Deklarasyon Brian E. Lewis
654 deklarasyon ki soti nan anrejistreman reyinyon, reyinyon ki pi resan an an premye.
Transkripsyon otomatik. Se yon machin ki mare deklarasyon yo ak ofisyèl sa a, epi li ka fè erè. Tcheke anrejistreman an.
Deklarasyon yo ak tit reyinyon yo parèt an anglè, lang yo te pale nan reyinyon yo. AskDover pa tradui yo.
8 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
I kindly took silence over this uh this code uh other than uh or this proposed ordinance, other than uh asking uh questions to our police chief. But uh over the weekend, I've done some research, and uh I uh went in depth and actually uh even spoke to uh an acquaintance who is a uh US District Court judge, uh and I wrote a statement out that I'd like to read into the record as I just so indicated. Uh while safety is undoubtedly important, it must be achieved within the framework of individual freedom and limited government interventions to ensure a thriving and vibrant society. We must remember sacrificing too much freedom in the name of safety can lead down a perilous path. To maintain a just and prosperous society, it is essential to cherish and uphold the principle of individual liberty. Courts have consistently determined that the act of asking for money in public space
Jwe apati 1:45:578 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
constitutes a form of speech protected by the First Amendment. Let's face it, folks. Um, you know, we all know that this ordinance originated, okay, by panhandling in the city. Okay? It wasn't originated by the fire department out there soliciting for funds for the fire department, or um school children uh working fundraisers and holding car wash signs. Are they not safety issues, too? How come we're not addressing those? Okay?
Jwe apati 1:46:598 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Uh let me further read on. "This protection extends beyond political or artistic expression to include solicitation for immediate personal financial assistance. The U.S. Supreme Court has affirmed that soliciting charitable contributions is a protected form of speech. The lower courts have broadly applied this principle to individual panhandling. Therefore, any government attempt to prohibit this activity is viewed as restriction on speech. A law that fails any part of this three-part test is likely to be found unconstitutional. A city cannot ban panhandling simply because some people find it annoying or because officials want to improve the city's image," Mr. Mayor. "Courts have found that this government's interest in, for example, preventing nuisance is not compelling enough to justify a content-based ban on panhandling. Any ordinance that singles out the act of begging or prohibition while allowing other forms of public address or solicitation will likely be invalidated." Now the public brought up some um some very interesting topics uh at our
Jwe apati 1:47:308 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
last meeting and tonight's meeting. And I wrote a couple of them down. And one of them, is it a fair, is it fair to restrict the speech of those in need, number one? Number two, again, okay, I know we can't uh discriminate against panhandling, but again, I think this ordinance originated from that, in my opinion. Do panhandling bans address the problem or do they simply push out of sight? And the last and final um statement that was brought up by many people that were in attendance at the last meeting and tonight's meeting is, should the City of Dover focus more on providing resources like housing, mental health services, and job training instead of penalizing those on the medians? I think those things um are very valid and I thank the public for bringing those up. And that's all I have. Well, with that, thank you and good night.
Jwe apati 1:48:468 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Councilwoman Hall, I have them on my phone, can I bring them over to you?
Jwe apati 1:58:098 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Make sure these are the right ones. Thank you. There's another two down here.
Jwe apati 1:58:188 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
To make it easier, these are the two down here.
Jwe apati 1:58:298 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
All right. Thank you. Under Title 21, and this is 4146, pedestrians in roadways obstructing traffic, 4146(a) states a pedestrian cannot stand in a roadway if it interferes with traffic flow. And then (b), a pedestrian cannot walk along or stand on the roadway when a sidewalk is available. And then if you go under Title 21 4177(b), obstruction of driver's view: a person cannot be positioned in a way that blocks or interferes with a driver's clear view of the roadway. Title 21 4144 states pedestrians right-of-way on sidewalks and safety zones...
Jwe apati 1:58:438 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
areas. Um so that's what I googled and uh just found. I don't know if they're the statute you were referring to,
Jwe apati 1:59:288 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Title 21, which we currently have that the police department can and should be enforced. Thank you.
Jwe apati 1:59:368 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
So the portions of section uh um the code for 21, everything that was read is basically for the solicitor, that was what you were referring to that the Attorney General said that they would not enforce?
Jwe apati 2:03:048 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Why Why can't we just ask for a report from somebody over at DelDOT to submit to us with respect to their opinion?
Jwe apati 2:46:018 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Well, instead of getting the mayor involved, I would suggest the solicitor reach out to them. And otherwise, I can't support this ordinance- excuse- this motion.
Jwe apati 2:46:168 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Um good evening. I have a question uh with respect to uh I have your action form right here, and uh my question is how does it how does it qualify as sole source of procurement? Because I looked up the uh City of Dover purchasing policy and procedures, and uh section six, exceptions, it states sole source procurement is not permissible unless a requirement is available from only a single supplier manufacturer. Um it goes on to say, "The following are examples of circumstances which could necessitate sole source procurement. Uh a, where the compatibility of equipment, accessories, uh, or replacement parts is the uh paramount consideration. Um then b, where the sole supplier item is needed for trial use or testing." That's my first question. My second question is, who's this being awarded to? Awarded to whom?
Jwe apati 2:57:118 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Yeah, I wouldn't want anybody to do anything, uh, illicit or not by the policy. That's why I bring it to your attention.
Jwe apati 2:59:178 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Um, now who's this going to be awarded to?
Jwe apati 3:00:068 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
Okay. Thank you. Um that's all the questions I have at this time. I may come back uh
Jwe apati 3:00:348 desanm 2025, Regular Council Meeting
For the record, I'm just going to abstain on this action.
Jwe apati 3:01:0725 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
that in the next month or two, um, if uh some of that is uh developed. I yield, Mr. President.
Jwe apati 03:1625 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Thank you, and good evening.
Jwe apati 49:3725 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
I uh I'm looking here at the box with the map in it that you are referring to,
Jwe apati 49:3925 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Yeah.
Jwe apati 49:4325 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
and I note that it states on the um bottom um the last sentence, "City declined to apply."
Jwe apati 49:4425 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Could you explain that? Are you referring to uh or is this referring to the city of Dover?
Jwe apati 49:5025 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
And if so, uh do you know why? And if that's the case, then I would assume the city of Dover would not be included. Am I correct?
Jwe apati 50:2325 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Okay. If you look in the box, right?
Jwe apati 50:3625 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Last sentence: "City declined to apply." Explain that to me, please.
Jwe apati 50:3925 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Okay, because th- this map is kind of hard to see.
Jwe apati 51:4925 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
I mean, it's it's it's minute.
Jwe apati 51:5225 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
So, I'm trying to ascertain like as far as uh safety concerns, you know, what areas in the city of Dover um has this affected, and I can't see. Is there any way you can get us a bigger map?
Jwe apati 51:5425 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
And what I'm also looking And and what I'm also looking for is like a breakdown as far as safety issues when it comes to uh fatalities of, you know, people crossing the street. I mean, I'd like a breakdown of what those fatalities were. Was it that uh somebody was crossing the street and and got run over by a vehicle, or was it somebody on a bicycle, uh
Jwe apati 52:1325 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Where can I get that information? Where can I get those statistics that are specific to those fatalities? Police department don't have it.
Jwe apati 52:2525 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
I don't believe the police department has it.
Jwe apati 52:3425 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
DelDOT has it? Okay.
Jwe apati 52:3825 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Okay.
Jwe apati 52:4625 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Okay. I mean this stuff is important.
Jwe apati 53:0025 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Thank you. No further questions.
Jwe apati 53:0325 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Mr. Hugg, um, I have a question for you. It may be a little off topic, but it has to do with the uh, CTP projects uh, and funding. Um, the money um, that's allocated uh, for these projects, uh, is it stipulated that um, it only address road work and sidewalk work? Or could it be used for miscellaneous things? Example, cameras, signs, etc.?
Jwe apati 1:10:1625 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Could you possibly uh, look into that and update the council uh, to include speed cameras, etc.? And um, as you're aware, I have a project in my district that's not part of the list that's currently before us, but I'm trying to address the camera issue, as we previously discussed via emails. And I know there's some issues with funding, and I was wondering if maybe we would be able to draw from one of these projects or CTF funds.
Jwe apati 1:11:2725 novanm 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting
Okay, I look forward to hearing back from you.
Jwe apati 1:12:26