Regular Council Minutes with Exhibits
City Council Meetings. 9 de junio de 2025.
Este texto se extrajo de el PDF de forma automática y puede contener errores. El PDF es el registro oficial, así que consúltelo antes de confiar en esto.
3 páginas tienen poco o ningún texto legible aquí, a menudo por ser escaneos o dibujos. Para verlas, consulte el PDF.
Página 1
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular City Council Meeting was held on June 9, 2025, at 6:30 p.m. with Council President Neil presiding. Council members present were Mr. Anderson, Ms. Hall, Ms. Arndt, Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rocha, and Mr. Lewis. Dr. Pillsbury and Mr. Boggerty were absent.
Staff members present were Police Chief Johnson, Ms. Marney, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Melson- Williams, Deputy Chief Bashista, Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Mayor Christiansen was also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 6:15 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Council President Neil declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.
William Faust, 136 Orchard Avenue, addressed members of council with questions and comments. He requested clarification on the city charter, stating that his interpretations suggested council members received raises with each fiscal budget. If this were accurate, he recommended halting those raises due to rising fiscal costs. He referenced a newspaper article about insurance companies providing funds to volunteers and inquired whether hiring paid staff would affect that funding. He noted potential savings since the proposed firefighters were already trained, citing Chief Carey’s estimate of approximately $150,000 for training, equipment, and related costs, which he believes would be lower in the first year if hiring pre-trained personnel.
Mr. Faust expressed frustration about budget decisions being made without certainty regarding state and federal funding. He questioned how a motion to hire two (2) firefighters, along with the associated costs, such as benefits, pensions, etc., could be proposed before the budget was finalized. He emphasized affordability concerns, mentioning struggling residents, rising utility costs, such as electric, water, and wastewater rates, and suggested that if new expenses were added, cuts should be made elsewhere, or additional revenue should be sought from large corporations. He noted that they have lost funds from events such as NASCAR and Firefly and questioned how the city plans to generate additional revenue. He emphasized that, as a taxpayer, he wanted his tax dollars to be used responsibly. He requested that, if his questions cannot be addressed during the meeting, they be placed on the agenda for discussion at the next Regular Council Meeting.
Vonderlear Smack, 1001 White Oak Road, Apartment #F12, read her statement into the record expressing concerns regarding the rising costs associated with the fiscal budget. (Exhibit #1)
INVOCATION
The invocation was given by Mayor Robin R. Christiansen.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Council President Neil.
Página 2
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 2
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Dr. Sudler moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha, and unanimously carried (Pillsbury and Boggerty absent).
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Mr. Rocha moved for adoption of the consent agenda, seconded by Ms. Arndt, and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hall, Anderson, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Neil), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty).
PRESENTATION – CAPITAL SCHOOL DISTRICT UPDATE (SEAN P.M. CHRISTIANSEN, VICE PRESIDENT, CAPITAL SCHOOL BOARD) Mr. Sean P.M. Christiansen, Vice President, Capital School Board, reviewed the Capital School District Update.
After the presentation, Dr. Sudler, speaking on behalf of the Sudler-Mishoe family, expressed pride in the Capital School District, noting that both he and his parents attended Dover High School. He thanked him and the school board, as well as the fire department, for their hard work.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Christiansen stated that the Capital School District is at a turning point and continues to grow. He invited council members to visit any of the buildings, noting that the doors are always open. He also highlighted that the Superintendent, Dr. Victoir T. Cahoon, and the Assistant Superintendent, Mr. Toriano Giddens, are bringing new ideas and moving the district forward.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Christiansen stated that the fire department had regularly participated in career days until about 12 months ago. He noted that the high school provided tables with information and designated days for the fire department’s involvement.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Gene Montano, Director of Secondary Education, explained that fire company recruitment typically involves coordination with school guidance counselors, where recruiters can set up informational tables and provide materials and sign-up information. Similar to military recruitment, the Dover Fire Department is welcome to participate by contacting the counselor or principal. He also mentioned that recruitment opportunities are available at both the middle and high school levels, especially with the addition of programs that help students earn their Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) and firefighter certifications. The idea is that they want the students to be able to give back to the community. He stated that those certifications not only serve the community by preparing students to become volunteer firefighters and Emergency Medical Services (EMS) providers but also offer career pathways where students can eventually earn substantial salaries after further training. He noted that it was part of the school’s broader effort to promote college and career readiness through Career and Technical Education (CTE) programs.
Página 3
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 3
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Montano explained that one (1) of the pathways for Level Two (2) students to become members or volunteers within the local fire department is designed to help them build the necessary experience for attending summer training, give back to the community, and offset some of the costs related to equipment and other expenses. He noted that they would provide transportation and meals for the students to get the training and provide the equipment through the volunteering and application process with the local fire departments. He also noted that it does not have to be with Dover, but it could be with Camden-Wyoming or other locations.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Christiansen stated that the current instructor, Mr. Jason Roswell, has encouraged all of the students to join their local fire departments during the summer. As they come back to school, those students would have more interest in the fire department. Citing Mr. Montano, he stated that the Career and Technical Education (CTE) program and school choice would allow students from Bethany Beach to attend Dover High School for the program, because there is no other program like it in the state. He noted that they have attempted a program in New Castle County with the New Castle County Emergency Service Program, but it only lasted for two (2) years and then failed. He emphasized that they would not let that happen in Capital School District. He also mentioned that the Milford School District is on the verge of implementing Emergency Medical Service (EMS) programs, but there has been no discussion of fire, although the Delaware State Fire School is in the backyard at Dover High School.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Montano stated that the key aspect when they first started the program was to model it after the approach was implemented in Maryland. There was some pushback from the state regarding how they wanted to structure the program. He noted that they adopted a state model but also incorporated Firefighter I and Firefighter II certifications to provide students more opportunities to be career-ready upon graduation. He emphasized that the state believed students should have greater chances to secure jobs and begin their careers after finishing school.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Christiansen explained that they were at the end of their first year. He further explained that the program began with the Department of Education’s approval, driven by a curriculum scheduled for implementation by Fall 2024. They started with 86 students, retaining approximately 54, who will now advance to their second year as a new freshman class starts.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Montano stated that next year they would have at least two (2) more classes, and he expects at least 100 students in the pathway. The pathway is projected to have approximately 60 students for whom he has purchased 60 books, complete with digital access and resources. With 458 eighth graders advancing, some will be entering the program, and at least 50 additional students are expected to join at the ninth-grade level.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Montano clarified that results from the program are expected sometime this summer, though more likely within a year. He noted that the results will primarily focus on the students who are joining their volunteer fire departments.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Montano stated that the key process was ensuring open
Página 4
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 4
communication and collaboration among everyone. He noted that they have partnerships with the Ambulnz as well as the Delaware State Fire School.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Christiansen explained that videos were key to engaging students. He emphasized that students are visual learners who prefer watching videos over listening to lectures. The strategy was to create an easily accessible video, delivered via email and set as the default view when students opened their laptops. It would also include a QR code to guide them to the next step.
Mr. Lewis thanked Mr. Christiansen for the presentation and commended the Capital School District for initiating the program. He also expressed his appreciation to Mr. Montano for coordinating the program.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Christiansen stated that he was aware that the fire department was invited to the senior awards by the counseling department at Dover High School. He noted that he attended the senior awards and ordered the graduation cords from Amazon, not knowing if the students would get them. To his understanding and talking with Mr. Richard Wang, he reached out to a fire officer on Friday morning and asked how they could get the graduation cords. He was told that they could come by the firehouse and pick them up. He mentioned that trying to get into the senior awards was important, as this was done last year. He was aware that there were messages sent out. He was not sure why they did not show up to the graduation on Friday, but they did go to Caesar Rodney's graduation on Saturday. He does not know if it was a staffing problem.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Deputy Chief Bashista congratulated Mr. Christiansen on giving a great presentation. He stated that he would need to check with Chief Carey about Friday evening, and the reason why no one from the fire department showed up for the Dover High School graduation. He noted that the challenge was whether there was staffing available, but those things should be a priority.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Christiansen explained that he and Mr. Roswell, the Career and Technical Education (CTE) coordinator, have discussed plans for next year’s program to include tours of the Dover Fire Station, the Delaware State Fire School, the Kent County 911 Center, and the Dover Police Department. Even though they do not have a police portion of the program, they would need to be aware of what happens on that side, as well as in the hospital. He explained that much of the pre-hospital care that they provide involves Nationally Registered Emergency Medical Technicians (NREMTs) transporting patients to the Emergency Room (ER). The students would not know what to expect when they go into the Emergency Room (ER), as it could be chaos, but they are going to be exposed to that. It is in the works for the coming year, and it would be coordinated by the local fire departments. He stated that if they have members in the program from other fire departments, they will try to go to their fire stations as well.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Christiansen stated that there are opportunities for students when they become seniors to join their local fire department, if they go through the program.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Christiansen explained that students could sign up as seniors regardless of which municipality they live in.
Página 5
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 5
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Montano stated that students of any age can sign up, but typically, ninth graders are the ones who usually enroll.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Christiansen explained that the Dover Fire Department accepts individuals starting at the age of 13, while Camden-Wyoming begins at the age of 14 or 15. He noted that age requirements vary among different fire departments.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Montano stated that the fire departments provide additional initial training in coordination with the Delaware State Fire School. Both the Dover Fire Department and the Delaware State Fire School offer on-site training for young participants. This initial exposure helps students, including young children, prepare for emergencies by providing essential skills like Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (CPR) training and other certifications necessary for their Nationally Registered Emergency Medical Technicians (NREMT) certification. The goal is to equip them to handle emergencies effectively, whether at home or elsewhere.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Christiansen stated that they have put a lot of time and effort into making this program a success. He noted that Mr. Montano would be retiring on a great note, even though there is still more work to be done, he will be leaving this in good hands for the next person who comes into the position. He also noted that he has two (2) more years on the Capital School District Board of Education, and that he is committed to ensuring the program’s success. This is because it will produce the first graduating class ready for employment, equipped with Nationally Registered Emergency Medical Technicians (NREMT), Pro Board Firefighter I and Firefighter II certifications, enabling them to volunteer at their local fire company.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Christiansen stated that they no longer have programs such as the Drug Abuse Resistance Education (DARE) program because of federal funding. He emphasized that there are background checks that have to be completed for an individual to become a Nationally Registered Emergency Medical Technicians (NREMT). They would also need to do a second background check to join their local fire department. He suggested introducing children to firefighting as early as age six (6) or in middle school. His question centered on how to best prepare the next generation of firefighters, because being a fireman is the coolest thing in the world.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Christiansen stated that they are going to do what they can to support the community, whether it be the police department, the fire department, or Habitat for Humanity, the Capital School District is committed to its role as a community partner.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Montano stated that they have a partnership with the Police Athletic League (PAL) through the City of Dover Police Department. This was a proponent of the 21st Century Program. He suggested partnering with the Dover Fire Department and the 21st Century Program to engage elementary students, helping them gain a better understanding and learn how to work with these organizations. He noted that he would like to talk with Chief Carey in the future about how this partnership could potentially develop. He stated that it would help establish an early connection with the middle school and build from there.
Página 6
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 6
PRESENTATION – FRIENDS OF THE DOVER LIBRARY UPDATE (JANET CARTER, PRESIDENT) Ms. Janet Carter, President, reviewed the Friends of the Dover Library Update.
Responding to Ms. Carter, Mr. Lewis noted that while reviewing the brochure, he did not see her contact information, so he offered his card for her to reach out to him. He expressed strong support for the free little libraries and shared that he recently worked with a constituent in the second district to erect one in Crossgates Park. He mentioned having leftover discretionary funds and had contacted the Finance Director and City Clerk’s Office to explore contributing those funds to purchase another free Little Library. However, since the constituent is not a non-profit organization, he could not directly contribute through her. He mentioned that the constituent had approached him about the lack of a little library in Crossgates Park, which led to the installation of one (1) several months ago. Mr. Lewis expressed enthusiasm about the program and called it phenomenal. He emphasized the importance of placing these little libraries in more parks throughout the city, noting that one (1) park in the Second District still lacks a little library. He expressed interest in further discussions and acknowledged that he may need to coordinate with the Finance Director in order to contribute funds, provided it pertains to purchasing a small library.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Carter stated that she has two (2) small libraries that they have commissioned, that are waiting to be built, and a request to make a third.
PUBLIC HEARING – ELECTRIC FUND BUDGET
A public hearing on the Electric Fund Budget is required for compliance with the City of Dover Electric Revenue Bonds Resolutions prior to the adoption of the budget. Notice of the public hearing was properly advertised for this time and place.
Mr. Shawn Burgett, Systems Operations and Engineer Superintendent, briefed members on the Electric Fund Budget.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Burgett stated that the top three reasons for the rate increase were the cost of purchasing power, along with rising material costs and wage increases. He explained that a major factor in the rate increase was the significant rise in the cost of purchasing power. Additionally, the cost of materials has increased across the board. He also mentioned a wage study that led to substantial pay increases for union workers, approximately 25% over the past six (6) years, which contributed to the higher costs.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney explained that the reason the electric line crew’s wages went up substantially was that they have a collective bargaining agreement that includes an increased rate of pay. It will have an impact on the cost of their line crew staffing. She noted that they did have several union negotiations last year that impacted not only last year’s fiscal budget, but this fiscal budget as well.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney clarified that the increase was related to wage increases. She noted that at the beginning of January 2026, they would have a health insurance increase and increases related to the Paid Family Medical Leave (PFMLA). She explained that all of these things are impacting the budget, not just for the Electric Department, but citywide, as far as the
Página 7
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 7
collective bargaining agreements and the Paid Family Medical Leave (PFMLA).
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney explained that the revisions included the addition of the Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) energy efficiency program, previously approved by council, which was not incorporated into the transmission and distribution budget.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney further explained that the inclusion of the Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) energy efficiency program was only a partial factor in the budget changes. She noted that, as previously discussed in past hearings, there would eventually be a payback or return on investment. She stated that constituents may see lower costs due to reduced energy usage, while the city would benefit from decreased expenses in electricity procurement and power generation.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that if constituents use less electricity, their electric bills should decrease accordingly, as lower usage leads directly to lower costs on their bills.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Burgett explained that there was a fund called New Developments used to cover upfront costs for infrastructure in new housing and community developments. He noted that even though the city does not control whether development occurs, the city initially covers those costs, which would be later reimbursed. He also mentioned that the fund has increased significantly.
Mr. Rocha stated for the record that PJM stood for Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland Interconnection. He noted that it was their regional transmission organization that coordinates the wholesale electricity market and transmission system for a large part of the eastern United States, which is where they purchase their power from.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Burgett clarified that $12.6 million was budgeted directly for power.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Burgett stated that the market purchase was set at $12.6 million, and the percentage of energy above hedged amounts was bought at the market price. He clarified that the congestion losses amounted to $17 million.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Burgett clarified that it was what Pennsylvania-New Jersey- Maryland Interconnection (PJM) charges for the energy.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Burgett explained that congestion occurs when transmission lines become overloaded, leading to congestion charges. Line losses refer to the percentage of purchased power that was unaccounted for, typically about 3% to 4% annually, which is caused by aging infrastructure, such as old transformers and utility lines.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Burgett clarified that by upgrading the infrastructure, they should reduce those losses, though there was no guarantee the target loss percentage would always be met.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Burgett clarified that as they upgrade, it brings the number down
Página 8
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 8
in theory. He noted that there was a chance that they might not hit that number at a loss.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg reminded everyone that the electric utility operates as an enterprise fund and must cover all expected costs, including reserves and replacements. He highlighted that rising market costs, such as transformers tripling in price, are factored into the energy cost speculation. Approximately 75% to 80% of the utility’s total energy purchases are hedged to protect against future price increases. He emphasized that The Energy Authority (TEA) was highly skilled at hedging, making regular hedge purchases monthly. The utility hedges about 75-80% of its energy purchases to protect against price spikes, with 55% already hedged for the upcoming energy year starting in June. He noted that the hedging reduces market exposure compared to other utilities. Additionally, the utility can adjust rates up or down through a purchase power adjustment provision to reflect actual costs. He stated that they already have about 55% hedged for the upcoming energy year, which starts in June, which would help to stabilize and keep energy costs as low as possible. He explained that their market exposure was significantly lower compared to most Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) or public electric utilities. They also have a purchase power adjustment provision, which allows them to adjust rates up or down based on actual costs.
Mr. Hugg explained that when actual costs are lower than estimated, adjustments are made to return savings to customers. However, predicting wholesale energy prices was highly unpredictable due to various factors such as the war in Europe, weather conditions, and malfunctions at the Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) facility in the Gulf, which diverts natural gas either to the market or from the market. He noted that they do their best to estimate both the expected costs and what their demand would be. He emphasized the fluid nature of energy prices, noting warm weather patterns this year, and that demand was down substantially. There was also a cold snap that caught residents by surprise, highlighting how volatile energy prices can be. He noted that energy prices can fluctuate daily, and even multiple times within a single day. He explained that by code and by operation as an enterprise fund, they have to deal with and recognize what those costs are and plan accordingly. They have to maintain a certain level of reserves and have a contingency fund. He noted that there was not a lot of flexibility to deviate from, and that sometimes results in a cost increase.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg stated that the activities were to regulate the available energy, which included determining when plants are taken out of service and what not. The Indian River Power Plant was initially slated for closure, a factor that had been incorporated into their plans. However, due to a capacity shortage on the peninsula, the plant will now remain operational. There were charges involved with bringing it back online, and because it was an inefficient old plant, it cost more to generate. He referenced that recently, President Trump issued an order to keep a Pennsylvania plant open that was scheduled to close, noting that the resulting costs were passed on to public utilities. He explained that situations like this, or unexpected failures, such as those that have occurred at Van Sant Station in the past, are examples of unforeseen events where the contingency fund would be necessary.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Burgett clarified that it would be an appropriate time to use the contingency fund if Van Sant Station was considered down due to an unforeseen outage, and there would be daily charges incurred.
Página 9
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 9
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg clarified that the city faced a $5 million charge due to its inability to meet performance requirements during a past winter peak when the McKee Run Plant was unable to operate. He explained that under the Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland Interconnection (PJM) rules, the city’s power plants, such as Van Sant Station, are sometimes required to run when called upon. If they are called upon and cannot run, penalties may apply, which would be covered by the contingency fund. While running the Van Sant Station can occasionally generate revenue for the city, it does not happen often. He also mentioned that The Energy Authority (TEA), a third-party organization, prepared the city’s electric budget, not the city employees themselves. He noted that he would get back with council to provide information regarding the plant contingencies.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Burgett stated that when they are called upon to run Van Sant Station, there is a potential opportunity for the city to make money. Unfortunately, it is not very often. He also mentioned that the Energy Authority, a third-party organization, prepared the city’s electric budget, not the city employees themselves. The city is relying on The Energy Authority (TEA) to create its budget. He noted that he would get back with council to provide information about the plant contingencies.
Responding to Mr. Hugg, Mr. Anderson expressed concern that, unlike in past years when hedging levels reached 70–80% by July during periods of low rates, the current hedging level is below 60%. He questioned the reasons for projecting such uncertain costs and requested more detailed technical justification from The Energy Authority (TEA). He emphasized that these decisions would significantly impact their constituents.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney stated that the revenue was considered part of their electric fund revenue resources. It would be applied toward the overall revenue for the electric fund.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that they budget a certain amount of revenue sales as part of the budget process. He noted that they count on a certain level of revenue they would receive from being called upon to run. He also mentioned that there are times when they are called upon a lot, and sometimes they are not. He emphasized that this was a revenue item.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that the amount of money was not significant enough to warrant a full adjustment to the rates on a real-time basis. He explained that the occurrences were very unpredictable. There are times when they could go months without being called. Each day, they would receive a report from The Energy Authority (TEA) estimating whether or not they were likely to run. He noted that trying to adjust the rates based on that variable would be pretty risky.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that the payments come from the Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland Interconnection (PJM).
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that, depending on the form of payment, it can be a check or a transfer from the Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland Interconnection (PJM).
Mr. Neil stated that if anyone has read any of the newspapers, particularly in this area, the cost of
Página 10
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 10
electricity and the rate increases that are being sought by private companies have risen dramatically. He noted that he had read an article in The Baltimore Sun highlighting the growing concern over the issue. He explained that they were facing two (2) cost factors. The first factor was the cost of delivering electricity to the residents continually, and that cost has increased due to the rising prices of equipment, transmission, and related infrastructure. The second factor is the cost of purchasing power itself, which the cost of power is erratic and has also increased. He noted that when they combine the two (2) factors, it results in a 25% increase in the total cost of providing electricity to the residents.
Mr. Neil mentioned that if they did not pay for the power, what would happen, and that would be the issue they face. He explained that they purchased the Smart Energy program to help all of the constituents manage and lower their electricity usage. It provides professional assistance, where experts can go into homes and identify ways to reduce their electricity usage. By doing that, it lowers the city’s cost to get the electricity to the residents. He noted that this was the concept behind the Smart Energy program, and it has worked successfully in other communities as well. He highlighted that since the first quarter of this year, their electric rates have been the lowest in the entire state. The city’s rates are even lower than the next lowest, which has been the electric department.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Burgett stated that they would need to do the calculations and get back to him about where they would stand when the rates were raised.
Mr. Neil stated that anyone who wants lower rates and is complaining about the city rates should go elsewhere and see how the rates are in other locations. It is one of the challenges that they face with utilities, whether it is electric or water, the rates are already at a low rate. He noted that when they reach a point where they have excess funds that they did not anticipate, they have provided credits back to residents because they are the investors. Instead of those funds going into the pockets of some fat cat, they go back to the residents, because it should. He believes that is where everyone stands and emphasized that his explanation made sense to them.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Hugg stated that they were one (1) of nine (9) municipal utilities, along with a not-for-profit co-op, a for-profit, and a private utility. He explained that the rates are difficult to compare directly across all of the utilities because various utilities have different structures. Some have seasonal rates, some offer economic development rates, and others have different pricing models. He noted that based on the rates for a typical residential customer, the City of Dover has, for as long as he has been involved, either been consistently the lowest or the second lowest residential electric rate in the state. He also mentioned that the closest comparisons were generally the co-op and, at times, the City of New Castle, depending on how their processes and systems are designed. He further stated that overall, the City of Dover has remained at or near the lowest rate level.
Mr. Hugg pointed out that when they have to raise rates or make adjustments, as a member of the Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) board, there are eight (8) other municipal utilities facing the same challenges. He explained that if they have been following the General Assembly, they tend to impose new regulations on the city almost every year, whether it is related to resource credits or other mandates, and those regulations increase their costs, often in areas where they have very little control. This year alone, there were 25 pieces of legislation
Página 11
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 11
pending that deal with electric utilities, including one (1) that was just signed into law that dictates how they are required to handle delinquent accounts. He noted that all of those uncertainties make direct comparisons between utilities difficult. They do not do those calculations themselves. He stated that Delaware Municipal Electric Corporation (DEMEC) handles them and publishes a bar chart every month. He highlighted that consistently, they are always at the bottom, meaning they have some of the lowest rates compared to other cities.
Responding to Mr. Hugg, Mr. Neil stated that he had heard from Mr. Paul Waddell and that he mentioned with the new rates, they would be the fourth lowest in the state. However, that does not necessarily mean they would remain in that position. He noted that if costs are increasing for them, it is likely that they would also increase for other communities across the state, since the underlying factors driving the increases were not going away.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg stated that the question being asked related specifically to the proceeds from Van Sant Station. He explained that the revenues from Van Sant Station were relatively small, so by themselves, they were not enough to justify any significant rate adjustment. However, he noted that they do have the ability to provide customers with a discount, such as a rebate and a return, and confirmed that a rebate was made last year.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Marney stated that the Power Cost Adjustment (PCA) credit that Mr. Hugg was referring to, which, according to the financial policies, they would be reviewing again next year to see if there was an ability to process a credit or return to the customers over a several-year period. In response to Mr. Anderson’s question regarding when they would be evaluating the rates again, she pointed out that the last rate study, which was done in 2023, that study covered projections through the fiscal year 2028. However, she noted that due to changes and the fact that they have realized some savings, they have requested an update to the rate study. After the start of fiscal year 2026, they would be initiating another rate study, and following their financial policies, a rate study should be done every three (3) to five (5) years. She pointed out that they are still within that window. She explained that the last rate study was conducted over a five (5) year period. However, it did not include some of the capital projects that Mr. Waddell would like to have cost out, such as the Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) project. She noted that they included a request for Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) in the budget, but they decided to turn it down to keep rates as low as possible for the constituents. Since Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) was not included in the previous rate study, had they incorporated it, it would have resulted in a significant rate increase for residents.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Marney emphasized that she would recommend that they approve the request because the rate study that was provided barely covers the costs. She pointed out that the revenue projection at that time was approximately $81 million, to costs of $97,000.
Responding to Ms. Marney, Dr. Sudler emphasized that he was looking for a different solution. He noted that he was looking for an alternative that would not place a burden on the taxpayers, especially given these hard times. At the same time, he understood the need to balance the budget, the differences between restricted and unrestricted funds, and how they should reappropriate the funds. He was not stating that it has not been done, but sometimes it does take a little longer to determine the best way to approach a solution. As part of his due diligence as a
Página 12
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 12
representative to his constituents, he felt that if they could find a solution, it would benefit both the city and the residents.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney stated that they review the Power Cost Adjustment (PCA) and work with The Energy Authority (TEA) to ensure that they comply with the city’s financial policies. She noted that according to those policies, the Power Cost Adjustment (PCA) is reviewed everyone (1) to three (3) years.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney stated that it would not be determined within the Fiscal Year 2026. She noted that it would be projected for the Fiscal Year 2027.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Marney clarified that there was no cost adjustment to the Fiscal Year 2026 budget.
Council President Neil declared the Public Hearing opened at 7:52 p.m.
William Faust, 136 Orchard Avenue, spoke in opposition to the Electric Fund Budget. He pointed out that he has only heard a lot of talk, but no answers. He noted that when he heard that they had received a refund or rebate but that he had not seen anything come back into his pocket. He also mentioned that when electric rates are being increased because of salary increases, that should have been figured out and not put on the budget of the taxpayer. He emphasized that a budget needs to be made and to live within that budget. He referenced what Mr. Neil stated, and that they should not let so many words move out; that was not the right answer or comment. They are held responsible for holding the line. He stated that he did not care that they had the fourth-lowest rate. If residents are hurting, it does not matter how cheap the rates are. He noted that they had a tax increase of 2%, and utilities and Emergency Medical Service (EMS) fees increased.
Mr. Faust stated that he has heard nothing productive from council about how they were going to bring money or revenue into the city. He referenced a comment that he said previously made that they had already lost a race at Dover Downs and that they had lost Firefly. He questioned where the revenue would be coming from. He pointed out that council was concerned about the taxpayers, but he did not see it, and did not hear any specific proposals or any rewards. He highlighted that he has been here since 2002, paying his bills on time, and has never seen any credit on his bill. People are struggling, and while $20 here or $5 there may seem small, it adds up quickly. Speaking from personal experience, he stated that his household expenses have gone up, such as home insurance, car insurance, and liability policy, and now they are discussing adding additional charges for water treatment and wastewater. He questioned at what point would be enough. He noted that he was not trying to be difficult, but it was easy to sit there and state that “They would do this,” or “They would do that,” but if there is no money, then cut something. It is not complicated to do.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Faust stated that he was referring to the Electric Fund Budget, and that it is added up. He noted that it was another pass on to the system.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Faust stated that he wanted them to do their jobs and try to reduce something in the budget.
Página 13
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 13
Vonderlear Smack, 1001 White Oak Road, Apartment #F12, spoke in opposition to the Electric Fund Budget. She stated that it was getting worse for residents with increased costs, and the city wants to put a hike on the taxpayers. She noted that no federal funds or stocks were coming to Delaware for non-profits or grants that individuals could use to pay their bills. She referenced Mr. Neil’s comment, suggesting that individuals should leave the city to see how they fare. She mentioned that where they rank should not matter, it was the point of the statement. She noted that they should be advocating for the constituents to keep those rates down. She emphasized that residents voted them into office because they had the best interests of the residents.
Mr. Neil emphasized that he did not ask anyone to leave the city but pointed out that it would be more expensive to live in other areas.
There being no one else present wishing to speak during the public hearing, Council President
Mr. Neil declared the Public Hearing closed at 7:58 p.m.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Neil stated that the first reading of the budget ordinance was tonight. The electric fund goes through the budget ordinance.
Lachelle Paul, 55 Glenn Street, spoke in opposition to the Electric Fund Budget via WebEx. She stated that costs are increasing everywhere, but constituents have stated that many of them are on fixed incomes. Residents cannot continue to afford the cost increases. She pointed out that when council was voted into office, residents wanted them to have their best interests at heart. As council, they oversee the City Manager, and it is the City Manager’s responsibility to find cuts and identify ways to avoid passing additional increases onto the citizens, taxpayers, and those who are paying bills year after year. She mentioned that she saw a pattern of taxing and spending. There are constant increases, but no reductions. She asked where they are going to cut their spending and when the City Manager will step up to do his job and find new revenue sources beyond what the city already collects.
Ms. Paul pointed out that no additional revenue sources are coming in, and no city could continue to function that way year after year. The city was operating with a top-heavy budget. She also mentioned that there are retired employees and pensioners who need to be paid, and the city cannot allow itself to fall into a deficit so large that it cannot recover. She explained that the city needs to figure out how to bring new revenue into the city. With the budget being so top- heavy right now, that responsibility falls on them. The pension obligations and the increased spending in that area would continue to grow. She noted that if they do not find a solution to fix the budget, people will no longer be able to afford to live in the city. She emphasized that the responsibility lies with them. As far as electric service goes, the residents do not have a choice of who provides their electricity. The industry operates as a monopoly, and there are no alternative providers available to select from.
ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF MAY 12, 2025 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of May 12, 2025, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Rocha, seconded by Ms. Arndt, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen (Pillsbury and Boggerty absent).
Página 14
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 14
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT – May 13, 2025 The Council Committee of the Whole met on May 13, 2025, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Neil presiding. Members of Council present were Mr. Anderson, Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lewis (in at 6:04 p.m.), Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Dr. Sudler (in at 6:02 p.m.). Ms. Hall was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Tholstrup, and Mr. Lewis (Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement), Mr. Iriowen (via WebEx), and Mr. Wilson (Utility), Mr. Garfinkel, and Mr. Shevock, (Legislative, Finance, and Administration).
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Ms. Arndt moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha, and unanimously carried.
Modernizing Social Media – Alex Peal Mr. Alex Peal, 848 Woodcrest Drive, Dover, explained that his goal would be for city council to set up a platform that would allow citizens to engage with public figures. He explained that too much information gets lost in translation, and having a city-run YouTube or Spotify-style platform would allow residents to hear updates directly from the source.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Peal stated that he could design a platform for the city similar to his own YouTube channel, so that the city council could interact with the citizens.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Peal stated that it does take time to be able to go live on YouTube, but eventually, they would be able to interact with citizens who call in.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Peal stated that the concept is similar to Stream Yard, and they would be able to stream to different platforms. They would also be able to save the audio and upload it to iTunes or Spotify to allow the audience to listen while driving as well.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Peal stated that his YouTube channel is his company.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Peal stated that he had not prepared a contract or budget of what it would cost to build the streaming platform. He explained that he wanted to bring forward the idea, and he would be willing to look into the potential costs.
Council President Neil recommended that Mr. Peal put together a presentation covering what he would be able to do and how he would be able to get it done.
Página 15
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 15
Mr. Anderson stated that, for clarification, Mr. Peal wanted to bring forward new ideas for council to consider, and he was not originally proposing to be the contractor, which is why he did not have a presentation prepared.
Council Reports – April 2025
First District
Dr. Pillsbury had nothing to report.
Mr. Rocha reported attending a ribbon-cutting ceremony along with the mayor at Delaware Technical Community College’s newly renovated Terry Building. He also attended a tour of the Garrison Oak facility, a transitional housing nonprofit discussion along with Mr. Hugg, and an Inner-City Cultural League title transfer luncheon. He also reported participating with Ms. Arndt in a Downtown Dover Partnership Request for Qualifications (RFQ) committee for a contractor for the Brownfields in the city. He participated in the energy stakeholders’ group with the General Assembly, attended the Governors' Prayer Breakfast and the Governors' Service Awards, had a cybersecurity discussion about MySherpa with Mr. Simmons, Information and Technology Director, and attended the quarterly pension meeting.
Second District Mr. Lewis reported assisting the Homeowners Association in Clearview Meadows with establishing a neighborhood watch program. He reported recognizing the nurses at Bayhealth Medical Center, along with the mayor, for National Nurses Week. He addressed constituent concerns on Elm Terrace regarding an array of potholes, which Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, is assisting with.
Ms. Hall was absent; no report was given.
Third District Ms. Arndt reported attending the pre-Dover Days Parade breakfast as well as the Dover Days Parade. She thanked Chief Carey for arranging transportation for herself and Mr. Neil on one of the firetrucks. She attended the Delaware League of Local Government dinners with several colleagues, where they were able to network and learn from other towns and cities. She attended the Downtown Dover Partnership board meeting with Mr. Neil, as well as consultant interviews for the oversight of the Brownfield redevelopment funds with Mr. Rocha. She reported touring the natural gas power plant at Garrison Oak. She also reported receiving notes from Bradford Street residents who are pleased with the outcome of the paving, sidewalk repairs, and flexible pavement that allowed the street trees to remain in place. She thanked the Public Works team for getting those repairs completed. She noted that she is exploring options with a local university to engage students in doing a tree inventory and gap analysis to identify where there are tree health concerns and where replacements are needed.
Página 16
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 16
Fourth District Dr. Sudler reported that in April, he spoke with former gang members and drug dealers seeking help to find legitimate employment, noting a growing number of individuals involved in illegal activity are now requesting support to transition into the workforce. He also volunteered at the Mount Zion A.M.E. Church, cooking for both the soup kitchen and the Bishop’s Reception. Additionally, he attended Old Dover Days and hosted a town hall meeting focused on road infrastructure, code enforcement, community relations, and educating constituents about the budget process. He noted that Mr. Lewis attended both the town hall meeting and the Bishop’s Reception, along with Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson, and Mayor Christiansen.
Mr. Anderson reported attending several events mentioned by other council members. He shared that he had a Zoom call with Senator Buckson and encouraged other members to join future calls. Senator Buckson is exploring the possibility of securing state funding to establish a Hope Center-style facility at a hotel on the highway currently up for lease. Additionally, he mentioned the potential of converting the old family court building into a service center, noting that it would require discussion with Fourth District constituents, as it could positively impact the neighborhood if implemented properly. He also reported attending two neighborhood watch meetings, looking to form organizations at Holy Trinity Church and the NeighborGood Partners facility, focusing on individuals who resided south of Division Street. He emphasized the importance of utilizing the $5,000 budget to support and encourage neighborhood watch efforts and urged the development of guidelines in the coming months to sustain citizen engagement. He added that they had supported several non-profits through leadership and other actions and noted his attendance at the Delaware League of Local Governments meeting.
Dr. Sudler modified his report, mentioning that Mr. Neil attended the Bishop’s Reception.
At-Large Mr. Boggerty reported attending the Governor’s Prayer Breakfast and the Sankofa Mortgage Burning. He shared that he serves on the Lead Paint Initiative committee, which focuses on removing lead paint from rental properties and addressing its impact on child development. He also spoke with a constituent about progress on the Kenton Road project and thanked Ms. Duca for responding to a Fourth District resident's request for speed bumps. Additionally, he attended a community meeting at Holy Trinity Church and holds monthly calls with the Lieutenant Governor, state officials, and organizational leaders on various statewide issues. He closed by thanking everyone involved in voting, campaigning, and running the April election.
Council President Neil Council President Neil reported attending the pre-Dover Days Parade breakfast, Dover Days Parade and a Zoom meeting with Delaware State Housing Authority
Página 17
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 17
(DSHA) on homelessness. He reported addressing a Towne Point constituent's complaint regarding a neighbor commercially repairing cars on a property. Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, has taken legal action against the landlord of the property, who has initiated an eviction notice. He addressed another long-running constituent complaint regarding a house on Williams Street that is in partial repair, with another repair permit set to expire in June. Again, Code Enforcement has ordered a cleanup for the surrounding house, which has taken place, and they will continue to monitor it. He reported continuing to work with a disabled mother of two young children who was misguided into purchasing a flipper house located in White Oak Farms. Mr. Neil reported that he contacted Mr. Paul Waddell and Mr. Jason Lyon regarding a neighbor’s complaint about city bills, and one of the issues has been resolved. He also mentioned ongoing email exchanges with a constituent concerned about an annexation request involving an Acorn Lane neighbor, which was removed from the agenda the previous night. Additionally, he expressed gratitude to Mr. Andrew West, Editor of the Delaware State News, for helping locate a missing obituary notice for the gentleman who lost his wife. The woman will be buried with military honors.
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE
The Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee met with Chairwoman Arndt presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Boggerty moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Anderson, and unanimously carried.
Community Development Fund Guidelines (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, and Councilwoman Arndt) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Community Development Fund Guidelines.
Ms. Arndt explained that the Community Development Fund Guidelines were first introduced in October 2024 and revisited on January 14, 2025, with a draft of the guidelines and application for their review. She acknowledged that the original $10,000 cap was her suggestion, intended to encourage smaller, grassroots projects rather than larger, ongoing ones. While she does not oppose for-profit participation, she emphasized a preference for partnerships with non- profits to preserve a community-focused, grassroots intent. Ms. Arndt clarified that the funding was intended to support the community, not to encourage or support businesses. She explained that if a for-profit was involved, then a non- profit should be the primary partner to receive the funds. She supported flexibility in the funding duration, which could be from 12 months, 18 months, or longer, depending on the project. She recommended handling requests on a case-by-case basis.
Página 18
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 18
Mr. Anderson agreed with Ms. Arndt that they should partner with a non-profit rather than involve for-profit entities, as non-profits are better suited to adapt to that type of funding and reporting requirements, helping to avoid potential issues. He emphasized the importance of including partnership guidelines to ensure people do not assume they are ineligible and opt out, which could lead to a loss of community creativity. He emphasized the importance of including partnership guidelines to ensure people do not assume they are ineligible and opt out, which could lead to a loss of community creativity. He also agreed with a 12-month obligation but could always make it renewable. If they needed an extension or another 12 months, because it was a small amount of money. He noted that if there is an original concept, the funding should be capped at $20,000 to get the original version of the community development project to be able to test out pilot programs.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that the funding would come from two grant programs. One of the programs is funded by economic development, which is funded by the sales of excess industrial and business properties. It also may be funded by some kind of community event that they hold the proceeds from that. Regarding the use of the funds, he noted that council had ideas for some of the funds that were received, but that they did not have a place to use that money. Placing the funds in the general fund would not be effective. The community development fund was intended to collect any unusual resources to be used for the community's benefit, allowing for a variety of potential funding sources. He noted that, with the use of funds, council initially believed that some of the received funds lacked a designated purpose and simply placing them into the general fund would not be particularly effective or impactful.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that they would not be able to pull money from the fund, as the resolution originally reads. He explained that those funds were set aside specifically for those purposes. Council could do whatever they needed to do, but if they were in a significant financial crunch, council could instruct them to pull money to cover a deficit, and all the funds would be available. The fund was designated as a fund to prevent it from being put in the general fund, ensuring better visibility and auditability.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that the city has flexibility in allocating funds, noting that they could distribute the monies as they see fit. He noted that over the years, proceeds from property sales and other miscellaneous revenues have been deposited into the general fund unless specifically required otherwise. He mentioned that in a few cases, such as leftover personal funds, there were provisions specifying where those funds must be directed. However, in most instances, one-time or unexpected revenues have defaulted to the general fund.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that, to his knowledge, the city has never had an actual deficit. While there have been instances where expenditures exceeded revenues, the city has always maintained a sufficient budget balance carryover to cover all financial needs and avoid a deficit.
Página 19
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 19
Mr. Hugg noted that eligible organizations are limited to 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(6) nonprofits, but they would consider allowing partnerships with for-profit organizations if specific guidelines, such as providing names, affiliations, addresses, and a budget description, are met. He emphasized that any proposed use of funds must primarily benefit the City of Dover or its residents. If businesses receive money, the ultimate beneficiary must be a citizen of Dover. He recommended adding flexibility to the guidelines, including requiring proof of property ownership or permission from a manager if a project involves a specific property. He also mentioned that each application should have a City Council member as a primary sponsor to show that the project has serious backing and council support. This would be included as one of the official guidelines. He noted that requiring a City Council member as a project sponsor would not convict council but simply acknowledge their involvement. He noted that the Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee could use its existing standing committee structure, since its members meet regularly, to handle application reviews. This would avoid the need to create a new administrative body, with applications being considered whenever they are submitted. The crux would be going through the certification process with the Finance Department.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Hugg noted that although specific guidelines are not yet established to define what best benefits the City of Dover, applicants outside city limits should still be considered if they serve Dover residents. For example, a shelter outside the city helping Dover mothers and children could qualify if most of those served are from Dover. The goal is to avoid discouraging participation solely based on geographic boundaries.
Dr. Sudler recommended providing a written example to clarify what the city considers a benefit, noting that the individual interpretations may vary, and a clear definition was needed for eligibility.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Hugg explained that the differing amounts of $10,000 and $20,000 listed on the document were due to him working on separate versions at different times. He clarified that the final amount would reflect whatever council ultimately decided, and that the number would appear throughout the document once a decision was made.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg explained that one of the requirements for grant applicants would be to designate a manager or project lead who would be held accountable and ensure compliance with financial requirements. Applicants would need to provide proof of their 501(c)(3) status and bank account information. He mentioned that funding would be issued on a reimbursement basis, meaning recipients must first show proof of expenditures. Additionally, they would be required to submit monthly reports and meet regularly with the controllers.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg clarified that someone would be monitoring the funding from the city, with receipts being submitted. They would go through a
Página 20
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 20
process just as they do for any vendor. When they make payments, they need an invoice and receipts for materials purchased and then consider reimbursement.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg expressed hope that the process functions as a reimbursement process, which would require applicants to demonstrate a value to the city and avoid blank check-type requests.
Responding to Mr. Tholstrup, Mr. Hugg stated that they did not include a specific match amount. He explained that some of the language must demonstrate broad community support and describe how they are leveraging other funding sources. He mentioned that those would be the applications that they would look at. He further mentioned that he does not want to increase taxes to require a match because some of the applicants are not going to have a lot of money.
Responding to Mr. Tholstrup, Mr. Hugg stated that he had noted two important questions for consideration: whether there should be a maximum amount of money committed and whether there should be a maximum number of grants awarded. He acknowledged that he had not yet determined answers to these questions, as the process remains open-ended. He suggested that there could be an open application window every three or six months, during which a set amount of funds would be made available.
Responding to Mr. Tholstrup, Mr. Hugg noted that if it was important, they could require no more than one grant every six months or 12 months, for example.
Ms. Arndt stated that grant committees that she has served on, there was a restriction on how often the same entity could come back through to apply for a project. She noted that they should leave some wiggle room for applicants who come through and have a successful project, moving toward the next phase of their project.
Mayor Christiansen agreed with Mr. Anderson that the $10,000 grant amount was not realistic and supported increasing it to $20,000. He shared concerns raised during the governor’s initial homelessness collaboration meeting, where it was noted that funds previously allocated for such efforts were mismanaged or lacked proper accountability. He emphasized that, regardless of the funding source, whether American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) or otherwise, there is a duty to ensure transparency and proper use. He referenced how three Delaware mayors walked away from opioid settlement discussions to avoid being associated with certain organizations that received funding. He emphasized the responsibility of the Mayor and Council to ensure public funds are used appropriately and not consumed by excessive administrative fees. While the $20,000 threshold may help prevent this, he stressed the need for strong accountability and oversight.
He noted that if the Mayor and Council award money to an organization and malfeasance occurs, the public will likely remember that the Mayor and Council provided the funding, not the individual who misused the funds.
Página 21
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 21
Mr. Hugg stated that he has specified within the program the use of a council committee. He noted that it would need to be endorsed by the committee, trying to stay away from full council endorsement because it can get complicated. It would be beneficial to have a standing committee responsible for decisions.
Ms. Arndt suggested adopting an established grant program model, such as the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) process. She pointed out that this model includes specific elements such as scoring criteria, a review committee, strict reporting requirements, and thorough record-keeping. By following that model framework, she noted it could help alleviate the concerns raised by Mayor Christiansen.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that the fund currently holds a limited amount of money, with the only deposit so far coming from a single property sale. He explained that the size of the fund, approximately $50,000, may influence decisions on whether to award any grants at this time or wait for additional funding. He emphasized that the fund was never intended to be large, but rather to serve as a tool to support community improvements and provide benefits when unallocated funds become available.
Mr. Rocha emphasized the importance of ensuring that the funds are set aside before officially launching the grant program. He agreed with Ms. Arndt’s suggestion that the program should be aligned with the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) model, including the use of its established criteria and structure. He clarified that funds would not be distributed to non-profits. Instead, organizations would need to submit receipts for reimbursement, emphasizing that no blank check funding would be issued. He noted that non-profits may apply, but those organizations would need to have the money up front, and some non-profit organizations may not be able to do that. Mr. Rocha expressed support for the idea that for-profit businesses could partner with non-profit organizations to accomplish projects. He agreed with Dr. Sudler about establishing criteria for the types of projects. He suggested that if such partnerships generate ideas benefiting city properties, it could be a valuable addition to the grant criteria.
Mr. Lewis shared that the Speedway Children’s Charity, Dover Motor Speedway Chapter SCC-Dover, runs a similar program annually, distributing funds to non- profits statewide. While not limited to the city, they use a helpful resource called GuideStar, a website that tracks all 501(c)(3) entities and provides tax documents, contact information, budgets, and other details. He noted that GuideStar has been valuable in verifying the legitimacy and financial standing of organizations, helping to screen unfamiliar entities effectively.
Mr. Anderson stated that the Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee has already put in place a general criterion outlined in its code, particularly regarding community development. He mentioned that instead of creating a comprehensive list of acceptable projects, which could limit creativity, he suggested that the applicants align their proposals with the existing criteria and
Página 22
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 22
convince the committee of their relevance. He noted that the committee can clarify what they seek by referencing the current code. Mr. Anderson stated that he would like to focus on what they have and what they have developed over the years. He explained that there are two types of funds: The Parkland Reserve and Community Development Funds. The Parkland Reserve is where they put money aside to protect the parklands from developers. The Community Development Funds come from within the local community and are used to benefit and revitalize those areas. These funds often come from the sale of low-cost, dilapidated properties and are reinvested to improve and strengthen the communities.
Dr. Iriowen suggested revisiting the Silver Alliances Club project as a reference and using it as a model. He emphasized the importance of following up on Mayor Christiansen’s approach, noting that the focus should not be on who received the money, but rather on holding the responsible council members accountable. Regardless of the amount allocated, he stressed that accountability should remain the primary concern.
Ms. Arndt acknowledged that everyone had made valid points and clarified that they were considering a $20,000 amount, not $10,000. She mentioned the inclusion of a timeframe with a possible justified extension and suggested using the current Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) process as a model. She emphasized the importance of verifying 501(c)(3) status through GuideStar and clarified that for-profit entities could partner with non-profits. Additionally, she proposed increasing the narrative limit from 50 words (about a quarter of a page) to a full page and stressed the importance of letters of support and leveraging other funding sources.
Responding to Mr. Hugg, Ms. Arndt stated that all the necessary information had been provided and should be incorporated into the revised document, which would then be brought back for review.
This item was informational, committee action was not required.
Ms. Arndt moved for adjournment of the Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee meeting, hearing no objection, the meeting adjourned at 7:04 p.m.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Council President Neil presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Dr. Sudler moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha, and unanimously carried.
Página 23
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 23
Construction Relief Program (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager) Mr. David S. Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Construction Relief Program.
Mr. Anderson offered a few suggestions, emphasizing the need to clarify that the list of criteria is an "or" list, not an "and" list, to avoid confusion for applicants who may think that they need to meet all the requirements. He noted that clarification was important, so eligible individuals are not discouraged from applying. He also stressed the importance of keeping the process simple and accessible, allowing people to easily download the application from the website. He added that the relevant areas should already be in the city's database, and that information should be shared with customer service so applicants can identify which blocks are eligible for the activities. Mr. Anderson emphasized the importance of keeping the unit of activity restricted to a block, explaining that activities, such as events or projects, can impact an entire block, regardless of whether they occur directly in front of a business or residence. He noted that clear and valid criteria have already been established and stressed the need to keep the application process simple and achievable.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg stated that some criteria would be established and provided to customer service, who would then apply any qualifying relief as a credit in the following months. If a business experienced disruption, such as a 50% reduction in foot traffic, it would need to provide proof of that impact. He explained that a document outlining the nature of the disruption, and its effect would be created and then submitted to customer service for processing.
Dr. Sudler expressed concern regarding high noise levels under the city's noise ordinance. He noted that the Dover Police Department uses a specific decibel threshold to measure excessive noise and suggested that this standard could be used as a reference point to set parameters for noise-related disruptions. Acknowledging that construction noise can affect areas beyond a single block, he emphasized the importance of defining a clear decibel threshold to guide decisions about providing relief to affected individuals or businesses, ensuring alignment with the existing noise ordinance.
Ms. Arndt acknowledged that State Street construction was disruptive but pointed out that residents received no relief for lost sleep. She argued that such quality-of- life impacts are too subjective and difficult to measure. She supported reimbursing businesses for documented financial losses but felt uneasy about addressing quality-of-life issues related to an individual’s sleep habits. Although she sympathized with affected residents, she emphasized that this was progress and warned that tracking such subjective impacts could set an undesirable precedent.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Hugg stated that there was no money coming in, but that they would have credit against the electric bill. He explained that if a
Página 24
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 24
downtown business met at least one of the established criteria, it would need to demonstrate the impact to qualify. The relief provided would come in the form of a utility credit, not a money transfer.
Responding to Mr. Hugg, Mr. Lewis stated that the proposal should have specified the funding source and indicated that the assistance would be in the form of credit. He questioned why, if businesses are impacted by future construction, they would not also request payment plans or similar relief. He raised equity concerns by questioning what support was being provided to customers in other areas of the city, such as Kenton Road, Forrest Avenue, and Saulsbury Road, where major construction projects are also underway. He questioned the advocacy for one group of customers without offering the same support to others who were facing similar disruptions.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney acknowledged that he made a valid point about the concern of singling out one group over others. She noted that the level of support or relief should depend on the specific impact experienced in a given area.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Marney stated that she was not in favor of issuing credits, viewing them as what would be considered a “goodwill credit” in the customer service and accounting world. She explained that offering those credits would be a gesture of goodwill toward constituents in response to disturbances. She emphasized that it would be up to council to decide whether or not to move forward with this approach.
Mayor Christiansen commended Mr. Anderson’s intentions but emphasized that other parts of the city have also experienced disruptions from construction, such as street paving, without receiving relief. He argued that the temporary inconveniences for downtown businesses and residents do not justify credits, since the long-term benefits, such as improved water, sewer, and electric infrastructure, would enhance property values and quality of life. While expressing his dislike for nighttime construction, he stated that he would be willing to tolerate the disruption if it meant replacing outdated infrastructure and achieving lasting improvements. He stated that by acknowledging the community's concerns for livelihoods and sleep, he stressed that the short-term discomfort would be outweighed by the long-term rewards for those living and working downtown.
Dr. Iriowen expressed that there was no reason to compensate individuals who are experiencing temporary disruptions aimed at improving their quality of life. He questioned what criteria would determine who qualifies for compensation. He emphasized the importance of going through the challenges together without focusing on compensation, trusting that there is a brighter future ahead. He cautioned against starting initiatives that they cannot control or complete.
Página 25
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 25
Mr. Anderson reminded council that the Construction Relief Program had already been approved, and that the current task was to establish the criteria for implementing it. He clarified that the intent was not to enhance the lives of current business owners directly, but rather the future expansion of downtown. He stated that long-standing businesses that endured COVID-19, economic struggles, and disruptions now bear the weight of their vision. Losing those anchor businesses for the improvement of downtown would be ridiculous. He noted that it was important to establish a positive criterion. He emphasized that economic development is not just about expansion, but also about retention. He stated that there were two goals for economic development and that was to retain existing businesses and attract new businesses. Keeping the businesses that currently exist should be the top priority, followed by efforts to attract new ones. He stated that if they do not keep the current businesses, then they are not going to bring in new businesses because those businesses would see how they treated their existing customers. He believed that the focus was on economic damages, and the original approved proposal addressed those affected businesses. He also noted that while he generally disagreed with Ms. Arndt, some members of council had requested that residents also be included.
Mr. Anderson stated that he was comfortable with whatever the majority of council decided, as long as the Construction Relief Program stayed within the $75,000 budget. He acknowledged that there could be a valid case for including residents in the program but emphasized that the focus was on economic survival. He compared the downtown area with areas like Kenton Road, noting that there were not a lot of businesses that were affected by the construction. As well as Forrest Avenue, most of the businesses located there have different outlets and do not have the same economic impact. He noted that Downtown Dover presented a unique situation where there was primarily street parking and sidewalk access, with no shopping centers. The focus was primarily on pedestrians walking to businesses where the sidewalks might be removed. He stated that this was a unique situation demanding unique actions to be taken.
Ms. Arndt stated that she agreed with Mr. Anderson’s comments but clarified that she did not support compensating residents for loss of sleep. Her concern was that her previous remarks might be misunderstood. She emphasized that she supports assisting businesses that experience a loss of revenue during the construction period by providing credits toward their city utility bills. She stated that the city owed those businesses support that have fought to remain downtown and that such assistance is reasonable during the disruption caused by construction.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson stated that while the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) officers and the businesses he has spoken with support the initiative, he was not aware of an official vote by the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) board. He clarified that he did not want to claim full Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) support without such a vote. However, the executive officers of the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) are unanimously in
Página 26
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 26
favor. If a Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) endorsement is desired, he suggested that the matter could be added to the agenda for a vote.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Dr. Sudler stated that it would be the right way to go, especially if the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) were asking for this. The Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) was part of the initial reason why council was doing this. They have a bit more money and are still an entity of the City of Dover. He noted that since grant money was provided to the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP), he believes that council should have access to those funds.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson stated that they did check into the grant money and that the grant money was limited to the specific criteria, which would be acceptable since the $1,500,000 did not have to be used for necessary upgrades. The grant would benefit the city's infrastructure, not the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP).
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Dr. Sudler suggested that the existing criteria would allow for compensation related to the disruptions, since they were still dealing with structural infrastructural issues and what could be allotted. He noted that if his argument was well-presented and aligned with the criteria, it could be permissible and justifiable, especially since it addressed structural issues and the disruption to businesses. That would support Downtown Dover’s economic vitality. Dr. Sudler suggested pursuing a legal opinion to determine if this approach would be appropriate.
Dr. Pillsbury stated that she supported Ms. Arndt’s comments. She noted that individuals work 24/7 and believed that they would have a difficult time compensating people for noise disruptions. She mentioned that everyone tolerates bad things, but there are alternative ways to deal with noise. She mentioned that she does not agree with supporting the residents but understands the issue with businesses.
Mr. Hugg stated that they had sufficient time to finalize the details of the Construction Relief Program, as the construction was not scheduled to begin until March of the following year. He emphasized that this provided an opportunity to develop and, if desired, test the program before they carry out the proposal. He noted that the construction would span 12 months, marking it as a significantly longer project than others the city undertakes, such as the Bradford Street repairs.
Ms. Arndt stated that she does not believe the financial impact on the city will be significant. She acknowledged that any impact matters but noted that due to phased construction, block-by-block, utility bill credits, the limited number of businesses per block, and many empty storefronts, the overall revenue loss on electric bills would not be substantial. She mentioned that it would be substantial to the property owners, but in terms of the impact on the city in regard to lost revenue, she does not foresee that as being something they should be concerned
Página 27
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 27
about at this point. She believes that it was more important to provide relief to the business owners because it represented a bigger issue for those individual owners than for the city’s collected revenue.
Mr. Neil stated that without funding from the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP), they may face similar challenges in the future. He questioned the support for renters but emphasized that the priority was the business owners. Some of whom might have to close because customers cannot access their locations. He acknowledged that residents living in the area would still need a way to navigate the construction, but the disruption for them would be fairly short. He noted that construction was inevitable, whether it happens now or later. He also noted that the choice would need to be made if it was only going to be just businesses or whether it was going to be on the residents who live there.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Marney stated that because the situation involves public utilities and the provision of credits, it would qualify as a goodwill credit to a customer’s utility account. She clarified that the action falls within their authority and would be in compliance with the bond council. She noted that she would officially confirm this, follow up with an email for verification, and assured that they would comply with the bond council.
Dr. Iriowen proposed separating businesses and residents into two groups, recommending that utility bill credits be provided to businesses while discussions regarding residents continue.
Mr. Hugg suggested exploring alternative options in coordination with Mr. Anderson, given his strong interest in the matter. He offered to contact the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) for feedback and, if Council agreed, report back in a few months to continue the discussion.
This item was informational, committee action was not required.
Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting, hearing no objection, the meeting adjourned at 7:40 p.m.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Shevock moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and unanimously carried.
Página 28
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 28
Proposed Ordinance #2025-09 – Amending Chapter 102 – Taxation, Article I – In General, Section 102-1 – Valuation and Assessment (Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director) Ms. Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director, reviewed the background and analysis regarding Proposed Ordinance #2025-09 – Amending Chapter 102 – Taxation, Article I – In General, Section 102-1 – Valuation and Assessment.
Staff recommended that the committee approve Proposed Ordinance #2025-09 and forward it to Council for approval.
Mr. Anderson expressed concern about depending on the Kent County Levy Court for future assessments, noting that the assessments were only done when the courts made them. He proposed an amendment to remove the strike-through language and instead have an option to choose either Kent County Levy Court assessors, or a group of assessors, such as mass assessors or a consortium, to handle the responsibility. He explained that as long as the Kent County Levy Court remained current, they would always be the preferred choice, unless they failed to fulfill their duties. However, removing the strike-through would limit options solely to the Kent County Levy Court, preventing the use of alternatives like Tyler Munis. He emphasized wanting to have the freedom to use a backup option if the Kent County Levy Court fails to do its job, so the city would not end up in a lawsuit with them.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Haines emphasized the need to examine the financial differences between the city and county assessments. She noted that the city’s 2025 assessment was based on 2020 data, amounting to $5.1 billion, while the county’s reassessment was at $6.5 billion. However, the county’s figure includes 210 more properties than the city’s records show. She stated that the financial distinction between the city and the county’s assessment would need to be looked into. Ms. Haines explained that the county taxes rental trailers, whereas the city taxes the land they occupy. She also noted the Customer Service team was unable to complete the task for this year and requested that the 2020 evaluation be applied to go for the 2025 tax bill, since it still needed to be evaluated.
Dr. Sudler expressed uncertainty about relying on the county for assessments, emphasizing the importance of having the city’s process to account for the criteria. He pointed out the differences between city and county tax variables. He noted that while using the county’s method might generate more revenue for the city. He was not convinced it would best serve their constituents' interests.
Ms. Haines reminded the council that the 2020 re-evaluation cost the city $104,550. She noted the ongoing expenses with Tyler Munis, noting that last year’s bill was $17,300. Each time assessments were needed, there was an additional charge of $700 for four hours of work. She stated that requesting an assessment report from Kent County would cost $60 per report, and the annual cost would total $300.
Página 29
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 29
Mr. Neil clarified that there was confusion about assessments, explaining that they are based on property sales in the given area, not on whether a home is in the county or city. He expected a significant increase in assessments in his community due to rising home values over the past five years. He mentioned that it was not a question about receiving more money, because the city is revenue- neutral. While some neighborhoods may see higher assessments, others may see little change or even lower amounts if property values are depressed. Mr. Neil also expressed concerns about how Tyler Munis conducted assessments in the community but noted that it had nothing to do with the home sales. He noted that there was miscommunication, which caused fear among residents, but he emphasized that no additional money would be collected beyond what was already budgeted from the assessments.
Mr. Anderson reminded everyone that the only reason the amount was $104,000 was that they used to have an Assessor’s office. They did the majority of the assessment work in-house and only contracted for what they could not do. Otherwise, it would have been $500,000. He noted that the cost would probably be more today than five years ago. He explained that the Kent County Levy Court used the same assessment company that the city did, and they received the same type of values. The city and Levy Court both received similar results, if not the same results, but they would just charge the city for it. He noted that if they wanted to use something different than the Kent County Levy Court, then they would need to look back at eliminating the Assessor’s office or be content with the double paying. He also noted that they were just going to use the work they did for the Kent County Levy Court for the City of Dover. They would import the information and then charge the city $500,000 but could get the work done for $60. He emphasized that it was the direction they should go. He noted that if they want to look differently, then he believes that they need to discuss whether or not they should have eliminated the Assessor’s office. That would be a discussion that they could not have due to a timeframe that they are required to meet. He believes the only answer is to take the Kent County Levy Court’s valuation and adjust it accordingly. If residents appeal to the values of the city, then they could make individual adjustments.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Haines clarified that they would take the Kent County Levy Court’s assessments, handle appeals, and then the city would accept their values. She noted that they were considering eliminating the Board of Appeals.
Ms. Marney stated that she and Ms. Haines spoke with representatives from Tyler Munis about steps for new assessments for the new year and were referred back to the county. She referred back to Mr. Anderson’s comments that the same data would be used for the assessments.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Marney stated that the double taxation occurred because residents who live in both the county and city would pay both the county and city tax bills. It was not based on the assessed value. She explained that
Página 30
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 30
regardless of whether the city uses its values or a different assessing company, it would still rely on the county’s values, and the issue of double taxation would remain due to the nature of tax design. In her opinion, they do have work to do to use the county values that Ms. Haines demonstrated, but it would save the city a significant amount of money. Not only by using the same assessment company, but also by maybe having to employ an Assessor’s office. She noted that it would be a council decision, and she supported using the county’s values. She also noted that there would be some reconsideration in doing away with the Board of Assessment Appeals so that the city still retained control over whether it issues a senior tax exemption, disability exemption, or an exemption for a non-profit.
Responding to Ms. Marney, Dr. Sudler stated that he knew that it was double taxation and understood the concept. He was focusing on that when it comes to property taxes and property assessment, what they are being taxed on, the assessment drives what the owners are getting taxed for their property. He noted that the city was charging him less than the county was, and he had the same amount of property. He explained that if the city could charge him between $1,500 to $2,000 less than the county, but if the city used the county’s criteria, his costs would increase by that amount. He emphasized that this was what he was discussing about the financial distinction between the county and city taxes. Dr. Sudler stated that he would be more in favor of staying with the city and having the city pay the cost.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Marney stated that there would always be a difference between county and city taxes. She explained that the city’s value at the moment was less than the county’s because the city’s last assessment was in 2020. If they were to do an assessment today, it would be more than or equal to what the county’s value stated. From reading Ms. Haines' proposal, she noted that it was not proposed that they implement the county values for Fiscal Year 2026. She stated that Ms. Haines is proposing to implement the county values in Fiscal Year 2027. She mentioned that it allows Ms. Haines' department time to evaluate the differences between what the county lists versus what the city has. She further mentioned that the county was currently assessing the mobile homes in Kings Cliff. She noted that the county was assessing the mobile homes, but that the city only assessed the land. She explained that it was not in the code that they assessed those buildings. To adhere to Mr. Neil’s point, it is a land lease community. The city was not currently taxing them. There were only certain land lease communities in their area that they taxed. She noted that Ms. Haines might present a proposal to council that could generate additional revenue for the city. Since they were using the 2020 assessment, the gap would eventually close as the county updates its assessments, regardless of whether the city or county values are used or who pays for the assessor.
Mayor Christiansen stated that Ms. Marney was correct that the values would eventually blend and that Fiscal Year 2027 was a good target date. He did have some concerns. He noted that when Mr. Crawford Carroll was mayor, they tried to get a separate service function budget established so that the services that the
Página 31
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 31
county provided to everyone would be duplicated within the city, with planning inspections, the assessor’s office, and other services. They wanted a refund, and it never came about. He mentioned that when they receive their county tax bill, the county taxes are a minimal part of that bill. The real impact is the school taxes, which are required by Delaware law to be collected by each county.
Mr. Anderson moved to recommend that the committee approve Proposed Ordinance #2025-09. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil. Responding to Mr. Shevock, Mr. Rocha stated that Mr. Anderson was going to move forward with the amendment, so there would be a change to the original ordinance.
Mr. Anderson moved to recommend that the committee approve the amended Proposed Ordinance #2025-09 to restore the strikeouts in lines 13 and 14 after the words Levy Court. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Rocha moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hall, Anderson, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Neil), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty).
Mr. Anderson moved to recommend adopting the amended Proposed Ordinance #2025-09, as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Rocha moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hall, Anderson, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Neil), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty).
Proposed Ordinance #2025-10 – Amending Chapter 2 – Administration, Article V. – Finance by adding Sec. 2-426 – Credit Card Processing Fees (Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director) Ms. Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director, reviewed the background and analysis regarding Proposed Ordinance #2025-10 – Amending Chapter 2 – Administration, Article V. – Finance by adding Sec. 2-426 – Credit Card Processing Fees.
Staff recommended that the committee approve Proposed Ordinance #2025-10 and forward it to Council for approval to charge $3.25 per credit card transaction.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Haines stated she would need to research which municipalities have the lowest and highest credit card fees.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Haines stated that the ultimate goal was to recoup the overall expense. She noted that they have approximately 153,000 electronic
Página 32
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 32
payments per year, so at $3.25, that would cover $497,250 of the cost. The city would still be responsible for $152,000.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Haines stated that going up to $3.50 or $3.75 would be open for discussion.
Dr. Sudler stated that he would like to see the numbers if they were to go up $3.75, and how that would impact their costs. He believes that would be doable because ATM transactions are at least $3.50, and that $3.75 would help collect some of the accrued financial hardships.
Ms. Arndt stated that she was in agreement with charging a fee and that it had been discussed several times before. She does not see this as a burden to the constituents because they have other options. Constituents do not have to pay by credit card, they can pay by direct debit, cash, or check directly to the city.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Haines stated that this was a reason why they wanted to go with a flat rate, because the flat rate pricing simplifies calculations for them, as they pay the same fee for every transaction. She noted that there was a credit card limit of $5,000 per swipe. Some businesses have an exception that can go over the $5,000 limit. She mentioned that Senate Bill 89, which was still in progress, could prevent charging any fees on credit card transactions exceeding $1,500.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Haines clarified that Senate Bill 89 would impact them because they would not be able to charge a fee.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Haines stated that Senator Russell Huxtable and Senator Bryan Townsend believed it was a good idea to come up with Senate Bill 89.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Haines stated that Senate Bill 89 does not clarify a benefit to protect the consumer from having to pay a fee for a credit card transaction.
Ms. Arndt supported the $3.25 and $3.50 fees and suggested working with key account specialists to encourage larger account holders who pay by credit card to switch to other payment methods to avoid processing fees.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Haines clarified that a fee would apply to online credit or debit card payments, but there would be no fee for payments made in person with cash, check, money order, or for those using auto withdrawal.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Haines stated that no additional fee would apply if a checking account was used for payment, as long as a debit card was not used.
Página 33
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 33
Mr. Lewis stated that the information should be shared with the public through Ms. Sass’s office to ensure transparency and prevent anyone from claiming they were not aware.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Haines explained that due to COVID-19, more individuals began paying bills with credit and debit cards instead of in person. Which led to reduced staffing in the cashiers. While online check payments avoid fees, small credit card transactions, such as $1.00 to $5.00 incur high processing costs.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Haines stated that the city’s bank and credit card fees totaled $650,000 in last year’s budget.
Mr. Neil stated that credit card companies offer different rates and questioned whether a Request for Proposal (RFP) should be done to find a better deal for the city. He emphasized that they should fight Senate Bill 89, saying it does not make sense, and noted Ms. Arndt’s point that there were alternative payment options. If there is a chance to get a better break from a credit card company for handling transactions, then they need to look for that.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Marney stated that the last banking Request for Proposal (RFP) was conducted five years ago. She noted that a banking Request for Proposal (RFP) is typically conducted every three years. She noted they are nearly tied into using the merchant service providers with which the city currently has credit card services. Due to their constraints with the utility billing and financial software, there were only a few merchants that could work with the accounting software companies that the city uses. She mentioned that she has looked into other credit card companies to handle transactions.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation of Proposed Ordinance #2025-10 with a provision to increase the credit card transaction fee from $3.25 to $3.75. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury. Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Haines stated that the dollar amount for the transaction would include the amount of the bill plus the $3.75 credit card transaction fee.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Ms. Marney explained that credit card fees vary based on the payment method and depending on the card type, ranging from 2% to 3%, with Visa at 1%, while Mastercard, Discover, and eChecks have different rates. Typically, a 2% charge per sale based on the sale amount, which is the gross sale multiplied by that percentage, would be what the city’s merchant charge is. She noted that in addition to the percentage, the city pays an administrative fee, so the flat fee was based on taking the gross number of online transactions, which was not the dollar figure, but the quantitative number. This would factor into what the city spends per year on the credit card fees to establish a flat fee rate. She also mentioned that Ms. Haines has been spending a lot of time working with credit card companies to ensure that it was enforced and while being compatible with
Página 34
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 34
their current accounting software and public portals to customers. The recommendation that was brought forth was the best path forward, as to a flat fee versus a percentage fee.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend accepting the Proposed Ordinance #2025-10 with a provision to increase the credit card transaction fee from $3.25 to $3.75 as the approved credit and debit card transaction fee, as recommended by staff. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Rocha moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hall, Anderson, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Neil), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty).
Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection, the meeting adjourned at 8:22 p.m.
Mr. Neil moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection, the meeting adjourned at 8:22 p.m.
By consent agenda, Mr. Rocha moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hall, Anderson, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Neil), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty).
MONTHLY REPORTS – APRIL 2024
By motion of Mr. Rocha, seconded by Ms. Arndt, the following monthly reports were accepted by consent agenda (Pillsbury and Boggerty absent):
City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
City Manager’s Report
Controller/Treasurer’s Budget Report
Fire Chief’s Report
Police Chief’s Report
APPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT NEIL
(DEFERRED DURING THE ANNUAL MEETING OF MAY 12, 2025)
By consent agenda, Mr. Rocha moved for approval of the following appointments, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hall, Anderson, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Neil), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty).
Página 35
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 35
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRS
- •ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026 Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee – Councilman David L. Anderson Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee – Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee – Councilman Andre M. Boggerty Utility Committee - Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
CITY CHAPLAIN – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Elder Ellis B. Louden
CONSTRUCTION AND PROPERTY MAINTENANCE CODE BOARD OF
APPEALS – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilman Andre M. Boggerty
Councilman Fred A. Neil
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
GENERAL EMPLOYEE PENSION PLAN BOARD – ONE-YEAR TERM
TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
OTHER POST-EMPLOYMENT BENEFITS (OPEB BOARD) – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
POLICE PENSION PLAN – RETIREMENT COMMITTEE – ONE-YEAR
TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
DOWNTOWN DOVER PARTNERSHIP BOARD OF DIRECTORS – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt
Councilman Roy Sudler, Jr.
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE – ONE-YEAR TERM TO
EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilwoman Donyale M. Hall
KENT COUNTY TOURISM BOARD – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE
MAY 2026
Councilwoman Donyale M. Hall
Página 36
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 36
KENT ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP BOARD OF DIRECTORS – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Mayor Robin R. Christiansen (Council President Designee)
HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION LIASON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO
EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Donyale M. Hall
CITY/COUNTY COMMITTEE – (LIASON TO KENT COUNTY) – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Mayor Robin R. Christiansen
Council President Fred A. Neil
Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt
Councilman David L. Anderson
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
David S. Hugg, III, City Manager
CENTRAL DELAWARE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE LIAISON – ONE-
YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Councilwoman Donyale M. Hall
EDUCATION LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
HEALTHCARE LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
DOVER AIR FORCE BASE (DAFB) LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO
EXPIRE MAY 2025
Councilman Andre M. Boggerty
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO
EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilman Andre M. Boggerty
UNSHELTERED AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING LIAISON – ONE-YEAR
TERM TO EXPIRE MAY 2026
Councilman Gerald L. Rocha, Sr.
HIGHER EDUCATION LIAISON – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY
2026
Councilwoman Tricia K. Arndt
CODE BOARD OF APPEALS – ONE-YEAR TERM TO EXPIRE MAY
2026
Councilwoman Julia M. Pillsbury
Página 37
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 37
Councilman Roy Sudler, Jr.
Council President Fred A. Neil
2024/2025 ANNUAL COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS – COUNCIL
COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE SUBCOMMITTEES –
RECOMMENDED BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT ANDERSON AND
COMMITTEE CHAIRS (DEFERRED DURING THE ANNUAL MEETING
OF MAY 13, 2024)
By consent agenda, Mr. Rocha moved for approval of the following appointments, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hall, Anderson, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Neil), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty).
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
William Garfinkel (Recommended by Chairman Anderson) Daniel T. Shevock (Recommended by Council President Neil)
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT
COMMITTEE
Michael Tholstrup (Recommended by Chairwoman Arndt) Michael W. Lewis (Recommended by Council President Neil)
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Vonderlear Smack (Recommended by Chairman Boggerty) Chanda P. Jackson (Recommended by Council President Neil)
UTILITY COMMITTEE
Esosa Iriowen (Recommended by Chairman Rocha) Michael Pugh (Recommended by Council President Neil)
RESOLUTION NO. 2025-07 – APPROVAL OF THE 2025 COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG) ACTION PLAN
The City Clerk read the following Resolution into the record:
A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE 2025-2029 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT CONSOLIDATED PLAN
WHEREAS, the City of Dover is entitled to $321,933 through the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development Community Development Block Grant program; and
WHEREAS, the City of Dover has prepared the 2025-2029 Consolidated Plan, in accordance with the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development guidelines, that serves as the primary planning document for identifying and meeting the housing and community development needs for the low and moderate-income residents of Dover; and
Página 38
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 38
WHEREAS, the City of Dover is in favor of utilizing the Community Development Block Grant funds for the community development purposes in accordance with the National Community Development objectives of benefiting low and moderate income families, eliminating slums and blight, and meeting other community development objectives; and
WHEREAS, the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development requires the City of Dover to submit a Consolidated Plan and an Action Plan for Application for Federal Assistance including the proposed use of funds and including certain certifications and policies to obtain its $321,933 entitlement; for eligible activities; and $18,000 in Program Income.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Council approve the 2025-2029 Community Development Block Grant Consolidated Plan and application for Federal Assistance included in the Consolidated Plan, along with certifications and policies attached and authorize its forwarding to the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for consideration.
ADOPTED: June 9, 2025
By consent agenda, Mr. Rocha moved for approval of the following appointments, seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a unanimous roll call vote and carried by a roll call vote, six (6) yes (Hall, Anderson, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Neil), one (1) no (Lewis), two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty).
SETTING OF ELECTRIC, WATER, AND WASTEWATER RATES AND TARIFFS
Mr. David Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the Electric, Water, and Wastewater Rates and Tariffs.
Ms. Arndt moved for adoption of the Electric, Water, and Wastewater Rates and Tariffs, seconded by Ms. Hall.
Ms. Arndt stated that they hire independent firms with expertise in setting, modeling, and projecting rates to ensure that they can continue to provide those essential services to their constituents. She pointed out that none of them want to raise rates, but unfortunately, these are the times they are living in, and everything is going up. The city cannot maintain the previous rates and still make necessary repairs, complete upgrades, and provide the level of service the constituents have come to expect. She emphasized that it was not her desire to raise rates, but at this point, there was no alternative. She noted that it was a very trim budget and felt that they had done their best, and that she stood by the rate as presented.
Ms. Arndt moved for adoption of the Electric, Water, and Wastewater Rates and Tariffs, seconded by Ms. Hall, and carried by a roll call vote, five (5) yes (Hall, Neil, Arndt, Rocha, Anderson), two (2) no (Sudler and Lewis), and two (2) absent (Pillsbury and Boggerty). IMMIGRATION POLICY CLARIFICATION (MAYOR ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN) Mayor Christiansen reiterated a statement he originally made on January 27, 2025, and reissued the statement, addressing the relationship between the City of Dover and Federal Immigration
Página 39
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 39
Laws (Exhibit #2). Before addressing his statement, he mentioned that he had been repeatedly asked about Chief Johnson’s presence at Legislative Hall. He explained that Chief Johnson attended committee meetings concerning laws affecting enforcement and public conduct, and each time, Chief Johnson did so with his support for the immigration policy.
REMOVING PROPERTY FROM THE 10-YEAR TAX ABATEMENT PROGRAM
(ALLISON HAINES, INTERIM CUSTOMER SERVICE DIRECTOR)
Ms. Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director, briefed members on Removing Properties from the 10-year Tax Abatement Program.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Haines stated that she would get back to him with more information regarding the Kent County assessment.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Haines stated that the tax abatement was originally given to the National Council on Agriculture. When the property was transferred, the abatement should have been removed, but that was not caught at the time. She noted that the 10-year period would have expired next year, but since the error had been identified, the abatement was being removed a year early.
Ms. Arndt moved for approval of the Removing Properties from the 10-Year Abatement Program, seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Pillsbury and Boggerty absent).
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-09 – AMENDING CHAPTER 102 – TAXATION, ARTICLE I – IN GENERAL, SECTION 102-1 – VALUATION AND ASSESSMENT (ALLISON HAINES, INTERIM CUSTOMER SERVICE DIRECTOR) Council President Neil reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com under “Government,” or by contacting the City Clerk’s Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us. Final action by Council on the proposed ordinance will take place during the Council Meeting of June 23, 2025.
Ms. Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2025-09 – Amending Chapter 102 – Taxation, Article I – In General, Section 102-1 – Valuation and Assessment.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Haines stated that she would get back to him with more information regarding the Kent County assessment.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Haines clarified that their reassessment will occur every five (5) years, and they would follow through with Kent County. She noted that was the reason the specific years were included in the ordinance. She also mentioned that next year would be the first year using Kent County’s assessed values, and the county’s next reassessment was scheduled for 2029.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
Página 40
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 40
ORDINANCE #2025-09 – AMENDING CHAPTER 102 -TAXATION,
ARTICLE I – IN GENERAL, SECTION 102-1 – VALUATION AND
ASSESSMENT.
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-10 – AMENDING CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION, ARTICLE V. – FINANCE BY ADDING SEC. 2-426 – CREDIT CARD PROCESSING FEES (ALLISON HAINES, INTERIM CUSTOMER SERVICE DIRECTOR) Council President Neil reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com under “Government,” or by contacting the City Clerk’s Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us. Final action by Council on the proposed ordinance will take place during the Council Meeting of June 23, 2025.
Ms. Allison Haines, Interim Customer Service Director, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2025-10 – Amending Chapter 2 – Administration, Article V. – Finance by Adding Sec. 2-246 – Credit Card Processing Fees.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Hugg stated that they have been communicating through the Delaware League of Local Governments (DLLG) regarding a series of bills that raised concerns for them. He noted that a particular reason that they were looking at having an effective date of September was that if, for some reason, one (1) of those bills passes, then they would need to revisit and either amend or choose not to move forward with the ordinance. The bill puts a ceiling on the amount a jurisdiction could charge as part of a utility or other municipal bill.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2025-10 – AMENDING CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION,
ARTICLE V. – FINANCE BY ADDING SEC. 2-426 – CREDIT CARD
PROCESSING FEES.
FIRST READING PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-11 – FISCAL YEAR 2025/2026 CITY OF DOVER BUDGET ORDINANCE (DAVID HUGG, III, CITY MANAGER) Council President Neil reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com under “Government,” or by contacting the City Clerk’s Office at 302-736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us. Final action by Council on the proposed ordinance will take place during the Council Meeting of June 23, 2025.
Mr. David Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed Proposed Ordinance #2025-11 – Fiscal Year 2025/2026 City of Dover Budget Ordinance.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that council was entitled to the same raise that non- bargaining employees receive on an annual basis. He clarified that the raise was set at 4%, but council members could choose to decline it either individually or collectively. If they did so, the corresponding amount would simply be removed from the budget.
Página 41
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 41
Mr. Lewis stated that he had previously raised the issue about receiving a raise and had written an op-ed in the newspaper where he respectfully declined the raise. He noted that he was informed that he had to accept it, and as a result, to this day, any additional monies that he has received have been donated to a non-profit organization. He stated that it has been the approach he has taken. He stated that if there was a new option or alternative that could be done to please let him know. He emphasized that he would not be accepting the raise for the next fiscal year and respectfully declined.
Ms. Marney stated that, with respect to Mr. Hugg’s comments, if council as a whole were to remove the pay increase, a motion would need to be made on the floor. She explained that if the increase was included as part of the budget, individual members could not reject the pay increase on their own. because it is part of the budget. She pointed out that it was the situation that they encountered last year.
Mr. Rocha made a motion to remove the Fiscal Year 2026 4% pay raise for members of City Council. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Marney stated that they would need to review the calculations and get back to council with the total dollar amount.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Hugg stated that council could take their current compensation and multiply it by 4% to determine the amount of the increase. He cannot recall the exact figure offhand, but that Council President would receive the largest increase, while other council members would all receive the same amount.
Mr. Anderston stated that he would not have an issue if the funds from the pay increase were redirected toward the fire department grants. He mentioned that he would like to know the exact amount because it would be estimated at a few thousand dollars. He pointed out that knowing the precise figure was important when making the decision, especially given the public policy implications. He explained that the charter was designed to match the pay increases of non- bargaining employees for a few reasons. It was to prevent the need for a large increase later to do a catch-up and to adjust to keep pace with the current wages. He noted that the raise was not designed to be significant, but rather it keeps council’s compensation aligned with the non- bargaining employees, just like everyone else, so there was no special treatment. He highlighted that it was a public policy decision.
Mr. Anderson was open to declining the raise for a year if those funds could be redirected to something such as firefighters' needs. He emphasized that he had a real policy problem if they made that a habit because that approach would lead them back to the problem the charter was designed to prevent. He noted that moving away from the charter’s guidance was a bad policy choice. He also mentioned that the wisdom embedded in the charter was the right path and believed it was important to keep that in mind.
Ms. Arndt concurred with Mr. Anderson, noting that there was sound logic behind the policy when it was established. She pointed out that the amount was not significant, and that it would not be sufficient to address any budget shortfalls. She viewed the pay raise as largely symbolic and suggested that the matter be revisited next year without making any changes as a matter of
Página 42
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 42
policy. She emphasized that she was willing to forego the increase.
Mr. Neil stated that as Mr. Lewis has done, he has taken the excess funds and managed to give back to the community. He reminded members of council that he voted against the increase to begin with, but that was another story to be told another time.
Dr. Sudler stated that for nearly 20 years, before the recent raise, they were only receiving $7,000 a year to serve their community in the position they serve. He could not speak for all of the council members, but the position requires a significant amount of attention. He noted that if they are truly doing their job and staying connected with their constituents, it demands enormous time and dedication, such as attending meetings, being prepared, and more. He mentioned that he was not retired, as well as a few other council members, though some members are retired. In that context, they should not feel bad about the compensation they receive. That being said, he does agree that the raise was largely symbolic, and right now, several constituents are facing real hardships, and they need to be mindful of that. He noted that he would be in support of it this year, but he did not support the idea of giving back money that they have earned overall. He felt that all council members had earned their compensation, and as mentioned before, when he was Council President in 2021, they were only receiving $7,000 annually. He highlighted that the amount was below the minimum wage for professionals who dedicated their time to respond to constituent concerns. He stated that he would support the symbolic gesture of standing with their constituents during hard times. He noted that for this year, he would not need that increase, but these are hard times for everyone. He concurred with Mr. Anderson that this should not become something that they do regularly.
Ms. Bennett stated that Mr. Rodriguez had pointed out that the pay increases were now in the charter, and any changes to the charter would have to be approved by the General Assembly.
Mr. Hugg stated that, according to the Code of Ordinances, City of Dover, Delaware, Section 2- 20. (a)(2), Councilmembers generally. Each council member shall receive an annual salary of $18,000.00 (FY 2023). The council president shall receive an annual salary of $23,000.00 (FY 2023). He noted that the minimum increase, not including any cost adjustment made last year, was roughly $7,000, which was not a large amount.
Mr. Rodriguez stated that the amendment made by the General Assembly to their charter required that any further changes must also be made by the General Assembly. The City of Dover cannot make changes through any type of action by council.
Mr. Lewis mentioned that with respect to the Mayor, he recalled not long after everyone received raises, the Mayor issued a proclamation, stating that he would not accept any salary until 2027. He asked if council would be able to do something similar and if Mr. Rodgrieuz could look into the matter.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Rodgrieuz stated that he would check the charter and let Mr. Neil know what his findings were.
Mr. Rocha suggested that the motion be withdrawn and that any action be postponed until the final reading of the budget.
Página 43
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 43
Mr. Rocha rescinded his motion to remove the Fiscal Year 2026 4% pay raise for members of City Council.
Ms. Arndt rescinded her second for Mr. Rocha’s motion.
Mr. Anderson suggested that they could raise an amendment at this stage and let it lie with the ordinance. He noted that then they could address or dispose of it at the next meeting during the final reading. That way, they would have the necessary information before making a decision.
Ms. Bennett stated that it would be easier to withdraw the motion. She noted that if they determine that it can be done, they could revisit it. She referenced Mr. Rodriguez's comment, pointing out that, according to the language in the charter, once council's annual salary was established in Fiscal Year 2023, all future council pay raises would be tied.
Dr. Sudler asked that, since there was a motion on the floor and it was properly seconded under Robert’s Rules, it should need to be formally rescinded. He noted that they could not vote on the motion because it was governed by the charter. Based on his limited knowledge of parliamentary procedures, he stated that the motion would need to be rescinded.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Neil stated that, to his understanding, Mr. Rocha withdrew his motion.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Dr. Sudler stated that the motion was not withdrawn; it was left on the table. He noted that under parliamentary procedures, a motion that has been properly made and seconded requires a vote. Since no action can be taken until they receive the necessary information regarding the charter.
Mr. Rocha rescinded his motion.
Ms. Arndt rescinded her second for Mr. Rocha’s motion.
Mr. Neil stated that the motion was off the floor for now and can be brought back if they determine what action can be taken.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2025-11 – FISCAL YEAR 2025/2026 CITY OF DOVER BUDGET ORDINANCE.
CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Hugg had no announcements.
MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mayor Christiansen stated that by resolution of council, he had requested that the mayor’s salary be frozen at the amount it was for the last fiscal year. He noted that any changes would require a unanimous vote of council in 2027, emphasizing that it was a
Página 44
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 44
point of clarification.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Lewis stated that he wanted to obtain the particulars to see if council could take similar action.
Mayor Christiansen announced several upcoming events that are coming to Dover. On Saturday, June 14, 2025, the city is hosting a Comic-Con downtown. On June 21, 2025, a Juneteenth celebration with a parade will take place on the Legislative Mall. The African American Festival, sponsored by former Councilman Rubin Salters and Positively Dover, is scheduled for June 28, 2025. The Old-Fashioned Independence Day Celebration Parade and fireworks will be held downtown on July 4, 2025. Additionally, an Elvis Presley tribute concert will be performed at the Schwartz Center for the Arts at 7:00 p.m. on June 20, 2025.
COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Anderson reported that the Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP) will hold a Capital City 2030 community update on Thursday, June 26th, from 4:30 to 6:30 p.m. at The Hive, 28 West Lockerman Street. The event will share updates on key projects, including a mobility center, the mixed-use redevelopment of 120 South Governor’s Avenue, Loockerman Streetscape enhancements, and more. The event is open to the public with no RSVP required. He wanted to encourage individuals to show up. Mr. Anderson explained that these developments aim to increase Dover’s taxable property base over time, helping to broaden the city’s tax base. He stated that it was reported that development of the Garrison Tracts is underway, which will add hundreds of millions of dollars to the city’s tax base, contributing to significant growth. He encouraged residents to attend the upcoming community updates on these developments. He highlighted that a tribute is to be made to the United States Army, which will celebrate its 250th birthday on June 14th, 2025. He noted that the Army was recognized as the oldest institution defending freedom in the world, having played a crucial role in shaping the United States and impacting global freedom, technology, and prosperity.
Mr. Lewis reported that he had assisted and coordinated a neighborhood watch in Clearview Meadow, a development in the Second District, last month. He mentioned that if any council members were interested in starting a neighborhood watch in their areas, to let him know and he would share the information. He noted that he has been contacted by a few other communities in the Second District interested in the neighborhood watch program. It is a very resourceful initiative, which is coordinated with the Dover Community Policing Unit. He noted that they attend the meetings and provide valuable insight.
Ms. Hall added to Mr. Anderson’s comments regarding the Army celebration, noting that June 12 also recognizes women’s service in the military. She expressed gratitude to all women veterans for their service and sacrifice, sharing her own pride in having served her country.
Mr. Neil addressed the fact that he was accused of telling individuals that they should leave the city. He clarified that he was warning them that if they did leave, they might be unhappy and would have to pay the moving and processing costs to return to Dover.
The meeting adjourned at 9:16 p.m.
Página 45
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF JUNE 9, 2025 PAGE 45
ANDRIA L. BENNETT CITY CLERK
All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by the City Council during their Regular Meeting of June 9, 2025, are hereby approved.
ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR /AB
Exhibits Exhibit #1 – Statement from Vonderlear Smack Exhibit #2 – Mayor Christiansen’s Letter for the City of Dover’s Relationship to Federal Immigration Laws
Página 46
EXHIBIT #1
Regular Council Meeting of 06/09/2025
Página 48
EXHIBIT #2
Regular Council Meeting of 06/09/2025