Ale nan kontni prensipal la
AskDover

CCW Packet - REVISED

Council Committee of the Whole. 25 fevriye 2025.

Louvri PDF la (36.5 MB)

Yo rale tèks sa a nan PDF la otomatikman, epi li ka gen erè. PDF la se dosye ofisyèl la, kidonk tcheke l anvan ou konte sou sa a.

11 paj pa gen anpil tèks ou ka li isit la, oswa yo pa gen ditou, souvan paske se eskanè oswa desen. Gade PDF la pou sa yo.

Paj 1

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING

Tuesday, February 25, 2025 at 6:00 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware

AGENDA THIS AGENDA AND PACKET HAVE BEEN REVISED BY UPDATING ITEM #1 – JUST HEALTH RESTORATION LLC, SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE MEETING ITEM #1 – ELECTRONIC SPEED ENFORCEMENT DEVICE UPDATE, AND SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORATION COMMITTEE MEETING ITEM #2 – LANDS OF 4BL, LLC: CECIL STREET TOWNHOUSES AT 207 N. WEST STREET

Public comments are welcomed on any item and will be permitted at the appropriate time. When possible, please notify the City Clerk (302-736-7008 or email at cityclerk@dover.de.us) should you wish to be recognized.

VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE

This meeting will be held in City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:

Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://shorturl.at/HsEoL
Event number: 2532 900 8990
Event password: DOVER (if needed)

If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at https://www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.

CALL COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING TO ORDER

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

PRESENTATIONS

  • 1.Just Health Restoration LLC (Janiene Campbell and Crystal Hunter, Founders)

(Committee Action Not Required)

1

Paj 2

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING - February 25, 2025 PAGE 2

PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE

ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA

  • 1.Review of Active Recreation Plan – Village of Maple Dale – Phase 3: Planned Neighborhood Design - Senior Citizen Housing Option (Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) (Located on Maple Dale Country Club Property at 180 Maple Dale Circle: Conditional Use Site Plan/Master Plan C-25-02)

(Staff Recommendation: Approval of the Active Recreation Area Plan for the project subject to the conditions outlined in the Active Recreation Review Report.)

  • 2.Review of Active Recreation Plan – Potential Cash-in-Lieu Request – Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street (Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) (Located at the corner of N. West Street and Cecil Street: Conditional Use Plan/Minor Subdivision Plan C-25-01)

(Staff Recommendation: Approval of the Cash-in-Lieu Donation for the Active Recreation Area for the subdivision with the specific amount to be determined upon receipt of the Appraisal in accordance with the Zoning Ordinance provisions.)

  • 3.Silver Lake Dam - Annual Inspection Review (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director)

(Staff Recommendation: To accept the Silver Lake Dam 2024 Dam Safety Inspection Report and the FY2025 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update Memorandum)

  • 4.Proposed Ordinance #2025-07 - Amending Chapter 98 by Establishing a Public Space Naming Policy (Councilwoman Arndt)

(Recommendation: Forward Proposed Ordinance #2025-07 along with the Application and Procedure Packet to council for approval)

ADJOURNMENT OF THE PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE MEETING

SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE

ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA

  • 1.Electronic Speed Enforcement Device Update (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, and Dustin Shane, Automated Enforcement Program Coordinator, DelDOT)

(Committee Action Not Required)

  • 2.Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street (Dawn Melson- Williams, Principal Planner) (Located at the corner of N. West Street and Cecil Street: Conditional Use Plan/Minor Subdivision Plan C-25-01)

Request for Waiver of Appendix A – Subdivision, Article VI – Subdivision General Requirements and Design standards, Section A – Streets, Item 13.8 – Requirement for Rear Access Alley for Townhouses

2

Paj 3

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING - February 25, 2025 PAGE 3

(Planning Commission Recommendation: The Planning Commission recommended approval of the subdivision waiver allowing the elimination of the Rear Access Alley Requirement)

Request for Waiver of Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 17 – Emergency Access Requirements

(Planning Commission Recommendation: The Planning Commission recommended approval of the waiver allowing the Alternative (Use of residential sprinkler system) to satisfy the Rear Emergency Access Requirement)

ADJOURNMENT OF THE SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE MEETING

UTILITY COMMITTEE

ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA

  • 1.The Edge at Dover Impact Fee Request (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, and Christopher Stumpo, and John Rathfon, The Metropolitan Development Group)

(Staff Recommendation: Continue to follow precedent with previous projects and collect one (1) equivalent dwelling unit (EDU) for each apartment unit. The Metropolitan Development Group is still subject to any Kent County Impact Fees for wastewater.)

ADJOURNMENT OF THE UTILITY COMMITTEE MEETING

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA

  • 1.Selection Process of New City Solicitor (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager)

(Staff Recommendation: Approval of the Request for Qualifications (RFQ))

  • 2.Proposed Ordinance #2025-05 - Amending Chapter 98, Sec. 98-5 - Duty of Tenants or Owners to Maintain Sidewalks and Landscaped Areas Within the Street Right-of-Way, and Proposed Ordinance #2025-06 - Amending Chapter 1 - General Provision by Adding Sec. 1-18. Code Board of Appeals (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, and Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement officer)

(Staff Recommendation: Forward Proposed Ordinance #2025-05 and Proposed Ordinance #2025-06 to council for approval)

  • 3.Proposed Ordinance #2025-04 - Amending Chapter 70 - Miscellaneous Provisions, Section 70-7. - Registered Sexual Offenders (Councilman Boggerty and Council President Anderson)

(Recommendation: Forward Proposed Ordinance #2025-04 to council for approval)

3

Paj 4

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING - February 25, 2025 PAGE 4

ADJOURNMENT OF THE LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE MEETING

ADJOURNMENT OF THE COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE

THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING

4

Paj 5

Item 1.

Just Health Restoration LLC
Janiene Campbell & Crystal
Hunter, Co-Founders
(302)-559-9398
info@justhealthrestorationllc.com
www.justhealthrestorationllc.com

5

Paj 6

Item 1.

Just Health Restoration, LLC. Mission To reduce health inequities in black and brown and underserved communities by bringing awareness to causal factors for health-related disparities and providing long- term solutions for bridging the gap between these communities and health care providers. Vision We envision a world where healthcare is provided for all regardless of race, ethnicity, religious beliefs, gender/gender identity, and/or economic status consistently and without deviation. Values Justice for all; Healthcare accountability; Honesty & Transparency; Healthcare Advocacy & Support; Rebuilding Trust; Commitment to Community 6

Paj 7

Item 1.
Just Health Restoration, LLC.
Public Health promotes and protects the health
of all people and their communities.

Public Health Crisis a disease, disorder, condition (physiological as well as sociological, and environmental) that negatively affects the mental and physical health of millions of people, preventing them 02 from attaining their highest level of health, and consequently, affecting the health of our nation.

7

Paj 8

Item 1.
Just Health Restoration, LLC.
Declarations of Racism as a Public Health Crisis

Organization Year of Declaration Level

Organization (Nationally
American Public Health Association 2016
Recognized)

Centers for Disease Control (CDC) 2021 Federal

Maryland (5) 2020 City, County, & District of Columbia

Delaware (1)
2020 City (of Wilmington)

Mayoral/City; City; Board of Education;
New Jersey (4) 2020
Borough/City; Borough

8
Pennsylvania 2019/2020 City Council

Paj 9

Item 1.

JHR LLC & State of DE. Bill Proposal

Over 260 health centers in 27 states, including right here in Delaware, have declared racism as a public health crisis. This isn't just a statement - it's a recognition of a systemic problem that demands immediate action.

Our organization, JHR, LLC, is responding with a specific Call to Action. We're proposing an amendment to Delaware House Bill 344, which would create mandatory requirements for all healthcare professionals in our state." "This amendment would require that as a condition of initial licensure, renewal, reinstatement, or endorsement of State of Delaware licensure and

9

Paj 10

Item 1.

certification, all healthcare professionals must complete comprehensive training in: - Implicit and explicit bias recognition - Preventative measures regarding racism and bias in healthcare - Intersectionality awareness - Cultural competency, sensitivity, and humility What makes this training unique is its interactive nature. It will include video case study interviews featuring real experiences from: - People of color - LGBTQIA individuals - Others who have faced discrimination or medical bias with harmful outcomes Importantly, this training is designed to be truly engaging - it cannot be simply clicked through or skipped." 10

Paj 11

Ingoude Company
Item 1.

Stop crying and yelling,
the pain isn’t that
Bias
bad!!!

Explicit -vs.- Implicit

11

Paj 12

Item 1.

Healthcare providers must:

  • •Challenge their implicit and explicit biases
  • •Provide truly informed consent at the patient's level of understanding
  • •Never assume based on appearances
  • •Recognize that healthcare needs are as diverse as our communities
  • •Create space for questions and cultural considerations
  • •Commit to ongoing self-reflection and cultural humility

12

Paj 13

Item 1.

Present
s:
THE STATE OF OUR HEALTHCARE DISPARITIES:
A DISCUSSION ON DELAWARE’S STATISTICS
&
PROPOSED STEPS TOWARDS CHANGE

“Justice in Health” Town Hall Event
13

Paj 14

Item 1.

Join Us! 1. Our weekly Justice and Health Committee Town Hall Planning meetings, held Wednesdays from 6-7 PM via Zoom

https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/iPLupDIjTt-EggcoWCAYYw

  • 2.Our Town Hall event, "The State of Our Healthcare Disparities: A Discussion on Delaware Statistics and Proposed Steps Towards Change" on March 29, 2025, from 10 AM-2 PM. Location:TBD. Virtual attendance option available.

As a Delawarean, your insights would be invaluable to this critical discussion about healthcare equity in Delaware.

14

Paj 15

Item 1.

Just Health Restoration LLC

15

Paj 16

Item 1.

References American Public Health Association. (2024). Racial Equity. Retrieved from APHA.org: https://apha.org/Topics-and-Issues/Racial-Equity Annie E. Casey Foundation. (2021, April 14). Clinicians’ Racial Biases as Pathways to Iatrogenic Harms for Black People. AMA J Ethics, 24(8). doi:10.1001 Knight, E. K., McDonough, K., & Codes-Johnson, C. (n.d.). Policy Brief - Delaware Focus: Health Inequities and Race in the First State. Newark: University of Delaware. Retrieved from https://www.dhss.delaware.gov/dhss/dph/mh/files/phcbriefsummary.pdf

16

Paj 17

Town Hall
Item 1.

Meeting
FRIDAY, JANUARY
31, 2025
6:00 PM-8:00 PM

LOCATION: HARVEST CHRISTIAN

ACADEMY

1101 DELAWARE STREET

NEW CASTLE, DELAWARE 19720

(NEW CASTLE COUNTY)

------------------ For more details, contact us: at (302) 599-9398 info@justhealthrestorationllc.com The State of Our Healthcare Disparities: A Discussion on Delaware’s Statistics Topic of & Discussion Proposed Steps Towards Change

SPEAKERS: Scan to Register:

Raymond Tutu, PhD
Professor, Global Societies Program,
Delaware State University

Summer McMenamin
RDH, MS, FADHA, Community
Navigator, The Hygiene Hive
17
Attend Virtually

Paj 18

City of Dover
Item 1.

DATA SHEET FOR RECREATION PLAN REVIEW

Review of Active Recreation Area Plan

PARKS, RECREATION AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE

MEETING OF February 11, 2025
Planning Commission Meeting of February 18, 2025

Plan Title: Villages of Maple Dale Senior Housing Community, C-25-02
Phase 3 Revised
Planned Neighborhood Design – Senior Citizen Housing Option

Plan Type: Conceptual Plan: Active Recreation Area Plan Recreation Plan Dated January 3, 2025

Location: Northeast side of Kenton Road; east of Maple Dale Road

Tax Parcel Number: ED-05-067.00-04-01.00-000

Owner: U & I Maple Dale, LLC

Property Area: 147.5 Acres +/- (Maple Dale Golf & Country Club Project Site Area: Villages of Maple Dale Phase 3: 5.0 Acres +/-

Proposed Use: Golf Course and Age-Restricted Apartment Building – 48 dwelling units (Permitted as a Conditional Use Under the PND-SCHO)

Zoning: RC (Recreational and Commercial Zone) Planned Neighborhood Design: Senior Citizen Housing Option

For Consideration: Active Recreation Area

  • I.Project Summary The Villages of Maple Dale PND-SHPO will be reviewed as a Conditional Use Site Plan/Master Plan under the provisions of the Planned Neighborhood Design: Senior Citizen Housing Option. The subject project area is approximately 5.0 acres+/- of the overall Maple Dale Country Club parcel consisting of 147.5 acres +/-. The Plan (Phase 3) proposes the construction of a three- story apartment building with 48 units, age-restricted to households with the head-of-household age 55 or older, and associated site improvements. This Application is the third phase of the Master Plan for a PND-SCHO project that was previously established by Application C-09-06; Phases 1A and 1B consist of thirty (30) townhouse units that are under construction.

II. Active Recreation Area Plan Summary: As part of the Plan review process for this project, the applicant prepared an Active Recreation Plan detailing how the Villages of Maple Dale PND-SCHO development will provide recreation amenities in accordance with the design specifications described in Article 3 §24.61 Common Open Space and Article 5 §10. Open space, recreation, and other public facilities of the Zoning Ordinance. The following excerpt from Zoning Ordinance, Article 3 §24.61(b) describes the P. O. Box 475 Dover, DE 19903 18

Community Excellence Through Quality Service

Paj 19

C-25-02 Villages of Maple Dale PND-SCHO Phase 3 Revised: Active Recreation Area Plan Item 1. Summary Report of Active Recreation Component Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee Meeting on February 11, 2025

common open space design requirements for this type of PND project:

Article 3 §24.61 (b) Senior citizen housing option. Useable open space shall be provided in accordance with the area requirements set forth in article 5, section 10.16 of this ordinance. The location, dimensions and orientation shall be designed to afford maximum accessibility and convenience for the residents of the development. Open space areas shall include landscaped walkways with park benches, patios, and garden areas, and may include other active recreation amenities suited to the needs, abilities and preferences of the anticipated service population. The open space area requirement may be reduced or waived by the planning commission if it is determined that the property on which a senior citizen housing option is proposed is within one-quarter mile walking distance of a public park which offers pedestrian amenities and appropriate recreation opportunities for senior citizens.

Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 10 – Open Space, Recreation and Other Public Facilities (select excerpts).

Article 5 Section 10 Section 10. - Open space, recreation, and other public facilities. The City of Dover shall require the reservation of open space, recreation, and other public facilities in accordance with the provisions of this section as a condition of approval for all one-family dwelling, two-family dwelling and multiple-family dwelling residential developments requiring conditional use approval, site development plan approval, or land subdivision approval by the City of Dover Planning Commission.

10.1 Recreation areas. 10.11 Purpose. The purpose of this section is to ensure that active recreation areas are provided as an integral design element within residential developments and that such facilities are of an adequate scale in relation to the size of the residential development and which provide residents with a variety of active recreational pursuits.

10.12 Dedication required. The commission shall require the dedication or reservation of recreation areas, and the subsequent construction of recreation facilities of a character, extent and location suitable to the needs created by a development for recreation facilities as defined and in accordance with the design guidelines set forth.

10.13 Definition. The following are illustrative of the types of recreation areas and subsequent facilities that shall be deemed to serve active recreational needs and therefore to count toward satisfaction of the recreation area requirements of this section: tennis courts, handball courts, racquetball courts, swimming pools, saunas and exercise rooms, meeting or activity rooms within clubhouses, baseball and soccer fields, basketball courts, volleyball courts, swings, slides and play apparatus, and developed walking, jogging or biking trails.

The Plan indicates that the amenities proposed for use as the Active Recreation Area for the project include the following: a walking trail and a sand volleyball court. This submission indicates that these amenities will be available for use by the prospective residents of the apartment units. It is noted that the Maple Dale Country Club & Golf Course remains on the site including the existing Clubhouse building with meeting rooms, banquet facility, bar/restaurant; putting green; driving range; and 18-hole golf course.

This Active Recreation component must be reviewed by the Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee for a recommendation prior to consideration of the Conditional Use Site Plan/Master Plan by Planning Commission.

19

Paj 20

C-25-02 Villages of Maple Dale PND-SCHO Phase 3 Revised: Active Recreation Area Plan Item 1. Summary Report of Active Recreation Component Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee Meeting on February 11, 2025

The following table provides information from the submitted Plan (dated 01/03/2025) for the Active Recreation Area proposal for Villages of Maple Dale PND-SCHO. This focuses on the amenities specifically being developed with this project:

Required Provided on Plan Common Open Space in Useable open space following Sand volleyball court PND – Senior Option the area requirement of Active Walking trails (Article §24.61b) Recreation Area

Active Recreation Area 150 S.F. per dwelling unit or 10,674 SF made up of: (Article 5 §10.514) 10,000 S.F., greater thereof Sand volleyball court 48 DU = 7,200 S.F. Walking trail Requires 10,000 S.F. Active Recreation Accessible Walking trail connects to sidewalks Amenities located on the property and to a (Article 5 §10.15) sand volleyball court. Active Recreation Age Oriented to development The walking trail is conducive to Amenities the age group being served. The (Article 5 §10.15) sand volleyball court would typically serve a younger audience. Parking The entire site has 249 parking spaces. Thirty-five parking spaces are adjacent to the proposed sand volleyball court. Setbacks: 30 feet from The sand volleyball court is not residential lots and 25 feet from within 30 feet of neighboring right-of-way for street residential lots nor within 25 feet of a street right-of-way. Landscaping The Landscape Plan shows a shade tree near the volleyball court and evergreens and shade trees near the walking trail.

III. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS:

The following are comments and recommendations from Staff of the Department of Planning & Inspections and the Parks & Recreation Department following review of the Active Recreation Area proposed for the Villages of Maple Dale: PND-SCHO.

  • 1.The plan is required to provide 10,000 SF of Active Recreation Area. The plan provides 10,674 SF, including a walking trail and sand volleyball court.
  • 2.Staff recommends approval of the walking trail as meeting the intent of the Active Recreation Area requirements.
  • 3.Clarification of the walking trail system is recommended to identify which areas are intended for golf course users versus the walking trail for the residents.
  • a.The walking trail system must include the appropriate accessibility accommodations, crosswalks, signage, etc., especially at the points of intersection with vehicular travel lanes. 20

Paj 21

C-25-02 Villages of Maple Dale PND-SCHO Phase 3 Revised: Active Recreation Area Plan Item 1. Summary Report of Active Recreation Component Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee Meeting on February 11, 2025

  • 4.The applicant should consider reallocating the 1,800 SF shown as a sand volleyball court to an activity area more suitable for the 55+ age group, such as shuffleboard, bocci ball, or pickleball. The developer is considering these alternatives.
  • 5.The following items should be included on the Plan to clarify the construction of the Recreation Area improvements:
  • a.Identify the length of proposed walking trail.
  • b.If benches or other amenities are proposed along the walking trail, a list of the amenities should be provided on the Active Recreation Plan (i.e. the list of amenities, the number of benches and the details of the items).
  • c.Identify locations of lighting.
  • 6.Identify the location of bicycle parking facilities associated with the Apartment Building and the general parking lot.
  • 7.The applicant is reminded of the requirements for construction phasing of the recreation area associated with the development of the residential units. With all residential units in one building, the recreation amenities will have to be completed in conjunction with the building’s construction and prior to issuance of a Final Certificate of Occupancy.

Article 5 §10.6 Construction Phasing. The recreation and open space areas shall be completed in a proportion equal to or greater than the proportion of residential dwelling units completed, except that one hundred (100) percent of the recreation and open space areas shall be completed prior to issuing building permits for the final twenty (20) percent of the dwelling units proposed. Building permits shall not be issued for dwelling units unless the requirements of this section are met.

  • 8.There shall be provisions which ensure that the common open space land (including active recreation area) shall continue as such and be properly managed and maintained. The developer shall either retain ownership and responsibility for maintenance of such open land; or provide for and establish one (1) or more organizations for the ownership and maintenance of all common open space i.e. a Homeowners Association. The organization shall be responsible for maintenance, insurance and taxes on the common open space.

IV. ADVISORY COMMENTS

  • 1)In the event that major changes and revisions to the Site Plan occur in the finalization of the Site Plan, contact the Department of Planning and Inspections. Examples include reorientation of buildings, relocation of site components like stormwater management areas, and increases in floor area. These changes may require resubmittal for review by the Development Advisory Committee, Planning Commission, or other agencies and commissions making recommendations in regard to the plan.
  • 2)The Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee shall submit to the Planning Commission a report detailing the recommendations as to the Recreation Area Plan.

21

Paj 22

C-25-02 Villages of Maple Dale PND-SCHO Phase 3 Revised: Active Recreation Area Plan Item 1. Summary Report of Active Recreation Component Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee Meeting on February 11, 2025

Attachments:
• Select Pages from C-25-02 Plan Set:
o Active Recreation Plan Sheet dated January 3, 2025
o Landscape Plan Sheet dated January 3, 2025

Note: This review Report was initially prepared by Staff of the Rossi Group (under a Planning Services contract with the City of Dover). The Report was completed with additional review and editing by the City’s Planning Office.

22

Paj 23

Item 1.

PENNONI ASSOCIATES INC.
LEGEND SITE DATA TABLE:
EXISTING PROPOSED DESCRIPTION
1. TAX MAP NUMBER : 2-05-06700-04-0100-000

Christiana Executive Campus
CURB 2. DEED REFERENCE: BK.: 12925, PG.: 140

VILLAGES OF MAPLE DALE - PHASE 3 CURB DEPRESSION 3. OWNER/DEVELOPER: U & I MAPLE DALE LLC EDGE OF PAVEMENT 1200 SOUTH BAY ROAD

121 Continental Drive, Suite 207
DOVER, DE 19904
EDGE OF GRAVEL
4. SITE ADDRESS : 180 MAPLE DALE CIRCLE
EASEMENT DOVER, DE 19904

Newark, DE 19713-4310 FENCE, COMPOSITE HUNDRED, TOWN, COUNTY: EAST DOVER HUNDRED, DOVER, KENT COUNTY

FENCE, STEEL 5. EXISTING TOTAL ACREAGE: 6,424,169 ± SF 147.48 ± ACRES

T 302.655.4451 F 302.654.2895 CONDITIONAL USE SITE PLANS FENCE, WOOD 6. CURRENT ZONING: RC - RECREATION/COMMERCIAL NATURAL GAS, METER 7. PRESENT USE: GOLF COURSE NATURAL GAS,VALVE 8. PROPOSED USE; GOLF COURSE & AGE-RESTRICTED RESIDENTIAL CONDOMINIUM NATURAL GAS, UNDERGROUND (PERMITTED AS A CONDITIONAL USE UNDER THE PLANNED NEIGHBORHOOD

ALL DIMENSIONS MUST BE VERIFIED BY CONTRACTOR PHONE, PEDESTAL DESIGN - SENIOR CITIZEN HOUSING OPTION (PND-SCHO))

PHONE, JUNCTION BOX9.PROPOSED DWELLINGS:48 UNITS
SECURITY, WITNESS POST
10. REFUSE:
POWER, JUNCTION BOXREQUIRED DUMPSTERS2
POWER, LIGHT
POWER, SPOT LIGHT180 MAPLE DALE CIRCLEPROPOSED DUMPSTERS2
  • 11.WATER PROVIDER: PUBLIC - CITY OF DOVER POWER, METER DOVER, DE 19904 | TAX MAP #: 2-05-06700-04-0100-00 AND OWNER MUST BE NOTIFIED OF ANY POWER, PANEL BOX 12. SANITARY PROVIDER: PUBLIC - CITY OF DOVER

POWER, TRANSFORMER 13. STREET: PRIVATE - OPEN POWER, UNDERGROUND SITE, BOLLARD KENT COUNTY, DE 14. POSTED SPEED LIMIT: 25 MPH (MAPLE DALE CIRCLE)

SITE, FLAG POLE
15. 2020 STATE INVESTMENT AREA: LEVEL 1
SITE, MAIL BOX OWNER/DEVELOPER
U & I MAPLE DALE LLC
SITE, POST
PREPARED FOR: 16. FIRE DISTRICT: DOVER FIRE DEPARTMENT (STATION 46)

DISCREPANCIES BEFORE PROCEEDING WITH WORK 1200 SOUTH BAY ROAD SITE, TRAFFIC SIGN DOVER, DE 19904 17. WATERSHED: BROADKILL-SYMRNA, HUC 8 - 02040207 SITE, SIGN POST AND BOARD SITE, BUILDING ENGINEER/ PLANNER PENNONI ASSOCIATES INC. OWNER/DEVELOPER 18. DATUM: SAINT JONES RIVER, HUC 10 - 0204020703

HORIZONTAL: NSR11 PROPERTY, LINE 121 CONTINENTAL DRIVE, SUITE 207 VERTICAL: NSR11 LEGAL RIGHT-OF-WAY NEWARK, DE 19713-4310 PROPERTY, IRON PIPE FOUND PROPERTY, MONUMENT FOUND PROPERTY, ADJOINING LINED SANITARY SEWER, CLEAN-OUT PHONE #: (302) 655-4451 FAX#: (302) 654-2895

SURVEYOR PENNONI ASSOCIATES, INC.

U & I MAPLE DALE LLC19.STATE PLANE COORDINATE:BENCHMARK #1 (IRON PIPE FOUND)
LONGITUDE:
LATITUDE:
W 075° 34' 29.16"
N 039° 10' 24.94"
BENCHMARK #2 (CONCRETE MONUMENT FOUND)
LONGITUDE:W 075° 34' 28.22"
SANITARY SEWER, UNDERGROUND (4" DIA TO 10" DIA)
SANITARY SEWER, MANHOLE
SCHOOL DISTRICT
CAPITAL1200 SOUTH BAY ROADLATITUDE:N 039° 10' 29.82"

VILLAGES OF MAPLE DALE - PHASE 3
FIRE DISTRICT 20. TID: NOT INCLUDED
STORM SEWER, CLEAN-OUT
STORM SEWER, INLET
DOVER FIRE DEPARTMENT (46)

POSTAL DISTRICT
DOVER, DE 19901 21. LOCAL GOVERNMENT
RESPONSIBLE FOR LAND USE APPROVAL: CITY OF DOVER
STORM SEWER, MANHOLE
DOVER (19901)
STORM SEWER, UNDERGROUND

DOVER, DE 19904 | TAX MAP #: 2-05-06700-04-0100-00
WATER UTILITY
VEGETATION, STUMP CITY OF DOVER
VEGETATION, DECIDUOUS
SANITARY UTILITY
VEGETATION, CONIFEROUS
CITY OF DOVER

U & I MAPLE DALE LLC VEGETATION, TREE LINE

180 MAPLE DALE CIRCLE
COVER SHEET
1200 SOUTH BAY ROAD
WATER, HOSE BIB
WATER, FIRE HYDRANT
WATER, UNDERGROUND
WATER, VALVE
TRAFFIC. PAVEMENT MARKINGS

DOVER, DE 19901 TRAFFIC, PAVEMENT MARKING, TURN ARROWS

SURFACE, ASPAHLT

SURFACE, CONCRETE

SURFACE, GRAVELM
NORTHNORTHNORTH
E
CK
E
SITERDSITE

ZONING BULK REGULATIONS ME RI ON SITE VALUES BELOW ARE BASED ON CODE SECTION 24.5 WHICH REFERS TO CODE SECTION 4.11 “GARDEN APARTMENTS”. RD ALSO, PER CODE SECTION 24.5, “THE PLANNING COMMISSION MAY RELAX THESE REQUIREMENTS WHEN SUCH ACTION IS DESIRABLE AND CONSISTENT WITH THE OBJECTIONS OF THIS ORDINANCE AND THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.” REQUESTED WAIVERS ARE NOTED BELOW.

REQUIRED PROPOSED MINIMUM AVERAGE LOT AREA PER DWELLING UNIT 1,800 SF 133,838 SF FOX HALL MINIMUM LOT AREA PER DWELLING UNIT 1,800 SF 133,838 SF MINIMUM OFF-STREET PARKING SPACES 2 PER DU 2.25 PER DU MINIMUM LOT AREA 1 AC 147.48 AC BY MINIMUM LOT WIDTH 100 FT > 100 FT MINIMUM LOT DEPTH 125 FT > 125 FT RD MINIMUM BUILDING SETBACK (STREET) 50 FT > 50 FT EG MINIMUM BUILDING SETBACK (PROPERTY LINE) 50 FT 50.46 FT E CHESTNUT GROVE LL MINIMUM BUILDING SPACING 50 FT N/A KE CO MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT 35 FT 38'-4”* CHESTNUT GROVE RD NTO MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT (STORIES) 2 3* NR D MAXIMUM LOT COVERAGE 60% <2% (APP.)

PLOTTED:1/2/2025 2:45 PM

, BY:Steven R. Anderson PLOTSTYLE:Pennoni NCS.stb MAXIMUM AVERAGE NUMBER OF DWELLING UNITS PER BUILDING 24 48*

  • •WAIVER REQUIRED BICENTENNIAL VILLAGE

REVISIONS PARKING RATIONALE EXISTING USE: GOLF COURSE, CLUBHOUSE AND RANGE (RANGE IS CONSIDERED AS AN ACCESSORY USE AND DOES NOT CONTRIBUTE TO THE PARKING DEMAND BELOW)

EXISTING PARKING REQUIREMENTS

GOLF COURSE

CLUBHOUSE

1 SPACE PER EMPLOYEE @ 10 EMPLOYEES + 4 SPACES PER HOLE @ 18 HOLES = 82 1 SPACE PER 300 SF @ 15,000 SF (APP.) = 50 SPACES LOCATION MAP SITE MAP SOILS MAP TOTAL EXISTING REQUIRED 82 + 50 = 132 Scale: 1" = 2,000' Scale: 1" = 500' Scale: 1" = 2,000' PROPOSED PARKING REEQUIREMENTS AGE-RESTRICTED APARTMENTS 2.25 SPACES PER DU @ 48 UNITS = 108 SPACES NO. TOTAL REQUIRED PARKING SPACES 132 + 108 = 240 SPACES

TOTAL PROPOSED PARKING SPACES 249 SPACES
PREPARED BY: DATE
OWNER/DEVELOPER CERTIFICATION:
IT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED THAT I AM THE OWNER/DEVELOPER OF THE PROPERTY

PENNONI ASSOCIATES INC. DESCRIBED AND SHOWN ON THIS PLAN. THE PLAN WAS MADE AT MY DIRECTION, CALL BEFORE YOU DIG THAT I ACKNOWLEDGE THE SAME TO BE MY ACT. IT IS MY DESIRE TO HAVE THE ALL DOCUMENTS PREPARED BY PENNONI ASSOCIATES PLAN DEVELOPED AS SHOWN AND IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL APPLICABLE LAWS Call Miss Utility of Delmarva AND REGULATIONS. ARE INSTRUMENTS OF SERVICE IN RESPECT OF THE PROJECT. THEY ARE NOT INTENDED OR REPRESENTED

U:\Accounts\UANDI\UANDI24002 - Villages of Maple Dale\DESIGN\_SHEETS\CS0001.dwg 800-282-8555 TO BE SUITABLE FOR REUSE BY OWNER OR OTHERS ON THE EXTENSIONS OF THE PROJECT OR ON ANY OTHER Ticket Number(s): PROJECT. ANY REUSE WITHOUT WRITTEN VERIFICATION

Christiana Executive Campus SIGNATURE DATE
OR ADAPTATION BY PENNONI ASSOCIATES FOR THE
SPECIFIC PURPOSE INTENDED WILL BE AT OWNERS
USMAN SANDHU SOLE RISK AND WITHOUT LIABILITY OR LEGAL

121 Continental Drive, Suite 207 U & I MAPLE DALE LLC 1200 SOUTH BAY ROAD EXPOSURE TO PENNONI ASSOCIATE; AND OWNER SHALL INDEMNIFY AND HOLD HARMLESS PENNONI ASSOCIATES FROM ALL CLAIMS, DAMAGES, LOSSES AND EXPENSES DOVER, DE 19901 Newark, DE 19713-4310 CITY PLANNER CONSTRUCTION IMPROVEMENTS PLANS HAVE BEEN REVIEWED AND ARE PHONE# (302) 242-8486 ARISING OUT OF OR RESULTING THEREFROM.

PROJECT UANDI24002 T 302.655.4451 FOUND TO BE IN GENERAL CONFORMANCE WITH THE CITY OF DOVER CONSTRUCTION STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS FOR WATER, SEWER AND ENGINEER CERTIFICATION: IT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED THAT I AM A REGISTERED ENGINEER IN THE STATE STREETS. THE OWNER AND HIS ENGINEER AND/OR SURVEYOR ASSUME ALL OF DELAWARE, THAT THE INFORMATION SHOWN HEREON HAS BEEN DATE 2025-01-03 F 302.654.2895 RESPONSIBILITY FOR DESIGN AND ACCURACY OF INFORMATION SHOWN HEREON. PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION, AND TO MY BEST KNOWLEDGE COMPLIES WITH APPLICABLE STATE AND LOCAL REGULATIONS AND ORDINANCES. THE DESIGN REPRESENTS GOOD ENGINEERING PRACTICES AS DRAWING SCALE AS NOTED REQUIRED BY THE APPLICABLE LAWS OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE. DRAWN BY KRML SIGNATURE:___________________________________DATE:________________ APPROVED BY DDB

CITY OF DOVER APPROVED BY : SIGNATURE DATE

CITY MANAGER:________________________________DATE:_______________
STEVEN R. ANDERSON JR, PE (DE PE#13187)
PENNONI ASSOCIATES, INC
121 CONTINENTAL DRIVE, SUITE 207
NEWARK, DE 19713-4310
CS0001
(DAVE HUGG) OFFICE (302) 655-4451 - FAX (302) 654-2895 SHEET 1 OF 8
23

Paj 24

Item 1.

PENNONI ASSOCIATES INC.
DEED REF: T. 41, PG. 343
R-10 ZONING
USE: SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING N 19°50'54"
149.73'
E

ACTIVE RECREATION AREA

1900 Market Street, Suite 300
TM#: 2-05-06612-01-2900-00001

Philadelphia, PA 19103

149LANDS N/F OF FILLAT PETER A.
.73'ACTIVE RECREATION CALCULATION
DEED REF: N/A
R-10 ZONING
N1 USE: SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING PER ARTICLE 5, SECTION 10.514 ("RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENTS OF TEN (10) OR FEWER

T 215.222.3000 F 215.222.3588
9°5 LIMITS OF ACRES WITH A DENSITY OVER SIX UNITS PER ACRE")
0'54 DEPRESSED

"E CURB REQUIRED ACTIVE RECREATION SPACE 150 SF PER DWELLING UNIT OR 10,000 SF (WHICHEVER IS GREATER)

= 7,200 SF (150 * 48) < 10,000 SF
K
AC
)
NORTH

ALL DIMENSIONS MUST BE VERIFIED BY CONTRACTOR

14 E
385.3
2'

TB 10,674 SQUARE FEET = 10,000 SF REQUIRED
SE
'25"
48°35
N

21GACTIVE RECREATION AREA
0A5.
32
'
D IN
WALKING TRAIL ANDPROPOSED ACTIVE RECREATION SPACE= 10,674 SF (WALKING TRAIL & OUTDOOR VOLLEYBALL COURT
D38UI
L

TE B VOLLEYBALL COURT (S 5" E 50 ' R IN 5'2 5' WIDE ASPHALT D A °3 WALKING TRAIL 48 TM#: 2-05-06612-01-2100-00001 OA M N L

AND OWNER MUST BE NOTIFIED OF ANY LANDS N/F OF SUH JOSHUA, KIM DANAH DEED REF: D.B. 10872, PG. 333 CA A R-10 ZONING LR IP USE: SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING | NIC LO D U °4 ' , R 1' 2 A -M =3 7 " 5' WIDE CONCRETE O 50 SIDEWALK 00' R VER 24 ' .0 0 30.

DISCREPANCIES BEFORE PROCEEDING WITH WORK 0

YOD
=
3
8SAND VOLLEY
E
.
0
L D5BALL COURT
F=1
LLSF PLEX60.
A YO1
68
8,7 COM FA)
ED IUM 04 G
00'

V IT R OS OP DOMI P ON D N (56 ING S ,3

E C IOR
SEN TORY
C I L
BU UNIT
48
IN LIMITS OF
3S

PDEPRESSED
CURB5' WIDE ASPHALT
'WALKING TRAIL
"0
50
5'
00.
5

VILLAGES OF MAPLE DALE - PHASE 3 1 1 1° =3 R = 0 ', D 73 . = 68 L

DOVER, DE 19904 | TAX MAP #: 2-05-06700-04-0100-00ACTIVE RECREATION PLAN
5' WIDE
6'CONCRETE
1.7
27SIDEWALK
E
'2 4".83'20.
5'

U & I MAPLE DALE LLC

0
°5 427
55

180 MAPLE DALE CIRCLE N

1200 SOUTH BAY ROAD
0" E
°28'
4
N 18
SAND VOLLEYBALL COURT

DOVER, DE 19901 TM#: 2-05-06616-01-0600-00001 EXISTING LANDS N/F OF STONEY CREEK REALTY, LLC BUILDING DEED REF: D.B.12925, PG.140 R-10 ZONING USE: SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING TM#: 2-05-06700-04-0100-00001 N/F U & I MAPLE DALE LLC DEED REF: D.B. 12925, PG.140 RC ZONING 147.48 ± ACRES EXISTING BUILDING

END CURB BY

2

E 428.01'

DU
N 18°26'47"

MP
S
(2 ARE TER PAVED WALKING TRAIL

PLOTTED:1/2/2025 2:46 PM

, BY:Steven R. Anderson PLOTSTYLE:Pennoni NCS.stb
TO A
TA
L) PROPOSED
STORMWATER
MANAGEMENT (PROPOSED TRAIL WILL BE 5 FEET WIDE)

REVISIONS
PARKING AREA
BUMPER
(TYP.)
5' WIDE ASPHALT 4
5' WIDE ASPHALT WALKING TRAIL
WALKING TRAIL

NO.

N

PEDATE
-O
A TED16
ALL DOCUMENTS PREPARED BY PENNONI ASSOCIATES

I|V INE
ARE INSTRUMENTS OF SERVICE IN RESPECT OF THE
PROJECT. THEY ARE NOT INTENDED OR REPRESENTED
E

U:\Accounts\UANDI\UANDI24002 - Villages of Maple Dale\DESIGN\_SHEETS\CS1002.dwg R TO BE SUITABLE FOR REUSE BY OWNER OR OTHERS ON LP A THE EXTENSIONS OF THE PROJECT OR ON ANY OTHER

C INT PROJECT. ANY REUSE WITHOUT WRITTEN VERIFICATION OR ADAPTATION BY PENNONI ASSOCIATES FOR THE

IRMA15SPECIFIC PURPOSE INTENDED WILL BE AT OWNERS
SOLE RISK AND WITHOUT LIABILITY OR LEGAL
CYEXPOSURE TO PENNONI ASSOCIATES; AND OWNER

L E EL SHALL INDEMNIFY AND HOLD HARMLESS PENNONI ASSOCIATES FROM ALL CLAIMS, DAMAGES, LOSSES AND EXPENSES ARISING OUT OF OR RESULTING THEREFROM.

A VAT
D RI PROJECT UANDI24002
L E P 2025-01-03
A P DATE

PARKINGDRAWING SCALE1" =30'
MBUMPER
(TYP.)DRAWN BYGBR
5' WIDE CONCRETE SIDEWALK TO
CONNECT TO SIDEWALK ON17APPROVED BYGBR
MAPLE DALE ROAD (CURRENTLY
UNDER CONSTRUCTION)030'60'
CS1002
S
34°08'2
106.18
2"'
E

SHEET 4 OF 8 24

Paj 25

Item 1.

PENNONI ASSOCIATES INC.

TM#: 2-05-06612-01-2400-00001 LANDS N/F OF KAZA BABU R., KAZA JANAKI B. 2024-12-30 17:24 Christiana Executive Campus CONCEPT PLANT SCHEDULE DEED REF: T. 41, PG. 343 121 Continental Drive, Suite 207 R-10 ZONING USE: SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING N 19°50'54" E 149.73'

SHADE TREE 39

Newark, DE 19713-4310
40 MIN. 2` CALIPER

T 302.655.4451 F 302.654.2895

EX. CLEAN OUTS TO REMAIN AND BEEVERGREEN TREE
TM#: 2-05-06612-01-2900-00001ADJUST TO FINISHED GRADE AND
28
3'MIN. 5` - 6` TALL
149LANDS N/F OF FILLAT PETER A.TRAFFIC RATED.
.7DEED REF: N/A
ER-10 ZONING
SEWER MANHOLE1
USE: SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING
4ORNAMENTAL TREE

ALL DIMENSIONS MUST BE VERIFIED BY CONTRACTOR

RIM: 39.52'9°5SEWER6
0'54MIN. 5`-6` TALL

NORTH I.I: 30.07' CLEANOUT I.I: 30.02' " I.O: 29.97' N1 PROPOSED SANITARY SEWER BLDG LATERAL TO CONNECT TO EX. SEWER ON SITE. FINAL LOCATION 40 ) AND SIZE TO BE DETERMINED. CK 0A E 385.3 2'

TB
A
SE
'25"
48°35
N

21
2' NG

AND OWNER MUST BE NOTIFIED OF ANY
41
14 D L=150.83', R=350.00'
D =024°41'27"

38
5 .3
BU
IL
DI

R TEE50
'
S
( IN5'25
"
D A°3
48
TM#: 2-05-06612-01-2100-00001A MNPROPOSED BLDG. WATER SERVICE
LANDS N/F OF SUH JOSHUA, KIM DANAHOLTO CONNECT TO EX. WATER SERVICE
40

DEED REF: D.B. 10872, PG. 333
R A ON SITE. FINAL LOCATION AND SIZE
L P
A ICI TO BE DETERMINED.

DISCREPANCIES BEFORE PROCEEDING WITH WORK
R-10 ZONING
USE: SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING |C N 41
41

O

LD U°4
'
, R 1' 2
A -M=3 7 "
O500'
CLEANOUT
(Poss. San. Sewer) PLANTING NOTES AND SPECIFICATIONS
R VER 0 '24.0
0
40
30.
0

YO = 8 D 0 3 SAND VOLLEY 1. ALL TOPSOIL SHALL BE A MINIMUM 4” IN ALL SOD AREAS, 6" IN SEEDED AREAS AND 8” IN TREE, SHRUB AND GROUND COVER BEDS, E D . BALL COURT INCLUDING PARKING LOT ISLAND BEDS. 5

L L F L =1 SF PLEX 60. 2. PLANTING BEHIND PERPENDICULAR PARKING IS TO BE LOCATED A MINIMUM OF 5' BEHIND THE CURB LINE.

A YO1
68
8,7 COM FA)
ED IUM 04 G
00'
3. ALL LANDSCAPE AND GRASS AREAS ARE TO BE HAND RAKED AND LEFT CLEAR OF ALL STONES, ROCK, CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS AND ANY
V ITR
OS
OP DOMI
P ON
D I
N
NG
(56
,3
UNSUITABLE MATERIALS.

E C IOR
C IL
BU UNIT 7
S
40

VILLAGES OF MAPLE DALE - PHASE 3 SEN TORY 48 2. 4. LANDSCAPE CONTRACTOR WILL LOCATE ALL UNDERGROUND UTILITIES PRIOR TO ANY EXCAVATION AND PLANTING INSTALLATION.

IN 3S =4 FF

P 5. ALL PROPOSED LANDSCAPING TO BE NURSERY GROWN, TYPICAL OF THEIR SPECIES OR VARIETY. THEY ARE TO HAVE NORMAL VIGOROUS ROOT SYSTEMS, FREE FROM DEFECTS AND INFECTIONS AND IN ACCORDANCE WITH ANSI Z60.1

" ' 6. ALL PROPOSED PLANTINGS SHOULD BE INSTALLED PER STANDARDS OF THE AMERICAN NURSERY AND LANDSCAPE ASSOCIATION, 0

DOVER, DE 19904 | TAX MAP #: 2-05-06700-04-0100-00

5 0 LATEST EDITION, AND STATE NURSERY/ LANDSCAPE ASSOCIATIONS WITH REGARD TO PLANTING, PIT SIZE, BACKFILL MIXTURE, STAKING '0 0. 15 3 5 AND GUYING. SEWER MANHOLE 1 1° = R RIM: 36.77' = 0 3 ', 7. ALL PLANTING CONTAINERS AND BASKETS SHALL BE REMOVED DURING PLANTING. ALL PLANTS SHALL BE SET PLUMB AND POSITIONED

LANDSCAPE PLAN

I.I: 30.75'D 740
. 41 SO THAT THE TOP OF THE ROOT COLLAR MATCHES, OR IS NO MORE THAN TWO (2”) INCHES ABOVE, FINISHED GRADE. REPLACE
6841

U & I MAPLE DALE LLC I.O: 30.67' AMENDED BACKFILL IN 6-INCH LAYERS AND COMPACT BACKFILL TO ELIMINATE VOIDS. CONTRACTOR SHALL PROVIDE A FOUR-INCH HIGH L = EARTHEN WATERING SAUCER ALONG THE PERIMETER OF EACH PLANTING PIT. CONTRACTOR SHALL WATER NEWLY PLANTED

180 MAPLE DALE CIRCLE 39

1200 SOUTH BAY ROAD VEGETATION PRIOR TO MULCHING PLANTING PIT. ALL VOIDS SHALL BE FILLED AND SETTLING MITIGATED AS REQUIRED. 39

.7 6' 42 8. AFTER INITIAL WATERING AND PRIOR TO MULCHING, CONTRACTOR SHALL APPLY HERBICIDES AND PRE-EMERGENT HERBICIDES AS 2 71 40 REQUIRED TO ELIMINATE ANY WEED SEEDS OR PLANTS PRESENT ON ROOT BALL. "E 5' 0'2 4 E 4 20. 40 9. ALL PLANTING BEDS AND PITS SHALL BE MULCHED WITH DOUBLE GROUND HARDWOOD MULCH AT A MINIMUM DEPTH OF 3”. 27.8 °5 55

DOVER, DE 19901 3' N 10. SEEDBED PREPARATION:

  • A.APPLY LIMESTONE AND FERTILIZER ACCORDING TO SOIL TESTS OR FERTILIZER MAY BE APPLIED AT THE RATE OF 260 POUNDS PER °28' ACRE OR 6 POUNDS PER 1000 SQUARE FEET USING 10-20-10 OR EQUIVALENT. IN ADDITION, 300 POUNDS 4-1-2 PER ACRE OR EQUIVALENT 40" 40 OF SLOW RELEASE NITROGEN MAY BE USED IN LIEU OF TOP DRESSING. N 18 B. WORK LIME AND FERTILIZER INTO THE SOIL AS PRACTICAL TO A DEPTH OF 4-INCHES WITH A DISC, SPRING TOOTH HARROW OR OTHER SUITABLE EQUIPMENT. THE FINAL HARROWING OR DISKING OPERATION SHOULD PARALLEL TO THE GENERAL CONTOUR. CONTINUE TILLAGE UNTIL A REASONABLE UNIFORM, FINE SEEDBED IS PREPARED. ALL BUT CLAY OR SILTY SOILS AND COARSE SANDS SHOULD BE ROLLED TO FIRM THE SEEDBED WHEREVER FEASIBLE. TM#: 2-05-06616-01-0600-00001 LANDS N/F OF STONEY CREEK REALTY, LLC 40
  • C.INSPECT SEEDBED JUST BEFORE SEEDING. IF TRAFFIC HAS LEFT THE SOIL COMPACTED, THE AREA MUST BE RETILLED AND FIRMED AS DEED REF: D.B.12925, PG.140 39 OUTLINED BELOW. R-10 ZONING 39
  • D.IN AREAS DESIGNATED AS SOD, FESCUE SOD IS TO BE INSTALLED ON MINIMUM 4” TOPSOIL. AREAS TO BE SODDED ARE TO BE USE: SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING PREPARED AS NOTED ABOVE FOR SEEDED AREAS.

TM#: 2-05-06700-04-0100-00001 12. TOPSOIL WITH A QUALITY ORGANIC SOIL AMENDMENT SHALL BE USED FOR ALL PLANTING AND SEEDING OPERATIONS. N/F U & I MAPLE DALE LLC 40 13. NOTIFY ALL UTILITY COMPANIES AND LOCATE ALL UTILITIES PRIOR TO EXCAVATING PLANT PITS. PLANT LOCATIONS MAY BE ADJUSTED DEED REF: D.B. 12925, PG.140 IN THE FIELD TO AVOID INTERFERENCE WITH UNDERGROUND UTILITIES. RC ZONING 36 147.48 ± ACRES 38 14. SHOULD ANY DISCREPANCY ARISE BETWEEN THE PLANTING PLAN AND THE PLANTING SCHEDULE, THE PLAN SHALL GOVERN AS TO THE QUANTITY OF PLANT MATERIAL. 39 35 39 15. ALL SHADE TREES TO BE PRUNED OF SIDE BRANCHES TO A HEIGHT OF 6' ABOVE GRADE EXCEPT WHERE NOTED IN PLANT SCHEDULE. 39 BY 40 16. ALL PLANT MATERIAL SHALL BE APPROVED UPON ARRIVAL TO THE SITE, UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTIFIED. 39 17. PROPOSED PLANT MATERIAL MAY BE SUBSTITUTED BY SIMILAR PLANTS PRIOR TO INSTALLATION, SUBJECT TO APPROVAL BY THE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT AND NEW CASTLE COUNTY.

  • 18.DISTURBANCE OF EXISTING VEGETATION SHALL BE LIMITED TO WORK AREA CONTRACTOR IS RESPONSIBLE FOR FINE GRADING AND 37 SEEDING ALL DISTURBED AREAS.

40 19. ALL PLANTS SPACED 7' O.C. OR CLOSER SHALL BE IN CONTINUOUS MULCHED BEDS.

PLOTTED:1/2/2025 2:46 PM

, BY:Steven R. Anderson PLOTSTYLE:Pennoni NCS.stb 20. SEED ALL DISTURBED AREAS WITH GRASS SEED MIX SPECIFIED IN SEDIMENT CONTROL REQUIREMENTS.

39 21. ALL PLANT MATERIAL SHALL BE WARRANTED AGAINST DEATH AND UNSATISFACTORY GROWTH FOR A MINIMUM PERIOD OF ONE YEAR

REVISIONS

39 AFTER THE DATE OF WRITTEN FINAL ACCEPTANCE BY THE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT AND/OR MUNICIPALITY REPRESENTATIVE. ANY N 18°26'47" E 428.01'

40 PLANT MATERIAL THAT DIES OR PERFORMS POORLY DURING THE WARRANTY PERIOD SHALL BE PROMPTLY REMOVED AND REPLACED IN KIND.

PROPOSED LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE NOTES STORMWATER 4 MANAGEMENT0 39 AREA ANY AND ALL PLANT MATERIAL THAT DIES OR FAILS TO THRIVE SHALL BE IMMEDIATELY REPLACED WITH LIKE SPECIES. RECOMMENDED ANNUAL MAINTENANCE OF SITE VEGETATION TO INCLUDE BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO:

  • 1.FERTILIZER: MOW LAWN - FERTILIZE TWICE PER YEAR. 36 37 2. PRUNING: PRUNING SHALL BE LIMITED OR REMOVAL OF DEAD WOOD OR BRANCHES FOR TREES OR FOR SIGHT DIFFERENCES/SAFETY NO. 38 REASONS. PRUNING OF SHRUBS AND TREES SHALL BE LIMITED TO THE PRUNING NECESSARY TO MAINTAIN THE NATURAL SHAPE OF 39 THE PLANT EXCEPT FOR SHEARED HEDGES. 40 41 DATE 40 3. PEST CONTROL: PRE-EMERGENT WEED CONTROL FOR MOWN LAWNS AND SHRUB BEDS MAY BE APPLIED IN FEBRUARY. CHEMICAL TREATMENT FOR INSECT INFESTATION AND DISEASE MAY BE APPLIED AND SHALL BE SPECIFIC TO THE PROBLEM.
  • 4.MULCHING: MULCHING SHALL BE MAINTAINED AT A DEPTH OF 3” IN PLANT BEDS AND AROUND BASE OF TREES. ALL DOCUMENTS PREPARED BY PENNONI ASSOCIATES ARE INSTRUMENTS OF SERVICE IN RESPECT OF THE
  • 5.MOWING: MOWN LAWN SEED MIX SHALL BE MOWN AT REGULAR INTERVALS THROUGHOUT THE GROWING SEASON. GRASS HEIGHT PROJECT. THEY ARE NOT INTENDED OR REPRESENTED

U:\Accounts\UANDI\UANDI24002 - Villages of Maple Dale\DESIGN\_SHEETS\CS2001.dwg EN TREE DENSITY WORKSHEET SHOULD NOT EXCEED 3 INCHES. MOWER BLADES SHALL BE SET AND 2-1/2 INCHES UNLESS OTHERWISE DIRECTED. WHERE TO BE SUITABLE FOR REUSE BY OWNER OR OTHERS ON

41THE EXTENSIONS OF THE PROJECT OR ON ANY OTHER
APPLICABLE, RAIN GARDEN AND/OR MEADOW SEED MIXES SHALL BE MOWN ONLY ONCE YEARLY IN LATE WINTER.
PPROJECT. ANY REUSE WITHOUT WRITTEN VERIFICATION

-O OR ADAPTATION BY PENNONI ASSOCIATES FOR THE 41 5.00 AC. 6. PLANT PROTECTION: AVOID EXCESS INTRUSION INTO THE ROOT ZONE AREA OF ESTABLISHED PLANTINGS. SPECIFIC PURPOSE INTENDED WILL BE AT OWNERS

TED TOTAL LOT (SITE WORK) AREA: SOLE RISK AND WITHOUT LIABILITY OR LEGAL (217,800 SQ. FT.) EXPOSURE TO PENNONI ASSOCIATES; AND OWNER 7. WATERING: UNLESS STATED OTHERWISE IN THESE DOCUMENTS, PROVIDE APPROXIMATELY 1-INCH OF RAINFALL/WATER PER WEEK A SHALL INDEMNIFY AND HOLD HARMLESS PENNONI

I|V INE THROUGHOUT THE GROWING SEASON FOR THE FIRST YEAR. ASSOCIATES FROM ALL CLAIMS, DAMAGES, LOSSES AND

E
R

LP A39
40TOTAL AREA OF WOODLANDS ON SITE:
0.00 AC
EXPENSES ARISING OUT OF OR RESULTING THEREFROM.

C INT

N
'
34°09'3 W
103.15 6"

41PROJECTUANDI24002
IR ATOTAL AREA OF WOODLANDS TO BE PRESERVEDLANDSCAPE ARCHITECT CERTIFICATION
CYM(MUST BE >= 50%):N/A
DATE2025-01-03

L E EL NON-WOODLAND AREA (SITE AREA MINUS AREA 5.00 AC. I, GREGORY B. RISHEL, HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I AM A LICENSED LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT IN THE STATE OF DELAWARE, THAT THE INFORMATION SHOWN HEREON HAS BEEN PREPARED UNDER MY DRAWING SCALE 1" = 30' A VAT OF PRESERVED WOODLAND): (217,800 SQ. FT.) SUPERVISION AND TO THE BEST OF MY BEST KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF REPRESENTS GOOD D RI LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURAL PRACTICES AS REQUIRED BY THE APPLICABLE LAWS OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE. DRAWN BY GBR E P NEW TREE PLANTINGS REQUIRED (1 TREE PER 3,000

PL
SQUARE FEET OF NON-WOODLAND AREA ON SITE): 73 APPROVED BY GBR

A 0 30' 60'

M3738394041TREE PLANTINGS PROPOSED:73GREGORY B. RISHEL, P.L.A. DELAWARE LA LICENSE #S1-0000435DATE
CS2001
SHEET7OF 8
25

Paj 26

Item 2.

City of Dover
DATA SHEET FOR RECREATION PLAN REVIEW
Review of Active Recreation Area Plan

PARKS, RECREATION AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE

MEETING OF February 11, 2025
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING of February 18, 2025

Plan Title: Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 W. North Street, C-25-01

Plan Type: Conditional Use Site Plan and Minor Subdivision Active Recreation Area Plan

Location: Northeast corner of N. West Street and Cecil Street

Address: 207 N. West Street

Tax Parcel: ED-05-076.08-02-01.00-000

Owner: 4BL, LLC

Site Area: 12,168 SF

Zoning: RG-1(General Residence Zone)

Current Use: Vacant Land

Proposed Use: Townhouse Lot
Dwelling Units: 4 units

Parking: Required: 2 per dwelling unit
Proposed: 2 per dwelling unit

Water and Sewer: City of Dover

For Consideration: Active Recreation Plan (Potential Cash-in-Lieu Donation) Exemption under Zoning Ordinance, Article 5 §10.511

  • P.O. Box 475 Dover, DE 19903 26 Community Excellence Through Quality Service

Paj 27

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street – Active Recreation Plan Report to Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee – February 11, 2025

  • I.PROJECT SUMMARY: This application is for review of a Conditional Use and Minor Subdivision Plan to permit the construction of four (4) townhomes on a 12,168-SF parcel of land located at the northeast corner of Cecil Street and North West Street. The property is currently a vacant parcel of land, after the prior residential structure was demolished. The property for the proposed development is zoned RG-1 (General Residence Zone). The owner of record is 4BL, LLC. Property Address: 207 North West Street. Tax Parcel Number: ED-05-076.08-02-01.00-000. Council District 4. For Consideration: Active Recreation Plan Review. See Attached Plan Sheets.

II. ACTIVE RECREATION AREA PLAN SUMMARY:

Article 5, Section 10 of the Zoning Ordinance requires the reservation of open space, recreation and other public facilities as a condition of approval for all one-family dwelling, two-family dwelling and multiple-family dwelling residential developments requiring conditional use approval, site development plan approval, or land subdivision approval by the City of Dover Planning Commission.

Exemption to Recreation Area and Open Space Dedication The Zoning Ordinance Article 5, Section 10.511 notes that residential developments with less than five acres of land and less than ten dwelling units are considered a “small development” and as such are exempt from requiring recreation area and open space facilities, but shall require a cash donation to be made by the developer in lieu of a dedication of land.

The Applicant is therefore not required to provide such recreation facilities, but must otherwise pay a cash-in-lieu fee. This fee is determined based off the appraised value of the gross land area. The appraisal document with the appraised value of the gross land area must be submitted to the Planning Office so that the fee calculation (Cash-in-Lieu amount) may be completed. The information is required to be submitted to the Parks, Recreation and Community Enhancement Committee of City Council for review and approval.

III. REVIEW PROCESS

The Planning Office has prepared this Active Recreation Area Report outlining the requirements based on the Zoning Ordinance. The Parks, Recreation and Community Enhancement Committee will make a recommendation. The Planning Commission must act to accept the Recreation Area Plan as part of the Site Plan review process.

The Parks, Recreation and Community Enhancement Committee will review the Recreation Area Plan at their meeting on February 11, 2025. The Planning Commission Public Hearing and Review of the Conditional Use/Minor Subdivision Plan C-25-02 is scheduled for February 18, 2025.

IV. CODE CITATIONS:

Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 10 – Open Space, Recreation and Other Public Facilities (select excerpts).

Article 5 Section 10 Section 10. - Open space, recreation, and other public facilities. The City of Dover shall require the reservation of open space, recreation, and other public facilities in accordance with the provisions of this section as a condition of approval for all one-family dwelling, two-family dwelling and multiple-family dwelling residential developments requiring conditional use 27

Paj 28

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street – Active Recreation Plan Report to Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee – February 11, 2025

approval, site development plan approval, or land subdivision approval by the City of Dover Planning Commission.

10.1 Recreation areas. 10.11 Purpose. The purpose of this section is to ensure that active recreation areas are provided as an integral design element within residential developments and that such facilities are of an adequate scale in relation to the size of the residential development and which provide residents with a variety of active recreational pursuits.

10.12 Dedication required. The commission shall require the dedication or reservation of recreation areas, and the subsequent construction of recreation facilities of a character, extent and location suitable to the needs created by a development for recreation facilities as defined and in accordance with the design guidelines set forth.

10.13 Definition. The following are illustrative of the types of recreation areas and subsequent facilities that shall be deemed to serve active recreational needs and therefore to count toward satisfaction of the recreation area requirements of this section: tennis courts, handball courts, racquetball courts, swimming pools, saunas and exercise rooms, meeting or activity rooms within clubhouses, baseball and soccer fields, basketball courts, volleyball courts, swings, slides and play apparatus, and developed walking, jogging or biking trails.

10.5 Exemption to recreation area and open space dedication. 10.51 Exemptions for small developments. 10.511 Residential developments with less than five acres of land and less than ten dwelling units. These developments shall be exempt from the land requirements set forth in [sub]sections 10.1 and 10.2, but shall require a full cash donation to be made by the developer in lieu of a dedication of land.

10.52 Amount of cash donation. This cash donation shall be equivalent to ten percent of the appraised value of gross land area. The land area value shall be based on the appraisal prepared for the developer to secure construction financing. This submitted appraisal shall be a copy of the original supplied to the lending institution, with that institution identified, and shall conform in all ways to the Uniform Standard of Professional Appraisal practice and be performed by an appropriately qualified certified appraiser. If an appraisal prepared for construction financing is not available, then the developer shall have an appraisal done in accordance with the procedures set forth in [sub]section 10.174.

10.53 Separate recreation account. The cash donation shall be deposited in a separate account to be used for parks, playgrounds or recreational purposes.

10.54 Appeal of appraised value. If the city does not accept the land value established by the appraisal detailed in [sub]section 10.52, the city may, at the developer's expense, require another appraisal be performed. This appraisal will be let on a bid basis between at least three qualified, certified and licensed appraisers selected by the city. The appraiser(s) who prepared the original appraisal in [sub]section 10.52 cannot be a party to this appeal appraisal.

10.55 Payment of cash donation. One hundred percent cash donation provided under this [sub]section [10.5] shall be collected prior to issuing the first building permit for the development.

10.6 Construction phasing. The recreation and open space areas shall be completed in a proportion equal to or greater than the proportion of residential dwelling units completed, except that 100 percent of the recreation and open space areas shall be completed prior to issuing building permits for the final 20 percent of the dwelling units proposed. Building permits shall not be issued for dwelling units unless the requirements of this section are met.

28

Paj 29

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street – Active Recreation Plan Report to Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee – February 11, 2025

10.7 Council approval. Prior to acceptance by the planning commission, all areas planned for public dedication, or cash donations provided under this section must be submitted to, and approved by the parks, recreation, and community enhancement committee of the City of Dover, and shall be subject to final review and approval by [the] city council.

Regarding the calculation of the amount of the cash donation, the Zoning Ordinance in Article 5 §10.52 specifies that the “cash donation shall be equivalent to ten percent of the appraised value of gross land area” and this value shall be “based on the appraisal prepared for the developer to secure construction financing.” The Applicant is aware of the need to submit this Appraisal document; upon its submission to the required Cash-in-lieu donation amount will be calculated.

  • V.STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS The following are comments and recommendations from staff of the Planning Office following review of the Active Recreation Area Plan (Potential request for Cash-in-Lieu).
  • 1)Staff recommends that a Cash-in-lieu donation of an Active Recreation Area be approved for this project. The project is located Downtown, across from the Senator Bikeway, and within walking distance of City parks and recreation amenities.
  • a.The Cash-in-lieu amount is yet to be determined as a land appraisal submission is required to be submitted to the Planning Office.
  • b.This Request must be reviewed by the Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee of City Council so that they may provide a recommendation to the Planning Commission.
  • c.The payment of the Cash-in-lieu is required prior to the issuance of the Building Permit for this first dwelling unit. The donation amount is deposited in the City’s Parkland Reserve Fund account.

VI. ADVISORY COMMENTS

  • 1)In the event, that major changes and revisions to the Plan occur in the finalization of the Plan contact the Planning Office. Examples include reorientation of buildings, relocation of site components, changes in floor area or unit count, or design revisions impacting Active Recreation Areas. These changes may require resubmission for review by the Development Advisory Committee, Planning Commission, or other agencies and commissions making recommendations in regard to the plan.
  • 2)The Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee shall submit to the Planning Commission a report detailing the recommendations as to the Recreation Area Plan.

Attachments:
• Select pages from the C-25-01 Plan set

Note: This review Report was initially prepared by Staff of the Rossi Group (under a Planning Services contract with the City of Dover). The Report was completed with additional review and editing by the City’s Planning Office.

29

Paj 30

Item 2.

30

Paj 31

Item 2.

31

Paj 32

Item 2.

2-IO
Notch and secure stakes with
plastic strapping, fiberglass tree tape ,
wire, or similar, protect
NO MULCH OVER BASE OF TRUNK AT ROOT CROWN
tree with hose or tree straps
Safety flagging

OVERHEAD LINES

4’ HT. min.
remove burlap, twine and
1-ARK wire from root crown area
after staked and planted securly
minimum 2” maximum 3” shredded
set ball top even with finished grade
hardwood bark

2’ deep min.
dish shaped hole
NO verticle sidewalls

backfill mix - see notes undisturbed grade or if disturbed compacted subgrade below ball Create Earth Saucer under mulch to hold water during establishment. Water throughly at planting. Remove twine from base of tree at root crown after securly staked. Set ball on existing grade or compacted soil with ball top even to finished surrounding grade. Stake with hardwood stakes minimum 6’ length 2” x 2” . One for trees 1.5” cal. two for trees over 2” cal. three for trees over 3.5” cal.

Hole (disturbed dish area) minimum 2 times
the width of the ball - NO EXCEPTIONS

1-ARK TREE PLANTING DETAIL

not to scale

1-CC 1-CC

NO MULCH MOUNDS OVER TREE OR SHRUB OVERHEAD LINES TRUNKS OR STEMS

Notch and secure stakes with plastic strapping, fiberglass tree tape , wire, or similar, protect tree with hose or tree straps NO MULCH OVER BASE OF TRUNK AT ROOT CROWN Safety flagging

TREE PRESERVATION PLANTING PLAN

  • •NO EXISTING WOOLAND, TREES, OR SPECIMEN TREES 3’ HT. min. remove burlap, twine and
wire from root crown areaPLANTING SCHEDULE
after staked and planted securly12,168 SF TOTAL LOT AREA / 3000 SF = 4.056 = 4 REQUIRED TREES
TYPE KEY #BOTANICAL AND COMMON NAMEMINIMUM SIZE
minimum 2” maximum 3” shredded
PROVIDED 6 TREES
Note: Substitions or variations of any kind from the materials specified requires Landscape Architect’s written approval prior to installation
set ball top even with finished grade
hardwood bark
TARK2ACER RUBRUM ‘KARPICK ’ - COLUMNAR RED MAPLE2.0” CAL. BB 12’ -14’ HT. BRANCHED TO NO LESS THAN 6’ HT ABOVE GRADE
O CC 2 CERCIS CANADENSIS - ‘FOREST PANSY’ - FOREST PANSY REDBUD 2.0” CAL. BB 12’ -14’ HT. BRANCHED TO NO LESS THAN 6’ HT ABOVE GRADE
1’ deep min.
dish shaped hole
NO verticle sidewallsEIO2ILEX OPACA - AMERICAN HOLLY6’ - 8’ BB BRANCHED TO THE GROUND
backfill mix - see notes
X XX - NOTE PLAN DRAWING FOR PLANT MATERIAL QUANTITIES IN REQUIREMENT AREAS SHALL
undisturbed grade
SUPERSEDE THE SCHEDULE - SUBSTITUTIONS ALLOWED WITH THE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS APPROVAL GRAPHIC SCALE
or if disturbed compacted subgrade below ball105102040
0

Create Earth Saucer under mulch to hold water during establishment. KEY - T = TREE, E = EVERGREEN TREE ST = STREET TREE O = UNDERSTORY TREE S = SHRUB P = PERENNIAL Water throughly at planting. Remove twine from base of tree at root crown ( IN FEET ) after securly staked. Set ball on existing grade or compacted soil with ball top G = GRASSES, GC = GROUND COVER H = HERBACEOUS RF = REFORESTATION B = BULBS V = VINES 1 inch = 10 ft. even to finished surrounding grade. Stake with one hardwood stakes minimum 4’ length The source of all plant material for the site shall be from within one whole number hardiness zone as defined Hole (disturbed dish area) minimum 2 times by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) of the zone that covers the majority of Kent County. the width of the ball - NO EXCEPTIONS The handling, planting and perpetual maintenance of all tree and plant material shall conform to Tree Care Industry Association ANSI A300-2011 standards. EVERGREEN TREE PLANTING DETAIL ALL TREES MUST BE PLANTED PER THE DETAIL INCULDING SOIL AMENDMENTS - MULCHED - STAKED - GUYED AND WATERED WHEN INSTALLED not to scale

PLANTING NOTES:

1 - PLANT IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE STANDARDS AS SET FORTH BY THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF NURSERYMEN, AND THE AMERICAN STANDARD FOR NURSERY STOCK. 2- LOCATE OVERHEAD AND UNDERGROUND UTILITIES PRIOR TO PLANTING. FIELD ADJUST PLANT LOCATIONS AS NEEDED TO AVOID CONFLICT WITH SWALES, PIPES, DRAINAGE STRUCTURES, WIRES, UTILITY BOXES TRANSFORMERS, EXISTING VEGETATION THAT REMAINS, ETC. STOP PLANTING AND CONTACT THE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT AND OWNER IF SOIL CONDITIONS ARE ENCOUNTERED THAT ARE UNSUITABLE FOR PROPER PLANT GROWTH. 3- FIELD LOCATION PLANTS TO AVOID CONFLICT WITH SWALES, DRAINAGE AND UTILITIES ABOVE FIELD LOCATE ALL UTILTIES PRIOR TO DIGGING AND BELOW GROUND, EXISTING VEGETATION ETC. ADJUST LOCATIONS OF PLANTINGS TO AVOID CONFLICTS WITH 4 - PLANTING BACKFILL MIX: ONE PART PEAT HUMUS, TO ONE PART TOPSOIL TO ONE PART EXISTING SOIL. DRAINAGE , UTILITIES, STRUCTURES, AND VEGETATION TO REMAIN. AMENDMENTS : MIX INTO SOIL PRIOR TO BACKFILLING, .25 LBS ORGANIC FERTILIZER 5-10-5 ORGANIC FERTILIZER IF SOILS UNSUITABLE FOR PLANTING AND PROPER PLANT ESTABLISHMENT .75 LBS OF BONE MEAL, AND 1 LB OF ORGANIC DECOMPOSED COW MANURE PER CUBIC FOOT OF BACKFILL. SET BALL OR CONTAINER ARE ENCOUNTERED, STOP PLANTING AND NOTIFY THE OWNER AND LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT. SOIL TOP EVEN WITH FINISHED GRADE. 5- THE QUANTITIES OF PLANTS ON THE PLAN DRAWING FOR CODE REQUIRED AREAS SHALL REMAIN WITH THE SPECIFIC 1901 Hickory Hill Road PLANTING AND CONSTRUCTION OPERATIONS SHALL CONFORM TO AREA (IE: BUFFERYARDS, PARKING AREAS ETC) BUT SHALL BE FIELD LOCATED TO AVOID UTILITIES OR OBSTRUCTIONS Chadds Ford PA 19317 ALL LOCAL STATE AND FEDERAL SAFETY, ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS. CONTRACTORS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL PERMITS AND SUBMISSIONS REQUIRED FOR THE WORK. AND SHALL GOVERN OVER THE SCHEDULE TO MEET MINIMUM CODE REQUIREMENTS. Landscape Architect Certification of Plan Accuracy 610-348-7786 I hereby certify that I am a registered professional landscape architect in the State of Delaware and that all of the information on this plan, other than the boundary and topographic 12-19-24 ellentraceyDESIGNSetc@gmail.com information, is true and correct to the accuracy required by accepted landscape architectural design standards. 32

Paj 33

Item 2.

33

Paj 34

Item 3.

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

ACTION FORM

PROCEEDING: Council Committee of the Whole (Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement) DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Water & Wastewater SUBMITTED ON: January 22, 2025 PREPARED BY: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services REVIEWED BY: Dave S. Hugg III, City Manager and Patricia M. Marney, Controller / Treasurer

SUBJECT: Silver Lake Dam – Annual Inspection Review TIMETABLE: In accordance with the 2024 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update Memorandum RELATED PROJECT: n/a REFERENCE: n/a

EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: n/a
AMOUNT BUDGETED: n/a
FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): n/a

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

To accept the Silver Lake Dam 2024 Dam Safety Inspection Report and the FY 2025 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update Memorandum.

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:

The Department of Water & Wastewater (DWW) utilizes a consultant to perform an annual inspection of the Silver Lake Dam. The annual inspection is required by the State of Delaware’s Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control (DNREC) as well as our insurance carrier. The 2024 above water inspection and underwater inspection was performed on November 6, 2024. The underwater inspection required a second visit and it was performed on December 23, 2024. The final report was fully executed on December 30, 2024. The next inspection will occur in the summer of 2025. Silver Lake Dam 2024 Dam Safety Inspection Report provides the results of the field observations of the embankment dam, concrete spillway and drop inlet including the sluice gate. The report also includes recommendations for repair and maintenance. The 2024 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update Memorandum provides a summary of the recommendations provided in the report. Action items are assigned to either the Parks & Recreation (P&R) Department’s Ground Division or the DWW Engineering Division. The plan of action and/or status for the recommendations are included within the memorandum. The breakdown of the thirty-six (36) action items contained in the report is as follows:  P&R Grounds Division – Annual Maintenance Checklist – 10  P&R Grounds Division – Evaluate / Monitor – 9  DWW Engineering Division – Future CIP Proposal –16  DPW Streets Division – Maintenance Action - 1

34

Paj 35

Item 3.

MEMORANDUM

Department of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services
P.O. Box 475
Dover, Delaware 19903
Phone: (302) 736-7025
Fax: (302) 736-7092
E-mail: jlyon@dover.de.us

TO: David S. Hugg III, City Manager
Sharon J. Duca, P.E., Assistant City Manager

CC: Roger Ridgeway, Parks & Recreation Director Mark Nowak, GISP, Public Works Director

FROM: Jason A Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services

DATE: January 31, 2025

SUBJECT: 2024 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update

Due to the projected cost of the project, a Request for Quotes to perform the 2024 Silver Lake Dam Inspection was sent out on July 17, 2024, to twelve (12) consulting firms. None of the firms submitted bids for the project. A search was performed for additional consulting firms to add to the vendor list. On September 20, 2024, a second Request for Quotes was sent to nineteen (19) consulting firms. Three firms submitted a quote, Verdantas, LLC was ultimately awarded the project. The Silver Lake Dam Inspection Report was finalized on December 30, 2024, and contains various recommendations necessary to maintain the dam in good working order. The tables below provide a summary of the recommendations as well as a status update of each. It should be noted that the report did not provide any repairs that needed to be immediately addressed.

A Silver Lake Dam Annual Maintenance Checklist for the Parks & Recreation Department Grounds Division was developed in January 2020. Since that time, annual maintenance activities have been performed and will continue to be performed. Some of the recommendations below added additional activities to the Annual Maintenance Checklist.

CATEGORY DESCRIPTION ASSIGNMENT STATUS

Earth Continue to control the vegetative growth in the Grounds Annual Maintenance Embankment rip rap with herbicide. Checklist – 3x Per Year Upstream Continue to remove trash and debris that Grounds Annual Maintenance Slope accumulates at the waterline. Checklist – 1x Per Year Seed the areas of bare ground on the east and Grounds Annual Maintenance west embankments. (10,000 SF) Checklist – 2x Per Year The stump noted above the rip rap on the east Grounds Annual Maintenance upstream slope can remain provided it is no Checklist – 3x Per Year longer alive and should be monitored periodically.

1|P a ge
35

Paj 36

Item 3.
2024 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update
January 22, 2025

CATEGORY DESCRIPTION ASSIGNMENT STATUS

Earth Continue to monitor the embankments for Grounds Evaluate Embankment depressions. Upstream Rip rap (1,600 SF) should be added on the east Grounds Evaluate Slope upstream slopes to help with wave action erosion (Continued) during low lake-level seasons. Repair the crack noted on the west side of the Engineering Future CIP proposal. boat ramp. Dam Crest The crest appears to be in good condition. As Grounds Continue to Monitor indicated in previous inspections, it should continue to be monitored for depressions. Consideration should be given to repaving the Streets Evaluate asphalt roadway on the dam crest. Earth Continue controlling the rip rap’s vegetative Grounds Annual Maintenance Embankment growth with herbicide. Checklist – 3x Per Year Downstream Any bare spots, including eroded areas, areas Grounds Annual Maintenance Slope disturbed by mowing operations, or areas around Checklist – 2x Per Year bollards, should be seeded and covered with new grass. The undermined sidewalk near the fence adjacent Grounds Evaluate to the fish ladder should be remediated/backfilled, as it will be a tripping hazard and could result in additional erosion or depressions. The woody bushes/weeds that were noted Grounds Annual Maintenance growing in the fence that cordoning off the Checklist – 2x Per Year bottom of the fish ladder and near the fish ladder sign can be left in place, provided they are no longer alive. They should be monitored periodically. The No. 57 stone used as ground cover inside the Grounds Evaluate fence adjacent to the fish ladder is allows weeds to grow. The weeds should be removed and controlled with herbicide. To minimize the potential for weed growth, consider replacing the No. 57 stone with grass seed or rip rap.

2|P a ge
36

Paj 37

2024 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update
January 22, 2025 Item 3.

CATEGORY DESCRIPTION ASSIGNMENT STATUS

Earth The riprap appears sparse or may have been filled Grounds Evaluate Embankment in the areas adjacent to the fish ladder on the east Downstream downstream slope. Additionally, rip rap has been Slope placed only along a portion of the west (Continued) downstream wing wall and appears to be sparse at the toe of the west downstream wing wall. A study should be performed to determine if additional rip rap should be added and/or replaced. The undermined fence post at the southern end Grounds Evaluate of the chain link fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated. The eroded areas noted in the area of the fence post and the eroded area south of the fence that extends to the exit channel should be remediated. Continue to monitor the eroded area adjacent to Grounds Evaluate the upper parking lot that has been remediated for further signs of erosion. Repair the soil reinforcement netting in this location. Concrete Repair the cracks below water, with pressure Engineering Future CIP proposal. Spillway – injected epoxy (7 LF). Upstream Field measure, cut and re-adjust rotated fence Engineering Future CIP proposal. Face and Wing extension on all wingwalls, and secure to prevent Walls rotation. (7 LF) Bolts should be checked, tightened, and replaced Engineering Future CIP proposal. if missing on the railing system. Concrete There are three seeps on the east wing wall, Engineering Future CIP proposal. Spillway – under the fish ladder. The seeps appear to be Downstream below areas that were previously patched and Face and Wing repaired. The 2023 inspection report also noted Walls these leaks. It is recommended to conduct a resistivity geophysics study to aid in determining the water elevation behind the wall nondestructive method) before looking into destructive methods of investigation. Fish Ladder Repair the broken weld at the third steel brace Engineering Future CIP proposal. from the north (less than 1 LF). This location was unable to be verified since the fish ladder was not operating. No evidence of welding repair was visible. Replace missing bolts and nuts with stainless steel Engineering Future CIP proposal. hardware.

3|P a ge
37

Paj 38

2024 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update
January 22, 2025 Item 3.

CATEGORY DESCRIPTION ASSIGNMENT STATUS

Fish Ladder Tighten loose bolts. Engineering Future CIP proposal. (Continued) Continue to remove the growing vegetation Grounds Evaluate Consider a total replacement suited for needs or a Engineering Future CIP proposal. replacement with minimum maintenance Spillway Monitor seep on the downstream side. Engineering Future CIP proposal. Evaluate a resurfacing program for the apron as Engineering Future CIP proposal. aggregates are getting more exposed and will eventually progress to complete aggregate loss. Pedestrian Repair the small indent on the west side of the Engineering Future CIP proposal. Walkway walkway to avoid potential tripping hazard. Monitor walkway for cracks, and repair as Engineering Future CIP proposal. needed. Outlet Works Repair the opening between the two trash rack Engineering Future CIP proposal. panels (5 LF). Operate sluice gate monthly to monitor Grounds Annual Maintenance performance and keep mechanical components in Checklist – Monthly. working shape. Repair outlet works platform and install railing for Engineering Future CIP proposal. added operator safety. Exit Channel Approximately 1,900 to 2,000 square feet of rip Engineering Future CIP proposal. rap recommended to be repaired downstream of the downstream apron. Bushes and woody weeds in the rip rap should be Grounds Annual Maintenance removed and controlled with herbicide. Checklist – Quarterly. Any bare spots along the exit channel should be Grounds Annual Maintenance remediated with rip rap or seeded. Checklist – 2x Per Year

TASK TOTALS36
P&R Grounds Division – Annual Maintenance Checklist10
P&R Grounds Division – Evaluate / Monitor9
DWW Engineering Division – Future CIP proposal16
DPW Streets Division – Maintenance Action1

4|P a ge
38

Paj 39

Item 3.

Dam Inspection Report
Silver Lake Dam
City of Dover, Delaware

Prepared for:
City of Dover
Department of Water and Wastewater
P.O. Box 475
Dover, DE 19903

Prepared by:
Verdantas LLC
1060 S. Governors Ave. – Suite 101
Dover, Delaware 19904

Verdantas Project No: 27233

December 2024

39

Paj 40

Item 3.

This page intentionally left blank.

40

Paj 41

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

Table of Contents

  • 1.Executive Summary 1
  • 2.Introduction 4 2.1 Background 4 2.2 Dam Design 5
  • 3.Observations 7 3.1 Main Dam 7 3.2 Fish Ladder 8 3.3 Left (East) Abutment 8 3.4 Walkway Bridge 8 3.5 Right (West) Abutment 9 3.6 Downstream Channel 9 3.7 Boat Ramp and Pier 9 3.8 Miscellaneous 9 3.9 Sluice Gate Exercise and Operator Comments 9
  • 4.Underwater Inspection Summary 10 4.1 Outlet Works 10 4.2 Spillway Wing Walls 10
  • 5.Recommendations 11 Appendix A 14 Appendix B 15 Appendix C 16

41
Verdantas.com i

Paj 42

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

  • 1.Executive Summary The following report provides the summary of Verdantas LLC’s (Verdantas) observations obtained during the annual inspection of the Silver Lake Dam performed on November 7 and 8, 2024 and December 23, 2024. Based on our review of the available information, the Silver Lake Dam was originally constructed in 1944 and classified as a high-hazard dam. This classification is based on the impact of dam failure, which has a high probability of causing loss of human life. As such, the dam is subject to annual inspections to ensure it conforms to the state’s guidelines and standards. The dam is an earthen embankment approximately 630 feet long with a concrete gravity spillway that is approximately 150 feet long and 15 feet high. Verdantas performed the above-water inspection while the underwater inspection was subcontracted to Walker Diving, a commercial diving contractor. The following non-immediate repairs/improvements are recommended. Quantities noted below are estimated and an engineer’s estimate of probable costs will be prepared following submission and review of this inspection report.

Upstream Slope: 1. Continue to control the vegetative growth in the rip rap with herbicide. 2. Continue to remove trash and debris that accumulates at the waterline. 3. Seed the areas of bare ground on the left and right embankments (10,000 SF). 4. Repair the crack on the boat ramp's right side. This crack appeared to have been repaired, but it has cracked again. 5. Continue to monitor the embankments for any depressions. 6. The stump noted above the rip rap on the right upstream slope can remain, provided it is no longer alive. This item should be monitored periodically. 7. Rip rap (1,600 SF) should be added on the east upstream slopes to help with wave action erosion during low lake-level seasons. Dam Crest: 1. The crest appears to be in good condition. As indicated in previous inspections, it should continue to be monitored for depressions. 2. Consideration should be given to repaving the asphalt roadway on the dam crest. Downstream Slope: 1. Continue controlling the rip rap's vegetative growth with herbicide. 2. Any bare spots, including eroded areas, areas disturbed by mowing operations, or areas around bollards, should be seeded and covered with new grass. 3. The undermined sidewalk near the fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated/backfilled, as it will be a tripping hazard and could result in additional erosion or depressions. 4. The woody bushes/weeds that were noted growing in the fence cordoning off the bottom of the fish ladder and near the fish ladder sign can be left in place, provided they are no longer alive. They should be monitored periodically. 5. The No.57 stone used as ground cover inside the fence adjacent to the fish ladder allows weeds to grow. The weeds should be removed and controlled with herbicide. To minimize

42
Verdantas.com 1

Paj 43

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

the potential for weed growth, consider replacing the No. 57 stone with grass seed or rip rap. 6. The riprap appears sparse or may have been filled in the areas adjacent to the fish ladder on the left downstream slope. Additionally, rip rap has been placed only along a portion of the right downstream wing wall and appears to be sparse at the toe of the right downstream wing wall. A study should be performed to determine if additional rip rap should be added and/or replaced. 7. The undermined fence post at the southern end of the chain link fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated. The eroded areas noted in the area of the fence post and the eroded area south of the fence that extends to the exit channel should be remediated. 8. Continue to monitor the eroded area adjacent to the upper parking lot that has been remediated for further signs of erosion. Repair the soil reinforcement netting in this location. Upstream Face and Wing Walls: 1. Repair the cracks below water, with pressure injected epoxy (7 LF). 2. Field measure, cut and re-adjust rotated fence extension on all wingwalls, and secure to prevent rotation. (7 LF) 3. Bolts should be checked, tightened, and replaced if missing on the railing system. Downstream Face and Wing Walls: 1. There are three seeps on the east wing wall, under the fish ladder. The seeps appear to be below areas that were previously patched and repaired. The 2023 inspection report also noted these leaks. It is recommended to conduct a resistivity geophysics study to aid in determining the water elevation behind the wall (nondestructive method) before looking into destructive methods of investigation. Fish Ladder: 1. Repair the broken weld at the third steel brace from the north (less than 1 LF). This location was unable to be verified since the fish ladder was not operating. No evidence of welding repair was visible. 2. Replace missing bolts and nuts with stainless steel hardware. 3. Tighten loose bolts. 4. Continue to remove the growing vegetation. 5. Consider a total replacement suited for needs or a replacement with minimum maintenance. Spillway: 1. Monitor seep on the downstream side. 2. Evaluate a resurfacing program for the apron as aggregates are getting more exposed and will eventually progress to complete aggregate loss. Pedestrian Walkway: 1. Repair the small indent on the west side of the walkway to avoid potential tripping hazard. 2. Monitor walkway for cracks, and repair as needed.

43
Verdantas.com 2

Paj 44

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

Outlet Works: 1. Repair the opening between the two trash rack panels (5 LF). 2. Operate sluice gate monthly to monitor performance and keep mechanical components in working shape. 3. Repair outlet works platform and install railing for added operator safety. Exit Channel: 1. Approximately 1,900 to 2,000 square feet of rip rap recommedned to be repaired downstream of the downstream apron 2. Bushes and woody weeds in the rip rap should be removed and controlled with herbicide. 3. Any bare spots along the exit channel should be remediated with rip rap or seeded. Boat Dock: 1. No repairs are recommended at this time. Concrete Slab on Grade Pad: 1. No repairs are recommended at this time.

44
Verdantas.com 3

Paj 45

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

  • 2.Introduction This report summarizes Verdantas LLC (Verdantas) observations and recommendations during from the 2024 annual inspection of the Silver Lake Dam. The dam has been classified as a high- hazard dam. This classification is based on the impact of dam failure, which has a high probability of causing loss of human life. As such, the dam is subject to annual inspections to ensure that it conforms with the state’s guidelines and standards. On November 7, 2024, Verdantas carried out the dam inspection and subcontracted Walker Diving Underwater Construction, LLC (Walker Diving) for underwater inspection services. Additional fieldwork was performed on November 8, 2024 utilizing an unmanned aircraft system (UAS, e.g. “drone”). Walker Diving performed additional review on December 23, 2024. The following documents were available to aid in the inspection and in developing this report: ▶ 2023 Dam Inspection Report for the City of Dover Department of Water and Wastewater, prepared by Remington & Vernick Engineers; ▶ 1944 Set of Plans prepared by Albright & Friel, Inc.; ▶ Silver Lake Dam Rehabilitation Plans prepared by EMJ/McFarland-Johnson Engineers, Inc. (undated) The following section discusses the dam's background and a brief description of the dam design based on review of existing information. Afterward, the above-water field observations of the dam conditions are outlined, followed by a summary of the underwater observations made by Walker Diving. These observations are accompanied by captioned photos included in Appendix A. The diver’s notes are included in Appendix B and highlight the observed conditions at the different locations of the dam. Appendix C includes the Delaware Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Council (DNREC) Dam Safety Program Visual Inspection Checklist.

2.1 Background The Silver Lake Dam, constructed in 1944, is located within the Silver Lake Park at the end of Lewis Mill Drive, City of Dover, Delaware, noted in Figure 1. The dam is along the Saint Jones River and impounds Silver Lake, an approximately 167-acre manmade Lake. The City of Dover owns the dam, Silver Lake Park, and Silver Lake Beach recreational areas. Silver Lake Beach is located to the west side of the dam, while residential structures and apartment buildings are located to the east.

45
Verdantas.com 4

Paj 46

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

Figure 1: Silver Lake Dam Site Location

2.2 Dam Design Albright & Friel Inc. of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, prepared a set of 9 design drawings, dated July 7, 1944. The dam upstream face was designed to be 22 feet in height. The foundation of the dam was composed of sheet steel piling on both upstream and downstream ends (north and south). The spillway apron was designed to have a 12-inch thick bituminous joint seal on the surface. The dam core was made of a Class “C” concrete. The width of the dam from the upstream foundation to the downstream foundation limits was 28 feet. The toe of the dam was designed to be a 24-inch wide and 6 feet deep concrete footing wall. The wing walls were made of Class “B” concrete. The design called for a 24-inch diameter cast iron pipe as the main outlet. Figure 2 shows the cross-section drawings used in this section.

46
Verdantas.com 5

Paj 47

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

Figure 2: Cross Section of Design (Plan Number 44023-5,
prepared by Albright & Friel Inc., dated July 7, 1944)

47
Verdantas.com 6

Paj 48

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

  • 3.Observations The observations and general assessment obtained during the dam inspection are outlined in the section herein. These observations are accompanied by photographs taken across the site and presented in Appendix A. The observations listed below addressed the main dam, fish ladder, walkway bridge, east and west abutments, downstream channel and boat ramp and pier separately. In addition, miscellaneous observations the do not pertain to the previously mentioned sections were addressed in a standalone section. For general guidance on the facilities discussed refer to Photos 1 through 3.

3.1 Main Dam ▶ The outlet works was located downstream south of the control platform. During the inspection, the outlet works was working properly (Photos 4 and 5). ▶ The outlet works platform can only be accessed by boat and is reported to be operated by two operators (Photo 6). ▶ The 24-inch diameter cast iron pipe (part of the outlet works) did not have visible cracks or evidence of deformation (Photo 7). ▶ The dam can channel water flow through two wingwalls that retain the earth embankments on both the west and east sides of the dam. ▶ The east wingwall (Photos 8 and 9) had a staff gage and fish ladder adjacent to the wingwall. There is a concrete chute adjacent to the fish ladder (adjacent to the west) (Photo 10). The staff gage and chute were working, the fish ladder was not in operation. The east wingwall was observed to be repaired and in good shape above the water line on the upstream side. ▶ The dam allows pedestrians to cross the dam with a pedestrian bridge supported by nine concrete piers. Following the 2023 inspection report numbering, the piers were identified by numbers from west to east (Photos 11 through 17). The piers were in good shape. ▶ The west wingwall was observed to have been repaired and was in good shape above water (Photo 18). There was minor debris on the crest of the dam (westmost side). ▶ The downstream side of the dam had two notable observations, a hole (2 inches deep and ¼ inch in diameter) and a potential seep (moist spot) (0.5 inches by 10 inches in area), presented in Photo 19 with zoomed/detailed on Photos 45 and 46. ▶ The water spilling over the dam (as designed) and the routine operation of the outworks appear to have displaced the riprap that is supposed to be abutting the downstream foundation wall of the dam (photo 20). ▶ There are potentially 10 feet (width) by 12.5 inches (depth) by 140 feet (length) of rip rap that has been displaced (Photos 21 and 22). ▶ There were three seeps on the east wingwall, all under the fish ladder elevation. One seep was noted to be under a metal bracket that supports the fish ladder (Photo 35). ▶ The second seep was on the lower part of a previously patched/repaired concrete spot (Photo 36). ▶ The third seep was near the bottom of the spillway, north of a metal bracket with iron oxidation staining (Photos 38 and 39).

48
Verdantas.com 7

Paj 49

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

▶ The downstream side of the spillway was in good condition. Patches were observed throughout (Photos 40 through 43). ▶ Verdantas conducted a hammer test using a geologic hammer on the concrete surface of the spillway to identify hollow sounds, which may be equivalent to potential voids under the concrete surface. (Photo 44). Verdantas found 4 areas with hollow sounds, but they appeared to be patched (typical of concrete surface patching). ▶ There was spalling and exposed aggregates throughout the surface of the downstream side of the spillway (Photos 47 and 48). ▶ No seeps were observed on the downstream side of the west wingwall and it appeared to be repaired and in good condition. There was dried moss on the west wingwall and spillway contact (Photo 49).

3.2 Fish Ladder ▶ The fish ladder was not in operation during the inspection. ▶ The fish ladder was in fair to poor condition due to missing bolts and nuts throughout the structure. Also, loose nuts may become undone during operation-induced vibrations (Photos 23 through 34). ▶ There was one bolt and nut missing, four bolts missing nuts, and three bolts with loose nuts about to become undone. ▶ The brackets of the fish ladder had oxidation throughout, and the welding seal could not be evaluated due to the lack of water flowing on the ladder (Photo 37).

3.3 Left (East) Abutment ▶ The east abutment/embankment had two different sizes of rip rap on the upstream side (Photo 50). The rip rap on the east part of the embankment was 6 inches in diameter, while the rip rap on the west side was 12 inches in diameter (Photo 51). ▶ The area above the rip rap was eroded and appeared bare (e.g., no vegetation cover) (Photo 52). ▶ The water line was below normal, and areas without rip rap protection were exposed (Photo 53). ▶ Approximately 7 feet of railing is recommended to be adjusted between the railing on the upstream side of the wingwall and the north/east corner of the walkway bridge.

3.4 Walkway Bridge ▶ The walkway bridge was in good condition, and the surface appeared sealed (Photos 54 and 55). ▶ The rails generally appeared secured. ▶ The repairs on the underside of the walkway bridge were complete and in fair condition. There were pockets of efflorescence observed throughout the repairs (Photos 56 through 59)

49
Verdantas.com 8

Paj 50

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

3.5 Right (West) Abutment ▶ The west abutment/embankment upstream generally appeared to have coverage of rip rap (Photo 60). ▶ The area above the rip rap was eroded and bare (e.g., no vegetation cover) (Photos 61 and 62).

3.6 Downstream Channel
▶ The channel appeared clear and in generally good working condition.

3.7 Boat Ramp and Pier ▶ The cracks on the ramp appeared to be repaired, but a recent ¼ inch crack on the repaired section (Photos 64 and 65) was observed. ▶ The pier appeared to be recently repaired and was observed to be in generally good condition (Photos 66 and 67).

3.8 Miscellaneous ▶ The streetlamp had exposed wiring at the base (Photos 68 and 69) ▶ The sidewalk on the east abutment, east of the fish ladder, had undermining and erosion (Photos 70 and 71). ▶ Both aerial drone and on-ground inspection confirmed that the asphalt pavement has alligator cracks. There was rutting on the east part of the east embankment (downstream) (Photo 72). ▶ The state of the boat ramp and erosion on the downstream side of the east embankment is presented in Photo 73. The erosion is throughout the east embankment. ▶ There is a tree less than 25 feet from the west wing wall (Photo 74). ▶ Bare spots of the east embankment were noted throughout (Photo 75).

3.9 Sluice Gate Exercise and Operator Comments The sluice gate was operated during the inspection. The operator appeared to have issues closing the gate and noted a cracking sound. During the operation, it was reported that personnel had to reopen the gate and then slowly close it for the gate to seal. The sluice gate can only be manually operated from a wooden platform, accessed by a boat. The operator indicated that a new ladder and railings would allow for a safer operation.

50
Verdantas.com 9

Paj 51

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

  • 4.Underwater Inspection Summary The following are observations (Photos presented in Appendix B) from Walker Diving Underwater Construction, LLC.:

4.1 Outlet Works ▶ The outlet works coupler and gate stop were in fair to good condition (Photo 76). ▶ The outlet works shaft that travelled through the gate to the top was in fair to good condition (Photo 77) ▶ The timber cribbing around the outlet works structure was in fair condition (Photo 78). ▶ There were gaps in the chain link fence used as a trash rack on the north side of the structure (Photos 79 and 80).

4.2 Spillway Wing Walls ▶ Abrasion was observed at the waterline across east wingwall Photo 81. ▶ There was a crack that runs horizontally with a width of ¼ inch to ½ inch, with a length of 27 inches. The crack was located 5 feet north of the fish ladder and 1 foot above the mudline (photo 82). ▶ Spalling was observed throughout the east wingwall ¼ inch to 3/8 inch deep below waterline. ▶ West wingwall has abrasions throughout at waterline to 1 foot in depth. There was spalling throughout. ▶ West wingwall had repairs that were made on the west wingwall appear to be to hand packed concrete placement and are in fair condition (photo 83). ▶ West wingwall has a crack 29 inches long, 1/8 inch wide, approximately 6 feet south from the north end of the wingwall. ▶ West wingwall had cracks 8 feet south from the north end of the wingwall that were 8 inches in length, ¼ inch in width and there directly above a crack that was 12 inches in length with ¼ inch in width.

51
Verdantas.com 10

Paj 52

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

  • 5.Recommendations The following non-immediate repairs/improvements are recommendations as noted on the DNREC Dam Safety Visual Inspection: Upstream Slope:
  • 1.Continue to control the vegetative growth in the rip rap with herbicide.
  • 2.Continue to remove trash and debris that accumulates at the waterline.
  • 3.Seed the areas of bare ground on the left and right embankments (10,000 SF).
  • 4.Repair the crack on the boat ramp's right side. This crack appeared to be repaired, but a recent crack was observed.
  • 5.Continue to monitor the embankments for any depressions.
  • 6.The stump noted above the rip rap on the right upstream slope can remain provided it is no longer alive. It is recommended that the stump be monitored periodically.
  • 7.Rip rap (1,600 SF) should be added on the east upstream slopes to help with wave action erosion during low lake-level seasons. Dam Crest:
  • 1.The crest appears to be in good condition. As indicated in previous inspections, it should continue to be monitored for depressions.
  • 2.Consideration should be given to repaving the asphalt roadway on the dam crest. Downstream Slope:
  • 1.Continue controlling the rip rap's vegetative growth with herbicide.
  • 2.Any bare spots, including eroded areas, areas disturbed by mowing operations, or around bollards, should be seeded and covered with new grass.
  • 3.The undermined sidewalk near the fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated/backfilled, as it will be a tripping hazard and could result in additional erosion or depressions.
  • 4.The woody bushes/weeds that were noted growing in the fence cordoning off the bottom of the fish ladder and near the fish ladder sign can be left in place, provided they are no longer alive. They should be monitored periodically.
  • 5.The No. 57 stone used as ground cover inside the fence adjacent to the fish ladder allows weeds to grow. The weeds should be removed and controlled with herbicide. To minimize the potential for weed growth, consider replacing the No. 57 stone with grass seed or rip rap.
  • 6.The riprap appears sparse or may have been filled in the areas adjacent to the fish ladder on the left downstream slope. Additionally, rip rap has been placed only along a portion of the right downstream wing wall and appears to be sparse at the toe of the right downstream wing wall. A study should be performed to determine if additional rip rap should be added and/or replaced.
  • 7.The undermined fence post at the southern end of the chain link fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated. The eroded areas noted in the area of the fence post

52
Verdantas.com 11

Paj 53

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

and the eroded area south of the fence that extends to the exit channel should be remediated. 8. Continue to monitor the eroded area adjacent to the upper parking lot that has been remediated for further signs of erosion. Repair the soil reinforcement netting in this location. Upstream Face and Wing Walls: 1. Repair the cracks below water with pressure injected epoxy (7 LF). 2. Field measure, cut and re-adjust rotated fence extension on all wingwalls, and secure to prevent rotation. (7 LF) 3. Bolts should be checked, tightened, and replaced if missing on the railing system. Downstream Face and Wing Walls: 1. There are three seeps on the east wing wall, under the fish ladder. The seeps appear to be below areas that were previously patched and repaired. The 2023 inspection report also noted these leaks. It is recommended to conduct a resistivity geophysics study to aid in determining the water elevation behind the wall (nondestructive method) before looking into destructive methods of investigation. Fish Ladder: 1. Repair the broken weld at the third steel brace from the north (< 1 LF). This location was unable to be verified since the fish ladder was not operating. No evidence of welding repair was visible. 2. Replace missing bolts and nuts with stainless steel hardware. 3. Tighten loose bolts. 4. Continue to remove the growing vegetation. 5. Consider a total replacement suited for needs or a replacement with minimum maintenance. Spillway: 1. Monitor seep on the downstream side. 2. Evaluate a resurfacing program for the apron as aggregates are getting more exposed and will eventually progress to complete aggregate loss. Pedestrian Walkway: 1. Repair the small indent on the west side of the walkway to avoid potential tripping hazard. 2. Monitor walkway for cracks, and repair as needed. Outlet Works: 1. Repair the opening between the two trash rack panels (5 LF). 2. Operate sluice gate monthly to monitor performance and keep mechanical components in working shape. 3. Repair outlet works platform and install railing for added operator safety.

53
Verdantas.com 12

Paj 54

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

Exit Channel: 1. Approximately 1,900 to 2,000 square feet of rip rap is recommended to be repaired downstream of the downstream apron 2. Bushes and woody weeds in the rip rap should be removed and controlled with herbicide. 3. Any bare spots along the exit channel should be remediated with rip rap or seeded. Boat Dock: 1. No repairs are recommended at this time. Concrete Slab on Grade Pad: 1. No repairs are recommended at this time. The following Maintenance items should be completed: 1. Area where new grass seed has been planted should be monitored for growth. 2. Weeds growing from the joints between the rip rap stones should be removed and maintained to prevent further growth

54
Verdantas.com 13

Paj 55

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

Appendix A
Inspection Photos (Verdantas)

55
Verdantas.com

Paj 56

Item 3.

Outlet Structure

Boat Ramp

Photo 1: Drone photograph showing Silver Lake Dam overview (looking west)

Outlet Control Platform
(Outlet Works)

Outlet Works

Fish Ladder

Photo 2: Drone photograph showing east abutment, fish ladder, and outlet works structure

56

Paj 57

Item 3.

West Wingwall

Photo 3: Drone photograph showing the west abutment

Photo 4: View of outlet works at the downstream side of dam before being operated

57

Paj 58

Item 3.

Photo 5: View of outlet works at the downstream side of dam being operated

Photo 6: View of opening sluice gate while on dam outlet control platform (looking north)

58

Paj 59

Item 3.

Photo 7: View inside of 24 inch diameter cast iron pipe (outlet works) from downstream side of dam (looking north)

East Wing Wall

Photo 8: View of the east abutment (east wing wall), upstream side

59

Paj 60

Item 3.

Photo 9: View of the east abutment (east wing wall), upstream side

Chute

Fish Ladder

East Wing Wall

Photo 10: View of upstream side of fish ladder and chute (looking south)

60

Paj 61

Item 3.

Pier 8

Pier 9

Photo 11: Upstream view of Pier 9 and 8 (looking south)

Pier 8 Pier 7

Photo 12: Upstream view of Pier 8 and 7 (looking south)

61

Paj 62

Item 3.

Pier 8 Pier 7

Pier 6

Photo 13: Upstream view of Piers 8, 7 and 6 (looking south)

Photo 14: Upstream view of Pier 5 (looking south)

62

Paj 63

Item 3.

Pier 3

Pier 4

Photo 15: Upstream view of Piers 4 and 3 (looking southwest)

Pier 1

Pier 2

Pier 3

Photo 16: Upstream view of Piers 3, 2 and 1 (looking southwest)

63

Paj 64

Item 3.

Photo 17: Upstream view of Pier 1

West Wing Wall
Debris

Photo 18: Upstream view of the west wing wall

64

Paj 65

Item 3.

Hole (Photo 45)

Seep (Photo 46)

Photo 19: Downstream view of the dam (looking north)

Rip Rap Displacement Zone
(10 feet)

Photo 20: Downstream view of the dam (looking east)

65

Paj 66

Item 3.

Photo 21: View of concrete spillway apron adjacent to outlet (looking south)

Photo 22: View of approx. 12.5 inch void between the rip rap elevation and exposed concrete spillway apron downstream face

66

Paj 67

Item 3.

Missing bolt and nut

Missing nuts

Photo 23: Downstream view of east wing wall, fish ladder, and chute (looking northeast)

Loose nuts

Missing nut

Photo 24: Downstream view of fish ladder and chute (looking north)

67

Paj 68

Item 3.

Photo 25: Aerial view of fish ladder.

Photo 26: Close up of missing nut on fish ladder

68

Paj 69

Item 3.

Photo 27: Close up on loose nut on fish ladder

Photo 28: Close up of loose nut on fish ladder

69

Paj 70

Item 3.

Photo 29: Close up of missing bolts and nuts on fish ladder

Photo 30: Aerial view of fish ladder.

70

Paj 71

Item 3.

Photo 31: View of fish ladder (looking north)

Photo 32: Aerial view of the fish ladder (looking east)

71

Paj 72

Item 3.

Photo 33: Aerial view of the fish ladder (looking east)

Photo 34: Aerial view of the fish ladder (looking east)

72

Paj 73

Item 3.

Photo 35: View under the fish ladder (showing apparent leak) (looking east)

Photo 36: View under fish ladder (showing apparent leak) (looking east)

73

Paj 74

Item 3.

Photo 37: View under fish ladder (looking south)

Photo 38: View of downstream side of chute and lower area of east wingwall

74

Paj 75

Item 3.

Photo 39: Photo 38 of apparent leak on east wingwall, under fish ladder (looking east)

Photo 40: View of the downstream east side of the dam (looking north)

75

Paj 76

Item 3.

Photo 41: View of the downstream side of dam (looking north)

Photo 42: View of downstream side of dam (looking north)

76

Paj 77

Item 3.

Photo 43: View of the downstream side of dam (west side) (looking north)

Photo 44: View of concrete joint that sounded hollow during the hammer/concrete test (photo taken

77

Paj 78

Item 3.

Photo 45: 2-inch-deep hole on the downstream side of the dam

Photo 46: Moist spot observed on the downstream side of the dam

78

Paj 79

Item 3.

Photo 47: Area with missing concrete and exposed aggregate on the downstream face of the dam

Photo 48: Photo 47 showing exposed aggregate

79

Paj 80

Item 3.

Dried Moss

Photo 49: Downstream side of west wing wall (looking north)

Different rip rap size division line

Area recommended for rip rap addition
(Zoomed in Photo 53)

Photo 50: Upstream side of east abutment and embankment

80

Paj 81

Item 3.

Smaller Rip Rap Larger Rip Rap
(6 inch) (12 inch)

Photo 51: Area where rip rap on east embankment upstream side changes size (zoomed in from Photo 50)

Photo 52: Erosion on upstream side of east embankment

81

Paj 82

Item 3.

Photo 53: View of the upstream side of the east embankment (looking east)

Photo 54: Walkway bridge (looking west)

82

Paj 83

Item 3.

Photo 55: Previous repair work on the west end of the walkway bridge.

Photo 56: View of the lower side of the walkway - west side; Apparent efflorescence

83

Paj 84

Item 3.

Photo 57: View of the lower side of the walkway, pier 4;View of efflorescence

Photo 58: View of lower side of the walkway; View of efflorescence

84

Paj 85

Item 3.

Photo 59: View of lower side of the walkway, pier 8 and 9 (looking northeast)

Photo 60: View of west upstream embankment

85

Paj 86

Item 3.

Photo 61: View of the west upstream embankment looking west (bare spots and erosion visible)

Photo 62: View of west upstream embankment, bare spots and erosion visible; (looking east)

86

Paj 87

Item 3.

Photo 63: Drone photo of downstream channel (downstream side of dam, looking south)

Zoomed in Photo 65

Photo 64: Photograph of the boat ramp (looking north)

87

Paj 88

Item 3.

Photo 65: Previously repaired crack (1/4 inch) on boat ramp is open

Photo 66: Photograph of pier (looking east)

88

Paj 89

Item 3.

Photo 67: Photograph of pier (looking north)

Photo 68: Photograph of street lamp (looking west)

89

Paj 90

Item 3.

Photo 69: Photograph of the bottom of street lamp (wires exposed)

Photo 70: Undermining/erosion on sidewalk (east of fish ladder)

90

Paj 91

Item 3.

Photo 71: Undermining/erosion on sidewalk (east of fish ladder)

Photo 72: Drone generated topographic lines showing asphalt pavement areas with recommended repair (circled in red)

91

Paj 92

Item 3.

Photo 73: Drone aerial of boat ram with open and repaired cracks

Tree

Photo 74: Drone aerial of west abutment downstream showing bare area without grass

92

Paj 93

Item 3.

Photo 75: Drone aerial of east abutment downstream showing bare area without grass

93

Paj 94

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

Appendix B
Underwater Inspection Photos (Walker Diving)

94
Verdantas.com

Paj 95

Item 3.

Photo 76: Outlet works coupler & gate stop

Photo 77: Shaft through gate

95

Paj 96

Item 3.

Photo 78: Timber cribbing around outlet works structure

Photo 79: Chain link fence used as trash rack

96

Paj 97

Item 3.

Photo 80: Chain link fence used as trash rack

97

Paj 98

Item 3.

Photo 81: East Wingwall Observed Abrasion

Photo 82: East Wingwall Observed Abrasion and Spalling

98

Paj 99

Item 3.

Photo 83: West wingwall hand packed concrete placement in generally fair condition

99

Paj 100

Project No. 27233
Silver Lake Dam Inspection Item 3.
December 2024

Appendix C
DNREC Inspection Checklist

100
Verdantas.com

Paj 101

Item 3.

Delaware Dam Safety Program Visual Inspection Checklist This general checklist should be used as an aid when examining all dams. This checklist may not, however, include all features or conditions found at a specific dam that are relevant to the safety of that dam. All features integral to the safety of the dam being examined should be inspected and their condition reported.

TYPE OF INSPECTION: (Regular, Formal or Informal): REGULAR

DE INSPECTION YEAR: 2024

DAM NAME: Silver Lake Dam

NID ID: S137

STATE ID: DE00031

LOCATION: St. Jones River, Dover

DE OWNER: The City of Dover, DE

OPERATOR:

DATE OF INSPECTION: November 7 and 8, 2024; December 23, 2024

RESERVOIR INFORMATION

Normal Reservoir Elevation (ft): N/A

Reservoir Elevation at time of inspection (ft): N/A

WEATHER CONDITIONS (including recent rainfall): Cloudy, 81 degrees F

101

Paj 102

Item 3.

INSPECTION PERSONNEL

Delaware Licensed Professional

Engineer(s):
Name Affiliation
Joseph Jakubowski, PE, LEED AP Verdantas LLC

Assisted By:

Name Affiliation
Daniel Granda, PE Verdantas LLC
Mohamed ElGhoraiby, EI
Ken Bakely Walker Diving Underwater
Harry Duffield Construction
Angel Ramos

DNREC Dam Safety Program
Representative(s):

Name Affiliation
John Moyle, P.E. DNREC Division of Watershed Stewardship

Dam Owner
Representative(s):

Name Affiliation
Robert LaFountain City of Dover, Dept. of Water and Wastewater
Donnie McClements

Others:

Name Affiliation

102

Paj 103

Item 3.

2008 DELAWARE DAM INVENTORY INFORMATION (provided by DNREC if available):

103

Paj 104

Item 3.

HISTORY

Date Constructed: 1944 Designer: Albright & Friel, Inc. Consulting Engineers Dates(s) Reconstructed: N/A Owner & Address: The City of Dover, DE, 19903 Constructed By: N/A Owner/ Operator present during inspection (yes or no): Yes

PREVIOUS INSPECTIONS

Last Regular Inspection:
Last Inspection: July 6, 2023

Phase I Inspection: January 1978 Last Formal Inspection:

List all recommendations from previous inspection reports and note whether those items have been completed: Completed Repairs: 1. The boat ramp dock timbers have been replaced. 2. The previously observed vegetative growth throughout the areas of embankment rip rap has been controlled, no new growth was visible. 3. A previously observed tree stump adjacent to the boat ramp sign on the dam crest has been removed. 4. A previous crack on the top of the downstream right-wing wall has been repaired. 5. A previous crack near Span 1 of the concrete walkway deck has been repaired. Immediate Repairs: No immediate repairs are required. Non-immediate repairs: Upstream Slope: 1. All weeds noted within the rip rap should be controlled with herbicide and removed. Continue to monitor— weeds were removed or dead due to the season. 2. The trash accumulated along the water line at the west end of the left embankment. Continue to monitor – trash was present during the inspection. 3. Seed areas on the ground on the left and right embankment. Not completed and requires reseeding due to foot traffic. 4. The small stump near the signs near the boat ramp can be left in place provided it is no longer alive and should be monitored periodically. Completed – Stump removed. 5. Repair the crack noted on the right side of the boat ramp. It was repaired but now it is cracked again, 10 LF needs repair again. 6. Asphalt should be placed along the lower right edge of the boat ramp in a similar fashion to other areas of the slab. Completed. 7. Depressions on the crest should be monitored periodically. Continue to monitor. 8. Any gaps present in the rip rap along the right upstream slope should be filled with additional rip rap. Completed. 9. The stump noted above the rip rap on the right upstream slope can remain provided it is no longer alive and should be monitored periodically. Continue to monitor. 10. The missing rip rap where the right upstream wing wall meets the water should be replaced. Completed. Dam Crest: 1. Depressions that were noted in previous inspections were not noted. Continue to monitor. 2. Consideration should be given to repair the cracks and depressed asphalt pavement. Not completed.

104

Paj 105

Item 3.

Downstream Slope: 1. All weeds noted within the rip rap should be removed and controlled with herbicide so future weeds do not grow. Continue to monitor – no weeds were active or present during inspection. 2. Any bare spots should be seeded and covered with new grass, including any eroded areas, areas disturbed by mowing operations, or around bollards. Not completed. 3. The undermined sidewalk near the fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated/backfilled. Not completed. 4. The woody bushes/weeds that were noted growing in the fence that cordons off the bottom of the fish ladder and near the fish ladder sign can be left in place provided they are no longer alive and should be monitored periodically. Continue to monitor. 5. The No. 57 stone that is being used as ground cover inside the fence adjacent to the fish ladder is allowing weeds to grow. The weeds should be removed and controlled with herbicide. Consideration should be given to replacing the No. 57 stone with grass seed or rip rap to minimize the potential for weed growth. Continue to monitor. 6. The undermined fence post at the southern end of the chain link fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated. The eroded areas noted in the area of the fence post and the eroded area south of the fence that extends to the exit channel should be remediated. Not completed. 7. Continue to monitor the eroded area adjacent to the upper parking lot that has been remediated for further signs of erosion. Repair the soil reinforcement netting in this location. Continue to monitor/not completed.

Upstream Face and Wing Walls 1. Repair the cracks throughout, above and below water, with pressure injected epoxy (27 LF). Completed above water but not completed below water line. 2. Repair the random pop-outs throughout with non-shrink grout (4 SF). Completed. 3. Repair the area of moderate to severe scaling at the extreme upstream end of the right wingwall with epoxy concrete (25 SF). Completed. 4. Field measure, cut and re-adjust the rotated fence extension on all wingwalls (195 LF). (7 LF was not completed on east abutment). 5. Clean and tighten the railing base plate hardware. Replace any damaged pieces (40 EA). Completed.

Downstream Face and Wing Walls: 1. Repair the cracks throughout with pressure-injected epoxy (52 LF). Completed. 2. Repair the delamination on the right downstream wingwall with concrete patching material. Completed.

Fish Ladder: 1. Repair the leaking joints. Not completed. 2. Repair the broken weld at the third steel brace from the north (0.17 LF) (Unable to verify since the fish ladder was not operating, no evidence of welding repair visible). 3. Replace the missing bolts and nuts with stainless steel hardware (2 EA) Not completed (additional bolts and nuts are becoming loose and need tightening). 4. Remove the growing vegetation. Not Completed

Spillway:
1. None of the defects noted warrant repair. Continue to monitor.

Pedestrian Walkway: 1. Repair the spalls throughout with non-shrink grout (8 SF). Completed. 2. Repair the cracks throughout with pressure injected epoxy (206 LF). Completed.

105

Paj 106

Item 3.

  • 3.Replace downstream top railing tee at pier 4 and between pier 9 and end wingwall with a galvanized tee. Completed.
  • 4.Bolts should be checked, tightened, and replaced if missing on the railing system. Continue monitoring.

Outlet Works: 1. Repair the opening between the two trash rack panels (5 LF). Not completed. 2. Continue to monitor the condition of the timbers & hardware for further deterioration or lack of function which would warrant repair. Not completed.

Exit Channel:

  • 1.The rip rap, other smaller stones, and the two bushes just downstream of the spillway and adjacent to the fish ladder should be removed. Not completed.
  • 2.Bushes and woody weeds should be removed and controlled with herbicide. Not completed.
  • 3.Any bare spots along the exit channel should be remediated with rip rap or seeded. Not completed.

Boat Dock: 1. Repair the northwest dock pile that exhibits 40% section loss. Completed – Dock Replaced. 2. Remove and replace rotted stringers that touch the concrete boat ramp and any rotten stringers that are hidden by the decking. Completed – Dock Replaced.

EMERGENCY ACTION PLAN (Required for all High and Significant Hazard dams)

Date of Approved Plan: N/A (Not Provided)

Date of Plan Revision: N/A (Not Provided)

Is the notification flowchart complete and current? (If the notification flow chart is not complete and current, all modifications, corrections, and additions must be made and replacement pages submitted with this report)

Is inundation mapping or a description included? N/A

Are emergency materials and equipment identified?

N/A When was the plan last tested? N/A

DOWNSTREAM HAZARD CLASSIFICATIONS

Present Hazard Classification: High

Changes in Downstream Land Use and Habitation: No

Is present classification appropriate? Yes

OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE

Date of Operation and Maintenance Plan: N/A

Are instructions adequate? N/A

Do operating personnel follow instructions? N/A

What are operating personnel capabilities? N/A

106

Paj 107

Item 3.

EXAMINATION OF EMBANKMENT DAMS

DESCRIPTION OF STRUCTURE

Embankment Material:

Earth Cutoff Type:

Unknown Impervious

Core: Unknown

Internal Drainage System: Drainage system outlets were not observed which may indicate one is not present

Movement (Horizontal and Vertical Alignment): None observed

Junctions with Abutments or Embankments: Good condition, no cracks or separation observed.

Miscellaneous: N/A

CREST

Vertical Alignment: Good

Horizontal Alignment: Good

Surface Cracks: None

observed Settlement: None

observed

Unusual Conditions: None observed

UPSTREAM SLOPE

Slope (Estimate) (H:V): 3H:1V Trees, Undesirable Growth or Debris, Animal Burrows: The Upstream Slope is in good to very good condition except as noted below. No animal burrows were observed.

  • 1.The riprap on both left and right slopes appeared in good condition, with some small to medium dried weeds noted. Monitoring should continue.
  • 2.Minor trash and debris accumulation was noted in the water at the end of the east upstream embankment.
  • 3.There is a 1,200 SF area on the west slope (upper side of slope) with recommended reseeding of the area that is bare from erosion and foot traffic.
  • 4.There is 310 SF of area on the east slope (upper side of slope, west of the boat ramp) with recommended reseeding of the area that is bare from erosion and foot traffic.
  • 5.There is 600 SF of area on the east slope (upper side of slope, east of boat ramp) with recommended reseeding of the area that bare from erosion and foot traffic.
  • 6.Additional 1,500 SF of rip rap is needed on the north side of the east slope for lower water elevations like the one encountered during the inspection.
  • 7.New grass seed in areas adjacent to boat ramp should be monitored for growth once they are reseeded.

Sloughing, Subsidence or Depressions: None observed

107

Paj 108

Item 3.

Slope Protection: The rip rap at the water line was nonexistent on east slope and in good condition on the west slope. Surface Cracks or Movement at Toe: None Observed. Unusual Conditions: None Observed.

DOWNSTREAM SLOPE

Slope (Estimate) (H:V): Variable 2H:1V to flatter than 5H:1V

Trees, Undesirable Growth or Debris, Animal Burrows: Downstream Slope in good condition except as noted below. No animal burrows observed.

  • 1.All weeds noted within the riprap and No. 57 stone ground cover should be controlled with herbicide and removed.
  • 2.Any bare spots on either side should be covered with new grass.
  • 3.The woody bushes/weeds that were noted growing in the fence that cordons off the bottom of the fish ladder and near the fish ladder sign can be left in place provided they are no longer alive and should be monitored periodically.
  • 4.A tree is 20 feet west from the downstream west wing wall. State of Delaware Dam Regulation 5103 Section 10.1.2.3 states, “Trees and other woody vegetation shall be prevented from growing on the dam unless waived by the Department”. It is recommended to monitor the wing wall for cracks or deflection as the tree continues to mature and grow. Tree roots can cause damage to concrete structures and create seepage paths.

Sloughing, Subsidence or Depressions: None Observed.

Surface Cracks or Movement at Toe: None Observed.

Seepage: None Observed.

External Drainage System (Ditches, Trenches, Blanket): None Observed.

Condition Around Outlet Structure: The rip rap directly downstream of the outlet structure has been displaced and needs to be repaired. Failure to address this will start the undermining of the concrete spillway. Placement of approximately 2,000 SF of riprap to protect the downstream concrete foundation of the spillway. This issue was missed in the previous 2023 inspection report (Inspection Report Dated: August 11, 2023, Photo 48). The stilling basin had no major obstructions and is in over all good condition.

Unusual Conditions: None Observed.

ABUTMENTS AND TOE AREA

Erosion at Contract: None Observed.

Seepage or Wet Area Along Contract: None Observed.

Signs of Movement: None Observed.

Depressions, Sinkholes: None Observed.

Unusual Conditions: None Observed.

108

Paj 109

Item 3.

SEEPAGE OR TOE DRAIN FLOW MEASUREMENTS

Location Estimated Flow Color (Turbidity)

OTHER CONDITIONS/OBSERVATIONS: None.

109

Paj 110

Item 3.

EXAMINATION OF SPILLWAYS AND OUTLET WORKS

TYPE(S) AND DESCRIPTION OF SPILLWAY(S)

Primary: Concrete Dam Spillway with base flow chute with flash boards on west side of spillway

Secondary (auxiliary): None

Emergency: Combined with Primary Spillway

Low Level Outlet (flashboards, operable gates, etc.): Wood riser structure with sluice gate

Other:

FOR EACH SPILLWAY THE FOLLOWING ASPECTS MUST BE EXAMINED WHERE APPROPRIATE

ENTRANCE CHANNEL

Description: Cast in place concrete wing walls.

Vegetation (Trees, Bushes): None observed.

Debris: Small wooded debris on the spillway crest (west side).

Channel Side-Slope Stability: Concrete Wing walls were observed to be vertical and in good to very good condition. There was a seep on the downstream east wingwall (1 SF), it should cleaned and patched with epoxy and monitored.

Slope Protection/Erosion: Unusual Conditions: Minor erosion around existing rip rap along left and right wingwalls. Unusual Conditions: None observed.

SPILLWAY CREST

Description: Concrete

Condition of Material:

  • 1.Water was low enough to see the crest. The crest had no cracks observed and it was in generally good condition.
  • 2.Rip rap appeared to be piled upstream of crest. Rip rap was visible at water level to 1 foot below water line.

Signs of Movement: None observed.

Joints: Good condition.

Unusual Conditions: None observed.

DROP BOX

Description: N/A

Condition of Material: N/A

110

Paj 111

Item 3.

Signs of Movement: Joints: N/A

Floor: N/A

Unusual Conditions: N/A

SPILLWAY WING WALLS

Description: Concrete

Condition of Material:

  • 1.Abrasion at water line across east wingwall.
  • 2.There was a crack that runs horizontally with a width of 1/4" inches to 0.5 inches, with a length of 27 inches. The crack was located 5 feet north of the fish ladder and 1 feet above the mudline.
  • 3.Spalling throughout the east wingwall ¼ inches to 3/8 inches below water line.
  • 4.West wingwall has abrasions throughout at water line to 1 foot in depth. There was spalling throughout.
  • 5.West wingwall had repairs that were made on the west wingwall appear to be to hand packed concrete placement and are in fair condition.
  • 6.West wingwall has a crack 29 inches long, 1/8 inches wide, approximately 6 feet south from the north end of the wingwall.
  • 7.West wingwall had cracks 8 feet south from the north end of the wingwall that were 8 inches in length, ¼ inches in width and there directly above a crack that was 12 inches in length with ¼ inches in width.
  • 8.There was patching of both east and west wingwall surfaces on the downstream side.
  • 9.The east wingwall had 3 active seeps under the fish ladder. The first seep was located under the metal bracket that holds the fish ladder, approximately 27 feet north of the south end of the east wall. The second seep was located on the bottom of recent patch repairs approximately 25 feet north of the south end of the east wing wall. The third seep was located approximately 15 feet north of the south end of the east wing wall.

Signs of Movement: None observed.

Joints: Good condition.

Drains: None active.

Unusual Conditions: None observed.

DOWNSTREAM APRON

Description: Concrete

Condition of Material: Fair.

  • 1.Exposed aggregate was observed throughout. The entire downstream face has sporadic pockets of abrasion where up to 75% of the aggregate grains are exposed.
  • 2.Dried moss downstream apron west side.
  • 3.There was a seep located 57 feet west from the east abutment wing wall. An area of 2 inches by 6 inches was moist but had no water actively coming out. It should be monitored quarterly.
  • 4.There was a hole, 2 inches deep, less than 0.5 inches in diameter located 41 feet east from the west abutment wing wall.
  • 5.A rock hammer was used to hit the apron to evaluate hollow sounds that may indicate undermining under the apron. There were four instances where a hollow sound was heard during the inspection and it occurred on previously patched repaired areas. The rock hammer test should be done again during the next inspection, and no further action is required at this time.

111

Paj 112

Item 3.

Signs of Movement: None observed.

Unusual Conditions: None

CULVERTS

Description: 24-inch diameter cast iron pipe from low level outlet works penetrates downstream apron.

Condition of Material: Observable portions appear to be in good condition.

Joints: The inside was photographed with flash, and not all joints could be observed. A pipe drone or camera inspection is recommended for the next regulatory inspection.

Signs of Movement: None observed.

Seepage: None observed.

Location Estimated Flow Turbidity

Unusual Conditions: Light scaling at interface with spillway.

TRASH RACKS

Description: N/A

Condition of Material: N/A

Unusual Conditions: N/A

CHUTES

Description: Base flow concrete chute located on west side of downstream apron with wood flash boards.

Condition of Material: The chute appears to be in good condition. There were no cracks or missing

components observed.

Signs of Movement: None observed.

Unusual Conditions: The chute exhibits light abrasion/scaling with exposed aggregate, similar to the downstream apron. The chute was partially working as there were no flashboards present, and the downstream apron was dry (the water elevation was lower than the crest of the apron.

112

Paj 113

Item 3.

STILLING BASIN

Description: 6 to 18-inch size stone riprap

Condition of Material: Fair, with no signs of seepage and boils observed to be present. The water flow from the dam has displaced the rip rap approximately 12 feet downstream creating a small rip rap berm downstream. Approximately 1,900 to 2,000 square feet of rip rap recommended to be placed downstream of the downstream apron.

Signs of Movement: None observed.

Erosion: Yes, as described on the “Condition of Material” description.

Unusual Conditions: None observed.

EXIT CHANNEL

Vegetation (Trees, Bushes): Some minor vegetation was observed to be growing in riprap that lined the entrance channel at the end of the wing walls for the downstream apron.

Debris: None observed.

Channel Side-Slope Stability: Good Condition. No signs of stability problems.

Erosion: Some shear erosion and bare spots were noted. Larger areas of erosion were observed on the right bank.

Unusual Conditions: None observed.

LOW LEVEL OUTLET

Description: Wood riser structure with sluice gate.

Condition:

  • 1.The trash racks around the perimeter of the outlet works and the lack of water clarity prevented the diver from inspecting the interior portions of outlet works.
  • 2.Trash rack was not repaired, and gaps remains.
  • 3.Personnel with the City of Dover successfully opened and closed the sluice gate.
  • 4.The wooden outlet structure appears in poor condition. The boarder that serves as a platform for the operators is cracked and warped. There are no rails to stop operators from falling off the structure.
  • 5.The timber structure’s galvanized hardware is in poor condition below the waterline with up to 30% section loss.
  • 6.The outlet work piles exhibit 1/8” W checking. The diver was unable to verify the previously noted 50% section loss at the right downstream pile due to lack of access, but some evidence of pile section loss was observed through the gaps in the trash rack fencing.
  • 7.The outlet works is armored with riprap around the perimeter and the riprap is covered with silt up to 0.25’H.

Trash Rack: The outlet works trash rack on the north face exhibit an opening between the two panels for 0.17’ H x 5.0’L.

Leakage: None observed.

113

Paj 114

Item 3.

Location Estimated Flow

Unusual Conditions: None observed.

Was the low-level outlet operated during the inspection? Sluice gate was opened and closed by the City of Dover.

Were there difficulties operating the low-level outlet? Yes, operator needed to close the sluice gate twice. The first time, the operator was unable to close it and water kept coming out. The operator had to open the sluice gate again and then slowly close it.

When was the low-level outlet last operated and did this conform with the Operation and Maintenance procedures? Operator said last year. It is recommended to operate the low-level outlet monthly to keep the mechanical components in working shape.

Miscellaneous: None.

STILLING BASIN FOR LOW LEVEL OUTLET

Description: Combined with stilling basin for combined principal and emergency spillways. See description above.

Condition of Material:

  • 1.The exit channel was observed to be in good condition.
  • 2.The banks of the channel were lined with 1 to 2-foot diameter size riprap observed to be in good condition.
  • 3.Several bare spots and some weeds were noted in the landscape areas directly adjacent to the riprap along the banks of the channel.

Signs of Movement: None observed.

Erosion: None observed.

Unusual Conditions: The rip rap has been displaced approximately 12 feet downstream. It should be repaired as mentioned in previous sections.

EXIT CHANNEL FOR LOW LEVEL OUTLET

Description (Trees, Bushes): N/A

Debris: N/A

Channel Side-Slope Stability: N/A

Slope Protection Erosion: N/A

Unusual Conditions: N/A

114

Paj 115

Item 3.

EXAMINATION OF CONCRETE AND MASONRY DAMS

DESCRIPTION OF STRUCTURE

Type of Dam (Gravity, Arch, etc.):

Internal Drainage System:

Movement (Horizontal and Vertical Alignment):

Miscellaneous:

UPSTREAM FACE

Condition of Concrete or Masonry:

Cracking:

Location Orientation Length Width Type

DOWNSTREAM FACE

Condition of Concrete or Masonry:

Cracking:

Location Orientation Length Width Type

Leakage through Dam (Location and Estimated Flow):

CREST

Condition of Concrete or Masonry:

Cracking

Location Orientation Length Width Type

Signs of Movement:

Differential Movement (Joint or Crack Separation or Offset):

GALLERIES

Cracking

Location Orientation Length Width Type

Differential Movement (Joint or Crack Separation):

Leakage into Galleries (Location and Estimated Flow):

115

Paj 116

Item 3.

Condition of Gallery Drains:

FOUNDATION

Condition of Rock or Concrete Lining:

Cracking:

Signs of Movement:

Seepage (Location and Estimated Flow):

ABUTMENTS AND TOE AREA

Seepage or Wet Areas:

Signs of Movement:

Cracking:

Erosion:

Unusual Conditions:

116

Paj 117

Item 3.

EXAMINATION OF OTHER FEATURES

INSTRUMENTATION (Monumentation/Surveys, Observation Wells, Weirs, Piezometers, etc.) location, condition: No Instrumentations except for reservoir staff gauge was present.

(A separate report including instrument readings, condition of instruments, observations, and conclusions based upon the collected data should be attached.)

RESERVOIR

Slopes: Good condition.

Sedimentation: Could not be observed.

Unusual Conditions Which Affect Dam: None observed.

Other Unusual Conditions: None observed.

APPURTENANT STRUCTURES

Description and Condition of Each:

Fish Ladder:

  • 1.The stainless-steel fish ladder was in generally poor condition. The top and side seem to be starting to rust.
  • 2.The fish ladder steel support members and hardware exhibit moderate corrosion with up to 10% section loss.
  • 3.The fish ladder was leaking in the previous inspection, no leaking was observed in this inspection.
  • 4.The third fish ladder steel brace from north exhibits a 2” L x ¼” W broken weld splice could not be confirmed since there was no water running.
  • 5.The horizontal beams at the bottom of the ladder are in good condition and painted. There is algae on the bottom vertical columns.
  • 6.There was one bolt and nut missing on the fish ladder upper area, west side.
  • 7.There were two bolts missing nuts on the fish ladder west side.
  • 8.There were two bolts missing nuts on the fish ladder east side.
  • 9.There were three bolts with loose nuts (about to detach from bolts) on the fish ladder west side.
  • 10.Missing bolts, nuts should be replaced. Loose nuts should be retightened.

Pedestrian Walkway:

  • 1.The concrete surfaces between spillway and bottom of piers exhibit abrasion up to ½” D with exposed aggregate on all piers.
  • 2.The underside of the deck has been repaired. Efflorescence is sporadic under all decks and should be monitored.

117

Paj 118

Item 3.

RECOMMENDATIONS THE FOLLOWING REPAIRS SHOULD BE MADE IMMEDIATELY:

No immediate repairs required.

THE FOLLOWING NON-IMMEDIATE REPAIRS/IMPROVEMENTS SHOULD BE MADE:

Upstream Slope:

  • 1.Continue to control the vegetative growth in the rip rap with herbicide.
  • 2.Continue to remove trash and debris that accumulates at the waterline.
  • 3.Seed the areas of bare ground on the left and right embankments (10,000 SF).
  • 4.Repair the crack on the boat ramp's right side. This crack was repaired, but it appears cracked again.
  • 5.Continue to monitor the embankments for any depressions.
  • 6.The stump noted above the rip rap on the right upstream slope can remain provided it is no longer alive and should be monitored periodically.
  • 7.Rip rap (1,600 SF) should be added on the east upstream slopes to help with wave action erosion during low lake level seasons. Dam Crest:
  • 1.The crest appears to be in good condition. As indicated in previous inspections, it should continue to be monitored for depressions.
  • 2.Consideration should be given to repaving the asphalt roadway on the dam crest. Downstream Slope:
  • 1.Continue controlling the rip rap's vegetative growth with herbicide.
  • 2.Any bare spots, including eroded areas, areas disturbed by mowing operations, or around bollards, should be seeded and covered with new grass.
  • 3.The undermined sidewalk near the fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated/backfilled, as it will be a tripping hazard.
  • 4.The woody bushes/weeds that were noted growing in the fence cordoning off the bottom of the fish ladder and near the fish ladder sign can be left in place, provided they are no longer alive. They should be monitored periodically.
  • 5.The No.57 stone used as ground cover inside the fence adjacent to the fish ladder allows weeds to grow. The weeds should be removed and controlled with herbicide. To minimize the potential for weed growth, consider replacing the No. 57 stone with grass seed or rip rap.
  • 6.The riprap appears sparse or may have been filled in the areas adjacent to the fish ladder on the left downstream slope. Additionally, rip rap has been placed only along a portion of the right downstream wing wall and appears to be sparse at the toe of the right downstream wing wall. A study should be performed to determine if additional rip rap should be added and/or replaced.
  • 7.The undermined fence post at the southern end of the chain link fence adjacent to the fish ladder should be remediated. The eroded areas noted in the area of the fence post and the eroded area south of the fence that extends to the exit channel should be remediated.
  • 8.Continue to monitor the eroded area adjacent to the upper parking lot that has been remediated for further signs of erosion. Repair the soil reinforcement netting in this location. Upstream Face and Wing Walls:
  • 1.Repair the cracks below water, with pressure injected epoxy (7 LF).
  • 2.Field measure, cut and re-adjust rotated fence extension on all wingwalls, and secure to prevent rotation. (7 LF)
  • 3.Bolts should be checked, tightened, and replaced if missing on the railing system.

118

Paj 119

Item 3.

Downstream Face and Wing Walls:

  • 1.There are three seeps on the east wing wall, under the fish ladder. The seeps appear to be below areas that were previously patched and repaired. The 2023 inspection report also noted these leaks. It is recommended to either conduct a resistivity geophysics study to aid in determining the water elevation behind the wall (nondestructive method) before looking into destructive methods of investigation. Fish Ladder:
  • 1.Repair the broken weld at the third steel brace from the north (0.17 LF) (Unable to verify since the fish ladder was not operating, no evidence of welding repair visible).
  • 2.Replace missing bolts and nuts with stainless steel hardware.
  • 3.Tighten loose bolts.
  • 4.Continue to remove the growing vegetation.
  • 5.Consider a total replacement suited for needs or a replacement with minimum maintenance.

Spillway:

  • 1.Monitor seep on the downstream side.
  • 2.Evaluate a resurfacing program for the apron as aggregates are getting more exposed and will eventually progress to complete aggregate loss.

Pedestrian Walkway:

  • 1.Repair the small indent on the west side of the walkway to avoid potential tripping hazard.
  • 2.Monitor walkway for cracks, and repair as needed.

Outlet Works:

  • 1.Repair the opening between the two trash rack panels (5 LF).
  • 2.Operate sluice gate monthly to monitor performance and keep mechanical components in working shape.
  • 3.Repair outlet works platform and install railing for added operator safety.

Exit Channel:

  • 1.Approximately 1,900 to 2,000 square feet of rip rap needs to be repaired downstream of the downstream apron
  • 2.Bushes and woody weeds in the rip rap should be removed and controlled with herbicide.
  • 3.Any bare spots along the exit channel should be remediated with rip rap or seeded.

Boat Dock:

  • 1.No repairs are required at this time.

Concrete Slab on Grade Pad:

  • 1.No repairs are required at this time.

THE FOLLOWING MAINTENANCE ITEMS SHOULD BE COMPLETED:

  • 1.Area where new grass seed has been planted should be monitored for growth.
  • 2.Weeds growing from the joints between the rip rap stones should be removed and maintained to prevent further growth

119

Paj 120

Item 3.

THE FOLLOWING ENGINEERING ANALYSIS/STUDIES SHOULD BE PERFORMED:

x Hydrologic and Hydraulic Analysis

Embankment Stability Analysis

x Dam Failure Analysis/Inundation Mapping

x Other: Electrical resistivity geophysics on the east wing wall to evaluatr the potential water path that is causing the three seeps on the downstream side of the wing wall (under the fish ladder)

None

120

Paj 121

Item 3.

CONDITION ASSESSMENT

Silver Lake Dam was personally inspected by me and was found to be in the following condition (select one only):

SATISFACTORY

No existing or potential dam safety deficiencies are recognized. Acceptable performance is expected under all loading conditions (static, hydrologic, seismic) in accordance with the applicable regulatory criteria or tolerable risk guidelines.

X FAIR

No existing dam safety deficiencies are recognized for normal loading conditions. Rare or extreme hydrologic and/or seismic events may result in a dam safety deficiency. Risk may be in the range to take further action.

POOR

A dam safety deficiency is recognized for loading conditions which may realistically occur. Remedial action is necessary. POOR may also be used when uncertainties exist as to critical analysis parameters which identify a potential dam safety deficiency. Further investigations and studies are necessary.

UNSATISFACTORY

A dam safety deficiency is recognized that requires immediate or emergency remedial action for problem resolution.

121

Paj 122

Item 3.

Delaware Registered Professional Engineer Performing Condition Assessment:

Name Joseph Jakubowski, PE, LEED AP DE PE License Number 15181

Affiliation (Agency/Company) Verdantas LLC

Signature 12/30/2024 Date 12/30/2024

Delaware Dam Safety Program Concurrence with Condition Assessment:

Name DE PE License Number

Signature Date

Dam Owner Acknowledgement of Condition Assessment:

Name Title_________________________

Signature Date_________________________

122

Paj 123

Item 4.

CITY OF DOVER PUBLIC SPACE NAMING APPLICATION AND PETITION

Prepared By: Arielle M. Rivera
Created: October 2, 2024 123

Paj 124

THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

Item 4.
PUBLIC SPACE NAMING PROCEDURE

Thank you for your inquiry into the City of Dover’s public space naming procedure. Please thoroughly review the following procedure, and submit your completed application and petition to the City Clerk’s Office, by mail to P.O Box 475, Dover, DE 19903, or in person at 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, DE 19901. Please note that an incomplete application and/or petition may delay the processing of your request and could potentially cause a delay in its consideration.

Should you have any questions, please contact the City Clerk’s Office at 302-736-7008 or by email to cityclerk@dover.de.us.

Chapter 98, Article II, Section 98-45 - Street name change procedure Recognizing that changing the name of a city street already named is a complicated and expensive procedure affecting many departments and many persons, the following procedure is adopted:

  • •Insert adopted code. • (Code 1981, § 19-25; Ord. of 7-10-2000)

124

-2-

Paj 125

Item 4.
THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC SPACE NAMING

Please complete the following application and petition and submit to the City Clerk’s Office, 15 The Plaza, Dover, DE 19903. Please print.

Current Space Name:
City Council District(s):
General Street Location (Impacted Area):

Proposed Space Name:
(Please list at least two (2) alternate street name choices)
1.
2.

Reason for Change:

Background on the individual, event, or entity being honored:

Petition-Initiator and/or Contact Person:
Name:
Mailing Address:
City, State, Zip:
Phone Number: Email address:

I attest that all of the above information is true and correct.

Contact Person Signature Date Submitted

125

-3-

Paj 126

THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

PETITION FOR PUBLIC SPACE NAME CHANGE Item 4.

An application is being submitted to the City of Dover requesting a public space name change for the area described below. I understand that this street name change will likely result in address changes. I am aware that each individual property owner would be responsible for any costs associated with changes in home or mailbox numbers; driver’s license information; stationary; personal or business checks; and other personal documents related to a street name or address change.

Current Space Name:

City Council District(s):

General Street Location (Impacted Area):

Proposed Space Name:
(Please list at least two (2) alternate space name choices)
1.
2.

Having read and understood the statement above, I am signing this petition in order to demonstrate my SUPPORT of the proposed public space name change.

ABUTTING ADDRESS PROPERTY OWNER

PRINT NAME SIGNATURE NUMBER and STREET PHYSICAL ADDRESS

126

-4-

Paj 127

PETITION FOR PUBLIC SPACE NAME CHANGE (Continued)
4.
ABUTTING ADDRESS PROPERTY OWItem
NER

PRINT NAME SIGNATURE NUMBER and STREET PHYSICAL ADDRESS

127

-5-

Paj 128

PETITION FOR PUBLIC SPACE NAME CHANGE (Continued)
ABUTTING ADDRESS PROPERTY OWNER
Item 5.

PRINT NAME SIGNATURE NUMBER and STREET PHYSICAL ADDRESS

STATE OF DELAWARE, COUNTY OF KENT * SS:

BE IT REMEMBERED that on this day of , A.D. 2 , personally appeared before me, the Subscriber, a Notary Public for the State and County aforesaid, , being duly sworn (or affirmed) deposes and says that he (she) is the circulator of the foregoing Petition paper containing signatures; that each signature appended thereto was made in his (her) presence; that each signature is the genuine signature of the person whose name it purports to be; and, that the deponent verily believes that each signer of said petition is an owner of property abutting the above referenced street.

SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED (or affirmed) before me the day and year aforesaid. Notary Public

OFFICIAL USE ONLY (Date/Time/Initial)
Application Received:
Petition Verified by Assessor’s Office: ; OR
Petition Declared Incomplete by Assessor’s Office: 128

-6-

Paj 129

Item 4.

S:\CLERK'S OFFICE POLICIES AND PROCEDURES\STREET NAME CHANGE\Street Name Change Blocks\Street Name Change Application and Procedure Packet - 10-17-2018.wpd

129

-7-

Paj 130

Item 4.

City of Dover
PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-07

1 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL

2MET:
3
4 That Chapter 98 – Streets, Sidewalks, Storm Sewers, and Other Public Places be amended by
5inserting a new Article IX – Public Space Naming Policy, as follows:
6
7 The City of Dover adopts this policy to guide the naming/re-naming of city-owned property in a
8 fair, objective, and equitable process that is reflective of the area’s history, characteristics, and
9community culture.
10
11Sec. 98-347. General Guidelines.
12 (a) City Council wishes to carefully deliberate the naming of streets, parks, and other
13 public places; and is committed to providing a fair, consistent, and efficient process
14 while respecting the important need for public consultation and legislative approval in
15 regard to the naming or re-naming of city-owned properties such as parks and
16recreational areas.
17 (b) Re-naming will be considered only in exceptional circumstances and with significant
18 justification. Proposals to rename a city public space as a community request are not
19 encouraged. Likewise, names that have become widely accepted by the community will
20 not be abandoned unless there are compelling reasons and strong public sentiment from
21 the broader community for doing so. Historical or commonly used place names will be
22preserved wherever possible.
23 (c) There is no assumption of right for a private donor to name a property because the
24 property was a gift to the public unless such right was required contractually with an
25 agreement. The naming of any property shall not provide a property right or privilege
26to the applicant or recipient of the naming.
27 (d) The city reserves the right to deviate from this ordinance if it is deemed to serve the
28best interest of the city.
29
30Sec. 98-348. Application Process.
31 (a) Any individual, group, or organization may propose a name for a public property by
32 submitting an application and signed petition to the City Clerk’s office. The petition
33 must be signed by 25 of the residents abutting the public space to be named.
34(b) The application must include:
35(1) The proposed name.
36 (2) A statement of significance or justification for the proposed name.

130

Paj 131

Item 4.

37 (3) Background information on the individual, event, or entity being honored (if

38applicable).
39(4) Any supporting documentation or endorsements.
40 (c) The City Clerk’s office will review the application for completeness and forward it to
41 the City Council for consideration. If the petition or other documentation does not meet
42 the requirements, then the request shall be summarily dismissed by the City Clerk and
43the person or persons presenting such request shall be notified.
44Sec. 98-349. Evaluation Criteria.
45 (a) The City Council will consider the following criteria when evaluating proposed names:
46(1) Historical significance.
47(2) Geographical location.
48(3) Contribution to the community.
49(4) Alignment with community values.
50(5) Public sentiment and support.
51 (b) Names that reflect the cultural, historical, and natural heritage of Dover will be given
52particular consideration.
53 (c) Commercial or corporate names will generally not be considered unless there is a
54significant and long-standing contribution to the community.
55Sec. 98-350. Approval Process.
56 (a) The opportunity for public comment shall be afforded prior to City Council action. A
57 public hearing shall be scheduled for a regular council meeting regarding the request,
58 and notice of the public hearing shall be given by the City Clerk by placing such notice
59 in one edition of a local newspaper, to be published at least ten days prior to the date of
60the public hearing.
61 (b) The City Council shall hear public comments at the public hearing and, at the
62 conclusion of the public hearing, vote to approve the naming or renaming. The City
63 Council will make the final decision on the naming of public properties. The decision
64 will be made by a majority vote of the City Council. If the naming or renaming of the
65 public property is granted, then notification thereof shall be given to the City Manager
66to implement the name change.
67 (c) The legend of any sign or plaque must be written or approved by the City Manager or
68 his/her designee. Upon approval, the City Manager’s office will coordinate the
69installation of appropriate signage or plaques.
70
71ADOPTED: *
72
73SYNOPSIS
74 This ordinance establishes a Public Space Naming Policy to guide the naming or re-naming of city-owned
75 properties. The application process allows individuals, groups, or organizations to propose names through
76 a petition signed by at least 25 residents abutting the public space to be named. Proposals must include a
77 statement of significance and supporting documents. The City Council will evaluate names based on
78 historical relevance, geographical ties, community contributions, and public support. A public hearing will
79 be held before the City Council votes on the proposed name, with a final decision made by a majority vote.

131

Paj 132

Item 4.

80

81(SPONSORS: ARNDT and *)
82
83
84
85Action History
86 02/25/2025 – Scheduled for Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and
87Administration Committee
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104

132

Paj 133

Item 1.
Delaware Electronic Speed Safety Program (ESSP)
Frequently Asked Questions
January 2025

General Program Information

  • 1.What is the Electronic Speed Safety Program (ESSP)?
  • a.The Electronic Speed Safety Program is an automated speed enforcement system authorized by the 152nd General Assembly and signed into law by Governor John Carney on June 30, 2023 (House Substitute No. 1 for House Bill 94). This act was codified under Title 21, § 4170A of the Delaware Code. This is a camera-based system that detects the speed of passing vehicles. When a vehicle is found to be traveling 11 miles per hour (mph) or greater over the posted speed limit, the system will capture images of the rear of the vehicle and related information (i.e., posted speed limit, vehicular speed, location, date, time, etc.). A citation is generated and sent to the registered owner of the vehicle.
  • 2.What is the goal of the ESSP?
  • a.Higher vehicle speeds may be a contributing factor in many crashes increasing the injury severity for persons involved. Reducing speeds is a proven way to reduce the severity of crashes when they do occur but also give motorists more time to react to avoid potential crashes all together. Speed Safety Cameras are included in FHWA’s Proven Safety Countermeasures for speed management. The goal of the ESSP is to improve roadway safety by enforcing posted speed limits on roadways, both within work zones and residential areas, improve driver behavior, save worker and road users lives, reduce crashes, and complement existing enforcement.
  • 3.Who operates DelDOT’s ESSP?
  • a.Elovate (a.k.a. Modaxo Group, Inc.; f.k.a. Conduent) is DelDOT’s vendor, who owns, operates, and maintains the ESSP camera equipment and citation/violation collection system. DelDOT’s Office of the Secretary and Division of Transportation Solutions, Traffic Engineering Section are responsible for facilitating engineering, safety, and policy decisions among a group of municipal and enforcement safety partners.
  • i.Elovate (a.k.a. Modaxo Group, Inc.; f.k.a. Conduent) will invoice DelDOT a monthly fixed fee per each automated speed enforcement device at a cost of $19,890 for work zone enforcement. This cost includes the enforcement device, initial deployment, placement, set-up, re-positioning, removal, calibration and required re-calibrations, camera(s), communications, routine maintenance, and any and all supporting equipment or services. ii. Elovate (a.k.a. Modaxo Group, Inc.; f.k.a. Conduent) will invoice the corresponding municipality or New Castle County a monthly fixed fee per each automated speed enforcement device at a cost of $5,700 for residence district enforcement via a certified-used enforcement device (increased to $7,900 per month for brand new equipment). This cost includes the enforcement device, initial deployment, placement, set-up, re-positioning, removal, calibration and required re-calibrations, camera(s), communications, routine maintenance, and any and all supporting equipment or services.

This information is solely provided as a public courtesy; see Delaware Code and Delaware Administrative Code for formal Statute and Regulations 137

Paj 134

Item 1.
Delaware Electronic Speed Safety Program (ESSP)
Frequently Asked Questions
January 2025

  • 4.Where are the automated speed enforcement cameras located?
  • a.As of July 2024, speed enforcement cameras are in operation along I-95 northbound and southbound within the work zone for the I-95 and SR 896 Interchange project area.
  • 5.How often are the ESSP systems checked for accuracy?
  • a.The ESSP systems are required by policy to be recalibrated and recertified on an annual basis. The systems run daily self-tests to ensure all aspects of the system are operating properly at the start and end of each enforcement period. Additionally, the responsible law enforcement agency may conduct random field speed verification to ensure the units are accurately detecting speeds.
  • 6.If I drive past a speed camera at 2 or 3 mph over the posted speed limit, will I automatically get a ticket?
  • a.No. Images are only captured and used for the purpose of issuing a citation if a vehicle is exceeding the posted speed limit by 11 mph or greater.
  • 7.How can I check to see if I will be receiving a citation?
  • a.Call Elovate Customer Service at (844) 213-7033.
  • 8.How long does it take to get a violation notice in the mail?
  • a.Notices of violation will be mailed to a registered owner within 45 days of the violation occurring. In most cases, the notice of violation will be mailed shortly after the violation has occurred.
  • 9.Are the violation notices reviewed before they are mailed out?
  • a.All violation notices are reviewed before issuance. First, the event is reviewed by Elovate to verify there were no system errors or glitches, the captured vehicle has an identifiable license plate, and the captured vehicle is not an authorized emergency vehicle being legally operated. Subsequently, every citation is reviewed by an individual who has been trained in reviewing and evaluating whether a violation has occurred, and is authorized by Statute to issue violations on behalf of the agency or department issuing the violation.
  • 10.I received a citation. How do I access Elovate’s online payment portal?
  • a.https://usview.cite-web.com
  • b.For more information on establishing a partial payment plan schedule, contact Elovate at (844) 213-7033. If a citation is not paid in full within 120 days, the citation will be further susceptible to collections and DMV registration holds (see FAQ #11b and #11c).

This information is solely provided as a public courtesy; see Delaware Code and Delaware Administrative Code for formal Statute and Regulations 138

Paj 135

Item 1.
Delaware Electronic Speed Safety Program (ESSP)
Frequently Asked Questions
January 2025

  • 11.What if I don't pay the fine?
  • a.Failure to pay the fine or contest the violation in court can result in additional fees and penalties. An additional $10.00 charge is due if an uncontested Notice of Civil Violation is not paid within 30 days of the mailing date. This is increased to $20.00 if not paid within 60 days and to $30.00 if the Notice of Civil Violation is not paid within 90 days.
  • b.If the fine is not paid within 120 days from the mailing date, the unpaid citation will be forwarded to the State’s third-party collections agency, Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson, LLP. The collections notice will be mailed by Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson, LLP on day 121 after the first violation notice mail date. Payment is due 30 days from the notice mail date. All subsequent collections will be handled by DelDOT’s Collections Vendor, and no more payments will be processed by Elovate Pay By Phone or Pay By Web.
  • c.Once the fine is sent to the State’s third-party collections agency, a hold will be placed on the registered owner’s vehicle registration via the DMV, preventing renewal of vehicle registration until the outstanding balance is paid in full.
  • 12.I do not believe my citation is valid. How do I dispute my citation?
  • a.Please follow the instructions on the citation. Appeal requests must be postmarked no later than 30 days from the mail date of your First Notice. For more information, contact Elovate at (844) 213-7033 or follow the online instructions at:
  • i.https://usview.cite-web.com
  • 13.What happens after I appeal my citation?
  • a.You will be assigned a case by the State of Delaware Justice of the Peace (JP) Court. You will receive a summons via U.S. mail advising you of the date and time of your hearing.
  • b.Cases assigned to hearings are held in person at the Delaware Justice of the Peace (JP) Court.
  • c.All corporations or artificial entities are required by rule to be represented by a lawyer at all court proceedings.
  • d.Under authority of 21 Del.C. Section 4101 (d) (8): If the owner or an operator identified by the owner fails to pay the civil penalty by voluntary assessment, request a hearing within the required time or submit an affidavit stating that the owner or operator identified was not the driver, the Division of Motor Vehicles may refuse to renew the registration of the owner’s vehicle operated at the time the summons was issued. If the owner or an operator identified by the owner is found responsible at a hearing and fails to pay as ordered by the Court, or requests a hearing and fails to appear, the Division of Motor Vehicles shall suspend the license of the owner or operator.
  • 14.I think I may have a defense to the ticket. Whom do I contact?
  • a.Neither DelDOT, Elovate, nor Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson, LLP can provide legal advice on any violations. Please consult legal counsel if you have any questions regarding the tickets.

This information is solely provided as a public courtesy; see Delaware Code and Delaware Administrative Code for formal Statute and Regulations 139

Paj 136

Item 1.
Delaware Electronic Speed Safety Program (ESSP)
Frequently Asked Questions
January 2025

  • 15.I was not driving the vehicle at the time of the violation. How do I appeal in this case?
  • a.Fill out the Affidavit of Non-Responsibility form (postmarked no later than 30 days from the mail date of your First Notice) on the back of the citation received and identify the driver of the vehicle at the time of violation. A driver’s notice is then generated by Elovate and sent to the identified driver. A letter is mailed to the registered owner informing that the transfer of liability was approved. However, if the driver of the vehicle does not pay the citation, the registered owner of the vehicle is ultimately responsible for the outstanding ticket. Contact Elovate at (844) 213-7033 or follow the online instructions at:
  • i.https://usview.cite-web.com
  • 16.How is revenue from the fines used?
  • a.Revenue from the fines collected as part of the program are received and managed by DelDOT and will cover expenditures related to the program. In the event that all expenditures related to the program are covered and excess revenue remains, that excess revenue will be transferred to the Delaware Office of Highway Safety and may be utilized only for transportation safety purposes under any of the following categories: education, enforcement, engineering, or administrative expenses.
  • 17.Are speed cameras an invasion of privacy?
  • a.No. Speed cameras only record images of vehicles whose drivers violate traffic laws by speeding. When motorists apply for a driver's license, they are agreeing to abide by the rules of the road. The purpose of the ESSP pilot program is to improve highway safety by detecting motorists who violate the law and endanger the lives of other motorists, construction workers, and other vulnerable road users.
  • b.In addition, speed cameras only record vehicles traveling at or above a defined speed threshold. Law-abiding citizens are unaffected by the use of this technology since images are only captured when a vehicle passes at a speed equal to or greater than the defined threshold (11 mph).
  • 18.Which other states/jurisdictions use speed cameras?
  • a.20 states and the District of Columbia permit the use of speed cameras, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (August 2023). In addition to Delaware, cameras are permitted statewide or by specific communities in Alabama, Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Washington DC, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Louisiana, Maryland, New Mexico, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Virginia, and Washington.
  • 19.How can I find out more about the ESSP?
  • a.https://deldot.gov/Programs/DSHSP/index.shtml?dc=project-speeding-safety-program
  • b.Annual Reports will be published with further information on the program; the annual report from the I-95 Restore the Corridor pilot program is available now.

This information is solely provided as a public courtesy; see Delaware Code and Delaware Administrative Code for formal Statute and Regulations 140

Paj 137

Item 1.
Delaware Electronic Speed Safety Program (ESSP)
Frequently Asked Questions
January 2025

  • 20.How else is DelDOT improving road safety in Delaware?
  • a.View the Strategic Highway Safety Plan at http://safety.deldot.gov
  • 21.I have an idea on how to improve roadway safety in Delaware. How do I inform DelDOT?
  • a.https://deldot.gov/Traffic/ReportRoadCondition/index.shtml
  • 22.Can speed cameras be used to help slow traffic on SR 1?
  • a.DelDOT may approve the installation and use of an Electronic Speed Monitoring System in a DelDOT work zone on SR 1 or any state-maintained roadway throughout the state with the goal of lowering speeds and reducing crashes. The Delaware State Police have enforcement authority over use of the Systems in all work zones.
  • b.Outside of DelDOT work zones, use of Electronic Speed Monitoring Systems are restricted to residence districts (defined under Title 21, § 101 of the Delaware Code) in New Castle County and statewide municipalities. Most locations along SR 1 and similar state and US highways would not qualify for monitoring based on these restrictions.

Work Zone Speed Enforcement

  • 23.Can I get a violation notice driving through a work zone even if work is not taking place?
  • a.Even if workers are not present in a work zone, there are work zone conditions that warrant safe operating speeds at all times of the day. Delaware’s ESSP enforces posted work zone speed limits 24 hours per day, 7 days per week, 365 days per year within the work zone in order to promote safe work zone speeds at all times.
  • 24.How do I know what the work zone speed limit is?
  • a.The work zone speed limit will be posted within the project work zone in advance of any electronic enforcement. The posted work zone speed limit will also have a “SPEED PHOTO ENFORCED” plaque installed beneath to alert motorists to the active speed photo enforcement.
  • 25.What is the fine? Are points assessed against my driver's license?
  • a.The base violation is $20.00 and an additional amount is added for each mile per hour over the posted work zone speed limit in accordance with Del. C. §4169(c). For example, if the captured violation occurs at a speed of 58 mph in a posted 45 mph work zone, the speed violation is $20.00 plus an additional $13.00 which accounts for $1.00 for each mile per hour over the 45 mph work zone speed limit. Additionally, there is a work zone fine applied; the sum total of the base fine and the additional speeding fine is doubled. This is a civil violation; no points are assessed against your drivers license and your insurance company is not notified.
  • b.At the I-95 and SR 896 Interchange project area (initial ESSP monitoring site – see FAQ #4a), warning notices for violations were only issued for violations occurring between July 8, 2024 and July 29, 2024. After this initial three-week period expired, warnings were no longer issued for violations occurring on or after July 30, 2024, even for first-time violations.

This information is solely provided as a public courtesy; see Delaware Code and Delaware Administrative Code for formal Statute and Regulations 141

Paj 138

Item 1.
Delaware Electronic Speed Safety Program (ESSP)
Frequently Asked Questions
January 2025

  • 26.What are the various fees and extra charges for on my citation?
  • a.Delaware Code requires certain fees to be assessed on moving violations under Title 21. The following fees are added to the speed violation for ESSP:
  • i.Transportation Trust Fund (TTF) Surcharge, 50% of speed violation (11 Del. C. §4101(g)) ii. Fund to Combat Violent Crimes, $15.00 (11 Del. C. §4101(h)) iii. Volunteer Ambulance Company Fund, $10.00 (11 Del. C. §4101(j))
  • b.See Work Zone Fine Structure on DelDOT’s ESSP Program Information page

Residence District Speed Enforcement

  • 27.What locations are eligible for “residence district” Electronic Speed Monitoring Systems?
  • a.Residence District is defined in Title 21 of the Delaware Code; effectively, it is any section of public roadway (300 feet or longer) with residential use of at least half of the property frontage along the roadway. The legislation also stipulates the eligible residence district must be located within New Castle County or a municipality. The law enforcement agency charged with enforcement of the residence district must agree to use of the ESSP. Because this is a new program, equipment and police resources are limited, and at this time, unincorporated areas of Kent County and Sussex County are not eligible for residence district speed enforcement. Future annual reporting may recommend expansion into these areas, which would also need to be authorized by new legislation.
  • i.The initial interpretation of the definition of a residence district versus suggested roadways by New Castle County or a municipality must be performed by the corresponding legal department or town/city management for New Castle County or a municipality, and the supporting documentation will be further reviewed by DelDOT’s Legal Section if there is any further uncertainty for eligibility.
  • 28.Will the residence district Electronic Speed Monitoring Systems be active during nighttime hours?
  • a.Delaware’s ESSP enforces posted speed limits 24 hours per day, 7 days per week, 365 days per year in order to promote safe speeds at all times. Though there are generally fewer vulnerable road users and other motorists during the night, many serious crashes, including pedestrian crashes, continue to occur along Delaware roads during nighttime hours. In many of these crashes, speed is a major factor in either causing the crash or the severity of any injuries sustained. The monitoring systems do include camera flashes to record the license plates when a violation occurs, DelDOT will consider this when locating these systems.

This information is solely provided as a public courtesy; see Delaware Code and Delaware Administrative Code for formal Statute and Regulations 142

Paj 139

Item 1.
Delaware Electronic Speed Safety Program (ESSP)
Frequently Asked Questions
January 2025

  • 29.What is the fine? Are points assessed against my driver's license?
  • a.The base violation is $20.00 and an additional amount is added for each mile per hour over the posted speed limit in accordance with Del. C. §4169(c). For example, if the captured violation occurs at a speed of 39 mph in a posted 25 mph speed zone, the speed violation is $20.00 plus an additional $14.00 which accounts for $1.00 for each mile per hour over the 25 mph speed limit. This is a civil violation; no points are assessed against your drivers license and your insurance company is not notified.
  • b.See Residential District Fine Structure on DelDOT’s ESSP Program Information page
  • 30.I work for a municipality and want to get speed cameras set up in my jurisdiction. How do I go about doing that?
  • a.The initial interpretation of the definition of a residence district versus suggested roadways by New Castle County or a municipality must be performed by the corresponding legal department or town/city management for New Castle County or a municipality, and the supporting documentation will be further reviewed by DelDOT’s Legal Section if there is any further uncertainty for eligibility.
  • b.Prior to DelDOT approval of entities requesting to use the system in residence districts, participating municipalities and New Castle County shall authorize the use of Electronic Speed Monitoring Systems in their code or ordinance and sign a memorandum of understanding or an agreement with DelDOT regarding the operation of the Electronic Speed Monitoring Systems.
  • c.A study must be provided to DelDOT by the requesting municipality or New Castle County. DelDOT may perform speed data collection or provide recently collected speed data along state-maintained roadways, based on available resources, and provide the information to the requesting municipality or New Castle County to be included in the required study.
  • i.The study must be no more than 1 year old from the date of the initial request and approved by DelDOT. ii. The study must document that the 85th-percentile speed on the road is 5 miles per hour or greater than the posted speed limit. iii. The study must have been overseen by a Delaware Registered Professional Engineer, a sworn law enforcement officer, or a municipal or county official acting in their official capacity. iv. The study must include continuous speed data, collected across a 24-hour window, at minimum.
  • d.Within a residence district, the police agency with jurisdiction over the road must approve the road and extent of the road eligible for electronic speed monitoring prior to DelDOT approval.
  • e.Within the boundaries of a municipality, the municipality must approve the road and extent of the road eligible for electronic speed monitoring prior to DelDOT approval.
  • f.A Request Form with the necessary information is provided on DelDOT’s ESSP Program Information page.

This information is solely provided as a public courtesy; see Delaware Code and Delaware Administrative Code for formal Statute and Regulations 143

Paj 140

Item 1.

Electronic Speed Safety ProgramElectronic Speed Safety Program
RESIDENCE DISTRICT Automated Speed EnforcementRESIDENCE DISTRICT Automated Speed Enforcement
Speed Violation Fine Matrix - FIRST OFFENSESpeed Violation Fine Matrix - SUBSEQUENT OFFENSES
RecordedRecorded
Speed OverAdditional Fine for SpeedSpeed OverAdditional Fine for Speed
Posted WorkBase FineDifferenceTotal FinePosted WorkBase FineDifferenceTotal Fine
Zone Speed(21 Del. C. §4169(c))Zone Speed(21 Del. C. §4169(c))
Limit (MPH)Limit (MPH)
≤10 MPH$0$0$0≤10 MPH$0$0$0
11$20$11$3111$20$22$42
12$20$12$3212$20$24$44
13$20$13$3313$20$26$46
14$20$14$3414$20$28$48
15$20$15$3515$20$30$50
16$20$32$5216$20$48$68
17$20$34$5417$20$51$71
18$20$36$5618$20$54$74
19$20$38$5819$20$57$77
20$20$60$8020$20$80$100
21$20$63$8321$20$84$104
22$20$66$8622$20$88$108
23$20$69$8923$20$92$112
24$20$72$9224$20$96$116
25$20$75$9525$20$100$120
26$20$78$9826$20$104$124
27$20$81$10127$20$108$128
28$20$84$10428$20$112$132
29$20$87$10729$20$116$136
30$20$90$11030$20$120$140
31$20$93$11331$20$124$144
32$20$96$11632$20$128$148
33$20$99$11933$20$132$152
34$20$102$12234$20$136$156
35$20$105$12535$20$140$160
36$20$108$12836$20$144$164
37$20$111$13137$20$148$168
38$20$114$13438$20$152$172
39$20$117$13739$20$156$176
40$20$120$14040$20$160$180
41$20$123$14341$20$164$184
42$20$126$14642$20$168$188
43$20$129$14943$20$172$192
44$20$132$15244$20$176$196
45$20$135$15545$20$180$200
46$20$138$15846$20$184$204
47$20$141$16147$20$188$208
48$20$144$16448$20$192$212
49$20$147$16749$20$196$216
50$20$150$17050$20$200$220
Speed Enforcement Equipment Calibration: The speed camera and radar devices meet the requirements and tolerance specified in the technical directive of the
manufacturer for the calibration.
The international usually accepted tolerances for placing on the market are: 1 mph for measurement values up to 100 mph and 1% of the right value for measurement
values over 100 mph by rounding up to the nearest interger value.

133

Paj 141

Item 1.
Delaware Department of Transportation
Electronic Speed Safety Program
Request for Residence District Electronic Speed Monitoring System

House Substitute No. 1 for House Bill 94 was enacted by the 152nd General Assembly and signed into law by Governor John Carney on June 30, 2023 establishing an Electronic Speed Monitoring System. This act was codified under Title 21, §4170A of the Delaware Code. The Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT) created the Electronic Speed Safety BACKGROUND Program (ESSP) to fulfill the requirements of this new law.

The ESSP provides automated speed enforcement in a DelDOT work zone, or in a residence district in either New Castle County or a municipality of the state. ESSP enforcement zones within residence districts will be enforced by the police agency with jurisdiction over the road. Prior to DelDOT approval of entities requesting to use the ESSP in residence districts, participating municipalities and New Castle County shall authorize the use of an Electronic Speed Monitoring System (ESMS) in their code or ordinance and sign a memorandum of PARTNER understanding (MOU) or an agreement with DelDOT regarding the operation of the ESMS. PROGRAM Code or Ordinance Reference: Executed MOU/Agreement: SET-UP Attached ☐ Attached ☐ _ URL: On File ☐ _

Road Requested
for Monitoring
From:
Bounding Limits
To:
Insert Image:

Posted Speed
Limit
Choose Direc�on
REQUESTED
ROADWAY
INFORMATION

Applicant: Location: provide speed Insert Image: limit data for both directions of roadway on approaches to requested Posted Speed monitored area Limit Choose Direc�on

Location:
In-Field Verification Date:
For DelDOT Use: Speed Resolution on File and Verified ☐

Page 1 of 3 134

Paj 142

Item 1.
Delaware Department of Transportation
Electronic Speed Safety Program
Request for Residence District Electronic Speed Monitoring System

If the road is within the boundaries of a municipality, the municipality must approve the road and extent of the road eligible for electronic speed monitoring prior to DelDOT approval. Within Municipality? Select If yes, which? Provide approving party name and contact information:

____________________________ JURISDICTION Signature AND The police agency with jurisdiction over the road must approve the road and extent of the road APPROVALS eligible for electronic speed monitoring prior to DelDOT approval. Police Agency Provide approving party name and contact information:

____________________________ Signature The road must be located within a Residence District as defined by Delaware Code. Roadway is within a Residence District? Select Provide concurring party name and contact information (e.g., city solicitor, town manager, county attorney QUALI- general): FICATION

____________________________
Signature

A study must be provided to DelDOT by the requesting municipality or New Castle County. Required approvals as noted above must be obtained prior to DelDOT reviewing a study or assisting with data collection. • The study must be no more than 1 year old from the date of the initial request. • The study must document that the 85th-percentile speed on the road is 5 miles per hour or greater than the posted speed limit. • The study must include continuous speed data, collected across a 24-hour window, at STUDY minimum. • The study must have been overseen by a Delaware Registered Professional Engineer, a sworn law enforcement officer, or a municipal or county official acting in their official capacity. Study Documentation Attached ☐ Applicant Requests DelDOT Provide Speed Data along the Requested ☐ Highest 85th Percentile Speed State-Maintained Roadway* *Speed studies will be completed as State resources allow

Applicant Name: Application Date: Applicant Title: Applicant Agency: Applicant Email: Applicant Phone: Please submit completed requests to DOT_TrafficEng_ESSP@delaware.gov Incorrect or incomplete submissions will not be accepted and could result in delays.

Page 2 of 3 135

Paj 143

Item 1.
Delaware Department of Transportation
Electronic Speed Safety Program
Request for Residence District Electronic Speed Monitoring System

Following the acceptance and approval of the request and study by the Concurrence: DelDOT Chief of Traffic Engineering, or designee, and prior to activation: To participate in the program, municipalities and New Castle County shall utilize "piggyback" agreements with DelDOT's selected vendor for speed monitoring as ☐ well as collections activities. The police agency with jurisdiction over the road must notify DelDOT of the intent to use the ESMS at least 30 calendar days in advance of implementation. ☐ For DelDOT Use: Police Agency Notification Date Confirmed ☐ DelDOT and the police agency with jurisdiction over the road must provide notice on their publicly accessible websites of the intended use of the ESMS at least 14 ☐ NEXT STEPS calendar days prior to its implementation. For DelDOT Use: DelDOT Website Date Confirmed ☐ Public Notification Police Agency Website Date Confirmed ☐ DelDOT shall be responsible for preparing an annual report on the ESMS as implemented statewide. Police agencies shall cooperate with DelDOT regarding the collection of data necessary to prepare the annual report. In the event a police ☐ agency does not provide the requested information in a timely manner to DelDOT, the police agency will no longer be eligible for use of ESMS. ☐

To establish an enforcement area along an approved roadway following the Concurrence: vendor coordination and posting of necessary notifications: Traffic control devices must be in accordance with the Delaware Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices, 2 DE Admin. Code 2402. ☐ If within a municipality, the municipality will be responsible for developing the traffic control device plan and for purchasing, installing, and maintaining the required traffic control devices; and, ☐ If along a state-maintained roadway, DelDOT must approve the traffic control device plan prior to deployment. A speed limit sign with photo enforced camera symbol or a "PHOTO ENFORCED" plaque mounted directly below must be installed in a location or locations where all motorists passing through the enforcement area would be expected to have seen ☐ the posted speed limit sign and photo enforced plaque. The ESMS unit and enforcement area of roadway must be within the same ENFORCED jurisdictional boundary. ☐ AREA AND Radar speed feedback signs (i.e., "YOUR SPEED" signs) may be used for motorist awareness and as speed data collection units. Due to technological differences OPERATIONS between radar speed feedback signs and the ESMS unit, a digital radar speed ☐ display may not be used in the immediate proximity of the enforcement area and must comply with DelDOT policy. Once installed and activated, ESMS shall remain at the location installed for a minimum of 75 calendar days. While systems may remain at a location longer than 75 calendar days, the municipality or New Castle County may need to relocate the ☐ systems or work with the selected vendor to provide additional systems to accommodate approved requests for additional roadways or locations. For DelDOT Use: Activation Date Date Active ☐ The operation of the ESSP shall be in compliance with the Electronic Speed Monitoring System regulations as promulgated in the Title 2 of the Delaware Administrative Code ☐ https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/april2024/final/27%20DE%20Reg%2077 7%2004-01-24.htm

Page 3 of 3 136

Paj 144

Item 2.

City of Dover Consideration of REQUEST TO WAIVE SUBDIVISION STANDARDS Consideration of REQUEST FOR ALTERNATIVE EMERGENCY ACCESS REQUIREMENTS Review by Council Committee of the Whole: Safety Advisory & Transportation Committee on February 25, 2025 Recommendation from Planning Commission of February 18, 2025 with Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review

Plan Title: Lands of 4BL LLC, Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street C-25-01

Plan Type: Conditional Use and Minor Subdivision Plan

Associated Application: V-24-06 Variance Requests for 207 N. West Street

Location: Northeast Corner of Cecil Street and North West Street

Address: 207 N. West Street

Tax Map ID: ED-05-076.08-02-01.00-000

Owner/Applicant: 4BL, LLC

Zoning: RG-1 (General Residence Zone)

Current Use: Vacant (residential structure demolished) Proposed Use: Four (4) Townhouse Lots

Site Area: 12,158.214 SF

Sewer & Water: City of Dover
Trash Service: City of Dover

For Consideration: Active Recreation Plan (Cash-in-Lieu Request)

Waivers Recommended: Appendix A - Land Subdivision Regulations, Article VI §A 13.8 Subdivision Waiver – Alley Requirement for Townhouses

Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 Section 17
Rear Emergency Access - Alternative

Planning Commission Recommendations Summary: The Conditional Use and Minor Subdivision Plan Application C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street was represented by the property owner Cameron Llewellyn and Doug Liberman of the applicant’s engineering firm Larson Engineering. A Public Hearing was conducted at the Planning Commission Meeting of P. O. Box 475 Dover, DE 19903 Community Excellence Through Quality Service 144

Paj 145

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

February 18, 2025 where three members of the public spoke and two letters of written comments (support) were received. The Planning Commission moved by vote of 4-1 of the members present (4 members absent) to grant conditional approval of Application C-25- 01 and including a recommendation of approval of the Subdivision Waiver allowing the elimination of the Rear Access Alley Requirement and a recommendation of approval of the Waiver allowing the Alternative (Use of residential sprinkler system) to satisfy the Rear Emergency Access requirement. See the following Report for additional information on the project and these associated requests. (Draft Meeting Minutes are pending.)

This Subdivision Waiver Request and Zoning Ordinance Waiver Request are forwarded to the Council Committee of the Whole: Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee and City Council for consideration. The following is the Development Advisory Committee (DAC) Report prepared for C-25-01 including the application review narrative and related Department/Agency Review comments and other information. See highlighted sections for detailed information on these Waiver Requests.

  • I.PLAN SUMMARY This application is for review of a Conditional Use and Minor Subdivision Plan to permit the construction of four (4) townhomes on a 12,158.214 SF parcel of land located at the northeast corner of Cecil Street and North West Street. The property is currently a vacant parcel of land, after the prior residential structure was demolished. The property for the proposed development is zoned RG-1 (General Residence Zone). The owner of record is 4BL, LLC. Property Address: 207 North West Street. Tax Parcel Number: ED-05-076.08-02-01.00-000. This Report was updated with Record Plan sheets (RP-1 and RP-2) dated February 5, 2025.

II. PREVIOUS APPLICATION

BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT – VARIANCES APPROVED (V-24-06)

On November 20, 2024, the Board of Adjustment heard a variance application from the property owner, requesting two variances: Variance 1 - a reduction in the minimum required lot depth from 100 feet to 84.5 feet and Variance 2 - a reduction in the minimum required lot area for two of the lots from 3,000 SF to 2,366 SF. The Board of Adjustment granted the variances requested based on a total parcel size of 12,168 SF.

III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION

The subject property is located on the northeast corner of Cecil Street and North West Street. The applicant is proposing to construct four (4) townhouses on the parcel subdivided into four lots. The homes would front on Cecil Street. Each townhouse is proposed to have a driveway and garage. Two driveways would take access from Cecil Street, one driveway would take access from the Alley (as Revised 2/5/2025), and one driveway would take access from North West Street.

At the February 18, 2025 meeting, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing and took action to grant conditional approval of the Conditional Use and Minor Subdivision Plan for the Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street noting that the Request

145

Paj 146

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

for Cash-in-lieu of Active Recreation Area was pending consideration by the Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee. The Planning Commission also recommended approval of the waiver to eliminate the requirement for a rear access alley for this townhouse development and recommended approval of the Alternative (use of residential sprinkler system) to satisfy the Rear Emergency Access Requirement. See the discussion below for the information on the two pending Waiver Requests.

IV. MINOR SUBDIVISION PLAN REVIEW

Waiver Request: Subdivision Waiver – Waiver of Rear Access Alley Requirement This application involves a Minor Subdivision to create the four (4) townhouse lots. Each lot created must comply with the RG-1 zoning district provisions for townhouse units and the variance granted related to these bulk standards.

According to the Lands Subdivision Regulations (Appendix A), Article VI, A. – Streets, §13.8, townhouse units are required to have a rear alley; see Code excerpt below.

13.8 All townhouses shall be provided with rear access alleys unless the planning commission finds that alleys are infeasible for the development or finds that the design of the townhouses precludes their suitability. The required alley right-of-way and roadway width may be increased at the discretion of the city manager.

A Subdivision Waiver can be considered by Planning Commission for recommendation to City Council for final action. While there is an alley to the east of the subject site, the new configuration of the lots requires another alley at the rear. Since an additional alley is not planned, a written waiver request for consideration by the Planning Commission was received to eliminate this rear alley. See Subdivision Waiver Request Letter of February 6, 2025.

The provisions for a waiver are found in the Land Subdivision Regulations in Article VIIA. A. Variance and Waiver. 1. Upon the findings of the commission that, due to special conditions peculiar to a subdivision or a site, certain requirements of these regulations are inappropriate, or that strict compliance with said requirements may cause extraordinary and unnecessary hardships, the commission may recommend to city council, and city council may vary or waive said requirements; provided that such variance or waiver shall not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or general welfare, or have the effect of nullifying the intent and purpose of the official map, the zoning ordinance, the development plan or these regulations. In varying or waiving certain requirements, the council may specify such conditions as will, in its judgment, secure substantially the objectives of the requirements so varied or waived.

Recommendation of Planning Staff: As part of the Development Advisory Committee (DAC) Report dated February 5, 2025, the Planning Staff recommended approval on the Subdivision Waiver Request for application C-25-01. Staff notes that the subject site has existing public streets on two sides of the development parcel and an existing alley on the east side. This requirement for another alley is related to the reconfiguration of the new proposed townhouse lots to front on Cecil Street. Given the depth of the lots, installation of a rear alley would impact the development area/lot size and increase the amount

146

Paj 147

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

of impervious surfaces. The City of Dover’s Department of Water & Wastewater/Department of Public Works also participates in the Development Advisory Committee review process. A copy of their review comments is attached to this Report.

Findings and Recommendation of the Dover Planning Commission: The Planning Commission at its meeting on February 18, 2025 reviewed the proposed Waiver Request as part of its review of the Application C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street. The Applicant made a presentation on their project and a public hearing was held; see Draft Meeting Minutes excerpt. The Planning Commission recommends approval of the Subdivision Waiver allowing the elimination of the Rear Access Alley Requirement for this Townhouse project based on the project submission documents and the applicant’s presentation. The motion passed 4-1 of the members present (4 members absent).

  • V.ZONING REVIEW The subject property is zoned RG-1 (General Residence Zone). The Applicant proposes to construct four (4) townhouses, which are permitted as a Conditional Use in the zone. According to the Zoning Ordinance, Article 3, Section 2. – General Residence Zones (RG-1 and RG-2):

Section 2. - General residence zones (RG-1 and RG-2). 2.4 Conditional uses. The following uses are permitted, conditional upon the approval of the planning commission in accordance with the procedures and subject to the general conditions set forth in article 10, section 1: a) Townhouses subject to the following restrictions: i. No more than one dwelling unit shall be permitted upon a lot. ii. No more than four dwelling units shall be permitted in a group of townhouses. iii. Each group of townhouses shall be physically separated from another by no less than two dwelling units of a different housing type from other groups of townhouses on the same side of the street. iv. Townhouse groups shall be designed to minimize points of access to the public street and to take access from an alley or other shared access where such access is available.

The following are the bulk standards of the RG-1 zoning district for the townhouse units: Article 4 Section 4.2. [RG-1 zones]. Bulk and parking regulations for general residence zone (RG-1) are as follows (see also article 12, definitions; article 5, supplementary regulations; and article 6, off-street parking, driveways and loading facilities):

One-FamilyDuplex/One-FamilyTownhouses/One-
Dwellings DetachedSemi-Detached andFamily Attached
Other Dwellings
Minimum required:
Lot area (sq. ft.)6,0005,0003,000
Lot width (ft.) per dwelling unit502520
Lot depth (ft.)100100100

147

Paj 148

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

Front yard (ft.)151515
Minimum side yard (ft.)51010
Rear yard (ft.)303030
Off-street parking spaces/DU111
Maximum permitted:
Building height
Stories2½2½3
Feet353535
Lot coverage45%50%60%
(Ord. of 12-14-1992; Ord. No. 2015-13, 10-12-2015)

The project has received variances relating to the lot area and lot depth. See previous discussion of Board of Adjustment Application.

This area is subject to infill standards for the construction of residential units found in Zoning Ordinance, Article 5 §1.12.

1.12 Infill standards. In locations where a lot or group of lots lies within a developed area, the following standards shall apply to the development of the infill lots:

(a) Sidewalks. Standard City of Dover sidewalk, per chapter 98, shall be required to be installed along public street frontage of every infill property by the property owner or developer.

(b) Landscaping. Infill structures shall be designed to minimize the impact on existing, mature trees when practical. All residential lots shall include landscaping to include plants and shrubs along the portions of the house that front a public street. No form of vegetat ion shall be planted on a property in a way that blocks more than half of the front façade(s) from public view.

(c) Primary facade. All buildings shall include a primary entry along the property's street frontage, and shall also include a porch or other entry feature.

Conditional Use This Conditional Use Site Plan is subject to the requirements of Article 10 §1 further discussed below.

With Conditional Use Site Plan applications, the Planning Commission reviews the proposed project to determine whether or not the intended use of townhouses is appropriate in type and scale for the immediate neighborhood. The Commission must also consider whether or not the proposed use will have an adverse impact on the future orderly development of the surrounding area. Article 10, Section 1. – Approval of Conditional Uses states:

Section 1. On application and after public notice and hearing, the commission may authorize the issuance by the city planner of permits for any of the conditional uses for which this ordinance requires, in the district in which such use is proposed to be located. In approving any such use, the planning commission shall take into consideration the public health, safety and welfare, the comfort and convenience of the public in general and of the residents of the immediate neighborhood in particular, and may prescribe

148

Paj 149

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

appropriate conditions and safeguards as may be required in order that the results of its action may, to the maximum extent possible, further the expressed intent of this ordinance and the accomplishment of the following objectives in particular: 1.1 Accessibility for emergency response. That all proposed structures, equipment or material shall be readily accessible for fire, ambulance, police, and other emergency response; 1.2 Harmony of location, size and character. That the proposed use shall be of such location, size and character that, in general, it will be in harmony with the appropriate and orderly development of the zone in which it is proposed to be situated and will not be detrimental to the orderly development of adjacent properties in accordance with the zoning classification of such properties; 1.3 Residential zones. That, in addition to the above, in the case of any use located in, or adjacent to, a residential zone: 1.31 The location and size of such use, the nature and intensity of operations involved in or conducted in connection therewith, its site layout and its relation to access streets shall be such that both pedestrian and vehicular traffic to and from the use and the assembly of persons in connection therewith will not be hazardous or inconvenient to, or incongruous with, the said residential district or conflict with the normal traffic of the neighborhood; and 1.32 The location and height of buildings, the location, nature and height of walls and fences, the nature and extent of landscaping, and other improvements on the site shall be such that the use will not hinder or discourage the appropriate development and use of adjacent land and buildings. If the Planning Commission approves a Conditional Use Application, the use is granted as a Conditional Use Permit. Such permits may be permanent, subject to limitations outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §1.41 or be required by the Commission to undergo periodic renewal using the procedure described in Article 10 §1.42. Any Conditional Use Permit, permanent or not, may be revoked using the procedure described in Article 10 §1.43 if the conditions prescribed by the Commission in conjunction with the issuance of the Conditional Use Permit have not been or are no longer being complied with. VI. PARKING SUMMARY The minimum parking requirements for residences in the RG-1 (General Residence Zone) is one (1) parking space for every dwelling unit. Based on the proposal of four (4) dwelling units, a minimum of four (4) off-street parking spaces must be provided as at least one per lot. The Conditional Use Site Plan submitted includes two (2) parking spaces per dwelling unit, one space in each driveway and one space in each garage. The driveway for the end unit (Lot 1) at the corner of Cecil Street and North West Street is proposed to be off of North West Street. The two middle lots (Lots 2 and 3) have a driveway from Cecil Street. The driveway for the eastern end unit (Lot 4) is proposed from the existing alley (as shown on Revised Plan of 2/5/2025).

VII. SITE CONSIDERATIONS

Sidewalks/ Pedestrian Circulation Sidewalks currently exist along Cecil Street and North West Street. The existing sidewalk on Cecil Street includes a curb depression where access was taken for the parking behind the former dwelling unit. Any disturbed and ADA non-compliant sidewalks should be replaced with ADA

149

Paj 150

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

compliant sidewalks. Connecting sidewalks lead from the street frontage sidewalk to each dwelling unit.

Rear Emergency Access Waiver Request – Alternative Rear Emergency Access Rear Emergency Access is required for some residential dwelling types. According to Article 5, Section 17 of the Zoning Ordinance, either an alley of 16 feet or an open rear yard of 16-foot width is required for Townhouses of three to five units (depending on if fire protected) to serve as rear access. This is to provide access to rear building areas. The plan currently shows an open rear year yard (no fences). The applicant is pursuing an alternative method of fire protection through installation of a residential fire sprinkler system. A written Waiver Request was received for Planning Commission regarding this proposed Alternative to providing the Rear Emergency Access via an alley or open rear yard formats. The Fire Marshal’s Office will also evaluate any fire protection measures as related to the fire lane requirements of the applicable Fire Codes. See attached Request Letter.

The provisions for a waiver are found in Zoning Ordinance, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 17 – Emergency Access Requirements. (2) Waiver. Should the planning commission determine, after demonstration by an applicant, that alternative means of fire protection can be provided which are equivalent to or greater than the public safety protection provided by this ordinance, then the planning commission may recommend to [the] city council to waive certain provisions of this ordinance that are not required under other city or state laws.

Recommendation of Planning Staff: As part of the Development Advisory Committee (DAC) Report dated February 5, 2025, the Planning Staff recommends approval the Waiver Request for Rear Emergency Access for Application C-25-01 finding that the project will likely have the open rear yard due to limitations of the utility easement and that the proposal for the use of residential sprinkler systems is a viable option for fire protection for each unit. The City of Dover’s Office of the Fire Marshal also participates in the Development Advisory Committee review process. A copy of his review comments is attached to this Report.

Findings and Recommendation of the Dover Planning Commission: The Planning Commission at its meeting on February 18, 2025 reviewed the proposed Waiver Request as part of its review of the Application C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street. The Applicant made a presentation on their project and a public hearing was held; see Draft Meeting Minutes excerpt. The Planning Commission recommends approval of the Waiver allowing the Alternative (Use of residential sprinkler system) to satisfy the Rear Emergency Access for this Townhouse project after consideration of the project submission documents and applicant’s presentation. The motion passed 4-1 of the members present (4 members absent).

VIII. BUILDING ARCHITECTURE

The Applicant has provided an Architectural Elevation Plan Sheet with the Plan submission. The architectural elevations show two story townhouses with standing seam steel siding, alternating

150

Paj 151

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

in color and in a vertical pattern. The modern appearance of the townhouses with a 24-foot height would have a flat roof (heat-welded PVC roof membrane) with roof-mounted HVAC equipment. The entry doors face Cecil Street for each townhouse unit. The garage doors, depending on the unit, face either N. West Street or Cecil Street or the alley. The elevation will be updated to reflect the change in garage placement for Lot 4.

IX. TREE PLANTING AND LANDSCAPE PLAN

Zoning Ordinance, Article 5 Section 16 lays out the requirements for tree planting and preservation. A new project is required to provide tree planting at a rate of one (1) tree per 3,000 SF of the “Development Area.” The site overall is noted as being 12,158.214 SF, which would require five (5) total trees. A Landscape Plan was submitted with the Conditional Use Plan showing six (6) trees proposed to be planted. The American Holly tree shown closest to the northern lot line is within the sanitary sewer easement and will conflict with the proposed sanitary sewer line to the rear of the proposed townhouses. There are also landscaping provisions associated with the infill standards (see section earlier in this report).

  • X.ACTIVE RECREATION AREA Article 5, Section 10 of the Zoning Ordinance requires the reservation of open space, recreation and other public facilities as a condition of approval for all one-family dwelling, two-family dwelling and multiple-family dwelling residential developments requiring conditional use approval, site development plan approval, or land subdivision approval by the City of Dover Planning Commission.

Exemption to Recreation Area and Open Space Dedication: Request for Cash-in-Lieu The Zoning Ordinance Article 5, Section 10.511 notes that residential developments with less than five acres of land and less than ten dwelling units are considered a “small development” and as such are exempt from requiring recreation area and open space facilities but shall require a cash donation to be made by the developer in lieu of a dedication of land.

Article 5, Section 10.52 further stipulates how the amount of the cash donation is determined

10.52 Amount of cash donation. This cash donation shall be equivalent to ten percent of the appraised value of gross land area. The land area value shall be based on the appraisal prepared for the developer to secure construction financing. This submitted appraisal shall be a copy of the original supplied to the lending institution, with that institution identified, and shall conform in all ways to the Uniform Standard of Professional Appraisal practice and be performed by an appropriately qualified certified appraiser. If an appraisal prepared for construction financing is not available, then the developer shall have an appraisal done in accordance with the procedures set forth in [sub]section 10.174.

The Applicant is therefore not required to provide such recreation facilities but must otherwise pay a cash-in-lieu fee. This fee is determined based off the appraised value of the gross land area. The appraisal document with the appraised value of the gross land area must be submitted to the Planning Office. The Applicant has submitted a formal Letter of Request to use the Cash-in-lieu provision. The information on the project’s Active Recreation Plan strategy required to be submitted to the Parks, Recreation and Community Enhancement Committee of City Council for

151

Paj 152

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

review and approval. A separate Active Recreation Review Report (Request for Cash-in-Lieu) was prepared.

XI. CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS (from Planning Office as part of DAC Review Report): The subject proposal has been reviewed for code compliance, plan conformity, and completeness in accordance with the agency’s authority and area of expertise. The following items have been identified as elements which need to be addressed by the applicant:

  • 1)The applicant is exempt from the requirement to provide Active Recreation Areas, Open Space, or other such Public Facilities. However, a cash-in-lieu fee must be approved by the Parks and Recreation Committee in order for this exemption to be utilized. The Applicant may choose to provide Active Recreation or other such facilities on-site or must otherwise provide the appraised value of the gross land area to calculate the fee. Once this is determined, the Applicant will be required to have the format/fee approved by the Parks, Recreation and Community Enhancement Committee. This application is scheduled to be presented to the Parks, Recreation and Community Enhancement Committee on February 11, 2025
  • a)The applicant has submitted a letter requesting the cash-in-lieu for the Active Recreation Area. They will also need to provide the property appraisal for the Cah-in-lieu amount to be formally calculated.
  • 2)According to the Land Subdivision Regulations (Appendix A), Article VI, A. – Streets, §13.8, rear alley access shall be provided for townhouses. A Subdivision Waiver Request to eliminate the alley has been submitted for consideration by the Planning Commission. This will also require review and action by City Council.
  • 3)A written waiver request was submitted for consideration by the Planning Commission related to the Rear Emergency Access provisions if an open rear yard (no fencing) or alley cannot be provided for the project. The application proposed an alternative to fire protection measure by using a sprinkler system.
  • 4)Title Sheet (TS-1):
  • a)General Note #27 indicates that sanitation will be provided by a private hauler. These townhouse units are eligible for City trash collection, so this note should be deleted.
  • b)Data Column:
  • i)Correct the Owner name to “4BL, LLC.” ii) Provide the bulk standards, including setbacks and lot coverage, for each lot. Each lot must comply individually with the required bulk standards, except for those standards for which the Board of Adjustment approved variances. iii) Remove the note “Trash pickup will be private” and indicate that the City of Dover will provide trash collection.
  • c)Update the Owner’s Certification to use the entity name “4BL, LLC” not, Tidemark Construction.
  • 5)Site Plan (SD-2):

152

Paj 153

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

  • a)Add the depth dimension on the interior lot lines. (These are shown on the revised Record Plan sheets of 2/5/2025.)
  • b)Label driveway and sidewalk width and depth. Sheet RP-2 shows it as asphalt paving of 10- foot width.
  • 4)Landscape Plan (LS-1):
  • a)In the tree planning calculation, correct the number of trees required to be on-site overall from (4) to (5).
  • b)Note that no tree plantings may be placed within 10 ft of any underground utilities. It appears that at least one of the American Holly trees is within 10 feet of the sanitary sewer lines or other utility lines.
  • c)Add landscape requirements of plants and shrubs at front of each unit as part of infill standards.
  • 5)The Record Plan Sheets (RP1 and RP2) of February 5, 2025 have provided updated and clarifying information on the lot dimensions. This clarified information appears to comply with the variances granted by the Board of Adjustment. Ensure that all sheets in the plan set are updated appropriately.
  • a)Previously it was noted that if a survey of the property yielded different information on lot dimensions, then the Planning Office may need to update the Board of Adjustment as related to the variances they granted (V-24-06).
  • 6)Ensure compliance with infill standards for porch or other entry features for each townhouse unit.
  • 7)The plan involves a Minor Subdivision to create four (4) townhouse lots. A Record Plan set to create the lots and identify easements was submitted February 5, 2025 and will be reviewed to confirm plan requirements and details for compliance.

XII. RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES: In accordance with the Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §1, the Planning Commission in considering and acting upon Conditional Use Plans may prescribe appropriate conditions and safeguards so that the public health, safety, and welfare, the comfort and convenience of the public in general, and the residents of the immediate neighborhood in particular shall be taken into consideration. These safeguards may to the maximum extent possible further the expressed intent of the Zoning Ordinance and the accomplishment of several objectives in particular listed in subsections 1.1 to 1.3.

  • 1)Conditional Use for Townhouses: The request is for the establishment of townhouses through the Conditional Use process. The proposal is consistent with the 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Housing and Community Development Chapter, Goal 1: Encourage Balanced Housing Opportunities for all Residents of the City, Recommendation 1: Encourage the Use of Mixed Housing Types.

153

Paj 154

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

This project is located within the City’s Downtown Development District where the development of quality housing is a priority. The proposed development is consistent with the goals of the Downtown Development District program.

  • 2)Active Recreation Area: Planning Staff notes that there are currently no Active Recreation Areas proposed with this Conditional Use Plan/ Minor Subdivision Plan submission. As this project is exempt from requiring Active Recreation, the Applicant may choose to implement an Active Recreation Plan or otherwise pay a cash-in-lieu by providing the appraised value of the gross land area for review by the Parks, Recreation and Community Enhancement Committee. The applicant is pursuing the Cash-in-lieu option and will be required to submit the appraisal for the property so Planning staff can calculate the amount.
  • 3)Lot Configuration:
  • a)Planning Staff is supportive of relocation of the garage and driveway for the easternmost lot (Lot 4) to be from the alley at side of the townhouse unit) rather than at the front from Cecil Street. This format shown on the 2/5/2025 Record Plan would allow for on-street parking to remain.
  • b)Consider options for access to the rear yards of Lots 2 and 3 for maintenance.
  • c)Ensure there are storage areas (in garage space) or elsewhere for the trash and recycling containers for all units.

XIII. ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT:

  • 1)In the event that major changes and revisions to the Conditional Use Site Plan occur in the finalization of the Conditional Use Plan, contact the Department of Planning and Inspections. These changes may require resubmittal for review by the Development Advisory Committee, Planning Commission, or other agencies and commissions making recommendations in regard to the Plan.
  • 2)Following Planning Commission approval of the Conditional Use Plan, the Plan must be revised to meet all conditions of approval from the Development Advisory Committee or as otherwise noted. A Check Print must be submitted for review by Planning Office Staff and the other commenting agencies. Upon determination that the Plan is complete and all agency approvals have been received, copies of the Plan may be submitted for final endorsement (Final Plan Approval).
  • 3)Other agencies and departments which participate in the Development Advisory Committee may provide additional comments related to their areas of expertise and code requirements.
  • 4)For building construction, the requirements of the building code and the fire code must be complied with. Consult with the Chief Building Inspector and City of Dover Fire Marshal for these requirements. The resolution of these items may impact the site design including such items as building dimensions and height, building openings, and fire protection

154

Paj 155

Item 2. C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street Petition to Waive Subdivision Standards Petition for Alternative Emergency Access Requirements Planning Commission Recommendation Report of February 18, 2025

needs, etc.

  • 5)The applicant/developer shall be aware that prior to any development or ground disturbing activities on the site the appropriate site inspections and permits are required. This includes activities to clean-up existing vegetation, the import of fill dirt, etc.
  • 6)Construction may have an effect on the adjacent property owners and adjacent roadways. Any work requiring the closing or rerouting of local traffic should be coordinated as to offer the least amount of inconvenience to the adjacent property owners.
  • 7)The addresses for the new townhouse units proposed will need to be confirmed with the City’s Tax Assessment Office and GIS Division. The existing address may be revised and new addresses assigned.
  • 8)The applicant shall be aware that Conditional Use Plan approval does not represent a Building Permit and associated construction activity permits. A separate application process is required for issuance of a Building Permit from the City of Dover. Each townhouse unit will require a Building Permit.
  • 9)This property is located in the Downtown Redevelopment Target Area and Dover Downtown Development District where there are City Incentives for eligible projects. Contact Planning Staff for more information and applications.

Attachments: • Plan drawings: Revised Title Sheet and Record Plan and Elevation Rendering • Subdivision Waiver Request Letter of February 6, 2025 • Waiver Request – Alternative Rear Emergency Access Letter of February 6, 2025 • Development Advisory Committee (DAC) Comments from the Department of Water & Wastewater/Department of Public Works and from the City’s Office of the Fire Marshal

  • •Excerpt of Draft Meeting Minutes of Planning Commission Meeting of February 18, 2025 (pending completion)

Notes: • The Planning Review narrative and comments of the Development Advisory Committee (DAC) Report were initially prepared by Staff of the Rossi Group (under a Planning Services contract with the City of Dover). The Report was completed with additional review and editing by the City’s Planning Office. • All Application materials are on file at the Planning Office including the complete Plan Set, letters, agency review comments, and Application Formas.

155

Paj 156

Item 2.

156

Paj 157

Item 2.

157

Paj 158

Item 2.

158

Paj 159

Item 2.

159

Paj 160

Item 2.

160

Paj 161

Item 2.

CITY OF DOVER
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: JANUARY 29, 2025

APPLICATION: Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West St. FILE #: C-25-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Water & Wastewater CONTACT PERSON: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services CONTACT PHONE #: 302-736-7025 CONTACT EMAIL #: jlyon@dover.de.us

T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .

T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :

CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS

SANITATION

  • 1.Trash collection site shall be oriented for side-loading pick-up if customer is utilizing City of Dover sanitation services.
  • 2.The containers shall be wheeled to Cecil Street for collection. STORMWATER
  • 1.Final site plan approval will not be granted until a copy of the approved Stormwater/Erosion and Sediment Control Plan from Kent Conservation District is submitted to our office.
  • 2.The size, length, slope, type and flow directions must be shown on all existing and proposed storm sewer lines. Rim and invert elevations must be labeled on all stormwater structures. STREETS
  • 1.Final site plan approval will not be granted until a copy of the approved entrance plan, signed by DelDOT is submitted to our office.
  • 2.Please add the following notes to the plans:
  • a.Standard City of Dover sidewalk, as per chapter 98, article IV of the Dover Code of Ordinances, shall be required to be installed along the entire public street frontage of a property. Where frontage sidewalk exists but does not meet the standards of chapter 98, article IV, the sidewalk shall be re-laid to meet the standards. Sidewalk shall include barrier-free access ramping at points of intersection with street crossings and at other locations so as to afford reasonable barrier-free pedestrian movement and site access.
  • b.In accordance to Appendix A, Article VI, Section B.3, all sidewalks shall ascend from the curbstone to the building line at the ratio of one-quarter of an inch to the foot. Nothing in this section shall be construed to affect any pavement previously laid by order of the city council, until it is taken up and relaid.
  • 3.Please provide spot elevations at the proposed driveway locations. Staff will need to review to confirm positive drainage on Cecil Street. 161

Paj 162

Item 2.
Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West St.
File #: C-25-01
January 29, 2025

  • 4.It shall be unlawful for any person to alter the curb of any street so as to create a curb depression for the purpose of permitting vehicles to enter onto or exit from the city streets, without a permit issued by the city manager WATER
  • 1.All water utility components must meet the requirements of the Water Wastewater Handbook, effective date March 22, 2010. Please contact our office for more information.
  • 2.The following notes must be added to the plans:
  • a.Hydrant connections by the contractor are prohibited. This method may not be utilized during any phase of the project.
  • b.Any existing water lines not to be utilized by the proposed facility must be properly abandoned at the mains in accordance with the City of Dover Department of Water & Wastewater specifications and requirements.
  • c.The site contractor shall contact the City of Dover Department of Water & Wastewater Construction Manager at (302) 736- 7025 prior to the start of construction. A representative from the City of Dover Department of Water & Wastewater must observe and approve all City owned water and sanitary sewer interconnections and testing. All water taps must be performed by a City of Dover approved contractor. The proposed location for the water connection may need to be adjusted in the field due to conditions of the existing main. Possible conditions that would require tapping relocation include proximity to pipe joints, other taps, concrete encasements, conflict with other utilities, and the like. Test holes must be performed by the contractor to determine the best tapping location. The City of Dover will not be held responsible for field conditions requiring adjustment of the tapping location or for any work required by the contractor to make an appropriate and lawful connection.
  • 3.The size, type, and location of all proposed and existing water lines and valves must be shown on the plan. Please be advised that effective May 1, 2022, water mains can now be constructed using DR 18 PVC pipe.
  • 4.The water service shall include a curb stop at the property line and the meter shall be installed in a pit within a non-traffic bearing location (including pedestrian).
  • 5.Water usage projections (peak demand or plumbing fixtures) must be submitted to our office to correctly determine the size of the domestic and irrigation (if applicable) water meter for the proposed buildings. These projections must be submitted prior to approval so the meter size can be placed on the final site plan. The proposed water meter must be installed in a pit per City of Dover requirements and manufacturer’s recommendations. Also, a dual check valve is required downstream of the meter.
  • 6.The domestic service, fire main connection and valves must be clearly shown for each building. A valve must be installed at the tee to isolate combined fire and domestic water service to the building from the water loop. Typically, this valve is installed at the tee or an acceptable distance from the building. A valve must be provided on the domestic water service, which must be tapped off of the combined eight-inch (8”) fire/domestic service outside of the building. The domestic water tap and valve should be as close to the building as possible. Typically, the domestic tap and valve are located within five feet (5’) to ten feet (10’) of the building. A blow up detail of this layout is recommended.
  • 7.Provide a construction detail for the proposed restraining system for the fire main located within the buildings. The Department of Public Works will test and inspect all fire mains to a blind flange located inside the buildings. The blind flange with tap is used for hydrostatic pressure testing (200 psi for two (2) hours) and dechlorination. The flange must be restrained in the direction of the pipe entering the facility. A pipe entering horizontally through a wall sleeve shall be restrained with rods through the wall. A pipe entering vertically through a slab shall be restrained through the floor to the ninety degree (90°) bend and thrust block. All rods shall be a minimum of ¾” all thread. All pipes through walls and slabs must be Class 52 cement lined ductile iron pipe. Confirm particulars to meet this requirement with mechanical designer.
  • 8.Water services shall be either type K copper or SDR-9.
  • 9.The City of Dover does not have a water main located adjacent to the proposed properties on Cecil Street. A new plan must be provided for review.

WASTEWATER 162

Paj 163

Item 2.
Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West St.
File #: C-25-01
January 29, 2025

  • 1.All wastewater utility components must meet the requirements of the Water Wastewater Handbook, effective date March 22, 2010. Please contact our office for more information.
  • 2.The following notes must be added to the plans:
  • a.Any existing sanitary sewer lines not to be utilized by the proposed facility must be properly abandoned at the mains in accordance with the City of Dover Department of Water & Wastewater specifications and requirements.
  • b.Part II, Chapter 180, Article III, Section 180-10 of the Code of Kent County requires that “no person shall discharge or cause to be discharged any stormwater, surface water, uncontaminated groundwater, roof runoff, subsurface drainage, uncontaminated noncontact cooling water or unpolluted industrial process waters to any sanitary sewer”, this shall include condensate. Sec. 110-231 of the City of Dover Code defines storm sewer as “…any system used for conveying rain water, surface water, condensate, cooling water or similar liquid wastes, exclusive of sewage.” The contractor, developer, owner and designers shall ensure during construction that no illegal discharges to the sanitary sewer system are created with the site improvements.
  • 3.The size, length, slope, type and flow directions must be shown on all existing and proposed sanitary sewer lines. Rim and invert elevations must be labeled on all sanitary structures, including cleanouts.
  • 4.Cleanouts must be installed on sanitary sewer laterals within five feet (5’) of the building, one foot (1’) outside of the right-of-way and at all bends. Any cleanout located within a traffic bearing location shall be installed with a heavy duty cast iron frame and cover to prevent damage to the cleanout and lateral.
  • 5.Minimum slope criteria shall meet Ten States Standards. Provide flow calculations to justify sizing of the sewer mains, showing that velocity requirements are met. Waiver requests must be approved by the Department of Public Works.
  • 6.The desired location for sewer mains is under the centerline of the street. One-tenth of a foot (0.1’) drop must be provided across all manholes. The minimum slope for eight-inch (8”) sanitary sewer pipe is 0.004 feet/feet. Minimum cover is 3.0 feet.
  • 7.Sanitary sewer manholes shall be spaced no more than 400 feet apart.
  • 8.The minimum size of all sanitary sewer laterals shall be six-inch (6”).
  • 9.Sanitary sewer laterals shall be connected directly to the main, not manholes, unless impracticable, as determined by the Department of Water & Wastewater.
  • 10.Please provide a twenty-foot (20’) easement for the proposed wastewater main. This shall be dedicated to the City of Dover for maintenance and ownership. No structures shall be installed within the easement.
  • 11.Doghouse manholes are not allowed in the City of Dover. GENERAL
  • 1.All existing utilities shall be adjusted to final grade in accordance with current City of Dover requirements and practices. This must be included as a note on the plan.
  • 2.No trees may be planted within ten feet (10’) of utility infrastructure.
  • 3.No structure may be installed within ten feet (10’) of utility infrastructure, please depict all underground utilities and structures on the utility plan sheet to confirm compliance.
  • 4.The final site plan must be submitted in the following compatible digital formats:
  • a.AutoCAD 2018 (.dwg format).
  • b.Adobe Reader (.pdf format).

RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES SANITATION / STORMWATER / STREETS / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. None.

163

Paj 164

Item 2.
Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West St.
File #: C-25-01
January 29, 2025

ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT

WATER

  • 1.The City of Dover water system is available to this site. The developer is responsible for all costs associated with extending and providing service to the proposed development.
  • 2.Prior to plan approval, the water system plans must be submitted to the Division of Public Health, Office of Drinking Water for review and approval. The owner/developer will be responsible for providing all completed forms and plan sets to the City of Dover as required for submission to the Office of Drinking Water. Plans will not be submitted to the Office of Drinking Water until review has been completed by our office.
  • 3.Hydrant flow testing is currently only performed during the spring and fall. The applicant must call the Department of Water & Wastewater directly to schedule these tests. This applies to both existing hydrants as well as those proposed for the site.
  • 4.Water impact fees will be required to be paid prior to Certificate of Occupancy for this project. WASTEWATER
  • 1.The City of Dover sanitary sewer system is available to this site. The developer is responsible for all costs associated with extending and providing service and capacity to the proposed development.
  • 2.Prior to plan approval, it may be required to submit the sanitary sewer system plans to the DNREC, Division of Water Resources, Surface Water Discharges Section for review and approval. The owner/developer is responsible for providing all application fees, completed forms and plan sets directly to DNREC.
  • 3.Wastewater impact fees will be required to be paid prior to Certificate of Occupancy for this project. GENERAL
  • 1.The applicant is advised that depending upon the size of the existing water service and sanitary sewer lateral to be abandoned, flowable fill may be required.
  • 2.Construction plans will not be reviewed by our office unless all previous comments have been clearly addressed within the plan set and accordingly identified within an itemized response letter and with the Water/Wastewater Initial Plan Submission Checklist, which can be obtained from the following website: https://imageserv9.team- logic.com/mediaLibrary/198/WaterWastewaterHandbookFinal_1.pdf, page 88. SANITATION / STORMWATER / STREETS
  • 1.None.

I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .

164

Paj 165

C F
Ite2.
C-25-01
m
I I
T R
CITY OF DOVER Y E

DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE O M

F A APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY R D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 01/29/25 D S O H V A E L R APPLICATION: Lands of 4BL, LLC, Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West St

FILE #: C-25-01 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover, Office of the Fire Marshal

CONTACT PERSON: Jason Osika, Fire Marshal PHONE #: (302) 736-4457 josika@dover.de.us

THE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE, PLAN CONFORMITY, AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY’S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE.

THE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESS BY THE APPLICANT:

CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS:

  • 1.Proposed occupancy classification is residential townhouses
  • 2.Emergency access to rear building areas compliant with City of Dover Code (Appendix B- Zoning, Article 5- Supplementary Regulations, Section 17);

all four stories and greater buildings require 24ft fire lane at the rear.

All two to three story apartment structures require an 18ft Secondary Fire Lane at the rear.

All townhouses (3-8 units with no fire protection) require a 16ft alley or 18ft secondary fire lane at the rear.

  • 3.Every house, building or structure used or intended for use as living quarters or as a place for conducting business, and having any wall facing or abutting any public or private street or alley, shall have displayed on that wall, in legible, easily read characters which are of contrasting color to the background, the proper street number for such house, building, or structure in accordance with the following:

One-family and two-family residential structures, height, the number shall measure a minimum of four inches in height, location, the number shall be placed on the house above or to the left or right of the front entrance, color, the number shall be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals, all numbers shall be Arabic numerals.

165

Paj 166

Item 2.

Multiple-family dwellings, measurements, the number shall measure a minimum of six inches when identifying individual apartments with exterior doors, and 12 inches when identifying buildings with apartment complexes where there are two or more buildings not assigned street addresses. Individual buildings with street addresses shall have numbers measuring six inches, location, numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the street end of the building so as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the parking lot, color, numbers shall be contrasting to the background color, Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic numerals.

Commercial, industrial and office buildings, height, the numbers shall measure a minimum of 12 inches in height, location generally, numbers shall be placed either in the center of the building or on the street end of the building so as to be visible from either the public or private street or from the parking lot,

property line or driveway, should the building be located far enough from a public or private road so that the numbers are not clearly visible from the street, then the street address shall also be posted on the property at or near the property line or driveway to said building,

color; each building, numbers shall be contrasting to the background color and shall be placed on each building in the complex,

Arabic numerals, all numbers used shall be Arabic numerals,

Shopping centers. Shopping centers consisting of two or more stores shall have a tenant or suite number affixed to the front of the tenant space and on the outside of the rear door which corresponds with that tenant space. Numbers shall measure six inches in height. (City of Dover Code of Ordinances, 98-344)

  • 4.Project to be completed per approved Site Plan.
  • 5.Full building and fire plan review is required.
  • 6.Construction or renovations cannot be started until building plans are approved.
  • 7.Fire alarm systems, fire suppression systems, hoods, exhaust ducts, and hood suppression systems require a fire permit from the Fire Marshal’s Office. This work cannot be started until the permit is approved.
  • 8.Building cannot be occupied by the public until a Certificate of Occupancy is obtained.
  • 9.The following is City Ordinance, Appendix B-Zoning, Article 8 Enforcement and Penalties:

Section 1. - Building permits.

No building or structure in any district shall be erected or structurally altered without a building permit duly issued upon application to the building inspector. No building permit shall be issued unless the proposed construction or use is in full conformity with all the provisions of this ordinance. Any building permit issued in violation of the provisions of this ordinance shall be null and void and of no effect, without the necessity for any proceedings for revocations or nullification thereof, and any work

166

Paj 167

Item 2.

undertaken or use established pursuant to any such permit shall be unlawful (see section 4 for penalties).

1.1 No building permit shall be issued for the construction or alteration of any building upon a lot without frontage upon, or legal permanent access to, a public street improved to the satisfaction of the planning commission, or without access to a public sewer.

1.2 No building permit shall be issued for any building where the site development plan of such building is subject to approval by the planning commission, except upon approval of such plans approved by the said commission.

1.21 No building permit shall be issued for any building in a subdivision unless the subdivision plot has been approved by the planning commission.

1.3 No building permit shall be issued for a building to be used for any conditional use in any zone where such use is allowed only with approval of the planning commission, unless and until such approval has been duly granted by the said commission.

(Ord. of 7-12-1993, § 3)

ADDITIONAL / SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS TO OBTAIN APPROVAL:

  • 1.Rear Emergency Access is required as outlined in item # 2 listed above. This can be waived if the townhouses are sprinklered.

APPLICABLE CODES LISTED BELOW (NOT LIMITED TO):

2021 NFPA 1 Fire Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2021 NFPA 101 Life Safety Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 72 National Fire Alarm and Signaling Code (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2019 NFPA 13 Installation of Sprinkler Systems (NFPA; National Fire Protection Association) 2009 IBC (International Building Code) Latest editions of all other NFPA Codes as defined by the Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations 2021 Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations City of Dover Code of Ordinances

*If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person listed.

167

Paj 168

Item 2.

CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION

February 18, 2025
Excerpt from Meeting Minutes – Draft

The Meeting of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Tuesday, February 18, 2025, at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system Webex. The Meeting Session was conducted with Vice Chair Mrs. Denney presiding. Members present were Mr. Michael Lewis, Mrs. Maucher (virtual), Dr. Jones, Mr. Reaves (virtual), and Mrs. Denney. Mr. Roach, Mr. Baldwin, Mrs. Welsh, and Mr. Witham were absent.

Staff members present were Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Ms. Sharon Duca, Mrs. Kristen Mullaney, and Mr. Jason Lyon.

NEW APPLICATIONS

C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street – Public Hearing and Review of Conditional Use Plan and Minor Subdivision Plan application to subdivide the existing 12,158.214 SF parcel located at the northeast corner of N. West Street and Cecil Street into four (4) townhouse lots (Cecil Street Townhouses). The property is zoned RG-1 (General Residence Zone). The owner of record is 4BL, LLC. Property Address: 207 N. West Street, Dover DE. Tax Parcel: ED-05-076.08-02-01.00-000. Council District 4. Waiver Request: Subdivision Waiver – Alley Requirement and Waiver for Rear Emergency Access - Alternative. For Consideration: Active Recreation Plan - Cash-in-lieu. This property was the subject of V-24-06 with the Board of Adjustment granting variances for lot depth and lot area on November 20, 2024.

Representatives: Mr. Cameron Llewellyn, 4BL, LLC; Mr. Doug Liberman, Larson Engineering

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that this is Application C-25-01. We are talking about a property located at the corner of N. West Street and Cecil Street. The image on the screen has Cecil Street along the bottom and N. West Street on the left as you are looking at it. The property at 207 N. West Street is currently vacant. Previously, there was a residential structure and a garage building on that property that has since been demolished at that location. Proposed tonight is a series of four townhouse lots here on this tract of land. Initially, this project did visit the City’s Board of Adjustment and was successful in receiving two Variances. The first Variance was a reduction in the minimum lot depth from 100 feet to 84.5 feet. That was necessary because they are looking to re-orient the lots to face Cecil Street rather than N. West Street. The second Variance approved by the Board of Adjustment is a reduction in the minimum lot area for a couple of the lots; the lots in the center, Lots 2 and 3 in particular. What is before the Planning Commission is a Conditional Use. In the RG-1 (General Residence Zone), the use as townhouses is a Conditional Use, meaning it needs special approval from the Planning Commission. Additionally, any subdivision of land, i.e. one lot becoming more than one lot, also requires review by the Planning Commission. There is also what they call a Minor Subdivision Plan as part of this application. There are several waivers that the Planning Commission will be making recommendations on this evening. The first comes from the Land Subdivision Regulations and that is where townhouses are required to provide a rear access alley. This tract of land does have an alley on its eastern boundary; however, with the Subdivision it would require an additional alley across the rear of the property. The Planning Commission can consider a waiver of that if

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 1 of 10 168

Paj 169

Item 2.

you find that it is infeasible for the development or the design of the townhouses precludes the ability to have such an alley. It will be a recommendation from the Planning Commission that will then move on through a City Council review process for ultimate action. With the townhouses, there are some requirements. Each unit has to be on an individual lot and the maximum number of units in a row is four, which is what we are seeing here. There is also the restriction that you should minimize points of access to the public street and take access from an alley or other shared access where it’s available. With this project, they are placing one driveway from the N. West Street location for that corner unit. The two center units have driveways off of Cecil Street and the remaining end unit is proposed through a Revised Plan to use the existing alley for the driveway access for that unit. With parking for each of these, as noted, there is a driveway which then actually leads to a single car garage. The RG-1 (General Residence Zone) would require that at least one parking space be provided on each property. With this configuration, they are providing two. There are existing sidewalks on N. West Street and on Cecil Street and each unit will also have a connecting sidewalk from those street frontage sidewalks. The second waiver that the Planning Commission needs to consider this evening is for rear emergency access. Our Code requires that townhouses have either an alley or an open rear yard of a certain width for townhouses to be able to access those rear building areas. This would preclude any fencing from being in that location. The applicant is interested in pursuing an alternative to this rear emergency access by doing the installation of a residential fire sprinkler system for these units. This is a proposed alternative that you will need to consider this evening. Again, you will make a recommendation and final action will move onto the City Council for that consideration through their Committee process. The Fire Marshal did weigh in on it in their comments regarding using that sprinkler system as an option for satisfying that requirement and they have noted that in their comments specifically. The building architecture for this property was also presented to the Planning Commission along with a Landscape Plan. They are planting a number of trees which may need to be slightly adjusted depending on where utilities land for these units as they will be serviced by City water and sewer. The architecture for the buildings is basically a two-story structure focused on a very modern look with a steel siding and a flat roof configuration for the units. There is some alteration in color and each of the entries has somewhat of a canopy piece that is over the front door. If we go back to the Site Plan, the other option that we need to discuss tonight for consideration is in regard to Active Recreation. There is a requirement for Active Recreation Areas with residential development; however, our Code does recognize that small developments may need an exemption from that. This applicant has requested to make use of that exemption and what that exemption does is reduce the amount of land area that would be required and instead of providing land and amenities, it offers opportunities for a payment of a Cash-in-Lieu. The Code outlines how to calculate that Cash-in- Lieu. It requires the applicant to submit an appraisal which upon receipt of that, the Planning Office will calculate what the Cash-in-Lieu payment of Active Recreation Area construction is. This was an item that was to be considered by the City’s Parks, Recreation and Community Enhancement Committee Meeting on February 11, 2025. That will be considered at their meeting that is now scheduled for February 25, 2025. This evening, Planning Staff is advising that the Commission can continue to review and evaluate this application and that any action taken tonight be conditioned upon completing that review of the Active Recreation Area component of that Cash-in-Lieu fee. What we can do is bring a Report on that back to you at a future meeting, but we wanted to keep the application moving forward since they don’t control Mother Nature and her gift of snow for last week.

For Planning Commission members, we have a Conditional Use Application with a Minor Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 2 of 10 169

Paj 170

Item 2.

Subdivision Plan. You are addressing three types of requests. A Subdivision Waiver related to the Alley requirement for townhouses, the Rear Emergency Access and the Request to use a sprinkler system as the Alternative and then the Active Recreation Area Plan Cash-in-Lieu request.

Mr. Llewellyn stated that he believes that Mrs. Melson-Williams did a fine job in explaining what they are trying to accomplish but in brief, when they were building the Rail Haus Beer Garden for the Legans Family, we noticed this property sitting here vacant. They attempted to purchase it and save it before the dereliction took over but they couldn’t come to terms. Then obviously City Staff took care of the issue and got the building to the ground and gone. They were able to negotiate a purchase of it. Where we are now is that they have adult children trying to move back into our homes, they have trades people and young adults that just can’t afford to buy a mansion in a corn field, and this is an opportunity where we can split the cost of this parcel into four and make four really nice, affordable homes there and help some young families get a leg up. Mr. Liberman will elaborate but the Alley requirement from their chair is almost one in the same. They saw in the comments from the (Development) Advisory (Committee) Meeting that Kent Conservation District, the Fire Marshal and the Kent County MPO all agree that they didn’t really need an alley and that they would prefer that they sprinkler the building. From our end, they start doing a cost analysis and the cost of non-combustible finishes on the outside of the building and paving that and curb cuts and all of the utilities, far out pays just putting a sprinkler system in this building. A sprinkler system makes it safer for these families if something bad were to happen. Finally, the item that you have for consideration with the Cash-in -Lieu donation, they do believe that between the City Council and the Planning Commission, they should all re-read the 2019 Comprehensive Plan thoroughly because when you look at this, they are going to take the appraised value of a property and then artificially raise that cost by 10% to hand it over to Parks and Recreation. He understands that they have expenses but he doesn’t think young families are concerned about a place to go do pull-ups. He thinks they would rather afford diapers and groceries. He would encourage both entities to revisit that, look at the 2019 Comprehensive Plan and see where we think that leads. It’s not just this parcel. Drive around Downtown Dover and look at all of the empty lots that we have sitting here. Are we discouraging the development of these parcels because we are going to make somebody make this large Cash-in-Lieu payment?

Mr. Liberman stated that he wanted to talk briefly about the two Waivers that they have. First, the Subdivision Waiver for the rear alley requirement, it requires townhouses to have a rear alley and one of the primary reasons they didn’t want to do this is because this alley would take up significant green space behind these lots. As Mrs. Melson-Williams mentioned, these are 84.5- foot-deep lots and they don’t have a lot of green space at the back. For example, the patched area that you see at the top of the Plan, that is a 20-foot-wide utility easement that they are going to have running down there. So, if they have a twelve (12) or sixteen (16) foot alley running across the back of all of those lots, you can see how much space that would take up. This would also put us at or above the 60% maximum lot coverage required by the Code so we would be asking for another waiver. Again, they are seeking to have green space in these areas as opposed to that. One of the things with the rear alley, the rear alley calls for access. They are going to have to have this utility easement here anyway which they can’t build in. They are going to add a provision in within that easement for access so all of these units would have access to that space. Not vehicular but they would be able to go back and forth across that space because with it being a sewer easement, they won’t be able to put a fence across there or anything like that anyway. Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 3 of 10 170

Paj 171

Item 2.

The second waiver for the City of Dover’s Zoning Ordinance from Article 5, Section 17 again requires either a 16-foot-wide alley or a 16-foot-wide open space, which given this configuration with this easement across the back, he thinks would address that issue. The Fire Marshal is supporting this. This area is going to be open. He thinks as far as these two Waivers; they have support on multiple sides for them.

Dr. Jones asked what the square footage of each townhouse is. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn stated that it is 1,750 SF give or take a few feet depending on which unit.

Dr. Jones asked if there was a particular reason for the flat roof other than perhaps cost. She went through the area and she didn’t see any flat roofs. Of course, they are needs to be built up. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn stated that when you look at where these units sit, if the two center units have an air conditioner sitting on the ground out back, it is going to take up a significant area that they could use for recreation. They come from the commercial world and we put the air conditioners on the roof. Full disclosure, we do that so people can’t steal the copper out of it. He is not concerned about that in this neighborhood, but it was just an easy way for us to solve the problem for where do we put all of these pieces of equipment.

Dr. Jones stated that he mentioned the idea of recreation and then you were speaking Cash-in- lieu of for the active recreation area. She was just interested in your comments that families are interested in nice places to live but if you have families and they have children, they need some place to play and there is not a lot of area. She is not opposed to the idea but your comment was a little interesting. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn stated that his kid now looks him in the eye but when she was little, he put her in the buggy behind a mountain bike and he could drag her all around Dover to go to parks and places to play. If you go out onto N. West Street, that is where the bike path is and that will lead these young families to many places where they can recreate. He believes that young families will get on that bike path and go find the parks and so on from there. They did build a very nice restaurant across the street and there is a children’s play area there so you can go get a sandwich, a pint and you kids can play in the sand pit too.

Dr. Jones stated that she noticed that the siding is vertical. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn asked if she had been to the Rail Haus Beer Garden.

Dr. Jones stated that she has not been in but she has been by. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn stated that the same siding they used when they did that build, they just kind of wanted to continue that theme in the neighborhood. Part of that came from the Fire Marshal’s Office when they first consulted them. They wanted non-combustible materials on the outside. There is the potential that they might go to more of a board and baton look because with sprinkling the townhomes, if they don’t have to do that alley in-lieu of sprinkle then they don’t have to use the steel siding and they can use something that would make these a little more affordable. Again, that is why they did a cost study before we just throw something up and say, “oh my gosh no one can afford to live here.”

Dr. Jones stated that she was very interested in this particular application. Are these townhouses for sale or rent? Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn stated that the answer is yes. He will let you know what the monthly rental or the purchase price will be once they finish.

Mrs. Denney stated that she tends to be a little bit more concerned with history here in the Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 4 of 10 171

Paj 172

Item 2.

Capital City of the State that started the Nation. She likes things to have a little history. There is really nothing that says history in this particular exterior to her unless it were maybe painted to look like a barn. To her, it doesn’t feel like that. She realizes that it is further down the street, but she is just wondering what was the decision maker with regard to this particular view from the street. Responding to that, Mr. Llewellyn stated that they travel a lot and take a lot of pictures of things he sees. They kind of copies off a building that looked really neat in an area not far from here if you go up to Fish Town in Philadelphia. It was an old, dilapidated building that they re- did and they really liked the look of that. One of their challenges here is that they don’t want to make all of the other homes in the community to look dated. Across the street, they have a pole barn if you know where Teal Construction is. We are looking at vertical metal siding and then across the street we have multiple churches in the neighborhood that are a combination of architectural genius and some not so much. The Community Center has vertical siding on it two doors down and then its the Beer Garden with vertical siding. They decided rather than doing something completed different and just putting vinyl dutch lap siding like you would see on a townhouse anywhere in a rural area, they would try to emulate some of the things going on in the neighborhood.

Dr. Jones stated that these are townhouses and four individual units, will there be a sprinkler system in each unit? Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn stated yes, it is not any different than when you walk into a shopping center you see the sprinkler heads poking out of the ceiling tiles. These would just come out of the drywall. They just did a project in Milford where they built ten apartments and they all have a sprinkler in them. It just makes them safer. A family that lives in one unit can’t control what happens in the unit next door. They have firewalls between them and a sprinkler that would take care of something. It is fundamentally no different in how it operates according to the commercial end of things, but basically there is a bell ringing outside. If that bell is ringing, it means water is following through a sprinkler head somewhere in that building and it would tell the alarm to go off. It is a system that they do in Maryland. We haven’t gotten that far. We have tried it here in Delaware and it hasn’t grown traction because unfortunately it is going to raise the cost of a unit. We looked at this about the safety and the cost to put a sprinkler system in versus paving the alley. People get a lot more benefit out of that sprinkler system and peace of mind than they would have to walk out your back door and half of your backyard is asphalt.

Mrs. Denney stated that prior to living in Dover, she lived in Camden, which the center of town is very historic and protected by the National Register. We had very little front yard as it was mostly sidewalk although they did have a back yard. She had plenty of land behind her house and an alley, but frankly she prefers a paved alley. To her, number one you don’t have to cut it, the City goes through when it snows and graciously plows the alley because the aprons to our garages are back there. So, to her, she personally prefers an alley. With her grandkids, there were days when they would have bike races and they had a basketball hoop in the alley because their alleys weren’t traversed that frequently so you could do that.

Mrs. Denney opened the public hearing.

Ms. Bonnie Pennington – Resident on N. Kirkwood Street Ms. Pennington stated that she was sitting back there listening to this gentleman and she gets that he wants to build condos out there and she has no issue with that. The issue that she is having is that she doesn’t know where he came from but where she lives at, it’s all homeless people. That Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 5 of 10 172

Paj 173

Item 2.

is the number one reason why they tore that house down. Number 2, there is copper and stuff being stolen off of that street. They watch it every day. Number 3, they are the ones who live on Kirkwood Street that set up a neighborhood watch because of everything that was going on down on that street. She doesn’t know what part of town he’s looking in but the part that she lives on it is not no saint. There is just as much trouble down on that side of town as there is on the other side of town. The issue with that is that there are no cops that come on that side of town like there is on the other side of town. She has lived on this street for 20 years and for 20 years, the cops have only been there three times. That is because the Elks Club was open. They got the Elk Club shutdown. She gets that he wants to build condos there. She gets that everybody is out to make money. But he needs to do a little bit of research before you start talking about an area that you just built a bar at and you know nothing about it. The community did not want the bar there. We were out voted for that to be there and now they are out voted for the condos to be there. Her question is that you all are talking about parking, but there is no parking on this street. You got the bar, the two churches, and you‘ve got people that live on Cecil Street and Kirkwood Street. Where is everybody going to park? If you ever come out on a Sunday or the night that the club is open, they are bumper to bumper. She literally had to call the cops one night because they were blocking her driveway for her to get in and out. Not only does she live there, but she has an 82- year-old neighbor. They both use that paper alley and that is a paper alley that was not a regular alley. Her and her neighbor fought the City of Dover to get that paper alley paved because it was tearing our car up to get in and out of that alley. She has no disrespect for this gentleman behind her but he needs to do a little more research before he comes in says what he knows about that street. Maybe he needs to start going down to talk to the neighbors and the people that live on that street before he comes in and makes a comment. By the way, there are a bunch of people that don’t want to come to these meetings that sent her in here to speak up because they feel what they say doesn’t matter anyway. That is not fair to them because they live on that street. The little playground that he is talking about, nobody’s kids have played on that playground in 20 years since she has been there. There are drugs on our street, there are homeless people on our street, and there are all kinds of people on that street just like there is on any other street in Dover. Start investigating and start looking at more before you come in and say something that you don’t know nothing about.

Mr. Charles White (virtual) – Resident of N. Kirkwood Street Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. White typed in the chat online “What is being done regarding parking because parking is now at a minimum due to the new restaurant and the churches?” Responding to Mr. White, Mrs. Melson-William stated that with these townhouse units, each of them will have two off-street parking spaces. One in their driveway and one in the garage. There is certainly on-street parking which might be limited by proximity to the corner or not in front of the alley network that’s in that area. This project would be meeting its minimum parking requirements for those residential units.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. White has a second question. “Is the project a done deal or is it up for vote approval?” Responding to Mr. White, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that tonight is the Planning Commission’s opportunity to consider this Application and if they feel they have all of the information, will be making a decision on the request to establish these four townhouse lots and some recommendations regarding several waivers that need to go onto other reviews.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. White also asked one of the questions that Dr. Jones asked earlier. “Are these rental properties or purchased homes?” Responding to Mr. White, Mrs. Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 6 of 10 173

Paj 174

Item 2.

Melson-Williams stated that we did hear from the applicant/developer that it sounds like it could be one and/or the other depending on the future of how the project shapes up. If they are rental properties, there is a requirement for a Rental Dwelling Permit. It is an annual process with the City. But they likewise could sell each unit.

Mr. Donny Legans – owner of 92 N West Street and 112 N Water Street He is a resident of Dover and owns Rail Haus and the old Double Diamond Recycling Center next door as well. He is calling in to show his unwavering support for the proposed project located at 207 N West Street adjacent to those two properties. The plan to have more density and residents lines up perfectly with the mini plan circulating regarding our Downtown: Restoring Central Dover that was written back in 2015 and now the Master Plan 2030 Capital City Plan. The idea of giving homeowners a different style house, he thinks is a winning strategy for Downtown in general, especially Dover that needs this win. It’s just the different value that is placed on mixed use and the variety style housing that Mr. Llewellyn mentioned earlier. The idea that a young homeowner or young family looking for housing has the big mansions in Eden Hill versus coming right to Downtown. All of our elected officials think that having more diversity of housing, having more residents Downtown really just helps us all. He is very familiar, obviously, with the developers tied to this project and will say that Rail Haus was their Exhibit A for them and what they can do for Downtown. The truth is, they have a track record of choosing Downtown repeatedly whether it is the boutique shop on Loockerman Street or picking Reed Street as their company headquarters or bringing in one of the preeminent festivals to Loockerman Street every year. They consistently chose Dover. Rail Haus just happened to line up perfectly with what they already represented in the Downtown area. He is sure that their craftsmanship and attention to detail will immediately be felt and seen as the project gets off the ground. On a personal note, they picked him, this novice restaurant, several years ago when the prospect of opening a restaurant was bleak. It was right around COVID when they got tied into the project. This is a chance for him now to say very publicly how much of a gamble that was and they never wavered in that commitment through the entire process. The second thing that they are doing today which is the DAC, the PC, all of the public hearings and the meetings and then actually going to build this place and more sure it stands up to the test of time. They have done that consistently and they will continue to do it even before his project and now it’s great to see them not just building a restaurant Downtown that’s been an absolute success over the last 15 months but doubling back down and investing right across the street. He thinks it’s an amazing thing and it’s a treasure to have them around and still be around with this new project that’s going on.

He is glad that he gets to support them very publicly on this latest Downtown Dover property. He fully supports this project and he looks forward to seeing another vacant lot Downtown get new life. That was sort of his written remarks. Now as he listens to this, he will add that there are two parks less than a block away in either direction. He grew up in Los Angeles. He lived in Philadelphia for many years and one of the biggest selling points for living Downtown or living in these bustling places is how quickly people can get to green space. Like the neighbor mentioned earlier, no one goes to these parks and so we pay these in-lieu taxes to prop up these parks but then we also require the buildings to have green space behind it and recreation areas. But both can’t not co-exist, but you almost need people to go to these parks. You can go to a Dover park right there on Mary Street, literally a block away or go the other direction to the south on Division Street and S. Kirkwood Street where there is another fantastic basketball court/playground that his kids play at sometimes. It’s just having those places activated and used Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 7 of 10 174

Paj 175

Item 2.

by residents. He hopes that the neighbors understand that Rail Haus does a lot for the area. We give back an awful lot. He thinks that the lady that just spoke before him, she actually approached him before to be a vendor. On March 8, 2025, we have the Women’s Market and we would love to have your scarves that you showed me about a month and a half ago to be one of our vendors there.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. White made some more comments and she is going to see if he would like the opportunity to speak.

Mr. Charles White – 206 N. Kirkwood Street Dover, DE 19901 Mr. White stated that this house has been in his family since 1937. He just moved here from Los Angeles. He lived in Los Angeles for almost 47 years; so, he knows L.A. better than he knows Dover at this point in time. His problem is parking. He understands that the Planning Commission has a duty to prescribe and designate areas where the City can get the most revenue. That is their job; to produce revenue barring properties in the City. But we must also take into consideration the parking liabilities. He has not been to the Rail Haus but he drives by there almost every day and he commends the gentleman for bringing such a facility to Dover but parking for that facility is especially hard when church is in session. He doesn’t know any place in this world where a Planning Commission would put a Beer Garden in front of two of the most iconic black churches in the City. To build a Beer Garden right across the street is deplorable. He doesn’t know how the Planning Commission could have even thought of anything like that. But they did. When church is in session and the Beer Garden is in session, there is nowhere to park within two or three blocks. He knows that because he goes out of that street every day. The guy talked about the playgrounds that are on each ends of the street. He lived in L.A., he knows what a City block is and believe him, the playground is on Mary Street and Kirkwood Street is more than one block as well as the playground that is on the corner of Division Street and West Street. That is a long City block. What is the Planning Commission doing for parking? You said that the places will have two parking spaces. That is nothing. Everybody has got two cars and some people have three or four cars in a family. Those people are going to be parking on the street. You know it and I know it. They are going to be parking on the street, which is going to create more parking problems. Now, the Alley that is to his property leads into that paper alley that Bonnie talked about. He had to go through hell to get that place paved. He drives a BMW. Every day that he went out before that Alley was paved, his car scraped the ground. The Mayor got it paved for him and he appreciates that. That is the only access that he has for his property. There is no driveway in front off of Kirkwood Street. He has to use that paper alley to get into his back yard. Bonnie told you that I am 80 some years old and that is the only way he can get into his house. He has seen them spray painting for sewer or gas lines or whatever they are going to put in there already. He does plan for some sort of rebuttal program through a letter, through a sign- up to get people to sign up to oppose this unless some better parking problems can be made.

Responding to Mr. White, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that she thinks he touched on the additional comments that you had put in the chat noting that your property is accessed through that alley that comes in off of Cecil Street. There are several lots that are accessed from that rear alley at that location. Mr. White stated that is correct. Bonnie is one and there are two other houses to his north that use that paper alley to get in and out of their properties.

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 8 of 10 175

Paj 176

Item 2.

Mrs. Melson-Williams asked Mr. White if that concludes his comments. Responding to Mrs. Melson-Williams, Mr. White said that yes, it does. You might provide him with a list of addresses where he can write some letters or send some flyers to get a campaign started.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. White can reach out to the Planning Office tomorrow. Our contact information is on the meeting agenda or in that letter. They would be happy to talk about your questions.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Ms. Rachel Rigliano noted in the chat “Amen Reverend. Why does the Rail Haus need to be open on Sundays at the time you are having services?” Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that she doesn’t think that it is subject to the project before us this evening other than the parking concerns that have been voiced.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that she wanted to read the written correspondence that the Planning Office received today. Copies of these are provided on the Planning Commission members’ desks. The first one is from Mr. Donny Legans of the Rail Haus. It is dated November 17, 2024 but addressed to the Planning Committee. He writes “I am writing to show my support for the project located at 207 N. West Street adjacent to my warehouse and Rail Haus. The plan to move more residents and families to the area is great plus giving homeowners a different style of housing is a winning strategy. He is very familiar with the builders tied to this project and wishes that he could say Rail Haus is Exhibit A for them in what they do for Downtown. The truth is they have a tract record for choosing Downtown Dover over and over again. Whether it was a Boutique Clothing Shop or picking Reed Street as their company headquarters or bringing one of the preeminent festivals to Loockerman Street annually, they consistently chose Dover. Rail Haus just happens to align with what they already represented in the Downtown Area. They picked a novice restaurateur in me to back several years ago when the prospects were bleak. This is a chance for him to say very publicly how much of a gamble that was and they never wavered in their commitment throughout the entire build-out process. This just happens to be the one-year anniversary of Rail Haus opening this week (that was referring back to the November timeframe) and he is very fortunate that he gets to support them on their latest endeavor for Downtown Dover. I fully support this project and look forward to seeing another vacant lot Downtown get new life.” Some of those statements he also made this evening.

The second letter that they received was dated November 18, 2024 and it was from Theo Braunskill with the address of 91 N West Street. It reads “I believe I can speak for our community since I has been a part of this community for more than 70 years. Most of the homes here on the 500 block of Fulton Street are still occupied and owned by my immediate family like my daughter and her family, another daughter and her family, and my brother and his family. I personally own three homes here. Some others who live here are elders who have grandchildren and have lived here and some he has known for years. My grandparents built their home on Fulton Street in 1920. They raised their children here and their children grew up and had families who lived next door. As I have said, my family still owns most of the houses on the 500 block of Fulton Street. We are all very close to our other neighbors. We are all members of the Neighborhood Community Watch Program. They would appreciate new construction in our community that would house new families. Our community speaks family. We welcome families, we welcome children. Again, I support new construction and I support new family homes.”

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 9 of 10 176

Paj 177

Item 2.

Dr. Jones asked what income level they are hoping to attract for your for sale or for rent homes. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn stated that there are some guidelines for affordable housing but specifically his 23-year-old daughter and my 22-year-old son-in-law need to afford something that is around $1,800 to $2,000 a month and there is nothing out there for that that is pleasant to look at. That is where this whole project has come from. We are trying to have our adult children not move back into our house and this is an opportunity here. If you are looking for his secret motivation, that’s it.

Dr. Jones stated that they are probably college trained. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. Llewellyn stated yes, they are.

Mrs. Denney closed the public hearing.

Mr. Lewis moved to recommend approval to the City Council for application C-25-01 Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 N. West Street and the Minor Subdivision Plan with the Waivers for the Alley requirement and the Waiver for the Rear Emergency Access. As for the Cash-in-Lieu, he doesn’t think that we can do anything about it at this meeting.

Responding, Mrs. Melson-Williams noted that you can make an initial recommendation on it and we can bring that aspect back to you. Technically, we have to bring the formal amount back to you anyway in the future. You may want to note in your motion that that aspect of the project is still under consideration by the Parks and Recreation Committee.

Mr. Lewis stated that hearing that, in addition to the Subdivision Waivers for the Alley requirement and the requirement for the Rear Emergency Access, he will move that we move forward with the Cash-in-Lieu in expectation of hearing more about it at a later date. Seconded by Dr. Jones and the motion was carried 4-1 by roll call vote with Mr. Roach, Mr. Baldwin, Mrs. Welsh and Mr. Witham absent. Mr. Lewis voting yes; for reasons that have been stated. His main issue with coming in here was the Alley requirement and the Emergency Access and seeing that the Fire Marshal is backing the sprinkler option, he will vote yes to move forward. He also has an Alley in the back of his house and he hopes that he never sees an emergency vehicle behind it but he is glad that it’s there. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; based on DAC comments. Dr. Jones voting yes; she thinks it’s a welcomed addition to the neighborhood. She is still wrestling with the vertical siding. Mr. Reaves voting no; based on the parking issue that it is going to create for the community and also the access issues that it is going to potentially create. Mrs. Denney voting yes; she thinks that it is in keeping with what we desire to do as we move forward there, with what the Comprehensive Plan and what the plan for the future is and she thinks that it’s a step forward on that street. She fully understands the comments that were made this evening about Rail Haus and the parking; however, that was meetings ago when there were opportunities to make decisions with regard to that and we are not addressing that this evening. Also, with the DAC comments, she thinks this is a good project and we should move forward with it.

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of February 18, 2025 Page 10 of 10 177

Paj 178

Item 1.

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

ACTION FORM

PROCEEDING: Council Committee of the Whole (Utility Committee) DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Water & Wastewater SUBMITTED ON: February 14, 2025 PREPARED BY: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services REVIEWED BY: David S. Hugg, III, City Manager and Patricia M. Marney, Controller / Treasurer

SUBJECT: The Edge at Dover Impact Fee Request TIMETABLE: Provide decision to Metropolitan Development Group within seven (7) days of Council direction. RELATED PROJECT: X REFERENCE: X

EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $0

AMOUNT BUDGETED: $0

FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): N/A

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Continue to follow precedent with previous projects and collect 1 equivalent dwelling unit (EDU)for each apartment unit. The Metropolitan Development Group is still subject to any Kent County Impact Fees for wastewater.

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:

The Metropolitan Development Group is constructing The Edge at Dover apartment complex, located on Leipsic Road. This apartment complex will provide 108 one-bedroom apartments and 108 two-bedroom apartments for a total of 216 units. Per Section 110-207.a.1; apartments with one kitchen and one or more baths and bedrooms will be issued 1.0 EDU each. For 216 units, the total cost of EDU’s would be $1,582,200. Of this amount, $683,856 would be owed to Kent County and cannot be negotiated. Therefore, $898,344 would be attributed to the City of Dover water and wastewater fund. Per Section 110-207.e: Maximum assignment. For projects that have a significant impact on the city's utility, city council may consider a maximum assignment of EDUs. A project will be considered to have a significant impact if it will contribute in excess of 100 EDUs. In these cases, city council may reduce the number of assigned EDUs to as low as 100 EDUs if an economic benefit to the City of Dover is demonstrated. Any request that will contribute less than 100 EDUs will not be eligible for a reduction. Maximum assignment of EDUs in excess of 100 EDUs will only apply to projects or

178

Paj 179

Item 1.

connections with building permits issued after July 28, 2014. Any project with a building permit issued prior to July 28, 2014, will be subject to a maximum assignment of no more than 100 EDUs. The Metropolitan Development Group is requesting a reduction in EDU’s for this project. Enclosed is a reduction request letter along with a revenue analysis provided by a Land Planning Consultant. Staff recommends that City Council follow precedent with previous projects and collect one (1) EDU for each apartment unit. The Metropolitan Development Group is still subject to any Kent County Impact Fees for wastewater.

179

Paj 180

Item 1.

FUTURE SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN 5400 LIMESTONE ROAD

NORTH THE EDGE AT DOVER NORTH RO FOCUSED WILMINGTON, DE 19808-1232

TEL. 302.239.6634 RO AD AD PEOPLE FAX 302.239.8485 LE C IP SI SI IP C LE

NT NT
PO PO
DU DU
P.E. #21140
W
AY

KENNETH JAMES TAYLOR, JR., P.E.
GH W
HI GH
AY HI
05/15/2024

STATE: DELAWARE LOCATION MAP SCALE: 1" = 400' BUILDING 1 3 STORY APARTMENT BUILDING 2 BUILDING 3 BUILDING 4 LOCATION MAP SCALE: 1" = 1200' 3 STORY APARTMENT 3 STORY APARTMENT 3 STORY APARTMENT BUILDING BUILDING GENERAL NOTES: BUILDING BUILDING 36 UNITS 36 UNITS SITE DATA: 36 UNITS 36 UNITS 14,900 SF (44,700 GSF) 14,900 SF (44,700 GSF) 14,600 SF (44,700 GSF) 14,900 SF (44,700 GSF) 1. ALL CONSTRUCTION SHALL BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE STATE OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY LAWS AND THE CITY OF DOVER 1. APPLICATION NUMBER: S-22-09

CHK'D BYDESIGNED BY: CHECKED BY: CODE AND STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS, MOST CURRENT EDITION. ALL CONSTRUCTION MUST BE DONE IN COMPLIANCE

PROJECT NO.
2. TAX PARCEL NO./ ED-05-068.05-01-15.01-000

DRAWN BY:

WITH THE OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ACT OF 1970 AND ALL RULES AND REGULATIONS THERETO APPURTENANT. SOURCE OF TITLE/ D10045-286 ZONING: SC-2, SWPOZ TIER 3 2. EXISTING UTILITIES ARE SHOWN FOR THE CONVENIENCE OF THE CONTRACTOR, BUT THE COMPLETENESS OF ACCURACY 14286 OF THE SAME IS NOT GUARANTEED. THE CONTRACTOR SHALL DETERMINE THE LOCATION AND ELEVATION OF EXISTING OC 3. LEGAL OWNER / DEVELOPER: METROPOLITAN 8, LLC JOHN RATHFON 2001 STATE HILL ROAD, SUITE 205 METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT GROUP MH M AP TC O R

UTILITIES AT HIS OWN EXPENSE. THE CONTRACTOR SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL DAMAGES AND REPAIRS TO EXISTING JTF KJT WYOMISSING, PA 19610 2001 STATE HILL ROAD, SUITE 205 UTILITIES DURING CONSTRUCTION. PHONE: 610-755-1778 x 3005 WYOMISSING, PA 19610

REVISION PER DNREC COMMENTS DATED EV EV

KJT

PHONE: 610-755-1778 x 3005 DATE 3. THE EXISTING UTILITIES SHOWN WERE TAKEN FROM THE BEST AVAILABLE RECORDS. THE CONTRACTOR SHALL CONTACT

9/20/23 & ODW COMMENTS DATED 10/05/23 10/09/2023

MISS UTILITY OF DELMARVA (1-800-282-8555) TO VERIFY THEIR EXACT LOCATION PRIOR TO THE START OF ANY 4. SITE ADDRESS: LEIPSIC ROAD SWM DOVER, DE 19901 CONSTRUCTION. ANY DAMAGE INCURRED TO ANY UTILITIES SHALL BE REPAIRED IMMEDIATELY AT THE CONTRACTORS' FACILITY # 4- REVISION PER KCD COMMENTS AR/KJT EXPENSE. IF THE CONTRACTOR RELIES ON THE UTILITY LOCATIONS SHOWN HEREON, HE DOES SO AT HIS OWN RISK AND 5. ZONING: EXISTING: WILL NOT BE ENTITLED TO ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION DUE TO THE DELAYS FROM SAID RELIANCE. 0.13 ± AC. BUILDING 5 BUILDING 7 SC-2 (COMMUNITY SHOPPING CENTER)

DATED 09/08/2023 3 STORY APARTMENT 10/30/2023 3 STORY APARTMENT SWPOZ (SOURCE WATER PROTECTION OVERLAY ZONE TIER 3 4. A FINAL TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY LETTER WAS RECEIVED BY VERDANTAS FROM DELDOT ON NOVEMBER 11, 2022. BUILDING BUILDING EXCELLENT RECHARGE AREA) 36 UNITS REVISION PER KCD COMMENTS 36 UNITS 3.28+/- AC ARE LOCATED WITHIN THE SWPOZ AR/KJT 5. ALL ROADS, PARKING AND OTHER PAVED AREAS WILL BE PRIVATELY OWNED AND MAINTAINED AND ARE NOT INTENDED 14,900 SF (44,700 GSF) 14,900 SF (44,700 GSF) SWM PROPOSED: SC-2, SWPOZ FOR DEDICATION. DATED 11/16/2023 FACILITY #2- 12/4/2023 6. PROPERTY USE: EXISTING VACANT 6. DELAWARE REGULATIONS PROHIBIT THE BURIAL OF CONSTRUCTION DEMOLITION DEBRIS, INCLUDING TREES AND STUMPS 0.30 ± AC. PROPOSED APARTMENT COMPLEX

REVISION PER KCD COMMENTS KJT ON CONSTRUCTION SITES. ANY SOLID WASTES FOUND DURING EXCAVATION MUST BE REMOVED AND PROPERLY

REVISION 7. SITE ACREAGE: EXISTING 15.00± ACRES (653,615± SF) DISPOSED. DATED 03/04/2024 PROPOSED 15.00± ACRES (653,615± SF) 7. THIS SITE IS LOCATED FULLY WITHIN A SOURCE WATER PROTECTION OVERLAY ZONE (SWPOZ) - TIER 3 EXCELLENT 8. LIMIT OF DISTURBANCE: 15.00± ACRES 03/04/2024

REVISION PER RFI #1, 2, 3 RECHARGE AREA. A WETLAND EVALUATION WAS CONDUCTED BY DUFFIELD ASSOCIATES IN JUNE 2017 AND NO WETLANDS SWM FACILITY #3- 9. SC-2 ZONING (C-4) REQUIREMENTS: DPM/KJT WERE FOUND ON THE SITE. NO FLOODPLAINS WERE FOUND ON SITE. DATED 04/24/2024 AND 04/26/2024 0.44 ± AC. 04/30/2024 8. ALL HANDICAPPED PARKING DEMARCATION, STALLS AND BUILDINGS ACCESSIBLE ROUTES SHALL COMPLY WITH THE REQUIRED PROPOSED MIN. LOT WIDTH 150 FT 1,195 FT

REVISION PER CALL WITH DEPARTMENT OF

AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT AND ANSI A117.1-1998 ACCESSIBLE AND USABLE BUILDINGS AND FACILITIES. DPM/KJT MIN. LOT DEPTH 150 FT 518.5 FT 9. BEFORE THE CONTRACTOR CAN BEGIN CONSTRUCTION, HE MUST OBTAIN THE PROPER PERMITS AND/OR APPROVALS MIN. FRONT YARD 20 FT 89 FT PUBLIC WORKS DATED 05/07/24 05/15/24 MIN. SIDE YARD 15 FT 101 FT FROM THE CITY OF DOVER, KENT CONSERVATION (KCD), DELAWARE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION (DELDOT), AND MIN. REAR YARD 10 FT OR BUILDING HEIGHT 76 FT OTHER APPROPRIATE FEDERAL, STATE, CITY, AND COUNTY AGENCIES. MIN. BUILDING SETBACK 50 FT (NONRESIDENTIAL ZONE) 89 FT No. 10. ALL CONSTRUCTION METHODS AND MATERIALS SHALL BE ACCORDING TO THE CITY OF DOVER AND DELDOT STANDARDS MAX. BUILDING HEIGHT 75', 6 STORIES 35', 3 STORIES 4 5 6 7 8 9- MAX. IMPERVIOUS COVERAGE 75%/60%* 61%/ 58% AND CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS. *60% MAXIMUM IMPERVIOUS COVERAGE IN SWPOZ TIER 3 ZONE, PROPOSED COVERAGE 58% 11. ALL FIRE LANES, FIRE HYDRANTS, AND FIRE DEPARTMENT CONNECTIONS SHALL BE MARKED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE 10. SITE COVERAGE: STATE FIRE PREVENTION REGULATIONS. EXISTING OPEN SPACE 577,436± SF (13.26± AC) 88.4% WOODS 13,200± SF (0.30± AC) 2.02% 12. ALL WORK WITHIN STATE MAINTAINED ROAD RIGHT-OF-WAYS SHALL MEET THE REQUIREMENTS AS SET FORTH IN THE 100' 0 100' 200' BUILDINGS 0± SF (0.00± AC) 0.0% CURRENT REVISION OF THE STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS FOR THE ROAD AND BRIDGE CONSTRUCTION, BY THE DELAWARE GRAVEL 48,765± SF (1.12± AC) 7.47% SHEET INDEX DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION (DELDOT). ASPHALT 14,106 ± SF (0.32± AC) 2.13% C-001 INDEX SHEET DRAWING SCALE 1" = 100'

EAST DOVER HUNDRED~CITY OF DOVER~KENT COUNTY~DELAWARE TOTAL 653,615± SF (15.00± AC) 100.0% 13. TRAFFIC AND SAFETY CONTROL SHALL BE MAINTAINED DURING CONSTRUCTION IN CONFORMANCE WITH THE CURRENT C-101 EXISTING FEATURES / DEMOLITION PLAN VERSION OF THE DELAWARE MANUAL ON UNIFORM TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES (DE MUTCD) FOR CONSTRUCTION AND C-201 - C-202 SITE PLAN PROPOSED OPEN SPACE 246,686± SF (5.66± AC) 37.7% MAINTENANCE OPERATIONS. C-301 UTILITY PLAN OVERALL WOODS 6,185± SF (0.14± AC) 0.9% BUILDINGS 117,855± SF (2.71± AC) 18.1% 14. ALL PROPOSED SIGNS (PYLON SIGNS, MONUMENT SIGNS) ARE SUBJECT TO A SEPARATE CITY OF DOVER PERMIT AND IS C-302 UTILITY PLAN OTHER IMPERVIOUS 282,889 SF (6.49± AC) 43.3% ALSO SUBJECT TO A COMPREHENSIVE UNIFIED SIGN PLAN. C-303 UTILITY PLAN TOTAL 653,615± SF (15.0± AC) 100.0% 15. STORMWATER MANAGEMENT SEDIMENT/EROSION CONTROL SHALL BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CURRENT DELAWARE C-304 STORM SEWER SCHEDULES 11. BUILDINGS: EXISTING VACANT SEDIMENT AND STORMWATER REGULATIONS BY THE DELAWARE DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND C-305 - C-310 STORM DRAIN PROFILES PROPOSED 6 APARTMENT BUILDINGS (216 UNITS): 89,400 SF ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL (DNREC). C-311 - C-312 SANITARY SEWER PROFILES 1 CLUBHOUSE: 4,900 SF 11 GARAGES: 17,243 SF

THE EDGE AT DOVER C-401 GRADING PLAN OVERALL 16. CONTRACTOR SHALL REFER TO ARCHITECTURAL/STRUCTURAL DRAWINGS OF PROPOSED BUILDING FOOTPRINTS. THE C-402 - C-403 GRADING PLAN 12. PARKING: APARTMENT- 2.25 SPACES PER UNIT REQUIRED (216 * 2.25 = 486) PROPOSED BUILDING FOOTPRINTS, AS SHOWN ON SITE PLAN, SHOULD ONLY BE USED AS A REFERENCE TO THE C-500 COVERSHEET AND GENERAL NOTES SPACES PROVIDED = 428 ABOVEMENTIONED PLANS. C-501 PRE-CONSTRUCTION SITE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN PARKING SPACES = 373 GARAGE SPACES = 55 17. WATER SUPPLY, SANITARY SEWER, AND STORM DRAIN LINES PROPOSED BY THIS PLAN ARE PRIVATE AND SHALL BE C-502 CONSTRUCTION SITE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN REQUIRED ADA SPACES= 9 SPACES (1 VAN ACCESSIBLE) MAINTAINED BY THE OWNER. C-503 - C-508 EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL DETAILS PROVIDED ADA SPACES= 14 VAN ACCESSIBLE SPACES 18. THE SITE CONTRACTOR SHALL NOTIFY THE CITY OF DOVER DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AT 302-736-7025 48 HOURS C-509 OVERALL POST CONSTRUCTION STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION GRANTED APPROVAL OF A WAIVER REQUEST ON C-510 POST CONSTRUCTION STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN, FACILITY #2

INDEX SHEET

PRIOR TO THE START OF CONSTRUCTION. A REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE CITY OF DOVER DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS JUNE 21, 2022 TO REDUCE THE PARKING REQUIREMENT FROM 486 VEHICLE MUST OBSERVE AND APPROVE ALL CITY OWNED WATER AND SANITARY SEWER INTERCONNECTIONS AND TESTING. ALL C-511 POST CONSTRUCTION STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN, FACILITY #2 DETAILS PARKING PACES TO TO 428 VEHICLE PARKING SPACES. WATER TAPS MUST BE PERFORMED BY A CITY OF DOVER APPROVED CONTRACTOR. THE PROPOSED LOCATION FOR THE C-512 POST CONSTRUCTION STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN, FACILITY #3 C-513 POST CONSTRUCTION STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN, FACILITY #3 DETAILS 13. ACTIVE RECREATION: 275 SF OF AREA REQUIRED PER UNIT (216 UNITS x 275 REQ'D SF = 59,400 SF) WATER CONNECTION MAY NEED TO BE ADJUSTED IN THE FIELD DUE TO CONDITIONS OF THE EXISTING MAIN. POSSIBLE AREA PROVIDED = 54,000 SF CONDITIONS THAT WOULD REQUIRE TAPPING RELOCATION INCLUDE PROXIMITY TO PIPE JOINTS, OTHER TAPS, CONCRETE C-514 POST CONSTRUCTION STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN, FACILITY #4 DEFICIT = 5,937 SF ENCASEMENTS, CONFLICT WITH OTHER UTILITIES, AND THE LIKE. TEST HOLES MUST BE PERFORMED BY THE CONTRACTOR C-515 POST CONSTRUCTION STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN, FACILITY #4 DETAILS ACTIVE RECREATION PATH 15,990 SF TO DETERMINE THE BEST TAPPING LOCATION OR FOR ANY WORK REQUIRED BY THE CONTRACTOR TO MAKE AN C-601 SIGNAGE & STRIPING PLAN CLUBHOUSE BLOCK 34,110 SF C-901 - C-907 CONSTRUCTION DETAILS DOG PARK 3,900 SF APPROPRIATE AND LAWFUL CONNECTION. L-1 LANDSCAPE PLAN CASH-IN-LIEU OF ACTIVE RECREATION AREA CONSTRUCTION DONATION IN THE 19. PART II, CHAPTER 180, ARTICLE III, SECTION 180-10 OF THE CODE OF KENT COUNTY REQUIRES THAT "NO PERSON SHALL L-2 - L-3 LANDSCAPE DETAILS AND NOTES AMOUNT OF $17,713.31 WAS APPROVED BY THE PARKS, RECREATION AND DISCHARGE OR CAUSE TO BE DISCHARGED ANY STORMWATER, SURFACE WATER, UNCONTAMINATED GROUNDWATER, LT-101 LIGHTING PLAN COMMUNITY ENCHANCEMENT COMMITTEE ON MARCH 14, 2023 AND THE PLANNING ROOF RUNOFF, SUBSURFACE DRAINAGE, UNCONTAMINATED NONCONTACT COOLING WATER OR UNPOLLUTED INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION ON APRIL 17, 2023. FM-101 FIRE MARSHAL PLAN PROCESS WATERS TO ANY SANITARY SEWER", THIS SHALL INCLUDE CONDESATE. SECTION 11-231 OF THE CITY OF DOVER CODE DEFINES STORM SEWER AS "ANY SYSTEM USED FOR CONVEYING RAIN WATER, SURFACE WATER, CONDENSATE, 14. BICYCLE PARKING 1 SPACE REQ'D FOR EVERY 20 PARKING SPACES (428 SPACES / 20 = 21.4) OWNER / DEVELOPER'S PLAN DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL BICYCLE SPACES PROVIDED= 102 COOLING WATER OR SIMILAR LIQUID WASTES, EXCLUSIVE OF SEWAGE." THE CONTRACTOR, DEVELOPER, OWNER AND DESIGNERS SHALL ENSURE DURING CONSTRUCTION THAT NO ILLEGAL DISCHARGES TO THE SANITARY SEWER SYSTEM 15. SOURCE OF WATER: CITY OF DOVER ARE CREATED WITH THE SITE IMPROVEMENTS. I JOHN RATHFON, HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I AM THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED 16. SOURCE OF SEWER: CITY OF DOVER AND SHOWN ON THIS PLAN, THAT THE PLAN WAS MADE AT MY DIRECTION, AND THAT I LEGEND: 17. SOURCE OF ELECTRIC: CITY OF DOVER 20. BOUNDARY AND TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY DATA SHOWN HERE WAS PREPARED BY TRANSITION ENGINEERING SURVEYING IN 18. SOURCE OF GAS: CHESAPEAKE UTILITIES ACKNOWLEDGE THE SAME TO ME BY ACT AND DESIRE THE PLAN TO BE DEVELOPED AS PR. RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE 19. TRASH COLLECTION: PRIVATE DECEMBER 2016. PR. PROPERTY LINE SHOWN AND IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL APPLICABLE LAWS AND REGULATIONS. 21. IF THE APPROVED PLAN NEEDS TO BE MODIFIED, ADDITIONAL SEDIMENT AND STORMWATER CONTROL MEASURES MAY BE PR. BENCHMARK 20. DUMPSTER REQUIREMENT: APARTMENT COMPLEX- 2 FOR FIRST 48 UNITS; THEN 1 PER EACH PR. BUILDING SETBACK LINE ADDITIONAL 24 UNITS (2 + (216-48) / 24= 9) REQUIRED AS DEEMED NECESSARY BY THE KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT. PR. PAVING SETBACK LINE 5/15/2024 __________________________________________ DUMPSTERS REQUIRED = 9 (216 UNITS) 22. THE KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT RESERVES THE RIGHT TO ENTER PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR PURPOSES OF PERIODIC PR. EASEMENT LINE DUMPSTERS PROVIDED= 9 SITE INSPECTION. DATE JOHN RATHFON, OWNER PR. BUILDINGS (6 PROVIDED, 3 FOR RESERVE) METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT GROUP 21. BENCHMARK: CAPPED REBAR FND. #51 23. ALL OPEN SPACES AND STORMWATER MANAGEMENT FACILITIES SHALL BE MAINTAINED BY THE PROPERTY OWNER WITH PR. FENCES 1243 EASTON ROAD, SUITE 205 ELEVATION = 24.92' THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE MAINTENANCE TO BEGIN AT THE COMPLETION OF THE PROJECT UPON FINAL ACCEPTANCE BY PR. ON-SITE CURB N: 430719.51' E: 624676.32' THE CITY, DELOT, AND KCD. IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE CONTRACTOR TO MAINTAIN THE STORMWATER WARRINGTON, PA 18976 PR. ON-SITE ASPHALT 22. DATUM: HORIZONTAL: NAD 83 DE STATE PLANE GRID MANAGEMENT FACILITIES UNTIL THE PROPERTY OWNER TAKES OVER RESPONSIBILITY OF THE MAINTENANCE. VERTICAL: N.A.V.D. 88 PR. ON-SITE CONCRETE 24. ANY GAS FIRED HVAC EQUIPMENT MUST BE EQUIPPED WITH EMERGENCY CUT OFF SWITCHES REMOTELY LOCATED. 23. TREE PLANTING CALCULATIONS SITE AREA: 653,515 SF (15.00 +/- AC) 25. ADDRESS NUMBERS OF AT LEAST 12 INCHES IN HEIGHT MUST BE PLACED ON THE STREET SIDE OF THE BUILDING VISIBLE REQUIRED PLANTINGS: 218 TREES CERTIFICATION OF ACCURACY PR. ON-SITE GRAVEL PROVIDED PLANTINGS: 218 TREES FROM THE STREET, 2 REQUIRED. PR. ON-SITE STRIPING 26. ANY NATURAL OR LP GAS BOTTLES, METERS, REGULATORS, ETC. MUST HAVE IMPACT PROTECTION. I, KENNETH JAMES TAYLOR, JR., P.E., HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I AM A APPLICATION NO. S-22-09 PR. RIPRAP REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER WITH A BACKGROUND IN CIVIL KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT NOTES: ENGINEERING IN THE STATE OF DELAWARE, THAT THE INFORMATION PR. OFF-SITE CURB DATE:

MAY 6, 2022 SHOWN HERON HAS BEEN PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION AND TO PR. OFF-SITE ASPHALT 1. IF THE APPROVED PLAN NEEDS TO BE MODIFIED DUE TO ERRORS, OMISSIONS, OR FIELD CONDITIONS, THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF REPRESENTS GOOD ENGINEERING PRACTICES AS REQUIRED BY THE APPLICABLE LAWS OF PR. OFF-SITE CONCRETE ADDITIONAL SEDIMENT AND STORMWATER CONTROL MEASURES MAY BE REQUIRED AS DEEMED THE STATE OF DELAWARE. SCALE: NECESSARY BY THE KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT. PR. OFF-SITE GRAVEL 1" = 100' 2. THE KENT CONSERVATION DISTRICT (KCD) RESERVES THE RIGHT TO ENTER PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR 5/15/2024 __________________________________ PURPOSES OF PERIODIC SITE INSPECTION. DATE KENNETH JAMES TAYLOR, JR., P.E. PR. MAINTENANCE ACCESS PATH SHEET:

C-001 3. THE OWNER IS RESPONSIBLE FOR PROPER OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF THE STORMWATER REGISTRATION #21140 SITE BENCHMARK MANAGEMENT FACILITIES ON SITE. BM 51

180

Paj 181

Item 1.

Metropolitan 8, LLC
2001 State Hill Road Suite 205
Wyomissing, PA 19610

December 30, 2024

Jason Lyons
City of Dover Department of Water and Wastewater
Weyandt Hall
5 E. Reed St.
Dover, DE 19901

Re: EDU Reduction Request – The Edge at Dover

Dear Mr. Lyon,

Please accept the enclosed as our formal request for a reduction in EDUs, in accordance with City of Dover Ordinance Section 110-207, Establishment of Equivalent Dwelling Units, (e) Maximum Assignment. As a reminder, The Edge at Dover is a newly developed 216-unit community consisting of six 36-unit apartment buildings and a clubhouse.

As per the attached Revenue Analysis by David Babbitt & Associates, the total projected annual revenue for the community is $234,060, generated from the following sources: • $109,608 City total revenue • $12,542 County property tax revenue • $5,876 Voc-Tech property tax revenue • $106,034 Capital School District property tax revenue

Metropolitan is excited to add The Edge at Dover to our portfolio of high-end, well- managed rental properties. Beyond the specific revenue outlined above, this development will indirectly impact the local community by fostering business growth and offering much- needed, high-quality housing for the workforce. As the long-term owner and manager of this property, we are dedicated to optimizing resources for management, maintenance, and amenities to enhance the tenant experience. Reducing EDU fees per Maximum Assignment would significantly support this goal.

We appreciate your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

Chris Stumpo
Development Project Manager
Metropolitan Development Group

181

Paj 182

DAVID C. BABBITT & ASSOCIATES, LLC Item 1.
Land Planning Consultants
P.O. Box 922 • Frazer, PA 19355-0922
610-651-5717 • david@babbittplanning.com

December 8, 2024

Mr. Christopher Stumpo Via email to cstumpo@mmgapts.com
Development Project Manager
Metropolitan Companies
500 Office Center Drive, Suite 200
Fort Washington, PA 19034

Re: Revenue Analysis
The Edge at Dover
City of Dover, Kent County, Delaware

Dear Chris:

As you requested, I have prepared this revenue analysis for the proposed Edge at Dover development. The proposed development involves 108 one bedroom apartments and 108 two bedroom apartments, for a total of 216 rental apartments. The annual revenue is projected to total $234,060, or $1,084 per unit, as shown in the table at the end of this report.

Assessments

The projected assessed value of the proposed rental apartments is based on three comparable apartment complexes constructed since 2006 in the City of Dover, as shown in the table below with data from the City Assessment Office database.

NameAddressBuiltAssessmentUnitsper Unit
Cannon & Westover105 Katrina Way2006$12,063,200120$100,527
Village at Blue Hen400 Haslet Street2010$35,842,700354$101,251
Leander Lakes100 Isabelle Isle2016$24,571,900240$102,383
TOTALS$72,477,800714$101,510

The average assessment of these 714 units is $101,510, which is applied to the 216 units at the proposed Edge at Dover to determine the projected assessment of $21,926,057. This projected assessment represents 0.6 percent of the total taxable assessment of the City of $3,555,093,900, according to the 2024-2025 City Operating Budget.

Annual City Revenue

Property Tax

The annual property tax revenue is determined by applying the City’s current tax rate of $0.4550 per $100 of assessed valuation (according to the City’s web site) to the projected $21,926,057 assessed value of the proposed development. The annual property tax revenue is projected to total $99,764.

182

Paj 183

Edge At Dover Revenue Analysis -2- December 8, 2024 Item 1.

Franchise Fee Revenue

The annual franchise fee revenue is determined by dividing the current budgeted revenue of $600,000 by the 16,364 housing units in the City of Dover (according to the 2022 American Community Survey of the U.S. Census Bureau) for a per unit revenue of $36.71, which is then applied to the 216 units in the proposed development. The annual franchise fee revenue is projected to total $7,929.

Recreation Revenue

The annual recreation revenue is determined by dividing the current budgeted revenue of $145,000 by the 16,364 housing units in the City for a per unit revenue of $8.87, which is then applied to the 216 units in the proposed development. The annual franchise fee revenue is projected to total $1,916.

Total City Revenue

The annual Township revenue from all sources is projected to total $109,608.

Please note that this analysis focuses on revenue sources within the City’s General Fund, and excludes revenue for water, wastewater, electricity, etc., which are handled by other City funds.

Annual County Tax Revenue

The annual property tax revenue is determined by applying the County’s current tax rate of $0.0572 per $100 of assessed valuation to the projected $21,926,057 assessed value of the proposed development. The annual County property tax revenue is projected to total $12,542.

Annual Voc-Tech Tax Revenue

The annual property tax revenue is determined by applying the Voc-Tech current tax rate of $0.0268 per $100 of assessed valuation to the projected $21,926,057 assessed value of the proposed development. The annual Voc-Tech property tax revenue is projected to total $5,876.

Annual Capital School District Tax Revenue

The annual school property tax revenue is determined by applying the Capital School District’s current tax rate of $0.4836 per $100 of assessed valuation to the projected $21,926,057 assessed value of the proposed development. The annual school property tax revenue is projected to total $106,034.

Annual Total Revenue

The annual revenue from all sources is projected to total $234,060, or $1,084 per unit.

I hope this information is helpful. Please feel free to contact me should you have any questions.

Sincerely,

David C. Babbitt, AICP
President

183

Paj 184

Item 1.

Revenue Analysis Proposed Edge at Dover Development December 8, 2024 Annual City Revenue Tax Rate per $100 or Revenue per unit Annual Revenue

Annual City Property Tax Revenue $0.4550 $99,764

Annual City Franchise Fee Revenue $36.71 $7,929

Annual City Recreation Revenue $8.87 $1,916

Subtotal Annual City Revenue $109,608

Annual County Property Tax Revenue $0.0572 $12,542

Annual Voc-Tech Property Tax Revenue $0.0268 $5,876

Annual School District Property Tax Revenue $0.4836 $106,034

Total Annual Revenue$234,060
Total Annual Revenue Per Unit$1,084

184

Paj 185

ACTION FORM

Item 1.

PROCEEDING: CCOW/ Legislative, Finance and Administration Committee DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: City Manager’s Office DATE SUBMITTED: 2/18/25 PREPARED BY: David S. Hugg III, City Manager SUBJECT: Solicitation/RFQ for City Solicitor REFERENCE: City Charter: Part 1-Charter and Related Laws, Subpart A - Charter; ;Article V, Miscellaneous Provisions; Section#54-City Solicitor RELATED PROJECT: n/a REVIEWED BY: Gerald Rocha and William Garfinkel and Dan Shevock (subcommittee members) EXHIBITS: Draft RFQ and schedule for posting and publication EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: n/a AMOUNT BUDGETED: n/a FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): n/a TIMETABLE: Immediate STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Forward to Council, publish RFQ ASAP

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS

The City Charter (noted above) provides for the annual appointment of a solicitor and sets requirements, therefore. The current Solicitor has indicated a desire to not be reappointed, hence the need to publish a Request for Qualifications from interested qualified attorneys who meet the requirements set forth in Section #54.

CCOW/ Legislative, Finance and Administration Committee recommendation and ultimately Council approval of the Request for Qualifications (RFQ) is necessary to develop a list of potential designees and their consideration. The RFQ sets forth the charter provisions, the requirements and duties of the Solicitor, the form of the submission package, the recruitment process and schedule (to be determined by the Council), contact for inquiries, and FRQ submissions.

The CCOW/LF&A action is review and recommendation to council along with suggested schedule.

RFQ publication schedule:

  • •Publish advertisement of the opening/availability of the RFQ in the Sunday edition of the Delaware State News twice in March 2025
  • •Post on the City of Dover website for the entire month of March 2025
  • •Send RFQ to solicitors representing other Delaware municipalities (based on DLLG list)
  • •Post on the Delaware State Bar Association website or other legal listing website (as allowed)

Staff recommends approval.

185

Paj 186

Item 1.

CITY SOLICITOR CITY OF DOVER REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS

The City of Dover (“City”) is issuing a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) to identify and retain a City Solicitor to represent the City. As a Charter position, the City Solicitor is the Chief legal counsel to the City, which includes the City Council, Mayor, the City Manager, various City departments, and various City Boards and Commissions. The successful candidate will be hired as an independent contractor of the City. This is an exciting opportunity to work on a variety of important issues facing “the Capital of the First State” as it continues to maintain its charm consistent with the needs of its residents, property owners, businesses, and visitors.

CITY SOLICITOR - Code of the City of Dover – Charter; Part 1 – CHARTER AND RELATED LAWS; Subpart A – CHARTER; ARTICLE V. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS; Section #54 – City solicitor.

“At the annual meeting the council shall elect a city solicitor for the term of one year or until their successor has been duly chosen and qualified.

The city solicitor may be removed during their term by a vote of three-fourths of the members elected to the council.

The city solicitor shall be an attorney at law who shall have practiced in the State of Delaware for at least five (5) years. The city solicitor shall be the chief legal adviser of and attorney for the city. It shall be the city solicitor's duty, either personally or by such assistants as they may designate, to attend meetings of the council; to give advice in writing, when so requested, to the council or the city manager; to prosecute or defend, as the case may be, all suits or cases to which the city may be a party; to prosecute for all offenses against the ordinances of the city and for such offenses against the laws of the state as may be required of them by law; to prepare all contracts, bonds and other instruments in writing in which the city is concerned, and to endorse on each their approval of the form and correctness thereof; and to perform such other duties of a legal nature as the council may by ordinance require. In addition to the duties imposed upon the solicitor by this Charter or required of the city solicitor by ordinance or resolution of the council they shall perform any duties imposed upon the chief legal officers of municipalities by law.

At the annual meeting the council shall elect a deputy city solicitor for the term of one year or until their successor has been duly chosen and qualified. The deputy city solicitor shall be an attorney-at-law entitled to practice law in the State of Delaware and shall serve in such manner as shall be determined by the city solicitor to be necessary and proper.”

The Solicitor shall make (a) recommendations of qualified individuals, and shall provide resumes and qualification for such appointment. to the Council for consideration as

1
186

Paj 187

Item 1.

Deputy Solicitor.

REQUIREMENTS AND DUTIES:

  • •The City Solicitor is selected by and is evaluated by the City Council of the City of Dover (“Council”), The Solicitor shall report to the Council President. The Solicitor serves at the pleasure of the Council for an annual appointment for a period of one year commencing after the annual City meeting.
  • •The City Solicitor shall be a member in good standing of the Delaware Bar and be licensed to practice law before all state Courts in the State of Delaware and the Federal District having jurisdiction over Delaware (or eligible to be admitted to practice before the Federal District Court as soon as practicable).
  • •The candidate shall have a minimum of five (5) years of legal experience and be licensed to practice law in Delaware. The City Solicitor shall serve as an independent contractor of the City.
  • •The City Solicitor should have adequate familiarity with many of the types of matters in the City Charter (https://library.municode.com/de/dover/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId= PTICHRELA) and City Code (https://library.municode.com/de/dover/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId= COORDODE), as well as matters addressed in the Delaware Code including those applicable to municipalities (e.g., Title 22 of the Delaware Code, https://delcode.delaware.gov/title22/index.html). Such matters may involve public infrastructure and property, city services, licensing, zoning, planning and development, personnel and employment, municipal borrowing, public records, election law, ethical standards, and litigation. It is preferable, but not required, that the selected candidate be familiar with and/or have expertise in all of these matters.
  • •The City Solicitor will manage all the legal activities and representation of the City. The City Solicitor may utilize other resources in his or her firm and, in consultation with the Council President and/or City Manager, will retain and manage outside counsel/attorneys that may be required to represent the city in a variety of matters. The Deputy Solicitor shall be authorized to act on behalf of the Solicitor, with the approval of the Council, as necessary.
  • •The selected attorney should be familiar with litigation procedures, land use law, real estate law, personnel and labor law, regulatory and election law, and expertise as it relates to city financial activities such as borrowing, bonds, etc., and other areas as needed.
  • •In his or her role of advice and consultation to the Council the City Solicitor will regularly prepare for and participate in all City Council meetings and workshops. This will include prior review and comment on all legal and legislative matters to come before the Council, including drafting resolutions, motions, ordinances, and other documents for further action, as well as assisting with reviewing the agenda prior to being published. The City Council typically meets twice monthly in regular session on

2
187

Paj 188

Item 1.

the second and last Monday of each month, and as Council of the Whole for Committee meetings the second and last Tuesday of the Month. Special meetings are scheduled as needed. Attendance may be required at all meetings of the City Council. The Planning Commission typically meets on the first Monday of each month. Participation by the Solicitor may be required. • The City Solicitor will also advise the City Manager regularly and continuously on all relevant matters pertaining to City activities. This includes but is not limited to the review of all contracts, all proposed ordinances, State and federal regulatory activities, code interpretation, all leases, and other ongoing matters. • Upon approval of the City Manager or Council President, the Directors and Department heads of the City, such as the Planning Director, Chief of Police, and others, may seek direct advice from the City Solicitor. • The City Solicitor is expected to consult regularly with the Planning Department on matters related to code interpretation and issuance of permits and represent the Planning Department before the City’s Board of Adjustment, the Property Maintenance Board of Appeals, and Historic Review Commission, when deemed appropriate. • The City Solicitor should have direct litigation experience and/or should have worked in coordination with litigators on some litigation, whether that is court and/or administrative agency litigation. In the past, when there was court District litigation involving the City, in some instances, the City Solicitor has represented the City (solely or as co-counsel), but in some instances, the City has retained separate litigation counsel. Where the Planning Commission or the Board of Adjustment is a named party to any court litigation, the City Solicitor may or may not be involved at which time outside counsel may be utilized. An otherwise strong candidate with an absence of direct litigation experience will not be excluded from consideration. • Regarding all matters in which the City Solicitor is involved, the City Solicitor (and any other resources authorized to be used and managed by the City Solicitor) must provide a high-quality work product in a timely manner. • Absent a waiver, the City Solicitor and all counsel utilized on behalf of the City or any of its entities must have no conflict of interest with the business of the city and shall take all measures to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest. • The City Solicitor is expected to be knowledgeable of Chapter 100, Title 29 of the Delaware Code, Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), and the ability to interpret and provide guidance on FOIA compliance and defend the city in any FOIA violation allegations.

SUBMISSION PACKAGE

The Request for Qualifications submission should include at minimum:

3
188

Paj 189

Item 1.

  • •Educational background.
  • •Date of admittance to the Delaware Bar and to Bars in another jurisdiction, if any.
  • •Relevant legal experience, with emphasis on municipal work or related experience.
  • •List of relevant memberships.
  • •Summary of the firm’s areas of practice, number of attorneys and support employees, and location of office(s).
  • •Resources - personnel and others – that will be made available to support work as the City Solicitor.
  • •Firm resources to assist if the designated Solicitor is not available.
  • •Any client references you are willing to share with the city.
  • •A statement that there is no conflict of interest between the business of the city and current clients of the firm or disclosure of any conflicts of interest.
  • •Any special skills or expertise that you or your firm may bring to the position of Solicitor.
  • •Compensation Requirements.

RECRUITMENT PROCESS AND SCHEDULE

  • •Due to recent FOIA opinions by the Attorney General's office, recruitment, review of RFQ submissions, and selection process of a new City Solicitor as an independent contractor must be conducted in an open public meeting.
  • •The City reserves the right to reject any and all responses to this RFQ.
  • •The City Council is interested in exploring the option of an in-house City Solicitor as a City employee rather than an independent contractor. If you prefer this scenario, please submit a resume and City of Dover employment application to the City Clerk at cityclerk@dover.de.us.

Proposed Schedule

  • •RFQ will be made available to interested parties.
  • •RFQ submissions are due Monday XXX.
  • •The City Manager will prepare an executive summary or cover memo of key points and qualifications of each applicant to present to the Council for short- listing. 4 189

Paj 190

Item 1.

  • •A review of submission packages (shortlist) will occur at a regular or special meeting of the Legislative, Finance and Administration Committee of the Council.
  • •Interviews (in person, phone or virtual) occur later that month at a special meeting (to be determined).
  • •As part of the interview process, an evaluation will be provided by the City Manager, City Clerk, and City Controller/Treasurer to provide additional feedback to the Council for their decision-making process. A satisfactory background check is required of all applicants.
  • •It is expected that the new City Solicitor will begin their services with the City by April 2025.

INQUIRIES

  • •We understand and respect that some candidates/firms require that any questions regarding the opportunity be handled with confidentiality due to their work status (e.g., current engagements with state, local, or federal government; current partner, associate or other position with a law firm; current position within academia or non-profit organization; retired or semi-retired work status).
  • •If you are in that situation, please contact the City Clerk at (302) 736-7008 with any questions.

RFQ SUBMISSIONS

Electronic submission of RFQ responses is preferred. Send your RFQ response by XXX (date) to:

City of Dover
PO Box 475
Dover, DE 19901

Attention: City Clerk

Or in electronic form to www.cityclerk@dover.de.us

5
190

Paj 191

Item 2.

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

ACTION FORM

PROCEEDING: Council Committee of the Whole (Legislative, Finance and Administration Committee) DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Planning & Inspections SUBMITTED ON: February 11, 2025 PREPARED BY: Sharon J. Duca, P.E., ICMA-CM, Assistant City Manager and Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer REVIEWED BY: David S. Hugg, III, City Manager

SUBJECT: Proposed Snow Removal Ordinance and Proposed Appeals Process TIMETABLE: Recommendation from Council Committee of the Whole February 11, 2025 First Reading of Recommended Ordinances February 24, 2025 Final Reading of Recommended Ordinances March 10, 2025 RELATED PROJECT: n/a EXHIBITS: Ordinance #2025-05 Ordinance #2025-06 REFERENCE: n/a

EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $0

AMOUNT BUDGETED: $0

FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): n/a

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

That City Council approve the recommended ordinances including Ordinance #2025-05 and Ordinance #2025-06.

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:

On January 28, 2025, City staff presented to the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee of the Council Committee of the Whole (CCW) snow removal related ordinances based upon citizen concerns received following the winter storm of January 6, 2025. The information below is to summarize the proposed ordinances provided regarding snow removal and the appeals process. • Ordinance #2025-05 – This draft ordinance would create a separate section (Section 98-12) within

191

Paj 192

Item 2.

the Code to address snow and ice removal from sidewalks in the public right-of-way. In general, it would grant an owner or occupant 24 hours after it ceased snowing to clear the sidewalks within the public right-of-way. In addition, a warning would be issued first, prior to the issuance of a citation, allowing 24 hours for the owner or occupant to clear the sidewalks. This draft ordinance also includes the establishment of penalties in Appendix F. No penalty would be imposed with the issuance of a warning. • Ordinance #2025-06 – This draft ordinance would establish an appeals process for appeals concerning the City of Dover Code of Ordinances less chapters of the code that are currently covered by an existing appeals process. There is currently no appeals process within the code for many sections of code. Based upon the above, staff recommends that that City Council approve the recommended ordinances including Ordinance #2025-05 and Ordinance #2025-06.

192

Paj 193

Item 2.

City of Dover
PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-05

1 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN 2 COUNCIL MET: 3 4 That Chapter 98 – Streets, sidewalks, storm sewers, and other public places be amended by 5 inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows: 6 7 Sec. 98-5. Duty of tenants or owners to maintain sidewalks and landscaped areas within the 8 street right-of-way. 9 10 (a) It shall be unlawful for the owner or occupant of any premises abutting upon a sidewalk 11 to permit or allow snow or ice to remain thereon for longer than 12 hours of daylight 12 after it has ceased snowing, or to permit debris or other materials to accumulate at any 13 time so that pedestrians may conveniently and safely pass. 14 (b) It is the responsibility of the owner or occupant of any premises abutting upon a 15 sidewalk to keep the landscaped area between the sidewalk and the curbline, or where 16 no sidewalk exists between the property line and curbline or paved street, maintained 17 in accordance with the standards set forth in chapter 114, article II, pertaining to weeds. 18 (c) It shall be unlawful to sweep, blow, or otherwise discharge grass clippings into any 19 street, sidewalk, storm drain, or water course more than incidental amounts of grass. 20 (d) Violations; penalties. Any person(s) violating any provision of this section shall be 21 fined as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 22 23 Sec. 98-12. Snow and ice removal from sidewalks in the public right of way. 24 25 (a) It shall be unlawful for the owner or occupant of any premises to permit or allow 26 sidewalk(s) abutting the property to accumulate snow or ice when 24 hours have 27 passed since it has ceased snowing. The sidewalks must remain clear after the 24- 28 hour period of the ceasing of snow. 29 30 (b) Warning; posting. Any property found to have snow or ice remaining on sidewalk(s) 31 abutting property after 24 hours have passed since the cease of snow will receive an 32 initial notice of violation via posting of notice by the code official. This notice 33 provides 24 hours to remove all snow and ice from the sidewalk. 34 35

193

Paj 194

Item 2. Proposed Ordinance #2025-05 – Amending Chapter 98, Sec. 98-5, Sec. 98-12 Page 2

36 (c) Violations; penalties. Any property owner who fails to keep the sidewalk(s) free 37 from snow and ice after 24 hours of the posting of the initial notice of violation will 38 be subject to penalties as provided in Appendix F- Fees and Fines.

39Secs. 98-12 13—98-40. Reserved.
40
41BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
42
43 That Appendix F -Fees and Fines, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font
44and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows:
45
46Chapter 98. – Streets, Sidewalks, and Other Public Places
Chapter 98. Streets, Sidewalks and Other Public PlacesFees and Fines
Article I. In General
Sec. 98-5. Duty of tenants or owners to maintain sidewalks and$100.00 per violation
landscaped areas within the street right-of-way
Sec. 98-11. Placement of wireless communications facilities within
rights-of-way
(c) Use of Rights-of-Way Permit
(1) Permit Fee$25.00 for ROW
Permit
(2) Annual Fee for Rights-of-way UseNo charge for WCF
placement on existing
City owned wireless
support structure in
City ROW

$220.00 for
Placement of new
wireless support
structure/pole in City
ROW

$220.00 for WCF
placement on a third
party/non-City
wireless support
structure/pole in City
ROW
Sec. 98-12. Snow and ice removal from sidewalks in the public
right of way.

(b) Warning; Posting$0.00
(c) Violations; penalities$100.00 per
violation
Article VI. Excavations

194

Paj 195

Item 2. Proposed Ordinance #2025-05 – Amending Chapter 98, Sec. 98-5, Sec. 98-12 Page 3

Sec. 98-253. BondMaximum of
$5,000.00 per
opening
Article VII. Parades
Sec. 98-303. Fee at the time of filing the application for a parade$10.00. This fee may
permitbe waived, in whole
or in part, by the
chief of police.
47
48
49
50ADOPTED: *
51
52
53SYNOPSIS
54
55 The ordinance amends Chapter 98 establishing a stricter timeline for snow and ice removal,
56 requiring sidewalk(s) abutting the properties to be cleared within 24 hours after snowfall ends with
57 a notice of violation issued if sidewalks remain uncleared after this period. Failure to comply after
58 the notice results in penalties. These changes aim to improve pedestrian safety, maintain clean
59 public spaces, and ensure compliance with city maintenance standards. Additionally, the ordinance
60 amends the fees and fines for violations, including a $100 fine for non-compliance with snow and
61ice removal.
62
63(SPONSORS:
64
65
66Action History
67 02/25/2025 - Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and Administration
68Committee

195

Paj 196

Item 2.

City of Dover
PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-06

1BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN
2COUNCIL MET:
3
4 That Chapter 1 – General Provisions be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, as
5follows:
6
7Sec. 1-18. Code Board of Appeals.
8
9 (a) Established; composition; appointment. There shall be a committee to be referred to as
10 the " Code Board of Appeals," consisting of five members. The council president shall
11 appoint three elected city officials, and the mayor shall appoint two city residents
12 generally selected as a representative of homeowners. Members shall serve one-year
13 terms unless sooner removed. All appointments are subject to confirmation by the city
14 council at its second regular meeting in May. The Code Board of Appeals shall elect
15one of its members as chairperson.
16
17 (b) Appeals. Whenever any person is aggrieved by a decision of the code official with
18 respect to any provision of the Dover Code of Ordinance, shall have the right of that
19 person to appeal to the Code Board of Appeals. Such an appeal must be filed in
20 writing and submitted to the City Clerk’s Office within 30 days after the
21determination by the official code.
22
23 (c) Exempt. The following are exempt from these provisions under this section:
24 (1) No notice, order, citation, or summons shall be determined by the Code Board of
25Appeals pertaining Chapter 22- Building and Building Regulations.
26
27 (2) No notice, order, citation, or summons shall be determined by the Code Board of
28Appeals pertaining Chapter 46- Fire Prevention and Protection.
29
30 (3) No notice, order, citation, or summons shall be determined by the Code Board of
31Appeals when issued by any law enforcement agency having jurisdiction.
32
33 (d) Notice; hearing. Upon receipt of such an appeal the Code Board of Appeals shall set a
34 time and place in not less than ten, nor more than 30 days, for the purpose of hearing
35 the appeal. Notice of the time and place of the hearing of the appeal shall be given to

196

Paj 197

Item 2. Proposed Ordinance #2025-06 – Amending Chapter 1 – General Provisions, Sec. 1-18 Page 2

36 all parties, at which time they may appear and be heard. The determination by the 37 Code Board of Appeals shall be final in all cases. 38 39 (e) Stay of Enforcement. Appeals of any notice, order, citation, or summons (other than 40 Imminent Danger notices) shall stay the enforcement of the notice, order, citation, or 41 summons until the appeal is resolved by the appeals board. 42 43 44 45 ADOPTED: * 46 47 48 SYNOPSIS 49 This ordinance establishes a Code Board of Appeals. The board will hear appeals from individuals 50 aggrieved by decisions made by the official code, with appeals to be filed within 30 days. Certain 51 provisions, such as those related to building regulations, fire prevention, and law enforcement, are 52 exempt from the board’s jurisdiction. The board will set a hearing date within 10 to 30 days of 53 receiving an appeal, and its decision will be final. 54 55 (SPONSORS: 56 57 58 Action History 59 02/25/2025 - Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and Administration 60 Committee

197

Paj 198

Item 3.

City of Dover
PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-04

1BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN
2COUNCIL MET:
3
4 That Chapter 70 – Offenses and Miscellaneous Provisions, Section 70-7. – Registered sexual
5 offenders, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, and deleting the text indicated
6in red strikeout as follows:
7
8Sec. 70-7. – Registered sexual offenders.
9
10 (a) Registration required. Sex offenders, as defined under the provisions of 11 Del. C., c.
11 41, § 4120A, shall register their places of residence and employment as required under
12the provisions of 11 Del. C., c. 41, § 4120.
13 (1) In the United States, sex offenders are legally required to provide accurate
14 personal identification information to law enforcement agencies. This mandate
15 is primarily governed by the Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act
16 (SORNA), which is Title I of the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act
17of 2006. SORNA establishes comprehensive standards for sex offender
18registration and notification across the nation.
19(2) Identification Requirements:
20 a. Personal Information: Offenders must supply their name, date of birth,
21Social Security number, and any aliases.
22 b. Residential Details: Current address and any places of residence must be
23reported.
24 c. Employment and School Information: Details of current employment and
25educational institutions attended are required.
26 d. Vehicle Information: Information about any vehicles owned or operated
27by the offender must be provided.
28 e. Online Identifiers: Offenders are obligated to disclose all internet
29 identifiers, such as email addresses and usernames used on social media
30platforms.
31 f. Physical Description: A current photograph and physical description are
32necessary.
33 (3) Offenders are required to keep this information current by reporting any
34changes within a specified timeframe, typically three business days.
35 Additionally, they must make periodic in-person appearances to verify and
36update their registration details.

198

Paj 199

Item 3. Proposed Ordinance #2025-04 – Amending Chapter 70, Section. 70-7 Page 2

37 (4) Offenders are required to provide their true name and notify the council

38district with which they reside.
39(b) Prohibited activities for sexual offenders.
40 (1) It is unlawful for any sexual offender to participate in a holiday event or practice
41 involving children under 18 years of age, such as distributing candy or other items
42 to children on Valentine’s Day, Halloween, Christmas, or any other holiday event.
43 Participation is to be defined as attendance at, or taking part of in, or cooperation
44with an event.
45 (2) It is unlawful for any sexual offender to wear costumes for the primary purpose of
46entertaining, attracting, or encouraging interaction with children.
47 (3) Any person designated a sexual offender shall be required on October thirty-first of
48each year or any other day upon which Halloween is celebrated to:
49a. Avoid all Halloween-related contact with children;
50 b. Post a sign at his/her residence stating, “No candy or treats at this residence.”
51 Such signs shall be in letters at least two inches high and shall be legible from
52the street or road adjacent to the residence;
53 c. Except for lighting provided on a year-round basis by a sexual offender or the
54 owner or manager of a multi-family residential unit for the purpose of security
55 or walkway or hallway illumination, all outside residential lighting shall be off
56 during the evening hours after 5:00 p.m., and no exterior holiday decorations
57 shall be exhibited on the sexual offender’s residence or on the property upon
58which the residence is located.
59 (4) Holiday events or practices in which the sexual offender is the parent or guardian
60 of the child or children involved, and where no non-familial children are present,
61are exempt from this section.
62 (f) (c) Penalties. Any person who violates this section shall be fined in accordance with
63 Appendix F – Fees and Fines, section 70-7. Every day that a violation occurs shall
64constitute a separate offense.
65
66BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
67
68 That Appendix F -Fees and Fines, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font
69and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows:
70
71Chapter 70. – Offenses and Miscellaneous Provisions
Chapter 70. Offenses and Miscellaneous ProvisionsFees and Fines
Sec. 70-1. Combative fighting
Subsec. (d)(1) Violations; penalties, finesNot to exceed
$1,000.00. Separate
fines may be issued
to the promoter of
such an event,
participants in such
an event, and the

199

Paj 200

Item 3. Proposed Ordinance #2025-04 – Amending Chapter 70, Section. 70-7 Page 3

owner of the
premises of such an
event
Sec. 70-2. Weapons generally

(e)(1) Penalties; finesNot less than
$500.00, nor more
than $1,000.00
Sec. 70-7. Registered sexual offenders
Subsec. (f) Penalties$500.00 for any
offense; each day
shall constitute a
separate offense
Sec. 70-8. Disorderly premisesNot to exceed
$1,000.00 for any
offense.
Sec. 70-10 Violations and penalties
Each day that a nuisance violation continues may be considered a new violation. If not paid,
fines may be subject to a lien on property of the owner.
1st offense$100.00 fine
2nd offense$250.00
rd
3 offense$500.00
All subsequent offenses$1,000.00
72
73
74ADOPTED: *
75
76SYNOPSIS
77 This ordinance amends Chapter 70, Section 70-7 of the City of Dover Code to align with the Adam
78 Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act. It requires registered sexual offenders to provide detailed
79 personal, residential, employment, vehicle, and online information, updating any changes within
80 three business days. The ordinance also strengthens restrictions on offenders' activities with
81 minors, banning them from participating in certain holiday events, such as distributing candy on
82 Halloween, Christmas, and Valentine’s Day, and prohibiting costumes that may attract children.
83 Offenders must also follow specific Halloween rules, including avoiding contact with minors and
84 posting a “No candy or treats” sign. Parents or guardians are exempt when attending private events
85with only their children.
86(SPONSORS: Boggerty and Anderson)
87
88
89Action History
90 02/25/2025 - Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and Administration
91Committee
92

200

Tounen nan reyinyon sa a