Página 1
CITY OF DOVER
Fiscal Year 2004/05 Capital Investments Plan
¾ The CIP is a five-year plan for capital projects whose value is $10,000 or greater.
Projects in the first year of the five-year CIP are included in the operating budget.
The sections of the CIP are as follows:
¾ Project Development – all funds
¾ General Fund projects
¾ Electric Fund projects
¾ Water/Wastewater Fund projects
¾ Vehicle Replacements – all funds
¾ The Project Development category contains projects in the concept phase. This
category serves as a "bookmark" until the project has been fully scoped with respect to
need, cost, timeline, and priority.
Página 2
CITY OF DOVER
What Is New with the Fiscal Year 2004/05 CIP
¾ A Project Number has been or will be assigned to each project. This allows for
better internal tracking. Equipment purchases will not receive a project number as
they have in previous years.
¾ The financing section for projects has been re-formatted and now includes a “Prior to
2005” and “After 2009” columns. This change provides consistency in formatting
among the Financing, Impact on Operating Budget, and Five-Year Cost Breakdown
Schedule.
¾ There are 23 new projects in the five-year CIP, 16 of which are in Fiscal Year
2004/05.
¾ There are two dropped projects in the five-year CIP, one of which is in Fiscal Year
2004/05.
Página 3
Status of Fiscal Year 2003/04 CIP Projects
All 2003/04 vehicle purchases have been completed. Of the 50 CIP projects in the 2003/04 CIP,
17 are complete and 21 are on track.
The status of the 12 remaining is as follows:
C Hanson House Preservation Program – going out to bid this week; completion in fall 2004
C Police Heating/Ventilation/Air Conditioning Computer System Upgrade – proposal for rescheduling
C U.S. 13 East Sanitary Sewer Interceptor – deferred to 2004/05 CIP
C Puncheon Run Motor Control and Pump Replacement – design completed; project deferred to 2004/05
and 2005/06
C Walker Road Pump Station Upgrade – design completed; completion in fall 2004
C Water System Master Plan Update – project has been started; completion in summer 2004
C Division Street Water Main Upgrade – project has been started; completion in fall 2004
C 230 KV Tie with Conectiv – project has been started; completion in summer 2004
C Replace CAMA Tax Software – project will be completed in summer 2004
C North Dover Athletic Complex, Pool – dropped
C Police Server Upgrade for CAD/RMS – dropped; pursuing a grant for 2004/05
C North State St./Rt. 13 Wire replacement -- dropped
Página 4
CITY OF DOVER
TOTAL CITY REVENUE SUMMARY
2005 CIP VERSUS 2004 CIP
Prepared as of 05/10/04
Revenue Requirement Proposed Budget
Fund 2004/05 2003/04 Difference
General Fund $1,467,325 $1,173,497 $293,828
Community Transportation Fund 500,000 500,000 0
Transportation Enhancement Grant 0 216,000 (216,000)
Water/Wastewater Fund 1,138,130 2,019,065 (880,935)
Bond Financing 1,175,000 0 1,175,000
Electric Improvement and Extension Fund 2,064,476 10,696,244 (8,631,768)
State Grant 247,000 280,000 (33,000)
Other (Preservation DE, Calvary Baptist 0 2,005,000 (2,005,000)
Church, Wilmington College, Duke)
Parkland Fund 0 20,000 (20,000)
Federal Grant 545,000 170,000 375,000
Impact Fee Reserve 75,000 175,000 (100,000)
State Reimbursement 0 198,958 (198,958)
Total Revenue Requirement for FY 2004/05 $7,211,931 $17,453,764 $10,241,833
Página 5
CITY OF DOVER
NEW PROJECTS INTRODUCED FOR FISCAL YEAR 2005
Prepared as of 05/10/04
PROJECT TOTAL PROJECT
COST FOR FY 2005
General
Fire
Replacement of Utility Vehicle $37,000
Information Technology
Information Technology Long Range Plan Implementation 185,000
Wireless Networking 18,925
Parks and Recreation
Dover Park Enhancement (State Match) 60,000
Mayfair Park Playground 20,000
St. Jones River Multi-Use Trail and Bridge Replacement 117,000
Richardson Park Fence Replacement 15,000
$452,925
Water/Wastewater
Inflow/Infiltration Removal $75,000
Cast Iron Main Replacement/Lining 50,000
$125,000
Página 6
CITY OF DOVER
NEW PROJECTS INTRODUCED FOR FISCAL YEAR 2005
Prepared as of 05/10/04
(continued)
PROJECT TOTAL PROJECT
COST FOR FY 2005
Electric
Electric Administration Building UPS $23,000
Electric Department Relay Test Set 60,000
Printer/Plotter 19,576
Pole Inventory System 160,000
Outage Reporting System 35,000
PTW Power Supply System Analysis Software 23,000
Radio Read Meter Change Out 195,000
Heart Start ADS 27,000
$542,576
Vehicles
Police - #244, 2005 Ford Crown Victoria $25,118
Police - #272, 2005 Ford Econoline Van 17,313
Electric T&D - #759, 2005 40' Bucket Truck 86,000
Electric T&D - #794, 2005 3/4-Ton 4x4 Pick-Up 20,000
$148,431
Página 7
CITY OF DOVER
PROJECTS DELETED OR DEFERRED BY BUDGET TEAM FOR FISCAL YEAR 2005 CIP
Prepared as of 05/10/04
Category Project Amount Description Reason
General Integrated Credit Card Processing $18,490 Deleted Will be completed by in-house staff.
Westside Recreation Center 1,300,000 Deferred Deferred for further planning and to
develop a financial strategy.
Branch Library 1,140,000 Deferred Deferred for further planning and to
develop a financial strategy.
5 East Reed Street Parking Lot Rehabilitation 45,000 Deleted Incorporated into the 2005 Street
Program.
Subtotal $2,503,490
Water Dupont Manor Commercial District Water System Expansion $25,000 Deferred Deferred due to resource limitations.
Southwest Water Loop 200,000 Deferred Deferred due to resource limitations.
Subtotal $225,000
Electric Mayfair to Mid City $650,000 Deferred Deferred due to resource limitations.
Replacement of 69 KV Breakers 300,000 Deferred Deferred due to resource limitations.
Kesslering Feeder 135,879 Deferred Deferred due to resource limitations.
System Operations Automation 38,000 Deferred Deferred due to resource limitations.
Subtotal $1,123,879
Página 8
CITY OF DOVER
PROJECTS DELETED OR DEFERRED BY BUDGET TEAM FOR FISCAL YEAR 2005 CIP
Prepared as of 05/10/04
(continued)
Category Project Amount Description Reason
Vehicles Grounds - #555, Truck $16,000 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Grounds - #552, 1-Ton Truck 32,899 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Planning/Inspections - #3, Auto 16,000 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Sanitation - #445, Rear Loader 92,000 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Sanitation - #452, Rear Loader 110,000 Deferred Deferred after discussion with Department.
Streets - #319, Case Backhoe 65,000 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Streets - #326, Dump Truck 75,000 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Wastewater - #692, Vacuum Truck 215,000 Deferred Deferred after discussion with Department.
Meter Reading - #154, Truck 16,000 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Electric Eng. - #790, Truck 16,637 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Electric Eng. - #9, Truck 16,637 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Electric Eng. - #7, Auto 14,127 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Electric Eng. - #785, Truck 13,648 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Electric Eng. - #749, Truck 20,951 Deferred Deferred due to condition of equipment.
Subtotal $719,899
Total $4,572,268 $63,490 was deleted; $4,508,778 was deferred.
Página 9
City of Dover
2004/05 Budget Presentation
• Budget Cycle
• Family of Funds
• Budget Environment and Challenges
• Carry Forward Goals
• General Fund
• Water/Wastewater Fund
• Electric Fund
• Pay-for-Performance
Página 10
The Budget Cycle
Strategic
Mayor & Organization Annual Budget
Council’s Plan Goals & 1 yr. Operating Implementation
Priorities Objectives 1 yr. Capital Exp.
Review
Current year CIP
Out years CIP 5-Year CIP
Reviewed
Reporting
progress
through
monthly and
annual reports
Página 11
Dover Family of Funds
ELECTRIC GENERAL WATER/WASTEWATER
FUNDS FUNDS FUNDS
OPERATING OPERATING OPERATING
FUND FUND FUND
Contingency Contingency Contingency
For a "rainy day" emergency For a "rainy day" emergency For a "rainy day" emergency
Improvement and Extension Capital Assets Reserve Improvement and Extension
Financing of system expansion Replacement and expansion Financing of system expansion
and improvement (i.e., infrastructure, buildings, etc.) and improvement
Depreciation Reserve Capital Assets Reserve
Replenishment of Replacement and expansion
assets (i.e., infrastructure, buildings, etc.)
Future Capacity
Financing for system capacity
expansion
Insurance Stabilization
Funding of the insurance
deductibles
Rate Stabilization
Funding to offset cost of power
cost adjustment
Página 12
Budget Environment
External
• National economic environment shows signs of recovery, but
not as favorable as in the mid to late 1990s
• Less grants from Federal and State budgets
• This economy means interest income is still low
• Poor performance for pension plan results in increased pension
contribution cost for the City
• High cost of medical care creates upward pressure on health
benefit (retirees and employees)
• GASB rules will soon require funding of our post-retirement
benefits. Estimated expense equals $1.9 million per year. We
have funded $900,000.
Página 13
Budget Environment
(continued)
Internal
• Financial policy requires maintenance of carry forward
balances, prohibits deficit spending
• Continued vehicle lease payment ($345,378 annually) from
Fiscal Year 2001/02
• Major water consumer reducing water consumption
processes
• Brown water issue
• Increased costs to Kent County for wastewater treatment
-- inflow infiltration
-- corrected metering at Kent County Pump Station #3
• Increased purchase power costs per D/FD contract
Página 14
Budget Challenges
Pension
FY 2004 Revised FY 2005
• General Pension Rate 14.60% 21.52%
• Pension Costs City-wide $1,832,851 $2,448,910
Página 15
Budget Challenges
(continued)
Healthcare Costs
FY 2004 Revised FY 2005
• Increase City-wide 15.50% 13-15%
• Healthcare Costs City-wide $2,055,927 $2,518,804
Página 16
Budget Challenges
(continued)
2004 Budget 2004 Rev. 2005 Proj.
• Kent County Treatment Chg. $2.9 million $3.7 million $3.6 million
• Purchase Power – DLD $38.6 million $37.4 million $40.5 million
• Street Lights charged to Gen. Fund $0 $460,000 $460,000
Página 17
This Budget Accomplishes...
• No reduction in programs or services
• No property tax increase
• No increase in basic electric rates
• No trash fee increase
How Do We Accomplish This?
• New revenue sources for the General Fund
– Civil Traffic Penalties
– Court of Chancery Fees
• Budget Team cut budget requests by $720,225
• Adjust Purchase Power Cost Adjustment to electric rate
• Allowable fund transfers eight percent of Electric and Water/
Wastewater Fund revenues
• Eliminated the declining block rate structure for water - $110,000
• Increased the Wastewater rate by $.25 - $389,000
Página 18
Fiscal Year - 2003/04 Carry Forward
Carry forward meets requirement!
Original Proposed Estimate
• General Fund $ 1,654,816 $ 2,644,445
• Water/Wastewater Fund $ 1,609,194 $ 969,422
• Electric Fund $ 2,876,612 $ 3,971,444
Página 19
General Fund
Top Revenue Streams
• Property Tax $7,396,454
• Electric Enterprise Fund Transfer $5,463,008
• Intrafund Service Receipts Electric $3,698,655
• Business Licenses and Permits $1,953,900
• Transfer Tax $1,400,000
• Intrafund Service Receipts Water/WW $ 998,487
• Trash Fees $ 950,000
Top Expense Departments
• Police $9,663,425
• Sanitation $1,948,318
• Streets $1,199,936
• Administrative Services $1,024,773
• Facilities Management $ 993,020
• Information Technology $ 949,654
• Grounds Maintenance $ 938,038
• Library $ 931,406
Página 20
2004/05 Top Five CIP Projects
Name Dollars Fund
1. Street and Alley $850,000 General Fund, Community
Program Transportation Fund
2. Police Radio System $375,000 Federal Grant
Upgrade
3. Annual Contributions to $253,000 General Fund
Robbins Hose Co.
4. Police Server Upgrade $200,000 General Fund,
for CAD/RMS Federal Grant
5. Information Technology $185,000 General Fund
Long Range Plan
Implementation
Página 21
General Fund Trend Data
Property Taxes
8 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
7,50 0 ,0 0 0
7,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
6 ,50 0 ,0 0 0
6 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
5,50 0 ,0 0 0
5,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
4 ,50 0 ,0 0 0
1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Página 22
General Fund Trend Data
Electric Fund Appropriation
6 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
5,50 0 ,0 0 0
5,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
4 ,50 0 ,0 0 0
4 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
3 ,50 0 ,0 0 0
3 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Página 23
General Fund Trend Data
Licenses and Permits
2 ,2 50 ,0 0 0
2 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
1,750 ,0 0 0
1,50 0 ,0 0 0
1,2 50 ,0 0 0
1,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Página 24
General Fund Trend Data
Percentage of Licenses to General Fund
11.0 0 %
10 .0 0 %
9 .0 0 %
8 .0 0 %
7.0 0 %
6 .0 0 %
5.0 0 %
4 .0 0 %
3 .0 0 %
2 .0 0 %
1.0 0 %
0 .0 0 %
1 9 93 1 9 94 1 99 5 1 99 6 19 9 7 1 9 98 1 99 9 2 00 0 20 0 1 20 0 2 2 00 3 20 04 20 0 5
Página 25
General Fund Trend Data
Municipal Street Aid
9 0 0 ,0 0 0
8 0 0 ,0 0 0
70 0 ,0 0 0
6 0 0 ,0 0 0
50 0 ,0 0 0
4 0 0 ,0 0 0
3 0 0 ,0 0 0
1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Página 26
General Fund Trend Data
Transfer Tax
2 ,50 0 ,0 0 0
2 ,3 0 0 ,0 0 0
2 ,10 0 ,0 0 0
1,9 0 0 ,0 0 0
1,70 0 ,0 0 0
1,50 0 ,0 0 0
1,3 0 0 ,0 0 0
1,10 0 ,0 0 0
9 0 0 ,0 0 0
70 0 ,0 0 0
50 0 ,0 0 0
1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Página 27
General Fund Trend Data
Sanitation Fees
1,3 0 0 ,0 0 0
1,10 0 ,0 0 0
9 0 0 ,0 0 0
70 0 ,0 0 0
50 0 ,0 0 0
3 0 0 ,0 0 0
10 0 ,0 0 0
2 00 0 2 00 1 2 00 2 20 03 2 00 4 20 0 5
Página 28
Fiscal Year 2004/05 - General Fund
Revenue $30,211,628
Expense $27,606,772
Balance Carry Forward: $ 2,604,856 – 10.91% (Goal - 8%)
Revenue Includes
• $2,644,445 – Prior year balance
• $7,396,454 – Property tax
• $ 480,000 – Court of Chancery Fees
• $ 800,000 – Civil Traffic Penalties
• $ 848,016 – Appropriation - Water/Wastewater Fund
• $5,463,008 – Appropriation - Electric Fund
• $ 998,487 – Water Intrafund Service Fees
• $3,698,655 – Electric Intrafund Service Fees
Página 29
Fiscal Year 2004/05 - General Fund
(continued)
Expenses
• Includes Street Lights expense - $460,000
• Transfers $600,000 to Post Retirement Benefits Reserve
• Three new positions
– Assistant Finance Director
– Mechanic I
– GIS Coordinator
• Three percent increase for FOP bargaining unit
• $174,191 budgeted for zero-to-five percent increase for non-
bargaining employees
• No increase for IUE – contract has not been settled
• Excludes $369,949 in requests from General Fund departments
Página 30
Budget Adjustments
as of May 19, 2004
Fiscal Department
Year Description Department Ele/Obj Description Increase Decrease Overall
2004 110-1500-525 20-26 Program Expenses/Supplies 0 (7,350) 0
2004 Police 110-1700-541 40-28 Computer Hardware - HVAC 0 (18,500) 0
2004 Facilities 110-2500-552 40-31 City Hall Roof Repairs Construction - 0 (71,000) 0
Management deferred
2004 Central 110-2700-571 40-31 Central Services Roof Repairs 0 (45,000) 0
Services Construction - deferred
2004 Subtotal 0 (141,850) (141,850)
2005 Library 110-1500-523 20-32 Cameras 0 (9,999) 0
2005 Police 110-1700-543 10-99 Salary and Benefits 18,017 0 0
2005 Assessor 110-1300-513 30-31 Contractual Services 0 (63,750) 0
2005 Assessor 110-1300-513 30-44 Agency Billing/Temporary Help 12,000 0 0
2005 Facilities 110-2500-552 40-31 City Hall Roof Repairs Construction - 46,500 0 0
Management rebudgeted
2005 Central 110-2700-571 40-31 Central Svcs Roof Repairs Construction - 84,300 0 0
Services rebudgeted
2005 Subtotal 160,817 (73,749) 87,068
Total 160,817 (215,599) (54,782)
Página 31
Water/Wastewater Fund
Top Revenue Sources
• Water Fees $3,962,500
• Wastewater Fees $2,931,810
• Wastewater Adjustment Fees $2,788,875
• Impact Fees $ 665,000
• Water Tank Space Leasing $ 240,102
Top Expenses
• Kent County Treatment Charge $3,600,000
• Intrafund Service Fees $ 998,487
• Wastewater Debt Service $ 872,552
• Water Department $ 865,572
• Water Debt Service $ 748,259
• Wastewater Department $ 727,539
• Water Treatment Plant $ 611,556
Página 32
2004/05 Top Four CIP Projects
Name Dollars Fund
1. U.S. 13 East Sanitary $875,000 Bond Financing
Sewer Interceptor
2. Puncheon Run Motor $500,000 Water/Wastewater Fund
Control and Pump
Replacement
3. Division Street Water $300,000 Bond Financing
Main Upgrade
4. Walker Road Pump $158,000 Water/Wastewater Fund
Station Upgrade
Página 33
Fiscal Year 2004/05 - Water/Wastewater Fund
• Revenue $11,911,339
• Expense $10,275,428
• Balance Carry Forward: $ 1,635,911 – 14.95% (Goal - 10%)
Revenue Includes
• Elimination of the declining block rate structure for water - $110,000
• Increase of the Wastewater rate by $.25 - $389,000
Expenses
• Begins tentative implementation of Ten Point Plan to remedy brown water
• Begins five-year phase-out of Kent County wastewater deficit
• Transfers $100,000 to Post Retirement Medical Benefits Reserve
• Carry Forward meets requirement
• $848,016 to General Fund (transfer increase of $17,016)
• $11,715 in budget cuts
Página 34
Electric Fund
Top Revenue Sources
• Direct Sales to Customers $55,633,802
• Purchase Power Adjustment $ 4,934,544
• Utility Tax $ 1,182,367
• Miscellaneous Revenue $ 496,000
• Rent Revenue $ 170,885
• Interest Earnings $ 120,000
Top Expenses
• Purchase Power $40,555,237
• Transfer to General Fund $ 5,463,008
• Intrafund Service Fees $ 3,698,655
• Transmission and Distribution $ 2,963,771
• Debt Service $ 2,623,372
• Transfer to Future Capacity $ 2,000,000
• Electric Engineering $ 1,710,053
Página 35
2004/05 Top Five CIP Projects
Name Dollars Fund
1. New Developments/ $510,000 Improvement and
Upgrades Extension Fund
2. 69 KV - Vansant to $300,000 Improvement and
Mayfair Extension Fund
3. Whiteoak 69 KV $273,900 Improvement and
Rebuild Extension Fund
4. 4 KV to 12 KV $214,000 Improvement and
Upgrade Extension Fund
5. Distribution $200,000 Improvement and
Upgrades Extension Fund
Página 36
Fiscal Year 2004/05 - Electric Fund
• Revenue $66,509,042
• Expense $62,664,076
• Balance Carry Forward: $ 3,844,966 - 6.14% (Goal - 5%)
Revenue Includes
• $3.82/750 kWh increased power cost adjustment
• Represents the power cost increase in Duke agreement
– Represents a $45.84 annual increase for 750 kWh/month user
– Dover remains competitively priced within the market
Expenses
• Transfers $200,000 to Post Retirement Medical Benefits Reserve
• Includes $761,344 increase in appropriation to General Fund, $460,000 of
which is for Street Lights expense
• Includes two and one half percent increase for IBEW bargaining unit per
contract
• Adds new position of Engineering Fieldman
• Budgets overlapping salary for new Electric Director
• Excludes $338,561 in salary/operating expense requested for Electric
Página 40
City of Dover
City Assessor
Memo
To: Mayor and Council
From: Jerome Cooper, City Assessor
CC: City Manager, Finance Director
Date: May 18, 2004
Re: Budget revision for 2004-05 for Contractor Services
Listed below are the revised figures for the consultant services and administrative
help that will be required during the reassessment for the 2004-05 Tax Year. If you
have any questions, please contact me.
COST HOURS
Consultants Fee $150.00 400 60,000.00
Part-Time Employee (administrative) $15.00 800 12,000.00
Assessment of 50 largest
Commercial
Properties $325.00 50 16,250.00
TOTAL $88,250.00
1
Página 41
City of Dover
Pay-for-Performance
WHAT IS PAY FOR PERFORMANCE (P.F.P.)?
Pay-for-Performance is a system for awarding pay increases
to Non-Bargaining employees based on:
z Employee performance in reaching goals and objectives and their
performance in Core Competencies
z Employees position in the Pay Plan (Example: below market,
at market, above market)
z Salary increases based on Market Studies
Página 42
Pay-for-Performance
(continued)
Human Resources Director Recommendation
z Analysis of the Market Survey recommends:
z 3.5 percent Average Market increase for the
FY 05 and
z 1.0 percent Equity Adjustment because of a
lower-than-market increase in FY 04
(Here is why)
Página 43
Pay-for-Performance
(continued)
Market Analysis for Projected Increases
Fiscal Year 2004 Fiscal Year 2005
City of Dover, Non-Bargaining 2.0 percent increase 4.5 percent increase
(proposed)
Kent County 4.0 percent increase 4.0 percent increase
State of Delaware $500-$600 bonus 3.0 percent increase
(equates to 3-5 percent)
City of Newark 3.5 percent increase 3.5 percent increase
Ocean City, MD 2.5-6.5 percent (2.5 2.5-6.5 percent (2.5
percent COLA + up to 4.0 percent COLA + up to 4.0
percent increase Step) percent increase Step)
FOP 3.0 percent increase 3.0 percent increase
IBEW 3.0 percent increase 3.0 percent increase
Daily Labor Report - BNA 3.4 percent increase 3.4 percent increase
Página 44
Pay-for-Performance
(continued)
Market Analysis Also Proposes Increase in
Labor Grade Ranges by 3.2 percent
z Note:
z This is not added on top of the P.F.P. increase.
z It establishes the job ranges for new
employment.
z It determines whether current employees are
ranked below market, at market, or above
market.
Página 45
Pay-for-Performance
(continued)
The 4.5 percent market increase is applied to the
employee “At Market” who scored “Good.”
OVERALL SCORE ADJUSTMENT
Employee Employee Employee Employee
Below At Above Above
From To Market (1) Market (1) Market (1) Maximum
Unsatisfactory 10 15 0 0 0 0
Needs 16 25 0 0 0 0
Improvement
Good 26 35 4.75% 4.50% 4.25% 4.00%
Commendable 36 45 5.00% 4.75% 4.50% 4.00%
Outstanding 46 50 5.50% 5.00% 4.75% 4.00%
P.F.P Salary Calculation Worksheet – Adopted by City Council on _______________