This text was pulled from the PDF automatically and may contain mistakes. The PDF is the official record, so check it before relying on this.
7 pages have little or no readable text here, often scans or drawings. See the PDF for those.
Page 1
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
AGENDA
April 25, 2011 - 7:30 P.M. - Council Chambers - City Hall - City of Dover
OPEN FORUM - 15 MINUTES PRIOR TO OFFICIAL MEETING (7:15 P.M.)
The “Open Forum” segment is provided to extend the opportunity to the general public to share
their questions, thoughts, comments, concerns, and complaints. Discussion of any item appearing
on the agenda is prohibited and citizen comments are limited to three (3) minutes. Council is
prohibited from taking action since they are not in official session; however, they may schedule
such items as regular agenda items and act upon them in the future.
INVOCATION BY CHAPLAIN WALLACE DIXON
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE LED BY MAYOR CAREY
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
CONSENT AGENDA
Those items on the Council Agenda which are considered routine and non-controversial shall be marked
with an asterisk (*) and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no
separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall
be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
1. Adoption of Minutes - Regular Council Meeting of April 11, 2011
2. Proclamation - Employee Appreciation Day
3. Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee Report - April 11, 2011
A. Proposal by Chyenne Arsenault - Community Service Requirement for Graduation
(Committee Recommended Acceptance of the Report)
B. Presentation of Master Plan for the Boys and Girls Club at Schutte Park
(Committee Recommended Acceptance of the Conceptual Schutte Park Master Plan)
C. Updates
(Committee Recommended Acceptance of the Reports)
4. Quarterly Revenue Report/Projected Revenues for FY 2012
5. Semi-Annual Inspection by City Manager - Robbins Hose Company
6. 2011 Municipal Election Results
7. Evaluation of Bids - Route 13 Water Main Replacement
Page 2
Council Agenda - April 25, 2011 Page 2
8. Rezoning Request/First Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2011-13
(Recommended for referral to the Planning Commission on May 16, 2011 and that a
Public Hearing be set for June 13, 2011 at 7:30 p.m.)
A. Property located at 1151-1155 Walker Road, owned by Walker Road, LLC c/o
Franklin Everett, Jr. This property is currently zoned C-PO
(Commercial/Professional Office Development District) and the proposed zoning
is 1O (Institutional and Office). Copies of the proposed ordinance are available
at the entrance of the Council Chambers.
(Tax PARCEL: ED05-067.18-01-79.00-000; FourTH CouNcIL DISTRICT;
PLANNING REFERENCE Z-11-04)
9. Final Reading - Proposed Ordinance #2011-10
The First Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2011-10 was accomplished during the
Council Meeting of April 11, 2011. Copies of the proposed ordinance are available
at the entrance of the Council Chambers.
A. 2011 Budget Revision - Transfer to General Employee Pension Fund
10. Council Members Announcements
/tm
S:\AGENDAS & MINUTES\Council-Agendas\2011\04-25-2011.wpd.
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO
CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS.
Page 3
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular Council Meeting was held on April 11, 2011 at 7:30 p.m. with Council President Hogan
presiding. Council members present were Mr. Leary, Mr. McGiffin, Dr. McGlumphy, Mr. Ruane,
Mrs. Russell, Mr. Salters, and Mrs. Williams. Mr. Bonar was absent.
Council staff members present were Police Chief Hosfelt, Ms. Russell, Mrs. Mitchell,
Mrs. Townshend, Fire Chief Fortney, Mr. DePrima, City Solicitor Rodriguez, and Mrs. McDowell.
Mayor Carey was also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 7:15 p.m., prior to commencement of the Official Council Meeting.
Council President Hogan declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that
Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.
Mr. Joe Simmons, 203 Pebble Valley Drive, referred to the construction of the new Dover High
School and stated his interest in community projects that address the needs of children. He proposed
that the Capital School District consider including a multi-purpose gymnasium large enough to
accommodate large tournaments. In addition, he suggested that a walking track be incorporated,
which would allow for more community involvement. Mr. Simmons noted that the current
Dover High School gymnasium has been used as a disaster shelter in times of emergency, as a venue
for large events, and for sports leagues and that it also has been made available for the use of outside
organizations. Mr. Simmons suggested that the Capital School District build a gymnasium with a
capacity for 2,500-3,500 persons. It was his feeling that, since Dover High School will be centrally
located, it should have one of the better gyms in the State and he proposed that local hotels,
restaurants, and businesses support construction of the gym. Noting that plans to construct a new
civic center in the area are not moving forward at this time, Mr. Simmons stated that, although the
Dover High School gym could not replace the Civic Center, it could provide a facility or venue to
serve large events. He stated that the Delaware State University gym can accommodate a crowd of
2,500 and the University of Delaware allows up to 5,000. He suggested that the City consider
partnering with the Capital School District for the construction of a large facility since it would
provide a tremendous benefit to the City, and he advised members that he will be discussing this
proposal with local legislators in hopes of obtaining bond funds.
The invocation was given by Chaplain Dixon, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
Dr. McGlumphy moved for approval of the agenda as presented, seconded by Mr. Leary and
unanimously carried.
Mr. Leary moved for approval of the consent agenda, seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried
by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
ADOPTION OF MINUTES - REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 28, 2011
The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of March 28, 2011 were unanimously approved
by motion of Mr. Leary, seconded by Mrs. Williams and bore the written approval of
Mayor Carey.
Page 4
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 2
PRESENTATION - GOVERNMENT FINANCE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION (GFOA)
DISTINGUISHED BUDGET AWARD
The Distinguished Budget Presentation Award for Fiscal Year beginning July 2010, from the
Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA), was awarded to the City of Dover. This award
recognizes the excellent manner in which the City prepares and presents its budget.
Mayor Carey read the following into the record:
“The Distinguished Budget Presentation Awards Program was established by the
GFOA (Government Financial Officers Association) to encourage and assist state
and local governments with the preparation of budget documents of the very highest
quality. Documents submitted must reflect both the guidelines established by the
National Advisory Council on State and Local Budgeting and the GFOA's
recommended practices on budgeting. GFOA then recognizes individual
governments that succeed in achieving that goal.
Documents submitted to the Budget Awards Program are reviewed by selected
members of the GFOA professional staff and by outside reviewers with experience
in public-sector budgeting.
In the State of Delaware, New Castle and Wilmington are the only other
municipalities that receive this award, and they have twice the number of budget staff
that the City employs. Dover has received this award for over 20 years. This is an
outstanding accomplishment.
It is my pleasure to present the GFOA Distinguished Budget Presentation Award for
the Fiscal Year beginning July 1, 2010 to Terry Tieman. Congratulations.”
Mayor Carey presented the award to Mrs. Teresa Tieman, Senior City Administrator. He noted that
the City has received this award for 22 years and that this is the 20" time the award has been received
by Mrs. Tieman.
Mrs. Tieman advised members that GFOA is a premier organization that serves the education and
career development needs of over 17,500 government officials in the United States and Canada. She
stated that the GFOA also focuses on recognizing achievements in Financial Reporting and Budget
Presentations, and that the City of Dover participates in both of these programs. She explained that,
as a part of this process, the City works to produce documents that meet established governmental
accounting standards and, in turn, it is hoped that the City will receive affirmation of this work
through the GFOA recognition programs. Reiterating that this is the 22‘ year of recognition for this
award, Mrs. Tieman noted that the City is one of only three (3) entities in the State of Delaware to
receive such an award and, statewide, the City has received the award more than any other entity,
which she stated is exceptional for a City the size of Dover.
Mrs. Tieman advised members that receipt of these awards is a strong indicator that the City’s
budget is an accurate reflection of the workplan and goals established by the Mayor and Council.
Page 5
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 3
She thanked the Mayor and Council for their guidance in the budget process during these past few
years, noting that, due to the economy, the past few budgets have been extremely difficult to develop
and implement. She stated that the City’s budget is the result of a team effort and recognized all
departments and employees who continue to provide good service under continued cutbacks.
Mrs. Tieman relayed appreciation to Budget Team members Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager,
and Mrs. Donna Mitchell, Controller/Treasurer. A special thank you was relayed to Ms. Hollie Ford,
Administrative Assistant, for putting the final Budget together.
PROCLAMATION - ARBOR DAY
The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:
WHEREAS, J. Sterling Morton, a Nebraska pioneer, understood that trees were needed for fuel and
building materials, for shade from the hot sun, and as windbreaks to keep soil in place; and
WHEREAS, J. Sterling Morton advocated tree planting by individuals and civic organizations and,
on January 4, 1872, proposed a tree-planting holiday to be called “Arbor Day”; and
WHEREAS, the first holiday was set for April 10, 1872, with prizes being offered to counties and
individuals for properly planting the largest number of trees and it was estimated that more than
one million trees were planted in Nebraska that day; and
WHEREAS, in 1885, Arbor Day was named a legal holiday in Nebraska and April 22, Morton's
birthday, was selected as the date for its permanent observance. Today, it is most common for
Arbor Day to coincide with the best tree planting weather for the region; and
WHEREAS, the City of Dover was named a Tree City USA in 2010 for the twenty-first consecutive
year by the National Arbor Day Foundation, recognizing Dover for its outstanding urban forestry
program, and
WHEREAS, the City of Dover Planning and Inspections Department’s Tree Planting and
Preservation Ordinance has caused the planting of thousands of trees in all subdivisions and
commercial sites since 1992 and the City has been aggressively planting street trees, which are trees
planted between the curb and the sidewalk, in almost every available site in the City; and
WHEREAS, the Delaware State champion American Elm on The Green may be the only living
witness to the United States Constitution Ratification enacted at the Golden Fleece Tavern 233 years
ago, underscoring that the planting and caring for trees is a special gift that one generation passes
down to the next.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, CARLETON E. CAREY, SR., MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER,
DELAWARE, do hereby proclaim April 23rd, 2011 as ARBOR DAY in the City of Dover, and urge
all citizens to support the efforts to care for our trees along our streets, in our parks, and in our
yards. As the City of Dover plants trees on public property, I urge all citizens to plant trees on their
property to enhance the environment and promote the well-being of present and future generations.
Page 6
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 4
Mayor Carey presented the Proclamation to Mr. Bill Cooper, Superintendent of Grounds, and relayed
appreciation to Mr. Cooper and his co-workers for the exceptional work performed in beautifying
the City.
Mr. Cooper stated that his staff works hard on the beautification program and explained the
importance of planting trees. He stated that staff has been very aggressive in planting trees along
the streets and in parks and open spaces. He expressed pride in the tree plantings along the St. Jones
River, from Silver Lake Park to Division Street, noting that more than 250 trees, 700 shrubs, and
several hundred perennials have been planted in this area. He advised members that an Arbor Day
celebration will be held on Monday, April 25, 2011, from 9:00 a.m. to 10:30 a.m., at Park Drive and
invited all to participate in the event.
In response to Mr. Salters, Mr. Cooper stated that the American Elm on The Green mentioned in
the Proclamation is the grandest (18’ in circumference) and most beautiful tree in the City. He
appreciated the compliment provided and noted that his predecessor, Mr. Orville Myers, would be
proud of the City’s accomplishments. He indicated that Mr. Myers had a great love for plants as well
as for the community.
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2011-01
A public hearing was duly advertised for this time and place to consider approval of Proposed
Ordinance #201 1-01, zoning text amendments, that would add solar energy systems and small wind
energy systems as accessory uses within all zoning districts; set standards for these systems to ensure
protection of the character of the zones, as well as public health, safety and welfare; and add
definitions for such systems to the Zoning Ordinance.
Mr. Salters moved that the Final Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2011-01 be acknowledged
by title only, seconded by Mr. Leary and unanimously carried. (The First Reading of the
Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of February 14, 2011.)
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, advised members
that staff developed the Proposed Ordinance in support of the recommendation in the
2008 Comprehensive Plan to promote green energy and building practices by removing obstacles
in the Building Code and Zoning Ordinances. She stated that the Proposed Ordinance would allow
small wind energy systems and solar energy systems as an accessory use within all zoning districts.
Mrs. Townshend explained that the Proposed Ordinance sets standards, such as height, setback, and
screening, to ensure that the placement of such structures protects the character of the surrounding
area.
In developing the Proposed Ordinance, Mrs. Townshend stated that staff reviewed the provisions of
the State statute regarding small wind energy systems, which limit the ability of local governments
to regulate these systems in residential districts. She assured members that the standards set forth
in the State statute are mirrored in the City’s Proposed Ordinance. She also stated that the Ordinance
adds definitions for “small wind energy systems” and “solar energy systems.” Mrs. Townshend
advised members that the Planning Commission recommended approval of Proposed
Ordinance #2011-01 as presented.
Page 7
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 5
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. Townshend stated that one (1) property owner has spoken to staff
about solar use and that the City has received its first application for a solar energy system, which
will be considered by the Planning Commission. She explained that this relates to an expansion
planned at the Delaware Technical and Community College (DTCC) Dover Campus. She explained
that DTCC is proposing wind turbines as an accessory use within the campus as well. She confirmed
that the Proposed Ordinance has a practical purpose, in addition to addressing concerns related to
protecting the environment for the future.
Council President Hogan declared the public hearing open.
Mr. John Paradee, of Prickett, Jones, and Elliott, 11 North State Street, stated that he represents
Mr. Donald Burge of CD Realty Advisors, a property owner who is planning a project that is likely
to be the subject of an application for a solar facility. He advised members that Governor Markell
is encouraging all local governments to undertake efforts to pursue renewable energy and noted that
the City’s Comprehensive Plan encourages code amendments that foster green energy. It was his
feeling that the Proposed Ordinance has been carefully reviewed and written in a way that provides
the most attractive benefits for property owners, while at the same time allowing for appropriate
buffers and safeguards for property owners adjacent to such facilities.
Mr. Donald Burge, CD Realty Advisors, 200 South Broad Street, Philadelphia, stated that his
organization owns the Silver Lake Office Project which consists of six (6) buildings and that the
primary tenants of all of the buildings are agencies of the State of Delaware. He explained that the
proposed project would provide solar energy to these buildings and that the Proposed Ordinance
would allow for the project. Mr. Burge stated the intention that most of the equipment for the project
would be obtained from Delaware and local contractors would perform the work. It was his feeling
that the Proposed Ordinance has both immediate and long-term benefits and shows a great deal of
forethought by the City. Mr. Burge stated that such an ordinance would eliminate the need to
undergo an extensive process when future projects are considered.
There being no one else present wishing to speak, Council President Hogan declared the public
hearing closed.
By motion of Mr. Ruane, seconded by Mr. McGiffin, and by a unanimous roll call vote
(Mr. Bonar absent), Council adopted Ordinance #2011-01, as follows:
BEIT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL
MET:
That Appendix B - Zoning, Article 5 - Supplementary Regulations be amended by adding a new
section 20 as follows:
Section 20. Solar and small wind energy systems.
Solar energy systems and small wind energy systems shall be permitted as accessory uses within all
zones subject to the following requirements:
Page 8
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 6
20.1 Residential Zones.
20.11 Solar energy systems shall be subject to the following:
(a) Ground-mounted solar energy systems shall be permitted only in the rear
yard.
(b) Ground-mounted solar energy systems shall be set back a minimum of five
feet from side and rear property lines, or the height of the tallest point on the
system, whichever is greater.
(c) Ground-mounted solar energy systems shall not exceed 15 feet in height.
(d) Ground-mounted solar energy systems shall be visually screened from
adjacent properties to a height of six feet by either an opaque fence or a dense
vegetative screen.
(e) All exterior electrical and/or plumbing lines must be buried below the surface
of the ground and placed in a conduit.
(f) Roof-mounted solar energy systems must comply with all building height
requirements for the zoning district where the system is to be installed.
20.12 Small wind energy systems in residential zones shall be subject to the following
restrictions:
(a) Small wind energy systems shall be set back 1.0 times the turbine height from
adjoining property lines. Turbine height means the height of the tower plus
the length of one blade.
(b) The aggregate noise or audible sound ofa small wind energy system shall not
exceed five decibels above the existing average noise level of the surrounding
area and shall be restricted to a maximum of 60 decibels measured at any
location along the property line of the parcel where the small wind energy
system is located.
(c) Small wind energy systems shall be free from signage, advertising, flags,
streamers, decorative items, or any item not related to the operation of the
wind turbine. Electric wiring for the turbines shall be placed underground for
non-building integrated systems.
(d) Small wind energy systems shall not be permitted within the H (Historic
District) Zone.
Page 9
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 7
(e) Any small wind energy system shall be visually screened to a height of six
feet by either an opaque fence or a dense vegetative screen from any
properties or structures included on the National Register of Historic Places.
20.2 Non-Residential Zones.
20.21 Solar energy systems shall be subject to the following:
(a) For the purposes of this subsection, a use is considered accessory if it is
located within a complex or campus that includes one or more contiguous
lots under common ownership and management, where the principal use of
the complex or campus is other than a solar energy system, and the energy
generated by the solar energy system is intended to primarily reduce on-site
consumption of utility-supplied energy.
(b) Ground-mounted solar energy systems shall not occupy more than 30 percent
of the lot area of the complex or campus for which the solar energy system
is proposed.
(c) If ground-mounted solar energy systems are proposed to occupy more than
30 percent of the lot area of the complex or campus, their placement shall be
subject to conditional use approval by the Planning Commission.
(d) Ground-mounted solar energy systems shall not be located between the
principal structure and the street upon which the principal structure fronts.
(e) All exterior electrical and/or plumbing lines must be buried below the surface
of the ground and placed in a conduit.
(f) Solar energy systems, whether roof-mounted or ground-mounted, must
comply with all building setback and height requirements for the zoning
district where the system is to be installed.
20.22 Small wind energy systems shall be subject to the following restrictions:
(a) Small wind energy shall be set back 1.0 times the turbine height from
adjoining property lines. Turbine height means the height of the tower plus
the length of one blade.
(b) The aggregate noise or audible sound of a wind system shall not exceed five
decibels above the existing average noise level of the surrounding area and
shall be restricted to a maximum of 60 decibels measured at any location
along the property line to the parcel where the small wind energy system is
located.
Page 10
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 8
(c) Small wind energy systems shall be free from signage, advertising, flags,
streamers, decorative items, or any item not related to the operation of the
wind turbine. Electric wiring for the turbines shall be placed underground for
non-building integrated systems.
(d) Small wind energy systems shall not be permitted within the H (Historic
District) Zone.
(e) Any small wind energy system shall be visually screened to a height of six
feet by either an opaque fence or a dense vegetative screen from any
properties or structures included on the National Register of Historic Places.
20.3 Decommissioning.
Solar energy systems and/or small wind energy systems must be maintained and kept in a
state suitable for immediate operation. When it can be demonstrated that a solar energy
system or small wind energy system, as approved in accordance with this section, is ina state
of disrepair and is not suitable for immediate operation, that system shall be removed and the
accessory use terminated.
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED:
That Appendix B - Zoning, Article 12 - Definitions, be amended to add the following definitions:
Solar energy system. Any solar collector or other solar energy device, or any structural design
feature, mounted on a building or on the ground, and whose primary purpose is to provide for the
collection, storage, and distribution of solar energy for space heating or cooling, for water heating,
or for electricity.
Small wind energy system. A wind energy conversion system consisting of a wind turbine, a tower,
and associated control or conversion electronics which is intended to primarily reduce on site
consumption of utility-supplied energy.
ADOPTED: APRIL 11, 2011
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2011-08
A public hearing was duly advertised for this time and place to consider approval of Proposed
Ordinance #2011-08 amending the 2008 Comprehensive Plan by replacing Map 12-1: Land
Development Plan. The Proposed Ordinance would adopt amendments to the 2008 Comprehensive
Plan, as amended on November 23, 2009 and March 14, 2011.
Mr. Leary moved that the Final Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2011-08 be acknowledged
by title only, seconded by Mr. Salters and unanimously carried. (The First Reading of this
ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of February 28, 2011.)
Page 11
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 9
Planner's Review
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, reviewed the
proposed amendments to the 2008 Comprehensive Plan. She noted that the proposal would result
in two (2) amendments, as follows:
* Land Use Classification Change from Industrial to Residential High Density
(Map 12-1): This is an applicant-initiated request to change property from an
Industrial and Public Utilities land use classification to a Residential High
Density land use classification. The property is located north of College Road,
just east of the railroad tracks. This proposed amendment was initially part of the
amendments reviewed at the February 22, 2011 meeting of the Planning
Commission, but consideration by Council was delayed due to an administrative
error involving the associated rezoning application. This amendment is
associated with a rezoning request to be considered by City Council during the
latter part of the meeting (see Proposed Ordinance #201 1-04).
* Land Use Classification Change from Institutional to Residential High Density
(Map 12-1): This is an applicant-initiated request to change property from an
Institutional land use classification to Residential High Density land use
classification. The property is located at 101-405 Doveview Drive, just north of
Delaware Route 8 between Saulsbury Road and the Modern Maturity Center.
It was previously approved under a PND: Senior Citizen Housing Option, as
senior apartments. The applicant wishes to develop as apartments without an age
restriction.
Referring to the first amendment, Mrs. Townshend advised members that at the
Planning Commission meeting of March 21, 2011, the applicant made a case in favor of a
Residential High Density land use classification, stating that the type of apartment building
permitted the site. She noted that the applicant stated that the bulk standards and features on the site
would prevent the full utilization of high density on the site, however, would provide design
flexibility that would allow for less impact on the environmental resources on the site. She noted
that, following the public hearing, the Planning Commission recommended approval of the requested
Comprehensive Plan amendment from the Industrial land use classification to Residential High
Density.
With reference to the second amendment, Mrs. Townshend reminded members that on
March 14, 2011, City Council held a public hearing on the proposed amendments to the
2008 Comprehensive Plan. She stated that, at that time, members of the public expressed concern
about the required cross-access drive between the Modern Maturity Center and the Doveview site
if the Doveview apartments were to be open to non-senior citizen residents. Following the public
hearing, City Council moved to defer action until the Planning Commission had considered a
request by the Modern Maturity Center to eliminate the cross-access requirement between the sites.
On March 21, 2011, after a public hearing where members of the public testified with regards to this
request, the Planning Commission voted to eliminate the requirement for a cross-access drive,
continuing to require a cross-access path for pedestrians and golf carts. Therefore, Mrs. Townshend
assured members that there would be no vehicle connection between the Modern Maturity Center
and the Doveview site.
Page 12
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 10
Council President Hogan declared the public hearing open.
Mr. Gregory Moore, Becker Morgan Group, 309 South Governors Avenue, stated that the action of
the Planning Commission has resolved the concerns relayed during the previous meeting regarding
the cross-access. He reminded members that he represents Sun Trust Bank, who currently owns the
property known as Doveview Apartments, and relayed support for the proposed amendments.
There being no one else wishing to speak, Council President Hogan declared the public hearing
closed.
Mr. Leary moved for the adoption of Proposed Ordinance #2011-08, amending the
Comprehensive Plan, as recommended by the Planning Commission. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Salters and by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent), Council
adopted Ordinance #2011-08, as follows:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE 2008 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN BY REPLACING
MAP 12-1: LAND DEVELOPMENT PLAN
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Dover, on February 9, 2009, adopted the
2008 Comprehensive Plan pursuant to Title 22, Section 702 of the Delaware Code; and
WHEREAS, the Honorable Jack Markell, Governor of the State of Delaware, certified the
2008 Comprehensive Plan on April 24, 2009; and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Dover, on November 23, 2009, adopted the
2009 Comprehensive Rezoning Project and 2009 Comprehensive Plan Amendments; and
WHEREAS, the 2008 Comprehensive Plan allows for an annual amendment process; and
WHEREAS, a property owner has requested an amendment to the Land Development Plan Map
(Map 12-1) in accordance with the process set forth in the 2008 Comprehensive Plan, and an
administrative error caused incomplete public notice with regards to the rezoning application
associated with this request, causing a delay in the Planning Commission hearing the application on
the originally scheduled date of February 22, 2011; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on March 21, 2011, after which the
Commission made a recommendation in regards to the proposed amendments to the
Land Development Plan related to the above request.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED THAT the Mayor and Council of the City of Dover
hereby amend Map 12-1: Land Development Plan of the 2008 Comprehensive Plan, as amended on
November 23, 2009 and on March 14, 2011, by replacing the referenced map with the Amended Map
12-1 presented to City Council on April 11, 2011.
ADOPTED: APRIL 11, 2011
Page 13
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 11
PUBLIC HEARING/FINAL READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2011-04 - REZONING
OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT GROVE STREET AND RAILROAD AVENUE, OWNED
BY COLLEGE ROAD MANAGEMENT, INC., KENT STORAGE FACILITIES, LLC, AND
LORALEX COMPANY, LLC
A public hearing was duly advertised for this time and place to consider rezoning of property located
at Grove Street and Railroad Avenue, owned by College Road Management, Inc., Kent Storage
Facilities, LLC, and Loralex Company, LLC, consisting of four (4) parcels totaling 30.78” acres.
The property is currently zoned M (Manufacturing) and the proposed zoning is RG-5 (General
Residence Zone for Mid-Rise Apartments). The subject property is located north of College Road
and east of the railroad corridor and Railroad Avenue. (Tax Parcels: ED05-067.00-02-53.00-000,
ED05-067.00-02-54.00-000, ED05-067.00-02-55.00-000, and ED05-067.00-02-56.00-000, Fourth Council
District; Planning Reference: Z-11-02.)
Mr. Salters moved that the Final Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2011-04 be acknowledged
by title only, seconded by Mrs. Williams and unanimously carried. (The First Reading of the
Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of January 24, 2011.)
Planner's Review
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, reviewed the
petition to amend the zoning district and the findings and recommendations of the Planning
Commission. She noted that the Planning Commission recommended approval of the rezoning
request.
In response to Mr. Ruane’s concerns regarding a buffer between the railroad and residential
properties, Mrs. Townshend stated that this issue would be discussed during the site plan review and
any requirements would be determined at that time. She confirmed that the Municipal Code contains
no relevant buffering requirements.
Council President Hogan declared the public hearing open. There being no one present wishing to
speak, Council President Hogan declared the public hearing closed.
Mr. Ruane relayed his opposition to the rezoning request, explaining that there is a need for more
manufacturing in the City and that this property was probably designated in the Manufacturing land
use category due to its close proximity to the railroad. He noted that he had experience residing near
a railroad and felt that the proposal would be problematic.
Mr. Salters moved for approval of the rezoning request, as recommended by the
Planning Commission. The motion was seconded by Mrs. Russell and by a roll call vote of
seven (7) yes, one (1) no (Mr. Ruane), and one (1) absent (Mr. Bonar), Council adopted
Ordinance #2011-04, as follows:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE
CITY OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED
AT GROVE STREET AND RAILROAD AVENUE
Page 14
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 12
WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property within
the limits of the City of Dover; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use of
property described below from M (Manufacturing Zone) to RG-5 (General Residence Zone for
Mid-Rise Apartments).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning designation from
M (Manufacturing Zone) to RG-5 (General Residence Zone for Mid-Rise Apartments) on
that property located at Grove Street and Railroad Avenue, north of College Road and east
of the railroad corridor and Railroad Avenue, consisting of four (4) parcels of land totaling
30.78" acres, owned by College Road Management, Inc.; Kent Storage Facilities, LLC; and
Loralex Company, LLC.
ADOPTED: APRIL 11, 2011
FINAL READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2011-05 - REZONING OF PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 101-405 DOVEVIEW DRIVE (DOVEVIEW APARTMENTS), OWNED BY
CRM MID-ATLANTIC, LLC AND SUN TRUST BANK
During their Regular Meeting of March 14, 2011, members of Council held a public hearing to
consider rezoning of property located at 101-405 Doveview Drive (Doveview Apartments),
consisting of 6.735” acres, owned by CRM Mid-Atlantic, LLC and Sun Trust Bank. The property
is currently zoned IO (Institutional and Office) and subject to the COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone)
and the proposed zoning is RG-5 (General Residence Zone for Mid-Rise Apartment) and subject to
the COZ-1. The property is located on the north side of Forrest Avenue (Route 8) just west of the
Saulsbury Road intersection. (Tax Parcel: ED05-076.07-01-30.00-000; First Council District; Planning
Reference: Z-11-03.) On March 14, 2011, Council deferred action on Proposed Ordinance #201 1-05
for the rezoning of property located at 101-405 Doveview Drive (Doveview Apartments).
Mr. Salters moved that the Final Reading of Proposed Ordinance #2011-05 be acknowledged
by title only, seconded by Mr. Leary and unanimously carried. (The First Reading of the
Proposed Ordinance was accomplished during the Council Meeting of January 24, 2011 and the
Final Reading was deferred on March 14, 2011.)
Planner's Review
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, reviewed the
petition to amend the zoning district and the findings and recommendations of the
Planning Commission. She noted that the Planning Commission recommended approval of the
rezoning request. She stated that earlier during this meeting, members of Council approved
Ordinance #2011-03 which adopted the 2008 Comprehensive Plan Amendment. She reminded
members that the cross-access requirement was removed from the Modern Maturity Center site plan
and that this requirement was the major concern relayed during the Council Meeting of
March 14, 2011.
Page 15
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 13
Mr. Salters moved for approval of the rezoning request, as recommended by the
Planning Commission. The motion was seconded by Mrs. Williams and by a unanimous roll
call vote (Mr. Bonar absent), Council adopted Ordinance #2011-05, as follows:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE
CITY OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED
AT 101-405 DOVEVIEW DRIVE
WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property within
the limits of the City of Dover; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use of
property described below from IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to COZ-1 (Corridor
Overlay Zone) to RG-5 (General Residence Zone for Mid-Rise Apartments) and subject to
COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning designation from
IO (Institutional and Office Zone) and subject to COZ-1 (Corridor Overlay Zone) to
RG-5 (General Residence Zone for Mid-Rise Apartments) and subject to COZ-1 (Corridor
Overlay Zone) on that property located at 101-405 Doveview Drive (on the north side of
Forrest Avenue (Route 8) just west of the Saulsbury Road intersection), consisting of
6.735+/- acres, owned by CRM Mid-Atlantic, LLC and SunTrust Bank.
ADOPTED: APRIL 11, 2011
SPECIAL PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE
REPORT - MARCH 24, 2011
A Special Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee meeting was held on
March 24, 2011 with Chairwoman Russell presiding.
Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Application Review
Mrs. Tracey Harvey, Community Development Manager, noted that members would be serving as
the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Review Panel for the CDBG Applications for
Fiscal Year 2011. As such, members were provided with a list of applicants, staff reports
summarizing each application, a CDBG Interview Schedule, a breakdown of federal resources
available for use, the total amount of grant funds requested, CDBG scoring criteria, and a
2011 CDBG Review Panel Scoring Sheet for each applicant. She requested that members
summarize their evaluation of each application on the CDBG Grant Application Review Sheet and
provide a score based on the information presented. Mrs. Harvey explained that the numbers in
parenthesis next to each measure indicate the maximum score for a given category and that the
maximum total points is 100.
Page 16
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 14
Mrs. Harvey advised members that the total amount of grant funds available for activities is
$228,406 and explained the allocation requirements of the grant, as follows:
CDBG Funds Allocation $270,000
Anticipated Program Income $ 15,507
Total Grant Allocation $285,507
20% of the grant must be allocated for $285,507
Program Administration x.20
$57,101
Grant Funds Available for Activities $228,406
Total Grant Funds Requested by Applicants $540,347
Mrs. Harvey cautioned that, according to CDBG requirements, funds awarded for public service
activities cannot exceed 15% of the total grant allocation ($42,826).
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, advised members
that until the federal budget process is complete, the funding level of the City’s CDBG allocation
is uncertain. She noted that the City’s representative from the Department of Housing and
Urban Development suggested using the City’s FY 2009 allocation for budgeting purposes.
Mrs. Townshend stated that members should understand that subgrant funding levels may need to
be adjusted after Congress adopts a final budget.
By unanimous consent (Mr. Ruane absent during this portion of the meeting), members agreed that they
would abide by a procedure adopted in previous years whereby applications that receive fewer than
70 points in the scoring process would be removed from consideration.
Oral Presentations
Each applicant was provided an opportunity to make oral presentations before the Committee, as
follows:
Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing
Ms. Jeanine Kleimo, Chair, Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing (DIMH), reviewed a grant
application in the amount of $46,000. She explained that DIMH is an interfaith community
organization which provides shelter, meals, and assistance to homeless men from the greater
Dover community. Ms. Kleimo indicated that DIMH has opened a shelter at 684 Forest Street in
Dover which can accommodate up to 36 lodgers. She stated that the 4,800 square-foot building is
leased from the Downtown Dover Partnership and was renovated using a previous $60,000 CDBG
award from the City of Dover. Ms. Kleimo noted that all shelter guests are assessed for counseling,
treatment, and employment needs and referrals are made to local agencies that provide for mental
health and addiction counseling, and social services. She advised members that the shelter program
is one of Dover's largest volunteer efforts and is well-supported and accepted by the community.
Ms. Kleimo stated that DIMH’s grant request is for operating funds for the building, including utility
and lease costs.
Page 17
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 15
In response to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Kleimo stated that very few shelter guests return for
additional services, estimating that approximately 15-20 of the 400 individuals served were
returnees. She noted that these guests were granted an additional 30-day stay and provided further
counseling. She reiterated that the goal of the DIMH is to shelter and feed men and restore them as
productive members of the community.
First State Resource Conservation and Development Council
Mr. Frederick Traute, Manager, Home Repair Project, First State Resource Conservation and
Development Council, Inc. (RC & D) reviewed a grant application, in the amount of $50,000, for
funding for the organization’s Emergency Home Repair Program. He explained that this program
provides assistance to low-income homeowners to eliminate conditions in their homes that are an
immediate threat to the occupants’ health, safety, or security. Mr. Traute noted that RC & D
provides materials and volunteers or contractors to complete repairs with no cost to the homeowner.
He emphasized that these repairs are much needed and that receipt of the organization’s services is
often the occupant’s last resort before becoming homeless. Mr. Traute explained that, if the CDBG
funds are secured, RC & D expects to carry out repairs on up to 20 low-income, owner-occupied
homes in the City over the next 12 months and plans to average three (3) completions per quarter.
In response to Mrs. Russell, Mr. Traute indicated that current program guidelines permit RC & D
to spend up to $5,000 per year on homes. He emphasized that RC & D is not an ongoing
maintenance program and that staff encourages owners to take responsibility for maintaining their
homes in good repair after services are provided.
Connections Community Support Program
Mr. Chris Devaney, Vice President of Operations, and Mr. Brad Milton, Director of Homeless
Program, Connections Community Support Programs, Inc. (Connections), reviewed a grant
application in the amount of $20,000. Mr. Devaney explained that Connections was founded in
1985 to provide primary medical, mental health and substance abuse treatment, employment, and
housing opportunities and to help individuals and families receiving services to become accepted
and productive members of their communities. He noted that CDBG funds would be used to
increase homeless shelter capacity in Dover by providing motel vouchers for homeless individuals
and families who have no other immediate housing alternatives.
Mr. Devaney stated that Connections also proposes to use CDBG funds to offer an alternative to
emergency shelter during the coldest nights of the year by operating a homeless café in the City from
December 15, 2011 through March 15, 2012, replicating a similar Connections program in
Wilmington. He noted that this facility would serve individuals who are unwilling or unable to stay
in traditional shelters due to fear, mental health problems, or other barriers. Mr. Devaney noted that
it is proposed to use Connections’ Dover Homeless Outreach Center, which currently provides
daytime outreach services for the homeless, for this purpose. He stated that this facility is located
at 621 W. Division Street.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. Townshend indicated that the current zoning of the Division Street
property would not permit use as a homeless café. Mr. Devaney stated that Connections would be
willing to consider another property owned by the organization, located at 696 S. Bay Road, as an
alternative location.
Page 18
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 16
Mr. Ruane suggested that Connections staff explore the possibility of linking services with the
Dover Public Library, noting that the Library has an employment counselor and could also benefit
from outreach efforts made to the homeless in the area.
Diamond State Community Land Trust
Mr. Van Temple, Executive Director, Diamond State Community Land Trust (DSCLT), reviewed
a grant application in the amount of $40,000. Mr. Temple explained that DSCLT was founded in
2006 to create permanent, affordable housing for individuals who are 60% below the area median
income. He noted that, under the DSCLT model, homeowners purchase the home; however, DSCLT
retains ownership of the land. Mr. Temple indicated that DSCLT clients sign 99-year renewable
leases for exclusive rent of the land for a set, below-market fee. He stressed that, under this model,
DSCLT homes are made affordable for the first time buyer and for future buyers of the property.
Mr. Temple stated that CDBG funds would be used to purchase two (2) vacant, foreclosed homes
in Northwest Dover Heights, Lincoln Park, or surrounding areas for low-income families. He noted
that one (1) of the criteria for selecting homes would be the roof orientation and size, so that
solar panels could be installed to generate electricity and heat for hot water.
Mr. Temple provided members an updated economic summary for their review.
Mr. Ruane requested that staff provide members a list of homes in the City that have been
rehabilitated by DSCLT.
Elizabeth W. Murphey School. Inc.
Mr. Michael Kopp, Executive Director, The Elizabeth W. Murphey School, Inc., reviewed a grant
application in the amount of $49,347. He advised members that the Elizabeth Murphey School is
a group home that serves neglected and abused homeless children. Mr. Kopp noted that the State has
requested the Murphey School to open an additional building to serve children who need emergency
placement. He stated that this building will house children as young as six (6) years of age who are
homeless and also have mental health concerns that will be addressed through school staff and the
services of other area professionals.
Mr. Kopp indicated that the cost of providing heat and moderate air conditioning to school buildings
has severely impacted the organization’s ability to serve more children and that conversion to
geothermal heating is crucial to the organization’s financial stability. Mr. Kopp advised members
that the CDBG funds will be used to provide a geothermal unit which will provide heat, hot water,
and air conditioning to a building which will accommodate children placed in the Murphey School’s
care on an emergency basis.
Downtown Dover Partnership
Mr. William Neaton, Executive Director, and Mr. Ed Perez, Coordinator, Downtown Dover
Partnership (DDP), reviewed a grant application in the amount of $42,000. Mr. Neaton explained
that CDBG funds were requested for the development of microenterprises in the Downtown Dover
area. He stated that funds would be used to provide: 1) grants, loans, loan guarantees and other
forms of financial support; 2) technical assistance, advice, and business services; 3) general support
to owners of microenterprises and persons developing microenterprises including child care,
transportation, counseling and peer support groups; and 4) training and technical assistance or other
support services to increase the capacity of small business owners.
Page 19
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 17
In response to Mrs. Russell, Mr. Neaton noted that many small businesses fail due to lack of a solid
business plan, lack of funds, or lack of proper marketing. He stated that, with the use of CDBG
funds, the DDP hopes to provide assistance in these three (3) areas to microenterprises.
In response to Mrs. Russell, Mr. Perez requested that any negative reviews of the DDP be brought
to the attention of Mr. Neaton promptly so that they can be addressed.
Responding to Mrs. Russell, Mr. Neaton stated that the DDP is responsive to all prospective business
developers who approach the organization for assistance, including minorities.
Inresponse to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Perez indicated that the Small Business Administration would provide
technical assistance to the DDP in administering a loan program. Mr. Neaton added that $25,000
in the current departmental budget has been allocated to the DDP’s Incentive and Loan Program
Subcommittee, and that guidelines and procedures for loan administration are under development.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Neaton stated that the $42,000 allocation requested would be
supplemental to the $25,000 currently budgeted for a loan program. He indicated that $28,000 of
the CDBG funds requested would be dedicated to loans and $14,000 to providing technical
assistance to loan recipients to assist them in managing their businesses.
In response to Dr. McGlumphy, Mr. Neaton stated that CDBG funds will not be used to supplant
funding granted to the DDP by the City of Dover.
In response to Mrs. Harvey, Mr. Neaton explained that staff would be responsible for providing
documentation related to job creation and retention for the life of the loan.
In response to Mrs. Horsey, Mr. Perez stated that the statistics provided regarding the percentage of
low-to-moderate income individuals to be served reflect that individuals who wish to start businesses
must qualify for loans and, therefore, typically have some capital.
City of Dover - Streets Project
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, reviewed a grant application
for the City of Dover Streets Project - Concrete and Pavement Rehabilitation in the amount of
$203,000. He stated that the proposed locations for rehabilitation include South New Street,
Janes Road, and Mays Lane, noting that these locations must be confirmed with census data to
ensure that residents of these areas are on a low or moderate income census track. Mr. Koenig
explained that the proposed work on South New Street would include the removal and replacement
of old and deteriorated concrete sidewalks, curbs, and drains; however, concrete rehabilitation on
Janes Road and Mays Lane would be limited to drainage structures. He stated that the pavement
surface would be milled and repaved at all three (3) locations and accessibility improvements would
be made at all practical locations. Mr. Koenig noted that receiving CDBG funds would allow staff
to leverage additional funds for an overall City street program. He advised members that the
investment would be expected to last 15-20 years and would have an immediate and long-term
impact for residents in the area.
Mr. Ruane noted that the targeted sections of Janes Road and Mays Lane are situated in isolated and
neglected portions of the City which are not likely to receive State support.
Page 20
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 18
Housing Rehabilitation Program
Mrs. Tracy Harvey, Community Development Manager, reviewed a grant application, in the amount
of $50,000, for the City of Dover Housing Rehabilitation Program. She indicated that this program
provides repairs on owner-occupied homes for low-to-moderate income individuals and assists in
bringing these homes up to code. She stated that there is a high demand for this program, noting that
the waiting list has been closed since 2009; however, she still receives several calls weekly from
interested individuals. Mrs. Harvey noted that the project will focus on preserving existing housing
stock in the City, with the goal of rehabilitating four (4) to (5) homes, using up to $15,000 per
household to perform needed repairs. Mrs. Harvey advised members that this program would be
severely impacted if not funded during this grant cycle.
Homeownership Assistance Program
Mrs. Tracey Harvey, Community Development Manager, reviewed a grant application, in the amount
of $40,000, for the City of Dover Homeownership Assistance Program. She indicated that this
program provides first-time homebuyers assistance with down payment or closing costs, allowing
them to purchase affordable housing in the City of Dover. Mrs. Harvey advised members that there
is a high demand for this program and that CDBG funds would be used to provide up to $10,000
each to four (4) first-time homebuyers to assist in the purchase of properties in the City. She noted
that all purchasers must complete a homeownership counseling session with the National Council
on Agricultural Life and Labor Research, Inc. (NCALL) before signing a sales contract.
Review/Scoring of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Applications
Members reviewed and discussed the various CDBG grant applications to develop a score for each
applicant.
After a period of discussion, members conducted a review of each grant application and provided
individual scores on the CDBG Grant Application Scoring Sheet for applicants (as on file in the
Office of the City Clerk) and staff tallied the scoring sheets.
The Committee recommended that the full amount of CDBG funds permitted for public service
activities ($43,826) be dedicated for this purpose.
The Committee recommended to consider those applications addressing public service activities
(Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing, Connections Community Support Program, and the
Downtown Dover Partnership) separately from the non-public service applications.
Mr. Lewis moved to recommend that $10,000 of the City’s CDBG grant allocation be distributed
to Community Connections Support Program and the remaining non-public service funds be awarded
to the Dover Interfaith Mission for Housing.
The Committee recommended that $5,000 of the City’s CDBG grant allocation be distributed to
Community Connections Support Program and the remaining non-public services funds ($37,826)
be awarded to the Dover Interfaith Mission unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendations,
seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
Page 21
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 19
Members then scored the CDBG applications for non-public service programs.
Based on the scoring of the grant applications by the Committee, the Committee recommended
approval of the distribution of the City’s Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) monies for
non-public service programs as follows:
Amount Amount
Applicant Requested Recommended
RC&D $40,000 $ 40,000
City of Dover Streets Program 303,000 $ 65,580
City of Dover Community Development Projects:
Housing Rehabilitation Program $50,000 $ 40,000
Homeownership Assistance Program $40,000 $ 40,000
Dr. McGlumphy stated that he disagreed with the CDBG allocation process and did not believe that
the City should be involved in the process in this manner.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation for
the distribution of the City's Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) monies for
non-public service programs. The motion was seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a
unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
The Committee recommended to include a stipulation that all funds recommended for distribution
to the City of Dover Streets program be allocated to the rehabilitation of South New Street.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Special Parks, Recreation, and
Community Enhancement Committee Report of March 24, 2011, seconded by Mrs. Williams
and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
UTILITY COMMITTEE REPORT - MARCH 28, 2011
The Utility Committee met on March 28, 2011 with Chairman Ruane presiding.
Evaluation of Proposals - Energy Management Agreement
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, reminded members that on May 4, 2006, the City of Dover
entered into an Energy Management Agreement with Pace Global Asset Management, LLC (PACE)
to assist the City with its energy procurement, energy sales, purchase of fuels, establishment and
management of risk policies, development and management of hedging protocols, provision of
power plant oversight and bidding strategy, and related energy procurement processes. He noted that
this agreement will expire on June 30, 2011.
Due to the extreme importance of this contract, Mr. DePrima stated that a staff team (including
himself, Donna Mitchell, Controller/Treasurer; Ronald Lunt, Public Utilities Director; and due to
the confidentially of the various proposals, Mr. Kirk Betts, Counsel from Betts and Holt LLP) was
organized to solicit proposals from potential bidders. He stated that the team issued a Request for
Page 22
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 20
Qualifications to sixteen (16) firms and that seven (7) responses were received. After evaluating the
responses received, the team selected three (3) finalists and a Request for Proposal (RFP) was sent
to these parties. He noted that, as a part of the RFP request, the current Energy Management
Agreement was included in the package to be used as a basis for the new agreement. Mr. DePrima
advised members that on February 8" and 9", interviews were conducted with the three (3) finalists.
Subsequent to these interviews, he stated that a “best and final” offer was requested and due by
February 28" so that the team could have ample time to develop a final recommendation. He stated
that of the three (3) proposals that were submitted, one (1) was rejected as non-compliant and not
considered for the final recommendation; however, the proposals submitted by PACE and The
Energy Authority, Inc. (TEA) were comprehensive and fully complied with the RFP. A summary
of the recommendation from the team was provided to members, which included details of the
analysis.
Staff recommended that the City Manager be authorized to execute a five (5) year contract with an
annual fee of $996,000, plus additional services as required, with The Energy Authority, Inc. (TEA)
as per the terms of the RFP.
Mr. DePrima stated that TEA was less costly than PACE Global and will also bring a certain depth
of services, as well as an association with other power companies that the City currently does not
have.
In response to Mr. Snaman, Mr. Ron Lunt, Public Utilities Director, stated the importance of
understanding the structure of TEA. He explained that TEA is a creation of public power utilities,
rather than a vendor who provides services to members of the authority. Mr. Lunt indicated that
TEA members provide services to themselves; therefore, it is difficult to obtain references. He stated
that TEA’s largest utility customer is Orlando Utilities and that the presentation by TEA includes
an outline of its owners.
Mr. McGiffin questioned if the City would become an owner if the City entered into a contract with
TEA. Responding, Mr. Lunt stated that, at this point, the City would be taking services from the
authority as a customer. TEA currently provides services to 38 customers who are not members.
He stated that he has spoken with another customer of TEA, Franklin Public Utility District, who
indicated their satisfaction.
Noting that TEA has offices located in Florida and on the West Coast, Mr. Snaman questioned if
TEA has any offices in the Northeast and how long TEA has been in business. Responding,
Mr. DePrima stated that TEA became incorporated in 1997; however, he noted that all companies
in this business are new since these companies were created to address the deregulation of the
wholesale power market. In regards to TEA’s office locations, Mr. DePrima noted that there are
provisions in the contract that require TEA to be in Dover on a monthly basis to meet with City staff.
Responding to Mr. McGiffin, Mr. DePrima stated that TEA is a Limited Liability Corporation (LLC)
that has 14 members who are equitable owners (partners and members of the Board of Directors).
He noted that there are 38 additional power companies who are customers of TEA and, as he
understands, there is an option for a customer to become an equitable owner of the corporation,
explaining that it is not a closed LLC.
Page 23
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 21
Mr. Ruane referred to Exhibit #1 - Recommendation of Energy Manager and requested an
explanation of the cost reduction provided by PACE that imposes several new conditions, one of
which is a generation cumulative run-time limit of 100 unit run-hours/year (the sum total of all
run-hours of all units, including for PJM testing - over 100 hours triggers an hourly fee).
Mr. DePrima stated that in order to reduce their flat fee, PACE put a restriction on the run-time of
the plant, explaining that once the plant runs over the 100 hours, there would be an additional fee
for their services for running the plant. He confirmed that this was a factor in the development of
the recommendation.
Responding to Mr. Bonar, Mr. Lunt stated that, last year, there were several days that the plant ran
over 100 hours, noting that this past summer, there were 24 days that the plants ran over 100 hours.
Mr. DePrima stated that if there was a year that the plants were not run at all, there would be
approximately 100 hours of run-time for the required testing.
At the request of Mr. Ruane, Mr. DePrima explained that PACE provided two (2) proposals: one
based on a base fee and another based on PACE sharing the revenue acquired from the
Auction Revenue Rights (ARR), which is a transmission strategy to mitigate the cost of congestion.
He confirmed that the recommendation was based on the base fee proposal rather than the
ARR option, since specific amounts would be difficult to determine.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mr. DePrima stated that TEA has more experience with trading in various
energy markets and would bring a 24/7 experience to the City of Dover. Elaborating, Mr. Lunt
explained that the value of a trading floor is that they are always working in the markets and are able
to follow trends and flows of power marketing. TEA’s floor consists of several traders, working on
a 24-hour basis, who monitor power costs to discover opportunities to sell or buy power on a
short-term basis. He stated that having their own trading floor allows TEA to better estimate, follow,
monitor, and track where the power supply is and where the costs and possible revenues are as well.
It was his belief that TEA’s ability to continuously schedule and bid in the market may provide the
City an opportunity that would not be available otherwise.
Mr. Ruane noted that a representative of PACE has been involved with the 2030 Committee and
questioned the effect that a change in contract would have in this regard. Responding, Mr. DePrima
assured members that, like PACE, TEA has committed to providing basic services to the
2030 Committee and, if there are more detailed negotiations or contracts over and above the basic
services, they would be paid (as PACE is). Therefore, it was his feeling that, other than specific
individuals being different and there being a learning curve required, there would be no changes.
He advised members that the City will retain the services of PACE for the negotiations related to the
LS Power Project in West Deptford, New Jersey.
In response to concerns of Mr. Ruane, Mr. DePrima stated that the North American Energy Services
Corporation (NAES) is an independent company from PACE and that the contract with NAES is
effective for an additional year. He confirmed that NAES will remain responsible for the plant
operations at this time.
Page 24
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 22
As mentioned by staff, Mr. Ruane reiterated that PACE provided the City of Dover with excellent
service during the past several years.
Responding to Mr. Snaman, Mr. DePrima stated that TEA would be submitting a monthly report.
Mr. DePrima introduced Mr. Jamie Mahne, Member Services Manager for TEA, who will be
working with the City, serving as a project manager for coordinating services.
Mr. Mahne reviewed a Presentation - Overview of The Energy Authority. He relayed the importance
of a true partnership and that TEA does a good job at not only maintaining customer satisfaction but
also tracking customer satisfaction, which is part of TEA’s annual process. He advised members
that every employee of TEA is compensated based on the results of customer satisfaction surveys.
He indicated that TEA’s goal is to produce “extremely satisfied” results from customers. He stated
the importance of value focused delivery, and requested that if the City values a service that TEA
is not providing, that TEA be informed in order to make necessary changes.
Responding to Mr. McGiffin regarding the non-profit status of TEA, Mr. Mahne explained that there
are two (2) IRS private letter rulings indicating that TEA is a 501(c)(3) organization and, as such,
is tax-exempt and not permitted to provide services to “for profit” companies. (City Clerk's Office
Note: At the request of Mr. McGiffin, members were provided an explanation of TEA’s non-profit
status in an email dated March 30, 2011.)
The Committee recommended that the City Manager be authorized to execute a five (5) year contract
with an annual fee of $996,000, plus additional services as required, with The Energy Authority, Inc.
(TEA), as per the terms of the Request for Proposal (RFP).
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Utility Committee Report,
seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous roll call vote.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE REPORT -
MARCH 28, 2011
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met on March 28, 2011 with
Chairman Leary presiding.
Review and Recommendation - Filling of Critical Positions
During their meeting of February 23, 2009, members recommended approval of a Hiring Freeze for
Fiscal Year 2008-2009, but to allow the hiring of critical positions through the review and approval
of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee and City Council. It was suggested that
there be a “standing” agenda item to consider the filling of critical positions and, if there were no
positions to consider, the item could be removed.
Page 25
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 23
Administrative Assistant - Police Department
Police Chief James Hosfelt reviewed a request to recruit for an Administrative Assistant to the
Chief of Police. He advised members that a vacancy will be created with the retirement of the
Department’s current Administrative Assistant in December 2011. Due to the lengthy process
involved in filling a position within the Police Department, which requires a background
investigation, he requested permission to begin recruitment at this time.
The Committee recommended approval of the request to recruit for the Administrative Assistant to
the Chief of Police, as recommended by staff.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
FY 2012 Five-Year Capital Investment Plan (CIP) (Deferred on March 14, 2011 Due to Time
Constraints)
During their meeting on March 14, 2011, members deferred review of the FY 2012 Five-Year
Capital Investment Plan (CIP) due to time constraints.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, reviewed the FY 2012 Five-Year CIP and noted that all new
projects have been highlighted.
In response to Dr. Jones, Mr. DePrima stated that he would with consult Mr. Scott Koenig, Public
Services Manager/Director of Public Works, to determine if the Salt Storage Facility at Schutte Park
should be deferred until after the trial of the Brine Manufacturing System.
Responding to Dr. Jones, Mr. DePrima stated that there are no plans to provide air conditioning for
the Pitts Center at Schutte Park.
In response to Mr. Ruane, Mr. DePrima indicated that the Customer Notification System by E-IVR
Automated Dialing is similar to the Reverse 911 System, serving as a more cost-effective way of
notifying customers of disconnection, outages, etc. He stated that the Reverse 911 System was
included in the proposed budget and has not been included in the CIP because there are no
equipment costs.
With regard to disconnection calls, Mr. Bonar suggested that staff obtain customers’ permission to
leave such messages if there is no answer, since this could cause consumer credit issues and legal
ramifications.
The Committee recommended acceptance of the FY 2012 Five-Year Capital Investment Plan (CIP)
as presented.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
Page 26
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 24
Review of Hospitality and Civic Function Policy (Committee Deferred on March 14, 2011
Pending Additional Information)
During their meeting of February 28, 2011, members considered a request from
Mayor Carleton E . Carey, Sr. to include certain functions offered by the Central Delaware Chamber
of Commerce and Kent County Tourism in the City’s Hospitality and Civic Function Policy.
Mayor Carey noted that these events are not covered under the City’s existing Policy. At that time,
members deferred action and requested that Mayor Carey provide the cost for each of the events
listed and the annual cost for members to attend these events.
During their meeting of March 14, 2011, members were provided details regarding the costs
associated for members of Council to attend these functions and deferred action to allow staff the
opportunity to make revisions to the Hospitality and Civic Function Policy.
Mrs. Donna Mitchell, Controller/Treasurer, reviewed the proposed revisions to the Hospitality and
Civic Function Policy, noting that additions to the policy were noted in red font and deletions were
noted with strikeouts.
The Committee recommended approval of the revisions to the Hospitality and Civic Function Policy.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation
(Exhibit #1), seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar
absent).
Reallocation of State Bond Funds (Request of Councilman Bonar)
Mr. Bonar stated he did not feel that the City of Dover has been receiving its “fair share” of State
funding and that he made a commitment to take any action necessary to ensure this would be
accomplished. He reminded members that, several years ago, there was discussion
regarding building a civic center in the area at an estimated cost of $13M, including the purchase of
land. He stated that the Legislative Bond Bill Committee (under former Senator Nancy Cook and
the late Senator James Vaughn) allocated funds specifically for this project. To date, he noted that
there is $6M in the fund.
Mr. Bonar stated that, due to budgetary constraints, the City never took action on this project, other
than being involved in related discussions and studies. Since the City has not moved forward with
this project, and due to the current economic situation in the State, Mr. Bonar advised members that
the Governor wants to de-authorize the $6M in the fund and reallocate the funds to other projects.
Mr. Bonar stated that one (1) of the projects being considered is a soccer complex near Frederica that
would peripherally benefit the City of Dover; however, it was his feeling that since the funds were
allocated specifically for and within the City, they should remain dedicated to City projects.
Understanding that the State will need some of the funds from the account, Mr. Bonar suggested that
the City establish a group to meet with legislators to request that a significant portion of the $6M be
set aside specifically for economic development projects in the City that would benefit the residents
of the State of Delaware. As an example, he stated that the City is in early discussions regarding
the possibility of a combined-cycle natural gas generator to be built on the Garrison Tract in the
City of Dover. Mr. Bonar suggested that the City propose that the State allocate $4M of the $6M
Page 27
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 25
for the purpose of building roads, water, wastewater, and other infrastructure that will be necessary
at the Garrison Tract. He stated that this project would employ hundreds of workers during
construction and other employees once the facility is complete. He felt that this project would
benefit all residents of the City, as well as the State of Delaware, by reducing electric bills.
Mr. Bonar reminded members that the purpose of the $6M originally allocated to the City was to
encourage economic development and that the creation of jobs and a reduction in electric fees would
provide such economic development and a benefit to all residents. He noted that, in accordance with
the State Controller General’s Office, construction of these types of infrastructure improvements is
a permitted use for the allocated funds.
Mr. Bonar reiterated his request for the Committee to recommend that Council establish a committee
to encourage the legislators, the Bond Bill Committee, and the Governor to ensure that this allocation
is accomplished in this legislative year, ending July 1, 2011.
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mr. Bonar confirmed that, in addition to the proposed soccer complex,
a portion of these funds is proposed for the civil air terminal. He stated that the request for funds
exceeds $4M for both projects, and it is his understanding that the additional $1.5M to $2M would
be reallocated by the Bond Bill Committee.
In response to Mr. Shevock, Mr. Bonar stated that the Bond Bill Committee has not made a final
decision regarding the reallocation of the funds.
Mayor Carey referred to a letter received from the Chamber of Commerce requesting the City to
support their efforts in the re-allocation of these funds for the Kent County Sports Complex. He
suggested that members respond to the Chamber of Commerce regarding the City’s position in this
regard.
In addition to the infrastructure mentioned by Mr. Bonar, Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager,
indicated that there are 14 additional 10-acre lots available at the Garrison Tract for development;
therefore, an investment in the infrastructure would make 140 acres “shovel ready” for other types
of economic development at that location.
The Committee recommended that City Council authorize the formation ofa committee to meet with
and encourage State Legislators, the Bond Bill Committee, and the Governor to ensure that a
significant portion of the $6M, currently authorized for the construction of a civic center, be
specifically allocated for an economic development project within the City of Dover that will benefit
every resident of the State of Delaware, such as the construction of a combined-cycle natural gas
generator at, or infrastructure that will be necessary to, the Garrison Tract, and that this allocation
be accomplished in this legislative year, ending July 1, 2011, and that a letter be sent in response to
related correspondence received from the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce, dated
March 2, 2011.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation to
authorize the formation of a committee as recommended by the Legislative, Finance, and
Administration Committee and that a letter be sent to the Central Delaware Chamber of
Commerce (Exhibit #2). The motion was seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a
unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
Page 28
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 26
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Legislative, Finance, and
Administration Committee Report, seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous
roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
SAFETY ADVISORY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE REPORT -
MARCH 30, 2011
The Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee met on March 30, 2011 with Chairwoman
Williams presiding.
FY 2012 Five-Year Capital Investment Plan (CIP)
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, reviewed the FY 2012 Five-Year Capital Investment
Plan (CIP) and noted that all new projects have been highlighted.
Noting that the City’s Annual Contribution in the CIP has decreased, Fire Chief Jack Fortney advised
members that, prior to his taking office, an error was made on the reporting regarding the purchase
of Ladder 2. He explained that the information originally indicated that the loan would be paid in
2012; however, he stated that it will not be paid until September 2014. Chief Fortney also advised
members that Engine 7 was due to be replaced in 2013 at a cost of $584,997 (amortized over
seven (7) years with yearly payments of $83,571). He stated that he and other fire line reviewed the
need to replace Engine 7 and determined that, due to the economic situation, replacement of this
engine could be deferred since it is utilized as a spare. He explained that in 2015 Engine 3 will be
due for replacement, and it is planned to replace Engine 7 at that time and utilize Engine 3 as a spare.
Chief Fortney explained his request to outfit the heavy Rescue | truck at Station 1 with Holmatro
equipment. He stated that several years ago, the Fire Chief outfitted all engines with Holmatro
equipment; however, Rescue | was not outfitted and has Hurst equipment, which he advised
members is not interchangeable. Chief Fortney stated that it was necessary to have repair work
performed on the Hurst equipment recently and that the cost was over $2,100 and did not include
the power unit. At the time of the repairs, it was noted that new blades would be necessary. As a
result, the Chief stated that it would be necessary to make purchases either from Hurst or Holmatro.
In order for the equipment to be interchangeable and provide consistency, he requested funding, in
the amount of $56,234, to outfit Rescue 1 with Holmatro Equipment.
For informational purposes, Chief Fortney provided a Holmatro/Hurst Comparison Chart. It was his
opinion that Holmatro has surpassed Hurst in terms of technology.
Although not provided in the CIP report, Mr. DePrima stated that staff has included the standard
Street Improvement Program, budgeted $300,000 in the General Fund, and will seek
Community Transportation Funds. He stated that $50,000 has been included for the Sidewalk
Replacement Program.
Responding to Mr. Harmon, Mr. DePrima stated that when a fire truck is purchased, a bank note is
issued to the Fire Department and the sale of the old fire truck is generally used to finance the
equipment that will go on the new truck.
Page 29
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 27
The Committee recommended acceptance of the FY 2012 Five-Year Capital Investment Plan (CIP)
as presented.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation,
seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
Announcement of Public Workshop - Alternatives for the Clarence Street Extended Project
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, announced that the City of Dover, in conjunction with the
Federal Highway Administration, will hold a workshop to present recommended alternatives for the
Clarence Street Extended Project. He stated that these improvements are part of the City’s overall
“Strategic Development Plan for the West Side” to further enhance the downtown area.
Mr. DePrima stated that the Workshop will be held on Tuesday, April 12, 2011, from 4:00 p.m. to
7:00 p.m. at Union Missionary Baptist Church, 883 Lincoln Street, Dover.
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for acceptance of the Safety Advisory and
Transportation Committee Report, seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a unanimous
roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
MONTHLY REPORTS - FEBRUARY 2011
By motion of Mr. Leary, seconded by Mrs. Williams, the following monthly reports were
accepted by consent agenda:
Budget Report
Chief of Police Report
City Assessor Report
City Manager's Report
City Planner’s Report
Dover Fire Department Report
Capital Investment Plan (CIP) Report
APPOINTMENTS RECOMMENDED BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT HOGAN - AD-HOC
COMMITTEE TO MEET WITH STATE LEGISLATORS, THE BOND BILL
COMMITTEE, AND THE GOVERNOR REGARDING THE REALLOCATION OF STATE
BOND FUNDS
Council President Hogan recommended the appointment of Mr. David L. Bonar (Chair), Mayor
Carleton E. Carey, Sr., Mr. Anthony J. DePrima, Mr. Thomas J. Leary, and Mr. William G. Neaton
to serve on the Ad-Hoc Committee to meet with State Legislators, the Bond Bill Committee, and the
Governor regarding the reallocation of State Bond Funds. (City Clerk’s Office Note: See the
Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee’s recommendation of March 28, 2011, and
approved by City Council earlier in this meeting.)
By consent agenda, Mr. Leary moved for approval of the appointments as recommended by
Council President Hogan. The motion was seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried by a
unanimous roll call vote (Mr. Bonar absent).
Page 30
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 28
FIRST READING - PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2011-10, 2011 BUDGET REVISION -
TRANSFER TO GENERAL EMPLOYEE PENSION FUND
Council President Hogan reminded the public that copies of the Proposed Ordinance are available
at the entrance of the Council Chambers or can be obtained from the City Clerk's Office. Final
action by Council on the Proposed Ordinance will take place during the Council Meeting of
April 25, 2011.
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of
Proposed Ordinance #2011-10 as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
Proposed Ordinance #2011-10: 2011 BUDGET REVISION - TRANSFER TO GENERAL
EMPLOYEE PENSION FUND
COUNCIL MEMBERS ANNOUNCEMENTS
Council President Hogan announced that the Municipal Election will be held on Tuesday,
April 19, 2011, between 7:00 a.m. and 8:00 p.m. The polling places are: Elks Lodge #1903,
200 Saulsbury Road - 1* and 4"" Districts; Seventh Day Adventist Church, 647 Wyoming Avenue -
2™ District; and Dover Park Recreation Center, 1210 White Oak Road - 3" District. He noted that
to be eligible to vote, residents must have been registered to vote with the State of Delaware
Department of Elections by Thursday, March 31, 2011. Absentee Ballots are available and further
information can be obtained by visiting the City’s website at www.cityofdover.com or by contacting
the City Clerk’s Office at 736-7008.
Council President Hogan also noted that Wilmington Trust Company commissioned the design and
production of 100 collectible pieces to commemorate the new Dover Public Library. He displayed
the piece that he received and advised members that identical pieces were presented to the City
Manager and others during the groundbreaking ceremony for the new Library which was held on
April 5, 2011.
Mr. McGiffin reminded members to mark their calendars for June 25, 2011 for the next African
American Festival.
Mr. Salters announced that the Inner-City Cultural League is sponsoring an excursion to the
Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture on Saturday,
April 16, 2011, and that youth and adults from the City are welcome to participate. He stated that
those wishing to travel should meet the group at 54 South Kirkwood Street at 9:00 a.m. He noted
that the event is free; however, a permission slip is required for participants under the age of 16.
Mayor Carey announced that a fundraising luncheon will be held on April 14, 2011 from 12:00 noon
to 2:00 p.m. to benefit Miyagi, Japan. He noted that this event is sponsored by the State of Delaware
and co-sponsored by the City of Dover. Mayor Carey stated that donations will go to a fund
established by the State of Delaware at the Delaware Community Foundation, named the
“Delaware Fund for Miyagi, Japan.” He advised members that Iwanuma City, Miyagi, Japan is the
City of Dover’s sister City and a sister prefecture to the State of Delaware. Mayor Carey encouraged
all to attend and stated that donations are requested for the luncheon. Mr. DePrima indicated that
individuals can register for this event online at www.delaware.gov.
Page 31
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 29
By unanimous consent, the meeting was adjourned at 8:18 P.M.
TRACI A. MCDOWELL
CITY CLERK
All orders, ordinances, and resolutions adopted by City Council during their Regular Meeting of
April 11, 2011, are hereby approved.
CARLETON E. CAREY, SR.
MAYOR
/TM/jg
S:A\AGENDAS & MINUTES\Council-Minutes\2011\04-11-2011 COUNCIL.wpd
Exhibits to Original Minutes and File Copy
Exhibit #1 - Revised Hospitality and Civic Function Policy
Exhibit #2 - Letter to the Central Delaware Chamber of Commerce, Dated April 11, 2011
Page 32
vas
a eee
168:
28 oF THE FIRST
a
Oelawart
PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS, the employees of the City of Dover continue to work hard to provide the best
customer service to the residents of our community even during times of economic
hardship; and
WHEREAS, all employees of the City of Dover do their best, on and off the job, to
continuously promote Community Excellence through Quality Service; and
WHEREAS, due to the teamwork and the commitment of our employees, the citizens of
Dover are able to enjoy a community where the employees take pride in their jobs, in
order to make Dover a place where people love to live, work and play; and
WHEREAS, the City of Dover recognizes that every member of our work force is a
valuable asset and the success of our City is due largely to the pride and efforts that all
employees put forth.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, Carleton E. Carey, Sr., Mayor, of the City of Dover, Delaware
do hereby proclaim Friday, May 6, 2011
EMPLOYEE APPRECIATION DAY
in the City of Dover and recognize the dedication and hard work of all City of Dover
employees, and request that all citizens take a moment to thank a City of Dover employee
for their outstanding service to our community.
Carleton E. Carey, Sr.
Mayor
Page 33
PARKS, RECREATION, AND
COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE
The Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee Meeting was held on
March 14, 2011, at 6:00 p.m. with Chairwoman Russell presiding. Members present were
Dr. McGlumphy, Mr. Ruane, Mrs. Horsey, and Mr. Lewis. Members of Council present were
Mr. Leary and Council President Hogan (arrived at 6:34 p.m. and departed at 6:50 p.m.).
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
Mr. Ruane moved for approval of the agenda, seconded by Dr. McGlumphy and unanimously
carried.
Proposal by Chyenne Arsenault - Community Service Requirement for Graduation
During the Open Forum Segment of the Regular Council Meeting of March 14, 2011,
Ms. Chyenne Arsenault, 219 Beechwood Avenue, presented a proposal to introduce community
service as a requirement for graduation from high school in Delaware.
Ms. Arsenault reminded members that she attends Polytech High School, is majoring in
Environmental Science, and is required to perform 10 hours of community service each year in order
to obtain her technical diploma. She quoted a statement by Margaret Meade: “Never doubt that a
small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that
ever has.” She stated that her community service has provided many benefits, including connections
with people, a sense of responsibility about her place in the workforce, skills and knowledge related
to community service activities, and job opportunities.
Ms. Arsenault felt that instituting such a graduation requirement in all Delaware schools would
greatly benefit the youth of Dover, particularly those who do not have a sense of direction, and would
motivate them to make a positive contribution. She noted that community service could equip
students with work experience and letters of recommendation, both of which are helpful to young
people when applying for employment. Ms. Arsenault reminded members that area organizations,
such as the Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control (DNREC), Dover Downs,
The Salvation Army, and Adopt-A-Highway (as well as in-school programs, such as the
Future Farmers of America (FFA), have a need for volunteers which could be filled by students. She
indicated that a community service requirement would also enhance the reputation of Delaware
schools.
Ms. Arsenault encouraged members to support the institution of community service as a requirement
for graduation from high school in Delaware.
In response to Dr. McGlumphy, Ms. Arsenault indicated that, to her knowledge, no schools in
Delaware have a community service graduation requirement; however, many of the schools in
Pennsylvania and New Jersey do have such a requirement. She stated that not all “Shops” at
Polytech require community service as a graduation requirement.
Noting that this issue is not in the purview of the City of Dover, Dr. McGlumphy suggested that
Ms. Arsenault pursue this proposal with the Department of Education and discuss her proposal with
the Superintendent of Polytech High School. Dr. McGlumphy explained that each school district
Page 34
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT
COMMITTEE MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 2
develops their own criteria for graduation and that even schools within the same school district may
have different requirements. He also explained that there is a process involved and procedures that
must be followed by the State. Dr. McGlumphy suggested that Ms. Arsenault present her proposal
to Polytech High School, explaining that it would then be presented to the local school board rather
than City Council.
Concurring with Mrs. Russell, Mrs. Horsey commended Ms. Arsenault for her efforts and expressed
her agreement with the proposal as presented. She encouraged Ms. Arsenault to pursue the proposal,
through the process suggested by Dr. McGlumphy.
Mr. Ruane also encouraged Ms. Arsenault to pursue her proposal and suggested that, in addition to
the action suggested by Dr. McGlumphy, she contact local legislators for their support. He
concurred with Ms. Arsenault’s view that community service can instill a sense of responsibility and
relayed appreciation for her view that such service opportunities should be provided for all youth,
not just those that may be required to perform community service by the courts.
Mrs. Horsey moved to recommend acceptance of the report, seconded by Mr. Lewis and
unanimously carried.
Presentation of Master Plan for the Boys and Girls Club at Schutte Park
Mr. Zachery Carter, Director of Parks and Recreation, provided and reviewed a Map of the Schutte
Park Master Plan (Attachment #1) and a List of the Schutte Park Master Plan Improvements
(Attachment #2). He advised members that the Master Plan will be utilized in the development of
the Capital Investment Plan (CIP) during the next five (5) years. Mr. Carter noted that the map was
not yet finalized and did not reflect the realignment of Wyoming Mill Road which is in progress.
He also noted that the Facility Management and Construction Facilities were labeled incorrectly on
the map.
Mr. Carter indicated the location of the proposed Boys and Girls Club (shown on the map at the
intersection of (realigned) Wyoming Mill Road and Hazlettville Road), based on the information
provided by the Boys and Girls Club regarding the proposed size of the facility and parking area.
He reviewed the existing layout and future improvements proposed for Schutte Park. Mr. Carter
advised members of staff’s desire to expand the current John W. Pitts Center to accommodate all
Parks and Recreation Department staff, including those at the Dover Park Recreation Center on
White Oak Road, as well as an additional multi-purpose room. He explained that the list of future
improvements will meet the City’s needs for the next five (5) years and beyond.
Mr. Ruane relayed his support of the expansion of the pedestrian and bicycle paths; however, he
encouraged the development of access to these pathways. He reminded members that the
Bicycle/Pedestrian Plan developed several years ago had access to Schutte Park as a high priority and
explained the dire need to provide access to the Park from all areas of the City. He reminded
members that a study was conducted which indicated the need for a means for residents coming from
the New Burton Road area to access Schutte Park, in spite of the significant cost involved. It was
his hope that staff will include an access plan in the pedestrian/bicycle section of the Master Plan and
that staff include a time frame and associated costs with their proposal.
Page 35
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT
COMMITTEE MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 3
Responding, Mr. Carter stated that some of the plans, including projected costs, have been included
in the five (5) year CIP. In addition, he noted that the Kent County Metropolitan Planning
Organization (MPO) is currently in the process of developing a bike plan for Kent County. He stated
that it is hoped that this plan will include access to Schutte Park. He assured members that the City
will consider this project; however, he noted that there are other avenues that can be used to assist
the City in this regard.
In response to Mrs. Russell, Mr. Carter stated that air conditioning for the gym at the Pitts Center
was inadvertently omitted from the list of improvements and assured members that it will be
included in the future.
Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, thanked various staff members for their efforts in preparing
the Master Plan, explaining that it would have cost the City between $30,000 and $50,000 to engage
outside consultants for this purpose.
Mr. Ruane moved to recommend acceptance of the Conceptual Schutte Park Master Plan,
seconded by Dr. McGlumphy and unanimously carried.
UPDATES
The following updates were provided to members:
Puncheon Run Watershed Action Team and Flood Plain Mapping
Mr. Scott Koenig, Public Services Manager/Director of Public Works, advised members that a
Community Workshop was held on March 22, 2011 at City Hall to review improvements made to
the Puncheon Run Watershed area by the Delaware Department of Transportation (DelDOT) and
the Kent Conservation District, discuss one resident’s recent success in obtaining a Letter of Map
Amendment (LOMA), and identify other property owners who might be successful in pursuing a
LOMA. He reminded members that an electronic notice regarding the Workshop was distributed
and hand-delivered notices and mailings were distributed. There were 18 residents who attended the
Workshop.
Mr. Koenig stated that the resident from Shadow Court who was recently successful in receiving a
LOMA reviewed his application during the Workshop. Mr. Greg Williams, Department of Natural
Resources and Environmental Control (DNREC), reviewed a portion of the application process,
which he stated was available on the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) website.
Mr. Koenig noted that, since the Workshop, Mr. Ruane has worked diligently to secure assistance
from a local surveyor who was successful with filing a previous application. He noted that this
individual is providing information to area residents regarding the LOMA process.
Mr. Koenig stated his feeling that the Workshop was very successful and that positive feedback was
received from residents in attendance.
Mr. Ruane commended staff for the Workshop and presentation to the residents. He stated that there
are eight (8) residents who are moving forward in seeking a LOMA. He requested that staff continue
to assist individual homeowners in this regard.
Page 36
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT
COMMITTEE MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 4
Dr. McGlumphy moved to recommend acceptance of the Puncheon Run Watershed Action
Team and Flood Plain Mapping Update, seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.
Planning and Funding for New Library
Ms. Margery Cyr, Library Director, advised members that a groundbreaking ceremony was held on
April 5, 2011 for the New Library and thanked the City staff for their assistance with the event and
all of the supporters that attended. She relayed special appreciation to the Friends of the Library for
their contribution of food and refreshments.
Ms. Cyr displayed a collectible piece that Wilmington Trust Company commissioned for the Library.
She noted that only 100 such pieces were issued and that some of them were presented to the
Council President, City Manager, and others during the ceremony.
Ms. Cyr noted the receipt of a contribution by the Kent County Levy Court, in the amount of $1M,
which was presented to the City during the ceremony.
Ms. Cyr stated that the City has received three (3) large pledges for the New Library Project, which
will reduce the required construction loan amount to approximately $390,000. She assured members
that fundraising efforts will continue for contributions toward the loan and other projects related to
the Library and stated that she anticipated that these efforts will negate the need for a construction
loan for the project.
Dr. McGlumphy moved to recommend acceptance of the Update on the Planning and Funding
for the New Library, seconded by Mr. Ruane and unanimously carried.
CDBG Program
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, reported the Status
of FY 2009-2010 CDBG Projects.
Mrs. Horsey moved to recommend acceptance of the CDBG Program, seconded by Mr. Ruane
and unanimously carried.
Housing and Recovery Act of 2008 Funds (Neighborhood Stabilization Fund)
Mrs. Ann Marie Townshend, Director of Planning and Community Development, reviewed the
Update on the Housing and Recovery Act of 2008 Funds (Neighborhood Stabilization Program).
Responding to Mr. Ruane, Mrs. Townshend stated that property records are maintained by the
Tax Assessor’s Office, including any information regarding transfers; although the Code
Enforcement Program tracks banks and management companies to ensure that vacant buildings are
registered.
Mr. Ruane requested that vacant homes be placed on a future agenda for further discussion.
Mrs. Horsey moved to recommend acceptance of the Housing and Recovery Act of 2008 Fund
(Neighborhood Stabilization Fund) Update, seconded by Mr. Ruane and unanimously carried.
Page 37
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT
COMMITTEE MEETING OF APRIL 11, 2011 PAGE 5
Dover Youth Advisory Committee
Mrs. Russell reported that nine (9) new members of the Dover Youth Advisory Committee will be
sworn into office on April 12, 2011 at City Hall.
Dr. McGlumphy moved to recommend acceptance of the Update on the Dover Youth Advisory
Committee, seconded by Mr. Ruane and unanimously carried.
Dover SunPark
Mr. William Neaton, Economic Development Director, reviewed a Presentation - The Dover
Sun Park, a Community Solar Project (Attachment #3). He advised members that the project is
progressing ahead of schedule and that construction plans are anticipated to be completed by the end
of July. Tours of the site are being scheduled and will begin April 20, 2011. He noted that this has
been a great economic development project and relayed appreciation for the City taking the
leadership role for this project.
Responding to Dr. McGlumphy, Mr. Neaton stated that, although this facility will not result in a
lower utility bills for residents, the project demonstrates the City’s commitment to supporting green
energy. In terms of savings, Mr. Anthony DePrima, City Manager, stated that the solar project will
assist the City in complying with Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS) legislation requirements and
that the pricing that the City receives for hosting the site is much less than the cost of purchasing
solar power on the market. In addition, he stated that he anticipates that the cost of solar energy
should remain stable as fuel prices escalate in the future, resulting in projected savings.
Mr. Ruane moved to recommend acceptance of the Update on the Dover SunPark, seconded
by Dr. McGlumphy and unanimously carried.
Dr. McGlumphy moved for adjournment, seconded by Mr. Lewis and unanimously carried.
Meeting adjourned at 7:03 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Sophia R. Russell
Chairwoman
SRR/DD/jg/js/ac/tm
S:AAGENDAS & MINUTES\Committee-Minutes\2011\04-11-2011 PR&CE.wpd
Attachments
Attachment #1 - Map of the Schutte Park Master Plan
Attachment #2 - List of the Schutte Park Master Plan Improvements
Attachment #3 - Presentation - The Dover Sun Park, a Community Solar Project
Page 38
A A VEEN
PR&CE Committee Meeting of 04/11/2011
Schutte Park Master Plan
Future. wit
Pitt Center,
Future
Spray,
Park
Legend
aA Proposed Parking Lots
cA Proposed Sidewalks
Base ; ’ sas - 3 - Mulching
Operations
§ Scoreboard
"=~ Stadium Lighting
gl Buildings
@ Roads
@ Parking Lots
SS Ponds
Cc) Sidewalks
|| Sports Fields
ea Tree Line
/\) Stream
0 100 200
ees Feet
Date Printed: April 11, 2011
Date C d: March 18, 2010
Page 39
ATTACHMENT #2
PR&CE Committee Meeting of 04/11/2011
Schutte Park
Master Plan Improvements
Existing
Softball Fields — 4 Lighted
Multipurpose Fields
John W. Pitts Recreation Center
Parking
Picnic Pavilion
Play Equipment
Walking Path — 10’ Wide
Nature Trail
Cross Country Course
Future Improvements
Boys & Girls Club
Skate Park
Skate Spot
Spray Park
Addition to John W. Pitts Recreation Center
Existing Parking Improvement — pave/stripe/lights
Expand existing walking path — 10’ wide
Additional sidewalk connection — 6’ wide
Expand Nature Trail
Tennis Courts (2)
Lighted multipurpose field
Landscaping
Softball Field Improvements
o Fence Cap
Windscreen back stops
Quick Coupler Fixture to water infields
Dugout cover — shade
Soft toss stations
Bleachers
Scoreboard main field
o Restroom / Concession Area
Signage
o Electric Ave. Pitts Center Sign
o Sign on Pitts Center
o0000 0
Page 40
eae #3
PR&CE Committee Meeting of 04/11/2011
THE DOVER SUN PARK
A COMMUNITY SOLAR PROJECT
TIOZ/T1/70 JO Stso yy SoWTUUOD FY
t# LNAWHOVLILV
Page 41
SUBDIVESION
GARRISON OAK
TECHNICAL PARK
Whirl OAK ROAD
CITY OF DOVER- KENT COUNTY.
Page 42
Property Details
Location: White Oak Rd. Adjacent to DE RT. 1
Zoning: Industrial Park Manufacturing
(IPM2)
Acreage: 389 +/- contiguous acres
Environmental: Phase I & limited Phase II have
been completed and show that the property has no
environmental issues
Abatement: Both the City of Dover & Kent
County have economic tax abatement programs
available
Page 43
Property Details (2)
Utilities
Water: Existing 10-inch water main, 1210 gallons per
minute. 65 ps. Residual (White Oak Road)
Sewer: — Existing 4” Force Main (White Oak Road)
Electric: 69KV loop is located on White Oak Road. This
loop is connected to Dover’s new Cartanza
230KV/600MW Primary Substation
Gas: 4” gas line located on White Oak Road
Fiber Optics: The city of Dover has a 24 fiber optic cable
on White Oak Road which is part of the City’s 96 fiber
optic loop
Page 44
Our Footsteps
In July 2007, Delaware charted a leadership role in the
drive to repower our economy when the General
Assembly created one of the most aggressive solar
requirements of the twelve States with solar specific
mandates in their Renewable Portfolio Standards
(RPS).
Page 45
Footsteps...
In March 2008, the City of Dover, determined to shape
its green energy future, initiated a Request for
Proposals (RFP) for the development of long-term,
reliable, cost competitive and environmentally prudent
electricity for the citizens of Delaware.
Page 46
Footsteps...
After nine months of analysis, Dover selected a leading
developer as its partner in planning and constructing
the largest solar project in the Northeastern
United States to date: a Community-scale Solar
Photovoltaic Power Plant located on the City’s
Garrison Farm site.
Page 47
Energy Independence & Security
- The Project will supply enough power for over 1,300
homes in the community, using green energy from the
most abundant energy source available.
- Power from the Project will not be subject to volatile
natural gas, oil or coal markets providing electricity
price stability to our community.
- The Project output will not be subject to fuel supply
disruptions and international conflict.
Page 48
Solar Leadership
- The Project will help Delaware achieve its nation-leading
solar power goals by supplying over 30% of Delaware’s
required solar power production through at least 2015.
* Community-scale solar projects offer the most cost effective
method to meet Delaware's distributed generation and
solar power goals — over 2,000 solar rooftop systems would
be required to supply the same amount of clean energy as
the Project at more than double the cost.
¢ The Project will position Delaware to better comply with
future Federal environmental mandates regarding
renewable energy targets or reduced pollutant emissions
from power generation.
Page 49
Current Construction Status
April 11, 2011
Page 50
Planned Construction Packages
Surveying $ 45,000
Earthwork/Drainage $ 45,000
Concrete $ 235.000
Landscaping $ 45,000
Driven Piers (Installation Only) $ 485,000
Chain Link Fencing and Gates $ 220,000
Steel Support System (Installation Only) $ 510,000
PV Install (Labor) $ 160,000
Electrical Work $1,400.00
$3,145,000
Page 51
Subcontract Procurement
DESCRIPTION SUB CONTRACTOR
Civil & Site Development e George & Lynch
Surveying Becker Morgan
Fencing Forrest Fencing
Concrete George & Lynch
Pier Installation Pierce & Moretto
Metal Erection RC Fabricators
PV Installation RMI Associates
DC & AC Electrical Nickle
SCADA Nickle
Page 52
Construction Activities
Pier Installation Complete
Fence Installation Complete
Tracker Rows (81 Full & 7 Partial) Completing Punchout West side. Half
done on East Side
Drive Motor Pads Complete
Inverter Pads
DC Wiring Per Invert Pad
AC Wiring Per Invert Pad
Install Drive Motors All drive motors on West Installed
Install Inverters/Xmfr
PV Installation Prep work complete in Array 1-3
PV to be installed week of 3/28/20
Page 53
Construction Status 3/26/2001
Pier Installation” 6,536 6,536 100%
Fence Installation 8,800 8,800 100%
Tracker Rows* (811 Full rows 818 649 79%
& 7 Partial)
Drive Motor Pads 36 36 100%
Inverter Pads 7 O 0%
DC Wiring per Invert Pad 7 fo) o%
AC Wiring per Invert Pad 7 O 0%
Install Drive Motors 67%
Install Inverters/Xmfr 0%
PV Installation 0%
* Revised for 14 String
Design
Page 54
Construction Activities
Substation Construction
Breakdown Substation Additional Activities for this item will
be added when work starts.
Commissioning by Area Additional Activities for this item will
be added when work starts.
Performance Testing Additional Activities for this item will
be added when work starts.
Security Bennett Security on 24/7
Page 55
Construction Status 3/26/2001
Substation 0%
Construction
Commissioning by 1 0%
Area
Performance 0%
Testing
Page 57
Ci CO le tl il
-——_
Page 60
Prepared for: Regular Council Meeting
April 25, 2011
GENERAL FU
Property Taxes
Transfer from Electric Fund
Intrafund Service Receipts Electric
Transfer Tax
Business Licenses
Intrafund Service Receipts Water/Wastewater
Trash Fees & DSWA Rebate
Permits & Other Licenses
Transfer from Municipal Street Aid Fund
Fines & Police Revenue
Court of Chancery Fees
Transfer from Water/Wastewater Fund
Transfer from Civil Traffic Penalties Fund
Library Revenues & County Reciprocal Pymt.
Police Extra Duty Fees
Franchise Fees
Grants
Business Improvement District Tax
Other Miscellaneous Receipts
Interest Income
Transfer from Reserves
TOTALS
FY 11 March
Original YTD
Budget Receipts
$ 10,982,634 $ 10,844,057
8,856,000 8,856,000
3,374,945 2,315,604
1,000,000 1,220,910
1,523,675 1,454,281
972,889 661,590
2,387,511 1,675,408
934,000 710,833
526,843 395,500
581,502 504,371
645,000 435,100
930,000 557,318
524,189 431,173
300,000 230,292
486,000 273,869
831,850 440,746
52,692 49,902
294,250 315,912
224,000 39,027
$ 35,427,980 _$ 31,411,893
75.0%
% Budget
Received
98.7%
100.0%
68.6%
122.1%
95.4%
68.0%
70.2%
76.1%
75.1%
86.7%
67.5%
0.0%
59.9%
82.3%
76.8%
56.4%
53.0%
94.7%
107.4%
COMMENTS
Billed in July; Includes PILOT, tax penalties, & report fees
FY 12 reflects Latest Electric Forecast
FY 12 reflects FY 11 amount
Received 2 large receipts in December; $633,046 + $58,500
Adjustment based on current experience
FY 12 reflects FY 11 amount
Trash out-of-city customers reduced
Adjustment based on building permit fees received year to date.
Receipts to date through February 2011; Based on trend;
Adjusted to reflect Kent County formula change
Includes Capital School District receipts
Quarterly receipts in arrears; Based on experience
FY11 Increase due to demoliltion billings
CITY OF DOVER
FISCAL YEAR JULY 1, 2010 TO JUNE 30, 2011
REVENUE FORECAST
As of March 31, 2011
FY11 FY12
PROJ'D PROJ'D
$ 10,982,600 $ 11,133,400
8,856,000 6,338,000
3,341,500 3,341,500
1,400,000 900,000
1,470,000 1,524,000
958,300 958,300
2,193,000 2,050,000
892,000 934,000
526,800 526,800
638,900 639,000
715,000 690,000
- 424,500
1,000,000 1,000,000
435,000 435,000
373,500 373,500
520,000 520,000
1,012,500 831,600
52,700 52,700
396,000 294,000
116,000 192,800
17.4%
0.0%
88.7%
$ 35,879,800 $ 33,159,100
FY10
RECEIPTS
$ 9,977,466 $
6,758,100
3,159,199
867,795
1,464,341
900,164
1,340,730
960,427
626,833
675,390
548,020
791,583
465,387
418,479
520,157
653,492
52,118
282,274
145,869
236,582
FY09
RECEIPTS
10,022,288
6,758,100
3,417,682
1,198,064
1,436,715
965,917
1,396,801
1,163,233
791,306
628,928
738,240
564,810
694,220
514,458
386,770
507,135
133,864
53,113
308,495
239,185
$ 30,844,406 $ 31,919,324
Original FY 11 Budget versus Projections
$ 451,820 $ (2,268,880)
$ 5,035,394 $
3,960,476
Page 61
Prepared for: Regular Council Meeting
April 25, 2011
CITY OF DOVER
FISCAL YEAR JULY 1, 2010 TO JUNE 30, 2011
REVENUE FORECAST
As of March 31, 2011
FY 11 March 75.0%
Original YTD % Budget FY11 FY12 FY10 FY09
WATER/WASTEWATER FUND Budget Receipts Received PROJ'D PROJ'D COMMENTS REVENUES | REVENUES
Water Fees $ 4,206,700 $ 3,786,339 90.0% $ 4,800,000 $ 4,603,400 FY11 reflects higher usage & running of McKee Power Plant $ 4,274,966 $ 4,070,523
Wastewater Fees 3,308,300 2,782,577 84.1% 3,500,000 3,756,700 FY11 reflects higher usage & running of McKee Power Plant 3,015,856 2,351,885
Wastewater Adjustment Fees - County Trtmt 4,275,600 2,308,443 54.0% 3,000,000 3,090,900 3,100,547 3,733,644
Groundwater Inflow Adjustment - 883,074 0.0% 1,350,000 1,386,900 Separated Inflow Adj fee from WW Adj - -
Wastewater Impact Fees 323,000 179,550 55.6% 323,000 323,000 418,475 609,024
Water Impact Fees 357,000 161,025 45.1% 357,000 357,000 369,750 126,000
Water Tank Space Leasing 299,400 190,974 63.8% 299,400 307,600 293,154 325,720
Interest Income 1,515 7,590 501.0% 19,800 36,700 1,573 63,714
Other Miscellaneous Revenues 71,000 66,030 93.0% 58,000 58,000 58,848 67,771
TOTALS $ 12,842,515 _$ 10,365,602 80.7% $ 13,707,200 $ 13,920,200 $ 11,533,169 $ 11,348,281
Original FY 11 Budget versus Projections $ 864,685 $ 1,077,685 FY11 Projection versus Prior Year Actuals $ 2,174,031 $ 2,358,919
FY 11 March 75.0%
Original YTD % Budget FY11 FY12 FY10 FY09
ELECTRIC REVENUE FUND Budget Receipts Received PROJ'D PROJ'D COMMENTS REVENUES | REVENUES
Sales to Customers $ 96,595,300 $ 76,837,490 79.5% $ 97,917,200 $ 95,675,500 FY12 -Kwh Sales volume decrease 1.2% $ 96,158,794 $ 97,904,431
Purchased Power Adjustment (2,000,000) (1,558,578) 77.9% (2,293,600) (6,012,000) -
Utility Tax 1,864,800 1,483,375 79.5% 1,965,000 1,966,100 1,922,645 1,738,059
Emission Credit Sales - - 0.0% : - 275,214 167,682
Miscellaneous Revenue 1,206,616 974,699 80.8% 1,507,700 1,208,300 1,388,482 1,642,420
Interest Income 65,700 823,476 1253.4% 943,300 233,000 FY11 - Gain on sale of investment/bond reserve account 16,441 428,212
Intrafund Service Fees - Water/Wastewater 299,442 124,705 41.6% 173,300 175,000 179,360 191,247
TOTALS $ 98,031,858
$78,685,167 80.3% $ 100,212,900 $ 93,245,900
$ 99,940,936
$ 102,072,051
Original FY11 Budget versus Projections $
2,181,042 $ (4,785,958) FY11 Projection versus Prior Year Actuals
271,964
(1,859,151)
Page 62
) | Dower
Memorandum
Office of the City Manager
PO Box 475
Dover, DE 19903
Phone: (302) 736-7005
Fax: (302) 736-7002
E-mail: tdeprima@dover.de.us
To: Mayor and City Council
From: Anthony J. DePrima, AICP, ICMA-CM
City Manager
Date: April 18, 2011
Subject: Semi Annual Inspection — Robbins Hose Company
In accordance with Section 46-43 of the City Code, I performed the inspection of the Dover Fire Department on
April 15, 2011 with Chief Jack Fortney, Deputy Chief Patrick West and Administrative Assistant Rebecca
Rollison. This was my first annual inspection with Chief Fortney; all indications are that he is completely
knowledgeable of all operations in the department. The Chief reported that he is very satisfied with having an
“Administrative Assistant to the Chief’ on staff and that the consistent supervision being provided to the
dispatchers is working very well. He also reported that response times are down and the number of members
responding to calls is up.
All vehicles are in service and there are no major equipment problems. The Chief reported that the new Ladder
#1 will be delivered on July 1, 2011. I previously reported that this vehicle will be renamed “Truck #1”;
however, the Chief now reported that it will remain “Ladder #1”.
All buildings are in good condition. The Central Services Department continues to provide general maintenance
assistance. Internally the department has taken a number of measures to conserve energy. Security cameras
have been installed at Station #2. I reported to Council in my last report that the Department’s dispatching
computer server was down, that problem has been solved on a temporary basis, and the permanent solution is
budgeted for next year. Dispatching equipment is the responsibility of the city.
The Department has lined up Community Transportation Funds from area legislators for the replacement and
expansion of the front apron at Station #2 to improve maneuverability and safety. This project should be
completed this year.
Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or concerns.
ADJ/yml
ce: Fire Chief Jack Fortney
t:/City Manager/Robbins Hose Inspection/April 2011
P.O. Box 475, Dover, DE 19903-0475
Community Excellence Through Quality Service
Page 63
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor and Members of City Council
FROM: Traci A. McDowell, City Clerk
DATE: April 20, 201
SUBJECT: — April 19, 2011 - 2011 Municipal Election Results
Following are the results of the 2011 Municipal Election, as certified by the Election Board:
AT-LARGE
Prameela Kaza............... 625 (35.23%)
Thomas J. Leary.......
Total Votes Cast.......
Total Registered Voters
1,149 (64.77%)
1,774 (8.27%)
FIRST DISTRICT COUNCIL
James L. Hutchison, Sr...... 332 (58.76%)
Holly L. Malone............ 233 (41.24%)
Total Votes Cast............ 565 (8.80%)
Total Registered Voters. .... 6,418
SECOND DISTRICT COUNCIL
William F. Hare............ 413 (54.70%)
Eugene B. Ruane........... 301 (39.87%)
Karlton H. Schmidt. ......... 25 (3.31%)
Faye D. White. ............. 16 (2.12%)
Total Votes Cast............ 755 (14.17%)
Total Registered Voters... . . 5,327
THIRD DISTRICT COUNCIL
Howard Q. Earle. ........... 89 (21.60%)
Sean M. Lynn.............. 320 (77.67%)
DeWitt Peterkin II............ 3 (.73%)
Total Votes Cast............ 412 (6.99%)
Total Registered Voters... . . 5,896
/tm
S:\CAFS\ELECTION RELATED\2011 Election Results for Council Packet.wpd
FOURTH DISTRICT COUNCIL
David L. Anderson.......... 152 (64.41%)
Mark D. Harmon. ........... 38 (16.10%)
Marion L. Lott, Sr..........., 46 (19.49%)
Total Votes Cast............ 236 (6.19%)
Total Registered Voters... .. 3,813
Page 64
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: City Council AGENDA ITEM:
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Public Utilities - Water Division DATE SUBMITTED: 04-15-11
PREPARED BY: Ron Lunt, Public Utilities Director
SUBJECT: Evaluation of Bids — Route 13 Water Main Replacement
REFERENCE: CIP — Water Quality Improvement - Route 13 Water Main (Project WQ0907)
APPROVALS: City Manager, Controller
EXHIBITS: Financial Transfers
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $2,325,967.60 AMOUNT BUDGETED: $1,023,700.00
FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): Water Wastewater — Water Mgmt., FY 2010 Page 199.
This project is to be funded primarily through the Drinking Water State Revolving Fund Program (DWSRF)
which is administered by DHSS, Office of Drinking Water (ODW). Additional funds to be provided by allocating
resources originally planned to be used for other FY10 and FY11 Water Quality Improvements and Misc.
Distribution System Upgrades. See attached spreadsheet for further detail.
IMETABLE: Notice to Proceed to be issued within 30 days of Council approval. Project anticipated to be
completed in 180 calendar days.
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Approve the low bid submitted by Eastern States Construction Services, Inc. in
the amount of $2,325,967.60 for the construction of the Route 13 Water Main Replacement with financial
transfers as outlined in the attached spreadsheet. This approval shall be with the understanding that the
State of Delaware agrees to contribute $307,835.82 to the project, thus obligating $2,018,131.78 to the City of
Dover.
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
The City of Dover Public Utilities Staff identified the need for upgrading the existing six-inch (6”) water main
located in the southbound land of Route 13, between North State Street and King’s Highway. This project will
replace the existing main, which is undersized and experiences numerous main breaks, with a new twelve-inch
(12”) ductile iron water main. The new water main will provide City of Dover customers with improved water
quality, increased system reliability and improved fire protection. The proposal was advertised to the public as
a Request for Proposal in accordance with the City’s purchasing policy by the City’s Purchasing Agent under
Bid #11-0048DPU. Bids were opened on April 12, 2011. The following three (3) contractors submitted
proposals for the project.
Company Location Price
Eastern States Construction Services, Inc. Wilmington, DE $2,325,967.60
Brandywine Construction Company, Inc. New Castle, DE $2,873,391.00
Daisy Construction Company, Inc.* Dover, DE $2,513,951.10
* Daisy Construction Company, Inc. was deemed non-responsive, due to omitting statement of qualifications in
the proposal.
The City staff reviewed the Eastern States Construction Services, Inc. proposal package and found it free of
math errors and/or discrepancies and upon review was deemed the most responsive submittal. In addition,
City Staff has reviewed the contractor’s qualification information which included a list of recently completed
projects similar in scope to the Route 13 Water Main Replacement as well as their financial statement and
found all information to be adequate. In conclusion staff recommends awarding the construction contract to
Eastern States Construction Services, Inc. in the amount of $2,325,967.60 ($2,018,131.78 City obligation with
$307,835.82 State of Delaware contribution) for the construction of the Route 13 Water Main Replacement
Project.
Page 65
Route 13 Water Main Replacement
Financial Transfers
Summary of DWSRF Loan, Number D-4049
Original Budget
Total Loan Amount Available
Account Number Project Code Project Name Uday BYETE Actual Charges Encumb Budget Balance
417-6800-568.40-31 waos05_ | WQI-Bayard Ave S$ 533,510.00 | $ 206,117.93 | $ 180,000.00 | $ 147,392.07
417-6800-568.40-31 Wwaqo906_ _|WQI-East N. State St. S$ 846,807.00] $ 147,821.91] $ - S 698,985.09
417-6800-568.40-31 WQ0907_ _|WQI-Route 13 Water Main S$ 1,023,700.00 | $ 90,380.00 | $ 153,396.94 | $ 779,923.06
$
1,626,300.22
Summary of WQI Fiscal Year 2011 Projects
Account Number Project Code Project Name Original Budget | Actual Charges Encumb Budget Balance
417-6800-568.40-31 WQ1101 |WAQI-Loockerman Plaza S 110,000.00 | $ 42,090.77 | $ 57,909.23 | $ 10,000.00
417-6800-568.40-31 WQ1102_ |WQI-Columbia Avenue S 253,000.00 | $ 2,125.00} $ 7,875.00] $ 243,000.00
417-6800-568.40-31 WQ1103 _|WQI-Ross Street S 117,000.00 | $ 2,125.00} $ 7,875.00] $ 107,000.00
417-6800-568.40-31 WQ1104 =| WaQI-William Street S 10,000.00 | $ 2,125.00] $ 2,875.00] $ 5,000.00
417-6800-568.40-31 WQ1105 |WQI-W. Street West Alley S 10,000.00 | $ 2,125.00} $ 2,875.00] $ 5,000.00
Total WQ11 Amount Available | $ 370,000.00
Summary of Misc. Dist. System Upgrades
Account Number
Project Code Project Name Original Budget
Actual Charges Encumb
Budget Balance
417-6800-568.40-34
WwD1101 Misc Dist System Upgrades s 60,000.00
$ - |$ 11,353.00
$ 48,647.00
otal Misc. Dist. System Amount Available
$ 48,647.00
Money to be allocated from DWSRF Loan No. D-4049 to_
Route 13 Water Main Replacement:
$1,626,300.22
Money to be allocated from WQI Fiscal Year 2011
370,000.00
Projects to Route 13 Water Main Replacement: 9370,
Money to be allocated from Misc. Dist. System Upgrades $21,900.00
to Route 13 Water Main Replacement:
Total Money to be Allocated to
v §2,018,200.22
Route 13 Water Main Replacement
Route 13 Water Main Replacement Bid Cost -
City of Dover Obligation:
$2,018,131.78
Route 13 Water Main Replacement Bid Cost -
State of Delaware Contribution:
$307,835.82
Total Route 13 Water Main
Replacement Bid Cost:
$2,325,967.60
Page 66
PETITION TO AMEND AND ZONING DISTRICT
Applicants/Owners:
Address:
Location:
Tax Parcel ID #s:
Size:
Present Use:
Present Comprehensive
Plan Designation:
Present Zoning:
Proposed Zoning:
Reason for Request:
File Number:
First Reading before the Dover City Council
April 25, 2011
Walker Rd, LLC c/o Franklin Everett, Jr.
1151-1155 Walker Road, Dover
North side of Walker Road and west of McKee Road
ED05-067.18-01-79.00-000
1.904 +/- acres
Professional Offices
Office
C-PO (Commercial/Professional Office Development District)
10 (Institutional and Office Zone)
To allow for the establishment of shelters.
Z-11-04
Page 67
City of Dover 6a) Application No.: Z-11-04
Department of Planning & Inspections
Vale
Plan Title: Lands of Frank Everett, Jr.
Location: 1151-1155 Walker Road
Plan Type: Rezoning
Tax Parcel: ED05-067.18-01-79.00-000
Current Zoning: C-PO (Commercial/Professional Office) ae Dover Parcels
Proposed Zoning: IO (Institutional and Office Zone) Cc] Zoning
Owner: Walker Rd, LLC c/o Franklin Everett, Jr.
Date: April 15, 2011
Page 68
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
FIRST READING
CITY OF DOVER
PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2011-13
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE
CITY OF DOVER BY CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED
AT 1151-1155 WALKER ROAD
WHEREAS, the City of Dover has enacted a zoning ordinance regulating the use of property within
the limits of the City of Dover; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of zoning and planning to change the permitted use of
property described below from C-PO (Commercial/Professional Office Development District) to
10 (Institutional and Office Zone).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THEMAYORAND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
1. That from and after the passage and approval of this ordinance the Zoning Map and Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Dover have been amended by changing the zoning designation from
C-PO (Commercial/Professional Office Development District) to IO (Institutional and Office
Zone) on that property located at 1151-1155 Walker Road (on the north side of Walker Road
west of McKee Road), consisting of 1.904 acres, owned by Walker Road, LLC c/o
Franklin Everett, Jr.
(Tax Parcel: ED05-067.18-01-79.00-000; Planning Reference: Z-11-04; Council District: 4)
ADOPTED: *
S:\PACKETS\2011\Council\04-25-2011\A. Proposed Ordinance #2011-13 - Rezoning of Property Located at 1151-1155 Walker Road - First Rdg.wpd
Actions History
April 25, 2011 - First.Reading - Council
Page 69
a RON =
aan Onno
a0
18
19
20
21
FINAL READING
CITY OF DOVER PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2011-10
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DOVER, IN COUNCIL MET:
The amounts hereinafter named in various City funds are changed from the currently approved revenues/receipts
and appropriations to the revised revenues/receipts and revised appropriations for use by the various
departments of the Municipal Government for:
2010-2011 Budget Ordinances
A. GENERAL FUND - Expenditures
Current Additions Revised
EXPENDITURES Budgets (Reductions) Budgets
Pension Unfunded Liability $ 995,000 $ 454,978 $ 1,449,978
Current Year Balance 3,651,444 (454,978) 3,196,466
Net Adjustments $ -
B ELECTRIC REVENUE FUND - Expenses
Current Additions Revised
EXPENSES Budgets (Reductions) Budgets
Pension Unfunded Liability 833,000 277,477 1,110,477
Current Year Balance 10,947,900 (277,477) 10,670,423
Net Adjustments $ -
Comments:
1) Attached for reference is Ordinance 2011-09. See line numbers 102, 126, 329 and 348.
2) The General Fund current year balance meets the minimum policy requirement of 8%. The current balance
is 8.9% of revenue or $334,267 greater than the minimum requirement.
3) The Electric Fund current year balance meets the minimum policy requirement of 8%. The current balance
is 10.5% of revenue or $2,536,542 greater than the minimum requirement.
4) The total budget remains the same as in Ordinance 2011-09. The revisions have a zero sum effect.
Actions History: April 25, 2011 - Proposed Final Reading - Council
April 11, 2011 - First Reading - Council