Ale nan kontni prensipal la
AskDover

Regular Council Minutes and Exhibits 1-3

City Council Meetings. 12 out 2024.

Louvri PDF la (1.3 MB)

Yo rale tèks sa a nan PDF la otomatikman, epi li ka gen erè. PDF la se dosye ofisyèl la, kidonk tcheke l anvan ou konte sou sa a.

Paj 1

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING

The Regular City Council Meeting was held on August 12, 2024, at 7:03 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Council members present were Mr. Hare, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Arndt, Mr. Rocha, Dr. Sudler (in at 6:24 p.m.), and Mr. Lewis (in at 6:28 p.m. and out at 8:11 p.m., in at 8:13 p.m.)

Staff members present were Police Chief Johnson, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Marney, Ms. Melson- Williams, Chief Carey, Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Mayor Christiansen was also present. (out at 7:02 p.m. and in at 7:19 p.m.)

OPEN FORUM

The Open Forum was held at 6:20 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Council President Anderson declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.

Belinda Main expressed her concerns, noting that she has perceived some childish behavior and cowardice from council. She shared that, although she has observed various communities within the City of Dover and interacted with many constituents, she has never seen any council members in those districts. This absence worries her, as homeowners frequently approach her, inquiring if she knows anyone on the council who can address their issues. Ms. Main highlighted her concerns about speeding, trash, and the inability of residents to play outside without the fear of a shooting or a drive-by occurring.

Stanley Richardson, Lincoln Park, stated that he is with a neighborhood watch. He expressed concern about the residents of 822 North Street, noting that there are trailers set up in the backyard. He mentioned that he has put up 'No Trespassing' signs, but the individuals have run over the signs while working on cars late at night. Mr. Richardson noted that they had also been throwing alternators and brake shoes into the field, and he suspected that they had been trying to damage his lawn mower when he mowed the yard. He emphasized that something needs to be done about the trespassing and the repeated knocking down of his signs.

Responding to Mr. Richardson, Dr. Sudler stated that he has seen him several times and that council has been championing his concerns for several years. Dr. Sudler noted that he has an open-door policy.

Alfreda Fisher Dean, 728 Bicentennial Boulevard, wanted to personally thank Mr. Boggerty for getting her stereo. She was concerned with a letter that she had received from the City of Dover about a $250 Goodwill credit applied to her utility bill for the loss of her stereo equipment when a transformer blew. She felt humiliated by this because it made her feel like she could not afford her electric bill.

Robert Duncan, The Grande 55 Plus Community, stated that his concern is with the wave of car thefts in the parking lot at the Grande apartments. He explained that there have been several incidents of car windows being broken, thefts from vehicles, and even thefts of the vehicles

Paj 2

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 2

themselves. They have contacted the community policing team and spoke with Corporal Reo, Corporal Amichi, and Corporal La Rochelle. They have set up a crime watch and have a patio patrol where they encourage people to go on their patio after dark to check their surroundings. Mr. Duncan expressed concerns and requested that a Dover patrol car from West Dover occasionally check the parking lot downtown, noting that this would provide reassurance for the residents of The Grande. He mentioned that the property management has been exploring various improvements, including fencing, lighting, cameras, and online monitoring. Additionally, he asked if there could be a way to shield the identity of seniors who call the police department, perhaps by using a crime watch number or a similar system. This, he believes, would make residents feel less intimidated to report issues and ensure their identity does not appear on the police report.

Janet Schroer, 103 West Drive, wanted to discuss the Watcher’s Association. Whenever a situation occurred, they could call the dispatcher, give them their number and they would respond immediately. She wanted to discuss the possibility that maybe they could do that with the dispatchers for the people who live at The Grande Apartments. This would be for the people, and they could have certain dispatchers they could contact when there is a problem. Ms. Schroer suggested setting up a system where residents could identify themselves with a code, such as “Black Watcher number 25,” when reporting issues. She also expressed a desire for increased police presence, with officers regularly driving around the community.

Nigel Mason, 41 South New Street, has established a group called the House of Pride Neighborhood Watch. Some of his concerns are street lighting and public trash cans. Several locations around his neighborhood need more streetlights and more public trash cans from the loitering.

Jonathon Berry expressed concerns about the poor lighting on New Street and its impact on the safety of children. He stated that issues such as pedophilia and human trafficking are occurring in the area. Mr. Berry emphasized that it is their responsibility to ensure the area remains nice, neat, well-maintained, and safe.

Bishop Marion Lott, Sr., Executive Director of The House of Pride, requested assistance in keeping the streets clean and advocated for the placement of additional trash cans to ensure that debris is properly disposed of.

Kimberly Schlichting, President and CEO of the Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) expressed her pleasure that the City of Dover has rejoined DEMEC. She wanted to extend a personal invite to the Annual Dinner on September 18th where they will be discussing energy transition, and where federal and state policies would be taking them. As well as what they are going to do with utilities and to try to look out for the community and the customers while protecting costs to them. This year they will be having a panel of four (4) where they are going to have the President of the American Public Power Association come and talk about what he is seeing across the country about national energy regulations.

Mr. Anderson expressed his gratitude to the new Neighborhood Watch group for their report. He commended their efforts and requested information on their next meeting so he could attend.

Paj 3

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 3

Additionally, Mr. Anderson mentioned that he and Dr. Sudler are preparing for a town hall meeting in Lincoln Park next month and are eager to address the issues on the agenda.

Dr. Sudler noted that Mr. Boggerty is the representative at-large if one of the council members is not available, they can contact him, as well.

INVOCATION

The invocation was given by Elder Ellis B. Loudon.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Councilman Rocha.

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried unanimously.

ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA

All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.

Mr. Neil requested that Item #9 be removed from the consent agenda and to defer the City Manager’s Report to September.

Mr. Lewis requested the removal of Item #13, the appointment of Ronald Coburn to the Board of Adjustment, from the consent agenda.

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda as amended. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

RESOLUTION NO. 2024-12 – ENACTING A MORATORIUM ON ANY PROGRAM
REQUIRING BACKFLOW PREVENTERS
The City Clerk read the following Resolution into the record:

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:

WHEREAS, in January 2021, the Delaware Department of Public Health adopted regulations encouraging the implementation of backflow preventers, but the requirements were not mandatory, except for those declared to have high-risk of backflow; and

WHEREAS, in June 2024, the majority of the Delaware House of Representatives voted to amend the City of Dover Charter to repeal the City of Dover Department of Water & Wastewater requirements for backflow preventers, sending a message to the City of Dover to review the requirements; and

Paj 4

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 4

WHEREAS, the Kent County Association of Realtors has presented cases of small businesses with no real risk of backflow being asked to retrofit at the cost of thousands of dollars with no benefit to the environment; and

WHEREAS, these requirements will have a contradictory impact on the City of Dover’s adopted goals of reclaiming empty storefronts and the building for economic expansion; and

WHEREAS, there will be ongoing costs to the City of Dover for inspections that will seriously impact the city budget in the long run; and

WHEREAS, there has not been a proper review of the new requirements by the City of Dover City Council.

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED:

The City Council does hereby enact a moratorium for one year on any program requiring backflow preventers within the City of Dover, Delaware, excepting those deemed moderate or high risk by state regulations explicitly requiring backflow regulators, subject to the following stipulations and conditions:

  • 1.This moratorium shall become effective immediately upon adoption by the City Council of the City of Dover, Delaware; and
  • 2.All current and future enforcement, notifications, and requirements in process regarding backflow preventers are suspended for one year, and any penalties shall neither be assessed in any pending cases except for those deemed high risk according to state and local regulations or auxiliary water systems; and
  • 3.Before any program can be implemented after this moratorium, it must be presented to the Utility Committee and passed by the City Council of the City of Dover; and
  • 4.The City of Dover requests staff to work with members of the General Assembly to permanently address the regulations that led to the City of Dover’s regulations.

ADOPTED: August 12, 2024

Andria Bennett, City Clerk, read three (3) emails supporting Resolution No. 20224-12. (Exhibits #1-3).

Mr. Boggerty stated that he had discussed the backflow preventer project with Senator Trey Paradee. He wanted to ensure that the overseeing company was legitimate, certified, and qualified. Mr. Boggerty expressed concern about the company's credibility, noting that their address appeared to be non-existent. While he does not wish to make definitive claims, he requested that the research and moratorium include a thorough verification of the overseeing company's trustworthiness.

Paj 5

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 5

Mr. Rocha, a trustee of the Dover Christian Church, reported that they received a letter and followed up with a phone call to a real person. He was directed to a local contact or someone from Southern New Jersey who typically handles backflow inspections for fire suppression systems. The church paid the company for their services, and the report was uploaded to the tracking company. Mr. Rocha noted that, based on previous discussions, the company appeared to be reputable.

Mayor Christiansen clarified that the backflow prevention devices and the annual testing are required for buildings that have boiler systems and fire suppression systems. He explained that these systems must be documented with the City of Dover Fire Marshal’s office and the State of Delaware and inspected by licensed fire sprinkler contractors. He emphasized that the process involves the appropriate authorities.

Mr. Neil moved for the adoption of Resolution No. 2024-12. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of July 22, 2024, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Ms. Arndt, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen.

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT OF – JULY 23, 2024

The Council Committee of the Whole met on July 23, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Hare, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury (via WebEx), Mr. Rocha, and Mr. Sudler. Mr. Lewis was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Shevock (via WebEx), and Mr. Garfinkel (Legislative, Finance, and Administration). Dr. Jackson-Short, Ms. Smack (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation), and Mr. Iriowen (Utility) were absent.

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.

SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE

The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairman Boggerty presiding.

Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Rocha moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Hare and
unanimously carried.

Paj 6

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 6

Discussion – City of Dover Emergency Operations Plan (Kay Sass, Public Affairs and Emergency Management Coordinator) Ms. Kay Sass, Public Affairs and Emergency Management Coordinator, reviewed the background of the Emergency Operations Plan.

Staff recommended approving staff to send the City of Dover Emergency Operations Plan to the State of Delaware for acceptance of the 2024 Updated EOP.

Mr. Rocha moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

Mr. Boggerty moved for adjournment of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:04 p.m.

UTILITY COMMITTEE

The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Ms. Arndt moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Possible Moratorium on Any Program Requiring Backflow Preventers (Council President David L. Anderson) Mr. David L. Anderson, Council President, reviewed the background to the Proposed Resolution No. 2024-12 and the memorandum written by Mr. Neil (Attachment #1).

Staff recommended forwarding Resolution No. 2024-12 to City Council with a recommendation of approval.

Mayor Christiansen stated that the single-feed water supplies that fed building sprinkler systems were made out of scheduled pipe which contained a silicone lining so that the pipe would not rust away. The original intent of the backflow prevention device was to keep water from the sprinkler system from leaching back into the potable also known as drinking water supply. He explained that the legislation requiring everyone to put backflow prevention devices on systems other than sprinkler systems, which is required by the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), is a severe overreach. He stated that unless the potable water system feeds not only the drinkable, unusable water in a household but also when it supplies a closed heating system or something similar, it has been shown that

Paj 7

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 7

domestic backflow prevention devices are usually not effective. Particularly in the case of the City of Dover, the water is cleaned and treated. Furthermore, Mayor Christiansen stated that another overreach by the state was when they required fluoride to be added to the water, in combination with chlorine, which was a federal mandate, and in turn created the current water in the City of Dover. He explained that the current water is not dangerous but the water before the state and federal mandates was pristine. In closing, Mayor Christiansen expressed support for the moratorium.

Mr. Sudler expressed support for the moratorium. He explained that it is extremely difficult to obtain the required backflow prevention mechanism and inspection report currently being required because there is a lack of agencies certified to conduct that type of inspection. He stated that the agencies that are certified to do the inspection are not in the vicinity of the City of Dover. Since many plumbing agencies do not have the certification, it has become alarming for businesses. Mr. Sudler stated that a restaurant business reached out to him and explained that the plumbing agencies they contacted could not perform the inspection. They were concerned about not complying within the allotted timeframe and facing a penalty. Mr. Sudler recommended educating the business owners, merchants, and private sector, as to why the backflow preventers are important and who is certified to complete the work if the requirement is implemented after the moratorium.

Ms. Arndt stated that she believes there is some flexibility in the state regulations regarding public water supplier requirements and recommends that the city determine what is best for Dover, its business owners, and its citizens. She also expressed her support for the moratorium, allowing the city to review the requirements thoroughly and make the best decisions moving forward.

Mr. Rocha explained that as the trustee that handles the church building that he is a part of they were fortunate that the building was built in 2017, so the fire suppression system was new. He noted that although he missed the deadline, he did not receive a fine and was able to complete the necessary work. He recommended creating a list of the companies certified to do the inspection and placing the information on the City of Dover website. He also stated that the letter has an 800 number that can be called and they will refer one or two companies in the area. He explained that they were fortunate to have a company that services their sprinkler system qualified to do the inspection and completed it during a normal inspection. In closing, Mr. Rocha recommended compiling a list of qualified inspectors to make it easier to find someone to complete the inspection within 90 days when the time comes.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson stated that the moratorium would be effective for one year from the date of adoption, which would likely be August 12, 2024, if adopted.

Paj 8

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 8

Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Rivera stated that the City Clerk’s Office had received several emails in support of Resolution No. 2024-12 (Attachment #2).

Mayor Christiansen stated that backflow prevention devices under the NFPA code are required to be tested annually. He explained that he believes the same requirements are intended for both the residential and business ones as well. He recommended after the moratorium, clarifying that the NFPA regulations on sprinkler systems are still in effect and a report is to be filed with the City of Dover Fire Marshal as well as the State of Delaware Fire Marshal.

Mr. Rocha moved to recommend forwarding Resolution No. 2024-12 to City
Council at the next City Council meeting with the recommendation of
approval for a moratorium of one year. The motion was seconded by Mr.
Anderson and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:20 p.m.

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Garfinkel moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Update on State Pension (Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director) Ms. Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director, briefed council on the status of joining the State Pension Plan.

Ms. Poole explained that the city manager had drafted a resolution letter of interest with an effective date of January 1, 2024, however, the effective date was later revised in another resolution letter with an effective date of July 1, 2024. The effective date of July 1, 2024, was then changed to October 1, 2024, but the resolution letter was never completed requesting an October date, therefore the State of Delaware Pension Office currently has the effective date of July 1, 2024.

Ms. Poole stated that in terms of the next steps, the city needs to make two policy- related decisions. She explained that the next step will be to decide if all employees will automatically be placed in the pension or if employees will be given a choice to either join the pension to include a city match or stay in their

Paj 9

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 9

current 401(k), 457 plan with an included city match. She further explained that a concrete effective date would also need to be established to move forward. The board has already approved two previous date revisions and changing the dates can present approval issues with the board.

Ms. Poole stated that the easier option would be if everyone were placed into a pension, which seems to be the standard practice per the state. She explained that Human Resources would need to identify an exclusions list that would incorporate a list of current employees who are in the General Employee Pension Plan, along with a list of active employees. If the second option were chosen, which may be more taxing, they would also need to identify an exclusion list that would incorporate a list of current employees who are in the General Employee Pension Plan and the employees who wish to remain in the 401(k), 457 plan, as well as a list of active employees. In closing, she stated that once a final option is chosen then a complete resolution letter with a new effective date can be sent to the State of Delaware Pension Office for board approval. She also included that the list of names can be sent at a later date.

Committee Action Not Required.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Poole stated that from a timeline perspective, they would need to establish an effective date so that Human Resources can gather the information required and send it to the pension office.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Poole stated that in order to build the exclusion list Human Resources would need to speak to every employee and have them sign a form stating that they would like to be excluded from the pension plan. She explained that this would prevent anyone from being able to say that they were not included in the process, or that their name was forgotten.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Poole stated that per the state, the only buy-in option that can happen is if the city buys all the employees into the plan. The employees cannot pull from their 401(k), 457 with the hopes of buying into the plan. She explained that it could happen, but it would cost the city a lot.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Poole stated that she is unsure whether there is a cap to the amount that someone can put into their 401(k) under the pension plan but she could investigate that. She also stated that they plan to create a Q&A for the employees.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Poole stated that if the city chooses the pension plan the match for the 401(k) and 457 would remain the same.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Poole stated that she was told during previous discussions that implementation would not have any negative budget effects and that it would be a wash.

Paj 10

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 10

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Poole stated that all new employees would automatically go into the state plan.

Mr. Neil moved to allow staff to move forward to figure out what additional information is necessary from the employees for council to take action. The motion was seconded by Mr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Poole stated that developing a policy of what they plan to do would be very helpful. She explained that having an effective date in mind would also be helpful in the planning process. Ms. Poole reiterated that they need to decide if they are going to automatically place the employees in the pension plan or if they are going to give them the option to stay in the 401(k), 457 plan, and, or go into the pension plan. Then they must select an effective date that they stick with so that it may be presented to the pension board.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Poole stated that the timing will be dictated by the option that is selected by council.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Poole stated that once a decision has been made then she can help figure out what the effective date needs to be. She also noted that the finance team will need to be included in order to prepare a new pension plan for the city.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Poole stated that while a decision is not immediately necessary, they need to collectively consider the decision and involve Mr. Hugg in the process.

The motion to allow staff to proceed with determining what additional information is needed from employees for the council to take action was rescinded by Mr. Neil and Mr. Sudler.

Mr. Rocha thanked Ms. Poole for bringing council up to date and stated that they will wait for Mr. Hugg to return to collectively come up with a plan and decision.

Discussion – Mayoral Compensation Mayor Christiansen expressed appreciation for the remuneration that council provided the mayor's office. He explained that it is not the money that he appreciates but the fact that council recognized the growing responsibilities that the Mayor of the City of Dover has for economic development and public safety. He explained that he is dedicated to being the voice of those who have no voice and works each day to make sure that the city is a great place to live, work, and play, just as the members of council. He requested that council consider freezing any additional remuneration until after the April 2027 election. In closing, he asked that any future increases for either the Mayor’s Office or the Mayor be by a unanimous vote of council as he feels it would be in the best interest of the next mayor, and the citizens that they serve.

Paj 11

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 11

Committee Action Not Required.

Mr. Neil recognized the mayor's desire to defer any increase until after the next election, however, he noted that council faces the same problems as employees. He explained that those problems are the ever-increasing costs caused by inflation. Mr. Neil recommended tying the mayor's remuneration to what is done for the Dover Organization of Employees (DOE), as is done for the council members. He explained that delaying the remuneration becomes a two-part thing. One is the delay for the mayor because he does not want it currently. However, Mr. Neil feels that the office should go up because the office deserves the same type of increase that the other employees are getting, including the members of council.

Mr. Neil moved to delay the increase for the mayor at his request until the next election and then tie in what the employees are receiving. The motion was seconded by Mr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mayor Christiansen stated that Mr. Sudler's clarification was correct. Council honored him with the $5,000.00 increase but he is asking that there be no further increases until after the next election.

Mr. Neil moved to recommend delaying any further increases for the mayor, at his request, until after the next election, and tie any future increases to what the employees are receiving. The motion was seconded by Mr. Sudler and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:06 p.m.

Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:06 p.m.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

MONTHLY REPORTS – JUNE 2024

By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Ms. Arndt, the following monthly reports were accepted by consent agenda:

City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
City Manager’s Report
Controller/Treasurer’s Budget Report

Paj 12

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 12

Police Chief’s Report

During the Council meeting. Ms. Marney explained to Mr. Neil that the stipulated value resembles the Wild Meadows, MHC situation, where they had attended a Board of Assessments meeting, discussed the value with the Board and their Assessor, and reached an agreement. She indicated that the likely amount is $11,113,200, rather than $11,113,020. Ms. Marney added that she was not present at the meeting and did not have specific details on why the value was reduced but promised to follow up with an answer.

Mr. Neil made a motion to defer the City Manager’s Report to September, seconded by Ms. Arndt, and carried unanimously.

APPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY MAYOR CHRISTIANSEN

Planning Commission Michael W. Lewis – Third District - Three-Year Term to Expire June 2027

By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Ms. Arndt, the Planning Commission Board appointment was accepted by consent agenda.

Board of Adjustment
Ronald L. Coburn, Jr. – Three-Year Term to Expire July 2027

During the Council meeting. Mr. Lewis requested that the item be pulled from the discussion to make a motion regarding it.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Rodriguez stated that he was not aware of any requirement that would prevent an employee from holding a job right after their termination. He noted that ethical considerations apply to individuals with strictly confidential information, and these would pertain to such a person. However, he is not aware of any specific code or charter provision restricting reemployment under these circumstances. Mr. Rodriguez explained that the code prohibits former employees or officials from disclosing confidential information or using it to influence official duties. This restriction applies to those who had access to confidential information, ensuring that they cannot materially affect matters related to their former position.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mayor Christiansen stated that he appreciated him looking into this but wanted to assure members of council that in his effort to appoint members to the committees, he brings talent. He looks for talent that would help the city that has prior knowledge. Mayor Christiansen noted that this was not the first time that a former city employee had been asked to serve on a committee. He explained that Mr. Coburn, with his years of experience, would be a valuable asset to the Board of Adjustment. He has thoroughly vetted Mr. Coburn’s qualifications and his ability to serve effectively. Mayor Christiansen stated that he carefully considers each appointment, emphasizing that his responsibility is to the city's citizens and the council to ensure that the necessary jobs are effectively carried out.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Rodriguez stated that there has been no change to Section Five (5) of the Charter, which stipulates that no former city council member may hold a compensated

Paj 13

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 13

appointed office or employment with the city until one (1) year after their council term ends unless a waiver is granted by the Board of Ethics.

Mr. Lewis made a motion to approve the Board of Adjustment appointment of Ronald Coburn, seconded by Mr. Neil, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

APPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT ANDERSON

By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Ms. Arndt, the following appointments were accepted by consent agenda.

City of Dover Employee Liaisons
Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt
Councilman Andre M. Boggerty
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.

Utility Committee Glen D. Wilson – Appointed by Council President to fill the unexpired term of Michael Pugh – term to expire May 2025

TENTATIVE LABOR CONTRACT WITH AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY, AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES (AFSCME) Mr. Hugg briefed members on the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME).

Mr. Hare moved to adopt the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Contract, seconded by Mr. Rocha, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

DEPUTY CITY SOLICITOR - LIAM N. GALLAGHER

Mr. Rodriguez, City Solicitor, briefed members on the potential appointment of Mr. Liam Gallagher as the new Deputy City Solicitor.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rodriguez stated that both the Deputy City Solicitor and he are compensated by the City of Dover at a rate of $245 per hour.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg clarified that Mr. Gallagher is not an employee of the City of Dover but rather an employee of Schmittinger & Rodriguez, the city's designated law firm. He explained that Schmittinger & Rodriguez bills the City of Dover for the time served by all firm members, with payments made monthly based on an invoice.

Dr. Sudler expressed concern that providing taxpayer dollars to the deputy solicitor implied that the position was filled without a competitive posting. He pointed out the ambiguity surrounding the matter and indicated that, due to this lack of clarity, he would be abstaining from voting.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rodriguez stated that according to the charter, the Deputy City Solicitor must be appointed and the requirement for the Solicitor is that they must be a member

Paj 14

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 14

of the Delaware Bar for five (5) years. There are no requirements for the Deputy Solicitor. He further explained that appointing a Deputy Solicitor from another law firm would not be feasible in his opinion because the charter designates him as the one who oversees the duties of both the Solicitor and the Deputy Solicitor, who must take instructions from him. He believes that managing instructions to an attorney from another firm would be problematic and emphasized that this is the way the charter is structured and should be followed.

Responding to Mr. Rodriguez, Dr. Sudler expressed his preference for having someone not from Mr. Rodriguez’s firm work with him. He suggested that having an individual from a different firm might alleviate concerns about potential conflicts of interest and retaliation, as he serves the firm in multiple capacities. Dr. Sudler noted that, in his view, the charter only requires the Deputy Solicitor to be a practicing professional and does not specifically mandate that the individual be from the same firm as the Solicitor. He did not see any indication in the charter that implies or asserts a requirement for the Deputy Solicitor to come from the same firm.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Rodriguez stated that Mr. Gallagher passed the bar a year and a half ago and has accumulated two (2) years of actual experience, including a year and a half as a licensed lawyer. He noted that Mr. Gallagher has worked with four (4) different municipalities, including the City of Dover before passing the bar exam, which provided him with substantial experience in municipal law. Mr. Rodriguez affirmed that Mr. Gallagher is fully qualified.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Rodriguez indicated that he was unsure of the exact date when Mr. Gallagher passed the bar exam, but he believes Mr. Gallagher is currently in his second year since becoming licensed. He noted that Mr. Gallagher had relevant experience as a law clerk and while working with his firm prior to passing the bar. Mr. Rodriguez suggested that if further discussion about qualifications is needed, he would propose a motion to go into executive session.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson clarified that according to the code, the only mention of the Deputy Solicitor is that the Deputy must be an attorney at law entitled to practice in Delaware. The Deputy’s duties are to be determined by the City’s Solicitor as necessary and proper. He explained that while the city primarily relies on one general law firm, there are also specialized firms for various functions, such as bond counsel, planning and zoning, environmental issues, and utilities. These specialized firms provide complementary services rather than competing with the general legal advice provided by the primary law firm. Mr. Anderson noted that the code outlines the Solicitor’s role, which includes attending council meetings, advising in writing when requested, prosecuting or defending suits involving the city, enforcing city ordinances, and preparing contracts. This indicates that while there is a general legal function provided by the Solicitor, there are also specialized functions covered by other firms.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Rodriguez stated that specialized areas of law often require hiring additional attorneys with expertise in those fields, a practice that has been in place for some time. Different law firms handle these specialized areas more effectively due to their focus and experience in those specific fields. This is why other attorneys are employed to address these specialized legal needs.

Paj 15

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 15

Mr. Lewis stated that he found the code to be quite ambiguous and noted that while the Deputy Solicitor does not need to have the same five (5) years of experience as the Solicitor, he would feel more comfortable with someone who has several years of legal experience, particularly in municipal affairs, when handling high-profile litigation and lawsuits against the city. Mr. Lewis also mentioned that he believes taxpayers are more reassured knowing that the city contracts with multiple law firms, each specializing in different areas. He feels that this approach is more cost-effective and provides better value for the legal services provided.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that they had considered switching to a different law firm in the past but determined that doing so would have resulted in costs that were double the current amount.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Rodriguez explained that, according to the code, the only requirement for the Deputy Solicitor is that they must be a licensed attorney in the state of Delaware. The Deputy Solicitor’s duties are determined by the City’s Solicitor and are considered necessary and proper. He added that while the city engages one general law firm, other law firms have specialized practices that complement, rather than compete with, each other.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rodriguez stated that by the charter, they are appointed by council, they are appointed for one (1) year, and that they can be removed at any time at the choice of council. He believes that it is a three-quarters (3/4) vote to remove the City or Deputy City Solicitor. Mr. Rodriguez noted that they are appointed not elected.

Mr. Neil made a motion to appoint Liam Gallagher as the Deputy City Solicitor, seconded by Mr. Hare, and carried by a roll call vote, seven (7) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Anderson) and two (2) no (Lewis and Sudler).

ANNEXATION/REZONING REQUEST/FIRST READING OF PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-28 - PROPERTY LOCATED AT 139 ACORN LANE A request was received for annexation and rezoning of property located at 139 Acorn Lane, consisting of 14,494 SF +/- ., owned by Byler Investments. This property is currently zoned RS- 1 (Residential Single Family Zone) (Kent County zoning classification), and the proposed zoning is R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) (City of Dover zoning classification). Staff recommended that the request be referred to the Utility Committee on August 13, 2024, and to the Planning Commission on September 16, 2024; and that a public hearing be set for October 14, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. (Tax Parcel: ED-00-068.19-01-23.00-000; Planning Reference: AX-24- 01)

Mr. Hare moved for referral, as recommended, seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.

In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:

Paj 16

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 16 ORDINANCE #2024-28 – AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT 139 ACORN LANE.

FINAL READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-27 – AMENDING CHAPTER 80 – PERSONNEL, ARTICLE IV – PENSION PLANS AND RETIREMENT BENEFITS (EXCEPT POLICE), DIVISION 3. – GENERAL EMPLOYEE PENSION PLAN The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of July 22, 2024. Council President Anderson reminded members of the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available on the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com under “Government”.

Mr. Neil moved that the Final Reading of the proposed ordinance be acknowledged by title only, seconded by Mr. Hare, and unanimously carried.

By motion of Mr. Hare, seconded by Mr. Rocha, by a unanimous roll call vote adopted Ordinance #2024-07 as follows:

BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:

That Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan, be amended to read as follows:

Section 80-500 – General employee pension plan established; purpose.

(a) Generally. There is hereby established the city general employee pension plan. The purpose of the plan is to establish the terms and conditions under which retirement and disability benefits shall be provided to eligible employees of the city. The benefits under the plan shall be in addition to amounts received as social security benefits or from any other pension plan.

(b) For employee exclusively. This plan is created for the exclusive benefit of the employees of the city and shall be interpreted in a manner consistent with it being an employee's trust, as defined in section 401(a) of the Internal Revenue Code (26 USC 401(a)). Therefore, under no circumstances shall any funds contributed to this plan, or any assets of the plan or trust ever revert to or be used or enjoyed by the city, nor shall any such funds or assets ever be used other than for the benefits of the employees of the city and the beneficiaries of those employees, prior to the satisfaction of all liabilities under this plan to the employees.

Section 80-501 – Eligibility of participant.

Each eligible employee not drawing any retirement benefits from the mayor and city council as of January 1, 1967, shall, upon compliance with the provisions of this division, become a general employee pension plan participant under this division, commencing on July

Paj 17

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 17

1, 1967, or at any subsequent time immediately upon employment. Effective September 28, 2009, the general employee pension plan is closed to new participants.

Section 80-502 – Participation mandatory; exceptions.

The pension plan shall not be construed to give any employee the right to be retained in the employ of the city. All new employees hired after July 1, 1991, shall be required, as a condition of employment, to join the general employee pension plan or the deferred compensation plan. All new employees hired after September 29, 2009, are required to join the money purchase plan (IRC 401(a)), as defined in division 4. All participants of the general employee pension plan as of September 28, 2009, will remain members of either plan thereafter unless leaving the employment of the city, retiring, passing away, or electing to terminate their participation in the general employee pension plan and becoming a member of the money purchase plan (IRC 401(a)), as defined in division 4.

Section 80-503 – Defraudment. It shall be unlawful for any person to knowingly make any false statement or falsify, or permit to be falsified, any record of the pension plan in an attempt to defraud the plan.

Section 80-504 – Normal retirement. The normal retirement date for each participant shall be the first day of the month following the attainment of the age of 65 years, provided that ten years of continuous service have been completed.

Section 80-505 – Early retirement.

(a) Reduced benefits. A participant who has completed ten years of continuous service and has attained the age of 55 years may retire at any time within the ten years preceding the normal retirement date; however, retirement benefits shall be computed at a reduced rate of one-half percent for each month computed from the date of early retirement to age 65 years.

(b) Unreduced benefits.

(1) Hired May 1, 1994, or later. For eligible employees hired on or after May 1, 1994, a participant who has attained the age of 55 years, and whose age plus years of continuous service is equal to or greater than 80, may retire at any time prior to the normal retirement date with no reduction in retirement benefits.

(2) Hired before May 1, 1994. For eligible employees hired before May 1, 1994, a participant who has completed 25 years of continuous service or who has attained the age of 50 years and completed 20 years of continuous service, may retire at any time prior to the normal retirement date with no reduction in retirement benefits.

Section 80-506 – Later retirement.

Paj 18

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 18

If a participant works beyond the normal retirement date, the payment of the participant's retirement benefits shall be deferred until actual retirement.

Section 80-507 – Forced retirement with pension.

The general employee pension plan board, upon recommendation of the city council or the city manager, may require retirement in any case deemed necessary due to the lack of work or inability of the employee to perform with a satisfactory degree of efficiency, provided that the employee qualifies for either normal retirement pursuant to section 80-504, or early retirement pursuant to section 80-505. The employee shall then be entitled to receive, commencing on the first day of the month coinciding with or next following the date of retirement, pension benefits equal to the benefits computed in accordance with the provisions of section 80-508 on the basis of the employee's service completed prior to actual retirement.

Section 80-508 – Amount of retirement benefits.

Retirement January 1, 1995, or later. The amount of retirement benefits payable to a participant who retires on or after January 1, 1995, shall be computed on the basis of one- fiftieth of the participant’s average actual monthly earnings multiplied by the total number of years of continuous service. Average actual monthly earnings shall be a participant's base pay plus scheduled overtime, payment for being on call, except those hours reported for being called out, and any retroactive pay corrections which involve any one of the mentioned payments during any period of 36 consecutive months in the final ten years of continuous service which results in the highest average monthly earnings.

If an employee's approved absence is the result of a workers compensation injury, the base wages that the employee would have earned had the employee not been on workers compensation leave will be included when determining the highest 36 consecutive months within the employee’s final ten years of continuous service.

The value of lost base salary as a result of mandatory furlough shall be added to an employee's final average compensation and considered in the calculation of the amount of retirement benefits if the time period in which the mandatory furlough was required is within the highest 36 consecutive months or earnings within the final ten years of continuous service.

Annual Increase. The retirement income of a retired member of this plan shall be increased by two percent per annum every January 1. This increase in retirement pay shall be cumulative and the previous year’s increase shall be included in the retired member’s retirement income for the purpose of calculating the annual two percent increase.

Section 80-509 – Form of benefits.

(a) Normal form. A monthly benefit shall be payable on the first day of the second month preceding the date on which the application for such benefit is filed. Payment will be retroactive to the retirement date. Payments of benefits shall be payable monthly thereafter during the participant’s lifetime and terminating with the last payment on the

Paj 19

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 19

first day of the month of the death of the participant. The general employee pension plan board shall be notified of all plan participant retirements.

(b) Death of participant, etc. Upon the death of a participant who has retired, or who is eligible to be retired under any of the provisions of this division, payment shall be made to the participant's eligible survivors in the amount of 50 percent of the monthly payments to which the participant was or would have been entitled. Upon the death of a participant who has completed a minimum of ten years of service but is not yet eligible to retire due to age and/or years of service, payment shall be made to the participant’s eligible survivors in the amount of 50 percent of the monthly payment to which the participant was or would have been entitled. The pension amount will be based upon section 80-508. There shall be no reduction in benefits. In no instance shall actual monthly payments be less than $200.00, effective July 1, 2000. Upon the death of both the participant and eligible survivor, if the benefit payments received in the aggregate are less than the member's contributions, the balance of the member's contributions, plus five percent interest, will be paid to the surviving beneficiary designated or to the estate if no designation has been made and submitted to the general employee pension plan board. The amount of benefit payments received, and the amount of the member's contributions shall be determined from the record of the pension board. The city shall request all plan participants to review eligible survivor and surviving beneficiary information annually and revise it as needed.

(c) Eligible survivor. An eligible survivor shall be one of the following in the order of preference listed:

(1) Spouse. The participant's spouse who was married to the participant for at least one year. Surviving spouse shall be required to provide supporting documents of marriage.

(2) Child or children of participant.

  • a.The surviving child or children, biological or legally adopted, of the participant, who have not attained 18 years of age.
  • b.Said surviving child or children of the participant attending school on a full-time basis and providing proof of attendance each year of eligibility who have not attained 26 years of age. Benefits shall cease with the payment due for the month in which the child or children cease to attend school on a full-time basis or with the payment due for the month in which age 26 is attained, whichever shall occur first. (d) Commencement of payment. Benefits payable to eligible survivors shall commence on the first day of the month following the date of the participant's death. (e) Cessation of benefits payable. Benefits payable to eligible survivors shall cease: (1) Spouse. With respect to an eligible survivor who is a spouse, with the payment due for the month in which remarriage or death shall occur, whichever occurs

Paj 20

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 20

first. (2) Surviving child or children. With respect to eligible survivors who are children with the payment due for the month in which age 18 is attained or death shall occur, whichever shall occur first unless the child or children attend school full- time and have not attained 26 years of age. Payments shall be made in accordance with subsections (2)a. and b. (f) Eligibility for benefits. The eligibility of any person or persons to receive payment of benefits as an eligible survivor shall be determined conclusively by the general employee pension plan board based on the application of such person or persons and any other information which the pension board deems to be appropriate.

Section 80-510 – Total and permanent disability.

(a) Definition. As used in this division, a participant shall be deemed to be "totally and permanently disabled" when the general employee pension plan board, on the basis of a medical examination by a physician or physicians selected by the pension board, finds the employee:

(1) Work generally. To be totally and permanently prevented from engaging in any occupation or employment for remuneration or profit as a result of bodily or mental injury or disease, whether occupational or nonoccupational in cause; or (2) Employment. To be totally and permanently prevented from continuing in their capacity as an employee as a result of bodily or mental injury or disease, whether occupational or nonoccupational in cause.

Section 80-511 – Early retirement due to permanent disability.

Any employee who has completed a minimum of ten consecutive years of service and sustains an injury or experiences a permanent health impairment to the extent of total and permanent disability shall be eligible for retirement upon application and certification by the general employee pension plan board that all of the criteria have been met. The pension amount will be based upon section 80-508. There shall be no reduction in benefit.

Section 80-512 – Commencement of disability benefits.

(a) Removed from payroll. A participant who files for a disability pension shall not work and be kept on the active payroll and receive credited service from the inception of the disability to the end of the first full calendar month following the date of application.

(b) Change in compensation; leave. During the application period above, the participant's compensation shall not be increased.

(c) Commencement of benefits. The eligibility for payment of disability benefits under this division shall commence, if approved, on the first day of the month following the application period set forth in subsection (a).

Paj 21

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 21

Section 80-513 – Termination of employment.

(a) Forfeiture of participation. Any participant whose employment is terminated prior to the date of eligibility for retirement benefits shall forfeit status as a participant in the pension plan and all accumulated credit for continuous service.

(b) Ten years' service. Any participant with a minimum of ten years of continuous service and whose employment is terminated prior to becoming eligible for retirement benefits under sections 80-504—Normal retirement, 80-505—Early retirement, 80-506—Later retirement or 80-511—Early retirement due to permanent disability, shall become vested and upon attaining the age of 65 years, shall be eligible for pension benefits under the provisions of section 80-508—Amount of retirement benefits, upon application to the pension board of trustees. The form of the benefit will be based on the formula which was in effect at the time of termination.

(c) Layoffs. Any participant who is laid off and then rehired within five years may apply to the general employee pension plan board to have their previous service credits restored immediately. Participants who withdrew their contributions must repay them as calculated by the city's actuary. Upon approval by the general employee pension plan board, returning participants must elect to return previously refunded amounts, plus calculated interest, within 30 days. Contributions will be reimbursed based on the gross amount received. Participants who are laid off and not rehired within five years shall forfeit status as a participant in the pension plan and all accumulated credit for continuous service.

(d) Request for refund. When an employee leaves city employment and is entitled to withdraw contributions, a written notarized request for a refund of contributions must be submitted before payment is made. Refunds will be issued 90 days from the date the notarized request is received. Interest on the contributions, at the rate of five percent per annum, shall be compounded annually from the last day of the plan year in which such contribution was made to the earlier of the date of commencement of retirement income or the date on which contributions are payable pursuant to the provisions of the plan. Contributions will automatically be refunded five years from the date of separation.

Section 80-514 – Cessation of disability pension benefits.

(a) A participant shall cease to qualify for disability pension benefits:

(1) Recovered. At the time that the general employee pension plan board determines, based on a medical examination by a physician or physicians selected by the pension plan board, that a participant is no longer totally and permanently disabled or has sufficiently recovered, but refuses to resume regular occupation as an employee or to be reemployed by the city in some other suitable position which is appropriate to the participant's training and experience; (2) Refuses examination. When the participant refuses to undergo a medical

Paj 22

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 22

examination requested by the general employee pension plan board; or (3) Age 65 years. On the first day of the month following the participant's 65th birthday. (b) Upon the occurrence of the earliest of the above events, disability pension benefits shall cease, except that, if the event of subsection (a)(3) of this section occurs, payment of the normal retirement benefits shall commence on that date, in the same amount as the disability pension benefits.

Section 80-515 – Effect of state workers’ compensation on disability benefits.

Any disability pension benefits received by a participant under the terms of this division as the result of an injury or illness compensable under the workers' compensation laws of the state shall be reduced by the amount of the workers' compensation payments actually received by the participant.

Section 80-516 – Benefits to cease upon reemployment; exceptions.

The Internal Revenue Code has provided guidance that to be considered retired for purposes of prohibitions against "in-service distributions," one must have an at least six-month break before returning to employment with the same employer and that such a return cannot be pre-planned at the time of retirement. If the individual is under the normal retirement age of 65, the individual will be subject to an annual earnings limit of $30,000.00.

Any employee of the city who is receiving, or who shall receive, benefits under this division, and who is thereafter reemployed by the city or appointed to any position by the mayor or council bearing remuneration, shall cease to draw benefits during the period of reemployment. Upon termination of the reemployment, the benefits shall be restored. The provisions of this section shall not apply to any employee who receives remuneration as a result of being elected or appointed to an elective or appointed office in the city, nor to any employee reemployed by the city in a casual/seasonal capacity, not to exceed 180 calendar days. Employees would be eligible to return to casual/seasonal status immediately following retirement.

Casual/seasonal employees may be employed by the city on a temporary basis in order to provide assistance for the following situations:

(a) Casual assistance. Employee is needed on a sporadic or on-call basis where hours cannot be predetermined and vary greatly from week to week. Such employees may be used as needed.

(b) Seasonal assistance. Employee is needed for peak operating seasons.

(c) Project assistance. Employee performs duties related to a specific project that has defined objectives and an established time period of completion that does not exceed 180 calendar days.

(d) Primary incumbent replacement. Employee is needed to fulfill the job responsibilities

Paj 23

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 23

of the primary incumbent who is unable to perform such responsibilities for an extended period of time. Such employees may be used for a maximum of 180 calendar days or the length of time the incumbent is unable to perform the job responsibility, whichever is less.

(e) Contracting. Any individual participating in the plan who contracts with the city or represents any private enterprise that has a contract with an employer participating in the plan must have a six-month separation from the effective date of retirement if the individual is under 65. The city shall maintain, in a form prescribed by the human resources director, a certification of the worker's status. The certification will be used for a determination of the individual meeting the definition of eligible employees under this section.

Section 80-517 – Benefit assignment, transfer, etc.

No participant or beneficiary under the plan shall assign, transfer, hypothecate, encumber, commute, or anticipate any interest in payments, funds, or contracts under this plan. No interest shall in any way be subject to any legal process, levy of execution, attachment, or garnishment proceedings for the payment of any claim against the participant or any beneficiary under the plan, nor shall any such interest be subject to the jurisdiction of any bankruptcy court or insolvency proceedings.

Section 80-518 – Contributions.

(a) Payroll deductions.

(1) Amount. For each year, while a participant of the plan, a participant shall contribute, by payroll deductions, an amount equal to 3½ percent of the participant’s average actual monthly earnings as described in section 80-508—Amount of retirement benefits (effective May 1, 1994). The city shall provide the plan participants with an annual statement of individual contributions.

(2) Employer contributions. The city, pursuant to the provisions of section 414(h)(2) of the United States Internal Revenue Code (26 USC 414(h)(2)), shall pick up and pay the contributions which would otherwise be payable by the employee under this section. The contributions so picked up shall be treated as employer contributions for purposes of determining the amounts of federal income taxes to be withheld from the employee's compensation.

(3) Employee contributions picked up by city. Employee contributions picked up by the city shall be paid from the same source of funds used for the payment of compensation to an employee. A deduction shall be made from each employee's compensation equal to the amount of the employee's compensation picked up by the employer. This deduction, however, shall not reduce the employee's compensation for purposes of computing benefits under the retirement system pursuant to this division.

Paj 24

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024PAGE 24
(4)Employee contributions credited.
  • a.Employee contributions shall be credited to a separate account within the employee's individual account so that the amount contributed prior to the effective date for the pickup of the employee's contributions may be distinguished from the amounts contributed on or after the effective date.
  • b.The contributions, although designated as employee contributions, are being paid by the employer in lieu of the contributions by the employee. The employee will not be given the option of choosing to receive the contributed amounts directly instead of having them paid by the employer to the retirement system.

(b) City contributions. The city shall make such contributions as necessary to meet the requirements of the plan. Effective May 1, 1994, the city shall pick up the employee contributions by a reduction in current earnings. Such picked-up contributions shall be treated as employer contributions in determining tax treatment under the Internal Revenue Code; however, the contributions so picked up shall be included in earnings for purposes of the plan. Participant contributions which are picked up shall be treated, for all purposes of this plan, in the same manner as participant contributions made prior to May 1, 1994.

(c) Other contributions. The general employee pension plan board shall receive all appropriations, contributions, and interest allowances as may be received from time to time by the city from the state or any other source and designated specifically for employee pensions.

(d) Withdrawal from plan. A member who withdraws from the general employee pension plan for any reason, other than retirement, death, or disability, may request that the accumulated contributions, plus five percent interest, be paid to them after such date of withdrawal; provided, however, the contributions shall not be refunded to them earlier than 90 days after receipt of the notarized application for the same.

(e) Death of ineligible member. Upon the death of a member not eligible to retire under any provision of this division, the employee contributions shall be payable in a single sum to the participant’s designated beneficiary or the participant’s estate if no designation has been made.

Section 80-519 – City paramedics transferred to county.

Notwithstanding any other provision of this division, all persons employed by the city as paramedics, who are transferred to the county emergency medical services department and who make a written election to remain in the city general employee pension plan, shall continue to be considered eligible employees within the meaning of the pension plan as long as the paramedics are employed by the county emergency medical services department. All benefits for any such paramedic shall be calculated as if the paramedic had remained a city employee while employed with the county emergency medical services department.

Section 80-520– General employee pension plan board; established; duties.

Paj 25

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 25

There is hereby established a general employee pension plan board, the duties of which shall be to manage the general employee pension plan.

Section 80-521– Composition.

The general employee pension plan board shall consist of the following persons:

(1) Manager. The city manager.

(2) City officials. Two elected city officials who shall be appointed by the council president, subject to confirmation of a voting majority of the city council at its annual meeting.

(3) Participants. Four participants; active, retired, or vested participants of the general employee pension plan who shall be elected by the active, retired, or vested participants of the plan.

(4) Controller/treasurer. The city controller/treasurer.

(5) Election.

(a) Such election shall be for three-year staggered terms, beginning July 1 and ending June 30 three years later. A regular election for filling these positions will be held the third week of June each year.

(b) In the first week of April of each year, the city clerk shall notify those eligible to vote of the exact time and place of the election. Any active, retired, or vested member of the general employee pension plan who wishes to fill an expiring term or vacancy must submit their name to the city clerk’s office by the deadline determined by the city clerk.

(c) Any general employee pension plan member that is eligible to vote and appears on the listing of qualified voters who will be unable to appear at the polling place on the date and time of the election may cast his or her vote by absentee ballot in the general employee pension plan election for the following reasons: 1) armed forces, 2) public service, 3) occupation, 4) sickness, 5) disability, 6) religion, 7) vacation, or 8) residency outside of the Dover area which makes it infeasible to vote in person. Participants wishing to vote by absentee ballot must request an affidavit for absentee voting from the city clerk’s office. Once the affidavit is returned, the city clerk shall send the participant an absentee ballot which must be completed and returned to the city clerk’s office. Both the affidavit and the completed absentee ballot must be returned by the deadline determined by the city clerk.

(d) Persons appearing to vote shall present proof of identity. The identification shall be 1 or more of the following items that show the identity of the person: (1) A current driver’s license or ID card; (2) A uniformed service ID card; (3) Another

Paj 26

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 26

current photo ID issued by a government agency, the voter’s employer, high school, or higher education institution. The Election Officer shall then check the person’s name against the voter list. If the Election Officer determines that the person is not eligible to vote in the election, the Election Officer shall refer the person to the city clerk. The city clerk, after hearing and considering evidence, shall determine whether to permit the person to vote. Upon making the decision, the city clerk shall appropriately annotate the voter list.

Section 80-522 – Term of office of members.

The term of office of each member of the general employee pension plan board, except the city controller/treasurer, city manager, and elected city officials, shall commence on the first day of the month following their election and continue for a period of three years or until their successor shall be elected and qualified.

Section 80-523 – Officers and ex officio members.

At its first meeting after each regular general employee pension plan board election, the board shall elect a chairperson and a vice chairperson who shall serve in the absence of the chairperson. The Committee Chair's responsibilities include chairing general employee pension plan board meetings, setting agendas, and facilitating communication with the board as needed. The city controller/treasurer shall be the pension fund treasurer and the treasurer’s bond shall cover all monies deposited with them.

Section 80-524 – Vacancies. If a vacancy occurs in the offices of the general employee pension plan board, the vacancy shall be filled for the unexpired term within 60 days and in the same manner as the office was originally filled. Should a member of the pension plan board cease to be in the employ of the city, other than by retiring or being vested in accordance with this division, the office shall be declared vacant.

Section 80-525 – Compensation of members.

Members of the general employee pension plan board shall serve without compensation.

Section 80-526 – Meetings.

The general employee pension plan board shall make all rules as to the time and place of meetings; and a majority of its membership shall be required to transact pension board business. The board shall meet on a quarterly basis to review investment performance but may meet more frequently if needed. Meetings may be called by the chairperson, vice chairperson, or three members of the board. The board will follow Robert’s Rules of Order as its parliamentary authority. The rules contained in the current edition of Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised shall govern the pension board in all cases to which they are applicable and in which they are not inconsistent with any special rules of order the board may adopt.

Paj 27

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 27

Section 80-527 – Powers.

The general employee pension plan board, in administering the pension plan, shall have the following powers in carrying out the purposes thereof:

(1) Payment of funds. To pay funds to those entitled to receive them. The controller/treasurer shall sign all vouchers for the disbursements of the funds and shall report to the general employee pension board all financial transactions. Monthly cash receipts and expenditure reports will be delivered on a quarterly basis. The quarterly reports shall be provided in writing seven days in advance of the quarterly meeting.

(2) Purchase annuity contracts. To purchase and pay the costs of group annuity contracts from any insurance company for the benefit of participants;

(3) Employment of agents, employees, etc. To employ agents, employees, or experts to assist the pension board in carrying out the provisions of this division, including an agent to advise and make recommendations concerning the investment of funds, and to pay reasonable compensation for those services, and the compensation may be paid from income or corpus of the pension fund or by direct appropriation by the city council as the pension board and the city council may determine;

(4) Investments. To invest and reinvest money in the pension fund, without any limitation, in United States or state municipal bonds or group annuity contracts. Money in the pension fund may also be invested and reinvested in other types of bonds, stocks, and securities to the extent the pension board may deem best and as is not prohibited by any law now or hereafter in force limiting the investments of the trustees. The pension board may from time to time change the investments of the fund and, to this end, may make sales of any investment privately, without advertisement and without the necessity of any court order, upon the terms that the pension board deems proper. The funds and investments may also be from time to time turned over to and placed in the custody of any fiscal agent designated by the pension board;

(5) Contracts. To generally contract in matters relevant to effectuating and achieving the purposes of this plan;

(6) Pension benefits. To receive and pay out pension benefits in accordance with the provisions of this division, or designate a fiscal agent to receive and pay out the pension benefits;

(7) Rules and regulations. To make rules and regulations as may be necessary to effectuate this subdivision.

Section 80-528 – City solicitor to render legal services.

Paj 28

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 28

The city solicitor shall render whatever legal service the general employee pension plan board shall require.

Section 80-529 – Appeals.

Any employee dissatisfied with the action of the general employee pension plan board shall have the right to appeal to the city council within 30 days from the date of formal notification of that action.

ADOPTED: August 12, 2024

CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mr. Hugg had no announcements.

MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mayor Christiansen announced that the First Annual Caribbean Festival will take place on August 17, 2024. The event will feature a parade at Legislative Hall, starting at noon.

COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mr. Lewis announced that the Second Annual Latino Festival will take place at Legislative Hall on Saturday, August 31st.

Mr. Boggerty expressed that Dover and Delaware as a whole have lost a community icon; with the passing of Apostle Robert Appling, who transitioned on Monday. His services will be held on Saturday, August 17th, at Speak Life, located at 2736 Forest Avenue. The viewing will begin at 11 a.m., followed by the service at noon. The viewing begins at 11 a.m. and services start at noon. Mr. Boggerty also extended his gratitude to Mr. Wolf and his team for their efforts in distributing COVID test kits. They had 100,000 tests and have already given away over 30,000 kits across the state. The warehouse has been instrumental, delivering 6,000 COVID tests to Delaware State University and 1,500 tests to the Capital School District, among others. He mentioned that there are still 70,000 test kits available for organizations or households. Mr. Boggerty thanked the City Clerk and her team. He noted that the FDA has extended the shelf life of the COVID test kits, with the new expiration date set for 2025.

Mr. Rocha announced that Dover Christian Church will be hosting a concert at 1738 Forest Avenue on September 7th at 6:00 p.m. The event is free, with no tickets required, but there will be a free-will offering. The Brian Cunningham Project will provide musical support during the event, which will take place in the church parking lot.

Mr. Hare shared that he had received calls from elderly citizens who were in need of COVID test kits and were afraid to go out. He contacted Mr. Boggerty, obtained a box of test kits, and distributed them around the neighborhood.

Mr. Neil announced that the band Phish will be performing on Thursday, August 15th. Starting on August 14th, traffic will be rerouted from Leipsic Road to Persimmon Tree Lane. Residents in that area will need a pass to access their homes, and these passes have already been distributed

Paj 29

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 2024 PAGE 29

by Dover Speedway. The communities have been notified of the changes. Mayor Christiansen estimated that the event would attract around 40,000 attendees.

Mr. Anderson reminded the public and members that the next set of council meetings are canceled as is done traditionally to allow staff vacations, et cetera.

The meeting adjourned at 8:20 p.m.

ANDRIA BENNETT CITY CLERK

All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by the City Council during their Regular Meeting of August 12, 2024, are hereby approved.

ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR /AB

Exhibits Exhibit #1 – Email from Constantine Malmberg in support of Resolution #2024-12 Exhibit #2 – Email from Rebecca Kidner in support of Resolution #2024-12 Exhibit #3 – Email from Philip McGinnis in support of Resolution #2024-12

Paj 30

EXHIBIT #1

Regular City Council Meeting of 08/12/2024

Bennett. Andria

From: Conny Malmberg <cmalmberg@themalmbergfirm.com>
Sent: Monday, August 12, 2024 3:18 PM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Backflow preventers

Some people who received this message don't often get email from cmalmberg@themalmbergfirm.com. Learn why this is important WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear City Council;

I urge you to support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers.

Small retail and office users are not going to pollute our water system

The cost of installing these devices far exceeds the benefit and puts our citizens and especially our small businesspeople at great financial hardship.

Thank you very much for your consideration.

Respectfully submitted,

---Constantine Malmberg

THE MALMBERG FIRM LLC

Constantine F. Malmberg III
30 The Green Dover, DE 19901
(302) 672-5600 Phone
(302) 672-5609 Fax

This message may contain attorney-client communications or other protected information. If you believe you are not an intended recipient (even if this message was sent to your e-mail address), you may not use, copy, or retransmit ii. If you believe you received this message by mistake, please notify us by return e-mail, and then delete this message. Thank you for your cooperation.

Paj 31

EXHIBIT #2

Regular City Council Meeting of 08/12/2024

Rivera, Arielle M

From: Rebecca Kidner <rbk@kidner.com> Sent: Monday, August 12, 2024 5:14 PM To: City Clerks Office Subject: EXTERNAL: Please Support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers

Some people who received this message don't often get email fromrbk@kidner.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear City Council Members:

Please Support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers. While we understand the overall importance of protecting the City's potable water system, we do not believe that installation and annual inspection (at the expense of the owner) of a separate backflow preventer on the upstream water line for low risk properties like our home and office space provides any measurable protection in the case of a line break and resultant siphonage of water out of our pipes back into the City's system. Recently during testimony before the Leg. and Fin. Committee, it was learned Dover's potable water system is interconnected which means that if one pump fails, the other pumps maintain pressure. This means positive flow remains, significantly reducing the chances of water backflow back into the City's system.

We respectfully urge the Council to adopt Resolution 2024-12 in its entirety, and then work with the various business and real estate organizations such asthe Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce and the Kent County Association of REALTORSto fashion a workable and reasonable solution to the use of backflow preventers in those properties located in Dover that may be considered "high risk" to the City's water system. We would also ask that the moratorium not grandfather any property class, Le., that any action taken in furtherance of requiring backflow preventers shall be null and void until a comprehensive rule is implemented after due consideration. Thank you for your attention to this matter, and as property owners, we stand ready to work with you and members of the City to address concerns relating to backflow preventers.

Respectfully,

Scott and Rebecca Kidner
15 Kings Hwy.
Dover, DE 19901

1

Paj 32

EXHIBIT #3

Regular City Council Meeting of 08/12/2024

Bennett. Andria

From: Philip McGinnis <pjm@mcginnisrealty.com> Sent: Monday, August 12, 2024 3:06 PM To: City Clerks Office Subject: EXTERNAL:Support Resolution 2024 - 12 Back Flow Preventers Moratorium

Somepeople who receivedthis messagedon't ohen get email frompjm@mcginnisrealty.com.Learnwhy this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization.Do not click links or open attachmentsunless you recognize
the sender and know the content is safe.
Dear City Council-
I urge you to support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers.
While I do not dispute that heavy industrial manufacturingusers should have backflow preventers,small
retail and office users are not going to pollute our water system.
The cost of installing these devices far exceeds the benefit and puts our citizens and especially our small
businesspeopleat great financial hardship.
Please let us reconsider this program.
Please also consider that this moratoriumshould not grandfatherany property class, for example, any
properties currently under pressure to install these devices.
Thank you very much for your assistance on this very importantmatter.

Phil McGinnis, CCIM, GAA, ACoM, ALC, e-PRO
McGinnis Commercial Real Estate Company
302-736-2710 office
302-270-0656 cell
mailto:pjm@mcginnisrealty.com

,
~c
, f'

1

Tounen nan reyinyon sa a