Este texto se extrajo de el PDF de forma automática y puede contener errores. El PDF es el registro oficial, así que consúltelo antes de confiar en esto.
Página 1
CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Monday, June 24, 2024 at 6:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware
AGENDA VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE
This meeting will be held in the City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:
Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://rb.gy/rfsihh
Event number: 2539 402 4349
Event password: DOVER (if needed)
If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.
The meeting can also be viewed on Comcast Channel 14, Verizon Channel 20, and on the City's Streaming Player located at www.cityofdover.com under "Quick Links".
OPEN FORUM - 15 Minutes Prior to Official Meeting (6:15 p.m.)
The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share their questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing on the agenda as a public hearing is prohibited during the Open Forum as an opportunity will be provided during consideration of that item. Citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is prohibited from taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule such items as regular agenda items and act upon them in the future.
INVOCATION - Elder Ellis B. Louden
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Councilman Neil
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Página 2
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - June 24, 2024 PAGE 2
PUBLIC HEARING
- 1.Electric Fund Budget
CONSENT AGENDA
ADOPTION OF MINUTES
- 2.Regular City Council Meeting of June 10, 2024
COMMITTEE REPORTS
- 3.Board of Assessment Appeals - June 4, 2024
- 4.Council Committee of the Whole Report June 11, 2024
Mayor and Council Reports - May 2024
- 5.First District
- 6.Second District
- 7.Third District
- 8.Fourth District
- 9.At-Large
- 10.Mayor Christiansen
- 11.Council President Anderson
Utility Committee
- 12.Evaluation of Bids - FY24 Inflow & Infiltration Rehabilitation Project (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director)
(Committee Recommendation: Award the contract to Insituform Technologies, LLC, for the City of Dover FY24 Inflow & Infiltration Rehabilitation Project, Bid #24- 0031WW, for the amount of $1,279,530.00)
Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
- 13.Evaluation of Bids - Relay Panels for Garrison Oak Technology & Business Park (GOTBP) (Paul Waddell, Electric Director)
(Committee Recommendation: Award the contract to Electrical Power Products, Bid #24-0028EL, for the amount of $251,201.00)
Página 3
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - June 24, 2024 PAGE 3
- 14.Discussion - Fiscal Year 2024 Audit Program (Patricia Marney, Interim Controller/Treasurer)
(Committee Recommendation: Acceptance of the Audit Program)
- 15.Proposed Ordinance #2024- 22 - Amending Chapter 26 - Businesses, Article II - Licenses, and Appendix F - Fees and Fines (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager)
(Committee Recommendation: Approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-22)
- 16.Proposed Ordinance #2024- 23 - Amending Chapter 106 - Traffic and Vehicles, Article I - In General, Sec. 106-14. - Off-road Motor Vehicle Regulations (Council President Anderson)
(Committee Recommendation: Approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-23)
- 17.Proposed Ordinance #2024- 24 - Amending Chapter 26 - Businesses, Article II - Licenses, Sec. 26-31. - Definitions, and Appendix F - Fees and Fines, Chapter 26 (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager and Ann Marie Townshend, Senior Project Manager at the Rossi Group)
(Committee Recommendation: Defer approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-24 to a future Special Legislative, Finance and Administration Meeting)
- 18.Proposed Ordinance #2024- 25 - Amending Appendix B - Zoning, Article 3 - District Regulations, Sec. 16 - Highway Commercial Zone (C-4), Sec. 19 - Manufacturing Zone (M), Sec. 20 - Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), Sec. 23 - Agricultural Zone (A), Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations, and Article 12 - Definitions (David
- S.Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ann Marie Townshend, Senior Project Manager at the Rossi Group)
(Committee Recommendation: Defer approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-25 to a future Special Legislative, Finance and Administration Meeting)
ITEMS NOT ON THE CONSENT AGENDA
- 19.Setting of Electric, Water, and Wastewater Rates and Tariffs
(Staff Recommendation: Adoption of Rates and Tariffs as presented for Fiscal Year 2025)
- 20.Removing Properties from the 10-Year Tax Abatement Program (Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director)
(Staff Recommendation: Approve removal of the presented properties from the tax abatement program.)
- 21.General Pension Check Disbursement Options (Patricia Marney, Interim Controller/Treasurer)
(Staff Recommendation: Approval of disbursement of funds approved through the FY2025 Budget Hearings. )
Página 4
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - June 24, 2024 PAGE 4
ORDINANCES
FIRST READING - The First Reading is offered on the Proposed Ordinance. Final action by Council will take place during the Second Reading on JULY 08, 2024. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us.
- 22.Proposed Ordinance #2024- 22 - Amending Chapter 26 - Businesses, Article II - Licenses, and Appendix F - Fees and Fines (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager)
(Staff Recommendation: Approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-22)
- 23.Proposed Ordinance #2024- 23 - Amending Chapter 106 - Traffic and Vehicles, Article I - In General, Sec. 106-14. - Off-road Motor Vehicle Regulations (Council President Anderson)
(Staff Recommendation: Approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-23)
FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of JUNE 10, 2024. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government."
- 24.Proposed Ordinance #2024-14 - Amending Chapter 1 - General Provisions, Sec. 1-17. - General penalty; separate offenses; unpaid fines (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer)
- 25.Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 - Amending Chapter 22 - Buildings and Building Regulations (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer)
- 26.Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 - Amending Chapter 46 - Fire prevention and protection (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer)
- 27.Proposed Ordinance #2024-17 - Amending Chapter 90 - Solid Waste, Sec. 90-16. - Violations; penalties (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer)
- 28.Proposed Ordinance #2024-18 - Amending Chapter 114 - Vegetation, Article II - Weeds, Sec. 114-34. - Fines (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer)
- 29.Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 - Amending Appendix F - Fees and fines (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer)
- 30.Proposed Ordinance #2024-20 - Amending Chapter 110 - Utilities, Article V - Stormwater (Mark Nowak, Public Works Director)
- 31.Proposed Ordinance #2024-21 - Amending Chapter 98 - Streets, Sidewalks, Storm Sewers, and Other Public Places, Article IX - Street Sweeping, and Article X - Leaf Collection Services (Mark Nowak, Public Works Director)
- 32.Proposed Ordinance #2024- 26 - Fiscal Year 2024/2025 City of Dover Budget Ordinance (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager)
Página 5
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - June 24, 2024 PAGE 5
CITY MANAGER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
MAYOR'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ANNOUNCEMENTS
ADJOURNMENT
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING
Página 6
Page 1 ofItem
2 #1.
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
The City of Dover Council will hold a public hearing on Monday, June 24, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers of Dover City Hall to consider adoption of the following proposed Electric Fund budgets for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2024, to June 30, 2025. The following budgets have been submitted to the Mayor and Council for their review and consideration and the amounts are subject to change. ELECTRIC REVENUE FUND
| BEGINNING BALANCE | $46,148,500 |
| DISTRIBUTION OF EARNINGS - PCA CREDIT | - |
| BEGINNING BALANCE – ADJUSTED | $46,148,500 |
BASE REVENUE:
| DIRECT SALES TO CUSTOMER | $91,131,200 |
| UTILITY TAX | 1,356,100 |
| MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE | 608,000 |
| RENT REVENUE | 136,000 |
| GREEN ENERGY | 135,000 |
| INTEREST EARNINGS | 1,500,000 |
| INTRAFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS W/WW | 75,000 |
| TOTAL REVENUES | $94,941,300 |
TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCE & REVENUES $141,089,800
EXPENSES:
| POWER SUPPLY | $24,945,600 |
| DOVER SUN PARK ENERGY | 3,700,800 |
| SOLAR RENEWAL ENERGY CREDITS | 381,900 |
| POWER SUPPLY MANAGEMENT | 701,800 |
| REC'S (Renewable Energy Credits) | 6,429,200 |
| RGGI | 70,500 |
| PJM CHARGES - ENERGY | 11,932,000 |
| PJM CHARGES - TRANSMISSION & FEES | 13,645,200 |
| CAPACITY CHARGES | 23,451,800 |
| SUB-TOTAL POWER SUPPLY | 85,258,800 |
| PLANT OPERATIONS | 2,296,800 |
| GENERATIONS FUELS | 191,300 |
| PJM SPOT MARKET ENERGY | (147,000) |
| PJM CREDITS | (262,800) |
| CAPACITY CREDITS | (10,404,300) |
| GENERATION SUBTOTAL | (8,326,000) |
POWER SUPPLY & GENERATION SUBTOTAL 76,932,800
DIRECT EXPENDITURES
| TRANSMISSION/DISTRIBUTION | $5,205,100 |
| ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING | 1,937,000 |
| ADMINISTRATION | 1,129,100 |
| METER READING | 529,800 |
| SYSTEMS OPERATIONS | 1,067,500 |
| DIRECT EXPENDITURE SUBTOTALS | 9,868,500 |
OTHER EXPENSES:
| UTILITY TAX | $1,356,100 |
| ALLOW FOR UNCOLLECTIBLES | 300,000 |
| CONTRACTUAL SERVICES - RFP'S | 50,000 |
| LEGAL EXPENSES | 50,000 |
| OTHER EMPLOYMENT EXPENSES | 954,000 |
| GREEN ENERGY PAYMENT TO DEMEC | 135,000 |
| INTERFUND SERVICE FEES | 4,371,600 |
| INTEREST ON DEPOSITS | 20,000 |
| BANK & CREDIT CARD FEES | 619,300 |
| DEBT SERVICE | 1,441,900 |
| STORM EXPENSE | 150,000 |
| OTHER EXPENSES SUBTOTAL | 9,447,900 |
TRANSFER TO:
| GENERAL FUND | 10,000,000 |
| RATE STABILIZATION RESERVE | 30,000 |
| TRANSFER TO INVENTORY WRITE-OFFS | 100,000 |
| TRANSFER TO SUBTOTAL | 10,130,000 |
TOTAL EXPENSES 106,379,200
BUDGET BALANCE - WORKING CAPITAL 34,710,600
TOTAL BUDGET BALANCE & EXPENSES $141,089,800
Página 7
Page 2 ofItem
2 #1.
IMPROVEMENT & EXTENSION FUND RECOMMENDED BEGINNING BALANCE $33,165,000
REVENUES
| GENERAL SERVICE BILLING | 1,000,000 |
| TRF FROM FUTURE CAPACITY | 2,000,000 |
| TOTAL REVENUES | 3,000,000 |
TOTALS $36,165,000
EXPENSES
| ELECTRIC GENERATION | 470,000 |
| TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION | 3,090,000 |
| ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING | 3,986,000 |
| TOTAL EXPENSES | 7,546,000 |
BUDGET BALANCE $28,619,000
TOTAL BUDGET BALANCE & EXPENSES $36,165,000
Página 8
Item #2.
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular City Council Meeting was held on June 10, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Council members present were Mr. Hare, Mr. Neil (in at 6:53 via Webex), Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Arndt, Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rocha, and Mr. Lewis. Mr. Boggerty was absent.
Staff members present were Police Chief Johnson, Ms. Marney, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Melson- Williams, Chief Carey, Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Mayor Christiansen was also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 6:15 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Council President Hare declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.
Ms. Lachelle Paul, who resides at 501 Silverside Drive, Wilmington, and Ms. Lauren Eisenbraun, City of Dover Code Enforcement Officer, stated that Mr. Rodriguez had been individually named in a complaint. Ms. Paul noted that any future communication from him regarding that matter would be considered unwelcome and should be directed to the Ethics Commission. Ms. Paul informed Council President Anderson that he owed her an apology. There was an email sent to her with unfounded facts and that the next time he comes to her, he should have the proper facts. She stated that moving forward, he should not threaten her or treat her differently than he treats anyone else in public. Furthermore, regarding the complaint about ethical behavior, she emphasized the need for the city council to ensure they understand and operate within the established codes. This is to prevent citizens from feeling mistreated or unjustly treated in any way. She noted that any future complaints brought to the committee should be handled properly according to the Municipal Code.
INVOCATION
The invocation was given by Elder Ellis B. Louden.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Mayor Christiansen.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Mr. Rocha moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt, and unanimously carried. (Neil and Boggerty absent)
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Mr. Rocha moved for adoption of the consent agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Página 9
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 2
PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2024-09 – APPROVAL OF THE 2024 COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG) ACTION PLAN
The City Clerk read the following Resolution into the record:
A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE 2024 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT ACTION PLAN
WHEREAS, the City of Dover is entitled to $309,594 through the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development Community Development Block Grant program; and
WHEREAS, the City of Dover has prepared the 2024 Action Plan, in accordance with the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development guidelines, that serves as the primary planning document for identifying and meeting the housing and community development needs for the low and moderate-income residents of Dover; and
WHEREAS, the City of Dover is in favor of utilizing the Community Development Block Grant funds for the community development purposes in accordance with the National Community Development objectives of benefiting low and moderate income families, eliminating slums and blight, and meeting other community development objectives; and
WHEREAS, the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development requires the City of Dover to submit a Consolidated Plan and an Action Plan for Application for Federal Assistance including the proposed use of funds and including certain certifications and policies to obtain its $309,594 entitlement; for eligible activities; and
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Council of the City of Dover approve the 2024 Community Development Block Grant Action Plan and application for Federal Assistance included in the Action Plan, along with certifications and policies attached and authorize its forwarding to the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for consideration.
ADOPTED: JUNE 10, 2024
Ms. Arndt moved for approval of Resolution No. 2024-09. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried. (Neil and Boggerty absent)
PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2024-10 – HONORING THE 95TH BIRTHDAY OF
REUBEN SALTERS
The City Clerk read the following Resolution into the record:
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
WHEREAS, per Ruben Salters, a man of humble beginnings, was born on May 28th, 1929, in South Carolina and pursued his education in North Carolina. His path led him to the United States Air Force, where in 1954, he encountered a woman who would change his life. Jo Anna McCray, at a local USO. Their love story, marked by a dance and a lifelong companionship,
Página 10
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 3
culminated in their marriage on June 10th, 1955, and the birth of their three children: Michael, Katrina, and Beverly; and
WHEREAS, after breaking commission and being stationed at Gunter Air Force Base in Montgomery, Alabama, he attended Dexter Avenue Baptist Church, where he heard the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr, preach. At the time, he was unaware that Dr. King would become such a powerful and wonderful man.
WHEREAS, after retiring from military service in 1971, he settled into civilian life in Dover, Delaware with his wife Jo Anna and three children following his arrival at the Dover Air Force Base in 1957; and
WHEREAS, before his tenure on the Dover City Council. Mr. Salters, in a remarkable display of community spirit, joined forces with the late Dr. Luna I. Mishoe. Their shared vision led to the initiation of the annual Martin Luther King Jr. Day program in 1987, a tradition that continues to unite and inspire the community, serving as a testament to their enduring legacy; and
WHEREAS, Ruben Salters is a prominent figure in Dover, Delaware, known for his extensive contributions to the community. Salters successfully ran for Dover City Council in 1989, representing the city’s 4th District, and served over 20 years on Dover City Council before retiring in 2011; and
WHEREAS, in addition to his political career, Salters dedicated himself to community development. He founded the Inner City Cultural League, a nonprofit organization that has become a beacon of cultural and educational opportunities for youth and adults in Dover. This organization with its diverse programs in dance, music, and theatre stands as a testament to its commitment to enriching the community. His instrumental role in organizing the city’s African American Festival further underscores his dedication to celebrating and promoting cultural diversity.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Council wish retired Dover City Councilman Ruben Salters a happy 95th birthday and recognize that he has played a pivotal role in numerous initiatives aimed at enhancing the local community. His work has earned him widespread respect and recognition within the community, making him a central figure in the ongoing efforts to enrich and support Dover’s cultural and civic life.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Mayor and Council direct the City Clerk to make this resolution a part of the permanent records of the City of Dover as a lasting symbol of appreciation and gratitude to Ruben J. Salters.
ADOPTED: JUNE 10, 2024
Mr. Hare moved for approval of Resolution No. 2024-10. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried. (Boggerty absent)
Página 11
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 4
PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2023-18 – CENSURE OF COUNCILMAN WILLIAM F.
HARE
Mr. Rocha took the chair at 6:55 p.m.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson stated that he chose to step down because he made a public statement on the matter. He mentioned that, although not required, doing so would appear fairer to both the person who brought the complaint forward and the person who responded to it.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Dr. Sudler stated that it sounded almost like a half-recusal. He suggested that to avoid any perception of bias, given the public comment made, Mr. Anderson should recuse himself from the chambers. Dr. Sudler noted that this was in line with what he was taught in ethics training.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson stated that there was no conflict of interest nor were there any violations of any rules. He noted that everything was legitimate and there would be no recusal and no abstentions. Mr. Anderson believed that it would be better for the chair to have done this and it is a call he has a right to make.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Dr. Sudler stated that the matter at hand is commonly referred to as the appearance of impropriety. Dr. Sudler expressed his discomfort in making a judgment call, noting that he was not involved in the hearing and therefore did not know the circumstances. He did not see how they could assess whether the resolution should stand or be omitted. Dr. Sudler questioned how council could vote on the recommendation without any merit, foundation, or evidence to make a judgment. Dr. Sudler stated that he did not feel comfortable undermining the Ethics Commission.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rodriguez stated that the Ethics Commission had requested that the complaint be referred to Council. The commission had already heard the matter, made a decision, and determined that it should be referred to council.
Mr. Rocha read into the record Section 30-73(l), which states that the commission shall send a written copy of its findings and recommendations to the respondent and the complainant. He noted that the section does not mention anything about Council. He believed that the recommendation to Council came from the Ethics Commission, and that is the basis of their deliberation.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Dr. Sudler stated that it is his understanding that the Ethics Commission makes a recommendation, and the recommendation was in the form of a resolution of censorship. He believed that the referral versus the recommendation for censorship and the resolution creates a certain distortion and lack of clarity, as they are referring it to Council, but not to Council to make a decision. The matter was referenced in a resolution indicating that a decision has been made and the resolution is being presented for adoption by the council, similar to other resolutions they have received. Dr. Sudler explained that without a hearing where all council members have access to the information, it is unrealistic to expect them to make a judgment call. He expressed his belief that the resolution lacked clarity for them to make a decision, especially since they were not part of the process.
Página 12
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 5
Dr. Pillsbury stated that they need to revisit the entire section because she agrees that the Ethics Commission makes the decision, not Council. She further stated that she had discussed this with a member of the Ethics Committee, and they were under the impression that all decisions came from City Council. She believed that there could be privacy issues with them publicly discussing the matter and that they were not there to hear the whole process. Dr. Pillsbury believed that what triggered the situation was the complainant was not notified of the results of the committee and that it was their responsibility to notify according to the ordinance, not City Council’s responsibility. She noted that there seems to be confusion about the responsibilities of each party involved and suggested establishing a panel consisting of members of the commission and someone from the City Council to clarify these roles.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Arndt cited Section 30-73(k), which states that if the respondent is a city official, the commission may propose actions to the city council that are appropriate to the finding as specified in Section 30-73(o). She interpreted this as the commission proposing an action to the Council, which the Council would then vote on.
Responding to Mr. Rodriguez, Mr. Lewis stated that he concurs with Dr. Sudler and his concerns. The members of the Ethics Commission are appointed by the mayor, and they are confirmed by Council. He explained that they entrust those that they confirm to the commission to make the appropriate decisions that come before them. Mr. Lewis stated that the statute is very ambiguous.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Rodriguez stated that the Ethics Commission issued an order dated October 3, 2023. The conclusion states that the censure of the respondent is directed to be served upon Council of the City of Dover for the respondent’s actions and conduct with a city employee. He noted that he pursued a complaint issued by an employee on behalf of a constituent in violation of ethical conduct cited in Section 30-20 (a)(2), (3), (4), (b), and the part of the action that the Ethics Commission could take.
Dr. Sudler made a motion to suspend the rules for public comment since the complainant is here and the complainant has something to say. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis.
Mr. Rocha stated that based on his conversation with Mr. Rodriguez, the purpose was to take action on the resolution as written. He clarified that they should not take any additional action or testimony regarding the matter but should only adopt the resolution into the record.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Dr. Sudler stated that he would rescind his motion to the public if the second is willing to rescind and move to make a motion to accept the Ethics Commission’s recommendation as presented.
Mr. Lewis rescinded, as well.
Ms. Andria Bennett, City Clerk, read Councilman Neil’s statement into the record. (Exhibit #1)
Dr. Sudler stated that could not undermine the Ethics Commission if they made a resolution. He noted that competent individuals serve on the Ethics Commission and are familiar with the details. He emphasized that the process must be able to withstand public scrutiny and expressed
Página 13
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 6
his belief that it would not.
Ms. Arndt stated that, as she understood the process, the commission had their hearing and presented their findings to the Council in the resolution. She noted that, based on a straightforward reading, the Ethics Commission unanimously determined that contact was made with the city employee regarding her duties and functions, which is the only violation stated in the resolution. Ms. Arndt also mentioned that Chapter 30 Standards of Ethical Conduct refers not only to a violation but also to the appearance of a violation. For these reasons, if put to a vote, she would regretfully vote in favor of the resolution.
Mr. Anderson believed that the aforementioned video was part of the Ethics Commission's record. He asked if the video could be played so that everyone could have the same information
Mr. Lewis called for a point of order, explaining that his reasoning was based on Mr. Rodriguez's indication that the vote was on the resolution and not on the introduction of any evidence at that time
Dr. Sudler stated that reopening the dialogue would be unfair, as it would present evidence from only one side, furthering the perception of bias in the process.
Mr. Rocha stated that they are voting on the acceptance of the resolution not issuing any punishment, as they are not making any judgments. It is simply a matter of addressing what was presented before them.
Mr. Hare stated that if he had stopped at an employee/neighbor’s house to advise them that an issue had been resolved and in doing so violated any city code, he apologized to the family. He added that if the code was indeed violated, he would accept whatever action the council deemed fit.
Dr. Sudler moved for the adoption of Resolution No. 2024-18. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a roll call vote, five (5) yes (Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Lewis), two (2) no (Neil, Anderson), one (1) abstain (Hare), one (1) absent (Boggerty). Council adopted Resolution #2024-18, as follows:
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
WHEREAS, on October 3, 2023, the Commission received a complaint filed by Cameron Eisenbraun alleging ethical violations by Council President William Hare; and
WHEREAS, once the Commission had reviewed the complaint, it was decided that in order to further evaluate the complaint the Complainant and the Respondent would be asked to appear at a hearing before the Commission in order to make a determination whether an ethical violation had occurred, all in accordance with Sec. 30-73(f), which hearing was duly held with both the Complainant and the Respondent giving testimony and responding to questions; and
WHEREAS, the Commission noted that since the Respondent is a City Official, the
Página 14
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 7
Commission may propose actions to the City Council that are appropriate to its findings in accordance with Sec. 30-73(o); and
WHEREAS, after the hearing was closed, Members of the Commission voted unanimously that Respondent had made contact with a City Employee regarding her duties and functions, which should not have been made so that his conduct was in violation of the ethical standards provided in Secs. 30-20(a)(2), (3), (4), and (b); and
WHEREAS, in accordance with the provisions of Sec. 30-73(o), the Commission unanimously decided that a censure of Respondent’s conduct should be reported to City Council of the City of Dover.
NOW, THEREFORE, this censure of Respondent is directed to be served upon Council of the City of Dover for Respondent’s actions and conduct with a City Employee, although he was pursuing a complaint issued by this employee on behalf of a constituent in violation of ethical conduct cited in Secs. 30-20(a)(2), (3), (4), and (b).
ADOPTED: JUNE 10, 2024
Mr. Rocha stepped down from the chair at 7:30 p.m.
PUBLIC HEARING - ELECTRIC REVENUE FUND BUDGET
A public hearing on the Electric Revenue Fund Budget is required for compliance with the City of Dover Electric Revenue Bonds Resolutions prior to the adoption of the budget. Staff recommended that the public hearing be set for June 24, 2024, at 6:30 p.m.
Mr. Hare moved to set a public hearing for June 24, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. for the 2024/2025 City of Dover Electric Revenue Fund Budget, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-11 – LANDS OF CHIANG & SONS PROPERTIES, LLC AT 1241 COLLEGE PARK DRIVE A public hearing was duly advertised for this time and place to consider the rezoning of the property located at 1241 College Park Drive, consisting of 1.1024 +/- acres, owned by Chiang & Sons Properties, LLC. The property is currently zoned C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone), and the proposed zoning is IO (Institutional and Office Zone). The property is located on the east side of College Park Drive (a private street) and north of State College Road . (Tax Parcel: ED-05-067.00-02-12.08-000; Planning Reference: Z-24-05; Council District 4).
Dr. Sudler moved that the Final Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2024-11 be acknowledged by title only, seconded by Ms. Arndt, and unanimously carried. (Boggerty absent). (The First Reading of the proposed ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of April 22, 2024.)
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the packet shows the zoning for the surrounding area, including the subject parcel. Adjacent to it are properties zoned CPO to the north, while properties zoned M for manufacturing are to the west across College Park Drive.
Página 15
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 8
The land across College Park Drive is the location of North Dover Elementary School. She also noted that the green shading shown on the map is part of the corridor overlay zone and does not fall in the zoning classification.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the distance of the property to the property line of the North Dover Elementary School is around 60 feet. The distance to the actual buildings on the elementary school property would be much greater than that.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that on page three (3) of the report, it has the code excerpt from Article Three (3), Section 10, which describes the permitted uses in the IO zone. She explained that there are conditional and accessory uses, as well as several uses that are prohibited in the IO zone. The conditional uses require a specialized review process and approval from the Planning Commission.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the uses that are specifically prohibited in the IO zone are landfills and dumps.
Council President Anderson declared the Public Hearing open at 7:42 p.m.
Mr. Nick Patel, Avi Consulting Group, 1671 South Street, stated that the building is up for lease, has been on the market for almost a year, and has taken a year and a half to renovate. Mr. Patel explained that they have not gotten any office use requests; the majority of the requests are for public places of assembly, community centers, and daycares. However, these cannot be considered under the current zoning. He suggested that this would be an opportunity to open up more uses within what is allowed in that specific area.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Patel stated that the building is up for sale. Mr. Patel explained that with the additional uses allowed under the IO zoning (Institutional and Office Zone), especially nursing homes and other facilities, they can advertise or market for a much broader range of uses.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Patel stated that any applications for whatever use would have to go through the city for approval. He described the building as two stories, with 6,000 square feet on each floor, totaling 12,000 square feet, and completely renovated from top to bottom with sprinkler systems. They are hopeful of securing a good long-term tenant for the City of Dover. Mr. Patel noted that the building has been sitting vacant for years
Council President Anderson declared the Public Hearing closed at 7:46 p.m.
Ms. Arndt moved for approval of Ordinance #2024-11, as recommended by the Planning Commission. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and by a unanimous roll call vote (Boggerty absent), Council adopted Ordinance #2024-11, as follows:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1241 COLLEGE PARK DRIVE
Página 16
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 9
WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property within the limits of the City of Dover; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use of property described below from C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) to IO (Institutional and Office Zone).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL, MET:
- 1.That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and Zoning Ordinance of the City of Dover has been amended by changing the zoning designation from C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) to IO (Institutional and Office Zone) on that property located at 1241 College Park Drive (on the east side of College Park Drive (a private street) and north of State College Road, consisting of 1.1024 acres, owned by Chiang & Sons Properties, LLC.
(Tax Parcel: ED-05-067.00-02-12.08-000; Planning Reference: Z-24-01; Council District 4)
ADOPTED: JUNE 10, 2024
ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF MAY 13, 2024 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of May 13, 2024, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Lewis, seconded by Dr. Sudler, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen. (Neil and Boggerty absent)
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT – May 14, 2024 The Council Committee of the Whole met on May 14, 2024, at 6:10 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Dr. Sudler. Ms. Arndt was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also absent. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Iriowen, and Mr. Pugh (Utility), Mr. Shevock (via WebEx), and Ms. Smith (Legislative, Finance, and Administration).
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Dr. Sudler moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
Página 17
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 10
Proposed Ordinance #2024-20 – Amending Chapter 110 – Utilities, Article V – Stormwater (Mark Nowak, Public Works Director) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the background for Ordinance #2024-20, Ordinance #2024-21, and the Stormwater Utility Credits, Grants, and Appeals Manual.
Staff recommended approval of proposed Ordinance #2024-20.
Dr. Sudler moved to recommend approval of Ordinance #2024-20. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Hugg stated that the Stormwater Utility qualifies as an Enterprise Fund because the city provides a service, expecting consumers to pay a fee for said service, thereby meeting the criteria for an Enterprise Fund.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg explained that the current stormwater program is included in the general fund budget and is funded by taxes. He highlighted that implementing a tax increase for Tier One, primarily residential areas, to adequately fund the stormwater program would result in an increase of approximately $245 per year for taxpayers, compared to $72 per year under the proposed program. When enacting the tax increase on commercial operations, the taxes would exceed $1,000, as opposed to $698 under the suggested plan. Mr. Hugg clarified that opting for the proposed program would entail lower costs for consumers compared to funding through taxes.
Ms. Anne Smith, 132 Oakmont Drive, Dover, questioned if the program would help protect residents from plastic pollution.
Responding to Ms. Smith, Mr. Nowak stated that the proposed fund would help with anything carried through the stormwater system. Mr. Nowak explained that the water that falls from the sky goes into the system coming out cleaner than it went in. Mr. Nowak explained that the fund enables them to enhance their efforts in maintaining the cleanliness of ditches and storm catch basins, conducting street sweeping, and preserving the condition of the pipes.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-21 – Amending Chapter 98 – Streets, Sidewalks, Storm Sewers, and Other Public Places, Article IX – Street Sweeping, and Article X – Leaf Collection Services (Mark Nowak, Public Works Director) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the background for Ordinance #2024-20, and Ordinance #2024-21.
Staff recommended approval of proposed Ordinance #2024-21.
Página 18
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 11
Mr. Hare moved to accept the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Nowak stated that in regard to street sweeping, they are back up and running at full capacity, however, they only have two street sweepers.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Nowak stated that they are required to meet or exceed the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permits, which require the city to be swept four times a year. Mr. Nowak stated that they are currently sweeping every day and night.
Stormwater Utility Credits, Grants, and Appeals Manual – Updated May 2024 (Mark Nowak, Public Works Director) Mr. Mark Nowak, Public Works Director, reviewed the background regarding the Stormwater Utility Credits, Grants, and Appeals Manual.
Staff recommended approving as recommended.
Mr. Hare moved to accept the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Responding to Mr. Pugh, Mr. Nowak stated that the way that it is currently written, an appeal would need to be submitted to the City Clerk’s office and then it would be scheduled to appear on the next available Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee agenda.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Nowak stated that the appeals procedure states that the appeal would be placed on the next Council Committee of the Whole meeting.
Mr. Anderson suggested adding a 30-day timeframe to the appeals process. Mr. Anderson stated that there could be instances where an agenda is very full and adding the appeal may not be compatible with that meeting.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Nowak stated that the Public Works Director has 30 days to reach their decision and it states that the appeal would be added to
Página 19
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 12
the next available meeting. If the agenda is full, it could be added to the following meeting.
Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting,
hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:30 p.m.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Anderson presiding.
Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and
unanimously carried.
Discussion – Celebrating 250 Years of America’s Independence (Councilman Anderson) Mr. Anderson stated that the topic of July 4, 2026, was first discussed a few years prior, is getting closer, and is a great opportunity for the city.
Committee action not required.
Ms. Margaret Hughes, 250th Coordinator for the State of Delaware, 121 Martin Luther King Blvd, Dover, stated that she is based out of the Delaware Public Archives building and appreciated the opportunity to talk about the upcoming anniversary. Ms. Hughes explained that since being brought on, the conversation has focused on the efforts to raise awareness and build momentum for Delaware's upcoming anniversary, marking both the signing of the Declaration of Independence and the state's statehood, highlighted annually by Separation Day. Delaware 250, the official initiative, operates under the Delaware Heritage Commission, with a steering committee representing various sectors across the state. The goal is to coordinate efforts, ensuring that all sectors are aware of and engaged in the upcoming anniversary. The initiative aims to avoid last-minute planning by coordinating statewide conversations, developing a website as a central hub for planning efforts, and implementing strategic marketing campaigns to amplify voices and avoid duplicating efforts. Ms. Hughes also explained that Delaware 250 is helping support fundraising by getting grant programs into museums and nonprofits. The first cycle is coming to a close and the awardees should be announced soon.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Hughes stated that there are 30 committee members, and several are Dover representatives, however, she is unsure exactly how many are there on behalf of Dover.
Ms. Andrea Maucher, President of the 4th of July Celebration Committee, and Carolyn Courtney, a member of the 4th of July Celebration Committee, thanked council for the opportunity to meet Ms. Hughes and connect with her. Ms.
Página 20
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 13
Maucher explained that the 4th of July Committee is very small, and they invited additional participation from both council and the general public. Ms. Maucher emphasized that funding has been the biggest hurdle for the committee and expressed her interest in learning about the available grants. She also explained that they have learned that with the expansion of Legislative Hall and the parking garage area, they may not have a location to set off fireworks. She explained that they have started to explore the possibility of setting them off at Schutte Park because that area is available, but the topic has not been a primary focus yet. Ms. Maucher continued to explain that the 4th of July events are primarily funded through donations from businesses and organizations such as the City of Dover, and the Parks and Recreation Department. Ms. Maucher recognized the American Legion, the Walter Fox Pavilion, which organizes the parade, and the Dover Downtown Rotary Club, which organizes all the vendors as their annual fundraiser.
Mr. Anderson expressed appreciation for the 4th of July Committee and their hard work.
Mr. Rocha suggested that he may be able to connect Ms. Maucher with the Dover Lions Club to assist her in gathering volunteers.
Pete Bradley, President of Kent County Tourism, 435 N Dupont Highway, Dover, explained that Ms. Hughes made a great presentation to the Kent County Tourism Board and that they are committed to collaborating with her and supporting the Delaware 250 celebration. He stated that Ms. Hughes mentioned Dover Days, which Kent County Tourism is heavily involved with, and they believe it is the perfect opportunity to incorporate the 250th anniversary. Mr. Bradley explained that they are open to any thoughts and ideas and will work with Ms. Hughes's team to promote the event.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-14 – Amending Chapter 1 – General Provisions, Sec. 1-17. – General penalty; separate offenses; unpaid fines (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed the background regarding the proposed ordinance #2024-14 changes.
Staff recommended approval of the text amendments in proposed Ordinance #2024-14.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Kopp noted that the changes were made based on council feedback as well as constituent concerns. Mr. Kopp explained that along with the Fire Marshal, they made changes to create transparency and provide a fee structure to assist constituents with their responsibilities if they do not correct violations.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Kopp explained that one of the most noticeable changes they made was the removal of all fees doubling.
Página 21
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 14
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp elaborated that a second change that was made was that if a fee or fine is issued, it is now due within 30 days instead of the previous 14 days. Mr. Kopp explained that currently any citation issued is due within two weeks and with the new proposal any citation issued from planning and inspections will be due within 30 days. He also emphasized that the fee scale was edited to remove a minimum of $50 up to $1,000 dollars. Both the Code Enforcement and the Fire Marshal ordinances now have flat fees and none of the fees double.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Kopp clarified that the removal of doubling was in reference to citations. He explained that there is another doubling within the ordinance that refers to permits. For example, if someone is caught working on a property without a permit, the permit fee automatically doubles.
Dr. Sudler questioned whether in the future there is a way to incorporate into the ordinance penalties for contractors who are taking advantage of the constituents. Dr. Sudler explained that there are people who are unable to do the work themselves, so they use their savings to get the work done, and the contractors take advantage of them.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Kopp explained that the public can call in and ask if a contractor has a license, or if the contractor has a permit to do work on their property. He further explained that it is often written into the contract that the contractor will obtain the permit, so the homeowner can call the licensing staff and verify that they have a permit to work on the property. Mr. Kopp stated that if they do not have a permit, the staff will let them know, and they will go out and address it.
Mr. Rocha recommended creating a flyer that outlines what constituents should be thinking about when planning to hire a contractor and includes the number for the licensing office.
Mr. Kopp clarified that not all roof work requires a permit; it depends on the type of work being done. He explained that there is a pamphlet on the City of Dover website, under code enforcement titled “Permits Are Needed For” which outlines exactly when a permit is needed.
Mr. Hare moved to accept Proposed Ordinance #2024-14. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Página 22
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 15
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Amending Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed the background regarding the proposed ordinance #2024-15 changes.
Staff recommended approval of the text amendments in proposed Ordinance #2024-15. Mr. Hare moved to accept Proposed Ordinance #2024-15. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Amending Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed the background regarding the proposed ordinance #2024-16 changes.
Staff recommended approval of the text amendments in proposed Ordinance #2024-16.
Mr. Hare moved to accept Proposed Ordinance #2024-16. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Proposed Ordinance #2024-17 – Amending Chapter 90 – Solid Waste, Sec. 90-16. – Violations; penalties (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed the background regarding the proposed ordinance #2024-17 changes.
Staff recommended approval of the text amendments in proposed Ordinance #2024-17.
Mr. Hare moved to accept Proposed Ordinance #2024-17. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Página 23
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 16
Proposed Ordinance #2024-18 – Amending Chapter 114 – Vegetation, Article II – Weeds. Sec. 114-34. – Fines (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed the background regarding the proposed ordinance #2024-18 changes.
Staff recommended approval of the text amendments in proposed Ordinance #2024-18.
Mr. Hare moved to accept Proposed Ordinance #2024-18. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Amending Appendix F – Fees and Fines (Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed the background regarding the proposed ordinance #2024-19 changes.
Staff recommended approval of the text amendments in proposed Ordinance #2024-19.
Mr. Hare moved to accept Proposed Ordinance #2024-19. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:57 p.m.
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:57 p.m.
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
Página 24
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 17
MONTHLY REPORTS – APRIL 2024
By motion of Mr. Sudler, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, the following monthly reports were accepted by consent agenda:
City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
City Manager’s Report
Controller/Treasurer’s Budget Report
Fire Chief’s Report
Police Chief’s Report
APPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY MAYOR CHRISTIANSEN
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the following appointments, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
ELECTION BOARD – THREE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2027
Alfreda F. Dean – First District
Dr. Cherritta L. Matthews – Second District
CONSTRUCTION AND PROPERTY MAINTENANCE CODE BOARD OF
APPEALS – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Matthew D. Campana – Representatives of Homeowners Charles Martin – Representative of Local Real Estate Industry Association
APPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT ANDERSON
(DEFERRED DURING THE ANNUAL MEETING OF MAY 13, 2024)
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the following appointments, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil, Boggerty).
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRS
- •ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025 Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee – Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr. Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee – Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee – Councilman Andrea M. Boggerty Utility Committee - Councilman Fred A. Neil
CITY CHAPLAIN – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Elder Ellis B. Louden
Página 25
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 18
CONSTRUCTION AND PROPERTY MAINTENANCE CODE BOARD OF
APPEALS – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilman Andre M. Boggerty
Councilman Fred A. Neil
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
GENERAL EMPLOYEE PENSION PLAN BOARD – ONE-YEAR TERM
TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
OTHER POST-EMPLOYMENT BENEFITS (OPEB BOARD) – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
POLICE PENSION PLAN – RETIREMENT COMMITTEE – ONE-YEAR
TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
DOWNTOWN DOVER PARTNERSHIP BOARD OF DIRECTORS – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt
Councilman Fred A. Neil
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE – ONE-YEAR TERM TO
EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman Fred A. Neil
KENT COUNTY TOURISM BOARD – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE
MAY 2025
Councilman Fred A. Neil
KENT ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP BOARD OF DIRECTORS – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Mayor Robin R. Christiansen (Council President Designee)
HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION LIASON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO
EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilman Roy Sudler, Jr.
CITY/COUNTY COMMITTEE – (LIASON TO KENT COUNTY) – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt
Página 26
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 19
CENTRAL DELAWARE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE LIAISON – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman William F. Hare
EDUCATION LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
HEALTHCARE LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
DOVER AIR FORCE BASE (DAFB) LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO
EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilman William F. Hare
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO
EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilman Andre M. Boggerty
UNSHELTERED AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING LIAISON – ONE-YEAR
TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
HIGHER EDUCATION LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY
2025
Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt
2024/2025 ANNUAL COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS – COUNCIL
COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE SUBCOMMITTEES – RECOMMENDED BY
COUNCIL PRESIDENT ANDERSON AND COMMITTEE CHAIRS (DEFERRED
DURING THE ANNUAL MEETING OF MAY 13, 2024)
By consent agenda, Dr. Sudler moved for approval of the following appointments, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hare, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Neil and Boggerty).
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
William Garfinkel (Recommended by Chairman Rocha) Daniel T. Shevock (Recommended by Council President Anderson)
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT
COMMITTEE
Michael Tholstrup (Recommended by Chairwoman Arndt) Michael W. Lewis (Recommended by Council President Anderson)
Página 27
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 20
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Vonderlear Smack (Recommended by Chairman Boggerty) Chanda P. Jackson (Recommended by Council President Anderson
UTILITY COMMITTEE
Esosa Iriowen (Recommended by Chairman Neil)
Michael Pugh (Recommended by Council President Anderson)
LUTHER VILLAGE PLANNED NEIGHBORHOOD DESIGN (PND) SENIOR CITIZEN HOUSING OPTION – SKETCH PLAN REVIEW Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed Luther Village Planned Neighborhood Design (PND) Senio Citizen Housing.
Mr. Hare moved to refer the Luther Village Planned Neighborhood Design (PND) Senior Citizen Housing to the Planning Commission. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried. (Boggerty absent)
TENTATIVE LABOR CONTRACT WITH FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE (FOP) Mr. David Hugg, III, City Manager reviewed the Labor Contract with the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP).
Responding to Mr. Hugg, Mr. Lewis stated his concern with the FOP contract was in section 3.18, Body-Worn Cameras. Mr. Lewis noted that he thought it was a requirement to have the body cameras activated.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg clarified that the one-month grace period for non- disciplinary action regarding body-worn camera activation is specifically intended for new officers who are utilizing this equipment for the first time. This allowance provides a brief window of time for them to become familiar with the device, ensure proper activation, and understand its correct usage. The goal is to facilitate a smooth transition and promote officer awareness of the cameras' importance
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Chief Johnson explained that this clause was originally implemented in relation to the initial introduction of body-worn camera technology when officers were not yet trained to develop the necessary "muscle memory" to ensure consistent activation. Chief Johnson noted that he did not anticipate this clause applying to anyone other than those who were part of the initial rollout, specifically new recruits who are still in their first month of service and are working under the supervision of a field training officer. As for any potential modifications to this clause, Chief Johnson clarified that he was not involved in the previous contract negotiations and is unsure if it was a topic of discussion. However, without the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP) present, he does not believe it would be possible to renegotiate the clause. In his view, the exposure is limited to a small number of recent sworn members, primarily those who have recently graduated from the academy.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that it is part of their training when they go through the academy and when they are out in their initial field activities. Council has to approve the
Página 28
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 21
agreement and if council chooses to strike a particular provision, as a condition of approval, they could.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg stated that he was correct. The FOP (Fraternal Order of Police) would have to re-ratify the agreement and it is to his understanding that the FOP (Fraternal Order of Police) unanimously ratified the contract.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Chief Johnson noted that at the time the clause was initially implemented, the agency was in the process of acquiring and rolling out this new technology across the entire organization, from newly sworn officers to seasoned veterans with over 20 years of service. He stated that the odds of a failed activation are almost impossible when they are with someone else. It is almost impossible in a group setting for there to be a failure and when an officer is on independent duty, the data that they are looking for would probably become visible. He noted that they do random auditing as a matter of policy, and it has not been brought to his attention that it is of any concern from any of the frontline supervisors that anyone is forgetting consistently to activate their camera. There have been no critical incidents since the program was initiated where they had to address someone for not having a camera activated. They have always captured what they have needed.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Chief Johnson stated that they introduced the body-worn camera during the academy, so it becomes second nature to them as every other piece of equipment they carry on their waist or their load-bearing vest. He explained that it is the same gear they would use when transitioning into the field. The only gap that might exist would be a lateral hire, a certified officer from another agency that perhaps got their basic training from a different academy. Chief Johnson noted the basic academy under the Dover model is around 20 to 21 weeks and the academies can vary in Delaware anywhere from 19 to 24 weeks. He stated that about half the academy is in four phases and they report every day wearing simulation of their working gear around the midway point. The police cadets get several weeks of the body cameras which becomes second nature to them while they learn their skills in the second half of the academy.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that everyone on the scene's camera would activate. As soon as one officer recognizes there is a reason why a camera should be on, they all come on. That is just to make sure that every abundance of caution and the manufacturer recognizes it.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that the current contract expires at the end of June and the new contract begins July 1, 2024, for two years. They are diligently trying to get all four (4) contracts that are up for renewal this year in place before the beginning of the new fiscal year. Mr. Hugg asked if there were a compelling reason, he would like the contract to be approved and if there is an issue, they need to deal with it at a later date as an MOU or some other by some other mechanism. He would hate to hold the contract up. The FOP (Fraternal Order of Police) could not have been an easier or better more cooperative group of individuals. Mr. Hugg explained that they were very honest about their financial situation and what they were trying to achieve and to make some of the language comparable across the four (4) contracts. This was the first contract that was finished and the only contract that at this point was brought to
Página 29
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 22
council. Mr. Hugg could not say enough about how good the process went and would hate to throw any kind of a monkey wrench in it if it is not a significant issue.
Responding to Mr. Hugg, Mr. Lewis stated that he had nothing against this contract, just concerning that particular clause and its wording. If they come back at a later date and as he indicated with an MOU and revise for legality purposes, he would be fine with it. He would be abstaining due to one particular issue.
Responding to Mr. Hugg, Dr. Sudler asked if it would be appropriate to let the FOP know their concerns since other council members have concerns. They do not want to supersede their concerns to get the job done quickly.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that the concern would be on the record. He would communicate to the FOP (Fraternal Order of Police) president that there is a concern and if there is an issue, they will need to address it and make it right. He believes it is a carry-over provision and there may not be an issue at all except for transitional.
Mr. Hare moved to accept Staff Recommendation on the Labor Contract with the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP), seconded by Mr. Arndt, and was adopted by a roll call vote, seven (7) yes (Hare, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) abstain (Lewis), one (1) absent (Boggerty).
STORMWATER UTILITY CREDITS, GRANTS, AND APPEALS MANUAL –
UPDATED MAY 2024 (MARK NOWAK, PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR)
Mr. Mark Nowak, Public Works Director reviewed the Stormwater Utility Credits, Grants, and Appeals Manual.
Mr. Rocha moved to accept Staff Recommendation on the Stormwater Utility Credits, Grants, and Appeals Manual, seconded by Ms. Arndt, and was adopted by a roll call vote, seven (7) yes (Hare, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) abstain (Lewis), one (1) absent (Boggerty).
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-20 – AMENDING CHAPTER 110 – UTILITIES, ARTICLE V – STORMWATER (MARK NOWAK, PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR) Mr. Mark Nowak, Public Works Director reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-20 – Amending Chapter 110 – Utilities, Article V – Stormwater.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-20 – AMENDING CHAPTER 110 – UTILITIES,
ARTICLE V – STORMWATER
Página 30
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 23
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-21 – AMENDING CHAPTER 98 – STREETS, SIDEWALKS, STORM SEWERS, AND OTHER PUBLIC PLACES, ARTICLE IX – STREET SWEEPING, ARTICLE X – LEAF COLLECTION SERVICES (MARK NOWAK, PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR) Mr. Mark Nowak, Public Works Director, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-21 – Amending Chapter 98 – Streets, Sidewalks, Storm Sewers, and Other Public Places, Article IX – Street Sweeping, Article X – Leaf Collection Services. Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Nowak clarified that the permit in question is federally mandated and extends jurisdictionally through the state.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Nowak stated yes, that it needs to be moved forward with what they are doing with utility and be compliant with the NPDS permit.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-21 – AMENDING CHAPTER 98 – STREETS,
SIDEWALKS, STORM SEWERS, AND OTHER PUBLIC PLACES, ARTICLE
IX – STREET SWEEPING, ARTICLE X – LEAF COLLECTION SERVICES
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-14 – AMENDING CHAPTER 1 – GENERAL PROVISIONS, SEC. 1-17. – GENERAL PENALTY; SEPARATE OFFENSES; UNPAID FINES (EDDIE KOPP, CHIEF CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-14 – Amending Chapter 1 – General Provisions, Sec. 1-17. – General Penalty; Separate Offenses; Unpaid Fines.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-14 – AMENDING CHAPTER 1 – GENERAL PROVISIONS, SEC. 1-17. – GENERAL PENALTY; SEPARATE OFFENSES; UNPAID FINES
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-15 – AMENDING CHAPTER 22 – BUILDINGS AND BUILDING REGULATIONS (EDDIE KOPP, CHIEF CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Amending Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations.
Responding to Mr. Kopp, Ms. Arndt noted that they are using the 2009 edition of the building codes when the 2024 is currently available. She acknowledged that there is no statewide building code; however, many municipalities within the state are already utilizing more updated and modern codes. Ms. Arndt suggested that they should consider adopting the newer edition in the near future.
Página 31
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 24
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Kopp stated that they are in the process of obtaining the 2024 building code books. He mentioned that the only book still needed is the 2024 International Residential Code (IRC), which is currently on backorder through the International Code Council (ICC). Mr. Kopp noted that they have all the other necessary materials and are ready to start the process, but they need the 2024 IRC to move forward since it governs all residential buildings.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-15 – AMENDING CHAPTER 22 – BUILDINGS AND BUILDING REGULATIONS
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-16 – AMENDING CHAPTER 46 – FIRE PREVENTION AND PROTECTION (EDDIE KOPP, CHIEF CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER) Mr. Phillip Lewis, Deputy Fire Marshall, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Amending Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-16 – AMENDING CHAPTER 46 – FIRE PREVENTION AND PROTECTION
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-17 – AMENDING CHAPTER 90 – SOLID WASTE, SEC. 90-16. – VIOLATIONS; PENALTIES (EDDIE KOPP, CHIEF CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-17 – Amending Chapter 90 – Solid Waste, Sec. 90-16. – Violations; Penalties.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-17 – AMENDING CHAPTER 90 – SOLID WASTE, SEC.
90-16. – VIOLATIONS; PENALTIES
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-18 – AMENDING CHAPTER 114 – VEGETATION, ARTICLE II – WEEDS SEC. 114-34. - FINES (EDDIE KOPP, CHIEF CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-18 – Amending Chapter 114 – Vegetation, Article II – Weeds Sec. 114-34. – Fines.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-18 – AMENDING CHAPTER 114 – VEGETATION,
ARTICLE II – WEEDS SEC. 114-34. – FINES
Página 32
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 25
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-19 – AMENDING APPENDIX F – FEES AND FINES – GENERAL PENALTY; SEPARATE OFFENSES; UNPAID FINES (EDDIE KOPP, CHIEF CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Amending Appendix F – Fees and Fines – General Penalty; Separate Offenses; Unpaid Fines.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Kopp stated that any citation issued is always sent by certified mail, requiring a signature upon receipt Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Kopp stated that the citation due date is 30 days from the date it is issued, similar to an electric bill. This date is clearly highlighted on the citation. He mentioned that they do work with individuals who request extensions, and he assured them that there would be no doubling of fees within the initial 30-day period.
Dr. Sudler moved to accept the Staff Recommendation as presented. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and carried unanimously.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-19 – AMENDING APPENDIX F – FEES AND FINES – GENERAL PENALTY; SEPARATE OFFENSES; UNPAID FINES
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-26 – FISCAL YEAR 2024/2025 CITY OF DOVER BUDGET ORDINANCE Mr. David Hugg, III, City Manager reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2024-26 – Fiscal Year 2024/2025 City of Dover Budget Ordinance.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2024-26 – FISCAL YEAR 2024/2025 CITY OF DOVER BUDGET ORDINANCE
FINAL READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-12 – AMENDING
CHAPTER 38 – EMERGENCIES BY ADDING ARTICLE III – EMERGENCY
SERVICES
Ms. Arndt moved that the Final Reading of the proposed ordinance be acknowledged by title only, seconded by Mr. Rocha, and unanimously carried. (Boggerty absent) (The First Reading of the proposed ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of April 8, 2024.)
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that the original proposal was one dollar ($1.00) for residential accounts and eight dollars ($8.00) for commercial accounts. However, Mr. Hugg noted that after the proposed ordinance went through the committee process following the first reading, the amounts were adjusted to one dollar and fifty cents ($1.50) for residential accounts and six dollars and fifty cents ($6.50) for commercial accounts. He added that these revised fees were incorporated into Ordinance #2024-19 as part of the staff amendment.
Página 33
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 26
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that it seemed that the eight dollars ($8.00) seemed like it was a larger charge and was both necessary and fair. They tried to balance the revenue projections, so they were evenly distributed around everybody that was affected.
By motion of Mr. Hare, seconded by Ms. Arndt, by a roll call vote, seven (7) yes (Hare, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Anderson), one (1) no (Lewis), one (1) absent (Boggerty) adopted Ordinance #2024-12 as follows:
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
That Chapter 38 – Emergencies, be amended by inserting a new Article III – Emergency Services, as follows:
Sec.38-85. Basic Life Support Ambulance Services Fund
(a) The city manager is hereby authorized to impose a fee and to bill residents and others for ambulance services. Such fees will be assessed monthly and included as a general billing item, included on monthly residential and commercial utility bills. The Basic Life Support Ambulance Service Fee shall apply to all utility customers in the Robbins Hose/Dover Fire Department district boundaries.
(b) Establishment of Specialized Fund
(1) All revenues received in accordance with this Ordinance shall be deposited in the Basic Life Ambulance Service Fund. These funds shall be used to pay the contracted annual cost of service, and regular and necessary administrative costs for Basic Life Support Ambulance Services, including allowances for externalities and uncertainties. Funds no expended in any fiscal year shall be maintained in the fund and used in subsequent years as necessary, including establishment of self-funded services.
(2) The proceeds of the Basic Life Support Ambulance Service Fund shall be managed by the City of Dover Department of Finance, which shall regularly report the status of the fund, arrange for audit, and oversee disbursements as provided for by any contractual provisions and the city’s financial management policies.
(c) Fees and the fee schedule will periodically be reviewed and adjusted to reflect changing costs. The fees are to be added, updated and reflected in the Rates and Tariff annual document, and such amount shall be kept in a separate, interest- earning account and shall be used only for the costs associated with Basic Life Support Ambulance Service. Is subject to the city’s collection policies and procedures but is not lien-able against customers’ property nor subject to the Clean Hands Ordinance. The city manager may authorize commercial collection procedures and utilize the same procedures as other outstanding fees. The Basic
Página 34
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 27
Life Support Ambulance Service Fee shall added to Appendix F as follows:
(1) Residential accounts shall be billed one dollar and fifty cents ($1.50) monthly.
(2) Commercial accounts shall be billed six dollars and fifty cents ($6.50) monthly.
(d) Severability. If any provision of this ordinance shall be determined to be invalid in whole or in part, all other provisions shall continue to be separately and fully effective.
(e) Effective Date. The Basic Life Support Ambulance Service Fee shall be effective on July 1, 2024.
ADOPTED: June 10, 2024
CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Hugg had no announcements.
MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mayor Christiansen wanted to remind everyone that on June 11th, 2024, at 6:00 p.m., there will be an important Council Committee of the Whole deliberation on the future sales and manufacture of marijuana within the city. There will be a Juneteenth Festival on Legislative Mall on June 15th, and on June 22nd, the African American Festival, founded by former Councilman Reuben Salters, will take place. Mayor Christiansen noted that the 4th of July celebration on Legislative Mall will feature a parade, the 280th National Guard Band, and fireworks.
COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Rocha mentioned that the Friday before Memorial Day weekend, there were several staff members still working after 4:00 p.m. Regarding staff, he is hoping that the city manager would give them a break the day before the holiday weekend, in particular for the 4th of July, letting everyone go two (2) hours early to show how much they are appreciated. He stated that since staff members are always here and spending time at work, it would be nice to give a little bit of family time back to them, as long as there is coverage where needed and necessary.
The meeting adjourned at 8:48 p.m.
ANDRIA BENNETT CITY CLERK
All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by the City Council during their Regular Meeting of June 10, 2024, are hereby approved.
Página 35
Item #2.
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 10, 2024 PAGE 28
ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR /AB
Exhibits
Exhibit #1 - Councilman Neil’s statement
Página 36
EXHIBIT #1
Regular City Council Meeting of 06/10/2024
Fred Neil Item #2.
Dover City Council ! Home address: 521 Weaver Drive, Dover, DE 19901 302-678-3288 ! fredneilbooks@comcast.net
Comment at Censure of Councilman William F. Hare. June 10, 2024
In our system of Jurist Prudence there exists an appeal process to insure that a miscarriage of justice hasn’t taken place. In this case, the city council has the power to make a judgement on the correctness of the decision of the Ethics Commission.
I learned a very, very long time ago, in my 1st profession as a newsman to look at the details rather than just one side that appears to be obvious. While there is a small modern version of a lynch mob, who in other instances would be standing on the other side of the fence, demanding a censure of Councilman Hare based on the Ethics Committee decision. A spokesperson has added an attack on the handling of the case based on an erroneous interpretation of the law.
History has shown the atrocities that have occurred by the hands of the self righteous or totalitarian regimessuch as the Nazis.
My decision not to vote for censure is based in 2 parts. One, is the evidence I have seen on a cell phone video which clearly shows the testimony of the husband regarding the position of the car in question to the demeanor of the conversation between the Councilman Hare and the husband was simply in error. Councilman Hare was neither combative or conformational. Quite to the contrary.
Second, is what I learned about Bill Hare since I served with him since I was elected in 2015. Even though our votes have not always matched, he never put his self interests in front of what he considered his duty to citizens of Dover. He has frequently gone on personal inspection tours after a complaint by a constituent. He has gone to his pocket and used his own funds to help out on occasion.
His sponsorship of the Dover Military Support organization to help our service members in dire need of short term financial help and all that entails is a perfect example of who he is and what he stands for.
Even when a Code Inspector issues a citation, the person cited can appeal that decision to a Appeal Board consisting of civilian and members of the council . I have sat on the Board and I have heard Code Inspectors offer solutions that saved the appealee money.
If I had setup a meeting with a code inspector to resolve an issue before it reached a time and money costly to the taxpayers Appeal, I would have wondered why Code Inspector Boss showed up rather than his employee who agreed to meet with me. There was enough suspicion to raise questions.
The employee did not make the complaint, the husband did. That is as permissible as the complaint we received not to long ago by a woman demanding the council take action against a downtown business that attracted customers causing problems after closing hours of the premisses.
However. after meeting with the owners of the property, she changed her mind about closing the business to giving the owners a chance to rectify the problems their customers have caused. Recently, she demanded the police protect the business from the customers this business attracts
Although, my personal approach may have been different, I see Councilman Hare’s actions consistent with his desire to see the taxpayers of Dover receive the best bang for their tax money. I can not approve his censure.
Página 37
Item #3.
Office of City Assessor
June 24, 2024
Página 38
Item #3.
Board of Assessment Appeals
June 4, 2024
The Board of Assessment Appeals was brought to order at 9:00 AM, by Chairman William Garfinkel. Board Members present were Chairman William Garfinkel, Board Members Doug Doyle and John Davis. Staff present were Customer Service Director Allison Haines, Ryan Zuck, Tyler Technologies and Administrative Assistant Annette Hart.
Agenda Additions/Deletions
By unanimous vote, the agenda was approved as presented.
Exempt Requests
Central Delaware Habitat for Humanity
| Location: | Exempt Request: |
|---|---|
| 37 S New St | $15,500 |
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
An exemption request for the above referenced properties was submitted to the Assessor’s Office.
Once these properties are complete and the ownership is transferred, the properties will be added back to the tax roll.
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Recommend that the request for exemption be reviewed.
Ms. Stark, Finance Director, represented Central Delaware Habitat for Humanity.
Ms. Stark told the board that the organization builds homes and does not hold these homes by way of investment. She explained that each home the organization builds is built with a homeowner assigned to the home. This future homeowner will be putting approximately 250 hours of sweat equity into the home. The home will be transferred to the new owner with a low interest 30-year mortgage.
Chairman Garfinkle asked Ms. Stark if the organization has the 501C3 Status, Ms. Stark confirmed that the organization has the 501C3 status.
Mr. Doyle wanted to know if the new owner has to start paying taxes once the property transfers.
Ms. Stark explained that the City of Dover has a First Time Home Buyer Tax Abatement Program which adds the now owners to the tax roll over a period of 5 years.
1
Página 39
Item #3.
Ms. Haines explained that the City of Dover offers a 10 Year Tax Abatement to organizations that have projects in the Down Town Development District but once these properties are sold to the new owners, the 10 Year Tax Abatement is removed because this is not transferable. The new homeowner must apply for the First Time Home Buyer Tax Abatement Program.
Mr. Doyle made the motion to approve, which was seconded by Mr. Davis.
Motion carried 3-0.
Elizabeth Murphy School Inc.
| Location: | Exempt Request: |
|---|---|
| 508 E Loockerman St | $156,900 |
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
An exemption request was submitted to the Assessor’s Office.
Mr. Kopp was present for the hearing. He told the Board that the Elizabeth W Murphy School is a non-profit organization, which is why he filed for tax exemption.
He explained that foster children that reach the age of 18, can no longer stay at the school, therefore Mr. Kopp purchased this home, so the children now have a place to stay.
These students are taught to become independent, they learn how to drive and take care of a car, how to cook and to take care of basic household chores.
He pointed out that the house is located close to downtown Dover, so the students are able to walk to stores and jobs.
Mr. Kopp said that, since foster children who turned 18 years of age could no longer stay at the school unless they were not finished with high school, at which time they could stay until the age of 19. Mr. Kopp started writing grants in 1987, so he could get funding from the State to place foster children who can no longer stay at the school or in foster homes in homes where they could be taught life skills.
Mr. Kopp told the board that the school already owns a few properties within the City of Dover.
Mr. Davis commended Mr. Kopp for the work his organization does for young adults.
Chairman Garfinkel asked if the children have to pay rent? Mr. Kopp told him that they are required to pay $300 monthly and went on to go into further detail about what the school does to make sure the children are working and building a life for themselves.
2
Página 40
Item #3.
. Mr. Davis made the motion to approve the exemption which was seconded by Mr. Doyle.
Motion carried 3-0.
Children Advocacy Center of Delaware
| Location: | Exempt Request: |
|---|---|
| 615 S DuPont Hwy. | $852,000 |
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
An exemption request was submitted to the Assessor’s Office.
This request was withdrawn by the petitioner during the hearing until next year, as the organization is currently renting the space to the tenant and will reapply once the tenant’s lease is up.
Academy of Dover Charter School
| Location: | Exempt Request: |
|---|---|
| 104 Saulsbury Rd. | $6,483,100 |
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
An exemption request was submitted to the Assessor’s Office.
Ms. Marinucci, Head of School and Ms. Gerardi, Executive Assistant were present for the hearing.
Ms. Marinucci told the board that after 20 years of renting the building they were finally able to purchase the building. She told the board that the school is a 501C3 non-profit, public charter school which receives their funding from the State.
Ms. Marinucci explained that the school teaches grades Kindergarten through 8th grade and has
3
Página 41
Item #3.
approximately 415 students enrolled.
Mr. Doyle made the motion to approve the exemption which was seconded by Mr. Davis.
Cavalry Baptist Church of Dover
| Location: | Exempt Request: |
|---|---|
| 28 N Queen St | $111,000 |
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
An exemption request was submitted to the Assessor’s Office.
No one from the organization was present for the hearing.
Mr. Doyle made the motion to dismiss the request due to failure to appear, which was seconded by Mr. Davis.
Brandywine Council & Community Service
| Location: | Exempt Request: |
|---|---|
| 696-698 Bay Rd | $551,600 |
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
An exemption request was submitted to the Assessor’s Office.
No one from the organization was present for the hearing.
Mr. Doyle made the motion to dismiss the request due to failure to appear, which was seconded by Mr. Davis.
4
Página 42
Item #3.
Dover Housing Authority
| Location: | Exempt Request: |
|---|---|
| 426 S New St (land Only) | $536,300 |
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
An exemption request was submitted to the Assessor’s Office.
Owens Queen Preservation Association LLC
| Location: | Exempt Request: |
|---|---|
| 402 S New St | $ 41,900 |
| 411 S Queen St | $3,516,200 |
| 426 S New St | $ 536,300 |
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
An exemption request was submitted to the Assessor’s Office.
Representative present were Mr. Mincey, Executive Director of Dover Housing Authority, Michael Acciani, Development Director of LNWA and Glen Brooks, President of LNWA.
Chairman Garfinkle asked for Mr. Mincey to start talking about 426 S New Street (Land Only) at which time the representative told the board that they are all there to discuss the property owner by Dover Housing Authority as well as the properties owned by Owens Queen Preservation Association LLC.
Mr. Acciani told the board that 426 S New Street had been owned by Owens Manor LLP and was transferred to Dover Housing Authority, which is why they are asking for an exemption for the land. The land and the improvements were split. The Dover Housing Authority owns the land and Owen Queen Preservation Association LLC leases the improvements from the Dover Housing Authority!
Chairman Garfinkel asked who the owner of all the properties was, Mr. Acciani explained that the Dover Housing Authority owns the land and is leasing the improvements to Owens Queen Preservation Association LLC, which was created for tax credit purposes.
Mr. Davis expressed his concern that ones the reservation of the building is done it would be no longer low-income housing for seniors. He was assured that the building located at 426 S New Street will continue to be primarily for low-income people of 62 years and older. The property located at 411 S Queen Street will still be affordable housing without age requirements.
5
Página 43
Item #3.
Mr. Doyle inquired about who was managing the rental aspect of the building.
Mr. Mincey told him that Dover Housing Authority was, at which time Mr. Doyle asked that Dover Housing Authority holds 0.01% interest ownership of the project.
Mr. Brooks explained that Owens Queen Preservation Association LLC is an entity which is used for an investor to funnel the funds for the renovation through.
Mr. Davis asked what the person that provides the capital for the renovations though this LLC gets in return and was told that that person receives tax benefits.
Mr. Brooks explained that the investment company purchases low-income housing and renovates them for tax credits that they then use to offset their taxes. He told the board that Dover Housing Authority is the managing member of the project.
Mr. Doyle was wondering what that land lease looks like?
Mr. Acciani did not have any documentation concerning that but believes that there is no land lease, but that there was an up-front payment at closing.
Chairman Garfinkel asked if Dover Housing and Owens Queen Preservation Association LLC were non-profit organizations.
He was told that Dover Housing Authority was, but the Owens Queen Preservation Association LLC was not.
Chairman Garfinkel asked if the properties received a tax bill form the City of Dover in 2023.
Mr. Acciani confirmed that they did receive tax bills in 2023.
Chairman Garfinkel does not believe that the LLC has a right to file for exemption because they do not have the 501C3 Status at which time Mr. Brooks explained that their attorney believed otherwise but could not attend this meeting.
Mr. Brooks read a part of a legal opinion from their attorney, in which he stated that it was the attorney’s belief that the LLC should be eligible for the exemption.
Mr. Brooks and Mr. Aviani explained that it takes a lot of money to renovate these buildings and that the tax money saved would go towards paying water and sewer bills.
Mr. Doyle asked what the tax savings would be at which point Mr. Acciani went over the property tax bills from 2023.
Chairman Garfinkel wanted to revisit the land owned by Dover Housing Authority at which time Mr. Davis made the motion to approve the exemption for 426 S New Steet (land only) owned by
6
Página 44
Item #3.
Dover Housing Authority, which was approved by Mr. Doyle.
The motion carried 3-0.
Chairman Garfinkel had concerns granting exemptions for the other three agenda items because the LLC was not listed as tax exempt.
Mr. Doyle suggested getting clarification from the attorney.
Mr. Doyle made the motion to table the additional application by Owns Queen Preservation Association LLC seeking advice from the City Solicitor, which was seconded by Mr. Davis.
Motion carried 3-0.
The meeting was adjourned at 11:45 A.M
7
Página 45
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE
The Council Committee of the Whole met on June 11, 2024, at 6:06 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil (via WebEx), Dr. Pillsbury, and Mr. Rocha. Mr. Boggerty and Mr. Sudler were absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Iriowen (Utility), and Mr. Shevock (via WebEx) (Legislative, Finance, and Administration). Mr. Pugh (Utility), and Mr. Garfinkel (Legislative, Finance, and Administration) were absent.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Ms. Arndt moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
Mayor and Council Reports – May 2024
First District Dr. Pillsbury reported that she has had several constituent concerns brought to her attention. She stated that all the issues have been resolved except for one.
Mr. Rocha reported that he has been working closely with Dr. Pillsbury to address First District issues so that they are not doing double the work.
Second District
Mr. Lewis had no report to give.
Mr. Hare had no report to give.
Third District Ms. Arndt reported that she and Mr. Neil continue to represent council on the Downtown Dover Partnership Board and that she continues to represent council on the Unhoused Working Group with Councilman Rocha. She explained that she and Mr. Neil submitted a letter of support for the Luther Village Housing and Urban Development funding proposal. Finally, Ms. Arndt reported that she and Mr. Neil have answered several constituent issues and complaints.
Mr. Neil provided his report electronically (Attachment #1).
Fourth District
Mr. Sudler was absent, no report was given.
At-Large
Mr. Boggerty was absent, no report was given.
Mayor Christiansen Mayor Christiansen stated that he will not be submitting a report as the public knows the job that is being done.
Página 46
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JUNE 11, 2024 PAGE 2
Council President Anderson Council President Anderson reported that there are a few constituent issues that are being worked on in the Fourth District. Mr. Anderson explained that the two main concerns are the house at 2 South Queen Street and several residents on North New Street. Mr. Anderson also reported that several issues have been raised with handicapped parking concerns. Mr. Anderson thanked the staff who worked on the budget, all the departments who brought forward legislation changes, and the City Clerk’s Office for making sure all of the proposed changes were placed in proper format, proofed, and available for what seemed like impossible deadlines.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Dr. Pillsbury moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Evaluation of Bids – FY24 Inflow & Infiltration Rehabilitation Project (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Inflow and Infiltration Rehabilitation Project.
Staff recommended awarding the contract to Insituform Technologies, LLC, for the City of Dover FY24 Inflow & Infiltration Rehabilitation Project, Bid #24-0031WW, for the amount of #1,279,530.00.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:16 p.m.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Dr. Pillsbury moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Evaluation of Bids – Relay Panels for Garrison Oak Technology & Business Park (GOTBP) (Paul Waddell, Electric Director) Mr. Paul Waddell, Electric Director, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Relay Panels for Garrison Oak Technology & Business Park.
Staff recommended awarding the contract to Electrical Power Products, Bid #24-0028EL, for the amount of $251,201.00.
Página 47
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JUNE 11, 2024 PAGE 3
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Waddell stated that the project was budgeted for, and the entire project is currently running under budget.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Waddell stated that the substation would be dedicated solely to the business park. Mr. Waddell explained that currently there is one 50 Mega Volt Amp (MVA) transformer in the park. However, with the design of the substation, there is a provision to place a second transformer in the park if the load were to grow beyond 50 MVA. Adding a second transformer would also provide the ability to switch the load in the event of an emergency, or during an outage between Horse Pond Road and Dover Downs. Mr. Waddell explained that providing another transformer will not only provide power to the customers of the technology park but will enhance system resiliency.
Mr. Hare moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Discussion – Fiscal Year 2024 Audit Program (Patricia Marney, Interim Controller/Treasurer) Ms. Patricia Marney, Interim Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Fiscal Year 2024 Audit Program.
Staff recommended accepting the Audit Program.
Ms. Arndt moved to recommend accepting the audit program. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Amending Chapter 26 – Businesses, Article II – Licenses, and Appendix F – Fees and Fines (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Kristen Mullaney, Licensing and Permitting Supervisor, reviewed the proposed changes in Ordinance #2024-22.
Staff recommended approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-22.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that all new fees and fines will be published on the city's website, in available materials, and made accessible to the public through calls or in-person visits.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Mullaney stated that license renewals will be issued in July, which is why the proposed changes are being discussed at this time.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Mullaney stated that currently, food trucks must obtain two licenses to operate as mobile food trucks. With the proposed changes, they will only have to obtain one license and pay one fee instead of two.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Mullaney stated that if they only do a one-time event in the city, they would not have to pay the full $180. Instead, they would still fall under the itinerant merchant license, as they do currently.
Página 48
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JUNE 11, 2024 PAGE 4
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Mullaney stated that the definition and fees for online sales were added due to an influx of people applying for that type of license. Ms. Mullaney stated that they currently do not have that type of license category therefore it was added to keep track of the license application.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Mullaney stated that he was correct and that there would be no way for them to enforce the license requirement and fees because they would not know if someone was operating an online business unless they came in to apply for that license. Ms. Mullaney explained that adding the permit is more for the record-keeping process.
Mr. Hugg explained that certain home operations are covered under the zoning ordinance. Adding online businesses would allow those conducting business from home or in a residential district to obtain a license recognizing their home sales operation.
Ms. Arndt requested that “warehouseman” be changed to warehouse operator.
Mr. Anderson proposed amending the ordinance by removing lines 226, 227, 228, and the corresponding reference in Appendix F because it would be impossible to enforce, and it does not serve to improve the life of the city's people.
Mayor Christiansen stated that he disagreed with Mr. Anderson's proposed amendment.
Mr. Anderson moved to delete lines 226, 227, 228, and the corresponding reference in Appendix F. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Mr. Anderson moved to accept and approve the ordinance as amended. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-23 – Amending Chapter 106 – Traffic and Vehicles, Article I – In General, Sec. 106-14. – Off-road Motor Vehicle Regulations (Council President Anderson) Council President Anderson, and Thomas Johnson, Chief of Police, reviewed the background regarding the proposed changes in Ordinance #2024-23.
Staff recommended approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-23.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Chief Johnson stated that they could follow his recommendation to sell the vehicle and apply the proceeds to the Dover Strong Fund or another initiative benefiting the city's citizens. Chief Johnson explained that he also proposed creating a victim’s fund because off-road vehicles are often involved in accidents resulting in injuries and tragedies.
Mayor Christiansen explained that all funds that come from the forfeiture of the vehicles should be directed back toward the citizens no matter the mechanism. He noted that many citizens have been victims of the renegade vehicles on the streets in one way or another.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson explained that his use of the word disposition was with the understanding that the vehicle would be sold versus disposed of.
Página 49
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JUNE 11, 2024 PAGE 5
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson explained that if the ordinance passes, there would not be an increase in aggressive enforcement, such as chasing the vehicles. He elaborated that the strategy would involve investigating using technology and surveillance, and if the vehicles are in plain view, they would be subject to seizure.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Chief Johnson stated that the way the state law is written if any property owner gave permission and there was a violation on the private property then the violation would go to the property owner. If a juvenile were stopped on a city street the violation would go to the parent or guardian.
Ms. Arndt moved to approve Ordinance #2024-23. The motion was seconded by Mr. Shevock and unanimously carried.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-24 – Amending Chapter 26 – Businesses, Article II – Licenses, Sec. 26-31. – Definitions, and Appendix F – Fees and Fines, Chapter 26 (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ann Marie Townshend, Senior Project Manager at the Rossi Group) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ann Marie Townshend, Rossi Group, reviewed the background regarding the proposed changes in Ordinance #2024-24.
Staff recommended approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-24.
Mr. Robert Coupe, Delaware Marijuana Commissioner, 540 N. Dupont Highway, Dover, emphasized that in Title 4 §1351, cities, towns, and municipalities have the authority to prohibit any of the regulated industries that his office is in charge of licensing. He further stated that 1351 also clarifies that the commissioner shall not issue a license unless the licensee has met the requirements of the local government where they plan to open their establishment. Mr. Coupe explained that there is a Certificate of Compliance, which ensures that his office does not approve a license unless the town has determined that the location meets whatever requirements that they have put in place. Mr. Coupe explained that his office is currently working on their regulations, which have been posted and are going through the state process that allows for public feedback. He stated that they received good feedback and made substantive changes, which will be posted again on the first of July. Mr. Coupe explained that Deputy Commissioner Paul Hyland spent a lot of time working on the regulations and they are close to what the final regulations will be.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Coupe stated that there were no major changes in the security section of the regulations. The only changes to the security section dealt with verbiage referring to diversion prevention plans. Mr. Coupe acknowledged that there are inherent dangers because dispensaries are mostly a cash business. He explained that most of the dispensaries that exist in Delaware have armed security in the building. They are required to have a vault, proper lighting, and video monitoring systems that allows direct access to Mr. Coupe’s office, as is currently required for the Office of Medical Marijuana. This setup enables live monitoring to ensure compliance with all necessary procedures. The dispensaries also must have plans for accidents, acts of violence, and active shooters.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Coupe stated that Deputy Hyland could speak more on medical marijuana because he oversaw the industry until he joined Mr. Coupe. However, Mr. Coupe explained that they do feel that the medical marijuana security provision has been successful over
Página 50
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JUNE 11, 2024 PAGE 6
the last few years. Mr. Coupe explained that there is a bill, House Bill 425, that is proposed to be introduced in the coming weeks that will administratively move the Office of Medical Marijuana under the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner. This approach will enhance efficiency for the state by consolidating regulatory oversight under one agency for both offices. It also opens the possibility of merging the industries, resulting in a single retail center serving both medical patients and adult-use recreational customers.
Mr. Paul Hyland, Deputy Commissioner, noted that having video surveillance inside and outside the compassion centers and marijuana businesses has proven beneficial. Law enforcement has frequently requested video footage for unrelated incidents captured by the cameras. This collaboration fosters a positive partnership between the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner and local law enforcement
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Coupe stated that he is unaware of any significant issues placing an additional burden on municipalities in responding to criminal incidents within the medical marijuana industry since its operationalization in 2015. He noted that nearly all the sites he has visited have armed security at the entrance and require the presentation of identification before entry. Additionally, he clarified that there is currently no provision in his budget for reimbursing a town or city for their response to a criminal incident.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Coupe explained that any incidents that do occur are reported to his office so they will be tracking any security incidents.
Ms. Browyn Sherman, Transportation, and Community Planner at the Rossi Group reviewed the presentation entitled “City of Dover Recreational Marijuana Ordinances – Business Licensing & Zoning”.
Ms. Anne Smith, 132 Oakmont Drive, Dover, expressed concerns about how marijuana cultivation can negatively affect the environment.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Townshend explained that the 500-foot buffer originally proposed touched every highway commercial property, so it was reduced to 250 feet. She noted that during the previous committee discussion, they were asked to avoid creating a buffer that would essentially prohibit the use within the city limits. The current wording requires the building footprint to be 250 feet from the residential zone, meaning that with a 500-foot buffer, there were few areas in the city where such use would be possible. Ms. Townshend clarified that while she acknowledges the viability of the policy position, it does not align with the direction given at the last Legislative, Finance, and Administration meeting.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Townshend stated that they looked at the C-4 zone because at the last committee meeting, it was discussed that it has the highest intensity of commercial use and that was the direction coming from the meeting. She also stated that there are options to not allow the use in the city however, it was not the direction provided when moving forward.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Townshend clarified that the buffer requirements were specifically for colleges, universities, schools, residential zones, and hospitals, and not for doctor's
Página 51
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JUNE 11, 2024 PAGE 7
offices, pharmacies, restaurants, hotels, grocery stores, homeless shelters, churches, pawn shops, or shopping malls.
Mr. Anderson stated that the council's decision to permit use in the C-4 zone was a compromise with the business community. He expressed that attempting to shadow ban it would contradict the will of the people as expressed through the council's vote.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Sherman stated that there are only a couple of red buildings right outside of the military base that would be affected therefore at the direction of council they could add a thousand-foot buffer further protecting the base as an economic development venue.
Mr. Anderson explained that many local state officials have been elected when campaigning on the issue of marijuana. He stated that if the city does nothing the state will decide what happens therefore it is better to develop regulations that restrict the businesses from being downtown, away from the schools and universities.
Mayor Christiansen stated that it is everyone's responsibility to consider all information from constituents and the business community when making decisions. This ensures that decisions are well-informed and based on the information presented.
Mr. Rocha suggested that there might be a need for further discussion regarding the distance restrictions, proposing a one-mile separation between retail marijuana stores within the city. He expressed concern about having an excessive number of marijuana stores similar to liquor stores. Additionally, Mr. Rocha agreed with Mr. Anderson, advocating for a buffer of a thousand feet from the Dover Air Force Base.
Ms. Cynthia Christiansen, 714 Carol Street, Dover, expressed opposition to the proposed ordinances allowing the addition of marijuana retail stores in downtown Dover. Ms. Christiansen explained that as a long-time city resident, she could walk to school and smell chocolate coming from the General Foods plant and today children walk to school smelling marijuana. She stated that as a public-school educator, marijuana can be smelled at morning drop-offs, on the playground at recess, and the afternoon pickups. Ms. Christiansen expressed concerns with the lack of a buffer around Delaware State University, which has an elementary school, daycare centers, and churches. Ms. Christiansen emphasized her opposition to the ordinances and explained that people come to the city for the history, and it should be kept that way.
Ms. Joan Denney, 350 N. State Street, Dover, expressed opposition to the proposed ordinances allowing the addition of marijuana retail stores in downtown Dover. Ms. Denney emphasized the concerns expressed by Ms. Christiansen. She also recalled hearing the past Governor of Texas, Ms. Dorothy Ann Richards speak regarding tobacco, and she expressed that if she had known how much harm tobacco use would cause, she would have never allowed it in Texas. Ms. Denney stated that the city should follow the municipalities down south and prohibit the sale of marijuana downtown.
Mr. Adam Windett, 218 N. State Street, Dover, expressed his support for the proposed ordinances allowing the addition of marijuana retail stores in downtown Dover. Mr. Windett explained as a practicing attorney, local business owner, and cannabis consumer he strongly urges council to
Página 52
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JUNE 11, 2024 PAGE 8
consider the proposed ordinances. He expressed opposition to the buffers as they are proposed because they limit the number of parcels to a few that are unsuitable for retail cannabis sales. Also, when factoring in a one-mile buffer they are further restricted. Mr. Windett referenced a 2022 study by Whitney Economics which found that the fewer the dispensaries per residence in a city, it is more likely that the city will have sales go through the illicit market. He explained that by creating a large one-mile buffer between the businesses, a buffer to the residential zones, and limiting the C-4 parcels will likely empower the illicit market.
Ms. Lizzie Golob, 20476 Asheville Drive, Millsboro, expressed her opposition to the proposed ordinances as written because they contain very large restrictions on where dispensaries can go. She feels that cannabis is a natural plant and there should be no restrictions on where the businesses can establish their retail stores. Ms. Golob stated that the dispensaries are very safe and secure.
Ms. Dina Vendetti, Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce (CDCC) President, 435 N. Dupont Highway, Dover, expressed opposition to the proposed ordinances allowing the addition of marijuana retail stores in downtown Dover. Ms. Vendetti explained that she has conducted some research and been in touch with chamber leaders across the country to find out what mistakes they feel they made so that Dover could learn from them. She stated that apart from one person, all of them said if Dover is interested in building a family-friendly, walkable, bikeable, downtown then allowing the retail sales of marijuana is not the way to go. She explained that there are close to 800 businesses in their membership, and they are concerned about what the ordinances will mean for their businesses. She stated that the CDCC and herself, as a resident of the City of Dover, remain opposed to the proposed ordinances. Ms. Vendetti explained that daycare centers, drug rehabs, and city parks should all be included in the restrictions.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Vendetti stated that he is correct, her opposition is to retail stores and cultivation.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Vendetti stated that he is correct, she does not have any opposition to the job intents surrounding testing in the manufacturing zone. She also stated that they are not opposed to medical marijuana either.
Ms. Zoe Patchell, Delaware Cannabis Advocacy Network Executive Director, 218 N. State Street, Dover, expressed opposition to the ordinances as proposed as a City of Dover resident. Ms. Patchell stated that the ordinances create an overly restrictive zoning for legal cannabis businesses in Dover. She explained that cannabis was legalized in the State of Delaware and had the overwhelming support of the residents of the State of Delaware. She proposed that legal cannabis businesses be zoned like alcohol businesses. Ms. Patchell explained that cannabis is safer than alcohol in every metric and heavily restricting where legal businesses can operate, ensures that the illicit market prospers. In closing, Ms. Patchell stated that the debate about whether cannabis should be legal or not has already occured, and it was passed. She strongly urged council to consider the legal businesses that are regulated in one of the most scrutinized industries in the state by a former law enforcement officer and reconsider the overly restricted zoning ordinances.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Patchell stated that the proposed ordinances should contain more reasonable buffer zones between schools, and they should be more aligned with the alcohol zoning requirements.
Página 53
Item #4.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING JUNE 11, 2024 PAGE 9
Mr. Ethan Whitsett, 226 Chenault Court, Dover, explained that he felt that the buffers are reasonable, however, there are no opportunities for a retail market if there is no area for cultivation. Mr. Whitsett stated that the city could benefit from the industrial economy of the cannabis industry.
Ms. Lachelle Paul, 501 Silverside Drive, Wilmington, emphasized the importance of council reaching out to constituents and business owners to gather their input before making any decisions. Ms. Paul stated that regarding the sales of marijuana, there is a need to control the type of marijuana being sold as opposed to the street version that may be laced with fentanyl. Ms. Paul explained that even though marijuana is legal, boundaries still need to be outlined concerning its use.
Mr. Hare expressed his agreement with Ms. Paul, stating that he believed more research should be conducted to understand the desires of the constituents.
Mr. Hare moved to defer Proposed Ordinance #2024-24 and #2024-25 to a future meeting and asked that the meeting be a Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration meeting. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-25 – Amending Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Sec. 16 – Highway Commercial Zone (C-4), Sec. 19 – Manufacturing Zone (M), Sec. 20 – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), Sec. 23 – Agricultural Zone (A), Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, and Article 12 – Definitions (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ann Marie Townshend, Senior Project Manager at the Rossi Group) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Ann Marie Townshend, Rossi Group, reviewed the background regarding the proposed changes in Ordinance #2024-25.
Staff recommended approval of Proposed Ordinance #2024-25.
Mr. Hare moved to defer Proposed Ordinance #2024-24 and #2024-25 to a future meeting and asked that the meeting be a Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration meeting. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.
Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:36 p.m.
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:36 p.m.
David L. Anderson
Council President
Attachments
Attachment #1 - Mr. Neil’s 3rd District Report.
Página 54
ATTACHMENT #1
Council Committee of the Whole Meeting of 06/11/2024 Item #4.
Walls, Ashley A
From: FRED Neil <fredneilbooks@comcast.net>
Sent: Tuesday, June 11, 2024 12:55 PM
To: Walls, Ashley A
Subject: EXTERNAL: 3rd District Report
WARNING: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Ashley,
I don't know if this should be read aloud or can be placed in the minutes of the meeting as my report for the 3rd District for the record. If it is referred to and not read, I would be happy.
Fred Neil
3rd District
Dover City Council
302-678-3288
Councilman Fred Neil, 3rd District report for June 12, 2024
May: Attended Governor’s Dover Days breakfast but was rained out of the Dover Day Parade when 1932 Fire Engine was a No-Show ● Participated in May 7th Chase Bank Ribbon Cutting Rt 13 & Leipsic Hwy ● Attended CDCC Awards Certificates Gov Office, in Leg Hall ● Attended Ceremony of Opening of the Electric Charging Station for City EV Fleet vehicles behind City Hall ● Attended Kent/Dover Tourism Meeting June: DDP Open House at Library at 1st Session on the planned Mobility Center ● DEMEC Report to Municipalities with Councilman Rocha in Smyrna ● Responded to Tahali Nichols, Founder and Executive Director of NXTGEN 302, for a possible presentation on cutting down on violence at a future meeting sshared with Council President & others. I am sure others have been approached as well. ● Responded o U.S. Veteran Builder and Associates LLC solicitation to clean up the debris in city that was sent to the members of the city council. ● Responded to complaint about Recycling container lids left open by the recycling company workmen after they empty them causing them to be filled by rain. Fast response from Assistant City Manager Duca. ● Sent a joint letter with Councilwoman Arndt of endorsement for HUD grant for Luther Towers expansion, ● Responded to Senator Coons’ office request along with Council membrrs Arndt and Boggerty regarding Housing/Rental Assistance and for tenant in Persimmon Tree Apartments Application Fee. ● Responded to complaint about a shopping cart on the road in the East lake development on Lakeview Drive. ● Responded to an inquiry about the Phish Concert scheduled in the Firefly grounds. Answers were supplied by Gary Camp, Speedway staff, The best place to direct folks with questions regarding the Mondegreen (Phish) Festival is their INFO page on their website, which includes a lengthy FAQ too: https://mondegreen.phish.com/info/
1 Page 54
Página 55
Item #4. ● Responded to a series of emails regarding the replacement of water lines in an alley that has been a stop and start process pver a period time that has left the alley a mess, The alley is between West and Carol Streets. As usual, Jason Lyons is doing the follow as promptly as possible, Shared with Coucilwoman Arndt. ● Responded to a series of inquiries as a result of the water survey sent by the water department as part of the Federal requirements, each water provider is required to obtain inventory of all water service material. Thanks to Jason Lyons. ● Responded to a series of a compalint as to who is responsible maintenance of the water ditch surrounding the Wild Meadows community. Thanks to Jason Lyons. ● Sent out 2 Alerts from Councilwoman Arndt and me to 3rd District Civic and HOA leaders to be shared with there members. One dealt with new activities on the Speedway grounds. The 2nd was a Know-B-4 warning we received.
2 Page 55
Página 56
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
City of Dover
Rates & Tariffs
July 1, 202324
Approved June 26, 2023
1
Página 57
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
TABLE OF CONTENTS Item #19.
PAGE
Purchased Power Adjustment “PPA” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Residential Service Classification “R”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Small Commercial Service Classification “C and C1". . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Medium Commercial Service Classification “C2 and C3”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Large Commercial Service Classification “C5”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Primary Service Classification “P”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Transmission Voltage Classification “T”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Transmission Voltage Federal Government Classification “FT” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Transmission Voltage Interruptible Service Classification “IT” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Firm Standby and Supplemental Service Classification “SS”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Private Outdoor Lighting Service Classification. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Water Pump Service Classification “FP”. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 Water Pump 2 Service Classification Contracted Rate “F2”. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Water, Sewer, Kent County Sewer Adjustment and Ground Water Inflow Adjustment Rates. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Trash Fees - Flat Rate Summaries. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 Green Energy Fund Rider “GEF”. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Net Energy Metering “NM”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Retail Customer Demand Response . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Stormwater Rate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 Basic Life Support . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
2
Página 58
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT “PPA”
PPA for “all” Tariffs unless listed separately
The cost per kWh for all energy adjusted upward or downward for changes in fuel and purchased power costs including transmission above or below the base rate amount per kWh for each rate class. When the total cost of fuel, purchased power, and transmission varies above or below the above base cost a charge or credit per kWh will be applied to all energy sold such that the cost or credit will be recovered or returned over time.
All kWh - per kWh $.00
Rate effective date begins with bill dates on and after August 1, 2023
3
Página 59
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
RESIDENTIAL SERVICE CLASSIFICATION “R”
This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area for household related services in a single private dwelling and incidental service outside of the home through the same meter, provided such incidental service does not exceed 20 kW of connected load. Service size cannot exceed 600 amps.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
Secondary voltage, 60 cycle, alternating current, single phase service
Customer Charge
Per bill $10.46
Energy Charge
All kWh – per kWh $0.1425
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILL
The minimum monthly bill shall be the Customer Charge.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill dates on and after August 1, 2023
4
Página 60
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
SMALL COMMERCIAL SERVICE CLASSIFICATION
“C and C1”
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area for small commercial and industrial purposes through a single meter. The maximum monthly usage must not exceed 3,500 kWh per month or have instrument rated metering. If there is a major change in the character of service or if the kWh usage exceeds 3,500 kWh for two (2) consecutive billing months, the account will be automatically transferred to the Medium Commercial Service Classification. If the customer’s usage does not exceed 3,500 kWh after a period of one (1) year, the customer may be returned to the Small Commercial Service Classification.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
Secondary voltage, 60 cycle, alternating current, single or three phase service. Other voltages may be applicable where available and at the option of the City.
Customer Charge
| Per bill – Single Phase Service | $12.06 |
| Per bill – Three Phase Service | $31.56 |
Energy Charge
Per kWh $0.1310
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILLING
The minimum monthly billing shall be the Customer Charge.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill dates on and after August 1, 2023
5
Página 61
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
MEDIUM COMMERCIAL SERVICE CLASSIFICATION Item #19.
“C2 and C3”
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area for commercial and industrial purposes through a single meter having monthly usages of more than 3,500 kWh for two (2) consecutive months. If the customer has a major change in the character of service and falls below the above criteria, the customer may be returned to the Small Commercial Service Classification.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
Secondary voltage, 60 cycle, alternating current, single or three phase service. Other voltages may be applicable and at the option of the City.
Customer Charge
| Per Bill – Single Phase Service | $20.15 |
| Per Bill – Three Phase Service | $39.09 |
Demand Charge
All kW, per kW $15.55
Energy Charge
All kWh, per kWh $0.0706
DETERMINATION OF DEMAND
The Billing Demand will be the maximum fifteen (15) minute demand during the month, determined by a block demand meter.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILLING
The minimum monthly bill shall be the Customer Charge and a Demand Charge, which shall be based on sixty percent (60%) of the greatest Billing Demand established during any month of the 11-month period ending with the current billing month.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill dates on and after August 1, 2023
6
Página 62
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
LARGE COMMERCIAL SERVICE CLASSIFICATION “C5”
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area for commercial and industrial purposes having instrument rated metering. If there is a significant change in the character of service, the City will, at its option on a case by case basis, temporarily transfer the account to another tariff.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
Secondary voltage, 60 cycle alternating current, single or three phase service. Other voltages may be applicable when available and at the option of the City.
Customer Charge
Per bill – single or three phase service $33.83
Demand Charge
All kW – per kW $13.94
Energy Charge
All kWh – per kWh $0.0673
DETERMINATION OF DEMAND
The Billing Demand will be the maximum fifteen (15) minute demand during the month, determined by a block demand meter. In any month in which the average power factor at the delivery point is greater or less than ninety-five percent (95%), the measured demand shall be corrected in accordance with the following formula:
Billing Demand = Measured demand X .95
Average Power Factor
The city measures both leading and lagging power factor, treating both as non-unity power factors, and the customer is billed accordingly.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILLING
The minimum monthly bill shall be the Customer Charge and a Demand Charge based on sixty percent (60%) of the greatest Billing Demand established during any month of the 11-month period ending with the current billing month.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill dates on and after August 1, 2023
7
Página 63
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
PRIMARY SERVICE CLASSIFICATION “P”
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area for commercial and industrial customers taking delivery at the primary voltage available, and where the transforming and protective apparatus is furnished, owned and maintained by the customer.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
Primary voltage, 60 cycle, alternating current, single phase or three phase service.
Customer Charge
Per bill – single or three phase $34.05
Demand Charge
All kW – per kW $10.09
Energy Charge
All kWh – per kWh $0.0719
DETERMINATION OF DEMAND
The Billing Demand will be the maximum sixty (60) minute demand during the month, determined by a block demand meter. In any month in which the average power factor at the delivery point is greater or less than ninety-five (95%), the measured demand shall be corrected in accordance with the following formula:
Billing Demand = Measured demand x .95
Average Power Factor
The City measures both leading and lagging power factor, treating both as non-unity power factors and the customers are billed accordingly.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILL
The minimum monthly bill shall be the Customer Charge and a Demand Charge, which shall be based on the greater of three hundred kilowatts (300 kW) or 60% of the greatest Billing Demand established during any month of the 11-month period ending with the current billing month.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification. If a customer who is on the Primary Service Classification wishes to switch to the Large Commercial Service Classification, the customer may do so at the customer’s choice. If such a change occurs, the City will determine on a case-by-case basis which portion, if any, of the customer-owned electrical equipment will be maintained by the City provided; however, any equipment transferred to City ownership, will be transferred at no cost to the City.
Rate effective date begins with bill dates on and after August 1, 2023
8
Página 64
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
TRANSMISSION VOLTAGE CLASSIFICATION “T”
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available by special contract throughout the City of Dover electric service area to customers located where Dover’s existing facilities are adequate to supply the character of service as specified below.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
The electric power delivered hereunder shall be three phase, 60 cycle, alternating current at a nominal potential of sixty-nine thousand (69,000) volts.
Demand, energy and power factor will be metered at the point of delivery of service. All transformation, circuiting and protective apparatus beyond the point of delivery shall be installed, owned, and maintained by the customer. Service shall be supplied and metered at sixty-nine thousand (69,000), and the customer is required to own and maintain all transforming, switching and protective equipment.
Demand Charge
All kW – per kW $10.20
Energy Charge
All kWh, per kWh $0.0703
DETERMINATION OF DEMAND
The measured demand shall be the average of the four (4) greatest sixty (60) minute demands measured on separate days of each month. In any month in which the average power factor at the delivery point is greater or less than ninety-eight and one half percent (98.5%), the measured demand shall be corrected in accordance with the following formula:
Billing Demand = Measured demand x . 985
Average Power Factor
The City measures both leading and lagging power factor, treating both as non-unity power factors; customers are billed accordingly.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILL
The minimum monthly bill shall be a Demand Charge, which shall be based on the greater of three hundred kilowatts (300 kW) or 75% of the greatest Billing Demand established during any month of the 11-month period ending with the current billing month.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill dates on and after August 1, 2023
9
Página 65
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
TRANSMISSION VOLTAGE FEDERAL GOVERMENT CLASSIFICATION
“FT”
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available by special contract throughout the City of Dover electric service area for Federal Government customers located where Dover’s existing facilities are adequate to supply the character of service as specified below.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
The electric power delivered hereunder shall be three phase, 60 cycle, alternating current at a nominal potential of sixty-nine thousand (69,000) volts.
Demand, energy and power factor will be metered at the point of delivery of service. All transformation, circuiting and protective apparatus beyond the point of delivery shall be installed, owned, and maintained by the customer. Service shall be supplied and metered at sixty-nine thousand (69,000), and the customer is required to own and maintain all transforming, switching and protective equipment.
Demand Charge
All kW – per kW $10.20
Energy Charge
All kWh, per kWh $0.05970
DETERMINATION OF DEMAND
The measured demand shall be the average of the four (4) greatest sixty (60) minute demands measured on separate days of each month. In any month in which the average power factor at the delivery point is greater or less than ninety-eight and one half percent (98.5%), the measured demand shall be corrected in accordance with the following formula:
Billing Demand = Measured demand x .985
Average Power Factor
The City measures both leading and lagging power factor, treating both as non-unity power factors; customers are billed accordingly.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILL
The minimum monthly bill shall be a Demand Charge, which shall be based on the greater of three hundred kilowatts (300 kW) or 75% of the greatest Billing Demand established during any month of the 11-month period ending with the current billing month.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
POWER SUPPLY PLANNING
Customer shall provide to the City of Dover each year in January a load forecast for the next three years for the planning period of May through June (example: May 2019 through June 2022) to allow Dover to plan and acquire power supply resources to meet customer’s requirements. Any changes in the Customer’s expected load forecast that is greater than one (1) megawatt shall be reported to the City of Dover within thirty (30) days of Customer’s knowledge of such change. Rate effective date begins with bill dates on and after August 1, 2023 10
Página 66
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
INTERRUPTIBLE TRANSMISSION VOLTAGE CLASSIFICATION “IT”
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available by special contract throughout the City of Dover electric service area to customers located where Dover’s existing facilities are adequate to supply the character of service as specified below.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
The electric power delivered hereunder shall be three phase, 60 cycle, alternating current at a nominal potential of sixty-nine thousand (69,000) volts.
Demand, energy and power factor will be metered at the point of delivery of service. All transformation, circuiting and protective apparatus beyond the point of delivery shall be installed, owned, and maintained by the customer. Service shall be supplied and metered at sixty-nine thousand (69,000), and the customer is required to own and maintain all transforming, switching and protective equipment.
| Demand Charge | Annual On Peak Penalty | |
|---|---|---|
| All kW – per kW | $7.89 | To be determined by City Manager |
Energy Charge
All kWh, per kWh $0.06180
DETERMINATION OF DEMAND
The measured demand shall be the average of the four (4) greatest sixty (60) minute demands measured on separate days of each month. In any month in which the average power factor at the delivery point is greater or less than ninety-eight and one half percent (98.5%), the measured demand shall be corrected in accordance with the following formula:
Billing Demand = Measured demand x .985
Average Power Factor
The City measures both leading and lagging power factor, treating both as non-unity power factors; customers are billed accordingly.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILL
The minimum monthly bill shall be a Demand Charge, which shall be based on the greater of three hundred kilowatts (300 KW) or 75% of the greatest Billing Demand established during any month of the 11-month period ending with the current billing month.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after July 1, 2018
11
Página 67
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
FIRM STANDBY AND SUPPLEMENTAL SERVICE CLASSIFICATION “SS” – (C5, P, & T)
AVAILABILTY
This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area to customers for firm standby and/or supplemental electric service for commercial and industrial purposes whom would otherwise be billed from the C5: Large Commercial Service, P: Primary Service, or T: Transmission Voltage electric tariffs. Qualifying customers shall take delivery at the voltage available, and where the transforming and protective apparatus is furnished, owned and maintained by the customer.
To service customers with electric generation facilities used to serve onsite power requirements and requiring firm standby and/or supplemental electric service. This rate is not applicable for customers whom meet one or more of the following criteria:
- 1.Onsite generation is for emergency or testing purposes only.
- 2.Onsite generating capability is less than 500 kW.
Service under this schedule is also available to any specific generation customer who does not satisfy the provisions above and to whom providing service, in City of Dover’s opinion, would be beneficial to its other customers.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
Secondary or primary voltages, 60 cycle alternating current, single phase or three phase service.
Standby (Maintenance and Back-Up) Service Charges:
Customer Charge
Per bill – single or three phase: $122.37 per month
Demand Charges
Daily Demand Charge: $0.23 per kW day of actual demand
Reservation Charge: $4.93 per kW of Contract Standby Billing Demand per month
Plus a distribution charge for the associated service voltage.
Primary Distribution Charge: Included
Secondary Distribution Charge: Included
Note: Distribution Charges are not applicable where electric service is provided solely from the transmission system.
Energy Charge
All kWh – per kWh: $0.05900
Supplemental Service Charges:
Supplemental Service shall be billed at the City of Dover’s otherwise applicable electric rates.
DETERMINATION OF BILLING DEMAND
Standby Billing Demand – Standby billing demand is the summation of the maximum integrated sixty (60) minute standby demand delivered by the City of Dover each day of the billing period. Standby demand for each sixty (60) minute period is the integrated sixty (60) minute demand delivered by the City, but not exceeding the difference between the contract standby demand and the sixty (60) minute integrated kW output of the customer’s generating unit(s), but never less than zero. In any month in which the average power factor at the delivery point is greater or less than ninety-five (95) percent, the measured demand shall be corrected in accordance with the following formula:
Billing Demand = Measured demand x .95
Average Power Factor
12
Página 68
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
The City measures both leading and lagging power factor, treating both as non-unity power factors; customers are billed accordingly.
Contract Reserved Standby Demand – The demand contracted shall not exceed the net dependable capability of the customer’s generating equipment. This demand will remain constant unless agreed to by mutual consent and appropriate changes are made to the tariff agreement and the agreement executed by the City and the customer. If at any point, Standby Billing Demand exceeds Contract Reserved Standby Demand, the Contract Demand rating shall be revised to match the Standby Demand rating that exceeded the Contract Demand rating.
Supplemental Billing Demand – Supplemental billing demand for the month shall be the maximum sixty (60) minute integrated “Supplemental Demand” for the month. It is intended that this demand shall fairly represent the capacity which the City is required to stand ready to supply in excess of the customer’s generating capacity. In any month in which the average power factor at the delivery point is greater or less than ninety-five (95) percent, the measured demand shall be corrected in accordance with the following formula:
Billing Demand = Measured demand x .95
Average Power Factor
The City measures both leading and lagging power factor, treating both as non-unity power factors; customers are billed accordingly.
Supplemental Demand – Determined for each sixty (60) minute interval as the net sixty (60) minute integrated demand delivered by the City of Dover minus the standby billing demand.
Installations which use this service in a manner such that measurement of a sixty (60) minute interval does not result in fair or equitable measure of the supply capacity required to serve the customer’s load, then the measured demand may be adjusted taking into account the known character of use and the rating data of the equipment connected or from special tests. It is the intent of this provision that the demand billed shall fairly represent the customer’s capacity requirement. In cases where City of Dover elects to use connected load instead of demand measurement as the method for determining demand, it will take into account the known character of use and the rating data of the equipment connected.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt-hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILL
The minimum monthly bill shall be the Customer Charge, Reservation Charge, Distribution Charge plus Adjustments.
The billing demand charge for all kW up to the maximum contracted standby requirements for each month will be billed at the maximum of:
The Reservation Charge plus any Primary or Secondary Distribution Charges per kW-month times the contracted standby demand requirements or per kW-day (charge listed above) of actual standby demand delivered.
All kW between the actual standby demand and the contract demand will be billed at the Reservation Charge rate plus any Primary or Secondary Distribution Charges per kW-month.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
13
Página 69
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
TEMPORARY DISCONTINUANCE OF SERVICE
Where the use of energy is seasonal or intermittent, no adjustments will be made for a temporary discontinuance of service. Any customer prior to resuming service within 12-months after such service was discontinued, will be required to pay all charges which would have been billed if service had not been discontinued.
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Power factor at the time of the monthly peak demand must be maintained above ninety-five (95) percent. Service hereunder is subject to the rules and regulations for electric service as adopted by City of Dover from time to time and on file with the City Clerk.
Service hereunder will be supplied at one location through one point of delivery and measured through one meter unless otherwise deemed necessary by City of Dover.
Customers electing to receive service under this rate tariff are required to provide a sixty (60) month notice, in writing, prior to transferring from this firm supplemental and standby service to any of the City of Dover’s firm full requirements service.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after July 1, 2020
14
Página 70
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
PRIVATE OUTDOOR LIGHTING SERVICE CLASSIFICATION
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area for all-night outdoor lighting service for lighting of outdoor areas on private property.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
UNMETERED – This will be the standard installation practice. The lights under this classification shall be fed directly from the City of Dover’s energy source.
METERED – This classification will be available at the City of Dover’s discretion and only when it is not feasible to install the lighting service from an unmetered source. These lights will have the energy supplied through the customers meter and the monthly rental fee shall be reduced to reflect this customer expense.
TERMS OF SERVICE
The equipment supplied will be the type of fixture currently being furnished by the City at the time of installation as described below in the Classifications of Security Lights, Decorative Lighting, and Roadway/Area Lighting. Lighting shall be from dusk to dawn each day.
The initial term for lighting service shall be for two (2) years. The City may require a fee if the installation is removed prior to the two (2) year term.
Where service is not associated with a metered service, a Customer Charge of $5.00 for residential lights and $10.00 for commercial lights will be added to cover the associated costs of billing and related consumer costs not reflected in the lighting schedule.
Unmetered – The City shall maintain, relamp, and supply the energy to the lighting equipment that it owns. Metered – The City shall also maintain and relamp the lighting equipment it owns where energy is supplied through the customer’s meter.
The City will perform relamping, repair, and/or maintenance during normal working hours within a reasonable period following notification by the Customer.
Customers requiring unique or unusual lighting service different than outlined below may obtain such service under a mutually agreeable contractual arrangement.
SECURITY LIGHTS
Includes a 2’ (+/-) arm, pole not included. If a pole needs to be installed, the location shall be accessible to truck traffic via driveway, roadway, alleyway, or other public accessible parking areas. If a pole must be installed and the location is not truck accessible, a decorative lighting fixture may be installed at the applicable rated.
| Unmetered | Est. Monthly | Metered Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Charge | kWh | Rental Charge |
| 100 watt HPS LED | $7.70 $4.25 | 35 |
| 175 watt HPS | $9.08 | 68 |
| 100 watt HPS, equivalent LED | $5.19 | 53 | No Longer Available |
| 175 watt HPS, equivalent LED | $5.34 | 74 | No Longer Available |
The following style is not available for new installations:
| 70 watt HPS | $6.70 | 33 | |
| 175 watt MV | $9.08 | 68 | No Longer Available |
15
Página 71
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
DECORATIVE LIGHTING
Includes a 18’ fiberglass pole (15' above ground). The electrical service to these poles shall be underground; therefore, the installation location shall be accessible to trencher traffic.
| Unmetered | Est. Monthly | Metered Monthly | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Charge | kWh | Rental Charge | |
| 150 watt HPS w/o ladder rest | $14.51 | 62 | 6.58 |
| 250 watt HPS w/o ladder rest | $20.31 | 101 | 8.43 |
| 70 watt HPS, equivalent LED | $9.56 | 29 | No Longer Available |
| 150 watt HPS, equivalent LED | $12.88 | 74 |
The following style is not available for new installations:
| Est. Monthly | Metered Monthly | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Charge | kWh | Rental Charge | |
| 70 watt HPS w/o ladder rest | $11.65 | 33 | 6.41 |
| 175 watt MV w/o ladder rest | $14.17 | 68 | |
| 175 watt MV contemporary | $14.81 | 68 |
ROADWAY/AREA LIGHTING
Includes choice of bracket from 8' to 16' if the fixture is accessible to truck traffic via driveway, roadway, alleyway, or other public accessible parking areas. If not accessible to trucks a 2' (+/-) arm shall be used. Pole not included.
Unmetered Est. Monthly Metered Monthly
Monthly Charge kWh Rental Charge
| 100 watt HPS | $9.41 | 47 | 3.74 |
| 250 watt HPS | $14.29 | 101 | 4.03 |
| 400 watt HPS | $19.25 | 154 | 4.27 |
| 100 watt, equivalent LED | $7.40 $4.78 | 36 | |
| 250 watt, equivalent LED | $9.99 $7.29 | 107 | |
| 400 watt, equivalent LED | $13.51 $8.71 | 200 | |
| 400 watt HPS, equivalent LED | $9.55 | 139 | No Longer Available |
The following style is not available for new installations:
| Unmetered | Est. Monthly | Metered Monthly | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Charge | kWh | Rental Charge | |
| 175 watt MV | $10.30 | 68 | 3.20 |
| 250 watt MV | $14.29 | 101 | 4.03 |
| 400 watt MV | $19.16 | 154 | 4.21 |
16
Página 72
City of Dover Rates & Tariff Item #19. POLE CHARGES PER MONTH For each wood pole required exclusively for the support of lighting fixtures or lighting circuits under this service classification a per pole charge will be assessed as follows:
Monthly Charge
Poles installed through February 28, 1997 $2.09
Poles installed or changed out after February 28, 1997 $3.22
Poles installed after July 1, 2018 $6.08
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All billed charges under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after July 1, 2020
17
Página 73
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
WATER PUMP SERVICE CLASSIFICATION “FP”
AVAILABILITY
This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area for water pumps used for emergency firefighting purposes and related equipment.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
Secondary voltage, 60 cycle, alternating current, single or three phase service. Other voltages may be applicable where available and at the option of the City.
Customer Charge
Per bill $15.00
Demand Charge
All kW, per kW $8.29
Energy Charge All
$0.13840
kWh, per kWh
DETERMINATION OF DEMAND
The Billing Demand will be the maximum fifteen (15) minute demand during the month, determined by a block demand meter.
In the case of fluctuating loads, the demand of which cannot readily be measured, the Billing Demand may be established from manufacturer’s rating or determined by other suitable methods.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILL
The minimum monthly bill shall be the Customer Charge and a Demand Charge based on 60% of the greatest Billing Demand established during any month of the 24‐month period, ending with the current billing month.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All billed charges under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after July 1, 2020
18
Página 74
City of Dover Rates & Tariff WATER PUMP 2 SERVICE CLASSIFICATION Item #19. CONTRACTED RATE “F2" AVAILABILITY This rate is available throughout the City of Dover electric service area by contract only. Contract terms will be for a minimum of ten (10) years. Service will be available for water pumps used for emergency firef ighting purposes and related equipment. Service will be supplied through one (1) meter. HP determination will be the total hp of all motors.
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
Secondary voltage, 60 cycle, alternating current, single or three phase service. Other voltages may be applicable where available and at the option of the City.
Customer Charge Up
| to 50 hp motor(s) | $100.00 |
| Over 50 hp up to 100 hp motor(s) | $150.00 |
| Over 100 hp motor(s) | $300.00 |
Demand Charge
All kW, per kW $8.29
Energy Charge All
$0.13840
kWh, per kWh
DETERMINATION OF DEMAND
The Billing Demand will be the maximum fifteen (15) minute demand during the month, determined by a block demand meter.
In the case of fluctuating loads, the demand of which cannot readily be measured, the Billing Demand may be established from manufacturer’s rating or determined by other suitable methods.
MINIMUM MONTHLY BILL
The minimum monthly bill shall be the Customer Charge.
PURCHASE COST ADJUSTMENT
All billed charges under this rate shall be subject to the Purchase Cost Adjustment Clause included with the City of Dover rate schedules and approved by the Council of the City of Dover.
PUBLIC UTILITY TAX
In addition to the charges provided for in this service classification, a surcharge will apply in accordance with any tax imposed by governmental authority upon sales of electricity.
RENEWABLE ENERGY CHARGE
All kilowatt hours billed under this rate shall be subject to the “GEF” Rider.
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after July 1, 2020
19
Página 75
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
WATER, SEWER, KENT COUNTY SEWER ADJUSTMENT AND GROUND WATER INFLOW ADJUSTMENT RATES
| Water: | WITHIN CITY | OUTSIDE CITY |
|---|---|---|
| Customer Charge | $5.00 | $5.00 |
| Water Rate – Tier 1 – 0 – 6,000 gallons | $2.88/ 1,000 gallons | $4.32 / 1,000 gallons |
| Water Rate – Tier 2 – 6,001 – 100,000 gallons | $3.60 / 1,000 gallons | $5.40 / 1,000 gallons |
| Water Rate – Tier 3 – Over 100,000 gallons | $4.32 / 1,000 gallons | $6.48 / 1,000 gallons |
| Sewer: | WITHIN CITY | OUTSIDE CITY |
|---|---|---|
| Customer Charge | $5.00 | $5.00 |
| Sewer Rate | $3.25 / 1,000 gallons | $4.87 /1,000 gallons |
WITHIN CITY OUTSIDE CITY
Kent County Sewer Adjustment: $2.84 $3.41/1,000 gallons $2.84 $3.41/1,000 gallons Ground Water Inflow Adjustment $1.84 /1,000 gallons $1.84 /1,000 gallons
Sewer charges are based on usage reported on water meters (WMT), and sewer meters (SMT). The sewer rate is $3.25 / 1,000 gallons for those within the City and $4.87 /1,000 gallons for those outside the City Limits.
Kent County Sewer Adjustments is based on sewer usage. The rate for Kent County Sewer Adjustment is $2.84 $3.41/1,000 gallons and is set by the Kent County Sewer Authority. All revenue produced by this charge is forwarded to the Sewer Authority. This rate is subject to change without notice. If changed by Kent County Sewer Authority the tariff document will be updated with the most recent change with notated date.
Lawn Meter Rates are based on current in city / out city water tier rates.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after July 1, 2023 2024
20
Página 76
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
TRASH FEES Item #19.
IN CITY ‐ FLAT RATE SUMMARY
Rate Code Description Unit Charge
DC I SVCF Trash Service Fee $27.00$33.00 D C I 33‐1 1 Pick Up 300 Gallon $81.00 $99.00 D C I 33‐2 2 Pick Ups 300 Gallon $162.00$198.00 D C I 90‐1 1 Pick Up 90 Gallon $$27.00$33.00 D C I 90‐2 2 Pick Ups 90 Gallon $54.00 $66.00 D C I 90‐4 4 Pick Ups 90 Gallon $108.00 $132.00 D R I FLAT Residential Trash $27.00$33.00 D R I SVCF Trash Service Fee $27.00$33.00 D R I 33‐1 1 Pick Up 300 Gallon $81.00 $99.00 D R I 33‐2 2 Pick Ups 300 Gallon $162.00$198.00 D R I 90‐1 1 Pick Up 90 Gallon $27.00$33.00 D R I 90‐2 2 Pick Ups 90 Gallon 54.00 $66.00 D R I 90‐3 3 Pick Ups 90 Gallon $81.00 $99.00 D R I 90‐4 4 Pick Ups 90 Gallon $108.00 $132.00
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after July 1, 2023 2024
21
Página 77
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
GREEN ENERGY FUND Item #19.
Rider “GEF”
Delaware Green Energy Fund Charge ‐ A State‐mandated charge for the municipal green energy fund established under 26 Del. C. §363(4) and collected from every Customer based on energy usage which is used to fund environmental programs for conservation and energy efficiency within the City’s service territory.
Delaware Green Energy Fund Charge
All kWh ‐ per kWh .000178
TAX ADJUSTMENT
Billings under this rate may be increased by an amount equal to the sum of taxes payable under the Gross Receipts Tax and of all other taxes, fees or charges (exclusive of all valorem, state and federal income taxes) payable by the utility and levied or assessed by any governmental authority on the public utility service rendered, or on the right of privilege of rendering the service, or on any object or event incidental to the rendition of the service.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after July 1, 2008
22
Página 78
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
NET ENERGY METERING Item #19.
“NM”
AVAILABILITY
This rider is available to customers served under the following service classifications, Residential “R”, Small Commercial “C and C1”, Medium Commercial “C2 and C3", Large Commercial “C5", Primary “P”, and Transmission “T” that own and operate an electric generation facility on the Customer’s premises that produces electricity from Eligible Energy Resources to offset part or all of the Customer’s electricity requirements.
CONNECTION TO THE CITY’S SYSTEM
The Customer or Community-owned electric generation facility cannot be connected to the City’s system unless it meets all applicable safety and performance standards set forth by the following: The City of Dover Technical Considerations Covering Parallel Operations of Customer Owned Generation of 500 kW located in the Electric Service Handbook, National Electric Code, the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers, Underwriters Laboratories, and the City of Dover Electric Service Handbook (Handbook). The Customer must, at his/her expense, obtain any and all necessary permits, inspections, and approvals required by any local public authorities and any other governing regulations in effect at that time.
POWER SUPPLY PLANNING:
Customer shall provide to the City of Dover each year in [Dover’s planning month for PJM] a load forecast for the next three years (“the Planning Period”) to allow Dover to plan and acquire power supply resources to meet customer’s requirements. Any changes in the Customer’s expected load forecast that is greater than one (1) megawatt shall be reported to the City of Dover within thirty (30) days of Customer’s knowledge of such change.
DELIVERED VOLTAGE
The delivered voltage and delivery point of the Customer’s electric generation shall be at the same delivered voltage and delivery point that would be supplied by the City to the Customer if the Customer purchased all of its electricity from the City.
RATE
The monthly billing shall be as stated in the applicable rate tariff. Under this rider, only the kWh charge for electricity delivered by the Customer is affected. The Customer will pay for all kWh delivered by the City of Dover. Credit for kWh under Section 4.3.2 and 4.4 of this Handbook shall be the budgeted average cost of energy as further described in 4.4.5 of this Handbook and will be valued at the applicable rate classification charge.
| Residential (R) | $ 0.1425 |
| Small Commercial (C&C1) | $ 0.1310 |
| Medium Commercial (C2 & C3) | $ 0.0706 |
| Large Commercial (C5) | $ 0.0673 |
| Primary (P) | $ 0.0719 |
| Transmission (T) | $ 0.0703 |
| Federal Transmission (FT) | $0.05970 |
RULES AND REGULATIONS
The General Rules and Regulations of the City of Dover for electric service shall apply to service rendered under this service classification. All minimum billings, charges for kWh, kW, Purchased Cost Adjustment, Public Utility Tax, Renewal Energy Charge, etc. will be covered under the applicable rate tariff.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after August 1, 2023
23
Página 79
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
RETAIL CUSTOMER DEMAND RESPONSE
AVAILABILITY
The Dover Electric Utility (“Dover”) or its authorized designee is the sole entity permitted to bid demand response directly into the PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. (“PJM”) (“DR Program”) on behalf of retail customers served by Dover. No Customer may participate in a DR program of any other entity unless such program is consistent with the terms and conditions in this tariff and approved in advance by Dover.
Dover or its authorized designee may allow a Customer to bid DR into PJM’s ancillary services market for energy imbalance, spinning reserves, supplemental reserves, reactive power and voltage control, or regulation and frequency response ancillary services, subject to the same terms and conditions.
DR programs may reduce electric service costs for the Customer, provide enhanced usage data, reduce emissions from electric generation, and provide demand flexibility.
CONTENTS OF APPLICATION
Customer shall submit to Dover a written request to participate that includes the following: 1) Type of DR program; and 2) Metering requirements for participation. Dover’s approval of the application shall be granted within fourteen (14) days.
EFFECT OF APPLICATION AND PARTICIPATION IN DR PROGRAM
Dover’s receipt and review of any documentation submitted by a Customer shall not constitute approval of such DR Provider or a guarantee of performance or payment by a DR Provider, nor shall Dover be liable for ANY damages sustained by the Customer.
RIGHT TO TERMINATE PARTICIPATION IN DR PROGRAM
Dover reserves the right to disapprove a request to participate in a DR program or to terminate participation by Customer when, in Dover’s sole discretion, Dover determines that participation by Customer will be detrimental to another customer or to the City of Dover.
SPECIAL METERING REQUIREMENTS
If Customer requires special metering equipment or devices to participate in the DR program, Customer shall provide the specifications for such equipment or devices in writing to the Dover Electric Department at the time of application or promptly thereafter. Within fourteen (14) days thereafter, Dover will provide the Customer with an estimate of the cost of the special metering equipment or devices and an estimate of the cost of providing special meter reading data. The cost of any special metering equipment or device shall be the responsibility of the Customer and shall be paid prior to the scheduled installation date. All costs for data or special readings shall be billed to Customer monthly.
Rate effective date begins with bill date on and after February 8, 2011
24
Página 80
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
STORMWATER UTITLIY
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
The Stormwater Utility will help address increasing National Pollutant Discharge and Elimination System (NPDES) compliance costs imposed by the federal and state government as well as cover personnel costs and capital improvement projects.
The Stormwater utility will be billed quarterly.
Residential Rates:
| Tier No. | Applicable Zoning | Average Impervious ERUs | Monthly | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Districts | Area (Square Feet) | Charge | ||
| 1 | RG-1, RG-2, RG-3, RM-1 | 1,700 | 1.0 | $6.00 |
| 2 | RM-2, R-7, R-8 | 2,400 | 1.4 | $8.40 |
| 3 | R-10, R-15, R-20 | 3,700 | 2.2 | $13.20 |
Commercial Rates:
The monthly stormwater fee is calculated for all other stormwater classes by dividing the estimated impervious area for a parcel by the average impervious area for the Tier 1 single- family residential stormwater class to determine the ERU ratio. The ERU ratio is then multiplied by the ERU rate to determine the monthly stormwater charge. See Table 2, in the Appendix for examples of an impervious surface. The impervious surface area shall be capped at 1,000,000 sq. ft.
25
Página 81
City of Dover Rates & Tariff
Item #19.
Basic Life Support
CHARACTER OF SERVICE
The Basic Life Support Ambulance Service Fee shall be a monthly fee applied to all utility customers in the Robbins Hose/Dover Fire Department district boundaries. These funds shall be used to pay the contracted annual cost of service, and regular and necessary administrative costs for Basic Life Support ambulance services, including allowances for externalities and uncertainties
Residential Rate
$1.50 per month per utility bill
Commercial Rate
$6.50 per month per utility bill
26
Página 82
ACTION FORM Item #20.
PROCEEDING: City of Dover Council DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Customer Service Department / Tax DATE SUBMITTED: 6/9/24 PREPARED BY: Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director SUBJECT: Removing properties from the 10 year tax abatement program REFERENC: Tax Code Sec. 102-115. - Termination of ownership. RELATED PROJECT: n/a REVIEWED BY: Dave Hugg, City Manager EXHIBITS: Exhibit A – Tax Abatement Change of Ownership Listing, Code Section 102-115 Termination of Ownership EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $0.00 AMOUNT BUDGETED: n/a FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): n/a TIMETABLE: July 1, 2024 Implementation STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommendation is to remove the presented properties from the tax abatement program. Properties will become taxable at the full assessed values on the assessment roll.
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
The City of Dover currently has 38 properties on the abatements listing that have transferred ownership.
As per code section 102-115 – Termination of Ownership, “If, prior to the expiration of the ten-year abatement period, the qualifying facility is sold to a non-associated outside party, the council has the option to both cancel all remaining years of the abatement program for the facility, and/ or require the selling party to reimburse the city for all tax abatement amounts allowed. The acceptance of any tax rebates under this article constitutes acceptance of this reimbursement provisions.” (Code 1981, § 19.5-35; Ord. of 12-11-2000) Staff requests permission to return the 38 properties shown below to the tax rolls at the stated assessed value and to cancel any remaining unexpired time left in the abatement period. Staff recommends that any past abatements approved be permitted to stand as the properties were sold by non-profit organizations.
Página 83
Item #20.
Página 84
Item #21.
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: City Council Approval DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Finance Department DATE SUBMITTED: 6/24/2024 PREPARED BY: Patricia Marney, Interim Controller / Treasurer SUBJECT: General Pension Check Disbursement Options REFERENCE: Approval of disbursement of funds approved through budget hearings
RELATED PROJECT:
REVIEWED BY: Patricia Marney, Interim Controller / Treasurer EXHIBITS: EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: None AMOUNT BUDGETED: $1,140,000 as approved through the FY25 Budget Process FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): TIMETABLE: Budget Approval 2nd Reading 6/24/24, Council direction on disbursement 6/24/24 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval / Authorization of Option 2
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
As discussed, and approved on May 30, 2024, through budget hearings for FY 2025 the council has directed staff to provide a plan for disbursement of approved pension funds for general pensioners in addition to their allotted monthly pension benefits.
On February 23, 2024, the approved actuarial consultant for the City of Dover’s General Pension Plan, Bolton, presented several recommendations for COLA and catch-up provisions. This report was presented to the General Pension Board on March 4, 2024, and to the Council. Through several discussions, different plans of action were discussed by the Pension Board, Council and the Budget Committee. Ultimately, the Budget Committee proposed to follow Bolton’s third recommendation in the report, which was to provide a One-Time Bonus Payment to all pensioners at their current monthly benefit rate. The cost to the city was projected to be $380,000.00. On May 30, 2024, the City Council approved the allocation of three times this amount for disbursement in FY 2025. The total cost associated with the approval is $1,140,000.
RECCOMENDATION
Below are three recommendations for disbursement. Following the budget hearings in May, staff consulted with Bolton, Millman’s, Principal Custody Solutions, and SB & Company LLC for recommendations on best practices for the distribution of funds. Additionally, the General Pension Board presented member concerns and recommendations for disbursement on June 5, 2024, during a scheduled special General Pension Board meeting.
Questions of equitably distributing the funds, especially to those who are below the poverty line, have been a challenge and a concern for many. The recommendations below attempt to address all concerns presented to staff.
Página 85
Item #21.
Option 1
General Pension Board recommendation – Disburse the equivalent of three checks to all pensioners based on their existing monthly pension benefit. This option disregards pensioners’ income levels, date of birth, and date of retirement.
Option 2
Disburse one check to all pensioners included in the Bolton report based on their existing monthly pension benefit in August 2024. The estimated cost of this disbursement per Bolton’s report is $380,000.
Evenly disburse the remaining budgeted funds, not to exceed $760,000 among all pensioners included in the Bolton report in February 2025. The actuarial report included 213 General Pensioners with retirement dates prior to July 1, 2023. Each included pensioner or beneficiary would receive a payment of $3,568.00. This option disregards pensioners’ income levels, date of birth, and date of retirement.
Option 3
Disburse one check to all pensioners included in the Bolton report based on their existing monthly pension benefit in August 2024. The estimated cost of this disbursement per Bolton’s report is $380,000.
The remaining budgeted funds, not to exceed $760,000, will be disbursed to all pensioners included in the Bolton report based on their benefit level received and associated assigned percentage in the chart below. The actuarial report included 213 General Pensioners with retirement dates prior to July 1, 2023.
City of Dover - General Pension Distribution Schedule Option 3 - February 2025 Payment
| Income Level | Up to $21,000 | $21,001 - $35,000 | $35,001 - $76,100 | Totals | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Pensioners By Category | 115 | 73 | 25 | 213 | ||||
| Percentage of Allocated Funds | 60% | 35% | 5% | 100% | ||||
| Benefit Allocation | $ | 456,000 | $ | 266,000 | $ | 38,000 | $ | 760,000 |
Benefit Amount $ 3,965.22 $ 3,643.84 $ 1,520.00 **Income levels reported from Principal Custody Solutions**
The city is unable to fully determine a pensioner’s level of poverty as it pertains to not only their pension income, but also income from other sources and family size. For purposes of this evaluation tables A – C below were used to set an income guideline.
- •Table A indicates the Poverty Threshold as reported in the 2023 Census Bureau report for calendar year 2023. (2024 data is not available)
- •Table B indicates the 2024 FPL (Federal Poverty Level) as assigned by HHS.gov. This is the matrix used for social service programs including social security related services. A notable difference is that the FPL table from HHS.gov does not reference family size or age.
- •Table C is a representation of the current table used by Delaware Health and Social Services for benefit programs such as the SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program). There are various social services programs, including those used for housing that use the FPL scale from 100% - 200% of the FPL depending upon the program details and qualifiers.
Página 86
Item #21.
Table A – Census Bureau Poverty Threshold
https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income-poverty/historical-poverty-thresholds.html
Table B – Health and Human Services Poverty Guidelines – 2024 (FPL)
https://tinyurl.com/s2hjn4a5
HHS.gov
Página 87
Item #21. Table C – Delaware Health and Human Services Federal Poverty Level Tables
https://dhss.delaware.gov/dhss/dss/fpl.html#100fpl
SNAP uses the 130% FPL –Annual Gross Income $18,960 for a family size of 1, $25,644 for a family size of 2.
Conclusion and Staff Recommendation
Staff requests authorization to proceed with option 2. This option seems to be the fairest and most equitable distribution of funds. This method keeps with the spirit of the actuary report and provides additional contributions equally among all pensioners included in the study regardless of their income level, date of retirement, or date of birth.
The fiscal year 2025 total expenditure for this measure will not exceed $1,140,000. All allocated funds will be disbursed to pensioners and /or beneficiaries. Any funds unable to be distributed to retirees through death benefits or where there is otherwise not an existing beneficiary for distribution will be deposited to the General Pension Fund.
Further, option 3, is not recommended by staff or our advisors as it requires city staff to evaluate each pensioner or beneficiary’s individual financial affairs. The evaluation would include their annual IRS 1040 filings, Social Security and entitlement program details, investment portfolios, among other personal and detailed financial reports.
Página 88
Item #21.
Patricia M. Marney
Interim Controller / Treasurer
City of Dover
5 East Reed Street
Dover, DE 19901
Re: Post-Retirement, Cost-of-Living Adjustment – General Employee Pension Plan
Dear Trisha:
The City of Dover (the “City”) is considering providing a post-retirement, cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) to the monthly pensions received by members of the City of Dover, Delaware General Employee Pension Plan (the “Plan”). The Plan does not currently offer automatic adjustments to member benefits after retirement.
As of July 1, 2023, there were 213 participants receiving monthly pension checks. The average annual pension was approximately $21,300. The range of annual benefits is wide, from a low of approximately $2,400 for some survivors to a high of approximately $76,000. The distribution of annual benefit amounts for individuals currently in receipt of pensions is as follows:
| Annual Benefit | Count |
|---|---|
| Under $12,000 | 57 |
| $12,000 to $24,000 | 80 |
| $24,000 to $36,000 | 53 |
| $36,000 to $48,000 | 12 |
| Over $48,000 | 11 |
| Total | 213 |
Requested Increase Based on our understanding of conversations between the City and individuals receiving benefits from the Plan, the initial request from Plan retirees 1 was for an increase to make up for the impact of inflation in the years since the last post-retirement COLA was granted. This amounts to a 27% 2 increase in monthly pension payments for those who retired prior to July 1, 2016. For participants who retired after that date, the increase is smaller, based on the year they retired.
Providing increases for all current retirees per the request would result in the following:
- •Increase the Plan liabilities by 15%.
- •Lower the funded ratio of the plan from 75% to 65%.
- •Increase the budgeted cash contribution by $1,230,000 per year for the next 15 years to pay for the higher benefit amounts. The $1,230,000 increase would first be reflected in the FYE 2026 calculated contribution and would represent a 35% increase over the FYE 2025 budget.
This approach would restore the purchasing power of the pensions of the current retiree population to a level similar to the level when they each retired (using the change in CPI-U as the basis for purchasing power). However, it would not protect their pension benefits from the impact of future inflation. If the plan were to be amended to build in an automatic, annual 2% COLA for all current and future retirees, on top of
1 Generally, the term “retirees” is used throughout this letter to collectively represent all individuals (i.e., including
beneficiaries) receiving payments from the Plan. 2 The 27% was calculated using the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U); the annual
average for calendar year 2023 (304.702) divided by the annual average for calendar year 2016 (240.007). 1 W. Pennsylvania Avenue, Suite 600 | Towson, MD 21204 Page 88 410.547.0500 | BoltonUSA.com
Página 89
Item #21.
Patricia M. Marney
February 23, 2024
the catchup adjustment requested, the cost would be much higher. We estimate that doing so would require an annual contribution that is $3,270,000 higher than the current budget.
Alternative Increase – 2% per year As an alternative to the initial request from the retirees, we also modeled the costs associated with determining the catch-up adjustment based on an increase of 2% per year (instead of CPI-U). This approach mirrors the COLA provided in the Police Pension Plan. The 2% per year adjustment equates to a 15% increase in monthly pension payments for those who retired prior to July 1, 2016. For participants who retired after that date, the increase is smaller, based on the year they retired.
Providing this increase for all current retirees would result in the following:
- •Increase the plan liabilities by 8%.
- •Lower the funded ratio of the plan from 75% to 69%.
- •Increase the budgeted cash contribution by $640,000 per year for the next 15 years to pay for the increase. The $640,000 increase would first be reflected in the FYE 2026 calculated contribution and would represent a 18% increase over the FYE 2025 budget.
This approach would restore a portion of the purchasing power of the pensions (using the change in CPI-U as the basis for purchasing power) of the current retiree population relative to where it had been upon retirement. However, it would not protect their pension benefits from the impact of future inflation. If the Plan were to be amended to build in an automatic, annual 2% cost-of-living increase for all current and future retirees, on top of the catchup adjustment requested, the cost would be much higher. We estimate that doing so would require an annual contribution that is $2,570,000 higher than the current budget.
Alternative Increase – one time “bonus” payment Another alternative to the initial request is to provide each retiree with a one-time payment over and above their regular pension payment. The payment would be equal to their regular monthly pension check. This effectively gives them an extra 8% to spend in the year that the extra payment is made. The increase would be one time only and, absent any action by the Pension Board, would not be repeated in the future. This approach would provide temporary current relief but would not address any systemic economic shortfalls faced by the retirees.
Providing this increase for all current retirees would result in the following:
- •Increase the plan liabilities by 0.5%.
- •Lower the funded ratio of the plan by about a half a percent.
- •Increase the budgeted cash contribution by $40,000 per year for the next 15 years to pay for the increase.. The $40,000 increase would first be reflected in the FYE 2026 calculated contribution and would represent a 1% increase over the FYE 2025 budget.
Under the current amortization method, unexpected annual changes in the Plan’s unfunded liability are funded using a level payment over 15 years. If the one-time bonus payment approach were implemented, we would suggest updating the amortization policy to cover the cost of the one-time bonus payment in a single year, rather than over 15 years. Funding the bonus payment over several years, rather than immediately, would result in immediate negative cash flow and a decreased funded status that wouldn’t be recouped for years. The estimated cost of the one-time payment is approximately $380,000.
Actuarial Certification This analysis has been prepared for the City of Dover for the purpose of estimating the effect on the actuarially determined contributions and the Plan’s funded status due to a possible change in level of retiree benefits provided by the Plan. It is neither intended nor necessarily suitable for other purposes.
Bolton | 1 W. Pennsylvania Avenue, Suite 600 | Towson, MD 21204 Page 89 410.547.0500 | BoltonUSA.com
Página 90
Item #21.
Patricia M. Marney
February 23, 2024
Bolton Partners is not responsible for the consequences of any other use or the reliance on this information by any other party.
Except as noted otherwise, we used the data, methods, and assumptions which will be contained in the forthcoming July 1, 2023 actuarial valuation report. There were no changes to the methods or assumptions from the July 1, 2022 actuarial valuation report (published by the prior actuary on April 13, 2023) to the forthcoming July 1, 2023 actuarial valuation report.
This analysis was completed using both proprietary and third-party models (including software and tools). We have tested these models to ensure they are used for their intended purposes, within their known limitations, and without any known material inconsistencies unless otherwise stated.
We, Thomas Vicente and Jordan McClane, are members of the Society of Actuaries and meet the Qualification Standards of the American Academy of Actuaries to render the actuarial opinion contained herein. We believe the data, methods, and assumptions used in this analysis to be reasonable for the purpose of this estimate. The actual effect on the Plan’s funded status and required contributions shall be determined by actual plan experience and may differ from the results presented in this analysis.
We are currently compliant with the Continuing Professional Development Requirement of the Society of Actuaries. We are not aware of any direct or material indirect conflict of interest that would impair the objectivity of this analysis.
Attached is a one-page summary of the results for each of the designs discussed on the prior pages.
We would be happy to discuss the results with you and make any needed changes at your convenience.
Sincerely,
Thomas Vicente FSA, EA, FCA, MAAA
Senior Consulting Actuary
Jorda McClane FSA, EA, FCA, MAAA
Consulting Actuary
Bolton | 1 W. Pennsylvania Avenue, Suite 600 | Towson, MD 21204 Page 90 410.547.0500 | BoltonUSA.com
Página 91
Item #21.
Patricia M. Marney
February 23, 2024
General Employee Pension Plan Results
Estimated Impact of Post-Retirement Cost-of-Living Adjustments
| No Adjustment | CPI-Based | 2%/Year | One-Time Bonus | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Provided | Catch-up | Catch-up | Payment | |||
| No Automatic Future COLA | ||||||
| Liability | $ | 74,370,000 | $ | 85,780,000 $ | 80,330,000 $ | 74,750,000 |
| Change | $ | 11,410,000 $ | 5,960,000 $ | 380,000 | ||
| Funded Ratio | 74.9% | 64.9% | 69.3% | 74.5% | ||
| Change | -10.0% | -5.6% | -0.4% | |||
| 2025 Budgeted Contribution* | $ | 3,490,000 | $ | 4,720,000 $ | 4,130,000 $ | 3,530,000 |
| Change | $ | 1,230,000 $ | 640,000 $ | 40,000 | ||
2%/Year Automatic Future COLA
| Liability | 74,370,000 | $ | 103,670,000 $ | 97,180,000 $ | N/A | |
| Change | $ | 29,300,000 $ | 22,810,000 $ | N/A | ||
| Funded Ratio | 74.9% | 53.7% | 57.3% | N/A | ||
| Change | -21.2% | -17.6% | N/A | |||
| 2025 Budgeted Contribution* | $ | 3,490,000 | $ | 6,760,000 $ | 6,060,000 $ | N/A |
| Change | $ | 3,270,000 $ | 2,570,000 $ | N/A |
*Based on the July 1, 2023 actuarial valuation and current funding policy. Under this policy, changes in plan liabilities are paid down over 15 years on a level-dollar basis. The difference from the 2025 budgeted contribution is shown here as a proxy for the impact to the 2026 budgeted contribution: if a COLA is granted, the higher benefit amounts would first be reflected in the July 1, 2024 actuarial valuation, which determines the 2026 budget.
Bolton | 1 W. Pennsylvania Avenue, Suite 600 | Towson, MD 21204 Page 91 410.547.0500 | BoltonUSA.com
Página 92
FIRST READING
Item #22.
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-22
WITH COMMITTEE AMENDMENT #1
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
That Chapter 26 – Business, Article II – Licenses, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, italics and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows:
Sec. 26-31. Definitions.
The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: Advertising agency means every person engaged in the business of displaying advertising matter by billboards, posters or circulars, signs or window displays, or undertaking the writing or composition of advertisements for other persons on a commission, rental, or flat fee basis. Amusement operator means every person or company engaged in the business of exhibiting public amusements, such as rides, games, demonstrations, and sideshows. This category shall include circuses, amusement parks, and carnivals, but shall not include persons defined as Entertainers. Architect means every person engaged in the business of designing, planning, and technically supervising the construction of any building, edifice, or other structural unit. ATM machines (third-party or off bank premises) means each machine that offers limited or full banking services. Attorney-at-law means every individual duly admitted to the bar of any court of this state and engaged in the active practice of such profession, whether self-employed or a member or employee of a law firm or private corporation. Auctioneer means every person engaged in the business of crying sales of real or personal property on behalf of other persons for profit, except as otherwise provided by this article. No auctioneer shall be authorized by virtue of the license granted to employ any other person to act as auctioneer in his behalf, except in his own store or warehouse or in his presence, nor shall the term "auctioneer" apply or extend to a judicial or executive officer making sales in pursuance of any execution, judgment, or decree of any court, nor to public sales made by executors or administrators. Automobile race operator includes every person in the business of conducting motor vehicle races for profit, including competition involving all recognized classes of stock, modified or sports
Página 93
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 2
car, midget racers, drag racers, and every type of motor vehicle in any form of race, competition, or time trial. For purposes of this license, motorcycle races shall be included in such definition. Bank and loan and trust company mean each bank, or building and loan association, or trust company, including non-deposit and limited-service banks. Barber means every person operating a business of shaving the beard and cutting, trimming, washing, waving, or otherwise dressing the hair of human beings. Beautician means any person operating a business of doing work which is generally and usually performed by so-called hairdressers, cosmetologists, beauticians, or beauty culturists and however denominated in so-called hairdressing and beauty shops, which work is for the embellishment, cleanliness, and beautification of women. Bottler means any person engaged in the business of bottling from the bulk all beverages commonly known as soft drinks, whether the beverages shall be prepared in whole or in part by the bottler. Broadcasting station includes every person engaged in the business of transmitting radio or television communications over assigned frequency and wave lengths and subject to the jurisdiction of the Federal Communications Commission. Broker means every person operating a business of buying and selling for the account of other persons for a commission or for profit, stocks, bonds, currency, negotiable paper, securities, and any other intangible personal property. Car wash includes every person operating a continuing business of cleaning, washing, or waxing motor vehicles for profit and not for charitable or educational purposes. Certified public accountant means every individual qualified and registered under the laws of the state to practice as a certified public accountant and engaged in the active practice of such profession, whether self-employed or a member or employee of a firm or private corporation. Cesspool cleaner means every person engaged in the business of cleaning cesspools for profit or reward. Chiropodist and podiatrist mean every person engaged in the practice of caring for the feet of human beings. Chiropractor means every person engaged in the practice of treating human ailments by means of muscular or bone manipulation. Clinical social worker includes every person qualified under the laws of the state to practice social work and engaged in active practice of such profession. Coin-operated amusement machine owner means any person engaged in the business of owning and operating, on his own account or by his agent, or leasing to or placing with another on a commission or other basis, any coin-operated machine, device, or table upon or by means of which games are played by the general public for amusement and entertainment, but not for the purpose of obtaining any money or other thing of value. Coin-operated vending machine owner means any person engaged in the business of owning and operating, on his own account or by his agent, or leasing to or placing with another on a commission or other basis, any coin-operated vending machine, contrivance or device which, upon
Página 94
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 3
the insertion of a coin, slug, token, plate, disc or key into any slot, crevice or other opening, or by the payment of any price, operates or may be operated for the emission of goods or services. Coin- operated stamp vending machines owned by the United States government and any pay telephone shall be exempted from any taxation. Coin-operated video machine means any person engaged in the business of owning and operating, on his own account or by his agent, or leasing to or placing with another on a commission or other basis, any coin-operated video machine, device, or table upon or by means of which games are played by the general public for amusement and entertainment, but not for the purpose of obtaining any money. Commercial sign business includes all persons engaged in an outside sign advertising business consisting of the erection, construction, maintenance, or leasing of outside signs, bulletin boards, and poster boards. Computer-related services includes persons or companies engaged in computer program- related services, system designing and consulting, computer processing and data preparation and processing, information retrieval, computer facilities management, and computer maintenance and repair. Consultant means every person operating a business, not more specifically defined otherwise in this section, who gives expert advice for profit or reward. Contractor means any person or company, whether operating from a place within the city or not, engaged in the business of the construction, alteration, repairing, dismantling, or demolition of buildings, roads, bridges, sewers, water and gas mains and every other type of structure within the definition of real estate, including all subcontractors. Day care operator means any person or company that provides care, supervision, and guidance for six or more children or dependent adults. Dentist means every person qualified under the laws of the state to practice dentistry and engaged in active practice of such profession. Distributor means every person engaged in the business of distributing samples, handbills, or posters for compensation or on commission. Drayperson and mover mean every person operating a business of transporting for profit tangible personal property of other persons. Eating establishment means any restaurant, coffee shop, cafeteria, short order cafe, luncheonette, tavern, sandwich stand, soda fountain, drink stand and all other public eating establishments where food is prepared, handled and served to the public at wholesale or retail prices or for no price at all, as well as kitchens and other places in which food is handled or prepared for sale elsewhere to the public, provided that food processing and distributing establishments that do not sell prepared food to the public directly are not included in such definition. Eating establishment operator means any person engaged in the business of operating a public place for the sale of food prepared or consumed on the premises for the accommodation of casual visitors.
Página 95
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 4
Employment agent means every person operating, for profit, a business of hiring laborers or securing positions for other persons to be employed within the limits of the state. Entertainer means every person or group of persons, whether operating from within the city or not, performing together and engaged in the business of entertaining the public in the city through live or recorded music, theater, or dance. Entertainment agent or operator means persons or companies in the business of collecting fees or commissions, or other payment for furnishing live or recorded music, theater, or dance entertainment, whether in their own place of business or in the place of another. Finance or small loan agency includes every person engaged in the business of lending money, with or without security, to other persons, with repayments of the loans to be made by installments or otherwise, but shall not include, either in reference to future or past transactions, banks, or trust companies. Fitness trainer means every person operating a business, whether full-time or part-time, of providing physical training services to paying clients. Food truck means any mobile or temporary cooking operation that stores, transports, cooks, prepares, serves, or sells food and/or drinks. Any cooking apparatus or equipment operated on a one-time basis, interim basis, or for less than 90 days in the same location, other than at a fixed location, building, or structure that has been inspected and permitted by the City of Dover Fire Marshal’s Office, City of Dover Licensing Office, and State of Delaware Public Health. Funeral director means every person engaged in the business and qualified under the laws of the state to be so engaged as funeral directors and in active conduct thereof. Gaming position means every individual space or seat, whether standing or sitting, authorized to conduct gaming activities as identified on an approved floor plan. General repairman means every person operating a business of repairing, reconditioning, or otherwise restoring to useful service personal property of every kind and description not otherwise provided for under this section. Gas, light, and power company and cable TV and telephone company include the license fee for utilities, provided that this license does not cover sales of appliances or equipment for which a separate license shall be required. Health spa and health club include every person engaged in the business of operating private health, weight control, or physical culture facilities designed to establish and maintain the optimum weight or physical conditioning of other persons. Home daycare operator means any person that provides care, supervision, and guidance for six or fewer children in an occupied residence excluding dependents of the operator or close relatives. Hotel includes every person engaged in the business of operating a place where the public may, for a consideration, obtain sleeping accommodations and meals and which, within city limits, has at least ten permanent bedrooms for the use of guests.
Página 96
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 5
Income tax consultant means every person, not licensed as an attorney or accountant under this section, engaged in the business of providing federal or state income tax assistance to other persons for a fee. Incorporator includes every person operating a business or procuring corporate charters or acting as resident, registration, or transfer agent of domestic corporations, except attorneys-at-law having a license to practice such profession in this state. Insurance adjustor office includes any person engaged in the business of settling claims for any insurance company or for any other purpose where insurance is involved, and a fair appraisal must be made of the loss, injury, or damage. Itinerant merchant means any person, whether as owner, agent, or employee, who engages in a temporary business of selling and delivering goods, prepared foods, beverages, wares, or merchandise within the city who is not located within a licensed "open market," as defined by this article, or participating in a "nonprofit sponsored event," as defined in this article, shall be required to obtain an itinerant merchant's license for each event or holiday season during which the itinerant merchant operates. The term "event" means any three-week period during which a special occurrence or holiday falls. Janitorial and cleaning service includes persons or companies engaged in the business of maintaining and cleaning building and structures, including pool maintenance services, in-house rug and carpet cleaners, and house washing businesses. Land lease community operator includes every person engaged in the business of providing home sites and facilities, for rent or lease, to owners of separately owned dwellings, including owners of mobile homes and manufactured homes. Landscape services includes persons or companies, whether operating from a place within the city or not, engaged in the business of designing or maintaining lawns, trees, bushes, or other ornamental plants, including but not limited to tree surgeons, grass cutting services, and landscape architects. Laundry service operator means every person engaged in the business of operating a laundry, including coin-operated self-service laundries, and/or of securing goods or fabrics to be so laundered, whether the actual work of laundering such goods or fabrics is done within or without the state. Linen supplier means every person actively engaged in holding himself out to do the business of supplying, furnishing, or making available coats, caps, aprons, uniforms, towels, dresses, diapers, industrial wipers, smocks, linens, or other like articles and laundering and otherwise renewing such supplies for profit. Manicurist means every person operating a business of caring for the appearance of hands. Manufacturer means any person, as owner or agent, in the practice, conduct, pursuit, or carrying on the business of working raw materials into products of a different character, finished or unfinished, or of effecting any combination or composition of material, the nature of which is changed; or of finishing, by hand or machinery, goods, wares, or merchandise, or any article or material.
Página 97
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 6
Manufacturer's agent or representative means every independent contractor in the business of representing one or more manufacturers for purposes of promoting the sale of the goods, product, or line of goods or products of such manufacturer or manufacturers within the city. Massage and bodywork therapist shall mean a person who represents himself or herself to the public by any title or description of services incorporating the words “bodywork”, “massage”, “massage therapist”, “massage therapy”, “massage practitioner”, “massagist”, “masseur”, “masseuse”, or who engages in the practice of massage and bodywork for a fee, monetary, or otherwise. Mercantile agency and collection agency include every person operating a business or investigation of financial ratings and credit and/or the collection of commercial accounts for other persons, except attorneys-at-law having a license to practice such profession in this state. Merchant means any person, as owner or agent, in the business of buying and selling merchandise for cash or by barter, or engaged in prosecuting, following, or carrying on a retail or wholesale business by purchasing and selling produce, goods, wares, or any property of whatever description. Motel includes every person engaged in the business of furnishing, for a consideration, transient guests with sleeping accommodations, private bath and toilet facilities, linen service, and a place to park an automobile and who is not in the business of operating a "hotel" or "tourist home," as such terms are defined in this section. Motion picture theater includes every person engaged in the business of displaying motion pictures for public entertainment, regardless of the physical location of the projection facilities, and shall include drive-in theaters. Motor vehicle serviceman means every person operating a business of repairing, rebuilding, repainting, or otherwise reconditioning motor vehicles or their parts. NAICS means the North American Industry Classification System developed by the United States Census Bureau and published as a manual. The NAICS was developed for use in the classification of establishments by type of activity in which they are engaged. The licensing officer shall use the NAICS to assist in the determination of license classes for this article and shall keep a current copy of the NAICS on file in the licensing office. Nursing, rest, or convalescent home (private) includes every person engaged in the business of operating any institution, building, or agency in which accommodation is maintained, furnished, or offered for any fee, gift, compensation, or reward for the care of aged, infirm, chronically ill, or convalescent persons. Online sales means any person conducting a business entirely on the internet. This category shall include but not be limited to businesses selling goods and services online as a home-based business. Open market operator means any person or company primarily engaged in the business of renting space, on a temporary or limited basis, to persons or businesses selling products and services. This category shall include but not be limited to flea markets, bazaars, farmers' markets, and common areas of shopping malls available for lease. Persons or businesses operating from open markets shall not be required to obtain licenses under this Code.
Página 98
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 7
Optometrist includes every person qualified under the laws of the state to practice optometry and engaged in active practice of such profession. Pawnbroker means every person operating a business of lending money on pledge of tangible personal property or purchasing the same on the condition of returning it to the seller at a stipulated price and of selling the property in default of the pawner. Payment means the annual license taxes paid by persons engaged in the occupations listed and defined in this section, at the rates specified in section 26-35(d). In addition to the annual license fee indicated in such section, each such person shall pay a fee for each additional separate branch or business location. Pest control services includes persons or companies engaged in the business of exterminating or controlling vermin from structures or properties. Pharmacist means every person qualified under the laws of the state to practice pharmacy and engaged in active practice of such profession. Photographer means every person operating a business of taking, making and/or developing photographs or pictures by action of light, for profit or reward. Physical therapist means every person operating a business of practicing physical therapy as defined in 24 Del. C. § 2601 et seq. Physician and surgeon mean every individual qualified under the laws of the state to practice medicine, osteopathy, and surgery, and engaged in active practice of such profession, whether self- employed or a member or employee of a firm or private corporation. Plant nursery and florist include every person in the business of operating a place where trees, shrubs, plants, flowers, and the like are cultivated, grown, or propagated from seed or otherwise for transplanting, for use as stock, for grafting, and for sale. Persons purchasing trees, shrubs, plants, flowers, and the like for resale are subject to the appropriate license fee in this article. Pool table operator means every person operating a business of maintaining pool or billiard tables for public use. Printer means any person engaged in the business of impressing letters or characters upon paper or other substance by mechanical act. Private investigator agency includes every person engaged in the business of practicing as a private investigator as defined in 24 Del. C. § 1301 et seq., provided nothing in this definition shall be construed to include any person exclusively employed as a guard, security officer or private patrol officer. Professional counselor means every person qualified under the laws of the state to practice counseling and engaged in active practice of such profession. Professional engineer means every individual qualified under the laws of the state to practice professional engineering and is engaged in active practice of such profession, whether self- employed or a member or employee of a firm or private corporation offering professional engineering services to the general public. Professional land surveyor means every individual who is a professional specialist in the techniques of the principles of mathematics and the related sciences; is experienced in the
Página 99
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 8
application of the principles of mathematics and the related sciences; understands the relevant requirements of law for the presentation of adequate assistance relating to property descriptions and the surveying of real property; is efficient in the practice of land surveying; and holds a valid certificate to practice land surveying as defined by the state. Psychologist means every person qualified under the laws of the state to practice psychology and engaged in active practice of such profession. Public accountant means every person actively operating a business of general public accounting, who is not qualified and registered under the laws of the state to practice as a certified public accountant. Public stenographer means every person operating a business, whether full-time or part-time, of providing stenographic services to the general public. Publisher includes any person engaged in the business of manufacturing, promulgating, or selling books, pamphlets, magazines, newspapers, or other literary productions, or issues or causes to be issued books, pamphlets, magazines, newspapers, or other literary productions from the press, for sale or for circulation. Real estate brokers of record, appraisers, and property managers mean and include every person or company, whether operating from the city or not, either certified by the state real estate commission as brokers or appraisers engaged in the real estate business and/or those engaged in real estate property management, whether owned by the management company or when acting as an agent. The term includes those among such persons who deal exclusively or partly with rental property. Persons or companies that combine one or more of these services shall pay for one license only. Real estate development corporation means every person or company in the business of real estate development. Real estate property manager means every person or company, whether operating from the city or not, in the business of real estate rental property management and not required to be licensed as a real estate broker of record, appraiser, or real estate agent by the state real estate commission. Real estate salesperson or associate broker means every person, whether operating from within the city or not, certified as such by the state real estate commission, and engaged in the real estate business. Such term includes those among such persons who deal exclusively or partly with rental property. Rental services includes persons or companies engaged in the business of renting equipment, motor vehicles, machinery, tools, furniture, videotapes and games, electronic sound, computer or video systems, tents, and any other article. Sales representative means every person, whether operating from a place within the city or not, who works selling or supplying goods, commodities, or merchandise from place to place, including fuel, food, services, goods, wares, and other articles. The term shall include peddlers, home demonstrators, solicitors, and hucksters. Schools and educational services (nonvocational) includes persons or companies engaged in the business of providing instruction in areas of knowledge and skill not intended or principally designed to provide a career. This definition shall include but is not limited to nonvocational art, music, dance, driving, charm, and athletic instruction.
Página 100
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 9
Schools and educational services (vocational) includes persons or companies engaged in the business of providing instruction in areas of knowledge and skill intended or designed to provide a career. This definition shall include but is not limited to barber, beautician, and modeling instruction. Scientific laboratory includes every person who operates, as a private business for a profit, a scientific or medical laboratory offering testing, research, analytical, and other such technical services to the public. Scrap and waste material dealer includes every person or company engaged in assembling, breaking up, sorting, and distributing, either wholesale or retail, scrap, or waste material of all compositions, including but not limited to junkyards, salvage yards, and recycling centers. Security services includes every person or company engaged in the business of providing private security services, including security officers, guards, or private patrol officers. Shoe repairman means any person engaged in the business of repairing or rebuilding shoes. Tailor and garment services include persons or companies who make repairs and alterations to clothes and other fabric products, including textile renovators. Taxicab or bus operator means every person in the business of the operation of motor vehicles in transporting persons for hire in the accommodation of the general public. The tax shall not apply, however, in the operation of school buses used solely in the transportation of children to and from kindergarten, grade school, vocational school, and high school. Tourist home includes every person who operates a place where tourists or transient guests, for a consideration, may obtain sleeping accommodations and which has at least two permanent bedrooms for the use of tourists or transient guests and who is not in the "hotel" or "motel" business as defined in this section. Travel agency includes every person who operates a full-service travel bureau which assists in the planning and acquisition of tickets for trips of its customers by land, sea, or air and for related accommodation, and includes transportation agents who sell tickets on behalf of others, for commission, and airline ticket sales offices. Veterinarian means every person qualified under the laws of the state to practice veterinary medicine and engaged in active practice of such profession. Warehouseman Warehouse Operator means every person operating a business of public storage of tangible personal property, including all services in connection therewith. Wholesale news agency includes every person engaged in the business of conducting a wholesale news agency, except any such person who is licensed as a merchant under city ordinance.
Sec. 26-35. License required; fees. (a) Nonprofessional service businesses. Except where expressed by definition in section 26- 31, nonprofessional service businesses shall pay an annual license fee for each store, place of business or vehicle from which the licensee conducts the business operated within the city.
Página 101
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 10
(b) Professional services. Persons engaged in professional services, such as accountants, certified or public, landscape architects, architects, optometrists, lawyers, dentists, physicians and surgeons, psychologists, physical therapists, podiatrists, professional engineers, and veterinarians shall pay an annual license fee for engaging in such professional services within the city. (c) Corporate employees. No license shall be required of any individual practicing a profession or trade who is in the employ of any corporation licensed under any other provision of this article and who does not practice his profession, except in his capacity as an employee of such corporation and, provided further, that no attorney in the employ of any such corporation shall be required to obtain a license under this section so as to fulfill assignments made to him by any state court. (d) Businesses licensed. (1) No person shall conduct or engage in any of the following trades, businesses, or occupations within the city without a license and paying the appropriate fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. (2) Manufacturers and contractors shall pay a license fee as provided for in Appendix F— Fees and Fines. (3) Merchants and bottlers shall pay a license fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. (4) Sports betting and horse racing (Simulcast) shall be licensed for each activity and shall pay a license fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines.
Sec. 26-36. Determination of license fee; duties of license officer; refunds. (a) Generally. License fees shall be in the amounts established in this article, and as further determined in this section. (b) Duties of license officer. The license officer shall: (1) Higher fee. Require the payment of an additional or higher license fee, to be prorated for the balance of the license period, when a licensee places himself in that status under this article by: a. Increasing the number of his employees. b. Expanding the size of his business, plant, or premises. c. Increasing the number or size of his vehicles. d. Making any other lawful and material change of any kind in his business. (2) Partial refund. Refund a proportion of the amount of fee already paid, prorated for the balance of the license period, upon notification by a licensee of his voluntary retirement from business. (3) Late commencement of business. Prorate the license fee quarterly for the balance of any license period, including minimum license fees of any business commenced after the beginning of the license period. Prorating of the license fee shall not occur for
Página 102
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 11
contractors who receive a per job license, or for itinerant merchant licensees. The first pro-ration begins on November 1st, the second pro-ration begins on February 1st, and the third pro-ration begins on May 1st, of each year. (c) Refund. (1) Except as provided, no rebate or refund of any license fee or part thereof shall be made by reason of the nonuse of the license or by reason of a change of location or business rendering the use of the license ineffective. The license officer shall have the authority to refund a license fee or prorated portion thereof where: a. Error. The license fee was collected through an error. b. Hardship. Some particular hardship might be involved. c. Death or incapacity. The licensee has been prevented from enjoying the full license privilege due to his death or incapacity to engage in the business. d. Armed services. The licensee has entered the armed services of the United States through induction or enlistment and is thereby rendered unable to conduct the business. e. Government takeover. The licensed business is forced to close before the expiration of the license period by reason of the taking over of the business or licensed premises by the United States government, the state, or this city. f. Fire, casualty. The licensed business was destroyed by fire or other casualty through no fault of the licensee. (2) A rebate or refund provided for in this subsection (c) shall be based upon the number of days in the license period remaining after the occurrence of the event relied upon for the rebate.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix F – Fees and Fines, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows:
Chapter 26. – Business Chapter 26. Businesses Fees and Fines Article II. Licenses Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. Sec. 26-35. License required; fees Subsec. (d)(1) Businesses licensed Advertising agency $95.00 $96.00 Amusement operator $157.00 $160.00 Architect (per person) $250.00 $256.00 Attorney-at-law (per person) $313.00 $320.00 ATM machines (third-party or off-bank premises) $50.50 $52.00
Página 103
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 12
Auctioneer $157.00 $160.00 Automobile race operator $375.00 $380.00 Bank, or loan and trust company $313.00 $320.00 Barber $63.00 $64.00 each additional chair over two $4.00 Beautician $63.00 $64.00 each additional chair over two $4.00 Broadcasting station $313.00 Broker $157.00 $160.00 Car wash $188.00 $192.00 Certified public accountant (per person) $250.00 $256.00 Cesspool cleaner $125.00 $128.00 Chiropractor (per person) $313.00 $320.00 Clinical social worker (per person) $96.00 $100.00 Coin-operated amusement machine owner, per machine $3.00 $4.00 Coin-operated vending machine owner, per machine $3.00 $4.00 Coin-operated electronic video machine, per machine $125.00 $128.00 Commercial sign business $125.00 $128.00 Computer-related services $125.00 $128.00 Consultant $50.50 $52.00 Daycare operator: Center or home provider with greater than six children $50.50 $52.00 Dentist (per person) $313.00 $320.00 Distributor $63.00 $64.00 Dray person or mover $125.00 $128.00 Eating establishment and/or eating establishment operator $125.00 $128.00 Employment agency $125.00 $128.00 Entertainer: One—three entertainers per group $50.50 $52.00 Four—nine entertainers per group $95.00 $96.00 Ten or more $125.00 $128.00 Entertainment agent $188.00 $192.00 Finance or small loan agency $250.00 $256.00 Fitness trainer $69.00 $72.00 Food Truck $180.00 Funeral director $250.00 $256.00 Gaming position $155.00 $160.00 Gas, light, power, cable TV, and telephone company $938.00 $960.00 General repairman $63.00 $64.00 Health spa or health club $188.00 $192.00 Home daycare operator $25.50 $28.00 Hotel: Per room $9.50 $12.00
Página 104
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 13
Per suite $12.50 $12.00 Income tax consultant $188.00 $192.00 Incorporator $125.00 $128.00 Insurance adjustor office $125.00 $128.00 Itinerant merchant, per event $100.00 Janitorial and cleaning service: One—three employees $50.50 $52.00 Four—nine employees $95.00 $96.00 Ten or more employees $125.00 $128.00 Land lease community operator, per home site within community $25.00 $24.00 Landscape service company: One—three employees $50.50 $52.00 Four—nine employees $95.00 $96.00 Ten or more employees $125.00 $128.00 Laundry service operator: Primary facility $125.00 $128.00 Additional drop-off locations $50.50 $52.00 Linen supplier $125.00 $96.00 Manicurist (per person) $32.00 $128.00 Manufacturer's agent or representative $125.00 $128.00 Massage Therapist (per person) $60.00 Mercantile agency or collection agency $125.00 $128.00 Motel, per room $7.00 $8.00 Motion picture theater $188.00 $192.00 Motor vehicle serviceman $95.00 $96.00 Nursing, rest, or convalescent home $188.00 $192.00 Online Sales (home-based business) $60.00 Open market operator: First 20 spaces, per rented space $22.50 $24.00 21st—50th space, per rented space $11.50 $12.00 Each space over 50, per rented space $6.00 $8.00 Outdoor tables, per table $6.00 $8.00 Optometrist (per person) $313.00 $320.00 Pawnbroker $188.00 $192.00 Pest control services $95.00 $96.00 Pharmacist (per person) $188.00 $192.00 Photographer $125.00 $128.00 Physical therapist (per person) $188.00 $192.00 Physician and/or surgeon (per person) $313.00 $320.00 Plant nursery and florist $95.00 $96.00 Podiatrist (per person) $313.00 $320.00 Pool table operator, per table $63.00 $64.00/ Maximum fee
Página 105
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 14
$189.00 $192.00 Printer $125.00 $128.00 Private investigator agency $188.00 Professional counselor (per person) $63.00 $64.00 Professional engineer (per person) $250.00 $256.00 Professional land surveyor (per person) $250.00 $256.00 Psychologist (per person) $313.00 $320.00 Public accountant (per person) $188.00 $192.00 Public stenographer $38.00 Publisher $313.00 $320.00 Real estate broker, appraiser, and manager $157.00 $160.00 Real estate development corporation $344.00 $352.00 Real estate property manager: One—three units managed $50.50 $52.00 Four—ten units managed $125.00 $128.00 Ten + units managed $125.00 $128.00 Real estate salesperson or associated broker $50.50 $52.00 Rental service $125.00 $128.00 Sales representative $50.50 $52.00 School and educational service (nonvocational) $63.00 $64.00 School and educational service (vocational) $125.00 $128.00 Scientific laboratory $250.00 $256.00 Scrap and waste material service $125.00 $128.00 Secondhand dealer of precious metals $125.00 Security service $188.00 $192.00 Self-service laundry or dry cleaner $125.00 Shoe repairman $50.50 $52.00 Sound truck, per hour $33.00 Tailor and garment service $50.50 $52.00 Taxicab or bus operator: First vehicle $26.00 $28.00 Each additional vehicle $26.00 $28.00 Tourist home, per room $7.00 $8.00 Travel agency $125.00 $128.00 Veterinarian (per person) $313.00 $320.00 Warehouseman Warehouse Operator $250.00 $256.00 Wholesale news agency $63.00 All other businesses not listed: One—three employees $50.50 $52.00 Four—nine employees $95.00 $96.00 Ten—50 employees $125.00 $128.00 51—100 employees $313.00 $320.00 Subsec. (d)(2) Manufacturers/contractors rate $0.00046 of
Página 106
Item #22. Proposed Ordinance #2024-22 – Chapter 26 – Businesses, Art. II – Licenses, App. F Page 15
aggregate gross receipts/ Minimum fee $125.00 $128.00 Subsec. (d)(3) Merchants/bottlers rate $0.00046 of aggregate gross purchases for resale/ Minimum fee $63.00 $64.00 Subsec. (d)(4) Sports betting and horse racing (Simulcast) rate of $0.00046 of the aggregate gross receipts (defined as commission) for each activity/ Minimum license fee $125.00 $128.00 Sec. 26-42. Penalty for late payment of license fee A penalty fee in the amount of ten percent per month of the amount of the licensee fee until the same is paid Article III. Going-Out-of-Business Sales; Fire Sales Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. Sec. 26-108. Violations; penalties Not less than $25.00, nor more than $1,000.00 Sec. 26-137. Fees $25.00; renewal fee $25.00
ADOPTED: *
SYNOPSIS
It has been since 2010 that business license fees were adjusted. This ordinance revises the fees charged for a business license by class of license to provide clarity and to reflect continued inflation and rising cost of issuance. The fees are also adjusted to round numbers divisible by 4 to provide ease in pro-rating for part-year license applications and to simplify the application process.
(SPONSORS: NEIL and HUGG)
Action History 06/24/2024 – Scheduled for First Reading – City Council 06/11/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
Página 107
Item #23.
FIRST READING
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-23
| 1 | BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN |
| 2 | COUNCIL MET: |
| 3 | |
|---|---|
| 4 That Chapter 106 – Traffic and Vehicles, Article 1 – In General, Section 106-14. Off-road motor | |
| 5 vehicle regulations be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, italics and deleting | |
| 6 | the text indicated in red strikeout as follows: |
| 7 | |
| 8 | Sec. 106-14. Off-road motor vehicle regulation |
| 9 | |
| 10 (a) Definitions. The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this section, shall have | |
| 11 the meanings ascribed to them in this subsection, except where the context clearly indicates | |
| 12 | a different meaning: |
| 13 | |
| 14 Off-road vehicle, or ORV, is interchangeable with the 21 Del. C. term of “Off-Highway | |
| 15 Vehicle”, or OHV, and means any motor vehicle or other motorized vehicle not licensed | |
| 16 to travel on the public roads of the state or permitted to travel on the public roads of the | |
| 17 state. It also means a motor driven off-road vehicle capable of cross-country travel | |
| 18 without benefit of a road or trail, on or immediately over land, snow, ice, marsh, | |
| 19 swampland or other natural terrain. It includes, but is not limited to, a multi-wheel | |
| 20 drive or low pressure tire vehicle, a motorcycle or related 2-wheel vehicle, an | |
| 21 amphibious machine, a ground effect air-cushion vehicle or other means of | |
| 22 transportation deriving motive power from a source other than muscle or wind, | |
| 23 including dirt bikes and all-terrain vehicles. ORV does not include a farm vehicle | |
| 24 being used for farming, a vehicle used for military, fire, emergency or law- | |
| 25 enforcement purposes, a construction or logging vehicle used in performance of its | |
| 26 common function, electric personal assistive mobility device or a registered aircraft. | |
| 27 However, nothing in this section shall be construed to include snowmobiles or electric | |
| 28 | bikes, scooters, etc., incapable of speeds exceeding 20 mph. |
| 29 | |
| 30 Victim Services means the support of victims and/or survivors of crime, fire, or | |
| 31 serious traumatic injuries of any mechanism occurring within the city limits. | |
| 32 | |
| 33 (b) Regulations. All off-road motor vehicles shall comply with the following regulations: | |
| 34 | |
| 35 (1) City License. The operator must obtain a license from the city in order to operate the | |
| 36 vehicle within the corporate limits of the city, which license shall be issued according | |
| 37 to regulations adopted by the city regarding the amount of the fee, display of the license, | |
| 38 | proof of insurance coverage, etc. |
Página 108
Item #23.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-23 – Chapter 106 – Traffic and Vehicles, Sec. 106-14 – Off-road motor vehicle Page 2
39 40 (2) Muffler. The vehicle must have a muffler system which limits engine noises to state
| 41 | noise violation standards. | |
| 42 | ||
|---|---|---|
| 43 (3) Place of operation; approval. The operator must have in his possession written approval | ||
| 44 of the owner of the property upon which he operates the vehicle, or he must operate the | ||
| 45 | vehicle on a site that is licensed and designated for such purpose. | |
| 46 (c) Violations. If any person witnesses a violation of subsection (b)(1), (b)(2), or (b)(3) of this | ||
| 47 section by a person on or in a motor vehicle and the identity of the offender is not otherwise | ||
| 48 apparent, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the person in whose name such motor | ||
| 49 | vehicle is registered committed such a violation. | |
| 50 | ||
| 51 (d) Penalties. Anyone violating any provision of this section shall be fined as provided for in | ||
| 52 Appendix F-Fees and Fines. Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, | ||
| 53 including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | ||
| 54 | ||
| 55 | (b) Ownership, Control, or Possession | |
| 56 | ||
| 57 (1) A person may own and/or control and/or possess an ORV so long as they adhere | ||
| 58 to all of the owner and/or operator provisions of 21 Del. C. § 6801 through § 6813, | ||
| 59 § 6825, § 6827, and § 6830 in publication at the time of the adoption of this Section, | ||
| 60 and any future revisions by the Delaware General Assembly regarding owner or | ||
| 61 | operator responsibilities; and, | |
| 62 | ||
| 63 (2) A person may own and/or control and/or possess an ORV in the City so long as | ||
| 64 the vehicle is securely locked or otherwise immobilized by a wheel clamp or other | ||
| 65 object, device, method, or mechanism, whether attached to the vehicle or not, that: | ||
| 66 | i. | prevents the vehicle from being freely moved; and |
| 67 | ii. | cannot be removed or deactivated without the assistance of the |
| 68 | vehicle’s owner. | |
| 69 | ||
| 70 | (c) Use, Driving or riding vehicle | |
| 71 | ||
| 72 (1) A person may use and/or drive and/or ride an ORV, on private property only, so | ||
| 73 long as they adhere to all of the owner and/or operator provisions of 21 Del. C. § | ||
| 74 6814(a), § 6821(a), and § 6823 in publication at the time of the adoption of this | ||
| 75 Section, and any future revisions by the Delaware General Assembly regarding | ||
| 76 | owner or operator responsibilities; and, | |
| 77 (2) A person may use and/or drive and/or ride an ORV so long as they adhere to all | ||
| 78 of the owner and/or operator restrictions of 21 Del. C. § 6815 through § 6820, § | ||
| 79 6822 and § 6824 in publication at the time of the adoption of this Section, and any | ||
| 80 future revisions by the Delaware General Assembly regarding owner or operator | ||
| 81 | responsibilities; and, | |
Página 109
Item #23.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-23 – Chapter 106 – Traffic and Vehicles, Sec. 106-14 – Off-road motor vehicle Page 3
82 (3) No person may use and/or drive and/or ride an ORV, on public property 83 anywhere in the City. The provisions of 21 Del. C. § 6814(a) (1) do not apply to 84 the movement of an ORV from one private property to another. The provisions 85 of 21 Del. C. § 6814(a) (2) will apply to any public event with an approved City
| 86 | permit. |
| 87 (4) City license. The owner of a private property must obtain a license from the city | |
|---|---|
| 88 in order to operate, or allow the operation, of ORV’s on said private property | |
| 89 within the corporate limits of the city, which license shall be issued according to | |
| 90 regulations adopted by the city regarding the amount of the fee, display of the | |
| 91 | license, proof of insurance coverage, etc. |
| 92 (5) Muffler. Any ORV operated under the umbrella of a city license must have a | |
| 93 muffler system which limits engine noises to state noise violation standards. | |
| 94 | |
| 95 | (d) Penalties. |
| 96 | |
| 97 (1) Civil Penalty. Any person who violates any part of sub-sections (b) or (c) (4) or (c) | |
| 98 (5) is subject to a civil fine of five hundred dollars ($500) for the first offense and | |
| 99 | one thousand dollars ($1,000) for every additional offense. |
| 100 (2) Civil Penalty. Any person who violates any part of sub-sections (c) (1), (c) (2) or | |
| 101 (c) (3) is subject to a civil fine of two thousand dollars ($2,000) for the first offense | |
| 102 and an additional one thousand dollars ($1,000) for every additional offense | |
| 103 documented prior to the identification of the offender and seizure of the | |
| 104 unlawfully driven ORV. After an adjudication favorable to the City of the first | |
| 105 recorded case, any person who violates any provision of these sub-sections, and | |
| 106 charged a second or subsequent time, is subject to a civil fine of four thousand | |
| 107 dollars ($4,000) for the first offense and an additional two thousand dollars | |
| 108 | ($2,000) for every additional offense |
| 109 | i. Any owner to whom a penalty is issued may, within forty-eight (48) |
| 110 hours of being fined, agree to forfeit the vehicle in lieu of contesting | |
| 111 | the violation and in lieu of any other fines or penalties. |
| 112 | ii. It should be considered a mitigating factor during judicial |
| 113 | proceedings if an individual charged under this Section, and who |
| 114 | has contested such charge, can provide proof that, after the time of |
| 115 | a violation, the vehicle in question has since been properly |
| 116 | registered and an appropriate immobilization device and |
| 117 | transportation mechanism have been secured in order to ensure |
| 118 | future compliance with this Section. |
| 119 | |
| 120 (3) Confiscate. In addition to any civil fines a police officer may issue pursuant to this | |
| 121 section, whenever a police officer has probable cause to believe that an ORV is | |
| 122 being used in violation of this section and either the ORV is not registered or the | |
| 123 ORV does not bear a valid registration decal pursuant to state law, the officer may | |
| 124 confiscate the ORV, either on view or upon execution of a lawfully obtained search | |
Página 110
Item #23.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-23 – Chapter 106 – Traffic and Vehicles, Sec. 106-14 – Off-road motor vehicle Page 4
125 warrant, whereupon the Police Department shall comply with the remaining
| 126 | provisions of this chapter. |
| 127 (4) Disposition. Any confiscated or forfeited ORV will be disposed of by a city- | |
|---|---|
| 128 approved vendor at auction. Revenues returned from the disposed ORVs will be | |
| 129 directed to a special City account and can only be used for purposes related to | |
| 130 victim services. A standing committee that includes the Mayor, the President of | |
| 131 Council, the Emergency Management Coordinator, the Fire Chief and the Police | |
| 132 Chief will inform the City Manager of authorized expenditures from the fund. | |
| 133 | |
| 134 (Code 1981, § 13-15; Ord. of 9-13-1982, § 2; Ord. of 9-22-2003; Ord. No. 2009-09, 6-22-2009) | |
| 135 | |
| 136 | |
| 137 | ADOPTED: * |
| 138 | |
| 139 | |
| 140 | SYNOPSIS |
| 141 This Ordinance amends Chapter 106 of the Dover Code to add to the definition of Off-road vehicle | |
| 142 (ORV), adopting language included in Title 21 of the Delaware State Code pertaining to such | |
| 143 motor-driven vehicles. This ordinance forbids the operation of Off-road vehicles within Dover | |
| 144 with the only exceptions being authorized persons, in complete compliance with owner/operator | |
| 145 provisions of the Delaware Code Title 21, Chapter 68. This ordinance also requires that off-road | |
| 146 vehicles possessed or stored within Dover be locked or otherwise immobilized when not being | |
| 147 used in accordance with state law. The intent of this ordinance is to prevent Off-road vehicles from | |
| 148 being operated on the streets of Dover in violation of State law and jeopardizing public safety. | |
| 149 | |
| 150 | (SPONSORS: ANDERSON, PILLSBURY, AND NEIL) |
| 151 | |
| 152 | |
| 153 | Action History |
| 154 | 06/24/2024 – Scheduled for First Reading – City Council |
| 155 06/11/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and | |
| 156 | Administration Committee |
Página 111
Item #24.
FINAL READING
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-14
| 1 | BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN |
| 2 | COUNCIL MET: |
| 3 | |
|---|---|
| 4 That Chapter 1 – General Provisions, Section. 1-17. – General penalty; separate offenses; unpaid | |
| 5 fines, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, italics and deleting the text indicated | |
| 6 | in red strikeout as follows: |
| 7 | |
| 8 | Sec. 1-17. General penalty; separate offenses; unpaid fines. |
| 9 | |
| 10 Whenever in this Code or in any ordinance of the city, any act or omission is prohibited, | |
| 11 or is made, or declared to be unlawful or a violation, or whenever in said Code or ordinance the | |
| 12 doing of any act is required, or the failure to do any act is declared to be unlawful or a violation, | |
| 13 and no specific penalty is provided therefor, the violation of any such provision of this Code or | |
| 14 any ordinance shall be punishable as provided for in Appendix F–Fees and Fines. Unless | |
| 15 specifically provided otherwise, or the context thereof so dictates, each day any violation of any | |
| 16 provision of this Code or any ordinance shall continue, shall constitute a separate offense. Fines | |
| 17 not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall | |
| 18 | be automatically doubled in amount. |
| 19 | |
| 20 | ADOPTED: * |
| 21 | |
| 22 | |
| 23 | SYNOPSIS |
| 24 The proposed amendment to this chapter removes language that requires the doubling of fines. | |
| 25 | |
| 26 | (SPONSORS: ANDERSON and HUGG) |
| 27 | |
| 28 | |
| 29 | Action History |
| 30 | 06/24/2024 – Scheduled for Final Reading – City Council |
| 31 | 06/10/2024 – First Reading – City Council |
| 32 05/14/2024 – Introduction - Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and Administration | |
| 33 | Committee |
Página 112
Item #25.
FINAL READING
FINAL READING
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-15
| 1 | BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN |
| 2 | COUNCIL MET: |
| 3 | |
|---|---|
| 4 That Chapter 22 - Buildings and Building Regulations, be amended by inserting the text indicated | |
| 5 in bold, blue, italics and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows: | |
| 6 | |
| 7 | ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL |
| 8 | |
| 9 Sec. 22-1. Construction and property maintenance code board of appeals. | |
| 10 | |
| 11 (a) Established; composition; appointment. There shall be a committee to be referred to as the | |
| 12 "construction and property maintenance code board of appeals," consisting of five | |
| 13 members. The council president shall appoint three elected city officials and the mayor | |
| 14 shall appoint one city resident generally selected as a representative of homeowners and | |
| 15 one representative of the local real estate industry association. Members shall serve one- | |
| 16 year terms unless sooner removed. All appointments are subject to confirmation by the city | |
| 17 council at its second regular meeting in May. The construction and property maintenance | |
| 18 | code board of appeals shall elect one of its members as chairperson. |
| 19 | |
| 20 (b) Appeals. Whenever any person is aggrieved by a decision of the building inspector with | |
| 21 respect to the provision of this chapter, it is the right of that person to appeal to the | |
| 22 construction and property maintenance code board of appeals. Such appeal must be filed, | |
| 23 in writing, within 30 days after the determination by the building inspector. | |
| 24 | |
| 25 (c) Notice; hearing. Upon receipt of such an appeal, the construction and property | |
| 26 maintenance code board of appeals shall set a time and place in not less than ten, nor more | |
| 27 than 30 days for the purpose of hearing the appeal. Notice of the time and place of the | |
| 28 hearing of the appeal shall be given to all parties, at which time they may appear and be | |
| 29 heard. The determination by the construction and property maintenance code board of | |
| 30 | appeals shall be final in all cases. |
| 31 | |
32 Sec. 22-2. Housing authority created; purpose. 33 34 Created; purpose. There shall be a housing authority as provided in 31 Del. C. 35 36 Secs. 22-3—22-30. Reserved.
Página 113
Item #25. Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 2
| 37 | ARTICLE II. BUILDING INSPECTOR |
| 38 | |
|---|---|
| 39 | Sec. 22-31. Office created; appointment. |
| 40 There is hereby created the office of building inspector. The building inspector shall be | |
| 41 | selected by the city council during its annual meeting. |
| 42 | |
| 43 | Sec. 22-32. Additional powers and authority. |
| 44 Along with other powers and authority granted to the building inspector in this chapter, | |
| 45 including the codes adopted herein, the building inspector shall have the following powers and | |
| 46 | authority: |
| 47 | |
| 48 (1) Temporary certificates of occupancy. The building inspector shall have authority to | |
| 49 issue temporary certificates of occupancy for buildings and structures which do not | |
| 50 comply with the codes, upon the terms and conditions as set forth in this section. | |
| 51 | |
| 52 (2) Affidavit to complete work. In the event that the owner and builder of a structure are in | |
| 53 agreement that certain items, such as grading, seeding, soil stabilization, and other | |
| 54 similar work, cannot be completed because of the weather or the season, but that these | |
| 55 items can be completed by the builder after a temporary certificate of occupancy is | |
| 56 granted, and the owner takes possession of the property, then the building inspector | |
| 57 may grant a temporary certificate of occupancy, conditioned upon the builder executing | |
| 58 an affidavit agreeing to complete the necessary items specified therein, within a time | |
| 59 period specified therein, with sanctions to be imposed by the building inspector for | |
| 60 noncompliance by the builder, to include, but not to be limited to, revocation of the | |
| 61 temporary certificate of occupancy, refusal to issue to the builder further building | |
| 62 permits on other parcels, and such other administrative action as the building inspector | |
| 63 | may deem appropriate. |
| 64 | |
| 65 (3) Hardship. Upon adequate hardship being shown to the building inspector and upon | |
| 66 agreement of all parties, including the owner or equitable owner and the builder, the | |
| 67 building inspector may issue temporary certificates of occupancy for buildings and | |
| 68 structures where any work of a minor nature is required in the future to comply with | |
| 69 the codes, provided that all parties sign an agreement to this effect and the builder | |
| 70 executes an affidavit, with the conditions and stipulations provided in subsection (2) of | |
| 71 this section, agreeing to the imposition of sanctions for noncompliance to be imposed | |
| 72 | by the building inspector. |
| 73 | |
| 74 (4) Agreements and affidavits for granting certificates. The building inspector shall | |
| 75 prepare uniform agreements and affidavits to be used in granting temporary certificates | |
| 76 | of occupancy as stated herein. |
| 77 | |
| 78 (5) The building inspector or his duly authorized assistant(s) shall have the right to enter | |
| 79 any building or enter upon any land at any reasonable hour, as necessary, in the | |
| 80 | execution of their duties. |
| 81 | |
Página 114
Item #25. Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 3
82 a. The building inspector shall notify the owner and tenant before conducting any
| 83 | inspection. |
| 84 | |
|---|---|
| 85 b. The building inspector or his duly authorized assistants shall display identification | |
| 86 | signed by the city manager upon commencing an inspection. |
| 87 | |
| 88 c. Inspections shall be commenced in the presence of the owner, or his representative | |
| 89 | or tenant. |
| 90 | |
| 91 | Secs. 22-33—22-60. Reserved. |
| 92 | |
| 93 | |
| 94 | ARTICLE III. BUILDING CODE |
| 95 | |
| 96 | |
| 97 | Sec. 22-61. Adopted. |
| 98 (a) International Building Code adopted. Certain documents, three copies of which are on file | |
| 99 in the lLicensing and pPermitting oOffice of the city, being marked and designated as "The | |
| 100 International Building Code, 2009 Edition" as published by the International Code Council | |
| 101 be and is hereby adopted as the Building Code of the City of Dover in the State of | |
| 102 Delaware; for the control of buildings and structures as herein provided; and each and all | |
| 103 of the regulations, provisions, penalties, conditions and terms of said International Building | |
| 104 Code, are hereby referred to, adopted and made a part hereof as if fully set out in this | |
| 105 section, with the additions, insertions, deletions and changes as follows: | |
| 106 | |
| 107 Section 101.1 Title. Insert "City of Dover, DE" in place of "[NAME OF JURISDICTION]" | |
| 108 | |
| 109 | 105.2 Work exempt from permit. |
| 110 | |
| 111 | Building: |
| 112 1. One-story detached accessory structures used as tool and storage sheds, | |
| 113 | playhouses, and similar uses, provided that the floor area does not |
| 114 | exceed 120 square feet. |
| 115 | 2. Oil derricks. |
| 116 | 3. Sidewalks and driveways not more than 30 inches (762 mm) above |
| 117 | adjacent grade and not over any basement or story below. |
| 118 4. Painting, papering, tiling, carpeting, cabinets, countertops, and similar | |
| 119 | finish work. |
| 120 5. Temporary motion picture, television and theater stage sets and scenery. | |
| 121 | 6. Prefabricated swimming pools accessory to a Group R-3 occupancy |
| 122 | provided that the swimming pools are not designed to retain a depth of |
| 123 | 24" (610 mm) or more, and do not exceed 5,000 gallons (18925L) and |
| 124 | installed entirely above ground. |
Página 115
Item #25. Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 4
125 7. Shade cloth structures constructed for nursery or agricultural purposes,
| 126 | not including service systems. |
| 127 | 8. Swings and other playground equipment accessory to a one or two- |
| 128 | family dwelling. Window awnings supported by an exterior wall which |
| 129 | do not project more than 54 inches (1372 mm) from the exterior wall |
| 130 | and do not require additional support of Group R-3 and U Occupancies. |
| 131 9. Non-fixed and movable fixtures, cases, racks, counters, and partitions | |
|---|---|
| 132 | not over 5 feet 9 inches (1753 mm) in height. |
| 133 | |
| 134 Section 105.5. Expiration. Insert the following text following the word "demonstrated" at the end | |
| 135 of the section: "and does not exceed the 3-year time limit as stated in 105.5.2."; and insert the | |
| 136 | following subsections: |
| 137 | |
| 138 105.5.1. Time limitation of permit. A permit for any activity for which a permit is required | |
| 139 shall be valid for 180 days from the date of issuance. One 180-day extension may be granted | |
| 140 without additional charge to the permit holder. Additional 180-day extensions may be granted | |
| 141 with payment of a renewal fee as specified in Appendix F: Fees and Fines. | |
| 142 | |
| 143 105.5.2. Completion of construction. All construction for which a building permit is required | |
| 144 must be completed and pass final inspection within three (3) years after issuance of the | |
| 145 building permit. If not completed within three (3) years, a new building permit must be | |
| 146 obtained and any associated fees paid incurred by the previous submission. | |
| 147 | |
| 148 | SECTION 107 SUBMITTAL DOCUMENTS |
| 149 | |
| 150 107.1 Submittal documents. Insert: "Construction documents, statement of special | |
| 151 inspections, structural observation programs and other data, for new construction, alterations, | |
| 152 repairs, expansion, additions or modifications of buildings or structures, which involve the practice | |
| 153 of architecture or engineering, as defined by the professional registration laws of the State of | |
| 154 Delaware shall be prepared by a registered design professional consistent with the professional | |
| 155 registration laws of the State of Delaware. Construction documents shall include the name, address | |
| 156 and license or registration number of the registered design professional and shall be signed, sealed | |
| 157 and dated by the registered design professional in accordance with the professional registration or | |
| 158 licensing laws, statutes, regulations or administration provisions of the State of Delaware." in place | |
| 159 of "Submittal documents consisting of construction documents, statement of special inspections, | |
| 160 geotechnical report and other data shall be submitted in two or more sets with each permit | |
| 161 application. The construction documents shall be prepared by a registered design professional | |
| 162 where required by the statues of the jurisdiction in which the project is to be constructed." | |
| 163 | |
Página 116
Item #25. Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 5
164 Section 108.3. 109.3 Insert: "see Section 22-65 Fees for permits" in place of "in accordance 165 with the schedule as established by the applicable governing authority". New construction 166 valuation will be confirmed using the most current ICC valuation chart information unless 167 otherwise approved by the authority having jurisdiction. 168 169 SECTION 113 BOARD OF APPEALS. See Chapter 22—Buildings and Building Regulations, 170 Article I—In General, Sec. 22-1 Construction and property maintenance code board of appeals. 171 172 Section 114.4 Violation Penalties. Any person who violates a provision of this code or fails 173 to comply with any of the requirements thereof or who erects, constructs, places, alters, repairs, a 174 building or structure in violation of the approved construction documents or directive of the 175 building inspector, or of a permit or certificate issued under the provisions of this code shall be 176 charged with a violation of this code and be guilty of a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine as 177 provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines, or by imprisonment thirty (30) days, or both such 178 fine and imprisonment. Each day that a violation continues shall be deemed a separate offense. 179 180 Section 114.3 Unlawful continuance. Insert: "Any person who shall continue any work after 181 having been served with a stop work order, except such work as that person is directed to perform 182 to remove a violation or unsafe condition, shall be charged with a violation of this section and shall 183 be fined as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. Repeat offenders shall not receive 184 warnings and shall instead be subject to progressively increasing fines as provided for in Appendix 185 F—Fees and Fines. Each day that a violation continues shall be deemed a separate offense." in 186 place of: "Any person who shall continue any work after having been served with a stop work 187 order, except such work as that person is directed to perform a violation or unsafe condition, shall 188 be subject to penalties as prescribed by law." 189 190 Section 1612.3. Flood Insurance Study for the City of Dover, dated July 7, 2014, or as 191 subsequently amended or revised. 192 193 Section 1612.4.1 Elevation requirements. The minimum elevation requirements shall be as 194 specified in ASCE 24 or the base flood elevation plus 18 inches, whichever is higher. 195 196 Section 3410.2 Applicability. Insert "April 4, 1984" in place of [DATE TO BE INSERTED 197 BY THE JURISDICTION. NOTE: IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT THIS DATE COINCIDE 198 WITH THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF BUILDING CODES WITHIN THE JURISDICTION]. 199 200 (b) International Residential Code Adopted. That certain document, three copies of which are 201 on file in the lLicensing and pPermitting oOffice in the city, being marked and designated 202 as the International Residential Code 2009 edition, as published by the International Code 203 Council, be and is hereby adopted as the code of the city for regulating the design,
Página 117
Item #25. Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 6
204 construction, quality of materials, erection, installation, alteration, repair, location, 205 relocation, replacement, addition to, use or maintenance of building, mechanical, plumbing 206 and electrical systems in the city and providing for the issuance of permits and collection 207 of fees therefor; and each and all of the regulations, provisions, conditions and terms of 208 such International Residential Code, as referenced in the building code adopted in 209 subsection (a), published by the International Code Council, on file in the office of the city 210 are hereby referred to, adopted and made a part hereof as if fully set out in this section. The 211 following sections of the International Residential Code are hereby revised: 212 213 Section 101.1 Title. Insert "City of Dover, DE" in place of "[NAME OF JURISDICTION]" 214 215 Section R105.2. Work exempt from permit, Building - 1. Insert "120" in place of "200". Delete 216 numbers 2 through 5 in their entirety. Replace number 7 with the following: "Prefabricated 217 swimming pools accessory to a Group R-3 occupancy provided that the swimming pools are not 218 designed to retain a depth of 24" (610 mm) or more, and do not exceed 5,000 gallons (18925L) 219 and installed entirely above ground. 220 221 SECTION R106 CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS 222 223 R106.1 Submittal documents. Insert: "Construction documents, statement of special 224 inspections, structural observation programs and other data, for new construction, alterations, 225 repairs, expansion, additions or modifications of buildings or structures, shall be submitted in 2 226 sets and as defined by the professional registration laws of the State of Delaware and be prepared 227 by a registered design professional consistent with the professional registration laws of the State 228 of Delaware. Construction documents shall include the name, address and license or registration 229 number of the registered design professional and shall be signed, sealed and dated by the registered 230 design professional in accordance with the professional registration or licensing laws, statutes, 231 regulations or administration provisions of the State of Delaware." in place of "shall be prepared 232 by a registered design professional where required by the statues of the jurisdiction in which the 233 project is to be constructed". Where special conditions exist, the building official is authorized to 234 require additional construction documents as described here. 235 236 Exception: The building official is authorized to waive the submission of construction 237 documents and other data not required to be prepared by a registered design professional if it is 238 found that the nature of the work applied for is such that review of construction documents is not 239 necessary to obtain compliance with this code. 240 241 SECTION R108 FEES 242
Página 118
Item #25. Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 7
243 R108.2 Schedule of permit fees. Insert "see Section 22-65 Fees for permits " in place of "in 244 accordance with the schedule as established by the applicable governing authority". 245
| 246 | SECTION R112 BOARD OF APPEALS See Chapter 22 - Buildings and Building | |||||||||
| 247 Regulations, Article I - In General, Sec. 22-1 Construction and property maintenance code | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 248 | board of appeals. | |||||||||
| 249 | ||||||||||
| 250 | SECTION R113 VIOLATIONS | |||||||||
| 251 | ||||||||||
| 252 Section 113.4 Violation Penalties. Insert "See Section 22-61 (a) Section 113.4 Violation | ||||||||||
| 253 Penalties" in place of "Any person who violates a provision of this code or fails to comply with | ||||||||||
| 254 any of the requirements thereof or who erects, constructs, places, alters, repairs, a building or | ||||||||||
| 255 structure in violation of the approved construction documents or directive of the building inspector, | ||||||||||
| 256 or of a permit or certificate issued under the provisions of this code, shall be subject to penalties | ||||||||||
| 257 | as prescribed by law." | |||||||||
| 258 | ||||||||||
| 259 | SECTION R114 STOP WORK ORDER | |||||||||
| 260 | ||||||||||
| 261 Section R114.2 Unlawful continuance. Insert: "See Section 22-61 (a) International Building | ||||||||||
| 262 Code, Section 114.3 Unlawful continuance" in place of "Any person who shall continue any work | ||||||||||
| 263 after having been served with a stop work order, except such work as that person is directed to | ||||||||||
| 264 perform a violation or unsafe condition, shall be subject to penalties as prescribed by law." | ||||||||||
| 265 | TABLE R301.2(1) CLIMATIC AND GEOGRAPHIC DESIGN CRITERIA | |||||||||
| Ground Wind Design | Seismic | Subject to Damage From | Winter | Ice | Flood | Air | Mean | |||
| Snow | Speed Topo- | Design | Weatheringa Frost | Termitec | Desig | Barrier | Hazards | Free | Annual | |
| d | f | g | ||||||||
| Load | graphic Category | line | n | Under- | zing | Temperatu | ||||
| (mph) effects k | ||||||||||
| Depth | Tempe | layment | Inde | j | ||||||
| b | Requiredh | xi | ||||||||
| 25 | 95 | NO | A | Severe | 24" | Moderate 14° | NO | Adopted | 450 | 55° |
| gust | To | in | ||||||||
| 77 | Heavy | Chapter | ||||||||
| fastest | 50 of the | |||||||||
| Code of | ||||||||||
| the City | ||||||||||
| of Dover | ||||||||||
| 266 Table R301.2(1), footnote (g): September 16, 1982, Flood Insurance Study for Kent County | ||||||||||
| 267 and Incorporated Areas, dated July 7, 2014, or as subsequently amended or revised. | ||||||||||
| 268 | ||||||||||
| 269 Table R301.5 MINIMUM UNIFORMLY DISTRIBUTED LIVE LOADS. Insert the following | ||||||||||
| 270 at the end of footnote "c": Calculations demonstrating compliance with the minimum live load | ||||||||||
Página 119
Item #25. Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 8
271 shall be provided by a registered design professional for stairs and fire escapes that do not have 272 additional "stringer" or "carriage" support located and equally distributed in the middle section of
| 273 | the stair width. |
| 274 | |
|---|---|
| 275 SECTION R313 AUTOMATIC FIRE SPRINKLER SYSTEMS—Delete this section in its | |
| 276 | entirety. |
| 277 | |
| 278 | R322.2.1 Elevation requirements. |
| 279 1. Buildings and structures in flood hazard areas not designated as Coastal A Zones shall | |
| 280 have the lowest floors elevated to or above the base flood elevation plus 18 inches or | |
| 281 | the design flood elevation, whichever is higher. |
| 282 2. Buildings and structures in flood hazard areas designated as Coastal A Zones shall have | |
| 283 the lowest floors elevated to or above the base flood elevation plus 1 foot (305 mm), or | |
| 284 | to the design flood elevation, whichever is higher. |
| 285 3. In areas of shallow flooding (AO Zones), buildings and structures shall have the lowest | |
| 286 floor (including basement) elevated at least as high above the highest adjacent grade as | |
| 287 the depth number specified in feet on the FIRM plus 18 inches or at least 3.5 feet if a | |
| 288 | depth number is not specified. |
| 289 4. Basement floors that are below grade on all sides shall be elevated to or above the base | |
| 290 flood elevation plus 18 inches or the design flood elevation, whichever is higher. | |
| 291 | |
| 292 Exception: Enclosed areas below the design flood elevation, including basements whose | |
| 293 floors are not below grade on all sides, shall meet the requirements of Section R322.2.2. | |
| 294 | |
| 295 | CHAPTER 4 FOUNDATIONS |
| 296 | |
| 297 | SECTION R403 FOOTINGS |
| 298 | |
| 299 R403.1.1 Minimum size. Insert "The minimum thickness of a footing shall be the nominal | |
| 300 width of the wall but not less than 8 inches. The nominal width of the footings shall be twice the | |
| 301 nominal thickness of the wall. Two story sections of a building shall have a minimum footing | |
| 302 width of 24 inches and a minimum footing depth of 10 inches." in place of " Minimum sizes for | |
| 303 concrete and masonry footings shall be as set forth in Table R403.1 and Figure R403.1(1). The | |
| 304 footing width, W, shall be based on the load-bearing value of the soil in accordance with Table | |
| 305 401.4.1. Spread footings shall be at least 6 inches in thickness. Footing projections, P, shall be at | |
| 306 least 2 inches and shall not exceed the thickness of the footing." Insert ", but in all cases shall be a | |
| 307 minimum of 24 inches × 24 inches × 12 inches deep." at the end of the following sentence: "The | |
| 308 size of footings supporting piers and columns shall be based on the tributary load and allowable | |
| 309 | soil pressure in accordance with Table 401.4.1." |
Página 120
Item #25. Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 9
310 R403.1.2 Continuous footings in Seismic Design Categories D1 and D2. Delete in its entirety 311 and Insert: R403.1.2 Footing reinforcement. Footings shall be reinforced with a minimum of two 312 #4 rebar wired together with a minimum 15" overlap; pier footings with a minimum of two #4 313 rebar wired together in two directions, and column footings with three #4 rebar wired together in 314 two directions. 315 316 R403.1.3 Seismic reinforcing. Delete in its entirety. 317 318 R403.1.4 Minimum Depth. Insert "24" in place of "12". 319 320 Amend R403.1.4.1 Frost protection—Exceptions to read: 321 1. Frost Protection of freestanding residential accessory/utility structures with an area of 322 240 square feet or less and an eave height of 10 feet or less, except for pole buildings 323 and garages, shall not be required to be frost protected. Freestanding accessory 324 structures (sheds) between 120 sf and 240 sf shall be secured with tie-downs or 325 equivalent manufactured home fastening devices on each corner. Structures 20 feet or 326 more in length shall have additional anchors attached in the center of each side unless 327 frost protection applies as stated herein. All accessory/utility structures greater than 240 328 square feet, all pole buildings and all garages shall have frost protection (footings). 329 2. Decks not supported by a dwelling shall also be provided with footings that extend 330 below the frost line. Single story supported in part by a dwelling and with 4" × 4" posts 331 shall have footings that are a minimum of 8 inches in diameter; with 6" × 6" posts a 332 minimum of 12" diameter is required; the bottom of all such footings shall be a 333 minimum of 24" below finished grade and be at least 6" deep. 334 335 Footings shall not bear on frozen soil unless such frozen condition is of a permanent character. 336 337 (c) The ICC Performance Code for Buildings and Facilities. That certain documents, three 338 copies of which are on file in the lLicensing and pPermitting oOffice of the city, being 339 marked and designated as "The ICC Performance Code for Buildings and Facilities 2009 340 Edition" as published by the International Code Council be and is hereby adopted as the 341 Performance Code of the City of Dover in the State of Delaware for regulating and 342 governing the performance-based design, construction, quality of materials, erection, 343 installation, alteration, repair, location, relocation, replacement, addition to, use or 344 maintenance of building and/or fire protection systems in the city. 345 346 (d) The International Existing Building Code. That certain documents, three copies of which 347 are on file in the lLicensing and pPermitting oOffice of the city, being marked and 348 designated as "The International Existing Building Code 2009 Edition" as published by the 349 International Code Council be and is hereby adopted as the Existing Building Code of the
Página 121
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 10 Item #25.
350 City of Dover in the State of Delaware for regulating and governing the repair, alteration, 351 change of occupancy, addition and relocation of existing buildings, including historic
| 352 | buildings, as herein provided. |
| 353 | |
|---|---|
| 354 (e) The International Energy Conservation Code. That certain documents, three copies of | |
| 355 which are on file in the lLicensing and pPermitting oOffice of the city, being marked and | |
| 356 designated as "The International Energy Conservation Code 2009 Edition" as published by | |
| 357 the International Code Council be and is hereby adopted as the Energy Conservation Code | |
| 358 of the City of Dover in the State of Delaware for regulating and governing energy efficient | |
| 359 building envelopes and installation of energy-efficient mechanical, lighting and power | |
| 360 | systems as herein provided. |
| 361 | |
| 362 | Sec. 22-62. Definitions. |
| 363 (a) Whenever the term "municipality" or "city" is used in the publications adopted by reference | |
| 364 in this article, it shall be construed to mean the City of Dover, Delaware. | |
| 365 (b) Whenever the term "corporation council" or "city attorney" is used in the publications | |
| 366 adopted by reference in this article, it shall be construed to mean the city solicitor. | |
| 367 (c) Whenever in the publications adopted by reference in this article a term is used which is | |
| 368 also defined in the city's zoning ordinance as set forth in appendix B to this Code, such | |
| 369 | term shall have the meaning provided in such appendix B. |
| 370 | |
| 371 | Sec. 22-63. Conflicting provisions. |
| 372 In the event of any conflict between the provisions of the publications adopted by reference | |
| 373 in this article and applicable provisions of state law, this Code or any other ordinance, rule or | |
| 374 regulation, the provisions of state law, this Code, or such other ordinance, rule or regulation shall | |
| 375 | prevail and be controlling. |
| 376 | |
| 377 | Sec. 22-64. Enforcement. |
| 378 | The building inspector shall enforce the provisions of this article. |
| 379 | |
| 380 | Sec. 22-65. Permit fees. |
| 381 (a) [Fees.] Before any permit shall be issued for buildings, fences, signs, swimming pools, | |
| 382 demolitions, moving, or construction plan reviews, a fee shall be paid unto the city as | |
| 383 | provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. |
| 384 | |
| 385 (b) Reinspection’s. There will be no charge for the first reinspection of a permit. For | |
| 386 subsequent reinspection’s the applicant shall pay a fee as provided for in Appendix F. | |
| 387 | |
Página 122
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 11 Item #25.
388 (c) Doubling fees. Fees for building, fence, sign, swimming pool, demolition, or moving 389 permits shall double in the event that a permit is applied for after construction has 390 commenced without the permission of the building inspector. The building inspector may 391 waive the doubling of fees in cases where the building permit applicant is not a professional 392 contractor, and the work is not being done by a professional contractor. 393 (d) Fines. A fine shall be issued when any code official discovers any project has started 394 or has been completed without an approved permit. 395 396 Secs. 22-66—22-100. Reserved. 397 398 ARTICLE IV. ELECTRICAL INSTALLATIONS 399 400 Sec. 22-101. Electrical code adopted. 401 (a) Copies filed; effect. There is hereby adopted by reference, for the purpose of establishing 402 rules and regulations for the installation, renewal, extension, and reception of electric 403 wiring and electric apparatus in existing buildings, structures, or outdoor electrical displays 404 or signs, that certain code known as the "National Electrical Code," as recommended by 405 the National Fire Protection Association, and the same is hereby adopted and incorporated 406 as fully as if set out at length herein, and shall be controlling for all electrical wiring and 407 apparatus in buildings, structures, or outdoor electrical displays, or signs within the city. 408 409 (b) Violations. It shall be unlawful for any person to violate any of the provisions of the code 410 adopted in subsection (a) of this section. 411 412 Sec. 22-102. Enforcement and inspections generally. 413 The publication adopted by reference in this article shall be enforced by the office of the 414 building inspector. The building inspector shall, upon the installation, renewal, extension, and 415 reception of any electric wiring and electric apparatus pursuant to this article, cause an inspection 416 or inspections to be made by himself or his duly authorized agents, to determine that the electrical 417 work conforms with the provisions of this article of the city and the statutes of the state. 418 419 Sec. 22-103. Approved materials, fittings, and devices. 420 Only the materials, fittings, and devices enumerated in the listings of Underwriters' 421 Laboratories, Inc., or approved by the inspection authority, as revised from time to time, shall be 422 used in the electrical work regulated by this article. 423 424 Sec. 22-104. Emergency shutoff switch required for certain appliances.
Página 123
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 12 Item #25.
425 Whenever an application for inspection is required under the terms of this article for 426 electrical wiring and apparatus to be done in connection with a gas or oil burner installation in any 427 existing building or structure or in the construction, reconstruction, alteration, or repair of 428 buildings or structures, there shall be installed an emergency shutoff switch, with a red plate 429 thereon marked "oil burner" or "gas burner," as the case may be, at the entrance to the basement
| 430 | or heating room. |
| 431 | |
|---|---|
| 432 | Sec. 22-105. Application for inspection. |
| 433 (a) Required. No person shall install, receive, renew, or extend electrical wires or conductors | |
| 434 to be used for the transmission of electric current for electric light, heat, or power purposes | |
| 435 in existing buildings, structures, or outdoor electrical displays or signs, or in the | |
| 436 construction, reconstruction, alteration or repair of buildings, structures or outdoor | |
| 437 electrical displays or signs, without first applying for an application for inspection to do so | |
| 438 | pursuant to the provisions of this article. |
| 439 | |
| 440 (b) Addressee. All such applications for inspection shall be made to the building inspector or, | |
| 441 in lieu thereof, to the city's authorized inspection agency, hereinafter referred to as that | |
| 442 agency specializing in such inspections, as determined, and approved by the building | |
| 443 | inspector. |
| 444 | |
| 445 (c) Form; contents. Such application form shall contain questions designed to elicit | |
| 446 information to determine whether or not said proposed electrical wiring and electrical | |
| 447 apparatus complies with all ordinances of the city or laws of the state. | |
| 448 | |
| 449 (d) Fee. Each such application form shall be accompanied by a fee as prescribed by this article. | |
| 450 | |
| 451 (e) Proof to building inspector. The city's authorized inspection agency shall furnish to such | |
| 452 building inspector proof, in writing, that an application for inspection of the proposed | |
| 453 electrical wiring and electrical apparatus has been made to such agency to determine that | |
| 454 the electrical work conforms with the provisions of this article. The payment of all | |
| 455 inspection fees and charges of such agency shall be borne by the applicant. | |
| 456 | |
| 457 (f) Inspection of premises. Each applicant for inspection shall cause the premises covered by | |
| 458 the application to be open for inspection to the building inspector and his agents and the | |
| 459 representative or representatives of the city's authorized inspection agency at all reasonable | |
| 460 | times. |
| 461 | |
| 462 (g) Certificate of approval. Upon determination by the building inspector or any authorized | |
| 463 inspection organization that the proposed electrical wiring and electrical apparatus comply | |
| 464 with the National Electrical Code adopted in this article and the provisions of this article | |
Página 124
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 13 Item #25.
465 and the provisions of the city ordinances and the laws of the state, a certificate of approval 466 shall be issued forthwith. 467 468 (h) Expiration. All applications for inspections shall expire at the expiration of one year from 469 the date of issuance by the building inspector or the city's authorized inspection agency. 470 471 (i) False information. Any person making any false answer to any of the questions or items 472 set forth in such application form shall forthwith forfeit and surrender any application 473 issued pursuant thereto. 474 475 Sec. 22-106. Inspection of work under application. 476 (a) Purpose; concealed wiring. All inspections shall be made to ensure that the proposed 477 electrical work complies with the provisions of this article. No electric wiring shall be 478 concealed unless inspected and approved by the building inspector or his agents and the 479 representative of the city's authorized inspection agency, but such inspection or 480 reinspection shall be made within a reasonable time after notice of the completion of the 481 electrical work sought to be inspected for approval. A duplicate record of each written 482 approval made by the city's authorized inspection agency shall be filed with the building 483 inspector. 484 485 (b) Decisions by building inspector. All decisions made to determine whether or not the 486 proposed electrical work complies with the provisions of the National Electrical Code shall 487 be made by the building inspector. 488 489 (c) Stop work orders. The building inspector shall have the power to stop electrical work and 490 order the removal thereof when he determines that such work is being installed not in 491 conformity with all ordinances and the laws of the state. 492 493 (d) Waiver of inspection. The building inspector may waive his inspection of all or that portion 494 of the proposed electrical work for which he shall have received a duplicate record of 495 approval by the city's authorized inspection agency that it complies with the provisions of 496 this article. The building inspector shall be informed of all violations not corrected within 497 15 days of notification to the contractor by the city's authorized inspection agency. 498 499 Sec. 22-107. Inspection of existing wiring and apparatus. 500 (a) Required. In order to safeguard persons and property against the hazards and perils incident 501 to defective electric wiring and apparatus that are or may now be in existence within the 502 city, the building inspector is hereby given the duty to inspect with his agents and the 503 representative of the city's authorized inspection agency, when requested by proper 504 authority, or when public interest so requires, any premises within the city at reasonable
Página 125
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 14 Item #25.
505 times to ensure that the existing electric wiring system and apparatus is are not defective
| 506 | and unsafe. |
| 507 | |
|---|---|
| 508 (b) Decisions by building inspector. All decisions that the existing electric wiring system and | |
| 509 apparatus is defective shall be made by the building inspector, in writing, on notice to the | |
| 510 owner of the premises served forthwith personally or by regular mail addressed to the | |
| 511 address as shown on the latest tax records, with reasons for his decision. | |
| 512 | |
| 513 (c) Corrections. Upon the building inspector's decision that the existing electric wiring system | |
| 514 is defective and unsafe as aforesaid, the system or portions of the system which are | |
| 515 defective and unsafe shall be discontinued until it is corrected and made to comply with | |
| 516 | the provisions of this article. |
| 517 | |
| 518 | Sec. 22-108. Permit exemptions. |
| 519 (a) Enumerated. No permit shall be required under this article for the following electrical | |
| 520 | work: |
| 521 | |
| 522 (1) Minor repairs. Any minor repair work, such as the replacement of lamps and fuses; | |
| 523 | |
| 524 (2) Utility companies. Any electric light or power company, electric railway company, | |
| 525 steam railway company, diesel railway company, or telegraph or telephone company, | |
| 526 and any person performing the electrical work of any such company, when such work | |
| 527 is a part of the plant, or services used by the company in rendering its authorized service | |
| 528 | to the public; |
| 529 | |
| 530 (3) Employees on the premises. Any person employed by any other person to repair and | |
| 531 maintain or to supervise the repair and maintenance of any electrical equipment on the | |
| 532 | premises and buildings of the employer; |
| 533 | |
| 534 (4) Home installations. Any person who installs his own electrical work, service, or | |
| 535 equipment in or about his own home and not for sale, except that such person shall be | |
| 536 required to file an application for inspection with the proper electrical inspection | |
| 537 | authority; |
| 538 | |
| 539 (5) Supervised employees. Any employee of any person engaged in the performance of | |
| 540 electrical work while under the supervision of any master electrician, or general master | |
| 541 | electrician limited; |
| 542 | |
Página 126
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 15 Item #25.
543 (6) Agricultural property. Property used exclusively for agricultural purposes, except for 544 the necessity to file for an application for an inspection certificate with the authorized 545 inspection authority where new installations are involved; 546 547 (7) Electrical engineers. Any manufacturing or industrial establishment retaining in its 548 own employment a professional electrical engineer with at least ten years experience 549 in planning and design. Such engineer may inspect the plant's additional electrical 550 installations if the said industrial plant files with the state board of electrical examiners 551 and the building inspector the name of the electrical engineer that would be responsible 552 for such electrical inspection and files with the board of electrical examiners and the 553 building inspector a letter stating that all additional electrical installations meet the 554 minimum standards of the National Electrical Code once a year. 555 556 (b) Insertion of devices, appliances. Nothing in this article shall be construed so as to forbid 557 the insertion in electrical circuits by unlicensed persons of devices or appliances which are 558 properly designed for such insertion and for which proper wiring and insertion devices are 559 installed. 560 561 (c) Heating, etc. Nothing in this article shall be so construed as to restrict anyone from 562 servicing equipment in the fields of heating, air conditioning, refrigeration, or appliances. 563 564 Sec. 22-109. Permit fees. 565 (a) No fee. There shall be no fee for permits or renewals thereof by the building inspector as 566 may be required by this article. 567 568 (b) Applications for inspections. Fees for applications for inspections issued by the city's 569 authorized inspection agency, as may be required of this article, shall be as determined by 570 said agency and approved by the building inspector. 571 572 Sec. 22-110. Violations. 573 Any person who shall violate any of the provisions of this article or fail to comply 574 therewith, or who shall violate or fail to comply with any order made thereunder, or who shall do 575 or cause to be done electrical work in violation of any detailed statement, or specifications or plans 576 submitted and approved hereunder, or any certificate or permit issued hereunder, and from which 577 no appeal has been taken, or who shall fail to comply with such an order as affirmed or modified 578 by the building inspector within the time fixed therein, shall, severally for each and every such 579 violation and noncompliance respectively, be punished as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and 580 Fines. The imposition of one penalty for any violation shall not excuse the violation or permit it to 581 continue, and all such persons shall be required to correct or remedy such violations or defects 582 within a reasonable time.
Página 127
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 16 Item #25.
| 583 | Sec. 22-111. Modifications. |
| 584 The building inspector shall have the power to modify any of the provisions of this article, | |
|---|---|
| 585 upon application, in writing, by the owner of a premises or his agent, when there are practical | |
| 586 difficulties in the way of carrying out the strict letter of this article, provided that the spirit of this | |
| 587 article shall be observed, public safety secured, and substantial justice done. | |
| 588 | |
| 589 | Sec. 22-112. Appeals. |
| 590 (a) Demand for hearing. Every applicant and owner of a premises and other parties in interest | |
| 591 shall have the right to demand, in writing, a hearing before the board of adjustment to | |
| 592 contest any decision or order made by the building inspector pursuant to this article. Such | |
| 593 demand for a hearing shall be signed by the contesting party, stating what portions of the | |
| 594 building inspector's decision or orders are contested and his interest in the premises. | |
| 595 | |
| 596 (b) Time and place for hearing; notice. The board of adjustment shall fix a time and place for | |
| 597 the hearing, not less than ten days, nor more than 30 days after receiving such demand for | |
| 598 a hearing and cause a notice of the hearing to be served personally or by regular mail on | |
| 599 | the contestant, owner of the premises and other parties in interest. |
| 600 | |
| 601 (c) Appearances; evidence. The contestant, owner of the premises, and other parties in interest | |
| 602 shall have the right to appear in person, or otherwise, and give testimony at the hearing, | |
| 603 and the rules of evidence prevailing in the courts shall not be controlling. | |
| 604 | |
| 605 (d) Decision; service on parties in interest. The board of adjustment, within a reasonable time | |
| 606 after such a hearing, shall make its decision, and the city clerk shall serve a copy of the | |
| 607 decision personally or by regular mail on the contestant, owner of the premises, and other | |
| 608 | parties in interest. |
| 609 | |
| 610 | Sec. 22-113. Restriction on city's liability and inspections. |
| 611 The city shall not incur liability, with regard to the installation, wiring, or appliances used, | |
| 612 from any violation of this article or from any accident resulting from the installation, and shall not | |
| 613 be obliged to inspect any installation before or after electricity is introduced. | |
| 614 | |
| 615 | Secs. 22-114—22-140. Reserved. |
| 616 | |
| 617 | ARTICLE V. MECHANICAL CODE |
| 618 | |
| 619 | Sec. 22-141. Adopted. |
Página 128
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 17 Item #25.
620 (a) Certain documents, three copies of which are on file in the lLicensing and pPermitting 621 oOffice of the city, being marked and designated as the International Mechanical Code 622 2009 Edition, including appendix chapter "A", as referenced in the building code adopted 623 in 22-61(a), published by the International Code Council, be and is hereby adopted as the 624 code of the city for regulating the design, construction, quality of materials, erection, 625 installation, alteration, repair, location, relocation, replacement, addition to, use or 626 maintenance of mechanical systems in the city and providing for the issuance of permits 627 and collection of fees therefore; and each and all of the regulations, provisions, conditions, 628 and terms of such International Mechanical Code, as referenced in the building code 629 adopted in section 22-61(a), published by the International Code Council, on file in the 630 office of the city are hereby referred to, adopted and made a part hereof as if fully set out 631 in this section. The following sections of the International Mechanical Code are hereby
| 632 | revised: |
| 633 | |
|---|---|
| 634 Section 101.1 Title. Insert "City of Dover, DE" in place of "[NAME OF JURISDICTION]" | |
| 635 | |
| 636 106.5 Fee Schedule. Insert "See DCO Section 22-145 Heating, air conditioning, and heat pump | |
| 637 permit fees" in place of "The fees for all mechanical work shall be as indicated in the following | |
| 638 | schedule:" |
| 639 | |
| 640 | In place of: |
| 641 | |
| 642 | Section 106.5.3 Fee refunds. Delete in its entirety. |
| 643 | |
| 644 | SECTION 108 VIOLATIONS |
| 645 | |
| 646 Section 108.4 Violation Penalties. Insert "See Section 22-61(a) International Building Code | |
| 647 Section 113.4, Violation Penalties" in place of "Any person who shall violate a provision of this | |
| 648 code or shall fail to comply with any of the requirements thereof or who shall erect, install, alters, | |
| 649 or repair, a plumbing work in violation of the approved construction documents or directive of the | |
| 650 code official, or of a permit or certificate issued under the provisions of this code, shall be guilty | |
| 651 of a [SPECIFY OFFENSE], punishable by a fine of not more than [AMOUNT], or by | |
| 652 imprisonment not exceeding thirty (30) days, or both such fine and imprisonment. Each day that a | |
| 653 violation continues after due notice has been served shall be deemed a separate offense." | |
| 654 | |
| 655 Section 108.5 Stop work orders. Insert "See 22-61(a)International Building Code, Section 114.3 | |
| 656 Unlawful continuance" in place of "Upon notice from the code official that mechanical work is | |
| 657 being done contrary to the provisions of this code or in a dangerous and unsafe manner such work | |
| 658 shall immediately cease. Such notice shall be in writing and shall be given to the owner of the | |
| 659 property, or to the owner's agent, or to the person doing the work. The notice shall state the | |
Página 129
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 18 Item #25.
660 conditions under which work is authorized to resume. Where an emergency exists, the code official 661 shall not be required to give a written notice prior to stopping work. Any person who shall continue 662 any work in or about the structure after having been served with a stop work order, except such 663 work as that person is directed to remove a violation or unsafe condition, shall be charged with a 664 violation of this section and shall be liable to a fine of not less than [AMOUNT] dollars or more
| 665 | than [AMOUNT] dollars" |
| 666 | |
|---|---|
| 667 | SECTION 109 MEANS OF APPEAL. Delete section in its entirety. |
| 668 | |
| 669 (b) If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase of this section is, for any reason, held | |
| 670 to be unconstitutional, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions | |
| 671 of this section. The city council hereby declares that it would have passed the ordinance | |
| 672 from which this section derives, and each section, subsection, clause, or phrase thereof, | |
| 673 irrespective of the fact that anyone (1) or more sections, subsections, sentences, clauses, | |
| 674 | and phrases be declared unconstitutional. |
| 675 | |
| 676 | Sec. 22-142. Definitions. |
| 677 (a) Whenever the word "municipality" or the word "city" is used in the publication adopted by | |
| 678 this article, it shall be construed to mean the City of Dover, Delaware. | |
| 679 | |
| 680 (b) Whenever the term "corporation counsel" or "city attorney" is used in the publication | |
| 681 adopted by this article, it shall be construed to mean the city solicitor. | |
| 682 | |
| 683 (c) Whenever, in the publication adopted by reference in this article, a term is used which is | |
| 684 also defined in the city's zoning ordinance as set forth in appendix B to this Code, such | |
| 685 | term shall have the meaning provided in such appendix B. |
| 686 | |
| 687 | Sec. 22-143. Conflicting provisions. |
| 688 In the event of any conflict between the provisions of the publication adopted by this article | |
| 689 and applicable provisions of state law, this Code or any other ordinance, rule or regulation, the | |
| 690 provisions of state law, this Code, or such other ordinance, rule or regulation shall prevail and be | |
| 691 | controlling |
| 692 | |
| 693 | Sec. 22-144. Enforcement. |
| 694 The building inspector shall enforce the provisions of the publication adopted by reference | |
| 695 | in this article. |
| 696 | |
| 697 | Sec. 22-145. Heating, air conditioning, and heat pump permit fees. |
Página 130
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 19 Item #25.
698 (a) Enumerated. Before any heating, air conditioning, or heat pump permit shall be issued, a 699 fee shall be paid unto the city as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 700 701 (b) Doubling of fees. Fees established in this section shall double in the event that a permit is 702 applied for after construction has commenced without the permission of the building 703 inspector. The building inspector may waive the doubling of fees in cases where the 704 building permit applicant is not a professional contractor, and the work is not being done
| 705 | by a professional contractor. |
| 706 | |
|---|---|
| 707 (c) Fines. A fine shall be issued when any code official finds any project has started or | |
| 708 | has been completed without an approved permit. |
| 709 | |
| 710 | Secs. 22-146—22-180. Reserved. |
| 711 | |
| 712 | ARTICLE VI. PLUMBING CODE |
| 713 | |
| 714 | Sec. 22-181. Adopted. |
| 715 (a) [International Plumbing Code.] Certain documents, three copies of which are on file in the | |
| 716 lLicensing and pPermitting oOffice in the city, being marked and designated as | |
| 717 International Plumbing Code 2009, including appendix chapters B, C, D, E, F, G, as | |
| 718 referenced in the building code adopted in 22-61(a), published by the International Code | |
| 719 Council, be and is hereby adopted as the code of the city for regulating the design, | |
| 720 construction, quality of materials, erection, installation, alteration, repair, location, | |
| 721 relocation, replacement, addition to, use or maintenance of plumbing systems in the city | |
| 722 and providing for the issuance of permits and collection of fees therefore; and each and all | |
| 723 of the regulations, provisions, conditions and terms of such International Plumbing Code, | |
| 724 as referenced in the building code adopted in 22-61(a), published by the International Code | |
| 725 Council, on file in the office of the city are hereby referred to, adopted and made a part | |
| 726 hereof as if fully set out in this section. The following sections are hereby revised: | |
| 727 | |
| 728 Exception: The 2009 International Private Sewage Disposal portion of this code is not adopted, | |
| 729 | as enforced by other authorities having jurisdiction. |
| 730 | |
| 731 Section 101.1 Title. Insert "City of Dover, DE" in place of "[NAME OF JURISDICTION]" | |
| 732 | |
| 733 Section 106.6.2 Fee Schedule. Insert "See Section 5.75 22-65 Permit Fees" in place of "The | |
| 734 fees for all plumbing work shall be as indicated in the following schedule: | |
| 735 | |
Página 131
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 20 Item #25.
736 [JURISDICTION TO INSERT APPROPRIATE SCHEDULE]". 737 738 Section 106.6.3 Fee refunds. Delete in its entirety. 739 740 Section 108.4 Violation Penalties. Insert: "See Section 22-61(a) International Building Code 741 Section 113.4, Violation Penalties" in place of "Any person who shall violate a provision of this 742 code or shall fail to comply with any of the requirements thereof or who shall erect, install, alters, 743 or repair, a plumbing work in violation of the approved construction documents or directive of the 744 code official, or of a permit or certificate issued under the provisions of this code, shall be guilty 745 of a [SPECIFY OFFENSE], punishable by a fine of not more than [AMOUNT] dollars or by 746 imprisonment not exceeding [NUMBER OF DAYS], or both such fine and imprisonment. Each 747 day that a violation continues after due notice has been served shall be deemed a separate offense." 748 749 Section 108.5 Stop work orders. Insert "See Section 22-61(a) International Building Code, 750 Section 114.3 Unlawful continuance" in place of "Upon notice from the code official, work on any 751 plumbing system that is being done contrary to the provisions of this code or in a dangerous and 752 unsafe manner shall immediately cease. Such notice shall be in writing and shall be given to the 753 owner of the property, or to the owner's agent, or to the person doing the work. The notice shall 754 state the conditions under which work is authorized to resume. Where an emergency exists, the 755 code official shall not be required to give written notice prior to stopping work. Any person who 756 shall continue any work in or about the structure after having been served with a stop work order, 757 except such work as that person is directed to perform to remove a violation or unsafe condition, 758 shall be charged with a violation of this section and shall be liable to a fine of not less than 759 [AMOUNT] dollars or more than [AMOUNT] dollars." 760 761 (b) International Fuel and Gas Code. That certain documents, three copies of which are on 762 file in the lLicensing and pPermitting oOffice of the city being marked and designated as 763 "The International Fuel and Gas Code, 2009 Edition" as published by the International 764 Code Council be and is hereby adopted as the Fuel and Gas Code of the City of Dover in 765 the State of Delaware; for regulating and governing fuel gas systems and gas fired 766 appliances as herein provided. 767 768 (c) [Severability.] That if any section, subsection, sentences, clause, or phrase of this section 769 is, for any reason, held to be unconstitutional, such decision shall not affect the validity of 770 the remaining portions of this section. The city council hereby declares that it would have 771 passed the ordinance from which this section derives, and each section, subsection, clause, 772 and phrase therefore, irrespective of the fact that any one or more sections, subsections, 773 sentences, clauses, and phrases be declared unconstitutional. 774 775 Sec. 22-182. Definitions.
Página 132
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 21 Item #25.
776 (a) Whenever the word "municipality" or the word "city" is used in the publication adopted 777 by this article, it shall be construed to mean the City of Dover, Delaware. 778 779 (b) Whenever the term "corporation council" or "city attorney" is used in the publication 780 adopted by this article, it shall mean the city solicitor. 781 782 (c) Whenever, in the publication adopted by reference in this article, a term is used which 783 is also defined in the city's zoning ordinance as set forth in appendix B to this Code, 784 such term shall have the meaning provided in such appendix B. 785 786 Sec. 22-183. Conflicting provisions. 787 In the event of any conflict between the provisions of the code adopted by this article and 788 applicable provisions of state law, this Code or any other ordinance, rule, or regulation, the 789 provisions of state law, this Code, or such other ordinance, rule or regulation shall prevail and be 790 controlling. 791 792 Sec. 22-184. Enforcement. 793 The building inspector shall enforce the provisions of the publication adopted by reference 794 in this article. 795 796 Sec. 22-185. Permit fees. 797 (a) Enumerated. Before any permit shall be issued for a plumbing permit a fee shall be paid 798 unto the city as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 799 800 (b) Doubling of fees. Fees established in this section shall double in the event that a permit is 801 applied for after construction has commenced without the permission of the building 802 inspector. The building inspector may waive the doubling of fees in cases where the 803 building permit applicant is not a professional contractor, and the work is not being done 804 by a professional contractor. 805 806 (c) Fines. A fine shall be issued when any code official finds a project has started or has 807 been completed without an approved permit. 808 809 Sec. 22-186. Water conservation performance standards. 810 (a) General policy. No water shall be provided for internal or external use to any residential, 811 commercial, industrial, agricultural, recreational, governmental, or public building or 812 structure of any kind which is constructed or remodeled and in which plumbing, water 813 piping, or water fixtures are to be installed, extended or altered in any way and for which
Página 133
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 22 Item #25.
814 construction a permit is required to be obtained (or would be required but for an exemption 815 from a permit requirement for public or governmental agencies) unless the new, extended 816 or altered plumbing, water piping and other water fixtures therein conform to the 817 requirements and standards of subsection (b) of this section. The provisions of this section 818 apply to any such building or structure for which such a building permit is issued or would 819 otherwise be required to be issued but for such an exemption on or after December 10,
| 820 | 1990. |
| 821 | |
|---|---|
| 822 | (b) Plumbing fixtures and fittings. |
| 823 (1) Water closets and associated flushing mechanisms. The water consumption of water | |
| 824 closets shall not exceed an average of 1.6 gallons per flush cycle. The fixture shall | |
| 825 perform in accordance with the test requirements of the ANSI A122.19.2M and ANSI | |
| 826 | A112.19.6M. |
| 827 | |
| 828 (2) Urinals and associated flushing mechanisms. Urinal water consumption shall not | |
| 829 exceed an average of 1.5 gallons per flush cycle. The fixtures shall perform in | |
| 830 accordance with the test requirements of ANSI 122.19.2M and ANSI A112.19.6M. | |
| 831 | |
| 832 (3) Showerheads. Showerhead discharge rates shall not exceed three gallons of water per | |
| 833 minute. The fixture shall perform in accordance with the test requirements of ANSI | |
| 834 | A122.18.1M. |
| 835 | |
| 836 (4) Faucets. Sink and lavatory faucet discharge rates shall not exceed three gallons of water | |
| 837 per minute. The fixture shall perform in accordance with the test requirements of ANSI | |
| 838 | A112.18.1M. |
| 839 | |
| 840 | (c) Special provisions. |
| 841 (1) Special purpose equipment. The performance standards of subsection (b) of this section | |
| 842 shall not apply to fixtures and fittings, such as emergency showers, aspirator faucets, | |
| 843 and blowout fixtures, that, in order to perform a specialized function, cannot meet the | |
| 844 | specified standards. |
| 845 | |
| 846 (2) Exemptions. Any person may apply to the city for an exemption to the terms of this | |
| 847 section, which may be granted by the city manager upon proof that some other device, | |
| 848 system, or procedure will save as much or more water as those set forth herein or that | |
| 849 | those set forth herein cannot be complied with without undue hardship. |
| 850 | |
| 851 (d) Modification and removal. The city may from time to time modify, add to, or remove the | |
| 852 | standards and restrictions herein. |
Página 134
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 23 Item #25.
| 853 | Secs. 22-187—22-220. Reserved. |
| 854 | |
|---|---|
| 855 | ARTICLE VII. PROPERTY MAINTENANCE CODE |
| 856 | |
| 857 | Sec. 22-221. Adopted. |
| 858 (a) A certain document, three copies of which are on file in the lLicensing and pPermitting | |
| 859 oOffice of the city, being marked and designated as "The International Property | |
| 860 Maintenance Code, 2009" as published by the International Code Council, be and is hereby | |
| 861 adopted as the Property Maintenance Code of the City of Dover, in the State of Delaware; | |
| 862 for the control of buildings and structures as herein provided; and each and all of the | |
| 863 regulations, provisions, penalties, conditions and terms of said property maintenance code | |
| 864 are hereby referred to, adopted, and made a part hereof, as if fully set out in this section, | |
| 865 | with the following additions, insertions, deletions and changes: |
| 866 Section 101.1 Title. Insert "City of Dover, DE" in place of "[NAME OF JURISDICTION]" | |
| 867 | |
| 868 SECTION 111 MEANS OF APPEAL See Chapter 22 - Buildings and Building Regulations, | |
| 869 Article I - In General, Sec. 22-1 Construction and property maintenance code board of appeals. | |
| 870 | |
| 871 Section 304.14 Insect screens. Insert "March 1st to November 30th" in place of "[date] to | |
| 872 | [date]". |
| 873 | |
| 874 Section 602.3 Heat supply. Insert "September 15th to May 1st" in place of "[date] to [date]". | |
| 875 | |
| 876 Section 602.4. Occupiable workspaces. Insert "September 15th to May 1st" in place of "[date] | |
| 877 | to [date]". |
| 878 | |
| 879 (b) It shall be unlawful for any person to violate any of the provisions of the publication | |
| 880 | adopted in subsection (a). |
| 881 | |
| 882 | Sec. 22-222. Definitions. |
| 883 (a) Whenever the word "municipality" or "city" is used in the publication adopted by this | |
| 884 | article, it shall be construed to mean the City of Dover, Delaware. |
| 885 | |
| 886 (b) Whenever the term "corporation counsel" or "city attorney" is used in the publication | |
| 887 | adopted by this article, it shall mean the city solicitor. |
| 888 | |
Página 135
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 24 Item #25.
889 (c) Whenever, in the publication adopted by reference in this article, a term is used which is 890 also defined in the city's zoning ordinance as set forth in appendix B to this Code, such
| 891 | term shall have the meaning provided in such appendix B. |
| 892 | |
|---|---|
| 893 | Sec. 22-223. Conflicting provisions. |
| 894 In the event of any conflict between the provisions of the code adopted by this article and | |
| 895 applicable provisions of state law, this Code or any other ordinance, rule, or regulation, the | |
| 896 provisions of state law, this Code or such other ordinance, rule or regulation shall prevail and be | |
| 897 | controlling. |
| 898 | |
| 899 | Sec. 22-224. Enforcement. |
| 900 The city planner code official shall enforce the provisions of the publication adopted by | |
| 901 | reference in this article. |
| 902 | |
| 903 | Sec. 22-225. Violations. |
| 904 (a) The Division of Code Enforcement, in accordance with the procedures set forth in the | |
| 905 International Property Maintenance Code adopted in section 22-221, shall inspect all | |
| 906 properties for compliance with the International Property Maintenance Code and all | |
| 907 | applicable codes to ensure compliance. |
| 908 | |
| 909 (b) Notification. Following an inspection, the code official shall issue a letter and/or report | |
| 910 of any code violations and provide a timeline for compliance. There shall be no fee for | |
| 911 | the first inspection. |
| 912 | |
| 913 (c) Notices. All notices of a code violation will be in writing and sent via first-class mail, | |
| 914 certified mail, electronic mail, or hand-delivered. A valid consent form must be on file | |
| 915 | to receive electronic mail. |
| 916 | |
| 917 (d) Owner’s address. The owner of the property shall be responsible for maintaining an | |
| 918 accurate mailing address with the City of Dover tax office at all times. | |
| 919 | |
| 920 (e) Compliance Date. Unless otherwise specified, all code violations must be corrected | |
| 921 within 30 days from the notice of violation. All code violations must be reinspected | |
| 922 | by the code official to confirm compliance with the code. |
| 923 | |
| 924 (f) Life Safety Violations. Code violations with an immediate threat to general welfare or | |
| 925 life safety must be corrected within 48 hours from the issuance of the violation notice. | |
| 926 These code violations are subject to an immediate penalty and shall be fined as | |
| 927 provided in Appendix F-Fees and Fines. Every life safety violation shall be treated as | |
| 928 | an individual and separate offense. |
| 929 (g) Failure to schedule. Failure to schedule a reinspection by the date provided by the | |
| 930 | code official shall be fined as provided in Appendix F-Fees and Fines. |
| 931 | |
Página 136
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 25 Item #25.
932 (h) Non-compliance. Failure to correct all code violation(s) by the date provided by the 933 code official shall be fined as provided in Appendix F--Fees and Fines. 934
| 935 | Sec. 22-225. Reserved. |
| 936 | Secs. 22-226—22-250. Reserved. |
| 937 | |
|---|---|
| 938 | ARTICLE VIII. LEASES |
| 939 | |
| 940 | Sec. 22-251. Unlawful leases. |
| 941 (a) Compliance with zoning. No owner or landlord shall enter into any agreement, contract, | |
| 942 lease, or sublease which provides for, permits, allows, contemplates, or facilitates | |
| 943 occupancy of any structure contrary to the use requirements of the city zoning ordinance | |
| 944 as set forth in Appendix B. Any agreement, contract, lease, or sublease which provides for, | |
| 945 permits, allows, contemplates, or facilitates such occupancy by more persons than | |
| 946 permitted in Appendix B to this Code is unlawful and hereby declared to be contrary to | |
| 947 | public policy. |
| 948 | |
| 949 (b) Noise; disorderly conduct; drugs. All agreements, contracts, leases, or subleases for the | |
| 950 occupancy of dwelling units shall prominently stipulate that any renter or occupier of the | |
| 951 rental unit shall not violate section 42-2 pertaining to noise or section 70-3 pertaining to | |
| 952 disorderly conduct in connection with the use of the premises and shall also prominently | |
| 953 stipulate that any renter or occupant of the rental unit shall not commit any drug offense on | |
| 954 the premises. The agreement, contract, lease, or sublease shall also prominently stipulate | |
| 955 that if any renter or occupant shall be convicted more than one time in any one-year period | |
| 956 of violating section 42-2 pertaining to noise or section 70-3 pertaining to disorderly conduct | |
| 957 in connection with the use of the premises or is convicted of any drug offense which | |
| 958 occurred on the premises, the renter or occupier shall be considered to have breached a | |
| 959 lawful obligation relating to his use of the premises and shall be grounds for termination | |
| 960 of the agreement, contract, lease, or sublease as it applies to that renter or occupant. | |
| 961 | |
| 962 (c) Notice of conviction to landlord. The city shall notify the landlord, owner, or owner's agent | |
| 963 if a renter or occupant of the rental unit is convicted of violating section 42-2 pertaining to | |
| 964 noise, section 70-3 pertaining to disorderly conduct, or any drug law. Notice shall be | |
| 965 deemed to be properly served upon the owner or the owner's agent if a copy thereof is | |
| 966 delivered to the owner, or the owner's agent; or by leaving a notice at the usual place of | |
| 967 abode, in the presence of someone in the family of suitable age and discretion, who shall | |
| 968 be informed of the contents thereof, or by certified mail addressed to the owner or the | |
| 969 owner's agent at the last known address, with return receipt requested; or lastly by posting | |
| 970 a copy thereof in a conspicuous place in or about the structure affected by the notice. | |
| 971 | |
Página 137
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 26 Item #25.
972 (d) Notice to renter. Within seven days of the receipt of notice that a renter or occupier has 973 been convicted of violating section 42-2 pertaining to noise or section 70-3 pertaining to 974 disorderly conduct, the landlord, owner, or owner's agent shall cause notice to be served 975 upon the affected renter or occupier that if a second such violation occurs within one year, 976 the rental agreement will be terminated. 977 978 (e) Second violation; termination of lease. Within seven days of the receipt of the notice that 979 a renter or occupier has been convicted of a second violation of section 42-2 pertaining to 980 noise or section 70-3 pertaining to disorderly conduct, or has been convicted of a drug 981 offense, the landlord, owner, or owner's agent shall cause to be served upon the affected 982 renter or occupier, notice that the rental agreement is terminated and that the renter or 983 occupier has not more than seven days to vacate the unit. 984 985 (f) Failure of renter or landlord to comply. If the renter or occupier fails to vacate the unit 986 within the time specified in the notice, the landlord, owner, or owner's agent shall 987 immediately initiate and diligently pursue, in good faith, summary proceedings for 988 possession as specified in the Residential Landlord-Tenant Code (25 Del. C. § 5101 et 989 seq.). The failure of the landlord, owner, or owner's agent to initiate or diligently pursue, 990 in good faith, summary proceedings for possession shall constitute a violation of this 991 section and shall subject the landlord, owner, or owner's agent to the penalties provided 992 herein. 993 994 (g) Violations; penalties. Any person, firm, or corporation who violates any provision of this 995 section shall have his rental license for the premises revoked and shall be punished by a 996 fine as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 997 998 Secs. 22-252—22-280. Reserved. 999 1000 ARTICLE IX. LODGING HOUSES 1001 1002 DIVISION 1. GENERALLY 1003 1004 Sec. 22-281. Purpose; applicability; definitions; compliance. 1005 (a) Purpose. The purpose and intent of this article is to ensure public health, safety, and welfare 1006 insofar as the continued occupancy and maintenance of lodginghouses lodging houses 1007 operated for public use affect them. The health, safety, and welfare of the occupants of the 1008 lodginghouses lodging houses are of the utmost importance to the city. 1009
Página 138
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 27 Item #25.
1010 (b) Applicability. The provisions of this article shall apply to all matters affecting or relating 1011 to lodging houses. Where, in this article, different sections of this Code may specify
| 1012 | different requirements, the most restrictive shall govern. |
| 1013 | |
|---|---|
| 1014 (c) Definitions. The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this article, shall have | |
| 1015 the meanings ascribed to them in this subsection, except where the context clearly indicates | |
| 1016 | a different meaning: |
| 1017 | |
| 1018 Lodginghouse Lodging house means a building operated principally for the temporary residence | |
| 1019 of the transient public, including, but not limited to, hotels, motels, inns, boardinghouses, rooming | |
| 1020 | houses, tourist homes, and dormitories. |
| 1021 | |
| 1022 (d) Compliance. No person shall operate, occupy, or let to another for occupancy any | |
| 1023 lodginghouse lodging house which is not in compliance with this chapter. No person shall | |
| 1024 operate, occupy, or let to another for occupancy any lodginghouse lodging house unless it | |
| 1025 is clean and sanitary, and complies with the requirements of this article. | |
| 1026 | |
| 1027 | Sec. 22-282. Responsibilities of operator. |
| 1028 The operator of every lodginghouse lodging house shall be responsible for: | |
| 1029 | |
| 1030 (1) Maintaining all supplied bedding in a clean and sanitary condition; | |
| 1031 | |
| 1032 (2) Changing all supplied bed linens and towels at least once each week and upon the | |
| 1033 | renting of any room; |
| 1034 | |
| 1035 | (3) Supplying clean towels daily; |
| 1036 | |
| 1037 (4) Maintaining the property in accordance with the International Property Maintenance | |
| 1038 Code adopted in section 22-221 and the International Fire Code adopted in section 46- | |
| 1039 | 121(a). |
| 1040 | |
| 1041 | Secs. 22-284—22-300. Reserved. |
| 1042 | |
| 1043 | DIVISION 2. PERMIT |
| 1044 | |
| 1045 | Sec. 22-301. Generally. |
Página 139
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 28 Item #25.
1046 (a) Required. It shall be unlawful for any person to let, or offer to let, space in any 1047 lodginghouse lodging house by advertisement, without first obtaining a permit from the 1048 licensing division of the dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections in order to determine 1049 compliance with the provisions of this chapter. 1050 1051 (b) Expiration; fee. The permit shall expire annually on January 31, and the fee for the annual 1052 permit shall be as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 1053 1054 (c) Failure to pay on due date. In the event that the permit fee set forth herein is not paid on 1055 the date due, then the permittee shall incur a penalty fee as provided for in Appendix F— 1056 Fees and Fines until the same is paid. 1057 1058 (d) Reinstatement fee. An owner whose permit has been suspended in accordance with section 1059 22-303 shall pay a reinstatement fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 1060 1061 (e) Lien. In the event that the property owner fails to pay said fees within 30 days from the 1062 date a notice thereof is mailed to the owner, then such fees may be entered into the 1063 municipal lien docket as a lien owing the city, and the same may be turned over to the city 1064 solicitor for collection. 1065 1066 (f) Utilities. The owner or occupant of any lodginghouse lodging house shall not be entitled 1067 to receive city utilities until the permit fee required in this section is paid in full and city 1068 personnel shall refuse to provide sewage, water, and electricity to the property until 1069 satisfactory proof is furnished that such permit fee has been paid. 1070 1071 Sec. 22-302. Application and issuance. 1072 No permit shall be issued until the applicant has complied with the provisions of this 1073 chapter applicable to lodginghouses lodging houses and until the applicant has furnished the 1074 licensing division of the dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections with any other information 1075 that may be required. 1076 1077 Sec. 22-303. Suspension. 1078 (a) Grounds; duration. The building inspector shall suspend the permit issued or withhold the 1079 permit paid for, pursuant to this division, when he determines that the lodginghouse 1080 lodging house or the premises surrounding the lodginghouse lodging house fails to meet 1081 the requirements of this chapter or any rule or regulation issued pursuant thereto. 1082 Suspension shall last until the violations have been corrected to the satisfaction of the 1083 building inspector, or the suspension shall have been reversed on appeal. 1084
Página 140
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 29 Item #25.
1085 (b) Notice to owner. Upon suspending any permit under this section or withholding the permit 1086 paid for, the building inspector shall notify the owner of the violations of the applicable 1087 code and shall prescribe a period in which the violation shall be corrected. 1088 1089 (c) Appeal. Any owner or operator of any lodginghouse lodging house, whose permit to 1090 operate the structure is suspended by the building inspector pursuant to the procedures of 1091 this section, shall have the right to appeal and notice as provided in section 22-225. 1092 1093 (d) Effect of appeal. Upon suspension of a permit or withholding of a permit ordered by the 1094 building inspector and upon the permittee serving the city clerk with a notice of appeal 1095 pursuant to section 22-225, the permit suspension shall be stayed, and an existing permit 1096 shall remain in force until the appeal is decided. 1097 1098 Secs. 22-304—22-330. Reserved. 1099 1100 ARTICLE X. RENTAL DWELLINGS 1101 1102 DIVISION 1. GENERALLY 1103 1104 Sec. 22-331. Purpose; applicability; definitions; compliance. 1105 (a) Purpose. The purpose and intent of this article is to ensure public health, safety, and welfare 1106 insofar as they are affected by the continued occupancy and maintenance of dwellings 1107 operated for lease to the public. The health, safety, and welfare of the occupants of the 1108 dwellings are of the utmost importance to the city, as is the general community character 1109 in which these dwelling units are located. 1110 1111 (b) Applicability. The provisions of this article shall apply to all matters affecting or relating 1112 to rental dwellings. Where, in this article, different sections of this Code may specify 1113 different requirements, the most restrictive shall govern. 1114 1115 (c) Definitions. The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this article, shall have 1116 the meanings ascribed to them in this subsection, except where the context clearly indicates 1117 a different meaning: 1118 1119 (1) Criminal activity is defined as any crime classified by applicable law as a (a) felony, 1120 (b) Class A misdemeanor, or (c) any of the following offenses: any drug offense defined 1121 by Title 16 of the Delaware Code, and the following misdemeanors in addition to any 1122 Class A misdemeanor, as defined by Title 11 of the Delaware Code: § 601—Offensive
Página 141
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 30 Item #25.
1123 touching, § 602—Menacing, § 628—Vehicular assault 3, § 763—Sexual harassment, 1124 § 764—Indecent exposure, § 811—Criminal mischief, § 812—Graffiti, § 820— 1125 Trespassing, § 821/2/3—Criminal trespassing, § 1105—Crime against a vulnerable 1126 adult, § 1106—Unlawfully dealing with a child, § 1301—Disorderly conduct, § 1313— 1127 Malicious interference with emergency communications, § 1315—Public intoxication, 1128 § 1321—Loitering, § 1322—Criminal nuisance, § 1323—Obstructing of public 1129 passage, § 1341—Lewdness, § 1342—Prostitution, § 1343—Patronizing a prostitute, 1130 § 1445—Unlawfully dealing with a dangerous weapon, § 1446—Unlawfully dealing
| 1131 | with a switchblade knife. |
| 1132 | |
|---|---|
| 1133 (2) Dwelling unit means a single unit providing complete independent living facilities for | |
| 1134 one or more persons, including permanent provisions for living, sleeping, eating, | |
| 1135 | cooking, and sanitation. |
| 1136 | |
| 1137 (3) Multiple-family dwellings means dwelling units operated as a group and located in the | |
| 1138 same building. This shall include apartments, roominghouses rooming houses, | |
| 1139 condominium dwelling units, and accessory apartments located within structures | |
| 1140 | principally used for owner occupancy. |
| 1141 | |
| 1142 (4) Rental dwelling means a dwelling unit that is leased for occupancy to a person or | |
| 1143 persons in exchange for monetary payment or provision of goods or services to the | |
| 1144 | owner of the dwelling unit. |
| 1145 | |
| 1146 (5) Single-family dwellings means dwelling units operated singly, and separated from other | |
| 1147 units. In general, this definition shall apply to single-family detached dwellings; mobile | |
| 1148 homes and manufactured homes; and attached units, including duplexes and | |
| 1149 | townhouses. |
| 1150 | |
| 1151 (d) Compliance required. No person shall operate, occupy, or to let to another for occupancy | |
| 1152 any dwelling which is not in compliance with the International Property Maintenance Code | |
| 1153 | adopted in section 22-221 and all other applicable codes. |
| 1154 | |
| 1155 | Sec. 22-332. Inspection required. |
| 1156 (a) The cCode eEnforcement oOffice, in accordance with the procedures set forth in the | |
| 1157 International Property Maintenance Code adopted in section 22-221, shall inspect rental | |
| 1158 dwellings for compliance with the property maintenance code and all other applicable | |
| 1159 | codes to ensure compliance. |
| 1160 (b) An inspection is required prior to the issuance of any new rental dwelling permit. No new | |
| 1161 permit shall be issued until all outstanding code violation(s) comply with the code and | |
| 1162 | are verified for compliance by the code official. |
Página 142
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 31 Item #25.
1163 1164 (c) Following an inspection, the code enforcement office shall issue a letter and/or report of 1165 any code violations and provide a timeline for compliance. There shall be no fee for the 1166 first follow up inspection. Each subsequent reinspection shall be subject to a fee as 1167 provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. The owner of the rental dwelling or a 1168 property manager must be present for all scheduled inspections. Failure to meet this 1169 requirement will result in the scheduled inspection to be terminated and shall be fined 1170 as provided in Appendix F-Fees and Fines. Property manager is defined in Sec. 22-
| 1171 | 333(a). |
| 1172 | |
|---|---|
| 1173 (d) It shall be the responsibility of the owner or property manager to schedule all | |
| 1174 | required inspections. |
| 1175 | |
| 1176 (e) Following an inspection, the code official shall issue a letter and/or report of any code | |
| 1177 violations and provide a timeline for compliance. There shall be no fee for the first | |
| 1178 follow-up inspection when all violations comply with the code. Each subsequent | |
| 1179 reinspection shall be subject to a fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. | |
| 1180 | |
| 1181 | Sec. 22-333. Agent required. |
| 1182 (a) Property manager. Any owner of a rental dwelling, residing outside of the county, shall be | |
| 1183 required to have a licensed property manager residing or having an office located in the | |
| 1184 county, or a family member or other designated individual who does not manage any other | |
| 1185 rental real estate for a fee and who resides in the county acting as a property manager. The | |
| 1186 property manager, including family members and designated individuals, shall have | |
| 1187 charge, care, and control of the rental dwelling, and shall provide access to the rental | |
| 1188 dwelling for inspection, upon request by the code official, within a reasonable time. | |
| 1189 | |
| 1190 (b) Corporate or partnership owners. Any corporation or partnership owning a rental dwelling | |
| 1191 shall have a designated member, partner, or employee having charge, care, and control of | |
| 1192 the rental dwelling. The designated member, partner, or employee shall reside in or have | |
| 1193 an office located in the county, or shall be required to have a licensed property manager | |
| 1194 residing or having an office located in the county, or a family member or other designated | |
| 1195 individual who does not manage any other rental real estate for a fee, and who resides in | |
| 1196 the county, acting as a property manager. The property manager, family members, or other | |
| 1197 designated individuals shall have charge, care, and control of the rental dwelling, and shall | |
| 1198 provide access to the rental dwelling for inspection, upon request by the code official, | |
| 1199 | within a reasonable time. |
| 1200 | |
| 1201 (c) The lessee of the dwelling cannot be the agent for the dwelling they lease. | |
| 1202 | |
Página 143
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 32 Item #25.
1203 (d) The property owner is required to provide agent updates by submitting a new Rental
| 1204 | Dwelling Permit application. |
| 1205 | |
|---|---|
| 1206 | Sec. 22-334. Insurance required. |
| 1207 (a) Any owner of a rental property shall have sufficient property insurance that covers the | |
| 1208 amount to replace the estimated value of the improvements on the property and provide | |
| 1209 | protection for claims resulting from fire or other damages. |
| 1210 | |
| 1211 (b) Proof of insurance coverage shall be provided upon application for a new rental permit and | |
| 1212 | upon each annual renewal thereafter. |
| 1213 | |
| 1214 | Secs. 22-335—22-350. Reserved. |
| 1215 | |
| 1216 | DIVISION 2. PERMIT |
| 1217 | |
| 1218 | Sec. 22-351. Generally. |
| 1219 (a) Single-family dwellings. It shall be unlawful for any person to operate any single-family | |
| 1220 rental dwelling without obtaining a permit from the licensing division of the dDepartment | |
| 1221 of pPlanning and iInspections to determine compliance with the appropriate provisions of | |
| 1222 this article. The permit shall expire annually on January 31. The fee for the annual permit | |
| 1223 shall be as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. The permit fee for rental dwelling | |
| 1224 permits issued after January 31 will be prorated from the date the permit is issued until the | |
| 1225 | next January 31. |
| 1226 | |
| 1227 (b) Multiple-family dwellings. It shall be unlawful for any person to operate any multiple | |
| 1228 dwelling without first obtaining an annual permit therefore from the licensing division of | |
| 1229 the dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections to determine compliance with the | |
| 1230 appropriate provisions of this article. The permit shall expire annually on January 31, and | |
| 1231 the fee for the annual permit shall be as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. The | |
| 1232 permit fee for rental dwelling permits issued after January 31 will be prorated from the date | |
| 1233 | the permit is issued until the next January 31. |
| 1234 | |
| 1235 (c) Late payment penalty. In the event that the permit fee set forth herein is not paid on the | |
| 1236 date due, then the permittee shall incur a penalty fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees | |
| 1237 | and Fines until the same is paid. |
| 1238 | |
| 1239 (d) Reinstatement fee. An owner whose permit has been suspended in accordance with section | |
| 1240 22-352 shall pay a reinstatement fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. | |
Página 144
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 33 Item #25.
1241 1242 (e) Lien. In the event that the property owner fails to pay said fees within 30 days from the 1243 date a notice thereof is mailed to the owner, then such fees shall be entered in the municipal 1244 lien docket as a lien owing the city; and the same may be turned over to the city solicitor
| 1245 | for collection. |
| 1246 | |
|---|---|
| 1247 (f) Utilities. The owner or occupant of any rental unit shall not be entitled to receive any new | |
| 1248 city utilities until the permit fee required in this section is paid in full and city personnel | |
| 1249 shall refuse to provide sewage, water, and electricity to the property until satisfactory proof | |
| 1250 | is furnished that such permit fee has been paid. |
| 1251 | |
| 1252 (g) Failure to obtain a Rental Dwelling Permit. Any owner of a rental property that fails | |
| 1253 to obtain or renew a Rental Dwelling Permit shall be fined as set forth in Appendix | |
| 1254 | F-Fees and Fines. |
| 1255 | |
| 1256 | Sec. 22-352. Suspension. |
| 1257 (a) Grounds; duration. The building inspector shall suspend the permit issued or withhold the | |
| 1258 | permit paid for, pursuant to this division, when: |
| 1259 | |
| 1260 (1) The building inspector determines that any dwelling or the premises surrounding the | |
| 1261 dwelling fails to meet the requirements of this chapter or any rule or regulation issued | |
| 1262 | pursuant thereto; |
| 1263 | |
| 1264 (2) The failure of the property owner or property manager to initiate and prosecute in good | |
| 1265 faith eviction proceedings following notification by the city that the terms of the safe | |
| 1266 | communities lease addendum have been violated; or |
| 1267 | |
| 1268 (3) The failure of the property owner or property manager to attend a safe communities | |
| 1269 | seminar when required by section 22-371(b). |
| 1270 Suspension shall last until the violations have been corrected to the satisfaction of the | |
| 1271 | building inspector, or the suspension shall have been reversed. |
| 1272 | |
| 1273 (b) Notice of violations. Upon suspending any permit under this section or withholding the | |
| 1274 permit paid for, the building inspector shall notify the owner of the violations of the | |
| 1275 applicable code and shall prescribe a period in which the violation shall be corrected. | |
| 1276 | |
Página 145
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 34 Item #25.
1277 (c) Appeal. Any owner or operator of any dwelling, whose permit to operate the structure is 1278 suspended by the building inspector pursuant to the procedures of this section, shall have 1279 the right to appeal and notice as provided in section 22-225. 1280 1281 (d) Effect of appeal. Upon suspension of a permit or withholding of a permit ordered by the 1282 building inspector and upon the permittee serving the city clerk with a notice of appeal 1283 pursuant to section 22-225, the permit suspension shall be stayed, and an existing permit 1284 shall remain in force until the appeal is decided. 1285 1286 Secs. 22-353—22-355. Reserved. 1287 1288 DIVISION 3. SHORT-TERM RENTAL USE 1289 1290 Sec. 22-356. Purpose; applicability; definitions; compliance. 1291 (a) Purpose. The City of Dover wishes to permit the limited and temporary rental use of one- 1292 family dwellings (residences) in established areas of the city as an economic asset, allowing 1293 for increased travel, visitation, and tourism and affording property owners of the 1294 opportunity to earn revenue from such occupancy, while ensuring that such uses do not 1295 become a nuisance, that neighborhood character is not compromised, and that such 1296 businesses are properly operated and maintained. The purpose of this division shall be to 1297 minimize public safety risks and public nuisances, such as noise, trash, and parking 1298 problems; to ensure that traditional neighborhoods are not turned into tourist areas to the 1299 detriment of long-term residents; and to ensure that individual dwellings are not turned into 1300 pseudo hotels or party houses. 1301 1302 (b) Applicability. A short Short-term rental use (STRU) shall be allowed in any one-family 1303 dwelling as defined in Appendix B—Zoning, Article 12—Definitions of the zoning 1304 ordinance wherever such are allowed by right and do not require a variance or conditional 1305 use approval. 1306 1307 (c) Definitions. The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this article, shall have 1308 the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a 1309 different meaning: 1310 1311 Good neighbor brochure means a document provided by the owner to the guest or guests 1312 and containing: the name and telephone number for the owner; notification on standards of 1313 behavior and occupancy relating to parking, noise, trash collection, waste disposal, street 1314 maintenance, snow removal, and public safety services and including contact and web 1315 access information; and such other information as the city may from time to time prescribe.
Página 146
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 35 Item #25.
1316 Guest or guests means the individual or individuals securing the short-term rental use for
| 1317 | the purposes of staying overnight. |
| 1318 | |
|---|---|
| 1319 Owner means the person or persons holding legal or equitable title to the property being | |
| 1320 | offered as a short-term rental use. |
| 1321 | |
| 1322 Short-term rental use (STRU) means rental of all or a part of a residential one-family | |
| 1323 dwelling unit which is made available by agreement for a residential occupancy by a tenant | |
| 1324 in exchange for compensation for a duration of a temporary occupancy of less than 30 days. | |
| 1325 Rentals of 30 days or more shall comply with the provisions of divisions 1 and 2 of this | |
| 1326 chapter. Lodginghouses Lodging houses as defined in Article IX; section 22-281 is not | |
| 1327 | included as short-term rental uses under this division. |
| 1328 | |
| 1329 (d) Compliance. No person shall operate, offer for occupancy, or let to another for occupancy | |
| 1330 as a short-term rental use any dwelling which is not in compliance with this article or any | |
| 1331 | other applicable codes. |
| 1332 | |
| 1333 Sec. 22-357. Registration and inspection requirements; inspection required for life safety and | |
| 1334 | building purposes; short-term rental use license required. |
| 1335 (a) The owner of any dwelling proposed for a short-term rental use must obtain an annual | |
| 1336 | short-term rental use license. |
| 1337 | |
| 1338 (b) An inspection by the city cCode eEnforcement oOffice shall be required to determine | |
| 1339 compliance with property maintenance and all other applicable codes. Any items in non- | |
| 1340 compliance shall be remedied before a license is granted. The inspection shall be required | |
| 1341 the first time a license is issued and may be required at renewal at the discretion of the | |
| 1342 cCode eEnforcement oOffice. The rental license must be kept current during any time the | |
| 1343 | dwelling is offered as a short-term rental use. |
| 1344 | |
| 1345 (c) The license shall be valid for up to one year and must be renewed no later than January 31 | |
| 1346 | of each year of continued operation. |
| 1347 | |
| 1348 (d) The short-term rental use license must be clearly displayed inside the dwelling along with | |
| 1349 | any state licenses or permits. |
| 1350 | |
| 1351 (e) The short-term rental use license may not be transferred to any party except heirs and | |
| 1352 assigns and shall be void upon transfer of ownership of the property where the short-term | |
| 1353 | rental use is located. |
| 1354 | |
Página 147
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 36 Item #25.
1355 Sec. 22-358. Owner obligations. 1356 An owner of a dwelling seeking to use a property as a short-term rental use shall comply 1357 with the following obligations: 1358 (1) The owner of the property being offered as a short-term rental use must be a resident 1359 of the city. Determination of residency shall be based on meeting city voting residency 1360 eligibility. Such owner may offer for short-term rental use only that property which is 1361 the owner's primary residence. 1362 1363 (2) A property not owned by a resident of the city shall not be used as a short-term rental 1364 use. Such property shall not be used for overnight accommodations unless such 1365 property qualifies as a bed and breakfast inn pursuant to Dover Code, Appendix B— 1366 Zoning, Article 3—District Regulations. 1367 1368 (3) A good neighbor brochure must be provided in the dwelling listing city provisions as 1369 required. 1370 1371 Sec. 22-359. Limitations on occupancy and use. 1372 (a) The number of guests 12 years and older permitted at any time shall not exceed twice the 1373 number of bedrooms (i.e. three bedrooms × two = six occupants), with a maximum of 12 1374 individual occupants of all ages at any one time regardless of the number of bedrooms 1375 available. 1376 1377 (b) No more than one extra vehicle per bedroom shall be allowed, not to exceed six extra in 1378 total; all parking shall comply with all requirements relating to street maintenance, fire 1379 access, parking on paved surfaces, trash collection, obstacles to travel, or other 1380 requirements. Violations shall be ticketed offenses. 1381 1382 (c) Signage identifying the short-term rental use, if desired, shall be limited to one sign, 1383 mounted on the dwelling, not illuminated, and not to exceed one square feet foot in size 1384 overall. A sign permit must be obtained for any desired sign. 1385 1386 (d) Access to a full bath must be provided. 1387 1388 (e) Guests shall be prohibited from further subletting the dwelling. 1389 1390 (f) Weddings, graduation parties, corporate events, commercial functions, large gatherings, or 1391 other special events associated with the STRU shall be prohibited unless a city special 1392 event permit shall have been granted for a specific activity and date.
Página 148
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 37 Item #25.
1393 (g) The owner has the responsibility to not knowingly allow any illegal or criminal activity on 1394 the property nor permit the guests to create a public nuisance including, but not limited to, 1395 creating noise, causing odors, permitting an unsafe condition, maintaining a disorderly 1396 premise, generation of trash, or other behavior which unreasonably disturbs the peace, 1397 safety and general welfare of the neighborhood as provided in this chapter and pursuant to 1398 Chapter 70—Offenses and Miscellaneous Provisions, Section 70-8—Disorderly Premises 1399 and Chapter 42—Environment, Section 42-2—Noise of the Dover Code of Ordinances. 1400 1401 Sec. 22-360. Enforcement, fees, and penalties, reporting. 1402 (a) Short-term rental license. Payment of a short-term rental use license fee as set forth in 1403 Appendix F—Fees and Fines is required annually beginning January 31 of each year; the 1404 fee will be prorated for a partial year. 1405 1406 (b) Failure to register and obtain a license. Penalties fines for failure to register and obtain a 1407 license shall be as set forth in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 1408 1409 (c) Penalties for violations. Penalties for violations of Division 3, Short Term Rental Use, shall 1410 be as set forth in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 1411 1412 (d) A dwelling cited three times by the Code official or by any city department as a nuisance 1413 or the location of illegal or criminal activity within any consecutive 12-month period shall 1414 have its short-term rental use license suspended for not less than the rest of the license year 1415 or a longer period up to permanently. 1416 1417 (e) The owner shall voluntarily report to the city annually documenting the occupancy and 1418 frequency of rentals obtained, such report to be completed by January 31 of the following 1419 year as part of the license renewal and for the purposes of building a database of STRU 1420 activity and economic impact, not for enforcement or tax purposes. 1421 1422 Sec. 22-361. Enforcement, notice, and appeals. 1423 Enforcement of violations of this division shall be as set forth in Chapter 22—Buildings 1424 and Building Regulations, Chapter 42—Environment, and Chapter 70—Offenses and 1425 Miscellaneous Provisions of the Code of Ordinances. 1426 1427 Secs. 22-362—22-369. Reserved. 1428 1429 DIVISION 4. SAFE COMMUNITIES 1430
Página 149
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 38 Item #25.
| 1431 | Sec. 22-370. Criminal activity. |
| 1432 Tenants of rental dwellings, any member of the tenant’s household, any guest, or other | |
|---|---|
| 1433 person under the tenant’s control shall not engage in criminal activity on or within 500 feet of the | |
| 1434 | lot on which the rental dwelling resides. |
| 1435 | |
| 1436 | Sec. 22-371. Safe cCommunities seminar. |
| 1437 (a) The City of Dover pPolice dDepartment shall offer a sSafe cCommunities seminar a | |
| 1438 minimum of two times each calendar year. The seminar shall be voluntary, except in the | |
| 1439 | following circumstances: |
| 1440 | |
| 1441 (1) When a rental dwelling permit has been suspended in accordance with section 22-352, | |
| 1442 the property owner or manager shall attend the seminar prior to reinstatement of the | |
| 1443 | suspended rental dwelling permit; or |
| 1444 | |
| 1445 (2) When a rental dwelling has been the subject of response by the police department on | |
| 1446 three or more occasions within a six-month period, due to occasions where the tenant, | |
| 1447 any member of the tenant's family, or any guest or other person under the tenant's | |
| 1448 control have engaged in criminal activity, the property owner or managers shall attend | |
| 1449 | the seminar. |
| 1450 | |
| 1451 (b) Upon notification by the chief of police that the sSafe cCommunities seminar is required | |
| 1452 in accordance with subsection (2) above, the dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections | |
| 1453 shall notify the property owner and/or property manager that he is required to attend the | |
| 1454 next scheduled sSafe cCommunities seminar. Such notice shall be sent by U.S. Mail, | |
| 1455 evidenced by Certificate of Mailing to the property owner and property manager if a | |
| 1456 property manager is on record with the dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections. | |
| 1457 | |
| 1458 | Sec. 22-372. Safe cCommunities lLease aAddendum. |
| 1459 (a) All residential leases shall include a sSafe cCommunities lLease aAddendum, signed by | |
| 1460 | the property owner and tenant, in the following form: |
| 1461 In addition to all other terms of the lease, landlord and tenant agree as follows: | |
| 1462 | |
| 1463 (1) The tenant, any member of the tenant's household, any guest, or any other person under | |
| 1464 | the tenant's control on or within 500 feet of the leased premises: |
| 1465 i. Shall not engage in criminal activity, including drug-related criminal activity, on or | |
| 1466 within 500 feet of the leased premises. "Drug-related criminal activity" means the | |
| 1467 illegal manufacture, sale, distribution, use, or possession of any illegal or controlled | |
| 1468 | substance defined by 16 Del. C. Ch. 47. |
| 1469 | |
Página 150
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 39 Item #25.
1470 ii. Shall not engage in any act intended to facilitate criminal activity. 1471 1472 iii. Shall not permit the dwelling unit to be used for or to facilitate any criminal activity. 1473 1474 (2) Any activity prohibited by the sSafe cCommunities lLease aAddendum shall constitute 1475 a substantial violation of the lease, material noncompliance with the lease, and grounds
| 1476 | for termination of tenancy and eviction. |
| 1477 | |
|---|---|
| 1478 (b) The dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections shall provide the sSafe cCommunities | |
| 1479 | lLease aAddendum. |
| 1480 | |
| 1481 (c) An executed copy of the sSafe cCommunities lLease aAddendum shall be required for all | |
| 1482 rental dwellings in the City of Dover prior to establishment of a utility account for the | |
| 1483 | premises. |
| 1484 | |
| 1485 | Sec. 22-373. Eviction required. |
| 1486 (a) If the tenant, any member of the tenant's household, any guest, or other person under the | |
| 1487 tenant's control engages in criminal activity as defined by Section 22-331(c)(1) and Chapter | |
| 1488 22, Buildings and Building Regulations, of the Dover Code on three or more occasions | |
| 1489 within a 12-month period, the chief of police shall notify the dDepartment of pPlanning | |
| 1490 and iInspections to initiate the safe communities lease termination notice procedure | |
| 1491 directing the property owner or property manager to terminate the tenancy in accordance | |
| 1492 | with subsection (b). |
| 1493 | |
| 1494 (b) Upon notification by the chief of police that termination of tenancy is required in | |
| 1495 accordance with subsection (a), the dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections shall notify | |
| 1496 the property owner and property manager that they have 30 days to initiate the eviction or | |
| 1497 otherwise terminate the tenancy. Such notice shall be sent by U.S. Mail, evidenced by | |
| 1498 Certificate of Mailing, to the property owner and property manager if a property manager | |
| 1499 | is on record with the dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections. |
| 1500 | |
| 1501 | Secs. 22-374—22-380. Reserved. |
| 1502 | |
| 1503 | ARTICLE XI. DANGEROUS BUILDINGS |
| 1504 | |
| 1505 | Sec. 22-381. Definitions. |
| 1506 The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings | |
| 1507 ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: | |
Página 151
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 40 Item #25.
1508 Dangerous buildings means all buildings or structures which have any or all of the following
| 1509 | defects or uses: |
| 1510 (1) Leaning interior walls. Those of which the interior walls or other vertical structural | |
|---|---|
| 1511 members list, lean or buckle to such an extent that a plumb line passing through the center | |
| 1512 | of gravity falls outside of the middle third of its base. |
| 1513 | |
| 1514 (2) Damaged walls, etc. Those which, exclusive of the foundation, show 33 percent or more | |
| 1515 of damage or deterioration of the supporting member or members, or 50 percent of damage | |
| 1516 or deterioration of the nonsupporting non-supportive enclosing or outside walls or | |
| 1517 | covering. |
| 1518 | |
| 1519 (3) Loads on roofs. Those which have improperly distributed loads upon the floors or roofs or | |
| 1520 which the same are overloaded or which have insufficient strength to be reasonably safe | |
| 1521 | for the purpose used. |
| 1522 | |
| 1523 (4) Fire damage, etc. Those which have been damaged by fire, wind, or other causes so as to | |
| 1524 have become dangerous to life, safety, morals, or the general health and welfare of the | |
| 1525 | occupants or the people of the city. |
| 1526 | |
| 1527 (5) Unfit for habitation. Those which have become or are so dilapidated, decayed, unsafe, | |
| 1528 iunsanitary, or so utterly fail to provide the amenities to decent living that they are unfit | |
| 1529 for human habitation, or are likely to cause sickness or disease, so as to work injury to the | |
| 1530 | health, morals, safety, or general welfare of those living therein. |
| 1531 | |
| 1532 (6) Light, air, sanitation. Those having light, air, and sanitation facilities which are inadequate | |
| 1533 to protect the health, morals, safety, or general welfare of human beings who live or may | |
| 1534 | live therein. |
| 1535 | |
| 1536 (7) Fire escapes, etc. Those having inadequate facilities in case of fire or panic, or those having | |
| 1537 insufficient stairways, elevators, fire escapes, or other means of communication. | |
| 1538 | |
| 1539 (8) Loose parts. Those which have parts thereof which are so attached that they may fall and | |
| 1540 | injure members of the public or property. |
| 1541 | |
| 1542 (9) General welfare. Those which, because of their condition or use, are unsafe, iunsanitary, | |
| 1543 or dangerous to the public health, morals, safety, or general welfare of the people of this | |
| 1544 | city. |
| 1545 | |
Página 152
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 41 Item #25.
1546 (10) Code violations. Those existing in violation of any provisions of the building code of this 1547 city, or any provision of the fire prevention code, or other ordinances of this city. 1548 1549 (11) Drug sales, use, etc. Those which are being used for the unlawful selling, serving, storing, 1550 giving away, or manufacturing (which includes the production, preparation, compounding, 1551 conversion, processing, packaging, or repackaging) of any drug, which includes all narcotic 1552 or psychoactive drugs, cannabis, cocaine, and all controlled substances as defined in the 1553 Uniform Controlled Substances Act (16 Del. C. § 4701 et seq.). 1554 1555 (12) Unoccupied buildings. Those which are left unoccupied and unattended for periods of three 1556 months or more so that decay is being accelerated by natural or manmade causes or which 1557 may be attracting trespassers and vagrants, increasing the probability of fire and danger to 1558 human life. 1559 1560 (13) Incomplete buildings. Those under construction, if the authorized work is substantially 1561 suspended or abandoned for a period of three months or more. 1562 1563 Sec. 22-382. Standards for repair, vacation, or demolition. 1564 The following standards shall be followed in substance by the building inspector code 1565 official in ordering the repair, vacation, or demolition of dangerous buildings: 1566 1567 (1) Repair. If the dangerous building can reasonably be repaired so that it will no longer exist 1568 in violation of the terms of this article, it shall be ordered repaired. 1569 1570 (2) Vacation. If the dangerous building is in such a condition or is being used to make it 1571 dangerous to the health, morals, safety, or general welfare of its occupants, it shall be 1572 ordered to be vacated and closed. Buildings ordered closed shall not be reopened until a 1573 certificate of occupancy is issued. 1574 1575 (3) Demolition. In any case, where a dangerous building is 50 percent damaged, decayed, or 1576 deteriorated from its original value or structure, it shall be demolished, and in all cases 1577 where a building cannot be repaired so that it will no longer exist in violation of the terms 1578 of this article, it shall be demolished. In all cases where a dangerous building is a fire 1579 hazard, or public safety hazard as determined by the fire marshal code official or is 1580 existing or erected in violation of the terms of this article or any ordinance of the city or 1581 statute of the state, it may be demolished. 1582 1583
Página 153
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 42 Item #25.
| 1584 | Sec. 22-383. Nuisance declared. |
| 1585 All dangerous buildings within the terms of section 22-381 are hereby declared to be public | |
|---|---|
| 1586 nuisances, and shall be repaired, vacated, and closed or demolished as hereinbefore and hereafter | |
| 1587 | provided. |
| 1588 | |
| 1589 | Sec. 22-384. Duties of the building inspector code official. |
| 1590 | The building inspector code official shall: |
| 1591 (1) Inspect public buildings. Inspect or cause to be inspected semiannually all public | |
| 1592 buildings, schools, halls, churches, theaters, hotels, tenements, or commercial, | |
| 1593 manufacturing, or loft buildings for the purpose of determining whether any conditions | |
| 1594 exist which render such places a dangerous building within the terms of section 22- | |
| 1595 | 381. |
| 1596 | |
| 1597 (2) Complaints. Inspect any building, wall, or structure about which complaints are filed | |
| 1598 by any person to the effect that a building, wall, or structure is or may be existing in | |
| 1599 | violation of this article. |
| 1600 | |
| 1601 (3) Reported violations. Inspect any building, wall, or structure reported (as hereinafter | |
| 1602 provided for) by the fire or police departments of this city as probably existing in | |
| 1603 | violation of this article. |
| 1604 | |
| 1605 (4) Dangerous buildings. Inspect such other buildings as shall from time to time come to | |
| 1606 his attention as possibly dangerous buildings within the terms of section 22-381. | |
| 1607 | |
| 1608 (5) Notice to owner. Notify, in writing, the owner, occupant, lessee, mortgagee, agent, and | |
| 1609 all other persons having an interest in said building, as shown by the land records of | |
| 1610 the recorder of deeds of the county, of any building found by him to be a dangerous | |
| 1611 | building within the standards set forth in section 22-381, that: |
| 1612 | |
| 1613 a. Duties of owner. The owner must vacate and close, or repair, or demolish said | |
| 1614 | building in accordance with the terms of the notice and this article; |
| 1615 | |
| 1616 b. Duties of occupant. The occupant or lessee must vacate and close said building or | |
| 1617 may have it repaired in accordance with the notice and remain in possession; | |
| 1618 | |
| 1619 c. Persons with interest. The mortgagee, agent, or other persons having an interest in | |
| 1620 said building, as shown by the land records of the recorder of deeds of the county, | |
| 1621 may, at their own risk, repair, vacate and close, or demolish the said building or | |
Página 154
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 43 Item #25.
1622 have such work or act done; provided that any person notified under this subsection 1623 to repair, vacate and close, or demolish any building shall be given such reasonable 1624 time, not exceeding 30 days, as may be necessary to do, or have done, the work or 1625 act required by the notice provided for herein; 1626 1627 d. Appeal. The person or entity receiving notice by the building inspector code official 1628 shall have the right to appeal his decision directly to the council and have a hearing 1629 conducted in accordance with the provisions of section 22-385 before council, 1630 provided that the notice of appeal is filed with the city clerk no later than five days 1631 after receiving notice from the building inspector code official. 1632 1633 (6) Order to remedy conditions. Set forth in the notice provided for in subsection (5) hereof 1634 a description of the building or structure deemed unsafe, a statement of the particulars 1635 which make the building or structure a dangerous building, and an order requiring the 1636 same to be put in such condition as to comply with the terms of this article within such 1637 length of time, not exceeding 30 days, as is reasonable. 1638 1639 (7) Noncompliance with notice. Report to the council any noncompliance with the notice 1640 provided for in subsections (5) and (6) hereof. 1641 1642 (8) Testify at hearings. Appear at all hearings conducted by the council and testify as to 1643 the condition of dangerous buildings. 1644 1645 (9) Notice on buildings. Place a notice on all dangerous buildings, reading as follows: 1646 "This building has been found to be a dangerous building by the building inspector 1647 code official. This notice is to remain on this building unit until it is repaired, vacated, 1648 and closed, or demolished in accordance with the notice which has been given to the 1649 owner, occupant, lessee, mortgagee, or agent of this building, and all other persons 1650 having an interest in said building, as shown by the land records of the recorder of 1651 deeds of Kent County. It is unlawful to remove this notice until such notice is complied 1652 with." 1653 1654 (10) Orders of council. Carry out all orders of the council to cause the repair, vacation, and 1655 closure, or demolition of dangerous buildings pursuant to section 22-385. In causing 1656 the vacation of the dangerous building, the building inspector code official may order 1657 the city utilities to be disconnected. In causing the closure of dangerous buildings, the 1658 building inspector code official may direct the removal from the building of all 1659 furniture, equipment, and other personal property left by vacated occupants. 1660 1661 Sec. 22-385. Hearing before council.
Página 155
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 44 Item #25.
| 1662 | The council of the city shall: |
| 1663 (1) Notice of hearing. Upon receipt of a report of the building inspector code official as | |
|---|---|
| 1664 provided for in section 22-384(7), give written notice to the owner, occupant, mortgagee, | |
| 1665 lessee, agent, and all other persons having an interest in said building, as shown by the | |
| 1666 records of the recorder of deeds of the county, to appear before it on the date specified in | |
| 1667 the notice to show cause why the building or structure reported to be a dangerous building | |
| 1668 should not be repaired, vacated and closed, or demolished in accordance with the statement | |
| 1669 of particulars set forth in the building inspector's code official’s notice provided for herein | |
| 1670 | in section 22-384(6). |
| 1671 | |
| 1672 (2) Conduct of hearing. Hold a hearing and hear such testimony as the building inspector code | |
| 1673 official or the owner, occupant, mortgagee, lessee, or any other person having an interest | |
| 1674 in said building, as shown by the land records of the recorder of deeds of the county, shall | |
| 1675 offer relative to the dangerous building. Hearings relative to reported dangerous buildings | |
| 1676 as defined in section 22-381(11) shall include the testimony of the city chief of police, who | |
| 1677 may submit arrest records, complaint records, and affidavits relative to the property as | |
| 1678 | evidence for the hearing. |
| 1679 | |
| 1680 (3) Findings. Make written findings of fact from the testimony offered pursuant to subsection | |
| 1681 (2) of this section as to whether or not the building in question is a dangerous building | |
| 1682 | within the terms of section 22-381. |
| 1683 | |
| 1684 (4) Order. Issue an order based upon findings of fact made pursuant to subsection (3) of this | |
| 1685 section, commanding the owner, occupant, mortgagee, lessee, agent, and all other persons | |
| 1686 having an interest in said building, as shown on the land records of the recorder of deeds | |
| 1687 of the county, to repair, vacate and close, or demolish any building found to be a dangerous | |
| 1688 building within the terms of this article, setting the time within which said building shall | |
| 1689 be repaired, vacated and closed, or demolished, and provided that any person so notified, | |
| 1690 except the owners, shall have the privilege of either vacating or repairing said dangerous | |
| 1691 building; or any person, not the owner of said dangerous building but having an interest in | |
| 1692 said building as shown by the land records of the recorder of deeds of the county may | |
| 1693 demolish said dangerous building at his own risk to prevent the acquiring of a lien against | |
| 1694 the land upon which said dangerous building stands by the city as provided in subsection | |
| 1695 | (5) hereof. |
| 1696 | |
| 1697 (5) Failure to comply. If the owner, occupant, mortgagee, or lessee fails to comply with the | |
| 1698 order provided for in subsection (4) hereof within ten days, cause such building or structure | |
| 1699 to be repaired, vacated and closed, or demolished, as the facts may warrant, under the | |
| 1700 standards hereinbefore provided for in section 22-384, and shall, with the assistance of the | |
| 1701 city solicitor, cause the costs of such repair, vacation, or demolition to be charged against | |
| 1702 the land on which the building existed as a municipal lien or cause such costs to be added | |
| 1703 to the tax duplicate as an assessment, or to be levied as a special tax against the land upon | |
| 1704 which the building stands or did stand, or to be recovered in a suit at law against the owner, | |
Página 156
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 45 Item #25.
1705 provided that in cases where such procedure is desirable and any delay thereby caused will 1706 not be dangerous to the health, morals, safety, or general welfare of the people of this city, 1707 the council shall notify the city solicitor to take legal action to force the owner to make all
| 1708 | necessary repairs or demolish the building. |
| 1709 | |
|---|---|
| 1710 (6) Report to solicitor. Report to the city solicitor the names of all persons not complying with | |
| 1711 | the order provided for in subsection (4) hereof. |
| 1712 | |
| 1713 | Sec. 22-386. Violations; penalty for disregarding notices or orders. |
| 1714 (a) Violations by owner. The owner of any dangerous building who shall fail to comply with | |
| 1715 any notice or order to repair, vacate and close, or demolish said building given by the | |
| 1716 council shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction thereof, shall be fined as | |
| 1717 | provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. |
| 1718 | |
| 1719 (b) Violations by occupant or lessee. The occupant or lessee in possession who fails to comply | |
| 1720 with any notice to vacate and close or who fails to repair said building in accordance with | |
| 1721 any notice given by the council as provided for in this article shall be guilty of a | |
| 1722 misdemeanor and, upon conviction thereof, shall be fined as provided for in Appendix F— | |
| 1723 | Fees and Fines. |
| 1724 | |
| 1725 (c) Removal of notice. Any person removing the notice provided for in section 22-384(9) shall | |
| 1726 be guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, shall be fined as provided for in | |
| 1727 | Appendix F—Fees and Fines. |
| 1728 | |
| 1729 (d) [Late payment.] Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the | |
| 1730 | day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. |
| 1731 | |
| 1732 | Sec. 22-387. Duties of the city solicitor. |
| 1733 | The city solicitor shall: |
| 1734 (1) Prosecutions. Prosecute all persons failing to comply with the terms of the order | |
| 1735 | provided for in section 22-385(4). |
| 1736 | |
| 1737 (2) Hearings. Appear at all hearings before the council in regard to dangerous buildings. | |
| 1738 | |
| 1739 (3) Collections. Bring suit to collect all municipal liens, assessments, or costs incurred in | |
| 1740 repairing or causing them to be vacated and closed or demolished dangerous buildings. | |
| 1741 | |
Página 157
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 46 Item #25.
1742 (4) Other legal action. Take such other legal action as is necessary to carry out the terms
| 1743 | and provisions of this article. |
| 1744 | |
|---|---|
| 1745 | Sec. 22-388. Emergency cases. |
| 1746 In cases where it reasonably appears that there is an immediate danger to the life or safety | |
| 1747 of any person, unless a dangerous building is immediately repaired, vacated, and closed, or | |
| 1748 demolished, the building inspector shall report such facts to the council, which may cause the | |
| 1749 immediate repair, vacation, or demolition of such dangerous building. The costs of such | |
| 1750 emergency repair, vacation, or demolition of such dangerous building shall be collected in the | |
| 1751 | same manner as provided in section 22-385(5). |
| 1752 | |
| 1753 | Sec. 22-389. Procedure when owner absent from the city. |
| 1754 In cases, except emergency cases, where the owner, occupant, lessee, or mortgagee is | |
| 1755 absent from the city, all notices or orders provided for herein shall be sent by registered or certified | |
| 1756 mail to the owner, occupant, mortgagee, lessee, and all other persons having an interest in said | |
| 1757 building, as shown by the land records of the recorder of deeds of the county, to the last known | |
| 1758 address of each, and a copy of such notice shall be posted in a conspicuous place on the dangerous | |
| 1759 building to which it relates. Such mailing and posting shall be deemed adequate service. | |
| 1760 | |
| 1761 | Sec. 22-390. Administrative liability. |
| 1762 No officer, agent, or employee of the city shall render himself personally liable for any | |
| 1763 damage that may accrue to persons or property as a result of any act required or permitted in the | |
| 1764 discharge of his duties under this article. Any suit against any officer, agent, or employee of the | |
| 1765 city as a result of any act required or permitted in the discharge of his duties under this article shall | |
| 1766 be defended by the city solicitor until the final determination of the proceedings therein. | |
| 1767 | |
| 1768 | Sec. 22-391. Duties of fire marshal and city employees. |
| 1769 The fire marshal, all members of the fire department, all officers of the police department, | |
| 1770 and all other employees of the city shall report, in writing, to the building inspector Division of | |
| 1771 Code Enforcement all buildings or structures within the city which shall come to their knowledge | |
| 1772 or attention as being dangerous buildings within the terms of this article. | |
| 1773 | |
| 1774 | Secs. 22-392—22-399. Reserved. |
| 1775 | |
|---|---|
| 1776 | ARTICLE XII. VACANT BUILDINGS |
| 1777 | |
| 1778 | Sec. 22-400. Purpose; applicability; definitions. |
Página 158
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 47 Item #25.
1779 (a) Purpose. The purpose and intent of this article is to establish a registration and 1780 identification program of vacant buildings within the city. Vacant buildings are detrimental 1781 to the surrounding buildings and neighborhoods in which they exist. The article is also to 1782 ensure the public health, safety, and welfare insofar as they are affected by vacant buildings 1783 within the city. The health, safety, and welfare of the neighborhoods in which vacant 1784 buildings are located are of the utmost importance to the city, as is the general community 1785 character in which these vacant buildings are located. 1786 1787 (b) Applicability. The provisions of this article shall apply to all matters affecting or relating 1788 to vacant buildings. Where, in this article, different sections of this Code may specify 1789 different requirements, the most restrictive shall govern. 1790 1791 (c) Definitions. The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this article, shall have 1792 meanings ascribed to them in this subsection, except where the context clearly indicates a 1793 different meaning. 1794 1795 (1) Vacant building means a building, structure, or dwelling that has been unoccupied for 1796 more than three consecutive months; or a commercial tenant space greater than 10,000 1797 square feet in an otherwise occupied building, that has been left unoccupied for more 1798 than three consecutive months. 1799 1800 (2) Actively for sale or lease means the building is being actively marketed through a 1801 licensed real estate broker or the owner who is regularly advertising the property in 1802 newspapers circulated in and around Dover, it is being offered for sale or lease at a cost 1803 of no more than 25 percent over market rate as determined by the city assessor, and the 1804 building is in reasonable condition for sale or lease, including but not limited to: no 1805 trash has collected inside or outside of the building, the utilities are functional, and it is 1806 not being used as storage that is unrelated to the former use. 1807 1808 Sec. 22-401. Monitoring, inspection, and condition standards. 1809 (a) The building inspector shall inspect any premises in the city for the purpose of enforcing 1810 and assuring compliance with the provisions of this article. Upon request of the building 1811 inspector, an owner shall provide access to all interior portions of a vacant building in order 1812 to permit a complete inspection. 1813 Once a building/structure/unit or residence (hereon after referred to as building) is registered as a 1814 vacant building, the vacant building shall be inspected annually for as long as it is considered 1815 vacant. 1816 1817 (b) The vacant building shall be secured; the exterior building and premises shall be 1818 maintained in accordance with all City of Dover Code requirements.
Página 159
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 48 Item #25.
1819 (c) The vacant building shall be in reasonable condition (all utilities shall be functional, there 1820 shall be no trash or debris inside or outside the building and it shall not to be used as storage 1821 that is unrelated to the former use). 1822 1823 Sec. 22-402. Agent—Responsible person required. 1824 (a) Property manager. Any owner of a vacant building, residing outside of the county, shall 1825 be required to have a licensed property manager residing or having an office located in the 1826 county, or a family member or other designated individual who does not manage any other 1827 real estate for a fee and who resides in the county acting as a property manager. The 1828 property manager, including family members and designated individuals, shall have 1829 charge, care, and control of the vacant building, and shall provide access to the vacant 1830 building for inspection upon request by the building inspector, within 30 days. 1831 1832 (b) Corporate or partnership owners. Any corporation or partnership owning a vacant building 1833 shall have a designated member, partner, or employee having charge, care, and control of 1834 the vacant building. The designated member, partner, or employee shall reside in or have 1835 an office located in the county or shall be required to have a licensed property manager 1836 residing or having an office located in the county, or another designated individual who 1837 does not manage any other real estate for a fee, and who resides in the county, acting as a 1838 property manager. The property manager, or other designated individuals shall have 1839 charge, care, and control of the vacant building, and shall provide access to the vacant 1840 building for inspection, upon request by the building inspector, within 30 days. 1841 1842 Sec. 22-403. Registration and registration fee. 1843 (a) Registration of building. There are two ways to register the building as vacant. 1844 1845 (1) The owner shall register with the city not later than 30 days after any building in the 1846 city becomes vacant, as defined. 1847 The registration of the vacant building shall include the site address, the name of the 1848 current owner or owners, current address of the owner and of all applicable owners, tax 1849 parcel number, proof of insurance on the building, description of the condition of the 1850 building, plans for the building (to eliminate the vacancy), the responsible person or 1851 agent and their contact information and any other applicable information. If any 1852 information changes the owner is responsible for informing the city of those changes 1853 in a timely manner. 1854 1855 (2) The building inspector or his designee, shall investigate any property that may be 1856 subject to registration. Based upon his findings, the building inspector may register the 1857 property as a vacant building subject to this chapter.
Página 160
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 49 Item #25.
1858 a. Notice of registration. Within five business days of such registration, the lLicensing 1859 and pPermitting oOffice shall notify the owners of the registered property by 1860 certified mail at their last known address according to the records of the city and 1861 Kent County. 1862 1863 b. Registration fee. 1864 i. The annual registration fee shall be paid at the time of registration. If the building 1865 inspector registers the building as vacant the fee shall be due not later than 30 1866 days after the building is registered as vacant. The annual registration fee will 1867 then be due on the registration anniversary date every year after that as long as 1868 it remains vacant. The starting point for counting a building as being vacant will 1869 begin on the date of the enactment of this article [June 26, 2006]. 1870 1871 ii. The annual fee is as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 1872 1873 Sec. 22-404. Violation and penalties. 1874 (a) If the registration fee is not paid within 30 days of being due, the owner shall be in violation 1875 of this article. 1876 1877 (1) A lien can be assessed against the property. Such fees shall be entered in the municipal 1878 lien docket as a lien owing the city, and the same may be turned over to the city solicitor 1879 for collection. 1880 1881 (2) The fee will be assessed to the parcel's tax bill. 1882 1883 (3) The fee shall be paid in full prior to the transfer of title. 1884 1885 (4) The fee shall be paid in full prior to the issuance of any building permits for the subject 1886 building and for any other building that is owned by the owner within the city. 1887 1888 Sec. 22-405. Exemptions—Types of buildings eligible for exemption status from the 1889 registration fee. 1890 (a) The following are exempt from the registration: The building has fire damage. The owner 1891 has 90 days to file for a permit to start construction or demolition or it will be determined 1892 a vacant property. 1893
Página 161
Proposed Ordinance #2024-15 – Chapter 22 – Buildings and Building Regulations Page 50 Item #25.
1894 (b) The following properties shall be registered as vacant, but they are exempt from the
| 1895 | registration fee: |
| 1896 | |
|---|---|
| 1897 (1) The building is actively being offered for sale or lease for a maximum period of five | |
| 1898 years. After such time this article will be in effect. Proof of activity shall fall on the | |
| 1899 | owner to provide. See definition. |
| 1900 | |
| 1901 (2) The owner has obtained a building permit and is progressing in an expedient manner | |
| 1902 | to prepare the premises for occupancy. |
| 1903 | |
| 1904 (3) The property is in probate or where the owner has entered a long-term care facility | |
| 1905 | within six months of the building being vacant. |
| 1906 | |
| 1907 (4) The property is undergoing currently undergoing environmental cleanup or | |
| 1908 | assessment. |
| 1909 | |
| 1910 (c) Failure to register. If the owner of the property fails to register the property with the City | |
| 1911 of Dover within 30 days of notification to do so by the City of Dover staff, then the property | |
| 1912 | owner/agent may not be entitled to exemption from the fees. |
| 1913 | |
| 1914 | Sec. 22-406. Appeal of the 25 percent over market rate. |
| 1915 An appeal of the 25 percent over market rate (from the actively for sale or lease definition) | |
| 1916 can be considered through an appraisal using accepted appraisal standards to determine market | |
| 1917 rate. The owner has the option of asking the city tax assessor to perform the appraisal or having | |
| 1918 one performed (using accepted appraisal standards) at their own expense. | |
| 1919 | ADOPTED: * |
| 1920 | |
| 1921 | SYNOPSIS |
| 1922 This proposed amendment to this chapter removes language that requires the doubling of fines. | |
| 1923 The amendments also add transparency defining how and when a fine is issued. The language that | |
| 1924 has been added and updated clarifies the responsibility of the property owner. This proposal also | |
| 1925 | defines the penalties for life safety violations. |
| 1926 | |
| 1927 | (SPONSORS: ANDERSON and HUGG) |
| 1928 | |
| 1929 | Action History |
| 1930 | 06/24/2024 – Scheduled for Final Reading – City Council |
| 1931 | 06/10/2024 – First Reading – City Council |
| 1932 05/14/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and | |
| 1933 | Administration Committee |
Página 162
Item #26.
FINAL READING
FINAL READING
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-16
| 1 | BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN |
| 2 | COUNCIL MET: |
| 3 | |
|---|---|
| 4 That Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection, be amended by inserting the text indicated in | |
| 5 bold, blue, italics and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows: | |
| 6 | |
| 7 | ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL |
| 8 | |
| 9 | Sec. 46-0. Definitions. |
| 10 | |
| 11 The following words, terms, and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings | |
| 12 ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: | |
| 13 | |
| 14 Automatic telephone dialing device and digital alarm communicator system means an | |
| 15 alarm system which automatically sends a prerecorded voice message or coded signal over regular | |
| 16 telephone lines, by direct connection or otherwise, indicating the existence of the emergency | |
| 17 | situation that the alarm system is designed to detect. |
| 18 | |
| 19 Barbecuing—Commercial means the preparation and cooking of food by way of gas grill, | |
| 20 charcoal grill, or other apparatus used for the cooking of food by way of flame produced through | |
| 21 wood, charcoal, or gas for the purpose of cooking food for the sale to and/or consumption by the | |
| 22 | general public. |
| 23 | |
| 24 Barbecuing—Recreational means the preparation and cooking of food by way of gas grill, | |
| 25 charcoal grill, or other apparatus used for the cooking of food by way of flame produced through | |
| 26 wood, charcoal, or gas for the purpose of cooking food for the consumption by a family and/or | |
| 27 guests or by the membership of a private organization or church congregation. | |
| 28 | |
| 29 Bollard means a solid post that conforms to the dimensions outlined in this section which | |
| 30 is constructed of concrete, steel, or other durable material approved by the Fire Marshal, cored into | |
| 31 a hard surface that is buried in the ground, designed to protect buildings and utilities by absorbing | |
| 32 | the impact of a motor vehicle collision. |
| 33 | |
| 34 Code enforcement officer shall mean fire marshals, police officers, and inspectors | |
| 35 | employed by the city. |
| 36 | |
| 37 Emergency shall mean any situation where the Dover Fire Department or any assisting fire | |
| 38 department is called to perform firefighting, rescue, or life saving life-saving operations within the | |
Página 163
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 2
| 39 | limits of the city. |
| 40 | |
|---|---|
| 41 Fine means the assessment of a monetary charge, payable to the city, authorized pursuant | |
| 42 to this section, to defray the expenses of responding to a preventable alarm or alarm malfunction. | |
| 43 | |
| 44 Fire alarm installation report means a report, in a form approved by the fire marshal, with | |
| 45 | the following minimum information: |
| 46 | |
| 47 (1) The name, address, business, and home telephone number of the owner, lessee, operator, | |
| 48 manager, or person in possession of the premises wherein the alarm system is installed. | |
| 49 | |
| 50 (2) The name, address, and telephone number of a minimum of two persons who can be | |
| 51 notified by the Robbins Hose Company in the event of the activation of the alarm system, | |
| 52 who shall be capable of responding to the premises within 30 minutes, and who are | |
| 53 | authorized to enter the premises to ascertain the status thereof. |
| 54 Fire alarm malfunction means the activation of any alarm, which results in the response of | |
| 55 the fire department, caused by mechanical failure, malfunction, improper installation, or lack | |
| 56 | of proper maintenance. |
| 57 | |
| 58 Fire alarm system means any mechanical, electrical, or radio-controlled device which is | |
| 59 designed to emit a sound or transmit a signal or message when activated or any such device | |
| 60 which emits a sound and transmits a signal or message when activated because of smoke, heat, | |
| 61 or fire. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing, the term "fire alarm system" shall be | |
| 62 deemed to include audible alarms at the site of the installation of the detection device, | |
| 63 proprietor alarms and automatic telephone direct dial devices, or digital alarm communicator | |
| 64 systems. A single-station alarm device shall not be deemed to be an alarm system under this | |
| 65 | section. |
| 66 | |
| 67 Fire alarm technician means any person who inspects, installs, repairs, or performs | |
| 68 maintenance on fire alarm systems and is licensed by the state or works under a state-licensed | |
| 69 | alarm contractor. |
| 70 | |
| 71 Fire protection system shall include any electronic or mechanical system designed and | |
| 72 installed to detect and alert, suppress, or seal off smoke and fire from the occupants of a | |
| 73 | building. |
| 74 | |
| 75 Impact protection means any bollards, walls, concrete barriers, or other devices, subject to | |
| 76 the approval of the fire marshal, used to stop vehicles or equipment in motion. | |
| 77 | |
| 78 Impairment means any effective lessening of the equipment to operate as designed, | |
| 79 | including times of maintenance and annual testing. |
| 80 | |
| 81 Means of egress means the most current edition of the National Fire Prevention Association | |
| 82 Life Safety Code shall be used to determine the definition of the term "means of egress." | |
| 83 | |
| 84 Open burning means the burning of materials wherein products of combustion are emitted | |
Página 164
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 3
85 directly into the ambient air without passing through a stack or chimney from an enclosed
| 86 | chamber. |
| 87 | |
|---|---|
| 88 Operative alarm system means an alarm system which the owner of a premises is required | |
| 89 to maintain in an operative condition pursuant to statute, law, ordinance, rule, or regulation of | |
| 90 | the state or the city. |
| 91 | |
| 92 Outdoor fireplace means any homemade or commercially produced fireplace, fire pit, or | |
| 93 | fire ring used for the kindling of wood. |
| 94 | |
| 95 Owner means any person who owns the premises in which an alarm system is installed or | |
| 96 the person or persons who lease, operate, occupy, or manage the premises. | |
| 97 | |
| 98 Premises means any building or structure, or combination of buildings and structures, | |
| 99 which serve as dwelling units, single-family or multifamily, or any other area within a building | |
| 100 or structure, or combination thereof, which is used for any purpose, other than residential, | |
| 101 | wherein an alarm system is installed. |
| 102 | |
| 103 Preventable alarm means the activation of any alarm, which results in the response of the | |
| 104 fire department, caused by the negligence or intentional misuse of the system by the owner or | |
| 105 his/her employees, servants, or agents; or any other activation not caused by heat, smoke, or | |
| 106 fire, exclusive of a "fire alarm malfunction" as defined in this section. An alarm is not | |
| 107 considered a preventable alarm if the alarm is activated due to malicious causes beyond the | |
| 108 | control of the owner. |
| 109 | |
| 110 Serve means hand-delivery, by a representative of either the fire department or police | |
| 111 department, to the owner or authorized representative who responded to the premises. In the | |
| 112 event the owner or authorized representative fails to respond to the premises within 30 minutes, | |
| 113 the term "serve" shall mean placing the form or other matter in the United States mail, | |
| 114 | addressed to the owner or authorized representative. |
| 115 | |
| 116 Single-station alarm device means an assembly incorporating the detector, control | |
| 117 equipment, and alarm-sounding device in one unit, operated from a power supply either in the | |
| 118 | unit or obtained at the point of installation. |
| 119 | |
| 120 | Sec. 46-1. Means of egress. |
| 121 | |
| 122 (a) Obstructions. The means of egress for an occupancy shall be kept continuously free of all | |
| 123 obstructions or impediments to full instant use in case of fire or emergency. | |
| 124 | |
| 125 (b) Exit doors. All required exit doors shall be unlocked and under the control of the occupants | |
| 126 within the building or area. This subsection is to include fenced-in outdoor events. | |
| 127 | |
| 128 | |
| 129 (c) Duty of owner, manager. It shall be the responsibility of the owner, manager, principal, or | |
| 130 any other person responsible for the day-to-day operations of the occupancy to ensure that | |
Página 165
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 4
131 exits are unobstructed and unlocked prior to the opening of the occupancy to the general 132 public. 133 134 (d) Merchandise in exits. In mercantile occupancies, merchandise is prohibited from being 135 displayed in any required exit access, exit, or exit discharge. Merchandise may be displayed 136 in the exit access, exit, or exit discharge of mercantile occupancies that have submitted a 137 written plan for the display of such merchandise, and the plan has been reviewed and 138 approved by the fFire mMarshal's oOffice. 139 140 (e) Penalties. If any exit access, exit, or exit discharge, with the exception of a locked exit 141 door, is found to be in violation of this section, a summons shall be issued as provided for 142 in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. Any required exit door found to be locked against egress 143 shall be in violation of this section and a summons shall be issued for each locked exit as 144 provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 145 146 Sec. 46-2. Obedience to state fire and safety laws and regulations. 147 148 (a) Health and safety laws. No person shall violate any of the provisions of Title 16, chapters 149 65—74, part VI of the Health and Safety of the Delaware Code (16 Del. C. §§ 6501— 150 7418). The penalties for such violations issued by the city shall be in accordance with those 151 issued by the state for the same offense. 152 153 (b) Fire prevention regulations. No person shall violate any of the provisions of the most 154 recently adopted state fire prevention regulations as now or hereafter amended. The 155 penalties for such violations shall be in accordance with those issued by the state for the 156 same offense. 157 158 Sec. 46-3. Impairment of fire protection equipment. 159 160 (a) Prohibited. It shall be a violation of this chapter for any owner, renter, lessor, or contractor, 161 after having been notified, in writing, by the fire marshal or code enforcement officer of 162 any impairment to fire protection equipment, including but not limited to fire hydrants, fire 163 alarm systems, sprinkler systems, commercial cooking ventilation, fire suppression 164 systems, standpipes, and smoke removal or pressurization systems, to allow it to remain 165 impaired for any time beyond that allowed by the fire marshal for repair. 166 167 (b) Impairment of fire protection systems. All fire protection systems, devices, units, and 168 service equipment shall be maintained in an operational condition at all times, and it shall 169 be unlawful for any person owning, controlling, or otherwise having charge of any fire 170 protection system to willfully or knowingly tamper with or impair the system from 171 operating as designed without proper approval. An approval form may be obtained from 172 the fFire mMarshal's oOffice. Approvals will not be required for temporary impairments 173 caused by periodic testing and inspection. Any impairment which will render the system 174 non-operational or out of service for more than eight hours for testing and inspection 175 purposes must be approved prior to the start of work.
Página 166
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 5
176 177 (c) Notification required. The owner, tenant, or contractor shall notify the Robbins Hose 178 Company of any impaired fire protection equipment, and shall renotify the Robbins Hose 179 Company when the fire protection equipment has been restored to normal service. 180 Certification from the repairing contractor shall be required to verify that the system has 181 been fixed and is functioning as designed. 182 183 (d) Fire watch required. When any impairment would cause a sprinkler system not to operate 184 or a fire alarm system not to detect and signal a fire, and if the building is to remain 185 occupied, a fire watch shall be established in that building or that portion of a building 186 affected. It shall be the responsibility of the owner or tenant to set up the fire watch. The 187 fire watch shall consist of an hourly check of the building or portion of the building 188 affected, and a log kept, there stating the date, time of the checks, and who was making the 189 checks. This log shall be accessible for immediate inspection by the fire chief, fire marshal, 190 or code enforcement officer. 191 192 (e) Authority of fire marshal. The fire marshal or his/her designee is authorized to close any 193 such building or property where fire protection equipment is found to be impaired or non- 194 operational to ensure the life safety of the occupants. 195 196 (f) Fines. Any owner, occupant, contractor, or corporate body found to be in violation of this 197 section shall be issued a summons as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 198 199 Sec. 46-4. Impact protection of natural gas and LP gas devices. 200 201 All natural gas and LP gas installations shall be installed per adopted NFPA and 202 International codes, with the following amendments: 203 204 (a) When required. The installation of natural gas and LP gas meters, regulators, valves, 205 and LP gas bottles shall be protected from impact damage by impact protection. Natural 206 gas and LP gas meters, regulators, and valves located inside structures shall have 207 impact protection, except when located in separate protected utility rooms. The fire 208 marshal and/or chief building inspector shall reserve the right to apply this section 209 whenever it is deemed necessary to provide impact protection to address a life or fire 210 hazard. 211 212 (b) Dimensions of bollards. Bollards shall be a minimum of six-inch diameter filled with 213 concrete. The bollard shall be set into the ground at a depth of at least 36 inches (three 214 ft.) and embedded in concrete at a minimum of 18 inches surrounding the bollard. The 215 bollards must be a least 48 inches (four ft.) in height above the finish grade elevation. 216 Any deviation of the stated requirements must be approved by the fire marshal and/or 217 chief building inspector. The above dimensions shall serve as the requirement for 218 installation; however, the fire marshal and/or chief building inspector shall have the
Página 167
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 6
219 authority to require more stringent dimensions to fit the needs of devices warranting 220 impact protection. 221 222 (c) Color of bollards. Bollards should be of the following colors: yellow, amber, or orange. 223 All colors shall be of fluorescent or have a reflective coating. Any deviation of the 224 stated requirements must be approved by the fire marshal and/or chief building 225 inspector. 226 227 (d) Responsibility. It shall be the responsibility of the property owner and/or contractor for 228 the new installation to ensure that natural gas and LP gas meters, regulators, and valves 229 are protected in accordance with these regulations. 230 231 (e) Compliance period. All new construction projects shall comply with the provisions of 232 this section. All existing multiple dwellings, schools, nursing homes, hospitals, and 233 daycare centers shall be protected in accordance with this section. All other existing 234 structures shall be protected when deemed a life or fire hazard by the fire marshal. 235 236 (f) Exemptions. Single-family homes, including townhouses, duplexes, and manufactured 237 housing, except where natural gas and LP gas devices are located directly in front of 238 head-in parking spaces and driveways, and where the fire marshal deems that impact 239 protection is not necessary, shall be exempt from this section. 240 241 Sec. 46-5. Open burning. 242 243 (a) Permit required. Open burning of structures, brush, or bonfires shall not be permitted 244 without a permit obtained from the fire marshal. 245 246 (b) Fire dimensions. Open burning, when permitted, shall be kindled in such a manner as not 247 to be a danger to other campers, recreational vehicles, tents, or structures and shall not be 248 of a size greater than 18 inches by 18 inches by 18 inches. Height of the fire shall be 249 measured from the ground or from the bottom of the inside of the container being used to 250 kindle the fire. Open burning shall not be kindled directly on the ground unless contained 251 in a fire ring. 252 253 254 (c) Fire clearances and time restrictions. Outdoor fireplaces shall have 36 inches clearance 255 from all combustibles when in use. Portable fireplaces, fire pits, or fire rings shall be 256 extinguished in a residential area between the hours of 12:00 midnight and 8:00 a.m. 257 258 (d) Commercial barbecuing. Commercial barbecuing shall be permitted under the following 259 conditions: 260 261 (1) The location has been approved by city licensing and inspections and the fire marshal 262 and an outdoor public gathering permit has been obtained. 263
Página 168
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 7
264 (2) One fire extinguisher of not less than five pounds ABC is to be located within ten feet 265 of the cooking area. Cooking area and cooking fuels shall be secured from public
| 266 | access. |
| 267 | |
|---|---|
| 268 | (3) Approval from the bBoard of pPublic hHealth has been obtained. |
| 269 | |
| 270 (4) The operator shall make all reasonable attempts to avoid causing a nuisance to nearby | |
| 271 | property owners with smoke, fumes, or sparks. |
| 272 | |
| 273 (5) All compressed flammable gas containers used for cooking shall be secured in such a | |
| 274 | way as to prevent them from being knocked, tipped, or blown over. |
| 275 Any commercial barbecuing operations which are a continual nuisance because of smoke, | |
| 276 fumes, or sparks shall be terminated by the code official, or fire marshal and the outdoor public | |
| 277 gathering permit revoked until such time as the director of licensing and inspections is satisfied | |
| 278 | that the problem has been corrected. |
| 279 | |
| 280 Barbecuing of any kind shall not be kindled within 200 feet of any fuel pump or storage tank fill. | |
| 281 Cooking grease shall not be disposed of by placing it directly on the ground or in stormwater | |
| 282 | drains. |
| 283 | |
| 284 | (e) Prohibited. |
| 285 | |
| 286 (1) Multifamily residential dwelling units. In apartment buildings, condominiums, or any | |
| 287 other multifamily residential dwelling of three or more units by any other name, the | |
| 288 storage of propane tanks inside units or on balconies is prohibited. Recreational | |
| 289 barbecuing shall be prohibited on any balcony or under any overhanging portion or | |
| 290 within 15 feet of any structure, except that the use of electrical ranges or electrical grills | |
| 291 shall be permitted. The use of outdoor fireplaces on balconies is prohibited. | |
| 292 | |
| 293 (2) Unattended burning. It shall be prohibited for open burning, commercial barbecuing, | |
| 294 and outdoor fireplaces to be unattended at any time. In the event that any open burning, | |
| 295 commercial barbecuing, or outdoor fireplaces are found to be unattended, the fire | |
| 296 marshal, code official, fire officer, or police shall order the open burning extinguished. | |
| 297 (f) Fines. Any owner, occupant, contractor, or corporate body found to be in violation of this | |
| 298 section shall be issued a summons as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. | |
| 299 | |
| 300 (g) Authority of the fire marshal. The fire marshal is authorized to impose a ban on open | |
| 301 burning if weather conditions do not safely permit open burning. The fire marshal or fire | |
| 302 officer shall order any fire extinguished that is deemed unsafe or not in compliance with | |
| 303 | this section of the Dover Code. |
| 304 | |
| 305 | Sec. 46-6. False fire alarms generally. |
| 306 | |
| 307 (a) Prohibited. No person shall willfully make, or cause to be made, any false alarm of fire by | |
| 308 means of the fire alarm telegraph system, or by means of any public or private alarm | |
Página 169
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 8
309 system, or by telephone, or by word of mouth, or by any other means of communication
| 310 | whatsoever. |
| 311 | |
|---|---|
| 312 (b) Tests. This section shall not apply to city, state, or federal employees who are testing such | |
| 313 alarms or are otherwise working with the same in their normal course of employment. | |
| 314 | |
| 315 | Sec. 46-7. Preventable and malfunctioning alarms to the fire company. |
| 316 | |
| 317 (a) Responsibility for malfunctioning and preventable alarms, owner response, and corrective | |
| 318 | action. |
| 319 | |
| 320 (1) Generally. The responsibility for a preventable or malfunctioning alarm shall be that of | |
| 321 the owner of the premises in which the fire alarm system is installed. A response to a | |
| 322 preventable or malfunctioning alarm shall result when any fire marshal or member of | |
| 323 the fire department shall be dispatched to the premises where the alarm has been | |
| 324 activated or learns of the activation of the alarm system, by any means whatsoever, and | |
| 325 responds thereto by traveling to that premises. After responding to a malfunctioning or | |
| 326 preventable alarm, the responding official shall notify the owner, or his/her authorized | |
| 327 representative and such person shall thereupon travel to the premises to ascertain the | |
| 328 status thereof. Should the person notified fail to appear at said premises within 30 | |
| 329 minutes after being notified to do so, the fire marshal may issue the owner of the | |
| 330 premises a fine as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. The official or member | |
| 331 of the fire department who responded to said premises shall notify the fFire mMarshal's | |
| 332 | oOffice. |
| 333 | |
| 334 (2) Malfunction. In the event of a fire alarm deemed by the responding official to be the | |
| 335 result of a fire alarm malfunction, the owner will be served a notice of violation form, | |
| 336 indicating that the activation was deemed to be the result of a fire alarm malfunction, | |
| 337 and requiring the owner to provide documentation that the fire alarm component that | |
| 338 caused the fire alarm malfunction has been corrected, to the satisfaction of the fire | |
| 339 marshal, and that the fire alarm system in question has actually been examined by a fire | |
| 340 alarm technician and that a bona fide attempt has been made to identify and correct any | |
| 341 defect of design, installation or operation of the fire alarm system which was | |
| 342 identifiable as the cause of the fire alarm malfunction. Failure to return documentation | |
| 343 of service/repair within the period of time stated on the notice of violation, which is | |
| 344 satisfactory to the fire marshal, will result in assessment against the owner of a fine for | |
| 345 the fire alarm malfunction as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. | |
| 346 | |
| 347 (b) Fine charges; multiple fire alarm malfunctions or preventable alarms. | |
| 348 | |
| 349 (1) Amount of fine. A fine may be assessed for the third and subsequent malfunctioning or | |
| 350 preventable alarms at the same premises responded to by the fire department within the | |
| 351 prior 12-month period. Thereafter, the fines, as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and | |
| 352 Fines, shall be paid by the owner for each preventable or malfunctioning fire alarm | |
| 353 responded to by the fire department at the same premises during a 12-month period | |
| 354 | beginning with the date of the first alarm. |
Página 170
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 9
355 356 (2) Panel reset. Once a preventable alarm or fire alarm malfunction has been responded to 357 by the fire department, it shall be unlawful for the alarm panel to be reset by any person 358 until the authorization of the fire department has been obtained. A fine as provided for 359 in Appendix F—Fees and Fines may be assessed to the owner of a premises where the 360 fire alarm has been reset before the fire department or assisting fire department arrives. 361 362 (3) Insufficient alarms. When any premises are protected by a fire alarm system that, in the 363 opinion of the fire marshal or his/her deputy(ies), will not safely alarm the occupants 364 of a fire, the fire marshal or his/her deputy(ies) may close said building, or a portion of 365 said building, to human occupancy until the problem with the fire alarm is corrected 366 and a written report from a licensed fire alarm company is submitted to the fire marshal. 367 368 Sec. 46-8. Maintaining a known violation or hazard. 369 370 (a) Known violation or hazard. Any person is guilty of maintaining a known violation or 371 hazard if: 372 373 (1) After having been informed in writing by a code enforcement officer of a violation of 374 the fire code, property maintenance code, a city ordinance, or state law existing on 375 property he or she owns or occupies, he or she fails to correct the said violation; 376 377 (2) He or she prevents a fire protection system from functioning as designed; 378 379 (3) He or she knows that a fire protection system will not function as designed and takes 380 no action to repair the fire protection system; 381 382 (4) He or she interferes with any occupant's egress from a building; 383 384 (5) He or she knows of an obstruction that would interfere with any occupant's egress form 385 from a building and takes no action to remove the obstruction; 386 387 (6) He or she engages in any act, written or verbal, within city limits that obstructs, delays, 388 hinders, or interferes with the operations of the fire department during an emergency. 389 390 (b) Penalties. 391 392 (1) Any fines issued for violation of this section shall be issued as provided for in Appendix 393 F—Fees and Fines. 394 395 (2) Occupancies that continue to maintain a known violation or hazard may be closed by 396 the code enforcement officer until such time as all violations and hazards have been 397 corrected. 398 399 Sec. 46-9. Fire hydrants and fire department connections.
Página 171
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 10
400 401 (a) It shall be unlawful for any person to park, place, or keep any vehicle or object within ten 402 feet of a fire hydrant or fire department connection on any city street or public property. 403 404 (b) Fire hydrants public and private shall have their tops painted with the appropriate color to 405 indicate flow, and the remainder of the hydrant shall not be painted any color other than 406 red unless approved by the fire marshal and public works department. 407 408 (c) It shall be unlawful to knowingly impair or tamper with a fire hydrant or fire department 409 connection so as to make it non-operational when needed. 410 411 (d) It shall be unlawful for any person other than members of a fire department engaged in the 412 performance of their duties, any person in the event of an emergency endangering life or 413 property, or any city department for authorized purposes to open, use, or take water from 414 any fire hydrant. 415 416 (e) During times of inclement weather, snow shall not be plowed or piled so as to obstruct the 417 use of fire hydrants on private property. 418 419 (f) Fire hydrants shall be installed per the requirements of the City of Dover Public Utilities 420 Water/Wastewater Handbook, NFPA requirements, and Delaware State Fire Prevention 421 Regulations. 422 423 Sec. 46-10. Report of fires required; spreading of alarm. 424 It shall be the duty of the owner, manager, occupant, responsible person, or any person in 425 direct control of any building or premises of any kind, upon discovery of a fire or evidence of 426 there having been a fire even though it has apparently been extinguished, or upon receiving 427 information that there is or was a fire on the premises, to immediately and with all reasonable 428 dispatch and diligence call or otherwise notify the fire department of the existence, 429 circumstances, and location of such fire and to spread an alarm to all occupants of the building. 430 This requirement shall not be construed to forbid any person to use all diligence necessary to 431 extinguish such fire prior to the arrival of the fire department. 432 433 Sec. 46-11. Unlawful regulation or order. 434 435 No person shall make, issue, post, or maintain any regulation or order, written or verbal, 436 that would require any person to take any unnecessary delaying action prior to reporting a fire 437 to the fire department. 438 439 Sec. 46-12. Maintaining records for inspections. 440 441 The building or property owner or manager of any occupancy required to have an annual 442 fire/life safety inspection conducted by the fFire mMarshal's oOffice shall maintain a fire 443 inspection log with the documentation pertinent to that occupancy for the preceding three years, 444 as follows: 445
Página 172
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 11
446 (1) Annual fire alarm system certificate of inspections. 447 448 (2) Annual fire suppression system certificate of inspections. 449 450 (3) Annual hood suppression system certificate of inspections. 451 452 (4) Annual elevator certification of inspection. 453 454 (5) Annual fire extinguisher inspection paperwork. 455 456 (6) Six-month steam cleaning paperwork for hood suppression system. 457 458 (7) Two-year boiler inspection paperwork. 459 460 (8) Three - or five-year electrical inspection paperwork. 461 462 (9) Current respondent information. 463 464 (10) Monthly fire extinguishers visual check. 465 466 (11) Monthly exit lights test. 467 468 (12) Monthly emergency lighting test. 469 (13) Monthly generator run. 470 471 (14) Self-closing fire door and exit hardware. 472 473 (15) Fire drills. 474 475 Secs. 46-13—46-40. Reserved. 476 477 478 ARTICLE II. FIRE DEPARTMENT 479 480 DIVISION 1. GENERALLY 481 482 483 Sec. 46-41. Created; purpose. 484 485 There is hereby created a city fire department, which shall protect and prevent against the 486 hazard of fire. Robbins Hose Company No. 1, Inc., is hereby recognized and designated as the fire 487 company of the city in accordance with the city Charter and this Code. 488 489 Sec. 46-42. Control; board of directors. 490 491 The fire chief and president of the fire department will be the liaisons from the fire
Página 173
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 12
492 department to the City of Dover. Any rules and regulations will be negotiated between the fire 493 department and the City of Dover and approved by the fire department membership and city
| 494 | council. |
| 495 | |
|---|---|
| 496 | Sec. 46-43. Semiannual inspections. |
| 497 | |
| 498 In the months of April and October of each year, the city manager shall inspect the fire | |
| 499 department with the fire chief and president, make inquiries as to the standing and efficiency of | |
| 500 the fire companies, investigate the capabilities of the officers of the fire department and the | |
| 501 operators of fire department apparatus, and make a report to the city council, in writing, stating the | |
| 502 results of their inspection and investigation and making those recommendations which they may | |
| 503 | deem proper. |
| 504 | |
| 505 | Sec. 46-44. Interference with discharge of duty. |
| 506 | |
| 507 It shall be unlawful for any unauthorized person to break through the established fire | |
| 508 barriers at a fire, to refuse to move from within the fire barriers, or to, in any manner, interfere | |
| 509 with or hinder any member of the fire department in the discharge of their duties. | |
| 510 | |
| 511 | Sec. 46-45. Reserved. |
| 512 | |
| 513 | |
| 514 | Sec. 46-46. Appeal of suspension. |
| 515 | |
| 516 Upon suspension from the fire department, the suspended member, officer, or fire company | |
| 517 shall have the right to appeal to the city council, which, upon giving notice and an opportunity to | |
| 518 be heard to those persons concerned, shall confirm the suspension or reinstate the member, officer | |
| 519 | or fire company. |
| 520 | |
| 521 | Secs. 46-47—46-70. Reserved. |
| 522 | |
| 523 | |
| 524 | DIVISION 2. OFFICERS |
| 525 | |
| 526 | Sec. 46-71. Generally. |
| 527 | |
| 528 The officers of the fire department, from highest rank to lowest rank, shall respectively be | |
| 529 fire chief, deputy fire chief, four assistant fire chiefs, and two fire captains. | |
| 530 | |
| 531 | Sec. 46-72. Annual appointment by council. |
| 532 | |
| 533 The fire chief, the deputy fire chief, the assistant fire chiefs, and the fire captains shall be | |
| 534 appointed at the first regular city council meeting in December by the city council. The | |
| 535 appointments shall be made from the duly elected nominees of each fire company as provided in | |
| 536 section 46-77. If, however, the city council deems the nominees or any one of them unsatisfactory, | |
| 537 it may refuse to appoint those nominees and instead may order a special election in accordance | |
Página 174
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 13
538 with the provisions of this article to choose another nominee or slate of nominees. 539
| 540 | Sec. 46-73. Qualifications. |
| 541 | |
|---|---|
| 542 (a) Nomination. No person shall be considered a candidate for nominee election as fire chief, | |
| 543 deputy fire chief, fire captain, or assistant fire chief unless they shall have been regularly | |
| 544 nominated for that office and their name shall appear upon the official ballot for that office | |
| 545 | at the nominee election. |
| 546 | |
| 547 (b) Prerequisites; exception. The fire chief, deputy fire chief, assistant fire chiefs, and fire | |
| 548 captains shall follow the Constitution and by-laws of the Robbins Hose Company. | |
| 549 | |
| 550 | Sec. 46-74. Terms. |
| 551 | |
|---|---|
| 552 (a) Calendar year. The fire department officers shall serve from the Tuesday after the first city | |
| 553 council meeting in December until the following Tuesday after the first city council | |
| 554 meeting in December, except that an appointee to fill a vacancy shall assume the post upon | |
| 555 | qualification. |
| 556 | |
| 557 (b) End of service. If a successor has not been elected and qualified for office at the expiration | |
| 558 of an officer's term, then the incumbent shall serve until their successor is duly elected and | |
| 559 | qualified. |
| 560 | |
| 561 | Sec. 46-75. Date of election of nominees. |
| 562 | |
| 563 The election of nominees for fire department officers shall be held each year on the third | |
| 564 | Monday in November. |
| 565 | |
| 566 | Sec. 46-76. Notice of election of nominees. |
| 567 | |
| 568 The fire department secretary shall notify the various fire companies of the election of | |
| 569 nominees for fire department officers at least one week before the nominee election is to be held, | |
| 570 stating the time and place of the election. A copy of the notice shall at once be placed on the | |
| 571 bulletin boards of the respective firehouses by the secretaries of the fire companies. | |
| 572 | |
| 573 | Sec. 46-77. Election and voting regulations for nominees. |
| 574 | |
| 575 Each fire company shall conform to the following regulations for the conduct of nominee | |
| 576 | elections for fire department officers: |
| 577 | |
| 578 (1) Membership list. At least one week before the nominee election, the fire department | |
| 579 secretary and fire recorder shall post a list of its active members in good standing. These | |
| 580 lists shall be certified by the president and secretary of each fire company, shall be | |
Página 175
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 14
581 under seal, and shall be used by the judges of the nominee election to determine 582 qualified voters. 583 584 (2) Where and how election held. The nominee election shall take place at a firehouse 585 designated by the fire department president and shall be conducted by three judges 586 appointed by the fire department president for that purpose. 587 588 (3) Eligible voters. The nominee election judges shall not permit anyone to vote whose 589 name is not on one of the lists mentioned in subsection (1) of this section. If a member's 590 name appears on the lists, but it is proven to the satisfaction of the judges that they do 591 not meet the requirements of active membership, then that person shall cast a 592 challenged ballot. The term "active membership," for the purposes of this section, shall 593 mean a member who has responded to at least 125 of the alarms, by way of attendance, 594 during the year immediately preceding the certification of the voting list and is in the 595 category of active and life membership within the fire department. This requirement is 596 waived for any member who was on active duty in the military service during any 597 portion of that year and who is otherwise in good standing with their individual fire 598 company. 599 600 (4) Secret ballot. The nominee election shall be by secret ballot and each voter shall have 601 only one vote for each of the open nominee positions. 602 603 (5) When polls open. Polls shall open at 7:00 p.m. and shall close at 8:00 p.m. 604 605 (6) Absentee voting. Follows the Constitution and by-laws of the Robbins Hose Company. 606 607 Sec. 46-78. Certification of results of nominee election. 608 609 Immediately after the close of the nominee election polls, the election judges shall tally 610 and certify the results of the nominee election. The ballot box, together with the ballots, judges' 611 certification, and tally sheet, shall be sealed and delivered within 24 hours, to the city clerk. The 612 city clerk shall submit the results of the election, together with the accompanying materials, to the 613 city council at its next regular meeting following the election. 614 615 Sec. 46-79. Special nominee elections. 616 617 If the city council shall order a special nominee election, to be held as provided in section 618 46-72, in order to replace a person the city council refused to appoint, that special nominee election 619 shall be held at the time fixed by the fire department president and in the same manner as the 620 regular nominee elections are held. At the special election, the person whom the city council 621 refused to appoint shall not be voted for and any ballot cast for them shall not be counted. 622 623 Sec. 46-80. No contestants. 624 625 If there are no contestants available for any one of the fire department offices and this fact 626 is certified by the president and secretary of each of the fire companies, then the city council shall
Página 176
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 15
627 appoint those officers without holding the nominee election. 628 629 Sec. 46-81. Election to fill vacancy. 630 631 Whenever the office of fire chief, deputy fire chief, fire captain, or assistant fire chief shall 632 become vacant through the resignation, death, absence, or disability of any person holding that 633 office, the vacancy shall be filled by an election held by the qualified fire company members 634 affected by the loss of command. The election shall be held in the same manner and form as other 635 elections of the fire department, in accordance with the provisions of this division. 636 637 Sec. 46-82. Powers and duties of fire chief. 638 639 The fire chief shall: 640 641 (1) Control at fires. Have full control of the fire department at all fires. 642 643 (2) Assignment of duties. Assign to each fire company their respective duties, when 644 necessary. 645 (3) Implement rules. Implement those rules for the regulation and management of the fire 646 companies at fires, and for going to and returning from fires. 647 648 (4) Attend fires. 649 650 (5) Summon police. Have the authority to summon the police to maintain order and protect 651 property during the continuance of fires. 652 653 (6) Barriers. Cause barriers to be placed across the streets and sidewalks to prevent 654 accidents and interference with the workings of the fire department and to admit no one 655 within the enclosed limits, except equipped firefighters, the police, and in their 656 discretion, those persons immediately interested in the property. 657 658 (7) Demolish buildings. Have the power, when it is, in their opinion, absolutely necessary 659 to stop the spread of a conflagration, to cause to be pulled down or blown up those 660 buildings that shall be required to be removed. 661 662 (8) Enter private property. Have the power to cause those members of the fire department 663 that they shall deem proper, with the apparatus that shall be necessary, to enter upon 664 any private property for the purpose of extinguishing a fire. They may cause those 665 fences or other obstructions to be removed that they may deem necessary. 666 Sec. 46-83. Submission of annual report to city council. 667 668 The fire chief and president shall present the city council with a report at its annual meeting, 669 which shall state the fire suppression and administrative activities of the department. 670 671 Sec. 46-84. Powers and duties of deputy fire chief, assistant chiefs, and fire captains. 672
Página 177
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 16
673 (a) In the absence of the fire chief, the deputy fire chief, and the assistant fire chiefs, a fire 674 captain, who shall be predetermined by the fire chief, shall assume the powers and duties
| 675 | and be obeyed accordingly. |
| 676 | |
|---|---|
| 677 (b) In the absence of the fire chief, the deputy fire chief, and the assistant fire chiefs, the fire | |
| 678 captain shall then assume the powers and duties and be obeyed accordingly. | |
| 679 | |
| 680 (c) It shall be the duty of the deputy fire chief, the assistant fire chiefs, and the fire captain to | |
| 681 be present at all fires and to assist the fire chief in the discharge of the duties of their office. | |
| 682 | |
| 683 | Sec. 46-85. Reserved. |
| 684 | |
| 685 | Secs. 46-86—46-120. Reserved. |
| 686 | |
| 687 | ARTICLE III. FIRE CODES |
| 688 | Sec. 46-121. Adopted. |
| 689 | |
| 690 (a) International Fire Code adopted. A certain document, three copies of which are on file in | |
| 691 the lLicensing and pPermitting oOffice of the city, being marked and designated as | |
| 692 "International Fire Code, 2009 Edition," as published by the International Code Council, | |
| 693 be and is hereby adopted as the Fire Prevention Code of the City of Dover in the State of | |
| 694 Delaware; for the control of buildings, structures and premises as herein provided; and each | |
| 695 and all of the regulations, provisions, penalties, conditions and terms of said International | |
| 696 Fire Code, are hereby referred to, adopted and made part hereof as if fully set out in this | |
| 697 | section, with additions, insertions, deletions and changes as follows: |
| 698 Section 101.1 Insert "City of Dover", in place of [NAME OF JURISDICTION]. | |
| 699 Delete in their entirety: Sections 105.6 Required operational permits, through 105.7.12 | |
| 700 | Temporary membrane structures, tents, and canopies. |
| 701 | |
| 702 (b) National Fire Codes adopted. There is hereby adopted the most recently published edition | |
| 703 of the National Fire Prevention Association's (NFPA) National Fire Codes (excluding | |
| 704 NFPA Codes 11C, 13E, 402M, -41s, 422, 424M-473, 901-906, 1001-1041, 1201-1410, | |
| 705 1452-1999, 5000), three copies of which are on file in the office of the fire marshal. | |
| 706 | |
| 707 (c) The more restrictive provisions of the International Fire Codes as set forth in subsection | |
| 708 (a) above or the National Fire Codes as set forth in subsection (b) above shall apply | |
| 709 | whenever they may be in conflict. |
| 710 | |
| 711 (d) It shall be unlawful for any person to violate any of the provisions of the publications | |
| 712 | adopted in subsection (a) or (b). |
| 713 | |
Página 178
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 17
| 714 | Sec. 46-122. Definitions. |
| 715 | |
|---|---|
| 716 (a) Whenever the term "municipality" or "city" is used in the publications adopted by this | |
| 717 | article, it shall be construed to mean the city. |
| 718 | |
| 719 (b) Whenever the term "corporation counsel" or "city attorney" is used in the publications | |
| 720 adopted by this article, it shall be construed to mean the city solicitor. | |
| 721 | |
| 722 (c) Whenever, in the publications adopted by reference in this article, a term is used which is | |
| 723 also defined in appendix B to this Code pertaining to zoning, such term shall have the | |
| 724 | meaning provided in such appendix B. |
| 725 | |
| 726 | Sec. 46-123. Conflicting provisions. |
| 727 | |
| 728 In the event of any conflict between the provisions of the publications adopted by this | |
| 729 article and applicable provisions of state law, this Code or any other ordinance, rule or | |
| 730 regulation, the provisions of state law, this Code, or such other ordinance, rule or regulation | |
| 731 | shall prevail and be controlling. |
| 732 | |
| 733 | Sec. 46-124. Fire marshal. |
| 734 | |
| 735 (a) Selection. There shall be a fire marshal, who shall be selected by the city council at its | |
| 736 | annual meeting. |
| 737 | |
| 738 (b) Fire prevention. The fire marshal or his/her authorized agent shall enforce this article and | |
| 739 any other fire prevention provisions of this Code and any other fire prevention regulations | |
| 740 | applicable to the city. |
| 741 | |
| 742 (c) Investigation of fires. The fire marshal or his/her deputies shall be responsible for the | |
| 743 investigation of the origins and causes of fires and explosions within the corporate limits | |
| 744 of the city, which involve the loss of life or injury or cause destruction or damage to | |
| 745 property. Such investigation shall be initiated immediately upon the occurrence of such fire | |
| 746 or explosion. Upon request of the fire marshal, the city police shall be authorized to assist | |
| 747 the fire marshal in the performance of his/her duties. When any fire or explosion is found | |
| 748 to be suspicious or criminal in nature or causes serious injury or death, the fire marshal or | |
| 749 his/her deputies shall contact the city police and, per the agreement of the fire marshal and | |
| 750 chief of police, conduct a joint investigation into the origin and cause of the fire or | |
| 751 | explosion. |
Página 179
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 18
752 753 (d) Hazardous conditions. When, in the opinion of the fire marshal or code official, a fire or 754 life safety hazard is of imminent danger to occupants of a building, structure, or outdoor 755 event, the fire marshal or code official may order the unsafe condition removed, said 756 building or structure evacuated or outdoor event terminated. 757 758 (e) Right of entry. The fire marshal or his/her designee is authorized at all reasonable times to 759 enter and examine any building, marine vessel, vehicle, or premises for the purposes of 760 making fire safety inspections. Before entering a private building or dwelling, the fire 761 marshal or his/her designee shall obtain the consent of the occupant thereof or obtain a 762 search warrant authorizing his/her entry for the purpose of inspection, except in those 763 instances where an emergency exists. As used in this section, "emergency" means 764 circumstances which the fire marshal or his/her designee knows or has reason to believe 765 exist, and which reasonably may constitute immediate and grave danger to life or property. 766 (f) Implied consent. Application for, or acceptance of, any license or permit requested or 767 issued pursuant to City Code constitutes agreement and consent by the person making the 768 application or accepting the license or permit to allow the fire marshal or his/her designee 769 to enter the premises at any reasonable time to conduct such inspections as required by this 770 code or deemed necessary by the fire marshal or his/her designee to determine compliance 771 with the requirements for such license or permit. 772 773 (g) [Placard—Health hazard and unsafe to enter.] The fire marshal or code official may 774 placard any building damaged by fire or explosion as being a health hazard and unsafe to 775 enter. No one shall enter any building having been placarded by the fire marshal or code 776 official as being a health hazard and unsafe without first contacting the fire marshal. 777 778 (h) [Unlawful to enter.] It shall be unlawful to enter any premise, structure, building, or vehicle 779 which has been damaged by fire or explosion for the purpose of removing, altering, or 780 tampering with any part of the structure, appliance, or object identified and tagged by the 781 fire marshal as being a possible ignition source or cause of the fire or explosion, without 782 approval of the fire marshal, until the conclusion of the investigation. 783 784 Sec. 46-125. Appeal; hearing. 785 786 Appeal; hearing. Whenever any person is aggrieved by a decision of the fire marshal with 787 respect to the provisions of this chapter, it is the right of that person to appeal to the construction 788 and property maintenance code board of appeals, as provided for in Chapter 22—Buildings and 789 Building Regulations, Article I—In General, Section 22-1—Construction and property 790 maintenance code board of appeals. Such appeal must be filed, in writing, within 30 days after the 791 determination by the fire marshal. Upon receipt of such appeal, the construction and property 792 maintenance code board of appeals shall set a time and place, in not less than ten or more than 30
Página 180
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 19
793 days, for the purpose of hearing the appeal. Notice of the time and place of the hearing of the 794 appeal shall be given to all parties, at which time they may appear and be heard. The determination 795 by the construction and property maintenance code board of appeals shall be final in all cases. 796
| 797 | Sec. 46-126. Fire prevention permit. |
| 798 | |
|---|---|
| 799 (a) Required. It shall be unlawful to construct, enlarge, alter or demolish a fire protection | |
| 800 | system without obtaining a fire prevention permit. |
| 801 | |
| 802 (b) Fee. Each applicant for a fire prevention permit, including, but not limited to, sprinkler | |
| 803 systems, fire alarms, hood suppression units, and tank installation, shall pay unto the city | |
| 804 a permit fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines, before such permit shall be | |
| 805 | issued. |
| 806 (c) Reinspections. There will be no charge for the first reinspection of a permit. The applicant | |
| 807 shall pay a fee for subsequent reinspections as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and | |
| 808 | Fines. |
| 809 | |
| 810 (d) Fire signaling system inspection fee. For each inspection of a fire alarm signaling system | |
| 811 located within the jurisdiction of the city and conducted by a licensed company pursuant | |
| 812 to Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations, the licensed company shall submit a copy | |
| 813 of the certificate of inspection for each fire alarm system to the city fFire mMarshal's | |
| 814 oOffice, along with a nonrefundable fee, as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. | |
| 815 | |
| 816 (e) Fire suppression system inspection fee. For each inspection of a fire suppression system | |
| 817 located within the jurisdiction of the city and conducted by a licensed company pursuant | |
| 818 to Delaware State Fire Prevention Regulations, the licensed company shall submit a copy | |
| 819 of the certificate of inspection for each sprinkler riser to the city fFire mMarshal's oOffice, | |
| 820 along with a nonrefundable fee, as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. | |
| 821 | |
| 822 (f) Doubling of fees. Fees established in subsection (b) shall be doubled in the event that a | |
| 823 permit is applied for after construction has commenced without the permission of the fire | |
| 824 marshal. The fire marshal shall waive the doubling of fees in cases where the permit | |
| 825 applicant is not a professional contractor, and the work is not being done by a professional | |
| 826 | contractor. |
| 827 | |
| 828 | Sec. 46-127. Smoke detection devices. |
| 829 | |
| 830 | (a) Installation required. |
Página 181
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 20
831 (1) New dwellings. All new structures and new dwellings shall be equipped with smoke 832 detectors and fire protection equipment as required by the provisions of the 833 International Building Code. 834 835 (2) Existing dwellings. All existing single-family dwellings, multifamily dwellings, and 836 dwelling units, whether such dwellings are owner-occupied or tenant-occupied, shall 837 be equipped with automatic smoke detection devices, which shall be approved smoke 838 detectors of the photoelectric or ionization type or battery-powered Underwriters' 839 Laboratories, Inc., or Factory Mutual approved type, as required by subsection (b)(1) 840 of this section. Such smoke detectors shall be installed in the number, location, and 841 manner required by this section and the rules and regulations of the fire marshal and, 842 when actuated, each such smoke detector shall provide an alarm suitable to warn the 843 occupants within the dwelling. It shall be the responsibility of the seller or lessor of 844 such existing dwellings to make such installations. 845 846 (3) Unlawful acts. In addition to and not in lieu of any other provisions of this section and 847 this Code, it shall be unlawful for any person responsible for the installation of a smoke 848 detector to fail to so install it. It shall be unlawful for any person to tamper with, 849 damage, or render inoperative, such as, but not exclusively, by disconnecting electrical 850 wiring or by removing the batteries, from any smoke detector. 851 852 (b) Types. 853 (1) Generally. Smoke detection devices shall be of the photoelectric or ionization type and 854 shall be electric, 110-volt AC, or battery-powered smoke detectors, Underwriters' 855 Laboratories, Inc., or Factory Mutual approved. 856 857 (2) Electric. Electric units shall be direct wired on a separate circuit on the line side of 858 service equipment, and immediately fused with the proper size fuse. Detector wiring 859 shall be a minimum of 14-gauge wire. All wiring shall comply with the National 860 Electrical Code and shall be performed by registered, licensed electricians or inspected 861 by the appropriate authority. 862 863 (3) Battery powered. Battery-powered units shall be permitted only in existing structures. 864 Where battery-powered units are permitted, the battery shall be of the type approved 865 for the detector and shall provide a minimum of 12 months' service. Battery-powered 866 units shall be equipped with an audible-sounding device to alert occupants of the need 867 for battery replacements. In rental dwelling units where battery-powered devices are 868 permitted, after installation of the detection devices at the landlord's expense, in 869 accordance with subsection (a) of this section, it shall be the tenant's responsibility, 870 unless otherwise provided in the tenant's lease agreements, to: 871
Página 182
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 21
872 a. Make periodic inspections of the unit to determine that it is in proper working order; 873 874 b. Notify the landlord of any malfunction of said detection device, which the landlord
| 875 | shall then repair or replace at his own expense; |
| 876 | |
|---|---|
| 877 c. Replace the batteries, when necessary, during the entire term of the rental | |
| 878 | agreement. |
| 879 | |
| 880 (c) Audible signal. Smoke detection devices shall be equipped with an audible-sounding | |
| 881 device that provides a steady signal with a minimum decibel rating of 85 decibels. | |
| 882 | |
| 883 | (d) Number required. |
| 884 | |
| 885 (1) Generally. The major threat from fire in a family living unit is at night when everyone | |
| 886 is asleep. The principal threat to persons in sleeping areas comes from fires in the | |
| 887 remainder of the unit; therefore, smoke detectors shall be located between the bedroom | |
| 888 areas and the rest of the unit. In units with only one bedroom area on one floor, the | |
| 889 smoke detector shall be located as shown in figure B-2.1.1 of the appendix of the NFPA | |
| 890 74-1984 Standard For the Installation, Maintenance, and Use of Household Fire | |
| 891 | Warning Equipment. |
| 892 | |
| 893 (2) Multiple detectors. In family living units with more than one bedroom area or with | |
| 894 bedrooms on more than one floor, more than one smoke detector will be required as | |
| 895 shown in figure B-2.1.2 of the appendix of the NFPA 74-1984 Standard For the | |
| 896 Installation, Maintenance, and Use of Household Fire Warning Equipment. | |
| 897 | |
| 898 (3) Each story of living unit. In addition to smoke detectors outside of the sleeping areas, | |
| 899 this subsection requires the installation of a smoke detector on each additional story of | |
| 900 the family living unit, including the basement. These installations are shown in figure | |
| 901 B-2.1.3 of the appendix of the NFPA 74-1984 Standard For the Installation, | |
| 902 Maintenance, and Use of Household Fire Warning Equipment. The living area smoke | |
| 903 detector shall be installed in the living room and/or near the stairway to the upper level. | |
| 904 The basement smoke detector shall be installed in close proximity to the stairway | |
| 905 leading to the floor above. If installed on an open-joist ceiling, the detector shall be | |
| 906 positioned relative to the stairway so as to intercept smoke coming from a fire in the | |
| 907 | basement before the smoke enters the stairway. |
| 908 | |
| 909 (e) Jurisdictional authority. The fire marshal shall have jurisdiction for purposes of enforcing | |
| 910 | compliance with this section. |
Página 183
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 22
911
| 912 | (f) Supervision of enforcement. |
| 913 (1) Registration of contractors. All general contractors, subcontractors, and their agents | |
|---|---|
| 914 who install electric 110-volt, AC-powered smoke detection devices shall be registered | |
| 915 with the office of the city fire marshal in order to sell, distribute, furnish, or install | |
| 916 | smoke detection equipment within the city. |
| 917 | |
| 918 (2) Certification of device. It shall be the responsibility of the contractor, installer, or seller | |
| 919 of an electric 110-volt, AC-powered smoke detector to certify, in writing, to the fire | |
| 920 | marshal that the device is in compliance with this section. |
| 921 | |
| 922 (3) Exception. This subsection (f) shall not apply to persons who perform the actual | |
| 923 installation of smoke detectors in dwelling units they own; however, such installations | |
| 924 shall still require any applicable inspections required by the building code. | |
| 925 (g) Violations; penalties. Any violation of the provisions of this section shall render the owner | |
| 926 or operator, or agent of the owner or operator of the building, or the tenant of rental property | |
| 927 if the rental agreement so provides in accordance with subsection (b), and/or the general | |
| 928 contractor, subcontractors, or their agents, liable for suspension or revocation of any | |
| 929 existing license to do business in the city, or a fine as provided for in Appendix F—Fees | |
| 930 and Fines, or both such penalties. Copies of this section shall be made available to the | |
| 931 public by the building inspector. Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was | |
| 932 issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| 933 | |
| 934 | (h) Secured key systems. |
| 935 (1) When required; exemption. A secured key system shall be required for any new or | |
| 936 existing building where a fire alarm or sprinkler system is being installed. It shall be | |
| 937 the responsibility of the owner or occupant to keep a set of keys in the secured key box | |
| 938 that are current to the locks of the protected occupancy. Buildings with 24-hour staffing | |
| 939 | or guard service shall be exempt from this subsection. |
| 940 | |
| 941 (2) Location. The secured key system shall be located as close to the main entrance as | |
| 942 possible. Should the building design not allow the secured key system to be located by | |
| 943 the main entrance, the fire marshal and fire chief shall come to an agreement as to an | |
| 944 alternate location for the key box. A secured key system, once installed, shall not be | |
| 945 obstructed from view or obstructed by any means that would delay the fire department's | |
| 946 | access to the box. |
| 947 | |
| 948 (3) Required keys. Keys to be secured in the key box shall include keys to all points of | |
| 949 ingress or egress, whether on the interior or exterior of the building, and keys to locked | |
| 950 mechanical rooms, electrical rooms, elevator rooms, fire alarm, and sprinkler controls, | |
Página 184
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 23
951 and any area protected by automatic fire detection. Keys to individual residential
| 952 | apartment units are not required. |
| 953 | |
|---|---|
| 954 (4) Ordering responsibility. It shall be the responsibility of the general contractor to order | |
| 955 the key box for new buildings. It shall be the responsibility of the owner or tenant to | |
| 956 | order the key box for existing buildings. |
| 957 | |
| 958 (5) Installation before testing. No acceptance test for sprinklers or fire alarms shall be | |
| 959 | conducted before the installation of a key box. |
| 960 | |
| 961 | Sec. 46-128. Marking rated walls. |
| 962 | |
| 963 (a) Fire walls, fire barriers, shaft enclosures, fire partitions, and smoke barriers shall be labeled | |
| 964 with their rating. Markings shall be red in color, located on both sides of the separation | |
| 965 wall, a minimum of four inches in height, and no more than 15 feet apart for the length of | |
| 966 the wall. Markings shall be visible when ceiling tiles are removed for inspection. | |
| 967 | |
| 968 | (b) Ratings are to be marked as follows: |
| One hour separation | 1HR |
| Two-hour separation | 2HR |
| Three-hour separation | 3HR |
| Four-hour separation | 4HR |
| Smoke Barriers | SB |
| 969 | |
| 970 | Secs. 46-129—46-160. Reserved. |
| 971 | |
| 972 | ARTICLE IV. PUBLIC OCCUPANCIES |
| 973 | |
| 974 | Sec. 46-161. Compliance required. |
| 975 | |
| 976 No person shall use or permit to be used any public occupancy structure which does not | |
| 977 comply with the most currently published edition of NFPA Life Safety Code 101. Public | |
| 978 | Occupancies shall include but not be limited to: |
| 979 | |
Página 185
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 24
980 (a) Assembly occupancy (facilities used for gathering of 50 or more people to include, 981 but not be limited to auditoriums, assembly halls, auditoriums, bowling lanes, club 982 rooms, college and university classrooms with 50 or more persons, conference 983 rooms, courtrooms, dance halls, drinking establishments, exhibition halls, 984 gymnasiums, libraries, mortuary chapels, motion picture theaters, museums, 985 passenger stations and terminals of air, surface, underground, and marine public 986 transportation facilities, places of religious worship, pool rooms, recreational piers, 987 restaurants, skating rinks, special amusement buildings, theaters); 988 989 (b) Educational occupancy (academies, kindergartens, schools); 990 991 (c) Daycare occupancy (adult, child, homes, nursery, center); 992 993 (d) Health care occupancy (hospitals, limited care facilities, nursing homes); 994 995 (e) Ambulatory health care occupancy (facilities used to provide services or treatment 996 simultaneously to four or more patients that provides, on an outpatient basis, one or 997 more of the following: 998 999 (1) Treatment for patients that renders the patient incapable of taking action for self- 1000 preservation under emergency conditions without the assistance of others; 1001 1002 (2) Anesthesia that renders the patients incapable of taking action for self- 1003 preservation under emergency conditions without the assistance of others; 1004 1005 (3) Treatment for patients who, due to the nature of their injury or illness, are 1006 incapable of taking action for self-preservation under emergency conditions 1007 without the assistance of others. 1008 1009 (f) Residential occupancy (lodging or rooming houses, hotel, dormitory, apartment 1010 buildings, bed and breakfast inns, short-term rentals); 1011 1012 (g) Residential board and care occupancy (group housing, facilities for social 1013 rehabilitation, alcoholism, drug abuse or mental health; assisted living); 1014 1015 (h) Mercantile occupancy over 10,000 square feet (auction rooms, department stores, 1016 drugstores, restaurants with fewer than 50, shopping centers, supermarkets);
Página 186
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 25
1017 1018 (i) Business occupancy over 10,000 square feet (city halls, college and universities 1019 instructional buildings, classrooms under 50 persons and laboratories, courthouses, 1020 dentist's office, doctor's office, general office, outpatient clinics (ambulatory), town 1021 halls); 1022 (j) Industrial occupancy (dry-cleaning plant, factories of all kinds, food processing 1023 plants, gas plants, hangars, laundries, power plants, pumping stations, refineries, 1024 sawmills, telephone exchanges); 1025 1026 (k) Storage occupancy over 10,000 square feet (barns, bulk oil storage, cold storage, 1027 freight terminals, grain elevators, hangars, parking structures, truck and marine 1028 terminals, warehouses); 1029 1030 (l) Assembly occupancy - special provisions 1 (to include, but not be limited to, outdoor 1031 facilities which are not part of the normal everyday operation of the building/land 1032 use and are subject to a City of Dover current special event permit); 1033 (m) Assembly occupancy - special provisions 2 (to include, but not be limited to, special 1034 amusement buildings, carnivals, circus, fireworks, pyrotechnic displays, outdoor 1035 music concerts/festivals, and special events). 1036 1037 Sec. 46-162. Sprinkler requirements. 1038 1039 (a) Places of assembly shall be sprinklered throughout in accordance with the most recently 1040 adopted edition of NFPA 13 when the following apply: 1041 1042 (1) All new indoor places of assembly with an occupant load of 150 persons or greater. 1043 1044 (2) Any interior renovations of 50 percent or more to an existing place of assembly with 1045 an occupant load greater than 150 persons. 1046 1047 (3) Any additions or increase in interior size to an existing place of assembly that would 1048 create an occupant load of 150 persons or greater. 1049 1050 (b) Places of assembly where alcohol is served for consumption on the premises shall be 1051 sprinklered throughout in accordance with the most recently adopted edition of NFPA 13 1052 when the following apply: 1053
Página 187
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 26
1054 (1) All new indoor places of assembly with an occupant load of 100 persons or greater and
| 1055 | where alcohol will be served for consumption on the premises. |
| 1056 | |
|---|---|
| 1057 (2) Any interior renovation of 50 percent or more to an existing place of assembly with an | |
| 1058 occupant load greater than 100 persons and where alcohol will be served for | |
| 1059 | consumption on the premises. |
| 1060 | |
| 1061 (3) Any additions or increase in interior size to an existing place of assembly which would | |
| 1062 create an occupant load of 100 persons or greater and where alcohol will be served for | |
| 1063 | consumption on the premises. |
| 1064 | |
| 1065 (c) New educational occupancies of 5,000 square feet or greater shall be sprinklered | |
| 1066 throughout in accordance with the most recently adopted edition of NFPA 13. | |
| 1067 | |
| 1068 (d) Three feet of unobstructed clear width shall be designed, designated, and maintained | |
| 1069 around sprinkler risers for access by firefighters and for maintenance. The three feet shall | |
| 1070 be measured from the outermost components of the sprinkler riser and all related support | |
| 1071 | equipment. |
| 1072 | |
| 1073 (e) Fire department connections. Unless otherwise approved by the fire marshal, fire | |
| 1074 department connections shall be on the street side of the building and shall be located and | |
| 1075 arranged so that hose lines can be readily and conveniently attached to without interference | |
| 1076 from any nearby obstructions as defined by the fFire mMarshal's oOffice. Fire department | |
| 1077 connections shall be a five-inch Storz. Fire department connections shall be within 300 feet | |
| 1078 of an approved City of Dover Fire Hydrant and within 50 feet of the main entrance of the | |
| 1079 structure it serves. All fire department connections shall be not less than three feet nor more | |
| 1080 than five feet in height above finished grade. The fire marshal shall have the authority to | |
| 1081 | require more stringent requirements when deemed necessary. |
| 1082 | |
| 1083 | Sec. 46-163. Permit required. |
| 1084 It shall be unlawful for any person to operate any public occupancy listed in section 46- | |
| 1085 164 of Appendix F—Fees and Fines without first obtaining a permit from the licensing | |
| 1086 division of the dDepartment of pPlanning and iInspections in order to determine compliance | |
| 1087 with the provisions of this article. A person desiring the permit shall pay unto the city a fee | |
| 1088 | as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. |
| 1089 | |
| 1090 | Sec. 46-164. Fees. |
| 1091 A person desiring the permit required by the provisions of this article shall pay the appropriate | |
| 1092 | permit fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. |
Página 188
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 27
1093
| 1094 | Sec. 46-165. Permit expiration. |
| 1095 A permit issued pursuant to this article shall expire on March 31 each year. | |
|---|---|
| 1096 | |
| 1097 | Sec. 46-166. Permit display. |
| 1098 The owner or operator of a public occupancy structure shall display the permit granted | |
| 1099 pursuant to this article in a prominent position near the main entrance of the building at all | |
| 1100 | times. |
| 1101 | |
| 1102 | Sec. 46-167. Inspections. |
| 1103 The fire marshal shall inspect every public occupancy structure according to the procedures | |
| 1104 set forth in this chapter to ensure compliance with the applicable provisions of this chapter | |
| 1105 | and all other ordinances. |
| 1106 | |
| 1107 | Sec. 46-168. Reinspection fee. |
| 1108 (a) Amount. There is hereby created a reinspection fee as provided for in Appendix F—Fees | |
| 1109 and Fines that shall be charged for any repeated violation cited by the fire marshal, | |
| 1110 determined to be a violation and which requires a follow-up inspection to confirm the | |
| 1111 | correction of the violation. |
| 1112 | |
| 1113 (b) Fee attached. A fee may be attached to any summons written for any violation found to | |
| 1114 | still be uncorrected upon re-inspection. |
| 1115 | |
| 1116 | Sec. 46-169. Permit suspension. |
| 1117 (a) Noncomplying structures. The fire marshal shall suspend the permit issued pursuant to this | |
| 1118 article when he determines that any public occupancy structure or the premises surrounding | |
| 1119 such public occupancy structure fails to meet the applicable requirements of this chapter | |
| 1120 or any rule or regulation issued pursuant hereto. Such suspension shall last until the | |
| 1121 violations have been corrected to the satisfaction of the fire marshal, or the suspension shall | |
| 1122 | have been reversed on appeal. |
| 1123 | |
| 1124 (b) Nuisance. The city licensing officer shall suspend the permit issued pursuant to this article | |
| 1125 when it is determined that a public occupancy structure, the use of any public occupancy | |
| 1126 structure, or the premises surrounding such public occupancy structure is so inimical to the | |
| 1127 public health, safety and welfare as to constitute a nuisance and thus gives rise to an | |
| 1128 emergency. Such suspension shall last until the violations have been corrected to the | |
| 1129 satisfaction of the licensing officer, or the suspension shall have been reversed on appeal. | |
| 1130 | |
Página 189
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 28
1131 (c) Notice. Upon suspending any permit under this section, the fire marshal or city licensing 1132 officer shall notify the permittee and, if possible, remove the written permit from the 1133 premises. He shall also notify the licensing division of the dDepartment of pPlanning and
| 1134 | iInspections of the suspension. |
| 1135 | |
|---|---|
| 1136 | Sec. 46-170. Appeals. |
| 1137 (a) Right generally. Any owner or operator of any public occupancy structure whose permit to | |
| 1138 operate the structure is suspended by the fire marshal or city licensing officer pursuant to | |
| 1139 this article shall have the right to appeal and notice as provided in this chapter. | |
| 1140 | |
| 1141 (b) Notice; effect. Upon suspension of a permit ordered by the fire marshal or city licensing | |
| 1142 officer pursuant to section 46-169 and upon the permittee serving the city clerk with a | |
| 1143 notice of appeal pursuant to section 46-125, the permit suspension shall be stayed and the | |
| 1144 permit shall remain in abeyance until the appeal is decided by the council. | |
| 1145 | |
| 1146 | Sec. 46-171. Fire alarm in place of assembly. |
| 1147 (a) Definition. For the purpose of this article, the requirements set forth in section A.4.1.2 of | |
| 1148 the most currently published edition of the NFPA Life Safety Code shall be used to | |
| 1149 | determine if an occupancy is a place of assembly. |
| 1150 | |
| 1151 (b) Occupant load. For the purpose of this article, the requirements set forth in the most | |
| 1152 currently adopted edition of the NFPA Life Safety Code shall be used to determine the | |
| 1153 | occupant load of a place of assembly. |
| 1154 | |
| 1155 (c) Fire alarm required. Any new occupancy or new portion of an occupancy determined to | |
| 1156 be a place of assembly by the fire marshal, and is capable of receiving an occupant load of | |
| 1157 75 persons or greater, shall be required to install a fire alarm in accordance with NFPA | |
| 1158 codes governing the installation of fire alarms and the National Electrical Code. | |
| 1159 | |
| 1160 (d) Fire alarm system required. Any existing occupancy or portion of an existing occupancy | |
| 1161 determined to be a place of assembly by the fire marshal, and is undergoing renovations in | |
| 1162 excess of 50 percent of the assessed value of the building and is capable of receiving an | |
| 1163 occupant load of 75 persons or greater, or is being enlarged to receive an occupant load of | |
| 1164 75 persons or greater, shall be required to install a complete fire alarm system in accordance | |
| 1165 with NFPA codes governing the installation of fire alarms and the National Electrical Code. | |
| 1166 | |
| 1167 (e) Public mode audible requirements. To ensure that audible public mode signals are clearly | |
| 1168 heard by occupants of a structure, they shall have a sound level at least 15 decibels (dB) | |
| 1169 above the average ambient sound level or five decibels (dB) above the maximum sound | |
| 1170 level having a duration of at least 60 seconds, whichever is greater, measured five feet | |
Página 190
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 29
1171 (1.5m) above the floor in the area required to be served by the system using the A-weighted 1172 scale dBA. In the event the stated requirement cannot be met a shunt trip relay/switches 1173 shall be the approved method of meeting the intent of this section of the Code. 1174
| 1175 | Secs. 46-172—46-200. Reserved. |
| 1176 | |
|---|---|
| 1177 | ARTICLE V. FIRE LANES |
| 1178 | |
| 1179 | Sec. 46-201. Generally. |
| 1180 (a) New construction marking. Fire lanes for new construction shall be marked in accordance | |
| 1181 with chapter V, part V of the most currently adopted state fire prevention regulations. | |
| 1182 | |
| 1183 (b) New construction plot plan. For new construction, a plot plan, showing signs, curb | |
| 1184 markings, and roadway markings, shall be submitted and approved by the fire marshal prior | |
| 1185 | to issuing a construction permit. |
| 1186 (c) Existing building markings. Fire lanes for existing buildings shall be marked in accordance | |
| 1187 with chapter V, part V of the most currently adopted state fire prevention regulations. | |
| 1188 | |
| 1189 (d) Existing building plot plans. For existing buildings, a plot plan, showing signs, curb | |
| 1190 markings, and roadway markings, shall be submitted and approved by the fire marshal prior | |
| 1191 | to the marking of the fire lanes. |
| 1192 | |
| 1193 (e) Retroactive. The fire lane regulations set forth in this section shall be retroactive to existing | |
| 1194 | buildings. |
| 1195 | |
| 1196 | Sec. 46-202. Violations. |
| 1197 (a) Vehicles parked. It shall be a violation of this article for any vehicle to be found disabled | |
| 1198 or parked in a fire lane. Anyone found to be in violation of [this sub] section shall be issued | |
| 1199 a summons pursuant to Chapter 106 Traffic and Vehicles; Article I, In General; section | |
| 1200 | 106-7, Obedience to state law. |
| 1201 | |
| 1202 (b) Summons placed upon vehicle. Any vehicle which has had a summons placed upon it and | |
| 1203 is found to still be parked in the fire lane for one hour or more from the time the summons | |
| 1204 | was placed upon the vehicle may be towed, at the owner's expense. |
| 1205 | |
| 1206 (c) Other obstructions. It shall be a violation of this article to obstruct any fire lane with any | |
| 1207 item, such as, but not limited to, dumpsters, trash cans, construction debris, construction | |
Página 191
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 30
1208 equipment, sidewalk sales, merchandise, carnivals and circuses, public gatherings, or any 1209 other items or activities that, once placed in the fire lane, would limit access for fire 1210 equipment or any other emergency vehicle in time of a fire or other emergency. Any 1211 property owner or tenant found to be in violation of [this sub] section shall be issued a 1212 summons as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 1213 1214 (d) Failure to mark. Property owners of existing buildings who do not have their fire lanes 1215 marked within 45 days of being notified by the fire marshal, shall be in violation of this 1216 article. Any property owner found to be in violation of [this sub] section 46-202(d) shall 1217 be issued a summons as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. 1218 1219 (e) [Late payments.] Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including 1220 the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. 1221 1222 Sec. 46-203. Reserved. 1223 1224 Sec. 46-204. Enforcement. 1225 (a) Removal of vehicle or obstruction. Any city police personnel, code enforcement officer, or 1226 fire marshal shall have the authority to tow, at the owner's expense, any vehicle found in 1227 violation of this article or to have removed, by whatever means is necessary, any 1228 obstruction of a fire lane, at the owner's expense. 1229 1230 (b) Summonses. Any city police personnel, code enforcement officer, or fire marshal shall have 1231 the authority to issue summonses for violations of this article. 1232 1233 Sec. 46-205. Responsibility of owner or tenant. 1234 (a) Legibility. It shall be the responsibility of the property owner to maintain the legibility of 1235 the marked fire lane surfaces and signs. 1236 1237 (b) Visibility. Fire lane signs or road surface markings shall be replaced or remarked, as 1238 necessary, to ensure adequate visibility. 1239 1240 (c) Obstructions. It shall be the responsibility of the owner or tenant to keep the fire lane free 1241 of obstructions. 1242 1243 (d) Closing. Contact shall be made with the fire marshal prior to any construction or 1244 maintenance work that would cause a portion of a fire lane to be closed or obstructed.
Página 192
Item #26. Proposed Ordinance #2024-16 – Chapter 46 – Fire Prevention and Protection Page 31
1245 1246 (e) Sign maintenance. All fire lane signs posted on the building or mounted on posts or poles
| 1247 | shall be readily visible. |
| 1248 | |
|---|---|
| 1249 (f) Any property owner found to be in violation of this section shall be issued a summons as | |
| 1250 | provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. |
| 1251 | |
| 1252 | ADOPTED: * |
| 1253 | |
| 1254 | |
| 1255 | SYNOPSIS |
| 1256 This proposed amendment to this chapter removes language that requires the doubling of fines. | |
| 1257 | The amendments also add transparency to the fine schedule. |
| 1258 | |
| 1259 | (SPONSORS: ANDERSON and HUGG) |
| 1260 | |
| 1261 | |
| 1262 | Action History |
| 1263 | 06/24/2024 – Scheduled for First Reading – City Council |
| 1264 | 06/10/2024 – First Reading – City Council |
| 1265 05/14/2024 - Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and | |
| 1266 | Administration Committee |
Página 193
Item #27.
FINAL READING
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-17
| 1 | BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN |
| 2 | COUNCIL MET: |
| 3 | |
|---|---|
| 4 That Chapter 90 – Solid Waste, Section 90-16 – Violations; penalties, be amended by inserting the | |
| 5 text indicated in bold, blue, italics and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows: | |
| 6 | |
| 7 | Sec. 90-16. Violations; penalties. |
| 8 Any person convicted of violating any provision of this chapter shall be fined in an amount | |
| 9 as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines, and if the violation amounts to an unlawful deposit | |
| 10 of rubbish, refuse, or other offensive matter in the corporate limits of the city, he shall be directed | |
| 11 to remove the same, and in the event of his failure to do so, the offensive matter shall be removed | |
| 12 by the city at the expense of the violator. Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was | |
| 13 issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| 14 | |
| 15 | |
| 16 | ADOPTED: * |
| 17 | |
| 18 | |
| 19 | SYNOPSIS |
| 20 This proposed amendment to this chapter removes language that requires the doubling of fines. | |
| 21 | |
| 22 | (SPONSORS: ANDERSON and HUGG) |
| 23 | |
| 24 | |
| 25 | Action History (Most recent first) |
| 26 | 06/24/2024 – Scheduled for Final Reading – City Council |
| 27 | 06/10/2024 – First Reading – City Council |
| 28 05/14/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and | |
| 29 | Administration Committee |
Página 194
Item #28.
FINAL READING
FINAL READING
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-18
| 1 | BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN |
| 2 | COUNCIL MET: |
| 3 | |
|---|---|
| 4 That Chapter 114 – Vegetation, Article II – Weeds, Section 114-34. - Fines, be amended by | |
| 5 inserting the text indicated in bold, blue, italics and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as | |
| 6 | follows: |
| 7 | |
| 8 | Sec. 114-34. Fines. |
| 9 | |
| 10 (a) Generally. Any person convicted of a violation of section 114-32, regardless of corrective | |
| 11 actions taken, shall be punished for that violation by a fine as provided for in Appendix | |
| 12 F—Fees and Fines. Any such fine shall be in addition to any charges or assessments | |
| 13 imposed upon the violator pursuant to section 114-33(c). All fines imposed shall be in | |
| 14 accordance with the minimum fine schedule set out in subsection (c) herein. | |
| 15 | |
| 16 (b) Each day. Every day that a violation of section 114-32 continues shall be considered a | |
| 17 separate offense, for which the violator may be tried and convicted without the necessity | |
| 18 | of further notice. |
| 19 | |
| 20 | (c) Minimums. |
| 21 | |
| 22 (1) Any fine assessed pursuant to subsection (a) of this section shall be no less than the | |
| 23 | minimum amount as provided for in Appendix F—Fees and Fines. |
| 24 | |
| 25 (2) In determining the applicable minimum fine, an offense shall be considered a recurring | |
| 26 offense only if the defendant has previously pleaded or been found guilty of causing or | |
| 27 permitting the same nuisance at the same location within the past 12 months, or for | |
| 28 every day that the violation of section 114-32 continues as per subsection (b) of this | |
| 29 | section. |
| 30 | |
| 31 (d) Lien. Any fines imposed pursuant to subsection (a) of this section which remain unpaid | |
| 32 | shall: |
| 33 | |
| 34 (1) Be added to the tax duplicate for the tax year said services were provided by the city | |
| 35 and invoiced as part of the annual property tax bill for said property and collected as | |
| 36 | part of the city property tax collection process, and |
Página 195
Item #28. Proposed Ordinance #2024-18 – Chap.114 – Vegetation, Art. II – Weeds, Sec. 114-34 – Fines Page 2
37 (2) Be placed by the city as specified in the municipal lien docket as a lien against the 38 property on which the violation occurred, and the procedures for enforcement or
| 39 | collection of said lien shall be as set out in section 114-33(d). |
| 40 | |
|---|---|
| 41 (e) When not paid. Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the | |
| 42 | day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. |
| 43 | |
| 44 (f) (e) Fine exemption. Any fine pursuant to subsection (a) of this section can be exempted | |
| 45 if the person convicted of a violation of section 114-32 is hospitalized or otherwise has | |
| 46 a serious medical condition during the time of the conviction that would prohibit the | |
| 47 | grass from being cut. |
| 48 | |
| 49 (1) In order to be considered for the exemption, documentation in the form of a | |
| 50 | doctor’s note or documentation from an authorized or certified medical |
| 51 provider, shall be submitted to the code enforcement office within 14 days of | |
| 52 | the receipt of the citation. |
| 53 | |
| 54 (2) The code enforcement officer, fire marshal, or their authorized agents shall | |
| 55 review the documentation per subsection (1) above and either grant or deny | |
| 56 the fine exemption in writing. A denial letter must include the reasons for the | |
| 57 | denial. |
| 58 | |
| 59 (3) Should the fine exemption be denied, then the person convicted of the violation | |
| 60 has 30 days to appeal in writing to the city council through the city clerk’s | |
| 61 office. The city clerk’s office shall put this item on the first available council | |
| 62 | agenda. |
| 63 | ADOPTED: * |
| 64 | |
| 65 | |
| 66 | SYNOPSIS |
| 67 This proposed amendment to this chapter removes language that requires the doubling of fines. | |
| 68 | |
| 69 | (SPONSORS: ANDERSON and HUGG) |
| 70 | |
| 71 | |
| 72 | Action History |
| 73 | 06/24/2024 – Scheduled for Final Reading – City Council |
| 74 | 06/10/2024 – First Reading – City Council |
| 75 05/14/2024 - Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and | |
| 76 | Administration Committee |
Página 196
Item #29.
FINAL READING
City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-19
WITH STAFF AMENDMENT #1
| 1 | BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN |
| 2 | COUNCIL MET: |
| 3 | |
|---|---|
| 4 That Appendix F – Fees and Fines, be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font | |
| 5 | and deleting the text indicated in red strikeout as follows: |
| 6 | |
| 7 Unless specifically provided otherwise, or the context thereof so dictates, each day any violation | |
| 8 of any provision of this code or any ordinance shall constitute a separate offense. Fines not paid | |
| 9 within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be | |
| 10 | automatically doubled in amount. |
| 11 | Appendix F – Generally: |
| 12 1. Unless otherwise specified in the ordinance all fines are to be paid within 30 days from | |
| 13 | the date of issue. |
| 14 2. Unpaid fines and fees as a debt. The amount of any unpaid fines and fees, the | |
| 15 payment of which is required pursuant to this chapter, shall constitute a debt due | |
| 16 | the city. |
| 17 3. Failure to pay fines and fees. In the event that the owner of record is deemed to be | |
| 18 in violation of any code or ordinance adopted by the city, and if the charges assessed | |
| 19 | by the city for said deficiency are not paid. |
| 20 4. The city, after having corrected the deficiency and violation, shall place its charges | |
| 21 and expenses as specified in the municipal lien docket as a lien against said property, | |
| 22 and add the charges and expenses as specified to the tax duplicate for the tax year | |
| 23 said services were provided by the city and invoiced as part of the annual property | |
| 24 tax bill for said property and collected as part of the city property tax collection | |
| 25 | process. |
| 26 5. In addition to the methods directed herein, the city solicitor shall be directed to | |
| 27 enforce said lien or to collect the charges imposed by the city by any other means | |
| 28 | that he may deem desirable and most advantageous to the city. |
| 29 6. The property owner shall be responsible for all collection costs and expenses, | |
| 30 | including attorneys' fees. |
| 31 | |
| 32 | Subpart B. Related Laws |
| 33 | |
| 34 | SUBPART B -RELATED LAWS |
Página 197
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 2
Fees and Fines
Sec. 2. Licenses
| Subsec. (c) Fines—Operating a business without a license | Not in excess of |
|---|---|
| $100.00 | |
| Initial Inspection or offense | $0.00 |
| Second Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $100.00 |
| Third Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $200.00 |
| Fourth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $300.00 |
| Fifth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $1000.00 |
| 35 | |
| 36 | CODE OF ORDINANCES |
| 37 | |
| 38 | Chapter 1. General Provisions |
| Chapter 1. General Provisions | Fees and Fines |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
|---|---|
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 1-17. General penalty; separate offenses; unpaid fines | Not less than $25.00, |
| nor more than | |
| $1,000.00 | |
| Initial Inspection or offense | $0.00 |
| Second Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $100.00 |
| Third Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $200.00 |
| Fourth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $300.00 |
| Fifth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $1000.00 |
| 39 | |
| 40 | Chapter 10. Alcoholic Beverages |
| Chapter 10. Alcoholic Beverages | Fees and Fines |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
|---|---|
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 10-1. Consumption or possession | |
| Subsec. (c) Underage persons | $100.00 |
| 41 | |
| 42 | Chapter 18. Animals |
| Chapter 18. Animals | Fees and Fines |
| Mandatory and non-suspendable fine of at least the minimum fine for each offense. Fines not | |
|---|---|
| paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall | |
| be automatically doubled in amount. | |
Página 198
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 3
Sec. 18-3. Keeping swine; for each violation Not less than $25.00 or more than $100.00 Sec. 18-4. Running at-large; for each violation Not less than $25.00 or more than $100.00 Sec. 18-5. Dog licenses required; for each violation First offense—Not less than $50.00 or more than $500.00. Second and subsequent offenses occurring within 12 months of prior offense—not less than $100.00 and not more than $500.00. The minimum fine for a subsequent offense shall not be subject to suspension. Conviction for the failure to pay the license fee is a violation. Sec. 18-6. Noisy animals or fowl Subsec. (b) Notice; abatement; fine Not less than $50.00 or more than $100.00 shall be subject to a fine until such nuisance is abated Sec. 18-7. Hitching to public trees; for each violation Not less than $10.00 or more than $100.00 Sec. 18-8. Excrement Subsec. (g) Violations; penalties Not less than $25.00 or more than $1,000.00 Sec. 18-9. Vicious dogs and animals—Generally Subsec. (f) Violations; penalties; for each violation $100.00 Sec. 18-12. Cruelty Subsec. (6) Violations; penalties; for each violation $100.00 Sec. 18-13. Public nuisances Subsec. (d) Violations; penalties; for each violation Not less than $25.00 or more than $100.00 Sec. 18-16. Keeping bees Subsec. (m) Violations; penalties, for each violation Not less than $25.00 or more than $100.00 43
Página 199
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 4
44 Chapter 22. Buildings and Building Regulations Chapter 22. Buildings and Building Regulations Fees and Fines Article III. Building Code Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. Sec. 22-61. Adopted (International Building Code) Sec. 105.5.1. Expiration: Additional 180-day extensions may be $25.00 per 180-day granted with payment of a renewal fee extension Sec. 113.4. Violation penalties; Each day that a violation continues Fine of not less than shall be deemed a separate offense $100.00 or more than $10,000.00 Sec. 114.3. Unlawful continuance First offense $100.00 Second offense $250.00 Third offense $500.00 Fourth and subsequent offenses No less than $1,000.00 and no more than $10,000.00 Sec. 22-65. Permit fees Fees shall double in the event that a permit is applied for after construction has commenced without the permission of the building inspector. The building inspector may waive the doubling of fees in cases where the building permit applicant is not a professional contractor, and the work is not being done by a professional contractor. Subsec. (a) Building permits $25.00 for first $1,000.00 of costs and $8.00 for each additional $1,000.00 of costs or multiples thereof up to $10,000,000.00 of costs, $6.00 for each additional $1,000.00 of costs or multiple thereof up to $20,000,000.00, and $5.00 for each additional $1,000.00 of costs or multiple thereof above $20,000,000.00 Subsec. (a) Fence permits $25.00 for first $1,000.00 of costs and $8.00 for each additional $1,000.00
Página 200
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 5
of costs or multiple
thereof
| Subsec. (a) Sign permits | $0.75 per square foot |
|---|---|
| of sign area; | |
| minimum fee for | |
| each permit $50.00 | |
| Subsec. (a) Swimming pool permits | $25.00 for first |
| $1,000.00 of costs | |
| and $8.00 for each | |
| additional $1,000.00 | |
| of costs or multiple | |
| thereof | |
| Subsec. (a) Demolition permits, any building which is being | $50.00; $0.00 if |
| demolished for the purpose of vacating the land for future | condemned and |
| development or construction upon the same | required to be |
| demolished by the | |
| city or any public | |
| entity | |
| Subsec. (a) Moving permits, each building | $250.00 |
| Subsec. (a) Construction plan reviews, nonresidential (Not subject | $20.00 per set of |
| to doubling) | plans |
| Subsec. (b) Reinspection’s (Not subject to doubling) | |
| First reinspection | $0.00 |
| Second reinspection | $25.00 |
| Third reinspection | $50.00 |
| Any subsequent reinspection | $100.00 |
| Subsec. (d) Fines | $0.00 |
| Initial Inspection or notification with non-compliance | $0.00 |
| Second Inspection or notification with non-compliance | $100.00 |
| Third Inspection or notification with non-compliance | $200.00 |
| Fourth Inspection or notification with non-compliance | $300.00 |
| Fifth Inspection or notification with non-compliance | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent Inspection or notification with non-compliance | $1000.00 |
| Article IV. Electrical Installations | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 22-110. Violations | Not less than $25.00 |
| or more than | |
| $1,000.00 | |
| Initial Inspection or offense | $0.00 |
| Second Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $100.00 |
| Third Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $200.00 |
| Fourth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $300.00 |
| Fifth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $500.00 |
Página 201
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 6
| Any subsequent Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $1000.00 |
| Article V. Mechanical Code | |
|---|---|
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 22-145. Heating, air conditioning, and heat pump permit fees | |
| Fees shall double in the event that a permit is applied for after construction has commenced | |
| without the permission of the building inspector. | |
| Subsec. (a) Heating permit | $40.00 first 10,000 |
| BTUs and $7.00 each | |
| additional 10,000 | |
| BTUs or multiple | |
| thereof | |
| Subsec. (a) Air conditioning permit | $40.00 per ton for the |
| first five tons and | |
| $7.00 per ton over | |
| five tons or multiple | |
| thereof | |
| Subsec. (a) Heat pump permit | $40.00 first 10,000 |
| BTUs and $7.00 for | |
| each additional | |
| 10,000 BTUs or | |
| multiple thereof or | |
| $40.00 per ton for the | |
| first five tons and | |
| $7.00 per ton over | |
| five tons or multiples | |
| thereof | |
| Subsec (c) Fines | |
| Initial Inspection or offense | $0.00 |
| Second Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $100.00 |
| Third Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $200.00 |
| Fourth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $300.00 |
| Fifth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $1000.00 |
| Article VI. Plumbing Code | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 22-185. Permit fees | |
| Fees shall double in the event that a permit is applied for after construction has commenced | |
| without the permission of the building inspector. The building inspector may waive the | |
| doubling of fees in cases where the building permit applicant is not a professional contractor, | |
| and the work is not being done by a professional contractor. | |
| Subsec. (a) Enumerated | |
| Fixtures | $35.00 first five |
| fixtures and $3.00 for | |
Página 202
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 7
each additional
fixture
| Garbage disposal and hot water heaters | A minimum fee of |
|---|---|
| $35.00 | |
| Gas, water, and sewer inspection underground | $30.00 for first 150 |
| feet and $0.75 for | |
| each additional ten | |
| feet or multiple | |
| thereof | |
| Subsec (c) Fines | |
| Initial Inspection or offense | $0.00 |
| Second Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $100.00 |
| Third Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $200.00 |
| Fourth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $300.00 |
| Fifth Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent Inspection or offense with Non-Compliance | $1000.00 |
| Article VII. Property Maintenance Code | |
| Sec. 22-225. Violations | |
| Subsec. (f) Life Safety Violations | |
| PM 304.18.1 Access doors | $100.00 per offense |
| PM 404.4.4 Prohibited occupancy | $100.00 per offense |
| PM 404.5 Overcrowding | $100.00 per offense |
| PM 505.4 Water heating facilities | $100.00 per offense |
| PM 602.3 Heat supply | $100.00 per offense |
| PM 603.2 Removal of combustion products | $100.00 per offense |
| PM 701.2 Responsibility | $100.00 per offense |
| PM 702.3 Locked doors | $100.00 per offense |
| PM 704.2 Smoke Detector | $150.00 per offense |
| Subsec. (g) Failure to Schedule | |
| Initial notification | $0.00 |
| Failure to schedule reinspection first offense | $100.00 |
| Failure to schedule reinspection second offense | $200.00 |
| Failure to schedule reinspection third offense | $300.00 |
| Failure to schedule reinspection fourth offense | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent offense of failure to schedule reinspection | $1000.00 |
| Subsec. (h) Non-compliance | |
| Initial Inspection | $0.00 |
| Second inspection with non-compliance | $100.00 |
| Third inspection with non-compliance | $200.00 |
| Fourth inspection with non-compliance | $300.00 |
| Fifth inspection with non-compliance | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent inspection with non-compliance | $1000.00 |
| Article VIII. Leases | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
Página 203
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 8
Sec. 22-251. Unlawful leases
Subsec. (g) Violations; penalties
| First offense | $100.00 |
| Second offense | $200.00 |
| Third offense | $300.00 |
| Fourth offense | $500.00 |
| Each subsequent offense | Not less than $100.00 |
| or more than | |
|---|---|
| $1,000.00 | |
| Article IX. Lodging Houses | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 22-301. Generally | |
| Subsec. (b) Expiration; fee | |
| Annual permit fee | $100.00 for the first |
| ten rooms and $10.00 | |
| for each additional | |
| room. | |
| Annual dormitory permit fee | $100.00 for the first |
| ten rooms and $10.00 | |
| for each room | |
| thereafter. | |
| Subsec. (c) Failure to pay on due date | A penalty fee in the |
| amount of ten percent | |
| per month of the | |
| amount of the license | |
| fee until the same is | |
| paid. | |
| Subsec. (d) Reinstatement fee | $100.00 |
| Article X. Rental Dwellings | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 22-332. Inspection required | |
| Subsec. (a) Failure to schedule inspection 1st offense | $100.00 |
| nd | |
| Subsec. (a) Failure to schedule inspection 2 offense | $200.00 |
| Subsec. (a) Failure to schedule inspection 3rd offense | $300.00 |
| th | |
| Subsec. (a) Failure to schedule inspection 4 offense | $500.00 |
| th | |
| Subsec. (a) Failure to schedule inspection 5 offense and each | $1000.00 |
| subsequent offense | |
| Subsec. (b) No show of owner or property manager 1st offense | $100.00 |
| nd | |
| Subsec. (b) No show of owner or property manager 2 offense | $200.00 |
| Subsec. (b) No show of owner or property manager 3rd offense | $300.00 |
| th | |
| Subsec. (b) No show of owner or property manager 4 offense | $500.00 |
Página 204
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 9
| Subsec. (b) No show of owner or property manager 5th offense | $1000.00 |
| and each subsequent offense | |
|---|---|
| Subsec. (b) Reinspection fee (Not subject to doubling) | |
| First follow-up inspection | $0.00 |
| Each subsequent reinspection, per inspection | $100.00 |
| If the permit fee is not paid on the date due, the permittee shall incur a penalty fee of ten | |
| percent per month of the amount of the license fee until the same is paid. | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 22-351. Generally | |
| Subsec. (a) Single-family dwellings, annual permit | |
| Single-family detached dwelling, each dwelling | $200.00 |
| Single-family attached dwelling, each dwelling | $200.00 |
| Subsec. (b) Multiple-family dwellings, annual permit | |
| Multiple dwellings consisting of three or less dwelling units | $200.00 |
| Multiple dwellings consisting of four or more dwelling units: | |
| For the first three dwelling units | $200.00 |
| For each additional dwelling unit in excess of three | $50.00 |
| Condominium units and accessory apartments located within | $75.00 |
| structures principally used for owner occupancy, each | |
| Subsec. (c) Late payment penalty | A penalty fee in the |
| amount of ten percent | |
| per month of the | |
| amount of the license | |
| fee until the same is | |
| paid. | |
| Subsec. (d) Reinstatement fee | $100.00 |
| Subsec. (g) Failure to register and obtain Rental Dwelling Permit | |
| Initial notification | $0.00 |
| Second notification | $100.00 |
| Third notification | $200.00 |
| Fourth notification | $300.00 |
| Fifth notification | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent notification | $1000.00 |
| Sec. 22-360. Enforcement, Fees and Penalties, Reporting | |
| Subsec. (a) Short-term rental license | $200.00 annually, |
| prorated for partial | |
| year | |
| Subsec. (b) Failure to register and obtain a license permit | Not less than $100.00 |
| or less than $1,000.00 | |
| (not prorated) in | |
| addition to license | |
| Initial notification | $0.00 |
| Second notification | $100.00 |
Página 205
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 10
| Third notification | $200.00 |
| Fourth notification | $300.00 |
| Fifth notification | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent notification | $1000.00 |
| Subsec. (c) Penalties for violations | Not less than $100.00 |
| or less than $1,000.00 | |
|---|---|
| per offense | |
| First offense | $100.00 |
| Second offense | $200.00 |
| Third offense | $300.00 |
| Fourth offense | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent offense | $1000.00 |
| First offense | $100.00 |
| Article XI. Dangerous Buildings | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 22-386. Violations; penalties for disregarding notices or orders | |
| Subsec. (a) Violations by owner, each offense, minimum | $100.00 |
| Initial inspection | $0.00 |
| Second inspection with non-compliance | $100.00 |
| Third inspection with non-compliance | $200.00 |
| Fourth inspection with non-compliance | $300.00 |
| Fifth inspection with non-compliance | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent inspection with non-compliance | $1000.00 |
| Subsec. (b) Violations by occupant or lessee, each offense, | $100.00 |
| minimum | |
| First offense | $100.00 |
| Second offense | $200.00 |
| Third offense | $300.00 |
| Fourth offense | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent offense | $1000.00 |
| Subsec. (c) Removal of notice, each offense, minimum | $100.00 |
| First offense | $100.00 |
| Second offense | $200.00 |
| Third offense | $300.00 |
| Fourth offense | $500.00 |
| Any subsequent offense | $1000.00 |
| Article XII. Vacant Buildings | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 22-403. Registration and registration fees | |
| Subsec. (a)(2)b.(ii). Registration fee | |
| Residential buildings and non-residential buildings <10,000 SF: | |
| Buildings vacant one year or less | $375.00 |
Página 206
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 11
| Buildings vacant for more than one year but less than two years | $750.00 |
| Buildings vacant for more than two years but less than three | $1,500.00 |
| years | |
|---|---|
| Buildings vacant for more than three years but less than five | $3,000.00 |
| years | |
| Buildings vacant for five years or longer | $5,000.00 |
| 45 | |
| 46 | Chapter 26. Businesses |
| Chapter 26. Businesses | Fees and Fines |
| Article II. Licenses | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 26-35. License required; fees | |
| Subsec. (d)(1) Businesses licensed | |
| Advertising agency | $95.00 |
| Amusement operator | $157.00 |
| Architect | $250.00 |
| Attorney-at-law | $313.00 |
| ATM machines (third-party or off bank premises) | $50.50 |
| Auctioneer | $157.00 |
| Automobile race operator | $375.00 |
| Bank, or loan and trust company | $313.00 |
| Barber | $63.00 |
| each additional chair over two | $4.00 |
| Beautician | $63.00 |
| each additional chair over two | $4.00 |
| Broadcasting station | $313.00 |
| Broker | $157.00 |
| Car wash | $188.00 |
| Certified public accountant | $250.00 |
| Cesspool cleaner | $125.00 |
| Chiropractor | $313.00 |
| Clinical social worker | $96.00 |
| Coin-operated amusement machine owner, per machine | $3.00 |
| Coin-operated vending machine owner, per machine | $3.00 |
| Coin-operated electronic video machine, per machine | $125.00 |
| Commercial sign business | $125.00 |
| Computer-related services | $125.00 |
| Consultant | $50.50 |
| Day care operator: | |
| Center or home provider with greater than six children | $50.50 |
| Dentist | $313.00 |
| Distributor | $63.00 |
Página 207
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 12
| Dray person or mover | $125.00 |
| Eating establishment and/or eating establishment operator | $125.00 |
| Employment agency | $125.00 |
| Entertainer: | |
|---|---|
| One—three entertainers per group | $50.50 |
| Four—nine entertainers per group | $95.00 |
| Ten or more | $125.00 |
| Entertainment agent | $188.00 |
| Finance or small loan agency | $250.00 |
| Fitness trainer | $69.00 |
| Funeral director | $250.00 |
| Gaming position | $155.00 |
| Gas, light, power, cable TV and telephone company | $938.00 |
| General repairman | $63.00 |
| Health spa or health club | $188.00 |
| Home day care operator | $25.50 |
| Hotel: | |
| Per room | $9.50 |
| Per suite | $12.50 |
| Income tax consultant | $188.00 |
| Incorporator | $125.00 |
| Insurance adjustor office | $125.00 |
| Itinerant merchant, per event | $100.00 |
| Janitorial and cleaning service: | |
| One—three employees | $50.50 |
| Four—nine employees | $95.00 |
| Ten or more employees | $125.00 |
| Land lease community operator, per home site within community | $25.00 |
| Landscape service company: | |
| One—three employees | $50.50 |
| Four—nine employees | $95.00 |
| Ten or more employees | $125.00 |
| Laundry service operator: | |
| Primary facility | $125.00 |
| Additional drop-off locations | $50.50 |
| Linen supplier | $125.00 |
| Manicurist | $32.00 |
| Manufacturer's agent or representative | $125.00 |
| Mercantile agency or collection agency | $125.00 |
| Motel, per room | $7.00 |
| Motion picture theater | $188.00 |
| Motor vehicle serviceman | $95.00 |
| Nursing, rest or convalescent home | $188.00 |
Página 208
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 13
Open market operator:
| First 20 spaces, per rented space | $22.50 |
| 21st—50th space, per rented space | $11.50 |
| Each space over 50, per rented space | $6.00 |
| Outdoor tables, per table | $6.00 |
| Optometrist | $313.00 |
| Pawnbroker | $188.00 |
| Pest control services | $95.00 |
| Pharmacist | $188.00 |
| Photographer | $125.00 |
| Physical therapist | $188.00 |
| Physician and/or surgeon | $313.00 |
| Plant nursery and florist | $95.00 |
| Podiatrist | $313.00 |
| Pool table operator, per table | $63.00/ |
| Maximum fee | |
|---|---|
| $189.00 | |
| Printer | $125.00 |
| Private investigator agency | $188.00 |
| Professional counselor | $63.00 |
| Professional engineer | $250.00 |
| Professional land surveyor | $250.00 |
| Psychologist | $313.00 |
| Public accountant | $188.00 |
| Public stenographer | $38.00 |
| Publisher | $313.00 |
| Real estate broker, appraiser, and manager | $157.00 |
| Real estate development corporation | $344.00 |
| Real estate property manager: | |
| One—three units managed | $50.50 |
| Four—ten units managed | $125.00 |
| Ten + units managed | $125.00 |
| Real estate salesperson or associated broker | $50.50 |
| Rental service | $125.00 |
| Sales representative | $50.50 |
| School and educational service (nonvocational) | $63.00 |
| School and educational service (vocational) | $125.00 |
| Scientific laboratory | $250.00 |
| Scrap and waste material service | $125.00 |
| Secondhand dealer of precious metals | $125.00 |
| Security service | $188.00 |
| Self-service laundry or dry cleaner | $125.00 |
| Shoe repairman | $50.50 |
Página 209
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 14
| Sound truck, per hour | $33.00 |
| Tailor and garment service | $50.50 |
| Taxicab or bus operator: | |
|---|---|
| First vehicle | $26.00 |
| Each additional vehicle | $26.00 |
| Tourist home, per room | $7.00 |
| Travel agency | $125.00 |
| Veterinarian | $313.00 |
| Warehouseman | $250.00 |
| Wholesale news agency | $63.00 |
| All other businesses not listed: | |
| One—three employees | $50.50 |
| Four—nine employees | $95.00 |
| Ten—50 employees | $125.00 |
| 51—100 employees | $313.00 |
| Subsec. (d)(2) Manufacturers/contractors rate | $0.00046 of |
| aggregate gross | |
| receipts/ | |
| Minimum fee | |
| $125.00 | |
| Subsec. (d)(3) Merchants/bottlers rate | $0.00046 of |
| aggregate gross | |
| purchases for resale/ | |
| Minimum fee $63.00 | |
| Subsec. (d)(4) Sports betting and horse racing (Simulcast) | rate of $0.00046 of |
| the aggregate gross | |
| receipts (defined as | |
| commission) for each | |
| activity/ | |
| Minimum license fee | |
| $125.00 | |
| Sec. 26-42. Penalty for late payment of license fee | A penalty fee in the |
| amount of ten percent | |
| per month of the | |
| amount of the | |
| licensee fee until the | |
| same is paid | |
| Article III. Going-Out-of-Business Sales; Fire Sales | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 26-108. Violations; penalties | Not less than $25.00, |
| nor more than | |
| $1,000.00 | |
| Sec. 26-137. Fees | $25.00; renewal fee |
| $25.00 | |
Página 210
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 15
47 48 Chapter 30. Standards of Ethical Conduct and Ethics Commission 49 Chapter 30. Standards of Ethical Conduct and Ethics Fees and Fines Commission Article II. Standards of Ethical Conduct Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. Sec. 30-20. Prohibitions relating to conflicts of interest Subsec. (i)(1) Criminal sanctions, penalties Not to exceed $1,000.00 50 51 Chapter 38. Emergencies 52 Chapter 38. Emergencies Fees and Fines Article II. Civil Emergencies Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. Sec. 38-84. Violations; penalties Not less than $25.00, nor more than $1,000.00 Article III. Emergency Services Sec. 38-85. Basic Life Support Ambulance Services Fund Subsec. (c) Fees
Residential Accounts $1.50/Monthly Commercial Accounts $6.50/Monthly 53 54 Chapter 42. Environment 55 Chapter 42. Environment Fees and Fines Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. Sec. 42-2. Noise Subsec. (d) Violations; penalties Not less than $50.00 nor more than $100.00 56 57 Chapter 46. Fire Prevention and Protection 58 Chapter 46. Fire Prevention and Protection Fees and Fines Article I. In General Sec. 46-1. Means of egress Subsec. (f) Penalties Any exit access, exit, or exit discharge, with the exception of a $100.00 first offense
Página 211
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 16
locked exit door, found to be in violation of this section $200.00 second or subsequent offense Any required exit door found to be locked against egress $100.00 each locked exit first offense, $200.00 subsequent offense Sec. 46-3. Impairment of fire protection equipment Subsec. (f) Fines $100.00 per device, first offense; $200.00 per device, second and subsequent offenses Sec. 46-7. Preventable and malfunctioning alarms to the fire company Subsec. (a)(1) Responsibility for malfunctioning and preventable Should the person alarms, owner response, and corrective action; generally, notified fail to appear at said premises within 30 minutes after being notified to do so, the city may charge the owner of the premises a fine of $100.00 Subsec. (a)(2) Responsibility for malfunctioning and preventable Failure to return alarms, owner response, and corrective action; malfunction documentation of service/repair within the period of time stated on the notice of violation, which is satisfactory to the fire marshal, will result in assessment against the owner of a fine of $100.00 for the fire alarm malfunction Subsec. (b)(1) Fine charges; multiple fire alarm malfunctions or preventable alarms; amount of fine Number of preventable or malfunctioning fire alarms Fine per preventable or malfunctioning fire alarm Third alarm $100.00 Fourth alarm $200.00 Fifth alarm $250.00 All over fifth alarm, each alarm $250.00 Subsec. (b)(2) Fine charges; multiple fire alarm malfunctions or A $50.00 fine may be
Página 212
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 17
preventable alarms; panel reset assessed to the owner of a premises where the fire alarm has been reset before the fire department or assisting fire department arrives. $100.00 for second and subsequent offenses Sec. 46-8. Maintaining a known violation or hazard Subsec. (c)(1) Penalties; Any fines issued for violation of this Not less than $25.00, section nor more than $1,000.00 Minor deficiency $500.00 Major deficiency $1000.00 Article II. Fire Department Sec. 46-44 Failure to answer alarms, orders and perform duties Fine of not less than orderly; Penalties $25.00, nor more than $1,000.00 or by suspension from the fire department or both Article III. Fire Codes Fees established in subsection (b) of this section shall be doubled in the event that a permit is applied for after construction has commenced without the permission of the fire marshal. The fire marshal shall waive the doubling of fees in cases where the permit applicant is not a professional contractor, and the work is not being done by a professional contractor. Sec. 46-126. Fire prevention permit Subsec. (b) Fee; each applicant $25.00 for each $1,000.00 of costs or multiple thereof of the fire protection system, provided that a minimum fee for each permit shall be $150.00 Subsec. (c) Reinspection First reinspection No charge Second reinspection $100.00 Third reinspection $200.00 Any subsequent reinspection $250.00 Subsec. (d) Fire signaling system inspection fee Certificate of inspection $25.00 each fire alarm system
Página 213
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 18
Exception: Apartment or other multifamily dwelling—Five or $25.00 each fire less buildings per complex alarm system Exception: Apartment or other multifamily dwelling—More than $15.00 each fire five buildings per complex alarm system up to a maximum of 20 buildings. Maximum fee per complex not to exceed $300.00 for fire alarm systems Subsec. (e) Fire suppression system inspection fee Certificate of inspection $25.00 each fire suppression system Exception: Apartment or other multifamily dwelling—Five or $25.00 each fire less buildings per complex suppression system Exception: Apartment or other multifamily dwelling—More than $15.00 each fire five buildings per complex suppression system up to a maximum of 20 buildings. Maximum fee per complex not to exceed $300.00 for fire suppression systems Sec. 46-127 Smoke detection devices Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. Subsec. (g) Violations; penalties Revocation of any existing license to do business in the city, or a fine of not more than $150.00 per violation, or both such penalties Article IV. Public Occupancies Sec. 46-164. Fees Assembly No charge for an occupant load less than 75; $100.00 for an occupant load of 75 or greater Assembly—Fixed Seating $100.00 for first 200 seats and $10.00 each additional 50 seats Educational $100.00 Day Care $50.00 for Day Cares
Página 214
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 19
as defined by
Appendix B -
Zoning, Article 5,
Sections 14.22, 14.23
and 22.1; $100.00 for
other day cares
| Health Care | $100.00 first 25 |
|---|---|
| rooms and $5.00 for | |
| each additional room | |
| Ambulatory Health Care | $100.00 |
| Residential | $100.00 per building |
| Residential Board and Care | $100.00 |
| Mercantile over 10,000 sq. ft. | $100.00 |
| Business over 10,000 sq. ft. | $100.00 |
| Industrial | $100.00 |
| Storage over 10,000 sq. ft. | $100.00 |
| Assembly special provisions 1 | $25.00 |
| Assembly special provisions 2 | $100.00 |
| Sec. 46-168. Reinspection fee | |
| Subsec. (a) Amount | $25.00 for any |
| repeated violation | |
| cited by the fire | |
| marshal, determined | |
| to be a violation and | |
| which requires a | |
| follow up inspection | |
| to confirm the | |
| correction of the | |
| violation | |
| Subsec. (b) Fee attached | A fee may be |
| attached to any | |
| summons written for | |
| any violation found | |
| to be uncorrected | |
| upon reinspection | |
| Article V. Fire Lanes | |
| Fines not paid within 14 days of the day the fine was issued, including the day the fine was | |
| issued, shall be automatically doubled in amount. | |
| Sec. 46-202. Violations; penalties | |
| Subsec. (c) Other obstructions | Any property owner |
| or tenant found to be | |
| in violation; $50.00 | |
| Subsec. (d) Failure to mark | Any property owner |
| found to be in | |
| violation; $50.00 | |
Página 215
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 20
Sec. 46-205. Responsibility of owner or tenant Any property owner found to be in violation; $50.00 59 60 Chapter 50. Floods 61 Chapter 50. Floods Fees and Fines Article II. Administration Sec. 50-22. Permits required Permit $50.00 Permit extension $25.00 Violation and non-compliance penalties Not less than $25.00 nor more than $100.00, plus cost of prosecution 62 63 Chapter 52. Freedom of Information Act Related to Public Records Access 64 Chapter 52. Freedom of Information Act Related to Public Fees and Fines Records Access Sec. 52-3. Fees for responding to FOIA requests Administrative fees First 30 minutes of staff time No charge Staff time in excess of 30 minutes Hourly salary plus the overhead rate of the lowest paid staff member capable of performing the service. Billed in 15- minute increments. Production fees—Photocopies Fees for printing the first 10 standard-sized black and white or the Waived first 5 color copies (single sided) Standard-sized (8.5" × 11", 8.5" × 14", or 11" × 17") black and $0.25 per sheet (each white copies side) Standard-sized (8.5" × 11", 8.5" × 14", or 11" × 17") color copies $0.50 per sheet (each side) Oversized copies (larger than 11" × 17") $30.00 per sheet (each side) Production fees—Electronically generated records Files provided via PDF (via email) No charge CD or DVD (including case) $2.00 Other electronic storage costs Material cost to generate records Other costs
Página 216
Item #29.
Proposed Ordinance #2024-19 – Appendix F – Fees and Fines Page 21
Other costs associated with filling the request, such as postage, are the responsibility of the requestor. If the city does not have the resources or equipment to duplicate requested records, the city, at its discretion, may arrange to have records duplicated by an outside cont
Este documento es demasiado largo para mostrarlo completo aquí. Lea el resto en el PDF.