Yo rale tèks sa a nan PDF la otomatikman, epi li ka gen erè. PDF la se dosye ofisyèl la, kidonk tcheke l anvan ou konte sou sa a.
8 paj pa gen anpil tèks ou ka li isit la, oswa yo pa gen ditou, souvan paske se eskanè oswa desen. Gade PDF la pou sa yo.
Paj 1
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING
Tuesday, March 25, 2025 at 6:00 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware
AGENDA
THIS AGENDA AND PACKET HAVE BEEN REVISED BY UPDATING THE SAFETY,
ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE MEETING ITEM #1 – REVIEW OF
DATA SURROUNDING SAFETY CONCERNS ON EAST LOOCKERMAN STREET
Public comments are welcomed on any item and will be permitted at the appropriate time. When possible, please notify the City Clerk (302-736-7008 or email at cityclerk@dover.de.us) should you wish to be recognized.
VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE
This meeting will be held in City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:
Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://shorturl.at/PzGkH
Event number: 2530 430 3321
Event password: DOVER (if needed)
If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at https://www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.
CALL COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING TO ORDER
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA
- 1.Review of Data Surrounding Safety Concerns on East Loockerman Street (David Suiters and Chief Johnson, Dover Police Department)
(Committee Action Not Required)
ADJOURNMENT OF THE SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE MEETING
1
Paj 2
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING - March 25, 2025 PAGE 2
UTILITY COMMITTEE
ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA
- 1.Presentation about the Efficiency Smart Program (Paul Waddell, Electric Director, Scott Lynch, DEMEC, and Tom Coyle, Account Management Director, Efficiency Smart)
(Staff Recommendation: Approve the inclusion of the Efficiency Smart Program into the FY26 budget.)
- 2.Evaluations of Proposals - PFAS Treatment Feasibility Study & Design (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director)
(Staff Recommendation: Award contract to Verdantas for the PFAS Treatment Feasibility & Design, RFP #25-0016WW, for the amount of $190,000.)
- 3.Annexation Request - 582 Acorn Lane, Owned by Robert Pellegrino (Dawn Melson- Williams, Principal Planner)
(Staff Recommendation: Upon consideration of utility services, it is found that electric, water, and sanitary sewer services are provided and/or available to the property at 582 Acorn Lane. The Electric Department and Department of Water and Wastewater have no objection to the proposed annexation)
ADJOURNMENT OF THE UTILITY COMMITTEE MEETING
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA
- 1.Fuel Pump Island Upgrade (Mike Hamlett, Central Services Director)
(Staff Recommendation: Approval of the proposal of $680,400 submitted by Coastal Pump & Tank in RFP #25-0017WH)
ADJOURNMENT OF THE LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE MEETING
ADJOURNMENT OF THE COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING
2
Paj 3
Item 1.
City of Dover
City Manager’s Office
PO Box 475
Dover DE 19903-0475
Phone: (302) 736-7005
E-Mail: sduca@dover.de.us
MEMORANDUM
To: Chairman Andre Boggerty
City Council and Council Committee Members
CC: David S. Hugg, III, City Manager Andria Bennett, CMC, City Clerk Chief Thomas A. Johson, Jr., Dover Police Department Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services Mark Nowak, GISP, Public Works Director Jason Osika, Fire Marshal
From: Sharon J. Duca, P.E., ICMA-CM, Assistant City Manager
Date: March 20, 2025
Subject: Review of Data Surrounding Safety Concerns on East Loockerman Street
Concerns have been received regarding traffic speeds and volumes on East Loockerman Street (a city- maintained street). As a result, a request to close the street at South Edgehill Avenue fully has been received. At the January 28, 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting, it was moved that staff should begin the process of evaluating the proposed road closure with the required agencies and departments. The following is information available to date.
In order to evaluate traffic speeds and volumes, a speed study is typically performed. The Dover Police Department performed a speed study of the subject area in July 2023 and March 2025. Overall, the volume of vehicles analyzed decreased by just over 5,000 vehicles between the two studies. The posted speed limit for the area is 25 MPH in accordance with state law for residential areas. The average speed for the two studies was fairly consistent, with an average speed of 24 MPH being registered in the most recent study. The fastest speed decreased by 11 MPH from 2023 to 2025 with eight enforceable violations (or one percent of the vehicles analyzed) found in the most recent study. The 85th Percentile Speed is also used to evaluate roads with this value being the rate at or below which 85 percent of the drivers travel on a road segment. Motorists traveling above the 85th Percentile Speed are considered to be exceeding the safe and reasonable speed for road and traffic conditions (Federal Highway Administration). The 85th Percentile Speed for both studies was 30 MPH which is within 5 MPH of the posted speed limit. Over 5 MPH can trigger additional analysis regarding the posted speed.
It should also be noted that the City of Dover Fire Marshal has reviewed the request to close East Loockerman Street at South Edgehill Avenue and does not support the closure. If the road were to close, it would increase the response time to emergency incidents. On January 14th of this year, there was a structure fire at Loockerman Court, and this was the route of travel for the Fire Department. If this area were closed, the Fire Department
3
Paj 4
Item 1.
Review of Data Surrounding Safety Concerns on East Loockerman Street
March 20, 2025
would have had to utilize East Division Street resulting in an increased response time. Increased response time allows a fire to grow larger and reduces the chance of life safety efforts for anyone trapped inside the structure.
Discussions have also occurred with the Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services and the Public Works Director. In the past, petitions have been required when requests were made to install stop signs that are not required by the Manual for Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD). As the MUTCD is silent on road closures, it is strongly recommended that a petition be established to determine what the affected residents desire. It is recommended that the procedure for the petition follow that utilized for a street name change (Section 98- 45 of the City of Dover Code of Ordinances). If it is determined that the community and Council wish staff to pursue this matter further, an engineering analysis can be performed to evaluate the costs and design requirements to close the road. It should be noted that capital improvements related to stormwater and drainage may be required, depending on the mechanism of closure, as East Loockerman Street currently drains in a westerly direction from South Edgehill Avenue to John Hunn Brown Road.
In conclusion, the data received does not warrant any specific changes based upon current guidelines and standards. If City Council would like to pursue the matter further, it is recommended that the community develop a petition for the closure. If the petition indicates that a majority of the property owners concur, additional engineering analysis can then be performed to determine the methodology and costs associated with a closure.
4
Paj 5
Item 1.
Default Report Title
Use Preferences to Define Titles
Site Code: 00000006 Comment 1:
Station ID: Dover PD Comment 2:
Location 1: E Loockerman St and S Edgehill Ave Comment 3:
Location 2: Comment 4:
Location 3: Latitude: 39.162295
Location 4: Longitude: -75.511893
Combined Lanes 3/12/2025 to 3/19/2025
Percentile Speeds
| Percentile | 25th | 50th | 65th | 70th | 75th | 80th | 85th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Speed - MPH | 20.9 | 23.9 | 26.9 | 27.9 | 27.9 | 28.9 | 29.9 |
Vehicles Traveling Greater Than 35.0 MPH
| Total Volume | 706 |
| Total Greater Than 35.0 | 14 |
| Percent Greater Than 35.0 | |
|---|---|
| 2.0% | |
| Mean, Median, and Mode Averages | |
| Mean: | 24.2 |
| Median (50th %): | 23.9 |
| Mode: | 23.0 |
5
1
Paj 6
Default Report Title Item 1.
Use Preferences to Define Titles
SPEED DATA ANALYSIS
6
Paj 7
Default Report Title Item 1.
Use Preferences to Define Titles
SPEED DATA ANALYSIS
7
Paj 8
Default Report Title Item 1.
Use Preferences to Define Titles
SPEED DATA ANALYSIS
8
Paj 9
Default Report Title Item 1.
Use Preferences to Define Titles
SPEED DATA ANALYSIS
9
Paj 10
Item 1.
10
Paj 11
Item 1.
Power Supply Plus
Prepared for Dover, DE | March 25, 2025
Scott Lynch | VP, Asset Development | DEMEC | demecinc.net Tom Coyle | Director, Account Management | Efficiency Smart | efficiencysmart.org
11
Paj 12
Item 1.
Power Supply Plus Prepared for Dover, DE | March 25, 2025 Scott Lynch | VP, Asset Development | DEMEC | demecinc.net Tom Coyle | Director, Account Management | Efficiency Smart | efficiencysmart.org
12
Paj 13
Why Municipal Utilities
Item 1.
Participate in Efficiency
Smart
• The most affordable way to meet
power supply needs
• Increases customer satisfaction
• Powerful customer engagement tool
• Drives economic development
13
Paj 14
Why Efficiency Smart? Item 1.
As an electric utility, you have two ways to
meet your power supply needs:
- 1.Buy power Electric Usage
- 2.Reduce your electric usage Power Supply
14
Paj 15
Why Efficiency Smart? Item 1.
Efficiency Smart is the most affordable way to meet your power supply needs.
Projected Efficiency
2026 Market Prices Efficiency Smart
Smart Cost for Dover
(AMP Power Supply) Discount
(2025 – 2028)
Energy Cost per MWh $18.46 $55.60 67%
Demand Cost
$5.49 $10.67 49%
per kW-month
15
Paj 16
Why Efficiency Smart?
Item 1.
Customer Satisfaction • Lowers bills for your customers • Demonstrates utility’s investment back into the community • Reflects the value and service level of public power • Improves perception of utility • Increases customer loyalty and trust • Fosters a sense of community and pride
16
Paj 17
Item 1.
You Don’t Need to Take Our Word for It
In Efficiency Smart program surveys, more than 80% of
respondents evaluate their utility more positively
because it participates in Efficiency Smart.
17
Paj 18
Why Efficiency Smart?
Item 1.
Customer Engagement • We are an extension of your utility. • We connect with customers through customer support, account managers, engineers, social media, and surveys. • We provide your customers with information and ways to control costs and meet goals. • We learn and share valuable customer insight and feedback with you.
18
Paj 19
Why Efficiency Smart?
Item 1.
Economic Development • Retention: by lowering operating costs, we make your businesses more competitive • Growth: lower costs enable reinvestment (expand facilities, add production lines) • Attraction: part of a package to attract new businesses to town • Helps your customers meet their corporate objectives/sustainability goals • Can play a role in your community’s sustainability efforts • Demonstrates leadership in public power and helps you earn recognition for it (e.g., Smart Energy Provider)
19
Paj 20
What is Efficiency Smart?
Item 1.
Efficiency Smart is a hands-on service that
interacts directly with your electric customers
to reduce their energy usage.
Efficiency Smart:
1 Provides information and incentives.
2 Drives behavioral and technology changes.
3 Quantifies and reports the changes.
20
Paj 21
Who is Efficiency Smart?
Item 1.
- •AMP’s member service for energy efficiency and peak reduction
- •Currently serves eight communities in Delaware: Clayton, Lewes, Middletown, Milford, Newark, New Castle, Seaford, and Smyrna
- •Staff located in and near the communities we serve
- •VEIC administered: o Works collaboratively with AMP and DEMEC o Designs custom energy solutions for local market needs
21
Paj 22
How Efficiency Smart Continues to Improve
Item 1.
- •Summer peak reduction goals • Enhanced customer engagement with guaranteed kW savings. and education through social media and other digital marketing
- •Building trust with customers channels. leads to involvement in planning and decision-making. • New program development to increase customer knowledge,
- •Regularly adding new products participation, and satisfaction. and technologies to our programs • Targeted programs that support based on market improvements spending locally. and customer interest.
22
Paj 23
Core Program Tenets
Item 1.
- •Delivering our participating municipalities’ performance guarantees
- •Being an objective third party o Vendor and technology-neutral
- •Giving cost-effective recommendations
- •Providing superior customer service
- •Return on investment greater than 100%
- •Third-party evaluation, measurement, and verification
23
Paj 24
Business Programs
Item 1.
& Services All businesses are eligible to receive account management and engineering consultations to help them identify opportunities to save money and energy. • We can help validate vendor proposals. • We can calculate cash flow impacts and returns on investment. • If a customer is interested but doesn’t know where to start, we can help them figure that out!
24
Paj 25
Residential Programs
Item 1.
- •There are multiple services we offer residential customers.
- •We design programs to be as simple to use as possible.
- •We offer programs to help customers confidently identify efficient products to purchase for their homes.
Online Home Energy
Savings Rebates
25
Paj 26
Residential Programs
Item 1.
- •Our appliance recycling program allows customers to get paid for responsibly recycling an appliance.
- •Refrigerators, freezers, dehumidifiers, and window air conditioners are all eligible for free pickup and recycling through our seasonal program.
Online
Appliance Recycling
Savings
Rewards
26
Paj 27
Residential Programs
Item 1.
- •We also offer programs that require no up-front purchase to participate.
- •Many of these programs are designed to help educate and inform residents on how they can make low-cost or no-cost changes to save energy in their homes.
Electric Bill Online Home Electric Usage
Energy Assessment
Advice Monitor
27
Paj 28
What Residents Say About Efficiency Smart Services Item 1.
28
Paj 29
Efficiency Smart Website Item 1.
- •Community-specific webpage: o Overview of Efficiency Smart and its partnership with the community o Residential and business program information o News and promotions
- •Resources: o Energy efficiency tips and guides
- •New and improved website coming soon
29
Paj 30
How Efficiency Smart Markets its Services Item 1.
- •Efficiency Smart website
- •Bill messages and inserts
- •Utility office flyers
- •Print and digital advertisements
- •Press releases
- •Email newsletters
- •Social media
30
Paj 31
Contract Terms and Benefits
Item 1.
for Dover, Delaware
Basic Program: 0.25% annual load reduction for
$0.90/MWh of retail sales.
Basic Performance
| Monthly Cost* | $49,354 |
| 3 Year Cost* | $1,776,727 |
| 3 Year MWh Goal* | 4,935.4 |
| Avoided Costs | $4,514,876 |
| Return on Investment | 154% |
| *Based on 2024 retail electric sales. | |
|---|---|
31
Paj 32
Why Municipal Utilities
Item 1.
Participate in Efficiency
Smart
• The most affordable way to meet
power supply needs
• Increases customer satisfaction
• Powerful customer engagement tool
• Drives economic development
32
Paj 33
Item 1.
For More Sean Clement
Director | Efficiency Smart
Information About sclement@efficiencysmart.org | 614-468-4918
Efficiency Smart: Tom Coyle
Director, Account Management | Efficiency Smart
tcoyle@efficiencysmart.org | 614-468-4924
Scott Lynch
Vice President, Asset Development | DEMEC
slynch@demecinc.net | Office: 302-653-2733
Maya Krasker
Energy Services Manager | DEMEC
mkrasker@demecinc.net | Office: 302-653-2733
www.efficiencysmart.org
33
Paj 34
Item 1.
What Others Have to Say
About Efficiency Smart
DEMEC Members
Mark Whitfield, Milford City Manager
Efficiency Smart has been a great asset to our Customer Service team. When customers complain about high electric bills, they can reference how Efficiency Smart can help them lower their electric usage and save money on their utility bills, plus the additional savings on purchases through their rebate programs. On the commercial side, we receive resounding compliments from businesses that use Efficiency Smart services. They save businesses money through recommendations on being more efficient and through rebates available for various equipment purchases. Efficiency Smart continues to reduce the city’s overall electric load through its programs, which helps sustain our distribution system further into the future.
Scott Blomquist, General Manager, New Castle Municipal Services Commission
I think the program is a great resource for our customers when replacing equipment. Many times, the rebates our customers can get through the program pay the difference for the upgraded or more energy-efficient equipment. Our customers then see the long-term savings in decreased consumption. Several of our large customers have really embraced the program and have seen significant savings. We really like the program because Efficiency Smart is completely managed by your team.
Scott Lynch, VP Asset Development, DEMEC
We always try to find ways to help our members get the lowest cost for reliable power. One of the best ways is not to use it. That’s why we look at Efficiency Smart as part of our power portfolio. We’re trying to bring our members the lowest cost of wholesale power that we can.
Efficiency Smart, which is designed uniquely for municipalities, was the program we selected because it was something we could customize to work for each individual member. Newark is a college town. Lewes is a beach town. They’re different. We can’t just apply the same thing to them and hope the same success will arise. We needed to be able to have a system that would work well and adapt to all of them. To us, that’s everything.
1111 Schrock Road | Columbus, Ohio 43229 | 877-889-3777 | info@efficiencysmart.org | efficiencysmart.org 34
Paj 35
Item 1.
Commercial & Industrial Customers Darren Cornish, Corporate Director of Facilities Management, Nationwide in Milford
Whether you’re considering something similar or a manufacturing facility or whatever the case may be, I would absolutely recommend Efficiency Smart. For us, it’s been a very rewarding relationship.
Julie Lacter, Porter Auto Group in Newark
Efficiency Smart is very knowledgeable and extremely helpful. I encourage everyone to apply for it. It is really a big step towards an energy-efficient future for us.
Cheyenne Rivera, Supervisor of Facilities, Cape Henlopen Schools in Lewes
I was skeptical at first because I didn’t think the process could be that easy, but it was. The incentive check was impressive, which I can now use towards future projects.
Dylan Parrish, Facilities Engineer, University of Delaware in Newark
Efficiency Smart has consistently demonstrated expertise and professionalism in identifying inefficiencies and providing incentive rebates on our energy-saving projects. I have worked closely with Efficiency Smart on a wide range of projects, and their exceptional customer service and expert guidance have made implementing energy-efficient solutions seamless and impactful. Their partnership has been crucial in helping us reduce our campus-wide energy use while creating a more sustainable campus for students, faculty, and staff.
Residential Customers
Vipul in Middletown
Efficiency Smart has helped me understand the efficient way to save electricity by using products that use less energy but give you the same output.
Andrew in Newark
Thank you for focusing on the essential pillar of improving efficiency… You are lifting LMI households by making it easier to afford higher-quality appliances that will save us more money in the long run.
Dawn in Smyrna (Appliance Recycling Rewards)
Setting up pickup was easy. Everything was communicated, and pickup was fast. This is a great opportunity for customers!
1111 Schrock Road | Columbus, Ohio 43229 | 877-889-3777 | info@efficiencysmart.org | efficiencysmart.org 35
Paj 36
Item 1.
Efficiency Smart Enhancing Municipal Electric Utilities Leverage a proven model that provides access to professional energy efficiency and peak reduction services tailored to your community’s unique characteristics.
At Efficiency Smart, we make it our job to understand the challenges that municipal utilities face. Beyond just energy efficiency. Issues like energy’s relationship to economic development. Challenges like increasing customer engagement and satisfaction. Efficiency Smart is designed to serve the unique needs of municipalities and their customers.
For Residents We help residential customers lower their electric bills and make their homes more comfortable. This includes guidance on reducing electric use, discounts on energy-efficient lighting, and rebates for energy-saving appliances.
For Businesses We assign each of our communities a dedicated account manager who, along with our engineering consultants, works in person to guide businesses through all phases of their energy efficiency projects. This includes identifying and prioritizing opportunities to save, reviewing proposals, recommending solutions, and more.
For Municipalities We help reduce municipal electric use, including city buildings, street lighting, and water and wastewater treatment facilities.
For Communities Our staff works within communities to build relationships with contractors, retailers, community agencies, and other key stakeholders. These partnerships help us to engage customers locally and leverage any additional energy efficiency and peak reduction opportunities that are available.
877.889.3777 • efficiencysmart.org 36
Paj 37
Item 1. Truth in Numbers Efficiency Smart is the most affordable way to meet your utility’s power supply needs, regardless of your current power supply portfolio. $12 Efficiency Smart is a tool to help your utility save per MWh money. Energy efficiency reduces costs, it reduces waste, and it reduces the overall rate at which you Between 2021-2023, Efficiency Smart buy power. Simply put, the least expensive form of saved energy at $12 per MWh – far below power is the one that you don’t have to buy. the market rate for new power supply.
Fueling Customer Engagement and Satisfaction Helping utility customers save energy and money is certainly a driver of customer satisfaction. However, there are many additional ways we engage with customers and influence their level of satisfaction with our program and your utility.
Our program surveys show that nearly 80% of responding customers evaluate their utility more favorably because it participates in Efficiency Smart.
Providing customers with the information they need to meet their energy-saving needs and control their costs is at the core of what we do, but it’s how we do it that often leaves a lasting impression. We treat individuals and businesses like people rather than applicants or account numbers. This personalized touch reflects the values and service level of public power. Having a strong local presence is critical for our hands-on, consultative approach to succeed. To this end, Efficiency Smart staff are located in and around the communities we serve, which allows us to interact directly with your customers. We also connect with customers across several other means, such as through our social media channels and our customer support team. Our proactive engagement with your customers allows us to build trust and loyalty with our program and your utility. We learn about your customers’ challenges so that we can help you solve problems or stop them before they materialize. Our participating communities view our team as an extension of their utility because we build relationships with their customers and share valuable customer insights and feedback with them. Ultimately, participation in Efficiency Smart demonstrates the utility’s investment back in the community.
877.889.3777 • efficiencysmart.org 37
Paj 38
Item 1.
Bolstering Economic Development Whether your community is looking to attract new businesses, retain existing ones, or simply help those businesses that already call your town home continue to grow and prosper, Efficiency Smart will work closely with your municipality to make your economic development efforts a success.
Attracting New Business
An effective energy efficiency program can be a key selling point when a business is deciding between multiple locations. That’s why Efficiency Smart is commonly part of the sales package when one of our participating communities is working to attract a new business. Businesses understand the impact that energy costs can have on their bottom line. Efficiency Smart gives your municipality a leg up over the competition.
Keeping Existing Business Prosperous
Efficiency Smart is also a tool for your community to grow existing businesses. We provide companies with the technical advice and financial incentives they need to reduce costs and become more competitive and resilient. This frees up funds for businesses to reinvest in your community through facility expansion or job creation. Additionally, Efficiency Smart offers targeted programs that encourage spending locally. For those companies that either have or want to define sustainability goals, Efficiency Smart can support them in these endeavors. Energy efficiency often plays a leading role in companies’ sustainability efforts. Having a comprehensive energy efficiency program can help them achieve their goals.
Efficiency Smart is American Municipal Power, Inc. (AMP)’s member service for energy efficiency and peak reduction. VEIC, a nonprofit organization that has worked in partnership with AMP since 2008, administers Efficiency Smart on behalf of AMP. Since 2011, Efficiency Smart has served more than 65 of AMP’s member utilities in Delaware, Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania.
877.889.3777 • efficiencysmart.org 38
Paj 39
Item 1. Program Options Efficiency Smart offers energy and peak reduction goals with MWh and kW savings guaranteed at 70% of your utility’s established goal. All claimed savings undergo independent savings verification through a third- party evaluation, measurement, and verification company hired by AMP. The table below highlights the performance options available to your community and the rate and deliverable for each option.
Performance Options
Service Option Rate Rate Basis Deliverable
Most recent year’s retail 0.5% annual load and 0.6% annual peak
Enhanced Performance $1.65
electric sales (MWh) data reduction
Most recent year’s retail 0.5% annual load and 0.4% annual peak
High Performance $1.40
electric sales (MWh) data reduction
Most recent year’s retail
Basic Performance $0.90 0.25% annual load reduction
electric sales (MWh) data
Most recent year’s C&I retail
Commercial & Industrial (C&I) $1.30 0.5% annual C&I load reduction
sales (MWh) data
Get Started With Efficiency Smart
Timothy Boland
Director of Economic Development & Efficiency Smart,
American Municipal Power, Inc.
tboland@amppartners.org
614-540-0933
Sean Clement
Director, Efficiency Smart
sclement@efficiencysmart.org
614-468-4918
877.889.3777 • efficiencysmart.org 39
Paj 40
Item 1.
Downtown Milford, Delaware
SUCCESS STORY
TIP JAR CONTEST: SERVING EFFICIENCY SMART
UP SUPPORT FOR STRESSED TIP JAR
RESTAURANTS CONTEST Tips
Efficiency Smart launched the Tip Jar Contest in June 2021 to
help ease the financial burden on restaurants in its service areas.
Efficiency Smart promoted the contest in its 26 participating
communities in support of their local restaurants while spreading
the word about its energy efficiency program.
In response, more than 100 people nominated 43 different restaurants on Facebook, five nominators won restaurant gift cards,
| and five restaurants won additional rebates to reduce the upfront | 43 |
| cost to install energy-saving equipment. | Restaurants Nominated |
The Tip Jar Contest gave communities a platform to support their favorite restaurants in a new way while providing a morale boost to an industry suffering job and sales loss.
One nominator in Newton Falls, Ohio wrote, “Our town has lost many businesses, suffered a tornado and endured through the pandemic. Through it all you could count in Roby Lee’s to find a way to feed our More Than hometown delicious homemade food.” 100 Another nominator in Newark, Delaware commented, “It’s a great Unique Nominators locally owned restaurant that does a ton for the local community and local (and state) First Responders. The two owners are also two of the nicest people you’ll ever meet and would be the first people to step up and help anyone and everyone if asked.”
All the communities involved were able to promote their favorite local restaurants while learning more about how energy efficiency contributes to thriving homes and businesses. 26 Communities Impacted
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG 40
Paj 41
TIP JAR CONTEST
Item 1.
Bowling Green Café Wins Support to Weather
Challenging Times
The Tip Jar contest created quite a buzz in Bowling Green, Ohio,
where Call of the Canyon Café has been a town fixture for more than
25 years. Its new owners took over in August 2020 and faced the
daunting task of trying to retain staff and keep the business afloat
amid pandemic challenges.
Fortunately, the café received a little extra support to weather the
storm and save on energy bills. After café patrons nominated it for
the Tip Jar contest, the response from the community was swift:
hundreds of town residents voted for the local favorite to help it
secure the win.
“The amount of support people gave us was overwhelming,” said the café’s co-owner Ardy Gonyer. “When we found out that we were one of five finalists, we were hoping for 25 to 50 votes from our followers on Facebook. I think we ended up being closer to 250.”
After the café won the contest, Efficiency Smart helped the café select a new, all-in-one energy-efficient line cooler and prep station. The equipment will reduce maintenance issues and monthly Call of the Canyon in Bowling Green, Ohio electric bills.
“The cooler was exactly what we were looking for, and the process was super easy,” said Gonyer. “The Efficiency Smart staff made checking specifications and ordering the equipment seamless. They’re great to work with.” The community engagement The publicity generated by the Tip Jar Contest also drove new through the Tip Jar contest business to the café. The boost was a boon for the café and the City was amazing and I feel of Bowling Green, which contracts with Efficiency Smart to provide strongly that Bowling Green energy efficiency services to town residents and businesses. rallied around this restaurant “Having a municipal utility is one thing that makes Bowling Green to win. It was an impactful way stand out in comparison to our neighbors, and Efficiency Smart is a for Efficiency Smart to say, component of that,” said Mary Hinkelman, Executive Director of the hey, look at what we do. Bowling Green Chamber of Commerce. Mary Hinkelman “The community engagement through the Tip Jar contest was Executive Director, Bowling Green amazing and I feel strongly that Bowling Green rallied around this Chamber of Commerce restaurant to win,” she added. “It was an impactful way for Efficiency Smart to say, hey, look at what we do.”
Efficiency Smart’s Tip Jar Contest helped dozens of communities promote energy efficiency and support local businesses.
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG 41
Paj 42
TIP JAR CONTEST
Item 1.
Wadsworth Sub Shop Saves on Upgrade for
Aging Refrigeration
In Wadsworth, Ohio, The Sub Station was one of the contest finalists who benefitted. Owner Matt Reed worked with Efficiency Smart to save on energy-efficient refrigeration upgrades to the shop’s beverage and produce cooler. The upgrades use less energy while keeping products fresher for longer, from lagers to lettuce. And the exposure from the contest helped drive more foot traffic to the restaurant.
“We did this project through Wadsworth’s Small Business program,”
said Reed. “It was a one-page application, and it wasn’t hard at all,
especially with Efficiency Smart’s help. I’d recommend the program
to anybody I knew—just the ease of it.”
Innovation Helps Small Businesses Stay Strong Efficiency Smart is always looking for ways to help its municipal utilities engage more people in taking advantage of the benefits of public power and energy efficiency. Providing technical assistance and financial support for new efficient equipment are two important ways to meet that goal. Community engagement is another. In the case of the Tip Jar Contest, Efficiency Smart was able to support The Sub Station in Wadsworth, Ohio restaurants in gaining new customers while spreading the word to other businesses and residents about ways to save on energy bills.
“I think it’s great to get the community more involved to help businesses,” said Sara Bluhm, Economic Development & Community Engagement Administrator for the City of Milford, Delaware, another I think it’s great to get the community that participated in the Tip Jar Contest. “It’s not easy to community more involved run a mom-and-pop shop. This is an easy and inexpensive way to to help businesses. It’s not help while supporting local businesses and putting them out there.” easy to run a mom-and-pop Efficiency Smart deploys community engagement as a proven shop. This is an easy and method for engaging more people and businesses in saving energy. inexpensive way to help while Moving forward, Efficiency Smart will continue to support Tip Jar supporting local businesses contest winners—and all participating communities—in lowering and putting them out there. their energy use. Sara Bluhm Set Up an Efficiency Program Today Economic Development and Community Engagement Since 2011, Efficiency Smart has helped residents and businesses Administrator, City of Milford use less energy and save money in more than 60 communities in four states. For more on how your business or community can engage, please contact us.
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG 42
Paj 43
Item 1.
SUCCESS STORY We’ve offered Efficiency Smart to our customers for LEDS A BRIGHT IDEA FOR LOCAL over ten years, renewing our HARDWARE STORE participation three times so far. The council really Columbiana Ace Hardware Saves Energy and Gains Customers likes pointing residents and with Efficient Lighting Programs business owners toward their programs. It’s a great resource Columbiana, Ohio is known for its friendliness and support for small and we love all the projects businesses. One of those small businesses is the locally owned Ace and creative programs they Hardware store, a downtown fixture that has become even more come up with.” popular, thanks to a city-sponsored program with Efficiency Smart. Lance Willard Residents go to Columbiana Ace to buy everything from nails to City Manager for the City of Columbiana cleaning supplies to garden mulch. Since 2017, it is also the place to purchase long-lasting, energy-efficient LEDs at a discounted price.
“Customers love to say, ‘I got this LED bulb at Ace for 99 cents!’” said store manager Steve Grappy. “They spread the word to their neighbors, or people hear about the discount through advertising from Efficiency Smart. Everybody really likes the program, and it helps bring more more than customers to the store.”
To date, the store has sold more than 7,000 discounted LED bulbs.
7,000
discounted LED bulbs sold
Many of those shoppers have become repeat customers. The program
is one of several being offered through Efficiency Smart to help
Columbiana’s residents and businesses become more energy-efficient.
How Ace Doubled Down on Lighting Savings Columbiana Ace Hardware’s introduction to the city’s lighting programs was a year earlier, in 2016. At that time, management will save swapped out all the store’s overhead fluorescents with support from Efficiency Smart. The new fixtures gave off so much light that store $130,000 owners had to paint the ceiling. on electric bills over the lifetime of the fixtures “No one noticed the wear and tear under the old, flickering fluorescents,” said Grappy. “The store is now brighter and more inviting for customers, and it’s a better work environment for staff.”
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG 43
Paj 44
ACE HARDWARE • COLUMBIANA, OH
Item 1.
The new fixtures have reduced the store’s energy consumption significantly. All told, the project will save store owners more than $130,000 on electric bills before the fixtures need to be replaced again.
But perhaps the most surprising benefit of the lighting upgrade was what it didn’t provide.
“With our old lighting system, we were climbing up and changing ballasts and bulbs once a week,” said Grappy. “I think I’ve changed one bulb since we installed the new system, and that was because of breakage, not burnout.”
The Power of a City-Sponsored Energy Efficiency Program
Since 2011, Columbiana has engaged Efficiency Smart to help residents and businesses save money on energy in a variety of ways. In addition to discounts on efficient lighting, city residents can take advantage of rebates on energy- efficient products and guidance on reducing their energy use. Efficiency Smart offers several free tools to help customers understand their energy use and the steps they can take to reduce it, including an electric usage monitor, an online home energy assessment, and one-on-one consultations with a customer support specialist.
“We’ve offered Efficiency Smart to our customers for over ten years, renewing our participation three times so far,” said Lance Willard, City Manager for the City of Columbiana. “The council really likes pointing residents and business owners toward their programs. It’s a great resource and we love all the projects and creative programs they come up with.”
Businesses, who are larger and more complex energy users, often need individualized support to lower their energy use and meet their unique business needs. Columbiana’s businesses have a dedicated Efficiency Smart account manager and the support of its energy consultants. They also receive custom incentives for the installation of energy-efficient equipment, from lighting to refrigeration to heating and cooling.
“The cheapest energy is the energy you don’t have to use,” said Willard. “Working with Efficiency Smart helps educate our customers and reduces Columbiana’s energy footprint, so that we don’t have to go out and spend millions to invest in a new power source.”
Set Up an Efficiency Program Today
City of Columbiana Electric Department is one of the municipal electric utilities that take advantage of the Efficiency Smart program to lower energy usage for commercial and residential customers. Since 2011, Efficiency Smart has helped residents and businesses use less energy and save money in more than 60 communities in four states. For more on how your business or community can engage, please contact us.
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG 44
Paj 45
Item 1.
SUCCESS STORY
Whether you’re considering NEW HEALTHCARE CAMPUS IN something similar or a manufacturing facility or MILFORD SAVES $9,000 A MONTH ON whatever the case may be, ENERGY BILLS I would absolutely recommend Efficiency Smart. A Triple Win for Nationwide Healthcare Services, its Tenants, For us, it has been a very and the City rewarding relationship.” Darren Cornish Nationwide Healthcare Services is a leading healthcare provider which Nationwide Corporate Director owns and operates healthcare facilities in Pennsylvania and Delaware. of Facilities Management The company provides post-acute and long-term care to residents at each of its campuses and also leases space to wellness-focused clients. When Nationwide Healthcare Services purchased the former Milford Memorial Hospital in Milford, Delaware, the buildings’ systems and controls were still set up for hospital use and occupancy rather than mixed commercial use. This wasted a substantial amount of energy and left Nationwide’s leadership with a challenge: a $50,000 utility bill each month with no occupancy or generated revenue to offset the costs. “There were so many systems, from humidification and dehumidification 36% to variable settings on motors and drives, and so many vastly different electric consumption operating mechanisms in the way things were set up,” said Darren reduction in six months Cornish, Nationwide Corporate Director of Facilities Management. “You couldn’t appreciate it unless you were here from the start.” According to the U.S. Department of Energy, inadequate sensing, monitoring, and control operations in commercial buildings lead to significant energy waste. With improved building controls, it is estimated that annual building energy usage could be reduced by close to 30 percent. more than Breathing New Life into Old Buildings $100,000 In late 2019, Nationwide contacted the City of Milford about how to in annual electric cost savings lower energy usage on their new campus. The city introduced them to Efficiency Smart, a service that helps residents and businesses save money by using less energy.
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG45
Paj 46
NATIONWIDE HEALTHCARE SERVICES • MILFORD, DE
Item 1.
Efficiency Smart sent a team to the campus to assess the situation. Over the next several weeks, Efficiency Smart worked in collaboration with Nationwide’s owner, facilities team, and mechanical contractor to monitor and analyze the buildings’ automation controls and mechanical systems. Within six months, the electric bill was cut in half and monthly electric consumption was reduced by 36 percent. “By understanding Nationwide’s needs and how they use energy, we were able to identify several opportunities for them to make system adjustments at no cost,” said Tim Stearns, Lead Engineering Consultant for Efficiency Smart. “When it comes to optimizing the energy efficiency of building systems, we first look for systems that can be turned off or turned down before recommending investments in maintenance and replacement equipment.” Based on the findings, Cornish was able to turn off several building mechanical systems and use others more efficiently by minimizing power when it wasn’t needed. Efficiency Smart also provided financial rebates to help reduce the cost for Nationwide to purchase more efficient equipment. During the first five months following the adjustments, Nationwide achieved 430,000 kWh in energy savings or more than $100,000 in annual electric cost savings.
Common Solutions for Diverse Tenants
Nationwide’s tenant businesses—including treatment centers, fitness centers, medical daycares, and a 100-bed skilled nursing center—offer valuable supplemental support to patients and caretakers. However, they represent a broad spectrum of needs and requirements, which complicates the picture of how facilities teams can adopt cost-effective energy efficiency measures. Fortunately for Nationwide, their partnership with the City of Milford and Efficiency Smart has made a huge difference in the presentation and buildout of the leased space. It has also led to direct benefits for its tenants: new LED lighting systems and air handling units that save energy and provide an inviting workspace for their staff and customers. “What we learned from the tenant buildouts and the relationship with the City of Milford and Efficiency Smart pushed us to do LED lighting in every buildout,” said Cornish. “It certainly opened our eyes on how to approach our larger capital plan going forward.” According to ENERGY STAR, lighting makes up 17 percent of all electricity consumed in U.S. commercial buildings. LED fixtures last longer and can provide up to a 45 percent reduction in energy use compared to fluorescent fixtures. This can translate into big savings, particularly when you consider the vast number of fixtures at some commercial facilities. “Nationwide bought this hospital campus with the intent to support the Milford community and it has definitely provided a unique opportunity to partner with local organizations to save on energy costs,” said Cornish. “Whether you’re considering something similar or a manufacturing facility or whatever the case may be, I would absolutely recommend Efficiency Smart. For us, it has been a very rewarding relationship.”
Set Up an Efficiency Program Today
The City of Milford Electric Department is one of the municipal electric utilities that takes advantage of the Efficiency Smart program to lower energy usage for commercial and residential customers. Since 2011, Efficiency Smart has helped residents and businesses use less energy and save money in more than 60 communities in four states. For more on how your business or community can engage, please contact us.
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG46
Paj 47
Item 1.
SUCCESS STORY
“Efficiency Smart and the RECENT SOUTHEASTERN Bowling Green electric utility have always been CONTAINER PROJECTS SAVE with us. It’s more than 2.7 MILLION KILOWATT HOURS transactional; it has always been a partnership.” OF ENERGY IN BOWLING GREEN John Johnson General Manager, Efficiency projects deliver massive local investment and Southeastern Container energy savings
Companies set sustainability goals to reduce their costs, boost their resilience, and reduce their carbon footprint, among other strategic objectives. Cities can help companies deliver on these goals—and strengthen the local economy—by contracting with a partner like Efficiency Smart to provide energy efficiency services and incentives. In Bowling Green, Ohio, Efficiency Smart recently worked with the local Southeastern Container plant to secure more efficient equipment that saves 2.7 million kilowatt-hours (kWh) of energy annually. That’s the equivalent of powering 250 homes each year. These energy savings are 5,300,000 also expected to result in more than $270,000 in annual electric savings kWh of annual energy savings for Southeastern Container’s Bowling Green facility. since 2013
“We’re very excited about it,” said Tyler Williams, Plant Engineer. “These projects help us drive down the costs of manufacturing and motivate our company to keep investing here in Bowling Green.”
Industrial Efficiency Can Net Huge Savings Southeastern Container is a manufacturing cooperative that produces plastic bottles and preforms primarily for Coca-Cola. Its mission is to be a leader in environmentally sustainable packaging within the bottling $6,700,000 community, a goal that aligns closely with Coca-Cola’s goal to reduce its savings over the lifetime of the global greenhouse gas emissions by 25 percent by 2030. installed products Efficiency Smart and the Southeastern Container Bowling Green plant have partnered for almost a decade to reduce energy use and operational costs. The plant won an Efficiency Smart Ambassador Award for its energy efficiency progress in 2013, and another in 2022—the first company to receive the award twice. In total, Efficiency Smart
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG47
Paj 48
SOUTHEASTERN CONTAINER • BOWLING GREEN, OHIO
Item 1.
has helped Southeastern Container save 5.3 million kWh of energy annually since 2013. Southeastern Container is also expected to save $6.7 million over the life of the installed products. “Bowling Green is committed to the success of its local industries and businesses,” said Bowling Green Mayor Mike Aspacher. “Our community is also committed to the sustainability initiatives demonstrated by this project. I look forward to continuing our successful partnership with Southeastern Container and Efficiency Smart and applaud Southeastern Container’s commitment to sustainable solutions like energy efficiency.” Most recently, the plant worked with Efficiency Smart to install energy-efficient manufacturing equipment: an injection molding machine that produces small preform plastic containers and a blow molding machine that transforms the preforms into beverage bottles. The machines were a significant investment, but Efficiency Smart was able to verify that they would also deliver substantial energy savings. To further encourage the investment, Efficiency Smart provided a financial incentive to Southeastern Container to help with the cost of the upgrades.
Participation Fuels Strong Partnerships
From LED lighting projects to efficient industrial machinery and processes, Southeastern Container is committed to maximizing its energy-saving potential in Bowling Green. As a result, Southeastern Container’s relationship with Efficiency Smart and the City of Bowling Green has grown strong over the years. “Efficiency Smart and the Bowling Green electric utility have always been with us,” said John Johnson, General Manager. “It’s more than transactional; it has always been a partnership.” The Southeastern Container plant is considering the addition of two more energy-efficient molding machines. Efficiency Smart is excited to continue to work with Williams and his team to explore the savings potential of these and other efficiency projects. “What’s so crucial to Efficiency Smart and the utility is that the customer is thrilled with the work we did and feels we really are part of the team,” said Efficiency Smart Account Manager, Joey Boston. “When we need a new machine or program, we know that there is a potential incentive coming in addition to our energy savings—that is a good thing,” said Williams. “It’s another way to reduce our costs and justify our investments.”
Set Up an Efficiency Program Today
The City of Bowling Green Electric Department is one of the municipal electric utilities that takes advantage of the Efficiency Smart program to lower energy usage for commercial and residential customers. Since 2011, Efficiency Smart has helped residents and businesses use less energy and save money in more than 60 communities in four states. For more on how your business or community can engage, please contact us.
EFFICIENCYSMART.ORG48
Paj 49
Item 2.
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: Council Committee of the Whole (Utility) DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Water & Wastewater SUBMITTED ON: March 14, 2025 PREPARED BY: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services REVIEWED BY: David S. Hugg, III City Manager and Patricia M. Marney, Controller / Treasurer
SUBJECT: Evaluation of Proposals – PFAS Treatment Feasibility & Design TIMETABLE: Notice to proceed to be issued within thirty (30) days of Council approval. Project anticipated to be completed in three hundred and sixty five (365) calendar days. RELATED PROJECT: X REFERENCE: X
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $191,000
AMOUNT BUDGETED: $885,000
FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): Department of Water & Wastewater- Water Management, CIP Project #WD2508, CIP Project Name: PFAS WTP Improvements Account No.: 401-41-76-99-000-54031. This project is fully funded through the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law (BIL) – Emerging Contaminants Grant.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Award contract to Verdantas for the PFAS Treatment Feasibility & Design, RFP #25-0016WW, for the amount of $190,000.
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:
This capital investments calls for a feasibility study and design to improve the current infrastructure at the Water Treatment Plant to counter any PFAS / PFOA contamination. This is in response to the federal requirements of removing these chemicals from our drinking water.
The proposal was advertised to the public as a Request for Proposals in accordance with the City’s purchasing policy by the City’s Purchasing Agent under RFP #25-0016WW. Proposals were opened on February 11, 2025. The City of Dover received seven (7) proposals. Each proposal was rated in six (6) categories and evaluated by three (3) staff members. The proposal evaluations are as follows:
49
Paj 50
Item 2.
AVERAGE
| CONTRACTOR | LOCATION | TOTAL COST | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EVALUATED SCORE | ||||
| AECOM | NEWARK, DE | 71.17 | $635,000 | |
| CENTURY ENGINEERING | DOVER, DE | 81.60 | $239,135* | |
| HAZEN & SAWYER | BALTIMORE, MD | 66.23 | $650,956 | |
| MONTROSE ENVIRONMENTAL | WILMINGTON, DE | 83.77 | $190,000 | |
| PRESTIGE ENVIRONMENTAL | SOMERSET, NJ | 35.00 | $1,108,002` | |
| VERDANTAS | DOVER, DE | 84.30 | $191,000* | |
| WHITMAN, | REQUARDT | & BALTIMORE, MD | 73.67 | $79,556 |
| ASSOCIATES | ||||
| * - Century Engineering and Verdantas claimed local vendor preference which provided a 3% reduction on their evaluation | ||||
| score. | ||||
| ` - Prestige Environmental claimed minority owned vendor preference which provided a 3% reduction on their evaluation | ||||
| score. | ||||
City staff reviewed the submissions and found that the Montrose Environmental proposal met all requirements for the qualifications of the project and received the highest average score from the evaluators. The staff recommends awarding the contract to Verdantas in the amount of $191,000 for the PFAS Treatment Feasibility & Design.
50
Paj 51
Item 3.
PETITION TO ANNEX AND REZONE PROPERTY
Before the Dover City Council Committee of the Whole – Utility Committee March 25, 2025
File Number: AX-25-01
Ordinance Number: 2025-08
Applicant/ Owner of Robert Pellegrino
Record:
Property Address: 582 Acorn Lane, Dover DE
Tax Parcel ID #: ED-00-068.15-01-11.00-000
Lot Size: 2.3096 acres +/-
Present Zoning: RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone)
Proposed Zoning: R-8 (One Family Residence Zone)
2019 Comprehensive Category 1: High Priority Annexation Areas Plan Designation:
2019 Comprehensive Residential Low Density
Plan Land Use Category:
Present Use: Single Family Detached Dwelling
Proposed Use: Single Family Detached Dwelling
Utility Availability: Electric: 582 Acorn Lane is currently served by City of Dover Electric. With any future redevelopment of the property, the electric service needs will be evaluated. The property owner will be responsible for any and all costs associated with the changes in electrical service needs related to any future redevelopment including extending and providing service upgrades to the proposed property.
Water: 582 Acorn Lane is served by City of Dover Water. The property owner is responsible for any and all costs associated with changes to service needs for property including extending
51
Paj 52
Item 3.
and providing service upgrades to the existing dwelling on the property or to any new parcel created in the future,
Sanitary Sewer: 582 Acorn Lane is not served by Sanitary Sewer. Sanitary Sewer is available for this property. The property owner is responsible for any and all costs associated with changes to service needs for property including extending and providing service upgrades to the existing dwelling on the property, this will include an assessment of $40 per front footage of the property for sanitary sewer, which shall be paid by the property owner prior to connection. Impact fees will also apply to this connection.
Staff Recommendation The Electric Department has no objection to the annexation. for AX-25-01: The Department of Water & Wastewater has no objection to the annexation.
Attachments:
• Location Map of AX-25-01
• Property Plan of 582 Acorn Lane
52
Paj 53
Item 3.
53
Paj 54
Item 3.
54
Paj 55
Item 1.
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: City Council DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Central Services SUBMITTED ON: March 12, 2025 PREPARED BY: Barry Wolfgang, Contract & Procurement Manager REVIEWED BY: David S. Hugg, III, City Manager and Patricia M. Marney, Controller / Treasurer
SUBJECT: FY25 CIP Budget – Fuel Pump Island Upgrade TIMETABLE: Notice to proceed to be issued immediately upon Council approval RELATED PROJECT: N/A REFERENCE: CIP- CS2502
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $680,400
AMOUNT BUDGETED: $ 600,000 (additional funds details below) FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): Central Services / Page 116
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Approve the proposal of $680,400 submitted by Coastal Pump & Tank in RFP 25-0017WH.
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:
The budget shortfall is being made up with savings on other projects that have been completed. $65,000 from project #FC2402 City Hall Painting and $18,000 from project #FC2303 City Hall Window Replacement have been added to the budget to give us a total of $683,000 available for this project. In recent years, the pumps have been having an increasing number of issues causing downtime. and parts are getting harder for our contractor to obtain for repairs. This style of suction pump is no longer in common use and no one stocks repair parts for them. The currently used dispensers have a pump inside the tank as they are more reliable and easier to maintain. We are also adding a dispenser for DEF fluid as our fleet now has multiple diesel vehicles (line trucks, refuse trucks, fire trucks, etc.) that require it, and all new diesel vehicles will require it going forward. In addition, the underground tanks are at the end of their useful life (30 years approximately) and need to be replaced. Insurance companies will stop providing insurance after a certain age due to higher probability with corrosion of the steel tank. The canopy that is presently covering the pumps is too small and too low for some of the new trucks (City Fleet and Fire Department) to fit under for fueling. They must stay a distance from the pumps to avoid hitting the rain gutters.
55
Paj 56
Item 1.
Proposals were opened on Thursday, February 13, 2025, at 2:00 pm. Two contractors submitted proposals for the proposed Fuel Pump Island Upgrade. The contract proposals are as follows:
| Contractor | Location | Proposal Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Coastal Pump & Tank | Harrington, DE | $680,400 |
TTI Environmental Moorestown, NJ $986,478
Each proposal was evaluated on six factors, which included experience, capabilities, work plan, cost, project history, and location related to the City of Dover. Based upon this comprehensive evaluation, Coastal Pump & Tank scored the highest with a 98.3 average (TTI average was 90.3)
ACTION REQUESTED:
The Council Committee of the Whole approve the project award to Coastal Pump & Tank as requested.
56