Ir al contenido principal
AskDover

Regular City Council Packet

City Council Meetings. 9 de diciembre de 2024.

Abrir el PDF (24.5 MB)

Este texto se extrajo de el PDF de forma automática y puede contener errores. El PDF es el registro oficial, así que consúltelo antes de confiar en esto.

Página 1

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING

Monday, December 09, 2024 at 6:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware

AGENDA VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE

This meeting will be held in the City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:

Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://tinyurl.com/yhnhe8xz
Event number: 2536 608 2735
Event password: DOVER (if needed)

If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.

The meeting can also be viewed on Comcast Channel 14, Verizon Channel 20, and on the City's Streaming Player located at www.cityofdover.com under "Quick Links".

OPEN FORUM - 15 Minutes Prior to Official Meeting (6:15 p.m.)

The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share their questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing on the agenda as a public hearing is prohibited during the Open Forum as an opportunity will be provided during consideration of that item. Citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is prohibited from taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule such items as regular agenda items and act upon them in the future.

INVOCATION - Elder Ellis B. Louden

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Councilman Neil

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA

All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.

Página 2

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - December 09, 2024 PAGE 2

PRESENTATIONS

  • 1.Certificate of Recognition and Congratulations - Debbie A. O'Brien
  • 2.Certificate of Recognition and Congratulations - Sharon J. Duca

PUBLIC HEARING

FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council meeting of October 28, 2024. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government."

  • 3.Proposed Ordinance #2024-29 - Amending Appendix B- Zoning, Article 3 - District Regulations, Sec. 19 - Manufacturing Zone (M), Sec. 20 - Industrial Manufacturing Zone (IPM), Sec. 23 - Agricultural Zone (A), Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations, Sec. 24 - Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 - Definitions (Formerly Proposed Ordinance #2024- 25A - Recreational Marijuana Land Use and Zoning: Cultivation, Manufacturing, and Testing Facilities)
  • 4.Proposed Ordinance #2024-30 - Amending Appendix B- Zoning, Article 3 - District Regulations, Sec. 16 - Highway Commercial Zone (C-4), Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations, Sec. 24 - Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 - Definitions (Formerly Proposed Ordinance #2024-25B - Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Zoning: Retail Marijuana Stores)

CONSENT AGENDA

ADOPTION OF MINUTES

  • 5.Regular City Council Meeting of November 25, 2024

COMMITTEE REPORTS

  • 6.Council Committee of the Whole Report of November 26, 2024

CCW Presentations

  • 7.Citizen Problem Reporter - Council Dashboard Training (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager)

(Committee Action Not Required)

Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee

  • 8.Discussion - Safety and Relationship Between City of Dover Police Department and Delaware State University (James Overton, Vice President of Student Affairs and Delaware State University Police Superintendent)

(Committee Action Not Required)

Página 3

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - December 09, 2024 PAGE 3

  • 9.Discussion - Capital School District Community Concerns Update (Sean Christiansen, Capital School District Board of Education, Vice President)

(Committee Action Not Required)

Utility Committee

  • 10.Discussion - Stormwater Utility Billing Concerns (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager)

(Committee recommendation: Set the stormwater utility rate to zero, transfer the stormwater utility back to the general fund for the time being, allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time, and find a way to refund or credit the money that people have already paid.) (See agenda item #30)

Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee

  • 11.Dover Fire Department Volunteer Stipend (Chief David Carey and President Jason Osika)

(Committee recommendation: Approval of the volunteer stipend program)

  • 12.Discussion - Amending Bond Council Requirements (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer)

(Committee recommendation: Amendment of all city code requirements for public notice to include modern communication tools)

  • 13.Discussion - Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer)

(Committee recommendation: Acceptance of the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR))

  • 14.Proposed Ordinance #2024-32 – Abandoned Shopping Carts (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager)

(Committee recommendation: Forward Proposed Ordinance #2024-32 to council)

  • 15."Campground of Hope" for the Unsheltered Population of the City of Dover (Leandra Marshall, Vice Chair, City of Dover Unsheltered Working Group)

(Committee recommendation: That the remaining ARPA funds of $91,000, grant $30,000 to John Wesley Church, once they comply with the request of the bids, and that the remainder of the funds be allocated to the Unsheltered Working Group and to sunset the Unsheltered Working Group as the Kent County Coalition will be taking over going forward.) (See agenda item #29)

Página 4

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - December 09, 2024 PAGE 4

MONTHLY REPORTS - October 2024

  • 16.City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
  • 17.City Manager’s Report
  • 18.Controller/Treasurer's Budget Report
  • 19.Fire Chief's Report
  • 20.Police Chief's Report

ELECTION OF OFFICERS - ROBBINS HOSE COMPANY - YEAR 2025 FIRE LINE OFFICERS

  • 21.Fire Chief - David Carey
  • 22.Deputy Fire Chief - Brian Bashista
  • 23.First Assistant Fire Chief - Jason Boc
  • 24.Second Assistant Fire Chief - James Iannucci
  • 25.Third Assistant Fire Chief - Brian Cullen
  • 26.Fourth Assistant Fire Chief - Christopher Riale
  • 27.First Fire Line Captain - Drew Kuntzi
  • 28.Second Fire Line Captain - Nickolas Senne

ITEMS NOT ON THE CONSENT AGENDA

  • 29.Reallocation of American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Funding for Housing and Community Service Projects (Councilman Rocha, Unsheltered and Affordable Housing Liaison and Councilman Boggerty, Community Engagement Liaison)

(Committee recommendation: That the remaining ARPA funds of $91,000, grant $30,000 to John Wesley Church, once they comply with the request of the bids, and that the remainder of the funds be allocated to the Unsheltered Working Group and to sunset the Unsheltered Working Group as the Kent County Coalition will be taking over going forward)

  • 30.Setting the Stormwater Fee to Zero, Stormwater Payment Credit/Refund Process (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager and Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director)

(Committee recommendation: Set the stormwater utility rate to zero, transfer the stormwater utility back to the general fund for the time being, allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time, and find a way to refund or credit the money that people have already paid.)

Página 5

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING - December 09, 2024 PAGE 5

  • 31.Rescheduling April 14, 2025, Regular Council Meeting and April 15, 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting due to the 2025 Municipal Election

(Staff recommendation: Reschedule April 14, 2025, Regular Council Meeting and April 15, 2025, Council Committee of the Whole Meeting to April 7, 2025 and April 8, 2025)

ORDINANCES

FINAL READING - The First Reading of the Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of October 28, 2024. The ordinance is available at the entrance of the Council Chambers and on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government."

  • 32.Proposed Ordinance #2024-24 - Amending Chapter 26 Businesses, Article II - Licenses, Sec. 26-31. - Definitions, and Appendix F - Fees and Fines, Chapter 26 (Formerly Proposed Ordinance #2024-24A - Recreational Marijuana Business Licenses: Cultivation, Manufacturing, and Testing Facilities)
  • 33.Proposed Ordinance #2024-25 - Amending Chapter 26 Businesses, Article II - Licenses, Sec. 26-31. - Definitions, and Appendix F - Fees and Fines, Chapter 26 (Formerly Proposed Ordinance #2024-24B - Recreational Marijuana Business Licenses: Compassion Centers, Retail Marijuana Stores)

CITY MANAGER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS

MAYOR'S ANNOUNCEMENTS

COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ANNOUNCEMENTS

ADJOURNMENT

THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING

Página 6

Item #1.

Página 7

Item #2.

Página 8

Item #3.

PETITIONS TO AMEND TEXT of Zoning Ordinance Public Hearing Before the Dover City Council December 9, 2024 Recommendations from the Planning Commission Meeting Session 2 of November 18, 2024 With Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review

Proposed Changes: Text Amendments to the following: • Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B: Zoning (Zoning Ordinance) o Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 19 – Manufacturing Zone (M) o Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 20 – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM) o Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 23 – Agricultural Zone (A) o Article 3 - District Regulations, Section 16 – Highway Commercial Zone (C-4) o Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations (Add Section 24) o Article 12 – Definitions

Summary of Amendments: This is a series of text amendments to the Zoning Ordinance to address the passage of the Marijuana Control Act by the Delaware General Assembly. Under the statute, municipalities can regulate where and how the marijuana-related land uses addressed by the law are permitted within the municipal limits. Municipalities can also prohibit marijuana-related land uses. The proposed Ordinance #2024-29 addresses marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing. The proposed Ordinance #2024-30 addresses marijuana retail stores. Together, the Ordinances would allow marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing facilities in the IPM and M Zones; marijuana cultivation facilities in the A Zone; and marijuana retail stores in the C-4 Zone. They would also add supplementary regulations (Section 24) for the marijuana-related uses in Article 5 and definitions for the marijuana-related uses in Article 12.

File Number: MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Lands Uses and Related Zoning Regulations

Ordinance Numbers: #2024-29
Proposed Ordinance #2024-29 – Amending Appendix B-Zoning,
Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 19 – Manufacturing Zone
(M), Section 20 – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), Section
23 – Agricultural Zone (A); Article 5 Supplementary Regulations;
Section 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 – Definitions

#2024-30
Proposed Ordinance #2024-30 – Amending Appendix B- Zoning,
Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 16 – Highway Commercial

Página 9

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #3.

Zone (C-4); Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses; Article 12 - Definitions

Planning Commission Recommendations: The Text Amendment Application – Ordinance #2024-29 and Ordinance #2024-30 were presented by Planning Office Staff and the Rossi Group (consultant). A Public Hearing was conducted the Planning Commission on November 18, 2024 where three (3) members of the public spoke. The Planning Commission’s motions were to recommend denial of Ordinance #2024-29 (vote 5-4) and to recommend denial of Ordinance #2024-30 (vote 5-4). These votes reflect an intent to prohibit recreational marijuana land uses. See detailed Planning Commission Recommendations beginning on page 6 of this Report and the Draft Meeting Minutes.

To formalize this intent and to codify it into the Zoning Ordinance, see the attached Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-29 and Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-30 which define each marijuana land use and specify that the uses are prohibited.

APPLICATON: MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations as Ordinance #2024-29 and Ordinance #2024-30

These Text Amendment Applications were referred to the Planning Commission as per Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §5. The Planning Commission is required to provide a Review Report to City Council. The following document and attachments are provided as the Review Report and Planning Commission Recommendation.

  • I.BACKGROUND ON DEVELOPMENT OF TEXT AMENDMENTS

Introduction Recreational marijuana became legal in the state of Delaware on July 5, 2023, when the Delaware Marijuana Control Act went into effect. This means that adults (ages 21+) may legally possess personal use quantities of marijuana in Delaware. Adults may also legally consume marijuana on private property. The Delaware Marijuana Control Act allows municipalities to regulate (including prohibit) land uses relating to cultivation, manufacturing, testing, and retail sale of marijuana within their jurisdiction through local ordinance. The Zoning Ordinance does not currently define or otherwise address the uses regulated under the Marijuana Control Act. The proposed ordinances would provide the framework for the uses established within the Marijuana Control Act in the City of Dover.

Background The Dover City Council Committee of the Whole – Legislative, Finance and Administration Subcommittee (CCW-LF&A) first discussed the Marijuana Control Act and how the City might address the regulated uses at a meeting on September 26, 2023. In a subsequent meeting on April 9, 2024, the CCW-LF&A discussed the matter again and directed the staff to develop an ordinance permitting marijuana cultivation, manufacturing, and testing in the M and IPM Zones and permitting marijuana retail stores in the C-4 Zone, with regulations such as distancing

Página 10

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #3.

requirements and other measures intended to protect neighboring uses from any potential adverse effects of these new uses.

Working with a consultant, the staff developed an ordinance that was presented to the CCW-LF&A on June 11, 2024. In response to public comment, the CCW-LF&A requested that the staff provide additional research. An informational webpage on the topic of Marijuana Regulations was added to the City’s website; see https://www.cityofdover.com/marijuanaregulations . Several of the research and background documents are attached for reference including the Recreational Marijuana White Paper and Marijuana Ordinance Q&A.

In July 2024, the City Council enacted a moratorium on all marijuana-related land uses through December 31, 2024, to ensure that no licenses would be issued for Dover locations while the matter was being deliberated. (See attached Moratorium as Council Resolution #2024-11)

In July 2024, a Survey to assess public opinion on how the City should address marijuana-related uses was made available online, at City buildings, and mailed with all utility bills. Survey respondents generally favored allowing marijuana-related uses in Dover with restrictions. The Summary of City of Dover Marijuana Survey (Report) is attached.

After discussing potential ordinances to address marijuana-related uses in Dover in seven public meetings, on October 15, 2024, CCW-LF&A recommended forwarding draft ordinances to City Council for First Reading. Four Ordinances to address business licensing and zoning of marijuana- related businesses were forwarded to begin the formal review process (identified as Ordinance #2024-24 and #2024-25 for business licensing; #2024-29 and #2024-30 for zoning regulations). First Reading of the Ordinances took place at the City Council meeting on October 28, 2024, at which time City Council set public hearings before the Planning Commission on November 18, 2024, and before the City Council on December 9, 2024.

State of Delaware Regulations and Licenses The Delaware Office of the Marijuana Commissioner (OMC) developed state regulations to govern the new recreational marijuana industry. The regulations were finalized in July 2024 and effective September 2024. The OMC office began accepting license applications on August 19, 2024. The first public license lottery was held by the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner on October 24, 2024. The State expects the first retail marijuana stores to open in spring 2025.

Also in 2024, the Delaware General Assembly passed a bill that allows medical marijuana facilities (compassion centers) to obtain a conversion license to convert to recreational facilities regulated under the Marijuana Control Act. In Dover, there is one compassion center that is retail only. This facility applied for a conversion license through the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner.

Proposed Ordinances Two Ordinances proposed are text amendments to the Zoning Ordinance. These are described below with copies of the Proposed Ordinances attached. Also provided are excerpts from a map series (Map 1, 2, 3, and 4) which depict zoning district locations and the regulations (buffers) as proposed.

Ordinance #2024-29 – (Previously #2024-25A) This proposed Ordinance #2024-29 would permit marijuana cultivation, manufacturing and testing facilities in the Manufacturing (M) and Industrial Park Manufacturing (IPM) zones and would allow marijuana cultivation in the

Página 11

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #3.

Agricultural (A) zone. The proposed Ordinance #2024-29 would classify State-licensed compassion centers as a retail use (consistent with current practice). It would also establish the standards by which such businesses would be required to operate, including: • Confirming that compassion centers (retail only) are permitted in all commercial zones where retail uses are permitted; • Requiring the building footprint for marijuana cultivation facilities or marijuana product manufacturing facilities be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, hospital, college or university, child day care center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facilities; • Requiring that the building footprint of marijuana product testing facilities be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, hospital, child day care center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facilities; • Requiring that marijuana cultivation facilities and marijuana product manufacturing facilities install odor control technology and that all openings, windows and entryways for such facilities be covered to prevent view into the interior from any public or semipublic area; • Requiring that applicants for marijuana cultivation and marijuana product manufacturing uses comply with the provisions of the water, wastewater and electric handbooks, and that any the cost of utility upgrades required to support the utility demand for these facilities would be the responsibility of the applicant. • The draft ordinance would also establish definitions for the marijuana land uses that are consistent with the State definitions.

Ordinance #2024-30 – (Previously #2024-25B) This proposed Ordinance #2024-30 would permit marijuana retail stores in the Highway Commercial (C-4) zone, establish a definition for “retail marijuana store” consistent with the State regulations, and establish the standards by which such businesses would be required to operate, including: • Requiring that the building footprint for retail marijuana stores be at least 500 feet away from the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, child daycare center, State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facility, hospital, college, or university and at least 250 feet from any residential zone; • Requiring that the building footprint for a retail marijuana store be at least one (1) mile from the lot line of any other marijuana retail store within the City of Dover; • Requiring that that all openings, windows and entryways for retail marijuana stores be covered to prevent view into the interior from any public or semipublic area; • Allowing for a compassion center licensed by the State before January 1, 2024, to be permitted to convert to a retail marijuana store exempt from the distancing requirement. • The draft ordinance would also establish definitions for the marijuana land uses that are consistent with the State definitions.

Other Ordinances In addition to these two proposed ordinances related to zoning/land use for recreational marijuana facilities there are two companion ordinances related to business licensing. Proposed Ordinances #2024-24 and #2024-25 are proposed amendments to the Dover Code of Ordinances to establish the business license fees for marijuana cultivation, manufacturing, and test facilities, marijuana retail stores, and compassion centers. These are not subject to review by the Planning Commission as they do not amend the Zoning Ordinance.

Página 12

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #3.

II. TEXT AMENDMENT REVIEW PROCESS

Because these are Text Amendments proposed to the Zoning Ordinance, a Public Hearing and Recommendation by the Planning Commission is required. This review process began when the proposed Ordinance was submitted to the City Council for First Reading on October 28, 2024. The City Council has referred Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 to the Planning Commission for a Public Hearing and consideration on November 18, 2024 (Planning Commission SESSION 2). Then it is scheduled for Final Reading, Public Hearing and Final Action by Council on December 9, 2024. At the meeting the City Council may act to adopt the whole Ordinances, to reject it, or to adopt the Ordinances with amendments. Legal Advertisements were published in the Daily State News on Sunday, November 3, 2024 giving notice and participation information for the Public Hearings as scheduled.

III. RECOMMENDATION OF PLANNING STAFF:

Review and Recommendations: As part of the process outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the City Planner must evaluate the following factors when preparing a report on the text amendment request:

Article 10 § 5.22 City planner report. For each proposed zoning text amendment, the city planner shall issue a report to the planning commission and city council, including comments from other reviewing agencies, that evaluates the following factors:

(A) Whether such change is consistent with the aims and principles embodied in the ordinance as to the particular zones concerned; and;

(B) Whether proposed amendment is consistent with the aims of the comprehensive plan of the city.

The City of Dover developed the subject Ordinances in response to the State’s legalization of recreational marijuana through the Delaware Marijuana Control Act. In developing the Ordinances, the principles and aims of the Zoning Ordinance and the 2019 Comprehensive Plan were considered.

Marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing are consistent with the types of uses permitted withing the M (Manufacturing Zone) and IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone) Zones, as these zones permit manufacturing and industrial processing of goods and research and testing labs. Marijuana Cultivation is consistent with other uses permitted within the A (Agricultural Zone), including crop harvesting. Marijuana retail stores are consistent with other permitted uses in the C-4 Zone including retail, and the C-4 Zone is intended for high-intensity, auto-dependent uses. Additionally, in response to concerns regarding this new category of uses, the Ordinances provide distancing requirements from incompatible uses and other protections that municipalities are allowed to control (time and place).

The 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 12: Land Development Plan discusses goals for various land use types (Land Use Categories). Relative to the proposed Ordinances, the following sections apply. In relation to Commercial – High Intensity Areas, specifically US Route 13/DuPont Highway and Bay Road Corridors, the Plan’s recommendation states (page 12-13):

The US Route 13/DuPont Highway and Bay Road corridors are dominated by highway focused commercial development, as free-standing buildings, strip commercial centers, and formal shopping centers and mall spaces. For the most part, the Land

Página 13

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #3.

Development Plan proposes to continue US Route 13/DuPont Highway and Bay Road as the major commercial corridors in Central Delaware.

In relation to Employment Centers, the Plan includes the following policy (page 12-17):

Provide sufficient land area for industrial purposes to enable the expansion of existing industries, the establishment of new facilities, and revitalization of underutilized older industrial sites.

The Planning Office finds that the proposed Ordinances are consistent with the aims and principles of the Zoning Ordinance and the zones specifically addressed, as well as with the aims of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan.

Additionally, the following advisory items are noted.

  • 1)The Planning Office provided an opportunity to Development Advisory Committee (DAC) members to comment on the proposed Text Amendments at their meetings on October 30, 2024 and November 6, 2024. Several Departments/Agencies which participate in the DAC process provide comments of “no objection” with regard to the proposed Text Amendments. It is noted that some of these Departments participated in the research into the development of the proposed ordinances.
  • 2)The Proposed Ordinances are also subject to Legal Review by the City Solicitor, which may identify additional clarifications or corrections.
  • 3)The approval of these Text Amendments does not authorize the establishment of the regulated uses at any specific location. Prior to the establishment of a use, a State license through the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner and the appropriate applications for site development activity plan review, Building Permits, and other construction activity Permits, Business and Occupancy Licensing, etc. of the City of Dover are required.

IV. PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEW FOR RECOMMENDATION

This is a request for a zoning text amendment which revises the text in the Zoning Ordinance. The Planning Commission as part of their public hearing and review process will provide a recommendation on the zoning text amendment requests to City Council. As part of the process outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the Planning Commission must evaluate the following factors when considering the request:

Article 10 § 5.23 Report of the planning commission. Regarding each proposed amendment to the ordinance text, the planning commission shall provide a report to the city council stating a recommended action with regards to the proposed amendment, along with the commission's evaluation of the following factors:

(A) Whether such change is consistent with the aims and principles embodied in the ordinance as to the particular zones concerned; and

(B) Whether such proposed amendment is consistent with the aims of the comprehensive plan of the city.

Página 14

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #3.

A Recommendation Report from the Planning Commission will be forwarded to the City Council for their consideration of the Text Amendment Applications. This document and its attachments make up the Recommendation Report.

RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION:

At the Hybrid (In-Person and Virtual) Planning Commission Meeting Session 2 of November 18, 2024, the Text Amendment Application MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations (Ordinance #2024-29 and Ordinance #2024-30) was represented by Planning Staff and Ann Marie Townshend of the Rossi Group (the City’s Project Consultant). During the Public Hearing, three (3) members of the public spoke and no written comments for the meeting were received.

A presentation on the background and provisions of the Proposed Ordinances was given (see PowerPoint presentation slides). Then following the Public Hearing, the Planning Commission posed questions and discussed the proposed text amendments.

After a motion to recommend approval of Ordinance #2024-29 establishing provisions related to marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion center uses and with an amendment to add a distancing requirement of 750 feet from courthouses, the motion failed (vote 4 in favor and 5 against). See Meeting Minutes for reasons given.

The Planning Commission’s follow-up motion recommended to deny Ordinance #2024-29 related to marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion center uses and resulted in a vote of 5-4 (vote 5 in favor of denial and 4 against). See Meeting Minutes for reasons given. *

The Planning Commission’s motion recommended to deny Ordinance #2024-30 related to retail marijuana store uses and provisions for compassion center conversions and resulted in a vote of 5-4 (vote 5 in favor of denial and 4 against). See Meeting Minutes for reasons given. *

*With the recommendations to deny (not adopt) Ordinance #2024-29 and to deny (not adopt) Ordinance #2024-30 related to Recreational Marijuana Land Uses, the intent of the Planning Commission vote is to prohibit such land uses in the City of Dover, DE. To formalize this intent and to codify it into the Zoning Ordinance, see the attached Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-29 and Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-30 which define each marijuana land use and specify that the uses are prohibited.

See also the included excerpt of the DRAFT Meeting Minutes of the November 18, 2024 Planning Commission Meeting Session 2. The comments received from the other member agencies of the Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) are also provided.

Attachments: • Development Advisory Committee Comments: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Department of Water & Wastewater, Electric Department, Dover Kent County MPO

Reference Documents provided to the Planning Commission: • Council Resolution #2024-11 for Moratorium on Recreational Marijuana Related Uses • Recreational Marijuana White Paper (updated September 9, 2024)

Página 15

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #3.

  • •Marijuana Ordinance Q&A
  • •Summary of City of Dover Marijuana Survey (Report)
  • •Maps 1-4 (Excerpt of Map Series):
  • •Map 1 - Based on Ordinance #2024-29 (zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing) as proposed
  • •Map 2 - Based on Ordinance #2024-30 (zoning for retail) as proposed
  • •Map 3 – Zoning: A, IPM, M parcels
  • •Map 4 – Zoning: C-4 parcels

Planning Commission Meeting Session 2 of November 18, 2024: • Presentation (PowerPoint slides) to Planning Commission at Meeting Session 2 on November 18, 2024 • Excerpt of DRAFT Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of Meeting Session 2 on November 18, 2024

Planning Commission Substitute Ordinances (to prohibit uses): • Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-29 (Zoning Regulations for Cultivation, Manufacturing, and Testing Marijuana Facilities and Compassion Centers) to define marijuana cultivation facility, marijuana product manufacturing facility, and marijuana testing facility and to prohibit such uses

  • •Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-30 (Zoning Regulations for Retail Marijuana Stores) to define and prohibit the retail marijuana store use

Proposed Ordinances for Public Hearing and Final Action by City Council: • Proposed Ordinance #2024-29 (Zoning Regulations for Cultivation, Manufacturing, and Testing Marijuana Facilities and Compassion Centers)

  • •Proposed Ordinance #2024-30 (Zoning Regulations for Retail Marijuana Stores and Compassion Centers)

Página 16

CITY OF DOVER Item #3.

DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: OCTOBER 30, 2024

APPLICATION: Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations FILE #: MI-24-09 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Water & Wastewater CONTACT PERSON: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services CONTACT PHONE #: 302-736-7025 CONTACT EMAIL: jlyon@dover.de.us

T HE S UBJECT P ROPOSAL HAS BEEN R EVIEWED FOR C ODE C OMPLIANCE , P LAN C ONFORMITY AND C OMPLETENESS IN A CCORDANCE WITH THIS A GENCY ’ S A UTHORITY AND A REA OF E XPERTISE .

T HE F OLLOWING I TEMS HAVE BEEN I DENTIFIED AS E LEMENTS W HICH N EED TO BE A DDRESSED BY THE A PPLICANT :

ORDINANCE #2024-29

CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS

SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. Our office has no objections to the proposed text amendments RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. None

ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT

SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. None
ORDINANCE #2024-30
CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS
SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL
1. Our office has no objections to the proposed text amendments

RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL 1. None

ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT SANITATION / STREETS / STORMWATER / WATER / WASTEWATER / GENERAL

Página 17

Item #3. Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations File #: MI-23-01 October 30, 2023

  • 1.None

I F Y OU H AVE A NY Q UESTIONS OR N EED TO D ISCUSS ANY OF THE A BOVE C OMMENTS , P LEASE C ALL THE A BOVE C ONTACT P ERSON AND THE P LANNING D EPARTMENT AS S OON AS P OSSIBLE .

Página 18

Item #3.

CITY OF DOVER ELECTRIC
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY
STAFF D.A.C. MEETING DATE: OCT 30, 2024

APPLICATION: Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations FILE #: MI-24-09 REVIEWING AGENCY: City of Dover Electric Department CONTACT PERSON: Shawn Burgett, Engineering Services & System Ops Superintendent CONTACT PHONE #: 302-674-7568 CONTACT EMAIL #: sburgett@dover.de.us

T HE SUBJECT PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVIEWED FOR CODE COMPLIANCE , PLAN CONFORMITY AND COMPLETENESS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS AGENCY ’ S AUTHORITY AND AREA OF EXPERTISE .

T HE FOLLOWING ITEMS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS ELEMENTS WHICH NEED TO BE ADDRESSED BY THE APPLICANT :

CITY AND STATE CODE REQUIREMENTS

ELECTRIC

  • 1.The Electric Department has no objections to the amendment text of Ordinance #2024-29 and Ordinance #2024-30. RECOMMENDATIONS SUGGESTED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TO MEET CODE OBJECTIVES
  • 1.None

ADVISORY COMMENTS TO THE APPLICANT

  • 1.None

I F YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR NEED TO DISCUSS ANY OF THE ABOVE COMMENTS , PLEASE CALL THE ABOVE CONTACT PERSON AND THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT AS SOON AS POSSIBLE .

Página 19

Item #3.

CITY OF DOVER Dover/Kent
DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE
County
Metropolitan
APPLICATION REVIEW COMMENTARY Planning
D.A.C. MEETING DATE: 11/6/2024 Organization

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations

FILE # MI-24-09 REVIEWING AGENCY: Dover/Kent County MPO

CONTACT PERSON: Malcolm Jacob PHONE #: (302) 387-6030

Issues of concern to the MPO are effective transit, reducing the amount of vehicle emissions by shortening or eliminating trips, and facilities for alternative modes of transportation, including bicycle and pedestrian access. The MPO considers the bicycle facilities required by the City of Dover to be the standard for all applications, not to be waived.

City of Dover Planning Commission
Text Amendment Review

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations

Dover Kent MPO does not typically provide comments on text amendments, unless it pertains directly to transportation planning. The only suggestion from the MPO is to consider the impact of the regulations on access to retail facilities. Many of Dover’s residents do not own a personal vehicle, which makes it harder for them to reach and travel along US13. Because the “equity focus areas” identified by DelDOT are more likely to have zero-vehicle households, the MPO recommends looking at the Equity Analysis Tool to better understand which neighborhoods may have impaired access to the new retail facilities. This is important in terms of employment along the US13 corridor, particularly for those who cannot drive to work. Referring to DART’s existing and future bus networks, and the most recent US Census Bureau data, can also help in studying these access gaps. Please see the link below for the Equity Analysis Tool.

https://deldot.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=e051d6e4313142dfb8b03205 e511f661

If you have any questions or need to discuss any of the above comments, please call the above contact person and the Planning Department as soon as possible.

Página 20

Item #3.

(!Citp of 11Bober
MAYOR AND COUNCIL

COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-11

A RESOLUTION TO ENACT A MORATORIUM ON RECREATIONAL MARIJUANA RELATED USES IN THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Council seek to preserve, protect, and promote the general health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of the City of Dover, Delaware through the enactment of certain codes, ordinances, and other regulatory tools and policies that are necessary, and good to achieve that end; and

WHEREAS, recreational marijuana became legal for adult use in the State of Delaware on July 5, 2023, when the Delaware Marijuana Control Act went into effect; and

WHEREAS, the Delaware Marijuana Control Act allows municipalities to enact ordinances or regulations prohibiting the operation of recreational marijuana related establishments within their jurisdiction or governing the time, place, manner, and number of recreational marijuana establishment operations; and

WHEREAS, the Council Committee of the Whole, Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee discussed options on regulating recreational marijuana within the City of Dover at their meetings on September 26, 2023, and April 09, 2024, and directed city staff to draft an ordinance permitting recreational marijuana establishments within certain zones; and

WHEREAS, the Council Committee of the Whole, Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee discussed Proposed Ordinance #2024-24 relating to recreational marijuana business licenses, and Proposed Ordinance #2024-25 relating to zoning regulations on June 11,2024; and

WHEREAS, during this meeting, several public commenters raised concerns about the provisions outlined in these proposed ordinances; and

WHEREAS, following this discussion, the Council Committee of the Whole, Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee and City Council requested that more research and community outreach be conducted and ultimately deferred the issue to a Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting; and

WHEREAS, the State of Delaware Office of the Marijuana Commissioner will begin accepting applications for all recreational marijuana business license types on September 1, 2024, and will begin issuing licenses on November 1, 2024; and

  • P.O. Box 475 Dover, DE 19903 Q!:ommunitp ClExceUence mbrougb <l!}ualitp $erlJice Page 20

Página 21

COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-11 PAGE 2 Item #3.

WHEREAS, the City of Dover, Delaware is actively working to determine the best way to regulate land uses related to the recreational marijuana industry.

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED:

The City Council does hereby enact a moratorium on recreational marijuana related uses within the City of Dover, Delaware, subject to the following stipulations and conditions:

  • 1.This moratorium shall become effective immediately upon adoption by the City Council of the City of Dover, Delaware; and
  • 2.This moratorium shall apply to all recreational marijuana establishments licensed by the Delaware Office of the Marijuana Commissioner, which are defined as follows:
  • a)"Marijuana cultivation facility" means an entity licensed to cultivate, prepare, and package marijuana and sell marijuana to retail marijuana stores, to marijuana product manufacturing facilities, and to other marijuana cultivation facilities, but not to consumers. A marijuana cultivation facility may not produce marijuana concentrates, tinctures, extracts, or other marijuana products.
  • b)"Marijuana product manufacturing facility" means an entity licensed to purchase marijuana, manufacture, prepare, and package marijuana products, and sell marijuana and marijuana products to other marijuana product manufacturing facilities and retail marijuana stores, but not to consumers.
  • c)"Marijuana testing facility" means an entity licensed to test marijuana for potency and contaminants.
  • d)"Retail marijuana store" means an entity licensed to purchase marijuana from marijuana cultivation facilities, to purchase marijuana and marijuana products from marijuana product manufacturing facilities, and to sell marijuana and marijuana products to consumers.
  • 3.It shall be understood that the purpose of this moratorium is to afford the City Council a reasonable due diligence period to consider alternative courses of action relative to the governing of recreational marijuana uses within the city including, but not limited to, adoption of an amendment to the Dover Code of Ordinances, regulating the time, place, manner, and number of marijuana establishment options; and
  • 4.This moratorium shall remain in effect until December 31, 2024, unless rescinded by City Councilor unless City Council adopts ordinances related to recreational marijuana related uses/establishments at an earlier date.

Página 22

COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-11 PAGE 3 Item #3.

ADOPTED: July 22, 2024

~.~~ cU~~
ROBINR.~ DAVID L. ANDERSON
MA COUNCIL PRESIDENT

Actions History 07/22/2024 - Final Reading - City Council 07/09/2024 - Introduction - Council Committee of the Whole/Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee

Página 23

Item #3.

Recreational Marijuana White Paper Problem Statement Recreational marijuana became legal in the state of Delaware on July 5, 2023, when The Delaware Marijuana Control Act went into effect. This means that adults (ages 21+) may legally possess personal use quantities of marijuana in Delaware. Adults may also legally consume marijuana on private property. The Delaware Marijuana Control Act allows municipalities to regulate land uses relating to cultivation, manufacturing, testing, and sale of marijuana within their jurisdiction through local ordinance. The City of Dover needs to determine a path forward to best manage the presence of this industry through local zoning ordinance.

What can an ordinance accomplish? CAN CANNOT A municipal ordinance may prohibit the operation of A municipal ordinance may not prevent marijuana marijuana establishments within their jurisdiction. establishments from opening outside of City limits in Kent County or in unincorporated areas. A municipal ordinance may regulate the time, place, or A municipal ordinance may not prevent adults from manner in which marijuana establishments operate. legally purchasing recreational marijuana at a licensed establishment, possessing marijuana within City limits, or using marijuana within City limits on private property. A municipal ordinance may not create a specific marijuana licensing fee or tax, though they may collect uniformly imposed fees and taxes.

Why is an ordinance needed? The City Code does not currently define, zone land uses, or dictate regulations for marijuana related businesses. It is important that the City of Dover pass an ordinance to provide the public, business owners, City staff, and the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner (OMC) with clear guidance on whether, where, and under what conditions marijuana establishments are permitted within City limits.

When is an ordinance needed? The Office of the Marijuana Commissioner will begin to accept applications for recreational marijuana business licenses on September 1, 2024. It is important for the City to have an ordinance in place soon, as licensees will begin selecting business locations as early as November 2024. Four license types will be issued based on the following schedule mandated by The Delaware Marijuana Control Act:

License Type License Description Date Licenses Number of Begin Being Licenses Issued Issued Statewide Marijuana Cultivation facilities will grow marijuana plants indoors, 11/1/2024 Up to 60 Cultivation prepare and package marijuana, and sell to cultivation or Facility product manufacturing facilities. They are NOT open to the public.

Updated September 9, 2024
Page 1 of 3 Page 23

Página 24

Item #3.

Marijuana Manufacturing facilities will manufacture, prepare, and 12/1/2024 Up to 30 Product package marijuana products and sell to manufacturing Manufacturing facilities or retail marijuana stores. They are NOT open to the public. Retail Marijuana Retail stores will purchase marijuana products from 3/1/2025 Up to 30 Store manufacturing facilities and sell to consumers. They ARE open to the public. Marijuana Testing facilities will test for potency and contaminants to 3/1/2025 Up to 5 Testing Facility ensure that products meet State safety standards. They are NOT open to the public.

Ordinance Options OPTION 1 Prohibit all recreational marijuana businesses within the City of Dover PROS CONS This is a straightforward policy to administer and Prohibition would not address common concerns enforce. related to marijuana legalization such as odors, possession or usage on private property. Marijuana businesses may open in the County just outside of Dover City limits or in enclave areas surrounded by Dover.

Prevents the existing compassion center from converting to a retail license at their current location. OPTION 2 Allow marijuana related businesses to open as permitted use within certain zones in the City of Dover. PROS CONS This option gives the City control over elements of Lack of community consensus about where and if uses these uses (i.e. time and place). should be allowed in Dover. Retail establishments provide access to legal marijuana Retail marijuana establishments generally operate in products that meet State safety standards. cash, making them potential targets for crime. The public will have an opportunity to object to the Marijuana cultivation and manufacturing facilities may issuance of a license near their property as there is a produce a strong odor and be large consumers of water public notice process mandated by the State. and energy. OPTION 2a Allow marijuana related businesses only with additional restrictions to regulate the time, place, or manner in which businesses operate. PROS CONS Distancing requirements could be utilized to prevent a Spatial evaluation will be needed to ensure that marijuana facility from opening too close to other uses proposed facility locations meet distancing such as K-12 Schools or residential zones. requirements in place. Additionally, the City may: limit hours of operation, Extensive buffering requirements and zoning require additional odor control technology, implement restrictions create administrative challenges for staff standards in terms of architectural design, signage, and and confusion among the public. Each additional outdoor lighting, and require regular removal of litter requirement adds to the administrative burden of and graffiti. executing the ordinance. For example, the City does not maintain a comprehensive list of some types of facilities, which makes applying buffers difficult.

Updated September 9, 2024
Page 2 of 3 Page 24

Página 25

Item #3.

Additional Considerations

The Office of the Marijuana Commissioner (OMC) is the agency responsible for regulating the recreational marijuana industry in Delaware. The OMC has developed regulations for the recreational marijuana industry that address the application and licensing process, specific facility requirements, staffing, safety and security, product tracking, health standards, packaging and labeling requirements, advertising, product testing, taxation, policy enforcement, and more. Regulations are finalized and in effect as of September 11, 2024. Meanwhile, information regarding the most recent Proposed Marijuana Regulations is available here: Office of the Marijuana Commissioner (delaware.gov)

Q&A Can existing compassion centers be ‘grandfathered in’ at their current location? HB408 became effective on 7/17/2024. This bill creates a temporary conversion license for existing medical marijuana compassion centers to operate for recreational marijuana purposes. The OMC will start the licensing process in August. Businesses will be converted by 10/31/2024 with adult use sales beginning no sooner than April 2025. The proposed ordinance would add the definition of a compassion center to City Code and allow compassion centers as a permitted use in all zones. Adding a ‘grandfather’ clause to the ordinance COULD allow the existing compassion center located on Route 13 in Dover to convert to a retail license at their existing location IF recreational marijuana retail uses are permitted in the C-4 Highway Commercial Zone. To do this, language would be added to the proposed ordinance that would exempt compassion centers operating prior to the passage of the Marijuana Control Act from buffering requirements in converting to a marijuana retail store, provided that the facility is located in a zone that allows marijuana retail stores. Can existing shops that sell smoke, vape, and CBD products be ‘grandfathered in’ at their current location? ‘Grandfathering’ is typically used when a use was once permitted but is no longer permitted in a certain zone. ‘Grandfathering’ provisions allow for existing uses that operated legally prior to a change in code to continue operation. In the case of compassion centers, while the use is different, it is similar to the marijuana retail store in that the product is the same and that these compassion centers operate under a license issued by the State. This is not the case for shops that sell smoke, vape, and CBD products. Neither State nor City Code provides a definition of a shop selling smoke, vape, or CBD products, nor maintains a list of these facilities. These establishments are currently treated as retail use within the City’s Zoning Ordinance. This means that there is not an easy way to differentiate between shops selling smoke, vape, and CBD products and any other retail use (i.e. a gas station that sells cigarettes), making it difficult to draft code language to grandfather these uses. Shops that sell vape, smoke, and CBD products are markedly different uses from marijuana retail stores as defined by the Marijuana Control Act, which further complicates efforts to ‘grandfather’ these facilities. Additionally, there are several shops selling smoke, vape, and CBD products throughout commercial zones in Dover, potentially in areas where marijuana retail uses would not be permitted in whatever ordinance is approved by City Council.

Updated September 9, 2024
Page 3 of 3 Page 25

Página 26

Item #3.

Marijuana Ordinance Q&A Compassion Centers & Conversion Licenses What is a compassion center? Delaware’s Medical Marijuana Act created the state’s Medical Marijuana Program, which has been operated by the Office of Medical Marijuana within Delaware Health and Social Services (DHSS) Division of Public Health. Under State code, municipalities may regulate but may not prohibit compassion centers from operating within their jurisdiction. Title 16 § 4902A of the Delaware Code defines a Registered Compassion Center as a “not-for-profit entity registered pursuant to §4914A of this title that acquires, possesses, cultivates, manufactures, delivers, transfers, transports, sells, supplies, or dispenses marijuana, paraphernalia, or related supplies and educational materials to registered qualifying patients who have designated the dispenser to cultivate marijuana for their medical use and the registered designated caregivers of these patients.” The Delaware Marijuana Control Act created a new recreational marijuana program to be operated by the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner within the Department of Safety and Homeland Security (DSHS). House Bill 425 became effective in July 2024. This bill moves the Office of Medical Marijuana from DHSS to the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner within DSHS. There are currently 12 open compassion centers in the state of Delaware, one of which is located within the City of Dover on Jefferic Boulevard. Some compassion centers, such as Best Buds, operate as dispensaries that simply sell medical marijuana products to medical cardholders. Others grow, manufacture, and sell medical marijuana.

What is a conversion license? House Bill 408 became effective July 2024. This bill creates a conversion license for existing medical marijuana compassion centers to operate for recreational marijuana purposes. The Office of the Marijuana Commissioner plans to begin the conversion license process in early August and have all businesses converted before October 31st of this year. Converted companies will be able to expand growing and manufacturing operations once the license is awarded, though no adult use sales will occur prior to April of 2025, which is when the recreational marijuana retail establishments will open.

Will conversion license holders retain not-for-profit status? No. According to Delaware State Code, a Compassion Center must have not-for-profit status. When medical companies convert to dual use, retaining not-for-profit status will no longer be a requirement, though license holders will be required to certify that they will continue to support medical patients. With conversion, the recreational marijuana retail stores will also sell medical marijuana to medical cardholders.

What will happen to compassion centers? The Office of the Marijuana Commissioner expects the demand for medical marijuana compassion centers to decline as recreational marijuana retail stores open. As such, they expect all medical locations to request conversion licenses. If an existing compassion center is issued a conversion license by the state, but local code does not allow a

Página 27

Item #3.

recreational marijuana business to operate at the existing location, the business would have to relocate to utilize the conversion license. It is expected that medical marijuana cardholders will utilize recreational retailers. The advantage of having a medical card is that these patients will not have to pay the tax levied on recreational marijuana, and those who are not eligible to purchase recreational marijuana would still have access (i.e. a person under 21 years of age with medical need).

Water and Energy Consumption How much water and energy does a marijuana cultivation facility utilize? Water Use Local Examples After reaching out to existing operations in Delaware, which include both cultivation and manufacturing activities, we learned that water use varies significantly depending on the cultivation method used. On the lower end, there is a facility of about 10,000 SF that uses an amount of water comparable to 5-6 houses. There is another facility of approximately 100,000 SF whose peak use was 75,000 gallons of water in a month. Additional Research Studies have found that cannabis requires significantly more water than other crops such as wheat, corn, soybeans. A commonly referenced statistic on water usage within cannabis grow operations comes from a 2021 study from the Journal of Cannabis Research, which found that on average, one cannabis plant needs 6 gallons of water per day (Source: How much water does it take to grow cannabis? | Cannabis | Tucson Weekly) The Cannabis Control Commission for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts provides information on Best Management Practices for Water Usage. They note that water usage may differ between indoor marijuana cultivation facilities depending on the plant cultivation method used. Additionally, water recycling systems may be used to clean and filter used water back into irrigation, reducing the amount of freshwater input into the system. That said, medical marijuana studies estimate that a 250 SF grow room would generally require 98 inches of water per year, or 40 gallons of water per day. Dover Water System Analysis The City of Dover Water and Wastewater Department completed an analysis to determine the sufficiency of the water system to support marijuana cultivation in the IPM, M and A zones. Based upon the modeling, the system could support the water demand associated with a 100,000-square-foot cultivation facility in most areas where the current draft ordinance proposes allowing cultivation facilities. In some areas, an increase in the size of the water main might be required to meet fire flow requirements. City staff ran the model using water demand at 108 Thousand gallons (Tgal) per day and also at 75 Tgal per month. The higher number is based on industry research, and the lower number is based on the actual water demand for a cultivation and manufacturing facility in Delaware. The modeling identified several areas where the required fire flow could not be supported even with a water main upgrade. Language could be added to the draft ordinance that specifies that off-site upgrades, including water main replacement to support demand, would be the responsibility of the applicant. For revenue projection, using the conservative estimate of the 75 Tgal per month demand for the Delaware example, the water revenue would be approximately $275 per month or $3,300 annually.

Página 28

Item #3.

Electric Consumption Local Example After reaching out to existing operations in Delaware, which include both cultivation and manufacturing activities, we learned that water use varies depending on the cultivation method used. There is a facility of about 10,000 SF whose demand for electricity is roughly equal to 30 houses in the area. There is also a warehouse of approximately 100,000 SF whose monthly electric use peaked at 536,000 kWh in a month. Newark: To address the variability in water and energy use, Newark ensured that their code allows them to deny plans if they would exceed the capacity of existing utility infrastructure, with the option for the developer to pay for necessary upgrades to move the project forward. National Examples Oregon: Within the state, cannabis cultivators are generally required to forecast their energy needs before beginning operation and must also submit annual energy use reports. Oak Creek, Colorado: This is a small town of about 1,000 people with public power. They have a one block industrial area, which now houses a number of cannabis businesses including four grow operations. Their town administrator said that the business brought a 26% increase in load, leading to $800,000 in revenues in 2016. They were projecting $1 million in revenues the following year but invested $460,000 in electric system upgrades. Upgrades were supported, in part, by annual licensing fees as well as plant investment fees collected from cannabis businesses. Boulder, Colorado: Requires commercial growers to pay $2.16 per kilowatt hour or use renewable energy systems to reduce their loads. Source: Putting the ‘Green’ in Renewable Energy at Cannabis Grow Facilities: Pullman & Comley (pullcom.com) Additional Research A 2018 report from the American Public Power Association notes that there is a need for more data regarding marijuana cultivation and energy consumption. It is known that growing cannabis indoors requires the use of lighting, venting, and air conditioning, which all require electricity. However, it has been a challenge for utilities to establish a baseline energy consumption rate for this industry. Based on interviews with medical marijuana growers in California, one utility came up with a rough standard:

 A single 1,000-watt high density discharge light consumes 1,100 watts per four foot-by-four foot area. That averages out to 68.8 watts per square foot. However, it is possible to use more energy efficient lighting implements, such as LED’s.  The report also references a 2012 study by Evan Mills published in the journal Energy Policy, which found that it takes about 13,000 kWh a year to operate a four-by-four-by-eight foot grow area.  An account manager from a Public Utility in Washington is quoted in the report comparing a cannabis grow operation with the load profile of a data center or a hospital. The National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) reported on average electricity consumption in Boulder County Colorado in 2015.

 The average electricity consumption of a 5,000-square-foot indoor marijuana cultivation facility was 41,808 kWh per month. By comparison, the average household in the county used about 630 kWh per month.

Página 29

Item #3.

Dover Electric System Analysis

The City of Dover Electric Department determined that based on a 100,000-square-foot cultivation facility, with an electric demand of 5.36 kWh per square foot per month, the annual demand would be about 6.4 Megawatts. Such a facility would be the fourth largest electric customer in Dover. The Department determined that the system could support this demand. This hypothetical customer would pay approximately $462,500 for electricity in a year, $100,000 - $150,000 of which would go to purchase of power.

How much water and energy does a marijuana manufacturing facility utilize? There is very little available research on this subject. The bulk of literature addressing heavy water and energy consumption in the marijuana industry focuses on cultivation. Manufacturing marijuana may be similar to other manufacturing uses in terms of water and energy use. The demand for water and energy would vary depending on the size of the facility and equipment and practices used.

Sustainable Practices

There are practices that can help cannabis grow facilities to reduce water and energy consumption. Solar power generation, use of LED light bulbs, and drip water irrigation are some examples. Generally, water and energy standards are handled at the state level. Most states where cannabis is legal, including Colorado, do not require cultivation facilities to meet specific energy standards, though Illinois and Massachusetts do. The Office of the Marijuana Commissioner’s Draft Regulations require that marijuana cultivation facilities have an environmental and sustainability plan that includes efforts the facility will take to minimize the environmental impact of its operations and plans to minimize water usage.

Odor Mitigation

Unlike sustainable practices, odor mitigation is more often handled at the local level. For example, nearly every county in Colorado has a strict odor ordinance. Ordinances generally require the use of some kind of filtration system. The most common type is Carbon Filtration, though biofilters, ozone generators, and other methods are also used. The National Cannabis Industry Association Policy Council issued a publication addressing industry impacts, best management practices, and policy considerations in 2020. The section titled ‘Best Management Practices: Air Quality’ on page 40 includes a detailed summary of odor control technology used. They note that Carbon Filtration is the most commonly used and recommended technology for reducing odor emissions as they are effective and reliable when properly maintained. Canada has federal requirements for odor filtration. Before obtaining a commercial license for indoor production of cannabis, applicants need to demonstrate that they have an adequate air filtration system. Health Canada’s Good production practices guide for cannabis contains the requirements for filtration and ventilation systems and proper maintenance is required (Section 5.1.5.1). Some ordinances require that the applicant hire a specialist (such as HVAC technician) to help them comply with local odor control requirements. According to an article in Chemical and Engineering News, Byers Scientific is an example of a company working to create emerging odor-mitigation technology. They combine “Carbon Scrubbers” and vaporizers to mitigate odors caused by the venting process, which is when roof vents are opened to control temperature and humidity. The carbon scrubbers absorb odors before air passes through a waterless vapor emitted along the base of each top vent. The vapor neutralizes the odors before they are released into the environment, according to Byers Scientific.

Página 30

Item #3.

Cultivation within Agricultural Preservation Districts

Are Marijuana Cultivation Facilities permitted within Agricultural Preservation Districts? Agricultural Preservation Districts are administered by the State’s Department of Agriculture. The Department of Agriculture does not have clear guidance to answer this question at this time, although they raised two major considerations. First, according to the Department of Agriculture, agricultural buildings are permitted within Agricultural Preservation Districts, which might allow for cultivation operations. However, ancillary uses, such as offices, laboratories, and processing areas, would not be permitted within an Agricultural Preservation District. The existing cultivation facilities in Delaware also include associated/ancillary uses, including manufacturing, testing, and retail. Any uses other than cultivation would clearly not be permitted (as either a principal or accessory use) within Agricultural Preservation Districts. Second, some Agricultural Conservation Easements were purchased with a combination of State and Federal funds. Marijuana remains illegal under federal law, so this would also need to be considered if a request came forward. Further review and consultation with the Department of Agriculture would be necessary if the City received a request to allow a cultivation facility on a property within an Agricultural Preservation District.

Página 31

Item #3.

Summary of City of Dover Marijuana Survey

Following several discussions before the City Council Committee of the Whole (CCCW) regarding marijuana legalization and whether and where marijuana-related land uses should be permitted within the City of Dover, City Administration and Rossi Group developed an online survey to gauge public opinion. The survey (attached at the end of this document) was published through Constant Contact on July 2, 2024, and the link to the survey was shared with City Council, through social media outlets, and on the City’s website. At a CCCW meeting on July 9, 2024, the Committee discussed the survey and requested that paper copies be made available and the survey be inserted in City utility bills beginning on July 15, 2024. Further, the closing date for the survey was extended from July 21, 2024 to August 31, 2024. In accordance with this direction, City staff placed paper surveys and drop boxes at City buildings, including Customer Service (5 E. Reed Street), City Hall Inspections Counter, the John W. Pitts Center, and the Dover Public Library. When the survey closed, the City had received a total of 2,228 surveys. Of these 831 were paper surveys and 1,409 surveys were completed online. The following is a summary of both the paper and online surveys received. Not all respondents completed every question, so the number of respondents for each question is indicated a “N=”. For some questions, there were open-ended questions where the respondent could provide a comment. These responses are captured at the end of this document. With the exception of correcting spelling errors and fixing characters that exported from the survey platform incorrectly, the responses documented in this report are verbatim as submitted by the respondents.

1

Página 32

Item #3.

Summary of Marijuana Survey Results
1. What is your age?
Under

Options21:
Under 21:151%1%
21-34:
21-34:36516%
16%
35-44:38717%
Over 64:
45-54:29813%37%
55-64:33215%35-44:
Over 64:83137%17%
N=2228
55-64:45-54:
15%13%
Non-Prefer
2. What is your gender Binary not to
1%answer
Options3%
Male105347%
Female110250%
Male
Non-Binary121%Female47%
49%
Prefer not to593%
answer
N=2226
  • 3.What Council District do you live in? Do not live in City, but Options own a business in City:, 4% District 1: 345 17% District 2: 388 19% District 1: Do not live in 17% District 3: 386 19% City: District 4: 192 9% 22% Unknown: 216 10% District 2: Do not live in City, 91 4% 19% but own a business Unknown: in City: 10%
Do not live in City:45722%District 4:District 3:
N=20759%19%

2

Página 33

Item #3.
4. Which of the following policy options do you support?
Other
1%
Options

Dover should ALLOW recreational74934%
marijuana businesses within the City
without any special restrictions.
ALLOW
Dover should ALLOW recreational28913%without any
marijuana businesses within the Cityrestrictions
with strong controls.PROHIBIT all34%
Dover should only ALLOW some26212%40%
recreational marijuana businesses
within the City with strong controls.ALLOW all
Dover should only PROHIBIT all88640%with strong
recreational marijuana businesses fromALLOW some controls
opening within City limits.with strong13%
controlsALLOW
Other372%12%58%
N=2223
  • 5.Do you support allowing any of the following 1250 marijuana related uses in the City? (You can 1188 choose multiple responses) 1200

1150

Options1100
10591068
Cultivation105948%
1050
Manufacturing100345%1003
Retail118853%1000
Testing106848%950
All2228
Respondents900
CultivationManufacturingRetailTesting
  • 6.Do you support allowing marijuana cultivation, Uncertain manufacturing, and testing facilities in Industrial and 7% Manufacturing zones within the City of Dover? Options Yes 1148 52% No 917 41% Yes No 52% Uncertain 146 7% 41% N= 2211

3

Página 34

Item #3.
7. Do you support allowing marijuana cultivation, Other

manufacturing, and testing facilities in other locationsUncertain
within the City of Dover? If "yes" please list possible9%3%
locations in "other"

Options
Yes

Yes83738%
38%
No111750%
Uncertain21310%No
Other613%50%
N=2228

Uncertain
8. Do you support allowing marijuana cultivation facilities 6%
in Agricultural zones within the City of Dover? Note:
Agricultural zones appear in green on the map.
Options

Yes115152%
Yes
No92642%No
52%
Uncertain1396%42%
N=2216
  • 9.Do you support allowing retail marijuana stores along Uncertain the Route 13/Bay Road Corridor within the City of 4% Dover? Options Yes 1192 54% No 940 42% No Yes Uncertain 89 4% 42% 54% N= 2221

4

Página 35

Item #3.
10. Do you support allowing retail marijuana stores in

Downtown Dover?Uncertain
4%
Options
Yes100845%
No113151%
Uncertain814%Yes
N=2220No45%
51%

Other
11. Do you support allowing retail marijuana stores in 8%
other locations within the City of Dover? If "yes"
please respond where in "other" section.
Options

Yes97643%
Yes
No114150%
42%
Other1758%No
N=229250%

5

Página 36

Item #3. 12. How important is it that there be a buffer or minimum distance required between marijuana cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and the following types of places?

2000Schools1632
Schools1500
Not at all28413%
1000
Somewhat25812%
Very163275%500284258
N=2174
0
Not at allSomewhatVery
2000Daycares1632
Daycares1500
Not at all29714%
1000
Somewhat25312%
Very163275%500297253
N=2182
0
Not at allSomewhatVery
1600Rehabilitation Centers1353
Rehabilitation Centers1400
1200
Not at all46121%
1000
Somewhat34216%800
Very135363%600461
342
400
N=2156200
0
Not at allSomewhatVery
1400Parks1217
Parks1200
Not at all55626%1000
Somewhat39118%800
556
600
Very121756%391
400
N=2164
200
0
Not at allSomewhatVery

6

Página 37

Item #3.

1400Residential1195
1200
Residential
1000
Not at all58227%
800
582
Somewhat39118%600391
Very119555%400
N=2168200
0
Not at allSomewhatVery
1400Hospitals1184
Hospitals1200
Not at all63129%1000
Somewhat35416%800631
Very118455%600
354
400
N=2169
200
0
Not at allSomewhatVery

7

Página 38

Item #3. 13. How important is it that there be a buffer or minimum distance required between marijuana retail stores and the following types of places?

Schools

Schools20001619
Not at all26512%1500
Somewhat28713%1000
Very161975%500265287
N=2171
0
Not at allSomewhatVery

Daycares

Daycares2000
1566
Not at all33415%1500
Somewhat27012%1000
Very156672%500334270
N=21700
Not at allSomewhatVery

Rehabilitation Centers
Rehabilitation Centers

15001326
Not at all45521%
Somewhat36717%1000
Very132662%455367
500
N=2148
0
Not at allSomewhatVery

Parks

Parks1500
1206
Not at all57427%
1000
Somewhat38118%
574
Very120656%500381
N=2161
0
Not at allSomewhatVery

8

Página 39

Item #3.
Hospitals

Hospitals1500
1150
Not at all65630%
1000
Somewhat34916%656
Very115053%500349
N=2155
0
Not at allSomewhatVery

Residential

Residential1138
1200
Not at all666 31%1000
Somewhat359 17%800666
Very1138 53%600
359
400
N=2163200
0
Not at allSomewhatVery
  • 14.What concerns do you have about allowing 1600 marijuana related facilities in the City of 1338 1400 Dover? (You can choose more than one) 1145 1200 998 1000 902 Options Total 800 622 Increased Crime 1145 575 600 470 447 Decreased Property Value 902 400 Noise 622 200 Impact on Youth 470 0 Traffic Congestion 998 Environmental Impact 575 Odor 1338 Other 447
  • 15.What potential benefits do you see in allowing marijuana related facilities in the 1400 City of Dover? (You can choose more than 1146 1119 1127 1200 one) 994 1000 800 Options Total 600 477 Economic Growth 1146 400 Increased Licensing Revenue 1119 200 Job Creation 994 0 Better Regulation of Marijuana Products 1127 Economic Increased Job Creation Better Other Growth Licensing Regulation of Other 477 Revenue Marijuana Products

9

Página 40

Item #3. “Other” responses to Question 4: Which of the following policy options do you support?  Dover should prohibit marijuana businesses, tobacco businesses, alcohol businesses, and vaping businesses. All things that can cause harm.  One retail store in Midtown Loockerman to bring customers to shop. No other businesses  It stinks keep it out of town  Regulate the same as alcoholic beverages  just like alcohol, if not within the law, prosecuted as any criminal act  Please do not introduce more addiction to anyone. We have enough addicts now.  Our city has too much trash, addicts, homelessness, hungry people and negative ways of living within the City of Dover. Enough is enough! Drugs are no good anywhere!  Medical only  No sales within the city  I don’t live in the city therefore I shall not answer.  Allow within the city but must not allowed near schools  It should be prohibited in the entire state!  Same as alcohol policies  Dover should allow recreational marijuana businesses within the City of Dover following Liquor Store controls  Please join the beach towns, Middletown, Dagsboro, Millsboro. Ban growing, sales of this in our CITY!  Only for medicinal purposes  It just creates more crime and criminal activity.  There is NO valid reason to encourage public use of ANY drug. Such use is deleterious to public safety and participation to public events.  Against marijuana  My doctor recommends it and I cannot afford a medical card, just move forward and stop waiting on what is everyone else doing. Make a decision for once, Dover!  We have enough crime in Dover  Does alcohol have special restrictions?  Democratize the recreational marijuana industry!  Neighbor always high and don’t feel safe  This will allow more drug related issues for the state! Should never have been allowed at all only for medical issues. I hope they are being treated the same as someone driving drinking same fines!  Dover should only allow minimum number (2) of marijuana businesses within city limits and in close surveillance by security authorities. Police state & federal monitoring  Do not allow at all unless medically prescribed by a Doctor MD  None Every  Dover need to deal with current homeless and fentanyl use. Marijuana smell already in Dover. No one, obeying laws already.  We need law and order for our citizens. Drivers today are bad enough without it (marijuana) . With it---scary. Let people find moral recreation as we did-it's free!  Marijuana makes people numb and dumb and us a gateway to other illegal drugs.  normal restrictions like age.  Dover needs to deal with current homeless and fentanyl use. Marijuana smell already in Dover. No one obeying laws already.  Allow recreational marijuana businesses within the city with strong controls - as well as creating a maximum cap on the total number of rec marijuana businesses within the city to preclude the exclusion of other business types  Dover and the state need to ban Marijuana. It not good. No store can't sell it in DE  DOVER SHOULD ALLOW RECREATIONAL MARIJUANA BUSINESS WHERE EVER ALCOHOL AND TOBACCO IS. SOLD .  Dover should allow recreational marijuana only in the business districts with minimum requirements to open.  Dover should only ALLOW some recreational marijuana businesses within the City with SOME controls.  Dover should PROHIBIT all use of marijuana, recreationally and medicinally. It is a gateway drug, even when used medicinally, and the dangers and harms FAR outweigh any possible helps. We do NOT want to be the next Colorado.  I believe that Dover should allow recreational use but just like alcohol there should be some controls  I feel it should be handled as alcohol is .  Make legal to certain age  Same restrictions as on alcohol and cigarettes  Should allow recreational marijuana business within city limits within control and restrictions  They should be allowed but I'm wondering exactly what "strong controls" means. I believe that marijuana should be treated very similarly to alcohol.  What exactly is strong control?

10

Página 41

Item #3. “Other” responses to Question 7: Do you support allowing marijuana cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities in other locations within the City of Dover? If "yes" please list possible locations in "other"  100% for growing the industry within our town with purchasing from illegal vendors. This is also a very profitable  agriculture zones industry that should be accessible to all.  All above items should be allowed in any area within the Dover  Need information on what is involved in manufacture, cultivation, city limits. and testing but generally any zone which allows similar activities  All locations everywhere should allow legal activities. More should allow this government equals more taxes and less rights.  Not in the downtown area  All manufacturing should be treated as though it is a hazard to  On the outskirts of town with distance from residential area and human health. schools.  Any commercial zone  Outside incorporated limits  Any current industrial parks for manufacturing and testing labs  Outskirts of Dover/country  Any farm in Dover should be allowed to grow marijuana  Plaza where buffalo wings is at.  Any location  Plenty of unused fields and plants in the Dover area  ANY location within the City is fine. These facilities pose no  Possibly around the old Playtex apparel area or out around threat to local citizens. Horsepond Rd  Any manufacturing, cultivation, and testing should only exist  Yes – Any within industrial/manufacturing or agricultural zones and regulated  To support low income are as such.  Yes – Wherever  Any place where alcohol would be allowed.  Yes – RT 8 further west plenty of industrial zoned properties  Any where we currently allow alcohol.  Yes – Farms  Any. These are business owners with employees. We should not  Yes – Industrial Parks only make it hard for them to do business in the city.  Yes – any and all must be fenced in  Any/all locations.  Yes – non-residential areas  Anywhere  Yes – Industrial Parks (Testing facilities)  Anywhere alcohol is allowed.  Yes – Business District  Anywhere available.  Yes – West of Dover  anywhere besides on school property  Yes – Where open spaces are  Anywhere business can go they should be allowed to go.  Yes – Any – Why prohibit taxpayers  Anywhere other than near schools  Yes – in a controlled pace!!!  Anywhere other then downtown.  Yes – Don’t know  Anywhere plausible for the resources required for the business to  Yes – Areas designated for such use function.  Yes – Any  Anywhere that isn't next to a school  Yes – All  Anywhere with available space. Possibly a mutually beneficial  Yes – Nonresidential agreement with local colleges like Del Tech to use their labs for  No – None – Stop testing in exchange for educating students on the process.  Yes – Home Grown for personal use only  Anywhere!  Yes – Prive residence  Anywhere, it's not a dangerous substance or process.  Yes – Dover Mall  Camden  Yes – in vacant spaces, in empty buildings/stores, old sears,  Controlled facilities and with regulations. Macys, post office  Cultivation on agricultural properties.  Yes – I do not see a need to limit  Do not care where these locations are stationed.  Yes – Any rural (open air) areas  Downtown, small business  Yes – West Dover  Everywhere  Yes – unknown  Farm land up for sale  Yes – DSU – U.D. Cooperative Extension (Perdue Building)  Farm land. Do not build more homes!  Yes – outside district limits  Farm/Agriculture, fields that have been for sale.  not in the city  Home cultivation  Yes – with limits in scope  In a safe monitored low crime area  Yes – Lots of farmland here  In areas commercially zoned that do not directly abut a  Preferably @ current (existing) I&M Parks/locations residential area  RT. 8 West Dover  In other cities in Delaware  Places with space  In the southern part of Dover and western parts of Dover  Yes – Same as alcohol locations  Make use of current unused buildings?  Yes – Select Business Zones (indoor)  Marijuana is a plant not a crime! Promoting access to safely  Near other factories produced marijuana reduces the risk of use and harm associated  Empty existing built stores, strip malls, business/retail locations

11

Página 42

Item #3.  Not sure of feasible locations  South/North Governors  Garrison Park  West Dover  As long as there is strong control.  Near open fields by packing company/the many vacant plazas.  Commercial and Residential  Where feasible  Map too small  Hamlet Shopping Center  Industrial, manufacturing, and agricultural zones  Possibly the area where General Foods is located  Very limited locations, not near school, etc,  Private dwellings  In commercial area  Safe areas where there is not any type of chemical runoff that  In retail areas gets absorbed into the material and now you're taking in  Empty warehouses something that is a natural product that's going to poison your  Little Creek body  No restrictions  Same locations as alcohol and tobacco cultivation, manufacturing  Everywhere and testing, if any  Enterprise business park  Seaford, Milford, Harrington, rehoboth beach, Bethany  Nearby fields there are enough around  Should have similar regulations as breweries, pubs, and liquor  Repurpose empty buildings stores when it comes to locations.  Any available locations  The agricultural zones, the industrial and manufacturing zones  Carrol’s Corner are too close to my home and I'm afraid marijuana infrastructure  South/North State Street would further deteriorate the safety in my neighborhood.  There's plenty if empty warehouses and buildings all over the City.  Where ever the business owner wishes to locate their business  Wherever tobacco is allowed

“Other” responses to Question 11: Do you support allowing retail marijuana stores in other locations within the City of Dover? If "yes" please respond where in "other" section.  ?  Anywhere  A more rural store  Anywhere  All above items should be allowed in any area within the Dover  Anywhere city limits.  Anywhere  All locations everywhere  Anywhere  Allowing a store downtown would drive much needed business to  Anywhere a vape store is permitted the area but really anywhere in Dover would be acceptable  Anywhere available.  Along 13  Anywhere business can go they should be allowed to go.  Along Bay Rd near AFB  Anywhere but in immediate downtown main streets  Along Rt 8, Salisbury Road, New Burton Road  Anywhere in city limits with same zoning as liquor stores.  Along the highway  Anywhere in Dover we absolutely need more marijuana retail  Any area stores everywhere here, this state is too underdeveloped as it is,  Any area. the retail stores will give us something new  Any dormant shopping location  Anywhere liquor can be sold  Any location except the Downtown Dover area.  Anywhere not next to a school  Any location where businesses are allowed, with consideration for  Anywhere plausible for the resources required for the business to possible traffic & parking issues function.  Any place where alcohol would be allowed.  Anywhere that isn't residential but regulated per Delaware laws  Any place where businesses are  Anywhere that it is appropriate to have a retail store. We have  Any property that would allow a tobacco store or liquor store. liquor stores throughout Dover, in and out of Downtown, so I am  Any where like vape or liquor stores are currently okay with rec. marijuana as well.  Any where that is zoned for commercial use  Anywhere where a liquor store could/is located  Any zone where similar retail activity is permitted  Anywhere with available space, maybe the mall  Any.  Anywhere you currently allow a liquor or tobacco store.  Any/all locations  Anywhere!  Anyplace a liquor store is allowed  Anywhere, as long as buffers are given for schools, and medical  Anyplace other then downtown. facilities.  anywhere  Anywhere.  Anywhere  Anywhere. It's not a dangerous product.  ANYWHERE  As previously stated  Anywhere  Away from downtown but still in Dover. For example  Anywhere

12

Página 43

 Away from schools and daycare centers where space is available. should not be restricted further than the others two types ofItem #3. Separate from from medical Marijuana store. Some mm patients stores. like privacy.  Maybe. Not certain  CAMDEN  Milford, seaford, rehoboth beach, bethany  Commercial zones 250 feet from schools  Must be a certain amount of miles away from schools or parks.  Depends. You do not want to create a target for crime. A  Near other retail locations cultivation or processing facility may attract those with criminal  Near route 13 or Forest Ave intent. The retail stores are usually fortified much like the  Neutral dispensaries.  Not in Downtown Dover. Downtown attracts too much homeless  Doesn't matter and violent crime offenders.  Dover does not limit the presence of liquor stores, so there should  not near schools be no greater limit on retail marijuana stores.  Not near schools or colleges  Dover Mall  Not the main roads, I believe those types of facilities attract  Downtown negative behavior in the surrounding area.  Downtown  On duPont Highway  Downtown, Loockerman Street  Other major streets with business such as parts of South State ST  Empty business on Governors Ave, Rt. 8, and Rt. 13. and Governors Ave and Forrest.  Everywhere  Other shopping areas  Everywhere  out side the city sure  Everywhere nigga. Fuck the white man  Outside city limits in rural farm land  Everywhere!  Possibly on Forrest Ave, somewhere on the westside  Forrest Avenue, Walker Road, Salisbury Road. Pretty much  Puffster’s! anywhere where there are businesses.  Retail locations outside of downtown and office/industrial parks  I do not see any reason to restrict their physical location. So work well. I hope that members of council will visit recreational anywhere other businesses are allowed is fine facilities in neighboring states before making a decision. There is  I don’t have anywhere particular in mind, but we have a lot of on in Centerville, Annapolis and Elkton. vacant storefronts throughout the City.  Retail marijuana is good for everyone , Delaware will profit from it  I support the growth of the cannabis industry. , create more jobs, and if marijuana is legal , it hurts drugs  If it is just a retail store it can exist within retail areas. I would not dealers!!! want retail stores in residential areas.  Rodney village shopping center, gas stations/ stores that sell  In a low crime area tobacco and marijuana related products  In all locations where liquor stores are permitted.  Route 13  In all places alcohol is sold.  Route 13 corridor  In certain business areas, mostly away from biz that typically  Route 8 and route 15. cater to children and families.  Route 8, 15. Wherever other business can exist  Industrial and Manufacturing zones  RT 8  Industrial and manufacturing zones.  Rt 8 business area  Industrial areas away from schools  Rt. 8  It's hard enough to get parking in the city. Most medical Marijuana  RT. 8 commercial zones places have lines, but have parking. Keep the lines off the  Same as alcohol. sidewalks and in front of other retailers then ok.  Same locations where alcohol and tobacco retail sales are  Local bakeries or coffee shops could work to mutually benefit allowed cannabis retail stores akin to culture in early 21st century  Same or similar where smoke shops/CBD stores are located Netherlands.  service commercial areas  Location regulations should be similar to breweries, pubs, and  Shopping Centers, Office complexes. liquor stores  Shopping centers.  Loockerman street  Shopping plazas or industrial parks  Mall  Should be kept along the main strip and out of residential  Malls/strip malls neighborhoods where there might be stores.  Malls, pretty much anywhere.  Similar to liquor stores  Manage, permit and license like you do for liquor stores.  Somewhere off the main roads. Set up shop in remote,  Marijuana is a plant not a crime! Promoting access to safely unpopulated, low traffic and volume areas produced marijuana reduces the risk of use and harm associated  South Dover in the mostly unused shopping center across from with purchasing from illegal vendors. This is also a very profitable the Blue Hen mall that houses the gym and Dollar Tree industry that should be accessible to all.  stand alone stores, strip malls, etc.  Marijuana retail stores should be allowed in any commercial  Strip mall/pad sites district in the city.  Strip malls/plaza like the smoke shops.  Marijuana retailers should be treated differently than liquor stores and cigarette stores. They are legal products for adults and 13

Página 44

Item #3.  The building south of South street on RT 13 that is on the split  Yes – Anywhere but near high schools before the car sales lot is always empty as well as the old diner  Yes – Rural next to hibachi  Other – Outside of designated Gov’s council target block  The mall neighborhoods that are suppose to restore peaceful, traditional  The outlying edges of north and south dover. life.  The stores should be allowed anywhere any other stores are  Yes – Malls allowed.  Yes – walker square  There are quite a few little shopping centers/strip malls along  Yes – Any place other than downtown route 8 and route 10.  Other – Unknown  They are a legitimate business, they should be allowed anywhere  Other – Anywhere that is safe any others are.  Yes – Dover Downs/Dover Mall  They should be allowed anywhere a liquor store is allowed to be  Yes – on the outskirts of the city  Unsure of area  Other – Limited  Walker Rd  Other – Industrial Park  west dover area  Other – just not in the city  West Dover  Yes – Anywhere not close to schools or daycares  West Dover, RT 8.  RT. 8 West Dover  West side of dover off rt 8. Near or in the dover mall, lot near the  Regulated same as alcohol stores old L& D parts store  Yes – Other major road corridors example RT 8 & RT 10  Where ever liquor stores are allowed  Selected business parks  Wherever  The old KFC & A&W on RT 8  Wherever liquor stores are allowed.  Eastside  Wherever makes sense. Marijuana should be treated the same as  Outside city limits alcohol.  Other commercial locations  Wherever there's a tobacco store.  Dover mall, 1 or 2 shops  Wherever tobacco is allowed  Anywhere zoned ok  Wherever you can have liquor stores, have marijuana stores.  Anywhere zoning will allow  White oak  Any location is ok  Why not regulate it as you do for retail sales of alcohol?  Any legal place  With medical marijuana store near hospital  City Perimeter  Woodside and cheswold  Everywhere in Dover  Yes  No limits  Yes – Males  Uncertain  Yes – Wherever  It will lead to other drug use  Yes – Rt 13  No  Yes – Strip mall store fronts  Blue Hen Corporate Center  Yes – near police station  Rt 13 & Alt 113  Other – Dover Mall & Shopping centers  West Dover, South Dover  Yes – Not near school  Strip Malls  Yes – All  Any business should be allowed as long as they follow laws.  Yes – Where possible!  All business areas should be allowed to obtain a license.  Yes – Any  Yes – Wherever they feel like it

14

Página 45

Item #3. “Other” responses to Question 14: What concerns do you have about allowing marijuana related facilities in the City of Dover?  Accidents  Health impact, DWIs second hand smoke  Affects Health problems and unsafe environment.  Heath hazards potentially related to all manufacturing  Alcohol have the same affects. Ban that too  Heath impact on the people.  Allowing drivers to drive under the influence. Drivers around them  I despise the fact that if I am driving or walking and am near have to be exposed to this as well. someone smoking or vaping, I become the second hand receiver  Already smell it where ever I go. Clean Dover up with the trash of the smell and smoke exhaust. being thrown on the ground. Dover should be ashamed of there  I do not have a concern about the impact on it surrounding areas. self letting Dover look like it does. Start informing these people  I do not have concerns. Council members need to visit facilities littering or put up cameras to start fining them. in other states to see what they are like. They are not at all what  Already the smell of Marijuana is overwhelming in Dover. In your some make them out to be. car, grocery store, retail store, fitness facilities, schools, you can't  I Don’t have any concerns. escape it. Intoxicated in public and while driving. This will only  I don’t have any concerns. I think it will make the state a lot of make matters worse. money  Always concerned about crime not necessarily related to  I don't have any concerns as long as it is located in the proper marijuana . place. I'm assuming you can't use the product in the property.  Any new business can bring traffic etc It is ridiculous to think  I feel this is a great step in improving the economy of Dover! everyone will not drive a mile outside of Dover to get it and bring it  I have literally no concerns. Bars already do all the above with home. Not allowing it here isn't going to keep it from being here, it the exclusion of "increased crime". is legal.  I have multiple examples of people in my own life who started  Attracts a population that is not conducive to support those with marijuana and moved on to harder drugs, even when used businesses that advocate the history and tourism of the capital. medicinally because the felt benefit diminishes over time and  Bad idea supporting any Marijuana related activities in or around something stronger is required to achieve the same baseline. the city. Marijuana is a proven health concern and addictive  I have no concerned considering the way the laws wrote it should substance. be handle like alcohol sales .  Black business owners seeking to get into the marijuana  I have no concerns. If you understand how the businesses run business will be shutout and excluded because the current you will understand how many of these worries are not realistic & medical marijuana facilities will have a monopoly on the industry. are based in fear. They’re being allowed to supply retailers before new distributors.  I have no concerns. The city will improve economically and it will  Cannot think of anything bring in more tax revenue  Crashes, bad behavior  I have none at all  Crazy impaired drivers  I have zero concerns.  crime  I imagine it would be similar to having a liquor store in an area.  Decrease in the quality and standards of our living environment  I live right outside of Dover on Cheswold. This will affect us all  developmental status of impaired/handicapped negatively. Do not bring a marijuana facility to Dover.  Distracted driving, DWI, bad attitudes and panhandling  I suggest that the Council take the time to read Alex Berenson's  Don't want Dover to become a Kensington, Philadelphia disaster. book entitled  Dover already smells half the time and there are too many damn  I think it would be beneficial, decreased crime, if people can buy pan handlers Marijuana legally, no need for weed dealers. Less chance of it  Dover will not be seen as family-friendly. being laced with other drugs.  Driving impairment in City of Dover  I think this will be an issue with the older residents. In other  Driving safety States where it’s been legalized, the economy has been boosted  Driving under the influence! Same as alcohol and drugs! Yet I and crime has decreased. Lawful access to marijuana could also smell it from lots of cars. I had one rear end my work vehicle and dampen the opioid crisis we all see in downtown Dover. the police did nothing!!!!  I would not care  DUI  I’m concerned that it hasn’t been allowed sooner  DUIS.  If they are not permitted, illicit market sales will flourish.  Everything and anything about it. We have little children and  If treated to the same standards as alcohol and tobacco sales don’t want them expose to these paraphernalia. Please do not there should be no impact to our youth. None of these should pass this bill as this is detrimental to the betterment of our really be an issue if handled properly. societies and will have a negative overall impact.  I'm concerned about a boom-and-bust cycle that is expected for  Gateway drug leading to other drug issues any state launching a new marijuana market. Dover is struggling  Gateway drugs. to improve its downtown. Opening marijuana stores will not  general degradation of society. Number of folks using it will likely enhance the appearance or safety of our historic Capital city. increase. Impact on teens is inevitable. Comparing marijuana's  I'm more worried about how licenses will be handled, will benefits as compared to alcohol is like comparing a small sin to a business get more help than people. Our state has a track record larger one. That said, its use is ubiquitous.

15

Página 46

Item #3. for businesses, our people should prop up and own most of the  Marijuana is now a legal product in Delaware. There should be businesses. no additional restrictions on a legal product. Existing ordinances  impact on health, well-being and quality of life for all Dover protect against noise, pollution, etc. residents, especially children  Missing out on economic value of excluding marijuana sales and  Impact on health. We know that second smoke is a health risk. production for our City We also know that marijuana carries health concerns. We have  Mo concerns regulated cigarettes because of the effects of second hand  More availability to purchase marijuana will mean more residents smoke. The same should apply to marijuana. using marijuana which I believe will result in increased traffic  Impact on small businesses in the area. accidents due to impairment and crime.  Improper use around children, while operating motor vehicles,  More Homeless performing work with risks of injury to third parties. Lack of regard  More homelessness while using in public spaces is already a problem, encouraging  More traffic accidents use through increased access is not going to help.  motor vehicle accidents due to intoxication  Increase in criminal activity  Multiple Health issues for recreational users  Increase in homeless and additional drug use  My biggest concerns are health and environmental impacts that  Increased impact on State and Federal needs based programs. any manufacturing and industry bring into an area.  Increased Loitering  My concern is that if weed is legalized they won't legalize Delta 9  Increased police presence and It would still be set at 0.3% but it should be a lot higher so  Individual sobriety which impacts ethical and timely decision they get all of the benefits I use it for medical purposes but Delta making for self and others 9. % should be 29% or higher  Individuals under the influence on streets and sidewalks.  My husband and I have personally had negative health impacts Increased drug use. from "second-hand" marijuana smoke in our building. Additionally,  It impairs the ability to drive safely. I live on a 4 way stop corner. opening the door for one such drug just increases the likelihood Someone ran the stop sign and slammed into the back of a that other worse ones will follow. This is very dangerous. properly parked SUV.  N/A  It will make a negative impact on quality of life and the  N/A community’s atmosphere  n/a  It will most likely increase the illegal use of other harmful drugs.  N/A  It will not have an negative impact  N/A  It’s a gateway drug to narcotics, ATS, synthetic, etc.  N/A the criminalization of marijuana, a safe plant to ingest, has a  It’s just a gateway to increase the already massive drug and more significant negative impact on the community, especially crime related issues in the city. How about getting a handle on all marginalized identifies within the community, than recreational the pan handling, and crime, and cleaning up this Capital city? legalization, sales, and manufacturing.  It's a gateway drug.  Need to make sure youth and anything marijuana related are  I've personally lived in a town that allowed marijuana sales and truly separated. Think the retail stores should have similar laws to there were much more traffic accidents due to people smoking in liquor stores and the license application process. their cars and driving impaired because of marijuana. It's  Negative effects on our community dangerous plain and simple!  Negatively effecting the character of downtown Dover that many  Lack of adequate parking. are working to build up. Impact on other non-drug related  Leads to harder drugs and outside gangs crime. businesses of having a proliferation of drug related businesses  Like cigarettes, I think Marijuana products should be heavily downtown. taxed. This would provide more tax revenue and put the price  Negatively effects family values point above what the majority of minors could afford from third  No parties.  No  Loitering and homeless  No  Lost our values as a human being.  no  Making people lazy and having their senses not all there by being  No concern in a fog from smoking weed. But I know it’s all about the money  No concern being made from this. Politicians care less about the everyday  No concerns people who live among the crime, drugs, homelessness  No concerns  Marijuana is a gateway drug that leads to usage of other drugs,  No concerns such as cocaine, methamphetamine, fentanyl, and others. This  No concerns will also lead to greatly increased healthcare costs and fewer  No concerns healthcare resources available for other medical needs.  No concerns  Marijuana is a mind altering drug which will bring nothing good to  No concerns our city. Homelessness and poverty will increase along with a  No concerns lower standard of living both financially and morally. Please do  no concerns not allow this.  No concerns at all you should be more vested in getting heroin Flacca 16

Página 47

Item #3.  No concerns it should be no different than liquor stores  none  No concerns what so ever. Have the powers that be visit  NONE Maryland, Nevada, New York or New Jersey. Dover currently has  None Medical Marijuana facilities and no one really pays any attention  None to them. Dover is making a big deal about nothing.  None  No concerns! It would make Delaware a lot of money! We could  None build a local solar powered /wind powered train in Delaware with  None the money it brings to the state ! Marijuana is a healing herb  none please treat it like one !  none  No concerns  None  No more than the ones created my alcohol related facilities  None  No negative impacts…  None  No problems. It's neither a dangerous product nor process. If  None alcohol is ok, cannabis should be even more acceptable.  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  NONE  none  None  None  None  None  None  NONE  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  None  none  None  None  None  None  None  none  None  None  None hopping it helps crime lower  None  None I think it would do good for the city if placed in the right  None spots.  none  None if they are properly controlled.  None  None it’s legal and should be available. Taxes from it could go to  None our schools.  None  none of the above  None  None of the above  none  None of the above. We have multiple liquor stores, bars &  none breweries & we know cannabis is safer than alcohol.  None  None of them  None  None of these options are a concern to me  none  None!  None  None! Alcohol is way worse.  None  NONE! It'd be nice if we could have retail stores in place during  None my lifetime, especially since it's LEGAL.  None  None, it's happening all over now... Pot heads are mellow, low  None crime alcohol have potential to be mean and reckless  None  None, just like alcohol, you have to be of legal age to purchase.  None  None.  None  None.  none  None.  None  None.  None  none. alcohol is worse.

17

Página 48

Item #3.  NONE. Everyone has been smoking weed before recreational -  The city is already facing significant issues around this will just help limit the black market. Marijuana is a beautiful homelessness, drug abuse and an increase in prostitution. Petty plant that helps many alignments so limiting resources to medical crime, theft and issues around trash are at a too high of a level. patients & ppl that cant afford a card is cruel.  The city loosing HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of money they  None. I hope the people making this decision will visit retail sites are passing up because of this survey. in other communities to understand that a dispensary is really no  The city needs to fix other major issues before even looking at different than a liquor store or pharmacy this  None. Let people do what they want as long as they are not  The City of Dover is in chaos and you want input on where the causing harm to others. best place to manufacture drugs would be in our city? You must  None. They can help drive business, economic development, and be joking? These new laws are the reason for all the crime, the tourism. run down businesses and boarded up homes.  None. This is a very biased survey. The only choices you’re  The City's downtown is already almost unlivable and impossible suggesting here are either no restrictions at all, or heavy to do business in. Drug peddling, prostitution and vagrancy have restrictions or outright banning it. For once, City of Dover, do the quickly increased. Establishing centers that attract legal users will right thing and stop standing in the way of progress. destroy shopping, family and tourist activities.  Not being able to identify and enforce D.U.I. Issues in regard to  The facility staff kept safe during business hours and facility kept Marijuana intoxication. safe after business hours  Nothing  There isn't any concerns  Nothing  There should be no foundation upon which allowing these  nothing operations to exist in Dover. Just like alcohol, it's risks of  Nothing impairment is high and likely to impact the safety of motorists and  Nothing at all pedestrians alike.  Nothing it’s a plant  There will be an increase in trafficking  Nothing only positive will come from this  There would be less zombies walking around  Nothing really  This is a bogus question. There is no evidence that this is so.  Nothing, i think small crimes would go down with people 21+  This is bad all the way around allowed to enjoy bud in the safety of their own home and think  This proposal in no way would assist the multi million dollar about all that school money you can use with all the weed revitalization efforts! The odor alone would be so off putting (just income. drive down State college road with your windows down!) Other  Once again it should be treated the same as alcohol. than obvious $ gains,, I see NO benefit for Dover!  Only benefit  This question seems inappropriate as the state of Delaware has  Only concern is we will need more facilities. And not just Dover. approved the sale. Most people grow it in their basements and  Over- population of marijuana businesses excluding other types gummies are more preferable. of businesses. A smoke shop every other store front is off putting  This should have never been passed in the first place. Do you  Parking congestion and also congestion of crowds may be want someone high on MJ on the highway with you? Teaching or unsafe do to increase of foot traffic it may bring. To keep foot daycare-tending your children? traffic moving along safely we need more sidewalks for around  This will flip the city of Dover upside down. There is already so and leading up to retail areas. much crime. Please do not bring any marijuana facilities to Dover.  Promoting drug use  Too available to youth  Regulations on crops, size, transportation between states,  Totally against use of marijuana. Would open a can of worms. trafficking, security at these facilities.  Traffic issues -- accidents. Accessibility by substance addicts.  Shirt and long term health consequences. Encouraging drug use  Travel and tourism will be adversely affected. will not end well in many ways. This is not pleasing to God and  Violence and increased black market products will destroy the mind, body, and spirit of the user  Violent crimes will increase  Slippery slope, opens us up to further crime activities, organized  We are already dealing with a drug addiction surge, if this isn’t or otherwise. How about the lynching just outside of town last adding any financial gain to the City, we do not need to carry the week, cartel, drug dealing related. Wake the hell up. This should expenses that having this added activities will bring not even be under consideration.  We are having a drug addiction problem as it is so adding drugs  Spiritual and moral weakening of our population in light of to an already problematic situation is ludicrous. We already have security challenges from without and within our country state city serious crime so lets not add more folks with skewed judgement.  stagnation of humans desire to be motivated to grow in jobs, Our youth should not have yet another free choice to drg knowledge, and community.  We need to revitalize downtown. More retail can be one way to  Stop trying to act like it’s going be any worse than the liquor and do it. cigarette stores that are on every street corner.  Route 13 is already loaded with vape stores. Please, no more.  That there won't be enough of them and concerned the  Whether some of the revenue will go back to communities government won't put the money back into the community to help  Worried there won't be enough of them the people  You have no parking now let alone when you sell Marijuana. If you want sell smoking pieces there fine. But your going to have a line to check IDs. Having a open door policy is not going to work.

18

Página 49

Item #3.  Other – None  DUI  Other – Decrease crime  Other – Will lead to more drug use and vagrancy issues for  Other – None business and police.  Other – No type DUI safeguards or regs in place  Just moved from MD to DE none for the above even remotely  Other – increase behavioral health demands on limited facilities happened. Just very large tax revenues.  Other – gateway to other drugs, fentanyl, etc. I love all of my  Health Impact brothers and sisters  It is addictive  Other – groups of people hanging out  Other – Unforeseen issues in regulated policies  Other – Intrastate crime and interstate crime  Stupidity!  Other – gateway drug  Deaths  Other – drug dealers increase  Other – Cause mental health issue  Other – Do we have enough water & electric. Zoning impact and  Contact wanting money to purchase week growth  None. I live less than a mile from a retail store and have seen  Other – precursor to addiction – impacts brain cells especially in zero impact besides increase of traffic. adolescents  No concerns  Other – We have enough people hanging downtown  N/A  Other – None!  Quality of people  Other – Addicts  None  Other – Traffic accidents due to impaired drivers  Impaired driving  Other – Increase water usage  Dangerous drivers. Too many ignore stop signs and red lights.  All of the above We have too many drug and alcohol addicts driving now.  Other - impaired drivers  Health  Other – Addicts come into Dover  N/A  Car Base  Control  Other – Parking  Attracts wrong element  Other – Negative impact on our law enforcement officers and  Trash citizens  Driving under influence  Other – causes addiction to the use of it and other drugs  Panhandlers  Other – Schizophrenia put weeds living on my property  Need odor control  Other – People with respiratory problems  None  Other – I see no reason that this is a good idea.  Increase in intoxicated customers in my place of business  Other – Increase of drug addicts migrating into the city and  Increased need for police management surrounding areas  Not important  Other – Acceleration drug use  Not important  Other – Where will the money go?  Increased traffic and possibly introduction to area of other drugs &  Other – Looks Trashy paraphernalia.  Other – Crime  None exist    Other – Totally against legal marijuana for recreational use.  People high and driving  Other – since dispensaries are necessarily a cash only business,  No weed there are a lot of robberies  Will only have good benefits  Other – Potential for “Stoner” culture to grow  No Drugs  Other – Impaired driving risk due to increase use  Do you want your children to stand at night on the street buying  Other – Not at all and/or smoking 1 &2? No  Other – Quality of life  Gateway Drug  Impact on youth – Marijuana use in children (10-12) and teens in  All nuts if you do dover is already out of control. My kids go to Dover High School,  Fear and it is used heavily daily by probably the majority of students. A  Impaired activity, Driving, Walking and Common sense large reason for all of the behavior issues at Dover High School. If  Operating cars/equipment under the influence it is easier to get this will be worse.  None, kids get much more dangerous, legal are resale it.  Odor – Also the smell when driving around town & on RT 13 is  People driving while high, promotes lazy lifestyle. awful – guaranteed people are smoking and driving. My kids are  mental problems, homelessness about to be driving on their own so it is a major concern for us that  illegal at federal level. they will drive high or encounter others who are.  old post office location.

19

Página 50

Item #3. “Other” responses to Question 15: What potential benefits do you see in allowing marijuana related facilities in the City of Dover?  Marijuana related facilities will benefit recovering addicts. Science  Decreased criminalization of non-dangerous substances, better has shown that individuals addicted to hard drugs have used personal freedom to control and treat ailments and mental health, marijuana to combat withdrawals and associated side effects. as well as increased revenue and removing the necessity of  A decrease in racialized policing in which non-white individuals having people selling it illegally. can no longer be falsely targeted related to "marijuana crimes."  Definite revenue booster to offset City and County Property The "War on Drugs" was an effort to increase racialized policing Taxes.... and needs to be repaired, starting with industry access  Don't see a benefit to ends justifying the means.  Absolutely no benefit at all  Dover can't even control the crime, speeding and homelessness  Absolutely NO benefits whatsoever that you currently have. Allowing this in Dover is an issue to  ABSOLUTELY NO POTENTIAL BENEFITS AT ALL!!! monitor & something that you will never be able to put back in  Absolutely none! Pandora's box. The "personal use" odor is horrible in Dover  ABSOLUTELY NONE!!!!  Dover needs to address other issues first such as crime, drugs,  Absolutely none. prostitution, and homeless. Just drive downtown and open your  Access for those who need it for rehab or medical needs. eyes.  Access to alternative medicines for those who qualify.  Dover was listed as the 5th most dangerous city in Delaware.  Accessibility to the public  Downtown Dover needs to be marijuana free. The people that  All of the above come and purchase are likely those with the finds to purchase,  All of the above. Let people do what they want as long as they however, are unlikely to spend time supporting local businesses. are not causing harm to others. Congestion for this purpose makes little sense.  All short term benefits for long term decline.  Extra economic revenue can open opportunities for or creating  Assisting in the breaking of out dated and unfair stigma and funding for reforming capital School District. Reading levels are stereotypes placed against cannabis consumers embarrassingly low as a whole and we have little resources to support students one on one.  Beneficial  Finally, decriminalization for the possession of marijuana.  Better access for eligible residents. Fairness matters!  Better medically graded product accessible to those who need it  Find another way!  Better quality of life!  For some people help with mental health issues  Better than alcohol  Freedom  can enhance public health by ensuring safe access to cannabis,  Freedom to medicate the way you want reduce illicit market activity, attract tourism, create community programs funded by cannabis revenue, and promote social equity  Generally relaxed and friendlier demeanor. through inclusive business opportunities.  Gives people access to safe marijuana so they don’t have to buy  Cheaper prices for medical Marijuana if we increase supply off the street  collect a sales tax  Go visit San Francisco and ask the residents there how things are going.  Contribution to taxes  Grants given to local business owners from minority groups that  Creating a legitimate market for a product that people will use were unfairly and overly policed for marijuana related crimes regardless allows for users to source that product from a would be a step towards transformative justice. These shops reputable business as opposed to taking chances with laced or should not have large scale corporate ownership if possible. incorrectly cured flower.  Happiness  Crime and criminal activity will increase. Our communities would run down quickly. The city is too small for all of this activity.  Happy & Healthy citizens!!!  Crime Decrease  Healthier citizens and lower healthcare costs  Death Growth. Undergraduate students, more sexual assault and  Help keep the money in our country and keep organized crime more delinquent, etc. families  Decrease in crime (perhaps) because it would be legally  Help people with anxiety, food disorders and medicinal purposes accessible like cancer patients  Decrease in taxes due to increased revenue from marijuana and  Help the city & state get out of debt like the state of Colorado did. more support for community with this revenue  Hey, it's Michael. Ohio is nice, but it's wild that since I've moved  Decrease of opioid use. here they've legalized marijuana and are going to beat Delaware to retail, given the head start we had. I think it's a great idea for  Decreased crime Dover, especially downtown. Wishing you the best  Decreased Crime  I believe Marijuana retail stores should require a membership for  Decreased crime due to more availability, decreased citizens in customers to shop there. Membership fees could help maintain jail for marijuana, increased awareness of benefits of marijuana / the facility and security. Also, membership allows stores to a shift in public perception about marijuana / decreased stigma enforce a code of conduct from members, may help with behavior surrounding marijuana  I do NOT believe there will be any benefits  Decreased crime.

20

Página 51

Item #3.  I do not see any benefit having anything marijuana related in the  It will better the city as a whole ! Dover doesn’t have much to City of Dover. Other cities that have allowed it, regret it. We are offer as it is now , malls are closed or empty Festivals were taken working so hard to make Dover a true capital city. We do not away. All events in town, profit doesn’t go to benefit of the city. need marijuana in any fashion being part of that. Dover needs some type of revenue.  I do not see any benefits to allowing marijuana facilities within the  It will send more cars into the junk yard or to a repair place city of Dover or the greater Dover area. Marijuana is a mind- increasing their businesses profits. altering drug, and will not have positive effects in the community.  It’s important marijuana is controlled because of fentanyl in street  I do not see any benefits whatsoever to the city in allowing drugs. To protect the public the government needs to assure that Marijuana related facilities to be established. the marijuana is pure just like any other pharmaceutical.  I do not support marijuana facilities  It's all positive  I don’t know  I've been wanting Dover Delaware to open your doors to the  I don't live in Dover, but I work in Dover. There wasn't an option future though marijuana for example I don't like drinking but I wish for me to put that so I am putting it here. they would be another option like smoking marijuana and options  I don't see any benefits allowing marijuana sale in city of Dover. from California growers  I don't see any benefits.  Keeping the $$$ that Delawareans spend on cannabis here in  I don't see any economic benefits outweighing the increased use Delaware - and believe me, they do instead of sending it to of marijuana, increased crime, attraction of lower class to the Maryland and NJ area, and the ultimate negative impact on our youth. There isn't a  Leave people alone and let em smoke. They’ll be nicer. trade-off.  Less Black men getting arrested for non violent crimes  I don't support any marijuana activities in Dover  Less crime  I really don’t see an overall benefit. Yes there will be job creation,  Less crime (a safe access point) increased licensing revenue and economic growth from the new  Less crimes related to Marijuana industry but the costs to society outweigh any economic benefit.  Less dependency on pharmaceutical companies.  I SEE A NO BENEFITS IN ALLOWING MARIJUAHA  Less to buy off streets ANYWHERE. OUR SON WAS ADDITCTED WHEN HE WAS  Let police focus on more serious crime. Marijuana use is NOT a ABOUT SEVENTEEN AND IT LED TO ANOTHER ADDICTION, positive for society but its use shouldn't be criminalized any more OFF THE STREET PAIN PILLS. THIS IS NOTHING MORE so than alcohol use. THAN GREED AND THE LOVE OF MONEY WHICH IS THE  Marijuana is a stepping stone for worse drugs. However, I do ROOT OF ALL EVIL. think people in severe pain or cancer should be able to use this  I see no benefit drug.  I see no benefit at all. If this decision goes ahead it will destroy  More peaceful our youth. Also increase motor vehicle accidents. Please say no!!!  Na  I see NO BENEFIT of any kind in promoting drug use.  Na  I see no benefits at all.  No benefit  I see none but a further downgrading if the city.  No benefit  I see that there is benefits in marijuana business but only if you  No benefit don't need a medical card especially if we allow Delta 9  no benefit percentage to be higher like 29% or higher but They will be less  No benefit at all. The sale and production of marijuana should be weed related crime Plus we allow alcohol that kills people illegal.  I see ZERO benefit to allowing marijuana-related facilities in the  No benefit at all. I would hope people would move out of Dover City of Dover. We are already the armpit of the State! Sussex and leave it to the ones who want drugs and homeless people county is growing as is the Middletown area while Dover making Dover a haven for crime and all kinds of ungodliness. It continues to deteriorate. Say NO to allowing this in our city! amazes me that I am even filling this out about allowing this.  If were to have a limited amount of retail stores, we could reap  No benefit to the City of Dover. This will only harm our youth and benefits of potential tax revenues. 13 corridor would present a minority communities. We have seen this throughout our country. negative image for city, most areas would be in close proximity of Please do not make a deal with the devil for money. It never residential/school/hospital/daycares. Limited Venues works.  Income from marijuana. People buy it anyway, so at least the city  No benefit! Do the research on long-term impact in CO/etc not can collect additional revenue & taxes. Plus it will regulate how just quick tax revenue. people buy it instead of buying it illegally on the street.  No benefit! It is failing in other states/cities. Do the research on  Increase in visitors, for purposes of making purchases will trickle long-term usage not just quick tax revenue. down to other stores in the area. EC growth  No Benefit!!!  Increased agricultural growth  no benefit.  Increased foot traffic in downtown Dover to support other  No benefit. businesses and justify the parking garage the city is building.  No benefit.  Increased job security for specific agencies  No benefits  It will be a lot of problems here in Dover, too many Crimes an  No benefits Killing here for an Family, I’m surely against the Marijuana being  No benefits here in Dover, DE  No benefits

21

Página 52

Item #3.

No benefitsNone
No benefits to the City by allowing marijuana related facilities.None
No benefits, it should not be allowed, and if it is approved I’mnone
sure it will be located in the minority areas!None
No benefits, only downsideNone
No benefits.None
No benefits. Dover already has enough issues with drug abuseNone
and attracting young families. Place looks like shit, smells likeNone
skunk, etc.None
No benefits. The city already has a drug and gang problemNone
No one has stopped using marijuana since I was in college in theNone
sixties. Why is city making a mountain out of a mole hill? ItNone
should be regulated like normal products like alcohol, cigarettes,None
and the like.NONE
No positive benefits.None
NO potential benefits, only negative consequencesnone
Nonenone
NoneNone-
NoneNone The shorter term $$$$ is so not worth it! Price too high
Nonefor current and future Dover residents!
NONENone NO BENEFITS what so ever
NoneNone above
NoneNone at all. Brings nothing but trouble to city & towns.
NONENone crime will rise
NoneNone more trouble and crime and trash and accidents
NoneNone of the above
NoneNone of the above!
NONENone see enclosed responses!
NoneNone that make it worth wile for the burden that will come as a
Noneresult of allowing it.
NONENone this is a gate way drug. And drug dealers will have to make
Nonetheir Marijuana more potent by mixing other drugs with it to keep
Nonethere users. The state is now a drug dealer, and you want the city
Noneto be a dealer. The whole population at risk
NoneNone whatsoever
NoneNone!
NoneNONE!
NoneNONE!
NoneNone!
NoneNone!
NoneNone! I expect the health care costs to exceed the benefits.
NoneNone! It should be illegal! It is a gateway drug!
NoneNone! People under the influence of any substance is so easy to
Nonecontrol! Lack of judgement and increased social issues. Marijuana
 None is just the first step towards a life of addiction. If it is not allowed to
NONEsmoke regular cigarettes, how come this is?
NoneNone! Robin - fire that idiot police Commissioner and get
nonesomeone who's serious about combating crime. You allow this,
Nonethe door is open for further infiltration, penetration of the cartels,
Nonestreet gangs. Clean this city up or leave office.
NoneNone!
NoneNone, as stated above.
noneNONE, Just a huge Liability
NONENone, opening up the use of marijuana very dangerous. What
Nonedrug would be next.
NoneNone.
NoneNone.
NoneNONE. I SEE THE DESTRUCTION OF OUR WAY OF LIFE.

22

Página 53

Item #3.  None. It’s sad you can’t go anywhere anymore with people  Safer options for pain management. driving and smoking just because it’s legal. Unless we are policing  Social areas our people this is not the way to go.  Social equity in existing industry  None. Marijuana is still a federally controlled substance. Drugs  Some kind of control. If you decide to ban these facilities they are drugs. Ban guns and constitutional rights but allow legal sale will end up right at the city line where you have no control and will of weed to make a buck... see none of the benefits listed above. It’s legal now. Nothing  None. There are no benefits only problems. council does will change that fact.  None. Zero. It will only bring down our state’s capital  Stoned morons will not need to drive to locations elsewhere in  NONE. DONT SMOKE! the county.  None. I am originally from Delaware and have worked as a social  Tax revenue worker for many years. I currently work in Dover. Increased drug  Tax revenue increase. use always has a negative effect on children and results in more  THC has been used for addiction treatment and has been proven crime. Please keep these facilities out of Dover. to be successful. An ME once told me THC does not hold the  None. I have seen how marijuana has impacted youth and young same mode of addiction as heroin does (it’s psychological, not adults. It began as occasional use, then more regular use, finally physical). This will improve the community all around. leading to narcotics.  The benefits do not out way the damage it will do to the city  None. Increase Crime, decrease property values, and destroy  The city can collect sales tax lives.  The downtown is already not very friendly for the public, so any  None. It will only cause more problems and attract stoners to our other business that is questionable is not a good idea. city. Who will take responsibility for the increase in DUIs? And an  The government should not be allowed to assign licenses for any increase in traffic fatalities? legal activity. Making a license for a right is abhorrent to the  None. Whoever is in office during the allowance of such constitution, any government entities that do so should be establishments I will be sure to rally to vote out next election immediately terminated.  Not a benefit  The number one benefit in my opinion is medicinal related  not a benefit without the use of medical cards that hinder people from certain  Not a dam thing things  Nothing  The only benefit would be profit, but it's not worth the damage  Nothing ! done.  Nothing good can or will come from recreational Marijuana  The top dogs get rich and the under privileged are offered yet legalization. another substance to create an issue that could be life changing  Nothing good will become of this. and hinder the growth of a successful determination to better  nothing positive can benefit from this themselves. Please don’t do this. Please.  one of the many potential benefits of uplifting marijuana related  There are no benefits businesses is the dissolution of the local stigma against medical  There are no benefits and recreational users.  There are no benefits  Only benefit will be to the city for the revenue not worrying about  There are no benefits other than increasing crime, violence and public safety and teen age exposure mental health issues.  Only plant for creating jobs; but not having stores around  There are NO potential benefits to having marijuana facilities  Out compete the illicit market, and thereby decrease related anywhere in Delaware. We already have gang/crime issues with crime ; increase property value; etc. limited police protection. All this does is bring more of the shady  Perhaps an end to the fear mongering we’ve lived with all of my characters from New York and PA to Delaware. life?  There are none.  Possible health benefits for those that weren't able to access it  There is no benefit before.  There is no benefit  Put the street dealers out of business, and maybe fewer people  There is no benefit refer back to question 14 will drink alcohol.  There is no benefit to the citizens of Dover  Recreational marijuana should be taxed same as tobacco  There is no benefits products. It will cause as many health issues as regular smoking.  There is no benefits. I fully disagree and reject any and all Plus law enforcement needs to be able to pull cars over from the marijuana usage. smell of pot. Smoking pot/drinking driving should be treat same.  there might be economic and financial benefits in the short term  Reduce illegal black market that is thriving today. but in my view, having marijuana products, facilities etc in the city,  Reduced crime though legal is a bad idea in the long term in my view.  Reduction in crime and violence, increased property values,  There should be no potential benefit for marijuana facilities in the fewer empty storefronts downtown, reduced opioid consumption City of Dover. and reductions in overdose deaths. Life and vitality to the city.  There would be no good benefit, only increased problems. City is more attractive to Millennials and Gen-Zers. Please do not let this destroy our great little city.  Regulated controls  Tourist Dollars  Safer communities, reduced access by minors, reducing the illicit  We don't need any of this within the City limits. market, safer products, less burden on law enforcement.

23

Página 54

Item #3.  What is the difference between liquor stores everywhere? As an  Other – Hopefully it would prevent users from buying from dealers employee in downtown dover, I am in support of retail marijuana & getting marijuana “laced” with something stronger (Fentanyl) for stores. Other drugs and alcohol are the problem down here. example.  WHEN SHOPPING IN STORES I DO NOT LIKE THE SMELL OF  Other - Zero Benefits THOSE USING MARIJUANA  Other – None  Will begin to stop the stigma against the use of the plant.  Other – Crime Hopefully, people will hear about all the medical properties it has.  Other – Neg. Social Impact  Zero benefits  Other - There are no benefits that will offset the negatives  Zero benefits. All this will do is make more people sell it illegally.  Other – Fewer street dealers. You don’t know the quality/safety of  Other – None street weed.  Other – I do not see any potential benefits but medical marijuana  Other – The city needs to oversee these retail stores and all other for patients with terminal conditions aspects of legalizing marijuana.  Other – Less alcohol consumption  Other – Just as liquor needs moderation so does this.  None of the above! (No benefits)  Other – and for health reasons that are not terminal like sleeping  Other – Do not see any benefits  Other – none of the above. While working I have witnessed poor  Other – I don’t think it is good around for the city and in residential job performance, bad forces. Keep marijuana out of Dover, City or the economics. has enough problems, crime as it is & a bad reputation for crime.  Other – decreasing putting people in jail for possession of drugs Devils workshop. Be cautious! or smoking it.  Other – no benefits/use in crime. Marijuana is a pathway for the  Other – No benefits use of more dangerous drugs.  Other – property tax increase. Bring people downtown to spend  Other – Test have proven that marijuana inhibits one’s mind, money in all retail shops. particularly while driving a vehicle.  Other – None! These facilities should be on the agricultural areas  Better Regulation of marijuana products – The only plus is that it of Dover. Not in or close to the City of Dover! would hopefully not be laced with other worse drugs. Overall, our  Other – I am not sure children are suffering because they do not see the harm they are  Other – There are not any benefits. doing to themselves and one it is a habit, they do not have the  Other – Taxes! maturity yet to be able to stop. This is going to be a major  Other – Keep drug dealers off the street? problem as this generation goes into adulthood with substance  Other – There are no benefits issues.  Other – None on a cost/benefit basis  No Benefits!  Other – No benefit to citizens  Do not allow these facilities at all! What do not you understand  Other - Don’t see any benefit about the word NO! No marijuana at all!  Other – No Benefit  None – Do not approve of recreational marijuana use but our astute legislature made this into law.  Other - N/A  Freedom to make choices in a human right  Other – Unknown  Other – Usage of already constructed empty buildings  Other – None should be allowed   Other – Stop helping cultivate addicts  Crime – the destroying of downtown dover same as parking  Other – Making it more like alcohol regulations garage. Please note my vehicle never got fixed or pay to fix it!  Other - Zero  None whatsoever  Other – Less government involvement in our lives  None   None  Other – Employment  More medical use  Other – Lower residential homeowner’s taxes, lower property  None taxes, school/city/county tax reform for Dover residents. Share your wealth with us.  None  Other – Tourism  None, find another way to grow the economy in and around the City of Dover.  Other – There are no benefits to this drug  None that I know of.  Other – No benefits in our beloved city!  None  Other – Crime increase  None – more addicts  Other – Absolutely none!  None  Other – Marijuana that is regulated & sold is safer that what people can buy on the streets! I’d much rather have people  None buying marijuana legally in a location that is only sells marijuana  Do not see benefits – if there were some, would be offset by than supporting a drug dealer who may have other dangerous negative results. drugs.  None  Other – Crime increase  None of the above  Other – Panhandlers employment  No potential benefits  Other – I don’t see how marijuana can make a community better!  Better regulations  Safer product 24

Página 55

Item #3.  None  it has already shown how good it has been, people have already  Avoid illegal sales been good with compliance. Just let it go as is, no need to be in  Put illegal sellers out of business the middle of everything everyone does.  None  Don't see any benefits. "They" must want to see the city to go  None "downhill".  None  None – no positive benefit  This should’ve been started in the Nixon Admin instead the DEA was formed! Crazy!  Against  Absolutely against  Being able to purchase a safe product  Increase tax revenue  I don’t see any potential benefits  Reduced fentanyl and methadone use  Within the old city, none  Absolutely none. I do not support any type of drugs! Next you will want to make heroin legal! I was born and raised here it used to be a quiet place to live and raise a family now it has gone to HELL with no respect for police officers who risk their life  All the Above reasons sound good however, eventually the bad will outweigh the good.  More harm than good.  Against any drugs in City of Dover  None  Dope City  None at all than higher crimes  None, will lead to more drugs, crime and disorder  None Are you guys $$ hungry & could care less about our youth?  Culture, Quality of Life  Negative impacts make this question completely irrelevant.   safe marijuana free from other drugs mixed in that could harm users.  Marijuana is being widely used by our youth @ the HS Level. Major Issues!  Absolutely “NO” benefits marijuana anything will only further decline positive growth in Dover. Citizens of Dover are tired of seeing Dover run into the ground. Have some pride. We are supposed to be the capital of the first state Act like it! Choose better! Drugs destroy lives + families! ENOUGH!  The potential benefits don’t outweigh the cost of what having it will do the city.  Don’t be hypocrites! I never got one of these for alcohol. We voted it in, now just get out of the way!  Let’s be like Cali, stop with being dumb.  Other - Death  Never needed in my lifetime till now.  Absolutely "no" benefits marijuana anything will only further decline positive growth in Dover. Citizens of Dover are tired of seeing Dover run into the ground. Have some pride. We are supposed to be the capital of the First State. Act like it! Choose better! Drugs destroy lives and families. ENOUGH!  I have seen and smelled. No potential benefits. Kindness, goodness, patience, consideration, respect. People helping people.  What is happening to our morals? The state is taken over all the vices, etc. Is prostitution next?

25

Página 56

Item #3. Dover Marijuana Regulations Survey The City of Dover is actively engaging with its residents to gather valuable input. With the legalization of marijuana in the State of Delaware, it is important to establish a comprehensive ordinance that outlines if and where marjuana businesses will be permitted in the City. Your participation in this process is important to ensure that the regulations are fair, just, and reflective of the community’s wishes. Your input matters, and together, we can shape a better and more inclusive future for Dover.

  • 1.What is your age? 5. Do you support allowing any of the Under 21 21 - 34 35 - 44 following marijuana related uses in the City? (You can choose multiple responses) 45 - 54 55 - 64 Over 64 Indoor Product Cultivation Facility Manufacturing
  • 2.What is your gender? Retail Store Testing Facility Male Female
  • 6.Do you support allowing marijuana cultivation, Non-Binary Prefer not to answer. manufacturing, and testing facilities in Industrial and Manufacturing zones with the City of Dover?
  • 3.What Council District do you live in? Yes District 1 District 2 District 3 No District 4 I do not live in the City, but I own a business in the City. Uncertain I do not live in the City.
  • 4.Which of the following policy options do you support? Note: if prohibited, it would still be legal for adults (21+) to 7. Do you support allowing marijuana cultivation, possess marijuana within Dover City limits and use mari- manufacturing, and testing facilities in other juana on private propertty. Prohibition would NOT apply to locations within the City of Dover? If yes, please list medical marijuana facilities. possible locations. Dover should ALLOW recreational marijuana businesses within the City without any special Yes: restrictions. No Dover should ALLOW recreational marijuana businesses within the City with strong controls.
  • 8.Do you support allowing marijuana cultivation Dover should only ALLOW some recreation- facilities in Agricultural zones with the City of al marijuana businesses within the City with Dover? strong controls. Yes Dover should PROHIBIT all recreational marijuana businesses from opening within City No limits. Uncertain Other:

Página 57

Dover Marijuana Regulations Survey (Page 2)
Item #3.

  • 9.Do you support allowing retail marijuana stores 13. How important is it that there be a buffer or along the Route 13/Bay Road Corridor within the minimum distance required between marijuana City of Dover? RETAIL STORES and the following types of places? Yes No Uncertain Not at all Somewhat Very Type of Place Important Important Important
  • 10.Do you support allowing retail marijuana stores Residential in Downtown Dover? Schools Yes No Uncertain Daycares Hospitals
  • 11.Do you support allowing retail marijuana stores Parks in other locations within the City of Dover? If “yes” Rehabilitation please respond where in other section. Centers Yes No Other:
  • 14.What concerns do you have about allowing marijuana related facilities in the City of Dover?
  • 12.How important is it that there be a buffer or (You can choose multiple responses) minimum distance required between marijuana Increased Crime Traffic Congestion CULTIVATION, MANUFACTURING, and Decreased Environmental TESTING FACILITIES and the following types of property values Impact places? (Please denote with an ‘X’ under the appropriate column) Noise Odor

Not at all Somewhat Very Impact on Youth Other:
Type of Place Important Important Important
Residential
Schools 15. What potential benefits do you see in allowing
Daycares marijuana related facilities in the City of Dover?
(You can choose multiple responses)
Hospitals
Parks Economic Growth Job Creation

Rehabilitation Increased Better Regulation of Centers Licensing Revenue Marijuana Products

Other:

Mail to: Or drop off at:
• Dover Public Library
City of Dover - Marijuana • Customer Services
Survey (Weyandt Hall) Scan to complete online:
PO Box 475 • City Hall lobby
Dover, DE 19903 • John W. Pitts Rec Center.

Página 58

Item #3.

Página 59

Item #3.

Página 60

Item #3.

Página 61

Item #3.

Página 62

Item #3.

City of Dover Recreational
Marijuana Ordinances
Planning Commission Public Hearing
November 18, 2024

Página 63

Overview of Presentation Item #3.

  • •Overview of Marijuana Control Act
  • •Timeline to Date
  • •Survey Take-Aways
  • •Overview of Draft Ordinances
  • •Next Steps

Página 64

The Delaware Marijuana Control Act Item #3.

  • •Passed during the 152nd General Assembly
  • •Includes Two (2) Bills:
  • •House Bill 1 decriminalizes the purchase, possession, transportation, Personal Use Quantity: use and sharing of personal use Maximum Allowable Product quantities of marijuana for adults over Personal Use Quantity the age of 21. Leaf Marijuana 1 Ounce
  • •House Bill 2 creates a framework for a Concentrated Cannabis 12 Grams legal recreational marijuana industry; Cannabis products containing 750 Milligrams regulating and taxing recreational delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol marijuana in a similar manner to (THC) alcohol.

Página 65

House Bill 1 Item #3.

Lawful Activities Unlawful Activities • Adults aged 21 and over may share • Individuals may not sell marijuana. personal use quantities of marijuana. • Consumption of marijuana inside of a • Adults aged 21 and over may possess, moving vehicle or drive under the use, display, purchase and transport influence. personal use quantities of marijuana • Transporting marijuana over state and accessories. lines. • Adults may transport marijuana and • Consumption of marijuana in an area accessories in a vehicle if the items accessible to the public. are in a closed container, not readily accessible to anyone in the vehicle. • Individuals under 21 may not partake in these activities.

Página 66

House Bill 2 with House Amendments 1 & 2 Item #3.

  • •Adds Chapter 13 to Title 4 of the Delaware Code.
  • •Establishes the role of the Marijuana Commissioner.
  • •Responsible for establishing a licensing process as well as regulations and penalties related to the industry.
  • •Establishes procedures for the 15% marijuana tax and the Marijuana Regulation Fund.
  • •Enforced by the Division of Alcohol and Tobacco.
  • •Office of the Marijuana Commissioner is within the Department of Safety and Homeland Security.

Página 67

Effects of Legislation Item #3.

  • •A specific license is required for growing, manufacturing, testing or selling marijuana.
  • •All growing facilities must be indoors.
  • •Marijuana sales will be restricted to the same days and times as liquor sales.
  • •Retail establishments will not be allowed to sell online or offer delivery.
  • •Retail establishments cannot sell alcohol, tobacco or food.
  • •No consumption of marijuana is permitted on the premises of marijuana establishments.
  • •Private Property Rights:
  • •Employers still have freedom to manage their terms of employment, policies and discipline procedures.
  • •Those in charge of a property can still prohibit or regulate marijuana on their property.

Página 68

Rights of Municipalities Item #3.

Municipalities Cannot: Municipalities Can: • Prohibit Use: HB 1 legalizes marijuana • Prohibit the operation of marijuana use, though not in public places. establishments in their jurisdiction • Create a specific marijuana license or through local ordinance. tax, though general occupational • Regulate the time, place or manner in licenses fees and taxes imposed which marijuana establishments uniformly on everyone are not operate and establish penalties for preempted. violations. • Even if the City permits marijuana • There is a process for residents to establishments in their jurisdiction, object to the issuance of a license. there is a process for residents to object to the issuance of a license.

Página 69

9/26/2023
Item #3.
Dover City Staff briefed CCW on Marijuana Control Act (MCA)

4/29/2024, 6/11/2024, 7/9/2024
CCW discussed options for addressing MCA

Timeline to Date 7/22/2024 City Council passed moratorium • First discussed by CCW over a year ago. • Nine public meetings. 7/2/2024 – 8/31/2024 Public Survey • Public Survey • Online Responses: 1,408 8/5/2024 • Paper Survey Responses: 820 L&F Special Meeting • 2,228 Total • Moratorium in place through 12/31/2024. 8/19/2024 OMC began accepting applications

9/11/2024
Marijuana Control Act regulations went into effect

9/24/2024, 10/8/2024
CCW Continued Discussion and Took Action on 10/8/24

10/28/2024
First Reading Before City Council

Página 70

Survey Themes and Trends Item #3.

  • •Majority (58%) favor allowing • Biggest concerns (over 1000 recreational marijuana selected) are odor and increased businesses within the City. crime.
  • •Distancing support strongest for: • Biggest potential benefits of
  • •Schools interest (over 1000 selected) are
  • •Daycares economic growth, better
  • •Rehabilitation Centers regulation of marijuana products, and increased licensing revenues.

Página 71

Item #3.

Ordinance Development

Página 72

Ordinance Options Item #3.

Prohibit Permit Permit with Restrictions

The City may enact a The City may enact a If the City permits policy prohibiting all policy allowing recreational marijuana recreational marijuana recreational marijuana uses in certain zones, businesses within City businesses to open as additional restrictions limits. permitted uses within may be implemented certain zones. to regulate the time, place, or manner in which businesses operate.

Página 73

Ordinance #2024-29 Item #3.

  • •Marijuana cultivation, manufacturing and testing facilities – permitted use in Manufacturing (M) Zone and Industrial Park Manufacturing (IPM) Zone.
  • •Marijuana cultivation facilities – permitted use in Agricultural (A) Zone.
  • •Supplementary Regulations.
  • •Definitions – Compassion center, Marijuana cultivation facility, Marijuana product manufacturing facility, marijuana testing facility.

Página 74

Ordinance #2024-29 Item #3.

Supplementary Regulations • Compassion Center classified as retail use. • Marijuana cultivation and manufacturing facilities: • Building footprint at least 750 feet from residential zones, K-12 schools, hospitals, colleges and universities, child daycare centers, substance abuse disorder treatment facilities. • Odor control technology. • Openings, entries and windows must be covered. • Compliance with utility handbooks and applicant responsible for upgrade costs. • Marijuana testing facilities – 750 feet away from residential zones, K- 12 schools, hospitals, child daycare facilities, substance abuse disorder treatment facilities.

Página 75

Item #3.

Página 76

Ordinance #2024-30 Item #3.

  • •Retail marijuana stores – permitted use in Highway Commercial (C-4) Zone.
  • •Supplementary Regulations:
  • •Building footprint at least 500 feet away from K-12 schools, child daycare centers, substance abuse disorder facilities, hospitals.
  • •Building footprint at least 250 feet away from residential zones and colleges/universities.
  • •Building footprint at least one (1) mile away from other marijuana retail.
  • •Openings, entries and windows must be covered.
  • •Licensed compassion centers may obtain a conversion license without meeting distance requirements.
  • •Definitions – Adds “Retail marijuana store.” Page 76

Página 77

Item #3.

Página 78

Next Steps Item #3.

  • •11/18/2024 – Planning Commission Public Hearing.
  • •12/9/2024 – City Council Public Hearing/Final Reading.
  • •12/31/2024 – Moratorium expires.

Failure to enact an ordinance would default to underlying permitted uses.

Página 79

Item #3.

CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION

November 18, 2024
Excerpt from Meeting Minutes – Draft

The Meeting Session 2 of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Monday, November 18, 2024, at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system Webex. The Meeting Session 2 was conducted with Chair Mr. Witham presiding. Members present were Mr. Michael Lewis, Mr. Roach (virtual), Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Maucher (virtual), Mr. Baldwin, Dr. Jones, Mr. Reaves (virtual), Mrs. Welsh (virtual), and Mr. Witham.

Staff members present were Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Ms. Sharon Duca, Mrs. Kristen Mullaney, and Mr. Jason Lyon (virtual).

NEW APPLICATIONS

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations - Public Hearing and Review for Recommendation to City Council of a series of Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance for establish provisions for recreational marijuana land uses and related zoning regulations.

  • A.Ordinance #2024-29: Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning: Article 3 - District Regulations Section 19 - Manufacturing Zone (M), Section 20 - Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), and Section 23 - Agricultural Zone (A); Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations adding new Section 24 - Marijuana Related Businesses; and Article 12 - Definitions. These amendments add definitions for marijuana related businesses, allow these business types to operate as permitted uses within certain zones, and add supplementary regulations by which these businesses must abide.
  • B.Ordinance #2024-30: Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for retail marijuana stores and provisions for compassion center conversions by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning: Article 3 - District Regulations Section 16 - Highway Commercial Zone (C-4); Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations adding new Section 24 - Marijuana Related Businesses; and Article 12 – Definitions. These amendments add the definition of retail marijuana stores and allow recreational marijuana stores to operate as permitted uses in the C-4 zone and add supplementary regulations by which these businesses must abide.

Representative: Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Rossi Group and Planning Staff

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that this evening there are two Text Amendments that are here before the Planning Commission. In regards to them, the Planning Commission will be making a recommendation. That recommendation goes onto City Council as City Council has their own public hearing and action scheduled for their December 9, 2024 meeting in regards to these two Ordinances. Because they are Ordinances that amend the Zoning Ordinance, that’s why they are Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 1 of 21

Página 80

Item #3.

here in front of the Planning Commission. Ordinance #2024-29 focuses on the marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing and where those marijuana land uses would be permitted in municipal city limits of Dover. The other Ordinance #2024-30 focuses on recreational marijuana retail stores and likewise, the provisions to allow that like when and where in the City of Dover. For this effort to focus on recreational marijuana land uses and zoning provisions, the City did retain consultant services given the staffing levels over the last year in the Planning Office and she is going to allow the consultant to really give this presentation. They are much better versed in what happened and how we got to this point here. Your Planning Commission meeting packet includes a narrative report with comments from our Development Advisory Committee members, copies of each of the Ordinances, and then a number of other reference documents.

Mrs. Townshend stated that she would start by giving an overview of what we are going to be talking about. There is a lot of ground to cover. We will talk first about the Marijuana Control Act: what it does, what it allows municipalities to do, and what the City’s options are under this Act. We will talk about the timeline to date. There was a public survey that was available online. It was also mailed with utility bills and available in paper form at City buildings. We will share some of the takeaways. She knows your packet includes the detailed Survey Report. In the interest of time, we will kind of hit the major takeaways from that and then we will talk about the Draft Ordinances and the next steps.

Basically, during the 152nd General Assembly, which was in 2023, the Legislature approved two bills: House Bill 1 and House Bill 2. House Bill 1 decriminalizes personal use quantities of marijuana and then House Bill 2 creates a framework for a legal recreational marijuana industry in Delaware with regulations and taxation that is similar to how the State regulates alcohol. Under House Bill 1, adults 21 and over may share personal use quantities of marijuana; they may possess, use, display, purchase, and transport personal use quantities of marijuana. They may transport marijuana and marijuana accessories in a vehicle if the items are in a closed container, not readily accessible to anyone in the vehicle. So, you cannot use it in a vehicle. Also, under what individuals cannot do is that individuals may not sell marijuana. They may not consume marijuana inside of a moving vehicle or drive under the influence of marijuana. You cannot transport marijuana over state lines. You cannot consume marijuana in areas that are accessible to the public; so that would be streets, sidewalks, restaurants, malls or any place that is open to the public. So, it’s not just an open space but places that are open to the public. People that are under 21 cannot use recreational marijuana. House Bill 2 adds Chapter 13 to Title 4 of the Delaware Code. Basically, this establishes the role of the Marijuana Commissioner and charges the Marijuana Commissioner with establishing a licensing process and regulations and penalties for the industry. It also establishes a 15% tax for recreational marijuana and creates the Marijuana Regulation Fund. The rules under this law and under the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner are enforced by the Division of Alcohol and Tobacco. The Office of the Marijuana Commissioner is located within the Department of Safety and Homeland Security. A State issued license is required for growing, manufacturing, testing, or selling marijuana. All growing facilities must be indoors; no outdoor cultivation is allowed. Marijuana sales are restricted to the same days and times as liquor sales; so, there are certain days of the year where marijuana sales, just like liquor stores are closed, marijuana sales are not allowed on those days either. Marijuana retail establishments will not be allowed to sell online or offer delivery. They will not be able to sell alcohol, tobacco, or food. No consumption of marijuana products is permitted on the premises of any marijuana establishments and that includes all of the Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 2 of 21

Página 81

Item #3.

establishments whether it’s the cultivation facilities, the retail, the manufacturing, or the testing. Employers still have the freedom to manage the terms of employment, policies and discipline procedures; so, not all employers are required to allow employees to use marijuana. Those in charge of a property can prohibit or somehow restrict marijuana use on their properties. That would mean that a landlord for instance, could say that it’s not allowed in their building. House Bill 2 does specifically mention what municipalities can and cannot do. House Bill 1 legalizes recreational marijuana; therefore, that preempts the City’s ability to be able to say it’s not allowed in municipal limits. We are also at the municipal level, preempted from creating a special tax or fee and that has been one of the things that have come up in many municipalities. She thinks municipalities would be more receptive if they could get some revenue from it, but the State does prohibit that. It can be licensed in the same manner as other business licenses that are issued. Similar to the alcohol regulations, the public will get notice and have the opportunity to comment at the State level before a license is issued for a specific location.

So, what can we do at the municipal level? One of the options is, and many municipalities in the State of done this, municipalities can prohibit the operation of marijuana establishments in their jurisdictions. You have seen this particularly in Sussex County with the coastal towns; most of them have passed something to say all of these uses are prohibited. The other thing that municipalities can do is regulate the time, place and manner in which the establishments operate. So, what does that mean? You can set hours; you can set standards. You will see when we get into some of the things that we have put into these draft ordinances, we have distancing requirements. You can do things at the municipal level to restrict how, where, and when these uses take place. Again, through the State regulatory process, residents do have the opportunity to comment before licenses are issued for a specific location.

Looking at the timeline to date: this was first discussed by the City Council Committee of the Whole back in September 2023 and there were three specific Committee meetings this year in 2024 where the Council Committee of the Whole discussed options for how the City could deal with it. In July 2024, the City passed a Moratorium basically to provide time for the City to thoughtfully address the issue and not be put in a situation where the clock runs out and a license is issued because we don’t have anything in effect. So basically, in July, the Moratorium was put in place and that will last until the end of the year. Also in July, the City launched a public survey. They started online and then it was at a Council of the Committee of the Whole Meeting where they said they wanted to make sure that it was as widely available as possible. So, paper copies were made available at City Buildings and they were mailed with every utility bill. The Survey remained open until the end of August. On August 5, 2024, the Legislative, Finance and Administration Committee had a special meeting to talk about options and to ask questions. At that point, they knew they weren’t going to make any decisions until after the Survey was done but they were able to have a little more of an exchange. On August 19, 2024, the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner started accepting applications for their lottery. On September 11, 2024, the Marijuana Control Act Regulations went into effect officially. Also, at the end of September and beginning of October, City Council Committee of the Whole: Legislative, Finance and Administration Subcommittee continued discussion and ultimately took action to recommend a set of Ordinances to City Council at their meeting on October 8, 2024. The First Reading was on October 28, 2024 and that was when the referral was made to the Planning Commission. Over the course of the last year, there have been nine (9) public meetings where this has been discussed. This will be the tenth meeting. There was a public Survey where they received 1,408 online responses and 820 paper responses for a total of 2,228 responses in general. Again, the Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 3 of 21

Página 82

Item #3.

Moratorium remains in place until the end of December. Some of the themes and trends that we saw on this Survey are that a majority of 58% of the people who responded in favor of allowing recreational marijuana businesses within the City. There was also support for distancing from incompatible uses. The uses that were really at the top of that list were schools, daycares and rehabilitation centers. The biggest concerns that were cited by over 1,000 people out of 2,228 were concerns about odor and crime. The biggest potential benefits, again cited by over 1,000 of the people who responded, were economic growth and better regulation of marijuana products and increased licensing revenue. Again, keeping in mind, the licensing revenue is not a big financial boom for the town because we are limited through State law by how much it can be licensed in terms that we can’t impose a higher license fee than we would on similar uses. In the Ordinance development, basically the City can prohibit all of the uses. That is an option and many municipalities have done that. The City can permit it similar as to how alcohol or any other use is permitted without any special restrictions. The path that City Council ultimately chose was to develop Ordinances that permit with restrictions. Again, as we get into the Ordinances you will see that they have drafted in things to work to protect the surrounding communities from any external negative effects.

The first Ordinance #2024-29 addresses marijuana cultivation, manufacturing and testing facilities. It would permit these as permitted uses in the M (Manufacturing Zone) and IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone) and additionally it would allow marijuana cultivation facilities as a permitted use in the A (Agricultural Zone). It would also include Supplementary Regulations which we will discuss in a second and it adds definitions for compassion center, marijuana cultivation facility, marijuana manufacturing facility, and marijuana testing facility.

For the Supplementary Regulations: one, it clarifies that a “compassion center” is classified as retail use. That is something that has been in place through policy and that the “compassion center” that is here was treated as a retail use similar to a pharmacy; so, that is memorialized in this. The real Supplementary Regulations that are there in order to protect the community are that the building footprint of a cultivation or manufacturing facility would be required to be 750 feet minimum from residential zones, K-12 schools, hospitals, colleges and universities, child daycare centers, and substance abuse disorder treatment facilities. The Supplementary Regulations would also require odor control technologies, as do the State regulations. But again, this just gives you that kind of double layer of regulation on that. It would require that openings be screened and windows be covered so that the inside cannot be viewed from the outside. And it would require compliance with the utility handbooks and the applicant would be responsible for upgrade costs. This issue is really an issue with cultivation. Cultivation utilizes a lot of water. It utilizes a lot of electricity. Anybody initiating a land use needs to comply with the utility handbooks anyway but it was because these could be big utility users. They decided that it was important to put that in there so that there’s not any question. Marijuana testing facilities would be required to be 750 feet away from residential zones, K-12 schools, hospitals, child daycare centers, and substance abuse disorder treatment facilities. What is not on that list is colleges and universities and part of that is because laboratories are often a use that’s on a university campus and it could be that there is some sort of interest in one of the universities or colleges to do something. The testing for of all of the uses has the least external effects. If you look at the Map, basically what you see is there are very few places where the manufacturing, cultivation, and testing would be allowed. Basically, anything that has one of those icons with a circle around it has the distance requirement and all of that gray shading is a distancing requirement. So, you have a portion of maybe the Enterprise Business Park and some of the industrial manufacturing Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 4 of 21

Página 83

Item #3.

land around the Base and the stuff around Kraft General Foods which at this point is all utilized. Basically, that’s what you are left with. She is going to explain the agricultural from a zoning perspective, but also then from a practical perspective because we did talk to the State about this. One, cultivation again, has to happen indoors. What the State is seeing is where there is cultivation; there is also the product manufacturing. So, you are seeing a lot of vertically integrated businesses and you see that in Milford and Newark where they have the cultivation facilities are also processing and manufacturing and, in some cases, they are also selling. Basically, that is the business model that seems to be out there and that would not be able to take place in the Agricultural Zone land because the only thing that would be allowed is the cultivation. But again, since we are not 100% sure how the business is going to unfold, there was a sense that because growing is an agricultural use that it should be allowed in that zone. Again, she thinks the likelihood is not really there. Then you have a whole other level of complexity if you get into agricultural land that is in the State’s Agriculture Preservation Program because the uses that are allowed and then there is also in some cases, federal money in the easements which adds another challenge. From a practical perspective, it’s unlikely that any of these will be in the Agricultural Zone but the Ordinance is drafted in a way that would allow the cultivation use.

The next Ordinance #2024-30 is specific to retail marijuana stores. One of the things that they decided in working with the City Administration is that breaking them into two ordinances keeps the retail which seems to have a lot more concern about it from what we heard, keeping that in a separate ordinance so that they are not dependent on each other. That’s why it’s in two separate ordinances. Basically, this would permit the retail marijuana stores in the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). So, the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) is only on Route 13 and Bay Road. It also includes Supplementary Regulations that include that the building footprint would need to be at least 500 feet away from K-12 schools, child daycare centers, substance abuse disorder treatment facilities, and hospitals and then 250 feet away from residential zones and colleges and universities. Additionally, there is language that would require that the building footprint be at least 1 mile away from other marijuana retail establishments or marijuana retail stores in the City. So that would prevent any grouping of marijuana retail stores near each other. Again, similar to with the other uses, it would require that openings and windows be covered. The last thing is that it would allow licensed compassion centers to obtain a conversion license and operate without meeting the distancing requirements. There is currently one compassion center in the City and it does not meet any of the distance requirements. This was something that as it was discussed at the Council Committee of the Whole, there was interest in making sure that establishment could receive a conversion license. The other thing is that is adds a definition of a “retail marijuana store.”

With that, we look at the Map and C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) is in red on that map. With the buffering, there are just a few places. A marijuana leaf shows where the current compassion center is located. So, if that compassion center received a conversion license at that location and became a retail marijuana store, we show in that light green strip as a mile in either direction. Basically, you take that out and you take the buffering from other uses and there might be some place just at the north end of town and then maybe right along Bay Road or at the south end of town. There is not a lot of area so it is not something that is really going to proliferate. There were some responses in the survey for the question “where else would it make sense?” Some people said anywhere liquor stores are allowed. Some people said nowhere. The current Ordinance Draft does not include anything along the Route 8 Corridor. It restricts it only to Route 13 and Bay Road. Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 5 of 21

Página 84

Item #3.

Tonight, we are here for the Planning Commission Public Hearing and then the City Council has set the Public Hearing and Final Reading before them at their December 9, 2024 meeting and on December 31, 2024 the Moratorium expires. One thing they want to make sure you understand and that the City Council understands also is that failure to have an Ordinance in place basically defaults to what the underlying use is. So, if the Zoning Ordinance doesn’t address marijuana retail stores, then basically you are looking at where retail stores are allowed. You are looking at the type of use not the category because retail in the Code doesn’t address what you are selling. So, without having that layer to say these are how we are dealing with the marijuana uses, it really will fall down to that base use below it. This is why with the Moratorium expiring, they have been working really hard to try to make sure that there is something in place before the end of the year. As for the Planning Commission, you will have your Public Hearing and you can obviously propose amendments. You could recommend to not approve any of these. You could recommend to scrap it all and prohibit. Basically, the motion you make is a recommendation to City Council. But if there are specific amendments, you could make that as well.

Mrs. Denney asked Mrs. Townshend to help her understand the “compassion centers.” When she reads this, her assumption is that it’s a facility where people who are prescribed by professionals, the use of marijuana. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated yes, but right now a “compassion center” is a medical marijuana facility where you need a medical card to go in and buy any product. Under the State Law, they created a conversion license and basically, they are expecting the compassion centers to convert to the full recreational and medical. They are issuing conversion licenses that would allow the existing establishment to become a recreational establishment. So, the “compassion center” that we have in Dover is only retail. They do not do any cultivation or manufacturing; so, for them to get a conversion license it would convert to a retail establishment for recreational and medical marijuana.

Mrs. Denney stated that realistically if a conversion happens, then what her understanding of what was just said is that if a conversion happens, our Council would have to allow or disallow with recommendations but if the conversion happens, then that is going to be a retail center where if she decided to use marijuana, she could go down there and buy it whether it is prescribed or not. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated yes.

Mrs. Denney stated that that needs to be clear and we all need to really understand that. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that it is in Ordinance #2024-30. Again, from a practical standpoint, she has had several conversations with the Office of Marijuana Commissioner about this and they are expecting that compassion centers will be phased out because the retail marijuana stores will service both. In order for a compassion center to get their conversion license, they have to demonstrate that they can still support that medical need but they are going to do that. What the Commissioner’s Office has said is that once industry is up and running, a business won’t be able to survive as compassion center alone. From a practical perspective, while the law still recognizes the compassion centers, from a practical perspective they will be phased out. In Ordinance #2024-29, the top of Page 2, starting Line 40 it says that “a compassion center licensed by the State of Delaware on or before January 1, 2024 (that date is there to make sure nobody tries to get a compassion center up and running) that obtains a conversion license under the State of Delaware Marijuana Regulations, must comply with the requirements of Article 3 - District Regulations.” This means it has to be permitted in the zone. If it wasn’t permitted in the zone, all bets are off. Also, it “shall be exempt from the distancing Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 6 of 21

Página 85

Item #3.

requirements detailed in Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations.” The conversion of a compassion center to recreational retail would allow the existing compassion center, which we only have one, to be where it is and not meet those distance requirements; but it wouldn’t allow any new.

Mrs. Denney stated that they can all see it on the map but do you happen to know the address of our compassion center? Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that it’s on Jefferic Boulevard but she can’t remember the exact number. It is near Big Lots and Burlington Coat Factory.

Mrs. Denney stated that it is more out on the Route 13 Corridor. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated yes.

Mrs. Denney stated that this is her opinion, but it feels like they shouldn’t be allowing that conversion to happen. The point here is that it is going to be legal and whether she likes it or not, that doesn’t matter. She doesn’t use it but again, being in medicine, she fully understands the need for many people to have access to it. She still thinks that it should be by prescription only because we all know, just like with alcohol, you can say that you can’t drink and drive but how many people are killed in this Country and even in this City because somebody decided not to obey the laws? Frankly, she lives on State Street. She drives down that road and it used to be that people stopped at stop signs and now they just roll through it. It is becoming more and more frequent and to her, it’s ridiculous. She is certainly not going to say “where is the City of Dover Police Department” because they have their hands full. To her, the first thing that would need to be adopted if we were even entertaining some of this would be that we have to find some type of a fine so that we can pay our Police Department to have the extra staffing although it is hard to recruit police officers. Her husband was a Delaware State Trooper and the United States Marshal. She has a stepson who is a Deputy United States Marshal and frankly if one of her grandchildren came to her tomorrow and said this is what they wanted to do to honor Granddad, she would have a heart attack because just like they don’t respect the laws, they don’t respect law enforcers. She is just saying that because we are about to vote on how we feel about allowing these things to happen.

Dr. Jones asked if there was a reason why houses of faith were not included. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Townshend stated that that has actually gotten quite a bit of discussion at the Council level and we have definitely looked to map them out. The challenge is this, for K-12 schools there is a very clear way to find where they are and the same with licensed daycare centers. Now if someone is doing it without a license that is a whole different issue. The places that are included are places that we are able to obtain a comprehensive list of where they are so that there is not errors and uncertainty. There is not a comprehensive list of churches. We looked at two data sources. We looked at the tax records and you can get some through that, but there are also a lot of houses of worship that rent. If it’s rented, you are not going to find them that way. So, they looked at Public Occupancy Permits and it looks like they might be able to do that but it is very labor intensive in terms of the Department being able to continue that. We have looked at that and the City Manager has that information. If an amendment were introduced that did that, they would find a way. But you have to be able to know where things are to be able to distance from that and that was the challenge with that.

Dr. Jones stated that she thinks that makes every bit of sense because they pop up here and there Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 7 of 21

Página 86

Item #3.

and they are renting here and there. She doesn’t think it’s too late in the process for your organization to take a look at this. But it is possible to call together, as there are organizations of faith-based organizations that run the gamut of various faiths. Bring them together and hear what they have to say. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Townshend stated that would be a question for City Council. That was discussed at the City Council meetings. Again, the information has been pulled together of where they are. She thinks they actually did some mapping and most of the places of worship are not in that area. There are some along the highway corridor but a lot of them are kind of more back in neighborhoods. They do have the mapping. If it is something that an amendment was introduced for and if the Ordinance was amended, it’s something that could be done potentially.

Dr. Jones asked if there was any relationship between manufacturing and/or the retail with CBD. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Townshend stated no, CBD is basically unregulated. Those places don’t fall into this; they are not regulated under this. They can continue to operate as they are.

Dr. Jones asked if they may become a part of what’s going on. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Townshend stated that is probably a question for like the market. There is a question on whether people will still be getting CBD if they can get marijuana. Again, she has had several people using CBD in her family and they are not using that for a high. Her mother-in-law uses it to put on her arthritic hands. She thinks that it is separate enough that it’s not going to be affected but she is not an industry expert either.

Mr. Witham asked if this Commission recommended to City Council to prohibit marijuana in the City, how would that affect the one compassion center? Are they likely to close because they are not going to be profitable? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that she knows they have already applied for and been approved for a conversion license. She knows the COO of the compassion center was here at one of the meetings where the Council Committee talked about it. He reached out to her afterwards and basically, he said here on the floor and then he said again to her, if they can’t get a conversion license then they won’t be able to continue.

Mr. Witham stated that the level of the HTC in marijuana has consistently gone up over the years so now they are selling high concentrated marijuana which presents great issues for people. His concern is, was there any consideration in regulating the level of HTC in marijuana either at the State level or could the City of Dover regulate that? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that the City can’t regulate the quality. They can only regulate the time, place and manner. She is not sure if that was addressed in the State. She does know that they have to put the strength; if it’s 5mg, 10mg, or 20mg on the packaging. She doesn’t know how that works for the flower. It seems to her that that’s harder to figure out in that.

Mr. Witham stated that some states are now looking into that to try to regulate the level of HTC in marijuana because they find that high levels are extremely dangerous. There are studies that show that the crime rates go up, the DUI rates go up. They have been going up ever since Colorado and some of the other states have allowed general recreational marijuana to exist in the states. The rates just continued to go up; so, he was just wondering whether there was any thought in that area? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that she is not aware. Again, at the local level they are preempted from regulating that aspect. She is not sure, but she can certainly find out from the Commissioner’s Office. She has read quite a bit about some of the effects of the higher content stuff that isn’t necessarily good. Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 8 of 21

Página 87

Item #3.

Mr. Witham stated that given his background, he has seen the worst. The other question that he has is he understands that Ordinance #2024-30 would permit the use of retail marijuana stores in a C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). He noticed that both of the Ordinances that pertain to this don’t mention at all courthouses. Courthouses in this City are located just off The Green. There is the Kent County Courthouse and the new Family Courthouse going up on Governors Avenue. Both of those courthouses are going to have programs in courts involving the use of drugs which will be prohibited from their standpoint. There is no mention of court houses. Are they covered in some other area? They should be viewed as the same thing as the substance abuse treatment center. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that it is something certainly that could be added.

Mr. Witham stated that he was informed by one Council member that there was a provision in those Ordinances that would exclude the establishment of retail stores, cultivation, and manufacturing so many feet from the courthouse, but he didn’t see it. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that she had not heard that discussed but again, that is something that you know where they are and we could easily identify them. From a practical perspective for today, she doesn’t think it’s an issue except the current Family Court. Once the Family Court moves it’s not, but the current Family Court could be within a distance of C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). It could be something that could be done through an amendment. But she thinks the courthouses, with the exception of Family Court, tend to be located in the Downtown Area.

Mr. Witham stated that he thinks the Superior Courthouse and the new Family Courthouse would be in the area of which we call the Downtown Development zone. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that the current ordinance does prohibit it in the Downtown Area. That was one of the things that came up on multiple occasions throughout the process and ultimately, the Survey showed that a majority of the people who responded did not think it should be Downtown. At this point, there was not the desire from Council to amend the drafts that they brought forward to do that.

Mr. Witham stated that he can assure them that members of the judiciary, if they knew about this, they would probably be concerned about this. He thinks that it is something that he would recommend that Council address if they want to adopt such an ordinance. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that Mrs. Melson-Williams can correct her if she is wrong but she would suggest that if there are recommendation that you want to make to Council to amend, to include that in a motion.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated yes, with looking at both of these Ordinances, if there are proposed as amendments. You have kind of mentioned the question of places of worship, which that gets difficult in our Code because they are more generally referred to as places of public assembly and then the courthouses. You could certainly make a recommendation to add to the Supplementary Regulations an amendment that would specify a distancing requirement from those two types of uses.

Mr. Witham stated that the other question that he has is that there appears to be no requirement of odor control technology for retail stores. Why is that? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that the research that they did and the areas that they found odor complaints Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 9 of 21

Página 88

Item #3.

were really on the cultivation and manufacturing. In the stores, you are not allowed to use it. Certainly, something could be added but it’s typically sealed and not out in the open.

Mr. Witham stated that this facility is closed now but the Central Delaware Committee on Substance Abuse Control operated the Kent County Counseling Center just off of Walker Road. They were a treatment center and one of the complaints that were made to him years ago was that they would treat people and people would light up right outside the store. The whole area would be permeated with the smell of marijuana. So, that was a retail establishment so why would that not occur if we allow retail stores in Dover? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that under the State Law and under the State Regulations, you cannot consume onsite. She smells it too; she is not pretending like she was born yesterday. But under the Law, you cannot consume it on the premises and you cannot consume it in a publicly accessible place. If people are smoking it on a street corner whether it’s near the retail or wherever it is, that’s not allowed. She thinks the practical matter to his point is what do you do about it because the Police are busy. They have a lot of other things.

Mrs. Denney stated exactly. It is almost like they are not laws; they are suggestions and it’s really just about the attitude of people when it comes to obedience. She is old and if it was a law and you had her father, you obeyed the law. By Big Lots there is the Lutheran Church right there on the highway. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that she is not sure the actual distance, but again, based on the current draft which was amended to include the exemption from the distancing to allow for the conversion; that is something that came about through the process.

Mrs. Denney stated that at one time there was a little preschool in that Lutheran Church. To her, that’s a school. Any place where children are being taught is a school, but she realizes that is not written in the laws necessarily. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that if it’s a licensed daycare center then that would be get picked. But again, by virtue of exempting compassion center conversions from the distancing, that would be one location where that would happen.

Mrs. Denney stated then perhaps about allowing that conversion, we shouldn’t be doing that. Perhaps we should not allow it and then we protect the children. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that is certainly something that they could recommend to Council. That’s what this process is for.

Mr. Witham stated that he appreciates Mrs. Townshend’s presentation but he has another question. As he understands from her presentation, the State Law on this subject is not going to allow a driver who is driving to use marijuana. Is that correct? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated yes, it also doesn’t allow passengers in the car to be using it in the car. Again, she thinks even before it was legal, we have all observed otherwise.

Mr. Witham stated that he is sure that was because a majority of our wonderful police officers would use the smell of marijuana as one aspect of probable cause to stop a driver driving. But by prohibiting that, it makes their job a little bit easier.

Mrs. Maucher asked how the distancing is determined for these buffers. Is that pulled out of the State Law? What is the basis for the 250 feet, 500 feet, and one mile? Responding to Mrs. Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 10 of 21

Página 89

Item #3.

Maucher, Mrs. Townshend stated that it is not in State Law. There is no distancing requirement in State Law. This was based on discussion with City Council Committee of the Whole to have some distancing but they also wanted to make sure that once you applied the distancing that it wasn’t a defacto prohibition. So, we looked at different scenarios and what distancing did to whether or not it would be viable. So, that’s how we got to where we are.

Mrs. Maucher stated that hypothetically if you applied these to these instances, how many potential sites would be available? Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mrs. Townshend stated that she thinks very few. Basically, you see what a mile is. You could theoretically get at the most four to five if that one dot moved. Again, that is theoretical. Once you look at available space. Then with the issue of distancing, they said the building footprint of where the marijuana use is. So, if it’s one retail space in a larger building, you are looking at the building footprint. You are not looking at that tenant space. She thinks that they looked at it and thought, theoretically you might be able to get four. But the likelihood to be able to get four without allowing it other than on Route 13 and Bay Road is really difficult. The other thing, it’s only C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). It doesn’t include the shopping center zones. For instance, you‘ve got Blue Hen Corporate Center and Bay Court Plaza. They are both zoned Shopping Center. They both have a lot of available retail space, but they aren’t zoned C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone).

Mr. Reaves stated that he has a question with regards to the cultivation. Does the Ordinance mention anything about container farming? Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mrs. Townshend stated that it does not. But both under the Ordinance and under the State Regulations, she doesn’t know how they would be able to meet the odor control in particular and the ventilation. There are a lot of things that she thinks would be difficult to meet in the context of container farming. She suspects that there is also National Fire Prevention Regulations that come into play that it would be very difficult to do in that type of environment. Even though it is not addressed, it certainly could be.

Mrs. Denney stated that it was an excellent question. It never crossed her mind.

Mr. Reaves stated that from a business perspective that people grow. This is not for sale or use or anything like that, but just from a business perspective. There is a growing movement of container farming in which people can have a successful business because as Mrs. Denney said with regards to the medicinal purposes, there is a need for production. With the land use space, container farming is a viable option for a lot of different uses. Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mrs. Townshend stated that the other thing that the State Regulations have is that they have very stringent security requirements.

Mrs. Welsh questioned that in regard to the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) and the comment that you just had, Mrs. Townshend, about the retail spaces in the Bay Court Plaza and Blue Hen Mall being retail spaces but not C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). Is it available to them to put a restriction on the ability for them to request a Rezoning to C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) in the future? Responding to Mrs. Welsh, Mrs. Townshend stated that she is going to defer to the Chair because her guess is that he has got a lot better background on being able to condition not allowing a request.

Mr. Witham stated that he can’t make a comment about future applications, but it would be a legitimate question of the Planning Commission and the Commissioners to ask a question if Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 11 of 21

Página 90

Item #3.

someone wants to rezone their property to C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) or some other zone that would permit cultivation, manufacturing or sales of marijuana. They can make an inquiry about the purpose of the Rezoning. It certainly would go under into the nick so to speak, as to whether it should be allowed.

Mrs. Townshend stated that you can’t really preempt the ability for somebody to request.

Mr. Witham stated that that triggers another question in his mind. He thinks that the adoption of these Ordinances would allow the transportation of the product from agricultural marijuana to the store, correct? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated yes, and that is also very tightly regulated in the State Regulations.

Mr. Witham further asked if that was so a person using his private vehicle could transport several pounds of marijuana. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that would not be allowed.

Mrs. Denney asked if it would be like a “Brinks” car operation. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that is her understanding in the conversations that she has had with the Commissioner’s Office. Each piece of plant will have a barcode, and it will be tracked so at no point would they “put this in your car and take it.” It is all very monitored from the time that it is germinated to the time that it is sold.

Mr. Witham opened the public hearing.

Mrs. Cynthia Christiansen – 714 Carol Street Dover, DE 19904 Mrs. Christiansen stated that she has been a resident of Dover, DE for 60+ years. This is not her first time here. If you have read any minutes from any previous Committee Meetings or Council Meetings, you know what her position is. She is a retired school teacher for 43 years but she is substituting full time. She is concerned about the location of a retail store anywhere near Route 13 or a housing development. It bothers her that the cultivation is 750 feet and schools, hospitals, and daycares is only 500 feet. That doesn’t make sense to her because these children are outside breathing the air and they should have clean air. If it’s near a store that is selling marijuana, whether they have it sealed that does not prevent them from smoking on the way home or smoking it in their car. Right now, she can’t go anywhere in this City on the highway, in neighborhoods or even her own neighborhood and drive down the street without smelling a dead skunk and there is not a dead skunk on the road. She knows that the cultivated marijuana is supposed to be different and a higher grade but there is still going to be that smell. There are still going to be people driving and dropping their kids off at school. She knows for a fact because she has opened doors of cars and she can get a contact high. A contact high can be given to a child. She has had students come in with a contact high in Dover schools. They are contact high not because they are smoking but because they are sitting in a car or at their home and their parents are smoking around them. They don’t know any different until about 9:30 or 10:00AM and they come off of that contact high. What happens at the end of the day? They get right back in that car and we can’t do anything as teachers or administrators. They have already tried. It’s because the laws are not really written. She thinks the cart has been put before the horse. “You shouldn’t” or “you are prohibited.” They don’t know what that word is in any place in Dover, especially at a concert. Let’s say that is different because that is supposed to be controlled but anywhere outside. For a football game, no you are not allowed to have drugs or marijuana in a Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 12 of 21

Página 91

Item #3.

stadium but you can sit in the car in the parking lot and smoke up and the air comes right to us. This bothers her greatly. It bothers her to the point where she looks and sees Dewey Beach, Rehoboth, Fenwick Island, Bethany Beach, all of the party towns said “absolutely no.” If you think about it, she thought they would be the biggest ones to pass it, but they said no. The Rossi Group was hired by City Council and she has questioned this through the whole process. She has heard nothing but positive; there is nothing negative. Dr. Vendetti commented twice at meetings and she said that she called other places in the country asking for them to tell her how things are with just marijuana. One place said, “if you have a nice town, don’t do it.” This is what bothers her because she has lived here all of her life and she loved her City. She loved it when she used to smell chocolate from General Foods and she loved when we smelled chicken from Richardson and Robbins. Now, we smell marijuana everywhere. How can the Police enforce this? She even asked the head czar of the Marijuana Department if he was going to give more money to towns and cities that are going to say yes. He just looked at her and shrugged his shoulders. She knows what the answer is; absolutely not. And that 15%, who knows where that goes. They are probably looking to make a lot of money. The thing is, your Police Department cannot do it. They can’t even pull over somebody that they assume is smoking. Yes, they are driving and smoking. If anyone drives up or down Route 13 or down Governors Avenue, you don’t have to be a rocket scientist to know that someone in the car in front of you is in there smoking because your car is going to smell like it. As a taxpayer, as a teacher, and as somebody who just had a brand-new baby granddaughter born last Thursday, do I want her to stay living in Dover? Yes, because it’s close to me. Do I think they will? Probably not, if we keep doing what we are doing. It’s not building up; she thinks we are building down.

Mr. Bill Winters – Mitten & Winters LLC at 117 W Loockerman Street Dover, DE 19904 Mr. Winters stated that he owns a business at 117 W Loockerman Street and he is a Dover resident located at 133 Walker Road Dover, DE 19904. He spoke to City Council months ago. He has some concerns about the Ordinance but first he has a question either for the Commissioners or Mrs. Townshend. Assuming the Ordinance passes and there is a retail location opened which he is against. If it is passed by the Commission and it is passed on to Council. Is there a limit to the quantity of marijuana that somebody can buy when they enter a facility? Can they go in like if they go into a liquor store and buy as much as they want or is there a limitation to the quantity at any one time? Responding to Mr. Winters, Mrs. Townshend stated that under House Bill 1, which is the first of the two marijuana bills, you are limited to a personal use quantity which is no more than one ounce per person. She doesn’t know for sure that you can’t buy any more than that but you can’t load up like you can at the Costco Liquor Store or anything.

Mr. Witham stated that he thinks from his standpoint, the way he would interpret that is that you are limited to personal use only. If you go in there a try to buy a pound or two of marijuana and you get in your car you are going to get stopped.

Mr. Winters stated that some of this is going to be repetitive, repeating what Mrs. Christiansen said but he has followed this pretty closely. He has seen what some of the towns in Sussex have done. Dewey said they didn’t want it because they have enough issues with alcohol. In Newark, Commissioners decided that they didn’t want it on Main Street because of the University being there and the excessive use that could possibly happen with a college campus. Fortunately, at least with the Ordinance that you currently have set up, there won’t be any retail within the Downtown area. But we do have the Del State University Campus which is three blocks from Downtown. You are faced with a very difficult decision on whether to approve this or not. Dover Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 13 of 21

Página 92

Item #3.

has some of the best parades in the State. It’s amazing what they do with parades. This past St. Patrick’s Day, they had a phenomenal parade. Loockerman Street was packed with people. His office is right across the street from the old Dover Hardware was and there is open space there now. After the conclusion of the parade, they had a DJ playing out there and our office was open on that Saturday because it was tax season. The music was great; however, the amount of marijuana being smoked out on the street was amazing. We had to have a couple of people leave our office because of the smell that permeated our office. Mrs. Christiansen is right; you go anywhere around Dover and you are going to smell marijuana. He and his wife regularly drive through Silver Lake Park on bike rides and the amount of consumption there on a regular basis is amazing. So, if we are already saying that it’s a problem, he can’t imagine what it’s going to be like if we approve this in our City right now. It’s going to be a big issue to deal with and how are the police going to deal with it if somebody’s doing public consumption, do they arrest them? Do they take the time to take them to the station and then they are going to get released right away? That’s the whole concept right there; he doesn’t know how that’s going to work. All he knows is that the Commission has a very difficult decision to pass along to the City Council. There is no revenue coming to the City of Dover for this provision; so, what benefit is it to our community? He doesn’t see any.

Mrs. Nicole Chick – 510 Kirkwood Highway Wilmington DE 19805 (virtual) Mrs. Chick stated that she had discussed a while back with Council President Anderson an Ordinance that he put forth on June 11, 2024 that businesses already in existence that apply for a retail license could obtain a waiver of the residential buffer restriction by obtaining signatures of approval from the residents. Her question is where does that stand currently and if it is still being considered? She would ask that we ensure the amendment says something like business owners and not just businesses because someone owning an existing hemp business, for instance, liability wise likely isn’t going to apply with the exact business names and risk the liability there. They would apply as a new business that would sell marijuana instead. If the amendment has already been voted on, could she know who voted for and against it? If it’s still under consideration, she just wanted to say that an existing medical dispensary or a compassion center shouldn’t qualify for an exemption to the zoning requirements if hemp stores can’t equally get the same treatment. Responding to Mrs. Chick, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that she believes that there were discussions in the City Council Committee of the Whole regarding potential amendments; however, that amendment was not voted upon or released from Committee as part of the proposed Ordinance packages for consideration here.

Mrs. Townshend stated that there was language and there were two kind of conceptual amendments: the one that Mrs. Chick mentioned and then the one that would address conversion licenses was the other. We put them both in Ordinance format and there was no action on the one that you mentioned. For the one that you mentioned, the way that you characterized it would not have allowed for your business to obtain a license anyway. Looking at the objective, they drafted something that would have allowed it as a Conditional Use in the C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) and that Draft Amendment did not move forward.

Mr. Witham stated that the bottom line is that presumably the not approved Amendment is not before this Commission. It is not being considered.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that there was no Amendment in short that came out of Committee to us for consideration by the Planning Commission in regards to a possible hemp store provision Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 14 of 21

Página 93

Item #3.

in the Ordinance.

There was technical difficulty with the sound through WebEx.

Mrs. Chick typed in the chat if someone could forward her the status of that Amendment. Responding to Mrs. Chick, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that that Amendment was never released from Committee as part of the Ordinance package.

Mrs. Chick asked through the chat if Mrs. Melson-Williams could repeat herself. Responding to Mrs. Chick, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the concept for that Amendment related to hemp stores was not part of the package that was released by the Council Committee of the Whole. It was discussed she believes, at one of their earlier meetings this summer but ultimately was not made part of the proposed Ordinance that was released for consideration.

Mr. Witham stated that it is not before this Commission. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that is correct.

Mrs. Chick asked through the chat who voted against it. Responding to Mrs. Chick, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated she doesn’t believe that it was ever brought forth formally as an amendment at that Committee. The City Clerk’s Office would have the meeting minutes for those Council Committee of the Whole Meetings where it was discussed.

Mr. Witham closed the public hearing.

Mr. Witham stated that they have before them a Petition for Text Amendments for recreational uses of marijuana in the City of Dover. Under Article 10, Section 5 they must evaluate these factors for proposed Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30. To get this matter moving forward, there are three options. The first option is to prohibit, recommending that the City Council deny adopting these Ordinances in whole. The second option is to permit as requested by these Ordinances before us. The third option is to approve with exception and/or recommendations for improvements.

Mrs. Denney stated that she thinks it’s pretty evident here to everybody from the beginning of this that in her perfect world, we would just go with Option 1 and prohibit it completely for non- medical uses because once again, she managed an orthopedic surgery practice. She has seen many people with injuries. She has happened to have been married, have her children and she is now widowed but she was married to a sailor and Vietnam left a lot of people with issues. She does see a medical necessity, but her feeling is if they decide not to prohibit it completely, just keep it out on the highway in a very restricted area. But her preference would be to do what they were brave enough to do in Sussex County. She remembers when her kids were young, there was a slogan “Just Say No” and that’s where she would love to be.

Mr. Witham stated that he believes that the Planning Office had found that the proposed Ordinances were consistent with the aims and principles of the Zoning Ordinance and the Comprehensive Plan. Is that correct? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that any time you are looking at a Text Amendment, the Zoning Ordinance has two criteria that are prescribed for you to evaluate those Text Amendments. This is found in the Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5 and when considering a proposed Text Amendment we have to Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 15 of 21

Página 94

Item #3.

issue whether or not the change is consistent with the aims and principles embodied in the Ordinance as to the particular zone concerned and whether the Amendment is consistent with the aims of the Comprehensive Plan for the City. As part of the DAC Report on Page 5, Planning Staff along with our consultant have responded to those criteria. In finding that when you generally look at cultivation, manufacturing and testing, those types of uses are allowed in the M (Manufacturing Zone) and the IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone) because those zones permit the manufacturing and industrial processing of goods. They also allow for research and testing labs. The cultivation, likewise when you look at the A (Agricultural Zone), is something where you find crop harvesting as permitted use. Then looking at marijuana retail stores, in looking at the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) that is a zone that allows for retail and that is a zone where they would expect to find higher intensity and likely auto dependent uses in that zone. It’s considered a higher intensity type provision. The Ordinance as proposed does provide those Supplementary Regulations where we find the requirements for distancing, the things that the City as a municipality is allowed to control related to time and place. For the second provision related to the Comprehensive Plan, they included in their Report some notations about specifically looking at where the Land Use Category of Commercial High Intensity areas are. That is found in the DuPont Highway (Route 13) and Bay Road corridors and there is a statement there about what the makeup of those types of corridors is. And then additionally, there is some discussion in the Land Use of Employment Centers where they should be providing sufficient land area for industrial purposes and whether that is existing facilities, new facilities, or revitalizations of older industrial sites. With those statements, they found that it would be consistent with the aims and principles of the Zoning Ordinance basically for similar type uses; however, given that it’s marijuana then adding additional restrictions to it as well as how those areas from a land use perspective are described in the Comprehensive Plan.

Mr. Michael Lewis stated that he might be looking at this from maybe a different perspective. He hesitates to make assumptions but he may be one of the younger people sitting here. Somebody mentioned Bay Court Plaza before but he is old enough to remember the Pink Elephant store that was there. He believes that it had a drive through window and that was an alcohol facility. He mentions that as just an example of how things evolve, how things change, how as a culture and society we move on from things from time to time. He appreciates the fact that Council submitted these proposed Ordinances and they followed pretty closely with what the Survey results were. More than 2,200 people filled out the Survey and they have seemed to narrowly follow what the majority of the Survey respondents wanted. 58-42 was the overall percentage breakdown as far as allowing some uses with the restrictions in general; allow was the 58% and prohibit was the 42%. He thinks the Ordinances do a fine job of capturing the mood and the result of the survey. The surveys can’t obviously be our end all but when they presented them, the public had the chance to weigh in and they did on this issue. He would support more surveys being sent on other issues. To him, this marijuana issue isn’t in the top 10 or 15 of issues facing Dover but that is a discussion for another day. From his perspective, he thinks the Ordinances do a good job of capturing what the mood and the wishes of the survey respondents are. He would support the permit with restrictions side of things. If there are no other comments, he would put forth a motion to approve but he doesn’t want to jump the gun.

Mr. Witham asked what exceptions or restrictions would he suggest. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mr. Lewis stated that he would be just in favor of adopting Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 as stated but he assumes that they have to do one at a time.

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 16 of 21

Página 95

Item #3.

Mr. Michael Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances as presented.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council to adopt Ordinance #2024-29 as presented. This is the one that focuses on manufacturing, cultivation and testing. We are looking for a second on that motion to move into discussion and/or a vote.

Mrs. Maucher seconded the motion.

Mr. Witham stated that his thoughts would be directed to Mr. Lewis. Would he be amenable to an amendment to the motion to include the requirement that City Council improve the proposed amendments to include a distance requirement from any and all public courthouses within the City of Dover? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mr. Lewis stated yes.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that if the motion maker is accepting of the amendment, is there a distance that they want to specify? Responding to Mrs. Melson-Williams, Mr. Witham stated that he would suggest like the other distance requirements of the other public facilities, which is 750 feet.

Mrs. Denney stated that she doesn’t think that it belongs in Dover and most definitely not in Downtown Dover.

Mrs. Welsh stated that she concurs with Mrs. Denney.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated they need to address the amendment. You had the motion maker agree to that. Is the second also amenable to that amendment? Responding to Mrs. Melson- Williams, Mrs. Maucher stated yes.

Mr. Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances and adding a requirement for a 750 feet distancing requirement from courthouses, seconded by Mrs. Maucher.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the amendment would be added to the section of Lines 90-94 where that distancing is listed and then also again on Line 129-133. That would capture all of the manufacturing, testing, and cultivation.

Mr. Witham asked if that would be for retail also. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson- Williams stated that retail is not discussed in this one. There are basically three sections where that (amendment for distancing from courthouses) would need to be added. That includes 165- 170 as well where the distancing is listed.

Mr. Michael Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 17 of 21

Página 96

Item #3.

for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances and adding a requirement for a 750 feet distancing requirement from courthouses, seconded by Mrs. Maucher and the motion failed with 4-5 by roll call vote(4 in favor, 5 against the motion). Mr. Lewis voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mr. Roach voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mrs. Denney voting no; if we approve manufacturing, next thing you know they are going to be fighting to sell it where they grow it and manufacture it. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; based on reasons stated in the motion. Mr. Baldwin voting no. Dr. Jones voting no; for her there are still areas that have been unaddressed and there seem to be some that are unenforceable. Mr. Reaves voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mrs. Welsh voting no; for reasons stated by Mrs. Denney and Dr. Jones. Mr. Witham voting no; he frankly doesn’t see how the adoption of these Ordinances would further the economic development goals of Dover for the sales, cultivation and manufacturing in this federally illegal drug which is still illegal under Federal Law. It is a Schedule II drug that has never been approved through the federal government although the State does allow it. It’s just problematic for the State and for the City. Second of all, we draw no income. The City gets no part of the 15% tax on marijuana yet the cost of public services to monitor, regulate and police the growing, dispensing and sales of marijuana is going to cause an increase in public funds being expended. And although it does meet the technical requirements of a proposed amendment under the zoning law, our zoning law doesn’t direct the type of retail sales that we promote in this community. Obviously, this is a retail sale or manufacturing of an item that is very problematic and controversial. He doesn’t think the Zoning Ordinance or the Comprehensive Plan ever contemplated this.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that it is probably best if there is a motion in the affirmative to say no and prohibit if that is your vote in order to clarify that.

Mrs. Denney stated that the motion failed so it dies, and someone can make a new motion. Is that the better way? Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Melson-Wiliams stated yes.

Mrs. Denney stated that she would be happy to make a motion, but she isn’t sure if we want to add anything.

Mrs. Denney moved to recommend denial to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, seconded by Dr. Jones.

Mrs. Denney stated that if there is something happening in the universities for testing or researching, she doesn’t want to prohibit that so she’s not sure what to do with that. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that testing in the context of this Ordinance is testing under the licensing program. It wouldn’t prevent academic research.

Mrs. Denney stated that with that understanding her motion still stands.

Mrs. Denney moved to recommend denial to City Council for Ordinance 2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, seconded by Dr. Jones and the motion was carried 5-4 by roll call vote (5 in favor and 4 against the motion to deny). Mrs. Denney voting yes; she thinks that it’s to the Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 18 of 21

Página 97

Item #3.

benefit to us and to our children and grandchildren. She feels that it’s necessary to protect them as much as we can and to protect our City which is the capital city of the State that started the Nation and she hopes that others follow our lead. Mrs. Maucher voting no; the State has determined that it is a legal product and has set up regulations for it. This is for cultivation, manufacturing and testing for it, and she thinks it’s reasonable. If it’s not allowed here, it’s going to occur somewhere else in the State and you are not insulating Dover from any of that material coming into the City. Having it in the City, she thinks, gives us additional protections rather than a free for all. Mr. Baldwin voting yes. Dr Jones voting yes. Mr. Reaves voting no; because this is a business proposition, this is not distribution or sell. This is the manufacturing, cultivation, and testing. This is just like a normal business that would be producing anything in Dover and would potentially sell it to different facilities. This product is legal in the State and he doesn’t think that they should be prohibiting this business opportunity. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons stated in the motion. Mr. Lewis voting no; he can just add with first hand experience that there is plenty of academic research that takes place at the Firefly Music Festival. Mr. Roach voting no; he agrees with Mrs. Maucher and thinks it is handicapping us. We are the capital of the State. It is legal in the State of Delaware so to prohibit the manufacturing and testing and things of that nature, it just seems not logical. If it’s legal in the State, to not be able to manufacture here is not doing anything but putting us behind times; behind everybody else that already has it in their City. It is actually counterproductive and he really would urge people to not do that. It is putting us behind the times by doing it anyway because the whole State is legalized. It just doesn’t make sense to prohibit it here. It is actually putting us in a worse place than it is a better place. Mr. Witham voting yes; the passage of this Ordinance will do nothing to improve the City of Dover. The reasons that he set forth in the previous motion will apply here. We draw no revenue from this. The only way to force the State to give us revenue is to deny the cultivation, manufacturing and transportation, and the retail sales of marijuana. If we don’t deny these motions, we are just asking for trouble.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the recommendation on Ordinance #2024-29 to City Council would be that Ordinance is not adopted and that there should be prohibition of manufacturing, testing, and cultivation.

Mr. Witham stated that the next Ordinance that needs to be addressed is Ordinance #2024-30.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that just to remind you, proposed Ordinance #2024-30 is the Ordinance that was set up with provisions related to retail marijuana stores with limitations in being established only in the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) and then a series of Supplementary Regulations for their operations.

Mr. Witham moved to recommend denial to City Council for Ordinance #2024-30 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for retail marijuana stores and provisions for compassion center conversions by amending Dover Code of Ordinances for the reasons that he stated earlier and for the reasons that Mrs. Denney stated, seconded by Dr. Jones and the motion was carried 5-4 (5 favor and 4 against of denial) by roll call vote. Mr. Lewis voting no; the Ordinance as proposed gives a pretty narrow window to anything potential retail establishment. Plus, we have already stated in this meeting how denying this would put the one compassion center that we do have in jeopardy which does serve for a medical marijuana purpose. Mr. Roach voting no; he agrees with the reasons previously stated. Mrs. Denney voting yes; for reasons she stated throughout this meeting. She Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 19 of 21

Página 98

Item #3.

thinks that we don’t need to legalize one other opportunity for people to drive intoxicated, act out intoxicated, get in fights at sporting events and she enjoys taking her grandchildren down to Silver Lake. They went there for homecoming photos and her grand-daughter went to the house and had to spray her dress because she smelled like marijuana from going to have a picture for homecoming taken by the lake. Mrs. Maucher voting no; again, the State has determined this to be a legal product. The Ordinance had put sufficient limitations on where and buffers for these types of businesses. Not allowing this retail sale in the City is not going to prevent people from bringing it into the City. You are talking about consumption issues, not sale issues. Mr. Baldwin voting yes; for reasons stated. Dr. Jones voting yes; in her mind and experience it is already out of hand and to try and bring it under control with these Ordinances with some things that are still unclear and unenforceable. Mr. Reaves voting no; for reasons stated previously. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons as noted by Dr. Jones. Mr. Witham voting yes; for the reasons that he stated earlier. In addition to that, his experience as a drug court judge tells him that this is a bad move for Dover. 80% of all of those people who came through his drug court program all had a marijuana issue. Four of them died from the use of marijuana. With the State unable to control and manage the high THC levels that this State has along with the entire country, the death rate is going to continue to rise. Our children are getting marijuana whether they like it or not. One of the reasons why people don’t come down to Dover is because he is convinced that they don’t want to fight the marijuana traffic or other drug traffic as well. This is not good for Dover.

Dr. Jones stated that she wanted to thank our consultant for breaking this down for her because the presentation helped her to understand more of what was presented and helped her to see some things that she did not see. The other thing that she thought of during the whole presentation is we protect our kids from cigarette smoke in restaurants, schools, and wherever we go. As Mrs. Christiansen indicated and we all know, she can’t tell you how many times she has almost had a contact high. That is not the reason that she voted against it. She just thinks there are some things that need to be cleaned up.

Mrs. Welsh stated that the presenter did a fantastic job in itemizing the situation for us and giving us good information as to what exactly was being covered by all of these amendments. It was great to see Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend again.

Mr. Roach stated that he definitely appreciated the presentation but he also just wants to put it in a perspective that again, it’s legal in the State. By us preventing it from here, we are not increasing the chances of us “protecting our kids”. Because again, if it’s legal in the State, now you are increasing their chance of having to go out of the City to be able to purchase it. This decreases the chances of the things that everybody is saying that they want to prevent like driving under the influence of THC and things of that nature rather than going two minutes up the street for recreational use. If you want to do it, you are going to access it regardless of whether you prohibit it or restrict it from the City. It is not stopping. It is a legal action in the State. Again, he understands everybody’s thought process and he respects everybody on this Commission but he thinks that it is counterproductive in regards to the mindset of wanting to protect people. Again, you can get cigarettes at age 18. He doesn’t like second-hand smoke and smelling like cigarettes no more than smelling like marijuana but people are allowed to smoke in certain places. That’s the reason why there are restrictions, and the prohibitions are going to be at certain places. He just really feels as though, again, like alcohol; kids are not supposed to drink until they are 21 years old, but they do it anyway. We can do whatever we can to try to “protect our children” by putting this bubble around Dover but if it’s a State legalized substance, there is Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 20 of 21

Página 99

Item #3.

no stopping it from getting here anyway. To be able to have it to at least where it is being able to be purchased somewhere locally and manufactured locally so therefore, you have safeguards and things of that nature to be put in place for our kids to be protected. If our children want to use it, they are going to use it regardless because it is legal in the State.

Mr. Witham stated that he thinks they all respect each other’s opinions. He thinks that as long as the State is putting a 15% tax on marijuana, marijuana is always going to be cheaper if you buy it from a drug dealer on the street. So, he doesn’t think it’s going to change any life at all just to legalize it.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the Commissioner’s actions tonight will be summarized in a Recommendation Report on those Ordinances that they will transmit to City Council. City Council will take up these two Ordinances at their December 9, 2024 meeting. They have their own public hearing and final action regarding those Ordinances.

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 21 of 21

Página 100

Item #3.

FINAL READING

City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-29

1BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN
2COUNCIL MET:
3
4 That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 19 – Manufacturing Zone
5 (M) be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
6
7Section 19. – Manufacturing Zone (M).
8
9 19.1 Uses permitted. No building or premises shall be used, and no building or part of a building
10 shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any
11 purpose, except the following, and in accordance with performance standards procedure as set
12 forth in article 5, section 8 and subject to the site development plan approval as set forth in article
1310, section 2:
14
1519.17 Railroad yards, sidings, and storage facilities.
16
17 19.18 Marijuana cultivation facilities, marijuana manufacturing facilities, and
18 marijuana testing facilities subject to the requirements outlined in article 5,
19section 24.
20
2119.18 19.19 Accessory uses:
22
23 (a) On-site offices, clinics, food service facilities, recreation facilities and child day care
24 services collocated within the permitted use and limited to exclusive use by employees,
25 and such other accessory uses and structures clearly incidental to, and customary to and
26associated with the permitted use.
27 (b) The following uses may be permitted as conditional uses if approved by the planning
28 commission in accordance with the provisions and procedures set forth in article 10,
29section 1 and any specified requirements set forth below:
30
31 (1) Associated retail uses in conjunction with and accessory to a permitted use,
32 provided that the associated retail uses do not occupy more than 30 percent of
33 the gross floor area of the building or group of buildings on a lot. Parking shall
34 be provided at a rate of one parking space per 300 square feet of retail space for
35 the exclusive use of retail customers in addition to the bulk parking requirements
36of this zoning district for a particular use.
37

Página 101

Item #3.

38 (2) Outside storage which is incidental to the primary uses on the lot, within a 39 completely enclosed and secure area appropriately screened from public view

40and not in any required setback from property lines.
41
42BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
43
44 That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 20 – Industrial Park
45 Manufacturing Zone (IPM) be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
46
47Section 20. – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM).
48
49 20.1 Uses permitted. No building or premises shall be used and no building or part of a building
50 shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any
51 purpose, except the following, and in accordance with performance standards procedure as set
52 forth in article 5, section 8, and subject to site development plan approval as set forth in article 10,
53section 2:
54
55 20.19 Marijuana cultivation facilities, marijuana manufacturing facilities, and
56 marijuana testing facilities, subject to the requirements outlined in Article 5,
57Section 24.
58
59BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
60
61 That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 23 – Agricultural Zone (A)
62 be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
63
64Section 23 - Agricultural Zone (A).
65
66 23.1 Uses Permitted. In an agricultural zone (A), no land or building shall be used and no building
67 or part of a building shall be erected or altered which is arranged, intended or designed to be used,
68in whole or in part, for any uses except the following:
69
70 23.17 Marijuana cultivation facilities, subject to the requirements outlined in Article
715, Section 24.
72
73BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
74
75 That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, be amended by inserting the
76text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
77
78Section 24. Marijuana Related Businesses.
79
80 24.1 Purpose. The purpose of this section is to protect public health and safety by
81 applying standards under which marijuana related businesses may operate
82within the City of Dover, Delaware.
83

Página 102

Item #3.

84 24.2 A compassion center is classified as retail use and is permitted in all commercial

85zones where retail uses are permitted.
86
87 24.3 Where permitted in accordance with Article 3, marijuana cultivation facilities
88are subject to the following restrictions:
89
90 24.31 The building footprint within which a marijuana cultivation facility is to
91 be located shall be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, and any
92 private or public K-12 school, hospital, college or university, child day care
93 center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment
94facility.
95
96 24.32 All marijuana cultivation facilities shall install odor control technology,
97 as necessary, to control ventilation at the establishment in such a manner that
98 no odor from cannabis products can be detected outside the building on the
99 same property or on adjacent properties or in public rights-of-way, or within
100 any other unit located within the same building. The facility owner/operator
101 shall properly maintain all odor mitigation equipment to ensure maximum
102 efficiency. An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied
103 by a certification by a Professional Engineer, Certified Industrial Hygienist, or
104 other equivalently qualified professional that proposed odor control measures
105 will effectively eliminate outdoor odors associated with the cultivation of
106marijuana.
107
108 24.33 An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a
109 photocopy of a valid license as required by Chapter 13, Title 4 of the Delaware
110State Code.
111
112 24.34 All building openings, entries and windows shall be located, covered or
113 screened in such a manner as to prevent a view into the interior from any public
114or semipublic area.
115
116 24.35 The applicant is responsible for complying with the Code of Ordinances
117 of the City of Dover, Delaware including all provisions in Chapter 110, Article
118II, Sec. 110-31 and Chapter 110, Article III, Sec. 110-63.
119
120 24.36 The applicant is responsible for all costs associated with infrastructure
121 upgrades, alterations, changes, or extensions required to provide adequate
122 water, wastewater, and electric utility service, including off-site upgrades
123 required to support the demand for water, wastewater, and electric utility
124service.
125
12624.4 Where permitted in accordance with Article 3, marijuana product
127manufacturing facilities are subject to the following restrictions:
128
129 24.41 The building footprint within which a marijuana product manufacturing

Página 103

Item #3.

130 facility is to be located shall be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, 131 and from the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, hospital, college or 132 university, child day care center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse

133disorder treatment facility.
134
135 24.42 All marijuana product manufacturing facilities shall install odor control
136 technology, as necessary, to control ventilation at the establishment in such a
137manner that no odor from cannabis products can be detected outside the
138 building on the same property or on adjacent properties or in public rights-of-
139 way, or within any other unit located within the same building. The facility
140 owner/operator shall properly maintain all odor mitigation equipment to
141 ensure maximum efficiency. An application for a certificate of occupancy shall
142 be accompanied by a certification by a Professional Engineer, Certified
143 Industrial Hygienist, or other equivalently qualified professional that proposed
144 odor control measures will effectively eliminate outdoor odors associated with
145the manufacturing of marijuana.
146
147 24.43 An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a
148 photocopy of a valid license as required by Chapter 13, Title 4 of the Delaware
149State Code.
150
151 24.44 All building openings, entries, and windows shall be located, covered, or
152 screened in such a manner as to prevent a view into the interior from any public
153or semipublic area.
154
155 24.45 The applicant is responsible for complying with the Code of Ordinances
156 of the City of Dover, Delaware including all provisions in Chapter 110, Article
157II, Sec. 110-31 and Chapter 110, Article III, Sec. 110-63.
158
159 24.46 The applicant is responsible for all costs associated with infrastructure
160 upgrades, alterations, changes, or extensions required to provide adequate
161 water, wastewater, and electric utility service, including off-site upgrades
162 required to support the demand for water, wastewater, and electric utility
163service.
164
165 24.5 Where permitted in accordance with Article 3, marijuana testing facilities are
166subject to the following restrictions:
167 24.51 The building footprint upon which a marijuana testing facility is to be
168 located shall be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, and from the
169 lot line of any private or public K-12 school, hospital, child day care center, or
170 State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facility.
171
172 24.52 An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a
173 photocopy of a valid license as required by Chapter 13, Title 4 of the Delaware
174State Code.
175

Página 104

Item #3.

176BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
177
178 That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 12 – Definitions, be amended by inserting the text indicated in
179bold, blue font in proper alphabetical order as follows:
180
181Article 12. – Definitions.
182
183 Compassion center means an entity registered pursuant to § 4914A of Title 16 of the
184 Delaware State Code that acquires, possesses, sells, supplies, or dispenses marijuana,
185 paraphernalia, or related supplies and educational materials to registered qualifying
186 patients who have designated the dispenser to cultivate marijuana for their medical use and
187the registered designated caregivers of these patients.
188
189 Marijuana cultivation facility or cultivation facility means an entity licensed by the
190 State of Delaware to cultivate, prepare, and package marijuana and sell marijuana to retail
191 marijuana stores, to marijuana product manufacturing facilities, and to other marijuana
192 cultivation facilities, but not to consumers. A marijuana cultivation facility may not produce
193 marijuana concentrates, tinctures, extracts, or other marijuana products.
194
195 Marijuana product manufacturing facility means an entity licensed by the State of
196 Delaware to: purchase marijuana; manufacture, prepare, and package marijuana products;
197 and sell marijuana and marijuana products to other marijuana product manufacturing
198facilities and retail marijuana stores, but not to consumers.
199
200 Marijuana testing facility means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to test
201marijuana for potency and contaminants.
202
203
204ADOPTED: *
205
206
207SYNOPSIS
208 This ordinance amends Appendix B- Zoning of the Dover Code by adding definitions of
209 marijuana-related businesses (with the exception of retail stores), allowing these businesses to
210 operate as permitted uses in certain zones, and adding supplementary regulations, by which these
211businesses must abide.
212
213(SPONSORS: ANDERSON and NEIL)
214
215Action History
21612/09/2024 – Scheduled for Public Hearing/First Reading – City Council
21711/18/2024 - Public Hearing - Planning Commission
218 10/28/2024 – First Reading – City Council (Ordinance number changed from #2024-25A to
219#2024-29)
220 10/15/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and
221Administration Committee (Split into 25A)

Página 105

Item #3.

222 09/24/2024 – Council Committee of the Whole / Legislative, Finance and Administration

223Committee
224 08/05/2024 – Deferred from 06/11/2024 – Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration
225Committee (Split into two parts)
226 06/11/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/Legislative, Finance, and
227Administration Committee.

Página 106

Item #4.

PETITIONS TO AMEND TEXT of Zoning Ordinance Public Hearing Before the Dover City Council December 9, 2024 Recommendations from the Planning Commission Meeting Session 2 of November 18, 2024 With Staff and Development Advisory Committee Review

Proposed Changes: Text Amendments to the following: • Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B: Zoning (Zoning Ordinance) o Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 19 – Manufacturing Zone (M) o Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 20 – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM) o Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 23 – Agricultural Zone (A) o Article 3 - District Regulations, Section 16 – Highway Commercial Zone (C-4) o Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations (Add Section 24) o Article 12 – Definitions

Summary of Amendments: This is a series of text amendments to the Zoning Ordinance to address the passage of the Marijuana Control Act by the Delaware General Assembly. Under the statute, municipalities can regulate where and how the marijuana-related land uses addressed by the law are permitted within the municipal limits. Municipalities can also prohibit marijuana-related land uses. The proposed Ordinance #2024-29 addresses marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing. The proposed Ordinance #2024-30 addresses marijuana retail stores. Together, the Ordinances would allow marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing facilities in the IPM and M Zones; marijuana cultivation facilities in the A Zone; and marijuana retail stores in the C-4 Zone. They would also add supplementary regulations (Section 24) for the marijuana-related uses in Article 5 and definitions for the marijuana-related uses in Article 12.

File Number: MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Lands Uses and Related Zoning Regulations

Ordinance Numbers: #2024-29
Proposed Ordinance #2024-29 – Amending Appendix B-Zoning,
Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 19 – Manufacturing Zone
(M), Section 20 – Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), Section
23 – Agricultural Zone (A); Article 5 Supplementary Regulations;
Section 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses, Article 12 – Definitions

#2024-30
Proposed Ordinance #2024-30 – Amending Appendix B- Zoning,
Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 16 – Highway Commercial

Página 107

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #4.

Zone (C-4); Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 24 – Marijuana Related Businesses; Article 12 - Definitions

Planning Commission Recommendations: The Text Amendment Application – Ordinance #2024-29 and Ordinance #2024-30 were presented by Planning Office Staff and the Rossi Group (consultant). A Public Hearing was conducted the Planning Commission on November 18, 2024 where three (3) members of the public spoke. The Planning Commission’s motions were to recommend denial of Ordinance #2024-29 (vote 5-4) and to recommend denial of Ordinance #2024-30 (vote 5-4). These votes reflect an intent to prohibit recreational marijuana land uses. See detailed Planning Commission Recommendations beginning on page 6 of this Report and the Draft Meeting Minutes.

To formalize this intent and to codify it into the Zoning Ordinance, see the attached Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-29 and Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-30 which define each marijuana land use and specify that the uses are prohibited.

APPLICATON: MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations as Ordinance #2024-29 and Ordinance #2024-30

These Text Amendment Applications were referred to the Planning Commission as per Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 §5. The Planning Commission is required to provide a Review Report to City Council. The following document and attachments are provided as the Review Report and Planning Commission Recommendation.

  • I.BACKGROUND ON DEVELOPMENT OF TEXT AMENDMENTS

Introduction Recreational marijuana became legal in the state of Delaware on July 5, 2023, when the Delaware Marijuana Control Act went into effect. This means that adults (ages 21+) may legally possess personal use quantities of marijuana in Delaware. Adults may also legally consume marijuana on private property. The Delaware Marijuana Control Act allows municipalities to regulate (including prohibit) land uses relating to cultivation, manufacturing, testing, and retail sale of marijuana within their jurisdiction through local ordinance. The Zoning Ordinance does not currently define or otherwise address the uses regulated under the Marijuana Control Act. The proposed ordinances would provide the framework for the uses established within the Marijuana Control Act in the City of Dover.

Background The Dover City Council Committee of the Whole – Legislative, Finance and Administration Subcommittee (CCW-LF&A) first discussed the Marijuana Control Act and how the City might address the regulated uses at a meeting on September 26, 2023. In a subsequent meeting on April 9, 2024, the CCW-LF&A discussed the matter again and directed the staff to develop an ordinance permitting marijuana cultivation, manufacturing, and testing in the M and IPM Zones and permitting marijuana retail stores in the C-4 Zone, with regulations such as distancing

Página 108

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #4.

requirements and other measures intended to protect neighboring uses from any potential adverse effects of these new uses.

Working with a consultant, the staff developed an ordinance that was presented to the CCW-LF&A on June 11, 2024. In response to public comment, the CCW-LF&A requested that the staff provide additional research. An informational webpage on the topic of Marijuana Regulations was added to the City’s website; see https://www.cityofdover.com/marijuanaregulations . Several of the research and background documents are attached for reference including the Recreational Marijuana White Paper and Marijuana Ordinance Q&A.

In July 2024, the City Council enacted a moratorium on all marijuana-related land uses through December 31, 2024, to ensure that no licenses would be issued for Dover locations while the matter was being deliberated. (See attached Moratorium as Council Resolution #2024-11)

In July 2024, a Survey to assess public opinion on how the City should address marijuana-related uses was made available online, at City buildings, and mailed with all utility bills. Survey respondents generally favored allowing marijuana-related uses in Dover with restrictions. The Summary of City of Dover Marijuana Survey (Report) is attached.

After discussing potential ordinances to address marijuana-related uses in Dover in seven public meetings, on October 15, 2024, CCW-LF&A recommended forwarding draft ordinances to City Council for First Reading. Four Ordinances to address business licensing and zoning of marijuana- related businesses were forwarded to begin the formal review process (identified as Ordinance #2024-24 and #2024-25 for business licensing; #2024-29 and #2024-30 for zoning regulations). First Reading of the Ordinances took place at the City Council meeting on October 28, 2024, at which time City Council set public hearings before the Planning Commission on November 18, 2024, and before the City Council on December 9, 2024.

State of Delaware Regulations and Licenses The Delaware Office of the Marijuana Commissioner (OMC) developed state regulations to govern the new recreational marijuana industry. The regulations were finalized in July 2024 and effective September 2024. The OMC office began accepting license applications on August 19, 2024. The first public license lottery was held by the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner on October 24, 2024. The State expects the first retail marijuana stores to open in spring 2025.

Also in 2024, the Delaware General Assembly passed a bill that allows medical marijuana facilities (compassion centers) to obtain a conversion license to convert to recreational facilities regulated under the Marijuana Control Act. In Dover, there is one compassion center that is retail only. This facility applied for a conversion license through the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner.

Proposed Ordinances Two Ordinances proposed are text amendments to the Zoning Ordinance. These are described below with copies of the Proposed Ordinances attached. Also provided are excerpts from a map series (Map 1, 2, 3, and 4) which depict zoning district locations and the regulations (buffers) as proposed.

Ordinance #2024-29 – (Previously #2024-25A) This proposed Ordinance #2024-29 would permit marijuana cultivation, manufacturing and testing facilities in the Manufacturing (M) and Industrial Park Manufacturing (IPM) zones and would allow marijuana cultivation in the

Página 109

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #4.

Agricultural (A) zone. The proposed Ordinance #2024-29 would classify State-licensed compassion centers as a retail use (consistent with current practice). It would also establish the standards by which such businesses would be required to operate, including: • Confirming that compassion centers (retail only) are permitted in all commercial zones where retail uses are permitted; • Requiring the building footprint for marijuana cultivation facilities or marijuana product manufacturing facilities be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, hospital, college or university, child day care center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facilities; • Requiring that the building footprint of marijuana product testing facilities be at least 750 feet away from any residential zone, the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, hospital, child day care center, or State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facilities; • Requiring that marijuana cultivation facilities and marijuana product manufacturing facilities install odor control technology and that all openings, windows and entryways for such facilities be covered to prevent view into the interior from any public or semipublic area; • Requiring that applicants for marijuana cultivation and marijuana product manufacturing uses comply with the provisions of the water, wastewater and electric handbooks, and that any the cost of utility upgrades required to support the utility demand for these facilities would be the responsibility of the applicant. • The draft ordinance would also establish definitions for the marijuana land uses that are consistent with the State definitions.

Ordinance #2024-30 – (Previously #2024-25B) This proposed Ordinance #2024-30 would permit marijuana retail stores in the Highway Commercial (C-4) zone, establish a definition for “retail marijuana store” consistent with the State regulations, and establish the standards by which such businesses would be required to operate, including: • Requiring that the building footprint for retail marijuana stores be at least 500 feet away from the lot line of any private or public K-12 school, child daycare center, State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder treatment facility, hospital, college, or university and at least 250 feet from any residential zone; • Requiring that the building footprint for a retail marijuana store be at least one (1) mile from the lot line of any other marijuana retail store within the City of Dover; • Requiring that that all openings, windows and entryways for retail marijuana stores be covered to prevent view into the interior from any public or semipublic area; • Allowing for a compassion center licensed by the State before January 1, 2024, to be permitted to convert to a retail marijuana store exempt from the distancing requirement. • The draft ordinance would also establish definitions for the marijuana land uses that are consistent with the State definitions.

Other Ordinances In addition to these two proposed ordinances related to zoning/land use for recreational marijuana facilities there are two companion ordinances related to business licensing. Proposed Ordinances #2024-24 and #2024-25 are proposed amendments to the Dover Code of Ordinances to establish the business license fees for marijuana cultivation, manufacturing, and test facilities, marijuana retail stores, and compassion centers. These are not subject to review by the Planning Commission as they do not amend the Zoning Ordinance.

Página 110

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #4.

II. TEXT AMENDMENT REVIEW PROCESS

Because these are Text Amendments proposed to the Zoning Ordinance, a Public Hearing and Recommendation by the Planning Commission is required. This review process began when the proposed Ordinance was submitted to the City Council for First Reading on October 28, 2024. The City Council has referred Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 to the Planning Commission for a Public Hearing and consideration on November 18, 2024 (Planning Commission SESSION 2). Then it is scheduled for Final Reading, Public Hearing and Final Action by Council on December 9, 2024. At the meeting the City Council may act to adopt the whole Ordinances, to reject it, or to adopt the Ordinances with amendments. Legal Advertisements were published in the Daily State News on Sunday, November 3, 2024 giving notice and participation information for the Public Hearings as scheduled.

III. RECOMMENDATION OF PLANNING STAFF:

Review and Recommendations: As part of the process outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the City Planner must evaluate the following factors when preparing a report on the text amendment request:

Article 10 § 5.22 City planner report. For each proposed zoning text amendment, the city planner shall issue a report to the planning commission and city council, including comments from other reviewing agencies, that evaluates the following factors:

(A) Whether such change is consistent with the aims and principles embodied in the ordinance as to the particular zones concerned; and;

(B) Whether proposed amendment is consistent with the aims of the comprehensive plan of the city.

The City of Dover developed the subject Ordinances in response to the State’s legalization of recreational marijuana through the Delaware Marijuana Control Act. In developing the Ordinances, the principles and aims of the Zoning Ordinance and the 2019 Comprehensive Plan were considered.

Marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing are consistent with the types of uses permitted withing the M (Manufacturing Zone) and IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone) Zones, as these zones permit manufacturing and industrial processing of goods and research and testing labs. Marijuana Cultivation is consistent with other uses permitted within the A (Agricultural Zone), including crop harvesting. Marijuana retail stores are consistent with other permitted uses in the C-4 Zone including retail, and the C-4 Zone is intended for high-intensity, auto-dependent uses. Additionally, in response to concerns regarding this new category of uses, the Ordinances provide distancing requirements from incompatible uses and other protections that municipalities are allowed to control (time and place).

The 2019 Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 12: Land Development Plan discusses goals for various land use types (Land Use Categories). Relative to the proposed Ordinances, the following sections apply. In relation to Commercial – High Intensity Areas, specifically US Route 13/DuPont Highway and Bay Road Corridors, the Plan’s recommendation states (page 12-13):

The US Route 13/DuPont Highway and Bay Road corridors are dominated by highway focused commercial development, as free-standing buildings, strip commercial centers, and formal shopping centers and mall spaces. For the most part, the Land

Página 111

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #4.

Development Plan proposes to continue US Route 13/DuPont Highway and Bay Road as the major commercial corridors in Central Delaware.

In relation to Employment Centers, the Plan includes the following policy (page 12-17):

Provide sufficient land area for industrial purposes to enable the expansion of existing industries, the establishment of new facilities, and revitalization of underutilized older industrial sites.

The Planning Office finds that the proposed Ordinances are consistent with the aims and principles of the Zoning Ordinance and the zones specifically addressed, as well as with the aims of the 2019 Comprehensive Plan.

Additionally, the following advisory items are noted.

  • 1)The Planning Office provided an opportunity to Development Advisory Committee (DAC) members to comment on the proposed Text Amendments at their meetings on October 30, 2024 and November 6, 2024. Several Departments/Agencies which participate in the DAC process provide comments of “no objection” with regard to the proposed Text Amendments. It is noted that some of these Departments participated in the research into the development of the proposed ordinances.
  • 2)The Proposed Ordinances are also subject to Legal Review by the City Solicitor, which may identify additional clarifications or corrections.
  • 3)The approval of these Text Amendments does not authorize the establishment of the regulated uses at any specific location. Prior to the establishment of a use, a State license through the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner and the appropriate applications for site development activity plan review, Building Permits, and other construction activity Permits, Business and Occupancy Licensing, etc. of the City of Dover are required.

IV. PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEW FOR RECOMMENDATION

This is a request for a zoning text amendment which revises the text in the Zoning Ordinance. The Planning Commission as part of their public hearing and review process will provide a recommendation on the zoning text amendment requests to City Council. As part of the process outlined in Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5, the Planning Commission must evaluate the following factors when considering the request:

Article 10 § 5.23 Report of the planning commission. Regarding each proposed amendment to the ordinance text, the planning commission shall provide a report to the city council stating a recommended action with regards to the proposed amendment, along with the commission's evaluation of the following factors:

(A) Whether such change is consistent with the aims and principles embodied in the ordinance as to the particular zones concerned; and

(B) Whether such proposed amendment is consistent with the aims of the comprehensive plan of the city.

Página 112

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #4.

A Recommendation Report from the Planning Commission will be forwarded to the City Council for their consideration of the Text Amendment Applications. This document and its attachments make up the Recommendation Report.

RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION:

At the Hybrid (In-Person and Virtual) Planning Commission Meeting Session 2 of November 18, 2024, the Text Amendment Application MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations (Ordinance #2024-29 and Ordinance #2024-30) was represented by Planning Staff and Ann Marie Townshend of the Rossi Group (the City’s Project Consultant). During the Public Hearing, three (3) members of the public spoke and no written comments for the meeting were received.

A presentation on the background and provisions of the Proposed Ordinances was given (see PowerPoint presentation slides). Then following the Public Hearing, the Planning Commission posed questions and discussed the proposed text amendments.

After a motion to recommend approval of Ordinance #2024-29 establishing provisions related to marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion center uses and with an amendment to add a distancing requirement of 750 feet from courthouses, the motion failed (vote 4 in favor and 5 against). See Meeting Minutes for reasons given.

The Planning Commission’s follow-up motion recommended to deny Ordinance #2024-29 related to marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion center uses and resulted in a vote of 5-4 (vote 5 in favor of denial and 4 against). See Meeting Minutes for reasons given. *

The Planning Commission’s motion recommended to deny Ordinance #2024-30 related to retail marijuana store uses and provisions for compassion center conversions and resulted in a vote of 5-4 (vote 5 in favor of denial and 4 against). See Meeting Minutes for reasons given. *

*With the recommendations to deny (not adopt) Ordinance #2024-29 and to deny (not adopt) Ordinance #2024-30 related to Recreational Marijuana Land Uses, the intent of the Planning Commission vote is to prohibit such land uses in the City of Dover, DE. To formalize this intent and to codify it into the Zoning Ordinance, see the attached Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-29 and Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-30 which define each marijuana land use and specify that the uses are prohibited.

See also the included excerpt of the DRAFT Meeting Minutes of the November 18, 2024 Planning Commission Meeting Session 2. The comments received from the other member agencies of the Development Advisory Committee (D.A.C.) are also provided.

Attachments: • Development Advisory Committee Comments: City of Dover Department of Public Works and Department of Water & Wastewater, Electric Department, Dover Kent County MPO

Reference Documents provided to the Planning Commission: • Council Resolution #2024-11 for Moratorium on Recreational Marijuana Related Uses • Recreational Marijuana White Paper (updated September 9, 2024)

Página 113

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Marijuana Related Uses: Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 Planning Commission Recommendation Report from November 18, 2024 (Meeting Session 2) Item #4.

  • •Marijuana Ordinance Q&A
  • •Summary of City of Dover Marijuana Survey (Report)
  • •Maps 1-4 (Excerpt of Map Series):
  • •Map 1 - Based on Ordinance #2024-29 (zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing) as proposed
  • •Map 2 - Based on Ordinance #2024-30 (zoning for retail) as proposed
  • •Map 3 – Zoning: A, IPM, M parcels
  • •Map 4 – Zoning: C-4 parcels

Planning Commission Meeting Session 2 of November 18, 2024: • Presentation (PowerPoint slides) to Planning Commission at Meeting Session 2 on November 18, 2024 • Excerpt of DRAFT Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of Meeting Session 2 on November 18, 2024

Planning Commission Substitute Ordinances (to prohibit uses): • Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-29 (Zoning Regulations for Cultivation, Manufacturing, and Testing Marijuana Facilities and Compassion Centers) to define marijuana cultivation facility, marijuana product manufacturing facility, and marijuana testing facility and to prohibit such uses

  • •Planning Commission Substitute to Ordinance #2024-30 (Zoning Regulations for Retail Marijuana Stores) to define and prohibit the retail marijuana store use

Proposed Ordinances for Public Hearing and Final Action by City Council: • Proposed Ordinance #2024-29 (Zoning Regulations for Cultivation, Manufacturing, and Testing Marijuana Facilities and Compassion Centers)

  • •Proposed Ordinance #2024-30 (Zoning Regulations for Retail Marijuana Stores and Compassion Centers)

Página 114

Item #4.

CITY OF DOVER PLANNING COMMISSION

November 18, 2024
Excerpt from Meeting Minutes – Draft

The Meeting Session 2 of the City of Dover Planning Commission was held on Monday, November 18, 2024, at 7:00 PM as an In-Person Meeting and also using the phone/videoconferencing system Webex. The Meeting Session 2 was conducted with Chair Mr. Witham presiding. Members present were Mr. Michael Lewis, Mr. Roach (virtual), Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Maucher (virtual), Mr. Baldwin, Dr. Jones, Mr. Reaves (virtual), Mrs. Welsh (virtual), and Mr. Witham.

Staff members present were Mrs. Dawn Melson-Williams, Ms. Sharon Duca, Mrs. Kristen Mullaney, and Mr. Jason Lyon (virtual).

NEW APPLICATIONS

MI-24-09 Text Amendments: Recreational Marijuana Land Uses and Related Zoning Regulations - Public Hearing and Review for Recommendation to City Council of a series of Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance for establish provisions for recreational marijuana land uses and related zoning regulations.

  • A.Ordinance #2024-29: Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning: Article 3 - District Regulations Section 19 - Manufacturing Zone (M), Section 20 - Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone (IPM), and Section 23 - Agricultural Zone (A); Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations adding new Section 24 - Marijuana Related Businesses; and Article 12 - Definitions. These amendments add definitions for marijuana related businesses, allow these business types to operate as permitted uses within certain zones, and add supplementary regulations by which these businesses must abide.
  • B.Ordinance #2024-30: Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for retail marijuana stores and provisions for compassion center conversions by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning: Article 3 - District Regulations Section 16 - Highway Commercial Zone (C-4); Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations adding new Section 24 - Marijuana Related Businesses; and Article 12 – Definitions. These amendments add the definition of retail marijuana stores and allow recreational marijuana stores to operate as permitted uses in the C-4 zone and add supplementary regulations by which these businesses must abide.

Representative: Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Rossi Group and Planning Staff

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that this evening there are two Text Amendments that are here before the Planning Commission. In regards to them, the Planning Commission will be making a recommendation. That recommendation goes onto City Council as City Council has their own public hearing and action scheduled for their December 9, 2024 meeting in regards to these two Ordinances. Because they are Ordinances that amend the Zoning Ordinance, that’s why they are Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 1 of 21

Página 115

Item #4.

here in front of the Planning Commission. Ordinance #2024-29 focuses on the marijuana cultivation, product manufacturing, and testing and where those marijuana land uses would be permitted in municipal city limits of Dover. The other Ordinance #2024-30 focuses on recreational marijuana retail stores and likewise, the provisions to allow that like when and where in the City of Dover. For this effort to focus on recreational marijuana land uses and zoning provisions, the City did retain consultant services given the staffing levels over the last year in the Planning Office and she is going to allow the consultant to really give this presentation. They are much better versed in what happened and how we got to this point here. Your Planning Commission meeting packet includes a narrative report with comments from our Development Advisory Committee members, copies of each of the Ordinances, and then a number of other reference documents.

Mrs. Townshend stated that she would start by giving an overview of what we are going to be talking about. There is a lot of ground to cover. We will talk first about the Marijuana Control Act: what it does, what it allows municipalities to do, and what the City’s options are under this Act. We will talk about the timeline to date. There was a public survey that was available online. It was also mailed with utility bills and available in paper form at City buildings. We will share some of the takeaways. She knows your packet includes the detailed Survey Report. In the interest of time, we will kind of hit the major takeaways from that and then we will talk about the Draft Ordinances and the next steps.

Basically, during the 152nd General Assembly, which was in 2023, the Legislature approved two bills: House Bill 1 and House Bill 2. House Bill 1 decriminalizes personal use quantities of marijuana and then House Bill 2 creates a framework for a legal recreational marijuana industry in Delaware with regulations and taxation that is similar to how the State regulates alcohol. Under House Bill 1, adults 21 and over may share personal use quantities of marijuana; they may possess, use, display, purchase, and transport personal use quantities of marijuana. They may transport marijuana and marijuana accessories in a vehicle if the items are in a closed container, not readily accessible to anyone in the vehicle. So, you cannot use it in a vehicle. Also, under what individuals cannot do is that individuals may not sell marijuana. They may not consume marijuana inside of a moving vehicle or drive under the influence of marijuana. You cannot transport marijuana over state lines. You cannot consume marijuana in areas that are accessible to the public; so that would be streets, sidewalks, restaurants, malls or any place that is open to the public. So, it’s not just an open space but places that are open to the public. People that are under 21 cannot use recreational marijuana. House Bill 2 adds Chapter 13 to Title 4 of the Delaware Code. Basically, this establishes the role of the Marijuana Commissioner and charges the Marijuana Commissioner with establishing a licensing process and regulations and penalties for the industry. It also establishes a 15% tax for recreational marijuana and creates the Marijuana Regulation Fund. The rules under this law and under the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner are enforced by the Division of Alcohol and Tobacco. The Office of the Marijuana Commissioner is located within the Department of Safety and Homeland Security. A State issued license is required for growing, manufacturing, testing, or selling marijuana. All growing facilities must be indoors; no outdoor cultivation is allowed. Marijuana sales are restricted to the same days and times as liquor sales; so, there are certain days of the year where marijuana sales, just like liquor stores are closed, marijuana sales are not allowed on those days either. Marijuana retail establishments will not be allowed to sell online or offer delivery. They will not be able to sell alcohol, tobacco, or food. No consumption of marijuana products is permitted on the premises of any marijuana establishments and that includes all of the Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 2 of 21

Página 116

Item #4.

establishments whether it’s the cultivation facilities, the retail, the manufacturing, or the testing. Employers still have the freedom to manage the terms of employment, policies and discipline procedures; so, not all employers are required to allow employees to use marijuana. Those in charge of a property can prohibit or somehow restrict marijuana use on their properties. That would mean that a landlord for instance, could say that it’s not allowed in their building. House Bill 2 does specifically mention what municipalities can and cannot do. House Bill 1 legalizes recreational marijuana; therefore, that preempts the City’s ability to be able to say it’s not allowed in municipal limits. We are also at the municipal level, preempted from creating a special tax or fee and that has been one of the things that have come up in many municipalities. She thinks municipalities would be more receptive if they could get some revenue from it, but the State does prohibit that. It can be licensed in the same manner as other business licenses that are issued. Similar to the alcohol regulations, the public will get notice and have the opportunity to comment at the State level before a license is issued for a specific location.

So, what can we do at the municipal level? One of the options is, and many municipalities in the State of done this, municipalities can prohibit the operation of marijuana establishments in their jurisdictions. You have seen this particularly in Sussex County with the coastal towns; most of them have passed something to say all of these uses are prohibited. The other thing that municipalities can do is regulate the time, place and manner in which the establishments operate. So, what does that mean? You can set hours; you can set standards. You will see when we get into some of the things that we have put into these draft ordinances, we have distancing requirements. You can do things at the municipal level to restrict how, where, and when these uses take place. Again, through the State regulatory process, residents do have the opportunity to comment before licenses are issued for a specific location.

Looking at the timeline to date: this was first discussed by the City Council Committee of the Whole back in September 2023 and there were three specific Committee meetings this year in 2024 where the Council Committee of the Whole discussed options for how the City could deal with it. In July 2024, the City passed a Moratorium basically to provide time for the City to thoughtfully address the issue and not be put in a situation where the clock runs out and a license is issued because we don’t have anything in effect. So basically, in July, the Moratorium was put in place and that will last until the end of the year. Also in July, the City launched a public survey. They started online and then it was at a Council of the Committee of the Whole Meeting where they said they wanted to make sure that it was as widely available as possible. So, paper copies were made available at City Buildings and they were mailed with every utility bill. The Survey remained open until the end of August. On August 5, 2024, the Legislative, Finance and Administration Committee had a special meeting to talk about options and to ask questions. At that point, they knew they weren’t going to make any decisions until after the Survey was done but they were able to have a little more of an exchange. On August 19, 2024, the Office of the Marijuana Commissioner started accepting applications for their lottery. On September 11, 2024, the Marijuana Control Act Regulations went into effect officially. Also, at the end of September and beginning of October, City Council Committee of the Whole: Legislative, Finance and Administration Subcommittee continued discussion and ultimately took action to recommend a set of Ordinances to City Council at their meeting on October 8, 2024. The First Reading was on October 28, 2024 and that was when the referral was made to the Planning Commission. Over the course of the last year, there have been nine (9) public meetings where this has been discussed. This will be the tenth meeting. There was a public Survey where they received 1,408 online responses and 820 paper responses for a total of 2,228 responses in general. Again, the Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 3 of 21

Página 117

Item #4.

Moratorium remains in place until the end of December. Some of the themes and trends that we saw on this Survey are that a majority of 58% of the people who responded in favor of allowing recreational marijuana businesses within the City. There was also support for distancing from incompatible uses. The uses that were really at the top of that list were schools, daycares and rehabilitation centers. The biggest concerns that were cited by over 1,000 people out of 2,228 were concerns about odor and crime. The biggest potential benefits, again cited by over 1,000 of the people who responded, were economic growth and better regulation of marijuana products and increased licensing revenue. Again, keeping in mind, the licensing revenue is not a big financial boom for the town because we are limited through State law by how much it can be licensed in terms that we can’t impose a higher license fee than we would on similar uses. In the Ordinance development, basically the City can prohibit all of the uses. That is an option and many municipalities have done that. The City can permit it similar as to how alcohol or any other use is permitted without any special restrictions. The path that City Council ultimately chose was to develop Ordinances that permit with restrictions. Again, as we get into the Ordinances you will see that they have drafted in things to work to protect the surrounding communities from any external negative effects.

The first Ordinance #2024-29 addresses marijuana cultivation, manufacturing and testing facilities. It would permit these as permitted uses in the M (Manufacturing Zone) and IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone) and additionally it would allow marijuana cultivation facilities as a permitted use in the A (Agricultural Zone). It would also include Supplementary Regulations which we will discuss in a second and it adds definitions for compassion center, marijuana cultivation facility, marijuana manufacturing facility, and marijuana testing facility.

For the Supplementary Regulations: one, it clarifies that a “compassion center” is classified as retail use. That is something that has been in place through policy and that the “compassion center” that is here was treated as a retail use similar to a pharmacy; so, that is memorialized in this. The real Supplementary Regulations that are there in order to protect the community are that the building footprint of a cultivation or manufacturing facility would be required to be 750 feet minimum from residential zones, K-12 schools, hospitals, colleges and universities, child daycare centers, and substance abuse disorder treatment facilities. The Supplementary Regulations would also require odor control technologies, as do the State regulations. But again, this just gives you that kind of double layer of regulation on that. It would require that openings be screened and windows be covered so that the inside cannot be viewed from the outside. And it would require compliance with the utility handbooks and the applicant would be responsible for upgrade costs. This issue is really an issue with cultivation. Cultivation utilizes a lot of water. It utilizes a lot of electricity. Anybody initiating a land use needs to comply with the utility handbooks anyway but it was because these could be big utility users. They decided that it was important to put that in there so that there’s not any question. Marijuana testing facilities would be required to be 750 feet away from residential zones, K-12 schools, hospitals, child daycare centers, and substance abuse disorder treatment facilities. What is not on that list is colleges and universities and part of that is because laboratories are often a use that’s on a university campus and it could be that there is some sort of interest in one of the universities or colleges to do something. The testing for of all of the uses has the least external effects. If you look at the Map, basically what you see is there are very few places where the manufacturing, cultivation, and testing would be allowed. Basically, anything that has one of those icons with a circle around it has the distance requirement and all of that gray shading is a distancing requirement. So, you have a portion of maybe the Enterprise Business Park and some of the industrial manufacturing Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 4 of 21

Página 118

Item #4.

land around the Base and the stuff around Kraft General Foods which at this point is all utilized. Basically, that’s what you are left with. She is going to explain the agricultural from a zoning perspective, but also then from a practical perspective because we did talk to the State about this. One, cultivation again, has to happen indoors. What the State is seeing is where there is cultivation; there is also the product manufacturing. So, you are seeing a lot of vertically integrated businesses and you see that in Milford and Newark where they have the cultivation facilities are also processing and manufacturing and, in some cases, they are also selling. Basically, that is the business model that seems to be out there and that would not be able to take place in the Agricultural Zone land because the only thing that would be allowed is the cultivation. But again, since we are not 100% sure how the business is going to unfold, there was a sense that because growing is an agricultural use that it should be allowed in that zone. Again, she thinks the likelihood is not really there. Then you have a whole other level of complexity if you get into agricultural land that is in the State’s Agriculture Preservation Program because the uses that are allowed and then there is also in some cases, federal money in the easements which adds another challenge. From a practical perspective, it’s unlikely that any of these will be in the Agricultural Zone but the Ordinance is drafted in a way that would allow the cultivation use.

The next Ordinance #2024-30 is specific to retail marijuana stores. One of the things that they decided in working with the City Administration is that breaking them into two ordinances keeps the retail which seems to have a lot more concern about it from what we heard, keeping that in a separate ordinance so that they are not dependent on each other. That’s why it’s in two separate ordinances. Basically, this would permit the retail marijuana stores in the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). So, the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) is only on Route 13 and Bay Road. It also includes Supplementary Regulations that include that the building footprint would need to be at least 500 feet away from K-12 schools, child daycare centers, substance abuse disorder treatment facilities, and hospitals and then 250 feet away from residential zones and colleges and universities. Additionally, there is language that would require that the building footprint be at least 1 mile away from other marijuana retail establishments or marijuana retail stores in the City. So that would prevent any grouping of marijuana retail stores near each other. Again, similar to with the other uses, it would require that openings and windows be covered. The last thing is that it would allow licensed compassion centers to obtain a conversion license and operate without meeting the distancing requirements. There is currently one compassion center in the City and it does not meet any of the distance requirements. This was something that as it was discussed at the Council Committee of the Whole, there was interest in making sure that establishment could receive a conversion license. The other thing is that is adds a definition of a “retail marijuana store.”

With that, we look at the Map and C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) is in red on that map. With the buffering, there are just a few places. A marijuana leaf shows where the current compassion center is located. So, if that compassion center received a conversion license at that location and became a retail marijuana store, we show in that light green strip as a mile in either direction. Basically, you take that out and you take the buffering from other uses and there might be some place just at the north end of town and then maybe right along Bay Road or at the south end of town. There is not a lot of area so it is not something that is really going to proliferate. There were some responses in the survey for the question “where else would it make sense?” Some people said anywhere liquor stores are allowed. Some people said nowhere. The current Ordinance Draft does not include anything along the Route 8 Corridor. It restricts it only to Route 13 and Bay Road. Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 5 of 21

Página 119

Item #4.

Tonight, we are here for the Planning Commission Public Hearing and then the City Council has set the Public Hearing and Final Reading before them at their December 9, 2024 meeting and on December 31, 2024 the Moratorium expires. One thing they want to make sure you understand and that the City Council understands also is that failure to have an Ordinance in place basically defaults to what the underlying use is. So, if the Zoning Ordinance doesn’t address marijuana retail stores, then basically you are looking at where retail stores are allowed. You are looking at the type of use not the category because retail in the Code doesn’t address what you are selling. So, without having that layer to say these are how we are dealing with the marijuana uses, it really will fall down to that base use below it. This is why with the Moratorium expiring, they have been working really hard to try to make sure that there is something in place before the end of the year. As for the Planning Commission, you will have your Public Hearing and you can obviously propose amendments. You could recommend to not approve any of these. You could recommend to scrap it all and prohibit. Basically, the motion you make is a recommendation to City Council. But if there are specific amendments, you could make that as well.

Mrs. Denney asked Mrs. Townshend to help her understand the “compassion centers.” When she reads this, her assumption is that it’s a facility where people who are prescribed by professionals, the use of marijuana. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated yes, but right now a “compassion center” is a medical marijuana facility where you need a medical card to go in and buy any product. Under the State Law, they created a conversion license and basically, they are expecting the compassion centers to convert to the full recreational and medical. They are issuing conversion licenses that would allow the existing establishment to become a recreational establishment. So, the “compassion center” that we have in Dover is only retail. They do not do any cultivation or manufacturing; so, for them to get a conversion license it would convert to a retail establishment for recreational and medical marijuana.

Mrs. Denney stated that realistically if a conversion happens, then what her understanding of what was just said is that if a conversion happens, our Council would have to allow or disallow with recommendations but if the conversion happens, then that is going to be a retail center where if she decided to use marijuana, she could go down there and buy it whether it is prescribed or not. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated yes.

Mrs. Denney stated that that needs to be clear and we all need to really understand that. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that it is in Ordinance #2024-30. Again, from a practical standpoint, she has had several conversations with the Office of Marijuana Commissioner about this and they are expecting that compassion centers will be phased out because the retail marijuana stores will service both. In order for a compassion center to get their conversion license, they have to demonstrate that they can still support that medical need but they are going to do that. What the Commissioner’s Office has said is that once industry is up and running, a business won’t be able to survive as compassion center alone. From a practical perspective, while the law still recognizes the compassion centers, from a practical perspective they will be phased out. In Ordinance #2024-29, the top of Page 2, starting Line 40 it says that “a compassion center licensed by the State of Delaware on or before January 1, 2024 (that date is there to make sure nobody tries to get a compassion center up and running) that obtains a conversion license under the State of Delaware Marijuana Regulations, must comply with the requirements of Article 3 - District Regulations.” This means it has to be permitted in the zone. If it wasn’t permitted in the zone, all bets are off. Also, it “shall be exempt from the distancing Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 6 of 21

Página 120

Item #4.

requirements detailed in Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations.” The conversion of a compassion center to recreational retail would allow the existing compassion center, which we only have one, to be where it is and not meet those distance requirements; but it wouldn’t allow any new.

Mrs. Denney stated that they can all see it on the map but do you happen to know the address of our compassion center? Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that it’s on Jefferic Boulevard but she can’t remember the exact number. It is near Big Lots and Burlington Coat Factory.

Mrs. Denney stated that it is more out on the Route 13 Corridor. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated yes.

Mrs. Denney stated that this is her opinion, but it feels like they shouldn’t be allowing that conversion to happen. The point here is that it is going to be legal and whether she likes it or not, that doesn’t matter. She doesn’t use it but again, being in medicine, she fully understands the need for many people to have access to it. She still thinks that it should be by prescription only because we all know, just like with alcohol, you can say that you can’t drink and drive but how many people are killed in this Country and even in this City because somebody decided not to obey the laws? Frankly, she lives on State Street. She drives down that road and it used to be that people stopped at stop signs and now they just roll through it. It is becoming more and more frequent and to her, it’s ridiculous. She is certainly not going to say “where is the City of Dover Police Department” because they have their hands full. To her, the first thing that would need to be adopted if we were even entertaining some of this would be that we have to find some type of a fine so that we can pay our Police Department to have the extra staffing although it is hard to recruit police officers. Her husband was a Delaware State Trooper and the United States Marshal. She has a stepson who is a Deputy United States Marshal and frankly if one of her grandchildren came to her tomorrow and said this is what they wanted to do to honor Granddad, she would have a heart attack because just like they don’t respect the laws, they don’t respect law enforcers. She is just saying that because we are about to vote on how we feel about allowing these things to happen.

Dr. Jones asked if there was a reason why houses of faith were not included. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Townshend stated that that has actually gotten quite a bit of discussion at the Council level and we have definitely looked to map them out. The challenge is this, for K-12 schools there is a very clear way to find where they are and the same with licensed daycare centers. Now if someone is doing it without a license that is a whole different issue. The places that are included are places that we are able to obtain a comprehensive list of where they are so that there is not errors and uncertainty. There is not a comprehensive list of churches. We looked at two data sources. We looked at the tax records and you can get some through that, but there are also a lot of houses of worship that rent. If it’s rented, you are not going to find them that way. So, they looked at Public Occupancy Permits and it looks like they might be able to do that but it is very labor intensive in terms of the Department being able to continue that. We have looked at that and the City Manager has that information. If an amendment were introduced that did that, they would find a way. But you have to be able to know where things are to be able to distance from that and that was the challenge with that.

Dr. Jones stated that she thinks that makes every bit of sense because they pop up here and there Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 7 of 21

Página 121

Item #4.

and they are renting here and there. She doesn’t think it’s too late in the process for your organization to take a look at this. But it is possible to call together, as there are organizations of faith-based organizations that run the gamut of various faiths. Bring them together and hear what they have to say. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Townshend stated that would be a question for City Council. That was discussed at the City Council meetings. Again, the information has been pulled together of where they are. She thinks they actually did some mapping and most of the places of worship are not in that area. There are some along the highway corridor but a lot of them are kind of more back in neighborhoods. They do have the mapping. If it is something that an amendment was introduced for and if the Ordinance was amended, it’s something that could be done potentially.

Dr. Jones asked if there was any relationship between manufacturing and/or the retail with CBD. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Townshend stated no, CBD is basically unregulated. Those places don’t fall into this; they are not regulated under this. They can continue to operate as they are.

Dr. Jones asked if they may become a part of what’s going on. Responding to Dr. Jones, Mrs. Townshend stated that is probably a question for like the market. There is a question on whether people will still be getting CBD if they can get marijuana. Again, she has had several people using CBD in her family and they are not using that for a high. Her mother-in-law uses it to put on her arthritic hands. She thinks that it is separate enough that it’s not going to be affected but she is not an industry expert either.

Mr. Witham asked if this Commission recommended to City Council to prohibit marijuana in the City, how would that affect the one compassion center? Are they likely to close because they are not going to be profitable? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that she knows they have already applied for and been approved for a conversion license. She knows the COO of the compassion center was here at one of the meetings where the Council Committee talked about it. He reached out to her afterwards and basically, he said here on the floor and then he said again to her, if they can’t get a conversion license then they won’t be able to continue.

Mr. Witham stated that the level of the HTC in marijuana has consistently gone up over the years so now they are selling high concentrated marijuana which presents great issues for people. His concern is, was there any consideration in regulating the level of HTC in marijuana either at the State level or could the City of Dover regulate that? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that the City can’t regulate the quality. They can only regulate the time, place and manner. She is not sure if that was addressed in the State. She does know that they have to put the strength; if it’s 5mg, 10mg, or 20mg on the packaging. She doesn’t know how that works for the flower. It seems to her that that’s harder to figure out in that.

Mr. Witham stated that some states are now looking into that to try to regulate the level of HTC in marijuana because they find that high levels are extremely dangerous. There are studies that show that the crime rates go up, the DUI rates go up. They have been going up ever since Colorado and some of the other states have allowed general recreational marijuana to exist in the states. The rates just continued to go up; so, he was just wondering whether there was any thought in that area? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that she is not aware. Again, at the local level they are preempted from regulating that aspect. She is not sure, but she can certainly find out from the Commissioner’s Office. She has read quite a bit about some of the effects of the higher content stuff that isn’t necessarily good. Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 8 of 21

Página 122

Item #4.

Mr. Witham stated that given his background, he has seen the worst. The other question that he has is he understands that Ordinance #2024-30 would permit the use of retail marijuana stores in a C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). He noticed that both of the Ordinances that pertain to this don’t mention at all courthouses. Courthouses in this City are located just off The Green. There is the Kent County Courthouse and the new Family Courthouse going up on Governors Avenue. Both of those courthouses are going to have programs in courts involving the use of drugs which will be prohibited from their standpoint. There is no mention of court houses. Are they covered in some other area? They should be viewed as the same thing as the substance abuse treatment center. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that it is something certainly that could be added.

Mr. Witham stated that he was informed by one Council member that there was a provision in those Ordinances that would exclude the establishment of retail stores, cultivation, and manufacturing so many feet from the courthouse, but he didn’t see it. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that she had not heard that discussed but again, that is something that you know where they are and we could easily identify them. From a practical perspective for today, she doesn’t think it’s an issue except the current Family Court. Once the Family Court moves it’s not, but the current Family Court could be within a distance of C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). It could be something that could be done through an amendment. But she thinks the courthouses, with the exception of Family Court, tend to be located in the Downtown Area.

Mr. Witham stated that he thinks the Superior Courthouse and the new Family Courthouse would be in the area of which we call the Downtown Development zone. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that the current ordinance does prohibit it in the Downtown Area. That was one of the things that came up on multiple occasions throughout the process and ultimately, the Survey showed that a majority of the people who responded did not think it should be Downtown. At this point, there was not the desire from Council to amend the drafts that they brought forward to do that.

Mr. Witham stated that he can assure them that members of the judiciary, if they knew about this, they would probably be concerned about this. He thinks that it is something that he would recommend that Council address if they want to adopt such an ordinance. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that Mrs. Melson-Williams can correct her if she is wrong but she would suggest that if there are recommendation that you want to make to Council to amend, to include that in a motion.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated yes, with looking at both of these Ordinances, if there are proposed as amendments. You have kind of mentioned the question of places of worship, which that gets difficult in our Code because they are more generally referred to as places of public assembly and then the courthouses. You could certainly make a recommendation to add to the Supplementary Regulations an amendment that would specify a distancing requirement from those two types of uses.

Mr. Witham stated that the other question that he has is that there appears to be no requirement of odor control technology for retail stores. Why is that? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that the research that they did and the areas that they found odor complaints Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 9 of 21

Página 123

Item #4.

were really on the cultivation and manufacturing. In the stores, you are not allowed to use it. Certainly, something could be added but it’s typically sealed and not out in the open.

Mr. Witham stated that this facility is closed now but the Central Delaware Committee on Substance Abuse Control operated the Kent County Counseling Center just off of Walker Road. They were a treatment center and one of the complaints that were made to him years ago was that they would treat people and people would light up right outside the store. The whole area would be permeated with the smell of marijuana. So, that was a retail establishment so why would that not occur if we allow retail stores in Dover? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that under the State Law and under the State Regulations, you cannot consume onsite. She smells it too; she is not pretending like she was born yesterday. But under the Law, you cannot consume it on the premises and you cannot consume it in a publicly accessible place. If people are smoking it on a street corner whether it’s near the retail or wherever it is, that’s not allowed. She thinks the practical matter to his point is what do you do about it because the Police are busy. They have a lot of other things.

Mrs. Denney stated exactly. It is almost like they are not laws; they are suggestions and it’s really just about the attitude of people when it comes to obedience. She is old and if it was a law and you had her father, you obeyed the law. By Big Lots there is the Lutheran Church right there on the highway. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that she is not sure the actual distance, but again, based on the current draft which was amended to include the exemption from the distancing to allow for the conversion; that is something that came about through the process.

Mrs. Denney stated that at one time there was a little preschool in that Lutheran Church. To her, that’s a school. Any place where children are being taught is a school, but she realizes that is not written in the laws necessarily. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that if it’s a licensed daycare center then that would be get picked. But again, by virtue of exempting compassion center conversions from the distancing, that would be one location where that would happen.

Mrs. Denney stated then perhaps about allowing that conversion, we shouldn’t be doing that. Perhaps we should not allow it and then we protect the children. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that is certainly something that they could recommend to Council. That’s what this process is for.

Mr. Witham stated that he appreciates Mrs. Townshend’s presentation but he has another question. As he understands from her presentation, the State Law on this subject is not going to allow a driver who is driving to use marijuana. Is that correct? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated yes, it also doesn’t allow passengers in the car to be using it in the car. Again, she thinks even before it was legal, we have all observed otherwise.

Mr. Witham stated that he is sure that was because a majority of our wonderful police officers would use the smell of marijuana as one aspect of probable cause to stop a driver driving. But by prohibiting that, it makes their job a little bit easier.

Mrs. Maucher asked how the distancing is determined for these buffers. Is that pulled out of the State Law? What is the basis for the 250 feet, 500 feet, and one mile? Responding to Mrs. Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 10 of 21

Página 124

Item #4.

Maucher, Mrs. Townshend stated that it is not in State Law. There is no distancing requirement in State Law. This was based on discussion with City Council Committee of the Whole to have some distancing but they also wanted to make sure that once you applied the distancing that it wasn’t a defacto prohibition. So, we looked at different scenarios and what distancing did to whether or not it would be viable. So, that’s how we got to where we are.

Mrs. Maucher stated that hypothetically if you applied these to these instances, how many potential sites would be available? Responding to Mrs. Maucher, Mrs. Townshend stated that she thinks very few. Basically, you see what a mile is. You could theoretically get at the most four to five if that one dot moved. Again, that is theoretical. Once you look at available space. Then with the issue of distancing, they said the building footprint of where the marijuana use is. So, if it’s one retail space in a larger building, you are looking at the building footprint. You are not looking at that tenant space. She thinks that they looked at it and thought, theoretically you might be able to get four. But the likelihood to be able to get four without allowing it other than on Route 13 and Bay Road is really difficult. The other thing, it’s only C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). It doesn’t include the shopping center zones. For instance, you‘ve got Blue Hen Corporate Center and Bay Court Plaza. They are both zoned Shopping Center. They both have a lot of available retail space, but they aren’t zoned C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone).

Mr. Reaves stated that he has a question with regards to the cultivation. Does the Ordinance mention anything about container farming? Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mrs. Townshend stated that it does not. But both under the Ordinance and under the State Regulations, she doesn’t know how they would be able to meet the odor control in particular and the ventilation. There are a lot of things that she thinks would be difficult to meet in the context of container farming. She suspects that there is also National Fire Prevention Regulations that come into play that it would be very difficult to do in that type of environment. Even though it is not addressed, it certainly could be.

Mrs. Denney stated that it was an excellent question. It never crossed her mind.

Mr. Reaves stated that from a business perspective that people grow. This is not for sale or use or anything like that, but just from a business perspective. There is a growing movement of container farming in which people can have a successful business because as Mrs. Denney said with regards to the medicinal purposes, there is a need for production. With the land use space, container farming is a viable option for a lot of different uses. Responding to Mr. Reaves, Mrs. Townshend stated that the other thing that the State Regulations have is that they have very stringent security requirements.

Mrs. Welsh questioned that in regard to the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) and the comment that you just had, Mrs. Townshend, about the retail spaces in the Bay Court Plaza and Blue Hen Mall being retail spaces but not C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone). Is it available to them to put a restriction on the ability for them to request a Rezoning to C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) in the future? Responding to Mrs. Welsh, Mrs. Townshend stated that she is going to defer to the Chair because her guess is that he has got a lot better background on being able to condition not allowing a request.

Mr. Witham stated that he can’t make a comment about future applications, but it would be a legitimate question of the Planning Commission and the Commissioners to ask a question if Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 11 of 21

Página 125

Item #4.

someone wants to rezone their property to C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) or some other zone that would permit cultivation, manufacturing or sales of marijuana. They can make an inquiry about the purpose of the Rezoning. It certainly would go under into the nick so to speak, as to whether it should be allowed.

Mrs. Townshend stated that you can’t really preempt the ability for somebody to request.

Mr. Witham stated that that triggers another question in his mind. He thinks that the adoption of these Ordinances would allow the transportation of the product from agricultural marijuana to the store, correct? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated yes, and that is also very tightly regulated in the State Regulations.

Mr. Witham further asked if that was so a person using his private vehicle could transport several pounds of marijuana. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Townshend stated that would not be allowed.

Mrs. Denney asked if it would be like a “Brinks” car operation. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that is her understanding in the conversations that she has had with the Commissioner’s Office. Each piece of plant will have a barcode, and it will be tracked so at no point would they “put this in your car and take it.” It is all very monitored from the time that it is germinated to the time that it is sold.

Mr. Witham opened the public hearing.

Mrs. Cynthia Christiansen – 714 Carol Street Dover, DE 19904 Mrs. Christiansen stated that she has been a resident of Dover, DE for 60+ years. This is not her first time here. If you have read any minutes from any previous Committee Meetings or Council Meetings, you know what her position is. She is a retired school teacher for 43 years but she is substituting full time. She is concerned about the location of a retail store anywhere near Route 13 or a housing development. It bothers her that the cultivation is 750 feet and schools, hospitals, and daycares is only 500 feet. That doesn’t make sense to her because these children are outside breathing the air and they should have clean air. If it’s near a store that is selling marijuana, whether they have it sealed that does not prevent them from smoking on the way home or smoking it in their car. Right now, she can’t go anywhere in this City on the highway, in neighborhoods or even her own neighborhood and drive down the street without smelling a dead skunk and there is not a dead skunk on the road. She knows that the cultivated marijuana is supposed to be different and a higher grade but there is still going to be that smell. There are still going to be people driving and dropping their kids off at school. She knows for a fact because she has opened doors of cars and she can get a contact high. A contact high can be given to a child. She has had students come in with a contact high in Dover schools. They are contact high not because they are smoking but because they are sitting in a car or at their home and their parents are smoking around them. They don’t know any different until about 9:30 or 10:00AM and they come off of that contact high. What happens at the end of the day? They get right back in that car and we can’t do anything as teachers or administrators. They have already tried. It’s because the laws are not really written. She thinks the cart has been put before the horse. “You shouldn’t” or “you are prohibited.” They don’t know what that word is in any place in Dover, especially at a concert. Let’s say that is different because that is supposed to be controlled but anywhere outside. For a football game, no you are not allowed to have drugs or marijuana in a Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 12 of 21

Página 126

Item #4.

stadium but you can sit in the car in the parking lot and smoke up and the air comes right to us. This bothers her greatly. It bothers her to the point where she looks and sees Dewey Beach, Rehoboth, Fenwick Island, Bethany Beach, all of the party towns said “absolutely no.” If you think about it, she thought they would be the biggest ones to pass it, but they said no. The Rossi Group was hired by City Council and she has questioned this through the whole process. She has heard nothing but positive; there is nothing negative. Dr. Vendetti commented twice at meetings and she said that she called other places in the country asking for them to tell her how things are with just marijuana. One place said, “if you have a nice town, don’t do it.” This is what bothers her because she has lived here all of her life and she loved her City. She loved it when she used to smell chocolate from General Foods and she loved when we smelled chicken from Richardson and Robbins. Now, we smell marijuana everywhere. How can the Police enforce this? She even asked the head czar of the Marijuana Department if he was going to give more money to towns and cities that are going to say yes. He just looked at her and shrugged his shoulders. She knows what the answer is; absolutely not. And that 15%, who knows where that goes. They are probably looking to make a lot of money. The thing is, your Police Department cannot do it. They can’t even pull over somebody that they assume is smoking. Yes, they are driving and smoking. If anyone drives up or down Route 13 or down Governors Avenue, you don’t have to be a rocket scientist to know that someone in the car in front of you is in there smoking because your car is going to smell like it. As a taxpayer, as a teacher, and as somebody who just had a brand-new baby granddaughter born last Thursday, do I want her to stay living in Dover? Yes, because it’s close to me. Do I think they will? Probably not, if we keep doing what we are doing. It’s not building up; she thinks we are building down.

Mr. Bill Winters – Mitten & Winters LLC at 117 W Loockerman Street Dover, DE 19904 Mr. Winters stated that he owns a business at 117 W Loockerman Street and he is a Dover resident located at 133 Walker Road Dover, DE 19904. He spoke to City Council months ago. He has some concerns about the Ordinance but first he has a question either for the Commissioners or Mrs. Townshend. Assuming the Ordinance passes and there is a retail location opened which he is against. If it is passed by the Commission and it is passed on to Council. Is there a limit to the quantity of marijuana that somebody can buy when they enter a facility? Can they go in like if they go into a liquor store and buy as much as they want or is there a limitation to the quantity at any one time? Responding to Mr. Winters, Mrs. Townshend stated that under House Bill 1, which is the first of the two marijuana bills, you are limited to a personal use quantity which is no more than one ounce per person. She doesn’t know for sure that you can’t buy any more than that but you can’t load up like you can at the Costco Liquor Store or anything.

Mr. Witham stated that he thinks from his standpoint, the way he would interpret that is that you are limited to personal use only. If you go in there a try to buy a pound or two of marijuana and you get in your car you are going to get stopped.

Mr. Winters stated that some of this is going to be repetitive, repeating what Mrs. Christiansen said but he has followed this pretty closely. He has seen what some of the towns in Sussex have done. Dewey said they didn’t want it because they have enough issues with alcohol. In Newark, Commissioners decided that they didn’t want it on Main Street because of the University being there and the excessive use that could possibly happen with a college campus. Fortunately, at least with the Ordinance that you currently have set up, there won’t be any retail within the Downtown area. But we do have the Del State University Campus which is three blocks from Downtown. You are faced with a very difficult decision on whether to approve this or not. Dover Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 13 of 21

Página 127

Item #4.

has some of the best parades in the State. It’s amazing what they do with parades. This past St. Patrick’s Day, they had a phenomenal parade. Loockerman Street was packed with people. His office is right across the street from the old Dover Hardware was and there is open space there now. After the conclusion of the parade, they had a DJ playing out there and our office was open on that Saturday because it was tax season. The music was great; however, the amount of marijuana being smoked out on the street was amazing. We had to have a couple of people leave our office because of the smell that permeated our office. Mrs. Christiansen is right; you go anywhere around Dover and you are going to smell marijuana. He and his wife regularly drive through Silver Lake Park on bike rides and the amount of consumption there on a regular basis is amazing. So, if we are already saying that it’s a problem, he can’t imagine what it’s going to be like if we approve this in our City right now. It’s going to be a big issue to deal with and how are the police going to deal with it if somebody’s doing public consumption, do they arrest them? Do they take the time to take them to the station and then they are going to get released right away? That’s the whole concept right there; he doesn’t know how that’s going to work. All he knows is that the Commission has a very difficult decision to pass along to the City Council. There is no revenue coming to the City of Dover for this provision; so, what benefit is it to our community? He doesn’t see any.

Mrs. Nicole Chick – 510 Kirkwood Highway Wilmington DE 19805 (virtual) Mrs. Chick stated that she had discussed a while back with Council President Anderson an Ordinance that he put forth on June 11, 2024 that businesses already in existence that apply for a retail license could obtain a waiver of the residential buffer restriction by obtaining signatures of approval from the residents. Her question is where does that stand currently and if it is still being considered? She would ask that we ensure the amendment says something like business owners and not just businesses because someone owning an existing hemp business, for instance, liability wise likely isn’t going to apply with the exact business names and risk the liability there. They would apply as a new business that would sell marijuana instead. If the amendment has already been voted on, could she know who voted for and against it? If it’s still under consideration, she just wanted to say that an existing medical dispensary or a compassion center shouldn’t qualify for an exemption to the zoning requirements if hemp stores can’t equally get the same treatment. Responding to Mrs. Chick, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that she believes that there were discussions in the City Council Committee of the Whole regarding potential amendments; however, that amendment was not voted upon or released from Committee as part of the proposed Ordinance packages for consideration here.

Mrs. Townshend stated that there was language and there were two kind of conceptual amendments: the one that Mrs. Chick mentioned and then the one that would address conversion licenses was the other. We put them both in Ordinance format and there was no action on the one that you mentioned. For the one that you mentioned, the way that you characterized it would not have allowed for your business to obtain a license anyway. Looking at the objective, they drafted something that would have allowed it as a Conditional Use in the C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) and that Draft Amendment did not move forward.

Mr. Witham stated that the bottom line is that presumably the not approved Amendment is not before this Commission. It is not being considered.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that there was no Amendment in short that came out of Committee to us for consideration by the Planning Commission in regards to a possible hemp store provision Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 14 of 21

Página 128

Item #4.

in the Ordinance.

There was technical difficulty with the sound through WebEx.

Mrs. Chick typed in the chat if someone could forward her the status of that Amendment. Responding to Mrs. Chick, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that that Amendment was never released from Committee as part of the Ordinance package.

Mrs. Chick asked through the chat if Mrs. Melson-Williams could repeat herself. Responding to Mrs. Chick, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the concept for that Amendment related to hemp stores was not part of the package that was released by the Council Committee of the Whole. It was discussed she believes, at one of their earlier meetings this summer but ultimately was not made part of the proposed Ordinance that was released for consideration.

Mr. Witham stated that it is not before this Commission. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that is correct.

Mrs. Chick asked through the chat who voted against it. Responding to Mrs. Chick, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated she doesn’t believe that it was ever brought forth formally as an amendment at that Committee. The City Clerk’s Office would have the meeting minutes for those Council Committee of the Whole Meetings where it was discussed.

Mr. Witham closed the public hearing.

Mr. Witham stated that they have before them a Petition for Text Amendments for recreational uses of marijuana in the City of Dover. Under Article 10, Section 5 they must evaluate these factors for proposed Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30. To get this matter moving forward, there are three options. The first option is to prohibit, recommending that the City Council deny adopting these Ordinances in whole. The second option is to permit as requested by these Ordinances before us. The third option is to approve with exception and/or recommendations for improvements.

Mrs. Denney stated that she thinks it’s pretty evident here to everybody from the beginning of this that in her perfect world, we would just go with Option 1 and prohibit it completely for non- medical uses because once again, she managed an orthopedic surgery practice. She has seen many people with injuries. She has happened to have been married, have her children and she is now widowed but she was married to a sailor and Vietnam left a lot of people with issues. She does see a medical necessity, but her feeling is if they decide not to prohibit it completely, just keep it out on the highway in a very restricted area. But her preference would be to do what they were brave enough to do in Sussex County. She remembers when her kids were young, there was a slogan “Just Say No” and that’s where she would love to be.

Mr. Witham stated that he believes that the Planning Office had found that the proposed Ordinances were consistent with the aims and principles of the Zoning Ordinance and the Comprehensive Plan. Is that correct? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that any time you are looking at a Text Amendment, the Zoning Ordinance has two criteria that are prescribed for you to evaluate those Text Amendments. This is found in the Zoning Ordinance, Article 10 Section 5 and when considering a proposed Text Amendment we have to Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 15 of 21

Página 129

Item #4.

issue whether or not the change is consistent with the aims and principles embodied in the Ordinance as to the particular zone concerned and whether the Amendment is consistent with the aims of the Comprehensive Plan for the City. As part of the DAC Report on Page 5, Planning Staff along with our consultant have responded to those criteria. In finding that when you generally look at cultivation, manufacturing and testing, those types of uses are allowed in the M (Manufacturing Zone) and the IPM (Industrial Park Manufacturing Zone) because those zones permit the manufacturing and industrial processing of goods. They also allow for research and testing labs. The cultivation, likewise when you look at the A (Agricultural Zone), is something where you find crop harvesting as permitted use. Then looking at marijuana retail stores, in looking at the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) that is a zone that allows for retail and that is a zone where they would expect to find higher intensity and likely auto dependent uses in that zone. It’s considered a higher intensity type provision. The Ordinance as proposed does provide those Supplementary Regulations where we find the requirements for distancing, the things that the City as a municipality is allowed to control related to time and place. For the second provision related to the Comprehensive Plan, they included in their Report some notations about specifically looking at where the Land Use Category of Commercial High Intensity areas are. That is found in the DuPont Highway (Route 13) and Bay Road corridors and there is a statement there about what the makeup of those types of corridors is. And then additionally, there is some discussion in the Land Use of Employment Centers where they should be providing sufficient land area for industrial purposes and whether that is existing facilities, new facilities, or revitalizations of older industrial sites. With those statements, they found that it would be consistent with the aims and principles of the Zoning Ordinance basically for similar type uses; however, given that it’s marijuana then adding additional restrictions to it as well as how those areas from a land use perspective are described in the Comprehensive Plan.

Mr. Michael Lewis stated that he might be looking at this from maybe a different perspective. He hesitates to make assumptions but he may be one of the younger people sitting here. Somebody mentioned Bay Court Plaza before but he is old enough to remember the Pink Elephant store that was there. He believes that it had a drive through window and that was an alcohol facility. He mentions that as just an example of how things evolve, how things change, how as a culture and society we move on from things from time to time. He appreciates the fact that Council submitted these proposed Ordinances and they followed pretty closely with what the Survey results were. More than 2,200 people filled out the Survey and they have seemed to narrowly follow what the majority of the Survey respondents wanted. 58-42 was the overall percentage breakdown as far as allowing some uses with the restrictions in general; allow was the 58% and prohibit was the 42%. He thinks the Ordinances do a fine job of capturing the mood and the result of the survey. The surveys can’t obviously be our end all but when they presented them, the public had the chance to weigh in and they did on this issue. He would support more surveys being sent on other issues. To him, this marijuana issue isn’t in the top 10 or 15 of issues facing Dover but that is a discussion for another day. From his perspective, he thinks the Ordinances do a good job of capturing what the mood and the wishes of the survey respondents are. He would support the permit with restrictions side of things. If there are no other comments, he would put forth a motion to approve but he doesn’t want to jump the gun.

Mr. Witham asked what exceptions or restrictions would he suggest. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mr. Lewis stated that he would be just in favor of adopting Ordinances #2024-29 and #2024-30 as stated but he assumes that they have to do one at a time.

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 16 of 21

Página 130

Item #4.

Mr. Michael Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances as presented.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that Mr. Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council to adopt Ordinance #2024-29 as presented. This is the one that focuses on manufacturing, cultivation and testing. We are looking for a second on that motion to move into discussion and/or a vote.

Mrs. Maucher seconded the motion.

Mr. Witham stated that his thoughts would be directed to Mr. Lewis. Would he be amenable to an amendment to the motion to include the requirement that City Council improve the proposed amendments to include a distance requirement from any and all public courthouses within the City of Dover? Responding to Mr. Witham, Mr. Lewis stated yes.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that if the motion maker is accepting of the amendment, is there a distance that they want to specify? Responding to Mrs. Melson-Williams, Mr. Witham stated that he would suggest like the other distance requirements of the other public facilities, which is 750 feet.

Mrs. Denney stated that she doesn’t think that it belongs in Dover and most definitely not in Downtown Dover.

Mrs. Welsh stated that she concurs with Mrs. Denney.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated they need to address the amendment. You had the motion maker agree to that. Is the second also amenable to that amendment? Responding to Mrs. Melson- Williams, Mrs. Maucher stated yes.

Mr. Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances and adding a requirement for a 750 feet distancing requirement from courthouses, seconded by Mrs. Maucher.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the amendment would be added to the section of Lines 90-94 where that distancing is listed and then also again on Line 129-133. That would capture all of the manufacturing, testing, and cultivation.

Mr. Witham asked if that would be for retail also. Responding to Mr. Witham, Mrs. Melson- Williams stated that retail is not discussed in this one. There are basically three sections where that (amendment for distancing from courthouses) would need to be added. That includes 165- 170 as well where the distancing is listed.

Mr. Michael Lewis moved to recommend approval to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 17 of 21

Página 131

Item #4.

for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances and adding a requirement for a 750 feet distancing requirement from courthouses, seconded by Mrs. Maucher and the motion failed with 4-5 by roll call vote(4 in favor, 5 against the motion). Mr. Lewis voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mr. Roach voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mrs. Denney voting no; if we approve manufacturing, next thing you know they are going to be fighting to sell it where they grow it and manufacture it. Mrs. Maucher voting yes; based on reasons stated in the motion. Mr. Baldwin voting no. Dr. Jones voting no; for her there are still areas that have been unaddressed and there seem to be some that are unenforceable. Mr. Reaves voting yes; for reasons previously stated. Mrs. Welsh voting no; for reasons stated by Mrs. Denney and Dr. Jones. Mr. Witham voting no; he frankly doesn’t see how the adoption of these Ordinances would further the economic development goals of Dover for the sales, cultivation and manufacturing in this federally illegal drug which is still illegal under Federal Law. It is a Schedule II drug that has never been approved through the federal government although the State does allow it. It’s just problematic for the State and for the City. Second of all, we draw no income. The City gets no part of the 15% tax on marijuana yet the cost of public services to monitor, regulate and police the growing, dispensing and sales of marijuana is going to cause an increase in public funds being expended. And although it does meet the technical requirements of a proposed amendment under the zoning law, our zoning law doesn’t direct the type of retail sales that we promote in this community. Obviously, this is a retail sale or manufacturing of an item that is very problematic and controversial. He doesn’t think the Zoning Ordinance or the Comprehensive Plan ever contemplated this.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that it is probably best if there is a motion in the affirmative to say no and prohibit if that is your vote in order to clarify that.

Mrs. Denney stated that the motion failed so it dies, and someone can make a new motion. Is that the better way? Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Melson-Wiliams stated yes.

Mrs. Denney stated that she would be happy to make a motion, but she isn’t sure if we want to add anything.

Mrs. Denney moved to recommend denial to City Council for Ordinance #2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, seconded by Dr. Jones.

Mrs. Denney stated that if there is something happening in the universities for testing or researching, she doesn’t want to prohibit that so she’s not sure what to do with that. Responding to Mrs. Denney, Mrs. Townshend stated that testing in the context of this Ordinance is testing under the licensing program. It wouldn’t prevent academic research.

Mrs. Denney stated that with that understanding her motion still stands.

Mrs. Denney moved to recommend denial to City Council for Ordinance 2024-29 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for cultivation, manufacturing, and testing facilities and compassion centers by amending Dover Code of Ordinances, seconded by Dr. Jones and the motion was carried 5-4 by roll call vote (5 in favor and 4 against the motion to deny). Mrs. Denney voting yes; she thinks that it’s to the Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 18 of 21

Página 132

Item #4.

benefit to us and to our children and grandchildren. She feels that it’s necessary to protect them as much as we can and to protect our City which is the capital city of the State that started the Nation and she hopes that others follow our lead. Mrs. Maucher voting no; the State has determined that it is a legal product and has set up regulations for it. This is for cultivation, manufacturing and testing for it, and she thinks it’s reasonable. If it’s not allowed here, it’s going to occur somewhere else in the State and you are not insulating Dover from any of that material coming into the City. Having it in the City, she thinks, gives us additional protections rather than a free for all. Mr. Baldwin voting yes. Dr Jones voting yes. Mr. Reaves voting no; because this is a business proposition, this is not distribution or sell. This is the manufacturing, cultivation, and testing. This is just like a normal business that would be producing anything in Dover and would potentially sell it to different facilities. This product is legal in the State and he doesn’t think that they should be prohibiting this business opportunity. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons stated in the motion. Mr. Lewis voting no; he can just add with first hand experience that there is plenty of academic research that takes place at the Firefly Music Festival. Mr. Roach voting no; he agrees with Mrs. Maucher and thinks it is handicapping us. We are the capital of the State. It is legal in the State of Delaware so to prohibit the manufacturing and testing and things of that nature, it just seems not logical. If it’s legal in the State, to not be able to manufacture here is not doing anything but putting us behind times; behind everybody else that already has it in their City. It is actually counterproductive and he really would urge people to not do that. It is putting us behind the times by doing it anyway because the whole State is legalized. It just doesn’t make sense to prohibit it here. It is actually putting us in a worse place than it is a better place. Mr. Witham voting yes; the passage of this Ordinance will do nothing to improve the City of Dover. The reasons that he set forth in the previous motion will apply here. We draw no revenue from this. The only way to force the State to give us revenue is to deny the cultivation, manufacturing and transportation, and the retail sales of marijuana. If we don’t deny these motions, we are just asking for trouble.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the recommendation on Ordinance #2024-29 to City Council would be that Ordinance is not adopted and that there should be prohibition of manufacturing, testing, and cultivation.

Mr. Witham stated that the next Ordinance that needs to be addressed is Ordinance #2024-30.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that just to remind you, proposed Ordinance #2024-30 is the Ordinance that was set up with provisions related to retail marijuana stores with limitations in being established only in the C-4 (Highway Commercial Zone) and then a series of Supplementary Regulations for their operations.

Mr. Witham moved to recommend denial to City Council for Ordinance #2024-30 Text Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance pertaining to recreational marijuana land use and zoning for retail marijuana stores and provisions for compassion center conversions by amending Dover Code of Ordinances for the reasons that he stated earlier and for the reasons that Mrs. Denney stated, seconded by Dr. Jones and the motion was carried 5-4 (5 favor and 4 against of denial) by roll call vote. Mr. Lewis voting no; the Ordinance as proposed gives a pretty narrow window to anything potential retail establishment. Plus, we have already stated in this meeting how denying this would put the one compassion center that we do have in jeopardy which does serve for a medical marijuana purpose. Mr. Roach voting no; he agrees with the reasons previously stated. Mrs. Denney voting yes; for reasons she stated throughout this meeting. She Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 19 of 21

Página 133

Item #4.

thinks that we don’t need to legalize one other opportunity for people to drive intoxicated, act out intoxicated, get in fights at sporting events and she enjoys taking her grandchildren down to Silver Lake. They went there for homecoming photos and her grand-daughter went to the house and had to spray her dress because she smelled like marijuana from going to have a picture for homecoming taken by the lake. Mrs. Maucher voting no; again, the State has determined this to be a legal product. The Ordinance had put sufficient limitations on where and buffers for these types of businesses. Not allowing this retail sale in the City is not going to prevent people from bringing it into the City. You are talking about consumption issues, not sale issues. Mr. Baldwin voting yes; for reasons stated. Dr. Jones voting yes; in her mind and experience it is already out of hand and to try and bring it under control with these Ordinances with some things that are still unclear and unenforceable. Mr. Reaves voting no; for reasons stated previously. Mrs. Welsh voting yes; for reasons as noted by Dr. Jones. Mr. Witham voting yes; for the reasons that he stated earlier. In addition to that, his experience as a drug court judge tells him that this is a bad move for Dover. 80% of all of those people who came through his drug court program all had a marijuana issue. Four of them died from the use of marijuana. With the State unable to control and manage the high THC levels that this State has along with the entire country, the death rate is going to continue to rise. Our children are getting marijuana whether they like it or not. One of the reasons why people don’t come down to Dover is because he is convinced that they don’t want to fight the marijuana traffic or other drug traffic as well. This is not good for Dover.

Dr. Jones stated that she wanted to thank our consultant for breaking this down for her because the presentation helped her to understand more of what was presented and helped her to see some things that she did not see. The other thing that she thought of during the whole presentation is we protect our kids from cigarette smoke in restaurants, schools, and wherever we go. As Mrs. Christiansen indicated and we all know, she can’t tell you how many times she has almost had a contact high. That is not the reason that she voted against it. She just thinks there are some things that need to be cleaned up.

Mrs. Welsh stated that the presenter did a fantastic job in itemizing the situation for us and giving us good information as to what exactly was being covered by all of these amendments. It was great to see Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend again.

Mr. Roach stated that he definitely appreciated the presentation but he also just wants to put it in a perspective that again, it’s legal in the State. By us preventing it from here, we are not increasing the chances of us “protecting our kids”. Because again, if it’s legal in the State, now you are increasing their chance of having to go out of the City to be able to purchase it. This decreases the chances of the things that everybody is saying that they want to prevent like driving under the influence of THC and things of that nature rather than going two minutes up the street for recreational use. If you want to do it, you are going to access it regardless of whether you prohibit it or restrict it from the City. It is not stopping. It is a legal action in the State. Again, he understands everybody’s thought process and he respects everybody on this Commission but he thinks that it is counterproductive in regards to the mindset of wanting to protect people. Again, you can get cigarettes at age 18. He doesn’t like second-hand smoke and smelling like cigarettes no more than smelling like marijuana but people are allowed to smoke in certain places. That’s the reason why there are restrictions, and the prohibitions are going to be at certain places. He just really feels as though, again, like alcohol; kids are not supposed to drink until they are 21 years old, but they do it anyway. We can do whatever we can to try to “protect our children” by putting this bubble around Dover but if it’s a State legalized substance, there is Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 20 of 21

Página 134

Item #4.

no stopping it from getting here anyway. To be able to have it to at least where it is being able to be purchased somewhere locally and manufactured locally so therefore, you have safeguards and things of that nature to be put in place for our kids to be protected. If our children want to use it, they are going to use it regardless because it is legal in the State.

Mr. Witham stated that he thinks they all respect each other’s opinions. He thinks that as long as the State is putting a 15% tax on marijuana, marijuana is always going to be cheaper if you buy it from a drug dealer on the street. So, he doesn’t think it’s going to change any life at all just to legalize it.

Mrs. Melson-Williams stated that the Commissioner’s actions tonight will be summarized in a Recommendation Report on those Ordinances that they will transmit to City Council. City Council will take up these two Ordinances at their December 9, 2024 meeting. They have their own public hearing and final action regarding those Ordinances.

Excerpt of Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of November 18, 2024 Page 21 of 21

Página 135

Item #4.

FINAL READING

City of Dover
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-30

1BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN
2COUNCIL MET:
3
4 That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 3 – District Regulations, Section 16 – Highway Commercial
5 Zone (C-4) be amended by inserting the text indicated in bold, blue text as follows:
6
7Section 16. Highway Commercial Zone (C-4).
8
9 16.1 Uses permitted. In a highway commercial zone (C-4), no building or premises shall be used,
10 and no building or part of a building shall be erected, which is arranged, intended, or designed to
11be used, in whole or in part, for any purpose, except the following:
12
13 (q) Retail marijuana stores, subject to the requirements outlined in Article 5, Section 24.
14
15BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
16
17 That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, be amended by inserting the
18text indicated in bold, blue font as follows:
19
20 24.6 Where permitted in accordance with Article 3, retail marijuana stores are
21subject to the following restrictions:
22
23 24.61 The building footprint upon which a retail marijuana store is to be
24 located shall be at least 500 feet away from any private or public K-12 school,
25 child daycare center, State of Delaware licensed substance abuse disorder
26 treatment facility, hospital, and at least 250 feet away from any residential zone,
27and from the lot line of any college or university.
28
29 24.62 The building footprint within which a retail marijuana store is to be
30 located shall be at least 1 mile away from the lot line of any other retail
31marijuana store within the City of Dover.
32
33 24.63 An application for a certificate of occupancy shall be accompanied by a
34 photocopy of a valid license as required by Chapter 13, Title 4 of the Delaware
35State Code.
36
37 24.64 All building openings, entries, and windows shall be located, covered, or
38 screened in such a manner as to prevent a view into the interior from any public

Página 136

Item #4.

39or semipublic area.
40 24.7 A Compassion Center licensed by the State of Delaware on or before January 1,
41 2024, that obtains a conversion license under the State of Delaware Marijuana
42 Regulations, must comply with the requirements of Article 3 District Regulations, and
43 shall be exempt from distancing requirements detailed in Appendix B- Zoning,
44Article 5- Supplementary Regulations, 24.61 and 24.62.
45
46BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
47
48 That Appendix B – Zoning, Article 12 – Definitions, be amended by inserting the text indicated in
49bold, blue font in proper alphabetical order as follows:
50
51Article 12. – Definitions.
52
53 Retail marijuana store means an entity licensed by the State of Delaware to purchase
54 marijuana from marijuana cultivation facilities; to purchase marijuana and marijuana
55 products from marijuana product manufacturing facilities; and to sell marijuana and
56marijuana products to consumers.
57
58
59ADOPTED: *
60
61
62SYNOPSIS
63 This ordinance amends Appendix B- Zoning of the Dover Code by adding the definition of retail
64 marijuana store, allowing retail marijuana stores to operate as permitted uses in certain zones, and
65 adding supplementary regulations, by which retail marijuana stores must abide.
66
67(SPONSORS: ANDERSON and NEIL)
68
69
70Action History
7112/09/2024 – Scheduled for Public Hearing/First Reading – City Council
7211/18/2024 - Public Hearing - Planning Commission
73 10/28/2024 – First Reading – City Council (Ordinance number changed from #2024-25B to
74#2024-30)
75 10/15/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/ Legislative, Finance, and
76Administration Committee (Split into 25B)
77 09/24/2024 – Council Committee of the Whole / Legislative, Finance and Administration
78Committee
79 08/05/2024 – Deferred from 06/11/2024 – Special Legislative, Finance, and Administration
80Committee (Split into two parts)
81 06/11/2024 – Introduction – Council Committee of the Whole/Legislative, Finance, and
82Administration Committee.
83

Página 137

Item #5.

REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING

The Regular City Council Meeting was held on November 25, 2024, at 6:33 p.m. with Acting Council President Hare presiding. Council President Anderson was present. (out at 7:18 p.m.) Council members present were Mr. Hare, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Arndt, Dr. Sudler, and Mr. Lewis. Mr. Boggerty and Mr. Rocha were absent.

Staff members present were Police Chief Johnson, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Marney, Ms. Melson- Williams, Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Fire Chief Carey was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present.

OPEN FORUM

The Open Forum was held at 6:15 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Acting Council President Hare declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.

EShed Alston, 406 Arnold Court, Dover, presented a follow-up to his proposal that was recently discussed with council. His proposal centers on creating a pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants who serve in the military or as an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent. He highlighted their determination in crossing the borders and suggested this resilience be utilized as a manpower resource. He proposed selecting 10% of the undocumented population, approximately 1.8 million individuals, for the initiative: 1.4 million for military enlistment and 400,000 for ICE agent roles. The plan includes a 22-week training period, extended by an additional four (4) weeks for linguistic and on-the-job training. He emphasized that these individuals, familiar with cartel operations and border dynamics, could offer valuable insights. Additionally, he advocated for holding cartels financially accountable, citing the significant impact of fentanyl-related deaths on Americans. He proposed redirecting resources seized from cartels to fund this initiative, framing it as a way to turn their exploitation into a resource for national benefit.

Cleveland Wilson, 234 North Kirkwood Street, urged council to consider holding community meetings once every two (2) months. He emphasized that these gatherings should differ from formal council meetings by providing an open forum for constituents to ask questions and gain information. Mr. Wilson believed that this approach would help bridge divides, foster transparency, and allow residents to feel more connected to city government. By gaining insight into the roles and responsibilities of officials, such as the Chief of Police and council members, constituents can become more informed and actively engaged in their community. Additionally, he expressed concerns about rising crime and the fear it creates among residents. While he clarified that he was not proposing to halt Project 2030, Mr. Wilson stressed the need for solutions that ensure people feel safe in their homes. He emphasized that addressing public safety was critical for maintaining trust and improving the quality of life for all residents.

Lachelle Paul, 501 Silverside Drive, raised concerns regarding the city's revitalization project and its financial implications. She noted that some constituents believe the project should be paused, as current finances do not align with community needs, particularly regarding the city's

Página 138

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 2

high crime rate. Ms. Paul emphasized that rebuilding is futile if criminal activity continues to undermine progress and criticized the use of taxpayer money for projects that might lack immediate impact. She also questioned the practice of allocating funds from property sales to nonprofits. She stressed the importance of transparency, asking for clarification on where these funds are directed and expressing skepticism about tracking nonprofit expenditures once funds are disbursed. With the budget already under strain, she advocated prioritizing financial clarity over approving additional allocations.

Regarding the city's financial management, Ms. Paul noted issues with understanding and interpreting financial reports. She referenced an email she had sent urging the council to delay budget approval to allow time for identifying potential cuts. However, the budget was approved despite unresolved gaps. She called for financial reports to be presented in layman’s terms and highlighted the lack of itemized departmental budgets, which makes it difficult for citizens to understand fund usage. Ms. Paul also criticized the council's lack of transparency, stating that the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests often yield vague responses about funds being in a general account without specific details. She emphasized that the council is ultimately responsible for ensuring effective budget oversight and improving the distribution of taxpayer dollars to address critical issues like crime and financial accountability.

INVOCATION

The invocation was given by Elder Ellis B. Loudon.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Councilman Boggerty.

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Dr. Sudler moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Neil, and carried unanimously. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA

All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.

Mr. Lewis requested the removal of Item #14, Proposed Resolution No. 2024-15 Creating Economic and Community Funds, be removed from the consent agenda.

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the consent agenda as amended, seconded by Mr. Anderson, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty and Rocha absent)

ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER 28, 2024 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of October 28, 2024, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Anderson, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

Página 139

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 3

ADOPTION OF MINUTES – SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 6, 2024 The Minutes of the Special Council Meeting of November 6, 2024, were unanimously approved by motion of Nr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Anderson, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT OF OCTOBER 29,
2024

The Council Committee of the Whole met on October 29, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lewis (out at 9:09 p.m.), Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Dr. Sudler (out at 8:27 p.m.). Ms. Arndt and Mr. Hare were absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Dr. Jackson-Short (via Webex) (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation), Mr. Iriowen (via Webex), Mr. Wilson (Utility), Mr. Garfinkel, and Mr. Shevock (Legislative, Finance, and Administration). Ms. Smack (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation) was absent.

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Dr. Sudler moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.

SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE

The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairman Boggerty presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Anderson and unanimously carried.

Request for Waivers – Appendix A – Subdivisions, Article VI – Subdivision – General Requirements and Design Standards, Section A – Streets: Subdivision Waiver of Requirement for Two Connections to a Public Street and Section E – Lots: Subdivision Waiver of Requirement for Lot Frontage on a Public Street as associated with Conditional Use Site Plan/Master Plan for the development of Luther Village Planned Neighborhood Design – Senior Citizen Housing Option (Apartment Units). Property Owner: Martin Luther Foundation of Dover, Inc. Property Address: 101 Babb Drive. Tax Parcels: ED-05-077.06-02-90.00-000, ED-05-077.06-02-90.01-000, ED-05- 077.06-02-90.02-000, and ED-05-077.06-02-90.03-000. Planning Reference: C- 24-02) (Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the request for waivers for Luther Village.

Página 140

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 4

The Planning Commission recommended approval of the subdivision waiver of the requirement for two connections to a public street and approval of the subdivision waiver of the requirement for lot frontage on a public street.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the first waiver is related to the number of dwelling units. When a site has more than 150 dwelling units, there must be two connections or access points to a public street. Regarding the request, they only have one connection at Babb Drive, and they would like to continue to only use one connection with a future second connection happening in a later phase. They will be providing a second connection, but it will be done at a later date.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that he was correct. When phase five is built the second connection will be installed. Currently, Babb Drive ends and appears to go into the farm field. Eventually, that will turn into a second entrance that will serve the eastern side of the overall project which has four future buildings to come.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that they have received the waivers in the past for the other phases. One of the things that was looked at with the Planning Commission is that their current entrance is divided. There is one side of the median which is the entrance, and the other side is the exit. Therefore, if something should happen on one side there is always the ability to go the wrong way in the case of an emergency.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that it is hard to tell when the plans will be available. Their approval will be in place for several years. She explained that they have built out the site as they have funds or achieved grant funding to assist with construction. She stated that they realize that there is a need for the units, but it depends on the timing of achieving funding and the time to build.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the application was subject to a public hearing as a part of the Planning Commission review process, at which time the property owners within 200 feet of the overall site were notified of the hearing process. She explained that at the Planning Commission meeting, only one member of the public spoke, and that the individual was a resident of Luther Village. They have not heard any additional questions or statements from the adjacent neighborhood of Clearview Meadows.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that regarding congestion, when Babb Drive was originally laid out, there was a right of way given from the Luther Village parcel, as well as from the landmass that became Clearview Meadows. Therefore, Babb Drive is a city street, city street standards have been planned for and it is currently built to those standards. It has also been on the books for a number of years.

Página 141

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 5

Mr. Neil moved to recommend following the Planning Commission recommendations for approval of the waivers as requested. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that regarding the timeframe for approval, because the project is a senior plan and design, the plan neighborhood design has a life expectancy of up to five years. However, there are timeframes to start and continue action. She explained the project is back before the committee because the original plan approvals lapsed due to a lack of activity at the site, due to the timing of their construction. Several years ago, the last building was built during phase three. The current code allows for a timeframe between phases before starting the next one, if progress is not made, approval is lost.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that she believed that the timeframe between phases is two years, but the code reflects that they should be actively moving along through the project.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that notification of a Planning Commission hearing occurs in three ways. A mailing is sent to adjacent property owners within 200 feet of the address. The city provides the mailing list to the applicant, who is responsible for completing the mailing and providing proof that notifications were sent to the listed addresses. A legal ad is published in a local newspaper that runs one time. Then there is a physical posting, which is a bright yellow sign that is placed on the property so that anyone passing by the property would have notice of the public hearing process in front of the Planning Commission. All three components must be completed within a minimum of 15 days before the Planning Commission meeting.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that proof of mailing is required. A lot of applicants tend to use certified mailings to accomplish that, but it is not required.

Dr. Sudler recommended requiring the applicant to use certified mail with a return signature. He explained that mail can be lost, especially when dealing with apartment units, and certified mail would ensure that everyone has been properly notified.

Página 142

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 6

Presentation – Dover Municipal Freight Plan and Downtown Dover Pathways (Marilyn Smith, Executive Director of the Dover/Kent County MPO, Cooper Bowers, DelDOT Planning, and Leah Kacanda, Whitman, Requardt & Associates) Ms. Marilyn Smith, Executive Director of the Dover/Kent County MPO, Cooper Bowers, DelDOT Planning, and Leah Kacanda, Whitman, Requardt & Associates, reviewed the background and analysis of the Dover Municipal Freight Plan and Downtown Dover Pathways. This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Kacanda stated that she would investigate the traffic density on both Kenton Road and Saulsbury Road, as well as the freight density, and provide him with the findings.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Smith stated that the initial study did not recommend a direct on-and-off option to Route 1 because there was not enough room to accommodate the required acceleration and deceleration.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Smith stated that the Future Horsepond Road Extension would provide Whiteoak Road with a southern connection to the nearest Route 1 on-and-off ramp, under the current circumstances. She explained that the study now needs to be revisited with the current state of Garrison Oak and the Civil Air Terminal, to evaluate if the three additional sections are still correct. If they are not, then they need to provide connections that would be more appropriate given the current changes.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Bowers stated that they do their best to reach out to the physical truck drivers, operators, and carriers who are working for the businesses in the area that are taking the routes. They have tried to implement signage to ensure they find the correct truck routes. He explained that sometimes it is difficult to find the right person from the company or reach the truck drivers directly. He stated they have tried to work with Waze, the geolocation app, which they had a little bit of success with. However, they experienced more issues with Google as they tried to reach out to them and were not always able to get a response. He explained that they are not only engaging the stakeholders but also looking into GPS devices and apps trying to communicate with them about the current freight routes and the correct avenues of travel that do not impact local residents.

Presentation – Police Officer Standards and Training Commission (POST) (Sean Moriarty, Executive Director) Mr. Sean Moriarty, Executive Director, reviewed the presentation titled “State of Delaware Police Officer Standards and Training Commission” (Attachment #1).

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Página 143

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 7

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Moriarty stated that there is a great deal of focus on officer wellness and resiliency. Particularly within the last few years, training has focused on what can be done for officer intervention in situations where other officers need to intervene for one reason or another. He explained that there has also been a great deal of emphasis on realistic training rather than lecture-based training and sitting in a classroom, they are using kinesthetic training. They are performing car stops and so forth with actors and simulation rounds, working through those situations. He explained that they are trying to get as close to the real situation as possible. They then go from the academy to three months of field training, working with another senior officer in the streets, and then working on their own. They will experience nine months of training where they try to encompass all the different simulations to hopefully mitigate the use of excessive force and get people to comply successfully, easily, and within the law.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Moriarty stated that POST would not have any intervention regarding psychological assessments. However, part of the accreditation process does inadvertently look at early warning signs. He explained that there is a system in place that looks at how many disciplinary cases, how many citizen complaints were there, how many uses of force were there, justified or not. That system requires supervisors to look at the body-worn cameras by pulling the video at random and addressing any issues. He explained that most agencies, particularly larger agencies, have a tracking system to be able to look at and use a code to evaluate those statistical anomalies. In other words, they look at how many citizen complaints of use of force, and how many times the officer has been written up, which may trigger a sit down for review. In terms of the psychological impacts, that would be up to the agency to look at the barometers and speak to the officers. Specialized units such as those looking at horrific images on computers, and those involved in critical incidents, such as mass shootings with casualties, do go through a psychological, critical incident debrief with a psychologist and then in the future if there is something there, a fit for duty evaluation. He explained that his knowledge is from his prior position however, if any of those things trigger an issue regarding fitness for duty and whether the person should be employed anymore, then POST would get involved. They would look to evaluate if the person should be suspended or de-certified, as a possibility.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Moriarty stated that regarding taking officers off patrol for unnecessary training, they have begun to review what hours are devoted to a specific subject and whether they should be devoted to something else or does training need to be increased. He explained that in most cases it is the latter. They do not have enough officers to be able to do their job and they are taking them off for training, which is a constant struggle. He stated that training is important, and they train so that they can do the right thing as a police officer.

Página 144

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 8

Discussion – Community Concerns Surrounding Trash, Glass Bottles, and Needles (Bishop Lott) Bishop Lott expressed that his primary concern was for the safety of children catching the bus in the early morning and evening, as well as for senior citizens. He stated that with the progress being made in the downtown Dover area, with the new homes, the population is changing, and there are more children and senior citizens. He explained that he is seeking the city’s help because the children are having to walk through syringes, small blue bags, clear bags, and blue strips, and they tend to pick them up as they grab their attention.

Bishop Lott stated that to prevent this he currently pays between $160 to $200 a month for someone to clean it all up. He asked the city to help clean up New Street around the bus stop. He explained that drug dealers seem to bring drugs to their clients around 6:00 every morning which is about the time kids are going to the bus stop. He emphasized that people are lying on the sidewalk, and against the building and the children must walk by them. He explained that parents must constantly encourage the kids to not pick up syringes or anything off the ground because it has become a safety issue.

Bishop Lott conveyed that he is concerned about the situation as it exists and although it would not be a permanent solution he would like to see the committee put something in place so that the children do not have to be exposed to the different experiences. He explained that he does not mind coming out of pocket to help keep the kids safe, especially since he is on-site and deals with it daily, but he feels the city can do a better job.

Furthermore, Bishop Lott explained that there have been games of dice with people rolling dice on the sidewalk in front of the senior citizen's homes. The senior citizens are taxpayers who do not have the freedom to walk out of their door through 15 people who have decided to play a game of dice. Bishop Lott also stated that the drug dealers are placing their drugs in potato chip bags so that they appear to be trash. He explained that he was informed that the drug dealers are not allowing certain parts of the street to be cleaned up because they have drugs hidden as trash and debris in the area. Bishop Lott asked if the city could come through with the vacuum trucks and perhaps vacuum up their drugs. Lastly, Bishop Lott explained that the community is facing an issue with shopping carts. He explained that on New Street, shopping carts are often seen filled with trash, left on sidewalks, and placed on any corner where they can fit.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Bishop Lott stated that they purchased brooms and encouraged individuals to clean the debris. Most of the debris accumulates between the sidewalk and the curb. He explained that they asked everyone to gather the debris and clean it up. Most of the trash they are having issues with is not in the containers on private property, it is where the individuals park their

Página 145

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 9

cars. He noted that some individuals clean out their cars on the street, leaving trash along the curb and in the space between the sidewalk and the curb

Mr. Rocha stated that when it comes to needles and things of that nature, council needs to find a way to help out. The families are doing their job by using a broom to get the trash to the street so the city needs to figure out a system that comes through and will pick it up. Mr. Rocha explained that he is not sure what tools may be needed but internally there needs to be a discussion to rectify the situation.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Bishop Lott suggested that it would be best to operate the street sweepers on Mondays and Wednesdays.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca stated something to keep in mind is that the additional days of street sweeping will need to be posted otherwise the cars will not move from the location to allow the sweeping to be completed. She also explained that depending on the items that are in the street, there is a chance that the sweeper will not necessarily pick them up and some materials could be left behind. Furthermore, she explained that they will have to provide personal protective equipment to staff, as they have to clean the debris out of the sweepers. She also stated that currently the materials are sent to the Sandtown landfill and must be tested on a regular basis. If there ends up being an excessive number of questionable debris, it could affect where the city can send the waste.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that she can certainly look into providing permit parking as is done in a certain number of other places. She recommended seeking input from the community as she could not speak to whether they were working during the day or night.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Bishop Lott stated that there are parking options for the individuals who live on the street.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Bishop Lott stated that a sign indicating no parking during street sweeping would not hurt the homeowners.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Duca stated that they can have signs made.

Sean Christiansen, Capital School District Board of Education Vice President, stated that during the discussion an email was sent to Interim Superintendent Victoir Cahoon, as well as Tiffany Hamm of the transportation office to set up a meeting. The meeting would be to look at the logistics of moving the bus routes affected by the situation on Reed Street, which is on every corner between South Governors Avenue and Kirkwood Street. If it is logistically possible, they will put in to change the stops to get the students out of the area to protect the safety of the students.

Página 146

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 10

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Chief Johnson stated he would take the message of providing enforcement in those areas affected by the street sweeping. He explained that he would manage the enforcement in a way that would meet the goal of getting movement on the issues so that the cleaning process can occur, but not disproportionately hammer someone with fines and costs.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that the issue with the dice rolling comes down to trespassing. They are either on their property or not and do the property owners condone their presence or do they not? He also recommended that individuals fill out an enforcement form, which would give the police department the authority to take action on their property after hours. Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that it is likely that if they are on the sidewalk they are on city property which can create concerns of the police authority to act on. Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that they are not allowed to impede the occupant of the resident from using the sidewalk. However, that can be a subjective assessment because their presence does not necessarily equate to a crime beyond a reasonable doubt. If they do not refuse to move or yield in any kind of way, they create a situation where it is harder to complete an arrest.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mayor Christiansen stated that the city is responsible for the maintenance of the sidewalks as well as the trees that are in the little section of grass. He also stated that the maintenance of the sidewalks still falls under the responsibility of the homeowner to keep them clear when it snows.

Discussion – Community Concerns Surrounding Trespassing (Kim Adams)

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

In the absence of Ms. Adams, Mr. Anderson stated that there has to be a priority on addressing trespassing. He thanked Chief Johnson for reminding everyone about the enforcement forms and working to compile an updated list. He explained that he does not agree with the attorney general, and the decisions implemented do not represent the community when it comes to loitering and panhandling laws. He went on to explain that it is terrible that those that citizens entrust to prosecute the laws pick and choose which laws they want to prosecute at the expense of the will of the people and the safety of the citizens.

Mr. Boggerty moved for adjournment of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:16 p.m.

UTILITY COMMITTEE

The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.

Página 147

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 11

Adoption of Agenda Dr. Pillsbury moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.

Evaluation of Bids – Persimmon Park Place Drainage Basin Improvements (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and analysis of the evaluation of bids for the Persimmon Park Place Drainage Basin Improvements.

Staff recommended awarding the contract to Gateway Construction, Inc. for the Persimmon Park Place Drainage Basin Improvements, ITB #25-0006WW, for $1,198,025.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the original project was originally developed in the late 80s, and the statute of limitations would be over for anyone to approach the prior developer.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that all of the funding comes from a bond bill, and the only thing that would come out of the budget would be the time of staff.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that the local vendor preference is a part of the procurement policy. It is an incentive to have local businesses bid on projects to keep the work local. When there is a three percent reduction, it is not that the price will be reduced by three percent, it is the evaluated price. For example, George and Lynch, which has a Dover proper address and local vendor preference, have an evaluated price three percent lower than the base bid.

Mr. Rocha moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation to award the contract to Gateway Construction, Inc. The motion was seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty and Rocha absent)

Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:25 p.m.

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.

Página 148

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 12

Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Shevock and
unanimously carried.

Presentation – Unsheltered Working Group (Leandra Marshall) Mr. Alex Cropper, Unsheltered Working Group Chair, and Ms. Leandra Marshall, Vice Chair, reviewed the presentation titled “Greater Kent County Coalition Plan” (Attachment #2).

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Cropper stated that intake would be completed at a service center or hub. Once the individual arrives at a facility an assessment will be done and placed in their electronic health record. He explained that they will be mirroring the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s (HUD) system Homeless Management Information System (HMIS) to keep the data mainstream. This would allow for resources that are needed to be identified and where they are needed. The individual will be assigned to a case worker and put into a housing placement. The only housing access they currently have available is 14 acres of land that was identified during the research process.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Cropper stated they will be collaborating with drug organizations throughout the state. If those organizations wish to do the intakes and assessments, they will have access to the proposed systems as well. He explained that he chose the proposed system because it allows unlimited users and allows for reports of data collected.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Cropper stated that they would have medical staff on site.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Cropper stated that the Capital Park location is scheduled to have a nurse practitioner, a psychiatric nurse practitioner, and a medical nurse practitioner. The hub locations will also have nurse practitioners and medical providers and will incorporate telehealth services.

Ms. Marshall stated that they have additional information regarding the nurse practitioners and qualified staff, not only at Synergy Recovery Solutions but also from the agencies and organizations they will be collaborating with within the Greater Kent County Coalition.

Ms. Marshall further explained that they did a lot of comprehensive research to evaluate where the gaps were and what things were missing. She explained that they needed to look at the organizations and evaluate their services. Mr. Cropper then conducted additional research on what other places were doing and what approaches were successful, which enabled them to develop their plan. She explained that they took an extra step by verifying the organization's licenses, as

Página 149

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 13

many did not have all the necessary paperwork. She emphasized that they would establish memorandums of understanding with those organizations and ensure they are certified and accredited in their respective areas of expertise.

Ms. Marshall explained that they have five sober living houses willing to assist in the process, ensuring that once a person begins treatment, they are not returned to the street or the same environment they started in.

Discussion – Update on the State Pension (Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director) Ms. Naomi Poole, Human Resources Director, updated the committee on the status of the state pension.

Ms. Poole stated that a link was sent out to eligible employees who do not currently have a pension to determine their interest in the state pension. The preliminary figures show that seventy-nine said yes, they were interested, forty- one people needed more information, and eight said no. She explained that she created a FAQ sheet answering questions that she felt employees may ask and providing them with responses.

She explained that the next task would be to schedule a representative from the state pension office to conduct a question-and-answer session with the eligible employees, which would be scheduled for November 6, 2024, at 1:00 p.m. She asked that employees send questions ahead of time, so the representatives are prepared to answer them. Also, they planned to record the session since the representatives were only available for one meeting.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Poole stated that she would leave the timeline up to Mr. Hugg because the state pension board still needed to give approval, and the resolution would need to include a new effective date.

Presentation – Council Dashboard (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager) Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, reviewed the background and analysis of the Council Dashboard presentation.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Duca stated that a presentation on how to use the system would be provided.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that the portal can be used from a desktop or phone.

Página 150

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 14

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that she would provide the City Clerk’s office with links as soon as the final adjustments are made.

Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Duca stated that the Code Enforcement Department is a receiving agency. The Fire Marshal’s office was not included based on the current issues received from council however, they could be added later if needed. The Fire Department was not included because most of the issues that would be received would be constituted as an emergency therefore the proposed process would take too long to track the issue.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Duca stated that to report a constituent issue, council will contact either herself or the City Clerk’s Office. Based on the GIS recommendations, they will enter the information into the system and begin tracking it from there.

Proposed Resolution No. 2024-15 – Creating Economic and Community Development Funds (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the background and analysis of Resolution No. 2024-15 – Creating Economic and Community Development Funds.

Staff recommended adopting Resolution No. 2024-15 establishing Economic Development and Community Development Funds.

City Manager Hugg explained that in March of 2023, the city realized that they were receiving significant amounts of funds from some of the property sales that were going on and that they really should be segregated so that they could use them for more dedicated purposes and not simply to augment the general fund.

Mr. Hugg further explained that he was given a draft of an economic development fund, and the minutes from that meeting suggest that committee action was not required. Mr. Hugg stated that even though the council committee did not take action at that time, an economic development fund was created. He further explained that when the city received a million dollars from the Garrison Oak proceeds, the money was placed into a special revenue fund at that time.

Mr. Hugg explained that they have spent approximately $260,000 of that money to have Chesapeake Utilities advance install gas lines in the park. Mr. Hugg stated that they have approximately $700,000 left in that fund.

Mr. Hugg explained that in discussions with the mayor and the council president, it seemed that they should officially create this fund and not just have it be there because they thought it was a good idea a couple of years ago. He further explained that there are two funds, one for community development and the second fund for economic development. There are some thresholds for minimum

Página 151

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 15

and maximum amounts to open the funds. Mr. Hugg stated that both funds will be set up as special revenue funds.

Mr. Hugg went on to explain that what is a bit different is that council needs to provide input on each of the two funds. They have created a mechanism where the appropriate council committee will consider the request to spend the money, and it will then require the approval of the committee chair and the city manager to initiate the expenditure

Mr. Hugg stated that they are working to put a mechanism in place so that those most directly involved, such as the Community Development Committee, will have an opportunity to provide input. He explained the need to develop some guidelines for this process.

Mayor Christiansen explained that one of the responsibilities of the mayor's office is economic development, and he believes it is a great idea to develop an economic development fund with a solid base to operate from and move forward. He further stated that as they consider future economic development, land acquisitions, and other projects, it is essential to have a cash reserve in place to avoid drawing from the general fund budget. Mayor Christiansen expressed his support for this fund.

Mr. Hugg added to the discussion that the proceeds for the fund will come from respective land sales or other sources. As the city disposes of property to improve the community, that will serve as a funding source for community development. Mr. Hugg further added that as the city finalizes the remaining lots at Garrison Oak, those proceeds will also contribute to the economic development fund

Mr. Anderson moved to recommend adoption of proposed Resolution No.
2024-15, establishing an economic and community Development fund, as
recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and
unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:30 p.m.

Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:30 p.m.

Página 152

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 16

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT OF NOVEMBER

12, 2024 The Council Committee of the Whole met on November 12, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Acting Council President Arndt presiding. Members of Council present were Mr. Boggerty (via Webex), Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Dr. Sudler. Council President Anderson was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Iriowen (out at 7:49 p.m.), and Mr. Wilson (Utility).

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.

Council Reports – October 2024

First District Dr. Pillsbury reported that she attended the Habitat for Humanity dinner on Saturday and that it was very well attended, except for the attendees from the City of Dover. She noted that only five people had come from the City of Dover. She announced that next Monday, November 18, 2024, she would be meeting with Chief Johnson to qualify with weapons, and anyone interested is welcome to join her. They will need to be at the location by 4:30 p.m. and, if anyone is interested, they should let Chief Johnson or herself know. On December 12, 2024, they would be having a District One Town Hall meeting at the Fire Station.

Mr. Rocha reiterated Dr. Pillsbury's announcement and reminded everyone that the First District would be having a meeting on December 12, 2024, at 6:30 p.m. He noted that he has been working with the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and on November 13, 2024, the Homeless Resource Fair at Dover Christian Church. The address for the Dover Christian Church is 1738 Forest Avenue. Mayor Christiansen and several officials would be present. Mr. Rocha stated that if Mr. Lewis’s schedule permits, he would attend, along with Dr. Pillsbury.

Second District Mr. Hare reported that a flyer for the Shepherd Place was on Council’s desks. The event will be held on Saturday, November 16, 2024. He noted that any help would be appreciated and mentioned that he had stopped by Shepherd Place to speak with the director. Mr. Hare encouraged everyone to visit and engage with the organization, emphasizing that any contribution or assistance would be appreciated.

Página 153

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 17

Mr. Lewis had nothing to report.

Third District Mr. Neil stated that he had attended the Dover Downtown Partnership (DDP) and the Kent County Tourism meetings. He had attended the Habitat for Humanity dinner and attended the Delaware League of Local Governments (DLLG) meeting that discussed the chemicals and water supply. He also attended a State Legislative Task Force meeting as a member of the Manufactured Housing Subcommittee. Mr. Neil attended a public open house of the Dover Municipal Freight Plan at the library. Mr. Neil has received several phone calls and emails, including concerns about the speed at Dover Motor Speedway and the rollout of the stormwater service fees, which he noted has been rather bumpy. He attended meetings as the utility chair with Mr. Hugg, Mayor Christiansen, and Mr. Novak and his team. He noted that Mr. Novak addressed the Dover Motor Speedway concern, but that the vice president had not informed the general manager about what was discussed. In addition to that meeting, he attended a meeting with over 50 residents at Wild Meadows. He had extensive emails from a homeowner because of the unique situation that was faced by the lease land community.

Mr. Neil explained that he filed a complaint with the Department of Justice (DOJ) regarding Wild Meadows's 2025 rent increase and requested and attended a meeting with the Dover Committee Community Police, with the HOA President and the manager of Persimmon Park Place (PPP). The meeting focused on a homeowner and management within the leasehold common interest community. Additionally, Mr. Neil completed the IT testing program.

He sent a special report in the Wild Meadows November Newsletter and referred a constituent to the Community Legal Aid Society for Legal help. A constituent questioned about the need for a camera near the synagogue on Queens Street and a constituent problem with a light being out on Townsend Boulevard. The report by Ms. Duca indicated that they were aware of the problem created by burying the overhead electrical lights. This situation was referred to as an unintended consequence and involved an email exchange with the East Lake resident, who had a problem with dogs. Additionally, a constituent from North State Street expressed gratitude for the leveled sidewalks, and their appreciation was forwarded to Ms. Duca and Mr. Novak.

Ms. Arndt shared that she had attended several meetings with Nr. Neil, and brought up an additional constituent issue at Persimmon Park Place. The concern was about the need for a bus stop and a sidewalk for children to ensure their safety while walking to the bus. She also mentioned that she attended the Citizens Police Academy, a nine-week course, and found it insightful. Ms. Arndt appreciated gaining a better understanding of the daily challenges officers face and encouraged others to attend, noting that the academy runs once a year, with the final session taking place next week.

Página 154

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 18

Fourth District Dr. Sudler stated that on November 8, 2024, at 4:00 p.m. he met with Mr. Boggerty and Mr. Anderson, the owner and a staff member of the Duncan Center to discuss erosion in their parking lot caused by heavy rainfall or by a burst of pipes near their manhole. The discussion was centered on who was responsible for the repairs to the parking lot, which has caused major parking lot sinkhole damage. They advised the Duncan Center administration to contact the Assistant City Manager and State Representatives to examine prospective steps moving forward.

At-Large
Mr. Boggerty had nothing to report.

Council President Anderson
Council President Anderson was absent.

UTILITY COMMITTEE

The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Dr. Pillsbury moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.

Evaluation of Bids – Brandywine Court Condominiums Water Service Replacement (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Brandywine Court Condominiums Water Service Replacement.

Staff recommended awarding the contract to Gateway Construction, Inc. for the Brandywine Court Condominiums Water Service Replacement, ITB#25- 0009WW, for $371,660.00.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that they have used Gateway Construction for a current stormwater project that is next to the library parking lot.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon rated Gateway Construction as extremely satisfactory. They have done some water main replacement projects as well as emergency projects for them. When the city had a sewer or water break, they stepped up for the city.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the Brandywine Court Condominiums was a private entity.

Página 155

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 19

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon clarified that they are not replacing the water line in the Brandywine Court Condominium Association. Instead, they were stubbing out the water services to each individual building, as outlined in the handbook. Mr. Lyon further clarified that the Brandywine Court Condominium Association can have water service to each building, but the association would need to hire a private plumber to complete the connections to each building’s water service. He explained that the work stopped at the easement line of the water main, and the project would use federal funds to provide the condominium association with the opportunity to connect to water and to disregard their aged infrastructure. He emphasized that federal funding was not allocated to private entities. Instead, it would follow a process similar to bond bill funding or Community Transportation Fund (CTF) funding.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the project could be coordinated through the City of Dover, provided there was available funding from the federal government.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the city would be responsible for carrying out the project under the infrastructure law.

Dr. Pillsbury moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

Evaluation of Bids – Puncheon Run Pump Station Roof Replacement (Jason
Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director)
Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and
analysis regarding the Brandywine Court Condominiums Water Service
Replacement.

Staff recommended awarding the contract to Kirkin Exteriors for the Puncheon Run Pump Station Roof Replacement, for $52,168.00.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the flow would go to the county, and they own the building.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon clarified that the wastewater in the city would go to the county at Frederica’s wastewater treatment facility, which operates under a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit. He explained that the city operated its wastewater treatment facility several years ago, but now the city has been a contract user of the county’s wastewater system for nearly 50 years. Mr. Lyon clarified that the wastewater

Página 156

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 20

flow from the city is directed to the Punch-to-Run station, located between Lynnhaven Drive and Webb’s Lane, where it is collected in a basin. From there, the wastewater is sent to the county’s treatment facility for processing and, after treatment, is deposited back into the environment.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon noted that the city pays the county for wastewater services, and the cost is structured as a pass-through expense that is billed to the citizens. There is a line item for the city sewer fee and another line item for the county sewer.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that he would rate the project as a critical situation that must be addressed within this fiscal year. He emphasized that the components inside the station are extremely expensive and high-tech. The roof leaks, allowing water to get inside, which could lead to component failures and potentially trigger a catastrophic event, such as sewer spilling out of the building. He further noted that there is a river directly next to the building, adding to the urgency of the situation.

Responding to Mr. Iriowen, Mr. Lyon stated that the city has used Kirkin Exteriors on several facility roof replacement projects in the past. He mentioned that the company has been very forthright in its dealings, and after speaking with the facilities team that managed those projects, they have nothing but positive feedback about their work.

Responding to Mr. Iriowen, Mr. Lyon stated that he could only speak about the lasting quality of the work done on the projects Kirkin Exteriors has completed recently. He noted that these projects appear to be holding up adequately. While he has not personally reviewed all of their projects in detail, he trusts the judgment of the facilities team that manages those projects and has heard nothing but positive feedback from them.

Responding to Mr. Iriowen, Mr. Lyon stated that they recently completed a project for another pump station roof replacement on the east side of town. This was a smaller-scope project that did not require Council approval due to the funding amount. He noted that the team addressed the work promptly, and the project was completed without any issues. The pump station had been experiencing water leakage, which was a significant concern, but since the roof replacement, no further issues have been observed.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the pump station was built in the 1960s, though he was unsure of the exact date.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that an evaluation was included in the Wastewater Master Plan presented to the Utility Committee about a month ago. Prior to that, the facilities team conducts routine checks on facilities throughout

Página 157

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 21

the city, including the pump stations. Mr. Lyon stated that he would need to check with the facilities team on the exact rate that they check on them.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the roof only needs to be replaced for the pump station and that it would cost $52,000.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that they went through a competitive bidding process and believed that this was the best option available at the time. He explained that the building is fairly large with a flat roof, which includes several components, as well as the vapor barrier mentioned earlier.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon explained that the roof would be an Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer (EPDM) roof, which is the material commonly used for flat roofs. He mentioned that they could go over the specifications and installation process, which would include a vapor barrier rubber overlap to prevent leaks. Mr. Lyon stated that he could provide a detailed quote if necessary for the committee.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the life expectancy of the proposed roof was a 20-year manufacturer with a 15-year craftsmanship warranty.

Responding to Mr. Lyon, Dr. Sudler expressed his concerns about the roof costs. While he understood the complexity of the project, he questioned the value, given that the roof has only a 15 to 20-year life expectancy. He was concerned that the price of the roof did not align with the relatively short lifespan it would provide.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that it was not his area of expertise and that he would talk with the facilities team to address the concerns. He noted that when the paperwork was submitted by the different bidders, there were no concerns raised regarding the roof’s lifespan. He explained that he does not know the actual industry standard for the flat roof material used.

Responding to Mr. Lyon, Dr. Sudler suggested that they wait to receive additional information on the lifespan of the typical flat roof and consider reopening the bid. He expressed concerns that the cost of a flat roof with limited coverage might not be the best option.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Lyon stated that the original building was built in the 1960s. He is unsure of how long the particular roof has been in place, but he will check with the facilities team to find out.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Lyon stated that based on his experience with a smaller pump station, which had less flow, a component failure occurred about seven years ago, costing upwards of $200,000 for cleanup and repairs, excluding overtime staff costs. The pump station in question handles approximately one and a half times more flow. Using the equations from seven years ago, adjusted for

Página 158

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 22

inflation, the cost could approach half a million dollars. He emphasized that if something were to happen, especially since the station is near a river, it could significantly impact the environment. He believes it is not worth waiting, as delaying the repairs could result in much higher costs in the long run.

Mr. Neil stated that the pump station in question is located near Route 13, close to the Home Depot area. He expressed his belief that they should not wait, as any issues that arise could lead to significantly higher costs in the long run.

Dr. Pillsbury believes that because the roof is flat, its life expectancy is much shorter than that of a typical resident or office-type roof. She explained that water, snow, and ice tend to accumulate on flat roofs, which increases the likelihood of damage. Despite these concerns, Dr. Pillsbury stated that she supported the proposal.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that while he does not believe the roof would collapse immediately, the project was included in the budget in March 2023, when they first became aware of the issue. After consulting with the facilities team, he explained that the roofing companies typically do not keep their prices firm for long. He noted that a standard bid process, as Mr. Lewis mentioned, would take one to two months, during which time they could risk higher costs due to price changes or potentially different pricing for a longer warranty from another company.

Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Lyon stated that the roof surface area would be close to 2,000 square feet.

Ms. Arndt stated that after reviewing the three bids, the bid before them was the lowest of the three. She believes that it is competitive and trusts the specifications that were provided to determine the final costs. Ms. Arndt does not see a need to rebid and express confidence in both the bid before them and the staff’s expertise in selecting the contractor.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that there had been standing water in some locations, skylights were tearing apart from the roof, and some skylights that are in the building were pulling away from the membrane. He noted that those are two major issues that he has seen. If it rains, there would be leakage in the building, though it would be minimal and not a critical issue.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon stated that in the other bids, they had guaranteed the same as Kirkin Exteriors. He noted that he did do a Google search and with a flat roof, the life expectancy would be between 15 to 25 years.

For the record, Mr. Lewis stated with hesitation and for the safety of civilians that he would vote yes.

Página 159

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 23

Dr. Pillsbury moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by unanimous roll call vote.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

Dedication of Rights-of-Way and Public Infrastructure – Patriot Village (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the background and analysis of the Dedication of Rights-of-Way and Public Infrastructure for Patriot Village.

Staff recommended accepting the dedication of rights-of-way and public infrastructure of the Patriot Village Subdivision. Dedication is to include all of the referenced public improvements noted in Attachment A.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon emphasized that the financial impact of the budget over the next year or two was expected to be minimal. On the water and wastewater side, he pointed out that the infrastructure is new, which would reduce the likelihood of significant work outside of routine maintenance tasks, such as maintaining the fire hydrants. Additionally, he noted that snow removal may be required if it snowed, but given the limited length of road involved, it would not have a substantial effect on the budget.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Lyon clarified that the Patriot Village community is working together to pull the funding to do the upgrade.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Lyon clarified that the roads are up to the standards of the city. The building was subdivided into a design portion, and they were told that there was a certain width for the curb and sidewalk, so they built it per the plan.

Dr. Sudler moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

Discussion – Stormwater Utility Billing Concerns (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager) Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, and Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director reviewed the Stormwater Utility Billing Concerns.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Página 160

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 24

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca noted that the annual operational costs are expected to range between $1.1 to $1.2 million, with adjustments for inflation over time. She emphasized that the projects best suited for funding through the infrastructure bill would fall under the capital program. These capital programs typically progress through feasibility, design, and construction in different years. Projects that are well-designed and prepared are likely to receive favorable consideration from the federal government for funding acceptance. By securing funding for capital projects from external sources, such as the infrastructure bill, the financial burden on rates could be reduced.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca highlighted that obtaining funds from the $11.7 billion being allocated to states would be the preferred approach, rather than continuing along their current path. She noted that one of the projects under the capital program involved the meeting house branch and improvements to PW2. However, eligibility for funding under the infrastructure bill would need to be verified, especially given that PW2 had contamination issues caused by the City of Dover.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Duca mentioned several concerns that have been raised with the Customer Service and Public Works Departments. The Public Works Department has been reviewing billing discrepancy issues, such as residents receiving a commercial bill as to a residential bill. The Public Works Department has been working to resolve these discrepancies and address the concerns that have been brought forward.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Mark Nowak, Public Works Director, clarified that the billing label “commercial” could be misleading. He explained that while the tier might be labeled as commercial and all other, it applies to properties that are not in a residential zone, such as manufactured housing. If a property is in any zone other than residential, it is categorized under a commercial tier for billing purposes. If the bill has a “C” for commercial, it does not mean that they are being charged because they are in a commercial zone, it is just not a residential zone.

Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Nowak explained that the credits and appeals manuals outline a process for parcel owners to appeal their tier classification if they believe it was assigned incorrectly. He emphasized that Public Works has been handling over 30 phone calls daily about the issue, not including emails and other inquiries. Staff have been informing customers about the credits and appeals manual and addressing their concerns. Mr. Nowak noted that the billing should have indicated “all other” rather than “commercial/all other” on the bill because it is anything other than residential zoning. He reassured customers that there was a way to request a tier reassignment through the appeal process, which involved a review of the case.

Página 161

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 25

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Duca stated that some of the projects were cut in previous years because of limited funding. Several capital projects that they are looking at are receiving more complaints about drainage concerns. Ms. Duca noted that they are finding some failed infrastructure in certain locations with sinkholes. They are doing their best to patch them up, but they are trying to address the overall infrastructure problem.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Duca noted that they have ignored the problems for the past eight years.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Duca explained that currently the transfer from the electric fund is capped at $10 million per year, which is what they had included in the budget that followed the financial policy. Doing any further work would require an act of council to change it under the advisement, which would most likely affect the bond rating to go above $10 million.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director, stated that they had to set it up as a general bill because that was where the tax bills were in the Tyler Program and that would be different from the utility bills, different customer and location numbers. Ms. Haines noted that they have made it easier for them to pay online and that they have taken off the part where they would have to set up an account, so they could use their customer number or the invoice number and make a credit card payment. She further noted that they could mail the bills to Wilmington, and at the office, payments could be made via cash, check, or money order, or customers could use the drop-off boxes. Ms. Haines stated that they are looking to rewrite some of the information on the bills to make it easier for people because they do not know their parcel ID numbers. The Tyler Program currently handles the payment of taxes, and at the moment, they are exploring the possibility of setting up automatic payments. However, this feature is not feasible at this time.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Haines stated that it could not be the same account number because then the payments would go to the utility bill. She clarified that if customers pay through bill pay, they must set up the bill with a different customer number, ensuring that the payment is sent to a different lockbox address than their utility bill. This is necessary to keep the funds separate, as the system for tax payments and utility payments operate in two different systems.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Haines clarified that customers received a double- sided flyer, with one side containing information about the stormwater utility, and the other side about the sanitation enterprise fund. This flyer was sent out with the utility bills for July and August. She noted that the same information was available on the website and that it would also be included with the tax bills. Exempt parcels would not be required to pay the fee, and the homeowner's cost would increase.

Página 162

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 26

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Nowak stated that based on the size of the lot versus the size of the impervious surface would not factor in as a credit to reduce the bill. He explained that it is based on the allowable impervious surface according to the person’s zoning as outlined in the code. The classification of the property is grouped according to its zone, rather than the specific size of the impervious surface relative to the lot.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Nowak stated that they do not calculate the impervious surface for residential zones, it is only for commercial or all other zones. Mr. Nowak noted that they only use the allowable impervious surface according to the zoning. In communities, people could apply for credits depending on whether they have stormwater ponds in their community, swales, or things of that nature. He suggested that a homeowner’s association put together a meeting and figure it out. There was a question from the Village of Westover regarding their ponds. They do not go case by case. He stated that a parcel owner can appeal their tier, but it had to be justifiable according to the credits and appeals manual, which would be reviewed by him. Mr. Nowak would then give a response in 60 days, and then if the customer does not agree with the response, they can appeal to the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Nowak clarified that if a neighborhood has a stormwater management pond, then all homes within that neighborhood would be able to take advantage of the credit for having the stormwater pond. He stated that there are certain criteria that they need to provide to the city that are in the credits and appeals manual. It states what they need to do, but everyone would get that credit.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Nowak stated that the homeowner’s association would be able to apply on behalf of the entire neighborhood and the city would adjust the rate for all of the parcels in that neighborhood.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Nowak stated that the Public Works Department has been able to provide customers with information and discuss the credits and appeals manual on a one-on-one basis. Mr. Nowak noted that they are providing them with guidance and what options are available to them. Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Haines stated that the Customer Service Department has been forwarding customers a link to the credit and appeals manual with instructions on how to pay. She noted that the flyer that was sent out contained information on how customers could apply for the credit. Ms. Haines stated that when customers call, she provides them a link via email so that more detailed information can be sent. Unfortunately, she mentioned that more questions are being directed at the Public Works Department as a result.

Ms. Arndt suggested organizing an interactive webinar where customers could listen and go through the appeals process. She noted that the webinar could be recorded, allowing customers to view it later, and that it would provide an

Página 163

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 27

opportunity to take comments and address their concerns. could listen to the recording, and they could take comments and address their concerns.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that $5 million was available through the state only for wastewater projects, not for stormwater.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca explained that #5 other funding sources, one example is the Community Transportation Fund (CTF). Currently, CTF is funding a project for Bogs Drive to address drainage concerns, with legislators assisting in covering the cost of the design. Additionally, the Meeting House Branch project was supported by state bond fill funding. Ms. Duca clarified that the capital budget for fiscal year 2027 included $10 million, which incorporates both city and state funding, helping to offset some of the project requirements.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that most of the stormwater projects would be classified as community development-related projects. Ms. Duca highlighted ongoing concerns from constituents, particularly in older neighborhoods with insufficient drainage infrastructure, such as fewer catch basins. This often results in roadway ponding and related issues.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that the community development funds from the sale of city properties. The parcels recently reviewed could likely cover the cost of a feasibility study, but there would not be enough funding for construction. Therefore, the community development funds would not be sufficient for the entire project.

Dr. Sudler expressed concern that employees are spending excessive time addressing issues related to the new process, which detracts from productivity and costs the city money. He suggested that the city return to relying more heavily on grants to meet its funding needs, rather than placing the burden on constituents. He emphasized that taxpayers, who are already financially strained, have been affected by raising utility bills over the past three years.

Dr. Sudler agreed with Mr. Hare's suggestion to explore alternative funding sources and reduce the reliance on taxpayers. He proposed leveraging resources such as Delaware State University and nearby institutions, which could assist with grant writing to support city projects. This collaboration, he argued, would provide relief to residents, improve their quality of life, and benefit the council by offering a more sustainable financial strategy.

Additionally, Dr. Sudler pointed to opportunities under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and EPA grants, which he viewed as attainable sources for covering infrastructure costs. He expressed discomfort with the current method of generating income for the city and strongly advocated abandoning the existing approach in favor of pursuing alternative funding avenues.

Página 164

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 28

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Duca stated that she would need to gather information to determine the exact amount currently available in the Water and Wastewater System Reserve Fund (WWSRF) and would provide an update once the details are confirmed.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Marney stated that she would need to confirm the exact amount currently held in the Electric Reserve fund and would provide that information once it was available.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney stated that the city did generate some revenue by supporting states in the southern U.S. with electricity during hurricane recovery efforts. She noted that the income was added to the city’s reserves and stated that she would provide the specific financial details upon request.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg clarified that the funds referenced by Dr. Sudler pertained to the Meeting House Square and the drainage program around that section of the city. He noted that these funds were committed and have not yet been spent. The money had a specific, dedicated purpose, and redirecting it to another use would negatively impact the Meeting House Square initiative. Mr. Hugg also shared that he had received a call from the property owner and Senator Paradee regarding the responsibility for a particular pipe. Based on his understanding, the pipe was installed when the building was originally constructed by its initial owner, although he could not confirm this conclusively. He further explained that the type of infrastructure was not something the city regularly maintained.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg strongly suggested that they avoid using the community development funds for the project due to the critical nature of the Meeting House Branch drainage project, which has been in development for several years and is essential to address ongoing drainage concerns.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Lyon clarified that the funding from Senator Paradee was earmarked for the Meeting House Branch project along with the Persimmon Tree drainage project, as presented to the committee last session. He noted that the funds have an expiration date of June 30, 2026. Currently, they are in the design phase and working with the Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control (DNREC) to develop an appropriate work plan, particularly given the challenges of dealing with contaminated soil. Additionally, they are collaborating with Bayhealth to redesign its property to accommodate upstream stormwater improvements. The redesign was considered in Bayhealth’s long-term plans, which would include constructing a building over the area in question. Mr. Lyon reiterated that while they are still in the design phase, the funding remained secure until the specified expiration date.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Mr. Lyon clarified that the money was for the Meeting House Branch project.

Página 165

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 29

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Duca explained that part of the money budgeted for the capital project was allocated for the necessary remediation work. The funding received through the bond bill would specifically cover the actual construction of the improvements, not the remediation efforts.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Duca clarified that the construction remediation is more than $3 million.

Mr. Neil explained that there were two categories for residents living on leased land: those who pay property taxes because their homes have been assessed, and those who pay an annual fee, often collected by the community owner and remitted. He pointed out that the funding for projects could lead to higher rents for those residents, creating a unique issue regarding their classification as residential. He stated that the situation is nuanced because these properties are residential but also not entirely straightforward. Mr. Neil mentioned that a packet had been provided for Mr. Nowak to review the process of appealing the matter. Mr. Neil highlighted concerns regarding the appeals process, noting that some individuals in leased land situations are incorrectly identified as property owners, which they are not. Misclassification creates challenges that need resolution. Mr. Neil emphasized that the issues with the Tyler system and any related platforms need to be resolved. He pointed out that resolving those technical issues would allow residents to make regular payments, including their monthly bills and taxes, through an integrated process. He expressed that the current situation was unsatisfactory and created unnecessary challenges for those who are willing and able to pay.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Hugg explained that the budget put together and enacted by the council was designed with the establishment of the enterprise fund in mind. The general funding portion of the budget assumed that certain expenses would not be charged to the general fund. He clarified that if any changes were made to the budget, a budget amendment would be necessary. That would allow for a detailed review of the budget to identify whether there are other funds the council wishes to transfer or if an alternative mechanism needs to be found to increase general fund revenue to cover additional costs.

Responding to Mr. Hugg, Ms. Arndt stated that she would be in favor of making modifications, and that would reduce the revenue that they would collect and offset that somewhere else.

Mr. Neil cautioned that there was uncertainty when it came to securing grants and that the city should not rely on them as guaranteed funding. He emphasized the importance of focusing on what they could reliably count on and maximizing the grants that they could secure. He suggested that by leveraging available funding sources, the council could minimize the impact on the general fund while still

Página 166

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 30

advancing essential projects. The approach will provide flexibility if they need to shift money around to address any funding gaps.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that, to his understanding, the council’s discussions about the stormwater program began between 2015 and 2017. These discussions eventually culminated in the decision to create a utility to cover the associated costs. He clarified that he was not involved at that time, but that the creation of the utility was the result of several years of deliberations within council.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg mentioned that while there was always a possibility of receiving funding, the chances of securing money for general operations were slim. However, there is a higher likelihood of receiving funding for specific projects. For example, if they had a significant stormwater pond that was failing and needed to be rebuilt, it might be possible to receive assistance from the general assembly for that particular project. He noted that they did not receive any general assembly funding for running the program itself.

Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that they used a financial model originally developed by a consultant to project over a five-year period. The model accounted for both personnel expenses and regular operating costs, including items like leaf collection, as well as the proposed capital program. By utilizing the model, they adjusted the capital program to make it more manageable, as attempting to include everything within five years was becoming too costly.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Nowak explained that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) created the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDS) program, which was administered through the State of Delaware Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control (DNREC). The program ensured that the city remained compliant with environmental regulations, and it is reviewed every five years. The most recent review was extended to 10 years due to organizational issues, but now it is more stringent. The city is required to follow specific guidelines, or risk citations and fines. He noted that the stormwater coordinator and environmental scientists have been actively enforcing regulations, and the sanitation division helps by notifying the department whenever issues arise, such as grass clippings and things of that nature. If compliance is not met, code enforcement steps in.

Mr. Nowak explained that the outfall inspections have become more demanding, with the inspection rate increasing from 5% to 20% per year. This year, the team worked with the fire department to inspect outfalls at Silver Lake, which had never been inspected before. The city was also required to comply with mandates regarding chemical containment at facilities like the fleet shop and pump stations. Additionally, Mr. Nowak mentioned that a new outreach program was mandated, and they had to prove that it was completed. He expects that the process will become even more cumbersome in five years when a new permit is required.

Página 167

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 31

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Nowak stated that fines were imposed when there was an issue with handling the process in a disorganized manner through the Planning Department. He indicated that the lack of effort or proper coordination contributed to the problem, which led to the fines. He noted that he was not directly involved in the matter and could not provide detailed information. He offered to look into it further for more details.

Arielle Rivera, Assistant City Clerk, read an email from Donna Mitchell regarding the stormwater utility fees. (Attachment #1)

Responding to Ms. Mitchell, Ms. Duca stated that the legality of the proposal has been researched and found to be legal. She also mentioned the utility was modeled after the system in Newark, which operated as an enterprise fund.

Responding to Ms. Mitchell, Ms. Duca clarified that the classification of commercial and all other customers was not determined by zoning but by the actual impervious surface on their property. She reiterated Mr. Nowak’s point that the property owners can request a review and potentially receive credit by following the process outlined in the credits and appeals manual, which addresses those calculations.

Responding to Ms. Mitchell, Ms. Duca stated that the billing is completed by using the property tax module in the Tyler System.

Responding to Ms. Mitchell, Ms. Haines stated that bank drafting was currently not supported by the Tyler system. However, residents can make payments using their checking accounts through EFT on the website, pay with a credit card, visit the office, or mail payments to Wilmington. She noted that the team is exploring the option of enabling bank drafting but working with Tyler has limitations.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca acknowledged her awareness of the $11.7 billion grant from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and the EPA’s Clean Water State Revolving Fund. She noted that while their previous grant writer had applied for projects under this initiative, the success was limited, and they only received a portion of the requested funding. Despite the challenges, she confirmed that they intend to explore the funding opportunity again for future projects.

Dr. Sudler moved that the City Manager and supporting staff review the criteria for submitting a letter of interest for funding through the Sewer Overflow and Stormwater Reuse Municipal Grant program to help the capital of Delaware address the stormwater and sewer infrastructure needs and provide the committee with an update by the subsequent Utility committee meeting. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis.

Página 168

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 32

Mr. Hare amended the motion to add having staff review the Wastewater Revolving Fund and the electric reserve fund to determine the amount in each. Then, the council can hold a budget review with the possibility of a budget amendment. Mr. Hare would like to see if there was money to cover the $2 million needed for the year.

Dr. Sudler and Mr. Lewis were amenable to the amendment.

Dr. Sudler stated for the record that council and the committee as a whole, needed to start moving towards a quarterly budget review. He emphasized that the approach would allow them to address issues more proactively quarterly rather than annually since they are not seeing what they need to see throughout the year in a budgetary manner.

Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Hare stated that the largest bill a business had received was for Edgewell, amounting to $60,000, and for the quarter, the largest bill that would have been received was from Dover Speedway, totaling $40,000.

Dr. Pillsbury expressed confusion regarding the billing amounts, particularly whether the charges discussed were annual or quarterly. She noted that the discussion was about a quarterly bill and believed the charges reflected an annual amount divided into quarterly payments. She emphasized the need for clarification to ensure that the highest amount was not charged every quarter.

Dr. Sudler moved that the City Manager and supporting staff review the criteria for submitting a letter of interest for funding through the Sewer Overflow and Stormwater Reuse Municipal Grant program to help the capital of Delaware address the stormwater and sewer infrastructure needs, provide the committee with an update by the subsequent Utility committee meeting, and have staff review the Wastewater Revolving Fund and the Electric Reserve Fund to determine the amount in each. Then council could hold a budget review with the possibility of a budget amendment. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 7:59 p.m.

Ms. Arndt moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 8:00 p.m.

Página 169

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 33

By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Boggerty, Rocha absent)

MONTHLY REPORTS

By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Mr. Anderson, the following monthly reports were accepted by consent agenda (Boggerty, Rocha absent):

City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
City Manager’s Report
Controller/Treasurer’s Budget Report
Police Chief’s Report
Fire Chief’s Report

PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. 2024-15 – CREATING ECONOMIC AND

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FUNDS (DAVID S. HUGG, III, CITY MANAGER) Mr. Lewis made a motion to suspend the rules so members of the public could speak. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and failed by a roll call vote of four (4) yes, (Anderson, Sudler, Lewis, Hare), three (3) no, (Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt), and two (2) absent, (Boggerty and Rocha).

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Hugg stated that she was correct and that there was a draft of guidelines and procedures that he had shared with the council president. Mr. Hugg was awaiting comments from Mr. Anderson before proceeding. It would specify what would be required, the kind of eligible projects, and the process for dispensing money.

Ms. Arndt stated that, based on Mr. Hugg’s comments, the item would be addressed in an upcoming committee agenda, with details provided to the council. She noted that there would be an opportunity for open discussion at that time and expressed opposition to suspending the rules.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hare clarified that, as the motion failed, individuals are not permitted to ask questions regarding the resolution.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis stated that he would ask the questions on behalf of the individual, emphasizing that it was his right as a council member to bring those questions forward.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg confirmed that the proceeds would come from the sale of city-owned property. He explained that the two (2) funds would initially be managed by two (2) of the council committees, which he believed are appropriately tasked with addressing economic and community development. He stated that proposals would be presented during committee meetings, providing an opportunity for public participation.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg affirmed that the proceeds from the sale of city properties would go into the general fund, but with the proposed resolution, those funds would no longer be used to cover shortfalls in the city budget as they had in the past. He explained that previously

Página 170

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 34

when there were no designated funds, the proceeds were treated as excess or unanticipated revenue and went into the general fund. Two (2) years ago, Mr. Hugg proposed using these proceeds on a one-time basis to balance the budget, though they were not needed for that purpose and remained in the economic development fund or a similar account. He reiterated that the council committee administered those funds, with the committees holding the authority to decide their use. The resolution also includes a provision requiring council approval if those funds were to be used to offset other budget obligations.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg explained that, under item number three (3), transfers from the funds for ordinary operating expenses should only be made with a majority vote of city council and only if critical to the city’s financial condition. He clarified that if the city needs to use those funds, the council can decide whether to allocate the proceeds to either fund. He emphasized that those funds were intended for one-time, unanticipated expenditures with no guarantee of future property sales or additional proceeds. However, the funds remain under the control of two (2) council committees, and council retains the authority to direct their use for financial needs, if necessary.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg agreed with him, stating that if the funds were not available, there could be a possibility of raising property taxes and utility fees to cover a budget shortfall. He explained that if the fund had a balance and council determined it was important, they could use that balance to either balance the budget or cover unanticipated expenses, such as costs from a major weather event. However, if the funds had already been used for other projects, there would be no funds left to transfer.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg clarified that the term “off-budget fund” was not a technical term. He explained that those were special revenue funds, which would be included in the budget but were not part of the general fund’s line-item operating budget. Instead, they are accounted for as part of the fund’s balance.

Mr. Lewis made a motion to retract the resolution and postpone until council has gone through the budget process. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Mr. Hugg clarified that if the property was sold in the city and $3 million became available, council would have the authority to decide how the funds should be allocated. He emphasized that, regardless of the procedures or special funds established, it was ultimately council’s responsibility to determine how money was spent and where it should be allocated. He stated that, if a large sale occurred, council had both the right and responsibility to decide the allocation of those funds. Given the specific situation, he believed the money should be used in some way, noting that it would require a budget amendment, which always needed to be approved by council.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that there would be a set of guidelines to determine eligibility for funding. In both cases, the council committee would decide which projects are appropriate and who would receive the funds. He mentioned that community cleanup could be one of the uses for the development fund, and unless the committee had other concerns, he suspected it could be awarded to any qualified applicant who could carry out that mission.

Página 171

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 35

Dr. Sudler expressed concern that small business contractors might not be given the opportunity to bid on proposals and be awarded contracts. While he supported the concept of creating economic and community development funds, he wanted to ensure that the funds would not be restricted to nonprofit organizations. He believed the funds should be used to clean up areas that Public Works may not have the capacity to address.

Mr. Anderson explained that there would be an opportunity to draft the exact guidelines, which were not fixed in the resolution. He emphasized that the purpose of creating the resolution was to ensure that the public and the community have a voice in shaping those guidelines. It would include civilian members of the committee, who would have more flexibility to allow public discussion time to be set, part of the reason for the community development fund stemmed from a recent town hall, where the public expressed a desire for proceeds from property sales to benefit the communities from which the money originated. Mr. Anderson also highlighted that the funds are one-time money and should be reinvested back into the community.

Mr. Anderson explained that the money should be allocated back to the community rather than simply going into the general fund. He noted that some communities have specific needs, with one of the main priorities being cleanup efforts. He suggested that, in the winter, council could hire small businesses for cleanup projects. The intent was to allow nonprofits to participate in bid proposals and take turns doing weekly cleanups, which was why the term “nonprofit” was mentioned during discussions.

Regarding community development, Mr. Anderson pointed out that it was clearly defined in the code, encompassing a wide range of activities, from enhancing community quality and housing to various development projects. He suggested that, if there were concerns about funding for neighborhood watches or street cleanups, council could consider implementing one-time pilot projects to test their effectiveness before including such items in the regular budget.

Mr. Anderson emphasized his desire to ensure that people can see the benefits of ongoing initiatives without the need to create new programs, raise taxes, or rely on grant agencies, which often involve long waiting periods. He wanted to focus on achieving results more quickly and efficiently.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Dr. Sudler wanted to emphasize the need for funds to assist seniors, particularly when it comes to snow removal. He pointed out that seniors are responsible for clearing their sidewalks and suggested that some of the funds could be used to help them with the task, ensuring that the city remains in compliance with regulations. Mr. Lewis moved to retract the resolution until council has gone through the budget process. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and failed by a roll call vote of one (1) yes (Lewis), six (6) no (Anderson, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Sudler, Hare, and two (2) absent (Boggerty and Rocha).

Mr. Anderson moved for approval of Resolution No. 2024-15. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and carried by a roll call vote of six (6) yes (Anderson, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Sudler, Hare), one (1) no (Lewis), and two (2) absent (Boggerty and Rocha).

Página 172

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 36

REZONING REQUEST FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1216 MCKEE ROAD – FIRST READING OF PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2024-31 A request was received to rezone properties located at 1216 McKee Road, consisting of 1.2302 +/- acres, owned by PAM Cubed Real Estate. The property is currently zoned C-PO (Commercial and Professional Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) and the proposed zoning is IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone). (Tax Parcel: ED-05-067.00-01-34.00-000; Planning Reference: Z-24-06)

Prior to amending the zoning ordinances and zoning map of the City of Dover, a public hearing is required.

Mr. Neil moved to refer the request to the Planning Commission on December 16, 2024, and set a public hearing for January 13, 2025, at 6:30 p.m. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.

In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2024-31 as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:

ORDINANCE #2024-31 – AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1216 MCKEE ROAD.

Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the location of the proposed rezoning is on the west side of McKee Road, which is between a rehabilitation hospital and a multi-tenant commercial building at the corner of McKee Road and College Road. The property in question is a vacant tract of land. She clarified that the specific address referred to is 1205 McKee Road and that is across the street.

CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mr. Hugg had no announcements.

MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mayor Christiansen announced that the Turkey Burn 5K, sponsored by Rail Haus, would take place on Saturday, November 30, 2024, and start at 8:30 a.m. He also announced that the Annual Capital Holiday Tree Lighting Celebration would be held on December 5, 2024, from 5:00 to 8:00 p.m. Mayor Christiansen noted that it was Mr. Neil’s birthday.

COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS

Mr. Lewis shared that he had the honor of volunteering to feed the homeless at the People’s Community Center in Dover over the past weekend. He mentioned that on November 24, 2024, he volunteered with Tracy Palmer Ministries for their Annual Thanksgiving Giveaway. He wished everyone a Happy Thanksgiving.

Página 173

Item #5.

CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF NOVEMBER 25, 2024 PAGE 37

The meeting adjourned at 7:24 p.m.

ANDRIA L. BENNETT CITY CLERK

All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by the City Council during their Regular Meeting of November 25, 2024, are hereby approved.

ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR /AB

Página 174

Item #6.

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE

The Council Committee of the Whole met on November 26, 2024, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Hare, Mr. Lewis (in at 6:15 p.m.), Mr. Neil, and Mr. Rocha (via WebEx). Dr. Pillsbury and Dr. Sudler were absent. Mayor Christiansen (out at 8:16 p.m.) was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Dr. Jackson-Short (via WebEx), Ms. Smack (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation), Mr. Iriowen, Mr. Wilson (Utility), Mr. Garfinkel, and Mr. Shevock (Legislative, Finance, and Administration).

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.

Citizen Problem Reporter – Council Dashboard Training (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager) Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, reviewed the proposed Citizen Problem Reporter website created for council to track citizen concerns in real-time.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Duca stated that she would work with Mike Walker, GIS Manager, to add the mayor’s office to the city manager's office in the system.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Duca stated that the website would be an internal application that is used by internal staff. Currently, the only people able to enter concerns are herself, the City Clerk and the Assistant City Clerk to limit the number of people entering items.

SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE

The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairman Boggerty presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Safety and Relationship Between the City of Dover Police Department and Delaware State University (James Overton, Vice President of Student Affairs, and Delaware State University Police Superintendent) Mr. James Overton, Vice President of Student Affairs, and Delaware State University Police Superintendent, detailed the relationship that Delaware State University has with the City of Dover Police Department.

Mr. Overton explained that he oversees the entire university police department which is led by Police Chief Donald Baynard. He explained that upon his return, he established a Memorandum of Understanding with the Dover Police Department to outline the partnership in addressing issues

Página 175

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 2 Item #6.

both on campus and off campus. He stated that they can proudly say that through their partnership they have not had one incident that has gone unsolved.

Mr. Overton stated that all their officers attend the Dover Police Department Academy and when the university lacked officers, the City of Dover Police Department stepped up and helped fill in the gaps. He explained that Homecoming 2023 was a homecoming that he will never forget and for 2024 he was able to work with Dover Police Department, DelDOT, Fire Marshal, and County members to have a mostly incident-free homecoming. He thanked the Dover Police Department for their cherished relationship.

Chief Johnson, Dover Police Department, commended Mr. Overton for his hard work and willingness to foster a relationship with the City of Dover Police Department. He explained that Mr. Overton has been very proactive in addressing issues such as homecoming and fostering a plan to prevent any incidents. Chief Johnson stated that some of the fluidness can be attributed to training together in both the academy and drills hosted by the university.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Overton stated that they immediately worked on a solution to put a stop to the parties being held in the parks. He explained that the university does not schedule any events off campus. He stated that they have told students that if they participate in the events and represent a fraternity or sorority, and they are found to be involved, they will be held responsible on campus. Mr. Overton explained that they got word of a larger party being planned, called in the organizations, and let them know that the parties reflect poorly on the university to the City of Dover as well as the County and they needed to encourage their organizations to not participate in the parties. He further explained that they have begun to monitor social media to where students, and people from outside areas like Philadelphia, and Washington D.C. are advertising parties. Through this work, they have been able to shut them down and establish a presence before the parties begin.

Discussion – Capital School District Community Concerns Update (Sean Christiansen, Capital School District Board of Education, Vice President) Mr. Sean Christiansen, Capital School District Board of Education, Vice President, explained that on October 29, 2024, Bishop Lott had brought forth concerns regarding Capital School District students and their downtown Dover bus stops.

Mr. Christiansen explained that an onsite meeting was scheduled for October 31, 2024, with Councilman Boggerty, Mayor Christiansen, Dr. Cahoon, Ms. Hamm, Officer Piazza, a member of community policing, himself, and Bishop Lott. He stated that they walked the area to identify the issues, which were primarily at New Street and Reed Street. After that, the Capital School District began rerouting the buses for the elementary school, the middle school, and the high school. An email went out to the people present at the onsite visit, the routes were approved, and they were communicated to the parents as well as the school. The new routes went into effect on November 13, 2024, and as of November 26, 2024, there had been no issues and there was an overwhelming response from the parents expressing gratitude.

Página 176

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 3 Item #6.

Mr. Christiansen requested that council have more open lines of communication with the board if they have any issues that affect the Capital School District. He explained that the board likes to be proactive and get things done rather quickly.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Mr. Boggerty moved for adjournment of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 6:33 p.m.

UTILITY COMMITTEE

The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Hare moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Anderson and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Stormwater Utility Billing Concerns (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager) Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Stormwater Utility billing concerns.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that the last financial policy adjustment was made in 2019. She explained that the bond ratings are adhering to the bond covenants and therefore are adhering to the adjustments made to the financial policy at that time. As far as transfers are concerned, the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) states that the funds must be used for their designated purpose. Therefore, the funds must be specifically used for the electric fund and not any other fund. She explained that the stormwater utility is its own enterprise fund and the funds from the electric reserve should not be used to fund the stormwater utility.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney clarified that the reserve balance for the rate stabilization reserve cannot exceed twenty percent of the purchase power cost in any given year. She explained that she spoke with the bond counsel regarding the depreciation reserve and the financial policy dictates that the depreciation reserve needs to have a minimum balance of $10 million per bond. As of 2017, the city must maintain at least $13.6 million. She explained that there are some other things that must be considered and one of them is the payback. There is a seven-year payback period therefore if those funds were chosen to fund the process they would need to be paid back. She stated that she does not advise using those funds, but it is possible according to bond counsel as long as it does not dip below $13.6 million. She also explained that with a depreciation reserve, the specific funds are to be used for utility capital projects, specifically electric fund utility capital projects, not other enterprise fund capital projects. Lastly, she explained in speaking with Mr. Paul Wadell, Electric Director, that there is approximately $10.5 million in capital projects that will be brought forward in fiscal year 2026. By removing the proposed $5 million from the reserve he would be limited in the projects he could move forward with such as the smart metering and he would have to put that project off for several years.

Página 177

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 4 Item #6.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that he is correct in saying that if any money is utilized from the electric fund and it brings the city below the 10 percent threshold the interest rates would potentially be high because the rates at which the city receives a loan could be compromised.

Ms. Marney also explained that any time funds are taken from the electric reserve there is a direct impact on the electric rates. The citizens will either be paying through a stormwater utility rate or the electric rate.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Duca stated that if council were to use the money from the economic and community development fund, council would have to adjust the motion that was already made to designate the purpose of those funds. She also emphasized that those funds are one-time funds, so if they are not being used to invest in something else or pay operational costs they are only going to help for a limited amount of time.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Duca stated that he is correct in that the concept of the stormwater utility is not new.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney stated that the city produces about 13,301 tax bills a year.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney confirmed that number roughly represents 58 percent of the properties in the City of Dover.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney stated that they estimated that it would add between 10 and 15 cents more to the tax rate.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Duca stated that the formula to establish the fees was from a model generated by a consultant starting back in 2015. She explained that it had been modified over the years by the consultant and staff to improve the accuracy. The model based residential on their zoning district and the commercial was based upon impervious maps from the state.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney stated that he is correct in that if they go the route of taxation to cover the total expenses, 58 percent of the homeowners and businesses will incur a possible nine-and-a-half cent increase on their taxes while anyone in the city who is tax exempt will not.

Responding to Mr. Hare, Ms. Marney stated that in the past they would include a reassessment fee to pay the assessment company, which happens to be the same as the County uses, Tyler Technologies. She explained that when Ms. Bundek retired, the recommendation to council was that at the appropriate time, the city would use the County’s assessment values, and the next city assessment happens to be in January 2025. She stated that there will be some cost savings in the general fund for fiscal year 2026 regarding the reassessment.

Página 178

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 5 Item #6.

Mr. Hare moved to set the stormwater utility rate to zero, transfer funds to pay for it from the electric depreciation reserve fund in the amount of $5 million, and also find a way to refund or credit the money that people have already paid. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson.

Mike Harrington, 516 Jefferic Boulevard, Dover, stated that small businesses are suffering because of the new assessments, insurance rates are constantly on the rise, and then the stormwater utility. He explained that several of his tenants owe him thousands of dollars because they are suffering. He stated that if someone has a large parking lot, like himself, the stormwater fees were a large increase and passing them on to the tenants is hard when they are barely making it as it is.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that they have not specifically asked any of the state legislators for help in funding the stormwater utility.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that if the money is taken from the electric reserve, then the city will either have to raise taxes or the electric rates. She added that there are certain legal and regulatory requirements when funds are involved. The electric fund is restricted to being used for the electric utility. In the financial policies, it does say that a certain percentage or dollar amount can be transferred. The current dollar amount for the inter-fund transfer from the electric fund to the general fund, which is specified in the policy that it cannot be other funds, is $10 million. The city has reached that cap for fiscal year 2025. She explained that Mr. Lewis is correct in that there could be long-term implications in using the funds from the deprecation reserve and not repaying them. She emphasized that there would be a cost associated which may be in the form of a tax rate increase or an electric utility rate increase. Taking anything from the electric reserve means staff will have to go back to the rate study and the professionals that assist with that and modify the rate study and rate structure that is currently in place for the electric fund. Those changes would then affect anyone who receives an electric bill. She explained that the expenses would still exist whether they are in the general fund or a stand-alone stormwater fund because they are mandated. She also emphasized that if they are not paid there are significant fines. According to the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit there is a fine of $10,000 a day if the city does not comply with the permit.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that she would have to speculate how long it would take for the city to return to a value that would give them a better interest rate if they were to need to purchase a large piece of equipment. She stated that in talking to Paul Waddell, two transformers will need to be replaced next year, costing $2 million apiece. Taking money from a specific reserve that is in place to cover in the case of an emergency is not recommended. If something drastic happens such as a hurricane or tornado and electric utility items need to be replaced, the reserve has then been depleted. She also explained that the wording implies that there must be reserves equal to the depreciation expense. For example, the depreciation for fiscal year 2024 may be $ 4 million. Fiscal year 2025 may also be $4 million. So based on the estimation that there is $21 million, the city must keep at least $18.7 million. Even though the bond covenants say the city can go down to $13.6 million it would be best to leave $19 million, leaving a $3 million reserve for emergencies.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that if the stormwater utility were to be paid from taxes it would have required a nine-to-ten-cent increase on the tax bill. When the budget was prepared

Página 179

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 6 Item #6.

for the year, it was prepared with the understanding that the stormwater utility would have its own enterprise fund, therefore funding itself. In doing that the city was able to keep the tax increase down to around two cents and by adjusting other fees at a modest rate. Had that not been done there would have been a need for substantially more funding.

Ms. Marney stated that there could be legal replications by transferring funds from one enterprise fund to another. She asked that they return the stormwater utility expenses to the general fund to aid in the regulatory requirements that are in the financial policies. She explained that a few years ago during the budgetary process, council voted to extend the inter-fund transfer from the electric fund to the general fund. The transfer was increased from $10 million to $12 million. She stated that in the financial policies, through the budgetary process, they must find a solution in three years, next year will be three years. They will have to find a solution to the increasing costs and increasing expenses versus the lower revenues. In closing, she stated that there would be fewer regulatory issues if the money is pulled from the general fund rather than being transferred from one enterprise fund to another.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney stated that he was correct and that the electric rates would need to be adjusted to replenish the funds. Part of the rate studies is that all the reserves and all the draws come from the reserves in the electric fund. If more is drawn than is typically planned through the financial policy, then the future use of the electric revenue is affected. According to financial policy, the reserves from the electric revenue must be replenished, which has a direct impact on the electric rates.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Ms. Marney confirmed that if the money is transferred back into the fund, during the 2026 budget consideration, the expenses for the current wastewater utility will have to be added in the form of taxes.

George Gaudioso, 167 Maple Glen Drive, Dover, stated that he is the President of the Maple Glen Homeowners Association. He explained that the individual owners, as well as the homeowner’s association, received the invoices in varying amounts. Mr. Gaudioso stated that his biggest concern was that, in 2014, Kent County set up a Stormwater Maintenance District (SWMD) to maintain the ponds. He explained that they are one of the original homeowner associations that joined and have been members ever since. Kent County Conservation District monitors the pond, and they pay a lot of money to Enviro Tech to make sure the pond is functioning and treated properly. He stated that the invoices were improperly constructed, and many people thought that the charge was a one-time yearly charge. He explained that they must take the invoice and multiply it by four and that would be what they must pay yearly. Mr. Gaudioso expressed frustration with the information on the website as well as the appeal process. He explained that to file an appeal the homeowner’s association would need to hire a civil engineer and incur the cost of doing so. He expressed frustration with doing the right thing in their community through Kent County and then being hit with an additional fee.

Jeff Wark, 612 Mary Street, Dover, stated that as one of the owners of Teal Construction, their property taxes would have gone up two hundred and fifty percent with the utility fee. He expressed dissatisfaction with the ordinance when it came to the impervious versus pervious areas. He stated that the impervious and pervious areas are not consistent with what they deal with in their line of

Página 180

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 7 Item #6.

business. He explained that their entire property was considered impervious, and they currently had two to three feet of stone gravel on about seventy percent of their property.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Wark stated that the property taxes would be around $5,000 and the annual stormwater fee would have been around $13,000.

Mr. Wark stated that they started the appeal process with a civil engineer, but the engineer stopped working on it because the definition in the ordinance considered anything that had been driven on once would be considered impervious therefore the engineer stopped the process.

Mr. Neil moved to amend that the stormwater utility go back to the general fund for the time being and to allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt.

Ms. Arndt clarified that Mr. Neil was stating that he would like to take the stormwater enterprise fund and transfer that back to the general fund and allow the opportunity to make the transfer from the electric fund to the general fund as an interim measure, if necessary. He also recommended revisiting the enterprise fund to reevaluate and make any necessary corrections.

Mr. Neil confirmed that was his intention so that next year it can be done correctly.

Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Neil stated that the original motion included figuring out how to credit those who had paid or return the money paid.

Ms. Marney stated that she spoke with Ms. Haines, and she devised a plan that if anyone has already made the payment on their account, the money will be credited back to them either through a credit balance refund or credit to their utility bill. Those who have not paid will have the bill adjusted, if moved by council.

Mr. Neil moved to amend that the stormwater utility go back to the general fund for the time being and to allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried with Mr. Lewis abstaining.

Mr. Hare moved to set the stormwater utility rate to zero, transfer the stormwater utility back to the general fund for the time being, allow staff to figure out where the money is going to come from while ending the stormwater utility at this time, and find a way to refund or credit the money that people have already paid. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried with Mr. Lewis abstaining.

Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 7:48 p.m.

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.

Página 181

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 8 Item #6.

Adoption of Agenda Mr. Boggerty requested that Item #5, “Campground of Hope” for the Unsheltered Population of the City of Dover, be considered as Item #1 and be renamed “Campground of Hope” for the Unsheltered Population of the City of Dover and other programs.

Mr. Boggerty moved for adoption of the agenda as amended, seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.

“Campground of Hope” for the Unsheltered Population of the City of Dover and Other Programs (Leandra Marshall, Vice Chair, City of Dover Unsheltered Working Group) Ms. Leandra Marshall, Vice Chair, City of Dover Unsheltered Working Group reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Campground of Hope.

This item was informational, and committee action was not required.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Marshall stated that he is correct because the campground would fall outside the city limits, they plan to focus the money on the projects within the city and privately raise money or obtain funding from the state and county to establish the campground. For example, Synergy Recovery Solutions, a coalition member, has helped to cap Medicaid rates to serve the unsheltered population. She explained that they would offer mental health services, medically assisted drug and alcohol treatment, and primary care. The intake rate for Medicaid for example, is typically $146 but Synergy has decided to cap the rate at $100, the individual session rate for Medicaid is $119 but Synergy has decided to cap the rate at $90, and the group session rate would be $25 for mental health services.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marshall stated that the original proposed budget was for the whole program. However, due to concerns about the campground being outside the city, she acknowledged that the budget would need to be revised. She explained that they came up with the campground as a relief to the city. She stated that with the constraints, they plan to revamp the budget and add additional services.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that there is approximately $91,000 in American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funding left. He explained that by December 09, 2024, they are going to have to earmark where the money is going, and they will be able to make adjustments afterward. If the money is not allocated by December 31, 2024, then the city will lose it.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that they can redirect the funding to the Kent County Coalition. He explained that the Community Development Director reviewed the two proposals for legal reasons and the current proposal is being revamped. He stated that they wanted to make sure there was no room for error because of the timeframe and the unsheltered group being formed by the city made sense because it is a city-directed project.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that it would be up to the committee to decide whether the unsheltered working group would be allocated $91,000.

Página 182

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 9 Item #6.

Ms. Marshall stated that she has worked with ARPA funds for many years and the city is allowed to reallocate them depending on the stipulations that were in the original proposal for the funding. She explained that they plan to create a budget based on what funding they are provided, and they will continue to raise money through private partnerships, grants, and other private agencies. She stated that the goal is to address the needs of the unsheltered population without putting a Band- Aid on it.

Mr. Anderson stated that when the city obtained the ARPA money, they followed the revenue offset provision which allowed them to direct the money anywhere they choose within certain restrictions. The funds cannot be used in retirement funds, and a few other things, so it must be treated like general revenue.

Reverend Dr. Maxine Johnson, John Wesley AME Church, 217 W. Division Street, Dover, stated that since her appointment in March of 2023, she has experienced the church's connection with the community and through the many partnerships. She explained that shortly after her appointment, Mr. Garcia “Gus” Walker let her know that the ceiling fell in. She stated that they had to cancel services and projects within the community such as the clothes closet. She explained that they are before council to ask for funding through the ARPA funding program.

Ms. Carla Benson-Green, Steward Pro Tem, provided the history of the church. She explained that the church has always been utilized as a refuge station or resource spot for the people in the community. She stated that in 2005 John Wesley engaged in a collaborative effort within the community during the HIV Epidemic and it became a part of the ministry to reach the people that are in the community. She emphasized that they are a boots-on-the-ground church, and everyone knows the church with the blue door as the place for services, support, and refuge.

She stated that they initially started working with the Division of Public Health and the DC3 Coalition, and later expanded their collaboration to include Kent County Counseling, Brandywine Counseling, as well as additional external resources such as Dover District Ministerial and the State of Delaware Office of Defense Services to provide expungement services. She explained that through their yearly projects and partnership with Brandywine Counseling, they have gone from reaching one hundred and eighty-five people in 2016 to eight hundred and fifty-six currently. She stated that they would like council to consider John Wesley as a candidate for ARPA funding to address their aging structure. The roofing issues were about $19,300 and the ceiling issue was around $10,200.

Mr. Anderson stated that in the past the People’s Church was awarded around $600,000 for renovations and the Murphy School was awarded around $30,000 for the HVAC system. It would not be out of the ordinary to provide funding for community purposes because the city is not supporting any religious organization. He asked that they provide three bids for each project to stay consistent with the City of Dover purchasing policy if approved.

Mr. Boggerty moved to recommend that from the remaining ARPA funds of $91,000, grant $30,000 to John Wesley Church, once they comply with the request for the bids, and that the remainder of the funds be allocated to the Unsheltered Working Group. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson.

Página 183

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 10 Item #6.

Mr. Anderson requested that they return on December 09, 2024, with as firm of numbers as possible for when council votes.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that they were not required to advertise the ARPA funding, but they decided to do it the first time because they wanted the broadest reach, therefore they did two rounds of advertising. He explained that if they chose to advertise this reallocation there would be no time to award the funding because it must be done within the next few weeks.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Boggerty stated as co-chair of the ARPA funding, he went around the community, spoke at several community events, and did several social media campaigns. He stated that there was not one step that was not taken to include groups like Tracy Palmer Ministries, The People’s Church, and many other organizations. There were several applications, and when they did not give out all the money in the first round, they did it all over again. He emphasized that there were social media campaigns galore, and he drove to events large and small to share about ARPA funding. Unfortunately, in many instances, the agencies were not prepared from an administrative standpoint to apply. Some had issues with taxes and the 501 formations, and they did not comply, which meant they had to revisit awards and provide extra money to dispense all the funds. He stated that unfortunately with less than 30 days to have the funding allocated they had to reach out to individuals such as Leandra Marshall and John Wesley Church, knowing the work that they do within the community.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Boggerty stated that unfortunately, due to other issues that he could not make public, there was funding that was not allocated.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that when the money was pulled back it was decided that the funding would need to be reallocated.

Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Marney stated the money could not be used to fund the stormwater utility.

Responding to Ms. Marney, Mr. Anderson stated that part of the ARPA funding was allocated towards water/wastewater because infrastructure is one of the items that was specifically mentioned in the ARPA final regulations, therefore the funding could be used to fund the stormwater utility.

Mr. Garfinkel moved to amend the motion that the $91,000 be put into the stormwater infrastructure. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis.

Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Marney stated that she would have to specifically look at whether the funding could be used. She stated she believed that ARPA funding could be used for infrastructure and not operational expenses. A stormwater utility may be considered operational expenses and not infrastructure. She explained that portions of stormwater utility would be infrastructure that could possibly qualify but she would have to research that.

Página 184

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 11 Item #6.

Mr. Garfinkel moved to amend the motion that the $91,000 be put into the stormwater infrastructure. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and failed by a roll call vote of six (6) no (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Arndt, Rocha, Anderson), three (3) yes (Lewis, Shevock, Garfinkel), and two (2) absent (Pillsbury, Sudler).

Mr. Boggerty moved to recommend that from the remaining ARPA funds of $91,000, grant $30,000 to John Wesley Church, once they comply with the request of the bids, and that the remainder of the funds be allocated to the Unsheltered Working Group. The motion was seconded by Mr. Anderson and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Hare, Boggerty, Neil, Arndt, Rocha, Lewis, Anderson, Shevock), one (1) no (Garfinkel), and two (2) absent (Pillsbury, Sudler).

Mr. Rocha moved to sunset the Unsheltered Working Group as the Kent County Coalition will be taking over going forward. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.

Dover Fire Department Volunteer Stipend (Chief David Carey and President Jason Osika) Chief David Carey and President Jason Osika, Dover Fire Company, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the volunteer stipend.

Staff recommended approval of the volunteer stipend program.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation for the fire department volunteer stipend. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Chief Carey stated that they currently have two hundred and thirty-three people. They range from the age of thirteen to the age of ninety-five. There are approximately fifty-two members active. He clarified that active means any member who makes one hundred and twenty-five calls or more a year.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Osika clarified that not everyone would get the stipend. There are guidelines that specify what the volunteer must do, such as duty crew hours or responding to general alarms.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Osika stated that they hired their department attorney and Dave Truax who provides audits of ambulances, finances, and other issues within the fire service. Mr. Truax put them in touch with an attorney who is well-versed in the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) since that was the biggest thing that needed to be looked at. The portion that Mr. Lewis quoted regarding the nominal fee was pulled from the FLSA advisory letter that the attorney gave them. It states that to maintain volunteer status they cannot be paid; however, they can be compensated a nominal fee. The nominal fee is not determined or defined by the Congress of 1985.

He went on to explain that there is a twenty percent rule that states they can get a nominal fee for the items listed which was covered in their policy after going to the state auditor's office. The twenty percent rule states that you cannot make more than twenty percent of what someone would make doing that job full-time. The numbers that were used in the upcoming budget for a firefighter

Página 185

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 12 Item #6.

position was approximately $54,000, therefore $10,000 is the most someone could make without violating the FLSA rule. He stated that the goal is to have duty crew shifts that volunteers are signing up for so that the station is staffed 24/7 with a crew at each station. If they were to complete a 12-hour shift they would receive credit for four calls. He explained that it would calculate to $10 an hour equating to $30 a call while staying at the firehouse. He stated that they would only be paid if they were on those shifts.

He explained that the goal is to have crews in place to run silent alarms so that they do not have to blow the fire whistle every time. Currently, they are running about one hundred and seventy-five calls, and the whistle blows an average of about twenty-five times. The whistle blows for accidents and fires, and when a crew is not in the station, they need people to respond.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Osika stated that the reasonable benefits are not medical benefits. He explained that the verbiage was taken from the Congress Act of 1985, which states what can be paid with the nominal fee while maintaining a volunteer status. The State Auditor's office recommended calling it a nominal fee to encompass everything so that no one can say something was left out and ask for reimbursement.

Responding to Mr. Lewis, Chief Carey stated that the funding came from the Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILOT) program, which is funding provided by the State of Delaware to Wilmington, Dover, and Georgetown. He explained that the City of Newark raised concerns about the number of university buildings that are government buildings within the City of Newark and that they are not able to tax to receive income to subsidize some of their needs. One of the state legislators asked to award Newark $2 million in Grant-in-Aid funds to subsidize the PILOT money that they do not receive. Senator Paradee requested that the City of Dover receive the same funds. The City of Dover was awarded $2 million, with a clear allocation that $500,000 was designated for the police department, and the remaining funds were allocated to the fire department. He stated that as President Osika mentioned, there were no guidelines as to how the money had to be spent. In speaking to Senator Paradee, he explained that he does not foresee the Grant-in-Aid money being eliminated any time soon, however, Grant-in-Aid does change year to year, so the possibility is there.

Mr. Osika stated that the $1.1 million that would be transferred should last anywhere from two to three years, but it would have to be monitored. He explained that after meeting with city staff they have decided to place the funding in a separate account and do monthly reports that include how much is going in and out because it will likely go back and forth depending on the time of the year. He stated that they predict they will receive another million or so next year but if the legislature decided to end the Grant-in-Aid, they would have to go back to the drawing board because once the program is started there would be no going back. He explained that once someone is being paid you would not get them back in the door by taking the money away. In closing, he stated that the goal is to use half a million dollars for the volunteers versus half going to paid staff.

Responding to Mr. Anderson, Chief Carey stated that if they were to go to a paid fire department it would be roughly $26 million doing a comparison to that of the City of Annapolis, Maryland, who have two fire stations and a similar population.

Página 186

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING NOVEMBER 26, 2024 PAGE 13 Item #6.

Mr. Hare moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation for the fire department volunteer stipend. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Amending Bond Council Requirements (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer) Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the bond council requirements.

Ms. Marney stated that the request had come as a result of publication issues at the local newspaper’s office during the budget season and in discussions with the Bond Counsel regarding changes made to the Tax Equity and Financial Responsibility Act (TEFRA) requirements from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) which allowed for public notice to be done on websites.

Staff recommended amendment of all city code requirements for public notice to include modern communication tools.

Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Marney stated that adding more modern publications does not mean that staff cannot publish in the newspapers. Adding more modern publications provides staff with additional tools to post on the website, in specific public notice portals used by some government entities, and on social media. The recommended change would allow staff to utilize additional tools to legally get the word out.

Mr. Neil stated that even though the newspapers have reduced publications he would recommend continuing to include one publication in the newspaper for public record.

Ms. Arndt moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation to amend city code requirements for public notice to include modern communication tools. The motion was seconded by Mr. Hare and unanimously carried.

Discussion – Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer) Ms. Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR).

Ms. Marney stated that the delay in completing the financial report was due to staff turnover in the finance department, including the Controller/Treasurer position, as well as unfinished reconciliations that were necessary to complete the schedules.

Ms. Marney stated that they have been wo

Este documento es demasiado largo para mostrarlo completo aquí. Lea el resto en el PDF.

Volver a esta reunión