Ale nan kontni prensipal la
AskDover

Regular City Council Packet - REVISED #2

City Council Meetings. 10 fevriye 2025.

Louvri PDF la (37.2 MB)

Yo rale tèks sa a nan PDF la otomatikman, epi li ka gen erè. PDF la se dosye ofisyèl la, kidonk tcheke l anvan ou konte sou sa a.

38 paj pa gen anpil tèks ou ka li isit la, oswa yo pa gen ditou, souvan paske se eskanè oswa desen. Gade PDF la pou sa yo.

Paj 1

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING

Monday, February 10, 2025 at 7:00 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware

AGENDA PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT THE MEETING TIME HAS CHANGED TO 6:45 P.M. FOR THE OPEN FORUM AND 7:00 P.M. FOR THE REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING. THIS AGENDA AND PAPERLESS PACKET HAVE BEEN REVISED BY REMOVING AGENDA ITEM #3 RESOLUTION NO. 2025-03 - A RESOLUTION TO PERMIT THE CITY OF DOVER TO ENTER INTO A CONTRACT WITH THE STATE BOARD OF PENSION TRUSTEES TO ALLOW THE CITY TO PARTICIPATE IN THE STATE OF DELAWARE COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL PENSION PLAN (NAOMI POOLE, HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR) AND ADDING AGENDA ITEM #18 RESIGNATION OF COUNCILMAN WILLIAM F. HARE.

VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE

This meeting will be held in the City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:

Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://shorturl.at/PCW5F
Event number: 2539 776 1992
Event password: DOVER (if needed)

If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.

The meeting can also be viewed on Comcast Channel 14, Verizon Channel 20, and on the City's Streaming Player located at www.cityofdover.com under "Quick Links".

OPEN FORUM - 15 Minutes Prior to Official Meeting (6:45 p.m.)

The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share their questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing on the agenda as a public hearing is prohibited during the Open Forum as an opportunity will be provided during consideration of that item. Citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is prohibited from taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule such items as regular agenda items and act upon them in the future.

INVOCATION - Elder Ellis B. Louden

Paj 2

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - February 10, 2025 PAGE 2

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Councilman Rocha

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA

All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.

PRESENTATIONS

ANNUAL REPORTS

  • 1.Dover Human Relations Commission
  • 2.Downtown Dover Partnership

RESOLUTIONS

PUBLIC HEARING

  • 3.Public Hearing - Proposed Resolution No. 2025-02 Approving Approving Alley Abandonment - Downtown Mobility Center Project

CONSENT AGENDA

ADOPTION OF MINUTES

  • 4.Regular City Council Meeting of January 27, 2025

COMMITTEE REPORTS

  • 5.Council Committee of the Whole Report of January 28, 2025

CCW Presentations

  • 6.The Green Beret Project (Adam Kramer, Executive Director)

Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee

  • 7.Prioritization of City of Dover State Capital Transportation Program (CTP) Projects (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager)

(Committee Recommendation: Approval of the 2025 Transportation Priorities)

  • 8.Snow Removal Practices and Constituent Concerns (Councilman Rocha)

(Committee Recommendation: Waive the fines that were issued from January 6, 2025, through January 28,2025. Also, bring back the proposed ordinances and a snow removal appeals process to the next Legislative, Finance, and Administration meeting)

Paj 3

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - February 10, 2025 PAGE 3

  • 9.Constituent Concerns Surrounding East Loockerman Street (Councilman Boggerty)

(Committee Recommendation: Have staff begin obtain information from the police department to compile an evaluation of a proposed road closure)

Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee

  • 10.Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 - Amending Appendix C - Downtown Redevelopment (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ann Marie Townshend, Rossi Group)

(Committee Recommendation: Forward Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 to Council)

  • 11.Proposed Ordinance #2025-03 - Amending Chapter 1 - General Provisions, Section 1- 18 - City of Dover Service Mark (Councilman Lewis and Dr. Sudler)

(Committee Recommendation: Forward Proposed Ordinance #2025-03, as amended, to Council)

  • 12.Fiscal Year 2026 Tax Evaluation and Fiscal Year 2027 Reevaluation Thereafter (Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director)

(Committee Recommendation: To use the City’s 2020 re-assessment values for the 2025 tax bills. Change the ordinance to adopt Kent County tax values starting with Fiscal Year 2027, thereafter in FY 2029 they would be assessed every 5 years.)

  • 13.Permission to Proceed with Implementation of Kronos Payroll Processing Program (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer)

(Committee Recommendation: Grant permission to proceed with obtaining quotes for the transition to the Kronos Payroll Processing Program)

MONTHLY REPORTS - December 2024

  • 14.City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
  • 15.City Manager’s Report
  • 16.Fire Chief's Report
  • 17.Police Chief's Report

ITEMS NOT ON THE CONSENT AGENDA

  • 18.Resignation of Councilman William F. Hare
  • 19.DelDOT Dover Freight Plan (Marilyn Smith, Dover Kent MPO Executive Director)

(Staff Recommendation: Approval of DelDOT Dover Freight Plan)

Paj 4

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - February 10, 2025 PAGE 4

ORDINANCES

FIRST READING - The First Reading is offered on the Proposed Ordinance. Final action by Council will take place during the Second Reading on February 24, 2025. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us.

  • 20.Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 - Amending Appendix C - Downtown Redevelopment (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner)

FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of JANUARY 27, 2025. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government."

  • 21.Proposed Ordinance # 2025-02 - Project Carry-Forward Budget Balances/Proposed Budget Amendments (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer)

CITY MANAGER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS

MAYOR'S ANNOUNCEMENTS

COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ANNOUNCEMENTS

ADJOURNMENT

THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING

Paj 5

Item #1.

2024 Dover Human Relations Commission Annual Report

Highlights and Accomplishments:

January

  • •DHRC commissioners discussed and agreed that a "reintroduction" of the commission should be presented to the Dover community. It was agreed upon to utilize various media outlets to accomplish that task.

February

  • •Discussion around the 2020-23 DHRC Strategic Plan with further discussion as to what could be done to expand the function of the commission to better serve the community needs.
  • •It was agreed upon to invite council members to help us better understand our role and responsibilities along with the possibility of an expanded scope.

March

  • •Commissioner Gaddis brought before the commission his desire to step down as the DHRC Chair. The discussion was lengthy and tabled until the following meeting.

April

  • •Discussion regarding the Chairmanship resumed. It was decided that Commissioner Gaddis would remain Chair and that Commissioner Hall would serve as Vice-Chair to assist with role if Commissioner Gaddis was unable to fulfill his duties.
  • •The following committee assignments were also decided: Assessment Ms. Hall, Ms. Mullen and Dr. Mishoe Sudler were appointed to the Assessment Committee. Community Programs Mr. Faust and Dr. Mishoe Sudler were appointed to the Community Programs Committee. School Programs Mr. Gaddis, Mr. Lott, Ms. White and Dr. Mishoe Sudler were appointed to the School Programs Committee. Media/Public Relations No one was appointed to the Media/Public Relations Committee at this meeting. Education and Development No one was appointed to the Education and Development Committee at this meeting. Intake Screening No one was appointed to the Intake Screening Committee at this meeting.

Paj 6

Item #1.
Dover Human Relations Commission Annual Report – 2024 Page 2

May

  • •Human Relations Commission Intake Form Modification to Meet Title VI Requirements were presented to DHRC by Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Direct. The changes to the Intake Form were accepted.
  • •Community Programs: Plans for community programs and events, including participation in the African American Festival and purchasing new shirts for DHRC members, were discussed and approved.
  • •Education and Development: Concerns about traffic and safety near Delaware State University were raised, with suggestions for collaboration with relevant agencies. Ideas for youth activities and potential funding for trips were also discussed.

June

  • •Jason Lyon reviewed the Title VI requirement and coordinator information.
  • •The commission appointed Donyale Hall as the Coordinator for the City of Dover and accepted the discrimination complaint and compliance review/grievance procedure and non-discrimination statement.
  • •Council President Anderson emphasized the importance of the changes and the council's support.

July

  • •The updated DHRC brochure was accepted with amendments.
  • •Mr. Fleming will gather prices for new DHRC shirts for members.
  • •Community Programs: Dr. Mishoe Sudler and Mr. Faust discussed community matters but have no specific programs planned. They mentioned an upcoming community health and wellness event on August 24th and the possibility of hosting a candidates' night.
  • •School Programs: Bishop Lott and Dr. Mishoe Sudler are in discussions with school officials and exploring summer programs for youth. They are considering partnerships with local colleges for sports and educational activities.

October

  • •Dr. Mishoe Sudler discussed upcoming community and school programs.
  • •The commission elected Ms. Donyale Hall as Chairperson and Dr. Travis Mishoe Sudler as Vice-Chairperson following the resignation of Chairperson Gaddis.
  • •Chairperson Hall highlighted free training opportunities and proposed a survey to determine preferred topics.
  • •The commission decided to continue monthly meetings despite a proposal to shift to quarterly meetings.

Current Initiatives: • Reviewing current bylaws for recommendations for any changes. • Receiving training from the Delaware State Human Relations Commission in relevant areas of concern.

Paj 7

Item #2.

Paj 8

Item #2.

Paj 9

Item #2.

Paj 10

Item #2.

Paj 11

Item #3.

City of Dover
COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2025- 02

A RESOLUTION PROPOSING THE VACATING AND ABANDONMENT OF CERTAIN IMPROVED ALLEY SITUATED IN THE CITY OF DOVER.

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:

Section 1. The Council of the City of Dover favors the vacating and abandoning of an alley extending north from Minor Street. An alley which is located in the block between South Governor’s Avenue and South Bradford Street as specified below:

All that certain lot, piece or parcel of land, situated in the City of Dover, East Dover Hundred, Kent County and the State of Delaware, said parcel being a portion of an unnamed alley lying on the north side of Minor Street Alley, said parcel being bounded on the south by Minor Street Alley, on the west in part by lands now or formerly of the City of Dover, in part by lands now or formerly of The Downtown Dover Development Corp Dover Parking Authority, and in part by lands now or formerly of the Downtown Dover Development Corporation, on the north in part by lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie and in part by other lands now or formerly of the City of Dover, and on the east in part by other lands now or formerly of the City of Dover, in part by lands now or formerly of Capital City Transformation Alliance, Inc. and in part by lands now or formerly of CEI Properties, LLC, said parcel being as shown as an “Existing Alley to be Abandoned” on an unrecorded plat plan entitled, “Parcel Consolidation Plan” for Lands of Downtown Dover Partnership as prepared by Becker Morgan Group, Inc., dated December 5, 2024, said parcel being more particularly bounded and described in accordance with said plan, as follows to wit:

Beginning for the same at a point on the northerly right-of-way line of Minor Street Alley (20.00 feet wide) at a corner for this parcel and lands now or formerly CEI Properties, LLC, said point being further located South 77° 42’ 52” West – 143.99 feet from the point of commencement being the intersection of the westerly right-of-way line of South Bradford Street (60.00 feet wide) with the northerly right-of-way line of Minor Street Alley; thence from said point of beginning continuing with the northerly right-of-way line of said Minor Street Alley South 77° 42’ 52” West – 12.02 feet to a point at a corner for this parcel and lands now or formerly of the City of Dover; thence running with the line for said lands now or formerly of the City of Dover, North 15° 41’ 56” West – 28.89 feet to a common corner for this parcel, said lands now or formerly of the City of Dover and lands now or formerly of The Downtown Dover Development Corp Dover Parking Authority; thence running with the line for said lands now or formerly of The Downtown

Paj 12

Item #3.

Dover Development Corp Dover Parking Authority, North 16° 31’ 31” West – 51.74 feet to a point at a common corner for this parcel, said lands now or formerly of The Downtown Dover Development Corp Dover Parking Authority and lands now or formerly of the Downtown Dover Development Corporation; thence running with the line for said lands now or formerly of the Downtown Dover Development Corporation, North 16° 46’ 00” West – 50.00 feet to a point in the line for lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie at a corner for this parcel and said lands now or formerly of the Downtown Dover Development Corporation; thence running with the line for said lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie, North 77° 23’ 17” East – 6.01 feet to a point in the line for other lands now or formerly of the City of Dover at a common corner for this parcel, said lands now or formerly of the Downtown Dover Development Corporation, said lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie and other lands now or formerly of the City of Dover; thence running with the line for said other lands now or formerly of the City of Dover along the following three (3) courses and distances: (1) South 16° 25’ 02” East – 0.67 feet to a point; thence (2) North 76° 11’ 01” East – 6.00 feet to a point; thence (3) South 16° 07’ 06” East – 49.99 feet to a point at a common corner for this parcel, said other lands now or formerly of the City of Dover and lands now or formerly of Capital City Transformation Alliance, Inc.; thence running with the line for said lands now or formerly of Capital City Transformation Alliance, Inc., South 16° 50’ 33” East – 35.16 feet to a point at a common corner for this parcel, said lands now or formerly of Capital City Transformation Alliance, Inc., and lands now or formerly of CEI Properties, LLC; thence running with the line for said lands now or formerly of CEI Properties, LLC, South 16° 27’ 15” East – 45.00 feet to the point and place of beginning, and containing within the above described metes and bounds 1,521.07 square feet ( 0.0350 acres) of land, be the same more or less.

Section 2. Since no person has been deprived of property by the vacating and abandoning of the aforesaid alley, no compensation is awarded.

Section 3. The Downtown Dover Partnership will work with the City of Dover Department of Public Works to relocate the two city provided dumpsters for downtown business trash removal and work with the City of Dover Department of Water & Wastewater to relocate the water line currently contained within aforesaid alley. Until such time, the dumpsters shall remain in place and accessible and the water line shall be retained in a public utility easement until relocated. All costs of relocation and conveyance shall be borne by the Downtown Dover Partnership.

Section 4. This resolution shall be effective upon completion of a parcel consolidation plan of the aforesaid alley.

ADOPTED: *

ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN DAVID L. ANDERSON MAYOR COUNCIL PRESIDENT

Action History 02/10/2025 - Introduction at City Council

Paj 13

Item #3.

CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION

December 16, 2024
Excerpt from Meeting Minutes – Draft

The Meeting of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Monday, December 16, 2024, at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system Webex. The Meeting Session was conducted with Chair Mr. Witham presiding. Members present were Mr. Michael Lewis, Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Maucher, Mr. Baldwin, Mrs. Welsh, and Mr. Witham. Mr. Roach, Dr. Jones, and Mr. Reaves were absent.

Staff members present were Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Ms. Sharon Duca, Mrs. Kristen Mullaney, and Mr. Jason Lyon (virtual).

NEW APPLICATIONS

MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street – Public Hearing and Review for Recommendation to City Council on a Request for Abandonment of a portion of the improved alley, located between South Governors Avenue and South Bradford Street and extending approximately 132 feet north of the Minor Street Alley, consisting of 1,550 square feet in area. The portion of the alley to be abandoned is adjacent to the properties located at 133 S. Governors Avenue, 139 S. Governors Avenue, 145 S. Governors Avenue, 136 S. Bradford Street, 148 S. Bradford Street, and 150 S. Bradford Street, Dover DE.

Representatives: Mr. Mike Riemann, Becker Morgan Group; Ms. Diane Laird, Downtown Dover Partnership; Mr. JD Bartlett, EDiS Company

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that this is a Request of Alley Abandonment. It’s not your typical application to the Planning Commission; however, you are called upon to participate in the process for consideration of Alley Abandonments. You can see in the image on the screen; we are located between S. Bradford Street and S. Governors Avenue to the north of Loockerman Street and to the north of the Minor Street Alley. We are talking about an area that springs north from the Minor Street Alley. On the image on the screen, it is a shaded hatched area that shows. There are a series of six parcels that are either adjacent to or the alley actually crosses the property itself. They have done some of the deed research and some of the alley portions here are located specifically in the right-of-way but in other instances, it traverses parts of the adjacent parcels. She will list those adjacent parcels that are adjacent to this alley segment. They are specifically moving from left to right and top to bottom. 133 S. Governors Avenue referenced as owned by the Downtown Dover Development Corporation and we now know that as the Downtown Dover Partnership. The property at 139 S. Governors Avenue, again, referenced with the Downtown Dover Development Corporation and the Dover Parking Authority now recognized as the Downtown Dover Partnership. The property at 145 S. Governors Avenue is actually owned by the City of Dover. Moving over to the eastern side, again, from the top to the bottom. The property at 136 S. Bradford Street is owned by the City of Dover. The property at 148 S. Bradford Street is now owned by the Capital City Transformation Alliance Inc. and then the property at 150 S. Bradford Street is currently or soon to be formally owned by CEI Properties LLC. The applicants making the request collectively were the Downtown Dover Partnership. The Request for Alley Abandonment moves through the review process with the Development Advisory Committee for some initial comments and review. The Planning Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024 Page 1 of 4 Page 13

Paj 14

Item #3.

Commission takes a look at the Alley Abandonment Request and provides a Recommendation. That Recommendation will be forwarded to City Council and its appropriate City Council Committees who will have their own consideration of this Request moving into the new year. The Alley Abandonment is brought forth because these properties are to be involved in a project known as the Dover Mobility Center Garage. It is a parking garage project which will eventually come before this body but right now we are just dealing with the Alley Abandonment. The image on the screen shows that for the most part, we’ve got a series of parcels that are functioning as surface parking lot areas. There are two properties that currently have buildings but their demolitions were authorized by other Applications already considered. The Alley Abandonment, again, is located in the middle and as noted, some of it is right of way and some of it just crosses some of the properties including some that are City owned. It is also noted that a couple of these properties, as she mentioned, are owned by the City of Dover. The City Manager’s Office under separate proceedings has been working with City Council to transfer some of this land ownership in the City of Dover to the Downtown Dover Partnership and associated entities for this redevelopment project. So, you are not really considering that issue at the moment but the alley is a separate matter per our Charter and Code. This redevelopment project is identified as a priority project in the Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030 Plan. The Planning Staff is recommending that the Alley Abandonment happen because it is part of those longer- term efforts to revitalize Downtown Dover. They do note and recognize that appropriate planning is going to have to occur related to utility infrastructure that may be located in this alley segment here. There actually is a fairly substantial water line that they have already been in discussion with the City’s Department of Water/Wastewater in regards to. Tonight, the Planning Commission is charged with conducting your own public hearing and making a recommendation on this Alley Abandonment Request which will then be forwarded to the Utility Committee and City Council.

Mr. Witham stated that the assumption that he has here and the assumption that he thinks that they need to understand is that there are six different addresses and six different tax parcel numbers some of which are owned by different entities other than the Downtown Dover Partnership. The assumption that he has here is that all of these entities have an agreement to the development of these six parcels. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the short answer to that is yes, there is a collective effort. Even as part of this request for Alley Abandonment, the City Clerk’s Office was required to reach out to each of those involved parcel owners to gage their participation in this Alley Abandonment process. The short answer is, she believes that all of the property owners are well aware of this request that is being made this evening.

Mr. Witham stated that some of these parcels were subject by this Commission for a Request for Demolition which was considered earlier. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated yes, there are two properties.

Mr. Riemann stated that Mrs. Melson-Williams has done an excellent job of summarizing the Application. He asked Mrs. Melson-Williams to zoom in on the easement itself so you can get a little better of a look about what’s actually on the ground versus the black and white. The area in question is this hatched area in the middle that’s got this yellow cross hatch. It’s actually in an easement; so, it’s not a separate deeded right of way. It is actually an easement of about 1,500 SF that is on the six parcels in question that were referenced. The Downtown Dover Partnership either owns, has already acquired, or is contracted to purchase all of the parcels in question. They Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024 Page 2 of 4 Page 14

Paj 15

Item #3.

have settled on one of the parcels there and are going to settlement on Wednesday on the last parcel. They will own and have them under their control, all of these particular properties. The alley, at this point, really is no longer needed. It doesn’t really serve a purpose with the parking lot in its current configuration. It certainly would impact the future Mobility Hub that is planned to go there that will come before this Commission soon in another Site Plan Application. This was really the first step to get through that process that needed to be accomplished first; so, we are going through this process now. As part of any application, this was sent to all of the same agencies as part of the Development Advisory Committee. They received no objections from all of the other agencies. They were all supportive of this Request as has been the Staff. The only item of mention that Mrs. Melson-Williams mentioned was a water line that exists. They have already met with Public Works on that and there will be a plan to relocate that waterline outside of that which would happen as part of that Mobility hub project anyway. So that is not an issue and will be solved as part of this project. We are asking for the Commission’s support.

Mrs. Denney stated that when she is looking at the parking and realizing that the intent is for a parking garage building for which she is certain there should be a charge because she understands that it might be Colonial and they would certainly charge. She actually volunteered for many years at Catholic Charities that used to be in one of the buildings on Loockerman Street. They utilized the parking behind it as did employees from the accountant and the bridal shop. She can’t remember what all was down there, but they had access to free parking. It is especially important in Catholic Charities because people are volunteering their time and the majority of clients that come in there really can’t afford to park. But at any rate, that said, at this point in this design there will be no free parking because Loockerman Street is not going to have parking on the street. So, there will be no free available parking for somebody who just wants to go and do something with their EZ Pass. Does everybody have to park in the garage and pay? Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mr. Riemann stated that the Application that is before us tonight is not the parking garage. It is the Alley Abandonment and so he thinks that would be more appropriately addressed at the time that we come before you with the parking garage application.

Mrs. Denney stated that the Alley Abandonment is a step towards a final result which would include elimination of the free parking as her understanding. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mr. Riemann stated that he is honestly not prepared to answer that particular question this evening. The Alley that is in question that they are proposing to abandon is no longer needed given the configuration of the parcels and the ownership of the parcels being a singular owner at this time. There is access to the parcels currently from both sides, S. Governors Avenue and Bradford Street; so, the Alley itself is no longer needed. There is no purpose for the Alley any further.

Mrs. Maucher stated that she used to work on State Street. Does this Alley continue further north? Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mr. Riemann stated it does but it terminates at the fire station. It doesn’t go all the way out.

Mrs. Maucher stated that the elimination of that section of the Alley is going to have limited impact on properties. She used to work on State Street and utilized the alley to get to the parking behind her building on State Street. With that elimination, are there properties that would be affected to the north? Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mr. Riemann stated no, there really wouldn’t be. They are only eliminating the portion from Minor Street up. The Alley does continue behind Harry Louie’s, but it terminates at the fire station.

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024 Page 3 of 4 Page 15

Paj 16

Item #3.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that if we scan back out on the plan shown on the screen.

Mrs. Maucher asked if the Alley came out to Reed Street. Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the Alley does not. You would run into the back side of the Fire Department’s building before that would happen; it kind of melds into those adjacent parking lot areas to the north at the top of the page.

Mr. Witham stated that he thinks it is safe to say that once all of the parcels are owned by one entity, not only will the Alley not exist on paper, it will not physically exist because it will be gone. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mr. Riemann stated correct and all of the parcels would be combined into one.

Mr. Witham further stated that there would be no need of an alley, period. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mr. Riemann stated correct.

Mr. Witham opened a public hearing and after seeing no one wishing to speak, closed the public hearing.

Mrs. Maucher moved to recommend approval to City Council for MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street. With the upcoming project, it’s pretty much necessary.

Mr. Witham asked if Mrs. Maucher would entertain an amendment to note that the Planning Commission recommends that once the full integration of the alley is accomplished by deed into one entity the Abandonment would be affective. As of right now, they are still in the process of combining those lots so there could be a limited need for the alleyway until they are all combined. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Maucher stated understood but it’s a joint application of the individual property owners and they are jointly requesting Abandonment of their Alley.

Mr. Witham stated that it’s a joint request in the sense that all of the individual property owners are a part of the Downtown Dover Partnership but that would be a legal document which is not before us. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Maucher stated the Amendment to the motion is accepted.

Mrs. Maucher moved to recommend approval to City Council for MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street. With the upcoming project, it’s pretty much necessary. Once the full integration of the alley is accomplished by deed into one entity, the Abandonment would be effective, seconded by Mrs. Welsh and the motion was carried 6-0 by roll call vote with Mr. Roach, Dr. Jones and Mr. Reaves absent. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; based on Staff recommendation and reasons stated in the motion. Mr. Baldwin voting yes; based on Staff recommendation. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mr. Lewis voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mrs. Denney voting yes. Mr. Witham voting yes; based on Staff recommendation and the documents submitted to the Planning Commission and based upon the oral discussion before the Commission today.

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024 Page 4 of 4 Page 16

Paj 17

Item #3.

REQUEST FOR ALLEY ABANDONMENT

Consideration by Council Committee of the Whole: Utility Committee on January 14, 2025 Recommendation from Planning Commission Meeting on December 16, 2024 With Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review

Applicants: Downtown Dover Partnership

Properties and Property Owners Adjacent to Alley Segment: 133 S. Governors Avenue Downtown Dover Development Corporation (Downtown Dover Partnership) 139 S. Governors Avenue The Downtown Dover Development Corp. - Dover Parking Authority (Downtown Dover Partnership) 145 S. Governors Avenue City of Dover 136. S Bradford Street City of Dover 148 S. Bradford Street Capital City Transformation Alliance Inc. 150 S. Bradford Street CEI Properties, LLC

Location: Portion of the Improved Alley located between South Governors Avenue and South Bradford Street and extending approximately 132 feet north of the Minor Street Alley See Plan Diagram for Detailed Location

Abandonment Area: ~1,550 square feet

Tax Parcel ID #: No Tax Parcel Numbers – All public right-of-way or alley is part of adjacent parcel

Present Use: Public Alley

Proposed Use: Integration into Adjacent Parcels

Reason for Request: To abandon and integrate the Alley area into the six parcels of land proposed to be consolidated for a redevelopment project for the Dover Mobility Center (Parking) Garage

File Number: MI-24-10

Planning Commission Recommendation: The Application MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street was represented by Mike Riemann of Becker Morgan Group on behalf of

Paj 18

Item #3. MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024

the Requestor; Diane Laird of the Downtown Dover Partnership; and JD Bartlett of EDiS Company. A Public Hearing was conducted on December 16, 2024 where no members of the public spoke, and no written comments were received regarding the Alley Abandonment Request. The Planning Commission’s motion to recommend approval of the proposed Alley Abandonment Request for the Part of the Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street (extending 132 feet north of Minor Street Alley) resulted in a 6-0 vote in favor (three members absent). (Draft Meeting Minutes attached.)

REQUEST: MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street

This Request for Alley Abandonment was referred to the Planning Commission as per the Dover Code of Ordinances. The Planning Commission is required to provide a Recommendation to the City Council Utility Committee. The following document and attachments are provided as the Review Report and Planning Commission Recommendation.

  • I.REQUEST SUMMARY Alley Abandonment Request: The Downtown Dover Partnership has requested that the City abandon portions of the Alley between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street, Dover DE. This request is being made as part of the project proposal for the redevelopment of a series of six parcels to the north of the Minor Street Alley for the Dover Mobility Center Garage (Parking Garage). This Request focuses on the process for Alley Abandonment only as the redevelopment project will be subject to separate Site Development Plan applications and reviews.

Existing Area: The subject area consists of a public alley, owned and maintained by the City of Dover. Recent property surveys have shown this Alley to be located within right-of-way and also traversing portions of several of the adjacent parcels. The Alley requested for abandonment is adjacent on both sides to properties held in the ownership of multiple properties. See Table below and attached Plan submission diagrams:

Address Tax Parcel Number Current Property Owner 133 S. Governors Avenue Downtown ED-05-077.09-02-10.00- Dover Dover Downtown Dover Development 000 Corporation (Downtown Dover Partnership) 139 S. Governors Avenue ED-05-077.09-02-09.00- The Downtown Dover Development 000 Corp. - Dover Parking Authority (Downtown Dover Partnership)

145 S. Governors Avenue ED-05-077.09-02-08.00- City of Dover
000
136 S. Bradford Street ED-05-077.00-02-24.00- City of Dover
000

Paj 19

Item #3. MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024

148 S, Bradford Street ED-05-077.00-02-25.00- Capital City Transformation 000 Alliance Inc 150 S. Bradford Street ED-05-077.00-02-27.00- CEI Properties, LLC 000

It is noted that under separate proceedings the City Manager’s Office has presented to Dover City Council a proposal for the transfer of City owned property to the Downtown Dover Partnership entity for this redevelopment project. The redevelopment project known as the Dover Mobility Center (Parking) Garage is identified as a priority project in the Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030 Plan.

II. RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING STAFF:

The Planning Staff notes the redevelopment efforts associated with the Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030 Plan which focuses on efforts to revitalize and redevelop Downtown Dover. To the extent that long-term abandonment of the subject Alley area will help accomplish this objective, staff supports the conceptual request. Staff believes that the requested Alley Abandonment should be conditioned on abandonment coinciding with appropriate planning for the relocation of any utility infrastructure in the Alley as associated with future site development plans.

III. PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEW FOR RECOMMENDATION

The Request for Alley Abandonment is to be considered by the Planning Commission. The Planning Commission as part of their public hearing and review process will provide a recommendation on the Alley Abandonment to the Utility Committee (a City Council Committee of the Whole Subcommittee).

RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION:

At the Hybrid (In-Person and Virtual) Planning Commission Meeting of December 16, 2024, the Request for Alley Abandonment MI-24-10 was represented by Mike Riemann of Becker Morgan Group on behalf of the Requestor; Diane Laird of the Downtown Dover Partnership; and JD Bartlett of EDiS Company. During the Public Hearing, no members of the public spoke, and no written comments were received regarding the Alley Abandonment Request.

The Planning Commission’s motion was to recommend approval of the proposed Alley Abandonment Request for the Part of the Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street (extending 132 feet north of Minor Street Alley) and resulted in a vote of 6-0 in favor of rezoning (three members absent) with the condition that the Alley Abandonment would be effective once the integration is accomplished by deed into one entity. The reasons cited for the recommendation of approval include the applicant’s presentation and discussion at the meeting and with reference to the Planning Staff’s Recommendation in the Development Advisory Committee Report.

See also the included excerpt of the DRAFT Meeting Minutes of the December 16, 2024 Planning Commission meeting. The comments received from the other member agencies of the Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) are also provided.

Paj 20

Item #3. MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street Planning Commission Recommendation Report of December 16, 2024

IV. ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:

  • 1.The Planning Commission’s role is to make a recommendation to the City Council on the matter. City Council has ultimate authority on the request for abandonment.
  • 2.Staff notes that abandonment of the public alley will require relocations or easements for existing utilities in the area. If the request for abandonment is successful additional coordination with various City Departments will be necessary to address utility infrastructure access, the need to maintain emergency access, and the development (and approval) of a Record Plan documenting a transfer of ownership and any associated infrastructure easements.
  • 3.Abandonment of public alleys does not constitute approval for physical alteration of such alleys. Any modification or ground-disturbing activity must be reviewed through the appropriate site plan process and receive all requisite approvals by regulatory agencies.

ATTACHMENTS:

  • •Alley Abandonment Map Exhibit A (with Utilities)
  • •Request MI-24-10 Submission: o Request Letter dated November 13, 2024 o Description of Portion of Alley to be Vacated o Alley Abandonment – Aerial Exhibit o Alley Abandonment – Plan Map (Existing Conditions/Location Plan Sheet)
  • •Development Advisory Committee Comments from City of Dover Departments of Public Works and Water & Wastewater, Electric Department, City Office of the Fire Marshal, DelDOT, Kent Conservation District, and Dover/Kent County MPO
  • •Excerpt from DRAFT Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of December 16, 2024

Paj 21

Item #3.

Paj 22

Item #3.

November 13, 2024

Ms. Andria L. Bennett
City Clerk
City of Dover
15 East Loockerman Street, City Hall
Dover, Delaware 19901

RE: Alley Abandonment Request
DOVER MOBILITY CENTER GARAGE
Dover, Delaware
2024314.00

Dear Ms. Bennett:

On behalf of our client, Downtown Dover Partnership, please accept this letter as a formal request for the City of Dover to begin the process to abandon the alley within the existing City of Dover parking lot located between Governors Ave and Bradford Street. The alley runs to the north from Minor Street through the parking lot to the southern boundary of Robbins Hose Company No. 1 of Dover’s property. We are seeking to vacate the portion of the alley that runs through the project’s boundaries. The areas included in this request are depicted on the following enclosures to this application:

  • 1.An aerial map, entitled “Alley Abandonment – Aerial Exhibit, Dover Mobility Center Garage”. This map identifies the section of the alley being requested to be vacated and the adjacent property owners, and roads over the current aerial photography.
  • 2.A smaller scaled drawing exhibit entitled “Alley Abandonment Exhibit, Dover Mobility Center Garage”. This exhibit identifies the section of the portion of the alley requested to be vacated as well as the tax parcels involved, parcel owners and topography.
  • 3.A legal description of the portion of the alley included in this request.

This request is being made to allow for the consolidation of the six (6) parcels involved in the project into one parcel, as well as the construction of the garage facility, as the garage will span from Governors Ave. to Bradford Street. Additionally, a parcel consolidation plan showing the consolidation of all six (6) parcels and the alley into one parcel will be prepared and submitted to the City’s Planning Department with the site development plans.

The portion of the alley included in this request is exclusively within the project’s property boundaries and several of the properties extend to the centerline of the alley currently. Under Section 27 of the Dover Charter, it allows the City Council to authorize the solicitation of bids for the sale of the land or street being vacated or abandoned. The portion of the alley proposed for abandonment is located entirely within the project’s outer property boundaries and given that The Downtown Dover Development Corp. is the owner of the six (6) parcels that make up the project boundary, we request that Council not offer them for public or private sale and that it be allowed to be consolidated in the overall parcel for the project.

Based on previous discussions, it is our understanding that the abandonment procedure begins with a formal request to your office. From there the request is added to the Development

Paj 23

Item #3.

Advisory Committee and Planning Commission agendas. After being discussed at the Planning Commission, their recommendation will be forwarded to the Utility Committee and then Council for discussion. If the Council feels the abandonment request is appropriate, it can then be scheduled for a public hearing for the next Council meeting. The Council will then make a decision on the abandonment after the public hearing.

Please include this request on the Development Advisory Committee agenda and Planning Commission agenda for December 16, 2024 and feel free to contact us with any questions or concerns with this request.

Sincerely,

BECKER MORGAN GROUP, INC.

Michael J. Henry, LEED AP
Senior Associate

MJH/

Enclosures

Cc: Dawn Melson-Williams, City of Dover Planning Department

202431400ac-ltr-Alley.docx

Paj 24

Item #3.

Portion of Alley Between Minor Street and Reed Street
Area to be Vacated
(1,550 S.F. ±)

All that certain piece, parcel, or tract of land, situated in the City of Dover, Kent County, State of Delaware, lying on the north side of Minor Street, being bounded on the south by Minor Street, on the west by lands now or formerly of The City of Dover and lands now or formerly of Downtown Dover Development, Corp., on the north by lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie and The City of Dover, on the east by lands now or formerly of The City of Dover, and lands now or formerly of Capital City Transformation Alliance Inc, and lands now or formerly of CEI Properties LLC, as follow to wit:

Beginning at a point in the northerly right of way line of Minor Street at the southwest corner of a 12 foot wide public alley and lands now or formerly of The City of Dover, said point of beginning being South 77°42’52” East 144.00 feet as measured from the northeast intersection of the South Governors Avenue and Minor Street right of way lines; thence from said point of beginning and running with said lands of The City of Dover 1) North 15°41’56” West 28.89 feet to a point at a corner of said public alley and lands now or formerly of Downtown Dover Development, Corp.; thence turning and running with said lands now or formerly of Downtown Dover Development, Corp. North 16°31’31” West 51.74 feet to a point in the south line of lands now or formerly of Downtown Dover Development, Corp.; thence turning and running across lands now or formerly of Downtown Dover Development, Corp. North 16°46’00” West 50.00 feet to a point in the south line of lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie; thence turning and running with said lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie North 77°23’17” East 6.01 feet to a point at a corner of lands now or formerly of Downtown Dover Development, Corp. and lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie; thence turning and running with said lands now or formerly of Downtown Dover Development, Corp South 16°25’02” East 0.67 feet to a point at a corner of lands now or formerly of Downtown Dover Development, Corp. and lands now or formerly of The City of Dover; thence turning and running with lands now or formerly of The City of Dover North 76°11’01” East 6.01 feet to a point in the west right of way of the public alley; thence turning and running across lands now or formerly of The City of Dover South 16°45’21” East 50.01 feet to a point in north line of lands now or formerly of Capital City Transformation Alliance Inc; thence turning and running across lands now or formerly of Capital City Transformation Alliance Inc. South 16°02’53” East 35.14 feet to a point at a corner of lands now or formerly of CEI Properties LLC; thence turning and running with lands now or formerly of CEI Properties LLC South 16°27’15” East 45.00 feet to a point at a corner of lands now or formerly of CEI Properties LLC. and said public alley; thence turning and running with said public alley South 77°42’52” West 12.09 feet to the point and place of beginning and containing 1,550 square feet of land be the same more or less.

202431400ad-desc-vacated.doc

Paj 25

Item #3.

EXISTING ALLEY .
AREA TO BE VACATED
1,550+/- S.F. N
LANDS N/F
CITY OF DOVER

LANDS N/F YAU YEE LEUNG LOUIE

RD

SOUTH BRADFO
LANDS N/F LANDS N/F
DOWNTOWN DOVER CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION

LANDS N/F LANDS N/F CAPITAL CITY TRANSFORMATION

NORS THE DOWNTOWN DOVER ALLIANCE INC.

SOUTH GOVER
DEVELOPMENT CORP
DOVER PARKING AUTHORITY
LANDS N/F

STREET
CEI PROPERTIES LLC
LANDS N/F
CITY OF DOVER

AVENUE MINOR STREET

LOOCKERMAN STREET LAYER STATE: AERIAL EXHIBIT

ALLEY ABANDONMENT - AERIAL EXHIBITARCH I T E C TUREBMG:2024314.00
ENG I NE E R I NGSCALE: AS SHOWN
02550DOVER MOBILITY CENTERDover, DEDATE:11-13-24
GARAGE309 S. Governors Ave.DRAWN BY:M.J.H.
CITY OF DOVER
Dover, DE 19904
Do Not Explode - Select Scale
Ph. 302.734.7950
SCALE: 1" = 50'KENT COUNTY, DELAWAREFax 302.734.79651Page 25
F:\AutoCAD\Projects\2024\2024314\DWG\2024314-Aerial.dwg, Nov 13, 2024 - 10:57am

2024-11-13

Paj 26

Item #3.

X X X X X X X X X X LANDS N/F CITY OF DOVER 2-05-077.09-02-23.00-00001 . X D/R O36-314 LANDS N/F ZONING: C2 YAU YEE LEUNG LOUIE 2-05-077.09-02-11.00-00001 D/R U19-165 30 N ZONING: C2 30 EXISTING BUILDING ±2,096 S.F. S 16° 25' 02" E 30 ING EXISTING BUILDING S 16° 42' 24" E EXISTING BUILD ±455 S.F. 0.67' ±711 S.F. 3.67' 150.00' S 77° 23' 17" W 65.20' N 76° 11' 01" E 84.50' N 76° 24' 28" E 143.99' 59.19' 6.01' 6.01' LANDS N/F CITY OF DOVER S 16° 46' 00" E N 16° 45' 21" W 2-05-077.09-02-24.00-00001 D/R 036-314

N 16° 07' 06" W
50.00' 50.01' ZONING: C2

129.80' S 16° 27' 15" E
30

50.00' 50.66'
EXISTING BUILDINGS
EXISTING ALLEY
LANDS N/F AREA TO BE VACATED
DOWNTOWN DOVER DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION

46.00'
1,550+/- S.F.
2-05-077.09-02-10.00-00001
D/R D3322-148
ZONING: C2
150.00'
N 77° 23' 17" E 149.71' N 76° 11' 00" E
LANDS N/F

SO
CAPITAL CITY TRANSFORMATION

N 16° 50' 33" W
ALLIANCE INC.

UTH BRADFORD 2-05-077.09-02-25.00-00001

ICATION)
D/R D13180-245 EXISTING BUILDING
ZONING: C2
S 16° 31' 31" E ±1,932 S.F.

DTH 60' - (CLASSIF
S 16° 02' 53" E
39.00'
35.00'
51.74' 35.14'
61.22'
LANDS N/F

RIGHT OF WAY WI THE DOWNTOWN DOVER DEVELOPMENT

SO
CORP DOVER PARKING AUTHORITY
2-05-077.09-02-09.00-00001 N 77° 42' 52" E 150.00'

UTH GOVERNO D/R D3181-289

BLIC USE 6.09' 143.91'

ICATION)

N 16° 27' 15" W
ZONING: C2

DEDICATED TO PU
DTH 60' - (CLASSIF
N 16° 27' 15" W
45.00'
STREET
144.00'

RIGHT OF WAY WI
130.00'
N 73° 36' 35" E
F.H.
EXISTING BUILDING
LANDS N/F ±2,305 S.F.

45.00'

BLIC USE CEI PROPERTIES LLC

18.58'
LANDS N/F 2-05-077.09-02-27.00-00001
CITY OF DOVER D/R D320-36

DEDICATED TO PU RS AVENUE 2-05-077.09-02-08.00-00001

D/R Y30-518S 15° 41' 56" EZONING: C2
ZONING: C2
144.00'28.89'12.09'143.91'X
300.00'S 77° 42' 52" W30
MINOR STREET
RIGHT OF WAY WIDTH 20' - (CLASSIFICATION)30
EXISTING BUILDINGDEDICATED TO PUBLIC USE

F.H.
EXISTING BUILDINGS
EXISTING BUILDING

0 15 30

Do Not Explode - Select Scale

SCALE: 1" = 30' GENERAL NOTES: LAYER STATE: ALLEY EXHIBIT

  • 1.BOUNDARY SURVEY DATA SHOWN HEREON WAS TAKEN FROM A PLAT ENTITLED "BOUNDARY SURVEY PLAN - DOVER MOBILITY ALLEY ABANDONMENT EXHIBIT ARCH I T E C TURE BMG: 2024314.00 ENG I NE E R I NG SCALE: AS SHOWN HUB, DOVER, DE 19904" AS PREPARED BY MOUNTAIN CONSULTING, 103 S. BRADFORD STREET, DOVER, DE., DATED 7-16-2024. TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY DATA SHOWN HEREON WAS TAKEN FROM A PLAN ENTITLED "DOVER MOBILITY HUB - TOPOGRAPHIC DOVER MOBILITY CENTER Dover, DE DATE: 11-13-24 SURVEY" AS PREPARED BY MOUNTAIN CONSULTING, 103 S. BRADFORD STREET, DOVER, DE., DATED 9-23-2024. GARAGE 309 S. Governors Ave. DRAWN BY: M.J.H. CITY OF DOVER Dover, DE 19904 Ph. 302.734.7950 KENT COUNTY, DELAWARE Fax 302.734.7965 1Page 26 F:\AutoCAD\Projects\2024\2024314\DWG\2024314-SITE-C3D21.dwg, Nov 13, 2024 - 10:56am

2024-11-13

Paj 27

CITY OF DOVER Item #3.

DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: NOVEMBER 27, 2024

APPLICATION: Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S Governors Avenue and S Bradford Street FILE #: MI-24-10 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Water & Wastewater CONTACT PERSON: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services CONTACT PHONE #: 302-736-7025 CONTACT EMAIL: jlyon@dover.de.us

T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .

T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :

CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS

SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL

  • 1.Our office has no objections to the proposed alley abandonment.

WATER

  • 1.The alley proposed for abandonment contains a water main. Our office requires that a public utility easement be provided in order to maintain proper service to our customers. The easement may not contain any structures or signage as per the Water / Wastewater Handbook. It is our understanding that adjacent parcels are to be redeveloped and lot lines will be re-recorded. As utility locations are to be redesigned at that time the public utilities easement is to be re-evaluated by the Department of Water & Wastewater with revisions made as appropriate at that time as well. RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
  • 1.None

ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT

SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL

  • 1.None WATER
  • 1.If the future development proposes to build on top of the aforementioned water main location, the developer shall relocate the water main to the satisfaction of the Department of Water & Wastewater. The cost of this relocation shall be the sole expense of the developer.

I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .

Paj 28

Item #3.

CITY OF DOVER ELECTRIC
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: NOV 27, 2024

APPLICATION: Request for Alley Abandonment, Part of Alley between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street FILE #: MI-24-10 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Electric Department CONTACT PERSON: Shawn Burgett, Engineering Services & System Ops Superintendent CONTACT PHONE #: 302-674-7568 CONTACT EMAIL #: sburgett@dover.de.us

T HE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE , PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY ’ S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE .

T HE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT :

CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS

ELECTRIC

  • 1.The Electric Department has no objections to the abandonment of a portion of the improved alley, located between South Governors Avenue and South Bradford Street. RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES
  • 1.None

ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT

  • 1.None

I F YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR NEED TO DISCUSS ANY OF THE ABOVE COMMENTS , PLEASE CALL THE ABOVE CONTACT PERSON AND THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT AS SOON AS POSSIBLE .

Paj 29

C F #3.
MI-24-10
Item
I I
T R
CITY OF DOVER Y E

DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE O M

F A APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY R D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 11/27/24 D S O H V A E L R APPLICATION: Request for Alley Abandonment Part of Alley between S Governors Ave and S. Bradford St

FILE #: MI-24-10 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover, Office of the Fire Marshal

CONTACT PERSON: Jason Osika, Fire Marshal PHONE #: (302) 736-4457 josika@dover.de.us

THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY, AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.

THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESS BY THE APPLICANT:

CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:

  • 1.Proposal is a request for abandonment of a portion of the improved alley. This office has no objections

ADDITIONAL / SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS TO OBTAIN APPROVAL:

  • 1.N/A

APPLICABLE CODES LISTED BELOW (NOT LIMITED TO):

2021 NFPA 1 Fire Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2021 NFPA 101 Life Safety Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 72 National Fire Alarm and Signaling Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 13 Installation of Sprinkler Systems (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2009 IBC (International Building Code) Latest editions of all other NFPA Codes as defined by the Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations 2021 Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations City of Dover Code of Ordinances

*If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person listed.

Paj 30

Item #3.

CITY OF DOVER D
E
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
L
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY D
O
T
===============================================================

APPLICATION: Request for Alley Abandonment

FILE#: MI-24-10 REVIEWING AGENCY: DelDOT

CONTACT PERSON: Brian Williams PHONE#: 302-760-2141

=============================================================== THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY'S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.

THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:

CITY & STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:

No person, firm, corporation or the like shall construct, open, reconstruct, maintain, modify or use any crossing or entrance onto a state-maintained highway, street or road, including any drainage modifications leading into or carried by the highway drainage system, without first having complied with standards and regulations adopted by the Department and having obtained a permit issued by the Department. Please contact the Delaware Department of Transportation - Development Coordination section to begin permit process.

RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES:

ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:

  • 1.DelDOT has no objections.

Paj 31

Item #3. KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT 1679 SOUTH DUPONT HIGHWAY • DOVER, DELAWARE 19901• (302) 608-5370 • WWW.KENTCD.ORG

CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
DECEMBER 2024

APPLICATION: Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street FILE #: MI-24-10 REVIEWING AGENCY: Kent Conservation District CONTACT PERSON: Cullen Baker PHONE: (302) 608 – 5370 EMAIL: stormwater@kentcd.org

THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE. THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT:

Source: 2019 Delaware Sediment and Stormwater Regulations

CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:

Kent Conservation District has no objection to the Alley Abandonment.

Paj 32

Item #3.

CITY OF DOVER Dover/Kent
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
County
Metropolitan
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY Planning
D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 12/4/2024 Organization

MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street

FILE # MI-24-10 REVIEWING AGENCY: Dover/Kent County MPO

CONTACT PERSON: Malcolm Jacob PHONE #: (302) 387-6030

Issues of concern to the MPO are effective transit, reducing the amount of vehicle emissions by shortening or eliminating trips, and facilities for alternative modes of transportation, including bicycle and pedestrian access. The MPO considers the bicycle facilities required by the City of Dover to be the standard for all applications, not to be waived.

City of Dover Planning Commission
Alley Abandonment Review

MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street

Dover Kent MPO does not have any objections to the alley abandonment. Further comments will be given when the site is developed.

If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person and the Planning Department as soon as possible.

Paj 33

'!Citp of i.lober
Item #3.

MAYOR AND COUNCIL

COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2025- 01

A RESOLUTION PROPOSING THE VACATING AND ABANDONMENT OF CERTAIN IMPROVED ALLEY SITUATED IN THE CITY OF DOVER.

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:

Section 1. The Council of the City of Dover favors the vacating and abandoning of an alley extending north from Minor Street. An alley which is located in the block between South Governor's Avenue and South Bradford Street as specified below:

All that certain lot, piece or parcel of land, situated in the City of Dover, East Dover Hundred, Kent County and the State of Delaware, said parcel being a portion of an unnamed alley lying on the north side of Minor Street Alley, said parcel being bounded on the south by Minor Street Alley, on the west in part by lands now or formerly of the City of Dover, in part by lands now or formerly of The Downtown Dover Development Corp Dover Parking Authority, and in part by lands now or formerly of the Downtown Dover Development Corporation, on the north in part by lands now or formerly of Yau Yee Leung Louie and in part by other lands now or formerly of the City of Dover, and on the east in part by other lands now or formerly of the City of Dover, in part by lands now or formerly of Capital City Transformation Alliance, Inc. and in part by lands now or formerly of CEI Properties, LLC, said parcel being as shown as an "Existing Alley to be Abandoned" on an unrecorded plat plan entitled, "Parcel Consolidation Plan" for Lands of Downtown Dover Partnership as prepared by Becker Morgan Group, Inc., dated December 5, 2024, said parcel being more particularly bounded and described in accordance with said plan, as follows to wit:

Beginning for the same at a point on the northerly right-of-way line of Minor Street Alley (20.00 feet wide) at a comer for this parcel and lands now or formerly CEI Properties, LLC, said point being further located South 77° 42' 52" West - 143.99 feet from the point of commencement being the intersection of the westerly right-of-way line of South Bradford Street (60.00 feet wide) with the northerly right-of-way line of Minor Street Alley; thence from said point of beginning continuing with the northerly right-of-way line of said Minor Street Alley South 77° 42' 52" West - 12.02 feet to a point at a comer for this parcel and lands now or formerly of the City of Dover; thence running with the line for said lands now or formerly of the City of Dover, North 15° 41' 56" West-28.89 feet to a common comer for this parcel, said lands now or formerly of the City of Dover and lands now or formerly of The Downtown Dover Development Corp Dover Parking Authority; thence running with the line for said lands now or formerly of The Downtown Dover Development Corp Dover Parking Authority, North 16° 31' 31" West-51.74 feet to a point at a common comer for this parcel, said lands now or formerly of The

Paj 34

Item #3.

Paj 35

Item #4.

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING

The Regular City Council Meeting was held on January 27, 2025, at 6:30 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Council members present were Mr. Hare, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Arndt, Mr. Rocha, Dr. Sudler, and Mr. Lewis.

Staff members present were Fire Chief Carey, Police Chief Johnson, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Marney, Ms. Duca, Ms. Melson-Williams, Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Mayor Christiansen was also present.

OPEN FORUM

The Open Forum was held at 6:15 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Council President Anderson declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.

William Faust, 136 Orchard Drive, expressed concerns about the snow removal fines, city audits for the years 2023 and 2024, and overflow refund. He thought it was atrocious that for the first offense, it was $100 if snow was not removed. He was concerned because he had received phone calls from several people who were handicapped and senior citizens. Another concern he had was that the city audits of 2023 and 2024 had not been posted on the website. He wanted to see the city thrive. Mr. Faust wanted to know if the city was on the verge of bankruptcy. His last concern was the overflow refund, and he had not gotten his refund back. He wanted to know if they would raise taxes or the fees if they ran out of electric funds. Mr. Faust believed they deserved answers. He noted that constituents have a responsibility and a right to know how well council is doing their jobs.

Responding to Mr. Faust, Ms. Marney stated that the Fiscal Year 2023 audit was being evaluated for several factors. She noted that the Finance Department had incurred significant staff turnover. She pointed out that as of last week, she had met with the auditor, and they were waiting for the final sign-off letters for the Fiscal Year 2023 audit to be released. Ms. Marney had been concerned with the electric fund bond covenants and further explained there were missing details that were discovered due to the turnover in staff, and gave assurances that the details had been added to the financial report so that it could be reported accurately to the public. She noted that with the inclusion of the PCA debit, which was billed in Fiscal Year 2023, the electric revenues had put the city within their bond covenant ranges for the year. As far as the Fiscal Year 2024 audit was concerned, that is still ongoing. Ms. Marney mentioned that she had been in contact with the Customer Service Director over the past few weeks regarding the stormwater utility refund. The anticipation of having the refunds issued by January 31st may be extended due to a city-wide system outage. However, they were actively working on applying credits to customer service utility accounts.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Marney clarified that the city’s bond ratings are AA with a stable outlook and that the city is not going bankrupt.

Doug Hall, 718 South Governors Avenue, expressed concerns regarding drug addicts, trash, and small businesses. He expressed concern that small businesses come and go downtown within six

Paj 36

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 2

(6) months. He noted that the previous governor had given $25 million to the Downtown Dover Partnership for the property and that the parking lot had become a dangerous area for drugs and prostitution. Mr. Hall stated that the homeless problem was not as bad as the addiction problem and that they cannot keep putting a band-aid on it, businesses are leaving because of the drug addicts. Mr. Hall would like to see Dover thrive, but it will never thrive with what is happening on Governors Avenue. Mr. Hall stated that the city has phenomenal police officers and a good chief, but that they need to do more.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Faust stated that he was referring to the stormwater overflow fee. He was concerned that residents were charged $30 or more. He noted that he had heard rumors that taxes would be raised, or a fee would be put in place. He wanted to know what they were doing to bring money in. Mr. Faust was concerned about how money was coming into the city since businesses were coming in and closing. He wanted to know if they were cherry-picking which laws would be enforced since the district attorney was not prosecuting prostitution.

INVOCATION

The invocation was given by Elder Ellis B. Loudon.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Councilwoman Arndt.

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda as amended, seconded by Mr. Boggerty, and carried unanimously.

ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA

All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the consent agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

PROCLAMATION – BLACK HISTORY MONTH

The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:

WHEREAS, since 1976, the United States has celebrated Black History Month in February to recognize and honor the profound contributions, achievements, and resilience of African Americans throughout our nation's history; and

WHEREAS, Black history is an integral part of American history, encompassing the struggle for freedom and equality, the pursuit of excellence in arts, science, education, public service, and countless other fields, and the enduring legacy of courage, leadership, and determination that continues to inspire us all; and

WHEREAS, the theme for Black History Month 2025, "African Americans and Labor, "focuses

Paj 37

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 3

on the various and profound ways that work intersects with the collective experiences of African Americans; and

WHEREAS, work has been central to much of Black history and culture, from the agricultural labor of enslaved Africans to debates among African American educators on vocational training, from self-help strategies and entrepreneurship in Black communities to organized labor's role in combating economic and social injustice. Everywhere we look, Black people's work has transformed societies across the nation; and

WHEREAS, Black leaders throughout our nation's history, such as Frederick Douglass, Harriet Tubman, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., Bayard Rustin, Thurgood Marshall, Fannie Lou Hamer, Rosa Parks, Langston Hughes, John Lewis, and many others, have worked tirelessly to create a more fair, just, and equitable society; and

WHEREAS, we honor the contributions of African American residents who have enriched our community through their leadership, service, and cultural contributions;

NOW, THEREFORE, I, ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE do hereby proclaim February 2025 as BLACK HISTORY MONTH in the City of Dover and encourage all citizens to recognize black owned businesses in our community.

PROCLAMATION – HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS MONTH

The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:

WHEREAS, according to the National Human Trafficking Hotline, "Human trafficking is a crime involving the exploitation of someone for the purpose of compelled labor or a commercial sex act through the use of force, fraud, or coercion. It affects individuals across the world, including the United States, and affects every community in the United States across age, gender, ethnicity, and socio-economic backgrounds"; and

WHEREAS, forced labor and forced sexual exploitation have risen to an estimated $236 billion in profits worldwide every year. The 2021 International Labour Organization report estimates 49.6 million adults and children were victims of modern slavery globally. An estimated 27.6 million were in forced labor including 17.3 million exploited in the private sector, 6.3 million in forced commercial sexual exploitation and 3.9 million in forced labor imposed by state. Traffickers often take advantage of instability caused by natural disasters, conflict, or a pandemic to exploit others; and

WHEREAS, since 2007, the Human Trafficking Hotline for Delaware has received close to 870 signals, such as phone calls, texts, emails and online tips, and identified over 600 victims included in 269 cases of human trafficking; and

WHEREAS, in 2009, Trafficking Victims Protection Act passed by Congress establishing methods for prosecuting traffickers, preventing human trafficking and protecting victims and survivors of trafficking. Recognizing potential red flags and knowing the indicators of human trafficking is a key step in identifying more victims and helping them find assistance. Delaware

Paj 38

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 4

leaders, social organizations and Delaware Healthcare Association all are devoting efforts to raise awareness and help stop the epidemic.

NOW, THEREFORE, I, ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE do hereby proclaim January 2025 as HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS MONTH in the City of Dover and urge all residents to take action by being informed, spread awareness and know the signs for it could save someone's life.

PRESENTATION – RECOGNITION OF SERVICE – LISA ENRIGHT – ETHICS COMMISSION (AUGUST 2017-DECEMBER 2024) On behalf of members of Council, Mayor Christiansen presented Lisa Enright with a Dover Cup in recognition of her service on the Ethics Commission from August 2017 through December 2024.

PRESENTATION – DOVER HOPE ZONE

Mr. Darius Brown and Ms. Tina Custis briefed members on the Dover Hope Zone.

RESOLUTION NO. 2025-01 – SETTING OF PUBLIC HEARING – ALLEY

ABANDONMENT – DOWNTOWN MOBILITY CENTER PROJECT

Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, briefed the members of council on the proposed Resolution No. 2025-01 – Setting of Public Hearing – Alley Abandonment – Downtown Mobility Center Project.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that as a member of the Planning Staff, she was not aware of any appraisal of the landmass being completed. A portion of the alley crosses adjoining parcels, some of which are within the right of way and are currently fully maintained by the City of Dover.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that he did not have the information available, but he would get the information to him before they made a decision.

For the record, Dr. Sudler stated that he had asked for information during the Utility Committee discussion and that it would be provided to him.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Madam Clerk Bennett explained that the Tyler system was currently down and clarified that the issue was primarily financial. She explained that the process involves running a public hearing advertisement, which is a legal requirement to be published 10 days prior to the hearing to inform the public of the upcoming event.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the Planning Commission had conducted their own public hearings and there was a notice as part of the Planning Commission meeting agenda. She noted that any other notification would be with the City Clerk’s Office.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Madam Clerk Bennett stated that they notified the surrounding businesses, but not the public. She explained that their procedures, in accordance with the code, involve sending out notification letters and publishing a public hearing advertisement, which is part of the city clerk’s responsibilities. It is part of the code and their procedure that they send

Paj 39

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 5

out letters and run a public hearing ad, on the city clerk’s part.

Ms. Arndt pointed out that the project has had a considerable amount of public outreach. The Mobility Center and the Downtown Redevelopment Project have had the information put out to the public. She noted that people should know that they are having a public hearing on the alleyway abandonment since it is for redevelopment. She believes that they need to lend their support to the Downtown Dover Partnership for the project.

Ms. Arndt moved for the adoption of Resolution No. 2025-01 and the setting of the public hearing date for February 10, 2025, at 6:30 p.m. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil.

Dr. Sudler stated that he would like to have the information regarding the value of the portion that the city owns in the reading of the record. He explained that based on their previous conversation city council could request that it be purchased from them and since they are at a point where they need to generate revenue, it would be a great alternative to see what the constituents wanted to do. It was a decision that required public input and knowledge regarding how they would want council to vote as their representatives. He believed that any opportunity that they have to generate income should at least be reviewed. Then whether they choose to take advantage of that opportunity or not, they should hear from the constituents and keep them informed about council’s actions. The constituents may want it to be purchased since it is public property. He wanted to state for the record that the alley portion being abandoned had a certain value and that this information should be made known to the constituents when read into the public hearing record.

Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the amended Resolution No. 2025-01 to ensure the approximate value of the property is disclosed. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis.

Ms. Arndt stated a point of order, since it was a request for information, she believed that they did not need to make a motion to receive the information. She noted that they should trust that since it has been asked, it would be answered.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Dr. Sudler stated that he had requested the information twice before and was told it would be provided. He believed the best course of action would be to make a motion so that the information would be provided.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Marney stated that the property does not have a parcel ID assigned to it, so they are unable to look up the current assessment value. She noted there was a difference between an assessed value versus an appraised value, unfortunately, they are not able to look that information up in their systems. They would need to get an appraisal to get a value for the property.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg stated typically streets and alleys do not have a parcel ID. They are simply marked on the parcel maps the same way city streets are shown as public rightaways. He noted that the property, alley, and the properties adjacent to it have been owned by the city for decades and are maintained regularly as part of the city and the downtown partnership. Mr. Hugg reminded council that they approved the transfer of the adjacent city properties to the Downtown Development District for redevelopment a few months ago and that

Paj 40

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 6

the property in question happens to be the alley that falls between those two (2) properties. For the record, at the time there was no concern raised about the value of the property.

Mr. Neil stated that taxpayers’ money had been taken care of the property by keeping it clean and doing whatever was necessary. If there was a value, they might be flipping the value from what they had to do to what the object was for now. It may cost more to get an assessment of what it would be if they had built a house, and a house cannot be built since the property is too small. He noted that, with the abandonment of the alley, they no longer have to spend money to maintain the property. Mr. Neil also mentioned that if the alley had been causing problems with things happening downtown, they would be getting rid of that particular problem.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that the alley is very narrow, the dimensions are 12 feet wide, and it is not a high-priority designated emergency access. He pointed out that it provides access to two (2) parking lots that are adjacent to it, which would be incorporated into the Mobility Center when it is completed, and then they will have access from Governors Avenue, Bradford Street, and Minor Street.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Chief Johnson stated that there has been crime activity on the Minor Street Alley. He noted that there has been violent crime in that area periodically. He cannot speak about too many accidents with a criminal component as it is a traffic way or a roadway, but its proximity to some of the other places that council is aware of has had events happen over the last several years. It has been connected to several criminal events.

Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Anderson stated that they are voting on the amendment and asking to have the approximate value brought to the next meeting, which is scheduled for February 10, 2025.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson stated that the motion did not say it had to be assessed, it could have a market assessment.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that to find out the assessed value for the alleyway, they would have to spend money. To the best of his knowledge, there was no assessed value for the alley itself. The adjacent parcels have an assessed value associated with them whether they are owned by the city or by the Downtown Partnership. The only way they would get some kind of value would be to get at least an informal appraisal from an appraisal firm. Mr. Hugg noted that he does not know the cost, but that it would not be free.

Dr. Sudler rescinded his motion based on the new information about the property not having a parcel ID. Dr. Sudler stated that he would not support the adoption because there was no parcel ID, that could provide who has the right to legal ownership. To the best of his knowledge, a court judgement would be needed stating that the city owns the property since they have been taking care of it for over twenty years. Dr. Sudler stated that the city does not have proof of legal ownership by law and for that reason, he cannot support the adoption of the ordinance.

Mr. Lewis withdrew his second for Dr. Sudler’s motion, stating that Dr. Sudler’s property concerns were valid. He was surprised that the city did not have a value for the property. Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Rodriguez stated that he would look into the property. He

Paj 41

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 7

thought it was a regular alley abandonment, which they do all the time. He continued to state that there was no question about the city’s ownership and that this was the basis for their decision to abandon it.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the alley, located within a separate right-of-way, crosses three (3) parcels, one (1) of which is owned by the City of Dover. She confirmed that the city charter gives council the authority to vacate or abandon streets and rights-of-way. While the City of Dover’s zoning ordinance and land subdivision regulations do not specifically outline a process for alley abandonments, the city clerk’s office has established procedures, based on city policy documents, that are used by the various boards and commissions.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there were a series of multiple different ownership entities that were involved. She further stated that because of the collective use of a portion of that area as public parking spaces that were previously managed by the Dover Parking Authority, and now by its successor, the Downtown Dover Partnership.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the request intended that the alley being utilized and designated would return to the adjacent property ownership. The six (6) parcels and an additional parcel were involved in a redevelopment plan, which would consolidate all six (6) tracks of land into one (1) large parcel for development activity.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg stated that he could not answer that question directly. However, he explained that the state had allocated $25 million to the Downtown Partnership, with about $11 million for utility work in the adjacent area. Around $14 million was available to the Downtown Partnership for redevelopment, which included the acquisition of two (2) parcels on Bradford Street, one (1) of which had already settled. The funding also included the design, engineering, and construction of a parking garage. Mr. Hugg clarified that the city’s contribution to the initiative involved transferring the city-owned parking lot to the Downtown Partnership so that they could build a public parking facility on that site. The properties surrounding the Downtown Dover Development Corporation include those of the City of Dover (Capital City Transformational Alliance subsidiary), the CBI properties (being acquired by the partnership), Downtown Delaware Development, the Dover Parking Authority, and other lands owned by the City of Dover. He noted that all of the land involved in the alley process is owned by either the City of Dover directly or by the Downtown Dover Partnership and will ultimately be Downtown Dover Partnership property.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rodriguez stated that he believes that the property is shown on plots, and that, by default, indicated a dedication to the City of Dover unless there was a prior reservation made. He believes that the recording of it amounted to an automatic dedication and that the city owns it. It is a normal procedure.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that the site plan for the project shows that all of the alleyways are encompassed in the six (6) parcels which would have parcel numbers and parcel IDs. It is no different than a public street. He noted that they do not have a parcel ID number for South Redford Street because it is public property. It is shown on public records, plot plans, maps, part of the highway, and the transportation system of the city. He pointed out that Mr.

Paj 42

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 8

Rodriguez stated that it has been long carried and long shown as a public right of way. Mr. Hugg explained that it occupies portions of six (6) properties, that have ID numbers that are appraised and owned by a public agency. He was not sure that the absence of a partial ID number was critical to the question of abandonment of an alley that has been in public use on public land, part of the parking process downtown and to be used again in the future by a quasi-public organization.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that the map was provided in the packet. He stated that the cross-hatched area on the survey depicted the alley and property ownership. He was unsure what further documentation could be provided

Mr. Anderson stated that Mr. Rodriguez would need to review it before the final vote.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Mr. Anderson clarified that the city could stop plowing, cleaning the streets, and performing any other maintenance to the property because it would not be their property. It would become the homeowner’s responsibility that live there.

Mr. Hare stated that it would save the city money by not having to clean and plow the streets. Mr. Hare agreed with Mr. Anderson, adding that they should get the final say. He pointed out if the city was going to start charging for the alley, then they should also charge for the streets since they do not have parcel IDs.

Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the amended Resolution No. 2025-01 to ensure the approximate value of the property being abandoned. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and failed by a roll call vote of two (2) yes (Lewis and Sudler), and seven no (7) (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Anderson).

Ms. Arndt moved for the adoption of Resolution No. 2025-01 for setting the public hearing date for February 10, 2025, at 6:30 p.m. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and carried, by a roll call vote of seven (7) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Anderson), two (2) no (Lewis and Sudler).

ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 13, 2025 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of January 13, 2025, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen.

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT OF –

JANUARY 14, 2025

The Council Committee of the Whole met on January 14, 2025, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis (via WebEx), Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Dr. Sudler. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Garfinkel, and Mr. Shevock (Legislative, Finance, and Administration). Mr. Iriowen and Mr. Wilson (Utility) were absent.

Paj 43

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 9

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

Council Reports – December 2024

First District Dr. Pillsbury reported that she attended their First District Town Hall in December. She explained that it was not well attended but very helpful. She also reported attending all the holiday celebrations and especially enjoyed the Kwanza celebration.

Mr. Rocha reported that he attended the same events as Dr. Pillsbury. He was present for the tree lighting ceremony and was the Master of Ceremonies (MC) for the Dashing Through Downtown Dover Parade on Loockerman Street.

Second District Mr. Hare reported that the tree lighting ceremony was cold and many of the kids were gone by the time Santa arrived.

Mr. Lewis had nothing to report.

Third District Mr. Neil reported that he and Ms. Arndt attended the tree lighting ceremony and they “knocked it out of the ballpark” on “We Wish You a Merry Christmas”. He received a constituent complaint regarding shots heard in the Garrison Track, the constituent wanted to know if hunting is still allowed there. He also received a complaint regarding an exceptionally high water bill which Jason Lyon promptly followed up on. He reported receiving multiple complaints regarding snow removal in Wild Meadows. He attended the Library Board meeting and noted that statistically, Kent County residents are using the library more than city residents. Under the new formula, the reimbursement to the city continues to drop. Brian Sylvester, Library Director, intends to prepare a presentation for Kent County Levy Court to request adjusting the formula. Mr. Neil reported sending alerts to the Third District Civic and Homeowners Association leaders regarding the January 13, 2025, Safety Action Workshop held at the Modern Maturity Center, KnowBe4 Scam Alerts, snow removal updates, and resumption of trash pickup.

Ms. Arndt reported that she attended the wonderful holiday events. She thanked the staff and volunteers who made the events possible. She also thanked the Dover Fire Department for allowing her to ride in the fire engine so that she did not have to walk in the cold during the parade. She emphasized her enthusiasm for being able to use the fire siren. She attended the 10th anniversary event of the Downtown Development District held at Rail Haus which celebrated the City of Dover's 10 years in the program. Lastly, she attended the Loockerman Street Tour with Governor-Elect Meyer. She explained that it was nice to spend time with him

Paj 44

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 10

but even more so with the merchants on Loockerman. She explained that there is a lot of energy and excitement about what is to come, and she is looking forward to supporting them as a council member.

Fourth District Dr. Sudler reported that he attended the celebration and final walk for Deputy Chief Spicer as well as the tree lighting ceremony. He received complaints about overgrown tree limbs on Forest Avenue as well as Conwell Street. He stated he would turn the pictures over to the City Manager and Assistant City Manager to aid in getting those complaints addressed. He reported receiving a call from a constituent asking the city to create a Homeowner Association Task Force. The constituent stated that those who are part of a homeowners association do not feel they are being treated fairly.

At-Large Mr. Boggerty reported that he attended the swearing-in ceremony of Bethany Hall-Long as well as the inauguration of the 153rd General Assembly of Delaware. Mr. Boggerty also paid his respects to Richard “Mouse” Smith, Delaware NAACP President, who tragically passed away unexpectedly. Lastly, Mr. Boggerty reported that on February 8, 2025, he will be hosting a faith-based workshop sponsored by the Gospel Music Workshop of America. They will be showcasing the local youth, artists, and music. Youths aged 10 to high school are welcome to register with talents ranging from singing, writing, musical instruments, dance, and art. Registration will be free and the event is scheduled to be held at The WELL Church. On January 31, 2025, a round table discussion will be held regarding the movie The Forge at The WELL Church. The discussion will be geared towards young men, fathers, and uncles.

Council President Anderson Council President Anderson reported that he was unable to attend the tree-lighting ceremony due to being ill. He commended Sankofa on raising the bar on events surrounding the December holidays. He stated they always bring an international flavor to Christmas from different places around the world and he is looking forward to their Martin Luther King events on January 20, 2025. Mr. Anderson reported that on January 18, 2025, he will be attending a preinaugural reception to provide a positive opportunity for the city. He stated there have been positive interactions and meetings with legislators, creating a partnership to represent the mutual constituents. He reported that the constituents from Kirkwood Street had some complaints regarding snow removal, but Queen Street noted that everything was handled perfectly. He praised the sanitation crews for picking up five days' worth of trash in three days after working 12-hour shifts during the snowstorm. Mr. Anderson also reported attending the 10th anniversary event of the Downtown Development District held at Rail Haus.

Selection Process of New City Solicitor (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the background information regarding the selection process of a new city solicitor.

Paj 45

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 11

Responding to Mr. Hugg, Dr. Sudler thanked him for compiling the data. Dr. Sudler requested a list be compiled of the services that the city is currently paying for. He would like to see the top three areas for which they provide services. He recommended that the conceptual models be provided to the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee so that they can absorb which model might be the best fit for the city. Whether they would like to hire an attorney who would work directly and solely for the City of Dover or what they have been traditionally doing. Dr. Sudler requested that the city publicly post the position and refrain from contacting any individuals directly, to ensure an unbiased hiring process. Dr. Sudler also recommended going outside of Delaware to see what small municipalities in Maryland are doing and bring that to the committee. Dr. Sudler would like to use that information to compile criteria. He would like to see the top five issues that the new solicitor will be dealing with.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that he could certainly do that. He also stated that any individual chosen must be a member of the Delaware Bar and have been practicing law in Delaware. Mr. Hugg stated that they will also need to include attorneys who specialize in other areas such as unions and police matters.

Dr. Sudler requested the breakdown of funds that the City is paying by specialty or expertise (unions/police matters) versus how much the city pays the City Solicitor. Dr. Sudler hopes to find an attorney who specializes in many different areas to save the city money. Dr. Sudler noted that currently in the code it does not state that the city has authority to hire outside attorneys, so that may need to be changed.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that some of the attorneys on the list only represent one municipality and a lot of that sometimes depends on where their offices are located. There are a few others who have made representing municipalities a specialty. Mr. Hugg noted that they could specify that the attorney would only represent the City of Dover. Mr. Hugg did reference the City of Rehoboth’s Request for Qualifications (RFQ) and how they did discuss in- house counsel as a full-time employee.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that he believes there is enough work for an in-house attorney and that an in-house attorney would make sense.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that having an in-house attorney could save the city money and give them more access to an attorney who does not charge $400 an hour every 15 minutes. The attorney would be available for Council meetings, Committee meetings, and other meetings as requested. Mr. Hugg noted that there are some advantages to having an in-house attorney.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that he does not believe that they could find an attorney who fits all their needs and that he would not recommend that either. He explained that having worked with bond counsel, labor union, and

Paj 46

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 12

employment counsel, they are specialized fields and he would be very cautious of the in-house attorney handling everything. Mr. Hugg noted that right now the City Solicitor and himself are the ones that reach out and work with outside counsel on a regular basis.

Responding to Mr. Hugg, Ms. Arndt recommended not making the RFQ process restricted. She recommended creating a list that was fairly general but still encompassed all the necessary requirements. That would give Council the opportunity to negotiate further once they see the proposals. Then at that point, if there are other items that they may want to include, they can negotiate with the applicant.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Hugg stated that if they look at the Rehoboth RFQ documents, under requirements and duties, the fifth one mentions that there are items that the attorney should be familiar with. Then it sets out a list of possible areas of law, so it does not only state land use, zoning, or finance.

Responding to Mr. Hugg, Ms. Arndt stated she believes that the Rehoboth RFQ is a good one to build from.

Responding to Mr. Hugg, Mr. Boggerty stated that he would be cautious about attempting to find a one-stop shop. While they can have a general attorney who can advise and guide them, they want subject matter experts to the best of their ability, especially because of the time restraints that it could take to perform the task.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that the code does not give them a whole lot of advice as far as the Deputy Solicitor. It requires that there be an attorney licensed to practice in Delaware in a manner as determined by the city solicitor. He stated that historically they have not had a great deal of involvement in selecting the Deputy Solicitor. Mr. Hugg noted that he would be very concerned about having a deputy in a different firm. Mr. Hugg stated that they may want to think about the deputy position and tighten the criteria a bit or define a little more thoroughly what the deputy’s primary role is.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that he would not recommend having an RFQ for each position. Mr. Hugg noted that the language in the code is very vague so it may be to their advantage to at least spell it out more. In addition to stating that they are to be a member of the Delaware Bar and practice for at least five years, maybe a little more specificity with three years’ experience in land use law, and two years’ experience in another field that defines a little more of what the job is.

Mr. Hare stated that if they hire a solicitor or if they hire an in-house solicitor, they are going to be held responsible for the advice they give the city to act on. He believes that the solicitor should have the majority of the input on who their deputy is going to be. Mr. Hare explained that if the solicitor is not available then

Paj 47

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 13

the deputy solicitor attends in their place. Mr. Hare stated that they should hire the solicitor, and then have the solicitor make recommendations for the Deputy Solicitor position. He believes that their main focus should be to get the solicitor hired and then worry about the deputy, but not do both at the same time.

Dr. Sudler suggested hiring two hybrid lawyers and a hybrid paralegal who has multiple skill sets. Dr. Sudler stated that his main concern is that sometimes, the deputy solicitor is being paid the same amount as the solicitor.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg noted that in other contracts there is a $50 to $100 difference because the primary solicitors are charging $500 an hour to begin with.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that it was Crystal Carey, who is another attorney at Schmittinger and Rodriguez. She practices a lot as if she were an outside specialty attorney for the city. He believes she handles employment and finance law.

Responding to Mr. Hugg, Dr. Sudler stated that he would like to add to the code that the deputy solicitor has at least five years of practicing law experience as well.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that Mr. Rodriguez did indicate to him that they would continue to provide services if the city is not able to hire a new solicitor by May. Mr. Rodriguez has indicated that they will not walk away from the city, but they have indicated clearly that they do not want to continue to be the city’s solicitor on a full-time basis.

Responding to Mr. Hugg, Dr. Sudler stated that he would like to see a clause added to the code that the outgoing city solicitor must provide the city with more than 90 or 120 days to properly search for a new solicitor. Possibly a six-month process.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Council President Anderson stated that he does not think that they should shy away from sending notifications to all the firms that provide municipal law as long as they send it to all of them. They cannot pick and choose who to send the notice to. They will also be sending it out in a variety of ways, such as the legal section of the newspaper, the city’s website, and the Delaware League of Local Governments.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg stated that there is a subscription service through the Delaware Bar for attorney solicitations as well.

Mr. Rocha stated that he would like to have the Legislative, Finance, and Administration committee sit down with Mr. Hugg to figure out the best way to produce the RFQ.

Paj 48

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 14

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg stated that at the bottom of page three of Rehoboth’s RFQ, there is a reference to a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) opinion that the selection must be open to the public. Mr. Hugg requested the city clerk to research that particular FOIA decision so they would know precisely what the issues were that resulted in that decision.

UTILITY COMMITTEE

The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Dr. Pillsbury moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried. (City Clerk’s Office Note: Mr. Iriowen was noted as being present prior to the committee meeting but did not successfully contact the clerk, therefore he is considered absent.)

Request for Alley Abandonment (Improved) – Downtown Mobility Center Project (Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) – (Alley extending north from Minor Street. Alley which is located in the block between South Governors Avenue and South Bradford Street)

Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the request for abandonment of the improved alley.

Staff recommended that the referenced alley be abandoned. If the Utility Committee and/or City Council was in favor of proceeding with the proposed abandonment the following actions were recommended: 1) The Downtown Dover Partnership would have to work with Public Works to relocate two dumpsters for downtown business trash removal and that a waterline would also need to be relocated; 2) That City Council adopt a Resolution setting a public hearing regarding the proposed abandonment for February 10, 2025.

Mr. Hare moved to accept staff recommendations.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that currently the alley is improved, meaning it has pavement, and it is owned as a public alley that the city would hold ownership of. In some cases, it crosses individual property lines, but it has been treated as a public alley. She explained that the abandonment is a process to relinquish the ownership of the land mass and that the alley was distributed to the adjacent property owners. In this case, the adjacent property owners at the time are a mix of different individual organizations, including the City of Dover. Ms. Melson-Williams noted that the long-term plan for the six parcels is to be consolidated into one large tract of land for the development of a building.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that parcels 148 and 150 are owned by an entity that was associated with representatives of the partnership.

Paj 49

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 15

She noted that the process would be that the Utility Committee make a recommendation and that it would be forwarded to City Council. City Council has a few steps that they would have to take for the abandonment of an alley, which would include a public hearing at a council meeting and the adoption of a resolution to take such action.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the short answer would be yes that the Downtown Dover Partnership would have control of the property, or some entity would. She noted that there has been separate action by council regarding some of the city-owned parcels in that area, but this would be a specific process focused on the area of the alley.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that currently, the City of Dover maintains that property. She was unsure if it was in the Charter or the Dover Code of Ordinances that would give council the power to lay out, locate, abandon, et cetera, the streets, sidewalks, alleys, and the like. There were statements about the abandonment in that it would mean a transfer of ownership, not necessarily one of neglect.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated it would be located in Article Two, Section 27, but was unsure if that was the Dover Code of Ordinance reference or a Charter reference.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hare stated that it would have been easier if it had said that this was the alley where they wanted to build the parking garage and that the city would be turning the property over to the Downtown Dover Partnership. He believed that everyone would have understood that without going through all the abandonment discussion, and that the Downtown Dover Partnership would be responsible for that property once it went through all the approvals, not the city.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the developer of the project would have to fund the relocation of the water line in conjunction with the plans approved by the city’s Department of Water and Wastewater. She does not believe it would be part of the overall utility project in the Loockerman Street Corridor.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the alley would become part of the development area for the building. It would be dissolved, as Mr. Lewis said. She noted that the land that currently served as that alley would become part of the overall development project area, and the building would take up the six parcels. It would no longer be a way to cross that area because the proposed building is a large rectangle that would encompass that area.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams clarified that the alleyway would not be in existence.

Paj 50

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 16

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated the planning office was not involved with knowing the value of the property. She believed that the code gave council the discretion regarding how the transfer occurs and whether it would need to be purchased or other considerations in transferring the title to it.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that code citation could be found in Article Two (2), Section 27, Power of Council to locate, layout, and locate abandoned streets and sidewalks. She believed that it was part of their Charter.

Mr. Hare moved to accept staff recommendations. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

Meeting House Branch Drainage Improvement Project Update (Jason Lyon,
Water/Wastewater Director)
Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and
analysis of the Meeting House Branch Drainage Improvement Project.

Staff recommended that the committee provide a recommended direction, based upon the two options provided by staff, to City Council for acceptance and implementation.

Dr. Sudler stated that with a lot of financial constraints that the city has gone through, he would go with option two, reduce the scope of the project to meet the minimum requirements of the Environmental Improvement Project (EIP).

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon confirmed with the state that the bond bill money could not be used for the Environmental Improvement Project (EIP).

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that it would be removing the clarifying rings, planting a meadow, and landscape, and providing a repairing buffer. He noted that a repairing buffer was like a filter before the water goes into the river, but there would be no drainage improvements with that.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that the original plan was kind of an open channel through that area, and then revised that to be a culvert, which would allow for future development. The plan was that they would remove any of the contaminated soil as part of the drainage project in concert and the clarifying rings would then stay there because they were thinking about redeveloping it. They would renegotiate with them to eventually redevelop the site. He noted that they do not want to dump a bunch of money into it now until they can get it figured out.

Paj 51

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 17

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that they could go with option two, it could be redeveloped but the drainage would not be there to help. In his opinion, it would not be prudent to develop that site with not enough drainage to pull that through that area, it would be a flooded mess.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that the Bayhealth property area was prone to flooding, even though they have been lucky not to experience an event so far. He noted that any event exceeding a 10-year storm, which would have a one in ten chance of happening, would result in flooding in that area.

Mr. Neil stated that the idea of having stormwater as an enterprise fund was a wise decision, but the outcome was not wise. He believed that they needed to go back to that because they needed that as a permanent source of funding for stormwater. He explained that the first step would be to take a look as fast as possible at reverse engineering the financials. Mr. Neil stated that they need to consider all properties, including those that do not pay taxes, and divide it up in terms of the money that they need using the smaller houses that are located throughout the city, moving up to how much it would cost them, and then move up to the larger buildings and see what the costs would be for those. There needs to be another method of figuring out how to make the equity between the actual size of the houses or buildings that they are dealing with. Mr. Neil explained that when 30% or more of the properties were not paying taxes, the amount should not have exceeded what it did, so the process had to be reversed.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Lyon stated that if they went with the Environmental Improvement Project (EIP), there would be no upstream drainage improvement project. He noted that it would just do the minimum and the meadow would be there, which would not improve any drainage issues. Mr. Lyon explained that in the notes, they would have to break those agreements, and those discussions would have to happen with the consultants and the organizations involved. He stated that it would be imperative that they have a game plan for sustainable payments for this, but it is not his jurisdiction. He believed that they should get the drainage improvement project done. It is just a matter of making sure that they have a sustainable plan going forward for it and that it would be the biggest anchor of their capital program for stormwater in the next five years and it needs to be accounted for.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that there has been a conversation with DNREC about the Environmental Improvement Project (EIP). They have been willing to work with the city on a timeline, in regard to the bond bill money, the $8.3 million that would come from the state. He mentioned that they have funds that need to be used before June 30, 2026, but he had received verbal confirmation from the state that they would extend the date if needed.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon acknowledged that there are taxes and payments are out-of-pocket expenses for constituents but reminded them that if the project keeps getting delayed, the cost will rise due to inflation.

Paj 52

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 18

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that his prediction for the cost to go up would be roughly 3.5% per year.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Lyon stated that they had not considered the idea of bonding the project. He noted that it would come with interest, but they could take a look at that and bring it back to the committee.

Mr. Neil suggested that Mr. Lyon work with his staff to find out what the process would be for bonding and reinstating the enterprise fund in a different formula so that they could have options to look at and how it would work.

No action was taken at this time.

Evaluation of Proposals – White Oak Road Pump Station Grit Removal System Engineering Support (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and analysis of the evaluation of proposals for the White Oak Road Pump Station Grit Removal System Engineering Support. Staff recommended awarding the contract to Century Engineering for the White Oak Road Pump Station Grit Removal System Engineering Support, RFP #25- 0013WW, for the amount of $65,620.

Dr. Sudler moved to accept staff recommendations. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 7:46 p.m.

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.

Economic Development Fund and Community Development Fund Guidelines (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the proposed Economic Development Fund and Community Development Fund guidelines.

Staff recommended approval of the recommended guidelines.

Paj 53

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 19

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Hugg agreed that they would need something more specific and directed to administer a project. He stated that it was part of the plan and that he was going to take one piece at a time to make sure that council was on board with how they were going to do things. He would then bring something to them depending on whether the application was to be approved by council or not, but he could bring that to them in the next few weeks.

Ms. Arndt moved to add a follow-up on receipts or proof that funds were administered in the way that they were intended, a specified timeline so that money is not administered and sit for several years, a means to claw back the funds if the project is not completed and to make sure that it is not to benefit one person, property, or business owner, it is to benefit the community and that must be demonstrated. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and carried with Mr. Lewis abstaining.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

Ms. Arndt clarified that she intended to approve the guidelines with the inclusion of the items listed, along with the understanding that they will be developing a process.

Proposed Ordinance #2025-02 – Project Carry-Forward Budget Balances/Proposed Budget Amendments (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer) Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer reviewed the proposed carry-forward budget balances and Proposed Ordinance #2025-02.

Staff recommended approval of the proposed Budget Amendments totaling $24,744,582 for Fiscal Year 2025 and adoption of Ordinance #2025-02.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Marney stated that the items that they would need to look out for would be the stormwater utility. She mentioned that they are reviewing different qualifications and how they can continually fund stormwater utility expenditures. As of right now, they have moved back to the general fund. Fortunately, they have not finished transferring all of the transfers for assets and the employees through the financials as far as booking those entries. As they are looking at the budget being carried forward, those items are already in the general fund. She noted that the documentation was provided in the packet.

Ms. Marney stated that they do need to work together as a team to re-evaluate the needs for stormwater utility and come back with a different plan. She believes that they would need a tax increase and then how they packaged that to the citizens going forward would be a challenge for all of them.

Paj 54

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 20

Ms. Arndt moved to accept the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:00 p.m.

Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:00 p.m.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

QUARTERLY REVENUE REPORT AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2024

Members were provided the Quarterly Revenue Report as of December 31, 2024.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Quarterly Revenue Report as of December 31, 2024, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

QUARTERLY REVIEW – CAPITAL INVESTMENT PLAN (CIP) (OCTOBER, NOVEMBER, AND DECEMBER) Members were provided the Quarterly Report for the Capital Investment Plan (CIP) as of December 31, 2024.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Quarterly Report for the Capital Investment Plan (CIP) December 31, 2024, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

CONFIRMATION OF POLICE PENSION ELECTION

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Confirmation of Police Pension Election, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.

Confirmation of Police Pension Election - Retired Sergeant Steve Rogers - Three (3) Year Term to Expire January 31, 2028.

ORDINANCE/FIRST READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-02 – PROJECT CARRY-FORWARD BUDGET BALANCES/PROPOSED BUDGET AMENDMENTS (PATRICIA MARNEY, CONTROLLER/TREASURER) Council President Anderson reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinances were available on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at 736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us. Council President Anderson further stated that the Final Action by City Council will take place during the Second Reading on February 10, 2025.

Paj 55

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 21

Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the proposed Ordinance #2025-02 – Project Carry – Forward Budget Balances/Proposed Budget Amendments.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney confirmed that the ordinance was done to rebudget project balances that were not spent in prior years. She noted that some projects were not completed.

Responding to Ms. Marney, Mr. Lewis requested that he receive a quarterly project report for follow-up. He noted that it would show him how long some of the projects have been in progress and would question the ones that have been ongoing for years, ones that have no expenses yet, and why they have not started.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that she could start working on putting the information together. She believed that she had those details when they went through the budgetary process.

In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:

ORDINANCE #2025-02 – PROJECT CARRY – FORWARD BUDGET BALANCES/PROPOSED BUDGET AMENDMENTS

CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mr. Hugg had no announcements.

MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mayor Christiansen requested a moment of silence in honor of Holocaust Remembrance Day, acknowledging the six (6) million lives lost and expressing hope that such a tragedy never occurs again. He then read comments addressing concerns and questions he had received throughout the week regarding federal immigration laws. (Exhibit #1)

COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mr. Boggerty shared that as he continued his community service in Dover, he and local community leaders will host an event on Friday, January 31, 2025, featuring a screening of The Forge, at 6:00 p.m. The event would be free, food would be provided and there would be discussion sessions about the movie. It will be held at The Well Church, Delaware and Beyond. He noted that on February 8, 2025, there would be a citywide arts workshop for all kids in the Dover area and that there would be a performance at 6:30 p.m. that same evening.

Mr. Lewis reported that he attended the Dover Fire Department 2025 Annual Banquet and Award ceremony at the Hyatt in Dewey Beach. He expressed wholehearted support for the fire department. He noted that Dr. Pillsbury attended the event as well. He announced he attended the Governor’s inauguration and looks forward to working with him. Mr. Lewis stated that he has been dealing with numerous constituent concerns regarding icy roads and sidewalk snow removal.

Paj 56

Item #4.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JANUARY 27, 2025 PAGE 22

Dr. Pillsbury thanked the fire department for a lovely event, and that she enjoyed it. It was her third time going and it continues to get better each year.

Mr. Anderson announced that anyone interested in giving their input regarding the snow removal and fines, et cetera is encouraged to attend the Committee of the Whole meeting on January 28, 2025. He noted that there would be time for public comments, during the committee items but not at the beginning of the meeting. He explained the format difference between council meetings and committee meetings, stating that while council meetings include a designated public forum, committee meetings allow public input after each agenda item is presented. Mr. Anderson mentioned that the Biggs Museum is offering a free eight (8) session art class for veterans, held on Fridays from 1:00 to 3:30 p.m., beginning on February 7, 2025.

The meeting adjourned at 8:05 p.m.

ANDRIA L. BENNETT CITY CLERK

All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by the City Council during their Regular Meeting of January 27, 2025, are hereby approved.

ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR /AB

Exhibits Exhibit #1 – Mayor Christiansen’s Letter for the City of Dover’s Relationship to Federal Immigration Laws

Paj 57

EXHIBIT #1

Regular City Council Meeting of Item
01/27/2025
#4.

Paj 58

Item #5.

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE

The Council Committee of the Whole met on January 28, 2025, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Dr. Sudler. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Dr. Jackson-Short and Ms. Smack (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation), and Mr. Garfinkel and Mr. Shevock (Legislative, Finance, and Administration).

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Anderson requested a quick update from Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, regarding the federal funds freeze.

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda as amended, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, briefed the members about the Presidents series of executive orders that would place a freeze on federal funds. One of the executive orders was effective at 5:00 p.m. and placed a freeze on all federal funds of all types from all agencies. Mr. Hugg stated he participated in a conference call with the congressional delegation and the governor. He explained that there are several uncertainties in what the executive order would do and what it would affect. He explained that the freeze applied to all federal money that was not received or dispersed to the state and the local governments. Mr. Hugg pointed out that the State Attorney General was planning to join a group of attorney generals across the country to file a lawsuit in Rhode Island Federal Court. They are requesting a temporary restraining order against the President and the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for the freeze. The freeze could become critical for the cities operations particularly in the department of water and wastewater, some of their projects rely on federal funds and several grants, including police grants, could be affected as well.

Mayor Christiansen stated that Mr. Hugg and himself sat in on the conference call and were informed that the district court in Rhode Island had supposedly issued a pause, but he was not able to verify that and the information.

THE GREEN BERET PROJECT (ADAM KRAMER, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR)

Mr. Adam Kramer, Executive Director, reviewed the presentation titled The Green Beret Project.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kramer stated that they could help fix a car, but they rely on mechanics to volunteer their time. Mr. Kramer explained that they have a young man who rents the shop in New Castle during the day, and they are currently mentoring him to start a business. They have given him a seventeen-year-old employee which he manages.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kramer stated that they do not work off referrals or enrolment; the kids usually join by word of mouth. He explained that there are levels of involvement. If the kids put in work, they are provided extra responsibilities and resources.

Paj 59

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 2

Ms. Arndt suggested an idea for a community service project for people in need like the elderly and disabled. She suggested that they could create a list of people who need assistance with shoveling their sidewalks. Once it snows, they could reach out to those individuals and possibly make a good amount of money for the program.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Kramer stated that their art program is usually done seasonally, as they have gotten several art-specific grants through the Delaware Community Foundation. He noted that there were girls from the Academy of Dover who were in the Green Beret Project and had been a part of the different art programs.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Kramer stated that they are working on getting the certificate of occupancy for the building in Manchester Square. He noted that the bathroom was in, however, there were some drainage issues. They are currently waiting on the ground to thaw to complete the cement and obtain the certificate of occupancy.

SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE

The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairman Boggerty presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

Prioritization of City of Dover State Capital Transportation Program (CTP) Projects (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager) Mr. David Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the Prioritization of City of Dover State Capital Transportation Program (CTP) Projects.

Staff recommended approving the 2025 Transportation Priorities.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that they are broken down by category, and the first project in each category was the number one priority. He explained that they used to rank them from one to twenty, but there was more than one number one for different reasons. For example, the Garrison Connector was an economic development priority, and Leipsic Road was a traffic priority.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that the Kenton Road project was funded. There was money in DelDOT’s budget for design, and right-of-way acquisition for this year and next year for the construction on College Road from McKee Road to Kenton Road to tie into the intersection in 2027. He noted that it was the number one priority under the safety and capacity improvements, and it was in the capital project for DelDOT. The sidewalks within the walk zone of the high school were the secondary priority in that same category.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that the project for Leander Lakes to the high school would include a crosswalk and a connection from the south side of the intersection down to the high school where there is a section of property just outside the city limits that does not have a

Paj 60

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 3

sidewalk either. He also brought attention to the first phase of the sidewalk improvement program that is taking place on Route 13 up to the area of Lowes.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg explained that the Crawford Carroll Avenue Extension was removed because the project was originally proposed over ten years ago, and Delaware State University has built their athletic fields in what would have been the right of way. Additionally, the projected traffic solution did not meet the cost requirements to make it feasible to do. The project dropped primarily at the request of DelDOT. At one time the project was included in a realignment of the north mall road that exists by the Volkswagen dealership. That intersection would have been a four-way intersection, crossing the highway and ending between the Produce Junction and Home Goods stores, that would have placed the road through the two Delaware State base ball fields.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that he does not recall the road being presented as easy access to transport students from Delaware State University. He noted that the idea at one time was to extend it across behind Lowe’s and then cut across what is now the baseball fields.

Mayor Christiansen explained that Crawford Carroll Boulevard was intended to improve and accommodate the proposed Dover Civic Center. When the property was given to Delaware State University the plans and the need for Crawford Carroll to be extended to the improvements at the intersection by Produce Junction were put on hold. Mayor Christiansen explained that he intends to have a meeting with the secretary of transportation as well as the governor to see if they can expedite the State College Road Project and the two traffic studies for McKee Road and State Street. He pointed out that Dr. Sudler brought forward the needs for those projects to be expedited if there were any means to do so. Mayor Christiansen explained that he also reached out to a legislator about a dedicated crossing with a signal from Leander Lakes to Dover Highschool. He stated that there is currently a signal in front of a building that is no longer being utilized as a school facility on Walker Road. He explained that he has not heard anything back, but it would save the city money and hopefully improve the traffic situation.

Mr. Neil moved to recommend accepting staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Snow Removal Practices and Constituent Concerns (Councilman Rocha and Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager) Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, briefed the committee on snow removal practices and constituent concerns (Attachments 1-2).

Committee Action Not Required.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Mark Nowak, Public Works Director, stated that salt and brine would not affect their National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit. He explained that using sand would be an issue because it is considered an illicit discharge into the system. Currently there is not a specific time in which they would have to sweep the sand up, but it would have to be in a timely fashion. He stated that the weather must be taken into account because if is freezing outside they cannot use water and if they are sweeping up the sand it will be

Paj 61

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 4

dirty and dusty, and people will likely complain. Mr. Nowak emphasized that in regard to the NPDES permit the sand would be the biggest issue because it is such a messy process to clean up.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Duca stated that currently the city treats critical routes which include several state roads and higher-use roads that have an increased thickness to the roadbed. She explained that one concern is the neighborhood and development roads which already have cracks and issues of grass and vegetation growing out of the roadbed. Treating those roads would continue to damage the roads quicker than is currently happening. Ms. Duca emphasized the importance of the balance between capital investment in the roads versus the operation. She explained that it is hard to predict how much material would be used in any given year because the weather is so inconsistent as opposed to Detroit.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Duca stated that one of the best preventative measures would be to keep up with regular street sweeping measures which the city currently executes a more aggressive pattern than is required by the NPDES permit. She explained that staff perform other preventative measures and maintenance efforts such as crack sealing which Mr. Nowak budgets for every year to address certain neighborhoods. She noted that it may be necessary to increase those efforts to prevent further decay.

Ms. Arndt stated that she did not recall having such high-volume constituent complaints in previous years. She believed that they did a good job with the resources that they had available given the situation and the weather that they were in. She stated that she felt the sand was not an option because of the permitting and disposal issues. She stated that brining and purchasing additional trucks would be a risk because it could be a wasted investment if they do not have a significant snowstorm in the future. Ms. Arndt explained that based on the information provided, she was not inclined to pursue either of the scenarios presented.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca stated that they have not looked into contractors that would be able to perform a level of service equivalent to what they are currently providing. She explained that Mr. Nowak was able to bring in a contractor to help with snow removal using several front loaders and equipment of that nature. She emphasized that two 12-hour shifts cost nearly $25,000. She stated that if there were to make additional efforts, they would want to minimize their staff increase as was mentioned. She explained that using contractors could benefit in that regard, but they would need to evaluate what equipment the different contractors use and what services they would be able to assist in providing.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca clarified that the cost of the contractors was nearly $25,000. She explained that in order to perform a valued analysis, they would need to get information back from contractors to find out what services they would provide and the cost. Requesting qualifications would be the best way to get the information and then they could analyze the cost- benefit.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that certain roads in the City of Dover are required to be taken care of by the city.

Paj 62

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 5

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Nowak stated that the city has a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) which lays out what roads the city is responsible for, a map of the DelDOT plow routes, and a do not plow list.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Nowak stated that the MOU outlines the state roads that the city will assist DelDOT in plowing.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that when POW-MIA Parkway was constructed, the original expectation of DelDOT was that the City of Dover would maintain the sidewalks and other infrastructure associated with the project and DelDOT would maintain the pavement and the bridges. The city did not have the staff to maintain those things, so they did some trading and DelDOT took on the sidewalks and the city took on part of a road. Part of the trading involved moving grass in certain areas along state roads three times a year because they did not want to mow more frequently than DelDOT performed that function themselves. She explained that the 1964 agreement outlined that DelDOT would maintain certain roads, but as a result, the city had to retain certain areas as well which is why the state is solely responsible for Route 13. They maintain a lot of signage and traffic signals.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that they could look at the 1964 agreement and renegotiate to see if they could minimize the number of state roads that they take care of so they can utilize more of their resources to address city matters.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that the state roads that the City of Dover is responsible for are pretreated by the City of Dover.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that they use the brine for all emergency routes. She explained that some of the state roads are on the critical list, so they use a mixture of brine and salt.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that roads are pretreated and get more travel which creates more friction. That friction helps dissipate the snow and ice and therefore the roads are better served. She explained that during a storm like the one that just occurred where it had been twenty-four hours before anything had been on the road and there was little traffic, the snow was then packed down making it more difficult to plow once the storm was over.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that the intent of the agreement with DelDOT was to save costs for the state, but they were looking at these past agreements and trying to uphold them. There are several agreements in addition to the 1964 agreement and the POW-MIA Parkway agreement.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that they are bringing forward a proposed ordinance that would change the timeframe for snow removal. The current code states that snow removal timeframe states removal must be completed within 12 hours of daylight after it ceases snowing. The proposal would be to change it to 24 hours after it ceases snowing. Additionally, there would be a proposed change from sending citations upon inspection and noting that the snow had not been shoveled. Currently, the citations are sent by certified mail and can take three to five days to

Paj 63

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 6

be received by a homeowner or occupant. The proposal would be to conduct a posting similar to what was approved with the grass ordinance and no fine would be issued in the company of the posting to give the homeowner or occupant time to clear the snow. Ms. Duca explained that they understand the concern for pedestrians when the sidewalks are not shoveled and there is additional concern for staff. She emphasized that there had been one injury from a slip and fall on ice in code enforcement this year.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Nowak stated that they are unable to remove any large piles of snow or ice that are not on the roadway because they do not have the proper equipment to remove it and run the risk of destroying anything underneath. He further explained that they ran out of space in many of the developments and were currently running through trash routes to remove excess snow piles. He estimated that they would spend two additional days to complete all the routes, and they have a large pile of snow at Schutte Park.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Nowak stated that they could possibly knock the piles down, but they would have to get assistance through Grounds and Parks and Recreation since they have the equipment for sidewalks.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that they could discuss that with Parks and Recreation and evaluate what they have and how long it might take to do that citywide.

Responding to Dr. Jackson-Short, Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, stated that code enforcement does go out after the period of time has passed. Twelve hours daylight is the current ordinance, which meant that they did not go out until Wednesday and were well within 12 hours. Changing that to 24 hours instead of having the word daylight in there would eliminate some of the confusion (Attachments 3-4). He pointed out that the reason why the time may seem small was because the ordinance was not a beautification ordinance. The sidewalks are to be cleared for public safety.

Mr. Kopp explained that he was aware of concerns with the homeowners, but several complaints were pedestrians walking into the roadways and highways. People in wheelchairs were trying to get down the sidewalk and they could not pass. He explained that the purpose of the ordinance was to protect the safety of all citizens, and a lot of people walk in Dover. Mr. Kopp emphasized that he was the slip and fall mentioned previously. He fell on an icy sidewalk posting a notice unrelated to snow removal.

Responding to Dr. Jackson-Short, Mr. Kopp stated that they start in the area where they receive complaints from and then they spread out from there. He explained that the city is split into four areas, and everyone in his department is assigned an area. He stated that staff focused on their assigned areas and what streets were most traveled and then worked their way into the neighborhoods. He emphasized that their focus was on the main highway because so many people were walking down the highway and the more exposed streets.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp clarified that it was not the sidewalk that walked up to the front door, but the sidewalks that surrounded the perimeter of the property.

Paj 64

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 7

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Nowak stated that the brine is made with a combination of water and salt and because their brining system is old, while making the brine they must continuously test to make sure they are at the twenty-three percent salt. He explained that they have no issue storing the salt. The salt that was used was from topping off the salt barn last year. He stated that they have already received two loads of salt to fill the barn after the one snowstorm this year. He emphasized that they have enough storage to keep up with the current need, however, if they needed to do more than what they are currently doing there would be a need for a bigger barn. If they were to do the whole city, they would need a salt barn like DelDOT.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Nowak stated that the only place that they could place a barn would be in Schutte Park.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Duca stated that based on the purchasing of the front half of Schutte Park, north of Van Sant, that area could only be utilized for recreational facilities, which is why most of the city’s operations are in the back half near Dover Little League. She stated that they would have to look at other facilities if they needed to expand operations.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Duca stated that the better investment would be the brine, however, it would not address the icy conditions afterwards and they would have to evaluate how it would work going into residential areas with the amount of traffic in them.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Nowak stated that every year when they are putting together a snow plan, they reach out to different companies for help. He explained that if the city does not have a retainer with the company, they have other customers that are serviced first. He stated that Teal Construction was the company that they used this year and past years, and they are able to assist the city once they have completed work for their other customers. He explained that it could be hard to find a company that they do not have to pay to be available.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Duca stated that they would likely have to pay a retainer if they were to expand to more contractors to be available when the city needs them. The retainer would likely be paid at the beginning of the year, and the money would not be refunded if there was no snowstorm because the company would be on standby for the city.

Mayor Christiansen stated when Shutte Park was purchased a deed restriction was put in that the properties to the front would remain for recreational purposes. He reminded council that over the years, several Public Works Directors requested a salt barn to be built, but those projects were removed from the budget and that was why they do not have salt barn in place. Additionally, the 1964 agreement was made with the State of Delaware to relinquish having to deal with plowing and maintaining the new Route 13. The city signed over that they would take up the maintenance on State Street, Governors Avenue, Division Street, Forest Street, and several other streets, and the city would pick up plowing them while the state would maintain the paving and maintenance.

Belinda Main, 142 Reese Street, Dover, stated that she had contacted Mr. Kopp about the notice she received about the snow removal on the sidewalks. She explained that after the snow on Monday, January 6, 2025, they shoveled their sidewalk and repeatedly shoveled it. Due to the wind drifting, the snow did go back on the sidewalk. Ms. Main had called and sent a picture on Thursday,

Paj 65

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 8

January 8, 2025, because she had received a fine of $100, and there was snow on one square in front of her walkway that had snow.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Kopp stated that snow removal is considered a non-appealable type fine, and they were in the process of updating the ordinance. The ordinances that are not appealable are based on a legal opinion. He explained that they are in the process of trying to incorporate an appeal process because currently there is no appeal process for any ordinances in the Dover Code of Ordinances.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Kopp stated that currently, the ordinance states that the sidewalks have to remain clear. At the time the photo that was taken, there was still snow on the sidewalk. Mr. Kopp stated that his interpretation of it, there was still snow on the sidewalk and he instructed the complainant to contact the city manager’s office if they felt they disagreed with his interpretation of the code. This was something that they would do with anyone who disagreed with their interpretation. He explained that their job as code enforcement was to interpret the ordinance in the way it is written and the way the ordinance is currently written, it does not grant any leniency. As a code enforcement officer, he has to follow the code, and the code does not give any opportunities to decide what they would or would not enforce.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Kopp stated that the $100 fine was increased recently as a part of all the fees and fines being increased.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Kopp stated that with the past snowstorm, they issued over 500 fines. He explained that there were a few reasons for this, one being the lack of compliance throughout the city and the other is because their office is completely staffed versus previous years. He stated that they were still receiving complaints and completing snow cases during the week as complaints were still coming in.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Kopp stated that in Ms. Main’s case, it was shoveled at a point. He had no way to determine when the snow came back onto the sidewalk. To be fair and consistent with everyone that Mr. Kopp spoke with, who may have shoveled their snow early, he could not make that determination. If he did try to interpret Ms. Main’s, he would have to interpret everyone else. He can interpret the way the ordinance is written, and it says that it has to remain free of hazards, whether it be snow drifts, ice, that may be on the sidewalk. Mr. Kopp noted that at the time he looked at the picture when the violation was issued, it was not free of hazards, so therefore it was not in compliance with the code and that was his interpretation of it.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Kopp stated technically the way the code is written right now, it would be required to chip the ice. Code Enforcement is taking a lot of heat, but they are enforcing the ordinance that was passed by City Council. He stated that the best way to go about was to revise the ordinance and specify what a hazardous condition was. They are looking into amending the ordinance, and they could look into defining hazardous conditions and put some parameters in there for ice and snow.

Paj 66

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 9

Marilyn Wilkes, WebEx attendee, asked why does the letter that came out state that it could be appealed when it was a non-appealable offense, and who was responsible for the sidewalks at Schutte Park.

Responding to Ms. Wilkes, Mr. Boggerty stated that the City of Dover would be responsible for the sidewalks at Schutte Park.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp stated that all the letters that they send out state there is a right to appeal. He explained that a legal review told them that it had to remain on the letter. The appeal does not necessarily say they are appealing to a board, but they are appealing to staff. They could appeal to the inspector who issued the citation as it does not say they appeal to the Construction and Property Maintenance Code Board of Appeals or appealing to a court of law.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp stated that it was not loosely interpreted, it was a legal opinion by the city solicitor. It did state that the Dover Code of Ordinances are not appealable, and they do have that in writing.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp stated that they could specify on the letter where they could appeal, such as to him or the city manager’s office, or they would have to appeal to the Construction and Property Maintenance Code Board of Appeals.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp stated that it would not be an easy fix, but it could be something to look into and define, and they might have to create a new letter.

Doug Hall, 718 Governors Avenue, Dover, expressed concerns with the advice of the City Solicitor regarding the snow removal appeal process and his previous opinion regarding an alley abatement.

LaChelle Paul, 501 Silverside Drive, Dover, wanted to know what areas the 500 citations were given. She stated that she was out helping to remove snow and elderly people in their neighborhoods. Ms. Paul noted that she had watched code enforcement ride by multiple times. She asked how they were giving the citations out when the roads were not cleared. Some roads were not addressed at all and there were cars out on the street and there was ice. The city has resources, but they are not going through the outsourcing like they should. She pointed out that they talk about outsourcing and picking bigger companies when they can go through smaller companies and give them smaller territories to cover so they can get it done for less money. Ms. Paul suggested that if they went through and lowered their bond rating, they could get small local businesses involved, but they made it impossible for those businesses to be able to assist in those situations. She stated that they talked about the safety of a sidewalk, but the city could not clear the roads that go up to those sidewalks. She further stated that the city could not state that it was not appealable but listed it because it had to be there.

Charles Cunningham, 116 East Sheldrake Circle, Dover, stated that he had tried to appeal when he received a letter, he went to City Hall after looking up the ordinance online and looking at the range for the fines. He was trying to figure out why he got fined the maximum. Mr. Cunningham spoke with Mr. Kopp and was told that it was a result of the ordinance change. He went online to

Paj 67

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 10

view the ordinance, and it had not been updated. He noted that it would be helpful to update the ordinances.

Responding to Dr. Jackson-Short, Mr. Rocha clarified that according to the ordinance online, it stated that any person, corporation, company, or entity found guilty of a violation of this article shall pay a fine of no less than $25, nor more than $100.

Ms. Arielle Rivera, Assistant City Clerk, stated that once council passes an ordinance, it is adopted. However, the online code system groups them together and processes them at one time once they have so many. She noted that it does take a while for the website to be updated, however, they are adopted whenever council passes them.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp stated that the citations were throughout the city. He did not have the information with him, but he could have it plotted on a map. The city is split into four different sections. The Code Enforcement staff are all assigned to their areas, and they have all received cases in their areas. He emphasized that no specific neighborhood was targeted, it was throughout the city, and that data could be shown on a map.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp stated that it would take a few days to provide the data. He would get with GIS and give him the data and plot it on the map. Mr. Kopp could provide the data in a week and provide it for their next meeting.

Dr. Sudler asked if he could provide the number of complaints that were submitted and the areas that received citations. He stated that they needed clarity in the ordinance, their responsibility, the constituent’s responsibility, and moving towards being more user-friendly as municipalities for their constituents. He believed that they need to waive fines for now and moving forward they could work on getting it right since it snows maybe one to three times a year.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp recommended putting the current date of January 28, 2025, to make sure everyone was covered and then he could instruct staff not to issue any mail the following day.

Dr. Sudler moved to waive the fines associated with snow removal for the month of January that were issued. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha.

Mr. Neil stated that the deadline should be January 28, 2025.

Dr. Sudler moved to waive the fines associated with snow removal from January 6, 2025, through January 28, 2025, that were issued. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha.

Dr. Pillsbury expressed concerns with waving everyone’s fines. She believed that people who made the effort to clear it and the snow blew onto their sidewalks, that was a legitimate excuse to get it waived, but people who made no effort to clear their sidewalks should still be fined.

Responding to Mr. Kopp, Mayor Christiansen asked that if he could provide them with a numeric or type of color coding as to where the complaints came in from. He believed that it would help

Paj 68

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 11

council and constituents to understand that no particular area was being singled out and how the citations came about.

Mr. Anderson stated that he would be in favor of the particular motion. He does share some agreement with Dr. Pillsbury that someone who has not done anything would be dereliction. He noted that the reason he supported the motion was that some time ago they had an issue of the non- appealable when it came up before the Construction and Property Maintenance Code Board of Appeals and the board stated that they did not handle the grass issues because it was not under the title that deals with what they consider. At that time, they pointed out that there was a problem with the letter because it stated that a person could appeal, and they had asked that the letter be revised. He felt that there should be two separate letters, one for the appeals board that tells the person the process and the other for the ones that are appealed in-house to the city manager’s office.

Since there are hundreds of citations and ongoing server issues and software, he did not want to push all those back onto the city manager to sort through which ones were legitimate and which ones were not. Mr. Anderson stated that for the sake of expediency, they should treat all of them equally, even though they are not all equal. The people in the Code Enforcement have spent several hours going out responding to constituent complaints and trying to keep people safe and hated that he felt like he was throwing away all of that work regardless. The problem needed to be fixed and there was no way to sort it out efficiently. He believed that the only way to deal with it was to have a clean slate and take the path forward to make adjustments that need to be made to the snow ordinance.

Dr. Sudler moved to waive the fines associated with snow removal that were issued from January 6, 2025, through January 28, 2025. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried with Dr. Pillsbury voting no.

Mr. Lewis moved to include the presented draft ordinance Section 98-12, snow and ice removal from sidewalks in the public right away be put on the next Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Rivera read the second proposed ordinance which proposed changes to Appendix F by stating that Section 98-12, snow and ice removal from sidewalks in the public right of way, (b) would be a warning and a posting for $0, and (c) violations and penalties would be a $100 per violation.

Ms. Bennett stated that one of the ordinances amended the code and the second ordinance would amend the fee schedule.

Mr. Lewis moved to include both proposed ordinances and an appeals process be put on the next Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.

Paj 69

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 12

Discussion – Constituent Concerns Surrounding East Loockerman Street (Councilman Boggerty) Mayor Christiansen briefed the committee on the constituent concerns surrounding East Loockerman Street.

Mr. Anderson moved to instruct staff to begin process of evaluating the proposed road closure with the required agencies and departments, seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously carried.

Mr. Boggerty moved for adjournment of the Safety, Advisory, and Transportation meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:36 p.m.

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C – Downtown Redevelopment (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner reviewed the background and analysis regarding Proposed Ordinance #2025-01.

Staff recommended forwarding Proposed Ordinance #2025-01.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.

Proposed Ordinance #2025-03 – Amending Chapter 1 – General Provisions, Section 1-18 – City of Dover Service Mark (Councilman Lewis and Dr. Sudler) Mr. Lewis reviewed the background and analysis regarding Proposed Ordinance #2025-03.

Staff recommended forwarding Proposed Ordinance #2025-03 to council.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend accepting the committee recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Andria L. Bennett, City Clerk, clarified that they would have to apply through an application to use the service mark. She explained that during their conversations the application would go to Ms. Kay Sass and appeals would be provided to the City Clerk’s Office to be placed on an agenda for council review.

Mr. Anderson expressed concerns with section one in the ordinance. He explained that it should exempt events that are sponsored or co-sponsored by the city explicitly, that way if the city was

Paj 70

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 13

investing money into an event, they should get credit for it and be able to use the seal and see it. Therefore, he proposed an amendment to line sixteen starting after Dover, to add unless the city is a sponsor or co-sponsor of the event.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Lewis believed that it would not apply because they would still be able to affix the seal, since they were sponsoring that event.

Mr. Anderson explained that they could run into timeframes where they have put community enhancement funds into, and the organization may have offered to place the city as a sponsor. If there is no meeting between the disbursement of funds and the event, then they would not be able to use the seal. He explained that in order to avoid any confusion in the future he would like to see it explicitly include the amendment. Staff and people in the future may not understand the assumed intent.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Lewis stated that he had no objection to that and that it was not the intent of the ordinance. The intent was to protect the seal from individuals who would use the city seal at their discretion.

Mr. Anderson moved to amend line 16 after Dover to say unless the city is the sponsor or co- sponsor of the event of the proposed ordinance. Mr. Hare and Mr. Neil accepted the amendment.

Mayor Christiansen expressed appreciation for the efforts of Mr. Lewis and Dr. Sudler. He believed that the seal needed to be protected. The City of Dover’s Mayor and Council have sponsored and contributed to numerous events that they have sanctioned such as Dover Days, The Caribbean Festival, and The Latino Festival. He believed that it was important that when they make a substantial contribution to these organizations and to other things that they participate in the City Seal should be authorized to show that the city supports these efforts to make their community a better place to live, work, and play. Mayor Christiansen urged members of council to accept the friendly amendment but to proceed forward with the protection of the City Seal and the uses thereof.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Garfinkel stated that he was looking at line 12 in the proposed ordinance, which no person shall intentionally or negligently use the Registered Service Mark.

Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Bennett stated that after discussions of what Mr. Lewis and Dr. Sudler were looking to do, Mr. Rodriguez and the paralegal put the language together. After hearing what their intent was, that was the language that Mr. Rodriguez and the paralegal drafted.

Ms. Bennett explained that she could get clarification before it comes to council for the first reading with the amendments and can talk with Mr. Rodriguez about the language and Mr. Garfinkel concerns to ask what the reason or rational was with using the language as presented.

Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Lewis stated that the appeal process would start with Ms. Sass as the coordinator and then the appeal would be brought before council.

Paj 71

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 14

Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Bennett stated that the appeals process is outlined on the application. The initial application would go to Ms. Sass and the appeal would come to the City Clerk’s Office because they serve at the pleasure of council.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend accepting the committee recommendation to forward Proposed Ordinance #2025-03 to council as amended. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.

Fiscal Year 2026 Tax Evaluation and Fiscal Year 2027 Reevaluation Thereafter (Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director) Ms. Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director, reviewed the Fiscal Year 2026 Tax Evaluation and Fiscal Year 2027 Reevaluation Thereafter.

Staff recommended using the City’s 2020 re-assessment values for the 2025 tax bills and changing the ordinance to adopt Kent County’s tax values starting with Fiscal Year 2027, thereafter in Fiscal Year 2029 they would be assessed every five years.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Haines stated that Kent County released the information late Friday afternoon, on January 24, 2025, without an MOU and a $60 fee.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend approving staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Shevock, Ms. Haines stated that to her understanding during a tax revaluation, the city’s preference is to remain revenue neutral.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Haines stated that she has been serving as the Interim Customer Service Director for a year now. Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Haines clarified that they would get the evaluation from Kent County and require an adjustment to the tax rates for them to make it revenue-neutral in 2027.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Haines stated that they paid $60 for the information from Kent County. She noted that she would need to get back to them for those numbers but said that they did save a lot of money by paying the $60 rather than going through an independent assessment.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend approving staff recommendation, seconded by Dr. Sudler and carried unanimously.

Permission to Proceed with Implementation of Kronos Payroll Processing Program (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer) Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the background and analysis to the Implementation of the Kronos Payroll Processing Program.

Staff recommended granting permission to proceed with obtaining quotes for the transition to the Kronos Payroll Processing Program.

Paj 72

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 15

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney stated that she would defer to council to decide if an RFP is required and if they would approve her moving forward with modifying the current contract.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney asked if they could modify the staff’s recommendation to proceed with a quote she received. If they agree to that, she would be happy to forward a copy of the quote to all council members.

Dr. Sudler noted his concern that there was only one (1) quote that they received. He was not sure if they could use one (1) quote and be in violation.

Mr. Boggerty stated that he was familiar with Kronos and that it was a great product. He wanted to make sure that there were no legal obligations for them to have an RFP put out and have conversations like this to avoid preselection.

Mr. Anderson stated that by declaring an emergency they could skip the RFP selection process.

Ms. Duca stated that getting three quotes would be in alignment with the purchasing policy because Ms. Marney was proposing additional services above $57,000. She explained that an emergency can be declared to maintain a continuity of service which provides the city manager the ability to act in those regards.

Mayor Christiansen stated by the power vested to him by the charter, he declared an emergency.

Mr. Hare moved to amend the motion to recommend granting permission to proceed, due to emergency with quotes received for the transition to the Kronos Payroll Processing Program.

Mr. Hare moved to recommended accepting the staff recommendation as amended to proceed, due to an emergency, with the quote received for the transition to the Kronos Payroll Processing Program. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and carried unanimously.

Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:10 p.m.

Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:11 p.m.

David L. Anderson
Council President

Paj 73

Item #5.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JANUARY 28, 2025 PAGE 16

Attachments
Attachment #1 – Snow Removal Practices Memorandum
Attachment #2 – Road Check 2025 Presentation
Attachment #3 – Proposed Snow Ordinance
Attachment #4 – Proposed Snow Ordinance Appendix F

Paj 74

ATTACHMENT #1

Council Committee of the Whole Meeting of 01/28/2025 Item #5.

City of Dover
City Manager’s Office
PO Box 475
Dover DE 19903-0475
Phone: (302) 736-7005
E-Mail: sduca@dover.de.us

MEMORANDUM

To: Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee

CC: Dave S. Hugg, III, City Manager

From: Sharon J. Duca, P.E., ICMA-CM, Assistant City Manager
Mark Nowak, GISP, Public Works Director
Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer

Date: January 28, 2025

Subject: Snow Removal Practices and Constituent Concerns

Attachments: Road Check 2025 Presentation
Draft Section 98-5, Section 98-12 and Appendix F

On January 5-7, 2025, the City of Dover experienced a snowstorm resulting in approximately six-inches (6”) of snow. Following this event, at the January 13, 2025 City Council meeting, the agenda was modified to include a report on the snow removal efforts (see attached presentation). Standard operational procedures were followed for both City snow removal and code enforcement efforts. Based upon concerns received from City Council and constituents, the following alternatives assessment is provided for discussion.

CITY SNOW REMOVAL PRACTICES

The City’s snow removal team currently consists of staff from the Department of Public Works (DPW), the Department of Water & Wastewater, the Parks & Recreation Department and the Central Services Department. While response will vary from storm to storm, the primary mission is to keep emergency and critical routes open during the storm. This involves pre-treating emergency routes with brine, pre-treating critical routes with salt, treating emergency and critical routes with salt if required and plowing. Once this part of the operation is complete, all other roads will be plowed if the snowfall exceeds four-inches (4”). Once roads are plowed and sidewalks are cleared, staff will return to their Departmental Assignments. For the DPW, this means Sanitation Division staff will return to trash collection and Streets and Stormwater Division staff will continue removing snow that was piled in cul-de-sacs and the like during plowing operations. For reference purposes, for the recent storm, trash collection resumed on January 8, 2025 and snow removal operations are still occurring today. (Please refer to the attached presentation for additional details regarding response efforts, what worked for us and what worked against us.) Complaints received regarding this snowstorm included concern over the icy conditions, particularly on residential roads, and requests were made for additional treatment options. As a result, three (3) scenarios were

Paj 75

Item #5.
Snow Removal Practices and Constituent Concerns
January 28, 2025

reviewed by staff including (1) Pretreatment: applying brine to all 133.5 miles of roadway, (2) Pretreatment: applying salt to all 133.5 miles of roadway, and (3) Post-treatment: applying sand at intersections. A summary of these scenarios on a per storm basis, including pros and cons, is provided below. Please note that all costs are estimates. Capital expenses would be up front costs only.

  • •Total Cost represents Year 1 investment plus operational expenses for one (1) storm.

Paj 76

Item #5.
Snow Removal Practices and Constituent Concerns
January 28, 2025

CategoryCurrent PracticeScenario 1Scenario 2Scenario 3
Staffing ExpensesNot includedNot includedNot includedNot included
FuelNot includedNot includedNot includedNot included
Contract Assistance$24,400$24,400$24,400$24,400
Brine400 gal / $8006,200 gal / $12,400400 gal / $800400 gal / $800
Salt70 tons / $5,70070 tons / $5,700315 tons / $25,70070 tons / $5,700
SandNot utilizedNot utilizedNot utilized2,000 tons / $45,000
Sand DisposalNot utilizedNot utilizedNot utilized1,000 tons / $73,000
Operational Cost$30,900$42,500$50,900$148,900
Existing EquipmentNot includedNot includedNot includedNot included
New Brine SystemNot required$100,000Not requiredNot required
New Brine TruckNot required3 / $549,000Not requiredNot required
New Salt/Sand BarnNot requiredNot required$200,000$400,000
New Spreader Truck Not requiredNot required4 / $768,0004 / $768,000
New Sander RackNot requiredNot required$50,000$50,000
New Sweeper TruckNot requiredNot requiredNot required$300,000
Capital Cost$0$649,000$1,018,000$1,518,000
Total Cost*$30,900$691,500$1,068,900$1,666,900
Pros1.Allroads1. Reduced potential 1. Reduced potential 1.Improved
addressed within 24of road icing.of road icing.traction.
hours of storm end.
Cons1. Residential roads1. More staff must1. More staff must1. More staff must
are typically notbe activated forbe activated forstay activated for
completely clear toresponse prior toresponse prior toresponseafter
pavement which canstart of storm.start of storm.plowingwhich
resultinicy2. Additional brine2. Additional saltcould effect trash
conditions.will decrease lifewill decrease lifecollection restart and
expectancy of roadsexpectancy of roadssnow pile removal.
of which the City isof which the City is2. To comply with
notadequatelynotadequatelyNPDES permit, sand
investing.investing.must be swept and
3. Will not address 3. Will not address disposed of.
issues in areas ofissues in areas of3. Will not address
parked cars.parked cars.issues in areas of
parked cars.
CODE ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS
The City’s Code Enforcement team, within the Department of Planning & Inspections, currently works to ensure
compliance with the City of Dover Code of Ordinances. In terms of snow Section 98-5 of the Code currently
requires sidewalks to be cleared within twelve (12) hours of daylight after it has ceased snowing.
Noncompliance currently results in a $100.00 fine.
In accordance with the Code, staff will go out into neighborhoods within their respective zones, following twelve

Paj 77

Item #5. Snow Removal Practices and Constituent Concerns January 28, 2025 (12) hours of daylight after the snow has ceased. Sidewalk inspections are performed and pictures are taken. Cases are entered in the system and notices / citations are sent out via certified. This past storm resulted in 556 citations sent at a cost of over $5,000. Various complaints were received as a result of these citations. In turn, the provided draft ordinance of Section 98-5 and Section 98-12 are proposed. A summary of the existing and proposed ordinances, including pros and cons, are provided below.

Category Current Section 98-5 Proposed Section 98-5 / 98-12 Removal Timeframe Within twelve (12) hours of After twenty-four (24) hours have daylight after it has ceased passed since it has ceased snowing. snowing. Notification Method Certified Mail Posting Notification Timeframe 3-5 days At time of inspection. Fine $100 No fine with posting. Pros 1. Ability to perform vehicle 1. Minimize the misinterpretation inspections. of the removal timeframe with providing for twenty-four (24) hours. Cons 1. Level of compliance determines 1. Concern for staff safety in how long it takes to complete posting notices when snow and ice inspections. Whole City was not are present. complete after three (3) days. 2. The additional step of posting will likely reduce the number of inspections performed over a similar period.

It should be noted that numerous residents and businesses were noncompliant with the current code requirements. In order to address, public outreach will be critical moving forward. Options include mailers being provided within the utility bills twice a year for grass and snow requirements. Also, before each storm, sending out notifications on social media, the City’s website and within the City’s newsletter.

Paj 78

ATTACHMENT #2

Council Committee of the Whole Meeting of 01/28/2025 Item #5.

ROAD CHECK

2025
Thursday January 9,
2025

Paj 79

Item #5.

MAYFAIR

Paj 80

Item #5.

MAYFAIR

Paj 81

Item #5.

ELM TERRACE

Paj 82

Item #5.

ELM TERRACE

Paj 83

Item #5.

ORCHARD AVE AND LOTUS

Paj 84

Item #5.

ORCHARD AVE AND LOTUS

Paj 85

Item #5.

MORIARITY STREET

Paj 86

Item #5.

MORIARITY STREET

Paj 87

Item #5.

WHY DO WE DO, WHAT WE DO?  Responsible to clear a total of 133.5 miles of roadway. Of those, 21.2 miles (15.9%) are critical and 8.6 miles (6.4%) are emergency routes.  Plowing of those critical and emergency routes must be done at the onset of the storm and done throughout the storm. This keeps the main arteries open.  Emergency Services (Police, Fire, EMS) help determine the what and why an area is considered critical or emergency.  We typically do not enter residential ares until the snow has stopped falling and we have full control over the emergency and critical areas. (If it is drifting badly, we may not get into the residential areas until the winds subside.) In addition, residential areas are not plowed unless the snow depth exceeds 4”.  We do not salt residential areas. This is a resource issue: staff, money, equipment and materials.  When we have large amounts that pile up, once we can free up dump trucks, we haul the large piles (particularly in cul-de-sacs) to Schutte Park.  Plows are not dropped to pavement level. To avoid damage to vehicles, drivers and infrastructure, plows maintain a height of approximately 3” from the ground when plowing.

Paj 88

WHAT WORKED FOR US? Item #5.

 Contractors

 Light snow – it was not a wet and heavy snow

 Sunshine – some areas get more sun

 All staff had personalized (to the city) snow plow
training.
 All Critical and Emergency Routes were brined /
pretreated.
 Critical/High Priority Routes were treated with salt.

 Emergency Routes were treated with brine.

Paj 89

Item #5.

WHAT WORKED AGAINST US?  Winds (winds on January 9, 2025 were 21 mph)  Starting asphalt temp was 27° at the onset of the storm which caused it to stick and ice faster.  Bitterly cold temps lasted for days.  Drifting  We don’t get large snow accumulations often, so we have resource issues which include staff, money, equipment and materials.  Not moving vehicles off the roadways.  The storm started at night.  Duration – the snow lasted almost 24 hours  We experienced the same thing the State of Delaware and many parts of Maryland reported. WBOC had good coverage of the struggles in DE and MD (aired on 1/9/25).

Paj 90

Item #5.

Special thanks to all who worked
the storm - in every capacity.
It is greatly appreciated!

Paj 91

ATTACHMENT

Item #5.
#3
Council Committee of the Whole Meeting of 01/28/2025

Sec. 98-5. Duty of tenants or owners to maintain sidewalks and landscaped areas within the street right-of-way. (a) It shall be unlawful for the owner or occupant of any premises abutting upon a sidewalk to permit or allow snow or ice to remain thereon for longer than 12 hours of daylight after it has ceased snowing, or to permit debris or other materials to accumulate at any time so that pedestrians may conveniently and safely pass. (b) It is the responsibility of the owner or occupant of any premises abutting upon a sidewalk to keep the landscaped area between the sidewalk and the curbline, or where no sidewalk exists between the property line and curbline or paved street, maintained in accordance with the standards set forth in chapter 114, article II, pertaining to weeds. (c) It shall be unlawful to sweep, blow, or otherwise discharge grass clippings into any street, sidewalk, storm drain, or water course more than incidental amounts of grass. (d) Violations; penalties. Any person(s) violating any provision of this section shall be fined as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. (Code 1968, § 28-25; Code 1981, § 19-5; Ord. of 8-10-1987, § 1; Ord. of 2-23-1998; Ord. No. 2014-19, 9-8-2014)

Sec. 98-12. Snow and ice removal from sidewalks in the public right of way. (a) It shall be unlawful for the owner or occupant of any premises to permit or allow sidewalk(s) abutting the property to accumulate snow or ice when 24 hours have passed since it has ceased snowing. The sidewalks must remain clear after the 24-hour period of the ceasing of snow. (b) Warning; posting. Any property found to have snow or ice remaining on sidewalk(s) abutting property after 24 hours have passed since the cease of snow will receive an initial notice of violation via posting of notice by the code official. This notice provides 24 hours to remove all snow and ice from the sidewalk. (c) Violations; penalties. Any property who fails to keep the sidewalk(s) free from snow and ice after 24 hours of the posting of the initial notice of violation will be subject to penalties as provided in Appendix F- Fees and Fines.

Secs. 98-12 13—98-40. Reserved.

Created: 2024-10-17 07:52:06 [EST]
(Supp. No. 41, Update 1)

Paj 92

ATTACHMENT #4

Item #5.
Council Committee of the Whole Meeting of 01/28/2025

Chapter 98. Streets, Sidewalks and Other Public Places Chapter 98. Streets, Sidewalks and Other Public Places Fees and Fines Article I. In General Sec. 98-5. Duty of tenants or owners to maintain sidewalks and $100.00 per violation landscaped areas within the street right-of-way Sec. 98-11. Placement of wireless communications facilities within rights-of-way (c) Use of Rights-of-Way Permit (1) Permit Fee $25.00 for ROW Permit (2) Annual Fee for Rights-of-way Use No charge for WCF placement on existing City owned wireless support structure in City ROW

$220.00 for
Placement of new
wireless support
structure/pole in City
ROW

$220.00 for WCF placement on a third party/non-City wireless support structure/pole in City ROW Sec. 98-12 Snow and ice removal from sidewalks in the public right of way. (b) Warning; Posting $0.00 (c) Violations; penalties $100.00 per violation Article VI. Excavations Sec. 98-253. Bond Maximum of $5,000.00 per opening Article VII. Parades Sec. 98-303. Fee at the time of filing the application for a parade $10.00. This fee may permit be waived, in whole

Created: 2024-10-17 07:52:16 [EST]
(Supp. No. 41, Update 1)

Paj 93

Item #5.

or in part, by the
chief of police.

(Ord. No. 2020-13, 11-9-2020; Ord. No. 2024-19, 6-24-2024)

Created: 2024-10-17 07:52:16 [EST]
(Supp. No. 41, Update 1)

Paj 94

Item #14.

COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND

Paj 95

Item #14.

CITY COUNCIL COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND

JULY 1, 2024 - JUNE 30, 2025

100-10-12-99-000-53037
Current Balance- $ 10,743.07

BUDGETED COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT FUND - $2,500 FOR EACH COUNCIL MEMBER PER DISTRICT AND $5,000 FOR THE AT-LARGE COUNCIL MEMBER. THE PURPOSE OF THE FUND IS TO ALLOW MEMBERS TO CONTRIBUTE FUNDS TO A SMALL PROJECT $ 25,000.00 AMOUNT OR COMMUNITY NEEDS IN EACH DISTRICT.

FINAL BUDGET $ 25,000.00 TOTAL

DATE COUNCIL SPONSOR VENDOR DESCRIPTION INVOICE # TOTAL CHARGES YEAR TO DATE BALANCE

Councilman Sudler authorized the designation of $1,500 of his Email from Roy Sudler dated 07/01/2024

A 2nd Chance A Haven for Abused and Batteredcommunity enhancement funds to Ms. Faye White at A 2ndand an invoice dated 07/02/2024
7/2/2024SudlerChance, for their Annual Veterans Honorary Dinner$1,500.00$1,500.00$23,500.00
Women and Children

Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated $500 of his community enhancement funds to the Women 06/18/24 and Email & Letter from William Women and Children Transformation Ministry and Children Transformation Ministry International, Inc. for Snorton, Jr. received 06/16/2024 7/8/2024 Anderson $500.00 $2,000.00 $23,000.00 International, Inc. their Boys to Men Development Program for Gas cards.

Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated $500 of his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic 06/25/24 and email from Anthony (Tony) 7/8/2024 Anderson Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Velazquez dated 06/25/24 $500.00 $2,500.00 $22,500.00 Dover Festival. Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $200.00 of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 07/08/2024 7/8/2024 Arndt United Way her community enhancement funds to United Way for their and email from Kenyatta Livingston dated $200.00 $2,700.00 $22,300.00 "Book Bash." 07/07/2024 Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $300 of his Email from Gerald Rocha dated 7/8/2024 Rocha United Way community enhancement funds to United Way for their "Book 07/07/2024 and email from Kenyatta $300.00 $3,000.00 $22,000.00 Bash." Livingston dated 07/07/2024 Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $300 of his Email from Bill Hare dated 07/08/2024 7/8/2024 Hare Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Dover Police and an email from Sgt. Jennifer Lynch $300.00 $3,300.00 $21,700.00 Department for their Summer Event. dated 07/08/2024 Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $350 of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 07/08/2024 7/8/2024 Arndt Dover Police Department her community enhancement funds to the Dover Police and an email from Sgt. Jennifer Lynch $350.00 $3,650.00 $21,350.00 Department for their Summer Event. dated 07/08/2024 Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $100 of his Email from Fred Neil dated 07/08/2024 7/8/2024 Neil Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Dover Police and an email from Sgt. Jennifer Lynch $100.00 $3,750.00 $21,250.00 Department for their Summer Event. dated 07/08/2024 Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated 7/9/2024 Anderson United Way $250 of his community enhancement funds to United Way for 07/09/2024 and email from Kenyatta $250.00 $4,000.00 $21,000.00 their "Book Bash." Livingston dated 07/07/2024

Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $500 of his Email from Gerald Rocha dated 07/09/24 community enhancement funds to the Hispanic Organization and email from Anthony (Tony) Velazquez 7/9/2024 Rocha Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) of Latin Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Dover Festival. dated 06/25/24 $500.00 $4,500.00 $20,500.00

Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 7/11/24 her community enhancement funds to the Caribbean Culture and email from Eveann Jerry dated 7/11/2024 Pillsbury Caribbean Culture Awareness Inc. $250.00 $4,750.00 $20,250.00 Awareness Inc. for their Delaware Caribbean Carnival. 7/11/24

Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200 of his Email from Gerald Rocha dated 7/17/2024 Rocha Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Dover Police 07/17/2024 and an email from Sgt. $200.00 $4,950.00 $20,050.00 Department for their Summer Event. Jennifer Lynch dated 07/08/2024 Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $300 of his Email from Brian Lewis dated 07/19/2024 A 2nd Chance A Haven for Abused and Battered community enhancement funds to Ms. Faye White at A 2nd and an invoice dated 07/02/2024 7/19/2024 Lewis $300.00 $5,250.00 $19,750.00 Women and Children Chance, for their Annual Veterans Honorary Dinner.

Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $250 of his Email from Fred Neil dated 7/23/24 and 7/23/2024 Neil Persimmon Park Place community enhancement funds to Persimmon Park Place for email from Karen, Park Manager dated $250.00 $5,500.00 $19,500.00 the Backpack Giveaway. 7/23/24 Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 7/23/24 and 7/23/2024 Arndt Persimmon Park Place her community enhancement funds to Persimmon Park Place email from Karen, Park Manager dated $250.00 $5,750.00 $19,250.00 for the Backpack Giveaway. 7/23/24 Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $300 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated his community enhancement funds to the Hispanic 07/25/24 and email from Anthony (Tony) 7/25/2024 Boggerty Hispanic Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) Organization of Latin Americans (HOLA) for their Baila Con Velazquez dated 06/25/24 $300.00 $6,050.00 $18,950.00 Dover Festival. Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $200 of his Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated A 2nd Chance A Haven for Abused and Battered community enhancement funds to Ms. Faye White at A 2nd 07/25/2024 and an invoice dated 7/25/2024 Rocha Chance, for their Annual Veterans Honorary Dinner. 07/01/2024 $200.00 $6,250.00 $18,750.00 Women and Children

Paj 96

Item #14.

Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $200 of his Email from Brian Lewis dated 08/20/2024 8/21/2024 Lewis Children's Beach House community enhancement funds to the Children's Beach house and email from Armina Domingue dated $200.00 $6,450.00 $18,550.00 for their Back to School Drive. 08/20/2024 Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $300 of his Email from Gerald Rocha, Sr. dated 8/23/2024 Rocha I Am My Sisters Keeper (MSK) community enhancement funds to I Am My Sister's Keeper 08/22/2024 and an email from Marcille $300.00 $6,750.00 $18,250.00 (MSK-Dover) "Dee" Sewell dated 08/22/2024 Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $500 of his Email from Brian Lewis dated 08/07/24 8/27/2024 Lewis Tracy Palmer Ministries community enhancement funds to the Tracy Palmer and a letter from the Tracy Palmer $500.00 $7,250.00 $17,750.00 Ministries. Ministries dated 07/22/24 Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $500 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated 9/3/2024 Boggerty I Am My Sisters Keeper (MSK) his community enhancement funds to I Am My Sister's Keeper 09/03/2024 and an email from Marcille $500.00 $7,750.00 $17,250.00 (MSK-Dover). "Dee" Sewell dated 08/22/2024 Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $500 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated his community enhancement funds to the Women and 09/09/24 and Email & Letter from William Women and Children Transformation Ministry Children Transformation Ministry International, Inc. for their Snorton, Jr. recived 09/09/2024 9/9/2024 Boggerty $500.00 $8,250.00 $16,750.00 International, Inc. Boys to Men and their Girls Breaking Barriers program.

Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated $300 of his community enhancement funds to Concerned 09/10/2024 and email from Elizabeth 9/10/2024 Anderson Concerned Citizens of the Community Citizens of the Community for porta potties for their First 1NA Daniels dated 09/09/2024 $300.00 $8,550.00 $16,450.00 Inaugural day and Summer Music Festival.

Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $150 of hisEmail from Fred Neil dated 09/11/2024
community enhancement funds to Concerned Citizens of theand email from Elizabeth Daniels dated
9/10/2024NeilConcerned Citizens of the CommunityCommunity for porta potties for their First 1NA Inaugural day09/09/2024$150.00$8,700.00$16,300.00
and Summer Music Festival.
Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $500 of hisEmail from Brian Lewis dated 09/16/24
community enhancement funds to the People's Communityand a letter from the Frances Perry,
9/16/2024LewisPeople's Community CenterCenter for their Janie's Hands Veterans Transitional HousingDirector dated 09/11/24$500.00$9,200.00$15,800.00
Program Inc.
Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 9/16/24
her community enhancement funds to the Delmar Community and email from Mildred Polk, President
9/16/2024PillsburyDelmar Community Service FederationService Federation for their First Health Fair.dated 9/3/24$250.00$9,450.00$15,550.00

Councilwoman Pillsbury authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Julia Pillsbury dated 9/17/2024 Pillsbury Dover Police Department her community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue 09/17/2024 and email from M/Cpl. Lee $250.00 $9,700.00 $15,300.00 Weekend Killen dated 09/17/2024. Councilwoman Arndt authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Tricia Arndt dated 09/17/2024 9/17/2024 Arndt Dover Police Department her community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue and email from M/Cpl. Lee Killen dated $250.00 $9,950.00 $15,050.00 Weekend. 09/17/2024. Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $250 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated 9/17/2024 Boggerty Dover Police Department his community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue 09/17/2024 and email from M/Cpl. Lee $250.00 $10,200.00 $14,800.00 Weekend. Killen dated 09/17/2024. Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $300 of his Email from Bill Hare dated 09/17/2024 9/17/2024 Hare Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue and email from M/Cpl. Lee Killen dated $300.00 $10,500.00 $14,500.00 Weekend. 09/17/2024. Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $250 of his Email from Fred Neil dated 09/17/2024 9/17/2024 Neil Dover Police Department community enhancement funds to the Faith and Blue and email from M/Cpl. Lee Killen dated $250.00 $10,750.00 $14,250.00 Weekend. 09/17/2024. Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $500 of his Email from Gerald Rocha dated 09/24/24 Women and Children Transformation Ministry community enhancement funds to the Women and Children and Email & Letter from William Snorton, 9/24/2024 Rocha Transformation Ministry International, Inc. for their Boys to Men Jr. received 09/16/2024 $500.00 $11,250.00 $13,750.00 International, Inc. and their Girls Breaking Barriers program. Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson to the City $52.31 of his community enhancement funds to the Dover Clerk's Office dated 09/30/2024 and an 9/30/2024 Anderson Independent Newsmedia, Inc. Post for the Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing advertisement invoice dated 09/30/2024 $52.31 $11,302.31 $13,697.69 for the Innovative Readiness Training Program Public Notice that ran on 09/29/2024. Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $52.31 of his Email from Bill Hare to the City Clerk's community enhancement funds to the Dover Post for the Office dated 09/30/2024 and an invoice 10/31/2024 Hare Independent Newsmedia, Inc. Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing advertisement for the dated 10/31/2024 $52.31 $11,354.62 $13,645.38 Innovative Readiness Training Program Public Notice that ran on 10/06/2024. Councilman Neil authorized the designation of $52.31 of his Email from Fred Neil to the City Clerk's community enhancement funds to the Dover Post for the Office dated 10/01/2024 and an invoice 10/31/2024 Neil Independent Newsmedia, Inc. Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing advertisement for the dated 10/31/2024 $52.31 $11,406.93 $13,593.07 Innovative Readiness Training Program Public Notice that ran on 10/13/2024. Councilman Rocha authorized the designation of $52.31 of his Email from Gerald Rocha to the community enhancement funds to the Dover Post for the 10/08/2024 and an invoice dated 10/31/2024 Rocha Independent Newsmedia, Inc. Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing advertisement for the 10/31/2024 $52.31 $11,459.24 $13,540.76 Innovative Readiness Training Program Public Notice that ran on 10/20/2024. Councilman Lewis authorized the designation of $500 of his Email from Brain lewis dated 11/19/2024 community enhancement funds to The Shepherd Place, Inc. and an letter from Tasha Schott Executive 11/19/2024 Lewis The Shepherd Place, Inc. Director dated 11/19/2024 $500.00 $11,959.24 $13,040.76

Paj 97

Item #14.

Councilman Hare authorized the designation of $500 of his Email from Bill Hare dated 11/19/2024 community enhancement funds to The Shepherd Place, Inc. and an letter from Tasha Scott Executive 11/19/2024 Hare The Shepherd Place, Inc. Director dated 11/19/2024 $500.00 $12,459.24 $12,540.76

Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated $400 of his community enhancement funds to Concerned 11/19/2024 and an letter from Tasha Scott 11/19/2024 Anderson Concerned Citizens of the Community Citizens of the Community Executive Director dated 11/19/2024 $400.00 $12,859.24 $12,140.76

Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $500 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated his community enhancement funds to The Shepherd Place, 11/22/2024 and an letter from Tasha Scott 11/22/2024 Boggerty The Shepherd Place, Inc. Inc. Executive Director dated 11/19/2024 $500.00 $13,359.24 $11,640.76

Council President Anderson authorized the designation of Email from David Anderson dated $497.69 of his community enhancement funds to the Inner 12/062024 and an email from Ruben 11/19/2024 Anderson Inner City Cultural League City Cultural League for their Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Saslters, CEO dated 12/05/2024 $497.69 $13,856.93 $11,143.07 Program for 2025. Councilman Boggerty authorized the designation of $400 of Email from Andre Boggerty dated his community enhancement funds to The People's 12/16/2024 and an email from Dr. Hodge 12/16/2024 Boggerty The People's Community Center Community Center for their Veterans Resources Center. Director and Frances Perry dated $400.00 $14,256.93 $10,743.07 12/16/2024

TOTALS $14,256.93 $10,743.07

Budgeted
District Council Sponsor YTD Expenditures Balance
Amount

$5,000.00 At-Large Boggerty $2,450.00 $2,550.00

$2,500.00 1st District Pillsbury $750.00 $1,750.00

$2,500.00 1st District Rocha $2,052.31 $447.69

$2,500.00 2nd District Hare $1,152.31 $1,347.69

$2,500.00 2nd District Lewis $2,000.00 $500.00

$2,500.00 3rd District Arndt $1,050.00 $1,450.00

$2,500.00 3rd District Neil $802.31 $1,697.69

$2,500.004th DistrictAnderson$2,500.00$0.00
$2,500.004th DistrictSudler$1,500.00$1,000.00

TOTAL $14,256.93 $10,743.07

Paj 98

Item #15.

CITY MANAGER’S MONTHLY REPORT

December 2024

1

Paj 99

Item #15.

Blank
Page

2

Paj 100

Item #15.

3

Paj 101

Item #15.

CENTRAL SERVICES MONTHLY REPORT

December 2024

PROCUREMENT & INVENTORY DIVISION

Purchase Orders for Stock by Fund

FY 2025 to DateDifference from FY 2024
Electric$2,064,285.89-0.5%
Water$51,744.80-158.7%
Wastewater$2,397.0067.9%
General$45,626.95-88.8%
Total$2,164,054.64-6.1%

Issues from Stock by Fund

FY 2025 to DateDifference from FY 2024
Electric$686,453.92-75.0%
Water$74,657.7345.9%
Wastewater$1,430.54100.0%
General$64,032.05-1.7%
Total$826,574.24-58.1%

Bids/RFPs Solicited

FY 2025 to DateDifference from FY 2024
2420.8%

Money Spent for Postal Services

FY 2025 to DateFY 2024 to Date
$104,974.80$88,334.26

Fuel Usage

TypeFY 2025 to DateFY 2024 to Date
Unleaded74,75074,138
Diesel41,69140,548
Dollars Spent$284,896.84$322,443.21

4

Paj 102

Item #15.

Warehouse Stock Value

FY 2025FY 2024
$5,076,833.00$3,235,681.96

Purchase Orders for Stock are down 6.1% compared to this time last year. Issues from Stock are down 58.1% compared to this time last year. Bids/RFP's are up 20.8% compared to this time last year. Postal Expenses are up 15.9% compared to this time last year. Fuel Costs are down 13.2% compared to this time last year. Overall warehouse value is up 36.3% compared to this time last year.

FLEET DIVISION

PM Work Orders Scheduled:PM Work OrdersTotal Work Orders PM &
12Completed: 32Repair: 109
Total Hours Turned:Excess Hours Turned:Uncaptured Time:
271.5043.8

MEASURE December 2024 December 2023

Completed PM's 32 37

DIFFERENCE -13.51%

There were 12 PM's scheduled for this month. A total of 32 PM's were completed along with 77 repair work orders. There were a total of 109 work orders completed.

5

Paj 103

Item #15.

FACILITIES DIVISION

Routine Work Orders Emergency Work Orders
Completed: 57 Completed: 7

City-owned Facility Work Events & Support Work Orders: 51 Orders: 13

MEASURE December 2024 December 2023

Completed Work Orders 64 52

DIFFERENCE 23.08%

There were 64 routine and emergency Work Orders completed during this month. The work orders consisted of 51 for maintenance and repair of City-owned facilities and 13 related to events and other support work.

Central Services Narrative
Warehousing & Procurement is operating as normal.
Facilities is operating as normal.
Fleet is operating as normal.

6

Paj 104

Item #15.

CENTRAL SERVICES PROJECT UPDATE

December 2024
FY/PROJECT NUMBER DEPARTMENT STATUS

CENTRAL SERVICES FC2303 COMPLETE CITY HALL WINDOWS

ELECTRIC System is 100% operational,
EA2204
WEYANDT HALL HVAC pending commissioning.

CENTRAL SERVICES FC2402 COMPLETE CITY HALL EXTERIOR PAINT

CENTRAL SERVICES CS2405 COMPLETE WASH BAY ROOF & DOORS

WATER WASTE WATER WD2409 COMPLETE WTP RENOVATIONS

CS2501 WAREHOUSE ROOF COMPLETE

CS2502 FUEL ISLAND UPGRADE RFP posted

7

Paj 105

Item #15.

Recap of monthly activities / notations –

As of December 31, 2024 the City of Dover served 25,117 electric utility customers and 13,253 water utility customers as compared to 2023, which represents 24,897 and 13,129 respectively. These figures were tabulated from the monthy utility bill summary report which tracks billing across all utility bill rate classifications. 2,540 phone calls were answered in the month of December by 5 staff members of customer service. Customer Service has been able to recruit for the Customer Serivce Clerk I and Field Service Rep I position and their start dates are 1/8/2025 and 1/13/2025 respectively. Our temporary help started on 12/16/2024. In December stormwater adjustments were made on the 12,715 accounts that were billed $1,271,160.98. Then the process of refunding the $459,540.72 that was paid by 6,065 constituents will be refunded. I was unable to pull all the information together for the December Major Program Updates and as soon as I have access to the program I will update.

Receivable Comparison FY 2024 to Utility Disconnections for December 2024 FY2025 to date (December 2024) 0 accounts were disconnected for non-payment of service. Compared to the same time last year the City had open receivables of Due to staffing no cuts were processed. $9,430,921.52 vs $10,146,049.32. Ending Utility Receivable Due - $6,921,666.12

Customer Service Department Mission

Continually provide quality public service to our diverse group of customers with professionalism, respect, & integrity. ~ City of Dover Customer Service Department

8

Paj 106

Item #15.

Number of Deeds Stamped for the

Month of Dec. 2023/2024Transfer Tax Dollar Amount for the
Month of Dec. 2023/2024
27$186
3023$200
Thousan
2516$101
20$101
1510 1011$100
101 30 1ds$20$23 $16$0 $1
520232023
0$0
20242024

First Time Buyer for the Dec. 2023/2024 Realty Month of Dec. 2023/2024 Property Sales in Dollars Received Prior to Recording 27 30 23 25 $12 $15 $7 $7

Millions

20Res. Non-First$10
$3 $3 $1$0 $0
151010Time Buyers$52023
10$0
Res. First Time2024
5Buyers
0
20232024

Major Updates

OctoberNovemberDecember
Assessment Change$476,600$0-$422,400

Residential Sales Ratio Report

Sales in StudyTotal AssessedTotal Sale PriceRatioPRD
Value
27$4,902,700$8,200,9400.601.03

9

Paj 107

Item #15.

Ratio – Assessed Value divided by Sale Price. PRD – Mean – A PRD above 1.03 tends to indicate assessment regressivity – high valued properties are under appraised relative to low valued properties. A PRD below .98 tends to indicate assessment progressivity – high valued properties are relatively over appraised.

Tax Office
Wild Meadows / Persimmon Park Place Home Sales for December 2024:

Property Address Assessed Value Sales Price

427 Moore Place $62,400 $135,000

27 Gordon Drive $79,400 $205,000

10

Paj 108

012ÿ456ÿ7578

57ÿ11ÿ1
9 ÿ ÿÿ
 ÿ1ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ
9147
1 2CD E9 1E2   C   119E1ÿ1 1ÿ 91
 !"#! # #$" #) *# &ÿ,*-./0-11ÿ21# ) #''&#!%( 9A 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ#%B& ( 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ(#Bÿ"(
 %%"#& # &'" ( *# ##&ÿ2-3ÿ45116ÿ*# #$ #''&#&)(& @A 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ&!$B( #) 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ$)Bÿ"!
 %%"#% ( &" ( *# $'ÿ0521ÿ51ÿ*# #( &&$&((& @A 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ&))B% &! 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ$&Bÿ"%)
 %%"#% ( $" ( *# $ÿ0521ÿ51ÿ*# #( &&$&(!! @A 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ(#B$  9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ$!Bÿ"%%
 %!"# # &#" #) *# $##ÿ/7258ÿ9-*#  &'&#')# @ 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ&$$B% & 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ$&'Bÿ"!
 %!"#( # (#" ( *# (#ÿ.ÿ2*./:-9;ÿ9/#  #'!)&(&#% 5 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ(B# ## 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ$$!Bÿ"%!
 %!"#$ ( &!" & *# #$ÿ71ÿ<7*,ÿ*# #( #'!%&##'$ 9 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ##!B# & 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ&#Bÿ"%
 %!"# ( &" & *# %!ÿ3ÿ533ÿ54# #$ #'%###& 9 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ#%)B & 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ(Bÿ"%
 %)"#$ # (&" #( *# ($#ÿ<*5*ÿ*#  #'%$&#% 9A 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ#!%B) #% 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ(%Bÿ"$'
 %)"#$ # #" #( *# (#ÿ-.3=7:*ÿ*# #$ #'%###( 9 <* ÿÿÿÿÿ#(B) (# 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ&Bÿ"$
 %)"#! ( %)" ) *# ()ÿ;-3,.ÿ=:6# # #'&)&($&! @ , ÿÿÿÿÿ&!'B! &( 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ()Bÿ"!$
 %)"#) & (" ! *# #%(ÿ>2153ÿ54# #$ #'###(! 9 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ#$)B( $ 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ&Bÿ"'
 %)"#) & !" ! *# '%ÿ3ÿ=51.6ÿ*# #$ #'###$#% 9 , ÿÿÿÿÿ#!B # 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ&&(B$ÿ"!
 %)"#'  %" #$ *# #!ÿ1?-3,/73ÿ21# #( &'&&!) 9A , ÿÿÿÿÿ#'B &( 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ(#(Bÿ"%&
 !%"$ # &(" & *# #%ÿ533ÿ077*ÿ./# #( &&$&#$& 9A 54 ÿÿÿÿÿ#$%B' ( 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ&'B''ÿ"
 !%"% & #" #( * &ÿ@*:63ÿ=511ÿ# & #'!(##%& @ , ÿÿÿÿÿ##B) ( 9 &$ÿÿÿÿÿ#'Bÿ"&

11

Page 108 Item #15.

Paj 109

012ÿ456ÿ7578 57ÿ1 1ÿ1 9 ÿ ÿÿ  ÿ 1ÿ7ÿÿÿÿÿÿ 9147 1  256 79 1 72   5    1197 1ÿ1 1ÿ  9 1   !" #$% $" #"$ % " & '! ( ÿ*+,-.ÿ/,  01!  0$#/2 3 ÿÿÿÿÿÿ1#4( "/"& ÿÿÿÿÿ 4 ÿ%#0

12

Page 109 Item #15.

Paj 110

012ÿ456ÿ7578

57ÿ11ÿ1
9 ÿ ÿÿ
 ÿ1ÿ4ÿÿÿÿÿÿ
9147
1 2?@ A9 1A2   ?   119A1ÿ1 1ÿ 91

 !"#$%""!&$ % - )#)ÿ*/0+1*0ÿ23 '(!(#&% +,5 ÿÿÿÿÿ'#>& #" +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ%> ÿ$'&
 !"$!"&"'($ ( -& &&ÿ2ÿ415-01-2ÿ,5&(%%%#' +,5 ÿÿÿÿÿ!'> %" +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ%!!> ÿ$#
 !"$""'$ # - %%!ÿ*, 6ÿ784ÿ - &%)%%% 7",5 ÿÿÿÿÿ&#> " +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ%#!> ÿ$!
 !"$"#"%!$% % - (ÿ910-1ÿ3- '%&'' +,5 ÿÿÿÿÿ'> #" +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ%!#> ÿ$#)
 !")!$#""#)$  - %ÿ+-:ÿ70 ÿ-!%!%%&% 7,5 ÿÿÿÿÿ%&(>& (" +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ'''> ÿ$!'
 !")!$)"")%$ % - ((ÿ*600;,50ÿ -!(#'%)' 7",5 ÿÿÿÿÿ%%> '" +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ&(> ÿ$!%
 !")!$%"%"%$ % - &!)ÿ:22*-/04ÿ,5 '(## +,5 ÿÿÿÿÿ&>! &" +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ%!!> ÿ$!%
 !")!$%"%")$ % - &%ÿ91+:/047/- ÿ,5!(#(%%% +=,5 ÿÿÿÿÿ)>) &" +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ&!> ÿ$!
 !")!$%"&"&$ % - &'ÿ<123ÿ7*5 '(##)! +,5 ÿÿÿÿÿ!>& " +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ%#> ÿ$#
*+!"!)$"'"($ , - %ÿ41- 10ÿ - (() =,5 ÿÿÿÿÿÿ(>' '" +"%'ÿÿÿÿÿ%!> ÿ$&(

13

Page 110 Item #15.

Paj 111

Item #15. ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT MONTHLY REPORT For the month of December 2024, the Electric Department contributed to the quality of life for all our customers.

The city experienced a system peak of 101.14 megawatts, an increase of 2.7 megawatts from last month and a 1.9 megawatt increase from the same month last year.

There was a total of 7 outages for the month affecting a total of 9029 customers with an average outage time of 79.77 minutes.

Project Updates:

The department continues to work on the new developments and services as well as other assorted other work. We are continuing work on scheduled FY25 capital projects.

Pole testing remained stalled due to new development and capital project work.

Substation construction continues as it can while we wait for the arrival of the switchgear building. Work was started on assembly of the bus work around the site. The demolition of McKee Run is now complete. Final documentation is under review from both Total Wrecking and DNREC.

Van Sant was not called on for the month but remains ready for dispatch.

FY 25 YTD Outages and Response Time: Total – 45 Average Response Time – 30.21 minutes (Goal – Less than 30 minutes)

Statistics: 3-year average: FY Average:

Average Interruption
Duration Index (SAIDI) 188.85 minutes 32.17 minutes
Goal – Not to exceed 100 mins

System Average Interruption
Frequency Index (SAIFI) 2.14 per cust .5 per cust
Goal – Not to exceed 1 per customer

Customer Average Interruption
Duration Index (CAIDI) 88.45 minutes 62.9 minutes

Lost Time Accidents – Workorders Generated –
Current Month – 0 Total FY – 0 Current Month – 97 Total FY – 757

14

Paj 112

Item #15.
ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT MONTHLY REPORT
FY25

Historical Peak Load
180

160

140

120

1002022
Megawatts
802023
2024
60

40

20

0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec

15

Paj 113

Item #15.

DECEMBER 2024

City of Dover Human Resources Mission Statement: The City of Dover’s Human Resources Department strives to provide quality service to assist our greatest asset, our employees. Equity, Integrity, and Urgency is our focus to ensure employee satisfaction as well as company wellness. We implement policies and procedures that align with organizational goals, including a safe and compliant workplace, effective training and professional development, and addressing both the needs of employees and the organization.

City of Dover Human Resources Value Statement:

Innovation: We strive to include best HR practices to enhance a robust technological movement to enhance the quality and efficiency of the department.

Collaboration: We honor knowledge sharing, diversity of thoughts and ideas, and experiences to encourage an inclusive workforce.

Integrity and Transparency: We honor our commitments and promote a healthy environment that promotes fairness, honesty, respect, and trust.

Results Driven: Customer service is front and center, and we advocate for employees' and retirees’ needs at all times.

DECEMBER SUMMARY:

December Hiring Trends FY24:

MONTHNEW HIRE AMOUNTSTATUS
DECEMBER54 FT, 1 PT

December Voluntary Termination/Involuntary Termination Trends FY24:

VOLUNTARY 4 FT, 0 PT INVOLUNTARY 0 RETIREMENT 3 FT

16

Paj 114

Item #15.

DECEMBER EEO DATA

EEO DATA 3% 2% 1% 3%

16%

75%

AMERICAN INDIAN ASIAN AFRICAN AMERICAN CAUCASIAN HISPANIC OTHER RACE

AMERICAN INDIAN3%
ASIAN1%
AFRICAN AMERICAN16%
CAUCASIAN75%
HISPANIC3%
OTHER RACE2%

17

Paj 115

Item #15.

DECEMBER EEO DEMOGRAPHICS

EEO DEMOGRAPHICS

MINORITY 89

CAUCASIAN 295

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350

CAUCASIAN295
MINORITY89

18

Paj 116

Item #15.

DECEMBER GENDER REPORT

GENDER REPORT

FEMALE MALE NONBINARY

MALES73%
FEMALE27%
NON-BINARY 0%

19

Paj 117

Item #15.

FULL-TIME VS. PART-TIME EE’S

FULL-TIME VS. PART-TIME EE'S 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC

FULL TIME PART TIME TOTAL EE'S

Numbers do not reflect temporary, seasonal, relief fire dispatchers, committees, or council members.

MONTHJAN FEB MARAPR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC
FULL- TIME 356 358 362365 365364364 360 358 263 363 356
PART-TIME 3130 25292726293134313238
TOTAL EE'S 387 388 387394 392390393 391 392 394 395 394

20

Paj 118

Item #15.

DECEMBER INTERNAL EE AGE DEMOGRAPHICS

AGE DEMOGRAPHICS

18-24

25-34

35-44

45-54

55-64

65+

0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%

AGEPERCENTAGE
18-246%
25-3426%
35-4422%
45-5423%
55-6417%
65 +5%

21

Paj 119

Item #15.

HIRING DETAILS

Position Hired: 1 FT CUSTOMER SERVICE CLERK/CUSTOMER SERVICE, 1 FT ELECTRICAL ENGINEER/ELECTRIC, 1 PT ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT/CUSTOMER SERVICE, 1 FT ACCOUNTANT I/FINANCE, 1 FT ARBORIST/GROUNDS Transferred/Promoted: 0 Position Terminated/Resigned/Retired/Other: 4 FT VOLUNTARY TERM, 3 FT RETIREMENTS Terminal Leave: N/A

CURRENT VACANT POSITIONS

*Not used for Budgeting Purposes

22

Paj 120

Item #15.

TURNOVER STATISTICS

23

Paj 121

Item #15.

24

Paj 122

Item #15.

25

Paj 123

Item #15.

DECEMBER WORKER’S COMPENSATION DATA

MONTHNOV 24DEC-24
WORKERS COMP INJURY DETAIL12

WORKERS COMP COST DECEMBER 2024

TOTAL

PUBLIC WORKS

POLICE

GROUNDS

CUSTOMER SERVICE

0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000

Respectfully Submitted by H. Naomi Poole

26

Paj 124

Item #15.

Information Technology Department
December 2024 Report
Larry Josefowski, Director

State and Local Community Cybersecurity Grant (SLCG) project: Funding is available, and meetings have been conducted with vendors regarding two of the projects. Network design improvement planning will begin in January, and we also are planning on moving to a more complete Endpoint Detection and Response solution at the beginning of January. Both projects will increase our security posture; the first will provide better security by limiting the damage and access that any breach may cause, and the second will increase the visibility and protection of the network by instituting 24/x investigation and remediation. It will also see a cost savings during the lifespan of grant dollar availability – we expect the cost savings over the 5-year period to be in the 40-100K range.

Tyler Enterprise ERP and HTE/Naviline: On the Tyler front, we followed up with a status request from our account manager, to make sure he knew about the decision to stop any further Tyler implementation. He had not been at work but was going to follow up with their legal department for confirmation. On the HTE/Naviline front, we began preparing the system for the new version, which required some hardware and software maintenance, with software installation for the test environment beginning during the month. We expect to have the new test environment functional by January.

We also have had conversations regarding the conversion of all information back to the HTE/Naviline and are awaiting a quote for the total cost to assist in the decision regarding the next steps. Although my previous report indicated a longer timeframe for possible conversion, cost savings may allow us to move this process up as early as the beginning of the next fiscal year.

Network improvements: We’ve experienced several network issues during the month; part of this is due to the replacement of newer hardware is causing some issues with the older parts that remain. We are working to alleviate that situation, as well as acquiring new equipment through the SLCG process.

Metrics: We track a fairly large number of metrics, and we’re highlighting some of the ones we don’t usually show, and why we track them. While

Number of Incidents: The number of incidents was lower than the average for the year, but the number of incidents tended to dip during holidays.

Time to Close Incidents: The time to resolve incidents dipped slightly, as we continued to catch up with holidays.

Percent Windows 11 installed: Windows 10 support ends next October, but our goal is to have all our computers upgraded by the end of September 2025, as support ends in October 2025.

27

Paj 125

Item #15.

Number of IncidentsCISA Detected Vulnerabilities
July-December 2024July-December 2024
18016
16014
12
14010
1208
1006
4
802
600
Time to close incidentsWindows 11 Completion
July-December 2024July-December 2024
10 d 0 h100.0%
90.0%
80.0%
7d0h70.0%
60.0%
50.0%
40.0%
4d0h
30.0%
20.0%
10.0%
1d0h0.0%

28

Paj 126

Reference Transactions
December 2024 Item #15.

Adults 421

Teens 57

Children
212

0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000
**Statistics Unavailable Due To A Statewide Extended Internet Outage

CirculationDecember '24FYTD '25December '23FYTD '24
City of Dover Residents8,74161,5319,18962,358
Electronic Materials7,41142,7284,91730,267
Kent County Residents9,31763,2898,78157,451
Non-County Residents1,2577,8041,2068,011
New Library Registrations
City of Dover Residents2091,4491831,285
Kent County Residents7763398884
Non-County Residents226637
Registered Library Users as of 12/31/2024Registered Library Users as of 12/31/2023
City of Dover Residents20,18818,297
Kent County Residents9,5688,076
Non-County Residents704650
TOTAL30,46027,023
Other
Visitors12,78785,31612,18785,076
Meeting Room Attendance3,32618,7842,89116,921
**Number of Computer UsersN/A4,0751,42310,268
Number of Wireless Computer Users1,1438,7421,3949,239
Inter/Intralibrary - Loaned4532
Inter/Intralibrary - Borrowed7389
Holds Sent2,3472,204
Holds Received1,5761,510
TOTAL4,04124,6983,83528,810
Tech Services/Items Added9631,046
Tech Services/Items Deleted2,1141,542
Passport Services/Customers1651,2961841,212
Passport Services/Revenue$9,130$55,308$7,181$47,699
Monthly Highlights
►298 attended 37 programs for adults.
►213 attended 22 program for teens.
►885 attended 26 programs for children.
► 0 volunteers.
Program Spotlight

29

Paj 127

Item #15.

30

Paj 128

Item #15.
Parks & Recreation
Monthly Report - December 2024

Parks & RecreaƟon Highlights  Five Park Projects Dover Park Building and Spray Pad. Staff con nues to following the project. Dry wall is mostly completed and work has begun on the Spray Pad. Building target opening date has been moved to early 2025. All Accessible Playground staff con nues to follow this project. Equipment was purchased last year. The equipment is onsite in storage containers. Skate Park in progress as noted in the FY25 CIP list. The Do It Yourself Skatepark is open. At this me, staff is working with WRA for construc on ready bid documents.

 Indoor Field Hockey shot off to a great start with Sunday hockey games at the John W. Pi s Recrea on Center. This indoor season is hos ng 7 Co‐ed, 6 High School, 8 Middle School and 3 Adult Women’s hockey teams. It’s a great season, come out watch them play!

 Proctor & Gamble hosted a quarterly business mee ng for their employees at the John W. Pi s Recrea on Center. Approximately 300 people a ended the one day event.

Outdoor Sports & Leagues
Recreation Revenue Breakdown ParƟcipant & Spectator Count

AcƟvity Moved inside for the
ParƟcipants winter!
Spectators LocaƟon

2024 Memories!

December 2024December 2023
General Recrea on$716General Recrea on$567
Sports$744Sports$545
Leagues$2,440Leagues$1,980
Trips$410Trips$0
Bldg, Field, Pavilion &Bldg. Field, Pavilion
$60$0
Stage permits& Stage Permits
Parks & RecreaƟonFYTDFYTD
Dec. 24Dec. 23
Programs2524
General Recrea on1552,0962561,362
Open Gym1516561251,002
Sports04960415
Leagues (Inside)3,71013,4162,96912,882
Bldg, Field, Facility permits271248
Camps01,60901,639

Thank you for supporƟng the Capital Holiday CelebraƟon and Food Drive!

31

Paj 129

Item #15.

Grounds Monthly Report
DEC.-2024

Arborist Crew:Arborist Crew
- Worked on Holiday light repairs. Tree Work Completed
- Trimmed and removed street trees Tree's Trimmed 29
- Added Hoilday Lights Tree's Removed 5
Beautification Crew:Root Pruning0
Stumps Removed0
- Worked on holiday decorations. Trees Planted 0
- Clean up Storm Damage
- Clean and maintaine flowers beds
Mowing Crew:
- General clean up of mowing locations.
- Worked on holiday decorations.
- Cleaned up storm Damage
Litter Removal:
- Litter is being picked up on city property as per the weekly schedule.
- Litter person has been diligent in the reporting of destruction in City parks.
- 119 Total 90 gallon cans collected.
Removed 3 Shopping Carts.

Parks Crew:
- Completed parks route daily.
- Spread Mulch
- Worked on holiday decorations

Miscellaneous:
- Finish Maintaining lights strands on loockerman
- Storm Damage cleanup
- Setups and Takedowns for Speacial Events

32

Paj 130

Item #15.

Litter Cans Collected 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec

2021 2022 2023 2024

Trees Removed
80

60

40

20

0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec

2021 2022 2023 2024

Trees Trimmed
250
200
150
100
50
0
Jan Feb Mar April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec

2021 2022 2023 2024

33

Paj 131

Item #15.

City Planner’s Monthly Report
Department of Planning & Inspections
DECEMBER 2024

Planning & Inspections Highlights
Some Items to Call to Your Attention

The Planning Office is part of the review process for certain types of construction activity permits. In December, staff reviewed 54 Building Permits and 20 Certificates of Occupancy Permits. Planning Office staff also provided support to the Planning Commission (5 applications reviewed) and the His- toric District Commission (1 application reviewed). The Planning Office continued to have 3 vacan- cies including the Director, a Planner II and a Planner I. Finding qualified candidates continues to be challenging. Due to these vacancies, the Department continues to utilize a consultant to assist staff in addressing the current workload. Construction activity continued in December with both residential and non-residential projects with Building Permits and Certificates of Occupancy being issued. Residential development areas consist- ed of Eden Hill Farm TND, The Edge at Dover Apartments, Owens & Queens Manor, and individual structures located in various locations across the city including the Downtown Development District. Non-residential projects included a tenant fit-out for Bubbakoo’s Burritos Restaurant. Overall, 160 permits were issued resulting in 399 inspections. Within the Inspections Division, Building Inspector II, Chris Scott, retired after over 20 years of ser- vice. A job posting was made for a Building Inspector I/II in conjunction with the existing post for the Chief Building Inspector position. Finding qualified candidates continues to be challenging. In order to ensure construction activity is not stalled, the Department is utilizing a contractor to assist in Building Permit/Plan reviews as well as with Building Inspections as needed. Deputy Fire Marshal Matthew Brown is providing assistance with coordination efforts between the consultant, staff and the development community. Department Division Managers continued work on the preparation of the FY26 budget including op- erational budget and revenue projection. At the end of December, 50.0% of FY25 had passed. Total revenue at that time for the Department was at 66% of the $3,195,000 budget. Code Enforcement staff conducted Annual Housing Inspections (119 cases) as part of the Rental Dwelling Permit program. Other Code Enforcement cases focused on exterior property maintenance issues/violations (40 cases) and Dover Code of Ordinance violations (33 cases). December ended with 127 registered vacant buildings, 57 dangerous buildings, and 7,853 active rental dwelling units. Staff within the Fire Marshal’s Office conducted 12 Annual Fire & Life Safety Inspections resulting in the identification of 2 deficiencies. Staff investigated 4 fire incidents which included a large fire loss at 309 W. Division Street.

34

Paj 132

Item #15.

Planning & Inspections Revenue

FY 2025 Revenue FY2025 Actual

Estimates from(YTD)
Revenue StreamBudgetDecember 2024% of Budget
Business License$1,450,000 $ 1,526,179105%
Manufactured Home License$14,000 $15,019107%
Building Permits$550,000 $351,77164%
Cert. of Occupancy$8,000 $5,81573%
Public Occupancy$45,000 $3,3657%
Lodging House$28,000 $320%
Plumbing/Heating/Air$100,000 $56,66257%
Rental Inspection Fee$750,000 $31,0804%
Miscellaneous$20,000 $12,33762%
Fire Protection Fees$80,000 $62,65778%
Code Enforcement Fines$100,000 $26,60127%
Vacant Building Reg.$50,000 $22,50045%

Total P&I Revenue $3,195,000 $ 2,114,018 66%

Planning Office Operations The Meetings of the Boards and Commission supported by the Planning Office are presented in the Hybrid format with both In-Person and Virtual (using Webex) meeting options for participation. Electronic commu- nications and conducting Meetings and Trainings in virtual formats are commonplace due to realized effi- ciencies. The Planning Office is part of the review process for certain types of construction activity permits (Building Permits, Sign Permits, etc.) and Certificate of Occupancy permits in order to confirm compliance with the Zoning Ordinance provisions. For December 2024, Planning Staff was involved with the review of 54 Build- ing Permits and 20 Certificates of Occupancy permits that were issued for a monthly total of 74 and a calen- dar year total of 909. The 2024 calendar year tally is lower than the calendar year totals of Permits and COs seen in 2023 at 1028 and in 2022 at 992. Staff also reviews new applications for Business Licenses and Rent- al Dwelling Permits.

  • •FY2025-2026 Budget: The Department of Planning & Inspections division managers submitted the De- partment’s Draft of the FY2025-2026 Budget focusing on operational activities.
DECEMBER 2024 (FY25)TOTAL FOR FY25
New Home Permits Issued139
Value of Commercial Projects$3,212,597.00$22,721,203.00
Downtown Incentives (Fees Waived)
$0.00$2,127.00

35

Paj 133

Item #15.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPLEMENTATION

2019 Comprehensive Plan Implementation of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan continues as Departments citywide focus on the plan im- plementation items as found in Implementation Plan (Chapter 15) items such as the projects, studies, code amendments, and other activities. A copy of the Final Plan (as amended) is available on the Comprehensive Plan website: https://www.cityofdover.com/2019-comprehensive-plan Visit the Dover Parcel and Zoning Viewer on the City’s website to see zoning information for properties located in Dover. Use the Quick Link on the main page www.cityofdover.com.

Other Activities • Downtown Dover Strategic Master Plan: The Downtown Dover Partnership’s Strategic Master Plan is known as “Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030” (January 2023). Various partners are focusing on aspects of Plan implementation. The Downtown Dover Partnership is moving forward with planning for the development of priority project sites with the first application for the Dover Mobility Center Garage reviewed by the Historic District Commission in December. Also, the City is involved in planning for water and sanitary sewer improvement projects. • Downtown Development District – Renewal Application: The Downtown Development District (DDD) for the City of Dover was designated in January 2015 for a period of ten years. The City applied for a five-year extension of DDD designation and its initial approval granted by the State Cabinet Committee in August. The next step is preparation of amendments to the Dover Code of Ordinances to formally es- tablish the revised Downtown Development District Boundary. The consultant (Rossi Group) is working to draft the required code text amendments and other implementation documents. The Draft Ordi- nance to establish the revised boundaries is expected to begin review in January 2025.

Construction Activities • In December 2024, Residential Building Permits were issued for six (6) Duplex units and two (2) Apart- ment Buildings at Eden Hill Farm TND (S-24-01); an Apartment Building at The Edge at Dover Apart- ments; and a single family detached dwelling in the Downtown Dover Development District. • Certificates of Occupancy were issued to two (2) single family detached dwellings in the Downtown De- velopment District; three (3) Townhouse units in the Villages of Maple Dale PND-SCHO; a single family detached dwelling on Pine Valley Road; ten (10) Townhouse units in Eden Hill Farm TND; and a manu- factured home placement in Dover East Estates. • Building Permits issued in December were for renovations at Owens Manor; and renovations at 60 Starlifter Avenue. • A Certificate of Occupancy was issued for a tenant fit-out for Bubbakoo’s Burritos Restaurant at 1128 Forrest Avenue B and for a portion of the renovation project at Owens & Queens Manor.

36

Paj 134

Item #15.

2024: Welcome to Dover!
Progress in Pictures
Bubbakoos Burritos

1128 Forrest Avenue Unit B

Delaware
State Univer-

182 Pine Valley Rd

U & I Builders

1061 S. Little
Creek Rd

Unit 47

Dover East
Estates

37

Paj 135

Item #15.

2024: Welcome to Dover!
Progress in Pictures

35 Maple Dale Road 7 & 11 Barrington Way
1360 College Rd 110-118 Ann Moore St.

Eden Hill Farm TND

DR Horton Townhomes

131 N. Kirk-
38 Kirkwood St.
wood St.
Habitat for Humanity
Habitat for
Humanity

Eden Hill Farm TND - 119, 117, 115, 113, 111 Ridgley Blvd.
By D.R. HORTON
29 45

29, 45, 51 Maple Dale Rd

Townhomes

U & I Builders

51

38

Paj 136

Item #15.

BOARD AND COMMISSION ACTIVITY

There were Meetings in December of the Boards and Commissions supported by the Planning Office. The Planning Commission held a meeting on December 16, 2024 consisting of reviewing two Requests for Exten- sion, a Rezoning, a Site Plan, and an Alley Abandonment Request. The Historic District Commission conduct- ed its Annual Meeting on December 19, 2024 and considered one Application for Architectural Review Certi- fication. The Board of Adjustment did not meet in December due to lack of agenda items.

Planning Commission: The Planning Commission met on December 18, 2024. The Commission considered the following applica- tions. The next Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for January 18, 2025.

  • •SB-23-03 Revised Stonebrook East Planned Neighborhood Design at McKee Road and W. Denneys Road
  • •The Planning Commission granted the Request for an additional 6-month Extension of the Planning Commission conditional approval granted December 18, 2023 and extension granted May 20, 2024 for the Revised Subdivision Plan to increase the number of townhouses from 87 to 103 townhouses (increase of 16 townhouse units) and to decrease the number of garden apartment units from 168 to 138 garden apartment units (decrease of 30 units). This development known as Stonebrook East Planned Neighbor- hood Design (PND) proposes 241 dwelling units, recreational areas, open space, and stormwater manage- ment areas. The conditional approval included PND- Alternative Design Standards. The property is zoned RM-1 (Medium Density Residential Zone) and approved as a PND (Planned Neighborhood Design Option). The site is on the northeast corner of McKee Road and W. Denneys Road. Property Address: in- tersection of McKee Road and West Denneys Road. Property Owners: Hanae Harmony Properties and Stonebrook East 168 LLC. Tax Parcels: ED-05-057.03-01-01.00-000 to ED-05-057.03-01-92.00-000. Council District 1.
  • •S-22-14 Commerce Way Dover DE LLC Warehouse on Commerce Way – The Planning Commission granted the one-year Extension of the Planning Commission conditional approval granted on December 19, 2022 for a Site Development Plan to permit construction of a 234,000 SF +/- warehouse and associat- ed site improvements on Commerce Way. The property is zoned IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone). The property is located on the northwest side of Commerce Way, north of W. North Street. The owner of record is H & M Properties, LLC. The Equitable Owner is Commerce Way Dover DE, LLC. Property Address: 22.967-acre unaddressed parcel on Commerce Way. Tax Parcel: ED-05-076.10-02- 07.03-000. Council District 1. PLUS #2022-09-05.
  • •Z-24-06 Lands of PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC at 1216 McKee Road: Rezoning C-PO to IO - The Plan- ning Commission Recommended approval to City Council on a Rezoning application for a parcel of land consisting of 1.2302 acres +/-. The property is zoned C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The proposed zoning for the property is IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). The property is located on the west side of McKee Road and north of the intersection of McKee Road and College Road. The owner of record is PAM Cubed Real Estate, LLC. Property Address: 1216 McKee Road. Tax Parcel: ED- 05-067.00-01-34.00-000. Council District 1. Ordinance #2024-31. The Public Hearing is scheduled for City Council on January 13, 2025.
  • •S-24-20 Office Building of Ditko Properties, LLC at 1107 S. Bradford Street – The Planning Commission recommended conditional approval for the Site Development Plan inclusive of the elimination of the side- walk waiver for construction of 2,140 SF one story Office Building on the parcel of land totaling 11,326 SF (0.26 +/- acres). The zoning is C-2A (Limited Central Commercial Zone). The property is located on the east side of S. Bradford Street approximately 135.37 ft south of Wyoming Avenue. The owner is Ditko Properties, LLC. Property Address: 1107 S. Bradford Street, Dover DE. Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.17- 07-27.00-000. Council District 2. Waiver Requests: Partial Elimination of Upright Curbing and Elimina- tion of Street Frontage Sidewalk. This property was the subject of Annexation Application AX-22-02 and annexed into the City on December 12, 2022.

39

Paj 137

Item #15.

Planning Commission Continued:

MI-24-10 Request for Alley Abandonment: Part of Alley Between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street – The Planning Commission recommended approval to City Council on a Request for Abandonment of a portion of the improved alley, located between South Governors Avenue and South Bradford Street and extending approximately 132 feet north of the Minor Street Alley, consisting of 1,550 square feet in area. The portion of the alley to be abandoned is adjacent to the properties located at 133 S. Governors Avenue, 139 S. Governors Avenue, 145 S. Governors Avenue, 136 S. Bradford Street, 148 S. Bradford Street, and 150 S. Bradford Street, Dover DE. This Recommendation will be forwarded to the CCOW Utility Committee.

Historic District Commission: The Historic District Commission met on December 19, 2024. One Application was filed for Recommenda- tion on Architectural Review Certification. In addition to other reporting, the Annual Meeting of the Historic District Commission was held with the re-election of Chair Eric Czerwinski and Vice-Chair Ellen Richard- son in addition to establishing the deadlines and meeting dates for 2025. The next Historic District Commis- sion meeting is scheduled for January 16, 2024.

  • •HI-24-09 Dover Mobility Center Garage at 133 S. Governors Avenue – The Historic District Commis- sion recommended approval of the Architectural Review Certification as presented including the ele- ments of Staff review comments and recommendation found in Section VI of the Review Report for construction of a four story, 400-space multi-purpose parking garage structure to be known as the Dover Mobility Center Garage. The subject site involves six parcels in the block between S. Governors Avenue and S. Bradford Street north of Minor Street Alley. The properties are zoned C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) and subject to the H (Historic District Zone). The owners of record are the Downtown Dover Part- nership, City of Dover, Capital City Transformation Alliance, and CEI Properties LLC. Property Ad- dresses: 133 S. Governors Avenue, 139 S. Governors Avenue, 145 S. Governors Avenue, 136 S. Brad- ford Street, 148 S. Bradford Street, and 150 S. Bradford Street, Dover.

Board of Adjustment: The Board of Adjustment did not meet on December 18, 2024 due to lack of agenda items. The next Board of Adjustment meeting is scheduled for January 15, 2025.

40

Paj 138

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT PROGRAM Item #15.

CDBG FY24 Projects

  • •Homeownership Assistance Program CDBG funds will be used to provide homeownership assistance to first-time homebuyers who purchase affordable housing in the City of Dover. Three families have purchased homes year-to-date.
  • •Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing (DIMH) CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for the shelter. This project is under- way. Ninety-five (95%) of program funds have been drawn down year-to-date.
  • •Central Delaware Housing Collaborative CDBG funds will be used to provide operations cost for a women’s shelter. This project is underway.
  • •Milford Housing Homeowner Rehabilitation/Emergency Home Repair Pro- grams CDBG funds will be used to rehabilitate existing owner-occupied housing in the City that are in violation of the City’s Housing Code and complete emergency home repairs to eliminate housing conditions that threaten the health and safety of low-income home- owners. Two (2) owner occupied homes have been rehabbed and seven (7) homes re- ceived emergency home repairs.
  • •American Rescue Act (ARPA) Funding City Council approved to award a little over $1.8 million in grant funding for Housing and Community Service projects. All projects are underway. A little under $1.8 million or 85% of funds have been spent on Round 1 of ARPA funding year-to-date. Dover Housing Authority, Murphey School, Reading Assist, and Peoples Church have completed their projects. ARPA Round 2 funding for a little under $500,000 was awarded to subgrantees in April 2023. Projects are currently underway. Thirty-seven percent (37%) of funds have been drawn down for Round 2 with Murphey School and Peoples Church completing their projects.

41

Paj 139

Item #15.
CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY

Dangerous Buildings, Vacant Buildings, Demolitions & Announcements
 Vacant Buildings currently registered - 127
 Dangerous Buildings – 57
 Active Rental Dwellings – 7,853 units

42

Paj 140

Building Inspections & Licensing Summary Item #15.

July 2023—
July 2024–
Current June 2025 December FY’24 June 2024

PERMITTING AND LICENSING

Permits IssuedDEC (2024)DEC (2023)
FY 25FYTD 25FY24FYTD 24
Administrative Permit
115135
Building Addition/Renovation Permits1615639193
Building Permits
241378112
Demolition Permits
115319
Fence Permits12104793
Fire Prevention Permits6381052
Mechanical Permits
4024717145
Plumbing Permits
5221118148
Sign Permits8421096
Swimming Pool Permits
0906
Subtotal974899
Business Licenses261677341749
Merchant Licenses
53175336
Contractor Licenses
201160371204
Subtotal31543289

Lodging House Licenses

0302
Public Occupancy
5766100
Rental Dwelling717311155
Subtotal252257

Manufactured Homes 4 301 5 263

BUILDING INSPECTIONS

InspectionsDEC (2024)DEC (2023)
FY 25FYTD 25FY24FYTD 24
Building (Inspections/CBI/Site Meetings)
1771820118850
Plumbing/Mechanical
2021798152899
Certificate of Occupancy
20831179

43

Paj 141

Item #15.
Office of the Fire Marshal
-The Fire Marshal’s Office staff investigated four (4) inci-
dents during the month of December including a large fire
loss at 309 W. Division Street.
- Deputy Fire Marshal Brown is assisting with the coordina-
tion of the Building Department’s third party contractor in
addition to his regular job duties.

MonthYear to DatePrevious Year to Date
Annual Fire & Life Safety Inspections12167162

Deficiencies From the Above Inspections 2 279 507

Fire Code Violations/Deficiencies/32186134
Complaints
C/O & Fire Equipment Acceptance Tests175861

Meetings & Walk Through 11 79 119

Fire Plan Review & DAC 7 56 71

Month Year to Date Previous Year to Date Accidental 3 totaling $110,000 28 totaling $527,102 19 totaling $1, 539,004

Incendiary 0 5 totaling $2,003 2 totaling $2

Undetermined 1 totaling $8,000 8 totaling $526,100 10 totaling $356,602

Natural 0 0 1 totaling $60,000

Investigation Time 17 hours 116 hours 58 hours

Injuries0113
Deaths000

Arrest made with DPD 0 0 0

44

Paj 142

Item #15.

45

Paj 143

Item #15.

46

Paj 144

Item #15.

47

Paj 145

Item #15.

48

Paj 146

Item #15.

CITY OF DOVER

DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER

MONTHLY REPORT

Dec-24

Inflow & Infiltration Costs
This chart indicates the amount of money the City is

$300,000.00spending on treating ground and / or rain water
through Kent County. This cost is being offset by the
$250,000.00Ground Water Inflow Adjustment rate passed on to the
customers. April 2024 had a large amout of rainfall,
$200,000.00causing a significant I & I deficit. July 2024 had a
inverted cost due to the timing of our report and the
timing of the Kent County Bill
$150,000.00

$100,000.00

$50,000.00

$- Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24 Dec-24 $(50,000.00)

$(100,000.00)

I & I Cost

Water & Wastewater Repairs

7Water mains and services are typically
repaired at a higher rate when drastic
change in temperature occurs. This
6freeze and thaw cycle expands and
contracts the soil, causing cracks in the
5water line. November 2024 had large
fluctuations of temperature, causing a
large volume of repairs.
4

3

2

1

0 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24 Dec-24

Water Mains Repaired Water Services Repaired Wastewater Mains Repaired Wastewater Laterals Repaired

49

Paj 147

Item #15.

CITY OF DOVER

DEPARTMENT OF WATER & WASTEWATER

MONTHLY REPORT

Dec-24

Number of Brown Water Complaints
20
This chart indicates the number of

18complaints the Department receives.
March 2024 was high because it has
16been over 5 months since the last
flushing operation. August was high due
14
to a contractor illegally connecting to a
12hydrant

10

8

6

4

2

0 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24 Dec-24

Number of Brown Water Complaints Linear (Number of Brown Water Complaints)

Department Spotlight - December
The Department of Water & Wastewater was tasked with
inspecting the rehabilitation of N. Bradford Street, here is a
photo of the sidewalk being replaced to meet ADA
requirements.

50

Paj 148

Item #16.

DOVER FIRE DEPARTMENT

December 2024

FIRE CHIEFS REPORT

Paj 149

Item #16.

To: Mayor and Council

From: David Carey, Fire Chief

Date: January 4, 2025

Subject: December 2024 Fire Department Report

The Dover Fire Department responded to 157 calls in December, accumulating a total of _1,289_____ personnel hours.

Personnel Activities:

  • •Meetings: __96___ hours
  • •Training: _452__ hours
  • •Duty Crew: _2,562_ hours

Total Personnel Hours for December: _4,399_ hours

Major Incidents for December:

  • •MVC with Entrapment at North and Governors Ave
  • •Building Fire at 1107 S Dupont Hwy (D and D Liquors)
  • •Two House Fires at 307 and 309 W. Division Street
  • •Trailer Fire at New Street, Cheswold
  • •Trailer Fire at Underwoods Corner Road, Clayton
  • •House Fire on Chesapeake Lane, Clayton

Special Recognition:

  • •DSFS Fire Academy Graduates: o Andie Bell – Instructors Award o Sara McKendrick – Leadership Award o Jarmarion Wilks
  • •Promotions: o Degazon Calvens – Firefighter 1 o Zachary Lawrence – Firefighter 1
  • •Newly Qualified Drivers: o Eric Dawson – Qualified on Ladder 1

Paj 150

Item #16.

o Andrew Hatfield – Qualified on Engine 1, 2, and Squad 1 o Chris Jacobs – Qualified on Engine 1, Engine 2, Ladder 1, Squad 1, Squad 2, and Engine 4

Boundary Dispute Update:

The boundary dispute has been postponed until February's Commission Meeting.

Community Engagement:

The Dover Fire Department traveled throughout the fire district over a 5-day period to spread holiday cheer in the City of Dover and surrounding communities. We greatly appreciate the support of the citizens as our members brought the holiday spirit to the area.

Fire Officer Swearing-In:

In December, the 2025 Fire Officers were sworn in by the Honorable Mayor Robin Christiansen. We look forward to a progressive year as we continue advancing the Dover Fire Department and enhancing service to our community.

Department Updates:

  • •We are moving forward with the implementation of a new time accountability program to ensure accurate tracking for the upcoming stipend program.
  • •Adjustments are being made to our Duty Crew responsibilities and scheduling program to better suit the department's needs.

Paj 151

Item #16.

Holiday Event:

A breakfast with Santa was held for our members and their families in December, with approximately 75 attendees. A special thank you to Councilman Hare for being the "Star of the Morning."

If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.

David Carey
Fire Chief

Paj 152

Item #16.

Paj 153

Item #16.

Paj 154

Item #16.

Paj 155

City of Dover Item #17.

Police Department

Monthly Report
December 2024

Paj 156

CITY OF DOVER DEPARTMENT OF POLICE Item #17.

400 SOUTH QUEEN STREET DOVER, DELAWARE 19904 302-736-7111

Chief of Police Police Captains
THOMAS A. JOHNSON, JR. RANDY R. ROBBINS
Deputy Chief of Police PAUL D. KUNTZI
DAVID E. SPICER ROBERT E. ROSWELL

February 10, 2025

Honorable Robin Christiansen, Mayor
Members of Dover City Council
City Hall
Dover, DE 19901

Mayor Christiansen and Council Members:

The following is the monthly report of Dover Police Department activities for December:

COMPLAINTS/EVENTS

YTD Totals compiled through December numbered 48,477.

This represents an increase of 5,266 from the 43,211 reported over the same period in 2023.

60,000
48,477

50,00039,90840,44343,211
40,00033,513
30,000
20,000
10,000
0
20202021202220232024

CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS

Burglary: 4 cases reported, 3 cases cleared and 0 cases was cleared from previous months.

Robbery: 4 cases reported, 3 cases cleared and 1 cases was cleared from previous months.

Sex Assault: 5 cases reported, 2 cases cleared and 0 cases was cleared from previous months.

Homicide: 1 case reported, 1 case cleared and 0 case cleared from previous months.

There were 7 Non-Criminal Death Investigations, 7 cases cleared and 0 cases cleared from previous months. 1

Paj 157

Item #17.
DRUG, VICE, & ORGANIZED CRIME / STREET CRIMES UNIT ENFORCEMENT

Marijuana: 1,360.77 grams seized Cocaine: 69.84 grams seized Ecstasy: 34.6 doses seized Prescription Pills: 0 doses seized Heroin: 422.51 grams seized Methamphetamine: 0 grams seized Fentanyl: 0 grams seized Other Rx Drugs: 3.6 grams/doses seized Drug Proceeds: $1,420 seized

FIREARM SEIZURES/INSIDE CITY LIMITS

15
10

5212
000000000
0
CIDVOC/STREET CRIMESPATROLSEU

HANDGUN RIFLE SHOTGUN

Firearms: 4 Handguns and I Rifle.

TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT

YTD Citation Totals compiled through December numbered 5,769.

This represents a decrease of 986 from the 6,755 reported over the same period in 2023.

9,000
7,807
8,000
6,755
7,000

5,7855,769
6,0005,182
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
20202021202220232024

TRAFFIC CRASHES: YTD = 1,962

2

Paj 158

Item #17.
911 CENTER ACTIVITY

Total compiled during December numbered 7,359 calls.

This represents an increase of 280 from the 7,079 reported during the same period in 2023.

8,200 8,060
8,000

7,800

7,600 7,503
7,359
7,400

7,200 7,079
7,000
6,812
6,800

6,600

6,400

6,200

6,000
2020 2021 2022 2023 2024

CITY ORDINANCE SUMMONS

YTD Totals compiled through December numbered 3,304.

This represents an increase of 1,275 from the 2,029 reported over the same period in 2023.

5,0004,097
3,5683,761
4,0003,304
3,000
2,029
1,714
2,0001,363
1,0308901,037
1,000
0
20202021202220232024
ISSUED3,5684,0973,7612,0293,304
PAID1,7141,0308901,0371,363

3

Paj 159

COMMUNITY POLICING Item #17.

This proactive unit takes the lead on community engagement and supporting our community organizations. They have administrative responsibilities and also support other departmental units, such as patrol, during times of high work volumes or special operations with enforcement activities. In addition to those duties, the unit accomplished the following in December:

 Assisted Patrol Units during major incidents, high 911 call volume and/or low staffing  Supported the Police Academy by delivering training on persons with disabilities  Attended the Cannon Mills HOA meeting  Participated in the annual Tree Lighting ceremony  Participated in the Cookies with Cops at the Charlton School  Supported the annual Holiday Heroes event at the Dover Target store  Facilitated the Hometown Holiday activities in December  Supported the Planning/Inspections enforcement team at 141 S. Queen Street  Supported the Dover Christmas Parade  The BHU took the lead on 43 events and took official action to provide services to 14 people needing mental health support & 8 needing substance abuse referral. 19 of the field contacts needed either both resources or some type of other assistance.  Continued the Quality of Life (QOL) Operation at hot spot locations on the Route 13 corridor & the Downtown District. See the programs/initiatives section for further details.

(As a reminder, the QOL operation has greatly reduced the capacity of CPU to keep up with other historical community engagement activities. This will return after the operation concludes.)

Members of the CPU attend numerous meetings with community associations and organizations as a part of our ongoing liaison relationships.

2024 TARGET Holiday Heroes participants Sworn and Civilian DPD Participants

4

Paj 160

PROGRAMS AND INITIATIVES Item #17.

A vacant police officer position was offered to Mr. Shamar Ince who has roots in Kent County Delaware but has been serving in the Polk County Florida Sheriff’s Office. He is currently working successfully as a Criminal Case Detective but his family dynamics have brought him back to serve in Delaware. We are fortunate to have attracted an experienced reciprocity candidate and we are making plans for his arrival in late January or early February. Five potential recruit officers have survived the background investigation phase of the current hiring cycle. They are scheduled for their Chief interviews in early January. If they are selected, they will become part of the next Municipal Academy slated to begin on April 27, 2025 and run through to September.

There are also several Police Cadet Candidates who have successfully passed through the background phase of the hiring process. They will also have their Chief interviews in early January and it is expected that this group will allow us to return to a full roster of Cadets. After discussion with the Mayor and City Manager, and in the interest of creating maximum visibility of public safety in the Downtown area, we may hire up to eight Cadets for the Special Services Unit. It is recognized that this will put us out in front of the typical cycle of attrition for this role. It is also recognized that supervisors will manage the schedule in such a way that it keeps the program within budget parameters.

Two non-sworn members of the Department left in December. Records clerk Brenda Unruh decided to call it a career and initiated her retirement which lead to her last working day being New Year’s Eve. Also stepping away was Communications Operator Nicholas Cathell who accepted a position with the Delaware Emergency Management Agency. Both of them were important members of the team. Those positions were advertised in December and received considerable interest. Interviews are expected in January of 2025.

The Quality of Life initiative continued in December and continues to be coordinated by the Community Policing Unit and led by the Behavioral Health Unit. Due to the holiday window and staff members using up benefit hours, there was less activity in the second month. During second month operations, as expected, we noted less overtime incurred, less intervention events and fewer field contacts recorded by the officers. Dispositions of the encounters continued to include transport to hospital, referral to services, left alone, or charged with the offense(s) appropriate to the situation.

On December 12th our ongoing partnership with the ATF paid dividends for Dover when multiple defendants were indicted on various Federal firearms violations that included straw purchases and conversions of semi-automatic pistols into fully automatic weapons. Task Force relationships are an invaluable tool in keeping Dover safe.

Please visit our website at www.doverpolice.org for up to date information on crimes and activities in the City of Dover.

Respectfully Submitted,

Thomas A. Johnson, Jr.
Chief of Police

5

Paj 161

Item #19.

Final Draft Dover Freight Plan
Presentation to
Dover City Council
February 10, 2025

1

Paj 162

Item #19.

Paj 163

Safety
Item #19.

Paj 164

Agenda Item #19.

  • •Objectives
  • •Recent and ongoing freight-related planning and development
  • •Recommendations
  • •Next steps

4

Paj 165

Objectives Item #19.

  • 1.Increase collaboration among government and industry stakeholders to address freight issues and concerns
  • 2.Build upon previous freight planning efforts
  • 3.Identify freight movement issues and develop recommendations to help protect, manage, and accommodate freight activity in Dover

7

Paj 166

Recent & ongoing efforts Item #19.

  • •February 2024: City Council approved revisions to city- designated truck routes
  • •August 2024: New DAFB Joint Use Agreement signed
  • •Ongoing:
  • •Leasing out of sites at Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center
  • •Construction of East Camden Bypass
  • •Phase 2 of the Kent County East/West Truck Freight Routes Study 8

Paj 167

Item #19.

Recommendations

9

Paj 168

  • 1.Development regulations & review Item #19.

Recommendation 1A: Truck parking requirements • Adopt development regulations requiring developers to provide truck parking/staging as part of manufacturing, warehouse, and logistics developments • Responsible party: City of Dover • See next slides for examples from Lehigh Valley area of PA • Note that this recommendation does not include specific numbers. Specific Example of a truck parking lot numbers would likely differ from the Lehigh Valley examples Page 168

Paj 169

  • 1.Development regulations & review Item #19.

Recommendation 1B: Freight considerations checklist • Incorporate freight- specific planning considerations checklist (like the one developed by CPCS for WILMAPCO) into development review processes • Responsible parties: Development review entities at all government levels

Paj 170

  • 2.Land use planning Item #19.

Recommendation 2A: Protect existing freight-intensive development opportunities along truck routes • Preserve opportunities for freight-intensive development in appropriate locations by protecting parcels currently zoned for freight-generating uses along Dover’s existing and future truck routes from rezoning • Responsible parties: City of Dover and Kent County Recommendation 2B: Create opportunities for freight-intensive development along Dover’s truck routes • Create opportunities for freight-intensive development in appropriate locations by pursuing rezoning for suitable parcels not presently zoned for freight-intensive uses along Dover’s existing and future truck routes • Draw on Dover/Kent MPO’s 2022 Rail Corridor Industrial Land Use Study for guidance on rezoning for freight-intensive uses • Responsible parties: City of Dover and Kent County 14

Paj 171

  • 3.Communication & coordination Item #19.

Recommendation 3A: Intergovernmental coordination • Improve communication/coordination between local, county, and state government and MPO regarding freight-related land development and transportation projects • To ensure awareness of proposed projects that will affect freight movement • Collect and share freight-relevant data from land development and transportation improvement projects

  • •“Dig Once” policy to ensure that relevant freight Example of tractor trailer’s wide turning recommendations are implemented when road work is occurring radius
  • •Responsible parties: City of Dover, Kent County, State of Delaware 17

Paj 172

  • 3.Communication & coordination Item #19.

Recommendation 3B: Stakeholder coordination • Improve engagement with local freight operators to better address their needs during planning processes • Responsible parties: City of Dover, Kent County, State of Delaware Recommendation 3C: Revisit Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Study recommendations • Revisit the Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Study – Planning and Environmental Linkage (PEL) Report (2021) to determine if recommendations need to be adjusted based on leasing activity at Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center • Responsible parties: Dover/Kent MPO, City of Dover, Kent County, State of Delaware 18

Paj 173

Item #19.

Next Steps

20

Paj 174

Report Development Process Item #19.

Task Timeframe Developed preliminary recommendations based on technical analysis Fall 2024 and stakeholder feedback Held Public Workshop/launched survey October 2024 Presentation to Council Committee of the Whole October 29, 2024 – Transportation and Safety Committee Closed survey and processed results November 29, 2024 Refined recommendations and prepared report December-January 2025 DelDOT and City of Dover reviewed draft report; finalized draft January-February 2025 We are here Review/endorsement of final draft: • Dover City Council February 10, 2025 • Dover Kent MPO Public Advisory Council February 13, 2025 • Dover Kent MPO Technical Advisory Council February 18, 2025 • Dover Kent MPO Council March 12, 2025

Finalize report with endorsements for DelDOT website March 2025 21

Paj 175

Thank you! Item #19.

 Cooper Bowers, DelDOT  Marilyn Smith, Dover Kent MPO  Cooper.Bowers@delaware.gov  Marilyn.Smith@doverkentmpo.org

 302-760-2153  302-387-6030

 Leah Kacanda, WRA
 lkacanda@wrallp.com

 302-778-9056

22

Paj 176

Item #19.

Dover Freight Plan

Final Draft Report
January 2025

This final draft will be reviewed by the following public bodies: Dover City Council, February 10, 2025 Dover Kent County MPO Public Advisory Council (PAC), February 13, 2025 Dover Kent County MPO Technical Advisory Council (TAC), February 18, 2025 Dover Kent County MPO Council, March 12, 2025

Should any of these bodies elect to endorse the document it will be noted on the cover following the meeting dates.

Paj 177

Item #19.

This page intentionally left blank

Paj 178

DOVER FREIGHT PLAN

Item #19.

Table of Contents

1 Introduction and Background ....................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Study Area, Scope, Project Sponsor, and Study Team ...................................................................................1 1.2 Planning Context .............................................................................................................................................2 1.3 Objectives ........................................................................................................................................................2 1.4 Study Methodology ..........................................................................................................................................2 1.5 Prior Relevant Planning Efforts ........................................................................................................................3

2 Stakeholder and Public Involvement Process ............................................................................ 6 2.1 Stakeholder Interviews.....................................................................................................................................6 2.2 Freight Roundtable ..........................................................................................................................................6 2.3 Appendix Stakeholder Meeting ........................................................................................................................7 2.4 Public Open House and Survey .......................................................................................................................7 2.5 Dover City Council Committee of the Whole Meeting ......................................................................................7

3 Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions ............................................................................... 8 3.1 Land Use .........................................................................................................................................................8 3.2 Transportation................................................................................................................................................ 10 3.3 Economic Conditions ..................................................................................................................................... 22 3.4 Environment................................................................................................................................................... 25 3.5 Planned Freight-Relevant Transportation Improvements............................................................................... 27

4 Findings and Recommendations ............................................................................................... 29 4.1 Feedback from Public and Stakeholder Involvement Process ....................................................................... 29 4.2 Recommendations ......................................................................................................................................... 33

5 Conclusions and Next Steps ...................................................................................................... 42

6 Appendices ................................................................................................................................... 43 Appendix A. Local, Regional, and State Plans, Studies, and Programs Related to Freight ........................................ 43 Appendix B. Stakeholder Interviews ........................................................................................................................... 46 Appendix C. March 26, 2024 Freight Roundtable Meeting Attendance....................................................................... 47 Appendix D. September 9, 2024, Stakeholder Meeting Attendance ........................................................................... 47 Appendix E. Public Survey Questions and Response................................................................................................. 49

Paj 179

DOVER FREIGHT PLAN

Item #19.

List of Figures

Figure 1. 2019 Proposed Land Development Plan.........................................................................................................8 Figure 2. Potential Land Uses for Priority Annexation Areas and Delmarva Central Railroad line .................................9 Figure 3. National Highway Freight Network in Delaware ............................................................................................ 10 Figure 4. First/Final Mile Freight Connectors and freight intensive land uses .............................................................. 11 Figure 5. Freight network in Dover Area. ..................................................................................................................... 12 Figure 6. Congested Intersections and Corridors in Dover .......................................................................................... 14 Figure 7. 2022 Heavy Truck Traffic Volume Estimates on NHS Roads and Truck Traffic Bottlenecks ........................ 15 Figure 8. 2022 Heavy Truck Traffic as a Percent of All Traffic for NHS Roads ............................................................ 16 Figure 9. Crashes Involving Heavy Vehicles in the Dover Area, 2019-2021 ................................................................ 18 Figure 10. Total Crashes and Truck-Involved Crashes on SR 8, 2015–2019 .............................................................. 19 Figure 11. Undesignated Truck Parking Clusters ......................................................................................................... 20 Figure 12. 2020 Estimated Truck Trip Generation by Traffic Analysis Zone ................................................................ 23 Figure 13. Improvements Recommended by the Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Study – Planning and Environmental Linkage (PEL) Report................................................................................................................................................... 25 Figure 14. FEMA Special Flood Hazard Areas............................................................................................................. 26 Figure 15. City of Dover and Kent County Parcels identified for protection or preservation for freight intensive uses. 39

List of Tables

Table 1. Protect-Manage-Accommodate Framework for Contextualizing Freight Conflicts (adapted from the Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Final Report) ..........................................................................................5 Table 2. Key to the Numbers 1–5 in Figure 6 (adapted from the Kent County TOMP) ................................................ 14 Table 3. FY23–28 Capital Transportation Plan Projects Proposed in Dover ................................................................ 27 Table 4. Freight-Relevant Projects from the FY23–28 Capital Transportation Plan Proposed Near Dover ................. 28 Table 5. Development Review and Regulations Recommendations ............................................................................ 34 Table 6. Land Use Planning Recommendations .......................................................................................................... 38 Table 7. Communication and Coordination Recommendations ................................................................................... 41

Paj 180

Item #19.

Executive Summary Statewide freight plans are required by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). The 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan recommends providing local freight planning support to municipalities throughout Delaware. DelDOT is providing municipal assistance for local freight planning via statewide planning contracts in coordination with municipal representatives and Metropolitan Planning Organizations (MPOs). The City of Dover is the third municipality that DelDOT has worked with on local freight planning initiatives. The importance of local freight planning cannot be overstated; according to the Delaware State Freight Plan, 36% of employees in Kent County work in a Freight-Intensive Sector. Focused on the City of Dover, this report assists in identifying local freight related concerns based on feedback from agency stakeholders, freight operators, and members of the community. The recommendations within this report are intended to address these concerns within the freight network as well as evolving freight movement trends as e-commerce grows. The core objectives of this report are as follows: • Increase collaboration among government and industry stakeholders to address freight issues and concerns. • Build upon previous freight planning efforts. • Identify freight movement issues and develop recommendations to help protect, manage, and accommodate freight activity in the city of Dover. To achieve these objectives, a process was developed to ascertain the existing conditions of the study area as well as the needs and desires of the freight operators and communities they operate within. This process was characterized by the following work tasks: • Establishing a public/stakeholder engagement framework. • Assess the existing conditions utilizing applicable information and recommendations from prior and ongoing relevant planning efforts and historical knowledge of the study area informed by State, Dover Kent County MPO, WILMAPCO, and local documentation. o Review of current land use and development regulations in the city of Dover (i.e., zoning code, land subdivision regulations) as they relate and apply to freight- and rail-related land uses, freight movement, and freight parking. o Conduct a site visit to conduct parking counts and document locations frequently used for truck parking; truck routes, signage and geometric issues were also observed and documented. • Upon completion of assessment, this final report was prepared to convey both the analysis findings and the associated recommendations. Those recommendations are summarized by the table below:

Paj 181

Item #19.

Dover Freight Plan Recommendations Responsible Category Recommendation Description Parties Development 1A: Adopt truck parking Adopt development regulations requiring City of Dover Review & requirements developers to provide truck parking/staging Regulations as part of manufacturing, warehouse, and logistics developments.

1B: Implement freight Incorporate freight-specific planning Development considerations checklist considerations checklist into development review entities review processes. at all government levels

Land Use 2A: Protect existing Preserve opportunities for freight-intensive City of Dover Planning freight-intensive development in appropriate locations by and Kent development protecting parcels currently zoned for County opportunities along freight-generating uses along Dover’s truck routes. existing and future truck routes from rezoning.

2B: Create Create opportunities for freight-intensive City of Dover opportunities for freight- development in appropriate locations by and Kent intensive development pursuing rezoning for suitable parcels not County along Dover’s truck presently zoned for freight-intensive uses routes. along Dover’s existing and future truck routes.

Communication 3A: Improve Improve communication and coordination City of Dover, & Coordination intergovernmental between local, county, and state Kent County, coordination. government and MPO regarding freight- State of related land development and transportation Delaware projects.

3B: Improve Improve engagement with local freight City of Dover,
stakeholder operators to better address their needs Kent County,
coordination. during planning processes. State of
Delaware

3C: Revisit Dover Air Revisit the Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Dover Kent Cargo Freight Access Study – Planning and Environmental MPO, City of Study Linkage (PEL) Report (2021) to determine if Dover, Kent recommendations. recommendations need to be adjusted County, State based on leasing activity at Garrison Oak of Delaware Business and Technology Center.

Paj 182

Introduction and Background DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

1 Introduction and Background 1.1 STUDY AREA, SCOPE, PROJECT SPONSOR, AND STUDY TEAM The study area is the City of Dover. However, some recommendations also apply to Kent County. Broadly, the methodology and recommendations included in this report may be worth consideration by other municipalities in the State of Delaware that are interested in integrating freight planning with their comprehensive planning process. The study sponsor is the Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT). The study team consisted of representatives from the Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT), Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization (Dover Kent MPO), City of Dover, and the study consultant Whitman, Requardt and Associates, LLP. The scope of this planning effort was as follows:

  • •Confirm the scope of work, project limits, deliverables, and schedule with the study team.
  • •Hold monthly coordination meetings with the study team.
  • •Perform a desktop analysis to document the existing conditions.
  • •Prepare study area project mapping using readily available geospatial data.
  • •Conduct targeted outreach to city staff, public agencies, and industry stakeholders such as Dover Air Force Base, Central Delmarva Railroad, and local freight-related companies.
  • •Conduct a site visit to document on street truck parking.
  • •Develop preliminary recommendations.
  • •Prepare for and conduct a public workshop to present preliminary recommendations. Adjust the recommendations based on feedback received.
  • •Prepare a final report to document the findings.

Page 1 Page 182

Paj 183

Introduction and Background DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

1.2 PLANNING CONTEXT

This planning effort was undertaken as part of DelDOT’s local freight planning support initiative, which is identified as a short-term (1–4 years) implementation task in the 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan. 1 The purpose of this initiative is to assist municipalities in identifying and addressing localized freight issues, including:

  • •Safety and speed management
  • •Truck routing, signage, and guidance
  • •Comprehensive planning
  • •Truck parking and staging
  • •Curb management
  • •Freight environmental impacts
  • •Development regulations for freight facilities
  • •Community quality-of-life issues

1.3 OBJECTIVES

The objectives of this planning effort are to: 1. Increase collaboration among government and industry stakeholders to address freight issues and concerns. 2. Build upon previous freight planning efforts. 3. Identify freight movement issues and develop recommendations to help protect, manage, and accommodate freight activity in Dover. This plan is intended to be a resource for the City of Dover and DelDOT as they address freight issues and needs in planning and development review processes.

1.4 STUDY METHODOLOGY

This plan was developed using the following methods:

  • •Review of prior relevant planning efforts.
  • •Documentation and mapping of existing and anticipated future conditions.
  • •Obtaining stakeholder input via one-on-one interviews, an industry roundtable, and phone surveys.
  • •Development of recommendations based on analysis of existing conditions, findings informed by previous planning efforts, and feedback from stakeholders.
  • •Obtaining public input via public workshop and surveying.

1 Delaware Department of Transportation, 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan (Dover, Delaware: Delaware

Department of Transportation, 2022), page 6-18, https://deldot.gov/Business/freight/pdfs/2022/2022%20Delaware%20State%20Freight%20Plan%20Full.p df.

Page 2 Page 183

Paj 184

Introduction and Background DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

1.5 PRIOR RELEVANT PLANNING EFFORTS

This section includes an overview of prior planning efforts that relate to freight. A summary of additional plans that were reviewed in the preparation of this document, such as the 2019 Dover Comprehensive Plan, are included in Appendix A.

1.5.1 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan The 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan “assesses freight transportation system details, needs, and opportunities in order to identify key projects, strategies, and other planning-related actions that will maximize the efficiency and reliability of Delaware’s current and projected freight transportation networks…” 2 As noted above, the State Freight Plan recommended local freight planning as a short-term implementation task. The State Freight Plan will be updated in 2026 based on federal requirements for state freight plans as revised under the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) and as detailed per 49 U.S.C. §70202(e).

1.5.2 Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Final Report (August 2021) The Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Final Report presents an inventory of road segments in Delaware that serve as first/final mile (FFM) freight connectors. FFM freight connectors are road or street segments that connect mainline freight routes with freight handling facilities. Notable clusters of activity are usually found near manufacturing facilities, retail centers, distribution centers, warehouses, ports, intermodal terminals, and farms. Study results include a data-driven screening of a state-specific first/final mile roadway network, coupled with an evaluation of potential needs and issues based on five major categories of consideration: institutional, land use, mobility, safety, and condition. Planning recommendations included guidance and support for policies, partnerships, projects, and programs that would help to prioritize and improve the network.

2 Delaware Department of Transportation, 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan, 1–1.

Page 3 Page 184

Paj 185

Introduction and Background DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

The Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Final Report presents the Protect-Manage- Accommodate (PMA) framework, shown in Table 1, as a strategic lens that can help DelDOT and its planning partners “contextualize and prioritize which freight conflicts they wish to address.” 3 This framework may assist DelDOT and Dover in avoiding or mitigating conflicts between freight uses and other land uses as land development and transportation improvements occur. The PMA framework is a lens through which planners can view the interaction of freight movement and other land uses. It is a foundational concept that can be applied to addressing freight in a range of planning contexts, including the present plan. Recommendations presented in this plan were developed within the PMA framework.

1.5.3 Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Study – Planning and Environmental Linkage (PEL) Report (2021) This study analyzed potential roadway improvements in the area around the Central Delaware Aviation Complex (CDAC) and the Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center (GOBTC) and made recommendations for improvements to support truck access to these facilities.

1.5.4 Delaware Statewide Truck Parking Study (2021) This statewide study inventories all truck parking within the state (authorized and unauthorized) and explores needs and methods to improve truck parking availability. Results identify potential information and technology improvements and site-specific truck parking capacity improvements at existing and private sites, other state-owned facilities, and along roadway shoulders.

3 CPCS, Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Final Report, 2021, 15,

http://www.wilmapco.org/freight/First_Final_Mile_Final_Report.pdf.

Page 4 Page 185

Paj 186

Introduction and Background DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Table 1. Protect-Manage-Accommodate Framework for Contextualizing Freight Conflicts (adapted from the Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Final Report) “Protect” “Manage” “Accommodate” Protect freight Accommodate freight Manage conflicts in tactical and Definitions industries from needs to prevent major targeted ways unreasonable conflicts issues

Areas where freight Areas where non-freight industries are Areas where freight and non- businesses and/or Context dominant; also freight freight activities are both residential communities are facilities of high significant land uses dominant importance

Central business districts or Freight clusters Mixed-use areas small-town downtowns Examples Ports, airports, Freight clusters transitioning to “Stranded” freight facilities intermodal terminals mixed use (legacy facilities enveloped by communities)

The beneficiaries of The focus is thus on A balanced approach reflects efficient freight movement accommodating non- the reality that freight industries are not only transportation freight needs where may impose negative companies and large reasonable, while externalities on communities shippers, but also freight prioritizing support for (such as traffic and noise), but receivers such as homes, the competitiveness these industries may also businesses, and and productivity of the constitute significant restaurants. These Additional area’s commercial and businesses employing many of receivers rely on trucks for Notes industrial base. This the people in those same deliveries of everyday can require communities. If done well, goods. Therefore, ensuring considerable advance conflicts can be managed by the safety and mobility of all planning to prevent finding tactical, targeted, and road users, including local non-industrial creative solutions rather than trucks, is to everyone’s activities’ merely striving for compromise benefit, even in situations encroachment into between competing where freight mobility is not industrial areas. stakeholders. a prime policy objective.

Page 5 Page 186

Paj 187

Stakeholder and Public Involvement Process DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

2 Stakeholder and Public Involvement Process Public involvement is a process where feedback from various stakeholders is collected and organized to inform decision-making. It is a key component of the planning process; therefore, appropriate identification of internal and external stakeholders early in the study process is essential. Stakeholders in the freight community have historic knowledge and ongoing awareness of the conditions of the study area as well as the needs and desires of the freight community. A public involvement plan provides a framework for how stakeholders interact with both the planning process and decision-makers. The public involvement plan evolved throughout the project in response to feedback from agency partners and stakeholders, but included the following steps:

  • •Held a virtual meeting with agency representatives including Dover Kent MPO, City of Dover, and the Kent Economic Partnership (KEP) to confirm the goals and limitations of the project.
  • •Established a project webpage on DelDOT Interact to share information with stakeholders and the public, including hosting public workshop materials.
  • •Worked with the agency representatives to identify all relevant stakeholders and ascertain their interest in participating in the study process.
  • •Determined the best way to collect stakeholder input. Opted to hold individual interviews followed by a Freight Roundtable; these events were held in-person and virtually.
  • •Held an in-person stakeholder meeting to review preliminary recommendations.
  • •Held an in-person public open house where a presentation concerning the plan goals, parameters, and background where the public was able to provide feedback about concerns, opportunities, and other observations. All workshop materials were also posted to the project website.
  • •Presented at the October 27, 2024 Dover City Council Committee of the Whole meeting.
  • •Presented at the December 11, 2024 Winter Freight Meeting for feedback from agency stakeholders.
  • •Conducted a public survey with online and in print options. The survey was advertised at the public workshop and City Council meeting and distributed via email to project stakeholders.

2.1 STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS

Five individual interviews were conducted in the spring of 2024 with industry stakeholders where existing conditions, ongoing issues, and freight-related concerns were discussed. These interviewees represented the following organizations: Procter & Gamble, Dover Air Force Base (DAFB), Delmarva Central Railroad Company (DCR), Byler’s Store, and the Office of State Planning and Coordination (OSPC). According to these stakeholders there were overarching problems concerning connectivity and mobility across the transportation network, procedural hinderances relating to the development coordination process, and economic constraints. Interviewees also shared their hopes for future freight-operations and facilities. The interviewees and interview dates are included in Appendix B. For more information on the feedback received please see Section 4.1.1.

2.2 FREIGHT ROUNDTABLE

The Freight Roundtable Meeting was held on March 26, 2024, at the Dover Kent MPO Conference Room in Camden to solicit broad feedback on freight issues in the Dover area for both this planning effort and

Page 6 Page 187

Paj 188

Stakeholder and Public Involvement Process DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

the East-West Freight Route Feasibility Analysis Phase 2. DelDOT and Dover Kent MPO provided an overview of the goals and objectives of each study before an open discussion with attendees. Appendix C lists the meeting attendees. For more information on the feedback received please see Section 4.1.2

2.3 APPENDIX STAKEHOLDER MEETING

A stakeholder meeting was held on September 9, 2024, at the Dover Public Library to review the preliminary recommendations. DelDOT provided an overview the planning effort and reviewed previously identified challenges and opportunities. This meeting included a presentation showcasing preliminary recommendations. The main objectives of the meeting were as follows:

  • •Increase collaboration among government and industry stakeholders to address freight issues and concerns.
  • •Identify freight movement issues and refine recommendations to help protect, manage, and accommodate freight activity in Dover.
  • •Stakeholders were given the opportunity to discuss potential changes to recommendations as well as additional recommendations and issues to address. Appendix D lists the meeting attendees. For more information on the feedback received please see Section 4.1.3.

2.4 PUBLIC OPEN HOUSE AND SURVEY

DelDOT held a public Open House on October 29, 2024, at City of Dover City Hall. Public notice of the Open House was posted on the state’s public meeting calendar. Presentation materials were posted on the project website on the day of the workshop to allow those who could not attend the workshop to review the information presented and provide feedback. The objectives of the public workshop were to:

  • •Present the study background, existing conditions, and preliminary recommendations.
  • •Solicit feedback from the public on the preliminary recommendations. A public survey was conducted in conjunction with the Open House. Printed surveys and a QR code linking to the online survey were available at the Open House and on the project website from October 29, 2024, to November 29, 2024. There were three responses to the survey. The public was also invited to send written comments to DelDOT through November 29, 2024. Appendix E provides an overview of the survey questions and results. For more information on the feedback received please see Section 4.1.4.

2.5 DOVER CITY COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING

Following the Public Open House, the project team presented at the Dover City Council Committee of the Whole Meeting. The agenda, meeting packet (this includes the presentation), recording, and minutes from the meeting are available via the City of Dover online calendar. The project team reviewed the preliminary recommendations with Council. Council members had questions regarding the density of freight traffic, future connections to SR 1, and how to best communicate with freight operators regarding the designated freight routes. None of the comments received resulted in changes to the draft preliminary recommendations.

Page 7 Page 188

Paj 189

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

3 Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions 3.1 LAND USE Land use planning is central to fostering synergy between social and economic activities by establishing and regulating the appropriate use of a given property through zoning. Since zoning dictates what types of development (e.g. residential, commercial, manufacturing, etc.) can go where, it dictates the parts of the transportation network that freight has to travel. If not properly planned, freight movements and related land uses have the potential to adversely affect the environment, the supply chain, and quality of life for proximate residents.

3.1.1 Future Land Use Approximately 1,700 acres (approximately 2%) of the city are zoned for Manufacturing (M) or Industrial Park Manufacturing (IPM, IPM-2, IPM-3). This does not include the approximate 2,268-acre Dover Air Force Base (DAFB), which is zoned R-20 (One Family Residential). These zoning categories permit uses that frequently rely on freight to function. The Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan’s future land uses map is called the Land Development Plan. The Land Development Plan, shown in Figure 1, provides insight into where freight intensive sector (FIS) land uses are likely to remain or expand in the future. The following land use categories can accommodate some types of FIS uses: Active Agriculture, Commercial, Dover Air Force Base, and Industrial & Public Utilities. The distribution of these land use categories has implications for future freight volumes and movement patterns.

Figure 1. 2019 Proposed Land Development Plan (source: Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan)

Page 8 Page 189

Paj 190

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

3.1.2 Lands Proposed for Annexation The 2019 Dover Comprehensive Plan identifies parcels that are priorities for annexation and assigns future land use categories to these parcels. As shown in Figure 2, areas near the Central Delaware Aviation Complex (CDAC) and just north of the city along the rail line (including the former Dow Reichhold site, which has rail spurs) are identified for industrial uses. However, there are also areas along the rail line identified for medium-density residential use and mixed use. These uses may result in development that is not compatible with freight rail operations or with industrial development that uses the freight rail, as documented in the August 2022 Rail Corridor Land Use Study prepared by Dover Kent MPO and the Kent Economic Partnership.

Delmarva Central
Railroad line

Figure 2. Potential Land Uses for Priority Annexation Areas (source: Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan Map 13-2) and Delmarva Central Railroad line

Page 9 Page 190

Paj 191

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

3.2TRANSPORTATION
3.2.1Freight Routes
National Highway Freight Network
The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) created the
National Highway Freight Network (NHFN) designation “to
strategically direct Federal resources and policies toward
improved performance of highway portions of the U.S. freight
transportation system.” 4 The NHFN comprises the following four
roadway types:
  • •Primary Highway Freight System (PHFS): This is a network of highways identified as the most critical highway portions of the U.S. freight transportation system determined by measurable and objective national data.
  • •Other Interstate portions not on the PHFS (non-PHFS): These highways consist of the remaining portion of Interstate roads not included in the PHFS. These routes provide important continuity and access to freight transportation facilities.
  • •Critical Rural Freight Corridors (CRFCs): These are public roads not in an urbanized area which provide access and connection to the PHFS and the Interstate with other important ports, public transportation facilities, or other intermodal freight facilities.
  • •Critical Urban Freight Corridors (CUFCs): These are public roads in urbanized areas which provide access and connection to the PHFS and the Interstate with other ports, public transportation facilities, or other Figure 3. National Highway Freight intermodal transportation facilities. 5 Network in Delaware

Figure 3 shows the NHFN in the Dover area.

Interim National Multimodal Freight Network The Delmarva Central Railroad (DCR) is a short line freight railroad on the Interim National Multimodal Freight Network. 6 The main trunk of the DCR is the Delmarva Secondary line, which has an interchange with Norfolk Southern Railroad in Porter, Delaware. As shown in Figure 2, the Delmarva Secondary line runs north-south through west Dover, with spurs connecting to the industrial parcels (Kraft-Heinz, Procter & Gamble, DCO Energy) on the southwest corner of the US 15-P.O.W./M.I.A. Parkway intersection.

4 U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration, “National Highway Freight

Network,” FHWA Operations, July 12, 2023, https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/freight/infrastructure/nfn/index.htm. 5 Ibid. 6 U.S. Department of Transportation, “Interim National Multimodal Freight Network State Maps and

Tables,” U.S. Department of Transportation, September 11, 2019,
https://www.transportation.gov/freight/INMFNTables.

Page 10 Page 191

Paj 192

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

The 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan identifies the Delmarva Secondary line as an area of opportunity to expand the usage of short line rail in Delaware. 7

Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network The 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan notes that FFM freight connectors are among the road segments most likely to be affected by roadway deterioration due to heavy truck traffic. The plan identifies several avenues through which DelDOT can better coordinate with other public sector agencies to identify where improvements are needed on the FFM freight network. One avenue is to provide municipal freight planning support to “assist towns with determining routes that are appropriate for heavy vehicles.” 8 Figure 4 shows FFM freight connectors in Dover as identified by the Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Final Report. To provide context for the FFM freight connectors, the map also shows freight-intensive land uses as depicted in the Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan.

Figure 4. First/Final Mile Freight Connectors and freight intensive land uses

7 Delaware Department of Transportation, 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan, page 4-8. 8 Ibid., D-10.

Page 11 Page 192

Paj 193

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Locally Designated Truck Routes Dover also has locally designated truck routes. Chapter 106, Article III, §106-17 of the Dover Code of Ordinances identifies the routes. Commercial vehicles with three or more axles cannot operate on any city streets other than the designated truck routes unless they are making local deliveries or pickups, or if another exception listed in §106-17(c) is applicable. In February 2024, Dover City Council approved an ordinance to revise the city’s designated truck routes. The revised truck routes are shown in Figure 5.

Figure 5. Freight network in Dover Area.

Page 12 Page 193

Paj 194

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Freight Rail The Delmarva Central Railroad short line freight rail line runs north-south through western Dover. Kraft- Heinz and Delmarva Corrugated Packaging use DCR’s freight rail service via the sidings on their property. Other companies including Procter & Gamble have sidings on their property that they no longer use. There are several other large parcels zoned for manufacturing or industrial park manufacturing along the DCR line that do not have sidings. These parcels can be seen in Figure 1 and Figure 2. These parcels are interspersed with parcels zoned and developed for residential use. The proximity between residential and industrial land uses can lead to complaints by residents regarding industrial and freight impacts such as noise and emissions, which makes it more challenging for industrial firms to continue operating or new industrial developments to be approved. Dover Kent MPO’s 2018 Rail Zoning Study and 2022 Rail Corridor Land Use Study recommends preserving parcels zoned for FIS uses along the DCR line and creating a minimum setback for non-FIS uses along the DCR line. These actions are recommended to minimize conflict between non-FIS uses, minimize conflict between FIS uses and the rail line itself, and to preserve opportunities for future expansion of freight-rail-supported uses. Dover and Kent County have an interest in preserving rail freight operations and rail-freight-supported development opportunities because rail freight has several benefits over truck freight, such as reducing truck traffic, greenhouse gas emissions, and wear and tear on roadways. 9 To that end, the 2022 Rail Corridor Land Use Study also identifies parcels that are potentially suitable for freight-rail-supported uses in Appendix B of that document.

3.2.2 Traffic Volumes and Congestion Prior DelDOT planning efforts and analysis has identified congestion hotspots in Dover for automobile traffic in general and freight trucks in particular. The 2021 Kent County Transportation Operations Management Plan (TOMP) identifies Dover as one of three congestion “hotspots” in the county; Camden and northern Milford are the other two hotspots. The TOMP defines congestion hotspots as areas where congestion keeps drivers from reaching their destinations on time. Figure 6, from the TOMP, shows intersections with LOS D or lower and congested corridors in Dover. Table 2 provides a key to the numbers 1–5 shown in Figure 6. These numbers correspond to actions (either in the pipeline or recommended) to mitigate congestion in the hotspot. 10

9 Reed Macmillan, Mike Ward, and Catherine Samardza, Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning

Organization Rail Zoning Study: An Assessment of Municipal Comprehensive Plans and Future Land Uses for Rail Freight Related Manufacturing/Employment Centers in Kent County, Delaware (Camden, Delaware: Dover/Kent County MPO, 2018), 19, https://doverkentmpo.delaware.gov/files/2018/11/Final- Rail-Study-November-14-NOV-18-FINAL-version.pdf. 10 Rybinski Engineering and Delaware Department of Transportation, Kent County Transportation

Operations Management Plan Report (Dover, Delaware: Delaware Department of Transportation, 2021), 16, https://deldot.gov/Programs/itms/pdfs/Kent-County-TOMP-Report.pdf.

Page 13 Page 194

Paj 195

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Figure 6. Congested Intersections and Corridors in Dover (source: Kent County TOMP)

Table 2. Key to the Numbers 1–5 in Figure 6 (adapted from the Kent County TOMP) Map ID Mitigating action Timeframe 1 Conducting a needs study on SR 8. DelDOT and Dover Kent MPO Project in the pipeline will conduct a needs study on SR 8 to help pinpoint causes of (expected completion congestion and make recommendations accordingly. date: 2025)

2 Improving the intersection of SR 8 and SR 15. Adding a through Project in the pipeline lane on SR 15 should relieve congestion at this intersection. (expected completion date: 2023)

3 Kenton Road and College Road corridor updates. Capacity Project in the pipeline upgrades will be considered along Kenton Road and College Road (expected completion as development continues to build up around them. date: 2027)

4Consider a two-stage pedestrian crossing at the intersection ofShort-term
US 13 and White Oak Rd. A two-stage pedestrian crossing wouldrecommendation
improve operations through the intersection. This improvement was
already evaluated and recommended from a safety perspective in
DelDOT’s June 2020 US 13 Pedestrian Safety Study.

5 Allow left turns from Centre Dr onto US 13. This would alleviate Medium-term stress at the intersection of White Oak Rd and US 13. recommendation

Page 14 Page 195

Paj 196

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Figure 7 and Figure 8 illustrate estimated truck traffic volumes and congestion in the Dover area. Figure 7 shows estimated daily heavy truck traffic volumes in 2022 on roads National Highway System (NHS) 11 roads and freight truck bottlenecks. Figure 8 shows the 2022 estimated truck traffic volumes as a percent of 2022 traffic volumes for all vehicles. The truck traffic data comprises unit trucks (FHWA Classes 5–7) and combination trucks (FHWA Class 8 and above). These estimates are derived from the National Performance Management Research Data Set.

Figure 7. 2022 Heavy Truck Traffic Volume Estimates on NHS Roads and Truck Traffic Bottlenecks (sources: National Performance Management Research Data Set and the 2022 Delaware Statewide Truck Bottleneck Analysis)

11 The NHS comprises all interstate highways as well as other roads that are important for national

mobility, defense, and the economy. Additional information is available at https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/planning/national_highway_system/nhs_maps/.

Page 15 Page 196

Paj 197

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Figure 8. 2022 Heavy Truck Traffic as a Percent of All Traffic for NHS Roads (source: National Performance Management Research Data Set)

Page 16 Page 197

Paj 198

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

The 2022 Delaware Statewide Truck Bottleneck Analysis 12 identified and ranked 15 NHS road segments throughout the state where congestion and delays significantly affect freight mobility and reliability. The data used to identify and rank the bottlenecks included:

  • •Travel Reliability (based on volume-to-capacity and related level-of-service estimates for the average weekday AM peak, weekday PM peak, and summer peak)
  • •Daily Truck Traffic Volume (unit trucks [FHWA Classes 5–7] and combination trucks [Class 8 and above])
  • •Daily Truck Traffic Percentage
  • •Daily Truck Trip Generation (based on zone estimates using employment details)
  • •Type of Route (based on NHFN, NHS, and other state-specific elements)
  • •Crash Impacts (based on intersection safety details or rankings) 13 As shown in Figure 7, the 2022 analysis identified two moderate-priority bottlenecks and one low-priority bottleneck in Dover. During public outreach for this study, none of the freight stakeholders identified issues traveling these bottleneck corridors. Section 3.5.1 of this memorandum lists freight-relevant projects included in DelDOT’s FY23-28 Capital Transportation Program (CTP) that are proposed in the Dover area. Two of the projects (HEP KC, SR 8 and SR 15 Intersection Improvements and HEP, KC, US13, Lochmeath Way to Puncheon Run Connector) may help alleviate two of the Dover truck bottlenecks.

East-West Truck Movement The Kent County East-West Truck Freight Route Feasibility Analysis Phase I (East-West Truck Route Analysis Phase I) reviews east-west freight truck traffic patterns and needs in Kent County west of SR 1. The study provides recommendations to improve traffic flow on key east-west freight corridors, including SR 8. The East-West Truck Route Analysis Phase I notes, out of the corridors included in the analysis, SR 8 has the most traffic signals, at 18 signals. 14 All but two of the traffic signals are in Dover. 15 This large number of traffic signals as well as the high vehicle and pedestrian traffic in downtown Dover, subsequently makes SR 8 less than ideal for truck traffic. Nevertheless, non-local truck traffic likely 16 travels through downtown Dover on SR 8 because SR 8 is one of the county’s limited east-west truck route options. The East-West Truck Route Analysis Phase I recommends developing an alternate truck route around downtown Dover. It notes that the planned Camden Bypass project (which will construct a bypass for SR 10 around Camden’s downtown) will provide an alternative east-west route through the Dover area that

12 “2022 Delaware Statewide Truck Bottleneck Analysis,” 2022,

http://www.wilmapco.org/freight/2022_DE_Bottlenecks_Summary.pdf. 13 Delaware Department of Transportation, 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan, D-11. 14 Kent Economic Partnership, Dover/Kent County MPO, and Whitman, Requardt & Associates, LLP,

Kent County East-West Truck Freight Route Feasibility Analysis Phase I, 2021, 5, https://doverkentmpo.delaware.gov/files/2023/01/E-W-Truck-Study-final-11-2022-WEB.pdf. 15 Ibid., 47. 16 There are currently no publicly available data regarding the proportion of truck traffic on SR 8 or other

streets in downtown Dover that is through traffic (as opposed to trucks making local deliveries or pickups). Therefore, the extent of the impact of through truck traffic on downtown Dover is unclear.

Page 17 Page 198

Paj 199

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

avoids Dover’s and Camden’s downtowns. 17 This may help direct through truck traffic away from downtown Dover, since diverting to the bypass may be preferable to driving a large truck through a downtown area. Dover Kent MPO began work on Phase II of the KEP-sponsored Kent County East/West Truck Freight Route Feasibility Analysis in FY 2024. Final recommendation will be presented to the public at the MPO PAC and TAC meetings in June 2025, and the MPO Council in July 2025. Final recommendations will be presented at the Delaware Freight Summit in June.

3.2.3 Crashes Figure 9 shows crashes involving heavy vehicles in the Dover area during 2019–2021 overlaid on the NHFN and FFM Freight Network. During this period, the percentage of crashes in Dover that involved heavy vehicles (0.2% or 13 18 heavy vehicle crashes out of 6,055 total crashes) was close to the percentage for Kent County (0.3% or 62 heavy vehicle crashes out of 18,644 total crashes).

Figure 9. Crashes Involving Heavy Vehicles in the Dover Area, 2019-2021

17 Kent Economic Partnership, Dover/Kent County MPO, and Whitman, Requardt & Associates, LLP,

Kent County East-West Truck Freight Route Feasibility Analysis Phase I, 29. 18 The crash shown at East Division Street and Acorn Street occurred in unincorporated Kent County and

is therefore not included in this count.

Page 18 Page 199

Paj 200

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

The East-West Truck Route Analysis Phase I provides crash information for SR 8 during 2015–2019. As shown in Figure 10, most truck crashes that occurred on SR 8 during this period occurred in Dover.

Figure 10. Total Crashes and Truck-Involved Crashes on SR 8, 2015–2019 (source: Kent County East- West Truck Freight Route Feasibility Analysis Phase I)

3.2.4 Truck Parking Analysis conducted for the Delaware Statewide Truck Parking Study Final Report (Truck Parking Study) identified five undesignated truck parking clusters in the Dover area, which are shown in Figure 11. The 2023 Dover Kent MPO Truck Parking Amenities Study states that Dover Mall’s parking lot is another undesignated truck parking location.

Page 19 Page 200

Paj 201

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Figure 11. Undesignated Truck Parking Clusters (source: Delaware Statewide Truck Parking Study Final Report)

Page 20 Page 201

Paj 202

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Multiple types of truck parking are required to meet the different parking needs of drivers. Truck parking needs include parking for drivers who are waiting to make pickups or drop-offs at a facility that is not yet open or does not have an available loading berth and parking for drivers taking breaks and rest periods which are required by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Association’s Hours of Service (HOS) requirements. To provide truck drivers with adequate rest and recuperation so that they can continue to work safely, truck parking facilities need to provide a variety of amenities. Key amenities include security features like lighting and cameras, bathrooms with showers, fuel, food options, supplies (e.g., toiletries, batteries) for purchase, and Wi-Fi. Other useful amenities are laundry facilities, lounges or break rooms, and auxiliary power units (APUs), which can used to run temperature control systems in refrigerated trucks or truck cabins without requiring the driver to keep their engine running. 19 For a more thorough review of truck amenities, please refer to the 2023 Dover Kent MPO Truck Parking Amenities Study. Another truck parking issue identified by the city of Dover is that Dover residents who own commercial trucks sometimes park them on residential streets. This indicates a need for truck storage lots where truck owners can park their trucks when they are at home. Since these lots would be used for truck storage rather than for drivers to take breaks and rest periods, they would not need to be equipped with the same amenities as a short-term or overnight truck parking facility where the driver stays with their truck. The Truck Parking Study also identifies potential opportunities for additional truck parking. Opportunities in the Dover area are as follows:

  • •Dover Toll Plaza o The study recommends incorporating protected roadside truck parking into planned upgrades to the Dover Toll Plaza, which is by the northernmost undesignated truck parking cluster shown in Figure 11. 20
  • •Existing capital project planning and development along SR 1 o The study states that Dover Kent MPO “is currently studying opportunities to develop a frontage road…to connect existing and planned industrial parks along SR 1” in Dover; suggests that DelDOT consider integrating truck parking into the potential project. 21
  • •Intersection of US 13 and SR 10 in Camden o The study suggests adding truck parking on state-owned land on the southeast corner of this intersection. 22
  • •New freight-generating facilities o The study suggests that DelDOT should incentivize or require private development of new truck parking capacity at new freight-generating facilities in Dover. 23
  • •Dover International Speedway and Dover Downs parking lots

19 Kent Economic Partnership and Dover/Kent County MPO, Truck Parking Amenities Study, 2023, 14–

22, https://doverkentmpo.delaware.gov/files/2023/03/Truck-Parking-Amenities-Final-3.2023.pdf. 20 CPCS and Century Engineering, Delaware Statewide Truck Parking Study Final Report, 2021, 35,

http://www.wilmapco.org/freight/DE_Truck_Parking_Final.pdf.
21 Ibid., 35–36.
22 Ibid., 37.
23 Ibid., 38.

Page 21 Page 202

Paj 203

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

o The study states that these lots could be used for truck parking during the businesses’ non-peak periods, including overnight. 24 In the spring of 2023, DelDOT added signage and striping for short-term truck parking at five DelDOT/DTC parking lots. One of the truck parking sites is at the DMV in Dover. In the fall of 2023, DelDOT reported that this site was minimally used.

Town Code Sections Related to Freight Truck Parking and Loading/Unloading Chapter 106 of the Dover Code of Ordinances addresses traffic and vehicles including truck traffic and loading/unloading. The code sections relevant to stopping, loading, and unloading of delivery trucks include the following:

  • •Article III, §106-122 prohibits vehicles from parking on city streets for longer than 25 minutes to load or unload freight.
  • •Article III, §106-123(a) prohibits vehicles with a carrying capacity of more than one ton, trailers, or any combination thereof from parking on city streets for longer than two consecutive hours.
  • •Article III, §106-123(b) prohibits commercial vehicles with a carrying capacity of more than one ton, trailers, or any combination thereof from parking “in any residential zone in the city except for temporary parking for immediate deliveries, pickups, and/or service calls to residences or for construction work on residential properties.”

3.3 ECONOMIC CONDITIONS

3.3.1 Daily Truck Trip Generation Figure 12 shows Traffic Analysis Zones (TAZs) in the Dover area by the estimated number of daily unit truck and combination truck trips they generate. A TAZ “is a special area delineated by state and/or local transportation officials for tabulating traffic-related data- especially journey-to-work and place-of-work statistics. A TAZ usually consists of one or more census blocks, block groups, or census tracts.” 25 The truck trip generation estimates were produced for the 2022 Delaware Statewide Truck Bottleneck Analysis. They were calculated using methodologies derived from FHWA’s 2017 Quick Response Freight Manual II and 2015 household and employment data. Note that some of the high-truck trip generation TAZs are not industrial areas. This is because the truck trip counts include trucks returning from delivering goods to other land uses, such as houses and stores. They may also include trips by service or utility trucks that are not carrying freight.

24 Ibid., 38–39.
25 State of Delaware, “Delaware Traffic Analysis Zones 2.0,” 2023,

https://hub.arcgis.com/datasets/delaware::delaware-traffic-analysis-zones-2-0/about.

Page 22 Page 203

Paj 204

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Figure 12. 2020 Estimated Truck Trip Generation by Traffic Analysis Zone (source: Kent County East- West Truck Freight Route Feasibility Analysis Phase 1) The Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan notes that industrial uses on the west side of Dover have good truck connectivity to SR 1 via McKee/Saulsbury Road, a locally designated truck route, and to US 13 via the P.O.W./M.I.A. Parkway. 26

Dover Air Force Base Dover is home to the Dover Air Force Base (DAFB). As the Department of Defense’s (DOD) largest aerial port, 27 DAFB is an important freight facility for the US Air Force. Additionally, DelDOT had a 25-year-long joint use agreement (JUA) with the DOD to use DAFB runways for civilian flights. Civil aircraft operations

26 City of Dover, Delaware, City of Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan (Dover, Delaware: City of Dover,

2020), page 9-5, https://redclay.wra.udel.edu/wpplan/wp- content/Plans/Dover/Dover%202019%20Comprehensive%20Plan%20Adopted%201-13- 2020%20Complete.pdf. 27 United States Air Force, “About Us,” Dover Air Force Base, accessed November 17, 2023,

https://www.dover.af.mil/About-Us/.

Page 23 Page 204

Paj 205

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

are managed at the CDAC, formerly known as the Civil Air Terminal (CAT), 28 which is next to DAFB and is accessed via Horsepond Road. 29 The CDAC is owned by DelDOT and operated by the Delaware River and Bay Authority (DRBA). 30 The 25-year-long JUA between DelDOT and the DOD expired in December 2022. DelDOT and Dover Air Force Based signed a new JUA on Thursday, August 15, 2024 with a lease term of 50 years. It expands use of DAFB facilities for approved civilian and commercial flight operations, allowing for double the number of annual flight operations that were allowed at the CDAC under the previous lease agreement. 31

Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center The Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center (GOBTC) is located east of SR 1 and north of White Oak Road and can be accessed from White Oak Road. The GOBTC has its own zoning category: IPM-2 (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone – Business and Technology Center). According to the Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan, 4 of the GOBTC’s 15 lots have been developed. 32 As of the completion of this plan, all of the remaining lots are under contract. The GOBTC, CDAC, and Kent County AeroPark (located west of the CDAC) do not have direct access to SR 1 and can only be accessed via local roads that were not designed for heavy truck traffic. 33 For instance, the shortest route between GOBTC and SR 1 requires driving on Acorn Lane, which is a local residential street. This limits the City’s ability to attract industrial establishments. The 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan identifies the impact of GOBTC- and CDAC-related truck traffic on local roads as an area of concern. 34 The Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Study – Planning and Environmental Linkage (PEL) Report identified potential roadway projects to better connect CDAC and GOBTC to SR 1. These projects can encourage more economic activity at the facilities and support the increased activity that may result from the new JUA between DelDOT and the DOD. The recommended projects are listed below and shown in Figure 13.

  • •Extension of Horsepond Road from S. Little Creek Road to White Oak Road o Included in DelDOT’s FY23–28 Capital Transportation Program (CTP) under the name “Garrison Oak Connector Road (SR 1 via White Oak Road)”
  • •Improvements to existing Horsepond Road
  • •Improvements to existing Lafferty Lane
  • •Extension of Starlifter Avenue from Galaxy Drive to S. Little Creek Road

28 According to the Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan, the CDAC comprises the CAT and a portion of the

Kent County Aeropark. 29 Delaware Department of Transportation, 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan, D-32. 30 Delaware River and Bay Authority, “Civil Air Terminal (CAT),” accessed November 17, 2023,

http://www.catatdover.com/. 31 Phillips, Mike, “DelDOT and DAFB sign joint use agreement,” WDEL, August 16, 2024,

https://www.wdel.com/news/deldot-and-dafb-sign-joint-use-agreement/article_453abe6a-5bd8-11ef-8ab0- 87c6c73fee4c.html (Accessed January 8, 2025). 32 City of Dover, Delaware, Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan, page 5-14. 33 Dover/Kent County MPO and Century Engineering, Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Study – Planning

and Environmental Linkage (PEL) Report, 2021, 5, https://doverkentmpo.delaware.gov/files/2021/09/Dover-Air-Cargo-Freight-Study-PEL_final.pdf. 34 Delaware Department of Transportation, 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan, page 4-6.

Page 24 Page 205

Paj 206

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Figure 13. Improvements Recommended by the Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Study – Planning and Environmental Linkage (PEL) Report

3.4 ENVIRONMENT

As the understanding of environmental science improves, there are growing concerns about both air and water quality, public health, land use and development patterns leading to an emphasis on freight transportation projects. Environmental considerations are critical in planning and designing freight projects. Moreover, environmental resources can affect and inversely be affected by all aspects of freight transportation; this includes the location of freight-related facilities, the movement of goods, vehicle performance, and energy use.

3.4.1 FEMA Flood Hazard Areas Dover contains several bodies of water, each of which is flanked by Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)-designated special flood hazard areas, as shown in Figure 14. Flooding events and their negative impact on freight movement will continue to increase in severity and frequency due to climate change. Some of Dover’s FFM connectors and portions of Dover’s freight rail are in flood hazard areas.

Page 25 Page 206

Paj 207

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Figure 14. FEMA Special Flood Hazard Areas

Page 26 Page 207

Paj 208

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

3.5 PLANNED FREIGHT-RELEVANT TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENTS

3.5.1 DelDOT Capital Transportation Plan Projects in the Dover Area DelDOT’s FY23–28 Capital Transportation Program (CTP) includes several capital projects in the Dover area that may have an impact on freight movement. The projects are listed in Table 3 (projects in Dover) and Table 4 (projects near Dover). The hyperlinks provided in the tables are to the projects’ website when available; otherwise, the hyperlink is to the project’s page in the CTP. Table 3. FY23–28 Capital Transportation Plan Projects Proposed in Dover Construction Start Project Name, Hyperlink, Description Date / End Date Winter (January– Kenton Road, SR 8 to Chestnut Grove Road (project website). This project will March) 2024 / Fall provide pedestrian and bicycle facilities and operational and safety improvements. 2025 Senator Bikeway Phase III, Mifflin Road to DHS (project website). This project Spring 2024 / will include the design and construction of a bike/ped pathway along RT8 from Summer 2024 Mifflin Road to Dover High School. SR8, Connector from Commerce Way to SR8 (CTP). This project proposes a FY 2025 / FY 2026 new connector road from SR 8 to Commerce Way. The connector will consist of two travel lanes with accommodations for bicycles and sidewalks and/or multi-use paths for pedestrians. College Road, Kenton Road to McKee Road (CTP). The proposed FY 2027 / TBD improvements of this project consist of widening for shoulders, sidewalk, or multi- use path on both sides of College Road; and intersection improvements to accommodate bicycles and drainage improvements. Some utility relocations will be necessary, as well as acquisition of right-of-way and easements. Additionally, the entire roadway will be overlaid with new pavement. West Street, New Burton Road to North Street (CTP). This project will widen FY 2027 / TBD West Street to urban collector standards. Garrison Oak Connector Road (SR 1 via White Oak Road) (CTP). This project TBD/TBD will provide a new 2-lane connector road between White Oak Road and Little Creek Road, which will improve GOBTC’s connectivity to SR 1. Phase 1 includes the design, engineering, land acquisition, and construction of a connector road from GOBTC at White Oak Road. This connection would make access from GOBTC more efficient and competitive for business. TBD/TBD (construction will HEP, KC,* US13, Lochmeath Way to Puncheon Run Connector (project not begin until website). This project will widen to provide a third through lane in each direction on construction of the US 13 from Lochmeath Way to the Puncheon Run Connector. East and West Camden Bypasses is complete) Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. Safety Improvements, River Rd. to Bay Rd. TBD/TBD (project website). This project is planned to improve safety and operational

Page 27 Page 208

Paj 209

Existing and Anticipated Future Conditions DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Construction Start Project Name, Hyperlink, Description Date / End Date improvements along Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. from River Road to Bay Road. This project was nominated by the 2019 Hazard Elimination Program. SR 1, Scarborough Road C-D Roads. This project will construct a new collector- TBD/TBD distributor road from the SR 1-Scarborough Road interchange to Dover Mall. Dover Kent MPO’s FY23–26 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) provides the following project justification: “This project will relieve congestion on US 13, improve safety for multi-modal movements throughout the area and encourage economic development.” 35 At the time of writing, this project was not listed on DelDOT’s Projects Portal or in the FY23–28 CTP Book. *HEP = DelDOT Hazard Elimination Program; KC = Kent County

Table 4. Freight-Relevant Projects from the FY23–28 Capital Transportation Plan Proposed Near Dover Construction Start Project Name / Projects Portal Hyperlink, DelDOT Project Description Date / End Date East Camden Bypass (project website). This project will provide a new connection Summer 2024 / from US 13 to Lebanon Road (SR 10) and Rising Sun Road. Summer 2026 Winter (January– West Camden Bypass (project website). This project will provide a new March) 2025 / connection from Willow Grove Road and South Street to US 13. Winter (January– March) 2026 Winter (January– HEP KC,* SR15/Kenton Rd. at Central Church Rd. Intersection Improvements March) 2025 / Fall (project website). This project will construct a roundabout. 2025 Rehabilitation of Bridges 2-356B&C on SR10 Lebanon Road (project website). Spring 2025 / This project will rehabilitate two bridges and add a bike lane. Spring 2026 SR8 & Chestnut Grove - Nault Rd. Intersection Improvements (project TBD/TBD website). This project is planned to either expand the existing signalized intersection to include auxiliary lanes or replace the signalized intersection with a roundabout. This project was nominated by the 2020 Hazard Elimination Program. HEP KC,* US13 Walnut Shade Rd. to Lochmeath Way (project website). This TBD/TBD project involves the addition of a third lane in each direction on US 13 from south of Walnut Shade Road to Lochmeath Way. This will require roadway widening, stormwater management facilities, multiple intersection redesigns, traffic signal reconfigurations, and multi-modal improvements. *HEP = DelDOT Hazard Elimination Program; KC = Kent County

35 Dover/Kent County MPO, Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization Two-Year

Transportation Improvement Program Fiscal Years 2023-2026 and 2024-2027 (Camden, Delaware: Dover/Kent County MPO, 2022), A-10, https://doverkentmpo.delaware.gov/files/2022/04/FY2023-2026- DOVER-KENT-MPO-FULL-TIP-DRAFT-5-4-2022-1.pdf.

Page 28 Page 209

Paj 210

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

DelDOT’s draft FY25–30 CTP includes two new project candidates in Dover: 1. Banning Street and Clarence Street between Forest Street and W. North Street Improvements: Design and construct new two-lane street connection with sidewalks (between Slaughter Street and Forest Street). Upgrade existing segment to match (between W. North Street and Slaughter Street). 2. US 13 at White Oak Road Intersection Improvements: Add a two-stage pedestrian crossing system.

4 Findings and Recommendations DelDOT drew on stakeholder input, existing conditions data, and relevant freight planning best practices to develop preliminary recommendations that can be incorporated into future municipal freight studies, local comprehensive planning, capital planning, operations and maintenance, and intergovernmental coordination.

4.1 FEEDBACK FROM PUBLIC AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT PROCESS

4.1.1 Individual Interviews The following bullets summarize the feedback provided during interviews with freight stakeholders held in spring of 2024.

  • •Connectivity/mobility: o According to the OSPC, there are issues related to freight circulation in Dover’s downtown though the streets are locally maintained and therefore not eligible for federal funding. Streets must be able to accommodate the size of trucks while not inducing additional freight trips since the community would like to prevent through freight traffic. o Procter & Gamble shared issues associated with connectivity and mobility for east-west (freight) movements. Trucks that are heading west must go east due to freight restrictions. This also requires trucks to traverse areas with a considerable number of streetlights and additional congestion present in the area. o Representatives from Procter & Gamble intend on improving both connectivity and mobility by designating their East Dover site for coordination and logistics. o Matt Jordan from the Dover Air Force Base shared that they are working with the state to raise Route 9 between DAFB and Port Mahon Road to address flooding issues around Little Creek. o Per Lyn Byler, there is a need for a new connector road between the Garrison Oak Technology Park, located off of White Oak Road, and SR 1. Currently, the most direct access to SR 1 is via Acorn Lane to the interchanges located on N. Little Creek Road [Acorn Road is a narrow residential street]. The only route with streets intended to handle freight is via SR 13 which is very indirect route. A new freight connector road between White Oak Road and N. Little Creek Road has been proposed in multiple transportation planning efforts, however it is still years from construction, which reflects a bigger issue in planning efforts as it relates to freight.
  • •Procedural Hinderances o According to truck drivers at Procter & Gamble, there is a consensus that freight facilities are crowded rather than the surrounding roads. This is reinforced by the fact that freight

Page 29 Page 210

Paj 211

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

volumes have shown a steady growth rate for the past 10-15 years, yet the supporting facilities have not expanded. Despite this and the overwhelming importance of the freight industry, there is a current shortage of CDL drivers that will only become more apparent when compounded with the current growth in the freight industry. o There is a need for increased collaboration between government and industry stakeholders. As it stands, there is not a way to communicate the needs of the freight community. For example, Cliff Grunstra from the Delmarva Central Railroad (DCR) shared his surprise that rail is not frequently used to move freight from Dover considering there are large industrial and manufacturing facilities located along the rail line that do not currently use rail service. o According to Grunstra, the DCR is limited by the lack of development opportunities along the rail corridor. Moreover, acquiring new clients presents a challenge because it takes a minimum of 6 months to construct siding for a new business. There are also difficulties finding contractors to do the construction. Railroad regulations often supersede local, county, and state requirements; however, DCR would like to collaborate with the county to develop a mechanism to preserve land along the rail corridor, potentially similar to Delaware’s Agricultural Lands (Aglands) Preservation Program. o Matt Jordan shared that all materials outgoing and incoming to the base are transported via trucks. However, there are economic limitations to this arrangement because personnel are required to be in place at admittance checkpoints. This is a challenge because not all parts of the base are operational around the clock. • Development Coordination o The group concurred that the City of Dover was phenomenal to work with during the site development process because they reviewed and granted approvals quickly. Some interviewees noted that DelDOT’s development coordination process caused delays because they were required to redraw and resubmit plans, which was unnecessary from the perspective of the interviewee.

4.1.2 March 26, 2024, Freight Roundtable

The following bullets summarize concerns mentioned by industry stakeholders during the March 26, 2024, Freight Roundtable.

  • •Mobility: o Due to the public’s disapproval of trucks in their downtown areas, operators must navigate around the downtown area which is difficult because there are no alternate direct east-west routes. o Truck routing has been affected by GPS routing applications. o Truck operators cited an aversion to navigating the Dover area due to traffic and congestion. As a result, truckers habitually use Route 10 instead of Route 1 whenever possible.
  • •Loading/unloading: o When the roads are adversely affected by weather conditions truck operators are not able to reach the appropriate facilities for loading and unloading. To load materials, they are forced to load their trucks from the road. This presents safety concerns considering many roads do not have shoulders.
  • •Street geometry: o Industry stakeholders cited an inability to navigate roundabouts requiring drivers to traverse the circle which may result in damaging the infrastructure [note: roundabouts are designed with truck aprons which are a raised concrete area between the edge of the

Page 30 Page 211

Paj 212

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

asphalt and center of the roundabout; the truck apron is designed to accommodate the turning radius of trucks]. o Truck operators shared an inability to complete their routes because local roads are not able to manage truck traffic. In these scenarios, stakeholders cited the benefits of utilizing rail when possible. • Additional comments: o Delaware relies heavily on the poultry industry with roundtable members stating, “If we lose it, we’re done,” which points to a need to sustain the poultry industry. o Each rail car hauls roughly 3 tractor trailers worth of goods. o Kent County Code has a provision that if a business uses a rail siding it is automatically considered industrial. A local farm (considered an agricultural use) is interested in using the siding, which would keep thousands of trucks off the road. This was shared by KEP, the Agricultural Bureau, and Dover Kent MPO. o A few signalized intersections on a straight path may be preferrable to an “out of the way” detours. o Rural Maryland roads all have shoulders while Delaware roads do not, it is not advisable to go through Magnolia. o Eden Hill is very close to an existing rail meaning land cannot be used for freight purposes. o There was a conversation around whether SR 10 would be a good freight connection; industry stakeholders expressed interest. It was noted that DAFB expressed interest in a connection to the rail.

4.1.3 September 9, 2024, Stakeholder Meeting A stakeholder meeting was held on September 9, 2024. Attendees were given the opportunity to discuss potential changes to preliminary recommendations, provide their own recommendations, and report on additional concerns. Several comments were provided regarding east-west truck access through Dover, especially via SR 8 and Loockerman Street. Stakeholders’ comments relating to east-west connectivity will be addressed by the Dover Kent MPO East-West Freight Route Feasibility Analysis Phase 2. The following bullets summarize the feedback given at this meeting.

  • •Parking o The City of Dover’s Jason Osika cited there were no provisions made for truck on street truck parking in Garrison Oak Technology Park because it was not desired at the time the area was developed. o Marilyn Smith shared that DelDOT produced a flyer to advertise statewide truck parking opportunities such as at the Dover DMV. Stakeholders shared that this information is not widely known by truckers. o The Kent Economic Partnership noted that truck parking needs were initially met by shopping centers during off business hours. This is no longer feasible due to increased patronage and extended hours at shopping centers. o Dover Kent MPO suggested considering the feasibility of a truck parking area on state owned land off of the POW/MIA Parkway south of Procter & Gamble.
  • •Observations o Recent conversation with travel plaza operators revealed that profit is most directly associated with the sale of diesel fuel, therefore truck traffic is most desirable; as a result, SR 1 was not as appealing since truck volumes are relatively low.

Page 31 Page 212

Paj 213

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

o Lynn Byler shared concerns regarding restricting truck traffic on SR 8 because it is their primary connection between their new facility at Garrison Oak and Byler’s Store which is located on SR 8/Forrest Avenue at Rose Valley School Road, west of Dover. o Dover’s Principal Planner Dawn Melson-Williams shared that the City will be annexing the area north of the Civil Air Terminal since the Joint Use Agreement between Dover Air Force Base and DelDOT has been signed. There was consensus that the Dover Civil Air Terminal Study should be revisited since the report was prepared when occupancy at Garrison Oak was much lower. [Freight traffic from the Civil Air Terminal and Garrison Oak Technology Park would use infrastructure proposed by the Civil Air Terminal Study]. • Requests o Representatives from Procter & Gamble requested that DelDOT provide parking along either US 13 or SR 1 considering that the state’s freight activity is growing. o Representatives from Byler added that there is also an opportunity to build electric charging stations on land acquired for truck parking. They also noted the state owned parcel located along POW/MIA Parkway as a potential parking opportunity. o Kent Economic Partnership and Dover Kent MPO noted that they are in search of a private partner to run a truck stop/travel plaza in Kent County seeing as a lot of operators are not aware of the fiscal opportunities to be found in the state of Delaware. o Kent Economic Partnership requested that parcels being evaluated for rezoning to support freight uses be highlighted. Representatives from the City replied that zoning must be compatible with land use categories identified in the Dover Comprehensive Plan. Following the adoption of a new Comprehensive Plan, properties are rezoned to maintain compliance with the new land use map. Outside of that formal process, properties can only be rezoned when property owners apply to rezone their own property. The Dover Comprehensive Plan will be updated next in 2028. o There was general interest in pursuing a “truck only lane,” or lanes that only allow freight traffic. o Procter & Gamble shared that they need a westbound left turn from Hazlettville Road into their facility. They noted they used to have a designated turn lane until the State of Delaware Department of Insurance Office opened across the street and the road was restriped to give the Department of Insurance an eastbound left turn lane.

4.1.4 October 29, 2024, Public Open House and Presentation to Council Committee of the Whole There were 4 attendees at the Public Open House, two of which were City Council members. One attendee was a member of City staff, and the fourth was a member of the public who was in the building to attend the Council Meeting. The project team provided an overview of the preliminary recommendations. The open house attendees had minimal questions and concurred with the preliminary recommendations. All attendees were provided a copy of the survey, website information, and were asked to share information about the online survey with members of their network who may be interested.

Page 32 Page 213

Paj 214

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

4.2 RECOMMENDATIONS

This section summarizes recommendations relating to development review and regulations, land use planning, and communication and coordination. Freight facilities and freight movement should be prioritized in local land use planning in terms of comprehensive planning, the site plan review process, and municipal code updates. Adequate planning also requires regular communication between all levels of government. Key examples of the interrelationship between the freight and the local community and land use planning are as follows:

  • •Freight-generating land uses support regional employment, generate revenue through local and state taxes, and allow for the availability of local goods needed by growing populations and businesses.
  • •Poor coordination between freight and land use planning can create challenges, such as the routing of large vehicles through residential areas, especially if not addressed proactively.
  • •Freight volumes and associated impacts on land use are expected to continuously grow in the coming years. Planning for associated needs and impacts now will integrate freight into the community more smoothly, allowing for benefits to their region sooner while minimizing adverse impacts on both residents and the environment. 36

36 FHWA Office of Freight Management and Operations, FHWA Freight and Land Use Handbook, 2012,

https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/fhwahop12006/.

Page 33 Page 214

Paj 215

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

4.2.1 Development Review and Regulations To adequately anticipate and address freight movement needs and conflicts, freight must be considered in the development review process. The development review process is not static, it can be modified and informed by things like the freight consideration checklist proposed in recommendation 1B. Additional freight education resources available to planners include:

  • •The Eastern Transportation Coalition’s Freight Academy
  • •National Highway Institute freight-related training courses such as the web-based Integrating Freight into Transportation Decision Making course (Course Number FHWA-NHI-139006)
  • •The FHWA’s Freight Professional Development Program
  • •Delaware Freight Summits hosted by the University of Delaware Institute for Public Administration

Additionally, development review processes can be modified to more holistically consider freight needs and impacts. Table 5 presents a checklist from the 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan that was adapted from a similar checklist in the Planning for Freight-Related Development document. The checklist can help planners address land use conflicts related to proposed freight truck trip-generating development during the development review process. Note that the checklist can be used for the review of all types of development that generate freight truck trips (pick-ups or deliveries), not just shipping facilities. The checklist considers land use conflicts around the site of the proposed facility and transportation impacts on roads likely to be used by trucks serving the facility. Table 5. Development Review and Regulations Recommendations

Responsible Recommendation Description Notes Parties Recommendation 1A: Adopt development regulations City of Dover Further analysis is Adopt truck parking requiring developers to provide necessary to requirements truck parking/staging as part of determine the number manufacturing, warehouse, and of truck parking logistics developments. spaces are appropriate in Dover. Examples from other municipalities are included below.

Page 34 Page 215

Paj 216

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Responsible

RecommendationDescriptionNotes
Parties
Recommendation 1B:Incorporate freight-specificDevelopmentThe WILMAPCO
Implement freightplanning considerationsreview entities atPlanning for Freight-
considerationschecklist (like the one linked toall governmentRelated Development
checklistthe right) into developmentlevelsSummary and
review processes.Checklist (2021)
conveys factors to
consider when
planning for and
reviewing proposed
freight-related
development. The
document highlights
the importance of
considering
transportation and
land use conditions
around proposed
freight facilities to
mitigate potential
conflicts. The
checklist is included
below.

Examples of Truck Parking Requirements The Township of Upper Macungie, PA enacted truck parking requirements for all industrial uses including warehousing, distribution, truck terminals, and manufacturing. The requirements are documented in municipal code Section 27-601 Required Number of Parking Spaces (Ord. 9-94, 4/7/1994, § 601; amended by Ord. 2017-4, 6/1/2017; and by Ord. No. 2020-08, 7/9/2020). One ten-foot by eighty-foot truck staging parking space is required for every two loading docks. The Township of Forks, PA requires truck parking in addition to amenities for truck drivers in Code Section 200-28 Subsection G(17) Wholesale/warehouse [Amended 7-15-2021 by Ord. No. 375]: Additional regulations for specific uses: a) Each and every building containing this use shall have amenities for the truck drivers/operators of the vehicles using the facility… 1) … 2) At least one amenity shall be provided for every thirty-truck loading/unloading docks/doorways of the use. 3) ...Each amenity shall contain not less than one seat per 10 docks/doorways... 4) ...There shall be provided at least one twelve-foot-by-eighty-foot truck parking space per each required lounge seat of the amenity.

Page 35 Page 216

Paj 217

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

  • b)…adequate queuing space shall be provided within the property boundaries to prevent stacking of tractor-trailers on or along public streets.
  • c)This use shall reserve a minimum of 5% of the proposed total tractor-trailer parking spaces for trucks which are required to arrive early or required to layover or rest due to hours of service regulations. Such spaces must be made available to tractor-trailers 24 hours a day/seven days a week.

Planning for Freight-Related Development Summary and Checklist

YES NO N/A Local Freight Planning Consideration

Freight Network Designation: Is the facility adjacent to an existing freight route identified on Delaware’s current highway freight network or First/Final Mile freight network? 37 If not, what is the likely route trucks will take to reach major highway corridors?

Truck Route Obstructions: Do the likely truck routes have sharp turns, low clearance restrictions, or other truck obstructions?

Truck Route Roadway/Bridge Conditions: Do the likely truck routes have adequate roadway/pavement conditions, shoulder conditions, bridge weight limits, or existing/potential deterioration due to heavy vehicles?

Truck Route Community Conflicts: Do the likely truck routes run through residential areas, or other sensitive areas such as school zones?

Truck Route Bicycle/Pedestrian Conflicts: Are the likely truck routes designated as bicycle or pedestrian routes?

Truck Route Congestion:
Are there existing congestion problems on the likely truck routes?

Truck Route Improvement Funding: If infrastructure improvements are needed for the truck route, will the freight facility developer or tenant help fund these improvements?

Freight Facility Truck Parking: Is truck parking available nearby, or will the developer provide parking?

Freight Facility Conflicts: Is the facility located adjacent or near to existing or planned residential development, or other sensitive land uses such as schools? The 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan notes that “this checklist is not intended to be a comprehensive planning resource; rather, it should be incorporated as an initial list of typical considerations as part of the land use planning process for communities that are planning for freight-related developments.” 38

37 Delaware’s current highway freight network and FFM freight network can be viewed on the Delaware

Freight Plan – Existing Conditions interactive map.
38 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan, p. 6-8.

Page 36 Page 217

Paj 218

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

4.2.2 Land Use Planning Overview 22 Delaware Code §702 requires municipal governments to develop and update comprehensive plans. The Delaware Office of State Planning Coordination (OSPC) provides guidelines and a checklist to facilitate the comprehensive planning process for municipalities. Although not explicitly stated, updates to local comprehensive plans should also address freight activity and land use issues. The comprehensive plan’s planning and policy direction must reflect Dover’s community vision so that the plan can serve as a solid foundation for other plans, policies, and decisions. Further, the comprehensive plan should consider issues and impacts associated with current freight activity, which will help the community leverage the benefits of freight while minimizing undesirable impacts. The FHWA Office of Freight Management and Operations developed the FHWA Freight and Land Use Handbook to provide land use and transportation planners with tools and resources to help them assess the impacts of land use decisions on freight movement and the impact of freight-related uses and movement on other land uses and land use planning goals. The handbook provides extensive background information and case studies of freight policies or programs enacted around the country. It is a valuable resource for communities wishing to address freight in their comprehensive planning. The 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan recommends two strategies related to land use (bolded italics added):

  • •Freight Land Use Preservation – Coordinate with and educate the region’s planning officials on the importance of preserving critical infrastructure and freight-oriented land uses in key freight or rail corridors and industrial areas. Planning and decision-making should aim to minimize residential encroachments while also managing real and perceived conflicts or expectations between the residential and freight communities.
  • •Freight and Community Impact Planning – Implement a proactive approach to assessing and balancing freight impacts, community needs, and competing interests much earlier in the planning process, including the use of tools such as the Protect-Manage-Accommodate framework for contextualizing freight conflicts and the local freight planning considerations checklist for freight facilities and truck routes. 39

Table 6. Land Use Planning Recommendations includes two recommendations reflecting these strategies.

39 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan, p. 6-6.

Page 37 Page 218

Paj 219

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Table 6. Land Use Planning Recommendations

Recommendation Description Responsible Parties Notes

Recommendation 2A: Preserve opportunities City of Dover and Kent Protect existing for freight-intensive County freight-intensive development in development appropriate locations opportunities along by protecting parcels truck routes. currently zoned for freight-generating uses along Dover’s existing and future truck routes from rezoning.

Recommendation 2B: Create opportunities City of Dover and Kent Draw on Dover Kent Create opportunities for freight-intensive County MPO’s 2022 Rail for freight-intensive development in Corridor Industrial development along appropriate locations Land Use Study for Dover’s truck routes. by pursuing rezoning guidance on rezoning for suitable parcels not for freight-intensive presently zoned for uses freight-intensive uses along Dover’s existing and future truck routes.

Parcel Analysis

In order to advance recommendations 2A and 2B a parcel analysis was conducted in order to identify parcels that should be protected or preserved for freight specific uses. The parcel identification criteria were as follows:

  • •Adjacent to a designated Dover truck route or to an improvement recommended in the Dover Air Cargo Freight Access Study (2021)
  • •Designated as a freight-relevant land use category on Dover’s (2002) or Kent County’s (2018) future land use maps
  • •Parcel area is not majority wetlands
  • •Primary use is not a rail spur, public park, or school
  • •Parcel size:
  • •Agricultural parcels: 5+ acres in size or in a cluster of agricultural-zoned parcels that is 5+ acres in size where all parcels in cluster meet the above criteria
  • •Non-agricultural parcels: 1+ acre in size or in a cluster of other non-agricultural-zoned parcels that is 1+ acre in size where all parcels in cluster meet the above criteria

Page 38 Page 219

Paj 220

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

The results of the analysis are shown in Figure

Figure 15. City of Dover and Kent County Parcels identified for protection or preservation for freight intensive uses.

Page 39 Page 220

Paj 221

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

Comprehensive Plan Updates The next comprehensive plan update process is the logical time to implement Recommendations 2A and 2B. Dover should consider the guidance provided by the documents referenced in this section, and also consider incorporating the following topics.

  • •Description of Physical, Demographic, and Economic Conditions – Transportation 40 o Key commercial vehicle traffic routes in and through the City of Dover o Key locations with the greatest concerns for truck movement o Nearby industries and major employment centers o Truck traffic volumes o Current conflict between through truck traffic on the one hand and businesses and other road users on the other hand, in downtown Dover o Current conflict between residential and freight-related land uses in other areas of Dover
  • •Policies, Statements, Goals, and Planning Components for Transportation o Study and, if found to be feasible and beneficial, implement relevant recommendations from the 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan and the 2021 Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Report o Develop strategies to support economic development and safe and efficient freight movement while promoting quality of life and safety for the community o Continue to engage in regional and state planning and coordinate activities to ensure freight needs are considered and supported

In addition to the comprehensive plan, Dover should consider reviewing and updating other local plans, policies, and code sections to ensure they are current and support land use and development decision- making in alignment with the implications of today’s freight activity. The Northampton County Freight-Based Land Use Management Guide was developed in 2022 by the Lehigh Valley Planning Commission, a regional planning organization for an area that has experienced some of the highest pressures of freight activity and freight-based land uses in recent years. The guide aims to “assist municipalities in making land use decisions regarding freight-based development and to alleviate issues that result from these types of land uses.” 41 This guide may be a useful reference as Dover updates freight-related plans, policies, and code sections.

40 Terminology comes from the State of Delaware Comprehensive Plan Checklist, 2015,

https://stateplanning.delaware.gov/lup/documents/comprehensive-plan-checklist-guide.pdf. 41 https://www.northamptoncounty.org/CMTYECDV/Pages/Freight-Based-Land-Use-Management-

Guide.aspx.

Page 40 Page 221

Paj 222

Findings and Recommendations DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

4.2.3 Communication and Coordination Table 7 presents recommendations that will improve the communication and coordination of freight issues relevant to Dover. Table 7. Communication and Coordination Recommendations

Recommendation Responsible Description Notes Name Parties Recommendation 3A: Improve communication and City of Dover, Collect and share Improve coordination between local, Kent County, freight-relevant data intergovernmental county, and state government State of from land coordination. and MPO regarding freight- Delaware development and related land development and transportation transportation projects. improvement projects. Consider a “Dig Once” policy to ensure that relevant freight recommendations are implemented when road work is occurring.

Recommendation 3B: Improve engagement with local City of Dover, Establish direct points Stakeholder freight operators to better Kent County, of contact at the City, coordination. address their needs during State of County, and Dover planning processes. Delaware Kent MPO for key and industry leaders.

Recommendation 3C: Revisit the Dover Air Cargo Dover Kent Dover Kent MPO is Revisit Dover Air Freight Access Study – MPO, City of monitoring the status Cargo Freight Access Planning and Environmental Dover, Kent of this Study Linkage (PEL) Report (2021) to County, State of recommendation. recommendations. determine if recommendations Delaware need to be adjusted based on leasing activity at Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center.

Page 41 Page 222

Paj 223

Conclusions and Next Steps DOVER FREIGHT PLAN Item #19.

5 Conclusions and Next Steps Statewide freight plans are required by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and the Delaware State Freight Plan of 2022 recommended DelDOT undertake local planning support initiatives. Local freight planning support includes utilizing DelDOT municipal assistance for tasks available within statewide planning contracts, along with similar MPOs within the state. The importance of local freight planning cannot be overstated; according to the Delaware State Freight Plan, 36% of employees in Kent County work in a Freight-Intensive Sector. Therefore, focused on the City of Dover, this study assists in identifying and addressing local freight movement concerns of both freight operators and members of the community within the freight network in addition to evolving freight movement patterns as e-commerce grows. This planning process utilized to prepare this study opened new lines of communication between DelDOT, Dover Kent MPO, the City of Dover, and freight stakeholders. Implementing the recommendations documented in this study will require ongoing coordination. As components of the study are implemented, private stakeholder should be notified. This will increase private sector buy-in to the study. Achieving the Dover Freight plan’s desired outcomes will require improvements to development regulations and review, land use planning, and intergovernmental coordination. Both public and private sector freight stakeholders, freight operators, and system owners should also reference the Dover Freight Plan to better understand DelDOT’s intended strategic direction as they develop programs and projects.

Page 42 Page 223

Paj 224

Appendices DOVER FREIGHT PLAN
Item #19.

6 Appendices APPENDIX A. LOCAL, REGIONAL, AND STATE PLANS, STUDIES, AND PROGRAMS RELATED TO FREIGHT This appendix provides descriptions of additional relevant planning efforts and programs that are not summarized in Section 1.5 above. Many of the descriptions in this appendix are excerpted or adapted from the 2022 Delaware State Freight Plan.

6.1.1 Dover City of Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan (2020) Dover’s most recent comprehensive plan is the City of Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan, adopted in 2020. The plan addresses freight as follows:

  • •States that several freight-related employers play an important role in the city’s economy. As of 2017, 13.7% of Dover’s labor force worked in production, transportation, and materials moving.
  • •Reports projected changes in freight intensive sector employment in Kent County from 2014 to 2024.
  • •Recommends developing and implementing strategies for addressing east-west traffic, particularly on SR 8.
  • •Recommends further study of an access road from the Garrison Oak Business and Technology Center (GOBTC) to SR 1.
  • •Identifies county lands that Dover is considering annexing, and their potential land use. Some of this land would provide additional opportunities for freight intensive sector development.

Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030 (2023) (also known as the Downtown Dover Strategic Master Plan) The Downtown Dover Strategic Master Plan was published by the Downtown Dover Partnership. The plan identifies transportation and logistics as an economic sector that is likely to grow in Dover, and states that there are “opportunities for small warehouse growth in Downtown Dover.” It also notes that the city could implement job density requirements for new logistics development to discourage sprawling site plans and highly autonomous operations. 42

Garrison Oak Traffic Study – Technical Memorandum (2017) This memorandum reports the results of a traffic study of intersections near GOBTC. The study found that intersections in the vicinity of the GOBTC “are expected to operate at acceptable LOS when the [GOBTC] is completely occupied and operational” and therefore the construction of a connector road between GOBTC and the SR 1-SR 8 interchange is not justified. However, the memorandum recommends undertaking an alignment study to determine the feasibility of constructing the connector road. 43

42 Mosaic Development Partners et al., Transforming Downtown Dover: Capital City 2030 (Dover,

Delaware: Downtown Dover Partnership, 2023), 148. 43 Shilpa Mallem, “Garrison Oak Traffic Study – Technical Memorandum,” June 14, 2017, 10,

https://doverkentmpo.delaware.gov/files/2019/05/Garrison-Oak-Study-FY17.pdf.

Page 43 Page 224

Paj 225

Appendices DOVER FREIGHT PLAN
Item #19.

6.1.2 Regional Innovations 2050: Metropolitan Transportation Plan (2025) The Dover Kent MPO’s Metropolitan Transportation Plan (MTP) serves as a blueprint to assist elected officials in addressing the transportation needs of their constituencies by identifying how Kent County’s transportation resources should be managed. It serves as the framework for transportation investment decisions for the years 2025 to 2050. The plan is updated every four years.

Truck Parking Amenities Study (2023) The Dover Kent MPO conducted this study of the existing conditions of truck parking amenities in Kent County. The study offers a list of amenities that would be most beneficial to truck drivers. Data was gathered from state and federal literature and outreach conducted by MPO staff.

Kent County Airport Inventory (2023) This inventory was prepared by Dover Kent MPO. It provides descriptions of each airport in the county, descriptions of relevant existing plans and information resources, and findings related to opportunities for growth and development, constraints on growth, land use conflicts, and emergency uses. The study notes that the Civil Air Terminal (CAT) (now known as the Central Delaware Aviation Complex [CDAC]) and Delaware Airpark (outside of Cheswold) are the two aviation facilities most likely to be capable of further development and expansion.

Kent County East-West Truck Freight Route Feasibility Analysis Phase I (2022) This Dover Kent MPO analysis reviews existing east-west freight truck traffic patterns and needs west of SR 1. The analysis identifies roadway deficiencies that impact freight movements and recommendations to improve traffic flow on key east-west freight corridors in Kent County. The conclusion to the study notes that the Dover Kent MPO recommends a Phase II Engineering Analysis be conducted to assess recommendations. The Phase II analysis is currently in development.

Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization Rail Zoning Study (2018) and Rail Corridor Industrial Land Use Study (2022) These Dover Kent MPO-led studies reviewed 13 municipal comprehensive plans and Kent County’s comprehensive plan to gauge their level of inclusion of rail freight information and related planning insights. Study products included interactive web mapping to explore land use and potential rail freight development opportunities. Recommendations focused on supporting existing federal, state, and regional freight plan goals and objectives; linking local transportation initiatives articulated in comprehensive plans with available federal and state transportation funding; and identifying future economic initiatives requiring follow-up studies.

Kent County Transportation Operations Management Plan (2021) The 2021 Kent County Transportation Operations Management Plan (TOMP) identifies three congestion “hotspots” in Kent County and presents recommendations to reduce congestion at each hotspot. The three congestion hotspots are Dover, Camden, and North Milford.

Page 44 Page 225

Paj 226

Appendices DOVER FREIGHT PLAN
Item #19.

2020-21 Kent County Target Industry Study Update (2022) The 2022 Kent County Target Industry Study Update was prepared by Rockport Analytics for the Kent Economic Partnership. This study is used to attract economic development to central Delaware, and identifies Distribution, Warehousing, and Logistics as target industry #2.

6.1.3 Delaware Delaware Truck Bottleneck Identification (2018) and Delaware Statewide Truck Bottleneck Analyses (2020/2022) These analyses of truck bottlenecks throughout Delaware were completed in coordination with federal Transportation Performance Management (TPM) reporting requirements established by the Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act (MAP-21). They identify highway segments in the state that significantly affect freight mobility and reliability. The 2020 and 2022 analyses identified 15 bottlenecks, them as high, medium, or low priorities using a data-driven process, and provided a list of projects/studies relevant to each bottleneck.

Innovation in Motion: The Delaware Long Range Transportation Plan (2019 plus annual supplements) The LRTP has a 20-year outlook and aims to express Delaware’s continually changing transportation environment by conveying land use patterns, demographics, travel patterns, preferences, and technology. All these variables together contribute to Delaware’s transportation network.

Delaware First Final/Mile Freight Network Development Working Paper 2: Addressing Delaware’s First/Final Mile Freight Needs and Issues (May 2021) This working paper is the second in a series of two working papers prepared as part of CPCS’s Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Project. It describes the performance needs and issues of the FFM network and strategies that could be used to address these needs and issues.

Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Working Paper 1: Initial Identification of First/Final Mile Freight Network (February 2021) This working paper is the first in a series of two working papers prepared as part of CPCS’s Delaware First/Final Mile Freight Network Development Project. The paper documents the steps taken to identify the road segments constituting the draft FFM freight network and identifies basic needs, issues, and land use/development trends related to FFM freight connectors.

DelDOT Highway-Rail Grade Crossing Safety Program (annual) On an annual basis, DelDOT performs a data-driven network screening process to identify public highway-rail at-grade crossing locations for study to evaluate the need for, and feasibility of, safety improvements that could be funded with federal Railway-Highway Crossings Program (Section 130) funds. Potential safety improvements are selected and prioritized for design and implementation based on available funding.

Page 45 Page 226

Paj 227

Appendices DOVER FREIGHT PLAN
Item #19.

APPENDIX B. STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS

Interview Date Interviewee Interviewee Organization

March 14, 2024 Matt Jordan Dover Airforce Base (DAFB)

March 18, 2024 Cliff Grunstra Delmarva Central Railroad (DCR)

March 18, 2024 Dave Edgell & Josh Thomas Office of State Planning Coordination (OSPC)

May 6, 2024 Lyn Byler Byler’s Store

May 17, 2024 Joseph Taylor Procter & Gamble

Page 46 Page 227

Paj 228

Appendices DOVER FREIGHT PLAN
Item #19.

APPENDIX C. MARCH 26, 2024 FREIGHT ROUNDTABLE MEETING ATTENDANCE

  • •DelDOT o Cooper Bowers
  • •Dover/Kent MPO o Marilyn Smith o Mike Petit de Mange o Malcolm Jacob
  • •Kent Economic Partnership o Linda Parkowski o Zach Prebula
  • •Kent County Farm Bureau o Jim Minner
  • •Century Engineering (Now known as Kleinfelder, staff for the Dover Kent MPO East-West Truck Study Phase 2) o Drew Boyce o Ted Foglietta o Wes Hicks
  • •Whitman, Requardt and Associates, LLP o Leah Kacanda (Staff) o Gemma Tierney (Staff)

APPENDIX D. SEPTEMBER 9, 2024, STAKEHOLDER MEETING ATTENDANCE

  • •DelDOT o Steve Bayer o Cooper Bowers
  • •Dover/Kent County MPO o Marilyn Smith
  • •City of Dover o Jason Lyon (Water and Wastewater) o Dawn Melson-Williams (Planning) o Mark Nowak (Public Works) o Chief Thomas Johnson (Police Department)
  • •Byler’s Store, Inc. o Lyn Byler
  • •Procter & Gamble o Joseph Taylor
  • •Kent Economic Partnership o Linda Parkowski
  • •Downtown Dover Partnership o Diane Laird

Page 47 Page 228

Paj 229

Appendices DOVER FREIGHT PLAN
Item #19.

  • •Century Engineering (Now known as Kleinfelder, staff for the Dover Kent MPO East-West Truck Study Phase 2) o Ted Foglietta o Sonia Marichic-Goudy
  • •Whitman, Requardt and Associates, LLP o Leah Kacanda (Staff) o Gemma Tierney (Staff)

Page 48 Page 229

Paj 230

Appendices DOVER FREIGHT PLAN
Item #19.

APPENDIX E. PUBLIC SURVEY QUESTIONS AND RESPONSE

Survey Questions: 1. What is your relationship with Dover’s freight economy (for example: do you work in the freight industry or an industry that is heavily supported by freight)?

  • 2.For each of the Dover Freight Plan’s draft recommendations, check the box under the column that most closely corresponds to your level of support for the recommendation.

Level of support Strongly Support Neutral Oppose Strongly
support oppose
Recommendation

1A: Adopt development regulations requiring
developers to provide truck parking/staging as part
of manufacturing, warehouse, and logistics
developments

1B: Incorporate freight-specific planning
considerations checklist (like the one developed by
CPCS for WILMAPCO) into development review
processes

2A: Preserve opportunities for freight-intensive development in appropriate locations by protecting parcels currently zoned for freight-generating uses along Dover’s existing and future truck routes from rezoning

2B: Enhance opportunities for freight-intensive development in appropriate locations by pursuing rezoning for suitable parcels not presently zoned for freight-intensive uses along Dover’s existing and future truck routes

3A: Improve communication/coordination between
local, county, and state government and MPO
regarding freight-related land development and
transportation projects

3B: Improve engagement with local freight
operators to better address their needs during
planning processes

  • 3.Please share any additional recommendation suggestions, considerations, or questions.

Page 49 Page 230

Paj 231

Appendices DOVER FREIGHT PLAN
Item #19.

Survey response (none of the 3 participants responded to questions 1 and 3):

Page 50 Page 231

Paj 232

Item #19.

Paj 233

Item #20.

First Reading

City of Dover

CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-01

1BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN
2COUNCIL MET:
3
4 That Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix C - Downtown Redevelopment, be amended by
5 inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, italics, and deleting the text indicated in red, bold,
6italics strikethrough as follows:
7
8ARTICLE I. INTENT
9 The city council has deemed it to be in the best interests of the residents of the city and in
10 furtherance of their health, safety and welfare to promote the redevelopment of downtown
11 Dover. In order to promote the redevelopment, the council has determined that incentives in the
12 forms of tax abatements, impact fee waivers and building permit caps should be offered.
13ARTICLE II. DOWNTOWN DOVER PARTNERSHIP
14 (a) The Downtown Dover Partnership shall be established and duly incorporated under the
15 not-for-profit corporation provisions of the Delaware General Corporation Law (8 Del. C
16 §101 et seq.) for the purpose of fostering redevelopment within the target area.
17 (b) Certification of incorporation. The city solicitor, as incorporator of the company, shall
18 prepare and cause, or amend, the certificate of incorporation to be filed with the secretary
19 of State of Delaware, which certificate shall include those requirements set forth in 22
20Del. C. § 1504, as amended.
21 (c) Membership of company and board of directors. The management company shall be a
22 corporation comprised of a board of directors established in accordance with the by-laws
23 approved by the board of directors, provided that not less than five directors shall own a
24 commercial property within the target area, or shall be the designee of such owner.
25 (d) Company reports. The management company shall file with the finance department and
26 with the city clerk a quarterly financial report and shall also provide an annual operating
27 report. The city shall annually review the performance of the management company and
28 shall prepare for public inspection a report which certifies that the management company
29 is in compliance with its enabling ordinance, its certificate of incorporation and bylaws,
30 and the provisions of this appendix and 22 Del. C. Ch. 15 (22 Del. C. § 1501 et seq.); the
31 management company is fiscally sound; and the management company has not
32 discriminated against any person based upon race, sex, national origin, religion, age or
33disability.
34
35

Paj 234

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C Downtown Redevelopment Page 2 Item #20.

36ARTICLE IIIII. DEFINITIONS
37 The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this ordinance, shall have the
38 meanings ascribed to them in this article, except where the context clearly indicates a different
39meaning:
40Section 1. Beneficiary of the incentives.
41 The beneficiary of the incentives shall include the person or artificial entity that receives the
42 incentive and the owner of one-half or greater interest in an artificial entity that receives the
43incentive.
44Section 2. Downtown Dover Partnership.
45 (a) The Downtown Dover Partnership shall be established and duly incorporated under the
46 not-for-profit corporation provisions of the Delaware General Corporation Law (8 Del. C
47 §101 et seq.) for the purpose of fostering redevelopment within the target area.
48 (b) Certification of incorporation. The city solicitor, as incorporator of the company, shall
49 prepare and cause, or amend, the certificate of incorporation to be filed with the secretary
50 of State of Delaware, which certificate shall include those requirements set forth in 22
51Del. C. § 1504, as amended.
52 (c) Membership of company and board of directors. The management company shall be a
53 corporation comprised of not less than five members or directors respectively who either
54 own a commercial property within the district, or are the designee of such owner.
55 (d) Company reports. The management company shall file with the finance department and
56 with the city clerk a monthly financial report and shall also provide an operating report
57 monthly. The city shall annually review the performance of the management company
58 and shall prepare for public inspection a report which certifies that the management
59 company is in compliance with its enabling ordinance, its certificate of incorporation and
60 bylaws, and the provisions of this appendix and 22 Del. C. ch. 15 (22 Del. C. § 1501 et
61 seq.); the management company is fiscally sound; and the management company has not
62 discriminated against any person based upon race, sex, national origin, religion, age or
63disability.
64Section 2 3. Eligible project.
65 Eligible project shall mean a new construction or renovation that meets the requirements of Article
66IV. Eligibility of this Appendix.:
67(a) Is located within the target area; and
68 (b) The fair market value of the materials to be used in and the labor to be performed on
69the project exceeds the sum of $15,000.00; and
70(c) Is for commercial, office, or a residential use; and
71(d) Conforms to the intent of this ordinance.
72 In order for a residential use to be an eligible project, the object of the construction or
73 renovation must be a dwelling unit as defined in article 12 of the City of Dover zoning
74 ordinance [appendix B]. Construction or renovation of accessory buildings as defined in
75 article 12 of the City of Dover zoning ordinance [appendix B] shall not be eligible for
76 development incentives. Construction or renovation which constitutes ordinary replacement or
77routine maintenance shall not qualify as an eligible project.

Paj 235

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C Downtown Redevelopment Page 3 Item #20.

78 Section 3 4. Target area. 79 Target area shall mean that part of the city more particularly described as follows: 80 Beginning at a point at the intersection of the centerlines of North New Street and Clara 81 Street south to the intersection of the centerlines of North New Street and Mary Street, 82 east to the intersection of the center lines of North Governors Avenue and Mary Street 83 south to the intersection of the centerlines of North Governors Avenue and Cecil Street, 84 east to the intersection of the centerlines of Cecil and North State Streets, then continuing 85 on the centerline of North State Street in a southerly direction to the intersection of the 86 centerline of State Street and an extension of the centerline of Delaware Avenue, then 87 continuing on the centerline and an extension of the centerline of Delaware Avenue in an 88 easterly direction to the point of intersection of an extension of the centerline of Delaware 89 Avenue and the St. Jones River, then following the centerline of the St. Jones River in a 90 southerly direction to the point of intersection of the centerline of the St. Jones River and 91 the southerly property line of the property located at 631 South State Street lands now or 92 formerly of the Catholic Diocese of Wilmington, being the site of Holy Cross Roman 93 Catholic Church, then proceeding in a westerly direction along said property line to the 94 easterly right-of-way line of South State Street (U.S. Route 13-A), then crossing the right- 95 of-way line of South State Street in a westerly direction and joining the centerline of Hope 96 Street and proceeding in a westerly direction to the centerlines of Hope Street and South 97 Governors Avenue, then proceeding in a southerly direction along the centerline of South 98 Governors Avenue to the point of intersection of the centerlines of South Governors Avenue 99 and Dover Street, then proceeding in a westerly direction along the centerline of Dover 100 Street to the point of intersection of the centerlines of Dover Street and Westview Terrace, 101 then continuing in a northerly direction on the centerline of Westview Terrace to the point 102 of intersection of the centerline of Westview Terrace and New Burton Road, then 103 proceeding in a northeasterly direction on the centerline of New Burton Road to the point of 104 intersection of New Burton Road and West Street, then continuing in a northerly direction 105 along the westerly right-of-way line of West Street to the point of intersection of the 106 westerly side of the right-of-way of West Street and the northerly property line of lands 107 now or formerly the property located at 724 South West Street, Dover Rent-All, Inc., then 108 continuing in a westerly direction along said property line to the point of intersection of said 109 property line and the lands of the railroad right-of-way Conrail Railroad, then proceeding 110 in a northerly direction along the easterly right-of-way line of the railroad right-of-way 111 Conrail Railroad in a northerly direction to the point of intersection of the centerline of 112 West North Street and then westerly along the centerline of West North Street to Clarence 113 Street and north along the center line of Clarence Street to Slaughter Street, and west along 114 the center line of Slaughter Street to Cherry Street and north along the center line of Cherry 115 Street to the intersection with the center line of Lincoln Street, west 122 feet to the 116 southeast corner of the property at 826 Forest Street, north along the easterly border of 117 said property, to Forest Street, northwest 287 feet to the intersection of the centerlines of 118 Forest Street, Weston Drive, and West Division Street, north 508 feet along Weston Drive 119 to the southern border of the property located at 200 Weston Drive, east 142 feet to the 120 southeast corner of said property, north 538 feet to the southwest corner of the property 121 located at 300 Ridgely Street, east along the southern border of said property 680 feet to 122 the eastern side of the railroad right-of-way, north 359 feet to the edge western terminus 123 of Mary Street, east to the intersection of the centerlines of North West Street and Mary

Paj 236

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C Downtown Redevelopment Page 4 Item #20.

124 Street, east 27 feet to the western property line of the property located at 511 Mary Street, 125 then continuing north 403 feet along the western border of said property, east 430 feet 126 along the northern border of said property to North Queen Street, then north 346 feet to 127 the intersection of the centerlines of North Queen Street and Clara Street, and east to the 128 intersection of the centerlines of Clara Street and North New Street. to a point of 129 intersection with an extension of the westerly property line of lands now or of late of 130 Michael Nash, being the site of the former Diamond Ice Company, then proceeding in a 131 northerly direction along the westerly property line of the Nash property and in a line 132 extending to the intersection of the southerly property line of lands now or of late Paul T. 133 and Aiko Moore, and then northwesterly and then northerly along the southern and 134 western property line of the Moore property and extending north to an intersection with 135 the centerline of Lincoln Street, and then easterly along the centerline of Lincoln Street 136 to a point of intersection of an extension of the westerly property line of lands now or 137 formerly of Frank Moore et al., and then northerly along the western property of Frank 138 Moore et al. and extending to a point of intersection with the centerline of Forest Street, 139 then easterly along the centerline of Forest Street to a point of intersection with an 140 extension of the westerly property of the lands now or formerly of the Salvation Army, 141 and then northerly and easterly along the western and north property line of the 142 Salvation Army property to the point of intersection with lands now or of late Conrail 143 Railroad, then northerly along the westerly property line of Conrail Railroad and 144 extending to a point of intersection with the centerline of West Division Street, and then 145 easterly along the centerline of East Division Street to the intersection of the easterly 146 right-of-way line of Conrail Railroad, and then northerly along the easterly right-of-way 147 line of Conrail Railroad to the intersection of the right-of-way of Conrail Railroad and 148 the northerly property line of lands now or of late of Southern States Cooperative, Inc., 149 then proceeding in an easterly direction a distance of 52.76 feet to the northeasterly 150 corner of the lands now or of late of Southern States Cooperative, Inc., then proceeding 151 in a southerly direction along the easterly property line of lands now or of late of 152 Southern States Cooperative, Inc., to the point of intersection of said property and the 153 centerline of Mary Street, then proceeding in an easterly direction along the centerline of 154 Mary Street to the point of beginning, being the point of intersection of the centerline of 155 Mary Street and North Governors Avenue, south along the centerline of North Governors 156 Avenue to the intersection of North Governors Avenue and Cecil Street, and west along 157 the center line of Cecil Street through the Wesley College Campus to the point of 158 intersection of Cecil Street and North State Street. 159 Section 4. Downtown Development District 160 Downtown Development District High Priority Target Area shall mean that area within the 161 Target Area designated as such by the State of Delaware in accordance with 22 Del. C. Ch. 19 162 and part of the city more particularly described as bounded by the street center lines as follows: 163 From the intersection of the centerlines of North Governors Avenue New Street and 164 Mary Clara Street south to the intersection of the centerlines of North New Street 165 Governors Avenue and Fulton Mary Street, east to the intersections of the center lines of 166 Fulton Mary Street and North Governors Avenue State Street, south to the intersection 167 of the centerlines of South State Street North Governors Avenue and Fulton 168 Loockerman Street, east to the intersection of the centerlines of North State Street and 169 Fulton Street, south to the intersection of the centerlines of State Street and Division

Paj 237

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C Downtown Redevelopment Page 5 Item #20.

170 Street, east to the intersection of the centerlines of Pennsylvania Avenue and Division 171 Street, south to the intersection of the centerlines of Pennsylvania Avenue and Kings 172 Highway, southwest to the intersection of the centerlines of Kings Highway and Reed 173 Street, east 1,361 along the southern boundary property located at 89 Kings Highway 174 SW to the westerly edge of Mirror Lake, south along the westerly edge of Mirror Lake 175 to Loockerman Street 201 feet west of the intersection of the centerlines of 176 Loockerman Street and Park Drive, west 1,386 feet along Loockerman Plaza, south 177 282 feet to the northeast corner of the property located at 15 East North Street, west 36 178 feet to the northwest corner of the property located at 15 East North Street, south 73 179 feet long the westerly border of the property located at 15 East North Street to North 180 Street, west 137 feet to the intersection of the centerlines of South State Street and 181 North Street, east 73 feet to the northwest corner of the property located at 7 The 182 Green, south 274 feet along the westerly edge of the property located at 7 The Green to 183 The Green, 792 feet along the western portion of The Green to the intersection of the 184 centerlines of South State Street and The Green, south 200 feet past the intersection of 185 the centerlines of South State Street and Water Street to the northeast corner of the 186 property located at 540 South State Street, west 787 feet along the northern border of 187 the property located at 540 South State Street to South Governors Avenue, north 172 188 feet to the intersection of the centerlines of South Governors Avenue and Water Street, 189 west to the intersection of the centerlines of South Queen Street and Water Street, 190 north to the intersection of the centerlines of South Queen Street and West North 191 Street, west to the intersection of the centerlines of Clarence Street and West North 192 Street, north to the intersection of the centerlines of Clarence Street and Slaughter 193 Street, west to the intersection of the centerlines of Cherry Street and Slaughter Street, 194 north to the intersection of the centerlines of Cherry Street and Lincoln Street, west 195 122 feet to the southeast corner of the property at 826 Forest Street, north along the 196 easterly border of said property, to Forest Street, northwest 287 feet to the intersection 197 of the centerlines of Forest Street, Weston Street, and West Division Street, north 508 198 feet along Weston Street to the southern border of the property located at 101 Weston 199 Drive, east 142 feet to the southeast corner of the property located at 101 Weston Drive, 200 north 538 feet to the southwest corner of the property located at 300 Ridgley Street, east 201 along the southern border of property located at 300 Ridgley Street 680 feet to the 202 eastern side of the railroad right-of-way, north 359 feet to the edge western terminus of 203 Mary Street, east to the intersection of the centerlines of North West Street and Mary 204 Street, east 27 feet to the western property line of the property located at 511 Mary 205 Street, north 403 feet along the western border of the property located at 511 Mary 206 Street, east 430 feet along the northern border of the property located at 511 Mary 207 Street to North Queen Street, north 346 feet to the intersection of the centerlines of 208 North Queen Street and Clara Street, and east to the intersection of the centerlines of 209 Clara Street and North New Street. 202 feet and then south 172 feet and then west 36 210 feet and south 73 feet, and west along the right-of-way of North Street for 136 feet, and 211 then south 45 feet along the center line of State Street and then east 73 feet along the 212 south right-of-way of North Street and then south 71 feet, and then west 11 feet and 213 south six feet and west 20 feet and south 135 feet and west 8 feet and then south 22 214 feet, then west following the centerline of The Green to the south intersection of the 215 center lines of South State Street and The Green, south to West Water Street and south

Paj 238

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C Downtown Redevelopment Page 6 Item #20.

216 218 feet and west 205 feet and southwest 41 feet and west 246 feet and north 102 feet 217 and west 103 feet and northwest 3 feet and west 40 feet and southwest 9 feet and west 218 44 feet and north to the intersection of South Governors Avenue and the centerline of 219 West Water Street and west to the intersection of the center lines of West Water Street 220 and South Queen Street, south along the center line of South Queen Street 541.11 feet 221 and then west to the center line of South West Street, and north to the intersection of 222 the center lines of West North Street and South West Street, and west to the 223 intersection of the center lines of West North Street and Clarence Street and north to 224 the intersection of the center lines of Clarence Street and Slaughter Street, and west 225 along the center line of Slaughter Street to Cherry Street and north along the center 226 line of Cherry Street to the intersection with the center line of Lincoln Street, and east 227 along the center line of Lincoln Street to the intersection of the center lines of Forest 228 Street and South West Street, and north along the center line of South West Street to 229 the intersection of the center lines of West Street and West Division Street, and west to 230 the east property line of the Norfolk Southern railroad track, and north along this 231 property line to the intersection with the center line of Mary Street, and west to the 232 intersection of the center lines of Mary Street and North Governors Avenue. 233 (b) Expanded boundary approved by the Cabinet Committee on State Planning Issues,

234effective February 1, 2024:
235 (1) Beginning at the intersection of S. State Street and Loockerman Street and then
236 turning east 202 feet along the southern edge of Loockerman Plaza and then
237 turning north 110 feet to the northern edge of Legislative Avenue and then
238 following the northern edge of E. Loockerman Street 621 feet to the westerly edge
239 of the bridge crossing the St. Jones River at Mirror Lake and then following the
240 westerly edge of Mirror Lake to the boundary of lands of the State of Delaware
241 and then turning west and following the southern boundary of said state lands
242 until the intersection with Kings Highway and then west along the southern edge
243 of E. Reed Street to the original target area boundary and co-located with that
244boundary south to the point of beginning.
245 (2) Being that the boundary extension encompassing 14 acres is approved by the
246Cabinet Committee on State Planning Issues.
247 (3) Subject to the condition that no rebates will be granted for expansion of the gross
248 square footage of the building on parcel 2-05-07705-04-5200-00001 unless an
249 eligible project(s) mitigates future flood risks and improves the resiliency of the
250 site. Renovations to the existing building may be considered appropriate, at the
251 discretion of the Office of State Planning Coordination (OSPC) and the Delaware
252State Housing Authority (DSHA).
253 (4) The boundary extension set forth above shall be incorporated into the City of
254 Dover's GIS system as an amendment to the High Priority Target Area (a.k.a. the
255Downtown Development District).
256
257
258

Paj 239

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C Downtown Redevelopment Page 7 Item #20.

259ARTICLE IV III. ELIGIBILITY
260Section 1. Eligible Project
261 Eligible projects shall include a new construction or renovation which:
262(a) Is located within the target area; and
263 (b) The fair market value of the materials to be used in and the labor to be performed on
264the project exceeds the sum of $5,000.00; and
265(c) Is for commercial, office, or a residential use; and
266(d) Conforms to the intent of this ordinance.
267 (e) In accordance with the agreement with the Delaware Office of State Planning
268 Coordination and the Delaware State Housing Authority, no rebates will be granted
269 for expansion of the gross square footage of the building on parcel 2-05-07705-04-
270 5200-00001 (9 East Loockerman Street) unless an eligible project(s) mitigates future
271 flood risks and improves the resiliency of the site. Renovations to the existing
272 building may be considered appropriate, at the discretion of the Office of State
273 Planning Coordination (OSPC) and the Delaware State Housing Authority (DSHA).
274 (f) In order for a residential use to be an eligible project, the object of the construction
275 or renovation must be a dwelling unit as defined in article 12 of Appendix B -
276 Zoning. Construction or renovation of accessory buildings as defined in article 12 of
277Appendix B - Zoning shall not be eligible for development incentives.
278Section 2 1. Development incentive ineligibility.
279 An otherwise eligible project shall be ineligible for development incentives if:
280 (a) An application for a building permit for the project was filed prior to the effective
281date of this ordinance; or
282 (b) Construction or renovation commenced prior to the effective date of this ordinance;
283or
284 (a)(c) Issuance of the certificate of occupancy and/or the completion and finalization of
285 the building permit occurs before the application for development incentives is
286received; or
287 (b)(d) The subject property is exempt from City of Dover real estate taxes, except in
288 cases where the property is owned by a non-profit organization constructing or
289 renovating a dwelling unit to be transferred to non-tax-exempt homeowners; or
290 (c)(e) The beneficiary of the incentives is delinquent on any of the obligations listed in
291Dover Code, Chapter 1 - General Provisions, section 1-13(b).
292Section 3 2. Revocation of eligibility.
293 The beneficiary of the incentives provided by this Appendix must remain current on all
294 obligations due the city. If, at any time after the incentives have been granted, the beneficiary of
295 the incentives becomes delinquent on any of the obligations listed in Dover Code, Chapter 1-
296 General Provisions, section 1-13(b), the city manager shall revoke the eligibility for any portion
297 of the incentives not yet received by the beneficiary. Notice shall be given to such beneficiary in
298writing.

Paj 240

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C Downtown Redevelopment Page 8 Item #20.

299 300 ARTICLE IV. DEVELOPMENT INCENTIVES 301 Eligible projects within the Target Area and Downtown Development District shall be 302 eligible for the following development incentives: 303 Section 1. Waiver of permit fees. 304 Fees for building, plumbing, mechanical, and fire protection permits shall be waived for 305 eligible projects. Waivers do not apply to sign permits. 306 Section 2. Waiver of impact fees. 307 Eligible projects shall qualify for city water and wastewater impact fee waiver of the cost of 308 such fees as established in Dover Code, Chapter 110, Article III and Article IV. The city 309 cannot waive Kent County impact fees. 310 Section 3. Abatement of property taxes on the value of improvement. 311 Eligible projects shall receive property tax waivers for a period not to exceed ten years so 312 that improvements to the properties made in accordance with the intent of this ordinance will not 313 be taxed for a period of time not to exceed ten years from the date of the making of the 314 improvements. The said ten-year period will commence with the date of issuance of a building 315 permit final inspection or certificate of occupancy. 316 Eligible projects within the High Priority Target Area Downtown Development District 317 shall also be eligible for the following incentives: 318 Section 4. Business license fee waiver. 319 Businesses that open within or relocate to the Downtown Development District on or after 320 March 1, 2015, shall be eligible for a waiver of all city business license fees associated with the 321 business for a period of three years. Eligible businesses are still required to obtain the 322 required city business licenses. 323 Section 5. Rebate of the buyer’s portion of the real estate transfer tax. 324 • For properties which have transferred on or after March 1, 2015, the property owner shall be 325 eligible for a rebate of the buyer's portion of the real estate transfer tax upon issuance of a 326 certificate of occupancy, provided that a certificate of occupancy is issued for improvements to 327 the property within five years of the payment of the real estate transfer tax. 328 • Businesses that open within or relocate to the high priority target area on or after 329 March 1, 2015, shall be eligible for a waiver of all city business license fees 330 associated with the business for a period of three years. Eligible businesses are still 331 required to obtain the required city business licenses. 332 ARTICLE VI. ADMINISTRATION 333 The city manager and his/her staff shall develop the administrative procedures and 334 application forms necessary to implement this ordinance. If a potential beneficiary of the 335 development incentives submits an application for incentives after a fee has been paid, except 336 as otherwise provided in this appendix, the city will not issue a refund of fees paid. The city 337 manager and his staff shall promulgate reasonable standards to be used in determining 338 whether an eligible project shall receive development incentives and, if so, which incentives 339 shall be granted. Administrative staff shall review applications for development incentives and

Paj 241

Proposed Ordinance #2025-01 – Amending Appendix C Downtown Redevelopment Page 9 Item #20.

340 grant incentives to eligible projects. Applicants shall be notified of the action taken on their

341applications by mail.
342ARTICLE VII. - APPEALS
343 Applicants denied development incentives shall have the right to appeal the decision to the
344 city council within 30 days from the date that the notification was sent to the applicant of
345 mailing of the formal notification. Such appeal shall be in writing, signed by the owner of the
346property in question, and filed with the city clerk.
347
348ARTICLE VIII. SEVERABILITY AND EFFECTIVE DATE
349Section 1. Severability.
350 Should any section or provision of this ordinance be declared to be unconstitutional or
351 otherwise invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the ordinance as a whole or any
352 part thereof other than the parts so declared to be unconstitutional or invalid.
353Section 2. Effective date.
354This ordinance shall be effective as of January 1, 1991.
355
356ADOPTED: *
357
358SYNOPSIS
359 The purpose of this ordinance is to codify the updated boundary of the Downtown Development
360 District (DDD) approved by the State of Delaware. The amendments to Appendix C include:
361 The description of the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) is moved from definitions to its own
362 article. The description of the Board of Directors make-up references the DDP by-laws and
363 maintains the requirement that at least five (5) members represent downtown property owners.
364 It also reduces the frequency for the DDP to submit financial reports to City Council from
365 monthly to quarterly and reduces the frequency of operational reporting from monthly to
366annually.
367 The ordinance moves the details of development incentive eligibility requirements from
368 definitions to the article on eligibility. It modifies the “Target Area” to encompass the entire
369 DDD area. It renames the “High Priority Target Area” to “Downtown Development District”
370 and references the State designation. It modifies the DDD boundary to align with the updated
371DDD boundary approved by the State of Delaware (summer 2024).
372 The ordinance clarifies that the ineligibility of tax-exempt properties does not apply to non-
373 profits building or renovating houses that will be transferred to non-tax-exempt owners. It also
374 clarifies that the City cannot waive Kent County impact fees and that permit fee waivers do not
375apply to sign permits.
376(SPONSORS: )
377
378Actions History
37902/10/2025 – Scheduled for First Reading – City Council
38002/05/2025 – Proofreading Edits by Planning Staff
381 01/28/2025 – Introduction - Council Committee of the Whole/Legislative, Finance and
382Administration

Paj 242

Final Reading
Item #21.
CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02
2024‐2025 BUDGET ORDINANCES

1 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET: 2 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Fifty‐Nine Million Five Hundred Forty‐Seven Thousand 3 Four Hundred dollars ($59,565,400) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated 4 from current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal 5 Government for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:

6GENERAL FUND
7CASH RECEIPT SUMMARY FOR 2024‐2025
82024/252024/25
9BUDGETREVISED
10BEGINNING BALANCE$5,547,600 $5,547,600
11RECEIPTS
12FINES AND POLICE REVENUE781,100781,100
13LIBRARY REVENUES153,100153,100
14KENT COUNTY BOOK REIMBURSEMENT155,000155,000
15BUSINESS LICENSES1,616,4001,616,400
16PERMITS AND OTHER FEES1,785,0001,797,000
17MISCELLANEOUS RECEIPTS1,262,0001,250,000
18POLICE EXTRA DUTY497,500497,500
19PROPERTY TAXES16,876,00016,876,000
20RECREATION REVENUE145,000145,000
21FRANCHISE FEE600,000600,000
22SANITATION FEES‐‐
23RENT REVENUE ‐ GARRISON FARM76,80076,800
24COURT OF CHANCERY FEES3,500,0003,500,000
25INVESTMENT INCOME50,00050,000
26RECEIPTS SUBTOTAL27,497,90027,497,900
27INTERFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS
28INTERFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS GENERAL GOV1,679,5001,679,500
29INTERFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS PUBLIC WORKS857,600857,600
30INTERFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS CENT SRVCS2,035,7002,035,700
31INTERFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS FIN ADMIN2,553,4002,553,400
32INTERFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS SUBTOTAL7,126,2007,126,200
33GRANTS:
34POLICE EXTRA DUTY165,000165,000
35DEMA GRANT‐‐
36POLICE PENSION GRANT620,000620,000
37GREEN ENERGY GRANT98,50098,500
38POLICE GRANTS FUND145,000145,000
38GRANTS SUBTOTAL1,028,5001,028,500
39TRANSFERS FROM:
40TRANSFER TAX2,000,0002,000,000
41LODGING TAX500,000500,000
42AMBULANCE SERVICE600,000600,000
43MUNICIPAL STREET AID750,000750,000
44CIVIL TRAFFIC PENALTIES50,00050,000
45WATER/WASTEWATER2,000,0002,000,000
46ELECTRIC10,000,00012,465,200
47TRANSFERS FROM SUBTOTAL15,900,00018,365,200
48TOTAL REVENUES51,552,60054,017,800
49TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCE & REVENUE$57,100,200 $59,565,400

Paj 243

Final Reading
50 2024‐2025 BUDGET ORDINANCES Item #21.

51GENERAL FUND ‐ EXPENDITURES AND BUDGET BALANCE FOR 2024‐2025
522024/252024/25
53DEPARTMENT EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
54CITY CLERK$486,800 $486,800
55COUNCIL266,500266,500
56PLANNING898,800898,800
57CITY MANAGER1,279,0001,379,000
58HUMAN RESOURCES478,000478,000
59MAYOR304,600304,600
60FIRE1,008,3001,013,800
61LIFE SAFETY1,222,5001,222,500
62CODE ENFORCEMENT1,163,5001,161,500
63INSPECTIONS767,400769,400
64POLICE23,061,10023,061,100
65POLICE EXTRA DUTY405,000405,000
66PUBLIC WORKS ‐ ADMINISTRATION670,700670,700
67STREETS797,000797,000
68SANITATION‐‐
69GROUNDS MAINTENANCE1,788,5001,788,500
70STORMWATER‐1,021,200
71FACILITIES MANAGEMENT886,400886,400
72PUBLIC WORKS ‐ ENGINEERING292,900292,900
73LIBRARY2,146,0002,146,000
74RECREATION1,573,3001,583,300
75PROCUREMENT & INVENTORY958,600958,600
76FLEET MAINTENANCE1,081,4001,081,400
77INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY920,500920,500
78FINANCE1,009,9001,009,900
79CUSTOMER SERVICE1,456,8001,446,800
80DEPARTMENT SUBTOTALS44,923,50046,050,200
81OTHER EXPENSES
82DEBT SERVICE626,700626,700
83CONTRIBUTION TO DDP150,000150,000
84INSURANCE1,044,3001,044,300
85RETIREES HEALTH CARE2,103,9002,103,900
87BANK & CREDIT CARD FEES30,70030,700
88STREET LIGHTS841,100841,100
89OTHER EXPENSE SUBTOTAL4,796,7004,796,700
90TRANSFERS
91TRANSFER TO CAPITAL FUND ‐ PROJECTS3,173,6004,617,600
92APPROP. TO THE POLICE PENSION FUND350,800350,800
93APPROP. POLICE PENSION ‐ STATE GRANT692,800692,800
94APPROP. TO TE GENERAL PENSION FUND1,140,0001,140,000
95TRANSFER TO ECONOMIC DEV. RESERVE‐‐
96TRANSFER TO ELECTRIC FUND (ERP)25,00025,000
97TRANSFER TO INVENTORY RESERVE25,00025,000
98TRANSFERS SUBTOTAL5,407,2006,851,200
99TOTAL EXPENDITURES55,127,40057,698,100
100 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE1,972,8001,867,300
101 TOTALS$57,100,200 $59,565,400
102 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
103 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
104 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 244

Final Reading
105 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

106GOVERNMENTAL CAPITAL PROJECTS FUND
107REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025

108 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET: 109 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Thirteen Million Nine Hundred and Forty‐Five Thousand Two 110 Hundred dollars ($13,908,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current 111 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year 112 beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025: 113 REVENUES

1142024/252024/25
115BUDGETREVISED
116 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ PROJECTS$348,200 $5,245,300
117REVENUES
118MISCELLANEOUS RECIEPTS20,00020,000
118LINE OF CREDIT (HEAVY DUTY VEHICLES)‐811,400
119STATE GRANTS ‐ Other948,9002,493,900
120TRANSFER FROM GENERAL FUND3,173,6004,617,600
121TRANSFER FROM PARKLAND RESERVE‐‐
122TRANSFER FROM CAPITAL ASSET RESERVE‐220,000
123TRANSFER FROM LODGING TAX500,000500,000
124SUBTOTAL PROJECT RECEIPTS4,642,5008,662,900
125 TOTAL FUNDING SOURCES4,642,5008,662,900
126 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCE AND REVENUES$4,990,700 $13,908,200
127EXPENSE SUMMARY
1282024/252024/25
129EXPENDITURESBUDGETREVISED
130FIRE$566,600$614,400
131GROUNDS80,00080,000
132LIBRARY‐‐
133RECREATION1,160,0002,029,800
134CODE ENFORCEMENT‐‐
135INSPECTIONS‐‐
136POLICE1,488,1002,351,400
137STREETS415,8002,973,100
138STORMWATER‐4,366,100
139SANITATION‐‐
140CITY MANAGER‐‐
141INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY112,000172,200
142PUBLIC WORKS ‐ ADMINISTRATION‐‐
143FACILITIES MANAGEMENT‐83,000
144GENERAL FUND ENG‐‐
145PROCUREMENT & INVENTORY820,000890,000
146FLEET MAINTENANCE‐‐
147DEPARTMENT SUBTOTAL4,642,50013,560,000
148 BUDGET BALANCE348,200348,200
149 TOTAL BUDGET BALANCE & EXPENDITURES$4,990,700 $13,908,200
150 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
151 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
152 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 245

Final Reading
153 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

154GENERAL FUND CONTINGENCY
155CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
156 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
157 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seven Hundred Sixty‐Eight Thousand Four Hundred dollars
158 ($768,400) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
159 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
160beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
161CASH RECEIPTS
1622024/252024/25
163BUDGETREVISED
164 BEGINNING BALANCE$759,400$759,400
165 INTEREST EARNED9,0009,000
166 TOTALS$768,400 $768,400
167EXPENSE SUMMARY
1682024/252024/25
169BUDGETREVISED
170 CARRY FORWARD TO NEXT YEAR$768,400$768,400
171 TOTALS$768,400 $768,400
172 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
173 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
174 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 246

Final Reading
175 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

176GOVERNMENTAL CAPITAL ASSET RESERVE
177CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
178 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
179 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Million Five Hundred Twenty‐Four Thousand Nine
180 Hundred dollars ($1,524,900) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from
181 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for
182the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
183CASH RECEIPTS
1842024/252024/25
185BUDGETREVISED
186 BEGINNING BALANCE$1,514,900 $1,514,900
187 INTEREST EARNINGS10,00010,000
188 TOTALS$1,524,900 $1,524,900
189EXPENSE SUMMARY
1902024/252024/25
191BUDGETREVISED
192 CARRY FORWARD TO NEXT YEAR1,524,9001,524,900
193 TOTALS$1,524,900 $1,524,900
194 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
195 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
196 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 247

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
197
198PARKLAND/RECREATION RESERVE
199CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
200 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
201 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Three Hundred and Eighty‐Nine Thousand Nine Hundred dollars
202 ($389,900) much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other
203 funds for the use other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
204 fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
205OPERATING REVENUES
2062024/252024/25
207BUDGETREVISED
208 BEGINNING BALANCE$386,900 $386,900
209 INTEREST EARNINGS3,0003,000
210 TOTALS$389,900 $389,900
211OPERATING EXPENSES
2122024/252024/25
213BUDGETREVISED
214 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE389,900389,900
215 TOTALS$389,900 $389,900
216 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
217 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
218 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 248

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
219
220SANITATION
221CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
222 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
223 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Four Million Eight Hundred and Fifty‐One Thousand Six Hundred
224 dollars ($4,851,600) much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and
225 other funds for the use other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
226fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
227OPERATING REVENUES
2282024/252024/25
229BUDGETREVISED
230 BEGINNING BALANCE$‐ $‐
RECEIPTS
231 SANITATION SERVICES4,851,6004,851,600
232 TOTALS$4,851,600 $4,851,600
233OPERATING EXPENSES
2342024/252024/25
235DEPARTMENT EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
236SANITATION OPERATIONS$3,140,600 $3,140,600
237INTERFUND SERVICE FEES500,200500,200
238TRANSFER TO CONTINGENCY RESERVES140,000140,000
239TRANSFER TO CAPITAL FUND ‐ PROJECTS739,000739,000
240 TOTAL EXPENSES4,519,8004,519,800
241 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE331,800331,800
242 TOTALS$4,851,600 $4,851,600
243 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
244 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
245 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 249

Final Reading
Item #21.

246CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02
247SANITATION CAPITAL PROJECTS FUND
248CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
249 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
250 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Million One Hundred and Ninety‐One Thousand dollars
251 ($1,191,000) much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other
252 funds for the use other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
253fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
254REVENUES
2552024/252024/25
256BUDGETREVISED
257 BEGINNING BALANCE$‐ $207,000
258 TRANSFER FROM OPERATING FUND739,000739,000
259 LINE OF CREDIT (HEAVY DUTY VEHICLES)‐245,000
260 TOTALS$739,000 $1,191,000
261EXPENSE SUMMARY
2622024/252024/25
263 DEPARTMENT EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
264 SANITATION CAPITAL PROJECTS739,0001,191,000
265 TOTAL EXPENSES739,0001,191,000
266 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE‐‐
267 TOTALS$739,000 $1,191,000
268 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
269 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
270 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 250

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
271
272STORMWATER
273CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
274 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
275 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Zero dollars ($0) much thereof as may be necessary
276 are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other funds for the use other funds for the use by
277 several departments of the Municipal for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
278
279OPERATING REVENUES
2802024/252024/25
281BUDGETREVISED
282 BEGINNING BALANCE$‐ $‐
283 STORMWATER SERVICES4,180,200‐
284 TOTALS$4,180,200 $‐
285OPERATING EXPENSES
2862024/252024/25
287DEPARTMENT EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
288STORMWATER OPERATIONS$1,021,200 $‐
289INTERFUND SERVICE FEES496,300‐
290UNCOLLECTIBLES5,400‐
291TRANSFER TO CONTINGENCY RESERVES140,000‐
292TRANSFER TO CAPITAL FUND ‐ PROJECTS1,914,000‐
293 TOTAL EXPENSES3,576,900‐
294 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE603,300‐
295 TOTALS$4,180,200 $‐
296 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
297 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
298 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 251

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
299
300STORMWATER CAPITAL PROJECTS FUND
301CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
302 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
303 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Zero dollars ($0) much thereof as may be necessary are hereby
304 appropriated from current revenues and other funds for the use other funds for the use by several departments
305 of the Municipal Government for thefiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
306
307OPERATING REVENUES
3082024/252024/25
309BUDGETREVISED
310 BEGINNING BALANCE$‐ $‐
311 STATE GRANT335,000‐
312 STORMWATER SERVICES1,914,000‐
313 TOTALS$1,914,000 $‐
314OPERATING EXPENSES
3152024/252024/25
316 DEPARTMENT EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
317 STORMWATER CAPITAL PROJECTS2,249,000‐
318 TOTAL EXPENSES2,249,000‐
319 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE‐‐
320 TOTALS$2,249,000 $‐
321 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
322 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
323 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 252

Final Reading
323 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

324WATER FUND
325REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
326 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
327 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Eight Million Nine Hundred Sixty‐Six Thousand dollars
328 ($8,966,000) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
329 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
330beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
3312024/252024/25
332BUDGETREVISED
333 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WATER$1,536,000 $1,536,000
334 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES1,536,0001,536,000
335BASE REVENUE
336STATE GRANT17,50017,500
337WATER SERVICES6,566,9006,566,900
338WATER TANK SPACE LEASING450,500450,500
339WATER IMPACT FEES230,000230,000
340INTEREST ‐ WATER100,000100,000
341MISCELLANEOUS SERVICE FEE65,20065,200
342TOTAL REVENUES7,430,1007,430,100
343 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES AND REVENUES$8,966,100 $8,966,100

Paj 253

Final Reading
344 2024‐2025 BUDGET ORDINANCES Item #21.

345WATER FUND ‐ EXPENSES AND BUDGET BALANCE FOR 2024‐2025
3462024/252024/25
347DIRECT EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
348ENGINEERING & INSPECTION$425,700 $425,700
349WATER DEPARTMENT881,300881,300
350WATER TREATMENT PLANT3,201,5003,201,500
351DIRECT EXPENDITURE SUBTOTAL4,508,5004,508,500
352OTHER EXPENSES
353DEBT SERVICE ‐ WATER695,600695,600
354RETIREES HEALTH CARE‐‐
355OTHER EMPLOYMENT EXPENSES109,500109,500
355INTERFUND SERVICE FEES1,029,9001,029,900
356BANK & CREDIT CARD FEES20,00020,000
357OTHER EXPENSES SUBTOTAL1,855,0001,855,000
358TRANSFER TO:
359GENERAL FUND FROM WATER1,000,0001,000,000
360WATER IMP AND EXT503,000503,000
361ELECTRIC FUND (ERP)25,00025,000
362TRANSFER TO INVENTORY WRITE‐OFFS5,0005,000
363TRANSFER TO SUBTOTAL1,533,0001,533,000
364 TOTAL EXPENSES7,896,5007,896,500
365 BUDGET BALANCES
366 BUDGET BALANCE WATER1,069,6001,069,600
367 BUDGET BALANCE SUBTOTALS1,069,6001,069,600
368 TOTAL CURRENT YEAR BALANCES AND EXPENSES$8,966,100 $8,966,100
369 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
370 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
371 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 254

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
372
373WATER IMPROVEMENT & EXTENSION FUND
374CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025

375 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET: 376 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Eight Million Nine Hundred and Sixty‐Three Thousand Nine 377 Hundred dollars ($8,963,900) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from 378 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government

379for the fiscal year begining July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
380CASH RECEIPTS
3812024/252024/25
382BUDGETREVISED
383 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WATER$1,900,100 $4,317,800
384 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES1,900,1004,317,800
385REVENUES
386STATE GRANT ‐ WATER2,009,0004,018,000
387TRANS FR OPERATING FUND ‐ WATER503,000503,000
388TRANSFER FR WATER IMPACT FEE‐75,100
389INTEREST INCOME50,00050,000
390TOTAL REVENUES2,562,0004,646,100
391 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES & REVENUES$4,462,100 $8,963,900
392EXPENSE SUMMARY
3932024/252024/25
394EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
395ENGINEERING$26,900$26,900
396WATER3,456,7007,886,700
397WATER TREATMENT PLANT885,000956,800
398TOTAL EXPENSES4,368,6008,870,400
399 BUDGET BALANCE ‐ WATER93,50093,500
400 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS93,50093,500
401 TOTAL BUDGET BALANCES & EXPENSES$4,462,100 $8,963,900
402 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
403 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
404 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 255

Final Reading
405 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

406WASTEWATER FUND
407REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
408 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
409 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Fourteen Million One Hundred and Sixty‐Six Thousand Two
410 Hundreddollars ($14,166,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from
411 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government
412for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
4132024/252024/25
414BUDGETREVISED
415 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER$3,942,400 $3,942,400
416 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES3,942,4003,942,400
417BASE REVENUE
418WASTEWATER SERVICES4,193,6004,193,600
419WASTEWATER TREATMENT SERVICES3,672,6003,672,600
420GROUNDWATER INFLOW ADJUSTMENT1,977,4001,977,400
421WASTEWATER IMPACT FEES230,000230,000
422INTEREST ‐ WASTEWATER100,000100,000
423MISCELLANEOUS SERVICE FEE50,20050,200
424TOTAL REVENUES10,223,80010,223,800
425 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES AND REVENUES$14,166,200 $14,166,200

Paj 256

Final Reading
426 2024‐2025 BUDGET ORDINANCES Item #21.

427WASTEWATER FUND ‐ EXPENSES AND BUDGET BALANCE FOR 2024‐2025
4282024/252024/25
429DIRECT EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
430ENGINEERING & INSPECTION$382,000 $382,000
431WASTEWATER DEPARTMENT1,369,0001,369,000
432DIRECT EXPENDITURE SUBTOTAL1,751,0001,751,000
433OTHER EXPENSES
434DEBT SERVICE ‐ WASTEWATER614,200614,200
435RETIREES HEALTH CARE‐‐
436OTHER EMPLOYMENT EXPENSES4,6004,600
436KENT COUNTY TREATMENT CHARGE5,198,6005,198,600
437INTERFUND SERVICE FEES724,900724,900
438BANK & CREDIT CARD FEES6,0006,000
439OTHER EXPENSES SUBTOTAL6,548,3006,548,300
440TRANSFER TO:
441GENERAL FUND FROM WASTEWATER1,000,0001,000,000
442WASTEWATER IMP AND EXT1,329,9001,329,900
443ELETRIC FUND (ERP)25,00025,000
444TRANSFER TO INVENTORY WRITE‐OFFS5,0005,000
445TRANSFER TO SUBTOTAL2,359,9002,359,900
446 TOTAL EXPENSES10,659,20010,659,200
447 BUDGET BALANCES
448 BUDGET BALANCE WASTEWATER3,507,0003,507,000
449 BUDGET BALANCE SUBTOTALS3,507,0003,507,000
450 TOTAL CURRENT YEAR BALANCES AND EXPENSES$14,166,200 $14,166,200
451 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
452 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
453 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 257

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
454
455WASTEWATER IMPROVEMENT & EXTENSION FUND
456CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025

457 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET: 458 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Five Million Eight Hundred and Fifty‐Two Thousand 459 dollars ($5,852,000) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated current 460 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government

461for the fiscal year begining July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
462CASH RECEIPTS
4632024/252024/25
464BUDGETREVISED
465 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER$767,900 $3,760,900
466REVENUES
467STATE GRANT354,000454,000
468TRANS FR OPERATING FUND ‐ WW1,329,9001,329,900
469TRANSFER FR WASTEWATER IMPACT FEE7,200287,200
470INTEREST INCOME20,00020,000
471TOTAL REVENUES1,711,1002,091,100
472 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES & REVENUES$2,479,000 $5,852,000
473EXPENSE SUMMARY
4742024/252024/25
475 EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
476 WASTEWATER$1,691,100 $5,064,100
477 TOTAL EXPENSES1,691,1005,064,100
478 BUDGET BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER787,900787,900
479 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS787,900787,900
480 TOTAL BUDGET BALANCES & EXPENSES$2,479,000 $5,852,000
481 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
482 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
483 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 258

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
484
485WATER CAPITAL ASSET RESERVE
486CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
487 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
488 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Six Hundred One Thousand Five Hundred dollars ($601,500)
489 or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other funds
490 for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning
491 July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
492CASH RECEIPTS
4932024/252024/25
494BUDGETREVISED
495 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WATER$594,500 $594,500
496 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES594,500594,500
497 RECEIPTS
498 INTEREST EARNINGS ‐ WATER7,0007,000
499 TOTAL RECEIPTS7,0007,000
500 TOTALS$601,500 $601,500
501EXPENSE SUMMARY
5022024/252024/25
503BUDGETREVISED
504 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE ‐ WATER$601,500 $601,500
505 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS601,500601,500
506 TOTALS$601,500 $601,500
507 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
508 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
509 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 259

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
510
511WASTEWATER CAPITAL ASSET RESERVE
512CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
513 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
514 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Six Hundred Thousand One Hundred dollars ($600,100)
515 or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other
516 funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning
517 July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
518CASH RECEIPTS
5192024/252024/25
520BUDGETREVISED
521 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER$593,100 $593,100
522 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES593,100593,100
523 RECEIPTS
524 INTEREST EARNINGS ‐ WASTEWATER7,0007,000
525 TOTAL RECEIPTS7,0007,000
526 TOTALS$600,100 $600,100
527EXPENSE SUMMARY
5282024/252024/25
529BUDGETREVISED
530 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER$600,100 $600,100
531 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS600,100600,100
532 TOTALS$600,100 $600,100
533 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
534 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
535 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 260

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
536
537WATER IMPACT FEE RESERVE
538CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
539 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
540 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Million Eight Hundred Fifteen Thousand Two Hundred
541 dollars ($1,815,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
542 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
543fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
544CASH RECEIPTS
5452024/252024/25
546BUDGETREVISED
547 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WATER$1,795,200 $1,795,200
548 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES1,795,2001,795,200
549 RECEIPTS
550 INTEREST EARNINGS ‐ WATER20,00020,000
551 TOTAL RECEIPTS20,00020,000
552 TOTALS$1,815,200 $1,815,200
553EXPENSE SUMMARY
5542024/252024/25
555BUDGETREVISED
556 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE ‐ WATER$1,815,200 $1,815,200
557 TRANSFER TO I & E FUND FROM WATER IMPACT FEES‐‐
558 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS1,815,2001,815,200
559 TOTALS$1,815,200 $1,815,200
560 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
561 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
562 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 261

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
563
564WASTEWATER IMPACT FEE RESERVE
565CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
566 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
567 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Five Million Three Hundred Sixty‐Seven Thousand Nine Hundred
568 dollars ($5,367,900) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
569 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal
570year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
571CASH RECEIPTS
5722024/252024/25
573BUDGETREVISED
574 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER$5,317,900 $5,317,900
575 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES5,317,9005,317,900
576 RECEIPTS
577 INTEREST EARNINGS ‐ WASTEWATER50,00050,000
578 TOTAL RECEIPTS50,00050,000
579TOTALS$5,367,900 $5,367,900
580EXPENSE SUMMARY
5812024/252024/25
582BUDGETREVISED
583CURRENT YEAR BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER$5,142,900 $5,142,900
584TRANSFER TO I & E FUND FROM WASTEWATER IMPACT FEES$225,000 $225,000
585CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS5,367,9005,367,900
586 TOTALS$5,367,900 $5,367,900
587 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
588 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
589 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 262

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
590
591WATER CONTINGENCY RESERVE
592CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
593 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
594 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Three Hundred Seventeen Thousand Seven Hundred dollars
595 ($317,700) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and
596 other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
597beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
598CASH RECEIPTS
5992024/252024/25
600BUDGETREVISED
601 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WATER$313,700 $313,700
602 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES313,700313,700
603 RECEIPTS
604 INTEREST EARNINGS ‐ WATER4,0004,000
605 TOTAL RECEIPTS4,0004,000
606 TOTALS$317,700 $317,700
607BUDGET SUMMARY
6082024/252024/25
609BUDGETREVISED
610 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE ‐ WATER$317,700 $317,700
611 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS317,700317,700
612 TOTAL EXPENSES AND CURRENT YEAR BALANCES$317,700 $317,700
613 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
614 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
615 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 263

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
616
617WASTEWATER CONTINGENCY RESERVE
618CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
619 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
620 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Three Hundred Seventeen Thousand Eight Hundred dollars
621 ($317,800) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and
622 other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning
623July 1, 2023 andending June 30, 2024:
624CASH RECEIPTS
6252024/252024/25
626BUDGETREVISED
627 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER$313,800 $313,800
628 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES313,800313,800
629 RECEIPTS
630 INTEREST EARNINGS ‐ WASTEWATER4,0004,000
631 TOTAL RECEIPTS4,0004,000
632 TOTALS$317,800 $317,800
633BUDGET SUMMARY
6342024/252024/25
635BUDGETREVISED
636 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE ‐ WASTEWATER$317,800 $317,800
637 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS317,800317,800
638 TOTAL EXPENSES AND CURRENT YEAR BALANCES$317,800 $317,800
639 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
640 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
641 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 264

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
642
643ELECTRIC REVENUE FUND
644REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
645 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
646 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Hurdred Forty‐Four Million Fifty‐One Thousand
647 Six Hundred dollars ($144,051,600) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated
648 from current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal
649 Government for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
6502024/252024/25
651BUDGETREVISED
652 BEGINNING BALANCE$46,148,500$46,148,500
653 DISTRIBUTION OF EARNINGS ‐ PCA CREDIT‐‐
654 BEGINNING BALANCE ‐ ADJUSTED46,148,50046,148,500
655BASE REVENUE
656DIRECT SALES TO CUSTOMER91,131,20091,131,200
657UTILITY TAX1,356,1001,356,100
658MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE608,000608,000
659RENT REVENUE136,000136,000
660GREEN ENERGY135,000135,000
661INTEREST EARNINGS1,500,0001,500,000
662TRANSFER FROM RATE STABILIZATION‐2,961,800
663TRANSFER FROM OTHER FUNDS (ERP)75,00075,000
664TOTAL REVENUES94,941,30097,903,100
665 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCE & REVENUES$141,089,800 $144,051,600

Paj 265

Final Reading

2024‐2025 BUDGET ORDINANCESItem #21.
666
667ELECTRIC REVENUE FUND EXPENSES AND BUDGET BALANCE FOR 2024‐2025
6682024/252024/25
669EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
670POWER SUPPLY$24,945,600 $24,945,600
671SOLAR ENERGY3,700,8003,700,800
672SOLAR RENEWAL ENERGY CREDITS381,900381,900
673POWER SUPPLY MANAGEMENT701,800701,800
674REC'S (Renewable Energy Credits)6,429,2006,429,200
675RGGI (Regional Greenhouse Gas Init.)70,50070,500
676PJM CHARGES ‐ ENERGY11,932,00011,932,000
677PJM CHARGES ‐ TRANSMISSION & FEES13,645,20013,645,200
678CAPACITY CHARGES23,451,80023,451,800
679SUB‐TOTAL POWER SUPPLY85,258,80085,258,800
680PLANT OPERATIONS2,296,8002,296,800
681GENERATIONS FUELS191,300191,300
682PJM SPOT MARKET ENERGY(147,000)(147,000)
683PJM CREDITS(262,800)(262,800)
684CAPACITY CREDITS(10,404,300)(10,404,300)
685GENERATION SUBTOTAL(8,326,000)(8,326,000)
686POWER SUPPLY & GENERATION SUBTOTAL76,932,80076,932,800
687DIRECT EXPENDITURES
688TRANSMISSION/DISTRIBUTION5,205,1005,205,100
689ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING1,937,0001,937,000
690ADMINISTRATION1,129,1001,129,100
691METER READING529,800529,800
692SYSTEMS OPERATIONS1,067,5001,067,500
693DIRECT EXPENDITURE SUBTOTALS9,868,5009,868,500
694OTHER EXPENSES:
695UTILITY TAX1,356,1001,356,100
696ALLOW FOR UNCOLLECTIBLES300,000300,000
697CONTRACTUAL SERVICES ‐ RFP'S50,00050,000
698LEGAL EXPENSES50,00050,000
699RETIREES HEALTH CARE‐‐
700OTHER EMPLOYMENT EXPENSES954,000954,000
701GREEN ENERGY GRANT135,000135,000
702INTERFUND SERVICE FEES4,371,6004,868,200
703INTEREST ON DEPOSITS20,00020,000
704BANK & CREDIT CARD FEES619,300619,300
705DEBT SERVICE1,441,9001,441,900
706STORM EXPENSE150,000150,000
707OTHER EXPENSES SUBTOTAL9,447,9009,944,500
708 TRANSFER TO:
709 GENERAL FUND10,000,00012,465,200
710 OTHER RESERVES30,00030,000
711 TRANSFER TO INVENTORY WRITE‐OFFS100,000100,000
712 TRANSFER TO SUBTOTAL10,130,00012,595,200
713 TOTAL EXPENSES106,379,200109,341,000
714 BUDGET BALANCE ‐ WORKING CAPITAL34,710,60034,710,600
715 TOTALS$141,089,800 $144,051,600
716 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
717 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
718 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 266

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
719
720ELECTRIC UTILITY IMPROVEMENT AND EXTENSION FUND
721CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025

722 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET: 723 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Forty‐Five Million One Hundred and Twenty‐Five Thousand 724 dollars ($45,125,000) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from 725 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government

726for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
727REVENUES
7282024/252024/25
729BUDGETREVISED
730 BEGINNING BALANCE$33,165,000 $40,276,000
731REVENUES
732GRANT/BOND/LOAN‐‐
733GENERAL SERVICE BILLING1,000,0001,000,000
734TRF FROM DEPRECIATION RSV‐1,849,000
735TRF FROM FUTURE CAPACITY2,000,0002,000,000
736TOTAL REVENUES3,000,0004,849,000
737 TOTALS$36,165,000 $45,125,000
738EXPENSE SUMMARY
7392024/252024/25
740EXPENSESBUDGETREVISED
741ELECTRIC ADMINISTRATION$‐ $1,078,600
742ELECTRIC GENERATION470,0002,379,000
743TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION3,090,0003,905,400
744ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING3,986,0007,339,500
745METER READING‐‐
745ERP SYSTEM‐1,803,500
746TOTAL EXPENSES7,546,00016,506,000
747 BUDGET BALANCE28,619,00028,619,000
748 TOTAL BUDGET BALANCE & EXPENSES$36,165,000 $45,125,000
749 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
750 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
751 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 267

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
752
753ELECTRIC UTILITY CONTINGENCY RESERVE
754CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
755 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
756 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Nine Hundred Seventy‐Nine Thousand Three Hundred dollars
757 ($979,300) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
758 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
759beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
760CASH RECEIPTS
7612024/252024/25
762BUDGETREVISED
763 BEGINNING BALANCE$969,300 $969,300
764 RECEIPTS
765 INTEREST EARNINGS10,00010,000
766 TOTAL RECEIPTS10,00010,000
767 TOTALS$979,300 $979,300
768EXPENSE SUMMARY
7692024/252024/25
770BUDGETREVISED
771 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE$979,300 $979,300
772 TOTALS$979,300 $979,300
773 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
774 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
775 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 268

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
776
777ELECTRIC UTILITY DEPRECIATION RESERVE
778SOURCES AND USE OF FUNDS FOR 2024‐2025
779 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
780 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Thirteen Million Five Hundred Seventeen Thousand Eight
781 dollars ($13,517,800) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from
782 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government
783for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
784CASH RECEIPTS
7852024/252024/25
786BUDGETREVISED
787 BEGINNING BALANCE$13,267,800 $13,267,800
788 INTEREST EARNINGS250,000250,000
789 TOTALS$13,517,800 $13,517,800
790BUDGET SUMMARY
7912024/252024/25
792BUDGETREVISED
793 TRANSFER TO ELECTRIC I & E$‐$2,961,800
794 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE13,517,80010,556,000
795 TOTALS$13,517,800 $13,517,800
795 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
796 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
797 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 269

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
798
799ELECTRIC UTILITY FUTURE CAPACITY RESERVE
800SOURCES AND USE OF FUNDS FOR 2024‐2025
801 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
802 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Fourteen Million Seven Hundred Sixteen Thousand Nine
803 Hundred dollars ($14,716,900) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated
804 from current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal
805 Government for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
806CASH RECEIPTS
8072024/252024/25
808BUDGETREVISED
809 BEGINNING BALANCE$14,581,900 $14,581,900
810 INTEREST EARNINGS135,000135,000
811 TOTALS$14,716,900 $14,716,900
812BUDGET SUMMARY
8132024/252024/25
814BUDGETREVISED
815 TRANSFER TO ELECTRIC I & E2,000,000 $2,000,000
816 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE$12,716,900 $12,716,900
817 TOTALS$14,716,900 $14,716,900
818 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
819 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
820 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 270

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
821
822ELECTRIC UTILITY INSURANCE STABLIZATION RESERVE
823SOURCES AND USE OF FUNDS FOR 2024‐2025
824 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
825 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Eight Hundred Sixty‐Two Thousand Five Hundred dollars
826 ($862,500) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and
827 other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
828beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
829CASH RECEIPTS
8302024/252024/25
831BUDGETREVISED
832 BEGINNING BALANCE$853,500 $853,500
833 INTEREST EARNINGS9,0009,000
834 TOTALS$862,500 $862,500
835BUDGET SUMMARY
8362024/252024/25
837BUDGETREVISED
838 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE$862,500 $862,500
839 TOTALS$862,500 $862,500
840 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
841 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
842 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 271

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
843
844ELECTRIC UTILITY RATE STABLIZATION RESERVE
845SOURCES AND USE OF FUNDS FOR 2024‐2025
846 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
847 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Ten Million Four Hundred and Twenty‐Four Thousand
848 Seven Hundred dollars($10,424,400) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated
849 from current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal
850 Governmentfor the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
851CASH RECEIPTS
8522024/252024/25
853BUDGETREVISED
854 BEGINNING BALANCE$10,314,400 $10,424,400
855 INTEREST EARNINGS110,000110,000
856 TOTALS$10,424,400 $10,534,400
857BUDGET SUMMARY
8582024/252024/25
859BUDGETREVISED
860 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE10,424,40010,424,400
861 TOTALS$10,424,400 $10,424,400
862 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
863 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
864 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 272

Final Reading
865 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

866MUNICIPAL STREET AID FUND
867CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
868 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
869 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seven Hundred Fifty Thousand One Hundred dollars
870 ($750,100) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
871 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
872beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
873CASH RECEIPTS
8742024/252024/25
875BUDGETREVISED
876 BEGINNING BALANCE$100 $100
877 STATE GRANT750,000750,000
878 TOTALS$750,100 $750,100
879BUDGET SUMMARY
8802024/252024/25
881BUDGETREVISED
882 TRANSFER TO GENERAL FUND$750,000 $750,000
883 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE100100
884 TOTALS$750,100 $750,100
885 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
886 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
887 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 273

Final Reading
888 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

889ELECTRONIC RED LIGHT SAFETY PROGRAM
890CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
891 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
892 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Fifty Thousand One Hundred dollars ($50,100) or
893 so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other
894 funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
895 beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
896CASH RECEIPTS
8972024/252024/25
898BUDGETREVISED
899 BEGINNING BALANCE$100 $100
900 POLICE FINES50,00050,000
901 TOTALS$50,100 $50,100
902BUDGET SUMMARY
9032024/252024/25
904BUDGETREVISED
905 TRANSFER TO GENERAL FUND$50,000$50,000
906 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE100100
907 TOTALS$50,100 $50,100
908 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
909 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
910 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 274

Final Reading

CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02Item #21.
911
912WORKERS COMPENSATION FUND
913CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
914 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
915 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Five Million Four Hundred Two Thousand dollars
916 ($5,402,000) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
917 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government
918for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
919OPERATING REVENUES
9202024/252024/25
921BUDGETREVISED
922 BEGINNING BALANCE$4,138,000 $4,138,000
923 INTEREST INCOME120,000120,000
924 PREMIUM FROM CITY1,144,0001,144,000
925TOTALS$5,402,000 $5,402,000
926OPERATING EXPENSES
9272024/252024/25
928BUDGETREVISED
929PROGRAM EXPENSES/SUPPLIES ‐ CLAIMS$300,000 $300,000
930INSURANCE200,000200,000
931STATE OF DEL ‐ SELF INSURANCE TAX30,00030,000
932CONTRACTUAL SERVICES35,00035,000
933 TOTAL EXPENSES565,000565,000
934 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE4,837,0004,837,000
935 TOTALS$5,402,000 $5,402,000
936 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
937 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
938 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 275

Final Reading
Item #21.

939CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02
940COMMUNITY TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT FUND
941CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
942 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
943 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Hundred Fifty‐Four Thousand Five Hundred dollars
944 ($154,500) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
945 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
946 beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
947OPERATING REVENUES
9482024/252024/25
949BUDGETREVISED
950 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE$114,500 $114,500
951 GRANTS REVENUE40,00040,000
952 TOTALS$114,500 $154,500
953OPERATING EXPENSES
9542024/252024/25
955BUDGETREVISED
956 PROGRAM EXP. GRANT RELATED$40,000 $40,000
957 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE114,500114,500
958 TOTALS$154,500 $154,500
959 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
960 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
961 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 276

Final Reading
Item #21.

962CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02
963LIBRARY GRANT FUND
964CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
965 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
966 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Five Hundred Sixty Thousand Five Hundred Ninety‐Four
967 dollars ($560,594) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
968 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
969 fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
970OPERATING REVENUES
9712024/252024/25
972BUDGETREVISED
973 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE$‐$159,917
974 STATE GRANT381,603396,939
975 FEDERAL GRANT3,7383,738
976 OTHER GRANTS‐‐
977 TOTALS$385,341 $560,594
978OPERATING EXPENSES
9792024/252024/25
980BUDGETREVISED
981STATE GRANTS
982FURNITURE/FIXTURES$15,003 $44,096
983OFFICE SUPPLIES30,00048,095
984PRINTING AND DUPLICATING10,00017,418
985PROGRAM EXPENSES/SUPPLIES37,00057,955
986BOOKS145,000159,412
987COMPUTER SOFTWARE6,00012,101
988COMPUTER HARDWARE30,00047,653
989AUDIO VISUAL SUPPLIES85,00098,736
990POSTAGE100121
991ADVERTISING10,00011,089
992TRAINING/CONF/FOOD/TRAV5,0005,688
993CONTRACTUAL SERVICES‐43,500
994OFF EQP/REPAIRS & MAINT2,0003,339
995OTHER EQUIP ‐ LEASE6,0007,153
996STATE GRANT PROG EXP500500
997SUBTOTAL EXPENSES STATE GRANTS381,603556,856
998 FEDERAL GRANTS
999 PROGRAM EXPENSES/SUPPLIES3,7383,738
1000 SUBTOTAL EXPENSES FEDERAL GRANTS3,7383,738
1001 GRAND TOTAL EXPENSES385,341560,594
1002 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE‐‐
1003 TOTALS$385,341 $560,594
1004 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1005 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1006 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 277

Final Reading
1007 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1008CDBG GRANT FUND
1009CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1010 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1011 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Six Hundred Forty‐Eight Thousand Nine Hundred Fifty‐Nine
1012 dollars ($648,959) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
1013 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
1014beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1015OPERATING REVENUES
10162024/252024/25
1017BUDGETREVISED
1018 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE4,013339,365
1019 CDBG GRANTS RECEIVED‐309,594
1020‐
1021 TOTALS$4,013 $648,959
1022OPERATING EXPENSES
10232024/252024/25
1024BUDGETREVISED
1025EXPENDITURES
1026PRIOR YEAR CLOSING COST/DOWN PAYMENT PROGRAM$‐$90,516
1027PRIOR YEAR DIFMH RENOVATIONS‐‐
1028PRIOR YEAR MHDC EMERGENCY HOME REPAIR‐71,115
1029PRIOR YEAR MHDC HOMEOWNER REHAB.‐59,399
1030PRIOR YEAR DIMH & CENTRAL DE HOUSING COLLAB‐12,360
1029PRIOR YEAR HOUSE OF HOPE‐23,077
1030PRIOR YEAR ADMIN EXPENSE‐82,899
1031CURRENT YEAR CLOSING COST/DOWN PAYMENT PROGRAM‐106,235
1032CURRENT YEAR DIFMH RENOVATIONS‐‐
1033CURRENT YEAR HABITAT FOR HUMANITY‐‐
1034CURRENT YEAR MHDC HOMEOWNER REHAB.‐55,000
1035CURRENT YEAR HOUSE OF HOPE‐31,440
1036CURRENT YEAR MHDC HOMEOWNER REHAB.‐40,000
1037CURRENT YEAR DIMH & CENTRAL DE HOUSING COLLAB‐15,000
1038CURRENT YEAR ADMIN EXPENSE‐61,919
1039TOTAL EXPENDITURES‐648,959
1040 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE4,013‐
1041 TOTALS$4,013 $648,959
1042 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1043 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1044 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 278

Final Reading
1045 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1046210 ‐ ARPA FUNDING
1047CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1048 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1049 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Two million Nine Hundred Thirty‐Nine Thousand Two Hundred
1050 dollars ($2,939,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
1051 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
1052beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1053OPERATING REVENUES
10542024/252024/25
1055BUDGETREVISED
1056 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE$2,864,200 $2,864,200
1057 INTEREST INCOME75,00075,000
1058 TOTALS$2,939,200 $2,939,200
1059OPERATING EXPENSES
10602024/252024/25
1061BUDGETREVISED
1062EXPENDITURES
1063PROGRAM EXPENSE/SUPPLIES$1,189,700 $1,189,700
1064CONSTRUCTION1,401,0001,401,000
1065TOTAL EXPENDITURES2,590,7002,590,700
1066 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE348,500348,500
1067 TOTALS$2,939,200 $2,939,200
1068 The above budget represents the combination of all State & Federal Grants.
1069 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1070 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1071 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 279

Final Reading
1072 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1073207 ‐ POLICE GRANTS FUND
1074CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1075 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1076 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Million Sixty‐Three Thousand and Two Hundred dollars
1077 ($1,682,600) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
1078 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
1079beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1080OPERATING REVENUES
10812024/252024/25
1082BUDGETREVISED
1083 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE$1,063,200 $1,063,200
1084 STATE AND FEDERAL GRANTS RECEIVED619,400619,400
1085 TOTALS$1,682,600 $1,682,600
1086OPERATING EXPENSES
10872024/252024/25
1088BUDGETREVISED
1089EXPENDITURES
1090MATERIALS AND SUPPLIES
1091PROGRAM EXPENSE410,000410,000
1091POLICE EQUIPT & PROG SUPP375,000375,000
1092ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENDITURES
1093TRAINING20,00020,000
1094TOTAL EXPENDITURES805,000805,000
1095 OTHER FINANCING USES
1096 OPERATING TRANSFERS‐OUT379,400379,400
1097 TOTAL FINANCING USES379,400379,400
1098 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE498,200498,200
1099 TOTALS$1,682,600 $1,682,600
1100 The above budget represents the combination of all State & Federal Grants.
1101 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1102 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1103 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 280

Final Reading
1104 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1105LODGING TAX FUND
1106CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1107 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1108 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Million dollars ($1,000,000) or so much thereof
1109 as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other funds for the use
1110 by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning
1111July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1112CASH RECEIPTS
11132024/252024/25
1114BUDGETREVISED
1115 BEGINNING BALANCE$‐ $‐
1116 LODGING TAXES1,000,0001,000,000
1117 TOTALS$1,000,000 $1,000,000
1118BUDGET SUMMARY
11192024/252024/25
1120BUDGETREVISED
1121 TRANSFER TO CAPITAL PROJECT FUND$500,000 $500,000
1122 TRANSFER TO GOVT CAPITAL FUND500,000500,000
1123 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE1,000,0001,000,000
1124 TOTALS$1,000,000 $1,000,000
1125 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1126 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1127 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 281

Final Reading
1128 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1129209 ‐ POLICE GRANTS FUND
1130CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1131 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1132 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Five Hundred Twelve Thousand and Two Hundred Twenty‐Four
1133 dollars ($512,224) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
1134 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
1135beginning July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1136OPERATING REVENUES
11372024/252024/25
1138BUDGETREVISED
1139 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE$122,224 $122,224
1140 STATE AND FEDERAL GRANTS RECEIVED390,000390,000
1141 TOTALS$512,224 $512,224
1142OPERATING EXPENSES
11432024/252024/25
1144BUDGETREVISED
1145 MATERIALS AND SUPPLIES
1146POLICE EQUIPT & PROG SUPP342,500342,500
1147 ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENDITURES
1148 TOTAL EXPENDITURES342,500342,500
1149 OTHER FINANCING USES
1150 OPERATING TRANSFERS‐OUT47,50047,500
1151 TOTAL FINANCING USES47,50047,500
1152 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE122,224122,224
1153 TOTALS$512,224 $512,224
1154 The above budget represents the combination of all State & Federal Grants.
1155 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1156 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1157 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 282

Final Reading
1158 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1159SUBSTANCE ABUSE GRANTS FUND
1160CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1161 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1162 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seventy‐Three Thousand dollars ($73,000) or so much
1163 thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other funds
1164 for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning
1165July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1166OPERATING REVENUES
11672024/252024/25
1168BUDGETREVISED
1169 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE$‐$‐
1170 STATE GRANTS RECEIVED40,00040,000
1171 RECREATION REVENUE33,00033,000
1172 TOTALS$82,200 $73,000
1173OPERATING EXPENSES
11742024/252024/25
1175BUDGETREVISED
1176EXPENDITURES
1177TEMPORARY HELP/BENEFITS$43,000 $43,000
1178PROGRAM EXPENSES/SUPPLIES30,00030,000
1179TOTAL EXPENDITURES73,00073,000
1180 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE‐‐
1181 TOTALS$73,000 $73,000
1182 The above budget represents the combination of all State & Federal Grants.
1183 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1184 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1185 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 283

Final Reading
1186 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1187REALTY TRANSFER TAX FUND
1188CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1189 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1190 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Two Million dollars ($2,000,000) or so much thereof
1191 as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other funds for
1192 the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning
1193July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1194CASH RECEIPTS
11952024/252024/25
1196BUDGETREVISED
1197 BEGINNING BALANCE$‐ $‐
1198 REALTY TRANSFER TAXES2,000,0002,000,000
1199 TOTALS$2,000,000 $2,000,000
1200BUDGET SUMMARY
12012024/252024/25
1202BUDGETREVISED
1203 TRANSFER TO GENERAL FUND$2,000,000$2,000,000
1204 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE‐‐
1205 TOTALS$2,000,000 $2,000,000
1206 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1207 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1208 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 284

Final Reading
1209 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1210ECONOMIC & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
1211CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1212 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1213 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seven Hunddred and Thirty‐Four Thousnd dollars ($734,000) or
1214 so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other funds for
1215 the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning
1216July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1217CASH RECEIPTS
12182024/252024/25
1219BUDGETREVISED
1220 BEGINNING BALANCE$734,000 $734,000
1221 TRANSFER FROM GENERAL FUND‐‐
1222 TOTALS$734,000 $734,000
1223BUDGET SUMMARY
12242024/252024/25
1225BUDGETREVISED
1226 PROGRAM EXPENSE$‐$‐
1227 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE734,000734,000
1228 TOTALS$734,000 $734,000
1229 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1230 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1231 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Paj 285

Final Reading
1232 CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2025‐02 Item #21.

1233AMULANCE SERVICE
1234CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2024‐2025
1235 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1236 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Eight Hundred and Fifty Thousand dollars ($850,000) or so
1237 much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other funds for
1238 the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning
1239July 1, 2024 and ending June 30, 2025:
1240CASH RECEIPTS
12412024/252024/25
1242BUDGETREVISED
1243 BEGINNING BALANCE$‐ $‐
1244 TRANSFER FROM GENERAL FUND850,000850,000
1245 TOTALS$1,000,000 $850,000
1246BUDGET SUMMARY
12472024/252024/25
1248BUDGETREVISED
1249 TRANSFER TO GENERAL FUND$600,000 $600,000
1250 TRANSFER TO RESERVE250,000250,000
1251 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE‐‐
1252 TOTALS$850,000 $850,000
1253 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
1254 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
1255 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.

Tounen nan reyinyon sa a