Page 1
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE
AGENDA
FEBRUARY 9, 2016 - 6:00 P.M.
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS
15 LOOCKERMAN PLAZA
DOVER, DELAWARE
PUBLIC COMMENTS ARE WELCOMED ON ANY ITEM AND WILL BE PERMITTED AT APPROPRIATE
TIMES. WHEN POSSIBLE, PLEASE NOTIFY THE CITY CLERK (736-7008 OR E-MAIL AT
CITYCLERK@DOVER.DE.US) SHOULD YOU WISH TO BE RECOGNIZED.
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
1. DRAFT COMMITTEE STRATEGIC PLAN TO SUBMIT FOR STAFF REVIEW
2. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG) PROGRAM QUARTERLY UPDATE (OCTOBER,
NOVEMBER, AND DECEMBER)
(COMMITTEE ACTION NOT REQUIRED)
3. CITIZEN SUGGESTION - ECONOMIC EMPOWERMENT (CLAY HAMMOND)
4. ADJOURNMENT
UTILITY COMMITTEE
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
1. ADDITIONAL POWER SUPPLY ALTERNATIVES
(STAFF RECOMMENDS AUTHORIZING THE ENERGY MANAGER TO EXPLORE TWO (2) EXCEPTIONS TO
THE GOVERNING ENERGY COMMODITY RISK POLICY TO PURSUE NEGOTIATIONS FOR TWO (2)
SEPARATE COMMODITY TRANSACTIONS INTENDED TO MEET THE CITY’S ELECTRIC LOAD
REQUIREMENTS AND REDUCE THE CITY’S RISK)
2. QUARTERLY REVIEW OF UTILITY RELATED CAPITAL INVESTMENT PLAN (CIP) (ELECTRIC AND
WATER/WASTEWATER)(OCTOBER, NOVEMBER, AND DECEMBER)
(COMMITTEE ACTION NOT REQUIRED)
3. TEA/NAES REPORT (OCTOBER, NOVEMBER, AND DECEMBER)
(STAFF RECOMMENDS ACCEPTANCE OF THE REPORT)
Page 2
FEBRUARY 9, 2016 COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE Page 2
UTILITY COMMITTEE (CONTINUED)
4. UPDATES
(COMMITTEE ACTION NOT REQUIRED ON THE BELOW ITEMS)
A. GREEN ENERGY FUNDING AND PROGRAMMING
B. NATIONAL POLLUTION DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM (NPDES) MUNICIPAL SEPARATE
STORM SEWER SYSTEMS (MS4) PERMIT
C. GARRISON OAK TECHNICAL PARK PROJECT UPDATES
C-1. CITY INFRASTRUCTURE
C-2. CALPINE ENERGY CENTER
C-3. DOVER SUN PARK
5. ADJOURNMENT
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
1. DISCUSSION - ELECTRIC CUTOFF PROCESS REVIEW
2. PROPOSED ORDINANCES
A. #2016-01 WITH STAFF AMENDMENT #1 (SA#1) AMENDING CHAPTER 18 - ANIMALS, SECTION 18-1
- DEFINITIONS, AND APPENDIX B - ZONING, ARTICLE 3 - DISTRICT REGULATIONS, SECTION 1 -
ONE-FAMILY RESIDENCE ZONES [(R-20, R-15, R-10, R-8 AND R-7)], SUBSECTION 1.1 - USES
PERMITTED, SUBSECTION 1.15 - ACCESSORY USES, LIMITED TO THE FOLLOWING:, PARAGRAPH
(D) - KEEPING DOMESTIC ANIMALS AND ARTICLE 12 - DEFINITIONS (REFERRED BACK TO
COMMITTEE BY CITY COUNCIL DURING THEIR REGULAR MEETING OF JANUARY 25, 2016)
B. #2016-07 - SECOND BUDGET AMENDMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2015/2016
3. REPORT OF INDEPENDENT PUBLIC ACCOUNTANTS FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 2015
(COMMITTEE ACTION NOT REQUIRED)
4. ADJOURNMENT
/TM
S:\AGENDAS-MINUTES-PACKETS-PRESENTATIONS-ATT&EXH\COMMITTEE-AGENDAS\2016\02-09-2016 CCW.WPD
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO
INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS.
Page 3
From: David Anderson
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: Fwd: Question
Date: Thursday, February 04, 2016 10:46:18 AM
Attachments: CM Anderson $1.5 million Bond Amtz.pdf
Please add this under strategic plan.
The Honorable David L. Anderson
4th District Councilman, Dover, DE
Phone: (302)339-1047
Council Office: (302)736-7006
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Mitchell, Donna <DMitchell@dover.de.us>
Date: Thu, Feb 4, 2016 at 10:15 AM
Subject: RE: Question
To: "Anderson, David" <davidlevianderson@gmail.com>
I’m not sure if I forgot the attachment. Sorry if I did.
Thank you,
Donna
From: Mitchell, Donna
Sent: Monday, February 01, 2016 9:27 AM
To: Anderson, David
Subject: RE: Question
Mr. Anderson,
It will depend on how the bond is structured. The Financial Advisor solicits a bid and the bidder’s
provide what each year’s CUSIP principal will be and the interest rate on each cusip. For example,
one year that may have a $30,000 principal and 3.0% interest rate and another year they may bid a
$40,000 principal payment and a 2.95% rate. The Financial Advisor will compile all the bids and find
out which one is the least cost for the
City.
Page 4
I have attached a straight line amortization table to give you a ball park figure. Our bonds are
normally done for a 20 year horizon, as the ratings agencies like to see you pay them off in a shorter
time span, and a 3.85% interest rate. The last bond issue we did in 2014 had a 3.0% interest rate on
the first 10 year cusips, and then went up as high as 4.25% in the latter years. The Fed is starting to
increase interest rates now.
Hope this helps.
Donna S. Mitchell, CPA
(not in public practice)
City of Dover
Controller/Treasurer
5 E. Reed Street, Suite 300
Dover, DE 19904
(302) 736-7018
dmitchell@dover.de.us
“Action without study is fatal. Study without action is futile.” - Mary Beard
From: David Anderson [mailto:davidlevianderson@gmail.com]
Sent: Sunday, January 31, 2016 11:59 PM
To: Mitchell, Donna
Subject: Question
Page 5
Donna,
What would the interest rate and annual payment be on a 1.5 million dollar general obligation
bond be?
Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device
Page 6
Loan Amortization Schedule
Enter values Loan summary
Loan amount $ 1,500,000.00 Scheduled payment $ 108,911.60
Annual interest rate 3.85 % Scheduled number of payments 20
Loan period in years 20 Actual number of payments 20
Number of payments per year 1 Total early payments $ -
Start date of loan 6/30/2017 Total interest $ 678,232.01
Optional extra payments $ -
Lender name: Request of CM Anderson
Pmt. Scheduled
Payment Date Beginning Balance Extra Payment Total Payment Principal Interest Ending Balance Cumulative Interest
No. Payment
1 6/30/2018 $ 1,500,000.00 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 51,161.60 $ 57,750.00 $ 1,448,838.40 $ 57,750.00
2 6/30/2019 $ 1,448,838.40 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 53,131.32 $ 55,780.28 $ 1,395,707.08 $ 113,530.28
3 6/30/2020 $ 1,395,707.08 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 55,176.88 $ 53,734.72 $ 1,340,530.20 $ 167,265.00
4 6/30/2021 $ 1,340,530.20 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 57,301.19 $ 51,610.41 $ 1,283,229.01 $ 218,875.41
5 6/30/2022 $ 1,283,229.01 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 59,507.28 $ 49,404.32 $ 1,223,721.73 $ 268,279.73
6 6/30/2023 $ 1,223,721.73 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 61,798.31 $ 47,113.29 $ 1,161,923.41 $ 315,393.02
7 6/30/2024 $ 1,161,923.41 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 64,177.55 $ 44,734.05 $ 1,097,745.86 $ 360,127.07
8 6/30/2025 $ 1,097,745.86 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 66,648.38 $ 42,263.22 $ 1,031,097.48 $ 402,390.28
9 6/30/2026 $ 1,031,097.48 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 69,214.35 $ 39,697.25 $ 961,883.13 $ 442,087.54
10 6/30/2027 $ 961,883.13 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 71,879.10 $ 37,032.50 $ 890,004.03 $ 479,120.04
11 6/30/2028 $ 890,004.03 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 74,646.45 $ 34,265.16 $ 815,357.59 $ 513,385.19
12 6/30/2029 $ 815,357.59 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 77,520.33 $ 31,391.27 $ 737,837.25 $ 544,776.46
13 6/30/2030 $ 737,837.25 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 80,504.87 $ 28,406.73 $ 657,332.39 $ 573,183.19
14 6/30/2031 $ 657,332.39 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 83,604.30 $ 25,307.30 $ 573,728.08 $ 598,490.49
15 6/30/2032 $ 573,728.08 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 86,823.07 $ 22,088.53 $ 486,905.01 $ 620,579.02
16 6/30/2033 $ 486,905.01 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 90,165.76 $ 18,745.84 $ 396,739.25 $ 639,324.86
17 6/30/2034 $ 396,739.25 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 93,637.14 $ 15,274.46 $ 303,102.12 $ 654,599.33
18 6/30/2035 $ 303,102.12 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 97,242.17 $ 11,669.43 $ 205,859.95 $ 666,268.76
19 6/30/2036 $ 205,859.95 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 108,911.60 $ 100,985.99 $ 7,925.61 $ 104,873.95 $ 674,194.37
20 6/30/2037 $ 104,873.95 $ 108,911.60 $ - $ 104,873.95 $ 100,836.31 $ 4,037.65 $ - $ 678,232.01
Page 7
CDBG Quarterly Report 2015
October, November, December
CDBG FY15 Projects
Homeownership Assistance Program
CDBG funds will be used to provide homeownership assistance to first-time homebuyers who
purchase affordable housing in the Downtown Development District (DDD) Target Area. One
(1) family is scheduled to go to settlement in January 2016 to purchase a property in the DDD
Target Area.
Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing
CDBG funds will be used for operations cost for the shelter. This project is currently underway with
41% of program funds spent year to date.
Connections Community Support Program
CDBG funds will be used to provide rapid re-housing/rental assistance services for homeless
households within the City. Rental assistance was provided for one (1) low income person.
Milford Housing Homeowner Rehabilitation Program
CDBG funds will be used to rehabilitate existing owner occupied housing in the City that is in
violation of the City’s Housing Code and complete emergency home repairs to eliminate
housing conditions that threaten the health and safety of low income homeowners. Emergency
home repairs were completed for five (5) low income households during the quarter.
Habitat for Humanity
CDBG funds will be used to rehabilitate an existing home to provide affordable housing to a
family in the Downtown Development District Target Area. Habitat purchased 111 S. Queen on
November 2, 2015, renovated the property, and sold the property on December 18th to a first time
homebuyer.
Peoples Place Whatcoat Homeless Shelter
CDBG funds will be utilized for minor renovations to a facility that shelters the homeless. This
project is completed.
Mayors Challenge to End Veterans Homelessness
The Mayor’s Task Force for Ending Veterans Homelessness has met its goal by housing 50
Veterans by December 28, 2015. There will be a 300 day celebration held on January 20th at
Grotto’s Pizza in Dover to celebrate this accomplishment.
Page 8
Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement 2/8/2016
Status of FY-15 Program Funds Spent - Fiscal Year 7/1/15- 6/30/16
2015 Grant Projects Project Details Total Grant Funds Expended Unencumbered Balance
Funds will be utilized for
settlement assistance for
Homeownership Assistance Program $60,000 $40,000 $20,000
properties purchased in
the DDD Target Area
Funds will be utilized for
rapid re-housing/rental
Connections $7,391 $1,700 $5,691
assistance for low income
persons
Funds will be used for
Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing $27,000 $11,258 $15,742
operation cost
Funds will be utilized for
Milford Housing Development Corp emergency home repairs. $35,262 $12,989 $22,273
Project underway
Funds will be utilized for
Milford Housing Development Corp rehabbing owner occupied $52,892 $0 $52,892
homes. Project underway
Funds will be utilized to
rehab a single family
Habitat for Humanity $40,000 $24,819 $15,181
home for a low income
family
Funds will be used for
Peoples Place replacement windows for $6,726 $6,726 $0
a homeless shelter.
Total $229,271 $97,492 $131,779
Page 9
From: David Anderson
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: Fwd: Per Our Conversation
Date: Thursday, February 04, 2016 10:36:57 AM
Attachments: Dover City Council 8 31.doc
for packet
The Honorable David L. Anderson
4th District Councilman, Dover, DE
Phone: (302)339-1047
Council Office: (302)736-7006
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: clay Hammond <chammond505@gmail.com>
Date: Mon, Aug 31, 2015 at 4:22 PM
Subject: Per Our Conversation
To: David Anderson <davidlevianderson@gmail.com>
Cc: Roy Sudler <roysudlerjr@comcast.net>
David
Attached is the email I will be sending to members of the city council this week requesting
that a commission be created to address issues that are adversely impacting the city's at-risk
and low income Black communities.
I'd like your and Roy's leadership on this issue.
Clay Hammond
Page 10
August 31, 2015
City Councilmen:
A major responsibility of municipal government is to provide a good quality of life for its
residents. With such being the case, city government has fallen woefully short as relates
to Black residents of low-income and at risk communities!
I make this assertion based on the following:
• The city’s economic development plans/strategy has never included
workforce development in spite of the high unemployment rate in the Black
community
• The city’s CDBG entitlement is only used for housing rehab in spite of the
fact that a large percentage of Blacks in distressed areas are renters
• The quasi-governmental economic development organization that the city
supports, Downtown Dover Partnership (DDP), has never developed
strategies or resources to address the economic development needs of low-
income and/or at risk residents of its target area that is comprised of a
significant number of Blacks
• The primary response to increased gun violence in the Black community is to
have an increased/enhanced police presence when increased economic
opportunities (i.e. jobs, self employment training, etc.) would be a more
effective deterrent.
• The city does not pursue grants to address the needs of at-risk and low
income residents of the city
There is a current phrase that is prevalent in our community across the nation is that
“Black lives matter”. For a significant portion of the Black community that is low-income
and /or at risk in Dover, Black lives don’t matter!
Given the tremendous economic and social disparities that exist in the city’s low-income
and at risk Black communities, government’s leadership has allowed them not only to
continue to exist, but increase in many areas! As data (i.e. poverty rate, unemployment
rate, etc.) that allows the city to receive CDBG funding is impacted by realities of the
low-income Black residents.
As a significant portion of the city’s Black community is in crisis, I would like to request
that city council create a formal “commission” that would be charged with the
development of a strategic plan and identifying resources to address both the causes and
effects of major issues in distressed Black communities (Kirkwood/New/Queen Streets,
Simon Circle, Capital Green). The commission could be composed of entities and
individuals that possess a wealth of resources, insight and expertise in addressing the
Page 11
myriad of issues that adversely impact the above-referenced communities. Some
members could be:
• Delaware State University
• Wesley College
• Faith Community
• Black Fraternal Organizations (fraternities, sororities, Masonic)
• City Government (City Council, Asst. City Manager, CDBG staff, etc.)
• Nonprofits (MLK Community Center, Delmarva Black Chamber, CenDel
Foundation, etc.)
• Community residents (youth, adults)
• Dover Housing Authority
• Dover Police Department
• Financial Institutions (credit unions, banks)
Let’s be proactive in addressing issues that have led to a sense of hopeless that many
Black residents feel too often contribute to negative behavior. As the same issues that led
to civil disturbance in Baltimore exist here, let’s not ignore them.
How the commission will differ from NCALL’s “Restoring Central Dover” initiative is
that it will focus exclusively on the Black community and address a broader range of
issues (i.e. mental health, asset creation, workforce development, etc.)
As the Black community comprises 40% Black (white population is 43% of the city’s
population, it is my hope that city government will invest in healing and empowering
Black residents of low-income and at risk communities.
Respectfully,
Clayton e. Hammond II
Page 12
Devine, Denise
From: David Anderson <davidlevianderson@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, February 04, 2016 10:39 AM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: Fwd: Economic Inclusion Advisory Body
For packet
The Honorable David L. Anderson
4th District Councilman, Dover, DE
Phone: (302)339-1047
Council Office: (302)736-7006
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: clay Hammond <chammond505@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, Nov 18, 2015 at 4:09 PM
Subject: Economic Inclusion Advisory Body
To: "Neaton, William G." <wneaton@dover.de.us>
Bill:
The following persons are my suggestions of individuals to comprise the Economic Inclusion
Advisory body.
Shep Sheppard House of Style chiffonrogers@yahoo.com
Dr. Tracy Underwood Eye to Eye Optometry seeingeye2eye@gmail.com
Mike White Janiaid’s The Salon for Men janaidkareem@hotmail.com
Hassan Zahar Zuha Men’s Fashions AHA18214@yahoo.com
Theo Morgan Computers Fixed Today computersfixedtoday@comcast.net
Kim Aigle Suds Bar sudsbar@gmail.com,
Clay Hammond Delmarva Black Chamber DeMdBlackChamber@comcast.net
Dr. Michael Casson DSU mcasson@desu.edu
Tifanee Lee-Scott Tifanee & Company tiffandcompany@yahoo.com
Arita Warren Tresses Hair Studio shellythestlist@gmail.com
Edmond Sinmaron Simaron’s simaron415@aol.com
Anne Smith MLK Center (workforce Development) floralconection@aol.com
Pablo Velazquez Branch Manager/Citizens Bank Pablo.velazquez@citizensbank.com
Clay
1
Page 13
Devine, Denise
From: David Anderson <davidlevianderson@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, February 04, 2016 10:43 AM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: Fwd: Request - Status Updates
And finally, the reason for moving this to the agenda, 4 months without the feeling that the issues are
addressed. The follow up letter.
The Honorable David L. Anderson
4th District Councilman, Dover, DE
Phone: (302)339-1047
Council Office: (302)736-7006
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: clay Hammond <chammond505@gmail.com>
Date: Mon, Dec 21, 2015 at 10:22 AM
Subject: Request - Status Updates
To: "Perez, Ed" <eperez@dover.de.us>, "Paul S. Davis" <paulsdavis@comcast.net>, Roy Sudler
<roysudlerjr@comcast.net>, David Anderson <davidlevianderson@gmail.com>
FYI
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "clay Hammond" <chammond505@gmail.com>
Date: Dec 21, 2015 10:19 AM
Subject: Request - Status Updates
To: "Neaton, William G." <wneaton@dover.de.us>
Cc:
Bill
Can you give me an update on the following:
1. Delmarva Black Chamber's status with the Kent County Entrepreneur Consortium
2. Status of funding request to City of Dover/DDP for the Ice House Program
3. New date for meeting with minority entrepreneurs in downtown Dover
4. Status for the creation of the Economic Inclusion Advisory body
Thanks
Clay Hammond
1
Page 14
From: David Anderson
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: Fwd: Important Research - Unbanked Individuals
Date: Thursday, February 04, 2016 10:38:01 AM
Attachments: FDIC Un Banked Study Exec Summary.pdf
For packet
The Honorable David L. Anderson
4th District Councilman, Dover, DE
Phone: (302)339-1047
Council Office: (302)736-7006
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: clay Hammond <chammond505@gmail.com>
Date: Fri, Jan 29, 2016 at 3:24 PM
Subject: Important Research - Unbanked Individuals
To: elmer davis <elmerdavis44@gmail.com>, Sylvester Beaman <sbeaman1@aol.com>,
leswanams@verizon.net, Michael Rogers <centralpastor@msn.com>, Rita Paige
<ritapaige7@comcast.net>, David Anderson <davidlevianderson@gmail.com>, Roy Sudler
<roysudlerjr@comcast.net>
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: <demdblackchamber@comcast.net>
Date: Jan 29, 2016 3:21 PM
Subject: Important Research - Unbanked Individuals
To: <chammond505@gmail.com>
Cc:
All:
The attached summary relates to research the FDIC conducted about the unbanked,
which reinforces our need for collective economic empowerment in our community!.
Clay Hammond
Chairman
Page 15
FDIC National
Survey of
Unbanked
and
Underbanked
Households
Executive Summary
Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation
December 2009
Page 16
Members of the FDIC Unbanked/Underbanked Survey Study Group
Team Members:
Office of the Vice Chairman: Barbara Ryan and Yazmin Osaki
Division of Insurance and Research: Susan Burhouse, David Chapman, Timothy Critchfield, Ryan Goodstein and Katherine
Samolyk
Division of Supervision and Consumer Protection: Angelisa Harris and Luke Reynolds.
Legal: Leneta Gregorie
Contributors: Michael Bachman, Peggi Gill, Michael Glenwick, Jocelyn Grazal, Peter Johnston, David Spanburg, Jacques Vilar,
and Kathy Zeidler
FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households ■ December 2009 2
Page 17
Executive Summary first time such data on unbanked and underbanked house-
holds are available at the national, state, and large MSA
levels. It is hoped that these survey results will help better
In January 2009, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corpora- inform the industry and policymakers about economic
tion (FDIC) sponsored a special supplement to the U.S. inclusion issues, and promote the goal of ensuring that all
Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey (CPS) to Americans have access to basic, safe, and affordable bank
collect national, state, and metropolitan statistical area services.
(MSA) data on the number of U.S. households that are
unbanked and underbanked, their demographic character- Key Overall Findings
istics, and their reasons for being unbanked and under- • An estimated 7.7 percent of U.S. households,
banked.1 The Census Bureau surveyed approximately approximately 9 million, are unbanked.3 At least 17
54,000 households, and about 47,000 (86 percent) partici- million adults reside in these unbanked households
pated in the FDIC’s supplement survey. (see Figure 1.1).4
The FDIC undertook this effort to address a gap in reliable • The proportion of U.S. households that are
data on the number of unbanked and underbanked house- unbanked varies considerably among different racial
holds in the United States. Access to an account at a and ethnic groups, with certain racial and ethnic
federally insured institution provides households with the minorities more likely to be unbanked than the
opportunity to conduct basic financial transactions, save population as a whole. Minorities more likely to be
for emergency and long-term security needs, and access unbanked include blacks (an estimated 21.7 percent
credit on affordable terms. Many people, particularly low- of black households are unbanked), Hispanics (19.3
to-moderate income households, do not have access to percent), and American Indian/Alaskans (15.6
mainstream financial products such as bank accounts and percent). Racial groups less likely to be unbanked are
low-cost loans. Other households have access to a bank Asians (3.5 percent) and whites (3.3 percent).5
account, but nevertheless rely on more costly financial
service providers for a variety of reasons. In addition to • In addition to the unbanked households, an esti-
paying more for basic transaction and credit financial mated 17.9 percent of U.S. households, roughly 21
services, these households may be more vulnerable to loss million, are underbanked.6 The number of adults that
or theft and often struggle to build credit histories and
achieve financial security.
The FDIC also conducted this survey to comply with a
statutory mandate that requires it to conduct ongoing
surveys of banks on their efforts to serve the unbanked.2
The supplement survey complements the FDIC Survey on 3
For the purposes of this survey, households were identified as unbanked
Banks’ Efforts to Serve the Unbanked and Underbanked, if they answered “no” to the question, “Do you or does anyone in your
household currently have a checking or savings account?”
published in February 2009, and provides insights into the 4
In addition, unbanked adults may also reside in other households. Adults
size of the unbanked and underbanked markets. It also are defined as persons aged 16 and older. This is a lower-bound estimate
presents a wealth of previously unavailable data regarding of the number of unbanked adults in the United States because it is based
households’ banking status and related issues. Teamed on the assumption that all adults residing in a “banked” household are
with the rich demographic and geographic data available banked. A banked household may contain one or more unbanked adults;
these unbanked adults residing in banked households are not included in
through the CPS, the supplement survey represents the the 17 million adults figure cited above.
5
The demographic characteristics of a household are taken to be those
1
The data for this report were collected through an FDIC-sponsored of the owner or renter of the home (i.e., “householder”), unless the demo-
Unbanked/Underbanked Supplement to the Current Population Survey graphic characteristic is one defined at the household level, such as
(CPS). Additional information on the CPS is available at http://www. income or household type. For convenience, some abbreviated language
census.gov/cps/. For additional methodological details and definitions, will be used to refer to the demographic characteristics of households. For
refer to the FDIC technical notes located in Appendix D of the full report. example, the term “black household” refers to a household for which the
2
Section 7 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Reform Conforming Amend- householder has been identified as black. Refer to the FDIC technical
ments Act of 2005 (Reform Act) requires that the FDIC conduct biennial notes for the race/ethnicity and other definitions used in this report.
surveys of insured depository institutions’ efforts to bring individuals and 6
Underbanked households are defined as those that have a checking or
families who have rarely, if ever, held a checking account, a savings savings account but rely on alternative financial services. Specifically,
account, or other type of transaction or check-cashing account at an underbanked households have used non-bank money orders, non-bank
insured depository institution into the conventional finance system. The check-cashing services, payday loans, rent-to-own agreements, or pawn
Reform Act also asks the FDIC for a “fair estimate” of the size and worth shops at least once or twice a year or refund anticipation loans at least
of the “unbanked” market in the United States. once in the past five years.
FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households ■ December 2009 3
Page 18
reside in these underbanked households is about 43 Region. In addition, the proportion of unbanked
million.7 households varies considerably among certain racial
and ethnic minorities across states and MSAs.
• Certain racial and ethnic minorities are more likely
to be underbanked than the population as a whole. Additional Key Unbanked Findings
Minorities more likely to be underbanked include • Family households for which the householder is an
blacks (an estimated 31.6 percent), American Indian/ unmarried female or unmarried male are consider-
Alaskans (28.9 percent), and Hispanics (24.0 ably more likely than married couple households to
percent). Asians and whites are less likely to be be unbanked.8 Almost 20 percent of unmarried
underbanked (7.2 percent and 14.9 percent, respec- female family households and 14.9 percent of unmar-
tively). ried male family households are unbanked, compared
Figure 1.1 Banking Status of U.S. Households with about 4 percent of married couple family
households.
Underbanked
17.9%
• A substantial percentage of lower-income house-
holds are unbanked. Nearly 20 percent of lower-
income U.S. households—almost 7 million
Unbanked households earning below $30,000 per year—do not
7.7%
currently have a bank account. Households with earn-
ings below $30,000 account for at least 71 percent of
Banked, but Not
Underbanked
unbanked households.
Banked, but
70.3% Underbanked
Status Unknown* • The proportion of unbanked households declines
4.1%
with education and age. Households more likely to be
Notes: Percentages are based on 118.6 million U.S. households. Percentages do not always sum to 100
because of the rounding of household weights to represent the population totals. unbanked than all U.S. households have less than a
* These households are banked, but there is not enough information to determine if they are underbanked.
college education or a householder under age 45.
• Not having enough money to feel they need an
• Taken together, at least 25.6 percent of U.S. house- account is the most common reason why unbanked
holds, close to 30 million, are either unbanked or households are not participating in the mainstream
underbanked. Approximately 60 million adults reside financial system.
in these households.
• The 9 million unbanked households are approxi-
• Overall, almost 54 percent of black households, mately split between households that have never
44.5 percent of American Indian/Alaskan house- had a bank account (46.9 percent) and households
holds, and 43.3 percent of Hispanic households are that were previously banked (49.0 percent).
either unbanked or underbanked.
• A considerable proportion (an estimated 41.1
• While 17.9 percent of U.S. households are known percent) of unbanked households believes that
to be underbanked, another 4.1 percent of U.S. opening a bank account in the future is “not likely
households, or roughly 5 million, are banked and at all.” However, among all unbanked households,
may also be underbanked, but their use of AFS could the previously banked are more likely to consider
not be determined because of missing data. The opening a bank account in the future. About 16
number of adults that reside in these households is percent of previously banked households believe that
estimated to be 11 million. they are “very likely” to open a bank account,
compared with 4.8 percent of those that have never
• The proportion of unbanked and underbanked been banked.
households varies across different regions of the
country, with the highest incidence in the Southern 8
A family household is a household that includes two or more people
related by birth, marriage, or adoption and residing together, along with
7
This is an upper-bound estimate of the total number of underbanked any unrelated people who may be residing there. For the definition of
adults in the United States because it is based on the assumption that all ‘householder’ see footnote 5. Detailed definitions regarding household
adults residing in an underbanked household are underbanked. However, types can be found in the CPS Glossary available at http://www.census.
an underbanked household may contain one or more adults that are not gov/apsd/techdoc/cps/mar97/glossary.html.
underbanked.
FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households ■ December 2009 4
Page 19
• About 66 percent of unbanked households use the services do so primarily because it is easier to qual-
following alternative financial services (AFS): non- ify for a loan from the AFS provider or because it is
bank money orders and non-bank check-cashing, more convenient.
pawn shops, payday loans, rent-to-own agreements
(RTOs), and refund anticipation loans (RALs). • Approximately 16 percent of underbanked house-
About one-quarter of unbanked households do not use holds have used a general spending prepaid card and
any AFS, suggesting a strong reliance on cash an estimated 4.2 percent receive their income
transactions. through a payroll card.
• Approximately 12 percent of unbanked households The full report that follows focuses primarily on the key
have used a general spending prepaid card, and an issues the FDIC intended to address in conducting the
estimated 3.1 percent receive their income through survey. It is organized as follows: Section 2 provides back-
a payroll card. ground and objectives; Section 3 provides a brief overview
of the survey findings related to the national percentage of
Additional Key Underbanked Findings unbanked and underbanked households; Section 4 summa-
• Family households for which the householder is an rizes findings related to unbanked households; Section 5
unmarried female or unmarried male are consider- summarizes findings related to underbanked households;
ably more likely than married couple family house- Section 6 compares select demographic characteristics of
holds to be underbanked. About 28 percent of unbanked and underbanked households; and Section 7
unmarried female family households and 27 percent of provides concluding remarks. Detailed national, state, and
unmarried male family households are underbanked, MSA-level tables appear in Appendices A, B, and C.
compared with 15.4 percent of households with a Technical notes for the FDIC’s supplement survey appear
married couple present. as Appendix D, and the supplement survey instrument is
included as Appendix E.
• The underbanked rate declines with age of the
householder but is more evenly distributed across
most educational and income groups. For example,
middle-income households (those with annual income
between $30,000 and $50,000) are about as likely as
lower-income households (those with annual income
below $30,000) to be underbanked. The proportion of
underbanked households is considerably lower among
the highest education level of the householder (at
least college degree) and the highest income group (at
least $75,000).
• The AFS products used most frequently by under-
banked households are non-bank money orders (an
estimated 81.1 percent of underbanked use money
orders) and check-cashing (30.0 percent) transac-
tion services. Underbanked households also use on
payday lenders (16.2 percent), pawn shops (15.8
percent), RTO services (13.0 percent), and RALs
(13.2 percent) for credit services from non-banks.
• The survey data indicate that the majority of under-
banked households that go to nonbanks for money
orders and check cashing do so primarily for conve-
nience. Speed and cost were also reasons under-
banked households use these non-bank transaction
services.
• Many underbanked households that use payday
loans or pawn shops rather than banks for credit
FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households ■ December 2009 5
Page 20
Devine, Denise
From: David Anderson <davidlevianderson@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, February 04, 2016 10:45 AM
To: City Clerks Office
Subject: Fwd: EDA Economic Development Conference
Attachments: image002.gif
also with Mr. Hammond's
The Honorable David L. Anderson
4th District Councilman, Dover, DE
Phone: (302)339-1047
Council Office: (302)736-7006
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: clay Hammond <chammond505@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, Feb 3, 2016 at 10:29 PM
Subject: EDA Economic Development Conference
To: Mike Casson <mcasson@desu.edu>, "Paul S. Davis" <paulsdavis@comcast.net>, La Mar Gunn
<lamargunn@me.com>, David Anderson <davidlevianderson@gmail.com>, Phil Bradford-VFNA
<pbradford@vfna.org>, elmer davis <elmerdavis44@gmail.com>, Jonathan Weaver
<jonathanwea@gmail.com>, Ken Anderson <Kenneth.r.anderson@state.de.us>
FYI
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Tamika Graham" <tgraham@ncall.org>
Date: Feb 3, 2016 4:27 PM
Subject: FW: Economic Development Conference
To: "Townshend, Ann Marie" <ATownshend@dover.de.us>, "Clay Hammond" <chammond505@gmail.com>,
"David Clendaniel" <dclendaniel@doverfcu.com>, "Perez, Ed" <eperez@dover.de.us>, "Herb Konowitz"
<herb.konowitz403@gmail.com>, "Hudson, Kirby A" <khudson@dover.de.us>, "James Waddington"
<james.waddington@co.kent.de.us>, "Joe Zilcosky" <joe.zilcosky@state.de.us>, "Judy Diogo"
<jdiogo@cdcc.net>, "Vandell Hampton Jr." <vhampton@firststateloan.org>, "Neaton, William G."
<wneaton@dover.de.us>, "Jackson, Beverly" <bjackson@dover.de.us>
Cc:
FYI - Please see conference link below.
1
Page 21
Best Regards,
Tamika
Tamika K. Graham
Neighborhood Revitalization Coordinator
NCALL Research, Inc.
363 Saulsbury Road
Dover, DE 19904
302-678-9400 ext 123
www.NCALL.org
From: Bynum, Maria L [mailto:Maria.L.Bynum@hud.gov]
Sent: Monday, February 1, 2016 4:45 PM
To: tgraham@ncall.org
Subject: Economic Development Conference
Tamika,
Hope all is well. A notice about an Economic Development Conference in
Washington, DC came across my desk. I wanted to pass it along in case
someone on the Economic Development Committee might be interested in
attending. Here's the link: https://useda2016.org/
Feel free to share with anyone you think might be interested.
Warm regards,
2
Page 22
Maria Bynum
Field Office Director, Wilmington
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development
920 N. King Street
Wilmington, DE 19801
(302) 573-6300
3
Page 23
Memorandum
Office of the City Manager
PO Box 475
Dover, DE 19903
Phone: (302) 736-7005
FAX: (302) 736-7002
E-mail: skoenig@dover.de.us
To: Utility Committee
From: Scott D. Koenig, P.E., City Manager
Harry Maloney, Electric Director
Donna Mitchell, Controller/Treasurer
Date: February 1, 2016
Subject: Additional Power Supply Alternatives
The purpose of this memorandum is to describe the Executive Risk Management Committee’s
(ERMC) request for approvals to explore two exceptions to the Governing Energy Commodity
Risk Policy. These exceptions if approved would authorize the Energy Manager to pursue
negotiations for two separate commodity transactions intended to meet the City’s electric load
requirements and reduce the City’s risk, but which fall outside of the Governing Energy
Commodity Risk Policy limits as stated below. Once negotiations are successful, The Executive
Management Committee would return to the City Utility Committee and City Council to seek
approval of these contracts.
Descriptions of Possible Products
Load Following Product for Fiscal year 2017 and 2018: A Third Party purchases 100% of
existing Dover hedges at the same price Dover paid for them originally. Third Party sells
Dover a “load following product” for every MW of actual load Dover consumes at a fixed
price. The risk that is managed by this product is the volumetric and price risk normally
borne by the City and associated with actual load variations due to weather or other
events affecting demand. Dover remains exposed to the congestion or basis risk (cost or
savings) between the DPL load point where Dover’s actual load is priced and the
purchase location of the PJM West Hub delivery point.
Purchase of up to 50 MW of fixed-price energy for up to 10 years: Up to 50 MW
purchase of PJM West Hub energy 7x24 starting in 2018 for five and ten year terms
(Physical Power). The risk managed by this product is lowering price risk future years by
purchasing at today’s forward prices. Current target for this product is 25 MW however,
we are requesting authorization to discuss up to a 50 MW purchase.
Page 24
Dover Governance Risk Policy Limits Exceedance:
Hedge Programmatic Level: 100% of actual load hedge is outside of the maximum
hedge limit of 80% of the expected loads.
Power (MW) Maturity Limit: 10 year transaction is outside of the 5 year term and 5
year maturity limit.
The ERMC is seeking approval to pursuing negotiations for these products as viable tools to
support the primary hedge program goals of providing price certainty in order to meet financial
and budget objectives and provide electric customers with rates that are competitive with
surrounding areas.
Prior to executing any transaction under these exceedances, the ERMC will review the
products’ effectiveness for reducing the City of Dover’s overall Portfolio Risk at a reasonable
cost and in accordance with the remaining tenets of the Governing Energy Commodity Risk
Policy:
Load Following will not be in exceedance of the Cost of Service Limit forecasted for 2017
and 2018 Power Year.
Physical and financial commodity transactions will be executed with counterparties
approved by the ERMC with credit available to support the transactions.
The transactions do not carry additional Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)
reporting requirements.
Transactions support the requirement of native load and Load Following will not exceed
100% of actual load.
Maturity limit for each permissible instrument will not exceed 10 years term 15 Year
Maturity.
Director of the Utility shall, in addition to notifying the ERMC if negotiations result in a
transaction, also notify the Chair of The Committee as soon as practicable.
Director of utility shall provide periodic reports to the Chair on the status of
negotiations and any subsequent transactions.
As stated before the ERMC will request approval of these possible contracts from the Utility
Committee and City Council.
Page 25
City of Dover
Capital Investment Plan
Project Tracking Report
Quarterly Report as of Dec 31, 2015
Points to Remember -
* Original Project Budget = Original Total Project Budget initially included in approved annual budget.
* Latest Project Budget = Revised Total Project Budget included in most recent approved annual budget or one of the following:
bond resolution, revolving fund loan agreement, Council approved budget amendment, or City Manager approved amendment as per
the Budget Amendment Procedure.
* Current Fiscal Year - Revised Fiscal Year Budget = Current Year approved project budgets plus carry forward balances of unspent
budgets in the prior fiscal year. Project Carry Forward balances will be submitted to City Council for amendment in January 2010.
Can also be amended with City Manager approval per the Budget Amendment Procedure.
* Water Quality, Inflow/Infiltration, Distribution Upgrades and New Development projects are budgeted as a blanket project and once
individual projects are identified and estimated they are created using an allocation of the overall budgeted amount.
* Status and Comments provided by City Manager.
Community Water & Total
Current Year Budget Funding Sources General Transportation Wastewater Electric CIP
Budget Balance $ 2,577,500 $ 512,900 $ 7,515,900 $ 3,900,700 $ 14,507,000
General Billings for Reimbursement of Expense - - 20,200 1,900,000 1,920,200
Debt Financing - - - - -
Income from Sale of Assets 51,900 - - - 51,900
State Community Transportation Funds - 500,000 - - 500,000
Transfer from WW Impact Fee Reserve - - 165,000 - 165,000
Transfer from General Fund 2,625,400 - - - 2,625,400
Transfer from Operating Funds - - 3,300,000 3,500,000 6,800,000
Transfer from Parkland Reserve - - - - -
Interest Income 5,000 - 25,000 26,700 56,700
Total Funding Sources (Unaudited) $ 5,259,800 $ 1,012,900 $ 11,026,100 $ 9,327,400 $ 26,626,200
Page 26
City of Dover
General Fund - Major CIP Projects
Quarterly Report as of Dec 31, 2015
TOTAL PROJECT - PAST, CURRENT & FUTURE BUDGETS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR
Original Latest Project Project % Original Revised Fiscal %
Project Project Project To Date Budget Budget Fiscal Year Fiscal Year YTD Budget Budget
Code Type Description Budget Budget Expenses Balance Spent Budget Budget Expenses Balance Spent Status Comments
1 FY 2013
2 ST1304 M B/L Garrison Farm Improvements $ 2,000,000 $ 4,641,000 $ 3,696,029 $ 944,971 79.6% $ 1,496,500 $ 1,537,500 $ 592,448 $ 945,052 38.5% In Process Project approximately 98% complete
3 Totals - FY 2013 $ 2,000,000 $ 4,641,000 $ 3,696,029 $ 944,971 79.6% $ 1,496,500 $ 1,537,500 $ 592,448 $ 945,052 38.5%
4
5 FY 2015
6 FR1501 SCBA Equipment/Radios $ 588,800 $ 588,800 $ 588,632 $ 168 100.0% $ 300,200 $ 300,200 $ 299,981 $ 219 99.9% Complete
7 PR1501 Park & Playground Impr Equipment 66,000 66,000 - 66,000 0.0% 66,000 66,000 - 66,000 0.0%
8 ST1502 Streets, Alleys and Concrete Prog. 900,000 505,100 430,645 74,455 85.3% 441,500 322,200 247,657 74,543 76.9% Complete Final invoices recently coded
9 ST1503 Misc Emergency Street/Storm Repairs - 71,800 71,881 (81) 100.1% 35,000 31,800 31,791 9 100.0% Complete
10 ST1504 Old PW2 Site Improvements 535,000 561,500 187,347 374,153 33.4% 330,000 455,400 81,152 374,248 17.8% In Process Design work ongoing 75% level
11 ST1506 Stormwater Ditch Maintenance 15,000 15,000 13,284 1,716 88.6% 15,000 15,000 13,284 1,716 88.6% Complete
Project continuing, approximately 95%
12 ST1508 G Stormwater Utility Planning 90,000 90,000 55,250 34,750 61.4% 82,400 82,400 47,600 34,800 57.8% In Process complete with study.
13 Totals - FY 2015 $ 2,194,800 $ 1,898,200 $ 1,347,038 $ 551,162 71.0% $ 1,270,100 $ 1,273,000 $ 721,465 $ 551,535 56.7%
14
15 FY 2016
16 --- Vehicles & Equipment $ 1,095,200 $ 1,113,800 $ 261,581 $ 852,220 23.5% $ 1,095,200 $ 1,113,800 $ 261,581 $ 852,220 23.5% In Process
17 FR1500 Annual Contribution to Robbins Hose 145,600 145,600 145,614 (14) 100.0% 145,600 145,600 145,614 (14) 100.0% Complete
18 GO1501 GOTP Farmhouse Demo/Project 35,000 35,000 27,605 7,395 0.0% 35,000 35,000 27,605 7,395 78.9% In Process
19 PD1601 Camera Monitoring Station 19,900 19,900 4,995 14,905 25.1% 19,900 19,900 4,995 14,905 25.1% In Process
20 ST1601 FY16 Street and Alley Program 1,000,000 925,000 - 925,000 0.0% 1,000,000 925,000 - 925,000 0.0% In Process Work underway, awaiting invoices
21 ST1603 Valve Replacement - Silver Lake Dam 60,000 60,000 - 60,000 0.0% 60,000 60,000 - 60,000 0.0% In Process Bids received, evaluating
Received zero bids on last request,
22 ST1604 Salt Storage Barn (originally proj ST1303) 50,000 75,000 2,435 72,565 3.2% 75,000 75,000 2,435 72,565 3.2% In Process staff to rebid
Project ongoing, work provided as
23 ST1605 Misc Emergency Street/Storm Repairs - 75,000 17,339 57,661 23.1% - 75,000 17,339 57,661 23.1% In Process emergencies arise.
24 Totals - FY 2016 $ 2,405,700 $ 2,449,300 $ 459,567 $ 1,989,733 18.8% $ 2,430,700 $ 2,449,300 $ 459,567 $ 1,989,733 18.8%
25
26 Grand Totals $ 6,600,500 $ 8,988,500 $ 5,502,634 $ 3,485,866 61.2% $ 5,197,300 $ 5,259,800 $ 1,773,480 $ 3,486,320 33.7%
Legend
M = Multi-year project - a project with a specific schedule to occur over multiple years.
R = Recurring project - a project that begins and ends each fiscal year and is re-budgeted to start over each fiscal year.
G = Grant funded project
B/L = To be financed through bonds or commercial loan.
Page 27
City of Dover
Community Transportation - Major CIP Projects
Quarterly Report as of Dec 31, 2015
TOTAL PROJECT - PAST, CURRENT & FUTURE BUDGETS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR
Original Latest Project Project % Original Revised Fiscal %
Project Project Project To Date Budget Budget Fiscal Year Fiscal Year YTD Budget Budget
Code Type Description Budget Budget Expenses Balance Spent Budget Budget Expenses Balance Spent Status Comments
1 FY 2014
2 CT1405 Lakeview Drainage Study $ 24,400 $ 24,400 $ 19,657 $ 4,743 80.6% $ 6,300 $ 6,300 $ 1,470 $ 4,830 23.3% In Process Design work approximately 98% complete
3 Totals - FY 2014 $ 24,400 $ 24,400 $ 19,657 $ 4,743 80.6% $ 6,300 $ 6,300 $ 1,470 $ 4,830 23.3%
4
5 FY 2015
6 CT1562 Village of Cannon Mill Repavement $ 315,000 $ 386,900 $ 215,630 $ 171,270 55.7% $ 361,000 $ 361,000 $ 189,633 $ 171,367 52.5% Complete Work complete, awaiting final invoices
7 CT1599 Signage Agreement 2,700 2,700 2,520 180 93.3% 1,600 1,600 1,350 250 84.4% Complete
8 Totals - FY 2015 $ 317,700 $ 389,600 $ 218,150 $ 171,450 56.0% $ 362,600 $ 362,600 $ 190,983 $ 171,617 52.7%
9
10 FY 2016
11 CT1616 The Meadows $ 22,200 $ 22,200 $ - $ 22,200 0.0% $ 22,200 $ 22,200 $ - $ 22,200 0.0% In Process Concrete work has started, awaiting invoices
12 CT1627 FY16 Paving Projects 247,400 247,400 - 247,400 0.0% 247,400 247,400 - 247,400 0.0% In Process Contractor has started work, awaiting invoices
13 CT1632 FY16 Signs Projects 14,600 14,600 - 14,600 0.0% 14,600 14,600 - 14,600 0.0% In Process Materials ordered, awaiting delivery
14 CTxxxx Unapplied CT Projects (placeholder) 644,000 359,800 - 359,800 0.0% 144,000 359,800 - 359,800 0.0%
15 Totals - FY 2016 $ 928,200 $ 644,000 $ - $ 644,000 0.0% $ 428,200 $ 644,000 $ - $ 644,000 0.0%
16
17 Grand Totals $ 1,270,300 $ 1,058,000 $ 237,807 $ 820,193 22.5% $ 797,100 $ 1,012,900 $ 192,453 $ 820,447 19.0%
Legend
M = Multi-year project - a project with a specific schedule to occur over multiple years.
R = Recurring project - a project that begins and ends each fiscal year and is re-budgeted to start over each fiscal year.
C = Project funded by combination of CT Funds and General Fund
Page 28
City of Dover
Water/Wastewater Improvement & Extension Fund - Major CIP Projects
Quarterly Report as of Dec 31, 2015
TOTAL PROJECT - PAST, CURRENT & FUTURE BUDGETS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR
Original Latest Project Project % Original Revised Fiscal %
Project Project Project To Date Budget Budget Fiscal Year Fiscal Year YTD Budget Budget
Code Type Description Budget Budget Expenses Balance Spent Budget Budget Expenses Balance Spent Status Comments
1 FY 2008 - FY 2013
Staff working on a memorandum of understanding with
2
WD0804 M 1.0 MG Elevated Water Storage $ 4,196,600 $ 2,556,000 $ 87,827 $ 2,468,173 3.4% $ 2,468,200 $ 2,468,200 $ - $ 2,468,200 0.0% In Process owner of property
Project underway, approximately 98% complete.
3
WD1302 M Garrison Farm Water Storage Tank 2,695,000 4,677,000 4,628,870 48,130 99.0% 1,297,300 1,297,300 1,249,131 48,169 96.3% In Process Anticipated completion by early February.
4 WW1304 M Garrison Farm WW Improvements 2,000,000 3,738,400 3,311,645 426,755 88.6% 628,500 628,500 201,669 426,831 32.1% In Process Project underway, approximately 99% complete.
5 Totals - FY 2008 - FY 2013 $ 8,891,600 $ 10,971,400 $ 8,028,342 $ 2,943,058 73.2% $ 4,394,000 $ 4,394,000 $ 1,450,800 $ 2,943,200 33.0%
6
7 FY 2014
Project underway, general contractor and manufacturer
8
WW1206 Brandywine Pump Station $ 402,000 $ 375,600 $ 274,381 $ 101,219 73.1% $ 101,200 $ 101,200 $ - $ 101,200 0.0% In Process have stalled project.
Contractor has mobilized, beginning site reconstruction.
9
WW1303 Westover PS 768,800 1,350,400 77,167 1,273,233 5.7% 1,292,400 1,292,400 19,165 1,273,235 1.5% In Process
10 Totals - FY 2014 $ 1,170,800 $ 1,726,000 $ 351,548 $ 1,374,452 20.4% $ 1,393,600 $ 1,393,600 $ 19,165 $ 1,374,435 1.4%
11
12 FY 2015
13 WQ1503 West Dover Connector Project $ 336,000 $ 338,800 $ 337,787 $ 1,013 99.7% $ 73,600 $ 76,400 $ 75,319 $ 1,081 98.6% Complete
14 WW1504 Lakeview Dr Pump Stn Replacement 450,000 408,400 266,837 141,563 65.3% 359,600 359,600 218,020 141,580 60.6% In Process Project approximately 98% complete.
15 WW1507 Retreat Pump Station Replacement 412,500 396,700 36,331 360,369 9.2% 360,500 360,500 157 360,343 0.0% In Process Project awarded. Notice to Proceed early February.
16 WW1509 West Dover Connector Road Utility Relo 922,000 922,300 922,221 79 100.0% 387,300 387,300 387,180 120 100.0% Complete
17 Totals - FY 2015 $ 2,120,500 $ 2,066,200 $ 1,563,176 $ 503,024 75.7% $ 1,181,000 $ 1,183,800 $ 680,676 $ 503,124 57.5%
18
19 FY 2016
20 --- R Vehicles & Equipment $ 409,500 $ 411,500 $ 305,651 $ 105,849 74.3% $ 103,700 $ 411,500 $ 305,651 $ 105,849 74.3% In Process
Meters have been ordered. Approximately 40 meters
21
WD1600 Meter Replacement Project 300,000 300,000 15,833 284,167 5.3% 300,000 300,000 15,833 284,167 5.3% In Process replaced
22 WD1601 R Wellhead Redevelopment 82,500 82,500 51,625 30,875 62.6% 82,500 82,500 51,625 30,875 62.6% In Process Staff to meet with contractor on specific work soon.
Staff has identified possible location of future well,
23
WD1605 Future Well Installation 80,000 80,000 - 80,000 0.0% 80,000 80,000 - 80,000 0.0% In Process await schedule to test.
24 WD1606 New Fence-Bayard Ave Water Tower 89,000 84,200 1,763 82,437 2.1% 89,000 84,200 1,763 82,437 2.1% Complete Final invoice paid in January
25 WD1607 R SCADA Equipment Tech Upgrade 83,000 83,000 - 83,000 0.0% 83,000 83,000 - 83,000 0.0% In Process Materials scheduled to be ordered soon.
26 WD1608 Shallow Well #7 Abandonment 15,000 15,000 8,815 6,185 58.8% 15,000 15,000 8,815 6,185 58.8% Complete Awaiting reimbursement by land owner.
27 WD1609 R WTP Process Improvements 284,400 284,400 73,497 210,903 25.8% 284,400 284,400 73,497 210,903 25.8% In Process Design work continuing.
28 WQ1601 R Water Quality Improvements 1,000,000 895,000 - 895,000 0.0% 1,000,000 895,000 - 895,000 0.0% In Process New Street to be bid out in February.
Project ongoing, work provided as emergencies arise.
29
WQ1602 R/T Misc Emerg Water Quality Repairs - 75,000 42,691 32,309 56.9% - 75,000 42,691 32,309 56.9% In Process
Staff awaiting invoice from Kent County to reimburse.
30
WQ1603 T Reimb KC for Water Main Increase - 30,000 - 30,000 0.0% - 30,000 - 30,000 0.0% In Process
31 WW1503 Hazzletteville Road Interceptor 755,000 462,100 - 462,100 0.0% 462,100 462,100 - 462,100 0.0% In Process Bids received, staff evaluating options.
32 WW1601 Inflow/Infiltration Removal 875,000 623,000 - 623,000 0.0% 875,000 623,000 - 623,000 0.0% In Process Additional projects under final review from DelDot
33 WW1602 Miscellaneous Pump Station Repairs 300,000 300,000 - 300,000 0.0% 300,000 300,000 - 300,000 0.0% Bids to be sent out in February.
34 WW1603 Rolling Acres PS Replacement 52,000 52,000 8,754 43,246 16.8% 52,000 52,000 8,754 43,246 16.8% In Process Design work underway, approx 75% complete.
35 WW1605 DE Ave Sanitary Sewer Extension 25,000 25,000 - 25,000 0.0% 25,000 25,000 - 25,000 0.0% In Process Design work 98% complete, to be bid out in Feb.
36 WW1607 T US 13 East PS #7 Repairs - 97,000 - 97,000 0.0% - 97,000 - 97,000 0.0% In Process Awaiting materials to be delivered
37 WW1608 T St Jones River Sewer Repair - 50,000 - 50,000 0.0% - 50,000 - 50,000 0.0% In Process Work complete, awaiting final video from contractor.
38 WW1609 T McKee Tax Ditch Sewer Repair - 30,000 - 30,000 0.0% - 30,000 - 30,000 0.0% In Process Work complete, awaiting final video from contractor.
Project ongoing, work provided as emergencies arise.
39
II1603 T Misc Emergency I&I Repairs - 75,000 5,820 69,180 7.8% - 75,000 5,820 69,180 7.8% In Process
40 Totals - FY 2016 $ 4,350,400 $ 4,054,700 $ 514,448 $ 3,540,252 12.7% $ 3,751,700 $ 4,054,700 $ 514,448 $ 3,540,252 12.7%
41
42
43 Grand Totals $ 16,533,300 $ 18,818,300 $ 10,457,515 $ 8,360,785 55.6% $ 10,720,300 $ 11,026,100 $ 2,665,089 $ 8,361,011 24.2%
Legend
M = Multi-year project - a project with a specific schedule to occur over multiple years.
R = Recurring project - a project that begins and ends each fiscal year and is budgeted to start over each fiscal year. No carry forward.
SL = State Loan Project - construction phase is financed
I = Impact Fee (partially) financed project
T = Transfer from blanket WQ or I&I original budget
Page 29
City of Dover
Electric Improvement & Extension Fund - Major CIP Projects
Quarterly Report as of Dec 31, 2015
TOTAL PROJECT - PAST, CURRENT & FUTURE BUDGETS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR
Original Latest Project Project % Current Revised Fiscal %
Project Project Project To Date Budget Budget Fiscal Year Fiscal Year YTD Budget Budget
Code Type Description Budget Budget Expenses Balance Spent Budget Budget Expenses Balance Spent Status Comments
1 FY 2012 - FY 2013
Work is completed. TSI and vibration testing
2 EG1212 M Unit 3 Turbine Inspection/Repair $ 1,760,000 $ 1,713,600 $ 1,699,848 $ 13,752 99.2% $ 53,500 $ 53,500 $ 39,700 $ 13,800 74.2% Complete completed.
New Switchgear online, working minor issues with
3 EE1312 M General Scott Switchgear 1,155,000 1,155,000 221,200 933,800 19.2% 1,107,200 1,107,200 173,405 933,795 15.7% In Process vendor, 99% complete
4 Totals - FY 2012 - FY 2013 $ 2,915,000 $ 2,868,600 $ 1,921,048 $ 947,552 67.0% $ 1,160,700 $ 1,160,700 $ 213,105 $ 947,595 18.4%
5
6 FY 2014
7 EE1443 GOTP Transmission Line Relocation $ 550,000 $ 550,000 $ 304,853 $ 245,147 55.4% $ 408,500 $ 408,500 $ 163,326 $ 245,174 40.0% In Process Final bill discrepancy, close out when verified
Mechanical and electrical work completed. Testing
has been completed. Need to install protective
closure around pump skid. Need to replace water
8 EG1416 M VanSant Capacity Increase 1,500,000 1,000,000 693,009 306,991 69.3% 492,200 492,200 185,169 307,031 37.6% In Process skid acid pumps.
9 Totals - FY 2014 $ 2,050,000 $ 1,550,000 $ 997,862 $ 552,138 64.4% $ 900,700 $ 900,700 $ 348,495 $ 552,205 38.7%
10
11 FY 2015
Boiler tube repairs, metallurgical analysis on failed
tubes. Safety valve testing to be completed by end
12 EG1504 McKee Unit 3 Boiler System $ 890,000 $ 180,000 $ 107,990 $ 72,010 60.0% $ 80,800 $ 122,800 $ 50,703 $ 72,097 41.3% In Process of January 2016.
13 EG1506 McKee & VanSant Safety Improvement 52,000 52,000 33,776 18,224 65.0% 18,300 18,300 - 18,300 0.0% In Process
14 EE1500 69 kV Rebuild 393,500 330,500 18,182 312,319 5.5% 318,500 318,500 6,153 312,348 1.9% In Process
Awaiting pole stakes and State verification of
15 EE1509 West Dover Connector 250,000 250,000 103,938 146,062 41.6% 155,800 155,800 9,729 146,071 6.2% In Process placement
16 EE1513 M Town Point Distribution Feeders 600,000 590,800 374,623 216,177 63.4% 350,000 350,000 133,786 216,214 38.2% In Process Phase 1 about 50% complete
Contractor to install conduit to proceed, PS
17 EE1516 Chestnut Grove 299,000 255,000 118,999 136,001 46.7% 136,000 136,000 - 136,000 0.0% In Process completed
18 EE1522 Garrison Oak Park 184,000 184,000 166,523 17,477 90.5% 17,500 17,500 - 17,500 0.0% Complete
19 EE1525 Leander Lakes Apt Phase 1 73,000 73,000 45,658 27,342 62.5% 69,400 69,400 42,049 27,351 60.6% In Process Awaiting final approval on closing in electrical loop
20 EE1526 Playtex Addition 354,100 354,100 278,704 75,396 78.7% 150,000 150,000 74,568 75,432 49.7% In Process Complete but awaiting final concrete bill
21 EE1544 Nottingham Meadows 28,600 28,600 10,245 18,355 35.8% 26,600 26,600 8,234 18,366 31.0% Complete
23 EE1547 NBR Properties 16,600 14,200 14,012 188 98.7% 11,500 11,325 175 98.5% Complete
24 Totals - FY 2015 $ 3,154,400 $ 2,325,800 $ 1,280,761 $ 1,045,039 55.1% $ 1,322,900 $ 1,376,400 $ 336,547 $ 1,039,853 24.5%
25
26 FY 2016
27 --- R Metering Infrastructure $ 150,000 $ 150,000 $ - $ 150,000 0.0% $ 150,000 $ 150,000 $ - $ 150,000 0.0% In Process
28 --- R Vehicles & Equipment 464,300 464,300 155,858 308,442 33.6% 464,300 464,300 155,858 308,442 33.6% In Process
29 EG1601 McKee Building Equipment Replacement 42,000 42,000 3,863 38,137 9.2% 42,000 42,000 3,863 38,137 9.2% In Process Building heating modifications.
Unit 3 ID fan motor inspection/repairs. TR-22 chart
30 EG1607 Unit 3 Auxilary Equipment 135,000 135,000 79,313 55,687 58.8% 135,000 135,000 79,313 55,687 58.8% In Process recorder replacement.
Computers purchased and sent to VIM Technologies
31 EG1608 McKee & VanSant CEMS Upgrade 89,000 89,000 - 89,000 0.0% 89,000 89,000 - 89,000 0.0% In Process for imaging.
Hydraulic system sequencing valve repairs, gas line
32 EG1609 VanSant Unit 11 Component Replacem 21,000 21,000 - 21,000 0.0% 21,000 21,000 - 21,000 0.0% In Process supply line regulators
Front lobby access improvements, replace obsolete 2-
33 EG1610 R McKee/VanSant Safety & Compliance 157,000 157,000 - 157,000 0.0% 157,000 157,000 - 157,000 0.0% In Process way radios
Expenditures have been in support of T&D
34 EG1611 McKee/VanSant Preserve Structure 215,000 215,000 4,707 210,293 2.2% 215,000 215,000 4,707 210,293 2.2% In Process transformer repairs.
Work to be completed in spring 2016 outage. Note
the project was changed from Unit #3 Circ Water
Pipe Inspection to Van Sant Exhaust Plenum
Replacement. Inspection was completed in 2012.
35 EG1612 Van Sant Exhaust Plenum Replacement 469,000 469,000 161,392 307,608 34.4% 469,000 469,000 161,392 307,608 34.4% In Process Scope of work to be determined.
Inspection was completed in 2012. Scope of work to
36 EG1613 McKee Unit 3 Stack Repairs 485,000 485,000 - 485,000 0.0% 485,000 485,000 - 485,000 0.0% be determined.
37 EE1603 Transmission Line Maintenance Program 75,000 75,000 - 75,000 0.0% 75,000 75,000 - 75,000 0.0% In Process
38 EE1604 R Lighting Proj & Rehab 67,000 67,000 20,560 46,440 30.7% 67,000 67,000 20,560 46,440 30.7% In Process
69 kV Cable Replacement North Street
39 EE1605 (originally proj EE1520) 565,700 135,000 - 135,000 0.0% 135,000 135,000 - 135,000 0.0% In Process Design in work
40 EE1606 Distribution Capacitors and Controls 50,000 50,000 - 50,000 0.0% 50,000 50,000 - 50,000 0.0% In Process
41 EE1607 Horsepond URD - Distribution Feeders 67,000 67,000 5,162 61,838 7.7% 67,000 67,000 5,162 61,838 7.7% In Process
42 EE1610 Frazier 900 Circuits 10,000 10,000 - 10,000 0.0% 10,000 10,000 - 10,000 0.0% In Process
43 EE1612 Dover AFB Substation Rebuild 30,000 30,000 - 30,000 0.0% 30,000 30,000 - 30,000 0.0% In Process
44 EE1616 R New Developments 2,500,000 1,852,200 - 1,852,200 0.0% 2,500,000 1,852,200 - 1,852,200 0.0% In Process
45 EE1617 Oak Grove Trailer Park - Dist Upgrade 78,500 78,500 - 78,500 0.0% 78,500 78,500 - 78,500 0.0% In Process
46 EE1618 Lakeland - Distribution Upgrades 63,000 63,000 - 63,000 0.0% 63,000 63,000 - 63,000 0.0% In Process
Page 30
City of Dover
Electric Improvement & Extension Fund - Major CIP Projects
Quarterly Report as of Dec 31, 2015
TOTAL PROJECT - PAST, CURRENT & FUTURE BUDGETS CURRENT FISCAL YEAR
47 EE1619 Route 8/Mifflin Road - Dist Upgrade 51,500 51,500 - 51,500 0.0% 51,500 51,500 - 51,500 0.0% In Process Awaiting easement paperwork from residents
48 EE1620 Route 8 Taps - Distribution Upgrade 38,500 38,500 - 38,500 0.0% 38,500 38,500 - 38,500 0.0% In Process Awaiting easement paperwork from residents
49 EE1621 Townsend Brothers - Dist Upgrade 14,500 14,500 - 14,500 0.0% 14,500 14,500 - 14,500 0.0% In Process Boring complete, awaiting wiring/terminations
50 EE1622 Persimmon Tree Apts - Dist Upgrade 62,000 62,000 - 62,000 0.0% 62,000 62,000 - 62,000 0.0% In Process Awaiting underground crew to start
51 EE1623 T DNREC R&R Metering - 41,000 - 41,000 0.0% - 41,000 - 41,000 0.0% In Process
52 EE1625 T Public Works Wetland Project - 78,000 - 78,000 0.0% - 78,000 - 78,000 0.0% In Process
53 EE1626 T Washington Street Lights - 40,000 - 40,000 0.0% - 40,000 - 40,000 0.0% In Process
54 EE1627 Dover East Estates - Dist Upgrade 130,000 130,000 - 130,000 0.0% 130,000 130,000 - 130,000 0.0% In Process
55 EE1629 T Tall Pine Condos - 43,000 - 43,000 0.0% - 43,000 - 43,000 0.0% In Process Awaiting developer go ahead
In discussion with architects and environmental
56 EE1630 Reed Street Roof Repair/Replacement 201,800 151,800 - 151,800 0.0% 201,800 151,800 - 151,800 0.0% In Process personnel
57 EE1631 North Street OH to UG - Dist Upgrade 100,000 100,000 - 100,000 0.0% 100,000 100,000 - 100,000 0.0% In Process
58 EE1632 T Blue Hen Corp - Phase I - 25,600 23,150 2,450 90.4% - 25,600 23,150 2,450 90.4% In Process
59 EE1633 T State Street Commons Fiber Optic Proj - 64,000 40,233 23,767 62.9% - 64,000 40,233 23,767 62.9% Complete
60 EE1635 T McKee Road - Edgewell - 7,000 - 7,000 0.0% - 7,000 - 7,000 0.0% In Process
61 EE1636 T Clearview - Phase 4 - 160,000 117,020 42,980 73.1% - 160,000 117,020 42,980 73.1% In Process
62 EE1637 T Dover Town Center Flex Site - 13,900 - 13,900 0.0% - 13,900 - 13,900 0.0% In Process
63 EE1638 T Dover Town Center - 35,200 22,953 12,247 65.2% - 35,200 22,953 12,247 65.2% In Process Install 90% complete
64 EE1639 T Outback Steakhouse - 30,600 - 30,600 0.0% - 30,600 - 30,600 0.0% In Process Awaiting contractor so we can terminate connections
65 EE1641 Reed St - Building/Safety Improvements - 50,000 42,803 7,197 85.6% - 50,000 42,803 7,197 85.6% In Process
66 EE1642 T Del Homes Warehouse - 18,000 15,000 3,000 83.3% - 18,000 15,000 3,000 83.3% In Process Awaiting contractor so we can terminate connections
67 EE1643 T Winner Volkswagen - 13,300 - 13,300 0.0% - 13,300 - 13,300 0.0% In Process Awaiting go-ahead from contractor
68 EE1644 T Retreat Pump Station - 7,300 - 7,300 0.0% - 7,300 - 7,300 0.0% In Process Awaiting Public Works go-ahead
69 EE1645 T Dover Family Cosmetic - 10,300 - 10,300 0.0% - 10,300 - 10,300 0.0% In Process
70 EE1646 T Loockerman Retail - 26,500 - 26,500 0.0% - 26,500 - 26,500 0.0% In Process
71 EE1647 T Ollies Transformer Replacement - 22,600 - 22,600 0.0% - 22,600 - 22,600 0.0% In Process Received permits
72 Totals - FY 2016 $ 6,331,800 $ 5,889,600 $ 692,015 $ 5,197,585 11.7% $ 5,901,100 $ 5,889,600 $ 692,015 $ 5,197,585 11.7%
73
74 Grand Totals $ 14,451,200 $ 12,634,000 $ 4,891,686 $ 7,742,314 38.7% $ 9,285,400 $ 9,327,400 $ 1,590,163 $ 7,737,237 17.0%
Legend
M = Multi-year project - a project with a specific schedule to occur over multiple years. B = Bonded Project
R = Recurring project - a project that begins and ends each fiscal year and is re-budgeted to start over each fiscal year. S = State fully or partially reimbursed project
Page 31
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Prepared By:
Arline Holloway
Client Services Manager
Phone: 904-360-1347
Email: aholloway@teainc.org
Date:
November 19, 2015
301 W. Bay Street, Suite 2600 Jacksonville, FL 32202 Tel: 904.356.3900 Toll-Free: 800.423.4800
Page 32
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Table of Contents
I. Executive Summary 1
Power Supply Summary 1
Supply Source Summary 2
Supply Variance 2
Generation Summary 3
Emissions Summary 5
Risk Management Summary 9
II. Budget Report 10
III. Operations Management 13
Executive Summary 13
IV. Appendix: PJM Invoice 26
November 19, 2015 Page ii
Page 33
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
POWER SUPPLY SUMMARY
Power Supply Costs FY2015-16
$7,000,000
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$0
Jul-15 Aug-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Nov-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16
Budget Actual
Overall Power Supply costs were $503,134 below budget predominantly driven by lower PJM-Energy,
Congestion and Losses and lower Hedge Energy costs.
Dover’s budgeted cost for all power supply (capacity AND energy) was $73.90/MWh. The actual cost of
all power supply (capacity AND energy) was $64.56/MWh in a positive budget variance of $9.34.
The actual cost of energy alone was $35.80/MWh as opposed to a budgeted energy cost of $43.23.
Dover’s total load was 55,510 MWh versus a forecasted load of 55,300 MWh. Hedge purchases totaled
42,128 MWh, which was 76% of the actual load. The budgeted hedge purchase totaled 45,976 MWh,
which was 83% of the budgeted load.
Dover’s power purchases from hedge transactions totaled $1,721,267. Purchases from PJM (energy and
fees) totaled $1,573,407.78. This number includes Locational Reliability charge of $904,154.06 and DA
spot market energy charges of $433,404.80. Dover’s planned energy purchase from the SunPark solar
installation was 1,224 MWhs. Dover’s actual energy purchase from the SunPark installation was 1,308
MWh.
November 19, 2015 Page 1
Page 34
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Supply Source Summary
Supply Variance
November 19, 2015 Page 2
Page 35
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
GENERATION SUMMARY
Generation Revenue FY2015-16
$700,000
$600,000
$500,000
$400,000
$300,000
$200,000
$100,000
$-
$(100,000) Jul-15 Aug-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Nov-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16
Budget Actual
Net Generation Revenue for the month of October was $602,485 versus a budget of $473,700. The
favorable budget variance was due to Non-Production Revenue $873,044.
November 19, 2015 Page 3
Page 36
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Generation Breakdown
City of Dover
Monthly Wholesale Generation Formula
October 2015
Net Generation
0.00 D
Production Margin
PJM - Generation
Economic and Reliability Dispatch $ 2,269.75 A
Natural Gas & Oil Consumption
Purchases for Generation $ (3,975.00)
Natural Gas Transport $ -
Eastern Shore Cashout $ -
Oil Consumption $ -
Subtotal: Natural Gas & Oil Consumption $ (3,975.00) B
Gross Production Margin $ (1,705.25) C = (A + B)
$/MWh Generation Production Gross Margin $ - E = (C/D)
PJM - Capacity
Generation Capacity Credit $ 902,145.57
Reactive Supply and Transmission Losses $ 45,546.40
Subtotal: PJM - Capacity $ 947,691.97 F
All in Generation Margin
All in Generation Margin Total $ 945,986.72 (G = C + F)
November 19, 2015 Page 4
Page 37
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
EMISSIONS SUMMARY
Emissions Allowance and Solar Renewable Energy Summary through October 31, 2015
The reinstated Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) replaced the Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR)
beginning January 1, 2015. The State of Delaware was included in the CAIR footprint but is not included
in the CSAPR footprint. CAIR allowances cannot be used for CSAPR compliance, so Dover’s CAIR
allowances essentially became valueless when CSAPR was reinstated.
The separate Clean Air Act acid rain deposition control program (CAA Title IV) which governs SO2
national allowance trading program remains in effect for Dover. Beginning with the January 2015
report, TEA no longer includes a CAIR summary. It will continue to report on Dover’s Clean Air Act Title
IV SO2 allowances.
Market liquidity for Title IV SO2 allowances is very low, with few transactions occurring. The following
table shows estimated values for Dover’s banked allowances, based on a market price assessment
published by SNL Energy.
Market Value for Clean Air Act Title IV Allowances
Commodity $/Ton1 Tons Market Value
SO2 Allowances – Title IV $0.56 15,018 $8,410
Total $8,410
Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative
The State of Delaware is a participant in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI). The City of
Dover must comply with RGGI by surrendering carbon dioxide (CO2) allowances pursuant to the State of
Delaware’s laws (Title 7, Chapter 60, Sub-Title II-A).
Dover had more than a sufficient number of RGGI allowances allocated to it to cover its requirements
through the first compliance period (calendar years 2009-2011) and second compliance period
(2012-2014). Any unused allowances are carried over (“banked”) for subsequent years. The table below
includes Dover’s historical activities and includes projections through 2020. Two projections are
presented: (1) future annual emissions based on the average for 2009-2014, and (2) future annual
emissions based on 2010 actual CO2 emissions, which was the highest emissions year between 2009 and
2014.
1 October 20, 2015 Daily Power Report by SNL Energy
November 19, 2015 Page 5
Page 38
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Dover, DE RGGI Allowance History and Forecast - October, 2015
CO2 Tons EOY Historical CO2 Tons CO2 Tons Projected EOY
Compliance CO2 Allowances Allocated CO2 Projected EOY
Emitted - Allowance Emitted - Proj. Emitted - Proj. Balance
Year (CY) Purchased Allowances Balance (High)
Historical Balance (Avg) (High) (Average)
2009 62,184 5,796 56,388
2010 49,747 32,971 73,164
2011 37,311 17,746 92,729
2012 27,983 15,957 104,755
2013 24,818 10,230 119,343
2014 1,000 N/A 25,427 94,916 94,916 94,916
2015 14,000 N/A 11,577 97,339 18,021 33,000 90,895 75,916
2016 N/A 18,021 33,000 72,874 42,916
2017 N/A 18,021 33,000 54,853 9,916
2018 N/A 18,021 33,000 36,831 -23,084
2019 N/A 18,021 33,000 18,810 -56,084
2020 N/A 18,021 33,000 789 -89,084
Dover RGGI Allowance History and Projection
October 30, 2015
150,000
100,000
Tons of CO2
50,000
0
-50,000
-100,000
Historical CO2 Emissions Projected CO2 Emissions - Avg CO2 Tons Emitted - Proj. (High)
EOY Historical Allowance Balance Projected EOY Balance (Average) Projected EOY Balance (High)
November 19, 2015 Page 6
Page 39
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
The table and chart indicate that Dover could run out of banked allowances as early as the end of 2017
under the high emissions scenario and by the end of 2020 under the average scenario. Therefore, Dover
has recently initiated a program to participate in RGGI’s quarterly auctions to ensure it has adequate
allowances in the future.
In anticipation of needing additional RGGI allowances in the future, Dover has participated in the last
four auctions and plans to continue to participate as required. The table below shows details for
Dover’s allowance purchases for each of these previous auctions.
Dover’s RGGI Allowance Purchase History
RGGI Auction Auction Clearing Quantity Of
Number Auction Date Price ($/Ton) Allowances Awarded Total Cost
26 December 3, 2014 $5.21 1,000 $ 5,210
27 March 11, 2015 $5.41 6,000 32,460
28 June 3, 2015 $5.50 4,000 22,000
29 September 3, 2015 $6.02 4,000 24,080
Totals 15,000 $83,750
The chart and table above does not include August or September actual CO2 emissions deductions.
These will be included in next month’s report.
The next quarterly RGGI auction will be held on December 2, 2015. Dover has submitted its intent to bid
in the upcoming auction and will be required to post financial security by November 24 to participate.
TEA will provide recommendations for Auction 30 during the Risk Management Committee (RMC)
meeting.
Based on the October 19, 2015 ICE price for the December 2015 strip ($6.81/ton), the estimated
market value of Dover’s existing 96,1562 ton RGGI allowance bank is $654,8223.
On November 17, 2015 RGGI held a stakeholder meeting to prepare for the 2016 RGGI program review.
Discussion topics included EPA’s Clean Power Plan, potential changes to the RGGI allowance cap post
2020 and a discussion about RGGI’s Flexibility Mechanisms. TEA will summarize the results of this
stakeholder meeting in the near future.
Renewable Energy Certificates
Dover owns two photovoltaic systems totaling 15 kW, consisting of one 5 kW unit at the Utilities
Administration Building and two 5 kW units at the McKee Run generating station. Dover also receives
solar energy produced by the 10 MW Dover Sun Park, which is owned by White Oak Solar Energy, LLC.
In addition to all of the physical energy produced by the Sun Park, Dover receives 15% of Sun Park’s
Solar Renewable Energy Credits (SRECS).
2 Subject to verification from RGGI COATS account.
3 i.d.
November 19, 2015 Page 7
Page 40
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Dover participates in the Delaware Municipal Electric Renewable Portfolio Standard (DMERPS) for
compliance with the State of Delaware’s RPS laws applicable to municipal utilities. The first compliance
period under DMERPS was for the 12 months ending May 2014 and the second compliance period was
for the 12 months ending May 2015.
Last month, it was reported that SRECs from the White Oak Solar Energy Center are eligible for a 10%
adder because the facility was constructed using a Delaware labor force. TEA, DEMEC and Dover staff
have reconciled this increase in SRECs. PJM’s GATs system does not include a mechanism to
retroactively record the 10% labor bonus SRECs. Therefore, DEMEC and TEA have had to account for
these bonus SRECs outside PJM’s GATS.
The revision indicated that Dover over-complied in the first compliance period by 290.2 SRECs. These
were used to off-set a portion of the second control period’s requirement to surrender 3,435 SRECs,
resulting in a net surrender for the second control period of 3,144.8 SRECs.
Through the end of generation month September 2015, Dover had accumulated a total of 5,853 SRECs
from these renewable energy resources, net of 2,941 SRECs transferred to DEMEC for surrender on
October 3, 2014 for the first compliance period and 2,861 SRECs for the second compliance period on
November 9, 2015.
Delaware periodically holds SRECs auctions; however, these auctions are for size tiers N1-N3, E1 and E2.
The Dover Sun Park is in the N4 tier for large-scale facilities. State-wide carve outs for Tier 4 has been
fully subscribed, so there is not a market for tier T4 SRECs in Delaware.
The nearest viable market for Dover’s SRECs is Pennsylvania. Daily settlement prices are from Flett
Exchange Environmental Services. The most recent settlement prices for Pennsylvania SRECS are used
in the table below.
SREC Balance 10% Bonus Transferred to Net SREC
SREC Vintage Market Before SRECs for DEMEC for Balance After
(June 1 – Clearing 2014/15 Sun Park 2014/15 Transfer and Market
May 31) Price Compliance Labor4 Compliance Surrender Value
Bonus GATs
2011/2012 $ 0.00 0 290.2 290.2 0 $0
2012/2013 $ 0.00 2,173 215.7 215.7 2,173 0 $0
2013/2014 $15.00 2,701 268.0 68.1 687 2,213.9 3,208
2014/2015 $15.00 2,685 265.0 0 0 2,950.0 44,250
2015/2016 $15.00 1,155 114.6 0 0 1,269.6 19,044
Totals 8,714 1,153.5 574 2,861 6,433.5 $66,502
4 Note: Retroactive Bonus Allowances were not transferred within PJM’s GATS system but were used to off-set 2014/15
compliance obligation.
November 19, 2015 Page 8
Page 41
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
TEA continues to recommend to Dover to retain these allowances for compliance with its Renewable
Portfolio Standard (RPS). Additionally, Dover will need to acquire additional SRECs resources in future
years. It is apparent that Dover’s portion of SRECs produced by White Oak Solar Energy Center will not
be sufficient future years as the compliance requirements increase. DEMEC has indicated that it expects
to have excess SRECs available for Dover’s compliance requirements. This and other alternatives will
need to be evaluated in the near future.
RISK MANAGEMENT SUMMARY
Forward power prices in PJM have decreased from last month.
Blended Cost Monthly Change
PY Hedge Ratio ($/MWh) ($/MWh)
2015-16 73% $42.57 ($0.51)
2016-17 54% $40.97 ($0.41)
2017-18 51% $40.41 ($0.42)
2018-19 41% $39.19 ($0.47)
2019-20 20% $36.30 ($0.38)
November 19, 2015 Page 9
Page 42
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
II. BUDGET REPORT
Budget Actual Variance
Oct-15 Oct-15
Gross Load 55,300 55,510 (210)
Power Supply
Hedged Energy $1,874,900 $1,721,267 $153,633
PJM - Energy, Congestion & Losses $347,400 90,213 $257,187
PJM - ARR, Transmission and Fees $650,000 588,201 $61,799
Dover SUN Park Energy $168,400 $175,542 ($7,142)
Dover SUN Park RECs $24,400 $30,249 ($5,849)
RECS (Solar and Non-Solar) $56,100 $0 $56,100
RGGI Credit Costs $0 $0 $0
Management Fees $83,000 $83,000 $0
PJM - Capacity UCAP Obligated Purchased $882,400 $894,995 ($12,595)
Subtotal - Power Supply $4,086,600 $3,583,466 $503,134
Power Generation O&M
Plant O&M 464,800 $343,502 121,298
Subtotal Generation O&M $ 464,800 343,502.00 $121,298
Power Generation Production Margin
PJM - Economic and reliability dispatch $0 $ (2,269.75) $2,270
Fuel Costs - Natural Gas $0 $ 3,975.00 ($3,975)
Fuel Costs - Oil $0 - $0
Testing Costs $0 - $0
Subtotal Generation Production Margin $0 $1,705 $ (1,705)
Power Generation Non-Production Revenue
PJM - Generation Capacity Credit ($908,500) $ (902,146) ($6,354)
Emissions Allowance Sales $0 $ - $0
Reactive Supply - Gas ($30,000) $ (45,546) $15,546
Subtotal - Non-Production Revenue ($938,500) ($947,692) $9,192
SubTotal - All Generation ($473,700) ($602,485) $128,785
Total - Utilities Cost $3,612,900 $2,980,981 $631,919
Unit Costs
Total - Power Supply $73.90 $64.56 $9.34
Total - Power Generation ($8.57) ($10.85) $2.29
Final Cost of Service to City of Dover Ratepayers $65.33 $53.70 $11.63
November 19, 2015 Page 10
Page 43
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Variance Analysis
Power Supply
Dover consumed 210 MWh more than forecasted for the month.
Dover saw a favorable variance for budgeted Hedged Energy of $153,633.
Dover experienced a favorable variance for budgeted PJM - Energy, Congestion & Losses of
$257,187 and a favorable variance for PJM ARR, Transmission and Fees of $61,799.
This resulted in a net power supply cost of $53.70/MWh, $11.63/MWh below budget.
The city realized a favorable variance of $503,134 for power supply vs. the monthly budget.
Dover Sun Park generated 14 MWhs more than forecasted.
Generation
Net Generation Revenue had a favorable variance of $128,785.
November 19, 2015 Page 11
Page 44
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Budget Actual Variance
YTD YTD
Gross Load 271,400 274,083 -2,683
Power Supply
Hedged Energy $9,395,500 $9,200,058 $195,442
PJM - Energy, Congestion & Losses $2,740,300 996,772 $1,743,528
PJM - ARR, Transmission and Fees $2,732,500 2,077,844 $654,656
Dover SUN Park Energy $784,400 $886,652 ($102,252)
Dover SUN Park RECs $150,200 $156,179 ($5,979)
RECS (Solar and Non-Solar) $224,400 $0 $224,400
RGGI Credit Costs $43,800 $24,080 $19,720
Management Fees $332,000 $332,000 $0
PJM - Capacity UCAP Obligated Purchased $3,501,100 $3,537,574 ($36,474)
Subtotal - Power Supply $19,904,200 $17,211,161 $2,693,039
Power Generation O&M
Plant O&M $2,498,800 $ 1,929,581 $569,219
Subtotal Generation O&M $2,498,800 $ 1,929,581 $569,219
Power Generation Production Margin
PJM - Economic and reliability dispatch ($569,400) ($575,353) $5,953
Fuel Costs - Natural Gas $389,200 $223,660 $165,540
Fuel Costs - Oil $0 $28,068 ($28,068)
Testing Costs $0 $0 $0
Subtotal Generation Production Margin ($180,200) ($323,625) $ 143,425
Power Generation Non-Production Revenue
PJM - Generation Capacity Credit ($3,604,700) ($3,016,487) ($588,213)
Emissions Allowance Sales $0 $0 $0
Reactive Supply - Gas ($120,000) ($263,996) $143,996
Subtotal - Non-Production Revenue ($3,724,700) ($3,280,483) ($444,217)
SubTotal - All Generation ($1,406,100) ($1,674,527) $268,427
Total - Utilities Cost $18,498,100 $15,536,634 $2,961,466
Unit Costs
Total - Power Supply $73.34 $62.80 $10.54
Total - Power Generation ($5.18) ($6.11) $0.93
Final Cost of Service to City of Dover Ratepayers $68.16 $56.69 $11.47
November 19, 2015 Page 12
Page 45
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
III. OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
During the month of October, there were no recordable accidents so the facility has gone 198 days
without an OSHA Recordable Accident through October 31, 2015 and there were no lost time accidents
so it has been 292 days since the last lost time accident at the facilities. There were no environmental
incidents during the month of October.
No units were dispatched for the month of October, and on October 12 the planned outage was started
on units 1, 2, and 3 for boiler inspections and safety valve work. Units 1 and 2 outages were cleared on
October 27 at 1500 hours. The Unit 3 planned outage was cleared October 29 at 0900. All Units
remained available for the remainder of the month.
The actual expenses for the month of October are $343,502 against a budgeted amount of $464,825 for
a favorable variance of $121,323 or 26.10%. The variance was due to the following: A favorable monthly
variance of $50,242 was due to not having a full complement of employees for this time period, an
unfavorable monthly variance of $574 was due to additional work done to support the plant
winterization project. Part of this was offset by the positive variance in water and sewer costs that were
lower than expected for the month and provided a favorable monthly variance of $71,655 due to the
timing of utility bill payments which resulted in (2) months of utilities expenses paid in September and
none in October.
November 19, 2015 Page 13
Page 46
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
NAES Corporation
Dover, Delaware
October 2015
Monthly Report
Rich Newman, I,C&E Tech, and Phil Marvel, Maintenance Supervisor, celebrate Rich’s past
service at a luncheon held in Rich’s honor
November 19, 2015 Page 14
Page 47
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Table of Contents
1.0 Environmental, Health and Safety
2.0 Financials
3.0 Operations
4.0 Maintenance
5.0 Capital Improvement Projects (CIP)
6.0 General Plant Information
7.0 Training
8.0 Upcoming Events
Cover picture: Rich Newman recently was determined to be restricted from certain portions of his job
requirements. He was put on short term disability with no hopes of recovery the job required ability he
is unable to perform. He will transfer to long term disability once his short term benefits run out.
November 19, 2015 Page 15
Page 48
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
1.0 Environmental, Health and Safety
During the month of October, there were no recordable accidents, lost time accidents or environmental
incidents. The facility has gone 198 days through October 31, 2015 without an OSHA Recordable Accident
or a Lost Time since the April 16, 2015 reportable accident.
There was one Near Miss reported on October 30, 2015 at McKee Run. Prior to a delivery of bulk
shipment of caustic liquid at McKee Run, an operator noticed caustic liquid dripping from the off-loading
pipe. The operator found that the check valve that bleeds-off caustic fill line was not working properly.
During the last caustic off-load, the operators didn’t clear the line by venting residual liquid to the
Neutralization Pit. As of October 31, 2015, two (2) employees need CPR/First Aid and AED training. They
are scheduled to attend a class on November 13, 2015.
During the month of October, there were no IWW discharges to the Kent County Public Works sewer
system. A representative sample of the industrial discharge was taken on October 9, 2015. McKee Run
is still waiting on the final analytical results from this sampling event. McKee Run submitted a waiver of
cyanide analysis to the Kent County Public Works division since cyanide was not detected in four (4)
consecutive quarters. No response has been received by Kent County Public Works to date on a waiver
determination.
During the month of October, representative storm water samples were collected as part of the
required semi-annual NPDES sampling event at Outfall 001, 004, 005 and 006. Additionally, Delaware
River Basin Commission (DRBC) storm water annual samples were collected from Outfalls 001 and 004
and analyzed for PCB congeners. Quarterly Visual Inspections of discharged storm water was also
evaluated at this time. The October DMR was not submitted to DNREC in time for this report. The DMR
will be submitted to DNREC before the 28th of November. An operator completed a storm water visual
inspection form prior to discharging accumulated storm water from Outfall 006 and submitted to DNREC
for review. No NPDES exceedances have been identified. All non-contact cooling tower blowdown
water is being discharged directly to the Kent County Department of Public Works under the facilities
Industrial Wastewater Discharge Permit #18. Van Sant’s final wet compression stack testing data and
report were submitted to DNREC and EPA for review on October 23, 2015.
In regards to a former incident that occurred in March 2015, the City of Dover-McKee Run Generating
Station received a formal Notice of Violation from DNREC for failure to submit the required compliance
certification report for CO2 allowances during the control period between 2012-2014 by March 1, 2015
deadline. The City of Dover has subsequently transferred 100% of the projected CO2 allowances from
McKee Run’s account to Van Sant’s new control period account.
November 19, 2015 Page 16
Page 49
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Environmental, Health and Safety Statistics
Fiscal Year to Date
October
7/1/2015-6/30/2016
NOVs 0 1
Opacity Deviations 0 1
Environmental Deviations 0 0
OSHA Recordable 0 0
OSHA LTA's 0 0
First Aid cases 0 0
Restricted Workday Accident 0 0
Near Miss 1 2
Man Hours Worked 4364.5 17691.25
Date of OSHA Recordable: 4/16/2015 Days since last Recordable: 198
Date of Lost Time Accident: 1/12/2015 Days since last LTA: 292
NOx Summary – Ozone Season (May-Sep) Tons
Year Unit #1 Unit #2 Unit #3 Unit #11 TOTAL
2013 1.1 1.7 19.3 1.3 23.4
2014 0.4 0.6 35 0.8 36.8
2015 0.1 0.2 7.5 2.6 10.4
NOx Summary - Year (Jan-Dec) Tons
Year Unit #1 Unit #2 Unit #3 Unit #11 TOTAL
2013 1.1 1.7 19.4 1.3 23.5
2014 0.8 1.1 39.8 3.7 45.4
2015 0.1 0.2 9.7 3.8 13.8
SO2 Summary - Year (Jan-Dec) Tons
Year Unit #1 Unit #2 Unit #3 Unit #11 TOTAL
2012 0 0 0 0.1 0.1
2014 0 0 0.4 0.6 1
2015 0 0 12.1 0.8 12.9
November 19, 2015 Page 17
Page 50
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
SO2 Allowance Summary
SO2 Allowances Available
Total SO2 Tons
SO2 Allowance SO2 Allowances Sold (Per Unit, Prior to Sale & SO2 Allowance
Emitted –
Vintage - YTD Reconciliation) Balance*
U3 & U11 YTD
Unit #3 Unit #11
2013 and earlier 0 10,365 690 2 11,053
2014 0 1,850 138 1 1,987
2015 0 1,850 138 11 1,978
Total SO2 Allowance Balance: 15,018
*Note – Emissions allowances are deducted according to oldest vintage first, unless otherwise directed.
CO2 Allowance Summary
CO2 CO2 Allowances Available Total
CO2 Allowance Allowances (Per Facility, Prior to Sale)* CO2 CO2 RGGI Account
Vintage Bought/Sold Tons Allowance Balance
YTD McKee Run VanSant Emitted
2014 and earlier 1,000 194,244 7,799 108,126 94,917
2015 14,000** 2,176 403 7,340 1,239
Total CO2 Allowance Balance: 96,156
*Note: CO2 allowance values are provided by the RGGI CO2 Allowance Tracking System.
**Note: 10,000 CO2 Tons Purchased in 2015 Auction to date.
This table remains in a state of development as we are working to obtain accurate data for proper status.
2.0 Financials
Monthly and year-to-date financial results as compared with the approved power plant budget for the
Generation Units are provided below.
October 2015
Actual Budget Variance
Personnel $226,958 $277,200 $50,242
Materials & Supplies $12,274 $11,700 ($574)
Administrative Expenses $104,270 $175,925 $71,655
Total $343,502 $464,825 $121,323
July 2015 thru October 2015
Actual Budget Variance
Personnel $885,237 $1,333,800 $448,563
Materials & Supplies $54,195 $127,050 $72,855
Administrative Expenses $990,155 $1,038,000 $47,845
Total $1,929,587 $2,498,850 $569,263
November 19, 2015 Page 18
Page 51
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
2.1 Variance analysis:
The actual expenses for the month of October are $343,502 against a budgeted amount of $464,825 for
a favorable variance of $121,323 or 26.10%. The variance was due to the following:
PERSONNEL EXPENSES: A favorable monthly variance of $50,242 was due to not having a full
complement of employees for this time period. As a result, this impacted three (3) labor accounts –
Straight Time, Overtime, and Labor Burdens.
MATERIALS AND SUPPLIES EXPENSES: An unfavorable monthly variance of $574 was due to additional
work done to support the plant winterization project. Part of this was offset by the positive variance in
water and sewer costs that were lower than expected for the month.
ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES: A favorable monthly variance of $71,655 was due to timing of utility bill
payments which resulted in (2) month’s being expensed in September and none in October. In addition,
the pollution liability insurance costs that were budgeted for October were expensed in July for fiscal
year 2016.
3.0 Operations
Unit Operations / Outages / Trips: No units were dispatched for the month of October by PJM or TEA.
On October 12 the planned outage was started on units 1, 2, and 3 for boiler inspections and safety
valve work. Units 1 & 2 were outage was cleared on October 27 at 1500 hours. The Unit 3 planned
outage was cleared October 29 at 0900. All Units remained available for the remainder of the month.
Month of October 2015
McKee McKee McKee MRGS VanSant Total ALL
Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 TOTAL Unit 11 Units
Capacity: (MW) 17 17 102 136 39 175.00
On Line Hours: (HRS) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Starts: (#) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Gross Generation: (MWh) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Net Generation: (MWh) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total Auxiliaries: (MWh) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Auxiliaries purchased: (MWh) 23.604 23.604 151.661 198.869 4.182 203.873
Fuel Gas Used: (MMBTU) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Fuel Oil Used: (MMBTU) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Fuel Oil Used: (Gallons) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total Fuel: (MMBTU) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Net Heat Rate: (BTU/KWh) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Unit Trips: (#) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Capacity Factor: (%) 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
Availability Factor: (%) 51.88% 51.88% 46.24% 50.00% 100.00% 62.50%
Commercial Unavailability : (%) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Planned Outage Hours (HRS) 358.000 358.000 344.000 1,060.000 0.0 1,060.000
Maintenance Outage Hours: (HRS) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Forced Outage Hours: (HRS) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Equivalent Derate Hours: (HRS) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Reserve Shutdown Hours: (HRS) 386 386 344 1,116 0 1,116
HW Boiler Gas Usage: (MMBTU) 0 0
November 19, 2015 Page 19
Page 52
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
2015-2016 Fiscal Year - July 2015 thru October 2015
McKee McKee McKee MRGS VanSant Total ALL
Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 TOTAL Unit 11 Units
Capacity: (MW) 17 17 102 136 39 175.00
On Line Hours: (HRS) 7.233 10.166 216.731 234.13 14.349 248.48
Starts: (#) 1 3 21 25 4 29.00
Gross Generation: (MWh) 81.874 96.694 8,868.27 9,046.83 548.985 9,595.82
Net Generation: (MWh) 79.759 92.259 7983.59 8155.608 548.611 8704.22
Total Auxiliaries: (MWh) 109.472 111.792 1,788.450 2009.714 6.816 2,016.530
Auxiliaries purchased: (MWh) 107.354 107.354 907.871 1,122.579 6.442 1,129.021
Fuel Gas Used: (MMBTU) 958.55 2059.93 97372.19 100390.7 7118.801 107509.47
Fuel Oil Used: (MMBTU) 0.00 0.00 7162.129 7162.129 0 7162.13
Fuel Oil Used: (Gallons) 0.00 0.00 51,181.00 51,181.00 0.00 51181.00
Total Fuel: (MMBTU) 958.55 2059.93 104534.5 107553 7118.801 114671.76
Net Heat Rate: (BTU/KWh) 12.02 22.33 12.705 15.683 12.959 28.64
Unit Trips: (#) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Capacity Factor: (%) 21.00% 25.00% 354.00% 272.00% 64.00% 336.00%
Availability Factor: (%) 87.87 87.87 86.45 87.40 100.0 90.55
Commercial Unavailability : (%) 0.0 0.0 97.66 97.99 0.0 98.99
Planned Outage Hours (HRS) 358.000 358.000 344.000 1,060.000 0.0 1,060.000
Maintenance Outage Hours: (HRS) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Forced Outage Hours: (HRS) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Equivalent Derate Hours: (HRS) 0.00 0.00 55.15 32.14 0 32.14
Reserve Shutdown Hours: (HRS) 2,586.77 2,583.834 2,326.269 7,496.873 2,937.651 10,434.524
HW Boiler Gas Usage: (MMBTU) 0 0.00
Fuel Oil Inventory (#2 Fuel Oil)
Monthly Monthly Fuel Monthly FY15-16 Fuel FY15-16
Starting Ending Monthly Inventory Starting Purchase Inventory
Inventory Inventory Purchase Change Inventory FYTD Change
McKee Run 697,950 828,375 126,038 130,425 739,369 126,038 89,006
Van Sant 180,011 222,992 44,971 42,981 180,770 44,971 42,222
Van Sant Lifetime through October 2015
Actual Starts Factored Starts Fired Hours
Van Sant 1,404 2392.75 4403.40
Since HGP–2004 275 725.05 1019.82
November 19, 2015 Page 20
Page 53
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
3.1 Team Report:
The Operations staff continues to support maintenance activities during the planned outage by serving
as Confined Space Attendants for confined space areas as well as other support tasks. The Operations
staff has also supported the outage by performing various LO/TO tasks needed to test or place
equipment in or out or service.
Operations personnel continue to support maintenance by working on Preventative Maintenance (PM)
work orders and other work orders that they have the skills to successfully complete the task. The
Operations Department continues to utilize the Day Shift Workers in both the Operations and
Maintenance areas to assist with maintenance of the plant.
4.0 Maintenance
During the month of October, the Plant Maintenance staff continued addressing the backlog of work
orders and the preventative and new work orders received during the month. Back logged Work Orders
are work orders that have been open for greater than thirty days. There were 88 new work orders
issued with 82 work orders being completed, and 31 of the back logged work orders completed during
the month. There were 2 new Safety Work Orders entered into the plant’s Computerized Maintenance
Management System (MP2) during the month of which 2 were completed. The table below summarizes
the monthly work order activities based on MP2 records and will continue to improve with time. This
table gives a representation of identified outstanding work; Preventative Maintenance tasks completion
and remaining corrective work orders and back logged work orders that require attention.
City of Dover – McKee Run Work Order Statistics
WO Starting Recv’d Total Comp Comp Total Ending OPEN
Type backlog WO WO WO Rcvd Comp Bcklog WO’s
ADM 13 10 23 0 3 3 13 20
CM 55 11 66 16 8 24 39 42
McKee Run
EW 5 2 7 0 2 2 5 5
PM 21 38 59 8 27 35 13 24
PR 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
SW 3 2 5 2 1 3 1 2
Site Totals 100 60 167 28 41 67 71 94
City of Dover – Van Sant Work Order Statistics
WO Starting Recv’d Total Comp Comp Total Ending OPEN
Type backlog WO WO WO Rcvd Comp Bcklog WO’s
ADM 3 0 3 0 0 0 3 3
Van Sant
CM 3 3 6 0 3 3 3 3
PM 3 5 8 2 5 7 1 1
PR 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
SW 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Site Totals 13 9 8 17 2 9 11 7
November 19, 2015 Page 21
Page 54
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Notable activities during the month include:
During the fall outage on Units 1, 2 & 3 the boiler inspector from XL Insurance inspected the boiler for
the yearly State of Delaware regulations. There were no issues with the boiler inspections. The inspector
started the all of the boiler are in good shape.
During the outage this fall the boiler safety and Units 1, 2 & 3 were removed by East Coast Valve
Company and taken back to their facility and inspected and tested. There were no major issues with the
safety valves. The safety valves were re-installed and the units were returned to normal operation.
During the fall outage Unit 3 3A ID fan motor was removed and sent to DEMCO motor shop to have the
cooling blades replaced. The cooling blades were the cause of 3B FD motor failure. The motor cooling
blades were changed, the motor bearing reworked and the windings dipped and baked. The motor was
re-installed and tested for correct operation. The motor ran well. The bearing temperatures ran
between 98°F-114°F. Before the motor was sent out to rework the bearing temperatures reached well
over 170°F.
During a heavy rain event one of the roof drains was discovered to be leaking. This leak was directly over
an electrical light panel on the turbine deck. A tent was fabricated over the electrical panel to divert the
rain water to a drain below the turbine deck. The maintenance staff replaced the old rusty pipe and
replaced it with ABS piping and fittings. They also cleaned two clogs in the line. Once this work was
completed the line was tested and there were no leaks and the water flowed out to the drain with no
issues. This was major safety concern to the facility due to the fact the rain water was dripping on the
electrical panel.
The maintenance crew fabricated roof vent covers for the turbine roof exhaust fan vents. By covering
these vents this will allow the heat in the build not escape out these roof vents. This will help immensely
in keep heat in the building this winter.
5.0 Capital Improvement Projects (CIP)
This month’s report still includes all of the CIP’s that are shown as “open” in HTE and the planned
budgeted CIP’s for the current budget year 2015/2016 with the status to date for the project.
2014/2015 CIP Status – Remaining Follow-up
Project
Description Update
Number
Progress: Project is complete.
EG1212 Unit 3 Turbine Repairs
Schedule: Project is complete.
McKee Run HEP Pipe Progress: Work is complete and final report has been received.
EG1406
Repairs Schedule: Project is complete.
Progress:
EG1504 Unit#3 Boiler System Repairs Schedule:
November 19, 2015 Page 22
Page 55
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
2015/2016 CIP Status
Project
Description Update
Number
Progress: Project on Hold.
Schedule: Project is on Hold until next year when RFP process will
EG1407 Metering System Upgrades
begin again. Project would be slated to be completed once Units 1
and 2 are decommissioned.
McKee Run / Van Sant Safety Progress:
EG1408 Schedule:
& Compliance
McKee Run / Van Sant Progress: Selecting equipment for spring painting work
EG1413
Structural Preservation Schedule: Paint some equipment/structures once weather warms.
Progress: Final stack emissions testing data submitted to DNREC for
revised emissions limits.
EG1416 VanSant Capacity Increase Schedule: Purchase system spare parts for inventory. Erect protective
shelter at the water skid.
Progress: Failed boiler water wall tube samples sent out for
EG1504 Unit#3 Boiler System Repairs metallurgical analysis to Riley Power.
Schedule: Expect analysis results by February 2016.
Van Sant Station Component Progress: Project on Hold.
EG1505 Schedule: Funding was moved to support other CIPs.
Replacement
Progress: Updated Drawings received and final work to be completed
McKee Run / Van Sant Safety
EG1506 with a balance of $18K.
Improvements
Schedule: Project was requested to be carried over into new FY.
McKee Run Units #1-#2 Progress: Funding removed to support other CIPs.
EG1507
Component Replacement Schedule: Once U1&U2 de-commissioned reevaluate meter work.
Progress: Project on Hold, some funds were used to support
McKee Run/VanSant transformer repair costs to preserve station reliability.
EG1508 Schedule: Planning on selected spring projects. Note this project has
Structural Preservation
been replaced by EG1611 for FY 16-17.
McKee Run Building Progress: Reviewing space heater work and sealing of structure.
EG1601 Schedule: Fall work to preclude winter weather/temperatures.
Equipment Replacement
McKee Run Unit #3 Boiler Progress: Unit #3 Boiler Tube Repair
EG1604
Systems Schedule: Initial repairs completed by Bremco, Inc.
McKee Run Unit #3 Auxiliary Progress: Unit #3A and #3B ID Fan Repairs
EG1607
Equipment Replacement Schedule: Work on both motors completed.
Progress: Consulting with other NAES plants and ESS to determine
McKee Run / Van Sant CEMS
EG1608 best equipment approach for upgrade.
Upgrades
Schedule: TBD
Van Sant Station Component Progress: Replacement gas skid valves received.
EG1609
Replacement Schedule: Investigate need to replace fuel flow divider.
McKee Run / Van Sant Safety Progress:
EG1610
Improvements Schedule:
Progress: Some funds were used to support transformer repair cost
McKee Run / Van Sant
EG1611 to preserve station integrity and reliability. (T&D Department)
Structural Preservation
Schedule:
November 19, 2015 Page 23
Page 56
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Project
Description Update
Number
Progress: Work awarded to Universal Acoustics and Emissions
Van Sant Exhaust Plenum Technology.
EG1612
Replacement Schedule: Materials invoice processed for payment. Expect delivery in
mid-February 2016 for beginning of installation on March 1, 2016.
McKee Run Unit #3 Boiler Progress: Inspection completed in 2012.
EG1613
Stack Repairs Schedule: Develop bid package to be sent for spring 2016 work.
6.0 General Plant Information
On October 9, a celebration lunch was held for Richard Newman, Instrument Technician and Electrician
for McKee Run since 1992. Staff was able to show their appreciation for Rich’s years of dedication and
teamwork.
We would also like to congratulate Sarah Maher, Administrative Assistant, and her new husband, Mike
Best, on their wedding held on October 3. Sarah is now known as Mrs. Best, and we all wish her and her
husband the best for their future.
7.0 Training
Jack Coleman with OES-NA will be on site November 3rd through the 5th for training on preparation for
the PJM Generation System Operators exam. Most of the class will consist of the new operators that
have been hired over the last six months. The class will go over emergency operations, system
restoration, and all phases of system operator requirements. Mr. Coleman used to teach this very same
class at PJM about ten years ago so he is very knowledgeable.
Topics discussed during the monthly safety committee meeting were reviewed by the entire staff. The
monthly safety topic was on “Compressed Air Hose Safety”, an air hose can be very useful but they can
be dangerous as well, keep air hoses off the floor where it is a tripping hazard, Keep sharp items rubbing
against the hose, don’t pull on a hose trying to free from being caught or snagged on a piece of
equipment. Make sure hoses are properly connected and seated before use.
November 19, 2015 Page 24
Page 57
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
8.0 Upcoming Events
A forecast of general event dates for the power plant projects, outages and various agency reporting
dates are listed below.
Calendar of Upcoming Events Date
NOx Ozone Season Started May 1, 2015
PJM Winter Capacity Test Period TBD
NOx Ozone Season Ends October 30, 2015
Unit 11 Spring Outage Schedule TBD (March 2016?)
Winter Capacity Period December 1, 2015 – February 28, 2016
2015 Title V Annual Certifications Due January 31, 2016
RGGI-COATS True Up March 1, 2016
Water Allocation Report January 31, 2016
November 19, 2015 Page 25
Page 58
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
IV. APPENDIX: PJM INVOICE
REPORT Monthly Billing Statement - CSV and
NAME: XML
CUSTOMER
ACCOUNT: City of Dover, Delaware
CUSTOMER
CODE: DOVDE
CUSTOMER
ID: 76.000000
FINAL
BILLING
STATEMEN
T ISSUED: 11/6/2015 9:28
BILLING
PERIOD
START
DATE: 10/1/2015
BILLING
PERIOD
END DATE: 10/31/2015
INVOICE
NUMBER: 2015103100076.000000
INVOICE
DUE DATE: 11/13/2015 12:00
SOURCE BILLING
CHARGES ADJ BILLING LINE ITEM NAME PERIOD START AMOUNT ($)
Network Integration
1100.000000 Transmission Service 449639.810000
1108.000000 Transmission Enhancement 70050.530000
Firm Point-to-Point
1130.000000 Transmission Service 0.000000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point
1140.000000 Transmission Service 0.000000
Day-ahead Spot Market
1200.000000 Energy 426408.960000
1205.000000 Balancing Spot Market Energy -60042.520000
Day-ahead Transmission
1210.000000 Congestion -290139.660000
Balancing Transmission
1215.000000 Congestion 15026.620000
Day-ahead Transmission
1220.000000 Losses 2384.120000
Balancing Transmission
1225.000000 Losses 122.170000
1230.000000 Inadvertent Interchange -62.290000
Day-Ahead Load Response
1242.000000 Charge Allocation 103.820000
Real-Time Load Response
1243.000000 Charge Allocation 360.250000
1250.000000 Meter Error Correction -3966.240000
November 19, 2015 Page 26
Page 59
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service -
1301.000000 Control Area Administration 9351.280000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service -
1302.000000 FTR Administration 42.020000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service -
1303.000000 Market Support 2149.250000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service -
Regulation Market
1304.000000 Administration 88.260000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service -
Capacity Resource/Obligation
1305.000000 Mgmt. 936.820000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service -
Advanced Second Control
1306.000000 Center 1308.380000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service -
1307.000000 Market Support Offset -215.540000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service
Refund - Control Area
1308.000000 Administration -60.800000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service
1310.000000 Refund - Market Support -11.400000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service
Refund - Regulation Market
1311.000000 Administration -0.930000
PJM Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch Service
Refund - Capacity
1312.000000 Resource/Obligation Mgmt. -5.270000
1313.000000 PJM Settlement, Inc. 215.540000
Market Monitoring Unit (MMU)
1314.000000 Funding 221.580000
1315.000000 FERC Annual Recovery 3702.940000
Organization of PJM States,
1316.000000 Inc. (OPSI) Funding 38.100000
North American Electric
1317.000000 Reliability Corporation (NERC) 652.180000
Reliability First Corporation
1318.000000 (RFC) 1061.140000
Transmission Owner
Scheduling, System Control
1320.000000 and Dispatch Service 4106.400000
Reactive Supply and Voltage
Control from Generation and
1330.000000 Other Sources Service 36129.040000
November 19, 2015 Page 27
Page 60
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Regulation and Frequency
1340.000000 Response Service 10490.760000
1360.000000 Synchronized Reserve 8984.770000
1362.000000 Non-Synchronized Reserve 1586.900000
Day-ahead Scheduling
1365.000000 Reserve 881.780000
1370.000000 Day-ahead Operating Reserve 3058.080000
1375.000000 Balancing Operating Reserve 2701.230000
Balancing Operating Reserve
1376.000000 for Load Response 1.230000
1378.000000 Reactive Services 14936.470000
1380.000000 Black Start Service 3392.420000
Load Reconciliation for Spot
1400.000000 Market Energy 894.570000
Load Reconciliation for
1410.000000 Transmission Congestion -315.090000
Load Reconciliation for
1420.000000 Transmission Losses 14.420000
Load Reconciliation for
1430.000000 Inadvertent Interchange 0.130000
Load Reconciliation for PJM
Scheduling, System Control
1440.000000 and Dispatch Service 4.510000
Load Reconciliation for
Schedule 9-6 - Advanced
1442.000000 Second Control Center 0.460000
Load Reconciliation for Market
1444.000000 Monitoring Unit (MMU) Funding 0.080000
Load Reconciliation for FERC
1445.000000 Annual Recovery 1.460000
Load Reconciliation for
Organization of PJM States,
1446.000000 Inc. (OPSI) Funding 0.020000
Load Reconciliation for North
American Electric Reliability
1447.000000 Corporation (NERC) 0.260000
Load Reconciliation for
Reliability First Corporation
1448.000000 (RFC) 0.420000
Load Reconciliation for
Transmission Owner
Scheduling, System Control
1450.000000 and Dispatch Service 1.620000
Load Reconciliation for
Regulation and Frequency
1460.000000 Response Service 4.790000
Load Reconciliation for
1470.000000 Synchronized Reserve 5.920000
Load Reconciliation for Non-
1472.000000 Synchronized Reserve 0.590000
Load Reconciliation for Day-
1475.000000 ahead Scheduling Reserve -0.090000
Load Reconciliation for
1478.000000 Balancing Operating Reserve 0.400000
November 19, 2015 Page 28
Page 61
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
Load Reconciliation for
1490.000000 Reactive Services 0.020000
Financial Transmission Rights
1500.000000 Auction -8708.830000
1600.000000 RPM Auction 6324.930000
1610.000000 Locational Reliability 904154.060000
Generation Deactivation
1932.000000 Refund -515.950000
1250.000000 A Meter Error Correction 9/1/2015 -7.300000
Regulation and Frequency
1340.000000 A Response Service 8/1/2015 0.340000
1360.000000 A Synchronized Reserve 9/1/2015 30.190000
Day-ahead Scheduling
1365.000000 A Reserve 7/1/2015 16.390000
Day-ahead Scheduling
1365.000000 A Reserve 8/1/2015 -19.760000
Day-ahead Scheduling
1365.000000 A Reserve 9/1/2015 0.430000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 3/1/2015 5.160000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 5/1/2015 0.200000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 7/1/2015 3.070000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 8/1/2015 152.710000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 9/1/2015 41.040000
1380.000000 A Black Start Service 8/1/2015 205.620000
1380.000000 A Black Start Service 9/1/2015 266.920000
Michigan - Ontario Interface
1911.000000 A Phase Angle Regulators 9/1/2015 194.900000
1618386.81000
Total Charges 0
SOURCE BILLING
CREDITS ADJ BILLING LINE ITEM NAME PERIOD START AMOUNT ($)
Network Integration
2100.000000 Transmission Service 0.000000
2108.000000 Transmission Enhancement 55113.410000
Firm Point-to-Point
2130.000000 Transmission Service 0.000000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point
2140.000000 Transmission Service 706.080000
2210.000000 Transmission Congestion -102627.710000
2220.000000 Transmission Losses 16078.820000
Transmission Owner
Scheduling, System Control
2320.000000 and Dispatch Service 0.000000
Reactive Supply and Voltage
Control from Generation and
2330.000000 Other Sources Service 29467.580000
Regulation and Frequency
2340.000000 Response Service 0.000000
2360.000000 Synchronized Reserve 0.000000
Day-ahead Scheduling
2365.000000 Reserve 0.000000
November 19, 2015 Page 29
Page 62
Monthly Management Committee Update
October 2015
2370.000000 Day-ahead Operating Reserve 950.710000
2375.000000 Balancing Operating Reserve 1444.800000
2380.000000 Black Start Service 0.000000
Load Reconciliation for
2420.000000 Transmission Losses 7.570000
2510.000000 Auction Revenue Rights 76153.980000
2600.000000 RPM Auction 908470.500000
2630.000000 Capacity Transfer Rights 2192.010000
Incremental Capacity Transfer
2640.000000 Rights 353.090000
2661.000000 Capacity Resource Deficiency 6614.340000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point
2140.000000 A Transmission Service 9/1/2015 15.570000
2210.000000 A Transmission Congestion 9/1/2015 0.000000
Total Credits 994940.750000
Monthly Billing Net Total 623446.060000
Previous Weekly Billing Net
Total 491986.270000
Total Due / Receivable $131,459.79
End of
Report
November 19, 2015 Page 30
Page 63
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Prepared By:
Arline Holloway
Client Services Manager
Phone: 904-360-1347
Email: aholloway@teainc.org
Date:
December 17, 2015
301 W. Bay Street, Suite 2600 Jacksonville, FL 32202 Tel: 904.356.3900 Toll-Free: 800.423.4800
Page 64
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Table of Contents
I. Executive Summary 1
Power Supply Summary 1
Supply Source Summary 2
Supply Variance 2
Generation Summary 3
Emissions Summary 5
Risk Management Summary 9
II. Budget Report 10
III. Operations Management 13
IV. Appendix: PJM Invoice 24
December 17, 2015 Page ii
Page 65
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
POWER SUPPLY SUMMARY
Power Supply Costs FY2015-16
$7,000,000
$6,000,000
$5,000,000
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$0
Jul-15 Aug-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Nov-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16
Budget Actual
Overall Power Supply costs were $732,802 below budget predominantly driven by lower PJM-Energy,
Congestion and Losses and lower Hedge Energy costs.
Dover’s budgeted cost for all power supply (capacity AND energy) was $70.64/MWh. The actual cost of
all power supply (capacity AND energy) was $62.56/MWh in a positive budget variance of $8.08.
The actual cost of energy alone was $36.10/MWh as opposed to a budgeted energy cost of $42.26.
Dover’s total load was 54,678 MWh versus a forecasted load of 58,800 MWh. Hedge purchases totaled
40,530 MWh, which was 74% of the actual load. The budgeted hedge purchase totaled 44,720 MWh,
which was 76% of the budgeted load.
Dover’s power purchases from hedge transactions totaled $1,635,046. Purchases from PJM (energy and
fees) totaled $1,569,465. This number includes Locational Reliability charge of $874,987 and DA spot
market energy charges of $374,974. Dover’s planned energy purchase from the SunPark solar
installation was 912 MWhs. Dover’s actual energy purchase from the SunPark installation was
790 MWh.
December 17, 2015 Page 1
Page 66
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Supply Source Summary
Supply Variance
December 17, 2015 Page 2
Page 67
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
GENERATION SUMMARY
Generation Revenue FY2015-16
$700,000
$600,000
$500,000
$400,000
$300,000
$200,000
$100,000
$-
Jul-15 Nov-15 Jun-16
Aug-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16
$(100,000)
Budget Actual
Net Generation Revenue for the month of November was $466,056 versus a budget of $454,000. The
favorable budget variance was attributed to Non-Production Revenue of $917,401.
December 17, 2015 Page 3
Page 68
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Generation Breakdown
City of Dover
Monthly Wholesale Generation Formula
November 2015
Net Generation
289.19 D
Production Margin
PJM - Generation
Economic and Reliability Dispatch $ 88,861.28 A
Natural Gas & Oil Consumption
Purchases for Generation $ -
Natural Gas Transport $ -
Eastern Shore Cashout $ -
Oil Consumption $ (62,965.90)
Subtotal: Natural Gas & Oil Consumption $ (62,965.90) B
Gross Production Margin $ 25,895.38 C = (A + B)
$/MWh Generation Production Gross Margin $ 89.54 E = (C/D)
PJM - Capacity
Generation Capacity Credit $ 873,044.10
Reactive Supply and Transmission Losses $ 44,357.13
Subtotal: PJM - Capacity $ 917,401.23 F
All in Generation Margin
All in Generation Margin Total $ 943,296.61 (G = C + F)
December 17, 2015 Page 4
Page 69
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
EMISSIONS SUMMARY
Emissions Allowance and Solar Renewable Energy Summary through November 30, 2015
The reinstated Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) replaced the Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR)
beginning January 1, 2015. The State of Delaware was included in the CAIR footprint but is not included
in the CSAPR footprint. CAIR allowances cannot be used for CSAPR compliance, so Dover’s CAIR
allowances essentially became valueless when CSAPR was reinstated.
The separate Clean Air Act acid rain deposition control program (CAA Title IV), which governs the SO2
national allowance trading program, remains in effect for Dover. Beginning with the January 2015
report, TEA no longer includes a CAIR summary. It will continue to report on Dover’s Clean Air Act Title
IV SO2 allowances.
Market liquidity for Title IV SO2 allowances is very low, with few transactions occurring. The following
table shows estimated values for Dover’s banked allowances, based on a market price assessment
published by SNL Energy.
Market Value for Clean Air Act Title IV Allowances
1
Commodity $/Ton Tons Market Value
SO2 Allowances – Title IV $0.56 15,018 $8,410
Total $8,410
Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative
The State of Delaware is a participant in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI). The City of
Dover must comply with RGGI by surrendering carbon dioxide (CO2) allowances pursuant to the State of
Delaware’s laws (Title 7, Chapter 60, Sub-Title II-A).
Dover had more than a sufficient number of RGGI allowances allocated to it to cover its requirements
through the first compliance period (calendar years 2009-2011) and second compliance period
(2012-2014). Any unused allowances are carried over (“banked”) for subsequent years. The table below
includes Dover’s historical activities and includes projections through 2020. Two projections are
presented: (1) future annual emissions based on the average for 2009-2014 and (2) future annual
emissions based on 2010 actual CO2 emissions, which was the highest emissions year between 2009 and
2014.
1
October 20, 2015 Daily Power Report by SNL Energy
December 17, 2015 Page 5
Page 70
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Dover, DE RGGI Allowance History and Forecast -November, 2015
CO2 Tons EOY Historical CO2 Tons CO2 Tons Projected EOY
Compliance CO2 Allowances Allocated CO2 Projected EOY
Emitted - Allowance Emitted - Proj. Emitted - Proj. Balance
Year (CY) Purchased Allowances Balance (High)
Historical Balance (Avg) (High) (Average)
2009 62,184 5,796 56,388
2010 49,747 32,971 73,164
2011 37,311 17,763 92,712
2012 27,983 15,957 104,738
2013 24,818 10,213 119,343
2014 1,000 N/A 25,426 94,917 94,917 94,917
2015 14,000 N/A 17,371 91,546 18,021 33,000 90,896 75,917
2016 N/A 18,021 33,000 72,875 42,917
2017 N/A 18,021 33,000 54,854 9,917
2018 N/A 18,021 33,000 36,833 -23,083
2019 N/A 18,021 33,000 18,812 -56,083
2020 N/A 18,021 33,000 791 -89,083
NOTE: 2015 Values subject to verification; 2015 emissions include 5,490 of excess emissions surrender
Dover RGGI Allowance History and Projection
November 30, 2015
150,000
100,000
Tons of CO2
50,000
0
-50,000
-100,000
Historical CO2 Emissions Projected CO2 Emissions - Avg
CO2 Tons Emitted - Proj. (High) EOY Historical Allowance Balance
Projected EOY Balance (Average) Projected EOY Balance (High)
December 17, 2015 Page 6
Page 71
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
The table and chart indicate that Dover could run out of banked allowances as early as the end of 2017
under the high emissions scenario and by the end of 2020 under the average scenario. Therefore, Dover
has recently initiated a program to participate in RGGI’s quarterly auctions to ensure it has adequate
allowances in the future.
In anticipation of needing additional RGGI allowances in the future, Dover has participated in the last
four auctions and plans to continue to participate as required. The table below shows details for
Dover’s allowance purchases for each of these previous auctions.
Dover’s RGGI Allowance Purchase History
RGGI Auction Auction Clearing Quantity Of
Number Auction Date Price ($/Ton) Allowances Awarded Total Cost
26 Dec 3, 2014 $5.21 1,000 $ 5,210
27 Mar 11, 2015 $5.41 6,000 32,460
28 June 3, 2015 $5.50 4,000 22,000
29 Sept 3, 2015 $6.02 4,000 24,080
30 Dec 2, 2015 $7.50 0 0
Totals 15,000 $83,750
Dover was unable to participate in Auction 30 due to an administrative error. Even if it had participated,
the auction cleared at a significantly higher price than the highest tier bid price which was approved by
Dover at last month’s RMC meeting. The RGGI spot market prices increased rapidly during the last two
weeks of November, as can be seen on the chart from SNL below:
December 17, 2015 Page 7
Page 72
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
The next RGGI auction will be held on March 9, 2015. The Cost Containment Reserve will be 10 Million
tons with a CCR price of $8.00/ton, so may be reasonable to expect that the next auction will clear in the
$7.50 to $8.25 range (assuming all CCR allowances are used). TEA will provide recommendations for
Auction 31 during the February 2016 Risk Management Committee (RMC) meeting.
Based on the December 9, 2015 ICE price for the January 2016 futures price ($7.53/ton), the estimated
market value of Dover’s existing 91,546 2 ton RGGI allowance bank is $689,341.
On November 17, 2015 RGGI held a stakeholder meeting to prepare for the 2016 RGGI program review.
Discussion topics included EPA’s Clean Power Plan, potential changes to the RGGI allowance cap post
2020 and a discussion about RGGI’s Flexibility Mechanisms. A Delaware specific stakeholder “listening
session” was held on November 20, 2015, with a focus on EPA’s Clean Power Plan and how it relates to
the RGGI program. Additionally, on December 8, RGGI made a number of comments, which were filed
after the November 17 meeting. The next stakeholder meeting has not yet been scheduled but is
expected sometime during the spring of 2016. TEA will continue to monitor the 2016 program review as
it evolves.
Renewable Energy Certificates
Dover owns two photovoltaic systems totaling 15 kW, consisting of one 5 kW unit at the Utilities
Administration Building and two 5 kW units at the McKee Run generating station. Dover also receives
solar energy produced by the 10 MW Dover Sun Park, which is owned by White Oak Solar Energy, LLC.
In addition to all of the physical energy produced by the Sun Park, Dover receives 15% of Sun Park’s
Solar Renewable Energy Credits (SRECs).
Dover participates in the Delaware Municipal Electric Renewable Portfolio Standard (DMERPS) for
compliance with the State of Delaware’s RPS laws applicable to municipal utilities. The first compliance
period under DMERPS was for the 12 months ending May 2014, and the second compliance period was
for the 12 months ending May 2015.
Last month, it was reported that SRECs from the White Oak Solar Energy Center are eligible for a 10%
adder because the facility was constructed using a Delaware labor force. TEA, DEMEC, and Dover staff
have reconciled this increase in SRECs. PJM’s GATs system does not include a mechanism to
retroactively record the 10% labor bonus SRECs. Therefore, DEMEC and TEA have had to account for
these bonus SRECs outside PJM’s GATs.
The revision indicated that Dover over-complied in the first compliance period by 290.2 SRECs. These
were used to off-set a portion of the second control period’s requirement to surrender 3,435 SRECs,
resulting in a net surrender for the second control period of 3,144.8 SRECs.
Through the end of generation month October 2015, Dover had accumulated a total of 6,651 SRECs
from these renewable energy resources. This total includes SRECs reported in PJM’s GATs account.
Bonus allowances for Sun Park labor and net of 2,941 SREC transferred to DEMEC for surrender on
October 3, 2014 for the first compliance period and 2,861 SRECs and 574 bonus SRECs for the second
compliance period on November 9, 2015.
2
Subject to verification from RGGI COATS account.
December 17, 2015 Page 8
Page 73
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Delaware periodically holds SRECs auctions; however, these auctions are for size tiers N1 – N3, E1 and
E2. The Dover Sun Park is in the N4 tier for large-scale facilities. State-wide carve outs for Tier 4 has
been fully subscribed, so there is not a market for tier T4 SRECs in Delaware.
The nearest viable market for Dover’s SRECs is Pennsylvania. Daily settlement prices from Flett
Exchange Environmental Services. The most recent settlement prices for Pennsylvania SRECs are in the
following table:
PJM-GATS Transferred to
Balance 10% Bonus DEMEC for Net SREC
SREC Vintage Market Before SRECs for 2014/15 Balance After
(June 1 – May Clearing 2014/15 Sun Park Compliance Transfer and Market
3
31) Price Compliance Labor Bonus GATs Surrender Value
2011/2012 $ 0.00 0 290.2 290.2 0 $0
2012/2013 $ 0.00 2,173 215.7 215.7 2,173 0 $0
2013/2014 $10.00 2,701 268.0 68.1 688 2,212.8 22,129
2014/2015 $15.00 2,685 266.3 0 0 2,951.3 44,269
2015/2016 $15.00 1,353 134.2 0 0 1,487.2 22,308
Totals 8,907 1,173.5 574 2,861 6,651.3 $88,706
TEA continues to recommend to Dover to retain these allowances for compliance with its Renewable
Portfolio Standard (RPS). Additionally, Dover will need to acquire additional SRECs resources in future
years. It is apparent that Dover’s portion of SRECs produced by White Oak Solar Energy Center will not
be sufficient in future years as the compliance requirements increase. DEMEC has indicated that it
expects to have excess SRECs available for Dover’s compliance requirements. This and other alternatives
will need to be evaluated in the near future.
RISK MANAGEMENT SUMMARY
Forward power prices in PJM have decreased from last month, except for 2019-2020.
Blended Monthly
Hedge Cost Change
PY Ratio ($/MWh) ($/MWh)
2015-16 75% $42.03 ($0.54)
2016-17 59% $40.46 ($0.51)
2017-18 56% $40.05 ($0.36)
2018-19 49% $38.96 ($0.23)
2019-20 32% $36.48 $0.18
3
Note: Retroactive Bonus Allowances were not transferred within PJM’s GATs system but were used to off-set 2014/15
compliance obligation.
December 17, 2015 Page 9
Page 74
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
II. BUDGET REPORT
Budget Actual Variance
Nov-15 Nov-15
Gross Load 58,800 54,678 4,122
Power Supply
Hedged Energy $1,803,100 $1,635,046 $168,054
PJM - Energy, Congestion & Losses $562,900 231440.88 $331,459
PJM - ARR, Transmission and Fees $650,000 471167.55 $178,832
Dover SUN Park Energy $118,700 $107,183 $11,517
Dover SUN Park RECs $25,800 $26,003 ($203)
RECS (Solar and Non-Solar) $56,100 $0 $56,100
RGGI Credit Costs $0 $0 $0
Management Fees $83,000 $83,000 $0
PJM - Capacity UCAP Obligated Purchased $853,900 $866,857 ($12,957)
Subtotal - Power Supply $4,153,500 $3,420,698 $732,802
Power Generation O&M
Plant O&M $455,200 477240 ($22,040)
Subtotal Generation O&M $455,200 477240 ($22,040)
Power Generation Production Margin
PJM - Economic and reliability dispatch $0 ($88,861) $88,861
Fuel Costs - Natural Gas $0 $0 $0
Fuel Costs - Oil $0 $62,966 ($62,966)
Testing Costs $0 $0 $0
Subtotal Generation Production Margin $0 ($25,895) 25895.38
Power Generation Non-Production Revenue
PJM - Generation Capacity Credit ($879,200) ($873,044) ($6,156)
Emissions Allowance Sales $0 $0 $0
Reactive Supply - Gas ($30,000) ($44,357) $14,357
Subtotal - Non-Production Revenue ($909,200) ($917,401) $8,201
SubTotal - All Generation ($454,000) ($466,057) $12,057
Total - Utilities Cost $3,699,500 $2,954,641 $744,859
Unit Costs
Total - Power Supply $70.64 $62.56 $8.08
Total - Power Generation ($7.72) ($8.52) $0.80
Final Cost of Service to City of Dover Ratepayers $62.92 $54.04 $8.88
December 17, 2015 Page 10
Page 75
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Variance Analysis
Power Supply
• Dover consumed 4,122 MWh less than forecasted for the month.
• Dover saw a favorable variance for budgeted Hedged Energy of $168,054.
• Dover experienced a favorable variance for budgeted PJM - Energy, Congestion and Losses
of $331,459 and a favorable variance for PJM ARR, Transmission and Fees of $178,832.
• This resulted in a net power supply cost of $54.04/MWh, $8.88/MWh below budget.
• The city realized a favorable variance of $732,802 for power supply vs. the monthly budget.
• Dover Sun Park generated 122 MWhs less than forecasted.
Generation
• Non Production Revenue had a favorable variance of $8,201.
• Net Generation Revenue had a favorable variance of $12,057.
December 17, 2015 Page 11
Page 76
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Budget Actual Variance
YTD YTD
Gross Load 330,200 328,761 1,439
Power Supply
Hedged Energy $11,198,600 $10,835,104 $363,496
PJM - Energy, Congestion & Losses $3,303,200 1228212.96 $2,074,987
PJM - ARR, Transmission and Fees $3,382,500 2549011.26 $833,489
Dover SUN Park Energy $903,100 $993,835 ($90,735)
Dover SUN Park RECs $176,000 $182,183 ($6,183)
RECS (Solar and Non-Solar) $280,500 $0 $280,500
RGGI Credit Costs $43,800 $24,080 $19,720
Management Fees $415,000 $415,000 $0
PJM - Capacity UCAP Obligated Purchased $4,355,000 $4,404,432 ($49,432)
Subtotal - Power Supply $24,057,700 $20,631,858 $3,425,842
Power Generation O&M
Plant O&M $2,954,000 2406821 $547,179
Subtotal Generation O&M $2,954,000 2406821 $547,179
Power Generation Production Margin
PJM - Economic and reliability dispatch ($569,400) ($664,214) $94,814
Fuel Costs - Natural Gas $389,200 $195,592 $193,608
Fuel Costs - Oil $0 $91,034 ($91,034)
Testing Costs $0 $0 $0
Subtotal Generation Production Margin ($180,200) ($377,589) 197388.5807
Power Generation Non-Production Revenue
PJM - Generation Capacity Credit ($4,483,900) ($3,889,531) ($594,369)
Emissions Allowance Sales $0 $0 $0
Reactive Supply - Gas ($150,000) ($308,353) $158,353
Subtotal - Non-Production Revenue ($4,633,900) ($4,197,884) ($436,016)
SubTotal - All Generation ($1,860,100) ($2,168,651) $308,551
Total - Utilities Cost $22,197,600 $18,463,207 $3,734,393
Unit Costs
Total - Power Supply $72.86 $62.76 $10.10
Total - Power Generation ($5.63) ($6.60) $0.96
Final Cost of Service to City of Dover Ratepayers $67.22 $56.16 $11.06
December 17, 2015 Page 12
Page 77
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
III. OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Executive Summary
During the month of November, there were no recordable accidents or lost time accidents. The facility
has gone 228 days through November 30, 2015 without an OSHA Recordable Accident and has not had a
Lost Time Accident since the January 12th, 2015 incident. PJM did not dispatch Unit 1, Unit 2 or Unit 3
during the month of November. Unit 11 was dispatched twice for the month of November for a total of
7.315 hours online.
Monthly Budget Variance – The actual expenses attributable to O&M of the two sites for the month of
November are $477,240 against a budgeted amount of $455,225 for an unfavorable variance of $22.015
or 4.84%. The variance was due to: a Personnel Expenses variance of $57,718 unfavorable due to 3 pay
periods occurring in the month of November, only 2 were budgeted, Materials and Supplies variance
was unfavorable $28,608 – due to accounting reversing the previous credit for the plant water & sewer
account and plant chemicals were purchased in November originally forecast to be purchased in July
and August. The Administrative Expense variance was favorable $63,771 due to timing of home office
invoicing. The operator management fee and insurance costs were not included in the November
expenses.
Please note the yellow highlighted numbers on the Operation Tables on pages 6 and 7 are not correct
because fuel oil analysis from those runs are not due back until December 17th or 18th. An updated final
monthly report will be issued once the results of those fuel oil samples are made available.
December 17, 2015 Page 13
Page 78
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
NAES Corporation
Dover, Delaware
November 2015
Monthly Report
Tyler Brown (Operator II Step I) was awarded his PJM shirt by Don Mordus
(Plant Manager) for passing his PJM Certification Exam.
December 17, 2015 Page 14
Page 79
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Table of Contents
1.0 Environmental, Health and Safety
2.0 Financials
3.0 Operations
4.0 Maintenance
5.0 Capital Improvement Projects (CIP
6.0 General Plant Information
7.0 Training
8.0 Upcoming Events
1.0 Environmental, Health and Safety
During the month of November, there were no recordable accidents, lost time accidents or
environmental incidents. The facility has gone 228 days through November 30, 2015 without an OSHA
Recordable Accident or a Lost Time since the April 16, 2015 reportable accident.
There were two Near Misses reported in November 2015 at McKee Run. While walking by the 4160
breakers on the #3 turbine deck, a I.C & E mechanic noticed that Ansul portable fire extinguisher #37
had disconnected hoses from the main CO2 tank with no volume regulators on either side of the
portable fire extinguisher. Also the tires are badly under inflated and require immediate attention. This
fire extinguisher was taken out of service until it can be repaired. A second Near Miss was reported
when exhaust gases entered Fire Pump Room (FPR) from damaged exhaust system while the gasoline
engine was started during weekend inspections. The carbon monoxide monitor was moved to another
location but an operator did not inform any supervision. A new carbon monoxide monitor was
immediately installed. All employees underwent CPR/First Aid and AED training and are now complete
for 2015.
During the month of November, there were no IWW discharges to the Kent County Public Works sewer
system. The November Significant Industrial User (SIU) report was submitted to Kent County Public
Works indicating no discharges occurred. McKee Run submitted a waiver of cyanide analysis to the Kent
County Public Works division since cyanide was not detected in four (4) consecutive quarters. No
response has been received by Kent County Public Works to date on a waiver determination.
During the month of November, there were no sampling events at Outfall 001, 004, 005 and 006. The
November DMR was submitted to DNREC indicating no discharge from Outfall 001, 004 and 005 for this
month. A visual inspection form was completed prior to a discharge of accumulated storm water from
Outfall 006 and submitted to DNREC for review. No NPDES exceedances have been identified. All non-
contact cooling tower blowdown water is being discharged directly to the Kent County Department of
Public Works under the facilities Industrial Wastewater Discharge Permit #18.
VanSant received written confirmation from DNREC that VanSant passed the compliance evaluation
during inspections on June 25th, 26th and 27th, 2015 without any conditional approvals. This indicates
that VanSant was operating in compliance with the Title V permit at the time of the inspection.
December 17, 2015 Page 15
Page 80
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
McKee Run and VanSant received written confirmation from DNREC that both facilities passed the Full
Compliance Audit on July 21, 2015 and the Semi Annual Compliance Certification Review without any
conditional approvals. . This indicates that McKee Run and VanSant were operating in compliance with
the Title V permit at the time of the inspection.
December 17, 2015 Page 16
Page 81
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
2.0 Financials
Monthly and year to date financial results as compared with the approved power plant budget for the
Generation Units are provided below.
2.1 Variance Analysis:
The actual expenses for the month of November are $477,240 against a budgeted amount of
$455,225 for an unfavorable variance of $22,015 or 4.84%. The variance was due to the
following:
• Personnel Expenses: An unfavorable monthly variance of $57,718 was due to (3) payroll
periods being expensed vs. the (2) that were budgeted. This had been a carryover from
the previous month. Note that a portion of this was offset by not having a full
complement of employees for this time period. As a result, this impacted three (3) labor
accounts – Straight Time, Overtime, and Labor Burdens.
• Materials and Supplies Expenses: An unfavorable monthly variance of $28,608 was due to
reversal of a credit in the water – sewer account and purchase of bulk chemicals that was
previously budgeted in July and August.
• Administrative Expenses: A favorable monthly variance of $63,771 was due primarily to
the timing of home office consolidated invoices being processed for payment. The
operator management fee and insurance costs were not included in November expenses.
December 17, 2015 Page 17
Page 82
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
3.0 Operations
Unit Operations / Outages / Trips: Unit 11 was dispatched by PJM on November 23rd at 2100 due to a
constraint on the Milford-Steele line the unit was cost-capped. The Unit tripped the first time on high
vibration and on the second start on operator error. The unit ran for 2.199 hours. Unit 11 was
dispatched by PJM on November 24th at 0428 due to a constraint on the Milford-Steele line the unit
was cost-capped. The unit ran for 5.116 hours. Units 1, 2, and 3 were not dispatch in the month of
November.
December 17, 2015 Page 18
Page 83
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
December 17, 2015 Page 19
Page 84
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
3.1 Team Report:
The Operations staff completed their CBT training through OES-NA. The training earns the
operator CEH credits for every online course they complete and have to take a final test with a
passing grade of 70% or higher. The courses range from transmission to generation training to
some of NERC regulations. The training is up to a year and if all courses are completed you can
earn up to 60 CEH credits.
Operations personnel continue to support maintenance by working on Preventative
Maintenance (PM) work orders and other work orders that they have the skills to successfully
complete the task. The Operations Department continues to utilize the Day Shift Workers in
both the Operations and Maintenance areas to assist with maintenance of the plant.
4.0 Maintenance
During the month of November, the Plant Maintenance staff continued addressing the backlog of work
orders and the preventative and new work orders received during the month. Back logged Work Orders
are work orders that have been open for greater than thirty days. There were 44 new work orders
issued with 48 work orders being completed, and 31 of the back logged work orders completed during
the month. There were 5 new Safety Work Orders entered into the plant’s Computerized Maintenance
Management System (MP2) during the month of which 3 were completed. The table below summarizes
the monthly work order activities based on MP2 records and will continue to improve with time. This
table gives a representation of identified outstanding work; Preventative Maintenance tasks completion
and remaining corrective work orders and back logged work orders that require attention.
December 17, 2015 Page 20
Page 85
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Notable activities during the month include:
The Maintenance and IC&E staff completed an extensive winterization upgrade to the McKee Run Power
Plant facility. This included sealing up outside louvers that were no longer in service. They sealed up pipe
penetrations coming from the outside walls. Cover were fabricated and installed to cover the opening of
the exhaust fan on the roof. All of the space heaters were checked for proper operation and repaired if
needed. New heaters were installed on the drum level on Units 1 & 2 boilers. The winterization upgrade
will ensure that the plant will stay warm during the cold winter months.
The Maintenance and IC&E staff installed two new upgraded acid pumps in the DI at VanSant. The old
pump were not preforming as they should have been. This was causing delays in the regeneration
process which could cause a risk in generation. These pumps were installed to make the DI system a
more reliable system.
A safety walk around was completed by the compliance coordinator after a rain event. It was noticed
that the wooden outfall steps were very slippery. A work order was issued to install some type of
material that would have a gripping type surface on the steps to prevent a slipping hazard. The
Maintenance staff installed an FRP material on the steps that has a non-skid surface fabricated into the
material. The steps are now safe to walk down during and after rain events.
The IC&E staff install the Christmas on the stack of Unit 3. This is a tradition of the facility and has been
for many years. The community appreciates that we install the Christmas every year. We received
several comments on the Christmas lights every year for the surrounding neighbors of the plant and
citizens of the City of Dover.
December 17, 2015 Page 21
Page 86
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
5.0 Capital Improvement Projects (CIP)
This month’s report for CIP project planned and budgeted for the current budget year 2015/2016 with
the status to date for the project.
2015/2016 CIP Status
December 17, 2015 Page 22
Page 87
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
6.0 General Plant Information
On November 17, 2015, Tyler Brown, Operator, passed his PJM examination. Tyler came to work with us
in March and has since become a dependable and trusted employee in that short time. We applaud his
hard work and determination in completing this challenge.
Plant employees began their Annual Food Drive for the local Food Bank. Our goal is to collect at least
150 lbs. of food, to best last year’s donations of 135 lbs. Our drive will continue through December 11,
at which time all donations will be turned over to the Food Bank.
Interviews are ongoing for a Plant Engineer and an IC&E Technician for our staff.
7.0 Training
Jack Coleman with OES-NA was on site November 3rd through the 5th for training on preparation for the
PJM Generation System Operators exam. The class was made up of two supervisors, four operators, and
plant manager. The class will go over emergency operations, system restoration, and all phases of
system operator requirements to prepare the operators to take the PJM Generation exam.
Topics discussed during the monthly safety committee meeting were reviewed by the entire staff. The
monthly safety topic was on “12 Safety Tips to Keep Your Holiday Safe”, No one plans for fires or injuries
when planning for the holidays, but ignorance of safety standards and carelessness can lead to severe
damage to the home or trips to the emergency room.
8.0 Upcoming Events
A forecast of general event dates for the power plant projects, outages and various agency reporting
dates are listed below.
December 17, 2015 Page 23
Page 88
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
IV. APPENDIX: PJM INVOICE
Monthly Billing
Statement - CSV and
REPORT NAME: XML
CUSTOMER
ACCOUNT: City of Dover, Delaware
CUSTOMER
CODE: DOVDE
CUSTOMER ID: 76.000000
FINAL BILLING
STATEMENT
ISSUED: 12/7/2015 9:21
BILLING
PERIOD START
DATE: 11/1/2015
BILLING
PERIOD END
DATE: 11/30/2015
INVOICE
NUMBER: 2015113000076.000000
INVOICE DUE
DATE: 12/11/2015 12:00
BILLING LINE ITEM SOURCE BILLING PERIOD
CHARGES ADJ NAME START AMOUNT ($)
Network Integration
1100.000000 Transmission Service 435135.300000
Transmission
1108.000000 Enhancement 70050.530000
Firm Point-to-Point
1130.000000 Transmission Service 0.000000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point
1140.000000 Transmission Service 0.000000
Day-ahead Spot Market
1200.000000 Energy 374974.400000
Balancing Spot Market
1205.000000 Energy -11380.990000
Day-ahead
Transmission
1210.000000 Congestion -153257.650000
Balancing Transmission
1215.000000 Congestion -50982.860000
Day-ahead
1220.000000 Transmission Losses 19916.490000
Balancing Transmission
1225.000000 Losses 32.630000
1230.000000 Inadvertent Interchange 107.440000
December 17, 2015 Page 24
Page 89
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Day-Ahead Load
Response Charge
1242.000000 Allocation 79.380000
Real-Time Load
Response Charge
1243.000000 Allocation 216.110000
1250.000000 Meter Error Correction -3014.610000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service -
Control Area
1301.000000 Administration 9293.610000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service - FTR
1302.000000 Administration 2.200000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service -
1303.000000 Market Support 2145.490000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service -
Regulation Market
1304.000000 Administration 88.030000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service -
Capacity
Resource/Obligation
1305.000000 Mgmt. 906.600000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service -
Advanced Second
1306.000000 Control Center 1205.730000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service -
1307.000000 Market Support Offset -215.340000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service Refund
- Control Area
1308.000000 Administration -60.410000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service Refund
1310.000000 - Market Support -11.370000
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service Refund
- Regulation Market
1311.000000 Administration -0.900000
December 17, 2015 Page 25
Page 90
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
Dispatch Service Refund
- Capacity
Resource/Obligation
1312.000000 Mgmt. -5.100000
1313.000000 PJM Settlement, Inc. 215.340000
Market Monitoring Unit
1314.000000 (MMU) Funding 221.270000
1315.000000 FERC Annual Recovery 3680.080000
Organization of PJM
States, Inc. (OPSI)
1316.000000 Funding 37.900000
North American Electric
Reliability Corporation
1317.000000 (NERC) 648.160000
Reliability First
1318.000000 Corporation (RFC) 1054.600000
Transmission Owner
Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch
1320.000000 Service 4081.070000
Reactive Supply and
Voltage Control from
Generation and Other
1330.000000 Sources Service 42343.240000
Regulation and
Frequency Response
1340.000000 Service 9825.760000
1360.000000 Synchronized Reserve 3825.180000
Non-Synchronized
1362.000000 Reserve 911.320000
Day-ahead Scheduling
1365.000000 Reserve 700.720000
Day-ahead Operating
1370.000000 Reserve 3854.570000
Balancing Operating
1375.000000 Reserve 1313.080000
Balancing Operating
Reserve for Load
1376.000000 Response 4.320000
Synchronous
1377.000000 Condensing 16.860000
1378.000000 Reactive Services 4144.690000
1380.000000 Black Start Service 3395.460000
Load Reconciliation for
1400.000000 Spot Market Energy -17790.450000
Load Reconciliation for
Transmission
1410.000000 Congestion -4693.050000
Load Reconciliation for
1420.000000 Transmission Losses -1244.430000
Load Reconciliation for
1430.000000 Inadvertent Interchange -4.140000
December 17, 2015 Page 26
Page 91
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Load Reconciliation for
PJM Scheduling,
System Control and
1440.000000 Dispatch Service 47.090000
Load Reconciliation for
Schedule 9-6 -
Advanced Second
1442.000000 Control Center 5.400000
Load Reconciliation for
Market Monitoring Unit
1444.000000 (MMU) Funding 0.910000
Load Reconciliation for
1445.000000 FERC Annual Recovery 15.280000
Load Reconciliation for
Organization of PJM
States, Inc. (OPSI)
1446.000000 Funding 0.160000
Load Reconciliation for
North American Electric
Reliability Corporation
1447.000000 (NERC) 2.690000
Load Reconciliation for
Reliability First
1448.000000 Corporation (RFC) 4.380000
Load Reconciliation for
Transmission Owner
Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch
1450.000000 Service 16.940000
Load Reconciliation for
Regulation and
Frequency Response
1460.000000 Service -74.140000
Load Reconciliation for
1470.000000 Synchronized Reserve -69.330000
Load Reconciliation for
Non-Synchronized
1472.000000 Reserve -10.370000
Load Reconciliation for
Day-ahead Scheduling
1475.000000 Reserve -804.560000
Load Reconciliation for
Balancing Operating
1478.000000 Reserve 35.540000
Load Reconciliation for
1490.000000 Reactive Services 151.950000
1600.000000 RPM Auction 6120.900000
1610.000000 Locational Reliability 874987.800000
Generation Deactivation
1932.000000 Refund -502.010000
PJM Annual
1995.000000 Membership Fee 5000.000000
Day-Ahead Load
Response Charge
1242.000000 A Allocation 10/1/2015 -0.010000
December 17, 2015 Page 27
Page 92
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Real-Time Load
Response Charge
1243.000000 A Allocation 10/1/2015 -0.010000
1250.000000 A Meter Error Correction 10/1/2015 -83.350000
1360.000000 A Synchronized Reserve 9/1/2015 -0.110000
1360.000000 A Synchronized Reserve 10/1/2015 -0.060000
Day-ahead Scheduling
1365.000000 A Reserve 9/1/2015 -3094.990000
Day-ahead Scheduling
1365.000000 A Reserve 10/1/2015 0.050000
Day-ahead Operating
1370.000000 A Reserve 7/1/2015 125.300000
Balancing Operating
1375.000000 A Reserve 7/1/2015 -0.560000
Balancing Operating
1375.000000 A Reserve 8/1/2015 0.320000
Balancing Operating
1375.000000 A Reserve 9/1/2015 306.190000
Balancing Operating
1375.000000 A Reserve 10/1/2015 -33.810000
Balancing Operating
Reserve for Load
1376.000000 A Response 10/1/2015 -0.010000
1378.000000 A Reactive Services 9/1/2015 -33.820000
1378.000000 A Reactive Services 10/1/2015 -260.800000
Michigan - Ontario
Interface Phase Angle
1911.000000 A Regulators 10/1/2015 183.860000
Total Charges 1633803.080000
BILLING LINE ITEM SOURCE BILLING PERIOD
CREDITS ADJ NAME START AMOUNT ($)
Network Integration
2100.000000 Transmission Service 0.000000
Transmission
2108.000000 Enhancement 55113.410000
Firm Point-to-Point
2130.000000 Transmission Service 0.000000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point
2140.000000 Transmission Service 689.930000
Transmission
2210.000000 Congestion 0.000000
2220.000000 Transmission Losses 14888.110000
Transmission Owner
Scheduling, System
Control and Dispatch
2320.000000 Service 0.000000
Reactive Supply and
Voltage Control from
Generation and Other
2330.000000 Sources Service 29467.580000
December 17, 2015 Page 28
Page 93
Monthly Management Committee Update
November 2015
Regulation and
Frequency Response
2340.000000 Service 0.000000
2360.000000 Synchronized Reserve 0.000000
Day-ahead Scheduling
2365.000000 Reserve 0.000000
Day-ahead Operating
2370.000000 Reserve 0.000000
Balancing Operating
2375.000000 Reserve 9651.370000
2380.000000 Black Start Service 0.000000
Load Reconciliation for
2420.000000 Transmission Losses 74.820000
2510.000000 Auction Revenue Rights 73697.400000
2600.000000 RPM Auction 879165.000000
2630.000000 Capacity Transfer Rights 2121.300000
Incremental Capacity
2640.000000 Transfer Rights 341.700000
Capacity Resource
2661.000000 Deficiency 5667.740000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point
2140.000000 A Transmission Service 10/1/2015 49.900000
Transmission
2210.000000 A Congestion 10/1/2015 0.000000
2220.000000 A Transmission Losses 7/1/2015 1.440000
Balancing Operating
2375.000000 A Reserve 9/1/2015 -88.000000
Balancing Operating
2375.000000 A Reserve 10/1/2015 -241.600000
Total Credits 1070600.100000
Monthly Billing Net Total 563202.980000
Previous Weekly Billing
Net Total 396994.530000
Total Due /
Receivable 166208.45
December 17, 2015 Page 29
Page 94
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Prepared By:
Arline Holloway
Client Services Manager
Phone: 904-360-1347
Email: aholloway@teainc.org
Date:
January 28, 2016
301 W. Bay Street, Suite 2600 Jacksonville, FL 32202 Tel: 904.356.3900 Toll-Free: 800.423.4800
Page 95
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Table of Contents
I. Executive Summary 1
Power Supply Summary 1
Supply Source Summary 2
Supply Variance 2
Generation Summary 3
Emissions Summary 5
Risk Management Summary 10
II. Budget Report 11
III. Operations Management 14
Operations Summary 14
IV. Appendix: PJM Invoice 28
January 28, 2016 Page ii
Page 96
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
POWER SUPPLY SUMMARY
Overall Power Supply costs were $658,115 below budget predominantly driven by lower PJM-Energy,
Congestion and Losses and lower Hedge Energy costs.
Dover’s budgeted cost for all power supply (capacity AND energy) was $73.74/MWh. The actual cost of
all power supply (capacity AND energy) was $63.75/MWh.
The actual cost of energy alone was $37.66/MWh as opposed to a budgeted energy cost of $43.75.
Dover’s total load was 56,530 MWh versus a forecasted load of 57,800 MWh. Hedge purchases totaled
42,128 MWh, which was 75% of the actual load. The budgeted hedge purchase totaled 45,976 MWh,
which was 80% of the budgeted load.
Dover’s power purchases from hedge transactions totaled $1,721,267. Purchases from PJM (energy and
fees) totaled $1,709,161. This number includes Locational Reliability charge of $904,154 and DA spot
market energy charges of $357,636.72. Dover’s planned energy purchase from the SunPark solar
installation was 804 MWhs. Dover’s actual energy purchase from the SunPark installation was
556 MWh.
January 28, 2016 Page 1
Page 97
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Supply Source Summary
Supply Variance
January 28, 2016 Page 2
Page 98
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
GENERATION SUMMARY
Net Generation Revenue for the month of November was $480,618 versus a budget of $489,700.
January 28, 2016 Page 3
Page 99
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Generation Breakdown
City of Dover
Monthly Wholesale Generation Formula
December 2015
Net Generation
185.54 D
Production Margin
PJM - Generation
Economic and Reliability Dispatch $ 18,212.62 A
Natural Gas & Oil Consumption
Purchases for Generation $ -
Natural Gas Transport $ -
Eastern Shore Cashout $ -
Oil Consumption $ (19,510.82)
Subtotal: Natural Gas & Oil Consumption $ (19,510.82) B
Gross Production Margin $ (1,298.20) C = (A + B)
$/MWh Generation Production Gross Margin $ (7.00) E = (C/D)
PJM - Capacity
Generation Capacity Credit $ 902,145.57
Reactive Supply and Transmission Losses $ 43,549.46
Subtotal: PJM - Capacity $ 945,695.03 F
All in Generation Margin
All in Generation Margin Total $ 944,396.83 (G = C + F)
January 28, 2016 Page 4
Page 100
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
EMISSIONS SUMMARY
Emissions Allowance and Solar Renewable Energy Summary through December 31, 2015
The reinstated Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) replaced the Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR)
beginning January 1, 2015. The State of Delaware was included in the CAIR footprint but is not included
in the CSAPR footprint. CAIR allowances cannot be used for CSAPR compliance, so Dover’s CAIR
allowances essentially became valueless when CSAPR was reinstated. EPA has recently updated the
National Ambient Air Quality Standard for Ozone, which will expand Ozone non-Attainment areas and
may result in more restrictive CSAPR standards. Based on a cursory review, it does not appear the
CSAPR footprint will be expanded to include Delaware.
The separate Clean Air Act acid rain deposition control program (CAA Title IV), which governs SO2
national allowance trading program, remains in effect for Dover. Beginning with the January 2015
report, TEA no longer includes a CAIR summary. It will continue to report on Dover’s Clean Air Act Title
IV SO2 allowances.
Market liquidity for Title IV SO2 allowances is very low, with few transactions occurring. The following
table shows estimated values for Dover’s banked allowances, based on a market price assessment
published by SNL Energy.
Market Value for Clean Air Act Title IV Allowances
1
Commodity $/Ton Tons Market Value
SO2 Allowances – Title IV $0.56 15,006 $8,403
Total $8,403
Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative
The State of Delaware is a participant in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI). The City of
Dover must comply with RGGI by surrendering carbon dioxide (CO2) allowances pursuant to the State of
Delaware’s laws (Title 7, Chapter 60, Sub-Title II-A).
Dover had more than a sufficient number of RGGI allowances allocated to it to cover its requirements
through the first compliance period (calendar years 2009-2011) and second compliance period
(2012-2014). Any unused allowances are carried over (“banked”) for subsequent years. The table below
includes Dover’s historical activities and includes projections through 2020. Two projections are
presented: (1) future annual emissions based on the average for 2009-2014, and (2) future annual
emissions based on 2010 actual CO2 emissions, which was the highest emissions year between 2009 and
2014.
1
October 20, 2015 Daily Power Report by SNL Energy
January 28, 2016 Page 5
Page 101
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Dover, DE RGGI Allowance History and Forecast -December, 2015
CO2 Tons EOY Historical CO2 Tons CO2 Tons Projected EOY
Compliance CO2 Allowances Allocated CO2 Projected EOY
Emitted - Allowance Emitted - Proj. Emitted - Proj. Balance
Year (CY) Purchased Allowances Balance (High)
Historical Balance (Avg) (High) (Average)
2009 62,184 5,796 56,388
2010 49,747 32,971 73,164
2011 37,311 17,763 92,712
2012 27,983 15,957 104,738
2013 24,818 10,213 119,343
2014 1,000 N/A 25,426 94,917 94,917 94,917
2015 14,000 N/A 11,989 94,000 18,021 33,000 90,896 75,917
2016 N/A 18,021 33,000 72,875 42,917
2017 N/A 18,021 33,000 54,854 9,917
2018 N/A 18,021 33,000 36,833 -23,083
2019 N/A 18,021 33,000 18,812 -56,083
2020 N/A 18,021 33,000 791 -89,083
Dover RGGI Allowance History and Projection
December 31, 2015
150,000
100,000
Tons of CO2
50,000
0
-50,000
-100,000
Historical CO2 Emissions Projected CO2 Emissions - Avg
CO2 Tons Emitted - Proj. (High) EOY Historical Allowance Balance
Projected EOY Balance (Average) Projected EOY Balance (High)
January 28, 2016 Page 6
Page 102
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
The table and chart indicate that Dover could run out of banked allowances as early as the end of 2017
under the high emissions scenario and by the end of 2020 under the average scenario. Therefore, Dover
has recently initiated a program to participate in RGGI’s quarterly auctions to ensure it has adequate
allowances in the future.
In anticipation of needing additional RGGI allowances in the future, Dover has participated in the last
four auctions and plans to continue to participate as required. The table below shows details for
Dover’s allowance purchases for each of these previous auctions.
Dover’s RGGI Allowance Purchase History
RGGI Auction Auction Clearing Quantity Of
Number Auction Date Price ($/Ton) Allowances Awarded Total Cost
26 Dec 3, 2014 $5.21 1,000 $ 5,210
27 Mar 11, 2015 $5.41 6,000 32,460
28 June 3, 2015 $5.50 4,000 22,000
29 Sept 3, 2015 $6.02 4,000 24,080
30 Dec 2, 2015 $7.50 0 0
Totals 15,000 $83,750
Dover was unable to participate in Auction 30 due to an administrative error. Even if it had participated,
the auction cleared at a significantly higher price than the highest tier bid price which was approved by
Dover at last month’s RMC meeting. RGGI futures prices from the Intercontinental Exchange are shown
in the chart below:
January 28, 2016 Page 7
Page 103
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
The next RGGI auction will be held on March 9, 2016. The Cost Containment Reserve will be 10 Million
tons with a CCR price of $8.00/ton. Based on the recent run-up in spot prices, it may be reasonable to
expect the next auction will clear in the $8.00 to $8.50 range (assuming all CCR allowances are used).
TEA will provide recommendations for Auction 31 during the February 2016 Risk Management
Committee (RMC) meeting.
Based on the January 26, 2016 ICE price for the January 2016 futures price ($8.45/ton), the estimated
market value of Dover’s existing 91,546 2 ton RGGI allowance bank is $773,564.
On November 17, 2015 RGGI held a stakeholder meeting to prepare for the 2016 RGGI program review.
Discussion topics included EPA’s Clean Power Plan, potential changes to the RGGI allowance cap post
2020 and a discussion about RGGI’s Flexibility Mechanisms. A Delaware specific stakeholder “listening
session” was held on November 20, 2015, with a focus on EPA’s Clean Power Plan and how it relates to
the RGGI program. Additionally, on December 8, RGGI made a number of comments which were filed
after the November 17 meeting. The next stakeholder meeting is scheduled on February 2, 2016. TEA
will continue to monitor the 2016 program review as it evolves.
Renewable Energy Certificates
Dover owns two photovoltaic systems totaling 15 kW, consisting of one 5 kW unit at the Utilities
Administration Building and two 5 kW units at the McKee Run generating station. Dover also receives
solar energy produced by the 10 MW Dover Sun Park, which is owned by White Oak Solar Energy, LLC.
In addition to all of the physical energy produced by the Sun Park, Dover receives 15% of Sun Park’s
Solar Renewable Energy Credits (SRECS).
Dover participates in the Delaware Municipal Electric Renewable Portfolio Standard (DMERPS) for
compliance with the State of Delaware’s RPS laws applicable to municipal utilities. The first compliance
period under DMERPS was for the 12 months ending May 2014, and the second compliance period was
for the 12 months ending May 2015.
Through the end of generation month November 2015, Dover had accumulated a total of 6,783 SRECS
from these renewable energy resources. This total includes SRECS reported in PJM’s GATS account,
Bonus allowances for Sun Park labor, and net of 2,941 SRECs transferred to DEMEC for surrender on
October 3, 2014 for the first compliance period and 2,861 SRECs and 574 bonus SRECs for the second
compliance period on November 9, 2015.
Delaware periodically holds SRECs auctions; however, these auctions are for size tiers N1 – N3, E1 and
E2. The Dover Sun Park is in the N4 tier for large-scale facilities. State-wide carve outs for Tier 4 has
been fully subscribed, so there is not a market for Tier T4 SRECs in Delaware.
The nearest viable market for Dover’s SRECs is Pennsylvania. Daily settlement prices from Flett Exchange
Environmental Services. The most recent settlement prices for Pennsylvania SRECS are used in the table
below.
2
Subject to verification from RGGI COATS account.
January 28, 2016 Page 8
Page 104
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
PJM-GATS Transferred to
Balance 10% Bonus DEMEC for Net SREC
SREC Vintage Market Before SRECs for 2014/15 Balance After
(June 1 – May Clearing 2014/15 Sun Park Compliance Transfer and Market
3
31) Price Compliance Labor Bonus GATs Surrender Value
2011/2012 $ 0.00 0 290.2 290.2 0 $0
2012/2013 $ 0.00 2,173 215.7 215.7 2,173 0 $0
2013/2014 $10.00 2,701 268.0 68.1 688 2,212.8 22,129
2014/2015 $10.00 2,685 266.3 0 0 2,951.3 29,513
2015/2016 $15.00 1,473 146.2 0 0 1,619.2 24,288
Totals 9,032 1,186.4 574 2,861 6,783.4 $75,930
TEA continues to recommend to Dover to retain these allowances for compliance with its Renewable
Portfolio Standard (RPS). Additionally, Dover will need to acquire additional SRECs resources in future
years. It is apparent that Dover’s portion of SRECs produced by White Oak Solar Energy Center will not
be sufficient in future years as the compliance requirements increase. DEMEC has indicated that it
expects to have excess SRECs available for Dover’s compliance requirements. This and other alternatives
will need to be evaluated in the near future.
3
Note: Retroactive Bonus Allowances were not transferred within PJM’s GATS system but were used to off-set 2014/15
compliance obligation.
January 28, 2016 Page 9
Page 105
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
RISK MANAGEMENT SUMMARY
Forward power prices in PJM have increased.
Monthly Change
PY Hedge Ratio Blended Cost ($/MWh) ($/MWh)
2015-16 75% $41.72 ($0.31)
2016-17 59% $40.65 $0.19
2017-18 56% $40.23 $0.18
2018-19 49% $39.07 $0.11
2019-20 32% $36.74 $0.26
January 28, 2016 Page 10
Page 106
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
II. BUDGET REPORT
Budget Actual Variance
Dec 15 Dec 15
Gross Load 57,800 56,530 1,270
Power Supply
Hedged Energy $1,874,900 $1,721,267 $153,633
PJM - Energy, Congestion & Losses $549,200 333,123 $216,077
PJM - ARR, Transmission and Fees $650,000 479,171 $170,829
Dover SUN Park Energy $104,700 $74,637 $30,063
Dover SUN Park RECs $18,100 $15,920 $2,180
RECS (Solar and Non-Solar) $56,100 $0 $56,100
RGGI Credit Costs $43,700 $0 $43,700
Management Fees $83,000 $83,000 $0
PJM - Capacity UCAP Obligated Purchased $882,400 $896,867 ($14,467)
Subtotal - Power Supply $4,262,100 $3,603,985 $658,115
Power Generation O&M
Plant O&M $ 448,800 $ 463,779 $ (14,979)
Subtotal Generation O&M $448,800 $ 463,779 ($14,979)
Power Generation Production Margin
PJM - Economic and reliability dispatch $0 ($18,213) $18,213
Fuel Costs - Natural Gas $0 $0 $0
Fuel Costs - Oil $0 $19,511 ($19,511)
Testing Costs $0 $0 $0
Subtotal Generation Production Margin $0 $1,298 $ (1,298)
Power Generation Non-Production Revenue
PJM - Generation Capacity Credit ($908,500) ($902,146) ($6,354)
Emissions Allowance Sales $0 $0 $0
Reactive Supply - Gas ($30,000) ($43,549) $13,549
Subtotal - Non-Production Revenue ($938,500) ($945,695) $7,195
SubTotal - All Generation ($489,700) ($480,618) ($9,082)
Total - Utilities Cost $3,772,400 $3,123,367 $649,033
Unit Costs
Total - Power Supply $73.74 $63.75 $9.99
Total - Power Generation ($8.47) ($8.50) $0.03
Final Cost of Service to City of Dover Ratepayers $65.27 $55.25 $10.01
January 28, 2016 Page 11
Page 107
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Variance Analysis
Power Supply
• Dover consumed 1,270 MWh less than forecasted for the month.
• Dover saw a favorable variance for budgeted Hedged Energy of $153,633.
• Dover experienced a favorable variance for budgeted PJM - Energy, Congestion & Losses of
$216,077 and a favorable variance for PJM ARR, Transmission and Fees of $170,829.
• This resulted in a net power supply cost of $55.05/MWh and a positive budget variance of
$10.01/MWh below budget.
• The city realized a favorable variance of $658,115 for power supply vs. the monthly budget.
• Dover Sun Park generated 248 MWhs less than forecasted.
Generation
• Non Production Revenue had a favorable variance of $7,195 due to higher Reactive Supply
Revenue.
• Net Generation Revenue had an unfavorable variance of $9,082 due to an unfavorable O&M
and production margin variance.
January 28, 2016 Page 12
Page 108
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Budget Actual Variance
YTD YTD
Gross Load 388,000 385,291 2,709
Power Supply
Hedged Energy $13,073,500 $12,556,371 $517,129
PJM - Energy, Congestion & Losses $3,852,400 1,561,336 $2,291,064
PJM - ARR, Transmission and Fees $4,032,500 3,028,182 $1,004,318
Dover SUN Park Energy $1,007,800 $1,068,472 ($60,672)
Dover SUN Park RECs $194,100 $198,103 ($4,003)
RECS (Solar and Non-Solar) $336,600 $0 $336,600
RGGI Credit Costs $87,500 $24,080 $63,420
Management Fees $498,000 $498,000 $0
PJM - Capacity UCAP Obligated Purchased $5,237,400 $5,301,299 ($63,899)
Subtotal - Power Supply $28,319,800 $24,235,843 $4,083,957
Power Generation O&M
Plant O&M $ 3,402,800 $ 2,870,600 $ 532,200
Subtotal Generation O&M $3,402,800 $ 2,870,600 $532,200
Power Generation Production Margin
PJM - Economic and reliability dispatch ($569,400) ($682,427) $113,027
Fuel Costs - Natural Gas $389,200 $195,592 $193,608
Fuel Costs - Oil $0 $110,545 ($110,545)
Testing Costs $0 $0 $0
Subtotal Generation Production Margin ($180,200) ($376,290) $ 196,090
Power Generation Non-Production Revenue
PJM - Generation Capacity Credit ($5,392,400) ($4,791,676) ($600,724)
Emissions Allowance Sales $0 $0 $0
Reactive Supply - Gas ($180,000) ($351,903) $171,903
Subtotal - Non-Production Revenue ($5,572,400) ($5,143,579) ($428,821)
SubTotal - All Generation ($2,349,800) ($2,649,269) $299,469
Total - Utilities Cost $25,970,000 $21,586,574 $4,383,426
Unit Costs
Total - Power Supply $72.99 $62.90 $10.09
Total - Power Generation ($6.06) ($6.88) $0.82
Final Cost of Service to City of Dover Ratepayers $66.93 $56.03 $10.91
January 28, 2016 Page 13
Page 109
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
III. OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
OPERATIONS SUMMARY
During the month of December, there were no recordable accidents so the facility has gone 259 days
thorough December 31, 2015 without an OSHA Recordable Accident, and there were no lost time
accidents so it has been 343 days since the last lost time accident. There were also no environmental
incidents during the month of December.
Unit 11 was dispatched by PJM on December 5 due to a constraint on the Milford-Steele line, the unit
was cost capped. Unit 11 was on line for 2.42 hours and Units 1, 2, and 3 were not dispatched during
the month of December. All Units were available for the remainder of the month.
The actual expenses for the month of December are $463,779 against a budgeted amount of $448,775
for an unfavorable variance of $15,004 or 3.34%. The variance was due to the following: A favorable
monthly variance of $43,971 was due to not having a full complement of employees for this time period,
a favorable monthly variance of $1,008 was due to lower water/sewer account was less than budgeted
and completion of the network cabling replacement project, and an unfavorable monthly variance of
$59,983 due primarily to the timing of home office consolidated invoices being processed for payment.
Primarily the November costs were booked in the December expenses.
January 28, 2016 Page 14
Page 110
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
NAES Corporation
Dover, Delaware
December 2015
Monthly Report
Happy Holidays from McKee Run Generating Station!
Cover picture: The Christmas lights on display at McKee Run on Unit #3 stack with wishes for a Merry
Christmas and Happy New Year to everyone!
January 28, 2016 Page 15
Page 111
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Table of Contents
1.0 Environmental, Health and Safety
2.0 Financials
3.0 Operations
4.0 Maintenance
5.0 Capital Improvement Projects (CIP)
6.0 General Plant Information
7.0 Training
8.0 Upcoming Events
January 28, 2016 Page 16
Page 112
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
1.0 Environmental, Health and Safety
During the month of December, there were no recordable accidents, lost time accidents or environmental
incidents. The facility has gone 259 days through December 31, 2015 without an OSHA Recordable
Accident or a Lost Time since the April 16, 2015 reportable accident. There were no Near Misses reported
in December 2015 at McKee Run.
During the month of December, there were no IWW discharges to the Kent County Public Works sewer
system. The December Significant Industrial User (SIU) report was submitted to Kent County Public
Works indicating no discharges occurred. McKee Run submitted a waiver of cyanide analysis to the Kent
County Public Works division since cyanide was not detected in four (4) consecutive quarters. The
waiver from Kent County was granted and McKee Run no longer has to analyze for cyanide.
During the month of December, there were no sampling events at Outfall 001, 004, 005 and 006. The
December DMR was submitted to DNREC indicating no discharge from Outfall 001, 004, 005 and 006 for
this month. No NPDES exceedances have been identified. All non-contact cooling tower blowdown
water is being discharged directly to the Kent County Department of Public Works under the facilities
Industrial Wastewater Discharge Permit #18.
DNREC was on-site December 22, 2015 for the annual Surface Water Discharge assessment. DNREC
reviewed SPCC Plans and daily logs, Storm Water Plans, training documents, review of lab calibration
procedures plus a field tour to inspect all storm water outfalls. Based on the inspectors evaluation of the
documents and field tour mentioned above, McKee Run and VanSant passed the assessment.
McKee Run conducted a required full deployment drill as part of the Facility Response Plan
requirements. The full deployment drill was conducted to measure McKee Run, City of Dover, Dover Fire
and Police Departments, LEPC, State agencies and spill response contractors readiness in the event of a
worst case discharge from the 2.5 million gallon tank of No. 2 fuel oil. The drill required full participation
from the all entities mentioned above included being prepared to deploy watercraft and harbor boom
into Silver Lake. Based on the requirements necessary to pass the exercise, McKee Run fulfilled those
requirements.
January 28, 2016 Page 17
Page 113
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
January 28, 2016 Page 18
Page 114
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
2.0 Financials
Monthly and year-to-date financial results as compared with the approved power plant budget for the
Generation Units are provided below.
2.1 Variance Analysis:
The actual expenses for the month of December are $463,779 against a budgeted amount of
$448,775 for an unfavorable variance of $15,004 or 3.34%. The variance was due to the
following:
PERSONNEL EXPENSES: A favorable monthly variance of $43,971 was due to not having a full
complement of employees for this time period. As a result, this impacted three (3) labor
accounts – Straight Time, Overtime, and Labor Burdens.
MATERIALS AND SUPPLIES EXPENSES: A favorable monthly variance of $1,008 was due to lower
costs in the water – sewer account than budgeted and completion of network cabling that was
completed earlier in the fiscal year.
ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES: An unfavorable monthly variance of $59,983 was due primarily to
the timing of home office consolidated invoices being processed for payment. The operator
management fee and insurance costs from November were booked in the December expenses.
January 28, 2016 Page 19
Page 115
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
3.0 Operations
Unit Operations / Outages / Trips: Unit 11 was dispatched by PJM on December 5 at 0625 due to a
constraint on the Milford-Steele line; the unit was cost-capped. Unit 11 was online at 0723 and ran for
2.417 hours. Units 1, 2, and 3 were not dispatched in the month of December.
January 28, 2016 Page 20
Page 116
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
January 28, 2016 Page 21
Page 117
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
3.1 Team Report:
The operators also use the GPi Learning courses to improve their knowledge and skills. The GPI
online training which supports plant safety, OSHA, and environmental training requirements are
being used by the teams to complete their training for the year. Along with the GPI OSHA
training, the operators review the plant’s safety procedures.
Operations personnel continue to support maintenance by working on Preventative
Maintenance (PM) work orders and other work orders that they have the skills to successfully
complete the task. The Operations Department continues to utilize the Day Shift Workers in
both the Operations and Maintenance areas to assist with maintenance of the plant.
4.0 Maintenance
During the month of December, the Plant Maintenance staff continued addressing the backlog of work
orders, preventative maintenance (PM’s) and new work orders received during the month. Back logged
Work Orders are work orders that have been open for greater than thirty days. There were 40 new work
orders issued with 51 work orders being completed, and 17 of the back logged work orders completed
during the month. There were no new Safety Work Orders entered into the plant’s Computerized
Maintenance Management System (MP2) during the month and none were completed. The table below
summarizes the monthly work order activities based on MP2 records and will continue to improve with
time. This table gives a representation of identified outstanding work; Preventative Maintenance tasks
completion and remaining corrective work orders and back logged work orders that require attention.
January 28, 2016 Page 22
Page 118
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Notable activities during the month include:
The Maintenance and Operations staff completed the installation of the new fuel oil bypass piping
around the fuel oil unloading meter. Operations removed the standing fuel oil, completed a LOTO and
installed nitrogen for pipe purging during the pipe removal process to commence Maintenance removed
the spool piece and removed existing fuel oil piping to install the new bypass piping. The LOTO was
removed and the piping leak tested. This allows the plant to bypass the fuel oil unloading meter for
calibration, PM maintenance or repair service.
The Maintenance and IC&E staff participated in the Facility Response Plan Drill. Mock drill was
commenced with the discovery of fuel oil leaking from the fuel oil tank. Staff responded to the
emergency call and deployed booms and pads in the drill area. The spill trailer was utilized during this
event. Also special creek booms were placed in the nearby creek to contain the fuel oil from entering
Silver Lake. This was a drill.
The Maintenance staff repaired the VanSant carbon tank. During the regeneration process of the
VanSant DI, it was discovered that the carbon tank had a pinhole leak. The tank was locked out, drained
and the repair completed. LOTO was removed and the process started again. No leaks were discovered.
The IC&E staff completed the change out of the VanSant natural gas skid condensate collection
receptacle. The collection jar had become very hard to read and monitor condensate levels. A new self-
contained five (5) gallon drum with a level indicator was installed. This allows the daily site inspector to
easily see any amount of condensate being contained.
January 28, 2016 Page 23
Page 119
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
5.0 Capital Improvement Projects (CIP)
This month’s report for CIP project planned and budgeted for the current budget year 2015/2016 with
the status to date for the project.
2015/2016 CIP Status:
January 28, 2016 Page 24
Page 120
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
6.0 General Plant Information
Throughout the month of December, three of our most recently hired Operators sat for the PJM
Examination. Debro Curtis, Kyle Polumbo and Jesse Kummerer each attempted this challenging exam.
Although they were not successful, we applaud their efforts to build on their knowledge base in
preparing for successfully achieving this step in their professional training in the near future.
Plant employees completed the 2015 Annual Food Drive for the local Food Bank. Our goal was to collect
at least 150 lbs. of food, to best last year’s donations of 135 lbs. Our drive continued through December
11, at which time all donations were turned over to the Food Bank. Our generous employees managed
to bring in a total of 355 lbs. of food, well over our initial goal of 150 lbs. Employees were encouraged to
guess the total weight of the donations, with Erik Petty, Senior Operator, guessing the closest.
Congratulations to Erik and all staff who participated and made a difference.
On December 22 we held a Plant Holiday Celebration with a Turkey Fry and all the Fixings. All staff
contributed with food, snacks, drinks and supplies. In addition, employees were encouraged to
participate in a Secret Santa. Gifts were limited to $25.00 or less, and we had a large participation rate
for the meal and the gift-giving.
New employee Jacob Aucoin started as Plant Engineer on December 29. Jake earned his Bachelor of
Science in Mechanical Engineering from Louisiana State University in Baton Rouge. Jake has most
recently worked with DuPont and Dentsply Caulk, and has experience with mechanical reliability
monitoring and improvement, failure analysis, facility maintenance, workplace and machine safety,
hazard identification, analysis and hazard mitigation, to name a few areas of experience. We look
forward to having Jake integrated into our team to support the many needs of the facility.
Interviews are completed for the IC&E Technician and an offer was made to John Neff on January 5,
2016. John accepted this offer, and is currently going through the NAES screening process. More
information on John will be posted in next month’s Monthly Report.
7.0 Training
Joe Hultberg from Condor Technologies was on site December 10 and 11 to hold classes on boiler and
cooling water treatment focusing on Unit 3. The classes were set up to help our new operators to have a
better understanding of the water chemistry and the best way to react to the results of testing. The two
classes were three hours each and covered all shifts.
Topics discussed during the monthly safety committee meeting were reviewed by the entire staff. The
monthly safety topic was on “Eye Injury Prevention Fact Sheet”, each day, an estimated 2,000 workers
suffer eye injuries on the job, which robs many of them of their sight.
January 28, 2016 Page 25
Page 121
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
8.0 Upcoming Events
A forecast of general event dates for the power plant projects, outages and various agency reporting
dates are listed below.
9.0 “Value Added” Accomplishments in 2015
During the year the power plant staff is tasked with providing Operation and Maintenance support for
maintaining the City of Dover power generation assets in a ready to run status and to protect the assets
for the City. Listed below are some of the accomplishments that were done this past year that we feel
protected, added value to, and provided improvement to the overall operation and reliability of the
City’s assets.
Repair of Unit 3A ID Fan from fire incident during startup of unit in January
Recovery from winter freeze up of the units and component repairs
Replacement of Condensate piping 6” and 8” line (approx. 200’ of piping)
Heat trace installation and insulation installation on repaired condensate piping
Replacement of concrete pads with deck gratings outdoors and heat trace and insulation to
condensate piping to allow
Rewind of 3B ID Fan after motor cooling fan blade failure and replacement of motor cooling fans
to improve blade performance/reduce failure(s).
Removal of 3A ID fan motor for inspection, testing and replacement of motor cooling fan blades
before they could fail was done to prevent similar failure that occurred on 3B ID Fan Motor.
Summer 2015 run season allowed additional unit operations to allow us to train and qualify 3
new Control Room Operators and excellent training and introduction to the old technology for 5
new employees. Great morale builder and invaluable training lessons.
Inlet Fogging System installation, testing and commissioning for summer operation
improvements (capacity) was completed for the Van Sant unit.
Performance testing at Van Sant proved a 6.3 MW increase in unit capacity.
Commenced weekly operational test on the starting diesel for Van Sant to improve start
reliability of the unit. In the past unit would sit for up to 6 months without operation which led
inconsistent start performance. This identified several issues which were tuned, adjusted and
improved on for starting reliability.
January 28, 2016 Page 26
Page 122
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Correction of diesel starting engine issues to improve start reliability for the Van Sant unit
included: diesel fuel injector replacement, some were sticking from lack of operations, throttle
setting adjustment was performed as unit was not capable of coming on line in a timely manner,
improved diesel start time of unit with adjustments to idle settings and ramp speed of diesel,
and diesel throttle linkage adjustment was done to improve engine operation, engine was
hunting and slow to come up to speed.
Instituted a once a month full speed no load run to exercise the CT and to engage new
employees in proper CT operation, this is improving the operating knowledge of senior
operators as well as providing invaluable on hands training to new operators.
Installation of hot water boiler additional heaters to allow space heat to supply power plant
building.
Winterization of power plant Van Sant and MRGS, power plant building at MRGS the building is
significantly warmer then past winters.
McKee Run submitted a waiver of cyanide analysis to the Kent County Public Works since
cyanide was not detected in four (4) consecutive quarters. The waiver from Kent County was
granted and McKee Run no longer has to analyze for cyanide. The City of Dover will realize a cost
saving from no more cyanide analysis.
Removed incandescent light bulbs and replaced them with LED lights in an effort to reduce
electricity costs for lighting and for longer lasting bulbs which equates to less frequent purchase
of replacement light bulbs.
Installed filter fabric silt sacks over Outfall 005 to significantly reduce sediment from storm
water run-off from entering the Outfall. DNREC approved the action and is very pleased with the
pollution reduction measure.
McKee Run hired a professional pest removal company to trap and remove groundhogs from
the property. Groundhogs were burrowed and damaged the Tank 1 (2.5MM No. 2 fuel oil tank)
berm which jeopardized the integrity of the berm. The empty holes were backfilled by McKee
Run operators.
At the recommendation of the pest company, McKee Run hired a landscape firm to cut an eight
foot (8’) wide path around the perimeter of the fencing to further reduce the likelihood of pests
from returning.
In coordination with the City of Dover IT Department, the entire computer cabling network at
McKee Run was upgraded and replaced throughout the facility. All old cabling was replaced with
the latest Cat 6, shielded cable. All connections were tested, logged and documented. Computer
racks on the 3rd floor and Computer Room were replaced. This has resulted in greater reliability
and less down time due to outdated support systems.
Developed an internal Budget Variance Report for the O&M Budget so our staff has a current
status of the budget line items to help comply with the annual O&M budget.
In coordination with City of Dover IT Department, a Barracuda Internet Filter was installed on
the computer network to minimize virus and security threats from the internet.
McKee Run employees were all converted to Microsoft Exchange e-mail hosting to allow easier,
more secure access to their e-mail accounts, and to keep up with technological changes in
communication.
Added dirt to the area immediately North of Unit #3 Cooling Water Tower, the final grading of
the area is not complete but the addition of the dirt has eliminated a low lying area and once
the finally grade is finished by public works, and grass is planted, this area will not be a concern
for DNREC or outfall concerns.
January 28, 2016 Page 27
Page 123
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
IV. APPENDIX: PJM INVOICE
REPORT
NAME: Monthly Billing Statement - CSV and XML
CUSTOMER
ACCOUNT: City of Dover, Delaware
CUSTOMER
CODE: DOVDE
CUSTOMER
ID: 76.000000
FINAL
BILLING
STATEMENT
ISSUED: 1/8/2016 9:12
BILLING
PERIOD
START
DATE: 12/1/2015
BILLING
PERIOD
END DATE: 12/31/2015
INVOICE
NUMBER: 2015123100076.000000
INVOICE
DUE DATE: 1/15/2016 12:00
SOURCE
BILLING
PERIOD
CHARGES ADJ BILLING LINE ITEM NAME START AMOUNT ($)
1100.000000 Network Integration Transmission Service 449639.810000
1108.000000 Transmission Enhancement 70050.530000
1130.000000 Firm Point-to-Point Transmission Service 0.000000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point Transmission
1140.000000 Service 0.000000
1200.000000 Day-ahead Spot Market Energy 357636.720000
1205.000000 Balancing Spot Market Energy -12316.700000
1210.000000 Day-ahead Transmission Congestion -47712.740000
1215.000000 Balancing Transmission Congestion 17205.320000
1220.000000 Day-ahead Transmission Losses 8543.730000
1225.000000 Balancing Transmission Losses 346.720000
1230.000000 Inadvertent Interchange -40.520000
Day-Ahead Load Response Charge
1242.000000 Allocation 17.520000
Real-Time Load Response Charge
1243.000000 Allocation 157.340000
1250.000000 Meter Error Correction -1466.580000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
Dispatch Service - Control Area
1301.000000 Administration 9668.490000
January 28, 2016 Page 28
Page 124
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
1302.000000 Dispatch Service - FTR Administration 0.000000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
1303.000000 Dispatch Service - Market Support 2224.810000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
Dispatch Service - Regulation Market
1304.000000 Administration 85.330000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
Dispatch Service - Capacity
1305.000000 Resource/Obligation Mgmt. 936.820000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
Dispatch Service - Advanced Second
1306.000000 Control Center 839.540000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
1307.000000 Dispatch Service - Market Support Offset -223.600000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
Dispatch Service Refund - Control Area
1308.000000 Administration -62.840000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
1310.000000 Dispatch Service Refund - Market Support -11.780000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
Dispatch Service Refund - Regulation
1311.000000 Market Administration -0.910000
PJM Scheduling, System Control and
Dispatch Service Refund - Capacity
1312.000000 Resource/Obligation Mgmt. -5.270000
1313.000000 PJM Settlement, Inc. 223.600000
1314.000000 Market Monitoring Unit (MMU) Funding 229.520000
1315.000000 FERC Annual Recovery 3828.550000
Organization of PJM States, Inc. (OPSI)
1316.000000 Funding 39.450000
North American Electric Reliability
1317.000000 Corporation (NERC) 674.280000
1318.000000 Reliability First Corporation (RFC) 1097.110000
Transmission Owner Scheduling, System
1320.000000 Control and Dispatch Service 4245.690000
Reactive Supply and Voltage Control from
1330.000000 Generation and Other Sources Service 42490.630000
Regulation and Frequency Response
1340.000000 Service 8602.700000
1360.000000 Synchronized Reserve 6410.050000
1362.000000 Non-Synchronized Reserve 1625.710000
1365.000000 Day-ahead Scheduling Reserve 263.630000
1370.000000 Day-ahead Operating Reserve 3950.770000
1375.000000 Balancing Operating Reserve 1336.620000
Balancing Operating Reserve for Load
1376.000000 Response -0.030000
1378.000000 Reactive Services 1510.160000
1380.000000 Black Start Service 3407.310000
1400.000000 Load Reconciliation for Spot Market Energy 9356.330000
January 28, 2016 Page 29
Page 125
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
Load Reconciliation for Transmission
1410.000000 Congestion -4176.940000
Load Reconciliation for Transmission
1420.000000 Losses -133.140000
Load Reconciliation for Inadvertent
1430.000000 Interchange 0.300000
Load Reconciliation for PJM Scheduling,
1440.000000 System Control and Dispatch Service 42.230000
Load Reconciliation for PJM Scheduling,
System Control and Dispatch Service
1441.000000 Refund -0.260000
Load Reconciliation for Schedule 9-6 -
1442.000000 Advanced Second Control Center 4.720000
Load Reconciliation for Market Monitoring
1444.000000 Unit (MMU) Funding 0.800000
Load Reconciliation for FERC Annual
1445.000000 Recovery 13.700000
Load Reconciliation for Organization of PJM
1446.000000 States, Inc. (OPSI) Funding 0.140000
Load Reconciliation for North American
1447.000000 Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) 2.410000
Load Reconciliation for Reliability First
1448.000000 Corporation (RFC) 3.930000
Load Reconciliation for Transmission Owner
Scheduling, System Control and Dispatch
1450.000000 Service 15.190000
Load Reconciliation for Regulation and
1460.000000 Frequency Response Service 43.910000
Load Reconciliation for Synchronized
1470.000000 Reserve 18.940000
Load Reconciliation for Non-Synchronized
1472.000000 Reserve 3.060000
Load Reconciliation for Day-ahead
1475.000000 Scheduling Reserve 3.490000
Load Reconciliation for Balancing Operating
1478.000000 Reserve 5.710000
1490.000000 Load Reconciliation for Reactive Services 14.640000
1600.000000 RPM Auction 6324.930000
1610.000000 Locational Reliability 904154.060000
1932.000000 Generation Deactivation Refund -499.230000
1250.000000 A Meter Error Correction 11/1/2015 -7.240000
North American Electric Reliability
1317.000000 A Corporation (NERC) 12/1/2015 780.940000
1318.000000 A Reliability First Corporation (RFC) 12/1/2015 1298.130000
1360.000000 A Synchronized Reserve 11/1/2015 -0.310000
1365.000000 A Day-ahead Scheduling Reserve 11/1/2015 0.010000
1370.000000 A Day-ahead Operating Reserve 7/1/2015 7.510000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 12/1/2013 1.280000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 6/1/2015 1.450000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 7/1/2015 0.560000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 9/1/2015 6.730000
January 28, 2016 Page 30
Page 126
Monthly Management Committee Update
December 2015
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 10/1/2015 -110.000000
1375.000000 A Balancing Operating Reserve 11/1/2015 1.220000
Michigan - Ontario Interface Phase Angle
1911.000000 A Regulators 11/1/2015 181.830000
Total Charges 1852808.520000
SOURCE
BILLING
PERIOD
CREDITS ADJ BILLING LINE ITEM NAME START AMOUNT ($)
2100.000000 Network Integration Transmission Service 0.000000
2108.000000 Transmission Enhancement 55113.410000
2130.000000 Firm Point-to-Point Transmission Service 0.000000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point Transmission
2140.000000 Service 619.600000
2210.000000 Transmission Congestion 0.000000
2220.000000 Transmission Losses 14083.320000
Transmission Owner Scheduling, System
2320.000000 Control and Dispatch Service 0.000000
Reactive Supply and Voltage Control from
2330.000000 Generation and Other Sources Service 29467.580000
Regulation and Frequency Response
2340.000000 Service 0.000000
2360.000000 Synchronized Reserve 0.000000
2365.000000 Day-ahead Scheduling Reserve 0.000000
2370.000000 Day-ahead Operating Reserve 0.000000
2375.000000 Balancing Operating Reserve 12497.040000
2380.000000 Black Start Service 0.000000
Load Reconciliation for Transmission
2420.000000 Losses 87.610000
2510.000000 Auction Revenue Rights 76153.980000
2600.000000 RPM Auction 908470.500000
2630.000000 Capacity Transfer Rights 2192.010000
2640.000000 Incremental Capacity Transfer Rights 353.090000
2661.000000 Capacity Resource Deficiency 4741.790000
2666.000000 Load Management Test Failure 3723.840000
Non-Firm Point-to-Point Transmission
2140.000000 A Service 11/1/2015 52.490000
2220.000000 A Transmission Losses 7/1/2015 -1.440000
Total Credits 1107554.820000
Monthly Billing Net Total 745253.700000
Previous Weekly Billing Net Total 668840.700000
Total Due / Receivable 76413.000000
January 28, 2016 Page 31
Page 127
Dover GREEN ENERGY SUMMARY AS OF 1/27/2016 Dover Green Energy Funds
Total Collected Green Energy Funds Ever $ 1,242,664.82 As January 27, 2016 Monthly Deposits and Payments
DEMEC Admin Fee Paid $ 77,460.37 Starting Balance $ 72,677.09
State Annual Admin Fee Total Paid $ 26,675.07 Deposit* $ 29,237.45
Grants Paid $ 535,563.25 Outgoing Payments
Grants/Fees Reserved and Amounts Owed $ 2,536.25 DEMEC Admin Fee* $ 2,923.75
Dover Library Green Building Improvements Cost $ 1,500,000.00 State 2014 Admin Fee $ -
Dover Library Reimbursements paid to Dover to date $ 397,408.32 Grants Paid $ -
Energy Depot Program Costs Paid $ 61,978.16 Energy Depot $ 1,692.13
Efficiency Program Incentives Paid $ 37,268.34 Library Reimbursement $ -
Solar Electric Power Association (SEPA) Dues Paid $ 6,476.41 SEPA Dues $ -
*Total Funds Available $ 97,298.66 Ending Balance $ 97,298.67
Encumbered Funds to Date - Dov. Lib. $98,500 due June 1 $ 90,000.00 *Deposits during this period represent through December 2015
Individual Grant Funds Availble $ 7,298.66
COMPLETED PROJECTS ONLY DNREC FEE OWED
Status Applicant Type Grant Reservation Request Review Fee
COMPLETED PROJECTS ONLY DNREC FEE OWED Michael J Kopp Geo-Res Paid $ 37.50
COMPLETED PROJECTS ONLY DNREC FEE OWED Frank Daniels Geo-Res Paid $ 26.25
Total $ 63.75
RESERVED BUT INCOMPLETE PROJECTS
Status Applicant Type Grant Reservation Request Review Fee
RESERVED BUT INCOMPLETE PROJECTS Lee Herrera Res-Geo $ 2,300.00 $ 172.50
Total $ 2,300.00 $ 172.50
ENERGY DEPOT FEES - (quarterly)
Paid Fee Period Amount
3/3/2008 Start-up Fees $ 5,872.50
4/15/2008 Start-up Fees $ 1,957.50
4/15/2008 Mar, Apr, May 2008 $ 1,692.13
7/22/2008 June, July, Aug 2008 $ 1,692.13
10/10/2008 Sept, Oct, Nov 2008 $ 1,692.13
1/2/2009 Dec 08, Jan, Feb 2009 $ 1,692.13
4/3/2008 Mar, Apr, May 2009 $ 1,692.13
7/1/2009 June, July, Aug 2009 $ 1,692.13
9/11/2009 Sept, Oct, Nov 2009 $ 1,692.13
1/4/2010 Dec 09, Jan, Feb 2010 $ 1,692.13
3/29/2010 Mar, Apr, May 2010 $ 1,692.13
6/30/2010 June, July, Aug 2010 $ 1,692.13
10/4/2010 Sept, Oct, Nov 2010 $ 1,692.13
1/3/2011 Dec 2010, Jan, Feb 2011 $ 1,692.13
4/5/2011 Mar, Apr, May 2011 $ 1,692.13
7/8/2011 June, July, Aug 2011 $ 1,692.13
Page 128
10/4/2011 Sept, Oct, Nov 2011 $ 1,692.13
1/3/2012 Dec 2011; Jan, Feb 2012 $ 1,692.13
4/5/2012 Mar, Apr, May 2012 $ 1,692.13
7/2/2012 June, July, Aug 2012 $ 1,692.13
9/25/2012 Sept, Oct, Nov 2012 $ 1,692.13
11/30/2012 Dec 12, Jan, Feb 2013 $ 1,692.13
2/25/2013 Mar, Apr, May 2013 $ 1,692.13
7/22/2013 June, July, Aug 2013 $ 1,692.13
8/26/2013 Sept, Oct, Nov 2013 $ 1,692.13
12/3/2013 Dec 13. Jan, Feb 2014 $ 1,692.13
3/4/2014 Mar, Apr, May 2014 $ 1,692.13
6/4/2014 June, July, Aug 2014 $ 1,692.13
9/4/2014 Sept, Oct, Nov 2014 $ 1,692.13
12/1/2014 Dec 14, Jan, Feb 2015 $ 1,692.13
3/9/2015 Mar, Apr, May 2014 $ 1,692.13
6/11/2015 June, July, Aug 2015 $ 1,692.13
9/1/2015 Sept, Oct, Nov 2015 $ 1,692.13
12/1/2015 Dec 15. Jan, Feb 2016 $ 1,692.13
Total $ 61,978.16
Solar Energy Professionals Association (SEPA) - (2015 and Forward particpation is through AMP at no additional charge)
Paid Membership Fee Amount
3/19/2012 2012 Annual Membership $ 2,158.81
1/31/2013 2013 Annual Membership $ 2,158.80
1/27/2014 2014 Annual Membership $ 2,158.80
Total $ 6,476.41
Page 129
City of Dover
Electric Revenue Fund
FY16 - White Oak Solar Park Incremental Cost
Original
July August September October November December YTD Budget
Power Supply & Generation
Dover Sun Park - Energy $ 241,720 $ 264,734 $ 204,656 $ 175,542 $ 107,183 $ 74,637 $ 1,068,472 $ 2,313,861
Dover Sun Park - REC's 43,325 42,602 30,249 26,003 15,920 - 158,100 363,381
Total Power Supply Cost 285,046 307,336 234,905 201,546 123,103 74,637 1,226,572 2,677,242
Non-Solar Power Supply Cost (119,924) (123,989) (97,565) (81,616) (48,168) (35,068) (506,330) (720,030)
Incremental Energy Cost $ 165,122 $ 183,347 $ 137,340 $ 119,929 $ 74,935 $ 39,569 $ 720,242 $ 1,957,212
Revenues
Customer Sales - Electricity (8,419) (8,580) (7,472) (7,473) (7,799) (7,621) (47,364) (93,900)
Rent Receipts (15,177) - - (15,177) - - (30,354) (93,700)
Total Revenues (23,596) (8,580) (7,472) (22,650) (7,799) (7,621) (77,718) (187,600)
Incremental Sun Park Cost $ 141,526 $ 174,767 $ 129,868 $ 97,279 $ 67,136 $ 31,948 $ 642,524 $ 1,769,612
MWh Purchased/Generated - Solar 2,084.336 2,100.192 1,525.008 1,308.064 798.680 556.160 8,372.440 18,159.000
MWh $ Solar Energy $ 115.97 $ 126.05 $ 134.20 $ 134.20 $ 134.20 $ 134.20 $ 127.62 $ 127.42
Solar REC's MWh 313.000 315.000 228.000 196.000 120.000 - 1,172.000
MWh $ Solar REC (one month lag)* 138.42 135.24 132.67 132.67 132.67 - 134.90
MWh $ Non-Solar Energy $ 57.54 $ 59.04 $ 63.98 $ 62.39 $ 60.31 $ 63.05
Note: Solar REC's are one month behind due to the time the invoice is received.
Page 130
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2016-01
WITH STAFF AMENDMENT #1 (SA#1)
(Staff Amendment #1 indicated in green text)
1 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL
2 MET:
3 That Chapter 18 - Animals, Section 18-1. - Definitions of the Dover Code be amended by inserting the
4 following definition in its correct alphabetical order:
5 Fowl means any various domestic birds intended for keeping outdoors, by way of example but
6 not limited to: Chickens, roosters, ducks, geese, turkeys, guinea fowl, emus, rheas, ostriches and
7 pigeons.
8 BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
9 That Appendix B - Zoning, Article 3 - District Regulations, Section 1 - One-family residence zones [(R-20,
10 R-15, R-10, R-8 and R-7)], Subsection 1.1 - Uses permitted, Subsection 1.15 - Accessory uses, limited to
11 the following:, paragraph (d) - Keeping domestic animals, of the Dover Code be amended by deleting the
12 text indicated in red strikeout and inserting the bold, blue text, as follows:
13 1.15 Accessory uses, limited to the following:
14 (a) Professional office or studio of an artist, dentist, musician, teacher, or physician, but not
15 including veterinarians, provided that:
16 i. Such office or studio is incidental to the residential use of the premises and is carried on by
17 a resident thereon with not more than one nonresident assistant; and
18 ii. Such office or studio shall occupy not more than 30 percent of the area of one floor of the
19 main building.
20 iii. Studios where dancing or music instruction is offered to groups in excess of four pupils at
21 one time or where concerts or recitals are held are prohibited.
22 iv. Medical centers, barbershops, beauty parlors, real estate offices, funeral homes or similar
23 uses shall not be considered permitted accessory uses.
24 (b) Garden house, tool house, playhouse, greenhouse or pool incidental to the residential use of the
25 premises and not operated for gain.
26 (c) Private garage, provided that, in the case of a one-family dwelling, such garage shall have a
27 capacity of not more than three passenger automobiles. One such space may be leased to a person
28 not [a] resident on the premises.
29 (d) Keeping domestic animals (except pigs and fowl) for individual domestic purposes or as pets.,
30 provided not No more than three dogs over six months old are permitted. Any fowl being
31 kept as of March 15, 2016 must be relocated by March 15, 2017 June 15, 2016. and not
32 more than 25 fowl shall be permitted, and no animals (except dogs) or fowl shall be penned
33 or housed within 20 feet of any lot line.
Page 131
Proposed Ordinance #2016-01 - Appendix B, Article 3, Section 1 Page 2
34 (e) (Reserved.)
35 (f) Dormitories accessory to schools, provided that such dormitories conform to the bulk regulations
36 of the RG-1 zone. For purposes of computing bulk requirements, each four rooms shall be
37 considered one dwelling unit. Parking shall be calculated as identified in Article 6-Off-Street
38 Parking, Section 3-Required off-street parking spaces, Paragraph 3.1-Schedule of requirements.
39 (g) Customary home occupations, provided that:
40 i. No display of products, goods and/or signs shall be visible from the street.
41 ii. Such home occupation shall be incidental and secondary to the residential use of the
42 premises and shall be conducted in the principal building by the resident or residents that
43 reside therein.
44 iii. Nonresident assistants or co-workers shall be prohibited.
45 iv. Such home occupation shall not occupy more than 30 percent of the area of one floor in the
46 principal building.
47 v. There shall be no exterior effect such as noise, traffic, odor, dust, smoke, gas, fumes,
48 radiation, or electromagnetic interference.
49 BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
50 That Appendix B - Zoning, Article 12 - Definitions of the Dover Code be amended by inserting the
51 following definition in its correct alphabetical order:
52 Fowl means any various domestic birds intended for keeping outdoors, by way of example but
53 not limited to: Chickens, roosters, ducks, geese, turkeys, guinea fowl, emus, rheas, ostriches and
54 pigeons.
55 ADOPTED: *
56 S:\ORDINANCES\2016\DRAFT\ORDINANCE #2016-01 APDX B-ZONING, ART 3, SEC 1, SUBSEC 1.15 ACCESSORY USES (FOWL)\Proposed Ordinance #2016-01 with SA#1-Fowl-Reconsideration-LF&A
57 02-09-2016.wpd
58 SYNOPSIS
59 The proposed amendment would disallow the keeping of foul in one-family residence zones.
60 (SPONSORS: HARE, HUTCHISON, AND COLE)
61 Actions History
62 02/09/2016 - Scheduled for Reconsideration - Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
63 01/25/2016 - City Council Referred Back to Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
64 01/11/2016 - Introduced - Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee
Page 132
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: Legislative, Finance & Administration Committee
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Finance DATE SUBMITTED: 01/28/2016
PREPARED BY: Donna Mitchell, Controller/Treasurer
SUBJECT: Proposed Budget Amendment for Fiscal Year 2016
APPROVALS: City Council
EXHIBITS: N/A
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: Total:
AMOUNT BUDGETED: N/A
TIMETABLE: Upon Council approval
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Staff recommends approval of the proposed Budget Amendment for Fiscal Year 2016.
The proposed budget amendment includes the adjustments to the Beginning Budget Balances for all funds
now that the City’s FY15 audit has been completed. It also includes any adjustments related to Council
Actions to date on changes in project budgets or operating items that were not included in the original
budget.
Financial Policy transfers of favorable carry forward balances are as follows –
• The General Fund includes a transfer to the Police Pension Fund of $106,500 and a transfer to the
Civilian Pension Fund of $266,400, for a total of $372,900. The Water/Sewer Fund transfer of
$248,400 to the Pension Fund is also included due to favorable personnel budget variances. A transfer
from the Electric Fund of $408,200 for personnel savings is not included. (See last bullet)
• The General Capital Asset Reserve has been increased by $229,600 due to favorable revenue
variances.
• The Electric Rate Stabilization Reserve has been increased by $394,800 due to favorable power
supply cost.
Additional adjustments are as follows –
• Increases in the following revenue items based on greater than planned receipts Fines & Police
Revenue, Investment Income, Business Licenses, Intrafund Services, Municipal Street Aid, and
Transfer Taxes, totaling $915,300. Water/Wastewater Revenues lowered $102,200 based on current
year to date trends.
• General Fund appropriation of $240,400 for the purchase of New Street properties. The asbestos
removal and demolition cost has been adjusted for in the Inspections budget $56,500.
• Increases to Division budgets for vacation sell-back, retirement payout, and education assistance with
a corresponding decrease to Other Employment Expenses across all applicable funds.
• Increase Police Department for FOP contract settlement $487,400 (covered by higher transfer taxes)
along with $22,000 of expenses related to Police Donations received.
• Transferred 2010 Bond Reserve balance of $2,108,000 to the Electric Improvement & Ext. Fund.
• Adjustments to Pension & OPEB transfers as per the Actuary reports as presented to City Council on
September 10, 2015. The Electric Fund experienced a budget decrease totaling $2,054,800 million
attributed to the Actuary results.
Page 133
FIRST READING
CITY OF DOVER ORDINANCE # 2016-07
2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
1 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
2 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Forty Seven Million Sixty Two Thousand Eight Hundred
3 dollars ($47,062,800) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from
4 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government
5 for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
6 GENERAL FUND
7 CASH RECEIPT SUMMARY FOR 2015-2016
8 2015/16 2015/16
9 BUDGET REVISED
10 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 3,977,500 $ 4,820,400
11 RECEIPTS
12 FINES AND POLICE REVENUE 702,300 724,300
13 INVESTMENT INCOME 35,000 105,200
14 LIBRARY REVENUES 72,000 72,000
15 KENT COUNTY BOOK REIMBURSEMENT 450,000 450,000
16 BUSINESS LICENSES 1,425,000 1,459,000
17 PERMITS AND OTHER FEES 1,436,300 1,436,300
18 MISCELLANEOUS CHARGES 22,700 22,700
19 POLICE EXTRA DUTY 533,000 533,000
20 PROPERTY TAXES 12,844,500 12,844,500
21 BID REVENUE 49,700 49,700
22 RECREATION REVENUE 149,000 149,000
23 FRANCHISE FEE 672,300 672,300
24 SANITATION FEES 2,580,000 2,580,000
25 RENT REVENUE - GARRISON FARM 93,700 93,700
26 COURT OF CHANCERY FEES 1,065,100 1,065,100
27 RECEIPTS SUBTOTAL 22,130,600 22,256,800
28 INTERFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS
29 INTRAFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS W/WW 1,492,700 1,501,800
30 INTRAFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS ELECTRIC 3,738,500 3,763,500
31 INTERFUND SERVICE RECEIPTS SUBTOTAL 5,231,200 5,265,300
32 GRANTS:
33 POLICE RELATED/EXTRA DUTY 74,400 74,400
34 POLICE PENSION GRANT 500,000 500,000
35 GREEN ENERGY GRANT 98,500 98,500
36 MISC GRANT REVENUE 25,000 25,000
37 VERIZON RESERVE 50,000 50,000
38 GRANTS SUBTOTAL 747,900 747,900
39 TRANSFERS FROM:
40 TRANSFER TAX 1,340,000 1,986,100
41 MUNICIPAL STREET AID 564,200 673,100
42 CIVIL TRAFFIC PENALTIES 450,000 450,000
43 WATER/WASTEWATER 850,000 850,000
44 ELECTRIC 10,000,000 10,000,000
45 OTHER RESERVES 13,200 13,200
46 TRANSFERS FROM SUBTOTAL 13,217,400 13,972,400
47 TOTAL REVENUES 41,327,100 42,242,400
48 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCE & REVENUE $ 45,304,600 $ 47,062,800
1
Page 134
FIRST READING
49 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT (CONTINUED)
50 GENERAL FUND - EXPENDITURES AND BUDGET BALANCE FOR 2015-2016
51 2015/16 2015/16
52 DEPARTMENT EXPENSES BUDGET REVISED
53 CITY CLERK $ 383,400 $ 387,200
54 COUNCIL 118,100 118,100
55 TAX ASSESSOR 234,800 238,200
56 FIRE 745,400 745,400
57 GROUNDS MAINTENANCE 1,210,300 1,212,000
58 LIBRARY 1,510,000 1,516,000
59 RECREATION 729,500 735,700
60 LIFE SAFETY 482,200 483,000
61 CODE ENFORCEMENT 419,400 421,800
62 PLANNING 534,000 539,800
63 INSPECTIONS 664,700 724,400
64 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 238,000 238,000
65 POLICE 15,159,000 15,882,400
66 POLICE EXTRA DUTY 602,400 602,400
67 STREETS 674,500 675,400
68 SANITATION 2,157,900 2,176,600
69 CITY MANAGER 750,300 756,800
70 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 704,800 711,900
71 FINANCE 978,500 989,100
72 PUBLIC WORKS - ADMINISTRATION 626,800 630,000
73 FACILITIES MANAGEMENT 707,500 719,700
74 PUBLIC WORKS - ENGINEERING 181,400 181,400
75 PROCUREMENT & INVENTORY 560,200 565,000
76 FLEET MAINTENANCE 768,500 768,500
77 CUSTOMER SERVICE 1,120,100 1,136,800
78 HUMAN RESOURCES 383,900 390,700
79 MAYOR 76,100 76,100
80 DEPARTMENT SUBTOTALS 32,721,700 33,622,400
81 OTHER EXPENSES
82 DEBT SERVICE 660,800 669,400
83 CONTRIBUTION TO DDP 70,000 70,000
84 MISCELLANEOUS GRANT RELATED EXP 25,000 25,000
85 INSURANCE 690,000 690,000
86 RETIREES HEALTH CARE 1,895,600 1,567,700
87 OTHER EMPLOYMENT EXPENSES 520,100 197,200
88 BANK & CREDIT CARD FEES 15,000 17,400
89 UNCOLLECTIBLES - TRASH AND OTHER 50,000 50,000
90 STREET LIGHTS 797,700 797,700
91 NEW STREET PROPERTIES ACQUISITIONS - 240,400
92 OTHER EXPENSE SUBTOTAL 4,724,200 4,324,800
93 TRANSFERS
94 TRANSFER TO CAPITAL FUND - PROJECTS 2,625,400 2,625,400
95 TRANSFER TO CAPITAL ASSET RESERVE - 229,600
96 APPROP. TO THE GENERAL EMPLOYEE PENSION FUND - 594,300
97 APPROP. TO THE POLICE PENSION FUND 570,000 676,500
98 APPROP. POLICE PENSION - STATE GRANT 500,000 500,000
99 TRANSFER TO VERIZON RESERVE 50,000 50,000
100 TRANSFER TO INVENTORY WRITE-OFFS 10,000 10,000
101 TRANSFERS SUBTOTAL 3,755,400 4,685,800
102 TOTAL EXPENDITURES 41,201,300 42,633,000
103 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 4,103,300 4,429,800
104 TOTALS $ 45,304,600 $ 47,062,800
105 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
106 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
107 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
108 ADOPTED:
2
Page 135
FIRST READING
109 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
110 GOVERNMENTAL CAPITAL PROJECTS FUND
111 REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
112
113 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
114 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Five Million Six Hundred Eighty Nine Thousand Five Hundred dollars
115 ($5,689,500)or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other
116 funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015
117 and ending June 30, 2016:
118 REVENUES
119 2015/16 2015/16
120 BUDGET REVISED
121 BEGINNING BALANCE - PROJECTS $ 154,800 $ 2,926,700
122 REVENUES
123 INCOME FROM SALE OF ASSETS 20,300 51,900
124 GRANT RECEIPTS - 80,500
125 INTEREST EARNINGS 5,000 5,000
126 TRANSFER FROM GENERAL FUND 2,625,400 2,625,400
127 SUBTOTAL PROJECT RECEIPTS 2,650,700 2,762,800
128 TOTAL FUNDING SOURCES 2,650,700 2,762,800
129 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCE AND REVENUES $ 2,805,500 $ 5,689,500
130 EXPENSE SUMMARY
131 2015/16 2015/16
132 EXPENDITURES BUDGET REVISED
133 FIRE $ 145,600 $ 445,800
134 GROUNDS MAINTENANCE 201,100 188,800
135 LIFE SAFETY 55,700 55,700
136 POLICE 262,100 302,700
137 RECREATION - 73,900
138 STREETS 1,428,500 3,656,700
139 SANITATION 449,000 449,000
140 CITY MANAGER 24,700 24,700
141 FLEET MAINTENANCE 84,000 84,500
142 BANK FEES - 1,300
143 DEPARTMENT SUBTOTAL 2,650,700 5,283,100
144 TOTAL EXPENDITURES 2,650,700 5,283,100
145 BUDGET BALANCE 154,800 406,400
146 TOTAL BUDGET BALANCE & EXPENDITURES $ 2,805,500 $ 5,689,500
147 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
148 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
149 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
150 ADOPTED:
3
Page 136
FIRST READING
151 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
152 GENERAL FUND CONTINGENCY
153 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
154 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
155 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seven Hundred Twenty One Thousand Four Hundred dollars
156 ($721,400) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
157 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
158 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
159 CASH RECEIPTS
160 2015/16 2015/16
161 BUDGET REVISED
162 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 719,200 $ 720,300
163 INTEREST EARNED 1,100 1,100
164 TOTALS $ 720,300 $ 721,400
165 EXPENSE SUMMARY
166 2015/16 2015/16
167 BUDGET REVISED
168 CARRY FORWARD TO NEXT YEAR 720,300 721,400
169 TOTALS $ 720,300 $ 721,400
170 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
171 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
172 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
173 ADOPTED:
4
Page 137
FIRST READING
174 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
175 GENERAL CAPITAL ASSET RESERVE
176 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
177 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
178 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Million One Hundred Forty Seven Thousand Two Hundred
179 dollars ($1,147,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
180 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal
181 year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
182 CASH RECEIPTS
183 2015/16 2015/16
184 BUDGET REVISED
185 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 914,000 $ 915,100
186 RECEIPTS
187 INTEREST EARNINGS 2,500 2,500
188 TRANSFER FROM GENERAL FUND - 229,600
189 TOTAL RECEIPTS 2,500 232,100
190 TOTALS $ 916,500 $ 1,147,200
191 EXPENSE SUMMARY
192 2015/16 2015/16
193 BUDGET REVISED
194 CARRY FORWARD TO NEXT YEAR $ 916,500 $ 1,147,200
195 TOTALS $ 916,500 $ 1,147,200
196 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
197 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
198 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
199 ADOPTED:
5
Page 138
FIRST READING
200 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
201 PARKLAND/RECREATION RESERVE
202 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
203 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
204 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Three Hundred Twenty One Thousand Eight Hundred Dollars
205 ($321,800) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and
206 other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
207 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
208 OPERATING REVENUES
209 2015/16 2015/16
210 BUDGET REVISED
211 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE $ 295,700 $ 320,800
212 INTEREST INCOME 1,000 1,000
213 TOTALS $ 296,700 $ 321,800
214 OPERATING EXPENSES
215 2015/16 2015/16
216 BUDGET REVISED
217 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 296,700 321,800
218 TOTALS $ 296,700 $ 321,800
219 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
220 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
221 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
222 ADOPTED:
6
Page 139
FIRST READING
223 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
224 WATER/WASTEWATER FUND
225 REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
226 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
227 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seventeen Million Eighty Eight Thousand One Hundred
228 dollars ($17,088,100) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
229 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
230 fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
231 2015/16 2015/16
232 BUDGET REVISED
233 BEGINNING BALANCE - WATER $ 861,600 $ 1,305,700
234 BEGINNING BALANCE - WASTEWATER 293,400 156,900
235 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES 1,155,000 1,462,600
236 BASE REVENUE
237 WATER SERVICES 6,200,000 5,676,000
238 WASTEWATER SERVICES 3,728,000 3,944,000
239 WASTEWATER TREATMENT SERVICES 3,026,500 3,108,000
240 GROUNDWATER INFLOW ADJUSTMENT 1,864,300 1,988,600
241 WATER TANK SPACE LEASING 341,900 341,900
242 SEWER IMPACT FEES 250,000 250,000
243 WATER IMPACT FEES 250,000 250,000
244 INTEREST - WATER 1,000 1,000
245 INTEREST - WASTEWATER 2,000 2,000
246 MISCELLANEOUS SERVICE FEE 64,000 64,000
247 TOTAL REVENUES 15,727,700 15,625,500
248 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES AND REVENUES $ 16,882,700 $ 17,088,100
7
Page 140
FIRST READING
249 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
250 WATER/WASTEWATER FUND - EXPENSES AND BUDGET BALANCE FOR 2015-2016
251 2015/16 2015/16
252 DIRECT EXPENSES BUDGET REVISED
253 ENGINEERING & INSPECTION $ 517,500 $ 521,500
254 WATER DEPARTMENT 673,300 678,100
255 WATER TREATMENT PLANT 1,910,000 1,918,100
256 WASTEWATER DEPARTMENT 968,600 968,600
257 DIRECT EXPENDITURE SUBTOTAL 4,069,400 4,086,300
258 OTHER EXPENSES
259 DEBT SERVICE - WATER 545,200 521,100
260 DEBT SERVICE - WASTEWATER 586,900 611,300
261 RETIREES HEALTH CARE 178,600 60,200
262 OTHER EMPLOYMENT EXPENSES 20,000 3,100
263 KENT COUNTY TREATMENT CHARGE 4,130,000 4,130,000
264 INTRAFUND SERVICE FEES 1,492,700 1,501,800
265 BANK & CREDIT CARD FEES 46,200 46,200
266 OTHER EXPENSES SUBTOTAL 6,999,600 6,873,700
267 TRANSFER TO:
268 GENERAL FUND FROM WATER 550,000 550,000
269 GENERAL FUND FROM WASTEWATER 300,000 300,000
270 WATER IMP AND EXT 1,800,000 1,800,000
271 WASTEWATER IMP AND EXT 1,500,000 1,500,000
272 CONTINGENCY RESERVE WATER 32,000 32,000
273 TRANSFER TO THE GENERAL EMPLOYEES PENSION FUND - 248,400
274 TRANSFER TO SUBTOTAL 4,182,000 4,430,400
275 TOTAL EXPENSES 15,251,000 15,390,400
276 BUDGET BALANCES
277 BUDGET BALANCE WATER 1,048,600 916,800
278 BUDGET BALANCE WASTEWATER 583,100 780,900
279 BUDGET BALANCE SUBTOTALS 1,631,700 1,697,700
280 TOTAL CURRENT YEAR BALANCES AND EXPENSES $ 16,882,700 $ 17,088,100
281 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
282 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
283 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
284 ADOPTED:
8
Page 141
FIRST READING
285 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
286 WATER/WASTEWATER IMPROVEMENT & EXTENSION FUND
287 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
288 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
289 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Thirteen Million One Hundred Fifty Eight Thousand Six Hundred
290 dollars ($13,158,600) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
291 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
292 begining July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
293 CASH RECEIPTS
294 2015/16 2015/16
295 BUDGET REVISED
296 BEGINNING BALANCE - WATER $ 833,500 $ 4,990,300
297 BEGINNING BALANCE - WASTEWATER 1,027,600 4,551,700
298 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES 1,861,100 9,542,000
299 REVENUES
300 TRANS FR OPERATING FUND - WATER 1,800,000 1,800,000
301 TRANS FR OPERATING FUND - WASTEWATER 1,500,000 1,500,000
302 TRANSFER FR WASTEWATER IMPACT FEE 165,000 165,000
303 INTEREST INCOME 25,000 69,900
304 GRANT RECEIPTS - 20,300
305 MISCELLANEOUS RECEIPTS - 61,400
306 TOTAL REVENUES 3,490,000 3,616,600
307 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES & REVENUES $ 5,351,100 $ 13,158,600
308 EXPENSE SUMMARY
309 2015/16 2015/16
310 EXPENSES BUDGET REVISED
311 WATER $ 2,028,600 $ 5,442,600
312 WASTEWATER 1,822,100 5,299,100
313 WATER TREATMENT PLANT - 284,400
315 BANK FEES - 7,500
314 TOTAL EXPENSES 3,850,700 11,033,600
315 BUDGET BALANCE - WATER 617,400 1,176,200
316 BUDGET BALANCE - WASTEWATER 883,000 948,800
317 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS 1,500,400 2,125,000
318 TOTAL BUDGET BALANCES & EXPENSES $ 5,351,100 $ 13,158,600
319 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
320 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
321 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
322 ADOPTED:
9
Page 142
FIRST READING
323 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
324 WATER/WASTEWATER CAPITAL ASSET RESERVE
325 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
326 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
327 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Million Twenty Eight Thousand dollars ($1,028,000)
328 or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and
329 other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
330 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
331 CASH RECEIPTS
332 2015/16 2015/16
333 BUDGET REVISED
334 BEGINNING BALANCE - WATER $ 514,600 $ 510,700
335 BEGINNING BALANCE - WASTEWATER 511,300 509,500
336 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES 1,025,900 1,020,200
337 RECEIPTS
338 INTEREST EARNINGS - WATER 3,900 3,900
339 INTEREST EARNINGS - WASTEWATER 3,900 3,900
340 TOTAL RECEIPTS 7,800 7,800
341 TOTALS $ 1,033,700 $ 1,028,000
342 EXPENSE SUMMARY
343 2015/16 2015/16
344 BUDGET REVISED
345 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WATER $ 518,500 $ 514,600
346 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WASTEWATER 515,200 513,400
347 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS 1,033,700 1,028,000
348 TOTALS $ 1,033,700 $ 1,028,000
349 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
350 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
351 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
352 ADOPTED:
10
Page 143
FIRST READING
353 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
354 WATER/WASTEWATER IMPACT FEE RESERVE
355 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
356 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
357 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Two Million One Hundred Eighty Two Thousand Eight
358 Hundred dollars ($2,182,800) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from
359 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government
360 for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
361 CASH RECEIPTS
362 2015/16 2015/16
363 BUDGET REVISED
364 BEGINNING BALANCE - WATER $ 200,500 $ 427,500
365 BEGINNING BALANCE - WASTEWATER 1,463,400 1,742,700
366 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES 1,663,900 2,170,200
367 RECEIPTS
368 INTEREST EARNINGS - WATER 1,500 1,500
369 INTEREST EARNINGS - WASTEWATER 11,100 11,100
370 TOTAL RECEIPTS 12,600 12,600
371 TOTALS $ 1,676,500 $ 2,182,800
372 EXPENSE SUMMARY
373 2015/16 2015/16
374 BUDGET REVISED
375 TRANSFER TO I & E FUND FROM WASTEWATER IMPACT FEES $ 165,000 $ 165,000
375 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WATER 202,000 429,000
376 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WASTEWATER 1,309,500 1,588,800
377 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS 1,511,500 2,017,800
378 TOTALS $ 1,676,500 $ 2,182,800
379 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
380 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
381 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
382 ADOPTED:
11
Page 144
FIRST READING
383 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
384 WATER/WASTEWATER CONTINGENCY RESERVE
385 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
386 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
387 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Three Hundred Twenty Nine Thousand Six Hundred dollars
388 ($329,600) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
389 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
390 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
391 CASH RECEIPTS
392 2015/16 2015/16
393 BUDGET REVISED
394 BEGINNING BALANCE - WATER $ 104,900 $ 105,200
395 BEGINNING BALANCE - WASTEWATER 189,700 190,200
396 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCES 294,600 295,400
397 RECEIPTS
398 INTEREST EARNINGS 2,200 2,200
399 TRANSFER FROM OPERATING ACCOUNT TO WATER 32,000 32,000
400 TOTAL RECEIPTS 34,200 34,200
401 TOTALS $ 328,800 $ 329,600
402 BUDGET SUMMARY
403 2015/16 2015/16
404 BUDGET REVISED
405 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WATER 137,700 138,300
406 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE - WASTEWATER 191,100 191,300
407 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE SUBTOTALS 328,800 329,600
408 TOTAL EXPENSES AND CURRENT YEAR BALANCES $ 328,800 $ 329,600
409 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
410 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
411 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
412 ADOPTED:
12
Page 145
FIRST READING
413 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
414 ELECTRIC REVENUE FUND
415 REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
416 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
417 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Ninety One Million Six Hundred Fifty Three Thousand Two
418 hundred dollars ($91,653,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from
419 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government
420 for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
421 2015/16 2015/16
422 BUDGET REVISED
423 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 6,177,600 $ 8,117,200
424 BASE REVENUE
425 DIRECT SALES TO CUSTOMER 78,279,200 78,279,200
426 UTILITY TAX 1,281,100 1,281,100
427 MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE 597,200 597,200
428 RENT REVENUE 202,600 202,600
429 GREEN ENERGY 128,000 128,000
430 INTEREST EARNINGS 47,900 47,900
431 TRANSFER FROM RATE STABILIZATION 3,000,000 3,000,000
432 TOTAL REVENUES 83,536,000 83,536,000
433 TOTAL BEGINNING BALANCE & REVENUES 89,713,600 91,653,200
13
Page 146
FIRST READING
434 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
435 ELECTRIC REVENUE FUND EXPENSES AND BUDGET BALANCE FOR 2015-2016
436 2015/16 2015/16
437 EXPENSES BUDGET REVISED
438 POWER SUPPLY $ 23,402,600 $ 23,402,600
439 SOLAR ENERGY 2,313,900 2,313,900
440 SOLAR RENEWAL ENERGY CREDITS 363,400 363,400
441 POWER SUPPLY MANAGEMENT 996,000 996,000
442 REC'S (Renewable Energy Credits) 673,400 673,400
443 RGGI (Regional Greenhouse Gas Init.) 175,000 175,000
444 PJM CHARGES - ENERGY 7,966,100 7,966,100
445 PJM CHARGES - TRANSMISSION & FEES 7,932,500 7,932,500
446 CAPACITY CHARGES 10,225,100 10,225,100
447 SUB-TOTAL POWER SUPPLY 54,048,000 54,048,000
448 PLANT OPERATIONS 6,434,600 6,382,900
449 GENERATIONS FUELS 1,167,300 1,167,300
450 PJM SPOT MARKET ENERGY (1,708,300) (1,708,300)
451 PJM CREDITS (360,000) (360,000)
452 CAPACITY CREDITS (10,472,100) (10,472,100)
453 GENERATION SUBTOTAL (4,938,500) (4,990,200)
454 POWER SUPPLY & GENERATION SUBTOTAL 49,109,500 49,057,800
455 DIRECT EXPENDITURES
456 TRANSMISSION/DISTRIBUTION 4,068,600 3,705,300
457 ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING 1,335,800 1,279,300
458 ADMINISTRATION 839,300 877,200
459 METER READING 360,500 334,200
460 SYSTEMS OPERATIONS 679,800 626,700
461 DIRECT EXPENDITURE SUBTOTALS 7,284,000 6,822,700
462 OTHER EXPENSES:
463 UTILITY TAX 1,281,100 1,281,100
464 ALLOW FOR UNCOLLECTIBLES 200,000 200,000
465 RETIREES HEALTH CARE 537,800 57,700
466 OTHER EMPLOYMENT EXPENSES 72,000 40,300
467 OPEB UNFUNDED LIABILITY 1,030,000 -
468 GREEN ENERGY PAYMENT TO DEMEC 128,000 128,000
469 INTRAFUND SERVICE FEES 3,738,500 3,763,500
470 INTEREST ON DEPOSITS 20,500 20,500
471 BANK & CREDIT CARD FEES 242,300 274,000
472 DEBT SERVICE 3,402,000 3,342,800
473 OTHER EXPENSES SUBTOTAL 10,652,200 9,107,900
474 TRANSFER TO:
475 IMPROVEMENT & EXTENSION 3,500,000 3,500,000
476 GENERAL FUND 10,000,000 10,000,000
477 TRANSFER INSURANCE RESERVE 10,000 10,000
478 TRANSFER CONTINGENCY RESERVE 13,000 13,000
479 TRANSFER RATE STABILIZATION RESERVE - 394,800
480 TRANSFER TO SUBTOTAL 13,523,000 13,917,800
481 TOTAL EXPENSES 80,568,700 78,906,200
482 BUDGET BALANCE - WORKING CAPITAL 9,144,900 12,747,000
483 TOTALS $ 89,713,600 $ 91,653,200
484 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
485 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
486 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
487 ADOPTED:
14
Page 147
FIRST READING
488 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
489 ELECTRIC UTILITY IMPROVEMENT AND EXTENSION FUND
490 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
491 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
492 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Fourteen Million Six Hundred Sixty One Thousand Two Hundred
493 dollars ($14,661,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
494 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
495 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
496 REVENUES
497 2015/16 2015/16
498 BUDGET REVISED
499 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 3,623,600 $ 7,095,300
500 REVENUES
501 TRANSFER FROM ELECTRIC 3,500,000 3,500,000
502 TRANSFER FROM 2010 BOND RESERVE - 2,108,000
503 GENERAL SERVICE BILLING 1,900,000 1,900,000
504 INTEREST EARNINGS 26,700 57,900
505 TOTAL REVENUES 5,426,700 7,565,900
506 TOTALS $ 9,050,300 $ 14,661,200
507 EXPENSE SUMMARY
508 2015/16 2015/16
509 EXPENSES BUDGET REVISED
510 ELECTRIC GENERATION $ 1,655,000 $ 2,299,800
511 TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION 2,887,600 3,602,900
512 ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING 1,724,300 3,401,700
513 METER READING - 23,000
514 BANK FEES - 22,300
515 TOTAL EXPENSES 6,266,900 9,349,700
516 BUDGET BALANCE 2,783,400 5,311,500
517 TOTAL BUDGET BALANCE & EXPENSES $ 9,050,300 $ 14,661,200
518 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
519 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
520 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
15
Page 148
FIRST READING
522 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
523 ELECTRIC UTILITY CONTINGENCY RESERVE
524 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
525 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
526 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Eight Hundred Fourty Two Thousand dollars ($842,000)
527 or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and other
528 funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
529 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
530 CASH RECEIPTS
531 2015/16 2015/16
532 BUDGET REVISED
533 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 825,300 $ 822,700
534 RECEIPTS
535 INTEREST EARNINGS 6,300 6,300
536 TRANSFER FROM ELECTRIC FUND 13,000 13,000
537 TOTAL RECEIPTS 19,300 19,300
538 TOTALS $ 844,600 $ 842,000
539 EXPENSE SUMMARY
540 2015/16 2015/16
541 BUDGET REVISED
541 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 844,600 842,000
542 TOTALS $ 844,600 $ 842,000
543 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
544 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
545 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
546 ADOPTED:
16
Page 149
FIRST READING
547 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
548 ELECTRIC UTILITY DEPRECIATION RESERVE
549 SOURCES AND USE OF FUNDS FOR 2015-2016
550 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
551 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Ten Million Thirty Three Thousand Eight Hundred dollars
552 dollars ($10,033,800) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
553 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
554 fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
555 CASH RECEIPTS
556 2015/16 2015/16
557 BUDGET REVISED
558 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 9,990,500 $ 9,957,900
559 INTEREST EARNINGS 75,900 75,900
560 TOTALS $ 10,066,400 $ 10,033,800
561 BUDGET SUMMARY
562 2015/16 2015/16
563 BUDGET REVISED
564 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 10,066,400 10,033,800
565 TOTALS $ 10,066,400 $ 10,033,800
566 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
567 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
568 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
569 ADOPTED:
17
Page 150
FIRST READING
570 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
571 ELECTRIC UTILITY FUTURE CAPACITY RESERVE
572 SOURCES AND USE OF FUNDS FOR 2015-2016
573 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
574 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Ten Million One Hundred Eighty Five Thousand dollars
575 ($10,185,000) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
576 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
577 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
578 CASH RECEIPTS
579 2015/16 2015/16
580 BUDGET REVISED
581 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 10,140,900 $ 10,107,900
582 INTEREST EARNINGS 77,100 77,100
583 TOTALS $ 10,218,000 $ 10,185,000
584 BUDGET SUMMARY
585 2015/16 2015/16
586 BUDGET REVISED
587 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 10,218,000 10,185,000
588 TOTALS $ 10,218,000 $ 10,185,000
589 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
590 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
591 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
592 ADOPTED:
18
Page 151
FIRST READING
593 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
594 ELECTRIC UTILITY INSURANCE STABLIZATION RESERVE
595 SOURCES AND USE OF FUNDS FOR 2015-2016
596 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
597 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seven Hundred Fifty Six Thousand Two Hundred dollars
598 ($756,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
599 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
600 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
601 CASH RECEIPTS
602 2015/16 2015/16
603 BUDGET REVISED
604 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 743,100 $ 740,600
605 INTEREST EARNINGS 5,600 5,600
606 TRANSFER FROM ELECTRIC FUND 10,000 10,000
607 TOTALS $ 758,700 $ 756,200
608 BUDGET SUMMARY
609 2015/16 2015/16
610 BUDGET REVISED
611 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 758,700 756,200
612 TOTALS $ 758,700 $ 756,200
613 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
614 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
615 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
616 ADOPTED:
19
Page 152
FIRST READING
617 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
618 ELECTRIC UTILITY RATE STABLIZATION RESERVE
619 SOURCES AND USE OF FUNDS FOR 2015-2016
620 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
621 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seven Million Nine Hundred Fifty Seven Thousand Five
622 Hundred dollars ($7,957,500) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from
623 current revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government
624 for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
625 CASH RECEIPTS
626 2015/16 2015/16
627 BUDGET REVISED
628 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 7,545,300 $ 7,505,400
629 INTEREST EARNINGS 57,300 57,300
630 TRANSFER FROM ELECTRIC OPERATING FUND - 394,800
631 TOTALS $ 7,602,600 $ 7,957,500
632 BUDGET SUMMARY
633 2015/16 2015/16
634 BUDGET REVISED
635 TRANSFER TO ELECTRIC FUND $ 3,000,000 $ 3,000,000
636 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 4,602,600 4,957,500
637 TOTALS $ 7,602,600 $ 7,957,500
638 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
639 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
640 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
641 ADOPTED:
20
Page 153
FINAL READING
642 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
643 MUNICIPAL STREET AID FUND
644 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
645 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
646 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Six Hundred Seventy Three Thousand Two Hundred
647 dollars ($673,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
648 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
649 fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
650 CASH RECEIPTS
651 2015/16 2015/16
652 BUDGET REVISED
653 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 100 $ 100
654 STATE GRANT 564,200 673,100
655 TOTALS 564,300 673,200
656 BUDGET SUMMARY
657 2015/16 2015/16
658 BUDGET REVISED
659 TRANSFER TO GENERAL FUND 564,200 673,100
660 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 100 100
661 TOTALS $ 564,300 $ 673,200
662 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
663 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
664 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
665 ADOPTED:
21
Page 154
FIRST READING
666 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
667 WORKERS COMPENSATION FUND
668 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
669 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
670 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Million Nine Hundred One Thousand Three Hundred
671 dollars ($1,901,300) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current
672 revenues and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the
673 fiscal year beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
674 OPERATING REVENUES
675 2015/16 2015/16
676 BUDGET REVISED
677 BEGINNING BALANCE $ 1,052,600 $ 1,248,200
678 INTEREST INCOME 10,600 10,600
679 PREMIUM FROM CITY 642,500 642,500
680 TOTALS $ 1,705,700 $ 1,901,300
681 OPERATING EXPENSES
682 2015/16 2015/16
683 BUDGET REVISED
684 PROGRAM EXPENSES/SUPPLIES - CLAIMS $ 475,000 $ 475,000
685 INSURANCE 103,900 103,900
686 BANK FEES 1,300 1,300
687 STATE OF DEL - SELF INSURANCE TAX 37,000 37,000
688 CONTRACTUAL SERVICES 25,000 25,000
689 TOTAL EXPENSES 642,200 642,200
690 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 1,063,500 1,259,100
691 TOTALS $ 1,705,700 $ 1,901,300
692 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
693 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
694 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
695 ADOPTED:
22
Page 155
FIRST READING
696 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
697 COMMUNITY TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT FUND
698 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
699 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
700 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Seven Hundred Forty Seven Thousand Two Hundred dollars
701 ($747,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues and
702 other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
703 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
704 OPERATING REVENUES
705 2015/16 2015/16
706 BUDGET REVISED
707 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE $ 144,000 $ 57,800
708 GRANTS REVENUE 500,000 688,900
709 INTEREST INCOME 500 500
710 TOTALS $ 644,500 $ 747,200
711 OPERATING EXPENSES
712 2015/16 2015/16
713 BUDGET REVISED
714 PROGRAM EXP. GRANT RELATED $ 644,000 $ 655,100
715 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 500 92,100
716 TOTALS $ 644,500 $ 747,200
717 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
718 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
719 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
720 ADOPTED:
23
Page 156
FIRST READING
721 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
722 LIBRARY GRANT FUND
723 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
724 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
725 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Three Hundred Thirty Eight Thousand Six Hundred dollars
726 ($338,600) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
727 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
728 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
729 OPERATING REVENUES
730 2015/16 2015/16
731 BUDGET REVISED
732 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE $ 17,300 $ 30,600
733 STATE GRANT 278,900 305,500
734 FEDERAL GRANT 2,500 2,500
735 TOTALS $ 298,700 $ 338,600
736 OPERATING EXPENSES
737 2015/16 2015/16
738 BUDGET REVISED
739 STATE GRANTS
740 FURNITURE/FIXTURES $ 3,100 $ 7,000
741 OFFICE SUPPLIES 24,000 30,800
742 PRINTING AND DUPLICATING 13,200 12,500
743 PROGRAM EXPENSES/SUPPLIES 24,100 27,500
744 BOOKS 129,200 133,300
745 AUDIO VISUAL SUPPLIES 75,100 77,200
746 POSTAGE 100 100
747 TRAINING/CONF/FOOD/TRAV 2,000 8,800
748 CONTRACTUAL SERVICES 900 -
749 OFF EQP/REPAIRS & MAINT 6,000 6,300
750 OTHER EQUIP - LEASE 1,200 2,000
751 SUBTOTAL EXPENSES STATE GRANTS 278,900 305,500
752 FEDERAL GRANTS
753 PROGRAM EXPENSES/SUPPLIES 2,500 2,500
754 SUBTOTAL EXPENSES FEDERAL GRANTS 2,500 2,500
755 GRAND TOTAL EXPENSES 281,400 308,000
756 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 17,300 30,600
757 TOTALS $ 298,700 $ 338,600
758 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
759 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
760 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
761 ADOPTED:
24
Page 157
FIRST READING
762 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
763 POLICE GRANTS FUND
764 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
765 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
766 The amount hereinafter named aggregating Six Hundred Eighty Two Thousand Two Hundred dollars
767 ($682,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
768 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
769 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
770 OPERATING REVENUES
771 2015/16 2015/16
772 BUDGET REVISED
773 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE $ 125,000 $ 154,900
774 STATE AND FEDERAL GRANTS RECEIVED 527,300 527,300
775 TOTALS 652,300 682,200
776 OPERATING EXPENSES
777 2015/16 2015/16
778 BUDGET REVISED
779 EXPENDITURES
780 PERSONNEL EXPENDITURES
781 CADET PROGRAM SALARIES 71,400 71,400
782 CADET PROGRAM FICA 5,400 5,400
783 CADET PROGRAM W/COMP 3,500 3,500
784 MATERIALS AND SUPPLIES
785 POLICE EQUIPT & PROG SUPP 410,600 379,600
786 TECHNOLOGY EQUIPMENT 20,000 20,000
787 ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENDITURES
788 CELL PHONE CHARGES 15,000 15,000
789 TRAINING 17,000 45,000
790 AUDIT FEES 1,000 1,000
791 CONTRACTUAL SERVICES - 3,000
792 TOTAL EXPENDITURES 543,900 543,900
793 OTHER FINANCING USES
794 OPERATING TRANSFERS-OUT 74,400 74,400
795 TOTAL FINANCING USES 74,400 74,400
796 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 34,000 63,900
797 TOTALS $ 652,300 $ 682,200
798 The above budget represents the combination of all State & Federal Grants.
799 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
800 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
801 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
802 ADOPTED:
25
Page 158
FIRST READING
803 2015-2016 BUDGET ORDINANCES - SECOND AMENDMENT
804 SUBSTANCE ABUSE GRANTS FUND
805 CASH RECEIPTS/REVENUES AND BUDGET FOR 2015-2016
806 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
807 The amount hereinafter named aggregating One Hundred Fifty Nine Thousand Two Hundred dollars
808 ($159,200) or so much thereof as may be necessary are hereby appropriated from current revenues
809 and other funds for the use by several departments of the Municipal Government for the fiscal year
810 beginning July 1, 2015 and ending June 30, 2016:
811 OPERATING REVENUES
812 2015/16 2015/16
813 BUDGET REVISED
814 PRIOR YEAR BALANCE $ 41,000 $ 98,200
815 STATE GRANTS RECEIVED 55,700 28,000
816 RECREATION REVENUE 33,000 33,000
816 TOTALS 129,700 159,200
817 OPERATING EXPENSES
818 2015/16 2015/16
819 BUDGET REVISED
820 EXPENDITURES
821 TEMPORARY HELP/BENEFITS 71,400 71,400
822 PROGRAM EXPENSES/SUPPLIES 5,400 5,400
823 TOTAL EXPENDITURES 76,800 76,800
824 CURRENT YEAR BALANCE 52,900 82,400
825 TOTALS $ 129,700 $ 159,200
826 The above budget represents the combination of all State & Federal Grants.
827 The City Manager is hereby authorized, without further approval of the City Council, to make
828 interdepartmental transfers of up to five percent of the amount hereinafter appropriated to any
829 department with the exception of any transfers prohibited by City Procedure #F306.
830 ADOPTED:
26
Page 159
YOUR PARTNER
Presentation to the Dover City Council
February 9, 2016 1
Page 160
Introductions
SB & Company, LLC
William Seymour, Audit Partner
Gray Smith, Concurring Partner
Sisilia Mo, Engagement Manager
2
Page 161
Scope of Services
Audit of June 30, 2015, financial statements
Review of the Comprehensive Annual Financial Report
Available for year-round consultation
3
Page 162
Summary of the Results
• Issued an unmodified opinion on the financial statements
• Discovered no instances of fraud
• Discovered no material weakness in internal controls
• Received full cooperation from management
• Results
2015 * 2014 2013
Increase (Decrease) in
Net Position $ 9.303 $ (1,686) $ 10,335
Net Position $ 191,144 $ 218,102 $ 219.788
• No material audit journal entries purposed or made
*- beginning balance was restated by $36,261,000 as a result of
implementation of GASB 68
• GASB 74/75- Accounting for OPEB, will required an additional liability to be
recorded. Current calculation is approximately $32.5 million
4
Page 164
FORCAM Audit Approach
“Focus on Risk, Controls and Misstatement”
6
Page 165
Significant Risk Areas
Significant Risk Areas
Cash reconciliations
Investment valuation
Collectability of accounts and grants receivable
Accounts payable
Revenue recognition
Deferred revenue
Actuarial assumptions
7
Page 166
Assessment of Control
Environment
Area Points to Consider Our Assessment
Key executive integrity, ethics and behavior
Control consciousness and operating style
Commitment to competence
Control
Exercise oversight responsibility
Environment
Organizational structure, responsibility, and authority
Enforce accountability
HR policies and procedures
Define objectives and risk tolerances
Identify, analyze, and respond to risk Not effective
Assess fraud risk
Risk Assessment Identify, analyze, and respond to change Suggested
improvements
Mechanisms to anticipate, identify, and react to significant events
Processes and procedures to identify changes in GAAP, business Effective
practices, and internal control
Design control activities
Design activities for the information system
Implement control activities
Existence of necessary policies and procedures
Clear financial objectives with active monitoring
Control Activities
Logical segregation of duties
Periodic comparisons of book-to-actual and physical count-to-
books
Adequate safeguards of documents, records, and assets
Assess controls in place
8
Page 167
Assessment of Control
Environment (continued)
Area Points to Consider Our Assessment
Use quality information
Communicate internally
Communicate externally
Adequate performance reports produced from information
systems
Information and Information systems are connected with business strategy
Communication Commitment of HR and finance to develop, test, and monitor IT
systems and programs
Business continuity and disaster plan for IT
Established communication channels for employees to fulfill Not effective
responsibilities Suggested
Adequate communication across organization improvements
Perform monitoring activities Effective
Remediate deficiencies
Monitoring
Periodic evaluations of internal controls
Implementation of improvement recommendations
9
Page 168
Evaluation of Key Processes
Process Function A B C D Design Operation
Cash Management
Investment Accounting
Investment Monitoring
Treasury
Investment Valuation
Investment Policy
Reconciliation
Methodology
Estimation Information
Calculation
Accounting Principles and Disclosure
Closing the Books
Financial Report Preparation
Reporting General Ledger and Journal Entry
Processing
Verification and Review of Results
Purchasing
Receiving
Expenditures
Accounts Payable and Cash
Disbursement
Not effective
A Understand the Process C What Can Go Wrong
Suggested improvements
B Walk-Through D Test of Controls 10
Effective
Page 169
Evaluation of Key Processes (continued)
Process Function A B C D Design Operation
Hiring
Attendance Reporting
Payroll Payroll Accounting and Processing
Payroll Disbursements
Separation
Billing
Cash Receipts
Revenue
Revenue Recognition
Cutoff
Physical Custody
Asset and Construction in Process
Fixed Assets
Accounting
Depreciation
Not effective
A Understand the Process C What Can Go Wrong
Suggested improvements
B Walk-Through D Test of Controls
Effective
11
Page 170
Evaluation of Key Processes (continued)
Process Function A B C D Design Operation
Assess Internal and External Risk
Regulatory Compliance
Compliance
Monitor Compliance
Grant Compliance
Computer Operations
Segregation of Duties and Management
Oversight
Information
Information Security and Transaction
Technology
Authorization
Program Integrity and Change
Management
Not effective
A Understand the Process C What Can Go Wrong
Suggested improvements
B Walk-Through D Test of Controls
Effective
12
Page 171
Key Accounts Assertions
and Audit Results
Key Accounts Assertions Results
Cash and cash equivalents Existence
Accounts receivable, net Existence, Valuation
Grants receivable Existence, Valuation
Security deposit held Existence, Valuation
Prepaid expenses Existence, Cut off
Capital assets, net of accumulated depreciation Existence
Accounts payable and accrued expenses Completeness
Deferred revenue Completeness
Grants payable Completeness
Material adjustments
Immaterial adjustments
No adjustments
13
Page 172
Key Accounts Assertions
and Audit Results (continued)
Key Accounts Assertions Results
Government grants and contracts Occurrence, classification
Contributions Occurrence, classification
Foundation and other grants Occurrence, classification
Fees Occurrence, Valuation
Memberships Occurrence, classification
Investment income Occurrence
Other income Occurrence
Operating expenses Completeness
Interest expense Completeness
Material adjustments
Immaterial adjustments
No adjustments
14
Page 174
Required Communications
1. Auditor’s Responsibilities Under Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS)
The financial statements are the responsibility of management. Our audit was designed in accordance with
auditing standards generally accepted in the United States of America, and provide for reasonable, rather
than absolute, assurance that the financial statements are free of material misstatement.
2. Significant Accounting Policies
Management has the responsibility for selection and use of appropriate accounting policies. In accordance
with the terms of our engagement letter, we will advise management about the appropriateness of
accounting policies and their application. The significant accounting policies used by management are
described in the notes to the financial statements.
3. Auditor’s Judgments About the Quality of Accounting Principles
We discuss our judgments about the quality, not just the acceptability, of accounting principles selected by
management, the consistency of their application, and the clarity and completeness of the financial
statements, which include related disclosures.
We have reviewed the significant accounting policies adopted by the City and have determined that these
policies are acceptable accounting policies.
16
Page 175
Required Communications (continued)
4. Audit Adjustments
We are required to inform the City’s oversight body about adjustments arising from the audit (whether
recorded or not) that could in our judgment either individually or in the aggregate have a significant effect
on the entity’s financial reporting process. We also are required to inform the City’s oversight body about
unadjusted audit differences that were determined by management to be individually and in the aggregate,
immaterial.
There were no passed adjustments identified during the audit process.
5. Fraud and Illegal Acts
We are required to report to the City’s oversight body any fraud and illegal acts involving senior
management and fraud and illegal acts (whether caused by senior management or other employees) that
cause a material misstatement of the financial statements.
Our procedures identified no instances of fraud or illegal acts.
6. Material Weaknesses in Internal Control
We are required to communicate all significant deficiencies in the City’s systems of internal controls,
whether or not they are also material weaknesses.
There were no material weaknesses noted during the audit.
17
Page 176
Required Communications (continued)
7. Other Information in Documents Containing Audited Financial Statements
None.
8. Disagreements with Management on Financial Accounting and Reporting Matters
None.
9. Serious Difficulties Encountered in Performing the Audit
None.
10. Major Issues Discussed with Management Prior to Acceptance
None.
11. Management Representations
We will receive certain written representations from management as part of the completion of the audit.
12. Consultation with Other Accountants
To our knowledge, there were no consultations with other accountants since our appointment as the City’s
independent public accountants.
13. Independence
As part of our client acceptance process, we go through a process to ensure we are independent of the City.
We are independent of the City.
18
Page 177
Required Communications (continued)
14. Our Responsibility Related to Fraud
• Plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance that there is no material misstatement
caused by error or fraud;
• Comply with GAAS AUC 240 “Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit”;
• Approach all audits with an understanding that fraud could occur in any entity, at any time, by anyone;
and
• Perform mandatory procedures required by GAAS and our firm policies.
Examples of Procedures Performed
• Discuss thoughts and ideas on where the financial statements might be susceptible to material
misstatement due to fraud;
• Understand pressures on the financial statement results;
• Understand the tone and culture of the organization;
• Look for unusual or unexpected transactions, relationships, or procedures;
• Discussions with individuals outside of finance;
• Evaluate key processes and controls; and
• Consider information gathered throughout the audit.
19
Page 178
Required Communications-Fraud
• Generally provided through weaknesses in internal control
Opportunity • Tone at the top is important
• We assess controls and tone at the top
• Pressure can be imposed due to economic troubles, personal vices and
Pressure unrealistic deadlines and performance goals
• There are increased pressures due to economy and minimal salary increases
Rationalization • Individuals develop a justification for their fraudulent activities
• Increased rationalization due to minimal salary increases and less personnel
20
Page 179
SBC’s Service Pledge to You
We will consistently deliver a Quality Product and Quality Service so that we have the opportunity to
establish a Quality Relationship with you, allowing us to provide you with Quality Knowledge for your
continual success. Only after we have provided you with the knowledge that enables your business to
grow and prosper, we have hit the bullseye!
Our commitment to you is the execution of our Bullseye
Philosophy. We execute this philosophy for every client, on
every engagement, every time.
21
Page 180
Headquarters
200 International Circle • Suite 5500
Hunt Valley • Maryland 21030
(P) 410.584.0060 • (F) 410.584.0061
Branch Office
1299 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW • Suite 1120
Washington • District of Columbia 20004
(P) 202.803.2335 • (F) 202.821.1320