This text was pulled from the PDF automatically and may contain mistakes. The PDF is the official record, so check it before relying on this.
Page 1
EXHIBIT #1
COUNCIL M INUTES 6/13/2005
2005 TAX APPEALS HEARING REPORT AS OF JUNE 2, 2005 - STIPULATED VALUES
PRIOR STIPULATED
PARCEL # OWNER'S NAME COMMENTS
VALUE VALUE
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT, SALES
56818405 STEVE B. SCHMIDT 107,000 102,100 COMPARISON
APPRAISAL AND SALES
57620335 GARRY & PENNY SAROUKOS 297,900 258,200 COMPARISON
57606406 WILLIAM & MARIA BOULINE 99,600 94,200 SALES COMPARISON
DATA ERROR CORRECTION, SQ FT
ADJUSTMENT, SALES
57710135003 MICHAEL S. SHIFFLET 94,900 87,400 COMPARISON
DATA ERROR CORRECTION, SALES
65814101701 JAMES & BARBARA BROCKTON 112,800 86,000 COMPARISON
56818128 SK HOLDINGS - DOVER LLC 431,200 295,700 SALES COMPARISON
57718290 FREDERICK W. HERTRICH III 10,062,900 2,455,900 DATA ERROR CORRECTION
57709521 RIDGELY HOUSE & GARDENS LLC 417,200 328,300 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
57709526 HENRY R. HORSEY 357,600 262,000 DATA ERROR CORRECTION
DATA ERROR CORRECTION AND
57608516 ERIC O'BRIEN 87,000 67,600 SALES COMPARISON
DATA ERROR CORRECTION AND
65818123 FREDERICK TOLBERT 105,400 86,500 SALES COMPARISON
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT AND SALES
65814101110 NANCY OCHS 113,500 92,300 COMPARISON
5570011303 DOVER MALL LP 10,878,700 9,246,900 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
55700114 DOVER MALL LP 56,187,700 43,885,500 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
5570011302 DOVER MALL LP 19,505,800 14,767,800 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
AGRICULTURAL EXEMPTION
VALUE CORRECT ON HOUSE AND
6690010701 DALE CONARD 1,889,100 147,700 SITE
APPRAISAL AND SALES
58512423 JEFFREY & FRANCES WAID 185,400 174,200 COMPARISON
APPRAISAL BY OWNER AND
5680910903 CRISFIELD LLC 2,217,570 1,263,100 INCOME APPROACH ADJSUTMENT
5570011304 BERKS CTY REAL EST ASSOC V LP 15,897,200 14,784,400 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
57606664 ONE GREENTREE OFFICE CENTER LP 3,745,400 2,690,000 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
57606665 DOVER HUNT LAND CO. LLP 300,000 20,000 LAND RESIDUAL ADJUSTMENT
57606666 STEVENS/ANSTINE 1987-1 LP 3,973,800 3,973,800 NO CHANGE
57606667 GREENTREE VILLAGE CENTER LP 8,846,600 6,466,900 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
57606669 STEVENS/ANSTINE 1987-1 LP 1,208,200 925,000 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
57605344 YATES ANNE S 128,800 119,000 SALES COMPARISON ANALYSIS
FIRST STATE FEDERAL CREDIT
57607156 UNION 1,236,300 911,500 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
57608401 HARMAN OIL COMPANY 36,400 25,900 LAND USE ADJUSTMENT
57705323 HARMAN BROTHERS LLC 40,100 36,300 LAND USE ADJUSTMENT
Page 2
PRIOR STIPULATED
PARCEL # OWNER'S NAME COMMENTS
VALUE VALUE
RENOVATIONS NEEDED
57718107 HARMAN OIL COMPANY 88,900 76,100 UNLIVABLE
SHAPE, SIZE AND LOCATION. LAND
56818547 HARMAN BROTHERS LLC 43,800 35,600 ADJUSTMENT
56817331 HARMAN BROTHERS LLC 196,300 196,300 NO CHANGE
57706189 AMER AHMAD E 8,254,300 4,091,900 INCOME APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
5771312822 CAREY CYNTHIA M - TRUSTEE 330,900 297,800 SALES COMPARISON ANALYSIS
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT AND SALES
56715124 BENNER ELIZABETH V 104,900 102,000 COMPARISON
SQ FT ADJSUTMENT AND SALES
57609249 WEINTRAUB DENNIS & KAREN 198,000 187,400 COMPARISON
CLAYTON CHRISTINE S & GSELL
56709116 FREDERICK D 499,600 425,100 SQ FT ADJUSTMENT
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT, SALES
56713230 WELSH ROBERT D & LINDA Y 218,200 178,700 COMPARISON
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT AND STORY
56716201 LONG JAMES P 147,100 129,400 HEIGHT
66800127 WICH WILLIAM R 123,900 120,600 SALES COMPARISON
SALES COMPARISON, LAND
57712106 MCDANIEL BARBARA R 623,000 298,600 DEVELOPMENT RESTRICTIONS
55717134 MCDANIEL BARBARA R 160,400 145,800 SALES COMPARISON
ARELLANO LAMBERTO M MD &
57713252 LYZBETH REVOC TRUST 177,700 164,700 SALES COMPARISON
ARELLANO LAMBERTO M MD & SQ FT ADJUSTMENT, INCOME
5771714501 LYZBETH REVOC TRUST 526,900 355,700 APPROACH ADJUSTMENT
DATA ERROR CORRECTION AND
57705352001 QUINN JAMES P 107,100 77,700 SALES COMPARISON
DATA ERROR CORRECTION AND
57705353 QUINN JAMES P 116,100 78,400 SALES COMPARISON
56715116 MCNAIR JAMES D II 101,000 97,900 SALES COMPARISON
DATA ERROR AND SALES
56815206 DUPHILY JOAN T 49,300 34,500 COMPARISON
DATA ERROR AND SALES
56815207 DUPHILY CRYSTAL L 124,300 101,500 COMPARISON
DATA ERROR AND SALES
56716176 FENNEL CARLD & GENEVA P 147,500 144,600 COMPARISON
66800205 DIEHL DANIEL J & PATRICIA S 126,900 125,600 DATA ERROR
56612130 AUSEJO PLACIDO JR & AZUCENA 328,200 321,100 SALES COMPARISON
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT, SALES
66808109 SIMPSON ADAM E & SUSAN B 295,400 254,600 COMPARISON, STORY HEIGHT
57508105 RONSTON RICHARD & ELIZABETH A 179,100 179,100 NO CHANGE
DATA ERROR AND SALES
58508320 COAN STUART W & SUSAN S 190,400 163,400 COMPARISON
SQ FT, STORY HEIGHT AND SALES
57705233 MOSES DAVID & CECICILIA V 170,800 140,400 COMPARISON
57607102 BIEKER RICHARD F & KATHLEEN A 94,200 93,600 DATA ERROR
ERROR CORRECTION AND SALES
58508111 BIEKER RICHARD F & KATHLEEN A 191,400 165,800 COMPARISON
5771412101 ARMIGER BETH 137,200 133,100 LAND SIZE ADJUSTMENT
BUILDINGS REMOVED FROM
57709351 BRAUN PROPERTIES LLC 151,900 69,500 RECORDS
Page 3
PRIOR STIPULATED
PARCEL # OWNER'S NAME COMMENTS
VALUE VALUE
BUILDING REMOVED FROM
56720118 EDGELL ROBERT L 291,500 215,400 RECORDS
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT, STORY
56718208 DIX THOMAS J KATHRYN M 181,700 165,200 HEIGHT, SALES COMPARISON
56711153 PARKER JONH E & CYNTHIA L 160,400 155,600 SALES COMPARISON
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT AND SALES
57605306 ORVIS JANICE L 176,300 161,000 COMPARISON
66800204 DIEHL DANIEL J & PATRICIA S 107,600 107,600 NO CHANGE
ANDERSON SCHUYLER & SMITH
57606618 THOMAS G 98,800 95,000 DATA ERROR
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT AND SALES
5671920223 TMM HOLDING CORP LLC 497,100 264,300 COMPARISON
SQ FT ADJUSTMENT, SALES
56709169 MYERS ROBERT J & LUETT E 174,300 179,500 COMPARISON
66800124 HIBBLER CLYDE L JR 23,700 23,700 NO CHANGE
66800123 HIBBLER VERNA 79,100 73,100 DATA ERROR
66800126 HIBBLER CLYDE L 51,000 51,000 NO CHANGE
57709132 HIBBLER CLYDE L JR 14,100 14,100 NO CHANGE
DATA ERROR AND SQ FT
57612124 GRAY BEULAH 110,300 96,700 CORRECTION
154,734,670 114,242,900
Page 4
EXHIBIT #2
COUNCIL M INUTES 6/13/2005
2005 TAX APPEALS HEARING REPORT AS OF JUNE 2, 2005 - EXEMPTIONS
ORIGINAL ADJUSTED
TAX PARCEL ID OWNERSHIP VALUE VALUE RECOMMENDATION
05850820201 Capitol Baptist Church 62,800 62,800 Exemption Granted
057717310 Capital Grange No. 18 296,000 296,000 Exemption Granted
057717315 Capital Grange No. 18 57,800 57,800 Exemption Granted
057608429 Holy Trinity Church 28,300 28,300 Exemption Granted
444,900 444,900