Skip to main content
AskDover

CCW Packet

Council Committee of the Whole. Mar 11, 2025.

Open the PDF (7.6 MB)

This text was pulled from the PDF automatically and may contain mistakes. The PDF is the official record, so check it before relying on this.

1 page has little or no readable text here, often scans or drawings. See the PDF for those.

Page 1

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING

Tuesday, March 11, 2025 at 6:00 PM
City Hall Council Chambers, 15 Loockerman Plaza, Dover, Delaware

AGENDA

Public comments are welcomed on any item and will be permitted at the appropriate time. When possible, please notify the City Clerk (302-736-7008 or email at cityclerk@dover.de.us) should you wish to be recognized.

VIRTUAL MEETING NOTICE

This meeting will be held in City Hall Council Chambers with electronic access via WebEx. Public participation information is as follows:

Dial: 1-650-479-3208
Link: https://shorturl.at/2sDFQ
Event number: 2536 534 2110
Event password: DOVER (if needed)

If you are new to WebEx, get the app now at https://www.webex.com/ to be ready when the meeting starts.

CALL COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING TO ORDER

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

COUNCIL REPORTS - FEBRUARY 2025

  • 1.First District
  • 2.Second District
  • 3.Third District
  • 4.Fourth District
  • 5.At-Large
  • 6.Council President Anderson

1

Page 2

COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING - March 11, 2025 PAGE 2

PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE

ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA

  • 1.Review of Active Recreation Plan – The Old Post (Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) (Located at 55 Loockerman Plaza: Site Plan/Architectural Review Certification S-25- 07)

(Staff Recommendation: Approval of the Active Recreation Area Plan for the project subject to the conditions outlined in the Active Recreation Review Report)

ADJOURNMENT OF THE PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE MEETING

UTILITY COMMITTEE

ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA

  • 1.Water / Wastewater Rate Study Results and Recommendations (Kate Mills, Water Production Manager and Eric Callocchia, NewGen Strategies & Solutions, LLC)

(Staff Recommendation: Authorize the City Manager to bring forward the revised rates to City Council for implementation in July 2025)

ADJOURNMENT OF THE UTILITY COMMITTEE MEETING

LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE

ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA

  • 1.Review of Training, Conference, and Travel Policy (Patricia Marney, Controller/Treasurer)

(Staff Recommendation: Acceptance of the Training, Conference, and Travel Policy as amended)

  • 2.Installation of Security Fence at Police Department (Chief Johnson, Dover Police Department)

(Staff Recommendation: Approve the bid of $93,784 submitted by Pro Max Fence Systems, LLC and initiate project using Bond Bill grant funds.)

ADJOURNMENT OF THE LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE MEETING

ADJOURNMENT OF THE COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE

THE AGENDA ITEMS AS LISTED MAY NOT BE CONSIDERED IN SEQUENCE. PURSUANT TO 29 DEL. C. §10004(e)(2), THIS AGENDA IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE TO INCLUDE THE ADDITION OR THE DELETION OF ITEMS, INCLUDING EXECUTIVE SESSIONS, WHICH ARISE AT THE TIME OF THE MEETING

2

Page 3

City of Dover
Item 1.

DATA SHEET FOR RECREATION PLAN REVIEW

Review of Active Recreation Area Plan

PARKS, RECREATION AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE

MEETING OF March 11, 2025
Planning Commission Meeting of March 17, 2025

Plan Title: The Old Post at 55 Loockerman Plaza (S-25-07)

Plan Type: Site Development Plan: Active Recreation Area Plan

Location: Northwest corner of Loockerman Plaza and Innovation Way in Dover, DE

Tax Parcel: ED-05-077.05-04-53.00-000

Owner: City of Dover
Equitable Owner: Old Post, LLC

Property Area: 1.267 Acres +/-

Proposed Use: Mixed-Use Commercial and Multi-family Housing (Apartments – 36 dwelling units) and associated parking

Zoning: C-2 (Central Commercial Zone)
H (Historic District Zone)
SWPOZ (Source Water Protection Overlay Zone): Tier 3- Excellent
Recharge Area

  • I.Project Summary The Old Post project will be reviewed as a Site Development Plan and for Architectural Review Certification by the Planning Commission. The Plan proposes redevelopment of the 1.267-acre site formerly occupied by the Dover Post Office. The project includes the demolition of the rear warehouse portion of the existing building, the preservation of a 4,560-SF portion of the existing building for commercial space, and a proposed building addition of 31,500 SF for 36 residential apartments.

II. Active Recreation Area Plan Summary: As part of the Plan review process for this project, the applicant is required to provide open space and Active Recreation Area in accordance with the Zoning Ordinance, Article 5, Section 10.

Dover Code of Ordinances, Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 10 – Open Space, Recreation and Other Public Facilities (select excerpts).

Article 5 Section 10
Section 10. - Open space, recreation, and other public facilities.

  • P.O. Box 475 Dover, DE 19903 3

Community Excellence Through Quality Service

Page 4

S-25-07 The Old Post at 55 Loockerman Plaza Item 1. Summary Report of Active Recreation Component Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee Meeting on March 11, 2025

The City of Dover shall require the reservation of open space, recreation, and other public facilities in accordance with the provisions of this section as a condition of approval for all one-family dwelling, two-family dwelling and multiple-family dwelling residential developments requiring conditional use approval, site development plan approval, or land subdivision approval by the City of Dover Planning Commission.

10.1 Recreation areas. 10.11 Purpose. The purpose of this section is to ensure that active recreation areas are provided as an integral design element within residential developments and that such facilities are of an adequate scale in relation to the size of the residential development and which provide residents with a variety of active recreational pursuits.

10.12 Dedication required. The commission shall require the dedication or reservation of recreation areas, and the subsequent construction of recreation facilities of a character, extent and location suitable to the needs created by a development for recreation facilities as defined and in accordance with the design guidelines set forth.

10.13 Definition. The following are illustrative of the types of recreation areas and subsequent facilities that shall be deemed to serve active recreational needs and therefore to count toward satisfaction of the recreation area requirements of this section: tennis courts, handball courts, racquetball courts, swimming pools, saunas and exercise rooms, meeting or activity rooms within clubhouses, baseball and soccer fields, basketball courts, volleyball courts, swings, slides and play apparatus, and developed walking, jogging or biking trails.

Because the project is located within the Downtown Redevelopment Target Area, it qualifies for an exemption under Article 5, §10.515 Residential developments located within the Downtown Redevelopment Target Area as defined in Appendix C. Under this provision, the applicant must provide 75 square feet of active recreation per dwelling unit with a minimum of 2,500 square feet provided on site. See code excerpt: Article 5 §10.5 Exemption to recreation area and open space dedication. 10.51 Exemptions for small developments. 10.515 Residential developments located within the Downtown Redevelopment Target Area as defined in Appendix C. These developments shall be exempt from the area requirements set forth in section 10.16, but shall be required to provide 75 square feet of active recreation area per dwelling unit with a minimum of 2,500 square feet provided on site. If the commission determines that the construction of the entirety of the required active recreation area is not practical or desirable, the commission shall require a cash in lieu donation for the active recreation area determined as not practical or desirable. Cash in lieu shall be calculated in accordance with subsection 10.173 of this article.

The plan identifies a proposed dog run area between the building addition and Innovation Way, with an area of 2,482 SF, which is shy of the 2,700 SF required. The accompanying floor plan of the building includes a rooftop patio on the third floor of the building that measures approximately 404 SF. Then on the first floor there are bike storage facilities. The applicant did not submit a specific separate plan sheet for the Active Recreation Plan; information on these areas was gathered from the various plans and drawings of the submission.

This Active Recreation component must be reviewed by the Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee for a recommendation prior to consideration of the Site Plan by Planning Commission.

4

Page 5

S-25-07 The Old Post at 55 Loockerman Plaza Item 1. Summary Report of Active Recreation Component Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee Meeting on March 11, 2025

The following table provides information from the submitted Plans and drawings for The Old Post project showing the Active Recreation Area plan. This focuses on the amenities specifically being developed with this project:

Required Provided on Plan Active Recreation Area 75 SF per dwelling unit or 2,500 2,482 SF Dog Run (Article 5 §10.515) SF, greater thereof 404 SF Rooftop Patio 36 DU = 2,700 SF Bike Storage (Interior) Requires 2,700 SF Total: over 2,886 SF Active Recreation Accessible Dog Run access from sidewalk. Amenities Rooftop Patio on the third floor is (Article 5 §10.15) not fully accessible as the building does not include elevators. Active Recreation Age Oriented to development Amenities can be used by a variety Amenities of age groups. (Article 5 §10.15)

Parking The entire site has 62 parking
spaces to serve the residents with
other parking nearby.
Setbacks: 30 feet from Amenities do not include game
residential lots and 25 feet from courts that are subject to this
right-of-way for street requirement.
Landscaping The Landscape Plan shows trees in
the Dog Run area.

III. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS:

The following are comments and recommendations from Staff of the Department of Planning & Inspections and the Parks & Recreation Department following review of the Active Recreation Area proposed for The Old Post project.

  • 1.The project plan is required to provide 2,700 SF of Active Recreation Area. The Plan shows a 2,482-SF dog run and a rooftop patio area that measures approximately 404 SF. Additionally, there is an indoor bike storage area.
  • 2.The applicant should submit an Active Recreation Plan sheet that provides area calculations and details on the proposed dog run and patio areas.
  • 3.Staff recommends approval of the proposed Active Recreation Area amenities, subject to review of the Active Recreation Plan sheet to confirm details. Staff also notes that this location in the Downtown is in a walkable area where the sidewalk system leads to open space areas like Mirror Lake Park, Silver Lake Park, the Legislative Mall area, and The Green and to the Capital City/St. Jones Greenway trail system.
  • 4.The applicant is reminded of the requirements for construction phasing of the recreation area associated with the development of the residential units. With all residential units in one building, the recreation amenities will have to be completed in conjunction with the building’s construction and prior to issuance of a Final Certificate of Occupancy. 5

Page 6

S-25-07 The Old Post at 55 Loockerman Plaza Item 1. Summary Report of Active Recreation Component Parks, Recreation & Community Enhancement Committee Meeting on March 11, 2025

Article 5 §10.6 Construction Phasing. The recreation and open space areas shall be completed in a proportion equal to or greater than the proportion of residential dwelling units completed, except that one hundred (100) percent of the recreation and open space areas shall be completed prior to issuing building permits for the final twenty (20) percent of the dwelling units proposed. Building permits shall not be issued for dwelling units unless the requirements of this section are met.

  • 5.There shall be provisions which ensure that the common open space land (including active recreation area) shall continue as such and be properly managed and maintained. The developer shall either retain ownership and responsibility for maintenance of such open land; or provide for and establish one (1) or more organizations for the ownership and maintenance of all common open space i.e. a Homeowners Association. The organization shall be responsible for maintenance, insurance and taxes on the common open space.

IV. ADVISORY COMMENTS

  • 1.In the event that major changes and revisions to the Site Plan occur in the finalization of the Site Plan, contact the Department of Planning and Inspections. Examples include reorientation of buildings, relocation of site components, and increases in floor area. These changes may require resubmittal for review by the Development Advisory Committee, Planning Commission, or other agencies and commissions making recommendations in regard to the plan.
  • 2.The Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee shall submit to the Planning Commission a report detailing the recommendations as to the Recreation Area Plan.

Attachments: • Select Pages from S-25-07 Plan Set: o Title Sheet and Landscape Plan Sheet dated January 2025 • Select Floor Plan: Third Floor with Rooftop Patio • Select Pages from Architectural Graphics Set (from Historic District Commission Presentation: o Cover Page and Page 2

Note: This review Report was initially prepared by Staff of the Rossi Group (under a Planning Services contract with the City of Dover). The Report was completed with additional review and editing by the City’s Planning Office.

6

Page 7

Item 7.

SITE OLD POST

PRELIMINARY PLANS1
2
TAX MAP ID
ENGINEER
DATA COLUMN
2-05-07705-04-5300-00001
OWNERDEVELOPER

ST. JONES RIVER WATERSHED DAVIS, BOWEN & FRIEDEL, INC. CITY OF DOVER LIGHTHOUSE CONSTRUCTION, INC. 1 PARK AVENUE PO BOX 475 859 GOLF LINKS LANE SUITE 1 MILFORD, DE 19963 DOVER, DE 19901 MAGNOLIA, DE 19962 JAMIE SECHLER EQUITY OWNER G. MICHAEL GLICK PHONE: (302) 424-1441 OLD POST, LLC. PHONE: (302) 677-1965

EAST DOVER HUNDRED EMAIL: JLS@dbfinc.com 859 GOLF LINKS LANE SUITE 1
MAGNOLIA, DE 19962
EMAIL:MGLICK@LHCONSTRUCTION.COM

LOCATION MAP 1" = 1200' KENT COUNTY, DELAWARE

3DATUMHORIZONTALVERTICAL
DBF PROJECT NO. 2916A039 JANUARY 2025NAVD 83 (DE STATE PLANE)NAVD 88
4ZONINGEXISTINGPROPOSED
C2C2
5LAND USEEXISTINGPROPOSED
OFFICEMIXED USE COMMERICAL AND MULTIFAMILY
(36 DWELLING UNITS)

R1UBV 6 FLOODPLAIN THE PROPERTY IS IMPACTED BY THE 100 YEAR FLOODPLAIN AS DETERMINED BY

ION FEMA PANEL 10001C0167H , DATED MAY 5, 2003.

KINGS HWVAT
7GROUNDWATER RECHARGEALL OF THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED IN AN AREA OF GOOD GROUNDWATER

INN O
SITE
Y.
RECHARGE.

ST.8WELLHEAD PROTECTION AREATHE PROPERTY IS NOT LOCATED IN A WELLHEAD PROTECTION AREA.
ER MAN
WY.OCK
E. LO
9WETLANDSTHE PROPERTY IS NOT IMPACTED BY STATE AND FEDERALLY REGULATED

ISLA
WETLANDS.
LAZA
LEG
AN P
CK ERM 10 UTILITIES WATER SEWER
LOO CITY OF DOVER CITY OF DOVER
FED TIVE

OLD POST

ERAAVE.BLV
D. 11 CODE COMPLIANCE REQUIRED PROPOSED
.G JR
L ST
.
KINFRONT SETBACK0 FT0 FT
HER

KENT COUNTY, DELAWARE T. LUT HS N 5 FT 5 FT ORT MAR TI SIDE SETBACK E. N REAR SETBACK 20 FT 20 FT NWI WETLANDS MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT 125 FT 40 FT 1" = 400' PARKING 1 SPACE PER 2 BEDROOM APARTMENT, 62 PROPOSED SPACES (INCLUDING 3 1 SPACE PER 1 BEDROOM APARTMENT, ADA ACCESSIBLE SPACES), 29 SHARED 1 SPACE PER STUDIO APARTMENT, 1 SPACES WITH THE CITY OF DOVER ON SPACE PER 300 S.F. OF COMMERCIAL ADJACENT PARCEL (INDLUDING 2 ADA SPACE, 1 SPACE PER 4 SEATS/3 BAR ACCESSIBLE SPACES), 180 PUBLIC 2 STOOLS = 108 SPACES SPACES IMMEDIATLEY ADJACENT TO THE PROPERTY

WATER

INNOLOT COVERAGE85.00%78.54%
3
KINGS HWION
VAT
SITE
Y.
12AREAS
1NST.
WY.RMAPARCEL AREA1.267 AC.
OCKE
SITEE. LOIMPERVIOUS COVER0.995 AC. (78.54%)

COMMERCIAL PROPERTY LEG 13 PROPOSED LAND USE AREAS ZA 4 ISLA AN PLA C KERM 5 BUILDINGS/PARKING 0.864 AC. (68.19%) LOO 6 TIVE SIDEWALKS 0.131 AC. (10.34%) FED RMAN ST. AVE VD. OPEN SPACE 0.272 AC. (21.47%) W. LO OCKE ERA JR . BL . K ING TOTAL 1.267 AC. (100%) R ST. L ST LU THE O RTH RTIN MA . E. N

FEMA FLOOD MAP PANEL #10001C0167H SCALE: 1" = 1/2 MILE

SacB Lo

04008001200
HkBWLOCATION MAP
Y. INNO SCALE: 1"=400'

KINGS HW
VAT
SITE
ION T.
AN S
ERM
WY. E. LO
OCK

ZA LEG PLA ISLA N RMA CKE LOO INDEX OF SHEETS ERA TIVE FED PL-01 PRELIMINARY TITLE AVE . LVD J R. B PL-02 EXISTING CONDITIONS L ST ING . RK ST. . LU THE PL-03 PRELIMINARY SITE PLAN H TIN ORT MAR E. N PL-04 PRELIMINARY LANDSCAPE PLAN SOILS MAP 1" = 400'

P:\Lighthouse\2916A039 Old Dover Post\PRELIM\2024-12-19 PRELIM TITLE.dwg Feb 07 , 2025 - 11:20am WESC SOILS DATA OWNER STATEMENT

LABELSOIL NAMETYPE
HkBHandbrook Urban Land Complex, 0 to 5 Percent SlopesBI, THE UNDERSIGNED, HEREBY STATE THAT I AM THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY
DESCRIBED AND SHOWN ON THIS PLAN, THE PLAN WAS MADE AT MY DIRECTION, I
ACKNOWLEDGE THE SAME TO BE MY ACT AND DESIRE THE PLAN BE RECORDEDDate:
JANUARY 2025
ACCORDING TO LAW.
ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERSScale:
AS NOTED
12-05-07705-04-5500-00001IO ZONINGCITY OF DOVER35 LOOCKERMAN ST., DOVER, DELAWARE 19901Dwn.By:
CAW
22-05-07705-04-5100-00001IO ZONINGSTATE OF DELAWARE89 KINGS HWY., DOVER DELAWARE 19901
Proj.No.:
32-05-07705-04-5200-00001IO ZONINGCENTRAL DOVER OFFICES, INC.9 E LOOCKERMAN ST., DOVER, DELAWARE 19901G. MICHAEL GLICKDATE
2916A039
121 MARTIN L KING JR BLVD., DOVER, DELAWARE 19901LIGHTHOUSE CONSTRUCTION LLC.
42-05-07709-05-1300-00001IO ZONINGSTATE OF DELAWARE
859 GOLF LINKS LANE, SUITE 1
52-05-07709-05-1200-00001IO ZONINGSTATE OF DELAWARE60 LOOCKERMAN ST., DOVER, DELAWARE 19901MAGNOLIA, DE 19962
62-05-07709-05-1100-00001IO ZONINGSTATE OF DELAWARE401 FEDERAL ST., DOVER, DELAWARE 19901
ENGINEER'S STATEMENT
PRELIMINARY
I, JAMIE L. SECHLER, P.E., HEREBY STATE THAT I AM A REGISTERED ENGINEER IN
THE STATE OF DELAWARE, THAT THE INFORMATION SHOWN HEREON HAS BEENTITLE
PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION AND TO MY BEST KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF
REPRESENTS GOOD ENGINEERING PRACTICES AS REQUIRED BY THE
APPLICABLE LAWS OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE.

Dwg.No.:
by JAMIE L. SECHLER, P.E. DATE

PL-01
DAVIS, BOWEN & FRIEDEL, INC.
1 PARK AVE.
MILFORD, DELAWARE, 19963

7 THIS DRAWING, THE DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION FEATURES DISCLOSED ARE PROPRIETARY TO DAVIS, BOWEN & FRIEDEL, INC., AND SHALL NOT BE ALTERED OR REUSED WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION. COPYRIGHT © 2024

Page 8

Item 7.

CURVE TABLE CURVE RADIUS ARC LENGTH CHORD LENGTH CHORD BEARING DELTA ANGLE C1 376.09' 56.63' 56.58' N 85°59'35" E 8°37'38"

  • E.LOOCKERMAN ST. (KCR023) C2 386.09' 102.26' 101.96' S 82°43'09" W 15°10'31"

INNOVATION WY.

LEGISLATIVE AVE. (KCR72)

OLD POST N 17°58'44" W 377.04'

KENT COUNTY, DELAWARE 8SS 8SS 8SS 8SS

6FW 6FW

1-MV 1-MV 1-IO 8W
1-IO 1-IO 1-IO 1-IO 1-IO
PE
PROPOSED DOG
6FW
RUN 2,482 S.F. 8W

C1

PROPOSED 6FW
PE
3 STORY
8W

COMMERCIAL PROPERTY BUILDING ADDITION

N 69°42'19" E
32,010 S.F.
FF=21.50
6F

150.97'
W

8W

EXISTING AWNING
EXISTING 2 STORY PE
BUILDING TO REMAIN
5,770 S.F.
FF=21.50

C2
1-MV 1-MV 1-MV 1-MV 1-MV 1-MV 1-MV

1-MV

S 12°37'09"
E 58.64'
N 18°13'49" W 279.97'

PE PE PE PE PE PE PE PE PE PE PE PE

P:\Lighthouse\2916A039 Old Dover Post\PRELIM\2025-01-14 PRELIM PLANS.dwg Feb 07 , 2025 - 11:52am WESC Date: JANUARY 2025 Scale: 1"=20' Dwn.By: CAW Proj.No.: 2916A039

PRELIMINARY

LOOCKERMAN PLAZA LANDSCAPE PLAN

Dwg.No.:

0 20 40 60 PL-04 8 THIS DRAWING, THE DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION FEATURES DISCLOSED ARE PROPRIETARY TO DAVIS, BOWEN & FRIEDEL, INC., AND SHALL NOT BE ALTERED OR REUSED WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION. COPYRIGHT © 2024

Page 9

Item 7.

Room Legend 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom Building Storage Corridor A-201 I202 - Rooftop Deck A1 1 -

Stairwell
Studio

Old Post
Level 3

DNStudio2 BedroomStudio2 BedroomStudio2 Bedroom
Stairwell302030403060308031003120
0103

Building Storage
0303

Corridor
0301
E1
2
- A-201
I202
-

Stairwell
REV REV DATE DESCRIPTION

0104
- Firm Name and Address :
DN

  • •- Lighthouse Construction, Inc. 859 Golf Links Lane, Suite 1 Magnolia, DE
Rooftop DeckStudio2 Bedroom1 Bedroom1 Bedroom1 BedroomStudio
0302301030303050307030903110

Project Name and Address :

Old Post

Enter address here

Project : Sheet :

Old Post

B1
2
- Date :

A-201
I201
-

Issue DateI104
Scale :
Level 3
11/8" = 1'-0"
1/8" = 1'-0"

9

Page 10

Item 1.

THE

OLD POST

An Adaptive Reuse,
Mixed-Use Development

55 Loockerman Plaza | Dover, De
10

Page 11

Item 1.

PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT THE OLD POST

(2) 2,500 SF
RETAIL UNITS

36
APARTMENT UNITS

2,000 SF
BUSINESS

Apartment Entrance on Innovation Way

Proposed Development 2
11

Page 12

Item 1.

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

ACTION FORM

PROCEEDING: Council Committee of the Whole (Utility Committee) DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Water & Wastewater SUBMITTED ON: February 28, 2025 PREPARED BY: Jason A. Lyon, P.E., Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services REVIEWED BY: David S. Hugg, III, City Manager and Patricia M. Marney, Controller / Treasurer

SUBJECT: Water / Wastewater Rate Study Results and Recommendations TIMETABLE: Public Outreach to occur in Fiscal Year 2025, revised rates to be implemented July 1, 2025 RELATED PROJECT: X REFERENCE: X

EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $0

AMOUNT BUDGETED: $0

FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): N/A

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends City Council to authorize the City Manager to bring forward the revised rates to City Council for implementation in July 2025.

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:

In Fiscal Year 2025, the Department of Water & Wastewater operational budgets were approved to conduct a Water / Wastewater Rate Study. The City of Dover contracted with NewGen Strategies to conduct this study and provide recommendations. The City of Dover has not altered the water or wastewater rates since FY 2024. As infrastructure improvement project costs continue to escalate, along with material costs, staff realized that the water and wastewater rates must be altered if the City wants to be fiscally responsible and maintain functioning water and wastewater infrastructure. The study investigated the operational and capital budgets of the Water Division, Wastewater Division and Water Treatment Plant Division housed within the Department of Water & Wastewater. The five (5) year Capital Improvement Plan was utilized to forecast future projects and the impacts to the funds. The following principles were used by the consultant to guide the rate study and were developed with the assistance of City staff: • FY 2025 Operating Budget with reasonable escalation in costs. • Existing Debt payable by Water and Sewer Funds. • Capital Improvement Projects

12

Page 13

Item 1.

  • •FY 2024 customer and consumption data with modest in customer or demand based on planned development.
  • •Determine a long-term financial plan to fund water and sewer system operating and capital costs.
  • •Ensure appropriate Water Fund and Sewer Fund reserves.
  • •Calculate updated Water and Sewer Impact Fees Staff has reviewed the recommended water and wastewater rate alterations provided by the consultant. Staff agrees with the recommendations and finds the rates sustainable and equitable. Staff will be bringing forward the revised rates to implement in July 2025.

13

Page 14

Item 1.

March 11, 2025

WATER AND SEWER RATE STUDY RESULTS P R ESENTATION TO T HE CI T Y COU N CI L CITY OF DOVER

14

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC

Page 15

Item 1.

PRESENTATION CONTENTS

  • •Study Process, Data, and Purpose
  • •Capital Improvement Plan Forecast
  • •Revenue Requirements Forecast
  • •No Rate Increase Fund Balance Forecast
  • •Recommended Rate Increases
  • •Customer Impacts / Benchmark
  • •Impact Fees

15

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC

Page 16

Item 1.

RATE STUDY PROCESS

16
3
© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC

Page 17

Item 1.

Basis for forecasts: Study purpose: STUDY DATA FY 2025 Operating Budget with Determine a long-term financial plan to AND PURPOSE reasonable escalation in costs. fund water and sewer system Existing Debt payable by Water and operating and capital costs. Sewer Funds. Ensure appropriate Water Fund and Capital Improvement Projects Sewer Fund reserves.

FY 2024 customer and consumption Calculate updated Water and Sewer
data with modest in customer or Impact Fees
demand based on planned
development.
17

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 44

Page 18

Item 1.

CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN AND NEW DEBT $14.0 $2.50

Millions$12.0Millions
$2.00
$10.0
$0.79
$8.0$1.50$0.63
$0.42
$0.21
$0.04
$6.0
$1.00
$0.64$0.64$0.64$0.64$0.64$0.64
$4.0
$0.50
$2.0
$0.54$0.54$0.54$0.55$0.55$0.55
$0.0$0.00
FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027 FY 2028 FY 2029 FY 2030
FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027 FY 2028 FY 2029 FY 2030
PAYGOGrantsNew DebtImpact Fee ReserveWater - ExistingSewer - Existing
Water - NewSewer - New
18

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 5

Page 19

Item 1.

WATER FUND PROJECTION – NO RATE INCREASES

$16.0$16.0
I & E Fund
MillionsMillions
$14.0Transfer
$14.0

$12.0 Transfers Out
$12.0

$10.0$10.0
New Debt
$8.0Service$8.0
$6.0Existing Debt$6.0
Service
$4.0$4.0
Operating
$2.0Expenses$2.0
$0.0Total Revenues$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030Under FY 2025202520262027202820292030
Fiscal YearRatesFiscal Year
Ending Fund Balance
Minimum Reserve Policy
19

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 6

Page 20

Item 1.

SEWER FUND PROJECTION – NO RATE INCREASES $16.0 $16.0

MillionsMillions
I & E Fund
$14.0Transfer$14.0

$12.0 Transfers Out $12.0

$10.0$10.0
New Debt
$8.0$8.0
Service
$6.0$6.0
Existing Debt
$4.0Service$4.0
$2.0Operating$2.0
Expenses$0.0
$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030202520262027 2028 20292030
Total Revenues
Fiscal YearFiscal Year
Under FY 2025
Ending Fund Balance
RatesMinimum Reserve Policy
20

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 7

Page 21

Item 1.

WATER AND SEWER RATE INCREASE RECOMMENDATIONS

CurrentFY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
FY 2025 RateIncreaseIncreaseIncreaseIncreaseIncrease
Water Rates
Flat Rate$5.00$0.60$0.50$0.37$0.19$0.20
Volumetric Rate (Tier 1)$2.88$0.35$0.29$0.21$0.11$0.12
Volumetric Rate (Tier 2)$3.60$0.43$0.36$0.26$0.14$0.14
Volumetric Rate (Tier 3)$4.32$0.52$0.44$0.32$0.17$0.17

Sewer Rates

Flat Rate$5.00$0.15$0.15$0.16$0.16$0.00
Volumetric Rate$3.25$0.10$0.10$0.10$0.11$0.00
Ground Water Rate$1.84$0.06$0.06$0.06$0.06$0.00
KCSA Fee$3.41$0.41$0.15$0.16$0.17$0.17

21

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 8

Page 22

Item 1.

WATER FUND PROJECTION – WITH RATE INCREASES

$16.0 I & E Fund Transfer $16.0

Millions$14.0Millions$14.0
Transfers Out
$12.0$12.0

$10.0 New Debt Service $10.0

$8.0$8.0
Existing Debt Service
$6.0$6.0

$4.0 Operating Expenses
$4.0

$2.0$2.0
Total Revenues
Under FY 2025 Rates
$0.0$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030Total Revenues202520262027202820292030
Fiscal YearUnder NewGenFiscal Year
Rates
Ending Fund Balance
Minimum Reserve Policy
22

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 9

Page 23

Item 1.

SEWER FUND PROJECTION – WITH RATE INCREASES $16.0 $16.0

MillionsMillions
I & E Fund Transfer
$14.0$14.0
$12.0$12.0
Transfers Out
$10.0$10.0
$8.0$8.0
New Debt Service
$6.0$6.0
$4.0$4.0
Existing Debt
$2.0Service$2.0
$0.0$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030Operating202520262027 2028 20292030
ExpensesFiscal Year
Fiscal Year
Ending Fund Balance
Minimum Reserve Policy
23

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 10

Page 24

Item 1.

AVERAGE

INSIDE CITYFY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
RESIDENTIALWater Bill$16.52$18.50$20.17$21.38$22.02$22.68
CUSTOMERSewer Bill$25.36$26.12$26.90$27.71$28.54$28.54
BILL IMPACTKCSA Fee$13.64$15.28$15.89$16.52$17.18$17.87
Total Monthly Bill$55.52$59.90$62.96$65.61$67.75$69.09
Monthly Bill
$ Change$4.38$3.06$2.65$2.13$1.35

24

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 11 11

Page 25

Item 1.

Kent County$49.23$68.81$118.04
City of Salisbury$28.67$71.01 $99.68
City of Seaford$31.23$60.88 $92.11
City of Harrington$24.67$61.07 $85.73
Town of Smyrna$33.70$49.55 $83.25
Camden-Wyoming SWA$29.93$41.68 $71.61
INSIDECity of Newark$39.28$22.08 $61.35
RESIDENTIAL BILLTown of Georgetown$27.19$33.94 $61.13
COMPARISON:City of Dover (Rec. FY 2026)$18.50$41.40 $59.90
4K GALCity of Dover (FY 2025)$16.52$39.00 $55.52
MONTHLYTown of Middletown$22.48$32.22 $54.69
City of Milford $15.20$33.47$48.67
Artesian Water$48.18 $48.18
Tidewater Utilities$46.16 $46.16
Veolia Water$41.14 $41.14WaterSewerTotal

$- $20 $40 $60 $80 $100 $120 $140
25

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC 12 12

Page 26

Item 1.

WATER AND SEWER IMPACT FEES

Historical Buy-In MethodWaterSewer
Net Book Value (NBV) - All Assets$29,487,316$35,126,353
Less: Outstanding Principal on Debt($5,494,814)($5,214,306)
Total Impact Fee Cost Basis$23,992,502$29,912,047
Capacity Available (MGD)3.005.00
Unit Cost (GPD; in $)$8.00$5.98
Rounded Impact Fee per Unit (250 GPD)$2,000$1,500
Current Impact Fee$2,100$1,900

26

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC

Page 27

Item 1.

THANK YOU!
NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS ERIC CALLOCCHIA, PARTNER
900 BESTGATE ROAD, SUITE 402 ECALLOCCHIA@NEWGENSTRATEGIES.NET
ANNAPOLIS, MD 21401 27

Page 28

Item 1.

Draft Report | February 2025

Water and Wastewater Rate Study
City of Dover, DE

Prepared by:

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC

28

Page 29

Item 1.

900 Bestgate Road, Suite 402
Annapolis, MD 21401
Phone: (410) 266-9101

March 5, 2025

Jason Lyon
Director of Water & Wastewater / Engineering Services
City of Dover
P.O. Box 475
Dover, DE 19903

Subject: Water and Wastewater Rate Study Report

Dear Mr. Lyon: NewGen Strategies and Solutions, LLC (NewGen) is pleased to submit to the City of Dover our report detailing our completed Water and Wastewater Rate Study. This report summarizes our study’s results regarding the forecasted costs of providing water and wastewater service to the City’s customers and our recommendations for recovering these costs over the next five years. Our recommendations relating to revenue increases will result in the sustainable operation of the City’s water and wastewater utilities and the financial health of the City’s Water Fund and Wastewater Fund. We appreciate the opportunity to provide our services to the City and would like to express our sincere appreciation to City staff. The dedication and assistance provided by City staff was essential to the completion of this study. It has been a distinct pleasure to work with the City of Dover.

Sincerely,
NewGen Strategies and Solutions, LLC

Eric Callocchia
Partner

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability www.newgenstrategies.net 29

Page 30

Item 1.

Table of Contents

Section 1 Study Background and Scope of Work .............................................................. 1-1 Study Background ......................................................................................................... 1-1 Project Approach........................................................................................................... 1-1

Section 2 Revenue Requirements ...................................................................................2-1 Study Assumptions ........................................................................................................ 2-1 Operating Budget Escalation Factors.................................................................. 2-1 Water and Wastewater Operating Costs ...................................................................... 2-2 Water and Wastewater Capital Costs ........................................................................... 2-4 Existing Debt Service ........................................................................................... 2-4 Planned Capital Improvements .......................................................................... 2-4 Miscellaneous Revenues ............................................................................................... 2-6 Net Revenue Requirements ................................................................................ 2-7

Section 3 Water and Wastewater Customers And Usage ................................................. 3-1 Water and Wastewater Customers and Consumption ................................................. 3-1 FY 2024 Water Consumption and Wastewater Generation ............................... 3-2 Projected Water System Demand ................................................................................. 3-3 Projected Wastewater System Demand ....................................................................... 3-4

Section 4 Financial Plan and Cash Flow Projections ......................................................... 4-1 Minimum Cash Reserve and Debt Coverage Requirements ......................................... 4-1 Minimum Fund Balance Calculation ................................................................... 4-1 Cash Flow Projections at FY 2025 Rates ........................................................................ 4-3 Utility Fund Cash Balance Projection at Current Rates....................................... 4-4 Recommended Rate Increases ...................................................................................... 4-6 Utility Fund Cash Balance Projection at Recommended Rates ..................................... 4-6

Section 5 Recommended Rates ..................................................................................... 5-11 Recommended Revenue Increases ............................................................................. 5-11 Projected Rates under Current Rate Structure ........................................................... 5-11

Section 6 Customer Bill Impacts and Benchmarking......................................................... 6-1 Projected Customer Bills ............................................................................................... 6-1 Regional Bill Comparison............................................................................................... 6-2

Appendix A ....................................................................................................................7-1 Five-Year Water and Wastewater Capital Improvement Plan ...................................... 7-1

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Draft Rate Study Report 30

Page 31

Item 1.

List of Tables Table E-1 Recommended Water and Wastewater Rate Increases............................................ iv Table E-2 Projected Combined Water and Wastewater Monthly Customer Bill .......................ix Table 2-1 Operating Budget Escalation Factors....................................................................... 2-1 Table 2-2 Projected Water Operating and Maintenance Expenses ($ Thousands)................. 2-2 Table 2-3 Projected Wastewater Operating and Maintenance Expenses ($ Thousands) ................................................................................................................... 2-2 Table 2-4 Projected Water Fund Transfers ($ Thousands) ...................................................... 2-3 Table 2-5 Projected Wastewater Fund Transfers ($ Thousands) ............................................ 2-3 Table 2-6 Current Debt Service Obligations by Issue ($ Thousands) ....................................... 2-4 Table 2-7 Planned Capital Improvement Projects Summary ($ Thousands) ........................... 2-5 Table 2-8 Water CIP by Funding Source ($ Thousands)........................................................... 2-5 Table 2-9 Wastewater CIP by Funding Source ($ Thousands) ................................................. 2-5 Table 2-10 Projected Water Non-Rate Operating Revenue ($ Thousands) ............................ 2-6 Table 2-11 Projected Wastewater Non-Rate Operating Revenue ($ Thousands) ................... 2-6 Table 2-12 Projected Capital Revenue ($ Thousands) ............................................................. 2-7 Table 2-13 Water Net Revenue Requirement Projection ($ Thousands) ................................ 2-7 Table 2-14 Wastewater Net Revenue Requirement Projection ($ Thousands) ...................... 2-8 Table 3-1 FY 2024 Water Customer Accounts ......................................................................... 3-1 Table 3-2 FY 2024 Wastewater Customer Accounts ............................................................... 3-1 Table 3-3 FY 2024 Water Consumption (kgal) ......................................................................... 3-2 Table 3-4 FY 2024 Wastewater Generation (kgal) ................................................................... 3-3 Table 3-5 Projected Water Consumption in kgal ..................................................................... 3-3 Table 3-6 Projected Wastewater Generation in kgal .............................................................. 3-4 Table 4-1 Calculated Minimum Water Fund Balance Policy ($ Thousands) ............................ 4-1 Table 4-2 Calculated Minimum Wastewater Fund Balance Policy ($ Thousands) .................. 4-2 Table 4-3 Calculated Water I&E Fund Reserve Balance Policy ($ Thousands) ........................ 4-2 Table 4-4 Calculated Wastewater I&E Fund Reserve Balance Policy ($ Thousands)............... 4-2 Table 4-5 FY 2025 Water Rates................................................................................................ 4-3 Table 4-6 FY 2025 Wastewater Rates ...................................................................................... 4-3 Table 4-7 Recommended Water and Wastewater Rate Increases............. Error! Bookmark not defined. Table 5-1 Recommended Water and Wastewater Rate Increases............. Error! Bookmark not defined. Table 5-2 Recommended Water Rates .................................................................................. 5-12 Table 5-3 Recommended Wastewater Rates ........................................................................ 5-13 Table 6-1 Combined Water and Wastewater Monthly Customer Bills ................................... 6-1

Dover Draft Rate Study Report ii 31

Page 32

Item 1.

List of Figures

Figure E-1: Water Expenses vs. Revenues at FY 2025 Rates........................................................ i Figure E-2: Wastewater Expenses vs. Revenues at FY 2025 Rates ............................................. ii Figure E-3: Water Fund Balance Projection at FY 2025 Rates ................................................... iii Figure E-4: Wastewater Fund Balance Projection at FY 2025 Rates ......................................... iii Figure E-5: Water Expenses vs. Revenues at Recommended Rates .......................................... iv Figure E-6: Wastewater Expenses vs. Revenues at Recommended Rates ................................. v Figure E-7: Water Fund Balance Projection at Recommended Rates ....................................... vi Figure E-8: Wastewater Fund Balance Projection at Recommended Rates.............................. vi Figure E-9: Water I&E Fund Expenses vs. Revenues..................................................................vii Figure E-10: Wastewater I&E Fund Expenses vs. Revenues ......................................................vii Figure E-11: Water I&E Asset Reserve ......................................................................................viii Figure E-12: Wastewater I&E Asset Reserve ..............................................................................ix Figure E-13: Regional Bill Comparison – Average Residential Customer, 4,000 gal/bill .............................................................................................................................. x Figure 1-1: Cost of Service Process .......................................................................................... 1-2 Figure 4-1: Water Expenses vs. Revenues Forecast – Current Rates ...................................... 4-4 Figure 4-2: Wastewater Expenses vs. Revenues Forecast – Current Rates ............................. 4-4 Figure 4-3: Projected Water Fund Balance at FY 2025 Rates .................................................. 4-5 Figure 4-4: Projected Wastewater Fund Balance at FY 2025 Rates ........................................ 4-5 Figure 4-5: Water Expenses vs. Revenues – Recommended Rates ......................................... 4-6 Figure 4-6: Wastewater Expenses vs. Revenues – Recommended Rates ............................... 4-7 Figure 4-7: Water Fund Balance – Recommended Rates ........................................................ 4-7 Figure 4-8: Wastewater Fund Balance – Recommended Rates .............................................. 4-8 Figure 4-9: Water I&E Fund Expenses vs. Revenues – Recommended Rates ......................... 4-8 Figure 4-10: Wastewater I&E Fund Expenses vs. Revenues – Recommended Rates .............. 4-9 Figure 4-11: Water I&E Reserve Balance – Recommended Rates ........................................... 4-9 Figure 4-12: Wastewater I&E Reserve Balance – Recommended Rates ............................... 4-10 Figure 6-1: Regional Bill Comparison – Residential Customer, 4,000 gal/mo. ........................ 6-3

© 2025 NEWGEN STRATEGIES AND SOLUTIONS, LLC

Dover Draft Rate Study Report iii 32

Page 33

Item 1.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The primary goal of NewGen’s study was to develop a five-year forecast of water and wastewater rates to support the future costs of operating and maintaining the City’s water and wastewater systems. NewGen used the City’s FY 2025 operating budget and ten-year capital improvement plan as the basis for its projections with appropriate cost escalation for future years. NewGen’s study determined that the City’s FY 2025 rates are not sufficient to maintain the financial and operational health of the City’s Water Fund and Wastewater Fund over the next five years. The following figures show the expenses vs. revenues and fund balance projections if the City does not increase water or wastewater rates over the five-year planning period.

Figure E-1: Water Expenses vs. Revenues at FY 2025 Rates
$16.0
I & E Fund Transfer
Millions $14.0
Transfers Out
$12.0

$10.0 New Debt Service

$8.0
Existing Debt Service
$6.0
Operating Expenses
$4.0

$2.0Total Revenues Under FY
2025 Rates
$0.0
202520262027202820292030
Fiscal Year

Figure E-1 demonstrates that future revenues generated by the City’s currently effective water rates will not be sufficient to meet the costs of the system. Expense expansion including rising capital costs, inflated O&M expenses, and new debt service results in a level of cost that is unsustainable for the Water Fund at current rates.

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Draft Rate Study Report 33

Page 34

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

Figure E-2: Wastewater Expenses vs. Revenues at FY 2025 Rates
$16.0
I & E Fund Transfer
Millions $14.0
Transfers Out
$12.0

$10.0 New Debt Service

$8.0
Existing Debt Service
$6.0
Operating Expenses
$4.0

$2.0Total Revenues Under FY
2025 Rates
$0.0
202520262027202820292030
Fiscal Year

Similarly, Figure E-2 demonstrates that future revenues generated by the City’s currently effective Wastewater rates will not be sufficient to meet the costs of the system. The Wastewater System is in a much more sustainable position than the Water Fund, with some amount of cash balance and current revenue estimates that support the Fund entirely for FY 2025, however rising costs will need to be offset in the near future. The City has an established Water Fund and Wastewater Fund balance minimum policy that requires 60 days of annual operating and maintenance (O&M) costs, as well as a $250,000 minimum contingency reserve for each fund. As the City’s costs increase this fund balance policy will increase as well, ensuring the financial stability of the Water and Wastewater Funds. Figures E-3 and E-4 show the forecasted Water Fund balance and Wastewater Fund balance if the City does not increase any water or wastewater rates above the current FY 2025 rates.

Dover Rate Study Report ii 34

Page 35

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

Figure E-3: Water Fund Balance Projection at FY 2025 Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0
Current Rate Ending Fund
$8.0 Balance

$6.0 Minimum Reserve Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Figure E-3 demonstrates that the Water Fund is currently being managed in a way to keep the reserves close to the minimum reserve policy limit. This means that there is less room for a slower build in revenues to adjust to rising costs in the coming years, meaning that larger and more immediate rate increases are needed to prevent the Fund from falling below the minimum. At current rates, the Fund’s reserve balance would be depleted by FY 2028.

Figure E-4: Wastewater Fund Balance Projection at FY 2025 Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0
Current Rate Ending Fund
$8.0 Balance

$6.0 Minimum Reserve Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Figure E-4 shows that Wastewater is in a more sustainable position than the Water Fund. The Wastewater Fund Balance has room for a few years of cash flow losses were rates to remain unchanged, however the minimum reserve policy would be compromised by FY 2030. To remain above the minimum reserve policy rate increases will be required.

Dover Rate Study Report iii 35

Page 36

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

NewGen’s recommended rate increases calculated to maintain the financial health of the City’s Water and Wastewater Funds are shown in Table E-1 below. The increases are necessary to meet the future inflation adjusted O&M costs and capital investments required to support the City’s water and wastewater systems, while meeting the minimum reserve policy limits.

Table E-1
Recommended Water and Wastewater Rate Increases

($ increase per year)FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Water Rates
Flat Rate$0.60$0.50$0.37$0.19$0.20
Volumetric Rate (Tier 1)$0.35$0.29$0.21$0.11$0.12
Volumetric Rate (Tier 2)$0.43$0.36$0.26$0.14$0.14
Volumetric Rate (Tier 3)$0.52$0.44$0.32$0.17$0.17

Wastewater Rates

Flat Rate$0.15$0.15$0.16$0.16$0.00
Volumetric Rate$0.10$0.10$0.10$0.11$0.00
Ground Water Rate$0.06$0.06$0.06$0.06$0.00
Kent County Service Authority Rate (1)$0.41$0.15$0.16$0.17$0.17
(1) Kent County Service Authority (KCSA) rate is set independently of the City of Dover rate. It is a pass-through charge for costs related to wastewater treatment by the KCSA.

The following figure shows the Water Fund and Wastewater Fund expenses and revenues if the City adopts the rate increases shown in Table E-1.

Figure E-5: Water Expenses vs. Revenues at Recommended Rates
$16.0
I & E Fund Transfer
Millions $14.0
Transfers Out
$12.0
New Debt Service
$10.0

Existing Debt Service
$8.0

$6.0 Operating Expenses

$4.0Total Revenues Under FY
2025 Rates
$2.0Total Revenues Under
Recommended Rates
$0.0
202520262027202820292030
Fiscal Year

Figure E-5 shows that the recommended Water rate increases would account for the lowers starting fund balance by instituting rate increases in year 1 of the forecast period that would account for all expenses,

Dover Rate Study Report iv 36

Page 37

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

while trending the projected revenues towards a level that would accommodate increased expenses in FY 2028 and beyond.

Figure E-6: Wastewater Expenses vs. Revenues at Recommended Rates
$16.0
I & E Fund Transfer
Millions $14.0
Transfers Out
$12.0
New Debt Service
$10.0

$8.0 Existing Debt Service

$6.0 Operating Expenses

$4.0Total Revenues Under FY
2025 Rates
$2.0
Total Revenues Under
Recommended Rates
$0.0
202520262027202820292030
Fiscal Year

Figure E-6 demonstrates that inflationary increases over the length of the forecast period can keep the Wastewater Fund in a healthy position while minimizing the rate increases necessary. Figures E-7 and E-8 shows the forecasted Water Fund balance and Wastewater Fund balance if the City adopts each of the annual rate increases shown in Table E-1. The rate increases were calculated to meet expenses and keep fund balance above the minimum reserve policy, so the Water and Wastewater Funds are both projected to have fund balances at a healthy level above the minimum limit throughout the length of the forecast period. These projected balances are detailed below.

Dover Rate Study Report v 37

Page 38

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

Figure E-7: Water Fund Balance Projection at Recommended Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0
Ending Fund Balance
$8.0

$6.0
Minimum Reserve
Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Figure E-8: Wastewater Fund Balance Projection at Recommended Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0
Ending Fund Balance
$8.0

$6.0 Minimum Reserve
Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Dover Rate Study Report vi 38

Page 39

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

The City also maintains Improvement & Extension Funds for both the water and wastewater systems, which are utilized to fund the planned capital improvement projects. Each fiscal year, the Water and Wastewater Fund transfer operating and impact fee revenue to the I&E Funds to cover the projected capital costs of infrastructure improvements, maintenance, and rehabilitation. Figures E-9 and E-10 show the Water and Wastewater I&E Funds’ expenses vs. revenues in FY 2025 – FY 2030.

Figure E-9: Water I&E Fund Expenses vs. Revenues $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0 Capital Project Expense

$8.0

$6.0
Beginning Fund Balance &
$4.0 Revenues

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

The Water Fund begins with a cash balance in the I&E Fund, meaning that there is some amount of reserve money to draw down on in the early years of the forecast to minimize the rate impact on customers. This is done in FY 2025 and FY 2026 of the model, where I&E reserves are used to fund capital projects until the reserves are brought to a minimum level in FY 2027, at which points rates are funding the transfers to the I&E fund.

Figure E-10: Wastewater I&E Fund Expenses vs. Revenues $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0 Capital Project Expense

$8.0

$6.0
Beginning Fund Balance &
$4.0 Revenues

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Dover Rate Study Report vii 39

Page 40

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

Wastewater I&E fund balance is also used in year 1 of the model, but due to the higher level of capital expenses in the Wastewater Fund, as well as the lower beginning balance, it plays less of a role in minimizing rate increases going forward.

The forecasted transfers to the I&E Funds required to fund the City’s PAYGO capital projects are a component of the Water and Wastewater Fund’s revenue requirements and are taken into consideration in NewGen’s calculated rate increase recommendations. The City has also established a minimum reserve policy for the Water and Wastewater I&E Funds in regard to asset reserve. The policy requires that each Improvement and Extension Fund maintain a Capital Asset Reserve of $500,000, as well as an Impact Fee Reserve equal to $1.5 million for the Water I&E Fund and 20% of revenue for the Wastewater I&E Fund. If at any point these asset reserves dip below the minimum a transfer would be made from the I&E Funds into these reserves, resulting in an increases capital project expenses burden in those years. The asset reserves are currently funded and throughout the length of the forecast period any draw down on reserves is replaced by either rate revenues or impact fee revenues. Figures E-11 and E-12 show the forecasted I&E Fund balances over the five-year study period.

Figure E-11: Water I&E Asset Reserve
$16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0Impact Fee Reserve
Balance
$10.0
Capital Asset
$8.0Reserve Balance

$6.0 Minimimum
Reserve Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Dover Rate Study Report viii 40

Page 41

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

Figure E-12: Wastewater I&E Asset Reserve
$16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0Impact Fee Reserve
Balance
$10.0
Capital Asset
$8.0Reserve Balance

$6.0 Minimimum
Reserve Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

The City currently charges a monthly flat rate per active meter, as well as inclining block, tiered volumetric rates per 1,000 gallons of usage to fund the water system. The City charges the same flat rate per active meter to fund the wastewater system, plus an all-volume volumetric rate and a ground water rate. City customers are also charged a Kent County Service Agreement (KCSA) fee per 1,000 gallons of wastewater usage for the treatment of sewage by Kent County. The average Inside City residential customer uses 4,000 gallons of water per monthly billing period. Table E-2 shows the impact of the recommended rate increases on the average Inside City residential customers under the current rate structure.

Table E-2
Projected Combined Water and Wastewater Monthly Customer Bill

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Average Use – 4 kgal
Water Bill$16.52$18.50$20.17$21.38$22.02$22.68
Wastewater Bill$25.36$26.12$26.90$27.71$28.54$28.54
KCSA Fee$13.64$15.28$15.89$16.52$17.18$17.87
Combined Total Bill$55.52$59.90$62.96$65.61$67.75$69.09
$ Change$4.38$3.06$2.65$2.13$1.35

Dover Rate Study Report ix 41

Page 42

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Item 1.

If the City adopts the rates recommended in this report in FY 2026, then the City’s combined water and wastewater bill for an average City customer would remain below the average of similar utilities in the region, as shown in Figure E-13.

Figure E-13: Regional Bill Comparison – Average Residential Customer, 4,000 gal/bill

Kent County $49.23 $68.81 $118.04

City of Salisbury $28.67 $71.01 $99.68

City of Seaford $31.23 $60.88 $92.11

City of Harrington $24.67 $61.07 $85.73

Town of Smyrna $33.70 $49.55 $83.25

Camden-Wyoming SWA $29.93 $41.68 $71.61

City of Newark $39.28 $22.08 $61.35

Town of Georgetown $27.19 $33.94 $61.13

City of Dover (Rec. FY 2026) $18.50 $41.40 $59.90

City of Dover (FY 2025) $16.52 $39.00 $55.52

Town of Middletown $22.48 $32.22 $54.69

City of Milford $15.20 $33.47 $48.67

Artesian Water $48.18 $48.18

Tidewater Utilities $46.16 $46.16

Veolia Water $41.14 $41.14

$- $20 $40 $60 $80 $100 $120 $140

Dover Rate Study Report x 42

Page 43

Item 1.

Section 1
STUDY BACKGROUND AND SCOPE OF WORK

Study Background The City of Dover is in Kent County, Delaware, United States, and is the Delaware State Capital. The City of Dover’s Public Utilities Department maintains watermain and sanitary wastewater infrastructure. The City of Dover operates and maintains a water system with a treatment and distribution capacity of 11.428 MGD. The system’s infrastructure is comprised of 14 deep production wells, a shallow well field consisting of 6 production wells that supply water to the City’s Water Treatment Plant, 7 elevated storage tanks with a combined capacity of 5.25 million gallons, and approximately 233 miles of water main. The distribution system also contains over 1,800 fire hydrants and 9,500 division valves. The City’s wastewater system includes 44 pumping stations and approximately 160 miles of gravity sanitary wastewater mains. The wastewater collected by the City is sent to the Kent County Wastewater Treatment Plant for treatment. The City of Dover sends an average daily flow of 4.7 million gallons to the Kent County wastewater system. The City engaged NewGen Strategies and Solutions, LLC (NewGen) to complete a Water and Wastewater Rate Study to ensure that the City’s water and wastewater rates are sufficient to generate the revenue necessary to operate, maintain, repair, rehabilitate, and replace the City’s utility systems while also maintaining appropriate Water Fund and Wastewater Fund reserves.

Project Approach NewGen’s approach to reviewing and evaluating municipal utility rates is governed by the view that the ideal rate structure must satisfy seven criteria:  Equity requires that rates and charges result in no undue discrimination among customers or customer classes. Although equity is normally related to the cost of service, it should be realized that customer acceptance will center on preconceived notions of equity and fairness.  Efficiency refers to the ability of the rate schedule to encourage wise use of the resources devoted to the services that the utility provides. • Rates should reflect the cost of providing service. • Rates should be similar for customers or customer classes served under similar conditions. • Customers should be able to understand the rate schedules so that they can make rational decisions regarding their purchase of additional service(s).  Revenue Adequacy is the most fundamental of all considerations, as it recognizes that rates are cost driven. When evaluating any rate structure, the rates must produce revenues sufficient to operate the system and those rates produce sufficient revenues if there are changes in demand for service.  Affordability means that the recommended rates must result in bills that are realistically within the ability of customers to pay.

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Rate Study Report 43

Page 44

Section 1 Item 1.

 Sustainability means that the objective of the rate methodology is to keep rates low over time, not to merely keep them low for the short-term by omitting or deferring needed expenses such as maintenance and funding of necessary cash reserves.  Administrative Simplicity recognizes that limits must be placed on the number of customer classes, the complexity of the rate schedule, and the frequency of billing.  Legal and Regulatory Compliance is a prime consideration because rate structures must incorporate applicable local, state, and federal statutes. The application of the criteria should recognize that a rate schedule is a form of public policy statement, setting forth those values that the utility considers important. Rate structures must be tailored to community perceptions, realities, and values. While each utility’s budgeting, financial reporting and flow of funds is unique, a generalized schematic illustrating our approach to a cost of service / rate study is shown in the figure below.

Figure 1-1: Cost of Service Process

Dover Rate Study Report 1-2 44

Page 45

Section 1 Item 1.

NewGen’s approach to completing a utility rate study is completed in a four-step process which includes:  Revenue Requirements - Development of the full cost of providing water and wastewater service to each class of City customers.  Cost of Service - Allocation of revenue requirements to customers based on the cost of providing service and each customer. For the City, this meant an evaluation of the current water rate tiers and the rates charged to each tier.  Financial Plan - Development of a financial plan, i.e., revenue increases, to fund system revenue requirements considering customer and usage demand forecasts.  Utility Pricing - Review of the current design based on revenue needs and rate design pricing objectives with specific rate projections. This report details the results of our study and our recommendations regarding water and wastewater rates sufficient to meet the future costs of the City’s systems.

Dover Rate Study Report 1-3 45

Page 46

Item 1.

Section 2
REVENUE REQUIREMENTS

The first step in the rate study is to identify and project the revenue requirements of the water and wastewater systems. The revenue requirements reflect the true cost of operating and maintaining each system when accounting for day-to-day operation and maintenance (O&M) costs, existing debt service, planned capital improvements, and contributions to reserves. This section of our report will detail the costs of each system and how those costs are reasonably expected to increase in the future.

Study Assumptions While the study is predicated on the most recently available data, several assumptions must be made to forecast future costs and revenues.

Operating Budget Escalation Factors NewGen’s cost projections are based on the City’s FY 2025 adopted Water and Wastewater budgets. To reasonably project future costs, NewGen applied escalation and inflation factors to each of the City’s budget line items. The study includes the following operating and maintenance line-item escalation factors in Table 2-1.

Table 2-1
Operating Budget Escalation Factors

FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Water Salaries6.2%6.2%3.0%3.0%3.0%
Wastewater Salaries6.8%6.8%3.0%3.0%3.0%
Benefits3.0%3.0%3.0%3.0%3.0%
General3.0%3.0%3.0%3.0%3.0%
Services3.5%3.5%3.5%3.5%3.5%
Supplies3.5%3.5%3.5%3.5%3.5%
Electricity3.3%3.3%3.3%3.3%3.3%
Chemicals12.0%12.0%12.0%12.0%12.0%
KCSA12.0%4.0%4.0%4.0%4.0%

In accordance with the City’s Union labor contract for a portion of the Department of Water & Wastewater staff, City Staff determined that the Water Fund’s salary costs will increase by 6.2% for the first two fiscal years of the study. Similarly, the Wastewater Fund’s forecasted salary costs in FY 2026 and FY 2027 are expected to increase by 6.8% and then level off at a 3.0% escalation rate in the following years of the forecast period. On average, NewGen projects that the water utility operating budget will increase by 3.9% per year and wastewater by 3.4% per year over the five-year projection period.

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Rate Study Report 46

Page 47

Section 2 Item 1.

Water and Wastewater Operating Costs The City’s FY 2025 budget and forecasted FY 2026 – FY 2030 Water Fund and Wastewater Fund O&M expenses are shown in Tables 2-2 and 2-3.

Table 2-2
Projected Water Operating and Maintenance Expenses ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
Engineering$426$431$453$466$481$495
Water Maintenance$881$919$962$991$1,022$1,053
Water Treatment Plant$3,202$3,167$3,332$3,470$3,617$3,773
Other Expenses$1,153$1,352$1,393$1,435$1,478$1,522
Total Water O&M$5,661$5,870$6,139$6,363$6,597$6,844
% Change3.7%4.6%3.6%3.7%3.7%

Table 2-2 shows that the actual treatment expenses associated with the Water Fund make up the majority of costs, but across the Fund salary expenses make up roughly 50% of expenses. This means that the impact of the compensation study and personnel increases is significant in the early years of the forecast.

Table 2-3
Projected Wastewater Operating and Maintenance Expenses ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
Engineering$382$383$403$416$428$442
Wastewater Maintenance$1,369$1,468$1,538$1,586$1,635$1,686
Other Expenses$5,930$6,654$6,912$7,180$7,458$7,747
Total Wastewater O&M$7,681$8,505$8,853$9,181$9,522$9,875
% Change10.7%4.1%3.7%3.7%3.7%

Table 2-3 demonstrates that the majority of the expenses incurred by the Wastewater Fund are related to Kent County providing the Treatment services. Of the $7.7 million in total O&M expenditures, $5.2 million are associated with Kent County’s service. As mentioned earlier the personnel expenses and increases are a major component of O&M increases going forward. The City plans to increase water and wastewater system personnel in FY 2026, resulting in a $185,000 increase in the water utility operating costs and a $165,000 increase in the forecasted wastewater utility operating costs. This expected personnel increase is escalated by 7.0% in the following two years (FY 2027 – FY 2028) as determined by City Staff and then returns to an average salary escalation factor of 3.0% in the study’s outyears. In addition to O&M expenses, each year the City conducts transfers out of the Water and Wastewater Funds to the City’s General Fund, Water and Wastewater I&E Funds, Water and Wastewater Impact Fee

Dover Rate Study Report 2-2 47

Page 48

Section 2 Item 1.

Reserves, the Electric Fund, and Inventory Write-Offs. Tables 2-4 and 2-5 below details the budgeted and projected transfers out of the Water Fund and Wastewater Fund during the five-year study period.

Table 2-4
Projected Water Fund Transfers ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
General Fund$1,000$1,000$1,000$1,000$1,000$1,000
Water Imp and Ext$503$-$410$1,590$1,512$868
Water I&E Reserve$-$-$-$-$-$69
Electric Fund (ERP)$25$25$25$25$25$25
Write-Offs$5$5$5$5$5$5
Total Transfers Out$1,533$1,030$1,440$2,620$2,542$1,967
% Change(32.8%)39.8%81.9%(3.0%)(22.6%)

Table 2-5
Projected Wastewater Fund Transfers ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
General Fund$1,000$1,000$1,000$1,000$1,000$1,000
Wastewater I&E$1,330$2,000$3,264$3,563$3,409$3,078
Wastewater I&E Reserve$-$-$-$-$-$-
Electric Fund (ERP)$25$25$25$25$25$25
Write-Offs$5$5$5$5$5$5
Total Transfers Out$2,360$3,030$4,294$4,593$4,439$4,108
% Change28.4%41.7%7.0%(3.4%)(7.5%)

The two main transfers incurred are one to the General Fund and one to the Impact and Extension Funds. The General Fund transfers are made to offset labor and work conducted by employees outside of the Water and Wastewater Funds. Although the transfer acts similar to an O&M expense in the purpose it serves, the transfer is only to occur if the funds are available. For the purposes of this report and the accompanying model, it is assumed that the General Fund transfer will occur every year and the rates are balanced to make this occur. The annual transfers to the I&E Funds have been calculated to cover the forecasted capital costs of infrastructure improvements and expansions in the period FY 2025 – FY 2030. The projected transfers to the Impact Fee Reserves ensure that these reserves meet the City’s required minimum policy. These transfers will be shown in the following section on capital costs. In addition to the General Fund transfer and the I&E transfer, it is worth noting that NewGen projects that a transfer to the Water Impact Fee Reserve will not be required until FY 2030. The Wastewater Impact Fee Reserve will not require a transfer throughout the five-year study forecast period. This means that

Dover Rate Study Report 2-3 48

Page 49

Section 2 Item 1.

the current balance in the Impact Fee reserve will be maintained by impact fees for the majority of the forecast period.

Water and Wastewater Capital Costs There are two components to the capital costs of the water and wastewater systems. The first is the existing debt obligations payable by the Water and Wastewater Funds. The second is any planned capital expenditures to be paid by the Funds, which can be paid on an annual basis (i.e., PAYGO funded) or with the issuance of new debt (i.e., debt-funded). The following capital costs are included in NewGen’s revenue requirement projections for the Water Fund and Wastewater Fund.

Existing Debt Service As of FY 2025, the City is obligated to pay seven outstanding debt issues. All current debt obligations will be paid in full by FY 2042. Table 2-6 shows the projected loan payments over the five-year study planning period.

Table 2-6
Current Debt Service Obligations by Issue ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
2009 Revenue Bonds$347$347$347$347$347$347
2010 Revenue Bonds$161$161$161$161$161$161
2011 Revenue Bonds$58$58$58$58$58$58
2013 Revenue Bonds$306$304$302$304$305$305
2018 Loan$57$57$57$57$57$57
2018 Loan$228$230$231$232$234$235
2020 Loan$29$29$29$29$29$29
Total Debt Service$1,188$1,187$1,186$1,190$1,192$1,194
% Change(0.0%)(0.1%)0.3%0.2%0.1%
Water Debt$543$543$543$546$548$549
Wastewater Debt$645$644$643$644$645$645

Planned Capital Improvements A major component of the City owning sustainable water and wastewater utilities is the planning for the rehabilitation and replacement of the City’s assets. The City provided NewGen with a Water and Wastewater Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) that detailed list of projects including when they are planned to be completed and how much they are projected to cost. The forecasted capital project costs are paid for out of the Water and Wastewater Improvement & Extension Funds. NewGen’s study includes funding for all CIP projects. NewGen assumes a capital inflation of 3.0% for the forecasted cost of planned projects, compounded annually. Table 2-7 summarizes the projected capital costs developed by City staff for the period FY 2025 – FY 2030.

Dover Rate Study Report 2-4 49

Page 50

Section 2 Item 1.

Table 2-7
Planned Capital Improvement Projects Summary ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
Water Projects$3,068$9,070$4,765$4,992$5,377$5,033
Wastewater Projects$1,446$2,785$3,708$3,595$3,736$3,412
Total Annual CIP$4,514$11,855$8,472$8,587$9,113$8,444

A detailed list of capital projects is provided in Appendix A of this report. Tables 2-8 and 2-9 show the forecasted costs of the City’s planned CIP spending and the funding sources used to develop the study’s financial projections.

Table 2-8
Water CIP by Funding Source ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
Cash$432$1,345$1,466$1,714$1,663$975
Grant$1,986$5,150$-$-$-$-
Debt$577$2,284$2,823$2,908$2,196$2,468
Impact Fee Reserve$73$291$476$370$1,518$1,590
Total Planned CIP$3,068$9,070$4,765$4,992$5,377$5,033

The City plans to PAYGO (cash) fund $7.6 million in water system capital projects from FY 2025 to FY 2030. The Downtown Dover Upgrades to the water system and PFAS Water Treatment Plant Improvement projects in FY 2025 and FY 2026 is assumed to be entirely Grant funded. About $13.3 million in capital projects over the five-year period are forecasted to be funded by new debt. The City also plans to use $4.3 million from the Water Impact Fee Reserve to cover the costs of necessary water system expansion projects.

Table 2-9
Wastewater CIP by Funding Source ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
Cash$1,085$2,777$3,677$3,563$3,407$3,075
Grant$354$-$-$-$-$-
Debt$-$-$-$-$-$-
Impact Fee Reserve$7$7$30$33$329$337
Total Planned CIP$1,446$2,785$3,708$3,595$3,736$3,412

Dover Rate Study Report 2-5 50

Page 51

Section 2 Item 1.

For the wastewater system, the City plans to PAYGO fund $17.6 million in capital projects in the period FY 2025 – FY 2030. The Downtown Dover Upgrades to the wastewater collection system, budgeted to cost $354,000 will be entirely grant funded in FY 2025. The City also plans to fund about $744,000 in growth- related capital expansion projects through the Wastewater Impact Fee Reserve. The City does not expect to debt fund any wastewater capital projects in the five-year planning period.

Miscellaneous Revenues The City accounts for certain Water Fund and Wastewater Fund revenues that are in addition to the various water and wastewater rates charged to retail customers. Tables 2-10 and 2-11 details these non- rate revenues for the Water and Wastewater Funds.

Table 2-10
Projected Water Non-Rate Operating Revenue ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjected Projected Projected Projected Projected
Misc Grant Revenue$18$18$18$18$18$18
Water Tank Space Leasing$451$464$478$492$507$522
Interest - Water$100$41$71$106$105$102
Miscellaneous Service Fee$65$65$65$65$65$65
Total Operating Revenues$633$588$632$681$695$707

City Staff forecasts that Water Tank Space Leasing revenue will increase by 3.0% each fiscal year for the length of the forecast period. Other miscellaneous revenues have far less of an impact on total cash flow and are largely kept flat outside of interest revenues which are attached to the fund balance.

Table 2-11
Projected Wastewater Non-Rate Operating Revenue ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY2029FY2030
BudgetProjected Projected Projected Projected Projected
Interest - Wastewater$100$159$177$172$160$157
Miscellaneous Service Fee$50$50$50$50$50$50
Total Operating Revenues$150$210$227$222$210$207

As mentioned earlier, the interest revenues in both the Water and Wastewater Funds are connected to fund balance. The calculated Interest revenue for each Fund is calculated based on a 3.3% rate for interest earned on investments on beginning fund balance. To be conservative, all other Wastewater revenue offsets (non-operating revenues) are assumed to remain constant over the forecast period.

The City also receives capital revenue from water and wastewater impact fees, which are used to offset the capital costs of growth-related infrastructure improvement and expansion projects. Table 2-12 shows the revenue obtained from the City’s impact fees. As mentioned previously, the impact fee revenues projected below are enough to offset growth related capital expenses for much of the forecast period.

Dover Rate Study Report 2-6 51

Page 52

Section 2 Item 1.

Table 2-12
Projected Capital Revenue ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY2029FY2030
BudgetProjected Projected Projected Projected Projected
Water Impact Fees$230$250$250$250$250$250
Wastewater Impact Fees$230$235$235$235$235$235
Total Capital Revenues$460$485$485$485$485$485

Net Revenue Requirements Based on the latest available FY 2025 operating, debt service, and capital expense data as well as the methodologies and assumptions detailed above, NewGen developed net revenue requirement forecasts for the City’s water and wastewater systems, shown in Tables 2-13 and 2-14.

Table 2-13
Water Net Revenue Requirement Projection ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
Operating Expenses$5,661$5,870$6,139$6,363$6,597$6,844
Existing Debt Service$543$543$543$546$548$549
New Debt Service$-$42$210$418$632$794
Transfers Out$1,030$1,030$1,030$1,030$1,030$1,099
I&E Fund Transfer$503$-$410$1,590$1,512$868
Total Rev. Req.$7,737$7,485$8,333$9,946$10,320$10,154
Less: Non-Rate Rev.($863)($838)($882($931)($945)($957)
Net Rev Req.$6,874$6,648$7,451$9,016$9,375$9,197
% Change(3.3%)12.1%21.0%4.0%(1.9%)

Dover Rate Study Report 2-7 52

Page 53

Section 2 Item 1.

Table 2-14
Wastewater Net Revenue Requirement Projection ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
BudgetProjectedProjectedProjectedProjectedProjected
Operating Expenses$7,681$8,505$8,853$9,181$9,522$9,875
Existing Debt Service$645$644$643$644$645$645
New Debt Service$-$-$-$-$-$-
Transfers Out$1,030$1,030$1,030$1,030$1,030$1,030
I&E Fund Transfer$1,330$2,000$3,264$3,563$3,409$3,078
Total Rev. Req.$10,685$12,179$13,790$14,418$14,605$14,627
Less: Non-Rate Rev.($380)($445)($462)($457)($445)($442)
Net Rev Req.$10,305$11,734$13,327$13,961$14,160$14,185
% Change13.9%13.6%4.8%1.4%0.2%

The net revenue requirement is the basis upon which rates are calculated for the City’s water and wastewater systems. Although the net revenue requirement varies from year to year, the financial plan developed during the study takes a long-term perspective to maintain stable rates and sufficient reserves. Before a financial plan can be developed for the City’s systems, an accounting of each system’s customer base must be completed. The City’s Water Fund customer base includes the City’s metered water customer accounts and metered water sales. The City’s Wastewater Fund customer base is comprised of the City’s metered wastewater customers and metered sewage generation collected for treatment. The next section of this report details the City’s water and wastewater customers and their use of the City’s utility systems.

Dover Rate Study Report 2-8 53

Page 54

Item 1.

Section 3
WATER AND WASTEWATER CUSTOMERS AND USAGE

This section will detail the composition of the City’s water and wastewater system customer base. The City’s primary revenue source for the Water and Wastewater Funds is the rates and fees charged to customers of the water and wastewater systems. The latest full year of customer and consumption data available for the study was FY 2024.

Water and Wastewater Customers and Consumption The City serves around 14,000 water accounts, a vast majority of which are residential customers within the City’s corporate limits. Additionally, the City has an agreement to provide water service to specified Tidewater Utilities connections at a modified usage rate. The number of City water connections by customer class is shown in Table 3-1 below.

Table 3-1
FY 2024 Water Customer Accounts

Customer TypeInside CityOutside City
Residential10,9171,070
Commercial1,883136
Tidewater1-
Total Accounts12,8011,206

The City also serves about 13,300 wastewater connections. Table 3-2 details the number of City wastewater connections by customer class.

Table 3-2
FY 2024 Wastewater Customer Accounts

Meter SizeInside CityOutside City
Residential10,834467
Commercial1,806104
Hunter’s Pointe-898
Total Accounts12,640659

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Rate Study Report 54

Page 55

Section 3 Item 1.

FY 2024 Water Consumption and Wastewater Generation Table 3-3 shows the billable water usage breakdown of the City’s FY 2024 water customers and contracted wholesale customers.

Table 3-3
FY 2024 Water Consumption (kgal)

Inside CityOutside City
Customer TypeConsumption (kgal)Consumption (kgal)
Residential
0 - 6,000382,02838,835
6,001 - 100,00066,7217,511
100,001+25,393651
Total474,14246,997

Commercial

0 - 6,00079,2054,958
6,001 - 100,000297,28612,717
100,001+607,227484
Total983,71818,159

Tidewater

0 - 6,00048
6,001 - 100,000752
101,000 – 1,250,0007,093
1,250,000+1,305
Total9,198

Total Consumption 1,467,058 65,156

The City’s water consumption in FY 2024 for all customers totaled 1,532,214 kgal. Table 3-4 below shows the billable wastewater generation breakdown of the City’s FY 2024 wastewater customers and contracted wholesale customers.

Dover Rate Study Report 3-2 55

Page 56

Section 3 Item 1.

Table 3-4
FY 2024 Wastewater Generation (kgal)

Customer TypeInside City Flow (kgal)Outside City Flow (kgal)
Residential
All Volume438,18320,184

Commercial
All Volume 732,632 16,064

Hunter’s Pointe
All Volume - 6,348

Total Consumption 1,170,815 42,596

The City’s total wastewater usage in FY 2024 for all customers totaled 1,213,411 kgal.

Projected Water System Demand The City’s projected water consumption is outlined in Table 3-5 below. In regard to future growth, the City expects to legalize marijuana cultivation in 2026 which will significantly increase water demand. City Staff forecasts the implementation of three locations with a projected usage of 75,000 gallons per month per location. The City also expects new development to occur during the five-year study period, including 1,342 apartments, 698 single-family homes, and nine industrial sites. The resulting increase in projected water consumption from these new City developments are detailed below.

Table 3-5
Projected Water Consumption in kgal

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Inside City1,457,8601,501,1681,544,4761,544,4761,544,4761,544,476
Marijuana Cultivation--1,8002,7002,7002,700
Outside City65,15665,15665,15665,15665,15665,156
Tidewater9,1989,1989,1989,1989,1989,198
Total Water Sold (kgal)1,532,2141,575,5221,620,6301,621,5301,621,5301,621,530

The City’s projected level of consumption for Outside City and Tidewater customers is expected to remain constant over the five-year period.

Dover Rate Study Report 3-3 56

Page 57

Section 3 Item 1.

Projected Wastewater System Demand The City charges for wastewater usage based on metered sewage generation that is collected by the City for treatment at the Kent County Wastewater Treatment Plant. The City applies a flat, all volume rate for wastewater usage. Table 3-6 below depicts the sewage generation in kgal. The City forecasts wastewater usage growth from the developments discussed above.

Table 3-6
Projected Wastewater Generation in kgal

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Inside City1,170,8151,214,1231,257,4311,257,4311,257,4311,257,431
Outside City42,59642,59642,59642,59642,59642,596
Total Sewage (kgal)1,213,4111,256,7191,300,0271,300,0271,300,0271,300,027

Dover Rate Study Report 3-4 57

Page 58

Item 1.

Section 4
FINANCIAL PLAN AND CASH FLOW PROJECTIONS

NewGen developed cash flow and cash balance projections assuming the revenue requirements detailed in Section 2 of this report and that the City does not increase any water and wastewater rates in any year of the five-year projection.

Minimum Cash Reserve and Debt Coverage Requirements NewGen’s study requires a baseline to which projected cash flow and reserve balances can be measured. NewGen relied on the financial policies of the City to ensure that the rates projected because of our study ensure the financial health of the City’s Water and Wastewater Funds. Our study requires that in each year, the City must maintain a minimum of 60 days of operating cash on hand and a contingency reserve of $250,000.

Minimum Fund Balance Calculation The City has an established minimum Fund balance policy based on the annual operating expenses of the water and wastewater systems. The current policy mandates an operating reserve of 60 days annual operating expenses and $250,000 contingency reserve. The minimum fund balances required each year of NewGen’s five-year projection are shown in Tables 4-1 and 4-2.

Table 4-1
Calculated Minimum Water Fund Balance Policy ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Annual O&M Costs$5,661$5,870$6,139$6,363$6,597$6,844
Days Required606060606060
O&M Reserve$931$965$1,009$1,046$1,084$1,125

Contingency Reserve $250 $250 $250 $250 $250 $250

Total Minimum Reserve $1,181 $1,215 $1,259 $1,296 $1,334 $1,375

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Rate Study Report 58

Page 59

Section 4 Item 1.

Table 4-2
Calculated Minimum Wastewater Fund Balance Policy ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Annual O&M Costs$7,681$8,505$8,853$9,181$9,522$9,875
Days Required606060606060
O&M Reserve$1,263$1,398$1,455$1,509$1,565$1,623

Contingency Reserve $250 $250 $250 $250 $250 $250

Total Minimum Reserve $1,513 $1,648 $1,705 $1,759 $1,815 $1,873

NewGen’s study includes revenue increases necessary to sustain a long-term forecast of Water Fund and Wastewater Fund balances above the minimum policy. The City’s also has established minimum reserve policies for the Water and Wastewater Improvement & Extension Funds. The City maintains a Capital Asset Replacement Reserve to cover the replacement or procurement of the utility’s assets and requires that this reserve maintain a minimum balance of $500,000. Additionally, the City has implemented a Water Impact Fee Reserve and Wastewater Impact Fee Reserve to provide for future expansion for the City’s water and wastewater systems due to increased demand. The City’s financial policy requires that the Water Impact Fee Reserve maintain a minimum reserve of $1.5 million, while the Wastewater Impact Fee Reserve must maintain a minimum equal to 20% of the system’s operating fund revenue. Tables 4-3 and 4-4 below show the current and projected I&E Fund reserve requirements over the five-year study period.

Table 4-3
Calculated Water I&E Fund Reserve Balance Policy ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Capital Asset Reserve$500$500$500$500$500$500
Impact Fee Reserve$1,500$1,500$1,500$1,500$1,500$1,500
Total Minimum Reserve$2,000$2,000$2,000$2,000$2,000$2,000

Table 4-4
Calculated Wastewater I&E Fund Reserve Balance Policy ($ Thousands)

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Capital Asset Reserve$500$500$500$500$500$500
Impact Fee Reserve$2,310$2,544$2,725$2,813$2,903$2,947
Total Minimum Reserve$2,810$3,044$3,225$3,313$3,403$3,447

Dover Rate Study Report 4-2 59

Page 60

Section 4 Item 1.

The Water and Wastewater Fund balance policies in addition to I&E reserve policies are a driving force behind all rate revenue increases since the minimum limits for all policies are never compromised throughout the entire forecast period. Revenue increases in future years are designed to make sure the minimum requirements should be met regardless of projected fluctuations in capital costs or O&M inflation.

Cash Flow Projections at FY 2025 Rates The City’s current water rate structure includes a monthly flat rate charge per active meter and a three- tiered inclining block rate per one thousand gallons (kgal) of metered consumption. The current wastewater rate structure also charges a monthly flat rate per active meter, as well as an all-volume volumetric rate, ground water rate, and KCSA rate per one thousand gallons of metered sewage generated. The City’s FY 2025 rate structures are shown in Tables 4-5 and 4-6.

Table 4-5
FY 2025 Water Rates

Inside CityOutside City
Flat Rate per Active Meter$5.00$5.00

Volumetric Rate per kgal

0 - 6,000$2.88$4.32
6,001 - 100,000$3.60$5.40
100,001+$4.32$6.48

Table 4-6
FY 2025 Wastewater Rates

Inside CityOutside City
Flat Rate per Active Meter$5.00$5.00

Volumetric Rate per kgal

City Rate$3.25$4.87
Ground Water Rate$1.84$1.84
KCSA Fee$3.41$3.41
All Volume$8.50$10.12

Dover Rate Study Report 4-3 60

Page 61

Section 4 Item 1.

Utility Fund Cash Balance Projection at Current Rates If the City does not increase water or wastewater rates from their current FY 2025 levels, the following four figures show NewGen’s projected cash flow and Water and Wastewater Fund balance projections for the period FY 2025 through FY 2030.

Figure 4-1: Water Expenses vs. Revenues Forecast – Current Rates
$16.0
I & E Fund Transfer
Millions $14.0
Transfers Out
$12.0

$10.0 New Debt Service

$8.0
Existing Debt Service
$6.0
Operating Expenses
$4.0

$2.0Total Revenues Under FY
2025 Rates
$0.0
202520262027202820292030
Fiscal Year

Figure 4-2: Wastewater Expenses vs. Revenues Forecast – Current Rates
$16.0
I & E Fund Transfer
Millions $14.0
Transfers Out
$12.0

$10.0 New Debt Service

$8.0
Existing Debt Service
$6.0
Operating Expenses
$4.0

$2.0Total Revenues Under FY
2025 Rates
$0.0
202520262027202820292030
Fiscal Year

In both the Water and Wastewater Funds, current revenues are projected to be outpaced by expenses as early as FY 2027. Both Funds will feel the impact of the negative cash flows in FY 2027, with the Water Fund falling below its minimum policy in that year and the Wastewater Fund beginning to draw down on reserves.

Dover Rate Study Report 4-4 61

Page 62

Section 4 Item 1.

Figure 4-3: Projected Water Fund Balance at FY 2025 Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0
Current Rate Ending Fund
$8.0 Balance

$6.0 Minimum Reserve Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Figure 4-4: Projected Wastewater Fund Balance at FY 2025 Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0
Current Rate Ending Fund
$8.0 Balance

$6.0 Minimum Reserve Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

The previous figures show that the City’s current FY 2025 water and wastewater rates are not sufficient to maintain the financial health of the water and wastewater systems. Projections of Fund balances show that reserves fall below minimum levels for both Funds by FY 2030 with no rate changes. The next subsections of this report will detail the revenue increases and rates necessary to produce sufficient cash flow to maintain the recommended minimum required fund balance for the City’s Water and Wastewater Funds.

Dover Rate Study Report 4-5 62

Page 63

Section 4 Item 1.

Recommended Rate Increases To increase revenues that will sustain the water and wastewater systems, NewGen recommends the following rate increases for the City’s water and wastewater rates.

Table 4-7
Recommended Water and Wastewater Rate Increases

($ increase per year)FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Water Rates
Flat Rate$0.60$0.50$0.37$0.19$0.20
Volumetric Rate (Tier 1)$0.35$0.29$0.21$0.11$0.12
Volumetric Rate (Tier 2)$0.43$0.36$0.26$0.14$0.14
Volumetric Rate (Tier 3)$0.52$0.44$0.32$0.17$0.17

Wastewater Rates

Flat Rate$0.15$0.15$0.16$0.16$0.00
Volumetric Rate$0.10$0.10$0.10$0.11$0.00
Ground Water Rate$0.06$0.06$0.06$0.06$0.00
Kent County Service Authority Rate (1)$0.41$0.15$0.16$0.17$0.17
(1) Kent County Service Authority (KCSA) rate is set independently of the City of Dover rate. It is a pass-through charge for costs related to wastewater treatment by the KCSA.

Utility Fund Cash Balance Projection at Recommended Rates If the City increases its water and wastewater revenues consistent with the table above, the result is that the City can fund each system’s projected operating, capital, and debt service expenses while also maintaining the recommended reserves, as shown in the following figures.

Figure 4-5: Water Expenses vs. Revenues – Recommended Rates $16.0 I & E Fund Transfer Millions $14.0 Transfers Out $12.0 New Debt Service $10.0 Existing Debt Service $8.0

$6.0 Operating Expenses

$4.0Total Revenues Under FY
2025 Rates
$2.0Total Revenues Under
Recommended Rates
$0.0
202520262027202820292030
Fiscal Year

Dover Rate Study Report 4-6 63

Page 64

Section 4 Item 1.

Figure 4-6: Wastewater Expenses vs. Revenues – Recommended Rates
$16.0
I & E Fund Transfer
Millions $14.0
Transfers Out
$12.0
New Debt Service
$10.0

$8.0 Existing Debt Service

$6.0 Operating Expenses

$4.0Total Revenues Under FY
2025 Rates
$2.0Total Revenues Under
Recommended Rates
$0.0
202520262027202820292030
Fiscal Year

Figures 4-5 and 4-6 demonstrate that the rate increases referenced above are sufficient to maintain revenues that can fully offset expenses throughout the forecast period. Both the Water and Wastewater Fund’s increase in expenses are accommodate for. The Water Fund is in more need of larger rate hikes due to PAYGO capital expenses increasing and New Debt service starting, and the recommended rate account for such changes. Wastewater rates are primarily increased to account for inflated O&M over the forecast period and some amount of capital expense increase. The following figures demonstrate the impact of the cash flows show above on the Water and Wastewater Fund balances.

Figure 4-7: Water Fund Balance – Recommended Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0
Ending Fund Balance
$8.0

$6.0
Minimum Reserve
Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Dover Rate Study Report 4-7 64

Page 65

Section 4 Item 1.

Figure 4-8: Wastewater Fund Balance – Recommended Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0
Ending Fund Balance
$8.0

$6.0 Minimum Reserve
Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Figures 4-7 and 4-7 show that the recommended rates are designed to keep the Fund balance at a healthy level above the minimum reserve policy limits. The rate increases in Table 4-7 also account for the required transfers to the Water and Wastewater I&E Funds to cover forecasted capital project expenses through the five-year planning period. The following figures depict the Improvement & Extension Fund cash flows and fund balances if the City implements the recommended rate increases in FY 2026 – FY 2030.

Figure 4-9: Water I&E Fund Expenses vs. Revenues – Recommended Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0 Capital Project Expense

$8.0

$6.0
Beginning Fund Balance &
$4.0 Revenues

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Dover Rate Study Report 4-8 65

Page 66

Section 4 Item 1.

Figure 4-10: Wastewater I&E Fund Expenses vs. Revenues – Recommended Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0

$10.0 Capital Project Expense

$8.0

$6.0
Beginning Fund Balance &
$4.0 Revenues

$2.0

$0.0 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Fiscal Year Figures 4-9 and 4-10 show a use of excess cash balance on the Water I&E Fund to minimize rate increases, and then the use of funds matching capital expenses throughout the rest of the projections to indicate that transfers in are matching expenses exactly. This shows that all excess cash is used, and subsequent years are not building any cash balance.

The cash balances in the I&E Fund are separate from reserve balances which are untouchable for regular project use. These reserve balances are shown below in figure 4-11 and 4-12.

Figure 4-11: Water I&E Reserve Balance – Recommended Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0Impact Fee Reserve
Balance
$10.0
Capital Asset
$8.0Reserve Balance

$6.0 Minimimum
Reserve Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

Dover Rate Study Report 4-9 66

Page 67

Section 4 Item 1.

Figure 4-12: Wastewater I&E Reserve Balance – Recommended Rates $16.0

Millions $14.0

$12.0Impact Fee Reserve
Balance
$10.0
Capital Asset
$8.0Reserve Balance

$6.0 Minimimum
Reserve Policy
$4.0

$2.0

$0.0
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
Fiscal Year

The proceeding figures show that reserve balances meet the minimum requirements throughout the forecast period, meaning that no additional rate funded transfers are needed to bring the I&E asset reserves into compliance with the minimum limits.

Dover Rate Study Report 4-10 67

Page 68

Section 5 Item 1.

Section 5
RECOMMENDED RATES

This section of our report details our recommended water and wastewater rate increases and the specific rate changes and bill impacts that will result from those recommendations.

Recommended Revenue Increases This section includes the total increases in revenue shown in Table 5-1, as described in Section 4. These revenue increases are necessary to maintain the financial and operational health of the City’s water and wastewater infrastructure.

Table 5-1
Recommended Water and Wastewater Rate Increases

($ increase per year)FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Water Rates
Flat Rate$0.60$0.50$0.37$0.19$0.20
Volumetric Rate (Tier 1)$0.35$0.29$0.21$0.11$0.12
Volumetric Rate (Tier 2)$0.43$0.36$0.26$0.14$0.14
Volumetric Rate (Tier 3)$0.52$0.44$0.32$0.17$0.17

Wastewater Rates

Flat Rate$0.15$0.15$0.16$0.16$0.00
Volumetric Rate$0.10$0.10$0.10$0.11$0.00
Ground Water Rate$0.06$0.06$0.06$0.06$0.00
Kent County Service Authority Rate (1)$0.41$0.15$0.16$0.17$0.17
(1) Kent County Service Authority (KCSA) rate is set independently of the City of Dover rate. It is a pass-through charge for costs related to wastewater treatment by the KCSA.

Projected Rates under Current Rate Structure The following water rates shown in Table 5-2 are based on the revenue increases in Table 5-1 and are forecasted to fully support the future operating, capital, debt service, and reserve requirements of the water system. The water rates in Table 5-2 assume that the City does not change its current rate structure.

Dover Rate Study Report 5-11 68

Page 69

Section 5 Item 1.

Table 5-2
Recommended Water Rates

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Flat Rate$5.00$5.60$6.10$6.47$6.66$6.86

Volumetric Rate per Kgal
Inside City

0 - 6,000$2.88$3.23$3.52$3.73$3.84$3.95
6,001 - 100,000$3.60$4.03$4.39$4.66$4.80$4.94
100,001+$4.32$4.84$5.27$5.59$5.76$5.93

Outside City

0 - 6,000$4.32$4.84$5.27$5.59$5.76$5.93
6,001 - 100,000$5.40$6.05$6.59$6.99$7.20$7.41
100,001+$6.48$7.26$7.91$8.39$8.64$8.90

Tidewater

0 - 6,000$3.60$4.03$4.39$4.66$4.80$4.94
6,001 - 100,000$4.50$5.04$5.49$5.82$6.00$6.18
100,001 – 1,250,000$5.40$6.05$6.59$6.99$7.20$7.41
1,250,000+$7.78$8.71$9.49$10.06$10.36$10.68

The City’s contract with Tidewater Utilities states that the rates charged to supply water service to Lakeland, Carlisle Village, and Reichold Chemical Connections will be the average of the Inside City rate and Outside City rate. NewGen projects the Tidewater usage rates using this agreed upon calculation throughout the Study’s forecast period. If the City adopts the recommended rate increases in Table 5-1 each year from FY 2025 – FY 2030, then the City’s Wastewater Service Charge would be as shown in Table 5-3.

Dover Rate Study Report 5-12 69

Page 70

Section 5 Item 1.

Table 5-3
Recommended Wastewater Rates

FY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Flat Rate$5.00$5.15$5.30$5.46$5.63$5.63

Volumetric Rate per Kgal
Inside City $3.25 $3.35 $3.45 $3.55 $3.66 $3.66

Outside City $4.87 $5.02 $5.17 $5.32 $5.48 $5.48

Groundwater Rate $1.84 $1.90 $1.95 $2.01 $2.07 $2.07

KCSA Fee (1) $3.41 $3.82 $3.97 $4.13 $4.30 $4.47

(1) Kent County Service Authority (KCSA) rate is set independently of the City of Dover rate. It is a pass-through charge for costs related to wastewater treatment by the KCSA.

The Kent County Wastewater Agreement Fee is determined by the Kent County Department of Water and Wastewater Services. Based on discussions with the Kent County Department, City Staff expects that the KCSA Fee will increase by 12.0% in FY 2026. City Staff forecasts a 4.0% increase in the following fiscal years based on historical rate increases. Again, the wastewater rates in Table 5-3 assume that the City does not change its rate structure.

Dover Rate Study Report 5-13 70

Page 71

Item 1.

Section 6
CUSTOMER BILL IMPACTS AND BENCHMARKING

A major consideration when developing any utility financial plan is the impact on the system’s customer bills. The recommendations detailed in this report will result in revenue increases, and therefore cost increases, to many of the system’s customers. This section summarizes the impact on the system’s customers, as well as provides a comparison of the total customer bill set against surrounding utilities.

Projected Customer Bills The following table shows the impact of NewGen’s recommended revenue increases on sample residential and commercial City customers if the City were to adopt the rate changes recommended in Section 4.

Table 6-1
Combined Water and Wastewater Monthly Customer Bills

Sample CustomerFY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
Inside City
Residential: 4kgal
Water Bill$16.52$18.50$20.17$21.38$22.02$22.68
Wastewater Bill$25.36$26.12$26.90$27.71$28.54$28.54
KCSA Fee$13.64$15.28$15.89$16.52$17.18$17.87
Combined Total Bill$55.52$59.90$62.96$65.61$67.75$69.09
$ Change$4.38$3.06$2.65$2.13$1.35

Commercial: 40kgal

Water Bill$144.68$162.04$176.63$187.22$192.84$198.62
Wastewater Bill$208.60$214.86$221.30$227.94$234.78$234.78
KCSA Fee$136.40$152.77$158.88$165.23$171.84$178.72
Combined Total Bill$489.68$529.67$556.81$580.40$599.46$612.12
$ Change$39.99$27.14$23.59$19.06$12.66

Outside City
Residential: 4kgal

Water Bill$22.28$24.95$27.20$28.83$29.70$30.59
Wastewater Bill$31.84$32.80$33.78$34.79$35.84$35.84
KCSA Fee$13.64$15.28$15.89$16.52$17.18$17.87
Combined Total Bill$67.76$73.03$76.87$80.15$82.72$84.30

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Rate Study Report

71

Page 72

Section 6 Item 1.

Table 6-1
Combined Water and Wastewater Monthly Customer Bills

Sample CustomerFY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029FY 2030
$ Change$5.27$3.84$3.28$2.57$1.58

Commercial: 40kgal

Water Bill$214.52$240.26$261.89$277.60$285.93$294.50
Wastewater Bill$273.40$281.60$290.05$298.75$307.71$307.71
KCSA Fee$136.40$152.77$158.88$165.23$171.84$178.72
Combined Total Bill$624.32$674.63$710.81$741.58$765.48$780.94
$ Change$50.31$36.18$30.77$23.90$15.45

Regional Bill Comparison The following figure shows a comparison of the monthly bill for an average Inside City residential customer (4 kgal monthly usage) in surrounding service areas.

Dover Rate Study Report 6-2

72

Page 73

Section 6 Item 1.

Figure 6-1: Regional Bill Comparison – Residential Customer, 4,000 gal/mo.

Kent County $49.23 $68.81 $118.04

City of Salisbury $28.67 $71.01 $99.68

City of Seaford $31.23 $60.88 $92.11

City of Harrington $24.67 $61.07 $85.73

Town of Smyrna $33.70 $49.55 $83.25

Camden-Wyoming SWA $29.93 $41.68 $71.61

City of Newark $39.28 $22.08 $61.35

Town of Georgetown $27.19 $33.94 $61.13

City of Dover (Rec. FY 2026) $18.50 $41.40 $59.90

City of Dover (FY 2025) $16.52 $39.00 $55.52

Town of Middletown $22.48 $32.22 $54.69

City of Milford $15.20 $33.47 $48.67

Artesian Water $48.18 $48.18

Tidewater Utilities $46.16 $46.16

Veolia Water $41.14 $41.14

$- $20 $40 $60 $80 $100 $120 $140

While regional comparisons may provide some context, the ranking of individual customer bills is not a consideration when developing a financial plan and rate structure. The City’s cash needs are independent of the rates in the surrounding jurisdictions, and this comparison is provided for information only.

Dover Rate Study Report 6-3

73

Page 74

Item 1.

Section 7
IMPACT FEES

NewGen’s scope of work included calculating updated Impact Fees for the City’s water and sewer utility systems. Water and Sewer impact fees are charges imposed on new connections to help fund the infrastructure needed to support new connections. These fees ensure that the costs of building and/or expanding water and sewer services, such as new pipelines, treatment facilities, and other necessary infrastructure, are covered by those who create the demand for these service expansions, rather than existing residents. In Delaware, water and sewer impact fees are part of a broader category known as development impact fees. These fees are governed by specific legal guidelines to ensure they are fair and proportionate to the impact of the new development. The Delaware Code outlines the purpose and implementation of these fees, emphasizing the need for adequate public facilities to support new growth and development. The key objectives of these laws include: 1. Ensuring that new developments contribute to the costs of public facilities required to serve them. 2. Promoting orderly growth by establishing uniform standards for assessing impact fees. 3. Preventing existing ratepayers from bearing the financial burden of new developments. There are three industry standard ways to calculate water and sewer impact fees: There are three methods that may be used to calculate cost-based Development Impact Fees: 1. The system buy-in method is based on the value of the existing system’s capacity, calculated either on an Original Cost Less Depreciation (OCLD) or Replacement Cost New Less Depreciation (RCNLD) basis. This method is typically used when the existing system has sufficient capacity to serve new development now and into the future.

Exhibit 7-1. Representation of the System Buy-In Cost Approach

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Rate Study Report

74

Page 75

0 Item 1.

  • 2.The incremental cost method is based on the cost to expand the existing system’s capacity, usually defined by a specific list of capital projects or a system master plan. This method is typically used when the existing system has limited or no capacity to serve new development and new facilities are needed to serve the next increment of new development.

Exhibit 7-2. Representation of the Incremental Cost Approach

  • 3.The combined or hybrid approach is based on a blended value of both the existing and expanded system’s capacity. This method is typically used where some capacity is available in parts of the existing system, but new or incremental capacity will need to be built in other parts to serve new development. NewGen used the system buy-in method at the Net Book Value (NBV) / Original Cost Less Depreciation (OCLD) to develop up-to-date water and sewer impact fees for the City.

Water Impact Fee Calculation The City’s current Water Impact Fee is $2,100 per Equivalent Dwelling Unit (EDU). NewGen’s water impact fee calculation is based on the Net Book Value of the City’s water system assets as of the end of FY 2025, based on original cost and depreciation schedules provided by the City. From the NBV, NewGen subtracts outstanding principal on debt as to not double count these costs. Principal on debt is included in the rate revenue requirement discussed previously in this report. Table 7-1 shows NewGen’s calculated Water Impact Fee.

Table 7-1
Water Impact Fee Calculation
FY 2026

NBV (All Assets)$29,487,316
Less: Outstanding Principal on Debt($5,494,814)
Total Impact Fee Cost Basis$23,992,502
Capacity Available (MGD)3.00
Unit Cost (GPD; in $)$8.00
Impact Fee per Unit (250 GPD)$2,000

Dover Rate Study Report 7-2

75

Page 76

0 Item 1.

Sewer Impact Fee Calculation The City’s current Sewer Impact Fee is $1,900 per Equivalent Dwelling Unit (EDU). NewGen’s sewer impact fee calculation is based on the Net Book Value of the City’s sewer system assets as of the end of FY 2025, based on original cost and depreciation schedules provided by the City. From the NBV, NewGen subtracts outstanding principal on debt as to not double count these costs. Principal on debt is included in the rate revenue requirement discussed previously in this report. Table 7-1 shows NewGen’s calculated Sewer Impact Fee.

Table 7-2
Sewer Impact Fee Calculation
FY 2026

NBV (All Assets)$35,126,353
Less: Outstanding Principal on Debt($5,214,306)
Total Impact Fee Cost Basis$29,912,047
Capacity Available (MGD)5.00
Unit Cost (GPD; in $)$5.98
Rounded Impact Fee per Unit (250 GPD)$1,500

Dover Rate Study Report 7-3

76

Page 77

Item 1.

APPENDIX A

Five-Year Water and Wastewater Capital Improvement Plan

ProjectSystemFY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029
2008 Dodge Advenger #427Water$26,900
2002 Sterling Dump Truck #424Water$165,000
2015 Ford F350 1 Ton Pickup #622Water$65,000
2008 Case Backhoe #672Water$131,000
New Utility Truck for Water Service PersonWater$75,000
Wellhead Redevelopment ProgramWater$166,000$171,000$177,000$183,000$189,000
Elevated Water Tower MaintenanceWater$96,700$73,200$175,700$116,700$188,700
Meter Replacement ProjectWater$418,700$418,700$418,700
Meter Reading Technology UpgradeWater$30,000
Water Tank Concrete RehabilitationWater$190,000
Water Treatment Plant Security UpgradeWater$222,000
Water Main Loop-StarlifterWater$110,000$1,100,000
Miscellaneous Emergency Water RepairsWater$85,000$85,000$85,000$85,000$85,000
Downtown Dover Upgrades - WaterWater$1,101,000
Water Quality ImprovementsWater$650,000$2,500,000$3,000,000$3,000,000$2,200,000
Mangenese Removal ProgramWater$57,000$400,000$460,000$600,000$465,000
PFAS WTP ImprovementsWater$885,000$5,000,000
WTP Storefront & Door ReplacementWater$60,000
2009 International Dump Truck #681Water$520,100$150,000
2012 Ford 350 #665Water$75,000
2016 International Vac Truck #691Water$520,000
2005 MGS Generator #604Water$80,000

Economics | Strategy | Stakeholders | Sustainability Dover Rate Study Report

77

Page 78

Item 1.

ProjectSystemFY 2025FY 2026FY 2027FY 2028FY 2029
2013 Case Skidsteer #674Water$80,000
Miscellaneous Emergency Wastewater RepairsWater$170,000$175,000$180,000$185,000$190,000
Laurel Drive Pump Station ReplacementWater$49,000$49,000$656,600
White Oak Road ImprovementsWater$65,000$800,000
Kings Cliffe Pump Station ReplacementWastewater$18,000$18,000$51,000$676,700
Downtown Dover Upgrades - WastewaterWastewater$354,000
Reed Street Gravity Wastewater UpgradeWastewater$90,000$90,000
Meter Replacement ProjectWastewater$418,700$418,700$418,700
Meter Reading Technology UpgradeWastewater$30,000
Inflow/Infiltration RemovalWastewater$1,875,000$1,875,000$1,875,000
Lepore Road Sanitary Wastewater UpgradeWastewater$370,000
Cedar Chase Pump Station ReplacementWastewater$636,500
Pump Station Scan InventoryWastewater$90,000$60,000
Hunter's Pointe Pump Station ReplacementWastewater$20,000$53,000
Westminster Pump Station ReplacementWastewater$22,000$55,000
Schoolview Pump Station ReplacementWastewater$24,000
Pump Station #7 UpgradesWastewater$90,000$680,000
Total CIP$4,513,700$11,509,700$7,986,100$7,858,700$8,096,800
Water Projects$3,067,600$9,070,386$4,764,926$4,992,014$5,377,006
Wastewater Projects$1,446,100$2,784,605$3,707,527$3,595,400$3,736,014

Dover Rate Study Report A-2

78

Page 79

Item 1.

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE ACTION FORM

PROCEEDING: Legislative and Finance Committee DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Finance office SUBMITTED ON: January 17, 2025 PREPARED BY: Patricia Marney, Controller, Treasurer REVIEWED BY:

SUBJECT: City of Dover Training, Conference & Travel Policy
TIMETABLE: Review and Approval.
RELATED PROJECT:
EXHIBITS Exhibit – Amended Training, Conference & Travel Policy

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Approve policy with documented changes to sections 2. (h) Other Reimbursement Categories and 3.(m) Non-Reimbursable Expenses

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:

Recommended approval, last updated May 10, 2022.

In May 2022 a recommendation for change was to apply babysitting expenses as an approved reimbursable expense. The recommended modification to the policy expands the definition of dependents and elder care expenses under section 2.(h) Other Reimbursement Categories (pages 12 and 13) to read as follows:

“The City will reimburse employees for dependent care or elder care expenses while traveling during normal business hours (8 a.m.- 5 p.m.) Dependent classification is identified by the IRS as being a child under the age of 13, a spouse or dependent of any age who is incapable of self-care and who lives with you for more than half of the year. For this purpose, elder care may qualify for those who do not live with the authorized employee or official. Elder care would qualify for an immediate family member as defined by the City of Dover Employee Handbook. Receipts for expenses paid will be required and only reimbursed if not otherwise covered by qualifying medical or care coverage held by the authorized employee, official, qualified dependent, or elder.”

A change to section 3.(m) Non-reimbursable Expenses (page 14) now includes pet and animal boarding or care.

79

Page 80

Item 1.

CITY OF DOVER

TRAINING, CONFERENCE & TRAVEL POLICY

ADOPTED – (enter 2025 approval date)

  • A.INTRODUCTION
  • 1.Purpose

The purpose of this policy is to provide guidelines under which City of Dover employees, public officials, and appointees will be reimbursed for authorized travel expenses incurred in the conduct of business for the City of Dover, hereinafter referred to as “City.” In addition to the guidelines, specific procedures regarding incurring and reporting related expenses are provided.

  • 2.Scope

This policy shall apply to employees of the City of Dover, elected officials, boards, commissions and others, who are engaged in authorized travel and who expend City funds for travel purposes. The Mayor and Members of City Council are not required to submit a Travel Request & Itinerary or Travel Expense Report Form but are required to follow the financial and budget requirements of this policy.

While this policy does not cover every possible situation, it establishes adequate guidelines for employees and officials to make appropriate and consistent judgments regarding the expenditure of City funds for reimbursable expenses. The City of Dover will provide flexibility to meet the special needs and requirements of their employees during travel.

It remains the responsibility of city management to control and approve travel-related expenditures. The City Manager and Controller/Treasurer may impose more stringent rules when deemed appropriate or necessary.

The City Manager and Controller/Treasurer will review every three years the implementation of this Policy and will provide policy interpretations and assistance to ensure effective and efficient implementation. Any exceptions will be subject to approval by the City Manager and Controller/Treasurer. The City Manager and Controller/Treasurer may also, on a case-by case basis, approve reimbursements exceeding the guideline amounts referenced in this policy. In any such instance, a detailed explanation and substantiation (a receipt) is required. Enforcement of this policy will be the responsibility of the Controller/Treasurer.

  • 3.Responsibility
  • a.Employee, Public Official, or Appointee

80

Page 81

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 2 of 19 Item 1.

· Traveler should be made aware of and comply with all provisions of this policy. · Obtain the necessary approvals in advance for overnight travel and out-of-state use of City vehicles. Provide a copy of the approval with the travel prepayment made by direct voucher. · All expenses incurred during City business are to be in accordance with the City’s Administrative Policies and Rules of Ethics and must be paid solely from appropriated funds. · Comply with the ten (10) working-day rule.

  • b.Department Director/City Manager/Council Designee · Ensure compliance with this policy.
  • i.Review and approve each of their employee’s/official’s travel approval requests and reimbursable expenses. ii. Ensure sufficient funds are available for all anticipated expenses.
  • c.Signatures on the Travel Expense Report (City of Dover Form 030 Exhibit B) certify that the expenses were incurred by the employee/official requesting reimbursement for official City business, are reimbursable in accordance with this policy, and have not been reimbursed except as indicated on this form.

Required signatures for expenses are:
· Employee
· Department Director or Council Designee

  • B.TRAINING AND CONFERENCE REGISTRATION FEES
  • 1.Request for payment of registration fees shall be accompanied by the registration form.
  • 2.City Council, Planning Commission and the Mayor are offered opportunities to attend courses designed for governmental officials. Any member of Council wanting to take advantage of these courses offered by the following organizations will submit to the City Clerk’s office their request for registration.
  • •Delaware League of Local Governments
  • •National League of Cities
  • •US Conference of Mayors
  • •International City Managers Association
  • •Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA)
  • •American Public Power Association (APPA)
  • •American Public Works Association (APWA)

81

Page 82

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 3 of 19 Item 1.

  • •American Planning Association
  • •Organizations that provide Continuing Education credits for professional license renewals of applicable staff.

Any courses not offered by these organizations will be submitted to the City Manager and Controller/Treasurer for concurrence.

  • C.TRAVEL AUTHORIZATION

All out-of-state travel that extends beyond one day shall be approved by the Department Head /Director. All requests shall be made on the "Travel Request and Itinerary Estimate Form” (City of Dover - Form 047 Exhibit A). A copy of the conference or meeting program must be attached to the form. The form should be submitted to the Department Head / Director at least 30 days prior to travel unless an explanation is given and approved.

The Department Head, Director or City Manager may impose specific requirements as to the time the form must be submitted prior to travel. Employees and Officials traveling on official City business should be aware that the approval is for travel only and is not a blanket approval of the expenses incurred.

A travel packet including the Travel Request and Itinerary Estimate form, the meeting program/itinerary, and the purchase order(s) if over $5,000, for advanced costs must be submitted to the Accounts Payable Department for audit prior to being keyed by department for reimbursement. Once the travel audit has been completed, Accounts Payable will scan and email the authorized packet to the department responsible for processing the travel costs. The department admin will then process the reimbursement request for payment. The Purchase Orders for the advanced costs should include the necessary supporting documentation. It does not require the submission of duplicate information.

Please note: Purchase Orders (if required based on Purchasing Policy) for registration costs must include the Registration form. Submission for hotel and airfare costs must include documentation of the individual costs. Cancellation and changes to travel should be done in a timely manner to avoid loss of City money. If travel cannot be refunded back to City, an explanation is required.

  • D.TRANSPORTATION: COMMON CARRIER
  • 1.General

All trips requiring the use of common carrier (airline, rail or bus) must be pre-approved by the appropriate approval authority.

The mode of travel must be justified based on the most economical use of time of the personnel involved, the cost of optional travel modes, and the requirements of the trip.

82

Page 83

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 4 of 19 Item 1.

All common carrier reservations must be consistent with reasonable business travel planning, common carrier will be booked at the lowest available fare. If the lowest available fare is turned down by the traveler, the traveler's explanation for the denial is to be provided with the travel authorization request.

Travelers should be advised to make travel reservations as far in advance as possible to attain the lowest fares, including non-refundable tickets. Travelers may not specify airlines or other carriers to accumulate mileage on promotional plans such as frequent flyer programs.

To take advantage of special discount rates (supersaver fares, etc.), reimbursement to an employee may be made prior to a trip being taken under the following conditions: a. Documentation of the substantial savings that will accrue to the City (e.g., supersaver discounts). b. Employee's proof of payment on a statement from the airline, other than credit card receipts.

Most airlines will not give refunds or partial refunds for supersaver airfares.

It is encouraged to examine the advantage of fares requiring early trip departure or delayed return. However, it is important to consider the additional cost of meals and lodging for the required extra day(s) stay when comparing cost.

  • 2.Air Travel
  • a.Accommodations - When commercial airlines are used as a mode of travel, accommodations shall be coach/economy class unless some other class accommodations are more economical. Costs of baggage should be considered along with accommodations to achieve the lowest total cost for travel.
  • b.Routing of Travel - All travel will be by the most economical and direct routes.

In the event a person travels by an indirect route for personal convenience, the extra expense shall be the responsibility of the individual. Reimbursement for expenses shall be based only on the cost of the most economical and direct route.

  • c.Conference Airfare Arrangements

When attending a conference, always check conference materials to see if special airline discounts are offered. When a special airline discount rate is offered and conferees are instructed to go directly to an airline to obtain the discount fare, the employee should compare the conference rates through the internet with all other airline rates available before scheduling airline reservations. The employee should

83

Page 84

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 5 of 19 Item 1.

always book the lowest fare possible. (See Section F.3. for Conference Lodging Arrangements).

*City will not pay for, nor reimburse priority boarding, preferred seating, or overweight baggage for personal preference. Detailed explanation and receipts are required. *

  • 3.Rail Travel
  • a.Accommodations – When it has been determined that rail travel is the most appropriate mode of transportation, the most economical class accommodations shall be utilized.
  • E.TRANSPORTATION: PASSENGER VEHICLES
  • 1.City-Owned Vehicles

City-owned vehicles should be utilized for both in-state and out-of-state travel when such use is the most practical and economical mode of transportation, including the cost of tolls, fuel and parking.

  • 2.Use of Privately-Owned Vehicles
  • a.The use of privately owned vehicles for any City travel (both in state and out-of-state) should only be used when a City Vehicle is not available. The use of a privately owned vehicle for City travel shall require the prior approval of the City Manager or Department Head / Director. Reimbursement of private vehicle expenses shall be at the Council approved rate as indicated on Exhibit B for actual and necessary miles traveled. Beginning and ending odometer readings are required for the reimbursement for mileage or a printout from MapQuest, Google Maps or other reputable internet mapping application showing the quickest or shortest route.
  • b.In considering approval for use of personal vehicles, the approval authority shall take into consideration the cost of alternative modes of travel and the cost of meals and lodging for the additional travel/transit days. Mileage reimbursements shall not exceed the cost of airfare plus travel to/from the airport.
  • c.When two or more employees travel in a privately owned vehicle, only one mileage reimbursement will be allowed at times when one vehicle is sufficient to carry all passengers.
  • 3.Rental Cars
  • a.General

84

Page 85

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 6 of 19 Item 1.

The use of a rental car when traveling out of state must be justified as an economical need and not as a matter of personal convenience. Prior approval by the Department Head / Director or City Manager is required before arranging for car rental. All rentals should be at the most economical rate per day including government rates or special rate agreements. When traveling in groups, sharing of cars, when practical, must be done to minimize costs. The city will not pay for the use of a rental car to accommodate family members or non-business associates traveling with the employee, public official, or appointee.

  • b.Vehicle Size

Whenever possible, compact cars shall be rented or reserved. However, if a larger size vehicle is more economical or more than two city travelers are traveling together the larger vehicle may be appropriate. Any representative of the City requesting an upgrade of the size of a rented vehicle shall provide a written explanation of their reasons to the City Manager or Department Head / Director. A receipt is always required.

  • c.Insurance

(1) The optional insurance coverage offered by the car rental agency must be declined when the traveler charges the rental car. The traveler will automatically receive primary coverage under the City blanket insurance policy for travel. When insurance is declined, the policy covers collision damage, theft, fire and vandalism. Reimbursements for additional or optional insurance coverage will not be allowed.

(2) Other. Travelers not covered under the blanket insurance policy may be covered by their personal automobile insurance policy or other personal credit cards. Travelers should check their automobile policy and credit card policy for business travel coverage and accept or decline additional coverage accordingly. Reimbursement for additional or optional insurance coverage will not be allowed.

  • d.Refueling Before Return

To avoid a refueling surcharge, all rental cars shall be refueled before returning the vehicle to the rental company. Any surcharges billed to the employee, public official, appointee, or City shall be explained in the reimbursement request.

  • e.Reservations

85

Page 86

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 7 of 19 Item 1.

Approved car rental reservations shall be made in advance whenever possible. The employee should compare car rental rates and always look to reserve the lowest rental.

  • F.PER DIEM EXPENSES

The City of Dover uses per diem expenses as set by the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) for official travel within the United States. M&IE Rates can be found at: http://www.gsa.gov/perdiem.

  • G.LODGING
  • 1.General City travelers are expected to seek accommodations that are comfortable, convenient, meet business and personal needs and offer good value. Employees are expected to compare local lodging rates in the area prior to reserving lodging.
  • 2.Accommodation
  • a.Lodging accommodations for reasonably priced single occupancy rooms are reimbursable when the traveler is away from home overnight due to official travel.
  • b.Accommodations shared with family members or others not on official City business are reimbursable at the single occupancy rate only.
  • c.Accommodations shared with other City travelers should be billed and reimbursed to one traveler. When required, reimbursements to more than one traveler shall be based on a pro rata share as reported on each reimbursement request.
  • 3.Conference Lodging Arrangements

When hotel rooms are blocked for a conference, seminar, etc., and a special discounted conference hotel rate provided, the employee/official should compare conference rates with the rates for other local hotels within a three (3) block radius of the conference. The employee is urged to reserve hotel accommodations that offer the best value to the City. This includes conference rate, government rate or lower rate, for the employee/official. If a lower rate is not available, the conferees should make their lodging arrangements directly utilizing the conference instructions. Conference lodging will be considered to accommodate persons with special circumstances.

  • 4.Occupancy/Sales Tax

The City is exempt from the tax on occupancy of hotel, motel and tourist home rooms within Delaware only. When instate overnight accommodations are necessary, the employee should be

86

Page 87

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 8 of 19 Item 1.

provided with a copy of the Occupancy Tax Exemption Certificate (see Exhibit C) to be presented to the lodging facility. Tax on occupancy of hotels in other states must be paid. Out of state hotels shall be asked about their sales tax exemption policies and the traveler shall provide documentation to avoid applicable sales taxes whenever possible.

  • H.MEAL ALLOWANCES
  • 1.General
  • a.The City will pay for or reimburse an employee/official for the necessary and reasonable cost of meals and incidental expenses incurred during out of state travel requiring overnight lodging.

Additional meal costs incurred over and above those provided as part of a conference, lodging, or airfare fee are not reimbursable, unless justified as a special circumstance and approved by the City Manager and/or Controller/Treasurer (e.g., special meeting or diet restrictions). Exceptions are to be pre-approved by the City Manager and/or Controller/Treasurer.

There will not be any reimbursement for meals when the meals are provided as part of the conference/training or by the host organization and when meals are provided as part of the hotel service and/or airfare.

If an employee is traveling partial days on any calendar day, the City will prorate the applicable advanced M&IE rate based upon time and location of meal. “Breakfast per diem is paid for travel extending after midnight until 10 am. Lunch per diem will be paid for travel that extends after 10 am and until 3 pm. Dinner reimbursement is paid for travel extending after 3 pm of the final day of travel. Travel begins when you leave your home, office or the last location before you proceed to the travel destination or transportation center (e.g., airport, train station). This applies to both day of departure and day of return.

When meals are provided at the conference or by the host, the meal allowance will be reduced by 25% for each meal provided. Continental Breakfast provided by the hotel or at the conference is counted as a meal, unless justified as a special circumstance and approved by the City Manager and/or Controller/Treasurer (e.g., special meeting or diet restrictions). Example of breakdown for M&IE rates can be found at: http://gsa.gov.perdiem.

  • 2.Day Trips, In-state Travel and Before or After Hours

The meal allowance for day trips out of the City of Dover will be reimbursed at actual cost, if it does not exceed 25% of the normal per diem per the M&IE Allowance. The meal allowance for working before or after hours as a rule are not encouraged but may be approved by the City Manager and/or Controller/Treasurer on a case-by-case basis. At no time can the amount exceed the allowances established. A receipt is required.

87

Page 88

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 9 of 19 Item 1.

  • I.CASH ADVANCES AND ADVANCE PAYMENT

General/Blanket travel advance checks may not be issued to employees, public officials, or appointees. Employees, public officials, and appointees will be reimbursed for specific travel related expenses after the trip or event has been completed.

Department Head / Directors should use their City of Dover credit card for business travel. Department Head / Directors may use their departmental travel credit card when arranging employee travel. Under urgent situations, and with prior approval, employees and officials can also use a personal credit card and request reimbursement when they return.

The City of Dover will pay specific travel and lodging costs in advance, if the request deadlines are met. Employees, public officials, and appointees shall use a City purchase order (if necessary) when requesting travel cost advances.

Please note: The same procedure for Travel Authorization, as identified in Part C (above) will be required, with the exception that the travel packet must be submitted to the Accounts Payable Department a minimum of 20 days prior to travel.

The City of Dover will pay in advance the following costs:

  • a)Conference/Training registration fees. Such payment will be made payable directly to the organization. A copy of the registration form describing the specific event must be attached to the travel packet.
  • b)Airfare. Airfare is normally reserved on-line through the internet and paid with a City of Dover credit card after travel approval has been received. (See City Credit Card Policy)
  • c)Lodging. Upon receipt of the approved Travel Request and Itinerary Estimate Form, the department may submit a purchase order (if necessary) for lodging. The check will be made payable to the hotel and will be given to the person for whom the lodging arrangements are made. The department must provide supporting documentation including the daily lodging rates and applicable taxes along with the travel packet. Lodging reservations can be held with the use of a City of Dover credit card. (See City Credit Card Policy)
  • d)Meal allowance. An advance for the M&IE Allowance, which includes meals, tax and tips expenses, will be permitted for meals not provided by the conference, lodging or airfare as indicated in Section H (1) above. Only per diem rates as set by the Federal Government for official travel will be provided for M&IE Allowance. No purchase order

88

Page 89

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 10 of 19 Item 1.

is required for employee travel advance if the amount is less than $5,000.00. M&IE Rates can be found at: http://www.gsa.gov/perdiem.

  • J.TRAVEL EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
  • 1.General

Travel Expense Report (City of Dover Form 30) is due to Accounts Payable for final audit within ten (10) working days after travel or an expense is incurred (Ten working- day rule). Travel Expense Reports will be scanned and emailed to the remitting department for entry. Paper copies will remain in Finance.

  • a.Timely reimbursement can be assured only if an accurate, properly substantiated Travel Expense Report is received by Accounts Payable ten (10) working days after completion of the trip.
  • b.Failure to submit timely Travel Expense Reports after the completion of a trip will result in administrative action, such as notification to the Department Head / Director and denial of future travel requests.

Travel Expense Reports for local travel and related expenses are to be submitted monthly. Explanation is required if over 30 days and approved by Controller/Treasurer Department Head / Director and/or City Manager. Failure to file for reimbursement for travel/conference/training related expenses within the 30-day window may result in denial of the reimbursement request.

Note: This section pertains to only those travel expenses paid by the traveler; not to travel expenses directly billed to/paid by the City of Dover.

  • 2.Receipt Requirements and Other Reimbursement Criteria
  • a.Tickets booked on common carriers (airline, rail or bus) require original copy of the paid invoice or email confirmation containing total travel costs for arrangements booked on-line.
  • b.Hotel/motel bills shall be the original copy of hotel/motel billing marked paid.
  • c.Ground transportation, including airport shuttle, taxi or public transit requires a receipt.

89

Page 90

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 11 of 19 Item 1.

  • d.Car rental reimbursements require paid invoice from the rental company.
  • e.All Meals DO NOT require receipts and are not reimbursable above the maximum daily/partial day per diem meal allowance. Tax and tips are included in the M&IE Allowance and will not be reimbursed separately. When more than one City employee, public official, or appointee’s meals are being reimbursed, each employee must submit a separate Travel Expense Reimbursement for their allowance.
  • f.Hotel/motel related expenses should be documented identifying the date and the cost for each category with the following requirements:

(1) Out-of-pocket costs for incidental items such as tips, baggage handling and maid service are not individually reimbursable by the City of Dover. Costs included under this category are included in the M&IE per diem rate. Only per diem rates as prescribed by the Federal Government for official travel will be provided for M&IE allowance.

(2) City-business related telephone calls are reimbursable as incurred and require a receipt from the telephone service provider or included on the hotel/motel billing invoice.

  • g.Lodging at campgrounds using traveler’s camper or recreational vehicle is reimbursable at the actual cost, not to exceed the equivalent cost of hotel/motel lodging. Receipt is required.
  • h.Other Reimbursement Categories

Reimbursement for the following categories should be submitted on a schedule identifying the date, the cost and the category. All supporting receipts must be attached:

(1) The City will reimburse employees for hotel and airport self-parking. The City encourages all employees to seek ‘economy and budget parking’. (2) The City will not reimburse employees for Valet parking, unless prior approval has been granted by the City Manager and Controller. (3) The City will reimburse employees the cost of tolls for interstates, turnpike, bridges and/or ferries. All travel expenses require a receipt. (4) The City will reimburse employees for necessary airport baggage fee. A receipt is required. (5) The City will reimburse employees for dependent care or elder care expenses while traveling during normal business hours (8 a.m.- 5 p.m.) Dependent classification is identified by the IRS as being a child under the age of 13, a spouse or dependent of any age who is incapable of self-care and who lives with you for more than half of

90

Page 91

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 12 of 19 Item 1.

the year. For this purpose, elder care may qualify for those who do not live with the authorized employee or official. Elder care would qualify for an immediate family member as defined by the City of Dover Employee Handbook. Receipts for expenses paid will be required and only reimbursed if not otherwise covered by qualifying medical or care coverage held by the authorized employee, official, qualified dependent, or elder.

  • i.Gasoline and/or Other Supplies require a receipt.

In extenuating circumstances where a receipt is not able to be procured for gasoline/fuel purchase(s), a copy of the credit card statement can be substituted for the receipt. The transaction date should reflect a range within the dates of travel.

Need for emergency repairs incidental to using a City-owned vehicle shall require a Vendor receipt.

  • j.Department Head / Director pre-approval is required to receive reimbursement for Internet Access Costs for city business. These costs must be substantiated with receipts.
  • k.While traveling overnight out-of-state, the City will reimburse employees for the cost of up to two (2) personal telephone calls not to exceed $8 per trip. A receipt is required for reimbursement.
  • l.Reimbursements for travel expenses incurred without required receipts, as outlined, is strictly prohibited. A "no receipt - no reimbursement" policy applies, except in extenuating circumstances in fuel purchase(s) referenced in (i) above.
  • 3.Non- Reimbursable Expenses

The City shall not reimburse expenses for the following: a. Alcoholic beverages. b. In-room movies or pay television. c. Theater tickets or nightclub entertainment. d. Laundry. e. Related expenses of spouse, children and other persons accompanying the authorized employee or official. f. Pleasure, historic or other tour related expenses. Expenses for business related tours would be reimbursed. g. Donations and gifts made while at training, conference, or meeting. h. Loss or damage of personal items. i. Meals for other conference attendees. j. Purchase of personal items. k. Any parking or moving violation fines.

91

Page 92

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 13 of 19 Item 1.

  • l.Any personal or pleasure travel while on City business.
  • m.Any pet or animal boarding or care.
  • K.CHARTER AND CODE OF CONDUCT

All City of Dover policies are subject to the City of Dover Charter Part 1, Subpart A, Article II, Section 12 “Compensation and expenses - Mayor and Council and other elected or appointed officials”, whereas “Members of the council, mayor and other elected or appointed officials shall receive reimbursement for actual and necessary expenses incurred when on official business as prescribed by city ordinance or policy” and Part. II Code of Ordinances Chapter 2, Article 1, Division 4 “Code of Conduct”, which is “applicable to all elected and appointed officials and to all employees of the City of Dover.”

  • L.INTERNAL REVENUE CODE - DEFINITION OF PUBLIC OFFICIAL

Generally, if there is any provision in a public law which authorizes the employment of the individual, and the individual is hired or elected under this authority, the individual is considered an employee of the State or political subdivision to which the provision applies.

The following factors indicate that an office is a “public office.”

The office was created by the constitution or through legislation, or by a municipality or other body with authority conferred by the legislature.

The office was delegated a portion of the powers of the government body.

The powers conferred and the duties to be discharged are defined either directly or indirectly law or through legislative authority.

The duties are being performed independently and without control of a superior power other than the law.

The office has some permanency and continuity, and the officer takes an official oath.

Examples of public officers are the president and vice president, a governor or mayor, the secretary of state, a member of a legislative body, such as a state legislature, county commission, city council, school board, a judge, a justice of the peace, and members of advisory boards and committees.

92

Page 93

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 14 of 19 Item 1.

  • M.REVIEW & REVISION

The City of Dover Travel Policy will be reviewed every three years by the City Manager and Controller/Treasurer to provide recommended changes to City Council for approval.

EXHIBITS

Exhibit A - COD Travel Request and Itinerary Estimate Form (Form 47) Exhibit B - COD Travel Expense Report Form (Form 30) Exhibit C - COD Exemption Certificate Form 99A

REVISION RECORD

Revised: November 24, 2003 Revised: February 9, 2004 Revised: July 24, 2006 Revised: March 23, 2009 Revised: January 23, 2012 Revised: February 23, 2015 Revised: February 26, 2018 Revised: February 24, 2020 Revised: May 10, 2022

93

Page 94

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 15 of 19 Item 1.

EXHIBIT A

CITY OF DOVER TRAVEL REQUEST AND ITINERARY ESTIMATE

EMPLOYEE TRAVELING REQUEST TE DA

BUSINESS PURPOSE

DEPARTMENT TRAVEL DAT ES

TRAVEL DESTINATION

ESTIMATE ITEMIZED EXPENSES AND TRAVEL ADVANCES NOTE: ITINERARY AND PROOF FOR ALL TRAVEL ADVANCE REQUESTS BELOW ARE REQUIRED PRIOR TO TRAVEL.

  • •APPROVAL FOR SPECIAL REQUESTS ARE REQUIRED FROM FINANCE-CONTROLLER/TREASURER OR CITY MANAGER PRIOR TO TRIP * ESTIMAT ED COST:

REGISTRATION FEE: MEALS PROVIDED BY CONFERENCE MUST BE DEDUCTED FROM M & IE RATE.

MODE OF TRAVEL AND COSTS:

AIRLINE ROUND ONE WAY TRIP 0.00

AIRPORT PARKING PER DAY TOTAL DAYS 0.00

ROUND TRAIN ONE WAY TRIP 0.00

ROUND

BUSONE WAYTRIP0.00
* RENTAL CAR
ROUND
ONE WAYTRIP0.00
  • •PERSONAL CAR TOTAL MILEAGE 0.40 PER MILE 0.00
  • •TOLLS ONE WAY ROUND TRIP 0.00

CITY VEHICLE " IS ADVISE TO BE USED INSTEAD OF PERSONAL CAR"

94

Page 95

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 16 of 19 Item 1.

LODGING EXPENSES: BREAKFAST PROVIDED BY HOTEL MUST BE DEDUCTED FROM M & IE RATE

PER HOTEL NIGHT TAXES NUM OF NIGHTS 0.00

  • •SHUTTLE PER TRIP TAXES TOTAL TRIP 0.00
  • •TAXI PER TRIP TAXES TOTAL TRIP 0.00
  • •PARKING PER DAY TAXES TOTAL DAYS 0.00

M&IE RATE (MEALS & INCIDENTAL EXPENSES) MEALS ARE PRORATED FOR PARTIAL DAYS AND MEALS: REDUCED BY 25% FOR EACH MEAL PROVIDED BY HOST. SEE TRAVEL POLICY.

SUN MON TUE WED THUR FRI SAT

DATES:

PERDIEM RATE:

TOTAL 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

$0.00
TOTAL EX PENSE

EMPLOYEE SIGNATURE DATE

DEPARTMENT HEAD APPROVAL DATE

ACCOUNTS PAYABLE APPROVAL DATE

CITY MANAGER OR COUNCIL DESIGNEE APPROVAL DATE

95

Page 96

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 17 of 19 Item 1.

Form 047

EXHIBIT B CITY OF DOVER TRAVEL EXPENSE REPORT FORM

NAME OF EMPLOYEE DEPARTMENT TRIP TAKEN TO (CITY)

PURPOSE OF TRIP

Please attach receipts for hotels, tolls, transportation, etc., and show all costs on this form. Please use a separate form for each week. Please note incidental expenses (tips) are included in M & IE Rate.

EXPENSES MON TUES WED THUR FRI SAT SUN TOTAL DATE

REGISTRATION FEES $ -

TRANSPORTATION - AIR/TRAIN/BUS$-
PERSONAL AUTO
Miles @ .40 cents a mile$-

AUTO RENTAL $ -

PARKING FEES / TOLLS / GAS $ -

TAXI / SHUTTLE / PUBLIC TRANSIT $ -

HOTEL / MOTEL $ -

TELEPHONE $ -

BAGGAGE / MISC. EXPENSES $ -

MEALS (M & IE RATE) $ -

MEAL ALLOWANCE OVERAGE$-
TOTALS$-$-$-$0.00$0.00 $-$-$-

EMPLOYEE INCURRING EXPENSE DATE FINANCE - FINAL ACTION DATE

DEPARTMENT HEAD SIGNATURE DATE GL ACCOUNT NUMBER

(For Certification)

FINANCE DEPARTMENT - AUDIT DATE

96

Page 97

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 18 of 19 Item 1.

Form 30 REIMBURSEMENT AMOUNT DUE EMPLOYEE

AMOUNT DUE CITY TOTAL EXPENSES INCURRED ABOVE $

LESS AMOUNT PAID BY CITY BELOW: $ -

REGISTRATION CHECK / CITY CC

HOTEL CHECK / CITY CC

AIRFARE CHECK / CITY CC

MEALS MISC: CHECK#

CHECK / CITY CC

EXHIBIT C

CITY OF DOVER DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE

EXEMPTION CERTIFICATE TAX ON OCCUPANCY OF HOTEL AND MOTEL AND TOUR IST HOME ROOMS

In accordance with Internal Revenue Code Section 5253(I), no tax shall be imposed under section 4251 upon any payment received for services or facilities furnished to the government of any State, or any political subdivision thereof, or the District of Columbia.

This Part to be Completed by the Operator

Name of Hotel, Motel, or Tourist Home Fed. EI or SS number

Address City State Zip Code

This Part to be Completed by the Occupant

This is to certify that I, the undersigned, am a representative of the City of Dover, Delaware; that the charges for the occupancy at the above establishment on the dates set forth below has been or will be paid for by the City of Dover, a government unit; and that such charges are incurred in the performance of my official duties as a representative or employee of the governmental unit.

Name (Please type or print) Signature

City of Dover 51-6000092

97

Page 98

Training, Conference & Travel Policy Page 19 of 19 Item 1.

Governmental Unit Tax I.D. # Title

P.O. Box 475 Dover DE 19903-0475
Address City State Zip Code

Date(s) of Occupancy

If additional information is needed, please contact the City of Dover Finance Director at (302) 7367018.

NOTE: A separate Exemption Certificate is required for each occupancy and for each representative or employee.

THIS EXEMPTION CERTIFICATE IS TO BE RETAINED BY THE OPERATORS OF HOTELS, MOTELS, AND TOURIST HOMES AS EVIDENCE OF EXEMPT OCCUPANCY. \\Dover_1\finance\FORMS\DOCUMENTS\FORM99 A.wpd

98

Page 99

Item 2.

CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE

ACTION FORM

PROCEEDING: City Council DEPARTMENT OF ORIGIN: Police SUBMITTED ON: February 18, 2025 PREPARED BY: Captain Robert E. Roswell, Administration Division Commander REVIEWED BY: David S. Hugg, III, City Manager and Patricia Marney, Controller / Treasurer

SUBJECT: FY25 CIP Budget – Installation of Security Fence at Police Department TIMETABLE: Notice to proceed to be issued immediately upon Council approval RELATED PROJECT: N/A REFERENCE: CIP- PD2501

EXPENDITURE REQUIRED: $93,784

AMOUNT BUDGETED: $ 215,800.00

FUNDING SOURCE (Dept./Page in CIP & Budget): Police-/Page 58

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Approve the bid of $93,784 submitted by Pro Max Fence Systems, LLC and initiate project using Bond Bill grant funds.

BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS:

In recent years, the Police Department has had an increasing number of issues on our campus with individuals trespassing in restricted areas, vandalizing police vehicles, and obstructing police operations in relation to access and egress. Undercover vehicles are also parked in the back parking lot. This leaves them visible to people passing by and operating in the surrounding areas. In addition, due to the close proximity of the Justice of the Peace Court, Bus Depot and U.S. Post Office, a significant number of people trespass through “police only” areas where essential police equipment is parked. Individuals have been found sleeping in the Police Station’s parking lot and recent civil disorder, that crossed the line into criminal conduct, led to projectiles being thrown at the glass windows and doors of Headquarters. Although the physical security of the property is improving; remote door locks and cameras were added to the front entrance and additional cameras in the station’s interior and exterior are being installed; access to the property is still open. There are “police vehicles only” signs at the parking lot entrances, along with markings on the road, but they are not effective. Due to the lack of physical security surrounding the Police Department, including the vehicle lots, there continues to be significant risk posed to personnel (particularly civilian) and property. Therefore, fencing is a logical solution to the lack of physical security.

99

Page 100

Item 2.

Being mindful of city budget challenges, in the fall of 2022, the Chief of Police began discussions with State Legislators regarding the need for the installation of a security fence at Police Department. A tour was arranged and the elected officials in attendance immediately recognized the need. The Chief was advised to make the necessary submissions for police projects that could be funded through the state bond bill. An estimate for the proposed project totaled $215,800.00. Leading into FY 24, the first effort was unsuccessful. Leading into FY 25, the City was successful in obtaining the funding for this project. Bids were opened on Tuesday January 14, 2025 at 2:00 pm. Four contractors submitted bids for the proposed fence installation. The contract bids are as follows:

ContractorLocationBid Amount
All VinylHammonton, NJ$102,400

Forrest Fencing Felton, DE $168,500

New Holland Chainlink New Holland, PA $96,498

Pro Max Fence Systems Reading, PA $93,784

Each bid was evaluated on five factors, which included experience, staff, cost (see above), service ability, and location related to the City of Dover. Furthermore, Forrest Fencing indicated that they were a minority owned business; however, the bid amount of $168,500 was not within the 3% margin for minority vendor preference according to the City of Dover Purchasing Policy. Based upon this comprehensive evaluation, Pro Max Fence Systems scored the highest with a 95 out of 100 possible points. It should be noted that residual dollars in this budget will be put towards creating electronic access points through a separate vendor.

ACTION REQUESTED:

The Council Committee of the Whole approve the project award to Pro Max Fence Systems, LLC as requested.

100

Back to this meeting