Ir al contenido principal
AskDover

Special LF&A Minutes with Attachments 1-3

Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee. 9 de julio de 2026.

Abrir el PDF (6.8 MB)

Este texto se extrajo de el PDF de forma automática y puede contener errores. El PDF es el registro oficial, así que consúltelo antes de confiar en esto.

16 páginas tienen poco o ningún texto legible aquí, a menudo por ser escaneos o dibujos. Para verlas, consulte el PDF.

Página 1

SPECIAL LEGISLATIVE FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

A Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee Meeting was held on July 09, 2026, at 6:00 p.m. with Chairman Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Council President Neil, Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lewis, Dr. Pillsbury, and Dr. Sudler. Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, and Ms. Hall were absent. Mayor Christiansen was also absent. Civilian members present were Mr. Garfinkel and Mr. Shevock (Legislative, Finance, and Administration).

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.

Discussion on the FY2026-27 Long-Term Fiscal Solvency, Wealth, and Health Optimization of The Capital of Delaware (Councilman Sudler and Councilman Lewis) Before the discussion began, Council President Neil read into the record a statement regarding the proposal (Attachment #1).

Dr. Sudler thanked Mr. Anderson for allowing the presentation to be included on a special meeting agenda for an extensive discussion.

Dr. Sudler requested that Ms. Arielle Rivera, Assistant City Clerk, read the questions submitted by Mr. Anderson and the responses provided by Dr. Sudler (Attachment #2).

Mr. Garfinkel thanked Dr. Sudler for the presentation and commented on the thoroughness of the presentation. He emphasized the importance of planning for the future. He stated that the costs of providing services should be shared by those who benefit from them, either directly or indirectly, rather than relying primarily on taxpayers.

Mr. Rocha expressed appreciation for initiating the discussion early in the fiscal year rather than near the end of the budget cycle. He commended Dr. Sudler and Mr. Lewis for listening to both the community and council's concerns. He stated that the proactive approach would better position the city to prepare for future fiscal challenges.

Mr. Lewis stated that the proposal had been made available online. He encouraged the public to review the proposal and stated that the city should address the issue rather than continue delaying action. He explained that the proposal, developed with Dr. Sudler, was intended to help reduce the financial burden on residents and taxpayers.

William Faust, Jr., Dover, stated that he had reviewed the proposal and questioned how existing tax abatements for downtown development projects would affect it. He expressed support for the proposal, stating that it was intended to reduce the financial burden on residents and that no alternative proposal had been presented. He also shared concerns about rising utility costs, the economic challenges facing residents and local businesses, and encouraged council to work together to identify a long-term solution.

Bonnie Pennington, Dover, thanked Mr. Lewis and Dr. Sudler for developing the proposal and expressed her support for the idea. She stated that the proposal would benefit residents broadly

Página 2

SPECIAL LEGISLATIVE FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE MEETING OF JULY 09, 2026 PAGE 2

and acknowledged the financial challenges many individuals face with increasing costs of living, including household expenses, medical costs, and utility bills.

Vonderlear Smack, Dover, thanked Mr. Lewis and Dr. Sudler for listening to constituents and bringing forward the proposal. She stated that she had been raising concerns about increasing electric rates for several years and shared that she has received calls from elderly residents seeking assistance with utility bills. Ms. Smack asked whether the city could consider rolling back the most recent rate increase to provide relief for residents on fixed incomes.

Responding to Ms. Smack, Dr. Sudler stated that the proposal would provide a mechanism for reallocating surplus funds back to residents and constituents in future years, pending council’s approval and the proposal's implementation. He stated that the plan would increase baseline revenue or reserves in the first year and, if projections are met, could allow for reductions in utility costs and potentially help offset future tax increases. He acknowledged that relief would not occur immediately but stated that the proposal represented a step toward addressing long-term financial concerns. Dr. Sudler also noted that the city has customer assistance programs available and referred residents to Customer Service for additional information.

Dr. Sudler reviewed the presentation entitled “Growth Pays for Growth” (Attachment #3).

Mr. Garfinkel moved to accept the Capital Area Municipality Sustainability Act (CAMSA) presentation and authorize City Manager Sharon Duca and the municipal budget team to conduct a rigorous sustainability, feasibility, and validity appraisal of the “Growth Pays for Growth” conceptual model, establishment of Section 49A (Municipal Services Impact Fee) by August 24, 2026. The motion was seconded by Mr. Shevock.

Mr. Rocha asked how the proposal would impact the city's budget structure and enterprise funds, specifically, and whether utility fees associated with electric and water services would remain in place or be restructured under the proposed method.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Dr. Sudler stated that, to his understanding, the enterprise fund fees would continue but could potentially be reduced. He stated that further discussion and review would be needed to determine the specific impact and suggested that additional information could be provided by the Controller and Treasurer.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, stated that the proposal would require further review, including research and discussions with other municipalities regarding similar approaches. She explained that enterprise funds and the General Fund must remain separate and that utility fees would continue because they cover the costs associated with operating and maintaining specific utilities. She clarified that the proposal could potentially provide an alternative funding source for certain capital and infrastructure costs, which could help reduce portions of utility charges. Ms. Marney noted that usage-based fees would remain in place, while the proposal could potentially impact customer charges associated with infrastructure costs.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney used the example of an electric bill. She stated that the customer charge covers the cost of bringing the transformers and putting the infrastructure in place. The usage fee is the amount the customer has used. She noted that, from her interpretation, it would be reducing the customer fee.

Página 3

SPECIAL LEGISLATIVE FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE MEETING OF JULY 09, 2026 PAGE 3

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney stated that the implementation details would need further development if the proposal moved forward. She explained that the structure of any potential transfer between funds would need to be clearly defined, documented, and aligned with each fund's designated purposes, with final decisions to be made by council.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney stated that the city receives approximately $450,000 from the State of Delaware and 1.6 million from the Grant-in-aid funding, which was allocated to public safety and higher education funds.

Ms. Marney stated that she believed the proposal was worth exploring but that it would require additional discussion and could present implementation challenges. She advised that implementation may not be feasible until Fiscal Year 2028 and explained that the approach would depend on how council chooses to structure and bill the proposed fee. Ms. Marney noted that changes to the city's billing and accounting systems could be required, resulting in implementation costs and additional time before the proposal could be put into effect. She explained that Seattle uses their tax billing system to bill their fee.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney stated that there appears to be a path to establishing the proposed revenue as a restricted fund dedicated to specific purposes, such as reducing utility costs and funding infrastructure improvements. She explained that the implementation would depend on how the proposal is structured and drafted and would require amendments to the City Charter and Code of Ordinances, along with further evaluation of the proposal's details.

Mr. Anderson stated that the proposal represented the beginning of a longer process and noted that it would require a fiscal note, which distinguishes it from many other charter amendments. He expressed support for placing the matter on a future agenda to allow for further consideration and potential coordination with the state's budget process. Mr. Anderson encouraged public engagement and support for the proposal, stating that its advancement would require participation from both city officials and residents. He also referenced examples from other municipalities that receive state support through similar funding mechanisms, such as Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, which received $5 million from the State of Pennsylvania for its PILOT.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Marney stated that Wilmington received millions in PILOT funding because of the language in the state code governing PILOT. She explained that they received one hundred percent of their taxable value, whereas, by code, the City of Dover receives only thirty percent. Additionally, she noted that the amount billed exceeded the state budget, so the City of Dover PILOT was reduced by $885,000. However, Mr. Anderson was able to recoup those funds.

Mr. Anderson explained that he questioned the city’s PILOT funding and was told it was awarded to Wilmington because its taxes increased. He thanked Senator Paradee and Senator Pettyjohn for their assistance, noting that Georgetown was affected as well. He stated that the proposed legislation could provide greater statutory predictability for future funding but emphasized that it would require thorough legal and fiscal review, broad support, and significant advocacy to secure the necessary approval.

Dr. Pillsbury expressed concern that the proposal could shift costs to other entities, which might result in increased costs elsewhere. She noted that, while she was not opposed to the proposal, she

Página 4

SPECIAL LEGISLATIVE FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE MEETING OF JULY 09, 2026 PAGE 4

believed it was important to consider the potential broader financial impacts of reallocating those costs.

Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Dr. Sudler stated that the proposal was designed to protect residents by providing a mechanism to reduce and potentially freeze residential utility costs over time. He stated that larger institutions have additional resources and funding mechanisms, such as grants and bond bill money, available to offset increased costs. In contrast, individual residents often have fewer options for financial relief. He emphasized that the proposal would provide residents with additional support in managing their monthly financial obligations.

Mr. Neil stated that he would support moving the proposal forward to allow staff to evaluate its feasibility, identify potential challenges, and provide a report to council. He acknowledged that the proposal may receive significant feedback and discussion from various stakeholders due to its potential impact. Mr. Neil stated that he believed the proposal warranted further review, particularly given that a portion of the city's population does not pay property taxes. He emphasized the importance of understanding the proposal's practicality and potential outcomes before proceeding further.

Mr. Anderson requested that Ms. Rivera read back the motion.

Ms. Rivera stated that Mr. Garfinkel moved to accept the Capital Area Municipality Sustainability Act (CAMSA) presentation and authorize City Manager Sharon Duca and the municipal budget team to conduct a rigorous sustainability, feasibility, and validity appraisal of the “Growth Pays for Growth” conceptual model, establishment of Section 49A (Municipal Services Impact Fee) by August 24, 2026. The motion was seconded by Mr. Shevock.

Mr. Anderson noted that the second set of meetings in August would be canceled, and the intention is to have the item back on the agenda in September so that a Resolution can be adopted by council before the end of September, allowing the General Assembly to begin lobbying for the city. He also recommended an amendment to add a legal review to the motion.

Mr. Garfinkel stated that he was in favor of the amendment. Mr. Shevock, the seconder, was in favor of the amendment. The amendment to add a legal review to the motion was unanimously adopted.

Mr. Faust expressed support for the proposal and encouraged those with concerns or alternative viewpoints to present other solutions. He stated that the city must continue working toward making Dover an affordable and safe place to live and expressed concerns about the impact of rising costs on residents. Mr. Faust commended Mr. Lewis and Dr. Sudler for developing and presenting the proposal and encouraged continued discussion and consideration of solutions to address the city's financial challenges.

LaChelle Paul, Dover, stated that she had reviewed the proposal in detail and provided comments regarding potential legal, funding, and implementation considerations. She stated that the proposed charge would likely need to be structured as a fee rather than a tax due to limitations related to taxing nonprofit organizations. Ms. Paul expressed concerns regarding the sustainability of grant funding and recommended establishing a cap on potential charges to ensure the proposal remains manageable for affected entities and other municipalities. She noted the importance of carefully

Página 5

SPECIAL LEGISLATIVE FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE MEETING OF JULY 09, 2026 PAGE 5

structuring the proposal to avoid shifting costs to residents through other organizations and stated that additional safeguards could improve the likelihood of legislative approval.

Responding to Ms. Duca, Dr. Sudler stated that MSIF was intended to be a municipal service infrastructure fee strictly for infrastructure.

Responding to Ms. Duca, Dr. Sudler stated that he initially proposed using the gross square footage. However, he noted that they can continue additional research into how other municipalities are implementing it.

Ms. Duca stated that staff had initiated the process of reviewing priority-based budgeting for Fiscal Year 2028. She explained that department heads had begun evaluating Fiscal Year 2026 operations and that additional work would be needed to analyze programs and priorities under this approach. Ms. Duca stated that staff intends to bring forward a proposal to council early in the process for review and consideration by both council and the public.

Mr. Garfinkel moved to accept the Capital Area Municipality Sustainability Act (CAMSA) presentation and authorize Sharon Duca, City Manager, and the municipal budget team to conduct a rigorous sustainability, feasibility, and validity appraisal of the “Growth Pays for Growth” conceptual model, establishment of Section 49A (Municipal Services Impact Fee), and a complete legal review by the first meeting in September. The motion was seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously carried.

Mr. Anderson noted that the Legislative, Finance, and Administration meeting of July 28, 2026, would be canceled.

Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 7:29 p.m.

David L. Anderson
Chair, Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee

Attachments
Attachment #1 – Council President Neils' remarks
Attachment #2 – Mr. Anderson and Dr. Sudler's email correspondence
Attachment #3 – Presentation Entitled “Growth Pays for Growth”

Página 6

ATTACHMENT #1

Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration Meeting of 07/09/2026

Página 7

ATTACHMENT #2

Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration Meeting of 07/09/2026

Página 11

ATTACHMENT #3

Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration Meeting of 07/09/2026

"Growth Pays for Growth" Sponsored By: Roy Sudler, Jr., Ph.D. District 4 Councilman and Brian Lewis District 2 Councilman © 2026 Roy Sudler, Jr., Ph.D. All Rights Reserved.

Página 12

Capital Area

CAMS

Municipality
Sustainability
Act (CAMSA)
CAMSA successfully reduces regressive tax burdens on
residents, secures the city's revenue engine, and promotes the
long-term fiscal and structural sustainability of the Dover
community.

Backing this revenue pipeline is an optimized Priority-Based Budgeting (PBB) model ensuring 100% compliance with Revenue Policy Mandates 1 and 7 of the city budget.

Pitch deck title 2
7/15/2026

Página 13

PROBLEM

PROBLEM

ECONOMIC GAP SYSTEMIC STRUCTURAL GAP:

No matter how massive tax-exempt 45% of the real property physical footprint grows or how much footprint is tax-exempt, forcing market value their buildings the remaining 55% of taxable command, their ad valorem property properties (working families and tax bill remains exactly $0.00. local shopkeepers) to absorb 100% of the financial burden for public assets utilized by the entire state. PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT AND ORGANIZATIONAL JUSTICE NON-TAX-EXEMPT FOOTPRINTS “Incremental budgeting" represents the Traditional municipal budgeting models ultimate failure of goal-setting theory. are failing mid-sized capital cities Shifting the cost burden back to the because they lack modern regulatory entities driving the asset exhaustion frameworks to recover infrastructure restores the psychological contract, wear-and-tear costs from the mega- driving a sense of institutional equity scale, tax-exempt institutional growth and shared community purpose. driving those very costs. 7/14/20XX Pitch deck title

Página 14

BAYHEALTH MEDICAL CENTER

7/14/20XX Pitch deck title 4

Página 15

THE DELAWARE
BAYHEALTH STATE
MEDICAL CENTER
UNIVERSITY

7/14/20XX Pitch deck title 5

Página 16

LEGISLATIVE HALL DELAWARE STATE CAPITAL

7/14/20XX Pitch deck title 6

Página 17

SOLUTION

CLOSE THE GAP

By shifting our budget mindset to an external revenue- generating framework

TARGET AUDIENCE

Mega-scale Institutional, Medical, and educational footprints.

COST SAVINGS

Under CAMSA's framework, financial resources will ne returned back to residents in the form of lower utility bills.

PREDICTABLE CAPITAL FORECASTS:

Priority-Based Budgeting (PBB) channels MSIF revenues
directly into dedicated infrastructure funds, removing
unpredictable capital project deficits from the general fund.
7

Página 18

Comparative UNIQUE TESTED IN OTHER Fiscal Analysis CAMSA breaks this cycle by CAPITAL CITIES Hartford, CT Olympia, generating $12,990,000 WA and Albany, NY. annually, immediately Dover remains the only transferring $2 million in capital city listed that Year 1 to permanently raise forces local residential the city's emergency reserve utility users to entirely floor to an unassailable absorb state-driven 11.35% statutory baseline infrastructure decay. ($6.78 million)

Página 19

LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

9

Página 20

Hard Reality & Technical Validity

Página 21

BUSINESS MODEL

RESEARCH ABSTRACT DESIGN

Capital Area Equity in Growth Biopsychosocial Municipality Large-scale, tax-exempt Model is not treated as Sustainability Act entities must generate an abstract healthcare (CAMSA) is built upon the capital required to theory. data-driven municipal sustain the public finance strategies infrastructure they Instead, they designed to shift the exhaust. operationalize it as a burden of infrastructure concrete municipal costs away from fiscal strategy. everyday taxpayers.

11

Página 22

Clarifying the Council’s Legal Mandate

  • A.Legal Incontrovertibility Article III, Section 18 of the Dover Charter vests City Council with the explicit legislative authority to pass ordinances, ensuring the power to set penalties for violations
  • B.Fixing a Structural Injustice: City Council and the Budget Team cannot ignore the math: 45% of Dover’s property footprint is tax- exempt, forcing the remaining 55% of taxable properties (residents and small businesses) to shoulder 100% of the maintenance burden for public grids.

12

Página 23

13

Página 24

FIVE-YEAR ALLOCATION FORECAST

14

Página 26

FORMAL REQUEST FOR STATE BOND BILL

CAPITAL ABSORPTION

CAPITAL ABSORPTION

To prevent the Municipal Services Impact Fee from draining individual institutional and agency operational budgets, the City of Dover formally requests that the Joint Capital Improvement Committee utilize its statutory authority to issue a direct cash premium or a general obligation bond allocation paid directly to the City of Dover. This dedicated capital allocation will seamlessly absorb the infrastructure wear-and-tear costs generated by the following state-supported footprints: ┌── Higher Education Footprints (Ranks 1, 3, 5, 9, 14) │ Combined GSF: 5,100,000 GSF ➔ $5,100,000.00 State Bond Allocation │ STATE LEVEL EXPOSURE ─────┼── State Executive & Agency Complexes (Ranks 4, 6, 12, 19) [Total: $8,310,000] │ Combined GSF: 2,230,000 GSF ➔ $2,230,000.00 State Bond Allocation │ └── Legislative & Judicial Complexes (Ranks 10, 15) 16 Combined GSF: 730,000 GSF ➔ $730,000.00 State Bond Allocation

Página 27

CAMSA Master Structural Overview

$12.9M $12.9M 12.9M

Year 1 Year 2 The Year 3 Permanently raise Sunset Target Upward Capital the city's emergency sweeping subsequent Re-allocation direct, reserve floor to an surpluses into direct proportional reductions unassailable 11.35% residential utility bill in existing residential statutory baseline reductions utility bills for Dover's ($6.78 million). working families.

17

Página 28

(MSIF)- BENEFITS

➢ Capital City 2030: Strategic Master Plan
for Downtown Dover Partnership

➢ State-Sanctioned Sovereignty
Section 49A's Municipal Services Impact
Fee

➢ Biopsychosocial Optimization
(Optimal Health & Financial Stability)

➢ Concrete Immunity Against
Corporate Litigation

➢ Protected Asset Environments

➢ Transparent Valuation
Pitch deck title 18

Página 29

MARKET COMPARISON

Funding Metric Resident Tax Hike Proposed MSIF

Annual Cost $841.29 $0.00

Opportunity to build Freedom to invent Few competitors
MonthlyAddressable
Cost market $70.11 Serviceable market $0.00 Obtainable market

Utility Rates +12% to 15% Spike Frozen (0%)

Small non-profits Burdened 100% Exempt
19

Página 30

Infrastructure Works & Workforce Stability

Convenient

A

Expensive Affordable

D C

E B

20

Página 31

The "Lockbox" Funding Model

Fire Department: Police Department:
Operational Solvency Operational Solvency

7/14/20XX 21

Página 32

Utility Grid Stress ($0.22 / GSF) Metric: Thermal Transformer Aging. Continuous high demand (12.5 VA/GSF) overheats substation transformers, reducing equipment lifecycles by 35%. 7/14/20XX Pitch deck title 22

Página 33

REBUTTAL & DEFENSE MATRIX (CAMSA PROPOSAL)

23

Página 34

MATHEMATICAL FORMULAS FOR CAMSA MATRIX

The Scenario: Let's look at a group of Dover residents. o Baseline (Start): 100 ER visits and 100 checkups. o Year 1 (After CAMSA): ER visits drop to 80, and regular checkups rise to 120. • The Simple Math: o ER visits dropped by \(20\%\) (80 out of 100). o Checkups increased by \(20\%\) (120 out of 100).

© 2026 Roy Sudler, Jr., Ph.D. All Rights Reserved.
7/7/2026 24

Página 35

The Dover Biopsychosocial Health & Stability Survey In the past 30 days, have you experienced When walking through your immediate neighborhood physical symptoms of chronic stress (such as or using local public parks, how safe do you feel from frequent tension headaches, unexplained chest open-air illicit drug activity, vandalism, or poorly lit tightness, racing heart, or severe sleep public pathways? disruption) brought on by worrying about your • Very unsafe; I actively avoid public areas in my household finances? neighborhood. (4) • Daily or almost daily (4) • Somewhat unsafe; I only use public spaces during • A few times a week (3) specific peak hours. (2) • Once or twice a month (2) • Completely safe; I utilize local parks and walkways • Rarely or never (0) confidently. (0)

7/14/20XX Pitch deck title 25

Página 36

Councilman MOVE to accept the Sudler & Lewis’s Capital Area Municipality Sustainability Act Recommendation: (CAMSA) Presentation and Authorize City Manager Sharon Duca, and the Municipal Budget Team to conduct a rigorous Sustainability, Feasibility, and Validity Appraisal of this “Growth Pays for Growth” Conceptual Model and ESTABLISHMENT OF SECTION 49A (MUNICIPAL SERVICES IMPACT FEE) by August 24, 2026.

© 2026 Roy Sudler, Jr., Ph.D. All Rights Reserved.
7/7/2026 26

Volver a esta reunión