Ale nan kontni prensipal la
AskDover

Regular City Council Packet

City Council Meetings. 12 out 2024.

Louvri PDF la (22.4 MB)

Yo rale tèks sa a nan PDF la otomatikman, epi li ka gen erè. PDF la se dosye ofisyèl la, kidonk tcheke l anvan ou konte sou sa a.

11 paj pa gen anpil tèks ou ka li isit la, oswa yo pa gen ditou, souvan paske se eskanè oswa desen. Gade PDF la pou sa yo.

Paj 1

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING

Monday, August 12, 2024 at 6:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware

AGENDA VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE

This meeting will be held in the City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:

Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://rb.gy/lir0nj
Event number: 2538 339 3955
Event password: DOVER (if needed)

If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.

The meeting can also be viewed on Comcast Channel 14, Verizon Channel 20, and on the City's Streaming Player located at www.cityofdover.com under "Quick Links".

OPEN FORUM - 15 Minutes Prior to Official Meeting (6:15 p.m.)

The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share their questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing on the agenda as a public hearing is prohibited during the Open Forum as an opportunity will be provided during consideration of that item. Citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is prohibited from taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule such items as regular agenda items and act upon them in the future.

INVOCATION - Elder Ellis B. Louden

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Councilman Rocha

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA

All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.

Paj 2

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - August 12, 2024 PAGE 2

RESOLUTIONS

  • 1.Resolution No. 2024-12 - Enacting a Moratorium on Any Program Requiring Backflow Preventers

(Committee Recommendation: Approval of Resolution No. 2024-12.)

CONSENT AGENDA

ADOPTION OF MINUTES

  • 2.Regular City Council Meeting of July 22, 2024

COMMITTEE REPORTS

  • 3.Council Committee of the Whole Report July 23, 2024

Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee

  • 4.Discussion - City of Dover Emergency Operations Plan (Kay Sass, Public Affairs and Emergency Management Coordinator)

(Committee Recommendation: Approval to send the City of Dover Emergency Operations Plan to the State of Delaware for acceptance of the 2024 Updated EOP)

Utility Committee

  • 5.Discussion - Possible Moratorium on Any Program Requiring Backflow Preventers (Council President Anderson, and David S. Hugg, III, City Manager)

(Committee Recommendation: Forward Resolution No. 2024-12 to City Council with a recommendation of approval)

Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee

  • 6.Discussion - Update on State Pension (Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director)

(Committee Action Not Required)

  • 7.Discussion - Mayoral Compensation

(Committee Action Not Required)

MONTHLY REPORTS - June 2024

  • 8.City Council's Community Enhancement Fund Report
  • 9.City Manager's Report
  • 10.Controller/Treasurer's Budget Report
  • 11.Police Chief's Report

Paj 3

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - August 12, 2024 PAGE 3

APPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY MAYOR CHRISTIANSEN

  • 12.Planning Commission
  • A.Michael W. Lewis - Third District - Three-Year Term to Expire June 2027
  • 13.Board of Adjustment
  • A.Ronald L. Coburn, Jr. - Three-Year Term to Expire July 2027

APPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT ANDERSON

  • 14.City of Dover Employee Liaisons
  • A.Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt
  • B.Councilwoman Andre M. Boggerty
  • C.Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
  • 15.Utility Committee
  • A.Glen D. Wilson (Appointed by Council President to fill the unexpired term of Michael Pugh
  • -term to expire May 2025)

ITEMS NOT ON THE CONSENT AGENDA

  • 16.Tentative Labor Contract with American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME)
  • 17.Deputy City Solicitor
  • A.Liam N. Gallagher

ORDINANCES

FIRST READING REFERRAL - The First Reading is offered on the Proposed Ordinances. It is recommended for referral to the Planning Commission for a public hearing on SEPTEMBER 16, 2024, and that a Public Hearing before City Council be set for OCTOBER 14, 2024, at 6:30 p.m., at which time the Final Reading and Council action will take place. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us.

  • 18.Annexation/Rezoning Request/First Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2024-28

The First Reading is offered on the Proposed Ordinance #2024-28. It is recommended for referral to the Utility Committee on August 13, 2024; Planning Commission on September 16, 2024; and that a Public Hearing/Final Reading before Council be set for October 14, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City's website at www.cityofdover.comunder "Government," or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us.

  • A.Amending the Zoning Ordinance and Zoning Map of the City of Dover by changing the zoning designation from RS-1 - Residential Single Family Zone ( Kent County zoning classification) to R-10 - One Family Residence Zone (City of Dover zoning classification) on that property located at 139 Acorn Lane, consisting of 14,494 SF +/-, owned by Byler Investments, LLC (Tax Parcel: ED-00-068.19-01-23.00-000; Planning Reference: AX-24-01; Third Council District)

Paj 4

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - August 12, 2024 PAGE 4

FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of JULY 22, 2024. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government."

  • 19.Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 - Personnel, Article IV - Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (Except Police), Division 3. - General Employee Pension Plan

(Staff Recommendation: Approve Proposed Ordinance #2024-07.)

CITY MANAGER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS

MAYOR'S ANNOUNCEMENTS

COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ANNOUNCEMENTS

ADJOURNMENT

THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING

Paj 5

Item #1.

City of Dover
MAYOR AND COUNCIL

PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-12

A RESOLUTION PLACING A ONE-YEAR MORATORIUM ON ANY PROGRAM REQUIRING BACKFLOW PREVENTERS

WHEREAS, in January 2021, the Delaware Department of Public Health adopted regulations encouraging the implementation of backflow preventers, but the requirements were not mandatory, except for those declared to have high-risk of backflow; and

WHEREAS, in June 2024, the majority of the Delaware House of Representatives voted to amend the City of Dover Charter to repeal the City of Dover Department of Water & Wastewater requirements for backflow preventers, sending a message to the City of Dover to review the requirements; and

WHEREAS, the Kent County Association of Realtors has presented cases of small businesses with no real risk of backflow being asked to retrofit at the cost of thousands of dollars with no benefit to the environment; and

WHEREAS, these requirements will have a contradictory impact on the City of Dover’s adopted goals of reclaiming empty storefronts and the building for economic expansion; and

WHEREAS, there will be ongoing costs to the City of Dover for inspections that will seriously impact the city budget in the long run; and

WHEREAS, there has not been a proper review of the new requirements by the City of Dover City Council.

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED:

The City Council does hereby enact a moratorium for one year on any program requiring backflow preventers within the City of Dover, Delaware, excepting those deemed moderate or high risk by state regulations explicitly requiring backflow regulators, subject to the following stipulations and conditions:

  • 1.This moratorium shall become effective immediately upon adoption by the City Council of the City of Dover, Delaware; and
  • 2.All current and future enforcement, notifications, and requirements in process regarding backflow preventers are suspended for one year, and any penalties shall neither be assessed in any pending cases except for those deemed high risk
  • P.O. Box 475 Dover, DE 19903 Community Excellence Through Quality Service Page 5

Paj 6

Item #1.
PROPOSED COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-12 PAGE 2

according to state and local regulations or auxiliary water systems; and

  • 3.Before any program can be implemented after this moratorium, it must be presented to the Utility Committee and passed by the City Council of the City of Dover; and
  • 4.The City of Dover requests staff to work with members of the General Assembly to permanently address the regulations that led to the City of Dover’s regulations.

ADOPTED: *

_______________________________ ______________________________
ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN DAVID L. ANDERSON
MAYOR COUNCIL PRESIDENT

Actions History 08/12/2024 – Final Reading – City Council 07/23/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/Utility Committee

Paj 7

Item #2.

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING

The Regular City Council Meeting was held on July 22, 2024, at 6:33 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Council members present were Mr. Hare, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Arndt, Mr. Rocha, Dr. Sudler, and Mr. Lewis (in at 6:33 p.m.).

Staff members present were Deputy Chief Spicer, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Melson-Williams, Chief Carey, Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Ms. Marney was absent.

OPEN FORUM

The Open Forum was held at 6:15 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Council President Anderson declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.

Ms. Alfreda Fisher Dean, 728 Bicentennial Boulevard, was concerned about the transformer that went out on June 3, 2024. She spoke at the June 24, 2024, meeting and explained that she contacted her insurance company, and they would not pay for her stereo to be replaced because it was not a hurricane, a fire, or a tornado. Ms. Dean explained that since the transformer was the City of Dover’s, they should take care of it. She was appalled that no one had responded to her letter. She feels that council is unfair to the seniors and would like to have a meeting with whoever she needs to get some explanation.

Mr. Boggerty stated that he would make plans to get the stereo replacement by the end of the month. He stated for the record that it would not be coming out of anyone’s pockets but his own.

Responding to Ms. Dean, Dr. Sudler apologized that she felt that way and that she has always been a great pillar of the community. He stated that throughout his high school years, she was always willing to help everyone while serving in the Capital School District.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Dean stated that the price of the stereo is $199. At the time that it was bought, it was over $500 and she has had the stereo for over 29 years. She noted that a gentleman from the electric company came to her and stated that her transformers were old and that they needed to be replaced. She was upset that Mr. Dill, the mayor, and Mr. Anderson never responded to her letters and she would like to know if they received her letters. The letters were brought to City Hall on July 17, 2024, and given to Nikki Arnold at 12:50 p.m.

Responding to Ms. Dean, Dr. Sudler apologized that this had happened and hoped that they could take care of this for her. He appreciated Mr. Boggerty for wanting to do this out of his pocket, but as a representative, he believes that it is something that the City of Dover could handle. Dr. Sudler believes that the city manager is authorized to up to $50,000 at his discretion regarding any matter, and this situation would not break the budget. He would urge that the City of Dover and the city manager take care of this and if need be, put it on the agenda for a vote. He understands that Mr. Boggerty wants to take care of the matter, but it is bigger than just doing that, it is about the perception of the city council as a whole and how they are handling the senior citizens who are in distress or dismay. He would personally like to see the City Council come together and authorize the city manager to replace what was broken for $199. He believes that it is manageable and reasonable.

Responding to Ms. Dean, Mr. Rocha stated that when he and Dr. Pillsbury received calls they chose between the two (2) of them who would call the constituents. He mentioned that it was he

Paj 8

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 2

who was going to make the call and reach out to her.

Mr. Nate Attard, President of the Friends of Old Dover, read his statement into the record. (Exhibit #1). Mr. Attard asked for the Board of Adjustment to at least hear their case and if they choose not to hear the case, return the application fee of $300. Mr. Attard noted that it was unfair that they did not get a chance to speak in two (2) different city forums.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the application fee was paid for the appeal to the Board of Adjustment. The Board of Adjustment has a filing fee of $300 that was established in the provisions of the zoning ordinance and Appendix F of the Dover Code of Ordinance. She believes there are provisions for the Board of Adjustment to consider returning that fee since the deliberation was not undertaken at their most recent meeting in July as part of the adoption of the agenda, the appeal application was removed from their agenda, finding that they did not have jurisdiction to hear that case.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that most of the boards and commissions have an application fee, depending on the type of application being filed. This fee covers staff involvement in processing the application to the Board of Adjustment and the public notice requirements that the city is responsible for, including legal advertising and mailing. The per diem that the board members receive for their participation in the meeting is their stipend.

Mr. Hare believes that the fee should be returned to the applicant.

Mr. Neil stated that at that meeting, they began by noting they had received a legal opinion indicating they could not hear the case, and it should be dismissed and automatically sent back due to its advanced stage. He believes it was their fault for not obtaining the opinion in advance and that the process should be done automatically

INVOCATION

The invocation was given by Elder Ellis B. Loudon.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Councilwoman Arndt.

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried unanimously.

ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA

All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.

Mr. Lewis requested a point of order and asked that item number 20 be removed from the consent agenda of the interview committee for the controller/treasurer for discussion.

Paj 9

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 3

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda as amended. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson) and one (1) no (Lewis).

RESOLUTION NO. 2024-11 – ENACTING A MORATORIUM ON RECREATIONAL
MARIJUANA LAND USES WHILE CONSIDERING ZONING REGULATIONS TO
ADDRESS SUCH USES
The City Clerk read the following Resolution into the record:

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:

WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Council seek to preserve, protect, and promote the general health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of the City of Dover, Delaware through the enactment of certain codes, ordinances, and other regulatory tools and policies that are necessary, and good to achieve that end; and

WHEREAS, recreational marijuana became legal for adult use in the State of Delaware on July 5, 2023, when the Delaware Marijuana Control Act went into effect; and

WHEREAS, the Delaware Marijuana Control Act allows municipalities to enact ordinances or regulations prohibiting the operation of recreational marijuana related establishments within their jurisdiction or governing the time, place, manner, and number of recreational marijuana establishment operations; and

WHEREAS, the Council Committee of the Whole, Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee discussed options on regulating recreational marijuana within the City of Dover at their meetings on September 26, 2023, and April 09, 2024, and directed city staff to draft an ordinance permitting recreational marijuana establishments within certain zones; and

WHEREAS, during this meeting, several public commenters raised concerns about the provisions outlined in these proposed ordinances; and

WHEREAS, following this discussion, the Council Committee of the Whole Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee and City Council requested that more research and community outreach be conducted and ultimately deferred the issue to a Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting; and

WHEREAS, the State of Delaware Office of the Marijuana Commissioner will begin accepting applications for all recreational marijuana business license types on September 1, 2024, and will begin issuing licenses on November 1, 2024; and

WHEREAS, the City of Dover, Delaware is actively working to determine the best way to regulate land uses related to the recreational marijuana industry.

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED:

Paj 10

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 4

The City Council does hereby enact a moratorium on recreational marijuana related uses within the City of Dover, Delaware, subject to the following stipulations and conditions:

  • 1.This moratorium shall become effective immediately upon adoption by the City Council of the City of Dover, Delaware; and
  • 2.This moratorium shall apply to all recreational marijuana establishments licensed by the Delaware Office of the Marijuana Commissioner, which are defined as follows:
  • a.“Marijuana cultivation facility” means an entity licensed to cultivate, prepare, and package marijuana and sell marijuana to retail marijuana stores, to marijuana product manufacturing facilities, and to other marijuana cultivation facilities, but not to consumers. A marijuana cultivation facility may not produce marijuana concentrates, tinctures, extracts, or other marijuana products.
  • b.“Marijuana product manufacturing facility” means an entity licensed to purchase marijuana, manufacture, prepare, and package marijuana products, and sell marijuana and marijuana products to other marijuana product manufacturing facilities and retail marijuana stores, but not to consumers.
  • c.“Marijuana testing facility” means an entity licensed to test marijuana for potency and contaminants.
  • d.“Retail marijuana store” means an entity licensed to purchase marijuana from marijuana cultivation facilities, to purchase marijuana and marijuana products from marijuana product manufacturing facilities, and to sell marijuana and marijuana products to consumers.
  • 3.It shall be understood that the purpose of this moratorium is to afford the City Council a reasonable due diligence period to consider alternative courses of action relative to the governing of recreational marijuana uses within the city including, but not limited to, adoption of an amendment to the Dover Code of Ordinances, regulating the time, place, manner, and number of marijuana establishment options; and
  • 4.This moratorium shall remain in effect until December 31, 2024, unless rescinded by City Council or unless City Council adopts ordinances related to recreational marijuana related uses/establishments at an earlier date.

ADOPTED: JULY 22, 2024

Mr. Lewis wanted to put on the record that realistically, recreational use businesses would not happen immediately because they would still need to get a permit from the state, which, to his understanding, would not be available until the fall. Thus, in his opinion, the moratorium would not be necessary. He stated that if he made a motion, he would be outnumbered. He hoped that city staff would continue to develop a code for the various types of marijuana businesses and that an ordinance would be presented in the near future.

Paj 11

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 5

Mr. Hare moved for the adoption of Resolution No. 2024-11. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a roll call vote of seven (7) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler,) and two (2) no (Lewis and Anderson).

ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 8, 2024 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of July 8, 2024, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Rocha, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen.

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE

The Council Committee of the Whole met on July 09, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis (arrived at 6:15 p.m.), Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Mr. Sudler. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Lewis, and Mr. Tholstrup (Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement), Mr. Iriowen, and Mr. Pugh (Utility), and Mr. Garfinkel, and Mr. Shevock (via WebEx) (Legislative, Finance, and Administration).

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

Council Reports – June 2024

First District Dr. Pillsbury reported that she attended Mr. Boggerty’s Unity Day event, the Fourth of July activities, and several Chamber of Commerce meetings.

Mr. Rocha had no report to give.

Second District Mr. Hare reported that he attended Mr. Boggerty’s Unity Day and was able to dance with the steppers.

Mr. Lewis was absent; no report was given.

Third District Mr. Neil reported that he attended the Kent County Tourism and Downtown Dover Partnership meetings. Mr. Neil also rode with Mayor Christiansen in the Fourth of July parade along with Councilwoman Dr. Pillsbury. Mr. Neil reported that, on behalf of both Councilwoman Arndt and himself, he sent the Third District Civic and HOA leaders an alert regarding the power failure caused by a truck hitting a pole near Home Depot. He also included the schedule and predicted traffic impacts due to the Phish concerts at the Woodlands from August 15, 2024, through August 18, 2024.The attendance is rumored to be in excess of

Paj 12

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 6

55,000 people. Mr. Neil also reported that they sent out an alert on the Recreational Marijuana Survey and received a number of direct responses. Mr. Neil thanked Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager for assisting in constituent concerns regarding recycling lid containers being left open at collection, and a driveway damaged by a city truck in Wild Meadows. In closing Mr. Neil reported that he responded to an Eastlake consultant regarding fireworks, concerns about smoking, and noise being made by crowds outside of an apartment and provided items for an event at the request of the President of the Wild Meadows Homeowners Association.

Ms. Arndt stated that she had nothing in addition to Mr. Neil’s report.

Fourth District Mr. Sudler reported that he recently attended an event with the Nigerian community, he met with Gregory Gross, Deputy Clerk of Peace to speak about concerns downtown in regard to loitering, prostitution, and the perception that the Department of Justice is not prosecuting the low-level offenses which is having an adverse effect on downtown Dover. Mr. Sudler explained that Mr. Gross plans to connect him with someone from the Department of Justice, and Ms. Kathy Jennings. Mr. Sudler stated that he would like to invite the mayor and the Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee chair to the meeting once it is scheduled. Furthermore, Mr. Sudler reported that he has been working with the church on New Street to address people loitering and assist them in addressing code enforcement and structural issues with their dwelling to help clean up New Street, and downtown. Lastly, Mr. Sudler reported that he has continued to volunteer with Mr. Rocha, Mr. Boggerty, and Mr. Anderson to help maintain the Sunset Memorial Garden on College Road.

At-Large Mr. Boggerty reported that his Third Annual Unity Day, which focused on anti- bullying, was successful. Mr. Boggerty explained that nearly everyone running for or currently holding a state-level office was present to speak about addressing bullying. Additionally, voter registration and COVID-19 tests were available among other services. Mr. Boggerty also reported that he obtained 100,000 COVID-19 tests for the city and is working on partnering with agencies to distribute the tests.

Council President Anderson Council President Anderson reported that city staff was very responsive in assisting with overgrowth on city property, which he expressed appreciation for since it affects the quality of life within the neighborhood, they also filled potholes, and addressed several other concerns. Mr. Anderson expressed gratitude for the Public Works and Parks and Recreation departments and their quick responsiveness. Mr. Anderson also expressed appreciation for the City of Dover Police Department for assisting a 72-year-old handicapped man after the Fourth of July Celebration by providing him with the resources he needed to get on the right path. Mr. Anderson acknowledged the General Assembly Finance

Paj 13

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 7

Committee, noting that the city is set to receive funding for the fire department, police department, and specific infrastructure projects. Mr. Anderson expressed appreciation for Ms. Kay Sass and her work getting the Recreational Marijuana Survey out as it has collected 544 responses so far. Lastly, Mr. Anderson reported that at the Delaware League of Local Governments (DLLG) meeting, the head of the Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) spoke about potential challenges related to maintaining reliable power. Mr. Anderson explained that the city will likely have to consider a path going forward.

PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE

The Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee met with Chairwoman Arndt presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Update on the Consideration of a Public Space Naming Policy (Tricia K. Arndt, Chair of Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee) Ms. Tricia Arndt, Chair, reviewed the presentation entitled "Guidelines for Naming Public Spaces” (Attachment #1).

(Committee Action Not Required)

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Arndt stated that when she initially started conducting research, she did not find any municipalities in the state of Delaware that had a policy to reference, nor did the state code. She further explained that as a result of not finding any information she searched other municipalities that were similar in comparison to Dover.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Arndt stated that she was able to find information that was included in a prior presentation that she could provide. She also explained that she attended a meeting of the Silver Lake Commission to get their input on the space naming proposal and she received positive feedback from them.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Arndt clarified that the request was not initiated by the Silver Lake Commission but rather came about when she received two requests to consider renaming a park. Upon reviewing the ordinances, she discovered that the city lacks a dedicated process or procedure for such requests. She further explained that in the past they came before council, it was discussed, and put to a vote. She stated that she initially presented the proposal to the committee, where it was suggested to establish an ad hoc committee for further

Paj 14

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 8

input. Given the Silver Lake Commission's status as an established committee, she decided to present the information to them, valuing their input.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Arndt stated that there would be a public process, which would include a public hearing prior to any vote on a name change.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Arndt asked for input on changing the requirement to having twenty-five signatures to move the consideration forward.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Arndt stated that in order to move the process forward the request would have to have the support of the neighborhood and then the request would come before council for a public hearing. She explained that she chose fifty percent as the requirement from the street naming procedure, but she is open to a different proposed number.

Mr. Boggerty expressed concerns about the process of naming a park that is not specifically located in a neighborhood. He recommended that the ordinance include language stating that if the park is situated in an established neighborhood, the requestor would need the support of that neighborhood.

Mr. Sudler expressed his support of using fifty percent of the property owners in conjunction with renters. He explained that having a park naming process will help preserve the historical knowledge of someone who was once there and provide the community the opportunity to learn about why that name is so significant.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Arndt stated that the evaluation criteria was based on her research and was designated as historical significance, geographic location, contribution to the community, alignment with community values, public sentiment, and support. The names would have to reflect the cultural, historical, and natural heritage of Dover to be considered. Any corporate or commercial names would not generally be considered unless there was a significant and longstanding contribution to the community. She further explained that in the application process, it would be on the requestor to put forward the documentation and justification in support of their proposal so that the members of council and the public could consider their request.

Mr. Sudler recommended including a few examples to help guide the requestor through the process, he used Mayor Christiansen as an example.

Mayor Christiansen provided the history of Holden Park. He explained that Mr. Holden was a longtime contractor for the City of Dover, and he built most of the houses in Lincoln Park. Mayor Christiansen also stated that Schutte Park is named after the family that sold the property to the City of Dover. He explained that they wanted $2 million for the property however, Councilman VanSant and himself sat down with the Schutte family and saved the city $500,000 by promising to name the park after their family.

Paj 15

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 9

Mr. Anderson suggested that instead of the two-thirds rule, a majority rule would be more appropriate, citing that it currently takes two-thirds to override a mayor’s veto, thereby providing a balanced approach. Additionally, he recommended using a fixed number for the petition requirement rather than a percentage of property owners. He pointed out that there are many situations where parks do not directly border neighborhoods or where property owners live out of state or own multiple properties.

Mr. Rocha expressed support for using a fixed number for the petition rather than fifty percent as well.

Dr. Pillsbury expressed support for using a fixed number for the petition. She explained that twenty-five people is a reasonable number to move the request forward and onto an agenda.

Mr. Tholstrup recommended that the language include the requirement for the park to be within a certain radius of a neighborhood, considering that some parks do not directly border a neighborhood. He also suggested requiring a plaque that details the history of the person being honored, ensuring their story is preserved for future generations.

Mr. Lewis expressed his support of the fifty percent requirement for the petition and not excluding any renters from signing the petition.

Ms. Arndt explained that her intent was never to exclude renters, when she said property owners, she meant a resident with an address that could be verified.

Mr. Sudler moved to recommend deferring the item back to staff to create an ordinance and have it brought back to the committee for review. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson) and one (1) no (Lewis).

Ms. Arndt moved for adjournment of the Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:44 p.m.

UTILITY COMMITTEE

The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Dr. Pillsbury moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.

Paj 16

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 10

Evaluation of Bids – Well #9 Improvements (Jason Lyon, Director of Water and Wastewater) Mr. Jason Lyon, Director of Water and Wastewater reviewed the background and analysis of the evaluation of bids for Well #9.

Staff recommended awarding the contract to A-Del Construction, for the construction phase of Well #9 Improvements, ITB #24-0026WW, for $1,699,000.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the well was built in 1976, so it is 48 years old.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that he considers this project to be a priority. The project has been on the books for three years and if the city wants to invite additional development into the City of Dover, they are going to need water. He explained that the well can not produce water because it is currently under the floodplain, which does not benefit the city.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that he is fortunate to be a part of the Delaware Consortium for the American Public Works Association, which is composed of folks from all over the state. He explained that they often talk about vendors sticking to the jobs they want to do. They have also heard that the State of Delaware currently has some big projects that are getting federal and state funds which has taken a lot of the vendors. He explained everyone has projects that they are trying to place a bid out for and there are only so many contractors that can do the proposed type of work.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Lyon stated that the project has funding from fiscal year 2024, as well as fiscal year 2025. The funding from 2024 was $1 million, and then once the bids were received it was programmed into the budget for fiscal year 2025.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that Garrison Oak Technical Park is reaching capacity, necessitating increased water usage. He also elaborated that his team is making preparations for marijuana cultivation within the city, alongside plans for shared use of the airport to attract more businesses, all of which could potentially increase water demand.

Mr. Lyon also mentioned that integrating the wells into the same pressure system allows for redundancy. In the event of a catastrophic occurrence, such as the loss of a well or prolonged power outage, the city could rely on wells across different parts of the system to maintain water supply for the main distribution system and fire protection needs.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that they are all on one pressure system, so a well on one side of town could potentially provide water on the other side of town.

Paj 17

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 11

Janelle Barrett, Dover Country Club, Dover, questioned if assessments were done prior to the bid being made, and was there an outline as to the method of construction that would be used in the process. She further questioned if a torque test was done to grade the type of soil necessary and see if there was a soil stabilization method that could be used to formulate a method of drainage. She explained that a slope in the land may assist as a runoff mechanism.

Responding to Ms. Barrett, Mr. Lyon stated that they have done soil samples to gauge the soil stability and what can be put there as far as weight and structure. He also explained that due to the location of the area and the classification in the flood plain, it is not feasible to do a diversion because of the topography and the way the stream runs around the house.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation and the motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha.

Mr. Sudler expressed concern with the lack of bids from contractors.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the proposed contractor has been used by the State of Delaware numerous times along with the Town of Smyrna and the Town of Middletown.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon explained that the local vendor preference does not mean that they get paid less money. The local vendor preference is extended through the bidding process to entice local vendors to work on city projects. For example, if there were two bidders and both bid a hundred dollars on a project and one happened to be in the City of Dover limits and one was not, then they would get a three percent reduction in the evaluated price.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson) and one (1) no (Lewis).

Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 7:03 p.m.

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.

Paj 18

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 12

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

Evaluation of Bids – Garrison Oak Steel (Paul Waddell, Electric Director) Mr. Paul Waddell, Electric Director reviewed the background and analysis of the evaluation of bids for Garrison Oak Steel.

Staff recommended awarding the contract to AUI, Bid #24-0037EL, for the amount of $162,688.82.

Mr. Sudler moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson) and one (1) no (Lewis).

Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 – Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (Except Police), Division 3. – General Employee Pension Plan Council President Anderson and Dr. Pillsbury reviewed the background for Proposed Ordinance #2024-07.

General Employee Pension Plan Board recommended approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-07.

Mr. Neil moved to recommend approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-07. The motion was seconded by Mr. Boggerty.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson stated that the board has been a part of the process, and they unanimously adopted the ordinance after a thorough review of each change.

Dr. Pillsbury stated that the ordinance had not been updated in a long time and that the General Employee Pension Plan Board reviewed it line by line even after seeking a legal opinion about concerns raised. She recommended that if any other city documents are that old and out of date they need to be reviewed before they become a liability.

Mr. Neil moved to recommend approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-07.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8)

Paj 19

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 13

yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson) and one (1) no (Lewis).

Discussion – Possible Moratorium on Recreational Marijuana Land Uses While Considering Zoning Regulations to Address Such Uses (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ann Marie Townshend, Rossi Group) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ann Marie Townshend, Rossi Group, reviewed the proposed moratorium on recreational marijuana land uses.

Staff recommended forwarding Resolution No. 2024-11 to city council with a recommendation of approval.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Townshend stated that it is doubtful for the city to be shut out of the program. She explained that businesses can begin applying for licenses for cultivation on the first of September and the first licenses will be issued on the first of November. After the initial issuance of permits, they will be staggered, and they will only be for cultivation as it is the most important to get out because there is no product without them. Ms. Townshend further explained that when the licenses are initially issued, they are not location-dependent. However, the license holders have 18 months to secure a location after the license has been issued. She explained that they are hoping to move forward by November, but the moratorium gives them the ability to take the extra time so that if licenses are issued and license holders are looking for locations, the city’s procedure is not unclear.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Townshend stated that the survey was pushed out through a Facebook post, and it contains a web link so that you do not need Facebook to access it. She also explained that the survey data is being collected through the electronic platform Constant Contact.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Townshend mentioned that she would discuss with Kay Sass to ensure that paper copies of the survey are made available.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Marney mentioned that including a paper copy with utility billing before July 21, 2024, would be extremely challenging. She explained that sending out a newsletter costs around $2,000-$3,000, not including postage, which is why they use Constant Contact.

Mr. Sudler recommended moving the survey deadline to August to fully capture the voice of the constituents.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Townshend stated that Constant Contact is the platform being used to collect the data.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Townshend stated that, to the best of her knowledge, Kay Sass will be the only one with access to the platform. She also

Paj 20

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 14

explained that the Constant Contact platform will collect, analyze, and provide reports on the data.

Mr. Sudler recommended using SurveyMonkey because it outputs reports as PDFs, which prevents manipulation of the data.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Townshend stated that they should be able to separate the data by council districts. She further explained that about twenty-nine percent of people who have completed the survey so far have stated that they do not live in the city.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Ms. Townshend explained that they included districts in the survey so that elected officials could understand the views of their constituents.

Mr. Boggerty asked whether the state has considered offering leniency, dropping charges, or releasing individuals with past marijuana offenses from incarceration.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Townshend stated that she had not seen anything, but she could research the topic.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townshend stated that she was not aware of any protections on the survey to prevent multiple submissions, but she would check with Ms. Sass. She explained that some platforms prevent multiple submissions from the same IP address and that she would find out if this applies. Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townshend clarified that implementing the moratorium would not prevent someone from applying for a license, as they do not need an approved location at the time of application. She explained that they are still hopeful to complete everything by November, but it is important for applicants to understand that their license will be on hold until the location issues are resolved.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townshend stated that applicants have 18 months from the time their license is issued to find a location. She added that the moratorium is set to expire at the end of the year, so the issues would need to be resolved before then, ensuring that applicants are not significantly delayed within their 18-month period.

Mayor Christiansen expressed support for moving the survey period to the end of August to allow everyone the opportunity to participate. He explained that the moratorium is fitting as it does not hinder anyone while allowing the city to work within the confines to resolve the issue promptly. He further explained that council should consider incorporating public opinion and research while not inhibiting anyone from having the opportunity to apply for a license, whether it is for the city or someplace else.

Paj 21

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 15

Mr. Sudler moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation, extending the survey closing date to August 31, 2024, and having an update brought back to a Legislative, Finance, and Administration meeting. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt.

Mr. Anderson expressed support for extending the survey. However, he did not recommend extending it beyond the date of the Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting that was scheduled to be held on August 5, 2024.

Mr. Anderson requested that the petitions from Puffster be added to the record (Attachment #2 and Attachment #3).

Responding to Mr. Hare, Mr. Rocha stated that in the special meeting to be held on August 5, 2024, Mr. Hugg and Ms. Townshend will provide an update on the consensus at the time. The goal of the meeting will be to put the wheels in motion and know where council is standing at that point but continue to gather survey information through the end of the month.

Ms. Arndt recommended extending the survey deadline to July 31 or August 1 to allow sufficient time to analyze the data before the August 5, 2024, meeting.

Ms. Marney stated that if council would like to send the survey out in the utility bills, customer service would need to have 25,000 copies by July 15, 2024. To better reach all of the customers the survey would need to be included with the July 15, 2024, and August 15, 2024, utility bills. She also recommended including a note that all responses must be received either by mail, dropped at city offices, or responded to online by August 31, 2024.

Cynthia Christiansen, 714 Carol Street, Dover, expressed her opposition to allowing retail marijuana stores downtown. She also explained that it was mentioned that a water survey was sent out via the electric bill, but she did not receive it nor did friends in south Dover and west Dover. Ms. Christiansen expressed her support for the moratorium and explained that city staff and the Rossi Group should not be collecting and analyzing the data. She questioned if all the addresses on the petition that was submitted had been checked for accuracy and explained that she was unaware petitions could be submitted.

Mr. Sudler stated that he agreed with Ms. Christiansen and that a third party that is not linked to the city should oversee the collection and distribution of the data of the survey. This would make sure that the process could withstand public scrutiny and bring validity to the findings.

Ms. Arndt stated that she disagreed with the thought of a third party because the city has hired a neutral consultant, who does not take one position or another. The consultant is to guide council through the process. She further stated that a professional planner has an ethics component that they must adhere to as a part of

Paj 22

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 16

their professional certification. She explained that the Rossi Group can analyze the survey data as they have been hired to do.

Mr. Anderson stated that he agreed with Ms. Arndt and recommended that the data be preserved once it has been collected, analyzed, and compiled so that anyone from the public could review it.

Joan Denney, 350 N. State Street, Dover, expressed her support for the moratorium. She explained that she opposes the retail sale of marijuana but feels differently about medical marijuana. She feels that anyone with a prescription should have access to medical marijuana. Ms. Denney also explained that many senior citizens do not have computer access and she believes taking paper surveys to the Modern Maturity Center would be a great benefit. She also explained that she pays her utility bill online, so when the paper copy arrives, she often files it away without opening it. She suggested that this might be something to consider. Ms. Denney stated that the National Institute of Health has a section called the National Institute of Drug Abuse and she recommends that everyone take time to look up their most recent meeting regarding marijuana.

Faye White, 101 Babb Drive, Dover, explained that at Luther Village and Luther Towers marijuana and all drugs are prohibited, especially marijuana. She explained that they are prohibited from medical marijuana on the premises and could lose their homes.

Mr. Lewis explained that he was willing to bring the surveys to gain their opinion if they felt that the city should or should not allow the retail sale of marijuana.

Michael Pugh, 31 Ann Avenue, Dover, questioned if customer service would be able to prepare all the documents by July 15, 2024, or if there would be logistical problems getting that completed. After Mr. Hugg confirmed that the surveys would be able to go out, he also suggested that it be included on the city website. Mr. Pugh stated that council needs to consider putting copies of the survey at places such as Delaware Technical Community College, Delaware State University, and the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce. He explained that certain groups of people tend to lean in specific directions, so it would be wise to include those locations.

Scott Kidner, 3 Shinnecock Road, Dover, expressed support for the moratorium. Mr. Kidner stated that council is faced with the tough decision of whether they will allow the establishment of various aspects of recreational marijuana within city limits. He explained that council has been very supportive of the Downtown Dover Partnership and the vision for the downtown Dover district. Mr. Kidner stated that he does not believe that allowing the recreational sales distribution downtown aligns with that vision.

Taylor Collins, 202 North American Avenue, Dover, expressed opposition to the moratorium. She further stated that the latest issue of AARP reported that

Paj 23

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 17

marijuana sales generated $27 billion in income in 2022. Ms. Collins reviewed a conversation between her and Nicole Chick, owner of Puffsters (Attachment #4).

Nicole Chick, 510 Kirkwood Highway, Wilmington, Delaware, expressed opposition to the moratorium. Ms. Chick stated that she feels that the survey is important to collect feedback from the city however, she does not feel it is right for her business to be impacted by the time it takes to collect the data. She reviewed the petitions she submitted in support of her business (Attachment #2 and Attachment #3). Ms. Chick requested council consider giving her business a grandfathered exception so that she may transition her business.

Ms. Chick read a letter from the Downtown Dover Partnership relaying their stance on the legalization of marijuana retail sales or related issues in downtown Dover (Attachment #5).

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated the city does not directly receive any of the proceeds from the sale of marijuana beyond a business license. He explained that manufacturing or cultivation could generate considerable revenue from both water and electric consumption. However, the city does not directly collect any revenue outside of the standard business license fees.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that if someone bought a building, they would have to pay a transfer tax, property tax, and any other retail business fees but there would be no additional revenue outside of those.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that the distribution of proceeds was set forth in the state law. He explained that the state law states that the state gets the revenue and there is no revenue sharing. He stated that the General Assembly could potentially decide to share a portion of the proceeds, but to the best of his knowledge, there have been no discussions on that possibility.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Hugg stated that his opinion about marijuana is irrelevant, and the city needs to address the provisions of the state law that allow municipalities to adopt regulations relating to marijuana activities in terms of where they are located or how they operate.

Amber Ember, 115 West Loockerman Street, Dover, expressed opposition to the moratorium. Ms. Ember stated that allowing Puffster to expand its business would provide a legal dispensary for safe marijuana. She explained that she found out that her friend, father, and downtown Dover employee Jose Colombo passed away over the weekend from a fentanyl overdose. Ms. Ember asked council to prevent these deaths by allowing downtown Dover access to safer marijuana.

Ethan Whitsett, 226 Chenault Court, Dover, expressed his support for Puffster and his interest in becoming a cannabis cultivator.

Paj 24

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 18

Jeannie Anderson, 217 Cecil Street, Dover, expressed support for the sale of retail marijuana. She stated that people are turning to the streets to obtain pain medication and they are continuing to die from fentanyl.

Mr. Sudler moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation, extending the survey closing date to August 31, 2024, and having an update brought back to a Legislative, Finance, and Administration meeting. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried with Mr. Anderson voting no, and Mr. Lewis abstaining.

Mr. Sudler moved to have a hard copy of the survey placed in with the electric bills and have the city manager provide council with a memo on the logistics of doing so. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and carried with Mr. Anderson, Ms. Arndt, and Mr. Shevock, voting no.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson) and one (1) no (Lewis).

Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:06 p.m.

Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:06 p.m.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson) and one (1) no (Lewis).

QUARTERLY REPORTS – MAY 2024

Quarterly Revenue Report as of June 30, 2024 Quarterly Review – Capital Investment Plan (CIP) (April, May, and June)

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Quarterly Reports, seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson) and one (1) no (Lewis).

APPOINTMENTS/REAPPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY MAYOR

CHRISTIANSEN

By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Rocha, the following appointments/reappointments were accepted by consent agenda:

Paj 25

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 19

Board of Adjustment:

Christian Joshua Swalm – One-Year Term to Expire July 2025 (to fill the unexpired term of E. Jane Warren) Richard D. Senato – Three-Year Term to Expire July 2027

Planning Commission:

Andrea B. Maucher – Second District – Three-Year Term to Expire June
2027
William L. Witham, Jr. – Second District – Three-Year Term to Expire
June 2027

APPOINTMENTS/REAPPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT

Economic Development Committee – One-Year Term to Expire May 13, 2025
Kim I. Adams – Minority Voting Member
Clayton E. Hammond – Minority Voting Member

By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Rocha, the Economic Development Committee was accepted by consent agenda.

Interview Committee for Controller/Treasurer
Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt – Chair
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman Fred A. Neil
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha

Ms. Arndt made a motion to approve the Interview Committee for Controller/Treasurer, seconded by Mr. Neil.

During the Council meeting. Mr. Lewis stated that the item be pulled from the discussion to make a motion regarding it.

Mr. Lewis made a motion to include Human Resources Director Naomi Poole on the committee to ensure a transparent process with an elevated level of integrity. He additionally recommended that Councilman Roy Sudler be added as a committee member. Mr. Lewis further amended his motion to include Mayor Christensen. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that he still has to have a motion and a second. He noted that Ms. Poole is part of the hiring process, and that council would be part of an ex officio member of the committee. Ms. Poole would be directing it, just not be a voting member, because that would be a council hire.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Lewis stated that he was aware of it, but he wanted to put it on the record and put it into motion format. He further stated that he does want Ms. Poole on the committee and that was the motion he was making.

Paj 26

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 20

Responding to Mr. Hare, Mr. Anderson stated that they could have five (5) council members on the interview committee, and they have to have the same notice and quorum, so it could be done.

Mr. Hare noted that if those five (5) decide who they want to hire, then the rest of council does not have a say.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Mr. Anderson stated if the committee members are unanimous, that would be part of the purpose of having a four-member committee. The Human Resources Director would not be a voting member but would be present as a professional to guide the committee.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hare stated that if they are going to have five (5) members on the committee, they might as well have all of council so they can all discuss, and if it comes back that the five (5) people on the committee come back and say here is who they want, then it does not matter what they think.

Mr. Boggerty stated that he could not be on the committee because he knew one of the applicants and he wanted to make sure that it was integral. He further stated that he is challenged by the statement that the process was to be questioned to make sure it was integral as if his colleagues do not have integrity. He believes that it is outlandish to think that these individuals who have served and represented the city, continued to represent the city for their integrity to be questioned for a hire. He noted that for his colleagues to be considered less than integral in a hiring process speaks volumes of what they think of each other. Mr. Boggerty stated that he would be opposed to this due to questioning his colleague's integrity.

Mr. Anderson pointed out that the same committee that was originally appointed by the past council president and everyone consented to with the backup member was Dr. Pillsbury. The only difference was that the chair was not named at the time.

Mr. Lewis stated that his concern is that he has been told that current members of the committee have expressed support for one particular candidate. He is bringing it to everyone’s attention and to the public to ensure transparency. He emphasized the importance of having Ms. Poole present, especially when adding someone to the committee. He concurred with Mr. Hare, suggesting that all council members could be on the committee, as they would ultimately make the final decision and handle the hiring.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Boggerty stated that he questioned the integrity of their colleagues and to clarify his statement, he already made a statement that the Human Resources Director would be part of the process. Mr. Boggerty noted that he just restated what he said and that it was recorded.

Ms. Arndt stated that she agreed to be on the committee and asked to be chair. She assured them that she would chair with the utmost integrity, pledging to conduct due diligence in interviewing, selecting, and evaluating candidates. She assumed that the Human Resources Director would be involved throughout the process to guide them and ensure that everything was conducted properly. Ms. Arndt also expressed concerns about having all nine members on the interview committee, citing potential scheduling challenges and the difficulty of coordinating interviews

Paj 27

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 21

with each candidate. She believes that this approach would not be feasible.

Dr. Sudler stated that the current tension was not reflecting the best spirit of the city council and its collaborative nature. Despite his expertise and doctorate in workplace behavior, he felt that he would not be a valuable asset to the committee. He declined to participate due to his observations and feelings about the situation. Dr. Sudler emphasized that the council could perform better collectively and noted that seniors perceive them as divided and not unified. He pointed out that much of the division is personal, which ultimately affects their ability to work together. Dr. Sudler expressed hope that council members with personal issues would resolve them, as their lack of unity is detrimental. He reminded the council that their role is to represent constituents and that they deserve the council's best efforts.

Mr. Hare believed that the four (4) members of the committee would do an excellent job, they are going to interview the candidates and recommend the top two (2) or three (3), for further consideration. He emphasized that the committee is not a hiring committee; its role is to provide recommendations on candidates. The final candidates will still be interviewed by the council.

Dr. Sudler declined to serve as a member of the committee. Mr. Lewis rescinded his motion.

Ms. Arndt made a motion for the approval of the interview committee as presented, seconded by Mr. Neil, and carried unanimously.

PROPOSED CANCELLATION OF AUGUST 26 AND 27, 2024 MEETINGS

Dr. Sudler moved to approve the cancellation of the August 26th Council Meeting and August 27th, Committee of the Whole Meetings for 2024, seconded by Mr. Hare and was unanimously carried.

TENTATIVE LABOR CONTRACT WITH DOVER ORGANIZATION OF

EMPLOYEES (DOE)

Mr. Hugg briefed members on the Tentative Labor Contract with the Dover Organization of Employees (DOE).

Mr. Neil moved to adopt the Dover Organization of Employees Labor Contract, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

TENTATIVE LABOR CONTRACT WITH INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF

ELECTRICAL WORKERS (IBEW)

Mr. Hugg briefed members on the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)

Dr. Sudler moved to approve the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Contract, seconded by Mr. Hare, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-07 – AMENDING CHAPTER 80 – PERSONNEL, ARTICLE IV – PENSION PLANS AND RETIREMENT BENEFITS (EXCEPT POLICE), DIVISION 3. – GENERAL EMPLOYEE PENSION PLAN Council President Anderson reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available on the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com under “Government”, or by

Paj 28

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 22

contacting the City Clerk’s Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us. Final action by council on the proposed ordinance will take place during the Council Meeting of August 12, 2024.

In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:

ORDINANCE #2024-07 – AMENDING CHAPTER 80 – PERSONNEL,
ARTICLE IV – PENSION PLANS AND RETIREMENT BENEFITS (EXCEPT
POLICE), DIVISION 3. – GENERAL EMPLOYEE PENSION PLAN

FINAL READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-27 – AMENDING

APPENDIX F – FEES AND FINES: CHAPTER 82 – PLANNING, APPENDIX A – SUBDIVISIONS, APPENDIX B – ZONING (DAVID S. HUGG, III, CITY MANAGER, AND DAWN MELSON-WILLIAMS, PRINCIPAL PLANNER)) The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of July 8, 2024. Council President Anderson reminded members of the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available on the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com under “Government”.

Mr. Neil moved that the Final Reading of the proposed ordinance be acknowledged by title only, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and unanimously carried.

Mr. David Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-27 – Amending Appendix F – Fees and Fines: Chapter 82 – Planning, Appendix A – Subdivisions, Appendix B – Zoning.

By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, by a roll call vote, eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), and one (1) no (Lewis) adopted Ordinance #2024-22 as follows:

BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:

That Appendix F – Fees and Fines, Chapter 82. - Planning be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, font and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows:

Chapter 82. – Planning

Chapter 82. Planning Fees and Fines Sec. 82-3. Planning services (a) Zoning verification letters/administrative interpretations $60.00 per letter/interpretation

BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:

Paj 29

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 23

That Appendix F – Fees and Fines, Appendix A. – Subdivisions be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows:

Appendix A. – Subdivisions

Appendix A. Subdivisions Fees and Fines Article IV. Subdivision—Procedure Subsec. A.2. Preapplication; filing fee $225.00 Subsec. B.2. Preliminary layout; filing fee $350.00 Subsec. C.3. Plat; review fee $225.00, plus $85.00 per acre for the first ten acres, $60.00 per acre for the next ten acres and $45.00 per acre for each acre thereafter Subsec. C.3. Plat; review fee—Minor lot line adjustment Plats for minor lot line adjustments shall require a review fee of $200.00 Subsec. C.3. Plat; review fee—Minor subdivision Plats for minor subdivisions shall require a review fee of $200.00 plus $20.00 per lot

BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:

That Appendix F – Fees and Fines, Appendix B. – Zoning be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows:

Appendix B. Zoning

Appendix B. Zoning Fees and Fines Article 3. District Regulations Sec. 24. Planned Neighborhood Design option (PND) Subsec. 24.2. Review process—General sketch plan review fee, each $150.00 application Subsec. 24.8. Conditional use plan approval Subsec. 24.81. Plan approval fee, each application $250.00, plus $20.00 per acre Subsec. 24.9. Site development preliminary subdivision plan review Subsec. 24.91. Preliminary plan approval fee; each application $350.00, plus $25.00 per acre Subsec. 24.10. Final subdivision plat approval

Paj 30

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 24

Subsec. 24.101. Final subdivision plat approval; each application$300.00
Sec. 28. Traditional Neighborhood Design Zone (TND)
Subsec. 28.4. Procedure; application for rezoning of a land area to a
TND zone
Subsec. 28.411. Minimum fee; each rezoning petition$350.00
Subsec. 28.422. Implementation plan approval; each application$350.00, plus $10.00
per acre
Subsec. 28.434. Site development plan or subdivision plat; each$300.00
application
Article 5. Supplementary Regulations
Section 4. Supplementary sign regulations
Subsec. 4.8. Unified campuses and complexes
Subsec. D.4. Submission requirements; application fee$250.00, due at time
of application
Subsec. 4.9. Supplementary sign provisions
Subsec. D.1. Temporary signs; permit$50.00
Article 9. Board of Adjustment
Sec. 3. Procedure
Subsec. 3.4. All variance requests and appeals from an order,
requirement, decision or determination made by an administrative
official, board, or agency of the city shall be accompanied by a fee
All variance requests for residential uses$325.00
All variance requests for nonresidential uses$625.00
All appeals from an order, requirement, decision, or determination$300.00
made by an administrative official, board, or agency of the city
The board of adjustment may, in its discretion, return to the applicant
part or all of the fee paid by him in the event that his appeal under
section 2.1 (interpretation) hereof is partially or wholly successful. The
fees filed in connection with applications under section 2.2 (variances)
shall not be returnable, regardless of disposition of the case by the board
Article 10. Planning Commission
Sec. 1. Approval of conditional uses
Subsec. 1.52. Application procedure; conditional use permit; each$450.00, plus $25.00
applicationper acre of the area or
multiple thereof
involved in the
application
Sec. 2. Site development plan approval
Subsec. 2.42. Fees—Application for administrative site plans$325.00
Subsec. 2.43. Fees—Application for site development plan approval$450.00 plus $25 per
acre
Sec. 3. Historic district commission and architectural review
Subsec. 3.26. Procedures for an architectural review by the historic
district commission or planning commission
Subsec. (b) Application and fee for an architectural review$250.00

Paj 31

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 25

certificate Sec. 5. Amendments Subsec. 5.32. Application. Each application for a zoning map amendment: Minimum fee, in addition to required district supplemental fee $450.00 One-family residence zones (R-8, R-10, R-15, and R-20); $25.00 per acre supplemental fee General residence zones, Medium density residence zones, and $50.00 per acre Mobile home park zones (RG-0, RG-1, RG-2, RG-3, RG-5, RM-1, RM- 2, and MH); supplemental fee Commercial and office (C-1, C-1A, C-2, C-2A, C-3, C-4, CPO, RC $75.00 per acre and IO); supplemental fee Shopping center development (SC-1, SC-2 and SC-3); supplemental $75.00 per acre fee Industrial zones (M, IPM, IPM2, and IPM3); supplemental fee $75.00 per acre

BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:

That the Effective Date of this schedule of application fees be established as September 1, 2024, and any application filed to meet an application filing deadline set for after September 1, 2024, be subject to these new rates.

ADOPTED: July 22, 2024

CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mr. Hugg discussed that the labor union contracts are nearing resolution, with only the fourth and final contract with AFSCME remaining. The main challenge is coordinating a date when all parties are available to meet and finalize the agreements.

MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mayor Christiansen noted that there would be several fun events coming in August and early September because he is the fun mayor.

COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS

Ms. Arndt wanted to wish Mr. Anderson a happy birthday, which is on July 29th.

Mr. Boggerty stated that he was contacted directly by Health and Human Services at the federal level to ensure that they received COVID-19 tests. They asked how many COVID-19 tests he wanted and had received a total of 100,000 COVID-19 tests for the city and surrounding areas and committed some to Delaware State University. He mentioned that Delaware State University would receive 6,000 COVID-19 tests, down south would receive 1,000, and abroad. Mr. Boggerty noted that if anyone’s organization would like newer COVID-19 tests, please let him know. He wanted to thank Mr. Wolfgang and his team for unloading 18 pallets of COVID-19 tests. Those tests are in the city warehouse. He wanted to thank Ms. Sass for all her work, as well. Mr. Boggerty announced that on July 27, 2024, from 9:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m., a drive-up distribution event will be held in the City Hall parking lot where people can collect as many

Paj 32

Item #2.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JULY 22, 2024 PAGE 26

COVID-19 tests as needed. Lanes will be set up in both directions for efficient distribution.

Mr. Rocha announced that on Monday, July 29, 2024, there will be a three (3)-on three (3) basketball tournament at the Capital Green basketball court. He also noted that Dr. Sudler would be cooking out at the event. This community event, which will run from 4:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m., is an excellent opportunity for everyone to come out and enjoy the festivities.

Mr. Anderson stated that the Dover Police National Night Out is on August 6, 2024, at Dover High School, starting at 6:00 p.m. This is a big event that people from all over the city and elsewhere very much enjoy. He encourages everyone to participate.

The meeting adjourned at 7:20 p.m.

ANDRIA BENNETT CITY CLERK

All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by the City Council during their Regular Meeting of July 22, 2024, are hereby approved.

ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR

/AB

Exhibits
Exhibit #1 – Nick Attard’s BOA Appeal Statement

Paj 33

EXHIBIT #1

Regular City Council Meeting of 07/22/2024
Item #2.

From: Nathan Attard
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Public Comment re: BOA appeal
Date: Monday, July 22, 2024 7:27:20 PM

Some people who received this message don't often get email from nateattard@gmail.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. My name is Nate Attard and I am the president of the Friends of Old Dover.

On June 17, myself and 19 members of our organization wanted to provide comments to the Planning Commission on the appeal of the historic district commission regarding the demolition of 148-150 S. Bradford Street.. We were not allowed based on a staff determination we believe to be incorrect. Items said by this staff person contradict our City Code and the requirements for the Planning Commission when they conduct architectural review certification. Not even the commissioners of the Historic District Commission got to speak. The public hearing was supposed to be the one conducted for the historic district commission, but minutes were only provided at the beginning of the meeting. In contrast, the DDP was allowed to state their case from their perspective, with five presenters, in a way greatly changed from how they presented to the Historic District Commission. But the public got to say nothing.

Citizens, groups, and even city boards and commissions can challenge an order, requirement, decision, or determination made by an administrative official of the City of Dover in the enforcement of the zoning ordinance through the Board of Adjustment. We wrote up a letter outlining our case against this staff person, and looked forward to it being heard on July 17.

The ability for any citizen or group to take this action is enshrined in the City of Dover Zoning Code, Article 9, and is not an authority unique to Dover but required of the city by state law, as written in Delaware Code Title 22, Chapter 3, Subsection II.

Instead of City staff receiving it for what it was, our desire for answers on why the decision was made to prevent public comment on June 17, it was written on the agenda as an appeal against the decision, when we sought an appeal against the staff determination. This created an us versus them movement with the Friends as “plan opponents” when we just sought the opportunity to speak and be heard. Had we had the chance to speak on June 17, there would have been no July 17 appeal. And if we could have spoken July 17, we would have set the record state that plan supporters were also public participation opponents.

The board of adjustment declined to hear our case, but only the morning of July 17. This decision was made after discussion in executive session, we had no opportunity to address the Board of Adjustment and have few insights into their justification. We continue to believe an appeal through the Board of Adjustment is an appropriate forum to hear grievances against

Paj 34

Item #2.

administrative officers. We received little information as to why this appeal was not heard, other than hearing from the media that it was based on a recent Superior Court decision on another case, Mishoe, et al. v. City of Dover Mayor and City Council, et al. which is an appeal of a complex project instead of an appeal based on the actions of an administrative officer of the City.

This is the last place I wanted to be tonight. I thought I was a supporter of the City and its downtown master plan, Capital City 2030. You have lost me. The plan you have rallied behind is not the plan that was crafted through a deliberate process. Many people would like to say this, but have been silenced by your staff. I will not go on as to my feelings on the plan further as I am here tonight about how staff actions are silencing those trying to speak up. Dover deserves a first class project. We are getting a single use parking garage the type that other cities are tearing down.

In conclusion, given the Board of Adjustment would not hear our case or speak to us on this matter, we are asking you to either let our case be heard as it should, as a complaint against an administrative officer, or return our appeal fee. I implore you to seek answers as to why our city is silencing members of the public through staff and solicitor actions.i also implore you to consider how actions like this violate the Delaware Open Meetings Law, where all boards and commissions must have the opportunity for the public to address decision makers. In this case, the Planning Commission is the decision maker, and they did not hear our concerns.

Thank you for your time.

Paj 35

Item #3.

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE

The Council Committee of the Whole met on July 23, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Hare, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury (via WebEx), Mr. Rocha, and Mr. Sudler. Mr. Lewis was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Shevock (via WebEx), and Mr. Garfinkel (Legislative, Finance, and Administration). Dr. Jackson-Short, Ms. Smack (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation), and Mr. Iriowen (Utility) were absent.

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.

SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE

The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairman Boggerty presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Rocha moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.

Discussion – City of Dover Emergency Operations Plan (Kay Sass, Public Affairs and Emergency Management Coordinator) Ms. Kay Sass, Public Affairs and Emergency Management Coordinator, reviewed the background of the Emergency Operations Plan.

Staff recommended approving staff to send the City of Dover Emergency Operations Plan to the State of Delaware for acceptance of the 2024 Updated EOP.

Mr. Rocha moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.

Mr. Boggerty moved for adjournment of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:04 p.m.

UTILITY COMMITTEE

The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Ms. Arndt moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.

Paj 36

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JULY 23, 2024 PAGE 2

Item #3.

Discussion – Possible Moratorium on Any Program Requiring Backflow Preventers (Council President David L. Anderson) Mr. David L. Anderson, Council President, reviewed the background to the Proposed Resolution No. 2024-12 and the memorandum written by Mr. Neil (Attachment #1).

Staff recommended forwarding Resolution No. 2024-12 to City Council with a recommendation of approval.

Mayor Christiansen stated that the single-feed water supplies that fed building sprinkler systems were made out of scheduled pipe which contained a silicone lining so that the pipe would not rust away. The original intent of the backflow prevention device was to keep water from the sprinkler system from leaching back into the potable also known as drinking water supply. He explained that the legislation requiring everyone to put backflow prevention devices on systems other than sprinkler systems, which is required by the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), is a severe overreach. He stated that unless the potable water system feeds not only the drinkable, unusable water in a household but also when it supplies a closed heating system or something similar, it has been shown that domestic backflow prevention devices are usually not effective. Particularly in the case of the City of Dover, the water is cleaned and treated. Furthermore, Mayor Christiansen stated that another overreach by the state was when they required fluoride to be added to the water, in combination with chlorine, which was a federal mandate, and in turn created the current water in the City of Dover. He explained that the current water is not dangerous but the water before the state and federal mandates was pristine. In closing, Mayor Christiansen expressed support for the moratorium.

Mr. Sudler expressed support for the moratorium. He explained that it is extremely difficult to obtain the required backflow prevention mechanism and inspection report currently being required because there is a lack of agencies certified to conduct that type of inspection. He stated that the agencies that are certified to do the inspection are not in the vicinity of the City of Dover. Since many plumbing agencies do not have the certification, it has become alarming for businesses. Mr. Sudler stated that a restaurant business reached out to him and explained that the plumbing agencies they contacted could not perform the inspection. They were concerned about not complying within the allotted timeframe and facing a penalty. Mr. Sudler recommended educating the business owners, merchants, and private sector, as to why the backflow preventers are important and who is certified to complete the work if the requirement is implemented after the moratorium.

Ms. Arndt stated that she believes there is some flexibility in the state regulations regarding public water supplier requirements and recommends that the city determine what is best for Dover, its business owners, and its citizens. She also expressed her support for the moratorium, allowing the city to review the requirements thoroughly and make the best decisions moving forward.

Mr. Rocha explained that as the trustee that handles the church building that he is a part of they were fortunate that the building was built in 2017, so the fire suppression system was new. He noted that although he missed the deadline, he did not receive a fine and was able to complete the necessary work. He recommended creating a list of the companies certified to do the inspection and placing the information on the City of Dover website. He also stated that the letter has an 800

Paj 37

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JULY 23, 2024 PAGE 3

Item #3.

number that can be called and they will refer one or two companies in the area. He explained that they were fortunate to have a company that services their sprinkler system qualified to do the inspection and completed it during a normal inspection. In closing, Mr. Rocha recommended compiling a list of qualified inspectors to make it easier to find someone to complete the inspection within 90 days when the time comes.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson stated that the moratorium would be effective for one year from the date of adoption, which would likely be August 12, 2024, if adopted.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Rivera stated that the City Clerk’s Office had received several emails in support of Resolution No. 2024-12 (Attachment #2).

Mayor Christiansen stated that backflow prevention devices under the NFPA code are required to be tested annually. He explained that he believes the same requirements are intended for both the residential and business ones as well. He recommended after the moratorium, clarifying that the NFPA regulations on sprinkler systems are still in effect and a report is to be filed with the City of Dover Fire Marshal as well as the State of Delaware Fire Marshal.

Mr. Rocha moved to recommend forwarding Resolution No. 2024-12 to City Council at the next City Council meeting with the recommendation of approval for a moratorium of one year. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson and unanimously carried.

Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:20 p.m.

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Garfinkel moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Update on State Pension (Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director) Ms. Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director, briefed council on the status of joining the State Pension Plan.

Ms. Poole explained that the city manager had drafted a resolution letter of interest with an effective date of January 1, 2024, however, the effective date was later revised in another resolution letter with an effective date of July 1, 2024. The effective date of July 1, 2024, was then changed to October 1, 2024, but the resolution letter was never completed requesting an October date, therefore the State of Delaware Pension Office currently has the effective date of July 1, 2024.

Ms. Poole stated that in terms of the next steps, the city needs to make two policy-related decisions. She explained that the next step will be to decide if all employees will automatically be placed in the pension or if employees will be given a choice to either join the pension to include a city match

Paj 38

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JULY 23, 2024 PAGE 4

Item #3.

or stay in their current 401(k), 457 plan with an included city match. She further explained that a concrete effective date would also need to be established to move forward. The board has already approved two previous date revisions and changing the dates can present approval issues with the board.

Ms. Poole stated that the easier option would be if everyone were placed into a pension, which seems to be the standard practice per the state. She explained that Human Resources would need to identify an exclusions list that would incorporate a list of current employees who are in the General Employee Pension Plan, along with a list of active employees. If the second option were chosen, which may be more taxing, they would also need to identify an exclusion list that would incorporate a list of current employees who are in the General Employee Pension Plan and the employees who wish to remain in the 401(k), 457 plan, as well as a list of active employees. In closing, she stated that once a final option is chosen then a complete resolution letter with a new effective date can be sent to the State of Delaware Pension Office for board approval. She also included that the list of names can be sent at a later date.

Committee Action Not Required.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Poole stated that from a timeline perspective, they would need to establish an effective date so that Human Resources can gather the information required and send it to the pension office.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Poole stated that in order to build the exclusion list Human Resources would need to speak to every employee and have them sign a form stating that they would like to be excluded from the pension plan. She explained that this would prevent anyone from being able to say that they were not included in the process, or that their name was forgotten.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Poole stated that per the state, the only buy-in option that can happen is if the city buys all the employees into the plan. The employees cannot pull from their 401(k), 457 with the hopes of buying into the plan. She explained that it could happen, but it would cost the city a lot.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Poole stated that she is unsure whether there is a cap to the amount that someone can put into their 401(k) under the pension plan but she could investigate that. She also stated that they plan to create a Q&A for the employees.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Poole stated that if the city chooses the pension plan the match for the 401(k) and 457 would remain the same.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Poole stated that she was told during previous discussions that implementation would not have any negative budget effects and that it would be a wash.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Poole stated that all new employees would automatically go into the state plan.

Paj 39

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JULY 23, 2024 PAGE 5

Item #3.

Mr. Neil moved to allow staff to move forward to figure out what additional information is necessary from the employees for council to take action. The motion was seconded by Mr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Poole stated that developing a policy of what they plan to do would be very helpful. She explained that having an effective date in mind would also be helpful in the planning process. Ms. Poole reiterated that they need to decide if they are going to automatically place the employees in the pension plan or if they are going to give them the option to stay in the 401(k), 457 plan, and, or go into the pension plan. Then they must select an effective date that they stick with so that it may be presented to the pension board.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Poole stated that the timing will be dictated by the option that is selected by council.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Poole stated that once a decision has been made then she can help figure out what the effective date needs to be. She also noted that the finance team will need to be included in order to prepare a new pension plan for the city.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Poole stated that while a decision is not immediately necessary, they need to collectively consider the decision and involve Mr. Hugg in the process.

The motion to allow staff to proceed with determining what additional information is needed from employees for the council to take action was rescinded by Mr. Neil and Mr. Sudler.

Mr. Rocha thanked Ms. Poole for bringing council up to date and stated that they will wait for Mr. Hugg to return to collectively come up with a plan and decision.

Discussion – Mayoral Compensation Mayor Christiansen expressed appreciation for the remuneration that council provided the mayor's office. He explained that it is not the money that he appreciates but the fact that council recognized the growing responsibilities that the Mayor of the City of Dover has for economic development and public safety. He explained that he is dedicated to being the voice of those who have no voice and works each day to make sure that the city is a great place to live, work, and play, just as the members of council. He requested that council consider freezing any additional remuneration until after the April 2027 election. In closing, he asked that any future increases for either the Mayor’s Office or the Mayor be by a unanimous vote of council as he feels it would be in the best interest of the next mayor, and the citizens that they serve.

Committee Action Not Required.

Mr. Neil recognized the mayor's desire to defer any increase until after the next election, however, he noted that council faces the same problems as employees. He explained that those problems are the ever-increasing costs caused by inflation. Mr. Neil recommended tying the mayor's remuneration to what is done for the Dover Organization of Employees (DOE), as is done for the council members. He explained that delaying the remuneration becomes a two-part thing. One is the delay for the mayor because he does not want it currently. However, Mr. Neil feels that the

Paj 40

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JULY 23, 2024 PAGE 6

Item #3.

office should go up because the office deserves the same type of increase that the other employees are getting, including the members of council.

Mr. Neil moved to delay the increase for the mayor at his request until the next election and then tie in what the employees are receiving. The motion was seconded by Mr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Sudler, Mayor Christiansen stated that Mr. Sudler's clarification was correct. Council honored him with the $5,000.00 increase but he is asking that there be no further increases until after the next election.

Mr. Neil moved to recommend delaying any further increases for the mayor, at his request, until after the next election, and tie any future increases to what the employees are receiving. The motion was seconded by Mr. Sudler and unanimously carried.

Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:44 p.m.

Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:44 p.m.

David L. Anderson
Council President

Attachments Attachment #1 - Memorandum in support of Resolution No. 2024-12 submitted by Mr. Neil Attachment #2 - Emails in support of Resolution No. 2024-12

Paj 41

ATTACHMENT #1

Council Committee of the Whole Meeting ofItem
7/23/2024
#3.

July 23, 2024

To: Members of the Dover City Council

From: Fred Neil, Chair, Utilities Committee

The City Council received a presentation on this Federally mandated Backflow, but cost aspects of it just caught up with us. In February 2021, Delaware Dept. of Health and Social Services, Division of Public Health mandated a cross-connection control program in Delaware. By February 2024, the City of Dover shall develop and comply with a plan for a cross-connection control program.

Although the presentation provided estimated charges for assessments to the public, what we did not fully comprehend until we were approached by a commercial realtor, there are some serious financial costs associated with the Federal attempt to prevent what occurred in Flint, Michigan where a fall in water pressure caused wastewater to flood back and contaminate the clean water system.

Recognizing the high cost of retrofitting backflow devices on homes and businesses with a small chance of having a backflow problem, Dover Representative Sean Lynn sponsored HB 453, co-sponsored by Senator Trey Paradee and Representative Bill Bush on June 25, 2024. On June 30th, the Bill received 24 votes For and 14 Against, leaving it short of the 2/3rds majority needed.

The public water system has the authority to enforce the cross-connection program. This includes an inventory and record-keeping of testing, repairs and maintenance of all backflow prevention assemblies and policies to complete assessments of customer premises for potential cross-connections. It also includes assessing the type of premise (high or low hazard) and includes public education, Non-compliance with this program shall be subject to penalty up to $10,000 per day.

As stated in Resolution #2024-12, while the Delaware Department of Health has encouraged the backflow preventers be installed, only a long list of specific businesses has been required to do so. In requesting a delay in implementation, it is noted that there is no imminent threat of contamination of the City’s water supply and thus no threat to the health of the public.

Council President Anderson was alerted by a Commercial Realtor of a series of steps to discover problem areas and the initial high cost and then continuing costs to homeowners and small businesses. The Public will be caught up in confusion and concern over financial implications that may not apply to them.

Cross-Connection: A connection or potential connection between any part of a potable water system and any other environment containing other substances in a manner that, under any circumstances, would allow such substances to enter the potable water system.

Paj 42

Item #3.

Backflow Preventer: An assembly, device or method designed to prevent backflow. Containment: Backflow prevention at service connection to public water supply Isolation: Backflow prevention at points of use (sinks, hose bibs, boilers).

The delay will provide the City a chance to find alternatives that will not cause a considerable financial burden on our property owners. By the very nature of the vote, it is possible the legislature will change its mind when the financial costs are verified before the January 2025 Legislative Session when a Bill is expected to be re- introduced.

The delay called for in the Resolution will let staff update and inform us and the public of what to expect as required. This is given that small businesses and residential homeowners are not likely to cause any contamination issues.

Paj 43

ATTACHMENT #2

Council Committee of the Whole Meeting of 7/23/2024 Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: Philip McGinnis <pjm@mcginnisrealty.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 12:51 PM To: City Clerks Office Subject: EXTERNAL: Support Resolution 2024-12, Backflow Preventer Moratorium

Some people who received this message don't often get email from pjm@mcginnisrealty.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear City Council- I urge you to support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers. While I do not dispute that heavy industrial manufacturing users should have backflow preventers, small retail and office users are not going to pollute our water system. The cost of installing these devices far exceeds the benefit and puts our citizens and especially our small businesspeople at great financial hardship. Please let us reconsider this program. Please also consider that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, for example, any properties currently under pressure to install these devices. Thank you very much for your assistance on this very important matter.

Phil McGinnis, CCIM, GAA, ACoM, ALC, e-PRO
McGinnis Commercial Real Estate Company
302-736-2710 office
302-270-0656 cell
mailto:pjm@mcginnisrealty.com

1 Page 43

Paj 44

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: Mike Walsh <mikewalshpt@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 12:58 PM To: City Clerks Office Subject: EXTERNAL: Support Resolution 2024-12, Backflow Preventer Moratorium

Some people who received this message don't often get email from mikewalshpt@gmail.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.

Dear City Council-

I urge you to support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers.

While I do not dispute that heavy industrial manufacturing users should have backflow preventers, small retail and office users are not going to pollute our water system.

The cost of installing these devices far exceeds the benefit and puts our citizens and especially our small businesspeople at great financial hardship.

Please let us reconsider this program.

Please also consider that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, for example, any properties currently under pressure to install these devices.

Thank you very much for your assistance on this very important matter.

Michael Walsh

City of Dover Resident

295 Troon Road, Dover, DE 19904

Michael Walsh, PT, J1-0001730

Owner & General Manager

Mike Walsh Physical Therapy LLC

810 New Burton Road, Suite 2

Dover, DE 19904

1 Page 44

Paj 45

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: Scott R. Brown <sbrown@savantwealth.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 12:59 PM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Resolution 2024-12

Some people who received this message don't often get email from sbrown@savantwealth.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. To Whom it Concerns,

Please note our support of Resolu on 2024-12, the moratorium on backflow preventers. If we are required to add backflow preventers to our building it will be a major unnecessary expense. We have discussed with several plumbers, and they don’t understand the requirement for “standard” office buildings to add the backflow preventers. We have many clients that have also expressed their approval of Resolu on 2024-12 so they can avoid the costly unnecessary expanse as well.

Thank you in advance of passing Resolu on 2024-12.

Sco

Scott R. Brown CPA/PFS
Managing Director, Financial Advisor
Savant Wealth Management
220 Beiser Blvd.
Dover, DE 19904
Office: 302-734-5826
Direct: 302-599-1241
savantwealth.com

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________ Confidential: This message and all contents contain information from Savant Wealth Management ("Savant"), and may be privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure under applicable law. The information is intended to be for the addressee only. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents of this message is prohibited. If you have received this message in error, please notify us immediately by reply email or telephone (866-489-0500) and destroy the original message and all attachments without retaining any copies. Your cooperation is appreciated.

WITHDRAWAL OR TRADE POLICY: SAVANT IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR PLACING ANY TRADES FROM INSTRUCTIONS LEFT VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL OR VOICE MAIL. Please note that we will not act upon withdrawal or trade instructions via electronic mail or voice mail request without first acknowledging a correct understanding of the request with you. If you do not receive a response from us, please contact us by telephone (866-489-0500) to ensure that we received your request.

Please remember to contact Savant, in writing, if there are any changes in your personal financial situation or investment objectives for the purpose of reviewing our previous recommendations and/or services, or if you want to impose or modify any reasonable restrictions to our investment advisory services. Savant shall continue to rely on the accuracy of information that you have provided. Please be advised that there can be no assurance that any email request will be reviewed and/or acted upon on the day it is received. A copy of our current written disclosure Brochure and Form CRS discussing our advisory services and fees continues to remain available for your review upon request or at www.savantwealth.com. 1 Page 45

Paj 46

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: LINCOLN WILLIS <Lincoln.Willis@thewillisgroupllc.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 1:23 PM To: City Clerks Office Subject: EXTERNAL: Dover Business Owner Support Resolution 2024-12, Backflow Preventer Moratorium

Some people who received this message don't often get email from lincoln.willis@thewillisgroupllc.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear Members of the Dover City Council,

I urge you to support Resolution 2024-12, the Moratorium for Backflow Preventers.

While I do not dispute that heavy industrial manufacturing users should have backflow preventers, small retail and office users are not going to pollute our water system.

The cost of installing these devices far exceeds the benefit and puts our citizens and especially our small business owners at great financial hardship.

Please reconsider this program.

Please also consider that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, for example, any properties currently under pressure to install these devices.

I appreciate your attention to this important matter.

Regards,
Lincoln D. Willis

Lincoln D. Willis, Principal
302-632-9898
4 The Green
Dover, DE 19901
Lincoln.Willis@TheWillisGroupLLC.com

“Advancing Your Cause in Delaware.”

******************************************************************************** IRS CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE: IRS regulations require us to notify you that this communication was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by you as the taxpayer, for the purpose of (1) avoiding penalties that the IRS 1 Page 46

Paj 47

Item #3.

MARENGO VENTURES, LLC

15 Kings Hwy.
Dover, DE 19901
David L. Anderson
President City Council
City of Dover

RE: Council Resolution No. 2024-12

Dear Council President Anderson,

First, as property owners in the City, we want to thank you for your strong support of the currently drafted Council Resolution No. 2024-12 that seeks to place a moratorium on the City taking any action related to the installation of “backflow” preventers for low risk commercial and residential buildings and structures for one year.

While we understand the overall importance of protecting the City’s potable water system, we do not believe that the installation and annual inspection (at the expense of the owner) of a separate backflow preventer on the upstream water line for our home and our business provides any measurable protection in the case of a line break and resultant siphonage of water out of our pipes back into the City’s system. Recently during testimony before the Leg. and Fin. Committee, it was learned Dover’s potable water system is interconnected which means that if one pump fails, the other pumps maintain pressure. This means positive flow remains, significantly reducing the chances of water backflow back into the City’s system. v We ask the Utility Committee and then Council to adopt this Resolution in its entirety, and then look to the various business and real estate organizations such as the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce and the Kent County Association of REALTORS to fashion a workable and reasonable solution to the use of backflow preventers in those properties located in Dover that may be considered “high risk” to the City’s water system.

Thank you for your consideration of this matter, and as property owners, we stand ready to work with you and members of the City to address our concerns relating to backflow preventers.

Respectfully,

Scott and Rebecca Kidner
Owners, Marengo Ventures LLC

Paj 48

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: Joan Bestpitch <j7garden@verizon.net>
Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 2:28 PM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Resolution 2024-12

Some people who received this message don't often get email from j7garden@verizon.net. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Hello, I would like to support Resolution 2024-12 as someone who uses Harrington Realty to manage my building. Joan Bestpitch, President of DFRW Building Fund at 116 E. Water Street, Dover. DE

1 Page 48

Paj 49

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: The Moving Experience <todd@themovingexperiencede.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 3:31 PM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Back flow preventers for tonight’s meeting

Some people who received this message don't often get email from todd@themovingexperiencede.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear City Council- I urge you to support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers. While I do not dispute that heavy industrial manufacturing users should have backflow preventers, small retail and office users are not going to pollute our water system. The cost of installing these devices far exceeds the benefit and puts our citizens and especially our small businesspeople at great financial hardship. Please let us reconsider this program. Please also consider that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, for example, any properties currently under pressure to install these devices. Thank you very much for your assistance on this very important matter. Todd Stonesifer The Moving Experience 302-242-2122 www.TheMovingExperienceDE.com 302-241-0899 27 W Loockerman Street, Dover, DE 19904

1 Page 49

Paj 50

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: Nora Martin <nora1956@aol.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 4:27 PM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Back flow preventers

Some people who received this message don't often get email from nora1956@aol.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.

we recognize the necessity of backflow preventers for heavy industrial manufacturing users, we strongly believe that imposing these requirements on small retail and office users is unnecessary and burdensome. The financial implications of installing these devices far outweigh any potential benefits and could place undue hardship on our citizens, particularly our small business community. Therefore, we urge a reconsideration of the current program and advocate for the adoption of Resolution 2024-12, which proposes a moratorium on the installation of backflow preventers. It is crucial to emphasize that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, including those currently under pressure to install these devices. Respectfully submitted

Nora Martin CRS GRI
Broker of Record
NextHome Tomorrow Realty
302 542 0188 cell
302 601 4171 Office
http://nexthometomorrowrealty.com/

1 Page 50

Paj 51

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: Sandi Unkrur <sandi@themovingexperiencede.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 4:44 PM To: City Clerks Office Subject: EXTERNAL: Support Resolution 2024-12, Backflow Preventer Moratorium

Some people who received this message don't often get email from sandi@themovingexperiencede.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.

Dear City Council-

I urge you to support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers.

While I do not dispute that heavy industrial manufacturing users should have backflow preventers, small retail and office users are not going to pollute our water system.

The cost of installing these devices far exceeds the benefit and puts our citizens and especially our small businesspeople at great financial hardship.

Please let us reconsider this program.

Please also consider that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, for example, any properties currently under pressure to install these devices.

Thank you very much for your assistance on this very important matter.

SandiUnkrur | The Moving Experience Real Estate
2024 KCAR President
27 W Loockerman St., Dover, DE 19904
m: 302-480-3966
w: www.themovingexperiencede.com
fb: www.facebook.com/themovingexperience
o: 302-241-0899

1 Page 51

Paj 52

Item #3.

From: Bobbi Slagle To: City Clerks Office Subject: EXTERNAL: Resolution 2024-12 Date: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 5:05:45 PM Attachments: image001.png image002.png image003.png image004.png image005.png image006.png image007.png image008.png image009.png image010.png image011.png image012.png

Some people who received this message don't often get email from bobbi@nexthomepreferred.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. To all City of Dover Council Members:

I am writing to encourage you to support Resolution 2024-12 at this evening’s meeting. As a business that assists owners of property, both residential and commercial, in the City of Dover, I am very familiar with the costs already incurred to operate a business in an economy that has been through significant turmoil due to commercial investment’s fluctuations over the last several years.

While I recognize the necessity of backflow preventers for heavy industrial manufacturing users, I strongly believe that imposing these requirements on small retail and office users is unnecessary and burdensome. The financial implications of installing these devices far outweigh any potential benefits and will place undue hardship on our citizens, particularly our small business community.

Therefore, I am urging a reconsideration of the current program and advocate for the adoption of Resolution 2024-12, which proposes a moratorium on the installation of backflow preventers. It is crucial to emphasize that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, including those currently under pressure to install these devices. Additional research and information needs to be evaluated to determine cost vs benefit during this moratorium to determine a fair, responsible and reasonable path forward.

Thank you for your time and sincere consideration.

Bobbi Slagle
Broker Owner, NextHome Preferred

Paj 53

Item #3.

From: Gary Stewart
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Resolution 2024-12
Date: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 7:02:05 PM

You don't often get email from garystewartrealestate@gmail.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. I wish to express your support for Resolution 2024-12. I stand with KCAR: Our stance on this is: While we recognize the necessity of backflow preventers for heavy industrial manufacturing users, we strongly believe that imposing these requirements on small retail and office users is unnecessary and burdensome. The financial implications of installing these devices far outweigh any potential benefits and could place undue hardship on our citizens, particularly our small business community. Therefore, we urge a reconsideration of the current program and advocate for the adoption of Resolution 2024-12, which proposes a moratorium on the installation of backflow preventers. It is crucial to emphasize that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, including those currently under pressure to install these devices. Your support on this matter is pivotal in safeguarding the interests of our community and ensuring that any regulations implemented are fair and reasonable. Sincerely, --

gary stewart
READ MY REVIEWS

Realtor

Century 21 Emerald

c | 302-382-6140

a | 34634 Bay Crossing Blvd Unit 2 Lewes, DE 19958

e | garystewartrealestate@gmail.com

Visit My Website

Paj 54

Item #3.

From: Rodney Callahan
To: City Clerks Office; Cynthia Gowie
Subject: EXTERNAL: BackFlow Prevention program
Date: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 7:02:06 PM

You don't often get email from cpsi.rodney@gmail.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.

Dear City Council-

I urge you to support Resolution 2024-12, The Moratorium for Backflow Preventers.

While I do not dispute that heavy industrial manufacturing users should have backflow preventers, small retail and office users are not going to pollute our water system.

The cost of installing these devices far exceeds the benefit and puts our citizens and especially our small businesspeople at great financial hardship.

Please let us reconsider this program.

Please also consider that this moratorium should not grandfather any property class, for example, any properties currently under pressure to install these devices.

Thank you very much for your assistance on this very important matter.

Thank You,

Rodney Callahan
Maintenance Supervisor
Colonial Investment & Management Co.
CPSI.rodney@gmail.com

Paj 55

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: Doreen Sawchak <doreenhomesales@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 23, 2024 11:05 PM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: 2014-12

You don't often get email from doreenhomesales@gmail.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. We understand the importance of backflow preventers for large industrial manufacturers. However, we feel that requiring these devices for small retail and office users is both unnecessary and overly burdensome. The costs associated with installing these devices can be overwhelming and may place undue strain on our small businesses. We kindly ask for a reconsideration of the current program and support the adoption of Resolution 2024-12, which proposes a pause on the installation of backflow preventers. It is important to note that this moratorium should apply to all property types, including those currently facing pressure to install these devices.

To help protect y our priv acy , Microsoft O ffice prev ented automatic download of this picture from the Internet.

SERVING ALL OF DELAWARE

Doreen Sawchak Group Ferguson Ford REALTOR® To help protect y our priv acy , Microsoft O ffice prev ented automatic download of this picture from the Internet.

To help protect y our priv acy , Microsoft O ffice prev ented automatic download of this picture from the Internet.

To help protect y our priv acy , Microsoft O ffice prev ented automatic download of this picture from the Internet.

www.DelawareHomesForMilitary.com
(302) 242 4686* Cell
(302) 453-3802 Office
418 E. Savannah Rd, Suite, B, Lewes, DE. 19958
228 Suburban Drive, Newark, DE. 19711
668 Yorklyn Rd, Hockessin, DE 19707
3608 Silverside Rd, Wilmington, DE. 19810

Check out my ZILLOW reviews here!

1 Page 55

Paj 56

Item #3.

Walls, Ashley A

From: Gilbert Myers <grmyersjr@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2024 3:27 PM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: EXTERNAL: Support Resolution 2024-12

Some people who received this message don't often get email from grmyersjr@gmail.com. Learn why this is important

WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. City Clerk of Dover, DE

Please be advised as a small business owner in the City of Dover, I support Resolution 2024-12. Our industry is heavily taxed and was just recently sued by the Department of Justice. Realtors as a whole are suffering greatly at this time. Having to install sewer equipment that my building will only add to my financial burden.

Should there be commercial industry and/or very heavy users of the City of Dover's sewer lines, I can see how it would be wise to install backflow preventers.

Speaking for a small business in Dover, I support Resolution 2024-12. I may be forced out of the city if these expenses continue. I can only imagine that other businesses in the City of Dover are facing similar hardships and could be easily forced out of business completely.

Respectfully,

To help protect y ou r priv acy , Microsoft O ffice prev ented automatic download of this picture from the Internet. Logo

G.R. Myers
Broker/Owner

office: 302-674-4255 mobile: 302-363-3950 1056 S. State Street Dover, DE 19901 To help protect y our priv acy , Microsoft O ffice prev ented automatic download of this picture from the Internet. Facebook icon

www.myersrealtyteam.com

1 Page 56

Paj 57

Item #8.

Paj 58

Item #8.

CITY COUNCIL COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND

JULY 1, 2023 - JUNE 30, 2024

100-10-12-99-000-53037
Current
Balance- $ 5,450.00

BUDGETED COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND - $2,500 FOR EACH COUNCIL MEMBER PER DISTRICT AND $5,000 FOR THE AT-LARGE COUNCIL MEMBER. $ 25,000.00 AMOUNT THE PURPOSE OF THE FUND IS TO ALLOW MEMBERS TO CONTRIBUTE FUNDS TO A SMALL PROJECT OR COMMUNITY NEEDS IN EACH DISTRICT.

FINAL BUDGET TOTAL $ 25,000.00

COUNCIL TOTAL YEAR TO

DATE VENDOR DESCRIPTION P.O. #/INVOICE # BALANCE

SPONSOR CHARGES DATE

Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $500.00 of his Women and Children Email from David Anderson dated 05/24/2023 and community enhancement funds to the Women and Children 7/10/2023 Anderson Transformation Ministry Email & Letter from William Snorton, Jr. received $500.00 $500.00 $24,500.00 Transformation Ministry International, Inc. for their Boys to Men International, Inc. 05/23/2023 Development Program for Gas cards. Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $300.00 of his Email from David Anderson dated 07/12/2023 and 7/12/2023 Anderson The 302 Movement community enhancement funds to The 302 Movement for the backpack $300.00 $800.00 $24,200.00 email from Tracey Weems dated 07/11/2023 program. Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $200.00 of his Email from Andre Boggerty dated 07/17/2023 and 7/17/2023 Boggerty I Am Me, Inc. $200.00 $1,000.00 $24,000.00 community enhancement funds to I Am Me, Inc. for their ME Festival. email from Peirrce McCoy dated 07/17/2023 Council President Hare authorized the designation of $200.00 of his Email from Bill Hare dated 07/17/2023 and email 7/17/2023 Hare I Am Me, Inc. $200.00 $1,200.00 $23,800.00 community enhancement funds to I Am Me, Inc. for their ME Festival. from Peirrce McCoy dated 07/17/2023 Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $300.00 of his community Email from Brian Lewis dated 07/25/2023 and email 7/25/2023 Lewis I Am Me, Inc. $300.00 $1,500.00 $23,500.00 enhancement funds to I Am Me, Inc. for their ME Festival. from Peirrce McCoy dated 07/17/2023 Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $200.00 of his Email from David Anderson dated 07/25/2023 and 7/25/2023 Anderson United Way $200.00 $1,700.00 $23,300.00 community enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book Bash." email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 07/25/2023 Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250.00 of her Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 07/25/2023 and 7/25/2023 Pillsbury United Way $250.00 $1,950.00 $23,050.00 community enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book Bash" email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 07/25/2023 Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $100.00 of his community Email from Fred Neil dated 07/25/2023 and email 7/25/2023 Neil United Way $100.00 $2,050.00 $22,950.00 enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book Bash" from Kenyatta Livingston dated 07/25/2023 Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $1,000.00 of his The Inner City Cultural Email from Andre Boggerty dated 07/31/2023 and 7/31/2023 Boggerty community enhancement funds to The Inner City Cultural League for the $1,000.00 $3,050.00 $21,950.00 League email from Reuben Salters dated 07/25/2023 reasons stated in the email. Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $250.00 of his Email from David Anderson dated 08/04/2023 and 8/4/2023 Anderson Yeshua Lighthouse community enhancement funds to The Yeshua Lighthouse for bookbags Email & Letter from Liana Pritchett received $250.00 $3,300.00 $21,700.00 for their community day 08/01/2023 Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200.00 of his Email from Gerald Rocha dated 08/07/2023 and 8/7/2023 Rocha United Way $200.00 $3,500.00 $21,500.00 community enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book Bash" email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 07/25/2023 Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $100.00 of his community Hispanic Organization of Email from Fred Neil dated 08/12/2023 and email 8/14/2023 Neil enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans $100.00 $3,600.00 $21,400.00 Latin Americans (HOLA) from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. Councilperson Arndt authorized the designation of $200.00 of her Hispanic Organization of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 08/14/2023 and email 8/14/2023 Arndt community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin $200.00 $3,800.00 $21,200.00 Latin Americans (HOLA) from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $250.00 of his Email from David Anderson dated 08/14/2023 and Hispanic Organization of 8/14/2023 Anderson community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated $250.00 $4,050.00 $20,950.00 Latin Americans (HOLA) Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. 08/11/2023 Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $250.00 of his Email from Andre Boggerty dated 08/14/2023 and Hispanic Organization of 8/14/2023 Boggerty community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated $250.00 $4,300.00 $20,700.00 Latin Americans (HOLA) Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. 08/11/2023 Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $300.00 of his community Hispanic Organization of Email from Brian Lewis dated 08/14/2023 and email 8/14/2023 Lewis enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans $300.00 $4,600.00 $20,400.00 Latin Americans (HOLA) from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 08/11/2023 (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.

Paj 59

Item #8.

Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200.00 of hisEmail from Gerald Rocha dated 08/18/2023 and
Hispanic Organization of
8/18/2023Rochacommunity enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latinemail from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated$200.00$4,800.00$20,200.00
Latin Americans (HOLA)
Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.08/11/2023
Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $150.00 of his community Email from Brian Lewis dated and Letter from Dr.
8/18/2023LewisDEMCO$150.00$4,950.00$20,050.00
enhancement funds to DEMCO for their Book Bag giveaway.Linda Hackett dated 08/17/2023
Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250.00 of herEmail from Julia Pillsbury dated 08/21/2023 and
Hispanic Organization of
8/21/2023Pillsburycommunity enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latinemail from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated$250.00$5,200.00$19,800.00
Latin Americans (HOLA)
Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.08/11/2023
InterdenomonationalCouncilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $300.00 of hisEmail from Andre Boggerty dated 08/25/2023 and
8/28/2023BoggertyMinisterial Alliance of Dovercommunity enhancement funds to the Annual Community Unity Familyemail from Bishop W. James Thomas, II dated$300.00$5,500.00$19,500.00
and Visinity (IMA)Day08/22/2023
Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $1,000.00 of his
Email from Andre Boggerty dated 10/2/2023 and a
10/2/2023BoggertyParks & Recreationcommunity enhancement funds to the Parks and Recreation Department$1,000.00$6,500.00$18,500.00
memo from Robin Eaton dated 09/26/2023
for the 50 Years of Hip Hop Event.
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $500.00 of his
Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated 10/2/2023 and a
10/2/2023RochaParks & Recreationcommunity enhancement funds to the Parks and Recreation Department$500.00$7,000.00$18,000.00
memo from Robin Eaton dated 09/26/2023
for the 50 Years of Hip Hop Event.
Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 10/05/23 and an
Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250.00 of her
10/5/2023PillsburyDover Police Departmentemail from CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated$250.00$7,250.00$17,750.00
community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Event
10/05/23
Council President Hare authorized the designation of $600.00 of hisEmail from Bill Hare dated 10/05/23 and an email
10/5/2023HareDover Police Department$600.00$7,850.00$17,150.00
community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Eventfrom CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated 10/05/23
Email from David Anderson dated 10/06/23 and an
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $550.00 of his
10/6/2023AndersonDover Police Departmentemail from CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated$550.00$8,400.00$16,600.00
community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Event
10/05/23
Email from Andre Boggerty dated 10/14/23 and an
Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $200.00 of his
10/16/2023BoggertyDover Police Departmentemail from CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated$200.00$8,600.00$16,400.00
community enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Event
10/05/23
Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $500.00 of his community Email from Fred Neil dated 11/06/23 and an email
11/6/2023NeilDover Police Department$500.00$9,100.00$15,900.00
enhancement funds to the Hometown Holiday Eventfrom CPL Killen, City of Dover PD, dated 10/05/23
Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $150.00 of his community Email from Brian Lewis dated 11/14/23 and a flyer
11/14/2023LewisTracy Palmer Ministries$150.00$9,250.00$15,750.00
enhancement funds to the Community Thanksgiving Dinnerfrom the Tracy Palmer Ministries
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200.00 of of his
Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated 11/27/2023 and
11/27/2023RochaUnited Way of Delawarecommunity enhancement fund to United Way of Delaware Wonderland$200.00$9,450.00$15,550.00
email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 11/27/2023
Coat and Toy Drive
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $100.00 of of his
Email from David Anderson dated 11/27/2023 and
11/27/2023AndersonUnited Way of Delawarecommunity enhancement fund to United Way of Delaware Wonderland$100.00$9,550.00$15,450.00
email from Kenyatta Livingston dated 11/27/2023
Coat and Toy Drive
Central Delaware Habitat for Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250.00 of her Email from Tricia Arndt dated 12/13/2023 and email
12/13/2023Arndt$250.00$9,800.00$15,200.00
Humanity community enhancement fund to Central Delaware Habitat for Humanity from Timothy M. Bailey dated 12/12/2023
Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250.00 of herEmail from Tricia Arndt dated 12/13/2023 and letter
12/13/2023ArndtPeople's Place$250.00$10,050.00 $14,950.00
community enhancement fund to People's Placefrom Mamie Charest dated 12/11/2023
I Am My Sisters KeeperCouncilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $750.00 of hisEmail from Andre Boggerty dated 01/11/2024 and an
1/11/2024Boggerty$750.00$10,800.00 $14,200.00
(MSK) community enhancement funds to I Am My Sister's Keeper (MSK-Dover) email from Marcille "Dee" Sewell, dated 1/11/24
Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $200.00 of his community
Email from Brian Lewis dated 02/14/24 and flyers
2/14/2024LewisTracy Palmer Ministriesenhancement funds to the Easter Eggstravaganza at the Elizabeth W.$200.00$11,000.00 $14,000.00
from the Tracy Palmer Ministries
Murphey School
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $300.00 of hisEmail from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated 02/21/24 and a
2/21/2024RochaTracy Palmer Ministriescommunity enhancement funds to the Easter Eggstravaganza at theletter from the Tracy Palmer Ministries dated$300.00$11,300.00 $13,700.00
Elizabeth W. Murphey School02/18/24
Council President Hare authorized the designation of $250.00 of hisEmail from Bill Hare dated 02/24/24 and an email &
2/26/2024HareZeta Rho Lambda$250.00$11,550.00 $13,450.00
community enhancement funds to the Zeta Rho Lambda Chapter 5Kletter from Dana T Shelton, dated 02/13/24
Councilman Anderson authorized the designation of $350.00 of his
The Inner City CulturalEmail from David Anderson dated 02/28/24 and
2/29/2024Andersoncommunity enhancement funds to The Inner City Cultural League for the$350.00$11,900.00 $13,100.00
Leagueletter/email from Kathrina Stroud dated 02/27/24
reasons stated in the email.
Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $100.00 of his community
Hispanic Organization ofEmail from Fred Neil dated 04/01/24 and email from
4/1/2024Neilenhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans$100.00$12,000.00 $13,000.00
Latin Americans (HOLA)Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 03/29/24
(HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.

Paj 60

Item #8.

Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $250.00 of hisEmail from Andre Boggerty dated 04/01/24 and
Hispanic Organization of
4/1/2024Boggertycommunity enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latinemail from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated$250.00$12,250.00 $12,750.00
Latin Americans (HOLA)
Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.03/29/24
Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated 04/19/24 and a
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $300.00 of his
4/19/2024RochaTracy Palmer Ministriesletter from the Tracy Palmer Ministries dated$300.00$12,550.00 $12,450.00
community enhancement funds to the Tracy Palmer Ministries.
04/19/24
Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $500.00 of his community
Hispanic Organization ofEmail from Brian Lewis dated 04/23/24 and an email
4/23/2024Lewisenhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans$500.00$13,050.00 $11,950.00
Latin Americans (HOLA)from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 03/29/24
(HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.

Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $300.00 of his community Email from Brian Lewis dated 04/23/2024 and letter

4/23/2024LewisElizabeth Daniels$300.00$13,350.00 $11,650.00
enhancement fund to Elizabeth Daniels for the Juneteenth Celebrationfrom Elizabeth Daniels dated 04/23/2024.

Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $250.00 of his Email from Andre Boggerty dated 04/23/2024 and

4/23/2024BoggertyElizabeth Danielscommunity enhancement fund to Elizabeth Daniels for the Juneteenth$250.00$13,600.00 $11,400.00
letter from Elizabeth Daniels dated 04/23/2024.
Celebration
Email from Andre Boggerty dated 04/23/24 and a
Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $200.00 of his
4/23/2024BoggertyTracy Palmer Ministriesletter from the Tracy Palmer Ministries dated$200.00$13,800.00 $11,200.00
community enhancement funds to the Tracy Palmer Ministries.
04/19/24
Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $50.00 of his communityEmail from Fred Neil dated 04/23/2024 and letter
4/23/2024NeilElizabeth Daniels$50.00$13,850.00 $11,150.00
enhancement fund to Elizabeth Daniels for the Juneteenth Celebrationfrom Elizabeth Daniels dated 04/23/2024.
Councilman President Hare authorized the designation of $300.00 of his
Email from Bill Hare dated 05/06/2024 and letter
5/6/2024HareElizabeth Danielscommunity enhancement fund to Elizabeth Daniels for the Juneteenth$300.00$14,150.00 $10,850.00
from Elizabeth Daniels dated 04/22/2024.
Celebration
Councilman President Hare authorized the designation of $300.00 of his
Hispanic Organization ofEmail from Bill Hare dated 04/23/24 and an email
5/6/2024Harecommunity enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin$300.00$14,450.00 $10,550.00
Latin Americans (HOLA)from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 03/29/24
Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $400.00 of his
Email from Gerald Rocha dated 05/23/2024 and
5/24/2024RochaElizabeth Danielscommunity enhancement fund to Elizabeth Daniels for the Juneteenth$400.00$14,850.00 $10,150.00
letter from Elizabeth Daniels dated 04/22/2024.
Celebration.
Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $600.00 of his community Email from Brian Lewis dated 06/14/24 and a letter
6/14/2024LewisTracy Palmer Ministries$600.00$15,450.00$9,550.00
enhancement funds to the Tracy Palmer Ministries.from the Tracy Palmer Ministries dated 06/13/24
Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $ 1,000.00 of herEmail from Julia Pillsbury Dated 6/17/24 and Letter
6/17/2024PillsburyDover Fire Department$1,000.00$16,450.00$8,550.00
community enhancement funds to the Dover Fire Departmentfrom Chief Carey received 06/17/2023
Dover Police Athletic League Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $500.00 of her Email from Julia Pillsbury Dated 6/17/24 and Letter
6/17/2024Pillsbury$500.00$16,950.00$8,050.00
(PAL)community enhancement funds to the 2024 Youth Police Academyfrom Corporal Anthony Smith received 06/17/2023
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $400.00 of hisEmail from Gerald Rocha dated 06/17/2024 and
6/18/2024RochaInner City Cultural League$400.00$17,350.00$7,650.00
community enhancement funds to the Sankofa African Dance Summerletter from Reuben Salters received 06/17/2024
Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250.00 of herEmail from Julia Pillsbury dated 06/17/2024 and an
6/18/2024PillsburyInner City Cultural League$250.00$17,600.00$7,400.00
community enhancement funds to the African American Festivalemail/letter from Katrina Stroud dated 06/17/24
Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $350.00 of his community Email from Bill Hare dated 06/17/2024 and an
6/18/2024HareInner City Cultural League$350.00$17,950.00$7,050.00
enhancement funds to the African American Festivalemail/letter from Katrina Stroud dated 06/17/24
Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $500.00 of his community Email from Bill Hare dated 6/18/24 and Letter from
6/18/2024HareDover Fire Department$500.00$18,450.00$6,550.00
enhancement funds to the Dover Fire DepartmentChief Carey received 06/17/2023
Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $150.00 of his community Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 06/17/2024 and an
6/20/2024NeilInner City Cultural League$150.00$18,600.00$6,400.00
enhancement funds to the African American Festivalemail/letter from Katrina Stroud dated 06/17/24
Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $100.00 of his community
Hispanic Organization ofEmail from Fred Neil dated 06/18/24 and email from
6/20/2024Neilenhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans$100.00$18,700.00$6,300.00
Latin Americans (HOLA)Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 03/29/24
(HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.

Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $600.00 of his Email from Andre Boggerty dated 06/21/2024 and 6/21/2024 Boggerty Psi Iota Hope Foundation $600.00 $19,300.00 $5,700.00 community enhancement funds to the Psi Iota Hope Foundation Email & Letter from Gregg Bunkley dated 06/20/2024

Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250.00 of her Hispanic Organization of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 06/25/24 and email 6/25/2024 Arndt community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization of Latin $250.00 $19,550.00 $5,450.00 Latin Americans (HOLA) from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez dated 06/25/24 Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival.

TOTALS $19,550.00 $5,450.00

Paj 61

Item #8.

Budgeted

DistrictCouncil SponsorYTD ExpendituresBalance
Amount
$5,000.00At-LargeBoggerty$5,000.00$0.00
$2,500.001st DistrictPillsbury$2,500.00$0.00
$2,500.001st DistrictRocha$2,500.00$0.00
$2,500.002nd DistrictHare$2,500.00$0.00
$2,500.002nd DistrictLewis$2,500.00$0.00
$2,500.003rd DistrictArndt$950.00$1,550.00
$2,500.003rd DistrictNeil$1,100.00$1,400.00
$2,500.004th DistrictAnderson$2,500.00$0.00
$2,500.004th DistrictSudler$0.00$2,500.00
TOTAL$19,550.00$5,450.00

Paj 62

Item #9.

CITY MANAGER’S MONTHLY REPORT

June 2024

Paj 63

Item #9.

Blank
Page

Paj 64

Item #9.

Paj 65

Item #9.

Paj 66

Item #9.

CENTRAL SERVICES MONTHLY REPORT

June 2024

PROCUREMENT & INVENTORY DIVISION

Purchase Orders for Stock by Fund

FY 2024 to DateDifference from FY 2023
Electric$2,995,155.6347.6%
Water$147,778.8855.8%
Wastewater$769.13100.0%
General$180,520.6049.0%
Total$3,324,224.2448.1%

Issues from Stock by Fund

FY 2024 to DateDifference from FY 2023
Electric$2,142,762.6221.2%
Water$110,200.4134.3%
Wastewater$0.00N/A
General$134,885.78-1.8%
Total$2,387,848.8120.5%

Bids/RFPs Solicited

FY 2024 to DateDifference from FY 2023
3948.7%

Money Spent for Postal Services

FY 2024 to DateFY 2023 to Date
$173,810.64$172,800.97

Fuel Usage

TypeFY 2024 to DateFY 2023 to Date
Unleaded150,117142,372
Diesel76,80375,707
Dollars Spent$621,122.59$694,023.09

Paj 67

Item #9.

Warehouse Stock Value

FY 2024FY 2023
$3,956,843.31$3,237,992.38

Purchase Orders for Stock are up 48.1% compared to this time last year. Issues from Stock are up 20.5% compared to this time last year. Bids/RFP's are up 48.7% compared to this time last year. Postal Expenses are up 0.6% compared to this time last year. Fuel Costs are down 11.7% compared to this time last year. Overall warehouse value is up 18.2% compared to this time last year.

FLEET DIVISION

PM Work Orders Scheduled:PM Work OrdersTotal Work Orders PM &
24Completed: 43Repair: 86
Total Hours Turned:Excess Hours Turned:Time Unaccounted For:
258.5031.7

MEASURE June 2024 June 2023

Completed PM's 43 50

DIFFERENCE -14.00%

There were 24 PM's scheduled for this month. A total of 43 PM's were completed along with 43 repair work orders. There were a total of 86 work orders completed.

Paj 68

Item #9.

FACILITIES DIVISION

Routine Work Orders Emergency Work Orders
Completed: 88 Completed: 1

City-owned Facility Work Events & Support Work Orders: 80 Orders: 9

MEASURE June 2024 June 2023

Completed Work Orders 89 78

DIFFERENCE 14.10%

There were 89 routine and emergency Work Orders completed during this month. The work orders consisted of 80 for maintenance and repair of City-owned facilities and 9 related to events and other support work.

Central Services Narrative The Warehousing & Procurement office continues to see inflated costs and excessive lead times. Facilities staff has been busy with routine work orders. We are currently short staffed due to a transfer and a retirement. Fleet is operating as normal at this time. Fleet currently has 1 vacancy.

Paj 69

Item #9.

CENTRAL SERVICES PROJECT UPDATE

June 2024
FY/PROJECT NUMBER DEPARTMENT STATUS

CENTRAL SERVICES FC2303 COMPLETE! CITY HALL WINDOWS

3rd and 2nd floor complete.
ELECTRIC Abatement on 1st floor
EA2204
WEYANDT HALL HVAC complete and finishing up
1st floor install.

CENTRAL SERVICES FC2402 COMPLETE! CITY HALL EXTERIOR PAINT

CENTRAL SERVICES CS2405 COMPLETE! WASH BAY ROOF & DOORS

WATER WASTE WATER WTP

WD2409 Construction is underway.
RENOVATIONS

Paj 70

Item #9.

Recap of monthly activities / notations –

As of June 30, 2024 the City of Dover served 24,968 electric utility customers and 13,165 water utility customers as compared to 2023, which represents 24,795 and 13,080 respectively. These figures were tabulated from the monthy utility bill summary report which tracks billing across all utility bill rate classifications. 2,750 phone calls were answered in the month of June by 5 staff members of customer service. Customer Service is still opeating two employees short. The interim positions are being held longer than anticipated and has held up any hiring processes. This is a concern that the City’s forward facing customer service team is being taxed daily. Majority of the time this is the City’s first impression team and they need support. Please note that seven years ago it was a staff of 6, a two person call center, and supervisor. The work load has increased for four staff memebers and supervisor. The City is growing and our head count has not.

Receivable Comparison FY 2023 to Utility Disconnections for June 2024 FY2024 to date (June 2024) Compared 186 accounts were disconnected for non-payment of service. to the same time last year the City had open receivables of $5,024,075.60 vs Total receivable collected through the disconnection process $91,708.48 $9,698,655.63. Ending Utility Receivable Due - $7,337,755.07

Customer Service Department Mission

Continually provide quality public service to our diverse group of customers with professionalism, respect, & integrity. ~ City of Dover Customer Service Department

Paj 71

Item #9.
ASSESSOR’S REPORT

Number of Deeds Stamped forTransfer Tax Dollar Amount for
the Month of June 2023/2024the Month of June 2023/2024
$94
2521 19 23$100
18
Thousand
201716$59
$46$36
15$50
s
10$19$0$0
50 10 02023$02023
0$0
20242024

June 2023/2024 Realty
First Time Buyer for the Month
Property Sales in Dollars
of June 2023/2024
Received Prior to Recording

2521 23
19$8$6 $6
17$4$5
20

Millions
$6

Res. Non-First$4$1 $0
15$0$02023
Time Buyers$2
10$0
Res. First Time2024
5Buyers
0
20232024

Major Updates

AprilMayJune
Assessment Change$0$0$8,909,620

Residential Sales Ratio Report

Sales in StudyTotal AssessedTotal Sale PriceRatioPRD
Value
34$6,048,000$10,272,5000.661.03

Ratio – Assessed Value divided by Sale Price. PRD – Mean – A PRD above 1.03 tends to indicate assessment regressivity – high valued properties are under appraised relative to low valued properties. A PRD below .98 tends to indicate assessment progressivity – high valued properties are relatively over appraised.

Paj 72

Item #9.
ASSESSOR’S REPORT

Tax Office
Wild Meadows / Persimmon Park Place Home Sales for June 2024:

Property AddressAssessed ValueSales Price
224 W Persimmon Cir$58,600$137,900
320 W Persimmon Cir$59,300$110,000

2024 Appeal Hearings have been completed. (See attached spread sheet)

Paj 73

Item #9.

2024 Appeal Log
Commercial

NamePIN#Property Address#2024 AmountReque. AmountRevised AmountBoard Decision
MAC RENTALS LLCED05-066.00-01-11.001655-1665 KENTON RD$2,910,700N/ADENIED

Exempt Request

NamePIN#Property Address #2024Reque. AmountBoard Decision
CENTRAL DE HABITAT FOR HUMANITY ED05-077.05-03-08.0037 S NEW ST$16,400$0$0APPROVED
CHILDRENS ADVOCACY CENTERED05-088.14-01-04.01615 S DUPONT HWY$852,000$0$0WITHDRAWN
ACADAMY OF DOVER CHARTER SCHOOL ED05-076.07-01-27.00104 SAULSBURY RD$6,483,100$0$0APPROVED
ELIZABETH W MURPHY SCHOOL INCED05-077.06-01-66.01508 E LOOCKERMAN ST$156,900$0$0APPROVED
CALVARY BAPTIST CHURCH OF DOVER ED05-076.08-04-47.0028 N QUEEN ST$111,000$0$0DENIED
DOVER HOUSING AUTHORITYED05-077.09-03-08.00426 S NEW ST (LAND ON$536,300$0$0APPROVED
OWENS QUEEN PRESERVATION ASSOCIED05-077.09-03-08.01426 S NEW ST (BLDG ON$4,630,400$0$0ONGOING
OWENS QUEEN PRESERVATION ASSOCIED05-077.09-03-02.00411 S QUEEN ST3,516,200$0$0ONGOING
OWENS QUEEN PRESERVATION ASSOCIED05-077.09-03-13.00402 S NEW ST41,900$0$0ONGOING
BRANDYWINE COUNCELING &
$0$0
COMMUNITY SERVICE INCED05-077.00-01-170.00696-698 BAY RD551,600DENIED
16,895,800$0$0
Stipulations
NamePin#Property Address #2024 AmountReque. AmountStipulated Amount
WILD MEADOWS MHC LLCLC05-058.14-01-01.00 PERSIMMON TREE LN$14,925,40011,113,20APPROVED
WILD MEADOWS MHC LLCLC05-058.14-01-01.529 529 WEAVER DR$561,600$561,600APPROVED

Paj 74

012ÿ456ÿ

8ÿ7879ÿÿ
2ÿÿ ÿÿ4ÿÿÿÿÿÿ
79
 DEF 21 1D  2 E2   2 1  2ÿ 2ÿ Item #9.
 !"# $ $%# $) ,$ %&ÿ./012ÿ,$  $()(%'$) / /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%)%C" %! A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%&C ÿ$#$)
 !"#$% & '# ) ,$ %ÿ,3,245/567ÿ*4$ $' %$"'%!"% : /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%$&C) $& A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'(C ÿ#"
 !"#$% & '"# ) ,$ &ÿ,3,245/567ÿ*4$ $' %$"'%$' : /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$()C% $ A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'$C ÿ#!&
 !"#$& % !# % ,$ $"ÿ80,25ÿ+,9ÿ,$ $' $("%$%($ + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$$)C$ & A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ$$)C$ÿ$
 !"#$& ' &"# % ,$ $ÿ945ÿ+6,$ $& $("&$$$) + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$'$C) $& A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%C ÿ#%
 !"#$& & $# $) ,$ $'&ÿ,ÿ0/9ÿ,$  $((%%!'& : /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%&$C $) A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ&&C ÿ#
 !"#$" ' &&# ' ,$ $%(ÿ:;,464<ÿ5,ÿ,$  $((%'$ / /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%(%C" %) A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ&(C ÿ#!&
 !"#$( ' %)# $" ,$ "'%ÿ:6+45446/*ÿ:*7$  $()"%%'&) : /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%%)C& % A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'(C ÿ#(
 !"#% $ !!# $ ,$ $%ÿ+0*;.:6/ÿ/7$ $& $("$$) + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$%%C( $% A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%&C ÿ#$
 !"#% % '(# $ ,$ %$ÿ*/9100ÿ3*$ ' $(&($$"! +B /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$)C% %& A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'C ÿ#!$
 !)#$ % &)# $' ,$ ("%ÿ:;+9ÿ,$ $& $(!&$$$% + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$&%C% $" A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ''C ÿ#&'
 !)#$& % '(# $' ,$ '')ÿ46.65=ÿ,$ $& $(!!$$$' + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$%C!  A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%(%C ÿ#%
 !)#$ & &"# ! ,$ $ÿ2ÿ>/4+0+9ÿ/7$  %%%%$)) : /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%'C% %" A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ&C ÿ#$
 !)#$" $ $%# ) ,$ "&ÿ3442?*7/46/ÿ/7ÿ@5$ ' $(&($$' +B /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$&C) %) A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'%C ÿ#&)
 !)#$" $ %"# ) ,$ '(ÿ3442?*7/46/ÿ/7ÿ@5$  $(&)%'!) : 7< ÿÿÿÿÿ'"$C! " A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ!!C ÿ#!
 "!# % )# $& ,$ $"$ÿ2504?ÿ,$ $& $()"$$%&' + < ÿÿÿÿÿ$!(C' $ A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%(C ÿ#"
 "!# ) %$# ' ,$ $%ÿ+>*2/ÿ1/?$ $& $((($$)' : /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%$C %) A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'$C ÿ#!&
 "!#! % )# % ,$ '&ÿ+0*ÿ23,64<ÿ3*$ $' $()&%$& + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$$%C % A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%)C ÿ#&
 "!#!  $)# $" ,$ $$ÿ.564<>0;2ÿ*4$  $(($%%'&) : /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%%'C( %" A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'(C ÿ#"
 "!#! " &$# $" ,$ $%%(ÿ/4,1ÿ,$  $((%%$)$ + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$)C %) A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'"$Cÿ#
 "!#$ ' )# $! ,$ $&$ÿ2ÿ8/,.761ÿ,$ ) $(($%$&' + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$&$C' ! A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%&C ÿ#(
 "!#$' % $'# $& ,$ %$$ÿ40,5>014ÿ,$ $& $(($$!&$ +B /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$(%C& %! A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ$!C ÿ$#$"
 "!#$& % $'# $& ,$ %%$ÿ5,/8/*</,ÿ,$  %%%!& +B /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ%%&C! $& A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'(C ÿ#)
 ""#! % &%# " ,$ "'%ÿ2ÿ>/*2?ÿ,$ $& $($$' + 7< ÿÿÿÿÿ$'&C" % A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%&C ÿ#
 ""#) % '# ! ,$ %$$ÿ,0A/4ÿ,$ $' %%&%$)) +B /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$C' " A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%)(C ÿ#&
 ""#$' % &(# & ,$ !'ÿ2/+9/,/+964ÿ/7$ ' $(&$$!( + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$"C$ %& A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'%C ÿ#'
 ""#$" ' %# & ,$ $(ÿ2ÿ:,/80,ÿ25$ ' $(&!$$'"! + < ÿÿÿÿÿ$&(C( %$ A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%)C ÿ#'
 ""#$" & '!# & ,$ $$"ÿ2ÿ25/5ÿ25$ ' $(&%$$! + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$!%C( %& A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%"(C ÿ#)
 )#) $ '# $% ,$ "ÿ>0**?ÿ,$ $& $()$$$&) + /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$&(C  A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%)C ÿ#%
 )#) $ %)# $% ,$ ""ÿ0/9ÿ,$ $! $(!'$$"' +B /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$"C $% A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ%C ÿ#!)
 )#) $ &)# $% ,$ $$"(ÿ0/9ÿ,$ $! $(!%$$"& +B /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$!$C) ! A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'$%C ÿ#%
 )#$% & ''# $% ,$ &&'ÿ/*,ÿ,$ $! $("($$!)% +B /7 ÿÿÿÿÿ$)C% %$ A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ'!C ÿ#!$
*+ )#$& $ $#%%&$ ,$ %%&ÿ1ÿ3,26..04ÿ+6,$ $$ %&$$&) + < ÿÿÿÿÿÿ)C! $" A;4 %&ÿÿÿÿÿ$'"C( ÿ#&%

Paj 75

012ÿ456ÿ 8ÿ7879 ÿÿ 2ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ7ÿÿÿÿÿÿ 79   89: 21  18  2 92    2 1  2ÿ 2ÿ  Item #9.  !"#$ # #"%&# '# %&ÿ)ÿ*+',-../0ÿ-' ### &1 # #$! 23 ÿÿÿÿÿÿ45% #% 670 &$ ÿÿÿÿÿ##5 ÿ"$

Paj 76

Item #9. ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT MONTHLY REPORT For the month of June 2024, the Electric Department contributed to the quality of life for all our customers.

The city experienced a system peak of 151.6 megawatts, an increase of 34.2 megawatts from last month and a 18 megawatt increase from the same month last year.

There was a total of 15 outages for the month affecting a total of 2,983 customers with an average outage time of 67.7 minutes.

Project Updates:

The department continues to work in the new developments, pole testing, LED light replacements and assorted other work. We are also prepping for scheduled FY25 capital projects.

Pole testing has progressed with approximately 4250 poles tested (80% complete) with a 9% fail rate, or 362 bad poles identified as needing replaced within three years. Roadway LED lights continue to be replaced with approximately 1,400 having been upgraded which is roughly 78% complete.

At Garrison Oak, the substation is moving forward nicely. Switchgear panels were awarded that will be used inside the building to house numerous components. Other aspects of the construction are continuing on both the engineering and construction fronts.

The majority of the McKee demolition has been completed. Total Wrecking is still on track to meet their deadline and possibly beat it.

Van Sant was not called on for dispatch in June.

FY 24 YTD Outages and Response Time:
Total – 97 Average Response Time – 30.1 (Goal – Less than 30 minutes)

Statistics: 3-year average: FY Average:

Average Interruption
Duration Index (SAIDI) 173.8 minutes 71.4 minutes
Goal – Not to exceed 100 mins

System Average Interruption
Frequency Index (SAIFI) 1.8 per cust .71 per cust
Goal – Not to exceed 1 per customer

Customer Average Interruption
Duration Index (CAIDI) 98.9 minutes 100.3 minutes

Lost Time Accidents – Workorders Generated –
Current Month – 0 Total FY – 0 Current Month – 150 Total FY – 2,057

Paj 77

Item #9.
ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT MONTHLY REPORT
FY24

Historical Peak Load
180

160

140

120

1002022
Megawatts
802023
2024
60

40

20

0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec

Paj 78

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

June 2024 City of Dover Human Resources Mission Statement: The City of Dover’s Human Resources Department strives to provide quality service to assist our greatest asset, our employees. Equity, Integrity, and Urgency is our focus to ensure employee satisfaction as well as company wellness. We implement policies and procedures that align with organizational goals, including a safe and compliant workplace, effective training and professional development, and addressing both the needs of employees and the organization.

City of Dover Human Resources Value Statement:

Innovation: We strive to include best HR practices to enhance a robust technological movement to enhance the quality and efficiency of the department.

Collaboration: We honor knowledge sharing, diversity of thoughts and ideas, and experiences to encourage an inclusive workforce.

Integrity and Transparency: We honor our commitments and promote a healthy environment that promotes fairness, honesty, respect, and trust.

Results Driven: Customer service is front and center, and we advocate for employees' and retirees’ needs at all times.

JUNE SUMMARY:

June’s Hiring Trends FY24:

MONTHNEW HIRESTATUS
JUNE72 FT, 5 PT

June’s Voluntary Termination/Involuntary Termination Trends FY24: In the month of June, there was 1 PT Voluntary Termination and 1 FT Retirement.

Paj 79

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

JUNE’S EEO DATA

EEO DATA

1%
2%
6% 3%

15%

73%

AMERICAN INDIAN ASIAN BLACK CAUCASIAN HISPANIC OTHER RACE

AMERICAN INDIAN3%
ASIAN1%
AFRICAN AMERICAN15%
CAUCASIAN73%
HISPANIC2%
OTHER RACE6%

Paj 80

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

JUNE’S EEO DEMOGRAPHICS

EEOC DEMOGRAPHICS

MINORITY

CAUCASIAN

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350

CAUCASIAN286
MINORITY104

Paj 81

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

JUNE’S GENDER REPORT

Gender Report
FEMALE MALE NONBINARY

0%

27%

73%

MALES73%
FEMALE27%
NON-BINARY 0%

Paj 82

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

FULL-TIME VS. PART-TIME EE’S

FULL - TIME VS. PART - TIME EE'S 450

387388387394392390
400
356358362365365364
350

300

250

200

150

100

50 31 30 25 29 27 26

0
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC

FULL TIME PART TIME TOTAL EE'S

Numbers do not reflect temporary, seasonal, relief fire dispatchers, committees, or council members.

MONTHJAN FEB MARAPR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC
FULL- TIME 356 358 362365 365364
PART-TIME 3130 25292726
TOTAL EE'S 387 388 387394 392390

Paj 83

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

JUNE’S INTERNAL EE AGE DEMOGRAPHICS

AGE DEMOGRAPHICS

18-24 6%

25-34 26%

35-44 21%

45-54 23%

55-64 19%

65+ 5%

0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%

AGEPERCENTAGE
18-246%
25-3426%
35-4421%
45-5423%
55-6419%
65 +5%

Paj 84

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

HIRING DETAILS

Position Hired: 1 FT ACCOUNTS PAYABLE CLERK, 1 FT PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER, 1 PT BUILDING SUPERVISOR, AND 4 PT PLAYGROUND LEADERS Transferred/Promoted: 0 Position Terminated/Resigned/Retired/Other: 1 PT VOLUNTARY, 1 FT RETIREMENT Terminal Leave: N/A

JUNE’S VACANT POSITIONS

VACANT POSITIONS BY DEPT.ORIGINAL POSTING DATEMay-24
CHIEF BUILDING INSPECTOR/PLANNING, INSPECTIONS, AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT 6/13/2024 FT
ARBORIST/PARKS AND RECREATION1/10/2024FT
LIBRARY ASSISTANT - YOUTH SERVICES/DOVER PUBLIC LIBRARY4/3/2024PT
LIBRARY PAGE/DOVER PUBLIC LIBRARY5/21/2024PT
ACCOUNTANT II/FINANCE DEPT5/21/2024FT
PARKS AND RECREATION DIRECTOR/PARKS AND RECREATION3/27/2024FT
PLANNING, INSPECTIONS, AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR/PLANNING AND INSPECTIONS DEPT 10/18/2023 FT
CONTROLLER - POSITON IS NO LONGER POSTEDFT
MOTOR EQUIPMENT OPERATOR I/SANITATION3/4/2024FT
ANIMAL CONTROL OFFICER/POLICE DEPT2/12/2024FT
CIVIL ENGINEER I/WATER/WASTEWATER DEPT2/1/2024FT
HUMAN RESOURCES GENERALIST7/26/2023FT
BUILDING SUPERVISOR/PARKS AND RECREATION DEPT1/18/2024PT
VICTIM SERVICES ADVOCATE/POLICE DEPT2/7/2024PT
PASSPORT CLERK/DOVER PUBLIC LIBRARY4/3/2024PT
PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER/POLICE DEPT11/29/2023FT
PLANNER II/PLANNING DEPT10/10/2023FT
MOTOR EQUIPMENT OPERATOR I/STORMWATER DIVISION5/1/2024FT
MOTOR EQUIPMENT OPERATOR I/ WATER/WASTEWATER DEPT5/1/2024FT
POLICE CADET/POLICE DEPTALWAYS OPENPT
RELIEF FIRE DISPATCHER/FIRE DEPTALWAYS OPENPT (AS NEEDED
BUILDING MAINTENANCE CRAFTSPERSON I6/27/2024FT

*Not used for Budgeting Purposes

Paj 85

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

TURNOVER STATISTICS

Monthly

Number ofAverageQuarterlyAnnual
Turnover
MonthSeparatedNumber ofTurnoverTurnover
Rates
EmployeesEmployeesRatesRate
(Percentage)
January03870.0%
February13880.3%
March43871.0%1.3%
April43941.0%
May23920.5%
June23900.5%2.0%
July010.0%
August010.0%
September010.0%0.0%
October010.0%
November010.0%
December010.0%0.0%3.3%

Paj 86

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

Monthly Turnover Rates (Percentage)

1.2%

1.0% 1.0%
1.0%

0.8%

0.6%
0.5% 0.5%

0.4%

0.3%

0.2%

0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
0.0%

Paj 87

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

Quarterly and Annual Turnover Rates
3.5% Annual, 3.3%

3.0%

2.5%

Q2, 2.0%
2.0%

1.5%
Q1, 1.3%

1.0%

0.5%

Q3, 0.0% Q4, 0.0%
0.0%

Paj 88

Item #9.

HUMAN RESOURCES

JUNE’S WORKER’S COMPENSATION DATA

MONTHMAY-24JUNE-24
WORKERS COMP INJURY DETAIL56

WORKERS COMP COST JUNE 2024

TOTAL 7097.12

PROCUREMENT 294.31

GROUNDS 1129.48

POLICE 1653.78

STORMWATER 2977.53

METERING 807.46

CODE ENFORCEMENT 234.56

0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000

Respectfully Submitted by H. Naomi Poole

Paj 89

Item #9.

Information Technology Department
June 2024 Report
Larry Josefowski, Director

Network Security: The grant program continues to be on hold, due to some regulatory issues between DEMA and FEMA, and we are looking at an early July approval date. Dover continues to be part of the committee and are working with other cities to try to get other years’ funding released, so we can apply for grants for those years. There is some concern at the national level that these funds have been under-utilized – approximately half of the FY-22 funding, and less than 25% of FY-23 funding have been released.

System Improvements: Work on Hyper-V environment (which is our virtual server environment – all servers but one have been virtualized) continues, making some improvements to increase reliability. We also discussed possible system improvements in regard to Internet connectivity, but the cost is prohibitive given the relative reliability we currently have.

We also continue to work with our vendors on improving our Wi-Fi capabilities. Some issues have been identified, and some improvements have been noted.

We also continue the work with the vendor on the networking of the upcoming Dover Park.

Tyler Enterprise ERP: Upgrades are on hold due to budget season, but a major upgrade will be done in early July. There were discussions with Finance on some of the billing demands of Tyler.

Training/Conferences: The director attended the Multi-State Information Sharing and Analysis Center in Orlando, Florida. We attended several meetings and conferences on a variety of topics, as well as a sit down review of the existing services we use from the organization. . Topics of particular interest were Generative Artificial Intelligence, Ransomware, workplace strategies, incident response, women in cybersecurity,

Metrics: We track a fairly large number of metrics, and we’re highlighting some of the ones we don’t usually show, and why we track them.

Maximum Bandwidth: This measures the most Internet that we are consuming during the course of a given month. We track this to ensure that we have enough resources to handle the demands of employees, citizens, and our various processes that operate 24 hours a day, with peak usage often occurring after business hours due to cloud activity. It also allows us to forecast our needs, and some capacity planning for redundant operations.

% Windows 11 installed: Support for Windows 10 end next October and getting all of our computers upgraded to Windows 11 is a must, with the goal of having all upgrades done before September 1st of next year. We have developed an imaging process as part of this that makes installation and reinstallation easier but are focusing on replacement computers and those used for training purposes at this time, as well as identifying any computers that will not work with Windows 11. We will be setting more targeted goals towards the end of the year for 2025 to ensure we meet this deadline.

Percent Training completed: This indicates the percentage of employees and elected officials who have completed the required training. We require all new employees to undergo this training, as well as refresher training conducted annually.

INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY - 1

Paj 90

Item #9.

Maximum BandwidthRisk Score (From KnowBe4)
Throughput (MBs)50
40048
46
350
44
30042
40
250
38
20036
34
150
32
10030
January February MarchAprilMayJuneJanuary February MarchAprilMayJune

Percent Windows 11 installed Percent training completed 100% 20% 95% 90% 85% 80% 10% 75% 70% 65% 60%

0%
January February March April May June

INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY - 2

Paj 91

Reference Transactions
June 2024 Item #9.

Adults855
Teens140

Children 262

0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000

CirculationJune '24FYTD '24June '23FYTD '23
City of Dover Residents11,070125,1109,601121,728
Electronic Materials6,13064,8754,84753,231
Kent County Residents9,814117,0198,60389,136
Non-County Residents1,31516,1711,33814,373
New Library Registrations
City of Dover Residents3522,8932102,760
Kent County Residents1461,5901261,360
Non-County Residents777659
Registered Library Users as of 06/01/2024Registered Library Users as of 06/30/2023
City of Dover Residents19,04917,313
Kent County Residents8,8567,108
Non-County Residents689616
TOTAL28,59425,037
Other
Visitors19,325178,15914,457173,618
Meeting Room Attendance4,96335,2332,11426,700
Number of Computer Users1,86220,8961,64518,949
Number of Wireless Computer Users1,67918,7321,63917,956
Inter/Intralibrary - Loaned4057
Inter/Intralibrary - Borrowed6988
Holds Sent2,7592,809
Holds Received4,7481,639
TOTAL7,61659,6194,59358,464
Tech Services/Items Added1,9512,109
Tech Services/Items Deleted1,4661,095
Passport Services/Customers2143,0732313,106
Passport Services/Revenue$8,097$122,179$9,054$125,339
Monthly Highlights
►366 attended 57 programs for adults.
►4,492 attended 15 program for teens.
►1,533 attended 36 programs for children.
► 0 volunteers.
Program Spotlight

Paj 92

Item #9.

Parks & Recreation Monthly Report - June 2024 Parks & RecreaƟon Highlights  Five Park Projects Update Dover Park Building and Spray Pad. Staff con nues to follow this project. Progress mee ngs have been held With Kent Contrac ng and Whitman Requardt & Associates to keep the project moving forward. All Accessible Playground staff con nues to follow this project. Onsite mee ngs have taken place regarding site prep and installa on. Staff is arranging a site visit for Congresswoman Lisa Blunt Rochester for a project status follow up. Skate Park in progress as noted in the FY25 CIP list. Nothing new to report at this me.

 Annual Youth Fishing Derby presented by the Dover Elks Lodge 1903 was another huge success! 99 children par cipated this year, with more than 300 fish caught. The children truly enjoyed the a ernoon of fishing, visi ng with Officer Roy (and his handler, Officer Killen) and our PAL Officer Anthony Smith and the awards ceremony that included free hots dogs, drinks & snack for all the kids. Thank you goes out to the Parks & Recrea on Department and Dover Police Department for their efforts to ensure this event successful.  Spring & Summer Performing Arts on The Green A special thanks goes to Bally’s of Dover for their Gold Level Sponsorship and to Shore United Bank for their Friend Parks & Recrea on sponsorship. Mark your calendars for Thursday Nights beginning June 6 at 7 pm for a night of free family entertainment!

Outdoor Sports & Leagues
Recreation Revenue Breakdown ParƟcipant & Spectator Count
AcƟvity ParƟcipants Spectators LocaƟon

Youth Soccer League 252 300 Schu e Park

Girls So ball Prac ces12520Dover Park
Church League So ball576480Schu e Park
Senior Mens So ball672126Schu e Park
Girls So ball Prac ces12515New Street Park
June 2024June 2023
Tuesday Night Track148223Dover High School
General Recrea on$1,573.50General Recrea on$1,899.75
Camps$24,755.00High School Field Hockey10254Dover High School
Camps$22,740.00
Leagues$4,300.00Leagues$4,400.00
Sports$175.00Sports$30.0
Park Permits/Bldg Rentals$1,100.00Park Permits/Rentals $1,000.00
Parks & RecreaƟonFYTDFYTD
June 24June 23
Programs2423
General Recrea on2932,9772422,959
Open Gym1422,730801,897
Sports391,857792,467
Leagues (Inside)76629,3301,82427,989
Bldg, Field, Facility permits6019018149
Camps5812,3355003,584

*Spring & Summer Concert Series ‐ Thursday evenings at 7pm ‐ The Green*

Paj 93

Item #9.

Grounds Monthly Report
Jun-24

Arborist Crew:Arborist Crew
- Alley trimming Tree Work Completed
- Street tree maintenance Tree's Trimmed 12
Tree's Removed5
Beautification Crew:Root Pruning2
- Continue maintenance on flower bed Stumps Removed 3
- Put up hanging baskets. Trees Planted 0

Mowing Crew:
- Mowing routes are being completed on schedule
- Began trimming trees and vegetation at mowing locations.

Litter Removal: - Litter is being picked up on city property as per the weekly schedule - Litter person has been diligent in the reporting of destruction in City parks - 454 Total 90 gallon cans collected - Removed 9 Shopping Carts

Parks Crew:
- Completed parks route daily
- Graded parking lots at Schutte Park
- Lined sports fields
- Prepped softball field weekly for games.
- Set up stage for events every weekend in June

Miscellaneous:
- Spraying at Parks and City property
- Bush hogging at City property

Paj 94

Item #9.

Litter Cans Collected 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec

2021 2022 2023 2024

Trees Removed
80

60

40

20

0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec

2021 2022 2023 2024

Trees Trimmed
250
200
150
100
50
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec

2021 2022 2023 2024

Paj 95

Item #9.

City Planner’s Monthly Report
Department of Planning & Inspections
JUNE 2024

Planning & Inspections Highlights
Some Items to Call to Your Attention

June was the ending month of Fiscal Year 2023-2024 and the kick-off to summer in Dover. As prime construction season and event season, Department Staff was kept busy from meetings of the sup- ported Boards and Commissions to issuing Permit and inspecting construction work. With applica- tions for development activities at Procter & Gamble and in the Downtown area, the future appears to continue a steady trend of development in the City. The commercial and residential sectors are very active. During the month, staff was also working on the drafting of text amendments to the Do- ver Code of Ordinances and sheparding other ordinances through the review and adoption process as related to code enforcement violations and fees and fines. An ordinance for changes to the Busi- ness License fess is also pending. The June construction pace continued to be high with Building Permits issued to thirteen (13) new house starts and with over $600,000 in construction value for commercial permits. The number of Inspections associated with construction activities for Building, Plumbing, and Mechanical Permits was higher with 595 inspections. By month’s end, Certificates of Occupancy were also issued to fourteen (14) additional dwelling units completed in the City. Department Revenue received for Fiscal Year 2024 exceeded the FY24 Budget estimates. The in- creases in the revenues were from Building Permits, and Plumbing/Mechanical Permits, and Fire Protection Permits. (See Revenue Report on next page). The Code Enforcement Staff continued to conduct Annual Housing Inspections as part of the Rental Dwelling Permit program with 71 completed in the month. There are currently close to 8,000 Rental Dwelling Units within the City. Due to dry weather, the number of Tall Grass & Weeds Violations decreased. Other Code Enforcement cases focused on exterior property maintenance issues/violations and Dover Code of Ordi- nance violations. For the month, there were over 640 inspections conducted. For the Fire Marshal’s Office Staff, the number of fire investiga- tions in June increase to nine (9)incidents. The Fire Marshal’s Office was involved in inspections related to Special Events in the Downtown area continued with multiple events including the Afri- can American Festival.

Paj 96

Item #9.

Planning & Inspections Revenue

FY2024 Revenue

Estimates fromFY2024 Actual
Revenue StreamBudget(YTD) June% of Budget
Business License$1,450,000 $ 1,484,561102%
Manufactured Home License$16,000 $14,51791%
Building Permits$450,000 $807,871180%
Cert. of Occupancy$8,000 $10,735134%
Public Occupancy$45,000 $47,550106%
Lodging House$28,000 $29,351105%

Plumbing/Heating/Air $105,000 $ 115,701 110%

Rental Inspection Fee$750,000 $744,83699%
Miscellaneous$20,000 $23,995120%
Fire Protection Fees$70,000 $133,770191%

Code Enforcement Fines $100,000 $ 81,221 81%

Vacant Building Reg.$70,000 $38,75055%
Total P&I Revenue$3,112,000 $ 3,532,858114%

Department Operations Managers from each Division of the Department participated in the Emergency Operations Plan (EOP) Workshop on June 5th in reviewing the operational functions and response activities for various hazards. The Draft EOP is being developed by the City’s Emergency Operations Manager with consultant assistance. It is a key component to receiving FEMA reimbursement of disaster response expenditures.

Planning Office Operations The Meetings of the Boards and Commission supported by the Planning Office are presented in the Hybrid format with both In-Person and Virtual (using Webex) meeting options for participation. Electronic commu- nications and conducting Meetings and Trainings in virtual formats are commonplace due to realized effi- ciencies. The Planning Office is part of the review process for certain types of construction activity permits (Building Permits, Sign Permits, etc.) and Certificate of Occupancy permits in order to confirm compliance with the Zoning Ordinance provisions. For June 2024, Planning Staff was involved with the review of 75 Building Per- mits and 10 Certificates of Occupancy permits that were issued for a monthly total of 85 and a year-to-date total of 449. The 2024 year-to-date tally is lower than the year-to-date totals of Permits and COs seen in 2023 at 542 and in 2022 at 493. Staff also reviews new applications for Business Licenses and Rental Dwell- ing Permits.

JUNE 2024 (FY24)TOTAL FOR FY24
New Home Permits Issued13108
Value of Commercial Projects$676,759.00$76,711,380.00
Downtown Incentives (Fees Waived)
$0.00$31,304.35

Paj 97

Item #9.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPLEMENTATION

2019 Comprehensive Plan Implementation of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan continues as Departments citywide focus on the plan im- plementation items as found in Implementation Plan (Chapter 15) items such as the projects, studies, code amendments, and other activities. A copy of the Final Plan (as amended) is available on the Comprehensive Plan website: https://www.cityofdover.com/2019-comprehensive-plan Visit the Dover Parcel and Zoning Viewer on the City’s website to see zoning information for properties located in Dover. Use the Quick Link on the main page www.cityofdover.com.

Other Activities • Downtown Dover Strategic Master Plan: The Downtown Dover Partnership’s Strategic Master Plan is known as “Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030” (January 2023). Various partners are focusing on aspects of Plan implementation. Currently, the Downtown Dover Partnership and the Do- ver/Kent County MPO are finalizing the Downtown Dover Pathways Study (underway with consultants). Also, the City is involved in planning for water and sanitary sewer improvement projects in the Down- town area. Downtown Development District – Renewal Application: The Downtown Development District (DDD) for the City of Dover was designated in January 2015 for a period of ten years. The City is eligible to ap- ply for a five-year extension of this designation. Rossi, a consultant group, has been retained to assist the City in preparation of the Renewal Application. The Draft Renewal Application and DDD Plan along with adopted Resolution #2024-06 supporting the Renewal Application for a five-year extension and including expansion of the DDD boundaries are being prepared for formal review.

Construction Activities • In June 2024, Residential Building Permits were issued for eight (8) Townhouse units in Rojan Meadows PND; five (5) Townhouse units (by D.R. Horton) in the Eden Hill Farm TND; and a manufactured home placement in Kings Cliffe Manufactured Home Park. • Certificates of Occupancy were issued to a single-family detached dwelling (by Chatham Bay) and five (5) Townhouse units (by D.R. Horton) in Eden Hill Farm TND; and for two (2) single family detached dwellings in the Downtown Development District. • Building Permits issued in June were for apartment renovations at 231 W. Loockerman Street (Rear); office renovation at 303 Transportation Circle; a Site Work Permit for future retail store at 293 S. Sauls- bury Road (S-22-16); and Parking Lot Improvements at 1128 Forrest Avenue (S-24-04). • A Temporary Certificate of Occupancy was issued for the MOD Wash, a car wash facility at 1414 N. DuPont Highway (S-21-10). A Certificate of Occupancy was issued for East Carolina Warehouse at 300 Ridgely Street (S-23-01).

Paj 98

Item #9.

2024: Welcome to Dover!
Progress in Pictures

East Carolina Warehouse 1414 N DUPONT HWY -MOD CAR WASH At 300 Ridgely Street

541 Ruth Way—Eden Hill Farm TND (Chatham Bay)

Paj 99

Item #9.

2024: Welcome to Dover!
Progress in Pictures

23 S. Governors Avenue

25 S. Governors Avenue

211, 213,215,
217, 219 Ridgely
Blvd (Eden Hill
Farm TND – by
D.R. Horton)

Paj 100

Item #9. BOARD AND COMMISSION ACTIVITY There were Meetings in June of the Boards and Commissions supported by the Planning Office. The Planning Commission Meeting on June 17, 2024 consisted of review of a Conditional Use Application, a Site Plan (Master Plan) Application, and two (2) Appeals of Historic District Commission Actions. The Historic District Commission met on June 20, 2024 to consider an Application for Architectural Review Certification (Demolition). The Board of Adjustment met on June 20, 2024 to consider a variance application.

Planning Commission: The Planning Commission met on June 17, 2024. The next Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for July 15, 2024.

  • •C-24-01 Tower-Based Wireless Communications Facility at 640 Lafferty Lane (Rise Up Towers, LLC) - The Planning Commission granted conditional approval of the Conditional Use Site Plan Application to permit construction of a tower-based wireless communications facility (WCF) and associated equipment compound in the northeastern area of the mini-storage facility property. The proposed wireless support structure is a monopole of 124 feet with a lightning rod for a total height of 129 feet. The 18.68-acre sub- ject property is located on the north side of Lafferty Lane, east of South Bay Road. The property is zoned IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone). The owner of record (parcel) is Secure Storage, LLC and the applicant (WCF developer/owner) is Rise Up Towers, LLC. Property Address: 640 Lafferty Lane.
  • •S-24-09 Procter & Gamble Warehouse Expansions & Parking Improvements - The Planning Commission granted conditional approval of a Site Development Plan Application to permit a phased construction of a 110,000 SF addition to JE Warehouse, a 20,000 SF addition to Warehouse 3, an expansion of employee/ visitor parking lot, an expansion and reconfiguration of contractor parking lot, and expansion of truck drop Lots A & B with associated site improvements. The property of 84.10 acres± is zoned IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone) and is subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone: Tier 3 – Excellent Recharge Area). The property is located on the south side of W. North Street/ Hazlettville Road at the southeast corner of Electric Avenue and Mifflin Road intersection with W. North Street. The owner of record is The Dover Wipes Company and equitable owner Procter & Gamble. Prop- erty Address: 1340 W. North Street.
  • •HI-24-02 Building at 148 S. Bradford Street: Demolition – The Planning Commission granted approval of the Architectural Review Certification (to allow Demolition) after consideration of the Appeal to the Plan- ning Commission of the Historic District Commission Action to deny the Architectural Review Certifica- tion for the Demolition of the existing 1 ½ story, stucco clad building. The parcel consists of 0.13 +/- acres of land. The property is zoned C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) and subject to H (Historic District Zone). The property is located on the west side of S. Bradford Street and slightly north of Minor Street Alley. The owner of record is Russell and Dee Ann Widder. The applicant is the Downtown Dover Part- nership. Property Address: 148 S. Bradford Street. Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.09-02-25.00-000.
  • •HI-24-03 Building at 150 S. Bradford Street: Demolition – The Planning Commission granted approval of the Architectural Review Certification (to allow Demolition) after consideration of the Appeal to the Plan- ning Commission of the Historic District Commission Action to deny the Architectural Review Certifica- tion for the Demolition of the existing 2 ½ story, frame building. The parcel consists of 0.17 +/- acres of land. The property is zoned C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) and subject to H (Historic District Zone). The property is located on the west side of S. Bradford Street at the corner with Minor Street Alley. The owner of record is CEI Properties, LLC. The applicant is the Downtown Dover Partnership. Property Address: 150 S. Bradford Street. Tax Parcel: ED05-077.09-02-27.00-000.

Paj 101

Item #9.

Historic District Commission: The Historic District Commission met on June 20, 2024. The next Historic District Commission meeting is scheduled for July 20, 2024.

  • •HI-24-05 Building at 120 S Governors Avenue: Demolition – The Historic District Commission granted approval of the Architectural Review Certification to allow the demolition of the existing commercial building (former Acme grocery store and other more recent tenants). The parcel contains 1.70 +/- acres with a 19,136 SF building. The property is zoned C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) and subject to H (Historic District Zone). The property is located on the west side of South Governors Avenue and half- way between Reed Street and West Loockerman Street. The owner of record is Downtown Dover Devel- opment Corporation c/o Downtown Dover Partnership. Property Address: 120 S. Governors Avenue, Dover. Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.09-01-44.00-000. Council District 4.

Board of Adjustment: The Board of Adjustment met on June 20, 2024. The next Board of Adjustment meeting is scheduled for July 17, 2024.

  • •V-24-01 Legislative Hall Parking Garage Project - Legislative Hall Parking Garage Project The Board of Adjustment granted approval to two variances related to development in the floodplain as associated with the proposed redevelopment of the property for construction of a three-story Parking Garage and other site improvements with portions of the existing surface parking lot and an office/credit union build- ing to remain. The project requested variances from the Zoning Ordinance, Article 5 Section 11.21 per- taining to development within the Flood Hazard Area (1% Annual Chance Flood/100-year floodplain). Variance Request 1 as approved allows a decrease in the required reduction of the impervious surface area of the predevelopment conditions on the lot from 15% to 5% (Article 5 Section 11.211a). Variance Request 2 as approved recognizes that 48.7% of the lot is within the flood hazard area which is greater than 33% that allows Planning Commission consideration of reductions in impervious surfaces (Article 5 Section 11.211b). These Variance Requests allow for some project development within the Flood Hazard Area. The 5.28 acre +/- property is zoned IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and is subject to H (Historic District Zone). The property is located at the southeast corner of Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard South and East Avenue/E. Water Street. The owner of record is the State of Delaware - OMB: Division of Fa- cilities Management. Property. Property Address: 425 East Avenue and existing building addressed as 150 E. Water Street. Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.10-01-02.00-000.

Paj 102

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT PROGRAM Item #9.

CDBG FY23 Projects

  • •Homeownership Assistance Program CDBG funds will be used to provide homeownership assistance to first-time homebuyers who purchase affordable housing in the City of Dover. One family purchased a home and one family is scheduled to close at the end of July.
  • •Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing (DIMH) CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for the shelter. DIMH has purchased a building for its new shelter location that will be renovated with CDBG funds. This project is underway. Seventy percent 70% of project funds have been spent year-to-date and 100% of funds have been spent on renovations cost.
  • •Central Delaware Housing Collaborative CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for a women’s shelter. This project is underway. Seventy percent (70%) of program funds have been spent year-to-date.
  • •Milford Housing Homeowner Rehabilitation/Emergency Home Repair Pro- grams CDBG funds will be used to rehabilitate existing owner-occupied housing in the City that are in violation of the City’s Housing Code and complete emergency home repairs to eliminate housing conditions that threaten the health and safety of low-income home- owners. Two owner occupied homes have been rehabbed and six (6) homes received emergency home repairs.
  • •American Rescue Act (ARPA) Funding City Council approved to award a little over $1.8 million in grant funding for Housing and Community Service projects. All projects are underway. A little under $1.5 million or 80% of funds have been spent on Round 1 of ARPA funding year to date. Dover Housing Authority, Murphey School and Reading Assist have completed their projects. ARPA Round 2 funding for a little under $500,000 was awarded to subgrantees in April 2023. Projects are currently underway. Thirty percent (30%) of funds have been drawn down for Round 2 with Murphey School completing their project.

Paj 103

Item #9.
CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY

DECEMEBER 2023 DECEMEBER

2023 DECEMEBER 2023 DE-

CEMEBER 2023 DECEMEBER 2023

DECEMEBER 2023 DECEMEBER

2023
Case Type Current MTD MTD FY23 % Changed YTD Total FY24 YTD Total
FY 23 % Changed YTD

Dangerous Buildings, Vacant Buildings, Demolitions & Announcements  Vacant Buildings currently registered - 131  Dangerous Buildings – 45  Active Rental Dwellings – 7,941 units  Active Demolitions - 137 S Queen St , 130 S New St, 132 S New St & 134 S New St

Paj 104

Building Inspections & Licensing Summary Item #9.

July 2022—
July 2023–
Current June 2024 June 2023 June 2023

PERMITTING AND LICENSING

Permits IssuedJUNE (2024)JUNE (2023)
FY 24FYTD 24FY23FYTD 23
Administrative Permit
457769
Building Addition/Renovation Permits3236529359
Building Permits
2825024266
Demolition Permits
332327
Fence Permits2118117295
Fire Prevention Permits9115777
Mechanical Permits
3036820512
Plumbing Permits
4233429566
Sign Permits915311105
Swimming Pool Permits
19116
Subtotal18642292
Business Licenses202020251911
Merchant Licenses
03650330
Contractor Licenses
211369221288
Subtotal37543529

Lodging House Licenses

047048
Public Occupancy
2055121510
Rental Dwelling472971693046
Subtotal35693604

Manufactured Homes 6 326 2 285

BUILDING INSPECTIONS

InspectionsJUNE (2024)JUNE (2023)
FY 24FYTD 24FY23FYTD 23
Building (Inspections/CBI/Site Meetings)
30219494874421
Plumbing/Mechanical
29320012214726
Certificate of Occupancy
1014328224

Paj 105

Item #9.
Office of the Fire Marshal
-The Fire Marshal’s Office staff investigated nine inci-
dents during the month of June.
-Staff worked Comic Con, Goodguys car show, Juneteenth
events, and the African American Festival to ensure that all
of the citizens and visitors were safe during the festivities.

MonthYear to DatePrevious Year to Date
Annual Fire & Life Safety Inspections23335388

Deficiencies From the Above Inspections 47 909 1,345

Fire Code Violations/Deficiencies/ 52 300 309

C/O & Fire Equipment Acceptance Tests 9 125 127

Meetings & Walk Through 14 239 213

Fire Plan Review & DAC 7 160 132

Month Year to Date Previous Year to Date Accidental 4 totaling $1,500 36 totaling $2,048,005 37 totaling $1,254,602

Undetermined 4 totaling $1,125 17 totaling $707,728 12 totaling $800,002

Incendiary 1 totaling $100 11 totaling $26,603 12 totaling $4,087,253

Natural 0 1 totaling $60,000 0

Arrest Made with DPD 0 2 4

Investigation Time13 hours142 hours233 hours
Injuries2111

Deaths 0 1 0

Paj 106

Item #9.

Paj 107

Item #9.

Paj 108

Item #9.

Paj 109

Item #9.

Paj 110

Item #9.

CITY OF DOVER

DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER

MONTHLY REPORT

Jun-24

Inflow & Infiltration Costs

$300,000.00This chart indicates the amount of money the City is
spending on treating ground and / or rain water
through Kent County. This cost is being offset by the
$250,000.00Ground Water Inflow Adjustment rate passed on to the
customers. April 2024 had a large amout of rainfall,
causing a significant I & I deficit.
$200,000.00

$150,000.00

$100,000.00

$50,000.00

$- Jun-23 Jul-23 Aug-23 Sep-23 Oct-23 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24

I & I Cost

Water & Wastewater Repairs

7Water mains and services are typically
repaired at a higher rate when drastic
change in temperature occurs. This
6freeze and thaw cycle expands and
contracts the soil, causing cracks in the
5water line. November 2023 had large
fluctuations of temperature, causing a
large volume of repairs.
4

3

2

1

0 Jun-23 Jul-23 Aug-23 Sep-23 Oct-23 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24

Water Mains Repaired Water Services Repaired Wastewater Mains Repaired Wastewater Laterals Repaired

Paj 111

Item #9.

CITY OF DOVER

DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER

MONTHLY REPORT

Jun-24

Number of Brown Water Complaints
20
This chart indicates the number of

18complaints the Department receives.
March 2024 was high because it has
16been over 5 months since the last
flushing operation.
14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0 Jun-23 Jul-23 Aug-23 Sep-23 Oct-23 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24

Number of Brown Water Complaints Linear (Number of Brown Water Complaints)

Department Spotlight - May
The Department of Water & Wastewater secured a
contractor to replace roughly 1 mile of water main on N.
State Street

Paj 112

Item #10.

Paj 113

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

This page intentionally left blank

PagePage
2 113

Paj 114

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

CITY OF DOVER

ACTIVITY REPORTS

June 2024

FY23 YTDFY24 YTD
BANK TRENDS
Number of Deposits Made (Hand, ACH & Wire, Lockbox)6,4036,488
Total Amount of All Deposits$ 197,887,959 $ 157,753,299
Other Activity
Number of Pay Periods2727
Number of Direct Deposits Issued11,01910,694
Number of Pension Checks Issued3,1553,099
Total Pension Benefits Paid - Defined Benefit Plan $ 5,564,851 $ 6,103,084

ACCOUNTS PAYABLE

Number of Check Vouchers6,1586,407
Number of EFT Vouchers4,1694,142
Vouchers Dollar Amount Disbursed$106,256,358$109,605,164

$109,384

FY23 YTD Wages$91,338FY24 YTD Wages
$111,701$1,028,696$151,029$732,496
$284,997$335,444
$812,312$770,684
$1,624,795

$1,948,513

$2,027,598 $2,558,779

$20,595,200$23,177,598
RegularRegular

All over time All over time

Vacation Vacation

Sick Sick

Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout

Personal Personal
Comp Time Comp Time
Other Other

Other includes: pay adjustments, military differential pay, training, committee meetings, worker compensation tracking/adjustments, etc.

PagePage
3 114

Paj 115

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

City of Dover Preliminary
General Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (June 2024)

Revenues

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Property & Transfer Taxes$ 18,056,100$ 18,056,100 $18,543,559103%
Program Revenues12,354,70012,670,30015,158,592120%
Utility Transfers9,000,0009,000,0009,000,000100%
Grants883,500923,5001,665,994180%
Interfund Services6,236,4006,236,4006,024,47397%
14,066,0004,296,3003,690,30086%
All Other
$ 50,596,700$ 51,182,600 $54,082,918106%
Expenditures
Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Program Expenses$ 34,903,300$ 34,840,300 $32,789,17194%
Interfund Services12,177,00012,487,50011,543,90892%
Debt Service630,700630,700627,990100%
Post Retirement Benefits2,548,0002,548,0002,548,000100%
Pension Fund Contributions1,000,0001,000,0001,000,000100%
Capital Project Transfers2,920,1003,037,8003,037,800100%
23,052,8003,052,8003,242,641106%
All Other
$ 57,231,900$ 57,597,100 $54,789,51095%

1 Includes Cable Franchise Revenue, Miscellaneous Receipts, Garrison Farm Rent, Sales of Assets, Fund Invest Manager Cost. 2 Includes Bank and CC Fees, Street Lights Expense, DDP Contribution, Trf to Cable Franchise Reserve, Trf to Electric I & E, and Trf to Electric Revenue Fund, Trf to Uncollectible Reserve and Misc. Grant Expense and Trf to Economic Development Reserve Fund.

PagePage
4 115

Paj 116

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

General Fund Revenues
$20,000,000

$18,000,000

$16,000,000

$14,000,000

$12,000,000

$10,000,000

$8,000,000

$6,000,000

$4,000,000

$2,000,000

$- Property & Transfer Taxes Program Revenues Utility Transfers Grants Interfund Services All Other 1

Original Budget Revised Budget Actual

General Fund Expenditures
$40,000,000

$35,000,000

$30,000,000

$25,000,000

$20,000,000

$15,000,000

$10,000,000

$5,000,000

$-

Program Expenses Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Benefits Pension Fund Contributions Capital Project Transfers All Other 2

Original Budget Revised Budget Actual

PagePage
5 116

Paj 117

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

City of Dover Preliminary
Water Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (June 2024)

Revenues

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Customer Sales$6,550,000$6,550,000 $6,544,591100%
Impact Fees225,000225,000353,484157%
Rents435,500435,500423,58897%
Miscellaneous 175,20075,200357,635476%
$7,285,700$7,285,700 $7,679,298105%

Expenditures

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Program Expenses$4,156,100$4,132,700 $3,776,54591%
Interfund Services1,138,0001,138,0001,095,76796%
Debt Service700,000700,000634,28491%
Post Retirement Benefits226,900226,900226,900100%
Capital Project Transfers1,536,7001,536,7001,536,700100%
Electric I&E Fund Transfer25,00025,00025,000100%
General Fund Transfer500,000500,000500,000100%
All Other 232,00032,00027,23185%
$8,314,700$8,291,300 $7,822,42694%

1 Includes Penalties, Income from Sale of Assets, Miscellaneous Income, and Reconnect Fees. 2 Includes Bank & CC Fees.

PagePage
6 117

Paj 118

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

Water Revenues
$7,000,000

$6,000,000

$5,000,000

$4,000,000

$3,000,000

$2,000,000

$1,000,000

$-
Customer Sales Impact Fees Rents Miscellaneous 1

Original Budget Revised Budget Actual

Water Expenditures
$4,500,000

$4,000,000

$3,500,000

$3,000,000

$2,500,000

$2,000,000

$1,500,000

$1,000,000

$500,000

$-

Program Expenses Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Benefits Capital Project Transfers Electric I&E Fund Transfer General Fund Transfer All Other 2

Original Budget Revised Budget Actual

Paj 119

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

City of Dover Preliminary
Wastewater Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (June 2024)

Revenues

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Customer Sales$ 10,326,000$ 10,326,000 $10,222,83499%
Impact Fees225,000225,000312,451139%
Miscellaneous 150,200188,600373,840198%
$ 10,601,200$ 10,739,600 $10,909,125102%

Expenditures

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Program Expenses$ 1,649,200$ 1,689,200 $1,471,39787%
Kent County Treatment Fee4,730,0004,828,4004,874,159101%
Interfund Services870,900870,900841,74197%
Debt Service696,200696,200603,16087%
Post Retirement Benefits110,000110,000110,000100%
Capital Project Transfers2,270,9002,270,9002,270,900100%
Electric I&E Transfer25,00025,00025,000100%
General Fund Transfer500,000500,000500,000100%
All Other 215,00015,00011,50877%
$ 10,867,200$ 11,005,600 $10,707,86597%

1 Includes Interest Income, Penalties, Loss on Disposal, and Miscellaneous Income. 2 Includes Bank & CC Fees.

PagePage
8 119

Paj 120

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

Wastewater Revenues
$12,000,000

$10,000,000

$8,000,000

$6,000,000

$4,000,000

$2,000,000

$-
Customer Sales Impact Fees Miscellaneous 1

Original Budget Revised Budget Actual

Wastewater Expenditures
$6,000,000

$5,000,000

$4,000,000

$3,000,000

$2,000,000

$1,000,000

$-

Program Expenses Kent County Treatment Interfund Services Debt Service Post Retirement Capital Project Transfers Electric I&E Transfer General Fund Transfer All Other 2 Fee Benefits

Original Budget Revised Budget Actual

Paj 121

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

City of Dover Preliminary
Electric Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (June 2024)

Revenues

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Customer Sales$ 92,743,400$ 92,743,400 $86,369,22493%
12,299,0002,299,0005,632,938245%
All Other
$ 95,042,400$ 95,042,400 $92,002,16297%

Expenditures

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Power Supply & Generation$ 82,658,600$ 82,856,900 $44,608,67854%
Electric Operating Div. Exp.9,208,7009,208,7009,000,41798%
Interfund Services4,227,5004,227,5004,086,96697%
Debt Service1,482,6001,482,6001,401,00594%
Post Retirement Benefits997,000997,000997,000100%
General Fund Transfer8,000,0008,000,0008,000,000100%
23,004,9003,004,9002,430,39981%
All Other
$ 109,579,300$ 109,777,600 $70,524,46564%
1
Includes Rental Revenue, Miscellaneous Service Revenue, Interest Earnings, Investment Management Fees,
New Service Fees, Sale of Assets, Trf from Uncollectible Reserves, General Service Billing, Revenue from Rate
Stabilization, Penalties, Green Energy Charges, and Delay Damages.
2
Includes Utility Tax, Interest on Deposits, Bank & CC Fees, Bond Issuance Costs, Transfer to Uncollectible
Reserve, and Green Energy.
Megawatt Hours Sold & PurchasedBudgetRev. BudgetActual
Sales to Customers MWh (excl. Street Light MWh)760,876760,876710,106
Sales per MWh$119.74$119.74$119.71
Purchased/Generated MWh773,010-773,010-759,192-
All In MWh Supply & Generation$106.87$107.12$58.70

Page Page
10 121

Paj 122

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

Electric Fund - Revenues

Millions
$80 $90 $100

Original Budget

Revised Budget

Actual

Customer Sales All Other 1

Electric Fund - Expenditures

$90,000,000

$85,000,000

$80,000,000

$75,000,000

$70,000,000

$65,000,000

$60,000,000

$55,000,000

$50,000,000

$45,000,000

$40,000,000

$35,000,000

$30,000,000

$25,000,000

$20,000,000

$15,000,000

$10,000,000

$5,000,000

$-

Power Supply &Electric Operating Div.Post Retirement
Interfund ServicesDebt ServiceGeneral Fund TransferAll Other 2
GenerationExp.Benefits
Original Budget$82,658,6009,208,7004,227,5001,482,600997,0008,000,0003,004,900
Revised Budget$82,856,9009,208,7004,227,5001,482,600997,0008,000,0003,004,900
Actual$44,608,6789,000,4174,086,9661,401,005997,0008,000,0002,430,399

Original Budget Revised Budget Actual

Page Page
11 122

Paj 123

Item #10.
Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024

City of Dover Preliminary
Division Expense Summary (General Fund)
Fiscal Year to Date (June 2024)

Original Budget Revised BudgetActual%General Fund Divisions % of Budget
City Clerk$414,200 $414,200 $427,881103%
Council260,000260,000234,31090%Mayor
Fire851,600851,600854,253100%Human Resources
Grounds1,741,1001,741,1001,603,12692%Customer Services
Library2,040,7002,040,7001,899,17693%
Fleet Maintenance
Recreation1,549,6001,549,6001,446,63193%
Procurement & Inventory
Life Safety690,600886,700735,73183%
Code Enforcement1,173,600957,500780,36582%Engineering
Planning826,100826,100615,53775%Facilities Management
Public Inspections800,800800,800733,04892%Pub. Services Administration
Police21,550,90021,495,00020,713,23796%Finance
Police Extra Duty405,000405,000746,018184%
Information Technology
Streets768,600783,785713,54391%
Sanitation3,060,1003,060,3402,591,52285%City Manager
Stormwater906,400903,875708,15978%Stormwater
City Manager1,300,1001,487,4001,457,14998%Sanitation
Information Technology874,100874,100809,69893%Streets
Finance1,032,3001,032,300752,67673%
Police Extra Duty
Pub. Services Administration646,900647,900616,71395%
Police
Facilities Management822,100822,100798,55097%
Engineering279,300279,300251,95190%Public Inspections
Procurement & Inventory873,600868,600844,17097%Planning
Fleet Maintenance1,078,6001,083,6001,032,28495%Code Enforcement
Customer Services1,417,5001,417,5001,280,36890%
Life Safety
Human Resources501,300481,300373,33578%
Recreation
Mayor245,200245,200201,46282%
$ 46,110,300 $ 46,215,600 $ 43,220,89394%Library
Grounds
Fire
Council
City Clerk
0%20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 160% 180% 200%

Page Page
12 123

Paj 124

Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024
Item #10.

City of Dover Preliminary
Utilities Expenditure Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (June 2024)

Water Divison

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Engineering & Inspection$386,500$386,500 $298,14677%
Water Department862,100862,100764,94489%
Water Treatment Plant2,907,5002,884,1002,713,45494%
$4,156,100$4,132,700 $3,776,54591%

Wastewater Divison

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Engineering & Inspection$304,100$304,100 $160,04953%
Wastewater Department1,345,1001,385,1001,311,34995%
$1,649,200$1,689,200 $1,471,39787%

Electric Division

Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual%
Transmission/Distribution$4,893,100$4,893,100 $4,886,611100%
Electrical Engineering1,826,6001,826,6001,700,14893%
Administration1,020,2001,020,200900,45288%
Meter Reading460,500460,500553,085120%
Systems Operations1,008,3001,008,300960,12195%
$9,208,700$9,208,700 $9,000,41798%

Paj 125

Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024
Item #10.

Water Division % of Budget

Water Treatment Plant

Water Department

Engineering & Inspection

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

Wastewater Division % of Budget

Wastewater Department

Engineering & Inspection

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

Electric Division % of Budget

Systems Operations

Meter Reading

Administration

Electrical Engineering

Transmission/Distribution

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140%

Paj 126

Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024
Item #10.

City of Dover Preliminary
Capital Outlay Summary (All Funds)
Fiscal Year to Date (June 2024)

General FundOriginal Budget Revised BudgetActual%
Fire$419,600 $419,600 $371,76089%
City Manager-40,00040,000100%
Code Enforcement34,60063,60042,36967%
Public Works Admin30,00030,00027,66092%
Public Works Eng48,30048,30041,32286%
Police1,186,5001,398,200751,21654%
Streets852,3003,577,800801,74622%
Sanitation707,8001,464,400982,10967%
Stormwater1,135,0003,554,700925,45226%
Grounds214,500249,300236,16095%
Library County Grant-87,30057,36566%
Recreation835,0002,900,6002,029,88370%
Inspections-30,10030,068100%
Purchasing-70,000-0%
Information Technology115,500115,50048,39242%
Facilities Management80,000159,30076,24948%
Fleet Maintenance30,000535,700519,47197%
General Fund Capital Projects$5,689,100 $ 14,744,400 $6,981,22247%

Water Fund

Water$4,579,300 $6,093,000 $2,059,81734%
Water Engineering48,00048,00041,32286%
Water Treatment Plant56,500423,300132,18731%
Water Fund Capital Projects$4,683,800 $6,564,300 $2,233,32634%

Wastewater Fund

Wastewater$2,576,900 $4,428,600 $955,74522%
Wastewater Fund Capital Projects$2,576,900 $4,428,600 $955,74522%

Electric Fund

Electric Generation$275,000 $ 12,723,400 $ 6,340,41950%
Transmission/Distribution2,497,4002,936,1002,060,30470%
Electrical Engineering2,076,0008,670,6004,663,81754%
ERP System-1,856,00052,5163%
Electric Administration2,000,0002,516,1001,437,50057%
Electric Fund Capital Projects$6,848,400 $ 28,702,200 $ 14,554,55651%

TOTAL CAPITAL PROJECTS $ 19,798,200 $ 54,439,500 $ 24,724,849 45%

Paj 127

Finance Department Monthly Report June 2024
Item #10.

Capital Outlay - All Divisions

$14,000,000

$12,000,000

$10,000,000

$8,000,000

$6,000,000

$4,000,000

$2,000,000

$-

Original Budget Revised Budget Actual

Capital Outlay - By Fund
$35,000,000

$30,000,000 $28,702,200

$25,000,000

$20,000,000

$14,744,400 $14,554,556
$15,000,000

$10,000,000

$6,848,400$6,564,300$6,981,222
$5,689,100
$4,683,800$4,428,600
$5,000,000
$2,576,900$2,233,326
$955,745
$-
Original BudgetRevised BudgetActual

General Fund Capital Projects Water Fund Capital Projects Wastewater Fund Electric Fund Capital Projects

Paj 128

CITY OF DOVER DEPARTMENT OF POLICE Item #11.

400 SOUTH QUEEN STREET DOVER, DELAWARE 19904 302-736-7111

Chief of Police Police Captains
THOMAS A. JOHNSON, JR. RANDY ROBBINS
Deputy Chief of Police PAUL KUNTZI
DAVID E. SPICER AARON DICKINSON

August 12, 2024

Honorable Robin Christiansen, Mayor
Members of Dover City Council
City Hall
Dover, DE 19901

Mayor Christiansen and Council Members:

The following is the monthly report of Dover Police Department activities for June:

COMPLAINTS/EVENTS

YTD Totals compiled through June numbered 23,375.

This represents an increase of 2,629 from the 20,746 reported over the same period in 2023.

25,00023,375
20,13020,746
18,965
20,00016,378
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
20202021202220232024

CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS

Burglary: 9 cases reported, 5 cases cleared and 5 cases were cleared from previous months.

Robbery: 6 cases reported, 4 cases cleared and 0 cases was cleared from previous months.

Sex Assault: 4 cases reported, 1 case cleared and 4 cases was cleared from previous months.

Homicide: 0 cases reported, 0 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous months.

There were 4 Non-Criminal Death Investigations, 4 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous months. 1

Paj 129

Item #11.
DRUG, VICE, & ORGANIZED CRIME / STREET CRIMES UNIT ENFORCEMENT

Marijuana: 91 grams seized Cocaine: 31.8 grams seized Ecstasy: 0 doses seized Prescription Pills: 0 doses seized Heroin: 15.042 grams seized Methamphetamine: 0 grams seized Fentanyl: 0 grams seized Other Rx Drugs: 33.5 grams/doses seized Drug Proceeds: $3,210 seized

FIREARM SEIZURES/INSIDE CITY LIMITS

15

106
511
000000000
0
CIDVOC/STREET CRIMESPATROLSEU

HANDGUN RIFLE SHOTGUN

Firearms: 7 Handguns, 1 Rifle

TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT

YTD Citation Totals compiled through June numbered 2,165.

This represents a decrease of 1,636 from the 3,801 reported over the same period in 2023.

4,0003,801
3,4233,379
3,500
3,0002,621
2,5002,165
2,000

1,500

1,000

500

0
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

TRAFFIC CRASHES: YTD = 968

2

Paj 130

Item #11.
911 CENTER ACTIVITY

Total compiled during June numbered 8,159 calls.

This represents a decrease of 61 from the 8,220 reported during the same period in 2023.

8,400

8,220
8,200 8,159

8,000 7,961

7,800
7,702

7,583
7,600

7,400

7,200
2020 2021 2022 2023 2024

CITY ORDINANCE SUMMONS

YTD Totals compiled through June numbered 720.

This represents a decrease of 532 from the 1,252 reported over the same period in 2023.

2,500

1,8521,946
2,0001,736
1,5001,252
1,000705720
516533
500334278
0
20202021202220232024
ISSUED1,8521,9461,7361,252720
PAID705516334533278

3

Paj 131

COMMUNITY POLICING Item #11.

This proactive unit takes the lead on community engagement and supporting our community organizations. They have administrative responsibilities and also support other departmental units, such as patrol, during times of high work volumes or special operations with enforcement activities. In addition to those duties, the unit accomplished the following in June:

 Police Athletic League: o Assist with the Millsboro & Harrington Youth Academy sessions, 1 with K9 Roy o Planning activity for the Day in their Boots event in July o Planning activity for the summer Youth Academy at AOD Charter School o Support Parks and Recreation with their Fishing Derby o Dover Library day in the Silver Lake Park o Outdoor basketball at North Kirkwood Street o Special Olympics Law Enforcement Torch Run  Collaboration with NeighborGood Partners to establish Neighborhood Watch downtown  Assisted with Williams Park – Dover BBQ contest event  Aggressive Panhandling arrest at Loockerman and S. Governor’s  Disorderly Person arrest at Kent Budget Inn  Corporal Smith delivered a 40-hour First Aid Course to the Police Academy  Corporal Smith delivered a Water Survival Course to the Police Academy  Participated in a security consultation meeting with Proctor and Gamble  Participated in the Fishing Derby – Parks and Recreation w/ K9 Roy’s help  Participated in the annual Special Olympics Law Enforcement Torch Run / Ceremony  Community Response Vehicle: Visit to Kings Cliff development  Participated in Habitat for Humanity Neighborhood Revitalization meeting  Participated in Kent County Crime Watch meeting  Obtained a warrant for a trespassing violator from Courtney Square  Visit with the management of Towne Point Apartments  CPU Officer attended School Resource Officer basic training  Participation in dignitary protection assignments in the Downtown  Participated in NeighborGood Partners “Open Streets” event  Participated in the “Moving Up” ceremony at Reily Brown Elementary School  Supported a Community BBQ Event – 30 E. Division Street, With K9 Roy  Conducted multiple, focused, property checks at 152 S. Governors, Governors & Loockerman and New & Reed  Community Outreach: Reily Brown Elementary School Graduation, Dover High School Graduation, Dover Comic Con, and Alder Park Apartments  Assisted Patrol Units during major incidents, high 911 call volume and/or low staffing  The BHU took the lead on 97 events and took official action to provide services to 40 people needing mental health support & 32 needing substance abuse referral. Some of the field contacts needed both resources.

Members of the CPU attend numerous meetings with community associations and organizations as a part of our ongoing liaison relationships.

POLICE CHIEF ADVISORY COMMITTEE 4

Paj 132

The Police Advisory Board is comprised of nine (9) diverse stakeholders living/working in the City Item #11. of Dover. It meets regularly to provide input/feedback to the Chief on the various operations of the agency.

As mentioned in the May report, there was no meeting scheduled for the Committee in June in anticipation of the July reorganizational meeting. The Dover Police Chief Advisory Committee will become the City of Dover Police Advisory Board on July 18, 2024. Now that the group will have published activities through the City of Dover website, it will no longer be a separate section of the Police Department Monthly Report.

PROGRAMS AND INITIATIVES

Lieutenant Derrick Lawson had his last day on June 7th. We wish him well in his retirement. He was replaced by Sgt. Pete Martinek who took over as the Patrol Lieutenant on June 8th.

The second Police Recruit assessment day for the current cycle took place on June 23rd. A total of 6 candidates survived the physical fitness, written, and oral board tests. They will proceed to the background investigative stage. This group will supplement the first group of 8 and be potential candidates for the Police Academy in the fall. Final interviews should occur sometime in August. On June 26th an offer of employment was extended to a police officer candidate who is currently serving in the Delaware Capital Police Department. Daniel Kauffman has close to two years of experience and will begin onboarding in July.

During the first week of June, Dover PD hosted a session of the FBI LEEDA Command Leadership Course. This nationally renowned program prepares supervisory officers for executive leadership roles. Graduation was on June 7th and three Dover PD Supervisors were a part of this class of more than 40 supervisors from around the State.

On June 18th the Dover PD was approved for a SLEAF related grant to help fund a training system that is considered “state of the art” technology. The grant is valued at a little more than 67K and the money will be pooled with other sources to help us purchase a VirTra Training Simulator. The simulator is a life-sized 300 degree scenario system to aid in the training of officer reactions and judgment in crisis situations.

A candidate for the part time victim services specialist position was identified and offered the job on June 20th. Danielle Martin, retired from the Delaware State Police, accepted the offer and should be operational by August. We are excited to be able to expand our capacity to serve the many victims of crime and tragic circumstances encountered during our mission.

On June 12th I represented Dover at a symposium for DelMarVa Law Enforcement Leaders held on the campus of the University of Maryland-Eastern Shore. There was substantial media coverage as the panel of Chiefs discussed challenges facing the profession in 2024.

On June 17th Dover PD met with Capital School District officials to evaluate school safety from the concluding academic year and make plans for the upcoming year.

The 2023 Annual Report was done as a summation video during the month of June to expand the exposure of our programs and achievements. An associated goal is to better inform the community of our organizational challenges and public safety strategies. Once edited, the video will be posted for viewing during the summer.

5

Paj 133

Please visit our website at www.doverpolice.org for up to date information on crimes and activitiesItem #11. in the City of Dover.

Respectfully Submitted,

Thomas A. Johnson, Jr.
Chief of Police

6

Paj 134

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

  • 1.Amend Article 1 to read:
  • 1.PREAMBLE

THIS AGREEMENT was entered into effective , 20204 by and between the City of Dover, hereinafter referred to as the City or as the Employer, and the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Council 81, AFL-CIO, on behalf of Local 2356 hereinafter referred to as the Union or as the Employees. The term of this Agreement shall be from July 1, 20204 through June 30, 20237.

  • 2.Amend Article 3 to read:
  • 3.TERM OF AGREEMENT

This agreement shall be effective as of the date of ratification by the Union and approval of the City Council and shall remain in full force and effect until the 30th day of June 20237, and shall be automatically renewed from year to year thereafter unless either party shall notify the other in writing not later than ninety

(90) days prior to the expiration date that it desires to modify or terminate this agreement. In the event such notice is given, negotiations shall begin no later than thirty (30) days following the date of the notice.

If negotiations are not concluded as of June 30, 20237, the mandatory subject of collective bargaining within this agreement shall remain in full force and effect until negotiations are completed and shall automatically be extended until such time as a new or modified agreement is approved by both parties.

This agreement may be amended at any time by mutual written consent.

  • 3.Amend Article 5 to read:
  • 5.RECOGNITION

The City recognizes Delaware Public Employees, AFSCME Council 81 as the exclusive bargaining representative of the employees covered hereby for the purpose of collective bargaining as certified by the Delaware Public Employment Relations Board.

The term “employee” as used herein shall include full-time employees who are classified to work forty 1

Paj 135

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

(40) hours or more per week in the following Job Title/Classifications:

911 Supervisor Account Clerk III Accountant II Administrative Assistant* Central Services Coordinator Chief Building Inspector Civil Engineer I Civil Engineer II Computer Operator/AS400 System Admin. Crime Analyst/Accreditation Manager (12/30/15) Downtown Coordinator Community Development Manager Electrical Engineer I Field Service Representative III Fire Chief’s Assistant GIS Technician LAN Analyst Librarian I Librarian II Licensing and Permitting Supervisor Planner I Planner II Police Resources Manager Public Affairs & Emergency Mgt. Coordinator Records Unit Supervisor Recreation Program Specialist Residential Assessment Technician Sex Offender Registry Enforcement Agent (12/30/15) Senior Computer Programmer Analyst Emergency Communications Manager Senior Planner Victim Services Coordinator

*Excluded are the Administrative Assistant for the City Manager, Controller, Human Resources Director and City Clerk.

The City is to provide the Local President with a monthly report of the names and job titles of all employees represented by the Union.

Modifications to the Unit to reflect newly created eligible classifications, official changes in classification titles or additions will be made only in accordance with the appropriate procedures of the State of Delaware, Public Employment Relations Board. The City agrees to notify the Union of any official changes in classification titles.

  • 4.Amend Article 8 to read:
  • 8.NON-DISCRIMINATION

The City shall not interfere with or discriminate against employees in matters of employment because of membership in or legitimate activity permitted by this

1

Paj 136

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

Agreement, nor shall the City discourage membership in the Union or encourage membership in any other union.

The parties agree that there shall be no discrimination against any employee on the basis of race, color, creed, national origin, veteran or marital status, age, sex, religion, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, pregnancy/childbirth, or political affiliation in the application of the provisions of this Agreement.

The Union agrees to represent employees by admitting persons into membership without discrimination on the basis of race, color, creed, national origin, veteran or marital status, age, sex, religion, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, pregnancy/childbirth, or political affiliation. In addition, the Union recognizes its responsibility of noninterference, and agrees not to restrain or coerce employees in the performance of their duties.

The City and the Union shall share equally the responsibility for applying the provisions of this Article.

  • 5.Amend Article 15 to read:
  • 15.MEALS DURING SEVERE WEATHER EMERGENCIES

In the event of a severe weather or other emergency and the City is closed, the City will provide employees involved with the emergency, working a minimum of at least ten (10) continuous hours with either: (1) a meal at a local establishment of the City’s choice; or (2) a ten fifteen ($1015) dollar meal allowance which will be paid within fourteen (14) business days of the last day of the severe weather or other emergency event. The City of Dover will have the sole decision on which option is selected.

  • 6.Amend Article 18 to read:
  • 18.ON-CALL AND CALL-IN PAY

The City shall provide compensation to non-exempt and exempt employees scheduled for “on-call” service after hours, weekends and holidays on a full seven (7) day cycle. Employees who are scheduled for on-call service in any given week shall receive an additional seven (7) hours of straight time (one (1) hour per day) pay over and above the normal hours worked in that week, even if the employee is not called out. The on call pay provided for herein shall be calculated into the employee’s overtime rate and included in pension calculations.

1

Paj 137

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

In addition to the on-call pay provided above, the paid call-out time shall be a minimum of two hours. Nonexempt employees shall receive compensation at the employee’s applicable overtime rate of pay, for each separate call-out or comp time at the applicable rate of 1.5x. Exempt employees shall receive comp time at straight time for the hours that they are called out. Only when an employee has returned home and is again called out shall it be considered a separate call-out. The minimum two hour call-out pay shall not apply if an employee is called into work within one (1) hour before the employee’s normal starting time and the employee continues working into the normal shift. In this situation, the employee shall only receive one (1) hour on-call compensation.

Any trading of on-call duty between employees must be approved, in writing, by the supervisor of the employee who was originally assigned for duty. Trading of on-call assignments for less than the full week shall not alter the method by which payroll will compensate only the original employee who was assigned for that week.

The City Manager must authorize all “on-call” statuses. In general, on-call status shall not be provided to employees who may from time to time be called in on extraordinary circumstances.

  • 7.Amend Article 19, to read:
  • 19.VACATION

Effective with the November 2014 July 1, 2024 accrual, vacations shall be earned as follows:

  • A.Each full-time regular employee from their date of hire until completion of six months of service shall earn vacation leave at the rate of four (4)eight (8) hours per completed month. Probationary employee’s vacation accrual for the month of November 2014 shall not be reduced.
  • B.Each full-time regular employee who has completed six months of service however fewer than five (5) complete years of continuous service shall earn vacation leave at the rate of 10 hours per completed month.
  • C.Each full-time regular employee with five (5) completed years of continuous service but less than ten (10) complete years of continuous service shall earn vacation leave at the rate of 14 hours per completed month.

1

Paj 138

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

  • D.Each full-time regular employee with ten (10) complete years of continuous service but less than fifteen (15) complete years of continuous service shall earn vacation leave at the rate of 16 hours per month.
  • E.Each full-time regular employee with fifteen (15) or more complete years of continuous service but less than twenty (20) complete years of continuous service shall earn vacation leave at the rate of 18 hours per month.
  • F.Each full-time regular employee with twenty (20) or more complete years of continuous service shall earn vacation leave at the rate of 20 hours per month.

Vacation leave accumulated by eligible employees shall be recorded and taken in fifteen minute increments.

Fifteen (15) minute increments will be implemented when agreed upon by all labor units. An employee must earn pay for one half of his or her workdays for that month to be credited with vacation leave. An employee cannot use a month’s credit until he/she has earned pay for one half of his or her workdays for that month.

  • 8.Amend Article 21 to read:
  • 21.VACATION SELL BACK

All employees may request, during the month of November, 2024 to sell back to the City unused vacation leave hours in accordance with the following schedules:

Effective with the sell back payment of November 2018.

Years of Completed Service Hours eligible for Sell Back
Up to 10 20 or 40
11+ 20 or 40 or 60 or 80

After the November 2018 sell back payment, vacation sell back shall be eliminated.

  • 9.Amend Article 28 to read:
  • 28.HEALTHCARE INSURANCE PAYMENTS

The City participates in a Group Health Insurance Program and employees are entitled to select their desired level of coverage from the options available thereunder.

1

Paj 139

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

The City shall notify the Union if it desires to leave the State of Delaware Group Health Insurance Program during the term of this Agreement. The parties shall then enter into negotiations. In the event that the parties are unable to reach agreement, the parties agree to submit all unresolved issues to the dispute resolution services offered by the Delaware Public Employment Relation Board, including binding interest arbitration.

Effective the first (1st ) of the month following ratification by the Union and approval by City Council, health insurance cost sharing will be as follows:

For all employees, who are hired prior to May 20, 2014 the City will pay 85% of the total monthly insurance premium regardless of plan or tier (employee, child(ren), spouse or family) coverage. The employee will pay 15% of the total monthly insurance premium regardless of plan or tier (employee, child(ren), spouse or family) coverage.

For employees who are hired on or after May 20, 2014 the City will pay 80% of the total monthly insurance premium regardless of plan or tier (employee, child(ren), spouse or family) coverage. The employee will pay 20% of the total monthly insurance premium.

  • 10.Amend Article 30, in relevant part, to read (with remaining existing subsection re- lettered accordingly):
  • 30.GROUP LIFE, ACCIDENTAL DEATH AND DISMEMBERMENT, AND OFF-THE- JOB ACCIDENT AND SICKNESS

The City shall pay a portion of the cost as outlined below:

  • a.Group Life: The City shall pay 50% of the cost of individual employee coverage for employees. The employee must pay the other 50%. The insurance shall provide coverage equal to twice an employee’s annual salary rounded to the next $1,000. Maximum coverage will be determined by the insurance policy.
  • b.Accidental Death and Dismemberment: The City shall pay 50% of the cost of individual employee coverage for full-time regular employees. The employee must pay the other 50%. The insurance shall provide accidental death insurance coverage equal to twice the employee’s annual salary and accidental dismemberment coverage based on a schedule rounded to the next $1,000. Maximum coverage will be determined by the insurance policy.
  • c.Information to Employees: A statement will be given to all AFSCME members showing the status of the Group Life and Accidental Death and Dismemberment insurance offered through the City of Dover. It will include on it an annual update

1

Paj 140

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

of the amount of policies, who to contact and any needed information. This will be provided on an annual basis beginning January 30, 2025. This can be done electronically.

  • 11.Amend Article 34 to read:
  • 34.401 RETIREMENT CONTRIBUTION (DEFERRED INCOME)

Employees who have chosen the 401 Money Purchase Plan (Defined Contribution Plan) as their primary pension plan will be required to contribute 3% of his/her pensionable wages. The City will make an equal matching contribution based upon the employee’s contribution.

The City will provide an additional matching contribution of up to 3%. The City’s matching contribution is deposited into the 401 Money Purchase Plan and the employee’s contribution will be deposited into the 457 plan.

For employees who have chosen the 401 Money Purchase Plan (also referred to as the Defined Contribution Plan) as their primary pension plan, the following chart depicts contribution levels.

Minimum Employee ContributionCity’s Match (Up To)
6%9%
Each May, employees will have the opportunity to change their contribution to the
457 plan thus effecting the City’s matching contribution to the 401 Money Purchase
Plan. The change will be effective July 1 and irrevocable until the following July.
Employee contributions cannot be below the minimum employee contribution as
indicated above.

The first opportunity for AFSCME members to change their contribution will occur in September 2024.

Thereafter, the City will provide notice during open enrollment (May) of each year.

  • 12.Amend Article 35 to read as follows:
  • 35.EDUCATIONAL ASSISTANCE The City promotes continuing education if this education will better equip the employee to do his/her job. An employee is allowed to receive reimbursement for a maximum of $7,500 per fiscal year beginning with fiscal year 2021 (July 1, 2020 – June 30, 2021). This benefit is available to an employee who has successfully completed his or her initial probationary period of employment.

1

Paj 141

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

To be eligible for this benefit an employee must have demonstrated during his/her employment with the City, prior to application, that his/her education is sufficient and adequate for extended study and training and that such education is compatible and commensurate with the employee’s chosen extended study. The employee’s selected courses must be approved in writing and in advance by their department head and the Human Resources Department. The selected courses of study must be helpful to the employee in his or her present work and basic advancement or must be in support of a major that is helpful to the employee in his or her present work and basic advancement. Requests will not be unreasonably denied.

Educational assistance is not available for remedial classes. The employee shall notify his or her supervisor during the normal budget cycle of their request for educational funding. Failure to do so, will disqualify the employee until funds are budgeted. Funding is only available to the limit requested during the budget cycle. Extenuating circumstances will be considered.

The City shall reimburse the employee for tuition, laboratory fees and books. Reimbursement will be the lower of University of Delaware in-state rates for the level and type of course taken or the actual amounts paid for tuition. Employees shall receive reimbursement based upon the following schedule:

Letter GradeReimbursement Percentage
A100%
B90%
C80%
D or F0%

Receipts and official grade verification must be provided for reimbursement.

An employee who takes advantage of this policy shall be required to complete at least two (2) continuous years of employment with the City upon receiving reimbursement or shall have the amount of the reimbursement deducted from his/her final pay check. This agreement shall not constitute an employment contract.

Benefits received under any other Education Assistance Plan, such as the “G.I. Bill”, financial aid or etc. will be applied first.

For complete details on the reimbursement process please contact the Human Resources Department.

Student loans are not considered “Educational Assistance Plans” or “Financial Aid” in terms of determining eligibility for reimbursement, since student loans must be repaid. The tuition reimbursement check will be paid to the employee within 30 days of submission of proper paperwork to the Human Resources Department.

1

Paj 142

Item #16.
City of Dover, Delaware and
AFSCME Council 81, AFL-CIO, Local 2356
Cumulative Tentative Agreement
August 1, 2024

  • 13.Amend Article 40 to read:
  • 40.SALARIES

All new hires will start out at Step 1, however if the individual has previous experience, then the City can place the individual on the scale at a level commensurate with their prior experience.

Effective July 1, 2024, all employees will be placed into the AFSCME Salary Progression Scale, attached hereto as Exhibit A, as shown in Exhibit D. Thereafter, employees will move up one step on the Salary Progression Scale on each subsequent July 1st.

When any position reaches the maximum salary as dictated in the Salary Progression Scale, there will be no additional steps added.

Temporary upgrades are defined in the personnel rules and are to be granted after 20 continuous days worked or 35 days worked in any 90-day period. Should there be another occasion in a twelve-month period, the temporary upgrade in pay will take place after 10 days worked.

Effective July 1, 2024 (FY 25) the City will implement the AFSCME Salary Progression Scale (Exhibit A)

Effective July 1, 2025 (FY 26) all employees will receive a step increase (unless they are at Step 16) and a 4% general wage increase as reflected in the AFSCME Salary Progression Salary Scale (Exhibit B).

Effective July 1, 2026 (FY 27) all employees will receive a step increase (unless they are at Step 16) and a 4% general wage increase as reflected in the AFSCME Salary Progression Salary Scale (Exhibit C).

All paychecks shall be made by direct deposit to the bank selected by the employee.

Local 2356 City of Dover

By: Lead Negotiator By: Lead Negotiator

1

Paj 143

AFCSME

Exhibit A
July 1, 2024 - June 30, 2025

FY 25StepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStep
Pay Grade12345678910111213141516
115$15.77$16.25$16.73$17.24$17.75$18.29$18.83$19.40$19.98$20.58$21.20$21.83$22.49$23.16$23.86$24.57
116$16.57$17.07$17.58$18.11$18.65$19.21$19.79$20.38$20.99$21.62$22.27$22.94$23.63$24.33$25.06$25.82
117$17.42$17.94$18.48$19.03$19.61$20.19$20.80$21.42$22.07$22.73$23.41$24.11$24.84$25.58$26.35$27.14
118$18.26$18.81$19.37$19.95$20.55$21.17$21.80$22.45$23.13$23.82$24.54$25.27$26.03$26.81$27.62$28.44
119$19.16$19.73$20.32$20.93$21.56$22.21$22.88$23.56$24.27$25.00$25.75$26.52$27.31$28.13$28.98$29.85
120$20.15$20.76$21.38$22.02$22.68$23.36$24.06$24.78$25.53$26.29$27.08$27.89$28.73$29.59$30.48$31.40
121$21.15$21.78$22.43$23.11$23.80$24.51$25.25$26.01$26.79$27.59$28.42$29.27$30.15$31.05$31.98$32.94
122$22.19$22.86$23.54$24.25$24.98$25.72$26.50$27.29$28.11$28.95$29.82$30.72$31.64$32.59$33.56$34.57
123$23.29$23.99$24.71$25.45$26.21$27.00$27.81$28.64$29.50$30.38$31.30$32.24$33.20$34.20$35.22$36.28
124$24.48$25.21$25.97$26.75$27.55$28.38$29.23$30.10$31.01$31.94$32.90$33.88$34.90$35.95$37.02$38.14
125$25.73$26.50$27.30$28.12$28.96$29.83$30.72$31.64$32.59$33.57$34.58$35.62$36.68$37.79$38.92$40.09
126$26.97$27.78$28.61$29.47$30.36$31.27$32.21$33.17$34.17$35.19$36.25$37.34$38.46$39.61$40.80$42.02
127$28.32$29.17$30.04$30.94$31.87$32.83$33.81$34.83$35.87$36.95$38.06$39.20$40.37$41.59$42.83$44.12
128$29.76$30.65$31.57$32.52$33.49$34.50$35.53$36.60$37.69$38.83$39.99$41.19$42.43$43.70$45.01$46.36
129$31.25$32.18$33.15$34.14$35.17$36.22$37.31$38.43$39.58$40.77$41.99$43.25$44.55$45.89$47.26$48.68
130$32.79$33.77$34.79$35.83$36.90$38.01$39.15$40.33$41.54$42.78$44.07$45.39$46.75$48.15$49.60$51.08
131$34.43$35.47$36.53$37.63$38.76$39.92$41.12$42.35$43.62$44.93$46.28$47.67$49.10$50.57$52.09$53.65
132$36.17$37.26$38.38$39.53$40.71$41.93$43.19$44.49$45.82$47.20$48.61$50.07$51.57$53.12$54.72$56.36
133$37.96$39.10$40.28$41.48$42.73$44.01$45.33$46.69$48.09$49.53$51.02$52.55$54.13$55.75$57.42$59.15
134$39.86$41.05$42.29$43.55$44.86$46.21$47.59$49.02$50.49$52.01$53.57$55.17$56.83$58.53$60.29$62.10
135$41.85$43.10$44.39$45.73$47.10$48.51$49.97$51.46$53.01$54.60$56.24$57.92$59.66$61.45$63.29$65.19

Page 143 Item #16.

Paj 144

AFCSME

Exhibit B
July 1, 2025 - June 30, 2026
4.00%

StepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStep
Pay Grade12345678910111213141516
115$16.40$16.90$17.40$17.93$18.46$19.02$19.59$20.18$20.78$21.40$22.05$22.71$23.39$24.09$24.81$25.56
116$17.23$17.75$18.28$18.83$19.40$19.98$20.58$21.19$21.83$22.49$23.16$23.85$24.57$25.31$26.07$26.85
117$18.12$18.66$19.22$19.80$20.39$21.00$21.63$22.28$22.95$23.64$24.35$25.08$25.83$26.60$27.40$28.22
118$18.99$19.56$20.14$20.75$21.37$22.01$22.67$23.35$24.05$24.77$25.52$26.28$27.07$27.88$28.72$29.58
119$19.92$20.52$21.14$21.77$22.42$23.10$23.79$24.50$25.24$26.00$26.78$27.58$28.41$29.26$30.14$31.04
120$20.96$21.59$22.23$22.90$23.59$24.30$25.02$25.78$26.55$27.34$28.17$29.01$29.88$30.78$31.70$32.65
121$21.99$22.65$23.33$24.03$24.75$25.49$26.26$27.05$27.86$28.69$29.55$30.44$31.35$32.29$33.26$34.26
122$23.08$23.77$24.48$25.22$25.97$26.75$27.56$28.38$29.23$30.11$31.01$31.95$32.90$33.89$34.91$35.95
123$24.22$24.95$25.69$26.46$27.26$28.08$28.92$29.79$30.68$31.60$32.55$33.52$34.53$35.57$36.63$37.73
124$25.46$26.22$27.01$27.82$28.65$29.51$30.40$31.31$32.25$33.22$34.21$35.24$36.30$37.38$38.51$39.66
125$26.76$27.56$28.39$29.24$30.12$31.02$31.95$32.91$33.90$34.91$35.96$37.04$38.15$39.30$40.48$41.69
126$28.05$28.89$29.76$30.65$31.57$32.52$33.49$34.50$35.53$36.60$37.70$38.83$39.99$41.19$42.43$43.70
127$29.45$30.33$31.24$32.18$33.15$34.14$35.17$36.22$37.31$38.43$39.58$40.77$41.99$43.25$44.55$45.88
128$30.95$31.87$32.83$33.82$34.83$35.88$36.95$38.06$39.20$40.38$41.59$42.84$44.12$45.45$46.81$48.21
129$32.50$33.47$34.48$35.51$36.58$37.67$38.80$39.97$41.17$42.40$43.67$44.98$46.33$47.72$49.15$50.63
130$34.10$35.12$36.18$37.26$38.38$39.53$40.72$41.94$43.20$44.49$45.83$47.20$48.62$50.08$51.58$53.13
131$35.81$36.89$37.99$39.13$40.31$41.52$42.76$44.04$45.37$46.73$48.13$49.57$51.06$52.59$54.17$55.79
132$37.62$38.75$39.91$41.11$42.34$43.61$44.92$46.27$47.66$49.09$50.56$52.08$53.64$55.25$56.90$58.61
133$39.48$40.67$41.89$43.14$44.44$45.77$47.14$48.56$50.02$51.52$53.06$54.65$56.29$57.98$59.72$61.51
134$41.45$42.70$43.98$45.30$46.65$48.05$49.50$50.98$52.51$54.09$55.71$57.38$59.10$60.87$62.70$64.58
135$43.52$44.82$46.17$47.55$48.98$50.45$51.96$53.52$55.13$56.78$58.49$60.24$62.05$63.91$65.83$67.80

Page 144 Item #16.

Paj 145

AFCSME

Exhibit C
July 1, 2026 - June 30, 2027
4.00%

StepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStepStep
Pay Grade12345678910111213141516
115$17.06$17.57$18.10$18.64$19.20$19.78$20.37$20.98$21.61$22.26$22.93$23.62$24.32$25.05$25.81$26.58
116$17.92$18.46$19.01$19.58$20.17$20.78$21.40$22.04$22.70$23.38$24.09$24.81$25.55$26.32$27.11$27.92
117$18.84$19.41$19.99$20.59$21.21$21.84$22.50$23.17$23.87$24.58$25.32$26.08$26.86$27.67$28.50$29.35
118$19.75$20.34$20.95$21.58$22.23$22.89$23.58$24.29$25.02$25.77$26.54$27.33$28.15$29.00$29.87$30.77
119$20.72$21.34$21.98$22.64$23.32$24.02$24.74$25.48$26.25$27.04$27.85$28.68$29.54$30.43$31.34$32.28
120$21.80$22.45$23.12$23.82$24.53$25.27$26.03$26.81$27.61$28.44$29.29$30.17$31.08$32.01$32.97$33.96
121$22.87$23.56$24.26$24.99$25.74$26.51$27.31$28.13$28.97$29.84$30.74$31.66$32.61$33.59$34.59$35.63
122$24.00$24.72$25.46$26.23$27.01$27.82$28.66$29.52$30.40$31.32$32.26$33.22$34.22$35.25$36.30$37.39
123$25.19$25.94$26.72$27.52$28.35$29.20$30.08$30.98$31.91$32.86$33.85$34.87$35.91$36.99$38.10$39.24
124$26.48$27.27$28.09$28.93$29.80$30.69$31.61$32.56$33.54$34.54$35.58$36.65$37.75$38.88$40.05$41.25
125$27.83$28.66$29.52$30.41$31.32$32.26$33.23$34.23$35.25$36.31$37.40$38.52$39.68$40.87$42.09$43.36
126$29.17$30.05$30.95$31.88$32.83$33.82$34.83$35.88$36.96$38.06$39.21$40.38$41.59$42.84$44.13$45.45
127$30.63$31.55$32.49$33.47$34.47$35.51$36.57$37.67$38.80$39.96$41.16$42.40$43.67$44.98$46.33$47.72
128$32.18$33.15$34.14$35.17$36.22$37.31$38.43$39.58$40.77$41.99$43.25$44.55$45.89$47.26$48.68$50.14
129$33.80$34.81$35.85$36.93$38.04$39.18$40.35$41.57$42.81$44.10$45.42$46.78$48.19$49.63$51.12$52.65
130$35.46$36.53$37.62$38.75$39.92$41.11$42.35$43.62$44.93$46.27$47.66$49.09$50.56$52.08$53.64$55.25
131$37.24$38.36$39.51$40.70$41.92$43.18$44.47$45.81$47.18$48.60$50.05$51.55$53.10$54.69$56.34$58.03
132$39.12$40.30$41.51$42.75$44.04$45.36$46.72$48.12$49.56$51.05$52.58$54.16$55.78$57.46$59.18$60.96
133$41.06$42.29$43.56$44.87$46.22$47.60$49.03$50.50$52.02$53.58$55.18$56.84$58.54$60.30$62.11$63.97
134$43.11$44.40$45.74$47.11$48.52$49.98$51.48$53.02$54.61$56.25$57.94$59.67$61.46$63.31$65.21$67.16
135$45.26$46.62$48.02$49.46$50.94$52.47$54.04$55.66$57.33$59.05$60.83$62.65$64.53$66.47$68.46$70.51

Page 145 Item #16.

Paj 146

Item #18.

PETITION TO ANNEX AND REZONE PROPERTY

First Reading Before the Dover City Council
August 12, 2024

File Number: AX-24-01

Ordinance Number: 2024-28

Applicant/ Owner of Byler Investments, LLC
Record:

Property Address: 139 Acorn Lane, Dover DE

Tax Parcel ID #: ED-00-068.19-01-23.00-000

Lot Size: 14,494 SF +/-

Present Zoning: RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone)

Proposed Zoning: R-10 (One Family Residence Zone)

2019 Comprehensive Category 1: High Priority Annexation Areas Plan Designation:

2019 Comprehensive Residential Medium Density Plan Land Use Category:

Present Use: Single Family Detached Dwelling

Proposed Use: Single Family Detached Dwelling

Paj 147

City of Dover Application No.: AX-24-01
Item #18.

Department of Planning & Inspections lvd a ry B olu tion Rev RM-1 ve R-8 oc kA anc SH R-8 R-8

R-20 ve
ki ns A
Hop

ROS

n Ln
Nixo R-8
C
er
ir
m
Cly

R-20 Aco
n ROS
R-20 rn L
R-8

R-8 Site

R-8 Mah
o R-8

RM-1 gany

c ia P
Aca
Pl
Shadybrook Dr l

S
RG-2 Girl e
Lind
t Ln R-8
R-8 c ou n Ct
R-8 R-8

Teak Ct R-8 R-7 ROS W il lis Rd E Division St N Little Creek Rd

Marta Dr

R-8R-
R-88
ROS

Tile: Lands of Byler Investments, LLC Ordinance #: 2024-28 Addresses: 139 Acorn Lane Legend Parcel ID: ED-00-068.19-01-23.00-000 Subject Property Existing Zoning: RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone) Proposed Zoning: R-10 (One Family Residence Zone) Dover Boundary Owner: Byler Investments, LLC Zoning Date: 07/31/2024 Dover Parcels

0150300600 Feet
«Kent County Parcels

Paj 148

Item #18.

Paj 149

Item #18.

FIRST READING

City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-28

1AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF
2THE CITY OF DOVER CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY
3LOCATED AT 139 ACORN LANE
4
5 WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property
6within the limits of the City of Dover; and
7
8 WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted
9 use of property described below from RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone) to R-10 (One
10Family Residence Zone).
11
12NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE
13CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
14
15 1. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and
16 Zoning Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning
17 designation from RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone) to R-10 (One Family Residence
18 Zone) on that property located at 139 Acorn Lane, consisting of 14,494+/- S.F., owned by
19Byler Investments, LLC.
20
21 (Tax Parcel: ED-00-068.19-01-23.00-000; Planning Reference: AX-24-01; Council District 3)
22
23ADOPTED: *
24
25Action History
2608/12/2024 – Scheduled for First Reading – City Council

Paj 150

Item #19.

FINAL READING

City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-07

1 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN 2 COUNCIL MET: 3 4 That Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except 5 Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan, be amended by inserting the text indicated 6 in bold, blue font and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows: 7 8 Section 80-500 – General employee pension plan established; purpose. 9 10 (a) Generally. There is hereby established the city general employee pension plan. The purpose 11 of the plan is to establish the terms and conditions under which retirement and disability 12 benefits shall be provided to eligible employees of the city. The benefits under the plan shall 13 be in addition to amounts received as social security benefits or from any other pension plan. 14 15 (b) For employee exclusively. This plan is created for the exclusive benefit of the employees of 16 the city and shall be interpreted in a manner consistent with it being an employee's trust, as 17 defined in section 401(a) of the Internal Revenue Code (26 USC 401(a)). Therefore, under 18 no circumstances shall any funds contributed to this plan, or any assets of the plan or trust 19 ever revert to or be used or enjoyed by the city, nor shall any such funds or assets ever be 20 used other than for the benefits of the employees of the city and their the beneficiaries of 21 those employees, prior to the satisfaction of all liabilities under this plan to the employees. 22 23 Section 80-501 – Eligibility of participant. 24 25 Each eligible employee not drawing any retirement benefits from the mayor and city 26 council as of January 1, 1967, shall, upon compliance with the provisions of this division, 27 become a general employee pension plan participant under this division, commencing on July 28 1, 1967, or at any subsequent time immediately upon his employment. Effective September 28, 29 2009, the general employee pension plan is closed to new participants. 30 31 Section 80-502 – Participation mandatory; exceptions. 32 33 The pension plan shall not be construed to give any employee the right to be retained in 34 the employ of the city. All new employees hired after July 1, 1991, shall be required, as a 35 condition of employment, to join the general employee pension plan or the deferred 36 compensation plan. All new employees hired after September 29, 2009, are required to join the 37 money purchase plan (IRC 401(a)), as defined in division 4. All participants of the general 38 employee pension plan as of September 28, 2009, will remain members of either plan thereafter 39 unless they shall leave leaving the employment of the city, retire, pass away, or elect retiring, 40 passing away, or electing to terminate their participation in the general employee pension plan 41 and become becoming a member of the money purchase plan (IRC 401(a)), as defined in

Paj 151

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 2

42division 4.
43
44Section 80-503 – Defraudment.
45
46 It shall be unlawful for any person to knowingly make any false statement or falsify, or
47 permit to be falsified, any record of the pension plan in an attempt to defraud the plan.
48
49Section 80-504 – Normal retirement.
50
51 The normal retirement date for each participant shall be the first day of the month following
52 the attainment of the age of 65 years, provided that he has completed ten years of continuous
53service have been completed.
54
55Section 80-505 – Early retirement.
56
57 (a) Reduced benefits. A participant who has completed ten years of continuous service and who
58 has attained the age of 55 years may retire at any time within the ten years preceding his the
59 normal retirement date; provided, however, that his retirement benefits shall be computed
60 at a reduced rate of one-half percent for each month computed from the date of early
61retirement to age 65 years.
62
63(b)Unreduced benefits.
64
65 (1) Hired May 1, 1994, or later. For eligible employees hired on or after May 1, 1994, a
66 participant who has attained the age of 55 years, and whose attained age plus years of
67 continuous service is equal to or greater than 80, may retire at any time prior to his the
68normal retirement date with no reduction in retirement benefits.
69
70 (2) Hired before May 1, 1994. For eligible employees hired before May 1, 1994, a
71 participant who has completed 25 years of continuous service or who has attained the
72 age of 50 years and completed 20 years of continuous service, may retire at any time
73 prior to his the normal retirement date with no reduction in retirement benefits.
74
75Section 80-506 – Later retirement.
76
77 If a participant works beyond his the normal retirement date, the payment of the
78 participant's retirement benefits shall be deferred until his actual retirement.
79
80Section 80-507 – Forced retirement with pension.
81
82 The general employee pension plan board, upon recommendation of the city council or the
83 city manager, may require retirement in any case where deemed necessary due to the lack of
84 work or inability of the employee to perform with a satisfactory degree of efficiency, provided
85 that the employee qualifies for either normal retirement pursuant to section 80-504, or early
86 retirement pursuant to section 80-505. The employee shall then be entitled to receive,
87 commencing on the first day of the month coinciding with or next following his the date of
88 retirement, pension benefits equal to the benefits computed in accordance with the provisions of

Paj 152

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 3

89 section 80-508 on the basis of the employee's service completed prior to actual retirement. 90 91 Section 80-508 – Amount of retirement benefits. 92 93 Retirement January 1, 1995, or later. The amount of retirement benefits payable to a 94 participant who retires on or after January 1, 1995, shall be computed on the basis of one-fiftieth 95 of his the participant’s average actual monthly earnings multiplied by the total number of years 96 of continuous service. Average actual monthly earnings shall be a participant's base pay plus 97 scheduled overtime, payment for being on call, except those hours reported for being called out, 98 and any retroactive pay corrections which involve any one of the mentioned payments during 99 any period of 36 consecutive months in his the final ten years of continuous service which results 100 in the highest average monthly earnings. 101 102 If an employee's approved absence is the result of a workers compensation injury, the base 103 wages that the employee would have earned had he the employee not been on workers 104 compensation leave will be included when determining the highest 36 consecutive months 105 within his the employee’s final ten years of continuous service. 106 107 The value of lost base salary as a result of mandatory furlough shall be added to an 108 employee's final average compensation and considered in the calculation of the amount of 109 retirement benefits, if the time period in which the mandatory furlough was required is within 110 the highest 36 consecutive months or earnings within the final ten years of continuous service. 111 112 Annual Increase. The retirement income of a retired member of this plan shall be increased 113 by two percent per annum every January 1. This increase in retirement pay shall be cumulative 114 and the previous year’s increase shall be included in the retired member’s retirement income for 115 the purpose of calculating the annual two percent increase. 116 117 Section 80-509 – Form of benefits. 118 119 (a) Normal form. A monthly benefit shall be payable on the first day of the second month 120 preceding the date on which the application for such benefit is filed. Payment will be 121 retroactive to the retirement date. Payments of benefits shall be payable monthly thereafter 122 during his the participant’s lifetime and terminating with the last payment on the first day 123 of the month of the death of the participant. The general employee pension plan board 124 shall be notified of all plan participant retirements. 125 126 (b) Death of participant, etc. Upon the death of a participant who has retired, or who is eligible 127 to be retired under any of the provisions of this division, payment shall be made to their the 128 participant's eligible survivors in the amount of 50 percent of the monthly payments to 129 which the participant was or would have been entitled. Upon the death of a participant who 130 has completed a minimum of ten years of service but is not yet eligible to retire because of 131 due to age and/or years of service, payment shall be made to their the participant’s eligible 132 survivors in the amount of 50 percent of the monthly payment to which the participant was 133 or would have been entitled. The pension amount will be based upon section 80-508. There 134 shall be no reduction in benefits. In no instance shall actual monthly payments be less than 135 $200.00, to be effective July 1, 2000. Upon the death of both the participant and eligible

Paj 153

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 4

136 survivor, if the benefit payments received in the aggregate are less than the member's 137 contributions, the balance of the member's contributions, plus five percent interest, will be 138 paid to the surviving beneficiary designated or his to the estate if no designation has been 139 made and submitted to the general employee pension plan board. The amount of benefit 140 payments received and the amount of the member's contributions shall be determined from 141 the record of the pension board. The city shall request all plan participants to review 142 eligible survivor and surviving beneficiary information annually and revise it as 143 needed. 144 145 (c) Eligible survivor. An eligible survivor shall be one of the following in the order of 146 preference listed: 147 148 (1) Spouse. The participant's spouse who was married to the participant for at least one 149 year. Surviving spouse shall be required to provide supporting documents of marriage. 150 151 (2) Children, unmarried. Child or children of participant. 152 153 a. The surviving child or children, biological or legally adopted, of the participant, 154 who have not attained their 18th birthday 18 years of age. 155 156 b. If said Said surviving child or children of the participant is attending school on 157 a full-time basis and provides providing proof of attendance each year of 158 eligibility, who have not attained 26 years of age. Benefits shall cease with the 159 payment due for the month in which he the child or children ceases to attend 160 school on a full-time basis or with the payment due for the month in which his 161 22nd birthday shall occur age 26 is attained, whichever shall occur first. 162 (d) Commencement of payment. Benefits payable to eligible survivors shall commence on 163 the first day of the month following the date of the participant's death. 164 165 (e) Benefits Cessation of benefits payable. Benefits payable to eligible survivors shall cease: 166 (1) Spouse. With respect to an eligible survivor who is a spouse, with the payment due 167 for the month in which their remarriage or death shall occur, whichever occurs 168 first. 169 (2) Children Surviving child or children. With respect to an eligible survivors who is a 170 child(ren) are children with the payment due for the month in which his 18th birthday 171 age 18 is attained or death shall occur, whichever shall occur first unless the child 172 or children attend school full-time and have not attained 26 years of age. 173 Payments shall be made in accordance with subsections (2)a. and b. 174 175 (f) Eligibility for benefits. The eligibility of any person or persons to receive payment of 176 benefits as an eligible survivor shall be determined conclusively by the general employee 177 pension plan board based on the application of such person or persons and any other 178 information which the pension board deems to be appropriate. 179

Paj 154

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 5

180Section 80-510 – Total and permanent disability.
181
182 (a) Definition. As used in this division, a participant shall be deemed to be "totally and
183 permanently disabled" when the general employee pension plan board, on the basis of a medical
184 examination by a physician or physicians selected by the pension board, finds the employee:
185
186 (1) Work generally. To be totally and permanently prevented from engaging in any occupation
187 or employment for remuneration or profit as a result of bodily or mental injury or disease,
188whether occupational or nonoccupational in cause; or
189
190 (2) Employment. To be totally and permanently prevented from continuing in their capacity
191 as an employee as a result of bodily or mental injury or disease, whether occupational or
192nonoccupational in cause.
193
194 (b) Exclusions. Total and permanent disability, within the terms of this division, shall exclude
195 disability resulting from or consisting of chronic alcoholism, addiction to narcotics, engaging in
196 a felonious criminal act for which they are found guilty, or a willful effort on their part to bring
197 about the injury or illness to themselves or any other person or service in the armed forces of
198any foreign country.
199
200Section 80-511 – Early retirement due to permanent disability.
201
202 Any employee who has completed a minimum of ten consecutive years of service and
203 sustains an injury or experiences a permanent health impairment to the extent of total and
204 permanent disability shall be eligible for retirement upon application and certification by
205 the general employee pension plan board that all of the criteria have been met. The pension
206 amount will be based upon section 80-508. There shall be no reduction in benefit.
207
208Section 80-512 – Commencement of disability benefits.
209
210 (a) Removed from payroll. A participant who files for a disability pension shall not work and
211 be kept on the active payroll and receive credited service from the inception of the disability
212 to the end of the first full calendar month following the date of application.
213
214 (b) Change in compensation; leave. During the application period above, the participant's
215compensation shall not be increased.
216
217 (c) Commencement of benefits. The eligibility for payment of disability benefits under this
218 division shall commence, if approved, on the first day of the month following the application
219period set forth in subsection (a).
220
221Section 80-513 – Termination of employment.
222
223 (a) Forfeiture of participation. Any participant whose employment is terminated prior to the
224 date he becomes eligible of eligibility for retirement benefits shall forfeit his status as a
225 participant in the pension plan and all accumulated credit for continuous service.
226

Paj 155

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 6

227 (b) Ten years' service. Any participant with a minimum of ten years of continuous service and 228 whose employment is terminated prior to the date he becomes becoming eligible for 229 retirement benefits under sections 80-504—Normal retirement, 80-505—Early retirement, 230 80-506—Later retirement or 80-510 80-511—Early retirement due to permanent disability, 231 shall become vested and upon attaining the age of 65 years, shall be eligible for pension 232 benefits under the provisions of section 80-508—Amount of retirement benefits, upon 233 application to the pension board of trustees. The form of the benefit will be based on the 234 formula which was in effect at the time of termination. 235 236 (c) Layoffs. Upon recall, any Any participant whose employment is terminated due to a layoff 237 and is recalled who is laid off and then rehired within five years of layoff, may apply to 238 the general employee pension plan board to have their previous service credits restored 239 immediately. If they have withdrawn Participants who withdrew their contributions, they 240 must repay them as calculated by the city's actuary. A Upon approval by the general 241 employee pension plan board, returning employee participants must make an election to 242 return previously refunded amounts, plus calculated interest, within 30 days. of approval of 243 the general employee pension plan board. Contributions will be reimbursed based on the 244 gross amount received. Participants who are laid off and not recalled rehired within five 245 years shall forfeit their status as a participant in the pension plan and all accumulated credit 246 for continuous service. 247 248 (d) Request for refund. When an employee leaves the employment of the city employment and 249 is entitled to withdraw his contributions, with interest thereon a written notarized request 250 for a refund of contributions must be submitted before payment is made. Refunds will 251 be issued 90 days from the date the notarized request is received. Interest on the 252 contributions, at the rate of five percent per annum, shall be compounded annually from 253 the last day of the plan year in which such contribution was made to the earlier of the date 254 of commencement of retirement income or the date on which contributions are payable 255 pursuant to the provisions of the plan., then he shall submit a written notarized request for a 256 refund of these contributions before payment shall be made. Refunds will be issued 90 days 257 from the date when the notarized request is received. Contributions will automatically be 258 refunded five years from the date of separation. 259

260 Section 80-514 – Cessation of disability pension benefits. 261 262 (a) A participant shall cease to qualify for disability pension benefits: 263 264 (1) Recovered. At the time that the general employee pension plan board determines, 265 based on the basis of a medical examination by a physician or physicians selected by 266 the pension plan board, that a participant is no longer totally and permanently disabled 267 or has sufficiently recovered, but refuses to resume their regular occupation as an 268 employee or to be reemployed by the city in some other suitable position for which 269 they are suited or which is appropriate to their the participant's training and 270 experience; 271 (2) Refuses examination. When the participant refuses to undergo a medical examination

Paj 156

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 7

272 requested by the general employee pension plan board; or 273 274 (3) Age 65 years. On the first day of the month following the participant's 65th birthday. 275 276 (b) Upon the occurrence of the earliest of the above events, disability pension benefits shall 277 cease, except that, if the event of subsection (a)(3) of this section occurs, payment of the 278 normal retirement benefits shall commence on that date, in the same amount as the 279 disability pension benefits. 280 281 Section 80-515 – Effect of state workers’ compensation on disability benefits. 282 283 Any disability pension benefits received by a participant under the terms of this division 284 as the result of an injury or illness compensable under the workers' compensation laws of the 285 state shall be reduced by the amount of the workers' compensation payments actually received 286 by the participant. 287 288 Section 80-516 – Benefits to cease upon reemployment; exceptions. 289 290 The Internal Revenue Code has provided guidance that to be considered retired for 291 purposes of prohibitions against "in-service distributions," one must have an at least six-month 292 break before returning to employment with the same employer and that such a return cannot be 293 pre-planned at the time of retirement. If the individual is under the normal retirement age of 65, 294 the individual will be subject to an annual earnings limit of $30,000.00. 295 296 Any employee of the city who is receiving, or who shall receive, benefits under this 297 division, and who is thereafter reemployed by the city or appointed to any position by the mayor 298 or council bearing remuneration, shall cease to draw benefits during the period of reemployment. 299 Upon termination of the reemployment, the benefits shall be restored. The provisions of this 300 section shall not apply to any employee who receives remuneration as a result of being elected 301 or appointed to an elective or appointed office in the city, nor to any employee reemployed by 302 the city in a casual/seasonal capacity, not to exceed 180 calendar days. Employees would be 303 eligible to return to casual/seasonal status immediately following retirement. 304 305 Casual/seasonal employees may be employed by the city on a temporary basis in order to 306 provide assistance for the following situations: 307 308 (a) Casual assistance. Employee is needed on a sporadic or on-call basis where hours 309 cannot be predetermined and vary greatly from week to week. Such employees may be 310 used as needed. 311 312 (b) Seasonal assistance. Employee is needed for peak operating seasons. 313 314 (c) Project assistance. Employee performs duties related to a specific project that has 315 defined objectives and an established time period of completion that does not exceed 316 180 calendar days.

Paj 157

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 8

317 318 (d) Primary incumbent replacement. Employee is needed to fulfill the job responsibilities 319 of the primary incumbent who is unable to perform such responsibilities for an 320 extended period of time. Such employees may be used for a maximum of 180 calendar 321 days or the length of time the incumbent is unable to perform the job responsibility,

322whichever is less.
323
324 (e) Contracting. Any individual participating in the plan who contracts with the city or
325 represents any private enterprise that has a contract with an employer participating in
326 the plan must have a six-month separation from their the effective date of retirement if
327 the individual is under 65. The city shall maintain, in a form prescribed by the human
328 resources director, a certification of the worker's status. The certification will be used
329 for a determination of the individual meeting the definition of eligible employees under
330this section.
331
332Section 80-517 – Benefit assignment, transfer, etc.
333
334 No participant or beneficiary under the plan shall assign, transfer, hypothecate, encumber,
335 commute, or anticipate any interest he may have in payments, funds, or contracts under this plan.
336 No interest shall in any way be subject to any legal process, levy of execution, attachment, or
337 garnishment proceedings for the payment of any claim against the participant or any beneficiary
338 under the plan, nor shall any such interest be subject to the jurisdiction of any bankruptcy court
339or insolvency proceedings.
340
341Section 80-518 – Contributions.
342
343(a)Payroll deductions.
344
345 (1) Amount. For each year, while a participant of the plan, a participant shall contribute,
346 by payroll deductions, an amount equal to 3½ percent of his the participant’s average
347 actual monthly earnings as described in section 80-508—Amount of retirement
348 benefits (effective May 1, 1994). The city shall provide the plan participants with
349an annual statement of individual contributions.
350
351 (2) Employer contributions. The city, pursuant to the provisions of section 414(h)(2) of the
352 United States Internal Revenue Code (26 USC 414(h)(2)), shall pick up and pay the
353 contributions which would otherwise be payable by the employee under this section.
354 The contributions so picked up shall be treated as employer contributions for purposes
355 of determining the amounts of federal income taxes to be withheld from the employee's
356compensation.
357
358 (3) Employee contributions picked up by city. Employee contributions picked up by the
359 city shall be paid from the same source of funds used for the payment of compensation
360 to an employee. A deduction shall be made from each employee's compensation equal
361 to the amount of the employee's compensation picked up by the employer. This
362 deduction, however, shall not reduce the employee's compensation for purposes of
363 computing benefits under the retirement system pursuant to this *division.

Paj 158

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 9

364 365 (4) Employee contributions credited. 366 367 a. Employee contributions shall be credited to a separate account within the 368 employee's individual account so that the amount contributed prior to the effective 369 date for the pickup of the employee's contributions may be distinguished from the 370 amounts contributed on or after the effective date. 371 372 b. The contributions, although designated as employee contributions, are being paid 373 by the employer in lieu of the contributions by the employee. The employee will 374 not be given the option of choosing to receive the contributed amounts directly 375 instead of having them paid by the employer to the retirement system. 376 377 (b) City contributions. The city shall make such contributions as necessary to meet the 378 requirements of the plan. Effective May 1, 1994, the city shall pick up the employee 379 contributions by a reduction in current earnings. Such picked-up contributions shall be 380 treated as employer contributions in determining tax treatment under the Internal Revenue 381 Code; however, the contributions so picked up shall be included in earnings for purposes of 382 the plan. Participant contributions which are picked up shall be treated, for all purposes of 383 this plan, in the same manner as participant contributions made prior to May 1, 1994. 384 385 (c) Other contributions. The general employee pension plan board shall receive all 386 appropriations, contributions, and interest allowances as may be received from time to time 387 by the city from the state or any other source, and designated specifically for employee 388 pensions. 389 390 (d) Withdrawal from plan. A member who withdraws from the general employee pension plan 391 for any reason, other than retirement, death, or disability, may request their that the 392 accumulated contributions, plus five percent interest, be paid to them after such date of 393 withdrawal; provided, however, their the contributions shall not be refunded to them earlier 394 than 90 days after receipt of their the notarized application for the same. 395 396 (e) Death of ineligible member. Upon the death of a member not eligible to retire under any 397 provision of this division, their the employee contributions shall be payable in a single sum 398 to their the participant’s designated beneficiary or their the participant’s estate if no 399 designation has been made. 400 401 Section 80-519 – City paramedics transferred to county. 402 403 Notwithstanding any other provision of this division, all persons employed by the city as 404 paramedics, who are transferred to the county emergency medical services department and who 405 make a written election to remain in the city general employee pension plan, shall continue to 406 be considered eligible employees within the meaning of the pension plan as long as they the 407 paramedics are employed by the county emergency medical services department. All benefits 408 for any such paramedic shall be calculated as if the paramedic had remained a city employee 409 during his employment while employed with the county emergency medical services 410 department.

Paj 159

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 10

411 412 Section 80-520– General employee pension plan board; established; duties. 413 414 There is hereby established a general employee pension plan board, the duties of which 415 shall be to manage the general employee pension plan. 416 417 Section 80-521– Composition. 418 419 The general employee pension plan board shall consist of the following persons: 420 421 (1) Manager. The city manager. 422 423 (2) City officials. Two elected city officials who shall be appointed by the council 424 president, subject to confirmation of a voting majority of the city council at its annual 425 meeting. 426 427 (3) Participants. Three Four participants; or active, retired, or vested participants of the 428 general employee pension plan who shall be elected by the active, retired, or vested 429 participants and retired participants of the plan. 430 431 (4) Controller/treasurer. The city controller/treasurer. 432 433 (5) Election. 434 435 (a) Such election shall be for three-year staggered terms, beginning July 1 and ending 436 June 30 three years later. A regular election for filling these positions will be held 437 the third week of June each year. 438 439 (b) In the first week of April of each year, the city clerk shall notify those eligible to 440 vote of the exact time and place of the election. Any general employee pension 441 plan member that is eligible to vote and appears on the listing of qualified voters 442 who will be unable to appear at the polling place on the date and time of the 443 election may cast his or her vote by absentee ballot in the general employee 444 pension plan election for the following reasons: 1) armed forces, 2) public service, 445 3) occupation, 4) sickness, 5) disability, 6) religion, 7) vacation, or 8) residency 446 outside of the Dover area which makes it infeasible to vote in person. Any active, 447 retired, or vested member of the general employee pension plan who wishes 448 to fill an expiring term or vacancy must submit their name to the city clerk’s 449 office by the deadline determined by the city clerk. 450

451 (c) Any general employee pension plan member that is eligible to vote and 452 appears on the listing of qualified voters who will be unable to appear at the 453 polling place on the date and time of the election may cast his or her vote by 454 absentee ballot in the general employee pension plan election for the 455 following reasons: 1) armed forces, 2) public service, 3) occupation, 4) 456 sickness, 5) disability, 6) religion, 7) vacation, or 8) residency outside of the

Paj 160

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 11

457 Dover area which makes it infeasible to vote in person. Participants wishing 458 to vote by absentee ballot must request an affidavit for absentee voting from 459 the city clerk’s office. Once the affidavit is returned, the city clerk shall send 460 the participant an absentee ballot which must be completed and returned to 461 the city clerk’s office. Both the affidavit and the completed absentee ballot 462 must be returned by the deadline determined by the city clerk. 463

464 (d) Persons appearing to vote shall present proof of identity. The identification 465 shall be 1 or more of the following items that show the identity of the person: 466 (1) A current driver’s license or ID card; (2) A uniformed service ID card; 467 (3) Another current photo ID issued by a government agency, the voter’s 468 employer, high school, or higher education institution. The Election Officer 469 shall then check the person’s name against the voter list. If the Election 470 Officer determines that the person is not eligible to vote in the election, the 471 Election Officer shall refer the person to the city clerk. The city clerk, after 472 hearing and considering evidence, shall determine whether to permit the 473 person to vote. Upon making the decision, the city clerk shall appropriately 474 annotate the voter list. 475 476 Section 80-522 – Term of office of members. 477 478 The term of office of each member of the general employee pension plan board, except the 479 city controller/treasurer, city manager, and elected city officials, shall commence on the first day 480 of the month following their election and continue for a period of three years or until their 481 successor shall be elected and qualified. 482 483 Section 80-523 – Officers and ex officio members. 484 485 The At its first meeting after each regular general employee pension plan board election, 486 the board shall elect a chairperson and a vice chairperson who shall serve in the absence of 487 the chairperson. The Committee Chair's responsibilities include chairing general employee 488 pension plan board meetings, setting agendas, and facilitating communication with the 489 board as needed. The city controller/treasurer shall be the pension fund treasurer and their the 490 treasurer’s bond shall cover all monies deposited with them. 491 492 Section 80-524 – Vacancies. 493 494 If a vacancy occurs in the offices of the general employee pension plan board, the vacancy 495 shall be filled for the unexpired term within 60 days and in the same manner as the office was 496 originally filled. Should a member of the pension plan board cease to be in the employ of the 497 city, other than by retiring or being vested in accordance with this division, their the office as 498 a member of the board shall be declared vacant. 499 500 Section 80-525 – Compensation of members. 501 502 Members of the general employee pension plan board shall serve without compensation.

Paj 161

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 12

503 504 Section 80-526 – Meetings. 505 506 The general employee pension plan board shall make all rules as to the time and place of 507 meetings; and a majority of its membership shall be required to transact pension board business. 508 The board shall meet on a quarterly basis to review investment performance but may meet 509 more frequently if needed. Meetings may be called by the chairperson, vice chairperson, 510 or three members of the board. The board will follow Robert’s Rules of Order as its 511 parliamentary authority. The rules contained in the current edition of Robert’s Rules of 512 Order Newly Revised shall govern the pension board in all cases to which they are 513 applicable and in which they are not inconsistent with any special rules of order the board 514 may adopt. 515 516 Section 80-527 – Powers. 517 518 The general employee pension plan board, in administering the pension plan, shall have 519 the following powers in carrying out the purposes thereof: 520 521 (1) Payment of funds. To pay funds to those entitled to receive them. The 522 controller/treasurer shall sign all vouchers for the disbursements of the funds and shall 523 report to the general employee pension board all financial transactions on an annual 524 basis;. Monthly cash receipts and expenditure reports will be delivered on a 525 quarterly basis. The quarterly reports shall be provided in writing seven days in 526 advance of the quarterly meeting. 527 528 (2) Purchase annuity contracts. To purchase and pay the costs of group annuity contracts 529 from any insurance company for the benefit of participants; 530 531 (3) Employment of agents, employees, etc. To employ agents, employees, or experts to 532 assist the pension board in carrying out the provisions of this division, including an 533 agent to advise and make recommendations concerning the investment of funds, and to 534 pay reasonable compensation for those services, and the compensation may be paid 535 from income or corpus of the pension fund or by direct appropriation by the city council 536 as the pension board and the city council may determine; 537 538 (4) Investments. To invest and reinvest money in the pension fund, without any limitation, 539 in United States or state municipal bonds or group annuity contracts. Money in the 540 pension fund may also be invested and reinvested in other types of bonds, stocks, and 541 securities to the extent the pension board may deem best and as is not prohibited by 542 any law now or hereafter in force limiting the investments of the trustees. The pension 543 board may from time to time change the investments of the fund and, to this end, may 544 make sales of any investment privately, without advertisement and without the 545 necessity of any court order, upon the terms that the pension board deems proper. The 546 funds and investments may also be from time to time turned over to and placed in the 547 custody of any fiscal agent designated by the pension board; 548 549 (5) Contracts. To generally contract in matters relevant to effectuating and achieving the

Paj 162

Item #19. Proposed Ordinance #2024-07 - Amending Chapter 80 – Personnel, Article IV – Pension Plans and Retirement Benefits (except Police), Division 3 – General Employee Pension Plan Page 13

550 purposes of this plan;
551

552 (6) Pension benefits. To receive and pay out pension benefits in accordance with the 553 provisions of this division, or designate a fiscal agent to receive and pay out the pension 554 benefits; 555

556 (7) Rules and regulations. To make rules and regulations as may be necessary to effectuate

557this subdivision.
558
559Section 80-528 – City solicitor to render legal services.
560
561 The city solicitor shall render whatever legal service the general employee pension plan
562board shall require.
563
564Section 80-529 – Appeals.
565
566 Any employee dissatisfied with the action of the general employee pension plan board shall
567 have the right to appeal to the city council within 30 days from the date of formal notification of
568that action.
569
570ADOPTED: *
571
572SYNOPSIS
573
574 The amendments make gender-neutral edits; suggests review of beneficiary information by plan
575 participants; removes total and permanent disability exclusions; requires the city to provide the plan
576 participants with an annual statement of individual contributions; changes the number and makeup of the
577 general employee pension plan board; provides additional direction with regard to the pension board
578 election; clarifies that a chairperson and a vice chairperson shall be elected annually; clarifies the
579 responsibilities of the chairperson; clarifies when the board can meet and who can call a meeting; adopts
580 Robert's Rules of Order as its parliamentary authority; requires that the board be provided monthly cash
581 receipts and expenditure reports and that quarterly reports shall be provided in writing and presented at the
582quarterly meetings.
583
584Action History
58508/12/2024 – Scheduled for Final Reading – City Council
58607/22/2024 – First Reading – City Council
587 07/09/2024 – Introduction – Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
58806/04/2024 – Pension Board review and recommendation
589 04/19/2024 – Pension Board considered amendments proposed by the sponsors and staff, sought legal
590assistance
591 04/09/2024 – Introduction at Council Committee of the Whole – Legislative, Finance, and
592 Administration (Remanded back to the Pension Board and for legal review)
593 02/08/2024 – Pension Board considered and recommended adoption, as revised by the Board

Tounen nan reyinyon sa a