the small business side. On the
small business side of things, we were thrilled to be able to give away 2.413 million dollars to
small business. It was called the American Rescue Plan Act. And when we gave those checks to
the business owners and we saw their reactions that was rescue in every sense of the word. So,
that was a big deal. And the lesson that we learned, and I’ll leave you with this unless there are
questions. The biggest lesson we learned in the last couple of years is that our businesses need
real help in real time. They don’t need something that we are going to think about 6 months to a
year, and then think about how to have a committee. When they need help, real help, in real
time. So, it is gone to be really important to us to be in touch with them all of the time, so we
know what they need, and we continue to do that work of connecting them with the things that
they need. That is really super important to us. As we look forward, we are trying to do whatever
we can to remain relevant in a world that has changed. And that is something many of us are
looking at. We got businesses now that once were brick and mortar and now they have gone to
become e-commerce, and their online businesses. Are we still relevant for them in terms of what
they need and what we can offer them? If were not, what are we doing to make ourselves
relevant? So those are things we are doing as we look ahead. I think that’s all I got for you
today.
Councilman Anderson asked two questions. First, I want to thank you for coming today, and
sharing, it is always good to see you. First question has to do with recovering from the pandemic.
How do you feel the small business community, which was hit the hardest by the regulations,
with the shutdowns, etc. for an unknown reason because they were probably the safest and they
were the most effected? How have recovered now and the members and the others that you have
seen how has their recovery been? Dina Vendetti replied that the small business community was
hit in a big way. I can tell that over the course of the shutdowns just talking about just Chamber
members we had 70 businesses close not to reopen and that was heartbreaking to see that and not
being able to do something more to help them. We had another number of businesses that
because they were the only ones working, they didn’t have time to use their Chamber
membership, so we ended up losing them as well. And that was very difficult because at the time
they needed us the most, we did our best to be there regardless of membership for our business
community but that was a tough spot as well. In terms of the recovery, I think a lot of businesses
are coming back now. We are starting to see businesses that had limited their hours beginning to
expand their hours again. The problems with shutdowns and lack of revenue when that part of it
was over and they were allowed to reopen again the next problem became not having enough
people to work. And that has been just a really big issue with everybody we talk to. We get calls
every single day. We want to reopen up, we want to expand our hours, we want to expand our
services, but we don’t have the people to do it. I do feel like that is just at the very beginning of
starting to ease just a little bit. And I do think from where we sit it looks like that is going to
come back it is just taking a long time for reason that none of us really understand. But I think
businesses are working hard to come back. The thing we saw during over the course of the
pandemic, and I am sure you saw this as well, is that our business community is extremely
resilient. And the people in those leadership positions in our businesses are the most creative, the
most innovative people on the planet. Because they were able to take a horrible situation and turn
into something different. Either provide their product in a different way or provide their service
Page 46
Página 47
Item #5.
Economic Development Meeting of November 15, 2022 PAGE 8
in a different way so that they can remain relevant during that time and remain open to some
extent. We saw people dig deep and come up with things that they never dreamt they could do
before. And it works well for them and for some of those businesses they are continuing to do
those things even now that they are able to be back open now, so I was thinking it was a
showcase of creativity and innovation.
Councilman Anderson stated that in today’s world of communication is a lot more challenging
because there is such a segmentation of the population, and no one seems to be at one place.
Everybody doesn’t watch one of the three tv stations, they don’t listen to the local radio/satellite
radio all the time, or people don’t always read the paper. There is a lot of social media platforms.
What lessons has the Chamber learned that maybe we can learn from when it comes to trying to
communicate to a diverse audience? Dina Vendetti responded; I think the biggest lesson that we
can all learn is that there are some situations that allow us to be redundant. So, you say it once
then you say it again, then you say it again, then say it again until you get tired of saying it and
even then, there is going to be somebody that might miss it, so you say it one more time. Part of
the issue is that we are competing for air space. And I mean that kind of in symbolic way. Like
you mention, people are getting information from so many places and sometimes all at the same
time. Your ears can only hear so many words a minute, and your brain can only process so much
in that period of time. And so, everybody who is trying to communicate is competing in that
market. That is what is happening. So, the message has to be clear, the message has to be
important, has to be seen as relevant, there is that word again, and it has to be repeated. And we
have as a chamber really worked to learn to use as many avenues of communication as we can.
So, we have the newspaper, we have email publications, we are on social media, we are calling
people, it’s all the stuff. We are telling people to tell other people. We’re encouraging people to
like and share so that our social medica stuff goes up higher on the google list. All of those
things so that we can grab attention and I think those are things we have to keep in mind all the
time when we are communicating with the people we are communicating with.
MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Councilman Ralph Taylor stated that the Mayor is not here so I’d like to do something a little
different. Diane, and anyone else, what would you like to see on the next Economic
Development meeting on January 10th? Diane what would you like to see? Diane Laird
responded that I think we will be ready to present the Master Plan in January for Downtown
Dover. Kim Adams stated I don’t have anything on the spot right now. I will get back to you.
Councilman Anderson stated I think that the Master Plan is definitely something I would like to
see in January and maybe a little afterwards just an update on where we are on some of the
Economic Development grants and other avenues. David Hugg stated I really am looking
forward seeing the Master Plan and I really want the opportunity to think about it. But I think
the sooner we can start identifying some of the key implementation steps that we as a city can
do. I know there is some zoning things we can do. I know there are some capital improvement
projects that we can start the program. To the extent if we have the time to both listen to the plan
and understand what it is, and also ask that question of what can we do pretty much right now?
What can we do quickly? I think that would be an important step rather than having another topic
on the agenda. Councilman Taylor stated the Master Plan seems to be one of things we need to
do. I would like to look at it from a little bit different perspective. Safety obviously is something
Page 47
Página 48
Item #5.
Economic Development Meeting of November 15, 2022 PAGE 9
we need to continue to look at. However, I like to see some type of tutorial playing continuously
on our website to help potential business owners to get started. I know there is different avenues
to take but I like for someone to be able to go on our website or go to our Facebook page and
something is looping, something that you can see continuously. There will be different tutorials
such as, how to get your permitting, how to get your plan through, and how to get started. I think
that is vitally important. I know when I was starting my business years ago, fear is a powerful
thing. So, if you are afraid to get started because of the financial reason then you don’t know
how to get started so you just don’t get started. So, if we have something there that is constantly
telling them how to get things going, I think that would be greatly appreciated. And also, if we
can find some experts on hiring. I believe that hiring struggles are real, and everybody is going
through them. And a lot of people are sifting through some of the exact same people. So, I
believe we start identifying our key core principles of what we are after, and we will and will not
accept. And then move forward from there, I like to see that being on one of our future meetings.
NEXT MEETING DATE
January 10, 2023 at 4:00 PM
ADJOURNMANT
Councilman Taylor called the meeting adjourned at 5:05 PM.
Exhibits
Exhibit #1 – Delaware Climate Active Plan (DNREC) Presentation
Page 48
Página 49
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Delaware’s Climate Action Plan and
Sustainability Opportunities for the City of Dover
Page 49
1
Página 50
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Why is the climate changing?
Human activities have increased the amount of greenhouse gases in our atmosphere, warming our
planet and causing climate change.
The leading sources of greenhouse gas emissions in Delaware are:
• Transportation
• Industrial
• Electrical Power
Page 50
2
Página 51
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Climate Change in Delaware
In Delaware, the impacts of climate change are already being felt. Here in our state, climate change
primarily takes the form of:
• Sea level rise,
• Increased temperatures, and
• More frequent intense storms, including heavy precipitation and flooding.
Page 51
3
Página 52
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Climate models show that Delaware will
continue to warm
Days with Maximum Temperature
75
Lower >100oF
60 Scenario
Higher
45 Scenario
30
15
0
1981-2010 2020-2039 2040-2059 2080-2099
(historical) (near (mid-century) (late century)
century)
De.gov/climatechange Page 52
4
Página 53
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Sea Level Rise
Rising sea levels have many effects:
• Inundation of low-lying areas
• Reduction of natural flood benefits of
wetlands and buffers
• Inundation of critical facilities like wastewater
plants
• Saltwater intrusion and rising water tables
At left: Projected sea level rise in Dover
2080-2100. Blue is high tide today; Green
Page 53
is high tide with 3 feet of sea level rise 5
Página 54
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Planning for Delaware’s Future
Delaware’s Climate Action Plan guides state efforts to Minimize greenhouse gas emissions and
Maximize resilience to climate change impacts.
The Climate Action Plan was created to:
• Help Delaware meet its emissions reduction goal (at least 26% from 2005 levels by 2025).
• Integrate emissions reduction and climate change adaptation actions.
• Set a course for state climate action in the decades ahead.
Page 54
6
Página 55
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Strategies For
Minimizing Emissions
• Clean and Renewable Energy
• Energy Efficiency
• Transportation Systems
• High Global Warming Potential
Greenhouse Gases
• Offsetting Carbon Emissions
Page 55
7
Página 56
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Strategies for
Maximizing Resilience
• Updated or New State Regulations
• Management Plans
• Facility and Infrastructure Design
and Management
• Agency Support
• Research and Monitoring
• Support for Communities and
Stakeholders
• Outreach and Education
Page 56
November 4, 2022
8
Página 57
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Progress Highlights
Regulations for High Electric Vehicle
Renewable Energy
Global Warming Charging Infrastructure
Goals updated to 40%
Potential Chemicals Planning and Grants
by 2035, plus
(HFCs) effective Sept,
community solar
2021
Page 57
9
Página 58
Attachment #1
Item #5.
The Important and Special Role of
Municipal and County Governments
• Zoning and Building Codes
• Energy Conservation Code
• Roads, Bikeways and Sidewalks
• Parking standards
• Water, Sewer and Energy Infrastructure
• Vehicle Fleets and Municipal buildings
• Conservation of Natural Resources/Green
Infrastructure Page 58
10
Página 59
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Funding and Financial Opportunities
for Municipal Operations
• Energy Efficiency Improvements
• Energize Delaware Empowerment Grant
• DNREC Energy Efficiency Investment Fund
• Public Electric Vehicle Infrastructure
• DNREC Clean Transportation Incentive Program
• Clean and Electric passenger and heavy-duty vehicles
• DNREC Diesel Emissions Reduction Program
• Energize Delaware EVs for municipalities
• Resilient Community Partnership
• DNREC Water Pollution Control Revolving Fund
• MANY MORE!
Page 59
11
Página 60
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Getting Started
• Identify Key Needs or opportunities
• Review existing strategic or comp plans
• Develop a Sustainability and/or Resiliency Plan to
bring it all together
• Start with small pilot projects
• Ask questions; we are here to help link you to
resources
Page 60
November 4, 2022
12
Página 61
Attachment #1
Item #5.
Learn More
@DelawareDNREC
@DNRECClimate
@DelawareDNREC
de.gov/climateplan @ DNRECClimate
Page 61
13
Página 62
Item #6.
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular City Council Meeting was held on January 9, 2023, at 6:30 p.m. with Councilman
Anderson presiding. Council members present were Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Ms.
Arndt, Mr. Rocha (via Webex), Mr. Taylor, and Mr. Hare. Mr. Sudler was absent.
Staff members present were Police Chief Johnson, Ms. Peddicord, Mr. Hugg, Mrs. Gray, Mr.
Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Mayor Christiansen was also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 6:21 p.m., prior to the commencement of the Official Council
Meeting. Acting Council President Anderson declared the Open Forum in session and reminded
those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.
Faye White, 101 Babb Drive, Unit 2219, Dover, explained that she sent a letter to the City on
August 24, 2021, and spoke at the September 12, 2022, Regular Council meeting regarding
obtaining one of the empty buildings downtown. She stated that she is the CEO of the nonprofit
organization, A Second Chance, and would like a building downtown. She asserted that council
has the authority to dispose of empty buildings/land/lots within the City limits. She asked the
council to consider her request.
INVOCATION
The invocation was given by Elder Ellis Louden.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Councilman Anderson
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty, and unanimously
carried (Sudler absent).
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon
by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items
unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the
Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the consent agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and carried
by a unanimous roll call vote (Sudler absent).
CERTIFICATE OF CONGRATULATIONS – DOVER HIGH SCHOOL FOOTBALL
TEAM
The City Clerk read the following Certificate of Congratulations into the record:
Page 62
Página 63
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 2
Item #6.
CERTIFICATE OF CONGRATULATIONS
presented to
The Dover High School Football Team
for an outstanding 2022 Football season. We commend the following student-athletes for their
outstanding performance:
Players
Tyrone Abrams Taishaun Allen Dominick Eacho Elijah Bowers
Rasheed Branch-Calhoun Connor Briggs Vincent Buttillo Amir Byrom
Dashaun Cole Jaheim Cole William Cooke Nahseem Cosme
Kaseem Cotton Keegan Countryman Tamir Darden Jefferson NohaRidge Eliazard
Frasly Francois Jordan Ghyll Christopher Grady Jalyn Hamilton
Tyrone Harrell Jamar Harris Bryant Hartwell Jason Hoskins
Zah’mere Jackson Troy Johnson Cameron Jones Jakwon Kilby
Tysean Milligan Shameek Morris Lucas Nichols Jaden Parker
Jamal Parker John Parker Marc Patterson Jonathan Payne
Jaylen Peace Ryan Perkins Nevon Pierce Jaylen Powell
Connor Ridgway Daniel Shockley Jamir Simmons Nasir Snipes-Guzman
Michael Stevenson Ja’Khai Tilghman Jeremiah Walker Nicolas Whiteman
Jamil Williams Nehemiah Williams Brandon Yoder
Managers
Mekhi Boyd Justin Carreras Eric Carter
Mubarak Hall Darius Stevens Zayir Veal
The entire team and Coaches Chip Knapp, Jason Hunt, David Norman, Robert Skripko, C.C.
Trott, Carl Batson, Issiah Chavis, Quan Harris, Alex Kemp, Eugene Scott, Hayden Vidrine, and
Holden Vidrine are applauded for their remarkable achievement. We enjoyed cheering you on
and look forward to next season.
ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 12,
2022
The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of December 12, 2022, were unanimously
approved by motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Boggerty, and bore the written approval
of Mayor Christiansen (Sudler absent).
MONTHLY REPORTS - NOVEMBER 2022
By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Boggerty, the following monthly reports were
accepted by consent agenda:
City Assessor’s Report
City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
City Manager’s Report
City Planner’s Report
Controller/Treasurer’s Budget Report
Fire Chief’s Report
Police Chief’s Report
Page 63
Página 64
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 3
Item #6.
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2022-21
A public hearing was duly advertised for this time and place to consider approval of proposed
zoning text amendments to Appendix B - Zoning, Article 3 - District Regulations, Section 20A –
Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone – Business and Technology Center (IPM2)
Mr. Neil moved that the Final Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2022-21 be acknowledged
by title only, seconded by Ms. Arndt, and unanimously carried (Sudler absent). (The First
Reading of the ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of November 28, 2022.)
Ms. Mary Ellen Gray, Director of Planning and Community Development, explained that the key
components of the proposed text amendment include adding a purpose and intent section that
articulates the purpose and intent of the business and technology zone. Ms. Gray further
explained that it includes the addition of the truck terminal use, the clarification and the addition
of accessory use, the addition of indoor and recreation amusement establishment uses, and the
addition of the following conditional uses: a builder’s/contractor’s yard, a vocational education
facility, associated retail uses in conjunction with an accessory to a permitted use, and the
addition of a craft distillery and microbrewery, as well as the addition of a definition of a
vocational education facility.
Ms. Gray further explained that because this is a text amendment proposed in the zoning
ordinance, a public hearing and recommendation by the Planning Commission are required. The
review occurred on December 19, 2022, at the Planning Commission meeting after it was heard
by council on November 28, 2022, at the First Reading. The Planning Commission voted 9 to 0
to recommend adopting the text amendment.
Acting Council President Anderson declared the hearing open.
There being no one present wishing to speak during the public hearing, Acting Council President
Anderson declared the hearing closed.
Mr. Hare moved for the adoption of the ordinance, as recommended by the Planning
Commission. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil, and, by a unanimous roll call vote
(Sudler absent), Council adopted
Ordinance #2022-21, as follows:
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN
COUNCIL MET:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 Section 20A Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone –
Business and Technology Center (IPM2) be amended as follows:
APPENDIX B – ZONING
ARTICLE 3 - DISTRICT REGULATIONS
Section 20A. Industrial park manufacturing zone – Business and Technology Center
(IPM2)
Page 64
Página 65
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 4
Item #6.
Sec. 20A.A Purpose and Intent. The industrial park manufacturing zone – Business and
Technology Center (IPM2) is established for the following:
(a) To provide locations for the development of light to moderate industrial
manufacturing, warehousing, distribution, logistics, research, and technology
establishments as well as offices and professional services which could be compatible
with residential uses.
(b)To provide employment opportunities for nonoffensive industries, businesses, and
technologies in close proximity to centers of population.
(c) To include guidelines and performance standards which will control and confine any
offensive features such as noise, vibration, heat, smoke, glare, dust, objectionable odors,
toxic waste, or unsightly storage.
Sec. 20A.1.
20A.1 Uses permitted. No building or premises shall be used and no building or part of a
building shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or
in part, for any purpose, except the following, and in accordance with performance
standards procedure as set forth in article 5, section 8, and subject to site development
plan approval as set forth in article 10, section 2:
20A.11 Manufacturing, assembling, converting, altering, finishing, cleaning, cooking,
baking, or any other type of manufacturing, industrial, or technological processing of any
goods, materials, products, instruments, appliances, biotechnology, and devices.
20A.12 Research, design, testing, and development laboratories.
20A.13 Offices and corporate support operations for business and professional services,
data management, financial services, insurance, and health care industries.
20A.14 Agricultural or farm uses as defined and permitted in article 3, section 1.11.
20A.15 Production of electricity provided that the power source used shall be gas, oil
solar, or wind.
20A.16 Warehousing, transshipment and distribution, and logistics support and trucking
terminals.
20A.17 Printing, publishing, binding, and packaging.
20A.18 Accessory uses:
a) On-site offices, clinics, food service facilities, recreation facilities, and
child day care services collocated within the permitted use and limited to
exclusive use by employees, and such other accessory uses and structures
clearly incidental to, and customary to, and associated with the permitted
use.
Page 65
Página 66
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 5
Item #6.
20A.19 Indoor recreation and amusement establishments.
20A.2 Conditional uses: The following uses may be permitted as conditional uses if
approved by the planning commission in accordance with the provisions and procedures
set forth in article 10, section 1 and any specified requirements set forth below:
20A.21 Building contractor’s yard provided that:
(a) Outside storage is within a completely enclosed and secure area and
appropriately screened from public view and not in any required setback from
property lines.
20A.22 Vocational education facility
20A.23 Associated retail uses in conjunction with and accessory to a permitted use,
provided that the associated retail use does not occupy more than 30 percent of
the gross floor area of the building or group of buildings on a lot. Parking shall
be provided at a rate of one parking space per 300 square feet of retail space for
the exclusive use of retail customers in addition to the bulk parking
requirements of this zoning district for a particular use.
20A.24 Craft distillery and microbrewery provided that:
(a) All permits and approvals required by the Delaware Alcoholic Beverage
Commission are obtained and remain in full force and effect.
(b) All aspects of the distilling or brewing process are completely confined
within a building, including storage of all materials and finished products.
(c) Such establishment may offer to the public, various activities ancillary to
its distilling and/or brewing process, including by way of example: tours of
the premises, educational classes, demonstrations, tasting rooms, and retail
sales areas limited to the sale of beer, mead, cider, or spirits brewed or
distilled on the premises for consumption off-premises and other retail
items.
(d) On-site consumption or tasting associated with a craft distillery or
microbrewery establishment shall be permitted. Any area associated with
on-site consumption or tasting shall not operate as a stand-alone bar or
tavern, shall be located on the premises of the craft distillery or
microbrewery establishment, and shall be ancillary to the primary use.
"Ancillary" for purposes of this section means subordinate, auxiliary,
smaller, and less intensive than the primary use. On-site consumption or
tasting of alcohol shall be limited to those products brewed or distilled on
the premises, except as otherwise permitted by Delaware Law.
(e) All food sales shall be limited to prepackaged snack items or those food
items prepared by a food establishment licensed by the State of Delaware.
Page 66
Página 67
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 6
Item #6.
(f) Outdoor seating and gathering areas shall be permitted subject to the
following requirements:
i. Permanent and temporary outdoor seating and gathering areas
shall be subject to building permit application and approval
requirements.
ii. Outdoor seating and gathering areas and ancillary improvements
shall include physical barriers from public rights-of-way and
physical and visual barriers from adjoining properties. Physical
barriers along public rights-of-way shall restrict access from the
public rights-of-way to the outdoor seating and gathering areas
and shall not exceed four feet in height. Barriers along adjoining
property lines shall create a physical and visual barrier consisting
of fencing six feet in height or vegetation at least six feet in
height.
iii. Maximum occupancy and points of ingress/egress shall be clearly
marked. Occupancy of outdoor seating and gathering areas shall
not exceed one person per 15 square feet of the outdoor seating
and gathering areas identified in the building plans or any other
occupancy limit established by the City of Dover.
iv. All structures and uses related to outdoor seating and gathering
areas and facilities are subject to the Dover Code of Ordinances,
Chapter 22 and Chapter 46.
v. The occupancy of outdoor seating and gathering areas shall be
included when calculating the building requirements and
minimum parking standards required by the City of Dover and
the State of Delaware.
vi. Tables, chairs, umbrellas, equipment, games, and any other items
provided in connection with outdoor seating and gathering areas
shall be maintained in good repair and shall be secured during
non-business hours in a safe and orderly manner.
vii. Any licensing required by the Delaware Alcoholic Beverage
Control Commissioner for outdoor seating and gathering areas
shall be obtained.
20A.3 Uses prohibited. The following uses are specifically prohibited:
20A.31 Residences, except those existing at the time of adoption of this amendment.
20A.32 Manufacturing uses involving primary production of the following products
from raw materials: Asphalt, cement, charcoal, and fuel briquettes; chemicals:
aniline dyes, ammonia, carbide, caustic soda, cellulose, chlorine, and carbon black
and bone black, creosote, hydrogen and oxygen, industrial alcohol, nitrates
(manufactured and natural) of an explosive nature, potash, and synthetic resins,
pyroxylin, rayon yarn, and hydrochloric, nitric, phosphoric, picric, and sulphuric
acids; coal, coke, and tar products, including gas manufacturing; explosives,
Page 67
Página 68
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 7
Item #6.
fertilizers, glue, and size (animal); linoleum and oil cloth; matches; paint,
varnishes, and turpentine; rubber (natural or synthetic); and soaps, including fat
rendering.
20A.33 Storage, except that which is incidental to the primary use on the lot.
20A.34 The following processes: nitrating of cotton or other materials; magnesium
foundry; reduction, refining, smelting, and alloying of metal or metal ores;
refining secondary aluminum; refining petroleum products, such as gasoline,
kerosene, naphtha, and lubricating oil; distillation of wood or bones; and
reduction and processing of wood pulp and fiber, including papermill operations.
20A.35 Operations involving stock yards, slaughter houses, and slag piles.
20A.36 Storage of explosives, and bulk or wholesale storage of gasoline above the
ground.
20A.37 Dumps.
20A.38 Quarries, stone crushers, screening plants, and storage of quarry screenings,
accessory to such uses.
20A.39 Junkyards, automobile dismantling plants, or storage of used parts of
automobiles or other machines or vehicles or of dismantled or junked
automobiles.
20A.4 Site development plan approval. Site development plan approval, in accordance
with article 10, section 2 hereof, shall be required of land zoned IPM2 prior to the
issuance of building permits for the erection or enlargement of all structures and
prior to the issuance of certificates of occupancy for any change of use.
20A.5 Performance standards. All uses are subject to performance standards as set
forth in article 5, section 8.
BE IF FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 12 – Definitions be amended by inserting the text indicated
in bold, blue font in appropriate alphabetical order:
Vocational education facility: Services or instruction which are geared toward training for
a specific occupation or set of skills.
ADOPTED: JANUARY 9, 2023
ANNEXATION/REZONING OF PROPERTY CONSISTING OF THREE PARCELS ON
THE NORTH SIDE OF WEST DENNEYS ROAD AND WEST OF CARLISLE DRIVE;
PARCEL A LOCATED AT 57 ROCKY ROAD, OWNED BY GEORGE L. CRAIG JR.
AND DEBORAH J. CRAIG; PARCEL B, LOCATED AT 4085 WEST DENNEYS ROAD,
OWNED BY ROBERT G. KELLER AND GLORIA K. KELLER; PARCEL C AN
UNADDRESSED PARCEL ON WEST DENNEYS ROAD, OWNED BY BRUCE A.
BURKETT
Page 68
Página 69
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 8
Item #6.
Ms. Mary Ellen Gray, Director of Planning and Community Development, reviewed the Petition
to Annex and re-zone the property. The Planning Commission recommended the annexation of
the property with the zoning designation of RM-2 (Medium Density Resident Zone) and partially
subject to the source water protection overlay zone, as submitted.
Public Hearing - Zoning Classification
Members considered a request for rezoning of properties consisting of three parcels on the north
side of West Denneys road and west of Carlisle Drive;
Parcel A, located at 57 Rocky Road, is owned by George L. Craig Jr. and Deborah J. Craig; the
property is currently zoned AR-Agricultural Residential District (Kent County zoning
classification), and the proposed zoning is RM-2 - Medium Density Residence Zone and partially
subject to the SWPOZ (City of Dover zoning classification).
Parcel B located at 4085 West Denneys Road, is owned by Robert G. Keller and Gloria K.
Keller; the property is currently zoned RM-Multifamily Residential District (Kent County zoning
classification), and the proposed zoning is RM-2-Medium Density Residence Zone and partially
subject to the SWPOZ (City of Dover zoning classification).
Parcel C, an unaddressed parcel on West Denneys Road, owned by Bruce A. Burkett; the
property is currently zoned AR-Agricultural Residential District (Kent County zoning
classification), and the proposed zoning is RM-2 - Medium Density Residence Zone.
A public hearing was duly advertised for this time and place to consider the rezoning of the
property consisting of three parcels on the north side of West Denneys road and west of Carlisle
drive; Parcel A, located at 57 Rocky Road, owned by George L. Craig Jr. And Deborah J. Craig;
Parcel B, located at 4085 West Denneys Road, owned by Robert G. Keller and Gloria K. Keller;
Parcel C, an unaddressed parcel on West Denneys Road, owned by Bruce A. Burkett.
Acting Council President Anderson declared the public hearing open.
Pam Scott, Saul, Ewing, LLP, 1201 North Market Street, Wilmington, Delaware. Ms. Scott
spoke on behalf of the applicants, Jack Lingo Asset Management, LLC, who are the equitable
owners of the property. Ms. Scott explained that the property is on the city’s comprehensive
development plan as being in a priority 2 annexation area, which means that the annexation of
these properties is considered consistent with the comprehensive plan. Ms. Scott further
explained that in addition to being part of the comprehensive plan, if the properties were to be
annexed into the city, they would be appropriately rezoned medium-density residential, which is
also consistent with the city’s comprehensive plan. Ms. Scott stated that the city has determined
that there is sufficient infrastructure available to accommodate the proposed project for
development and is consistent with the surrounding community.
Mark Slater, 22 Ardsley Circle, Dover, Delaware. Mr. Slater explained that he has two concerns
with the rezoning, the first is the number of houses that would end up on these properties. He
explained that the main concern would be the property value reduction if it is denser than what
Carlisle Village currently is. Mr. Slater explained that his second concern is the traffic on West
Denneys. Mr. Slater stated that if the access to these houses that would probably be built on this
Page 69
Página 70
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 9
Item #6.
land if the access is on West Denneys, that area right there on the map is kind of dangerous.
There is an S-curve there, and there are a decent number of accidents regularly.
Geneva and Michael Warren, 42 Ardsley Circle, Dover, Delaware. Ms. Warren stated that she
opposes the building because of the added traffic that would come with the building of the
additional facilities. She explained that her daughter, who lives right around the corner if she
goes to pick her daughter up from school, it is hard to leave her development. She was also
thinking that if they build these additional houses on West Denneys Road, she too will have that
same experience at West Denneys Road. So that is going to be one of her concerns and if she can
piggyback off from the value of the homes. They live in Carlisle Village, they live in a very nice
quiet development, and they love it there. They are thinking with the additional homes that it
may become really busy and a lot of noise and much traffic and things of that nature.
City Clerk Ms. Bennett read an email submission (Exhibit 1) for the Annexation/Rezoning public
hearing into the record.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Gray explained that a traffic analysis study is premature
at a rezoning stage. Ms. Gray stated that items to be considered for rezoning are whether the uses
are permitted, would be compatible with the existing uses and the zone in the area concerned,
whether there are adequate public services and infrastructure exist and whether the needs of any
additional demand as a result of such change, and whether the proposed use is by the city’s
current comprehensive plan. Ms. Gray explained that they are not at the site plan approval stage
and are not looking at a proposed use. She further explained that they are just looking at what is
allowed. Another thing to consider is that this is zoned in the county and there is nothing to
preclude this is also developed in the county for residential use.
Mr. Neil stated that he wanted to emphasize two things. One of which is really what the city’s
Planning Director has already stated. They are looking at the fact that they have a desperate need
for housing and it is more desperate than anybody can presume. Mr. Neil continued to state that
even in terms of protecting other properties, this is to be set for medium density. Two, the fact
that if there is flooding, that will be something that will be taken up within the development
because they are required to have the resources to move that water through drains, swales, and
whatever else because that is a problem. Mr. Neil noted that this is why the zone recognizes that
there is an over zone dealing with water and that all of this is premature. Mr. Neil explained that
this emphasizes the fact that if traffic is a problem, Del-DOT is going to be stepping in and
saying, yay, nay, or they have got to straighten this road. The city has the MPO where they can
direct and request that it be done. The MPO can also make sure it becomes a priority to have
Del-DOT work on this particular road if it is a state-maintained road. If it is not a state-
maintained road then it is a city road, and the city will have to handle it. The city knows that
there are problems because there are problems now. Mr. Neil stated that the fact is, they are
calling for this property to be used for housing, which is a desperate, desperate need for the city.
There is also a need for the public to be able to have additional housing coming in. Mr. Neil
continued to state that in regard to planning, the people who are here to object to it will have
another opportunity to say, “I do not like this, I do not like what is planned.” That is when it
comes to digging in the ground and fixing it up. Mr. Neil stated that this is just to allow them to
do this and that he thinks it is something that they do need.
Page 70
Página 71
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 10
Item #6.
Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Gray confirmed that the proposed properties are currently in the
county and that one lot is approved, one is zoned RM multi-family residential, and the other is
zoned agricultural residential.
Mr. Hare stated that he would disregard the email that was read into the record. He explained
that, as far as he is concerned that it could be coming from another contractor who is trying to get
the property. Mr. Hare stated that if someone is not willing to sign for it, he knows in the Ethics
Commission that if you do not sign for it is not considered.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Gray stated that she was looking at the utility report, referring
back to that. Ms. Gray stated that the properties are not currently served by the City of Dover
Electric and explained that any future redevelopment with an electric service provider will be
evaluated. The properties are not currently served by the City of Dover Water Sanitary Sewer.
She further explained that water and sanitary sewer services are available to be hooked into, so
should this project move forward for development, then the developer would have to pay for the
development of the infrastructure to provide the connection for the water and sewer.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Gray explained that there would be appropriate impact fees
for city services.
Adoption of Annexation Resolution No. 2022-08
Members considered Annexation Resolution No. 2022-08 for property consisting of three parcels
on the north side of West Denneys road and west of Carlisle Drive; Parcel A, located at 57
Rocky Road, owned by George L. Craig Jr. and Deborah J. Craig; Parcel B located at 4085 West
Denneys Road, owned by Robert G. Keller and Gloria K. Keller; Parcel C, an unaddressed parcel
on West Denneys Road, owned by Bruce A. Burkett.
By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, Council, by a unanimous roll call vote
(Sudler absent), adopted Resolution No. 2022-08, as follows:
A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE INCLUSION OF AN AREA WITHIN THE
LIMITS OF THE CITY OF DOVER
WHEREAS, the Charter of the City of Dover authorizes Council to extend the boundaries of the
said City in accordance with Title 22, Chapter 1, Section 101 of the Delaware Code (22 Del. C.§
101); and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council deem it to be in the best interest of the City of Dover to
include an area contiguous to the present City limits, and hereinafter more particularly described,
within the limits of the City of Dover; and
WHEREAS, the Charter of the City of Dover provides that if an annexation is petitioned by all
owners of all property considered for annexation; no election shall be required. For an
annexation petition not requiring an election, such petition shall be processed in accordance with
procedures established for amendments to the zoning map, specified in Dover Code, Appendix B
- Zoning. All annexation petitions shall be processed concurrently with the rezoning of the
property considered for annexation and shall be subject to a public hearing before City Council.
Page 71
Página 72
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 11
Item #6.
Public notice shall be completed in accordance with the provisions of the Dover Code relating to
the amendment of the zoning map.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1. That the following described area, situated in East Dover Hundred, Kent County, State of
Delaware, along with all adjacent paths, sidewalks, roadways, and rights-of-way in their
entirety shall be annexed to and included within the limits of the City of Dover:
Parcel A (Tax Map Parcel No.: ED-00-056.00-01-40.00-000)
BEGINNING at a point on the northly side of West Denneys Road - KCR #100 (25’ from
centerline) said being the southwesterly boundary corner for lands now or formerly of Robert G.
& Gloria K. Keller, where it joins the northeasterly boundary corner for lands herein described.
Said point being located by the following (5) courses & distances from a 25’ radius junction
curve joining the southwesterly side of Carlisle Drive (60’ Wide) with the northwesterly side of
West Denneys Road. 1. With an arc curving to the left A=116.40’ R=997.23’ CB=S 52⁰37’37”
W CD=116.34’ to a point another point of curvature. 2. With an arc curving to the left
A=258.98’ R=617.98’ CB=S 34⁰51’41” W CD=257.09’ to a point. 3. S 22⁰52’19” W, 60.48’ to a
point. 4. S 17⁰59’54” W, 96.64’ to a point of curvature. 5. With an arc curving to the right
A=183.15’ R=495.86’ CB=S 28⁰34’42” W CD=182.11’ to a point of beginning.
THENCE from the point of beginning, along the westerly side of West Denneys Road –
KCR#100 the following (2) courses & distances. 1. With an arc curving to the right A=63.55’
R=495.86’ CB=S 42⁰49’54” W CD=63.51’ to a point. 2. S 48⁰00’36” W, 37.09’ to a point, a
corner for lands now or formerly of the Church of God, Trustees. Thence by the same, with
Church of God, Trustees the following (2) courses & distances: 3. N 50⁰27’45” W, 535.91’ to a
point. 4. S 51⁰22’57” W, 188.44’ to a point in the line of lands now or formerly of David &
Veronica Gonce.
THENCE by the same, with David & Veronica Gonce the following (4) courses & distances: 1.
N 38⁰01’21” W, 904.08’ to a point. 2. S 44⁰25’05” W, 169.00’ to a point. 3. S 13⁰46’11” E,
292.99’ to a point. 4. S 23⁰33’43” W, 145.23’ to a point.
THENCE by the same and with lands now or formerly of William M. & Joan R. Warrington and
Gerald P. & Lura J. Johnson, S 35⁰40’37” W, 561.02’ to a point, a corner for lands now or
formerly of Michael A. & Karen L. Belton. Thence by the same and with lands now or formerly
of Alvin D. & Evelyn L. Rohm, Chase A. Bechtol, Albert E. Muchille, and Brandon & Sabrina
Fansler, N 20⁰16’02” W, 1373.79’ to a point, a corner for lands now or formerly of Brandon B.
Pollitt.
THENCE by the same, N 71⁰49’49” E, 799.65’ to a point, a corner for lands now or formerly of
DEL-HOMES, Inc.
THENCE by the same, and with lots 351 thru 355 of Carlisle Village section 3, S 61⁰01’56” E,
608.69’ to a point, a corner for lands now or formerly of Robert G. & Gloria K. Keller.
Page 72
Página 73
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 12
Item #6.
THENCE by the same with Robert G. & Gloria K. Keller the following (3) courses & distances.
1. S 27⁰58’15” W, 309.00’ to a point. 2. S 48⁰43’51” E, 1096.00’ to a point. 3. S 47⁰08’55” E,
172.65’ to the first mentioned point or place of beginning. Containing within said metes and
bounds 27.5834 +/- acres.
Parcel B (Tax Map Parcel No.: ED-00-056.00-01-41.00-000)
BEGINNING at a point on the northly side of West Denneys Road - KCR #100 (25’ from
centerline) said being the southwesterly boundary corner for lands now or formerly of Bruce A.
Burkett, where it joins the northeasterly boundary corner for lands herein described. Said point
being located by the following (2) courses & distances from a 25’ radius junction curve joining
the southwesterly side of Carlisle Drive (60’ Wide) with the northwesterly side of West Denneys
Road. 1. With an arc curving to the left A=116.40’ R=997.23’ CB=S 52⁰37’37” W CD=116.34’
to a point another point of curvature. 2. With an arc curving to the left A=210.53’ R=617.98’
CB=S 37⁰06’28” W CD=209.51’ to a point of beginning.
THENCE from the point of beginning, along the westerly side of West Denneys Road –
KCR#100 the following (4) courses & distances. 1. With an arc curving to the left A=48.45’
R=617.98’ CB=S 25⁰06’07” W CD=48.44’ to a point. 2. S 22⁰52’19” W, 60.48’ to a point. 3. S
17⁰59’54” W, 96.64’ to a point of curvature. 4. With an arc curving to the right A=183.15’
R=495.86’ CB=S 28⁰34’42” W CD=182.11’ to a point of lands now or formerly of George L. &
Deborah J. Craig.
THENCE by the same, with George L. & Deborah J. Craig. the following (3) courses &
distances: 1. N 47⁰08’55” W, 172.65’ to a point. 2. N 48⁰43’51” W, 1096.00’ to a point. 3. N
27⁰58’15” E, 309.00’ to a point in the line of lot 356, Carlisle Village section 3.
THENCE by the same, and with lots 357 thru 362 of Carlisle Village section 3, and lands now or
formerly of Wilson M. Dennis, Phillis P. Palmer, and Shannon L. Schilling, S 61⁰01’56” E,
824.11’ to a point, a corner for lands now or formerly of Bruce A. Burkett.
THENCE by the same with Bruce A. Burkett the following (2) courses & distances. 1. S
37⁰06’26” W, 209.72’ to a point. 2. S 62⁰16’59” E, 420.19’ to the first mentioned point or place
of beginning. Containing within said metes and bounds 10.5661 +/- acres.
Parcel C (Tax Map Parcel No.: ED-00-056.00-01-42.00-000)
BEGINNING at a point on the northly side of West Denneys Road - KCR #100 (25’ from
centerline) said being the southwesterly boundary corner for lot 1, Carlisle Village, Section 1,
where it joins the northeasterly boundary corner for lands herein described. Said point being
located by an arc curving to the left A=116.40’ R=997.23’ CB=S 52⁰37’37” W CD=116.34’
from a 25’ radius junction curve joining the southwesterly side of Carlisle Drive (60’ Wide) with
the northwesterly side of West Denneys Road.
THENCE from the point of beginning, along westerly side of West Denneys Road – KCR #100
with an arc curving to the left A=210.53’ R=617.98’ CB=S 37⁰06’28” W CD=209.51’ to a point,
a corner for lands now or formerly of Robert G. & Gloria K. Keller.
Page 73
Página 74
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 13
Item #6.
THENCE by the same the following (2) course and distances: 1. N 62⁰16’59” W, 420.19’ to a
point. 2. N 37⁰06’26” E, 209.72’ to a point, a corner for lot 6 of Carlisle Village section 1.
THENCE by the same and with lots 1 thru 6 of Carlisle Village section 1, S 2⁰15’18” E, 420.16’
to the first mentioned point or place of beginning. Containing within said metes and bounds
1.9662 +/- acres.
2. That the above-described properties shall be annexed into the City of Dover with a
zoning classification as set by City Council and in accordance with the zoning map and
environs then in force, effective upon such lands being included within the limits of the
City of Dover.
3. That the certified copy of this resolution of annexation, together with a plot of the area
annexed, shall be filed for record with the Recorder of Deeds of Kent County.
4. That the effective date of this resolution shall be the 10th day of January 2023, at 12:01
a.m.
ADOPTED: JANUARY 9, 2023
Final Reading/Adoption of Rezoning Ordinance #2022-25
Members considered Rezoning Ordinance #2022-25 for property consisting of three parcels on
the north side of West Denneys road and west of Carlisle Drive; Parcel A located at 57 Rocky
Road, owned by George L. Craig Jr. and Deborah J. Craig; Parcel B located at 4085 West
Denneys Road, owned by Robert G. Keller and Gloria K. Keller; Parcel C, an unaddressed parcel
on West Denneys Road, owned by Bruce A. Burkett.
Mr. Hare moved that the Final Reading of Ordinance #2022-25 be acknowledged by title
only, seconded by Mr. Neil, and unanimously carried (Sudler absent). (The First Reading of
the ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of November 14, 2022.)
Mr. Neil moved for approval of the rezoning, as recommended by the Planning Commission.
The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and, by a unanimous roll call vote (Sudler
absent), Council adopted Ordinance #2022-25, as follows:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF
THE CITY OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF THREE
(3) PROPERTIES LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF WEST DENNEYS ROAD.
WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property
within the limits of the City of Dover; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use
of property located at 57 Rocky Road (Parcel A) described below from AR (Agricultural
Residential District)(Kent County Zoning Classification) to RM-2 (Medium Density
Residence Zone), and partially subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay
Zone)(City of Dover zoning classifications).
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use
Page 74
Página 75
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 14
Item #6.
of property located at 4085 West Denneys Road (Parcel B) described below from RM
(Multifamily Residential District) (Kent County Zoning Classification) to RM-2 (Medium
Density Residence Zone), and partially subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection
Overlay Zone)(City of Dover zoning classifications).
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted
use of an unaddressed property located on the north side of West Denneys Road (Parcel C)
described below from AR (Agricultural Residential District) (Kent County Zoning
Classification) to RM-2 (Medium Density Residence Zone) (City of Dover zoning
classifications).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
A. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and
Zoning Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning
designation from AR (Agricultural Residential District)(Kent County Zoning
Classification) to RM-2 (Medium Density Residence Zone), and partially subject to the
SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone)(City of Dover zoning classifications)
on that property located at 57 Rock Road (Parcel A) (located on the north side of West
Denneys Road and west of Carlisle Drive), consisting of 27.5834+/- acres., owned by
George L. Craig and Deborah J. Craig.
(Parcel A; Tax Parcel: ED-00-056.00-01-40.00-000; Planning Reference: AX-22-03; First
Council District)
B. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and
Zoning Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning
designation from RM (Multifamily Residential District) (Kent County Zoning
Classification) to RM-2 (Medium Density Residence Zone), and partially subject to the
SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone)(City of Dover zoning classifications)
on that property located at 4085 West Denneys Road (Parcel B) (located on the north
side of West Denneys Road and west of Carlisle Drive), consisting of 10.5661+/- acres.,
owned by Robert G. Keller and Gloria K. Keller.
(Parcel B; Tax Parcel: ED-00-056.00-01-41.00-000; Planning Reference: AX-22-03; First
Council District)
C. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and
Zoning Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning
designation from AR
(Agricultural Residential District)(Kent County Zoning Classification) to RM-2 (Medium
Density Residence Zone) on an unaddressed parcel on West Denneys Road (Parcel C)
(located on the north side of West Denneys Road and west of Carlisle Drive), consisting
of 1.9662+/- acres., owned by Bruce A. Burkett.
(Parcel C; Tax Parcel: ED-00-056.00-01-42.00-000; Planning Reference: AX-16-01; First Council District)
ADOPTED: JANUARY 09, 2023
Page 75
Página 76
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 15
Item #6.
CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
City Manager Hugg shared his 2023 Looking Forward, Observations, and Speculations with
members of council. (Exhibit 2)
CITY MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mayor Christiansen was not present to give announcements.
COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS
Councilman Boggerty thanked everyone for their warm congratulations, thoughts, and prayers.
He thanked everyone for being team Dover even when they are debating. He further explained
that during an interview, he stated that while the council members are different, they each have
one thing in common: they want what is best for the City of Dover.
Councilman Taylor announced that he will resign from City Council on February 1, 2023. He
explained that four years ago, his wife Jean told him he had four years, and that is it. Mr. Taylor
explained that they have purchased a home outside the city limits and will take possession on
February 1, 2023. Mr. Taylor stated that it has been 32 years with him and the city having boots
on the ground. He stated that he loves the city; however, it is time for a change, and change is
good. Mr. Taylor explained that he had permitted himself to leave three months ago but was
stubborn and was going to give the Mayor one heck of a race. He stated that he was going to
honor his promise to his wife and that they will take possession of their new home and make it
their primary residence and be happy. Mr. Taylor followed up, stating it has been an honor
working with everyone over the past four years. Mr. Taylor respectfully requested that the
Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee Chair position be filled immediately due to the
decisions being made. Mr. Taylor suggested that Mr. Boggerty would be a great fit. He further
stated that Mr. Boggerty has a very balanced approach.
Councilman Anderson asked Chief Johnson to thank his staff for Law Enforcement Appreciation
Day and reminded everyone that the City Council stands with the men and women of law
enforcement in the City of Dover. Mr. Anderson thanked the officers for their dedication to the
city, its citizens, and those who come in and work, visit and worship. He stated that they make
our city safer so we all can do our jobs in the community, and we thank them. Mr. Anderson then
reminded everyone that Dr. Martin Luther King Day is coming up on Monday, January 16, 2023,
and that there is an event at Delaware State University at noon. He suggested letting Council
President Sudler and the Inner-City Cultural League, Inc. know if anyone on the council is
interested in attending. Mr. Anderson also reminded everyone that there is a breakfast for Martin
Luther King Day at Modern Maturity Center, and doors open at 7:15 a.m.
Councilman Anderson reminded everyone of the Special Council Meeting that will take place on
Thursday, January 26, 2023, from 6:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. in Council Chambers.
Councilman Neil reminded everyone of Coffee with a Cop on Tuesday, January 17, 2023, from
5:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m. at McGlynn’s.
Page 76
Página 77
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 09, 2023 PAGE 16
Item #6.
The meeting adjourned at 7:27 p.m.
ANDRIA BENNETT
CITY CLERK
All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by City Council during their Regular
Meeting of January 9, 2023, are hereby approved.
ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN
MAYOR
/AB
\\VMFILEPRINT\CityClerk\AGENDAS-MINUTES-PACKETS\Council-Minutes\2023\01-January\01-09-2023 REGULAR COUNCIL MINUTES.doc
Exhibits
Exhibit #1 – Annexation Public Hearing Email Submission
Exhibit #2 – 2023 Looking Forward – City Manager Hugg
Page 77
Página 78
Exhibit #1
Item #6.
From: James
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Proposed annexation and rezoning of properties of lands of Craig,Keller,andBurkett
Date: Saturday, January 7, 2023 12:50:19 PM
WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open
attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.
I have an issue of the proposed annexation and rezoning of the lands of Craig Keller and
Burkett. I saw the yellow sign and I see where the entrance to this proposed annexation
property would be. West Indies road around that sharp curve has many accidents. Putting a
new development subdivision or apartment complex on those curves will cause even more
accidents and maybe cost lives. There are already too many cars and tractor trailers going up
and down West Indies road in this area. This annexation should not be done because safety of
people's lives is more important than building a whole bunch of apartments or homes in that
low section always holding water land. When we get heavy rain the water runs out of those
woods down the road into Carlisle village. Whoever develops in there is going to either have
flooding issues on their property or they're going to raise the property and Carlisle village the
church on the other side of the property and homes over there will then have flooding
problems this area is not a good area for development in my opinion. My biggest concern is
the amount of traffic on West Indies road and this this property entryway is going to be in
these curves causing many more accidents. I oppose this annexation for the safety of all who
travel and live on West Indies road. Sincerely James
Page 78
Página 79
Exhibit #2 Item #6.
2023 – Looking Forward; Observations and Speculations
I try not to make unsupported predictions, but as 2022 comes to an end I’ve been cogitating
about what we have learned and where we might be headed in 2023. By no means a complete
list, and without hard evidence in some instances, the following are my observations and
expectations (and speculations). They are in no priority order and reflect only my thinking
about the subject; with the caveat that I might be totally off course. Just thought there might
be value in sharing.
Inflation –
The good news is that inflation, at least as measured by the Philadelphia South Regional CPI
appears to be in decline. The month-to-month average was up marginally but the 12-month
average for November was at 7.1% (seasonally unadjusted) for all urban consumer
commodities. This is down from over 8% the previous month and from highs over 10% a few
months ago. Many will take credit for this trend but actions by the Federal Reserve are primary.
The Federal Reserve has indicated it may increase interest rates at least once more to control
inflation. For the City, a slowing of inflation impacts on the costs of goods and services we
purchase and may temper higher costs of construction. Fuel prices, for example, are now below
a year ago favorably impacting our vehicle fuel costs; an area where budgeted amounts are
proving inadequate.
Interest rates –
While the Federal Reserve’s actions to control inflation appear to be working, higher rates are
beginning to be reflected in slowed housing lending, mortgages, and credit. This has caused
some development deals to be suspended. The city has already lost one land sale opportunity
in GOBTP as the increased cost of borrowing caused the project to become risky. Higher
interest rates could have varied impacts on the city’s ability to borrow for capital projects or
lend funds to foster redevelopment.
Wholesale energy –
As an electric utility our costs for purchased power drive the amount we pay for energy and the
costs we must build into our utility rates and charges. Just this year the city was forced to
impose a PPCA debit on customers’ bills, increasing their monthly charges significantly. At
budget time we were experiencing costs in the $8-$9 MMBtu range for wholesale energy.
Those costs have begun to trend lower, although colder weather forecasted for this winter and
resumed LNG exports are anticipated to cause prices to escalate. For the moment lower costs
have a positive benefit on purchases and energy hedges. The wholesale energy market is too
volatile to count on reduced costs anytime soon, and unfortunately any relief for customers.
Page 79
Página 80
Item #6.
Any change to the PPCA at this point would be premature and subject to reconsideration next
fiscal year based on economic conditions.
Developer interest/investment/economy –
Despite the factors above, the city continues to see interest from developers/investors. Some
are clearly tire-kickers, but we have been approached by parties looking for good opportunities
and recognizing the competitiveness in certain sectors (manufacturing, logistics, rental
housing). Although one deal fell through, we currently have two agreements of sale and a
couple of LOI’s for property at Garrison Oak, two large logistics/warehouse projects are under
development at Lafferty Lane and Enterprise Business Park, and Kent Economic Partnership has
26 active projects in play, many of which are Dover focused. And we continue to see retail
projects moving forward in such areas as banking and food. Most economic observers suggest
that there is still a large amount of private resources seeking good investment opportunities.
But the lack of an ample trained, dependable workforce is critical. One large employer
continues to consider leaving Dover and another often doesn’t have enough employees show
up to be able to run the third shift. Employee shortages are adversely affecting our economy
across every sector.
City finances –
Fortunately, city revenues are tracking favorably compared to our budget. We have not
experienced significant budget-busters, nor have we seen extraordinary or unanticipated
revenue windfalls. Revenues could be tempered if the economy falls into a recession and our
confidence in upcoming years is low. Wage and benefit increases associated with wage equity,
benefit costs increase, and retirement issues will pose a significant challenge both this year and
next while deferred vehicle replacement is already driving maintenance costs to new levels and
supply chain issues are delaying infrastructure projects while also pushing up costs. A proposed
legislative change in the Real Estate Transfer Tax formula (a bill was just introduced in the
House) could make some investments more attractive resulting in added revenues, but the
State continues to consider and enact unfunded mandates of all types.
State Government/General Assembly –
A new and probably more progressive General Assembly takes office in January. Prior General
Assemblies and the Governor, in my opinion, have tended to be more moderate conservative,
so I expect to see more focus on social and environmental concerns such as climate change and
clean energy, electric vehicles, homeless rights, police funding and oversight, local land use
control, etc. Many of these will result in additional unfunded mandates and/or limitations on
local authority; a concern over what was Senate Bill 305 (Climate Change) last year proposed
granting the Secretary of DNREC very broad powers that impact local development and land
use control. Building strength in numbers through the Delaware League of Local Governments
(DLLG) and other cooperative associations will be vital in the next session. DLLG also believes
Page 80
Página 81
Item #6.
that most of the “new” money from DEFAC (and any surplus this year) will be absorbed by
inflation related costs and probably not available for local projects.
Cybersecurity –
The ever-increasing threat of cyber-attacks, along with rapidly changing technology, make this a
significant issue looking forward. More funding from federal grants for both Information
Technology (IT), that underlies our business processes, and Operational Technology (OT), that
controls our water and electric grids, is very likely. On the IT side, Delaware received approval
for over 2.2M of federal grant dollars for the current fiscal year, with 80% going to county and
municipalities. Cooperation with the state is key, as future funding in the out-years is
contingent on matching funds and the state would like to simplify the process by providing the
match themselves. Additional funding opportunities on the electrical OT side are likely later this
fiscal year as we look for opportunities to further secure our infrastructure against both cyber
and physical threats.
Federal funding –
The Biden administration has and continues to pump federal funding into infrastructure,
inflation reduction, housing, and recovery from pandemic and economic downturns. Last year
Congress reestablished “earmarks” in the budget process, and a part of the upcoming federal
budget as well. While these funds are attractive, they raise questions of the City’s capacity to
efficiently utilize grants and loans and they come with various constraints such as addressing
social and environmental equity (Justice40 requirement), clean energy and climate change, and
disadvantaged neighborhoods. The city is slated to get congressional earmarks for police
cameras and water system enhancements.
Housing –
Aside from federal funding emphasis on housing, local rental housing rates are up by over 10%
(based on CPI) with local rents over $1200/month and up. Rental housing inventories are tight
as well, making it difficult for low to moderate income persons to afford. New single-family
construction and inventories are also very tight according to local realtors; they anticipate a
slowing in construction and resales as interest rates increase (despite continued building in the
area). Fortunately, aggressive code enforcement and the efforts of NCALL/Neighbor Good
Partners and Central Delaware Habitat for Humanity have reduced the number of vacant and
problematic properties (but many of these previously provided substandard but “affordable”
housing). Housing for homeless or seriously underhoused individuals/families is almost non-
existent and hard to locate due to NIMBY opposition.
Future of the Downtown –
The long-awaited master plan is nearing completion and hopefully will generate excitement and
investor/entrepreneurial interest. DDP has set up a capital building improvement grant
program with solid interest. The fire-damaged building on W. Loockerman Street has been
Page 81
Página 82
Item #6.
demolished. The new State Family Court building construction is underway. But we await any
large-scale project proposals. The plan will call for various streetscape and utility investments,
signage and wayfinding, parking changes, removal of large trees, increased policing, and other
public improvements, of which costs to the city budget are not yet known.
David S. Hugg III
City Manager
January 3, 2023
Page 82
Página 83
Item #7.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE
The Council Committee of the Whole met on January 10, 2023, at 6:03 p.m. with Councilwoman
Dr. Pillsbury presiding. Members of Council present were Mr. Anderson, Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty,
Mr. Hare, Mr. Neil, and Mr. Rocha. Mr. Sudler and Mr. Taylor were absent. Mayor Christiansen was
also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Shelton (Utility),
Mr. Contant (via WebEx) and Mr. Shevock (via WebEx) (Legislative, Finance, and Administration
Committee). Mr. McCutcheon (Utility), and Dr. Jackson, and Mr. Hosfelt (Safety, Advisory, and
Transportation) were absent.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.
Evaluation of Bids – FY 2023 Street and Alley Program (Jason Lyon, Director of Water and
Wastewater)
Mr. Jason Lyon, Director of Water and Wastewater, reviewed the background and analysis of the
evaluation of bids for the FY 2023 Street and Alley Program.
Staff recommended awarding the contract to Sam’s Construction, LLC, for the City of Dover FY 2023
Street and Alley Program, Bid #23-0005PW, for the amount of $1,037,595.25.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Lyon stated that the total amount of repaving is 0.99 miles.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Lyon stated that if this project is approved, the process to notify the
residents of the paving project would be by sending a letter that states this project is coming forward.
Mr. Lyon explained that the next step would be to set up a kickoff meeting with the contractor to
schedule a start time and send a second notice of when the work will begin. Mr. Lyon further explained
that a third handwritten, hand-delivered notice would be delivered one week prior to the start of work.
Mr. Boggerty requested that Mr. Lyon state what process he followed to make sure that everyone
including minorities had ample opportunity to bid on the construction.
Mr. Lyon stated that they publicly advertise through the newspaper and the City of Dover website.
Mr. Lyon explained that they solicit from the State of Delaware’s list of Disadvantaged Business
Enterprise. Mr. Lyon further explained that they use that database to reach out to qualified vendors
that could do this work.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lyon stated the City of Dover does not require the vendor to provide
a diversity statement or proof of Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO).
Page 83
Página 84
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 10, 2023 PAGE 2
Item #7.
Responding to Mr. Lyon, Mr. Boggerty stated that he thought it sounded like Mr. Lyon did his due
diligence and wanted the process on record. Mr. Boggerty stated that he appreciated Mr. Lyon.
Responding to Mr. Shelton, Mr. Lyon stated that the city will coordinate with the Delaware
Department of Transportation (DelDOT) and notify police, fire, emergency services, and schools for
any road construction that would cause any type of detour or delays.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend awarding the contract to Sam’s Construction, LLC, for the City
of Dover FY 2023 Street and Alley Program, Bid #23-0005PW, for the amount of $1,037,595.25,
as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
Evaluation of Bids – Williams Park Storm Pipe Replacement (Jason Lyon, Director of Water and
Wastewater)
Mr. Jason Lyon, Director of Water and Wastewater, reviewed the background and analysis of the
evaluation of bids for the Williams Park Storm Pipe Replacement.
Staff recommended awarding the contract to Gateway Construction, Inc. for the Williams Park Storm
Pipe Replacement, ITB #23-0004PW, for $148,000.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Lyon stated that the corroded pipe led to a washout of soil around the
pipe. Mr. Lyon explained that the pipe had started to disintegrate, and that sediment and dirt are going
into the river. Mr. Lyon noted that the river is stormwater, and the quality of drinking water has not
been affected.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Lyon stated that they have anticipated 60 days for the construction
process of this project, and that would include the allocation of materials. Mr. Lyon stated that once
the contractor receives the materials, the process should not take longer than four weeks. Mr. Lyon
noted that this area is grass and that they will not have to worry about pavement, detours, or traffic
control.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Lyon stated that the project could start roughly around late spring.
Mr. Lyon noted that they have seen a wide range of time delays with getting materials that could affect
this time frame.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Lyon stated that both projects require a performance bond.
Mr. Lyon explained that if the contractor does not complete the work, then the city can pull the bond,
and use that money to hire another contractor to do the work.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend awarding the contract to Gateway Construction, Inc. for the
Williams Park Storm Pipe Replacement, ITB #23-0004PW, for $148,000, as recommended by
staff. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
Annual Review and Approval of Governing Policy for Energy Commodity Risk Management (Lori
Peddicord, Controller/Treasurer)
Ms. Lori Peddicord, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the background and analysis of the amendments
to the Governing Policy for Energy Commodity Risk Management.
Page 84
Página 85
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 10, 2023 PAGE 3
Item #7.
Staff recommended approving the proposed amendments to the Governing Policy for Energy
Commodity Risk Management.
Mr. Neil stated that he thought everybody here was being hurt so badly by the cost of electricity.
Mr. Neil explained that the city went through a period for several years where they were able to
purchase advances that held down electric rates very comfortably, and very low. Mr. Neil stated that
the city does not make money from this and that they are not a profit-making organization.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Peddicord stated that there is too much in the mix to say if the increase
in purchasing power would result in lower costs to the customer. Ms. Peddicord explained that this
allows the city to purchase either the equivalent of what the city used to purchase in 2015 and/or larger
lump sums to maybe capture a better price.
Mr. Neil stated that for those who may not be aware, everything Ms. Peddicord explained is always
available to the public. Mr. Neil explained that any member of the public can go to
www.cityofdover.com and look under Agendas, they will be able to see and read what has been
presented to council tonight.
Mr. Neil stated that what Ms. Peddicord is saying is not a surprise to members of council because they
have done their homework and reviewed the material prior to the meeting. Mr. Neil explained that
members of the public can review the same information and understand what they are going through
in the process to try to keep electric rates down and to be fair. Mr. Neil stated that hopefully the prices
are coming down and that council will be able to take the surcharge off or drop it down as soon as
they possibly can.
Ms. Peddicord reviewed the chart entitled On Peak Purchasing MW By Year – Current $20M Limit
on page 50 of the packet. Ms. Peddicord explained that prior to 2020 the city was buying a lot more
peak or megawatts. Ms. Peddicord stated that going forward, the increase in limit increases the city’s
ability to capture more. Ms. Peddicord noted the difference between the gray line and the red line is a
large variance between the pricing of what they were capturing versus what it is currently costing.
Ms. Peddicord stated that increasing the limit to 40 million will allow the city to hopefully either
purchase larger quantities at a lesser price and/or just more than what they used to be able to do at a
lesser value.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend approving the proposed amendments to the Governing Policy for
Energy Commodity for Risk Management, as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by
Ms. Arndt.
Mr. Anderson stated that this is an important change, and he congratulated the board for that because
it had been a concern. Mr. Anderson noted that he has been bugging the board that the city needs to
be able to buy more when the price drops. Mr. Anderson explained that when the price drops the city
needs that flexibility.
Mr. Anderson congratulated the staff and stated this is an intelligent policy for the ratepayers of the
City of Dover.
Page 85
Página 86
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 10, 2023 PAGE 4
Item #7.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend approving the proposed amendments to the Governing Policy
for Energy Commodity Risk Management, as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded
by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee, hearing no objection, the meeting
adjourned at 6:26 p.m.
SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairwoman Pillsbury presiding.
Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
Dover Roundabout Analysis for Governors Boulevard, Ross Street, and Bradford Street (Sharon Duca,
Assistant City Manager)
Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Dover
Roundabout Analysis for Governors Boulevard, Ross Street, and Bradford Street.
Ms. Duca introduced Ms. Wendy Carpenter, Traffic Calming Manager, DelDOT, and Ms. Nicole
Wilson, Consultant, DelDOT. Ms. Carpenter and Ms. Wilson reviewed the traffic calming measures
in Attachment #1 – Governors Boulevard at Ross and North Bradford – Intersection Improvement
Options.
Ms. Carpenter noted that Representative Sean Lynn is willing to fund most of the options through the
Community Transportation Fund, however, the larger two roundabouts on pages 9 and 10 of
Attachment #1 would require a capital project through the Dover/Kent Metropolitan Planning
Organization (Dover/Kent MPO).
Staff recommended that Council receive public input regarding the options presented and allow for
additional research into low-impact traffic calming options.
Mr. Neil stated that this is just the first step because they have a lot of people who are going to be
concerned about this. Mr. Neil emphasized the fact that every time they had this, they had to give
everybody the chance to say what they think. Mr. Neil explained that these are things that DelDOT
and Council are going to have to take a very close look at in terms of presenting this to an audience of
neighbors who are going to be affected by this.
Mr. Neil stated that Councilwoman Arndt, himself, and Mayor Christiansen have been inundated with
complaints about the accidents that have occurred in this intersection, and that they must do something,
they are concerned about safety. Mr. Neil stated that he wanted everybody to know that this is a first
step, and this is a process that will consider everyone’s thoughts to come up with a decision.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Carpenter stated that for anything that has right-of-way impacts,
drainage impacts, or environmental impacts CTF funds cannot be used.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Carpenter stated that CTF funds could not be used for the larger
roundabouts on pages 9 and 10 of Attachment #1. Ms. Carpenter noted the smaller roundabout on page
Page 86
Página 87
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 10, 2023 PAGE 5
Item #7.
11 of Attachment #1 would qualify for CTF funds, but that you cannot drive in a complete circle
around it.
Mr. Rocha stated that he grew up in an area that had roundabouts his whole life. Mr. Rocha stated that
he felt the ones that are here, that are small, really are not effective at all. Mr. Rocha explained that if
someone is going to speed, they will go right over the bricks in the middle. Mr. Rocha further explained
that where he grew up, it was grass, and if it rained you would be stuck in there, so they learned not to
do that.
Mr. Rocha suggested either putting grass in the middle or not making it so appealing to drive straight
across. Mr. Rocha noted that he felt the small roundabouts are not effective, at all. For example, the
one on Mifflin Road, might as well just be ripped out.
Mr. Anderson stated that there is just not enough room for the large roundabouts and that they are
trying to protect neighborhoods not disrupt them. Mr. Anderson continued to state that taking away
houses and getting rid of a couple of his neighbors is something that he would never support.
Mr. Anderson explained that it is just not practical and would absorb the money that the city
desperately needs to repave other roads.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Carpenter stated that there are options, such as 1A on page one of
Attachment #1, which is just signing and striping, there are no kind of closure or anything like that.
Ms. Carpenter explained that for options such as the all-way stop and the closures, DelDOT would
need to do some analysis just to make sure if they close this road, what is that going to mean? Where
are the cars going to detour to? Does it cause issues somewhere else then? Ms. Carpenter explained
they need to do a study for those questions.
Ms. Carpenter stated that for the options that are just signing and striping, it is just installing the signs
and putting the striping down. Ms. Carpenter explained that for DelDOT, the striping season is spring
and summer, and is dependent on when they can get on the schedule. Ms. Carpenter then further
explained that striping and signing in Kent County are quick, and signage may be installed by the City
of Dover.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Carpenter stated that they do not have a time frame for the larger
projects as DelDOT would need to do more analysis.
Mr. Hare stated that there was a similar issue on Wyoming Avenue, and what prevailed was what the
people that lived there wanted. Mr. Hare stated that he is more concerned about the people who live
there, right on it, around it, and what they want. Mr. Hare stated that he would not sit there and say we
are going to do this if the residents do not want it. Mr. Hare stated the residents who live there, that is
whom he wants to hear from and what they want.
Ms. Arndt stated that she wanted to reiterate Councilman Neil's point that this is the first step, this is
a preliminary assessment. Ms. Arndt apologized and stated that she can certainly appreciate the folks
from the neighborhood who when they first saw this in the packet and saw this giant roundabout, she
knew that caused them considerable anxiety. Ms. Arndt explained that residents have heard here
tonight that that is not an option worth pursuing, it is too large for that area, and certainly, they are not
going to take anyone's home. Ms. Arndt noted that council is not choosing any of these options tonight.
Page 87
Página 88
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 10, 2023 PAGE 6
Item #7.
Ms. Arndt stated that the point of tonight was to say, okay, council is going to move this forward.
Council is going to take it to the public and they will be holding a workshop. Council will be getting
input from the public. Ms. Arndt explained there is more work that DelDOT needs to do regarding
researching these alternatives to see what can happen in this area.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Duca stated that one of the key factors is going to be working with
DelDOT directly. One of the things that she would foresee on this is something similar to some of the
charettes DelDOT does for some other projects so that they can have time with the public to go over
the options. Ms. Duca stated that Ms. Carpenter could speak on this, DelDOT may want to do some
additional analysis before holding those charettes so that they can answer more questions. Ms. Duca
noted that she appreciates the point that they rule out some of the options, to begin with, so they do
not need to be researching the large roundabouts. Ms. Duca explained looking forward, the city is
trying to get that public input before it comes back to council. Ms. Duca noted that the dates would be
posted when those meetings were occurring with the public so that interested members of council
could attend.
Mayor Christiansen requested Madam Chair Pillsbury allow members of the audience who live in that
area of Governors Boulevard, Ross Street, and Bradford Street an opportunity to speak.
Mr. James Frazier, 643 North Bradford Street, stated that he lives on the corner of North Bradford
Street and Ross Street. Mr. Frazier stated that in the 43 years that he has lived on the corner of North
Bradford Street and Ross Street, almost all of his neighbors, including himself, have had vehicle or
property damage. Mr. Frazier explained that these have been single-car accidents caused by reckless
driving, carelessness, and some cases drunk driving. The number of these accidents equates to about
one every five years. Other accidents in the intersection have been due to inattentive driving and
speeding. Mr. Frazier noted that many times, he has observed drivers sitting at the stop sign at North
Bradford and Ross Street, talking, texting on their cell phones, and then pulling into the intersection,
nearly missing cars that are traveling on Governors. The recent addition of signs on the corners of
North Bradford Street and Ross Street, alerting motorists that traffic on Governors Boulevard does not
stop, has been a help.
Mr. Frazier stated that one constant problem at the intersection is excess speed. The speed limit on
Governors Boulevard is 25 miles per hour. When drivers are coming from the north or coming north
from Silver Lake and have a green light at Governors Boulevard and Walker Road, they do not start
to slow down until they get through the intersection and see the solar-powered speed sign flashing at
them. Mr. Frazier stated that he consistently sees speeds of 35 to 50 miles an hour registered on that
sign. Drivers need to realize that when they travel down Governors Boulevard and State Street from
the stop light at State Street, Governors Boulevard, and Walker Road, they are entering a residential
neighborhood. Mr. Frazier suggested that it would be helpful to have another solar-powered sign
placed on Governors Boulevard, between the intersection and the traffic light at Governors Boulevard
and Walker Road. Drivers need to be reminded of their speed before they get to the intersection, not
after it.
Mr. Frazier requested to step up traffic speed enforcement. Mr. Frazier explained that the sight of a
police car is one of the best traffic-calming devices that he knows of. Mr. Frazier also suggested that
one other thing that might slow down people is to paint crosswalk hash marks across the north and
south sides of the intersection on Governors Boulevard, and the same for Ross Street and North
Page 88
Página 89
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 10, 2023 PAGE 7
Item #7.
Bradford Street and putting the State Law Yield to Pedestrian signs in the middle of them like there
are on Governor's Avenue down by Delaware State Universities Downtown Campus.
Mr. Frazier asked council to please keep in mind, with the problems mentioned, traffic through the
intersection travels or traffic moves through the intersection 99% of the time without a problem. Before
they spend millions of dollars and start condemning houses and destroying parts of the neighborhood,
he would like for them to consider less destructive and cheaper ways to enhance the safety of both
motorists and homeowners.
Jim Barron, 640 North Governors Avenue, stated that in 35 years, six fences, telephone poles, and
multiple accidents at all times. Mr. Barron noted that he gets to see most of his neighbors when there
is an accident, and they come out and try to work with people. The speeding is still there, last night at
3:45 pm, a car went through at 54 miles per hour on the flashing sign. Mr. Barron stated that they need
enforcement.
Mr. Barron stated that he is really encouraged by the bigger roundabouts going away and seeing some
of the ideas of making streets one way. Mr. Barron explained that in the morning vehicles are coming
south on Bradford Street heading across and not stopping at all to see if they can get through. He
explained that this started happening when they changed the Walker Road intersection, which created
more traffic on Ross Street because people are trying to avoid the light by coming up Ross Street,
coming through that intersection, and cutting over to Walker Road. Mr. Barron noted that DelDOT
buses do that a lot. Mr. Barron thanked the city and DelDOT for getting this started. He noted they do
not need to take people's homes, but that they need to make it safe.
Mr. Neil stated that the only point he is making is that the residents made the point that they have
already heard. Mr. Neil explained that the only option that was given tonight that looked promising
would have been the small roundabout on page 11 of Attachment #1. Mr. Neil stated that DelDOT
must complete their program and study this because they are the experts. Mr. Neil stated that DelDOT
will come to council to educate them as to what effect it would have, and then to the public for input
on what they prefer.
Mr. Neil stated that anything that helps, he is in favor of. Mr. Neil stated that he is sure that the residents
will get support from this entire group when that occurs, and it is going to happen. Mr. Neil explained
that it would not happen in 35 years or 40 years, it is happening now, and the community has council’s
attention. Mr. Neil thanked the residents for coming out and participating. Mr. Neil reminded the
residents that this is the first step.
Ms. Arndt moved to recommend that Council receive public input regarding the options presented and
allow for additional research into low-impact traffic calming options, as recommended by staff. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Neil.
Mr. Anderson moved to amend the motion to include Community Transportation Fund (CTF)
funded options. Ms. Arndt and Mr. Neil accepted the amendment and unanimously carried.
Ms. Arndt moved to recommend that Council receive public input regarding the Community
Transportation Fund (CTF) funded options presented and allow for additional research into
low-impact traffic calming options, as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by
Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
Page 89
Página 90
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 10, 2023 PAGE 8
Item #7.
Dr. Pillsbury moved for adjournment of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee,
hearing no objection, the meeting adjourned at 7:01 p.m.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Anderson presiding.
Adoption of Agenda
Ms. Arndt moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
Draft Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) (Lori Peddicord, Controller/Treasurer)
Mr. Anderson congratulated Ms. Peddicord and her staff for an unmodified audit and a Certificate of
Excellence in financial reporting.
Ms. Lori Peddicord, Controller/Treasurer, introduced Mr. Bill Seymour, Engagement Partner, S&B
Company. Mr. Seymour reviewed the presentation entitled Fiscal Year 2022 Audit Results.
Staff recommended acceptance of the draft report.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend acceptance of the draft report, as recommended by staff. The
motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Library Rebranding Presentation (Brian Sylvester, Library Director)
Mr. Brian Sylvester, Library Director reviewed the presentation entitled Dover Public Library Brand
Guide. Mr. Sylvester stated that the Dover Public Library hired Kristine Arth, Brand Consultant,
Lobster Phone. Mr. Sylvester noted that the rebranding campaign was covered by the state’s side of
the budget and did not include municipal funds.
Mr. Boggerty thanked Mr. Sylvester for the great work they have done. Mr. Boggerty stated that the
L does not have an L shape. Mr. Boggerty also stated that he would like to see a space between the
D and P. He explained that the letters are so exaggerated that they look more like shapes than letters.
Ms. Arndt stated that they could ask a hundred different people and get a hundred different points of
view. Ms. Arndt stated that she thought the design looked great, it is fun, it is modern, and she loved
the color choices. Ms. Arndt also liked that the Dover Public Library staff can fully customize this
design in any way without going back to the designer.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Sylvester stated that he reached out to Ms. Diane Laird, Director of the
Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) but had not heard back from her. Mr. Sylvester stated that he
would contact Ms. Tina Bradbury, DDP, regarding the banners in front of the library to ensure
cohesiveness with Mosaic’s Downtown Master Plan.
Mr. Neil stated that he is a fan and customer of the Dover Public Library. Mr. Neil stated that the
programs are phenomenal for kids and everyone that is there. Mr. Neil explained that there is space
available for things such as DDP will be there to show and tell for Mosaic. Mr. Neil stated that he
believes that when you have a great library if you are bringing in businesses and economic
development you can show them what Dover has. Mr. Neil stated that he was very proud of the library.
Page 90
Página 91
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 10, 2023 PAGE 9
Item #7.
Mr. Neil explained that sometimes you must change the feel or the look to kind of freshen it and give
excitement to the staff. Mr. Neil noted they are a great staff.
Committee action was not required.
Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Dover Public Library’s report. The motion was seconded
by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration
Committee meeting, hearing no objection, the meeting adjourned at 7:23 p.m.
Mr. Hare moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting. The motion
was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
The meeting adjourned at 7:23 p.m.
Roy Sudler, Jr.
Council President
RS/re
\\VMFILEPRINT\CityClerk\AGENDAS-MINUTES-PACKETS\Committee-Minutes\2023\01-
January\01-10-2023 CCW Minutes.docx
Page 91
Página 92
Item #15.
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: City Council
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Water & Wastewater SUBMITTED ON: January 13, 2023
PREPARED BY: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services
REVIEWED BY: David S. Hugg, III, City Manager and Lori Peddicord, Controller / Treasurer
SUBJECT: Community Reinvestment Funds – Project Allocation
TIMETABLE: Project Creation and Final Design to Begin within five (5) days of approval
RELATED PROJECT: X
REFERENCE: X
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $0
AMOUNT BUDGETED: N/A
FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Accept the $3M from the Community Reinvestment Fund and approve the project allocation plan.
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:
On or around July 8, 2022, the City of Dover was notified that we would be receiving $3M from the State
of Delaware Community Reinvestment Fund (CRF). This is a capital grant program to be used for
community redevelopment, revitalization and investment. The title of our award was Water, Wastewater
and Public Works Repair and Replacement Infrastructure Project. Due to the fact the $3M could not fully
revitalize any specific community, the city decided to utilize the funds with the following projects:
North State Street Water Main Replacement Project. Due to the state of inflation with
construction projects, this project was underfunded, utilizing the CRF will allow this project to be
completed. ($904,100)
Inflow and Infiltration Repair. The city recently completed a large-scale evaluation of our
sanitary sewer mains and manholes. The report provided several locations throughout the city that
required rehabilitation. The total amount of pipe relined will be approximately 2,600 linear feet
and this project will rehabilitate 52 manholes. The repairs will decrease the infiltration into our
infrastructure and increase the structural condition of the sewer pipes and manholes. ($910,900)
Street and Alley Program. The city originally budgeted six (6) streets / alleys to be rehabilitated
in FY23. Unfortunately, the current economic state only allowed three (3) streets / alleys to be
worked on with our original budget. This project would rehabilitate Buckson Street, Carvel Drive
and Ross Street. ($1,185,000)
Page 92
Página 93
Item #15.
The city provided these plans to the State of Delaware after we were awarded the funds and the
Controller General’s Office had no objection to the allocation of funds. The advantage of these
projects are they are at least ready to be bid out for construction.
Staff recommends accepting the $3M and utilizing this funding plan to improve the water, wastewater,
and street infrastructure within the city.
Page 93
Página 94
Exhibit A Item #15.
North State Street
Water Main Replacement
e
mb ia Av
e
Colu
venu
an A
eric
d
N Am
woo
Lake
Pl
Ext
St
ison
Mad
ania
sylv
t
am S
Penn e Ext
Willi
Rd
Av
ney
Rod
St
ton
r hing
adfo
Was
N Br Clar
a St
d St
l Rd
Haze
N St
N Go Ave
l and
t Mary
ate S
or
vern
e
s Av St
th
Smi
St
Mary
w St
N Ne e
a Av
vani
N Qu
nsyl
Pen
St
een
e
n Av
erica
N Am ware
Ave
e
Dela t Av
Ken
il St
Cec le L
Map
t
n
od S
rkwo
N Ki
y
s Hw
t King
on S
Fult n St
visio
E Di n
Pen
Ave
an
eric
S Am v e
t
Source:ion S ate
Esri, Maxar, GeoEye, Earthstar Geographics, CNES/Airbus DS,
S St
Divis
WUSDA, St A
USGS, AeroGRID, IGN, and the GIS User Community
0 150 300 Feet
Date Printed: March 30, 2022
File: M:\WW_DATA\TwinkleMXD\NorthStateStreetExhibit/Exhibit
¯
Legend
Department: Water & Wastewater
City of Dover, Delaware Exhibit
Dover Parcels
Page 94
Página 95
Exhibit B Item #15.
Inflow & Infiltration
for the City of Dover
!
.
!
.
!
.
.!
!.!
.
!
. !
.
!
.!
.
!
. !
.
!
. !
.!
.!
.
!
.
.!
.!
! .!
.
!
..!
.!
!
.
. !
! .
!
. !
.
!
.
!
. !
. !
.
!
.
!
. !
.
!
. !.
!
.!
. !
.
!
. !
.
!
.
!
. !
.
!
.
! !
.
. !
.
Source: Esri, Maxar, GeoEye, Earthstar Geographics, CNES/Airbus DS,
USDA, USGS, AeroGRID, IGN, and the GIS User Community
0 0.25 0.5 Miles
Date Printed: January 12, 2023
¯
File: M:\WW_DATA\TwinkleMXD/I&ITable/I&I_pipes_manholes_exhibit
Legend
Department: Water & Wastewater
. I&I Sewer Manholes to be Rehabilitated
!
City of Dover, Delaware I&I Sewer Pipes to be Rehabilitated
Page 95
Página 96
Exhibit C
Item #15.
Page 96
Página 97
Item #15.
Page 97
Página 98
Item #15.
Page 98
Página 99
Item #16.
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: City Council
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Water & Wastewater SUBMITTED ON: January 13, 2023
PREPARED BY: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services
REVIEWED BY: David S. Hugg, III, City Manager and Lori Peddicord, Controller / Treasurer
SUBJECT: Well #9 Change Order
TIMETABLE: Notice to proceed to be issued within two (2) days of Council approval. Project
anticipated to be completed in sixty (60) calendar days.
RELATED PROJECT: X
REFERENCE: X
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $19,500
BUDGET REMAINING: $225,800
FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): Department of Water & Wastewater – Water
Management, CIP Project #WD2304 CIP
Name: Well #9 Improvements Account No.:
210-10-99-99-000-54031.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Approve change order request from AECOM, Inc. in the amount of $19,500, in accordance with the
City of Dover Purchasing Policy & Procedures.
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:
Per the City of Dover Purchasing Policy & Procedures, section 3.11.B, the City Manager and
Controller/Treasurer are authorized to approve change orders that are within fifteen percent (15%) of the
originally approved contract. This project involves the design to improve the existing Well #9, which is
currently located within a flood plain. The original agreement with AECOM, Inc. was in the amount of
$79,500. The proposed change order, in the amount of $19,500 is greater than fifteen percent (15%) of
the original contract. This change order includes additional soil borings and geotechnical investigation
for the future structure that will be built for this well. In addition, plumbing code requires upgrades to a
building when certain remodeling takes place. The change order includes the necessary design to upgrade
the existing plumbing fixtures to meet code.
City staff has reviewed the proposed change order and finds the proposal fair and reasonable. Staff
recommends awarding change order to AECOM, Inc. in the amount of $19,500 for the required design
changes for the project.
Page 99
Página 100
Item #17.
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
First Reading before the
Dover City Council
January 23, 2023
MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
Review of a series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as amended. The
Amendments include consideration of the following as associated with Annexation Application
AX-23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road: requests for
amendment of Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the Annexation Plan category of
two properties and requests for amendment of Map 13-2: Potential Land Uses for Annexation
Areas to identify the Land Use Classification of two properties.
These Requests for Amendment of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan were submitted by the
property owners as associated with the City of Dover’s annual opportunity to request
Comprehensive Plan Amendments (see Chapter 15: Implementation Plan). Only the
Comprehensive Plan Amendments are being considered at this time; the associated Annexation
Application AX-23-01 will have a separate review process.
A. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan Map -
Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside
Drive to revise the Annexation Plan category from Area of Concern and unidentified area
to Category 2: Priority Annexation Area on Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Plan
Map. (Planning Reference: MI-23-01A)
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-
Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road
Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC
Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-1 –Annexation Plan Category: None
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-1 Annexation Plan Category:
Category 2 – Priority Annexation Area
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-
Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road
Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC
Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-1 –Annexation Plan Category: Area of Concern
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-1 Annexation Plan Category:
Category 2 – Priority Annexation Area
Page 100
Página 101
Item #17.
MI-23-01– Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023
First Reading Report to City Council for January 23, 20223
Page 2
B. Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas
Map - Request for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of
Bayside Drive to identify the Land Use Classification as Public & Private Utilities on
Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map. (Planning Reference: MI-23-
01B)
a. Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-
Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road
Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC
Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2 – Land Use Classification: None
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use Classification:
Public & Private Utilities
b. Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-
Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road
Property Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC
Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000
2019 Comprehensive Plan, Map 13-2: Land Use Classification: None
Proposed Comprehensive Plan Designation, Map 13-2 Land Use Classification:
Public & Private Utilities
Attachments:
• Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas (Current Map in 2019 Comprehensive Plan)
• MI-23-01A Comprehensive Plan Amendment Request Locations on Map 13-1
• MI-23-01A Comprehensive Plan Amendments on Map 13-1: Current Designation &
Proposed Designation of Annexation Area Category
• Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas (Current Map in 2019
Comprehensive Plan)
• MI-23-01B Comprehensive Plan Amendment Request Locations on Map 13-2
• MI-23-01B Comprehensive Plan Amendments on Map 13-2: Current Designation &
Proposed Designation of Potential Land Use Classifications
• Proposed Ordinance #2023-01
Page 101
Página 102
Item #17.
City of Dover, DE 2019 Comprehensive Plan
File: M:\PS_DATA\2018_Comp_Plan_Draft_Maps\Comp_Plan_2018_FINAL_MXDS\Map 13-1 Potential Annexation Areas.mxd
Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas As Adopted on January 13, 2020
0 2,500
LEGEND
5,000 Feet
¯
Dover Boundary
Municipal Boundaries
Roads
Hydrology
Water Bodies
2019 Annexation Plan
Category
Category 1 - High Priority
Category 2 - Priority
Category 3 - Long Term Annexation
Areas of Concern
0 3,000 6,000 Feet
Inset Map
PAPER MAP DISCLAIMER:
By acceptance of this map material you agree to the following: This map material is
made available by the City of Dover, Delaware as a public service. The material is for
reference purposes only, and the City makes no warranty, re presentation, or guaranty as
to the accuracy of the material, including its accuracy, availability, use, and misuse. In
no event shall the City be liable for any direct or indirect damages suffered by the
Recipient or others arising from any inadequacies of the digital data or the Recipient's
use of this data. The material is in the public domain and may be copied without
permission. Citation to the source would be appreciated. Any errors or omissions in the
material should be reported to the City of Dover, Delaware's Public Works GIS Page 102
Division.
Página 103
MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2023 Request Locations
Item #17.
File: I:\DAC\2023 Applications\MI-23-01 Comp Plan Amendment
- Annexation Calpine\MI-23-01 Mapping\Map 13-1_Potential
(City of Dover, DE 2019 Comprehensive Plan) Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas Request Date: 12/15/2022
0 3,000
LEGEND
Hydrology
6,000 Feet
¯ Proposed Amendment Area
on White Oak Road
Water Bodies
Roads
Municipal Boundaries
Dover Boundary
2019 Annexation Plan
Category
Category 1 - High Priority
Category 2 - Priority
Category 3 - Long Term Annexation
Areas of Concern
0 4,000 8,000 Feet
Inset Map
PAPER MAP DISCLAIMER:
By acceptance of this map material you agree to the following: This map material is
made available by the City of Dover, Delaware as a public service. The material is for
reference purposes only, and the City makes no warranty, re presentation, or guaranty as
to the accuracy of the material, including its accuracy, availability, use, and misuse. In
no event shall the City be liable for any direct or indirect damages suffered by the
Recipient or others arising from any inadequacies of the digital data or the Recipient's
use of this data. The material is in the public domain and may be copied without
permission. Citation to the source would be appreciated. Any errors or omissions in the
material should be reported to the City of Dover, Delaware's Public Works GIS Page 103
Division.
Página 104
City of Dover MI-23-01A
Item #17.
Department of Planning & Inspections 2023 Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Current Designation Proposed Designation
File: MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2023
Potential Annexation Areas Dover Parcels
Location: 3015 White Oak Road & unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road Category Kent County Parcels
Plan Type: Comprehensive Plan Amendment A
«
Category 1 - High Priority Dover Boundary
Current Annexation Area: Area of Concern and unidentified area
Proposed Annexation: Category 2: Priority Annexation Area Category 2 - Priority
Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC Category 3 - Long Term Annexation
Date: 1/5/2023 Page 104
0 800 1,600 3,200 Feet
Areas of Concern
Página 105
Item #17.
City of Dover, DE 2019 Comprehensive Plan
File: M:\PS_DATA\2018_Comp_Plan_Draft_Maps\Comp_Plan_2018_FINAL_MXDS\Map 13-2 Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas.mxd
Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas As Adopted on January 13, 2020
0 2,500
LEGEND
Dover Boundary
5,000 Feet
¯
Municipal Boundaries
Roads
Hydrology
Water Bodies
2019 Annexation Areas Land Use
Agriculture
Commercial Entertainment
Commercial High Intensity
Commercial Low Intensity
Industrial
Mixed Use
Office and Office Park
Open Space
Residential Low Density
Residential Medium Density
Right-Of-Way
0 3,000 6,000 Feet
Inset Map
PAPER MAP DISCLAIMER:
By acceptance of this map material you agree to the following: This map material is
made available by the City of Dover, Delaware as a public service. The material is for
reference purposes only, and the City makes no warranty, re presentation, or guaranty as
to the accuracy of the material, including its accuracy, availability, use, and misuse. In
no event shall the City be liable for any direct or indirect damages suffered by the
Recipient or others arising from any inadequacies of the digital data or the Recipient's
use of this data. The material is in the public domain and may be copied without
permission. Citation to the source would be appreciated. Any errors or omissions in the
material should be reported to the City of Dover, Delaware's Public Works GIS Page 105
Division.
Página 106
File: M:\PS_DATA\2018_Comp_Plan_Draft_Maps\Comp_Plan_2018_FINAL_MXDS\Map 13-2 Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas.mxd
MI-23-01 Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2023 Request Locations
Item #17.
(City of Dover, DE 2019 Comprehensive Plan) Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Request Date: 12/15/2022
0 2,500
Dover Boundary
LEGEND
Municipal Boundaries
5,000 Feet
¯ Proposed Amendment Area
on White Oak Road
Roads
Hydrology
Water Bodies
2019 Annexation Areas Land Use
Agriculture
Commercial Entertainment
Commercial High Intensity
Commercial Low Intensity
Industrial
Mixed Use
Office and Office Park
Open Space
Residential Low Density
Residential Medium Density
Right-Of-Way
Public and Private Utilities
0 3,000 6,000 Feet
Inset Map
PAPER MAP DISCLAIMER:
By acceptance of this map material you agree to the following: This map material is
made available by the City of Dover, Delaware as a public service. The material is for
reference purposes only, and the City makes no warranty, re presentation, or guaranty as
to the accuracy of the material, including its accuracy, availability, use, and misuse. In
no event shall the City be liable for any direct or indirect damages suffered by the
Recipient or others arising from any inadequacies of the digital data or the Recipient's
use of this data. The material is in the public domain and may be copied without
permission. Citation to the source would be appreciated. Any errors or omissions in the
material should be reported to the City of Dover, Delaware's Public Works GIS Page 106
Division.
Página 107
City of Dover MI-23-01B
Item #17.
Department of Planning & Inspections 2023 Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Current Designation Proposed Designation
Site Site
File: MI-23-01B Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023 Legend
Location: 3015 White Oak Road & unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road Dover Parcels Commercial High Intensity Open Space
Plan Type: Comprehensive Plan Amendment B
«
Dover Boundary Commercial Low Intensity Residential Low Density
Current Land Use: None
Proposed Land Use Classifcation: Public & Private Utilities Public and Private Utilities Industrial Residential Medium Density
Owners: Calpine Holdings LLC Agriculture Mixed Use Right-Of-Way
Date: 1/5/2023 0 625 1,250 2,500 Feet Commercial Entertainment Office and Office Park
Page 107
Página 108
Item #17.
City of Dover
FIRST READING
CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE #2023-01
1 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN BY AMENDING MAP 13-
2 1: BY CHANGING THE ANNEXATION PLAN CATEGORY AND BY AMENDING MAP 13-2:
3 BY IDENTIFYING THE LAND USE CLASSIFICATION OF TWO PROPERTIES LOCATED
4 ON WHITE OAK ROAD.
5
6 WHEREAS, the City of Dover has adopted a Comprehensive Plan laying out land use policies within the
7 City of Dover, Delaware; and
8
9 WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Dover, on January 13, 2020, following the recommendation
10 of the City of Dover Planning Commission, adopted the 2019 Comprehensive Plan pursuant to Title 22,
11 Section 702 of the Delaware Code; and
12
13 WHEREAS, the Honorable John Carney, Governor of the State of Delaware, certified the 2019
14 Comprehensive Plan to be effective as of January 13, 2020, by letter of March 10, 2020; and
15
16 WHEREAS, the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 15 – Implementation Plan allows for an annual
17 amendment process; and
18
19 WHEREAS, a property owner of two properties has requested amendments to the Potential Annexation
20 Areas Map (Map 13-1) and requested amendments to the Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map
21 (Map 13-2) in accordance with the process set forth in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan; and
22
23 WHEREAS, the Planning Office has prepared these amendments to the Potential Annexation Areas Map
24 (Map 13-1) and to the Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map (Map 13-2) for review as part of the
25 Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2023; and
26
27 WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on February 21, 2023, after which the
28 Planning Commission made a recommendation in regard to these amendments to the Annexation Plan
29 (Map 13-1 and Map 13-2) related to the two properties.
30
31 WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of future development, zoning, and planning in the City of
32 Dover to change the Annexation Plan Category and associated Land Use Classification of the two
33 properties on the Potential Annexation Areas Map (Map 13-1) and on the Potential Land Use for
34 Annexation Areas Map (Map 13-2) as described below.
35
36 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
37 DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET AND AMEND THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN BY:
38
39 That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance, that Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
40 Plan Map of the City of Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan has been amended by changing the designated
41 Annexation Plan Category from an unidentified area and from an Area of Concern to Category 2: Priority
42 Annexation Area for two parcels located on the north side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside Drive
P.O. Box 475 ❖ Dover, Delaware ❖19903
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Page 108
Página 109
Proposed Ordinance #2023-01: Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
Item #17.
Plan Map and to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map, 2019 Comprehensive Plan
(MI-23-01A and MI-23-01B: Two Properties on White Oak Road) Page 2
43 known as an unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road and as 3015 White Oak Road. The properties are
44 more fully described below. (Planning Reference: MI-23-01A)
45
46 Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road. Property
47 Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000.
48
49 Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine
50 Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
51
52 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
53 DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET AND AMEND THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN BY:
54
55 That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance, that Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for
56 Annexation Areas Plan Map of the City of Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan has been amended by
57 identifying the Land Use Classification as Public & Private Utilities for two parcels located on the north
58 side of White Oak Road and west of Bayside Drive known as an unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road
59 and as 3015 White Oak Road. The properties are more fully described below. (Planning Reference: MI-
60 23-01B)
61
62 Property Area: 144.83 acres +/-. Property Address: unaddressed parcel near White Oak Road. Property
63 Owner: Calpine Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-49.00-000.
64
65 Property Area: 104.06 acres +/-. Property Address: 3015 White Oak Road. Property Owner: Calpine
66 Holdings, LLC. Tax Parcel: LC-00-058.00-02-48.00-000.
67
68 BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
69
70 That upon final action to adopt this ordinance, the amendments as approved changing the designated
71 Annexation Plan Category of the two properties shall be made to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
72 Map and the amendments as approved identifying the Land Use Classification of the two properties shall
73 be made to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Plan Map of the 2019 Comprehensive
74 Plan.
75
76 ADOPTED: *
77
78 \\VMFILEPRINT\CityClerk\ORDINANCES\2023\DRAFT\2023-01-COMP PLAN AMENDMENTS MI-23-01A & MI-23-
79 01B (White Oak Road)\ORDINANCE 2023-01 COMP PLAN AMENDMENTS MI-23-01 FIRST READING.docx
80
81
82 SYNOPSIS
83 The proposed ordinance would adopt a series of Amendments to the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, as
84 amended. The Amendments include consideration of the following as associated with a future Annexation
85 Application AX-23-01 Lands of Calpine Holdings, LLC – Two Properties on White Oak Road: requests
86 for amendment of Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas to revise the Annexation Plan category of two
87 properties and requests for amendment of Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas to identify
88 the Land Use Classification of two properties. The specific properties are an unaddressed parcel on the
P.O. Box 475 ❖ Dover, Delaware ❖19903
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Page 109
Página 110
Proposed Ordinance #2023-01: Consideration of Amendments to Map 13-1: Potential Annexation Areas
Item #17.
Plan Map and to Map 13-2: Potential Land Use for Annexation Areas Map, 2019 Comprehensive Plan
(MI-23-01A and MI-23-01B: Two Properties on White Oak Road) Page 3
89 north side of White Oak Road and 3015 White Oak Road. (Planning Reference: MI-23-01A and MI-23-
90 01B)
91
92 Actions History:
93 03/13/2023 – Public Hearing/Final Reading - City Council
94 02/21/2023 – Public Hearing & Action - Planning Commission
95 01/23/2023 – First Reading – City Council
P.O. Box 475 ❖ Dover, Delaware ❖19903
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Page 110