Yo rale tèks sa a nan PDF la otomatikman, epi li ka gen erè. PDF la se dosye ofisyèl la, kidonk tcheke l anvan ou konte sou sa a.
18 paj pa gen anpil tèks ou ka li isit la, oswa yo pa gen ditou, souvan paske se eskanè oswa desen. Gade PDF la pou sa yo.
Paj 1
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Monday, February 12, 2024 at 6:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware
AGENDA VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE
This meeting will be held in the City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:
Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://rb.gy/dsxwpx
Event number: 2538 405 6095
Event password: DOVER (if needed)
If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.
The meeting can also be viewed on Comcast Channel 14, Verizon Channel 20, and on the City's Streaming Player located at www.cityofdover.com under "Quick Links".
OPEN FORUM - 15 Minutes Prior to Official Meeting (6:15 p.m.)
The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share their questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing on the agenda as a public hearing is prohibited during the Open Forum as an opportunity will be provided during consideration of that item. Citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is prohibited from taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule such items as regular agenda items and act upon them in the future.
INVOCATION - Elder Ellis B. Louden
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Councilwoman Arndt
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Paj 2
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - February 12, 2024 PAGE 2
PRESENTATIONS
- 1.Recognition of Service - Reverend Rita Mishoe Paige- Human Relations Commission (October 2016 - January 2024)
- 2.Downtown Dover Partnership 2023 Annual Report
- 3.Unsheltered Working Group Update (Mayor Robin R. Christiansen)
PUBLIC HEARING
FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinances was accomplished during the Council meeting of December 11, 2023. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government."
- 4.Rescheduling of Public Hearing - Proposed Ordinance #2023-12- Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue (Applicant Request)
Review of Rezoning application for a parcel of land consisting of 5.04+/- acres. The property is zoned R-10 (One-Family Residence Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The proposed zoning for the property is C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The property is located on the north side Forrest Avenue adjacent to Cranberry Run Drive.
(The owner of record is Draper Farm Properties, LLC. Property Address: 1617 Forrest Avenue. Tax Parcel: ED-05-075.00-01-07.00-000. Planning Reference: Z-23-02. Council District 1)
(Staff Recommendation: Approve the applicant request to reschedule the public hearing/final reading of Proposed Ordinance 2023-12 to the Regular City Council Meeting scheduled for Monday, April 22, 2024.
- 5.Proposed Ordinance #2023-13 - Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza
Review of Rezoning application for a parcel of land consisting of approximately 1.27 acres (Old Dover Post Office property). The property is zoned IO (Institutional and Office Zone), subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone), and subject to the H (Historic District Zone). The proposed zoning for the property is C-2 (Central Commercial Zone), subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone), and H (Historic District Zone). The property is located on the north side Loockerman Plaza and adjacent to Innovation Way.
(The owner of record is City of Dover, DE. Property Address: 55 Loockerman Plaza. Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.05-04-53.00-000. Planning Reference: Z-24-01. Council District 4.)
CONSENT AGENDA
ADOPTION OF MINUTES
- 6.Regular City Council Meeting of January 22, 2024
COMMITTEE REPORTS
Paj 3
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - February 12, 2024 PAGE 3
- 7.Council Committee of the Whole Report of January 23, 2024
Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee
- 8.Review of the Research on the Solar Powered Feedback Signs and Electronic Speed Enforcement Devices (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director)
(Committee Recommendation: Approve a method of speed enforcement equipment to utilize in City of Dover neighborhoods.)
- 9.Discussion - Complaint from Kate Howard, Irish Mikes Pub Bar Owner/Manager regarding the Dover Police Departments responsibility to serve and protect their business. (Councilman Sudler)
(Committee Action Not Required)
- 10.Discussion - Concerns with the homeless and tent village on College Road across from the Delaware State University Nursery Facility. (Councilman Sudler)
(Committee Recommendation: Put together a working group to tackle the immediate needs of those in tents right now, whether they need heat or porta-potties to get them to a level where they do not freeze to death, and then have reports brought back to council. )
Utility Committee
- 11.Tidewater Utilities - Agreement for Water Sales / Purchase (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director)
(Committee Recommendation: Allow staff to enter into an agreement with Tidewater Utilities with specified water rates.)
- 12.Tree Trimming Bid Award (Paul Waddell, Electric Director)
(Committee Recommendation: Awarding a two (2) year (2024, 2025) tree trimming contract to Asplundh Tree Experts with a city option to extend it an additional three (3) years (2026, 2027, 2028), five years total. The contract work will be adjusted to stay within the budget each year.)
Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
- 13.Proposed Ordinance #2024-02 - Amending Chapter 106 - Traffic and Vehicles, Sec. 106-136 On-street disabled parking (Councilman Neil and Councilwoman Arndt.)
(Committee Recommendation: Defer Proposed Ordinance 2024-02 for staff input)
MONTHLY REPORTS - December 2023
- 14.City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
- 15.City Manager’s Report
Paj 4
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - February 12, 2024 PAGE 4
- 16.Controller/Treasurer's Budget Report
- 17.Fire Chief's Report
- 18.Police Chief's Report
APPOINTMENTS/REAPPOINTMENTS - RECOMMENDED BY THE COUNCIL
PRESIDENT
- 19.Dover Human Relations Commission-Second District Appointment - William G. Faust, Jr. - Three-Year (3) Term to Expire February 2027 RESOLUTIONS
- 20.Resolution No. 2024-01- Authorizing Signatures for Banking Services on Behalf of the City of Dover, Delaware - Controller/Treasurer, Assistant Controller/Treasurer, and Assistant Treasurers
ITEMS NOT ON THE CONSENT AGENDA
ORDINANCES
FIRST READING - The First Reading is offered on the Proposed Ordinance. Final action by Council will take place during the Second Reading on FEBRUARY 26, 2024. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us.
- 21.Proposed Ordinance #2024-05 - Amending Chapter 106 - Traffic and Vehicles, Section 106-17-Truck Routes (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director)
CITY MANAGER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
MAYOR'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ANNOUNCEMENTS
ADJOURNMENT
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING
Paj 5
Item #2.
Paj 6
Item #2.
Paj 7
Item #2.
Paj 8
Item #2.
Paj 9
Item #4.
Paj 10
Item #4.
FINAL READING
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2023-12
| 1 | AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE CITY |
| 2 | OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT |
| 3 | 1617 FORREST AVENUE |
5 WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property within the 6 limits of the City of Dover; and
7 WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use of property 8 described below from R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) 9 to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone).
| 10 | NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF |
| 11 | DOVER, IN COUNCIL, MET: |
12 1. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and Zoning 13 Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning designation from R-10 14 (One Family Residence Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) to C-1A (Limited 15 Commercial Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) on that property located at 16 1617 Forrest Avenue (on the north side of Forrest Avenue, east of Cranberry Run Drive), consisting of 5.04+/- 17 acres, owned by Draper Farm Properties, LLC. 18 (Tax Parcel: ED-05-075.00-01-07.00-000; Planning Reference: Z-23-02; First Council District)
19 ADOPTED: *
| 20 | Actions History |
| 21 | 02/12/2024 - Scheduled for Public Hearing/Final Reading – City Council |
| 22 | 01/16/2024 - Public Hearing - Planning Commission |
| 23 | 12/11/2023 - First Reading - City Council |
Paj 11
Item #4.
PETITION TO AMEND ZONING DISTRICT
Public Hearing Before the Dover City Council
February 12, 2024
Recommendation from Planning Commission Meeting of January 16, 2024
With Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review
Application: Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Zone
Owner: Draper Farm Properties, LLC
Address: 1617 Forrest Avenue, Dover DE
Location: North side of Forrest Avenue, east of Cranberry Run Drive
Tax Parcel: ED-05-075.00-01-07.00-000
Size: 5.04 acres+/-
Present Use: Vacant (Previous residence demolished and with associated agricultural outbuildings and land in cultivation)
2019 Comprehensive Plan Designation – Land Use Category: Mixed Use
Present Zoning: R-10 (One-Family Residence Zone) and COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone)
Proposed Zoning: C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) and COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone)
Reason for Request: To amend the zoning of the 5.04+/- acre parcel at 1617 Forrest Avenue, Dover DE 19904 from R-10 to C-1A (while retaining COZ-1 Overlay).
File Number: Z-23-02
Ordinance Number: 2023-12
Paj 12
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
Planning Commission Recommendation: The Application Z-23-02 for Rezoning of Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC of 5.04 acres at 1617 Forrest Avenue was represented by Jonathan Street (of the Becker Morgan Group) and John Paradee, Esq. (of Baird Mandalas, Brockstedt & Federico). A Public Hearing was conducted on January 16, 2024 where ten (10) members of the public spoke, and one written comment was received regarding the Rezoning application. The Planning Commission’s motion to recommend denial of the proposed Rezoning from R-10/COZ-1 to C-1A/COZ-1 resulted in a 6-2 vote in favor of denial. (Draft Meeting Minutes attached.)
APPLICATION: Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue
This Rezoning Application was referred to the Planning Commission as per Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §5. The Planning Commission is required to provide a Review Report to City Council. The following document and attachments are provided as the Review Report and Planning Commission Recommendation.
- I.APPLICATION SUMMARY This Rezoning Application Z-23-02 is for a parcel of land consisting of 5.04 acres. The property is zoned R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The proposed zoning is C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The property is located on the north side of Forrest Avenue and adjacent to Cranberry Run Drive. The owner of record is Draper Farm Properties LLC. Property Address: 1617 Forrest Avenue. Tax Parcel: ED-05-075.00-01-07.00-000. Council District 1. Ordinance #2023-12
The First Reading was completed by the City Council on December 11, 2023 referring the Application to the Planning Commission for Public Hearing, Review, and Recommendation.
Existing Property: The property consisted of 5.04 acres is located at the northeast corner of Forrest Avenue and Cranberry Run Drive. The property has frontage of over 750 feet along Forrest Avenue/Route 8 and frontage of over 300 feet on Cranberry Run Drive. The property has a farmstead location (previous dwelling now demolished) and a series of accessory structures that appeared to have served as agricultural buildings. A majority of the property has been in agricultural cultivation. Both street frontages have existing sidewalks and existing curb cuts for the former dwelling location (from Forrest Avenue) and to the field/accessory structures (from Cranberry Run Drive).
This application only seeks rezoning of the property from R-10 to C-1A; the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) zoning designation will remain. The applicant is seeking rezoning to allow for future mixed-use development of the property. Any redevelopment of the site will be subject to a separate application submission for plans or permits. See attached Applicant’s submission Letter of October 31, 2023.
Previous Applications: This property was subject to a Request during the review process for the adoption of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan. As Request for Changes to DRAFT 2019 Comprehensive Plan - Request
Paj 13
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
#1, the property owner requested a change in the Land Use Classification (on Land Development Plan Map 12-1) from the proposed Residential Medium Density Land Use Classification to Mixed Use or Commercial Land Use Classification. On December 16, 2019, the Planning Commission recommended (by a vote of 5-2) a Land Use Classification of Mixed Use. Then, the Land Use Classification Category of Mixed Use for this property was approved by the City Council on January 13, 2020 as part of the review and adoption of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan document and maps. The Land Use Classification of the property is Mixed Use.
In 2021, a Rezoning Application (Z-21-05) was considered for this 5.04 acre property at 1617 Forrest Avenue. The Application Z-21-05 sought to rezone the property from R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) to the C-2A (Limited Central Commercial Zone) subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The Planning Commission on June 21, 2021 recommended denial of the Rezoning request to C-2A with COZ-1 for property by a vote of 8-0 (one member absent) following a Public Hearing where thirteen (13) members of the public spoke and over twenty-one (21) written comment items were received. Then following a rescheduled Public Hearing (originally set for July 12, 2021) and consideration on August 9, 2021, the City Council’s motion to adopt the Rezoning Ordinance #2021-14 failed (vote of 1-8). Thus, the Rezoning Application Z-21-05 for 1617 Forrest Avenue to C-2A and COZ-1 was unsuccessful, and the property remained zoned as R-10 and subject to the COZ-1 zone.1
Surrounding Land Uses The surrounding parcels are zoned residential. The properties immediately adjacent on the north and to the west of the property are zoned R-10 (One Family Residence Zone). This is a residential subdivision of single family detached dwellings known as Cranberry Run. Adjacent to the east are properties zoned RM-1 (Residential Medium Density Zone) as another residential subdivision of Heatherfield consisting of single family detached dwellings and duplexes along Stoney Drive. There are more residential developments along Forrest Avenue as you move east until reaching the extensive commercial corridor which starts about Mifflin Road and continues east. Across Forrest Avenue/Route 8 to the south of the subject site are a series of nine (9) parcels with eight (8) single family detached dwellings located under Kent County’s jurisdiction. Also, to the south (and surrounding these residences) is the campus of the Dover High School. Access to the Dover High School, is via Dover High Drive with its signalized intersection with Forrest Avenue (0.36 miles west of the subject site) and at the campus entrance with HAWK Signal at the intersection of Heatherfield Way and Forrest Avenue.
II. COMPRENSIVE PLAN COMPLIANCE REVIEW
In the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, the Land Development Plan (Map 12-1) recommends that this property be used for Mixed Use. Regarding Mixed Use Areas and the Land Use Classification of Mixed Use, this is discussed in Chapter 12 – Land Development Plan beginning on page 12-7. The goals and for Mixed Use Areas Land Use are listed in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan excerpts presented below:
Goals: Mixed Land Use
The overall goals for Mixed Use areas are:
1
It is noted that on August 27, 2021 Case # 2021-0740-JRS Draper Farm Properties, LLC v. City of Dover was filed with the Court of Chancery.
Paj 14
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
- 1.Encourage creation of neighborhood centers.
- 2.Within the close-knit neighborhood fabric there are opportunities for the creation of urban centers. These centers should be established along major roadways and feature mixed use development, pedestrian-friendly public environments and opportunities for connection to future transit.
- 3.In order to encourage non-automobile access to the center, the activities should be clustered within a one-half mile radius (or 10-minute walk) and be located so as to draw upon residents from a number of surrounding neighborhoods.
- 4.Develop strategies that will encourage the creation of well-defined public street spaces and pedestrian-friendly village areas that encourage walking and bicycle use. This may include on-street and behind building parking, and the creation of build-to lines for new development.
- 5.Improve access that limits public access to open spaces areas such as pedestrian, bicycle, and transit networks to parks and natural areas.
- 6.Encourage the Mixed Use of residential and commercial uses in the Downtown area. The Comprehensive Plan notes that Mixed Use Areas “can be an area where a new development should foster walkability and close interactions among activities and uses in a traditional neighborhood setting.” Chapter 9 – Transportation Plan from the Comprehensive Plan identifies Forrest Avenue/Route 8 as a Minor Arterial Street and the need to focus efforts on improvements along the Route 8 corridor “that would improve safety, better manage access, reduce congestions, and provide improved traffic flow.” The development and implementation of strategies for addressing East/West Traffic in the City is Recommendation 7 from that Chapter.
The Rezoning Request to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) is consistent with the Land Use Classification of Mixed Use. Table 12-1: Land Use and Zoning Matrix (from the 2019 Comprehensive Plan) specifies that the following zones are compatible with this land use classification. See the excerpt from Table 12-1 given below. It is noted that Table 12-1 for the Mixed Use Land Use Category identifies a number of zoning districts that allow for a mix of commercial and residential uses with some zoning districts being more limiting in the specific types of uses permitted.
C-2 (Central Commercial) (Downtown Redevelopment Target Area Only) C-2A (Limited Central Commercial) TND (Traditional Neighborhood Design) C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial) C-1A (Limited Commercial) RGO (General Residence and Office) (Downtown Redevelopment Target Area Only) Mixed-Use R-8 (One Family Residence) R-10 (One Family Residence) RG-1 (General Residence) RG-2 (General Residence) RG-4 (General Resident - Multi-Story Apartments) C-3 (Service Commercial) CPO (Commercial and Professional Office) IO (Institutional and Office)
Paj 15
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
III. ZONING REVIEW
Request for C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) Zoning The types of permitted uses and conditional uses in the C-1A zone are given Article 3 §12 of the Zoning Ordinance. See the following code excerpt.
Article 3 Section 12. – Limited Commercial Zone (C-1A). 12.1 Uses permitted. In a limited commercial zone (C-1A), no building or premises shall be used, and no building or part of a building shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any purpose, except the following: (a) Retail stores. (b) Personal service establishments. (c) Service establishments. (d) Restaurants. (e) Business, professional, and governmental offices. (f) One family residences, including attached and semi-detached dwellings, complying with the bulk standards of the RG-1 (General Residence) zone. (g) Apartments and multi-family dwellings. 12.2 Conditional uses. The following uses are permitted, conditional upon the approval of the planning commission in accordance with the procedures and subject to the general conditions set forth in article 10, section 1: (a) Drive-throughs accessory to a permitted use.
12.3 Uses prohibited. The following uses are prohibited:
(a) Fuel pumps and motor vehicle storage, sales, or repairs.
12.4 Enclosed buildings. All permitted uses and all storage accessory thereto, other than offstreet parking, shall be carried on in buildings fully enclosed on all sides, except for outdoor eating areas associated with restaurants and outdoor sales areas approved by the city plan ner.
12.5 Performance standards. All uses are subject to performance standards as set forth in article 5, section 8.1.
12.6 Site development plan approval. Site development plan approval in accordance with article 10, section 2 hereof shall be required prior to the issuance of building permits for the erection or enlargement of all structures and prior to the issuance of certificates of occupancy for any change of use.
(Ord. of 6-25-1984; Ord. of 3-24-1986; Ord. of 7-10-2000; Ord. of 2-12-2001; Ord. No. 2014-08, 7-14-2014 )
COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) The provisions of the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) are established to “promote superior urban corridor development and the highest quality-built environment.” There are a series architectural, parking, and landscaping guidelines that would be required by the COZ-1 zoning district, if development of the property is proposed. The purpose and requirements of the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) are given in Article 3 §27 of the Zoning Ordinance. See the following code excerpt.
Paj 16
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
Article 3 Section 27. – Corridor Overlay Zone 1 (COZ-1)
27.1 Purpose. The corridor overlay zone (COZ) is established for the following reasons: (a) To promote superior urban corridor development and the highest quality built environment;
(b) To foster coordination and linkage among corridor properties and with adjacent lands;
(c) To preserve the functionality and efficiency of the roadway for traffic movement; and
(d) To achieve a visually balanced streetscape environment which is friendly to the pedestrian and motorist alike.
27.2 Superior urban design. For the purposes of this ordinance the term "superior urban design" shall meet the following criteria:
(a) Superior urban design places a strict and primary importance on the pedestrian. The concept should lend itself to interconnectivity while presenting building structures as aspects of the street, not simply islands existing in the "sea of roads". The design should encourage fewer car-trips, as well as promote automobile trips on an interconnected local street system rather than trips that utilize the arterials. In demonstrating superior urban design, an applicant must show that the plan presented exceeds the requirements of the zoning ordinance in at least two of the following areas:
(i) Transportation amenities for bicycles, pedestrians and transit that exceed those required by the zoning ordinance;
(ii) Architectural features including, but not limited to: LEED-certified buildings; unique architecture not replicated in other locations; use of architectural elements such as entry porticos, porte-cocheres, colonnades, cornices, porch columns and balusters, band courses, coins, water tables and other trim that enhances visual quality and function of the structure; and use of the highest-quality construction materials.
(iii) Landscaping that exceeds the requirements of this section, including robust use of trees, shrubbery, and flowering plants to screen parked cars; water gardens and ponds; arboretums; tree preservation measures;
(iv) Public spaces and art including, but not limited to, sculpture, memorials, murals, public court yards and pocket parks, and fountains;
(v) Green technologies for stormwater management, as well as green energy technologies such as geothermal heating and cooling and solar energy supplies.
(b) The city planner shall develop policy guidance on how the concept of superior urban design will be evaluated.
27.3 Zone boundaries. The COZ encompasses the lands adjacent to the following roadways as outlined on the City of Dover Zoning Map as set forth in article 2, section 2 of this ordinance: (a) Delaware Route 8 (Forrest and Division Streets) from the railroad tracks in a westerly direction to the city limit line.
(b) McKee/Saulsbury Road (County Road 156) from the intersection at Dennys Road (County Road 100) in a southerly direction to the terminal intersection with West North Street (County Road 73).
Paj 17
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
27.4 Permitted uses. Land use shall be governed by those provisions of this ordinance related to the specific zoning district designations of each property as depicted on the zoning map.
27.5 Site development plan approval. Site development plan approval in accordance with article 10, section 2 shall be required prior to the issuance of building permits for the erection or enlargement of all structures and prior to the issuance of certificates of occupancy for any change in use. When the zoning district regulations specify that a particular use requires conditional use approval in accordance with article 10, section 1, the provisions of that article shall apply. Site development plans and conditional use site plans for properties within the COZ shall reflect compliance with the development guidelines of this article, in addition to all other applicable codes and regulations.
27.6 Development guidelines.
27.61 Setbacks:
a. Front yards.
Residential Nonresidential Min. Max. Min. Max. McKee/Saulsbury 60' to 80' 40' to 50' * Route 8—Artis Drive to Mifflin Road 60' to 80' None Route 8—Mifflin Road to Saulsbury 40' to 60' 40' to 60' * Road Route 8—Saulsbury Road to R.R. line 20' to 30' 20' to 30' Subdivision streets (Setback provisions of article 4 shall apply)
- •When the applicant can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the planning commission through the site plan review process that the proposal involves a superior urban design, the maximum setback may be increased to no more than 90 feet from the property line on Route 8 from Mifflin Road to Saulsbury Road and on McKee and Saulsbury Roads.
27.62 Building placement. Buildings shall be situated on the property so as to maximize the use of the frontage along the roadway and shall have the longest side of the building arranged parallel and square to the roadway. When the applicant can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the planning commission that, due to specific constraints related to lot configuration, alternative building placements may be permitted.
27.63 Parking. (a) Location. Parking shall not be permitted to be situated within the front yard, nor between the right-of-way line and the building, except in the following instances: (i) Automobile service stations; (ii) Properties in a shopping center (SC) zoning district, in which case, parking may be permitted between the building and the roadway, provided that such parking [shall] be limited to five rows of single parking spaces between the road and the storefront; (iii) When the applicant can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the planning commission through the site plan review process that the design presented involves a superior urban design, parking may be permitted between the building and the street, provided that such parking within this area shall be adequately landscaped and screened from the roadway.
(b) Required number of spaces. See specific district requirements in article 4.
Paj 18
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
(c) Layout. (i) Parking lots shall be arranged in such a manner so that not more than 20 parking spaces in a row shall be permitted without a landscaped island. No more than six rows of 20 spaces shall be provided without provision for a landscaped median. Parking islands shall be a minimum of ten feet wide and planting medians shall be no less than eight feet wide.
(ii) There shall be a landscaped buffer area of at least 12 feet in width between the building and parking lot and drive areas. The buffer area shall include provisions for a sidewalk of at least six feet and no greater than eight feet in width. The buffer area and sidewalk shall be grade separated from the parking lot by concrete curbing of at least six inches in height.
(d) Landscaping. Design shall be simple and easy to maintain and shall consist of a combination of hardy canopy trees, low evergreen shrubs and turf grass, and shall be designed in accordance with landscape guidelines set forth in article 5, section 15 of this ordinance and as follows: (i) Interior landscaping. A minimum of five percent of the interior area of a parking lot shall be reserved for landscape purposes. This provision shall include the landscaping of all required parking islands and medians. Shade trees shall be incorporated within the landscaped islands whenever and wherever practicable.
(ii) Parking lot screening adjacent to public right-of-way. Low profile screening shall be required when parking spaces would result in vehicles facing onto the roadway. Screening may consist of a low wall, evergreen hedge with a minimum height of two feet at the time of planting, planted three feet apart on center, and a maximum height of three feet at maturity, or earth berm. Should a low wall be used, such wall shall be accompanied by evergreen shrub plantings on the roadway side of the wall and spaced ten feet apart on center.
(iii) Reserved.
27.64 Site access. (a) Entrance width and radii. Site entrances shall have a minimum width of 24 feet. Entrances involving a median divider shall be at least 35 feet in width. Entrance radii shall be a minimum of 15 feet and a maximum of 25 feet.
(b) Number of entrances and curb cut spacing. One curb cut shall be permitted for each street which abuts a site. For sites with street frontage in excess of 300 linear feet, one additional curb cut may be permitted. For sites with street frontage in excess of 600 linear feet, two additional curb cuts may be permitted.
Multiple curb cuts on a property shall have a minimum spacing distance in accordance with the following schedule:
| Speed Limit | Maximum Spacing (Ft.) |
|---|---|
| 25 | 105 |
| 30 | 125 |
| 35 | 150 |
| 40 | 185 |
| 45 | 230 |
| 50 | 275 |
Paj 19
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
(c) [Shared access.] Shared access shall be provided, whenever possible, for entrances to adjoining uses, including residential driveways.
(d) [Cross access.] Cross access shall be provided among abutting uses of similar use categories, whenever possible, to provide linkage between properties as an alternative to re-entering the corridor to access both existing and future neighboring properties.
(e) Entrance locations for adjoining properties. Commercial site entrances shall be no closer than 25 feet to an adjoining property which is zoned residential and no closer than ten feet to an adjoining property which is in a nonresidential zoning category.
27.65 [Signs.] Signs shall meet the regulations found in article 5, section 4, supplementary sign regulations.
27.66 Building height. (a) Buildings shall be limited in overall height to 35 feet and shall not exceed two stories.
27.67 Open space and landscaping. (a) Lot coverage. Each lot shall have a minimum of 25 percent of the lot area dedicated to be landscaped open space. A lesser amount of landscaped open space may be permitted when it can be demonstrated to the satisfaction of the planning commission, through the site plan review process, that, due to lot configuration and existing built conditions, the required minimum is impractical.
(b) Frontage. Each lot shall have a landscaped open space of at least 25 feet in width, measured from the back of curb along the entire frontage of the lot, except at points of site access. Trees shall be provided along the frontage perimeter at a minimum rate of one tree for each 50 linear feet of frontage.
(c) Side and rear yards. A minimum of 15 feet of landscaped open space shall be provided along all side and rear lot lines when abutting a residential use and a minimum of five feet when abutting a nonresidential use. Tree plantings shall be provided along all nonfrontage perimeters at a minimum rate of one tree for each 75 linear feet.
(d) Stormwater detention ponds. Detention ponds may be counted toward the minimum 25 percent open space area, provided that such ponds are designed to emulate natural features by incorporating irregular outline, gradual slopes (no greater than 1:4), and appropriate landscape plantings.
(e) Landscaping. Landscaped open spaces shall be designed in accordance with the provisions of this section, as well as the landscaping guidelines as set forth in article 5, section 9 of this ordinance.
(f) Screening. The following items shall be located so as to minimize visibility from the roadway, adjacent properties and other public areas, and shall be screened from public view: (1) Service bays; (2) Loading docks and platforms; (3) Rooftop utilities; (4) Satellite dishes; (5) Dumpsters; (6) Storage areas.
(g) Standard for tree plantings. Trees shall be of a high canopy variety and shall be limbed to a minimum height of 12 feet above grade at maturity.
Paj 20
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
(h) Standards for shrubbery. Shrubbery shall be of a low evergreen variety and shall be limited to use as foundation plantings and for screening purposes.
(i) Standards for ground cover. Ground cover shall be limited to turf and ornamental grasses and ornamental evergreen ground cover plantings within required landscape areas.
27.68 Lot configuration. All lots within the corridor overlay district created after the enactment of this section shall conform to the following: (a) Minimum lot area [shall be] 10,000 square feet. Service stations [shall have a minimum lot area of] 20,000 square feet. (b) Minimum lot depth shall be 100 feet. In the C-3 (service commercial) district, the minimum lot depth shall be 150 feet. (c) Minimum road frontage shall be at least 100 feet. In the C-3 (service commercial) district, the minimum road frontage shall be 150 feet.
27.69 Architectural review. The side of any building which faces the corridor (or corridors) shall be referred to as the "corridor elevation." Buildings in the COZ-1 shall be designed to front on the corridor, and the corridor elevation shall contain architectural elements traditionally associated with the front of a building. Blank walls without functioning windows are prohibited along the corridor. Windows must be incorporated into the overall design concept of the corridor elevation. Providing one or several small windows on a large corridor elevation shall not constitute compliance with this ordinance.
A "functioning window" shall be defined as a window which lets light into the interior of the structure, and is integrated and related to the interior layout of the space. In addition to functioning windows, the corridor elevation shall have the following elements: (a) A primary entrance door or doors (except for loading doors). (b) A primary entrance feature, such as a porch, portico, awning, entrance walk, or other similar feature.
In addition, the corridor elevation shall have one of the following elements: (a) Landscaping integrated into the building design concept. (b) Architectural or urban design elements which link adjacent structures together, such as plazas, walkways, colonnades, or similar features. (c) Architectural relief, such as vertical and horizontal offsets in exterior wall elevations, band courses, lintels and sill courses, cornices, and the like, to create shadow lines.
The applicant shall submit 12 copies of the corridor elevation at the time of application. The city planner or his/her designee shall determine whether compliance with the provisions of this ordinance has been achieved.
27.7 Properties located on a corner lot with two frontages within the Corridor Overlay Zone. When a property is located on the corner of two corridors within the Corridor Overlay Zone, only one of the two corridors shall be subject to the requirements of Section 27.61 Setbacks and Section 27.63 Parking, Subsection (a) Location. The frontage of the property on which the identifiable front of the building is located shall be the frontage that is subject to the requirements of Section 27.61 And Section 27.63, Subsection (a). In designing the site, in order to qualify for the relief under this subsection, the applicant must demonstrate to the satisfaction of the planning commission that the design incorporates the principles of superior urban design as defined in Section 27.2.
IV. RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING STAFF:
This Request is to rezone lands from R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone). The property would remain subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). Page 20
Paj 21
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
The permitted uses allowed in the current zoning district of R-10 focus on residential uses as one-family detached residences and also provides the ability for consideration of conditional uses for places of worship, schools, and certain other institutional types uses. The proposed Rezoning to C-1A zone is a zoning district offering a mix of uses. For the C-1A zone, the range of permitted uses that are commercial uses include retail, personal service establishments, service establishments, restaurants, and offices. The C-1A zone also includes permitted uses that are residential in nature including one-family residences (detached dwellings, attached (townhouse) units, and semi-detached (duplex) units); apartments; and multi-family dwellings (more than 2 dwelling units in same building). The C-1A zone also includes conditional uses (uses subject to specific review for approval) for drive-throughs accessory to a permitted use. The C-1A specifically prohibits fuel pumps and motor vehicle storage, sales, or repairs.
Staff recommends that the rezoning for C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) while retaining the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) be granted as requested, as the proposed zoning is consistent with the 2019 Comprehensive Plan (as amended) for the Mixed Use Land Use Classification Category. The C-1A zoning district is a mixed use district allowing for development of both commercial land uses and residential land uses.
Staff also recommends that the property remain subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) due to its frontage on Forrest Avenue. The purposes of the COZ-1 are to promote superior urban corridor development; to foster coordination and linkage among corridor properties; to preserve functionality and efficiency of the roadway for traffic movement; and to achieve a visually balanced streetscape environment friendly to the pedestrian and motorist. (Zoning Ordinance, Article 3 §27). The COZ-1 includes a number of additional buffers/setbacks, landscaping enhancements, and site layout design requirements which will be required as part of any proposed development activities on the parcel.
This area of Forrest Avenue is part of a corridor gateway leading into the City of Dover. This location is along a key west-east corridor in the transportation system. The area is a transition from the rural areas west of Dover as the corridor becomes residential and then a more heavily commercial area as it moves towards the central core of the City. Within the City limits to the west/southwest of this subject site there is the Dover High School campus, several places of assembly (churches), and an existing apartment complex and other apartment developments proposed. Planning Staff does note the residential character and density of housing units within the area surrounding this subject property and the existence of a sidewalk network for walkability that would allow for residents to reach this location (by walking) should small scale commercial uses be proposed for development to provides services. In addition, other transportation improvements may also be required based on the traffic generation of any proposed development.
This Rezoning Request does not grant approval of a specific use for the property but makes its land use subject to a listing of uses permitted and potential conditional uses as allowed in the C-1A zoning district. Staff again notes that any potential development for the site would have to be in line with the zoning district classifications and would similarly have to follow all development design guidelines of the Zoning Ordinance and other City and State regulations. Were the application for Rezoning to be recommended by the Planning Commission and subsequently approved by the City Council, the applicant would still have to submit Site Development Plans for review for most uses of the site to be established.
Paj 22
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
Any development of the property once zoned C-1A with the COZ-1 would be subject to the bulk standards and provisions and the review processes for site development. Staff notes that the C- 1A includes a series of bulk standards related to lot width, setbacks, a two story building height, and a Floor Area Ratio (FAR) of 1.5 (ratio of building floor area to lot area). Also, the COZ-1 zone includes design standards for development related to setbacks, height, buffers, landscaping, etc. Any non-conformity of the existing buildings’ uses and placement regarding the bulk standards of the C-1A and COZ-1 would be subject to the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance, Article 7 – Nonconforming Buildings and Uses.
This recommendation is being made without the benefit of hearing the comments of surrounding landowners and residents. A public hearing is required on this matter and the Planning Commission should give those comments consideration.
- V.PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEW FOR RECOMMENDATION This Rezoning Application is a request for a zoning map amendment which changes the zoning district of a property. The Planning Commission as part of their public hearing and review process will provide a recommendation on the rezoning request to City Council. As part of the process outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the Planning Commission must evaluate the following factors when considering the request:
Article 10 § 5.36 Report of the planning commission. Regarding each application for a zoning map amendment, the planning commission shall provide a report to the city council stating a recommended action with regards to the proposed amendment, along with the commission's evaluation of the following factors:
(A) Whether the uses permitted by the proposed change would be compatible with the existing uses and zones in the area concerned;
(B) Whether adequate public services and infrastructure exist or can be created or expanded to serve the needs of any additional demand as a result of such change; and
(C) Whether the proposed change is in accordance with the city's current comprehensive plan.
A Recommendation Report from the Planning Commission will be forwarded to City Council for their consideration of the Rezoning Application. This document and its attachments make up the Recommendation Report.
RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION:
At the Hybrid (In-Person and Virtual) Planning Commission Meeting of January 16, 2024, the Application Z-23-02 was represented by the members of the project team including Jonathan Street of Becker Morgan Group and John Paradee, Esq. of Baird, Mandalas, Brockstedt & Federico. The project team presented their request for rezoning with a PowerPoint presentation including a series of maps. During the Public Hearing, ten (10) members of the public spoke, and one written comment was received.
The Planning Commission’s motion was to recommend the denial of Rezoning application Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue for rezoning from R-10/COZ-1 to C-1A/COZ-1 and resulted in a vote of 6-2 in favor of denial of the rezoning.
Paj 23
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
The Planning Commission members’ reasons cited for denial of the rezoning include concerns with compatibility of the addition of commercial in a residential neighborhood (housing) area; the inappropriateness of the proposed rezoning; concerns with traffic and safety of residents and children and safety issues in regard to nearby school; and the broadness of the C-1A zoning district; and the testimony received from residents.
The Planning Commission members’ reasons cited against the motion for denial of the rezoning included the compliance of the proposed rezoning with the desire of the Comprehensive Plan for a mixed of uses and noting that the concerns of safety and traffic will be addressed during a Site Plan process.
See also the included excerpt of the DRAFT Meeting Minutes of the January 16, 2024 Planning Commission meeting. The comments received from the other member agencies of the Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) are also provided.
VI. ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
- 1)The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Rezoning Application does not represent Site Development Plan or Subdivision Plan approval. Following any decision made by City Council in regard to this Rezoning, then an application for a Site Plan, Subdivision Plan, and/or appropriate Building Permits must be submitted to the Planning Department prior to the establishment of a use, development activity, or any construction activity on the site. The applicant should contact the Planning Staff to determine the appropriate review process for any proposed projects.
- 2)The property is subject to the requirements of the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) related to development.
- 3)The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Rezoning Application does not represent a Building Permit, Sign Permit, or other construction activity permit approval. A separate application submission is required before issuance of permits by the City of Dover.
- 4)The applicant shall be aware that any future use of the existing structures may be subject to a separate permitting or licensing process through the City of Dover Licensing and Permitting Division. All businesses operating in the City of Dover are required to obtain a City of Dover Business Licenses. Certain types of uses also require a Public Occupancy Permit or Rental Dwelling Permits.
ATTACHMENTS:
- •Zoning Map Exhibit
- •Application Z-23-02 Submission: o Letter Narrative of Submission o Forrest Avenue Rezoning Exhibit Plan Sheet
Paj 24
Item #4. Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue: Rezoning to C-1A and COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
- •Development Advisory Committee Comments from City of Dover Departments of Public Works and Water & Wastewater, Electric Department, City Office of the Fire Marshal, DelDOT, and the Dover/Kent County MPO
- •PowerPoint Presentation Slide Series from 1/16/2024 Meeting (Presentation by Applicant)
- •Public Comments Set 1: Email from Robert Hice dated 1/16/2024
- •Excerpt from DRAFT Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024
- •Proposed Ordinance #2024-01
Paj 25
City of Dover Application No.: Z-23-02
Item #4.
Department of Planning & Inspections
R-8
ir
Som
e rse
tC R-10 ROS
Che ROS
lsea
T uc k Way
et Cir
R-10
Matthew Ct
R-8
RM-1 R-8
R-10
Stoney Dr
Falm
R-10 ou th W
a y Dr
Cranberry Ru
R-10
n
R-10
Heatherfield Way
| A | Yarmouth Way | R-8 | R- |
|---|---|---|---|
| R-10 | 20 |
Forrest Ave
IO
Dr
igh
rH
D ove
RM-1
Mar
ROS g a te
C ir
Tile: Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC Ordinance #: 2023-12 Address: 1617 Forrest Ave Legend Parcel IDs: ED-05-075.00-01-07.00-000 Dover Boundary Existing Zoning: R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) Subject Property Proposed Zoning: C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) Zoning COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) Owner: Draper Farm Properties LLC Dover Parcels Date: 12/05/2023
«
Corridor Overlay Zone
0 200 400 800 Feet
Paj 26
Item #4.
Paj 27
Item #4.
Paj 28
Item #4. SITE DATA ZONING - R - 10 1. OWNER OF RECORD: DRAPER FARM PROPERTIES, LLC ONE FAMILY RESIDENCE ZONE 23 ZION ROAD SMYRNA, DE 19977 2. ENGINEER: BECKER MORGAN GROUP INC. 309 SOUTH GOVERNORS AVENUE ZONING - R - 10 DOVER, DE 19904 ONE FAMILY RESIDENCE ZONE (302) 743 - 7950 3. PROPERTY MAP NUMBER: 2-05-07500-01-0700-00001 ZONING - R - 10 ONE FAMILY 4. ZONING CLASSIFICATION: EXISTING: R-10 - ONE FAMILY RESIDENCE ZONE RESIDENCE ZONE PROPOSED: C-1A - LIMITED COMMERCIAL ZONE 5. DEED SUMMARY: 9233 - 0253 & 7548 - 0312 6. PRESENT USE: VACANT RESIDENTIAL HOME 7. PROPOSED USE: MIXED USE 8. TOTAL SITE AREA: 5.00 ACRES ± 9. SOURCE OF WATER: CITY OF DOVER ZONING - RG - 2 GENERAL RESIDENCE
SOURCE OF SEWER: ZONING -
CITY OF DOVER
RECREATIO ROS
N & OPEN
SPACE
ZONING - R - 10
ONE FAMILY ZONING - R - 10
RESIDENCE ZONE ONE FAMILY
RESIDENCE ZONE
ZONING - R - 10
CRANBERRY RUN DRIVE ONE FAMILY RESIDENCE ZONE
SITE LANDS N/F DRAPER FARM PROPERTIES, LLC. T.P. 2-05-07500-01-0700-00001 ZONING - R - 10 - ONE FAMILY RESIDENCE ZONE ZONING - A 5.00 ACRES ± AGRICULTURAL ZONING - R - 10 ONE FAMILY ZONING - R-M1 ZONING - R - 20 ZONING - R - 20 RESIDENCE ZONE ONE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MEDIUM DENSITY ZONING - R-M1 ONE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL RESIDNECE MEDIUM DENSITY ZONING - R - 8 ZONING - R - 8 RESIDNECE ONE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ONE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL
FORREST AVENUE
ZONING - IO ZONING - RS1
INSTATUTIONAL SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ZONING - R - 10 ZONING - RS1
OFFICE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL
ONE FAMILY RESIDENCE ZONE
LAYER STATE: 11x17
FORREST AVENUE ARCH I T E C TURE
ENG I NE E R I NG
BMG: 2021070.00
1" = 150' 0 75 150 SCALE: REZONING EXHIBIT Dover, DE DATE: 11/03/2023 309 S. Governors Ave. DRAWN BY: A.C.F. Dover, DE 19904 Do Not Explode - Select Scale CITY OF DOVER Ph. 302.734.7950 SCALE: 1" = 150' KENT COUNTY, DELAWARE Fax 302.734.7965 1Page 28 F:\AutoCAD\Projects\2021\2021070\DWG\2021070-AERIAL.dwg, Dec 05, 2023 - 3:21pm
2023-12-05
Paj 29
Item #4.
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: DECEMBER 27, 2023
APPLICATION: Lands of Draper Farm Properties at 1617 Forrest Avenue FILE #: Z-23-02 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Water & Wastewater CONTACT PERSON: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater CONTACT PHONE #: 302-736-7025 CONTACT EMAIL #: jlyon@dover.de.us
T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .
T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
- 1.Our office has no objections to the proposed rezoning of tax parcel ED-05-075.00-01-07.00-000. Any redevelopment shall adhere to the City of Dover Water/Wastewater Handbook and the Specifications, Standards & Procedures for Public Works Construction. Impact fees may be applied to this property. Future development shall comply with all aspects of the City of Dover’s Cross Connection Control Program.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. None
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. None I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .
Paj 30
Item #4.
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: DEC 27, 2023
APPLICATION: Lands of Draper Farm Properties at 1617 Forrest Ave FILE #: Z-23-02 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Electric Department CONTACT PERSON: Shawn Burgett, Engineering Services & System Ops Superintendent CONTACT PHONE #: 302-674-7568 CONTACT EMAIL #: sburgett@dover.de.us
T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .
T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
ELECTRIC
Our office has no objection to the rezoning of: ED-05-075.00-01-07.00-000, Council District 1.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES ELECTRIC 1. Should this site be redeveloped, which includes modifications to the use, the applicant / developer will be responsible for all costs associated with providing the appropriate meter / service to this site based upon the use including any necessary system upgrades or extensions. The appropriateness and adequacy of electric and meters will be assessed at that time. 2. Any redevelopment shall adhere to the City of Dover’s Electric Service Handbook. https://evogov.s3.amazonaws.com/media/27/media/13108.pdf.
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
ELECTRIC
- 1.None.
I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .
Paj 31
C F #4.
Z-23-02
Item
I I
T R
CITY OF DOVER Y E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE O M
F A APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY R D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 12/27/23 D S O H V A E L R APPLICATION: Lands of Draper Farm Properties at 1617 Forrest Ave
FILE #: Z-23-02 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover, Office of the Fire Marshal
CONTACT PERSON: Jason Osika, Fire Marshal PHONE #: (302) 736-4457 josika@dover.de.us
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY, AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESS BY THE APPLICANT:
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
- 1.Proposal is for a rezoning application. This office has no objections.
- 2.Every house, building or structure used or intended for use as living quarters or as a place for conducting business, and having any wall facing or abutting any public or private street or alley, shall have displayed on that wall, in legible, easily read characters which are of contrasting color to the background, the proper street number for such house, building, or structure in accordance with the following:
One-family and two-family residential structures, height, the number shall measure a minimum of four inches in height, location, the number shall be placed on the house above or to the left or right of the front entrance, color, the number shall be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals, all numbers shall be Arabic numerals.
Multiple-family dwellings, measurements, the number shall measure a minimum of six inches when identifying individual apartments with exterior doors, and 12 inches when identifying buildings with apartment complexes where there are two or more buildings not assigned street addresses. Individual buildings with street addresses shall have numbers measuring six inches, location, numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the street end of the building so as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the parking lot, color, numbers shall be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic numerals.
Paj 32
Item #4.
Commercial, industrial and office buildings, height, the numbers shall measure a minimum of 12 inches in height, location generally, numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the street end of the building so as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the parking lot,
property line or driveway, should the building be located far enough from a public or private road so that the numbers are not clearly visible from the street, then the street address shall also be posted on the property at or near the property line or driveway to said building,
color; each building, numbers shall be contrasting to the background color and shall be placed on each building in the complex,
Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic numerals,
Shopping centers. Shopping centers consisting of two or more stores shall have a tenant or suite number affixed to the front of the tenant space and on the outside of the rear door which corresponds with that tenant space. Numbers shall measure six inches in height. (City of Dover Code of Ordinances, 98-344)
ADDITIONAL / SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS TO OBTAIN APPROVAL:
- 1.N/A
APPLICABLE CODES LISTED BELOW (NOT LIMITED TO):
2021 NFPA 1 Fire Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2021 NFPA 101 Life Safety Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 72 National Fire Alarm and Signaling Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 13 Installation of Sprinkler Systems (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2009 IBC (International Building Code) Latest editions of all other NFPA Codes as defined by the Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations 2021 Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations City of Dover Code of Ordinances
*If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person listed.
Paj 33
Item #4.
CITY OF DOVER D
E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
L
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY D
O
T
===============================================================
APPLICATION: Lands of Draper Farm Properties
FILE#: Z-23-02 REVIEWING AGENCY: DelDOT
CONTACT PERSON: Michael Vandevander PHONE#: 302-760-2141
=============================================================== THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY'S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:
CITY & STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
No person, firm, corporation or the like shall construct, open, reconstruct, maintain, modify or use any crossing or entrance onto a state-maintained highway, street or road, including any drainage modifications leading into or carried by the highway drainage system, without first having complied with standards and regulations adopted by the Department and having obtained a permit issued by the Department. Please contact the Delaware Department of Transportation - Development Coordination section to begin permit process.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES:
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
- 1.The developer will need a pre-submittal meeting to discuss the development with DelDOT.
- 2.No access will be given off Forest Avenue.
Paj 34
Item #4.
CITY OF DOVER Dover/Kent
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
County
Metropolitan
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY Planning
D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 1/3/2024 Organization
APPLICATION: Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties at 1617 Forrest Avenue
FILE # Z-23-02 REVIEWING AGENCY: Dover/Kent County MPO
CONTACT PERSON: Malcolm Jacob PHONE #: (302) 387-6030
Issues of concern to the MPO are effective transit, reducing the amount of vehicle emissions by shortening or eliminating trips, and facilities for alternative modes of transportation, including bicycle and pedestrian access. The MPO considers the bicycle facilities required by the City of Dover to be the standard for all applications, not to be waived.
City of Dover Planning Commission
Zoning Review
Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties at 1617 Forrest Avenue
- 1)The MPO does not have any objections to the proposed rezoning. Further comments will be submitted if site development takes place at a later date.
- 2)Last year the MPO completed a study on the topic of pedestrian safety around Dover High School. The recommended improvements included building out the network of sidewalks and crosswalks on Forrest Avenue. It should also be noted that Cranberry Run is located within the walk zone of Dover High School. While the frontage of this property already contains sidewalks, there is no safe means of crossing Forrest Avenue from this location, which means a pedestrian must use the crosswalks further to the east or west. This connectivity gap should be examined by DelDOT, the City of Dover, and other officials in the future. Please see the following link for the complete study: https://doverkentmpo.delaware.gov/files/2023/07/Dover-High-School-Walk- Zone-Sidewalk-Gaps-Final-7.2023.pdf
If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person and the Planning Department as soon as possible.
Paj 35
Item #4.
D R A P E R FA R M P R O P E R T I E S CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION
P UBL I C H EA R I N G 1. 16. 2024
Paj 36
L O C AT I O N M A P Item #4.
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 37
REQUESTED REZONING Item #4.
- •Petition for an amendment to zoning map for the subject parcel from current zoning category of R-10 (Single Family Residential) to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone).
- •The parcel remains subject to Corridor Overlay Zone-1 regulations.
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 38
REZONING CRITERIA Item #4.
- •Whether adequate public services and infrastructure exist or can be created or expanded to serve the needs of any additional demand as a result of such change:
- •Whether the uses permitted by the proposed change would be compatible with the existing uses and zones in the area concerned:
- •Whether the proposed plan is in compliance with the City of Dover’s current comprehensive plan:
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 39
REZONING CRITERIA Item #4.
- •Whether adequate public services and • According to the City of Dover Public Works and City of infrastructure exist or can be created Dover Electrical Department, the subject parcel has access or expanded to serve the needs of any to City water, sewer, and electrical utilities. additional demand as a result of such change:
- •C-1A Is a permitted zone in the Mixed-use Land Use
- •Whether the uses permitted by the category of the Comprehensive Plan. The subject property proposed change would be compatible is located along the Route 8 corridor on the west side of the with the existing uses and zones in the City. There are numerous examples of mixed use area concerned: commercial and residential applications operating along the Route 8 corridor.
- •Whether the proposed plan is in • From Dover’s 2019 comprehensive plan, the parcel is compliance with the City of Dover’s currently designated Mixed Use land use category. This current comprehensive plan: category is meant to encourage the creation of neighborhood centers. The zoning change would allow the parcel to be developed in a residential / commercial “neighborhood center” type application. These neighborhood centers provide residents from the surrounding community with convenient and walkable access to retail services, without having to make frequent or lengthy vehicle trips across town or out to the highway.
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 40
CITY OF DOVER COMPREHENSIVE PLAN - MAP 12-1 Item #4.
SUBJECT PARCEL
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 41
N E I G H B O R H O O D C O M PAT I B I L I T Y - M A P 1 2 - 1 Item #4.
RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL
SUBJECT PARCEL COMMERCIAL RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 42
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMPLIANCE Item #4.
- •The rezoning aims to accomplish all three of the City of Dover’s goals for Mixed Land Use category:
The permitted uses of mixed use zoned
parcels are designed to encourage
creation of neighborhood centers.
The parcel is located along a major
roadway (Forrest Avenue).
The parcel is located within a one-half
mile radius of several surrounding
neighborhoods.
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 43
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMPLIANCE Item #4.
- •Zoning classification C-1A falls within the acceptable zoning districts for the mixed-use land use category in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan.
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 44
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMPLIANCE - USE Item #4.
b e c k e r m o r g a n . c o m
Paj 45
Item #4.
Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue (5- Acre Parcel): Rezoning R-10/COZ-1 to C-1A/COZ-1
Public Comments Received Through January 16, 2024 (at 3:00pm):
1. Email from Robert Hice of 124 Chelsea Way in Cranberry Run
Development received January 16, 2024 (forwarded from City Clerk’s
Office): Objection to Rezoning
Paj 46
Item #4.
From: Bennett, Andria
To: Melson-Williams, Dawn; Purnell, Maretta; Mullaney, Kristen N
Cc: City Clerks Office
Subject: FW: EXTERNAL: Tonights meeting.
Date: Tuesday, January 16, 2024 8:22:44 AM
Attachments: image001.png
Good Morning,
The Clerk’s Office received the email below providing testimony for this evening’s Planning Commission Meeting.
Andria Bennett
City Clerk
City of Dover
P: (302) 736-7009
F: (302) 736-5068
abennett@dover.de.us
-----Original Message-----
From: Robert Hice <RHice86591@aol.com>
Sent: Tuesday, January 16, 2024 7:04 AM
To: City Clerks Office <CityClerk@dover.de.us>
Subject: EXTERNAL: Tonights meeting.
[Some people who received this message don't often get email from rhice86591@aol.com. Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.
To whom it may concern,
My name is Robert Hice and I live at 124 Chelsea Way in Dover. This is a subject of tonights meeting. The rezoning of a parcel of land that sits in front of Cranberry Run. I, and many others thought that this issue was put to rest a few months ago, but here it is again. The current owners want to have this parcel rezoned so they can sell it to a buyer that wants to build a “convenience store with gas pumps.” It is my understanding that it is currently zoned for residential building.
I and those that I have spoken too are absolutely against this rezoning effort. This location sits in our
Paj 47
Item #4.
backyard and we don’t want it. The list of reasons is long but a few are as follows. The area is already to congested with traffic with all the developments and high school across the street. The brights lights at night and loud noise will also be unwanted. And we don’t want the associated crime that surrounds these places this close to our front doors. Just ask a police officer how much crime occurs at these places. Just recently there was a shooting at the Wawa that is only a half mile away. Speaking of Wawa you can no longer stop there and get out of your vehicle without smelling the aroma of maijuana.
We initially bought a house in Cranberry Run because it was in the city but still out in the country surrounded by farmland. You can see how the sprawl has affected us with all the new developments, High School etc. I sincerely hope that you vote against this rezoning and do what the homeowners, voting citizens want rather than what money and big business want. Our quality of life is hanging in the balance.
Sincerely,
Robert Hice, USAF Retired
124 Chelsea Way
Dover, DE 19904
302-672-6458
PS: Notices were sent out to surrounding properties regarding the rezoning but we never received one because we were inches beyond the requirement to notify. Even though we are affected more than many that were notified.
Paj 48
Item #4.
CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION
January 16, 2024 Excerpt from Meeting Minutes – Draft
The Meeting of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Tuesday, January 16, 2024 at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system WebEx. The Meeting Session was conducted with Chair Mrs. Maucher presiding. Members present were Mr. Cooper, Mrs. Denney, Mr. Witham, Mr. Baldwin, Dr. Jones, Mr. Reaves, Mrs. Welsh (virtual), and Mrs. Maucher. Mr. Roach was absent.
Staff members present were Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Ms. Katherine Oehmke, Mr. Jason Lyon (virtual) and Mrs. Kristen Mullaney (virtual).
NEW APPLICATIONS
Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue - Public Hearing and Review for Recommendation to City Council of a Rezoning application for a parcel of land consisting of 5.04 acres. The property is zoned R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The proposed zoning is C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The property is located on the north side of Forrest Avenue and adjacent to Cranberry Run Drive. The owner of record is Draper Farm Properties LLC. Property Address: 1617 Forrest Avenue. Tax Parcel: ED-05-075.00-01-07.00- 000. Council District 1. Ordinance #2023-12
Representative: Mr. Jonathan Street, Becker Morgan Group; Mr. John Paradee, Baird, Mandalas & Brockstedt
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that this is a Rezoning request for the Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC located at 1617 Forrest Avenue. It is a request to Rezone from R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) and COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) to a proposed zoning classification of C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) and remaining subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). This is just over five acres of land located on the north side of Forrest Avenue. It is shown in the image on the screen in the solid blue color. The areas that are highlighted and outlined in blue on that image, are the areas of public notice that fall within that 200 hundred feet mailing requirement. Additionally, public notice is achieved by a bright yellow sign that is physically posted on the property and a legal ad posted in the local newspaper. All three items of public notice were completed. With this property, as noted, it is an existing parcel land. It is predominantly vacant. There was a previous residence that was demolished and there are several associated agricultural outbuildings that may remain on the property at this point. This location may look familiar to some as it was a previous Rezoning request in 2021 to rezone it to C-2A (Limited Central Commercial Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). Ultimately, that Rezoning application was unsuccessful. Tonight, we have a new application that is seeking to rezone to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone). The Comprehensive Plan for this location identifies in the Land Development Plan that the property has a land use category of Mixed Use. Our Report outlines some of the information about Mixed Use strategies in the city in the Comprehensive Plan. It is noted that the Mixed Use land use category does have C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) as one of the zoning districts that it could be rezoned to. Specifically
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 1 of 14
Paj 49
Item #4.
talking about the C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone), this is a zoning district that allows uses such as retail stores, personal service establishments, service establishments, restaurants, a variety of offices as well as residential uses such as one family residences, apartments, and multi-family dwellings. Through a Conditional Use process, drive-throughs may be considered. She does want to note very specifically that the C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) zoning district prohibits the use of fuel pumps and motor vehicle storage, sales, or repairs. In the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) for this property, that zoning classification is more related to design and development aspects for the property as it would require a series of architectural parking and landscaping guidelines to be implemented with any development on the property. With a Rezoning application such as this, the Planning Commission has to consider several factors when looking at the request which will amend the zoning map. Specifically, they have to make a recommendation and that is carried in a report to the City Council. They have to evaluate it based on the following factors: whether the uses permitted by the proposed change would be compatible with the existing uses and zones in the area concerned; whether the adequate public services and infrastructure exist or can be created or expanded to serve the needs of any additional demand based on the change; and whether the proposed change is in accordance with the City’s current Comprehensive Plan. As part of the Development Advisory Committee Report, the Planning Staff has made a recommendation in regards to this Rezoning request. Planning Staff is recommending approval of the Rezoning to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) while retaining that COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) provision. They make this finding noting that the zoning is consistent with the 2019 Comprehensive Plan and the Mixed Use land classification category it has. The C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) zoning district, we find is a mixed use zoning district and allows for commercial and residential land uses. They do recommend that the property remain subject to that COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) provision related to development activities. They recognize that this area of Forrest Avenue is a gateway into the City of Dover moving from more residential areas in the far west to increasingly commercial areas as it moves towards the central core of the City. The general area is residential in nature. There is the Dover High School Campus as well as apartment buildings of higher density residential within the general area. The property does have significant frontage on Forrest Avenue and then also frontage on Cranberry Run. There are sidewalks in the area. They note that with any Rezoning request, this does not lock it into any particular land use that is identified in the C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone). Any potential development of the site would be subject to separate review processes and implementation of the design requirements of the Zoning Ordinance. Additionally from the other reviewing agencies that participate in the Development Advisory Committee, they have no objections to this Rezoning from the departments of Public Works, Water/Wastewater, Electric, the Office of the Fire Marshal, DelDOT, and the Dover Kent County MPO. Each of these have identified no objection to the Rezoning and offer some advisory comments that should development happen in the future. There will be more requirements to come associated with that development review process.
Mr. Street stated that as usual, he can toss most of his presentation out because Staff has already gone through it, but he will pick up some highlights this evening. What they are proposing, as shown before you on the screen, is the five acre piece almost directly across the street from the Dover High School located along Forrest Avenue on the west end of the City itself. The petition that they are requesting is to go from R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) as well as the parcel remaining subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) regulations. As Staff outlined, the City has three criteria for a Rezoning. The first is whether or Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 2 of 14
Paj 50
Item #4.
not there is adequate public facilities available to the parcel itself. The second would be whether or not a permitted use is compliant and/or acceptable with the surrounding parcels as far as uses in the zones. The third is whether or not it is in compliance with the 2019 Comprehensive Plan. The first is whether or not the parcel has adequate public facilities. He would submit that the City has adequate water, sewer, electric, and he believes that there is also gas on Forrest Avenue. So, without any objection to Public Works, the public facilities are taken care of and are available for the site to use. The second two kind of go hand in hand. They are whether or not the uses are compatible with the surrounding areas and zones and whether or not it is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan. Shown on the screen is a map of the proposed Land Development Plan within the 2019 Comprehensive Plan. The subject parcel is shown in purple which identifies it as a Mixed Use parcel or Mixed Use land use in the Comprehensive Plan. This is a blow up of that map and on the left hand side is the purple rectangle of the five acre piece that is our parcel. He wants to try to explain what he is trying to convey with this image. If you start Downtown and you work your way west on Loockerman Street, you will come up to that purple area on the right hand side of the screen, that is where Division Street and Loockerman Street come together right about at the Booker T. Washington School. You are going to see along the Route 8 Corridor is both commercial and residential along that entire corridor. You will have commercial facing the corridor itself as you get to the McKee Road and Saulsbury Road area. You have CVS, Walgreens, Vincenzo’s, the Food Lion/Gateway West Shopping Center that’s got restaurants, retail, and a grocery store in it. As you move west, you have the Modern Maturity Center, Dunkin Donuts and then behind the Dunkin Donuts and behind the Modern Maturity Center you have Bicentennial Village, Woodmill Apartments in the Woodmill subdivision itself. As you move further west, you are going to run into Redners. With Redners, you’ve got a mixture of not only service establishments such as hair and nails, you’ve got a grocery store, offices. Then behind that is more residential along Dover Kenton Road as well as Bicentennial Village itself. On the south side of Route 8, you are going to have the new Mexican restaurant (La Hacienda) that just opened, Wawa, WSFS Bank and more commercial/retail establishments in front of residential all along Forrest Avenue. It should be noted that if you look in the current Dover’s Comprehensive Plan, Dover’s expansion is west. The majority of the proposed annexations for the City are all west on Route 8 and Hazlettville Road. Dover High School was constructed on the west end of town because Dover’s expansion is west and they wanted it to be, once Dover expands, more centrally located. As you travel west, now you are getting into residential and you have this nice five acre parcel which is prime for light commercial, residential, mixed use, service type establishments, and small retail that support the surrounding community. That is what you have all along that Route 8 Corridor. The goals of Mixed Use in the Comprehensive Plan “encourage creation of neighborhood centers.” He thinks that this is kind of a key piece. He grew up in town right over in Fairview and one thing that they had growing up was the Little Store and the old Marsteller’s. Marsteller’s was a more of a couple of acres parcel. There was Marsteller’s, Roma’s, and an Ace Hardware. You had small service type facilities. He could walk to the Little Store all of the time. Those are the types of small walkable service type of facilities that they are talking about here in concert with small pieces of residential. The second thing is that it talks about these types of centers being close and walkable to a close community and fronting on major roadways. This fronts on Forrest Avenue and as Staff said, this is one of the gateways to Dover from the west. The third, he would submit, and he is sure that majority of the people behind him would submit that it is right smack in the middle of communities around it and a half a mile away that are all walkable and that would all be forced to be walkable, not long
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 3 of 14
Paj 51
Item #4.
through DelDOT on Forrest Avenue but through the City with pedestrian facilities themselves. C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) is an allowable use in the Mixed Use land use classification for the Comprehensive Plan. So, when you look at compliance with the Comprehensive Plan and compatibility with neighboring uses and zones, he would submit that you have a Route 8 Corridor just has commercial on the Route 8 Corridor itself and residential behind them. C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) is an allowable zone and Mrs. Melson-Williams already brought up all of the uses that are allowed with the C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) itself. You are talking about retail stores, personal establishments, restaurants, some residential as well as a scattering of office uses.
Mr. Reaves asked why not C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone) opposed to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone). Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mr. Street stated that he believes the difference between C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone) and C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) is that it dealt with the size of either the office or retail. C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) allows a little bit more flexibility with the size of the retail. We are not talking about giant retail; it’s like single use retail that you would see in Greentree Village, like a 1,500 SF space. He thinks that C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) allows for a little bit larger space than that.
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone) does have a limitation on the size of all establishments. It is limited to 2,500 SF per establishment. The uses are fairly similar to what is proposed with a Rezoning to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone). There are some limitations and some additional uses that are specifically prohibited in C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone).
Mr. Reaves stated that the 2,500 SF seems reasonable for a small neighborhood possible store or service establishment. He would be asking if 2,500 SF enough for what the plan is for there. Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mr. Street stated that they have no physical buildings laid out. The plan is a mixture of residential and commercial. With the 2,500 SF limitation, just through discussions, it limits what you can do commercially. So if someone needs something a little bit bigger as far as an office space than the 2,500 SF, then that’s not allowed in the zone. It allows a little bit more flexibility with that. He doesn’t think that they are talking about anything really big. You can’t really put a large building there but it just offers a little more flexibility. Through conversations with Staff and the client, C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) made the most sense.
Dr. Jones stated that she thinks this application has a little bit of history or previous applications. Has there been any communications to the residents because apparently there were some concerns early on? Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Street stated that he is not sure if there has been any communication between the owner and the residents themselves.
Mr. Witham asked that the fact that the area in question is over 5 acres, does that impact your judgement as to whether you are seeking a Rezoning from R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone)? That is no small area and it is not a large area but it is a good sized area. Because it is over 5 acres, would that play a major factor in your decision to seek a Rezoning to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone)? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mr. Street stated that he doesn’t know that the area itself does. It’s whether or not they would keep it residential and build houses or whether they would go commercial. He wasn’t part of those conversations; they came to him and said “we want to rezone it.” They kind of get their marching orders and
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 4 of 14
Paj 52
Item #4.
they may consult with them on what zoning may or may not make sense but they (the applicant) are the ones that come to us and they (the applicant) are the ones requesting a commercial zoning.
Mr. Witham stated that if the acreage was like one acre as opposed to five acres, could that have an impact of whether you seeking a Rezoning to the C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) or the C- 1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone)? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mr. Street stated that without having both and comparing them with the size of the parcel, it would probably play some part. He has developed a lot of one acre parcels so it kind of plays into it.
Mr. Cooper asked Mrs. Melson-Williams if she knows what the maximum square footage is for C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) versus C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone). He knows that it is at 2,500 SF for C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone) but it is hard to compare without the other end. Responding to Mr. Cooper, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) does not have a maximum size per establishment. That is one of the big differences. There are some slight differences in the uses that are allowed between the zones. For example, the C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone) does not specifically call out offices as an allowable use. It also has a few more prohibitions to it. We could also look to the bulk standards for both of those zones for comparisons, but the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) is also going to play a factor into some of those bulk standard limitations for development as well. The COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) has a height limitation and there is buffering and landscaping requirements that are going to make your buildable area smaller in general.
Mr. Street stated that having the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) remain on the parcel also means the buildings have to be put within 30-40 feet of Route 8. The buildings have to be pushed forward so that the buildings sit forward and the parking is to the rear. The COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) is subject to an exhaustive amount of plantings along the roadway and on the parcel as well as superior architectural standards. Those all have to be met if Site Plans move forward.
Mr. Reaves stated that with the explanation that Mr. Street explained about the commercial properties that are more east of Route 8 from the Wawa to the Redners, those areas contain four lanes of traffic, two lanes each direction. When you get down to this particular parcel, there is only two lanes of traffic going in either direction. Was that something that is a concern for this particular parcel? Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mr. Street stated not in general. He says that because he has done this for 20 years, DelDOT has their own standards and DelDOT has their own requirements depending on the traffic with whatever is generated. They can start getting into Site Plan issues. Depending on what goes there, traffic is calculated and then quantified and then they have to provide an entrance and safely maneuver that traffic in and out of the site. DelDOT plays a big part in that so it would have to meet DelDOT’s standards for number 1 and for number 2 it would have to meet safety and DelDOT’s requirements for left turn lanes, right turn lanes, signals, and everything else. They would have to go through that whole process before they even get access. In general, the two lanes doesn’t necessarily concern him off-hand because they would have to make accommodations for the site depending on what went there anyway.
Mr. Reaves stated that with regards to the Development Advisory Committee, the report from the
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 5 of 14
Paj 53
Item #4.
DelDOT agency clearly states that there will be no access to this property from Forrest Avenue which means that the entrance to this property which is an existing entrance would be into the neighborhood entrance and exit. Traffic that would be traveling east more or less would bottleneck in that particular area and that would be pretty devastating especially around the time periods that they are exiting the school and everyone is coming back in that direction. He doesn’t know what the conversation was that you had with DelDOT; however, if that road is not expanded, that could be a tremendous burden on traffic coming in and out. Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mr. Street stated that he can tell you that he saw the comment and it kind of made him scratch his head because it’s just a Rezoning and that comment is really more appropriate for a Site Plan. He actually reached out to both the reviewer and the subdivision engineer and asked if there was something that he was not seeing. At times, there can be deed restrictions or actually a denial of access to a road that DelDOT says you cannot have access to the road. Route 13 is good example. It is in the Corridor Capacity Overlay which they try and limit access to Route 13. Having said that, he received communications back from when he asked if this was just a standard comment because it’s on Forrest Avenue. It may be a little congested and it would be something that they would have to work through on the Site Plan and the response was basically yes. That is why it is an advisory comment not a requirement as a condition of approval of the Rezoning itself with all of these issues, DelDOT’s stance might be right now that they don’t want it to have access but they would still have to come work with us on any access when it was proposed with whatever Site Plan might come forward which there is none at this point.
Mrs. Maucher asked what housing density is allowed under this zoning. Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the types of units that are allowed include one family residences as attached and detached which would be things like townhouses, duplexes, single family detached, and apartments and multi-family dwellings which are more than one unit in an individual building. Some of those refer to the RG-1 (General Residence Zone) bulk standards and the RG-1 (General Residence Zone) bulk standards give a minimum lot size. There is not necessarily a density calculation; you just have to do the math.
Mrs. Maucher stated that if garden apartments were to be built, are there capacity restrictions as far as that would go with this zone? Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that you are going to have some limitation just with the bulk standards and setbacks from property lines that creates a buildable area within the property itself. With that, they have not done the math to figure out what the buildable area is on the parcel with 5 acres. There is certainly opportunity there. She wouldn’t want to guess the exact size this evening.
Mr. Street stated that he wanted to address something else. It is kind of his concern with DelDOT and he has had the conversation with them. They (the applicant) don’t want to pull the traffic onto that residential street. That just doesn’t make sense and that was his first comment. If they can’t come off of Route 8, then why would they want to go to the residential street? They would try and avoid that as much as possible because it just doesn’t make any sense for traffic as far as how traffic flows and what not. Your thinking is along the same lines; it doesn’t make sense to pull all that traffic into a residential street. No matter how big it is, it’s still the entrance to their subdivision and he wouldn’t want it if it was his.
Mr. Paradee stated that he wanted to try to address Mr. Witham’s question about the size of the acreage and the square footage limitation in the C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone). That is
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 6 of 14
Paj 54
Item #4.
found in Section 11 of Article 3 (of the Zoning Ordinance) Section 11.4 limits the total floor area in any one establishment to 2,500 SF. So, you have a five acre piece of land and it wouldn’t be a very sufficient use of that land to just put one 2,500 SF building on it. If it was a one acre parcel then that would make sense perhaps. But 2,500 SF on five acres is not a sufficient use of land. Their client has the intention of building something larger than 2,500 SF which they couldn’t do in C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone).
Mrs. Maucher stated that it is not limited to one per parcel, you could have ten establishments that are each 2,500 SF. Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mr. Paradee stated that they could. Now we are starting to get a little bit into Site Plan issues but frankly, even if you were able to have three or four 2,500 SF buildings, it’s probably not a flexible design or as efficient design as maybe having a 10,000 SF building which you couldn’t do in C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial Zone). The C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) gives them a lot more design flexibility. That is the concept and that is why the client chose that. It also specifically prohibits gas pumps.
Mrs. Maucher opened the public hearing.
Mr. John Davis – 4 Stoney Drive Dover, DE 19904 Mr. Davis stated that Dr. Jones asked a question about past history. This parcel, 2.5 years ago, was rejected by this body by a vote of 9-0 because it was not an appropriate use for that particular area which is residential. Mr. Street pointed out on his PowerPoint presentation, the map of Route 8 and the purple area which represented this property. It was outlined very well in terms of it shows that it is totally surrounded by residential area. When we talk about it being mixed use on Route 8, that’s true up until you get to Dover Kenton Road. From Dover Kenton Road and Mifflin Road on west, there is no commercial establishment. These are residential neighborhoods. He did read, after 2.5 years ago, the Comprehensive Plan. The neighborhood centers that Mr. Street references with Marsteller’s, Grocery Basket and some other quaint little stores that he remembers, that is not what’s going to go in here. It is not going to be a neighborhood center that this neighborhood wants. To answer Dr. Jones’ question about was there any outreach towards the neighbors. He can say unqualified, no. They have the President of the Cranberry Run Homeowner’s Association here and there has been no attempt to contact any of the members of the public that came 2.5 years ago. As now, everybody had our information. Dealing with Mr. Reaves’ question in terms of a left hand turn going east bound on Route 8, you pass a stop light at Dover High and then it’s just a couple of hundred feet until you get to the entrance of Cranberry Run. Where the entrance it going to be directly off of Route 8, that will create yet another potential traffic tie up as somebody attempts to make a left land turn into that property. Unless you decide that there is going to be no left hand turn and of course that is something for a Site Plan as they say. What he wanted to address specifically, is whether the proposed use is in keeping with the neighborhood especially, since there is no commercial property. If we are talking about a mixed use being in compliance with the residents of Route 8 from Dover Kenton Road east, sure. You have Redners right there and Wawa across the street. There is also the new Mexican restaurant, but you do not have west of Kenton Road and Mifflin Road, another commercial property until you hit the old Buck’s Barber Shop at the corner of Artis Drive and Route 8. That is all residential area. They are well aware of what happens with little strip centers at the edge of the western boundaries of the City of Dover. They are very
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 7 of 14
Paj 55
Item #4.
aware of what happens at the Wawa of Forrest Avenue. There was a shooting there last month. They are very aware of some of the issues that come with those particular strip centers. That is not in keeping with what is the residential nature of Heatherfield, Heatherfield East, Cranberry Run, and approximately eight (8) properties on the other side of Route 8 which back up on Dover High School’s property. He would like to thank Planning Staff who have always been unbelievably helpful toward him whenever he has stopped in.
Dr. Valarie Boyer – 3 Somerset Circle Dover, DE 19904 Dr. Boyer stated that she is the President of the Cranberry HOA. She moved here on October 22, 1999. Why? Because there were horses across the street on Route 8. Because there were cows. There was a man living in a little trailer and he had these little animals. She thought, “I’m going to move here.” Then she bought a cul-de-sac property and paid extra money to have a cul-de-sac that backed up to the woods where she put a $23,000 fence up. Now, it is a possibility that C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) is going to intrude on our neighborhood like this. We only have like 73 houses, but we are happy. We keep it up and we get our dues. Everyone takes care of their property. Can you imagine how our property value is going to plummet once these little structures go up? It was said before; Wawa just had a shooting. Someone was hiding in the bushes as he fired the shots. He hit someone and could have killed them. Who’s to say that they can’t hide behind a house or a shed or our cars and start doing some kind of rampage? The suggestion that there could be a convenience store there makes her wonder about the traffic coming down Route 8. They would have to turn into Cranberry Run. The 18-wheeler who has to use the bathroom and they want to come in would have to turn into Cranberry Run. What about the children who cross Route 8 from the high school? They want that snack. You know how it is when you’re hungry after school; so, they dart across that street and with all of that traffic somebody is going to get hit. Or when you are trying to go to work in the morning and you are trying to get onto Route 8, but you can’t get to Route 8 because there are people coming in and out of the development entrance. Traffic is steady on Route 8 as it is. They don’t need another back up. We don’t want commercial in our neighborhood. No one asked her or anyone that she knows. Would you want it in your neighborhood? No, you don’t. She didn’t move all the way here to have commercial structure on the side of the entrance of her neighborhood. She has a doctor who used to live across the street from her and he moved to Quail Run. It is a professional neighborhood. She is a professor at Delaware State University, and she is proud of it. She doesn’t want to move; she thought this was going to be her last stop. But commercial coming in, it is definitely something that she is going to have to rethink. If there is food being sold on that corner, you can believe that they are going through our park to sit there and eat and then throw the trash on the ground and then they may take a stroll through the woods. She has seen people do it before, but it hasn’t happened in a long time because she called the Police about it. It won’t take long before Cranberry Run will be absolutely destroyed for money.
Ms. Rose Marie Eberly – 109 Tucket Circle Dover, DE 19904 Ms. Eberly stated that they have been here before, and she is not quite sure what has changed because she can tell you that the community hasn’t changed their mind. They are definitely opposed to this Rezoning. They have concerns regarding the traffic. They already have trouble getting out of our development. Not just during the school times but also on Sundays when church lets out or if there are any activities going on in west Dover like funerals from the cemetery and many other events that cause them to have problems getting out of the
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 8 of 14
Paj 56
Item #4.
development. Any retail establishments here would be 24-hour lights, noise, trash thrown everywhere with the community expected to clean it up, and loitering from kids and adults. All of the establishments that this gentleman mentioned previously east of this property have crime which is theft, prostitution, drugs, or assault. If there is any doubt that they are there, just look at Route 8 and what’s going on at the Wawa or at the Kent 8 Shopping Center. Also, getting into our development, they are looking at having the entrance to this property come in on Cranberry Run. When we try to make a right turn into our development which we can’t even get a turn lane there, we are taking our lives into our hands. People don’t want to stop, slow down, or let us get into the development. As far as coming from the other direction, she is a bike rider, and she has had a car come directly at her because she was in the turn lane and they were too impatient to wait for somebody to make a right hand turn. That car slammed on their brakes to prevent hitting her. There have been other times while she is out on Route 8 where there are wide shoulders and she should be able to ride her bike there, but no because of the traffic in that area, it is not safe. The gentleman talked about a neighborhood center. It is not a neighborhood center if the people don’t want it there. The mission of the City Council is to have a “place that people want to live.” She thinks that right now, they have that. It is also to have a “clean and safe place.” Right now, they have that. If you put a commercial development in there, that is not going to be. “Diversity is valued” and she believes that is true. “Citizens are heard and enjoy a high quality of life.” You put a retail establishment in there and that’s not with the mission of City Council. They are not happy with this, and she hopes that the Commission will not rezone it because this proposed establishment does not go with the neighborhood.
Ms. Lynn Sadusky – 16 Stoney Drive Dover, DE 19904 Ms. Sadusky stated that she just wanted to start out by thanking each Commission member who asked questions because they were very thoughtful and some of the questions that she had weren’t answered in the presentation. She was here 2.5 years ago, and she agrees with the people who have already spoken that nothing has changed. They weren’t notified or contacted, and they remain opposed as multiple neighborhoods in that area. They are opposed to this kind of construction or commercialism in our neighborhood. She wants to mention three things. First of all, she leaves for work in the mornings between 7AM and 7:15AM each morning and to get out of the neighborhood of Heatherfield, she has to sit at that stop sign sometimes for 3-5 minutes just to get out safely because there are so many buses leaving Dover High School and traffic of parents dropping their kids off. It is really a difficult place to navigate without a light. Also, as a high school teacher, she is very concerned and she mentioned this a couple of years ago, with the enticement of having a business like that across the street from Dover High. Either during school hours or after school hours, she remembers when she was in high school at Dover High a long time ago, they were running to the local Hardees, and it wasn’t even within visual sight. She thinks it could be very dangerous for the students at Dover High School to have that kind of business there in addition to all of the traffic and the poor residents of Cranberry Run and Heatherfield. She just wants to press that she doesn’t think that we need another convenience store or some other type of large establishment in that area. Again, like somebody already said, we have businesses east of this area but there is nothing in that area except for neighborhoods. She knows that they would like to create some competition for Wawa possibly, but we don’t need another establishment like that in our neighborhood. It’s in accordance with the City of Dover’s planning, but it’s definitely not compatible with the neighborhood. They have residential zoning, and they have a residential area. They don’t need this type of building in the western part
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 9 of 14
Paj 57
Item #4.
of Dover. She also wants to suggest that she thinks that if Mr. Street or Mr. Paradee lived in the neighborhood or if your client lived in the neighborhood or their children or grandchildren lived in the neighborhood that they would certainly not be in favor of this type of Rezoning. She too is old enough to remember Marsteller’s on Walker Road and the Little Store that was a couple of miles from Fairview. She doesn’t think this is a fair comparison to the kind of building that is being proposed.
Mr. Richard Heisler – Forrest Avenue Dover, DE 19904 Mr. Heisler stated that there is no sense in repeating everything that has been said. He would like to reiterate that getting out on Route 8 when the school is letting out or starting up, it is just all but impossible and he lives on the right side of the road. The people on the other side, he pities them. He agrees with everything that has been said and he appreciates the Planning Commission taking our input. The previous Planning Commission, they did not attend it and that’s why your decision went the way it did. He certainly hopes that you consider everything that has been said here tonight by the residents.
Mr. Darrell Muchison, Sr – 129 Falmouth Way Dover, DE 19904 Mr. Muchison stated after hearing everyone with their statements and their proposals, he and his wife bought this home 16 years ago in June. They moved here from Philadelphia to raise our two children, which has been the greatest move that we have ever done just for our children’s sake. But in the same instance, they were introduced to a whole different lifestyle here in the City of Dover and he is grateful for that. He is also grateful for the peace and the quiet tranquility that this neighborhood and community brings with his choice to move here from Philadelphia. He wouldn’t change it for the world. The last proposal was to put a Sheetz gas station down the street, but we came together as a community, and we voiced our opinion and that was done away with. Along with everyone who just made their statements, we are really against any more confusion, any more traffic congestion that it takes for us to get in and out of our development even with the regards to the children that go to Dover High. Both of our children are graduates of Dover High; so, he has seen the changes. Some change is good and some change isn’t good and this change here, he doesn’t think would benefit the neighborhood of this community.
Mrs. Ashia Muchison – 129 Falmouth Way Dover, DE 19904 Mrs. Muchison stated that she heard a couple of people touch on the children and their safety, but she doesn’t think that the magnitude of their safety was presented well enough to make you guys reconsider. That bus stop is full of children at about 7AM and they are waiting to get on the bus when someone can be turning to another area which will cause confusion with anyone getting in or out. She knows that C-1 or C-1A is saying that it could be housing but would it be a halfway house? Would it be a homeless shelter? Would it be a safe haven for women who are running from something? What is it going to be? There is going to be not only bus traffic, but it is also going to be our children in the street racing across traffic to get to that store or to get to the other side. It is going to cause chaos and not only chaos, but the cost of living. Her property taxes are definitely going to go up more and her cost of living is going up as well. To her, the safety of our children and grandchildren are not considered.
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. Robert Hice did send an email and that email was provided to the Planning Office via the City Clerk’s Office and Staff distributed it to the
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 10 of 14
Paj 58
Item #4.
Planning Commission members. Mr. Hice is at 124 Chelsea Way in Cranberry Run. His email notes where he is residing, and he notes that he thought the Rezoning of this parcel was put to rest months ago. He makes the statement that “the current owners want to have this parcel rezoned so that they can sell it to a buyer that wants to build a convenient store with gas pumps. It is his understanding that it is currently zoned for residential building.” He notes that he is “absolutely against that Rezoning effort because it’s near his back yard.” It goes on with some of the other statements related to traffic, lighting and the issues at the Wawa that was recently experienced. He feels that his house is in the City, but it is still out in the country. He’s asking that the Commission vote against this Rezoning. He notes that he did not receive the notice that was sent to surrounding properties. Planning Staff checked his location, and his property is not within 200 feet of the subject site. It is like one parcel away from being in that mandatory notification area.
Mr. Robert Hice – 124 Chelsea Way Dover, DE 19904 Mr. Hice stated that he doesn’t have much to add as everyone else covered it pretty well.
Ms. Patricia Cohen – 1602 Forrest Avenue Dover, DE 19904 Ms. Cohen stated that she wanted to thank everyone for everything that has been said tonight. She was looking over the Comprehensive Plan. The 2019 Comprehensive Plan described our City of Dover as “poised for growth in order to maintain a small-town feeling, respecting the tranquility of residential areas to ensure safe and livable neighborhoods and well planned communities.” The Plan lists future challenges of maintaining the character of the neighborhoods while addressing the impact of the increased traffic infrastructure, maintenance, and air quality. She feels like the proposed changes should take into account the factors that are not seen on a daily basis unless you live there. So firstly, Route 8 is, as others have already said tonight, it’s already a high traffic flow area. The 35 MPH speed limit is rarely observed and instead Route 8 resembles a NASCAR race. Speeding and illegal passing are daily occurrences. They are very grateful to our City of Dover Police Department for their continued presence in helping to promote safety in the area. But naturally, they are extremely concerned for the safety of pedestrians and residents. If this land is developed, it will result in even more traffic up and down Route 8. Consider the detrimental effects on the air quality and exposure to environmental toxins as well. Next, while the proposed changes may appear advantageous on the surface, it is important to consider the impact on the infrastructure. The existing roadways will not be able to sustain increased traffic. In reviewing the Comprehensive Plan, they are all seeking to arrive at a positive solution. She struggles to understand how this zoning change would benefit surrounding neighborhoods and residents. So lastly, she urges the Planning Commission members to take a field trip. Even if it’s for only an hour of their day to physically sit on Route 8 and observe the traffic patterns in order to be more accurately informed of how negatively this proposed zoning change will influence the future of west Dover.
Mr. Jack Sutton – 1618 Forrest Avenue Dover, DE 19904 Mr. Sutton stated that after being on the phone listening to everybody, he has some great neighbors. He has nothing really to add to what they said. Everything they said is right on point. This is not a good thing for the traffic and safety. This just bothers him that this is even coming up again. He’s really just angry about it. He doesn’t think that anybody is happy about what’s happening here, and he’s just disgusted with it all. He and his wife have lived here for 18 years
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 11 of 14
Paj 59
Item #4.
now. This is a beautiful place to live and a beautiful place to raise your children. It is a beautiful place to walk and exercise and don’t take that away from us. There are a lot of senior citizens around here that feel comfortable living here. All for money and greed and he just finds it disgusting. He appreciates your time and that is all that he has to say because these people are right on the money.
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. Muchison who spoke earlier had another question that he entered into the chat. The question is will they cut down the trees? She believes that there are some existing trees on the property. This is just a Rezoning application. Any future development would be subject to a separate review process. The City does have tree preservation and tree planting requirements. Should development occur, she would imagine that’s something they would evaluate versus design and the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance.
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that she did get a note from Ms. Yvonne Biddle that her husband had already spoken.
Mrs. Maucher asked if there were any other written comments received other than Mr. Hice’s comments. Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that there were no other additional public comments, only the email from Mr. Robert Hice that she mentioned earlier.
Mrs. Maucher closed the public hearing.
Mrs. Denney asked if it was possible that somebody would have an interest in voting to approve this, would it be possible to make it conditional? For instance, a condition upon the fact that no entry to this come through or involve in any way Cranberry Run? Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that a Rezoning request is on the face of the zoning district alone. You cannot condition it to a particular use or to a condition of approval such as that.
Mr. Witham asked if the issue about the entrance access to the site just raised by Mrs. Denney, wouldn’t that come up on Site Plan review? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that any questions of site design, be it entrance, building placement, and all of that would be part of a Development Review Application for the project site.
Mr. Witham stated that the public could then certainly have input with respect to that, correct? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that certainly during a Site Development Plan, there is the ability for public hearing and input and potential conditions with an application; however, the appropriate regulatory agencies must also weigh in. The Planning Commission can’t supersede a DelDOT or Kent Conservation District requirement in the long run.
Dr. Jones moved to recommend denial to City Council for Z-23-02 Lands of Draper Farm Properties, LLC at 1617 Forrest Avenue for the change from present zoning (R-10/COZ-1) to the proposed zoning (C-1A/COZ-1) because of the testimonies from the residents. In addition to the comments made by one of the callers, she had already written these things down, but she distinctly put them in order. She does not believe that approval of this Rezoning would add to the safety of the residents and/or the young people who traverse that area quite a bit. She lives almost in that area, so she sees them. The zoning request appears not to be compatible with a Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 12 of 14
Paj 60
Item #4.
livable community and adding any type of commercial endeavor to that area would in fact not enhance tranquility, seconded by Mrs. Denney for the same reasons as the maker of the motion. She doesn’t believe that a Rezoning in this particular area considering at most, the safety issues with regard to the school and the students. She just thinks that this is not appropriate. She doesn’t think that it meets the character of what is already there as far as the housing and the character. The motion was carried 6-2 by roll call vote with Mr. Roach absent.
Dr. Jones voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mr. Reaves voting yes; based on the Corridor Overlay Zone Article 3, Section 27.1A. He has a concern that it doesn’t promote superior urban corridor development in the highest quality building environment. Also, it does not foster the coordination and linkage among corridor properties with adjacent lands and it does not preserve the functionality and efficiency of the roadway for traffic movement and safety. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons stated and also as she looks at Map 12.1, she sees that the ratio of commercial establishments and properties depicted on that map are significantly smaller compared to the residential neighborhoods and properties in that area and as noted by Mr. Davis in his comments. She knows that area well. She lives in that general area. The properties to the west of Mifflin Road are all depicted as residential on that Map and so she feels that that’s more compatible with the situation and it is an immense safety concern as far as what we do here. Mr. Cooper voting no (as clarified); this has got to be the toughest vote that he has had to make since joining this Commission. The Comprehensive Plan says to approve the application, but the road and the residents say not to. He thinks that if there was a Site Plan that showed the entrance which he understands is not feasible at this moment, he thinks it would make it a lot easier to vote for it. Unfortunately, he has to vote to deny the motion. Mrs. Denney voting yes; in keeping with the comments that she made when she seconded the motion. She does believe that most especially it’s the safety issues and as far as the traffic, we all know that that is ultimately up to DelDOT. But she travels that road a lot and it is just, to me, the fact that when she even thinks in her mind of students from the high school running across. We all know that it is the same thing with those teenagers. You can say that you shouldn’t run a stop sign and that you should slow down at a yellow light and all of those different things that we say that are ignored. Certainly, that would be one of them with a bunch of high school students. She thinks the safety issue is big. Mr. Witham voting no; for this particular site, the request is to amend the Zoning Map to rezone the property from R-10 (General Residence Zone) to C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) with the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) remaining in place. This certainly comes within the desire of the Comprehensive Plan to extend the commercial uses to include retail, personal service establishments, service establishments, restaurants, and offices. While the main concern as he sees it is a safety issue and traffic issues, he feels that perhaps those issues can be adequately addressed when it comes for Site Plan approval. He doesn’t think that should adversely impact on whether it meets the Comprehensive Plan design for this particular area. Mr. Baldwin voting yes; this is a just a recommendation to City Council. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; she thinks the C-1A (Limited Commercial Zone) is a very broad zoning option and it leads to a large number of facilities that may not meet the compatibility of the surrounding area. She does recognize that it is compatible with the Comprehensive Plan, but again, that is a very broad zoning category. (Note: The vote was originally announced as 8-0 in favor of denial. However, the Chair and Staff asked for clarification of the votes and two members, Mr. Witham and Mr. Cooper had voted against the motion.)
Mr. Reaves stated that he would like to give clarification to his comment in how he addressed the
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 13 of 14
Paj 61
Item #4.
issue. He votes to support the denial of Z-23-02.
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that is a recommendation to City Council. That, along with the reasons and comments and the Report will be packaged and forwarded the City Council. This is subject to a hearing before City Council and the public hearing is scheduled for February 12, 2024. City Council meets in Council Chambers also and their meetings begin at 6:30PM.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 14 of 14
Paj 62
Item #5.
FINAL READING
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2023-13
| 1 | AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE CITY |
| 2 | OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT |
| 3 | 55 LOOCKERMAN PLAZA |
4 WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property within the 5 limits of the City of Dover; and
6 WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use of property 7 described below from IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection 8 Overlay Zone) and H (Historic District Zone) to C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) and subject to the 9 SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) and H (Historic District Zone).
| 10 | NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF |
| 11 | DOVER, IN COUNCIL, MET: |
12 1. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and Zoning 13 Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning designation from IO 14 (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) 15 and H (Historic District Zone) to C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) and subject to the SWPOZ 16 (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) and H (Historic District Zone) on that property 17 located at 55 Loockerman Plaza (on the north side of Loockerman Plaza and adjacent to Innovation 18 Way), consisting of 1.27+/- acres, owned by the City of Dover. 19 (Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.05-04-53.00-000; Planning Reference: Z-24-01; Fourth Council District)
20 ADOPTED: *
| 21 | Actions History |
| 22 | 02/12/2024 - Scheduled for Public Hearing/Final Reading – City Council |
| 23 | 01/16/2024 - Public Hearing - Planning Commission |
| 24 | 12/11/2023 - First Reading - City Council |
Paj 63
Item #5.
PETITION TO AMEND ZONING DISTRICT
Public Hearing Before the Dover City Council
February 12,2024
Recommendation from Planning Commission Meeting of January 16, 2024
With Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review
Application: Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza
Owner: City of Dover
Address: 55 Loockerman Plaza, Dover DE
Location: North side of Loockerman Plaza and adjacent to Innovation Way
Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.05-04-53.00-000
Size: 1.27 +/- acres
Present Uses: Vacant Office Building (previous Dover Post Office) and a Parking Lot
2019 Comprehensive Plan Designation –Land Use Category: Mixed Use
Present Zoning: IO (Institutional and Office Zone
SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone)
H (Historic District Zone)
Proposed Zoning: C-2 (Central Commercial Zone)
SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone)
H (Historic District Zone)
Reason for Request: To amend zoning to support revitalization/redevelopment to allow mixed use involving residential apartments, retail/office, and occupant amenities.
File Number: Z-24-01
Ordinance Number: 2023-13
Planning Commission Recommendation: The Application Z-24-01 for Rezoning of Lands of City of Dover, DE (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza was represented by Sharon Duca, P.E. Assistant City Manager on behalf of the City
Paj 64
Item #5. Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
Manager’s Office. A Public Hearing was conducted on January 16,
2024 where no members of the public spoke, and no written
comments were received regarding the Rezoning application. The
Planning Commission’s motion to recommend approval of the
proposed Rezoning from IO/SWPOZ/H to C-2/SWPOZ/H resulted in
an 8-0 vote in favor (one member absent). (Draft Meeting Minutes
attached.)
APPLICATION: Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover, DE (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza
This Rezoning Application was referred to the Planning Commission as per Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §5. The Planning Commission is required to provide a Review Report to City Council. The following document and attachments are provided as the Review Report and Planning Commission Recommendation.
- I.APPLICATION SUMMARY
This Rezoning Application Z-24-01 is for a parcel of land consisting of approximately 1.27 acres (Old Dover Post Office property). The property is zoned IO (Institutional and Office Zone), subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone), and subject to the H (Historic District Zone). The proposed zoning is C-2 (Central Commercial Zone), subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone), and subject to the H (Historic District Zone). The property is located on the north side of Loockerman Plaza and adjacent to Innovation Way. The owner of record is the City of Dover. Property Address: 55 Loockerman Plaza. Tax Parcel: ED-05- 077.05-04-53.00-000. Council District 4. Ordinance #2023-13
The First Reading was completed by the City Council on December 11, 2023 referring the Application to the Planning Commission for Public Hearing, Review, and Recommendation.
Existing Property: This City of Dover owned property consists of 1.27 acres at the northwest corner of Loockerman Plaza and Innovation Way/ Legislative Avenue. It is the location of an existing partial two-story brick building with rear loading dock area and parking lot area. With a Greek Revival style façade, the building was originally constructed to serve as the Dover Post Office in the mid-1960s. It served as the Post Office until the relocation of the retail and carrier operations to a new facility constructed circa 2021. The new Dover Post Office (for the USPS - United States Postal Service) is now located at 445 Bank Lane. In the last year, the City Manager’s Office at the direction of City Council has taken steps to dispose of (sell) this property on Loockerman Plaza for redevelopment by a new owner. This area is part of the local Historic District zone.
This application only seeks rezoning of the property from IO to C-2; the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) and H (Historic District Zone) zoning designations will remain. The applicant is seeking rezoning to allow for future mixed-use development of the property. Any redevelopment of the site will be subject to a separate application submission for plans or permits.
Paj 65
Item #5. Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
Surrounding Land Uses: The surrounding parcels in the immediate area are zoned IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and are within the H (Historic District Zone). The property immediately to the west is City owned property including the Dover Public Library and the Dover City Hall which are served by a municipal parking lot located north of those buildings. Further to the north is a separate parking lot associated with the State-owned property which includes the Richardson & Robbins Building housing the DNREC (Delaware Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control) Offices. Across Innovation Way to the east is Treadway Towers, a multi-tenant office building including a ground floor restaurant space. To the south across Loockerman Plaza are several State-owned office buildings including the Delaware Public Archives, a small brick office building, and the Townsend Hall Building.
II. COMPRENSIVE PLAN COMPLIANCE REVIEW
In the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, the Land Development Plan (Map 12-1) recommends that this property be used for Mixed Use. Regarding Mixed Use Areas and the Land Use Classification of Mixed Use, this is discussed in Chapter 12 – Land Development Plan beginning on page 12-7. The goals and for Mixed Use Areas Land Use are listed in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan excerpts presented below:
Goals: Mixed Land Use The overall goals for Mixed Use areas are: 1. Encourage creation of neighborhood centers. 2. Within the close-knit neighborhood fabric there are opportunities for the creation of urban centers. These centers should be established along major roadways and feature mixed use development, pedestrian-friendly public environments and opportunities for connection to future transit. 3. In order to encourage non-automobile access to the center, the activities should be clustered within a one-half mile radius (or 10-minute walk) and be located so as to draw upon residents from a number of surrounding neighborhoods. 4. Develop strategies that will encourage the creation of well-defined public street spaces and pedestrian-friendly village areas that encourage walking and bicycle use. This may include on-street and behind building parking, and the creation of build-to lines for new development. 5. Improve access that limits public access to open spaces areas such as pedestrian, bicycle, and transit networks to parks and natural areas. 6. Encourage the Mixed Use of residential and commercial uses in the Downtown area. The Comprehensive Plan notes that Mixed Use Areas “can be an area where a new development should foster walkability and close interactions among activities and uses in a traditional neighborhood setting.” The following is an excerpt from the 2019 Comprehensive Plan regarding the Mixed Use Area in Downtown Dover (page 12-8):
Recommendation for Downtown Dover – Historic Core and Center City: Mixed Use Area: Downtown Dover is the City’s primary Mixed Use area. The historic City center clustered around
Paj 66
Item #5. Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
The Green dates back as early as the 1700s. It expands to also include the traditional City pattern of grid streets which developed during the 19th and early 20th centuries. As a result of its earlier development, Downtown Dover, like many other historic cities, includes a variety of intermingled land uses. The Downtown area, which includes the traditional Loockerman Street business district, is broadly bounded by Wesley College on the north, the railroad tracks on the west, Bayhealth-Kent General Hospital on the south, and Street Jones River on the east. It includes a street level mix of residential, commercial, office, cultural, and institutional uses.
Downtown Dover is the traditional and symbolic center of the community and is vitally important to the overall image and identity of the City. As the State’s office complex and other businesses and services make Downtown the largest area of employment in the City, Downtown Dover is vital to the economy. It is important to preserve the area as a safe, convenient, and aesthetically pleasing business environment. Downtown provides a unique and affordable commercial environment where locally owned businesses reflect the small-town nature of the community.
Downtown also provides a residential environment with a wide variety of housing types near commercial, cultural, education, and employment resources. The age of the buildings and infrastructure in the Downtown area requires special attention and incentives to assist in continual use and revitalization activities. Downtown lacks the vibrancy of years gone by and its revitalization will hinge on mixed land uses and developing a commercial niche. Removal of blighted conditions, rehabilitation and redevelopment of traditional residential areas, and reestablishment of neighborhood identity will be important components of the City’s strategies and initiatives.
The goal of the Land Development Plan is to enhance the role of Downtown Dover as a major employment, residential and commercial center as well as the symbolic and cultural heart of the community. Efforts should strive to recognize its unique heritage and historic resources and to provide for mixed use development allowing greatest variation of uses, Activities to reestablish the economic and social vitality of Downtown neighborhoods are encouraged.
The Rezoning Request to C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) is consistent with the Land Use Classification of Mixed Use. Table 12-1: Land Use and Zoning Matrix (from the 2019 Comprehensive Plan) specifies that the following zones are compatible with this land use classification. See the excerpt from Table 12-1 given below. It is noted that Table 12-1 for the Mixed Use Land Use Category identifies a number of zoning districts that allow for a mix of commercial and residential uses with some being more limiting in the specific types of uses permitted. This property location is within the Downtown Redevelopment Target Area as described in the Dover Code of Ordinances. C-2 (Central Commercial) (Downtown Redevelopment Target Area Only) C-2A (Limited Central Commercial) TND (Traditional Neighborhood Design) C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial) C-1A (Limited Commercial) RGO (General Residence and Office) (Downtown Redevelopment Target Area Only) R-8 (One Family Residence) Mixed-Use R-10 (One Family Residence) RG-1 (General Residence) RG-2 (General Residence) RG-4 (General Resident - Multi-Story Apartments) C-3 (Service Commercial) CPO (Commercial and Professional Office) IO (Institutional and Office)
Paj 67
Item #5. Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
III. ZONING REVIEW
Request for C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) Zoning The types of permitted uses and conditional uses in the C-2 zone are given Article 3 §13 of the Zoning Ordinance. See the following code excerpt below for the current provisions of the C-2 zone. It is noted that Planning Staff has been directed to develop a series of proposed revisions to the C-2 zoning district that will be offered as a Text Amendment to the Zoning Ordinance for consideration and adoption in the near future.
Article 3 Section 13. – Central Commercial Zone (C-2).
13.1 Uses permitted. In a central commercial zone (C-2), no building or premises shall be used, and no building or part of a building shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any purpose, except the follow ing:
(a) Retail stores. (b) Restaurants. (c) Hotels, including bed and breakfast inns. (d) Art galleries and studios. (e) Service establishments. (f) Personal service establishments. (g) Business, professional, and government offices. (h) Apartments and multi-family dwellings, provided that no dwelling units shall be permitted in the first floor on the street frontage of Loockerman Street.
13.2 Conditional uses. The following uses are permitted, conditional upon the approval of the planning commission in accordance with the procedures and subject to the general conditions set forth in article 10, section 1:
(a) Parking lots and parking structures as a principal use. (b) Places of public assembly. (c) Manufacturing, assembling, converting, altering, finishing, cleaning, or any other processing of products where goods so produced or processed are to be sold at retail exclusively on the premises, provided that: (1) An area fully concealed from any street and equal to not more than 20 percent of the area devoted to retail sales shall be so used; (2) Electrical power not to exceed a total of five rated horsepower, and steam pressure not in excess of 60 pounds of pressure per square inch shall be used exclusively; (3) Not more than four employees are engaged in such production or processing.
13.3 Uses prohibited. The following uses are prohibited:
- I.Fuel pumps and motor vehicle storage, sales, or repairs.
13.4 Enclosed buildings. All permitted uses and all storage accessory thereto, other than offstreet parking, shall be carried on in buildings fully enclosed on all sides, except for outdoor eating areas associated with restaurants and outdoor sales areas approved by the city planner.
13.5 Performance standards. All uses are subject to performance standards as set forth in article 5, section 8.1.
13.6 Site development plan approval. Site development plan approval in accordance with article 10, section 2 hereof shall be required prior to the issuance of building permits for the erection or enlargement of all structures and prior to the issuance of certi ficates of occupancy for any change of use.
Paj 68
Item #5. Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
(Ord. of 1-14-1980; Ord. of 6-24-1985; Ord. of 4-25-1994; Ord. of 12-8-1997; Ord. of 7-10- 2000; Ord. of 2-12-2001; Ord. No. 2008-33, 8-25-2008; Ord. No. 2014-08, 7-14-2014)
SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) The property is located within the SWPOZ (Tier 3: Excellent Recharge Area) found in Article 3 Section 29.7 of the Zoning Ordinance. The SWPOZ does include a prohibition of certain uses where the activity may be harmful to water resources; see Zoning Ordinance, Article 3 §29.51. However, this project site is within the Downtown Redevelopment Target Area which is exempted from the SWPOZ requirements and restrictions as per Zoning Ordinance, Article 3 §29.79.
H (Historic District Zone) The H (Historic District Zone) is described in Zoning Ordinance, Article 3 Section 21 with the following purpose statement:
Article 3, Section 21. - Historic district (H). 21.1 Purpose. The purpose of this historic district regulation is to preserve and enhance that unique character and value of the old portion of Dover as an area of special charm and interest. It is particularly intended that the regulations prevent, in the historic district, any chang e of conditions that would be deemed to be a disfigurement or degradation of the present unique visual and architectural qualities of the district.
The property’s location within the H (Historic District Zone) requires proposals for demolition, new construction, additions, and certain renovation or rehabilitation activities to receive an Architectural Review Certificate. The Architectural Review Certificate review process occurs during the plan review process and permit review process. As stated in the Design Standards and Guidelines for the City of Dover Historic District Zone, an Architectural Review Certificate will be granted “if it is found that the architectural style, general design, height, bulk and setbacks, arrangement location and materials affecting the exterior appearance are generally in harmony with neighboring structures and complementary to the traditional architectural standards of the historic district.” Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §3.2 outlines the review process for Architectural Review Certification and related building height, bulk, and setback standards.
IV. RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING STAFF:
This Request is to rezone lands from IO (Institutional and Office Zone) to C-2 (Central Commercial Zone). The property would remain subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) and H (Historic District Zone).
The current IO zone is a zoning district offering a mix of uses focused on the public, institutional and office related realms. In the IO zone, the permitted uses include business, professional and governmental offices and also banks and laboratories. Also permitted are a variety of public and institutional uses serving the public in the medical, governmental, and educational fields and places of public assembly related to civic, social, and religious functions. The other group of uses in IO focuses specifically on the care of people ranging from child day care and adult day care facilities to facilities/shelters for temporary housing and social services of other populations. The SWPOZ has provisions to protect underground water resources. The H (Historic District Zone) looks to preserve and enhance the historic core of Dover and includes regulatory provisions to retain the area’s character and architectural qualities.
Paj 69
Item #5. Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
The proposed Rezoning to C-2 zone is a zoning district offering a mix of uses. For the C-2 zone, the range of permitted uses that are commercial uses include retail, personal service establishments, service establishments, restaurants, and offices. The C-2 zone also includes permitted uses that are residential in nature including apartments and multi-family dwellings (more than 2 dwelling units in same building). The C-2 zone also includes conditional uses (uses subject to specific review for approval) for parking lots and parking structures as a principal use, places of public assembly and manufacturing with limitations. The C-2 zone specifically prohibits fuel pumps and motor vehicle storage, sales, or repairs.
Staff recommends that the rezoning for C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) be granted as requested, as the proposed zoning is consistent with the 2019 Comprehensive Plan (as amended) for the Mixed Use Land Use Classification Category. Staff also recommends that the property remain subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) and H (Historic District Zone).
It is noted that the Comprehensive Plan’s goals for the Mixed Use Land Use Classification in Dover’s historic core focuses on recognition of its historic development patterns and while noting the opportunities for redevelopment and revitalization with a variety of residential, commercial, office, cultural and institutional uses typically found in Downtown areas. The core of Downtown Dover is where a mix of commercial, institutional, and residential type activities could be expected to serve the community. The neighboring blocks moving west along Loockerman Street include a mix of commercial businesses (offices, restaurants, banks). The areas to the south in the Capital Complex area are institutional with offices, courthouses, museums, and government related facilities. There are also a variety of residential options within the adjacent blocks ranging from single family houses to duplexes and apartments. It is noted that the Loockerman Street/ Loockerman Plaza corridor is one of the main east-west roadways though the core of Downtown Dover. It is only a few blocks from the more intense commercial corridor of DuPont Highway (Route 13). The Downtown area includes a range of transportation modes and opportunities (vehicle, transit, pedestrian, and bicycle) in the grid-like street system and sidewalk network. There is existing infrastructure for water, sanitary sewer, and electric services and the police, fire, and emergency medical services service the area.
Planning Staff notes that this area of Downtown Dover was part of a recent strategic master plan known as Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030. The plan focused on a range of physical and programmatic solutions to provide a fresh integrated approach to transform Down Dover and the surrounding area into a vibrant, thriving community and regional destination.
This Rezoning Request does not grant approval of a specific use for the property but makes its land use subject to a listing of uses permitted and potential conditional uses as allowed in the C-2 zoning district (and as limited by the SWPOZ zone). The Design Standards and Guidelines of the Historic District Zone offer a design review process to balance the compatibility of new construction with surviving historic structures. Staff again notes that any potential development for the site would have to be in line with the zoning classifications and would similarly have to follow all development design guidelines of the Zoning Ordinance and other City and State regulations. Were the application for Rezoning to be recommended by the Planning Commission and subsequently approved by the City Council, the applicant would still have to submit plans and/or permits for review for most uses of the site to be established.
Paj 70
Item #5. Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
Any development of the property once zoned C-2 with the SWPOZ and H zones would be subject to the bulk standards and provisions and the review processes for site development. Any non-conformity of the existing buildings’ uses and placement regarding the bulk standards of the C-2 would be subject to the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance, Article 7 – Nonconforming Buildings and Uses or may be addressed through the H (Historic District Zone) zone’s Architectural Review Certification process.
This recommendation is being made without that benefit of hearing the comments of surrounding landowners and residents. A public hearing is required on this matter and the Planning Commission should give those comments consideration.
- V.PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEW FOR RECOMMENDATION This Rezoning Application is a request for a zoning map amendment which changes the zoning district of a property. The Planning Commission as part of their public hearing and review process will provide a recommendation on the rezoning request to City Council. As part of the process outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the Planning Commission must evaluate the following factors when considering the request:
Article 10 § 5.36 Report of the planning commission. Regarding each application for a zoning map amendment, the planning commission shall provide a report to the city council stating a recommended action with regards to the proposed amendment, along with the commission's evaluation of the following factors:
(A) Whether the uses permitted by the proposed change would be compatible with the existing uses and zones in the area concerned;
(B) Whether adequate public services and infrastructure exist or can be created or expanded to serve the needs of any additional demand as a result of such change; and
(C) Whether the proposed change is in accordance with the city's current comprehensive plan.
A Recommendation Report from the Planning Commission will be forwarded to the City Council for their consideration of the Rezoning Application. This document and its attachments make up the Recommendation Report.
RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION:
At the Hybrid (In-Person and Virtual) Planning Commission Meeting of January 16, 2024, the Application Z-24-01 was represented by Sharon Duca, P.E. Assistant City Manager on behalf of the City Manager’s Office. During the Public Hearing, no members of the public spoke, and no written comments were received.
The Planning Commission’s motion was to recommend approval for Rezoning application Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office) at 55 Loockerman Plaza from IO/SWPOZ/H to C-2/SWPOZ/H and resulted in a vote of 8-0 in favor of rezoning (one member absent). The reasons cited for the recommendation of approval include consistency with the City’s 2019 Comprehensive Plan for the core of Downtown; notation that future development is subject to site plan review; allows potential use of vacant building; with
Paj 71
Item #5. Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza Planning Commission Recommendation Report of January 16, 2024
reference to the Development Advisory Committee Report; and recognition of the recommendation of approval from the Planning Staff.
See also the included excerpt of the DRAFT Meeting Minutes of the January 16, 2024 Planning Commission meeting. The comments received from the other member agencies of the Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) are also provided.
VI. ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
- 1)The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Rezoning Application does not represent Site Development Plan or Record Plan approval. Following any decision made by City Council in regard to this Rezoning, then an application for a Site Plan, Subdivision Plan, and/or appropriate Building Permits must be submitted to the Planning Department prior to the establishment of a use, development activity, or any construction activity on the site. The applicant should contact the Planning Staff to determine the appropriate review process for any proposed projects.
- 2)The property is subject to the requirements of the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) and H (Historic District Zone) related to development.
- 3)The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Rezoning Application does not represent a Building Permit, Sign Permit, or other construction activity permit approval. A separate application submission is required before issuance of permits by the City of Dover.
- 4)The applicant shall be aware that any future use of the existing structures may be subject to a separate permitting or licensing process through the City of Dover Licensing and Permitting Division. All businesses operating in the City of Dover are required to obtain a City of Dover Business Licenses. Certain types of uses also require a Public Occupancy Permit or Rental Dwelling Permits.
ATTACHMENTS:
- •Zoning Map Exhibit
- •Application Z-24-01 Submission: o Site Property Sheet
- •Development Advisory Committee Comments from City of Dover Departments of Public Works and Water & Wastewater, Electric Department, City Office of the Fire Marshal, DelDOT, and Dover/Kent County MPO
- •Excerpt from DRAFT Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024
- •Proposed Ordinance #2023-13
Paj 72
City of Dover Application No.: Z-24-01
Item #5.
Department of Planning & Inspections RG-1 IO RG-1 e RG- Av RG- IO SC-1 IO ware RG- 1 Ken Dela 1 sylva le 1 Map t Av e Penn n St RG-1 Fulto N Am RG-1 Ln Park Dr RG-1 v RG- RGO erica n nia A 1 RGO t ate S Hwy R-10 N St e N Br Ave gs R-10 IO R-10 n St A K in isio Penn rd B ay a adfo E Div R-8 rd St Ave t ve nS R-10 ivisio S Am R-10 WD RGO RGO n Rd erica ill ROS nh r ee Ave G RG-2 RGO IO RG- RG-1 1 S Br C-2A R-10 adfo IO ed St rd S E Re St W Reed C-2A t v RGO Inno t C-2A an S R-10 ock erm E Lo ation S St t Way ROS C-2 at e S C-2 RG-1 A ly reet ate S za Court St S St la IO C-2 an P St o c kerm Minor t Lo C- C-2 IO 2 St Blvd rman g Jr oocke RGO IO r Kin WL in L uthe t t Mar SG rth S IO C-2 E No isla IO Leg ve ors A IO C-2 St overn h A W Nort ROS tive era C-2 Fed ve
l St IO RGO Eas G r een ROS ROS t Ave IO C-2A The IO k Ln IO Ban RGO RGO Rd IO t ter S E Wa Riv ROS er
Tile: Lands of City of Dover Legend Ordinance #: 2023-13 Address: 55 Loockerman Plaza Dover Boundary Parcel IDs: ED-05-077.05-04-53.00-000 Subject Property Existing Zoning: IO (Institutional and Office Zone) SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) Zoning H (Historic District Zone) Dover Parcels Proposed Zoning: C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) Historic District H (Historic District Zone)
«
SWPOZ Tier 3
Owner: City of Dover
Date: 12/05/2023 Page 72
Paj 73
Item #5.
Paj 74
Item #5.
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: DECEMBER 27, 2023
APPLICATION: Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza FILE #: Z-24-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Water & Wastewater CONTACT PERSON: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater CONTACT PHONE #: 302-736-7025 CONTACT EMAIL #: jlyon@dover.de.us
T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .
T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
- 1.Our office has no objections to the proposed rezoning of tax parcel ED-05-075.00-01-07.00-000. Any redevelopment shall adhere to the City of Dover Water/Wastewater Handbook and the Specifications, Standards & Procedures for Public Works Construction. Impact fees may be applied to this property. Future development shall comply with all aspects of the City of Dover’s Cross Connection Control Program.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. None
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. None I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .
Paj 75
Item #5.
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: DEC 27, 2023
APPLICATION: Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza FILE #: Z-24-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Electric Department CONTACT PERSON: Shawn Burgett, Engineering Services & System Ops Superintendent CONTACT PHONE #: 302-674-7568 CONTACT EMAIL #: sburgett@dover.de.us
T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .
T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
ELECTRIC
Our office has no objection to the rezoning of: ED-05-077.05-04-53.00-000, Council District 4.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES ELECTRIC 1. Should this site be redeveloped, which includes modifications to the use, the applicant / developer will be responsible for all costs associated with providing the appropriate meter / service to this site based upon the use including any necessary system upgrades or extensions. The appropriateness and adequacy of electric and meters will be assessed at that time. 2. Any redevelopment shall adhere to the City of Dover’s Electric Service Handbook. https://evogov.s3.amazonaws.com/media/27/media/13108.pdf.
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
ELECTRIC
- 1.None.
I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .
Paj 76
C F #5.
Z-24-01
Item
I I
T R
CITY OF DOVER Y E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE O M
F A APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY R D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 12/27/23 D S O H V A E L R APPLICATION: Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office) at 55 Loockerman Plaza
FILE #: Z-24-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover, Office of the Fire Marshal
CONTACT PERSON: Jason Osika, Fire Marshal PHONE #: (302) 736-4457 josika@dover.de.us
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY, AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESS BY THE APPLICANT:
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
- 1.Proposal is a rezoning application. This office has no objections.
- 2.Every house, building or structure used or intended for use as living quarters or as a place for conducting business, and having any wall facing or abutting any public or private street or alley, shall have displayed on that wall, in legible, easily read characters which are of contrasting color to the background, the proper street number for such house, building, or structure in accordance with the following:
One-family and two-family residential structures, height, the number shall measure a minimum of four inches in height, location, the number shall be placed on the house above or to the left or right of the front entrance, color, the number shall be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals, all numbers shall be Arabic numerals.
Multiple-family dwellings, measurements, the number shall measure a minimum of six inches when identifying individual apartments with exterior doors, and 12 inches when identifying buildings with apartment complexes where there are two or more buildings not assigned street addresses. Individual buildings with street addresses shall have numbers measuring six inches, location, numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the street end of the building so as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the parking lot, color, numbers shall be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic numerals.
Paj 77
Item #5.
Commercial, industrial and office buildings, height, the numbers shall measure a minimum of 12 inches in height, location generally, numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the street end of the building so as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the parking lot,
property line or driveway, should the building be located far enough from a public or private road so that the numbers are not clearly visible from the street, then the street address shall also be posted on the property at or near the property line or driveway to said building,
color; each building, numbers shall be contrasting to the background color and shall be placed on each building in the complex,
Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic numerals,
Shopping centers. Shopping centers consisting of two or more stores shall have a tenant or suite number affixed to the front of the tenant space and on the outside of the rear door which corresponds with that tenant space. Numbers shall measure six inches in height. (City of Dover Code of Ordinances, 98-344)
ADDITIONAL / SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS TO OBTAIN APPROVAL:
- 1.N/A
APPLICABLE CODES LISTED BELOW (NOT LIMITED TO):
2021 NFPA 1 Fire Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2021 NFPA 101 Life Safety Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 72 National Fire Alarm and Signaling Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 13 Installation of Sprinkler Systems (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2009 IBC (International Building Code) Latest editions of all other NFPA Codes as defined by the Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations 2021 Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations City of Dover Code of Ordinances
*If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person listed.
Paj 78
Item #5.
CITY OF DOVER D
E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
L
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY D
O
T
===============================================================
APPLICATION: Lands of City of Dover
FILE#: Z-24-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: DelDOT
CONTACT PERSON: Michael Vandevander PHONE#: 302-760-2141
=============================================================== THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY'S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:
CITY & STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
No person, firm, corporation or the like shall construct, open, reconstruct, maintain, modify or use any crossing or entrance onto a state-maintained highway, street or road, including any drainage modifications leading into or carried by the highway drainage system, without first having complied with standards and regulations adopted by the Department and having obtained a permit issued by the Department. Please contact the Delaware Department of Transportation - Development Coordination section to begin permit process.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES:
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
- 1.The developer will need a pre-submittal meeting to discuss the development with DelDOT.
- 2.No objection to Rezoning
Paj 79
Item #5.
CITY OF DOVER Dover/Kent
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
County
Metropolitan
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY Planning
D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 1/3/2024 Organization
APPLICATION: Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza
FILE # Z-24-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: Dover/Kent County MPO
CONTACT PERSON: Malcolm Jacob PHONE #: (302) 387-6030
Issues of concern to the MPO are effective transit, reducing the amount of vehicle emissions by shortening or eliminating trips, and facilities for alternative modes of transportation, including bicycle and pedestrian access. The MPO considers the bicycle facilities required by the City of Dover to be the standard for all applications, not to be waived.
City of Dover Planning Commission
Zoning Review
Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office Site) at 55 Loockerman Plaza
- 1)The MPO does not have any objections to the proposed rezoning. Further comments will be submitted if site development takes place at a later date.
If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person and the Planning Department as soon as possible.
Paj 80
Item #5.
CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION
January 16, 2024 Excerpt from Meeting Minutes – Draft
The Meeting of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Tuesday, January 16, 2024 at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system WebEx. The Meeting Session was conducted with Chair Mrs. Maucher presiding. Members present were Mr. Cooper, Mrs. Denney, Mr. Witham, Mr. Baldwin, Dr. Jones, Mr. Reaves, Mrs. Welsh (virtual), and Mrs. Maucher. Mr. Roach was absent.
Staff members present were Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Ms. Katherine Oehmke, Mr. Jason Lyon (virtual) and Mrs. Kristen Mullaney (virtual).
NEW APPLICATIONS
Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office) at 55 Loockerman Plaza - Public Hearing and Review for Recommendation to City Council of a Rezoning application for a parcel of land consisting of approximately 1.27 acres (Old Dover Post Office property). The property is zoned IO (Institutional and Office Zone), subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone), and subject to the H (Historic District Zone). The proposed zoning is C-2 (Central Commercial Zone), subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone), and subject to the H (Historic District Zone). The property is located on the north side of Loockerman Plaza and adjacent to Innovation Way. The owner of record is the City of Dover. Property Address: 55 Loockerman Plaza. Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.05-04-53.00-000. Council District 4. Ordinance #2023-13
Representative: Mrs. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager for City of Dover
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that this is a Rezoning Application for the Lands of the City of Dover; the Old Post Office site at 55 Loockerman Plaza. That subject parcel is shown on the screen in yellow. It is currently zoned IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone), and subject to the H (Historic District Zone). The proposed Rezoning would take it to C-2 (Central Commercial Zone), with it remaining subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone), and subject to the H (Historic District Zone). This is land owned by the City of Dover. The building that stands on it was the Post Office that was constructed in the 1960’s. The Post Office has since relocated in the last few years into the facilities over on Bank Lane leaving the City with a tract of land with a building. City Council has taken steps to dispose of/or sell in this case the property; however, the City is currently bringing forward this request to Rezone. Looking at the Comprehensive Plan, again, we find a property that is identified as Mixed Use in the Land Development Plan for the City on Map 12-1. The Comprehensive Plan does talk specifically about the historic core and center city as a Mixed Use area where there is a mix of a commercial environment as well as a residential environment. The next piece of the Comprehensive Plan that we always look to is that Land Use Matrix where we find the C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) as one of the zoning districts for the Mixed Use land use category. Looking at zoning, the C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) is here in Downtown currently and would allow for a mix of retail, restaurants, hotels, art galleries, service establishments, personal service offices, as well as on the residential side, apartments, and multi- family dwellings. Additionally, there are some Conditional Uses that are allowed in the C-2 Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 1 of 3
Paj 81
Item #5.
(Central Commercial Zone). She will note that specific uses that are prohibited in C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) zoning district currently are fuel pumps and motor vehicle storage sales or repairs. Noted in our Report is also the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone). There is some prohibition on uses to help protect our water resources. Then its presence in the Historic District Zone will require that any proposals for demolition and new construction redevelopment receive an Architectural Review Certificate as part of that review process. Again, this is a Rezoning, and the Planning Commission is charged with evaluating the Rezoning on a series of three factors. Those factors being the uses permitted by the proposed change and whether they would be compatible with existing uses and zones in the area; the adequateness of public services and infrastructure either existing or to be created and expanded; and then if the proposed change is in accordance with the City’s Comprehensive Plan. Planning Staff is recommending approval of the Rezoning to C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) finding that it is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. It is a district that they find in the Mixed Use land use classification and offers opportunities for development and revitalization both on the residential and commercial and office side which are all elements of a strengthened Downtown core area. There are limitations of the current zoning with the IO (Institutional and Office Zone). While it focuses on office related realms and some of the civic kind of functions, it is very limiting when it comes to commercial activity such as retail and housing or residential opportunities. With this, again, Planning Commission is making a recommendation to City Council for this Rezoning request to take the property from IO (Institutional and Office Zone) to C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) with it remaining subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) and the H (Historic District Zone).
Mrs. Duca stated that basically the City Manager’s Office has been charged by the City Council to sell the old Post Office site. They are looking to, as noted in the Report from the Planning Office, support the revitalization and redevelopment of this area, looking particularly at the mixed-use options.
Mrs. Maucher opened a public hearing and after seeing no one wishing to speak, closed the public hearing.
Dr. Jones asked if this site was part of the Historic District. Were there any comments from the Historic District Commission? Aren’t they a part of DAC? Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the Historic District Commission is an appointed body of the city. Their activities are laid out in the Zoning Ordinance. Rezoning requests do not come before them unless it involves Rezoning to or from the Historic District Zone. They will be involved in any future redevelopment of the project site, and you will hear from them at that point. No, they are not a standing member of the Development Advisory Committee.
Mr. Reaves asked if this property is currently up for sale or when will the City list this property for sale? Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the property was previously posted for sale. The City actually took requests for proposals for the project site and has selected an entity to purchase. She believes that they are in the process of contract work to complete that sale. At the present time, she believes that the City still owns it at the moment, but it may not be for long.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 2 of 3
Paj 82
Item #5.
Mr. Reaves moved to recommend approval to City Council for Z-24-01 Lands of City of Dover (Old Post Office) at 55 Loockerman Plaza (for Rezoning to C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) with SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone) and H (Historic District Zone) zones), seconded by Mr. Witham and the motion was carried 8-0 by roll call vote with Mr. Roach absent. Mr. Reaves voting yes; based upon the zoning of the old Post Office and the understanding that during the Site Plan review, we will be able to comment on anything that may be contrary to that zoning. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons stated in the DAC comments. Mr. Cooper voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mrs. Denney voting yes; in keeping with the thought that when we come to Site Plan review, they will have an opportunity to delve further into it. It is a good thing that the Post Office building is being sold and that something new will begin there. Mr. Witham voting yes; it seems to him that this fits within and is consistent with the 2019 Comprehensive Plan as it is a part of the core Downtown area and frankly, he thinks that a very few people in the City of Dover would like to see a building of that size be vacant for that long period of time. We have too many vacant properties already in Dover and we don’t need anymore, particularly in the Downtown area. Also, for the other reasons set forth on the record by his fellow Commissioners. Mr. Baldwin voting yes; based on the reasons stated and Staff recommendation. Dr. Jones voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; for the reasons previously stated.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of January 16, 2024 Page 3 of 3
Paj 83
Item #6.
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular City Council Meeting was held on January 22, 2024, at 6:32 p.m. with Council President Hare presiding. Council members present were Mr. Anderson, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Arndt, Mr. Rocha, Councilman Sudler, and Mr. Lewis. Mr. Boggerty was absent.
Staff members present were Police Chief Johnson, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Melson-Williams, Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Fire Chief Carey was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 6:20 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Council President Hare declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.
There was no one present wishing to speak during the Open Forum.
INVOCATION
The invocation was given by Mayor Christiansen.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Dr. Pillsbury.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Sudler moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Neil, and unanimously carried. (Boggerty absent)
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the consent agenda, seconded by Mr. Lewis, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
PRESENTATION – DELAWARE STATE UNIVERSITY CHORAL STUDENTS'
MUSICAL PRESENTATION UNDER THE DIRECTION OF DR. GREGORY
MCPHERSON
Dr. Gregory McPherson shared pieces from the Delaware State University Choral group and the blessings to the members.
PROCLAMATION – BLACK HISTORY MONTH
The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:
Paj 84
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 2
WHEREAS, during Black History Month we celebrate the many contributions and achievements made by African Americans to our nation. The Association for the Study of African American Life and History has chosen “African Americans and the Arts” as the 2024 Black History theme which commemorates the fundamental influence in which African American artists have used art, infused with African, Caribbean, and Black American lived experiences, to preserve history. For centuries, African Americans have significantly influenced art in the fields of performing arts, literature, fashion, film, music, architecture, and other essential forms of cultural expression; and
WHEREAS, according to the Study of African American Life and History, African Americans set the standard for popular trends around the world through artistic and cultural movements such as New Negro, Black Arts, Black Renaissance, hip-hop, and Afrofuturism. Each movement has played an essential role in shaping our nation in the past and present.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE do hereby proclaim February 2024 as BLACK HISTORY MONTH in the City of Dover and encourage all citizens to recognize the inspiration of African American arts and artisans in our culture.
PROCLAMATION – HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS MONTH
The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:
WHEREAS, according to the National Human Trafficking Hotline, “Human trafficking is a crime involving the exploitation of someone for the purpose of compelled labor or a commercial sex act through the use of force, fraud, or coercion. It affects individuals across the world, including the United States, and affects every community in the United States across age, gender, ethnicity, and socio-economic backgrounds”; and
WHEREAS, human trafficking generates over $150 billion in profits worldwide every year. The 2021 International Labour Organization report estimates 49.6 million adults and children were victims of modern slavery globally. An estimated 27.6 million were in forced labor including 17.3 million exploited in the private sector, 6.3 million in forced commercial sexual exploitation and 3.9 million in forced labor imposed by state. Traffickers often take advantage of instability caused by natural disasters, conflict, or a pandemic to exploit others; and
WHEREAS, since 2007, the Human Trafficking Hotline for Delaware has received close to 680 signals, such as phone calls, texts, emails and online tips, and identified over 500 victims included in 212 cases of human trafficking; and
WHEREAS, in 2009, Trafficking Victims Protection Act passed by Congress establishing methods for prosecuting traffickers, preventing human trafficking and protecting victims and survivors of trafficking. Recognizing potential red flags and knowing the indicators of human trafficking is a key step in identifying more victims and helping them find assistance. Delaware leaders, social organizations and Delaware Healthcare Association all are devoting efforts to raise awareness and help stop the epidemic.
Paj 85
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 3
NOW, THEREFORE, I, ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE do hereby proclaim January 2024 as HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS MONTH in the City of Dover and urge all residents to take action by being informed, spread awareness and know the signs for it could save someone’s life.
PRESENTATION – HONORABLE DAVID WEISS, UNITED STATES ATORNEY FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE, THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE Mayor Christiansen introduced the Honorable David Weiss, United States Attorney for the District of Delaware, the United States Department of Justice. The Honorable David Weiss briefed members about the United Against Hate program on Thursday, January 25, 2024, at the Dover Public Library.
ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 8, 2024 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of January 8, 2024, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Sudler, seconded by Mr. Neil, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen. (Boggerty absent)
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT – JANUARY 9, 2024 The Council Committee of the Whole met on January 09, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Hare presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Mr. Sudler. Mr. Anderson was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Iriowen, and Mr. Pugh (Utility), Mr. Shevock (via WebEx), and Ms. Smith (in at 6:32 p.m. via WebEx) (Legislative, Finance, and Administration).
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Neil and
unanimously carried.
Evaluation of Proposals – Downtown Dover Upgrades Engineering Design (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water and Wastewater Director reviewed the background and analysis of the Downtown Dover Upgrades Engineering Design.
Paj 86
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 4
Staff recommended awarding the contract to KCI Technologies for the engineering design of the Downtown Dover Upgrades Engineering Design, RFP# 24-0010WW, for $233,027.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Lewis, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting,
hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:05 p.m.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Council President Hare presiding in the absence of a chair.
Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and
unanimously carried.
Change Order – Mirror Lake Drainage Basin Improvements (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water and Wastewater Director reviewed the background and analysis of the Mirror Lake Drainage Basin Improvements.
Staff recommended approving the change order request from Gateway Construction, Inc. in the amount of $154,559 in accordance with the City of Dover Purchasing Policy & Procedures. The design engineer of the project will split the cost of the change order with the city.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Lyon stated that when a design firm starts a project, they request the plans and prints from utilities to find the pipe locations. Mr. Lyon explained that the scope of the information provided to them was short of what they requested, thereby not showing the location of the pipe. Mr. Lyon also stated that the reason that the design firm is paying for half is because they should have done more research but again, the city could have provided that information.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Lyon stated that the GIS information is not provided to the public, and the prints are provided through Miss Utility. Mr. Lyon explained that the design engineer would place the request with Miss Utility, which then gets filtered through the call center to the city and then the information is provided to the requestor.
Paj 87
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 5
Mr. Neil moved to recommend approval of the staff recommendation for the project. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Lewis, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
Update on potential revisions to the Zoning Ordinance for C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) per the Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2023 Plan (Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed the background and analysis of the potential revisions to the Zoning Ordinance for the C-2 (Central Commercial Zone).
Proposed Ordinance #2024-01 – Amending Appendix B - Zoning, Article 3 - District Regulations, Section 13 - Central Commercial Zone (C-2), Article 4 - Zoning and Bulk Parking Regulations, Section 4.14 - [C-1, C-1A, C-2, C-2A zones], Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations, Section 6 - Dumpsters for trash and recycling, Article 6 - Off-Street Parking, Driveways and Loading Facilities, Section 3 - Required Off-Street Parking Spaces, Article 12 - Definitions.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the proposed ordinance would be adding uses to the C-2 zone such as manufacturing. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that manufacturing, assembling, converting, altering, finishing, cleaning, cooking, baking, and other processing of products is the standard language for describing manufacturing throughout the code. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there is a size limit on the establishment as a smaller- scale operation would be appropriate for the downtown setting. Ms. Melson- Williams explained that some examples would be a bakery, crafter, woodworker, or glass blower, something that is not a full production line like Kraft Heinz. Ms. Melson-Williams also explained that manufacturing is a broad term with conditional use and specialized conditions and moves small-scale operations into permitted use.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the potential state legislation and forthcoming regulations on cannabis will provide specific definitions tied to the cultivation, processing, and sale of those items. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the concern with cannabis sales will need to be addressed specifically in the code but that is not what is intended with the ordinance amendment.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the public was involved in a series of opportunities in October. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that two stakeholder meetings were held with a targeted audience of local realtors, developers, and those with downtown Dover business interests. Ms. Melson- Williams stated that a public walk-in workshop was also held for a couple of hours where folks walked in and learned about the C-2 zoning and gave initial
Paj 88
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 6
feedback on what staff had developed as potential revision ideas. Ms. Melson- Williams explained that the draft ordinance had not had a formal public hearing because that would be part of the review process moving forward.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the draft changes are not specific to any individual property, and they would apply to anything zoned C-2. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the regulations for the proposed changes do not require public notice, but should the ordinance move forward through the review process, there are notice requirements and publication requirements for the upcoming hearings.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the way the current code reads there are a specific number of dumpsters required based on floor area or unit count. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that many times during development planning the developers are doing the calculations for their project and realize they do not need so many dumpsters. The developers will then build two dumpsters, and reserve space for future needs. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that provision is still in the code, and they can build as many as they think they will need but the reservation requirement is still there and it gives the planner the authority to say that they received trash complaints, go ahead, and build another dumpster on the site. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that what is proposed is to make it clearer for the residential side of apartments and multi-family type units where there is a centralized trash and recycling dumpster area, and for the non- residential units where there is a requirement for two per property for recycling, and solid waste collection. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the dumpster containers are not necessarily the containers the city collects, they are usually the commercial containers collected by a commercial hauler. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there is flexibility within the recommended amendments for centralized collection methods.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there are no negative effects because the proposed text amendments offer a greater variety of potential uses. So, for business owners who have been looking for tenants, the amendments give them more options for tenants. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that if the business owners are looking towards redeveloping their site, the amendments give them greater flexibility for more creative designs in a potential project. For those happy with the business or the tenants that they have now, the amendments will allow them to have vacant buildings or tenant spaces around them redeveloped into something that brings in more foot traffic, which is needed for all downtown businesses.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the proposed ordinance does not address the road infrastructure system however, some of the approved items are related to the downtown planning for infrastructure and will start to address what is under the road. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the truck route ordinance that was adopted last year focuses on trucks moving
Paj 89
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 7
throughout the city, but it does not prohibit local deliveries. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the businesses downtown will likely make their delivery drivers aware of the road system so it is likely that there will be smaller box trucks finding their way downtown or traveling during off-peak travel hours.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the stakeholder meetings included invitations to the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce, key developers that have either worked downtown or have potential projects for downtown, as well as groups like the Downtown Dover Partnership. Ms. Melson- Williams explained that the information had been posted on the city website, so the information was open to the public.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there was at least one group that would classify as a minority, and they are interested in a potential project. Ms. Melson-Williams also stated that there are some in the group that the partnership collectively speaks for as well.
Mr. Todd Stonesifer, 15 North State Street, Dover, President of the Downtown Dover Partnership Board of Directors, thanked the city council, committee members, and all the different city departments that have put so much work into the Transforming Downtown Dover 2030 plan. Mr. Stonesifer explained that the goal is to bring pedestrian traffic back downtown and give the people who live there a walkable community. Mr. Stonesifer stated that in order to do that they recommend the additional height restrictions and the ability to be creative with parking so that there can be a centralized parking solution. Mr. Stonesifer stated that the first main project will be at 20 South Governors Avenue and there are potential designs on the Downtown Dover Partnership’s website, which depicts commercial development on the ground floor and five additional floors of residential units.
Mr. John Childress, Vice President of Projects, Mosaic Development Partners, thanked the council, Downtown Dover Partnership, and city departments for all their help. Mr. Childress explained that the changes to the structured parking are to make it easier for the developers and folks coming into downtown Dover. Mr. Childress explained that the next key point would be the step-backs. Mr. Childress stated that the goal is to have a nice community that does not create tunnel vision of straight walls going up and there must be consideration of the development because the goal is to bring more developers downtown. Mr. Childress stated that typically wood construction would be used in buildings up to six floors. Mr. Childress explained that they have come up with a proposal to do a step-back of two or three feet for six floors and anything six and above move it back to five feet. Mr. Childress explained that this recommendation means that once the building is over six floors it would become concrete or steel construction, which allows for easier step-backs. Mr. Childress continued to explain that the beauty of downtown Dover is that there are incredible anchors in the master plan including the Dover Air Force Base, Bayhealth, Delaware State University, and the state
Paj 90
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 8
government all within a central location. Mr. Childress stated that if the step- backs go too far back then the plan would lose about one-fourth of the apartments which could hurt financial growth. Mr. Childress explained that the goal is to be able to build quality housing that honors the city and the architecture but still encourages developers to go downtown and build (Attachment #1).
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the step-backs are not currently part of the code, other than the idea of stepping back on upper floors which is one of the design standards for the City of Dover Historic District Zone. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that it was mentioned that on the upper floors, they would do a step-back of 10 feet and then an additional 10 feet with each floor over six stories when looking at taking the C-2 zone from a maximum of six stories to a maximum of 10 stories. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that if someone is looking to build a six-story building, four floors could be on the sidewalk, but then floors five and six would have to be stepped back 10 feet. If the building was taller than six stories, the upper floors would have to go back another 10 feet. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that after doing research they tried to come up with something simple in concept that would be respectful of the design standards for the historic district.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the design standards do not give a dimension, they only talk about the concept of stepping back the upper floors. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the text amendment says that it does not have to start on the fourth floor, it could start lower, and it does not have to be the entire width. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the idea is that visually it will look like the building is shorter than what it is from a pedestrian standpoint at the street level.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Childress stated that it is not impossible to do with the proposed step-backs but that ideally there would be a shorter step-back on the lower floors because there is only so much width on the block, so as the design is pushed back the front row gets reduced. This would cause a loss of 20 to 25% of apartments on the side with the step-back and cause challenges in the construction of the walls, which would then need to have additional structural support.
Mr. Sudler suggested that documentation from an engineer expressing whether the proposed step-back changes would be structurally sound and safe.
Ms. Arndt asked if the Mosaic team could provide their comments in writing and provide the resources and justification for what they have proposed. Ms. Arndt also asked that Ms. Melson-Williams review that information and if it meets the city design standards, consider making the changes to the step-backs.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mayor Christiansen stated that any fire that is above four stories is fought with a standpipe system. Mayor Christiansen also stated that the Fire Marshal’s office is run by a past Chief of the City of Dover Fire
Paj 91
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 9
Department, who would ensure that all the step-backs would meet the NFPA standards before the buildings are even considered.
A written public comment was provided in support of the potential revisions of the C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) by Donny Legans, Rail Haus owner/operator (Attachment #2).
Mr. Neil moved to recommend acceptance of staff recommendations to move forward with the provision that staff look at the step-back and a determination will be made regarding the step-back going forward in the final documents. The motion was seconded by Mr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Lewis, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
Mr. Hare moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:56 p.m.
Mr. Hare moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:56 p.m.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Mr. Lewis and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
QUARTERLY REVENUE REPORT AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2023
Members were provided the Quarterly Revenue Report as of December 31, 2023.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Quarterly Revenue Report as of December 31, 2023, seconded by Mr. Lewis and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
QUARTERLY REVIEW – CAPITAL INVESTMENT PLAN (CIP) (OCTOBER, NOVEMBER, DECEMBER) Members were provided the Quarterly Report for the Capital Investment Plan (CIP) as of December 31, 2023.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Quarterly Report of the Capital Investment Plan (CIP) as of December 31, 2023, seconded by Mr. Lewis and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
APPOINTMENTS BY MAYOR CHRISTIANSEN
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the following appointments, seconded by Mr. Lewis, and carried by unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
Paj 92
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 10
Confirmation of Police Pension Election – Retired Captain Larry Gray – Three (3) Year Term to Expire January 31, 2027
CONSIDERATION OF RESCINDING RESOLUTION NO. 2023-16 (RESOLUTION ADOPTED BY CITY COUNCIL ON OCTOBER 23, 2023) Mr. Hugg briefed the members on the Rescission of Resolution #2023-16. Mr. Hugg explained that they have been actively working with the State Pension Office, with the intention of making the State Municipal Employee Pension an option for the City of Dover employees. Mr. Hugg further explained that there was a misunderstanding of one of their requirements and had asked council to pass the resolution, which was passed on October 23, 2023, to join the State Municipal Pension Plan. Mr. Hugg stated that he believed it would set forth the actual process and steps to complete the lists of employees who would be eligible and document the process. Mr. Hugg further stated that it was unanticipated by them that it would trigger the state pension plan to be available, which is something they would love to have but the timing is not right. There is still a lot of information to gather and outreach to the employees before the program can be available for someone to join. Mr. Hugg further stated that after discussing the matter with the State Pension Office, they have advised that the quickest and best thing to do is to rescind the 2023-16 resolution and then submit a new resolution later in the spring when they have the list of employees and information ready so that there is no confusion about who is and who is not eligible. Since council passed the resolution, he needs council to agree to approve this action.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that at this time there is only one employee who would be eligible for the State Municipal Pension at this time. That is a brand-new employee who just joined and has been advised that the pension will be coming but it is not available for them to join today.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg explained that it would not negatively affect the individuals that are eligible and that the actual effective plan has always been July 1, 2024. Council has to certify all of the employees who are willing and interested in joining. That is where they got misdirected. Mr. Hugg further stated that they realized after the fact that it was not something that they intended to do; they wanted to get the city and the pension office moving on with the process.
Mr. Neil moved to rescind Resolution No. 2023-16. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried unanimously roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
FIRST READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-03 – COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT 2024 – CONSIDERATION OF AMENDMENT TO MAP 12-1: LAND DEVELOPMENT PLAN MAP Council President Hare reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinances were available on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at 736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us. Since the ordinances amend the Comprehensive Map and Plan, a public hearing is required. Staff recommended referral of the amendments to the Planning Commission for a public hearing on February 20, 2024, and that a public hearing bet set before City Council on March 11, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. at which time the Final Reading and final action by council will take place.
Paj 93
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 11
Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed proposed Ordinance #2024-03 – Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2024 – Consideration of Amendment to Map 12-1: Land Development Plan Map. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the address 10790 Silver Lake Boulevard is just over five acres of land. The request is to revise the land use category of office to a proposed designation of mixed use. This will require a referral to the Planning Commission for a public hearing, and the Planning Commission will make a recommendation to City Council.
Responding to Ms. Melson-Williams, Mr. Neil asked if this was talking about the possibility of housing, convenience, retail offices, etc.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that this is a request to amend the land use designation in the Comprehensive Plan. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that currently the property has a land use classification of office and that the land use category of mixed-use does broaden the potential zoning classifications where they could see a mix of uses, both commercial and residential.
Mr. Neil moved to refer the request to the Planning Commission for a public hearing on February 20, 2024 and to set a public hearing before City Council on March 11, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-03 – AMENDING THE 2019 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN WITH CONSIDERATION OF AN AMENDMENT OF MAP 12-1: LAND DEVELOPMENT PLAN TO REVISE THE LAND USE CLASSIFICATION OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1079 SILVER LAKE BOULEVARD.
FIRST READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-04 – LANDS OF DOVER
FEDERAL CREDIT UNION AT 1079 SILVER LAKE BOULEVARD: CPO TO C-2A Ms. Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed proposed Ordinance #2024-04 – Lands of Dover Federal Credit Union at 1079 Silver Lake Boulevard, CPO to C-2A. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that this is a rezoning application and that it is associated with the Comprehensive Plan amendment. If the Comprehensive Plan amendment is successful, then the rezoning application would be eligible for consideration.
Ms. Melson-Williams stated that rezoning applications require a first reading to set the hearing dates for the Planning Commission and City Council. Ms. Melson-Williams further stated that this request is for the property at 1079 Silver Lake Boulevard, which is owned by Dover Federal Credit Union. Ms. Melson-Williams further stated that this is a vacant tract of land and is currently zoned CPO and that the proposed zoning classification is C-2A, which is the Limited Central Commercial Zone. The Planning Commission will have a public hearing and make a recommendation to City Council regarding this zoning request, and it is brought to council the first reading announcing the future public hearing dates.
Paj 94
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 12
Mr. Neil moved to refer the request to the Planning Commission for a public hearing on February 20, 2024 and to set a public hearing before City Council on March 11, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty absent)
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-04 AMENDING THE LANDS OF DOVER FEDERAL CREDIT UNION AT 1079 LAKE BOULEVARD FROM CPO (COMMERCIAL AND PROFESSIONAL OFFICE ZONE) TO PROPOSED ZONING C-2A (LIMITED CENTRAL COMMERCIAL ZONE).
FIRST READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-01 – AMENDING APPENDIX B – ZONING, ARTICLE 3 – DISTRICT REGULATIONS, SECTION 13 – CENTRAL COMMERCIAL ZONE (C-2), ARTICLE 4 – ZONING AND BULK PARKING REGULATIONS, SECTION 4.14 – [C-1, C-1A, C-2, C-2A ZONES], ARTICLE 5 – SUPPLEMENTARY REGULATIONS, SECTION 6 – DUMPSTERS FOR TRASH AND RECYCLING, ARTICLE 6 – OFF-STREET PARKING, DRIVEWAYS AND LOADING FACILITIES, SECTION 3 – REQUIRED OFF-STREET PARKING SPACES, ARTICLE 12 – DEFINITIONS Ms. Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed proposed Ordinance #2024-01 Zoning, Article 3-District Regulations, Section 13 – Central Commercial Zone (C-2), Article 4 – Zoning and Bulk Parking Regulations, Section 4.14 – [C-1, C-1A, C-2, C-2A zones], Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 6 – Dumpsters for trash and recycling, Article 6 – Parking Spaces, Article 12 – Definitions. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that this had been presented this month to the Council Committee of the Whole, the Legislative Finance and Administration Committee, and was reported out of that committee.
Ms. Melson-Williams explained that this is a series of amendments to the zoning ordinance, primarily focusing on the C-2 zoning district to add additional uses and to revise the bulk standards and design standards for that zone. Ms. Melson-Williams further explained that there are some amendments to other portions of the zoning ordinance related to the development activity, which include dumpsters, parking, and adding some definition to the code. This is in response to implementing the Transforming Downtown Dover Capital City 2030 Plan.
Ms. Melson-Williams noted that this was a task that staff has worked on over the last nine months and brought forth a proposed ordinance to the Legislative, Finance and Administration Committee. She stated that they did recommend moving forward with this first reading and that staff look at the height requirements and the step-back provision. Ms. Melson-Williams further stated that this was included in the first reading provision and what they are calling the Legislative Finance Administration Committee Amendment #1 which in the proposed ordinance itself, changes the provisions that were to be considered for item #13.52’s height. This is a design standard in the C-2 zone and the proposal is outlined beginning on line 89. This needs to be referred to the Planning Commission for their public hearing and recommendation before returning to council, for their public hearing and final action on the proposed ordinance.
Paj 95
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 13
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the bulk of this ordinance was what was presented to the committee as a result of the committee’s discussion and testimony that evening. The staff did go back and look at the step-back provisions, which are related to the height in that zoning district, and have put forth an alternative, and what is shown in the green text as reference beginning line 89. Ms. Melson-Williams further stated that they did utilize the suggestion from one of the speakers that evening and used the step-back provision of six (6) feet rather than 10 feet.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there was no specific statement from an engineer that was received. Ms. Melson-Williams explained that typically the information related to the structural soundness of any construction project would be part of a building permit submission. Ms. Melson-Williams further explained that from a professional standpoint as a planner, if someone wanted to build something, the engineer can certainly design it to fit whatever dimensional requirements may be established in the code. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that they are comfortable moving forward with the suggestion of a 6-foot step-back, without having that in hand.
Responding to Ms. Melson-Williams, Mr. Sudler stated that the committee had specifically asked for information and that he believed that Councilman Neil had concurred with him that it was not a bad idea. Mr. Sudler asked them to bring that to the committee. His concern is that the information was never brought back to them. Mr. Sudler felt that they are being overlooked or disregarded. Mr. Sudler stated that council or the committee asked for additional information before they made a final ruling or before they moved forward.
Mr. Neil stated that the comments made by Mosaic at the time indicated that the step-back of the six (6) feet rather than the 10 feet would strengthen the wall but was expecting something from them that they would produce or DDP would produce to let them know or to confirm that it was stronger build than the 10 feet would have been.
Mr. Sudler stated that there was a consensus and that they had asked for that just so they would cover the City of Dover. Mr. Sudler further stated that their decision would be a sound and educated decision, so they could have something to fall back on. Mr. Sudler explained that Mr. Stonesifer had said it would not be a problem. Mr. Sudler believed that they needed to have that report before they moved forward because that is what they had asked for.
Mr. Neil asked if the information could be forwarded to them before they have the hearing before the Planning Commission as it has to become part of the Planning Commission discussion.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Melson-Williams responded that what they have brought forth is the proposed ordinance for the first reading and any additional information that is received will be provided to the Planning Commission and City Council as the ordinance moves through the review process. Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there was a discussion about an engineer, and it is identified in the minutes. Mosaic did offer to provide the statements in writing that they had made that evening. Ms. Melson-Williams further stated that a letter was submitted on behalf of the Downtown Dover Partnership, and it is included as attachments to the minutes. Ms. Melson-
Paj 96
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 14
Williams explained that the motion from the Legislative and Finance Committee did not specifically list the requirement for that engineering statement. It was asked that staff look at the step-back and that a determination be made regarding the step-back going forward in the final documents. Ms. Melson-Williams noted that they are not at the final documents at that point in time.
Ms. Arndt stated that her understanding was that the gentleman from Mosaic was going to provide his comments in writing for staff consideration. Ms. Arndt further stated that she is comfortable moving forward through the process, understanding that there will be additional time for input and consideration.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the letter attached to the meeting minutes is Attachment #1 and that it came from the board of the Downtown Dover Partnership. Ms. Melson-Williams further stated that she does not believe that it was under the hands of an engineer who drafted it.
Responding to Ms. Melson-Williams, Mr. Sudler wanted clarification that an engineer did not draft the letter in which they had asked for that as confirmation from the engineer. Mr. Sudler stated that he is not opposed to moving forward but if something is aligned with a safety precaution or is questionable, he would like to be able to come back to this. Mr. Sudler further stated that he does not want to be bound by this if they to decide since Ms. Melson-Williams stated that additional information could be provided, and additional information could be used to make a final decision if they had this first reading.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that their action made that evening is for a first reading referral. It puts the proposed ordinance out there and forwards it for a more detailed review and recommendation by the Planning Commission and then also by Council. Ms. Melson-Williams further stated that at any point moving forward there can be amendments made to the proposed ordinance. The review by the Planning Commission could suggest revisions, and City Council could make revisions as part of their review and final adoption process in their March meeting.
Mr. Hare stated that Ms. Melson-Williams knows what they are looking for and will make sure that the information is there when it comes back to them and the Planning Commission.
Mr. Sudler stated that he would like to make a motion that they ask an engineer to confirm that it would not be a structural compromise. Mr. Sudler further stated that if they decide to go with the staff recommendation for that step-back, their expertise and license on the line, would confirm this. So that council members could make a sound and educated decision without putting their constituents’ tax-paying dollars in harm’s way if something does not go the way that they thought it would.
Mr. Hare stated that a motion had already been made and a second to move forward and it is going to come back to them. Mr. Hare further stated that if the information is not there, the members can decline, and it will not be approved.
Paj 97
Item #6.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 22, 2024 PAGE 15
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that certainly for construction buildings the typical design professional who is sealing the documents is an architect at times. They may seek the professional expertise of an engineer, specifically a structural engineer in the design of the components of a building.
Mr. Neil moved to refer the request to the Planning Commission for a public hearing on February 20, 2024 and to set a public hearing before City Council on March 11, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a roll call vote of five (5) yes (Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, and Hare), three (3) no (Anderson, Sudler, and Lewis), and one (1) absent (Boggerty).
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, the Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-01 – AMENDING APPENDIX B – ZONING, ARTICLE 3
– DISTRICT REGULATIONS, SECTION 13 – CENTRAL COMMERCIAL
ZONE (C-2), ARTICLE 4 – ZONING AND BULK PARKING REGULATIONS,
SECTION 4.14 – [C-1, C-1A, C-2, C-2A ZONES], ARTICLE 5 –
SUPPLEMENTARY REGULATIONS, SECTION 6 – DUMPSTERS FOR
TRASH AND RECYCLING, ARTICLE 6 – PARKING SPACES, ARTICLE 12
– DEFINITIONS.
CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
No Announcements from Mr. Hugg.
MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
No Announcements from Mayor Christiansen.
COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS
No Announcements from Council Members.
The meeting adjourned at 7:47 p.m.
ANDRIA BENNETT CITY CLERK
All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by the City Council during their Regular Meeting of January 22, 2024, are hereby approved.
ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR
Paj 98
Item #7.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE
The Council Committee of the Whole met on January 23, 2024, at 6:01 p.m. with Council President Hare presiding. Members of Council present were Mr. Anderson, Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Mr. Sudler. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Dr. Jackson-Short and Ms. Smack (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation), and Mr. Shevock (via WebEx) (Legislative, Finance, and Administration). Mr. Iriowen, Mr. Pugh (Utility), and Ms. Smith (Legislative, Finance, and Administration) were absent.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.
SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairman Lewis presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Anderson and unanimously carried.
Review of the Research on the Solar Powered Feedback Signs and Electronic Speed Enforcement Devices (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the research on the Solar Powered Feedback Signs and Electronic Speed Enforcement Devices.
Staff recommended approving a method of speed enforcement equipment to utilize in the City of Dover neighborhoods.
Mr. Lyon explained that he and his team conducted research on the implications of House Bill 94, which covers electronic speed enforcement devices and was passed by the State of Delaware. Mr. Lyon stated that the electronic automatic ticketing devices are about $25,000, the mobile feedback signs are $3,000, and the non-permanent, trailer-mounted signs are $7,000. In addition to the upfront cost for the unit, there is an annual cost of $7,000 a year for the electronic automatic ticketing software, the cloud storage, and the use of the photographs going to the cloud for the third-party company. The automatic ticketing devices cost around $70 a year for maintenance, and the feedback signs cost around $200 a year.
Mr. Lyon stated that if the automatic ticketing devices were to go through a third party it would cost the city $14 a ticket to the company to do the mailing, collection, and creation of the bill. After touring with the Dover Police Department and going over red-light ticketing, which is like automatic ticketing, Mr. Lyon learned that there are about 12,000 red-light tickets a year, and 10 to 12 percent get appealed. The police department’s staff must review each ticket to see whether it has been appealed or not.
Paj 99
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 2 Item #7.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Lyon stated that each ticket would need to be reviewed by a police officer, which is the statute because it cannot be assumed that technology is going to work correctly. Mr. Lyon explained that every one of the 12,000 per year would need to be reviewed by a team member, and if the person issued the ticket wanted to appeal it, then the team member must appear in court, so it takes resources.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Lyon stated that it would have to be a legal officer rather than a designee who reviews the tickets and goes to court.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Lyon stated that he had a meeting with the police department and his understanding is that it must be a sworn officer.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Chief Johnson stated that preliminary research has not led him to a definitive answer of whether it could be delegated. Chief Johnson explained that in other jurisdictions, they would be considered civil violations and are not motor vehicle code violations, therefore they do not require a sworn office to file the charging document. Chief Johnson explained that they are researching other jurisdictions to explore if someone who is appropriately trained, like a retired police officer with the core knowledge of what constitutes a violation, could work in a civilian capacity to process the violations and send them to the vendor.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that the program is in the infancy stage in Delaware, and he is not aware of any other municipalities with a similar program. Mr. Lyon explained that when he spoke to one of the vendors, they stated that they have municipalities in Florida that are placing the equipment in school zones and they have been collecting about 400 tickets per day, five days a week, during the school year. Mr. Lyon explained that it is up to them to charge it, but that it is sustainable.
Mr. Lyon stated that in the state statute, there is a statement that reads “Any excess revenue not used for the administration of this system will be managed by the Office of Highway Safety and used only for purposes of education enforcement, engineering, and administration”. Mr. Lyon explained that automatic ticketing cannot be used as a revenue source, but it can be used to cover the administrative costs of an additional member working on the ticket process. Mr. Lyon also explained that a study must be done that is not longer than one (1) year old by DelDOT showing that the area that is proposed has a speeding problem, and the eighty-five percentile is over five miles per hour over the speed limit. DelDOT currently does not have a process for this because it is too new, but they hope in six months to have a process.
Mr. Lyon stated that the Office of Highway Safety, which provides grants for such items, requires that electronic automatic ticketing software only be used in school zones and construction zones. Mr. Lyon continued to state that it is possible to get grants for solar-powered feedback signs, but that they prefer the mobile kind because they can be moved around.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that according to the law, and DelDOT, the study must come from DelDOT, it cannot be done by the municipality.
Paj 100
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 3 Item #7.
Mr. Anderson stated that the City of Dover has a policy that does not allow speed bumps on public property. Mr. Anderson explained that there have been upgrades made to the designs and technology of speed bumps and that he would like to have them looked at again. Mr. Anderson suggested that the research include speed tables, which do not cause disruption or damage to the vehicle, and other designs that are designed to allow emergency vehicles to move through safely. Mr. Anderson explained that with the changing technology, there may be products that meet the needs of the community without causing too much disruption to emergency services.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Lyon stated that traditionally a speed bump is used, they are as wide as they are short, and they can be driven over at two (2) to 10 miles per hour. A speed hump or speed table is spread out, not as abrupt, and they can be driven over at 10 to 15 miles per hour. Mr. Lyon also stated that there is an alternative called a speed cushion, they are the standard width of a vehicle’s wheelbase. Since a firetruck has a wider wheelbase the speed cushion allows them to pass by with little interruption. Mr. Lyon stated that he is unsure how this would affect an ambulance, but the speed cushions are currently being used in Odessa. They are rubber, bolted into the ground, and can be removed for snow plowing. Mr. Lyon also stated that the Office of Highway Safety does not provide funding for speed cushions.
Mayor Christiansen stated that he supports the electronic speed enforcement devices because it does not take officers off the road and when DelDOT creates their procedure the city needs to have a mechanism in place to put in service because the citizens expect more.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that they are only allowed to be used on city local roads of a speed limit of 25 miles an hour.
Responding to Ms. Smack, Mr. Lyon stated that the $25,000 unit is more for behavior-changing, but that they would not qualify for grants unless they were placed in a school district.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the Office of Highway Safety stated that they get their money through the federal government, through the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. They do not know exactly how much money they will receive every year, and what the city could receive depends on what their funding allocation is.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lyon stated that per House Bill 94, the speed must be 11 miles an hour or higher to issue a ticket.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Lyon stated that the city is not eligible to enforce the cameras as a municipality on state roads, however, DelDOT could once they create a process.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Lyon stated that in 1964 there was a group of streets that were originally in the City of Dover limits that were city-owned and maintained. The state took over ownership from the city and now when any work needs to be done to a water main for example, the city must go through the state for a permit.
Ms. Arndt recommended creating a map that shows what schools are on city roads, talk to the principals, the school districts, and determine where the problems are occurring. Ms. Arndt stated
Paj 101
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 4 Item #7.
that she spoke to the principal at Towne Point and the problem is primarily the parents speeding as they drop off their children.
Mr. Anderson moved to recommend proceeding with obtaining additional speed signs, with the recommendation depending on funding, whether they be mobile or static.
Mr. Neil recommended the use of mobile signs.
Mr. Anderson moved to recommend proceeding with obtaining additional mobile speed signs. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
Mr. Anderson moved to refer back to staff for a recommendation for the speed cameras after more studies have been done with a recommendation from public works and the police department on the issue.
Mr. Lyon stated that the cameras could be placed in a residential zone, but the city would have to come up with the funding. The Office of Highway Safety grants are only available for use in the school and construction zones.
Mr. Anderson stated that they do qualify for CTF funds.
Mr. Anderson moved to refer the issue of the speed cameras back to staff for input from the police department. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Mr. Lewis recommended that Mr. Lyon work with Chief Johnson regarding where the need is for the mobile radar speed signs and how to move forward with the speed cameras.
Discussion – Complaint from Kate Howard, Irish Mikes Pub Bar Owner/Manager regarding the Dover Police Department’s responsibility to serve and protect their business (Councilman Sudler) Mr. Sudler stated that he had been contacted by Ms. Kate Howard and constituents regarding the protection of individuals once the bar had been let out.
Committee Action Not Required.
Ms. Kate Howard, Irish Mikes, City of Dover, explained that she wanted to get on the same page with the city. Ms. Howard stated that when she calls, she feels there is a perception issue between Irish Mikes and dispatch. Ms. Howard explained that dispatchers seem annoyed when they call to be proactive before the fighting starts, or if they feel like police presence is needed for a lot of commotion while people are waiting to get their food around the corner. Ms. Howard stated that she understands that they are short-staffed, and she does not want the police department to think she is complaining about them. Ms. Howard stated that she called on Saturday and they were professional, officers arrived within five minutes, made sure everyone got in their cars, and cleared the sidewalk. Ms. Howard stated that the complaints have come from her bartenders, so they plan to have a staff meeting to discuss tips from Chief Johnson on how to provide dispatch information rather than trying to spit it off to them.
Paj 102
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 5 Item #7.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Howard stated that the issues occur after one o’clock when everyone is leaving. Ms. Howard explained that it has increased since Covid with everyone sitting outside, drinking, and staying around downtown until three in the morning.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that typically they tend to have a police presence in the area at the time of closing. Chief Johnson explained that one in the morning on a Thursday, Friday, or Saturday is primetime for all types of incidents in areas other than Irish Mikes. Chief Johnson stated that response times are directly related to how pressed resources are. When someone is there in two minutes, that means they are in a good spot and have the resources ready, when five to seven minutes have passed and there is no car, then there is likely a dispatcher somewhere asking if anyone can break loose and get to Loockerman Street.
Mr. Boggerty commended Chief Johnson for inviting him to review video footage of an event that occurred around Irish Mikes. Mr. Boggerty explained that in viewing the video footage, he was able to see the bigger picture and obtain deeper knowledge of what had transpired.
Ms. Arndt commended Chief Johnson and thanked Mr. Boggerty for providing the information on the video. Ms. Arndt stated that she saw the video and appreciated the additional context of how the situation was handled and the video that was played was only a minute and a half of a 55- minute video.
Lachelle Paul, 501 Silverside Road, Wilmington, expressed concerns about the police department enforcing laws so that patrons of establishments like Irish Mikes know that certain behaviors will not be tolerated. Ms. Paul expressed concerns with the video, where an individual struck another individual and the police were present, but nothing was done. Ms. Paul stated that businesses should not have to deal with the issues simply because they serve alcohol. Ms. Paul stated that the businesses want people arrested if they are creating issues in front of the businesses.
Mr. Boggerty stated that he had the same question when he first watched the video as well. Mr. Boggerty explained that when he took in all of the situational awareness, he found himself asking what had to happen. Through the community policing model, they were told to go home so they would not be embarrassed but ultimately someone was arrested.
Enrico Stratton, 66 Barrett Court, Felton, expressed concerns about blaming the community rather than blaming the establishments that provide the alcohol and drugs in the community.
Responding to Mr. Carey, Ms. Howard stated that she felt like the police were annoyed by her girls calling sometimes two times a week when most of the calls were to be proactive. Ms. Howard stated that people were getting food, they were in the middle of the street, cars were parked on Bradford Street, and they were in the bank parking lot drinking. Ms. Howard stated a lot of the people who hang outside do not even come into her business.
Matthew Carey, Emergency Communications Manager, explained that the staff is not annoyed but they must maintain a level of calm to make it through a twelve-hour shift. Mr. Carey stated that he has a copy of the 17 times Ms. Howard’s establishment has called the police department for her review. Mr. Carey stated that no one was disrespectful and complied with national standards.
Paj 103
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 6 Item #7.
Mr. Carey stated that every Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and Saturday night they review the videos provided by Ms. Howard through EagleView, and they deploy officers as soon as possible. Mr. Carey explained that as Mr. Boggerty stated, they cannot always rush in because they may be outnumbered.
Mr. Sudler stated that council needs to make sure their constituents are heard, and that they should not feel like they cannot come to council to express their concerns. Mr. Sudler explained that he took Ms. Howard’s concerns as a complaint and maybe that was misinterpreted.
Discussion – Concerns with the displaced and tent village on College Road adjacent to the Delaware State University facilities (Councilman Sudler) Mr. Sudler briefed the committee on the concerns of Delaware State University alumni and individuals in the district regarding the tent city on College Road. Mr. Sudler expressed concerns about the individuals who may be registered sex offenders or violent, property owners receiving citations from code enforcement for unlawful tent villages on their property, and the accountability from the homeless individuals and city council.
Committee Action Not Required.
Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer briefed the committee on the status of the homeless encampments. Mr. Kopp stated that the problem is not with the property owners because they are taking corrective actions, the problem is that they cannot keep up with the encampments. Mr. Kopp stated that the encampments are well connected, and the problem is being moved from one area to another. Mr. Kopp stated that code enforcement is working closely with the police department and the community policing unit to bring resources to the people that they are encountering, unfortunately, they often refuse the resources.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Kopp stated that there are between 40 and 50 encampments throughout the city.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Kopp stated that the encampments averaged between 15 to 30 people.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Kopp stated what has been most effective is having the property owner make sure that the property is clear of brush and debris and is visible from the public right of way.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Kopp stated that drug paraphernalia is a major concern at most encampments. Mr. Kopp stated that it is a safety concern for code enforcement, the police department, and kids when the location is close to a neighborhood.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Kopp stated that they are working with the property owners as best as they can, but it has become an ongoing issue that causes them to move from one location to another. Mr. Kopp emphasized that it is not just one property that is the issue.
Paj 104
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 7 Item #7.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Kopp stated that he believes what Georgetown is doing is helping, however, he does think that there are substance abuse treatment requirements for the program. Mr. Kopp stated that they are taking resources out to the encampments, and they are being turned away.
Alonzo Hall, 320 Raymond Street, Dover, expressed his concerns with people saying that the unhoused do not want help. Mr. Hall spoke from previous experiences about the conditions in the shelters and how the volunteers speak to people. Mr. Hall also explained that they do want help and they need help.
Tracy Palmer, 301 Cassidy Drive Suite B, Dover, explained that Tracy Palmer Ministries is in the community helping to feed, provide showers, and anything else that is needed by the community. Ms. Palmer expressed dissatisfaction with council following through on what has been proposed at council meetings. Ms. Palmer explained that the community needs help, people are begging for food, loitering on properties, and defecating on properties. She continued to explain that Tracy Palmer Ministries wants to help the community, the homeless, and the children who run away, but they cannot do it by themselves. Ms. Palmer asked the council to afford Tracy Palmer Ministries a building, land, or both.
Alex Cropper, 217 N.E. Front Street, Milford, explained that the people in the community need help. Mr. Cropper stated that when he worked at Dover Interfaith, he saw many of the things that Mr. Hall described. Mr. Cropper explained that the people need thorough assessments done and follow-up case management. Mr. Cropper stated that he attended a city homeless expo that was held one weekend and consisted of a comedy show, basketball tournament, concerts with local artists, and on Sunday they had breakfast, and a prayer service to raise funding to aid the homeless. Mr. Cropper offered his services to organize an event like this in the city and as a counselor to Tracy Palmer Ministries.
Lachelle Paul, 501 Silverside Road, Wilmington, expressed her concerns about homelessness in the community. Ms. Paul explained that her organization may have contributed to tents at the encampments because they collected tents to provide individuals with some type of shelter. Ms. Paul suggested finding a safe place to house the tents within the city that does not interfere with property owners. Ms. Paul stated that many of the resources that are available to the homeless do not have anything left to give. Ms. Paul explained that Tracy Palmer Ministries has a great proposal if the council could review it and help her with her vision.
Bonnie Pennington, 200 N. Kirkwood Street, Dover, expressed her concerns about the lack of help from the state. Ms. Pennington stated that two people passed away because of the below-freezing temperatures. Ms. Pennington explained that everyone makes mistakes, and that homeless people need a second chance because they deserve it.
Teresa Campbell, 28 Holden Court, Clayton, expressed her concerns as the Director of the Center for Neighbors in Need. Ms. Campbell stated that the city does not have a homeless situation, it has a mental health situation. Ms. Campbell stated that there are no mental health facilities in Dover, and shelters like hers are lining people up on tables at night.
Paj 105
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 8 Item #7.
Enrico Stratton-Bey, 66 Barrett Court, Felton, expressed the need for council to be out in the community physically helping the organizations like Tracy Palmer Ministries, and Code Purple to fully understand the need of the community.
Ashley Robinson, 119 Albert Place, Felton, explained as the owner of The Wedding Boutique on Loockerman Street, she can attest to homelessness being a major concern. Ms. Robinson suggested that there be a committee that gathers all of the city’s resources together to evaluate how many programs there are and where the money needs to go. Ms. Robinson stated that if she knew where to direct people instead of having to call the police, she would like to be able to do that. Ms. Robinson suggested that once all the programs and shelter information is gathered, it would be helpful if a newsletter could be sent out sharing the information of where to direct the people.
Josette Cooper, 580 N. Dupont Highway, Dover, stated that she is actively involved in feeding the homeless on holidays and that she always obtains food from Tracy Palmer Ministries. Ms. Cooper stated that Tracy Palmer is always helping the community, the homeless community, and the families and children of the community. Ms. Cooper stated that Tracy Palmer is always available, and she would like the city to say yes to her proposal.
Francis Perry Hawkins, 7012 Coffee Circle, Dover, stated that as a retired veteran who has experienced homelessness and volunteered with Code Purple and Tracy Palmer Ministries, many of the homeless that she has seen in the community are veterans. Ms. Hawkins asked that council consider Tracy Palmer’s proposal because many of the people are homeless or veterans who have served the country for years.
Albert Roach, 301 Cassidy Drive, Dover, expressed appreciation for Tracy Palmer and all that she does for the community through Tracy Palmer Ministries.
Ennio Zaragoza, 123 E. Division Street, Dover, expressed support for Tracy Palmer’s proposal and all of the work that she does in the community.
Reverend Rita Mishoe Paige, 355 Rita Wilma Road, Dover, suggested that a planning committee be developed to come up with financial initiatives to finance buildings such as the one Tracy Palmer has proposed. Reverend Paige stated that the committee needs to have conversations with the Delaware State Housing Authority about providing funding through the housing council, and offering private developer tax credits so that they may build affordable housing for the homeless. Reverend Paige also suggested that the housing be scattered because there can be a negative connotation behind housing them in one location. Reverend Paige explained that the homeless need help, they need finances and training. Reverend Paige commended Tracy Palmer Ministries for all of the work that they do in the community. Reverend Paige stated that the city does own old buildings that could be rehabbed to house the homeless but that there needs to be job training, mental health issues need to be addressed, and counseling needs to be offered to address all of the things that go along with being homeless. Revered Paige stated that she and her daughter recently hosted a dinner for the homeless at the Delvets and out of 75 people approximately six of them were veterans. Reverend Paige stated that anyone could become homeless, and they deserve compassion.
Paj 106
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 9 Item #7.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Reverend Paige stated that when she worked as the Community Development Block Grant Administrator in Milford, she ran into people living in chicken coops because they were afraid of moving into a new environment. Reverend Paige stated that most people want help if they can get help.
Angela Williams, 723 S. Wynn Wood Circle, Camden, expressed support for Tracy Palmer Ministries. Ms. Williams also expressed the need for a committee to organize the resources available to assist the homeless.
Mr. Boggerty stated that he understands the urgency of homelessness in the community as a veteran himself and as someone who has experienced homelessness in his life as well. Mr. Boggerty asked the Mayor and Council President to work with Ms. Palmer because she has proven to be effective in all things that she does with the community.
Mr. Rocha stated that council should look at taking Reverend Paige’s recommendation to form a working group or committee formally. Mr. Rocha stated that in conjunction with the working group, there is a need to create a plan to put together a healthy and conducive place for them to stay in the meantime. Mr. Rocha explained that the working group will bring everyone together, but they cannot lobby for their own organization.
Mr. Rocha moved to recommend putting together a working group to tackle the immediate needs of those in tents right now, whether they need heat or porta-potties to get them to a level where they do not freeze to death, and then have reports brought back to council. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.
Responding to Ms. Smack, Mr. Rocha stated that they would go through the mayor’s office and would be brought back in 30 days. Mr. Rocha explained that he would like it brought back at the second meeting in February, however, that does not mean that the group will not be working.
Responding to Ms. Palmer, Mr. Rocha stated that she should bring her plan, but they are going to work together, shuffle through all the papers, and address the immediate needs first.
Responding to Ms. Palmer, Mr. Rocha stated that he is unsure why the Dover Housing Authority and Delaware State Housing Authority have not stepped in.
Mayor Christiansen stated that the committees that they created before have disappeared because there was continual fighting. Mayor Christiansen explained that one of the successful committees was the Mayor’s Challenge to End Veterans Homelessness, which housed over 2,000 homeless veterans. Mayor Christiansen explained that he would bring everyone to the table, they will elect their leadership, he will make sure that they do not fight, and that they come up with something productive to bring back to council in either a written or verbal report.
Mr. Neil recommended using the city website to communicate when the committee is meeting, where they will meet, and what they will be covering.
Paj 107
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 10 Item #7.
Mayor Christiansen stated that as soon as he hears from people who want to serve on the committee, they will have a meeting in the next 10 to 15 days.
Mr. Lewis moved for adjournment of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:49 p.m.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.
Tidewater Utilities – Agreement for Water Sales/Purchase (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and analysis of the Tidewater Utilities agreement.
Staff recommended allowing staff to enter into an agreement with Tidewater Utilities with the specified water rates.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.
Tree Trimming Bid Award – Sole Source Vendor (Paul Waddell, Electric Director) Mr. Paul Waddell, Electric Director, reviewed the background and analysis of the tree trimming bid award.
Staff recommended awarding a two (2) year (2024, 2025) tree trimming contract to Asplundh Tree Experts with a City option to extend it an additional three (3) years (2026, 2027, 2028), five (5) years total. The contract work will be adjusted to stay within the budget each year.
Mr. Waddell noted that the sole source vendor was a typo, and the contract was opened up to the RFP process. Two responses were received, and Asplundh was the only one to provide a complete response.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:52 p.m.
Paj 108
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 11 Item #7.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Anderson presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously carried.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-02 – Amending Chapter 106 – Traffic and Vehicles, Sec. 106-136 On-Street disabled parking (Councilman Neil and Councilwoman Arndt) Mr. Neil reviewed the background behind Proposed Ordinance #2024-02.
Staff recommended approving Ordinance #2024-02.
Mr. Neil stated that he was approached by a constituent who saw a problem in their neighborhood, where there were two handicapped spaces across from the driveway of the home of the person who requested them, which caused other neighbors to park farther and farther away, and the two parking spaces were not being used. Mr. Neil explained that the constituent provided documents from other government entities showing their process, because of this it was asked if a person had a driveway, do they need to have parking spots on the public road. Mr. Neil stated that the ordinance was prepared and improved in the sense that it now says the parking spot will be based on a DMV- issued parking permit. Mr. Neil explained that there was a list of 172 places that have handicapped parking, in addition to that, 62 are in residential areas, and approximately four addresses in the city have at least two parking spots listed at the specific address. Mr. Neil stated that the proposed ordinance does not take parking away from anyone who needs it, however, it does say that if they have two parking spots and a driveway, then they can only have one parking spot on the street. If they need two parking spots and do not have a driveway then they will need two permits from the DMV to use them. Mr. Neil explained that the proposed ordinance will be fair to people with disabilities and to the people in the neighborhood who have had their parking displaced from near their homes because someone is taking up two spots.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Neil stated that if they prove that they have two valid permits from the DMV showing that there will be two vehicles going in and out, then they will be able to have their driveway plus one parking spot on the road.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Neil stated that they would have to go through a review process with evidence from the City of Dover Public Works Department.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil stated that the clerk’s office had to go through the ADA for approval to make it on the agenda.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil stated that if they had three permits from the DMV, they could have two spots.
Paj 109
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 23, 2024 PAGE 12 Item #7.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil stated that typically there is one foot of length for each one inch of height, and it would be impossible to have a house flat and a driveway going up, but if it comes up then they would have to request a review.
Mr. Hugg stated that the proposed ordinance does not address whether existing permits are grandfathered in, and that the city has an ADA Coordinator in Water/Wastewater and Engineering Services for construction projects, but that they are not involved in approving individual requests. Mr. Hugg stated that several driveways in the city do not meet the ADA standards because they are sloped, rounded, or have a higher curb than necessary, and for that reason, he would like to have more time to re-examine some of the sites. Mr. Hugg stated that to the best of his knowledge, a handicapped parking space is not designated to any particular individual, they may request it, and it may be put in front of their house but anyone with a placard can park there.
Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mr. Neil stated that the community has an HOA, but that it is not a private community.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend deferring Proposed Ordinance #2024-02. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:11 p.m.
Mr. Hare moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:11 p.m.
William F. Hare
Council President
Paj 110
Item #14.
Paj 111
Item #14.
CITY COUNCIL COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND
JULY 1, 2023 - JUNE 30, 2024
100-10-12-99-000-53037
Current
Balance- $ 14,250.00
BUDGETED COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND - $2,500 FOR EACH COUNCIL MEMBER PER DISTRICT AND $5,000 FOR THE AT-LARGE COUNCIL MEMBER. THE PURPOSE OF THE FUND IS TO ALLOW MEMBERS TO CONTRIBUTE FUNDS TO A SMALL PROJECT OR COMMUNITY NEEDS IN EACH DISTRICT. $ 25,000.00 AMOUNT
FINAL BUDGET $ 25,000.00 TOTAL
COUNCIL TOTAL YEAR TO
| DATE | VENDOR | DESCRIPTION | INVOICE # | BALANCE | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPONSOR | CHARGES | DATE | |||||
| Women and Children Transformation Ministry Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $500.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Women and Children Transformation Ministry Email from David Anderson dated 05/24/2023 and Email & Letter from William Snorton, Jr. received | |||||||
| 7/10/2023 | Anderson | $500.00 | $500.00 | $24,500.00 | |||
| International, Inc. | International, Inc. | for their Boys to Men Development Program for Gas cards | 05/23/2023 | ||||
| 7/12/2023 Anderson The 302 Movement Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $300.00 of his community enhancement funds to The 302 Movement for the backpack program. Email from David Anderson dated 07/12/2023 and email from Tracey Weems dated 07/11/2023 $300.00 $800.00 $24,200.00 | |||||||
| 7/17/2023 Boggerty I Am Me, Inc. Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $200.00 of his community enhancement funds to I Am Me, Inc. for their ME Festival Email from Andre Boggerty dated 07/17/2023 and email from Peirrce McCoy dated 07/17/2023 $200.00 $1,000.00 $24,000.00 | |||||||
| 7/17/2023 Hare I Am Me, Inc. Council President Hare authorized the designation of $200.00 of his community enhancement funds to I Am Me, Inc. for their ME Festival Email from Bill Hare dated 07/17/2023 and email from Peirrce McCoy dated 07/17/2023 $200.00 $1,200.00 $23,800.00 | |||||||
| 7/18/2023 | Jenmor Florist | Void | Void | Void | -$50.00 | $1,150.00 | $23,850.00 |
| 7/25/2023 Lewis I Am Me, Inc. Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $300.00 of his community enhancement funds to I Am Me, Inc. for their ME Festival Email from Brian Lewis dated 07/25/2023 and email from Peirrce McCoy dated 07/17/2023 $300.00 $1,450.00 $23,550.00 | |||||||
| 7/25/2023 Anderson United Way Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $200.00 of his community enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book Bash" Email from David Anderson dated 07/25/2023 and email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 07/25/2023 $200.00 $1,650.00 $23,350.00 | |||||||
| 7/25/2023 Pillsbury United Way Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250.00 of her community enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book Bash" Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 07/25/2023 and email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 07/25/2023 $250.00 $1,900.00 $23,100.00 | |||||||
| 7/25/2023 Neil United Way Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $100.00 of his community enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book Bash" Email from Fred Neil dated 07/25/2023 and email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 07/25/2023 $100.00 $2,000.00 $23,000.00 | |||||||
| Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $1000.00 of his community enhancement funds to The Inner City Cultural League for the reasons | |||||||
| 7/31/2023 Boggerty The Inner City Cultural League Email from Andre Boggerty dated 07/31/2023 and email from Reuben Salters dated 07/25/2023 $1,000.00 $3,000.00 $22,000.00 | |||||||
| stated in the email. | |||||||
| Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $250.00 of his community enhancement funds to The Yeshua Lighthouse for bookbags for their | |||||||
| 8/4/2023 Anderson Yeshua Lighthouse Email from David Anderson dated 08/04/2023 and Email & Letter from Liana Pritchett received 08/01/2023 $250.00 $3,250.00 $21,750.00 | |||||||
| community day | |||||||
| 8/7/2023 Rocha United Way Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200.00 of his community enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book Bash" Email from Gerald Rocha dated 08/07/2023 and email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 07/25/2023 $200.00 $3,450.00 $21,550.00 | |||||||
| Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $100.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) for | |||||||
| 8/14/2023 Neil Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Email from Fred Neil dated 08/12/2023 and email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 $100.00 $3,550.00 $21,450.00 | |||||||
| their Baila Con Dover Festival. | |||||||
| Councilperson Arndt authorized the designation of $200.00 of her community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans | |||||||
| 8/14/2023 Arndt Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Email from Tricia Arndt dated 08/14/2023 and email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 $200.00 $3,750.00 $21,250.00 | |||||||
| (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. | |||||||
| Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $250.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans | |||||||
| 8/14/2023 Anderson Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Email from David Anderson dated 08/14/2023 and email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 $250.00 $4,000.00 $21,000.00 | |||||||
| (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. | |||||||
| Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $250.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans | |||||||
| 8/14/2023 Boggerty Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Email from Andre Boggerty dated 08/14/2023 and email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 $250.00 $4,250.00 $20,750.00 | |||||||
| (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. | |||||||
| Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $300.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) | |||||||
| 8/14/2023 Lewis Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Email from Brian Lewis dated 08/14/2023 and email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 $300.00 $4,550.00 $20,450.00 | |||||||
| for their Baila Con Dover Festival. | |||||||
| Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) | |||||||
| 8/18/2023 Rocha Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Email from Gerald Rocha dated 08/18/2023 and email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 $200.00 $4,750.00 $20,250.00 | |||||||
| for their Baila Con Dover Festival. | |||||||
| 8/18/2023 Lewis DEMCO Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $200.00 of his community enhancement funds to DEMCO for their Boog Bag giveaway. Email from Brian Lewis dated and Letter from Dr. Linda Hackett dated 08/17/2023 $150.00 $4,900.00 $20,100.00 | |||||||
| Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250.00 of her community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans | |||||||
| 8/21/2023 Pillsbury Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 08/21/2023 and email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 $250.00 $5,150.00 $19,850.00 | |||||||
| (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. | |||||||
| Interdenomonational Ministerial Alliance of Dover | |||||||
| 8/28/2023 Boggerty Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $300.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Annual Community Unity Family Day Email from Andre Boggerty dated 08/25/2023 and email from Bishop W. James Thomas, II dated 08/22/2023 $300.00 $5,450.00 $19,550.00 | |||||||
| and Visinity (IMA) | |||||||
| Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $1,000.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Parks and Recreation Department for the 50 | |||||||
| 10/2/2023 Boggerty Parks & Recreation Email from Andre Boggerty dated 10/2/2023 and a memo from Robin Eaton dated 09/26/2023 $1,000.00 $6,450.00 $18,550.00 | |||||||
| Years of Hip Hop Event. | |||||||
| Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $500.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Parks and Recreation Department for the 50 | |||||||
| 10/2/2023 Rocha Parks & Recreation Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated 10/2/2023 and a memo from Robin Eaton dated 09/26/2023 $500.00 $6,950.00 $18,050.00 | |||||||
| Years of Hip Hop Event. | |||||||
10/5/2023 Pillsbury Dover Police Department Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250.00 of her community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Event Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 10/05/23 and an email from CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated 10/05/23 $250.00 $7,200.00 $17,800.00
10/5/2023 Hare Dover Police Department Council President Hare authorized the designation of $600.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Event Email from Bill Hare dated 10/05/23 and an email from CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated 10/05/23 $600.00 $7,800.00 $17,200.00
10/6/2023 Anderson Dover Police Department Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $500.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Event Email from David Anderson dated 10/06/23 and an email from CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated 10/05/23 $550.00 $8,350.00 $16,650.00
10/16/2023 Boggerty Dover Police Department Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $200.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Event Email from Andre Boggerty dated 10/14/23 and an email from CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated 10/05/23 $200.00 $8,550.00 $16,450.00
11/6/2023 Neil Dover Police Department Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $500.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Event Email from Fred Neil dated 11/06/23 and an email from CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated 10/05/23 $500.00 $9,050.00 $15,950.00
11/14/2023 Lewis Tracy Palmer Ministries Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $150.00 of his community enhancement funds to the Community Thanksgiving Dinner Email from Brian Lewis dated 11/14/23 and a flyer from the Tracy Palmer Ministries $150.00 $9,200.00 $15,800.00
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200.00 of of his community enhancement fund to United Way of Delaware Wonderland Coat and Toy 11/27/2023 Rocha United Way of Delaware Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated 11/27/2023 and email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 11/27/2022 $200.00 $9,400.00 $15,600.00 Drive Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $100.00 of of his community enhancement fund to United Way of Delaware Wonderland Coat and 11/27/2023 Anderson United Way of Delaware Email from David Anderson dated 11/27/2023 and email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 11/27/2022 $100.00 $9,500.00 $15,500.00 Toy Drive
12/13/2023 Arndt Central Delaware Habitat for Humanity Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250.00 of her community enhancement fund to Central Delaware Habitat for Humanity Email from Tricia Arndt dated 12/13/2023 and email from Timothy M. Bailey dated 12/12/2023 $250.00 $9,750.00 $15,250.00
12/13/2023 Arndt People's Place Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250.00 of her community enhancement fund to People's Place Email from Tricia Arndt dated 12/13/2023 and letter from Mamie Charest dated 12/11/2023 $250.00 $10,000.00 $15,000.00
1/11/2024 Boggerty I Am My Sisters Keeper (MSK) Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $750.00 of his community enhancement funds to I Am My Sister's Keeper (MSK-Dover) Email from Andre Boggerty dated 01/11/2024 and an email from Marcille "Dee" Sewell, dated 1/11/24 $750.00 $10,750.00 $14,250.00
TOTALS $10,750.00 $ 14,250.00
Budgeted
| District | Council Sponsor | YTD Expenditures | Balance | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amount | ||||
| $5,000.00 | At-Large | Boggerty | $3,700.00 | $1,300.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 1st District | Pillsbury | $750.00 | $1,750.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 1st District | Rocha | $1,100.00 | $1,400.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 2nd District | Hare | $800.00 | $1,700.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 2nd District | Lewis | $900.00 | $1,600.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 3rd District | Arndt | $700.00 | $1,800.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 3rd District | Neil | $700.00 | $1,800.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 4th District | Anderson | $2,150.00 | $350.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 4th District | Sudler | $0.00 | $2,500.00 |
| TOTAL | $10,800.00 | $14,200.00 | ||
Paj 112
Item #15.
CITY MANAGER’S MONTHLY REPORT
December 2023
Paj 113
Item #15.
Blank
Page
Paj 114
Item #15.
Paj 115
Item #15.
CENTRAL SERVICES MONTHLY REPORT
December 2023
PROCUREMENT & INVENTORY DIVISION
Purchase Orders for Stock by Fund
| FY 2024 to Date | Difference from FY 2023 | |
|---|---|---|
| Electric | $2,075,421.96 | 85.7% |
| Water | $133,852.06 | 69.4% |
| Wastewater | $769.13 | 100.0% |
| General | $86,153.62 | 44.5% |
| Total | $2,296,196.73 | 83.2% |
Issues from Stock by Fund
| FY 2024 to Date | Difference from FY 2023 | |
|---|---|---|
| Electric | $1,201,403.23 | 97.4% |
| Water | $40,383.83 | 98.6% |
| Wastewater | $0.00 | N/A |
| General | $65,138.57 | 89.1% |
| Total | $1,306,925.63 | 97.0% |
Bids/RFPs Solicited
| FY 2024 to Date | Difference from FY 2023 |
|---|---|
| 19 | 63.2% |
Money Spent for Postal Services
| FY 2024 to Date | FY 2023 to Date |
|---|---|
| $88,334.26 | $86,096.15 |
Fuel Usage
| Type | FY 2024 to Date | FY 2023 to Date |
|---|---|---|
| Unleaded | 74,138 | 72,762 |
| Diesel | 40,548 | 41,899 |
| Dollars Spent | $322,443.21 | $274,977.49 |
Paj 116
Item #15.
Warehouse Stock Value
| FY 2024 | FY 2023 |
|---|---|
| $3,235,681.96 | $3,005,104.41 |
Purchase Orders for Stock are up 83.2% compared to this time last year. Issues from Stock are up 97.0% compared to this time last year. Bids/RFP's are up 63.2% compared to this time last year. Postal Expenses are up 2.5% compared to this time last year. Fuel Costs are up 14.7% compared to this time last year. Overall warehouse value is up 7.1% compared to this time last year.
FLEET DIVISION
| PM Work Orders Scheduled: | PM Work Orders | Total Work Orders PM & |
|---|---|---|
| 12 | Completed: 37 | Repair: 130 |
Total Hours Turned: 352 Excess Hours Turned: 0 Time Unaccounted For: 65.3
MEASURE December 2023 December 2022
Completed PM's 37 39
DIFFERENCE -5.13%
There were 12 PM's scheduled for this month. A total of 37 PM's were completed along with 93 repair work orders. There were a total of 130 work orders completed.
Paj 117
Item #15.
FACILITIES DIVISION
Routine Work Orders Emergency Work Orders
Completed: 51 Completed: 1
City-owned Facility Work Events & Support Work Orders: 45 Orders: 7
MEASURE December 2023 December 2022
Completed Work Orders 52 69
DIFFERENCE -24.64%
There were 52 routine and emergency Work Orders completed during this month. The work orders consisted of 45 for maintenance and repair of City-owned facilities and 7 related to events and other support work.
Central Services Narrative The Warehousing & Procurement office continues to see inflated costs and excessive lead times. Vehicle replacements have begun to trickle in as several trucks were received this month. Facilities staff has been busy with routine work orders and holiday preparations. Fleet staff has continued keeping the leaf removal equipment running for the leaf season and prepping snow removal equipment.
Paj 118
Item #15.
CENTRAL SERVICES PROJECT UPDATE
December 2023
FY/PROJECT NUMBER DEPARTMENT STATUS
CENTRAL SERVICES
FC2303 COMPLETE!
CITY HALL WINDOWS
ELECTRIC Stage 1 of install underway
EA2204
WEYANDT HALL HVAC on the 3rd floor.
CENTRAL SERVICES FC2402 COMPLETE! CITY HALL EXTERIOR PAINT
CENTRAL SERVICES Roofing material and doors
CS2405
WASH BAY ROOF & DOORS ordered.
WATER WASTE WATER WTP Engineering plans 90%
WD2409
RENOVATIONS complete.
Paj 119
Item #15.
Recap of monthly activities / notations – As of December 31, 2023 the City of Dover served 24,897 electric utility customers and 13,129 water utility customers as compared to 2022, which represents 24,751 and 13,010 respectively. These figures were tabulated from the monthy utility bill summary report which tracks billing across all utility bill rate classifications. A customer concern was brought to council regarding the enforcement of the clean hands ordinance in November was reviewed. A settlement offer by the customer was declined. The customer has requested to be heard by council again on January 8th. Staff will be attending a trial on January 17th for the collections of a $44,000 debt.
Receivable Comparison FY 2023 to Utility Disconnections for December 2023 FY2024 to date (November 2023) 348 accounts were disconnected for non-payment of service. Compared to the same time last year the City had open receivables of Total receivable collected through the disconnection process $107,806.45 $10,312,625.03 vs $9,430,921.52. Ending Utility Receivable Due - $6,358,783.05
Customer Service Department Mission
Continually provide quality public service to our diverse group of customers with Page 119 professionalism, respect, & integrity. ~ City of Dover Customer Service Department
Paj 120
Item #15.
ASSESSOR’S REPORT
| Number of Deeds Stamped for | Transfer Tax Dollar Amount for | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| the Month of Dec. 2022/2023 | the Month of Dec. 2022/2023 | ||
| 28 27 | |||
| 30 | $200 | ||
| 21 | |||
| 25 | 16 | Thousand | $101 |
| $102 | |||
| $120 | |||
| 20 | 11 | $100 | |
| 15 | 10 | ||
| s | |||
| 4 | $42$20 | $0$0 | |
| 10 | 1 | 0 0 | $16 |
| 5 | 2022 | 2022 | |
| 0 | $0 | ||
| 2023 | 2023 | ||
| First Time Buyer for the Month | Dec. 2022/2023 Realty Property |
|---|---|
| of Dec. 2022/2023 | Sales in Dollars Received Prior to |
| 28 | Recording |
| 27 | |
| 30 | $8 |
| 21 | $7 $7 |
| $8 | $6 |
Millions
| 20 | Res. Non‐First | $6 | $3 |
| $4 | $1 | $0 $0 | 2022 |
| 10 | Time Buyers | $2 | |
| 10 | Res. First Time | $0 | 2023 |
| Buyers | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | |||
| 2022 | 2023 | ||
Major Updates
| October | November | December | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assessment Change | $129,800 | $0 | $4,504,700 |
Residential Sales Ratio Report
| Sales in Study | Total Assessed | Total Sale Price | Ratio | PRD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Value | ||||
| 30 | $4,615,900 | $7,753,700 | 0.60 | 1.00 |
Ratio – Assessed Value divided by Sale Price. PRD – Mean – A PRD above 1.03 tends to indicate assessment regressivity – high valued properties are under appraised relative to low valued properties. A PRD below .98 tends to indicate assessment progressivity – high valued properties are relatively over appraised. 1
Paj 121
012ÿ445ÿ
| 6ÿ4647 | 89 ÿ 9ÿÿ | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1ÿ1 | ÿ | 1ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ | |||
| 8147 | |||||
| 19 | 2BC D8 1 | D29 B 9 | 118D | 1ÿ1 1ÿ | 98Item #15.1 |
| !"#$ $ "# $) ,$ ($$ÿ./012ÿ+3, | $ (! | ( | $"&& < 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ((A (% + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&(A ÿ#!& | |
| !"#% & '# & ,$ ("%ÿ034ÿ51**6ÿ, | $ $& $%)( | ( | (&% < 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ(((A% (% + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&A ÿ#!' | |
| !"#$ ($# $ ,$ )'(ÿ7//+,8.ÿ.,4 | $ $& $%)' | ( | $&! + 9, ÿÿÿÿÿ$&A! " + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ($"A ÿ#! | |
| !"#$) & $$# $" ,$ (&ÿ9,/:ÿ, | $ & $%)( | $ | $"!( < = ÿÿÿÿÿ$%A$ () + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&&!A ÿ#) | |
| !"#( $ !# $ ,$ $$ÿ+/*;:<31ÿ15 | $ $' $%" | $ | $(&( + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$&)A $) + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ(A ÿ# | |
| !"#( & !&#$ ) ,$ '$&ÿ4ÿ=/5,4/,8ÿ15 | $ ) $% | ( | $') < 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$&(A! $( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ(&%A% ÿ# | |
| !)#% ( ('# $& ,$ (ÿ<1+/4ÿ+. | $ $' $%"& | $ | $'' + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$'A! (( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&(A ÿ#') | |
| !)#$ & (# $& ,$ %"ÿ+1,5*ÿ, | $ $' $%!' | $ | $&!) + = ÿÿÿÿÿ$)$A( ( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ()A ÿ#!' | |
| !)#$& $ '#'$ $ , )$ÿ+>1.>1:ÿ+. | $ $& $%)" | ( | $!) < 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$$%A$ ' + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ($A ÿ# | |
| !)#$ & "'# ! ,$ $')ÿ>/0?348ÿ15 | $ & $%)" | $ | $(% + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$$A $' + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&A ÿ#$ | |
| !)#$ ' &)# ! ,$ ("ÿ.1ÿ01,.6ÿ.,* | $ $& ((& | ( | $'') +@ 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$)A( $& + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&%A ÿ#) | |
| !)#$" ( ''# ) ,$ ()ÿ4ÿ8.1.ÿ8. | $ $ $)) | ( | $"!( < = ÿÿÿÿÿ$!(A' $ + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&$A ÿ#( | |
| !)#$) ( !"# " ,$ $)ÿ4ÿ>1*86ÿ, | $ $' $%( | $ | $!' + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$()A! ) + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ(&%A ÿ#' | |
| !)#$% ! %# ! ,$ ''ÿ4/<ÿ>3**ÿ, | $ $ ($" | ( | $%( < 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ(&&A) (( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ'$A ÿ#) | |
| "!#& $ !&# $' ,$ $%ÿÿ8>*,1?ÿ+3, | $ $& (! | ( | $) +@ 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$!&A ) + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ('$A ÿ#!) | |
| "!# ' $#)$( , &!ÿ+/;,.83ÿ, | $ ( $%") | $ | $) + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿÿ'"A! + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$$A ÿ#'$ | |
| "!# ' $#)$( , "'ÿ01,ÿ>154ÿ, | $ ( $%") | $ | $) + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿÿ')A ( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$$)A ÿ#'$ | |
| "!#! ) ()# $" ,$ $($ÿ0,3734?*ÿ, | $ $& $%% | ( | $(! +@ 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$&(A! $ + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$)A ÿ#"' | |
| "!#$ ( '# $! ,$ (&$ÿ:399*34ÿ, | $ $%!& | ( | $) + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ(&A) ( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&&A ÿ#!$ | |
| "!#$ & '&# $! ,$ $'ÿ7//:3**ÿ, | $ ) $%%$ | ( | $'& + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$''A) (( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ(&)A ÿ#!$ | |
| "!#$& & $$# $' ,$ &$&ÿ+>1,,34=ÿ+,/88ÿ, | $ $& $%%) | ( | $)' +@ 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$'&A ( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ('A ÿ#) | |
| "!#$& ' '%# $' ,$ &'ÿ+>1,,34=ÿ+,/88ÿ, | $ $& $%%) | ( | $)' +@ 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$'&A' $% + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ('%A% ÿ#" | |
| ""# & $$# % ,( (&ÿ8ÿ47ÿ8. | ( ) $%( | ( | $"%! + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$&"A) $ + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ((&A ÿ#!( | |
| ""# & ('# % ,' 'ÿ8ÿ=/5,4/,8ÿ15 | ' $ $% | ( | &)) +@ 9, ÿÿÿÿÿ$$A ! + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ()A ÿ#' | |
| ""#$ ( # ( ,$ "&ÿ,35,ÿ, | $ $' $%! | $ | %)) + 9, ÿÿÿÿÿÿ%'A $$ + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$A ÿ#% | |
| ""#$ ( !# ( ,$ )$'ÿ47ÿ+18.*ÿ15 | $ $' $%! | $ | % + 9, ÿÿÿÿÿÿ%'A! (% + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$A ÿ#!& | |
| ""#$" ' "# ' ,$ (!ÿ*/.;8ÿ8. | $ & $%'$ | $ | %)% + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ$')A& (" + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ($A% ÿ#% | |
| )#) & $$# $( ,$ 'ÿ/=7//ÿ+. | $ $! $%! | $ | $%') +@ = ÿÿÿÿÿ$%%A$ ( + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&$A ÿ#!& | |
| )#) & !# $( ,$ &'&ÿ93*,8ÿ=,4 | $ $! $%!! | $ | $! +@ = ÿÿÿÿÿ$"&A& $ + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ()A ÿ#!$ | |
| *+ !)# $ '$# ! ,$ ($&ÿ7>3.ÿ/1?ÿ, | $ $' $%%' | $ | () + 15 ÿÿÿÿÿ()A (% + (& | ÿÿÿÿÿ&(A ÿ#) | |
Paj 122
Item #15. ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT MONTHLY REPORT For the month of December 2023, the Electric Department contributed to the quality of life for all our customers.
The city experienced a system peak of 103.1 megawatts, an increase of 5.8 megawatts from last month and a 2.9 megawatt decrease from the same month last year.
There was a total of 6 outages for the month affecting a total of 2,540 customers with an average outage time of 259 minutes. The large amount of average outage minutes was due to 2,540 customers being without power for 263 minutes. With that large outage taken out, the average outage minutes would fall to 60 minutes.
Project Updates:
The department finalized the contract with Total Wrecking & Environmental for demolition of McKee Run. Projects in Towne Point, Verona Woods, Rojan Meadows, and electric pole testing continued in the city but was slowed due to the holidays. Preparation for FY25 budget submission is ongoing.
Van Sant was not called on for dispatch for the month of December due to the events in November. NAES troubleshot the issue and found bus ducts with severe arcing and tracking, most likely from moisture and weather conditions. All of the buses were removed and shipped out for repair. NAES requested an engineer visit the site for recommendations on how to prevent this from happening again, his recommendations for sealing and conditioning the area to prevent moisture accumulation were implemented.
FY 24 YTD Outages and Response Time:
Total – 53 Average Response Time – 29.57 (Goal – Less than 30 minutes)
Statistics: 3-year average: FY Average:
Average Interruption
Duration Index (SAIDI) 166.9 minutes 51.1 minutes
Goal – Not to exceed 100 mins
System Average Interruption
Frequency Index (SAIFI) 1.7 per cust .509 per cust
Goal – Not to exceed 1 per customer
Customer Average Interruption
Duration Index (CAIDI) 97.789 minutes 100.4 minutes
Lost Time Accidents – Workorders Generated –
Current Month – 0 Total FY – 0 Current Month – 171 Total FY – 1,146
Paj 123
Item #15.
ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT MONTHLY REPORT
FY24
Historical Peak Load
180
160
140
120
100
| Megawatts | 2022 | |||||||||
| 80 | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | ||||||||||
| 60 | ||||||||||
| 40 | ||||||||||
| 20 | ||||||||||
| 0 | ||||||||||
| Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of | ||||||||||
| Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sept | Oct | Nov | Dec |
Paj 124
Item #15.
HUMAN RESOURCES
December 2023
City of Dover Human Resources Mission Statement: The City of Dover’s Human Resources Department strives to provide quality service to assist our greatest asset, our employees. Equity, Integrity, and Urgency is our focus to ensure employee satisfaction as well as company wellness. We implement policies and procedures that align with organizational goals, including a safe and compliant workplace, effective training and professional development, and addressing both the needs of employees and the organization.
City of Dover Human Resources Value Statement:
Innovation: We strive to include best HR practices to enhance a robust technological movement to enhance the quality and efficiency of the department.
Collaboration: We honor knowledge sharing, diversity of thoughts and ideas, and experiences to encourage an inclusive workforce.
Integrity and Transparency: We honor our commitments and promote a healthy environment that promotes fairness, honesty, respect, and trust.
Results Driven: Customer service is front and center, and we advocate for employees and retirees’ needs at all times.
Summary: December Hiring Trends FY24: The month of December shows an average hiring rate of 4 new hires! We are excited to have filled 2 positions that have been vacant for some time, Civil Engineer and FOIA Coordinator!
December Voluntary Termination/Involuntary Termination Trends FY24: In the month of December, we have 1 voluntary termination in the Public Works department.
1|Page
Paj 125
Item #15.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Current City of Dover Ethnicity Breakdown
Current City of Dover Gender Breakdown
Current City of Dover Gender
Breakdown
34%
71%
Male Female
2|Page
Paj 126
Item #15.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Current EEOC Demographics
EEOC Demographics
450
400
108
350 82 88
77
80
300
250
200
150 294 308 312 315 317
100
50
0
Mar '19 Mar '20 Mar '21 Mar '22 December '23
Caucasian Minority
Current Full-Time vs. Part-Time Employees
Five year Full-Time vs Part-Time Employees
500
450
49
| 400 | 31 |
| 24 | 27 |
| 350 | 28 |
300
250
| 200 | 408 | |||
| 346 | 359 | 367 | 373 | |
| 150 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 | ||||
| 50 | ||||
| 0 | ||||
| Mar '19 | Mar '20 | Mar '21 | Mar '22 | December '23 |
Full-Time Part-Time
3|Page
Paj 127
Item #15. HUMAN RESOURCES Numbers do not reflect temporary, seasonal, relief fire dispatchers, committee, or council members. Position Hired: 1 FT Sanitation MEO, 1 FT Civil Engineer, 1 FT FOIA Coordinator, 1 PT Fire Dispatcher Transferred/Promoted: 0 Position Terminated/Resigned/Retired/Other: 1 FT Voluntary Term Terminal Leave: N/A Open or Currently Recruiting* Open or Currently Recruiting by Dept. December 2023
Controller- Treasurer FT Customer Service Clerk I FT Payroll Specialist FT Fire Administrative Manager FT Utility Maintenance Mechanic II (In House FT Planning and Community Development Director FT Parking Enforcement Officer FT Accountant I FT Library Page PT Planner II FT Civil Engineer FT Motor Equipment Operator II – Water & Wastewater FT Human Resources Generalist FT Motor Equipment Operator I – Water & Wastewater FT Financial Reporting & Account Manager FT
Electric Engineer FT
Motor Equipment Operator I FT
Motor Equipment Operator I FT
Police Cadet PT
Relief Fire Dispatcher PT
Total: 17 FT, 3 PT
*Not used for Budgeting Purposes
Turnover Statistics
| 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | |
| Total | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Turnover % | 11.00 | 10.91 | 6.02 | 12.05 | 8.68 | 15.36 | 10.33 | 9.66 | 13.96 | 9.69 | 15.93 | 4.3 |
Termination
Turnover % 0.29 1.47 0.57 0.28 0.54 1.92 1.36 0.54 1.42 .25 1.62 0.9
4|Page
Paj 128
Item #15.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Resignation
Turnover % 5.21 5.01 2.29 7.56 6.24 7.41 5.98 6.17 7.98 7.14 9.01 2.59
Retirement
Turnover % 5.50 4.42 3.15 4.20 1.90 4.39 2.45 2.68 4.27 2.29 1.15 0.44
Other - - - - - 1.65 0.54 0.27 0.28 .25 .23 0.0 2012 Healthcare cost sharing implemented 2013 Healthcare cost sharing implemented for DOE 2016 RIF in Economic Development; 2018 RIF in Electric
Average Employees
| 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | |
| Total Number of | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Employees Separating | 38 | 37 | 21 | 42 | 32 | 56 | 38 | 36 | 49 | 38 | 48 | 24 |
| from Service | ||||||||||||
| Average Number of | ||||||||||||
| 333 | 325 | 331 | 333 | 340 | 337 | 340 | 346 | **355 | 370 | 405 | 443 | |
| Full-time Employees | ||||||||||||
| Average Number of | 25 | 23 | ||||||||||
| 12 | 14 | 18 | 24 | 28 | 28 | 28 | 26 | 28 | 31 | |||
| Part-time Employees | ||||||||||||
| * Healthcare cost sharing implemented **Updated | ||||||||||||
Worker’s Compensation
| November | December | |
|---|---|---|
| Category | 2023 | 2023 |
| Monthly Workers Comp. Injuries | 6 | 2 |
5|Page
Paj 129
Item #15.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Workers Compensation Cost December 2023
$3,889
$3,130
Department
$1,795
$17,141
$3,889
Total Cost (In thousands) = $25,541.65
6|Page
Paj 130
Item #15.
Information Technology Department
December 2023 Report
Larry Josefowski, Director
Network Security (Internal): Work continues improving the security of the network, with replacing some switches and segmenting of the network continuing. We also continue to educate our workers on the latest scams and identity fraud.
Network Security (External): We began the process of adding some additional monitoring tools on the SCADA network. If implemented, it would provide a more in-depth look at the traffic and provide additional warnings of potential threats.
Phone System: The vendor continued to work on switching over some of the remaining lines but had difficulties in working with our provider. Work will continue this into the new year.
Tyler Enterprise ERP: System upgrades continue, with the most significant being the upgrade of IasWorld, which is used in our property tax transactions. This upgrade was done in conjunction with Tyler support, but this program is now more closely integrated with our regular platform, and we’ll be able to do future upgrades with minimal assistance from Tyler.
Training: Plans are underway to use the disturbance created by the HVAC replacement to focus on some training for the team. There are several platforms that we can use, and we want to use both the vendor provided and the contracted training to it’s full advantage.
Other: Our Senior LAN Analyst turned his resignation in at the end of the month. This was our most experienced hardware technician. His loss will be felt, as both other technicians have been here less than 6 months. We anticipate advertising it at the beginning of the new year.
Metrics: IT tracks about 40 metrics, although that number changes as new systems or new ways of tracking data become available. We choose to highlight those that help tell the story of the past month, but more complete reports are available.
# of Tickets/Incidents: This reflects a bit of a bounce-back from the previous month but is still down from our monthly average of 92 incidents a month. The holidays generally keep the number of tickets down, as well. The leading issue we handled was in relation to Tyler, which accounted for about 25% of our incidents.
Time to Close incidents: The decrease in time reflects being fully staffed for the month, and the ability to get the incidents done in a timely manner.
VOIP Phone quality: This is a new metric and reflects the 6 months of data we have on tracking usage of the phone system. 80% is the standard, and we generally have exceeded that over the time. The interesting thing about this data is it allows us to draw down even further, and even though the quality is generally acceptable, we note that our Reed Street building gets the most calls, which as it hosts our Customer Service Call Center, is not a surprise. The lower quality calls may be a result of those calling in on poor cellular connections, or it could indicate a need for local network improvements. We will continue to monitor this over time.
% of Computers Patched: Reports the number of PCs that we have that have the agent that controls patching working properly. We patch all devices on a regular basis, so this is an accurate measure that the environment is getting properly updated.
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY - 1
Paj 131
Item #15.
| # of Tickets/Incidents | Time to close incidents |
|---|---|
| 100 | 12 d 0 h |
| 95 | |
| 90 | 10 d 0 h |
| 85 | 8d0h |
| 80 | |
| 75 | 6d0h |
| 70 | |
| 65 | 4d0h |
| 60 | 2d0h |
| 55 | |
| 50 | 0d0h |
| VOIP Phone Quality | % of Computers patched | |
|---|---|---|
| 95% | ||
| 90% | ||
| 99% | 99% | 99% |
| 85% | ||
| 98% | ||
| 80% | ||
| 97% | 97% | |
| 75% | ||
SEPTEMBER NOVEMBER DECEMBER
JULY
AUGUST OCTOBER
Call Legs quality
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY - 2
Paj 132
Reference Transactions
December 2023 Item #15.
| Adults | 692 |
| Teens | 61 |
Children 103
0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000
- •Electronic Materials include Overdrive & Hoopla starting July 2022
| Circulation | Dec. '23 | FYTD '24 | Dec. '22 | FYTD '23 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City of Dover Residents | 9,189 | 62,358 | 8,170 | 63,254 |
| * Electronic Materials 4,917 30,267 4,287 26,137 | ||||
| Kent County Residents | 8,781 | 57,451 | 5,583 | 43,392 |
| Non-County Residents | 1,206 | 8,011 | 1,120 | 7,493 |
| New Library Registrations | ||||
| City of Dover Residents | 183 | 1,285 | 183 | 1,440 |
| Kent County Residents | 98 | 884 | 80 | 671 |
| Non-County Residents | 6 | 37 | 5 | 25 |
| Registered Library Users as of 12/31/2023 | Registered Library Users as of 12/31/2022 | |||
| City of Dover Residents | 18,297 | 17,089 | ||
| Kent County Residents | 8,076 | 6,578 | ||
| Non-County Residents | 650 | 611 | ||
| TOTAL | 27,023 | 24,278 | ||
| Other | ||||
| Visitors | 12,187 | 85,076 | 12,145 | 78,982 |
| Meeting Room Attendance | 2,891 | 16,921 | 2,205 | 10,928 |
| Number of Computer Users | 1,423 | 10,268 | 1,370 | 9,413 |
| Number of Wireless Computer Users | 1,394 | 9,239 | 1,321 | 8,623 |
| Inter/Intralibrary - Loaned | 32 | 24 | ||
| Inter/Intralibrary - Borrowed | 89 | 70 | ||
| Holds Sent | 2,204 | 2,367 | ||
| Holds Received | 1,510 | 1,491 | ||
| TOTAL | 3,835 | 28,810 | 3,952 | 29,057 |
| Tech Services/Items Added | 1,046 | 630 | ||
| Tech Services/Items Deleted | 1,542 | |||
| 208 | 2,406 | |||
| Passport Services/Customers | 184 | 1,212 | 170 | 1,136 |
| Passport Services/Revenue | $7,181 | $47,699 | $7,070 | $46,351 |
| Monthly Highlights | ||||
| ►269 attended 39 programs for adults. | ||||
| ►130 attended 16 program for teens. | ||||
| ►1,164 attended 29 programs for children. | ||||
| ► 0 volunteers. | ||||
| Program Spotlight | ||||
Paj 133
Item #15.
Parks & Recreation
Monthly Report - December 2023
Parks & RecreaƟon Highlights Five Park Projects Update Dover Park Building and Spray Pad progress con nues. Staff con nues to document progress. All Accessible Playground con nues to be on track. SchuƩe Park Dog Park Completed. We expect to add a dog water fountains this spring. Skate Park in progress as noted in the FY25 CIP list. Progress con nues on the temporary site. Winter Youth Basketball prac ces began, with 272 children making up 28 teams.
John W. PiƩs RecreaƟon Center hosted the City Holiday Luncheon.
Adult Volleyball League playoffs were held with team Smak that Ace winning the season championship.
Indoor Field Hockey Leagues kicked off in December at the John W. Pi s Recrea on Center. Ten Middle School team, six (6) adult co‐ed teams and five (5) adult women’s teams are on the courts Saturday a er‐ noons and all day Sunday. In January, the High School League will kick off with three (3) teams.
Recreation Revenue Breakdown Outdoor Sports & Leagues ParƟcipant & Spectator Count
AcƟvity ParƟcipants Spectators LocaƟon
Moved inside for the winter!
| December 2023 | December 2022 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| General Recrea on | $567 General Recrea on | $1,491 | Dover Park | |
| Trips | $0 | Trips | $540 | |
| Leagues | $1,980 | Leagues | $1,570 | Community Building & Spray Pad |
| Bldg./Field/Pavilions | $0 | Bldg./Field/Pavilions | 0 | |
| Progress ConƟnues…. | ||||
| Sports | $545 | Sports | 0 | |
| Parks & RecreaƟon | FYTD | FYTD |
|---|---|---|
| Dec 23 | Dec 22 | |
| Programs | 24 | 23 |
General Recrea on 256 1,362 235 1,130
Open Gym 125 1,002 131 591
| Sports | 0 | 415 | 0 | 597 |
| Leagues (Inside) | 2,969 | 12,882 | 2,799 | 11,741 |
*Save the Date ‐ Dover Duathlon ‐ April 20, 2024 ‐ Schu e Park* Page 133
Paj 134
Item #15.
Grounds Monthly Report
Dec-23
| Arborist Crew: | Arborist Crew | |
|---|---|---|
| - Trimmed street trees. Tree Work Completed | ||
| - Removed stumps from parks. Tree's Trimmed 13 | ||
| Tree's Removed | 68 | |
| Beautification Crew: | Root Pruning | 0 |
| - General clean up of flower beds and city property. Stumps Removed 46 | ||
| Trees Planted | 0 | |
| Mowing Crew: | ||
| - General clean up of mowing locations. | ||
Litter Removal: - Litter is being picked up on city property as per the weekly schedule. - Litter person has been diligent in the reporting of destruction in City parks. - 178 Total 90 gallon cans collected. Removed 17 Shopping Carts.
Parks Crew:
- Completed parks route daily.
- Worked on holiday decorations.
Miscellaneous: - Cleaned parking lot at City Hall with assistance from the street department. - Meet with Delaware Forest service in regards to a tree on the green damaged by the wind. - Posted and then removed abandoned items left behind in Continental Park.
Paj 135
Item #15.
Trees Trimmed
250
200
150
100
50
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
2021 2022 2023
889 Tree Trimmed in 2023
Trees Removed
80
60
40
20
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
2021 2022 2023
400 Tree Removed in 2023
90 Gallon Litter Cans Collected 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
2021 2022 2023
4,458 Litter cans collected in 2023
Paj 136
Item #15.
City Planner’s Monthly Report
Department of Planning & Inspections
DECEMBER 2023
Planning & Inspections Highlights
Some Items to Call to Your Attention
As the 2023 year came to a close, the month of December activities still involved Department Staff fo- cused on permit and plan reviews and inspections across both the commercial and residential sectors. The overall Permit numbers for permits submitted in 2023 finished slightly below the permit tally for 2022. However, Building Permit Revenue for FY24 is exceeding revenue projections for the fiscal year due to this steady activity in the residential construction sector, ongoing renovation projects in the com- mercial and institutional sectors, and with the start of large projects like the Kent County Family Court- house and Parking Structure. Inspections associated with construction activities for Building, Plumbing, and Mechanical Permits con- tinued with the month of December seeing over 280 inspections completed for these Permit types. Based on the working days in the month, this reflects an average of 14 inspections per day by our Build- ing Inspection team. By month’s end, Certificates of Occupancy were issued to four additional dwelling units completed in the City. The planning for more residential development within the City continued to be strong as the initial step of the construction process saw more applications for residential development submitted for review by the Planning Commission. In December, the Planning Commission granted conditional approvals to a new Apartment Complex (Walker Road Apartments) for 48 units and a Revised Plan for the development of Stonebrook East PND on West Denneys Road for a mix of townhouses and apartments totaling 241 units. Once all Department and agency approvals are granted to these Plans we will see them move into the Building Permit phase and eventually occupied by new City residents. With calendar year 2024 getting ready to begin, the Permits & Licensing Staff was busy in late December preparing the distribution of Renewals for Rental Dwelling Licenses, Lodging House Permits, and Public Occupancy Licenses. These Renewals are mailed to current license/permit holders as the new licensing year begins February 1st (current licenses expire January 31, 2024). The Code Enforcement Staff in December completed a number of Annual Housing Inspections as part of the Rental Dwelling Permit program. There are currently almost 7,900 Rental Dwelling Units within the City. Other Code Enforcement cases focused on exterior property maintenance issues and other Dover Code of Ordinance violations. The Fire Marshal’s Office Staff investigated eight (8) incidents during the month of December. The Fire Marshal’s Office continued its focus on Inspections of hotel and motel facilities before moving onto oth- er business occupancies within the City to confirm compliance. In addition, the Fire Marshal’s Office completed other inspections, plan and permit reviews, and outreach activities.
Paj 137
Item #15.
Planning & Inspections Revenue
FY2024 Revenue
Estimates from FY2024 Actual
Revenue Stream Budget (YTD) December % of Budget
| Business License | $1,450,000 $ | 1,446,967 | 99% |
| Manufactured Home License | $16,000 $ | 12,521 | 78% |
| Building Permits | $450,000 $ | 509,505 | 113% |
| Cert. of Occupancy | $8,000 $ | 5,890 | 74% |
| Public Occupancy | $45,000 $ | 5,925 | 13% |
| Lodging House | $28,000 $ | 100 | 0% |
| Plumbing/Heating/Air | $105,000 $ | 47,652 | 45% |
| Rental Inspection Fee | $750,000 $ | 14,978 | 2% |
| Miscellaneous | $20,000 $ | 10,274 | 51% |
| Fire Protection Fees | $70,000 $ | 49,659 | 71% |
| Code Enforcement Fines | $100,000 $ | 51,121 | 51% |
| Vacant Building Reg. | $70,000 $ | 10,250 | 15% |
Total P&I Revenue $3,112,000 $ 2,164,842 70%
Department Operations—
Planning Office The Meetings of the Boards and Commission supported by the Planning Office are presented in the Hybrid format with both In-Person and Virtual (using WebEx) meeting options for participation. Electronic commu- nications and conducting Meetings and Trainings in virtual formats are commonplace due to realized effi- ciencies. Dawn Melson-Williams (Principal Planner), Tracey Harvey (Planner I/Community Development Manager), Katherine Oehmke (Planner I) attended the Delaware Chapter of the American Planning Association’s Annu- al Meeting & Forum on December 13, 2023. Dawn and Planning Commission members Joan Denney and Mark Reaves attended “Advanced Land Use Law,” a virtual training session presented by the University of Delaware’s Institute for Public Administration. The Planning Office is part of the review process for certain types of construction activity permits (Building Permits, Sign Permits, etc.) and Certificate of Occupancy permits in order to confirm compliance with the Zoning Ordinance provisions. For December 2023, Planning Staff was involved with the review of 38 Build- ing Permits and 11 Certificates of Occupancy permits that were issued for a monthly total of 49 and a year- end total of 1028. The number of permits reviewed in December continued a downward trend as we moved into the winter months. However, the overall calendar year-end tally is slightly higher to the year- end total in 2022 of 992 Permits and COs and significantly higher than the year-end total in 2021 total of 844 Permits and COs. Staff also reviews new applications for Business Licenses and Rental Dwelling Permits.
| DECEMBER 2023 (FY24) | TOTAL FOR FY24 | |
|---|---|---|
| New Home Permits Issued | 0 | 44 |
| Value of Commercial Projects | $1,114,503.00 | $54,382,267.00 |
| Downtown Incentives (Fees Waived) | $12,000.00 (September) | |
| $4083.35 (December) | $26,220.35 |
Paj 138
Item #15. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPLEMENTATION 2019 Comprehensive Plan Implementation of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan continues as Departments citywide focus on the plan im- plementation items as found in Implementation Plan (Chapter 15) items such as the projects, studies, code amendments, and other activities. A copy of the Final Plan (as amended) is available on the Comprehensive Plan website: https://www.cityofdover.com/2019-comprehensive-plan Visit the Dover Parcel and Zoning Viewer on the City’s website to see zoning information for properties located in Dover. Use the Quick Link on the main page www.cityofdover.com. • Each December is the annual opportunity for requests to be made for Amendments to the Comprehen- sive Plan. By the filing deadline of December 15, 2023, there was a Request for Comprehensive Plan Amendment filed requesting a change to the Map 12-1: Land Development Plan Map. These Compre- hensive Plan Amendments 2024 will be submitted for Preliminary Land Use Services Review (PLUS) in January 2024 and will begin its formal review process.
Other Activities • Downtown Dover Strategic Master Plan: The Downtown Dover Partnership’s Strategic Master Plan is known as “Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030” (January 2023). Various partners are focusing on aspects of Plan implementation. The Planning Office Staff Working Group is focused on po- tential ordinance and policy changes for the C-2 zoning district. At the direction of City Council and the Council Committee of the Whole – Legislative, Finance and Administration Committee’s recommenda- tion (of October 24, 2023), Planning Staff worked on drafting the text amendment language for the po- tential revisions to the C-2 zoning district focused on uses, building height, parking, and miscellaneous items. The proposed text amendment will be presented in early January 2024.
CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES
- •In December 2023, a Residential Building Permit was issued for a manufactured home placement in Do- ver East Estates.
- •A Temporary Certificate of Occupancy was issued for a single family detached dwelling on Lotus Street. Certificates of Occupancy were issued to a single family detached dwelling on Oak Drive, a single family detached dwelling in Patriot Village, Phase III area, and to two (2) manufactured home placements in Dover East Estates.
- •Building Permits issued in December were for a new Warehouse Building at 110 Lafferty Lane (S-22-13 Garrison Homes, LLC Warehouse); medical office renovations at Eden Hill Medical Center Building; a building for the Green Beret Project at 76 Stevenson Drive (S-23-08); the sitework for the Bayhealth Staff Parking Lot Expansion at the Scull Property (S-20-10A); a canopy over gas pumps at the Valero on
- •DuPont Highway; and other office renovations.
- •Certificates of Occupancy were issued for Chase Bank at 837 N DuPont Highway (S-22-11); new ware- house/distribution facility for Frito Lay at 300 Lafferty Lane (S-22-02); renovations at 1241 College Park Drive; tenant fit-out for Key to Life Juice Bar at 136 W. Loockerman Street; tenant fit-out for State Farm Insurance Offices in Capital Station; and for interior renovations at Brandywine Counseling & Commu- nity Services office on Bay Road.
Paj 139
Item #15.
2023: Welcome to Dover!
Progress in Pictures
837 N. Dupont Hwy —Chase Bank 50 N. Dupont Hwy Unit 8 at Capital Station — State Farm
136 W Loockerman St—Key to Life Juice Bar 300 Lafferty Lane—Frito Lay
1241 College Park Dr - Office Building by Chang & Sons
Paj 140
Item #15.
2023: Welcome to Dover!
Progress in Pictures
696 Bay Rd
Brandywine Counseling Commercial Renovation
749 Oak Dr
K&J Company
1520 Hopkins Ave -Mast Homes
106 Lotus St—U&I Builders
1061 S. Little Creek Rd
#43 Dover East Estates 1061 S. Little Creek Rd
Manufactured Home #79 Dover East Estates
Manufactured Home
Paj 141
Item #15.
BOARD AND COMMISSION ACTIVITY
There was a December Meeting of one of the Boards and Commissions supported by the Planning Office. The Planning Commission Meeting on December 18, 2023 consisted of review of a Request for Extension, one Site Plan Application, and a Revised Subdivision Plan for a Planned Neighborhood Development Applica- tion. The Board of Adjustment and the Historic District Commission did not meet in December due to lack of agenda items.
Planning Commission: The Planning Commission met on December 18, 2023. The next Planning Com- mission meeting is scheduled for January 16, 2024. The following applications were considered:
- •C-21-08 Royal Farms at 1205 McKee Road - The Planning Commission granted approval of the Re- quest for the One-year Extension of the Planning Commission approval granted on December 20, 2021 for the Conditional Use Site Plan and associated Minor Subdivision Plan Application for construction of a 5,154 SF Retail Store (Convenience Store) and associated fuel pumps. The Application includes asso- ciated site improvements and a 1,248 SF Accessory building to serve as a drive-through Car Wash. The property is currently zoned C-2A (Limited Central Commercial Zone) and is subject to COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The proposed Lot 1 is 2.545 +/ acres (110,854 SF) and is the location of the proposed development. The proposed Lot 2 is 0.870 +/- acres (37,897 SF) and is currently not subject to a design proposal. The Site overall currently consists of 3.415 +/- acres (148,751 SF) and is located at the north- east corner of the intersection of McKee Road and College Road.
- •S-23-22 Walker Road Apartments at Guinn property – The Planning Commission granted conditional approval of the Site Development Application for the construction of two (2) three story, garden style apartment buildings consisting of twenty four (24) units each for a total of 48 units. Also proposed are a clubhouse, parking lot improvements, and three (3) outdoor recreation areas. The property is zoned RM- 2 (Medium Density Residence Zone). The subject site consists of one parcel totaling 6.83 acres +/- lo- cated on the north side of Walker Road and west of Independence Boulevard. The action also included approval of the Active Recreation Area Plan for the project.
- •SB-23-03 Revised Stonebrook East Planned Neighborhood Design at McKee Road and W. Denneys Road The Planning Commission granted conditional approval of the revised Subdivision Plan for this Planned Neighborhood Design project subject to the D.A.C. Comments and along with approval of the requested Alternative Design Standards specified in this proposal. Approval granted to increase the number of townhouses from 87 to 103 townhouses (increase of 16 townhouse units) and to decrease the number of garden apartment units from 168 to 138 garden apartment units (decrease of 30 units). This development known as Stonebrook East Planned Neighborhood Design (PND) proposes 241 dwelling units, recreational areas, open space, and stormwater management areas. The property is zoned RM-1 (Medium Density Residential Zone) and approved as a PND (Planned Neighborhood Design Option). The site is on the northeast corner of McKee Road and W. Denneys Road. Property Address: intersec- tion of McKee Road and West Denneys Road. PND - Alternative Design Standards Requests: Town- house Units – To permit a minimum lot width of 20 feet; establish the building setback from the street at 20 feet, and to change of minimum lot area. Garden Apartments - To permit four (4) stories, a 48- foot building height, and an average thirty five (35) dwelling units per building, and to require 1.5 parking spaces per dwelling unit. Previously the Planning Commission granted conditional approval of a Conditional Use Application C-07-01 for the Conceptual Plan for Stonebrook East Planned Neigh- borhood Design Development on February 20, 2007. Planning Commission also granted conditional approval for the Preliminary Subdivision Plan SB-07-07 for Stonebrook East PND on November 19, 2007 and Final Record Plan approval was given on September 28, 2010. A previous plan for revision of SB-21-05 Stonebrook East PND was never finalized.
Paj 142
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT PROGRAM Item #15.
CDBG FY23 Projects
- •Homeownership Assistance Program CDBG funds will be used to provide homeownership assistance to first-time homebuyers who purchase affordable housing in the City of Dover. Two families have purchased homes and one family will be closing in January 2024.
- •Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing (DIMH) CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for the shelter. DIMH has purchased a building for its new shelter location that will be renovated with CDBG funds. This project is underway. Fifty percent 50% of project funds have been spent year to date.
- •Central Delaware Housing Collaborative CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for a women’s shelter. This project is underway.
- •Milford Housing Homeowner Rehabilitation/Emergency Home Repair Pro- grams CDBG funds will be used to rehabilitate existing owner-occupied housing in the City that are in violation of the City’s Housing Code and complete emergency home repairs to eliminate housing conditions that threaten the health and safety of low-income home- owners. One owner occupied home has been rehabbed, one home is under contract for rehab work to begin, and one home received emergency home repairs.
- •American Rescue Act (ARPA) Funding City Council approved to award a little over $1.8 million in grant funding for Housing and Community Service projects. All projects are underway. A little over $1.4 million or 77% of funds have been spent on Round 1 of ARPA funding year to date. Dover Housing Au- thority, Murphey School, and Reading Assist have completed their projects. ARPA Round 2 funding for a little under $500,000 was awarded to subgrantees in April. Projects are currently underway. Twelve percent (12%) of funds have been drawn down for Round 2 with Murphey School completing their project.
Paj 143
Item #15.
CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY
Dangerous Buildings, Vacant Buildings & Demolitions
Vacant Buildings currently registered - 150 Dangerous Buildings – 64 Active Rental Dwellings – 7,899 Active Demolitions - 207 N West St, 411 W Reed St, 51 Saulsbury Rd & 848 Forest St- (Accessory Structure)
Paj 144
Building Inspections & Licensing Summary Item #15.
July 2022—
July 2023–
Current June 2024 DECEMBER 2022 June 2023
PERMITTING AND LICENSING
| Permits Issued | DEC (2023) | DEC (2022) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY 24 | FYTD 24 | FY23 | FYTD 23 | |
| Administrative Permit | ||||
| 1 | 35 | 3 | 35 | |
| Building Addition/Renovation Permits | 39 | 193 | 29 | 167 |
| Building Permits | ||||
| 8 | 112 | 9 | 147 | |
| Demolition Permits | ||||
| 3 | 19 | 2 | 14 | |
| Fence Permits | 7 | 93 | 9 | 193 |
| Fire Prevention Permits | 10 | 52 | 5 | 32 |
| Mechanical Permits | ||||
| 17 | 145 | 26 | 238 | |
| Plumbing Permits | ||||
| 18 | 148 | 52 | 235 | |
| Sign Permits | 10 | 96 | 6 | 47 |
| Swimming Pool Permits | ||||
| 0 | 6 | 0 | 7 | |
| Subtotal | 899 | 1115 | ||
| Business Licenses | 34 | 1749 | 34 | 1682 |
| Merchant Licenses | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 336 | 26 | 318 | |
| Contractor Licenses | ||||
| 37 | 1204 | 19 | 1110 | |
| Subtotal | 3289 | 3110 | ||
Lodging House Licenses
| 0 | 2 | 0 | 3 | |
| Public Occupancy | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | 100 | 9 | 71 | |
| Rental Dwelling | 11 | 155 | 25 | 143 |
| Subtotal | 257 | 217 | ||
Manufactured Homes 5 263 3 269
BUILDING INSPECTIONS
| Inspections | DEC (2023) | DEC (2022) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| FY 24 | FYTD 24 | FY23 | FYTD 23 |
| Building (Inspections/CBI/Site Meetings) | |||
| 118 | 850 | 28 | 1759 |
| Plumbing/Mechanical | |||
| 152 | 899 | 328 | 2470 |
| Certificate of Occupancy | |||
| 11 | 79 | 18 | 92 |
Paj 145
Item #15.
Fire Marshal’s Office—At a Glance December 2023
The Fire Marshal’s Office staff investigated eight incidents
during the month of December including a significant loss on
Spruance Road.
Staff is completing annual Fire and Life Safety inspections at
hotels and motels and are starting business occupancies.
| Month | Year to Date | Previous Year to Date | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual Fire & Life Safety Inspections | 31 | 162 | 146 |
Deficiencies From the Above Inspections 82 507 676
| Fire Code Violations/Deficiencies/ | 18 | 134 | 147 |
| Complaints | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| C/O & Fire Equipment Acceptance Tests | 6 | 61 | 83 |
Meetings & Walk Through 15 119 102
Fire Plan Review & DAC 15 71 64
Month Year to Date Previous Year to Date Accidental 2 totaling $1,001 19 totaling $1,539,004 24 totaling $363,601
Undetermined 5 totaling $46,002 10 totaling $356,602 1 totaling $75,000
Incendiary 1 totaling $1 2 totaling $2 3 totaling $4,000,002
Natural 0 1 totaling $60,000 0
Arrest Made with DPD 0 0 1
| Investigation Time | 6 | 58 hours | 112 hours |
| Injuries | 1 | 3 | 0 |
Deaths 0 0 1
Paj 146
Item #15.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS DECEMBER 2023 MONTHLY REPORT
GIS
GIS PROJECT HOURS
Create Data Requests Printing Technical Support Updates Configure Training
1%
13%
27%
9%
41%
1%
8%
GIS PROJECT HOURS
Other City-Wide DWW DPW Tax Mayor IT Cust. Service Dover PD City Manager City Clerk Planning & Insp. Library Parks & Rec Electric
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
GIS Project Hours
Paj 147
Item #15.
SANITATION
MONTHLY REFUSE (TONS)
| Bulk | Rear | Automated | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 932.49 | 947.38 | |||
| 875.96 | 853.95 | |||
| 828.39 | 843.85 | 843.51 | 849.42 | 849.97 |
| 830.2 | 816.65 | 804.09 | 817.34 |
| 134.19 | 113.94 | 117.42 | 127.77 | |||
| 85.64 | 120.63 | 101.98 | 113.84 | |||
| 60.86 | 162.61 | 162.42 | ||||
| 85.7 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 71 | ||||||
| 60 | 175.41 | 141.87 | 142.5 | 124.47 | 128.15 | 70.27 |
| 104.93 | 98.65 | 108.22 | 104.91 | 88.4 | ||
| 80.2 | ||||||
DEC 22 JAN 23 FEB 23 MAR 23 APRIL 23 MAY 23 JUNE 23 JULY 23 AUG 23 SEPT 23 OCT 23 NOV 23 DEC 23
SANITATION HOURS
600
543
518
500
425
| 400 | 380 | |
| 328 | 317 | 304 |
| 300 | ||
|---|---|---|
198
200
100
0
Bulk Automated Hand Trash Yard Waste
Dec 2022 Dec 2023
| SANITATION | Dec 23 | FYTD 24 | Dec 22 | FYTD 23 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trips to DSWA Sandtown Landfill | 194 | 1,317 | 198 | 1,247 |
| Total Tonnage to DSWA | 967.01 | 6,523.37 | 995.99 | 6,521.88 |
| 90-gallon Containers Delivered | 46 | 324 | 50 | 355 |
| 300-gallon Containers Delivered | 1 | 4 | 0 | 2 |
| Total Man Hours Containers Delivered | 31 | 159 | 20 | 134 |
| CURBSIDE RECYCLING | TOTAL CANS COLLECTED | TOTAL ACCOUNTS | WEIGHT (LBS) | AVE. WEIGHT (LBS) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| December 2024 | 21,277 | 10,229 | 306,160 | 14.39 |
Paj 148
Item #15.
STREETS / STORMWATER
MONTHLY STREET SWEEPING & LEAF COLLECTION
Sweeper Waste (cu.yd.) Street Sweeping (miles) Leaf Collection (miles) Leaf Debris (cu.yd.)
12
6356.5
817 1220
144
| 1765 | 1234 | 4571 | |
| 12.5 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 470 0 | |||
| 1528 | 1701 | 3855 | |
| 86 | 239 | ||
| 3524 | |||
| 5 | 1201 | 555 | |
| 0 | |||
| 674 | |||
| 47 | |||
| 3279 | 1739.75 | ||
| 2 | 94.5 | 15.5 | |
| 132 | |||
| 1351 | |||
| 0 | |||
| 102 | |||
| 98 | 0 | ||
| DEC | 31 | 1430 | |
| 0 | Leaf Debris (cu.yd.) | ||
| 711 | |||
| 0 | |||
| JAN | FEB | ||
| 100 | 1312 | ||
| 22 | 23 | MAR | |
| 0 | 0 | Leaf Collection (miles) | |
| 23 | APR | 134 | |
| MAY | 1343 | 0 | |
| 23 | 0 | ||
| JUNE | |||
| 0 | 80 | 0 | Street Sweeping (miles) |
| 23 | 23 | JULY | 0 |
| 23 | AUG | ||
| SEPT | |||
| 0 | Sweeper Waste (cu.yd.) | ||
| 23 | 23 | OCT | |
| 23 | NOV | ||
| 23 | DEC | ||
| 23 | |||
| 23 | |||
| STREETS / STORMWATER | December 23 | FYTD 24 | December 22 | FYTD 23 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Signs Installed | 4 | 65 | 0 | 33 |
| 12 | 16 | 83 | 5 | 78 |
| Curbs Painted Yellow (ft) | 4 | 1,675 | 0 | 1,716 |
| New Posts Installed | 7 | 50 | 3 | 49 |
| Storm Catch Basins Repaired | 0 | 2 | 0 | 6 |
| Storm Catch Basin Repairs (hrs) | 0 | 4 | 0 | 16.5 |
| Storm Catch Basins Cleaned (l.f.) | 0 | 6 | 0 | 0 |
| Storm Catch Basin Cleaning (hrs) | 0 | 6.75 | 0 | 2.75 |
| Hot Mix Patching (tons) | 0 | 21.17 | 0 | 31.25 |
| Hot Mix Patching (hrs) | 0 | 23 | 0 | 82.5 |
| Cold Mix Patching (hrs) | 72.5 | 128.15 | 1.25 | 53.50 |
| Concrete Work (hrs) | 0 | 87 | 0 | 224 |
| Concrete Patching (cu.yd.) | 0 | 14.87 | 0 | 39.18 |
| Ditch Work (hrs) | 0 | 20 | 0 | 4 |
| Street and Alley Maintenance (hrs) | 0 | 23 | 0 | 8 |
| Street Sweeping (miles) | 0 | 4,796 | 12 | 3,302.5 |
| Street Sweeping (cu.yd.) | 0 | 412 | 2 | 471.5 |
| Leaf Collection (miles) | 3,524 | 9,080 | 3,177 | 3,762 |
| Leaves Collected (cu.yd.) | 4,571 | 12,667.25 | 1,765 | 8,087 |
Paj 149
Item #15.
CITY OF DOVER
DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER
MONTHLY REPORT
Dec-23
Inflow & Infiltration Costs
$180,000.00
This chart indicates the amount of money the City is
| $160,000.00 | spending on treating ground and / or rain water |
| through Kent County. This cost is being offset by the | |
|---|---|
| $140,000.00 | Ground Water Inflow Adjustment rate passed on to |
| $120,000.00 | the customers. |
$100,000.00
$80,000.00
$60,000.00
$40,000.00
$20,000.00
$-
I & I Cost
Water & Wastewater Repairs
| 7 | Water mains and services are typically repaired at a higher |
| rate when drastic change in temperature occurs. This freeze | |
|---|---|
| 6 | and thaw cycle expands and contracts the soil, causing cracks |
| in the water line. November 2023 had large fluctuations of | |
| 5 | temperature, causing a large volume of repairs. |
4
3
2
1
0
Water Mains Repaired Water Services Repaired Wastewater Mains Repaired Wastewater Laterals Repaired
Paj 150
Item #15.
CITY OF DOVER
DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER
MONTHLY REPORT
Dec-23
Number of Brown Water Complaints
20
This chart indicates the number of
| 18 | complaints the Department receives. |
| 16 | October and April on this chart are high |
| due to the flushing operation. | |
|---|---|
| 14 | |
| 12 | |
| 10 | |
| 8 | |
| 6 | |
| 4 | |
| 2 | |
| 0 | |
Number of Brown Water Complaints Linear (Number of Brown Water Complaints)
Department Spotlight - December
The Department of Water & Wastewater is required, as part
of the 1996 Safe Drinking Water Act, to provide an annual
water quality report.
Paj 151
Item #16.
Paj 152
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
This page intentionally left blank
PagePage
2 152
Paj 153
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
CITY OF DOVER
ACTIVITY REPORTS
December 2023
| FY23 YTD | FY24 YTD | |
|---|---|---|
| BANK TRENDS | ||
| Number of Deposits Made (Hand, ACH & Wire, Lockbox) | 3,302 | 3,377 |
| Total Amount of All Deposits | $ 126,793,465 $ 90,878,950 | |
| Other Activity | ||
| Number of Pay Periods | 14 | 11 |
| Number of Direct Deposits Issued | 5,789 | 5,366 |
| Number of Pension Checks Issued | 1,597 | 1,558 |
| Total Pension Benefits Paid - Defined Benefit Plan $ 3,046,982 $ 3,061,214 | ||
ACCOUNTS PAYABLE
| Number of Check Vouchers | 3,174 | 3,754 |
| Number of EFT Vouchers | 1,670 | 2,149 |
| Vouchers Dollar Amount Disbursed | $ 50,980,272 | $ 51,190,738 |
| FY23 YTD Wages | $25,911 | |
| FY24 YTD Wages | ||
|---|---|---|
| $55,243 | ||
| $59,273 $49,276 | $464,095 | |
| $126,9 | $502,205 | $254,298 |
| 47 | ||
| $455,503 | ||
| $417,312 | ||
| $1,019,329 | ||
$1,163,193
$1,108,310 $1,153,292
| $10,450,140 | $11,418,125 |
| Regular | Regular |
All over time All over time
Vacation Vacation
Sick Sick
Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout
Personal Personal
Comp Time Comp Time
Other Other
Other includes: pay adjustments, military differential pay, training, committee meetings, worker compensation tracking/adjustments, etc.
PagePage
3 153
Paj 154
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
City of Dover
General Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (December 2023)
Revenues
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Property & Transfer Taxes | $ 18,056,100 | $ 18,056,100 $ | 17,223,624 | 95% |
| Program Revenues | 12,354,700 | 12,354,700 | 7,536,646 | 61% |
| Utility Transfers | 9,000,000 | 9,000,000 | 4,500,000 | 50% |
| Grants | 883,500 | 883,500 | 443,396 | 50% |
| Interfund Services | 6,236,400 | 6,236,400 | 2,224,005 | 36% |
| 1 | 4,066,000 | 4,221,000 | 1,983,658 | 47% |
| All Other | ||||
| $ 50,596,700 | $ 50,751,700 $ | 33,911,329 | 67% | |
| Expenditures | ||||
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |
| Program Expenses | $ 34,903,300 | $ 34,890,200 $ | 15,547,785 | 45% |
| Interfund Services | 12,177,000 | 12,177,000 | 5,645,088 | 46% |
| Debt Service | 630,700 | 630,700 | 315,056 | 50% |
| Post Retirement Benefits | 2,548,000 | 2,548,000 | 1,274,000 | 50% |
| Pension Fund Contributions | 1,000,000 | 1,000,000 | 250,000 | 25% |
| Capital Project Transfers | 2,920,100 | 2,947,100 | 1,460,050 | 50% |
| 2 | 3,052,800 | 3,052,800 | 1,093,584 | 36% |
| All Other | ||||
| $ 57,231,900 | $ 57,245,800 $ | 25,585,563 | 45% | |
1 Includes Cable Franchise Revenue, Miscellaneous Receipts, Garrison Farm Rent, Sales of Assets, Fund Invest Manager Cost. 2 Includes Bank and CC Fees, Street Lights Expense, DDP Contribution, Trf to Cable Franchise Reserve, Trf to Electric I & E, and Trf to Electric Revenue Fund, Trf to Uncollectible Reserve and Misc. Grant Expense and Trf to Economic Development Reserve Fund.
PagePage
4 154
Paj 155
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
General Fund Revenues
$20,000,000
$18,000,000
$16,000,000
$14,000,000
$12,000,000
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$- Property & Transfer Taxes Program Revenues Utility Transfers Grants Interfund Services All Other 1
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
General Fund Expenditures
$40,000,000
$35,000,000
$30,000,000
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$15,000,000
$10,000,000
$5,000,000
$-
Program Expenses Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Benefits Pension Fund Contributions Capital Project Transfers All Other 2
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
PagePage
5 155
Paj 156
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
City of Dover
Water Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (December 2023)
Revenues
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Sales | $ | 6,550,000 | $ | 6,550,000 $ | 3,543,569 | 54% |
| Impact Fees | 225,000 | 225,000 | 126,708 | 56% | ||
| Rents | 435,500 | 435,500 | 435,588 | 100% | ||
| Miscellaneous 1 | 75,200 | 75,200 | 179,401 | 239% | ||
| $ | 7,285,700 | $ | 7,285,700 $ | 4,285,266 | 59% |
Expenditures
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Program Expenses | $ | 4,156,100 | $ | 4,156,100 $ | 1,693,406 | 41% |
| Interfund Services | 1,138,000 | 1,138,000 | 406,107 | 36% | ||
| Debt Service | 700,000 | 700,000 | 316,442 | 45% | ||
| Post Retirement Benefits | 226,900 | 226,900 | 113,450 | 50% | ||
| Capital Project Transfers | 1,536,700 | 1,536,700 | 768,350 | 50% | ||
| Electric I&E Fund Transfer | 25,000 | 25,000 | - | 0% | ||
| General Fund Transfer | 500,000 | 500,000 | 250,000 | 50% | ||
| All Other 2 | 32,000 | 32,000 | 10,673 | 33% | ||
| $ | 8,314,700 | $ | 8,314,700 $ | 3,558,427 | 43% |
1 Includes Penalties, Income from Sale of Assets, Miscellaneous Income, and Reconnect Fees. 2 Includes Bank & CC Fees.
PagePage
6 156
Paj 157
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
Water Revenues
$7,000,000
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$-
Customer Sales Impact Fees Rents Miscellaneous 1
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Water Expenditures
$4,500,000
$4,000,000
$3,500,000
$3,000,000
$2,500,000
$2,000,000
$1,500,000
$1,000,000
$500,000
$-
Program Expenses Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Benefits Capital Project Transfers Electric I&E Fund Transfer General Fund Transfer All Other 2
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Paj 158
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
City of Dover
Wastewater Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (December 2023)
Revenues
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Sales | $ 10,326,000 | $ 10,326,000 $ | 5,348,268 | 52% |
| Impact Fees | 225,000 | 225,000 | 116,575 | 52% |
| Miscellaneous 1 | 50,200 | 50,200 | 179,802 | 358% |
| $ 10,601,200 | $ 10,601,200 $ | 5,644,644 | 53% |
Expenditures
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Program Expenses | $ 1,649,200 | $ 1,649,200 $ | 702,301 | 43% |
| Kent County Treatment Fee | 4,730,000 | 4,730,000 | 1,729,994 | 37% |
| Interfund Services | 870,900 | 870,900 | 309,533 | 36% |
| Debt Service | 696,200 | 696,200 | 300,780 | 43% |
| Post Retirement Benefits | 110,000 | 110,000 | 55,000 | 50% |
| Capital Project Transfers | 2,270,900 | 2,270,900 | 1,135,450 | 50% |
| Electric I&E Transfer | 25,000 | 25,000 | - | 0% |
| General Fund Transfer | 500,000 | 500,000 | 250,000 | 50% |
| All Other 2 | 15,000 | 15,000 | 3,322 | 22% |
| $ 10,867,200 | $ 10,867,200 $ | 4,486,381 | 41% |
1 Includes Interest Income, Penalties, Loss on Disposal, and Miscellaneous Income. 2 Includes Bank & CC Fees.
PagePage
8 158
Paj 159
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
Wastewater Revenues
$12,000,000
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$-
Customer Sales Impact Fees Miscellaneous 1
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Wastewater Expenditures
$5,000,000
$4,500,000
$4,000,000
$3,500,000
$3,000,000
$2,500,000
$2,000,000
$1,500,000
$1,000,000
$500,000
$-
Program Expenses Kent County Treatment Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Capital Project Transfers Electric I&E Transfer General Fund Transfer All Other 2 Fee Benefits
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Paj 160
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
City of Dover
Electric Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (December 2023)
Revenues
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Sales | $ 92,743,400 | $ 92,743,400 $ | 44,865,817 | 48% |
| 1 | 2,299,000 | 2,299,000 | 2,676,314 | 116% |
| All Other | ||||
| $ 95,042,400 | $ 95,042,400 $ | 47,542,130 | 50% | |
Expenditures
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Power Supply & Generation | $ 82,658,600 | $ 82,856,900 $ | 23,587,171 | 28% |
| Electric Operating Div. Exp. | 9,208,700 | 9,208,700 | 4,407,767 | 48% |
| Interfund Services | 4,227,500 | 4,227,500 | 1,508,365 | 36% |
| Debt Service | 1,482,600 | 1,482,600 | 700,850 | 47% |
| Post Retirement Benefits | 997,000 | 997,000 | 498,500 | 50% |
| General Fund Transfer | 8,000,000 | 8,000,000 | 4,000,000 | 50% |
| 2 | 3,004,900 | 3,004,900 | 997,525 | 33% |
| All Other | ||||
| $ 109,579,300 | $ 109,777,600 $ | 35,700,178 | 33% | |
| 1 | ||||
| Includes Rental Revenue, Miscellaneous Service Revenue, Interest Earnings, Investment Management Fees, | ||||
| New Service Fees, Sale of Assets, Trf from Uncollectible Reserves, General Service Billing, Revenue from Rate | ||||
| Stabilization, Penalties, Green Energy Charges, and Delay Damages. | ||||
| 2 | ||||
| Includes Utility Tax, Interest on Deposits, Bank & CC Fees, Bond Issuance Costs, Transfer to Uncollectible | ||||
| Reserve, and Green Energy. | ||||
| Megawatt Hours Sold & Purchased | Budget | Rev. Budget | Actual |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales to Customers MWh (excl. Street Light MWh) | 760,876 | 760,876 | 321,529 |
| Sales per MWh | $119.74 | $119.74 | $137.33 |
| Purchased/Generated MWh | 773,010- | 773,010- | 340,292- |
| All In MWh Supply & Generation | $106.87 | $107.12 | $69.26 |
Page Page
10 160
Paj 161
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
Electric Fund - Revenues
Millions
$- $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 $70 $80 $90 $100
Original Budget
Revised Budget
Actual
Customer Sales All Other 1
Electric Fund - Expenditures
$90,000,000
$85,000,000
$80,000,000
$75,000,000
$70,000,000
$65,000,000
$60,000,000
$55,000,000
$50,000,000
$45,000,000
$40,000,000
$35,000,000
$30,000,000
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$15,000,000
$10,000,000
$5,000,000
$-
| Power Supply & | Electric Operating Div. | Post Retirement | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interfund Services | Debt Service | General Fund Transfer | All Other 2 | ||||
| Generation | Exp. | Benefits | |||||
| Original Budget | $82,658,600 | 9,208,700 | 4,227,500 | 1,482,600 | 997,000 | 8,000,000 | 3,004,900 |
| Revised Budget | $82,856,900 | 9,208,700 | 4,227,500 | 1,482,600 | 997,000 | 8,000,000 | 3,004,900 |
| Actual | $23,587,171 | 4,407,767 | 1,508,365 | 700,850 | 498,500 | 4,000,000 | 997,525 |
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Page Page
11 161
Paj 162
Item #16.
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023
City of Dover
Division Expense Summary (General Fund)
Fiscal Year to Date (December 2023)
| Original Budget Revised Budget | Actual | % | General Fund Divisions % of Budget | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Clerk | $ | 414,200 $ | 414,200 $ | 179,369 | 43% | |||
| Council | 260,000 | 260,000 | 117,357 | 45% | Mayor | |||
| Fire | 851,600 | 851,600 | 393,789 | 46% | Human Resources | |||
| Grounds | 1,741,100 | 1,741,100 | 840,906 | 48% | Customer Services | |||
| Library | 2,040,700 | 2,040,700 | 920,222 | 45% | ||||
| Fleet Maintenance | ||||||||
| Recreation | 1,549,600 | 1,549,600 | 729,988 | 47% | ||||
| Procurement & Inventory | ||||||||
| Life Safety | 690,600 | 690,600 | 300,139 | 43% | ||||
| Code Enforcement | 1,173,600 | 1,173,600 | 336,081 | 29% | Engineering | |||
| Planning | 826,100 | 826,100 | 298,082 | 36% | Facilities Management | |||
| Public Inspections | 800,800 | 800,800 | 346,964 | 43% | Pub. Services Administration | |||
| Police | 21,550,900 | 21,523,900 | 9,913,990 | 46% | Finance | |||
| Police Extra Duty | 405,000 | 405,000 | 304,113 | 75% | ||||
| Information Technology | ||||||||
| Streets | 768,600 | 782,500 | 329,130 | 42% | ||||
| Sanitation | 3,060,100 | 3,060,100 | 1,261,635 | 41% | City Manager | |||
| Stormwater | 906,400 | 906,400 | 268,588 | 30% | Stormwater | |||
| City Manager | 1,300,100 | 1,300,100 | 628,285 | 48% | Sanitation | |||
| Information Technology | 874,100 | 874,100 | 394,171 | 45% | Streets | |||
| Finance | 1,032,300 | 1,032,300 | 350,084 | 34% | ||||
| Police Extra Duty | ||||||||
| Pub. Services Administration | 646,900 | 646,900 | 293,577 | 45% | ||||
| Police | ||||||||
| Facilities Management | 822,100 | 822,100 | 382,786 | 47% | ||||
| Engineering | 279,300 | 279,300 | 145,028 | 52% | Public Inspections | |||
| Procurement & Inventory | 873,600 | 873,600 | 439,045 | 50% | Planning | |||
| Fleet Maintenance | 1,078,600 | 1,078,600 | 564,687 | 52% | Code Enforcement | |||
| Customer Services | 1,417,500 | 1,417,500 | 655,022 | 46% | ||||
| Life Safety | ||||||||
| Human Resources | 501,300 | 501,300 | 182,249 | 36% | ||||
| Recreation | ||||||||
| Mayor | 245,200 | 245,200 | 111,472 | 45% | ||||
| $ 46,110,300 $ 46,097,200 $ 20,686,797 | 45% | Library | ||||||
| Grounds | ||||||||
| Fire | ||||||||
| Council | ||||||||
| City Clerk | ||||||||
| 0% | 10% | 20% | 30% | 40% | 50% | 60% | 70% | 80% |
Page Page
12 162
Paj 163
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023 Item #16.
City of Dover
Utilities Expenditure Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (December 2023)
Water Divison
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engineering & Inspection | $ | 386,500 | $ | 386,500 $ | 135,261 | 35% |
| Water Department | 862,100 | 862,100 | 336,824 | 39% | ||
| Water Treatment Plant | 2,907,500 | 2,907,500 | 1,221,320 | 42% | ||
| $ | 4,156,100 | $ | 4,156,100 $ | 1,693,406 | 41% |
Wastewater Divison
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engineering & Inspection | $ | 304,100 | $ | 304,100 $ | 70,055 | 23% |
| Wastewater Department | 1,345,100 | 1,345,100 | 632,247 | 47% | ||
| $ | 1,649,200 | $ | 1,649,200 $ | 702,301 | 43% |
Electric Division
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Transmission/Distribution | $ | 4,893,100 | $ | 4,893,100 $ | 2,373,023 | 48% |
| Electrical Engineering | 1,826,600 | 1,826,600 | 785,098 | 43% | ||
| Administration | 1,020,200 | 1,020,200 | 510,497 | 50% | ||
| Meter Reading | 460,500 | 460,500 | 274,356 | 60% | ||
| Systems Operations | 1,008,300 | 1,008,300 | 464,793 | 46% | ||
| $ | 9,208,700 | $ | 9,208,700 $ | 4,407,767 | 48% |
Paj 164
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023 Item #16.
Water Division % of Budget
Water Treatment Plant
Water Department
Engineering & Inspection
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45%
Wastewater Division % of Budget
Wastewater Department
Engineering & Inspection
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50%
Electric Division % of Budget
Systems Operations
Meter Reading
Administration
Electrical Engineering
Transmission/Distribution
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Paj 165
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023 Item #16.
City of Dover
Capital Outlay Summary (All Funds)
Fiscal Year to Date (December 2023)
| General Fund | Original Budget Revised Budget | Actual | % | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fire | $ | 419,600 $ | 419,600 $ | 184,430 | 44% |
| Code Enforcement | 34,600 | 63,600 | 42,369 | 67% | |
| Public Works Admin | 30,000 | 30,000 | - | 0% | |
| Public Works Eng | 48,300 | 48,300 | 41,322 | 86% | |
| Police | 1,186,500 | 1,347,500 | 385,661 | 29% | |
| Streets | 852,300 | 3,665,600 | 225,050 | 6% | |
| Sanitation | 707,800 | 1,464,400 | 32,313 | 2% | |
| Stormwater | 1,135,000 | 3,389,600 | 120,600 | 4% | |
| Grounds | 214,500 | 249,300 | 236,160 | 95% | |
| Library County Grant | - | 87,300 | 57,365 | 66% | |
| Recreation | 835,000 | 2,900,600 | 797,438 | 27% | |
| Inspections | - | 30,100 | 30,068 | 100% | |
| Purchasing | - | 70,000 | - | 0% | |
| Information Technology | 115,500 | 115,500 | 16,312 | 14% | |
| Facilities Management | 80,000 | 159,300 | 76,249 | 48% | |
| Fleet Maintenance | 30,000 | 535,700 | 124,566 | 23% | |
| General Fund Capital Projects | $ | 5,689,100 $ 14,576,400 $ | 2,369,903 | 16% |
Water Fund
| Water | $ | 4,579,300 $ | 6,093,000 $ | 703,517 | 12% |
| Water Engineering | 48,000 | 48,000 | 41,322 | 86% | |
| Water Treatment Plant | 56,500 | 423,300 | 113,237 | 27% | |
| Water Fund Capital Projects | $ | 4,683,800 $ | 6,564,300 $ | 858,076 | 13% |
Wastewater Fund
| Wastewater | $ | 2,576,900 $ | 4,428,600 $ | 318,616 | 7% |
| Wastewater Fund Capital Projects | $ | 2,576,900 $ | 4,428,600 $ | 318,616 | 7% |
Electric Fund
| Electric Generation | $ | 275,000 $ 12,723,400 $ | 242,823 | 2% |
| Transmission/Distribution | 2,497,400 | 2,936,100 | 998,759 | 34% |
| Electrical Engineering | 2,076,000 | 8,544,700 | 646,624 | 8% |
| ERP System | - | 1,856,000 | 2,860 | 0% |
| Electric Administration | 2,000,000 | 2,500,000 | 687,500 | 28% |
| Electric Fund Capital Projects | $ | 6,848,400 $ 28,560,200 $ | 2,578,566 | 9% |
TOTAL CAPITAL PROJECTS $ 19,798,200 $ 54,129,500 $ 6,125,161 11%
Paj 166
Finance Department Monthly Report December 2023 Item #16.
Capital Outlay - All Divisions
$14,000,000
$12,000,000
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$-
Original Budget Revised Budget Actual
Capital Outlay - By Fund
$30,000,000 $28,560,200
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$14,576,400
$15,000,000
$10,000,000
| $6,848,400 | $6,564,300 | |
| $5,689,100 | ||
|---|---|---|
| $4,683,800 | $4,428,600 | |
| $5,000,000 | ||
| $2,576,900 | $2,369,903 | $2,578,566 |
| $858,076 | $318,616 | |
| $- | ||
| Original Budget | Revised Budget | Actual |
General Fund Capital Projects Water Fund Capital Projects Wastewater Fund Electric Fund Capital Projects
Paj 167
Item #17.
DOVER FIRE DEPARTMENT
December 2023
FIRE CHIEFS REPORT
Paj 168
Item #17.
Mayor and Council, During December, the Dover Fire Department responded to 143 calls for service of 858 personnel hours. Members performed 12 hours of training consisting of 108 personnel hours. Operation Santa was a huge success! Firefighters traveled over 700 miles throughout the fire district, consisting of 280 personnel hours. Total personnel hours for December 1,246. Crews responded to the following serious incidents: Building Fires House Fire – Phoenix Drive House Fire – Spruance Road
Motor vehicle accidents
Hopkins Avenue – MVC with Entrapment
1121 Forrest Avenue – MVC with Entrapment
SAFER Grant (recruitment) We have recently hired a marketing company for our recruitment and retention SAFER grant program. The Fire Department and the marketing company will be working together to recruit new members soon. Ladder 2 The Ladder 2 Replacement Committee will be going for final inspection on January 23, 2024.
City Hall The 20-year County/Municipal Police /Firefighter State Pension Plan was approved by the pension board on November 17th.
Fire Company Treasurer Terry Whitham and Lori Peddicord are working on the financing for the new ladder truck. The Fire Chief is working with Lori Peddicord on finalizing the documents for the 20-year pension plan for fire department employees.
The Fire Administrative Manager Position is posted; we plan to interview for the position the week of December 18th.
The Fire Chief attended:
City Council Meeting
Dover Fire Department Company meeting
Kent County Fire Chiefs Meeting
Dover Fire Department Officer Training
Paj 169
Item #17.
Paj 170
Item #17.
Paj 171
Item #17.
Paj 172
City of Dover Item #18.
Police Department
Monthly Report
december 2023
Paj 173
CITY OF DOVER DEPARTMENT OF POLICE Item #18.
400 SOUTH QUEEN STREET DOVER, DELAWARE 19904 302-736-7111
Chief of Police Police Captains
THOMAS A. JOHNSON, JR. RANDY ROBBINS
Deputy Chief of Police KEVIN KOBER
DAVID E. SPICER AARON DICKINSON
February 12, 2024
Honorable Robin Christiansen, Mayor
Members of Dover City Council
City Hall
Dover, DE 19901
Mayor Christiansen and Council Members:
The following is the monthly report of Dover Police Department activities for December:
COMPLAINTS/EVENTS
YTD Totals compiled through December numbered 43,211.
This represents an increase of 2,768 from the 40,443 reported over the same period in 2022.
| 50,000 | 41,580 | 43,211 | ||
| 39,908 | 40,443 | |||
| 40,000 | 33,513 | |||
| 30,000 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20,000 | ||||
| 10,000 | ||||
| 0 | ||||
| 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 |
CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS
Burglary: 4 cases reported, 2 cases cleared and 5 cases were cleared from previous months.
Robbery: 2 cases reported, 2 cases cleared and 1 case was cleared from previous months.
Sex Assault: 6 cases reported, 1 case cleared and 0 cases was cleared from previous months.
Homicide: 2 case reported, 2 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous months.
There were 9 Non-Criminal Death Investigations, 9 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous months. 1
Paj 174
Item #18.
DRUG, VICE, & ORGANIZED CRIME / STREET CRIMES UNIT ENFORCEMENT
Marijuana: 7,814.27 grams seized Cocaine: 52.91 grams seized Ecstasy: 0 doses seized Prescription Pills: 0 doses seized Heroin: 979.64 grams seized Methamphetamine: 697.26 grams seized Fentanyl: 0 grams seized Other Rx Drugs: 0 grams/doses seized Drug Proceeds: $7,819.00 seized
FIREARM SEIZURES/INSIDE CITY LIMITS
15
10
4
| 5 | 2 | 1 | ||||||
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 0 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CI | DVOC/STREET CRIMES | PATROL | SEU | |||||
HANDGUN RIFLE SHOTGUN
Firearms: 6 Handguns & 1 Shotgun
TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT
YTD Citation Totals compiled through December numbered 6,755.
This represents an increase of 970 from the 5,785 reported over the same period in 2022.
| 10,000 | 9,353 | |||
| 9,000 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7,807 | ||||
| 8,000 | ||||
| 6,755 | ||||
| 7,000 | ||||
| 5,785 | ||||
| 6,000 | 5,182 | |||
| 5,000 | ||||
| 4,000 | ||||
| 3,000 | ||||
| 2,000 | ||||
| 1,000 | ||||
| 0 | ||||
| 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 |
TRAFFIC CRASHES: YTD = 2,303
2
Paj 175
Item #18.
911 CENTER ACTIVITY
Total compiled during December numbered 7,079 calls.
This represents a decrease of 424 from the 7,503 reported during the same period in 2022.
8,200 8,060
8,000
7,800
7,600 7,503
7,400
7,200 7,079
7,043
7,000
6,812
6,800
6,600
6,400
6,200
6,000
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
CITY ORDINANCE SUMMONS
YTD Totals compiled through December numbered 2,029.
This represents a decrease of 1,732 from the 3,761 reported over the same period in 2022.
| 6,000 | 5,280 | ||||
| 5,000 | 4,097 | ||||
| 3,568 | 3,761 | ||||
| 4,000 | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3,000 | 1,889 | 2,029 | |||
| 1,714 | |||||
| 2,000 | 1,030 | 890 | 1,037 | ||
| 1,000 | |||||
| 0 | |||||
| 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | |
| ISSUED | 5,280 | 3,568 | 4,097 | 3,761 | 2,029 |
| PAID | 1,889 | 1,714 | 1,030 | 890 | 1,037 |
3
Paj 176
COMMUNITY POLICING Item #18.
This proactive unit takes the lead on community engagement and supporting our community organizations. They have administrative responsibilities and also support other departmental units, such as patrol, during times of high work volumes or special operations with enforcement activities. In addition to those duties, the unit accomplished the following in December:
Covered the Motor Unit with prosecution of traffic offenses in court Assist the Police Academy with Active Shooter Training / Crisis Negotiation training Participated in the Downtown Dover Partnership meeting Provided tour of HQ for local Cub Scout organizations Participated in the Kent County Crime Watch Meeting Worked with Habitat for Humanity on Hometown Holiday Event Engagement of Homeless individuals behind the Kohl’s property Participated in activities in support of the Ronald McDonald House Participated in the Dover Christmas Parade Assisted Patrol Units during major incidents, high 911 call volume and/or low staffing (Occurred at a much higher rate this month due to staffing challenges) Training events included SORT members monthly obligations & Tactical Medical education The BHU made contact with 51 individuals and took official action to provide services to 15 of them. 12 were mental health supports and 3 were substance abuse referrals.
Members of the CPU attend numerous meetings with community associations and organizations as a part of our ongoing liaison relationships.
CHIEF’S ADVISORY COMMITTEE
The Police Chief’s Advisory Committee (PCAC) is comprised of nine (9) diverse stakeholders living/working in the City of Dover. It meets regularly to provide input/feedback to the Chief on the various operations of the agency.
The Committee met on December 7th as scheduled. The Committee continued to study the path to establishing the existing body as the official City of Dover Advisory Board to become compliant with the recently passed Act. The topic will continue to be revisited in meetings as the COPT continues to evolve into the POST Commission and more guidance is available. Several members will be attending a meeting with the Mayor and interested stakeholders on this topic in early January.
As has been established custom, municipal elected officials do not serve on the Committee. Now that Ms. Hall is a declared candidate for US Congress, she will be stepping away until her campaign is over. She is certainly eligible to return in the future should her status change.
The Chief provided an overview of the mechanisms of “due process” in police disciplinary matters. This included appeal hearings on Administrative violations as well as consideration of Officer Certification at the State level.
PROGRAMS AND INITIATIVES
Dover PD was credited with having one of the top recruiting videos in the country as noted by Police1.com in their nationwide contest to identify the best in the nation. We enjoyed great 4
Paj 177
support throughout the month while our stakeholders voted for the Dover video. While it is Item #18. unfortunate that we were not declared the winner, we were extremely honored to be nominated for the recognition. The pride that our officers have in being part of Dover PD certainly came through in the recruiting video and was probably the biggest reason we became a national finalist. We thank everyone who voted for us and I want to thank the team for being a “First Class” group.
The Department is happy to announce that Corporal Strovenscolv LaRochelle has returned from his military deployment overseas. He has been away from us for approximately a year while serving our country as a member of the Delaware Army National Guard. His regular duty for the DPD was serving in the Community Policing Unit when he was called to deploy. After catching him up on some past due training requirements, and some reorientation, he will return to Community Policing as we move into 2024.
With our continued focus on firearms-related criminal cases, we managed to make it to mid- December before we suffered a firearms-related fatality. That death was part of a series of three events occurring during the month of December. Through aggressive investigation, and through the aid of top notch technology, a suspect was identified and arrested to bring justice to the four individuals victimized by the gunman. For complete details, the special press briefing is available on the DPD YouTube channel for review. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cymDk8mJ00I
From a staffing perspective, our Planning and Training office conducted another “How to Succeed” seminar in advance of our January assessment day. We still have quite a number of open police positions and a continued shortage of qualified applicants. On the civilian side, we were able to get the Emergency Communications Center back to full staff when a candidate accepted the offer to fill the last open spot in the Unit. We are hopeful that the recent hires will make it through training and orientation as a full staffed center is key to our larger array of mission objectives. A big thank you is due to the members of the Administrative Division for their many months of effort to get this accomplished.
Please visit our website at www.doverpolice.org for up to date information on crimes and activities in the City of Dover.
Respectfully Submitted,
Thomas A. Johnson, Jr.
Chief of Police
5
Paj 178
Item #20.
City of Dover
MAYOR AND COUNCIL
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-01
| 1 | A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING SIGNATURES FOR BANKING SERVICES ON |
| 2 | BEHALF OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE. |
3 WHEREAS, the City of Dover's investment policy includes the investment of funds up to $100,000 4 per banking institution, investments in the State of Delaware Investment Pool, and the purchase and 5 sale of investment grade corporate bonds, and U.S. Treasury and agency securities; and
6 WHEREAS, the banking institutions, brokerage firms, trust companies, and other various 7 financial institutions require an Authorizing Resolution for the opening of accounts, and for 8 purchasing, selling, transferring, assigning, and handling securities;
9 WHEREAS, by the Mayor and Council of the City of Dover, that the Controller/Treasurer 10 and Assistant Treasurers are hereby authorized to open accounts with banking institutions and 11 purchase, sell, transfer, assign, and handle securities, and that they are authorized to sign all 12 related forms;
13 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and Council of the City of 14 Dover, that the Controller/Treasurer and Assistant Treasurers are hereby authorized to 15 open accounts with banking institutions and purchase, sell, transfer, assign, and handle 16 securities and that they are authorized to sign all related forms;
17 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the transactions in these accounts be carried out 18 with any one signature; and
19 That the following are the office holders authorized for these purposes, until further notice:
| 20 | Patricia M. Marney | Interim Controller/Treasurer |
| 21 | Melanie S. Patterson | Assistant Controller/Treasurer |
| 22 | Andria L. Bennett | Assistant Treasurer |
| 23 | Arielle M. Rivera | Assistant Treasurer |
| 24 | ADOPTED: |
| 25 | ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN | WILLIAM F. HARE |
| 26 | MAYOR | COUNCIL PRESIDENT |
| 27 | Actions History |
| 28 | 02/12/2024 - Introduction - City Council |
P.O. Box 475 ❖ Dover, Delaware ❖19903
Community Excellence Through Quality Service Page 178
Paj 179
Item #21.
FIRST READING
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-05
| 1 | BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN |
| 2 | COUNCIL MET: |
| 3 | |
|---|---|
| 4 That Chapter 106 – TRAFFIC AND VEHICLES, Article I – IN GENERAL, be amended by inserting | |
| 5 the text indicated in bold, blue font and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows: | |
| 6 | |
| 7 | Section 106-17 – Truck routes. |
| 8 | |
| 9 (a) Except as hereinafter provided, no commercial vehicle having three or more axles shall be | |
| 10 | operated on any street in the city except on a “truck route”. |
| 11 (b) The following roads are designated as “truck routes” within the city: | |
| 12 | (1) U.S. Route 13; |
| 13 | (2) Bay Road; |
| 14 | (3) Governors Avenue; |
| 15 | (3) Saulsbury Road; |
| 16 | (4) Dover-Kenton Road; |
| 17 | (5) Persimmon Tree Lane; |
| 18 | (6) Delaware Route 1; |
| 19 | (7) Scarborough Road; |
| 20 | (8) McKee Road; |
| 21 | (9) South Little Creek Road; |
| 22 | (10) Leipsic Road; |
| 23 | (11) Denny’s Road |
| 24 | (12) Delaware Route 8; |
| 25 (13) North Street (from Mifflin Road to Saulsbury Road South Governors Avenue); | |
| 26 | (14) POW/MIA Parkway; |
| 27 | (15) White Oak Road.; |
| 28 | (16) Hazlettville Road; |
| 29 (c) This section shall not apply to any commercial vehicles with three or more axles: | |
| 30 (1) Making a local delivery to or a pickup from a place in the city incapable of being | |
| 31 directly accessed from a designated “truck route”. The driver must have available | |
| 32 | proof of intended place of delivery or pickup and: |
| 33 a. If entering the city limits, the driver shall use the most direct practical route | |
| 34 | from a designated truck route to and from the delivery or pickup, and |
| 35 b. If originating from within the city limits, the driver shall use the most direct | |
| 36 practical route to and from the place of delivery or pickup within the city and/or | |
| 37 the most direct practical route to a designated “truck route” if going outside the | |
| 38 | city limits. |
| 39 (2) Owned by or leased to the city or any volunteer fire company or emergency response | |
| 40 organization when engaged in official business, including, by way of example, those | |
| 41 vehicles of any fire department or any police department or agency, or to any town or | |
| 42 | state public works department or agency. |
| 43 (3) Owned by, leased to, or operated by any public utility company (or its subcontractor) | |
| 44 | while engaged in public utility operations. |
| 45 (4) Garbage and solid waste haulers in the course of their business operations. | |
Paj 180
Item #21. Proposed Ordinance #2024-05 Amending Chapter 106 - Traffic and Vehicles Page 2
46 (5) Operated on any city street officially designated as a detour route where such vehicle 47 could otherwise be lawfully operated upon the street for which such detour is
| 48 | established. | |
| 49 | ||
|---|---|---|
| 50 | ||
| 51 | ||
| 52 | ADOPTED: | * |
| 53 | ||
| 54 | ||
| 55 | SYNOPSIS | |
| 56 This ordinance updates the current truck routes within the city. Additional roads have been constructed | ||
| 57 within the city limits that were designed for truck traffic. Other streets within the city are residential in | ||
| 58 nature and do not provide a proper safety environment for the trucks and residents. | ||
| 59 | (SPONSORS: ANDERSON) | |
| 60 | ||
| 61 | ||
| 62 | Actions History: | |
| 63 | 02/12/2024 - Scheduled for First Reading - City Council | |