This text was pulled from the PDF automatically and may contain mistakes. The PDF is the official record, so check it before relying on this.
Page 1
SPECIAL UTILITY COMMITTEE
AGENDA
April 10, 2006 - 5:45 P.M. - Council Chambers - City Hall - City of Dover
Public comments are welcomed on any item and will be permitted at appropriate times.
When possible, please notify the City Clerk (736-7008 or e-m ail at Jgreen@dover.de.us)
should you wish to be recognized.
AGENDA ADDITIONS/DELETIONS
1. Division Street Water Main/Bayard Avenue Water Main Project Budget Increases
2. Authorization to Purchase Security Fencing With Card Reader - Electric Department
and Power Plant
/tm
S:\ClerksOffice\Agendas&Minutes\Committee-Agendas\2006\04-10-2006 Special Utility.wpd
THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE
TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS.
Page 2
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: Utility Committee and Council AGENDA ITEM: 4/10/06 – 1 & 4/10/06 - 11
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Public Works DATE SUBMITTED: 3/30/06
PREPARED BY: Scott D. Koenig, P.E., Public Services Manager
SUBJECT: Division Street Water Main/Bayard Avenue Water Main Project Budget Increases
REFERENCE: N/A
RELATED PROJECT: N/A
APPROVALS: City Manager
EXHIBITS: N/A
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $1,270,000 +/- for Division Street/Bayard Avenue Water Main Upgrades
AMOUNT BUDGETED: $785, 866 plus an additional $227,348 transferred from other project budgets
FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): Pages 187, 202, 343 & 344 of the 2005 Annual
Operating Budget
TIMETABLE: The Time and Materials contract portion of the Division Street/Bayard Avenue Water Main
Upgrades will be completed during the first half of April.
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Recommend the transfer of up to $260,000 from the Water/Wastewater
Capital Asset (Brown Water) Reserve to the Division Street Water Main and Bayard Avenue Water Main
Projects.
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
The original intent for the Division Street Water Main Upgrade Project was to improve the water supply from
the east side of the City to the west side by replacing old 8-inch and 14-inch cast-iron pipes with a new 16-inch
pipe. In addition, the project became an important part of the City’s program to eliminate brown water.
Construction on the Division Street Water Main Upgrade Project began on Monday, September 19, 2005 and
has progressed continuously since that date under a Time & Materials contract with George & Lynch, Inc. The
contract was approved by City Council on June 13 2005. The project was budgeted in FY 04/05 at $660,000;
and $585,886 was carried into FY 05/06. The project budget was increased to $785,866 as part of the
November 14, 2005 budget amendment when it had already appeared that the project was running over the
projected costs.
A number of obstacles including unmarked old utilities, uncertain Miss Utility markings, changes in service
shutdown schedules, unexpected pavement materials (concrete vs. hot mix), and changing roadway restoration
requirements have caused significant construction challenges and cost overruns for this project. The cost
overruns were not detected in advance of the approved budget because a weekly cost monitoring system was
not in place. A weekly monitoring system will be required for all future Time and Materials contracts. Segment
1 of the Division Street Water Main Upgrade Project (from State Street to the St. Jones River) is now in service.
Segment 2 (from the St. Jones River to Bayard Avenue) is awaiting the results of bacteriological testing and
will be tied in and placed into service as soon as acceptable results are received. A few minor restoration
requirements for Segment 2 remain.
In addition, the Director of Public Works authorized the purchase of additional pipe to upgrade pipe from
Division Street to the Bayard Avenue Water Tank in January 2006 to address pipe issues associated with the old
Page 3
pipe segment located in Bayard Avenue. This pipe segment has been identified in various public presentations
related to brown water and is consistent with the Cast Iron Replacement/Relining project identified in the
budget document. It should be noted that $76,000 in pipe material costs could have been charged to the Cast
Iron Pipe Replacement Program which was funded in the amount of $100,000. However, it was decided to
simply add it to the Division Street Water Main Project.
The project costs for both projects as billed to date and estimated for March & April are:
FY-2006 Construction Project Start thru December 31, 2005 $ 582,484.85
January 2006 Invoice (including pipe material for Bayard Avenue) $ 409,120.99
February 2006 Invoice (labor, equipment & misc. materials) $ 147,610.93
March 2006 Invoice (labor, equipment & misc. materials) $ 100,000.00 (estimate)
April 2006 Invoice (labor, equipment & misc. materials) $ 30,000.00 (estimate)
Total $1,269,216,77 (estimate)
The construction obstacles and the additional pipe for Bayard Avenue have put the project $483,350.77 over
budget. Some of the cost overage has been addressed by transferring moneys from other project accounts as
follows:
Project $ Transfer Status
Cast Iron Pipe Replace WS0502 $ 100,000 - Both Bayard & Division Street meet objective of this
project fund.
Misc. Distr. Imp. WS0602 $ 30,000- Both Bayard & Division Street meet objective of this
project fund.
U.S. 13 N. Water Main Crossing WD0403 $ 35,000 - Project completed, these funds remain in account.
SE Water Loop WD0701 $ 8,000 - Project contracted, contract below budget.
Vehicle #681 (Water Fund Only) $ 41,850 - Purchase deferred, need will be re-evaluated by
Public Utilities Manager.
Construction Budget Lease (40-42) $ 12,498 - Leased Vehicle transferred.
Total $ 227,348
With the use of these transferred funds, the project is still estimated to be over budget by approximately
$260,000. The City Manager is requesting to transfer up to $260,000 from the Water/Wastewater Capital Asset
Reserve account to allow the project charges to be paid.
The George and Lynch contract work will stop on Division Street at Bayard Avenue. The Bayard Avenue pipe
will be installed by our own utility construction crew. How the new 16-inch Division Street Water Main west
of Route 13 will be connected to the line east of Route 13 will be re-evaluated by the Public Utilities Manager
and engineers to develop the most cost-effective route.
Page 4
ACTION FORM
PROCEEDING: Utility Committee and Council AGENDA ITEM NO.: 4/10/06- 2 & 4/10/06-10
DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Electric DATE SUBMITTED: 4/3/06
PREPARED BY: Steve Sax, Electric Department Director/ Scott D. Koenig, Public Services Manager
SUBJECT: Authorization to Purchase Security Fencing With Card Reader - Electric Department and Power
Plant
REFERENCE: N/A
RELATED PROJECT: N/A
APPROVALS: City Manager, Finance Director
EXHIBITS: N/A
EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $39,500.00 AMOUNT BUDGETED: $ 0.00
FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): Federal FY-2005 Homeland Security grant funds
(Physical Security Enhancements); this purchase was not part of the original FY-2006 spending plan for the
Electric Department.
TIMETABLE: Issue award letter on Tuesday, April 11, 2006, pending Council authorization. The target
completion date for the fence installation will be May 31, 2006.
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Authorize staff to use Federal FY-2005 Homeland Security grant funds to
purchase and install a 30 foot slide gate with all electric controls at the Electric Administration Building and
McKee Run Power Plant. Installation will be completed by the City’s authorized fence contractor, Duck’s
Quality Fences, using some of the items on the annual fence contract. The electronic components of this
purchase have been negotiated with the fence contractor. Staff will adjust the final budget to reflect this
purchase as well as the receipt of the grant funds.
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
The City of Dover has requested Federal FY-2005 (Physical Security Enhancement) grant funds for
improvements to various sites within the City of Dover’s utility systems. The proposed fencing project would
limit access to the rear of the administration building where equipment, vehicles, tools, and project materials are
stored. This project will also limit access to the Electric Department’s designated environmental hazard area.
In addition to the new fencing, an electronic gate reading card will be installed that will only allow access for
employees of the Electric Department and McKee Run Power Plant. This type of fencing was listed on the
City’s annual fencing contract which was awarded to Duck’s Quality Fences earlier this fiscal year. Duck’s
Quality Fences will complete the fencing installation for this project upon authorization by the City of Dover.
Electric Department staff is awaiting the signed authorization from DEMA for this improvement and will utilize
the sub-grant process offered by DEMA to complete the project. Staff is anticipating the written authorization
of the sub-grant from DEMA by April 11, 2006.
This purchase will be included in the final budget revisions and will be 100% reimbursed through the Homeland
Security Grant Program.