Ir al contenido principal
AskDover

Transcripción: Council Committee of the Whole

Martes, 10 de noviembre de 2026

Transcripción automática. Una máquina identificó los nombres de quienes hablan y puede equivocarse. Consulte la grabación.

La transcripción se muestra en inglés, el idioma que se habló en la reunión. AskDover no la traduce.

Mostrando 408 de 408 declaraciones

Fred A. Neil

Call the Committee of the Whole meeting of Tuesday, November 10th, 2026 to order. I would like to remind the public that the public comments are welcome on any item and will be permitted at the appropriate time. You have before you this evening's agenda. I'll entertain a motion for its adoption.

Reproducir desde 00:00

Brian E. Lewis

Move to adopt.

Reproducir desde 00:13

Fred A. Neil

It's moved and seconded. Any questions? If not, all in favor please say aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, it passes unanimously.

Reproducir desde 00:14

Fred A. Neil

At this time, uh I will uh have the on the agenda are council reports, and I believe both Dr. Pillsbury and uh Mr. Rocha are absent from the First District. Mr. Lewis, in the Second District.

Reproducir desde 00:22

Brian E. Lewis

I'll be short this evening. I have no report.

Reproducir desde 00:32

Fred A. Neil

Was that it? Miss Hall, Councilwoman Hall is online. Miss Hall?

Reproducir desde 00:36

Donyale M. Hall

I've just been uh taking and working uh with a few um constituents uh that they have uh brought in, brought down. I've been successful at getting those to the people who they belong to. So I thank all the city staff that um worked on those things for me, and uh that would conclude my report. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 01:09

Fred A. Neil

Thank you. Third District, Councilwoman Arndt.

Reproducir desde 01:23

Tricia K. Arndt

Nothing.

Reproducir desde 01:25

Fred A. Neil

Fourth District, Dr. Sudler.

Reproducir desde 01:28

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you, Mr. President. On November the 8th, I attended the Dover Housing Authority community day, and just listened to some of my constituents in regards to the sprinkler system uh mandate in conjunction to uh the LD, opioid use disorder uh task force. It was some attended, and it went well, and they got listened to. Other than that, I yield.

Reproducir desde 01:29

Fred A. Neil

Councilman Anderson.

Reproducir desde 02:08

David L. Anderson

Uh thank you, Mr. President. Uh I am pleased to uh report that he has been uh had a lot of physical uh impact through the efforts the staff's been been making uh when it comes to uh different efforts of uh of uh improvement, quality of life improvement. Everything from uh street lights to the uh condemning of uh of certain nuisance properties including uh some that become known from vacant buildings. Uh we've also wanted to thank uh the all the diverse squad, from the police, to the to our state federal partners, to code enforcement and others when it comes to uh uh South Governors Avenue in the area. That's uh has has been very and and even public works uh when it comes to uh um moving certain trash cans and things of that nature. Uh this uh this have gotten a lot of positive feedback from the residents there. And uh I just want to thank uh the city staff for for uh because it's uh making a real difference in in the area. Uh we I want to thank the Mayor for his volunteerism as well, because that's that's also been important. And uh we also had uh of course uh this also pertains to the moving of uh things, essential services, and stuff like that. Uh I want to thank uh the the Dover Police Department and the Chief of Police and the recruiter for uh a personal donation they made to to uh help a family in in need. I can't go into detail into the public forum, but that is this is how broad the outreach and the uh well really needs some help from our state partners, and I want to thank uh Representative Gray for for sending in help and and uh trying to help out these. And uh we are we had a great uh restart of a Veterans Day activity at uh Sankore Academy, high school Sankore. It was a a great uh restart of a something we hadn't had for 50 years, since 1974. And I I hope they're able to continue that on an annual basis. And I want to thank everyone here on both sides of the sprinkler issue. We've been hearing from you. We look forward to hearing what you have to say tonight. I yield, Mr. President.

Reproducir desde 02:09

Fred A. Neil

Thank you. In the absence of uh Councilman-at-Large Boggerty, I'm up. And uh we had participated on the uh Construction and Property Maintenance Appeals hearing held on November the 5th with Chairman Boggerty and Councilman Rocha and our civilian board members. Responded to news media inquiries and numerous uh emails on the sprinkler ordinance uh that we'll be hearing again tonight in the new form. And that is the end of our reports from the uh members of the council. Uh in the absence of uh Chairman Rocha of the Utility Committee, uh his substitute will take over, and with that I will request the adoption of the Utility agenda.

Reproducir desde 05:10

Brian E. Lewis

Move to adopt.

Reproducir desde 06:05

Fred A. Neil

Second? It's been uh seconded and uh any discussion? All in favor please say aye. Any objection? No objections, it passes unanimously.

Reproducir desde 06:07

Fred A. Neil

The evaluation bid of the Cedar uh the Cedar Chase pump station replacement by Kate Mills, Water and Water Wastewater Director. And welcome in your new capacity.

Reproducir desde 06:17

Kate Mills

Thank you. Uh Kate Mills, Director of Water, Wastewater, and Engineering Services. Uh just here to present our uh evaluation of bids for the Cedar Chase pump station replacement. Staff only received two bids for the project, and uh we're recommending that we move forward and we accept the bid uh from Teal Construction Company. I'll open up for any questions.

Reproducir desde 06:26

Fred A. Neil

Any questions?

Reproducir desde 06:40

Brian E. Lewis

Uh one question. Uh are we within our budget for this?

Reproducir desde 07:06

Kate Mills

Uh so we were uh $100 over our budget, but we are we had savings from another pump station replacement project that we're able to use to cover that $100 and thirty-some dollars.

Reproducir desde 07:10

Brian E. Lewis

Okay. And uh as for the bidding process, uh do you know, did uh we inquire of what other municipalities are doing uh as to the cost?

Reproducir desde 07:18

Kate Mills

Um well, we've we've been doing the pump station replacements for 20-plus years now, so we always make sure we get a professional engineer, our design engineer, who also works with other municipalities in the area. So we we used that for our judgment, it's sound, and they're very close on what um our budget was. That helps make that our our uh assessment that with the help of those engineers is is good.

Reproducir desde 07:25

Brian E. Lewis

Okay. Appreciate uh that explanation, staff. I have no further questions at this time. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 07:40

Fred A. Neil

Any additional questions? Hearing none, I'll entertain a motion. Yes, Councilman Anderson.

Reproducir desde 08:08

David L. Anderson

Thank Thank you, Mr. President. I move to uh accept the uh staff recommendation for awarding the contract to Teal Construction.

Reproducir desde 08:12

Tricia K. Arndt

Second.

Reproducir desde 08:19

Fred A. Neil

It's been moved and it has been seconded. Uh Madam uh Clerk, can you please take the roll.

Reproducir desde 08:21

City Clerk

Miss Hall?

Reproducir desde 08:26

Donyale M. Hall

Yes.

Reproducir desde 08:27

City Clerk

Mr. Anderson?

Reproducir desde 08:28

David L. Anderson

Yeah.

Reproducir desde 08:29

City Clerk

Miss Arndt?

Reproducir desde 08:30

Tricia K. Arndt

Yes.

Reproducir desde 08:31

City Clerk

Dr. Sudler?

Reproducir desde 08:32

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Yeah.

Reproducir desde 08:33

City Clerk

Mr. Lewis?

Reproducir desde 08:33

Brian E. Lewis

Yeah.

Reproducir desde 08:34

City Clerk

Mr. Wilson?

Reproducir desde 08:35

City Clerk

Council President Neil?

Reproducir desde 08:40

Fred A. Neil

Yes.

Reproducir desde 08:42

City Clerk

Passes.

Reproducir desde 09:07

Fred A. Neil

All right. The vote has been unanimous, it passes. And thank you, Kate. And with that, uh the Utility Committee is adjourned. And I turn the floor over to the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee chaired by Chairman uh David Anderson.

Reproducir desde 09:08

David L. Anderson

Thank you very much, Mr. President. We're going to allow the members to uh come forward.

Reproducir desde 09:21

David L. Anderson

Uh welcome back, Mr. Czepek.

Reproducir desde 09:33

David L. Anderson

Mr. Shevock, is that working for you? There you go. Welcome, Mr. Shevock.

Reproducir desde 09:39

Terry Shevock

Good evening.

Reproducir desde 09:43

David L. Anderson

This time, I will entertain a motion to accept the agenda for the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee.

Reproducir desde 10:09

Terry Shevock

So moved.

Reproducir desde 10:13

Brian E. Lewis

Second.

Reproducir desde 10:14

David L. Anderson

Is there discussion? Hearing none, all in favor? Any opposed? The agenda is adopted.

Reproducir desde 10:15

David L. Anderson

That brings us to the first item, which is proposed Ordinance 2026... er 16, uh 2024-16 that uh ICC code uh Mr. Matthew Brown, Deputy Fire Marshal, and let's see. Mr. Czepek. Good evening.

Reproducir desde 10:23

Matthew Brown

Good evening, Council. Uh glad to be back again. Over the last couple months we did the 2024 ICC change uh for the building department. Myself, Matthew Brown, Deputy Fire Marshal, uh for the last couple years I'm with assisting the building department, now I'm just following through with the code change. Uh unfortunately, we had some formatting issues that were caught, um and it's not the content of what was being changed, it was simply section numbers and titles of the sections. Um so after some phone calls, meetings with the the city solicitor, he recommended repealing it, which we did last night, and we're reintroducing it in a different format. Instead of the strike the word through the old one to change it, he just recommended striking the entire section and inserting a whole new section with these words. Um so I'll go over it real briefly. Um a lot of it is just inserting City of Dover um departments. Uh the one thing that we did um add in um when we get to it is the item of fire sprinklers, residential. There was an amendment made last time this was brought, which passed, which did not require existing homes to be retrofitted even if they met the threshold of having to bring a house up to current code, um which normally is a 50% threshold. Um so instead of having that as a separate addendum this time, what we did is we just incorporated it into the main body, um which is um under page 10, line starts at line 153 and goes to 162. Um so again, the ordinance is exactly the same. I can go over the highlights of what the building code uh entails. Uh Fire Marshal Teague is going to talk about the residential sprinklers. Um the scope is the same. We did not change anything that affects zoning. Tiny houses is still in there, but again that's only how you build a tiny house. Planning and Zoning still determine if it's allowed for the land use. Um so I don't know how in depth you want me to get to into some of the changes between the 2009 and the 2024 version.

Reproducir desde 10:40

David L. Anderson

If you could uh just give uh a quick overview, because there are probably people here who aren't weren't here last time, you don't have to go into that much depth.

Reproducir desde 13:13

Matthew Brown

Okay. Absolutely. So between 2009 and 2024, updated wind, seismic, and snow loads are changed. There's the first ever tornado loading provision and rules for certain categories of buildings, explaining with mercantile. Uh rain loads uh to simulate static head, hydraulic head, and ponding uh head, which is concentrated, not just sir in the rain, but there's ponding on top of the roof. Uh mass timber construction changed for tall buildings to now build uh a building up to 18 stories uh in wood with the new codes and the new materials that you can use. Um special requirements uh for dead uh dead power generation since some houses are leaning towards generation of their own power, um whether it be solar panels or generators or what not. Um broader sprinkler requirements. Uh carbon monoxide detection is now required in any residence or building that has a combustion-type fixture, whether it's a heater, water heater, stove. If it has any of those, then it's required then at that point to have a carbon monoxide detector, which right now you don't have to have. Um refinements to the fire barriers, firewalls, atriums. Um high-rise definitions have changed slightly, so if it's 75 feet above the lowest level can trigger high-rise requirements. Some accessibility changes. Um it just brings it in line with the ICC A117.1 table, which got strength strengthened big time in 2021, so it's we're just bringing it in as part of the 2024. Um expanded requirements for accessible routes, parking and toilet rooms, electric vehicle charging stations and provisions for Group R-2 um are no longer fully exempt in the 2024 edition. Um there's some adult changing table changes into building code, some changes to uh temporary structures and how they how they work through it, updates the International Existing Building Code, uh which is something the state drives as well. Um obviously the fire's uh residential fire sprin- sprinklers mandate comes into play. Um construction performance list uh for the that we've had out for our locally established list. Energy code, it's moving us up to the current one, which again is state driven, we're required to do that within a year when they change it back in March if I'm correct. Those are the major highlights of the building code uh changes. Uh I'll let Jason talk on sprinklers as he has something prepared.

Reproducir desde 13:19

David L. Anderson

Before before that, on um non-sprinkler issues, do members of the committee have any questions?

Reproducir desde 15:43

David L. Anderson

Okay. Thank you. Mr. Shevock, uh you have a question?

Reproducir desde 16:16

Terry Shevock

Uh, one question on the sprinklers. Someone questioned me if one of the sprinkler heads goes off, say in the garage of a new house, does that sprinkler system then completely engulf the whole house with spray and in all those places? That was one question that was asked of me.

Reproducir desde 16:21

David L. Anderson

Let's go let's go ahead into sprinkler stuff. Can you answer that and just go into your presentation?

Reproducir desde 16:35

Jason Teague

Jason Teague, City of Dover Fire Marshal. Um to answer that question, uh no, it's just the one head that would activate. Um that would continuously flow until the fire department got there and shut the system off or until a resident shuts the system off. It would only be it would only be the one head that's activated.

Reproducir desde 16:39

Terry Shevock

All right. Because this individual apparently had it happen to them. I assume, because the way they explained it, champ, one sprinkler head went off and the whole head house was doused until the water was shut off, and ruined everything. That's why I had asked that question. Um so somebody can answer that, you know, more in more detail. And um the other question they had uh would curtail um future results within the city limits of Dover. That were the two main questions that I had.

Reproducir desde 17:15

David L. Anderson

The second the second question uh would be maybe answered in your presentation or maybe not, but he he had the question of the effect uh on development in the city of Dover. Would it uh have a negative effect on the of suppressing development?

Reproducir desde 17:44

Jason Teague

So, this would be for uh newer developments. Uh we've been talking about this code for over a year now. Um I can tell you only one off the top of my head, the residential projects that have gone through our DAC process. There's one um on Denny's Road near Millcreek. Um when that project went through, we let them know 2024 code was uh being looked at and could adopt it and it could have residential sprinklers. That developer did not have an issue with it.

Reproducir desde 18:19

Terry Shevock

So any any development at all within the city of Dover, if this passes, will have to have uh sprinklers put in it? Is what you're saying?

Reproducir desde 18:39

Jason Teague

Correct.

Reproducir desde 18:45

Terry Shevock

If it pass- if it passes.

Reproducir desde 18:46

Jason Teague

Correct.

Reproducir desde 18:48

Terry Shevock

Okay. And uh the only the last question then is uh the the insurance um credit uh on a any particular home, would cause it to go up or go down?

Reproducir desde 18:50

Jason Teague

I can't give you an honest answer on that. Um I'd have to reach out to an insurance agency. Um my understanding is that it usually goes down.

Reproducir desde 19:25

Terry Shevock

It usually goes down.

Reproducir desde 19:31

Matthew Brown

So this is Matthew Brown again with uh Fire Marshal's office. Just real quick, I I can't give quotes on actual insurance rates, um our ISO rating was re-evaluated this past summer,

Reproducir desde 19:33

Jason Osika

Uh, we're at a 10 out of 10, which is the worst that we could get because of our code year that we were in. Um, all's I know is we have resubmitted, um, since you did pass it, we resubmitted the new ordinance that was passed a couple weeks ago, uh, to the ISO rating company, um, who then is realigning it with the new code. Um, their ex- expectation we should be between a 4 and a 6, um, which as long as the insurance company uses the rating recommendation, should bring the cost, overall cost, homeowners insurance down. Not specifically because of residential sprinklers, but because we're going to the 2024 code. Um, and as soon as we get that actual information of our exact rating, that will be passed along to council, obviously, once it comes to there. It's in every- the re-review process now.

Reproducir desde 19:39

Council Member

That's that's all I have. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 20:12

Council Member

Thank you. You can go ahead and start your presentation, Fire Marshal.

Reproducir desde 20:19

Jason Osika

So I put this presentation together. It was more based on, uh, all the emails that were forwarded from the Clerk's Office as well as the, um, open forum from last time. Um, so in regards to the '24 IRC, the Residential Code, which does require residential sprinklers, this would require residential, not commercial. There's been a lot of commercial versus residential sprinkler systems as outlined in NFPA 13D. Um, the commercial system is NFPA 13. You can use the domestic system for residential one- and two-family dwellings.

Reproducir desde 20:23

Jason Osika

Uh, to the right, the International Code Council develops construction and public safety codes through a governmental consensus process. This system of code development has provided the highest level of safety in the world for more than 90 years. This code adoption went through the same process at a national level that this council went through.

Reproducir desde 20:57

Jason Osika

So I'm going to respond to the emails and the open forum. Um, a person is highly likely to suffer from smoke asphyxiation and incapacitation long before ceiling temperatures near a sprinkler head reach 135°. Later on, I'm going to have a side-by-side presentation to show you how quick that sprinkler activates. Um, it's the temperature that of the flame that hits that sprinkler head, not the entire room. Sprinkler systems are designed to save property, not lives. That's actually completely opposite. They're designed to save lives, not property. They suppress the fire so people can exit the structure and contain the fire for a safer environment for firefighters. Maryland Fire Marshal over 15 years zero. In fact, those numbers, I think, what what they're referring to is that zero fire fatalities have occurred in a sprinkler-protected home since adoption. Fire does still have occurred in uh sprinklered homes.

Reproducir desde 21:46

Jason Osika

Cost outweighs the benefit. Um, can a price be put on someone's life, whether it's a civilian or our firefighters? Actual cost, I covered this last time, on the high end, we're looking at $2.50 a square foot, which is, uh, $5,000 for a 2,000 square foot house. We got that from a residential sprinkler contractor. This is a big one, and and I'm going to touch on this. I'll be quick. I know it's a lot of slides. Um, evidence of death caused by fire within the city. I'm going to show you a review of the last 3 years. All's I went back is the last 3 years. Everything you're going to see is either in the City of Dover or in the Dover Fire Department's fire district. But you will see deaths that has occurred and injuries. Statistics that first responders are in danger without sprinklers. We'll see that at the end. Fires occur in older, existing houses, not brand new builds. Once again, when we go through the slide show, you'll see some of the newly constructed houses within the City of Dover that have uh had major fires. Catastrophic pipe freezing, uh dry pipes or antifreeze systems. Um, those are options out there, but the 13D system does not require, um, sprinklers in the attic areas, so that's usually where your pipe freezing takes place. Um, once again, there was a comment about fire systems require commercials here. This is not following commercial sprinklers.

Reproducir desde 22:45

Jason Osika

Maintaining the system, yearly compliance costs. This is really big because commercial systems are very expensive. I will say that with with requirements for maintenance. With 13D, maintenance items are recommended by NFPA, which the homeowner can conduct at no cost. Monitoring is optional; it is not required. Non-working smoke detectors versus sprinkler systems. Um, there was a lot on smoke detectors, uh, isn't that enough? But when you look at the statistics, uh, you'll see that while smoke detectors are effective, they're not 100%. People are still dying uh with smoke detectors in their house. Annual service with a 5-year internal, that goes back to the commercial system, that's not for residential. Permit fees, um, there is a fire permit fee currently. It's $25 per each $1,000 cost. So basically, it's a $125 permit on that $5,000 system. That's That That is not I think the number that was given in the open forum was the cost of the house. That's not the case. It's the cost of the sprinkler part when it comes to the Fire Department.

Reproducir desde 24:04

Jason Osika

Um, metered water. Um, you're going to see one example in the slide show. We have a set of townhouses in Dover already that have been sprinklered for some time. And on those projects we researched it, it's a 2-inch line going in for the domestic. It wyes off, so you have a 1-inch line going in for your domestic water, 1-inch for the sprinkler. Uh, it doesn't have to be designed like that, but the only meter is on the domestic water. So the sprinkler, they don't get charged for that. Road destruction, um, I think they're once again referring to commercial. When you have a building that's existing and needs a sprinkler system, yes, that's when you get into someone to dig up the street to tie into the water supply to get into it. That's That's very expensive. That's not the case here. This is everything's run off of domestic water line. Backflow prevention, um, NFPA does not require it on residential systems.

Reproducir desde 25:15

Jason Osika

This does not affect existing residential houses unless 50% modifications are completed. We kind of touched on that at the last meeting, kind of bring it up here now. New homes are already built to modern safety standards. You want to keep in mind sprinklers are part of the code that that is nation- reviewed nationwide, um, by the Code Council. And that the lightweight construction goes with the sprinkler. You're allowed to have the cheaper material because the sprinkler is supposed to take the place for that lightweight construction. Um, there was a comment about not affecting the saving of lives. I would say that's false. You do have to be an authorized, um, sprinkler-certified person to install these just like any other trade. Um, there was a a topic on plumbers. Plumber to- uh would have to be certified if they want to do sprinkler, and I see nothing wrong with that. Uh, City of Dover water supply, there shouldn't be any concern with that. Uh, before this, I talked to water wastewater. Jason Robbins indicated that the City of Dover has a great water system and that wouldn't be a factor. There was a comment someone came in for a residential permit and was denied because plans did not show a sprinkler. I need some additional information on that. If that happened, that shouldn't have happened because there's a 6-month window until we get funds established. And then there was a comment about a sprinkler leak in a half- in a townhouse made in the months that went certainly unnoticed. I'm not going to say that can't happen, but it's no different than a domestic line leaking. Insurance should cover it, and not that it's often.

Reproducir desde 26:42

Jason Osika

Um, so with the water wastewater handbook and NFPA, they're the water wastewater currently addresses commercial properties only with an 8-inch line. We reviewed residential projects from 2017, the townhouses that were built with double 2-inch lines. We're going to continue those conversations. And then, um, that's basically what it had for requirements. So a minimum 1-inch line if it's could be 3/4 inch with other materials. The next two, I'm not going to read these. Basically, that's two slides of what the fire code allows in reduction of material for residential. If you take the sprinklers away, all these go away as well.

Reproducir desde 28:14

Jason Osika

So this is the biggest thing. Um, like I said, this is just within the last 3 years. I didn't go back any farther than that. So that was just the other night. That's 30 South Governors Avenue, right down from the firehouse. They had a crew in the station and still got on scene with conditions like that. That's Janae Lane, um, in June of this year. This is Rockford Crossing, the Laurels. Um, we put this in there because it's a sprinkler save, small fire in the kitchen, but the sprinkler activated, saved the sprinkler complex. I wanted to point that out. 35 Virginia Avenue, house fire there. This is actually an apartment complex, um, but I wanted to put it in. Uh, it's a sprinkler save from an arson. There was actually a fire on the third floor, sprinkler put the put the fire out before it progressed into severe damage.

Reproducir desde 29:08

Jason Osika

65 Laurel Drive, um, that was in December of last year. Um, I have it here it should say program housing. We have several different programs, but I think it came up, I think there's going to be at least three slides slides where there's some type of program housing where you could have up to almost 10 people in houses. So that's that's a concern as well. Westover Drive, that's a townhouse fire there. 101 Webb Drive, this is one of many sprinkler saves. That's Luther Village and Luther Towers that uh sprinklers have saved, evacuated and saved property there many times and lives. Trafalgar Drive, another townhouse fire, uh duplex, sorry. Topaz Circle, I think that was built after '09 if they had a sprinkler system.

Reproducir desde 30:28

Jason Osika

Once again, this is uh 1155 Walker Road. This is the men's shelter. They had a sprinkler save. There was a fire in the attic. Without that sprinkler system, the roof probably would have burned off of that later. Stevenson Drive. Go back one. Uh, Otter Road, that was another uh program house. Um, this is 111 South Queen Street, 2017, 2015. That was built by Central Delaware Habitat for Humanity. Turned over Someone bought it from them once they built it, and you can see the end result there. I was actually there last night. It's an empty foundation. I think someone's purchased the property since then, and uh we actually had a shed was on fire last night. South Queen Street, um, duplex fire. East Loockerman Street. This is right on West Division Street around the corner. That's Ann Street behind Safeway that we had a- We've been there twice actually for that. Stevenson Drive again. Uh, Tee Court, another burned room from that. Willis Road. And some of these are older, but some of them would fall into if they were built after '09, they'd have sprinkler systems. Schoolhouse Lane, uh that was another arson fire with a program house.

Reproducir desde 31:37

Jason Osika

Uh, I put this in even though it's not a residential, it happened at a hotel. That's a sprinkler save for an arson that was set in one of the hotel rooms. Um, these are going to get a little This is still within the 3-year window, but they're going to get a little older. Uh, Sunset Terrace, that's a fatal fire there. Forest Avenue house fire. I think everyone's familiar with this one, 239 West Loockerman Street, fatality and uh several injuries on that fire. This is a complex I'm speaking of. This is off Silver Lake Boulevard. Um, when this builder came in, they didn't want rear access, so they put the sprinklers in the whole complex. Every one of those townhouses is sprinklered. No real issues that I've heard of. And that was a sprinkler save on New Year's Eve, uh had a fire in the garage, sprinkler put it out. Without that, they would have had serious.

Reproducir desde 32:45

Jason Osika

Super 8 Lodge, that's just another fatal. I wanted to capture all the fatals we've had since I've been around. Um, Woodcrest Apartments, that was a double fatal. That's non-sprinklered. Both of those are non-sprinklered. If built today, they'd have sprinklers. Um, and then uh South New Street, uh that was a fatal fire as well. So before we play that, the reason I wanted Like I said, I only went back 3 years, and that's just of properties in the City of Dover. I didn't venture down to Kent County, I didn't go out to Delaware, I didn't go out That all took place here. That's why I wanted to show that. This is a um side-by-side uh demonstration. Paul Egly, who's here tonight, he uh conducted this. If you want to hit play the- Before you The right side's going to go first, and you'll see a sprinkler activate and put the fire out within 15 seconds. And then the left side's going to be what happened.

Reproducir desde 34:03

Jason Osika

That sprinkler's activated, that fire's already out.

Reproducir desde 35:13

Jason Osika

This recorder is uh, the narrator of this, um. As that fire is going on the left, what he was telling everybody is: you're going to make a call to 911 because there's a fire, that's usually a 60-second call at the minimum uh to get your information. And by that time on the right side it's already extinguished. That then has to be passed on to the fire department for dispatch. Uh luckily today they are staffed at the station. But how far out, or how far from the firehouse, like some of the ones I showed where the house was fully involved. So obviously there's farther areas within the city.

Reproducir desde 36:10

Jason Osika

Turned it to full room, then can't extinguish in time.

Reproducir desde 37:14

Jason Osika

When it gets to the point it's going to be about 2 and 1/2 minutes, um, that's when you're going to have full room involvement. Everything, the whole room flashes and burns.

Reproducir desde 37:26

Jason Osika

There it goes. About 2 minutes and 10... So you can go on to the next one. So 2 minutes, that's what you had compared to the 15 seconds for the fire to be extinguished.

Reproducir desde 38:09

Audience Member

Did it start over?

Reproducir desde 38:28

Audience Member

It started over.

Reproducir desde 38:32

Jason Osika

So before you, this is going to be um a little hard to follow, you'll you'll understand it. Um, this is not the City of Dover, this is in the Dover Fire Department's district, but they had a house fire. Uh, pretty routine fire. Ended up having an unexpected collapse within the garage, and uh one of those right on firefighters have been trapped. So we're going to play that.

Reproducir desde 38:33

Jason Osika

It's already collapsed, the firefighter got trapped.

Reproducir desde 39:16

Speaker

Chief Carey.

Reproducir desde 39:31

Speaker

You got a call back.

Reproducir desde 39:36

Speaker

So I know affordability is a big question. I'll turn it in with what is the price of the system to the fire fighter's fight. The last video was also the city number 40. That was found near that time. So I'll show you this because now our top that goes down, then it breaks in here. So that's why we're in the back end. And program the same thing. That's all I have.

Reproducir desde 39:40

Speaker

Thank you, Councilman. Question.

Reproducir desde 40:22

Speaker

Done. Councilman.

Reproducir desde 40:24

Fred A. Neil

Yes, thank you. Our apartment houses, new home apartment houses required now to have a sprinkler systems?

Reproducir desde 40:26

Speaker

Correct.

Reproducir desde 40:32

Fred A. Neil

All in what? All departments have to have it, so that's already built in. So this basically is only single houses.

Reproducir desde 40:32

Speaker

Single-family houses, townhouses.

Reproducir desde 40:37

Fred A. Neil

All right, single-family including townhouses.

Reproducir desde 40:38

Fred A. Neil

I thank you very much, I yield.

Reproducir desde 40:40

Speaker

All right, Councilwoman Arndt.

Reproducir desde 40:44

Tricia K. Arndt

So I have a question. So in watching the video and showing the the one section without sprinklers, so it was showing the fire flashed for 2 and 1/2 minutes. What is Dover Fire's average response time?

Reproducir desde 40:46

Speaker

Chief Carey.

Reproducir desde 40:53

Speaker

Chief, you want someone else, Chief, to answer that?

Reproducir desde 40:54

Tricia K. Arndt

Sure. Just how long it would take for, on average, for a firefighter to to put out a place.

Reproducir desde 40:55

David Carey

Chief. Good evening. My name is David Carey. I'm the fire chief in the Dover Fire Department. Our average response time right now, station being staffed, is a minute and a half of getting out the door. So from the time we take the call, the 911 call, call's dispatched, firefighters get dressed, get on the truck, we're out the door within a minute and a half, um at the at the very most a minute and a half. It's 90 seconds. Uh most of the time it's around 60 seconds. Average response time to get on scene is less than 5 minutes.

Reproducir desde 41:24

David Carey

Now, I I will say this, it depends on where it is in the fire district as well.

Reproducir desde 41:45

Tricia K. Arndt

An impressive response time, but based on what we've seen, the fire can certainly be out of control. So, thank you. I yield.

Reproducir desde 41:48

Speaker

Sure. I can I can tell you, um, the Dover Fire Department's well below the NFPA standard for volunteer fire departments, uh, for response times mainly because of that staffing. Um, the one thing the chief didn't say, still keep in mind you have that 1 minute of the 911 call. So go ahead and add that on.

Reproducir desde 41:53

Speaker

Councilman Lewis.

Reproducir desde 42:29

Brian E. Lewis

Thank you. Could you identify to me any instances that you are aware of uh both locally and nationally where the sprinkler systems have failed?

Reproducir desde 42:31

Speaker

From the classes I've been in and took, um, any system that is in service and has been properly maintained does not fail. There's obviously times where you're going to have arson fires where systems are taken out of service, that's that's one of the ways they do, uh, or if it's not properly maintained, um, more of a commercial system, there is a chance of failure without maintaining the system.

Reproducir desde 42:40

Brian E. Lewis

I see. Well, like I indicated before, um they're not 100%, nothing's 100%. Uh but what about uh like freezing temperatures, for instance, where the pipes freeze up? Is that a possibility?

Reproducir desde 42:56

Speaker

So, the residential the domestic system should be in um areas that are maintained with heat. The only way that would happen is if it wasn't an hour and they were working and there is that possibility that heat sleep. If you turn that system at that house, that could happen, but that's with your other, you know, domestic piping system, the interior piping could freeze.

Reproducir desde 43:30

Brian E. Lewis

So, if there'd be a situation where let's say a lighter fire and the electricity goes out in the uh residence, will that have an effect on a system um or will it still activate?

Reproducir desde 43:46

Speaker

It'll still activate.

Reproducir desde 43:55

Brian E. Lewis

So, it has nothing to do with uh any electricity or anything to the system to to activate?

Reproducir desde 43:56

Speaker

The uh water's already at the sprinkler head, and that glass bulb fails from the heat, that pressure comes out, that burst.

Reproducir desde 44:25

Brian E. Lewis

Okay. Understood. Um, Mr. Chair, uh I know a lot of uh concerns were raised by constituents, uh small-business owners uh in the city of Dover, so um, I don't know if any other council members have any questions, but I would like to hear from uh from the public, those individuals.

Reproducir desde 44:31

Fred A. Neil

I have an additional question, sir.

Reproducir desde 44:44

Brian E. Lewis

That's all I have at this time.

Reproducir desde 44:45

Speaker

Okay. To make sure the uh that everyone who wishes to speak or ask questions that has an opportunity, uh I'm going to uh go with uh Dr. Sudler because he hasn't spoken yet and and then to Mr. Neil. Uh Dr. Sudler.

Reproducir desde 44:46

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you, Frank. Now, thank you for your presentation. Uh last time I think we discussed this, the meeting before this, so to get off topic a little bit, and I think I asked, who regulates the who allows them to do legally the material? Because to me it sounds like the developer and or the manufacturer um they increase their profit while the consumer increases the cost. And I think that's sort of very unfair, and it's almost like sort of puts me in the mind set of the opioid disorder challenge, right, crisis, where the pharmacies they maximized profit and then, you know, the damage and the harm was done to the consumer, right? So um thinking in that manner, so my question is, who, I know that there's a council that looks over the um looks over, what is the what do you just call them again, the the adopted ordinance by, say it again, yes, the standards. So, who looks over the standards per manufacturer, who allowed them to do legally the cheaper material? Because now on the on the front end, and now the back end the consumer is is is um you know, absorbing the cost.

Reproducir desde 44:59

Matthew Brown

So, the International, this is Matthew Brown, fire marshal for the city. The International Code Council was made up of developers, product manufacturers, um similar to like how this board is set up. You have certain elected officials and you have people from the community. Um they have people from the Sprinkler Coalition there, they have people there from everywhere and they collaborate and make their decisions based on the data. And you know, if they have a new product that says, hey, you know, we have this new I-beam that's made out of wood, and it's glued together, and it holds twice the weight. Then the concern comes in, well, the glue, if the glue gets to 150°, what happens to it? Breaks apart, collapses. Um and that's where the sprinkler mandate came in and originally through the code, is because manufacturers, the developers wanted this cheaper way of building materials, um they wanted to build closer to property lines, all that kind of good stuff. Um so that's why the stipulation was then put in, but it's been routinely left out by the same pushback that was pushed into lighter materials if that makes sense. But it's it's a national committee that forms for this and it's made up of everybody that's in the in the realm of that industry.

Reproducir desde 46:37

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you, and so that leads to my question uh another question, so it's made up of I guess those who initiated, right, the huge part in the development process, right? So, there's no representation from the, you know, the main of the fire department, because I'm what I'm thinking is this a great presentation, right, so this would be a great presentation for them to consider and it's acting to the else increase the durability to C streets. So, you know, so in other words, this sounds like to me this is all about green and then the greediness and those individuals want the profit, then, right, if the cost for 20% would be already struggling to meet the affordable um housing, you know, uh payment standard or standard. So, I guess I have some other stuff to talk about, but I guess my question to you is, what do you think would be a happy alternative? Because I agree with why safe. I have a partner building that I've had that had fire smoke alarm did not go off or paint, you know, cook it off and then unaware, and gladly I was there, and I helped painting with, you know, at residents there, so I get it, you know, at no former pastor nobody buy into life saving measures. But, I also have to realistically look at the impact when it comes to affordable housing, and our comprehensive plan says for 2028 that we support affordable housing. So, my question is, how are going to have this happen, and how can we get this happy medium uh with the presentation that's made, we can honestly see that it does save quality, right? And it makes sense. But how, but you know, it's not it's not affordable, and I know they say you can't put a cost on life, just like you can put a cost on health care, right, it's high. But, if you can't afford housing, how is that going to impact the mental and physical well-being of our citizens? So, wh- have you have an alternative, or is there an initiative that the fire um in the fire domain, you know, firefighters and and fire marshals to advocate for increasing the durability, you know what I'm talking about, so on the front end it would be it will help save everyone's life because it's more durable, and then on the back end it will save um uh consumers uh the cost they won't have to build these sprinkler systems or, you know. Uh so so that's my dilemma. Uh that's my dilemma because my constituents are saying, hey, we can't afford it. And I'm agreeing with you, from a personal end, no body, there's no cost or or health care service, right. So, where what initiatives are we as the capital of Delaware first state, how can we lead this initiative, what do you think we can do? Um, and I've, you know, sort of, you know, brought that to your attention last time, and I know y'all been working harder, but I think that's really the question everyone wants safety, comes with the cost, right? But, really does it have to come at the cost to the consumer when they're already struggling to drink any to you know, get a home, it's just, you know, really uh attainable. Even in Even in housing uh HUD, right? A one-bedroom they're they're they're 14, it's $14.88 for a one-bedroom voucher. I mean the housing choice voucher for Delaware County, Delaware, I know I'm sorry. $14.88 for one bedroom, who's speaking out? You know, if you don't have any if you don't have a housing voucher, and you're just, you know, working with no assistance, thank God for people that work for me known as NCALL and Alliance, if you don't have that, oh, if I don't have the assistance, how are we going to afford it? You know, so we have all to think about those things. So, I wanted to bring that to your attention, and um and and and I just and you know, it's just it's just sad, and I have other things on that table, the time to start the discussion, but we have to keep that in mind, uh how can affordable housing happen and attained. And it appears that the sprinkler systems, it's not attainable, even though it makes sense. It's just not attainable for everyone.

Reproducir desde 47:44

Speaker

Yeah. Go ahead.

Reproducir desde 52:43

Speaker

The only other thing I want to clarify is um, to make sure it's clear, cuz I think there was some confusion on the Open Forum or somewhere from somebody else. If you have an existing single-family residence, that does not, if this passes, that does not mean tomorrow you have a sprinkler system. It's not the rules. This is for new construction or uh, there's a standard where if you sell 50% or the houses. Your house is built, you're living in your house, that does not affect you.

Reproducir desde 52:45

Speaker

Now for Councilman Neil.

Reproducir desde 53:03

Fred A. Neil

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh, several questions. First off, uh according to my conversations with code inspectors, and I'm I want to see whether it it's true to you because you basically uh it's uh going and examine houses and rentals and and the like, um that many of the smoke detectors don't work or are inoperative, and the they're they're that they do not actually provide protection for people. What is your experience, does it match up with the code inspectors? And we have uh uh we the director of code inspectors, Eddie Kopp here, who can elaborate if necessary. Are they working or are they not working, and do they if they're not working, they don't help.

Reproducir desde 53:04

Speaker

So, smoke detectors do help if they're operable.

Reproducir desde 53:58

Fred A. Neil

If they're operable. Okay.

Reproducir desde 54:00

Speaker

I can tell you uh, my near four to nine months in Code Enforcement before going in the Fire Marshal world, um a lot of houses that we inspect uh, which are rental properties, a lot of times the batteries were missing out of them or they're or not. That's a common, say that's highly concentrated.

Reproducir desde 54:02

Speaker

Mr. Kopp, you can say yes to that.

Reproducir desde 54:38

Fred A. Neil

Uh, he's nodding his head. Okay. The second question is, and I think this is one of the reasons I brought up the apartments, and anybody coming into an apartment basically has more protection in a apartment because they have to have sprinklers. Now, the we talk about affordable housing, and this is my wheelhouse, because you have to have money to buy a house. Fixed-income and low-income people can't afford that. They're not, they're they're in apartments, whether it's a house, an apartment building, or lease land. Th- they basically do not have the money to buy housing, because it's not affordable to them. So when we talk about affordable and helping people, you've got to have money. And at this particular point we're not talking about the low-income people who need it, the fixed-income people who basically are desperate for housing throughout this entire state. We know that housing is in short supply. We need 20,000 more houses. We housing units, but the housing units include apartments. Apartments are going to have it. And the second thing is, according to what I I watched, that the property basically there's a saving in property that can be be saved and reused and rebuilt, whereas those who that do not have it uh do not have sprinklers, basically can be destroyed because you're not getting to the fire in time. So we have lives and we have property. And I think the argument for sprinklers, it's because it doesn't really help people who don't have money. People who don't have money can't afford a house to begin with. And everything is going up. The they can't stop the cost that's going up. So, unless there is another solution, unless you have basically uh going around to all the houses to to make sure that they have a a smoke detec- detector that's fixed and working, this the argument in terms of affordable housing uh is very weak because it doesn't help the group that that basically can't afford to buy a house. I yield.

Reproducir desde 54:39

Speaker

All right. Councilwoman Arndt.

Reproducir desde 56:59

Tricia K. Arndt

Thank you. I want to revisit the cost of the systems. So I think in your presentation you quoted 5,000. Um what I've been looking at was anywhere from 2,500 to 5,000. Um we have received a barrage of emails um quoting prices 10,000, 15,000 per house. Can you help me understand why there's such, obviously the size of the house matters, but can we bring it down to by the square foot, the average, you know, 2,000-square-foot home um and why we're seeing such a wide range of these figures. And then also I mean this is over the life of the mortgage, right? So whatever this cost is, it's going to be spread out over 30 years. So 5 grand 5 grand might sound like a lot at the front end, but when you look at it over 30 years, and the protection that you would get from a sprinkler system, I think it pays for itself. But I'd like to hear your thoughts on the cost of this system.

Reproducir desde 57:01

Speaker

So, uh, Matt reached out to one of the companies cuz they there are different companies. There's one that do a lot of commercial and they won't do residential. Although there's a lot more money in commercial. Uh, one of the predominant ones that does the residential, that's where we got the high end of 2.50 a square foot. Uh, we did a 2,000-square-foot cuz most houses here or in that range are 2,000 square feet or lower. Um, I think where the big number's coming from is just like the presentation, you have to think what's being built in the city of Dover. This isn't Sussex County where 4 or 5,000 sq ft houses are going up, and each has its piece. You start getting that square footage with the math, then you're going to start hitting near $10-, $20,000. Um, I'm not saying it can't be done here, but what we're seeing going in right now, uh, Garrison Meadows, 18-

Reproducir desde 58:03

Speaker 1

that we were starting to see that build, honest representation that we spread. They're all smaller-type houses, not larger-scale houses. So, the square footage, as it goes up, per square foot cost goes down, as does the whole cost of the house.

Reproducir desde 58:58

Tricia K. Arndt

Okay. So, your figure is, in this area, an average-sized home, $5,000, which would be steaks to real the 30-year mortgage, for example. Okay.

Reproducir desde 59:15

Speaker 1

250 a square foot is the that is the best numbers.

Reproducir desde 59:26

Tricia K. Arndt

Okay. Thank you. I hear you.

Reproducir desde 59:29

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you, Dr. Sudler.

Reproducir desde 59:35

Speaker 1

Thank you, for having me.

Reproducir desde 59:37

Roy Sudler, Jr.

And that will be placed to the public after the committee gets its questions. Yes, please.

Reproducir desde 59:40

Andre M. Boggerty

Thank you for recognizing me, Mr. Chairman. Okay, and okay, so we have some major projects that we're considering, a data center, which is going to draw a lot of our water demand, like what an impact it would be in. We have made the institutions that are still going on and developing, even on, I think, Salisbury Road, over that side, after the King, Plaza there. There's a lot of development, right? And commercial development. So, it's going to require more electric, more water. So, my concern is, currently, we are looking at doing an infrastructure study to see our vulnerabilities and whether or not we can sustain, right? Additional water ends demand. So, I feel like we're at a blind spot right now looking at the engineering perspective of whether or not our our infrastructure vulnerabilities can sustain

Reproducir desde 59:48

Andre M. Boggerty

more water demand at this present moment. So, that that was my major concern, separate from the cost housing infrastructure. So, I'm going to put it out there now that I believe that we need to have, at least we need to wait, at the very least, until we get that infrastructure study done to see if we can even sustain that for the future, because if we want to do a data center, and that that's a we don't know if we're going to do it now, yes, we're at 18 months, or 20 months, 17 months now, that's it we decide we want to do that.

Reproducir desde 1:01:29

Andre M. Boggerty

We have to have those calculations, those mathematical calculations in play, as well as what our current volume would be. I think that that has to be considered in what we're going to do, because it is going to happen, right? Would you agree or disagree that it is going to decrease, right, the water usages, water pressure, it won't decrease?

Reproducir desde 1:02:24

Speaker 1

So, the only way you're going to have any more demand is if this sprinkler

Reproducir desde 1:04:08

Andre M. Boggerty

Right, but we're talking about new homes. Right? So, we are going to be activated. So, we want So, what is What is the

Reproducir desde 1:04:12

Andre M. Boggerty

number of fires that you have, have you, you know, put some figures together in regards to how much water consumption you're predicting that we may have to go into, you know, calculating the infrastructure demand? And you may not have that in front of you tonight. I'm just saying, those are Yeah, those are some of the questions based on your your highest amount of, you know, fee at the lowest per year.

Reproducir desde 1:04:20

Speaker 1

And So, it's a typical question. Um so sprinkler system in the house is a static system. So, it's filled with water. Once it's filled with water, it's just 1-in pipe that's filled, stays there until a sprinkler head activates. Ideally, when a sprinkler head activates, it's the one head, which is going to pump out 20 to 25 gal a minute. Um say it's on for 10 minutes, 15 minutes till the fire department gets there, you're talking 300 gal. Um I, Jason Lyon, uh, Assistant City Manager, can comment more on our water supply. I I don't think a 2 or 300-gal usage during a fire event

Reproducir desde 1:04:48

Speaker 1

is going to be a concern, considering if they show up in a house that's fully ablaze fire department's going to flow They're going to flow thousands of gallons a minute uh trying to put that out when they just got it done for 2 or 300. Um so, I don't think it's going to have a negative impact on our water supply. Um, the one thing you just have to remember is the water supply needs to be there. Um, our current pressure that the system has throughout the city is sufficient uh to activate one of the heads properly. Um, if we ever got to a a scenario where the water pressure, for some reason, was in the mid-20s or something like that at a house, then, yes, there would be an additional cost for the pumping so we can get the pressure up to it. Um, but for everything we've seen now with our city water, it's phenomenal, it's going to it's going to fully do what it's got to do, and I think the impact is actually going to be less than it would if the fire department had to go put the fire out once they get there.

Reproducir desde 1:05:52

Andre M. Boggerty

Thank you for that answer. And, again, I'm just concerned that to make sure that it'd be sustained. Because, you know, we do have huge projects in our other institutions that absorb our water, our infrastructure. So, I would I would like to hear more about that once I just received some statistics, some data, to support uh what you're saying. You know, I'm valuing what you're saying, but it always helps to, when we have our constituents, who are saying, "Hey," and it always helps us to show.

Reproducir desde 1:07:33

David L. Anderson

So, we'll we'll get that information together,

Reproducir desde 1:08:08

Speaker 1

um and then we'll have the clerk's office disseminate it to you, and also have it available at the next meeting if there's another meeting after this.

Reproducir desde 1:08:10

Off Andre M Boggerty

And that would be great. You know, city manager, as they prepare for our vulnerability in preparation for our vulnerability study for engineering, maybe we need to add is uh some that criteria into factor in uh what we're going to be asking our, you know, RFP for engineer expert engineer to come and do our assessment in in our other uh domains. Thank you, I hear you. Thank you for recognizing me. That's all the questions I have at this point.

Reproducir desde 1:08:17

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Councilman Lewis, and then Neil, please.

Reproducir desde 1:09:27

Brian E. Lewis

This is probably my last question for now. Uh when we when we talk about cost of the installation of the sprinkler systems, um one of the things that concerns me is um we're not just talking about sprinkler heads and piping. Um, what about things, maybe you can elaborate on this, like backflow prevention, the pits, the meters taps, for water water service, uh, in particular, um when you have to install this in an older home, like on an addition, because this also applies to additions on homes, if you have an older home in the city, um a lot of times you're going to have older piping construction there, so how is that going to um, you know, relate to being cost-effective?

Reproducir desde 1:09:32

Speaker 1

So, um like I said in the presentation, it hitchhikes your domestic line coming in. Um, so if they have an older house, I'm not going to say you wouldn't have to upgrade your water line. Um the townhouses you saw in there, that line goes straight in, goes right where the hot water heater is, there's a valve that right there for it on/off for the sprinklers, and that feeds the whole system. That's all it is. There's What you're starting to get into is start to get into more of a commercial-type system uh versus the residential. The reason NFPA did this, is to keep the cost down. They're not If they were forcing everybody to put commercial system in there, it's going to be a So, they've come a long way. That's why they're allowing CPVC piping versus steel, all that's bringing the cost of the system down.

Reproducir desde 1:11:10

Brian E. Lewis

Uh so, like with the older homes, uh only the addition is going to have to have sprinkler systems placed in. So, if it's like a a mother-in-law suite or whatever suite that you add to the older home, only that portion is going to have to have the sprinkler system. So, basically, you're going to tap in to the existing water supply uh using PVC pipe and that's it?

Reproducir desde 1:12:37

Speaker 1

Correct. So, in that situation, you would have to evaluate the current meter that's there. Uh for a normal residence uh sprinkler system residential sprinkler system, you need a 1-in meter. For most of our houses currently are going in with 5/8 meter. Um we did uh ask the Assistant City Manager Jason Lyon to to look up the cost. It's about $130 more the difference between the 5/8 to the 1-in meter. There is an additional cost there that you would have to add that a little bit of a larger meter to accommodate that. Now, if you're adding onto your house, the only time you're going to have to sprinkler that is when you hit the 50% mark. That's a very magical number in the building world, it's a 50% renovation. So, you would literally If you have a 1,000-ft² house, you'd have to put 501 ft² on it. If you have a 2,000-ft² house, you have to put 1,001 ft² on it, in order to be required to sprinkle that. If you're just adding a sunroom or a mother-in-law suite, the odds are it's not 50% of the size of the house, so you would not be required. Only if you hit that 50% mark. At that point, as Jason uh pointed out, it depends on the water line goes to the house. If it if it's an old, old water line, the odds are you will have to upgrade that water line to a 1-in, uh as well as upgrade your meter from 5/8 to 1-in.

Reproducir desde 1:13:01

Brian E. Lewis

And what would you say the estimate of that would be?

Reproducir desde 1:14:54

Speaker 1

So, the the meter itself, and that difference is about $130. Honestly, the water line, I can tell you what I have a piece of property in the city that I had to put a new water line in a couple years ago and it was about two grand. Um but that was a new meter, meter pit, and the line going to the house. The house was also relatively close to the street, so it's not like it's, you know, 200 ft or anything. Uh but I I'll be honest, I don't know if I were to get that done today how much more it would be.

Reproducir desde 1:14:58

Brian E. Lewis

Uh and that would also apply, when we talk about additions, to finished basements, added on square footage. If you happen to decide like your basement currently is not finished, you want to finish it all, you're going to have to install a sprinkler system, depending on the square footage.

Reproducir desde 1:16:03

Speaker 1

Correct. So, um well, I just pointed that out, because on the concessions that are the NFPA allows for uh when you put a sprinkler system in, if one if they were to sprinkle the basement, they don't have to have that large rescue window. Um, because the sprinkler system is designed to put the fire out, you shouldn't need the rescue window. It's one of those things, it's concession that you don't have to do. So, if you're cutting out the big hole in your wall, put a window with a big well and stairs to go out, you wouldn't have to do that in the basement if you were to sprinkle it. However, just finishing your basement, the cost value of finishing your basement is nowhere near 50% of the value of the house, because you're not putting in foundation walls, you're not, you know, having electric service, you know, to the addition and stuff where you have footers, foundation, you're just putting up non-bearing walls, drywall, paint, trim, and you're done. It's nowhere near a 50% renovation, just to upgrade a better or a just like a basement. Even if you have bathrooms, you live

Reproducir desde 1:16:20

David L. Anderson

Mr. Anderson, your microphone.

Reproducir desde 1:17:55

Speaker 1

Yeah. The the the cost of Say it's a try to use round number, $300,000 house. I don't think I've ever seen a building permit come through to finish a basement for 150 grand. Um, most of them are 60 to 80, I think would probably be the average, uh and that doesn't go anywhere close to that 50% mark. Now, if they went really elaborate, they put in, you know, marble tile and all kinds of stuff and it hit a 50% dollar value, then that might be taken into consideration.

Reproducir desde 1:17:58

Public Speaker

And I do really appreciate the opportunity now to address this issue of adopting the 2024 building code before you all we were not given that opportunity at earlier stages.

Reproducir desde 1:18:38

Public Speaker

Um for nonprofit housing developers and low and moderate income home buyers, every dollar matters. Installing sprinklers in new residential construction will add an estimated, in our opinion, $8,000 to $10,000 to the construction cost. And some estimates are significantly higher. Each incremental cost causes a difficult choice for us. Can we find more gap financing? If the City of Dover wants to give us that gap difference in gap financing, we'll go for it. But or do we reduce the number of houses we build? Or do we pass the cost onto the home buyer who are low and moderate income?

Reproducir desde 1:18:52

Public Speaker

And I've heard that we don't there's less maintenance. I appreciate the presentation that was made earlier, so that's an interesting point that there is less maintenance for the sprinkler systems.

Reproducir desde 1:19:35

Public Speaker

New homes are hardwired with smoke alarms and other safety features that make them safer than older homes. Residential sprinkler systems are activated at a temperature of 135 to 165°, um they're not activated by smoke. We do feel that smoke detectors are an active deterrent for fire situations.

Reproducir desde 1:20:26

Public Speaker

At a time when Delaware is working to address the health affordable housing crisis, local governments should be looking for ways to reduce unnecessary barriers to housing production, not create new ones.

Reproducir desde 1:20:50

Public Speaker

We are not against sprinklers, just making it mandatory. Requests that that not be made mandatory.

Reproducir desde 1:21:02

Public Speaker

So we urge the the Dover City Council to offer and approve an amendment to the 2024 building code that excludes mandating requiring sprinklers in new residential construction of one- and two-family dwellings and townhouses. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:21:10

David L. Anderson

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:22:09

Andre M. Boggerty

I want to thank the the the partnership because it's made a tremendous difference in our neighborhoods and including the neighborhood that I live in. The the whole character of the neighborhood has changed and it has just been incredible for like living in entirely different neighborhood with bringing in more homeowners. Thank you. We'd like to see that partnership continue.

Reproducir desde 1:22:11

David L. Anderson

Next speaker, please.

Reproducir desde 1:22:45

City Clerk

Next is Jeff Eisenbrey.

Reproducir desde 1:22:47

City Clerk

Katie Gillis?

Reproducir desde 1:22:56

Katie Gillis

Wonderful to see all of you again. Um my name is Katie Gillis, I'm the executive officer of the Home Builders Association of Delaware. Um I had prepared remarks, but instead, I'd like to maybe address some of the points that were made this evening, if that's okay.

Reproducir desde 1:23:46

Katie Gillis

Um first, Councilwoman Arndt, you uh described rolling the cost of a sprinkler system into a 30-year mortgage. Unfortunately, it is not that simple, because people still become disqualified for a home when the price, the final price of the home springs by $5,000. When the cost of a house increases by $1,000, you're pricing out nearly 400 families from that house. So if you raise it by just $5,000, that's almost 2,000 families that are priced out of a home, so I just wanted to make that point.

Reproducir desde 1:24:01

Katie Gillis

Um Councilman Sudler, um you mentioned something about uh the standards and the regulations that builders build to. Um I just want to point out that those regulations and those standards are imposed by bodies such as this. And our builders build to the standards that are imposed by local government officials. Um you know, uh Habitat and NCALL, they build houses. It's the same costs to them as it is to the uh for-profit developers. They just end up being financed differently. You can't build a home for less than $250,000 these days. It's just not going to happen.

Reproducir desde 1:24:37

Katie Gillis

And that's because of the regulations and standards that builders are required to adhere to.

Reproducir desde 1:25:59

Katie Gillis

Um and Council President Neil, you mentioned building apartments and fire sprinklers being required in apartments, which is true. But just because apartments may be cheaper in some circumstances, that's not the case across the board. I think the average rent in Delaware is probably more than $2,000 a month, which is more than my mortgage in the City of Dover. Um and those people who are low-income, who you are protecting are safer in the apartments because they have sprinkler systems, they still deserve opportunities to own a home.

Reproducir desde 1:26:05

Katie Gillis

And you're taking that away when you raise the costs of housing, which is what happens with every single regulation that a government imposed, I'm not just talking about sprinklers, every single regulation increases the cost of housing, makes it harder for home ownership. And if we're going to talk about public safety, you're forcing people to stay in older homes that are less safe because they can't afford a home. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:27:26

City Clerk

Next up is Paul Eichler.

Reproducir desde 1:27:57

Paul Eichler

Uh Paul Eichler. I'm a resident of the Second District and a firefighter here in Dover for 39 years and and let me add to that, I've been a volunteer firefighter here in the City of Dover for 39 years.

Reproducir desde 1:28:53

Paul Eichler

I've spoken before this body before. Mr. Anderson, Mr. Neil, thank you very much for the recognition, I greatly appreciate it. With regards to a lot of the comments that have been made this evening um and to some requests that have been made by Councilwoman Arndt and uh your your committee, I I dress my initial comments specific to that, and specifically to the aspect that, first and foremost,

Reproducir desde 1:29:11

Paul Eichler

uh this sprinkler requirement has been in the International Residential Code since 2009. So it's been there for 17 years. It's actually, brass tacks, been enforced since 2011, so there was a grace period with regards to putting that into place. So it's been 15 years. The International Residential Code has gone through five code revisions in that time frame.

Reproducir desde 1:29:39

Paul Eichler

Through those five code revisions, the requirement for residential sprinklers has remained in the code as it has been reviewed by the International Code Council, the Congress that oversees the International Residential Code where, yeah, there are developers, there are builders, and there is fire service representation through the International Code Council. So point being, it's been there for 17 years.

Reproducir desde 1:30:41

Paul Eichler

And again, frankly, uh City of Dover has not been following that code for 17 years, so not to be mean about it, but you've gotten away with 17 years of of not building with it, thus, you know, not having that expense, you've had those savings through the years. Uh I cannot thank enough City Fire Chief David Carey and my colleagues, uh the volunteer firefighters who are standing behind me this evening, for taking time out of their schedules to attend tonight's meeting to show their support of the sprinkler ordinance as well.

Reproducir desde 1:31:18

Paul Eichler

Because, specifically, directly, you look, these are the some of the lives that will be saved by having this, you know, ordinance go through. Uh we talked about, you know, cost, we talk about cost all night, absolutely. My costs again, I support Mr. Osika with regards to $2.50 a square foot that came from deliberations in Middletown.

Reproducir desde 1:32:17

Paul Eichler

Uh other colleagues that are with me this evening can actually speak to better pricing on active projects that they have going on in the state of Delaware at this time. And the bottom line of that is uh a $2.50 on a 2,000-square-foot home at $5,000 is 2% added to the price. With respect to Ms. Gillis's comments, yes, I understand that of affordability and the increase in a price causes concern. Uh however, with regards to that as well, Councilwoman Arndt, your question with regards to amortization of $5,000 over a 30-year mortgage equates to uh at 7%, which is you know unfortunately prevailing rate today, uh equates to $1.11 per day.

Reproducir desde 1:32:51

Paul Eichler

Currently, at this time, Middletown with the sprinkler ordinance has active construction going on, residential construction. At this time, the town of Milton has active residential construction going on with residential inclusion there. At this time, the city of Lewes has active residential construction going on. They have a 90 townhouse townhome project that has just been introduced to their planning and zoning. The aspect of building with residential sprinklers does not deter from development in communities whatsoever.

Reproducir desde 1:34:31

Paul Eichler

The Middletown proceedings the same night that their ordinance was passed was the same night that they approved 1,500 new homes in their jurisdiction.

Reproducir desde 1:35:50

Paul Eichler

My colleague from the National Fire Sprinkler Association, Mr. Frank Ellis who's with us this evening, can speak better uh to this as well, but information with regards to insurance is that it can go from 5% to 25%.

Reproducir desde 1:36:01

David L. Anderson

Got your time, Paul.

Reproducir desde 1:36:17

Paul Eichler

Thank you, Mr. Anderson, I greatly appreciate it, taking time afforded for the time and certainly provide more information. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:36:19

David L. Anderson

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:36:26

Andre M. Boggerty

I want to thank all the members of the Dover volunteer Robbins Dover Fire Department, you know, for coming out tonight and for your service. Uh next, please.

Reproducir desde 1:36:32

City Clerk

William Faust?

Reproducir desde 1:36:43

William Faust

Dover, Delaware. I just want to say, good evening to all the council members here and fire department that's here. And especially they got honest people on uh teleconference, going to stare faces on a computer. First of all, get back to the ordinance. Uh mechanical things do break. That's one. And my next comment is not to discourage anything about the fire department. I believe they have a dangerous job. I did 20 years in corrections.

Reproducir desde 1:36:49

William Faust

When you pin on a badge and raise your hand and sworn in, you take the risk of what you're doing, what you love. Even if all your equipment works, you can have tragedies, loss of property, injuries, and death. Second of all, everything being increased daily to the country, and through the tax, we probably have another increase, what good is having a sprinkler system if people can't maintain it? Most contractors come out and do service on your air conditioning heater is $150 plus parts and labor. What good is having the appliance that people can't maintain?

Reproducir desde 1:37:45

Unknown Speaker

have enough flow power to head for 25 gallons per minute and you got to be able to do a maximum of two heads. That's the way the code is written that's in there now. Um the other thing that uh you need to be cognizant of is there's two potential systems: a combined system which works with the domestic water so the backflow preventer that the city already requires would satisfy that except that it's going to have to be upsized again along with meter upsizing. All those little nuances are what brings that price up to $4.50 to $5 a square foot as opposed to the bid price for the sprinkler contractor to do his portion of the work. All those other contractors' projects are affected by when you put the sprinklers into the building. Plus, as uh Steve mentioned, you've got uh uh developer's overhead and profit that goes on top of everything that you put into the house. Uh so if you're talking a separate system, as uh fire marshal mentioned, you know, it's a separate valve, so it's not metered. Well, that means you've got to have a backflow preventer on that line because that line is now a stagnant line. So the NFPA may not require it, but your cross-connections from the uh water department are going to require a backflow preventer, and a more sophisticated one than you're requiring for your domestic water, because now you have stagnant water that has the potential to backflow into a city system. Um As far as the fact that uh the code's been in place for 17 years, well, in those 17 years we've got two states that have adopted the sprinkler requirements on the 2024 IRC, basically Maryland and California. There are no other two states in the union so far that have adopted that. Now there's been some locales within states that have adopted, and similar to once what was mentioned here tonight for Delaware. And then the professional engineer needed to design the pump system now because it's now got a fire marshal stamp on the city. You either have to go with NICET certification or professional engineer stamp for all. Thank you so much.

Reproducir desde 1:38:18

Roy Sudler, Jr.

The uh Councilwoman Hall had uh that she would like to recuse herself from the discussion so she checked with counsel because of the fact that she is uh now a a licensed realtor. So we'll know that the answer to that one uh by the uh by the meeting. Thank you. Just to just to let you know that it wasn't just talking on the phone or something, counsel was talking to her. All right. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:41:10

Roy Sudler, Jr.

The uh next, please.

Reproducir desde 1:41:46

City Clerk

Next is Frank Ellis.

Reproducir desde 1:41:47

Frank Ellis. Thank

Uh my name is Frank Ellis. Thank you for the opportunity to speak to you tonight. Uh I've spent over 30 years in the fire department, uh currently now the National Fire Sprinkler Association. Very pleased to see the presentation the fire marshal was presenting the information. It's a great presentation. Incidentally, the video of the demonstration, I was actually there that day at fall uh the black guy up front uh there. You saw the code, um, but, um, some of the questions that came up, there was a concern about how much strain residential water system put into the city. Um, fire sprinklers typically on on an average house fire, um, there's a Scottsdale study, 15-year review of sprinkler requirements, found that sprinkler uses on an average 341 gallons. These are designed to control fires when they're small. We don't have fire sprinklers when the fire department has to respond with those response times that were discussed earlier. Um the fire department arrives at a much larger fire, right? So now they're using uh, on average, nearly 3,000 gallons. So if you're concerned about not having enough water for sprinklers, um, then you really should be concerned that you don't have enough water for your fire department to treat that one particular instance. Um cost is always a factor, and I understand the responsibility to your constituents to make sure that um the extra cost that will probably be added to the home, roughly 1% to 1.5%, um will mostly likely be passed on, and we understand. Um, so as far if you look at it from a return on investment standpoint, what is that return? Well, the civilian death rate for fire will decrease by 90% in homes with sprinklers. So I don't know what what other thing you can invest in, you're going to get that type of return in your life. Um I think that's really all I have, because um all your questions were already answered. Fire marshal did an excellent job this evening. If you have any additional questions about fire sprinklers, please reach out to me. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:41:59

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you, sir. Could you come back, please, sir? Um you're an expert in the field. Uh we if there's a member of the committee has a question. And by the way, members of the committee, there there will be various experts, and if you do have questions, after the three minutes you may ask them, but please keep them relatively short. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:44:17

Andre M. Boggerty

Thank you, Dr. Pillsbury couldn't ask, she had other obligations, I think, to Dover. She had that question uh before you came in, in her statement, so thank you. Um do you um coincide or concur with the previous statement from the individual that talked about that it was Maryland, that's what he was talking about, how he hates it in Maryland. Do you see any similarities, is it money the same, or do you, that's all I need to ask you, not trying to get into, that's not a debate, but just to see if anything he said, could you concur? And if so, what are the areas that you concur?

Reproducir desde 1:44:44

Frank Ellis. Thank

So my experience is specifically with New Jersey. Um we are the National Fire Sprinkler Association. We do have representatives in Maryland that would probably be able to better answer your question, so if you reach out nationally, we can definitely give you a a better, more accurate answer. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:45:20

Andre M. Boggerty

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:45:34

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Any other questions? Not seeing any other, thank you. Okay, next.

Reproducir desde 1:45:38

City Clerk

Next up is Bobbie Slagle.

Reproducir desde 1:45:46

Bobbie Slagle

Good evening. Uh really amazing presentation this evening and very moving, and makes you really think about the whole situation when you come from saving lives and costs and how that debate is being heard tonight. Um I sincerely appreciate our volunteer firefighters that are here. Thank you for the service that you do and for putting your lives on the line. I'm sorry, Bobbie Slagle from uh representing Kent County Association of Realtors. Taking some notes on some of the things that have been said uh this evening. I wanted to kind of for starters reiterate um something that Representative Gray was replying earlier in relation to how the cost is passed on. Uh every $1,000 increase in home price uh basically prices out about 371 Delawareans. That's kind of where she was coming from as far as affordability. So, having been in real estate for 22 years, the last 6 years of real estate have been tough. Um prices have skyrocketed. Um many buyers have had very difficult time getting into homes, whether it's because they were flying off the market or because all of a sudden the interest rates skyrocketed and that just priced a lot of them out. The problem has always been supply and demand. It's very simple, basic economics. I think after everything that I've heard tonight, one of the things that I just want to press upon this committee is there seems to be a whole lot of unanswered questions. And why rush through to pass something that we need better information on? I understand that the code as a whole needs to be updated, but why pass the mandate for sprinklers until we can get better information? Um I don't feel that there is a need that it has to be rushed right through. So Delaware already has, and I gave this to the clerk last night, not sure if she shared that with everybody, um Delaware state already has a mandate that requires homebuilders to disclose to the buyers the benefits of sprinkler systems and to itemize what that cost would be to put into new construction. Yes, sir. And because we already have that piece in place, I would just urge this committee to rethink coming together just for right now. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:45:56

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:48:25

City Clerk

Todd Stonesifer.

Reproducir desde 1:48:29

Todd Stonesifer

Good evening. Thank you for having me here. My name is Todd Stonesifer, a homeowner with you and a real estate agent. I have been in the real estate business for 26 years in Kent County. Um through best days, we are in an affordability crisis. We just had an election last week, and the results of that election are proof that we are in an affordability crisis. Um in the statistics that I've heard, it has been zero, zero deaths in New Castle County in a home built in the last 25 years with a working smoke detector. Look, there is no doubt that sprinkler systems are going to save lives. There is no doubt that these fine people up here are putting their lives at stake every time they step foot in a burning house. We're going to have more people living on the streets or more people sleeping on those couches because, you already heard, costs go up, people get priced out of houses. What is the value of a life? Of course it's invaluable, but if you use that argument, then you uh open up Pandora's box. How many deaths are there today on Route 13, Route 1, or any traffic? So are we going to put a moratorium on driving? No. What we're going to do is measure the cost versus the benefit. Right now, there is not a problem with people dying in houses that are not sprinklered, then why are we creating a solution for something that we don't have a problem? And I'm not saying this just to be a smart aleck. I'm saying these things to point out some of the other observations. Um Look, that presentation was emotional, and Jason is my close friend. I appreciate everything. Um But I have some questions on some of the properties. There were two, only, of all the pictures there were only three or four mentioned, am I correct, Jason, in that had a death, and of those, how many were monitored or we had smoke detectors in them? Um Sunset, Lockerman Street, New Street. So the real problem that I have, the stakeholders weren't addressed, weren't aren't weren't given an opportunity to work with everyone and to come up with compromises and solutions and talk about this as an adult. Have a conversation with Jason, have a conversation up here, we can't debate things back and forth. So in the future, I would make a strong suggestion that you seek out all the stakeholders: those that supply fire sprinklers, those that use them, and those that have to participate in the industry in which they will affect. So look, you got a tough decision, I appreciate the opportunity to speak. The affordability crisis right now outweighs the need to save zero lives that were that would've been passed over the past 25 years.

Reproducir desde 1:48:40

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you. Don't go away just yet. Uh let me see your hand.

Reproducir desde 1:50:47

Fred A. Neil

One of the aspects haven't been addressed is resale. Can you address that with the home with or without a sprinkler?

Reproducir desde 1:50:57

Todd Stonesifer

What's the question, Councilman? I'm sorry, I don't

Reproducir desde 1:51:09

Fred A. Neil

Was it is it is a home more salable with the sprinkler system?

Reproducir desde 1:51:12

Todd Stonesifer

So what we do is we do an analysis called a comparative market analysis, and if I am, for example, there are townhouses as fire chief mentioned, Silver Lake, that have sprinkler systems. There are also townhouses in adjacent areas, and so we would use sales from an adjacent area to to help us suggest what those prices might be on a new house in Silver Lake, and I would never make an adjustment because that sprinkler or one didn't. So there would be no increased resale value, in my expert opinion, for a house that has a sprinkler system over one that does not. There are other realtors in the room, and I would suggest you could ask them the same question. They'll have different opinions, but in my opinion, there is no added value in the resale. There's an added cost in the new construction that doesn't equate in reselling.

Reproducir desde 1:51:18

Fred A. Neil

All right. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:52:11

City Clerk

Uh last one I have on the list, please pardon your first name, Bernd Lenger?

Reproducir desde 1:52:16

Bernd Lenger

Good evening. Um my question doesn't relate to residential, although it does address the building code that you're looking at. I see that there's an amendment being done here on residential. If you're going to do an addition, you do not need to retrofit the existing. Um I represent a church here in the neighborhood, and half of our facility's sprinklered and half isn't. And we're looking to doing an addition on the sprinklered section section. However, we're being told that we have to retrofit all the existing as well, and that's what's killed this code go right now. So we're looking in. We're not sure how we're going to be proceeding with our project if we have to retrofit all that existing area as well. I just want to bring that up as another code that could probably help. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 1:52:33

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you. Okay. Now we're going to uh recognize other. Is there anyone else? Okay. And then, uh, see the others that everybody's going to get a chance, okay?

Reproducir desde 1:53:27

Tonya

Good evening, everyone. My name is Tonya, I live in Dover. I do not like the fact that we have to put a sprinkler system in our home. My first question is, what is our Constitution like? You are taking our rights from us to tell us what we can and cannot have in my home. No disrespect, this man back here has built four homes, you guys has been riding his butt about different things. This is ridiculous. Third, third, the time with the um uh firefighters said it takes them an hour to get to a house fire, how long does it take for them to get to the fire station when they're at work someplace else? I don't think it's fair the way y'all sit here and you're judging and putting wanting to put stuff in people's house. What are you going to do next, tell people what kind of underwear they can wear? This is ridiculous. You know why? Y'all sit here, and y'all push stuff on people. All these gentleman back here, young men, I appreciate everything they're doing, but I guarantee you not one of them live on their own. I bet they live home with their mama. No, that's all I have to say.

Reproducir desde 1:53:56

Roy Sudler, Jr.

By the way, thank for your information. I wanted to point out to the members of the committee that an email sent by the town of Fort Worth today, if you'd like to pull it up, might be beneficial.

Reproducir desde 1:56:19

Cameron Llewellyn

Name? Uh my name is Cameron Llewellyn, work at 117 West Reed Street. I can guarantee you these guys don't live with their parents in the basement. They're badasses over there, and I can assure they're what's what bones and uh they're they're offering to help. Um so uh full disclosure uh we're both town houses, Jason talking about them, they got a 2-in main and it splits off to 3/4. I'm not going to go back through that. What I can tell you is it's the line size that's expensive, okay? So that 2-in line coming in uh it's not ungodly expensive, it's a piece of plastic, 2-in in diameter. But when it gets to a meter, the meter's got to be at least an inch and 1/2 so that the 2-in of water ripping through there, can it can get somewhere. You don't want to choke it down like peeing in a garden hose. Uh just the meter pits that we had to use were $13,000 more than a standard 3/4-in meter pit. Write that down, it's going to be on your test. So it so, I believe in sprinklers, I don't want these guys getting hurt, but I also, you know, I we agreed to this, Jason, a long time ago. But my daughter says every time I come to City Hall, my blood pressure goes up. So we got a lot more questions we need to answer, and I haven't had a chance to sit down with Matt and Jason, but I think we need to pump the brakes on that. Um

Reproducir desde 1:56:42

Public Commenter

So, um, yeah, we did that voluntarily because we didn't want our kids to have no backyard. So it's something called sprinkler in lieu of access, okay? So in order to have backyards and not have an alley stepping out on the asphalt, we had to sprinkle those units because these guys can't get fire truck back there. What I want you guys to understand is that same language, sprinkler in lieu of access, this is going to blow your minds. That language was used when the library behind me, in front of you, was built. There was supposed to be an alley between this building and that. They didn't do it. They didn't put an alley in. So City of Dover agreed to put a sprinkler system in this building, retrofitted, which y'all look up. It was in our budget, $212,000 to put a sprinkler system retrofitted into this building, and it never got done. So I really think right now you guys ought to keep your side of the street clean before we start telling individuals they have to put a sprinkler system when we're all in grave danger if a home burns in grave danger, because there's no sprinkler system in here. So let's go back. Let's look at that. Let's tidy that up. And then we can go back. I don't want these guys getting hurt, but I also leave, people don't afford more, like that's not something to buy, the taxpayer. Sound good? I look forward to uh what you guys come back with.

Reproducir desde 1:57:57

Public Commenter

Thanks.

Reproducir desde 1:59:29

Council Member

Thank you. Who's the other...?

Reproducir desde 1:59:30

Council Member

Have anyone else uh speak? Yeah, well, we got to make sure everyone's voice is heard.

Reproducir desde 1:59:36

Homeowner

Hello, City Council. I do respect the fire department very well, but as a homeowner who's lived in my house for 7 years, um, and going back to what, um, the outset uh group one with uh afford home what can't afford a home cuz it doesn't apply to them, um, going back a couple years ago, me and my husband had a house built. They put whatever they had to in order to upgrade it. We backed off from having a brand-new house that we paid for. Instead, we bought a nice little old-fashioned house, 63 years old now, about 65 by now. I love it. But if you I had to add an addition or anything else and add a sprinkler system to it, not only with the cost of the addition hit me hard, the sprinkler system, that would have to be applied, would also hit me pretty dang hard, along with the utility raise for that addition. So the more cost we put on homeowners that have two jobs and still are fighting city council for other things that are being raised like taxes and utilities, having a sprinkler system for an addition to a house is just like fighting the same battle that nothing gets done with. So, in in in order to go back and redo to where it's a choice, do you want to put a sprinkler system in, or do you not want to put a sprinkler system in in order to put an addition in? Newer construction, go have at it, but also let the homeowners know that that sprinkler system is being is the reason why their house is more expensive, and they may lose it within the next year or two when they can't afford to live there anymore. So, I mean, we can either have people on the street, or we pay or we can force people to put sprinkler systems in their house and still be on the street. So, it it's your guys' choice. I'm for it for being safe in my house, but not at the cost of having to put something in that's I have to maintain, I have to pay for someone to come look at it, I have to make sure that it's running properly because it may fail, and that part of my house might go under and affect the rest of my house just fine, and I'm still left with nothing. I mean, we we really do have to think before we go passing things that gives impacts on these on the constituents and, you know, make force them to do something they don't want to do.

Reproducir desde 1:59:44

Homeowner

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:02:07

Council Member

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:02:09

Phil McGinnis

Thank you all very much. My name is Phil McGinnis, McGinnis Commercial Real Estate. I do applaud the first responders. They should be protected. But there is a question about housing affordability. I've been in business 47 years in this town, this city, and I've spent just about every day working to strengthen this community. I have advocated for affordability. I think Allen Clark, who was an elected legislator, can confirm that. Uh housing affordability is the American dream, and a comment I heard earlier was that we conceded that some people aren't entitled to the American dream, that they're resigned to living in apartments. And that breaks my heart. The home builders did a study some years ago and and analyzed construction costs: 26, 27, 28% of the cost of a new home is in regulatory requirements. This food isn't helping that. The reason that we have our citizens can't attain the American dream is because we keep raising the cost of housing to the point where there are no starter homes, builders can't build starter homes. Middletown, Lewes, the median price of those homes are $4-, $5-, $600,000. When you're trying to provide starter homes for $200,000, $225,000, ain't going to happen. Um, there was a question about the cost of sprinklers, and I get that. The hard cost of the sprinklers, whatever it is, $4- or $5,000, $2,000, what whatever it is, that's the input cost. That's not the retail cost. Every cost that's every input cost in the price of a home gets marked up over and transfer taxes get applied, and so forth. And so while the hard cost might be $5,000, the end cost is going to be $10- or $12,000 on the retail price. Um, and so yes, you can finance it, but as you've heard a couple of times, the $1,000 increase in the price of a house prices out our citizens from the American dream. There's got to be a solution other than this. I don't know what it is, and I'm more than happy with work with Toddy, as he suggested, to find the solution. But affordability and safety is really what we need at this point. Thank you all very much. I appreciate your patience.

Reproducir desde 2:02:24

Council Member

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:05:35

Council Member

Okay, we're going to go online and uh and enter your name, please, sir.

Reproducir desde 2:05:49

Zach Prebula

Can you hear me?

Reproducir desde 2:05:58

Council Member

Hi, we can hear you. Your name and town for the record?

Reproducir desde 2:05:59

Zach Prebula

Hi, it's Zach Prebula. I'm the Director of Operations for the Kent Economic Partnership. And uh we're the economic development organization for Kent County, and we focus on business retention, expansion, and attraction, and creating quality employment opportunities throughout the county. Uh I'm here to express our concerns with the proposed adoption of the building codes and the potential impact they could have on housing affordability and economic development. As we continue working to attract new businesses and support the expansion of our existing businesses, one of the most important factors is having a reliable workforce. But attracting businesses and creating jobs is only part of that equation. We also need to make sure that employees building these positions have access to housing that they can afford. When businesses are looking at locations for new investment or expansion, the availability of a workforce is a major consideration. If employees can't afford to live in or near the communities where they work, it becomes much more difficult for businesses to attract and retain the employees they need to operate and grow. With housing affordability already being a challenge throughout Kent County, we need to be mindful of additional construction requirements that could further increase housing costs and limit new development. And for these reasons, we ask you to reconsider this. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:06:03

Council Member

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:07:28

Council Member

I believe do uh Keith, do you want to respond to that? Or uh the Fire Chief is there. He can say uh You don't need to start the timer. Call the Fire Chief.

Reproducir desde 2:07:31

Fire Chief

Good evening. Hearing the Fire Chief here in Dover, I just want to kind of bring some of this into perspective for you. Um, so we talk about residential sprinkler systems and fire alarm systems throughout the City of Dover. We talk about how fire alarm systems save lives. I want I want what I want to bring to perspective for you is many of the times when we're going into these houses, single-family dwellings, townhouses, apartment buildings, we're going in and finding the smoke detectors either disconnected or no batteries in them, laying on the counter. Why? Because they went beep, beep, beep, and they were tired of hearing it and took it off the ceiling and sat it down. And now they have no protection at all. Um, so while there's a fire alarm system throughout the building, now the fire has to get big bigger for another smoke detector to activate somewhere else in the residence or in the building. Talk about fire flows. We're talking about 25 gallons a minute. When we pull up, the first line we pull is going to flow 185 gallons a minute. The last house fire we had on Governors Avenue, we probably threw 15,000 gallons at that. Big difference. So when you're talking about water consumption, we're flowing a lot of water for a fire compared to a sprinkler head that's going to contain a room with less than 300 gallons from one line. And you may even be able to live in your house the same evening because it's going to be contained to a small area. We go to kitchen fires all the time in apartment buildings where the sprinkler head goes off, contains it to the stove, just a little bit of darkness on the ceiling above, no damage to the building probably at all. Um, we talked about affordability, you know, and, yeah, I understand that you know, people worry. But you're talking about people's lives. Um, you know, recently I bought a house. Built a house out there and it's just a just under 2,500 square foot. It was supposed to cost $5,000 square $5,000 for a sprinkler system. I wasn't going to go without one today when I knew we have a great fire department here. We staff our fire trucks 24 hours a day, the majority of the time, well-trained firemen. But I know other places are not that way. It takes them minutes to get out the door. On top of minutes to get to the scene to put the fire out, I wouldn't build a house without it. I would do away with my HBO channel before I would do away with a sprinkler system. Um, there was a comment about no fire deaths in the City er in New Castle County in 25 years. The night, I believe, you guys passed the sprinkler ordinance, there was a fire in Wilmington where two people died. Just a couple weeks ago, I believe one of them jumped from a second-floor window or third-floor window. He's a Wilmington fireman happens to be here with us as well. So, talking about saving lives, sprinklers are the way to go. Yeah, it's a little bit of cost, but you look at the overall picture of this, and it's doing the right thing for your people. And the majority of our fires are in these affordability places. Think about it. Governors Avenue, Fulton Street, some of the other pictures that the Fire Marshal gave you. We have a lot of fires downtown where affordability is an issue. Now, these people are homeless because they didn't have a sprinkler system. They can't move back. So, consider that as well. That's all I have for that, Mr. Chairman.

Reproducir desde 2:07:44

Council Member

Go ahead, Mr. Mayor.

Reproducir desde 2:11:25

Robin R. Christiansen

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I know this might be a conflict, Chief, but I want a point of clarification since you're my boss in another avenue. But Chief, the lady stepped to the podium and said it took an hour for the fire department to get someplace. Have we ever had a response time of an hour unless we're going like to Delmar or to Clayton? Can you please clarify that, sir?

Reproducir desde 2:11:30

Fire Chief

So, I'll give you a step-by-step process here. So when you call 911, it's answered by a 911 communicator. That person has up to 90 seconds to take the call, which means that person goes through a variety of questions to find out what type of incident that you have: a house fire, car fire, whatever. And then they ask questions in regards to the structure, trapped, where are they at inside, what kind of fire do you have, where's the fire located. Um, once all that information is taken, it's transferred to fire dispatcher that dispatches the fire department. Like I said, we're staffed in the fire station. 2:00 in the morning, uh I'll tell you that taking us 90 seconds to get out. Guys have to get out of bed, run down the steps, put their gear on, start the truck, get out the door. We're on scene on an average of approximately 5 minutes in close proximity to within the city limits. Now we have areas outside the city limits near by Dover Air Force Base. It takes us a lot longer to get there because of travel time. Or west of Dover, we run out almost out to Pearson's Corner. Takes us time to get there. Um, but we're normally on scene within the 5 to 6-minute window throughout the city. Um, it's always our staff which the majority of the time we are, and we've never taken an hour. Now, I will say if it was during the tornado, there were calls that probably went pending, and some of the network dispatching could probably answer those questions, um where we've let wires down tend or a tree in a tree down in the roadway tend, because it wasn't important enough as compared to the house that had a tree that fell through it, there's people stuck inside. That would be the only issue, only time that it would take us an hour to respond.

Reproducir desde 2:11:53

Robin R. Christiansen

Thank you, Chief. I appreciate that clarification. Mr. Chairman, I yield.

Reproducir desde 2:13:47

Council Member

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:13:51

Tony Fleming

Good evening. Hold on a second. Hi, everyone. Actually, my name's Tony Fleming. I'm actually a sprinkler contractor that services the Mid-Atlantic area. So, I got quite a bit of experience doing this since 1998. Um, and we've done work from D.C., Delaware, Maryland, Mid-Atlantic area. So, a couple things that I've heard about the cost and all that. I've actually sat on some Delaware committees uh speaking about the cost now. For Delaware, we went from $1.61, and then 13 and 09 it dropped down to like $1.37. We're currently doing one right now in Sussex that is at $1.20, comparing it across the country to what these costs are. So, but I can tell you that our company, we do quite a bit of work in in Delaware, it's primarily that does the trade-offs or whatever, from builders that want it. Our cost as a whole, when there's uh incoming water is typically around $1.75 a square foot or lower. That's right now. I'd be glad to share proposals to back to show you that, all of them. A lot of builders in here are talking about the markups and all that. I cannot control that, but I can tell you the price of that for charging for it. So, a couple of things that I heard too, drawings, and I'm going to speak real fast. I'm going to try to cover all this as I can, so, sorry about that. Speak fast anyway. But a couple of things, uh I heard about the extra fee for having drawings uh stamped by a NICET Level 2 or an engineer. That's actually a state requirement anyways, so it's irrelevant, because you have to have that like you have to have that requirement to get a license. So, that basically kills that out, because you should have that individual on your staff stamping it all anyways to get a license from the state. Um, pause my own timer. Every year, it's funny, every year since the innovation of smoke detectors, there's close to 3,000 deaths. That number has not changed in all these years. Since 1978, that number has not gone down. A matter of fact, last year was one of the highest years that we had in the country. So, you can look this up, and now with the innovation of ChatGPT, everyone's just everyone knows everything. So, all these, you can fact-check everything I'm saying, and trust me, I'm almost as fine. It's safe and from what I know and everything. Now, here's an interesting fact. The incoming line, I heard one talk about the incoming line. Believe it or not, contrary to what you what you've heard and everything, you can, and it's going to be an issue with the water authority which you can do. A lot of times, typically in some areas, we do bottleneck lines. In other words, you can come in with a 3/4-inch line right to the property and then run a larger-sized line from there. That actually it sounds crazy that you bottleneck it, but when we're calculating sprinklers, we're calculating it based on friction loss. So, yes, you're going to have a higher friction loss for that first 10, 15, 20 feet. But then from then on, if false would run a 2-inch line versus anything else, shouldn't be any difference. The real cost would be in the meter, but in every situation, the meter size is always typically smaller than the line. So, you heard a gentleman say something about, you know, where you run a 3/4 line to a 5/8 meter, that's always a common phase. So, you have a bottleneck right there, so realistically, you can bottleneck the line. You just have to calculate it through a house for water. Um, and I'd be glad to share ideas and stuff on that, too. Sprinkler heads, like I said, typical residential sprinkler head only does 13 gallons a minute. So, when two go off, and 98% of all fires, only one head ever goes off, but when two heads do go off, you're actually talking about only 26 gallons. Um, bathrooms, you don't have to sprinkle everything. Unfinished basements, finished basements, bathrooms less than 55, closets less than 24, do not need it. And around this Mid-Atlantic area, too, New York is very close right now. We're one vote away from getting New York to pass, as well as Virginia. If you go in there, Maryland, just like you said earlier, early since 2011 has been a requirement. Um, and then one thing that I hear, cuz I go all over East Coast One last thought. One last thought. One thing that I hear that always frightens me is I always hear the time is not right. Well, I've sat in situations where we were in a recession, and then people are complaining times are not right. Right now, what I know in Delaware from where I work and what I see,

Reproducir desde 2:14:12

Unknown Speaker

getting right travel. Everything's booming. So when is the right time? Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:17:37

Council President

Anyone have a final thought? Seeing no people who have spoken, oh wait a minute. Yes, I'll give you a one minute for your final thought to see if something pops in your mind.

Reproducir desde 2:17:48

Council President

Okay. If everyone is uh that thought, then we will uh return back to the committee. And the committee has the different options, um, option to recommend, option to uh, to uh, refer to staff for changes, or to uh, send, send on to uh, to the uh, council. Um, Councilman Lewis, did you uh, have any uh, thoughts?

Reproducir desde 2:18:05

Brian E. Lewis

Well, my first comment is does anybody uh on the committee have any issues with uh the ordinance uh as a whole with the exception of section R309 automatic sprinkler systems? Has everybody read it thoroughly, so there's no question or concerns or issues with the uh content of the ordinance itself? Um, so the only issue would be uh with the automatic sprinkler system. So um, this particular ordinance, uh Mr. Chair, if I stay uncorrect, uh has been amended. That's why it's returned. Um,

Reproducir desde 2:18:44

Council President

It amended. In essence, uh yes, uh they were more of a technical amendments because the uh the previous, it was 17 years between the the first uh the one we had and this one, basically, I think you'd say 15 years with the additions. And the sections didn't line up that were being referred to. Um, and that was uh discovered uh uh right after passage when they were trying to enforce it. And it to fix it to that would have been so complicated, it was better to strike it, uh put it back in, uh replace the a new uh section a replacement of the whole section of the code, so you didn't have problems lining things up. And then and that way, it's just better technically and everyone can read it and understand it and follow it and enforce it. So it was a technical formatting issue.

Reproducir desde 2:19:33

Brian E. Lewis

Well, before uh I make any motions to uh the effect of this ordinances, uh my esteemed colleague, uh Councilman uh Dr. Sudler uh have anything that he wants to introduce or propose?

Reproducir desde 2:20:45

Council President

Recognized.

Reproducir desde 2:21:02

Roy Sudler, Jr.

I I recognize Dr. Sudler. Thank you for uh recognizing me. I do have a brief statement. Before I go into that, I do believe that a very nice should be offered. for a fire chief should be offered, but I think I don't think we have enough information, particularly like he presented. In all of this, um my main concern is infrastructure, and when we talk about infrastructure and our vulnerabilities and being able to sustain whatever infrastructure strain that we may encounter and how it's going to impact our constituents, whether utility or tax hike, I'm just not convinced that all of the I's have been dotted and all the T's have been crossed. I think it's been compelling arguments on both sides: life safety as well as affordability. So, a practice for everyone, how would we balance that? which leads me right back to my initial statement that I prepared. So, I'm just going to go ahead and read that, and then, whatever should come should come. That's, I just want to put it on record that I clarify it. Hopefully the majority of the information is accurate. I'm not an expert in this domain, but I'm only to go off of the information I receive from experts, which have different interpretations and their descent.

Reproducir desde 2:21:03

Roy Sudler, Jr.

So, as one of three council members representing District 4 in the capital of Delaware, I believe that we must carefully balance essential safety standards with the economic realities of housing affordability. Every policy this committee endorses must be based on verified data and necessity of our local community. A detailed analysis of concerns raised by constituents, specifically the price multiplication effect highlighted by real estate analyst Bill McGuinness, and the infrastructure water pressure trap articulated by retired utilities engineer Richard J. Murphy, and the questionable heat activation data discussed by broker Bobby Stangall, demonstrates that maintaining a mandatory sprinkler system requirement, requirement could severely hinder affordable housing development and adversely affect our real estate market. Thus, I propose adopting the buyer option program, a strong pro-consumer initiative that allows home buyers to decide whether to install residential sprinkler systems. With transparent pricing from builders, adopting it as a means of empowering choice not only supports consumers, but also aligns with our commitment under the Housing for Every Delaware Act, Delawarean Act, and significantly strengthens the economic foundation for our 2028 Comprehensive Plan renewal. Empowering buyers with choice isn't just equitable, it's essential for maintaining housing affordability. Real estate analyst Bill McGuinness warns us of the price multiplication effect where a reasonable initial installation cost of $4,000 to $5,000 can boost the final home price by nearly $14,000 once costs pass through engineering, finance, and builder margins. With up to 25% of housing construction costs driven by government regulations, an additional $5,000 to $14,000 can effectively exclude low- to moderate-income families and first-time buyers from the market. The proposed $200 annual property tax credit does not appease this disparity. The buyer option program enables organizations like Central Delaware Habitat for Humanity to produce affordable housing, or affordable homes, by allowing consumers who want these systems to opt in based on builder pricing. In addition, giving consumer choice protections homeowners from substantial infrastructure and property liabilities. As former facilities engineer Richard J. Murphy points out, the infrastructure water pressure trap indicates that our public water grid may lack the capacity to sustain high-demand systems uniformly. A proper implementation would require installing, or could require installing, off-standalone fire loops, creating, and potential creating, a double-utility rate scenario in which homeowners would be responsible for the cost of additional connections and fees. Moreover, consumers may be confronted with daily risks, such as high-pressure flooding due to accidental breaks in fragile systems, pipe freezing in unconditioned space spaces during extreme cold, issues with home filtration systems that could impair fire loop functionality, unwarranted annual inspection fees for backflow prevention that can add up significantly. Um this is essential to acknowledge the data presented. In 2023, Kent County reported no fire-related fatalities. Could be wrong, like I said, I'm not an expert in this domain. Um no, uh reported no fire fatalities, and research suggests that stringent regulatory measures do not materially impact the incidence of fire deaths when, how can I say it, um, when the the effectiveness of well-maintained smoke detectors, or in conjunction with the presence of multiple smoke detectors. The evidence strongly supports that the buyer option program, once, promotes consumer choice, protects homeowners' opportunity, honors our local empirical data, and supports overall market stability by enabling municipalities to impose rigorous regulations on high commercial developments. Lastly, we must assess our city's water infrastructure comprehensively. As the capital of Delaware, we encounter a critical challenge: heavy industrial data centers consume millions of gallons of cooling, raising legitimate worries about our ability to meet both these needs and the essential requirements of a robust residential fire loop network. Without a meticulous engineering report on our infrastructure vulnerabilities, we risk compromising water pressure during peak times. Furthermore, operating without an up-to-date water capacity report shifts financial liabilities onto residents for both increased risk of inadequate fire protection. While I recognize the importance of essential life safety standards, I believe we must prioritize our community safety by ensuring our water supply meets all requirements for everyone's needs. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for allowing me to raise this proposal. And it is my intention to move forward, to give you the floor, to enable the buyer option framework that would benefit I think, thank you. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:22:50

Council President

Councilwoman Arndt.

Reproducir desde 2:29:25

Tricia K. Arndt

Thank you for recognizing me. Well, I I feel the wind shifting here in the chamber, uh, and I just want to to put on record my thoughts. Um, we've passed this once. Uh, it it went through committee. We had many discussions, then it was presented to the council floor, and we passed it um, almost unanimously, one abstention, or maybe everybody, you or no. Um, this is no different. It is the same ordinance, nothing has changed. Um, sprinklers are not new. Uh, the point has been made that it's been in the code since 2009 and enforceable since 2011. We would not be the only uh, town in the in the state to have this requirement. Um, we would be following Newark, uh, City of New Castle, Delaware City, Camden, Milton. Our staff has stated that we do have the the water infrastructure, the pressure, the capacity. And I think the the main thing that is is driving me to to maintain this position, is the fact that we have a volunteer firefighting department. And I think we should be doing all that we can to make sure that new construction is built to the standard that protects them as well as us, as well as our property. And I am not changing my vote. I'm going to continue to vote in support of this ordinance. I yield.

Reproducir desde 2:29:26

Fred A. Neil

Mr. Chairman.

Reproducir desde 2:30:49

Council President

Uh, Mr. Neil.

Reproducir desde 2:30:51

Fred A. Neil

Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh basically, we have three of our members that are absent. We have one who has uh recused herself for a vote. I move that we table this till the members of the council are in session, because it'll be very unfair to be able to get a majority vote of the total uh council with with the uh members of uh the committee uh to pass a law uh with without uh getting five votes uh to win or or to whether it pass or not. So, I suggest that we table this and come back, because if it is not, basically, I'm going to vote with the losing side in order to bring it up, for pure transparency, to make sure that it's considered by everybody in this council. You have my motion.

Reproducir desde 2:30:53

Council President

I would point out that with the current number, uh, it would uh take uh six out of the seven votes to advance it to the floor. So, but you have the motion. The motion to lay on the table. I would ask, uh, okay, I will, uh, I would ask that we take some time and, like Mr. Slavin requested, that we see if we can have a discussion between now and, uh, and uh, then uh, with the with the stakeholders on, on both sides. It may not change anything, but, but who knows, maybe something creative can happen. Um, and the, the motion to lay on the table is not a, a, a, a debatable motion. And if, uh, no one has an objection, is there any objection? No, it's by unanimous consent. I'll take Mr., uh, a second.

Reproducir desde 2:31:48

Brian E. Lewis

It's not debatable.

Reproducir desde 2:32:45

Council President

It's by unanimous, is there a second? I have a second. Call the roll, please.

Reproducir desde 2:32:47

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you, I just want to say that I want to help the everything about the sprinkler system, that's why I'll descend. And I think that we should, I think they were all in agreement based on the last, you know, I guess the when we voted that time unanimously, I wasn't here, though, for that, and it was always 7. But it wasn't 8 to 1. It was actually, that should be, I think, 7, I think 7, and one absent, one absent, and then, yeah. So, um, I would like to see the rest of the reg- regulation, what do you call it, the the The code? the code, yes, sir. I'd like to see that, try that to go on with independent sprinkler system. That's why I ascended that with that sprinkler system component and the mandate is what I'm concerned about. Um, so that's why I descend, I just wanted to state that for the record.

Reproducir desde 2:32:55

Council President

Councilman Lewis.

Reproducir desde 2:34:01

Brian E. Lewis

I I concur with Councilman Sudler. Actually, um I was going to make a motion, and it was going to be to that effect, to except the proposed ordinance uh as a whole with the exclusion of section R309. It is uh That's why I asked did anybody have any issues with the uh the rest of the ordinance and its content. So, um, I mean I I think we need to get the the full ordinance uh introduced and let it move forward to council here at the committee with the exclusion of section R309 uh for further review with uh staff uh and the stakeholders involved. Uh, that's where I stand.

Reproducir desde 2:34:02

Council President

It makes sense. Um, I I mean it's not uh nothing wrong with that, and if you feel that way, it's good to move forward. But you know also folks, I like the motion because I think it it brings that item back separately. I don't I don't know, I'd I'd like to uh uh just let everyone have the time uh talk. And then if uh and then we can bring it back and and then we can do the same thing, we can vote on the amendments. But, but I would like to give uh Mrs. Arndt a chance to at least uh have her ordinance as uh she intended um to to come before council or have a vote to amend it. I mean if, you know, one way or the other, you know. But yeah, this stuff is what whatever you all want, of course, majority rules. Uh Councilman Lewis.

Reproducir desde 2:34:51

Brian E. Lewis

And and further more, for the record, I object to uh Council President Neil's uh introduction of this, or his motion, because um we've had council meetings before where council members have been absent. Councilman Sudler was absent when this was voted on previously. So, I think that's discriminatory in nature because just because other council members aren't here, we're going to delay a vote, um, and we do have, you know, civilian committee members here, we have a quorum. So, I just want put that on the record that um, it's discriminatory in nature, and I hope the media gets uh,

Reproducir desde 2:36:17

Council President

Holy, call the roll please.

Reproducir desde 2:36:59

Brian E. Lewis

I'm, on, on, uh, you know, that, on, on, and you know, so, it's not fair to the civilian members.

Reproducir desde 2:37:00

Unknown Speaker

It's not fair to this one civilian member because if members aren't here,

Reproducir desde 2:37:07

Brian E. Lewis

these

Reproducir desde 2:37:11

Council President

Just please just vote. Just the majority of the people

Reproducir desde 2:37:12

Fred A. Neil

here. Can I get a yes on that? Okay. It's been first, second. All in favor of the motion to pay, please say aye.

Reproducir desde 2:37:16

Julia M. Pillsbury

Aye.

Reproducir desde 2:37:21

Brian E. Lewis

Aye.

Reproducir desde 2:37:22

Fred A. Neil

All opposed, nay? Okay. Go to sleep, Brian.

Reproducir desde 2:37:23

Brian E. Lewis

In the spirit of being Dover, you know, I agree with this, with Councilman Lewis that, you know, I wish people would consider being in a, you know, a part of the Dover, in the spirit of being Dover when it's appropriate, you know, vote in favor of, you know, thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:37:26

Fred A. Neil

Uh, all, all, all opposed, no. I would say the, if somebody calls for division, I'd say the motion passes.

Reproducir desde 2:37:42

Fred A. Neil

Thank you. And uh, probably fully unsatisfying to everybody.

Reproducir desde 2:37:51

Fred A. Neil

Unless somebody's got us beat tonight, we'll follow our next five. Oh wait, there's item two. This is uh human resources committee or a committee of council. Yes. All prepare your soul. Holy treasure. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:38:20

Lori Peddicord

So just to put this into context, you know, you can't just go into your program and hit a button to say I want to print a budget report. You'd have to download and there's various things that you have to do to create that specific report. There's also what's called cell sense. We've met with, I believe it was Newark or New Castle, they also use the same program that we use.

Reproducir desde 2:38:41

Fred A. Neil

Good evening, Ms. Lori. Lori Peddicord. All right. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:39:29

Lori Peddicord

Uh, I'm before you tonight uh just as an opportunity uh to provide additional training and uh infrastructure or systems of an infrastructure build to the city that would benefit not just the financial uh team the finance team, but the city as a whole. Uh, I will say that there's no budget impact here. We already have the funds budgeted for it. There is a cost of uh at least $20,000. We may have to uh increase that. I conferred with Tyler yesterday. We need to consider, instead, attending upon uh how many implementation hours that we want to put in place to build some of the critical pieces that will aid us in improving our financial reporting uh modules, our budgeting reporting modules, our project ledger reporting modules and tracking modules. uh cash cash management and uh procurement. Differ- different training modules. Just as an example, we have several bank accounts where our finance team uh actually manually uses Excel spreadsheets and pivot tables, etc. etc. to balance our checkbooks every month, which is quite time consuming. We have thousands and thousands of entries and I'd like to automate those processes using the systems that we already have and the city has invested uh quite the money in. Uh, the other item which would be specifically uh interesting to you is uh implementing a priority-based budgeting module based on directive that we've received from council. Uh, with that said, uh of course the other other piece of it, as I said before, is that financial reporting. It'll help us uh complete our ACFR, I think, in a better better time more timely manner. Uh, right now our ACFR is about 300 pages and we do that all by hand. Okay? There's nothing automated about it. Uh, so, I think it's important that our staff gets the training that they've asked for that they need, and that's the purpose behind uh this request. Um, and as I said, that we already have the money budgeted. There's no additional cost, but I wanted to uh bring this to council's attention for openness and and full Thank you very much, Lori.

Reproducir desde 2:39:34

Fred A. Neil

Thank you very much, Lori. I will recognize uh Councilman Lewis.

Reproducir desde 2:42:27

Brian E. Lewis

Ms. Mauri, um I'm all for a priority-based budget, and you know, I'm in line with that. But um who need this trainer? How many people in your department are needing training on the one? And why now, since you've been in this position for over a year? Okay. Why are we implementing now?

Reproducir desde 2:42:32

Lori Peddicord

It's not a new request. This is a request that over the last uh 2-year almost 2 years I've been in the position, I've identified concerns from my staff, and from other city staff, and found the deficiencies where we need to improve on.

Reproducir desde 2:42:44

Brian E. Lewis

Okay. So um is there anybody in your office that is trained in it already that can train staff or are you trained?

Reproducir desde 2:42:56

Lori Peddicord

Yes, I am trained in this, but this is an improvement to our training.

Reproducir desde 2:43:27

Brian E. Lewis

So you couldn't train the staff to save $20,000?

Reproducir desde 2:43:30

Lori Peddicord

This is not just training the staff, it's also building modules that have not been built. Okay? So there are staff that are newer that need trained that have never worked within a government entity before that would need the additional support, and as much as I would love to be on top of them everyday, I'm required to attend several meetings and be available for other priorities.

Reproducir desde 2:43:33

Brian E. Lewis

Okay. Uh so, um my next question is, um are you hiring anybody that has this kind of training already, in the requirements?

Reproducir desde 2:43:51

Lori Peddicord

We do look for employees or staff members that have MUNIS-specific training, absolutely. Uh it is hard to find, as I've said all before the board. Government accounting, and Tyler is a specific program that, again, requires experience within a government. Okay. How long is the training?

Reproducir desde 2:43:58

Brian E. Lewis

Okay, how long is the training?

Reproducir desde 2:44:42

Lori Peddicord

It depends on on the actual module, but this is up to 15 15 hours or 15 weeks, so it's 8 hours per day for 15 weeks.

Reproducir desde 2:44:43

Brian E. Lewis

Okay. And is that take staff uh a curtailment of doing their work in the office?

Reproducir desde 2:44:51

Lori Peddicord

No, we would intertwine that with their daily work. The idea is basically, if you train individual staff members or train the trainer, and you can utilize your existing workload within that training module to make sure that you're getting the adequate use of time and still get the work done.

Reproducir desde 2:44:54

Brian E. Lewis

Okay. I don't have no further questions.

Reproducir desde 2:45:33

Fred A. Neil

Mr. Chairman? Thank you. Councilwoman Arndt? Councilman Rocha? Okay.

Reproducir desde 2:45:36

Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Um, yes. Um, Ms. Mauri,

Reproducir desde 2:45:39

Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.

is Tyler have they been very difficult to work with or was a different Tyler uh system that we were having troubles with?

Reproducir desde 2:45:41

Lori Peddicord

They used

Reproducir desde 2:45:55

Lori Peddicord

We've

Reproducir desde 2:45:56

Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.

So in other words this is and how long have we been are are we committed with Tyler?

Reproducir desde 2:46:16

Lori Peddicord

We completed uh once we got to phase 4, it did not work for our city's needs.

Reproducir desde 2:46:19

Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.

And hopefully, this will then speed up the processes that's basically, not your fault, but basically this is what what has occurred uh of while we have to be paying catch-up so much.

Reproducir desde 2:46:28

Lori Peddicord

So so, to put this into context, the banking reconciliation module should have been put into place with phase 1, and it was not. Okay? Uh so, that one, especially, takes a significant amount of time for the finance team to complete our bank reconciliations. The reporting modules use what's called cubes. Uh and sometimes cubes break. So, you can't just go into your program and hit a button to say I want to print a budget report. You have to download and uh there's various things that you have to do to create that specific report. Uh there's also what's called CellSense. Uh we've met with, I believe it was Newark or New Castle, they also use the same program that we use. And uh what CellSense does is map, using your general ledger numbers, it maps the uh the information from your general ledger, specifically to a report that you're building. Uh so, that's not something that was built previously, and we'd like to build those things to improve our reporting processes.

Reproducir desde 2:46:36

Fred A. Neil

Okay. I want to welcome uh Councilwoman Hall back, and uh Councilwoman Arndt, your hand came on.

Reproducir desde 2:47:46

Tricia K. Arndt

Thank you. So, I'm reading from your um your write up here, and you're going to be able to use modules that we have essentially paid for in the system that have not been fully developed. Right? Okay. And then you're going to train folks to to use those systems, plus improve the use of the system overall, and this is going to improve the accuracy and efficiency of your staff, right? Correct. Okay. And it's within budget. That is fantastic. So, I'm going to go ahead and make a motion to approve the staff recommendation to authorize to proceed with the Tyler MUNIS ERP training.

Reproducir desde 2:47:54

Fred A. Neil

It's been moved and seconded uh to approve the staff recommendation. Discussion? Dr. Sudler?

Reproducir desde 2:48:35

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Thank you. Um you know, I'm all about training, and I'm glad that you're all getting the training that you need. Um do you feel like the Tyler system is, so I know that when we first implemented it it was very sour. Um is it becoming antiquated now, and and we'll have to call, or should we be looking at using something else? Is it just very challenging or? I understand your concerns.

Reproducir desde 2:48:47

Lori Peddicord

I I understand. So I would not recommend implementing a new system. It We have quite diverse flow of information. It's tied to too many things like payment processing, Fintech, etc. Um it does not work for all of the needs within the city city's per- Okay. For For example, I'll give you an example. The utility billing module. We had to implement uh a modification to our systems to allow us to build a larger uh electric utility customers. Uh Tyler's system for utility billing could not handle that modification and also had trouble with return consumption and solar solar billing. Uh so there Again, there's pieces to that system that just do not work very well. And so the system I have found breaks more often than I would care to deal with. Quite frankly, though, if if I'm really honest, what I would like to see the city do, and we've discussed this internally, is to upgrade backline HTE. Uh that system worked great. I know it's old, but it worked great for us. Uh there the reason behind, and speaking with Donna Mitchell and Lori Peddicord over the years, the reason behind the uh want to want to uh modernize our county system was to improve efficiencies. Unfortunately, in some areas, yes, it has improved, but in others it has not. Tax billing, as an example. We have over a month delay this year, almost 2 months delay, because of a tax billing issue. I don't see that that is uh the fault of anyone else. I've experienced that problem myself with the tax billing module. But that's that's an example of the system breaking and not working as we would anticipate it to. And um, you know, while we've worked through these things, doing not only through the training and building, rebuilding uh that I'm suggesting here, that's not That's not only going to help you with training, but, like you said, it's going to help you to rebuild the system and make sure that the system is built up to current standards, so you stop losing time and you increase your effi- That's the ultimate goal, is to increase efficiency. Uh, I don't know if anyone here uh recalls that the city underwent uh city management staff underwent a few years several years ago we underwent lean government training. That That's what I'd like to implement, okay? Um, and that's one of the main purposes behind this. You know, there there may be individuals that, yes, they're trained on the system, but there may be a newer or better way to complete a process where they're going through certain steps that are, just because we've always done it that way, doesn't mean that we need to continue to always do it that way. And uh, sometimes it's hard to break those habits. And that, again, that's the purpose of my request, this request.

Reproducir desde 2:49:29

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Well, thank you for the explanation. Um and I just want to also convey to you that I I think it's very important that you uh expand your knowledge, you know, on what what you discovered and what you know be transferred to someone at least one or two people in case something, you know what I'm saying, because it could shrink our knowledge, you know, sharing the knowledge, you know, increases our strength in our organization. Because you never know what may or may not happen, right? Yeah, and then also, if you get you can get burned out, you know, on taking everything yourself. You know, our senior dominion sugar and what you're talking about, It's hard to beat. But no one's really willing to go into the nuts and bolts of being exchanged. I appreciate all of what you're doing and still need aid in banking and continue to look for new innovative ways for this, so I commend you for all your hard work. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 2:52:50

Lori Peddicord

Council, it's already, they recognize the value and sharing knowledge, so it's all more to be shared, and it's accepted to share as well.

Reproducir desde 2:53:53

Fred A. Neil

Other questions, discussion? Call the question, please. Lori, how much have we invested in Tyler?

Reproducir desde 2:53:59

Lori Peddicord

Uh roughly, invested in Tyler, over a million dollars. I'm going to say closer to two off the top of my head, plus uh we have roughly um I'm hoping I'm not confusing the two, but roughly uh $800,000, I think it is an invoice for support services that I recall. Don't hold me to that.

Reproducir desde 2:54:34

Fred A. Neil

Thank you. And uh, so, it's uh lessons enjoyed, the full fruitfulness of the time that's trained in that way for uh legal purposes. We uh, now the uh system we have will will be the much more helping with if it's new level that for uh keeping recording heavy. And then, um, not because of the issue fully, but, don't get, it gives a talk back to them modernize some which I can mention, but then again, that would be tricky stuff, but on the other hand, the support and, how it, how helps to, um, catch up into the goal.

Reproducir desde 2:54:51

Lori Peddicord

Well, it's definitely going to take time to, like you have for billing now, it's going to take time to get that built, it's going to take time to get the bank reconciliations built, once you uh modules built. But once you get them built, the ultimate goal is, yeah, I can press a button and it's going to it's going to generate a report, rather than a person sitting behind a desk and manually going through thousands and thousands of lines to create a spreadsheet that then they have to create pivot tables and links to another that then have to get linked to a Word document to present on a monthly. Um so it it's not going to be a a quick fix is what I'm what I'm trying to say. It will take time to

Reproducir desde 2:56:02

Patricia Dobson

get those things put in place, again, with the ultimate goal of creating better efficiencies to get audits done quicker, to get financial reports done to be presented to the City Clerk's office and ultimately to the council quicker and more timely, more efficiently. Give you a better opportunity to make financial decisions at a rapid pace than how things normally had been.

Reproducir desde 2:56:56

Andre M. Boggerty

In this day and age, we need, even if it's possible, we need closer to real-time understanding than what happened two months ago. So approximately how long, how many hours does it take just to do bank reconciliations?

Reproducir desde 2:57:15

Patricia Dobson

Currently, our largest bank account takes about, for one individual, takes about two days to complete, a particular rec. There's another rec, another larger account, we have several smaller accounts and two larger accounts. The 4380 account takes about two days to complete when the methods and procedures have been put in place. The 4209 account takes roughly around the same amount of time. We made some changes and efficiencies with the bank recs, I want to just put that out there. There were seven months behind and we got them more than up to date.

Reproducir desde 2:57:23

Andre M. Boggerty

That's quite an accomplishment.

Reproducir desde 2:58:26

Patricia Dobson

Thank you. And there were several unreconciled items that we were able to correct. What we found in that is that there were several ACH payments that were not processed on our end that required a significant amount of research time, so I had reached out to our banking partners. We also found that we were not utilizing the service properly. So I reached out to our banking partners to create a special report for us so that we can make sure that there's nothing lingering, tracing down some of those items also. Some issues prevent some of that. We're also moving towards a full-cash method so that we don't have dual bank accounts. We can have one main bank account.

Reproducir desde 2:58:27

Roy Sudler, Jr.

I'm going to, in committee review of this action form and your discussion, I'm going to support this with hope that, in the end, our finance department gets dialed down, sir. Appreciate you.

Reproducir desde 2:59:28

Fred A. Neil

All those in favor of the motion to accept the staff recommendation?

Reproducir desde 3:00:06

Brian E. Lewis

Now, do we have to have a roll call?

Reproducir desde 3:00:09

City Clerk

No, I just had it there just in case. Yep.

Reproducir desde 3:00:10

Brian E. Lewis

Okay. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 3:00:11

Fred A. Neil

What's that? It doesn't matter to council. Can't hear anything.

Reproducir desde 3:00:12

Brian E. Lewis

I'd prefer a roll call. Roll call.

Reproducir desde 3:00:19

Fred A. Neil

Roll call.

Reproducir desde 3:00:23

City Clerk

Ms. Hall?

Reproducir desde 3:00:28

Donyale M. Hall

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:00:29

City Clerk

Ms. Arndt?

Reproducir desde 3:00:32

Tricia K. Arndt

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:00:32

City Clerk

Dr. Sudler?

Reproducir desde 3:00:57

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:00:58

City Clerk

Mr. Lewis?

Reproducir desde 3:00:59

Brian E. Lewis

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:01:00

City Clerk

Council President Neil?

Reproducir desde 3:01:01

Fred A. Neil

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:01:02

City Clerk

Mr. Chabbott?

Reproducir desde 3:01:03

David Chabbott

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:01:04

City Clerk

Mr. Garfinkel?

Reproducir desde 3:01:05

Michael Garfinkel

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:01:06

City Clerk

Mr. Anderson?

Reproducir desde 3:01:07

David L. Anderson

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:01:07

City Clerk

8 to 0.

Reproducir desde 3:01:10

Fred A. Neil

Moving to agenda item 2, migration of vendor from Flock Safety to Axon Enterprise. Council.

Reproducir desde 3:01:16

Thomas Johnson

Thank you, sir. Evening, council. For the record, Todd Case, Chief of Police. I'd also like to introduce Captain Robert Roswell, call him Randy, likes that, that's fine. I've stood before you before, and I'm just teeing this up so that Captain Roswell can take care of the presentation.

Reproducir desde 3:01:25

Thomas Johnson

This agenda item is related to a migration from one vendor to another under a budget that's already been outlined in previous council sessions. In very, very brief terms that Captain Roswell will expand on, the idea that we saw an opportunity to save a little bit of money for the same service stretched out over multiple years, and also take a nod towards take a step towards acknowledging some concerns that we've been observing over the last two years with the existing vendor that we've been working with, and seeing an opportunity to address perhaps growing public concern about a vendor and their business practices. If we can take that step, I think that's going to improve some consumer confidence in the product that we have in the service that we provide, and Captain Roswell's going to lay out all those details for you. But just again, this is mostly a presentation about money. I see a chance to save some money in the upcoming, actually FY '24 through FY '28, by virtue of the timeline that we're looking to implement. It's not a lot of money, but it's considerable enough for us to see that, and we thought it would be better for us to come to you with this earlier rather than later so that it gets best consideration by council. So I'm going to step aside, and I'm pleased to Captain Roswell. Thank you.

Reproducir desde 3:02:03

Captain Randy Roswell

Thanks, Chief. Good evening. Thanks for having me here today. Again, my name is Captain Randy Roswell. I don't think it's often that the police department comes asking to spend less money. In fact, I never guessed that any department comes here asking to spend less money. But we have good reason to do so, and hopefully I can display that to you today.

Reproducir desde 3:03:28

Captain Randy Roswell

Currently, we're budgeting $158,500 annually for Flock Safety LPR services. That's been approved in the Capital Improvement Plan. Axon, who we relate it to this project, we have Axon body-worn cameras, which I'm sure everybody's familiar with. We also have Axon fleet in-car cameras. We're an Axon police department. So they've approached us for a five-year deal totaling $697,514.99, or approximately $139,503 annually. That's going to represent a savings of just under $19,000 per year compared to what we're currently paying for Flock services. That equates to almost $95,000 for five years. Now, along with that, Axon LPR also provides agency-controlled data. That's the important part that we must stress. Agency-controlled data and retention, search permissions, enhanced administrative oversight, security, and auditable action activity reports. Therefore, in addition to the cost savings that was previously approved in CIP, the police department wants to migrate to this platform to better align aligns with the objective of this project.

Reproducir desde 3:04:05

Captain Randy Roswell

Some of the things that I can explain to you before we get to any question and answer, the difference between Flock and these Axon LPR technologies, this Axon will actually be a video camera. I think you guys are familiar with the amount of infrastructure that we have invested in our downtown camera network. This would add to that, in addition to also being able to conduct LPR data as well. Something that we're also trying to build is already within our Axon body-worn camera project, and it's already approved for a five-year deal, is Axon Fusus. And I'm not going to get too in the detail with what it actually does, but it helps us get to the period of more real-time information quicker. That's what we're using this technology for. Credit the mayor within the last year for wanting us to research technology that would help us cut down on violent crime. And this Fusus project that Axon has has actually allowed us to incorporate what we've already invested in our downtown camera system. We have, to this date, I believe we're at 150 of our downtown cameras that already already own and invested, have actually incorporated it into this project. Again, the idea is when we get a complaint, hop on that camera immediately. So we are building this system from the ground up, and doing it at no extra cost to the city. Doing it within the contracts that were already already agreed upon, and this is yet another Axon product that we can incorporate into this system that will work seamlessly with it. That's another advantage of making the switch.

Reproducir desde 3:05:21

Captain Randy Roswell

I don't want to get too long-winded, but, again, we're trying to save money. We're trying to invest in technology that's going to help keep the city safe. It's going to give officers the ability to respond and investigate and get to a good conclusion quicker for the victims of crime, for those that report crime, and certainly for families of victims. So that's what we're trying to do. We're trying to save some money. We're trying to be fiscally responsible, also continue to advance with the technology that we think we need to help keep the city safe. I'll take questions.

Reproducir desde 3:07:16

Fred A. Neil

Thank you. Dr. Sudler, and Councilman Lewis.

Reproducir desde 3:08:00

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Go ahead, Lewis.

Reproducir desde 3:08:03

Brian E. Lewis

I'm going to support this, Chief. Any time we're saving the money, it sounds great, and that I'll I'll second that motion, but I just got a comment. Chief Johnson, Captain Roswell, I want to commend you for saving the city money with this petition, but you're going to have $19,000 left. What are you going to do with the $19,000? Where is that going?

Reproducir desde 3:08:06

Captain Randy Roswell

If the city manager and the Chief can come to a conclusion...

Reproducir desde 3:08:23

Brian E. Lewis

Go back to the general fund, or for the police department? And he's smiling already, girl. I know, you know, he's looking to find some sort of a You're trying to find some sort of toy with that 19. Don't be facetious.

Reproducir desde 3:08:25

Thomas Johnson

I'll I'll jump right in, council. It's I have no pre-designated idea of what we're going to do with that savings. When you talk about the amount of technology that we're invested in, it's significantly higher than that $19,000, and the crying shame of it is, is $19,000 on its own doesn't buy a whole lot. It's almost like buying medical devices. If you're in that profession, just because it's a medical device, it's three times what it should cost. Public safety's not a whole lot different. So as far as I'm concerned, the CIP program is the CIP program, and we're just basically letting the city know that we'd like to change vendors for operational reasons, for security reasons, because we'd like the public to know that we're thinking about these things before they come to council or come to the police station to share their concerns. And so when we're talking about, and Capt. is right on top of the idea that we've been looking at technology for probably four-plus years in earnest, and we've been carefully selecting the technologies that we think are good for Dover, migrating towards this real-time center and putting all the pieces together so they function in harmony. So if we ever get another opportunity to do that, whether it's a particular technology or extension of something we already have or something new, whatever it is, we'll look at that at its own stand-alone project, and if required, send justification. So the idea of whether it's in discussions with the city's financial team on what we're going to do with the capital in any particular budget year, that's a fresh conversation. So that's a long way of saying, no, I actually don't have any immediate plans, but I understand why someone would go What's he got? What's he thinking about? Yeah. In this particular case, I'm just basically saying, every once in a while, you have to establish your credibility with city officials that when you see an opportunity to save money, you deliver the dollars back and you don't ask for anything new, you walk away. And, you know, and I'm saying that plainly. That way the next time I might be in front of you and I'm asking you to go $15,000 to $20,000 out of your comfort zone, it's not because I get to make that ask and at least be able to say once or twice, hey, I don't do this every time. Sometimes I come back to you with $10,000 or $15,000 or $20,000. So I'm laying the foundation, and I don't know whether I'm talking about next year, two years, three years, whatever it's going to be, but every once in a while, you've got to show your due diligence and you've got to show a little bit of conscientious conscientious behavior, and I think that's what we're trying to do tonight.

Reproducir desde 3:08:33

Brian E. Lewis

Once again, I appreciate you saving the city funds with respect to this, but, on another note, as you are aware, I'm a watchdog when it comes to taxpayer money, so I'm going to be watching this fund to death. All right. Thank you for that. No further questions.

Reproducir desde 3:11:20

David L. Anderson

Through the Chair? It's fine. It's fine, Brian. So question, when you go, you go into this new system, is there a the fine print there in the in the Flock contract? Is there money that we have to owe them or will owe them in terms of terminating the contract?

Reproducir desde 3:11:32

Captain Randy Roswell

No. We're year-to-year with Flock, and we just have to give them 30 days' notice before the end of the contract. Our contract with them is extended until June next, June 30th next year. So we will be done, and this will start July 1st. They'll come pick up their equipment, yep. We just have to give them 30 days' notice in the contract. I just read it a few days ago.

Reproducir desde 3:12:11

David L. Anderson

Now, again, going to a new system, are you going to need a new thingamajig or flimflam in the back for an in the end, it's $19,000? Yeah. This is all-in cost.

Reproducir desde 3:12:24

Captain Randy Roswell

This is this is all-in cost.

Reproducir desde 3:12:32

David L. Anderson

So so it integrates well?

Reproducir desde 3:12:34

Captain Randy Roswell

Yes. Yes, I can I can expand on that if you need me to, but we're we're like our body cameras are Axon, we use evidence.com, which I know many of you are familiar with, but that's where all of our images and stuff go to, and it helps us send things to the AG's office, the attorneys that need to get access to this. It's it's all done on these platform, this Axon platform. And it all works seamlessly. As I was talking about Axon Fusus, really excited about it, I think it's going to really do wonders for this city and for the officers. It's going to revolutionize how we investigate crime. It's going to allow us to use technology and make it actionable, quick, so that we can get those good good outcomes for people. It just it just fits in with with the product. It seems, cuz it is Axon. So it makes sense.

Reproducir desde 3:12:35

David L. Anderson

Thank you.

Reproducir desde 3:13:30

Fred A. Neil

Yeah. One more question. Is someone online with a question?

Reproducir desde 3:13:33

City Clerk

Miss Cornish here, the Executive Director of Faith, just requested.

Reproducir desde 3:14:01

Fred A. Neil

Very good. And then okay. Let's go back and talk with someone. Is she here? Ready for that? All right. So I'm going to go to Dr. Sudler while they're figuring that out.

Reproducir desde 3:14:06

Roy Sudler, Jr.

I just want to say I want to thank the mayor and appreciate that, and I mean the technology through Peter Strong, want to thank them.

Reproducir desde 3:14:17

Fred A. Neil

All right. Um, give another 30 seconds and not, we'll go to the vote. If she's not here for that, we'll follow up. All right. Um, we call the roll.

Reproducir desde 3:14:29

City Clerk

Sure. Ms. Hall?

Reproducir desde 3:15:06

Donyale M. Hall

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:15:08

City Clerk

Ms. Arndt?

Reproducir desde 3:15:10

Tricia K. Arndt

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:15:11

City Clerk

Dr. Sudler?

Reproducir desde 3:15:12

Roy Sudler, Jr.

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:15:12

City Clerk

Mr. Lewis?

Reproducir desde 3:15:13

Brian E. Lewis

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:15:14

City Clerk

Council President Neil?

Reproducir desde 3:15:15

Fred A. Neil

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:15:15

City Clerk

Mr. Chabbott?

Reproducir desde 3:15:16

David Chabbott

Abstain.

Reproducir desde 3:15:17

City Clerk

Mr. Garfinkel?

Reproducir desde 3:15:18

Michael Garfinkel

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:15:18

City Clerk

Mr. Anderson?

Reproducir desde 3:15:19

David L. Anderson

Yes.

Reproducir desde 3:15:20

City Clerk

Seven yes, one abstention.

Reproducir desde 3:15:25

Fred A. Neil

You guys have done such a great job, take tomorrow off. Is there any other business before the council? Seeing none, this council Committee of the Whole is adjourned.

Reproducir desde 3:16:02
¿Hay algo incorrecto? Informe sobre esta transcripción

No tiene que dar un correo electrónico. Déjelo en blanco si no necesita respuesta. Solo lo usamos para contestar este reporte.