Yo rale tèks sa a nan PDF la otomatikman, epi li ka gen erè. PDF la se dosye ofisyèl la, kidonk tcheke l anvan ou konte sou sa a.
30 paj pa gen anpil tèks ou ka li isit la, oswa yo pa gen ditou, souvan paske se eskanè oswa desen. Gade PDF la pou sa yo.
Paj 1
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Monday, January 13, 2025 at 6:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware
AGENDA VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE
This meeting will be held in the City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:
Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://shorturl.at/0zZ83
Event number: 2534 924 3021
Event password: DOVER (if needed)
If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.
The meeting can also be viewed on Comcast Channel 14, Verizon Channel 20, and on the City's Streaming Player located at www.cityofdover.com under "Quick Links".
OPEN FORUM - 15 Minutes Prior to Official Meeting (6:15 p.m.)
The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share their questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing on the agenda as a public hearing is prohibited during the Open Forum as an opportunity will be provided during consideration of that item. Citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is prohibited from taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule such items as regular agenda items and act upon them in the future.
INVOCATION - Elder Ellis B. Louden
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Dr. Julia Pillsbury
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Paj 2
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - January 13, 2025 PAGE 2
PRESENTATIONS
- 1.Certificate of Recognition for Ms. Delmarva 2025 - Denise Dudley
- 2.Council President Year End Report
PUBLIC HEARING
FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council meeting of November 11, 2024. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government."
- 3.Proposed Ordinance #2024-31 - Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road
Ordinance 2024-31 Review and Recommendation of a Rezoning application for a parcel of land consisting of 1.2302 acres +/-. The property is zoned C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The proposed zoning for the property is IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The property is located on the west side of McKee Road and north of the intersection of McKee Road and College Road.
(The owner of record is PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC. Property Address: 1216 McKee Road. Tax Parcel: ED-05-067.00-01-34.00-000. Planning Reference: Z-24-06. Council District 1.)
CONSENT AGENDA
ADOPTION OF MINUTES
- 4.Regular City Council Meeting of December 9, 2024
- 5.Special Council Meeting of January 2, 2025
COMMITTEE REPORTS
- 6.Council Committee of the Whole Report of December 10, 2024
COUNCIL REPORTS - NOVEMBER 2024
- 7.First District
- 8.Second District
- 9.Third District
- 10.Fourth District
- 11.At-Large
- 12.Council President Anderson
Paj 3
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - January 13, 2025 PAGE 3
Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
- 13.Discussion - Additional Information Regarding the State of Delaware Pension (Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director, David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Stephanie Tatman, State of Delaware Deputy Pension Administrator)
(Committee Action Not Required)
- 14.Annual Review of the Investment Policy (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer)
(Committee Recommendation: Approve the policy with no changes)
- 15.Sole Vendor Purchase Approval for the HVAC - Dover Police Department (Chief Johnson)
(Committee Recommendation: Approve the Sole Vendor Purchase from Service Unlimited, New Castle, DE)
Utility Committee
- 16.Annual Engineering Consultant's Report on the Operation and Maintenance of the Electric System - Fiscal Year 2025 (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, and Paul Waddell, Electric Director)
(Committee Recommendation: Acceptance of the report)
MONTHLY REPORTS - November 2024
- 17.City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
- 18.City Manager’s Report
- 19.Controller/Treasurer's Budget Report
- 20.Fire Chief's Report
- 21.Police Chief's Report
APPOINTMENTS
- 22.Dover Housing Authority
- A.Enrico LePore - Fill Remainder of Six-Year Term to Expire August 2030
Paj 4
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - January 13, 2025 PAGE 4
CITY MANAGER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
MAYOR'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ANNOUNCEMENTS
ADJOURNMENT
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING
Paj 5
Item #1.
Paj 6
Item #3.
City of Dover
PETITION TO AMEND ZONING DISTRICT
Public Hearing Before the Dover City Council on January 13, 2025
Recommendation from Planning Commission Meeting on December 16, 2024
With Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review
Application: Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road:
Rezoning C-PO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1
Owner: PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC
Address: 1216 McKee Road, Dover DE
Location: Located on the west side of McKee Road and north of the intersection of McKee Road and College Road
Tax Parcel: ED-05-067.00-01-34.00-000
Size: 1.2302 +/- acres
Present Uses: Vacant
2019 Comprehensive Plan – Land Use Category: Office
Present Zoning: C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone)
Proposed Zoning: IO (Institutional and Office Zone) COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone)
Reason for Request: Rezoning the property for a future expansion of the existing hospital (Post Acute Medical (PAM) Health Rehabilitation Hospital of Dover)
File Number: Z-24-06
Ordinance Number: 2024-31
Planning Commission Recommendation: The Application Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road was represented by Mike Riemann of Becker Morgan Group on behalf of the property owner. A Public Hearing was conducted on December 16, 2024 where no members of the public spoke, and no written comments were received regarding the Rezoning application. The Planning Commission’s motion to recommend approval of the proposed rezoning from C-PO/COZ-1 to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) with COZ-1 resulted in a 6-0 vote in favor (three members absent). (Draft Meeting Minutes attached.)
- P.O. Box 475 Dover, DE 19903 Page 6 Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Paj 7
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
APPLICATION: Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road, Dover DE: Rezoning C-PO/COZ-1 to I-O/COZ-1
This Rezoning Application was referred to the Planning Commission as per Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §5. The Planning Commission is required to provide a Review Report to the City Council. The following document and attachments are provided as the Review Report and Planning Commission Recommendation.
- I.APPLICATION SUMMARY: This Rezoning Application is for a parcel of land consisting of 1.2302 acres +/-. The property is zoned C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The proposed zoning for the property is IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The property is located on the west side of McKee Road and north of State College Road. The owner of record is PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC. Property Address: 1216 McKee Road. Tax Parcel: ED-05-067.00-01-34.00-000. Council District 1. Ordinance #2024-31.
Existing Property: The property is currently a vacant tract of land with frontage along McKee Road. This application only seeks rezoning of the property from CPO to IO; the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) zoning designation will remain. The applicant is seeking rezoning to allow for future development of the property. Any redevelopment of the site will be subject to a separate application submission for plans or permits.
Previous Applications: A Demolition Permit (#21-132) was granted for the demolition of the previous single family detached dwelling located on the property. The subject property was previously part of a series of four properties fronting on McKee Road that were rezoned from R-8 (One Family Residence Zone) to CPO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) as part of the Comprehensive Rezoning 2009 Project. The property became subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) with the creation of that zone in the 1990s.
Surrounding Land Uses The surrounding parcels are zoned a mix of institutional, commercial, and industrial: IO (Institutional and Office Zone), C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone), and C-2A (Limited Central Commercial Zone). The property to the north is the location of the Post-Acute Medical (PAM) Rehabilitation Hospital and is zoned IO. The property to the south is a multi- tenant commercial building with retail establishments and offices. To the west is a residential area zoned R-8 (One Family Residential Zone) which consists of the Emerald Pointe Subdivision and a one family detached dwelling fronting on College Road. Across McKee Road to the northeast are several residential parcels located in Kent County and there is also a vacant tract at the northeast corner of the intersection (1205 McKee Road) zoned C-2A. The properties that front on McKee Road are subject to the COZ-1(Corridor Overlay Zone).
Paj 8
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
II. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN COMPLIANCE REVIEW
In the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, the Land Development Plan (Map 12-1) recommends that this property be used for Office and Office Parks. The goals and polices for Office Areas are listed in the 2019 Comprehensive Plan excerpts presented below (page 12-18): Office Parks The Land Development Plan designates specific tracts of land of various sizes for Office and Office Park land uses. Office Park development involves an integrated development of office buildings with shared entrances, driveways and parking. The majority of uses permitted within an Office Park are generally weekday professional office uses involving very little or no activity at night or on weekends. For this reason, the Office Park designation may be viewed as a transitional use category when situated between more intense commercial and industrial land uses and residential land uses. This designation usually involves the C-PO (Commercial/Professional Office Zone) zoning district. These areas are located throughout the City with established office concentrations in the Enterprise Business Park, along Silver Lake Boulevard, on College Park Drive, along Old Rudnick Lane, the Northgate Center, and elsewhere. Scattered office uses are also located along Saulsbury/McKee Road and within designated “Mixed Use” areas in the Eden Hill Farm Traditional Neighborhood Design (TND). Smaller scale areas for office parks are the Woodbrook complex on South Governors Avenue, office complexes along Walker Road, and areas along Route 8.
The Rezoning Request to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) is consistent with the Land Use Classification of Office and Office Parks. Table 12-1: Land Use and Zoning Matrix (from the 2019 Comprehensive Plan) specifies that the following zones are compatible with this Land Use classification. See the excerpt from Table 12-1 given below.
CPO (Commercial and Professional Office)
Office and Office Parks IO (Institutional and Office)
IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing)
RGO (General Residence and Office)
III. ZONING REVIEW
Request for IO (Institutio0nal and Office) Zoning The following code excerpt of the IO zoning district is provided from Article 3 §10 of the Zoning Ordinance. Article 3 Section 10. Institutional and office zone (IO). 10.1 Uses permitted. In an institutional and office zone (IO), no building or premises shall be used, and no building or part of a building shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any purpose, except the following: (a) Business, professional, or governmental offices. (b) Banks. (c) Research, design, and development laboratories. (d) Public and institutional uses including hospitals, medical clinics, libraries, police stations, courthouses, transit centers, schools, colleges, universities, places of public assembly, philanthropic and charitable institutions, parks, playgrounds, public indoor recreation centers, athletic fields.
Paj 9
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
(e) Public utility rights-of-way and structures necessary to serve areas within the city. (f) Child day care centers, provided they are established in accordance with all applicable state regulations pertaining to child care and provided that they are established and maintained in accordance with article 5, section 14 of this ordinance. (g) Emergency shelters and transitional housing. (h) Adult day care facilities provided they are established in accordance with all applicable state regulations pertaining to adult care and provided that they are established and maintained in accordance with article 5, section 22 of this ordinance. 10.2 Conditional uses. The following uses are permitted, conditional upon the approval of the planning commission in accordance with the procedures and subject to the general conditions set forth in article 10, section 1: (a) Firearm ranges, prisons, and correctional facilities. (b) Public incinerators. (c) Hotels and restaurants. 10.3 Accessory uses. The following uses shall be permitted accessory to other permitted uses on a lot. (a) Clinics, cafeterias, and recreational facilities. (b) Motor vehicle storage and repair facilities accessory to a public or institutional use. (c) Restaurants that are on a campus and intended to support users of the campus. 10.4 Uses prohibited. The following uses are prohibited: (a) Landfills, dumps. 10.5 Enclosed buildings. All permitted uses and all storage accessory thereto, other than offstreet parking, shall be carried on in buildings fully enclosed on all sides, except for outdoor eating areas associated with restaurants approved by the city planner. 10.6 Performance standards. All uses are subject to performance standards as set forth in article 5, section 8.1. 10.7 Site development plan approval. Site development plan approval in accordance with article 10, section 2 hereof shall be required prior to the issuance of building permits for the erection or enlargement of all structures and prior to the issuance of certificates of occupancy for any change of use.
COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) The provisions of the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) are established to “promote superior urban corridor development and the highest quality-built environment.” There are a series architectural, parking, and landscaping guidelines that would be required by the COZ-1 zoning district, if development of the property is proposed. The purpose and requirements of the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) are given in Article 3 §27 of the Zoning Ordinance. See the following code excerpt.
Article 3 Section 27. – Corridor Overlay Zone 1 (COZ-1)
27.1 Purpose. The corridor overlay zone (COZ) is established for the following reasons: (a) To promote superior urban corridor development and the highest quality built environment;
(b) To foster coordination and linkage among corridor properties and with adjacent lands;
Paj 10
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
(c) To preserve the functionality and efficiency of the roadway for traffic movement; and
(d) To achieve a visually balanced streetscape environment which is friendly to the pedestrian and motorist alike.
27.2 Superior urban design. For the purposes of this ordinance the term "superior urban design" shall meet the following criteria:
(a) Superior urban design places a strict and primary importance on the pedestrian. The concept should lend itself to interconnectivity while presenting building structures as aspects of the street, not simply islands existing in the "sea of roads". The design should encourage fewer car-trips, as well as promote automobile trips on an interconnected local street system rather than trips that utilize the arterials. In demonstrating superior urban design, an applicant must show that the plan presented exceeds the requirements of the zoning ordinance in at least two of the following areas:
(i) Transportation amenities for bicycles, pedestrians and transit that exceed those required by the zoning ordinance;
(ii) Architectural features including, but not limited to: LEED-certified buildings; unique architecture not replicated in other locations; use of architectural elements such as entry porticos, porte-cocheres, colonnades, cornices, porch columns and balusters, band courses, coins, water tables and other trim that enhances visual quality and function of the structure; and use of the highest-quality construction materials.
(iii) Landscaping that exceeds the requirements of this section, including robust use of trees, shrubbery, and flowering plants to screen parked cars; water gardens and ponds; arboretums; tree preservation measures;
(iv) Public spaces and art including, but not limited to, sculpture, memorials, murals, public court yards and pocket parks, and fountains;
(v) Green technologies for stormwater management, as well as green energy technologies such as geothermal heating and cooling and solar energy supplies.
(b) The city planner shall develop policy guidance on how the concept of superior urban design will be evaluated.
27.3 Zone boundaries. The COZ encompasses the lands adjacent to the following roadways as outlined on the City of Dover Zoning Map as set forth in article 2, section 2 of this ordinance: (a) Delaware Route 8 (Forrest and Division Streets) from the railroad tracks in a westerly direction to the city limit line.
(b) McKee/Saulsbury Road (County Road 156) from the intersection at Dennys Road (County Road 100) in a southerly direction to the terminal intersection with West North Street (County Road 73).
27.4 Permitted uses. Land use shall be governed by those provisions of this ordinance related to the specific zoning district designations of each property as depicted on the zoning map.
27.5 Site development plan approval. Site development plan approval in accordance with article 10, section 2 shall be required prior to the issuance of building permits for the erection or enlargement of all structures and prior to the issuance of certificates of occupancy for any change in use. When the zoning district regulations specify that a particular use requires conditional use
Paj 11
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
approval in accordance with article 10, section 1, the provisions of that article shall apply. Site development plans and conditional use site plans for properties within the COZ shall reflect compliance with the development guidelines of this article, in addition to all other applicable codes and regulations.
27.6 Development guidelines.
27.61 Setbacks:
a. Front yards.
Residential Nonresidential Min. Max. Min. Max. McKee/Saulsbury 60' to 80' 40' to 50' * Route 8—Artis Drive to Mifflin Road 60' to 80' None Route 8—Mifflin Road to Saulsbury 40' to 60' 40' to 60' * Road Route 8—Saulsbury Road to R.R. line 20' to 30' 20' to 30' Subdivision streets (Setback provisions of article 4 shall apply)
- •When the applicant can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the planning commission through the site plan review process that the proposal involves a superior urban design, the maximum setback may be increased to no more than 90 feet from the property line on Route 8 from Mifflin Road to Saulsbury Road and on McKee and Saulsbury Roads.
27.62 Building placement. Buildings shall be situated on the property so as to maximize the use of the frontage along the roadway and shall have the longest side of the building arranged parallel and square to the roadway. When the applicant can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the planning commission that, due to specific constraints related to lot configuration, alternative building placements may be permitted.
27.63 Parking. (a) Location. Parking shall not be permitted to be situated within the front yard, nor between the right-of-way line and the building, except in the following instances: (i) Automobile service stations; (ii) Properties in a shopping center (SC) zoning district, in which case, parking may be permitted between the building and the roadway, provided that such parking [shall] be limited to five rows of single parking spaces between the road and the storefront; (iii) When the applicant can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the planning commission through the site plan review process that the design presented involves a superior urban design, parking may be permitted between the building and the street, provided that such parking within this area shall be adequately landscaped and screened from the roadway.
(b) Required number of spaces. See specific district requirements in article 4.
(c) Layout. (i) Parking lots shall be arranged in such a manner so that not more than 20 parking spaces in a row shall be permitted without a landscaped island. No more than six rows of 20 spaces shall be provided without provision for a landscaped median.
Paj 12
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
Parking islands shall be a minimum of ten feet wide and planting medians shall be no less than eight feet wide.
(ii) There shall be a landscaped buffer area of at least 12 feet in width between the building and parking lot and drive areas. The buffer area shall include provisions for a sidewalk of at least six feet and no greater than eight feet in width. The buffer area and sidewalk shall be grade separated from the parking lot by concrete curbing of at least six inches in height.
(d) Landscaping. Design shall be simple and easy to maintain and shall consist of a combination of hardy canopy trees, low evergreen shrubs and turf grass, and shall be designed in accordance with landscape guidelines set forth in article 5, section 15 of this ordinance and as follows: (i) Interior landscaping. A minimum of five percent of the interior area of a parking lot shall be reserved for landscape purposes. This provision shall include the landscaping of all required parking islands and medians. Shade trees shall be incorporated within the landscaped islands whenever and wherever practicable.
(ii) Parking lot screening adjacent to public right-of-way. Low profile screening shall be required when parking spaces would result in vehicles facing onto the roadway. Screening may consist of a low wall, evergreen hedge with a minimum height of two feet at the time of planting, planted three feet apart on center, and a maximum height of three feet at maturity, or earth berm. Should a low wall be used, such wall shall be accompanied by evergreen shrub plantings on the roadway side of the wall and spaced ten feet apart on center.
(iii) Reserved.
27.64 Site access. (a) Entrance width and radii. Site entrances shall have a minimum width of 24 feet. Entrances involving a median divider shall be at least 35 feet in width. Entrance radii shall be a minimum of 15 feet and a maximum of 25 feet.
(b) Number of entrances and curb cut spacing. One curb cut shall be permitted for each street which abuts a site. For sites with street frontage in excess of 300 linear feet, one additional curb cut may be permitted. For sites with street frontage in excess of 600 linear feet, two additional curb cuts may be permitted.
Multiple curb cuts on a property shall have a minimum spacing distance in accordance with the following schedule:
| Speed Limit | Maximum Spacing (Ft.) |
|---|---|
| 25 | 105 |
| 30 | 125 |
| 35 | 150 |
| 40 | 185 |
| 45 | 230 |
| 50 | 275 |
(c) [Shared access.] Shared access shall be provided, whenever possible, for entrances to adjoining uses, including residential driveways.
Paj 13
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
(d) [Cross access.] Cross access shall be provided among abutting uses of similar use categories, whenever possible, to provide linkage between properties as an alternative to re-entering the corridor to access both existing and future neighboring properties.
(e) Entrance locations for adjoining properties. Commercial site entrances shall be no closer than 25 feet to an adjoining property which is zoned residential and no closer than ten feet to an adjoining property which is in a nonresidential zoning category.
27.65 [Signs.] Signs shall meet the regulations found in article 5, section 4, supplementary sign regulations.
27.66 Building height. (a) Buildings shall be limited in overall height to 35 feet and shall not exceed two stories.
27.67 Open space and landscaping. (a) Lot coverage. Each lot shall have a minimum of 25 percent of the lot area dedicated to be landscaped open space. A lesser amount of landscaped open space may be permitted when it can be demonstrated to the satisfaction of the planning commission, through the site plan review process, that, due to lot configuration and existing built conditions, the required minimum is impractical.
(b) Frontage. Each lot shall have a landscaped open space of at least 25 feet in width, measured from the back of curb along the entire frontage of the lot, except at points of site access. Trees shall be provided along the frontage perimeter at a minimum rate of one tree for each 50 linear feet of frontage.
(c) Side and rear yards. A minimum of 15 feet of landscaped open space shall be provided along all side and rear lot lines when abutting a residential use and a minimum of five feet when abutting a nonresidential use. Tree plantings shall be provided along all nonfrontage perimeters at a minimum rate of one tree for each 75 linear feet.
(d) Stormwater detention ponds. Detention ponds may be counted toward the minimum 25 percent open space area, provided that such ponds are designed to emulate natural features by incorporating irregular outline, gradual slopes (no greater than 1:4), and appropriate landscape plantings.
(e) Landscaping. Landscaped open spaces shall be designed in accordance with the provisions of this section, as well as the landscaping guidelines as set forth in article 5, section 9 of this ordinance.
(f) Screening. The following items shall be located so as to minimize visibility from the roadway, adjacent properties and other public areas, and shall be screened from public view: (1) Service bays; (2) Loading docks and platforms; (3) Rooftop utilities; (4) Satellite dishes; (5) Dumpsters; (6) Storage areas.
(g) Standard for tree plantings. Trees shall be of a high canopy variety and shall be limbed to a minimum height of 12 feet above grade at maturity.
Paj 14
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
(h) Standards for shrubbery. Shrubbery shall be of a low evergreen variety and shall be limited to use as foundation plantings and for screening purposes.
(i) Standards for ground cover. Ground cover shall be limited to turf and ornamental grasses and ornamental evergreen ground cover plantings within required landscape areas.
27.68 Lot configuration. All lots within the corridor overlay district created after the enactment of this section shall conform to the following: (a) Minimum lot area [shall be] 10,000 square feet. Service stations [shall have a minimum lot area of] 20,000 square feet. (b) Minimum lot depth shall be 100 feet. In the C-3 (service commercial) district, the minimum lot depth shall be 150 feet. (c) Minimum road frontage shall be at least 100 feet. In the C-3 (service commercial) district, the minimum road frontage shall be 150 feet.
27.69 Architectural review. The side of any building which faces the corridor (or corridors) shall be referred to as the "corridor elevation." Buildings in the COZ-1 shall be designed to front on the corridor, and the corridor elevation shall contain architectural elements traditionally associated with the front of a building. Blank walls without functioning windows are prohibited along the corridor. Windows must be incorporated into the overall design concept of the corridor elevation. Providing one or several small windows on a large corridor elevation shall not constitute compliance with this ordinance.
A "functioning window" shall be defined as a window which lets light into the interior of the structure, and is integrated and related to the interior layout of the space. In addition to functioning windows, the corridor elevation shall have the following elements: (a) A primary entrance door or doors (except for loading doors). (b) A primary entrance feature, such as a porch, portico, awning, entrance walk, or other similar feature.
In addition, the corridor elevation shall have one of the following elements: (a) Landscaping integrated into the building design concept. (b) Architectural or urban design elements which link adjacent structures together, such as plazas, walkways, colonnades, or similar features. (c) Architectural relief, such as vertical and horizontal offsets in exterior wall elevations, band courses, lintels and sill courses, cornices, and the like, to create shadow lines.
The applicant shall submit 12 copies of the corridor elevation at the time of application. The city planner or his/her designee shall determine whether compliance with the provisions of this ordinance has been achieved.
27.7 Properties located on a corner lot with two frontages within the Corridor Overlay Zone. When a property is located on the corner of two corridors within the Corridor Overlay Zone, only one of the two corridors shall be subject to the requirements of Section 27.61 Setbacks and Section 27.63 Parking, Subsection (a) Location. The frontage of the property on which the identifiable front of the building is located shall be the frontage that is subject to the requirements of Section 27.61 And Section 27.63, Subsection (a). In designing the site, in order to qualify for the relief under this subsection, the applicant must demonstrate to the satisfaction of the planning commission that the design incorporates the principles of superior urban design as defined in Section 27.2.
Paj 15
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
IV. RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING STAFF:
This Request is to rezone lands from C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) to IO (Institutional and Office Zone). The current CPO zone is mainly commercial in nature with the zoning district permitting offices, banks, and medical laboratories type uses with other commercial uses only allowed through a conditional use review process when the use is accessory to a permitted use on the same lot. The C-PO zone also allows for conditional use review to create residential uses in the form of apartments, multi-family residences, and one- family residences. While both zones are commercial in nature, the IO Zone generally does not allow for residential dwelling units instead focusing on offices, public buildings, places of public assembly, institutional uses, and recreation related facilities. The additional uses in the IO zone beyond office uses are similar to the uses in the surrounding area such as schools and institutional buildings. The IO zone also allows for uses including Child Day Care Centers and Adult Day Care Facilities that would be allowed in any zone per the Zoning Ordinance, Article 5 §22. In the IO zone, the allowable residential uses are related to institutional facilities like housing at colleges, emergency shelter facilities, and transitional housing (allowed by definition in a single-family house setting).
As part of the process to change the zoning district of a property outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the City Planner must evaluate the following factors when considering the request:
Article 10 § 5.22 City planner report. For each proposed zoning text amendment, the city planner shall issue a report to the planning commission and city council, including comments from other reviewing agencies, that evaluates the following factors:
(A) Whether such change is consistent with the aims and principles embodied in the ordinance as to the particular zones concerned; and
(B) Whether such proposed amendment is consistent with the aims of the comprehensive plan of the city.
Staff recommends that the Rezoning be granted to IO (Institutional and Office Zone). The proposed zoning is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan for the Office and Office Parks Land Use Category classification, as it fits the goals of the Comprehensive Plan by grouping similar institutional activities together and will likely provide essential services. Rezoning to IO is one of the possible zoning districts eligible for consideration in this Land Use Category classification.
Staff also recommends that the property remain subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) due to its frontage on McKee Road. The purposes of the COZ-1 are to promote superior urban corridor development; to foster coordination and linkage among corridor properties; to preserve functionality and efficiency of the roadway for traffic movement; and to achieve a visually balanced streetscape environment friendly to the pedestrian and motorist. (Zoning Ordinance, Article 3 §27). The COZ-1 includes a number of additional buffers/setbacks, landscaping enhancements, and site layout design requirements which will be required as part of any proposed development activities on the parcel.
Paj 16
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
The Comprehensive Plan attempts to put employment centers adjacent to main transportation routes. There is existing infrastructure for water, sanitary sewer, and electric services in the vicinity of the property (and could be expanded if necessary); and the police, fire, and emergency medical services already service the area.
This Rezoning Request does not grant approval of a specific use for the property but makes its land use subject to a listing of uses permitted and potential conditional uses as allowed in IO (Institutional and Office Zone) zoning district. Were the application for Rezoning to be recommended by the Planning Commission and subsequently approved by the City Council, the applicant would still have to submit plans and/or permits for review for most uses of the site to be established.
This recommendation is being made without the benefit of hearing the comments of surrounding landowners and residents. A public hearing is required on this matter and the Planning Commission should give those comments consideration.
- V.PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEW FOR RECOMMENDATION This Rezoning Application is a request for a zoning map amendment which changes the zoning district of a property. The Planning Commission as part of their public hearing and review process will provide a recommendation on the rezoning request to City Council. As part of the process outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the Planning Commission must evaluate the following factors when considering the request:
Article 10 § 5.36 Report of the planning commission. Regarding each application for a zoning map amendment, the planning commission shall provide a report to the city council stating a recommended action with regards to the proposed amendment, along with the commission's evaluation of the following factors:
(A) Whether the uses permitted by the proposed change would be compatible with the existing uses and zones in the area concerned;
(B) Whether adequate public services and infrastructure exist or can be created or expanded to serve the needs of any additional demand as a result of such change; and
(C) Whether the proposed change is in accordance with the city's current comprehensive plan.
A Recommendation Report from the Planning Commission will be forwarded to City Council for their consideration of the Rezoning Application.
RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION:
At the Hybrid (In-Person and Virtual) Planning Commission Meeting of December 16, 2024, the Rezoning Application Z-24-06 was represented by Mike Riemann of the Becker Morgan Group on behalf of the property owner PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC. During the Public Hearing, no members of the public spoke, and no written comments were received.
The Planning Commission’s motion was to recommend approval for Rezoning application
Paj 17
Item #3. Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning CPO/COZ-1 to IO/COZ-1 Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024
Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road from C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office) to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) remaining subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) and resulted in a vote of 6-0 in favor of rezoning (three members absent). The reasons cited for the recommendation of approval include the applicant’s presentation; the opportunity for an addition to the PAM Center (extra beds) for community needs; compatibility with existing land uses; sufficient infrastructure; consistency with the City’s 2019 Comprehensive Plan; and with reference to the Planning Staff’s recommendations of approval (uses of the zoning district, compatibility with Comprehensive Plan, and presence of existing infrastructure) in the Development Advisory Committee Report.
See also the included excerpt of the DRAFT Meeting Minutes of the December 16, 2024 Planning Commission meeting. The comments received from the other member agencies of the Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) are also provided.
VI. ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
- 1)The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Rezoning application does not represent Site Development Plan or Subdivision Plan. Following any decision made by City Council regarding this Rezoning, then an application for a Site Plan, Subdivision Plan, and/or appropriate Building Permits must be submitted to the Planning Department prior to the establishment of a use, development activity, or any construction activity on the site. The applicant should contact the Planning Staff to determine the appropriate review process for any proposed projects.
- 2)The applicant shall be aware that approval of any Rezoning application does not represent a Building Permit, Demolition Permit, Sign Permit, or other construction activity permit approval. A separate application submission is required before issuance of permits by the City of Dover.
- 3)The applicant shall be aware that any future use and/or buildings may be subject to a separate permitting or licensing processes through the City of Dover Licensing and Permitting Division. All businesses operating in the City of Dover are required to obtain a City of Dover Business License. Certain types of uses also require a Public Occupancy Permit or Rental Dwelling Permits.
ATTACHMENTS:
- •Zoning Map Exhibit
- •Application Z-24-06 Submission: Existing Conditions Plan Sheet
- •Development Advisory Committee Comments from City of Dover Departments of Public Works and Water & Wastewater, Electric Department, City Office of the Fire Marshal, DelDOT, Kent Conservation District, and Dover/Kent County MPO
- •Excerpt from DRAFT Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024
- •Proposed Ordinance #2024-31
Paj 18
City of Dover Application No.: Z-24-06
Item #3.
Department of Planning & Inspections
Title: Rezoning Lands of PAM C ubed Real Estate, LLC 2024-31 Ordinance #: 1216 McKee Road Legend Addresses: Parcel ID: ED0S-067.00-01-34.00-000 C-PO (Commercial & Professional Office Zone) and COZ-1 D Subject Property Existing Zoning: IO (Institutional & Office Zone) and COZ-1 Proposed Zoning: PAM C ubed Real Estate, LLC. c:::J Dover Boundary Owner: 11/14/2024 D Zoning D Dover Parcels Date:
D Kent County Parcels
0 200 400 800 Feet
- Corridor Overlay Zone
Paj 19
Item #3.
Paj 20
Item #3.
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: NOVEMBER 27, 2024
APPLICATION: Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning C-PO to IO FILE #: Z-24-06 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Water & Wastewater CONTACT PERSON: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater CONTACT PHONE #: 302-736-7025 CONTACT EMAIL #: jlyon@dover.de.us
T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .
T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
- 1.Our office has no objections to the proposed rezoning of tax parcel ED-05-067.00-01-34.00-000. Any redevelopment shall adhere to the City of Dover Water/Wastewater Handbook and the Specifications, Standards & Procedures for Public Works Construction. Impact fees may be applied to this property. Future development shall comply with all aspects of the City of Dover’s Cross Connection Control Program.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. None
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / GENERAL
- 1.None WASTEWATER
- 1.When this site is developed, an evaluation of the downstream wastewater pump station must be conducted by the developer. Upgrades may be required by the developer.
I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .
Paj 21
Item #3.
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: NOV 27, 2024
APPLICATION: Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning C-PO to IO FILE #: Z-24-06 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Electric Department CONTACT PERSON: Shawn Burgett, Engineering Services & System Ops Superintendent CONTACT PHONE #: 302-674-7568 CONTACT EMAIL #: sburgett@dover.de.us
T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .
T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
ELECTRIC
Our office has no objection to the rezoning of: ED-05-067.00-01-34.00-000.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES ELECTRIC 1. Should this site be redeveloped, which includes modifications to the use, the applicant / developer will be responsible for all costs associated with providing the appropriate meter / service to this site based upon the use including any necessary system upgrades or extensions. The appropriateness and adequacy of electric and meters will be assessed at that time. 2. Any redevelopment shall adhere to the City of Dover’s Electric Service Handbook. https://evogov.s3.amazonaws.com/media/27/media/13108.pdf.
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT
ELECTRIC
- 1.None.
I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .
Paj 22
C F #3.
Z-24-06
Item
I I
T R
CITY OF DOVER Y E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE O M
F A APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY R D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 11/27/24 D S O H V A E L R APPLICATION: Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate LLC at 1216 McKee Rd
FILE #: Z-24-06 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover, Office of the Fire Marshal
CONTACT PERSON: Jason Osika, Fire Marshal PHONE #: (302) 736-4457 josika@dover.de.us
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY, AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESS BY THE APPLICANT:
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
- 1.Proposal is a rezoning application. This office has no objections.
ADDITIONAL / SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS TO OBTAIN APPROVAL:
- 1.N/A
APPLICABLE CODES LISTED BELOW (NOT LIMITED TO):
2021 NFPA 1 Fire Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2021 NFPA 101 Life Safety Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 72 National Fire Alarm and Signaling Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 13 Installation of Sprinkler Systems (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2009 IBC (International Building Code) Latest editions of all other NFPA Codes as defined by the Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations 2021 Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations City of Dover Code of Ordinances
*If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person listed.
Paj 23
Item #3.
CITY OF DOVER D
E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
L
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY D
O
T
===============================================================
APPLICATION: Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC
FILE#: Z-24-06 REVIEWING AGENCY: DelDOT
CONTACT PERSON: Brian Williams PHONE#: 302-760-2141
=============================================================== THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY'S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:
CITY & STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
No person, firm, corporation or the like shall construct, open, reconstruct, maintain, modify or use any crossing or entrance onto a state-maintained highway, street or road, including any drainage modifications leading into or carried by the highway drainage system, without first having complied with standards and regulations adopted by the Department and having obtained a permit issued by the Department. Please contact the Delaware Department of Transportation - Development Coordination section to begin permit process.
RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES:
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
- 1.DelDOT has no objections to the rezoning.
Paj 24
Item #3. KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT 1679 SOUTH DUPONT HIGHWAY • DOVER, DELAWARE 19901• (302) 608-5370 • WWW.KENTCD.ORG
CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
DECEMBER 2024
APPLICATION: Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road
Rezoning C-PO to IO
FILE #: Z-24-06
REVIEWING AGENCY: Kent Conservation District
CONTACT PERSON: Cullen Baker
PHONE: (302) 608 – 5370
EMAIL: stormwater@kentcd.org
THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE. THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:
Source: 2019 Delaware Sediment and Stormwater Regulations
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:
Kent Conservation District has no objection to the proposed rezoning for the above referenced site.
ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:
Soil disturbance (e.g. clearing, grading, excavations, tree clearing, or stoning) equal to or greater than 5,000 square feet requires a Sediment and Stormwater Management Plan to be submitted and approved by the Kent Conversation District prior to the commencement of disturbance.
Paj 25
Item #3.
CITY OF DOVER Dover/Kent
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
County
Metropolitan
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY Planning
D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 12/4/2024 Organization
Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning C-PO to IO
FILE # Z-24-06 REVIEWING AGENCY: Dover/Kent County MPO
CONTACT PERSON: Malcolm Jacob PHONE #: (302) 387-6030
Issues of concern to the MPO are effective transit, reducing the amount of vehicle emissions by shortening or eliminating trips, and facilities for alternative modes of transportation, including bicycle and pedestrian access. The MPO considers the bicycle facilities required by the City of Dover to be the standard for all applications, not to be waived.
City of Dover Planning Commission
Zoning Review
Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning C-PO to IO
Dover Kent MPO does not have any objections to the proposed rezoning. Further comments will be given when the site is developed.
Note that in terms of transportation connectivity, there is already a shared use path for pedestrian and bicycle access along the property’s frontage. This path runs north to south on McKee Road. Because of this, there are no serious connectivity gaps.
If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person and the Planning Department as soon as possible.
Paj 26
Item #3.
CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION
December 16, 2024
Excerpt from Meeting Minutes – Draft
The Meeting of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Monday, December 16, 2024, at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system Webex. The Meeting Session was conducted with Chair Mr. Witham presiding. Members present were Mr. Michael Lewis, Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Maucher, Mr. Baldwin, Mrs. Welsh, and Mr. Witham. Mr. Roach, Dr. Jones, and Mr. Reaves were absent.
Staff members present were Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Ms. Sharon Duca, Mrs. Kristen Mullaney, and Mr. Jason Lyon (virtual).
NEW APPLICATIONS
Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning C-PO to IO - Public Hearing and Review for Recommendation to City Council on a Rezoning application for a parcel of land consisting of 1.2302 acres +/-. The property is zoned C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The proposed zoning for the property is IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The property is located on the west side of McKee Road and north of the intersection of McKee Road and College Road. The owner of record is PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC. Property Address: 1216 McKee Road. Tax Parcel: ED-05-067.00-01-34.00-000. Council District 1. Ordinance #2024-31. The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was completed on November 25, 2024 and Public Hearings were scheduled for Planning Commission on December 16, 2024 and City Council on January 13, 2025.
Representative: Mr. Mike Riemann, Becker Morgan Group
Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that this a Rezoning Request. The Planning Commission will be making a recommendation regarding this Request. The property shown on the screen in yellow is just to the northwest of the intersection of McKee Road and College Road. The property is addressed as 1216 McKee Road. It is currently zoned CPO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). They have made a Request for Rezoning to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) with it remaining subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). As this is an Ordinance, the Planning Commission will be conducting their public hearing and making a Recommendation regarding the Rezoning. It then moves onto City Council for their own public hearing and final action on the Rezoning Request. The Report details what the allowable uses and zoning requirements of the IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) zoning districts are. The Comprehensive Plan places this in a Land Use Category of Office. The recommendation from the Planning Staff is a recommendation for approval for Rezoning of the property. They note that the IO (Institutional and Office Zone), while it’s commercial in nature it does allow for a number of institutional type buildings and the property owner has a future plan related to institutional expansion in that area. Their submission also included a location diagram of the property itself. Staff is recommending that it be rezoned to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) finding that it’s consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and the goals of the Plan related to that Land Use Category. They are also Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024 Page 1 of 4
Paj 27
Item #3.
recommending that the property remain subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) because of the frontage that it has on McKee Road. In the interest of time, she knows the applicant has a more detailed presentation so she will let them run through that.
Mr. Riemann stated that he wanted to highlight a little more detail on top of what Mrs. Melson- Williams has already mentioned. The subject site is located on McKee Road just north of the intersection with College Road. It is a 1.23-acre parcel that their client has recently purchased. They have owned it for the last couple of years and it is associated with the PAM Rehabilitation Facility that is located directly to the north. They are here tonight requesting a Rezoning from CPO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and they are okay with this remaining within the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) as well. The Code outlines the criteria as it relates to Rezoning, which he knows the Commission is very familiar with, but basically there are three criteria that they must demonstrate that they meet. First, is whether or not adequate services and infrastructure exist or can be created to support the zoning change; then whether the uses permitted by the proposed change would be compatible with existing uses and zones in the area, and whether or not the proposed zoning is in compliance with the City of Dover proposed Comprehensive Plan. As it relates to each of these points, they believe this Rezoning application does meet these three criteria specifically as it relates to adequate public facilities. The project would be served by City of Dover sewer, water, and electric. There is already sewer and water serving the adjacent facility which this Rezoning will help for that facility to expand. That is the purpose of this Rezoning so that this facility can expand and serve the health care needs of the community. There is already an existing access as well onto McKee Road for that project. Secondly, whether or not the use is permitted by the proposed change would be compatible. The IO (Institutional and Office Zone) is a permitted zone in the Office and Office Park Land Development Matrix which he will get to in a minute as part of the Comprehensive Plan. It is located along McKee Road. There are number of other Institutional zones in the area which we will show on the next slide and a number of other compatible commercial and institutional uses in the area. Lastly, is whether or not the proposed application is in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan. The 2019 Comprehensive Plan calls for this area to be designated as Office and Office Park; and IO (Institutional and Office Zone) is a zone that is permitted within that designation. The next slide shows the arrows pointing to the subject parcel. The light blue color is IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and you can see that IO (Institutional and Office Zone) is in the vicinity of the project which is directly to our north. That is the existing zone of the existing PAM Facility and then to our south we have C-2A (Limited Central Commercial Zone) as well. We do believe that the zoning is compatible with the zoning in the area. As it relates to the Comprehensive Plan, one of the goals of the Comprehensive Plan is to maintain and improve the City’s position as a center of government, education, and medicine through the support of existing institutions and encourage well-designed campuses that are integrated into community and have room to expand. That’s exactly what this Application is about. This is about the PAM Facility; they essentially need to expand to add beds to serve that community and that is why they need to do this Rezoning. That is why they purchased this piece of property. They believe that this Rezoning Request does exactly that. The next slide shows a snippet from the Comprehensive Plan. As you know, the Comprehensive Plan defines various areas for development and uses. This is the Office and Office Park portion of the Comprehensive Plan. As you can see on the right side, those are the various zoning districts that are compatible with Office and Office Park; and you can see IO (Institutional and Office Zone) is listed as one
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024 Page 2 of 4
Paj 28
Item #3.
of those permitted zonings. The next slide lists the different uses that are permitted with the IO (Institutional and Office Zone) for your refence. With that, the project did go through DAC. Of course, as part of that process, you hear back from other relevant agencies such as Kent Conservation District, DelDOT, the Fire Marshal, etc. All agencies had no objection to this particular Zoning Request. With that, they believe that they do meet the three criteria outlined in the Code. They do believe that this is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and he would be happy to answer any questions.
Mr. Witham opened a public hearing and after seeing no one wishing to speak, closed the public hearing.
Mrs. Denney stated that they have from time to time, as they look at different things that might occur in the area of McKee Road and College Road, are reminded by residents locally with regard to the already challenged traffic that exists. As things improve and things happen, DelDOT becomes involved, but they tend to not become involved at this level. She just wanted to remind us all. Especially Mr. Reaves, at some point he has always had some concern about things in that area. She doesn’t take it often but occasionally she does, and he makes a point. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mr. Witham stated that obviously with any development you are going to have an impact on local roads as well. He recognizes the issue that you just raised but he is not sure how they can address it. It is always going to be an issue.
Mrs. Denney stated exactly, nor does she have a suggestion. Again, what tends to happen in a situation like this is if DelDOT needs to become involved at some point they will, but right now that’s not the case for them. They are not going to do a Traffic Study for this.
Mrs. Welsh stated that she will comment just because of the traffic issue. She is on the road three or four times a day. She recalls that traffic was an issue when the original PAM Building was under review. While traffic does tend to get busy at different times and at different stages and different seasons, she says having traveled that road at least three times a day for the last ten (10) years, it might be a little bit busy but it has not appreciably increased over what it used to be. Her thought is that if it’s a similar use that she thinks with DelDOT’s cooperation, the traffic can be addressed. Responding to Mrs. Welsh, Mr. Witham stated that he would agree. Of course, we would have to speculate on what the impact was going to be but obviously that particular road is a corridor that directly connects onto Route 1. So, it’s obviously utilized by a lot of people not just from the PAM Facility but other businesses out there as well.
Mrs Welsh stated that she will make a further comment on what Mr. Witham just said. The traffic is backed up from McKee Road to Division Street a lot. It is just bumper to bumper at certain times of the day and it’s been bumper to bumper for a few years like that. So, she hopes that DelDOT will jump in and address issues but unless you add 3,000 beds there, she is not sure that she can imagine that there would be detrimental impact on traffic other than what the normal growth of the City would generate.
Mr. Riemann stated that they are adding twelve (12) beds. When they come in for the Site Plan Application, keep in mind that the Site Plan for this will come back to this body, that will be the time that they go through DelDOT with the details on entrance access and all of those things as
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024 Page 3 of 4
Paj 29
Item #3.
part of that process. It’s not currently as part of the Rezoning. He knows that some other projects in the area, be believes, are contributing to some intersection improvements at McKee Road and College Road. So, there are plans to do some work there from other projects in the area that are contributing. He thought that might be helpful.
Mrs. Welsh moved to recommend approval to City Council for application Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning C-PO to IO.
Mrs. Maucher asked to make a friendly amendment before seconding the motion. She wants to add that it remains subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mrs. Welsh stated that she agreed.
Mrs. Welsh moved to recommend approval to City Council for application Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning C-PO to IO with the property to remain subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone), seconded by Mrs. Maucher and the motion was carried 6-0 by roll call vote with Mr. Roach, Dr. Jones, and Mr. Reaves absent. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; the presentation was well presented. Becker Morgan always does a great job and it is apparently a needed addition to the PAM Center and should be a good improvement and something that the community needs. Mr. Lewis voting yes. Mrs. Denney voting yes; she definitely thinks that the extra beds are needed. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; the Rezoning meets the criteria outlined in that the new zoning is compatible with existing land uses, there is sufficient infrastructure to service the new property, and that it’s consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Mr. Baldwin voting yes; based on Staff recommendation. Mr. Witham voting yes; for the reasons set forth on the record by the Commissioners and Staff.
Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024 Page 4 of 4
Paj 30
FINAL READING
Item #3.
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-31
| 1 | AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF |
| 2 | THE CITY OF DOVER CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY |
| 3 | LOCATED AT 1216 MCKEE ROAD |
| 4 | |
|---|---|
| 5 WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property | |
| 6 | within the limits of the City of Dover; and |
| 7 | |
| 8 WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted | |
| 9 use of property below from C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) and subject to | |
| 10 COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to COZ-1 | |
| 11 | (Corridor Overlay Zone). |
| 12 | |
| 13 | NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE |
| 14 | CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET: |
| 15 | |
| 16 1. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and Zoning | |
| 17 Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning designation | |
| 18 from C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) and subject to COZ-1 (Corridor | |
| 19 Overlay Zone) to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to COZ-1 (Corridor | |
| 20 Overlay Zone) on that property located at 1216 McKee Road, consisting of 1.2302 acres, | |
| 21 | owned by PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC. |
| 22 | |
| 23 (Tax Parcel: ED-05-067.00-01-34.00-000; Planning Reference: Z-24-06; Council District 1) | |
| 24 | |
| 25 | ADOPTED: * |
| 26 | |
| 27 | Action History |
| 28 | 01/13/2025 – Scheduled for Public Hearing/Final Reading – City Council |
| 29 | 12/16/2024 – Public Hearing – Planning Commission |
| 30 | 11/25/2024 –First Reading – City Council |
Paj 31
Item #4.
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular City Council Meeting was held on December 9, 2024, at 6:45 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Council members present were Mr. Hare, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Arndt, Mr. Rocha, Dr. Sudler, and Mr. Lewis.
Staff members present were Fire Chief Carey. Police Chief Johnson, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Marney, Ms. Melson-Williams, Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Mayor Christiansen was also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 6:18 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Council President Anderson declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.
William Faust, 136 Orchard Avenue, voiced concerns about the stormwater fees and other increasing costs imposed by the city. He noted that the stormwater fee was implemented without prior notification, and while a refund is now being processed due to corporate complaints, he fears this will deplete the electric reserve funds, raising questions about their replenishment. Mr. Faust highlighted several recent financial burdens on residents, including EMS fees, a 2% square footage tax, and increases in electrical rates and services. He questioned what cost-cutting measures have been implemented and raised concerns about the potential impact on the city’s bond rating. While he supports raises for city workers, recognizing their hard work, he pointed out that many residents are struggling with rising costs, often working multiple jobs, and may be hesitant to voice their concerns publicly out of fear of repercussions. Mr. Faust emphasized that he would prefer paying the $39 stormwater fee quarterly rather than facing higher taxes or utility bills later. He urged the city to clarify what cuts are being made to manage these costs, stressing the importance of maintaining essential services like police and EMS.
EShed Alston, 406 Arnold Court, addressed Mayor Christiansen to revisit a conversation with him from 2023 concerning the original concept of Lenape Moore Day, which took place on October 9 of that year, not Columbus Day of this year. Mr. Alston recounted meeting an elder during the event, where they exchanged information about shaman rituals, including one performed that day at McKinney's Garage. He has been trying for nearly two (2) years to identify and reconnect with this elder, emphasizing the importance of respecting elders and seeking the mayor's assistance in facilitating this connection.
Mr. Alston raised concerns about annexing the Generals Green area into the City of Dover, noting that residents have lived there for nearly 40 years. They highlighted that Dover Police can pursue vehicles up to the gates of the Dover Air Force Base, which requires passing through Generals Green, suggesting the city should also have jurisdiction over the neighborhood. He pointed out that while they pay their electric bill to the City of Dover, they are not considered part of the city, describing it as "taxation without representation."
Mike Harrington, 516 Jefferic Boulevard, expressed concerns about the wastewater management tax, advocating for a more equitable distribution method rather than basing it on land. He cited the example of Best Buds, which faces nearly $1,000 per quarter in taxes for its parking lot.
Paj 32
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 2
Mr. Harrington highlighted the challenge of managing this cost and noted his struggle to pass it on to tenants who are already financially burdened.
Frank Zabe, 903 Schoolhouse Lane, expressed concerns about the wastewater management tax and the stormwater fees. Mr. Zabe expressed his opposition to the policy, stating that he was a victim of the backflow device mandate for his buildings. He explained that he spent $4,500 to install the system, only to later learn it was unnecessary. Adding to his frustration, a third-party contractor was now requiring them to have the backflow devices inspected annually, which incurs additional costs for hiring a plumber. Mr. Zabe expressed dissatisfaction with being forced to comply with these requirements despite the initial installation not being needed.
He stated that he has spoken to Mayor Christiansen and Mr. Hugg, but no one wants to take responsibility for it. Mr. Zabe had asked for a rebate or some kind of concession for spending $4,500 on something that was not needed and now he had found out that he was being billed by another company representing the City of Dover Public Works to have a plumber come and inspect the device, with payment to be submitted for the inspection. He stated that he was having problems with his meters. He has four (4) meters on one of his buildings and he was billed four (4) times for the EMS fee because he has four meters, but he only has one geographical location, and he believes that this is unfair. Mr. Zabe expressed that he has gone to the City of Dover Electric Department and was told that they only collect the money. He has talked with the City Clerk’s Office and council, with no answer as to why. He is a small business owner who has been successful for the past 60 years in the City of Dover and noted that the fees are getting excessive. If they hit each resident once, some of the people like himself are being hit four or five times on the fees and they add up.
Dr. Sudler asked if they could have a follow-up on how to merge the meters since at least two of them are duplicates and asked if they could put a priority on following up on that.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Zabe stated that after making three (3) separate trips to address the issue, he eventually gave up on the matter and expressed that no one was taking responsibility for resolving the matter.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Zabe shared the contact number for the Army Navy Store.
Dr. Sudler noted that he would follow up with the city manager.
Responding to Mr. Zabe, Dr. Sudler mentioned that, depending on the circumstances, they may be able to apply a credit to his account, such as his electric account, as a possible solution.
Mark Reeves, 10 Tanzanite Court, representing the Emerald Point Homeowner Association, raised concerns about the safety and traffic flow between McKee Road and Gemstone Boulevard. He highlighted that the community has only one (1) entrance and one (1) exit, causing residents to wait around 10 to 15 minutes each time to leave. Despite multiple discussions with DelDOT, the association has not received any resolution regarding the installation of a traffic control device. Mr. Reeves, who has lived in the neighborhood since 2011, pointed out that the community has grown from 70 to 107 homes, and now approximately 250 vehicles enter and exit the neighborhood. Initially, the decision was made not to install a
Paj 33
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 3
traffic control device but given the growth in the number of homes and vehicles, the need for one has become more pressing.
Mr. Reeves further expressed that it is challenging for residents to exit onto McKee Road due to the high traffic speed—45-50 miles per hour in both directions. While there is a traffic light at the intersection of McKee Road and Saulsbury Road Extension, there is no middle relief lane for drivers to pull into, and the area has seen numerous accidents. He mentioned a proposal for a development across Gemstone Boulevard that would create a four-way intersection, but construction for the development has been delayed, with an extension applied for. A traffic light was promised after the fifth certificate of occupancy for the development, but this would mean starting construction without a traffic control device in place, creating potential safety concerns for both the construction entry and exit. Mr. Reeves requested the opportunity to attend an official agenda meeting, where they could speak to the Safety Committee and have the community voice their specific safety concerns.
Don Anderson, 505 Oak Lane, shared concerns along with his wife, Cecilia Ventura, about the trash at Silver Lake. Ms. Ventura echoed her husband's concerns, specifically highlighting the litter and shopping carts scattered throughout the neighborhood. She expressed that the presence of trash makes her, and her husband feel unsafe. He mentioned that while they enjoy living in the neighborhood, they wish it were cleaner, as Dover is a city where many people retire and should live up to its reputation for cleanliness. (Exhibit #1)
Cecilia Ventura, 505 Oak Lane, expressed concerns about the trash at Silver Lake. She stated that every day that they go into their home, there are litter and shopping carts in the neighborhood. She noted that she and her husband do not feel safe because of what they see.
Lachelle Paul, 501 Silverside Drive, expressed frustration about the lack of consistency in trash collection, and street sweeping, despite having signs indicating the scheduled days for pickup, which were Wednesday and Friday. She pointed out that the streets were not being swept, garbage was not being collected, and the streets were not being washed. When there is a holiday pickup, it is often delayed by a day or two (2), and sometimes entire pickup cycles are skipped, forcing residents to wait another week for service. Ms. Paul emphasized that regardless of financial status, all residents pay taxes and pay for trash pickup, so they deserve consistent service. She urged council to ensure that the scheduled pickups are being carried out properly.
Ms. Paul acknowledged Chief Johnson and the visible presence of his police officers in the area. She pointed out that when the officers are present, it helps reduce undesirable behavior, but when they leave, it becomes noticeable as people regroup and the situation deteriorates. She emphasized that reviewing the cameras would provide evidence of this pattern. Ms. Paul highlighted that the officers' presence contributes to the safety and well-being of the residents. She complimented Chief Johnson for his attention to this issue and the improvements seen in recent times.
INVOCATION
The invocation was given by Elder Ellis B. Loudon.
Paj 34
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 4
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Councilman Neil.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Ms. Arndt requested that items 32 and 33 be considered in front of Item 29 so all marijuana items could be considered sequentially.
Ms. Arndt moved for adoption of the agenda as amended, seconded by Mr. Neil, and carried unanimously.
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Dr. Sudler requested the removal of Item #10, Discussion – Stormwater Utility Billing Concerns, be removed from the consent agenda.
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the consent agenda as amended, seconded by Mr. Anderson, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
PRESENTATION – RECOGNITION AND CONGRATULATIONS – DEBBIE A. O'BRIEN The City Clerk read the following Certificate of Recognition and Congratulations into the record:
CERTIFICATE OF RECOGNITION
presented to
Debbie A. O’Brien
In recognition of your outstanding accomplishment in completing the Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA) certification process and achieving the designation of Certified Public Finance Officer (CFPO)
Your dedication to excellence in public finance, unwavering commitment to professional growth, and extraordinary achievement as only the third individual in the State of Delaware to earn this prestigious certification are truly amenable.
Your accomplishment reflects your expertise, determination, and leadership in advancing the principles of accountability, transparency, and fiscal responsibility in public service.
The City of Dover honors your exceptional achievement and thanks you for your continued contributions to the Finance Department and our community.
Paj 35
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 5
PRESENTATION – RECOGNITION AND CONGRATULATIONS – SHARON J. DUCA The City Clerk read the following Certificate of Recognition and Congratulations into the record:
CERTIFICATE OF RECOGNITION
presented to
Sharon J. Duca
In recognition of your outstanding accomplishment in obtaining the prestigious ICMA-CM (International City/County Management Association Credentialed Manager) designation.
Your dedication to professional growth, commitment to excellence in local government management, and tireless efforts to serve your community exemplify the highest standards of leadership and service.
This significant milestone reflects your unwavering commitment to ethical governance, continuous improvement, and effective management practices.
The City of Dover extends sincere appreciation for your exceptional accomplishment and looks forward to your continued contributions to public service and leadership excellence.
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-29 –
AMENDING APPENDIX B – ZONING, ARTICLE 3 – DISTRICT REGULATIONS, SEC. 19 – MANUFACTURING ZONE (M), SEC. 20 – INDUSTRIAL MANUFACTURING ZONE (IPM), SEC. 23 – AGRICULTURAL ZONE (A), ARTICLE 5 – SUPPLEMENTARY REGULATIONS, SEC. 24 - MARIJUANA RELATED BUSINESSES, ARTICLE 12 – DEFINITIONS (FORMERLY PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-25A – RECREATIONAL MARIJUANA LAND USE AND ZONING: CULTIVATION, MANUFACTURING, AND TESTING FACILITIES) A public hearing was duly advertised for this time and place to consider approval of proposed zoning text amendments to Appendix B-Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 19 – Manufacturing Zone (M), Section 20 – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), Section 23 – Agricultural Zone (A); Article 5 Supplementary Regulations; Section 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 – Definitions.
Mr. Neil moved that the Final Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2024-29 be acknowledged by title only, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and unanimously carried. (The First Reading of the ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of October 28, 2024.)
Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, briefed the members of council on the proposed Ordinance #2024-29 – Amending Appendix B-Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 19 – Manufacturing Zone (M), Section 20 – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), Section 23 – Agricultural Zone (A); Article 5 Supplementary Regulations; Section 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 – Definitions.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there have been several inquiries
Paj 36
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 6
regarding the recreational marijuana land use in general and they have advised those individuals that there was currently a moratorium in place through the end of the calendar year as council was still considering ordinances related to those land use activities.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Ann Marie Townsend, Rossi Group, stated that one of the items under the regulations, once a business was selected through the lottery process, they have 18 months to find a location. There have been businesses selected in Kent County, but they were not tied to location, and they needed to provide the paperwork that verifies that they are eligible under zoning. She noted that there are no specific locations in the city at this point, however, the conversion licenses have been approved but not issued. The medical dispensary that is in the city was one of the recipients of a conversion license, so if the ordinance does not pass to allow that, they would have to relocate.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend clarified that it has nothing to do with manufacturing.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend explained that the map highlights certain areas, marked in purple, where industrial marijuana-related businesses could potentially be located, as long as they aren't covered by the gray boundaries. The areas include limited spaces near Kraft and the Dover Air Force Base, as well as a small location on McKee Road. However, the map doesn't account for specific building footprints, which is important because if a building is partially within the eligible area, the entire building may not qualify for use by these businesses. Therefore, while the map shows potential locations, the actual availability of space and building suitability could limit the number of businesses that can be established in these zones.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Townsend explained that Mr. Lyon and his staff had conducted a model to identify the locations where industrial marijuana-related businesses could potentially be established based on the map. These locations would not require major upgrades, and any necessary upgrades would be the responsibility of the applicants, not the city. However, she noted that some areas would be ineligible because they would not be able to accommodate the fire flow requirements. Specifically, certain locations near Bay Road and Dover Air Force Base might not be suitable, depending on their water usage. If a site cannot meet these regulations, individuals will not be able to open a facility there.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Townsend clarified the distinction between manufacturing and cultivation in the context of marijuana-related businesses. She explained that cultivation refers to the growing process of the operation, which consumes a significant amount of water and electricity. On the other hand, product manufacturing involves taking the grown plants and processing them into various end products, such as vape oil, edible products, or raw flour.
Dr. Sudler expressed his concern about the cultivation component of the ordinance, stating that he would not vote in favor of it. He believed that cultivation would place additional strain on the water system, especially since upgrades are already being considered to address wastewater and other infrastructure issues. While he is not opposed to the manufacturing or testing facility components of the ordinance, his concern centers on the impact of cultivation.
Council President Anderson declared the hearing open.
Paj 37
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 7
Dina Vendetti, 435 North DuPont Highway, represented the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce and emphasized that the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce's stance on the ordinances has remained consistent throughout the process. She pointed out that, based on the ordinance under discussion and the associated questions and concerns, it appears the city would gain no fiscal benefits from its approval and could face potential costs. For these and other reasons, she expressed that pursuing the ordinance might not be a prudent decision for the city.
Responding to Ms. Paul, Mr. Hugg stated that all proceeds from the licensing and regulation portion of the marijuana ordinance are directed at the state, with no local share of licensing or fees. He explained that the city's revenue would depend on the utility usage of the operation, such as water, sewer, and electric services, for which the operation would pay like any other large customer. Additionally, he noted that there might be property tax benefits depending on the level of investment, particularly in manufacturing.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg clarified that they could not estimate potential revenue without knowing the scope of the operation. He explained that until an application is submitted detailing the amount of land to be cultivated and the space allocated for manufacturing, they would not have a solid basis for determining potential revenue figures.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Townsend stated that Mr. Lyon had analyzed models to estimate water usage and projected revenue for a 100,000-square-foot facility. She noted that water revenue would be a minimal $3,000 annually. However, significant revenue was projected from electricity, based on other growth facilities in the state. With an average consumption of 5.36 kilowatt hours per square foot, a 100,000-square-foot facility could generate approximately $462,000 annually in electricity revenue. A portion of this would cover power purchase costs, but some would benefit the city. She emphasized that this would likely be the primary source of revenue, depending on the facility's size. The analysis used a large facility to ensure the system could support it, acknowledging that smaller facilities would have reduced electricity usage and revenue.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend stated that other facilities can cultivate, manufacture, and test all in one in the state and that is where they are fully vertically integrated. A facility in Newark called Fresh Delaware grows manufactured products, testing, and retail all at the same location.
William Faust, 136 Orchard Avenue, inquired whether, given limited resources, there would be sufficient funding for the Police and Fire Departments if the policy were implemented. He also asked whether there was any information about the storage of chemicals for marijuana manufacturing and any security concerns for the police associated. He referenced Chief Johnson’s earlier statement about being understaffed and suggested that an additional 10 officers would be beneficial. Mr. Faust expressed concern about whether the city has enough manpower to manage these responsibilities while ensuring public safety.
EShed Alston, of 406 Arnold Court, discussed that there were thousands of dollars made on the streets every day and the idea that there was no value added to marijuana and street-level drugs in Delaware was ridiculous because there is a lot of money involved. Citing reports from California and other areas that have embraced similar policies, he highlighted public safety
Paj 38
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 8
concerns, such as accidents caused by individuals under the influence. Mr. Alston raised two key issues: the economic viability of the drug trade in Dover, with marijuana being a substantial part of it, and the question of who would benefit financially from it and where the money would go.
There being no one else present wishing to speak, Council President Anderson declared the public hearing closed.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Townsend explained that the state enforces strict security measures through statutes and regulations. Every plant and growth are tagged and barcoded, allowing it to be monitored from cultivation to product creation and final sale. She noted that facilities must comply with stringent security standards, including video surveillance and secure storage requirements. Additionally, manufacturing, cultivation, and testing facilities are not open to the public and have security procedures to restrict access to areas where products are handled.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Chief Johnson acknowledged ongoing concerns and, referring to Ms. Townsend's remarks, questioned the necessity of strict regulations for retail-destined products from seed to sale. He noted that tracking valuable items invites risks such as burglary at growth, testing, or cultivation sites, hijacking during transit, and robbery during delivery. While expressing concerns across the board, he clarified that he did not want to sound negative, since they were not discussing the significant number of locations, but all the concerns are omnipresent.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Townsend clarified that, as of now, there are no recreational marijuana facilities in the state. Regarding conversion licenses, she explained that existing growers are expected to transition into the cultivation and manufacturing of the product. She stressed that they are still in the early stages of the process and have not yet reached the point where any legal marijuana is being sold.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Townsend clarified that facilities within the state, whether recreational or medical, were already engaged in production and manufacturing activities.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Townsend stated that she was not aware of any reports of criminal activity at marijuana facilities, whether recreational or medicinal. She mentioned having discussions with municipalities where the facilities are located and with the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner, noting that the issue had not been raised.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Townsend explained that security measures begin at the very start of the process, as soon as a facility is licensed to cultivate. While she admitted some uncertainty about the initial source of the seeds, she emphasized that once the seeds enter the cultivation facility, until it is sold, they are tracked throughout the process.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townsend stated that she was unaware of any incidents or increases in crime related to marijuana facilities. She mentioned having spoken with staff in Milford and Newark, where the facilities are located, and confirmed that no issues had been raised.
Mr. Lewis referenced a previous meeting where Chief Johnson confirmed that the current
Paj 39
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 9
medical marijuana facility in Dover, Best Buds, had only experienced one alarm, with no other incidents.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Chief Johnson clarified that there have been no incidents of any significance related to the marijuana product, they have only responded to calls you would except for a typical address.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townsend explained that the industrial zones, where marijuana facilities are located, have several warehouses. She pointed out that multiple factors must be considered when looking for suitable spaces, ensuring that the building footprint does not interfere with required distance regulations.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townsend acknowledged that most of the industrial zones are located in the inner population of Dover. However, she pointed out exceptions like the Enterprise Business Park and Kraft Foods, which are closer to town, but are separated from residential areas.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townsend highlighted the potential on Horse Pond Road for marijuana facilities but noted a limitation due to the Airport Environs Zoning Overlay (AE). The map indicated that the clear zone and APZ-1 areas prohibited food manufacturing. As a result, marijuana products would not be allowed in those zones since marijuana would be considered consumable, which cannot be produced in areas where food manufacturing was prohibited.
Mr. Neil expressed that they are on the horns of a dilemma. He acknowledged that the state has legalized marijuana, and the focus would be to determine where it should be allowed and how to control the impact on the community. He recognized that while the benefits would not be significant, one advantage would be that the marijuana facilities could help manage the risks associated with marijuana laced with dangerous substances like fentanyl. Mr. Neil stated that marijuana legalization would not be a cure-all for the city, and the financial gains would not be big, only limiting too small amounts of money from utilities like electricity and water.
Mr. Neil stated that it would generate property tax revenue by filling empty spaces and serving a purpose. Mr. Neil explained that if he was in the legislature he would have voted against it because he believed that there is a dependency, except for the medical aspect of it. He noted that from the medical aspect, without the conversion license, the one marijuana facility could not stay open. Mr. Neil believed that it needs to be approved and that placing the marijuana facilities in the best possible locations, whether for retail or cultivation, would be best. This is the best option for them because it cannot be stopped.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townsend stated that it was unlikely the state would return a portion of its revenue to municipalities once the marijuana program was in place. She mentioned that if the League of Local Governments felt strongly about the issue, they could potentially lobby the state to secure even just 1% of the 15% revenue. She emphasized that they would need to rely on the League of Local Governments to advocate for them.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townsend stated that she had not heard of any plans for the state to allocate additional revenue to municipalities beyond fees. However, she noted that each year,
Paj 40
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 10
the League of Local Governments determines what their legislative priorities are. With many municipalities adopting ordinances to allow cannabis to some degree within their limits, Ms. Townsend emphasized the importance of those municipalities continuing to bring up the issue to advocate for any potential benefits.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Townsend clarified that it was always possible to amend the zoning ordinance. If the municipality decided to expand the zones in the future, they could do so. She noted that while it was more challenging to reverse changes, it is easier to expand, but that could always be an option.
Ms. Arndt reflected on the long process of considering the ordinance, noting that public comments were roughly split, with a slight majority against it during this evening session. She acknowledged the mixed opinions heard during the listening sessions and public comment hearing, emphasizing that marijuana was legal statewide. Ms. Arndt agreed with many of Mr. Neil’s points and noted that council had made a good-faith effort to address concerns. She highlighted the stringent state regulations and the additional layers of considerations in the ordinance, such as odor, safety, and utilities. She expressed satisfaction with the compromise reached, even though she anticipated their stance might not be popular, suggesting that if half the people were upset, they may have successfully balanced both sides of the issue.
Mr. Neil moved for the adoption of Ordinance #2024-29. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the motion was to approve Ordinance #2024-29 presented for its final reading. The ordinance addressed manufacturing, cultivation, and testing. She noted that it established where the uses can happen, supplementary regulations, and definitions.
Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Melson-Williams clarified that the ordinance would establish that the manufacturer's cultivation, facilities, manufacturing facilities, and testing would be allowed in the Manufacturing Zone (M). These same uses for the marijuana cultivation facilities, marijuana manufacturing facilities, and testing facilities would be allowed in the Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM Zone) and marijuana cultivation facilities in the Agricultural Zone (A). The ordinance further outlines the supplementary regulations and specific definitions for each land use category.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the ordinance addresses three specific land use activities: cultivation, manufacturing, and testing.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Townsend described the marijuana industry as a developing sector. She noted that Del-Tech offers a training program for the marijuana business industry. She also mentioned concerns raised by the commissioner’s office about mold, pesticides, and toxins in plants due to a lack of oversight in cultivation, as well as the concerns Mr. Neil raised about the fentanyl in the plants. While a PhD in chemistry is not required to work in the industry, some level of education and training is necessary.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Townsend stated that the initiative would provide an
Paj 41
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 11
opportunity to create jobs, though on a small scale.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend stated that waste from marijuana manufacturing is addressed in the regulations. While she is unsure of the specific disposal methods, she noted that such waste cannot simply be disposed of.
Dr. Sudler explained that he would be voting no, citing concerns that high demand from manufacturing could necessitate upgrades to the water system infrastructure, with the financial burden falling on the constituents.
Mr. Neil moved for the adoption of Ordinance #2024-29. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried, by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Lewis, Anderson), one (1) no (Sudler), Council adopted Ordinance #2024-29, as follows:
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 19 – Manufacturing Zone (M) be amended as follows:
Section 19. – Manufacturing Zone (M).
19.1 Uses permitted. No building or premises shall be used, and no building or part of a building shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any purpose, except the following, and in accordance with performance standards procedure as set forth in article 5, section 8 and subject to the site development plan approval as set forth in article 10, section 2:
19.17 Railroad yards, sidings, and storage facilities.
19.18 Marijuana cultivation facilities, marijuana manufacturing facilities, and marijuana testing facilities subject to the requirements outlined in article 5, section 24.
19.19 Accessory uses:
(a) On-site offices, clinics, food service facilities, recreation facilities and child day care services collocated within the permitted use and limited to exclusive use by employees, and such other accessory uses and structures clearly incidental to, and customary to and associated with the permitted use. (b) The following uses may be permitted as conditional uses if approved by the planning commission in accordance with the provisions and procedures set forth in article 10, section 1 and any specified requirements set forth below:
(1) Associated retail uses in conjunction with and accessory to a permitted use, provided that the associated retail uses do not occupy more than 30
Paj 42
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 12
percent of the gross floor area of the building or group of buildings on a lot. Parking shall be provided at a rate of one parking space per 300 square feet of retail space for the exclusive use of retail customers in addition to the bulk parking requirements of this zoning district for a particular use.
(2) Outside storage which is incidental to the primary uses on the lot, within a completely enclosed and secure area appropriately screened from public view and not in any required setback from property lines.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 20 – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM) be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
Section 20. – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM).
20.1 Uses permitted. No building or premises shall be used and no building or part of a building shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any purpose, except the following, and in accordance with performance standards procedure as set forth in article 5, section 8, and subject to site development plan approval as set forth in article 10, section 2:
20.19 Marijuana cultivation facilities, marijuana manufacturing facilities, and marijuana testing facilities, subject to the requirements outlined in Article 5, Section 24.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 23 – Agricultural Zone (A) be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
Section 23 - Agricultural Zone (A).
23.1 Uses Permitted. In an agricultural zone (A), no land or building shall be used and no building or part of a building shall be erected or altered which is arranged, intended or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any uses except the following:
23.17 Marijuana cultivation facilities, subject to the requirements outlined in Article 5, Section 24.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
Section 24. Marijuana Related Businesses.
Paj 43
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 13
24.1 Purpose. The purpose of this section is to protect public health and safety by applying standards under which marijuana related businesses may operate within the City of Dover, Delaware.
24.2 A compassion center is classified as retail use and is permitted in all commercial zones where retail uses are permitted.
24.3 Where permitted in accordance with Article 3, marijuana cultivation facilities are subject to the following restrictions:
24.31 The building footprint within which a marijuana cultivation facility is to be located shall be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, and any private or public K-12 school, hospital, college or university, child day care center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facility.
24.32 All marijuana cultivation facilities shall install odor control technology, as necessary, to control ventilation at the establishment in such a manner that no odor from cannabis products can be detected outside the building on the same property or on adjacent properties or in public rights-of-way, or within any other unit located within the same building. The facility owner/operator shall properly maintain all odor mitigation equipment to ensure maximum efficiency. An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a certification by a Professional Engineer, Certified Industrial Hygienist, or other equivalently qualified professional that proposed odor control measures will effectively eliminate outdoor odors associated with the cultivation of marijuana.
24.33 An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a photocopy of a valid license as required by Chapter 13, Title 4 of the Delaware State Code.
24.34 All building openings, entries and windows shall be located, covered or screened in such a manner as to prevent a view into the interior from any public or semipublic area.
24.35 The applicant is responsible for complying with the Code of Ordinances of the City of Dover, Delaware including all provisions in Chapter 110, Article II, Sec. 110-31 and Chapter 110, Article III, Sec. 110-63.
24.36 The applicant is responsible for all costs associated with infrastructure upgrades, alterations, changes, or extensions required to provide adequate water, wastewater, and electric utility service, including off-site upgrades required to support the demand for water, wastewater, and electric utility service.
24.4 Where permitted in accordance with Article 3, marijuana product manufacturing facilities are subject to the following restrictions:
Paj 44
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 14
24.41 The building footprint within which a marijuana product manufacturing facility is to be located shall be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, and from the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, hospital, college or university, child day care center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facility.
24.42 All marijuana product manufacturing facilities shall install odor control technology, as necessary, to control ventilation at the establishment in such a manner that no odor from cannabis products can be detected outside the building on the same property or on adjacent properties or in public rights-of-way, or within any other unit located within the same building. The facility owner/operator shall properly maintain all odor mitigation equipment to ensure maximum efficiency. An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a certification by a Professional Engineer, Certified Industrial Hygienist, or other equivalently qualified professional that proposed odor control measures will effectively eliminate outdoor odors associated with the manufacturing of marijuana.
24.43 An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a photocopy of a valid license as required by Chapter 13, Title 4 of the Delaware State Code.
24.44 All building openings, entries, and windows shall be located, covered, or screened in such a manner as to prevent a view into the interior from any public or semipublic area.
24.45 The applicant is responsible for complying with the Code of Ordinances of the City of Dover, Delaware including all provisions in Chapter 110, Article II, Sec. 110-31 and Chapter 110, Article III, Sec. 110-63.
24.46 The applicant is responsible for all costs associated with infrastructure upgrades, alterations, changes, or extensions required to provide adequate water, wastewater, and electric utility service, including off-site upgrades required to support the demand for water, wastewater, and electric utility service.
24.5 Where permitted in accordance with Article 3, marijuana testing facilities are subject to the following restrictions:
24.51 The building footprint upon which a marijuana testing facility is to be located shall be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, and from the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, hospital, child day care center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facility.
24.52 An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a photocopy of a valid license as required by Chapter 13, Title 4 of the Delaware State Code.
Paj 45
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 15 BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 12 – Definitions, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font in proper alphabetical order as follows:
Article 12. – Definitions.
Compassion center means an entity registered pursuant to § 4914A of Title 16 of the Delaware State Code that acquires, possesses, sells, supplies, or dispenses marijuana, paraphernalia, or related supplies and educational materials to registered qualifying patients who have designated the dispenser to cultivate marijuana for their medical use and the registered designated caregivers of these patients.
Marijuana cultivation facility or cultivation facility means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to cultivate, prepare, and package marijuana and sell marijuana to retail marijuana stores, to marijuana product manufacturing facilities, and to other marijuana cultivation facilities, but not to consumers. A marijuana cultivation facility may not produce marijuana concentrates, tinctures, extracts, or other marijuana products.
Marijuana product manufacturing facility means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to: purchase marijuana; manufacture, prepare, and package marijuana products; and sell marijuana and marijuana products to other marijuana product manufacturing facilities and retail marijuana stores, but not to consumers.
Marijuana testing facility means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to test marijuana for potency and contaminants.
ADOPTED: December 9, 2024
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-30 –
AMENDING APPENDIX B – ZONING, ARTICLE 3 – DISTRICT REGULATIONS, SEC. 16 – HIGHWAY COMMERCIAL ZONE (C-4), ARTICLE 5 – SUPPLEMENTARY REGULATIONS, SEC. 24 – MARIJUANA RELATED BUSINESSES, ARTICLE 12 – DEFINITIONS (FORMERLY PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-25B – RECREATIONAL MARIJUANA LAND USES AND ZONING: RETAIL MARIJUANA STORES) A public hearing was duly advertised for this time and place to consider approval of proposed zoning text amendments to Appendix B - Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 16 – Highway Commercial Zone (C-4); Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses; Article 12 – Definitions.
Mr. Neil moved that the Final Reading of proposed Ordinance #2024-30 be acknowledged by title only, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and unanimously carried. (The First Reading of the ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of October 28, 2024.)
Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, briefed the members of council on the proposed Ordinance #2024-30 – Amending Appendix B- Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section
Paj 46
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 16
16 – Highway Commercial Zone (C-4); Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 24 – Marijuana-Related Businesses; Article 12 – Definitions.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Townsend referred to the map and highlighted that the red areas that were not encumbered by a gray or yellow buffer were the areas where facilities could be located. She noted that the way the ordinance was written, a retail facility cannot be located within one (1) mile of another retail facility within the city. The ability to get more than three (3) facilities would be highly unlikely because the math would not work out by the time the distances were met.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Townsend stated that the limit on the number of retail licenses is six (6) for Kent County.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that in order to prohibit something in the zoning ordinance, it would need to be specifically listed in the zoning ordinance. If there were no provisions in place, for example, a retail store was to come to Dover, and they would have to look wherever retail establishments were allowed. There either needs to be an ordinance that places them in a specific zone with conditions, something that prohibits it, or they could choose not to do anything. She noted that not doing anything means they would have to look at it like any other retail establishment in the zoning ordinance because it was not specifically eliminated by that product type. Certain zones allow for retail that does have some prohibitions on their product type. If there is no action, then the interpretation would reside with the Planning Staff and the zoning ordinance.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Townsend concurred with Ms. Melson-Williams in the absence of addressing the use based on the type of product. She explained that it was basically what that use was, so manufacturing is considered manufacturing, and there are places in the zoning ordinance where, for example, someone could have retail, but they cannot sell gasoline. Ms. Townsend noted that unless it was expressly prohibited, it would fall to that use.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Townsend clarified that if an ordinance was not in place after December 31, 2024, the use could be permitted in any zone where retail was allowed.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend stated that if they wanted to extend the moratorium it would need to be published on the agenda in advance of a meeting.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson stated that he would not call for a special meeting. They have been doing this for two (2) years.
Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Townshend clarified that if nothing was done before the end of the year, then the retail sale of marijuana could be anywhere where retail sales were allowed, including downtown.
Council President Anderson declared the hearing open.
Mark Pugh, 728 Leipsic Road, addressed his concerns about the distance between the businesses, noting that similar rules do not apply to other establishments like gas stations or liquor stores. He
Paj 47
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 17
highlighted that those regulations seem inconsistent compared to state guidelines for distances from schools and churches. Mr. Pugh mentioned that he had received an offer on their property and implied the importance of the matter in that context. He emphasized the significance of the issue, agreeing with the council president that only six (6) licenses would be available across Kent County. He expressed skepticism about Dover obtaining all of them. Drawing on his own experience as a council member, he advised against imposing further restrictions, as the current limitations are already substantial. He urged council to amend the ordinance, either removing the additional restrictions entirely or aligning them with the state’s existing standards for schools and churches.
Michael Pillsbury, 141 Shinnecock Road, expressed support for businesses in Dover selling marijuana, highlighting Puffster as a suitable candidate. He noted that such businesses could boost foot traffic on Loockerman Street. Mr. Pillsbury referenced an article stating that in areas where marijuana has been legalized, teen usage has declined because legal access is more difficult for underage individuals compared to the black market.
Aaron Epstein, Chief Operating Officer of CannTech Research, operating as Best Buds in Dover, expressed gratitude for being part of the local business community and appreciated the council's thorough debate on the issue. He emphasized the importance of allowing their marijuana business to continue operating in the city, highlighting the job opportunities it creates. Operating for two years as a unionized shop, he pointed out that the industry promotes unionization, providing residents and constituents with benefits such as job security, health insurance, retirement plans, and other employee protections.
He highlighted the wide range of opportunities that the marijuana industry offers, benefiting a wide range of individuals, including veterans, recent college graduates, pharmacy technicians, former teachers, and even ex-police officers. He emphasized the industry's capacity to unite people from various disciplines into meaningful employment roles, such as scientists, laborers, and growers. Mr. Epstein stated that another benefit to the program was designed to stamp out the black market largely in its implementation and what they have seen in other states was that when the practice of retail is banned, they are promoting the black market.
Mr. Epstein addressed safety concerns and discussions that there would be violence or there might not be enough ambulances, police officers, or the fire department to handle the influx of crime that would come about from allowing businesses to operate. He stated that it was not true. He pointed out the successful integration of marijuana businesses in cities like Newark, Jersey City, Hoboken, and Paterson, New Jersey, where no significant issues have arisen after two years of legalization. He criticized opponents for spreading fear and adopting a "not in my backyard" mindset, advocating instead for a safe and regulated environment in Dover.
Lachelle Paul, 501 Silverside Drive, expressed concerns about legalizing marijuana in relation to fentanyl overdoses, as Mr. Neil had previously stated. She highlighted that New Street averages about two overdoses per week involving illegal drugs. She emphasized the dangers of not knowing the contents of illegal drugs. While acknowledging that marijuana is now legal, she questioned whether individuals already using drugs would travel 20-30 minutes for legal purchases when they could easily obtain substances around the street corner. She directed her concerns to Chief Johnson, asking for statistics on marijuana drug use and the impact of the
Paj 48
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 18
black market. She suggested that understanding current black-market trends and incorporating those numbers, how would help with those statistics if they made it legal.
Responding to Ms. Paul, Chief Johnson noted that her question would be a lot to unpack and in the interest of brevity, the greater Dover, because it is one of those situations where in the profession, they call crime that occurs across jurisdictional lines. He explained that while Dover has a significant drug market, some of it is nearby, while most of it comes from far away. The idea of the network of illicit drug distribution at times is complex. He clarified that his earlier comments about potential concerns were not intended to be alarmist but from someone who has dialed into the intel of the conditions that they have there. Chief Johnson stated that it was not necessarily persuaded that one (1) or two (2) retail establishments to speak to the issue of the statistics of what they would encounter in law enforcement would move the needle that much.
Comparing marijuana retail establishments to alcohol distribution centers, he suggested similar issues could arise, such as loitering or solicitation. Chief Johnson does not necessarily believe that adding legal retail in the city would solve juvenile consumption. He offered to provide supporting data in the future, should council request it.
EShed Alston, 406 Arnold Court, shared his personal experience with the street-level marijuana trade, emphasizing its reality as an economic resource and supporting efforts to regulate and redirect the associated money into legitimate channels. He acknowledged the existence of the black market and recognized it would continue to compete with legal establishments but argued that regulation provides a better alternative for managing the industry.
Mr. Alston defended Councilman Hare’s concerns as legitimate and expressed support for legal marijuana businesses despite potential competition. He highlighted the importance of ensuring that communities of color, often at the forefront of street-level trade, have opportunities to participate in the legal industry, referencing promises made during legalization discussions.
He called for prioritizing education and outreach to younger users, advocating for a "teach one, reach one" approach to guide them toward safer, regulated products. Mr. Alston urged the council to begin meaningful discussions that focus not just on immediate concerns but on long- term benefits for future generations.
Cindy Christiansen, 714 Carroll Street, identifying as someone who does not use marijuana, raised several concerns about its legalization and regulation. She criticized the lack of clear enforcement mechanisms, fines, and ordinances at both state and local levels, citing examples of public consumption violations in Dover, such as smoking on sidewalks and in cars. She expressed doubts about the police force's ability to address these issues effectively, including the capacity to test marijuana intoxication.
While she supported medical marijuana dispensaries requiring prescriptions, she opposed opening dispensaries to the public, arguing it wouldn't prevent issues like fentanyl contamination. Ms. Christiansen emphasized the dangers of fentanyl-laced products and questioned the inconsistency in distancing requirements, pointing out that cultivation facilities must be 700 feet from schools while retail locations need only be 500 feet away. She also expressed frustration that churches were not considered in zoning regulations, despite their
Paj 49
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 19
activities during the week.
Ms. Christiansen referenced other cities like Dewey Beach rejecting marijuana sales and argued that Dover, as the capital of the first state, should follow suit. She concluded by opposing the legalization of public dispensaries, advocating instead of stricter regulations, and rejecting marijuana sales in the city.
Eric Czerwinski, 34 Maple Lane, raised concerns about the high-security requirements for marijuana businesses, suggesting that such establishments are not suitable neighbors and could attract crime. He highlighted the differences between medicinal and recreational marijuana sales, noting that recreational sales would bring significantly increased foot traffic and related challenges. Drawing comparisons to experiences in states like Colorado and California, he argued that legal retail sales often fail to eliminate the black market due to high costs, with many consumers continuing to buy from illegal sources.
He warned of potential issues such as drug dealers loitering in retail parking lots, increased crime along major corridors like DuPont Highway, and the stigma associated with marijuana sales, which could deter other businesses from investing nearby. He also expressed concerns about straw buyers enabling underage access to marijuana and noted that any potential revenue from sales would likely be offset by increased enforcement costs. Mr. Czerwinski concluded by urging the council to vote against allowing retail marijuana sales in Dover and Kent County, presenting it as a straightforward decision to protect the community.
Dina Vendetti, 435 North DuPont Highway, representing the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce, reiterated her opposition to the retail sale of marijuana in Dover. She emphasized that the Chamber had consulted with chamber executives from across the country, particularly from cities where marijuana retail has already been implemented, to learn from their experiences. She shared several concerns, notably that the legalization of marijuana retail led to increased illicit drug use and a rise in crime.
She noted that the black market did not disappear but instead grew due to the high costs of marijuana in dispensaries, with drug dealers often congregating in parking lots of legal retail facilities. The majority of those she spoke with across various cities, including Denver, Portland, and Atlantic City, advised against allowing retail marijuana sales, citing negative impacts on crime and community welfare. She also emphasized that restricting marijuana sales could help a community grow economically and become a more attractive destination rather than a pass- through area. Ms. Vendetti reaffirmed the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce's position against the retail sale of marijuana, urging the council to consider the lessons learned from other areas that have already experienced these challenges.
Scott Kidner, 3 Shinnecock Road, reiterated his strong opposition to the proposed marijuana retail sales ordinance. He shared a recent experience at Elizabeth W. Murphey School’s Christmas gift-wrapping event, where he spoke with Michael Kopp, Executive Director, who expressed concerns about the city's decision to legalize marijuana sales. Mr. Kidner highlighted the challenges faced by the 26 young people at Elizabeth W. Murphey School, suggesting that introducing legal marijuana sales would make it harder for them and other residents by glorifying drug use and making it more accessible.
Paj 50
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 20
He argued that the decision to allow marijuana sales would negatively impact the progress made by the Downtown Dover Partnership in revitalizing the area, fearing it would deter people from coming to the city. Mr. Kidner emphasized that the issue is not about access, money, or taxes but about the type of community Dover wants to be. He urged the council to reconsider the ordinance, suggesting that allowing marijuana sales would make the city a place where people "walk to get their drugs," which he believed would harm the city's reputation and future growth.
Bill Winters, 117 Loockerman Street, expressed opposition to the retail sale of marijuana. He raised concerns about the current widespread public marijuana use, noting that it is already a problem in the city, particularly in the downtown area. Mr. Winters emphasized that the police force struggles to enforce existing laws around public marijuana use and that allowing retail sales would exacerbate the issue. He described how, during events like the St. Patrick's Day parade, marijuana use was persistent, with the smell infiltrating businesses and affecting those with health conditions. (Exhibit #2)
Mr. Winters pointed out the challenges faced by businesses in downtown Dover due to the existing marijuana use and argued that retail sales would undermine the city's revitalization efforts. He emphasized the importance of the vision for downtown Dover's future, which he believes would be threatened by the legalization of marijuana retail sales. Mr. Winters voiced his opposition to retail sales both in the downtown area and along major highways, stressing that the city's progress and revitalization efforts would be compromised.
Jun Xu, White Oak, explained that he moved to the area seeking a safer, higher quality of life for his children. He expressed concern over the proximity of marijuana retail stores to residential areas, particularly with a 500-foot buffer, questioning how such proximity would affect families and children. Mr. Xu was unclear on how the buffer zones work and worried about the pervasive smell of marijuana and its impact on the community. He emphasized the desire for a clean, safe environment for his children and hoped that the council would make a wise decision in consideration of the community's wellbeing.
Joan Denney, 350 North State Street, and the vice chair of the Dover Planning Commission, shared her opposition to the retail sale of marijuana. She explained that she made the motion at the planning commission meeting to simply "say no" to marijuana, reflecting her concerns about its potential impact on the city. While she might have been okay with restricting marijuana sales to the highway, she strongly opposed its presence downtown, especially with the upcoming investments in downtown development. Ms. Denney highlighted the efforts to revitalize Downtown Dover and expressed her belief that allowing marijuana retail sales in the area would undermine those efforts. She and her husband, who enjoy visiting downtown for local events and dining, were concerned about the negative effects such a decision might have on the community's vibrancy.
Ms. Denney continued her remarks by emphasizing that she didn't believe downtown Dover, particularly areas like Lockerman Street, was an appropriate location for retail marijuana sales. She stressed that events like St. Patrick's Day exemplified the potential for downtown Dover to thrive with community activities and foot traffic, and the addition of marijuana sales would not be beneficial for its growth. Ms. Denney expressed a preference for not having marijuana sales at
Paj 51
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 21
all but suggested that if retail marijuana was allowed, it should only be permitted on the highway, rather than in the downtown area. She also voiced concerns about the growing disregard for laws, referencing her background in law enforcement, and suggested that once marijuana retail sales were allowed, it would be difficult to reverse the decision.
There being no one else present wishing to speak, Council President Anderson declared the public hearing closed.
Dr. Pillsbury made a motion for the Recreational Marijuana Ordinance Amendment #2, the building footprint within which a retail marijuana store is to be located shall be at least 500 feet from the lot line of any other retail marijuana store within the City of Dover. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson stated that several buffers would not be qualified. If they look at the map and ignore the grayed-out areas, the red would be in that area with that buffer.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Townsend stated that by looking at the map, there could be potentially a few more locations on the east side of the highway, if the one (1) mile was off, particularly as it gets closer to Leipsic Road and North State Street.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Townsend stated that there looks to be potentially two (2) locations if they go north of Best Buds and possibly one if they go south if the mile is taken off.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend clarified that the Town of Smyrna has already implemented ordinances for marijuana sales, treating them in a manner similar to liquor stores. She also mentioned that the City of Milford is currently in the process of developing its ordinances regarding marijuana, with two versions of the ordinance pending. One version would be a prohibition on retail marijuana sales, while the other would allow it as a conditional use.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend stated that as of right now, it is only for medical purposes, but facilities are eligible for a conversion license, which means that they would be able to sell retail as well.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend stated that the new location would be within one mile of an existing location, so it would apply to future locations.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend stated that as the ordinance was written, Best Buds would be grandfathered in. If nothing has passed, they would have two (2) weeks where there would be no rules in effect. The question would be if property owners come in requesting the ability to open something, what would the city do? She does not know that they can administratively put it on hold until the ordinances are approved. She noted that there was a pending ordinance doctrine where if there was a pending ordinance, they would not approve of something contrary to it.
Responding to Ms. Townsend, Mr. Rodriguez clarified that if an ordinance was pending approval, actions that would conflict with the potential ordinance should not be approved.
Paj 52
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 22
Ms. Arndt stated that this would be the first time that they would be seeing the change from one (1) mile to 500 feet and that the maps were based on the information presented. To her understanding, the 500 feet is consistent with other buffers within the ordinance, but if they have come that far with one (1) mile in the ordinance, she would not be comfortable with changing it via an amendment.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Anderson stated that if they do not allow retail, then they would not be allowed to do the conversion license, and it has been said that they would shut their doors and move their jobs.
Dr. Pillsbury expressed concerns about losing a business in Dover when the business has already invested a tremendous amount of money in security and everything. She noted that it does not make any sense to pass an ordinance that would put them out of business. Dr. Pillsbury stated that the first thing they should do was to approve the ordinance and then work on the amendments.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Anderson stated that parliamentary-wise, they could not do that.
Dr. Pillsbury noted that she has concerns about shutting down the ordinance and not allowing retail sales in the city.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Townsend clarified that the ordinance currently being considered permits retail sales only in the C-4 zone. If the property of Mr. Pugh was in a different zoning classification, it would not be allowed under the proposed ordinance.
Mr. Anderson stated that according to the Kent County Pride server, Mr. Pugh’s property is currently zoned C-4.
Ms. Townsend stated that there are properties that are used residentially but are not zoned in a residential zone. The ordinance specifies a residential zone.
Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the apartments off Route 13 have a shopping center zone because it was related to the neighboring parcel on DuPont Highway.
Ms. Townsend clarified that there would be no distance required from the apartments off Route 13 because they are not in a residential zone.
Dr. Pillsbury made a motion for Amendment #2 that the building footprint to be within which a retail marijuana store is to be located shall be at least 500 feet from the lot line of any other retail marijuana store within the City of Dover. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson and failed by a roll call vote of four (4) yes (Boggerty, Pillsbury, Lewis, Anderson), and five (5) no (Hare, Neil, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler).
Dr. Sudler stated on record that he wanted to initially say yes but voted no due to concerns from constituents and uncertainty about the potential future impact.
Paj 53
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 23
Mr. Neil moved to approve the Ordinance #2024-30. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt.
Mr. Rocha stated that the only reason why he considered the ordinance and personally felt that this had nothing to do with what was discussed. He worked in anti-drug prevention for several years, as a mobilizer and knows what the effects are. As a mobilizer, Mr. Rocha stated that he had studied instances that have occurred in other cities and states, such as Denver, Colorado, and Portland. He agreed with Dr. Dina Vendetti's concerns and leaned in favor of Ms. Christiansen's statement. Mr. Rocha stated on record that he was going to stand with those who were against the retail sale of marijuana in the city.
Mr. Boggerty stated that he was challenged due to people who are against having concerns which make those concerns his own. He noted that the smell would not go away, whether it be recreational or bought from the street. He expressed concerns about individuals incarcerated for low-level marijuana offenses. Mr. Boggerty stated that individuals are incarcerated strictly for marijuana distribution and that was a way to feed their families.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Anderson clarified that the ordinance could be revisited and adjusted over time to address emerging issues.
Mr. Hare apologized to the constituents but expressed that he did not see any benefit to the city from the proposed ordinance. He pointed out that the city is not generating revenue from it and believes it would lead to additional issues. As a result, Mr. Hare stated that he would not be able to support the ordinance based on the discussions held that evening.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson clarified that marijuana would remain legal regardless of the council's decision. The issue at hand was determining how it would be regulated within the city.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Anderson stated that the part of the ordinance that specifically allowed the business to convert as the ordinance is currently. If the ordinance passes, there would be no such concern.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Anderson explained that if the ordinance failed, a new ordinance would need to go through the legislative process, including committee review, first reading, second reading, and so on. He noted that if Best Buds license to convert was granted during that time they would likely be grandfathered in, and it would be unreasonable not to do so. However, if their license to convert was not granted, their status would depend on the provisions of the new future ordinance.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Epstein explained that their application process for conversion was thorough, similar to that of a standard applicant. This included detailing general operations like product dispensing and facility security, as well as providing extensive narratives on protecting the current patient population, serving both adult-use customers and medical patients, and supporting social equity applicants and programs. These plans were submitted to the commissioner’s office, and the conversion was officially approved. He further clarified that any potential closure would not result from regulatory decisions but from economic challenges.
Paj 54
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 24
Following the legalization of adult-use cannabis in nearby states like Maryland and Delaware, fewer people are registering for medical cannabis programs. While medical products are tax- advantaged, costs such as card renewals and doctor’s fees reduce incentives to maintain medical registrations. Mr. Epstein noted that this shift has made it financially unsustainable to operate solely as a medical cannabis facility, putting the business at risk of closure due to economic pressures.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Townsend stated that she had discussed the situation with the Commissioner’s Office regarding Best Buds. While the business has been approved for a license, the office would not issue it until verification was provided that the use is permitted. She noted that if marijuana was not allowed in Dover, the city would not be able to provide the verification that it was permitted, which could jeopardize the issuance of their license.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Townsend clarified that they would still be allowed for medical only, but the market would not support it.
Responding to Mr. Hare, Mr. Anderson clarified that they would not have to come up with something else if the ordinance did not pass. He noted that if they did not have something, then it would put them in a situation like the Town of Smyrna was in, where any appropriate retail avenue could open up a marijuana shop and it would be like a smoker/vape shop.
Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Townsend stated that if the ordinance were voted down, the current moratorium would remain in effect until December 31, 2024. She noted that if the council's goal was to prohibit marijuana, they would need to introduce a specific ordinance to that effect and follow the necessary process.
Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Townsend stated that potentially anyone with a retail shop could sell marijuana, but it would require them to go through the state to get the license.
Responding to Ms. Townsend, Mr. Hare believed that the decision being voted on that night was final, but since it was not, they would have voted differently to keep the 500-foot requirement along the corridor Route 13.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that council was considering an amendment that would change a distancing requirement related to retail marijuana stores. The amendment was to an ordinance that was proposed #2024-30 that establishes where retail marijuana stores could happen in the City of Dover. The ordinance aims to designate retail marijuana stores as permitted use in the C-4 zoning district, which would cover the areas along DuPont Highway and the Bay Road Corridor. Ms. Melson-Williams emphasized that without the ordinance, the zoning ordinance would be silent, potentially allowing retail marijuana stores to open in any zone where retail businesses would be allowed, without considering the type of product being sold.
Dr. Sudler stated that based on the majority of his constituents that have voiced their opinion on the matter they do not support the legalization of marijuana in the State of Delaware. He noted that the constituents prefer that there would be a safe pathway to a healthier alternative to cannabis usage, that would be free from the fear of lethal dosage of fentanyl.
Paj 55
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 25
Mr. Lewis called the question on the motion.
Mr. Hare moved to reconsider the proposed amendment #2. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried with Mr. Rocha voting no.
Mr. Hare moved to approve the amendment #2 of Ordinance #2024-30. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a roll call vote of six (6) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Pillsbury, Sudler, Lewis, Anderson) and three (3) no (Neil, Arndt, Rocha)
Mr. Anderson voted yes because 60% of the people in the city stated what direction they wanted to go. He believed that they could save people from dying from contaminated marijuana by having a legal alternative available.
Mr. Hare moved for the adoption of Ordinance #2024-30 as amended. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried, by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Sudler, Lewis, Anderson), one (1) no (Rocha), Council adopted Ordinance #2024-30, as follows:
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 16 – Highway Commercial Zone (C-4) be amended as follows:
Section 16. Highway Commercial Zone (C-4).
16.1 Uses permitted. In a highway commercial zone (C-4), no building or premises shall be used, and no building or part of a building shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any purpose, except the following:
(q) Retail marijuana stores, subject to the requirements outlined in Article 5, Section 24.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
24.6 Where permitted in accordance with Article 3, retail marijuana stores are subject to the following restrictions:
24.61 The building footprint upon which a retail marijuana store is to be located shall be at least 500 feet away from any private or public K-12 school, child daycare center, State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment
Paj 56
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 26
facility, hospital, and at least 250 feet away from any residential zone, and from the lot line of any college or university.
24.62 The building footprint within which a retail marijuana store is to be located shall be at least 1 mile away from the lot line of any other retail marijuana store within the City of Dover.
24.63 An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a photocopy of a valid license as required by Chapter 13, Title 4 of the Delaware State Code.
24.64 All building openings, entries, and windows shall be located, covered, or screened in such a manner as to prevent a view into the interior from any public or semipublic area.
24.7 A Compassion Center licensed by the State of Delaware on or before January 1, 2024, that obtains a conversion license under the State of Delaware Marijuana Regulations, must comply with the requirements of Article 3 District Regulations, and shall be exempt from distancing requirements detailed in Appendix B- Zoning, Article 5- Supplementary Regulations, 24.61 and 24.62.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 12 – Definitions, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font in proper alphabetical order as follows:
Article 12. – Definitions.
Retail marijuana store means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to purchase marijuana from marijuana cultivation facilities; to purchase marijuana and marijuana products from marijuana product manufacturing facilities; and to sell marijuana and marijuana products to consumers.
ADOPTED: December 9, 2024
Mr. Hare voted yes due to not wanting marijuana to be able to be opened in the Downtown Dover Business District.
Mr. Boggerty voted yes so, they can have control of the retail of marijuana within the city and not allow others to make decisions for them.
Dr. Pillsbury voted yes to protect the businesses that currently exist.
Ms. Arndt voted yes because they had done their due diligence.
Dr. Sudler voted yes because he believed that this would be a safer pathway to any marijuana usage free from the legal dosage of fentanyl. He noted that he does not want it downtown as his
Paj 57
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 27
constituents have expressed their concerns, so he was voicing their concerns. His vote was based on his constituents.
Mr. Hare noted that his understanding is that if the ordinance did not pass marijuana retail sales could be in the city anywhere retail sales are allowed.
Mr. Anderson stated that Mr. Hare was correct.
Dr. Sudler stated he would like to add Mr. Hares's comment to his reason for voting yes as well.
ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of November 25, 2024, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Anderson, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT OF –
NOVEMBER 26, 2024
The Council Committee of the Whole met on November 26, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis (in at 6:15 p.m.), Mr. Neil, and Mr. Rocha (via WebEx). Dr. Pillsbury and Dr. Sudler were absent. Mayor Christiansen (out at 8:16 p.m.) was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Dr. Jackson-Short (via WebEx), Ms. Smack (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation), Mr. Iriowen, Mr. Wilson (Utility), Mr. Garfinkel, and Mr. Shevock (Legislative, Finance, and Administration).
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Citizen Problem Reporter – Council Dashboard Training (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager) Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, reviewed the proposed Citizen Problem Reporter website created for council to track citizen concerns in real- time.
This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Duca stated that she would work with Mike Walker, GIS Manager, to add the mayor’s office to the city manager's office in the system. Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Duca stated that the website would be an internal application that is used by internal staff. Currently, the only people able to enter concerns are herself, the City Clerk and the Assistant City Clerk to limit the number of people entering items.
Paj 58
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 28
SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairman Boggerty presiding.
Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and
unanimously carried.
Discussion – Safety and Relationship Between the City of Dover Police Department and Delaware State University (James Overton, Vice President of Student Affairs, and Delaware State University Police Superintendent) Mr. James Overton, Vice President of Student Affairs, and Delaware State University Police Superintendent, detailed the relationship that Delaware State University has with the City of Dover Police Department.
Mr. Overton explained that he oversees the entire university police department which is led by Police Chief Donald Baynard. He explained that upon his return, he established a Memorandum of Understanding with the Dover Police Department to outline the partnership in addressing issues both on campus and off campus. He stated that they can proudly say that through their partnership they have not had one incident that has gone unsolved.
Mr. Overton stated that all their officers attend the Dover Police Department Academy and when the university lacked officers, the City of Dover Police Department stepped up and helped fill in the gaps. He explained that Homecoming 2023 was a homecoming that he will never forget and for 2024 he was able to work with Dover Police Department, DelDOT, Fire Marshal, and County members to have a mostly incident-free homecoming. He thanked the Dover Police Department for their cherished relationship.
Chief Johnson, Dover Police Department, commended Mr. Overton for his hard work and willingness to foster a relationship with the City of Dover Police Department. He explained that Mr. Overton has been very proactive in addressing issues such as homecoming and fostering a plan to prevent any incidents. Chief Johnson stated that some of the fluidness can be attributed to training together in both the academy and drills hosted by the university.
This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Overton stated that they immediately worked on a solution to put a stop to the parties being held in the parks. He explained that the university does not schedule any events off campus. He stated that they have told students that if they participate in the events and represent a fraternity or sorority, and they are found to be involved, they will be held responsible on campus. Mr. Overton explained that they got word of a larger party being planned, called in the organizations, and let them know that the parties reflect poorly on the university to the City of Dover as well as the County and they needed to encourage their
Paj 59
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 29
organizations to not participate in the parties. He further explained that they have begun to monitor social media to where students, and people from outside areas like Philadelphia, and Washington D.C. are advertising parties. Through this work, they have been able to shut them down and establish a presence before the parties begin.
Discussion – Capital School District Community Concerns Update (Sean Christiansen, Capital School District Board of Education, Vice President) Mr. Sean Christiansen, Capital School District Board of Education, Vice President, explained that on October 29, 2024, Bishop Lott had brought forth concerns regarding Capital School District students and their downtown Dover bus stops.
Mr. Christiansen explained that an onsite meeting was scheduled for October 31, 2024, with Councilman Boggerty, Mayor Christiansen, Dr. Cahoon, Ms. Hamm, Officer Piazza, a member of community policing, himself, and Bishop Lott. He stated that they walked the area to identify the issues, which were primarily at New Street and Reed Street. After that, the Capital School District began rerouting the buses for the elementary school, the middle school, and the high school. An email went out to the people present at the onsite visit, the routes were approved, and they were communicated to the parents as well as the school. The new routes went into effect on November 13, 2024, and as of November 26, 2024, there had been no issues and there was an overwhelming response from the parents expressing gratitude.
Mr. Christiansen requested that council have more open lines of communication with the board if they have any issues that affect the Capital School District. He explained that the board likes to be proactive and get things done rather quickly. This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
Mr. Boggerty moved for adjournment of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:33 p.m.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Anderson and unanimously carried.
Discussion – Stormwater Utility Billing Concerns (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager) Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Stormwater Utility billing concerns.
This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
Paj 60
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 30
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that the last financial policy adjustment was made in 2019. She explained that the bond ratings are adhering to the bond covenants and therefore are adhering to the adjustments made to the financial policy at that time. As far as transfers are concerned, the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) states that the funds must be used for their designated purpose. Therefore, the funds must be specifically used for the electric fund and not any other fund. She explained that the stormwater utility is its own enterprise fund and the funds from the electric reserve should not be used to fund the stormwater utility.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney clarified that the reserve balance for the rate stabilization reserve cannot exceed twenty percent of the purchase power cost in any given year. She explained that she spoke with the bond counsel regarding the depreciation reserve and the financial policy dictates that the depreciation reserve needs to have a minimum balance of $10 million per bond. As of 2017, the city must maintain at least $13.6 million. She explained that there are some other things that must be considered and one of them is the payback. There is a seven-year payback period therefore if those funds were chosen to fund the process they would need to be paid back. She stated that she does not advise using those funds, but it is possible according to bond counsel as long as it does not dip below $13.6 million. She also explained that with a depreciation reserve, the specific funds are to be used for utility capital projects, specifically electric fund utility capital projects, not other enterprise fund capital projects. Lastly, she explained in speaking with Mr. Paul Wadell, Electric Director, that there is approximately $10.5 million in capital projects that will be brought forward in fiscal year 2026. By removing the proposed $5 million from the reserve he would be limited in the projects he could move forward with such as the smart metering and he would have to put that project off for several years.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that he is correct in saying that if any money is utilized from the electric fund and it brings the city below the 10 percent threshold the interest rates would potentially be high because the rates at which the city receives a loan could be compromised.
Ms. Marney also explained that any time funds are taken from the electric reserve there is a direct impact on the electric rates. The citizens will either be paying through a stormwater utility rate or the electric rate.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that if council were to use the money from the economic and community development fund, council would have to adjust the motion that was already made to designate the purpose of those funds. She also emphasized that those funds are one-time funds, so if they are not being used to invest in something else or pay operational costs they are only going to help for a limited amount of time.
Paj 61
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 31
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Duca stated that he is correct in that the concept of the stormwater utility is not new.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney stated that the city produces about 13,301 tax bills a year.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney confirmed that number roughly represents 58 percent of the properties in the City of Dover.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney stated that they estimated that it would add between 10 and 15 cents more to the tax rate.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Duca stated that the formula to establish the fees was from a model generated by a consultant starting back in 2015. She explained that it had been modified over the years by the consultant and staff to improve the accuracy. The model based residential on their zoning district and the commercial was based upon impervious maps from the state.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney stated that he is correct in that if they go the route of taxation to cover the total expenses, 58 percent of the homeowners and businesses will incur a possible nine-and-a-half cent increase on their taxes while anyone in the city who is tax exempt will not.
Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Marney stated that in the past they would include a reassessment fee to pay the assessment company, which happens to be the same as the County uses, Tyler Technologies. She explained that when Ms. Bundek retired, the recommendation to the council was that at the appropriate time, the city would use the County’s assessment values, and the next city assessment happens to be in January 2025. She stated that there will be some cost savings in the general fund for fiscal year 2026 regarding the reassessment.
Mr. Hare moved to set the stormwater utility rate to zero, transfer funds to pay for it from the electric depreciation reserve fund in the amount of $5 million and also find a way to refund or credit the money that people have already paid. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson.
Mike Harrington, 516 Jefferic Boulevard, Dover, stated that small businesses are suffering because of the new assessments, insurance rates are constantly on the rise, and then the stormwater utility. He explained that several of his tenants owe him thousands of dollars because they are suffering. He stated that if someone has a large parking lot, like himself, the stormwater fees were a large increase and passing them on to the tenants is hard when they are barely making it as it is. Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that they have not specifically asked any of the state legislators for help in funding the stormwater utility.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that if the money is taken from the electric reserve, then the city will either have to raise taxes or the electric rates.
Paj 62
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 32
She added that there are certain legal and regulatory requirements when funds are involved. The electric fund is restricted to being used for the electric utility. In the financial policies, it does say that a certain percentage or dollar amount can be transferred. The current dollar amount for the inter-fund transfer from the electric fund to the general fund, which is specified in the policy that it cannot be other funds, is $10 million. The city has reached that cap for fiscal year 2025. She explained that Mr. Lewis is correct in that there could be long-term implications in using the funds from the deprecation reserve and not repaying them. She emphasized that there would be a cost associated which may be in the form of a tax rate increase or an electric utility rate increase. Taking anything from the electric reserve means staff will have to go back to the rate study and the professionals that assist with that and modify the rate study and rate structure that is currently in place for the electric fund. Those changes would then affect anyone who receives an electric bill. She explained that the expenses would still exist whether they are in the general fund or a stand-alone stormwater fund because they are mandated. She also emphasized that if they are not paid there are significant fines. According to the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit there is a fine of $10,000 a day if the city does not comply with the permit.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that she would have to speculate how long it would take for the city to return to a value that would give them a better interest rate if they were to need to purchase a large piece of equipment. She stated that in talking to Paul Waddell, two transformers will need to be replaced next year, costing $2 million apiece. Taking money from a specific reserve that is in place to cover in the case of an emergency is not recommended. If something drastic happens such as a hurricane or tornado and electric utility items need to be replaced, the reserve has then been depleted. She also explained that the wording implies that there must be reserves equal to the depreciation expense. For example, the depreciation for fiscal year 2024 may be $ 4 million. Fiscal year 2025 may also be $4 million. So based on the estimation that there is $21 million, the city must keep at least $18.7 million. Even though the bond covenants say the city can go down to $13.6 million it would be best to leave $19 million, leaving a $3 million reserve for emergencies.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that if the stormwater utility were to be paid from taxes it would have required a nine-to-ten-cent increase on the tax bill. When the budget was prepared for the year, it was prepared with the understanding that the stormwater utility would have its own enterprise fund, therefore funding itself. In doing that the city was able to keep the tax increase down to around two cents and by adjusting other fees at a modest rate. Had that not been done there would have been a need for substantially more funding. Ms. Marney stated that there could be legal replications by transferring funds from one enterprise fund to another. She asked that they return the stormwater utility expenses to the general fund to aid in the regulatory requirements that are in the financial policies. She explained that a few years ago during the budgetary process, council voted to extend the inter-fund transfer from the electric fund to
Paj 63
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 33
the general fund. The transfer was increased from $10 million to $12 million. She stated that in the financial policies, through the budgetary process, they must find a solution in three years, next year will be three years. They will have to find a solution to the increasing costs and increasing expenses versus the lower revenues. In closing, she stated that there would be fewer regulatory issues if the money is pulled from the general fund rather than being transferred from one enterprise fund to another.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney stated that he was correct and that the electric rates would need to be adjusted to replenish the funds. Part of the rate studies is that all the reserves and all the draws come from the reserves in the electric fund. If more is drawn than is typically planned through the financial policy, then the future use of the electric revenue is affected. According to financial policy, the reserves from the electric revenue must be replenished, which has a direct impact on the electric rates.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney confirmed that if the money is transferred back into the fund, during the 2026 budget consideration, the expenses for the current wastewater utility will have to be added in the form of taxes.
George Gaudioso, 167 Maple Glen Drive, Dover, stated that he is the President of the Maple Glen Homeowners Association. He explained that the individual owners, as well as the homeowner’s association, received the invoices in varying amounts. Mr. Gaudioso stated that his biggest concern was that, in 2014, Kent County set up a Stormwater Maintenance District (SWMD) to maintain the ponds. He explained that they are one of the original homeowner associations that joined and have been members ever since. Kent County Conservation District monitors the pond, and they pay a lot of money to Enviro Tech to make sure the pond is functioning and treated properly. He stated that the invoices were improperly constructed, and many people thought that the charge was a one-time yearly charge. He explained that they must take the invoice and multiply it by four and that would be what they must pay yearly. Mr. Gaudioso expressed frustration with the information on the website as well as the appeal process. He explained that to file an appeal the homeowner’s association would need to hire a civil engineer and incur the cost of doing so. He expressed frustration with doing the right thing in their community through Kent County and then being hit with an additional fee.
Jeff Wark, 612 Mary Street, Dover, stated that as one of the owners of Teal Construction, their property taxes would have gone up two hundred and fifty percent with the utility fee. He expressed dissatisfaction with the ordinance when it came to the impervious versus pervious areas. He stated that the impervious and pervious areas are not consistent with what they deal with in their line of business. He explained that their entire property was considered impervious, and they currently had two to three feet of stone gravel on about seventy percent of their property.
Paj 64
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 34
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Wark stated that the property taxes would be around $5,000 and the annual stormwater fee would have been around $13,000.
Mr. Wark stated that they started the appeal process with a civil engineer, but the engineer stopped working on it because the definition in the ordinance considered anything that had been driven on once would be considered impervious therefore the engineer stopped the process.
Mr. Neil moved to amend that the stormwater utility go back to the general fund for the time being and to allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt.
Ms. Arndt clarified that Mr. Neil was stating that he would like to take the stormwater enterprise fund and transfer that back to the general fund and allow the opportunity to make the transfer from the electric fund to the general fund as an interim measure, if necessary. He also recommended revisiting the enterprise fund to reevaluate and make any necessary corrections.
Mr. Neil confirmed that was his intention so that next year it can be done correctly.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Neil stated that the original motion included figuring out how to credit those who had paid or return the money paid. Ms. Marney stated that she spoke with Ms. Haines, and she devised a plan that if anyone has already made the payment on their account, the money will be credited back to them either through a credit balance refund or credit to their utility bill. Those who have not paid will have the bill adjusted, if moved by council.
Mr. Neil moved to amend that the stormwater utility go back to the general fund for the time being and to allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried with Mr. Lewis abstaining.
Mr. Hare moved to set the stormwater utility rate to zero, transfer the stormwater utility back to the general fund for the time being, allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time, and find a way to refund or credit the money that people have already paid. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried with Mr. Lewis abstaining.
During the council meeting, Dr. Sudler requested an update from staff.
Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, stated that with regards to the EPA grant, the sewer overflow and stormwater reuse municipal grant that was researched was approved by the EPA on May 9, 2024. All records regarding what they have been able to find on
Paj 65
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 35
the grant show that it was going to be transmitted to the state in order to be administered and based upon their discussions with DNREC, they have not received any funds yet to open up a grant cycle.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca stated they had not received any details on an estimated timeframe.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca stated that they could reach out and try to find contact numbers. She explained that it was noted in the memo that the grants do not pay for operation costs, which would be personnel costs or other material, which would equate to about $1.2 million of the budget. The way they have been administered was since they include combined sewers and sanitary sewers, the money would be going to compete with wastewater flows. Ms. Duca noted that there would be a level of competition to try to get it, but it was still something they could look at timing for.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca mentioned that many of the local municipalities charge stormwater fees, and some municipalities have a stormwater utility like Newark does, which is the model they follow, and other municipalities have them contained within their general fund as they used to. She explained that Dover has experienced an increase in costs for departments that are under the general fund, such as the Police Department, Public Works, Streets, Finance, and Central Services. All the general fund service costs have been increasing over the years and by looking at the expenses and revenues through the budgetary documents, the expenses have slowly increased revenues since the 2019 Fiscal Year. Ms. Duca stated that the expenses had exceeded the revenues and that the stormwater utility was to be an option to pull out the expenses to increase the overall revenue. It would be no different than pulling out the sanitation or trash fees, which originally years ago were covered by taxes. She noted that the fees have slowly increased to cover the expenses until this year when it was solely an enterprise fund.
Mr. Lewis put on the record that in the Kent County Activity Guide, page nine (9), it had its stormwater fee at $28.00 per residential property per year.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that the services are still being provided. The biggest issue would be trying to reconcile the books. If services are not provided, then they will be fined by the EPA and the State of Delaware. She noted that in 2003, the fines were up to $25,000 per day per occurrence. It would be an option to pay for it out of the general fund or take money from the depreciation of the electric reserve to stop services, which included street sweeping and leave collection.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney clarified that according to the bond counsel for the electric bonds, the reserves were considered restricted funds. The rate stabilization fund, while not restricted in the operating fund, was meant to be the electric customers’ money, not property taxpayers' money, based on policy.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that part of the motion was to move the stormwater utility back to the general fund rather than having it held separately as a stormwater utility enterprise fund. If they have them remain as enterprise funds, that
Paj 66
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 36
could be a possibility of a class action suit by the bondholders, but she would have to defer to the bond council for a decision. She explained with the enterprise funds, the ratepayers and each enterprise fund were responsible for the expenses to those enterprise funds. For example, if they have a stormwater utility, the ratepayers would be responsible for the expenses incurred for the stormwater utility. It was the reason to have a separate rate specific for those services and the same for electric to have a set of separate electric rates for electric services. Ms. Marney further stated that part of the motion was to return the stormwater utility expenses to the general fund and to treat any transfer as an inter- fund transfer to the general fund, which would be part of their financial policies. She noted that they do have a $10 million threshold in their financial policies for the transfer to the general fund.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that she does have concerns with that transaction being made. She explained that when those expenses are in the general fund or whether they have transferred from the electric fund, no matter what, they would have to pass those charges to the constituents. No one likes to have increased fees, and it would either increase tax fees, increase electric rates, or even both.
Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Duca stated that the stormwater fee was no different than the trash fees. She noted that 50 years ago, whatever service was provided by hand to collect the trash, not with automated trucks, was paid for by their taxes. The expenses, disposal services, mandate recycling fees, personnel costs, and automated trucks have all increased over the years, which led them to the point where it was now its enterprise fund. It could be compared the same way as stormwater. It used to be absorbed by taxes, but they were no longer able to continue doing so with the increase in expenses.
Mr. Anderson emphasized that reversing the stormwater maintenance fee would be the most prudent course of action, as calculations did not turn out the way they had anticipated when they were voted upon, and the projections and the modeling did not add up. He acknowledged that they would need to find a way to bridge this year and plan for a supplemental budget. Several options were available, by transferring funds to the general fund would give them the maximum options. One (1) option would involve using depreciation reserves while staying within bond covenant thresholds, while another option would be pending land sales after the economic development fund is completed, which the amount of money from those pending sales would get them closer to where they needed to go and be a bridge for this year. However, they would need to bridge and plan out the next step, and work towards various grants. Mr. Anderson was not optimistic about the $41 million EPA grant due to high competition but pointed to the bipartisan infrastructure bill as a more promising pathway for funding for water waste, water, stormwater infrastructures, et cetera. Mr. Anderson stated that various people have pledged to help, including the Delaware League of Local Governments. They have reached out to him about this and are willing to help them get those particular grants.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that a lot of the extra money would be driven by projects, and they would not be charged a fee that would need to be paid. There are a certain number of projects that have to happen to accomplish a certain result to get
Paj 67
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 37
permits with Silver Lake, Near Lake, and other areas. These projects are required to keep their permit.
Dr. Sudler recommended having quarterly budget reviews. Dr. Sudler concurred with Mr. Anderson that when something is not right, it is best to go back to the drawing board and find other types of innovative strategies that they all can come up with together.
Mr. Hare moved for acceptance of the committee report. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and carried with Mr. Lewis abstaining.
Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 7:48 p.m.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Boggerty requested that Item #5, “Campground of Hope” for the Unsheltered Population of the City of Dover, be considered as Item #1 and be renamed “Campground of Hope” for the Unsheltered Population of the City of Dover and other programs.
Mr. Boggerty moved for adoption of the agenda as amended, seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
“Campground of Hope” for the Unsheltered Population of the City of Dover and Other Programs (Leandra Marshall, Vice Chair, City of Dover Unsheltered Working Group)
Ms. Leandra Marshall, Vice Chair, City of Dover Unsheltered Working Group reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Campground of Hope. This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Marshall stated that he is correct because the campground would fall outside the city limits, they plan to focus the money on the projects within the city and privately raise money or obtain funding from the state and county to establish the campground. For example, Synergy Recovery Solutions, a coalition member, has helped to cap Medicaid rates to serve the unsheltered population. She explained that they would offer mental health services, medically assisted drug and alcohol treatment, and primary care. The intake rate for Medicaid for example, is typically $146 but Synergy has decided to cap the rate at $100, the individual session rate for Medicaid is $119 but Synergy has decided to cap the rate at $90, and the group session rate would be $25 for mental health services.
Paj 68
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 38
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marshall stated that the original proposed budget was for the whole program. However, due to concerns about the campground being outside the city, she acknowledged that the budget would need to be revised. She explained that they came up with the campground as a relief to the city. She stated that with the constraints, they plan to revamp the budget and add additional services.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that there is approximately $91,000 in American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funding left. He explained that by December 09, 2024, they are going to have to earmark where the money is going, and they will be able to make adjustments afterward. If the money is not allocated by December 31, 2024, then the city will lose it.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that they can redirect the funding to the Kent County Coalition. He explained that the Community Development Director reviewed the two proposals for legal reasons and the current proposal is being revamped. He stated that they wanted to make sure there was no room for error because of the timeframe and the unsheltered group being formed by the city made sense because it is a city-directed project.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that it would be up to the committee to decide whether the unsheltered working group would be allocated $91,000.
Ms. Marshall stated that she has worked with ARPA funds for many years and the city is allowed to reallocate them depending on the stipulations that were in the original proposal for the funding. She explained that they plan to create a budget based on what funding they are provided, and they will continue to raise money through private partnerships, grants, and other private agencies. She stated that the goal is to address the needs of the unsheltered population without putting a Band- Aid on it.
Mr. Anderson stated that when the city obtained the ARPA money, they followed the revenue offset provision which allowed them to direct the money anywhere they choose within certain restrictions. The funds cannot be used in retirement funds, and a few other things, so it must be treated like general revenue.
Reverend Dr. Maxine Johnson, John Wesley AME Church, 217 W. Division Street, Dover, stated that since her appointment in March of 2023, she has experienced the church's connection with the community and through the many partnerships. She explained that shortly after her appointment, Mr. Garcia “Gus” Walker let her know that the ceiling fell in. She stated that they had to cancel services and projects within the community such as the clothes closet. She explained that they are before council to ask for funding through the ARPA funding program.
Paj 69
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 39
Ms. Carla Benson-Green, Steward Pro Tem, provided the history of the church. She explained that the church has always been utilized as a refuge station or resource spot for the people in the community. She stated that in 2005 John Wesley engaged in a collaborative effort within the community during the HIV Epidemic and it became a part of the ministry to reach the people that are in the community. She emphasized that they are a boots-on-the-ground church, and everyone knows the church with the blue door as the place for services, support, and refuge.
She stated that they initially started working with the Division of Public Health and the DC3 Coalition, and later expanded their collaboration to include Kent County Counseling, Brandywine Counseling, as well as additional external resources such as Dover District Ministerial and the State of Delaware Office of Defense Services to provide expungement services. She explained that through their yearly projects and partnership with Brandywine Counseling, they have gone from reaching one hundred and eighty-five people in 2016 to eight hundred and fifty-six currently. She stated that they would like council to consider John Wesley as a candidate for ARPA funding to address their aging structure. The roofing issues were about $19,300 and the ceiling issue was around $10,200.
Mr. Anderson stated that in the past the People’s Church was awarded around $600,000 for renovations and the Murphy School was awarded around $30,000 for the HVAC system. It would not be out of the ordinary to provide funding for community purposes because the city is not supporting any religious organization. He asked that they provide three bids for each project to stay consistent with the City of Dover purchasing policy if approved.
Mr. Boggerty moved to recommend that from the remaining ARPA funds of $91,000, grant $30,000 to John Wesley Church, once they comply with the request for the bids, and that the remainder of the funds be allocated to the Unsheltered Working Group. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson.
Mr. Anderson requested that they return on December 09, 2024, with as firm of numbers as possible for when council votes.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that they were not required to advertise the ARPA funding, but they decided to do it the first time because they wanted the broadest reach, therefore they did two rounds of advertising. He explained that if they chose to advertise this reallocation there would be no time to award the funding because it must be done within the next few weeks.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Boggerty stated as co-chair of the ARPA funding, he went around the community, spoke at several community events, and did several social media campaigns. He stated that there was not one step that was not taken to include groups like Tracy Palmer Ministries, The People’s Church, and many other organizations. There were several applications, and when they did not give out all the money in the first round, they did it all over again. He emphasized
Paj 70
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 40
that there were social media campaigns galore, and he drove to events large and small to share about ARPA funding. Unfortunately, in many instances, the agencies were not prepared from an administrative standpoint to apply. Some had issues with taxes and the 501 formations, and they did not comply, which meant they had to revisit awards and provide extra money to dispense all the funds. He stated that unfortunately with less than 30 days to have the funding allocated they had to reach out to individuals such as Leandra Marshall and John Wesley Church, knowing the work that they do within the community.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Boggerty stated that unfortunately, due to other issues that he could not make public, there was funding that was not allocated.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that when the money was pulled back it was decided that the funding would need to be reallocated.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Marney stated the money could not be used to fund the stormwater utility.
Responding to Ms. Marney, Mr. Anderson stated that part of the ARPA funding was allocated towards water/wastewater because infrastructure is one of the items that was specifically mentioned in the ARPA final regulations, therefore the funding could be used to fund the stormwater utility.
Mr. Garfinkel moved to amend the motion that the $91,000 be put into the stormwater infrastructure. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Marney stated that she would have to specifically look at whether the funding could be used. She stated she believed that ARPA funding could be used for infrastructure and not operational expenses. A stormwater utility may be considered operational expenses and not infrastructure. She explained that portions of stormwater utility would be infrastructure that could possibly qualify but she would have to research that.
Mr. Garfinkel moved to amend the motion that the $91,000 be put into the stormwater infrastructure. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and failed by a roll call vote of six (6) no (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Arndt, Rocha, Anderson), three (3) yes (Lewis, Shevock, Garfinkel), and two (2) absent (Pillsbury, Sudler).
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Mr. Boggerty moved to recommend that from the remaining ARPA funds of $91,000, grant $30,000 to John Wesley Church, once they comply with the request of the bids, and that the remainder of the funds be allocated to the Unsheltered Working Group. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson
Paj 71
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 41
and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Arndt, Rocha, Lewis, Anderson, Shevock), one (1) no (Garfinkel), and two (2) absent (Pillsbury, Sudler).
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Mr. Rocha moved to sunset the Unsheltered Working Group as the Kent County Coalition will be taking over going forward. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Dover Fire Department Volunteer Stipend (Chief David Carey and President Jason Osika) Chief David Carey and President Jason Osika, Dover Fire Company, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the volunteer stipend.
Staff recommended approval of the volunteer stipend program.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation for the fire department volunteer stipend. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Chief Carey stated that they currently have two hundred and thirty-three people. They range from the age of thirteen to the age of ninety-five. There are approximately fifty-two members active. He clarified that active means any member who makes one hundred and twenty-five calls or more a year.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Osika clarified that not everyone would get the stipend. There are guidelines that specify what the volunteer must do, such as duty crew hours or responding to general alarms.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Osika stated that they hired their department attorney and Dave Truax who provides audits of ambulances, finances, and other issues within the fire service. Mr. Truax put them in touch with an attorney who is well-versed in the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) since that was the biggest thing that needed to be looked at. The portion that Mr. Lewis quoted regarding the nominal fee was pulled from the FLSA advisory letter that the attorney gave them. It states that to maintain volunteer status they cannot be paid; however, they can be compensated a nominal fee. The nominal fee is not determined or defined by the Congress of 1985.
Paj 72
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 42
He went on to explain that there is a twenty percent rule that states they can get a nominal fee for the items listed which was covered in their policy after going to the state auditor's office. The twenty percent rule states that you cannot make more than twenty percent of what someone would make doing that job full-time. The numbers that were used in the upcoming budget for a firefighter position was approximately $54,000, therefore $10,000 is the most someone could make without violating the FLSA rule. He stated that the goal is to have duty crew shifts that volunteers are signing up for so that the station is staffed 24/7 with a crew at each station. If they were to complete a 12-hour shift they would receive credit for four calls. He explained that it would calculate to $10 an hour equating to $30 a call while staying at the firehouse. He stated that they would only be paid if they were on those shifts.
He explained that the goal is to have crews in place to run silent alarms so that they do not have to blow the fire whistle every time. Currently, they are running about one hundred and seventy-five calls, and the whistle blows an average of about twenty-five times. The whistle blows for accidents and fires, and when a crew is not in the station, they need people to respond.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Osika stated that the reasonable benefits are not medical benefits. He explained that the verbiage was taken from the Congress Act of 1985, which states what can be paid with the nominal fee while maintaining a volunteer status. The State Auditor's office recommended calling it a nominal fee to encompass everything so that no one can say something was left out and ask for reimbursement.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Chief Carey stated that the funding came from the Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILOT) program, which is funding provided by the State of Delaware to Wilmington, Dover, and Georgetown. He explained that the City of Newark raised concerns about the number of university buildings that are government buildings within the City of Newark and that they are not able to tax to receive income to subsidize some of their needs. One of the state legislators asked to award Newark $2 million in Grant-in-Aid funds to subsidize the PILOT money that they do not receive. Senator Paradee requested that the City of Dover receive the same funds. The City of Dover was awarded $2 million, with a clear allocation that $500,000 was designated for the police department, and the remaining funds were allocated to the fire department. He stated that as President Osika mentioned, there were no guidelines as to how the money had to be spent. In speaking to Senator Paradee, he explained that he does not foresee the Grant- in-Aid money being eliminated any time soon, however, Grant-in-Aid does change year to year, so the possibility is there.
Mr. Osika stated that the $1.1 million that would be transferred should last anywhere from two to three years, but it would have to be monitored. He explained that after meeting with city staff they have decided to place the funding in a separate account and do monthly reports that include how much is going in and out because it will likely go back and forth depending on the time of the year.
Paj 73
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 43
He stated that they predict they will receive another million or so next year but if the legislature decided to end the Grant-in-Aid, they would have to go back to the drawing board because once the program is started there would be no going back. He explained that once someone is being paid you would not get them back in the door by taking the money away. In closing, he stated that the goal is to use half a million dollars for the volunteers versus half going to paid staff.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Chief Carey stated that if they were to go to a paid fire department it would be roughly $26 million doing a comparison to that of the City of Annapolis, Maryland, who have two fire stations and a similar population.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation for
the fire department volunteer stipend. The motion was seconded by Mr.
Lewis and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Discussion – Amending Bond Council Requirements (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer) Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the bond council requirements.
Ms. Marney stated that the request had come as a result of publication issues at the local newspaper’s office during the budget season and in discussions with the Bond Counsel regarding changes made to the Tax Equity and Financial Responsibility Act (TEFRA) requirements from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) which allowed for public notice to be done on websites. Staff recommended amendment of all city code requirements for public notice to include modern communication tools.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Marney stated that adding more modern publications does not mean that staff cannot publish in the newspapers. Adding more modern publications provides staff with additional tools to post on the website, in specific public notice portals used by some government entities, and on social media. The recommended change would allow staff to utilize additional tools to legally get the word out.
Mr. Neil stated that even though the newspapers have reduced publications he would recommend continuing to include one publication in the newspaper for public record.
Ms. Arndt moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation to amend city code requirements for public notice to include modern communication tools. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.
Paj 74
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 44
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Discussion – Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer) Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR).
Ms. Marney stated that the delay in completing the financial report was due to staff turnover in the finance department, including the Controller/Treasurer position, as well as unfinished reconciliations that were necessary to complete the schedules.
Ms. Marney stated that they have been working to fill positions within the finance department, however, there is a shortage of candidates as it relates to the accounting field. Currently, they are in need of someone who is experienced in certain specialties within municipal government accounting. She explained that her goal is to have the final draft of the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report released by January, if not sooner.
This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that they are actively working on the audits for both 2023 and 2024. For fiscal year 2024, they need to complete bank reconciliations for the cash concentration fund and the disbursement funds, which are reconciled through February 2024. Part of the delay was the health reconciliations, which have since been completed, once the bank reconciliations are complete, and the depreciation expense schedules are recorded they will be in a better position for the audit of fiscal year 2024.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that fiscal year 2023 should be completed by January.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that she believes the city's federal funding is safe. She has contacted the bond carriers with the bond rating agencies, and they are aware of the challenges that have occurred over the past year, the city is currently on watch, however, the city is still at a double-A or triple-A rating.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend acceptance of the report. The motion was seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Paj 75
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 45
Proposed Ordinance #2024-32 – Abandoned Shopping Carts (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the background and analysis regarding Proposed Ordinance #2024-32.
Staff recommended forwarding Proposed Ordinance #2024-32 to council.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that if sanitation workers find a cart, the owner of the cart will be notified, if they do not take the cart, the city would take the cart and when it is delivered back to the owner, there will be a fine given to them.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that Mr. Lewis was correct, if there were a cart in the retention pond at Stoney Creek, sanitation would collect the cart if Target did not and when the cart is delivered back to Target, they would be given a fine.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:15 p.m.
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:15 p.m.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
ORDINANCE/FINAL READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-24 –
AMENDING CHAPTER 26 BUSINESSES, ARTICLE II – LICENSES, SEC. 26-31. DEFINITIONS, APPENDIX F – FEES AND FINES, CHAPTER 26 (FORMERLY PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-24A – RECREATIONAL MARIJUANA BUSINESS LICENSES: CULTIVATION, MANUFACTURING, AND TESTING FACILITIES) The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of October 28, 2024. Council President Anderson reminded members of the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available at the entrance of the Council Chambers or on the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com under “Government.”
Ms. Arndt moved that the Final Reading of the proposed ordinance be
Paj 76
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 46
acknowledged by title only, seconded by Mr. Neil, and unanimously carried. (The First Reading of the proposed ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting on October 28, 2024.)
By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, Council, by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Lewis, Anderson) and one (1) no (Sudler), adopted Ordinance #2024-24, as follows:
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN 1 COUNCIL MET:
That Chapter 26 – Businesses, Article II – Licenses, Section 26-31. – Definitions, be amended as follows:
Sec. 26-31. Definitions.
The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning:
Marijuana cultivation facility or cultivation facility means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to cultivate, prepare, and package marijuana and sell marijuana to retail marijuana stores, to marijuana product manufacturing facilities, and to other marijuana cultivation facilities, but not to consumers. A marijuana cultivation facility may not produce marijuana concentrates, tinctures, extracts, or other marijuana products.
Marijuana product manufacturing facility means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to: purchase marijuana; manufacture, prepare, and package marijuana products, and sell marijuana and marijuana products to other marijuana product manufacturing facilities and retail marijuana stores, but not to consumers.
Marijuana testing facility means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to test marijuana for potency and contaminants.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix F – Fees and Fines, Chapter 26 – Businesses, Article II. - Licenses be amended as follows: Chapter 26. Businesses Fees and Fines Article II. Licenses Sec. 26-35. License required; fees Subsec. (d)(2) Manufacturers/contractors/marijuana $0.00046 of aggregate cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing gross receipts/Minimum facilities rate fee $128.00
Paj 77
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 47
ADOPTED: December 9, 2024
ORDINANCE/FINAL READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-25 –
AMENDING CHAPTER 26 BUSINESSES, ARTICLE II – LICENSES, SEC. 26-31. DEFINITIONS, APPENDIX F – FEES AND FINES, CHAPTER 26 (FORMERLY PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-24B – RECREATIONAL MARIJUANA BUSINESS LICENSES: COMPASSION CENTERS, RETAIL MARIJUANA STORES) The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of October 28, 2024. Council President Anderson reminded members of the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available at the entrance of the Council Chambers or on the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com under “Government.”
By motion of Mr. Hare, seconded by Mr. Neil, Council, by a unanimous roll call vote, adopted Ordinance #2024-25, as follows:
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
That Chapter 26 – Businesses, Article II – Licenses, Section 26-31. – Definitions, be amended to read as follows:
Sec. 26-31. Definitions.
The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning:
Compassion center means an entity registered pursuant to §4914A of Title 16 of the Delaware State Code that acquires, possesses, sells, supplies, or dispenses marijuana, paraphernalia, or related supplies and educational materials to registered qualifying patients who have designated the dispenser to cultivate marijuana for their medical use and the registered designated caregivers of these patients.
Retail marijuana store means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to purchase marijuana from marijuana cultivation facilities; to purchase marijuana and marijuana products from marijuana product manufacturing facilities, and to sell marijuana and marijuana products to consumers.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix F – Fees and Fines, Chapter 26 – Businesses, Article II. - Licenses be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
Chapter 26. Businesses Fees and Fines
Article II. Licenses
Sec. 26-35. License required; fees
Paj 78
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 48
Subsec. (d)(3) Merchants/bottlers/retail marijuana $0.00046 of aggregate stores/compassion centers rate gross purchases for resale/ Minimum fee $64.00
ADOPTED: December 9, 2024
REALLOCATION OF AMERICAN RESCUE PLAN ACT (ARPA) FUNDING FOR
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY SERVICE PROJECTS (COUNCILMAN ROCHA,
UNSHELTERED AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING LIAISON AND COUNCILMAN
BOGGERTY, COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT LIASON)
(Committee recommendation: That the remaining ARPA funds of $91,000, grant $30,000 to John Wesley Church, once they comply with the request of the bids, and that the remainder of the funds be allocated to the Unsheltered Working Group and to sunset the Unsheltered Working Group as the Kent County Coalition will be taking over going forward)
Mr. Hare moved for acceptance of the committee recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
SETTING THE STORMWATER FEE TO ZERO, STORMWATER PAYMENT CREDIT/REFUND PROCESS (SHARON DUCA, ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER AND ALLISON HAINES, INTERIM CUSTOMER SERVICE DIRECTOR)
(Committee recommendation: Set the stormwater utility rate to zero, transfer the stormwater utility back to the general fund for the time being, allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time, and find a way to refund or credit the money that people have already paid.)
Mr. Hare moved for acceptance of the committee recommendation. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler.
Ms. Allision Haines, Interim Customer Service Director, stated that the plan was to set all the fees back to zero and for individuals that have paid anything under $100.00, if they have an open utility account in their name, it will transfer the credit to the utility. Individuals who have paid over $100.00, would have to research and issue refund checks.
Mr. Hare moved for acceptance of the committee recommendation. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and carried with Mr. Lewis abstaining.
RESCHEDULING APRIL 14, 2025, REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING AND APRIL 15, 2025 COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING DUE TO THE 2025 MUNICIPAL ELECTION
(Staff recommendation: Reschedule April 14, 2025, Regular Council Meeting and
Paj 79
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 49
April 15, 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting to April 7, 2025, and April 8, 2025)
Mr. Hare moved to accept the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Hugg had no announcements.
MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mayor Christiansen announced that there would be three (3) events happening on December 14, 2024. The first event is a holiday celebration sponsored by the Dover Police Department and Habitat for Humanity. The event is from 12:00 to 4:00 p.m., at the Legislative Mall. The second event, sponsored by the City of Dover and Delaware State University, How the Grinch Stole Christmas, would be shown at The Schwartz Center of the Arts, at 4:15 p.m. He noted that there would be free popcorn and other goodies available, and the movie would be free of charge to those who show up. He further noted that there would be the Annual Dashing Through Dover Electric Light Parade down from Loockerman Street through Downtown Dover, starting at 6:30 p.m.
COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Rocha stated that he had two (2) announcements. In the first announcement, he emphasized to Mr. Hugg and the Clerk’s Office to get together to make bids into redoing the audio and video and to tie in the video with WebEx so that they could see in real-time what they see on the screen. He noted that whatever comes through with the microphones goes directly to WebEx in real-time. In the second announcement, he stated that he would be seeking re-election for another term. Mr. Rocha noted that he wanted to accomplish things for the city and would continue to work hard for the constituents in his district and throughout the city.
Mr. Boggerty announced that he would be seeking re-election. He noted that he was celebrating his second anniversary with his wife.
Mr. Anderson wished Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Rocha, and Mr. Lewis upcoming birthdays.
Dr. Pillsbury announced that there would be a District One meeting on Thursday, December 12, 2024, at the West Dover Fire Station, starting at 6:00 p.m.
Mr. Rocha stated that he had to attend a funeral in New York and would not be in attendance for the District One meeting.
The meeting adjourned at 10:15 p.m.
ANDRIA L. BENNETT CITY CLERK
Paj 80
Item #4.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF DECEMBER 9, 2024 PAGE 50
All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by the City Council during their Regular Meeting of December 9, 2024, are hereby approved.
ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR /AB
Exhibits
Exhibit #1 - Don Anderson’s Photos – Public Comment
Exhibit #2 – Bill Winter’s Statement – Public Hearing
Paj 81
EXHIBIT #1
Regular City Council Meeting of 12/09/2024
Item #4.
Paj 82
Item #4.
Paj 83
Item #4.
Paj 84
Item #4.
Paj 85
Item #4.
Paj 86
Item #4.
Paj 87
EXHIBIT #2
Regular City Council Meeting of 12/09/2024
Item #4.
Paj 88
Item #4.
Paj 89
Item #4.
Paj 90
Item #5.
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING
A Special Council Meeting was held on January 2, 2024, at 5:18 p.m., with Council President Anderson presiding. Council members present were Mr. Hare, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Arndt (via Webex), Mr. Rocha, Dr. Sudler, and Mr. Lewis. Mayor Christiansen was also present.
Staff members present were Mr. Hugg, Mr. Rodriguez, Ms. Marney (via Webex), and Ms. Bennett.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty, and unanimously carried.
MAYOR ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN VETO – MOTION ADOPTED BY CITY COUNCIL ON DECEMBER 9, 2024 – TO AFFIRM CITY COUNCIL’S DECISION OF DECEMBER 9, 2024, ORDINANCE #2024-24 – AMENDING CHAPTER 26 BUSINESSES, ARTICLE II – LICENSES, SEC. 26-31. – DEFINITIONS, AND APPENDIX F – FEES AND FINES, CHAPTER 26; ORDINANCE #2024-25 – AMEDNING CHAPTER 26 BUSINESSES, ARTICLE II – LICENSES, SEC. 26-31. – DEFINITIONS, AND APPENDIX F – FEES AND FINES CHAPTER 26; ORDINANCE #2024-29 – AMENDING, APPENDIX B-ZONING, ARTICLE 3 – DISTRICT REGULATIONS, SEC. 19 – MANUFACTURING ZONE (M), SEC. 20 – INDUSTRIAL MANUFACTURING ZONE (IPM), SEC. 23 – AGRICULTURAL ZONE (A), ARTICLE 5 – SUPPLEMENTARY REGULATIONS, SEC. 24 – MARIJUANA RELATED BUSINESSES, ARTICLE 12 – DEFINITIONS; ORDINANCE #2024-30 – AMENDING APPENDIX B – ZONING, ARTICLE 3 – DISTRICT REGULATIONS, SEC. 16 – HIGHWAY COMMERCIAL ZONE (C-4), ARTICLE 5 – SUPPLEMENTARY REGULATIONS, SEC. 24 – MARIJUANA-RELATED BUSINESSES, ARTICLE 12 – DEFINITIONS
During their Regular Meeting of December 9, 2024, by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Lewis, Anderson), and one (1) no (Sudler), Council adopted Ordinance #2024-29 – Amending Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Sec. 19 – Manufacturing Zone (M), Sec. 20 – Industrial Manufacturing Zone (IPM), Sec. 23 – Agricultural Zone (a), Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Sec. 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 – Definitions.
During their Regular Meeting of December 9, 2024, by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Sudler, Lewis, Anderson), and one (1) no (Rocha), Council adopted Ordinance #2024-30 – Amending Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Sec. 16 – Highway Commercial Zone (C-4), Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Sec. 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 – Definitions.
During their Regular Meeting of December 9, 2024, by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Lewis, Anderson), and one (1) no (Sudler), Council adopted Ordinance #2024-24 – Amending Chapter 26 Businesses, Article II – Licenses, Sec. 26-31. Definitions, Appendix F – Fees and Fines, Chapter 26.
During their Regular Meeting of December 9, 2024, by a unanimous roll call vote, Council adopted Page 90 Ordinance #2024-25 – Amending Chapter 26 Businesses, Article II – Licenses, Sec. 26-31.
Paj 91
Item #5.
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 2, 2025 PAGE 2
Definitions, Appendix F – Fees and Fines, Chapter 26.
Mr. Lewis moved to reaffirm the previous Council action to adopt Ordinances #2024-29, #2024-30, as amended; #2024-24, and #2024-25. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler.
On December 16, 2024, the City Clerk received a letter from Mayor Robin R. Christiansen disapproving the motions, which stated:
"RE: To the Citizens of the City of Dover and Members of Council, I hereby veto the following Ordinances pursuit to the City of Dover Charter Section 10,
2024-24 -Amending Chapter 26 Businesses, Article II - Licenses, Sec. 26-31. - Definitions, and Appendix F - Fees and Fines, Chapter 26 (Formerly Proposed Ordinance #2024-24A - Recreational Marijuana Business License: Cultivation, Manufacturing, and Testing Facilities)
2024-25 -Amending Chapter 26 Businesses, Article II - Licenses, Sec. 26-31. - Definitions, and Appendix F - Fees and Fines, Chapter 26 (Formerly Proposed Ordinance #2024-24B - Recreational Marijuana Business License: Compassion Centers, Retail Marijuana Stores)
2024-29 -Amending Appendix B- Zoning, Article 3 - District Regulations, Sec. 19 - Manufacturing Zone (M), Sec. 20 - Industrial Manufacturing Zone (1PM), Sec. 23 - Agricultural Zone (A), Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations, Sec. 24 -Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 - Definitions (Formerly Proposed Ordinance #2024- 25A - Recreational Marijuana Land Use and Zoning: Cultivation, Manufacturing, and Testing Facilities)
2024-30 -Amending Appendix B- Zoning, Article 3 - District Regulations, Sec. 16 - Highway Commercial Zone (C-4), Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations, Sec. 24 - Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 - Definitions (Formerly Proposed Ordinance #2024-25B - Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Zoning: Retail Marijuana Stores)
For the following reasons -
The 4 ordinances recently passed by City Council represent, in my opinion and in concert with many of our residents, law enforcement, first responders, and business community, will cause irreparable harm to this City, the capital of the Frist State. Given Dover's already significant problems with alcohol and illegal drug abuse, I do not believe it to be in the best interest of this city to add another drug to this difficult situation. The use of this drug, legal according to state law but illegal as classified by Federal Statute, sends all the wrong messages and none of the right messages as we work to bring back a city that is full of families and residents, young and old, who live, work, and play here and raise families.
Further, the growth, manufacturing, distribution, testing and/or retail of this drug benefits the State of Delaware, not the city of Dover. All taxes paid by the consumer will flow to the State. Dover will gain little benefit from business licensing, water
Paj 92
Item #5.
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 2, 2025 PAGE 3
and electricity, yet all other taxes, fees, and state licensing monies benefit the State's General Fund. However, the consequences from the consumption of this drug, including but not limited to anticipated expenses, will be borne exclusively by the City's residents, law enforcement, and medical community.
Further, by allowing all four categories of this drug within the city limit without adequate protection for our schools, hospitals, clinics, and no protection for our religious organizations is unacceptable. The ordinances leave blank any setback distances from any of our many well-established churches and religious organizations in the city. Additionally, the 500 feet noted in the Ordinance # 2024- 30 for retail along our Rt. 13 corridor would have allowed up to six, or even seven, retail shops stretching from the City of Dover Sign to the north entrance of DAFB. This number of retail marijuana establishments, without sufficient distance standards to sensitive properties as named previously, does not create a healthy situation for our city.
Further, these ordinances were written and produced without any review by the City Solicitor to determine their legality or potential conflicts with the current City Code and the revised zoning ordinances sent back to the planning commission for review.
Further, some on City Council believed action must be taken to preserve the ability of the one compassionate care/medical dispensary currently operating in the city to remain in business. Specifically, any currently zoned and state licensed medical facility will not lose their ability to stay in business as a medical dispensary. They will be automatically granted a retail license by the State. It then becomes the choice of the owner to seek zoning and acceptance by a local jurisdiction of their state retail license. Their ability to remain a medical dispensary is not impacted.
Further, there have been numerous arguments rendered about removing the illegal market within the city. I have seen no evidence of this in the areas that have legalized the growth, manufacturing, distribution, testing, and/or retail sale of this drug.
Further, by the act of the Assembly, they have granted all the towns and cities in Delaware the option to allow or not allow the growth, manufacture, distribution, testing, and/or sale of this drug within their city limits. Currently, over 65% of the towns and cities have found in their studies good reasons to ban any industry related to marijuana within their city limits and have done so.
Finally, by the authority given to me by the City of Dover and my deep concerns with the significant negative impact this drug already has, an impact that stands only to be amplified by adding its growth, manufacturing, distribution, testing, and retail sale within our great City's limits, I hereby veto Ordinances # 2024-24, 2024- 25, 2024-29, 2024-30, for the above stated reasons.
Respectfully Submitted this Day, the Sixteenth of December, Two Thousand and Twenty-Four.
Paj 93
Item #5.
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 2, 2025 PAGE 4
Mr. Rocha stated for the record that he agreed with Mayor Christiansen’s veto and everything that was specified. He wanted to let council know that they were making a decision, and if there was any thought process that would go into being in favor, would this be something they want for a family-oriented city where they have invested millions of dollars into the development of the Downtown Dover to become a destination for families. Mr. Rocha noted that from what he heard from his constituents, it was the negative, not to approve the ordinance. He believed that this would not benefit the city and if they went against this veto, they could bring forth another ordinance on the contrary to this.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Anderson clarified that if the ordinances did not pass, people could set up retail marijuana shops in the city, including Downtown Dover.
Mr. Neil stated that he understood why Mayor Christiansen vetoed the ordinances, but that does not ban marijuana, and they cannot get rid of it from the state. The fact was that it was here, and they were dealing with this, and it could not stop a person from coming in and selling because it was legal. The question would be if they are just pushing it off so that a business could open up directly across their border and be smoking across from a sign that stated: “Welcome to Dover.”
Mr. Boggerty stated that his position was that he did not disagree with Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Rocha, or Mr. Neil. If he was ever going to abstain from something, it would be from this, but he would not because that was not why he was voted into council.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Anderson stated that they would need to have a license to add a small sales tax, but under the current state law, it would be specifically made to benefit the state. It does not mean the law cannot change. He noted that Wilmington’s representatives are trying to lobby for a small local tax, and they have reached out to see if Dover would like to join in, and he fully supports that. Mr. Anderson emphasized that once they were through the ordinances, they would bring a resolution to support that if they all agreed upon it.
Mr. Anderson pointed out that regardless of whether the ordinances were passed or not, marijuana remained legal, and all costs were legal. The concern would be driving out local businesses, such as the business to be converted, which they have said would move those jobs outside the city. Furthermore, the other concern could be driving out other local businesses that are trying to relocate to areas where those businesses could legally sell marijuana.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Anderson clarified that if the ordinances were approved, businesses would stay, but if the ordinances were not approved, the businesses would leave. Mr. Anderson noted that at least two (2) businesses would leave if the ordinances were not approved.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Anderson stated that Wilmington representatives were discussing addressing a 1% to 1 ½% tax and the 1 ½% would be the equivalent of 10% of the state tax. He noted that they do not want to put the tax too high, or they would drive the black market up, and that would be where people would get contaminated products, which could lead to death, and they do not want that. Mr. Anderson emphasized that if one good thing can come out of this would be to save lives.
Mr. Lewis concurred with Mr. Neil and reiterated marijuana was here to stay. The state legislators voted, and it passed. Despite what some people think, a public survey was conducted months ago, Page 93
Paj 94
Item #5.
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 2, 2025 PAGE 5
and he believed that it was a fair process because it was open to those who wanted to take it. The data was analyzed and after it was closed, 60% of the citizens wanted retail marijuana, with the caveat not being downtown, which council had abided by. Mr. Lewis has no problem and concurs with marijuana not being downtown. It was what the public wanted, and it was their interest.
Mr. Rocha stated that when the survey was conducted, the draft ordinance at that time had a one (1) mile distance along the corridor on Route 13, which has now been changed to 500 feet. In his opinion, that was a game-changer for him. He pointed out that other municipalities are having the same discussion and have not passed an ordinance yet. For example, Milford is looking at two (2) ordinances, one (1) to approve, and one to ban sales. Those municipalities still have one (1) mile distance in one (1) ordinance that they are trying to approve. Mr. Rocha noted that at the last council meeting, he had made a statement that if the ordinances were not approved that evening, then he was told no they could not have a special council meeting. He further noted that they could have resolved this within the last three (3) weeks, and now are still sitting here in chambers discussing the veto. They could have been making improvements or changing things in a special council meeting, had they acted accordingly during the last council meeting. Whatever would be decided, he is part of the team, but his vote would be no.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson clarified that only six (6) dispensaries would be licensed in Kent County.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson stated that it would be impossible to have six (6) dispensaries in Dover due to the setbacks. The very most that could be had would be four (4) dispensaries, but there are 20 municipalities. The Town of Smyrna has already voted to allow marijuana, and they are treating marijuana just like alcohol, which essentially can go anywhere in the town.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Townsend stated that if there was no ordinance, then it would fall back to whatever that underlying use was. A retail license would be permitted anywhere that retail was allowed.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rodriguez stated that the Planning Commission voted not to approve the two (2) zoning amendments, and the other two (2) ordinances would not go before the Planning Commission because they did not involve zoning, that was the position of the Planning Commission.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rodriguez clarified that council would have the authority to change the ordinance after the Planning Commission had reviewed it.
Dr. Sudler stated that, in his view, Cannabidiol (CBD) was more harmful than cannabis because CBD has synthetic marijuana in it, and not only is that legal, but a person does not have to be 18 years of age to have it. Dr. Sudler’s concern from his and his constituent’s perspective, was that they would rather have a safe pathway to cannabis usage, that was free from synthetics and fentanyl. If individuals want to indulge in cannabis, that can be an alternative that would be clean. Dr. Sudler emphasized that their role was to serve their constituents. If the constituents felt that they wanted it and it was reasonable, ethically sound, and a tangible tool that they could assess, then council owed it to their constituents to at least give it a shot.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson stated that just like with any ordinance, they would have Page 94
Paj 95
Item #5.
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 2, 2025 PAGE 6
the ability to come back and make changes to the ordinance if something was not working. He noted that the only caveat would be the existence of a location that was grandfathered in because of certain property rights, but council could adjust the boundary lines, setbacks, et cetera. Mr. Anderson stated that Mr. Rodriguez formed an opinion that under state law, there would be no timeframe given limiting their action so that they could come back and address actions, just like with any other ordinance.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Dr. Sudler suggested that they should consider that and decide to move forward as a team by honoring their constituents’ feedback.
Mr. Hare concurred with Mr. Rocha. He does not want to see marijuana in the Downtown Dover Business District. As much as Mr. Hare does not want to see drugs in the city if the ordinances do not pass, then they could see marijuana downtown and anywhere in the city.
Dr. Pillsbury stated that her understanding was that not allowing the sale within the city limits, would limit the number of people within the city who would be using marijuana. People could still get it in the county and anywhere else, it is not against the law to smoke it. There would be no repercussions for anyone who chooses to use marijuana. She believed that they were not going to be able to accomplish Mayor Christiansen’s laudable goals by not allowing marijuana and the concerns from others who have expressed where marijuana would go. She noted that it was a tough decision and would not change people’s behavior.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Anderson stated that there was a caveat that Mr. Rodriguez pointed out that individuals were not supposed to smoke marijuana on a public street itself, and it would need to be on private property.
Mr. Anderson explained that when they look at the particular ordinances, they are born of compromise. There was a large portion of the city that had been heard in the chambers, and what was seen from the surveys, a large portion of the city wanted no restriction whatsoever. There was a sizable minority that wanted all the restrictions. People wanted to ban marijuana if they could, but the state made it legal no matter what. He explained that the state allowed some ways for the municipalities to have options within their local values and their local constraints. There was a sizable portion of the city that wanted marijuana to be legal, but they wanted it to be restricted. He noted that the ordinances were supported by 60% of people. More people who responded to those surveys were from Dover than those who would vote in the elections. He further noted by looking at the public hearings that they have had, it breaks down in the same range.
Mr. Anderson believed that there was validity to these surveys and the petitions that he had received, this was not a controversial issue in his district. The compromise has given the people who want restrictions, 90% of what they want, and over 90% of the city will be off-limits to marijuana retail, marijuana cultivation, and marijuana testing. Mr. Anderson stated that they have walled off the vast majority of the city's marijuana and people would have to accept the 90% victory. The compromise that has been worked through would allow businesses to flourish and expand. It allowed them to receive the benefits of an industry that would be growing in Delaware; if they did not, they would be missing out on any benefits from it, but they would have all the burdens. The question would be why they would accept the burdens and not have any of the benefits. Mr. Anderson questioned why they would not want the jobs, utilities, and property taxes that could come along. He noted that what they have done had a balanced approach to the ordinances. He noted that the ordinances were not what he would have chosen if he had drawn Page 95
Paj 96
Item #5.
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 2, 2025 PAGE 7
them up because it was more restrictive than his libertarian learnings.
He noted that there are a substantial number of people who want to regulate marijuana, but they do not want to ban it. Mr. Anderson stated that the question would be do they go with the wisdom of the people or not. Mr. Anderson supported Mr. Lewis’s motion and said that he was willing to be a sponsor of the ordinances, even though they were not particularly what he preferred. He noted that council had decided on a moderate approach, and with moderation, Mr. Anderson believed there was wisdom to it.
Mr. Anderson stated that a vote of yes would override the veto and that the motion would reaffirm the council’s action, which was the way they have done in the past, and a vote of no would be against the ordinance.
Mr. Lewis made a motion to reaffirm the previous Council action to adopt Ordinances #2024- 29, #2024-30, as amended; #2024-24, and #2024-25. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Sudler, Lewis, Anderson), and one (1) no (Rocha).
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Special Council meeting, hearing no objection; the meeting adjourned at 6:00 p.m.
ANDRIA BENNETT CITY CLERK
ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR
/CW
Exhibits
Exhibit #1 – Dr. Dina Carol Vendetti’s Letter
Exhibit #2 – Jun Xu’s Letter
Paj 97
EXHIBIT #1
Special City Council Meeting of 01/02/2025
Item #5.
Paj 98
EXHIBIT #2
Special City Council Meeting of 01/02/2025
Item #5.
Paj 99
Item #5.
Paj 100
Item #6.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE
The Council Committee of the Whole met on December 10, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis (via WebEx and out at 6:46 p.m.), Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, and Mr. Rocha. Mr. Boggerty and Dr. Sudler were absent. Mayor Christiansen was also absent. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Shevock (Legislative, Finance, and Administration), and Mr. Iriowen (Utility). Mr. Wilson (Utility) was absent.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Dr. Pillsbury moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously carried.
Council Reports – November 2024
First District Dr. Pillsbury reported that she participated in the Ethics Ad-Hoc meeting and qualified in the weapons training with the City of Dover Police Department in November.
Mr. Rocha reported that he held a meeting regarding the Academy of Dover to address parking and traffic concerns. The discussion focused on strategies to increase parking capacity and improve traffic flow during school drop-off and dismissal times. He explained that they are working with Dr. Marinucci to resolve those issues.
Second District Mr. Hare reported that someone was camping and sleeping in a pine tree at Dover Park, and he received complaints from neighbors. Ms. Duca, Assistant City Manager, had the Parks and Recreation Department respond and they removed the mattress and other debris from the area, and he has been gone ever since. Mr. Hare thanked Ms. Duca and the Parks and Recreation team.
Mr. Lewis had nothing to report.
Third District Ms. Arndt reported that she attended the Delaware Chapter of the American Planning Association Annual Planning Conference. She emphasized that several awards were given, and the Planning Project of the Year went to a Dover project, the Rail Haus – Beer Garden. She expressed congratulations to Donny and Kim Legans who were there to accept the award. She also explained that they asked how many people in the room had been to Rail Haus in Dover, and she was impressed to see that at a meeting in Newark, a lot of hands went up. She stated that it is drawing in folks from far and near and she wanted to express that good news.
Mr. Neil reported receiving multiple emails and phone calls regarding the stormwater charges. He met with 40 residents of Wild Meadows to help prepare a stormwater appeal from the Homeowners Association (HOA) on their behalf. He also met with the HOA president and Mark Nowak to discuss the appeal. He attended a meeting with Dover Speedway officials, Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, and Councilwoman Arndt. He sent an alert to the Third District’s HOA and civic
Paj 101
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING DECEMBER 10, 2024 PAGE 2 Item #6.
leaders on the demise of the stormwater service fee for the year. He reported that he inspected the Gift of Lights event on the Firefly grounds which will be available through New Year's Day. He filed a formal complaint with the Department of Justice (DOJ) over the attempt of RHP Properties to collect property taxes paid to the city and county from 2023 and 2024, in 2026 rent increases through the Wild Meadows homeowners. The DOJ ombudsman for the manufactured housing community has stopped the attempt. He explained that the state law guarantees lease land community owners a profit without oversight. He participated in various events and meetings, including the Downtown Dover Partnership meetings, Kent County Tourism meetings, a ribbon- cutting ceremony at the John Dickinson Plantation Visitor Center, the Bayhealth Medical Center ribbon-cutting at the Blue Hen Mall, a groundbreaking ceremony on Ann Avenue for Habitat for Humanity, a Library Foundation meeting, the Dover Speedway Charity Luncheon Award Ceremony, and the Tree Lighting Ceremony. Additionally, he gave an interview with WBOC TV regarding the shopping cart ordinance set to be introduced after the beginning of the year.
Fourth District
Dr. Sudler was absent; no report was given.
At-Large
Mr. Boggerty was absent; no report was given.
Council President Anderson Council President Anderson reported receiving numerous inquiries regarding the stormwater utility and marijuana ordinances. He explained that at the National League of Cities, he found the discussion on transportation and infrastructure hubs particularly useful. He also reported that they have worked successfully with Milford, securing grants, and would love to work with Dover. Also, the Delaware League of Local Governments is interested in helping as well. In addition, he reported that he attended several community events where Thanksgiving dinners were provided to those in need, including the giveaway of 125 turkeys with all the fixings.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Garfinkel moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Anderson and unanimously carried.
Discussion – Additional Information Regarding the State of Delaware Pension (Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director, David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Stephenie Tatman, State of Delaware Deputy Pension Administrator) Ms. Stephenie Tatman, State of Delaware Deputy Pension Administrator, reviewed the background and analysis of the State of Delaware County and Municipal General Pension Plan.
This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Tatman stated that pension calculation is based on the employee’s years of service and compensation. For example, if someone retires at sixty-two with
Paj 102
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING DECEMBER 10, 2024 PAGE 3 Item #6.
only five years of service, their pension is not going to be anywhere near what someone who worked thirty years is going to be. Therefore, they may receive a couple of hundred dollars for a pension versus $3,000 for someone who works thirty years.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Tatman stated that the reduction would be because of age. For example, if someone was sixty and had at least fifteen years of service, they could retire with no reduction. The reduction could only come into play if they have fifteen years of service or more and are under the age of sixty. A more detailed example would be if someone were fifty-seven and had sixteen years of service, they would be eligible to retire because they would have fifteen years of service and are at least fifty-five but there would be a 0.4% penalty for the thirty-six months that they fall short of the age of sixty.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Tatman stated that another way to look at it could be if the employee was fifty-five and started collecting a pension, they would withdraw more from the funds than if they had worked until the age of sixty. That is what the reduction is for, to help offset the impact on the fund from people who retire at an earlier age.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Tatman stated that the city could purchase any amount of service for their employees. She explained that the state could provide a multi-tier option. They would request an estimate from their actuary on what the buy-in costs would be for sixty employees, for example. For example, if the city had sixty employees and wanted to purchase one year of service for all of them, the state could prepare an estimate for what that would cost the City of Dover. She also clarified that the city could purchase any number of years that it chooses.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Tatman stated that the city share would be 5.7% of the salary. She also clarified that the driving factor for the employer rate is salary. If the city were to give a significant pay increase to the employees, that could have an impact in the long run. However, inflation does not impact the employer contribution rate.
Responding to Mr. Shevock, Ms. Tatman stated that the Office of Pensions administers the program. The City of Dover's Human Resources Department would provide the state with information about the employees participating in the plan and would submit monthly payroll details, including employee and employer contribution rates.
Responding to Mr. Shevock, Ms. Tatman stated that the Board of Pension Trustees holds the ultimate oversight responsibility and that they have a sub-investment committee comprised of highly experienced veterans. The committee's members bring a range of expertise, including experience with DuPont and the University of Delaware Endowment.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Tatman stated that dental and vision coverage are separate, and the employee would be responsible for paying for the coverage.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Tatman stated that the employee would be given the option to choose coverage at retirement and again each year during open enrollment, with the option to waive coverage altogether.
Paj 103
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING DECEMBER 10, 2024 PAGE 4 Item #6.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Tatman stated that he was correct. If the city chose to buy a five-year service buy-in but an employee had only worked three years, the city would only pay for the three years for that employee.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Tatman stated that it must be a one-size-fits-all approach. The city cannot give the secretaries five years and the utility workers ten years, it must be the same number of years for everyone participating.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Tatman stated that the prior service is generally a point of contention when trying to make the same decisions in other municipalities. Depending on the plan that is currently offered, if an employee is close to retirement in the existing plan, that is when they have individual factors to consider. She explained that purchasing prior service helps but is expensive, so she recommends submitting a cost estimate to their office.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Tatman stated that anyone who is close to retirement and chooses to stay in their current 401 or 457 plan will be offered a one-time irrevocable option to join the plan.
Annual Review of the Investment Policy (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer) Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Investment Policy.
Staff recommended approval of the policy with no changes.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
Sole Vendor Purchase Approval for the HVAC System Upgrade – Dover Police Department (Chief Johnson) Chief Johnson reviewed the background and analysis regarding the sole vendor purchase for the HVAC system upgrade.
Staff recommended approval of the sole vendor purchase from Service Unlimited, New Castle, DE.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:46 p.m.
Paj 104
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING DECEMBER 10, 2024 PAGE 5 Item #6.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Rocha moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
Annual Engineering Consultant’s Report on the Operation and Maintenance of the Electric System – Fiscal Year 2025 (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, and Paul Waddell, Electric Director) Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, and Mr. Paul Waddell, Electric Director, reviewed the background and analysis of the Engineering Consultant’s Report on the Operation and Maintenance of the Electric System for Fiscal Year 2023.
Staff recommended acceptance of the report.
Ms. Marney clarified for the record that the report is for the Fiscal Year 2023.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Marney stated that she is correct in that all utilities are having the same issues regionally because expenses are higher because of the cost of natural gas and the Indian River Power Plant.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Marney stated that she is correct in noting that it seems the city is being penalized because expenses exceed revenue. She further explained that, according to the bond resolution, the city must maintain a specific ratio. With the draft financials, the city is currently at 0.98, but it needs to be at 1.25.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Waddell stated that to the best of his knowledge, the Indian River payments are complete for the Reliability Must-Run (RMR). He clarified that this payment represented the additional amount that had been required monthly. He stated that all of the electric providers in the area went through the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) and tried to get the rate reduced and they were able to get them drastically reduced from the initial costs.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Waddell stated that natural gas prices have settled back down. He explained that the report was based on data from two years ago when natural gas prices went through the roof. He added that they had budgeted for that year on the lower side, as such a rise had not been anticipated.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Marney stated that she is still working on the fiscal year 2024 report along with the engineering consultants and they will be working on that over the next few months.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Iriowen and unanimously carried.
Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:58 p.m.
Paj 105
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING DECEMBER 10, 2024 PAGE 6 Item #6.
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:58 p.m.
David L. Anderson
Council President
Paj 106
Item #17.
COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND
Paj 107
Item #17.
CITY COUNCIL COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND
JULY 1, 2024 - JUNE 30, 2025
100-10-12-99-000-53037
Current Balance- $ 10,743.07
BUDGETED COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND - $2,500 FOR EACH COUNCIL MEMBER PER DISTRICT AND $5,000 FOR THE AT-LARGE COUNCIL MEMBER. THE PURPOSE OF THE FUND IS TO ALLOW MEMBERS TO CONTRIBUTE FUNDS $ 25,000.00 AMOUNT TO A SMALL PROJECT OR COMMUNITY NEEDS IN EACH DISTRICT.
FINAL BUDGET $ 25,000.00 TOTAL
DATE COUNCIL SPONSOR VENDOR DESCRIPTION INVOICE # TOTAL CHARGES YEAR TO DATE BALANCE
Councilman Sudler authorized the designation of $1,500 of Email from Roy Sudler dated A 2nd Chance A Haven for his community enhancement funds to Ms. Faye White at A 07/01/2024 and an invoice dated 7/2/2024 Sudler Abused and Battered Women $1,500.00 $1,500.00 $23,500.00 2nd Chance, for their Annual Veterans Honorary Dinner 07/02/2024 and Children Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated Women and Children $500 of his community enhancement funds to the Women 06/18/24 and Email & Letter from 7/8/2024 Anderson Transformation Ministry and Children Transformation Ministry International, Inc. for William Snorton, Jr. received $500.00 $2,000.00 $23,000.00 International, Inc. their Boys to Men Development Program for Gas cards. 06/16/2024
Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated Hispanic Organization of Latin $500 of his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic 06/25/24 and email from Anthony 7/8/2024 Anderson $500.00 $2,500.00 $22,500.00 Americans (HOLA) Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con (Tony) Velazquez dated 06/25/24 Dover Festival. Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $200.00 Email from Tricia Arndt dated of her community enhancement funds to United Way for 07/08/2024 and email from Kenyatta 7/8/2024 Arndt United Way $200.00 $2,700.00 $22,300.00 their "Book Bash." Livingston dated 07/07/2024
Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $300 of Email from Gerald Rocha dated 7/8/2024 Rocha United Way his community enhancement funds to United Way for their 07/07/2024 and email from Kenyatta $300.00 $3,000.00 $22,000.00 "Book Bash." Livingston dated 07/07/2024 Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $300 of his Email from Bill Hare dated 07/08/2024 7/8/2024 Hare Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Dover Police and an email from Sgt. Jennifer Lynch $300.00 $3,300.00 $21,700.00 Department for their Summer Event. dated 07/08/2024 Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $350 of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 7/8/2024 Arndt Dover Police Department her community enhancement funds to the Dover Police 07/08/2024 and an email from Sgt. $350.00 $3,650.00 $21,350.00 Department for their Summer Event. Jennifer Lynch dated 07/08/2024 Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $100 of his Email from Fred Neil dated 07/08/2024 7/8/2024 Neil Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Dover Police and an email from Sgt. Jennifer Lynch $100.00 $3,750.00 $21,250.00 Department for their Summer Event. dated 07/08/2024 Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated 7/9/2024 Anderson United Way $250 of his community enhancement funds to United Way 07/09/2024 and email from Kenyatta $250.00 $4,000.00 $21,000.00 for their "Book Bash." Livingston dated 07/07/2024 Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $500 of Email from Gerald Rocha dated Hispanic Organization of Latin his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic 07/09/24 and email from Anthony 7/9/2024 Rocha (Tony) Velazquez dated 06/25/24 $500.00 $4,500.00 $20,500.00 Americans (HOLA) Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250 Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 7/11/24 Caribbean Culture Awareness of her community enhancement funds to the Caribbean and email from Eveann Jerry dated 7/11/2024 Pillsbury $250.00 $4,750.00 $20,250.00 Inc. Culture Awareness Inc. for their Delaware Caribbean 7/11/24 Carnival. Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200 of Email from Gerald Rocha dated 7/17/2024 Rocha Dover Police Department his community enhancement funds to the Dover Police 07/17/2024 and an email from Sgt. $200.00 $4,950.00 $20,050.00 Department for their Summer Event. Jennifer Lynch dated 07/08/2024 A 2nd Chance A Haven for Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $300 of his Email from Brian Lewis dated 7/19/2024 Lewis Abused and Battered Women community enhancement funds to Ms. Faye White at A 2nd 07/19/2024 and an invoice dated $300.00 $5,250.00 $19,750.00 and Children Chance, for their Annual Veterans Honorary Dinner. 07/02/2024 Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $250 of his Email from Fred Neil dated 7/23/24 and 7/23/2024 Neil Persimmon Park Place community enhancement funds to Persimmon Park Place email from Karen, Park Manager dated $250.00 $5,500.00 $19,500.00 for the Backpack Giveaway. 7/23/24 Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 7/23/24 7/23/2024 Arndt Persimmon Park Place her community enhancement funds to Persimmon Park and email from Karen, Park Manager $250.00 $5,750.00 $19,250.00 Place for the Backpack Giveaway. dated 7/23/24
Paj 108
Item #17.
Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $300 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated Hispanic Organization of Latin his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic 07/25/24 and email from Anthony 7/25/2024 Boggerty $300.00 $6,050.00 $18,950.00 Americans (HOLA) Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con (Tony) Velazquez dated 06/25/24 Dover Festival. Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200 of Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated A 2nd Chance A Haven for his community enhancement funds to Ms. Faye White at A 07/25/2024 and an invoice dated 7/25/2024 Rocha Abused and Battered Women $200.00 $6,250.00 $18,750.00 2nd Chance, for their Annual Veterans Honorary Dinner. 07/01/2024 and Children Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $200 of his Email from Brian Lewis dated 8/21/2024 Lewis Children's Beach House community enhancement funds to the Children's Beach 08/20/2024 and email from Armina $200.00 $6,450.00 $18,550.00 house for their Back to School Drive. Domingue dated 08/20/2024 Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $300 of Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated 8/23/2024 Rocha I Am My Sisters Keeper (MSK) his community enhancement funds to I Am My Sister's 08/22/2024 and an email from Marcille $300.00 $6,750.00 $18,250.00 Keeper (MSK-Dover) "Dee" Sewell dated 08/22/2024 Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $500 of his Email from Brian Lewis dated 08/07/24 8/27/2024 Lewis Tracy Palmer Ministries community enhancement funds to the Tracy Palmer and a letter from the Tracy Palmer $500.00 $7,250.00 $17,750.00 Ministries. Ministries dated 07/22/24 Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $500 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated 9/3/2024 Boggerty I Am My Sisters Keeper (MSK) his community enhancement funds to I Am My Sister's 09/03/2024 and an email from Marcille $500.00 $7,750.00 $17,250.00 Keeper (MSK-Dover). "Dee" Sewell dated 08/22/2024 Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $500 of Email from David Anderson dated Women and Children his community enhancement funds to the Women and 09/09/24 and Email & Letter from 9/9/2024 Boggerty Transformation Ministry Children Transformation Ministry International, Inc. for their William Snorton, Jr. received $500.00 $8,250.00 $16,750.00 International, Inc. Boys to Men and their Girls Breaking Barriers program. 09/09/2024
Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated $300 of his community enhancement funds to Concerned 09/10/2024 and email from Elizabeth Concerned Citizens of the 9/10/2024 Anderson Citizens of the Community for porta potties for their First Daniels dated 09/09/2024 $300.00 $8,550.00 $16,450.00 Community 1NA Inaugural day and Summer Music Festival.
Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $150 of his Email from Fred Neil dated 09/11/2024 Concerned Citizens of the community enhancement funds to Concerned Citizens of and email from Elizabeth Daniels dated 9/10/2024 Neil $150.00 $8,700.00 $16,300.00 Community the Community for porta potties for their First 1NA Inaugural 09/09/2024 day and Summer Music Festival. Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $500 of his Email from Brian Lewis dated 09/16/24 community enhancement funds to the People's Community and a letter from the Frances Perry, 9/16/2024 Lewis People's Community Center $500.00 $9,200.00 $15,800.00 Center for their Janie's Hands Veterans Transitional Director dated 09/11/24 Housing Program Inc. Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250 Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 9/16/24 Delmar Community Service of her community enhancement funds to the Delmar and email from Mildred Polk, President 9/16/2024 Pillsbury $250.00 $9,450.00 $15,550.00 Federation Community Service Federation for their First Health Fair. dated 9/3/24
Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250 Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 9/17/2024 Pillsbury Dover Police Department of her community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue 09/17/2024 and email from M/Cpl. Lee $250.00 $9,700.00 $15,300.00 Weekend Killen dated 09/17/2024. Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 9/17/2024 Arndt Dover Police Department her community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue 09/17/2024 and email from M/Cpl. Lee $250.00 $9,950.00 $15,050.00 Weekend. Killen dated 09/17/2024. Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated 9/17/2024 Boggerty Dover Police Department his community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue 09/17/2024 and email from M/Cpl. Lee $250.00 $10,200.00 $14,800.00 Weekend. Killen dated 09/17/2024. Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $300 of his Email from Bill Hare dated 09/17/2024 9/17/2024 Hare Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue and email from M/Cpl. Lee Killen dated $300.00 $10,500.00 $14,500.00 Weekend. 09/17/2024. Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $250 of his Email from Fred Neil dated 09/17/2024 9/17/2024 Neil Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue and email from M/Cpl. Lee Killen dated $250.00 $10,750.00 $14,250.00 Weekend. 09/17/2024. Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $500 of Email from Gerald Rocha dated Women and Children his community enhancement funds to the Women and 09/24/24 and Email & Letter from 9/24/2024 Rocha Transformation Ministry William Snorton, Jr. received $500.00 $11,250.00 $13,750.00 Children Transformation Ministry International, Inc. for their International, Inc. Boys to Men and their Girls Breaking Barriers program. 09/16/2024 Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson to the City $52.31 of his community enhancement funds to the Dover Clerk's Office dated 09/30/2024 and an Post for the Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing invoice dated 09/30/2024 9/30/2024 Anderson Independent Newsmedia, Inc. $52.31 $11,302.31 $13,697.69 advertisement for the Innovative Readiness Training Program Public Notice that ran on 09/29/2024.
Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $52.31 of Email from Bill Hare to the City Clerk's his community enhancement funds to the Dover Post for the Office dated 09/30/2024 and an invoice 10/31/2024 Hare Independent Newsmedia, Inc. Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing advertisement for the dated 10/31/2024 $52.31 $11,354.62 $13,645.38 Innovative Readiness Training Program Public Notice that ran on 10/06/2024.
Paj 109
Item #17.
| Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $52.31 of his | Email from Fred Neil to the City Clerk's | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| community enhancement funds to the Dover Post for the | Office dated 10/01/2024 and an invoice | ||||||
| 10/31/2024 | Neil | Independent Newsmedia, Inc. | Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing advertisement for the | dated 10/31/2024 | $52.31 | $11,406.93 | $13,593.07 |
| Innovative Readiness Training Program Public Notice that | |||||||
| ran on 10/13/2024. | |||||||
| Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $52.31 of | Email from Gerald Rocha to the | ||||||
| his community enhancement funds to the Dover Post for the | 10/08/2024 and an invoice dated | ||||||
| 10/31/2024 | Rocha | Independent Newsmedia, Inc. | Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing advertisement for the | 10/31/2024 | $52.31 | $11,459.24 | $13,540.76 |
| Innovative Readiness Training Program Public Notice that | |||||||
| ran on 10/20/2024. | |||||||
| Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $500 of hisEmail from Brain lewis dated | |||||||
| community enhancement funds to The Shepherd Place, Inc. | 11/19/2024 and an letter from Tasha | ||||||
| 11/19/2024 | Lewis | The Shepherd Place, Inc. | $500.00 | $11,959.24 | $13,040.76 | ||
| Schott Executive Director dated | |||||||
| 11/19/2024 | |||||||
| Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $500 of his Email from Bill Hare dated 11/19/2024 | |||||||
| community enhancement funds to The Shepherd Place, Inc. and an letter from Tasha Scott | |||||||
| 11/19/2024 | Hare | The Shepherd Place, Inc. | $500.00 | $12,459.24 | $12,540.76 | ||
| Executive Director dated 11/19/2024 | |||||||
Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated Concerned Citizens of the $400 of his community enhancement funds to Concerned 11/19/2024 and an letter from Tasha 11/19/2024 Anderson $400.00 $12,859.24 $12,140.76 Community Citizens of the Community Scott Executive Director dated 11/19/2024 Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $500 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated his community enhancement funds to The Shepherd Place, 11/22/2024 and an letter from Tasha 11/22/2024 Boggerty The Shepherd Place, Inc. $500.00 $13,359.24 $11,640.76 Inc. Scott Executive Director dated 11/19/2024 Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated $497.69 of his community enhancement funds to the Inner 12/062024 and an email from Ruben 11/19/2024 Anderson Inner City Cultural League $497.69 $13,856.93 $11,143.07 City Cultural League for their Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Saslters, CEO dated 12/05/2024 Program for 2025. Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $400 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated his community enhancement funds to The People's 12/16/2024 and an email from Dr. 12/16/2024 Boggerty The People's Community Center $400.00 $14,256.93 $10,743.07 Community Center for their Veterans Resources Center. Hodge Director and Frances Perry dated 12/16/2024 TOTALS $14,256.93 $10,743.07
Budgeted
District Council Sponsor YTD Expenditures Balance
Amount
| $5,000.00 | At-Large | Boggerty | $2,450.00 | $2,550.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 1st District | Pillsbury | $750.00 | $1,750.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 1st District | Rocha | $2,052.31 | $447.69 |
| $2,500.00 | 2nd District | Hare | $1,152.31 | $1,347.69 |
| $2,500.00 | 2nd District | Lewis | $2,000.00 | $500.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 3rd District | Arndt | $1,050.00 | $1,450.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 3rd District | Neil | $802.31 | $1,697.69 |
| $2,500.00 | 4th District | Anderson | $2,500.00 | $0.00 |
| $2,500.00 | 4th District | Sudler | $1,500.00 | $1,000.00 |
| TOTAL | $14,256.93 | $10,743.07 |
Paj 110
Item #18.
CITY MANAGER’S MONTHLY REPORT
November 2024
1
Paj 111
Item #18.
Blank
Page
2
Paj 112
Item #18.
3
Paj 113
Item #18.
4
Paj 114
Item #18.
CENTRAL SERVICES MONTHLY REPORT
November 2024
PROCUREMENT & INVENTORY DIVISION
Purchase Orders for Stock by Fund
| FY 2025 to Date | Difference from FY 2024 | |
|---|---|---|
| Electric | $2,048,398.75 | 6.1% |
| Water | $46,670.00 | 85.9% |
| Wastewater | $2,397.00 | 67.9% |
| General | $41,629.93 | -97.9% |
| Total | $2,139,095.68 | 5.9% |
Issues from Stock by Fund
| FY 2025 to Date | Difference from FY 2024 | |
|---|---|---|
| Electric | $653,010.87 | -55.7% |
| Water | $67,136.61 | 60.6% |
| Wastewater | $1,430.54 | 100.0% |
| General | $55,086.00 | -3.4% |
| Total | $776,664.02 | -41.6% |
Bids/RFPs Solicited
| FY 2025 to Date | Difference from FY 2024 |
|---|---|
| 22 | 22.7% |
Money Spent for Postal Services
| FY 2025 to Date | FY 2024 to Date |
|---|---|
| $89,780.51 | $74,845.76 |
Fuel Usage
| Type | FY 2025 to Date | FY 2024 to Date |
|---|---|---|
| Unleaded | 63,206 | 62,451 |
| Diesel | 35,009 | 34,169 |
| Dollars Spent | $243,622.97 | $274,741.98 |
5
Paj 115
Item #18.
Warehouse Stock Value
| FY 2025 | FY 2024 |
|---|---|
| $4,626,069.02 | $3,284,865.60 |
Purchase Orders for Stock are up 5.9% compared to this time last year.
Issues from Stock are down 41.6% compared to this time last year.
Bids/RFP's are up 22.7% compared to this time last year.
Postal Expenses are up 16.6% compared to this time last year.
Fuel Costs are down 12.8% compared to this time last year.
Overall warehouse value is up 29.0% compared to this time last year.
FLEET DIVISION
| PM Work Orders Scheduled: | PM Work Orders | Total Work Orders PM & |
|---|---|---|
| 16 | Completed: 46 | Repair: 139 |
| Total Hours Turned: | Excess Hours Turned: | Uncaptured Time: |
|---|---|---|
| 296 | 0 | 64 |
MEASURE November 2024 November 2023
Completed PM's 46 39
DIFFERENCE 17.95%
There were 16 PM's scheduled for this month. A total of 46 PM's were completed along with 93 repair work orders. There were a total of 139 work orders completed.
6
Paj 116
Item #18.
FACILITIES DIVISION
Routine Work Orders Emergency Work Orders
Completed: 52 Completed: 7
City-owned Facility Work Events & Support Work Orders: 54 Orders: 5
MEASURE November 2024 November 2023
Completed Work Orders 59 74
DIFFERENCE -20.27%
There were 59 routine and emergency Work Orders completed during this month. The work orders consisted of 54 for maintenance and repair of City-owned facilities and 5 related to events and other support work.
Central Services Narrative The Warehousing & Procurement office is operating as normal. Facilities staff has been busy setting up the Santa house, Santa's sleigh and helping with the trees on the lake. Fleet is operating as normal at this time and maintaining leaf equipment and refuse trucks.
7
Paj 117
Item #18.
CENTRAL SERVICES PROJECT UPDATE
November 2024
FY/PROJECT NUMBER DEPARTMENT STATUS
CENTRAL SERVICES FC2303 COMPLETE! CITY HALL WINDOWS
ELECTRIC System is 100% operational,
EA2204
WEYANDT HALL HVAC pending commissioning.
CENTRAL SERVICES FC2402 COMPLETE! CITY HALL EXTERIOR PAINT
CENTRAL SERVICES CS2405 COMPLETE! WASH BAY ROOF & DOORS
WATER WASTE WATER WD2409 COMPLETE! WTP RENOVATIONS
CS2501 WAREHOUSE ROOF 75% COMPLETE
CS2502 FUEL ISLAND UPGRADE RFP pending final draft
8
Paj 118
Item #18.
Recap of monthly activities / notations –
As of November 30, 2024 the City of Dover served 25,051 electric utility customers and 13,240 water utility customers as compared to 2023, which represents 24,904 and 13,106 respectively. These figures were tabulated from the monthy utility bill summary report which tracks billing across all utility bill rate classifications. 2,312 phone calls were answered in the month of November by 5 staff members of customer service. Customer Service has been able to recruit for the open cashier position and their start date is on 12/2/24. We are working to get the open Field Service Rep I and Customer Service Clerk I position filled.
Receivable Comparison FY 2024 to Utility Disconnections for November 2024 FY2025 to date (November 2024) 0 accounts were disconnected for non-payment of service. Compared to the same time last year the City had open receivables of Due to staffing no cuts were processed. $8,945,454.07 vs $11,736,656.99. Ending Utility Receivable Due - $7,729,662.41
Customer Service Department Mission
Continually provide quality public service to our diverse group of customers with professionalism, respect, & integrity. ~ City of Dover Customer Service Department
9
Paj 119
Item #18.
ASSESSOR’S REPORT
| Number of Deeds Stamped for | Transfer Tax Dollar Amount | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| the Month of Nov. 2023/2024 | for$96 | ||
| the Month of Nov. | |||
| $99 | |||
| 30 | |||
| 26 24 | $100 | 2023/2024 | |
| 25 | 16 20 | 20 19 | |
| Thousand | |||
| 20 | |||
| 15 | $50 | $35$40 | $39 |
| s | |||
| 10 | 1 2 | $12 | $0 $1 |
| 5 | 0 1 | 2023 | 2023 |
| 0 | $0 | ||
| 2024 | 2024 | ||
| First Time Buyer for the | Nov. 2023/2024 Realty | |
|---|---|---|
| Month of Nov. 2023/2024 | Property Sales in Dollars | |
| Received Prior to Recording | ||
| 30 | 26 | |
| 24 | ||
| 20 | $6 $7 | $5 |
| $8 | $5 | |
| 16 | $6 | |
| Millions | ||
| 20 | Res. Non-First | $3 |
| $4 | $1 | $0 $0 |
| Time Buyers | $2 | 2023 |
| 10 | $0 | |
| Res. First Time | 2024 | |
| Buyers | ||
| 0 | ||
| 2023 | 2024 | |
Major Updates
| September | October | November | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assessment Change | $5,535,700 | $476,00 | $0 |
Residential Sales Ratio Report
| Sales in Study | Total Assessed | Total Sale Price | Ratio | PRD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Value | ||||
| 20 | $3,122,300 | $5,359,230 | 0.58 | 1.00 |
Ratio – Assessed Value divided by Sale Price. PRD – Mean – A PRD above 1.03 tends to indicate assessment regressivity – high valued properties are under appraised relative to low valued properties. A PRD below .98 tends to indicate assessment progressivity – high valued properties are relatively over appraised.
10
Paj 120
Item #18.
ASSESSOR’S REPORT
Tax Office
Wild Meadows / Persimmon Park Place Home Sales for November 2024:
Property Address Assessed Value Sales Price
118 KURT DRIVE $72,100 $150,000
11
Paj 121
012ÿ456ÿ4745 77ÿ 1ÿ98 289 ÿ ÿ0ÿ1 19ÿ 1ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ 245 80 =>?0 @2 001 @=899 1 >9 9 81 0120@ 9 9ÿ 1ÿ09 821 !!" !% '! ! %ÿ)*+,ÿ-,.ÿ' ! !" " ! !&!$ 5; *2 ÿÿÿÿÿ !!<$ .32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ$%< ÿ #! "! % '! "&ÿ'+'/.0*012ÿ,. ! !$ ! $ !"" 5 *2 ÿÿÿÿÿ!&< ! .32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ$$< ÿ& #!"$ % '! !$%ÿ3,ÿ43'-ÿ' ! !$ !&# ! 7 *2 ÿÿÿÿÿ!!#< .32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ "$< ÿ"% #!#! $ '! ÿ+55,ÿ2*,,6ÿ' ! !&&" & 5; *2 ÿÿÿÿÿ #< !$.32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ$ < ÿ% #!% !# '! #! ÿ1.+..7ÿ5,2 ! !&&! !%$" 5 *2 ÿÿÿÿÿ!&<$ !&.32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ$ < ÿ %!"!! '! !"ÿ0*ÿ+*'06ÿ0', !$ !"& 5 *2 ÿÿÿÿÿ!#&< ! .32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ$!< ÿ% #$!! !" '! !%#ÿÿ/8,'*9ÿ71' ! !$ !% 7; *2 ÿÿÿÿÿ!< #.32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ %< ÿ #"!! '! %ÿ5*..1.-ÿ/0 ! !$ " !" 7; *2 ÿÿÿÿÿ!"#<$ ".32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ$!#<&& ÿ" #"! &! ' &ÿ+*'ÿ8*2.ÿ' ! !&#% ! # $ 7 *2 ÿÿÿÿÿÿ"< !".32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ!!< ÿ$& #! !" '! !!ÿ)*008:ÿ70 ! !&&$ # 7; - ÿÿÿÿÿ!%< !.32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ$$< ÿ # !!$ ' !ÿ-'*.ÿ8*,,ÿ ! !&#$ ! #&" 5 - ÿÿÿÿÿÿ<$ ".32 " ÿÿÿÿÿ! < ÿ""
12
Page 121 Item #18.
Paj 122
012ÿ456ÿ4745
| 77ÿ | 1ÿ98 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 289 ÿ ÿ0ÿ1 | |||||||
| 19ÿ | 1ÿ4ÿÿÿÿÿÿ | ||||||
| 245 | |||||||
| 80 | =>?0 @2 001 | @=899 1 >9 9 81 | 0120@ 9 9ÿ 1ÿ09 | 821 | |||
| !"! # $" ) $ÿ+ÿ(,)-'.+ÿ/' | $ | #%% | %% 3: | ,; ÿÿÿÿÿÿ%<# ! +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ< | ÿ"! | |
| !" $#" & ) $ÿ+-)01-2+ÿ) | $ | $ | %&% (: | ,; ÿÿÿÿÿ&!<# +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$!&<## | ÿ" | |
| " ! #" ! ) $ÿ+-3ÿ1.''ÿ) | $! | $ | #$ 3 | ,; ÿÿÿÿÿ$< % +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$&< | ÿ"#! | |
| " %" ! ) $&!ÿ+-3ÿ1.''ÿ) | $ | $ | $$ 3 | ,; ÿÿÿÿÿ&&<% $$ +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$< | ÿ"& | |
| " $" ) %$ÿ45+40ÿ0) | ! | ## | !$! (: | ,; ÿÿÿÿÿ<! $! +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$< | ÿ"! | |
| " ! $" $ ) %ÿ6-+)-ÿ0) | #&% | ! ( | ,; ÿÿÿÿÿ&< $ +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$< | ÿ"& | ||
| %"% $" $ ) %ÿ-,7ÿ'+ | & | #!$ | ! ( | ,; ÿÿÿÿÿ<% +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$< | ÿ" | |
| %"% &" $ ) &ÿ8.')4ÿ9)+ | & | #!& | ! ( | 9 ÿÿÿÿÿ%< +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ$%< | ÿ"! | |
| '( %"& "% ) %ÿ75)0ÿ) | $! | $% ( | 9 ÿÿÿÿÿÿ$< +-; $& | ÿÿÿÿÿ< | ÿ"&% | ||
13
Page 122 Item #18.
Paj 123
Item #18. ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT MONTHLY REPORT For the month of November 2024, the Electric Department contributed to the quality of life for all our customers.
The city experienced a system peak of 98.47 megawatts, a decrease of 4.1 megawatts from last month and a 2.2 megawatt increase from the same month last year.
There was a total of 4 outages for the month affecting a total of 793 customers with an average outage time of 77.17 minutes.
Project Updates:
The department continues to work in the new developments and services as well as other assorted other work. We are continuing work on scheduled FY25 capital projects. The department worked to finalize the agreement with the engineering firm to commence work on the full system study.
Pole testing remained stalled due to new development and capital project work, but the roadway LED light replacements are complete.
Substation construction continues as it can while we wait for the arrival of the switchgear building. The demolition of McKee Run was all but complete in November with the final piece needing to come from DNREC on the excavation of the previously identified soil contaminants.
Van Sant was not called on for the month but remains ready for dispatch.
FY 25 YTD Outages and Response Time: Total – 37 Average Response Time – 26.9 minutes (Goal – Less than 30 minutes)
Statistics: 3-year average: FY Average:
Average Interruption
Duration Index (SAIDI) 170.03 minutes 12.21 minutes
Goal – Not to exceed 100 mins
System Average Interruption
Frequency Index (SAIFI) 1.79 per cust .2 per cust
Goal – Not to exceed 1 per customer
Customer Average Interruption
Duration Index (CAIDI) 94.9 minutes 77.38 minutes
Lost Time Accidents – Workorders Generated –
Current Month – 0 Total FY – 0 Current Month – 110 Total FY – 660
14
Paj 124
Item #18.
ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT MONTHLY REPORT
FY25
Historical Peak Load
180
160
140
120
| 100 | 2022 |
| Megawatts | |
|---|---|
| 80 | 2023 |
| 2024 | |
| 60 | |
40
20
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
15
Paj 125
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
NOVEMBER 2024
City of Dover Human Resources Mission Statement: The City of Dover’s Human Resources Department strives to provide quality service to assist our greatest asset, our employees. Equity, Integrity, and Urgency is our focus to ensure employee satisfaction as well as company wellness. We implement policies and procedures that align with organizational goals, including a safe and compliant workplace, effective training and professional development, and addressing both the needs of employees and the organization.
City of Dover Human Resources Value Statement:
Innovation: We strive to include best HR practices to enhance a robust technological movement to enhance the quality and efficiency of the department.
Collaboration: We honor knowledge sharing, diversity of thoughts and ideas, and experiences to encourage an inclusive workforce.
Integrity and Transparency: We honor our commitments and promote a healthy environment that promotes fairness, honesty, respect, and trust.
Results Driven: Customer service is front and center, and we advocate for employees' and retirees’ needs at all times.
NOVEMBER SUMMARY:
November Hiring Trends FY24:
| MONTH | NEW HIRE AMOUNT | STATUS |
|---|---|---|
| NOVEMBER | 3 | 2 FT. 1 PT |
November Voluntary Termination/Involuntary Termination Trends FY24:
VOLUNTARY 1 FT, 0 PT INVOLUNTARY 0 RETIREMENT 3 FT
16
Paj 126
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
NOVEMBER EEO DATA
EEO DATA
2%
3%
6% 3%
15%
72%
AMERICAN INDIAN ASIAN AFRICAN AMERICAN CAUCASIAN HISPANIC OTHER RACE
| AMERICAN INDIAN | 3% |
| ASIAN | 2% |
| AFRICAN AMERICAN | 15% |
| CAUCASIAN | 72% |
| HISPANIC | 3% |
| OTHER RACE | 6% |
17
Paj 127
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
NOVEMBER EEO DEMOGRAPHICS
EEO DEMOGRAPHICS
MINORITY 87
CAUCASIAN 295
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
| CAUCASIAN | 295 |
| MINORITY | 87 |
18
Paj 128
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
NOVEMBER GENDER REPORT
GENDER REPORT 0%
27%
73%
FEMALE MALE NONBINARY
| MALES | 73% |
| FEMALE | 27% |
| NON-BINARY 0% | |
|---|---|
19
Paj 129
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
FULL-TIME VS. PART-TIME EE’S
FULL - TIME VS. PART - TIME 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC
FULL TIME PART TIME TOTAL EE'S
Numbers do not reflect temporary, seasonal, relief fire dispatchers, committees, or council members.
| MONTH | JAN FEB MAR | APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FULL- TIME 356 358 362 | 365 365 | 364 | 364 360 358 263 363 | ||||||
| PART-TIME 31 | 30 25 | 29 | 27 | 26 | 29 | 31 | 34 | 31 | 32 |
| TOTAL EE'S 387 388 387 | 394 392 | 390 | 393 391 392 394 395 |
20
Paj 130
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
NOVEMBER INTERNAL EE AGE DEMOGRAPHICS
AGE DEMOGRAPHICS
18-24 6%
25-34 27%
35-44 22%
45-54 23%
55-64 18%
65+ 5%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%
| AGE | PERCENTAGE |
|---|---|
| 18-24 | 6% |
| 25-34 | 27% |
| 35-44 | 22% |
| 45-54 | 23% |
| 55-64 | 18% |
| 65 + | 5% |
21
Paj 131
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
HIRING DETAILS
Position Hired: 1 FT MEOI/WATER WASTEWATER, 1 FT LICENSED ELECTRICAN/FACILITIES MAINTENANCE, 1 PT LIBRARY CLERK/LIBRARY Transferred/Promoted: 0 Position Terminated/Resigned/Retired/Other: 1 FT VOLUNTARY TERM, 3 FT RETIREMENTS Terminal Leave: N/A
CURRENT VACANT POSITIONS
*Not used for Budgeting Purposes
22
Paj 132
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
TURNOVER STATISTICS
Monthly
| Number of | Average | Quarterly | Annual | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Turnover | |||||
| Month | Separated | Number of | Turnover | Turnover | |
| Rates | |||||
| Employees | Employees | Rates | Rate | ||
| (Percentage) | |||||
| January | 0 | 387 | 0.0% | ||
| February | 1 | 388 | 0.3% | ||
| March | 4 | 387 | 1.0% | 1.3% | |
| April | 4 | 394 | 1.0% | ||
| May | 2 | 392 | 0.5% | ||
| June | 2 | 390 | 0.5% | 2.0% | |
| July | 4 | 393 | 1.0% | ||
| August | 4 | 391 | 1.0% | ||
| September | 18 | 392 | 4.6% | 6.6% | |
| October | 4 | 394 | 1.0% | ||
| November | 4 | 395 | 1.0% | ||
| December | 0 | 1 | 0.0% | 2.0% | 12.0% |
23
Paj 133
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Monthly Turnover Rates (Percentage)
5.0%
4.6%
4.5%
4.0%
3.5%
3.0%
2.5%
2.0%
1.5%
1.0% 1.0% 1.0% 1.0% 1.0% 1.0%
1.0%
| 0.5% | 0.5% |
| 0.5% | 0.3% |
| 0.0% | 0.0% |
| 0.0% | |
|---|---|
24
Paj 134
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Quarterly and Annual Turnover Rates
14.0%
Annual, 12.0%
12.0%
10.0%
8.0%
Q3, 6.6%
6.0%
4.0%
| Q2, 2.0% | Q4, 2.0% |
|---|---|
| 2.0% | Q1, 1.3% |
0.0%
25
Paj 135
Item #18.
HUMAN RESOURCES
NOVEMBER WORKER’S COMPENSATION DATA
| MONTH | OCT 24 | NOV-24 |
|---|---|---|
| WORKERS COMP INJURY DETAIL | 1 | 1 |
WORKERS COMP COST NOVEMBER 2024
Total
Grounds
Customer Service
Police
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000
Respectfully Submitted by H. Naomi Poole
26
Paj 136
Item #18.
Information Technology Department
November 2024 Report
Larry Josefowski, Director
State and Local Community Cybersecurity Grant project: We continue to provide updates on the grant process and received final approval during the last week of November. While the funds are now available, I have requested approval from City Council to accept and add in to the IT budget the 80K in funding.
Tyler Enterprise ERP and HTE/Naviline: We received a letter from Tyler requesting payment, and we responded to them, and our account manager, letting them know that we intend to not move forward with any more of the applications on that platform.
IT and Finance met with HTE/Naviline to discuss our plans for consolidation on their platform. While our tentative plans are to simply stop moving forward with Tyler (I included our previous thought process below in italics), and upgrading and getting to a steady state, HTE/Naviline seems very interested in converting us back, and may make it very financially advantageous to do so sooner rather than later.
I should note that we will be on two ERPs for a given period of time – at least long enough to stabilize the two platforms. Our plan would be to eventually migrate to a single platform – whether this it HTE/Naviline or a third party is unknown at this time. Additionally, the timeframe for consolidation has not been decided, but I do not see this being budgeted until at least the 2027 budget cycle.
Network improvements: We continue to update and improve our network, including the replacement of one of our Hyper-V servers, which is a “super server”, in that it is one of our devices that our servers run on. Some of this involves updating hardware and software, and sometimes upgrades don’t go as well as we would have liked. We had an issue at the end of the month with an upgrade to some of the underlying client configuration software. We were having issues with some outdated hardware communicating with our newer hardware, and we attempted to upgrade the software that allows them to communicate. Unfortunately, it did not go as planned. We had planned for a weekend fix, but it continued into the following week. We got it resolved, and the system is more stable than before, but there was an impact that hopefully will not happen again.
Metrics: We track a fairly large number of metrics, and we’re highlighting some of the ones we don’t usually show, and why we track them. While
Number of Incidents: The number of incidents dipped below our average for the first time in 6 months, likely due to the Thanksgiving holiday.
Percent Windows 11 installed: Windows 10 support ends next October, but I want to have all our computers upgraded by the end of September 2025. We have approximately 115 workstations left to upgrade.
Time to Close Incidents: The time to resolve incidents continued to increase over the last month. Part of this is due to the holidays, as well, as the free software tool we use does not take holidays into account. However, the large number of incidents last month likely had an impact on the time to resolve this month’s incidents.
27
Paj 137
Item #18.
| Percent training completed | Percent Windows 11 installed |
|---|---|
| 100% | 40% |
| 95% | |
| 90% | 30% |
| 85% | |
| 80% | 20% |
| 75% | |
| 70% | 10% |
| 65% | |
| 60% | 0% |
| Number of Incidents | Time to close incidents |
|---|---|
| 180 | 10 d 0 h |
| 160 | |
| 140 | 7d0h |
| 120 | |
| 100 | 4d0h |
| 80 | |
| 60 | 1d0h |
28
Paj 138
Reference Transactions
November 2024 Item #18.
Adults 302
Teens 54
Children
192
0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000
**Statistics Unavailable Due To A Statewide Extended Internet Outage
| Circulation | November '24 | FYTD '25 | November '23 | FYTD '24 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City of Dover Residents | 8,881 | 52,790 | 10,306 | 53,169 |
| Electronic Materials | 6,804 | 35,317 | 4,949 | 25,350 |
| Kent County Residents | 9,572 | 53,972 | 9,256 | 48,670 |
| Non-County Residents | 1,105 | 6,547 | 1,236 | 6,805 |
| New Library Registrations | ||||
| City of Dover Residents | 178 | 1,240 | 192 | 1,102 |
| Kent County Residents | 82 | 556 | 139 | 786 |
| Non-County Residents | 4 | 24 | 2 | 31 |
| Registered Library Users as of 11/30/2024 | Registered Library Users as of 11/28/2023 | |||
| City of Dover Residents | 19,992 | 18,161 | ||
| Kent County Residents | 9,484 | 7,965 | ||
| Non-County Residents | 702 | 639 | ||
| TOTAL | 30,178 | 26,765 | ||
| Other | ||||
| Visitors | 10,340 | 72,529 | 13,085 | 72,889 |
| Meeting Room Attendance | 1,938 | 15,458 | 2,550 | 14,030 |
| **Number of Computer Users | N/A | 4,075 | 1,531 | 8,845 |
| **Number of Wireless Computer Users | N/A | 3,414 | 1,413 | 7,845 |
| Inter/Intralibrary - Loaned | 49 | 50 | ||
| Inter/Intralibrary - Borrowed | 68 | 56 | ||
| Holds Sent | 2,370 | 2,607 | ||
| Holds Received | 1,682 | 1,888 | ||
| TOTAL | 4,169 | 20,657 | 4,601 | 24,975 |
| Tech Services/Items Added | 823 | 854 | ||
| Tech Services/Items Deleted | 381 | 761 | ||
| Passport Services/Customers | 233 | 1,131 | 208 | 1,028 |
| Passport Services/Revenue | $9,642 | $46,178 | $8,482 | $40,518 |
| Monthly Highlights | ||||
| ►250 attended 42 programs for adults. | ||||
| ►48 attended 16 program for teens. | ||||
| ►1,178 attended 37 programs for children. | ||||
| ► 0 volunteers. | ||||
| Program Spotlight | ||||
29
Paj 139
Item #18.
30
Paj 140
Item #18. Parks & Recreation Monthly Report - November 2024 Parks & RecreaƟon Highlights Five Park Projects Update Dover Park Building and Spray Pad. Staff con nues to follow the project. Dry wall is mostly completed, work has begun on the Spray Pad. Building target opening date has been moved to early 2025. All Accessible Playground staff con nues to follow this project. Equipment was purchased last year. The equipment is onsite in storage containers. Skate Park in progress as noted in the FY25 CIP list. The Do It Yourself Skatepark is open. At this me, staff is working with WRA for construc on ready bid documents.
John W. PiƩs RecreaƟon Center was busy with two big events. The Delaware Department of Elec ons u lized our facility as a 2024 Elec on Site, bringing in many people who otherwise may not visit our park and building. This is a good opportunity to our cons tuents learn what we have to offer. The second event to note, is the return of the Delaware Middle School Volleyball Invita onal sponsored by DADD. This tournament serves up a great me for Middle School girls on their respec ve school teams.
Recreation Revenue Breakdown Outdoor Sports & Leagues
ParƟcipant & Spectator Count
AcƟvity ParƟcipants Spectators LocaƟon
Moved inside for the winter!
| November 2024 | November 2023 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| General Recrea on | $600.00 | General Recrea on | $1,526 |
| Sports | $330.00 | Sports | $2,205.00 |
| Leagues | $12,360.00 | Leagues | $8,250 |
| A peek inside! | |||
| Trips | $2,785.00 | Trips | $3,698.50 |
| Bldg, Field, Pavilion & Stage | Bldg, Field, Pavilion & Stage | ||
| $315.00 | permits | ||
| $2,677.50 | |||
| permits | |||
| Parks & RecreaƟon | FYTD | FYTD |
|---|---|---|
| Nov. 24 | Nov. 23 | |
| Programs | 25 | 24 |
| General Recrea on | 178 | 1,941 | 265 | 1,106 |
| Open Gym | 182 | 505 | 272 | 877 |
| Sports | 54 | 496 | 52 | 415 |
| Leagues (Inside) | 0 | 9,706 | 280 | 9,913 |
| Bldg, Field, Facility permits | 6 | 69 | 5 | 46 |
| Camps | 0 | 1,609 | 0 | 1,639 |
**Holiday Food Drive and Capital Holiday FesƟval December 5**
31
Paj 141
Item #18.
Grounds Monthly Report
NOV. 2024
| Arborist Crew: | Arborist Crew | |
|---|---|---|
| - Worked on Holiday light repairs. Tree Work Completed | ||
| - Trimmed street trees. Tree's Trimmed 8 | ||
| Tree's Removed | 11 | |
| Beautification Crew: | Root Pruning | 0 |
| - Planted Tulips. Stumps Removed 2 | ||
| - Worked on holiday decorations. Trees Planted 0 | ||
| - Cut ornamental grass at City property. | ||
| - Clean and maintaine flowers beds | ||
| Mowing Crew: | ||
| - General clean up of mowing locations. | ||
| - Worked on holiday decorations. | ||
| - Spread stone in City Hall Parking lot | ||
| Litter Removal: | ||
| - Litter is being picked up on city property as per the weekly schedule. | ||
| - Litter person has been diligent in the reporting of destruction in City parks. | ||
| - 288 Total 90 gallon cans collected. | ||
| Removed 15 Shopping Carts. | ||
Parks Crew:
- Completed parks route daily.
- Planted tulips
- Worked on holiday decorations
Miscellaneous:
- Decorated Police memorial with holiday lights.
- Placed 34 wreaths on City Buildings.
- Installed 76 Wreaths on lights poles.
- Installed 76 strands of garland on light poles.
32
Paj 142
Item #18.
Litter Cans Collected
800
600
400
200
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov
2021 2022 2023 2024
Trees Removed
80
60
40
20
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov
2021 2022 2023 2024
Trees Trimmed
250
200
150
100
50
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov
2021 2022 2023 2024
33
Paj 143
Item #18.
City Planner’s Monthly Report
Department of Planning & Inspections
NOVEMBER 2024
Planning & Inspections Highlights Some Items to Call to Your Attention The Planning Office is part of the review process for certain types of construction activity permits. In November, staff reviewed 46 Building Permits and 7 Certificates of Occupancy Permits. Planning Office staff also provided support to the Planning Commission (3 applications reviewed) and the Board of Adjustment (2 applications reviewed). In particular, at the Planning Commission meeting, Public Hearings and consideration of Text Amendments pertaining to Recreational Marijuana Land Uses occurred. The Planning Office continued to have 3 vacancies including the Director, a Planner II and a Planner I. Construction activity continued in November with both residential and non-residential pro- jects. Residential development areas included Eden Hill Farm TND and individual structures lo- cated in various locations across the city. Non- residential projects included a Garrison Homes Flex Warehouse Building, renovations at Owens Manor and a tenant fit-out for a liquor store in Uno Plaza II. Overall, 145 permits were issued resulting in 354 inspections. Within the Inspections Division, the Chief Building Inspector, Greg Akers, retired after over 20 years of service. Although this position was posted a number of months prior to his retirement, finding qualified candidates has been challenging. In order to ensure construction activity is not stalled, the Department is utilizing a contractor to assist in building permit/plan reviews. Department Division Managers began work on the preparation of the FY26 budget including opera- tional budget and revenue projection. At the end of November, 41.6% of FY25 had passed. Total revenue at that time for the Department was at 63% of the $3,195,000 budget. Code Enforcement staff conducted Annual Housing Inspections (17 cases) as part of the Rental Dwelling Permit program. Other Code Enforcement cases focused on exterior property maintenance issues/violations (31 cases) and Dover Code of Ordinance violations (50 cases). November ended with 119 registered vacant buildings, 55 dangerous buildings, and 7,846 active rental dwelling units. Staff within the Fire Marshal’s Office conducted 28 Annual Fire & Life Safety Inspections resulting in the identification of 34 deficiencies. Staff investigated 5 fire incidents which included a fire loss at a homeless camp. Staff also conducted bar checks on Thanksgiving Eve to ensure that all patrons were safe and all fire codes were being followed.
34
Paj 144
Item #18.
Planning & Inspections Revenue
FY 2025 Revenue FY2025 Actual
Estimates from (YTD) November
Revenue Stream Budget 2024 % of Budget
| Business License | $1,450,000 $ 1,521,018 | 105% | |
| Manufactured Home License | $14,000 $ | 14,828 | 106% |
| Building Permits | $550,000 $ | 289,832 | 53% |
| Cert. of Occupancy | $8,000 $ | 4,630 | 58% |
| Public Occupancy | $45,000 $ | 3,115 | 7% |
| Lodging House | $28,000 $ | 32 | 0% |
| Plumbing/Heating/Air | $100,000 $ | 48,340 | 48% |
| Rental Inspection Fee | $750,000 $ | 30,746 | 4% |
| Miscellaneous | $20,000 $ | 11,327 | 57% |
| Fire Protection Fees | $80,000 $ | 54,957 | 69% |
| Code Enforcement Fines | $100,000 $ | 22,701 | 23% |
| Vacant Building Reg. | $50,000 $ | 21,750 | 44% |
Total P&I Revenue $3,195,000 $ 2,023,276 63%
Planning Office Operations The Meetings of the Boards and Commission supported by the Planning Office are presented in the Hybrid format with both In-Person and Virtual (using Webex) meeting options for participation. Electronic commu- nications and conducting Meetings and Trainings in virtual formats are commonplace due to realized effi- ciencies. The Planning Office is part of the review process for certain types of construction activity permits (Building Permits, Sign Permits, etc.) and Certificate of Occupancy permits in order to confirm compliance with the Zoning Ordinance provisions. For November 2024, Planning Staff was involved with the review of 46 Build- ing Permits and 7 Certificates of Occupancy permits that were issued for a monthly total of 53 and a year-to -date total of 835. The 2024 year-to-date tally is lower than the year-to-date totals of Permits and COs seen in 2023 at 979 and in 2022 at 932. Staff also reviews new applications for Business Licenses and Rental Dwelling Permits.
FY2025-2026 Budget: The Department of Planning & Inspections division managers met to begin the prepa- ration of the FY2025-2026 Budget Draft focusing on operational activities.
| NOVEMBER 2025 (FY25) | TOTAL FOR FY25 | |
|---|---|---|
| New Home Permits Issued | 1 | 39 |
| Value of Commercial Projects | $3,212,597.00 | $22,721,203.00 |
| Downtown Incentives (Fees Waived) | ||
| $0.00 | $2,127.00 | |
35
Paj 145
Item #18.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPLEMENTATION
2019 Comprehensive Plan Implementation of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan continues as Departments citywide focus on the plan im- plementation items as found in Implementation Plan (Chapter 15) items such as the projects, studies, code amendments, and other activities. A copy of the Final Plan (as amended) is available on the Comprehensive Plan website: https://www.cityofdover.com/2019-comprehensive-plan Visit the Dover Parcel and Zoning Viewer on the City’s website to see zoning information for properties located in Dover. Use the Quick Link on the main page www.cityofdover.com.
Other Activities • Downtown Dover Strategic Master Plan: The Downtown Dover Partnership’s Strategic Master Plan is known as “Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030” (January 2023). Various partners are focusing on aspects of Plan implementation. The Downtown Dover Partnership is moving forward with planning for development of priority project sites. filing an application for review by the Historic District Commission. Also, the City is involved in planning for water and sanitary sewer improvement projects. • Downtown Development District – Renewal Application: The Downtown Development District (DDD) for the City of Dover was designated in January 2015 for a period of ten years. The City applied for a five-year extension of DDD designation and its initial approval granted by the State Cabinet Committee in August. The next step is preparation of amendments to the Dover Code of Ordinances to formally es- tablish the revised Downtown Development District Boundary. A Kick-off meeting was held in Novem- ber with the consultant (Rossi Group) who is continuing with the project to develop the required code text amendments and other implementation documents.
Construction Activities • In November 2024, Residential Building Permits were issued for an Apartment Building at Eden Hill Farm TND (S-24-01); a single family detached dwelling on Ann Avenue; and a manufactured home placement in Dover East Estates. • Certificates of Occupancy were issued to three (3) Townhouse units in the Villages of Maple Dale PND- SCHO and two (2) Duplex units in Chestnut Grove Farms. • Building Permits issued in November were for a tenant fit-out of a contractor’s office/laboratory space in a unit in the Garrison Homes Flex Warehouse Building at 110 Lafferty Lane; renovations at Owens Manor; generator installation at 415 Transportation Circle; tenant shell space creation in the North Do- ver Shopping Center; and tenant fit-out for a liquor store in Uno Plaza II at 1125 N DuPont Hwy. • A Temporary Certificate of Occupancy was granted to a tenant fit-out renovations for office space at 60 Starlifter Avenue. A Certificate of Occupancy was issued for a tenant fit-out for Hangry Joe’s Hot Chick- en Restaurant at Capital Station.
36
Paj 146
Item #18.
2024: Welcome to Dover!
Progress in Pictures
Fortescue Zero
1414 N DUPONT HWY -MOD CAR WASH
60 Starlifter Ave
Commercial
Tenant Fit-out
Delaware
State Universi-
Hangry Joe’s
50 N. Dupont
Hwy Unit 7
Commercial
Tenant Fit-out
37
Paj 147
Item #18.
2024: Welcome to Dover!
Progress in Pictures
35 7 & 11 Barrington Way
1360 College Rd
49 Maple
Dale Rd
47 Maple
Eden Hill Farm TND - Dale Rd
119, 117, 115, 113, 111
Ridgley Blvd. By
38
Paj 148
Item #18.
BOARD AND COMMISSION ACTIVITY
There were Meetings in November of the Boards and Commissions supported by the Planning Office. The Planning Commission held two meetings on November 18, 2024 with Session 1 focused on a Conditional Use Plan and a Site Plan with Architectural Review Certification. consisted of reviewing two Conditional Use Plans and a Site Plan. Planning Commission Meeting Session 2 focused on review of the Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations. The Historic District Commission Meeting did not meet in November due to lack of agenda items, pushing its Annual Meeting until December. The Board of Adjustment met on November 20, 2024 to consider two Applications for variances: one related to signage and one related to bulk standards (lot area and setbacks).
Planning Commission: The Planning Commission met on November 18, 2024 with a meeting that consisted of (Session 1 and Ses- sion 2) and considered the following applications. The next Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for December 16, 2024. Session 1 • C-24-05 JJ’s Learning Experience II Child Day Care Center at 261 North DuPont Highway - The Plan- ning Commission granted the Conditional Use approval to convert an existing 12,000 SF tenant space (previous retail establishment) into a Child Day Care Center. The subject site is within a building located on a parcel developed as a shopping center known as the Centre at Dover. The subject site is located east of North DuPont Highway and east of Centre Drive (private drive). The property is zoned SC-2 (Community Shopping Center Zone). The owner of record is Mahavir Realty, LLC c/o HH Property Man- agement Inc. Applicant: JJ’s Learning Experience, LLC (Keith and Shawanda Johnson). Property Ad- dress: 261 North DuPont Highway, Suite 1. Tax Parcel: ED-05-068.14-01-03.05-000. Council District 3.
- •S-24-19 Legislative Hall Building Addition at 411 Legislative Avenue – The Planning Commission grant- ed conditional approval of a Site Development Plan Application and associated Architectural Review Cer- tification to permit renovation and expansion of Legislative Hall. The proposal includes a three-story 56,820 SF Building Addition on the east side of the existing Legislative Hall building creating a new main public entrance, a Plaza area with Monument Walk, and other site improvements. The main property of 2.80 acres+/- is zoned IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Pro- tection Overlay Zone) and the H (Historic District Zone). The other property of 0.43 acres+/- is zoned ROS (Recreational and Open Space Zone) and subject to H (Historic District Zone). The subject proper- ties are located on the east side of Legislative Avenue as the block between Martin Luther King Jr. Boule- vard North and Martin Luther King Jr. South. The owner of record is the State of Delaware. Property Ad- dresses: 411 Legislative Avenue and Court Street. Tax Parcels: ED-05-077.09-05-15.00-000 and ED-05- 077.09-05-14.00-000. Council District 4. The project was the subject of HI-24-07 for Historic District Commission Review and Recommendation on the Architectural Review Certification at their October 17, 2024 Meeting.
Session 2 Planning Commission Session 2 involved the Public Hearings and consideration of the following Text Amend- ments pertaining to Recreational Marijuana Land Uses. The Actions with Recommendations of the Planning Commission on each proposed Ordinance are given.
- •MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations - Public Hearing and Review for Recommendation to City Council of a series of Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance for establish provisions for recreational marijuana land uses and related zoning regulations.
- •Ordinance #2024-29: Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning: Article 3 - District Regulations Section 19 - Manufacturing Zone (M), Section 20 - Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), and Section 23 - Agricultural Zone (A); Article 5
- •Supplementary Regulations adding new Section 24 - Marijuana Related Businesses; and Article 12 - Defini- tions. These amendments add definitions for marijuana related businesses, allow these business types to oper- ate as permitted uses within certain zones, and add supplementary regulations by which these businesses Page 148 must abide. 39
Paj 149
Item #18.
Ordinance #2024-29: Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers.
Action: Planning Commission recommended denial of the Ordinance #2024-29. Mr. Michael Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zon- ing Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facili- ties and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances and adding a requirement for a 750 feet distancing requirement from courthouses, seconded by Mrs. Maucher and the motion failed with 4-5 by roll call vote(4 in favor, 5 against the motion). Mrs. Denney moved to recommend denial to City Council for Ordinance 2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordi- nance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, seconded by Dr. Jones and the motion was carried 5-4 by roll call vote (5 in favor and 4 against the motion to deny).
- B.Ordinance #2024-30: Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for retail marijuana stores and provisions for compassion center conversions by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning: Article 3 - District Regulations Section 16 - Highway Commercial Zone (C-4); Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations adding new Section 24 - Mari- juana Related Businesses; and Article 12 – Definitions. These amendments add the definition of retail marijuana stores and allow recreational marijuana stores to operate as permitted uses in the C-4 zone, and add supplementary regulations by which these businesses must abide.
Action: Planning Commission recommended denial of the Ordinance #2024-30. Mr. Witham moved to recommend denial to City Council for Ordinance #2024-30 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordi- nance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for retail marijuana stores and provisions for compas- sion center conversions by amending Dover Code of Ordinances for the reasons that he stated earlier and for the reasons that Mrs. Denney stated, seconded by Dr. Jones and the motion was carried 5-4 (5 favor and 4 against of denial) by roll call vote.
Historic District Commission: The Historic District Commission did not meet on November 21, 2024 due to lack of agenda items. The next Historic District Commission meeting is scheduled for December 19, 2024.
Board of Adjustment: The Board of Adjustment met on November 20, 2024. Two Applications were filed for Review and Public Hearing. The next Board of Adjustment meeting is scheduled for December 18, 2024.
- •Application #V-24-05 Property at 1151 N. DuPont Highway. The Board granted approval for the Vari- ance from the requirements of Zoning Ordinance, Article 5 §4.7 associated with signage for a new res- taurant building with drive-through and site improvements. The Variance as approved allows an increase in the number of permitted wall signs from two (2) wall signs to five (5) wall signs. The property is zoned C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) and subject to the SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone: Tier 3 – Excellent Recharge Area). The owner of record is Tung Ching Lin. Property Address: 1151 N. DuPont Highway, Dover DE. The Tax Parcel ID is ED-05-057.00-01-30.01-000.
- •Application #V-24-06 Property at 207 N. West Street. The Board granted approval for the Variances from the requirements of Zoning Ordinance, Article 4 §4.2 as associated with a proposal to subdivide the existing 12,168 SF parcel located at the northeast corner of N. West Street and Cecil Street into four (4) townhouse lots (Cecil Street Townhomes). Variance Request 1 as approved allows a reduction of the minimum lot depth to 84.5 feet from 100 feet. Variance Request 2 as approved allows a minimum lot ar- ea of 2,366 SF reduced from the required minimum lot area of 3,000 SF for two (2) of the townhouse lots. The property is zoned RG-1 (General Residence Zone). The owner of record is 4BL, LLC. Property Address: 207 N. West Street, Dover DE. The Tax Parcel ID is ED-05-076.08-02-01.00-000.
40
Paj 150
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT PROGRAM Item #18.
CDBG FY24 Projects
- •Homeownership Assistance Program CDBG funds will be used to provide homeownership assistance to first-time homebuyers who purchase affordable housing in the City of Dover. Three families have purchased homes year-to-date.
- •Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing (DIMH) CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for the shelter. This project is under- way. Ninety-five (95%) of program funds have been drawn down year-to-date.
- •Central Delaware Housing Collaborative CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for a women’s shelter. This project is underway.
- •Milford Housing Homeowner Rehabilitation/Emergency Home Repair Pro- grams CDBG funds will be used to rehabilitate existing owner-occupied housing in the City that are in violation of the City’s Housing Code and complete emergency home repairs to eliminate housing conditions that threaten the health and safety of low-income home- owners. Two (2) owner occupied homes have been rehabbed and seven (7) homes re- ceived emergency home repairs.
- •American Rescue Act (ARPA) Funding City Council approved to award a little over $1.8 million in grant funding for Housing and Community Service projects. All projects are underway. A little under $1.8 million or 85% of funds have been spent on Round 1 of ARPA funding year-to-date. Dover Housing Authority, Murphey School, and Reading Assist have completed their projects. ARPA Round 2 funding for a little under $500,000 was awarded to subgrantees in April 2023. Projects are currently underway. Thirty-five percent (35%) of funds have been drawn down for Round 2 with Murphey School completing their project.
41
Paj 151
Item #18.
CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY
DECEMEBER 2023 DECEMEBER
2023 DECEMEBER 2023 DE-
CEMEBER 2023 DECEMEBER 2023
DECEMEBER 2023 DECEMEBER
2023
Case Type Current MTD MTD FY23 % Changed YTD Total FY24 YTD Total
FY 23 % Changed YTD
Dangerous Buildings, Vacant Buildings, Demolitions & Announcements
Vacant Buildings currently registered - 119
Dangerous Buildings – 55
Active Rental Dwellings – 7,846 units
Demolished by Owner- 383 N Dupont Hwy (Kent Budget Motel)
42
Paj 152
Building Inspections & Licensing Summary Item #18.
July 2023—
July 2024–
Current June 2025 November FY’24 June 2024
PERMITTING AND LICENSING
| Permits Issued | NOV (2024) | NOV (2023) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY 25 | FYTD 25 | FY24 | FYTD 24 | |
| Administrative Permit | ||||
| 3 | 14 | 6 | 34 | |
| Building Addition/Renovation Permits | 19 | 140 | 29 | 154 |
| Building Permits | ||||
| 10 | 113 | 12 | 104 | |
| Demolition Permits | ||||
| 0 | 14 | 0 | 16 | |
| Fence Permits | 22 | 92 | 11 | 86 |
| Fire Prevention Permits | 0 | 32 | 4 | 42 |
| Mechanical Permits | ||||
| 33 | 207 | 27 | 128 | |
| Plumbing Permits | ||||
| 56 | 159 | 23 | 130 | |
| Sign Permits | 1 | 34 | 8 | 86 |
| Swimming Pool Permits | ||||
| 1 | 9 | 1 | 6 | |
| Subtotal | 814 | 786 | ||
| Business Licenses | 20 | 1651 | 39 | 1715 |
| Merchant Licenses | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | 312 | 14 | 331 | |
| Contractor Licenses | ||||
| 25 | 1140 | 29 | 1167 | |
| Subtotal | 3103 | 3213 | ||
Lodging House Licenses
| 1 | 3 | 0 | 2 | |
| Public Occupancy | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | 71 | 6 | 94 | |
| Rental Dwelling | 12 | 166 | 38 | 144 |
| Subtotal | 240 | 240 | ||
Manufactured Homes 7 297 36 258
BUILDING INSPECTIONS
| Inspections | NOV (2024) | NOV (2023) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| FY 25 | FYTD 25 | FY24 | FYTD 24 |
| Building (Inspections/CBI/Site Meetings) | |||
| 182 | 1342 | 131 | 732 |
| Plumbing/Mechanical | |||
| 165 | 1596 | 170 | 747 |
| Certificate of Occupancy | |||
| 7 | 63 | 1 | 68 |
43
Paj 153
Item #18. Office of the Fire Marshal -The Fire Marshal’s Office staff investigated five (5) inci- dents during the month of November including a fire loss at a homeless camp. - Staff conducted bar checks on Thanksgiving Eve to ensure that all patrons were safe and all fire codes were being fol- lowed. - Staff conducted an acceptance test on a new fire alarm sys- tem at the Bally's hotel and casino. - Annual Fire and Life Safety Inspections are being conduct- ed at mercantile occupancies.
| Month | Year to Date | Previous Year to Date | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual Fire & Life Safety Inspections | 28 | 155 | 131 |
Deficiencies From the Above Inspections 34 277 425
| Fire Code Violations/Deficiencies/ | 35 | 154 | 116 |
| Complaints | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| C/O & Fire Equipment Acceptance Tests | 9 | 41 | 55 |
Meetings & Walk Through 16 68 104
Fire Plan Review & DAC 6 49 56
Month Year to Date Previous Year to Date Accidental 2 totaling $5,001 25 totaling $417,102 17 totaling $1, 538,003
Incendiary 1 totaling $1 5 totaling $2,003 1 totaling $1
Undetermined 2 totaling $4,500 7 totaling $518,100 5 totaling $310,600
Natural 0 0 1 totaling $60,000
Investigation Time 6 hours 99 hours 52 hours
| Injuries | 1 | 11 | 2 |
| Deaths | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Arrest made with DPD 0 0 0
44
Paj 154
Item #18.
45
Paj 155
Item #18.
46
Paj 156
Item #18.
47
Paj 157
Item #18.
48
Paj 158
Item #18.
CITY OF DOVER
DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER
MONTHLY REPORT
Nov-24
Inflow & Infiltration Costs
This chart indicates the amount of money the City is
| $300,000.00 | spending on treating ground and / or rain water |
| through Kent County. This cost is being offset by the | |
|---|---|
| $250,000.00 | Ground Water Inflow Adjustment rate passed on to the |
| customers. April 2024 had a large amout of rainfall, | |
| $200,000.00 | causing a significant I & I deficit. July 2024 had a |
| inverted cost due to the timing of our report and the | |
| timing of the Kent County Bill | |
| $150,000.00 | |
$100,000.00
$50,000.00
$- Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24 $(50,000.00)
$(100,000.00)
I & I Cost
Water & Wastewater Repairs
Water mains and services are typically
| 7 | repaired at a higher rate when drastic |
| change in temperature occurs. This | |
|---|---|
| 6 | freeze and thaw cycle expands and |
| contracts the soil, causing cracks in the | |
| water line. November 2024 had large | |
| 5 | |
| fluctuations of temperature, causing a | |
| large volume of repairs. | |
| 4 | |
3
2
1
0 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24
Water Mains Repaired Water Services Repaired Wastewater Mains Repaired Wastewater Laterals Repaired
49
Paj 159
Item #18.
CITY OF DOVER
DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER
MONTHLY REPORT
Nov-24
Number of Brown Water Complaints
20
This chart indicates the number of
| 18 | complaints the Department receives. |
| March 2024 was high because it has | |
|---|---|
| 16 | been over 5 months since the last |
| flushing operation. August was high due | |
| 14 | |
| to a contractor illegally connecting to a | |
| 12 | hydrant |
10
8
6
4
2
0 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24
Number of Brown Water Complaints Linear (Number of Brown Water Complaints)
Department Spotlight - October
The Department of Water & Wastewater was tasked with
seeking out Community Transportation Funds to pave a
section of Kerbin Street. Our team received the notice to
proceed in the end of October and paved the street in
November!
50
Paj 160
Item #19.
Paj 161
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
This page intentionally left blank
PagePage
2 161
Paj 162
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
CITY OF DOVER
ACTIVITY REPORTS
November 2024
| FY24 YTD | FY25 YTD | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BANK TRENDS | ||||
| Number of Deposits Made (Hand, ACH & Wire, Lockbox) | 2,883 | 2,970 | ||
| Total Amount of All Deposits | $ 80,793,054 $ 102,057,652 | |||
| Other Activity | ||||
| Number of Pay Periods | 11 | 12 | ||
| Number of Direct Deposits Issued | 4,131 | 4,846 | ||
| Number of Pension Checks Issued | 1,299 | 1,497 | ||
| Total Pension Benefits Paid - Defined Benefit Plan | $ | 2,552,160 | $ | 2,801,103 |
ACCOUNTS PAYABLE
| Number of Check Vouchers | 3,113 | 2,315 |
| Number of EFT Vouchers | 1,760 | 1,421 |
| Vouchers Dollar Amount Disbursed | $ 41,556,701 | $ 46,250,737 |
| FY24 YTD Wages | $29,425 | |||
| FY25 YTD Wages | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $41,147 | ||||
| $23,115 | $363,620 | $337,345 | $68,783 | $304,231 |
| $181,899 | $346,656 | |||
| $317,882 | ||||
$852,423 $1,025,842
$843,335
$1,308,772
$10,435,473
$8,830,206
Regular Regular
All over time All over time
Vacation Vacation
Sick Sick
Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout Terminal Leave - Retiree Vacation/Sick Payout
Personal Personal
Comp Time Comp Time
Other Other
Other includes: pay adjustments, military differential pay, training, committee meetings, worker compensation tracking/adjustments, etc.
PagePage
3 162
Paj 163
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
City of Dover
General Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (November 2024)
Revenues
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Property & Transfer Taxes | $ | 18,876,000 | $ | 18,363,215 | 97% |
| Program Revenues | 14,296,700 | 6,377,019 | 45% | ||
| Utility Transfers | 12,000,000 | 5,000,000 | 42% | ||
| Grants | 1,028,500 | 163,799 | 16% | ||
| Interfund Services | 7,126,200 | 2,495,814 | 35% | ||
| All Other 1 | 1,976,800 | 313,212 | 16% | ||
| $ | 55,304,200 | $ | 32,713,060 | 59% | |
| Expenditures | |||||
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
| Program Expenses | $ | 37,497,500 | $ | 14,860,390 | 40% |
| Interfund Services | 12,632,000 | 4,698,104 | 37% | ||
| Debt Service | 626,700 | 262,773 | 42% | ||
| Pension Fund Contributions | 1,140,000 | 475,000 | 42% | ||
| Capital Project Transfers | 3,173,600 | 1,586,800 | 50% | ||
| All Other 2 | 2,115,400 | 628,135 | 30% | ||
| $ | 59,289,100 | $ | 23,387,827 | 39% | |
1 Includes Cable Franchise Revenue, Miscellaneous Receipts, Garrison Farm Rent, Sales of Assets, Fund Invest Manager Cost. 2 Includes Bank and CC Fees, Street Lights Expense, DDP Contribution, Trf to Cable Franchise Reserve, Trf to Electric I & E, and Trf to Electric Revenue Fund, Trf to Uncollectible Reserve and Misc. Grant Expense and Trf to Economic Development Reserve Fund.
PagePage
4 163
Paj 164
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
General Fund Revenues
$20,000,000
$18,000,000
$16,000,000
$14,000,000
$12,000,000
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$- Property & Transfer Taxes Program Revenues Utility Transfers Grants Interfund Services All Other 1
Original Budget Actual
General Fund Expenditures
$40,000,000
$35,000,000
$30,000,000
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$15,000,000
$10,000,000
$5,000,000
$-
Program Expenses Interfund Services Debt Service Pension Fund Contributions Capital Project Transfers All Other 2
Original Budget Actual
PagePage
5 164
Paj 165
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
City of Dover
Water Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (November 2024)
Revenues
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Sales | $ | 6,566,900 | $ | 3,220,420 | 49% |
| Impact Fees | 230,000 | 132,294 | 58% | ||
| Rents | 450,500 | 477,220 | 106% | ||
| Miscellaneous 1 | 182,700 | 122,196 | 67% | ||
| $ | 7,430,100 | $ | 3,952,130 | 53% |
Expenditures
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Program Expenses | $ | 4,508,500 | $ | 1,559,137 | 35% |
| Interfund Services | 1,029,900 | 444,441 | 43% | ||
| Debt Service | 695,600 | 298,501 | 43% | ||
| Capital Project Transfers | 503,000 | 251,500 | 50% | ||
| Electric I&E Fund Transfer | 25,000 | 25,000 | 100% | ||
| General Fund Transfer | 1,000,000 | 416,667 | 42% | ||
| All Other 2 | 25,000 | 9,154 | 37% | ||
| $ | 7,896,500 | $ | 3,050,025 | 39% |
1 Includes Penalties, Income from Sale of Assets, Miscellaneous Income, and Reconnect Fees. 2 Includes Bank & CC Fees.
PagePage
6 165
Paj 166
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
Water Revenues
$7,000,000
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$-
Customer Sales Impact Fees Rents Miscellaneous 1
Original Budget Actual
Water Expenditures
$5,000,000
$4,500,000
$4,000,000
$3,500,000
$3,000,000
$2,500,000
$2,000,000
$1,500,000
$1,000,000
$500,000
$-
Program Expenses Interfund Services Debt Service Capital Project Transfers Electric I&E Fund Transfer General Fund Transfer All Other 2
Original Budget Actual
Paj 167
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
City of Dover
Wastewater Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (November 2024)
Revenues
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Sales | $ | 9,843,600 | $ | 5,318,980 | 54% |
| Impact Fees | 230,000 | 108,460 | 47% | ||
| Miscellaneous 1 | 150,200 | 102,501 | 68% | ||
| $ 10,223,800 | $ | 5,529,941 | 54% |
Expenditures
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Program Expenses | $ | 1,751,000 | $ | 695,303 | 40% |
| Kent County Treatment Fee | 5,198,600 | 2,209,804 | 43% | ||
| Interfund Services | 724,900 | 334,600 | 46% | ||
| Debt Service | 614,200 | 293,104 | 48% | ||
| Capital Project Transfers | 1,329,900 | 664,950 | 50% | ||
| Electric I&E Transfer | 25,000 | 25,000 | 100% | ||
| General Fund Transfer | 1,000,000 | 416,667 | 42% | ||
| All Other 2 | 11,000 | 3,136 | 29% | ||
| $ 10,659,200 | $ | 4,644,480 | 44% |
1 Includes Interest Income, Penalties, Loss on Disposal, and Miscellaneous Income. 2 Includes Bank & CC Fees.
PagePage
8 167
Paj 168
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
Wastewater Revenues
$12,000,000
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$-
Customer Sales Impact Fees Miscellaneous 1
Original Budget Actual
Wastewater Expenditures
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$-
Program Expenses Kent County Treatment Interfund Services Debt Service Capital Project Electric I&E Transfer General Fund Transfer All Other 2 Fee Transfers
Original Budget Actual
Paj 169
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
City of Dover
Electric Fund Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (November 2024)
Revenues
| Original Budget | Actual | % | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Sales | $ 92,487,300 | $ | 39,803,351 | 43% |
| All Other 1 | 2,454,000 | 1,811,935 | 74% | |
| $ 94,941,300 | $ | 41,615,248 | 44% |
Expenditures
| Original Budget | Actual | % | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Power Supply & Generation | $ 77,032,800 | $ | 16,872,507 | 22% |
| Electric Operating Div. Exp. | 9,868,500 | 4,054,320 | 41% | |
| Interfund Services | 4,371,600 | 1,716,773 | 39% | |
| Debt Service | 1,441,900 | 584,438 | 41% | |
| General Fund Transfer | 10,000,000 | 4,166,667 | 42% | |
| All Other 2 | 2,710,400 | 999,449 | 37% | |
| $ 106,379,200 | $ | 28,791,654 | 27% | |
| 1 | ||||
| Includes Rental Revenue, Miscellaneous Service Revenue, Interest Earnings, Investment Management Fees, | ||||
| New Service Fees, Sale of Assets, Trf from Uncollectible Reserves, General Service Billing, Revenue from Rate | ||||
| Stabilization, Penalties, Green Energy Charges, and Delay Damages. | ||||
| 2 | ||||
| Includes Utility Tax, Interest on Deposits, Bank & CC Fees, Bond Issuance Costs, Transfer to Uncollectible | ||||
| Reserve, and Green Energy. | ||||
| Megawatt Hours Sold & Purchased | Rev. Budget | Actual |
|---|---|---|
| Sales to Customers MWh (excl. Street Light MWh) | 764,148 | 327,096 |
| Sales per MWh | $119.26 | $119.76 |
| Purchased/Generated MWh | 774,549- | 327,770- |
| All In MWh Supply & Generation | $99.39 | $51.46 |
Page Page
10 169
Paj 170
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
Electric Fund - Revenues
Millions
$- $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 $70 $80 $90 $100
Original Budget
Actual
Customer Sales All Other 1
Electric Fund - Expenditures
$85,000,000
$80,000,000
$75,000,000
$70,000,000
$65,000,000
$60,000,000
$55,000,000
$50,000,000
$45,000,000
$40,000,000
$35,000,000
$30,000,000
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$15,000,000
$10,000,000
$5,000,000
$-
| Power Supply & | Electric Operating Div. | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interfund Services | Debt Service | General Fund Transfer | All Other 2 | |||
| Generation | Exp. | |||||
| Original Budget | $77,032,800 | 9,868,500 | 4,371,600 | 1,441,900 | 10,000,000 | 2,710,400 |
| Actual | $16,872,507 | 4,054,320 | 1,716,773 | 584,438 | 4,166,667 | 999,449 |
Original Budget Actual
Page Page
11 170
Paj 171
Item #19.
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024
City of Dover
Division Expense Summary (General Fund)
Fiscal Year to Date (November 2024)
| Original Budget | Actual | % | General Fund Divisions % of Budget | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Clerk | $ | 486,800 $ | 172,796 | 35% | ||||
| Council | 266,500 | 108,138 | 41% | Mayor | ||||
| Fire | 1,008,300 | 448,411 | 44% | Human Resources | ||||
| Grounds | 1,788,500 | 677,791 | 38% | Customer Services | ||||
| Library | 2,146,000 | 849,966 | 40% | |||||
| Fleet Maintenance | ||||||||
| Recreation | 1,573,200 | 600,307 | 38% | |||||
| Procurement & Inventory | ||||||||
| Life Safety | 1,222,500 | 425,425 | 35% | |||||
| Code Enforcement | 1,163,500 | 302,322 | 26% | Engineering | ||||
| Planning | 898,800 | 216,899 | 24% | Facilities Management | ||||
| Public Inspections | 767,400 | 319,070 | 42% | Pub. Services Administration | ||||
| Police | 23,061,100 | 9,293,789 | 40% | Finance | ||||
| Police Extra Duty | 405,000 | 555,773 | 137% | |||||
| Information Technology | ||||||||
| Streets | 797,000 | 278,043 | 35% | |||||
| Sanitation | 3,140,600 | 1,167,168 | 37% | City Manager | ||||
| Stormwater | 1,021,200 | 304,422 | 30% | Stormwater | ||||
| City Manager | 1,279,000 | 592,580 | 43% | Sanitation | ||||
| Information Technology | 920,500 | 392,222 | 43% | Streets | ||||
| Finance | 1,009,900 | 322,699 | 32% | |||||
| Police Extra Duty | ||||||||
| Pub. Services Administration | 670,700 | 261,270 | 39% | |||||
| Facilities Management | 886,400 | 287,039 | 32% | Police | ||||
| Engineering | 292,900 | 98,795 | 34% | Public Inspections | ||||
| Procurement & Inventory | 958,600 | 412,791 | 43% | Planning | ||||
| Fleet Maintenance | 1,081,400 | 409,950 | 38% | Code Enforcement | ||||
| Customer Services | 1,456,800 | 558,866 | 39% | |||||
| Life Safety | ||||||||
| Human Resources | 478,000 | 137,389 | 29% | |||||
| Recreation | ||||||||
| Mayor | 304,600 | 85,342 | 28% | |||||
| $ 49,085,200 $ 19,279,263 | 39% | Library | ||||||
| Grounds | ||||||||
| Fire | ||||||||
| Council | ||||||||
| City Clerk | ||||||||
| 0% | 20% | 40% | 60% | 80% | 100% | 120% | 140% | 160% |
Page Page
12 171
Paj 172
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024 Item #19.
City of Dover
Utilities Expenditure Summary
Fiscal Year to Date (November 2024)
Water Divison
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engineering & Inspection | $ | 425,700 | $ | 172,222 | 40% |
| Water Department | 881,300 | 325,896 | 37% | ||
| Water Treatment Plant | 3,201,500 | 1,061,019 | 33% | ||
| $ | 4,508,500 | $ | 1,559,137 | 35% |
Wastewater Divison
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engineering & Inspection | $ | 382,000 | $ | 106,495 | 28% |
| Wastewater Department | 1,369,000 | 588,808 | 43% | ||
| $ | 1,751,000 | $ | 695,303 | 40% |
Electric Division
| Original Budget | Actual | % | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Transmission/Distribution | $ | 5,205,100 | $ | 2,165,783 | 42% |
| Electrical Engineering | 1,937,000 | 750,762 | 39% | ||
| Administration | 1,129,100 | 491,774 | 44% | ||
| Meter Reading | 529,800 | 232,384 | 44% | ||
| Systems Operations | 1,067,500 | 413,617 | 39% | ||
| $ | 9,868,500 | $ | 4,054,320 | 41% |
Paj 173
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024 Item #19.
Water Division % of Budget
Water Treatment Plant
Water Department
Engineering & Inspection
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45%
Wastewater Division % of Budget
Wastewater Department
Engineering & Inspection
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50%
Electric Division % of Budget
Systems Operations
Meter Reading
Administration
Electrical Engineering
Transmission/Distribution
36% 38% 40% 42% 44% 46%
Paj 174
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024 Item #19.
City of Dover
Capital Outlay Summary (All Funds)
Fiscal Year to Date (November 2024)
| General Fund | Original Budget | Actual | % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fire | $ | 566,600 $ | 206,258 | 36% |
| Police | 1,488,100 | 655,865 | 38% | |
| Streets | 415,800 | 1,286,644 | 159% | |
| Sanitation | 739,000 | 237,657 | 32% | |
| Stormwater | 2,249,000 | 674,252 | 30% | |
| Grounds | 80,000 | - | 0% | |
| Recreation | 1,160,000 | 326,589 | 28% | |
| Purchasing | 820,000 | 69,802 | 8% | |
| Information Technology | 112,000 | 54,555 | 49% | |
| Fleet Maintenance | - | 398 | 0% | |
| General Fund Capital Projects | $ | 7,630,500 $ | 3,512,019 | 42% |
Water Fund
| Water | $ | 3,456,700 $ | 222,068 | 6% |
| Water Engineering | 26,900 | 25,612 | 95% | |
| Water Treatment Plant | 885,000 | 71,767 | 7% | |
| Water Fund Capital Projects | $ | 4,368,600 $ | 319,447 | 7% |
Wastewater Fund
| Wastewater | $ | 1,691,100 $ | 963,950 | 57% |
| Wastewater Fund Capital Projects | $ | 1,691,100 $ | 963,950 | 57% |
Electric Fund
| Electric Generation | $ | 470,000 $ | 887,175 | 274% |
| Transmission/Distribution | 3,090,000 | 773,877 | 25% | |
| Electrical Engineering | 3,986,000 | 1,066,886 | 24% | |
| ERP System | - | 1,920 | 0% | |
| Electric Administration | - | 625,000 | 0% | |
| Electric Fund Capital Projects | $ | 7,546,000 $ | 3,354,859 | 43% |
TOTAL CAPITAL PROJECTS $ 21,236,200 $ 8,150,275 36%
Paj 175
Finance Department Monthly Report November 2024 Item #19.
Capital Outlay - All Divisions
$4,500,000
$4,000,000
$3,500,000
$3,000,000
$2,500,000
$2,000,000
$1,500,000
$1,000,000
$500,000
$-
Original Budget Actual
Capital Outlay - By Fund
$9,000,000
$8,000,000 $7,630,500 $7,546,000
$7,000,000
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,368,600
$4,000,000 $3,512,019 $3,354,859
$3,000,000
$2,000,000 $1,691,100
$963,950
$1,000,000
$319,447
$-
Original Budget Actual
General Fund Capital Projects Water Fund Capital Projects Wastewater Fund Electric Fund Capital Projects
Paj 176
Item #20.
DOVER FIRE DEPARTMENT
November 2024
FIRE CHIEFS REPORT
Paj 177
Item #20.
Mayor and Council,
The Dover Fire Department responded to 158 calls in November, consisting of 1,182 personnel hours.
Members performed:
112 hours of meetings
500 hours of training
2798 hours of Duty Crew
Total Personnel hours for the month of October 4,592 Personnel hours
Major incidents for November
Trailer Fire – Dyke Branch Road
MVC with Entrapment – assist Camden Westville Road
MVC with Entrapment – assist Hartly Halltown Road
Structure fire – assist Camden Mifflin Meadows
MVC with Entrapment – N Dupont Hwy and College Road
Structure Fire - Chatham Court
Promotions
Firefighter I
Genesis Gomez
David Smiros
Wyatt Martin
Newly Qualified Drivers
Troy Christiansen is qualified on Tower 2
Duty Crews/ Live-ins
Jamarion Wilks has been accepted into the live in program
Boundary Dispute update The Delaware State Fire Commission has postponed the Boundary Dispute hearing until the December Commission Meeting
Operations
The updated 2026 Capital Improvements Plan has been sent to the City Manager. The Fire Department has requested 5 full-time employees in our budget year 2026 proposal.
The Fire Department has reapplied for the Assistance to Firefighter Grant for Turnout gear.
Paj 178
Item #20.
The 2025 Fire Officers will be sworn in at City Hall on December 18th by Mayor Robin Christiansen.
We would like to thank the City Council for taking the first step in approving the stipend program at the Legislative and Finance Committee meeting.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
David Carey,
Fire Chief
Paj 179
Item #20.
Paj 180
Item #20.
Paj 181
Item #20.
Paj 182
City of Dover Item #21.
Police Department
Monthly Report
November 2024
Paj 183
CITY OF DOVER DEPARTMENT OF POLICE Item #21.
400 SOUTH QUEEN STREET DOVER, DELAWARE 19904 302-736-7111
Chief of Police Police Captains
THOMAS A. JOHNSON, JR. RANDY R. ROBBINS
Deputy Chief of Police PAUL D. KUNTZI
DAVID E. SPICER ROBERT E. ROSWELL
January 13, 2025
Honorable Robin Christiansen, Mayor
Members of Dover City Council
City Hall
Dover, DE 19901
Mayor Christiansen and Council Members:
The following is the monthly report of Dover Police Department activities for November:
COMPLAINTS/EVENTS
YTD Totals compiled through November numbered 44,676.
This represents an increase of 5,101 from the 39,575 reported over the same period in 2023.
| 50,000 | 44,676 | |||
| 37,036 | 39,575 | |||
| 40,000 | 36,520 | |||
| 30,749 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30,000 | ||||
| 20,000 | ||||
| 10,000 | ||||
| 0 | ||||
| 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 |
CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS
Burglary: 3 cases reported, 2 case cleared and 0 cases was cleared from previous months.
Robbery: 4 cases reported, 4 cases cleared and 0 cases was cleared from previous months.
Sex Assault: 7 cases reported, 5 cases cleared and 2 cases was cleared from previous months.
Homicide: 0 case reported, 0 case cleared and 1 case cleared from previous months.
1
Paj 184
There were 12 Non-Criminal Death Investigations, 12 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous Item #21. months.
DRUG, VICE, & ORGANIZED CRIME / STREET CRIMES UNIT ENFORCEMENT
Marijuana: 2,086.53 grams seized Cocaine: 387.5 grams seized Ecstasy: 0 doses seized Prescription Pills: 0 doses seized Heroin: 77.95 grams seized Methamphetamine: 155.53 grams seized Fentanyl: 0 grams seized Other Rx Drugs: 0 grams/doses seized Drug Proceeds: $0.00 seized
FIREARM SEIZURES/INSIDE CITY LIMITS
15
10
| 5 | 3 | 2 | |||||||
| 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 0 | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CI | DVOC/STREET CRIMES | PATROL | SEU | ||||||
HANDGUN RIFLE SHOTGUN
Firearms: 6 Handguns
TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT
YTD Citation Totals compiled through November numbered 5,026.
This represents a decrease of 1,332 from the 6,358 reported over the same period in 2023.
8,000
7,109
| 7,000 | 6,358 |
| 6,000 | 5,382 |
| 5,026 | |
|---|---|
| 4,760 | |
| 5,000 | |
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
TRAFFIC CRASHES: YTD = 1,797
2
Paj 185
Item #21.
911 CENTER ACTIVITY
Total compiled during November numbered 7,332 calls.
This represents an increase of 581 from the 6,751 reported during the same period in 2023.
7,400 7,332
7,200 7,170
7,000
| 6,800 | 6,751 |
| 6,695 | 6,685 |
6,600
6,400
6,200
2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
CITY ORDINANCE SUMMONS
YTD Totals compiled through November numbered 2,960.
This represents an increase of 1,025 from the 1,935 reported over the same period in 2023.
5,000
3,926
| 4,000 | 3,272 | 3,513 | |||
| 2,960 | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3,000 | |||||
| 1,935 | |||||
| 2,000 | 1,610 | ||||
| 978 | 985 | 1,206 | |||
| 820 | |||||
| 1,000 | |||||
| 0 | |||||
| 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | |
| ISSUED | 3,272 | 3,926 | 3,513 | 1,935 | 2,960 |
| PAID | 1,610 | 978 | 820 | 985 | 1,206 |
3
Paj 186
COMMUNITY POLICING Item #21.
This proactive unit takes the lead on community engagement and supporting our community organizations. They have administrative responsibilities and also support other departmental units, such as patrol, during times of high work volumes or special operations with enforcement activities. In addition to those duties, the unit accomplished the following in November:
Assisted Patrol Units during major incidents, high 911 call volume and/or low staffing Supported Ribbon Cutting for Fears Gym on W. Loockerman Street Attended a NeighborGood Partners meeting Participated in a neighborhood meeting at Fire Station 2 Continued planning for Hometown Holiday activities in December Supported the Rail Haus 5K Run Supported the Dover Library 5K Run The BHU took the lead on 62 events and took official action to provide services to 14 people needing mental health support & 18 needing substance abuse referral. Some of the field contacts needed both resources. Initiated the Quality of Life (QOL) Operation at hot spot locations on the Route 13 corridor and the Downtown District before expanding the effort across the City. See the programs/initiatives section for further details.
Members of the CPU attend numerous meetings with community associations and organizations as a part of our ongoing liaison relationships.
PROGRAMS AND INITIATIVES
Police Accountability Committee training continued on November 7th as sworn and civilian attendees continue to compile the required 20 hours of training in order to serve on a board or committee. We continue to appreciate the presence of State Representatives Harris and Romer in the class that will continue through February.
The 36th session of the Dover PD Citizen’s Police Academy held its graduation ceremony on Wednesday, November 13th in our Public Assembly Room. Mayor Christiansen handed out the graduation certificates to all 12 members of the class. This annual training program introduces our community members to the structure and function of their Dover Police Department. The Department extends appreciation to Councilwoman Arndt for her interest and participation in this year’s session.
The Quality of Life initiative began on November 5th and is being coordinated by the Community Policing Unit with a heavy reliance on the Behavioral Health Unit. During the first month of operations, we noted 120 invested hours of overtime in addition to the efforts of uniform elements during normal business hours. More than 120 events were logged into the system with more than 120 field contacts recorded by the officers. Depending upon the totality of the circumstances, contacted individuals were sent to a hospital, referred to services, left alone, or charged with the offense(s) appropriate to the situation. We will continue to carefully track the operation and the outcomes.
On Thursday, November 17th, in conjunction with the Quality of Life Initiative, the DVOC Unit/Street Crimes Unit worked in conjunction with the DOJ Human Trafficking Unit on a 4
Paj 187
reverse prostitution operation in the Downtown area. A decoy Dover Officer worked in an Item #21. undercover capacity as a prostitute. The objective was to arrest as many Johns soliciting sex as possible. Four individuals were taken into custody in a little less than 4 hours. They were released on bail after being charged with the solicitation related offense.
Please visit our website at www.doverpolice.org for up to date information on crimes and activities in the City of Dover.
Respectfully Submitted,
Thomas A. Johnson, Jr.
Chief of Police
5