Paj 1
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
AGENDA
October 11, 2010 - 7:30 P.M. - Council Chambers - City Hall - City of Dover
OPEN FORUM - 15 MINUTES PRIOR TO OFFICIAL MEETING (7:15 P.M.)
INVOCATION BY CHAPLAIN WALLACE DIXON
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE LED BY COUNCILWOMAN WILLIAMS
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
* CONSENT AGENDA
Those items on the Council Agenda which are considered routine and non-controversial shall be marked
with an asterisk (*) and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no
separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall
be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
* 1. Adoption of Minutes - Regular Council Meeting of September 27, 2010
2. Certificate of Congratulations - Dr. Harry Williams, President of Delaware State
University
3. Presentation - Mayor’s Arts Awards
4. Proclamations
A. Halloween Trick-or-Treat
B. Breast Cancer Awareness Month
* 5. Utility Committee Report - September 27, 2010
A. Delaware State University (DSU) Force Main Reroute
(Committee Recommended Approval of the Proposal Submitted by Eastern States
Construction Services, Inc., in the Amount of $240,300, for the Construction of the
Rerouting of the DSU/DTCC Force Main Rerouting and that the Finance Department Be
Authorized to Include the Additional Expenditure as a Change Order and a Part of the
Existing Loan Agreement Between the City of Dover and the Delaware Water Pollution
Control Revolving Loan Fund Program, as Recommended by Staff)
B. Commercial Recycling Fee
(Committee Recommended Authorization to Create a Special Billing Code and Implement
a Fee of $6.00 per Month per Container for Commercial Curbside Recycling for
Customers Who Do Not Have City of Dover Trash Collection Services)
Paj 2
Council Agenda - October 11, 2010 Page 2
* 5. Utility Committee Report - September 27, 2010 (CONTINUED)
C. Requests for Alley Abandonments (paper)
c-1. 18 Elm Terrace - Valerie Satterfield
(Committee Recommended Approval of the Alley Abandonment at 18 Elm Terrace,
Reserving a Utility Easement on the Property) (City Clerk's Note: In Accordance
with the City's Procedure for Alley Abandonments, Resolution No. 2010-11 Setting
the Public Hearing for Monday, October 25, 2010 at 7:30 P.M. is Presented to
Council for Consideration and Adoption)
c-2. Girl Scout Lane - Traci McDowell
(Committee Recommended Approval of the Abandonment of the Unimproved Lane
Adjacent to 80 and 100 Girl Scout Lane, Reserving a Utility Easement for Existing
Utilities) (City Clerk's Note: In Accordance with the City's Procedure for Alley
Abandonments, Resolution No. 2010-12 Setting the Public Hearing for Monday,
October 25, 2010 at 7:30 P.M. is Presented to Council for Consideration and
Adoption.)
D. Dedication of Rights-of-Way and Infrastructure - Susan Place
(Committee Recommended Acceptance of Dedication of Rights-of-Way and Public
Infrastructure for Susan Place, Including All of the Referenced Public Improvements)
E. Update - Green Energy Funding and Programming
(Committee Recommended Acceptance of the Update on the Green Energy Funding and
Programming)
F. Review of Utility Related CIP's (Electric and Water/Wastewater) (June)
(Committee Recommended Acceptance of the Utility Related CIP's Report)
G. PACE/NAES Monthly Report (June and July)
(Due to Time Constraints, this Item was Deferred by the Committee)
* 6. Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee Report - September 27, 2010
A. Review and Recommendation - Filling Critical Positions
(Committee Action Not Required)
B. Minority Procurement Program Policy
(Committee Recommended Approval of the Proposed Amendment to Section 3.4 of the
Purchasing Policy for Purchases in the Mid-range of $5,000.00 - $24,999.99 and
Appendix E of the Purchasing Policy)
7. Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee Report - September 29, 2010
A. Discussion - Manchester Square Safety Concerns
(Committee Recommended that the Manpower for the City of Dover Police Department Be
Increased to 100 and to Explore the Necessary Means of Raising the Revenues to See this
Accomplished)
* B. Waiver Request for Length of Dead-end Street (Cul-de-Sac) in Wynsome Oaks
Subdivision on White Oak Road
(Committee Recommended Approval of the Requested Waiver to Allow the Length of the
Dead End Street to Exceed 400 feet, as Recommended by the Planning Commission)
* C. Prioritization of Transportation Projects
(Committee Recommended the Establishment of New Priorities for Transportation Projects
as Recommended by Staff, with Priority #8 Becoming #1 and Priority #4 Becoming #2)
Paj 3
Council Agenda - October 11, 2010 Page 3
7. Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee Report - September 29, 2010
(CONTINUED)
* D. Briefing on Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT) Projects
(Committee Action Not Required)
* E. Briefing on Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) Projects
(Committee Action Not Required)
* 8. Monthly Reports - August 2010
A. Budget Report
B. Chief of Police Report
C. City Assessor’s Report
D. City Manager’s Report
E. City Planner’s Report
F. Dover Fire Department Report
9. Tentative Labor Contract with IUE-CWA 88315
10. Permanent Easement Agreement with DelDOT for Access and Maintenance Agreement
of Lands Located West of Garrison Farm Property Parcel (LC-05-068.00-01.01)
11. Authorization to Purchase City of Dover Defining and Information Pages in the Kent
County Delaware 2011 Profile
12. Evaluation of Bids - Payroll, Timekeeping, and Human Resources Services Contract
13. Final Reading - Proposed Ordinance #2010-26
The First Reading of the following proposed ordinance was accomplished during the
Council Meeting of September 27, 2010. Copies of the proposed ordinance are available
at the entrance of the Council Chambers.
A. FY 2011 Budget Amendment - Project Budgets
14. Council Members Announcements
/tm
S:\AGENDAS & MINUTES\Council-Agendas\2010\10-11-2010.wpd
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO
CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS.
Paj 4
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular Council Meeting was held on September 27, 2010 at 7:30 p.m. with Council President
Hogan presiding. Council members present were Mr. Bonar, Mrs. Russell, Mr. McGlumphy,
Mr. Leary, Mr. McGiffin, Mr. Salters, and Mr. Ruane. Mrs. Williams was absent.
Council staff members present were Police Chief Hosfelt, Mrs. Mitchell, Mrs. Townshend,
Mr. DePrima, City Solicitor Rodriguez, and Mrs. McDowell. Mayor Carey was also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 7:15 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting.
Council President Hogan declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that
Council is not in official session and cannot take formal action.
Mr. Eric O’Brien, 30 N. New Street, read a statement into the record in regards to Property
Reassessments (Exhibit #1).
The invocation was given by Chaplain Dixon, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
Mr. McGlumphy moved for approval of the agenda as presented, seconded by Mr. Bonar and
unanimously carried.
Mr. Leary moved for approval of the consent agenda, seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried
by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 13, 2010
The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of September 13, 2010 were unanimously
approved by motion of Mr. Leary, seconded by Mrs. Russell and bore the written approval of
Mayor Carey.
PRESENTATION - RECOGNITION OF SERVICE - GERALD FOSS - ELECTION BOARD
(SEPTEMBER 1991 - JULY 1994 AND MAY 2000 - SEPTEMBER 2010)
On behalf of members of Council, Mayor Carey presented Mr. Gerald Foss with a Dover Cup in
recognition of his many years of service on the Election Board, serving from September 1991 to July
1994 and from May 2000 to September 2010.
Mr. Foss thanked the City for the recognition.
Having also served as a member and Chair of the Election Board for several years, Mr. Leary
commended Mr. Foss for his contributions, as well as his assistance with the census and redistricting
in the City of Dover.
PRESENTATION - RECOGNITION OF SERVICE - PAUL FLEMING - DOVER HUMAN
RELATIONS COMMISSION (MARCH 2004 - AUGUST 2010)
Noting the absence of Mr. Paul Fleming, Council President Hogan stated that this presentation would
be deferred.
Paj 5
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 2
PRESENTATION - RECOGNITION OF SERVICE - MARK MONROE - DOVER HUMAN
RELATIONS COMMISSION (OCTOBER 2008 - AUGUST 2010)
On behalf of members of Council, Mayor Carey presented Mr. Mark Monroe with a Certificate of
Appreciation for the service he provided as a member of the Dover Human Relations Commission,
serving from October 2008 to August 2010.
PRESENTATION - CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT FOR EXCELLENCE IN
FINANCIAL REPORTING - COMPREHENSIVE ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORT FOR
FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2009
The Government Finance Officers' Association awarded a Certificate of Achievement for Excellence
in Financial Reporting to Mrs. Donna Mitchell, Controller/Treasurer, for the City of Dover's
Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2009. The Certificate
is the highest form of recognition in governmental accounting and financial reporting and its
attainment represents a significant accomplishment by a government and its management.
Mayor Carey presented Mrs. Mitchell with a plaque in recognition of this accomplishment. Mayor
Carey advised members that this is the 25th year the City has received the award.
Mrs. Mitchell advised members that this accomplishment is the result of the dedication and hard
work of the Finance Department staff, as well as the support of other departments. She reiterated
that the City is fortunate to have such a dedicated staff as that of the Finance Department.
PRESENTATION - CRY OUT AMERICA - DOVER POLICE DEPARTMENT
Mayor Carey advised members that a group of seven (7) clergy in the City of Dover have established
a local branch of the “Cry Out America” movement. Each year, this group holds a prayer gathering
on The Green, and Mayor Carey stated that this year the group presented a plaque to the Dover
Police Department, which the Mayor accepted on the Department’s behalf.
Mayor Carey presented the plaque to Chief Hosfelt in recognition of the bravery, courage, and
dedication provided by the Dover Police Department to the residents of the City of Dover, as well
as a special thank you to the families of police officers for their unselfishness and courage.
On behalf of the men and women of the Dover Police Department and their families, Chief Hosfelt
accepted the plaque, relaying appreciation for the recognition, and stated that all prayers are
welcomed.
PRESENTATION BY DOVER/KENT COUNTY MPO (METROPOLITAN PLANNING
ORGANIZATION) - SCOPE AND PURPOSE OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD PLAN FOR THE
SOUTH SIDE OF DOWNTOWN
Mr. James Galvin, representative of the Dover/Kent County MPO, advised members that
consultants for the Dover/Kent County MPO were currently conducting their first meeting related
to the downtown neighborhood charrette. The downtown neighborhood being studied is the area
around the new Transit Center located at the corner of Queen and Water Streets. Mr. Galvin
indicated that the Transit Center is scheduled for completion by December, including the driveways,
islands, parking area, and shelter. He stated that the Center is planned to be a multi-story building
Paj 6
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 3
eventually. Mr. Galvin noted that the Dover/Kent Count MPO is attempting to determine what the
impact of the Transit Center will be on the surrounding neighborhood and to push the project beyond
standard development into a facility that will complement existing infrastructure and current
development. He stated that the consultants have indicated that a final plan will be completed by
Friday, October 1, 2010. Mr. Galvin stated that several public meetings regarding the project will
be held, including an open house on Wednesday, September 29, 2010, from 4:30 p.m. to 6:30 p.m.
at Becker Morgan Group, 309 S. Governors Avenue, and a final presentation on Friday, October 1,
2010, at 4:00 p.m., on the 3rd Floor of the Eden Hill Center.
Mr. Galvin advised members that the consultants would welcome public comment and urged
Council’s involvement on September 28, 2010 at meetings with key stakeholders and focus groups
and at the public meetings on September 29th and October 1st.
Having attended several of the presentations and meetings thus far regarding this project, Mr. Bonar
relayed appreciation to Mr. Galvin for his work and presentations made on this project. Mr. Bonar
noted that this project, once completed, will benefit not only that particular section of town, but the
entire City.
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Galvin explained that the function of the Transit Center would exceed
the Delaware Transit Corporation (DART) system currently operating in Dover. He stated that the
Transit Center is planned to house the taxi service and interstate buses (Trailways and Greyhound).
As alluded to by Mr. Bonar, when Dover receives rail service in the future, it would also be served
by the new Transit Center.
PROCLAMATION - FIRE PREVENTION WEEK
The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:
WHEREAS, the City of Dover is committed to ensuring the safety and security of all those living
in and visiting our city; and
WHEREAS, fire is a serious public safety concern both locally and nationally, and homes are where
people are at greatest risk to fire, resulting in more than 3,000 deaths a year; and
WHEREAS, roughly two-thirds of home fire deaths resulted from home fires in which no smoke
alarms or no working smoke alarms were present, and had they been it could have cut the chance of
dying in half; and
WHEREAS, the National Fire Protection Association recommends at least one smoke alarm on
every level of the home (including the basement) outside all sleeping areas, and in all bedrooms;
informing the public about the importance of smoke alarm installation and maintenance serves an
essential step toward increasing the public's safety from home fires; and
WHEREAS, City of Dover's, Fire Marshal's and the Volunteer Fire Department are dedicated to
reducing the occurrence of home fires and home fire deaths and injuries through prevention and
proper education; and
Paj 7
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 4
WHEREAS, the Fire Prevention Week 2010, October 3-9 theme, "Smoke Alarms: A Sound You
Can Live With!" actively works to motivate residents to implement smoke alarm recommendations
in their homes;
THEREFORE, I CARLETON E. CAREY, SR., Mayor of Dover, Delaware, do hereby proclaim
October 3-9, 2010 as Fire Prevention Week and I urge all people to protect their homes and
families by heeding the potentially life-saving messages of Fire Prevention Week 2010, and to
support the many activities and efforts of fire and emergency services.
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE REPORT -
SEPTEMBER 13, 2010
The Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee met on September 13, 2010 with
Chairwoman Russell presiding.
Proposed Ordinance #2010-25 - Amendment to Appendix B - Zoning, Article 5 -
Supplementary Regulations, Section 11 - Environmental Protections
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, reminded
members that the Implementation Chapter of the 2008 Comprehensive Plan includes a
recommendation that the City update the environmental protection provisions within the Zoning
Ordinance. In support of this action, she advised members that the Planning Office assembled a
working group which included staff from the City and Department of Natural Resources and
Environmental Control (DNREC), consulting engineers, the Kent Conservation District, the Sierra
Club, and the Delaware Home Builders Association. Although the Kent County Association of
Realtors was invited to participate, she stated that they did not attend any meetings.
Mrs. Townshend indicated that the working group met monthly, beginning in January 2010, to
discuss updates to the environmental protection section of the Zoning Ordinance. As a result of these
discussions, the Planning Office drafted revisions to the Zoning Ordinance that were reviewed and
discussed by the participants and ultimately finalized in late August. She stated that the Silver Lake
Commission reviewed a draft of the proposed ordinance in August 2010.
Members were provided with Proposed Ordinance #2010-25. Mrs. Townshend explained that the
proposed amendments add clarity to the current requirements, include guidance for redevelopment
within the 100-year flood plain, provide options for buffering water bodies, and grant the Silver Lake
Commission the ability to review applications for Silver Lake prior to review by the Planning
Commission. Staff recommended that the proposed ordinance be forwarded to City Council for a
First Reading on September 27, 2010, referred to the Planning Commission for consideration on
October 18, 2010, and that the Final Reading and public hearing be set before City Council on
November 8, 2010.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. Townshend indicated that the flood hazard area is defined as the
100-year flood plain, as depicted on the most recent maps adopted by the Federal Emergency
Management Agency (FEMA). She stated that FEMA updates these maps every five (5) years and
the last update was accomplished in 2005. Mr. Ruane noted that the City has been attempting to
have flood plain maps in the Puncheon Run area revised for some time and reminded members that
Paj 8
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 5
the City prohibits residents from constructing certain types of structures, such as patios, in these
areas. Mrs. Townshend explained that the flood plain map identifies the boundary of the flood plain,
as well as the flood elevation; therefore, if topographical information indicates that the actual flood
plain is different from the map, this information is considered, provided there is supporting evidence.
Mr. Michael Albert, Planner II, stated that there are provisions in the ordinance that specifically
exempt existing homes in the area from the restrictions mentioned by Mr. Ruane.
Mr. McGlumphy relayed concerns that the proposed ordinance contains topics that are embedded
in different areas of the document, such as waivers. He suggested that changes in the ordinance be
clearly identified, explaining that it is difficult for the layman to understand some of the provisions
included.
Responding to Mrs. Russell, Mrs. Townshend suggested that the synopsis be amended to include
details which address the concerns relayed by Mr. McGlumphy.
It was also suggested that staff issue a press release, advertising the public hearing, to alert property
owners within a flood plain.
The Committee recommended approval of staff’s recommendation that Proposed
Ordinance #2010-25, with the recommended adjustments suggested by the Committee, be forwarded
to City Council for a First Reading on September 27, 2010, referred to the Planning Commission for
consideration on October 18, 2010, and that the Final Reading and public hearing be set before City
Council on November 8, 2010.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
(The First Reading of the proposed ordinance will take place during the latter part of the meeting.)
Presentation - St. Jones River Stabilization
Mr. Zachary Carter, Director of Parks and Recreation, introduced Mr. Dean Holden, Chairman of
the Silver Lake Commission. Members were provided detailed information regarding the St. Jones
River Stabilization Project.
Mr. Holden advised members that the St. Jones River Stabilization Project will not only beautify the
area but also improve water quality. He noted that public workshops were held and that the final
construction documents were developed with consideration of public input.
Mr. Lyle Jones, Program Manager, DNREC Watershed Assessment Division, reviewed the
information provided to members regarding the St. Jones River Stabilization Project.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Jones indicated that, upon approval by the City, DNREC will move
forward with the project. He advised members that DNREC is currently in the process of obtaining
federal and State permits and, if the permits are granted, a meeting will be held with the Army Corps
of Engineers to discuss plans for proceeding.
Paj 9
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 6
With regards to Mirror Lake, Mr. Jones stated that there are complicated issues involving this area
due to contaminated sediments, the need for dredging, and problems with grading. He advised
members that DNREC would make a presentation to the City, in the near future, outlining
recommendations for improvement.
In response to Mrs. Horsey’s concerns regarding debris, Mr. Jones stated that the State and the City
share responsibility for maintaining the waterways in the Court Street Bridge area. He recommended
the use of a youth corps to clean up these areas and maintain the buffers. Mrs. Russell suggested the
possibility of consulting with the City’s Youth Advisory Committee on this project.
With regards to the poison ivy which Mrs. Horsey indicated can be observed from the Court Street
bridge, Mr. Carter stated that he would request the Grounds Department staff to investigate possible
removal.
Mr. Ruane commended the leadership of the Silver Lake Commission and DNREC for the work that
has been accomplished over the years and their partnership with the City of Dover.
The Committee recommended approval of the St. Jones River Stabilization Presentation.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
Fund Expenditure Guidelines - Youth Advisory Committee
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, reminded members that the City formed a Youth Advisory
Committee in 2009 for the purpose of advising the City on youth activities and issues. He noted that
this Committee has been given a budget of $1,000 annually.
Mr. DePrima advised members that he, the City Clerk, and the Controller/Treasurer discussed the
development of procedures to allow the Youth Advisory Committee to expend budgeted funds. As a
result, Financial Procedure #F358 was developed and presented for the Committee’s review.
Mr. DePrima stated that finance procedures are not required to be approved by City Council;
however, staff requested Council’s concurrence in this instance due to the involvement of an
advisory committee that reports to City Council. Staff recommended acceptance of Finance
Procedure #F358: “Youth Advisory Committee Spending.”
The Committee recommended acceptance of Finance Procedure #F358: “Youth Advisory Committee
Spending,” as recommended by staff.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation
(Exhibit #2), seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote
(Mrs. Williams absent).
Paj 10
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 7
Benchmarks Established for the Economic Development Office
Mr. William Neaton, Director of Economic Development, reviewed objectives and measures for the
Economic Development Office, which included goals and accomplishments for the Downtown
Dover Partnership (DDP), Downtown Dover business growth, and City-wide economic
development. He also reviewed FY2009-2010 Strategic Accomplishments for the Economic
Development Office.
Mr. Neaton advised members that the following DDP accomplishments were not included in the
benchmarks:
1) Sale of several properties to Mr. Robert Duncan (properties along Loockerman Street east
of the Duncan Center) in the amount of $290,000.
2) Completion of property sales to Mr. Charlie Grimes on West Street in the amount of
$225,000 (relocation of NAPA).
3) Purchase of C. Moore’s building at a sheriff’s sale for $225,000 (noting that the property
requires asbestos abatement, which will begin in October), allowing the DDP to begin
renovations or locate an interested developer.
4) Completion of a lease for the Dover Interfaith Mission.
5) Completion of an agreement for the Inner-City Cultural League to lease a second parcel of
land immediately adjacent to the planned NAPA building location.
6) Utilization of a U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) grant in the amount of $44,000 by
the DDP to host seven (7) business development workshops that provided information on
marketing techniques, green business, and developing business plans. Mr. Neaton noted that
there were 160 attendees and that these types of workshops will continue to be held.
In response to Mr. Ruane regarding the development of the Dover Transit Center, Mr. Neaton stated
that the total cost of the Transit Center was estimated to be $13M and that $5M in stimulus funds
was allocated for the project, which would fund construction of the horizontal (ground) portion
of the building. He noted that the DDP had been working with the Delaware Department of
Transportation (DelDOT) on plans to construct the remainder of the building. He indicated that
State transit operations will be housed in the Center, the Kent County Metropolitan Planning
Organization (MPO) has committed to relocate to the building, and EZ Pass has made a tentative
commitment.
Mr. Neaton noted that DelDOT requested the DDP to join a public/private partnership to develop
the 30,000 sq. ft. structure; however, the DDP declined to participate with DelDOT in this
partnership. Instead, the DDP will look for private sector partners to build the transit center.
Further clarifying, Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, explained that it would be advantageous
for the City to be involved in both the construction of the facility and the ownership/operation of the
building. He stated that if the DDP joined the DelDOT public/private partnership, the DDP would
be prohibited from competing with private developers when bids are submitted for the construction
and development of the site. For this reason, the City declined the opportunity to join the
partnership. However, the City would have the opportunity to participate in the design of the
building through the process of Planning Commission review, etc.
Paj 11
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 8
Mr. Neaton stated that the ground level portion of the structure is proposed to be completed by the
end of the year and the second phase of the project would be completed through the work of the
public/private partnership. He felt confident that plans for the Center would come to fruition.
In regards to the Economic Development benchmarks report, Mr. McGlumphy requested that, in the
future, staff provide specific information for the measurements, such as the inclusion of the survey
mentioned under the measure “monitor downtown merchant and business owner satisfaction” and
the names of new businesses as mentioned under the measure “monitor number of businesses opened
in the Downtown Target Area.” In addition, he requested that members be provided with the number
of jobs created from an opening business and the number lost from a closing business.
Mr. McGlumphy relayed his concerns with the unfavorable appearance of the Route 13 corridor
which serves as the “gateway” to the City. In response, Mr. Neaton advised members that Governor
Jack Markell is interested in improving this area, as well as Downtown Dover. He advised members
that he maintains a close relationship with the State Economic Development Director and intends
to discuss these matters with him.
Mr. Ruane expressed his appreciation for the progress that has been made by the City’s Economic
Development Office.
The Committee recommended acceptance of the report provided on the Benchmarks Established for
the Economic Development Office.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
UPDATES
The following updates were provided:
Puncheon Run Watershed Action Team Update
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, advised members that the
Kent Conservation District is working on contacting property owners near the new Governors
Avenue bridge regarding a flood mitigation project that would create an overflow channel on the
existing stream bed for larger storm events. He stated that the proposed project affects two (2)
property owners and that both seem to be receptive to these improvements. Mr. Koenig stated that
he has requested the incorporation of Puncheon Run flood plain mapping into this project.
Planning and Funding for New Library
Mr. Zachary Carter, Parks and Recreation Director, reviewed updated information regarding
planning and funding for the new library. He reminded members that, although $2.5M was
requested from the State of Delaware Bond Bill, a total of $3.2M was received. He stated that the
State is committed to this program and the projected Library completion date is September 2012.
Mrs. Donna Mitchell, Controller/Treasurer, noted that the additional funds mentioned by Mr. Carter
were allocated funds that were received sooner than the City anticipated and did not represent an
Paj 12
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 9
increase in funding. She reviewed the updated schedule of cost and funding sources for the Library
project and indicated that the schedule outlines the fundraising dollars received to date by the Library
Foundation (attachment to Committee minutes). Mrs. Mitchell assured members that the schedule
was being updated regularly and is reviewed by herself, the City Manager, the Director of Parks and
Recreation, and the Library Director.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, noted that the economic recession is affecting fundraising
efforts for the Library and stated that the City is in discussion with project architects to find possible
ways to cut expenses. He stated that several million dollars of contingencies were included in the
Library budget and will be examined for reductions as construction approaches. In addition, he
noted that the City could consider “phasing” completion of some projects; for example, outfitting
the technology and multi-purpose rooms in the Library could be postponed if funding was not
immediately available. He stated that updated estimates will be presented to the Legislative,
Finance, and Administration Committee during their meeting scheduled for October 11, 2010 and
the financing plans will be reviewed at that time.
The Committee recommended acceptance of the Updates.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Parks, Recreation, and Community
Enhancement Committee Report, seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll
call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE REPORT -
SEPTEMBER 13, 2010
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met on September 13, 2010 with Chairman
Leary presiding.
Review and Recommendation - Filling of Critical Positions
During their meeting of February 23, 2009, members recommended approval of the Hiring Freeze
for Fiscal Year 2008-2009 but to allow for the hiring of critical positions through the review and
approval of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee and City Council. It was
suggested that there be a “standing” agenda item to consider the filling of critical positions but if
there are no positions to consider, the item could be removed.
Librarian II
Ms. Marjorie Cyr, Library Director, reviewed a request to recruit for a Librarian II position.
She reminded members that, during the Regular Council meeting of December 14, 2009, the Library
was granted permission to recruit to fill the Librarian II: Head of Adult Services position. Ms. Cyr
explained that an in-house candidate (Librarian I) was promoted in April 2010 to fill this position;
however, due to personal matters, this employee is unable to continue employment with the
Dover Public Library. She further stated that in May 2010, the City advertised for the position of
Librarian I and is requesting that the current vacancy (Librarian II) be filled utilizing the pool of
Paj 13
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 10
candidates who applied for the Librarian I position. Ms. Cyr assured members that there were
several qualified candidates interviewed in August 2010.
The Committee recommended approval to recruit for the position of Library II: Head of Adult
Services, as requested by staff.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
Motor Equipment Operator I (MEO I) - Streets
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, reviewed a request to recruit
for a Motor Equipment Operator I (MEO I) vacancy created by the recent termination of an employee
in the Streets Division.
Responding to Mr. Shevock regarding the approval of an MEO I in the Sanitation Division on
August 23, 2010, Mr. Koenig indicated that the Committee’s recommendation to recruit for that
position would be considered by Council during their Regular Meeting being held later in the
evening. He stated that, if approved by Council, the position would be advertised as an MEO I in
the Sanitation Department; therefore, individuals with experience in sanitation would apply.
Mr. Koenig felt that candidates would not equate the position in the Streets Division with openings
in the Sanitation Division, and if the two (2) openings were not advertised separately, the pool of
qualified applicants would be reduced.
The Committee recommended approval to immediately recruit for the position of Motor Equipment
Operator I (MEO I) in the Streets Division.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
Presentation - Energy Savings Procurement Contracting - Ralph Nigro of Sustainable Energy
Utility (SEU)
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that, several years ago, he became interested
in exploring energy procurement contracting for the City. He explained that this concept would
involve hiring a company to assess how the City could make existing City-owned buildings more
energy efficient, project the cost of making energy-related improvements, determine energy cost
savings, and finance the improvements with the City paying the finances back through the energy
savings realized. The State of Delaware has created a new agency, Sustainable Energy Utility (SEU),
responsible for coordinating and working on energy procurement contracting.
Mr. DePrima introduced Mr. Ralph Nigro, Contract Administrator for Delaware Sustainable Energy
Utility, and explained that the purpose of bringing this matter to members is to determine the
Committee’s and Council’s interest in the idea.
Mr. Nigro reviewed the Power Point presentation “Sustainable Energy Utility Performance
Contracting.”
Paj 14
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 11
Responding to Mr. Shevock, Mr. Nigro explained that one of the performance contractors would
provide engineering staff to evaluate the facilities and, at the conclusion of this process, a detailed
report would be provided. The report would include findings, recommendations for improvement,
and associated costs and savings. Mr. Nigro indicated that the City would be aware of the costs and
benefits before a contract was negotiated and before committing any money. Assuming the City
moved forward with the recommendations, the cost of the assessment would be included in the
financing. Mr. Nigro indicated that the performance contractor would do the work “at risk,” bearing
the cost necessary to conduct the assessment, and would be paid when the financing closed or, if the
City chose not to proceed with the recommendations, the City would only pay for the performance
contractor evaluation. He advised members that some of the performance contractors are well
established, citing Johnson Controls, Honeywell, Semans, Pepco Energy Services, Constellation
Energy Services, Noresco, Amerisco, etc.
Mr. Nigro stated that the approximate costs associated with assessment are highly dependent upon
the number of facilities evaluated and the complexity of the assessment; however, a “rule of thumb”
would be that the assessment would be conducted at a cost of 0.10¢ to 0.15¢ per square foot.
Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Nigro indicated that performance contractors target at least a 20%
overall savings in order for a project to be considered worthwhile; however, it is common for
contractors to discover savings of up to 40%-50%.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Nigro stated that consideration of this type of program for new
construction falls into a “gray area.” Although he stated this would be possible, parameters have not
yet been determined. Mr. Ruane urged the exploration of this possibility, noting that the City has
a new project that is being designed and that SEU bonding would assist with the financing of this
project. Mr. Nigro assured members that it is not the State’s intention to focus only on existing
buildings and noted that the SEU would pursue this matter further, although he indicated that
financing related to new construction is more complex.
Mr. DePrima stated that, if there were no objections, staff would include the cost of the energy audit
in next year’s budget. He indicated that the City would “piggyback” with the SEU by consolidating
with other organizations, and then the City would move forward from there. He advised members
that City buildings that would be considered include City Hall, the Warehouse, the Recreation Center
on Whiteoak Road, and the Public Utilities/Administrative Offices at 5 East Reed Street.
No further action was taken.
Disposition of City Owned Land - 45 S. State Street and Associated Parking Lot Property
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, reminded members that funds from the sale of the current
Dover Public Library Building and the associated parking area are anticipated for use in the
construction of the new library building. He stated that there have been at least two (2) inquiries
from parties interested in purchasing the property. Given the time table for the new library,
Mr. DePrima indicated that it was time to begin the process of disposing of the current library
building.
Paj 15
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 12
In accordance with the City of Dover Procedure for Sale and Disposition of Real Property,
Mr. DePrima stated that staff has evaluated the property and determined that no City departments
have a need for it. Staff has also determined that the current zoning of RGO (Residential and
General Office) is not appropriate, and that changing the zoning would enhance the value of the lot.
He noted that, in order to prepare the site for sale, it will be necessary to prepare a minor
subdivision\lot line adjustment to place the library and parking lot on one (1) parcel and annex the
Carriage House to the 5 East Reed Street Property. Mr. DePrima indicated that variances may be
needed and advised members that there is a paper alley running through the property that must be
abandoned.
Members were advised that the City of Dover Procedure for Sale and Disposition of Real Property
is a three (3) step process, as follows:
1) Obtain a recommendation from the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee to
dispose of the property.
2) After accepting the Committee’s recommendation, City Council would advertise the intent
to dispose of the property and the pertinent information in a local paper once a week for two
(2) weeks. As a result, any correspondence on the sale of the property would be part of the
public record. City Council would then hold a public hearing for the purpose of taking
public comment on the sale.
3) After considering public comments and the public record, City Council would determine
whether it is in the best interest of the City to sell the property as well as the method of sale
and level of advertising.
Staff recommended that Council designate the property as excess real estate and authorize the City
Manager to publicize the pertinent information concerning the surplus parcel and its availability for
purchase at least once a week for two (2) weeks in a local newspaper, and hold a public hearing
before Council to allow public comment on the proposed sale. It was noted that further action would
be required to authorize the City Manager to obtain the necessary zoning and planning approvals for
the rezoning, minor subdivision, alley abandonment, and possible variances.
Responding to Mr. Shevock, Mr. DePrima stated that a lease purchase for the property was a
possibility.
In response to Mr. Salters, Mr. DePrima stated that, if the City retains the building, it would create
a $1.2M deficit in the finance plan for the new library. He noted that the building was assessed at
$1.4M by the City Assessor and reminded members that the current timeline for occupancy of the
new Library is September 2012.
For clarification, Mr. DePrima stated that the Carriage House utilized by the Friends of the
Library would not be part of the sale and would become a part of the 5 East Reed Street property.
The carriage house, a small garage located on the property, is included as part of the sale.
The Committee recommended that Council designate the property as excess real estate and authorize
the City Manager to publicize the pertinent information concerning the surplus parcel and its
Paj 16
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 13
availability for purchase at least once a week for two (2) weeks in a local newspaper, and hold a
public hearing before Council to allow public comment on the proposed sale.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
FY 2011 Budget Amendment - Project Budgets
Members were provided draft Budget Ordinance #2010-26, including the final budget balances and
project budget balances carried forward from FY10 for incorporation into the FY11 Budget.
Mrs. Donna Mitchell, Controller/ Treasurer, reviewed the major points regarding the re-appropriation
of funds for projects that were not completed in the previous fiscal year. In addition, she advised
members that some “clean-up” amendments unrelated to projects were required, as follows:
1) The General Fund changes reflect a reduction in the Fire Department budget due to apparatus
loan payments being less than budgeted by $64,510 and the removal of a transfer from the
Capital Asset Reserve in the amount of $140,000. The need for the transfer was resolved by
a greater FY10 ending budget balance, along with the reduction in the Fire Department
budget.
2) The Wastewater Utility had a negative Beginning Budget Balance of $45,665, which will be
reversed in FY11. This was attributed to the timing of receipts from the State Revolving
Fund Loan. The State loans work as a line of credit and reimbursements are drawn as money
is spent on the projects. This reduces the City’s interest cost, since the City only pays on the
loans for the principal outstanding at the time until the projects are completed.
3) The Electric Utility ended the year with a higher than projected Beginning Budget Balance
by $1,643,065. The Controller/Treasurer recommended that $1M of the savings be
transferred to the Depreciation Reserve to meet the City’s policy requirement sooner than
forecasted. The transfer would be included in the Budget Ordinance if the Committee agrees
with the recommended action. The remaining savings may be needed to complete the Unit
#1 Boiler repairs. Mrs. Mitchell indicated that Council would be briefed on this project in
the near future. Savings are a result of the following major items:
a) The bonded projects came in under budget and the remaining
proceeds were used for distribution upgrades that were originally
planned to be paid from operating fund transfers and/or reserves;
b) The economy impacted new development projects; therefore, all
budgeted dollars were not spent; and
c) Significant savings were realized on the Governors Avenue
project, since the City budgeted for the installation of conduit to
bury the electric lines and the State is covering this cost.
Paj 17
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 14
Mrs. Mitchell noted that the budget amendment is being presented earlier than normal. She
explained that, by submitting these project carry forward balances prior to the completion of the
annual audit, staff would be able to enter the correct balances in the financial system. This would
alleviate a great deal of manual work required to track funds.
Staff recommended adoption of the Budget Ordinance, with the recommendation to transfer $1M
to the Depreciation Reserve from the Electric Improvement & Extension (I & E) Fund, to be
forwarded to City Council for a First Reading on September 27, 2010.
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. Mitchell stated that an analysis has not been conducted to determine
the impact if the $1M were utilized to reduce electric rates rather than being transferred to the
Depreciation Reserve. She explained that since the excess carry forward monies were in the Capital
Improvement Fund and not the Operating Fund, the funds were put back into the Depreciation
Reserve, since these reserves were used in the past to help pay for projects and the fund dropped
below policy levels. Mrs. Mitchell noted that a transfer from the Electric Fund to the I & E Fund in
the amount of $3.5M was included. She suggested that Council may wish to reduce that amount to
$2.5M, which would provide $1M to be used for customers.
Mr. Ruane requested that Council be provided such an analysis when this matter is presented
for consideration. Responding, Mrs. Mitchell requested guidance relative to an effective date.
She reminded members of the work currently being required by the Finance Department and the time
it would take for staff to conduct the requested analysis.
In response to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Mitchell suggested that the analysis could be accomplished by the end
of October. She suggested that, as an alternative, the Committee’s recommendation could exclude
staff’s recommendation regarding the transfer of $1M to the Depreciation Reserve from the Electric
I & E Fund to be considered at a later time.
Mr. Ruane questioned the urgency for the Depreciation Reserve to be at $10M, feeling that there may
be a missed opportunity to assist the City’s constituents, particularly during these difficult economic
times.
The Committee recommended adoption of Proposed Ordinance #2010-26, Proposed Budget
Amendment - Fiscal Year 2011, with the recommendation to transfer $1M to the Depreciation
Reserve from the Electric Improvement & Extension (I & E) Fund, to be forwarded to City Council
for a First Reading on September 27, 2010, as recommended by staff.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
(The First Reading of the proposed ordinance will take place during the latter part of the meeting.)
Discussion - Public Notice for Planning Applications
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, advised members
that Council had requested that the City’s public notice requirements for planning applications be
updated. In addition to this update, she stated that staff has begun a comprehensive update of
Paj 18
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 15
Article 10 of the Zoning Ordinance which addresses the procedures for various applications reviewed
by the Planning Office, the Planning Commission, and the Historic District Commission.
Mrs. Townshend indicated that last September she reviewed the public notice requirements of other
local governments in Delaware. Based on the research that staff performed and the guidance
provided by City Council and the Committee, staff proposed that Code amendments be brought
forward for consideration later this fall which would include the following changes to public notice
requirements:
1) Increase in distance for mailed notice from 200 feet from the subject property to 300 feet
from the subject property;
2) Change the date of mailed notice and newspaper publication from 10 days prior to Planning
Commission hearings to 15 days prior to Planning Commission hearings;
3) Add a new requirement to physically post a notice on the subject property in a conspicuous
location.
Since several members of the Committee and/or City Council had expressed specific interest in the
issue of public notification, Mrs. Townshend stated that these recommendations were being
presented for discussion prior to completion of the proposed code amendments.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. Townshend indicated that the distance for notifying property owners
could vary significantly depending upon the size of the subject property. In conducting research, she
stated that there were no other municipalities or counties in the State that had a notification
requirement of greater than 300 feet. Additionally, she felt that physically posting a notice on the
subject property would have more impact than a mailed notice. Mrs. Townshend did not feel that
increasing the notification requirement to 500 feet from the subject property would reach
significantly more property owners.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Legislative, Finance, and
Administration Committee Report, seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll
call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
MONTHLY CIP REPORT - JUNE 2010
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Monthly CIP Report for June 2010,
seconded by Mrs. Russell and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
EVALUATION OF BIDS - SUBSTATION POTENTIAL TRANSFORMER (PT) AND
CURRENT TRANSFORMERS (CT) REPLACEMENT
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, reminded members that the Substation Potential Transformer
(PT) and Current Transformer (CT) Replacement Project will allow for the replacement of aging
metering/system protection equipment in the older substations. The equipment to be replaced
includes the PT’s, which measure the line voltage and reduce it to a voltage level the relays can
interpret, and the CT’s, which reduce the current to a level that can safely be measured by the relays
Paj 19
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 16
and meters, all of which provide electric system protection. The lightning arrestors, which protect
the equipment during lightning strikes, will also be replaced. Mr. DePrima indicated that all of the
existing components have exceeded their useful life and are subject to failure, which could be
catastrophic.
Mr. DePrima reminded members that a Request for Proposals (RFP) was sent out last fiscal year and
provided for a three (3) year pricing matrix. He stated that the proposals were advertised in
accordance with the City’s Purchasing Policy and three (3) vendors submitted proposals; one (1)
vendor included five (5) different options and manufacturers to choose from. Since this was a
Request for Proposal, staff evaluated the seven (7) submissions based on price, reputation of the
product, compliance with specifications, and delivery. A point system analysis was performed by
staff to adequately and impartially evaluate the proposals. Staff utilized the same analysis and bid
prices as per the previous bid.
Staff recommended awarding the proposals to HD Supply for the total amount of $145,888.29, as
outlined in the table below:
Vendor Unit $ Quantity Total $ Eval. Score
69 KV PT HD Supply/Ritz $4,684.21 24 $112,421.05 117
15 KV PT HD Supply/GE $636.00 20 $12,720.00 112
54 KV Lightning Arrestor HD Supply/Siemens $573.68 30 $17,210.40 103
9 KV lightning Arrestor HD Supply/Siemens $168.42 21 $3,536.84 110
Total Bid Award Value $145,888.29
Members were advised that not all recommended purchases are to the low bidder, as the bid award
is based on the evaluations.
Mr. Ruane moved to accept the proposal from HD Supply and authorize the City Manager to
enter into a contract for a total amount of $145,888.29, in accordance with the schedule
provided (on the action form), as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by
Mr. Leary and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
EVALUATION OF BIDS - MASTER ELECTRICIAN CONTRACT
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that the Public Utilities Department
maintains blanket contracts with potential contractors to ensure that the bidding rules are adhered
to for contractors hired to perform work for the Utility Department. These contracts are priced as
“time, equipment, and material” contracts and may exceed $25,000 annually. Mr. DePrima
explained that the current proposal is for emergency and scheduled electrical work for the electric,
water, and wastewater divisions. He stated that other City Departments may also utilize this
contractor when required. Mr. DePrima noted that the Public Utilities Department often has projects
that involve customer-owned equipment (such as overhead to underground conversion projects)
which require an inspection by a licensed Master Electrician and that the City does not employ an
electrician with this type of license.
Paj 20
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 17
Mr. DePrima stated that staff solicited bids and eight (8) proposals were received and evaluated,
based on hourly rates and a standard fee for a simple service conversion from overhead to
underground. Staff suggested authorization for two (2) potential contracts to help ensure contractor
availability, should an emergency repair be required or in the event that a scheduling conflict arises
with the primary contractor that would delay required work.
Staff recommended awarding a primary contract to HCS Electric & Technologies, Inc., of Smyrna,
Delaware, and a backup contract to DeVary Electric, Inc., for three (3) years, with the City’s option
to extend the contracts annually for two (2), one (1) year extensions, for a total of five (5) years.
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mr. DePrima stated that, to his knowledge, a formal analysis had not been
performed to compare the cost of an in-house electrician versus a contractor; however, he felt that
the cost estimate used (not to exceed $25,000 annually) was far less than the cost of hiring such an
electrician. He advised members that the City has employee who has such skills and is capable of
performing electrical work; however, this employee works only on City-owned buildings and
equipment. Mr. DePrima noted that a licensed electrician is required for certifying some of the work
performed by the Public Utilities Department.
Mr. Ron Lunt, Public Utilities Director, indicated that a licensed electrician would be used for
projects such as the conversion process that was performed in Crossgates and other locations in the
City, or the installation of a new meter socket or pan on a home that requires an electrical inspection.
He noted that it has been necessary, on occasion, to have such an electrician work on City buildings,
such as the Police Department, when internal staff was not available.
Mr. Leary moved to award a primary contract to HCS Electric & Technologies Inc., of
Smyrna, Delaware, and a backup contract to DeVary Electric Inc., for three (3) years with the
City's option to extend the contracts annually for two (2), one (1) year extensions, for a total
of five (5) years, as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by Mr. Salters and
carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
EVALUATION OF BIDS - ELECTRIC SYSTEM MODELING SOFTWARE
Members were advised that the City is currently required to contract with a consulting electrical
engineering firm to determine the relay settings in the substations. Since the City now has an
engineer on staff, it has been determined that it would be financially feasible to purchase the software
to perform most of this work in-house. Staff has also determined that it would be financially feasible
to use the software that the City’s consulting engineer, Pike Electric, Inc., has been using, since the
laborious task of entering all of the City’s transmission line details has already been completed by
this engineering firm. The electric modeling system software (ETAP) is the package that was used
to model the City of Dover’s 69kV transmission system. Additionally, the City requires the
successful candidate for the upcoming Transmission Relay and Coordination project to use ETAP
to examine/evaluate the relay settings, coordination, and other aspects of the existing protection
scheme.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that the purpose of the electric system
modeling software is to enable City staff to build a distribution model to add to the “corrected”
Paj 21
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 18
transmission model, which will result from the Transmission Relay and Coordination project. This
modeling software will allow City staff to conduct system studies and modify/install the correct relay
settings in the substations and modify/install the correct fuse size in the distribution
protection/isolation system to ensure maximum customer reliability.
Mr. DePrima indicated that this is a sole source contract as the manufacturer does not sell this
product through distribution channels; it is only sold factory direct.
Staff recommended purchasing (2) two ETAP licenses and training from the sole vendor, Operations
Technology, Inc., for a total amount of $56,252.
Mr. Ruane moved for approval of staff’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Salters and
carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
EVALUATION OF BIDS - REPLACEMENT OF 69KV BREAKER
Members were advised that the Electric Engineering Division began a transmission breaker
replacement program in FY 06 whereby all obsolete breakers would be replaced with new breakers.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that this was a multi-year project scheduled
to end in FY 11 and that this would be the last breaker of the project. He stated that bids were
solicited and, although only one bid was received, staff felt that the bid price was fair and reasonable.
Mr. DePrima assured members that other bidders had a reasonable opportunity to respond. It was
noted that the bid price for this breaker was less than the previous bid award in 2009.
Staff recommended purchasing one (1) Siemens 69 kV breaker for $37,500 from Siemens Energy,
Inc., c/o National Transformer Sales.
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Ron Lunt, Public Utilities Director, stated that an engineering study
will be required since the wiring would be completely different. The exact calibration of the breaker
itself, time travel, etc., would be accomplished by internal staff; however, outside help would be
needed on the engineering and wiring.
Mr. Salters moved to authorize the purchase of one (1) Siemens 69 kV breaker for $37,500
from Siemens Energy, Inc., c/o National Transformer Sales, as recommended by staff. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Leary and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams
absent).
APPOINTMENT - PREVENTION POLICY BOARD FOR GAMES GRANT (AID IN
DOVER)
During their Regular Meeting of August 23, 2010, City Council approved the Title V Grant
Application for Growing Up and Meeting Each Success (GAMES) Partnership with Aid in Dover,
with the City of Dover being the municipal sponsor in partnership with Aid in Dover, and with the
stipulation that all requirements for assurances are met.
In accordance with the Grant requirements, members were provided with proposed appointments to
the Prevention Policy Board for their consideration.
Paj 22
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 19
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the appointments to the Prevention
Policy Board for GAMES as presented (Exhibit #3). The motion was seconded by Mrs. Russell
and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mrs. Williams absent).
FIRST READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2010-25
Council President Hogan reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinance are available
at the entrance of the Council Chambers or can be obtained from the City Clerk's Office. Since the
ordinance contains amendments to the Zoning Code, a public hearing is required. Staff
recommended referral of the amendments to the Planning Commission on October 18, 2010, and that
a public hearing take place during the Council Meeting of November 8, 2010, at 7:30 p.m., at which
time final action by Council will take place.
Mr. Bonar moved to refer Proposed Ordinance #2010-25 to the Planning Commission on
October 18, 2010, and that a public hearing be set before City Council for November 8, 2010
at 7:30 p.m., as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by Mr. Leary and
unanimously carried.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of
Proposed Ordinance #2010-25 as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
' AMENDMENT TO APPENDIX B - ZONING , ARTICLE 5 - SUPPLEMENTARY
REGULATIONS, SECTION 11 - ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONS AND SECTION 16 -
TREE PLANTING AND PRESERVATION ; AND ARTICLE 12 - DEFINITIONS
FIRST READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE
Council President Hogan reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinance are available
at the entrance of the Council Chambers or can be obtained from the City Clerk's Office. Final
action by Council on the proposed ordinance will take place during the Council Meeting of
October 11, 2010.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the
Ordinance Amendment as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
' FY 2011 BUDGET AMENDMENT - PROJECT BUDGETS
COUNCIL MEMBERS ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. McGiffin reminded members to mark their calendar for June 25, 2011 for the next African
American Festival.
Mr. Ruane stated that the West Dover Connector is a critical improvement needed in the City of
Dover. He referred to a recent newspaper article which referred to the proposed extension of
Saulsbury Road in a southerly direction from its intersection with North Street. Being aware of the
traffic concerns on West Street, North Street, Webbs Lane, New Burton Road, etc., he noted that the
project has been discussed for several years and that the Delaware Department of Transportation
(DelDOT) is nearing announcement of the preferred alternative. Mr. Ruane recalled that City
Paj 23
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 20
Council, during their Regular Meeting of December 12, 2005, agreed that the preferred alternative
is 5C. He invited everyone to attend the workshop scheduled for September 28, 2010, at the Modern
Maturity Center, from 4:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Mr. Bonar advised members that over the last several years, Delaware’s Volunteer Fire Services
spent several hundreds of thousands of dollars throughout the State to provide free smoke alarms to
anyone who wanted one for their residence. He felt that this project, in conjunction with the Wake
Up Delaware Program, helped to save lives. Unfortunately, he stated that the Federal Government
has eliminated approximately $380,000 of funding for this program in the past year. Mr. Bonar
noted that, although the Fire Services do not have the number of free smoke alarms that were
available in the past, there is a surplus of batteries available. He announced that the smoke detectors
should be replaced every 10 years and encouraged citizens to check with their local fire department
regarding the availability of free smoke detectors.
Mr. McGlumphy moved for adjournment, seconded by Mr. Leary and unanimously carried.
Meeting Adjourned at 8:12 P.M.
TRACI A. McDOWELL
CITY CLERK
All orders, ordinances, and resolutions adopted by City Council during their Regular Meeting of
September 27, 2010, are hereby approved.
CARLETON E. CAREY, SR.
MAYOR
/TM/jg
S:\AGENDAS & MINUTES\Council-Minutes\2010\09-27-2010 Council.wpd.USEAB556
Exhibits Attached to Original Minutes and File Copy
Exhibit #1 - Statement Read by Mr. Eric O’Brien - Property Reassessments
Exhibit #2 - Finance Procedure #F358: “Youth Advisory Committee Spending”
Exhibit #3 - Appointments - Prevention Policy Board for GAMES
Paj 24
CERTIFICATE OF CONGRATULATIONS
Presented to
Dr. Harry L. Williams
On the Occasion of His Inauguration as
The Tenth President of Delaware State University
October 11, 2010
CARLETON E. CAREY, SR. KENNETH L. HOGAN
MAYOR COUNCIL PRESIDENT
Paj 26
PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS, breast cancer forms in tissues of the breast, usually the ducts and lobules. It
occurs in both men and women, although male breast cancer is rare; and
WHEREAS, breast cancer is the most common cancer in women in the Unites States, aside from
skin cancer. It is the second leading cause of death in women; and
WHEREAS, it is estimated that more than 190,000 new cases of invasive breast cancer are
expected to be diagnosed among women and more than 40,000 women will die from this
disease in the United States this year; and
WHEREAS, the basic treatment choices for breast cancer are surgery, radiation,
chemotherapy, and hormonal therapy; and
WHEREAS, a patient and their physician will choose the treatment that is right for him/her
based on the location and extent of the cancer; patient's age and preferences; and the risks and
benefits of each treatment; and
WHEREAS, some of the most common risk factors are: sex, age, personal history, family
history, the breast cancer gene, first pregnancy after age 25 or 35, having no children, the use
of Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT), and Oral Contraceptives; and
WHEREAS, Mammography screening remains the best available method to detect breast
cancer early; and
NOW, THEREFORE, I, Carleton E. Carey, Sr., MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE,
do hereby proclaim October 2010 as
BREAST CANCER AWARENESS MONTH
throughout the City of Dover and encourage all citizens to join in activities that will help the
community understand what they can do to prevent and control breast cancer.
Carleton E. Carey, Sr.
Mayor
Paj 27
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee Meeting was held on September 27, 2010 at 5:00 p.m. with Chairman Ruane
presiding. Members present were Mr. Bonar, Mr. McGiffin, Major Kosior, and Mr. Snaman.
Councilman Leary (arrived at 5:52 p.m.) was present. Mayor Carey was also present.
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
The agenda was approved by unanimous consent.
Delaware State University (DSU) Force Main Reroute
Mr. Ron Lunt, Public Utilities Director, advised members that the FY 2011 Operating Budget for
the Public Utilities Wastewater Management Division includes a capital project to install a new force
main from the west end of West Rustic Lane to the existing Delaware State University (DSU) force
main along the Delaware Civic Center property. He explained that this project will consist of
installing approximately 1,000 feet of 16-inch diameter ductile iron pipe. Mr. Lunt noted that the
existing DSU force main currently flows to the Delaware Technical and Community College
(DTCC) pump station, and the proposed force main rerouting will also provide for the reversal of
flow from the DTCC pump station through valve installation and utilizing the remaining portion of
the existing DSU force main. He advised members that flows from both pump stations will no
longer discharge into Kent County Station #2 but will instead discharge into the new US Route 13
West Sanitary Sewer Interceptor (Rt. 13 Interceptor). Mr. Lunt noted that the DSU force main
rerouting construction drawings were submitted to Eastern States Construction Services, Inc., who
is currently constructing the Rt. 13 Interceptor. He stated that City staff and KCI Technologies, Inc.,
(KCI) the City’s Project Manager on the Rt. 13 Interceptor, reviewed the Eastern States Construction
Services, Inc. bid proposal and found it free of math errors and/or discrepancies. KCI also conducted
an independent cost analysis of the proposed project and found the Eastern States proposal to be
reasonable and acceptable when compared to current construction costs.
Mr. Lunt noted that the source of the funds for this project will be the Delaware Water Pollution
Control Revolving Loan Fund Program, using the excess funds from the Rt. 13 Interceptor project,
which was anticipated during the budget process. The Rt. 13 Interceptor project was budgeted at
$3,201,480, the actual construction bid was $2,308,800, and the current estimated completion cost
is approximately $2.6M. He stated that KCI and City staff are confident that the Rt. 13 Interceptor
project cost will remain below this estimate; therefore, the City will have approximately $600,000
in excess loan funds to support the completion of the DSU/DTCC Force Main Rerouting project.
Mr. Lunt stated that since this is the final stage of the Rt. 13 Interceptor, the DSU/DTCC Force Main
Rerouting project will be submitted to DNREC as part of an approved change order to the ongoing
Rt. 13 Interceptor project. He noted that City staff has received assurance from DNREC staff that
this is an acceptable change order to the loan program due to this interconnectivity.
Staff recommended approval of the proposal submitted by Eastern States Construction Services, Inc.
in the amount of $240,300 for the construction of the DSU/DTCC Force Main Rerouting and that
the Finance Department be authorized to include the additional expenditure as a change order and
a part of the existing loan agreement between the City of Dover and the Delaware Water Pollution
Control Revolving Loan Fund Program.
Paj 28
UTILITY COMMITTEE MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 2
Responding to Mr. Bonar, Mr. Lunt assured members that the 16-inch pipe is substantially larger
than what is currently needed and will accommodate future expansion when necessary. He advised
members that Kent County performed some of the engineering work on this project to assure it
would be adequate for the County’s rerouting/bypassing project for the current interceptor, which
saved the City approximately $26,000 that was budgeted for engineering work.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, assured members that City Council
was made aware of the appropriation for this project.
Mr. McGiffin moved to recommend approval of the proposal submitted by Eastern States
Construction Services, Inc., in the amount of $240,300, for the construction of the DSU/DTCC
Force Main Rerouting and that the Finance Department be authorized to include the
additional expenditure as a change order and a part of the existing loan agreement between
the City of Dover and the Delaware Water Pollution Control Revolving Loan Fund Program,
as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bonar and unanimously carried.
Commercial Recycling Fee
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, advised members that, during
the changeover of vendors for the curbside recycling program, the Delaware Solid Waste Authority
(DSWA) informed the City of its intent to discontinue recycling collection service to 17 Dover
businesses that do not have City trash services. These 17 businesses use a private trash collection
service due to their individual business needs. These customers were receiving direct service from
the DSWA for a fee of $6.00 per month, per container; however, as of September 1, 2010, the
DSWA no longer provides service to these customers. Staff requested authorization to create a
special billing code and implement a fee of $6.00 per month per container for commercial curbside
recycling for customers who do not have City of Dover trash collection services.
Responding to Mr. Snaman, Mr. Koenig stated that the six (6) customers who are listed outside of
the City limits are located in “in-fill” areas along Governors Avenue and are existing DSWA
customers. He noted that staff did not recommend extending recycling services outside of the City
limits at this time.
Mr. Bonar moved to recommend approval of staff’s recommendation, seconded by
Major Kosior and unanimously carried.
Request for Alley Abandonment (paper) - 18 Elm Terrace - Valerie Satterfield
A request was received from Ms. Valerie Satterfield for the abandonment of an unimproved alley
running east-west on property located at 18 Elm Terrace. Members were provided with a map of the
area. Since the alley is unimproved and is considered to be a “paper” alley, it does not require
review by the Development Advisory Committee (DAC) or Planning Commission.
Ms. Satterfield, 18 Elm Terrace, advised members that she wishes to erect a shed on the property
behind her garage and that, prior to requesting a building permit, she assumed it would be necessary
to own the property. Since the alley has not been used for several years, if ever, she requested that
the alley be abandoned.
Paj 29
UTILITY COMMITTEE MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 3
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Ms. Satterfield stated that, if approved, she would be willing to pay for
any costs involved with the preparation of the necessary deed. She relayed no objection to the utility
easement that will be retained by the City.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that the homes that front on the south side
of Elm Terrace have a paper alley that transects their property. In essence, he stated that these
property owners own two (2) lots; one (1) on both sides of an alley that was not developed or
dedicated to the City, but still appears on official tax maps. The situation has existed since this area
was developed in the first half of the 1920s or 1930s. The owners of these properties have enjoyed
the full benefit of this land without finding a need to abandon the alley.
Mr. DePrima assured members that he reviewed the proposal with various City departments and that
there was no objection to the abandonment. He noted there is a sewer line that transects the alley;
therefore, staff recommended that the City retain a utility easement on the property. Any legal
expenses related to the processing of the deeds or annexing the property to adjacent lots is to be paid
for by the property owner.
Although the sewer lines were depicted on the map provided, Mr. Snaman suggested that staff
provide details as to the location of all utilities for future requests. Responding, Mr. DePrima
relayed no objection to such a request.
For the record, Major Kosior noted that his property is located immediately to the west of
Ms. Satterfield’s and relayed no objection to the request.
Mr. McGiffin moved to recommend approval of the alley abandonment at 18 Elm Terrace,
reserving a utility easement on the property. The motion was seconded by Major Kosior and
unanimously carried. (City Clerk’s Note: In accordance with the City’s Procedure for Alley
Abandonments, Resolution No. 2010-11 setting the Public Hearing (Attachment #1) will be
presented to Council for consideration for adoption.)
Request for Alley Abandonment (paper) - Girl Scout Lane - Traci McDowell
A request was received from Mrs. Traci McDowell for the abandonment of an unimproved portion
of Girl Scout Lane, which runs behind her properties located at 80 and 100 Nixon Lane. Members
were provided a map of the area. The roadway is unimproved and is considered to be a “paper” road;
therefore, it does not require review by the DAC or Planning Commission.
Mrs. McDowell, 115 Nixon Lane, advised members that Girl Scout Lane is an unimproved, paper
road, which she has been maintaining for several years. If the abandonment is approved, she stated
that it would provide enough property to allow her to subdivide and build another house at some time
in the future.
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. McDowell assured members of her understanding that, if approved,
she would be responsible for any costs involved with the preparation of the necessary deed. She
relayed no objection to the utility easement that will be retained by the City.
Paj 30
UTILITY COMMITTEE MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 4
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, advised members that Girl Scout Lane is an unimproved (dirt)
lane/alley that was annexed into the City of Dover and never paved. Only one (1) house fronts
on the alley. He stated that the properties on the west side of Nixon Lane have access to the rear of
their lots and that Mrs. McDowell owns two (2) properties on the east side of the lane on the
north end. The west side of the Lane is owned by the City and is associated with Dover Park. There
are two (2) lots on the west side of the Lane that are owned by David and Mary Miller. Only the
one (1) lot is impacted by this abandonment.
Mr. DePrima reminded members that when abandoning roadways with owners on both sides of the
property, the City will offer one half to each owner. In this instance, he stated that the City has no
interest in the half that runs along Dover Park, noting that the area is outside of the fence and has not
been maintained by the City. He stated that no City departments objected to the abandonment and
that there are no utilities in the proposed abandonment area. Mr. DePrima indicated that any legal
expenses related to the processing of the deeds or annexing the property to adjacent lots would be
paid for by the property owner.
In response to Mrs. McDowell, Mr. DePrima confirmed that the map provided to members did not
depict the correct abandonment. He advised members that the abandonment would include property
from Nixon Lane back to and including Girl Scout Lane. Mr. Ruane requested that the correct map
be provided to City Council when this matter is presented for their consideration.
Responding to Mr. Snaman, Mr. DePrima stated that Mr. and Mrs. Miller may or may not exercise
their right to take ownership of their half of the alley. If they do not, the area would remain a part
of the alley.
Mr. Bonar moved to recommend approval of the abandonment of the unimproved lane
adjacent to 80 and 100 Girl Scout Lane, reserving a utility easement for existing utilities, as
requested by Mrs. McDowell. The motion was seconded by Mr. McGiffin and unanimously
carried. (City Clerk’s Note: In accordance with the City’s Procedure for Alley Abandonments,
Resolution No. 2010-12 setting the Public Hearing (Attachment #2) will be presented to Council
for consideration for adoption.)
Dedication of Rights-of-Way and Infrastructure - Susan Place
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, submitted a request for
all public infrastructure improvements associated with the construction of Susan Place, located
within the Persimmon Park Place Subdivision, to be dedicated to the City of Dover for permanent
ownership and maintenance. Members were provided a list (noted as Attachment A to the Committee
Action Form) that identified the public improvements associated with the proposed dedication,
as well as a map (noted as Attachment B to the Committee Action Form) that showed the general
location and configuration of the subject right-of-way. Mr. Koenig advised members that
Separe, Inc., constructed most of the improvements in accordance with City standards and
specifications and that, last fall, the developer paid the City to complete the final construction of the
street. He stated that, as of this date, all work related to the public infrastructure has been completed.
Staff recommended acceptance of the dedication of rights-of-way and public infrastructure for Susan
Place and that the dedication include all of the referenced public improvements.
Paj 31
UTILITY COMMITTEE MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 5
Mr. McGiffin moved to recommend acceptance of the dedication of rights-of-way and public
infrastructure for Susan Place and that the dedication include all of the referenced public
improvements (Attachment #3 and Attachment #4), seconded by Mr. Snaman and unanimously
carried.
Update - Green Energy Funding and Programming
Members were provided a Green Energy Funding and Programming Update - Stimulus Funding.
Mr. Ron Lunt, Public Utilities Director, reviewed the information provided to members, stating that
there had been a slight change in the funding and programming. He reminded members that the
State Energy Office has allocated $2M of the federal American Recovery and Reinvestment Act
stimulus money received by the State towards reducing the existing backlog of approved residential
green energy grants that have delayed grant payments due to insufficient funds in the respective grant
program. He stated that the $2M has been put into one (1) fund that is available to the City of Dover,
other Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) participants, Delmarva Power, and
Delaware Electric Cooperative customers.
Mr. Lunt stated that the City has one (1) customer in the delayed grant program who would have paid
once the grant funds were available; however, the establishment of the new fund would provide the
opportunity to receive these monies in advance (or earlier). He explained that the customer could
apply directly to the State Energy Office for funds. A home energy audit of the residence in question
would be required, with a rebate of up to $250 (50%) available to cover this cost. The customer
would be required to complete improvements totaling a minimum of $500 to the residence based on
the audit, and this cost could also be rebated.
Mr. McGiffin moved to recommend acceptance of the Update on the Green Energy Funding
and Programming, seconded by Major Kosior and unanimously carried.
Review of Utility Related CIP’s (Electric and Water/Wastewater) (June)
Members were provided a Project Tracking Report, as of June 30, 2010, for the Utility (Electric and
Water/Wastewater) Related Capital Investment Plan (CIP).
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, indicated that the Cooling Towers
Repair/Renovation Project is a FY2011 Project and was not included in the CIP Report provided.
He stated that the condensation problem has been resolved and that, to his knowledge, there have
been no complaints filed regarding “soot” damages to the vehicles of nearby residents.
With regards to Mr. Ruane’s questions regarding the Bayard Avenue Project, Mr. Ron Lunt stated
that the east side of North State Street, and Bayard Avenue Projects are being completed by the
internal construction crew. He noted that currently, Phase A of North State Street, which includes
Hazel and Rodney Roads, is underway. Mr. Lunt explained that once construction is completed
there, the crew will move to Bayard Avenue to begin construction. Following completion of this
project, the crew plans to return to North State Street to begin Phase B. He stated that the Route 13
Program has been delayed due to Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT) requirements
involving an extensive traffic management plan that has been submitted for approval. Once
approved, bids will be solicited, since this project will be contracted. In addition, Mr. DePrima
Paj 32
UTILITY COMMITTEE MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 6
reminded members that these three (3) projects were part of the State Revolving Loan, which caused
a substantial delay. Concurring, Mr. Lunt indicated that the City was not provided the funds until
after the first of the fiscal year and that the engineering work had to be accomplished.
Responding to Mr. Bonar, Mr. Lunt stated that the last paperwork submitted to DelDOT by the City
regarding this matter was in August. Mr. Bonar suggested that staff contact DelDOT to expedite the
required approval and if there is a delay, he felt that it may be necessary for City Council to become
involved.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mr. DePrima stated that the Review of the CIP is scheduled to be
presented to members each month. He reminded members that there is always a delay in submitting
the June report since it is the end of the fiscal year. Mr. Ruane suggested that a “prepared date” be
included on the report.
Mr. Snaman moved to recommend acceptance of the Utility Related CIP’s Report, seconded
by Major Kosior and unanimously carried.
PACE/NAES Monthly Report (June and July)
Due to time constraints, Mr. Ruane suggested that the PACE/NAES Monthly Report be considered
by members during their next meeting. He noted that he had concerns regarding the Reports and
requested that staff provide an update on the condition of the plants.
By unanimous consent, the meeting was adjourned at 5:56 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Eugene B. Ruane
Chairman
EBR/AC/tm/jg
S:\AGENDAS & MINUTES\Committee-Minutes\2010\09-27-2010 UTILITY.wpd
Attachments
Attachment #1 - Resolution No. 2010-11 - Elm Terrace Alley Abandonment
Attachment #2 - Resolution No. 2010-12 - Girl Scout Lane Alley Abandonment
Attachment #3 - List of Dedication of Rights-of-way and Public Infrastructure Susan Place - Persimmon Park Place
Attachment #4 - Map of Dedication of Rights-of-way and Public Infrastructure Susan Place - Permission Park Place
Paj 33
Attachment #1
Utility Committee M eeting of 09/27/10
City of Dover
MAYOR AND COUNCIL
1 DRAFT PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2010-11 - ALLEY ABANDONMENT IN
2 THE AREA OF ELM TERRACE
3 A RESOLUTION PROPOSING THE VACATING AND ABANDONMENT OF CERTAIN ALLEYS
4 SITUATED IN THE CITY OF DOVER.
5 BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL
6 MET:
7 Section 1. The Council of the City of Dover favors the vacating and abandoning of the following alley:
8 All that certain piece or parcel of land situated in the City of Dover, Kent County, State of Delaware,
9 a 12 foot wide paper alley running west to east approximately 67.00 feet from the southwest property
10 corner of Parcel No. 1: Tax Parcel #ED-05-077.09-05-65.00 to the southeast property corner of said
11 parcel, then running in a southerly direction 12 feet to the northeast property corner of Parcel No.
12 2 - Tax Parcel #ED-05-077.09-05-65.00, then running east to west approximately 68.27 feet to the
13 northeast corner of Parcel No. 2 - Tax Parcel #ED-05-077.09-05-65.00, then running in a northerly
14 direction 12 feet to back to the southwest property corner of Parcel No. 1: Tax Parcel
15 #ED-05-077.09-05-65.00, comprising 811.62 square feet, more or less.
16 Section 2. The Council of the City of Dover will sit on Monday, October 25, 2010, at 7:30 p.m., in the
17 Council Chambers at City Hall, Dover, Delaware, to hear the objections of such residents of the City or
18 owners of the property affected as shall attend, in accordance with the provisions of Section 27 of the
19 Charter of the City of Dover (Chapter 158, Volume 36, Laws of Delaware).
20 Section 3. The Clerk of Council is hereby directed to post copies of this Resolution in five or more
21 public places in the City of Dover.
22 ADOPTED: *
23 S:\RESOLUTIONS & PROCLAMATIONS\2010\DRAFT\Res. No. 2010-11 - Setting Public Hearing - Elm Terrace Alley Abanondonment.wpd
24
25 CARLETON E. CAREY, SR. KENNETH L. HOGAN
26 MAYOR COUNCIL PRESIDENT
27 Actions History:
28 October 11, 2010 - Introduced at City Council
P.O. Box 475 Dover, Delaware 19903
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Paj 34
Elm Terrace Southern Alley
Proposed Alley Abandonment
!Ò§
!Ò§
§Ò
!
Elm Terrace .
!
!Ò§
.
!
!Ò§
§Ò !Ò§ !Ò§
!
!Ò§
.
!
.
!
.
!
.
!
!Ò§ !.
!
.
.Notes: 0 50 100 200 Feet
Legend
-No waterÒ§ line present in the alley
!
!
!Ò§ -A sewer easement will be required §Ò
! Overhead Electric Pole
¯
Overhead Electric Lines
Date Printed: October 4, 2010 Right of Way to be Abandoned
Date Created: September 9, 2010
File: m:\gis_data\projects/tech_mxds .
! Manholes
\st_abandonment_map
Sewer Line
Department: Public Services GIS
City of Dover, Delaware Dover Parcels
Paj 35
Attachment #2
Utility Committee M eeting of 09/27/10
City of Dover
MAYOR AND COUNCIL
1 DRAFT PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2010-12 - STREET ABANDONMENT
2 GIRL SCOUT LANE
3 A RESOLUTION PROPOSING THE VACATING AND ABANDONMENT OF CERTAIN ALLEYS
4 SITUATED IN THE CITY OF DOVER.
5 BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL
6 MET:
7 Section 1. The Council of the City of Dover favors the vacating and abandoning of the following alley:
8 All that certain piece or parcel of land situated in the City of Dover, Kent County, State of Delaware,
9 beginning at the northeasterly corner of Tax Parcel #ED-05-068.19-01-32.00 and running west a
10 distance of 175.00 feet to a set yellow capped pin at the northwesterly corner of said parcel, then
11 running in a southerly direction a distance of 200.00 feet to a set yellow capped pin at the
12 southwesterly corner of said parcel, then running in a southerly direction a distance of 250.00 feet
13 along the western property line of Tax Parcel #ED-05-068.19-01-42.00 to a set pipe in the East line
14 of Girl Scout Lane (unopened), then running in a westerly direction 27.5 feet along the same bearing
15 as the southern property line of Tax Parcel #ED-05-068.19-01-42.00 to the West line of Girl Scout
16 Lane (unopened), then running is a northerly direction a distance of 477.50 feet to a set corner of Tax
17 Parcel #ED05-068.19-01-28.00, then running easterly a distance of 202.50 feet to the intersection
18 of the west line of Nixon Lane and the north line of Girl Scout Lane, then running south a distance
19 of 27.5 feet to the northeasterly corner of Tax Parcel #ED-05-068.19-01-32.00, comprising
20 17,943.75 square feet, more or less.
21 Section 2. The Council of the City of Dover will sit on Monday, October 25, 2010, at 7:30 p.m., in the
22 Council Chambers at City Hall, Dover, Delaware, to hear the objections of such residents of the City or
23 owners of the property affected as shall attend, in accordance with the provisions of Section 27 of the
24 Charter of the City of Dover (Chapter 158, Volume 36, Laws of Delaware).
25 Section 3. The Clerk of Council is hereby directed to post copies of this Resolution in five or more public
26 places in the City of Dover.
27 ADOPTED: *
28 S:\RESOLUTIONS & PROCLAMATIONS\2010\DRAFT\Res. No. 2010-12 - Setting Public Hearing - Girl Scout Lane.wpd
29
30 CARLETON E. CAREY, SR. KENNETH L. HOGAN
31 MAYOR COUNCIL PRESIDENT
32 Actions History:
33 October 11, 2010 - Introduced at City Council
P.O. Box 475 Dover, Delaware 19903
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Paj 36
Girl Scout Lane
Proposed Street Abandonment
.
!
§Ò
!
.
!
!Ò§
!Ò§
ut
Sco
Girl
!Ò§ !Ò§
.
! .
!
Lan
!Ò§ e
§Ò
!
!Ò§ !Ò§ !.
!Ò§
!Ò§
!Ò§ !Ò§ .
!
.
!
!Ò§ !Ò§
§Ò
!
.
! !Ò§
!Ò§
!Ò§ !.
§Ò
!
!Ò§ !Ò§
!Ò§ !.
.
!
!Ò§
!Ò§ !
.
!Ò§ !Ò§
§Ò !Ò§ !Ò§
!Ò§ !
. !Ò§ ! !Ò§ !Ò§
!Ò§ .
! §Ò
! !
.
0 100 200 400 Feet LegendÒ§
!
!Ò§ Overhead Electric Pole
¯
Overhead Electrric Lines
Date Printed: October 4, 2010
Date Created: September 10, 2010 .
! Manholes
File: m:\gis_data\projects\tech_mxds
Sewer Line
\street_abandonment_map
Department: Public Services GIS Right of Way to be Abandoned
City of Dover, Delaware
Dover Parcels
Paj 37
Attachment #3
Utility Committee M eeting of 09/27/10
DEDICATION OF RIGHTS-OF-WAY AND PUBLIC INFRASTURCTURE
SUSAN PLACE – PERSIMMON PARK PLACE
ATTACHMENT A
The following is a list of all public improvements which are to be accepted by the City of Dover:
Sewer Utility Infrastructure (Construction Value = $56,250):
8” SDR-35 PVC Sanitary Sewer Main - 1,125 l.f.
6” PVC Sanitary Sewer Laterals - 460 l.f. (23 laterals)
4' Diameter Sanitary Sewer Manholes - 5 ea. (25.50 v.f.)
Water Utility Infrastructure (Construction Value = $45,500):
8” C900 PVC Water Main - 1,300 l.f.
6” C900 PVC Water Main - 481 l.f.
1” Polyethylene Water Service Lines - 460 l.f. (23 services)
8” Gate Valve - 1 ea.
6” Hydrant Valve - 2 ea.
Fire Hydrants - 2 ea.
Storm Water Infrastructure (Construction Value = $20,000):
Catch Basins - 6 ea.
15” Type III Reinforced Concrete Pipe - 78 l.f.
Street Infrastructure (0.23 miles) (Construction Value = $100,000):
Susan Place - From Station 00+00 to Station 12+25 1,225 l.f.
Paj 38
Attachment B
Attachment #4
Utility Committee M eeting of 09/27/10
Susan Place-Persimmon Park Place
Right of Way to be Dedicated to the City of Dover
a
Sus
nP
lac e
0 75 150 300 Feet
¯
Legend
Date Printed: September 16, 2010
Date Created: September 16, 2010 Right of Way to be Dedicated
File: m:\gis_data\projects\st_dedication_map
Department: Public Services GIS Dover Parcels
City of Dover, Delaware
Paj 39
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting was held on September 27, 2010
at 6:00 p.m. with Chairman Leary presiding. Members present were Mr. McGiffin, Mr. Salters,
Dr. Jones, and Mr. Shevock. Members of Council present were Council President Hogan,
Mr. Bonar, Mr. McGlumphy (arrived at 6:06 p.m.) , and Mr. Ruane (arrived at 6:03 p.m.) . Mayor Carey was
also present.
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
Mr. Salters moved for approval of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously
carried.
Review and Recommendation - Filling of Critical Positions
During their meeting of February 23, 2009, members recommended approval of the Hiring Freeze
for Fiscal Year 2008-2009, but to allow the hiring of critical positions through the review and
approval of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee and City Council. It was
suggested that there be a “standing” agenda item to consider the filling of critical positions and, if
there are no positions to consider, the item could be removed.
Mr. Leary noted that there were no critical positions to be considered; therefore, no further action
was required.
Minority Procurement Program Policy
Members were advised that the City does not have a tracking or control mechanism for seeking
minority/women vendors for purchases in the mid-range of $5,000.00 - $24,999.99. As a result, staff
submitted a proposed amendment to Section 3.4 of the Purchasing Policy, along with the addition
of Appendix E, to provide a mechanism to ensure minority/women vendors are approached for
purchases within this range and a mechanism for tracking by the Procurement Manager.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, reminded members that this matter was previously discussed
and that Mr. Clay Hammond, Chairman of the Delmarva Black Chamber of Commerce and
Vice President of Business Development, Global Diversity Group, has reviewed the proposed
amendments and has indicated his concurrence.
Mr. Pete Gregg, Contract and Procurement Manager, reviewed the proposed amendment and form
(Appendix E), which will be utilized by departments.
In response to Mr. Salters, Mr. Gregg explained that when the 3% minority vendor preference is
applied, staff considers the amount of a minority bid at 3% less than submitted. This allows the City
to select a minority vendor who may not have been the lowest bidder (as long as it is within 3% of
the lowest bid); however, the City pays for the services at the full bid amount.
Mr. Jay Burks, Director of the State Office of Minority and Business Women Enterprises, stated that
the database utilized consists of those businesses that are certified as 51% owned/managed by
minorities and/or women. He advised members that the database contains over 1,800 certified
vendors and is available for public access.
Paj 40
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION
COMMITTEE MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 27, 2010 PAGE 2
Mr. Salters requested specifics regarding the percentage of minority-owned businesses and those that
are located in Kent County. Responding, Mr. Burks stated that the information would be provided
to Mr. Gregg for distribution to members.
Mr. McGiffin moved to recommend approval of the proposed amendment to Section 3.4 of the
Purchasing Policy for purchases in the mid-range of $5,000.00 - $24,999.99 (Attachment #1)
and Appendix E of the Purchasing Policy (Attachment #2). The motion was seconded by Dr.
Jones and unanimously carried.
By unanimous consent, the meeting adjourned at 6:17 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Thomas J. Leary
Chairman
TJL/TM/jg
S:\AGENDAS & MINUTES\Committee-Minutes\2010\09-27-2010 LF&A.wpd
Attachments
Attachment #1 - Proposed Amendment to Section 3.4 of the Purchasing Policy
Attachment #2 - Appendix E of the Purchasing Policy
Paj 41
ATTACHMENT #1
LF&A Committee Meeting of 09/27/2010
3.4 PURCHASING THRESHOLD TABLE
PURCHASING THRESHOLDS
Less than $5,000 $5,000 to $24,999 $25,000 & Over
Open market; Department Head Department Head solicit no less than Formal Invitation to Bid (ITB) or Request for
discretion to obtain quotes; three (3) written quotations; If fewer Proposal (RFP/RFQ); No less than three (3)
than three (3) quotations, justification potential vendors supplied to Central Services;
must be included;
Purchases will be made by Quotations and support Pre Solicitation Meeting required of the
designated personnel; documentation to be maintained in respective Department & Procurement
Central Services files as public record; Manager to discuss appropriate procedures and
To include name of vendor, date of specifications;
submission, and amount; Use the
quotation worksheet in Appendix E.
Approved invoices sent to Requires requisition and purchase Public sealed bid or sealed proposal procedures
Accounts Payable for payment. order through the financial system; as outlined in Appendix A;
Purchases under existing City All purchases will be made by Central Public Advertising at least once a week for two
contracts shall be made in Services or the Police Department (2) consecutive weeks in publication with
accordance with the terms of such Purchase Coordinator by Purchase circulation in each county of the State;
contract. Order or Contract, Additional advertising discretionary;
Supplies available from City stock Award shall be made to the lowest Lowest and/or most responsive bid will be
should not be procured from third and the best quotation; Vendor accepted; Vendor references may be checked
party vendors. references may be checked; to verify ability to meet contract requirements;
Item numbers, quantities, unit Item numbers, quantities, unit cost, Public Bid/Proposal Opening; Time and date
cost, and extension must be and extension must be completed on of public bid opening shall be stated in the
completed on every purchase every purchase order for materials or notice for bids; Delivered to Central Services,
order for materials or paying for paying for contracted labor at hourly 710 William Street, Dover, DE 19904
contracted labor at hourly rates; rates;
Approval - Department Head Fax and email quotations are Bid Bond or certified check in the amount
Level acceptable; equivalent to ten percent (10%) of the bid
amount for items/contracts over $25,000; Can
be waived by Purchasing Agent and
Department Head;
Electronic Approval - City Manager Performance Bond required for construction
& Treasurer work;
Purchase Order to include: Faxed bid are not acceptable for this category;
Unit Cost $; Account number; project Sealed bids may be emailed to
number if applicable; Brief description bids@dover.de.us or as agreed to with the
of item or service when not identifiable; Department Head;
Quotes from each vendor in comments;
Purchases exceeding $25,000 shall require
NOTE – Changes to Purchase Orders Council approval for sole source procurement,
are to be completed through the greater than budget and not low bidder;
financial systems. Purchase Orders Committee/Council Action Forms to include:
received with manual changes to Budget $, P. O. $ or Unit Cost $; Account
amounts/unit cost will not be number; project number; page number in budget;
processed by the Finance Department. Bid/RFP number if applicable. If unit cost bid
include cost comparison. If blanket bid or
proposal is for recurring services, provide
average annual cost for past three years for the
service. Description and recommended action.
Paj 42
ATTACHMENT #2
LF&A Committee Meeting of 09/27/2010
APPENDIX E
CITY OF DOVER QUOTATION WORKSHEET
(To be used for purchases between $5,000.00 and $24,999.99)
Department: ___________________________ Division: _________________________
Department Contact (Name & number): _______________________________________
Item/Service: ____________________________________________________________
Estimated Dollar Value: ___________________________________________________
Account Code: _________________________________ Project Code: ______________
Vendors (At least three vendors must be used. Include at least one minority or women owned
vendor, if available. Use of more than one minority or women owned vendor is encouraged):
1. Go to http://gss.omb.delaware.gov/omwbe/index.shtml.
2. Select Minority and/or Women Business Enterprise Directory
3. Search by keyword i.e. Electrician, Construction, Furniture
List keyword(s) used: ______________________________________________
4. Each company displayed will have its assigned NAICS code listed.
List NAICS Code(s) used: __________________________________________
5. Refine search by NAICS Code if necessary.
6. Were Vendors Found: YES NO If so, how many:__________________
Vendor 1: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 2: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 3: _______________________________________________________Minority
If more than three vendors are used, list them on the reverse of this form.
Date sent out for quotes: __________________________
Date due back: _________________________
Date of award: _____________________
Vendor receiving the award: ________________________________________________
Was the 3% minority vendor preference applied in the evaluation? YES NO
Was this a minority vendor? YES NO
Total dollar amount of purchase or estimated total contract value: $_________________
Purchase Order produced: YES NO PO Number: ________________________
Send completed form to the Procurement Office in Central Services.
Paj 43
Additional vendors used for this purchase
Vendor 4: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 5: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 6: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 7: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 8: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 9: _______________________________________________________Minority
Vendor 10: ______________________________________________________Minority
Send completed form to the Procurement Office in Central Services.
Paj 44
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
The Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee Meeting was held on September 29, 2010 at
5:00 p.m. with Chairwoman Williams presiding. Members present were Mrs. Russell, Mr. Bonar,
Mr. Davis, and Mr. Harmon. Members of Council present were Mr. McGlumphy (departed at 6:00 p.m.)
and Mr. Ruane (arrived at 5:24 p.m. and departed at 6:00 p.m.) . Mayor Carey (departed at 6:00 p.m.) was also
present.
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
Mr. Bonar moved for approval of the agenda, seconded by Mrs. Russell and unanimously
carried.
Discussion - Manchester Square Safety Concerns
Ms. Ami Sebastian-Hauer, Executive Director of the Dover Housing Authority (DHA), reviewed a
Presentation from the DHA (Attachment #1). She noted that on August 24, 2010, at 5:00 p.m.,
a major shooting occurred at Manchester Square involving 15 people. Ms. Sebastian-Hauer
stated that the Dover Police Department responded immediately and that the majority of the
individuals involved were apprehended. She stated that all of the individuals, with the exception
of one (1), have since made bail. Since this incident, there has been an alarming increase in the
number of reports of shots being fired and/or weapons displayed at several DHA properties.
Ms. Sebastian-Hauer advised members of improvements being made by the DHA with regards to
safety and security. She requested that the City of Dover consider increasing the number of police
officers in the community policing division. She explained the vital importance of the visibility of
police officers, as well as the development of relationships between the police and residents.
Ms. Sebastian-Hauer introduced Mr. Dave Sweeney, of Advantech, Inc., the contractor who
performed the upgrades and additions to the security systems for the DHA.
Responding to Mrs. Williams, Police Chief Hosfelt indicated that in 2006, five (5) City police
officers were assigned to community policing and four (4) officers to quality of life (nuisance
crimes), for a total of nine (9) officers. He stated that the Police Department currently has only
six (6) officers serving in these areas, and the community policing and quality of life teams have
been combined due to the necessity to reallocate officers to address other problems in the City, such
as sex offenders. He reminded members that, due to budget constraints, he agreed to maintain the
police force at 91 for FY 10, rather than returning the authorized strength of the force to 93 officers.
In response to Mr. Clay Hammond, 505 Troon Road, Chief Hosfelt stated that the City is no longer
eligible for the Weed and Seed Grant, explaining that there is a five (5) year window before a new
application can be made. He stated he had made an inquiry to the Attorney General’s Office
regarding the City’s status in this matter.
With regards to the incident on August 24, 2010, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer reiterated that none of the
individuals involved were legal tenants of the DHA, although some were unauthorized guests or
family members of three (3) tenants. She assured members that the DHA has taken appropriate
action regarding those three (3) tenants in enforcing their “zero tolerance” approach.
Paj 45
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 29, 2010 PAGE 2
Responding to Mrs. Williams, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer stated that there is a problem with gang activity
at Manchester Square that is continuing to worsen.
Ms. Joybeth Guy, 745-B Bacon Avenue, advised members that she has resided in Manchester Square
for three (3) years and problems have been in existence there for several years. It was her feeling
that the DHA is not managing the property in a manner that would prevent the situations that are
occurring. She felt the situation there has become out of control.
Mr. Bobby Wilson, 1561 Nathaniel Mitchell Road, questioned how long security cameras in the area
have been “out of service.” Responding, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer stated that only one (1) camera was
out of operation and that the security camera system was recently updated. Mr. Wilson noted that
a shooting incident occurred on June 26, 2010, and questioned the delay in responding to the
problems that have been occurring. He advised members that this shooting involved the front
window of one of the residents and that the window has not been repaired to date. It was his
understanding that no one from the DHA has spoken with this resident, who felt like a prisoner in
her own home. Mr. Wilson stated that, due to fear, she does not “live” in the first floor of her home,
where the window is located. He suggested that the DHA improve their relationship with their
residents.
In response to Mr. Wilson’s concerns, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer indicated that there are two (2) residents
at the home where the window was shot and that it is a one (1) story home. These residents have
been offered transfers as part of the DHA’s relocation program and have been provided choice
vouchers to move from the development. Ms. Sebastian-Hauer assured members that information
regarding this incident was provided to the Dover Police Department and that there are investigations
pending. She advised members that when the DHA has requested increased police presence, there
have been complaints from the tenants. Ms. Sebastian-Hauer explained that, while the DHA
enforces the “one strike” policy and lease provisions, they must also respect the civil rights and
privacy of the tenants.
Mr. Hammond advised members of his previous involvement with public housing and felt that a
more effective strategy in dealing with these concerns is to focus on prevention rather than
monitoring undesirable activity. It was his feeling that resources must be provided to address the
needs of families in the community, explaining that children do not want to sell drugs but they must
be given alternatives. He suggested involving tenants and getting them to take ownership.
In response to Mrs. Williams, Chief Hosfelt stated that when the Dover Police Department had
substations located at Senate View and Manchester Square there was much less crime in these areas.
Regarding the incident that occurred on August 24, 2010, Chief Hosfelt stated that warrants have
been obtained for eight (8) individuals, six (6) of whom have been arrested and two (2) of whom
remain at-large. He explained that there were two (2) groups of subjects involved whose ages ranged
from 10 to 20, and several shots were fired across the Manchester Square Development. Information
obtained from witnesses indicated that there were 20 to 30 gunshots fired. Chief Hosfelt stated that
Paj 46
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 29, 2010 PAGE 3
the City was very fortunate that no one was injured or lost their life as a result of this incident;
however, there was damage to three (3) vehicles and houses in the area. He advised members that
a subsequent search warrant for a follow-up investigation resulted in the recovery of a 45-caliber,
semi-automatic pistol, as well as an SKS assault rifle with a caliber of 223, which is the same caliber
that the U.S. military carries in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Chief Hosfelt advised members that, since 2008, there have been 15 gang-related shootings in Dover,
three (3) gang-related stabbings, and five (5) gang-related homicides in or around subsidized housing
(not just DHA projects). He stated that, since 2005, the Police Department has been educating the
public regarding gang problems that were occurring and/or were anticipated in the City. He stated
that the gangs in the Dover area consists of the “Bloods” and “Crips,” which are active in the
neighborhoods of Capital Park, Capital Green, Liberty Court, Downtown Dover, and Whatcoat. He
noted that there are other gangs, such as “Three Block,” which is a sect of the “Bloods” located in
the downtown area.
Chief Hosfelt stated that when he began on the police force 22 years ago, it was a rare occurrence
to hear a “shots fired” announcement over the radio; however, it is now common to hear this at any
time of day. He stated that from January 1, 2010 through the beginning of September, 91 calls of
“shots fired” were received by the Police Department.
Chief Hosfelt recommended increasing the number of authorized officers. He advised members that
hiring and training a new officer is an 11-month process that includes a background check, 20 weeks
of training at the Police Academy, and a 12-week training period with Dover officers. He stated that
manpower surveys and workload assessments indicate that 34 additional police officers are needed
for the City of Dover, which he understood was unrealistic. Chief Hosfelt stated that he would like
Dover to have four (4), 12-man shifts, which would require an additional six (6) officers in order to
put two (2) officers back into community policing.
Responding to Mrs. Russell, Ms. Sebastian-Hauer explained that if an individual commits a crime
on property owned by the DHA, they are placed on a “banned list.” Once banned from public
housing, an individual is banned for life unless a request for removal is submitted. She stated that
the banned list is provided to all residents, who are advised to contact the Police Department if
anyone on the list is observed on the property since the individual would be trespassing.
Mr. Bonar stated that, although he supports the “right to bear arms,” it was his opinion that handguns
and automatic weapons have no place in the City of Dover except in the hands of police officers in
the line of duty. He felt that the City should send a message to those coming into the City carrying
a handgun that they are not welcome and that this message should be sent to the “Bloods” and
“Crips.” He felt that the City should provide the Police Department with all the ammunition and
resources required to do their job and ensure that the citizens of the public housing areas are safe.
Paj 47
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 29, 2010 PAGE 4
Mr. Bonar moved to recommend that the manpower for the City of Dover Police Department be
increased to 100 and to explore the necessary means of raising revenues to see this accomplished.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Harmon.
Referring to the City’s Vision Statement in regards to the City of Dover being “a place where people
want to live,” Mr. McGlumphy stated that this refers to “all” people, regardless of where they reside.
He stated that public housing residents should be provided the opportunity to live in peace and
without fear. He requested that the DHA continue their efforts and strongly recommended that the
City heed the information that was provided to members. He noted that the City has an additional
$2M, which was presented during the discussion of Proposed Ordinance #2010-26, Budget
Amendments, which was presented for a First Reading before City Council on September 27, 2010,
and he felt that this matter should be the number one (1) priority for the City.
In response to Mr. Harmon, Chief Hosfelt indicated that there are no requirements for owning a
handgun in the City of Dover. He explained that when a handgun is purchased, the gun must be
registered; however, if the purchaser then sells the gun, there is no requirement to update gun
registration.
Mr. Hammond suggested the possibility of creating a non–profit organization to address quality of
life issues. It was his feeling that this would bring the churches, public sector, masonic community,
and fraternity/sorority communities together and would provide additional funding resources. As
an example, he stated that churches could offer positive alternatives, such as “movie nights” for
children.
Referring to the maintenance of DHA property, Mr. Wilson noted that lack of proper maintenance
can draw undesirable elements into a community. He questioned which department is responsible
for inspecting the DHA properties. Responding, Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning
and Community Development, stated that the City’s Inspection Department is responsible for
conducting inspections. She stated that more than 3,000 rental permits have been issued in the City
and that the Department’s manpower has also been reduced; therefore, only 600 units were inspected
last year. Mrs. Townshend explained that the Department is currently operating in a complaint-
driven mode and that recently, due to the large number of foreclosures and vacant properties, many
demands have been placed upon staff.
Mrs. Williams suggested that the maintenance issue be considered by members during an upcoming
meeting and invited Mr. Wilson to participate in further discussion at that time.
On a call for the question, the motion to recommend that the manpower for the City of Dover
Police Department be increased to 100 and to explore the necessary means of raising the
revenues to see this accomplished was unanimously carried.
Paj 48
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 29, 2010 PAGE 5
Waiver Request for Length of Dead-end Street (Cul-de-Sac) in Wynsome Oaks Subdivision
on White Oak Road
Members considered a waiver request which would allow the length of a dead-end street in the
Wynsome Oaks Subdivision to exceed 400 feet. The Conceptual Subdivision Plan proposes to
create 17 parcels from an existing parcel totaling 12.78+/- acres. The property is located on the south
side of White Oak Road, southwest of Mourning Dove Lane. The owner of record is TFLD
Management, LLC (Tax Parcel: LC-05-068.00-01-18.00-000).
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, advised members
that the Subdivision Plan for this project proposes 17 parcels with residual land, and the entrance
street leading into the site is off White Oak Road. The Subdivision Ordinance limits a dead end
street to a maximum length of 400 feet. The proposed development proposes a dead end street of
900+/- feet. The street layout in the subdivision proposes one (1) main street (Bella Boulevard) and
a stub street (Emerson Drive) to connect to the property to the west. The portion of Bella Boulevard,
south of the intersection with Emerson Drive, that will end in a cul-de-sac is 400 feet in length and
would be permitted. However, until the road connection to the west is established, the entirety of
Bella Boulevard will be a dead end street exceeding 400 feet in length.
Mrs. Townshend advised members that the Planning Commission recommended approval of the
waiver to allow the length of the dead end street to exceed 400 feet.
Mr. Bonar moved to recommend approval of the requested waiver, as recommended by the
Planning Commission, seconded by Mr. Harmon and unanimously carried.
Prioritization of Transportation Projects
During their meeting of August 25, 2010, members were advised that in the upcoming months,
the Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT), the Dover/Kent County Metropolitan
Planning Organization (MPO), the Wilmington Area Planning Council (WILMAPCO), and Sussex
County will be holding public hearings on the State’s Capital Transportation Program for the
next fiscal year. These hearings will begin the process of preparing a capital program that will
ultimately be approved as part of the Bond Bill in June 2011. Members recommended that the
Mayor and Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development,
finalize the list of City Capital Transportation Program priorities that will be ranked by members
during their September meeting, provide this list to Mr. Ralph Reeb and other appropriate DelDOT
officials and, following the November State elections, meet with legislators to obtain their support
for these projects. (This recommendation was approved by City Council on September 13, 2010.)
Mrs. Townshend reminded members that each year City Council ranks transportation projects in the
City of Dover in order to share the City’s priorities with DelDOT. (The last ranking of priorities
took place at the Safety Advisory and Transportation Meeting of September 30, 2009, and was
approved by City Council on October 12, 2009.) Mrs. Townshend reviewed the previous year’s
priority listing that was provided to members as well as staff’s comments, which were noted in red.
Paj 49
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 29, 2010 PAGE 6
With reference to the Delaware Route 8 Study, Mrs. Townshend advised members that there have
been intense discussions with the Capital School District regarding the construction of the new
Dover High School. She stated that two (2) stub streets were constructed in the Village of Westover
and Village of Cannon Mill with the intent that these streets would connect to the property to the
north (now the site of the proposed Dover High School) when it was developed. Mrs. Townshend
noted that the Capital School District has been very resistant to interconnection. Staff has agreed
that if the school district provides a bicycle/pedestrian connection at the stub street in the Village of
Westover, this would be sufficient; however, with approximately 1,000 units in the Villages of
Westover and Cannon Mill, she stressed that it is unacceptable to have individuals drive to Artis
Drive or Mifflin Road, which are already overly congested intersections; and therefore, there is a
need to connect to the stub street in the Village of Cannon Mills. She noted that the new high school
is planned to open in 2014 and she provided a map depicting the road connection (Forrest Avenue
and Hazlettville Road) that will ultimately be required (Attachment #2).
In discussions with DelDOT regarding this matter, Mrs. Townshend explained the necessity for both
the City and the School Board to give this road connection high priority in order for this project to
come to fruition and for funding to be in place when the high school opens.
In addition, members discussed the possibility of a crossover bridge for pedestrians at the school.
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, explained the high costs that
would be associated due to the need to meet requirements under the Americans with Disabilities Act.
After much discussion, staff recommended that Priority #1 - Intermodal Transportation Terminal
(Dover Transit Hub) be removed, #8 - Delaware Route 8 Study become either #1 or #2, #4 - West
Dover Connector become either #1 or #2, and that the remaining priorities remain the same.
Mr. Bonar moved to recommend the establishment of new priorities for Transportation
Projects as recommended by staff, with Priority #8 becoming #1 and Priority #4 becoming #2
(Attachment #3). The motion was seconded by Mr. Davis and unanimously carried.
Briefing on Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT) Projects - Gary Laing
Mr. Gary Laing, Community Relations Officer for the Delaware Department of Transportation
(DelDOT) and Public Relations Liaison, briefed members on DelDOT Projects, as follows:
West Dover Connector
Mr. Laing stated that a workshop was held by DelDOT on September 28, 2010, regarding the West
Dover Connector and that approximately 200 people were in attendance. During the workshop,
DelDOT presented the preferred alternative and stated that changes will be made to this alternative
as a result of comments received.
Paj 50
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 29, 2010 PAGE 7
Mr. Laing stated that money is available in the draft Capital Transportation Program (CTP) which
will allow DelDOT to move forward with project engineering for the design of the road in FY11 and
FY12, right-of-way acquisition in FY12 and F13, and construction in FY14, FY15, and FY16. He
stated that the total expenditure is estimated at $22M, that the process began in 2004, and that it will
be 12 more years before the roadway is completed.
South Governors Avenue Improvements
Mr. Laing reported that, according to contract, paving of South Governors Avenue from Wyoming
Avenue to just south of Water Street will begin next week. Additional work is required at the Water
Street intersection; therefore paving of this intersection cannot be completed at this point.
Responding to Mrs. Williams, Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works,
stated that the Governors Avenue Improvement Project will not solve the water problem at
the intersection of Water Street. He explained that, in order to reduce the flooding at Water Street,
it will be necessary to upgrade the piping system from the intersection to the St. Jones or past
Elm Terrace and Kerbin Street, where the pipe comes to daylight. This upgrade would cost
approximately $3M-$4M.
Responding to Mr. Bonar, Mr. Laing indicated that, according to the project contract, all Governors
Avenue road work is to be completed by the end of the year.
Water Street Railroad Crossover
Mr. Laing advised members that there is no new information to report on the Water Street railroad
crossover, explaining that this project is a long way from being realized. He reminded members that
any at-grade railroad crossing requires approval of the railroad.
Mr. Bonar relayed concern that this project will not be necessary once the transit center is complete.
He stated his feeling that a railroad crossing would not be desired next to the transit center.
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, advised members
that there has been much discussion regarding the railroad crossover being key to pulling the
downtown and Eden Hill areas together.
Wyoming Mill Road Project
Mr. Laing advised members that he spoke with the manager of the Wyoming Mill Road Project who
estimated that the project will be let out to bid in approximately one (1) month. He explained that
there are two (2) properties that must be acquired and funds must be shifted internally. Mr. Laing
stated that the project is planned to go to construction in the Spring of 2011.
Briefing on Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) Projects - Juanita
Wieczoreck
Due to the absence of a representative from the Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning
Organization, there was no briefing provided to members.
Paj 51
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 29, 2010 PAGE 8
Mr. Bonar moved for adjournment, seconded by Mr. Davis and unanimously carried.
Meeting Adjourned at 6:47 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Beverly C. Williams
Chairwoman
BCW/TM/js/jg
S:\AGENDAS & MINUTES\Committee-Minutes\2010\09-29-2010 SA&T.wpd
Attachments
Attachment #1 - Presentation of the Dover Housing Authority
Attachment #2 - Map - Forrest Avenue and Hazletteville Road Connection
Attachment #3 - 2010 City of Dover Transportation Projects Prioritization List
Paj 52
ATTACHMENT #1
SA&T Committee Meeting of 09/29/2010
Dover Housing Authority
Presentation to
City of Dover
SA&T Committee Meeting of 09/29/2010
Safety Advisory
And
ATTACHMENT #1
Transportation Committee
Paj 53
Reported Incidents in
Senate View for 2010
9
8
7
6
Kent Avenue
5
4 New Castle
3 Avenue
2
1
0
Jan Mar May Jul Sep
Paj 54
Reported Incidents in Colonial
Gardens for 2010
14
12
10
8
Simon Circle
6 Hayes Circle
4
2
0
Jan Mar May Jul Sep
Paj 55
Reported Incidents in
Manchester Square 2010
30
25
20
15
Manchester Sq
10
5
0
Jan Mar May Jul Sep
Paj 56
Reported Incidents in
Derby Estates 2010
5
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
Bacon Ave
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
Jan Mar May Jul Sep
Paj 57
Reported Incidents in
Queen Manor
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
Queen Manor
1.5
1
0.5
0
Jan Mar May Jul Sep
Paj 58
Since August 24, 2010 . . .
Reports of Shots Fired and/or Weapons
Displayed:
September 7
September 9
September 13 (2 sites)
September 16
September 20
September 24
September 28
Paj 59
In Addition . . .
DHA has received 2 reports of fights
involving youth.
One reported a 17-year old with a gun
One reported a 9-year old with a knife
Paj 60
Improvements to Safety and
Security:
Short-term additional patrols
24-hour evictions for residents involved
in, connected to, associated with
offenders of violent and/drug crimes
Ban List distributed to all residents
House Rules re-distributed to all
residents
Paj 61
Improvements to Safety and
Security:
Upgrades and Additions to Security
System
Installation of light on back fence at
Manchester Square Development
Implementation of assigned parking
Installation of “No Loitering” and “24-
Hour Surveillance” signs
Paj 62
Improvements to Safety and
Security:
Resident Meetings to encourage
residents to TAKE BACK THEIR
COMMUNITY!
Implementation of Emergency Admin
Phone Line
Paj 63
Improvements to Safety and
Security:
Improvements to Customer Service by
DHA staff to include:
Better grass cutting schedule
Daily inspections and trash pick-up by
maintenance staff
More visibility of Admin Staff
Paj 64
Other Actions Taken:
Ensure DPD has access to DHA’s
Security System
Discussed issues with:
National Gang Intel Center
DE Information & Analysis Center
Consultant/Expert on Gangs
Paj 65
Actions That Need To Be Taken:
Take an aggressive approach with
offenders—involve DPD, P & P, AG’s
office
Increase number of officers in the
Community Policing Department
Take a Zero Tolerance approach in
applying the DHA One Strike You’re Out
Policy
Paj 66
ATTACHMENT #2
SA&T Committee Meeting of 09/29/2010
SA&T Committee Meeting of 09/29/2010
ATTACHMENT #2
Paj 67
ATTACHMENT #3
SA&T Committee Meeting of 09/29/2010
CITY OF DOVER
2010 TRANSPORTATION PRIORITIZATION LIST
For the purpose of aiding in the prioritization of projects for the coming year, updates have been added to
for projects that City Council prioritized projects in 2009. The Delaware Department of Transportation is
in the process of developing the FY 2012 - FY2017 Capital Transportation Program (CTP). This sets out
the State’s transportation funding priorities over the next six years. Ultimately, the CTP will tie in with the
FY2012 Bond Bill approved by the General Assembly in June 2011. The City’s identified transportation
priorities, once approved by City Council, will be shared with the Delaware Department of Transportation,
and City staff and the Mayor will advocate for these projects as discussed previously by the Safety
Advisory and Transportation Committee.
1. North/South Road between Route 8 and Hazlettville Road on the West Side of the Capital School
District Property and the Village of Cannon Mills (Project from Delaware Route 8 Study)
The Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization conducted a study in 2007 of the
State Route 8 corridor from the railroad tracks, west to Artis Drive. The study identifies a
number of service roads and alternative roadways to help disperse the traffic pattern and reduce
congestion on Route 8.
The Capital School District is moving forward with plans for a new Dover High School, and the
construction of a north/south road between Artis Drive and Mifflin road, along the west edge of
the Capital School District property and immediately west of the Village of Cannon Mills, is
important in relieving potential stress on Hazlettville Road, Route 8, Artis Drive, and Mifflin
Road associated with traffic related to the new school. While the Capital School District will
fund and construct a portion of this road from Route 8 into the Dover High School campus, the
Delaware Department of Transportation will need to construct the majority of the road, as more
than half of the distance between Route 8 and Hazlettville Road is south of the property owned
by the Capital School District. Additionally, sidewalk installation where sidewalk gaps are
present might be a priority for implementation to ensure safe pedestrian access to the new Dover
High School.
2. West Dover Connector
With the completion of SR 1 around Dover, the east-west corridors in and out of the City have
seen increases in traffic. The City of Dover Comprehensive Plan Update in 2003 and the
Dover/Kent County MPO Long Range Transportation Plan recommended studying the extension
of Saulsbury Road due to persistent and fast-paced growth that contributes to existing and future
traffic congestion in the area. The West Dover Connector project is studying the feasibility of
extending Saulsbury Road across the Eden Hill Farm and adjacent agricultural parcels making
connections to New Burton Road and possibly to US Route 13. Because much of the land needed
for such a roadway is undeveloped, the opportunity still exists to make improvements that best
accommodate the area's multi-modal transportation needs. Alternative routes and concepts have
been developed with the input and guidance of the West Dover Connector Working Group that
began in 2004. This group is working in conjunction with DelDOT and with neighborhood and
community officials, schools, local government leaders, concerned citizens, federal and state
environmental and cultural resource agencies, and others to develop options that meet the diverse
needs of the community.
1
Paj 68
Through a series of workshops, the group developed five alternative options to improve mobility
across the Norfolk Southern Railroad for all modes of travel to and from the west side of Dover,
to reduce congestion at key intersections in the study area, and to improve the connecting
roadway network for local travel.
City Council, in December 2005, adopted a resolution to endorse Alternative Option 5C as
the best possible alternative alignment for the West Dover Connector. The key features of
5C states:
Extends Saulsbury Road over Puncheon Run and the railroad spur on a bridge
Parallels New Burton Road on the west side of the railroad corridor
Provides a new connector road across the Kesseling Farm (west of New Burton Road)
Connects to New Burton Road with a ramp
Connects to US Route 13 using Charles Polk Road corridor
Potential connection to Wyoming Mill Road
The Resolution stated that Alternative Option 5C has little or no impact on the existing homes,
churches, and schools nearby adjoining streets, would reduce cut-through traffic and traffic
volumes along Camden-Wyoming Avenue as well as provide a direct connector to US Route 13.
Alternative Option 5C provides for interconnectivity and offers protection of City utilities
without impacting the Mayfair Electric Substation. This option would establish a defined
southern boundary for the City. This option was one of two concepts recommended by both the
Working Group and the Project Team. Alternative Option 5C has been identified in the Dover
City Council's Transportation Projects Prioritization as a key aspect of the West Dover
Connector project.
On September 28, 2010, the Department of Transportation held a workshop and unveiled the
preferred alternative, which is a modified 5C.
a. West Street/North Street Intersection
The intersection of West Street and North Street has been identified as a potentially
problematic portion of the road network. Difficulties for northbound traffic on West
Street attempting to make left turns are compounded by line of sight issues down North
Street. There have not been simple solutions to this issue to date as the road network in
the surrounding area is compact enough where even small adjustments to one intersection
can have dramatic impacts on other intersections. Increased traffic generation from Eden
Hill Farm TND has begun to contribute to congestion in the area and is expected to be
more significant with the addition of Eden Hill’s commercial portions.
3. Garrison Oak Connector Road
Garrison Oak is a 385-acre tract zoned as IPM2 (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone-Technology
Center) and is the only site in the City to be zoned as such. It has been identified by the City as an
ideal location for large technological/green industry firms that require large lot sizes of over
twenty acres.
DelDOT has acquired the necessary right-of way to build a road extending south to Route 8 to tie
in with the interchange. As development plans for Garrison Oak are well underway, the design
and construction of this road is a priority for marketing Garrison Oak. The Dover Sun Park is
2
Paj 69
expected to break ground in late 2010, and the City is in negotiations with Macquarie Energy for
a gas power plant on another lot in the park. Dover City Council has prioritized this project and
recommended that it be identified in the State's six-year CTP.
4. Loockerman Street/Forest Street Improvements
This project includes a series of improvements throughout Dover that will encourage economic
development and alternative modes of transportation. These improvements include a roundabout
adjacent to the Dover Train Station building, new curbing, and new sidewalks. Additionally, this
project will enhance Downtown Dover development.
This project remains an important component to the western gateway to the downtown. It also
ties in with the Clarence Street extension project, which will extend Clarence Street north from
North Street to Forest Street. Additionally, a new office building proposal by Bob Duncan on
what is referred to as the “triangle site” across from the Duncan Center also makes this a timely
project. Dover City Council has prioritized this project and recommended that it be identified in
the State's 6-year CTP.
5. US Route 13 Service Road Corridor
In adherence to the State’s Corridor Capacity Preservation Program, the addition of service roads
from Scarborough Road, east and west of Route 13, from the toll plaza through to Dover Downs,
behind the Dover Mall and Wilmington University, would decrease traffic on US 13 in an
attempt to get local traffic off Route 13. Dover City Council has prioritized this project and
recommended that it be identified in the State's 6-year CTP.
The purpose of the US Route 13/113 corridor through the City has changed. This roadway once
served the dual purposes of a high speed through travel route and as a local access road to service
the many commercial businesses that were constructed along it. With SR 1 serving the needs of
through travelers, US Route 13/113 corridor is becoming a destination for commerce and
community activities, as well as a significant employment center for the growing service sector.
In order to address the changing character of this roadway a workshop was conducted by the
Dover/Kent County MPO. The purpose of the workshop was to generate new ideas for
improving the appearance and operation of the corridor. The organization prepared a report
entitled “Concept Plan for US Routes 13 and 113 in Dover – Phase I, Technical Memorandum II:
Final Recommendations.” This was adopted by the MPO in November 1, 2000.
The final recommendations of the study were:
Create a corridor overlay zone;
Service roads for local traffic;
Assist voluntary development of rear access to business;
Construction of sidewalks and bike paths;
Median landscaping;
Add bus pullovers where needed;
Installation of attractive lights that serve both motorists and pedestrians;
Bury utilities;
3
Paj 70
Install pedestrian buttons at signals and strip crosswalks heavily;
And develop a system of appropriate signage.
6. US Route 13 Sidewalk Construction
As part of an ongoing effort along the corridor, this project will complete the sidewalk network
on both sides of US Route 13. The scope of the project includes addressing accessibility and
ADA compliance. Field surveys and preliminary design have been conducted and this project is
in the design phase. Dover City Council has prioritized this project and recommended that it be
identified in the State's 6-year CTP.
7. Kenton Road Corridor Upgrades
The proposal is to upgrade the Kenton Road corridor from Route 8 to Denneys Road to an urban
road standard. Improvements to the corridor focus on new pavement sections, sidewalks,
shoulders, curbing, enclosed drainage systems, bicycle lanes, lighting and intersection
reconfiguration. DelDOT has entered into a contract with Whitman, Requardt & Associates and
this project is in the study phase.
The study is a large study and in terms of prioritization, the installation of sidewalks along
Kenton Road between Route 8 and College Road would be a first phase priority implementation
project from this study that should be added to the CTP. Dover City Council has prioritized this
project and recommended that it be identified in the State's six-year CTP.
8. College Road Corridor Upgrades
Another road improvement project is to upgrade the College Road corridor from Kenton Road to
Saulsbury Road to an urban road standard. Improvements in this project include new pavement
sections, sidewalks, shoulders, closed drainage system, bicycle lane, lighting and other
improvements. Once completed, this road will be similar to Walker Road. Dover City Council
has prioritized this project and recommended that it be identified in the State's 6-year CTP.
9. Crawford Carroll Avenue Extension
This project will continue the improved right-of-way of Crawford Carroll Avenue from West
Rustic Lane in a southerly direction to the site with Circuit City and PetSmart and connect to US
Route 13 via a signalized intersection. Crawford Carroll Avenue is a limited access service
roadway designed to alleviate traffic congestion on Route 13 and provide local motorists with
alternate routes to access the commercial areas of Route 13 in north Dover. This project is
currently in Phase III of implementation.
Policy/Program Prioritization List
1. Weekend Bus Service
2. Airport Studies and Improvements to Accommodate Passenger and Aircraft Related Industries
4
Paj 71
3. Red Light Photo Enforcement Program
4. Bike Path Connectivity
5. Continued Exploration of Options for Relocating the Storage and Marshalling of Chemical Cars
at the Norfolk Southern Yard on New Burton Road
6. Additional Studies of Next Phase to Implement Commuter Passenger Rail Service between
Wilmington and Dover.
5
Paj 72
CITY OF DOVER
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
MONTHLY BUDGET REPORT
AUGUST 2010
PREPARED BY: FINANCE DEPARTMENT
PLEASE NOTE – THIS REPORT PROVIDES TOP LINE INFORMATION ON THE THREE MAJOR
OPERATING FUNDS. IF YOU WOULD LIKE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, PLEASE FEEL
FREE TO CONTACT THE FINANCE DEPARTMENT.
Paj 73
Page 2 of 8
City of Dover
Finance Department
Monthly Budget Report
August 2010
S
Strategic Objectives for Fiscal Year 2010 – 2011
1. Develop Days Sales Outstanding (DSO) monthly report to provide timely information on
receivable collections.
2. Assist with implementation of inventory system for Electric Plant inventory.
3. Implementation and transition to an external service for time keeping and payroll.
4. Implement and transition to lockbox and remote deposit services for cash receipts.
ACTIVITY LEVELS
FY10 YTD FY11 YTD
BANK TRENDS
Number of Deposits Made 230 513
Total Amount of All Deposits $ 28,175,050 $ 31,955,792
PAYROLL
Hours % Amount Hours % Amount
Gross wages per registers 184,532 100.0% $ 3,946,194 177,063 100.0% $ 3,851,465
Wages and Hours Worked
Regular 150,975 81.8% $ 1,208,349 146,347 82.7% $ 1,221,335
All over time 5,575 3.0% $ 86,179 5,321 3.0% $ 78,817
Other Paid or Unpaid Wages and Hours
Vacation 13,300 7.2% $ 166,346 14,189 8.0% $ 155,140
Sick 3,786 2.1% $ 32,838 3,215 1.8% $ 31,830
Furlough 2,176 1.2% $ - 1,458 0.8% $ -
Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout 3,354 1.8% $ 65,375 2,141 1.2% $ 4,672
Comp Time (Police) 1,354 0.7% $ 16,197 1,408 0.8% $ 19,279
Personal 197 0.1% $ 2,274 245 0.1% $ 1,656
Leave Without Pay 1,369 0.7% $ - 321 0.2% $ -
Other (description below) 2,449 1.3% $ 22,715 2,421 1.4% $ 2,935
Other includes: pay adjustments, military differential pay, committee meetings, worker compensation tracking/adjustments, etc.
Other Activity
Number of Pay Periods 5 5
Number of Payroll Checks Issued 2,309 2,140
Number of Pension Checks Issued 451 477
Total Pension Benefits Paid - Defined Benefit Plan $ 705,741 $ 756,303
ACCOUNTS PAYABLE
Number of Check Vouchers 1,385 780
Number of EFT Vouchers 277 278
Vouchers Dollar Amount Disbursed $ 22,673,481 $ 13,183,167
Paj 74
Page 3 of 8
City of Dover
Finance Department
Monthly Report – August 2010
General Fund Summary
17% of
Budget YTD Balance Budget
Beginning Balance - Unaudited $ 2,277,575 $ 2,688,521 $ (410,946) 118.0%
Revenues
Court of Chancery Fees 645,000 - 645,000 0.0%
Fines & Police Revenues 881,502 90,422 791,080 10.3%
Franchise Fees 486,000 - 486,000 0.0%
Grants 831,850 14,212 817,638 1.7%
Intrafund Services 4,347,834 677,695 3,670,139 15.6%
Library & Recreation Revenues 665,689 32,669 633,020 4.9%
Licenses & Permits 2,457,675 1,475,507 982,168 60.0%
Property Taxes (Includes BID Revenue) (1) 11,035,326 10,596,171 439,155 96.0%
Sanitation Revenues 2,387,511 489,008 1,898,503 20.5%
Other Miscellaneous Revenues 365,250 25,365 339,885 6.9%
Transfers-In from Special Funds & Utilities
Civil Traffic Penalties 930,000 - 930,000 0.0%
Municipal Street Aid Fund 526,843 - 526,843 0.0%
Transfer Taxes 1,000,000 49,459 950,541 4.9%
Electric Fund 8,856,000 2,214,000 6,642,000 25.0%
Total Revenues 35,416,480 15,664,508 19,751,972 44.2%
Total Beginning Balance & Revenues $ 37,694,055 $ 18,353,029 $ 19,341,026 48.7%
Expenditures
City Clerk & Council $ 418,172 $ 56,542 $ 361,630 13.5%
Mayor, City Manager & Human Resources 1,008,803 126,839 881,964 12.6%
Police & Police Extra Duty 12,907,889 1,776,236 11,131,653 13.8%
Public Services 4,574,682 636,255 3,938,427 13.9%
Central Services 2,422,663 333,734 2,088,929 13.8%
Planning & Inspections 1,943,804 273,591 1,670,213 14.1%
Finance, Info Tech & Customer Services 2,444,787 461,940 1,982,847 18.9%
Library & Recreation 1,904,696 291,434 1,613,262 15.3%
Fire Department 709,862 121,813 588,049 17.2%
Assessor 197,249 33,786 163,463 17.1%
Insurance 600,000 164,033 435,967 27.3%
OPEB - Retiree’s Health Care Contribution 1,297,509 324,664 972,845 25.0%
Pension Trust Contribution - Unfunded liability 1,090,000 343,750 746,250 31.5%
Police Pension Trust Contribution - State Grant 620,000 - 620,000 0.0%
Street Lights 985,000 152,563 832,437 15.5%
Debt Service 331,800 302,450 29,350 91.2%
Loss on sale of asset - - - 0.0%
Transfer to CDBG 6,000 - 6,000 0.0%
Provision for Uncollectible 10,000 - 10,000 0.0%
Transfers Out
Capital Asset Reserve - - - 0.0%
Capital Projects Fund 1,307,839 - 1,307,839 0.0%
Total Expenditures 34,780,755 5,399,630 29,381,125 15.5%
Budget Balance - Working Capital 2,913,300 - 2,913,300 0.0%
Total Budget Balance & Expenditures $ 37,694,055 $ 5,399,630 $ 32,294,425 14.3%
Reserve Balances
Contingency $ 417,971 $ 531,217
(1) Property Taxes are the taxes billed and not cash received. The outstanding receivable balance as of 8/31/10 is $1.5 million.
Paj 75
Page 4 of 8
City of Dover
Finance Department
Monthly Report – August 2010
Water/Wastewater Fund Summary
17% of
Budget YTD Balance Budget
Beginning Balance - Water - unaudited $ 943,545 $ 1,236,193 $ (292,648) 131.0%
Beginning Balance - Wastewater - unaudited $ 585,053 $ 902,719 $ (317,666) 154.3%
Beginning Balance - Kent County Treatment - unaudited $ (1,632,876) $ (1,872,081) $ 239,205 114.6%
Revenues
Water Fees 4,206,700 1,088,360 3,118,340 25.9%
Wastewater Fees 3,308,300 699,748 2,608,552 21.2%
Kent County Treatment Fees 4,275,600 813,911 3,461,689 19.0%
Water Tank Leases 299,400 5,272 294,128 1.8%
Miscellaneous 72,515 12,310 60,205 17.0%
Impact Fees - Water 357,000 48,533 308,467 13.6%
Impact Fees - Wastewater 323,000 42,117 280,883 13.0%
Total Revenues 12,842,515 2,710,251 10,132,264 21.1%
Total Beginning Balance & Revenues $ 12,738,237 $ 2,977,082 $ 9,761,155 23.4%
Expenses
Water/Wastewater Operating Divisions
Engineering & Inspection $ 642,878 $ 64,983 $ 577,895 10.1%
Water 412,588 60,140 352,448 14.6%
Water Treatment Plant 1,499,857 237,264 1,262,593 15.8%
Wastewater 969,762 104,761 865,001 10.8%
Construction & Inspection 392,561 57,394 335,167 14.6%
Kent County Treatment Fees 4,235,403 293,186 3,942,217 6.9%
Intrafund Services 1,272,331 179,982 1,092,349 14.1%
OPEB - Retiree’s Health Care Contribution 177,427 44,355 133,072 25.0%
Pension Trust Contribution - Unfunded liability 372,000 93,000 279,000 25.0%
Debt Service 562,601 69,387 493,214 12.3%
Transfers Out
Water I & E Fund 500,000 - 500,000 0.0%
Wastewater I & E Fund 500,000 - 500,000 0.0%
Capital Asset Reserve - Water 100,000 - 100,000 0.0%
Capital Asset Reserve - Wastewater 100,000 - 100,000 0.0%
Impact Fee Reserve - Water 110,597 - 110,597 0.0%
Impact Fee Reserve - Wastewater 6,802 - 6,802 0.0%
Total Expenses 11,854,807 1,204,452 10,650,355 10.2%
Budget Balances
Budget Balance - Working Capital - Water 1,348,501 - 1,348,501 0.0%
Budget Balance - Working Capital - Wastewater 1,127,608 - 1,127,608 0.0%
Budget Balance-Working Capital - Kent County Treatment (1,592,679) - (1,592,679) 0.0%
Total Budget Balances 883,430 - 883,430 0.0%
Total Budget Balances & Expenses $ 12,738,237 $ 1,204,452 $ 11,533,785 9.5%
Reserve Balances
Contingency-Water $ 126,607 $ 122,458
Contingency-Wastewater $ 141,575 $ 137,012
Impact Fee Reserve - Sewer NO BUDGET $ 3,857,076
Impact Fee Reserve - Water NO BUDGET $ 246,737
Bond Coverage Ratio (Covenant 1.20) 10.42 16.83
Paj 76
Page 5 of 8
City of Dover
Finance Department
Monthly Report – August 2010
Electric Revenue Fund Summary
17% of
Budget YTD Balance Budget
Beginning Balance - unaudited $ 12,086,275 $ 13,537,864 $ (1,451,589) 112.0%
Revenues
Sales to Customers 96,595,300 20,736,727 75,858,573 21.5%
Purchased Power Adjustment - Credit (2,000,000) (405,489) (1,594,511) 20.3%
Utility Tax 1,864,800 383,485 1,481,315 20.6%
Weyandt Hall Rents 186,816 49,559 137,257 26.5%
Miscellaneous Revenues 1,085,500 222,137 863,363 20.5%
Intrafund Service Receipts Water/Wastewater 299,442 24,555 274,887 8.2%
Total Revenues 98,031,858 21,010,974 77,020,884 21.4%
Total Beginning Balance & Revenues $ 110,118,133 $ 34,548,838 $ 75,569,295 31.4%
Expenses
Power Supply & Generation
Power Supply $ 48,059,699 $ 9,818,147 $ 38,241,552 20.4%
Power Supply Management/Incentive 2,280,000 425,506 1,854,494 18.7%
Capacity Charges 11,618,223 1,668,127 9,950,096 14.4%
PJM Charges - Load 11,850,876 2,925,324 8,925,552 24.7%
Total Power Supply 73,808,798 14,837,104 58,971,694 20.1%
Plant Operations 5,694,315 1,032,439 4,661,876 18.1%
Generation Fuels 297,820 2,807,991 (2,510,171) 942.8%
Capacity Credits (11,488,785) (1,552,301) (9,936,484) 13.5%
PJM Credits (720,797) (3,718,849) 2,998,052 515.9%
Total Generation (6,217,447) (1,430,720) (4,786,727) 23.0%
Total Power Supply & Plant 67,591,351 13,406,384 54,184,967 19.8%
Electric Operating Divisions:
Transmission/Distribution 3,206,515 467,021 2,739,494 14.6%
Electrical Engineering 1,842,903 155,448 1,687,455 8.4%
Administration 609,169 84,172 524,997 13.8%
Meter Reading 222,908 33,987 188,921 15.2%
Systems Operations 518,053 68,658 449,395 13.3%
Intrafund Services 3,374,945 522,268 2,852,677 15.5%
Utility Tax 1,864,800 383,485 1,481,315 20.6%
Interest on Deposits 54,500 4,504 49,996 8.3%
OPEB - Retirees Health Care Contribution 639,110 159,780 479,330 25.0%
OPEB Trust Contribution 1,200,000 - 1,200,000 0.0%
Pension Trust Contribution - Unfunded liability 833,000 208,250 624,750 25.0%
Green Energy Payment to DEMEC 128,600 29,351 99,249 22.8%
Accounts Receivable Write-Offs 135,000 - 135,000 0.0%
Inventory Write-Offs 175,000 - 175,000 0.0%
Debt Service 4,058,700 677,451 3,381,249 16.7%
Transfers Out:
General Fund 8,856,000 2,214,000 6,642,000 25.0%
Electric Improvement & Extension Fund 3,500,000 875,000 2,625,000 25.0%
Depreciation Reserve 1,250,000 - 1,250,000 0.0%
Rate Stabilization Reserve 1,300,000 - 1,300,000 0.0%
Pension COLA - - - 0.0%
Total Expenses 101,360,554 19,289,759 82,070,795 19.0%
Budget Balance - Working Capital 8,757,579 - 8,757,579 0.0%
Total Budget Balance & Expenses $ 110,118,133 $ 19,289,759 $ 90,828,374 17.5%
Reserve Balances
Contingency Reserve $ 1,071,054 $ 1,041,226
Insurance Reserve $ 408,503 $ 397,146
Rate Stabilization Reserve $ 6,171,027 $ 4,783,653
Bond Coverage Ratio (Covenant 1.25) 1.51 4.67
Megawatt Hours Sold & Purchased
Sales to Customers MWh (excluding Street Light MWh) 707,536 154,028
Sales per MWh $ 136.524 $ 134.630
Purchased/Generated MWh 738,215 161,918
All In MWh Supply & Generation $ 91.561 $ 82.797
Paj 77
Page 6 of 8
City of Dover
Finance Department
Monthly Report – August 2010
General Capital Project Fund Summary
17% of
Budget YTD Balance Budget
Beginning Balance - Projects - Unaudited $ 65,479 $ 227,592 $ (162,113) 347.6%
Beginning Balance - Library - Unaudited $ - $ 34,583 $ (34,583) 0.0%
Revenues
Transfer from General Fund for Projects 1,307,839 - 1,307,839 0.0%
State Grant - Library 3,343,520 4,281 3,339,239 0.1%
Police Grant 18,000 - 18,000 0.0%
Library Bond Issue/Contributions 1,000,000 30,000 970,000 3.0%
Transfer from Library Reserve 2,343,519 - 2,343,519 0.0%
Transfer from Capital Asset Reserve 140,000 - 140,000 0.0%
Interest Earnings 10,900 1,654 9,246 15.2%
Income from Sale of Assets - 1,856 (1,856) 0.0%
Total Revenues 8,163,778 37,791 8,125,987 0.5%
Total Beginning Balance & Revenue $ 8,229,257 $ 299,966 $ 7,929,291 3.6%
Expenditures
Fire $ 288,210 $ 3,262 $ 284,948 1.1%
Grounds Maintenance 63,675 - 63,675 0.0%
Library 6,687,039 - 6,687,039 0.0%
Recreation 45,000 3,927 41,073 8.7%
Police 282,380 - 282,380 0.0%
Streets 481,055 - 481,055 0.0%
Sanitation 246,075 - 246,075 0.0%
Information Technology 12,000 - 12,000 0.0%
Mayor 31,500 - 31,500 0.0%
Total Expenditures 8,136,934 7,189 8,129,745
Budget Balance - Projects 92,323 - 92,323 0.0%
Total Budget Balance & Expenditures $ 8,229,257 $ 7,189 $ 8,222,068 0.1%
Reserve Balances
Capital Asset Replacement Reserve $ 116,465 $ 249,532
Library Reserve $ 1,243,686 $ 3,208,365
Parkland/Recreation $ 185,045 $ 221,943
Paj 78
Page 7 of 8
City of Dover
Finance Department
Monthly Report – August 2010
Water/Wastewater Improvement & Extension Fund Summary
17% of
Budget YTD Balance Budget
Beginning Balance - Water - unaudited $ 743,431 $ 1,590,874 $ (847,443) 214.0%
Beginning Balance - Wastewater - unaudited $ 257,168 $ (45,665) $ 302,833 -17.8%
Beginning Balance - Bond Proceeds - Wastewater $ 286,500 $ - $ 286,500 0.0%
Revenues
Bond Issue Proceeds Series 2010 3,016,200 - 3,016,200 0.0%
Interest Earned - 3,068 (3,068) 0.0%
Transfer from Water Operating Fund for Water 500,000 - 500,000 0.0%
Transfer from Wastewater Operating Fund for Wastewater 500,000 - 500,000 0.0%
Transfer from Impact Fee Reserve - Wastewater 242,040 - 242,040 0.0%
Total Revenues 4,258,240 335,636 3,922,604 7.9%
Total Beginning Balance & Revenues $ 5,545,339 $ 1,880,845 $ 3,664,494 33.9%
Expenses
Water $ 620,000 $ 4,831 $ 615,169 0.8%
Wastewater 1,560,700 517,249 1,043,451 33.1%
Total Expenses 2,180,700 522,080 1,658,620 23.9%
Budget Bal-Working Capital - Wastewater Bond Proceeds 2,153,140 - 2,153,140 0.0%
Budget Balance - Working Capital - Water 623,431 - 623,431 0.0%
Budget Balance - Working Capital - Wastewater 588,068 - 588,068 0.0%
Total Budget Balances 3,364,639 - 3,364,639 0.0%
Total Budget Balances & Expenses $ 5,545,339 $ 522,080 $ 5,023,259 9.4%
Reserve Balances
Capital Asset Replacement - Water $ 319,003 $ 212,042
Capital Asset Replacement - Wastewater $ 168,767 $ 66,579
Paj 79
Page 8 of 8
City of Dover
Finance Department
Monthly Report – August 2010
Electric Improvement & Extension Fund Summary
17% of
Budget YTD Balance Budget
Beginning Balance - unaudited $ 1,688,861 $ 3,429,624 $ (1,740,763) 203.1%
Beginning Balance Bond - unaudited $ - $ 415,585 $ (415,585) 0.0%
Revenues
Interest Earnings 40,700 7,055 33,645 17.3%
Transfer from Electric Revenue Fund 3,500,000 875,000 2,625,000 25.0%
Department of Energy Grant - 58,559 (58,559) 0.0%
Income from Sale of Assets - 2,280 (2,280) 0.0%
Total Revenues 3,540,700 942,894 2,597,806 26.6%
Total Beginning Balance & Revenues $ 5,229,561 $ 4,788,103 $ 441,458 91.6%
Expenses
Power Plant $ 1,480,068 $ 579,978 $ 900,090 39.2%
Transmission/Distribution 739,000 77,956 661,044 10.5%
Electrical Engineering 1,390,429 189,734 1,200,695 13.6%
Total Expenses 3,609,497 847,668 2,761,829 23.5%
Budget Balance - Working Capital 1,620,064 - 1,620,064 0.0%
Total Budget Balance & Expenses $ 5,229,561 $ 847,668 $ 4,381,893 16.2%
Reserve Balances
Depreciation Reserve $ 9,572,390 $ 8,017,983
Future Capacity Reserve $ 9,294,563 $ 9,020,359
Paj 80
Dover Police Department
Monthly Report
To
Mayor & City Council
“To Protect and Serve”
August 2010
Paj 81
September 14, 2010
Honorable Carleton E. Carey, Sr., Mayor
Members of Dover City Council
City Hall
Dover, DE 19901
Mayor Carey and Council Members:
The following is the report on Police Department activities for the month of August 2010:
COMPLAINTS
Total complaints received through August 31st 30,000
numbered 23,080. This is an increase of 3,595* 23,080
complaints over the same time period for last year. 24,000 20,565 19,917
19,935 18,668
18,000
*Such a large increase is due in part to all calls for
service are now included in total. 12,000
6,000
0
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS
18
13 Cases Reported in
12 August
Cases Cleared in
7 7
6 6 4 August
6 Cases Cleared from
2 Previous Months
0 0
0
Burglary Robbery Rape
Paj 82
Report to Mayor and Council
August 2010
Page 2
QUALITY OF LIFE TASK SECTION
ENFORCEMENT ACTION ARRESTS
ABANDONED VEHICLES 3
ALCOHOL VIOLATIONS/DUI’S 7
ASSIST OTHER 1
WARRANTS ON FILE 1
BIKE ON SIDEWALK 2
CITY PARK VIOLATIONS 0
CRIMINAL ARRESTS 30
DRUG RELATED ARRESTS 20
LOUD MUSIC 6
MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONS 12
PARKING VIOLATIONS 20
PEDDLER 0
MEETINGS 35
PROSTITUTION 0
COLLECTION OF DELINQUENT DCO’S 0
WANTED CHECKS/CPC’S 18
TRAFFIC ARRESTS 96
WARNINGS 46
FUGITIVE 10
TOTAL ARRESTS 307
TRAFFIC ARRESTS 18,000
12,736 12,558 12,547 13,412 14,073
The department issued 14,073 traffic citations through this
reporting period. This is an increase of 661 citations over the 12,000
number issued during the same period last year.
6,000
0
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
TRAFFIC CRASHES
Through August 31st, Dover Police investigated 1,194 traffic crashes. This is a decrease of 43 accidents investigated during the
same period last year.
1,800
1,418 1,357
1,262 1,237 1,194
1,200
600
0
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Paj 83
Report to Mayor and Council
August 2010
Page 3
911 CENTER
10%
During the month of August, our 911 Center handled
a total of 10,418 calls averaging 337 calls per day.
911 Landline Dispatchers handled 2,114 calls on the 911 wireless
20%
911 Wireless lines, an average of 69 calls per day and 1,078 calls
on the 911 landlines, an average of 35 calls per day.
Administrative
70%
CITY ORDINANCE SUMMONS 8,000
6,633 6,325 6,094
st 5,360 5,595
Through August 31 , we issued 5,595 city ordinance
4,555 4,537
summons, an increase of 235 summons over August of 4,188 3,622 3,748
last year. *Note: of those summonses issued in August, 4,000
26 were issued for handicapped parking violations, 4 for
fire lane parking violations, 97 for false alarms (58 for 3-5
alarms, 24 for 6-9 alarms, 5 for 10-15 alarms, and 10 for
16 or more alarms) and 40 for noise violations (32 for
0
vehicle violations and 8 for residence violations). 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
ISSUED PAID
Listed below are the major crimes and activities that occurred during the month of August:
• On August 3, 2010, the Dover Police Department in conjunction with Target held the National Night Out 2010 in the
Target parking lot on John Hunn Brown Road. This year’s event included several first responder static displays which
consisted of several police cars from various local municipalities, a Dover Air Force Flight Line Fire Truck, the Dover
Fire Department Ladder Truck, the Levy Court Command Post, the Dover Fire Marshall Response Truck and a Kent
County Paramedic Vehicle. The Police Department had on display the SORT Vehicle, the CNT Vehicle, the Crime
Scene Van, and the Mobile Command Post. The K-9 officers provided two demonstrations and the Motorcycle Section
put on a demonstration through a cone course. D.A.R.E. Officers and QOL/Community Policing Officers provided
assistance as well. This year’s event was attended by over 700 individuals.
• On August 4, 2010, officers assigned to the Drugs, Vice, & Organized Crime Section arrested a subject in the parking
lot of Walgreens Pharmacy after he was found to have 122 doses of LSD, 15 Alprazolam pills, 2 Cyclobenzatrine pills,
and a knife.
• On Thursday, August 12, 2010, officers assigned to the Drugs, Vice, & Organized Crime Section contacted a subject in
his vehicle. A pound of marijuana was recovered. A subsequent search of his residence on Stoney Drive revealed an
additional 38 pounds of marijuana and related drug paraphernalia. He was charged with Trafficking Marijuana,
Possession with the Intent to Deliver Marijuana, Maintaining a Dwelling for Keeping Controlled Substances,
Conspiracy 2nd Degree and Possession of Drug Paraphernalia. Investigation revealed that two other subjects also lived
in the residence. Those two subjects were charged with Maintaining a Dwelling for Keeping Controlled Substances and
Conspiracy 2nd Degree along with simple Possession of Marijuana and Drug Paraphernalia.
• On Saturday, August 14, 2010, a Dover Officer checked the registration on a vehicle being driven around the Dover
Mall. This motor vehicle check found the vehicle was stolen out of Newark, Delaware. The officer then stopped the
vehicle and the operator (suspect) fled on foot. The officer chased the suspect into Macy's and the suspect began
throwing clothing at the officer and knocking down display racks in an attempt to slow down the officer. As the suspect
exited Macy's, he was tasered and taken into custody.
Paj 84
Report to Mayor and Council
August 2010
Page 4
Major crimes and activities that occurred during the month of August continued:
• On Friday, August 20, 2010, an unknown suspect broke the glass on the east side of the Dover Library to gain entry.
Once inside the suspect removed the donation bottle for the new library building fund which contained a small amount
of money. The donation bottle was a blue colored water cooler bottle.
• On Tuesday August 17, 2010, a Dover Officer stopped a suspect, who was on a bicycle in possession of numerous
packs of cigarettes and several bottles of assorted alcohol. That same morning, Detectives had responded to Mr. B's
Liquor Warehouse for a burglary in which they were able to link the suspect to, not only to the property recovered but
also through surveillance footage. The suspect broke a window to gain entry and was wearing a hooded sweatshirt in an
effort to avoid being identified.
• On August 21, 2010, Dover Officers responded to BayHealth for a report of a subject who had been shot in the right
arm. Investigation revealed that the 28 year old male victim was standing in yard of friend’s residence, when they heard
several gunshots and then he realized he had been shot. Victim was transported to the emergency room by a neighbor
who also heard the shots. Victim advised that he has no idea who shot him or why he was shot. Victim was admitted to
Bayhealth in stable condition.
• On August 23, 2010, Dover Officers attempted to contact 17 year old subject for loitering at the corner of South New
and Reed streets. He then fled on foot tossing a loaded .22 Cal handgun to the ground. The suspect was apprehended
and taken into custody.
• On August 24, 2010, officers assigned to the Drugs, Vice & Organized Crime Section conducted a search warrant at a
residence on Vera Way. Three subjects were arrested after Officers located 124.3 grams of marijuana, half a pill of
Endocet, half a pill of oxycodone, and over $1000.00 in cash. All three were released on unsecured bonds.
• On August 24, 2010, a victim was sleeping inside her home when she heard a knock on her bedroom door. The 18 year
old victim answered the door to find a subject had entered her home without permission. The subject then grabbed
victim and attempted to rape her. The victim’s dog became aggressive toward the subject and he then fled the
residence. The subject was apprehended without incident in the early morning hours of August 25, 2010 at his
residence.
• On August 24, 2010, Dover Officers responded to a report of numerous shots fired in Manchester Square by two
separate groups of individuals. One of the groups ran from the scene to a residence on Willis Road and refused to come
out after being surrounded by officers. The Dover Police Special Operations Response Team arrived and 8 subjects
then voluntarily surrendered and were taken into custody. The second group involved fled back into two residences on
Stevenson Drive and a total of 7 additional subjects were removed by Dover Police. All subjects were taken in for
questioning and as a result, two subjects were arrested for their part in the incident. Investigators have determined that
this appears to be gang related between the two separate groups. Dover Officers released the other subjects pending
further investigation. As a result of the investigation, Detectives have obtained arrest warrants for five additional
suspects in connection with the shooting investigation. Three of the five have been arrested, two still remain at large.
• On the evening of August 25, 2010, officers assigned to the Drugs, Vice, & Organized Crime Section, with the
assistance of officers from the Quality of Life Section, conducted an undercover Prostitution Operation in the
downtown Dover area. During the operation three subjects contacted the undercover police officer and agreed to pay
money in exchange for sexual acts.
Respectfully Submitted,
James E. Hosfelt, Jr.
Chief of Police
Paj 85
Monthly Report
August 2010
Office of City Assessor
Paj 86
Assessor’s Office
Major Updates
June‐10 July‐10 Aug‐10
Assessment Change $312,856,020 ‐$101,231,200 ‐$4,240,100
Residential Sales Ratio Report
Sales in Study Total Assessed Value Total Sale Price Ratio PRD
20 $3,079,810 $3,503,253 0.90 0.96
Ratio – Assessed Value divided by Sale Price.
PRD – Mean – A PRD above 1.03 tends to indicate assessment regressivity – high valued properties are under
appraised relative to low valued properties. A PRD below .98 tends to indicate assessment progressivity – high
valued properties are relatively over appraised.
Paj 87
Assessor’s Office
Points of Interest
Scanning & Filing
‐ All new deeds are being scanned and attached to the CAMA software for easy retrieval.
‐ All appeal documents and correspondence are being scanned and attached to the CAMA software for easy
retrieval.
‐ All deeds from 2006 through current day are scanned and attached to our software.
‐ Hard Copies of original property record cards are being scanned and attached to the CAMA software for easy
retrieval of previous years history.
Assessor’s Office
‐ Adjusting clerical errors. (See attached spreadsheet)
Paj 89
Clerical Errors
Owner Parcel Old Value New Value Reason Location Clerical Error
Capitol School District ED05‐075.00‐01‐03.00 $ 2,356,400 $ ‐ Exempt 59718 coded incorrectly
Scott, Maynard W & Carolyn L ED05‐076.12‐04‐07.00 $ 57,500 $ 87,000 Clerical Error 5952 parcel‐split
Scott, Maynard W & Carolyn L ED05‐076.12‐04‐07.01 $ 102,400 $ 32,200 Clerical Error 60622 parcel‐split
Paj 90
CITY MANAGER’S
MONTHLY REPORT
August 2010
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 91
Customer Services
1,291 payments were processed online or by telephone in August 2010.
City of Dover property taxes were due August 31, 2010. As of September 1, 2010 the delinquent property taxes to-
tal $1,415,089.21 for all tax years.
Budget and Program Development
Participated in the IUE-CWA contract negotiations.
Attended web outsourcing vendor evaluation meetings.
Held annual Budget Post Mortem meeting with departments.
Human Resources
Continued contract negotiations with labor unions (IUE-CWA and IBEW).
30 employees participated in the Summer Blood Drive Challenge.
Information Technology
Continued web outsourcing vendor evaluation meetings.
Parks, Recreation, & Library
The Library recorded 880 people attending 26 children’s programs.
Fifty-nine were recorded in Job Center and 27 attended twp teen programs.
Concerts on the Green, held on Thursdays, has hosted 1,010 spectators for the month of August.
Delaware Senior Olympics hosted approximately 175 patrons at Dover Park for a Veteran’s Service.
Public Services
Resolved various issues related to the Curbside Recycling Program vender changeover .
Finalized several Fiscal 2011 equipment purchases and issued purchase orders.
Public Utilities
August 2010 had the least amount of electrical outages for the month, in a 20 year history.
2 City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 92
PUBLIC AFFAIRS
TOTAL #
DEPARTMENT # OF DAYS
COMPLAINTS
Planning/Code Enforcement
108 6.3 days
(property code violations)
Police (community policing) - 0 days
Public Services
- Grounds -
- Sanitation
0 days
-
- Streets -
Public Utilities (electric outages) 2 1.3 days
Site Admin/Other Departments
- City Clerk’s Office 1
13.39 days
- Customer Service 3
Community Outreach, Training and Education Events – August 2010
Two- Library Public Relations Committee Meetings
Newsletter distributed to City of Dover
Other Activities Aug 2010 July 2010 FYTD
Facebook - New Posts 26 21 47
Facebook - Page Views 1,004 716 1,720
Facebook –Replies to Questions 37 17 54
Press Releases 9 16 25
Ceremonial Documents 16 25 41
(Proclamations, Certificates, Letters of Welcome)
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010 3
Paj 93
CENTRAL SERVICES
Fleet Operations & Maintenance Items on Hand with no Usage over 36 Months
70000 Costs 120 $1,000,000
60000 100
Total Work Orders
50000 $800,000
80
Total Dollars
40000
60 $600,000
30000
40
20000
$400,000
10000 20
0 0 $200,000
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb M ar Apr M ay Jun Jul Aug Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- M ar- Apr- M ay- Jun- Jul- Aug-
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Total Dollars Total Work Orders Electric Water General
Work Orders: 70 Electric: $427,145.32
Fleet Maintenance: $11,873.75 (excludes Melvin’s Sunoco) Water: $ 25,851.22
Fuel: $41,373.18 General: $ 42,339.35
Stock Purchases by Fund Contingency & Warehouse Stock
$500,000
$4,500,000 2,700
2,600
$400,000 $4,000,000 2,500
Total Line Items
2,400
$300,000 $3,500,000 2,300
Total Dollars
2,200
$200,000 $3,000,000 2,100
2,000
$2,500,000 1,900
$100,000
1,800
$2,000,000 1,700
$0
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb M ar Apr M ay Jun Jul Aug
Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- M ar- Apr- M ay- Jun- Jul- Aug-
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Electric Water General Total Dollar Value Total Line Items
Electric: $ 48,509.04 Total Dollar Value: $2,664,918.74
Water: $ 10,844.17 Total Line Items: 1,815
General: $ 4,975.63
Major Program Updates
MEASURE AUGUST 2010 AUGUST 2009 DIFFERENCE
Issue Effectiveness (>90%)
How often the warehouse has what cus-
98.0% 99.3% -1.31%
tomers need when it’s needed.
[issues / (issues + back orders)] * 100
Turn Over Rate (4-5 per yr.)
Indicates that the material stocked is the 1 every 20.9 years 1 every 23.9 years -3.01 years
material being used.
Bids for non-inventory items converted to
1 of 1 Bids 7 of 7 Bids (FY10 Total)
purchase orders within timeframe -
100% 100%
(Quantity and Percentage)
Sealed bids prepared, received & distrib-
16 of 17 Bids 36 of 38 Bids (FY10 Total)
uted within 7 working days of receipt -0.6%
94.1% FYTD 94.7%
(Quantity and Percentage)
Scheduled Preventative Maintenance 26 of 28 appointments kept
8 of 25 appointments kept
appointments being kept. (FY10 Total) -60.8%
32.0%
(Quantity and Percentage) 92.8%
399,185 pieces
Mail receiving lowest discounted rate 36,015 pieces
(FY10 Total) 0.11%
(Quantity and Percentage) 96.0%
95.9%
Routine work orders completed within 5 41 work orders completed 29 work orders completed
1.9%
days (Quantity and Percentage) 91.1% 93.5%
Emergency work orders completed within 7 work orders completed 10 work order completed
-
2 days (Quantity and Percentage) 100% 100%
4 City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 94
CUSTOMER SERVICES
WORK ORDERS PROCESSED EXTENSIONS OF CREDIT
3,500
900
783
738 714
3,000 800 698
628
2,262 613 612
700
2,500 556 568 547 556
1,984 1,970 1,972
1,848 1,841 1,833
600
468
1,737 1,709
1,526
2,000 500
1,382 1,355 1,399 400
356
1,500
300
1,000 200
100
500
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug 2009 2009 2009 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010
2009 2009 2009 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010
CUTS FOR NON PAYMENT
CUSTOMER PAYMENT USAGE
$1,800,000
34,257
32,289
40,000 $1,600,000
35,000 $1,400,000
30,000
$1,200,000
25,000
$1,000,000
11,778 11,606
20,000
15,000 $800,000
4,886 5,742
10,000 3,925 4,025 $600,000
5,000 24 23 $400,000 $329,397
0 $207,161 $209,602
$200,000 $97,612
Drive-Thru Over the Mail, Drop Credit Cards Bank Drafts
Window Counter Box $-
2011 YTD 2010YTD August 2010 August 2009 FYTD11 FYTD10
FY 2011 FY 2010
Major Program Updates Aug 2010 Aug 2009 Difference
Year-to-Date Year-to-Date
Number of Customers Served 33,809 30,930 2,879 56,511 54,229
Final Bills 851 674 177 1,621 1,385
Estimated Bills 154 141 13 309 274
Penalties Posted $ 11,946 $ 10,567 $ 1,379 $ 35,283 $ 31,328
Extensions of Credit - Amount Extended $ 247,732 $ 143,011 $ 104,722 $ 400,053 $ 290,089
Balance Transfers $ 1,686 $ 1,142 $ 544 $ 4,667 $ 11,506
Utility Collections $ 24,997 $ 17,336 $ 7,661 $ 53,287 $ 37,615
Special Assessments $ 1,331 $ 31,047 $ (29,716) $ 1,711 $ 31,607
Miscellaneous Billings $ 217,374 $ 79,676 $ 137,698 $ 259,352 $ 213,235
CNP through Disconnect Collars 8 31 (23) 17 62
Court Cases - - - - -
Tamperings 4 2 2 11 3
Taxes Levied $ 11,112,832 $ - $ 11,112,832 $ 10,112,893 $ 9,795,998
Billing Adjustments $ 339,151 $ 2,077 $ 337,074 $ 273 $ 53,945
Total Taxes Collected $ 660,788 $ 7,537,066 $ (6,876,278) $ 8,563,471 $ 8,498,223
Taxes Outstanding $ 10,112,893 $ 1,243,830 $ 8,869,063 $ 1,549,695 $ 10,026,803
Payments in Lieu $ 1,500 $ 1,500 - $ 3,000 $ 3,000
Billing Accuracy (on schedule billings) 99.0% 99.0% - 99.0% 99.0%
Bills Published on Schedule 99.9% 99.9% - 99.9% 99.9%
Meters Read on Schedule 99.9% 99.9% - 99.9% 99.9%
Customer Satisfaction Rating 99.7% 99.7% - 99.7% 99.7%
Deliquent Accounts Collected 99.7% 99.7% - 99.7% 99.7%
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010 5
Paj 95
HUMAN RESOURCES
Customer Service Contacts Payroll Hours
700 9,000
600 8,000
7,000
500
6,000
400
5,000
300
4,000
200
3,000
100
2,000
0 1,000
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug 0
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Aug
Jul 10
Citizens Assisted 79 173 112 43 30 25 20 25 68 55 50 42 103 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Employees Assisted 43 39 52 79 65 75 37 70 97 172 85 78 79 Overtime 1,906 1,785 1,463 1,808 1,564 3,293 1,556 1,415 1,602 1,316 1,779 1,874 1,133
Applications Processed 122 373 174 1 0 0 35 0 2 0 75 4 482 Sick 2,631 1,482 1,508 1,903 2,018 4,832 2,173 3,320 1,969 961 731.5 1,749 1,466
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug
Category Total
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
*
Caucasian 327 324 325 323 322 320 320 318 315 315 315 314 314 N/A
*
Minorities 62 60 60 61 61 61 61 61 61 62 63 62 62 N/A
Hired - 1 2 1 1 1 - 1 - 2 2 - 2 13
Terminated/Resigned/
4 6 1 2 2 4 - 3 4 1 1 2 2 32
Retired
Promoted - 1 - 1 - 1 2 1 6 3 - 1 - 16
Jobs Posted 1 1 1 - 3 1 3 3 - 3 - 2 3 21
Workers Comp. Injuries 3 3 1 1 - 4 2 2 3 4 8 5 6 42
Workers Comp. Hours 417 283 103 25 26 23 50 186 358 299 123 11 9 1,913
Insurance Claims 9 1 2 5 2 1 10 9 6 7 10 8 2 72
Workers’ Comp. hours may not be the result of injuries that occurred during the current month.
Full-time Employees: 361
Part-time Employees: 15 (4 Pitts Center, 1 Recreation, 11 Library)
Numbers do not reflect, temporary, seasonal, relief fire dispatchers, committee or council members.
Hired: Utility Maintenance Mechanic I and Utility Maintenance Mechanic II
Resigned: Motor Equipment Operator I (Streets) and Part-time Library Clerk
Jobs Posted: Motor Equipment Operator II (Water/Wastewater), Communications Operator (Police) and Lineman
First Class (Public Utilities)
Unfilled/Open Positions Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug
By Department 09 09 09 10* 10 10 10 10** 10 10 10
Public Utilities 8 8 8 9 10 13 12 12 11 12 5 3
Public Services 1 1 2 43 3 3 3 4 4 1 2
Police 3 3 3 4 4 4 56 5 5 3 2 2
All Other Departments 8 9 9 10 10 10 10 10 11 12 5 6
Totals 20 21 22 27 26 27 30 30 31 31 31 13* 13
30
*January 2010: Public Services was overstated by one
*April 2010: Police understated by one. Six vacancies existed in April. June 2010: One Officer began terminal leave in April.
*May 2010: Incorrect numbers reported.
Individuals is on terminal leave and is not included in totals in chart: Public Utilities - 1
One vacant position filled with temp, position included in totals in chart: Central Services
*Significant decrease in number of Open Positions due to positions no longer being funded during Budget Process.
Public Utilities: Grounds Worker (2), Motor Equipment Operator II/Water (1)
Public Services: Motor Equipment Operator/Grounds (1) and Motor Equipment Operator/Streets (1)
Police: Police Master Corporal (1), Communications Operator (1)
All Other Departments: Custodian I (1), Librarian I (1), Assistant Library Director (1), Library Clerk (1), Admin Asst/City Clerk **Currently being filled with a tempo-
rary employee (1), Programmer Analyst (1)
6 City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 96
HUMAN RESOURCES
continued
Bonus Program Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug
Total
Category 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Stop Program-Sensibly
Taking Off Pounds(weigh- 4 20 57 - 13 20 - 20 24 41 42 42 29 312
ins)
Caught Doing it Right-
Promotes employees
productivity & creativity
- 1 2 2 2 1 - - - - - 2 3 13
(submissions)
Breathe Program-Rewards
for ending tobacco use - 1 - - 2 1 - - - 1 1 - - 6
(submissions)
Ducs in a Row-Doing Useful
Community Service - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
(submissions)
Workers Comp Injuries
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug-
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Public Utilities Public Services Police Others
Public Utilities: 1 Public Services: 4 Police: 1 All Other Depts.: 0
Workers Comp Hours
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug-
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Public Utilities Public Services Police Others
Public Utilities: 0 Public Services: 9 Police: 0 All Other Depts.: 0
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010 7
Paj 97
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
Service Requests Resolved Citizen Action Center - Customers w/ New Issues
200 178
170
182 177 150
162 161 163 127
153 151 153 153 124
130
150 123
132
102 108
110
100 90 73
79
70 53 59 54
50 50 41 36 34 32
30
0 10
Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug-
Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug-
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Programming Requests Completed Page Views - City of Dover Web Page
30 90,000
25 80,000
25 22
20 20 20 70,000
19
20
Pages View ed
60,000
15 15 14 15
50,000
15
77,138
69,485
11
66,744 65,764 66,869
40,000
65,415 60,065 61,049
9 9
52,462
10 30,000
36,994 38,684 39,610
30,819
20,000
5
10,000
0 0
*
Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug- Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug-
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Same
Current Last
Performance Indicators Month
Month Month
Last Year
iSeries Availability 100% 100% 100%
Server Availability 100% 100% 100%
AS/400 Connections
42% 40% 36%
(concurrent/authorized users)
PCs Supported 343 341 350
Scheduled PCs Replaced - - -
Servers Supported 16 16 16
People Trained 3 8 23
Availability Statistics based on 7:00 AM until 5:00 PM Monday—Friday
8 City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 98
PARKS, RECREATION & LIBRARY
Library
Adult Services Children Services
3500 1200
3000 1000
2500
800
2000
600
1500
400
1000
500 200
0 0
A ug- Sep- Oct- No v- Dec- Jan- Feb- M ar- A pr- M ay- Jun- Jul- A ug- A ug- Sep- Oct- No v- Dec- Jan- Feb- M ar- A pr- M ay- Jun- Jul- A ug-
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Reference Reader's A dviso ry Outreach Electro nic A ssistance Reference Reader's A dviso ry Outreach Electro nic A ssistance
Reference: 81 Reader’s Advisory: 5 Reference: 108 Reader’s Advisory: 51
Outreach: 0 Electronic Assistance: 97 Outreach: 0 Electronic Assistance: 12
CIRCULATION AUGUST 10 FYTD 11 AUGUST 09 FYTD 10
Dover Residents 18,779 38,190 17,638 36,467
Kent County Residents* 15,818 32,352 17,040 33,554
Non-County Residents 1,243 2,581 1,217 2,438
REGISTRATIONS
Dover Residents 291 560 271 549
Kent County Residents* 122 265 154 345
Non-County Residents 11 25 13 34
OTHER
Visiting Patrons 35,845 70,198 36,262 72,617
Meeting Room Usage 300 420 140 280
Photocopier Usage 1,830 3,867 1,719 3,370
Dial-A-Story 1,518 3,377 1,143 3,455
Computer Usage 5,089 10,028 5,351 10,596
Holds (Total) 8,705 17,710 6,200 12,377
*Breakout of Kent County Residential Statistics
Circulation Registrations
Harrington: 196 Harrington: 1
Smyrna: 1,091 Smyrna: 15
Milford: 102 Milford: 1
Outside City Limits: 14,429 Outside City Limits: 105
Total Registered Users: (Card Holders)
City: 16,332 County: 13,350 New Castle & Sussex Counties: 6,491
Other Points of Interest:
Interlibrary: 3,371 items loaned out Technical services: 1,423 items added
3,143 items borrowed 606 items deleted
Volunteers: 350.25 hours of service completed
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010 9
Paj 99
Parks and Recreation
Recreation Revenue Recreation Revenue Breakdown
$30,000
$28,825
$35,000
$25,000
$22,518
$30,000
$19,813
$20,000
$25,000
$15,745 $15,682 $15,000
$12,413 $12,644
$20,000
$10,734 $10,000
$7,842
$15,000
$6,466 $7,451
$10,000
$3,829 $4,953 $5,000
$5,000 $0
$0 A ug- Sep- Oct- No v- Dec- Jan- Feb- M ar- A pr- M ay- Jun- Jul- A ug-
Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug- 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
General Rental Payments Sports Leagues Trips
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
General: $2,501 Rental Payments: $2,032 Sports: $914
Leagues: $9,920 Trips: $315
Rentals AUGUST 10 FYTD 11 AUGUST 09 FYTD 10
Baseball/Softball Field Rentals* 19 55 29 81
Dover Park Pavilions (2) 1 17 0 18
Multipurpose/Field Hockey Field Rentals* 26 51 22 44
Recreation Center – Dover Park 30 68 9 32
Silver Lake Pavilions (2) / Schutte (1) 10 18 9 24
Soccer Field Rentals* 3 4 4 6
Stage – Mobile Platform 4 9 4 10
*These numbers reflect groups that utilized our facilities during August.
Program Attendance* AUGUST 10 FYTD 11 AUGUST 09 FYTD 10
Yogalates 2 9 Not Offered
*This number reflects activities that took place in August. (Not included on the JWP report.)
Pi tts Center - Total Program Attendence
FREE Open Gym Registration Cards* - through 8/30/2010
Total Cards Issued: 3,697
15,000
12,043
City Residents: 1,686 - (46%)
Non-City Residents: 2,011 - (54%)
# of people
10,000 - Kent County: 1,602 - (43%)
7,374
6,082 5,753
- Sussex County: 137 - (4%)
3,975 - New Castle County: 93 - (2%)
5,000 2,995 3,329
2,431 2,018 2,307 2,041 - Out of State: 179 - (5%)
1,175 1,315
0
*The cards permit entrance to the facility during sched-
Aug- Sep- Oct- Nov- Dec- Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug-
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 uled Public Gym Periods at no charge.
10 City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 100
PUBLIC SERVICES
Administration
Administrative review and inspection services continued on all residential and commercial developments.
The following residential subdivisions are in various phases of construction:
Oak Shadows Emerald Pointe Lexington Glenn
Village of Westover (Phase VI) Farthing Woods Nottingham Meadows
Stoney Creek (Phase II) Clearview Meadows Village of Cannon Mill
Somerset Park Patriot Village Eden Hill (Residential)
SANITATION
Monthly Total Refuse (Tons) Sanitation Hours
1,038
1,500
1200
1,041
971
1,012 1,002 1,029 1,028 1,018
987 983 1000
928 919
1,000 833 815
800 653
636
522 569 569 580 571
426 419 470 439 600
376 408
500 319 318 354
233
167 400
200 76
- 30 10
3
Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug 0
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 Bulk Collection Mechanized Hand Trash Container Electronic Goods
Collection Collection Repair/Delivery Pickup
Bulk Automated Aug 10 Aug 09
AUGUST 10 FYTD 11 AUGUST 09 FYTD 10
Trips to DSWA Sandtown Landfill 262 537 236 510
Total Tonnage to DSWA 1,425.73 2,762.20 1,437.58 2,911.66
90-Gallon Containers Delivered 17 35 29 53
300-Gallon Containers Delivered - 14 - 4
Total Man Hours-containers Delivered 76 124 30 62
CURBSIDE RECYCLING TOTAL # OF HOUSEHOLDS
WEIGHT/LBS. % PICKED UP
STATS HOUSEHOLDS PICKED UP
JULY 2010* 16,318 11,557 241,900 71%
*Numbers are reported one month behind
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010 11
Paj 101
STREETS AUGUST 10 FYTD 11 AUGUST 09 FYTD 10
Signed Installed 25 57 9 17
Signs Repaired 38 60 12 30
Curbs Painted Yellow (feet) - 293 240 240
New Post Installed 13 18 4 11
Storm Catch Basins Repaired 4 24 5 5
Storm Catch Basin Repairing (Hrs.) 36 148 36 44
Hot Mix Patching (Tons) 18 70 294 296
Hot Mix Patching (Hrs.) 65 273 419 812
Cold Mix Patching Hrs.) 20 64 24 64
Concrete Work (Hrs) 32 84 82 142
Concrete Patching (Cubic Yards) 2 23 6 11
Street and Alley Maintenance (Hrs) 162 312 128 283
Ditch Work (Hrs). 65 65 22 22
Street Sweeping (Miles) 974 2,216 1,712 3,422
Street Sweeping (Cubic Yards) 204 396 324 600
GROUNDS - Arborist Crew AUGUST 10 AUGUST 10
Trees Trimmed 57 89
Trees Removed 19 24
Stumps Removed 9 9
Root Pruning 5* -
– *Part of the sidewalk replacement program and working with the concrete contractor
– Boom axed the burms around the oil tanks at the power plant and the VanSant turbine.
Beautification Crew
– Continued maintenance of 48 annual beds including edging, weeding, and extensive watering of the beds and
78 hanging baskets.
– Weeded at the following locations: the Library, Weyandt Hall, City Hall, and Fire Station #2.
– Spillway bank stabilization project on each side of the concrete spillway at Silver Lake Park. Installed 800 feet of
curlex and plants numerous native plants.
Grounds Maintenance/Mowing Crews
– Mowed all 280 acres including parks, around city buildings, ditches and right-of-ways.
– All Grounds personnel attended the annual Delaware Nursery and Landscape Association Summer Turf and
Nursery Expo receiving pesticide credits.
–
Special Projects Crew
– Applied 29 gallons of herbicide to curbs, sidewalks, parking lots and mulched areas downtown.
– Assisted Beautification Crew with spillway project.
– Removed planter area on the State Street side of the Library by digging out weeds, planting 200 English Ivy and
mulching the entire area.
12 City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 102
ECONOMIC DEVELOPEMENT
UNEMPLOYMENT RATES DEC 09 JAN 10 FEB 10 MAR 10 APR 10 MAY 10 JUN 10 JUL 10 AUG 10
City of Dover 8.8% 9.0% 10.2% 9.6% 9.6% 9.5% 10.3% 9.9% PENDING
National & State averages (US-9.5% & State-8.4%) Source: State of Delaware Department of Labor
Number of contacts made with small businesses and with out-of-town companies interested in locating to Dover.
TYPE YTD Contacts Made
Small Businesses 4
Out-of-town Companies 2
Staff met with CEO of Fordham Brewery to discuss future expansion plans and current employment levels.
A meeting scheduled with Senator Carper’s Office and the CEO of Evergreen LED to bring the Senator up-to-date on
their proposed expansion and to ask for assistance in identifying funding sources.
Staff met with Barron Marketing and Kramer Communications to develop a marketing plan concept for the Garri-
son Tract.
Met with Kent County Commissioner, Eric Buckson, to discuss the County’s proposed economic development in-
centives and how the City could utilize those funds.
Met with staff from DEDO to outline a strategy for attracting a start-up manufacturing company to a facility in Do-
ver.
Also met with staff from DelDOT to discuss the Garrison Tract traffic impact studies and right-of-way dedication for
White Oak Road.
DOWNTOWN DOVER PARTNERSHIP
Board of Directors approved the Fiscal Year 2011 Budget and moving forward on a branding project to develop a
new marketing image that could be used downtown. The Board also approved a partnership with the Dover/Kent
County MPO to include specific downtown properties as part of the charrette they will conduct for the area sur-
rounding the new Transit Center.
A draft Memorandum of Understanding was prepared with the YMCA for business development training to be of-
fered to local business owners under the USDA Rural Development Grant.
Meeting was held with potential bidders to describe the RFP process for asbestos removal at 22-24 W. Loockerman
Street.
Staff completed the Downtown Development Incentives informational brochure which will be included in business
recruitment packets.
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010 13
Paj 103
LIFE SAFETY
Inspections AUGUST 10 FYTD 11 AUGUST 09 FYTD 10
Fire Protection Inspections (new & existing) 83 182 13 105
Fire Code Inspections 84 293 45 125
Inspection Deficiencies 83 327 279 279
Certificate of Occupancy 4 9 12 16
Non-Inspection Hours
Office 104 196 84 230
Meetings 61 87 53 106
Plan Review 56 106 70 138
Training - 17 50 83
Fire Investigations 11 38 6 49
Damage Cost
Accidental $5,500 $40,500 $ 6,000 $ 6,000
Incendiary $2,000 $10,000 $80,000 $130,000
Undetermined $ - $1,500 $ - $ -
PERMITTING AND LICENSING
Permits Issued AUGUST 10 FYTD 11 AUGUST 09 FYTD 10
Administrative Permit 3 5 2 7
Building Addition/Renovation Permits 90 144 45 106
Building Permits 8 14 16 33
Demolition Permits 2 4 3 6
Fence Permits 10 22 11 22
Fire Prevention Permits 6 12 11 11
Mechanical Permits 21 50 33 89
Plumbing Permits 63 101 52 115
Sign Permits 14 44 16 43
Swimming Pool Permits - 2 - 1
Licenses Issued
Business Licenses 268 1,117 229 787
Merchant Licenses 62 253 60 235
Contractor Licenses 161 620 120 553
Lodging House Licenses - - - -
Mobile Homes 58 135 53 184
Public Occupancy 10 16 2 5
Rental Dwelling 14 31 25 44
BUILDING INSPECTIONS
Permits Issued AUGUST 10 FYTD 11 AUGUST 09 FYTD 10
Building 473 874 447 -
Plumbing/Mechanical 287 692 280 581
Certificate of Occupancy 43 56 33 48
GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS (GIS)
– Printed several copies of documents created for Economic Development.
– General updating of multiple GIS layers.
– Determined approximate number of households in given area for the City Clerk’s Office.
14 City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 104
PUBLIC UTILITIES
ELECTRIC
System Peak Total System Load
85,805
200.0 100,000
164.1 164.0 78,500 78,221
74,934
90,000
161.1 160.2
66,117
80,000
63,373
133.8 59,833 60,764
128.1 56,420 56,857 57,103
150.0 70,000
54,029 52,792
60,000
103.7 107.0 104.0 107.7
99.1 98.2 98.1
50,000
100.0 40,000
30,000
20,000
50.0 10,000
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Outages Customers of Gained/Lost
35 25,000 60
52
30 48
20,000 50
25
40
Customers
15,000 32
Outages
20
30 24
15 10,000
23
10 20 15 15 13 11 11
5,000
5 10 7 5
3
0 0 0
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul 10 Aug
Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Outages Customers 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
Outages: 4 Customers: 128
Electric Monthly Outage Report
The annual outage goal will be less than 295 minutes per customer, which is a Delaware Standard. This will be measured by
calculating the System Average Interruption Duration Index.
FY 11 YTD FY 10 FY 09
106.58 160.14 155.17
Controllable Outages Average Response Time
Annual goal is less than 40 Goal is less than 30 minutes
Month Year-to-date Month Year-to-date
2 15 44.75 Minutes 39.09 Minutes
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010 15
Paj 105
Electric Engineering Design
Major Program Updates Aug 10 Aug 09 DIFF FY11 YTD FY10
Extensions Design Completed Within 30 days
0 0 - 0 3
of complete Submission
New Underground Installation % Completed New Underground Installation % Completed
Kent General Hospital Ongoing Farthing Woods Ongoing
Crossgates Development Ongoing Buchanan Acres Ongoing
Mid City Substation Circuits
PROGRAM UPDATES AUG 10 AUG 9 FY11 YTD
Tree Trimming 141 188 292
Number of Oil Releases 0 1 -1
Lost Time Accidents – All Electric Utility Divisions 0 0 0
New Services 19 32 35
Major Goals Completed in the Past Two Months
16 City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010
Paj 106
WATER/WASTEWATER
Water Production/Billed Consumption/Flow to Kent County
300,000,000
250,000,000
200,000,000
150,000,000
100,000,000
50,000,000
0
Aug 09 Sep 09 Oct 09 Nov 09 Dec 09 Jan 10 Feb 10 Mar 10 Apr 10 May 10 Jun 10 Jul 10 Aug 10
Total Water Prod. Billed Consumpt. Total Flow to County City Readings
ENGINEERING SUMMARY
Major Program Updates AUGUST 10 AUGUST 09 DIFF FY11 YTD FY10
State and Federal Violations 0 violations 0 violations - - -
Water Quality Complaints 4 24 -20 17 40
-4
Plan Review Completed Within 30 days of 7 plans 3 plans
plans 100% 100%
Submission 100% 100%
Field Inspection Response within 48 hours of
100% 100% - 100% 100%
Request
Major Goals Completed in the Past Two Months
Acorn Lane Pump Station was completed.
OPERATIONAL SUMMARY
Task AUGUST 10 AUGUST 09 Current FY
Water Production – Daily Average 5,632,677 5,091,613 12,011,677
Average Field Response Time (goal is < 30 minutes) 18.4 16.3 19.1
Water Mains Repaired 1 - 1
Water Service Lines Repaired 1 4 6
Wastewater Mains Repaired - - -
Wastewater Service Lines Repaired - 3 -
Sewer Lines Flushed – Linear Feet 98,439 112,216 152,162
Percentage of Flow Sent to Kent County vs. Gallons Billed
100% 96% 100%
(inflow/Infiltration monitoring)
Total Water Meters in City Distribution System 13,857 13,706 29
Lost Time Accidents – All Water/Wastewater Divisions - - -
City Manager’s Monthly Report, August 2010 17
Paj 107
CITY PLANNER’S
MONTHLY REPORT
Public Services Group
P.O. Box 475
Dover, DE 19903
Phone: (302) 736-7010 Fax (302) 736-4217
August 2010
EDEN HILL FARM TND
Construction continues in the Residential District of Eden Hill Farm Traditional Neighborhood Design. In
August, permit review was completed for a set of seven townhouses on Ann Moore Street and for two duplexes
on Ruth Way. The total unit count of permits issued is for 44 residential units for the development (29 dwellings
complete). One set of townhouses in the 400 block of Ann Moore Street is almost complete with Certificate of
Occupancy inspections anticipated for mid-September. In August, there was no specific activity associated with
the Professional Office, Medical & Financial District. In August, a new Revised Implementation Plan for the
Neighborhood Commercial District was filed for Planning Commission review that would supersede the
previous Revised Implementation Plan of March 2009. This new Revised Implementation Plan will be reviewed
by the Development Advisory Committee and Planning Staff in preparation for Planning Commission review.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPLEMENTATION
Planning Staff continues to focus efforts on the implementation items identified in the 2008 Comprehensive
Plan as amended. In late August, Staff held a final working group meeting on the update to the Environmental
Protections within the Zoning Ordinance. The draft ordinance on the Environmental Protections is expected to
begin the formal review process in September. The City Council hearing on the 2010 Comprehensive Rezoning:
ROS Rezoning occurred August 9, 2010 and Council took action to approve the rezoning of 147 properties to
ROS (Recreational and Open Space zone). City Council also approved a series of text amendments to update
the Board of Adjustment provisions in the Zoning Ordinance. Planning Staff has now begun review of the
application processing provisions of Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 in anticipation of drafting a text amendment.
PERMITTING AND LICENSING REVIEW
The Planning Staff is part of the Building Permit review process. Our activities involving reviewing specific
types of permit applications for compliance with the Zoning Ordinance and for compliance with any conditions
of approval from the Planning Commission, Board of Adjustment, or Historic District Commission.
Permits Reviewed Jan- Feb- Mar- Apr- May- Jun- Jul- Aug- #
(Issued) 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 Reviewed
(Issued)
YTD
Building 16 15 25 30 22 40 51 79 278
Additions/Renovations/
Shed/Deck Permits
Building Permits 12 10 9 5 8 6 5 7 62
Demolition Permits 3 5 2 2 2 3 2 2 21
Fence Permits 4 0 8 16 11 5 12 9 65
Sign Permits 12 10 12 5 11 7 11 6 74
Temporary Sign Permits 7 3 9 4 8 4 6 5 46
Paj 108
Swimming Pool Permits 0 0 0 2 2 4 2 0 10
Certificate of Occupancy 6 6 9 11 24 28 13 31 128
Total # Permits 60 49 74 75 88 97 102 139 684
Reviewed (Issued)
CODE ENFORCEMENT
Case Type # cases # cases % staff % staff
current month YTD initiated initiated YTD
current month
No valid rental permit 4 76 50% 95%
No valid building permit 4 26 100% 77%
Tall grass and weeds 123 448 58% 57%
Unregistered vehicle 1 33 100% 55%
Abandoned vehicle 6 63 33% 40%
Annual Housing 46 389 91% 96%
Inspection
CO Inspection – 1 1 100% 100%
Planning
Property Maintenance – 43 328 21% 50%
Exterior
Electric Termination 21 145 5% 5%
Dover Code of 36 434 75% 35%
Ordinances
Zoning 13 98 77% 73%
Basketball goal 2 21 50% 43%
Total Cases 300 2062
Total # of Inspections 431
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
FISCAL YEAR 09-10 CDBG PROJECTS
U
Homeowner Rehabilitation Program
Four (4) homes are underway (814 River Road, 40 Bertrand Drive, 508 Walker Road, and 106 Gordon Place.) Lead
base paint testing is being conducted on two properties. Once testing is completed, properties will be advertised for
bid.
CDBG FY10 Projects
Funding for CDBG 2010 is expected to be available for draws in late September. Contract signings for sub-
recipients has been scheduled for September 30th.
Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP)
The City was awarded $1,426,740 for the acquisition and rehab of foreclosed properties to be sold to qualifying
families. A total of $1,210,016 has been expended on the acquisition of 8 properties and renovations for 3
properties. The remaining balance of $216,723 will be utilized for renovations. Two properties have been sold,
four (4) are being renovated, and two (2) are completed and for sale.
Paj 109
MEETING REPORTS
Board of Adjustment:
The Board of Adjustment did not meet on August 18, 2010. The next Board of Adjustment meeting is scheduled
for September 15, 2010.
Historic District Commission:
The Historic District Commission met on August 19, 2010 and took the actions listed below. The next regularly
scheduled meeting for the Historic District Commission is September 16, 2010. Discussion is ongoing
regarding updating the Historic District Guidelines.
1. HI-10-07 Building Permit #10-1263 at 408 South State Street – Moved to approve with the condition
they place wood shingles on the street front façade and/or asphalt or metal on the remainder of the rear
roof of their choice and that proper gutters and downspouts be placed on the roof to direct water away
from the building and surrounding buildings.
2. HI-10-06 Delaware Public Archives: Banner Program – Moved to approve.
Planning Commission
The Planning Commission met on August 16, 2010 and took the actions summarized listed below. The next
scheduled Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for September 20, 2010.
1. MI-10-13 Maple Glen Subdivision: Active Recreation Area Revisions – Moved to approve revised
recreation area plan.
2. C-10-02 The Arbors at 1051 College Road – Moved to approve the Conditional Use Site Plan with the
condition that the building be built and marketed as a condominium complex. Require the construction
of road (public street) from College Road and connecting to Emerald Point at Topaz Circle. Approval of
the waiver request for partial elimination of curbing. Approval of the Active Recreation Plan. And also
to have the applicant work with staff: to improve and increase in the amount of vegetative planting
between this property and Emerald Point; and to provide the additional twelve (12) parking spaces
needed to meet the code requirement of 108 spaces.
3. S-10-19 Sam’s Club: Building Remodel and Site Improvements – Moved to approve the Site Plan
along with approval of the waiver request to allow for a 12% parking reduction (85 parking spaces) and
with approval of the waiver request for a reduction of the bicycle parking. Added the condition that the
property provide a covered parking area to accommodate horse & buggy parking.
Submitted by:
Ann Marie Townshend, AICP
Planning & Community Development Director
Paj 122
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: Council
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: City Manager’s Office DATE SUBMITTED: October 1, 2010
PREPARED BY: Anthony J. DePrima, City Manager
SUBJECT: Permanent Easement Agreement with DelDOT for Access and Maintenance Agreement of Lands
located West of Garrison Farm Property Parcel LC-05-068.00-01.01
REFERENCE: N/A
RELATED PROJECT: Dover Sun Park
REVIEWED BY:
EXHIBITS: Permanent Easement Agreement
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $ 27,250 AMOUNT OF REIMBURSMENT: $27,250
FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): L.S. Power Corporation
TIMETABLE: Exercised upon approval of City Council
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Approve the Permanent Easement Agreement
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
The agreements between the City of Dover and LS Power for the Development of the Dover Sun Park required
the City of Dover to secure access and maintenance easements to 24.39 acres of DelDOT owned lands west of
the Sun Park. The purpose of the easement is to remove trees that will cast a shadow on the Solar Panels. LS
Power agreed to reimburse the City for the cost of the easement. Once the easement is secure we will develop
an agreement with LS Power to actually complete the initial work and maintain it.
The cost associated with the agreement that LS Power has agreed to reimburse the city includes $2,250 for the
appraisal of the property and $25,000 for the easement.
Please note that the Exhibit for the Easement has not been prepared yet, but I will have an exhibit at the meeting
to show council the exact location of the easement area.
Paj 127
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: City Council
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Economic Development Office DATE SUBMITTED: 9/28/10
PREPARED BY: Bill Neaton
SUBJECT: Authorization to Purchase City of Dover Information Page in the Kent County
Delaware 2011 Profile
REFERENCE: N/A
RELATED PROJECT: N/A
APPROVALS: City Council
EXHIBITS:
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $1200 AMOUNT BUDGETED: $0
FUNDING SOURCE: To Be Determined
TIMETABLE:
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Authorization to place City of Dover Information Page in the Kent County
Delaware 2011 Profile
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
Independent Newspapers publishes an annual Kent County Delaware profile. Designed to help with the
economic growth of the County, it will be used by the Economic Development office, the chambers of
commerce, local businesses, Realtors, colleges & universities, hospitals and medical groups, etc. to attract new
business and industry to the area, and to recruit professionals and executives for employment in this market.
10,000 copies of this booklet will be printed and in distribution throughout the year.
Paj 128
Page 1 of 3
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: City Council AGENDA: 10/11/10
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Finance DATE SUBMITTED: 9/28/10
PREPARED BY: Donna Mitchell, Controller/Treasurer
SUBJECT: Outsourcing Payroll Services – Integrated Human Resources and Payroll Services – RFP#11-001FN
APPROVALS: City Council
EXHIBITS: Evaluation Rating Payroll & Human Resource Service RFP
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: FY11 est. $57,105 with leased time clocks Total: $114,209 annually
AMOUNT BUDGETED: $65,000
FUNDING SOURCE: Finance Department Budget – Contractual Services 110-2300-517-30-31
TIMETABLE: Three Year Contract beginning January 1, 2011 ending December 31, 2013
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
1) Award a three year contract, to begin in January 1, 2011 and end December 31, 2013, to ADP for Human
Resource, Payroll and Time & Attendance services totaling $95,335.10 per year plus equipment leases of
$5,160.00.
2) Award contract to Wells Fargo for retiree payments at an annual cost of $5,664.
Background
Prior to issuing the above referenced RFP, Department Heads and representatives from our City Departments reviewed a
demonstration of the ADP system in March 2010 to assist in analyzing the payroll outsourcing option. The response was
favorable and it was determined this system would create City-wide efficiencies more particularly for the largest
departments, Police and Public Utilities. A Cost/Benefit Analysis to compare outsourcing versus hiring additional payroll
staff was shared with the City Manager, Human Resource Director and City Council prior the issuance of the RFP.
Staff’s recommendation is consistent with the Cost/Benefit Analysis completed in March, prior to the budget approval.
Every department participated in a time study for hours spent on timekeeping; payroll entry and administrative duties
(leave slips). The analysis quantified the overall City cost of the current payroll process. All three vendors submitted
consistent data on wage savings and efficiency gains using a fully integrated system for human resources, timekeeping
and payroll. Based upon the analysis conducted the City should realize a net savings of $300,476 as follows:
Manual System
Human Error Factor (manual input errors) $93,796
Lost Time Factor (long lunches/breaks, tardiness, early departure) 186,102
Recovery of Excess Overtime (ability to monitor employee work habits) 8,933
Manual system auditing & recording costs (clerks & supervisors) 36,902
Manual time card cost (supervisor & clerical) 3,892
Employee, benefits, and cost of current system maintenance & PC * 85,060
Total Cost of Present Manual System $414,685
National percentages were higher; The City percentages were lowered so as to not overstate estimated savings
Integrated Human Resources, Timekeeping & Payroll
Annual service cost & equipment leases (active & retired) * $106,159
Automated time & attendance, clerical maintenance 3.188
Automated time & attendance, supervisory review 4,862
Total Cost of Fully Integrated System $114,209
Paj 129
Page 2 of 3
Council Action Form (continued)
Outsourcing Payroll Services – Integrated Human Resources and Payroll Services
October 11, 2010
We received three proposals, all of which met the above criteria including-functionality, qualifications and project
understanding. The RFP provided for all vendors to price the service for 410 active employee’s (includes seasonal help)
and 236 retiree’s on an annual basis. The firms we received proposals from are as follows:
Ultimate Software, ADP - Major Accounts, and Kronos
We included in our review, the potential for our Pension Trust Custodian, Wells Fargo handle the issuance of our pension
payments and benefit changes for retirees’. We asked the payroll vendors to provide separate pricing for retiree payments
for this purpose. We found Wells Fargo to be a little less costly than the payroll vendor and we would also create
efficiencies in the Finance Department since all transactions would go directly to the Pension accounts and not have to
pass through the payroll account. If Council agrees with the recommendations we would notify all active and retired
employees of the change by October 31, to take effect on January 1, 2011.
A summary of the proposal review, including fees, is attached for your review. There were no local vendor or minority
vendor preferences identified and submitted in these proposals.
Pros & Cons of Outsourcing
Pros
Web based system; Better technology and user friendly access as compared to our current system;
Provides employee’s with self-service functionality and on-line access to wage and benefit information
Provides City portal to post newsletters, bulletins and benefit changes
Potential to reduce long-term wage & benefit costs of additional headcount
Supervisors can more effectively manage employee schedules and overtime
Would require use of time clocks (cost of equipment included in the analysis)
End user report capability and labor analysis
City-wide efficiency gains on time and attendance, payroll, HR, leave slips, etc…
Goal to have paperless payroll (electronic timekeeping, leave slips, personnel changes)
Eliminate work around solutions and double entry of payroll data
Labor cost savings attributed to reduced payroll errors, leave inflation, overtime and absenteeism –
Average payback period is five months
Reduces risk of errors and grievances; i.e. Holiday Pay by contract
Minimum compliance risks with federal and state regulations; all reporting by vendor;
Any turnover in the payroll office would not be as disruptive to the City
Would reduce workload on I/T staff and programming request
Ability to easily calculate “what if” pay increases for budgeting and union negotiations
Ability to use selected vendor’s integrated PFP function and data base for wage comparisons
Ability to do self-evaluations and have individuals and managers monitoring performance goals on-line
Department Heads have reviewed demo and response has been favorable
Cons
Cultural change
Separate interface will be required for the financial and budget modules to transfer data
No wire for time clocks at two locations – Facility Maintenance & Construction Crew sites; Manual
process until such time as communication lines can be installed;
Public Utilities is working on a cost estimate to extend the fiber from the VanSant substation and
install the hardware, not completed at time of submission.
Paj 130
Page 3 of 3
Council Action Form (continued)
Outsourcing Payroll Services – Integrated Human Resources and Payroll Services
October 11, 2010
Paj 131
1 of 12
Manual Time and Attendance Process
Labeling & setting up time Employees fill out Time
cards & updating excel timesheet/punch time Sheets/cards
spreadsheets (new hires, clock Collected
terms, etc.)
5 minutes per 5 minutes per payroll
.5 hour per payroll
payroll
Supervisors check on excessive overtime,
exceptions, missing hours, review, check for
errors,.5and
hour perdelivers
couriers payrollto payroll
Payroll double Payroll transcribes Check totals & correct
checks time cards information Total Payroll errors
And verifies PTO sheets as necessary.
1 hour per payroll 2 hours per payroll .5 hours per
payroll
Create reports or transcribe information to
other systems for labor reporting File
time cards.
1 minute per
1 hour per payroll
payroll
Paj 132
2 of 12
Enterprise eTIME Software
• Handles Complex Pay Policies
• Rounding, Shift Differentials, Union Rules, Premium Pays, Accrual Policies
• Calculates Hours Automatically Based on Your Pay Policies
• Highlights Exceptions
• Missed Punches, Absent, Early, Late, Tardy, Overtime
• Easy to Use Timesheet Editor allows for easy on-line editing.
• Manage Employee Scheduling
• Multiple Shifts and Availability Reporting. Control coverage.
• Attendance
• On Premise p reports, Automated enforcement of policy, Automated generation of warnings.
• Access and Visibility to Real Time Information
• Gaps in Coverage due to FMLA. On Premise and Unscheduled hours happening.
• Reports and Queries can be scheduled to be delivered to your printer or Email.
Paj 133
3 of 12
What is Enterprise eTIME ?
A browser-based application, which is scaleable, Enterprise eTIME provides
clients with:
• Company-specific pay rule calculations
• Database views through QuickNavs
• Electronic itimecard approval
• Edit lock-out of timecards by payroll
• Historical edits with Retropay calculations.
• Audit trails for tracking timecard edits
• Managing employee schedules
• yp
Hyperfind Queries
• Links to e-mail
• Workflow notifications
Paj 134
4 of 12
Enterprise eTIME Software
Paj 135
5 of 12
Requesting Time Off at the 4500
Paper can be the exception, not the norm. Employee fills in the
Time Off Request, then selects Submit
Time Off Request
Current Balances
Floating Holiday: 16
Personal Day: 0
Vacation: 170
Comment Code:
Leave Information
Leave Type:
From Date:
To Date:
Hrs/Day:
Submit Add Another Cancel
Paj 136
6 of 12
Requesting Time Off at the 4500
Receives q
request pp
approval
Paj 137
7 of 12
Approved Vacation is added to
schedule and timecard automatically.
Paj 139
9 of 12
QuickNav - Check Overtime
Paj 140
10 of 12
Department Manager Portal ** Premise Based Clients only
Paj 141
11 of 12
HR Manager Portal ** Premise Based Clients only
Paj 142
12 of 12
Time & Labor Automation Benefits
Employee Supervisor Payroll / HR Executive
More accurate Review employee No more manual Access to
paychecks exceptions only calculations comprehensive
Efficient way to Review non productive One vendor to resolve reporting
track their non on-line problems
Eliminate potential
productive time No manual keying of hours
Edit by exception only profit leaks
Automate the Electronic audit trail
Run management reports Reduce labor
capture of time
[e.g. Approaching Elimination of Actual expenses
Overtime Report] Timecard
Improve employee
No more manual Retrieve employee punch morale
history electronically
calculation of an Control payroll
employee’s pay/time accuracy
Paj 143
Page 1 of 3 FINAL READING
CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE #2010-26
1 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
2 The amounts hereinafter named in various City funds are changed from the currently approved revenues/receipts
3 and appropriations to the revised revenues/receipts and revised appropriations for use by the various departments
4 of the Municipal Government for:
5 City of Dover
6 Governmental Capital Projects Fund
7 Proposed Budget Amendment - Fiscal Year 2011
2010/11
2010/11 BUDGET REVISED
8 BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS BUDGET
9 BEGINNING BALANCE & RECEIPTS:
10 BEGINNING BALANCE - PROJECTS $ 65,479 $ 162,113 $ 227,592
11 BEGINNING BALANCE - LIBRARY - 34,583 34,583
12 STATE GRANTS 3,343,520 888,828 4,232,348
13 INTEREST EARNINGS 10,900 - 10,900
14 POLICE GRANTS 18,000 - 18,000
15 LIBRARY BOND ISSUE/CONTRIBUTIONS 1,000,000 - 1,000,000
16 TRANSFER FROM GENERAL FUND FOR PROJECTS 1,307,839 - 1,307,839
17 TRANSFER FROM PARKLAND RESERVE (JWP ADDTN) - 36,872 36,872
18 TRANSFER FROM LIBRARY RESERVE 2,343,519 20,213 2,363,732
19 TRANSFER FROM CAPITAL ASSET RESERVE 140,000 (140,000) -
20 TOTAL BUDGET $ 8,229,257 $ 1,002,609 $ 9,231,866
21 DEPARTMENT EXPENDITURES:
22 FIRE $ 288,210 $ (64,510) $ 223,700
23 GROUNDS MAINTENANCE 63,675 - 63,675
24 LIBRARY 6,687,039 943,624 7,630,663
25 RECREATION 45,000 36,872 81,872
26 POLICE 282,380 53,500 335,880
27 STREETS 481,055 - 481,055
28 SANITATION 246,075 - 246,075
29 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 12,000 - 12,000
30 MAYOR 31,500 - 31,500
31 TOTAL EXPENDITURES $ 8,136,934 $ 969,486 $ 9,106,420
32 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - PROJECTS 92,323 33,123 125,446
33 TOTAL BUDGET $ 8,229,257 $ 1,002,609 $ 9,231,866
Paj 144
2 of 3
34 City of Dover
35 Water/Wasterwater Improvement & Extension Fund
36 Proposed Budget Amendment - Fiscal Year 2011
2010/11
2010/11 BUDGET REVISED
37 BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS BUDGET
38 BEGINNING BALANCE & RECEIPTS:
39 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE - WATER $ 743,431 $ 847,443 $ 1,590,874
40 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE - WASTEWATER 543,668 (589,333) (45,665)
41 BOND PROCEEDS - WASTEWATER 3,016,200 - 3,016,200
42 STATE LOAN FUND - WATER - 2,404,017 2,404,017
43 STATE LOAN FUND - WASTEWATER - 5,597,956 5,597,956
44 TRANS FR WATER/WASTEWATER FOR WATER 500,000 - 500,000
45 TRANS FR WATER/WASTEWATER FOR WASTEWATER 500,000 - 500,000
46 TRANSFER FROM IMPACT FEE RESERVE 242,040 516,781 758,821
47 FEDERAL/STATE GRANTS (WASTEWATER) - 45,248 45,248
48 TOTAL BUDGET $ 5,545,339 $ 8,822,112 $14,367,451
49 DEPARTMENT EXPENSES:
50 WATER 620,000 2,985,055 3,605,055
51 WASTEWATER 1,560,700 5,515,294 7,075,994
52 TOTAL EXPENSES $ 2,180,700 $ 8,500,349 $10,681,049
53 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WASTEWATER BOND 2,153,140 - 2,153,140
54 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WATER 623,431 266,405 889,836
55 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WASTEWATER 588,068 55,358 643,426
56 TOTAL BUDGET CURRENT YEAR BALANCES $ 3,364,639 $ 321,763 $ 3,686,402
57 TOTAL BUDGET $ 5,545,339 $ 8,822,112 $14,367,451
Paj 145
3 of 3
58 City of Dover
59 Electric Improvement & Extension Fund
60 Proposed Budget Amendment - Fiscal Year 2011
2010/11
2010/11 BUDGET REVISED
61 BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS BUDGET
62 BEGINNING BALANCE & REVENUES:
63 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE $ 1,688,861 $ 1,688,307 $ 3,377,168
64 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE BOND - 415,585 415,585
65 INTEREST EARNINGS 40,700 - 40,700
66 STATE REIMBURSEMENT FOR GOVS AVE - 254,757 254,757
67 FEDERAL GRANTS (DOE) - 135,152 135,152
68 TRANSFER FROM ELECTRIC 3,500,000 - 3,500,000
69 TOTAL BUDGET $ 5,229,561 $ 2,493,801 $ 7,723,362
70 DEPARTMENT EXPENSES:
71 ELECTRIC GENERATION $ 1,480,068 $ 471,672 $ 1,951,740
72 TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION 739,000 - 739,000
73 ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING 1,390,429 379,064 1,769,493
74 TRANSFER TO DEPRECIATION RESERVE - 1,000,000 1,000,000
75 TOTAL EXPENSES $ 3,609,497 $ 1,850,736 $ 5,460,233
76 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 1,620,064 643,065 2,263,129
77 TOTAL BUDGET $ 5,229,561 $ 2,493,801 $ 7,723,362
ADOPTED:*
Actions History
October 11, 2010 - Proposed Final Reading – Council
September 27, 2010 - First Reading – Council
September 13, 2010 - Considered by Legislative, Finance & Administration Committee