This text was pulled from the PDF automatically and may contain mistakes. The PDF is the official record, so check it before relying on this.
9 pages have little or no readable text here, often scans or drawings. See the PDF for those.
Page 1
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
The Regular City Council Meeting was held on March 10, 2025, at 6:30 p.m., with Council President Anderson presiding. Council members present were Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mrs. Arndt, Mr. Rocha, and Dr. Sudler. Mr. Lewis was absent.
Staff members present were Police Chief Johnson, Mr. Hugg, Ms. Melson-Williams, Fire Chief Carey (via Webex), Mr. Rodriguez, and Ms. Bennett. Ms. Marney was absent. Mayor Christiansen was also present.
OPEN FORUM
The Open Forum was held at 6:15 p.m., prior to the commencement of the Official Council Meeting. Council President Anderson declared the Open Forum in session and reminded those present that Council was not in official session and could not take formal action.
LaChelle Paul, 501 Silverside Drive, expressed concerns for constituents in the Fourth District regarding street cleaning and the pick-up process. She mentioned that this has been ongoing since 2020, with the mayor, Dr. Sudler, and Mr. Anderson being aware of the situation. It involves certain streets in the Fourth District not being cleaned, leading to residents cleaning the streets themselves. Residents should not be cleaning the streets because the city provides the service. She emphasized that this issue needs to be addressed, and that street cleaning needs to be consistent.
Responding to Ms. Paul, Mr. Anderson mentioned that they have increased the frequency of street cleaning, and if she would like he would send her the street cleaning records.
Ms. Paul mentioned that the streets are not being cleaned as scheduled. She personally goes out the day before and the day after the scheduled street cleaning, taking pictures to document the situation. She stated that cars are not being moved at night when street cleaning is supposed to occur. Ms. Paul suggested that council go out and see the issues for themselves. She stressed that the districts must be serviced properly, as they are supposed to be.
INVOCATION
The invocation was given by Bishop Carol Boggerty.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Council President Anderson.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Dr. Sudler moved for the adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Neil, and unanimously carried (Lewis absent).
ADOPTION OF CONSENT AGENDA
All Consent Agenda items are considered routine and non-controversial and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the Council. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of Council so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered a separate item.
Page 2
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 2
Ms. Arndt requested the removal of Item #7, Review of Active Recreation Plan – Cash-in-Lieu Request – Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 North West Street and Item #11, Request for Waiver of Appendix A – Subdivision, Article VI – Subdivision General Requirements and Design Standards, Section A – Streets, Item 13.8 – Requirement for Rear Access Alley for Townhouses and Request for Waiver of Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 17 – Emergency Access Requirements from the consent agenda.
Mr. Neil moved for the adoption of the consent agenda as amended, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Lewis absent).
PROCLAMATION – WOMEN’S HISTORY MONTH
The City Clerk read the following Proclamation into the record:
WHEREAS, the theme for Women’s History Month in March 2025, as established by the National Women’s History Alliance, is “Moving Forward Together! Women Educating and Inspiring Generations.” This theme celebrates the collective strength and influence of women who have dedicated their lives to education, mentorship, and leadership. Through their efforts, they have served as an inspiration for all generations – both past and present; and,
WHEREAS, the theme of the United Nations Observance of International Women’s Day on March 8, 2025, is “Accelerate Action,” which “emphasizes the importance of taking swift and decisive steps to achieve gender equality. It calls for increased momentum and urgency in addressing the systemic barriers and biases that women face, both in personal and professional spheres;” and,
WHEREAS, the history of International Women’s Day and Women’s History Month emerged from the labor and antiwar movements of the early 20th century, with an emphasis on women’s suffrage and workers’ rights that later expanded to include equal pay and other fair labor practices, sexual and reproductive rights, and the prevention of gender-based violence; and,
WHEREAS, International Women’s Day and Women’s History Month offer a reminder that all attempts to subjugate women, erode women’s rights, and promote and defend gender-based violence – whether in our homes, our workplaces, or our legislatures – must be resisted; and,
WHEREAS, these observances also offer an opportunity to celebrate the contributions that women of every race, class, ethnic background, and gender identity have made to the social, cultural, and economic life of the community; and,
NOW, THEREFORE, I, ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF DOVER, DELAWARE, do hereby proclaim March 2025 as WOMEN’S HISTORY MONTH & INTERNATIONAL WOMEN’S DAY in the City of Dover and encourage all residents to honor and recognize the vital contributions made by women. Dedicated to the women who have served on City Council: Esther Frear, Goldie Legates, Holly Malone, Beverly Williams, Sophia Russell, Tricia Arndt, and Dr. Julia Pillsbury.
Mayor Christiansen presented the Proclamation to Councilwoman Arndt and Councilwoman Dr.
Page 3
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 3
Pillsbury and thanked them for all that they do and for all that the women in the country and nation do to make it a greater place to live, work, and play.
Dr. Pillsbury stated that she is a product of the fifties, and she has seen the impact of women over the last seventy years. She stated that they still have a long way to go to get equality and to be recognized equally with the men in the room.
Ms. Arndt stated that the honor was bestowed upon them last year as well. She was hopeful then and remains hopeful but now more than ever all women need to be cautiously optimistic and vigilant to maintain the rights that they have and to expand those rights.
PRESENTATION – ANNUAL REPORT – PLANNING, INSPECTIONS, AND
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT 2024 ANNUAL REPORT
Ms. Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, provided a presentation of the 2024 Annual Report of Planning, Inspections, and Community Development.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca explained that the traffic impact study was a requirement set by the state through DelDOT, so the city was not involved in collecting the fees as it was handled at the state level. She noted that sometimes, developers pay in lieu of conducting a traffic study, particularly when considering a larger area. If multiple developments are in a similar district or along the same road segment, they may prefer them to be evaluated together, but that process is completed by the state. The developers would get input from the Planning Office on the project and any concerns that the city has.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca explained that the Parkland Fund is a special fund managed by the city, where cash-in-lieu of funds related to Parkland are deposited. She noted that those funds are monitored separately and are not combined with other city funds. The funds could only be used for park improvements or developments. When the funds are spent, they would be presented as a capital project in the budget documents, with the funding option being shown.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Duca mentioned that designating the funds was something that could be discussed at the council level. She suggested it would be a good idea to address this during the application process, allowing them to review the applicant’s intent and identify any areas that could be served best.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the manufactured homes license was grouped for reporting purposes. However, it was not part of the Planning Office but belonged to another department. She clarified that the license was collected at the same time as business licenses and has always been grouped within their reporting.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Duca stated that there were certain educational requirements and certifications for both the Planner I and Planner II positions. She noted that the Planner I position offered more flexibility and could be closer to an entry-level role, while the Planner II position required the necessary education and the American Institute of Certified Planners (AICP) certification.
Page 4
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 4
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Duca mentioned that they have considered allowing builders to hire inspectors directly, provided they are cleared by the city. She shared that one (1) developer had already taken advantage of the option to keep their project moving at the pace they needed. Ms. Duca pointed out that several municipalities use outside firms due to the difficulty in finding individuals who are qualified for those duties. She highlighted that one (1) of the benefits of using contractors was that they assist staff with training, reviewing code requirements, etc. She expressed that they are considering all aspects and looking at the future of the department to determine the best way to serve the community. Ms. Duca emphasized that they are completely open to exploring options.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Duca stated that each unit has its own inspection, as each unit deserves the same level of attention for the occupant’s benefit. She also pointed out that, with the number of apartment units coming up, the department needs to evaluate effective staffing levels, set clear expectations, and determine how many inspections can be completed in a year.
Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Planning, Inspections, and Community Development 2024 Annual Report. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried (Lewis absent).
ADOPTION OF MINUTES -REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF FEBRUARY 24, 2025 The Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of February 24, 2025, were unanimously approved by motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and bore the written approval of Mayor Christiansen (Lewis absent).
COUNCIL COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE REPORT - FEBRUARY 25,
2025
The Council Committee of the Whole met on February 25, 2025, at 6:00 p.m. with Council President Anderson presiding. Members of Council present were Ms. Arndt, Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lewis (out at 10:03 p.m.), Mr. Neil, Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rocha, and Dr. Sudler. Mayor Christiansen was also present. Civilian members present for their Committee meetings were Mr. Tholstrup, and Mr. Lewis (Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement), Ms. Smack (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation), Mr. Wilson (Utility), and Mr. Garfinkel and Mr. Shevock (Legislative, Finance, and Administration). Dr. Jackson-Short (Safety, Advisory, and Transportation) and Mr. Iriowen (Utility) were absent.
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Dr. Sudler moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
Just Health Restoration, LLC (Janiene Campbell and Crystal Hunter,
Founders)
Ms. Janiene Campbell and Crystal Hunter, Just Health Restoration, LLC,
Founders, reviewed the presentation titled Just Health Restoration.
Page 5
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 5
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Hunter and Ms. Campbell stated that education was a major part of their promotion for advocacy.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Hunter stated that Ms. Campbell has a background in both healthcare and education, and she also is currently running for the school board. Ms. Hunter, a long-time nurse with experience in healthcare administration and adult healthcare education, noted the need for education across all socioeconomic backgrounds, particularly among people of color.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Campbell stated that she did not know the exact number of complaints received in the State of Delaware for racism and bias in the healthcare system.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Hunter explained that such matters are typically handled by individual healthcare institutions and their patient experience teams, who then release the information unless the institution is private and choose not to be transparent. She noted that most institutions publish this information online to maintain transparency and accreditation. Additionally, the Joint Commission (JCO) plays a role in overseeing this process and serves as a source for obtaining such information.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Hunter stated that they do not currently have a legislator to sponsor the house bill and are actively seeking one. They are aware of recent changes within the house committee and are waiting for the situation to stabilize before proceeding. Regarding the development of specific continuing medical education (CME) courses, they have identified potential organizations or individuals to approach. However, this effort is on hold until the house bill is finalized, and a legislator agrees to sponsor it.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Hunter stated that the target number of continuing education credits is four (4).
Responding to Ms. Hunter, Dr. Pillsbury stated that requiring four (4) hours of Continuing Medical Education (CME) training may be excessive, as physicians already have numerous required trainings, many of which are only two (2) hours. She explained that obtaining four hours (4) may be challenging and emphasized the importance of securing support from organizations such as the American Medical Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and the American Academy of Family Physicians. She also noted that physicians must complete several mandatory training courses, making it difficult to keep up with both general and specialty-specific training requirements.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Ms. Hunter explained that their rationale for using four (4) hours is based on the substance abuse disorder and diversion training. She clarified that the training could be divided into two (2) sessions of two (2) hours each or even one (1) hour session. She stated that they used substance abuse
Page 6
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 6
disorder and diversion training because that has been recognized as a public health crisis.
Responding to Ms. Hunter, Dr. Pillsbury expressed concern that mandatory training requirements were reaching a point where individuals would not have enough time to complete training specific to their specialty. She wanted to make Ms. Hunter aware of this issue and suggested reducing the training to two (2) hours, as she anticipated that training would be required every two (2) years. Dr. Pillsbury also emphasized that when individuals renew their licenses, the training should be updated to avoid repetition. She proposed that the training could be split and spread over a two (2) or four (4) year period.
Responding to Ms. Hunter, Dr. Pillsbury agreed that providing care for patients in a culturally sensitive and appropriate way was crucial for making informed decisions and avoiding harm. She noted that she works very hard to give good quality care to individuals. She emphasized that she interacts with individuals from diverse backgrounds and works very hard to meet their needs and that they understand the care she provides. Dr. Pillsbury pointed out that they could face issues with the professional organizations if they require too many continuing medical education (CME) hours.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Hunter mentioned that they would like to do a cross-sectional research study involving a set number of participants. She pointed out there would be a call for participants, starting from 18 years old and older, to focus on the adult population. She explained that the study aims to provide a snapshot of Delaware, reaching out to all Delawareans to understand their perspectives, how they are being treated, and their educational literacy levels. The research would build upon and expand on Dr. Tutu’s work. Ms. Hunter also emphasized that healthcare professionals will be included in the study.
This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
PARKS, RECREATION, AND COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE
The Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee met with Chairwoman Arndt presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Boggerty and unanimously carried.
Review of Active Recreation Plan – Village of Maple Dale – Phase 3: Planned Neighborhood Design – Senior Citizen Housing Option (Dawn Melson- Williams, Principal Planner) - (Located on Maple Dale Country Club Property at 180 Maple Dale Circle: Conditional Use Site Plan/Master Plan C-25-02)
Page 7
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 7
Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed the Active Recreation Plan for the Village of Maple Dale.
Staff recommended approval of the Active Recreation Area Plan for the project subject to the conditions outlined in the Active Recreation Review Report.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the development would be considered a 55-plus retirement community. She mentioned that she was unsure of the details of the city’s noise ordinance regarding gameplay, such as pickleball, but they can make the applicant aware of it.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the zoning ordinance offers a planned neighborhood design senior housing option, which follows a conditional use review process. It would allow a variety of housing type opportunities. She mentioned that the code would restrict the head of household to age 55 or greater but noted that any federal designation was not part of the zoning ordinance. She further mentioned that it would involve a specialized review process, which they are working to complete.
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Usman Sandhu, U & I Maple Dale, LLC, Developer, stated that the golf course would be away from the pickleball court. He explained that the 10th tee is northwest and is facing away from the pickleball courts. He mentioned that no golf ball would hit anyone at the pickleball court.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Sandhu stated that there are eight (8) pickleball courts at Wild Quail, and they are severely underused. About six (6) years ago, they built Arbor Senior Apartments on College Road, and it was the same concept as having a 55-plus retirement community. No pickleball courts were put in. He hopes the individuals will be golfers rather than pickleball players as their goal is to support the golf course and restaurant through the process.
Responding to Mr. Tholstrup, Mr. Sandhu explained that the intent was to provide an amenity for the residents of the 55-plus retirement community. They are planning to have a gym, so that would be an amenity for them. He mentioned that they may consider using key fobs for access, but they have not considered the details of it.
Responding to Mr. Tholstrup, Mr. Sandhu stated that on the north side of the pickleball court, there is a row of mature evergreen trees ranging from 15 to 25 feet tall. He also mentioned that they might add a few benches along the trails.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Sandhu stated that there was no way to stop the public from going to the facilities unless the area was secure. He also mentioned that they do not want to create issues for council by having unsupervised youth gather there, which could lead to problems.
Page 8
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 8
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Arndt stated that she had not heard any noise complaints at the city parks regarding the pickleball courts.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mayor Christiansen stated that there were no police complaints, just ambulance calls.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendation to approve the Active Recreation Area Plan for the project subject to the conditions outlined in the Active Recreation Review Report. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Lewis absent)
Review of Active Recreation Plan – Potential Cash-in-Lieu Request – Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 North West Street (Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) - (Located at the corner of North West Street and Cecil Street: Conditional Use Plan/Minor Subdivision Plan C-25-01)
Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed the Potential Cash-in- Lieu Request for the Active Recreation Area Plan at 207 North West Street and Cecil Street.
Staff recommended the approval of the Cash-in-Lieu Donation for the Active Recreation Area for the subdivision with the specific amount to be determined upon receipt of the Appraisal in accordance with the Zoning Ordinance provisions.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that Article V, Section 10 of the zoning ordinance discusses open space and recreation areas, which would be required as part of the zoning ordinance. She noted that this has been part of the code for more than 20 years. They realized that some smaller projects may not require the same calculation for active recreation, and a few years ago, an exemption was added to the code. For larger residential projects, such as apartment complexes and large subdivisions, it allows the creation of an open space park area and recreation amenities within the community that is being built. She pointed out that the burden of upkeep would be on the homeowner’s association or the management company, which is typical in an apartment complex. Ms. Melson-Williams noted that an apartment complex involves a holistic approach where the infrastructure, such as roads, utilities, tree planting, and recreation, is all part of the residential development package.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated the proposal is for four (4) townhouse units and the zoning ordinance does not limit them to being income-based in any way. She pointed out that the zoning ordinance does not limit the property to be owner-occupied or as a rental. The applicant’s presentation to the planning commission indicated that one of the reasons behind
Page 9
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 9
the project was to provide more affordable housing options. Ms. Melson-Williams noted that the lots are smaller, and that the townhouse format was not commonly seen in the downtown area, particularly in this part of the city. She explained that the area is predominantly a neighborhood developed years ago with single-family detached units. With other redevelopment in the area, some housing partners have redeveloped vacant or deteriorating lots. She believes the size of the lot and the units make the project suitable for affordable housing, although there was nothing in the code that would require it to be.
Responding to Mr. Tholstrup, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the zoning ordinance does not particularly allow for funds to be designated to this community. Instead, it states that funds go to the Parkland Reserve account. She acknowledged that he was correct regarding the block to the north of the Mary Street Park, which recently acquired land for potential expansion through development efforts. She believes there are amenities in the area, including a larger playground that spans nearly three (3) blocks along South Division Street. Ms. Melson-Williams mentioned that the Parkland Reserve funds could be allocated wherever donations are made and that the park funds tend to be best used throughout the city. She was unsure if they could earmark the funds through the action taken that evening. She also noted that the Parks and Recreation Director would look favorably on the fact that someone in the neighborhood contributed to the fund, and it could be used for capital improvements in nearby parks.
Dr. Sudler stated that the objective was to provide some type of recreation for the community, and he expressed that he would support a motion to achieve that goal.
Ms. Arndt suggested that they should talk with the Parks and Recreation Director to review funding priorities and planned improvements. This would provide a better understanding of what is happening, what is planned, and the budget. They would then consider those options.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Arndt stated that she and the Parks and Recreation Director have a meeting scheduled.
Mr. Anderson moved to approve staff recommendation of the cash-in-lieu request for the active recreation plan for the subdivision. The specific amount is to be determined upon receipt of the appraisal in accordance with the zoning ordinance provisions. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil.
Mr. Anderson expressed his support for the project, noting that it was a small area that would not be conducive to a lot of active recreation, especially with a park nearby. He pointed out that this particular park needed attention and hoped that it would be included on an agenda soon. He mentioned that there are more families and children in the area than five (5) years ago. It has become safer and attractive for families. He emphasized the importance of considering the needs of the area
Page 10
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 10
since younger individuals are moving back into the neighborhood and believed that money should stay in the neighborhood.
Dr. Sudler agreed that the money should stay in the community but disagreed with the perception that the neighborhood was safer. He mentioned that the constituents that he has talked with who live around Kirkwood Street and the surrounding parks are ready to move. The constituents do not want to be outside or let their children go outside. He mentioned that the community meetings he attended had addressed and listened to the constituents' concerns. His concern was that despite investment in the Kirkwood recreational area, the stigma from constituents that live on those streets has led them to believe that the area is not safe. Dr. Sudler suggested that they have an alternative recreational area close by. He pointed out that there was nothing for the mid-age teenagers to deter away from youth gang initiatives. He would like to see an alternative to Kirkwood Street because individuals are stating that it is not safe. He noted that there was a lot of youth gang initiation and pressure from what he had heard.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Anderson disagreed because they were talking about the area of North West Street; they were talking about the park on Mary Street and other particular areas. He mentioned that there was an active neighborhood watch group that he was a member of, also that families were moving to the area and having new homes built. He noted that they need to take some of the approaches that they had utilized north of Division Street and use them south of Division Street; it is vital to do so. He stated that the recently renovated Fulton Street Deli which had been a drug front, and changes had been made to the Elk Lodge. He also pointed out the dramatic improvement in crime statistics.
Mr. Anderson moved to approve staff recommendations of the Cash-in-Lieu Request for the Active Recreation Plan. The specific amount is to be determined upon receipt of the appraisal in accordance with the zoning ordinance provisions. The motion was seconded by Mr. Neil and carried with Dr. Sudler voting no.
During the council meeting, Councilwoman Arndt stated that she pulled Item #7 - Review of Active Recreation Plan – Potential Cash-in-Lieu Request off of the consent agenda because the applicant Mr. Cameron Llewellyn, was unable to attend the Council Committee of the Whole Meeting on February 25, 2025. She mentioned that Mr. Llewellyn would like to provide additional information for council’s consideration to reconsider those items.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Arndt stated that Item #7, Review of Active Recreation Plan – Potential Cash-in-Lieu Request, had passed. However, for discussion, she raised the issue of the cash-in-lieu fee, noting that while the impact fees are waived, the cash-in-lieu fee is not waived in the redevelopment area. She mentioned that the developer expressed concern that the fee could be a deterrent to redevelopment in an area that the city is targeting for redevelopment. The property owner would like to have a discussion and present it to council.
Page 11
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 11
Mr. Cameron Llewellyn, 117 West Reed Street, Developer for Tidemark, LLC, provided additional information regarding the Review of Active Recreation Plan – Potential Cash-in-Lieu Request. (Exhibit #1)
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the provisions for active recreation in the zoning ordinance are outlined in Article 5, Section 10, and those requirements apply to all residential development without setting a threshold. She noted that within Article 5, Section 10.5, there are a series of exemptions for smaller development situations. There are five (5) different potential exemptions related to the number of acres that are involved and the number of dwelling units. It would change the normal active recreation area requirement of 275 square feet per dwelling unit to something less than that.
Ms. Melson-Williams explained that in some cases, if the active recreation area requirement cannot be met, it would result in a cash-in-lieu. In other cases, the area requirement might be reduced, but a minimum size threshold of that recreation area is required. If the area requirement for active recreation cannot be met, it offers the cash-in-lieu of area construction. She mentioned that the exemptions were added around 2009, when the code was last amended, in response to issues calculating the 275 square feet per dwelling unit. She further mentioned that if developers could not meet the active recreation requirement, they would need to consider how the cash-in- lieu would look. Ms. Melson-Williams also mentioned that the code does not apply when it comes to a single vacant lot and that a permit for a single unit would be required. She noted that much of what has happened downtown has not been subjected to this provision. The provision comes into play if they appear in front of the Planning Commission as part of their development. In the case of the application for 207 North West Street, it went before the Planning Commission as a conditional use and a minor subdivision plan.
Ms. Melson-Williams explained that if there was an interest in reviewing the active recreation area requirements, the staff could work on it. The result would be amendments to the section of the code, which would go through a formal review process before being adopted. She noted that during recent updates to the C-2 (Central Commercial Zone) zoning district, several areas of the code were identified as needing potential review and updates, including the active recreation requirement. The code recognized small exemptions, particularly in the redevelopment target areas, but still required meeting the active recreation area requirement or cash-in-lieu option.
Responding to Ms. Melson-Williams, Ms. Arndt stated that she would like the staff to review the active recreation area requirements for improvements, particularly with the redevelopment target area. She expressed concern about not wanting to disincentivize redevelopment in that area and make projects more expensive than necessary.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the zoning ordinance categorizes housing types as single-family, duplex, townhouse, and apartments, but it does not make a distinction between rental and ownership properties.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams clarified that single-family housing developments are required to provide a recreational area within the development. She mentioned that any residential development, whether it be a large subdivision with a hundred lots, a smaller
Page 12
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 12
development with four (4) lots, or a site plan with a series of apartment buildings, would require an active recreation area.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that, for example, several recent subdivisions feature a variety of common space areas, such as open lawn areas, playground equipment, or clubhouse buildings. She mentioned that the apartments typically have interior spaces like gyms or meeting rooms, but they also include amenities like clubhouses and pools.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams noted that years ago, there was an attempt to set up exemptions for small developments, which were likely to address the issues at the time. However, she pointed out that the housing market is different today, and it may be worth re- evaluating those exemptions or determining when they should apply.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the downtown development district incentives are offered within the downtown redevelopment target area, but those incentives are not found in the zoning ordinance. Instead, they are part of a different section of the code, specifically Appendix C, which was recently amended. She mentioned that these incentives could be considered as an option for potential waivers, but they would only apply to residential development and have limited applicability. Ms. Melson-Williams believed that the potential changes to the program would be better addressed by reviewing the zoning ordinance requirements for the active recreation area. She suggested that they could look at factors such as the size of the development, number of lots, land size, and proximity to existing recreational amenities in the downtown area to address those issues more comprehensively, rather than waiting on a fee waiver later on.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that for this particular application, the calculation of the cash-in-lieu has not been completed. She noted that the calculation requires the submission of an appraisal, which is then used to determine the amount of the cash-in-lieu. The code outlines the type of appraisal needed, and if there is a concern about its reasonableness, there are options for appealing the appraised value. However, at this time, they have not received the appraisal needed to proceed with the calculation.
Mr. Rocha mentioned that he would be amenable to the waiver and suggested revisiting the ordinance to consider making changes to the code.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Melson-Williams stated the recommendation from the Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee regarding the project was to provide active recreation through the cash-in-lieu option. She clarified that her reference to the Board of Adjustment pertains to a specific application that the applicant would need to submit if they wished to avoid meeting the active recreation requirements, either by not providing active recreation or by not paying the cash-in-lieu for the project. She does not believe that the authority would be granted for city council to waive the items as they are written.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Ms. Melson-Williams clarified that an application would need to be submitted, which could delay the process, depending on how quickly the applicant plans to move forward with the project. She mentioned that to waive the requirement for active recreation and the payment of a cash-in-lieu, action would need to be taken by the Board of Adjustment.
Page 13
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 13
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Llewellyn stated that the two (2) center units would be the smallest, measuring 29 feet by 45 feet, which is just over 1,200 square feet. He also mentioned that the two (2) end units have the grass space towards North West Street and the existing alley.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Llewellyn clarified that no spaces would be directly assigned to the units.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that the beginning of Article 5, Section 10 of the code addresses backyards, noting that it is required because it applies to a certain type of application that goes before the Planning Commission. She does not believe that the definition of a recreation area was interpreted for an individual backyard area on an individual lot that would satisfy the active recreation area. This is because the active recreation areas are meant to be collectively used by the residential development and not necessarily just an individual landowner, in how this section of code was written. She mentioned that she was not sure if they could look at that to meet the requirements of the code for this particular development. She stated that if they were to look at future changes to the section of code, that would be something to take into consideration. For smaller-scale projects, if they had a minimum yard size at the time of development, that could be considered, but she does not believe that the code would allow them to interpret that as of today.
Ms. Arndt stated that to maintain compliance with the code, they should vote again to approve the cash-in-lieu donation for the active recreation. This would be a requirement and could be appealed to the Board of Adjustment. She mentioned that the next motion she would like to make would be to ask staff to review codes specific to the zoning provisions of active recreation to consider lot size, number of units, and proximity to active recreation to make improvements moving forward. This has already been discussed and agreed upon, and it was determined that there was not a waiver that they could do at this time for this particular project.
Ms. Arndt moved to approve the cash-in-lieu donation for the active recreation for the subdivision, with the specific amount to be determined upon receipt of the appraisal in accordance with the zoning ordinance provisions. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Anderson explained that they had to approve the item because it was removed from the consent agenda. If the item remained on the consent agenda, the item would have been approved by council.
Ms. Arndt moved to approve the cash-in-lieu donation for the active recreation for the subdivision, with the specific amount to be determined upon receipt of the appraisal in accordance with the zoning ordinance provisions. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Lewis absent).
Ms. Arndt moved to ask staff to review the code specific to the zoning provisions of active recreation requirements to consider lot size, number of units, and proximity to active recreation to existing parks and other features. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried (Lewis absent).
Page 14
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 14
Silver Lake Dam – Annual Inspection Review (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the Silver Lake Dam Annual Inspection Review. Staff recommended the acceptance of the Silver Lake Dam 2024 Safety Inspection Report and the FY2025 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update Memorandum.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that this was the annual evaluation that was required by the insurance company, so this will be done again. The goal is to put it out for bid in the summer of the Fiscal Year 2026, after July 1st, and then evaluate it in the fall.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend accepting staff recommendation to accept the Silver Lake Dam Annual Inspection Review and FY2025 Silver Lake Dam Inspection Update Memorandum. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Lewis absent)
Proposed Ordinance #2025-07 – Amending Chapter 98 by Establishing a Public Space Naming Policy (Councilwoman Arndt) Councilwoman Arndt reviewed the background and analysis regarding Proposed Ordinance #2025-07.
Staff recommended forwarding Proposed Ordinance #2025-07 along with the Application and Procedure Packet to council for approval
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Arndt stated that there had been a few requests to rename the parks. She stated that there was no specific ordinance outlining the process, and historically, council decisions were made through discussion and a vote. However, she felt that this approach was not fair or equitable. She emphasized that the public should be involved in renaming a public space, as it is something that they should all consider very seriously, and that is why there is a proposed ordinance to legislate that process.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Arndt mentioned that there were concerns from members of the community regarding the ordinance.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Arndt mentioned that 25 signatures would be required on the petition, but that she needed to review the application. This process was modeled after the existing ordinance for renaming a public street.
Mr. Neil moved to recommend accepting the staff recommendations for Ordinance #2025-07. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and unanimously carried.
Page 15
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 15
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Lewis absent)
Ms. Arndt moved for adjournment of the Parks, Recreation, and Community Enhancement Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 7:27 p.m.
SAFETY, ADVISORY, AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
The Safety, Advisory, and Transportation Committee met with Chairman Boggerty presiding.
Adoption of Agenda
Dr. Sudler moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Mr. Rocha and
unanimously carried.
Discussion - Electronic Speed Enforcement Device Update (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, and Dustin Shane, Automated Enforcement Program Coordinator, DelDOT) Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, and Mr. Dustin Shane, Automated Enforcement Program Coordinator, DelDOT, reviewed the Electronic Speed Enforcement Device Update.
Committee Action Not Required.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Shane explained that the program is structured so that any revenue generated goes into the general fund after first covering all of the program’s expenses. He clarified that if new resources are required to help run the program, any costs to the City of Dover or other municipalities are covered first by the program’s generated revenue. Any remaining revenue then would go into the general fund, not back to the city.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Shane stated that they would essentially lease the system. The revenue is generated from the tickets, the violations, and the citations that are covered first. Then any additional funds beyond that would go into the general fund.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Shane stated that the program would be controlled by the City of Dover and that they have control of determining the costs. He pointed out that City of Dover already has a good program in place, and that program is a good comparison with the Red Light Program. He mentioned that he has worked with the Red Light Program for the state and has worked alongside Officer Ian Thompson. He explained that DelDOT is not involved in the actual finance of this program as the actual revenue generation of the program is all within the City of Dover. He noted that DelDOT would be available to help, but they cannot get involved with the finance funds.
Page 16
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 16
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Chief Johnson mentioned that what he has read in the past, the program’s overhead is covered with the generated revenue. It is just a simple matter of workflow. The red light camera system requires hours to review and verify that there was a violation, depending on the volume of violations that they receive. It also depends on how many have to be reviewed within a certain timeframe. He explained that he could hire a full-time employee, and that the individual’s salary would be handled on the first of each month before any other associated expenses are paid. It could also be overtime for an existing position. Chief Johnson stated that he would need to figure out how to give the hour-for- hour dollar value back so they can know what to bill the program. He noted that he would work with the city manager and council because the number of their authorized staffing, whether it be civilian or sworn, has other issues associated with it. He needs to determine the most efficient method for managing the review of violations, including whether to allocate a dedicated full-time equivalent (FTE) position at straight time or assign it as an extra duty or overtime responsibility. Also, whether the task should be performed by sworn officers or civilian personnel. He mentioned that if it was a civilian position, it would need to be someone that would be trained to know and understand what a violation looked like. This could be a retired cop or an individual who knows how to administer traffic violations.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Chief Johnson stated that numerous expenses are associated with that position.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Shane explained that, by definition, it is any cost associated with the program. DelDOT circumnavigates that because their technicians are casual, seasonal part-time employees, that work 29 and a half hours a week. Most of the individuals are retired police officers and that there was no retirement to consider in that avenue.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Shane mentioned that the speed overage was legislated at 11 plus miles per hour over the limit and that there are mobile units that are self-powered by a battery. It is legislated that the camera units have to be in the same spot for the first 75 days of deployment, and they cannot be moved until afterwards. After the 75 days, it would be at the discretion of the city where the cameras can be moved.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mr. Shane stated that a study would need to be put in place to prove that speeding is an issue in certain areas of the city. He provided information on the study and included a residence request form. He explained that there was a study already in place and that they would need to provide the speed data for any locations where they may want to put the cameras at. They do not have to do anything new or special to meet DelDOT standards. He mentioned that the data needs to be collected within one (1) year. The city would have to decide where they would want the cameras. Mr. Shane had included a list of Newark’s proposed locations. The cameras can be put anywhere that the City of Dover determines as a residential district.
Page 17
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 17
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that the most egregious problem is where the camera would go first. He mentioned that there would be a pecking order and a rotation, ensuring that the services are applied everywhere. Chief Johnson stated for the record that he agrees with council about it not being a revenue generator. He cautioned that it would take time to get to the point of knowing how many devices he may need to have running at the same time. This would be to ensure that they have enough violations that are paid and or sustained by the courts. He has no information to offer council as to what posture the judiciary would take and how often a judge would choose to convict if a ticket is contested. He explained that they need to assess the volume that it produces, determine how many are confirmed violations, track how many people either pay or address the civil violation, and how many tickets are being upheld by the courts. Chief Johnson stated that he would need to build a system until he can find the sweet spot. The costs are covered, and they are hitting the areas that are supported by data and the constituents’ concerns. They have noticed behavior changes as to whether the violations by that system go down over time to the presence of the device.
Responding to Chief Johnson, Mr. Shane stated that the reporting is on an annual basis, so they would have that opportunity if they have disparities and make adjustments to the budget within the year. He is unsure if that would carry over into the next fiscal year, but it is something DelDOT could look for. He mentioned that nothing is going to happen overnight or even within the next 60 days.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Shane mentioned that Newark was leading the race with putting out cameras and noted that Mr. Lyon had been in contact with them. He pointed out that there are no municipalities in Delaware that have cameras, but that New Castle, Newark, and Newport are very interested. He stated that he had the opportunity to work with individuals from Washington, D.C., and that they have 211 speed cameras. They do use a different vendor and a different system. Since the city has nothing to compare to in Delaware, the vendor that the city would be using could provide the information.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that they start with the constituents’ concerns. He explained that when an individual sends an email complaining about speed in a specific neighborhood, they have someone take the trailer to the location and have the device sit for a week to capture data. He mentioned that there were not too many locations in the city that they did not already know about. It was just a matter of priority, how often the violations were occurring, and what was the highest return on improved pedestrian safety and traffic safety. He emphasized that he needed to put cameras out on DuPont Highway because pedestrian incidents and serious collisions are occurring that are disabling individuals. This is notably near Delaware State University’s main entrance and sections of the highway that have long distances between red lights. Chief Johnson stated that the priority for placing cameras would be in areas where they can gather data to better understand the problem and quickly address safety
Page 18
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 18
concerns. Afterwards, the secondary roads across the city would be considered, along with their justifications for camera placement.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that while the system is being built and the bugs are being worked out, if they were not needing to respond to a constituent’s complaint, he could start putting the trailer out at problematic locations for a week to start data collecting. This would give data for every day of the week, every hour of the day, and at least one (1) round around the neighborhood through a complete work week. He noted that they have a heat map of where the camera could go when it comes time to deploy a system that council approves of.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson stated that they do have the speed trailers that are being used for traffic calming and also to collect data.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Shane explained that the DelDOT work zone program on I-95 and State Route 896 has been successful in that speeds have reduced significantly since the start of the program. Crashes and injuries have also been reduced. He was not able to give an informed decision on anything in the residential district because they do not have anything to compare it to. The speed thresholds within a town, ranging from 25 miles per hour to 45 miles per hour, are significantly different from the 65 miles per hour reduced to 55 miles per hour speed limit in a work zone on an interstate. Mr. Shane mentioned that he could not make an informed decision on the effectiveness of the device since they do not have anything to compare it to.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Shane stated that they have noticed a 10% to 20% reduction in speed, though the numbers are not exact. He could provide more precise numbers if needed. Regarding safety, he mentioned that crashes on I-95 have decreased by 25% to 30% in both directions.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Shane stated that three (3) technicians monitor the program, and they deal with about 5,000 to 7,000 violations a day on a stretch of road that gets about 55,000 travelers in each direction. He mentioned that they have retired police officers who serve as seasonal technicians for the state.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Chief Johnson stated that it could be possible to hire two (2) part-time positions instead of one (1) full-time position. The only hesitation he had for council was that he did not know how many devices they would have, where they would be placed, and how many violations would be generated. If the number of violations is low, then in addition to Sergeant Thompson’s duties, he could start tracking the speed violations and report the volume. He explained that once data had been collected and the situation assessed, he would be able to determine if a part-time position would be needed to handle the overflow that could not be managed with their current deployment of resources. If there was an increase in violations, it might require a full-time position. If that were to happen, he would show the numbers and outline how
Page 19
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 19
many violations can be processed per hour. He would then recommend if they need one (1) full-time position or if they want to do three (3) part-time positions at an hourly rate that everyone would be comfortable with.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that he was hesitant to discuss any grants with the way the federal government was moving. He also noted that Mr. Shane had stated that they would have to enter into a contract with the state for their device. He mentioned that each device is $5,700 per month to lease. Mr. Lyon noted that they could research to see if grants were available, but he does not believe that they would be able to use grants for this program.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Shane stated that he was not sure if they could get state grants or any assistance from the state for the purchase of the equipment.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Lyon stated that the third party would be the vendor.
Responding to Ms. Smack, Mr. Shane stated that he could not verify the number of devices the city would be getting. He mentioned that she was correct on the citation cost per ticket. The citation matrix was different than the state’s. He explained that the state has their cameras in a work zone and the ticket would be doubled. Also, they were dealing with more excessive speeds than most individuals travel in a municipal area.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Shane stated that the ticket amount does not go up more after subsequent violations. For example, if individuals went over 12 miles per hour, those individuals would continue to get that $44 ticket. As for when the ticket resets, it was based on vehicle registration, not per motorist. He was not sure of the exact reset time frame. He mentioned that there is a process called Transfer of Liability (TOL), where the individual can transfer the responsibility for a ticket to another person. If the original driver uses the car and receives a ticket, then that would be their first notice.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Shane stated that the equipment is like what most officers use when they are doing speed in the field. He mentioned that their equipment is good and is accurate within one (1) mile per hour, under 100 miles per hour, and within 1% above 100 miles per hour. The system itself is LiDAR and falls under the same restrictions as when it is annually tested by an independent laboratory. He noted that the system self-calibrates daily, and before every citation, it records its calibration.
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Shane stated that the system does self-calibrate each day. He mentioned that there are around 60 cases that are dealing with JP Court 20 in Wilmington and have had zero (0) issues with anyone successfully contesting the accuracy of the system.
Page 20
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 20
Responding to Mr. Anderson, Mr. Shane explained that when a citation has been received, it has the photo information of the vehicle and registration. The second page contains the Transfer of Liability (TOL) form, enabling the identification of a different driver. It requires the driver's and registered owner's information and must be notarized. Additionally, an appeal form is available for those who wish to appeal the citation in court. He stated that these forms are supplied in the first notice of citation.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Chief Johnson mentioned that they could calculate the average speed violation adjusted for the average end means, analyzing both of those numbers, and find a spot in between the two (2). From there, they could count the number of violations. Chief Johnson stated that he would talk to Sergeant Thompson and find out how they are doing with the red light violations. It could be a good indicator of how they would deal with speed violations since he was unsure where the plea bargain would be on a civil citation versus a violation of the vehicle code.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Shane stated that there was no maintenance costs associated with it because they do not own the cameras; it would be a leased unit. He mentioned that part of the agreement with Elevate, the vendor that they use, is very responsive. If something happens, they respond quickly and are hands-on with the units because they are battery-operated. The batteries must be changed roughly every two (2) days. He also mentioned that part of their agreement is a loss of revenue, which means that if something were to happen to the camera and it is not working, the company does not do anything; they are liable for the lost revenue during that timeframe.
Responding to Ms. Smack, Mr. Shane stated that the study documented five (5) miles per hour to indicate a pattern of exceeding the speed limit. He explained that within a 24-hour window, they would only collect a limited amount of data and would not be able to get the full picture of what was going on throughout the week. Especially with issues of speeding. He mentioned that seven (7) days of collecting data is better because then they can get an idea of what is happening seven (7) days a week. Mr. Shane emphasized that getting as much data as possible is necessary.
Charles Cunningham, 116 East Sheldrake Circle, addressed a few concerns regarding the red light camera citations. He had questions regarding the additional fines that were listed on the citation, such as ambulance fees, violent crimes fees, and an additional fee that he was unaware of.
Responding to Mr. Cunningham, Mr. Shane stated that it was not speed that he was specifically talking about, but the program that he was involved in. Mr. Shane stated that he could appeal and question his red light camera citation in court. Some similar fines and fees are associated with the speed program as well.
Page 21
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 21
Mr. Cunningham mentioned that, recently, the additional charges were ruled illegal in New York. There was an appellate court ruling in the Ninth Circuit that the additional charges were not constitutional under the Eighth Amendment.
Lachelle Paul, 502 Silverside Road, addressed concerns regarding the price of the red light camera. She suggested that since the budget was already stretched, it would be more feasible to hire an officer because officers are needed, and it would be less expensive than leasing a machine.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lyon stated that the $5,700 per month would be inclusive of the amount of money running the program.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Lyon stated that the $5,700 would be reimbursable.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Shane stated that DelDOT would be there as a resource for the city and that the vendor, Elevate, would be doing the maintenance to the machine.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Shane stated that the city does not pay for any maintenance.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Shane stated that Elevate would maintain the machine, and the $5,700 was the responsibility of the City of Dover.
Ms. Paul raised concerns about how the machine would cover costs, questioning if people were going to receive the same tickets in the same area. Even if the machine was moved, it may not generate enough to cover its costs. She suggested that if they are going to pay $5,700 without the knowledge of the return, it might be better to hire officers so that they could move to different locations, like the machine.
This item was informational, and committee action was not required.
Lands of 4BL, LLC: Cecil Street Townhouses at 207 North West Street (Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner) (Located at the corner of North West Street and Cecil Street: Conditional Use Plan/Minor Subdivision Plan C-25-01)
Request for Waiver of Appendix A – Subdivision, Article VI – Subdivision General Requirements and Design Standards, Section A – Streets, Item 13.8 – Requirement for Rear Access Alley for Townhouses
Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed the Request for Waiver of Appendix A – Subdivision, Article VI – Subdivision General Requirements and Design Standards, Section A – Streets, Item 13.8 – Requirement for Rear Access Alley for Townhouses.
Page 22
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 22
Planning Commission Recommendation: The Planning Commission recommended approval of the subdivision waiver allowing the elimination of the Rear Access Alley Requirement.
Mayor Christiansen mentioned that he was against the first proposal to do away with the alley. He emphasized that if they were to bring that to an end, then they needed to consider whether or not they needed an alley. He also mentioned that, regarding the second waiver, he was a strong believer in sprinkler systems. Mayor Christiansen stated that it was important to have a residential sprinkler system because it would save lives and protect the property. He opposed both waivers because he believed they were detrimental to the aesthetics and the safety of the community. He went on the record stating that he supported the use of residential sprinklers.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that because of the reorientation of the proposed units facing Cecil Street, the code would require an alley to be placed along the rear. She mentioned that the parcel that they are dealing with has frontage on North West Street, and that there was an existing alley on the east side of the property. The existing alley from Cecil Street runs for a short distance; that alley would not change. She explained that the request was to eliminate the construction of a new alley and that it would impact the rear units. If it was not eliminated, they would run into issues with lot coverage and lot sizing. Also, the project would require additional variances and consideration to create the four (4) lots.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that from the map, the mesh area was an estimated location of an utility easement to bring water and/or sewer services to the lots. She noted that there would likely need to be an easement to bring it from the North West Street side of the property. Since it would be crossing one (1) property to provide services to another property, it would need to be placed in an easement. She mentioned that it was still being refined as they continue to work with the Water and Wastewater Department regarding how water and sewer services would be provided to the individual units.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the whole area in the back would be proposed as grass.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mayor Christiansen stated that the response would depend on the tactical situation at that particular time. They may need to establish with an engine, a water curtain to protect any kind of exposure that they have. He mentioned that the two (2) ladder trucks that they currently have are rather massive, and fire equipment is getting bigger and bigger. He also mentioned that the response would depend on whether the fire is in the middle unit, the unit on the end, or all four (4) units as the tactical situation would be upon arrival.
Page 23
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 23
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mayor Christiansen stated that he was not familiar with the floor plans, but the kitchen area would usually be in the rear of the building.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that there was no fencing in the back due to the open rear yard provisions which limits any kind of fencing. She highlighted that fences would not be encouraged in those areas where the utility easement lies on the map. If a fence was to be placed in those areas, the applicant would need to sign a waiver acknowledging that a utility easement was there.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that Cecil Street would be the location for the trash and recycling collection. This would occur in their front yard, along the street frontage. She continued to state that trash cans would need to be stored in a location other than the front of the building. She also mentioned that the overall review addressed the need for planned trash and recycling container storage.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the driveway for the one (1) end unit is off of North West Street, the two (2) center units have a driveway that comes off of Cecil Street, and the other end unit comes off of the alley. It is a driveway that leads to a single-car garage.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Mayor Christiansen stated that there are not supposed to be any fences behind those properties, but if they notice around town, there are several fences in the easements that are not supposed to be there. He noted that as a former firefighter, easy access would be greatly appreciated. He also mentioned that he was not making that comment about the alley only for aesthetics but for public safety as well.
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams anticipated that the project would require redesign. The alley is placed in the right-of-way area, and it was not part of the individual lot. Taking up the northern portion of the lots could end up reducing the lot size and it would also impact setback requirements from that rear property line. She is certain that it would entail redesigning the project. The units are for townhouses in the General Residence Zone (RG-1), and there is a minimum lot width of 20 feet. She stated that the lot depth from Cecil Street would be roughly 84.5 feet.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the zoning ordinance outlines the bulk standards required for a townhouse in the General Residence Zone (RG-1). She mentioned that it has been to the Board of Adjustments once already to address the lot depth and minimum lot area. She stated that the reconfiguration of lots to face Cecil Street means projects not meeting code requirements would require a variance from the Board of Adjustment. Should the project require redesign, an application to the Board of Adjustment would be
Page 24
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 24
necessary to request a variance from the bulk standard requirements if compliance cannot be met
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that variances are an option. They have already obtained two (2) variances from the Board of Adjustment. However, a redesign would likely necessitate additional variances or a reconsideration of the previously granted variances.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that they have been successful with the variances that have been requested.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that they could potentially need additional variances, depending on what would necessitate a redesign.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Ms. Melson-Williams explained that should an alley be required; a project redesign may be necessary. They would then have to go to the Board of Adjustment for new variances.
Dr. Sudler agreed with Mayor Christiansen’s concerns. He believes that they should not compromise public safety for the almighty dollar. He inquired how they could achieve a balance between property development and ensuring that adjacent communities are not adversely affected, while also maintaining the fire department's ability to effectively perform life-saving operations.
Mr. Lewis agreed with Mayor Christiansen’s concerns, especially when it comes to safety. He mentioned that the location in the downtown area is already condensed. He noted that he would not vote in favor of the waiver.
Mr. Neil moved to reject the waiver as related to the subdivision waiver, allowing the elimination of the rear access alley requirement. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis.
Mayor Christiansen stated that he stood by his comments.
Mr. Anderson stated that he had a problem with voting no on both of the waivers. Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that she wished the applicant were present to speak but explained that they viewed the 12,000 square foot lot as an opportunity to provide multiple housing units. This would lower the cost down per individual unit. From a zoning perspective, she mentioned that the RG-1 zone allowed for a single-family detached house on an individual lot. The requirements for the size and setbacks are different. It would not trigger a need for an alley request. She also mentioned that the RG-1 allows for a consideration of duplex units, which are only two (2) units together, with differences in lot sizes and options. She concluded that in either case, it would involve a redesign of the project and a revisit to the Planning Commission for a subdivision of a different nature. The requirement for duplex units is also a conditional use, so it would be a new application to the Planning Commission.
Page 25
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 25
Responding to Ms. Arndt, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that it was unlikely that they could fit two (2) duplexes and get four (4) units. She mentioned that the applicant and their engineer would have to assess the situation to see what the options were.
Jason Osika, Fire Marshall, stated that while the rear access is a requirement, sprinklers are not. He considered a sprinkler system installation, as opposed to rear access, a major benefit, citing its ability to suppress fires in their initial stages, before fire department intervention
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Osika stated that since these are townhouses, ladders can still be utilized. He emphasized that a sprinkler system, by suppressing the fire prior to responder arrival, would enhance lifesaving efforts and aid in fire control. He further noted that response time is a significant factor in such situations.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mayor Christiansen stated that he respected Mr. Osika, but that there was a difference of opinion regarding the waiver. He noted that council should rely on Mr. Osika’s expertise as well. They both are speaking in the interest of public safety
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mayor Christiansen stated that he concurred with some of Mr. Osika’s observations, but he still had his own personal druthers.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mayor Christiansen, citing his experience with sprinkler systems, described a Cambridge fire where a sprinklered building was lost. The fire's volume exceeded the system's capacity, and the building burned down. It took four (4) days to put the fire out, and that building had a terrific sprinkler system. Sprinkler systems do their job, but sometimes the volume of a fire can overwhelm the sprinkler system.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Ms. Melson-Williams stated that the sprinkler system requires a fire protection permit and that the system has to be installed by a licensed contractor. The review is done by the city’s Fire Marshal’s Office. She mentioned that the residential sprinkler system was different in design and installation than a commercial sprinkler system. Dr. Sudler mentioned that if the units are being rented, then they would be required to have an annual inspection every year for fire and building.
Mayor Christiansen stated that the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) standards require scheduled pipe on commercial and multiple-family residences. The sprinkler systems that are in individual homes are fire-rated PVC pipes, and they come off the domestic water system with a small backflow prevention device. He was unsure if there was a provision for an annual inspection on them unless they are in a rental property or if there is a local jurisdiction that requires them to be inspected yearly.
Page 26
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 26
Ms. Arndt expressed her support for the waiver, noting that there was access to the front of the property on North West Street, as well as to the side of one of the units and the units on the alley side. She also mentioned a restriction that required the back area to remain open without a fence, for emergency vehicles to have access to the back of the property. Regarding the fire suppression system, Ms. Arndt emphasized that there were sufficient fail-safes and praised the skills of volunteer firefighters, stating that if they need to get into a house, they will.
Ms. Arielle Rivera, Assistant City Clerk, restated that Mr. Neil’s motion was to move to reject the waiver as related to the subdivision waiver, allowing the elimination of the rear access alley requirement.
Mr. Neil moved to reject the waiver as related to the subdivision waiver, allowing the elimination of the rear access alley requirement. The motion was seconded by Mr. Lewis and carried by a roll call vote of six (6) yes (Boggerty, Neil, Rocha, Sudler, Lewis, Smack) and three (3) no (Pillsbury, Arndt, Anderson), one (1) absent (Jackson).
Mr. Boggerty stated that it was denied for reasons stated in the debate.
Request for Waiver of Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 17, Emergency Access Requirements
Ms. Dawn Melson-Williams, Principal Planner, reviewed the Request for Waiver of Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 17, Emergency Access Requirements.
Planning Commission Recommendation: The Planning Commission recommended approval of the waiver allowing the Alternative (Use of residential sprinkler system) to satisfy the Rear Emergency Access Requirement.
Ms. Arndt moved to approve the alternative use of a residential sprinkler system to satisfy the rear emergency access requirement. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mayor Christiansen stated that his comments still stand and that he respectfully disagreed with the Fire Marshal on the second waiver with no disdain. Mr. Neil stated that Appendix B is moot because it had not been approved instead of having an alternate, so he believes that it does not apply. He mentioned that they could approve it, but it is the use of the residential sprinkler that has to satisfy the rear emergency access requirement, and that had been made void by the denial of Appendix A.
Mr. Rocha concurred with Mr. Neil by stating that because the use of the word alternative, they are approving it as an alternative. He believes that it muddies the decision on the first waiver they had voted on.
Page 27
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 27
Responding to Ms. Melson-Williams, Mayor Christiansen emphasized that Ms. Melson-Williams would ensure developers continue to consider the use of residential sprinklers in their plans.
Responding to Mr. Lewis, Mr. Anderson stated that the motion needed to be voted upon to dispose of the item.
Ms. Rivera restated Ms. Arndt’s motion to approve the alternative use of a residential sprinkler system to satisfy the rear emergency access requirement.
Mr. Rocha stated that he was stuck on the word “alternative” because there was no alternative. They should restructure the motion so that it does not appear that they agreed with it as an alternative.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson stated that he would vote no because there had to be a motion to deal with this item, and it would either be approved or rejected. He mentioned that they are disposing of the item, and he would vote no.
Dr. Sudler stated that there was a discrepancy regarding whether or not they should be voting on the item. He noted that the city solicitor was not in attendance and believes that they should not do a second vote. He suggested bringing it back with a legal opinion from the city solicitor so that no one would be confused.
Ms. Rivera restated Ms. Arndt’s motion to approve the alternative use of a residential sprinkler system to satisfy the rear emergency access requirement. She mentioned that voting yes would be approving the waiver.
Mr. Neil stated that he would abstain because it was moot.
Ms. Arndt stated that her vote would be no on the basis that it was a moot point if the previous motion was not carried.
Mr. Anderson stated that his vote would be no based on the reason stated earlier, that it is now moot and had to be disposed of.
Ms. Arndt moved to approve the alternative use of a residential sprinkler system to satisfy the rear emergency access requirement. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and failed by a roll call vote of one (1) yes (Pillsbury) and seven (7) no (Boggerty, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Lewis, Anderson, Smack), one (1) abstention (Neil), and one (1) absent (Jackson).
During the council meeting, Councilwoman Arndt stated that she pulled Item #11, Request for Waiver of Appendix A – Subdivision, Article VI – Subdivision General Requirements and Design Standards, Section A – Streets, Item 13.8 – Requirement for Rear Access Alley for Townhouses and Request for Waiver of Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 17 – Emergency Access Requirements off of the consent agenda because the applicant Mr. Cameron Llewellyn, was unable to attend the Council Committee of the Whole
Page 28
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 28
Meeting on February 25, 2025. She mentioned that Mr. Llewellyn would like to provide additional information for council’s consideration to reconsider those items.
Mr. Cameron Llewellyn, 117 West Reed Street, Developer for Tidemark, LLC, provided additional information regarding the Request for Waiver of Appendix A – Subdivision, Article VI – Subdivision General Requirements and Design Standards, Section A – Streets, Item 13.8 – Requirement for Rear Access Alley for Townhouses and Request for Waiver of Appendix B – Zoning, Article 5 – Supplementary Regulations, Section 17 – Emergency Access Requirements. (Exhibit #1)
Mr. Jason Osika, Fire Marshal, stated that when he goes through the Design Approval Committee (DAC) process before they do anything regarding rear access, he makes sure that the fire chief is aware of what they are doing. He mentioned that they work together all the time, and the fire chief is aware of what they are doing in reference to eliminating the rear access. Mr. Osika explained that during the Design Approval Committee (DAC) process, rear access is required per code. The requirement can always be met or exceeded. They have traded off in the past for sprinkler systems in townhouse units. He also mentioned that when the fire department sets up their ladder trucks, there is about 150 feet of space in the rear. The first engine is positioned at the front, and the ladder trucks can either be placed in the current alley or on North Street. With two (2) ladders, they can reach halfway across. He does not believe that it would pose an issue for the hose lines, as they range from 200 to 300 feet, which is standard for trucks.
Mr. David Carey, Fire Chief, stated that installing sprinkler systems in the townhouses would be a good choice. He acknowledged that Mr. Osika made an important point regarding rear access, noting that his team was experienced in handling hose lines and managing rear access around various structures such as apartment buildings and townhouses. Chief Carey emphasized that with sprinkler access, less rear access would be required compared to what would be needed if there were no sprinkler systems in the building. As far as ladder truck access is concerned, Chief Carey mentioned that they would be able to reach the building from both the rear and the front of the building.
Mr. Rocha stated that they should move forward with implementing the sprinkler system, based on the information that was provided regarding how sprinkler systems have successfully extinguished fires in similar townhouses before the arrival of the fire department. As well as hearing comments made from Fire Chief Carey and Mr. Osika.
Ms. Arndt reiterated the comments that she made during the Council Committee of the Whole Meeting on February 25, 2025, emphasizing that this type of project was what they were looking for downtown, especially in the redevelopment area, to provide more affordable housing. She pointed out that home prices are becoming unaffordable for individuals and families. Projects like this are the ones they should be supporting. Ms. Arndt expressed appreciation for the clarification on the emergency response and stated that she would maintain her previous vote.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Osika explained that the probability of flames overtaking the sprinkler system for a one (1) to two (2) family dwelling setting would be very low, but he would not say it could never happen. He mentioned an incident involving an apartment building that had an exterior fire that burnt the roof off. He noted that if the building was built today, it would
Page 29
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 29
have had the sprinklers on the balcony, and that would not have happened. He emphasized that as time evolves, so do the standards. Mr. Osika stated that when it comes to sprinklers for one (1) to two (2) family dwellings in Delaware, there have been zero (0) deaths in fires at residential buildings with sprinkler systems. He explained that the materials are built differently today, causing both the house and the items inside to burn faster and hotter. The intent of the sprinkler system is to suppress the fire as quickly as possible. He mentioned that within 30 seconds to a minute of a fire starting, the sprinkler system would have already been activated, helping to suppress the fire. He pointed out that the average response time from calling 911 to the fire department arriving on the scene is about four (4) minutes, which is the best-case scenario. He highlighted that sprinklers not only benefit the residents and developers but are also crucial for firefighters’ safety. Without the sprinkler systems, the fire grows larger, putting firefighters in danger, especially in situations with lightweight construction, which falls faster and has led to more firefighter injuries.
Ms. Arndt moved to approve the subdivision waiver, allowing the elimination of the rear access alley requirement. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson stated that there would be two (2) motions for two (2) different waivers.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Anderson clarified that they were addressing the waiver for Appendix A.
Ms. Arndt moved to approve the subdivision waiver, allowing the elimination of the rear access alley requirement. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried unanimously by a roll call vote (Lewis absent).
Ms. Arndt moved to approve the Planning Commission’s recommendation of the waiver to allow the alternate use of a residential sprinkler system to satisfy the rear emergency access requirement. The motion was seconded by Mr. Rocha and carried unanimously by a roll call vote (Lewis absent).
Mr. Boggerty moved for adjournment of the Safety Advisory and Transportation Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 9:12 p.m.
UTILITY COMMITTEE
The Utility Committee met with Chairman Neil presiding.
Adoption of Agenda
Mr. Rocha moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Sudler and
unanimously carried.
The Edge at Dover Impact Fee Request (Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, and Christopher Stumpo, and John Rathfon, The Metropolitan Development Group)
Page 30
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 30
Mr. Jason Lyon, Water/Wastewater Director, reviewed the Edge at Dover Impact Fee Request.
Staff Recommendation: Continue to follow precedent with previous projects and collect one (1) equivalent dwelling unit (EDU) for each apartment unit. The Metropolitan Development Group is still subject to any Kent County Impact Fees for wastewater.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. John Rathfon, Vice President of Land Development at The Metropolitan Development Group, stated that the total fees for 218 EDUs at $4,159 per EDU would be $906,000. Mr. Rathfon stated that with the reduction, it would bring the fees down to $478,000, which is a $428,000 reduction. Mr. Rathfon stated that is the reason had he presented Council with the gallonage per day figures.
Responding to Mr. Rathfon, Dr. Sudler thanked him for the gallonage per day figures, noting that they were tremendously helpful.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that the city's portion of the impact fees has not increased in the 18 years he has been with the city.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that the $906,000 does not include Kent County’s fees. Mr. Lyon reiterated that, as indicated in the committee action form, the city cannot do anything about Kent County’s fees. That would have to be a discussion for The Metropolitan Development Group to have with the county. They are only discussing the city’s portion of the EDU fees, in the amount of $4,159 per EDU.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that the last three (3) apartment complexes have covered their own fees.
Responding to Mr. Lyon, Mayor Christiansen stated that the city has consistently maintained a maintenance of standards across the board for all other developments that they have done.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Lyon clarified that he has not previously received a waiver for this specific request. He acknowledged that the city has granted fee waivers for the downtown development areas, citing council being familiar with those requests. Mr. Lyon further stated that in the past, the city had considered waivers for the revitalization of older commercial and industrial buildings.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Lyon stated that the impact fees for Proctor and Gamble’s expansion project were not waived.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Lyon stated that the daycare facility on South State Street, south of South Dover Elementary School, did not receive a
Page 31
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 31
waiver. Mr. Lyon noted the possibility of credits that could have been applied to that building from beforehand.
Responding to Mr. Lyon, Mayor Christiansen stated that they did not have credits from beforehand.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Lyon stated that the daycare facility would have had to pay the impact fees.
Responding to Mr. Lyon, Mayor Christiansen stated that while he appreciated the efforts of the developer, he believed that if they were going to be benevolent to one (1) entity, then they would violate the maintenance of standards. These are items that are set in stone, and while he appreciates the appeal process, he thinks that if they are going to actually facilitate the reason why these EDUs are in place then they should do it fairly and provide maintenance of standards across the board.
Council President Anderson pointed out that if another applicant does not apply for this request because they do not know the law, then that does not invalidate this particular request. He stated that to be honest, rent is just too high. That is the complaint that a lot of individuals have, and Council has said that they have wanted to have affordable housing. If they want to add $2,000 per unit, then it is not making rent more affordable. They either want affordable housing or they do not. He noted that they have said that they do, yet they keep turning down opportunities for affordable housing time and time again. Council President Anderson explained that they really need to decide if they believe what they say or they do not. This is not something that is new. It is something that was already in the code because the code was anticipating large scale projects like this and did not want to discourage them.
Council President stated that the Council intended to encourage projects like this to develop within the city, utilizing city infrastructure, rather than expanding into the county and contributing to urban sprawl on agricultural land. He noted that it is good for the agricultural community, and it is good for the City of Dover as it expands the city’s population, as well. It brings in revenue that they are going to get forever, essentially at least for the next 50 years. As long as individuals are living in this building, the city will receive revenue from electric fees, water fees and taxes. Council President Anderson noted that he supports it based upon the data of what they actually charge.
Responding to Council President Anderson, Dr. Sudler stated that he thinks a little differently in regard to fair housing. He noted that there is a fair standard payment rate for Kent County that they have to adhere to or else they will be in violation of the State of Delaware Fair Housing regulations. The housing cost is not fixed on whether or not Council wants to promote fair housing and give someone a reduction on impact fees. Housing costs are based on inflation and as inflation rises, so does the cost. Council cannot offset that cost by waiving fees. Right now,
Page 32
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 32
in Kent County rent for a one (1) bedroom is $1,400. He noted that it is a lot of money, but the cost of living is a lot, things are high. It is not contingent upon whether or not Council wants a developer to come in and waive a portion of impact fees so that they keep their costs down. They still have to abide by the fair housing standards, the payment standards for Kent County and for the State of Delaware. He explained that they cannot charge excessive rents, such as $2,000 or $3,000 for a one (1) bedroom unit, but that they can charge rents close to the fair market rate. He cautioned that setting rent prohibitively high could be perceived as discriminatory, effectively excluding certain groups and violating housing regulations. He stated that he agreed with the mayor’s position, acknowledging that while he would personally prefer to grant the request, doing so would set a precedent that could compromise fair housing standards. He added that he is also involved in the housing sector and if he planned on building, he would like impact fees to be waived as well. He noted that the bottom line is that they would be setting a precedence. How can they be certain that past applicants were aware of this option? Did the city inform them that there is an ordinance stating that if they meet specific criteria, they would be eligible? In fairness, if they are to implement this policy, they should publicize its availability. This would allow new applicants to apply, and then they could gradually consider past cases.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rathfon clarified that their request was not for a waiver, as in the previous agenda item, but rather to utilize the existing ordinance. He acknowledged the relevant provision was in the 'fine print' but emphasized that they were simply seeking to utilize the ordinance that is already in place.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rathfon explained that they review the ordinances when they go into any municipality. It is also due to them owning as many apartments as they do. They have noticed that it is an issue across a lot of municipalities. Some municipalities charge 300 gallons per day and some charge less than that. It is something that they are aware of that is very prevalent in every single community. He noted that the combined EDU fee, which includes both the city's and the county's portions, is more than double the average of the tri-state area.
Responding to Mr. Rathfon, Dr. Sudler said that if it is in the ordinance and they did their due diligence, he kind of agrees with Council President Anderson.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon explained that the Capital School District was not a reduction in impact fees. It was a transference of impact fees from one property to another. Then, the next step was the discussion of the student population or the student body. He pointed out that school impact fees are not based on how many toilets there are in the schools, but on their enrollment. So, it was a different situation.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon explained that in regard to the Capital School District, the city is allowing the school district to utilize the student body as a whole for the entire district as an impact measure. Every year they submit the
Page 33
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 33
actual enrollment of the student body to the city. If it increases by 25 students, then they pay the city an impact fee because that is the trigger, every 25 students.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Lyon stated that the impact fees for the Edge at Dover are a one-time fee.
Mayor Christiansen stated that while he appreciates Mr. Rathfon and The Metropolitan Development Group’s efforts to provide housing in their community, and he concurs with the Council President, he does have to remind council that they do have a large number of proposed apartment complexes coming into the city. He understands everyone's time is valuable, and he is wondering if they would be setting a precedent. He also wondered if they were going to stop maintaining standards for everyone who comes to the podium. Should they just get rid of EDUs altogether? Each council member is responsible for maintaining standards, whether it is a single-family house, a duplex, or townhouses, there is an impact fee. If it is a 36-unit or 100-unit apartment building, it is still council’s job to follow the rules. Those impact fees are there for a reason, just like everything else in the code, they seem to pick and choose from. He cautioned council to think long and hard about what they are doing. They will spend many nights addressing the numerous apartment complexes and buildings in the City of Dover's development pipeline. He challenged council to adhere to the standards that they have already set.
Mr. Neil stated that he has observed the building's construction from his residence in Wild Meadows, which is located across from the former Firefly site. He is really concerned about the traffic, and they are currently asking DelDOT to take a look at the traffic because it is going to be a bottleneck. Mr. Neil noted that they desperately need the housing and for it to be fair housing. The fact that they keep their apartments as part of the total picture is terrific. Every time one of these apartment buildings is sold, every time a leased land home is sold, the tenants pay a new and higher rent to pay off the mortgages. He would anticipate that they are going to be holding the cost down fairly well because it is their property, and they are not going to sell it to someone else who would then take whatever they purchased it for and add it to the total of the rent that the individuals are going to pay. Mr. Neil noted that he is counting on it, and his inclination is to do what the law says.
Mr. Neil stated that Mr. Rathfon saw it in the law, it was there, and they requested the reduction. He noted that he will follow whatever the Council President is doing because they desperately need it. He explained that he had served on a state task force for affordable housing where they were 19,000, almost 20,000 short. The Edge will have 216 units and there are 358 units that are being built in the Scarborough Road area. There are all kinds of projects that are happening in the city, so it is important to add to that process. Mr. Neil noted that he will watch them go up stick by stick every time he goes home and every time the traffic is stopped, while Mr. Rathfon’s individuals are out on the road.
Page 34
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 34
Responding to Dr. Pillsbury, Mr. Rathfon stated that he was just trying to be honestly fair. He explained that their calculations were based on documented historical sewer and water usage, supported by billing records from their approximately 4,000 apartments. They adhered to the Delaware Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control (DNREC) standard of 125 gallons per day per unit, despite their actual usage being between 60 and 85 gallons. This higher figure accounts for potential leaks and inflow and infiltration (I&I), which is groundwater and rainwater entering the sewer system.
Mr. Rathfon’s calculation in regard to this was 260 apartments multiplied by 125 gallons per day, plus two additional EDUs for the clubhouse and pool, resulting in 27,480 gallons. Dividing this by the city's standard of 240 gallons per EDU yielded 114.5 EDUs, which he then rounded up to 115.
Responding to Mr. Rathfon, Dr. Pillsbury stated that if the city is going to have other requests, perhaps they should consider a percentage of the number of units. She noted that she respects how Mr. Rathfon completed his calculations. Dr. Pillsbury continued to state that she has no problem with that but that they need some standards so that as additional requests come in, they have a standard that they can apply. Perhaps it is 75% of the number of units that are going to be there. So that they are covering the city’s expenses, they are covering things for the constituents of the city, but they are still giving a break to the developers.
Councilwoman Arndt stated that her thought process is that the impact fee is to offset the impact to the city’s infrastructure, so that the existing residents are not burdened by the increase in use. That is the point of an impact fee, and they have not waived it in the past. She agrees with the mayor that waiving it or reducing it in this circumstance sets the expectation that they will do it for future development requests. They would have to be very careful with moving forward, denying any future requests, on the basis that they have already granted that type of request. She stated that her vote would be to uphold the EDU standards as they have been presently.
Councilman Boggerty stated that the ordinance provision is a privilege, and that the city cannot flip flop on their documentation. He noted that he is torn as an individual who lives an administrative legal process but that he is not an attorney. He has to respect what is written and what the ordinance states. He understands the company read the ordinance and then invested based on that allowance. However, he also acknowledged the need for firmness, fairness, and consistency. Councilman Boggerty suggested that they should revisit the ordinance and make any necessary adjustments. He noted that they have a financial need, but their mistakes should not be passed along to their constituents.
Mr. Lyon clarified that impact fees are specifically allocated to water and wastewater projects, not the general fund, and must be used for growth-related expenses. He referenced the annual transfer of funds from the water and wastewater fund to the general fund in regard to the budget annually. He noted
Page 35
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 35
that Mr. Rathfon had done his research when it came to the ordinance. Mr. Lyon explained that the ordinance states that council may consider the request and that the current discussion itself constitutes council's consideration.
Mayor Christiansen reminded council that enterprise funds which include water, sewer, and electric funds, and their transfers subsidize property taxes, which the city does not collect on 40% of property. He urged council to consider the purpose of impact fees when making their decision.
Mr. Rathfon stated that he believed the ordinance aims to promote businesses within the City of Dover by offering fee reductions for large, economically beneficial projects. This project is roughly a $55 million investment for his company, and they are committed to the City of Dover. He thinks that they are showing a decent financial impact by taking an unused parking field for the racetrack and turning it into what could be and is going to be a very nice complex. Mr. Rathfon noted that he hopes council can consider that when they are making their final decision.
Mr. Rocha moved to recommend acceptance of the staff recommendation. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and carried by a roll call vote of eight (8) yes (Boggerty, Neil, Pillsbury, Arndt, Rocha, Sudler, Lewis, Wilson) and one (1) no (Anderson).
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Lewis absent).
Mr. Neil moved for the adjournment of the Utility Committee meeting,
hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 10:02 p.m.
LEGISLATIVE, FINANCE, AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
The Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee met with Chairman Rocha presiding.
Adoption of Agenda Mr. Neil moved for adoption of the agenda, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
Selection Process of New City Solicitor (David S. Hugg, III, City Manager) Mr. David Hugg, III, City Manager, reviewed the Selection Process for the New City Solicitor and the Request for Qualifications (RFQ).
Staff recommended approval of the Request for Qualifications (RFQ).
Mr. Rocha stated that discussions included whether to hire a full-time solicitor or contract with a firm. He noted that submitting the RFQ would allow the city to
Page 36
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 36
compare costs before making a decision. If the cost significantly exceeded the current expenditure, alternative options would be explored.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rocha emphasized that they considered the advantages of having an in-house solicitor but stressed the importance of evaluating financial implications first. He further explained that the current city solicitor would remain available throughout the transition, eliminating the need for a rushed decision.
Mayor Christiansen questioned if the institutional knowledge and history that is currently in the possession of the current city solicitor is transferable to their successor. He also questioned whether the process of transferring the documents would incur additional costs. Mayor Christiansen recommended adding a provision to the proposed RFQ that would ensure that the institutional knowledge and legal records gathered during the solicitor's tenure be the property of the city.
Responding to Mayor Christiansen, Mr. Hugg stated that the requirement is not specifically outlined in the RFQ, but it is his understanding that any decisions made by the solicitor on behalf of the city or city property should be available to the city. He explained that losing the current solicitor will create a tremendous gap in knowledge, but that is a common challenge in transitions.
Mayor Christiansen stated that he would like a provision to be added that the institutional knowledge and history shall be turned over to the city. He explained that he would like the provision to be clear and in writing that the information is proprietary to the city for the tenure of the solicitor, the deputy solicitor, or the combination of the two.
Mr. Rocha stated that he agreed with the mayor and if it is not in the RFQ then that provision should be added to the contract at some point.
Mr. Neil moved to accept the staff recommendation for approval to move forward with the RFQ. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Rocha stated that they would be approving the draft, but if there are any concerns they can be brought forward.
Mr. Hugg stated that he would like to propose posting the RFQ beginning on March 09, 2025, for a period of thirty days. He stated that by posting it on the ninth would allow for it to be posted in the Delaware State News, which he explained would allow for it to be advertised for two Sundays in a row. He further stated that they could bring back a list to council for review on April 21, 2025, then set up interviews and have a final decision by council around May 5, 2025.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Hugg stated that March 09, 2025, would be the date to release the finalized RFQ. It would then be sent to the Delaware State Bar
Page 37
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 37
Association, posted on the city's website, posted in the Delaware State News for two weekends, and provided to existing solicitors for surrounding municipalities.
Mr. Neil moved to accept the staff recommendation for approval to move forward with the RFQ. The motion was seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Lewis absent)
Proposed Ordinance #2025-05 – Amending Chapter 98, Section 98-5 – Duty of Tenants or Owners to Maintain Sidewalks and Landscaped Areas Within the Street Right-of-Way, and Proposed Ordinance #2025-06 – Amending Chapter 1 – General Provision by Adding Section 1-18. Code Board of Appeals (Sharon Duca, Assistant City Manager, and Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer) Mr. Eddie Kopp, Chief Code Enforcement Officer, reviewed the background and analysis regarding Proposed Ordinances #2025-05 and #2025-06.
Staff recommended forwarding Proposed Ordinances #2025-05 and #2025-06 to council for approval.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Kopp stated that Proposed Ordinance #2025-06 creates a Code Board of Appeals because currently there is no appeals process for any Dover Code of Ordinances that are issued in the City of Dover. He explained that he does not feel like staff should be taking into consideration if someone is an elderly person, because then staff are not being fair and consistent with their enforcement, therefore, it should go before a board. By establishing the board, if a situation arises regarding an elderly person, it would be the pleasure of the board to make the decision. Mr. Kopp emphasized that the staff wants to be able to enforce the ordinances as written and not be accused of being impartial or biased and creating the board would alleviate that.
Responding to Mr. Boggerty, Mr. Kopp stated that he was able to remove the verbiage regarding an appeal on snow citations, however, there are several occurrences within the Dover Code of Ordinances with the same situations, which is why developing the board is so important. He explained that currently there is no appeal process for grass citations, unlawful waste or any Dover Code of Ordinance citations. He clarified that the citations would go to a separate board from the Construction and Property Maintenance Code Board of Appeals because they would cover the Dover Code of Ordinances, and the Construction and Property Maintenance Code Board of Appeals covers the International Property Maintenance Code, and it is recommended to keep them separate.
Mr. Kopp further explained that there were exceptions provided for Chapter 22 and Chapter 46. Chapter 22 covers not only code enforcement but also the building code. Therefore, they would fall under the jurisdiction of the
Page 38
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 38
Construction and Property Maintenance Code Board of Appeals. He also explained that Chapter 46 is also covered by the Construction and Property Maintenance Code Board of Appeals as well as a state appeal process.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that the ordinances are in the initial stages and can be amended, but they were drafted based on the current Construction and Property Maintenance Code Board of Appeals.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that the reason that the proposed ordinance is in Chapter 1 – General Provisions is because any ordinance in the Dover Code of Ordinances would be covered, including a snow ordinance, and they would be subject to an appeals process. He explained that rather than going through and amending every single ordinance by adding an exemption, all of the ordinances would be covered by placing the board under Chapter 1.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that he can take his recommendation into consideration and if it is the pleasure of the committee, he can add an exemption that gives an affirmative defense to seniors and those that are disabled.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that currently the appeals process is noted on the citation, however, they have considered updating the language on the citation to make the process more clear. He explained that the appeals process starts in the City Clerk’s Office, and they have thirty days from the date of issuance to file for their appeal in writing.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that the Planning and Inspections Office has an appeal request form up front, and they are time-stamped when they are received. He explained that often constituents prefer to send in a handwritten letter, and they would prefer not to accept their letter because it is in writing and not on the form.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that he will have to do further research on the definitions of premises and person. He explained that he tried to keep the same language from the previously adopted ordinance, and because he was not present during the adoption, he will have to conduct further research into the definitions.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that his definition of a person would be the owner of the property.
Responding to Mr. Rocha, Mr. Kopp stated that currently all citations are issued against the owner. He explained that they had run into situations before where the occupant was given the citation because it was in their lease that the owner would give them the citation. He stated that, unfortunately, that would be a civil matter, and they do not enforce anything in the landlord tenant code. He further explained that they cite the owner of the property in accordance with the code. He stated that
Page 39
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 39
he could fix the language to reflect the owner in unison with all other issued citations.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that the intent is for the owner or the occupant to clear the sidewalks. Similarly, to grass, the owner or occupant should be maintaining their grass. Unfortunately, if it is not maintained then the citation would be issued against the owner of the property.
Responding to Mr. Garfinkel, Mr. Kopp stated that they would not serve the occupant, the citation would be sent to the owner via certified mail. He explained that the citation is sent to the owner because they are not aware of who the occupants are, and the owner is ultimately responsible for their property.
Mr. Garfinkel recommended adding a definitions section to define key phrases. For example, owners could be a person, human being, an LLC corporation, or a Homeowners Association.
Ms. Arndt stated that she is against the idea of issuing a warning. She explained that the purpose of the fines is not to generate revenue, it is to change behavior, and for that reason she does not believe a warning would change the behavior. Ms. Arndt stated that having to issue a warning and then having to go back to recheck the property and then issue a citation is a burden put on staff. It puts staff in an unsafe situation because the sidewalks have not been shoveled and could be icy.
Ms. Arndt stated that she believes having an appeals process is fantastic, however she does not feel the need to specify specific reasons for the appeal. She explained that if someone is elderly or infirm, and they cannot find someone to shovel their sidewalk, those reasons do not need to be listed out. She recommended knowing who your neighbors are and building those networks to know who needs assistance shoveling. She stated that everyone needs to come together as a community and help each other out to get the sidewalks cleared.
Ms. Arndt further stated that Section 98-5, Subsection (a) reads “It shall be unlawful for the owner or occupant of any premises abutting upon a sidewalk to permit or allow debris or other materials to accumulate at any time so that pedestrians may conveniently and safely pass.” She explained that as currently written it does not read clearly, and she recommended adding the word “not” before conveniently.
Mr. Anderson thanked Mr. Kopp for bringing forward the options presented. He explained that he would be in support of having a warning because it has worked so well with grass. However, he is concerned that placing a warning could result in staff injuries while placing a door hanger around icy walkways. Mr. Anderson stated that he agreed with most of Mr. Garfinkel’s comments, but he believes most of the definitions are already in the code and can be referred to from there. He also stated that he does not think a form should be required because the
Page 40
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 40
constituents have a right in the code to a written appeal. He explained that the written appeal should not have to be in a certain format. For example, they should be able to email, send a written letter, or fill out the form. He explained that the forms are at the front desk of City Hall and in the City Clerk’s Office. Mr. Anderson stated that he agreed with Mr. Garfinkel and the forms should be available on the website.
Mr. Anderson further stated that he agreed with Mr. Garfinkel and an affirmative defense should be added but not necessarily based on age. He recommended adding that if someone can show that they were unable to remove the snow in the conditions, then give them the affirmative defense for a right to appeal.
Ms. LaChelle Paul, 501 Silverside Drive, Dover, explained that anything that comes with a fine or fee under the Federal Trade Commission Law, they have a right to challenge the debt. She recommended seeking legal advice regarding the appeals process because the people have a right to appeal. Ms. Paul stated that council had yet to produce the information regarding the five hundred fines that were given out and what areas they were provided to.
Mr. Anderson stated that the information was requested, and it was stated on the record at the previous meeting that the citations were written by five people throughout the city. He further explained that Mr. Kopp had provided the maps and would be reviewing them.
Mr. Kopp stated that he was asked to create a map and color coordinate the snow citations by date (Attachment #1). He explained that he also included a map that contains all code enforcement cases from 2024 (Attachment #2). He stated that everything is color coded in green to prevent anyone from identifying and targeting nuisance properties such as homeless encampments. He stated that, as reflected in the map, they are not specifically downtown, they are throughout the city, and they are trying to provide consistent code enforcement throughout.
Dr. Sudler asked Mayor Christiansen to provide clarity on the previous request for the information to be included in the maps. Dr. Sudler stated that he anticipated that maps would depict how many citations were complaints driven out of the five hundred and how many were in each specific district. He recommended breaking down the four districts and providing the percentage of citations for that district.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mayor Christiansen stated that he did request that they be color coded and indicate which were complaint driven, however, the information provided does show that the enforcement was city wide. Mayor Christiansen stated that in the past they did away with their alderman’s court, which he opposed, and there was no better place to adjudicate a fine that was given than an alderman’s court. He further stated that Ms. Paul is correct, the constituents do have a right to a judicial review of any fine or regulation that is given. He explained that they have at least six months to put in all the aspects that
Page 41
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 41
are needed and make sure that there is a maintenance of standards across the board.
Dr. Sudler stated that he agreed with Ms. Arndt, and they have to get the communities engaged and provide other alternatives. He recommended compiling a list of small contractors that not only do snow removal but also cut grass. That list can be available on the city's website as an additional resource to provide to the constituents.
Responding to Mr. Shevock, Mr. Rocha stated that one of the reasons he was in agreement with waving the citations was because there were circumstances where people had attempted to plow their sidewalks and with the wind it blew back onto them. He explained that currently there is still snow on the sidewalks in some areas, and it was 64 degrees, and it has not melted yet. Mr. Rocha stated that they need to figure out what they are going to do with the city's snow removal process first. If the snow is caked up and thrown onto the sidewalks, it is impossible to get rid of it, especially when the temperature drops into single digits.
Responding to Mr. Shevock, Mr. Kopp stated that he would like time to consult with the other departments that are in charge of snow removal as he does not want to speak for them. He explained that if there were a mound of snow on the sidewalk, they would not write them a citation because it is unreasonable to remove that mound. He explained he would like the opportunity to look into it further to see if there are alternative placements for the snow mounds.
Mr. Anderson moved to defer the Proposed Ordinances #2025-05 and #2025- 06 for one month so that staff may evaluate the feedback and do the research that was requested. The motion was seconded by Dr. Sudler and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Lewis absent)
Ms. Arndt stated that during the review she would like Mr. Kopp to take a look at Sec. 98-12 (b) and (c) and consider eliminating the provision for a warning and provide that as an option moving forward.
Dr. Sudler stated that he is in agreement with Ms. Arndt's recommendation.
Proposed Ordinance #2025-04 – Amending Chapter 70 – Miscellaneous Provisions, Section 70-7. – Registered Sexual Offenders (Councilman Boggerty and Council President Anderson) Councilman Boggerty and Council President Anderson reviewed the background and analysis regarding the Proposed Ordinance #2025-04.
The recommendation was to forward Proposed Ordinance #2025-04 to council for approval.
Page 42
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 42
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Boggerty stated that the federal law stated that they have to include any names or aliases that they were known by their sexual orientation is not an issue. He explained that if they were known as one (1) gender and committed a crime under a different gender form than those names need to be identified.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Boggerty stated that there is already a team in place at the police department, but he would allow Chief Johnson to elaborate.
Chief Johnson, City of Dover Police Department, stated that he would have to review the final version of the ordinance to determine if it would affect the department any further. He stated that there are a lot of codes at the state level that regulate sexual offenders. He recommended having an ordinance that is in sync with those codes to solve the greatest number of problems. He explained that in the eyes of the courts, not every sex offender is created equal and there are three (3) tiers in Delaware. He stated that each one (1) of the tiers has separate regulations for the dissemination of information and community notification. He stated that the registry is maintained at the state level and what fields they can populate and how deep that information can be drilled down for public consumption would be an Information Technology (IT) question and a Delaware State Police question. He stated that they are charged with the responsibility of managing all of the information.
Chief Johnson stated that if the suggestion is that a local database is created, then there would be an impact on the department. He explained that there are hundreds of offenders that they track over the course of the year, and the only saving grace is that homeless offenders are direct reports to the state's Bureau of Identification because of their inherent transient situation and the timeline for reporting is condensed immensely. He stated that there are two (2) full-time sex offender agents who are out in the field making sure they are where they are supposed to be. He explained that if a local database needed to be developed, in the event that the state police could not accommodate some of the data that would be needed based on the ordinance, he is not sure how that would work out.
Mr. Neil moved to defer the Proposed Ordinance #2025-04 for one (1) month to allow more time for review. The motion was seconded by Ms. Arndt and unanimously carried.
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for approval of the Committee’s recommendation, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury and carried by a unanimous roll call vote. (Lewis absent)
Mr. Rocha moved for adjournment of the Legislative, Finance, and Administration Committee meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 11:15 p.m.
Mr. Anderson moved for adjournment of the Council Committee of the Whole meeting, hearing no objection the meeting adjourned at 11:15 p.m.
Page 43
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 43
By consent agenda, Mr. Neil moved for acceptance of the Council Committee of the Whole Report, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried by a unanimous roll call vote (Lewis absent).
MONTHLY REPORTS - JANUARY 2025
By motion of Mr. Neil, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, the following monthly reports were accepted by consent agenda:
City Council’s Community Enhancement Fund Report
City Manager’s Report
Controller/Treasurer’s Budget Report
Fire Chief’s Report
Police Chief’s Report
SETTING OF PROPERTY ASSESSMENT APPEALS
Staff recommended that the 2025 Property Assessment Appeals be scheduled for May 27, 2025, through May 30, 2025, from 9:00 a.m. until 4:00 p.m., and one (1) evening (if needed). The hearing times are subject to change.
Mr. Neil moved for approval of the dates and times recommended by staff for the 2025 Property Assessment Appeals, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury.
Responding to Mr. Neil, Mr. Hugg stated that, to his understanding, it was a one (1) year deferral to use Kent County assessment records. Each year, they need to approve the assessments and hold an appeal based on their numbers, as some adjustments may be made. He explained that the process must be done every time that they set the tax rate or conduct an assessment.
Mr. Neil suggested that they may need to extend the appeals process for a month, depending on what they see from Tyler.
Mr. Neil moved for approval of the dates and times recommended by staff for the 2025 Property Assessment Appeals, seconded by Dr. Pillsbury, and carried by a unanimous carried (Lewis absent).
FIRST READING – PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-07 – AMENDING CHAPTER 98 BY ESTABLISHING A PUBLIC SPACE NAMING POLICY AND THE APPLICATION AND PROCEDURE PACKET (COUNCILWOMAN ARNDT) Council President Anderson reminded the public that copies of the proposed ordinance were available at the entrance of the Council Chambers, on the City's website at www.cityofdover.com under "Government," or by contacting the City Clerk's Office at (302) 736-7008 or cityclerk@dover.de.us. Final action by Council on the proposed ordinance will take place during the Council Meeting of March 24, 2025.
Councilwoman Arndt briefed the members of council on proposed Ordinance #2025-07 – Amending Chapter 98 by Establishing a Public Space Naming Policy and the Application and Procedure Packet.
Page 44
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 44
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2025-07 – AMENDING CHAPTER 98 BY ESTABLISHING A PUBLIC SPACE NAMING POLICY AND THE APPLICATION AND PROCEDURE PACKET.
ANNEXATION/REZONING REQUEST/FIRST READING REFERRAL OF PROPOSED ORDINANCE #2025-08 – PROPERTY LOCATED AT 582 ACORN LANE A request was received for annexation and rezoning of property located at 582 Acorn Lane, consisting of 2.3096 acres +/- ., owned by Robert Pellegrino. This property is currently zoned RS-1 (Residential Single Family Zone) (Kent County zoning classification), and the proposed zoning is R-8 (One Family Residence Zone) (City of Dover zoning classification). Staff recommended that the request be referred to the Utility Committee on March 25, 2025; and to the Planning Commission on April 21, 2025; and that a Public Hearing/Final Reading be set for May 12, 2025, at 6:30 p.m. (Tax Parcel: ED-00-068.15-01-11.00-000; Planning Reference: AX- 25-01)
Mr. Neil moved for referral, as recommended, seconded by Mr. Rocha, and unanimously carried (Lewis absent).
In accordance with Section 1-9 of the Dover Code, Council acknowledged the First Reading of the proposed Ordinance as read by the City Clerk, by title only, as follows:
ORDINANCE #2025-08 – AMENDING THE ZONING ORDINANCE AND ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF DOVER CHANGING THE ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT 582 ACORN LANE.
CITY MANAGER'S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Hugg had no announcements.
CITY MAYOR’S ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mayor Christiansen acknowledged that there has been frustration in the community due to not having a St. Patrick’s Day parade. He explained that they had struggled to get volunteers to take over the responsibility of organizing the St. Patrick’s Day parade despite making a genuine effort. He announced that Ms. Melissa Burgold would be stepping up to organize the St. Patrick’s Day parade in 2026. Mayor Christiansen stated that they would have a small celebration on March 17, 2025, in front of City Hall. This would include a presentation of a proclamation to the Irish Society of Delaware, a bagpiper performance, and the singing of Irish songs.
Mr. Donny Legans, Owner of Rail Haus, explained that since the St. Patrick’s Day parade would not be happening, he wanted to continue the tradition of the Bar Crawl. He mentioned that he has contacted all nearby bars, including McGlynns Pub, Irish Mike’s Olde Towne Pub, 9 East Taphouse Restaurant, and Grey Fox Grille & Public House, to continue the Bar Crawl on Saturday, March 15, 2025, from 1:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m.
Page 45
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 10, 2025 PAGE 45
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Legans stated that there would be a party bus for the Bar Crawl event, and to join the ride, it would cost $20 for a wristband. They would leave from the Rail Haus to McGlynns Pub to Grey Fox Grille & Public House to 9 East Taphouse Restaurant. He clarified that he forgot to mention that the Stone Rail Market would be included in the route before heading to Irish Mike’s Olde Towne Pub. The Bar Crawl would follow a continuous loop, with the bus moving every 30 minutes.
Responding to Dr. Sudler, Mr. Legans mentioned that individuals could go to the Rail Haus Instagram or Facebook page and follow a link to Eventbrite. Individuals could sign up online for their wristbands.
COUNCIL MEMBERS' ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Anderson expressed his gratitude to Dr. Pillsbury for chairing the Council Committee of the Whole meeting tomorrow, March 11, 2025. He mentioned that he was in Washington D.C. with the Administration’s Deputy Director for Intergovernmental Affairs and the Special Assistant to the President. He noted that they are interested in exploring opportunities to reprogram infrastructure funds for harder infrastructure and are also interested in the stormwater program. He expressed that the reprogramming of infrastructure funds would be a positive development. He also mentioned that while it may be a temporary cut in the revolving water fund due to the recently passed continuing resolution, it does not look like a permanent thing.
Mayor Christiansen pointed out that Ms. Bennett had recently become a Certified Municipal Clerk, achieving her certification in three (3) years.
The meeting adjourned at 8:14 p.m.
ANDRIA BENNETT CITY CLERK
All ordinances, resolutions, motions, and orders adopted by City Council during their Regular Meeting of March 10, 2025, are hereby approved.
ROBIN R. CHRISTIANSEN MAYOR /AB
Exhibits Exhibit #1 – Cameron Llewellyn’s presentation on Cecil Street Townhomes.
Page 46
EXHIBIT #1
Regular Council Meeting of 3/10/2025
Cecil Street Townhomes
North West and Cecil Streets, Dover, DE
Project Summary – March 7, 2025
CECIL STREET TOWNHOMES 1
Page 47
The project is located at the corner of North West Street and Cecil Street within Dover city limits, and is within the City of Dover Downtown Development District. The existing site of 12,168 square feet previously contained a single-family home with a detached shed and a large concrete parking area. The prior occupant passed away, the home fell into disrepair and was a center for drug and vagrant activity. Fortunately, the City of Dover staff identified the issue and ultimately the dwelling was demolished by the City.
4BL, LLC acquired the property in June of 2024 with the intent to redevelop it as a multifamily affordable housing project. The re-development of the site entails division into 4 lots. Two story townhomes of approximately 1,750 square feet, with one car garages will be constructed. The intent is to create homes for young families that are within their financial reach.
The project lies on the fringe of Residential (RG-1) Zoning District to the east of North West Street, and Industrial/Manufacturing (M) to the west. The Senator Bikeway passes North/South on West Street. Immediately to the south is Mt. Carmel Church of the Living God. To the southwest is the Rail Haus Beer Garden and the former recycling center (now parking for the Rail Haus). To the west is Teal Construction’s warehouse and equipment yard. To the north and east are single family residences in varying states of repair, generally trending toward improvement.
The existing lots is significantly larger in relation to the neighboring properties. To justify the cost of the parcel after the demolition and fines were absorbed, a very large
CECIL STREET TOWNHOMES 2
Page 48
single-family home would need to be constructed to make the project economically viable. A large single-family home would be very imposing, and frankly, not marketable.
The economics of providing affordable homes to working class families underscored the need to divide the parcel. The cost of building materials, mortgage rates, and groceries are making quality housing un-affordable to Delawareans. Dividing the costs of the development, infrastructure, management and construction of the project by four is allowing the homes to meet a price point that is reachable to young families.
Per Chapter 11 of the Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan:
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Goal 1: Encourage Balanced Housing Opportunities for all Residents of the City • Promote adequate, safe, and affordable housing for all residents in the City. Recommendation 1: Encourage the Use of Mixed Housing Types • Evaluate the provisions of the Planned Neighborhood Design and the Senior Citizen Housing Option for residential development. • Continue to encourage compact and diverse residential development throughout the City. • Re-evaluate all residential zones development requirements and housing types in the City. • Evaluate and update Codes to encourage compact and diverse development throughout the City. • Amend the provisions in the Zoning Ordinance for the definition of “family” to remove undue restrictions for members of protected classes.
Recommendation 2: Explore the Feasibility of Allowing Alternative Housing Units Options • Develop zoning provisions to allow an accessory dwelling unit within one family residence zones for the use of family members.
CECIL STREET TOWNHOMES 3
Page 49
- •Develop zoning provisions for alternative housing options including group housing and transitional housing.
Recommendation 3: Encourage the Development of Affordable Housing • Work with housing providers and developers to construct affordable rental housing options throughout the City including accessible housing for persons with disabilities. • Work with housing providers to provide affordable housing to low income residents. • Continue to work with housing providers to end homelessness and increase the number of permanent supportive housing for the homeless.
Recommendation 4: Promote Residential Development within the City • Encourage mixed use of existing and new buildings. • Encourage “in-fill” residential development. • Encourage housing in the Downtown and other areas that are near transit and multi- modal routes, retail areas, employment and essential services.
On November 20, 2024 the City of Dover Board of Adjustments granted two area variances allowing the parcel to become 4 townhome lots oriented toward Cecil Street. The variances waived the minimum lot depth for all four parcels, and minimum lot area for the two center lots.
The City of Dover Planning Commission granted approval, including a subdivision waiver for an Alley Requirement for Townhouses, and a waiver for Rear Emergency Access. Providing an automatic sprinkler system in the homes was the basis for the approval.
Pending approval by Dover City Council, and building permit review; construction of the new homes is planned to begin in June of 2025.
CECIL STREET TOWNHOMES 4
Page 52
CECIL STREET TOWNHOMES
ARIAL CONCEPT-CECIL STREET TOWNHOMES
SITE PLAN-CECIL STREET
Page 53
REAR ACCESS AND FIRE APPARATUS
LADDER 1- 100 FOOT REACH
SENATORS LAKE TOWNHOMES
Page 58
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 11 Housing & Community Development
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Goal 1: Encourage Balanced Housing Oppor tunities for all Residents of the City Promote adequate, safe, and affordable housing for all residents in the City.
Recommendation 1: Encourage the Use of Mixed Housing Types • Evaluate the provisions of the Planned Neighborhood Design and the Senior Citizen Housing Option for residential development. • Continue to encourage compact and diverse residential development throughout the City. • Re-evaluate all residential zones development requirements and housing types in the City. • Evaluate and update Codes to encourage compact and diverse development throughout the City. • Amend the provisions in the Zoning Ordinance for the definition of “family” to remove undue restrictions for members of protected classes.
Recommendation 2: Explore the Feasibility of Allowing Alternative Housing Units Options • Develop zoning provisions to allow an accessory dwelling unit within one family residence zones for the use of family members. • Develop zoning provisions for alternative housing options including group housing and transitional housing.
Recommendation 3: Encourage the Development of Affordable Housing • Work with housing providers and developers to construct affordable rental housing options throughout the City including assessible housing for persons with disabilities. • Work with housing providers to provide affordable housing to low income residents. • Continue to work with housing providers to end homelessness and increase the number of permanent supportive housing for the homeless.
Recommendation 4: Promote Residential Development within the City • Encourage mixed use of existing and new buildings. • Encourage “in-fill” residential development. • Encourage housing in the Downtown and other areas that are near transit and multi-modal routes, retail areas, employment and essential services.
Goal 2: Preserve Existing Housing Stock Preserve the existing variety types of housing in the City through the continuation of programs and initiatives available for housing.
Page 11- 16 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020
Page 59
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 11 Housing & Community Development Plan
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Recommendation 5: Encourage Property Owners to Maintain and Rehabilitate Existing Housing Stock • Continue to make emergency repairs and rehab homes with Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds. • Continue to work with other housing agencies to eliminate severe housing conditions that constitute immediate health or safety hazards to the occupants. • Continue to support the rehabilitation of owner-occupied homes with families who are low to moderate income. • Support the adaptive mixed reuse of existing buildings throughout the City.
Goal 3: Provide Safe and Healthy Livable Neighborhoods Continue to provide safe livable residential and commercial neighborhoods to improve the quality of life.
Recommendation 6: Promote Safe and Livable Neighborhoods through Enforcement of City Codes • Continue to conduct housing inspections on rental housing to ensure the compliance with City Codes. • Proactively enforce City Codes for property maintenance to improve community appearance for all residential units and adopt the 2018 International Property Maintenance Code. • Enforce building and fire codes for all buildings in the City and evaluate updated ICC and NFPA Codes for adoption. • Continue enforcement of floodplain regulations and associated construction codes. • Evaluate and amend provisions in the “Safe Communities Initiative” that may be a violation to fair housing. • Increase community policing efforts in the neighborhoods to reduce crime. • Continue to improve and maintain infrastructure in established neighborhoods throughout the City.
Recommendation 7: Articulate the Link between Housing and Health • Advocate for the development of complete neighborhoods and mixed-use developments. • Collaborate with public health agencies, housing authorities, advocacy groups and others on matters concerning housing and health. • Support programs that promote good quality housing such as collaboration on weatherization programs and on lead paint hazards programs. • Support programs to address housing inequities and injustices such as collaborating with tenants’ alliances and promoting neighborhood initiatives to address hazards.
Goal 4: Provide Homeownership Oppor tunities Provide homeownership opportunities throughout the City, especially within low and moderate- income neighborhoods.
2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020 Page 11-17
Page 60
Adopted – 1.13.2020
Chapter 11 Housing & Community Development
Dover 2019 Comprehensive Plan
Recommendation 8: Promote Homeownership Incentives for Low to Moderate Income Households • Continue to support funding the Homeownership Assistance Program to provide down payment or settlement assistance up to $20,000 to qualified homebuyers who purchase property in the City of Dover through the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Program. • Continue to support the provision of education regarding homeownership opportunities and responsibilities. • Support the Diamond State Community Land Trust and explore opportunities to utilize the land trust model to expand homeownership. • Continue to support the Restoring Central Dover Initiative and the Downtown Development District Incentives to increase homeownership in the Downtown area. • Continue to implement the most current Community Development Consolidated Plan.
Recommendation 9: Update the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Consolidated Plan and the Fair Housing Plan • Maintain updates to the Consolidated Plan as required by the CDBG Program. • Update and adopt the 2020-2024 CDBG Consolidated Plan. • Participate in the development and the adoption of the 2019 Fair Housing Plan.
Page 11- 18 – 2019 Comprehensive Plan Adopted 1.13.2020